## _041106 - Executive Summary

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_041106 - Executive Summary](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2006/_041106.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2006/_041106.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2006/_041106.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary findings
- Staffs of IDA and the IMF identified 11 countries that meet the enhanced HIPC Initiative’s income and indebtedness eligibility criteria at end-2004 and might wish to be considered for debt relief under the Initiative:
  - Central African Republic; Comoros; Côte d’Ivoire; Eritrea; Haiti; Kyrgyz Republic; Liberia; Nepal; Somalia; Sudan; Togo.
- Three countries technically meeting the end-2004 income and indebtedness criteria indicated they do not wish to avail themselves of the Initiative:
  - Bhutan; Lao PDR; Sri Lanka (as of April 7, 2006).
- Progress on PRS and programs:
  - Most of the 11 countries have progressed with their poverty reduction strategies; three are making significant progress in implementation of macroeconomic programs and structural reforms; three are experiencing difficulties; five have not had an IMF- and IDA-supported program since October 1996.
  - All but two (Liberia and Somalia) have begun the PRS process.
- Staff recommendation on list management:
  - Staffs propose that the Boards endorse and close the list of countries meeting the assessed income and indebtedness eligibility criteria at this time, with the Boards able to amend the list on a case-by-case basis to include countries whose data are verified to meet the relevant thresholds at end-2004.
- Sunset clause issue:
  - The expiration of the sunset clause on December 31, 2006 could imply that some countries on the list may not be able to benefit from debt relief under the Initiative if they do not meet the policy eligibility criterion by that date. Staffs will examine the issue and propose options in the coming months.

### Cost estimates and financing implications
- Total estimated cost of HIPC Initiative debt relief for the 11 countries: US$21 billion in 2004 NPV terms.
  - World Bank’s share: about US$2.9 billion.
  - IMF’s share: about US$2.1 billion.
  - About 25 percent (US$5 billion) of the total cost corresponds to the six countries that have met all HIPC Initiative eligibility requirements (Central African Republic, Côte d’Ivoire, Haiti, the Kyrgyz Republic, Nepal, and Togo).
  - The three protracted arrears cases (Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan) account for more than 70 percent of the total cost.
  - Estimated costs for official bilateral and multilateral creditors are roughly equal.
- Additional financing and operational notes:
  - These estimates are based on end-2004 debt data; actual cost will be determined at countries’ decision points using then-available data.
  - IDA-delivered World Bank debt relief (IDA) would require additional donor resources and is expected to be financed in future IDA replenishments.
  - For the IMF, no provision has been made for financing Somalia, Liberia, Sudan, Eritrea, Haiti, the Kyrgyz Republic and Nepal in the PRGF-HIPC Trust resources mobilized in 1999; new bilateral grant resources will need to be mobilized for IMF HIPC assistance.
  - Commercial creditor participation share (US$2.5 billion) is significantly higher than observed in HIPCs that have already reached decision points.

### Policy performance and qualification status
- Countries assessed to have met the Policy Performance Criterion:
  - Central African Republic; Nepal; Haiti; Togo; Cote d'Ivoire; Kyrgyz Republic.
- Countries assessed not to have met the Policy Performance Criterion:
  - Liberia; Somalia; Sudan; Eritrea; Comoros.
- Notes on PRSP and program status:
  - Nepal has completed its full PRSP.
  - Côte d’Ivoire has completed its I-PRSP.
  - Togo has recently prepared its I-PRSP.
  - Comoros has prepared its I-PRSP; Eritrea and Sudan are in the process of preparing I-PRSPs; Liberia and Somalia have not started the PRSP process.
  - Comoros, Eritrea, Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan have not had an IMF- and IDA- supported program since 1996. Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan are protracted arrears cases.

### Staff proposals and procedural points
- Staffs propose Boards:
  - Endorse and close the list of countries meeting the income and indebtedness criteria at end-2004, allowing case-by-case amendment if data verification warrants.
  - Allow staffs to continue consultations with authorities to ascertain intentions to avail themselves of the Initiative and report results to the Boards.
  - In coming months, examine implications of the sunset clause expiration on December 31, 2006 and propose options for countries that may not meet the policy eligibility criterion by that date.
- Participation principle:
  - Meeting end-2004 income and indebtedness criteria does not guarantee qualification; countries must satisfy additional conditions and qualify only at their request. Staffs will not proceed with HIPC-specific preparations if a country has informed staffs it does not wish to participate.

### Methodology and data handling (summary)
- Three-stage approach to prepare the list:
  - Stage 1: Short-list based on end-2003 debt burden indicators (thresholds for short-list: above 120 percent NPV debt-to-exports and 200 percent NPV debt-to-revenue).
  - Stage 2: Preliminary list using end-2004 external debt and macroeconomic data.
  - Stage 3: Final list after resolving data deficiencies via loan-by-loan data collection and reconciliation.
- Data collection and reconciliation:
  - Loan-by-loan debt data obtained and analyzed for Bangladesh, Bhutan, Eritrea, Haiti, Kyrgyz Republic, Nepal, Sri Lanka, and Tonga.
  - Technical missions undertaken to facilitate data collection and reconciliation.
  - Myanmar authorities indicated they would not provide required data and did not want HIPC debt relief at this time.
  - Cape Verde classification confirmed as below HIPC NPV of debt-to-export threshold based on revised loan-by-loan data.
  - Afghanistan could not be conclusively classified because much of its potential external obligations remain unverified or in dispute; verified end-2004 debt indicators are below HIPC thresholds; staffs propose reassessment once disputes are resolved.
- Key technical rules preserved (selected):
  - HIPC thresholds: 150 percent for NPV of debt-to-exports and 250 percent for NPV of debt-to-fiscal revenue.
  - Exports denominator: three-year backward-looking average exports of goods and non-factor services.
  - Revenue: current central government revenue excluding grants.
  - Traditional debt relief: Paris Club Naples terms (67 percent NPV reduction on non-ODA debt) and at least comparable terms on other official bilateral and commercial debt.
  - Cut-off date: a June 1999 cut-off date applied to countries without a Paris Club rescheduling.

