## TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE REPORT — National Revenue Strategy Implementation: Customs Administration Reforms

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE REPORT — National Revenue Strategy Implementation: Customs Administration Reforms](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/tar/2025/english/tarea2025080-source-pdf.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/tar/2025/english/tarea2025080-source-pdf.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/tar/2025/english/tarea2025080-source-pdf.pdf.json)

---

### I. Introduction
- A National Revenue Strategy 2024-2030 (NRS) was adopted in December 2023 by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine, outlining revenue mobilization reforms. Its customs administration component includes measures listed in Box 1 (5.2.1–5.2.5).
- IMF FAD provided peripatetic expert support at the request of the State Customs Service (SCS) and the Customs Policy Department of the Ministry of Finance (MoF).
- The technical assistance covered the period September 16 to December 16, 2024:
  - The expert organized weekly video conferences (VCs) with senior management of the SCS and the MoF.
  - Advice was provided through regular VCs and desk assessments of documents prepared for the NRS Steering Committee (SC), which convened twice during the expert’s assignment.
  - Capacity development (CD) support focused on agreed areas of the NRS customs component, project management and governance, risk management, and planning the modernization of customs IT systems.

### II. Findings and Advice

#### A. Overall progress and legal alignment
- Key implementation milestones and timelines:
  - RP30 (SCS Reform Plan 2024-30) was adopted in May 2024.
  - A Steering Committee (SC) was established in September 2024; the SC has organized two meetings during the expert’s assignment.
  - Monthly RP30 progress reporting to SCS has been produced since July 2024; a quarterly report is submitted to the MoF. The first quarterly report covered July-August 2024.
  - Ukraine has advanced legal alignment with EU standards, including the Union Customs Code (UCC).
  - Laws adopted: No. 3926 on August 22, 2024, and No. 3977 on September 17, 2024.
  - A new draft of the Customs Code, fully aligned with the UCC and other EU regulations, is underway; the first draft is expected to be published in Q1 2025.
  - An EU assessment noted customs (Chapter 29) as one of five out of 29 EU association chapters implemented at a good level in Ukraine.
- IT modernization:
  - The SCS launched a single integrated IT platform—the automated customs clearance system—to centralize and unify customs clearance across all regions and to align with EU IT strategy.

#### B. Stakeholder engagement (vulnerabilities and recommendations)
- Observations:
  - Stakeholder engagement is a critical and vulnerable factor; stakeholders may have agendas differing from NRS goals.
  - Past organizational changes (merger and separation of tax and customs services) reduced staff motivation and productivity due to insufficient communication and consultation.
  - For many years the SCS had only an acting head who was not fully empowered; the selection process for a new head has begun during the assignment.
- Recommended practices:
  - Actively promote stakeholder engagement while maintaining transparency and accountability.
  - Enhance the SCS stakeholder engagement forum and continue circulating RP30 among stakeholders.
  - Avoid bilateral engagement with stakeholders unless subject to precautionary measures and record-keeping.
  - Prefer engagement with business associations rather than individual companies.
  - Avoid direct telephone calls to SCS executives; calls should go through assistants or operators who record the caller's identification.
  - Prioritize internal stakeholder engagement and develop change management plans; FAD HQ-led CD mission to focus on change management and stakeholder involvement.

#### C. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
- Current status:
  - KPIs to monitor NRS implementation have been approved by the SC.
  - An SCS document approved by the SC lists 23 KPIs, their target values, calculation methods, and recommended monitoring intervals.
  - The expert introduced KPIs based on the WCO Performance Measurement Mechanism and SMART criteria.
- Guidance and issues:
  - Having too many KPIs is not advisable (risk of overwhelm, diluted focus, data overload).
  - Advice was provided to group KPIs by purpose (internal use vs wider audience).
  - Several KPIs are highly relevant for monitoring NRS progress, e.g., trade volume by Authorized Economic Operators (AEOs), stakeholder perception of transparency, budget reliability, and legislative alignment with EU customs law.
  - Other KPIs are internal-administration specific and less useful for a broader audience (examples: changes in the number of corruption cases, complaints about possible corruption, Help Desk effectiveness, risk management system indicators).
  - Nine out of 23 KPIs apparently have weak linkage with measuring progress toward strategic objectives and were advised not to be used (example given: 'Decent wages').
  - Further KPI discussion agreed for HQ-led mission in February 2025.

#### D. Improving the risk management function
- Subjects discussed for further CD work:
  - Advance cargo information.
  - Application of random checks.
  - Practical information from competence centers (centers of excellence).
- Advance cargo information:
  - Advance cargo information from transporters and logistics operators (freight forwarders) is valuable as third-party data for risk-based selectivity.
  - Consolidated shipments create challenges: consignment-level cargo information is often retained by freight forwarders in exporting countries.
  - A regulatory framework is needed to obtain accurate data from transporters/logistics operators rather than from traders.
- Random checks:
  - The SCS introduced random inspections of AEO companies' consignments to measure integrity of AEO selectivity, maintain prevention, and identify new threats.
  - Methodology for random checks should be further developed and evaluated in practice.
  - Purposes of random checks include measuring effectiveness of risk assessment (compare detection rates of random vs risk-based checks), verifying performance of customs control staff, and estimating levels of smuggling or undervaluation.
  - Typical sample sizes: statistically significant samples commonly range between one percent or smaller to ten percent of global samples, depending on risk patterns and available sources.
- Competence centers:
  - RP30 includes measures for developing competence centers (centers of excellence and expertise) focused on national targeting, classification, valuation, and industry-specific knowledge.
  - Recommendation to explore various models for establishing competence centers and study international practices.

#### E. Customs Information Technologies (IT) program
- Strategic IT Plan:
  - The SCS Strategic IT Plan for 2024–2026 includes development of critical systems: customs clearance system, risk management system, and modernization of the transit system (New Computerized Transit System (NCTS) Phase 6).
- Challenges:
  - Insufficient funding, reliance on external teams, and inadequate capacity to identify the best option for IT projects.
- Development options and considerations:
  - Options discussed: in-house development, outsourcing, purchasing off-the-shelf products, Build-Operate-Transfer PPPs, and other alternatives.
  - EU4PFM experts noted that recent EU Member States typically rely on outsourced IT development supported by multi-year contracts.
  - For each option, assess potential risks and long-term financial implications of expanding internal IT development capacity within Ukrainian administrations.
- Project management:
  - The SCS has undertaken measures to enhance project management practices and facilitate outsourcing of large-scale customs system development projects.
  - Further advice on advantages and disadvantages of in-house development and outsourcing to be provided by the HQ-led customs administration CD mission (February 2025).

### III. Suggested Way Forward (agreed next steps)
- Authorities agreed with FAD HQ-led customs administration CD mission in February 2025 for follow-up review and advice covering:
  - Stakeholder engagement and change management.
  - KPIs.
  - Selected issues of risk management (advance cargo information, random selection, competence centers).
  - IT development.

*Prepared By Urmas Koidu, Authoring Department: Fiscal Affairs Department, APRIL 2025*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/tar/2025/english/tarea2025080-source-pdf.pdf_
