## wpiea2019128

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [wpiea2019128](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2019/wpiea2019128.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2019/wpiea2019128.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2019/wpiea2019128.pdf.json)

---

### I. Introduction — scope and key research question
- Objective: Study how domestic policies and structural attributes mediate the role of external conditions on growth patterns in emerging market and developing economies (EMDEs).
- Four categories of domestic attributes analyzed:
  - De jure degree of integration with the global economy.
  - Initial conditions at onset of a growth episode (level of external debt and the current account balance).
  - Macroeconomic policy framework (exchange rate regime, monetary stability, level of public debt).
  - Structural factors and institutions (quality of governance, legal and regulatory environment, availability of public services, level of education).
- High-level empirical claim:
  - Demand from trading partners has a stronger growth impact in EMDEs that are de jure more open to international trade.
  - Loosening external financial conditions is more likely to result in sustained growth when economies impose fewer restrictions on capital mobility and have a sufficiently developed and sound domestic financial system.
- Policy-relevant patterns highlighted:
  - Low external imbalances help translate favorable external conditions into positive growth outcomes.
  - Exchange rate flexibility and fiscal discipline appear to have a broadly positive influence on growth outturns (influences vary across external conditions and growth episodes).
  - Quality of institutions and property rights influence the effect of external conditions on the likelihood of favorable growth outturns.

### II. Empirical approach, timing, and identification
- Model specification:
  - Binary dependent (logit) model with country fixed effects:
    - log(Pr(episode=1)/(1−Pr(episode=1))) = γ + β + α_i + ε_{i,t}
    - α_i denotes time-invariant country fixed effects.
- Timing (moving averages):
  - External condition variables: moving averages between t+1 and t+5 (leading moving averages).
  - Domestic policy variables: moving averages between t−3 and t−1 (three years preceding onset of episode).
- Marginal effects and interpretation:
  - Average marginal effects computed from logit estimates; marginal effect of a variable depends on its coefficient and the values of all variables in the nonlinear model.
- Identification and endogeneity:
  - Leading moving averages for external variables are used so external conditions are contemporary with output outcome and are expected to be exogenous.
  - Domestic attributes averaged over the three years preceding onset to minimize reverse response to growth during the episode.

### III. Growth episode definitions and sample statistics
- Definitions (five-year interval):
  - Persistent acceleration episode requires:
    - trend growth rate of real GDP per capita during the period ≥ 3.5 percent a year;
    - trend growth increases by at least 2 percentage points;
    - level of real GDP per capita at the end of the episode is at least as large as the maximum level recorded prior to onset;
    - not followed by a growth reversal starting within three years of the end of the acceleration episode, nor by a banking crisis that starts three years before or after the end of the acceleration episode.
  - Growth reversal episode requires:
    - discrete drop in trend growth rate of at least 2 percentage points relative to the preceding five-year interval;
    - level of real GDP per capita declines such that its average during the five-year episode is lower than the average during the five-year period immediately preceding the episode.
- Sample outcomes (1970–2014):
  - Identified 95 persistent accelerations in the sample during 1970–2014.
  - Identified 125 growth reversals in the sample during 1970–2014.
- Sample notes:
  - EMDE group follows IMF’s World Economic Outlook classification, includes economies reclassified as “advanced” since 1996.
  - Economies with populations in 2010 below 1 million (PWT 9.0 vintage) are excluded.

### IV. Domestic attributes and variables used
- External conditions (country-specific, treated as exogenous):
  - External demand conditions — export-weighted growth rate of domestic absorption of trading partners.
  - External financial conditions — quantity-based measure of capital flows to peer economies as a share of their aggregate GDP.
  - Terms of trade — trade-weighted average of world commodity prices indicating income windfall gains and losses as a share of GDP.
- Domestic attributes and policy variables:
  - Integration and domestic financial capacity:
    - Free Trade Agreements — flows by year of signature; stock from WTO Regional Trade Agreements database.
    - Financial Depth — total assets held by deposit money banks as a share of GDP.
    - Sound credit growth — identification of excessive credit growth follows Dell’Ariccia and others 2016.
    - Capital account openness — index updating Quinn 1997 measure; higher value denotes fewer restrictions.
  - Initial conditions:
    - Current account balance — as a share of GDP.
    - External debt — stock of external debt liabilities as a share of GDP.
  - Macroeconomic policy framework:
    - Exchange rate flexibility — de facto index.
    - Public debt — ratio of public debt to GDP.
    - Sound monetary framework — sound money index standardized across money growth, inflation level and volatility, and ability to hold foreign currency accounts.
  - Structural factors and institutions:
    - Regulation, Legal System and Property Rights — indices compiling indicators from multiple sources.

