## _file2pdf - 1998. Through the early part of 1999, activity

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_file2pdf - 1998. Through the early part of 1999, activity](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-flagship-issues/external/pubs/ft/ar/1999/pdf/_file2pdf.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-flagship-issues/external/pubs/ft/ar/1999/pdf/_file2pdf.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-flagship-issues/external/pubs/ft/ar/1999/pdf/_file2pdf.pdf.json)

---

### East Asia and Emerging Asia
- Activity remained weak through early 1999, partly because of high real interest rates amid negative inflation and weak domestic demand.
- Singapore:
  - Strong domestic fundamentals, but affected by the regional crisis.
  - Accommodative monetary policies together with downward exchange rate adjustments limited effects; activity weakened in the second half of 1998 before positive growth resumed in early 1999.
- India:
  - Relatively closed economy; proved more resilient to regional financial turbulence.
  - Growth failed to pick up after its slowing in 1997, partly reflecting a stalling of structural reforms and a deterioration in government finances.
- East Asian crisis contributed to increases in financing costs and declines in oil and other commodity prices, exerting severe pressure on emerging market economies in other regions.

### Russia and Spillovers to Transition Economies
- Russia: structural weaknesses in the enterprise and banking sectors, persistent fiscal imbalances, and a buildup of short-term government debt (including to foreign investors) left the economy especially vulnerable.
- August 1998: mounting tensions in foreign exchange and treasury bill markets led to a de facto devaluation and a unilateral restructuring of domestic debt.
- Output declined, by 4!/2percent in 1998 as a whole.
- Inflation accelerated to more than 100 percent on a 12-month basis in early 1999, with the currency remaining under pressure.
- Loss of access to private market financing led to sharp import compression and a corresponding shift into current account surplus.
- Authorities were forced to reschedule payment obligations on debt inherited from the former Soviet Union.
- Russian crisis had a strong adverse impact on neighboring countries in transition and contributed importantly to currency depreciations in a number of them—including Ukraine—and further inflationary consequences.
- Baltic countries: less affected; maintained exchange rate pegs and retained access to international capital markets, but experienced growth slowdown owing in part to reduced trade with, and banking sector exposure to, Russia.
- Central and Eastern Europe:
  - Mostly temporary impact from Russian crisis; weakening demand in export markets of western Europe was a more important negative influence on growth in late 1998 and early 1999.
  - Czech Republic: output fell by 2!/4percent in 1998, in part reflecting a tightening of policies in 1997 and early 1998 needed to reduce external imbalances.
  - Hungary and Poland: growth relatively robust, at about 5 percent in 1998, despite the year-end slowdown.
- Consumer price inflation in the Czech Republic, Hungary, and Poland declined rapidly in late 1998 and early 1999, to single digits on a 12-month basis, reflecting falling commodity prices, past monetary policy tightening, and weakening economic growth.

### Latin America and the Caribbean
- Most countries coped well with financial pressures emanating from the Asian crisis, owing in part to actions to tighten macroeconomic policies.
- Russian crisis: interest rate spreads on external debt soared and private capital inflows came to a virtual halt.
- Brazil:
  - Came under heavy pressure because of concerns about its large fiscal deficit and sustainability of its exchange rate peg.
  - Authorities raised official interest rates and, in late October 1998, announced fiscal measures aimed at producing substantial primary surpluses as part of a policy program supported by IMF financing.
  - Investor concerns about implementation and fears that interest rates were insufficiently high resulted in increasing pressure on the currency; in January the central bank abandoned its crawling exchange rate band and allowed the real to float.
  - The currency initially depreciated by more than 40 percent against the U.S. dollar and remained under pressure until early March, when moves to strengthen the fiscal adjustment program began to restore confidence in Latin American countries generally.
- Brazilian devaluation: relatively limited and mostly temporary effects on financial markets in other Latin American countries, but significant trade-related spillovers to MERCOSUR partners (Argentina, Paraguay, Uruguay).
- Regional growth slowed sharply in the second half of 1998, reflecting less favorable external financing, significantly lower commodity prices, and tighter monetary and fiscal policies in most cases.
  - Argentina: after three years of vigorous recovery from the Mexican crisis, growth turned negative in the latter part of 1998; downturn worsened by trade effects of Brazil’s recession.
  - Venezuela: hit hard by decline in oil prices, suffered from an unsustainable fiscal situation and recession deepened starting in Q4 1998.
  - Ecuador: severe exchange rate and banking crisis erupted in February 1999.
  - Mexico: growth better sustained than most South American countries, partly reflecting closer links to the strongly growing U.S. economy.
- Central America: several countries, especially Honduras and Nicaragua, were afflicted by Hurricane Mitch in October 1998.

