## INTRODUCTION

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [INTRODUCTION](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2023/english/wpiea2023244-print-pdf.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2023/english/wpiea2023244-print-pdf.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2023/english/wpiea2023244-print-pdf.pdf.json)

---

### Overview and historical context
- Dollarization is "deeply entrenched within the Uruguayan economy, becoming a longstanding characteristic."
- Dollar deposits introduced in the 1960s as a more secure store of value.
- Dollarization increased from near-zero levels in 1972 to "over 70 percent in 1989".
- Financial dollarization peaked after the 2002 crisis following abandonment of the exchange rate peg and peso depreciation.
- Inflation targeting regime implemented since 2005 achieved lower and more stable inflation but the economy "continues to grapple with a significant degree of dollarization in both deposits and loans."

### Risks and macrofinancial implications
- Key risks from reliance on a foreign currency:
  - Heightened vulnerability to exchange rate volatility.
  - Amplified financial fragility and increased susceptibility to external financial shocks.
  - Exposure of domestic banks and borrowers to exchange rate risks and potential liquidity shortages during global financial turmoil.
- Dollarization may weaken monetary policy effectiveness by:
  - Strengthening the exchange rate transmission channel to domestic prices, especially with price and cultural dollarization.
  - Weakening the interest rate channel because deposits and loans indexed to international interest rates respond to global rather than domestic rates.
  - Creating a negative feedback loop: high and unstable inflation leads to high dollarization, and high dollarization hinders the ability to control inflation.

### Paper focus and organization
- Emphasis on prudential policies within broader de-dollarization strategies, including currency-differentiated reserve requirements, differentiated provisions for loan losses, and risk weights.
- Paper organization:
  - Section 2: literature on dollarization and de-dollarization policies.
  - Section 3: stylized facts on Uruguay (inflation, exchange rate, dollarization, interest rate effects).
  - Section 4: empirical evidence on drivers and prudential policy effectiveness; special focus on Peru.
  - Section 5: conclusions and policy recommendations.

### Short-term benefits and longer-term costs
- Potential short-term benefits:
  - Risk diversification and a more stable store of value in high-inflation environments.
  - Can encourage saving, investment, and financial integration; may help remonetize the economy and reverse capital flight.
- Costs and longer-term vulnerabilities:
  - Currency mismatch from dollar liabilities and local-currency assets/incomes increases exchange rate vulnerability.
  - Constraints on monetary policy effectiveness, higher financial vulnerability, and increased banking crisis risk.
  - Weakening of central bank’s effectiveness as lender of last resort and need to adjust policy to account for foreign currency deposits.

---

### DETERMINANTS OF DOLLARIZATION

### Monetary and institutional determinants
- Monetary factors:
  - Inflation and exchange rate stability are primary determinants.
  - Historical high inflation and depreciating exchange rate trends foster dollarization.
- Institutional and structural factors:
  - Credibility of monetary policy and financial development influence dollarization.
  - Higher dollarization associated with:
    - (i) lower economic development,
    - (ii) lower governance quality indicators,
    - (iii) higher financial and trade openness,
    - (iv) higher remittances inflows.
  - Financial market imperfections can lock economies into high-dollarization equilibria due to high transition costs.

### Micro and sectoral determinants (Uruguay)
- Household-level:
  - Dollarization of bank savings positively explained by size of savings and household wealth; "cultural dollarization" correlates with wealth and home ownership.
- Pricing and sectors:
  - US dollar pricing persists for high-value goods (vehicles, real estate, home appliances, electronics); pricing positively associated with product value.
  - Price dollarization prevalent in housing market and durable goods; sectors priced primarily in dollars include real estate, appliances, jewelry, livestock, and other high-value items.
- Corporate-level:
  - Liquidity in dollars associated with levels of debt in dollars, firm size, and tradable/non-tradable sales condition.
  - Debt in dollars correlates with firm leverage, asset dollarization, and tradable/non-tradable input/output structure.

