## The EU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [The EU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility](https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2026/english/wpiea2026114-source-pdf.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2026/english/wpiea2026114-source-pdf.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/files/publications/wp/2026/english/wpiea2026114-source-pdf.pdf.json)

---

### Overview and objectives
- The Recovery and Resilience Facility (RRF) was agreed in mid-2020 as the central instrument of NextGenerationEU (NGEU) with a total envelope of around €650 billion at inception.
- Twofold objective:
  - Provide a countercyclical demand boost during the Covid-19 contraction, prevent cuts in public investment, and support structural reforms to avoid scarring.
  - Channel stimulus into modernizing Europe’s economies—advancing green and digital transitions, strengthening resilience, and raising future productive capacity.
- The paper assesses: i) short-term demand impact of RRF-financed spending, ii) implications of EU-level borrowing for sovereign debt markets, iii) medium-to-long-term supply-side effects of the RRF’s combined reform-and-investment approach; and draws lessons for the next Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF).

### Key design and allocation facts
- Allocation formula for grants:
  - 70 percent of RRF grants allocated based on population and the inverse of GDP per capita in 2019 and the average unemployment rate from 2015-2019.
  - Within that composite allocation key, population had a weight at 50 percent, while the other two factors each had a weight of 25 percent.
  - Remaining 30 percent used the same factors but substituted the unemployment rate with a measure of the severity of the economic impact by the pandemic (proxied by the real GDP loss in 2020 and the projected cumulative change in GDP in 2020-2021); the 30 percent allocation was adjusted in June 2022 to reflect outturn data from 2020-2021.
- Loans and demand:
  - RRF loans were demand driven and initially capped at 6.8 percent of gross national income (GNI); loan portions not requested could be reallocated to others (even if above the cap).
  - Twelve member states made use of RRF loans, though some eventually reduced requested amounts.
  - For some countries, total RRF allocations reached more than 10 percent of GDP.

### Macroeconomic impact — short term and channels
- Short-term countercyclical role:
  - The RRF acted as a countercyclical tool, providing a significant macroeconomic impulse, supporting demand, employment, and output during the post-pandemic recovery—particularly in countries with larger allocations.
  - Spending has been concentrated in areas with relatively high short-term multipliers; full impact expected to strengthen as absorption progresses.
  - Time-to-build constraints in infrastructure and gradual transmission of structural reforms imply productivity and supply-side gains will materialize over the medium to long term.
  - Overall macroeconomic impact depends on effective absorption of RRF funds.
- Measured effects and magnitudes:
  - For some member states, the impact exceeded 0.5 percentage point, with effects surpassing 1 percentage point in a few cases—notably Greece, Croatia, and Latvia.
  - Few studies estimate annual GDP effects from the RRF in the range of 0.3–0.8 percent, conditional on implementation success, spillovers, and modelling assumptions.
  - Back-of-the-envelope calculations using multipliers of 0.6—consistent with the revised assumption in the European Commission’s debt sustainability framework—suggest the RRF is estimated to have lifted EU annual GDP growth by 0.3 percentage point.
  - Rubén Domínguez-Díaz and others (2025) find NGEU funds increase Spain’s annual GDP growth by 0.08-0.13 percentage point over the period of disbursement.

### Sovereign debt markets and market confidence
- EU-level borrowing and issuance:
  - Under NGEU, the European Commission is authorized to raise up to €806.9 billion between 2021 and 2026 through the issuance of EU-level debt.
  - EU institutions’ debt more than doubled between 2020 and 2024; by late 2025, the EU had already issued more than €400 billion in bonds under NGEU.
  - The loan component take-up has been lower than initially envisaged; about €83 billion—including €60 billion from Spain—has been de-committed at governments' request.
  - As a result, total expected disbursements of grants and loans are now around €575 billion, including about €20 billion financed through revenues from the EU Emissions Trading System.
- Market effects:
  - Sovereign spreads in several southern European countries declined by around 15–40 basis points in the weeks following the initial announcement; by December 2020, when NGEU was formally adopted, spreads had broadly returned to pre-pandemic levels.
  - The EU–Bund spread declined while the KfW–Bund spread rose, indicating an improvement in the liquidity of EU bonds and supporting market depth.
  - The coordinated EU-level fiscal response helped stabilize market expectations, compress risk premia, and reduce financing costs for member states relative to national issuance alone at that time.

