## 1. Planning of the INS Program

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Planning of the INS Program](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2008/_041808.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2008/_041808.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2008/_041808.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary and purpose
- Focus: the IMF’s training program as part of the Medium–Term Strategy (MTS) for capacity building in member countries.
- Paper updates Executive Directors on current features of the program, reviews recent efforts to strengthen curriculum and enhance value for money, and considers options for boosting external financing of training through charging and increased donor contributions.
- Key questions addressed:
  - Are the objectives of IMF training fully consistent with the broader objectives of the institution and are these training objectives being met?
  - Is Fund training efficiently organized—i.e., is the current degree of decentralization sensible?
  - Are adequate evaluation and feedback mechanisms in place?
  - In the absence of market signals and with a large unsatisfied demand, how can we determine the “right” volume of training and how can we assess its worth?
- Coverage: Focus mainly on training through the IMF Institute (INS) program, which accounted for 75 percent of IMF training in CY 2007.

### Scale and delivery of training (CY 2007)
- Close to 63,000 person–days of training delivered for government officials in CY 2007.
- Delivery channels: Headquarters (HQ), seven regional training centers (RTCs), regional technical assistance centers (RTACs), collaborations with regional organizations and national governments, and INS distance learning.
- RTC locations (in order of establishment): Vienna, Singapore, Abu Dhabi, Tunis, Dalian (China), Brasilia, and Pune (India).
- Participant composition: Three–fourths of course participants come from low– and lower middle–income countries.
- INS accounted for 75 percent of IMF training in CY 2007; INS itself presented one-half of total Fund training during 2007.

### Key features of IMF training
- Oversight:
  - Fund–wide committee composed of area departments and training departments, chaired by a Deputy Managing Director, oversees organization and regional course mix.
- Centralization vs. decentralization:
  - About three-fourths of IMF training is centrally organized under the INS program for administration and curriculum development efficiencies.
  - Training outside INS by other departments and RTACs is highly decentralized and flexible.
- Curriculum and participant selection:
  - Curriculum responsive to member-country issues; inputs from area departments, brainstorming with senior officials, and external surveys.
  - Participant selection emphasizes relevance of job, education, work experience, and potential for advancement; relies on area departments and resident representatives.
- Evaluation:
  - Regular feedback from area departments and country officials, end-of-course questionnaires, and periodic independent sponsor surveys.
  - Donors require positive assessments of quality and cost effectiveness for continued support.
- Networking and reputational benefits:
  - Training and networking welcomed by member countries; trained officials facilitate Fund missions and policy dialogue.
- Role of RTCs:
  - RTCs (together with donors) cover two–thirds of participant costs and provide administrative support and facilities; regional delivery supports curriculum diversity and cross-country experience-sharing.
- Donor financing:
  - Donors pay for a significant amount of INS training at the margin.

### Objectives and orientation of IMF training
- Main objective: strengthen analytical and technical capacities of member country officials to formulate and implement effective macroeconomic policies.
- Subsidiary objectives: support Fund surveillance, program design, technical assistance (TA), and improve interactions for Article IV consultations and resource discussions.
- TA linkage:
  - About 50 percent of IMF training—courses delivered by TA departments and the RTACs—directly supports the Fund’s TA strategy; half of this training is delivered in the INS program.
- Distinctiveness:
  - INS curriculum heavily based on IMF methodology and policy experience; developed by Fund staff with quality control by Fund staff or consultants with Fund experience.

### Scope, languages, and high-level seminars
- Language coverage: Arabic, English, French, Spanish, occasionally Portuguese; simultaneous interpretation where appropriate into Chinese, Russian, and other languages.
- High-level seminars:
  - One- or two-day seminars for ministers and central bank governors.
  - Number of INS high-level seminars: average nine per year in 2004–05; seven in 2006; three in 2007.
  - INS medium-term plan envisages two such seminars per year, with participant costs covered by donor funding and contributions from agencies sending participants or arranged with the annual meetings.
  - Recent topics included China’s exchange rate regime, macroeconomic management of foreign aid, lessons from financial crises, and structured financial products.

### Organization, planning tradeoffs, and delivery modes
- Control and flexibility:
  - Broad central control over INS size and administration; other IMF training decentralized.
- Lead time:
  - Efficient RTC use requires substantial lead time; TA departments and RTACs can organize more rapidly outside INS.
  - INS retains flexibility: about 10 percent of its training is delivered at overseas locations outside the RTCs without far-advance commitments.
- Distance learning:
  - Funded in part by donors; interactive with Fund staff counselors and participant bulletin boards; residential concluding segment for successful participants.
- INS manages eight training campuses in six different time zones on five continents.