### V. Direct effects of domestic attributes on growth episode likelihood
- Estimation: include one domestic attribute at a time in logit (controlling for three external conditions and country fixed effects); coefficients report impact in percent on the odds ratio of experiencing a growth episode.
- Key direct findings:
  - Persistent accelerations:
    - More financial depth, a sound monetary framework, and better quality of institutions significantly increase the odds ratio of a persistent acceleration episode.
    - Trade and financial openness and initial conditions in themselves are not found to significantly affect the probability of experiencing a sustained shift in growth.
  - Reversals:
    - A sound monetary framework and more financial depth significantly reduce the odds ratio of a reversal episode.
    - Lower exchange rate flexibility increases the odds ratio of experiencing a reversal.
- Economic relevance (marginal effects):
  - Moving from the 25th to the 75th percentile of financial depth, sound monetary framework, and the legal system is associated with an increase in the likelihood of experiencing an acceleration episode of between 0-3 percentage points.
  - For reversals, a shift toward more exchange rate flexibility reduces the probability of experiencing a reversal episode.
  - Note: For the exchange rate regime, the 25th percentile corresponds to a fully flexible exchange rate regime, while the 75th percentile corresponds to a fixed exchange rate regime.

### VI. How domestic attributes modify the impact of external conditions (interaction analysis)
- Estimation approach:
  - Logit with interaction terms between an external condition (z, t+1 to t+5) and a domestic attribute (x, t−3 to t−1); compute marginal effects following Ai and Norton (2003); evaluate changes when shifting domestic attribute from 25th to 75th percentile with external conditions at their medians.
- Main interaction findings and magnitudes:
  - Trade integration:
    - De jure trade integration amplifies external demand effects.
    - Example: when the number of partners with which an economy has free trade agreements increases from the 25th to the 75th percentile, a 1 percentage point increase in external demand raises the probability of an acceleration by 3 additional percentage points.
  - Financial development and capital account openness:
    - Supportive external financial conditions (an increase in capital inflows to the region of 1 percentage point of GDP) raise the probability of accelerations more in economies with higher financial development and fewer restrictions on capital mobility.
    - Financial depth magnitudes:
      - "6.6 percent in economies at the 75th percentile of financial development compared with 4.5 percent in economies at the 25th percentile" — the difference is statistically significant.
      - Deeper financial systems reduce, for a given impulse from external financial conditions, the probability of reversals by only 1/3 percentage point.
    - Sound credit growth:
      - "The probability of a persistent acceleration when external financial conditions are supportive is about 7 percent higher when domestic credit has been growing at a healthy pace as opposed to under credit-boom conditions."
      - The marginal effect of external financial conditions on reversals improves by "2 1/3 percentage points for economies that avoid excessive credit growth."
    - Capital account openness:
      - "In more open economies, favorable external financial conditions lower the probability of reversals 2½ percentage points more than under restrictive capital account settings."
      - Trade-off noted: "the probability of an acceleration increases less for economies with more open capital accounts—although the change in the marginal effect is small and not statistically significant."
  - Initial external imbalances:
    - Current account deficits:
      - "A low current account deficit significantly increases the marginal effect of external financial conditions on the probability of accelerations by ¾ percentage point."
      - "The marginal effect of better external demand conditions on the likelihood of an acceleration also improves significantly—by 1 percentage point—when the initial current account deficit is low."
      - "The effect of demand conditions on the probability of reversals also significantly decreases—by 1½ percentage points—when the initial current account deficit is low."
    - External debt:
      - "Lower external debt increases the likelihood of accelerations when terms of trade or external financial conditions improve—by about 1 percentage point and 1/3 percentage point, respectively."
      - "It also increases the extent to which improvements in terms of trade reduce the probability of reversals."
  - Policy characteristics:
    - Exchange rate flexibility:
      - "The marginal effect of external demand conditions on the likelihood of episodes of sustained growth significantly improves by 3 percentage points with exchange rate flexibility."
      - For external financial conditions: "The effect of external financial conditions on the probability of experiencing a period of sustained growth is about 1¼ percentage points larger under a more flexible exchange rate regime than otherwise, while the probability of a reversal decreases further and significantly by about 2 percentage points."
      - Note: the lower impact of positive external demand conditions under less flexible exchange rates could reflect inefficient allocation of resources and low productivity growth as price signals are distorted.
    - Fiscal discipline:
      - "The marginal effect of external demand conditions on the likelihood of persistent accelerations significantly improves by about 1.8 percentage points when public debt is low."
    - Monetary framework:
      - "A sound monetary framework in itself has a significant favorable effect on the likelihood of persistent acceleration and reversal episodes ... it does not meaningfully influence the marginal effect of external conditions on episode probabilities."
  - Institutions, regulation, and property rights:
    - "The marginal effect of external demand on accelerations increases significantly by 8 percentage points when the quality of regulation improves."
    - "An improvement in the quality of the legal system and property rights further increases the marginal effect of external demand on accelerations by 9 percentage points and further decreases the probability of reversals by 3 percentage points."
    - Summary: improvements in integration, financial depth, capital account openness (fewer restrictions), and institutional quality typically increase the positive marginal effect of favorable external shocks and reduce vulnerability to reversals.