### Africa, Middle East, and Turkey
- Africa: economic growth remained subdued in 1998, at about 3!/2percent, mainly due to weakness in commodity prices and, in South Africa, unfavorable international financial market conditions.
- Lower commodity prices, including oil, produced relatively modest effects on Africa as a whole, but fiscal positions and external accounts in many countries came under pressure and large terms of trade losses entailed significant real income reductions.
- Oil-producing countries of Africa and the Middle East experienced growth slowdowns driven by lower oil prices.
- Turkey: slower growth, output expanded by 2#/4percent in 1998—down from 7!/2percent in 1997—as contagion from the Russian crisis showed up in high real interest rates and reduced access to international financial markets.
- Developing countries in the Middle East region and Europe: growth slowed to 3 percent in 1998 from 4!/2percent in 1997, owing mainly to developments in the oil-producing countries and in Turkey.

### Advanced Economies — Overview
- Divergences grew more pronounced in 1998: Japan’s recession deepened, euro-area growth momentum waned late in the year, and growth remained strong in the United States.

### Japan
- Japanese economy contracted by 2#/4percent in 1998.
- In early 1999 output recovered sharply to a level slightly above that of early 1998, though still below 1997 levels.
- Consumer prices remained broadly unchanged; wholesale prices fell, contributing to deflation concerns.
- Recession deepening stemmed primarily from weakness in private demand (declining confidence and financial sector weaknesses) and weakening demand in East Asian emerging markets.
- Policy response: additional fiscal stimulus and further monetary easing, lowering the overnight call rate virtually to zero by March 1999.
- Financial sector: legislation approved in October 1998 to create a comprehensive framework for dealing with banking problems; these measures helped boost activity and improve financial market sentiment in early 1999.

### Europe and the Euro Area
- Stage 3 of European Economic and Monetary Union began on January 1, 1999, with 11 EU member countries adopting the euro and the European Central Bank assuming responsibility for monetary policy in the euro area.
- Through 1998, short- and long-term interest rates continued to converge toward levels prevailing in Germany, France, and other core countries; in a coordinated move in early December, official short-term interest rates were lowered to 3 percent.
- The ECB held its repurchase (“repo”) rate at 3 percent until early April 1999, when the rate was lowered to 2!/2percent.
- Growth in the euro area had strengthened in 1997 and momentum was largely maintained through mid-1998, but slowed significantly in late 1998 reflecting weaker external demand and a deterioration in business confidence, before recovering partially in early 1999.
- Inflation remained well under control in the area as a whole, with 12-month consumer price inflation at 1.1 percent at the end of the period, partly reflecting

### Global growth and regional developments
- World growth slowed in 1999 relative to 1998 with a projection of a modest downward revision to world output growth in 1999 and a moderate pickup in 2000.
- United States:
  - Expanded by almost 4 percent in 1998.
  - Unemployment fell to a 29-year low of 4!/4percent in early 1999.
  - Federal budget swung into a surplus of nearly 1 percent of GDP in 1998.
- Euro area:
  - Unemployment remained high, at 10!/2percent in April 1999, compared with 11 percent a year earlier.
  - Growth slowed in late 1998, most apparent in Germany and Italy; France recorded above-potential growth in 1998 as a whole.
  - Ireland, the Netherlands, Portugal, and Spain recorded robust growth in 1998 but with some slowdown toward year-end; inflation in these countries remained somewhat above the euro-area average.
- United Kingdom:
  - Growth declined further during 1998 and in early 1999.
  - Inflation held close to the 2!/2percent target in the second half of 1998 and early 1999.
  - Official U.K. interest rates (repo rates) were lowered to 5!/4percent from 7!/2percent between October and April.
- Japan:
  - Continued weakness of activity; deflationary forces justified maintaining short-term interest rates as low as possible.
  - Fiscal deficit estimated at more than 10 percent of GDP at fiscal year-end in March 1999.
- Other countries:
  - Canada: economic activity slowed in 1998; core inflation at lower end of the 1–3 percent official target range.
  - Australia: growth accelerated in 1998; annual inflation about 1!/2percent.
  - New Zealand: recession in first half of 1998; annual inflation about 1!/2percent.

