## conclusions and offers policy recommendations.

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [conclusions and offers policy recommendations.](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2021/english/wpiea2021206-print-pdf.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2021/english/wpiea2021206-print-pdf.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2021/english/wpiea2021206-print-pdf.pdf.json)

---

### Housing affordability and distributional effects
- Price-to-income ratios are an imperfect indicator of housing affordability since they ignore the impact of financing costs.
- Households in other euro area countries are likely to encounter mortgage rates that are comparable to those in the Netherlands; therefore, price-to-income ratios still provide a measure of affordability pressures in relative terms.
- Contribution of housing costs to inequality measured as change in Gini-coefficient attributable to housing costs is shown for multiple countries (chart referenced; exact values in source charts).

### CRE market characteristics and participants
- CRE encompasses diverse property types: hospitals, hotels, housing for the elderly, industrial premises, offices, shopping malls, single store retail, warehouses.
- Financial market participants with CRE risk include: banks; institutional investors (pension funds, insurance companies, real estate investment funds and trusts); holders of debt collateralized by CRE; buyers of equity and bonds issued by firms active in CRE-related lines of business.
- Exposure acquisition channels: direct purchase of physical structures; indirect investment via financial instruments and vehicles; provision of credit.
- Data limitations and definitional heterogeneity:
  - No harmonized classification of CRE; different definitions used by private actors and public sector bodies.
  - Private market participants typically subsume multi-family dwellings under CRE, while some European institutions characterize rental housing as RRE.
  - MSCI property price indicators cover only a fraction of the CRE market due to voluntary reporting and inclusion criteria, limiting cross-country comparability.
- Size and composition (MSCI, 2020 data):
  - Total capital value (EUR bn): Netherlands 61.2; Belgium 8.4; France 183.1; Germany 101.4; Italy 29.0; Spain 22.0.
  - Total capital value (percent of GDP): Netherlands 7.7; Belgium 1.9; France 8.0; Germany 3.0; Italy 1.8; Spain 2.0.
  - Residential (percent of total capital value): Netherlands 60.3; (other countries show much smaller residential shares; office dominates several peers).
  - Retail (percent): Netherlands 13.7; Office 12.0; Industrial 8.5; Hotel 1.8; Other 3.6.
- Financial sector exposures (2020/2019 data):
  - Banks: exposure to CRE risk in balance sheets of banks in the Netherlands at 20 percent of GDP, ranking among the highest in the euro area.
  - Occupational pension funds: nearly 14 percent of assets allocated to real estate.
  - Investment funds with a real estate mandate: more than 13 percent of total investment fund assets.
  - Insurance companies: relatively small prevalence of CRE in asset structure, but significant residential real estate holdings may be classified as CRE under some definitions.
- Internationalization:
  - Approximately one third of commercial properties in the Netherlands were held by foreigners in 2016 (Klapwijk et al. (2017)).
  - Since 2013, more than half of investment flowing into Dutch CRE has originated abroad (CBRE (2021)).
  - Banks have substantially pared back cross-border CRE exposures (about a fifth of bank exposures collateralized by immovable commercial property held outside the Netherlands in 2019, vs. more than two thirds in 2014).