---

### STYLIZED FACTS: URUGUAY

### Levels and composition
- About 75 percent of total deposits in the banking system are in dollars.
- Households account for 72 percent of private sector foreign exchange deposits; corporations account for 28 percent.
- Private FX loans composition: 97% corporate loans; 3% households.
- As of end-2021:
  - Approximately 50 percent of the central government's market debt is denominated in foreign currency.
  - More than 75 percent of corporate debt is in dollars.
- Around 25 percent of FX loans are estimated to be unhedged (estimated as the ratio of FX loans granted to firms in the non-tradable sector).

### Macroeconomic and structural characteristics
- Inflation and exchange rate:
  - Uruguay has stable but high average inflation and a history of significant exchange rate fluctuations relative to the US dollar.
  - Since inflation targeting in 2005, average inflation is "about 8 percent."
  - Exchange rate volatility is among the highest among Latin American dollarized economies.
- Development and openness:
  - Relatively high GDP per capita in the region.
  - Minimal restrictions on external financial account (low FARI).
  - Trade openness rose from 37 percent of GDP in 2000 to 58 percent of GDP in 2022.
- Historical public debt composition:
  - In 2000, foreign exchange public debt accounted for approximately 90% of GDP; by 2022 it had decreased to about 45% of GDP.

### Causality and pass-through
- Granger causality tests indicate causality from ER depreciation to inflation; reverse causality not supported.
- During 2004-2014 commodity boom, ER–inflation relationship weak; stronger during depreciation periods.
- Exchange rate pass-through:
  - Declined to about zero or negative between 2011-2013, then increased to positive and statistically significant thereafter.
  - Uruguay's pass-through estimated as one of the lowest among dollarized countries in the region; some peers estimated as high as 0.6.
  - Local projection estimates show exchange rate has a statistically significant and long-term impact on inflation; inflation expectations marginally influenced at 12-month horizon and insignificantly at extended horizons.
  - Inflation expectations remain relatively well-anchored but "are tightly anchored above the inflation target range in Uruguay."

---

### MONETARY CHANNELS AND UIP

- MVP model highlights inflation and ER depreciation as primary drivers under fixed nominal interest rates; extensions consider interest rate volatility.
- UIP implications:
  - Positive UIP premium favors de-dollarization (higher returns in local currency); negative UIP premium favors dollarization.
- Uruguay specifics:
  - Volatility of the 12-month deposit UIP premium primarily driven by changes in exchange rate expectations; interest rate differentials generally stable over two decades.
  - Exchange rate expectations have consistently favored depreciation of the local currency relative to the US dollar.
  - Prudential policies in the first half of the 2000s and financial development over two decades may have helped bring down UIP premia from high early-2000s levels.
  - For 12-month deposits, the UIP condition holds (see Annex III).
- Regression evidence:
  - Level of dollarization decreases as the interest rate differential between domestic currency and dollar deposits increases.
  - A higher spot exchange rate is associated with lower dollarization.
  - Expectations of a depreciating exchange rate tend to result in higher dollarization.

---

### PRUDENTIAL POLICIES: EVIDENCE, MECHANISMS, AND TOOLS

### Effectiveness and mechanisms
- Prudential measures, coordinated within comprehensive de-dollarization strategies, have been effective in reducing financial dollarization.
- Empirical country evidence:
  - Increased reserve requirement differentials in Peru lowered commercial credit dollarization.
  - Higher provisions for dollar-denominated loans decreased mortgage loan dollarization in Peru.
  - Increased reserve requirement spreads helped de-dollarize credit in Peru and Paraguay and de-dollarize deposits in Bolivia and Paraguay.
  - Stricter capital requirements against open FX positions, higher provisions for foreign-currency loans, and differentiated capital risk weights lowered credit dollarization in Bolivia, Paraguay, and Uruguay.
  - Cakir et al. (2022) find similar impacts in Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz Republic, Armenia.
  - Catao and Terrones (2016) report higher provisions for dollar-denominated loans in Peru reduced credit and deposit dollarization.
  - Introduction of local currency repos in 2015 identified as a new prudential tool to encourage de-dollarization.