### Data revisions and illustrative country impacts
- Overall result of data improvements:
  - Loan-by-loan data and creditor reconciliation materially affected some countries’ NPV ratios and hence eligibility classification.
- Selected country revision highlights (Sep-05 versus Apr-06 where presented; changes preserved exactly as in source):
  - Liberia: NPV/X Ratio Sep-05 = 1,433; Apr-06 = 1,433; Data Revisions = 0.
  - Somalia: NPV/X Ratio Sep-05 = 1,091; Apr-06 = 1,091; Data Revisions = 0.
  - Central African Republic: Sep-05 = 546; Apr-06 = 562; Data Revisions = 16.
  - Sudan: Sep-05 = 561; Apr-06 = 561; Data Revisions = 0.
  - Eritrea (Export Window): Sep-05 = 362; Apr-06 = 522; Data Revisions = 160.
  - Comoros: Sep-05 = 378; Apr-06 = 378; Data Revisions = 0.
  - Nepal (Export Window): Sep-05 = 1/20; Apr-06 = 1198; Data Revisions = -3.
  - Haiti: Sep-05 = 190; Apr-06 = 189; Data Revisions = -1.
  - Lao, PDR: Sep-05 = 197; Apr-06 = 221; Data Revisions = 24.
  - Bhutan (Export Window): Sep-05 = 1/  2/148; Apr-06 = 299; Data Revisions = 151.
  - Togo (Fiscal Revenue Window): Sep-05 = 1/39; Apr-06 = 409; Data Revisions = 14.
  - Kyrgyz Republic (Fiscal Revenue Window): Sep-05 = 1/345; Apr-06 = 376; Data Revisions = 31.
  - Sri Lanka (Fiscal Revenue Window): Sep-05 = 1/238; Apr-06 = 258; Data Revisions = 20.
  - Bangladesh: Sep-05 = 1/  2/158; Apr-06 = 146; Data Revisions = -12.
  - Tonga: Sep-05 = 2/126; Apr-06 = 132; Data Revisions = 5.
  - Afghanistan: Sep-05 = 3/83; Apr-06 = 67; Data Revisions = -16 (assessment inconclusive due to unverified/disputed obligations).
- Reconciliation quality:
  - Reconciliation levels ranged from 90 percent (Eritrea, Kyrgyz Republic) to close to 100 percent (Bhutan, Nepal, Tonga).
  - Staffs consider these reconciliation levels sufficient for final assessment of potential eligibility.
  - For the IMF, a minimum 70 percent reconciliation of total debt is required for decision point documents.

### Annex I — Country status summaries (status as of end-February 2006) (selected highlights)
- Central African Republic:
  - Transition completed with May 2005 elections; tensions remain due to economic difficulties and wage arrears; PRGF off track in 2001; first EPCA approved July 2004; second EPCA on January 27, 2006; authorities aim for HIPC decision point in 2007; final PRSP completion expected in 2006.
- Cote d'Ivoire:
  - Some progress toward peace in 2005 but security fragile; no IMF program in place; PRGF inoperative since 2002 and expired March 2005; I-PRSP endorsed March 2002; large external arrears.
- Haiti:
  - Presidential and parliamentary elections scheduled February-March 2006; second EPCA purchase approved October 2005; authorities completed a first draft of an I-PRSP.
- Kyrgyz Republic:
  - New PRGF arrangement approved March 2005; full PRSP completed and endorsed February 2003; in process of completing second annual report on its PRSP.
- Nepal:
  - PRGF arrangement approved November 2003; full PRSP completed and endorsed November 2003; second and third PRGF reviews overdue.
- Togo:
  - New president took office April 2005; I-PRSP approved by Council of Ministers November 2004 but not submitted to Boards; possible decision point by late 2007 assuming satisfactory Fund-supported program performance.
- Comoros:
  - National reconciliation improved; donors pledged some $200 million at December 2005 roundtable; I-PRSP transmitted to Fund and Bank.
- Eritrea:
  - State of mobilization over border dispute with Ethiopia; draft I-PRSP June 2003 not finalized; Government indicated intention to invite IMF/WB back for more detailed discussions in April/May 2006.
- Liberia:
  - New President inaugurated January 16, 2006; nearly all debt in arrears; monthly token payments to IMF resumed early 2004; new government interested in SMP; has not begun PRSP process.
- Somalia:
  - Transitional institutions in place but recognition and security issues persist; substantial arrears; no PRSP process.
- Sudan:
  - Interim National Constitution passed July 2005; large external debt mostly in arrears; financing assurances needed to clear about US$1.5 billion of arrears to the Fund; I-PRSP being prepared.

*Source: Executive Summary, “_041106 - Executive Summary,” IMF/IDA staffs (end-2004 assessment; as presented in the supplied content).*

### Executive Summary.......................................................................................................

### _041106 - Executive Summary

### Executive summary findings
- Staffs of IDA and the IMF have identified 11 countries that meet the enhanced HIPC Initiative’s income and indebtedness eligibility criteria at end-2004 and might wish to be considered for debt relief under the Initiative. These include seven countries previously identified as HIPCs (Central African Republic, Comoros, Côte d’Ivoire, Liberia, Somalia, Sudan, and Togo) and four other countries (Eritrea, Haiti, the Kyrgyz Republic, and Nepal).
- As of April 7, 2006, three countries that technically meet the income and indebtedness criteria at end-2004 have indicated that they do not wish to avail themselves of the Initiative: Bhutan, Lao PDR, and Sri Lanka.
- Most of the 11 identified countries have progressed with their poverty reduction strategies; three are making significant progress in implementation of macroeconomic programs and structural reforms, three are experiencing difficulties, and five have not had an IMF- and IDA-supported program since October 1996. All but two (Liberia and Somalia) have begun the PRS process.
- Estimated cost of HIPC Initiative debt relief for these 11 countries: US$21 billion in 2004 NPV terms.
  - World Bank’s share: about US$2.9 billion.
  - IMF’s share: about US$2.1 billion.
  - About 25 percent (US$5 billion) of the total cost corresponds to the six countries that have met all HIPC Initiative eligibility requirements (Central African Republic, Côte d’Ivoire, Haiti, the Kyrgyz Republic, Nepal, and Togo).
  - The three protracted arrears cases (Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan) account for more than 70 percent of the total cost.
  - Estimated costs for official bilateral and multilateral creditors are roughly equal.
- Staffs propose that the Boards endorse and close the list of countries meeting the assessed income and indebtedness eligibility criteria at this time, with the Boards able to amend the list on a case-by-case basis to include countries whose data are verified to meet the relevant thresholds at end-2004.
- The expiration of the sunset clause on December 31, 2006 could imply that some countries on the list may not be able to benefit from debt relief under the Initiative, since they would not have met the policy eligibility criterion. Staffs will examine the issue and propose options in the coming months.