### Stylized facts and sectoral evidence
- Disbursement composition:
  - In 2024, about half of RRF disbursements went to the construction sector.
  - Manufacturing accounted for about 20 percent of disbursements.
  - Italy and Spain show the highest disbursements in construction and manufacturing; notable construction disbursements also occur in Poland and France.
  - Information and communication, and professional and scientific activities exhibit large disbursements in Spain and Italy.
- Sectoral multipliers and employment:
  - Michels and others (2025) simulate the RRF’s investment component could yield a cumulative multiplier of about 1.36 over ten years.
  - Basso and others (2025) find the largest employment expansion in construction, with significant effects in technologically intensive sectors related to the digital transition and in professional services.
  - Evidence on crowding-out/crowding-in is mixed: Espinoza and Durand (2021) find limited effects on total investment, while De Santis and Vinci (2025) find both short- and long-term crowding-in effects, stronger for richer regions.
- Concentration in future-oriented sectors:
  - Approximately half of total RRF allocations are directed toward measures under the green transition pillar, either as a primary or secondary objective.
  - Around one quarter of funding is assigned to the digital transition pillar.
  - An AI-based textual analysis of the top 100 fund recipients in each country indicates strong concentration of funding in future-oriented sectors such as research and development, infrastructure, and innovation hubs.

### Implementation, conditionality, and absorption constraints
- Performance-based conditionality:
  - Disbursements are conditional on fulfillment of pre-agreed milestones and targets rather than reimbursement of eligible expenditure.
  - Predominance of output-based milestones and targets facilitated monitoring and accountability but raised concerns about “check-the-box” compliance and limited focus on results.
  - Performance-based conditionality works best when grounded in strong national ownership and aligned with implementation capacity; effectiveness is enhanced by parsimonious and outcome-oriented indicators, complementary technical assistance, and sufficient flexibility.
- Complexity and administrative capacity:
  - Overambition and complexity of national plans, administrative capacity limits, and bottlenecks have slowed disbursement in several member states.
  - Some countries listed over 500 M&Ts; plan complexity, proxied by the total number of words in milestones and targets, is systematically associated with slower RRF disbursements.
  - By the end of 2025, EU countries' accrual expenditure and other costs amounted to 63 percent of the total grant allocation (Eurostat); over the same period, the European Commission had disbursed 66 percent of the grant envelope.
  - The parallel rollout of RRF and Cohesion funds may have strained national administrative capacities and contributed to delays.
- Revisions and mid-course correction:
  - The European Commission encouraged simplification; twelve member states revised their RRPs in spring 2025, streamlining nearly 600 measures; further Council-endorsed amendments occurred in autumn 2025.
  - 2025 RRP revisions demonstrated the need and political feasibility of mid-course corrections while highlighting the need to preserve credibility and trust.

### Supply-side impact, sequencing, and examples of reforms
- Sequencing and timing:
  - Reform measures were largely front‑loaded, while investment execution accelerated in 2022 and was projected to scale up more decisively from 2024 onward.
  - Investment-related milestones and targets under the RRF are predominantly backloaded toward the end of the implementation period, postponing associated spending and its macroeconomic impact.
  - Peak impact from structural reforms is expected well after the initial phase of implementation; many investment effects may materialize after contractual commitment and disbursement deadlines (notably private investment may materialize in 2027).
- Examples of reforms:
  - Italy: 2021 judicial reforms to reduce court backlogs; decrees M4C1-14 and M4C1-14bis approved rankings for at least 70,000 candidates who passed the public competition, including around 40,000 teachers hired under the national RRP targets.
  - Spain: 2021 labor market reform to enhance market efficiency and reduce duality, covering contracts, subcontracting, collective bargaining, short-time work schemes, and employment stability mechanisms.
  - Slovenia: 2025 pension reform aiming at increasing the retirement age, increasing the weight of inflation in pension indexation, and extending the contribution years for pension calculations.