### VII. Quantitative highlights and examples
- Sample counts: 95 persistent accelerations; 125 growth reversals (1970–2014).
- Financial depth example: 6.6 percent (75th percentile) versus 4.5 percent (25th percentile) probability of acceleration under favorable external financial conditions.
- Credit dynamics: about 7 percent higher probability of persistent acceleration when domestic credit growth is healthy versus credit-boom conditions.
- Exchange rate flexibility: external demand marginal effect on sustained growth improves by 3 percentage points with flexibility; external financial conditions marginal effect is about 1¼ percentage points larger and reversal probability falls by about 2 percentage points.
- Regulation and legal system: external demand marginal effect on accelerations rises by 8 percentage points (regulation) and 9 percentage points (legal system/property rights); reversals fall by 3 percentage points with better legal/property rights.

### VIII. Policy implications and recommended policy mix for EMDEs
- Core messages:
  - Favorable external demand and financial conditions help medium-term growth by increasing the likelihood of accelerations and reducing the likelihood of reversals.
  - Domestic attributes matter: stronger institutions, better legal systems, and property rights raise the likelihood of persistent accelerations.
  - Exchange rate flexibility significantly reduces the likelihood of growth reversals.
  - A sound monetary framework and deeper domestic financial systems are associated with higher likelihood of accelerations and lower likelihood of reversals.
- Policy mix recommendation:
  - Strengthen institutional framework and property rights.
  - Protect trade integration (de jure openness and participation in trade agreements).
  - Permit exchange rate flexibility.
  - Contain vulnerabilities from high current account deficits, high external debt, and high public debt.
  - Foster financial depth while maintaining sound credit growth and risk management to better channel external financing.

*Source: Excerpt from IMF working paper wpiea2019128 (Introduction and Empirical Approach sections).*

### References .............................................................................................................

### wpiea2019128 - References

### I. Introduction — scope and research question
- Objective: Study how domestic policies and structural attributes mediate the role of external conditions on growth patterns in emerging market and developing economies (EMDEs).
- Four broad categories of domestic attributes examined:
  - De jure degree of integration with the global economy.
  - Initial conditions at onset of a growth episode (such as the level of external debt and the current account balance).
  - Macroeconomic policy framework (exchange rate regime, monetary stability, level of public debt).
  - Structural factors and institutions (quality of governance, legal and regulatory environment, availability of public services, level of education).
- High-level empirical claim: Demand from trading partners has a stronger growth impact in EMDEs that are de jure more open to international trade; loosening external financial conditions is more likely to result in sustained growth when economies impose fewer restrictions on capital mobility and have a sufficiently developed and sound domestic financial system.
- Policy-relevant patterns (as stated in the text):
  - Low external imbalances help translate favorable external conditions into positive growth outcomes.
  - Exchange rate flexibility and fiscal discipline appear to have a broadly positive influence on growth outturns (influences vary across external conditions and growth episodes).
  - Quality of institutions and property rights influence the effect of external conditions on the likelihood of favorable growth outturns.