### CRE market developments and vulnerabilities
- Cycle and prices:
  - After bust post-global financial crisis, CRE investment picked up substantially since 2016.
  - In 2020, flows into CRE properties remained above the pre-global financial crisis peak despite Covid-19 disruptions.
  - Residential properties witnessed steep price increases; office and industrial climbed after mid-2010s trough; retail lagged and declined.
- Vacancies and valuations:
  - Vacancies increased due to Covid-19 economic fallout; retail showed the most marked deterioration with 2020 vacancy rates far exceeding 2012 levels.
  - Valuations continued to climb, increasing the risk of a correction if rents do not recover alongside economic rebound.
  - Depressed yields for safe assets have supported CRE valuations; an increase in yields of other asset classes may put pressure on CRE valuations.
- Structural risks:
  - High digital penetration and potential for telecommuting imply scope to economize on office space; slightly more than 60 percent of Dutch employees do not engage in working from home (chart referenced).
  - Online sales grew at average annual growth rates of nearly 10 percent between 2004 and 2019 in the Netherlands; share of households purchasing online exceeded 80 percent.
  - Retail vacancy rates have steadily risen; online sales surged in 2020 in high double-digits.
  - Business travel may not fully recover if remote interactions substitute for in-person exchanges, affecting retail and hotel demand.
- Financial stability transmission channels:
  - Souring of CRE exposures may burden balance sheets and capital positions of banks and non-bank financial institutions.
  - Tighter funding conditions and losses may dampen economic activity, amplify construction downturns, and increase financial market volatility.
  - Interlinkages across many entity types raise complexity and potential for intra-sectoral spillovers.
- Balance sheet vulnerabilities and stress testing:
  - Banks have reduced CRE portfolios but exposures remain high; CRE-related loans quality is generally worse than other loans.
  - Insurance companies and pension funds face potential losses compounded by low interest rates and ageing demographics.
  - Leverage among real estate investment funds, while declining since the global financial crisis, remains elevated, raising risk of fire sales.
  - DNB stress tests (DNB (2020a); extended DNB (2021b)) indicate notable CRE-related losses under adverse pandemic assumptions:
    - Retail and office segments would suffer most; industrial and residential impacts are significant but more contained.
    - Capital cushions of banks and insurance companies would deteriorate but remain at relatively comfortable levels.
    - Funding ratios of many pension funds, already in breach of regulatory minima, would worsen further.

### RRE market characteristics and challenges
- Tenure and mortgage prevalence:
  - Netherlands has one of the highest shares of occupants living in rental accommodation among European economies.
  - More than a third of the building stock offers below-market rents (social housing).
  - Fraction of residences without mortgages is one of the smallest: just slightly more than a tenth of dwellings free of debt.
- Household indebtedness and mortgage performance:
  - Despite a small uptick in 2020, mortgage non-performing loan ratios rank among the lowest in the euro area.
  - RRE valuations have become elevated but remain below their 2007 peaks.
  - Household debt burden in the Netherlands is significantly above peers in the euro area (chart referenced).
  - High savings likely provide limited liquidity cushion due to lack of liquidity.
  - Phase-out of pandemic-related support could put near-term pressure on some households’ ability to service debt.
  - About half of mortgages in the Netherlands are non-amortizing debt with maturities peaking in the mid-2030s (AFM (2021)); scenario analysis suggests a manageable risk of debt distress among interest-only borrowers.
- Tax and policy distortions:
  - Income tax system creates incentives toward homeownership indebtedness via the mortgage interest tax deduction (MITD) and the imputed rental income mechanism.
    - Box 1 taxed progressively up to a maximum of 49.5 percent in 2021; Box 2 at flat 26.9 percent; Box 3 at flat 31 percent on deemed remuneration.
    - Imputed rental income is calculated on market value; MITD has been significantly larger than imputed rent, creating negative taxable income carry-back for up to three years in practice.
    - Interest on full mortgage amounts is deductible for balloon mortgages taken before 2013 for the loan duration.
    - Estimated budgetary revenue cost: about 1.3 percent of GDP in forgone revenue (OECD 2021).
- Supply rigidities and social impact:
  - Structural rigidities exacerbate social impact of rising prices and rents: subsidization of social and owner-occupied dwellings but not private rentals.
  - Municipal incentives favor owner-occupied construction (higher land development revenues) over rental supply.
  - Spatial constraints and zoning restrictions frequently prevent housing expansion, especially in major cities; planning capacity was scaled down after the post-global financial crisis real estate bust.
  - Median Dutch tenant renting at market prices dedicates a rather large share of disposable income to accommodation relative to European peers; the poorest quintile likely overburdened (tenant overburden thresholds cited at 40 percent or more conservatively 30 percent of disposable income).