### Lessons for performance-based conditionality and the next MFF
- Five assessment dimensions and recommendations:
  1. Ownership and capacity: align ambitious reform agendas with realistic administrative and absorptive capacity; complement instruments with measures to strengthen absorption capacity (e.g., enhancing the EU budget’s Technical Support Instrument).
  2. Reform prioritization: prioritize and sequence reforms to ensure parsimony and sufficient depth; calibrate ambition with feasibility and consider longer implementation horizons.
  3. Output vs results-based indicators: reliance on output-based indicators improves verifiability but risks “check‑the‑box” reforms; greater use of result indicators could filter out low-utility projects.
  4. Plan complexity and administrative burdens: keep plans succinct and realistic; fewer, more focused performance indicators and greater reliance on result-based targets would enhance transparency and ease assessment; streamline auditing and digitalize monitoring.
  5. Flexibility: greater flexibility in implementation can enhance effectiveness; mid-course corrections are feasible but require balancing adaptation with commitment.
- Implications for the next MFF:
  - The RRF experience provides a case for a central fiscal capacity in Europe: it delivered a countercyclical macroeconomic response during a large common shock and a mechanism for cross-country risk sharing.
  - The European Commission’s 2025b proposal for the next MFF draws on RRF lessons: National and Regional Partnership Plans (NRPPs) will negotiate coherent plans linking investments and reforms; the proposal also introduces an emergency loan instrument backed by common EU borrowing, which would provide up to €150 billion of budget-supported loans under “Catalyst Europe”.
  - Embedding RRF features—linking reforms and investments, using performance-based delivery, and mobilizing common borrowing when warranted—would enhance the EU’s capacity to respond to shocks and support long-term growth.

### Key implementation risks and policy priorities going forward
- Risks and constraints:
  - Uneven pace of funds absorption; infrastructure time-to-build constraints could delay impacts.
  - Overambition and complexity of plans, administrative capacity limits, and absorption bottlenecks.
  - Risk of “check-the-box” compliance if indicators are overly numerous or not outcome-oriented.
- Policy priorities:
  - Maintain progress in implementation while safeguarding quality control.
  - Ensure sustainability of RRF-financed investments beyond 2026 through continued funding, maintenance, and crowding in private investment.
  - Use the current MFF and the proposed next MFF (with NRPPs) to carry forward reforms and investments.
  - Prioritize parsimonious, outcome-oriented conditionality, complemented by technical assistance and implementation flexibility.

### Conclusion — takeaways
- The RRF provided a meaningful macroeconomic impulse, supported demand and employment, and helped stabilize sovereign debt markets through coordinated EU-level borrowing.
- Supply-side gains from the RRF’s reform-and-investment approach are real but will materialize gradually and depend critically on effective implementation, absorptive capacity, and sustained reform momentum.
- The RRF set an institutional precedent for performance-based, EU-level fiscal action; embedding its lessons in the next MFF could strengthen the EU’s ability to respond to shocks, support productivity and resilience, and deliver on strategic priorities.
- An ex-post evaluation of the longer-term impact of the RRF will be warranted as additional data become available.

*Source: IMF Working Paper — “The EU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility” (Introduction and selected sections).*

### Introduction ...........................................................................................................

### Introduction

### Overview
- The Recovery and Resilience Facility (RRF) was agreed in mid-2020 as the central instrument of NextGenerationEU (NGEU) with a total envelope of around €650 billion at inception.
- The RRF combined large-scale borrowing with performance-based disbursements. Disbursements are conditional on fulfillment of pre-agreed milestones and targets rather than reimbursement of eligible expenditure.
- Twofold objective:
  - Provide a countercyclical demand boost during the Covid-19 contraction, prevent cuts in public investment, and support structural reforms to avoid scarring.
  - Channel stimulus into modernizing Europe’s economies—advancing green and digital transitions, strengthening resilience, and raising future productive capacity.
- This paper assesses: i) short-term demand impact of RRF-financed spending, ii) implications of EU-level borrowing for sovereign debt markets, iii) medium-to-long-term supply-side effects of the RRF’s combined reform-and-investment approach; and draws lessons for the next Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF).

