## Executive Summary

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Executive Summary](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2006/_020806.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2006/_020806.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2006/_020806.pdf.json)

---

### Overview and Context
- Provides an update on actions taken under the offshore financial center (OFC) program since the last update issued in February 2005.
- Three jurisdictions were assessed in 2005 and nine assessments have been scheduled.
- Assessments coordinated with mutual evaluations conducted by FATF and FATF-style regional bodies to avoid duplication.
- Several jurisdictions requested postponements to focus on enhancing supervisory arrangements.
- Technical assistance (TA) has been provided mostly to small, lower-income jurisdictions in banking and insurance supervision, AML/CFT legislation and supervision, and statistics.

### Information Framework Initiative: Monitoring and Transparency
- Aims:
  - improve transparency in the activities of international and offshore financial centers; and
  - provide the IMF with information for its ongoing monitoring of financial developments in these centers.
- Framework features:
  - provides structural and activity indicators for banking, insurance sectors, and collective investment schemes; complements CPIS and BIS international banking statistics.
- Pilot phase:
  - Forty-six jurisdictions were invited in December 2004 to participate in the pilot phase of this voluntary initiative.
  - MFD, with assistance from STA and TGS, held a workshop on May 11–12, 2005; attended by 27 international and offshore financial centers.

### Key statistics and status (As of end-January 2006)
- Jurisdictions that have submitted data: 16
- Jurisdictions that have committed/indicated intention to participate but not yet submitted data: 18
- Jurisdictions that have yet to confirm participation: 7
- Jurisdictions that have declined to participate: 5

Jurisdictions that have submitted data (Total: 16)
- Bahrain*
- Bermuda*
- Cayman Islands*
- Cyprus‡
- Guernsey*
- Isle of Man*
- Jersey*
- Luxembourg* ‡
- Netherlands Antilles*
- Panama*
- Singapore* ‡
- Switzerland* ‡

Jurisdictions that have committed/indicated intention to participate but not yet submitted data (Total: 18)
- Andorra
- Anguilla
- Antigua & Barbuda
- Bahamas, The*
- Barbados
- Belize
- Costa Rica‡
- Dominica
- Grenada
- Lebanon‡
- Marshall Islands3/
- Malaysia (Labuan)3/
- Nauru
- Niue
- Palau
- Samoa
- Seychelles
- St. Kitts and Nevis
- St. Lucia
- St. Vincent and the Grenadines
- Turks and Caicos Islands
- Vanuatu

Jurisdictions that have yet to confirm participation (Total: 7)
- Aruba
- British Virgin Islands
- Cook Islands
- Gibraltar
- Liechtenstein
- Monaco
- Montserrat

Jurisdictions that have declined to participate (Total: 5)
- Hong Kong SAR* ‡ 1/
- Ireland* ‡ 1/
- Malta‡
- Mauritius
- Panama*2/

Notes associated with the table
- * These jurisdictions report data to the BIS.
- ‡ These jurisdictions are participating in the IMF’s FSI Coordinated Compilation Exercise.
- 1/ These jurisdictions while declining to participate in the initiative have authorized the BIS to forward data on banks' external assets/liabilities to the Fund.
- 2/ While these jurisdictions have yet to submit data as part of the initiative, data on banks' external assets/liabilities have been received from the BIS.
- 3/ While these jurisdictions have yet to confirm participation they were represented at the May 2005 workshop which discussed how this initiative would be implemented.

### Observations on the initiative
- Data collected provide useful comparisons of the significance of different centers and a more complete picture of geographical distribution of the financial services industry.
- Six jurisdictions have provided banking sector external assets/liabilities data through the BIS, including 3 jurisdictions who have declined to otherwise participate.
- A few jurisdictions are making significant changes to their collection systems to improve data availability.
- Staff are following up with jurisdictions to encourage broader participation and data dissemination.
- The usefulness of the initiative will be enhanced by higher participation rates—the larger the number of jurisdictions who participate, the more cross-country comparable data will be available to staff, and gaps in the global monitoring framework reduced.