### Reserve requirement differentials (tool overview)
- Differentiate reserve requirements for dollar and local currency deposits by raising the reserve requirement of dollar-denominated deposits above that for local currency deposits to impose an additional cost to banks.
- Peru cited as successful example combining marginal reserve requirements with higher provisions for foreign currency loans.
- Uruguay historically had a relatively low level of marginal reserve requirement for foreign currency deposits, only reaching comparable levels in the last year.

### VEC cointegration results (Uruguay monthly 2003–2020)
- Cointegrating Equation (key coefficients; standard errors in ( )):
  - Deposit Interest Rate Differential (i-i*): 0.031*** (0.00393)
  - Log of ER (eop): 1.97*** (0.6090)
  - Log of ER 12-month expectations: -1.88*** (0.57)
  - Error Correction Term: -0.009** (0.00515)

---

### EMPIRICAL FINDINGS: PANEL, URUGUAY, AND PERU

### Panel regression (annual 1999–2019; sample of 10 countries)
- Sample: Bolivia, Chile, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, Paraguay, Peru, and Uruguay.
- Positive and significant correlates of deposit dollarization:
  - Exchange rate (log) — continued depreciation incentivizes FX holdings.
  - MVP term — positive relationship supports MVP framework.
  - Net remittances — increase availability of FX and boost FX deposits.
- Negative and significant correlates:
  - Financial development (Financial Development index) — deeper financial systems reduce FX deposit incentives.
  - Financial account restrictiveness (FARI) — more restrictiveness associated with lower dollarization.
  - Trade openness — negative relationship in this regional sample.

### Uruguay-specific high-frequency and country results
- Reserve requirement differential (USD dep. req. minus peso dep. req.) effect:
  - Country-specific regression: a one percent increase in the differential reduces financial dollarization by around 0.8 percentage points.
  - Monthly model (2006–2021): a one percentage increase in the reserve requirement differential decreases deposit dollarization by 0.75 percentage points (Column 11, Table 3).
- Inflation targeting and short-term rate policy instrument (2007–2013, and since late 2020) contributed to reducing financial dollarization.
- A reduction of inflation of 1 percentage point would lower dollarization by about 3.5 percentage points.
- External high-frequency factors:
  - Higher interest rate spreads between peso and dollar deposits reduce dollarization.
  - Higher US interest rates increase dollarization.
  - Lower US inflation increases dollarization (quantitatively small).
  - Increased global financial market volatility (VIX) encourages deposit dollarization (flight-to-safety).

### Robustness and credit dollarization
- Most findings hold for credit dollarization; role of monetary policy and prudential policies is consistent.
- Some variables display opposite signs between deposits and credit due to differing mechanisms (e.g., global volatility and interest rate differentials in stress scenarios).

### Repos evidence (Peru)
- A one percentage point increase in outstanding foreign currency credit substitution repos decreases credit dollarization by approximately 1.6 percentage points.
- The same increase in foreign currency credit substitution repos reduces deposit dollarization between 0.7 and 1.1 percentage points.
- A one percentage point increase in outstanding local currency credit expansion repos is associated with:
  - a 1.9 percentage point reduction in credit dollarization, and
  - a 2.5 percentage point decrease in deposit dollarization.
- Reserve requirement differentials also show significant effects in reducing financial dollarization in Peru.

---

### POLICY RECOMMENDATIONS AND RESEARCH AGENDA

### Policy recommendations
- De-dollarization requires coordinated policy across structural elements, macroeconomic conditions, and prudential regulations.
- Key measures to include:
  - Improve monetary policy framework and use the short-term interest rate as the monetary policy instrument to support de-dollarization.
  - Lower inflation in a sustained manner; a 1 percentage point reduction in inflation estimated to lower dollarization by about 3.5 percentage points in Uruguay.
  - Prudential measures: currency-differentiated reserve requirements, higher provisions and risk weights for FX lending, stricter capital requirements against open FX positions.
  - Use local currency repos to inject liquidity into local currency credit markets and substitute dollar-denominated loans (evidenced in Peru).
- Quantitative illustrative effects for Uruguay:
  - An increase of one percentage point in the reserve requirement differential between local currency and US dollar deposits could result in a reduction of approximately 0.8 percentage points in the share of FX deposits and 0.5 percentage points in the share of FX credit.