### Key design and allocation facts
- Allocation formula for grants:
  - 70 percent of RRF grants allocated based on population and the inverse of GDP per capita in 2019 and the average unemployment rate from 2015-2019.
  - Within that composite allocation key, population had a weight at 50 percent, while the other two factors each had a weight of 25 percent.
  - Remaining 30 percent used the same factors but substituted the unemployment rate with a measure of the severity of the economic impact by the pandemic (proxied by the real GDP loss in 2020 and the projected cumulative change in GDP in 2020-2021); the 30 percent allocation was adjusted in June 2022 to reflect outturn data from 2020-2021.
- RRF loans were demand driven and initially capped at 6.8 percent of gross national income (GNI); loan portions not requested could be reallocated to others (even if above the cap).
- Twelve member states made use of RRF loans, though some eventually reduced requested amounts.
- For some countries, total RRF allocations reached more than 10 percent of GDP.

### Major findings: macroeconomic impact
- Short-term countercyclical role:
  - The RRF acted as a countercyclical tool, providing a significant macroeconomic impulse, supporting demand, employment, and output during the post-pandemic recovery—particularly in countries with larger allocations.
  - Spending has been concentrated in areas with relatively high short-term multipliers; full impact expected to strengthen as absorption progresses.
  - Time-to-build constraints in infrastructure and gradual transmission of structural reforms imply productivity and supply-side gains will materialize over the medium to long term.
  - Overall macroeconomic impact depends on effective absorption of RRF funds.
- Sovereign debt markets:
  - Joint EU-level borrowing at scale helped stabilize sovereign debt markets at a critical juncture, improving prospects of EU bonds to become safe assets through a likely combination of improved liquidity, market depth, and creditworthiness.
- Implementation and conditionality:
  - Overambition and complexity of national plans, administrative capacity limits, and bottlenecks have slowed disbursement in several member states.
  - Predominance of output-based milestones and targets facilitated monitoring and accountability but raised concerns about “check-the-box” compliance and limited focus on results.
  - Performance-based conditionality works best when grounded in strong national ownership and aligned with implementation capacity; effectiveness is enhanced by parsimonious and outcome-oriented indicators (e.g., number of individuals trained, kilometers of road constructed), complementary technical assistance, and sufficient flexibility to adapt to evolving conditions.

### Stylized facts and sectoral evidence
- Stylized fact 1 — Disbursement composition skewed toward construction and manufacturing:
  - In 2024, about half of RRF disbursements went to the construction sector.
  - Manufacturing accounted for about 20 percent of disbursements.
  - Italy and Spain show the highest disbursements in construction and manufacturing; notable construction disbursements also occur in Poland and France.
  - Information and communication, and professional and scientific activities exhibit large disbursements in Spain and Italy.
  - Evidence and references:
    - Michels and others (2025) develop a sectoral dataset and—using the JRC general equilibrium model (FIDELIO)—simulate the RRF’s investment component could yield a cumulative multiplier of about 1.36 over ten years.
    - Basso and others (2025) find the largest employment expansion in construction, with significant effects in technologically intensive sectors related to the digital transition and in professional services.
    - Bucci and others (2025) study around 1,600 investment projects implemented by Italian public entities financed by Cassa Depositi e Prestiti and find RRF co-financed projects were much less likely to be delayed compared to those without such funding.
  - Sectoral multiplier and crowding considerations:
    - Studies on European Structural Funds suggest construction spending and manufacturing generate high short-term gross value added (GVA)—mainly through wages—but have a more limited impact on long-term productive capacity.
    - One-year GVA multipliers in construction tend to be large while empirical estimates show only limited effects on construction investment, implying possible displacement or crowding out of other investments.
    - Evidence on crowding-out/crowding-in is mixed: Espinoza and Durand (2021) find limited effects on total investment, while De Santis and Vinci (2025) find both short- and long-term crowding-in effects, stronger for richer regions.
- Stylized fact 2 — RRF disbursements associated with higher employment and output growth:
  - Correlation analysis suggests sectors receiving RRF disbursements tend to be associated with higher employment.
  - Examples: education sector in Italy and Spain shows particularly strong employment gains; in Germany, employment in manufacturing and information and communication increased alongside high RRF disbursements.
  - Estimates and model results:
    - Few studies estimate annual GDP effects from the RRF in the range of 0.3–0.8 percent, conditional on implementation success, spillovers, and modelling assumptions (Pfeiffer and others, 2023; Bańkowski and others, 2022; Watt and Watzka, 2020).
    - Rubén Domínguez-Díaz and others (2025) find NGEU funds increase Spain’s annual GDP growth by 0.08-0.13 percentage point over the period of disbursement, mostly through endogenous productivity responses.
    - Back-of-the-envelope calculations using multipliers of 0.6—consistent with the revised assumption in the European Commission’s debt sustainability framework—suggest the RRF is estimated to have lifted EU annual GDP growth by 0.3 percentage point.