### Curriculum development and recent course changes
- INS course planning:
  - Proposals from training departments reviewed by area departments; INS coordinates calendar-year planning to accommodate global partners and synchronized with fiscal-year budgeting.
  - First global catalog in 2007 included HQ and RTC courses.
- FPP (financial programming and policies) courses:
  - Accounted for 34 percent of training within the INS program and 25 percent of total IMF training in 2007.
  - HQ FPP course overhauled; first delivery in August-September 2007.
  - New FPP variant on inflation targeting launched in November 2007.
  - Ongoing improvements to distance learning FPP.
- Macroeconomic diagnostics:
  - Four-week HQ course since late 2005; two-week overseas version rolled out in August 2007.
- Planned and developing courses:
  - New course on external vulnerabilities for delivery later in the year.
  - Four-week Finance for Macroeconomists planned for HQ delivery in 2009.
- Other departments’ course contributions (examples):
  - STA: financial soundness indicators, external debt statistics, remittances statistics.
  - FAD: program and performance budgeting, fiscal transparency, natural resource taxation.
  - MCM: payment systems, central bank accounting, sovereign asset and liability management.
  - LEG: anti-money laundering, bank insolvency, financial sector regulation.
  - FIN: safeguards assessments of central banks.

### Data consolidation, regional allocation, and participant selection
- Training outside INS has not been maintained in a unified dataset; volume outside INS was about 25 percent of IMF training in 2007 (including 13 percentage points in collaboration with RTACs).
- Interdepartmental Subcommittee on Training agreed to compile an integrated database and to submit regularly updated ex ante training plans to improve planning and regional/course mix coherence.
- INS regional allocation monitors distribution in absolute terms and relative to population size; medium-term RTC commitments provide stability but distribution can shift with needs.
- Participant selection:
  - Course descriptions published in the Training Catalog and on INS/RTC websites.
  - INS solicits nominations; area departments and resident representatives help ration excess demand.
  - Electronic registry of training contacts created to improve communication.

### Distribution of INS training by venue (participant weeks, CY 2007)
- RTCs: 53 percent of INS program participant weeks (up from 30 percent in 1998).
- Other overseas venues: 11 percent.
- Distance learning: 7 percent.
- Headquarters (HQ): 29 percent.
- Note: Residential component of distance learning classified under distance learning.

### Feedback, evaluation, and impact assessments
- Participant evaluation:
  - Formal questionnaire and closing-session probing for every INS course.
  - Participants rate likelihood of using knowledge/skills, recommendation propensity, and overall satisfaction.
- Sponsor survey (January–March 2006; covering participants sent during 2003–05; 516 agencies in 179 countries):
  - 97 percent satisfied with IMF training experience; 72 percent strongly agreed.
  - 95 percent agreed training helped participants do their jobs better.
  - 94 percent agreed training enhanced understanding of the IMF and its work.
  - 91 percent agreed training improved ability to formulate and implement policy.
  - 70 percent said officials received added responsibilities or promotions as a result of INS training.
  - Over two-thirds expected demand for INS training to increase over the next five years.
- Internal audit:
  - Assessed INS as well focused on Fund interests and an important service.
  - Suggested requiring exams and conducting impact studies; INS judged existing feedback sufficient and has not pursued mandatory exams but is experimenting with low-key quizzes.

### Costs, value for money, and funding
- Excess demand: applicants typically three times available spaces.
- OBP estimate: gross IMF budget for external training in FY 2009 at US$68 million, representing about 7 percent of the overall budget (includes donor funds flowing through IMF accounts; excludes partner-financed RTC spending).
- Preliminary basic delivery cost estimate for INS-delivered training in FY 2009: around US$2,400 per participant week (excludes personnel costs of other departments and non-IMF overseas support staff).
- Table (projections for FY 2009) — participant costs and staff travel costs per participant week (US$):
  - Long HQ Courses (Average 4–6 week courses, mean length 5.4 weeks): Gross cost: 1,300; Net cost to IMF: 1,300.
  - Two-Week Course (HQ): Gross cost: 1,920; Net cost to IMF: 1,920.
  - One-Week Course (HQ): Gross cost: 2,920; Net cost to IMF: 2,920.
  - RTCs (participant costs only), Two-Week Course: Gross cost: 1,490; Net cost to IMF: 490.
  - RTCs (participant costs only), One-Week Course: Gross cost: 2,110; Net cost to IMF: 740.
  - RTCs (including staff travel), Two-Week Course: Gross cost: 2,060; Net cost to IMF: 1,020.
  - RTCs (including staff travel), One-Week Course: Gross cost: 3,110; Net cost to IMF: 1,660.
- Observations:
  - Net costs to the Fund of one-week and two-week courses are considerably lower at RTCs than at HQ, even including staff travel.
  - RTC partners, donors, and local hosts cover about two-thirds of participant costs for training outside Washington.
  - INS basic two-week course delivery cost approximated at US$4,800 per participant (inclusive estimate noted).
  - Universities comparison: undergraduate tuition often exceeds US$35,000 per academic year; professional school tuition often above US$40,000.