### Countries identified as satisfying the income and indebtedness criteria at end-2004 (staff assessment)
- Listed countries (as stated in the document): Central African Republic; Comoros; Côte d’Ivoire; Eritrea; Haiti; Kyrgyz Republic; Liberia; Nepal; Somalia; Sudan; Togo.
- Three countries that technically meet the criteria but indicated they do not wish to avail themselves of the Initiative: Bhutan; Lao PDR; Sri Lanka.

- Table 1 (as presented in source — numerical strings preserved exactly as they appear):
  - Liberia 1,4333,3881233
  - Somalia  7/ 1,091 n.an.an.a
  - Central African Republic 562810913
  - Sudan 5613681716
  - Eritrea 5221913111
  - Comoros 3783501617
  - Nepal  1982611218
  - Haiti  189272914
  - Togo  2014091538
  - Kyrgyz Republic   1843761537
  - Cote d'Ivoire1513611748
  - (as of end-April 7, 2006)
  - 3/ Bhutan, Lao PDR and Sri Lanka have been assessed to have met the end-2004 income and indebtedness criteria, but they have indicated to IMF and IDA staffs that they would not avail themselves of the Initiative.
  - Notes preserved from source:
    - 4/ Exports refer to the last three-year average of exports of goods and non-factor services.
    - 7/ Data on central government revenue and GDP were unavailable.
    - 6/ Both the numerator and the denominator are calculated as averages of the last 3 years.
    - 5/ Revenue refers to the current year revenue of the central government, excluding grants. A country qualifies under the revenue window if its exports-to-GDP and revenue-to-GDP ratios are above 30 percent and 15 percent, respectively.
    - Data sources: Country authorities, multilateral creditors, Paris Club Secretariat, Global Development Finance and staff estimates.
    - 1/ All countries considered are IDA-only and PRGF-eligible and have not benefited from assistance under the HIPC Initiative. If a country qualifies under both the exports and revenue windows, the criterion that maximizes the amount of debt relief to be provided is retained.
    - 2/ Results reflect the information available to staffs but could change on the basis of additional or updated information.

### Assessment details and data handling
- Staffs refined calculations of debt indicators using end-December 2004 loan-by-loan and aggregate debt data and macroeconomic data for 2002–2004; emphasis was on countries with insufficient data in September 2005 or whose debt ratios were close to HIPC thresholds.
- Loan-by-loan debt data were obtained and analyzed for Bangladesh, Bhutan, Eritrea, Haiti, the Kyrgyz Republic, Nepal, Sri Lanka, and Tonga. Revised debt data were obtained and analyzed for most remaining countries in the preliminary list.
- Cape Verde classification was confirmed as below the HIPC NPV of debt-to-export threshold based on revised loan-by-loan data.
- Afghanistan could not be conclusively classified because much of its potential external obligations remain unverified or in dispute; verified end-2004 debt indicators are below HIPC thresholds. Staffs propose to reassess Afghanistan once disputes are resolved.
- Tonga and Bangladesh: loan-by-loan data showed NPV of debt-to-export ratios at end-2004 of 132 percent for Tonga and 146 percent for Bangladesh; staffs propose these countries not be included in the list.
- Myanmar could not be assessed due to lack of data; authorities indicated they will not participate and would not provide required data.

### Status of IMF- and IDA-supported programs and PRSs
- Six of the 11 identified countries have met the policy criterion for eligibility under the enhanced HIPC Initiative: Central African Republic; Côte d’Ivoire; Haiti; the Kyrgyz Republic; Nepal; and Togo. These countries meet all eligibility criteria and could qualify for debt relief at decision point if they establish a track record of performance and have a satisfactory PRS in place.
- Of the 11 countries: three are making significant progress on macroeconomic programs and structural reforms; three are experiencing difficulties; five have not had an IMF- and IDA-supported program since October 1996.
- All but two (Liberia and Somalia) have begun the poverty reduction strategy process.

### Cost estimates and financing implications
- Total estimated cost of HIPC Initiative debt relief for the 11 countries: US$21 billion (2004 NPV terms).
  - World Bank share: about US$2.9 billion.
  - IMF share: about US$2.1 billion.
  - Approximately 25 percent (US$5 billion) of the total cost corresponds to the six countries that have met all HIPC Initiative eligibility requirements (Central African Republic, Côte d’Ivoire, Haiti, the Kyrgyz Republic, Nepal, and Togo).
  - The three protracted arrears cases (Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan) account for more than 70 percent of the total cost.
  - Estimated costs for official bilateral and multilateral creditors are roughly equal.
- These estimates would be affected if other countries choose not to avail themselves of the Initiative or if the Boards decide to include new countries later. Additional donor resources would be required for the IMF and IDA to finance the costs of providing debt relief.

### Staff proposals and procedural points
- Staffs propose that the Boards endorse and close the list of countries meeting the assessed income and indebtedness eligibility criteria at this time, while allowing the Boards to amend the list on a case-by-case basis if data verification warrants.
- Staffs will continue consultations with authorities of assessed countries to ascertain their intentions to avail themselves of the Initiative and will report results to the Boards.
- Staffs will examine implications of the sunset clause expiration on December 31, 2006 and propose options to address countries that may not meet the policy eligibility criterion by that date.