### Supply-side and sequencing considerations
- Supply-side gains from reforms and investments are expected to materialize with lags; time-to-build constraints and gradual reform transmission imply medium-to-long-term benefits.
- The degree of long-term capital deepening depends on type of construction: routine maintenance and small projects mainly support short-run employment, whereas large-scale infrastructure or energy efficiency upgrades can contribute meaningfully to productive capacity over time.
- Institutional quality and absorptive capacity influence whether RRF-related investment translates into sustained capital accumulation.

### Lessons for performance-based conditionality and implications for the next MFF
- Performance-based conditionality strengths:
  - Facilitates monitoring and accountability through milestones and targets.
  - Can accelerate implementation when aligned with national ownership and capacity.
- Performance-based conditionality weaknesses:
  - Risk of “check-the-box” compliance if indicators are overly numerous or not outcome-oriented.
  - Overambitious plans and complexity can slow disbursement.
- Design recommendations (high-level, grounded in presented analysis):
  - Ground conditionality in strong national ownership and realistic assessment of implementation capacity.
  - Use parsimonious and outcome-oriented indicators that focus on direct outputs of spending.
  - Provide complementary technical assistance and flexibility to adapt to evolving conditions.

*Source: IMF Working Paper — “The EU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility” (Introduction and selected sections).*

### 2025. For some member states, the impact

### The EU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility

### Macroeconomic impact and measured effects
- For some member states, the impact exceeded 0.5 percentage point, with effects surpassing 1 percentage point in a few cases—notably Greece, Croatia, and Latvia.
- The calculation is based on Eurostat RRF expenditure data and assumes a homogenous multiplier of 0.6; this uniform fiscal multiplier is a strong simplification because multipliers can vary with the composition of spending, the degree of economic openness, and broader country‑specific macroeconomic conditions, including the degree of slack and of monetary policy accommodation.
- Ultimately, the magnitude of the macroeconomic impact hinges on the effective absorption of RRF funds.

### Concentration in “future‑oriented” sectors
- The RRF was explicitly designed to strengthen economic sustainability and resilience, facilitating green and digital transitions.
- Approximately half of total RRF allocations are directed toward measures under the green transition pillar, either as a primary or secondary objective, while around one quarter of funding is assigned to the digital transition pillar.
- An AI-based textual analysis of descriptions of the measures associated with the top 100 fund recipients in each country indicates a strong concentration of funding in future-oriented sectors—such as research and development, infrastructure, and innovation hubs—suggesting alignment with long-term growth and transformation objectives.
- Note: the analysis is based on a taxonomy of transformative sectors and an associated word dictionary and is therefore subject to the caveat that alternative taxonomies may lead to different results.