### Monitoring, Assessments, and Technical Assistance
- Assessment frequency and priorities:
  - Assessments invited on a 4–5 year frequency agreed by Directors, with priority to jurisdictions with significant activity or where important weaknesses were identified.
  - Members may choose to be assessed under the FSAP which has an average frequency of five years.
  - Assessments prioritize: progress in addressing substantial shortcomings identified in earlier assessments; significant areas not previously assessed; and evaluating important reforms.
- Increased emphasis on cooperation and information exchange; standard setters and jurisdictions with significant cross-border activity invited to identify cooperation and information exchange issues for follow-up during assessments.
- Monitoring results inform the Financial Stability Forum (FSF)’s work; at its March 2005 meeting the FSF withdrew its 2000 listing of OFCs, noted remaining problems particularly in cross-border cooperation and information exchange, and established a Review Group on Offshore Financial Centers to monitor progress.
- Technical assistance delivery:
  - Seventeen jurisdictions from all regions received TA in banking supervision or closely related areas during 2005 and two in insurance supervision.
  - In the Asia-Pacific region, three jurisdictions received assistance with AML/CFT supervision and legislation from MFD and LEG.
  - Several IOFCs participated in three AML/CFT supervision, legislative and FIU workshops hosted by the Singapore Training Institute, in cooperation with MFD and LEG.
  - To address TA requirements in the Pacific region, staff, in cooperation with PFTAC, is strengthening cooperation with bilateral agencies.
  - Caribbean and Middle East jurisdictions benefited from three AML/CFT workshops held for each region by MFD and LEG, and two Caribbean countries received AML/CFT TA for legislative drafting and establishment of FIUs.
  - STA provided assistance on statistical collection for the Coordinated Portfolio Investment Survey (CPIS); eleven IOFC jurisdictions participated in a workshop in May 2005 to review 2003 results and plan for the 2004 survey.

### Collaboration, Cooperation, and Emerging Themes
- The third IMF roundtable (November 2005) emphasized continued attention to cooperation and information sharing, risk-based supervision, and appropriate sequencing of standards implementation to address increasingly complex cross-border issues.
- Participants agreed supervisors and standard setters should consider:
  - disseminating good practices on information sharing;
  - providing website guides to jurisdictions’ information sharing arrangements; and
  - assigning priority and resources to information exchange issues.

### 13. The Third Annual Roundtable for offshore and onshore supervisors and standard setters (Sydney, November 17–18, 2005)

### Roundtable overview and participation
- Held on November 17–18, 2005, in Sydney; hosted jointly by APRA, ASIC, AUSTRAC, and the RBA.
- Attended by 27 jurisdictions, BCBS, FATF, IAIS, IOSCO, the FSF, OGBS, the Egmont Group, and the APG.
- Advance copies of the Proceedings of the 2004 MFD-hosted conference on cross-border cooperation and information exchange were distributed; formal publication is expected in mid-2006.

### Major cross-border supervisory themes and sectoral findings
- General:
  - Complexity of international financial services associated with increasing cross-sectoral and cross-border integration and the development of new instruments and products.
  - International and offshore financial centers often used to domicile new instruments/products developed to share and transfer risk across sectors and agents.
- Banking:
  - Effective supervision of complicated, cross-border banking conglomerates requires extensive two-way information exchange between supervisors in the home and host supervisors—not only host to home, but host to host, home to host, and home to home.
  - Basel II has provided new impetus for such exchange; "supervisory colleges" are discussing approaches to Basel II, but no established practices yet as regards content and modalities.
- Insurance:
  - Enhanced cooperation among supervisors required to monitor risk transfer occurring through nontraditional arrangements.
  - Cross-border and cross-sectoral cooperation required for supervising the insurance industry’s use of the capital market for insuring catastrophic risks.
  - Nontraditional insurance or reinsurance cited includes captive insurance, finite reinsurance, and securitization.
- Securities:
  - Widespread operations of hedge funds and their opacity seen as requiring enhanced disclosure facilitated by supervisory cooperation in collecting data.
- AML/CFT:
  - Challenges in implementing the increased scope of the standard.
  - The standard explicitly provides for a risk-based approach to rationalize and prioritize the use of resources.
  - Further work needed to develop accepted approaches to risk-based supervision in the AML/CFT context.

