## Introduction

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Introduction](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2026/english/wpiea2026017-source-pdf.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2026/english/wpiea2026017-source-pdf.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2026/english/wpiea2026017-source-pdf.pdf.json)

---

### Background and research question
- The United States’ large tariff increases in 2025 brought trade policy uncertainty (TPU) to the forefront; a central objective was to reign in large and persistent current account deficits (Executive Order No. 14,257, 2025).
- TPU measures constructed from news reports reached record levels during recent episodes, exceeding previous peaks from the 2018 U.S.–China trade tensions.
- Core question: Has TPU historically affected current account dynamics (CAB), and through which channels (trade flows vs. savings–investment)?

### Conceptual channels
- Accounting identity emphasized: CAB = X − M + BPI + BSI = S − I (primary/secondary income contributions are relatively small).
- TPU distinct from general policy uncertainty:
  - Acts as a direct trade cost on imports and affects exports indirectly (via imported inputs, capital costs, exchange rate effects, and potential retaliation) → potential positive effect on CAB.
  - Raises precautionary saving and delays irreversible investment (real options, risk premium effects) → higher S and lower I that could improve CAB.
- Policy implication: The manner of conducting trade policy (reducing or increasing TPU) matters for welfare and CAB targets.

### Empirical focus and identification
- Country/sample: United States, quarterly data 1990–2024 (benchmark).
- Principal TPU measure: newspaper-based TPU index from Caldara et al. (2020); alternative TPU measures used for robustness.
- Empirical method: local projections (Jordà, 2005) to estimate impulse responses of TPU shocks on CAB and subcomponents; TPU treated as a news-driven shock known within quarter t.
- Endogeneity mitigation:
  - Residualized TPU innovations (projecting TPU on industrial production growth, tariff rate, VIX, REER) as a robustness check.
  - Caldara et al. (2020) evidence that TPU is not Granger caused by major macro shocks.

### Data scope and controls
- Benchmark controls: contemporaneous and lagged macroeconomic and trade controls (industrial production, REER, tariffs, non-tariff measures, VIX), quarter fixed effects, two lags of dependent variables.
- Trade and macro variables: CAB, exports, imports, gross savings (share of GNI), gross investment (GFCF, share of GDP), industrial production growth, REER, applied tariff rate, VIX.
- Granular trade data by product, end use, and partner sourced monthly from USITC DataWeb for product- and bilateral-level analysis.

### Key summary statistics (Table 1)
- Current account (share of GDP): Mean -.029, SD 0.014, Min -.062, Max .001, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Export (share of GDP): Mean .076, SD 0.009, Min .058, Max .097, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Import (share of GDP): Mean .116, SD 0.017, Min .08, Max .159, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross savings (share of GNI): Mean .182, SD 0.016, Min .134, Max .216, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross investment (GFCF) (share of GDP): Mean .214, SD 0.014, Min .172, Max .24, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross private savings (share of GNI): Mean .203, SD 0.028, Min .164, Max .389, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross govt savings (share of GNI): Mean -.021, SD 0.036, Min -.218, Max .041, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross private investment (share of GDP): Mean .130, SD 0.010, Min .095, Max .154, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross govt investment (share of GDP): Mean .039, SD 0.004, Min .034, Max .049, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Industrial production (growth rate): Mean .377, SD 2.033, Min -13.465, Max 10.885, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Real effective exchange rate: Mean 2.043, SD 0.038, Min 1.97, Max 2.125, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Average applied tariff (annual rate): Mean 1.997, SD 0.686, Min 1.2, Max 3.4, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- VIX index: Mean 19.469, SD 6.963, Min 10.308, Max 58.605, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4

### Notable historical policy events in sample (1990–2024)
- NAFTA and Marrakesh Agreement/WTO: 1994
- China WTO accession: 2001
- Collapse of Doha Round negotiations: 2008
- TTIP/TPP failures and U.S. withdrawal: 2016–17
- U.S.–China trade conflict escalation: 2018–19
- NAFTA renegotiations → USMCA: 2018
- COVID-19 pandemic / supply-chain disruptions and export controls: 2020
- CHIPS and Science Act and Inflation Reduction Act: 2022
- Expanded Section 232 and 301 tariffs ahead of 2024 U.S. elections
- TPU at end-2024 around 7 standard deviations; sample does not include 2025.