### Timing and peak impact
- The full growth effects of investment funded by the RRF are expected to materialize only gradually, with larger effects likely emerging in the later years of the program and, in many cases, after its formal conclusion.
- Investment-related milestones and targets under the RRF are predominantly backloaded toward the end of the implementation period, postponing associated spending and its macroeconomic impact.
- Infrastructure projects face time-to-build constraints from planning, procurement, and construction, further delaying impact on economic activity.
- To maximize transformative impact and safeguard long-term objectives, it is crucial that investments are maintained beyond 2026 and that adequate management and upkeep of investments are ensured.
- The growth effects of structural reforms supported by the RRF are also likely to be delayed due to reforms’ long implementation period; peak impact on output is expected to occur well after the initial phase of implementation.
- RRF resources are often implemented through financial instruments intermediated by national development or promotional banks that allow spending to be advanced or postponed relative to the receipt of funds; contractual commitment and disbursement to the member state must occur by 2026, but associated private investment may materialize in 2027.
- Member states can transfer RRF funds to the InvestEU Member State compartment or channel resources into EU-level mechanisms, including Joint Undertakings, which can support strategic projects.

### Effect on EU sovereign debt markets and market confidence
- The announcement of a large, coordinated EU-level fiscal response under NGEU helped stabilize market expectations during the pandemic by signaling a credible commitment to countercyclical policy support and reducing concerns about a fragmented recovery.
- Under NGEU, the European Commission is authorized to raise up to €806.9 billion between 2021 and 2026 through the issuance of EU-level debt.
- EU institutions’ debt more than doubled between 2020 and 2024; by late 2025, the EU had already issued more than €400 billion in bonds under NGEU.
- The loan component take-up has been lower than initially envisaged; some member states have not used their entire loan allocations, and about €83 billion—including €60 billion from Spain—has been de-committed at governments' request.
- As a result, total expected disbursements of grants and loans are now around €575 billion, including about €20 billion financed through revenues from the EU Emissions Trading System.
- Sovereign spreads in several southern European countries declined by around 15–40 basis points in the weeks following the initial announcement; by December 2020, when NGEU was formally adopted, spreads had broadly returned to pre-pandemic levels.
- The EU–Bund spread declined while the KfW–Bund spread rose, indicating an improvement in the liquidity of EU bonds and supporting market depth.
- Taken together, improved growth expectations, enhanced perceptions of risk-sharing and asset safety, greater liquidity, and increased market depth contributed to a reduction in overall financing costs, allowing member states to access funding at lower interest rates than would have been possible through national issuance alone at that time.
- The short-term macro-financial effect from the announcement and issuance helped stabilize sovereign debt markets and compress risk premia, but financial-market effects alone are unlikely to fully offset delays in actual spending.

### Supply-side impact, sequencing of reforms and investments
- The RRF is anchored in a conditionality framework combining milestones and targets (M&Ts). Reform measures were largely front‑loaded, while investment execution initially accelerated in 2022 and was projected to scale up more decisively from 2024 onward.
- Milestones dominated the initial phase of implementation, with projects and measures gradually transitioning toward completion and delivery of final targets; progress in target fulfillment was expected to accelerate over 2024–26.
- Examples of important reforms implemented or being implemented:
  - Italy: 2021 judicial reforms aimed at reducing court backlogs; these correspond to three RRF milestones and are complemented by investments in document digitalization and increased human resources. Decrees M4C1-14 and M4C1-14bis approved rankings for at least 70,000 candidates who passed the public competition, including around 40,000 teachers hired under the national RRP targets.
  - Spain: 2021 labor market reform aimed at enhancing market efficiency and reducing duality, including changes to contracts, subcontracting regulations, collective bargaining, short-time work schemes, and employment stability mechanisms.
  - Slovenia: 2025 pension reform aiming at increasing the retirement age, increasing the weight of inflation in pension indexation, and extending the contribution years for pension calculations; such reforms generate supply-side benefits primarily through higher labor force participation and help stabilize long-term pension costs.
- The RRF’s allocation pattern is consistent with empirical literature linking “mission-oriented” public investment to medium-term productivity gains, provided governance and implementation capacity are sufficiently strong.