### Exchange rates, commodity prices, and external balances
- Major currency movements in 1998/99:
  - U.S. dollar: reached its highest nominal effective level since December 1986 in mid-July 1998; later fell sharply in early September and early October; rebounded in late 1998 and early 1999.
  - Yen: after reaching an eight-year low of more than ¥145 to the U.S. dollar in mid-June 1998, appreciated about 25 percent against the dollar over the following six months and by 20 percent in nominal effective terms; fell back by about 5percent in effective terms in February–April 1999.
  - Euro: began to depreciate shortly after introduction; by the end of April it was more than 9 percent below its initial value in dollar terms, and more than 6 percent lower in effective terms.
  - Pound sterling: traded in a relatively narrow range in 1998, tended to depreciate in effective terms in second half of 1998; appreciated in effective terms in early 1999 as the euro weakened.
  - Canadian dollar: depreciated to record lows against the U.S. dollar in August 1998; recovered following an increase in official interest rates in August 1998.
- Commodity price declines contributed to downward pressure on some currencies and to slowing growth in commodity-exporting countries.
- Current account movements in 1998:
  - Industrial countries as a group: current account balance deteriorated by more than $80 billion in 1998.
  - United States: current account deficit widened by about $75 billion in 1998, to $230 billion or 2#/4percent of GDP.
  - Japan: current account surplus increased to 3!/2percent of GDP.
  - Euro area: current account surplus about 1!/2percent of GDP, changed little in 1998.

### IMF Executive Board assessments and outlook risks
- Board review schedule and focus:
  - World Economic Outlook reports discussed in September 1998, December 1998, and April 1999.
  - Discussions focused on financial market turbulence from Asia, the Russia crisis, and turmoil in Brazil.
- Key assessments and risks:
  - September 1998: near-term outlook had deteriorated considerably; contagion and capital flow reversals posed downside risks.
  - December 1998: market turbulence (mid-August–early October) was unprecedented; calm returned after mid-October due to policy actions; modest downward revision to 1999 world output projected.
  - April 1999: global slowdown likely to continue in 1999 but risk of global recession had receded; moderate pickup projected for 2000.
- Priority concerns:
  - Balance of risks remained predominantly on the downside.
  - Need for policies to support recovery in Asia (including Japan) and to reverse slowdown in continental Europe.
  - Uneven growth among the United States, euro area, and Japan had increased global payment imbalances and posed risks of destabilizing exchange rate movements and protectionist pressures.
- Policy guidance for major economies:
  - United States: risk of overheating; some Directors favored early monetary tightening if domestic demand did not moderate; many urged resisting pressures to spend fiscal surpluses and to preserve fiscal room for stabilization when needed.
  - Japan: limited fiscal room given deficit of more than 10 percent of GDP; full implementation of planned stimulus and extensive structural and bank-sector reform required; maintain very low short-term interest rates and ensure adequate liquidity growth.
  - Euro area: welcome of EMU third stage but concerns over slowing growth; some Directors argued for further monetary easing given limited fiscal maneuvering space and inflation below midpoint of target range; emphasis on labor and product market reforms to enhance medium-term growth and employment.

### Crisis-afflicted economies and emerging markets
- Brazil:
  - Public sector imbalances were at the root of the crisis; crawling peg perceived as unsustainable.
  - Directors expected recovery to begin in 2000 conditional on fiscal consolidation and stabilization of inflation expectations and exchange markets.
- Russia:
  - Sharp deterioration in economic performance after August 1998; sharply increased inflation and risk of prolonged recession.
  - Emphasis on strong fiscal adjustment to limit central bank financing and stop accumulation of budget arrears; reinvigorated structural reform and financial sector measures required.
- Asia:
  - Signs of recovery or turnaround in crisis-afflicted Asian economies, most advanced in Korea, followed by Thailand; Indonesia possibly beginning to turn in second half of 1999 though political instability and reform delays hinder confidence.
  - Directors stressed banking and corporate restructuring and reforms to foster market functioning and efficient resource allocation.
- Other emerging economies:
  - China: strong growth in 1998 but financial and state-owned-enterprise sector problems persist; maintain renminbi stability and stimulus as appropriate.
  - India: relatively modest repercussions from Asian crisis but medium-term prospects constrained by fiscal and structural weaknesses.
  - Africa and Middle East: declines in commodity and oil prices led to shortfalls in export earnings and fiscal revenue; need for debt-reduction options, international assistance, and continuation of adjustment efforts.