### HIPC Initiative eligibility and qualification criteria (Box 1 preserved text)
- Assessment of potential eligibility: A country is considered potentially eligible for debt relief under the HIPC Initiative if the following conditions are satisfied: (a) it is IDA-only and PRGF-eligible (see footnote 3) and (b) its end-December 2004 debt burden indicators are above the thresholds established under the HIPC Initiative after full application of traditional debt relief mechanisms. The thresholds are 150 percent for the ratio of the net present value of debt (NPV) to exports of goods and services and 250 percent for the ratio of NPV to fiscal revenue. To qualify under the second criterion a country must have ratios of exports of goods and services to GDP and fiscal revenue to GDP above 30 percent and 15 percent, respectively.
- Determination of eligibility: To become eligible for debt relief under the HIPC Initiative, a country not only has to satisfy the two criteria above, but must also have begun a reform program supported by the IMF and IDA between October 1, 1996 and December 31, 2006, when the sunset clause of the Initiative expires. Countries satisfying the three eligibility criteria could qualify for debt relief under the HIPC Initiative even after the sunset clause expires.
- Qualification for debt relief (decision point): At the decision point, the Executive Boards of IDA and the IMF determine whether an eligible country qualifies for debt relief under the HIPC Initiative. To qualify for debt relief under the HIPC Initiative an eligible country must have (a) debt burden indicators above the HIPC Initiative thresholds using the most recent data for the year immediately prior to the decision point; (b) established a satisfactory track record of policy performance under respective IMF- and IDA-supported programs; (c) in place a poverty reduction strategy. A satisfactory poverty reduction strategy paper (PRSP) could be in the form of an Interim-PRSP, PRSP preparation status report, full-PRSP, or PRSP-Annual Progress Report (APR).
- At the completion point, the Executive Boards of IDA and the IMF determine whether or not a country has met the requirements established at the decision point. If so, all creditors are expected to start providing debt relief on an irrevocable basis. Moreover, upon reaching the completion point, countries become eligible for 100 percent debt relief on their eligible obligations toward the AfDB, IDA, and the IMF under the MDRI.

*Source: Executive Summary, “_041106 - Executive Summary,” IMF/IDA staffs (end-2004 assessment; as presented in the supplied content).*

### 14.      The Central African Republic, Haiti, and the Kyrgyz Republic are making

### _041106 - 14.      The Central African Republic, Haiti, and the Kyrgyz Republic are making

### Progress toward meeting HIPC Initiative qualification criteria
- The Central African Republic, Haiti, and the Kyrgyz Republic are making progress toward meeting the qualification criteria for HIPC Initiative debt relief (Annex I).
- Kyrgyz Republic:
  - Advancing implementation of its program supported under the PRGF arrangement.
  - In the process of completing the second annual report on its PRSP.
- Central African Republic and Haiti:
  - Implementing satisfactorily their EPCA-supported programs.
  - Preparing their PRSP (Central African Republic) and I-PRSP (Haiti), respectively.

### Countries and policy performance eligibility
- Countries that meet the Policy Performance Criterion:
  - Central African Republic
  - Nepal
  - Haiti
  - Togo
  - Cote d'Ivoire
  - Kyrgyz Republic
- Countries that do not meet the Policy Performance Criterion:
  - Liberia
  - Somalia
  - Sudan
  - Eritrea
  - Comoros
- Notes:
  - Nepal has had protracted interruptions in program implementation.
  - Côte d’Ivoire and Togo face continuing domestic conflict or unsettled transitions from conflict that have hampered policy implementation and institution building.
  - On PRSPs: Nepal has completed its full PRSP; Côte d’Ivoire has completed its I-PRSP; Togo has recently prepared its I-PRSP.
  - Comoros, Eritrea, Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan have not had an IMF- and IDA- supported program since 1996. Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan are protracted arrears cases.
  - Comoros has prepared its I-PRSP; Eritrea and Sudan are in the process of preparing I-PRSPs; Liberia and Somalia have not started the PRSP process.

### Estimated cost of HIPC Initiative debt relief (major figures)
- Total estimated cost for the 11 identified countries: US$21 billion in 2004 NPV terms.
  - This amount is about US$1.5 billion lower than the estimate in the September 2005 report (Republic of Congo excluded: US$1.5 billion).
- The three protracted arrears cases (Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan) represent US$15 billion, or more than 70 percent of the total.
- Breakdown highlights:
  - Official bilateral and multilateral creditor costs are roughly equal.
  - World Bank’s share among multilateral creditors: about US$2.9 billion.
    - Of this, US$0.5 billion represent costs related to Eritrea, Haiti, the Kyrgyz Republic, and Nepal.
  - IMF’s share: approximately US$2.4 billion.
    - About 91 percent of the IMF share corresponds to the three protracted arrears cases.
  - AfDB Group cost: around US$1.0 billion.
  - Paris Club creditors account for two thirds of the US$10.2 billion attributable to official bilateral assistance.
  - Commercial creditors account for about 12 percent (US$2.5 billion) of the total cost.
- Operational and financing notes:
  - Total cost based on end-2004 debt data; actual cost determined at countries’ decision points using then-available data.
  - Costs related to IDA-delivered World Bank debt relief (IDA) would require additional donor resources and are expected to be financed in future IDA replenishments.
  - For the IMF, no provision has been made for financing Somalia, Liberia, Sudan, Eritrea, Haiti, the Kyrgyz Republic and Nepal in the PRGF-HIPC Trust resources mobilized in 1999; new bilateral grant resources will need to be mobilized for IMF HIPC assistance.
  - Commercial creditor participation share (US$2.5 billion) is significantly higher than observed in HIPCs that have already reached decision points.