### Productivity gains and efficiency measures (recent years)
- INS output rose by more than 20 percent from FY 2004 to FY 2008; net administrative budget rose by less than 15 percent in nominal terms.
- With overall INS employment essentially unchanged, output increase reflects productivity gains (reduced research time, cuts in participant administrative services, new technologies).
- Flagship FPP course reduced from 8 to 7 weeks in 2006 and to 6 weeks in 2008 without sacrificing objectives.
- Donor contributions to participant and consultant costs rose by about 60 percent over the past four years.
- Participant airfare allowances reduced in nominal terms; living allowances frozen in nominal terms.
- INS strengthened nomination/selection procedures and improved internal recording of participant performance.
- Steps underway to broaden training database to include training outside the INS program.

### Budgetary imperatives, cuts, and external financing (FY 2008–FY 2011)
- Two imperatives:
  - Limit training to activities reflecting the Fund’s unique capacities and mission-critical needs.
  - Reduce reliance on the IMF budget; increase external financing and participant co-payments.
- INS real net administrative budget reduced by 21 percent between FY 2008 and FY 2011.
- Responses across three fronts:
  - (1) reduction in volume of training;
  - (2) staff productivity gains and efficiency savings;
  - (3) increased reliance on external financing (participant co-payments and greater donor funding).
- Planned volume reductions:
  - Overall cut of about 6 percent from the FY 2008 level.
  - 5 percent reduction in training for officials.
  - 10 percent reduction in internal economics training (IET).
- Budget impact:
  - Reduced volume yields real savings equivalent to 7 percent of the FY 2008 net INS budget (net-budget contribution greater than decline in training because external financing assumed unaffected).
  - Training by other departments preliminarily expected to fall by an amount larger than INS-delivered training.
- Productivity and staff spending:
  - Productivity gains of almost 7 percent expected to yield savings equivalent to 4½ percent of the net INS budget.
  - Real spending on INS staff projected to decline by 12½ percent (with a 12 percent cut in positions) during FY 2009–2011.
  - Overall INS personnel spending, including contractuals, to fall by a similar amount.
- Non-staff savings:
  - More than 2½ percent of the FY 2008 net INS budget from non-staff savings, much from shifting training toward RTCs.
  - Most short courses (3-weeks duration or less) to be held outside Washington.
  - Requirement: participant costs for high–level seminars to be fully financed externally or seminars held with the Annual Meetings.
  - Continued tight rein on participant expenses; part realized in FY 2008.

### External financing targets and charging for training
- Medium-term plan target: increase in real external financing equivalent to almost 7 percent of the INS FY 2008 net budget:
  - About 3½ percentage points expected from charging for training (co-payments for participant costs).
  - Balance from boosting donor financing.
- Result: IMF contribution to participant costs in FY 2011 planned to be almost 60 percent lower in real terms than in the FY 2008 budget.
  - FY 2011 projected IMF spending on participant costs: about US$2.8 million.
- Charging design:
  - Co-payments proposed only for training at HQ.
  - Charges to cover participant costs (travel, per diems, accommodation) and an imputation for Concordia.
  - Implemented as a standard weekly participant fee calibrated to cover the average cost per participant; fees differentiated by per capita income level using same scale as for TA outside program countries.
  - Proposed charge per participant week (US$): 260 (Low-Income), 520 (Lower-Middle-Income), 780 (Upper-Middle-Income), 1,300 (High-Income).
  - In percent of total participant cost: 20 (Low-Income), 40 (Lower-Middle-Income), 60 (Upper-Middle-Income), 100 (High-Income).
  - Revenue yield: about US$1¼ million based on the HQ course program for FY 2009 and assuming unchanged participant composition by country income group.
  - Example: For a standard six-week course, charges would range from US$1,560 (Low-Income) to US$7,800 (High-Income).
- Rationale for participant-cost basis:
  - Avoids large price differentials between HQ and RTCs that could reduce HQ demand.
  - Reduces risk of diminishing upper middle-income and high-income country involvement in HQ training.
  - Prevents distortions among agencies within countries.
  - Aligns with other institutions that expect participants to cover expenses with varying subsidization.
  - Promotes country buy-in and budgeting attention.
- Review: co-payment scheme experience to be reviewed after one year for effects on demand composition and donor financing.

### Boosting donor financing: strategy and operational elements
- Immediate focus: boost external financing of existing training to meet medium-term budget.
- Three fund-raising elements:
  - Increase donor funding where weak (Africa, Middle East, Latin America).
  - Attract donor funding for HQ training (support participants from donor regions).
  - Broaden donor-covered costs to include staff travel and, as policy permits, staff time.
- Coordination:
  - INS to work with OTM to align donor strategy with corporate fundraising.
  - Use RTACs where cost-effective and negotiate RTAC collaboration to address coverage and logistics issues.

### Issues for Executive Directors’ discussion
- Are objectives of IMF training aligned with the Fund’s forward-looking institutional strategy?
- Are curriculum developments consistent with medium-term priorities?
- Are oversight, feedback, and administrative mechanisms adequate for value for money?
- How to assess the “right” volume of regional training absent market signals?
  - Are government feedback and donor funding reliable signals of marginal value?
- In adapting to tighter budgets, is the balance right among:
  - changes in volume,
  - changes in course location,
  - introduction of country co-payments, and
  - increases in donor financing?
- Specific sub-questions include:
  - Standard weekly fee vs. actual travel costs basis?
  - Risk of shifting demand away from flagship HQ courses?
  - Potential shifts in participant composition toward central banks?
  - Could differentiated co-payments reduce country diversity?
  - Reasonableness of requiring donor/sending-agency financing for high-level seminars?
  - Desirability of planned increase in donor financing?