### International capital markets, contagion, and financial architecture
- Causes and characteristics of 1998 turbulence:
  - Russian unilateral debt restructuring and the near-collapse of a major hedge fund triggered severe market corrections and portfolio rebalancing.
  - Highly leveraged positions and rapid unwinding amplified market stress.
  - Limitations in risk-management models, liquidity shortages, and systemic exposures in mature markets contributed to intensity of turbulence.
- Lessons and policy recommendations:
  - Strengthen domestic macroeconomic policies and financial systems to reduce vulnerability to contagion; avoid significant exchange rate overvaluation.
  - Improve prudential regulation and supervision, including attention to maturity and currency composition of bank and corporate debt and management of public debt maturity structure.
  - Enhance disclosure, transparency, and market discipline; adopt Basle Committee principles for banking supervision.
  - Reexamine capital requirements to better reflect risks of short-term interbank lending and off-balance-sheet activities.
  - Consider measures to limit systemic risk from highly leveraged institutions (including hedge funds), including stronger oversight and information sharing between supervisors.
  - Recognize that optimal exchange rate arrangements vary across countries; policies must support chosen regimes.
  - Sequence capital account liberalization carefully and develop local capital markets to reduce reliance on short-term external liabilities.
- Role of public and private sectors:
  - Need for greater private-sector responsibility in improving risk management and for the international community to strengthen financial supervision and market surveillance in mature economies.
  - IMF surveillance of international financial markets deemed essential and timely.

*Source: ANNUAL REPORT 1999 — THE GLOBAL ECONOMY (World Economic Outlook).*

### 1998. Through the early part of 1999, activity

### _file2pdf - 1998. Through the early part of 1999, activity

### East Asia and Emerging Asia
- Activity remained weak through early 1999, partly because of high real interest rates amid negative inflation and weak domestic demand.
- Singapore: strong domestic fundamentals, but affected by the regional crisis; accommodative monetary policies together with downward exchange rate adjustments limited effects, yet activity weakened in the second half of 1998 before positive growth resumed in early 1999.
- India: relatively closed economy; proved more resilient to regional financial turbulence, but growth failed to pick up after its slowing in 1997, partly reflecting a stalling of structural reforms and a deterioration in government finances.
- East Asian crisis contributed to increases in financing costs and declines in oil and other commodity prices, exerting severe pressure on emerging market economies in other regions.

### Russia and Spillovers to Transition Economies
- Russia: structural weaknesses in the enterprise and banking sectors, persistent fiscal imbalances, and a buildup of short-term government debt (including to foreign investors) left the economy especially vulnerable.
- August 1998: mounting tensions in foreign exchange and treasury bill markets led to a de facto devaluation and a unilateral restructuring of domestic debt.
- Output declined, by 4!/2percent in 1998 as a whole.
- Inflation accelerated to more than 100 percent on a 12-month basis in early 1999, with the currency remaining under pressure.
- Loss of access to private market financing led to sharp import compression and a corresponding shift into current account surplus.
- Authorities were forced to reschedule payment obligations on debt inherited from the former Soviet Union.
- Russian crisis had a strong adverse impact on neighboring countries in transition and contributed importantly to currency depreciations in a number of them—including Ukraine—and further inflationary consequences.
- Baltic countries: less affected; maintained exchange rate pegs and retained access to international capital markets, but experienced growth slowdown owing in part to reduced trade with, and banking sector exposure to, Russia.
- Central and Eastern Europe: mostly temporary impact from Russian crisis; weakening demand in export markets of western Europe was a more important negative influence on growth in late 1998 and early 1999.
  - Czech Republic: output fell by 2!/4percent in 1998, in part reflecting a tightening of policies in 1997 and early 1998 needed to reduce external imbalances.
  - Hungary and Poland: growth relatively robust, at about 5 percent in 1998, despite the year-end slowdown.
- Consumer price inflation in the Czech Republic, Hungary, and Poland declined rapidly in late 1998 and early 1999, to single digits on a 12-month basis, reflecting falling commodity prices, past monetary policy tightening, and weakening economic growth.