### Implications of closing the list and sunset clause issues
- September 2004 decision to “ring-fence” the list of countries that meet income and indebtedness criteria at end-2004 to prevent the Initiative being seen as permanent and to improve cost estimations for the HIPC Initiative and MDRI.
- Staffs propose closing the list of countries that meet the income and indebtedness criteria at end-2004; Boards could explicitly endorse and close the list.
  - Countries not assessed as satisfying thresholds (based on final data or unavailable data) would not be treated as potentially eligible.
  - Boards could, on a case-by-case basis, amend the closed list if data verification warrants inclusion (example: possible inclusion of Afghanistan upon debt reconciliation).
- Meeting end-2004 income and indebtedness criteria does not guarantee qualification for HIPC debt relief; countries must satisfy additional conditions and qualify only at their request.
  - Countries can decide whether to avail themselves of the Initiative; staffs will not proceed with HIPC-specific preparations if a country has informed staffs it does not wish to participate.
  - Bhutan, Lao PDR, and Sri Lanka have already informed staffs they do not want to participate.
- Sunset clause:
  - The Initiative’s sunset clause expires end-2006. Five identified countries have not begun an IMF and IDA-supported program since October 1996 and have only until December 2006 to do so to remain eligible.
  - Most of these countries are likely to experience problems meeting the deadline.
  - Staffs will monitor developments and return to the Boards to discuss options related to the sunset clause expiration.

### Annex I — Country status summaries (status as of end-February 2006)
- Central African Republic:
  - Political: Transition completed with May 2005 elections; tensions remain due to economic difficulties and wage arrears; civil service strike in Q4 2005.
  - Programs: PRGF arrangement approved July 1998 went off track in 2001. First EPCA approved July 2004; second EPCA on January 27, 2006. Authorities aim for HIPC decision point in 2007. Preparation of final PRSP resumed; completion expected in 2006. Efforts to clear external arrears to multilateral creditors hopefully by end 2006.
- Cote d'Ivoire:
  - Political: Some progress toward peace in 2005 but security fragile; presidential elections delayed; new transition government formed December 2005; presidential elections expected by October 2006.
  - Programs: No IMF program in place. March 2002 PRGF became inoperative in 2002 and expired March 2005. Possible reengagement via EPCA leading to PRGF and potential HIPC decision point in 2007. I-PRSP endorsed March 2002; conflict delayed full PRSP. Large external arrears.
- Haiti:
  - Political: Presidential and parliamentary elections scheduled February-March 2006.
  - Programs: PRGF-supported program approved October 1996 but review never completed. October 2005 IMF Board approved second EPCA purchase after broadly satisfactory first EPCA (approved January 2005). Once elected government takes office, a PRGF request is expected. Authorities completed a first draft of an I-PRSP.
- Kyrgyz Republic:
  - Political: New government after regime change March 2005; political situation tense; possible move toward parliamentary system to be put to referendum late 2006.
  - Programs: New PRGF arrangement approved March 2005; first review completed October 2005. Agreement ad referendum on 2006 economic program expected to be considered by the Board in May 2006 for the second review. Full PRSP completed and endorsed February 2003; first annual progress report endorsed June 2004; draft second APR completed.
- Nepal:
  - Political: King Gyanendra took over executive powers in February 2005; political situation difficult.
  - Programs: PRGF arrangement approved November 2003; first review completed October 2004. Full PRSP completed and endorsed November 2003. Second and third PRGF reviews are overdue.
- Togo:
  - Political: New president took office April 2005 after turmoil; new government formed late June 2005.
  - Programs: 1994 PRGF went off track in 1998; no IMF arrangement since. Authorities eager for SMP to build track record toward possible PRGF. I-PRSP approved by Council of Ministers November 2004 but not submitted to Boards. Possible decision point by late 2007 assuming satisfactory Fund-supported program performance.
- Comoros:
  - Political: Improved situation with national reconciliation; agreement on division of competences and revenue sharing; donors pledged some $200 million at December 2005 roundtable; presidential elections scheduled April 2006.
  - Programs: No Fund arrangement since 1991. Performance under 2005 SMP mixed; more time needed to build track record before PRGF. I-PRSP transmitted to Fund and Bank; expected to be issued to Boards alongside a JSAN in April 2006.
- Eritrea:
  - Political: State of mobilization over border dispute with Ethiopia; US initiated new facilitation in January 2006; prospects uncertain; "no war/no peace" impasse likely to continue.
  - Programs: Never had an IMF arrangement; no development policy lending from IDA. Draft I-PRSP June 2003 not finalized. 2005 Article IV discussions focused on preparedness to qualify for Enhanced HIPC; Government indicated intention to invite IMF/WB back for more detailed discussions in April/May 2006.
- Liberia:
  - Political: Long-term international assistance program agreed September 2005 to improve governance. New President inaugurated January 16, 2006.
  - Programs: Nearly all debt in arrears. Monthly token payments to IMF resumed early 2004. New government interested in SMP to build track record and de-escalate remedial measures. Negotiations on a 6-month SMP can commence in February 2006 once short-term key actions progress. Liberia could reach decision point by mid-2007 once SMP completed and financing assurances for arrears clearance and debt relief are available. Liberia has not begun PRSP process.
- Somalia:
  - Political: Transitional Parliament inaugurated August 2004; Transitional Government cabinet appointed January 2005. Relocation issues and factions remain; Aden Declaration signed; reconciliation incomplete. Security turbulent in south-central Somalia; Puntland and Somaliland relatively stable.
  - Programs: No Fund-supported arrangement since 1987. Substantial arrears; ineligible for general resources of the Fund since 1988. TFG has made initial contacts with the Fund but lacks sufficient international recognition to exercise membership rights. No PRSP process. World Bank engaged under LICUS with UNDP on reconstruction needs assessment.
- Sudan:
  - Political: Interim National Constitution passed July 2005; Government of National Unity and Government of Southern Sudan established fall 2005. Darfur situation critical; progress slow. First Sudan Consortium scheduled March 9-10, 2006.
  - Programs: Large external debt, most in arrears. Restoring external viability would require wide international support and exceptional debt relief including HIPC. Performance under 2004 SMP was satisfactory; new SMP presented to Board in April 2005. I-PRSP being prepared. Rights Accumulation Program could be in place once appropriate financing assurances are in place. Financing assurances needed to clear about US$1.5 billion of arrears to the Fund.