### Longer-term strategy and sequencing
- Combine short-term prudential tools with long-term structural reforms:
  - Improve financial development and deepen local-currency financial instruments.
  - Maintain macroeconomic stability and exchange rate flexibility, especially during appreciation episodes.
  - Target reductions in the system’s exposure to non-hedged borrowers and safeguard FX deposits.

### Research agenda
- Examine additional prudential regulation instruments given the influence of financial account restrictions on dollarization in other economies.
- Further study the design, sequencing, and calibration of repos and reserve requirement differentials to maximize effectiveness while managing trade-offs.

*Italic: Source — IMF Working Papers: Taming Financial Dollarization: Determinants and Effective Policies (INTRODUCTION and selected chapters).*

### INTRODUCTION _________________________________________________________________________________ 5

### INTRODUCTION

### Overview and historical context
- Dollarization has "deeply entrenched within the Uruguayan economy, becoming a longstanding characteristic."
- Origins trace to the 1960s when dollar deposits were introduced as a more secure means of storing value.
- Dollarization increased from near-zero levels in 1972 to "over 70 percent in 1989" (Guidotti & Rodriguez, 1992).
- Financial dollarization peaked in Uruguay following the 2002 crisis after the exchange rate peg was abandoned, producing a significant depreciation of the Uruguayan peso.
- Uruguay implemented an inflation targeting regime since 2005, achieving comparatively lower and more stable inflation, but "continues to grapple with a significant degree of dollarization in both deposits and loans."

### Risks and macrofinancial implications
- Key risks from reliance on a foreign currency:
  - Heightened vulnerability to exchange rate volatility.
  - Amplified financial fragility and increased susceptibility to external financial shocks.
  - Exposure of domestic banks and borrowers to exchange rate risks and potential liquidity shortages during global financial turmoil.
- Dollarization may weaken monetary policy effectiveness by:
  - Strengthening the exchange rate transmission channel to domestic prices, especially when price and cultural dollarization are present.
  - Weakening the interest rate channel because deposits and loans indexed to international interest rates respond to global rather than domestic rates.
  - Creating a negative feedback loop: episodes of high and unstable inflation lead to high dollarization, and high dollarization hinders the ability to control inflation.

### Determinants of dollarization (literature and structural factors)
- Monetary factors:
  - Inflation and exchange rate stability are primary monetary determinants.
  - Historical high inflation and depreciating exchange rate trends foster dollarization (Reinhart et al., 2003; Rennhack and Nozaki, 2006).
- Institutional and structural factors:
  - Credibility of monetary policy and financial development influence dollarization levels.
  - Evidence associates higher dollarization with:
    - (i) lower economic development,
    - (ii) lower governance quality indicators,
    - (iii) higher financial and trade openness,
    - (iv) higher remittances inflows (Garcia-Escribano and Sosa, 2011; IMF, 2021).
  - Financial market imperfections can lock economies into high dollarization equilibria because of the high costs of moving to a low-dollarization state (Rennhack and Nozaki, 2006).
- Micro and sectoral determinants in Uruguay:
  - Household-level: dollarization of bank savings is positively explained by the size of savings and household wealth; "cultural dollarization" correlates with wealth and home ownership (Licandro and Mello, 2017).
  - Pricing: US dollar pricing persists for high-value goods (vehicles, real estate, home appliances, electronics) and is positively associated with product value (Landaberry and Mello, 2019).
  - Corporate-level: liquidity in dollars is associated with levels of debt in dollars, firm size, and tradable/non-tradable sales condition; debt in dollars correlates with firm leverage, asset dollarization, and tradable/non-tradable input/output structure (Mello, 2016).