### Latin America and the Caribbean
- Most countries coped well with financial pressures emanating from the Asian crisis, owing in part to actions to tighten macroeconomic policies.
- Russian crisis: interest rate spreads on external debt soared and private capital inflows came to a virtual halt.
- Brazil: came under heavy pressure because of concerns about its large fiscal deficit and sustainability of its exchange rate peg.
  - Authorities raised official interest rates and, in late October 1998, announced fiscal measures aimed at producing substantial primary surpluses as part of a policy program supported by IMF financing.
  - Investor concerns about implementation and fears that interest rates were insufficiently high resulted in increasing pressure on the currency; in January the central bank abandoned its crawling exchange rate band and allowed the real to float.
  - The currency initially depreciated by more than 40 percent against the U.S. dollar and remained under pressure until early March, when moves to strengthen the fiscal adjustment program began to restore confidence in Latin American countries generally.
- Brazilian devaluation: relatively limited and mostly temporary effects on financial markets in other Latin American countries, but significant trade-related spillovers to MERCOSUR partners (Argentina, Paraguay, Uruguay).
- Regional growth slowed sharply in the second half of 1998, reflecting less favorable external financing, significantly lower commodity prices, and tighter monetary and fiscal policies in most cases.
  - Argentina: after three years of vigorous recovery from the Mexican crisis, growth turned negative in the latter part of 1998; downturn worsened by trade effects of Brazil’s recession.
  - Venezuela: hit hard by decline in oil prices, suffered from an unsustainable fiscal situation and recession deepened starting in Q4 1998.
  - Ecuador: severe exchange rate and banking crisis erupted in February 1999.
  - Mexico: growth better sustained than most South American countries, partly reflecting closer links to the strongly growing U.S. economy.
- Central America: several countries, especially Honduras and Nicaragua, were afflicted by Hurricane Mitch in October 1998.

### Africa, Middle East, and Turkey
- Africa: economic growth remained subdued in 1998, at about 3!/2percent, mainly due to weakness in commodity prices and, in South Africa, unfavorable international financial market conditions.
- Lower commodity prices, including oil, produced relatively modest effects on Africa as a whole, but fiscal positions and external accounts in many countries came under pressure and large terms of trade losses entailed significant real income reductions.
- Oil-producing countries of Africa and the Middle East experienced growth slowdowns driven by lower oil prices.
- Turkey: slower growth, output expanded by 2#/4percent in 1998—down from 7!/2percent in 1997—as contagion from the Russian crisis showed up in high real interest rates and reduced access to international financial markets.
- Developing countries in the Middle East region and Europe: growth slowed to 3 percent in 1998 from 4!/2percent in 1997, owing mainly to developments in the oil-producing countries and in Turkey.

### Advanced Economies — Overview
- Divergences grew more pronounced in 1998: Japan’s recession deepened, euro-area growth momentum waned late in the year, and growth remained strong in the United States.

### Japan
- Japanese economy contracted by 2#/4percent in 1998.
- In early 1999 output recovered sharply to a level slightly above that of early 1998, though still below 1997 levels.
- Consumer prices remained broadly unchanged; wholesale prices fell, contributing to deflation concerns.
- Recession deepening stemmed primarily from weakness in private demand (declining confidence and financial sector weaknesses) and weakening demand in East Asian emerging markets.
- Policy response: additional fiscal stimulus and further monetary easing, lowering the overnight call rate virtually to zero by March 1999.
- Financial sector: legislation approved in October 1998 to create a comprehensive framework for dealing with banking problems; these measures helped boost activity and improve financial market sentiment in early 1999.