### Cross-cutting responses and priorities
- Identified means to address complex cross-border issues:
  - Information sharing
  - Risk-based supervision
  - Appropriate sequencing of standards implementation
- Work needed:
  - Improve formal and informal channels of cooperation and information sharing to ensure adequate understanding and oversight of complex cross-border financial activities.
  - Refine approaches to risk-based supervision.
  - Develop approaches to sequencing standards implementation to effectively prioritize areas of higher risk.

### Recommended actions and operational measures
- Supervisors and standard-setters should consider:
  - Disseminating good practices in information exchange.
  - Providing website guides to jurisdictions’ information-sharing arrangements.
  - Assigning priority to information exchange, including the allocation of adequate resources to the cooperation function.
- The Roundtable was viewed as a very useful forum for discussing issues of mutual interest.

### Appendix III: Information Framework — data submissions and monitoring (as of end-January 2006)
- Submissions and scope:
  - Data submitted directly by 16 jurisdictions and banking data forwarded by the BIS.
  - Initial submission allowed for partial submission; some variables and their components were not provided.
  - Four jurisdictions that made partial submissions indicated they are enhancing data collection and would provide additional variables in a second submission.
- Banking sector data highlights:
  - Reporting centers show a marked dispersion in size of banking sector: assets ranged from just above $100 million to over $1 trillion compared with banking assets of close to $10 trillion in a sample of G7 countries.
  - Most centers’ assets are cross-border assets; a few jurisdictions were unable to provide the breakdown of external assets/liabilities.
  - About two thirds submitted some off-balance sheet information.
  - 7 of the 16 jurisdictions provided limited information on derivatives.
  - 10 jurisdictions provided optional data on financial soundness indicators (FSIs).
- BIS locational statistics:
  - Indicate pronounced regional concentration in placement of cross-border assets and liabilities.
  - Banks located in European and Middle Eastern financial centers invested largely in Europe and the United Kingdom.
  - Banks located in the Western Hemisphere are primarily invested in the United States.
  - Banks located in the Asia-Pacific region invest most of their assets in Japan and the rest of Asia-Pacific region.
- Insurance sector data highlights:
  - Gross premiums range from about $10 million to $100 billion.
  - Most markets’ aggregate gross premiums are below or about $1 billion (setting aside one center that is one of the world’s largest insurance services providers).
  - Markets vary significantly in development and product offerings (e.g., various types of captives, protected cell companies).
  - Only five jurisdictions provided the optional balance sheet information for this industry.
- Collective investment schemes (CIS):
  - Establishment of CIS mainly undertaken in middle- and high-income jurisdictions.
  - These jurisdictions recorded aggregate net assets value of CIS of over $1 billion.
  - Ten of the 16 reporting jurisdictions provided data on this sector.
  - One major jurisdiction (the Cayman Islands) recently announced a proposal to collect data on hedge funds from the industry (noted as partly in response to this initiative).
- Other sectoral indicators:
  - The financial sector plays an important role in economic activity in many centers; in one instance, contribution to GDP is as high as 50 percent.
  - The number of trust and company service providers reported varies greatly across jurisdictions.
- Transparency and dissemination:
  - The framework provides a common template to help jurisdictions in their dissemination efforts.
  - Two jurisdictions reported they have increased the number of variables they disseminate following the start of this initiative.
  - Five jurisdictions indicated they plan to increase dissemination based on the framework in the near future (e.g., after the second submission of data in the pilot phase) or following requisite changes in their publication formats.

*Source: Executive Summary (content unit: _020806 - Executive Summary).*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### Executive Summary

### Overview and Context
- This paper provides an update on the actions taken under the offshore financial center (OFC) program since the last update issued in February 2005.
- Three jurisdictions were assessed in 2005 and nine assessments have been scheduled.
- To avoid duplication, assessments are being coordinated with mutual evaluations conducted by FATF and FATF-style regional bodies.
- Several jurisdictions asked to postpone assessments, so that they may continue to focus on enhancing their supervisory arrangements.
- Technical assistance has been provided mostly to small, lower-income jurisdictions in banking and insurance supervision, AML/CFT legislation and supervision, and statistics.