*Source: IDA and IMF Country Documents; IMF staff report content as provided in the source PDF.*

### ANNEX II.  METHODOLOGY AND DATA ISSUES

### ANNEX II.  METHODOLOGY AND DATA ISSUES

### I. Introduction
- Purpose: outline steps to prepare the list of countries meeting the HIPC Initiative income and indebtedness criteria at end-2004.
- Sections: II describes the approach to identify countries; III discusses data sources, estimation methods, and data quality.

### II. Methodology
- Three-stage approach followed by staffs:
  - Stage 1: Defining a short-list of countries based on end-2003 debt burden indicators.
    - Short-list criteria: IDA-only/PRGF-eligible countries as of end-December 2004 (excluding countries that reached the decision point under HIPC) were short-listed when their estimated end-2003 debt ratios before traditional debt relief were above 120 percent for the NPV of debt-to-exports ratio and 200 percent for the NPV of debt-to-revenue ratio.
    - Resulting classification summarized in Annex Table 1: Countries considered at "Stage 1" = (23).
      - 1.1 Countries previously identified as HIPCs = (10)
      - 1.2 New countries = (13)
    - Countries excluded from the short-list = (16).
  - Stage 2: Establishing a preliminary list of countries based on end-2004 debt ratios.
    - Preliminary list compiled using end-2004 external debt and macroeconomic data from authorities, supplemented by creditors, the Paris Club Secretariat, and Global Development Finance.
    - Annex Table 1: Countries considered at "Stage 2" = (13).
      - 1.1 Countries previously identified as HIPCs = (9)
      - 1.2 Other countries = (4)
    - Countries excluded from the preliminary list = (5).
  - Stage 3: Defining the list and solving data deficiencies.
    - Priority data collection for countries not classified at Stage 2: Bangladesh, Bhutan, Myanmar, Sri Lanka, Tonga.
    - Confirmation of classification for newly identified countries: Eritrea, Haiti, Kyrgyz Republic, Nepal.
    - Staffs resolved Stage 2 data deficiencies for the remainder of the preliminary list.
    - Annex Table 1: Countries meeting the income and indebtedness criteria = (14).
      - 1.1 Countries previously identified as HIPCs = (8)
      - 1.2 Other countries = (6)

- Additional procedural notes:
  - Staffs requested loan-by-loan external debt data as at end-December 2004 and data on exports of goods and non-factor services, central government revenues and GDP for calendar years 2002-04.
  - Technical missions organized to facilitate data collection and reconciliation (Bangladesh, Bhutan, Eritrea, Nepal, Sri Lanka). Country authorities provided loan-by-loan data and supporting creditor documentation in all cases except Myanmar.
  - Myanmar authorities indicated in an official letter they were not able to provide required data and did not want HIPC debt relief at this time.

### III. Data Sources, Method of Estimation and Data Quality
- Identified data quality concerns (from methodological annex of the September 2005 Status of Implementation Report):
  - bilateral debt data insufficiently disaggregated in currency composition, hindering NPV estimation;
  - macroeconomic and bilateral debt data from some countries not on a calendar basis, conflicting with the extension of the sunset clause requirement;
  - macroeconomic data provided were preliminary and subject to revision;
  - coverage of external debt data incomplete for some countries.
- Staff actions to improve data quality:
  - Collected loan-by-loan debt data enabling application of cut-off dates for countries without a Paris Club rescheduling (improving simulation of traditional debt relief).
  - Revisions to debt indicators resulted for some countries; robustness of NPV estimates of multilateral debt confirmed (discrepancy with reconciled multilateral debt data was less than one tenth of a percent).
  - Additional or updated information could lead to further changes in estimates.

### Annex Box 1 — Technical definitions and calculation rules (selected)
- Debt: limited to medium and long-term public and publicly guaranteed external debt with exceptions: short-term debt in arrears > one year; private sector debt previously covered by Paris Club agreements; debt of public enterprises (≥ 50 percent government owned) regardless of formal guarantee; debt of public enterprises being privatized if liability remains with government. Only disbursed and outstanding debt is considered; future disbursements excluded.
- Debt Service: projected on a loan-by-loan basis reflecting disbursed and outstanding portions; when repaid on a commitment basis, projected using contractual repayment profile pro-rated by disbursed amount.
- Net Present Value (NPV): discounted value of projected debt service payments. Currency-specific discount rates = average OECD Commercial Interest Reference Rates (CIRRs) calculated over the six-month period leading up to the cutoff date for the debt stock. For units of account, discount rate = weighted average of CIRRs for currencies in the basket; SDR discount rate used if CIRR unavailable (except if pegged to a currency with a CIRR).
- Traditional Debt Relief: Paris Club stock-of-debt operation on Naples terms (67 percent NPV reduction on non-ODA debt) and action on at least comparable terms on other official bilateral and commercial debt.
- Cut-off date: date established at first Paris Club rescheduling before which loans must have been contracted to be eligible for rescheduling. A June 1999 cut-off date applied to countries without a Paris Club rescheduling.
- Official Development Assistance (ODA): defined by OECD as credits aimed at promoting economic development/welfare and concessional with grant element ≥ 25 percent (fixed discount rate 10 percent).
- Exports denominator: three-year backward-looking average exports of goods and non-factor services (IMF BPM5, 1993). Gross exports; excludes worker’s remittances and transit trade.
- Revenue: current central government revenue excluding grants.
- Exchange rates: NPV of debt converted into U.S. dollars using exchange rates prevailing at end of base year for debt stock. Exports converted to U.S. dollars using average exchange rate for the year. Three-year export average derived after annual exports conversion. Revenue converted to U.S. dollars using average exchange rate for the year.