*Source: IMF internal paper "Planning of the INS Program" (excerpt).*

### 1. Planning of the INS Program .........................................................................................

### 1. Planning of the INS Program

### Executive summary and purpose
- Focus: the IMF’s training program as part of the Medium–Term Strategy (MTS) for capacity building in member countries.
- Paper updates Executive Directors on current features of the program, reviews recent efforts to strengthen curriculum and enhance value for money, and considers options for boosting external financing of training through charging and increased donor contributions.
- Provides background for addressing:
  - Are the objectives of IMF training fully consistent with the broader objectives of the institution and are these training objectives being met?
  - Is Fund training efficiently organized—i.e., is the current degree of decentralization sensible?
  - Are adequate evaluation and feedback mechanisms in place?
  - In the absence of market signals and with a large unsatisfied demand, how can we determine the “right” volume of training and how can we assess its worth?
- Focus is mainly on training through the IMF Institute (INS) program, which accounted for 75 percent of IMF training in CY 2007.

### Scale and delivery of training (CY 2007)
- The IMF delivered close to 63,000 person–days of training for government officials in CY 2007 at Headquarters (HQ), through a global network of seven regional training centers (RTCs), through regional technical assistance centers (RTACs), in collaboration with other regional training organizations and national governments, and through the INS distance learning program.
- In some regions, a high proportion of senior officials have been through one or more INS courses.
- The training is focused on topics that the IMF is uniquely placed to address.
- RTC locations (in order of establishment): Vienna, Singapore, Abu Dhabi, Tunis, Dalian (China), Brasilia, and Pune (India).

### Key features of IMF training
- Oversight:
  - Organization of training is overseen by a Fund–wide committee—composed of area departments and training departments, chaired by a Deputy Managing Director—which seeks to ensure each region receives the most appropriate mix of courses.
- Centralization and decentralization:
  - About three-fourths of IMF training is centrally organized under the INS program, permitting efficiency gains in administration and facility use and longer-term investment in curriculum development.
  - Training outside the INS program by other departments and RTACs is highly decentralized, requires less advance planning, and enhances delivery flexibility.
- Curriculum and participant selection:
  - Curriculum development is responsive to evolving member-country issues, drawing on area departments, brainstorming with senior officials on regional needs, and external surveys.
  - Participant selection relies critically on inputs from area departments and resident representatives, with substantial weight on the relevance of the candidate’s job, education, work experience, and potential for advancement.
- Evaluation methods:
  - Evaluation uses regular feedback from area departments and country officials, questionnaires collected at the end of every INS course, and periodic surveys of relevant government institutions by an independent outside consulting firm.
  - Donors also provide implicit evaluation, requiring positive assessments of quality and cost effectiveness as a condition for continued financial support.
- Networking and reputational benefits:
  - Training and its networking benefits are universally welcomed by member countries; as trained officials advance, Fund missions and Management find favorably disposed interlocutors.
- Role of RTCs:
  - A large share of training is delivered through the RTCs, which (together with other donors) cover two–thirds of participant costs and provide administrative support and facilities.
  - Regional delivery supports a diversified and relatively sophisticated curriculum, facilitates experience-sharing across countries, and develops cross-country networks.
- Donor financing:
  - Donors pay for a significant amount of INS training at the margin.
- Participant composition:
  - Three–fourths of course participants come from low– and lower middle–income countries.

### Objectives and orientation of IMF training
- Main objective: strengthen analytical and technical capacities of member country officials to formulate and implement effective macroeconomic policies.
- Subsidiary objectives: support Fund work on surveillance, program design, and technical assistance (TA) and contribute to more productive interactions between Fund staff and country officials for Article IV consultations and discussions on Fund resources.
- Training outside INS:
  - 75 percent of IMF training for member–country officials is delivered through the INS program, with the remaining 25 percent arranged independently by other IMF departments and the RTACs (based on participant weeks of training).
  - INS program includes all courses taught by INS and those training events by other departments supported administratively by INS, including all training by other departments at the RTCs and almost all of their training at HQ.
  - INS itself presented one-half of total Fund training during 2007.
- TA linkage:
  - About 50 percent of IMF training—courses delivered by TA departments and the RTACs—directly supports the Fund’s TA strategy; half of this training is delivered in the INS program and typically focuses on broader goals within the TA strategy (e.g., building capacity in statistical methodologies).
  - Courses in collaboration with RTACs are conducive to experience-sharing among countries and contribute importantly to TA delivery.
- Distinctiveness vs. other providers:
  - INS curriculum is heavily based on IMF methodology and policy experience; risk of overlap with comparators is limited.
  - INS courses are developed by Fund staff and quality control relies primarily on Fund staff or consultants with previous Fund experience, contrasting with some other organizations (e.g., WBI) that have relied heavily on consultants or partners.