### Pandemic impacts, distributional effects, and household burden
- The recession triggered by the Covid-19 crisis has been disproportionately shouldered by more vulnerable groups; IMF (2021b) shows that particularly the young and the lower-skilled have experienced considerably larger increases in unemployment than older and better educated parts of the citizenry.
- These more adversely affected groups align relatively closely with segments most likely to rent and for whom buying a property or coping with rising rental costs is challenging due to insufficient savings or income.
- Some pandemic effects could lessen upside pressures on rents (e.g., reduction in tourism and business travel; migration away from urban centers due to remote working), but their impact is described as "rather uncertain" and "unlikely to provide much immediate relief" for a housing market as tight as the Netherlands’.
- Key statistics and household burden illustrations:
  - Median annual equivalized disposable income (right axis in figure): 9,270; 10,640; 10,072; 12,747; 11,350; 19,490; 18,910; 9,972; 23,034.
  - Disposable income spent on rent at market prices, 2018 (Percent) shown across countries and quintiles — countries included: AT, BE, DK, FI, FR, GR, IT, LU, NL, NO, PT, SI, ES, SE, and CH.
  - Note: Data for Ireland and the United Kingdom are as at 2017.
- Macro-financial and socio-economic assessment:
  - Real estate valuations appear elevated, particularly considering Covid-19 disruptions.
  - Real estate represents a sizeable share in portfolios of Dutch banks, insurance companies, pension funds and investment funds, elevating macro-financial stability risks in the event of a protracted and potentially synchronized downturn in RRE and CRE markets.
  - CRE faces far-reaching structural change, partly accelerated by the crisis, affecting long-term appeal and viability of some building classes.
  - RRE is characterized by a shortage of affordable housing options outside the social rental segment, particularly for vulnerable groups hit hardest by the recession — a potential source of social tension and slower resource reallocation post-pandemic.

### Recent policy actions (chronology and specifics)
- Legally binding limits on debt-service-to-income and loan-to-value ratios were introduced in January 2013.
- Loan-to-value ratio dropped by 1 percentage point per year until it reached 100 percent in 2018.
- Eligibility for MITD on new mortgages was limited from January 2014 to loans amortized over 30 years or less.
- The MITD rate fell from 52 percent to 49 percent in 2019; it was set to decline faster by 3 percentage points per year starting in 2020 until reaching 37 percent by 2024.
- As of 2021, mortgage interest paid can only be deducted against a maximum tax rate of 43 percent.
- As of 2021, the deemed income (imputed rent) is generally calculated as 0.50 percent of the estimated market value of the house; for properties worth more than EUR 1.11 million, a rate of 2.35 percent is applied to the value exceeding this threshold.
- The Dutch central bank announced minimum risk weights for mortgage loans in October 2019 (suspended during the pandemic) to start from 1 January 2022, with intention to begin a gradual build-up of countercyclical capital buffers thereafter.

### Identified gaps and vulnerabilities and data considerations
- Data gaps inhibit appropriate classification, pricing, valuation and identification of exposures in CRE; addressing these gaps at the national level is urged and international-level efforts should be expedited.
- Policy tools to counter vulnerabilities from bank and non-bank exposures to CRE should be in place and deployed timely.
- Consider modifying risk weights and capital requirements for CRE by collateral quality, borrower leverage and debt servicing capacity, or stage of the CRE investment cycle, drawing lessons from RRE experience.
- Close monitoring by regulators and supervisors warranted given high relative CRE exposures in the Dutch financial sector and potential for early risk build-up.
- Need to account for data and definitional limitations when assessing CRE and RRE risks due to inconsistent classifications and incomplete coverage by data providers.
- Consideration of structural shifts (telecommuting, e-commerce, business travel patterns) when calibrating risk assessments and policy responses for CRE segments.
- Monitor pension funds’ funding ratios and real estate investment fund leverage given sensitivity to CRE price shocks and potential for fire sales.