### IV. Data Revisions and Country-Specific Impacts (selected entries)
- General: availability of loan-by-loan data allowed more accurate application of cut-off dates and adjustments; in some cases, data revisions materially changed NPV/X or NPV/R ratios.
- Selected country revision highlights (comparisons labeled Sep-05 and Apr-06 where provided):
  - Liberia: NPV/X Ratio Sep-05 = 1,433; Apr-06 = 1,433; Data Revisions = 0.
  - Somalia: NPV/X Ratio Sep-05 = 1,091; Apr-06 = 1,091; Data Revisions = 0.
  - Central African Republic: NPV/X Ratio Sep-05 = 546; Apr-06 = 562; Data Revisions = 16. Currency-specific loan-by-loan bilateral debt data obtained; resulted in an 8 percent increase in NPV of bilateral debt after traditional debt relief.
  - Sudan: NPV/X Ratio Sep-05 = 561; Apr-06 = 561; Data Revisions = 0.
  - Eritrea (Export Window): Sep-05 = 362; Apr-06 = 522; Data Revisions = 160. Exports of goods and services revised downwards correcting overestimation of travel receipts; 3-year average of exports declined by 40 percent and increased debt ratio by 146 percentage points. Improvements in bilateral debt data and June-1999 cutoff date added 2 percentage points.
  - Comoros: NPV/X Ratio Sep-05 = 378; Apr-06 = 378; Data Revisions = 0.
  - Nepal (Export Window): Sep-05 = 1/20; Apr-06 = 1198; Data Revisions = -3. Currency-specific loan-by-loan bilateral debt data at end-December 2004 included debt relief ($202 million in nominal terms) provided by Japan and application of June-1999 cutoff date; NPV of bilateral debt after traditional debt relief declined by 13 percent.
  - Haiti: NPV/X Ratio Sep-05 = 190; Apr-06 = 189; Data Revisions = -1. Currency-specific loan-by-loan bilateral debt data obtained allowed more robust estimation.
  - Lao, PDR: NPV/X Ratio Sep-05 = 197; Apr-06 = 221; Data Revisions = 24. ADB-provided currency-specific data allowed precise NPV estimation for Yen-denominated debt; earlier estimates underestimated Yen share. Revision increased ratio by 19 percentage points. Exports revised upwards: 3-year average exports increased by 7.5 percent reducing debt ratio by 13.8 percentage points. A 32 percent upward revision to outstanding bilateral and commercial debt at end-December 2004 added 11.4 percentage points.
  - Bhutan (Export Window): Sep-05 = 1/  2/148; Apr-06 = 299; Data Revisions = 151. Exports revised upwards: 3-year average exports increased by 6.5 percent reducing debt ratio by 9 percentage points. A 221 percent increase in outstanding bilateral debt at end-December 2004 (due to currency-specific loan-by-loan data, reclassification of loans by ODA and non-ODA category, inclusion of accrued interest, application of June-1999 cutoff date) added 172 percentage points. Multilateral debt revised downwards by 2.3 percent, reducing debt ratio by 1.6 percentage points.
  - Togo (Fiscal Revenue Window): Sep-05 = 1/39; Apr-06 = 409; Data Revisions = 14. Currency-specific loan-by-loan bilateral debt data obtained resulted in a 6 percentage point increase in the debt ratio. Preliminary 2004 central government revenue after grants revised downward by 2 percent, causing the remaining increase.
  - Cote d'Ivoire: Sep-05 = 361; Apr-06 = 361; Data Revisions = 0.
  - Kyrgyz Republic (Fiscal Revenue Window): Sep-05 = 1/345; Apr-06 = 376; Data Revisions = 31. Currency-specific loan-by-loan bilateral debt data at end-December 2004 obtained; resulted in a 37 percent increase in estimated NPV of bilateral debt after traditional debt relief.
  - Sri Lanka (Fiscal Revenue Window): Sep-05 = 1/238; Apr-06 = 258; Data Revisions = 20. Currency-specific loan-by-loan bilateral debt data at end-December 2004 and application of June-1999 cutoff date allowed a 16 percent increase in estimated NPV of bilateral debt after traditional debt relief.
  - Bangladesh (Sep-05/Apr-06): Sep-05 = 1/  2/158; Apr-06 = 146; Data Revisions = -12. Currency-specific loan-by-loan bilateral debt data at end-December 2004, including treatment of debt relief ($1.52 billion in nominal terms) provided by Japan, and application of June-1999 cutoff date reduced NPV of bilateral debt after traditional debt relief by 31.6 percent.
  - Tonga: Sep-05 = 2/126; Apr-06 = 132; Data Revisions = 5. Currency-specific loan-by-loan bilateral debt data and June-1999 cutoff date allowed a 40 percent increase in estimated NPV of bilateral debt after traditional debt relief.
- Countries for which assessment is not possible:
  - Afghanistan (Sep-05/Apr-06): Sep-05 = 3/83; Apr-06 = 67; Data Revisions = -16. Exports of goods and services revised upwards: 3-year average exports increased by 39 percent reducing debt ratio by 23.3 percentage points. Upward revisions to outstanding bilateral debt arrears at end-December 2004 and more precise implied interest rate added 7 percentage points.
- Footnotes and important qualifiers preserved from source:
  - 1/ Debt data for multilateral creditors was revised marginally. The impact of such revisions on the debt ratio is negligible.
  - 2/ Earlier estimates for these countries include data provided by authorities on bilateral debt as of end of their respective fiscal years; estimates calculated based on macroeconomic data provided on a fiscal year basis.
  - 3/ Estimates for Afghanistan include only debt that is verified and not under dispute.
  - Sri Lankan authorities noted that the NPV of debt-to-revenue ratio method does not take into account revenue from provinces and may overstate Sri Lanka’s debt burden.
  - Republic of Congo was excluded from analysis at stage 3 because it reached its decision point under the HIPC Initiative in February 2006.
  - A letter from the Governor of the Central Bank of Myanmar dated January 24, 2006, indicated authorities could not provide data needed and do not want to benefit from HIPC Initiative debt relief at this time.
  - A final assessment on Afghanistan depends on verification of external obligations and resolution of disputes with external creditors; based on verified debt only, Afghanistan's estimated debt burden indicators were below HIPC thresholds.