### Europe and the Euro Area
- Stage 3 of European Economic and Monetary Union began on January 1, 1999, with 11 EU member countries adopting the euro and the European Central Bank assuming responsibility for monetary policy in the euro area.
- Through 1998, short- and long-term interest rates continued to converge toward levels prevailing in Germany, France, and other core countries; in a coordinated move in early December, official short-term interest rates were lowered to 3 percent.
- The ECB held its repurchase (“repo”) rate at 3 percent until early April 1999, when the rate was lowered to 2!/2percent.
- Growth in the euro area had strengthened in 1997 and momentum was largely maintained through mid-1998, but slowed significantly in late 1998 reflecting weaker external demand and a deterioration in business confidence, before recovering partially in early 1999.
- Inflation remained well under control in the area as a whole, with 12-month consumer price inflation at

*Source: IMF, World Economic Outlook (May 1999).*

### 1.1 percent at the end of the period, partly reflecting

### _file2pdf - 1.1 percent at the end of the period, partly reflecting

### Global growth and regional developments
- World growth slowed in 1999 relative to 1998 with a projection of a modest downward revision to world output growth in 1999 and a moderate pickup in 2000.
- United States:
  - Expanded by almost 4 percent in 1998.
  - Unemployment fell to a 29-year low of 4!/4percent in early 1999.
  - Federal budget swung into a surplus of nearly 1 percent of GDP in 1998.
- Euro area:
  - Unemployment remained high, at 10!/2percent in April 1999, compared with 11 percent a year earlier.
  - Growth slowed in late 1998, most apparent in Germany and Italy; France recorded above-potential growth in 1998 as a whole.
  - Ireland, the Netherlands, Portugal, and Spain recorded robust growth in 1998 but with some slowdown toward year-end; inflation in these countries remained somewhat above the euro-area average.
- United Kingdom:
  - Growth declined further during 1998 and in early 1999.
  - Inflation held close to the 2!/2percent target in the second half of 1998 and early 1999.
  - Official U.K. interest rates (repo rates) were lowered to 5!/4percent from 7!/2percent between October and April.
- Japan:
  - Continued weakness of activity; deflationary forces justified maintaining short-term interest rates as low as possible.
  - Fiscal deficit estimated at more than 10 percent of GDP at fiscal year-end in March 1999.
- Other countries:
  - Canada: economic activity slowed in 1998; core inflation at lower end of the 1–3 percent official target range.
  - Australia: growth accelerated in 1998; annual inflation about 1!/2percent.
  - New Zealand: recession in first half of 1998; annual inflation about 1!/2percent.

### Exchange rates, commodity prices, and external balances
- Major currency movements in 1998/99:
  - U.S. dollar reached its highest nominal effective level since December 1986 in mid-July 1998; later fell sharply in early September and early October; rebounded in late 1998 and early 1999.
  - Yen: after reaching an eight-year low of more than ¥145 to the U.S. dollar in mid-June 1998, appreciated about 25 percent against the dollar over the following six months and by 20 percent in nominal effective terms; fell back by about 5percent in effective terms in February–April 1999.
  - Euro: began to depreciate shortly after introduction; by the end of April it was more than 9 percent below its initial value in dollar terms, and more than 6 percent lower in effective terms.
  - Pound sterling: traded in a relatively narrow range in 1998, tended to depreciate in effective terms in second half of 1998; appreciated in effective terms in early 1999 as the euro weakened.
  - Canadian dollar: depreciated to record lows against the U.S. dollar in August 1998; recovered following an increase in official interest rates in August 1998.
- Commodity price declines contributed to downward pressure on some currencies and to slowing growth in commodity-exporting countries.
- Current account movements in 1998:
  - Industrial countries as a group: current account balance deteriorated by more than $80 billion in 1998.
  - United States: current account deficit widened by about $75 billion in 1998, to $230 billion or 2#/4percent of GDP.
  - Japan: current account surplus increased to 3!/2percent of GDP.
  - Euro area: current account surplus about 1!/2percent of GDP, changed little in 1998.