### Design lessons from performance-based conditionality
- Stylized Fact 1 — Ownership and progress:
  - The performance‑based conditionality framework proved effective in supporting implementation of key structural reforms, with strong national ownership because member states negotiated RRPs directly with the European Commission.
  - Progress in implementing Country‑Specific Recommendations (CSRs) improved noticeably during the RRF period relative to pre‑RRF experience.
  - However, incentives existed for member states to choose M&Ts related to already planned measures, potentially limiting additionality; the Commission noted that Greece, Italy, Romania, and Spain moved some advanced projects from other EU instruments into RRPs due to tighter deadlines and urgency.
- Stylized Fact 2 — Complexity of performance indicators:
  - Ambitious national plans often included very large sets of reform and investment measures; some countries listed over 500 M&Ts, adding to administrative burdens.
  - Plan complexity, proxied by the total number of words in milestones and targets, varied substantially across countries and is systematically associated with slower RRF disbursements.
  - The European Commission encouraged simplification; twelve member states revised their RRPs in spring 2025, streamlining nearly 600 measures and underpinning M&Ts, followed by further Council‑endorsed amendments to 16 plans in autumn 2025.
- Stylized Fact 3 — Absorption capacity constraints:
  - By the end of 2025, EU countries' accrual expenditure and other costs amounted to 63 percent of the total grant allocation (Eurostat); over the same period, the European Commission had disbursed 66 percent of the grant envelope.
  - Absorption constraints and delays are a longstanding challenge also observed under Cohesion Policy funds; the parallel rollout of RRF and Cohesion funds may have strained national administrative capacities and contributed to delays.
- Five dimensions for assessing performance-based conditionality and lessons:
  1. Ownership and capacity: align ambitious reform agendas with realistic assessments of administrative and absorptive capacity; complement instruments with measures to strengthen absorption capacity (e.g., enhancing the EU budget’s Technical Support Instrument).
  2. Reform prioritization: prioritize and sequence reforms to ensure parsimony and sufficient depth; calibrate ambition with feasibility and consider longer implementation horizons to ease administrative constraints while balancing benefits of front‑loading.
  3. Output vs results-based indicators: reliance on output-based indicators improves verifiability but risks “check‑the‑box” reforms; RRF largely tracks outputs rather than tangible results—greater use of result indicators could filter out low-utility projects.
  4. Plan complexity and administrative burdens: keep national plans succinct and realistic; fewer, more focused performance indicators and greater reliance on result-based targets (counterbalanced by fewer milestones) would enhance transparency and ease assessment; streamline auditing and control procedures and digitalize monitoring and reporting.
  5. Flexibility: greater flexibility in implementation can enhance effectiveness; 2025 RRP revisions demonstrated the need and political feasibility of mid-course corrections, but preserving credibility and trust requires balancing adaptation with commitment.

### Implications for the next Multiannual Financial Framework (MFF)
- The RRF’s combination of reforms and investments created incentives to implement challenging reforms and strengthened accountability via performance-based disbursements; this approach should be embedded in the next MFF.
- The RRF experience provides a case for a central fiscal capacity in Europe: it delivered a countercyclical macroeconomic response during a large common shock and a mechanism for cross-country risk sharing—functions the current MFF was not designed to perform.
- The European Commission’s 2025b proposal for the next MFF draws on RRF lessons: National and Regional Partnership Plans (NRPPs) will negotiate coherent plans linking investments and reforms; the proposal also introduces an emergency loan instrument backed by common EU borrowing, which would provide up to €150 billion of budget-supported loans under “Catalyst Europe”.
- In sum, a more ambitious, flexible, and performance-oriented MFF, potentially underpinned by common borrowing, would strengthen the EU’s ability to respond to shocks, support productivity and resilience, and deliver on strategic priorities.

*IMF Working Paper: The EU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility*

### Conclusion

### Conclusion

### Macroeconomic impact and absorption
- The RRF combined large-scale EU-level borrowing with a performance-based framework linking financial support to reforms and investments.
- The RRF has provided a meaningful macroeconomic impulse, supporting demand during the recovery from the pandemic and creating jobs and growth, particularly in countries with large allocations.
- Sectoral evidence suggests RRF-financed spending has been concentrated in areas with strong short-term multipliers, with further effects expected as absorption accelerates in 2026.
- Challenges remain:
  - Pace of funds absorption is uneven as implementation is still ramping up.
  - Overall macroeconomic impact will ultimately depend on how effectively RRF funds are utilized.
  - Infrastructure projects subject to time-to-build constraints could further delay their economic impact.
  - Reform-driven gains typically materialize over the medium to long run as labor markets and productivity adjust gradually.
- An ex-post evaluation of the longer-term impact of the RRF will be warranted as additional data become available.