*Source: ANNEX II. METHODOLOGY AND DATA ISSUES (content unit _041106) — extracted text as provided.*

### Annex Table 2. Revisions to the Estimated Debt Burden Indicators since September 2005

### Annex Table 2. Revisions to the Estimated Debt Burden Indicators since September 2005

### Data improvements for countries identified as potentially eligible for HIPC Initiative before September 2005
- For Comoros, Côte d’Ivoire, Liberia, Somalia, and Sudan, there were no revisions to the data collected at Stage 2.
- For Central African Republic, Lao PDR and Togo, the revised data led to an increase in their debt indicators by about 8 percent on average.
  - Central African Republic: bilateral debt estimates were improved as loan-by-loan data from the authorities were used.
  - Lao PDR: currency-specific data from the Asian Development Bank and bilateral creditors were used to improve the NPV estimates.
  - Togo: estimates of debt burden indicators were revised to reflect new debt data provided by the authorities for three multilateral creditors (BOAD, FEGECE, and FSA), revised bilateral debt data, and updated estimates of economic variables.
- Footnotes preserved verbatim:
  - 35 A summary of the sources of information, quality of the data and method of estimation used for those countries is presented in Annex III of  “Heavily Indebted Poor Country (HIPC) Initiative—Status of Implementation,” August 19, 2005, http://www.imf.org/external/np/pp/eng/205/081905.htm..
  - 36 Earlier estimates were based on loan-by-loan data in the currency of commitment (SDR) rather than currency of repayments, which were not available at the time. Using the SDR discount rate for the calculation of the NPV of these obligations did not reflect adequately its currency composition, in particular the significant share of Japanese Yen.

### Data improvements for countries identified in September 2005 as new potential HIPCs and previously unanalyzable cases
- Authorities’ loan-by-loan debt data reconciled with creditor documentation for: Bangladesh, Bhutan, Eritrea, Haiti, Kyrgyz Republic, Nepal, Sri Lanka and Tonga.
  - Bangladesh and Nepal: included confirmation of outstanding debt owed to the Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC) following the implementation of its December 2002 decision to cancel part of its ODA claims.
  - Eritrea and Tonga: currency-specific data from the African Development Bank and the Asian Development Bank were used to calculate the NPV of debt.
- In cases where creditor information was unavailable, authorities’ data were used after validation by staff, involving continuous exchanges to minimize inconsistencies. Most inconsistencies in the data were satisfactorily minimized.

### Reconciliation levels, staff assessment, and minimum requirement
- The level of reconciliation between country authorities’ debt data and creditor information ranged from 90 percent in the case of Eritrea and Kyrgyz Republic to close to 100 percent in the case of Bhutan, Nepal and Tonga.
- Staffs’ view: these reconciliation levels are sufficient to allow for the final assessment of potential eligibility.
- Footnote preserved verbatim:
  - 37 For the IMF, a minimum 70 percent reconciliation of total debt is required for decision point documents.

### Country-specific reconciliation and quality indicators (selection from Annex Table 3)
- Afghanistan
  - Authorities: √
  - Multilateral creditor: √
  - Paris Club creditors/Secretariat: √
  - Progress on Debt Data Reconciliation: Multilateral 99
- Bangladesh
  - Authorities: √
  - Multilateral creditor: √
  - Bilateral: 87
  - Paris Club creditors/Secretariat: √
  - Overall: 97
- Bhutan
  - Authorities: √
  - Multilateral creditor: √
  - Bilateral: 100
  - Paris Club creditors/Secretariat: √
  - Overall: 100
- Eritrea
  - Authorities: √
  - Multilateral creditor: √
  - Bilateral: 68
  - Paris Club creditors/Secretariat: √
  - Overall: 90
- Haiti
  - Authorities: √
  - Multilateral creditor: √
  - Bilateral: 47
  - Paris Club creditors/Secretariat: √
  - Overall: 91
- Kyrgyz Republic
  - Authorities: √
  - Multilateral creditor: √
  - Bilateral: 68
  - Paris Club creditors/Secretariat: √
  - Overall: 90
- Nepal
  - Authorities: √
  - Multilateral creditor: √
  - Bilateral: 99
  - Paris Club creditors/Secretariat: √
  - Overall: 100
- Sri Lanka
  - Authorities: √
  - Multilateral creditor: √
  - Bilateral: 98
  - Paris Club creditors/Secretariat: √
  - Overall: 99
- Tonga
  - Authorities: √
  - Multilateral creditor: √
  - Bilateral: 100
  - Paris Club creditors/Secretariat: √
  - Overall: 100

### Assessment notes and remaining issues (excerpted)
- Other debt data sources refer to creditor statements and other documentation from Non-Paris club and commercial creditors allowing for the reconciliation of the debt.
- Afghanistan: aggregated figures provided by the authorities did not allow for a loan-by-loan reconciliation for multilateral creditors. However both datasets had a discrepancy of less than one percent.
- Eritrea: Authorities did not provide currency-specific data on the debt owed to the African Development Fund. 100% reconciliation includes the data provided by the AfDB, which proved 100% accurate for the remaining African countries, as part of the reconciled debt.
- Tonga: Authorities did not provide currency-specific data on the debt owed to the Asian Development Bank. 100% reconciliation includes the data provided by the AsDB, which proved 100% accurate for the remaining Asian countries, as part of the reconciled debt.
- Selected quality annotations from Annex Table 3:
  - Some guaranteed loans have not been reconciled because of unavailable supporting creditor information.
  - On the bilateral side, loans to Russia and China were not reconciled because of unavailable supporting documentation.
  - On the bilateral side, France, Canada and Spain have been reconciled accounting for 47 % of the outstanding stock.
  - Validation checks showed discrepancies between the authorities data and creditor information for a number of loans. Supporting creditor information for several loans was unavailable.
  - Unverified debts to a number of creditors, including Iraq, Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, and Saudi Arabia, and has debt in dispute with Russia (estimated at US$10.8 billion).

*Annex Table 2. Revisions to the Estimated Debt Burden Indicators since September 2005*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2006/_041106.pdf_