### Costs and potential short-term benefits
- Potential short-term benefits:
  - Risk diversification and a more stable store of value in high-inflation environments.
  - Can encourage saving, investment, and financial integration with global markets; may help remonetize the economy and reverse capital flight (Baliño et al., 1999; De Nicolo et al., 2003).
- Costs and longer-term vulnerabilities:
  - Currency mismatch from dollar-denominated liabilities while assets/incomes are in local currency increases vulnerability to exchange rate fluctuations (Galindo & Leiderman, 2005).
  - Constraints on monetary policy effectiveness, higher financial vulnerability, and increased risk of banking crises (Levy-Yeyati, 2006).
  - Weakening of central bank’s effectiveness as lender of last resort and need to adjust monetary/exchange rate policies to account for foreign currency deposits (Quispe-Agnoli, 2002).

### Transmission channels and "fear of floating"
- Higher dollarization is associated with a higher pass-through from exchange rate changes to consumer prices, raising nominal risk and reinforcing "fear of floating" (Honohan and Shi, 2002; Reinhart et al., 2003).
- In some dollarized countries, the exchange rate channel dominates monetary transmission over the interest rate channel, limiting the policy rate’s effectiveness in curbing inflation (Acosta-Ormaechea & Coble, 2011).
- Semi-structural neo-Keynesian model evidence for Uruguay shows that partial dollarization in the context of contractive monetary policy leads to higher output loss and lower price effects, increasing the sacrifice ratio relative to a non-dollarized economy (Güenaga, 2017).

### Policy emphasis and paper focus
- Prudential policies can play a crucial role in de-dollarization strategies:
  - Currency-differentiated reserve requirements can incentivize banks to reduce foreign-currency exposure by imposing higher reserve ratios on foreign currency–denominated liabilities.
  - Differentiated provisions for loan losses and risk weights for local-currency versus foreign-currency loans can discourage excessive foreign-currency borrowing.
- The paper focuses on drivers of dollarization in the region with emphasis on Uruguay’s dollarization levels and proposes policy measures to mitigate effects, arguing that targeted prudential measures, alongside long-term structural policies and improvements in the monetary policy framework, can help reduce dollarization and enhance monetary and financial stability.

### Organization of the paper
- Section 2: comprehensive literature review on factors driving dollarization and de-dollarization policies.
- Section 3: stylized facts on dollarization in Uruguay, including relationships among inflation, exchange rate, and dollarization, and interest rate effects.
- Section 4: empirical approach and evidence on drivers of dollarization and effectiveness of prudential policies, with focus on Uruguay and regional cases; includes special focus on Peru’s de-dollarization experience.
- Section 5: conclusions and policy recommendations.

_Italic: Source — IMF Working Papers: Taming Financial Dollarization: Determinants and Effective Policies (INTRODUCTION)._

### 15.      Prudential policies have shown to be effective in reducing financial dollarization when they are

### 15.      Prudential policies have shown to be effective in reducing financial dollarization when they are

### Prudential policies: evidence and mechanisms
- Prudential measures, when coordinated within a broader comprehensive de-dollarization strategy, have been effective at reducing financial dollarization (Garcia-Escribano, 2010).
- Empirical findings:
  - Increased reserve requirement differentials in Peru lowered commercial credit dollarization.
  - Higher provisions for dollar-denominated loans decreased mortgage loan dollarization in Peru.
  - Increased reserve requirement spreads helped de-dollarize credit more broadly in Peru and Paraguay and de-dollarize deposits in Bolivia and Paraguay.
  - Prudential measures internalizing FX risks—stricter capital requirements against open FX positions, higher provisions for foreign-currency-denominated loans, and differentiated capital risk weights on dollar-denominated loans—lowered credit dollarization in Bolivia, Paraguay, and Uruguay.
  - Cakir et al. (2022) find similar impacts in other Emerging Markets, significantly reducing credit dollarization in Georgia, Kazakhstan, and Kyrgyz Republic; higher reserve requirement differentials assisted in de-dollarizing deposits in Armenia, Georgia, and Kyrgyz Republic and de-dollarizing loans in Georgia and Kyrgyz Republic.
  - Catao and Terrones (2016) report that higher provisions for dollar-denominated loans in Peru reduced credit and deposit dollarization.
  - Introduction of local currency repos in 2015 identified as a new prudential tool to encourage financial de-dollarization and suggested for later examination.