### Methodological diagnostics and robustness checks
- Diagnostic regression: TPU on contemporaneous and four lags of current account plus controls → current account terms jointly insignificant.
- Robustness checks: alternative TPU measures (earnings calls, tariff volatility, extensive margin TPU), controls for economic (non-trade) policy uncertainty, restricted subsamples (1990-2016, 1990-2019), residualized TPU.

### Empirical results — headline effects
- A one standard deviation TPU shock:
  - Raises the current account balance (CAB) by around 0.23 percentage points at its peak; effect is transient and reverses after 8 quarters.
  - Historical comparison: 2018 TPU shock ≈ 4 standard deviations, estimated to have increased the CAB by 0.92 percentage points.
- Effects robust when controlling for actual trade restrictions (tariffs, non-tariff barriers) and general economic uncertainty.

### Trade channel results
- Imports: Statistically significant negative effect; trough around -0.4 percentage points (share of GDP).
- Exports: Smaller negative effect; around -0.2 percentage points in quarter 9 (share of GDP), statistically significant only at longer horizons.
- Aggregate CAB improvement driven by larger reduction in imports than exports.

### Savings–investment channel results
- Savings (share of GNI): Significant positive impact, peak around 0.5 percentage points, persistent for a long period; consistent with precautionary savings motive.
- Investment (GFCF, share of GDP): Negative effect at trough around -0.2 percentage points, intermittently significant; turns positive but statistically insignificant subsequently.
- Decomposition:
  - Private savings rise; government dissaving partially offsets this increase.
  - Private investment shows a small increase driven by high-tech investment, offset by a drop in government investment.
  - Residential and non-residential investment: No statistically significant immediate response.
  - Inventories: Level shows insignificant increase then decline; inventory-to-sales ratio initially increases significantly then declines (consistent with transitory front-loading behavior).

### Sectoral and product-level heterogeneity
- Durable vs. non-durable goods (BEC classification):
  - Exports: Durable goods decline by up to 10 percent; non-durables decline by 5 percent.
  - Imports: Durable goods decline by about 4 percent; non-durables decline by about 2 percent.
- HS Section groupings: No significant differences across industry groupings at HS Section level.
- Interpretation: Durable goods more sensitive to uncertainty because purchases are more easily postponed.

### Partner-country heterogeneity
- Income-class findings:
  - U.S. exports fall for both Advanced Economies (AEs) and Emerging Markets (EMs).
  - Imports decline mainly driven by EMs; imports from AEs rise following a TPU shock (consistent with risk-hedging toward safer partners).
  - Trade with Low-Income Countries (LICs) remains broadly stable.
- Geopolitical distance:
  - Larger decline in imports from partners with higher geopolitical distance.
  - Closer partners may be shielded by trade agreements, reducing sensitivity to TPU.
- GVC and FDI linkages:
  - Stronger GVC and FDI linkages with the United States correspond to larger reductions in bilateral trade following TPU shocks.

### Identification and robustness (summary)
- Three-pronged approach:
  1. Caldara et al. (2020) evidence that TPU is not Granger caused by major macro shocks.
  2. Residual-based approach: innovation orthogonal to macro controls yields nearly identical impulse responses.
  3. Alternative TPU indicators and additional controls produce qualitatively consistent results.

### Main interpretations and implications
- TPU shocks are typically transient with transient real effects, unlike more persistent effects from tariff or non-tariff barrier changes.
- TPU improves the CAB modestly and temporarily because imports fall more than exports and precautionary private savings rise while investment dips modestly.
- Policy relevance:
  - Conducting trade policy to reduce TPU (binding agreements, dispute settlement, institutional guardrails, stakeholder consultation, timely communication, staged implementation) can avoid welfare costs of uncertainty while achieving trade objectives.
  - Empirical analyses of trade policy should control for TPU to avoid spurious attribution of policy effects.

_Source: IMF Working Paper — Introduction (wpiea2026017-source-pdf)._

### Introduction ...........................................................................................................

### Introduction

### Major sections in this content unit
- Introduction (page 5)
- Data and Stylized Facts (page 9)
- Empirical Results (page 11)
  - Benchmark specification and results (page 11)
  - Identification and robustness (page 16)
  - Sector and partner country characteristics (page 16)
- Conclusions (page 20)
- Annex I. (page 21)
- References (page 30)