### II. Empirical approach and data — model specification and timing
- Binary dependent model (logit) to estimate probability of a growth episode:
  - Pr(episode_{e,i,t} = 1) = Φ(γ_{e,i,t}, β_{e,i,t})
  - Empirical specification uses a logit functional form with country-fixed effects:
    - log(Pr(episode=1)/(1−Pr(episode=1))) = γ + β + α_i + ε_{i,t}
    - α_i denotes time-invariant country fixed effects.
- Timing of variables (moving averages):
  - External condition variables: moving averages between t+1 and t+5 (leading moving averages).
  - Domestic policy variables: moving averages between t−3 and t−1 (three years preceding onset of episode).
- Average marginal effects:
  - Computed from logit estimates; marginal effect of a variable depends on its coefficient and the values of all variables in the nonlinear model (equation representation shown in text).
- Identification and endogeneity considerations:
  - Leading moving averages for external variables are used so external conditions are contemporary with output outcome; these external measures are expected to be exogenous to the economy in question.
  - Domestic attributes are averaged over the three years preceding the onset to minimize concerns that attributes respond to growth during the episode.

### III. Growth episode definitions and sample statistics
- Definitions (from Gruss, Nabar, and Poplawski-Ribeiro (2018)):
  - Persistent acceleration episode (five-year interval):
    - (i) trend growth rate of real GDP per capita during the period ≥ 3.5 percent a year;
    - (ii) trend growth increases by at least 2 percentage points;
    - (iii) level of real GDP per capita at the end of the episode is at least as large as the maximum level recorded prior to onset (to rule out rebound from a collapse);
    - (iv) not followed by a growth reversal that starts within three years of the end of the acceleration episode, nor by a banking crisis (Laeven and Valencia 2013) that starts three years before or after the end of the acceleration episode.
  - Growth reversal episode (five-year interval):
    - (i) discrete drop in trend growth rate of at least 2 percentage points relative to the preceding five-year interval;
    - (ii) level of real GDP per capita declines such that its average during the five-year episode is lower than the average during the five-year period immediately preceding the episode.
- Sample outcomes:
  - Identified 95 persistent accelerations in the sample during 1970–2014.
  - Identified 125 growth reversals in the sample during 1970–2014.
- Auxiliary sample notes:
  - EMDE group definition follows IMF’s World Economic Outlook classification, includes economies reclassified as “advanced” since 1996 (list provided in source).
  - Economies with populations in 2010 below 1 million (PWT 9.0 vintage) are excluded.

### IV. Key substantive findings (as summarized in the text)
- External demand and trade openness:
  - Demand from trading partners has a stronger growth impact in EMDEs that are de jure more open to international trade.
- External finance, capital mobility, and financial development:
  - A loosening of external financial conditions is more likely to result in sustained growth when economies impose fewer restrictions on capital mobility and when domestic financial systems are sufficiently developed and sound (i.e., can channel external financing to financially constrained agents while maintaining relatively robust risk management and origination standards).
- External imbalances and translation of external conditions into growth:
  - Low external imbalances are important for translating favorable external conditions into positive growth outcomes.
- Macroeconomic policy characteristics:
  - Exchange rate flexibility and fiscal discipline are broadly associated with better growth outcomes for a given external impulse (effects vary across external conditions and growth episode types).
- Structural institutions:
  - Quality of institutions and property rights influence the effect of external conditions on the likelihood of favorable growth outturns.

*Source: Excerpt from IMF working paper wpiea2019128 (Introduction and Empirical Approach sections).*

### 2. The years identified as persistent acceleration episodes are shown in Annex Table 3, and

### 2. The years identified as persistent acceleration episodes are shown in Annex Table 3, and

### Country-specific external conditions
- Analysis focuses on three country-specific external conditions (defined as exogenous from the perspective of each economy):  
  - External demand conditions — measured by the export-weighted growth rate of domestic absorption of trading partners (Arora and Vamvakidis 2005; IMF 2014).  
  - External financial conditions — proxied by a quantity-based measure of capital flows to peer economies (other EMDEs within the same region) as a share of their aggregate GDP (constructed to be exogenous to each country along Blanchard, Adler, and de Carvalho Filho 2015).  
  - Terms of trade — based on international commodity prices as a trade-weighted average of the world price of imported and exported commodities to indicate income windfall gains and losses (as a share of GDP) associated with changes in international prices (Gruss 2014; IMF 2015; Gruss and Kebhaj 2019).