### Need for a comprehensive policy approach
- A coordinated set of policies is required:
  - Macroeconomic structural policies
  - Adequate monetary conditions
  - Prudential measures
- These elements are tightly intertwined in the pursuit of de-dollarization (Garcia-Escribano and Sosa, 2011; Della Valle et al., 2018).
- This paper aims to precisely measure the impact of prudential policies, among other monetary and structural determinants, on dollarization levels.

### Stylized facts: Uruguay dollarization trends
- Uruguay has one of the highest ratios of FX deposits to total deposits among Latin-America and Caribbean economies.
- Dollarization history:
  - A de-dollarization trend followed the 2002/2003 dollarization peak but lost momentum during the Global Financial Crisis; since then financial dollarization has stabilized.

Key statistics (Uruguay, as reported)
- About 75 percent of total deposits in the banking system are in dollars.
- Households account for 72 percent of private sector foreign exchange deposits; corporations account for 28 percent.
- Private FX loans: 97% corporate loans; 3% households.
- As of end-2021:
  - Approximately 50 percent of the central government's market debt is denominated in foreign currency.
  - More than 75 percent of corporate debt is in dollars.
- Around 25 percent of FX loans are estimated to be unhedged (estimated as the ratio of FX loans granted to firms in the non-tradable sector).
- Price dollarization prevalent in housing market and durable goods; specific sectors priced primarily in dollars (real estate, appliances, jewelry, livestock, and other high-value items).

### Uruguay macroeconomic and structural characteristics
- Inflation and exchange rate:
  - Uruguay has stable but high average inflation and a history of significant exchange rate fluctuations relative to the US dollar.
  - Since implementing an inflation targeting regime in 2005, Uruguay's inflation rate has consistently remained elevated, with an average inflation of about 8 percent.
  - Exchange rate volatility is among the highest among Latin American dollarized economies.
- Development and openness:
  - Uruguay has relatively high GDP per capita in the region, minimal restrictions on its external financial account (low FARI), but trade openness is relatively low and financial development has room to improve.
  - Trade openness growth: rose from 37 percent of GDP in 2000 to 58 percent of GDP in 2022.
- Historical public debt composition note:
  - In 2000, foreign exchange public debt accounted for approximately 90% of GDP; by 2022 it had decreased to about 45% of GDP.

### Dollarization, inflation and exchange rate: causality and pass-through
- Relationship complexity:
  - Inflation and exchange rate variations may increase dollarization; higher dollarization may weaken monetary policy transmission and increase inflation.
- Causality evidence:
  - Granger causality tests indicate causality from ER depreciation to inflation (exchange rate fluctuations preceded price variations).
  - During 2004-2014 (commodity boom) the ER–inflation relationship was weak; the relationship is stronger during depreciation periods than appreciation periods.
  - Reverse causality (inflation causing exchange rate movements) is not supported by the data.
- Exchange rate pass-through:
  - Uruguay’s exchange rate pass-through to inflation declined to about zero or negative between 2011-2013, then increased to positive and statistically significant levels thereafter.
  - Uruguay's pass-through estimated as one of the lowest among other dollarized countries in the region; some regional peers estimated as high as 0.6.
  - Local projection estimates show exchange rate has a statistically significant and long-term impact on inflation; inflation expectations are only marginally influenced at the 12-month horizon and insignificantly affected at extended horizons.
  - Inflation expectations remain relatively well-anchored but are tightly anchored above the inflation target range in Uruguay (IMF, 2023).