### Stabilization of sovereign debt markets
- Coordinated EU-level borrowing under NGEU played an important role in stabilizing sovereign debt markets at a critical juncture.
- The announcement and subsequent issuance of EU bonds were associated with:
  - A compression of sovereign spreads in more vulnerable member states.
  - Improvements in market liquidity and depth.
  - Enhanced confidence and expectations of policy coordination.
- Cautions: these effects should be interpreted with caution because other factors (including an accommodative monetary policy in the first two years after the RRF adoption) may have contributed.
- Preliminary evidence suggests EU-level issuance can generate positive spillovers for national financing conditions.

### Supply-side effects, productivity, and resilience
- The RRF’s combined reform-and-investment approach has the potential to raise productivity and resilience over time.
- By sequencing front-loaded reforms with back-loaded investments, the RRF sought to strengthen institutional frameworks and increase the returns to public and private capital.
- These supply-side effects will materialize only gradually and depend critically on:
  - Effective implementation.
  - Sustained reform momentum.
- Beyond 2026, sustaining and maintaining RRF investments is essential to avoid underutilization or obsolescence (Boeri and Perotti, 2023).
- Important policy dimensions as the RRF window closes:
  - Creating fiscal space.
  - Crowding in private investment to ensure continued funding.
  - Designing exit strategies for programs with “unproductive” recurrent expenditure.

### Implementation constraints and monitoring
- Experience revealed important constraints:
  - Overambition and complexity of plans.
  - Administrative capacity limits.
  - Absorption bottlenecks that slowed disbursement in several member states.
- The predominance of output-based milestones and targets:
  - Facilitated monitoring and accountability.
  - Raised concerns about “check-the-box” compliance and limited focus on results.
- Mid-course plan revisions in 2025 demonstrated both:
  - The need for flexibility.
  - The importance of preserving credibility.

### Lessons for the next MFF and future EU-level instruments
- Design principles drawn from RRF experience:
  - Performance-based conditionality can be effective when anchored in strong national ownership, focused on macro-critical reforms, and calibrated to implementation capacity.
  - Parsimony in the number and complexity of milestones and targets is essential.
  - Greater emphasis on outcome-oriented indicators where feasible.
  - Complementary technical support and built-in flexibility to adapt to changing conditions.
  - These elements help maximize impact while limiting administrative burden.
- The RRF experience strengthens the case for equipping the EU budgetary framework with tools that can provide timely, coordinated, and credible support in the face of large shocks.
- Core RRF features offering guidance for the future:
  - Linking reforms and investments.
  - Using performance-based delivery.
  - Mobilizing common borrowing when warranted.
- Embedding these lessons in the next MFF would enhance the EU’s capacity to support convergence, resilience, and long-term growth while preserving sound incentives and accountability.

### Urgency of implementation and sustainability beyond 2026
- With limited time remaining and a significant share of funds yet to be disbursed, further progress in implementation—while safeguarding adequate quality control—is crucial to maximizing impact.
- Ensuring the sustainability of RRF-financed investments beyond 2026 requires:
  - Continued funding and maintenance to prevent projects from losing momentum or deteriorating over time.
  - Use of the current MFF, which can provide some funds to sustain the impact, although its investment structure and focus differ.
  - The next MFF with its proposed NRPPs could play a pivotal role in carrying forward RRF reforms and investments to ensure the impact on the European economies is truly maximized.

### Institutional legacy
- The RRF’s most important contributions may lie not only in its immediate macroeconomic effects, but also in the institutional precedent it sets.
- Whether these gains endure will depend on the ability to:
  - Sustain reforms.
  - Maintain investments.
  - Translate the lessons learned into a more flexible and effective EU fiscal architecture.

*Source: Conclusion, The EU’s Recovery and Resilience Facility: Experience and Lessons for the Next Multiannual Financial Framework, Working Paper No. WP/2026/114*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/wp/2026/english/wpiea2026114-source-pdf.pdf_