### Policy recommendations — Residential Real Estate (RRE)
- Tighten supervisory policies and extend their reach to non-bank financial institutions.
- Review tax design to reduce the debt bias in the owner-occupied housing market.
- Further discourage riskier forms of mortgage lending; while loan-to-value ratios have been reduced, employing generous borrowing limits to address affordability appears second best.
- Consider reforms toward more neutral taxation between owner-occupied and rental housing:
  - Fully neutral taxation would require full taxation of imputed rents and capital gains on housing, combined with mortgage interest deductibility (Keen et al. (2010) framework).
  - The Netherlands currently taxes imputed rent, but at a level substantially below its actual value; gradually raising the value of imputed rents in Box 1 would partially correct the debt bias.
  - Shifting taxation of housing to Box 3 would automatically increase imputed rents and remove the incentive to raise mortgage debt while investing in other financial assets; a broader reform would combine this with a reform of Box 3 to tax actual rather than notional returns.

### Policy recommendations — Supply, zoning, and structural measures
- Consider loosening rent controls and replacing them with housing allowances better targeted at tenants in need.
- Examine reasons for smaller municipalities disproportionately focusing on owner-occupied housing to identify levers enabling stronger prioritization of rental dwelling construction.
- Explore re-evaluating stringency of building and zoning criteria and the construction permit process to improve supply responsiveness, acknowledging challenges for a small and densely populated country.
- Assess opportunities to restore financial viability of stranded CRE assets by rededicating obsolete office or retail properties to other uses (e.g., residential dwellings) when in desirable locations to help alleviate housing bottlenecks.

### Climate and environmental considerations
- Climate and environmental factors bear on real estate markets; the Dutch courts’ decision to void the government’s nitrogen emissions framework in 2019 had considerable ripple effects on many construction projects.
- The environmental footprint and energy efficiency of structures can affect valuations; appropriate incentives should be implemented to modernize existing building stock to preserve financial value and sustainability.

*IMF staff summary based on content in the provided chapter/section.*

### conclusions and offers policy recommendations.

### conclusions and offers policy recommendations.

### Housing affordability and distributional effects
- Price-to-income ratios are an imperfect indicator of housing affordability since they ignore the impact of financing costs.
- Households in other euro area countries are likely to encounter mortgage rates that are comparable to those in the Netherlands; therefore, price-to-income ratios still provide a measure of affordability pressures in relative terms.
- Contribution of housing costs to inequality measured as change in Gini-coefficient attributable to housing costs is shown for multiple countries (chart referenced; exact values in source charts).

### CRE market characteristics and participants
- CRE encompasses diverse property types (hospitals, hotels, housing for the elderly, industrial premises, offices, shopping malls, single store retail, warehouses).
- Financial market participants with CRE risk include: banks; institutional investors (pension funds, insurance companies, real estate investment funds and trusts); holders of debt collateralized by CRE; buyers of equity and bonds issued by firms active in CRE-related lines of business.
- Exposure acquisition channels: direct purchase of physical structures; indirect investment via financial instruments and vehicles; provision of credit.
- Data limitations and definitional heterogeneity:
  - No harmonized classification of CRE; different definitions used by private actors and public sector bodies.
  - Private market participants typically subsume multi-family dwellings under CRE, while some European institutions characterize rental housing as RRE.
  - MSCI property price indicators cover only a fraction of the CRE market due to voluntary reporting and inclusion criteria, limiting cross-country comparability.
- Size and composition (MSCI, 2020 data):
  - Total capital value (EUR bn): Netherlands 61.2; Belgium 8.4; France 183.1; Germany 101.4; Italy 29.0; Spain 22.0.
  - Total capital value (percent of GDP): Netherlands 7.7; Belgium 1.9; France 8.0; Germany 3.0; Italy 1.8; Spain 2.0.
  - Residential (percent of total capital value): Netherlands 60.3; (other countries show much smaller residential shares; office dominates several peers).
  - Retail (percent): Netherlands 13.7; Office 12.0; Industrial 8.5; Hotel 1.8; Other 3.6.
- Financial sector exposures (2020/2019 data):
  - Banks: exposure to CRE risk in balance sheets of banks in the Netherlands at 20 percent of GDP, ranking among the highest in the euro area.
  - Occupational pension funds: nearly 14 percent of assets allocated to real estate.
  - Investment funds with a real estate mandate: more than 13 percent of total investment fund assets.
  - Insurance companies: relatively small prevalence of CRE in asset structure, but significant residential real estate holdings may be classified as CRE under some definitions.
- Internationalization:
  - Approximately one third of commercial properties in the Netherlands were held by foreigners in 2016 (Klapwijk et al. (2017)).
  - Since 2013, more than half of investment flowing into Dutch CRE has originated abroad (CBRE (2021)).
  - Banks have substantially pared back cross-border CRE exposures (about a fifth of bank exposures collateralized by immovable commercial property held outside the Netherlands in 2019, vs. more than two thirds in 2014).