### Role of interest rates and Uncovered Interest Parity (UIP)
- The MVP model notes inflation and ER depreciation as primary drivers, assuming fixed nominal interest rates; extensions consider interest rate volatility.
- In a framework with changing interest rates, a positive UIP premium favors de-dollarization (higher returns in local currency); negative UIP premium favors dollarization.
- Uruguay specifics:
  - Volatility of the 12-month deposit UIP premium is primarily driven by changes in exchange rate expectations; interest rate differentials were generally stable over the last two decades.
  - Exchange rate expectations have consistently favored depreciation of the local currency relative to the US dollar.
  - Prudential policies in the first half of the 2000s and financial development over two decades may have helped bring down UIP premia from high early-2000s levels.
  - For 12-month deposits, the UIP condition holds (see Annex III), indicating no systematic compensation for risk on average.
- Regression evidence:
  - Level of dollarization decreases as the interest rate differential between domestic currency and dollar deposits increases.
  - A higher spot exchange rate is associated with lower dollarization.
  - Expectations of a depreciating exchange rate tend to result in higher dollarization.

*IMF Working Paper excerpt: Taming Financial Dollarization: Determinants and Effective Policies*

### 29.       Macroprudential policies such as marginal reserve requirement for foreign currency deposits

### 29.       Macroprudential policies such as marginal reserve requirement for foreign currency deposits

### Overview of the tool
- Differentiate reserve requirements for dollar and local currency deposits by raising the reserve requirement of dollar-denominated deposits above the one for local currency deposits to impose an additional cost to banks of holding dollar deposits.
- Peru cited as a successful example where marginal reserve requirement combined with additional prudential measures, such as higher provisions for foreign currency loans, helped reduce financial dollarization.
- Uruguay historically had a relatively low level of marginal reserve requirement for foreign currency deposits, only reaching comparable levels in the last year.

### Empirical evidence (cointegrating/VEC results presented)
- Cointegrating Equation (VEC model) monthly data 2003-2020; Johansen cointegration test indicates existence of a cointegrating vector. Standard errors in ( ). Significance: *** p<0.01, ** p<0.05, * p<0.1.
- Key coefficients from the VEC cointegrating equation:
  - Deposit Interest Rate Differential (i-i*): 0.031*** (0.00393)
  - Log of ER (eop): 1.97*** (0.6090)
  - Log of ER 12-month expectations: -1.88*** (0.57)
  - Error Correction Term: -0.009** (0.00515)

### Panel regression setup and sample
- Baseline regression: annual data between 1999 and 2019 using a panel regression approach.
- Sample comprises 10 countries: Bolivia, Chile, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, Paraguay, Peru, and Uruguay.
- Determinants included: economic size (population and real GDP per capita), trade openness (percent of GDP), capital account openness (IMF's Financial Account Restrictiveness Index (FARI)), remittances, governance indicators, MVP estimates, exchange rate, and inflation.

### Drivers of deposit dollarization (panel and country-specific findings)
- Positive and significant correlates:
  - Exchange rate (log of exchange rate index) — continued depreciation incentivizes FX holdings.
  - MVP term — positive relationship supports MVP model framework.
  - Net remittances — higher net remittances increase availability of FX and boost FX deposits.
- Negative and significant correlates:
  - Financial development (Financial Development index) — deeper financial systems reduce incentives to hold FX deposits.
  - Financial account restrictiveness (FARI) — more restrictiveness associated with lower dollarization.
  - Trade openness — negative relationship in this regional sample (imports have a slightly larger negative effect than exports).
- Uruguay-specific contributions: exchange rate, financial development, and trade openness are the most significant contributors to fitted dollarization values.

### Uruguay: high-frequency and country-specific results
- Country-specific regressions using monthly data (including deposit interest rates and a reserve requirement differential variable) confirm main drivers and add:
  - Reserve requirement differential (USD dep. req. minus peso dep. req.) has a quantitatively significant effect: a one percent increase in the differential reduces financial dollarization by around 0.8 percentage points (country-specific regression).
- High-frequency (monthly) model results (2006–2021) find:
  - A one percentage increase in the reserve requirement differential between dollar and peso deposits decreases deposit dollarization by 0.75 percentage points (Column 11, Table 3).
  - Implementation of inflation targeting with a short-term rate policy instrument (between 2007 and 2013, and again since late 2020) contributed to reducing financial dollarization.
  - A reduction of inflation of 1 percentage point would lower dollarization by about 3.5 percentage points.
- External factors at high frequency:
  - Higher interest rate spreads between peso and dollar deposits reduce dollarization.
  - Higher US interest rates increase dollarization.
  - Lower US inflation increases dollarization (quantitatively small effect).
  - Increased global financial market volatility (VIX) encourages deposit dollarization (flight-to-safety effect).