### Information Framework Initiative: Monitoring and Transparency
- The information framework initiative aims to:
  - improve transparency in the activities of international and offshore financial centers; and
  - provide the IMF with information for its ongoing monitoring of financial developments in these centers.
- The framework provides structural and activity indicators for banking, insurance sectors, and collective investment schemes and complements existing statistical reporting (e.g., CPIS and BIS international banking statistics).
- Forty-six jurisdictions were invited in December 2004 to participate in the pilot phase of this voluntary initiative.
- To kick off the initiative, MFD, with assistance from STA and TGS, held a workshop on May 11–12, 2005 to discuss implementation, data collection, compilation, and dissemination. The workshop was attended by 27 international and offshore financial centers.

Key statistics and status (As of end-January 2006)
- Jurisdictions that have submitted data: 16
- Jurisdictions that have committed/indicated intention to participate but not yet submitted data: 18
- Jurisdictions that have yet to confirm participation: 7
- Jurisdictions that have declined to participate: 5

Jurisdictions that have submitted data
- Bahrain*
- Bermuda*
- Cayman Islands*
- Cyprus‡
- Guernsey*
- Isle of Man*
- Jersey*
- Luxembourg* ‡
- Netherlands Antilles*
- Panama*
- Singapore* ‡
- Switzerland* ‡
- (Total: 16)

Jurisdictions that have committed/indicated intention to participate but not yet submitted data
- Andorra
- Anguilla
- Antigua & Barbuda
- Bahamas, The*
- Barbados
- Belize
- Costa Rica‡
- Dominica
- Grenada
- Lebanon‡
- Marshall Islands3/
- Malaysia (Labuan)3/
- Nauru
- Niue
- Palau
- Samoa
- Seychelles
- St. Kitts and Nevis
- St. Lucia
- St. Vincent and the Grenadines
- Turks and Caicos Islands
- Vanuatu
- (Total: 18)

Jurisdictions that have yet to confirm participation
- Aruba
- British Virgin Islands
- Cook Islands
- Gibraltar
- Liechtenstein
- Monaco
- Montserrat
- (Total: 7)

Jurisdictions that have declined to participate
- Hong Kong SAR* ‡ 1/
- Ireland* ‡ 1/
- Malta‡
- Mauritius
- Panama*2/
- (Total: 5)

Notes associated with the table
- * These jurisdictions report data to the BIS.
- ‡ These jurisdictions are participating in the IMF’s FSI Coordinated Compilation Exercise.
- 1/ These jurisdictions while declining to participate in the initiative have authorized the BIS to forward data on banks' external assets/liabilities to the Fund.
- 2/ While these jurisdictions have yet to submit data as part of the initiative, data on banks' external assets/liabilities have been received from the BIS.
- 3/ While these jurisdictions have yet to confirm participation they were represented at the May 2005 workshop which discussed how this initiative would be implemented.

Observations on the initiative
- The data collected so far provide useful comparisons of the significance of different centers and a more complete picture of the geographical distribution of the financial services industry.
- Six jurisdictions have provided banking sector external assets/liabilities data through the BIS, including 3 jurisdictions who have declined to otherwise participate.
- A few jurisdictions are making significant changes to their collection systems to improve data availability.
- Staff are following up with jurisdictions to encourage broader participation and data dissemination by jurisdictions.
- The usefulness of the initiative will be enhanced by higher participation rates—the larger the number of jurisdictions who participate, the more cross-country comparable data will be available to staff, and gaps in the global monitoring framework reduced.