### IMF Executive Board assessments and outlook risks
- Board review schedule and focus:
  - World Economic Outlook reports discussed in September 1998, December 1998, and April 1999.
  - Discussions focused on financial market turbulence from Asia, the Russia crisis, and turmoil in Brazil.
- Key assessments and risks:
  - September 1998: near-term outlook had deteriorated considerably; contagion and capital flow reversals posed downside risks.
  - December 1998: market turbulence (mid-August–early October) was unprecedented; calm returned after mid-October due to policy actions; modest downward revision to 1999 world output projected.
  - April 1999: global slowdown likely to continue in 1999 but risk of global recession had receded; moderate pickup projected for 2000.
- Priority concerns:
  - Balance of risks remained predominantly on the downside.
  - Need for policies to support recovery in Asia (including Japan) and to reverse slowdown in continental Europe.
  - Uneven growth among the United States, euro area, and Japan had increased global payment imbalances and posed risks of destabilizing exchange rate movements and protectionist pressures.
- Policy guidance for major economies:
  - United States: risk of overheating; some Directors favored early monetary tightening if domestic demand did not moderate; many urged resisting pressures to spend fiscal surpluses and to preserve fiscal room for stabilization when needed.
  - Japan: limited fiscal room given deficit of more than 10 percent of GDP; full implementation of planned stimulus and extensive structural and bank-sector reform required; maintain very low short-term interest rates and ensure adequate liquidity growth.
  - Euro area: welcome of EMU third stage but concerns over slowing growth; some Directors argued for further monetary easing given limited fiscal maneuvering space and inflation below midpoint of target range; emphasis on labor and product market reforms to enhance medium-term growth and employment.

### Crisis-afflicted economies and emerging markets
- Brazil:
  - Public sector imbalances were at the root of the crisis; crawling peg perceived as unsustainable.
  - Directors expected recovery to begin in 2000 conditional on fiscal consolidation and stabilization of inflation expectations and exchange markets.
- Russia:
  - Sharp deterioration in economic performance after August 1998; sharply increased inflation and risk of prolonged recession.
  - Emphasis on strong fiscal adjustment to limit central bank financing and stop accumulation of budget arrears; reinvigorated structural reform and financial sector measures required.
- Asia:
  - Signs of recovery or turnaround in crisis-afflicted Asian economies, most advanced in Korea, followed by Thailand; Indonesia possibly beginning to turn in second half of 1999 though political instability and reform delays hinder confidence.
  - Directors stressed banking and corporate restructuring and reforms to foster market functioning and efficient resource allocation.
- Other emerging economies:
  - China: strong growth in 1998 but financial and state-owned-enterprise sector problems persist; maintain renminbi stability and stimulus as appropriate.
  - India: relatively modest repercussions from Asian crisis but medium-term prospects constrained by fiscal and structural weaknesses.
  - Africa and Middle East: declines in commodity and oil prices led to shortfalls in export earnings and fiscal revenue; need for debt-reduction options, international assistance, and continuation of adjustment efforts.

### International capital markets, contagion, and financial architecture
- Causes and characteristics of 1998 turbulence:
  - Russian unilateral debt restructuring and the near-collapse of a major hedge fund triggered severe market corrections and portfolio rebalancing.
  - Highly leveraged positions and rapid unwinding amplified market stress.
  - Limitations in risk-management models, liquidity shortages, and systemic exposures in mature markets contributed to intensity of turbulence.
- Lessons and policy recommendations:
  - Strengthen domestic macroeconomic policies and financial systems to reduce vulnerability to contagion; avoid significant exchange rate overvaluation.
  - Improve prudential regulation and supervision, including attention to maturity and currency composition of bank and corporate debt and management of public debt maturity structure.
  - Enhance disclosure, transparency, and market discipline; adopt Basle Committee principles for banking supervision.
  - Reexamine capital requirements to better reflect risks of short-term interbank lending and off-balance-sheet activities.
  - Consider measures to limit systemic risk from highly leveraged institutions (including hedge funds), including stronger oversight and information sharing between supervisors.
  - Recognize that optimal exchange rate arrangements vary across countries; policies must support chosen regimes.
  - Sequence capital account liberalization carefully and develop local capital markets to reduce reliance on short-term external liabilities.
- Role of public and private sectors:
  - Need for greater private-sector responsibility in improving risk management and for the international community to strengthen financial supervision and market surveillance in mature economies.
  - IMF surveillance of international financial markets deemed essential and timely.

*Source: ANNUAL REPORT 1999 — THE GLOBAL ECONOMY (World Economic Outlook).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-flagship-issues/external/pubs/ft/ar/1999/pdf/_file2pdf.pdf_