### Robustness and extension to credit dollarization
- Most findings hold for credit dollarization; role of monetary policy and prudential policies is consistent (Table 3, Column 12).
- Some variables have opposite signs between deposits and credit due to differing mechanisms (e.g., global volatility and interest rate differentials capture credit dollarization declines in stress scenarios; local currency vs FX interest rates have opposite effects on FX credit demand).

### Additional prudential measures and the Peru example
- Beyond reserve requirements, other prudential tools can complement de-dollarization:
  - Repos in local currency to inject liquidity into local currency credit markets and substitute dollar-denominated loans.
- Peru implemented three types of repos as part of a comprehensive strategy:
  - Foreign currency credit repos aimed at substituting dollar-denominated loans with local currency loans.
  - Foreign currency reserve repos directed at exchanging foreign currency reserves for local currency credit.
  - Public deposits repos which auction fiscal surpluses deposited at the central bank.
- Country-specific regression for Peru using monthly data groups repos into:
  - Repos aimed at substituting dollar-denominated loans with local currency loans.
  - Repos directed at expanding credit in local currency (foreign currency reserve repos and public deposit repos).
- In Peru, effects of reserve requirement differentials, interest rate spreads, deposit interest spreads, and credit expansion repos are examined separately due to multicollinearity.

*Source: IMF Working Paper — “Taming Financial Dollarization: Determinants and Effective Policies” (chapter content provided).*

### 43.      Regression results confirm the efficacy of repos as a tool to reduce financial dollarization in

### Regression results confirm the efficacy of repos as a tool to reduce financial dollarization in Peru

### Empirical findings on repos and dollarization
- A one percentage point increase in the amount of outstanding foreign currency credit substitution repos decreases credit dollarization by approximately 1.6 percentage points.
- The same increase in outstanding foreign currency credit substitution repos has an additional effect in reducing deposit dollarization between 0.7 and 1.1 percentage points.
- A one percentage point increase in outstanding local currency credit expansion repos is associated with:
  - a 1.9 percentage point reduction in credit dollarization, and
  - a 2.5 percentage point decrease in deposit dollarization.
- Reserve requirement differentials show a significant effect in reducing financial dollarization, reinforcing the need for a comprehensive set of prudential policies.

### Policy recommendations and strategy
- De-dollarization should address structural elements, macroeconomic conditions, and prudential regulations together:
  - Structural factors and macroeconomic indicators (including exchange rate volatility and the level of financial development) substantially affect the degree of dollarization.
  - A comprehensive de-dollarization strategy should incorporate:
    - improving the monetary policy framework,
    - lowering inflation in a sustained manner, and
    - adjusting prudential regulations.
- Prudential re-calibration and monetary framework strengthening (Uruguay example):
  - An increase of one percentage point in the reserve requirement differential between local currency and US dollar deposits could result in a reduction of approximately 0.8 percentage points in the share of FX deposits and 0.5 percentage points in the share of FX credit.
  - Using the short-term interest rate as the monetary policy instrument has positive effects on de-dollarization.
- A comprehensive de-dollarization plan should coordinate long-term and short-term policies:
  - Policies to improve structural factors and maintain macroeconomic stability (including sustained exchange rate flexibility, especially during exchange rate appreciation).
  - Prudential measures such as currency-differentiated reserve requirements and local currency repos are crucial to success.

### Research agenda and further policy tools
- Future research should examine the role of additional prudential regulation instruments, given the substantial influence of financial account restrictions on dollarization in other economies.
- Prudential regulation should aim to:
  - reduce the system's exposure to non-hedged borrowers, and
  - safeguard FX deposits, targeting a common objective of lower financial dollarization.

*Source: IMF Working Paper content (excerpt).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2023/english/wpiea2023244-print-pdf.pdf_