### Figures listed in this content unit
- Figure 1. U.S. Current Account Balance by Component (page 5)
- Figure 2. Impulse Response of Current Account Balance to TPU (page 12)
- Figure 3. Impact of TPU on trade flows (page 13)
- Figure 4. Impact of TPU on savings and investment (page 13)
- Figure 5. Impact of TPU on the Savings–Investment Balance (page 14)
- Figure 6. Impact of TPU on Different Products (page 17)
- Figure 7. Impact of TPU on U.S. Trade with Different Partners by Income Class (page 18)
- Figure 8. Impact of TPU on U.S. Trade with Different Partners by Geopolitical Distances (page 18)
- Figure 9. Impact of TPU on U.S. Trade with Different Partners by Strength of GVC Linkages (page 19)
- Figure 10. Impact of TPU on U.S. Trade with Different Partners by Strength of FDI Linkages (page 19)
- Figure 11. Impact of TPU developed by Baker et al. (2021) (page 21)
- Figure 12. Impact of Extensive TPU (page 22)
- Figure 13. Impact of Tariff Volatility (page 23)
- Figure 14. Impact of TPU Net of Other Policy Uncertainties (page 24)
- Figure 15. Impact of residualized TPU (page 25)
- Figure 16. Impact of TPU 1990-2016 (page 26)
- Figure 17. Impact of TPU Before 2020 (page 27)
- Figure 18. Impact of TPU on BPI and BSI (page 28)
- Figure 19. Impact of TPU with Different Controls (page 29)

### Tables in this content unit
- Table 1. Summary Statistics (page 10)

*IMF WORKING PAPERS U.S. Trade Policy Uncertainty and the Current Account — INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND*

### Introduction

### Introduction

### Background and research question
- The United States’ large tariff increases in 2025 brought trade policy uncertainty (TPU) to the forefront; a central objective was to reign in large and persistent current account deficits (Executive Order No. 14,257, 2025).
- TPU measures constructed from news reports reached record levels during recent episodes, exceeding previous peaks from the 2018 U.S.–China trade tensions.
- Core question: Has TPU historically affected current account dynamics (CAB), and through which channels (trade flows vs. savings–investment)?

### Conceptual channels
- Accounting identity: CAB = X − M + BPI + BSI = S − I (primary/secondary income contributions are relatively small).
- TPU is distinct from general policy uncertainty; it:
  - Acts as a direct trade cost on imports and affects exports indirectly (via imported inputs, capital costs, exchange rate effects, and potential retaliation), implying a potential positive effect on the CAB.
  - Raises precautionary saving and delays irreversible investment (real options, risk premium effects), implying higher S and lower I that could improve the CAB.
- Policy implication: The manner of conducting trade policy (reducing or increasing TPU) matters for welfare and CAB targets.

### Empirical focus and identification
- Country and sample: United States, quarterly data 1990–2024 (benchmark), motivated by high-quality long time series and central role in global imbalances.
- Principal TPU measure: newspaper-based TPU index from Caldara et al. (2020); alternative TPU measures used for robustness.
- Empirical method: local projections (Jordà, 2005) to estimate impulse responses of TPU shocks on CAB and subcomponents; TPU treated as a news-driven shock known within quarter t.
- Endogeneity mitigation:
  - Use of residualized TPU innovations (projecting TPU on industrial production growth, tariff rate, VIX, REER) as a robustness check.
  - Reference to Caldara et al. (2020) finding TPU not Granger caused by major macro shocks.

### Data scope and controls
- Benchmark controls: contemporaneous and lagged macroeconomic and trade controls (industrial production, REER, tariffs, non-tariff measures, VIX), quarter fixed effects, two lags of dependent variables.
- Trade and macro variables: CAB, exports, imports, gross savings (share of GNI), gross investment (GFCF, share of GDP), industrial production growth, REER, applied tariff rate, VIX.
- Granular trade data by product, end use, and partner sourced monthly from USITC DataWeb for product- and bilateral-level analysis.

### Key summary statistics (Table 1)
- Current account (share of GDP): Mean -.029, SD 0.014, Min -.062, Max .001, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Export (share of GDP): Mean .076, SD 0.009, Min .058, Max .097, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Import (share of GDP): Mean .116, SD 0.017, Min .08, Max .159, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross savings (share of GNI): Mean .182, SD 0.016, Min .134, Max .216, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross investment (GFCF) (share of GDP): Mean .214, SD 0.014, Min .172, Max .24, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross private savings (share of GNI): Mean .203, SD 0.028, Min .164, Max .389, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross govt savings (share of GNI): Mean -.021, SD 0.036, Min -.218, Max .041, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross private investment (share of GDP): Mean .130, SD 0.010, Min .095, Max .154, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Gross govt investment (share of GDP): Mean .039, SD 0.004, Min .034, Max .049, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Industrial production (growth rate): Mean .377, SD 2.033, Min -13.465, Max 10.885, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Real effective exchange rate: Mean 2.043, SD 0.038, Min 1.97, Max 2.125, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- Average applied tariff (annual rate): Mean 1.997, SD 0.686, Min 1.2, Max 3.4, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4
- VIX index: Mean 19.469, SD 6.963, Min 10.308, Max 58.605, Time Coverage 1990q1-2024q4