### Domestic attributes and policies — four categories (variables used)
- Integration and domestic financial capacity:  
  - Free Trade Agreements — flows by year of signature from IMF (2016) using the Design of Trade Agreements database; stock from the WTO Regional Trade Agreements database.  
  - Financial Depth — total assets held by deposit money banks as a share of GDP (World Bank Global Financial Development database).  
  - Sound credit growth — identification of excessive credit growth follows Dell’Ariccia and others 2016.  
  - Capital account openness — index updating Quinn 1997 measure; higher value denotes fewer restrictions.
- Initial conditions:  
  - Current account balance — current account balance as a share of GDP (IMF World Economic Outlook database).  
  - External debt — stock of external debt liabilities as a share of GDP (updated from Lane and Milesi-Ferretti 2007).
- Macroeconomic policy framework:  
  - Exchange rate flexibility — de facto index (Aizenman, Chinn, and Ito 2010).  
  - Public debt — ratio of public debt to GDP (Mauro and others 2013).  
  - Sound monetary framework — sound money index (Gwartney, Lawson, and Hall 2016), standardized across money growth, inflation level and volatility, and ability to hold foreign currency accounts.
- Structural factors and institutions:  
  - Regulation, Legal System and Property Rights — indices from Gwartney, Lawson, and Hall (2016), compiling indicators from multiple sources (Global Competitiveness Report, International Country Risk Guide, Doing Business, World Development Indicators, International Financial Statistics).

### Direct effects of domestic attributes on the likelihood of growth episodes (summary of logistic estimates)
- Estimation approach: include one domestic policy/attribute at a time in logit specification (controlling for the three external conditions and country fixed effects); coefficients on domestic variables report impact in percent on the odds ratio of experiencing a growth episode versus not. Values below (above) 1 indicate lower (higher) odds of experiencing an episode for higher values of the domestic attribute variable.
- Key findings from Tables 1 and 2:  
  - For persistent acceleration episodes (Table 1):  
    - More financial depth, a sound monetary framework, and better quality of institutions significantly increase the odds ratio of a persistent acceleration episode.  
    - Trade and financial openness and initial conditions in themselves are not found to significantly affect the probability of experiencing a sustained shift in growth.  
  - For reversal episodes (Table 2):  
    - A sound monetary framework and more financial depth significantly reduce the odds ratio of a reversal episode.  
    - Lower exchange rate flexibility increases the odds ratio of experiencing a reversal.  
- Economic relevance (marginal effects using equation (3)):  
  - Moving from the 25th to the 75th percentile of financial depth, sound monetary framework, and the legal system is associated with an increase in the likelihood of experiencing an acceleration episode of between 0-3 percentage points.  
  - For reversals, a shift toward more exchange rate flexibility reduces the probability of experiencing a reversal episode.  
  - Note: For the exchange rate regime, the 25th percentile corresponds to a fully flexible exchange rate regime, while the 75th percentile corresponds to a fixed exchange rate regime.

### How domestic attributes modify the impact of external conditions on growth episodes (interaction analysis)
- Estimation approach: modify logit to include interaction terms between a country-specific external condition (z) and a moving average (t–3 to t–1) of the domestic policy/attribute (x), with country fixed effects (specification (4)); derive marginal effects and evaluate changes when shifting the domestic attribute from its 25th to 75th percentile, with external conditions evaluated at their medians.  
- Interpretation note: the interaction coefficient in nonlinear logit (odds ratios) is not sufficient; marginal effects are computed following Ai and Norton (2003). The bars in Figure 3 represent the change in the marginal effect of the external condition variable as the domestic attribute improves (for some variables comparison is reversed to represent improvement).
- Main interaction results and economic implications:  
  - Trade integration amplifies external demand effects: deeper de jure trade integration (coverage of trade agreements) increases the likelihood that supportive external demand leads to growth accelerations. Example: when the number of partners with which an economy has free trade agreements increases from the 25th to the 75th percentile in the sample, a 1 percentage point increase in external demand raises the probability of an acceleration by 3 additional percentage points.  
  - Financial development amplifies benefits from favorable external financial conditions: supportive external financial conditions (an increase in capital inflows to the region of 1 percentage point of GDP) raise the probability of accelerations more in economies with higher financial development and fewer restrictions on capital mobility. Higher financial depth allows channeling external financing to financially constrained agents while maintaining risk management and origination standards that limit pitfalls from excessive credit growth.  
  - Overall conclusion from interaction analysis: several domestic attributes—de jure trade openness, capital account openness (fewer restrictions), financial depth, and institutional quality—meaningfully condition how external conditions translate into the probability of accelerations or reversals, with improved domestic attributes typically increasing the positive marginal effect of favorable external shocks and reducing vulnerability to reversals.