### Monitoring, Assessments, and Technical Assistance
- Assessments are being invited on a 4–5 year frequency agreed by Directors, with priority to jurisdictions where there is significant activity or where important weaknesses were identified.
- Members may also choose to be assessed under the FSAP which has an average frequency of five years.
- Assessments prioritize:
  - progress in addressing substantial shortcomings identified in earlier assessments;
  - significant areas not previously assessed; and
  - evaluating important reforms.
- An increased emphasis is being given to cooperation and information exchange; standard setters and jurisdictions with significant cross-border activity are being invited to identify cooperation and information exchange issues to be followed up during assessments.
- Monitoring results continue to inform the Financial Stability Forum (FSF)’s work. At its March 2005 meeting, the FSF withdrew its 2000 listing of OFCs, noted remaining problems particularly in cross-border cooperation and information exchange, and established a Review Group on Offshore Financial Centers to monitor progress.
- Technical assistance (TA) delivery has generally targeted small, lower-income jurisdictions and focused on banking supervision and AML/CFT:
  - Seventeen jurisdictions from all regions received TA in banking supervision or closely related areas during 2005 and two in insurance supervision.
  - In the Asia-Pacific region, three jurisdictions received assistance with AML/CFT supervision and legislation from MFD and LEG.
  - Several IOFCs participated in three AML/CFT supervision, legislative and FIU workshops hosted by the Singapore Training Institute, in cooperation with MFD and LEG.
  - To address TA requirements in the Pacific region, staff, in cooperation with PFTAC, is strengthening cooperation with bilateral agencies.
  - Caribbean and Middle East jurisdictions benefited from three AML/CFT workshops held for each region by MFD and LEG, and two Caribbean countries received AML/CFT TA for legislative drafting and establishment of FIUs.
  - STA provided assistance on statistical collection for the Coordinated Portfolio Investment Survey (CPIS); eleven IOFC jurisdictions participated in a workshop in May 2005 to review 2003 results and plan for the 2004 survey.

### Collaboration, Cooperation, and Emerging Themes
- The third IMF roundtable for onshore and offshore supervisors and standard setters held in November 2005 highlighted the need for continued attention to cooperation and information sharing, risk-based supervision, and appropriate sequencing of standards implementation to address increasingly complex cross-border issues.
- Participants agreed that supervisors and standard setters should consider:
  - disseminating good practices on information sharing;
  - providing website guides to jurisdictions’ information sharing arrangements; and
  - assigning priority and resources to information exchange issues.

*Source: Executive Summary (content unit: _020806 - Executive Summary).*

### 13.      The Third Annual Roundtable for offshore and onshore supervisors and

### 13. The Third Annual Roundtable for offshore and onshore supervisors and standard setters (Sydney, November 17–18, 2005)

### Roundtable overview and participation
- Held on November 17–18, 2005, in Sydney, hosted jointly by four Australian agencies: Australian Prudential Authority (APRA), Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC), Australian Transaction Reports and Analysis Centre (AUSTRAC), and the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA).
- Attended by 27 jurisdictions, the 4 standard setting bodies (BCBS, FATF, IAIS, and IOSCO), the FSF, OGBS, the Egmont Group, and the APG.
- Advance copies of the Proceedings of the 2004 MFD-hosted conference on cross-border cooperation and information exchange (incorporating the background paper and information exchange survey results) were distributed; formal publication is expected in mid-2006.

### Major cross-border supervisory themes and sectoral findings
- General
  - The roundtable highlighted the complexity of international financial services associated with increasing cross-sectoral and cross-border integration and the development of new instruments and products.
  - International and offshore financial centers are often used to domicile new instruments/products developed to share and transfer risk across sectors and agents.
- Banking
  - Effective supervision of complicated, cross-border banking conglomerates requires extensive two-way information exchange between supervisors in the home and host supervisors—not only host to home, but host to host, home to host, and home to home.
  - Basel II has provided new impetus for such exchange; for example, "supervisory colleges" are discussing approaches to Basel II, but there are as yet no established practices as regards content and modalities.
- Insurance
  - Participants concluded that enhanced cooperation among supervisors is required to monitor risk transfer occurring through nontraditional arrangements.
  - Cross-border and cross-sectoral cooperation is required for supervising the insurance industry’s use of the capital market for insuring catastrophic risks.
  - Nontraditional insurance or reinsurance cited includes captive insurance, finite reinsurance, and securitization.
- Securities
  - The widespread operations of hedge funds and their opacity were seen as requiring enhanced disclosure that can be facilitated by supervisory cooperation in collecting data.
- AML/CFT
  - Challenges lie in implementing the increased scope of the standard.
  - The standard explicitly provides for a risk-based approach to rationalize and prioritize the use of resources.
  - Further work is needed to develop accepted approaches to risk-based supervision in the AML/CFT context.