### Scope, languages, and high-level seminars
- Language coverage: Arabic, English, French, Spanish, and occasionally Portuguese; simultaneous interpretation where appropriate into Chinese, Russian, and other languages.
- Demand includes policy issues faced by advanced emerging-market countries as well as low-income countries.
- High-level seminars:
  - INS has provided one- or two-day seminars for high-level officials (ministers, central bank governors) to foster dialogue on global or regional policy issues.
  - Number of high-level seminars under INS reduced from an average of nine per year in 2004-05 to seven in 2006 and three in 2007 due to high cost and budget/staff constraints.
  - INS’s medium-term plan envisages organizing two such seminars per year, with participant costs covered by donor funding and contributions from agencies sending participants, or by arranging the seminar in conjunction with the annual meetings. INS will provide administrative support to seminars organized by other departments on the same basis.
  - Recent seminar topics have included: (i) the domestic and international implications of China’s exchange rate regime, (ii) the macroeconomic management of foreign aid, (iii) what we have learned from the financial crises of the past decade, and (iv) structured financial products and the implications of the crisis in asset-backed securities.

### Organization and planning tradeoffs
- Control and flexibility:
  - Broad control is exercised over the size and administration of the INS program, while other IMF training is arranged in a decentralized manner by individual training departments.
  - Centralized administration aims to ensure efficient use of facilities and coordination with RTC partners.
- Lead time and flexibility:
  - Efficient use of RTC facilities requires substantial lead time in planning the INS program.
  - TA departments and RTACs can organize training outside the INS program with much less advance scheduling, enabling responsiveness to needs not covered by INS and to region- or country-specific TA initiatives.
  - INS retains some flexibility: about 10 percent of its training is delivered at overseas locations outside the RTCs where commitments are not made as far in advance.

### Key statistics (as presented)
- INS accounted for 75 percent of IMF training in CY 2007.
- Nearly 63,000 person–days of training delivered in CY 2007.
- Table 1 (Distribution of IMF Training by Provider, 2007) — participant weeks:
  - IMF Institute within INS Program: 6,108 participant weeks; 64.7 percent (within INS Program total).
  - IMF Institute total (including outside INS Program where applicable): 6,108 participant weeks; 48.6 percent (of Total IMF Training).
    - Financial Programming (IMF Institute): (3,168) participant weeks; (33.6) percent (within INS Program) and (3,168) participant weeks; (25.2) percent (of Total IMF Training).
    - Other (IMF Institute): (2,941) participant weeks; (31.2) percent (within INS Program) and (2,941) participant weeks; (23.4) percent (of Total IMF Training).
  - Statistics Department: 2,195 participant weeks within INS Program; 23.3 percent (within INS Program) and 740 participant weeks outside INS Program; 23.6 percent (outside INS Program); total 2,935 participant weeks; 23.3 percent (of Total IMF Training).
  - Other departments: 1,131 participant weeks within INS Program; 12.0 percent (within INS Program) and 1,690 participant weeks outside INS Program; 53.9 percent (outside INS Program); total 2,821 participant weeks; 22.4 percent (of Total IMF Training).
  - RTACs: 706 participant weeks within INS Program; 22.5 percent (within INS Program) and 706 participant weeks; 5.6 percent (of Total IMF Training).
  - Total: 9,434 participant weeks within INS Program; 100 percent (within INS Program); 3,136 participant weeks outside INS Program; 100 percent (outside INS Program); total 12,570 participant weeks; 100 percent (Total IMF Training).
  - Memorandum: Training delivered by, or in collaboration with, RTACs — 217 participant weeks within INS Program; 2.3 percent; 1,425 participant weeks outside INS Program; 45.4 percent; total 1,642 participant weeks; 13.1 percent.
- Participant composition: Three–fourths of course participants come from low– and lower middle–income countries.
- INS contributed one-half of total Fund training during 2007.

*Source: IMF internal paper "Planning of the INS Program" (excerpt).*

### 12. One drawback of the decentralized organization of IMF training is that data on

### 12. One drawback of the decentralized organization of IMF training is that data on

### Data consolidation, planning, and interdepartmental coordination
- Training delivered or planned outside the INS program have not been maintained in a unified format or consolidated dataset.
- The volume of training outside the INS program represented about 25 percent of all IMF training of officials in 2007 (13 percentage points in collaboration with the RTACs).
- As recommended under the MTS, the interdepartmental Subcommittee on Training has agreed upon, and begun to implement, procedures for:
  - compiling an integrated database to provide a more complete picture of IMF training ex post;
  - submitting and regularly updating the ex ante training plans of individual departments, allowing the Subcommittee and the Committee on Capacity Building to reflect more coherently on whether the aggregate plan is sensibly distributed across regions and provides an appropriate mix of courses within each region.
- The Subcommittee on Training includes members from all five area departments, the six main training departments (INS, FAD, FIN, LEG, MCM, STA), OBP, and OTM, and functions as a subcommittee of the Committee on Capacity Building, which is chaired by Management.