### Notable historical policy events in sample (1990–2024)
- NAFTA and Marrakesh Agreement/WTO: 1994
- China WTO accession: 2001
- Collapse of Doha Round negotiations: 2008
- TTIP/TPP failures and U.S. withdrawal: 2016–17
- U.S.–China trade conflict escalation: 2018–19
- NAFTA renegotiations → USMCA: 2018
- COVID-19 pandemic / supply-chain disruptions and export controls: 2020
- CHIPS and Science Act and Inflation Reduction Act: 2022
- Expanded Section 232 and 301 tariffs ahead of 2024 U.S. elections
- (Note: TPU at end-2024 around 7 standard deviations; sample does not include 2025.)

### Methodological diagnostics
- Diagnostic regression: TPU on contemporaneous and four lags of current account plus controls → current account terms jointly insignificant, suggesting limited reverse causality once macro-financial conditions are controlled.
- Robustness checks include alternative TPU measures (earnings calls, tariff volatility, extensive margin TPU), controls for economic (non-trade) policy uncertainty, and restricted subsamples (1990-2016, 1990-2019).

### Empirical results — headline effects
- A one standard deviation TPU shock:
  - Raises the current account balance (CAB) by around 0.23 percentage points at its peak; effect is transient and reverses after 8 quarters (around 2 years).
  - Historical comparison: 2018 TPU shock ≈ 4 standard deviations, estimated to have increased the CAB by 0.92 percentage points.
- Effects are robust when controlling for actual trade restrictions (tariffs, non-tariff barriers) and general economic uncertainty.

### Trade channel results
- Imports: Statistically significant negative effect; trough around -0.4 percentage points (share of GDP).
- Exports: Smaller negative effect; around -0.2 percentage points in quarter 9 (share of GDP), statistically significant only at longer horizons.
- Aggregate CAB improvement is driven by a larger reduction in imports than exports.

### Savings–investment channel results
- Savings (share of GNI): Significant positive impact, peak around 0.5 percentage points, persistent for a long period; consistent with precautionary savings motive.
- Investment (gross fixed capital formation, share of GDP): Negative effect at trough around -0.2 percentage points, intermittently significant (not consistently significant); turns positive but statistically insignificant subsequently.
- Decomposition:
  - Private savings rise; government dissaving partially offsets this increase.
  - Private investment shows a small increase driven by high-tech investment, offset by a drop in government investment.
  - Residential and non-residential investment: No statistically significant immediate response.
  - Inventories: Level shows insignificant increase then decline; inventory-to-sales ratio initially increases significantly then declines (consistent with transitory front-loading behavior).

### Sectoral and product-level heterogeneity
- Durable vs. non-durable goods (BEC classification):
  - Exports: Durable goods decline by up to 10 percent; non-durables decline by 5 percent.
  - Imports: Durable goods decline by about 4 percent; non-durables decline by about 2 percent.
- HS Section groupings: No significant differences across industry groupings at HS Section level.
- Interpretation: Durable goods more sensitive to uncertainty because purchases are more easily postponed.

### Partner-country heterogeneity
- Panel approach differentiating partners by characteristics (income class, geopolitical distance, GVC linkages, FDI linkages).
- Income-class findings:
  - U.S. exports fall for both Advanced Economies (AEs) and Emerging Markets (EMs).
  - Imports decline mainly driven by EMs; imports from AEs rise following a TPU shock (consistent with risk-hedging toward safer partners).
  - Trade with Low-Income Countries (LICs) remains broadly stable.
- Geopolitical distance:
  - Larger decline in imports from partners with higher geopolitical distance (examples include Algeria, China, Egypt, India).
  - Closer partners may be shielded by trade agreements, reducing sensitivity to TPU.
- GVC and FDI linkages:
  - Stronger GVC and FDI linkages with the United States correspond to larger reductions in bilateral trade following TPU shocks.
  - Many countries belong to both strong-GVC and strong-FDI groups, producing similar patterns: relation-specific investments and global value chains amplify sensitivity to TPU.