### Cross-cutting responses and priorities
- Identified means to address complex cross-border issues:
  - Information sharing
  - Risk-based supervision
  - Appropriate sequencing of standards implementation
- Work needed:
  - Improve formal and informal channels of cooperation and information sharing to ensure adequate understanding and oversight of complex cross-border financial activities.
  - Refine approaches to risk-based supervision.
  - Develop approaches to sequencing standards implementation to effectively prioritize areas of higher risk.

### Recommended actions and operational measures
- Supervisors and standard-setters should consider:
  - Disseminating good practices in information exchange.
  - Providing website guides to jurisdictions’ information-sharing arrangements.
  - Assigning priority to information exchange, including the allocation of adequate resources to the cooperation function.
- The Roundtable was viewed as a very useful forum for discussing issues of mutual interest.

### Appendix III: Information Framework — data submissions and monitoring (as of end-January 2006)
- Submissions and scope
  - Data submitted directly by 16 jurisdictions and banking data forwarded by the BIS.
  - The initial submission allowed for partial submission; some variables and their components were not provided.
  - Four jurisdictions that made partial submissions indicated they are enhancing data collection and would provide additional variables in a second submission.
- Banking sector data highlights
  - Reporting centers show a marked dispersion in size of banking sector: assets ranged from just above $100 million to over $1 trillion compared with banking assets of close to $10 trillion in a sample of G7 countries.
  - Most centers’ assets are cross-border assets; a few jurisdictions were unable to provide the breakdown of external assets/liabilities.
  - About two thirds submitted some off-balance sheet information.
  - 7 of the 16 jurisdictions provided limited information on derivatives.
  - 10 jurisdictions provided optional data on financial soundness indicators (FSIs).
- BIS locational statistics
  - Indicate pronounced regional concentration in placement of cross-border assets and liabilities.
  - Banks located in European and Middle Eastern financial centers invested largely in Europe and the United Kingdom.
  - Banks located in the Western Hemisphere are primarily invested in the United States.
  - Banks located in the Asia-Pacific region invest most of their assets in Japan and the rest of Asia-Pacific region.
- Insurance sector data highlights
  - Gross premiums range from about $10 million to $100 billion.
  - Most markets’ aggregate gross premiums are below or about $1 billion (setting aside one center that is one of the world’s largest insurance services providers).
  - Markets vary significantly in development and product offerings (e.g., various types of captives, protected cell companies).
  - Only five jurisdictions provided the optional balance sheet information for this industry.
- Collective investment schemes (CIS)
  - Establishment of CIS mainly undertaken in middle- and high-income jurisdictions.
  - These jurisdictions recorded aggregate net assets value of CIS of over $1 billion.
  - Ten of the 16 reporting jurisdictions provided data on this sector.
  - One major jurisdiction (the Cayman Islands) recently announced a proposal to collect data on hedge funds from the industry (noted as partly in response to this initiative).
- Other sectoral indicators
  - The financial sector plays an important role in economic activity in many centers; in one instance, contribution to GDP is as high as 50 percent.
  - The number of trust and company service providers reported varies greatly across jurisdictions.
- Transparency and dissemination
  - The framework provides a common template to help jurisdictions in their dissemination efforts.
  - Two jurisdictions reported they have increased the number of variables they disseminate following the start of this initiative.
  - Five jurisdictions indicated they plan to increase dissemination based on the framework in the near future (e.g., after the second submission of data in the pilot phase) or following requisite changes in their publication formats.

*Source: _020806 - 13. The Third Annual Roundtable for offshore and onshore supervisors and standard setters (Provisions as of end-January 2006).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2006/_020806.pdf_