### INS geographical strategy, RTC expansion, and delivery modes
- INS strategy over the past decade: (i) expand network of RTCs and increase training delivered abroad; (ii) exploit new technologies to extend reach through distance learning courses.
- RTCs are established in cooperation with regional or national partners who provide substantial co-financing.
- Distance learning courses:
  - Funded in part by donors;
  - Especially useful for officials unable to spend extended periods away from their jobs;
  - Unlike many e-learning courses, IMF distance learning entails considerable interaction with Fund staff counselors via e-mail and among participants through a bulletin board;
  - Only participants who satisfactorily complete the distance phase are invited to participate in the concluding residential segment.
- RTCs present management challenges: INS manages eight training campuses in six different time zones on five continents, requiring substantial oversight, renegotiations of agreements, and attention to administrative, staffing, and budgetary issues.

### Distribution of INS training by venue (participant weeks)
- In calendar year 2007 (INS program):
  - RTCs accounted for 53 percent of the total participant weeks of training under the INS program (up from 30 percent in 1998).
  - Other overseas venues accounted for 11 percent.
  - Distance learning accounted for 7 percent.
  - Headquarters (HQ) accounted for 29 percent, where courses tend to be relatively long and typically involve many IMF staff.
- Note: The residential component of distance learning courses is classified under distance learning, irrespective of location.

### Efficiency and scope considerations
- Concentration of overseas courses in a small number of RTCs provides efficiency gains from economies of scope in course administration and investment/procurement of computer, interpretation, and audio-video facilities.
- Administration of HQ courses is concentrated in INS for efficiency, but inserting INS into organizing and administering courses delivered outside the INS network is unlikely to yield efficiency gains.
- Many training activities outside the INS program use the RTAC network and enjoy similar efficiencies; where practical, INS uses the RTAC network for overseas courses it delivers outside the RTCs.

### Curriculum development, course content, and delivery
- INS course planning process:
  - Starts with proposals from each training department submitted to area departments for review.
  - Modified in response to reactions from area departments, the RTCs, and collaborative organizations.
  - Calendar-year basis of INS program creates budgeting complications because the IMF fiscal year differs; INS course plan is designed on a calendar-year basis to accommodate global partners.
  - Two channels alleviating budgeting complications:
    - Move to medium-term budgeting to facilitate planning beyond the current fiscal year.
    - In 2007, INS adjusted the timeline to synchronize calendar-year curriculum planning with the Fund’s fiscal-year budget design process; course plans for calendar year 2008 began to take shape during January–March 2007 and were endorsed in early May.
  - The 2007 edition was the first global catalog to include courses at HQ and IMF courses at all of the RTCs.
- Curriculum emphasis and developments:
  - INS courses emphasize macroeconomic and financial topics supporting surveillance and policymaking.
  - FPP (financial programming and policies) courses:
    - Long-standing staple of INS curriculum.
    - During 2007, FPP courses accounted for 34 percent of training within the INS program and 25 percent of total IMF training.
    - INS conducted an internal stocktaking finding the conventional FPP course out of date for shocks amplified by portfolio shifts and repricing of risk in global capital markets.
    - Overhauled HQ FPP course first delivered in August-September 2007 to provide more extensive treatment of balance sheet vulnerabilities and capital account crises.
    - A new variant placing macroeconomic policy design in the context of inflation targeting was launched in November 2007.
    - Ongoing substantive and technological improvements to the distance learning FPP course.
  - Macroeconomic diagnostics:
    - A four-week course offered at HQ since late 2005.
    - A two-week version for overseas delivery rolled out in August 2007.
  - Sectoral courses expanded to include macroeconomic management and fiscal policy (inter alia on intertemporal issues and debt sustainability), financial markets and instruments, monetary and exchange rate policy.
  - Planned and developing courses:
    - A new course on external vulnerabilities for delivery later this year.
    - A four-week course on Finance for Macroeconomists being developed for delivery at HQ in 2009.
  - Other departments’ contributions:
    - STA: new courses on financial soundness indicators, external debt statistics, international trade-in-services statistics, and remittances statistics.
    - FAD: courses on program and performance budgeting, fiscal transparency, and natural resource taxation.
    - MCM: revamped courses on payment systems and central bank accounting; new courses on strategic aspects of sovereign asset management and operational approaches to sovereign liability management.
    - LEG: courses on anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism, bank insolvency, financial sector regulation, and international financial institutions.
    - FIN: course on safeguards assessments of central banks.
  - Training departments continuously upgrade course content to reflect environment changes, lessons of experience, and evolution of analytic tools.