### CRE market developments and vulnerabilities
- Cycle and prices:
  - After bust post-global financial crisis, CRE investment picked up substantially since 2016.
  - In 2020, flows into CRE properties remained above the pre-global financial crisis peak despite Covid-19 disruptions.
  - Residential properties witnessed steep price increases; office and industrial climbed after mid-2010s trough; retail lagged and declined.
- Vacancies and valuations:
  - Vacancies increased due to Covid-19 economic fallout; retail showed the most marked deterioration with 2020 vacancy rates far exceeding 2012 levels.
  - Valuations continued to climb, increasing the risk of a correction if rents do not recover alongside economic rebound.
  - Depressed yields for safe assets have supported CRE valuations; an increase in yields of other asset classes may put pressure on CRE valuations.
- Structural risks:
  - High digital penetration and potential for telecommuting imply scope to economize on office space; slightly more than 60 percent of Dutch employees do not engage in working from home (chart referenced).
  - Online sales grew at average annual growth rates of nearly 10 percent between 2004 and 2019 in the Netherlands; share of households purchasing online exceeded 80 percent.
  - Retail vacancy rates have steadily risen; online sales surged in 2020 in high double-digits.
  - Business travel may not fully recover if remote interactions substitute for in-person exchanges, affecting retail and hotel demand.
- Financial stability transmission channels:
  - Souring of CRE exposures may burden balance sheets and capital positions of banks and non-bank financial institutions.
  - Tighter funding conditions and losses may dampen economic activity, amplify construction downturns, and increase financial market volatility.
  - Interlinkages across many entity types raise complexity and potential for intra-sectoral spillovers.
- Balance sheet vulnerabilities and stress testing:
  - Banks have reduced CRE portfolios but exposures remain high; CRE-related loans quality is generally worse than other loans.
  - Insurance companies and pension funds face potential losses compounded by low interest rates and ageing demographics.
  - Leverage among real estate investment funds, while declining since the global financial crisis, remains elevated, raising risk of fire sales.
  - DNB stress tests (DNB (2020a); extended DNB (2021b)) indicate notable CRE-related losses under adverse pandemic assumptions:
    - Retail and office segments would suffer most; industrial and residential impacts are significant but more contained.
    - Capital cushions of banks and insurance companies would deteriorate but remain at relatively comfortable levels.
    - Funding ratios of many pension funds, already in breach of regulatory minima, would worsen further.