### Identification and robustness
- Three-pronged approach to exogeneity concerns:
  1. Caldara et al. (2020) evidence that TPU is not Granger caused by major macro shocks.
  2. Residual-based approach: Using the innovation orthogonal to macro controls yields nearly identical impulse responses.
  3. Alternative TPU indicators and additional controls (extensive-margin TPU, tariff volatility, earnings-call TPU, Baker et al. non-trade policy uncertainty) produce qualitatively consistent results.

### Main interpretations and implications
- TPU shocks are typically transient with transient real effects, in contrast to more persistent effects from tariff or non-tariff barrier changes.
- TPU improves the CAB modestly and temporarily because of a larger reduction in imports than exports, and through a rise in precautionary private savings and a dip in investment.
- Policy relevance:
  - Conducting trade policy in ways that reduce TPU (binding agreements, dispute settlement, institutional guardrails, stakeholder consultation, timely communication, staged implementation) can avoid the welfare costs of uncertainty while achieving trade objectives.
  - Since TPU can bias empirical estimates of policy impacts, empirical analyses of trade policy should control for TPU to avoid spurious over- or underestimation of policy effects.

*Source: IMF Working Paper — Introduction (wpiea2026017-source-pdf).*

### Conclusions

### Conclusions

### Key findings on trade policy uncertainty (TPU) and the current account balance (CAB)
- TPU shocks have historically been transient and have only transient macroeconomic effects.
- TPU has a statistically significant positive effect on the CAB, but this effect is small and short lived.
- The aggregate CAB impact is explained by a larger reduction in imports than in exports, with durable goods disproportionately affected.
- From a savings and investment perspective:
  - Positive effect on savings driven by precautionary savings in the private sector.
  - Small negative effect on investments, driven by government investment and partially offset by private investment, in particular in high-tech sectors.
- Bilateral trade effects show meaningful heterogeneity:
  - Geopolitically distant partners and partners tightly connected through GVC or FDI linkages are disproportionately affected.

### Mechanisms identified
- Trade flows:
  - Imports fall more than exports following TPU shocks, contributing to an improved CAB.
  - Durable goods are disproportionately affected in both imports and exports responses.
- Savings and investment channels:
  - Precautionary private savings increase and contribute to the CAB improvement.
  - Investment declines modestly, with government investment declines dominating while private high-tech investment partially offsets.
- Income balance dynamics:
  - BPI rises, while BSI declines and then increases, consistent with an initial shift toward profit-seeking cross-border flows followed by a gradual move into defensive allocations.

### Robustness and sample-sensitivity
- Multiple robustness checks were performed, including:
  - Using TPU measures developed by Baker et al. (2021) and extensive TPU by Albrizio et al. (2025).
  - Using tariff volatility (1990-2018) as an alternative measure.
  - Controlling for other policy uncertainties by excluding the TPU component from the overall EPU index.
  - Using residualized TPU and different sample periods (e.g., 1990-2016; 1990-2019).
  - Adding alternative tariff measures based on Schmitt-Grohé and Uribe (2025), VIX, and oil prices (Brent Crude) as additional controls.
- Selected robustness outcomes reported in the text:
  - Adding oil prices to the full baseline specification yields an estimated current account surplus of about 0.2 percent of GDP within the first year after the shock.
  - Restricting the sample to 1990-2016 (excluding TPU related to the US-China trade conflict in 2018) produces a statistically insignificant effect on the overall current account, though precautionary private savings still respond positively.
  - Extending the sample to 2019 (excluding only the COVID-19 period) yields results that align closely with the baseline.

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Uncertainty matters: actions that raise TPU impose a cost on households and firms but do not yield dividends in terms of achieving current account objectives.
- Optimal trade policy should be conducted within institutional guardrails and should seek to anchor expectations, for example:
  - Stakeholder consultations.
  - Timely communication of policy changes.
  - Sufficiently long implementation periods.
- Uncertainty should be monitored and incorporated into econometric and modeling exercises to avoid spurious attribution of current account improvements to implemented trade policies.

### Directions for further research
- Exploit microdata to disentangle the causal mechanisms determining:
  - The impact of TPU on savings and investment decisions.
  - Importing and exporting decisions and their interactions.
- Extend the analysis to other countries beyond the United States, including emerging markets and surplus countries, given their important role in shaping global imbalances.

*Conclusions from "U.S. Trade Policy Uncertainty and the Current Account: Unpacking Trade and Financial Channels," Working Paper No. WP/2026/017.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2026/english/wpiea2026017-source-pdf.pdf_