### Regional allocation and participant selection
- INS regional allocation practices:
  - Seeks to respond to urgency of area department demands while considering regional distribution.
  - Monitors regional distribution in both absolute terms and relative to population size.
  - Medium-term strategic commitments in RTC agreements provide year-to-year stability in training distribution.
  - Distribution can shift in response to changing training needs and the environment.
  - Training outside the INS program can significantly influence the distribution and is highly responsive to evolving TA delivery needs.
  - INS and RTACs make efforts to prevent language issues from adversely affecting country distribution (e.g., collaboration with Bank of Portugal for Lusophone African countries; use of interpretation where applicable).
- Participant selection and nominations:
  - INS publishes course descriptions in the IMF Institute’s Training Catalog and posts them on the INS website and the RTC websites.
  - Selection procedures aim to ensure officials chosen can use what they learn for their countries’ benefit.
  - Application and nomination processes:
    - INS directs nomination requests to appropriate agencies and solicits applications from prospective participants.
    - Area departments, in consultation with resident representatives, help solicit applications/nominations and ration large excess demand.
    - INS works closely with TA departments to match participants appropriately for courses delivered by those departments in the INS program.
    - INS has created an electronic registry of training contacts to enhance communication with member-country agencies about prospective course participants and other issues.

### Key statistics and factual highlights
- 25 percent: share of all IMF training of officials in 2007 delivered or planned outside the INS program (including 13 percentage points in collaboration with RTACs).
- 53 percent: share of INS program participant weeks at RTCs in calendar year 2007.
- 11 percent: share of INS program participant weeks at other overseas venues in calendar year 2007.
- 7 percent: share of INS program participant weeks delivered through distance learning in calendar year 2007.
- 29 percent: share of INS program participant weeks provided at HQ in calendar year 2007.
- 34 percent: share of INS program training accounted for by FPP courses during 2007 (and 25 percent of total IMF training).
- Eight: number of training campuses INS manages.
- Six: number of different time zones across INS training campuses.
- Five: number of continents on which INS training campuses are located.
- January–March 2007: period when calendar year 2008 course plans began to take shape in coordination with fiscal-year business plans.
- August-September 2007: first delivery of the thoroughly overhauled HQ FPP course.
- November 2007: launch of the FPP variant focused on inflation targeting.
- Late 2005: start of the four-week macroeconomic diagnostics course at HQ.
- August 2007: rollout of the two-week macroeconomic diagnostics overseas version.
- 2009: planned HQ delivery year for a four-week course on Finance for Macroeconomists.

*Source: IMF internal chapter text.*

### 27. Various feedback mechanisms are used to evaluate the relevance of the training

### 27. Various feedback mechanisms are used to evaluate the relevance of the training

### Feedback mechanisms and participant evaluation
- Participant feedback is collected for every INS course via:
  - a formal questionnaire; and
  - further probing during the closing session.
- Participant input addresses:
  - appropriateness of topics covered;
  - whether lecture content met expectations;
  - lecturer effectiveness;
  - whether workshops and readings contributed to understanding;
  - suggestions for course improvement.
- INS generates a summary measure of course value by asking participants to rate:
  - the extent to which the knowledge/skills acquired will be used in their jobs;
  - how strongly they would recommend the course to others;
  - their overall satisfaction with the course.

### Surveys of sponsors (external evaluation)
- INS commissions independent outside organizations to survey member-country agencies that send officials to INS courses.
- Most recent sponsor survey covered January–March 2006 and solicited feedback from 516 central banks, ministries of finance, statistical agencies, and other ministries and agencies in 179 member countries that had sent participants during 2003–05.
- Key findings from the 2006 sponsor survey:
  - 97 percent agreed they were satisfied with their IMF training experience; 72 percent indicated strong agreement.
  - 95 percent agreed INS training helped participants do their jobs better.
  - 94 percent agreed INS training enhanced understanding of the IMF and its work.
  - 91 percent agreed INS training improved participants’ ability to formulate and implement policy.
  - 70 percent said officials had been given added responsibilities or promotions as a result of their INS training.
  - Over two-thirds of respondents indicated that their demand for INS training would increase over the next five years.
- Note in survey commentary: greatest increase in demand was for specialized courses such as finance, inflation targeting, macroeconomic diagnostics, and macroeconomic forecasting; demand for financial programming and policies and macroeconomic statistics remained strong.

### Internal audit findings and assessment of exam use
- Internal audit assessed INS training as:
  - well focused on areas of Fund interest and comparative advantage;
  - an important service that enhances member countries’ policy-making capacity, fosters Fund policy dialogue, and creates goodwill.
- Audit suggestions for enhancing evaluation:
  - require training participants to take exams; and
  - conduct studies to assess the capacity–building impact of training.
- INS response and considerations:
  - Neither approach is extensively employed by comparator organizations.
  - INS judged existing feedback mechanisms sufficient and has not pursued these approaches for evaluation purposes.
  - Rationale against mandatory exams includes:
    - exams would require baseline and end-of-course testing to measure learning, which is time consuming;
    - no proven methodology exists for analyzing training impact; comparator organizations are not conducting impact analysis; costs would be high.
  - Concern that individual examinations could undermine course atmospherics: group engagement and workshops are essential for bond-building, networking, and peer learning.
  - INS selection procedures generally yield highly motivated participants; INS is encouraging low-key experimentation with quizzes.