### RRE market characteristics and challenges
- Tenure and mortgage prevalence:
  - Netherlands has one of the highest shares of occupants living in rental accommodation among European economies.
  - More than a third of the building stock offers below-market rents (social housing).
  - Fraction of residences without mortgages is one of the smallest: just slightly more than a tenth of dwellings free of debt.
- Household indebtedness and mortgage performance:
  - Despite a small uptick in 2020, mortgage non-performing loan ratios rank among the lowest in the euro area.
  - RRE valuations have become elevated but remain below their 2007 peaks.
  - Household debt burden in the Netherlands is significantly above peers in the euro area (chart referenced).
  - High savings likely provide limited liquidity cushion due to lack of liquidity.
  - Phase-out of pandemic-related support could put near-term pressure on some households’ ability to service debt.
  - About half of mortgages in the Netherlands are non-amortizing debt with maturities peaking in the mid-2030s (AFM (2021)); scenario analysis suggests a manageable risk of debt distress among interest-only borrowers.
- Tax and policy distortions:
  - Income tax system creates incentives toward homeownership indebtedness via the mortgage interest tax deduction (MITD) and the imputed rental income mechanism.
    - Box 1 taxed progressively up to a maximum of 49.5 percent in 2021; Box 2 at flat 26.9 percent; Box 3 at flat 31 percent on deemed remuneration.
    - Imputed rental income is calculated on market value; MITD has been significantly larger than imputed rent, creating negative taxable income carry-back for up to three years in practice.
    - Interest on full mortgage amounts is deductible for balloon mortgages taken before 2013 for the loan duration.
    - Estimated budgetary revenue cost: about 1.3 percent of GDP in forgone revenue (OECD 2021).
- Supply rigidities and social impact:
  - Structural rigidities exacerbate social impact of rising prices and rents: subsidization of social and owner-occupied dwellings but not private rentals.
  - Municipal incentives favor owner-occupied construction (higher land development revenues) over rental supply.
  - Spatial constraints and zoning restrictions frequently prevent housing expansion, especially in major cities; planning capacity was scaled down after the post-global financial crisis real estate bust.
  - Median Dutch tenant renting at market prices dedicates a rather large share of disposable income to accommodation relative to European peers; the poorest quintile likely overburdened (tenant overburden thresholds cited at 40 percent or more conservatively 30 percent of disposable income).

### Policy-relevant implications highlighted in the text
- Close monitoring by regulators and supervisors warranted given high relative CRE exposures in the Dutch financial sector and potential for early risk build-up.
- Need to account for data and definitional limitations when assessing CRE and RRE risks due to inconsistent classifications and incomplete coverage by data providers.
- Consideration of structural shifts (telecommuting, e-commerce, business travel patterns) when calibrating risk assessments and policy responses for CRE segments.
- Attention to tax-induced incentives for large mortgage indebtedness (MITD and imputed rent treatment) and to the social distributional consequences of subsidization patterns that favor owner-occupation and social housing over private rentals.
- Monitor pension funds’ funding ratios and real estate investment fund leverage given sensitivity to CRE price shocks and potential for fire sales.

*Italicized source attribution: conclusions and offers policy recommendations. (wpiea2021206-print-pdf)*

### 1.      By unevenly affecting different strata of the population, the pandemic has

### 1.      By unevenly affecting different strata of the population, the pandemic has

### Impact on population groups and housing affordability
- The recession triggered by the Covid-19 crisis has been disproportionately shouldered by more vulnerable groups; IMF (2021b) shows that particularly the young and the lower-skilled have experienced considerably larger increases in unemployment than older and better educated parts of the citizenry.
- These more adversely affected groups align relatively closely with segments most likely to rent and for whom buying a property or coping with rising rental costs is challenging due to insufficient savings or income.
- Some pandemic effects could lessen upside pressures on rents (e.g., reduction in tourism and business travel; migration away from urban centers due to remote working), but their impact is described as "rather uncertain" and "unlikely to provide much immediate relief" for a housing market as tight as the Netherlands’.

### Key statistics and household burden illustrations
- Median annual equivalized disposable income (right axis in figure): 9,270; 10,640; 10,072; 12,747; 11,350; 19,490; 18,910; 9,972; 23,034.
- Disposable income spent on rent at market prices, 2018 (Percent) shown across countries and quintiles (bottom, middle, top quintile) — countries included: AT, BE, DK, FI, FR, GR, IT, LU, NL, NO, PT, SI, ES, SE, and CH.
- Note: Data for Ireland and the United Kingdom are as at 2017.