*Source: IMF staff calculations (excerpts from the provided chapter).*

### 6.6 percent in economies at the 75

### 6.6 percent in economies at the 75th percentile of financial development

### Financial development, credit growth, and capital openness
- Financial depth: "6.6 percent in economies at the 75th percentile of financial development compared with 4.5 percent in economies at the 25th percentile"—the difference is statistically significant.  
- Financial depth and reversals: "Deeper financial systems also further reduce, for a given impulse from external financial conditions, the probability of reversals, although by only 1/3 percentage point."  
- Sound credit growth:
  - "The probability of a persistent acceleration when external financial conditions are supportive is about 7 percent higher when domestic credit has been growing at a healthy pace as opposed to under credit-boom conditions."
  - "The marginal effect of external financial conditions on reversals also improves ... by 2 1/3 percentage points for economies that avoid excessive credit growth."
- Capital account openness:
  - "In more open economies, favorable external financial conditions lower the probability of reversals 2½ percentage points more than under restrictive capital account settings."
  - Trade-off: "the probability of an acceleration increases less for economies with more open capital accounts—although the change in the marginal effect is small and not statistically significant."

### Initial external imbalances and demand conditions
- Current account deficits:
  - "A low current account deficit significantly increases the marginal effect of external financial conditions on the probability of accelerations by ¾ percentage point," while its impact on reversals is "negligible and statistically insignificant."
  - "The marginal effect of better external demand conditions on the likelihood of an acceleration also improves significantly—by 1 percentage point—when the initial current account deficit is low."
  - "The effect of demand conditions on the probability of reversals also significantly decreases—by 1½ percentage points—when the initial current account deficit is low."
- External debt: "Lower external debt increases the likelihood of accelerations when terms of trade or external financial conditions improve—by about 1 percentage point and 1/3 percentage point, respectively."  
  - "It also increases the extent to which improvements in terms of trade reduce the probability of reversals."

### Policy characteristics: exchange rate regimes, fiscal discipline, and monetary framework
- Exchange rate flexibility:
  - "The marginal effect of external demand conditions on the likelihood of episodes of sustained growth significantly improves by 3 percentage points with exchange rate flexibility."
  - For external financial conditions: "The effect of external financial conditions on the probability of experiencing a period of sustained growth is about 1¼ percentage points larger under a more flexible exchange rate regime than otherwise, while the probability of a reversal decreases further and significantly by about 2 percentage points."
  - Note on trade-off: "The lower impact of positive external demand conditions on the likelihood of sustained growth episodes under less flexible exchange rates could reflect inefficient allocation of resources and low productivity growth as price signals are distorted." Also: "the effect of external demand on the probability of reversals decreases less for economies with more flexible exchange rate regimes—although the change is not statistically significant."
- Fiscal discipline (public debt to GDP): "The marginal effect of external demand conditions on the likelihood of persistent accelerations significantly improves by about 1.8 percentage points when public debt is low."
- Monetary framework: "A sound monetary framework in itself has a significant favorable effect on the likelihood of persistent acceleration and reversal episodes ... it does not meaningfully influence the marginal effect of external conditions on episode probabilities."

### Institutions, regulation, and property rights
- Regulation quality: "The marginal effect of external demand on accelerations increases significantly by 8 percentage points when the quality of regulation improves."
- Legal system and property rights: "An improvement in the quality of the legal system and property rights further increases the marginal effect of external demand on accelerations by 9 percentage points and further decreases the probability of reversals by 3 percentage points."
- Summary: "Improvements in all four categories of domestic attributes considered are typically associated with a better growth outturn for a given impulse from external conditions."

### Conclusion: policy implications for EMDEs
- External impulses: "A favorable impulse from external demand and financial conditions helps medium-term growth outcomes by making growth accelerations more likely. It also reduces the likelihood of growth reversals."
- Domestic policies and attributes:
  - "Economies with stronger institutions—proxied by higher-quality legal systems and better protection of property rights—are significantly more likely to experience persistent acceleration episodes."
  - "The likelihood of experiencing growth reversal episodes ... significantly decreases with the extent of exchange rate flexibility."
  - "A sound monetary framework and domestic financial depth are significantly associated with a higher likelihood of persistent acceleration episodes and lower likelihood of growth reversal episodes."
- Policy mix recommendation: "Emerging market and developing economies ... can get the most out of a weaker growth impulse from external conditions by strengthening their institutional framework and adopting a policy mix that protects trade integration; permits exchange rate flexibility; and ensures vulnerabilities stemming from high current account deficits and external debt, as well as high public debt, are contained."

*Source: IMF staff compilation.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2019/wpiea2019128.pdf_