### Macro-financial and socio-economic assessment
- Real estate valuations appear elevated, particularly considering Covid-19 disruptions.
- Real estate represents a sizeable share in portfolios of Dutch banks, insurance companies, pension funds and investment funds, elevating macro-financial stability risks in the event of a protracted and potentially synchronized downturn in RRE (residential real estate) and CRE (commercial real estate) markets.
- CRE faces far-reaching structural change, partly accelerated by the crisis, affecting long-term appeal and viability of some building classes.
- RRE is characterized by a shortage of affordable housing options outside the social rental segment, particularly for vulnerable groups hit hardest by the recession — a potential source of social tension and slower resource reallocation post-pandemic.

### Recent policy actions taken by the authorities (chronology and specifics)
- Legally binding limits on debt-service-to-income and loan-to-value ratios were introduced in January 2013.
- Loan-to-value ratio dropped by 1 percentage point per year until it reached 100 percent in 2018.
- Eligibility for MITD on new mortgages was limited from January 2014 to loans amortized over 30 years or less.
- The MITD rate fell from 52 percent to 49 percent in 2019; it was set to decline faster by 3 percentage points per year starting in 2020 until reaching 37 percent by 2024.
- As of 2021, mortgage interest paid can only be deducted against a maximum tax rate of 43 percent.
- As of 2021, the deemed income (imputed rent) is generally calculated as 0.50 percent of the estimated market value of the house; for properties worth more than EUR 1.11 million, a rate of 2.35 percent is applied to the value exceeding this threshold.
- The Dutch central bank announced minimum risk weights for mortgage loans in October 2019 (suspended during the pandemic) to start from 1 January 2022, with intention to begin a gradual build-up of countercyclical capital buffers thereafter.

### Identified gaps and vulnerabilities (CRE focus)
- Data gaps inhibit appropriate classification, pricing, valuation and identification of exposures in CRE; addressing these gaps at the national level is urged and international-level efforts should be expedited.
- Policy tools to counter vulnerabilities from bank and non-bank exposures to CRE should be in place and deployed timely.
- Consider modifying risk weights and capital requirements for CRE by collateral quality, borrower leverage and debt servicing capacity, or stage of the CRE investment cycle, drawing lessons from RRE experience.

### Policy recommendations — Residential Real Estate (RRE)
- Tighten supervisory policies and extend their reach to non-bank financial institutions.
- Review tax design to reduce the debt bias in the owner-occupied housing market.
- Further discourage riskier forms of mortgage lending; while loan-to-value ratios have been reduced, employing generous borrowing limits to address affordability appears second best.
- Consider reforms toward more neutral taxation between owner-occupied and rental housing:
  - Fully neutral taxation would require full taxation of imputed rents and capital gains on housing, combined with mortgage interest deductibility (Keen et al. (2010) framework).
  - The Netherlands currently taxes imputed rent, but at a level substantially below its actual value; gradually raising the value of imputed rents in Box 1 would partially correct the debt bias.
  - Shifting taxation of housing to Box 3 would automatically increase imputed rents and remove the incentive to raise mortgage debt while investing in other financial assets; a broader reform would combine this with a reform of Box 3 to tax actual rather than notional returns.

### Policy recommendations — Supply, zoning, and structural measures
- Consider loosening rent controls and replacing them with housing allowances better targeted at tenants in need.
- Examine reasons for smaller municipalities disproportionately focusing on owner-occupied housing to identify levers enabling stronger prioritization of rental dwelling construction.
- Explore re-evaluating stringency of building and zoning criteria and the construction permit process to improve supply responsiveness, acknowledging challenges for a small and densely populated country.
- Assess opportunities to restore financial viability of stranded CRE assets by rededicating obsolete office or retail properties to other uses (e.g., residential dwellings) when in desirable locations to help alleviate housing bottlenecks.

### Climate and environmental considerations affecting valuation and construction
- Climate and environmental factors bear on real estate markets; the Dutch courts’ decision to void the government’s nitrogen emissions framework in 2019 had considerable ripple effects on many construction projects.
- The environmental footprint and energy efficiency of structures can affect valuations; appropriate incentives should be implemented to modernize existing building stock to preserve financial value and sustainability.

*IMF staff summary based on content in the provided chapter/section.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2021/english/wpiea2021206-print-pdf.pdf_