### Donor support, RTC oversight, and information dissemination
- Donor oversight is pronounced at the RTCs: local partners either administer programs or provide oversight via RTC Boards or Executive Committees; RTC agreements (except for the newest one for India) have been through at least one renewal.
- Local partners have in some renewals invested substantially in upgrading training and accommodation facilities.
- Donors outside local RTC partners require regular value-for-money evaluations; these are analyzed and often prompt follow-up before renewed commitments.
- INS disseminates information to stakeholders:
  - course and participant details made available to Fund staff via the Technical Assistance Information Management System (TAIMS);
  - course evaluation scores shared with RTC partners and other donors;
  - financial reports to donors include actual costs rather than standard costs;
  - a comprehensive Report on Training is circulated annually in streamlined form (previously biennial).

### Costs and value for money: scale and cost drivers
- Excess demand for IMF training is evident: number of applicants typically three times available spaces; many requests must be turned down.
- OBP estimate: gross IMF budget for external training in FY 2009 at US$68 million, including allocated support and governance spending, representing about 7 percent of the overall budget. (This includes spending financed by donor funds flowing through IMF accounts, but excludes spending financed by partners at the RTCs.)
- Major cost components:
  - personnel and travel (participant and teaching staff travel for overseas courses).
- Funding practices:
  - At HQ and RTCs, the Fund together with relevant cosponsors currently cover all participant travel costs.
  - For overseas regional courses outside RTCs, practice varies: Fund typically does not cover participant costs; donor funds often cover these; in some cases participants’ employers fund travel.
- Cost metrics and estimates:
  - Preliminary estimate: basic delivery costs for INS-delivered training in FY 2009 average around US$2,400 per participant week of training provided. (Calculation limited to training delivered by INS staff; excludes personnel costs of other departments delivering training and excludes support personnel at overseas locations who are not IMF employees.)
- Participant and staff travel costs vary by location and course length. Table 2 (projections for FY 2009, including staff accommodation and imputed participant accommodation) reports participant costs and staff travel costs per participant week:
  - Long HQ Courses (Average 4–6 week courses, mean length 5.4 weeks):
    - Gross cost: 1,300
    - Net cost to IMF: 1,300
  - Two-Week Course (HQ):
    - Gross cost: 1,920
    - Net cost to IMF: 1,920
  - One-Week Course (HQ):
    - Gross cost: 2,920
    - Net cost to IMF: 2,920
  - RTCs (participant costs only), Two-Week Course:
    - Gross cost: 1,490
    - Net cost to IMF: 490
  - RTCs (participant costs only), One-Week Course:
    - Gross cost: 2,110
    - Net cost to IMF: 740
  - RTCs (including staff travel), Two-Week Course:
    - Gross cost: 2,060
    - Net cost to IMF: 1,020
  - RTCs (including staff travel), One-Week Course:
    - Gross cost: 3,110
    - Net cost to IMF: 1,660
  - Notes: RTC net cost is based on general cost–sharing provisions and excludes additional donor funding for some courses; table excludes staff travel in the participant-cost-only RTC rows.
- Observations on costs:
  - Net costs to the Fund of one-week and two-week courses are considerably lower at RTCs than at HQ, even accounting for staff travel.
  - Partners at RTCs, donors, and local hosts cover about two-thirds of participant costs for training outside Washington.
  - RTC partners cover facilities and most local support staff costs that the Fund would otherwise incur.
  - Donors also contribute significantly to consultant/expert costs for overseas courses.
  - INS has combined or eliminated most one-week courses because fixed travel costs make one-week courses expensive in participant-week terms; some TA departments at RTCs continue to offer many one-week events due to specialized topics.

### Comparisons with universities and broader benefits
- Typical INS two-week course provides approximately 60 hours of lectures and workshops plus group working time, reading, and preparation—more classroom time than many semester-long university courses.
- Basic delivery cost of a two-week course is about US$4,800 per participant.
- Comparison notes:
  - Undergraduate tuition at many private U.S. universities exceeds US$35,000 per academic year; professional school tuition often above US$40,000.
  - IMF training compares reasonably with top university courses given additional financing universities receive from endowments and donations.
- Value-added attributes of INS training:
  - Strong orientation toward real-world policy issues, combining theory and case studies.
  - IMF staff provide down-to-earth policy perspectives drawn from internal policy discussions.
  - Small workshop groups and personalized attention.
  - Careful participant selection aligned with background, job responsibilities, and priorities from area departments and resident representatives.
- Externalities and public goods:
  - Sound macroeconomic policies generated by training confer worldwide benefits not reflected in individual country demand.
  - INS-trained interlocutors facilitate Fund missions’ work; training creates favorable impressions and relationships as participants rise in careers.
  - Example: 2007 Bank/Fund Annual Meetings included 378 delegates who had taken INS courses, including 47 Central Bank Governors, 22 Ministers, 20 Deputy Central Bank Governors, and 8 Deputy Ministers.

### Donor contributions, productivity gains, and efficiency measures
- Donor willingness to underwrite a large part of variable costs suggests good value for money and that scale may not be excessive; donors do not cover Fund staff salaries.
- INS actions over past four years to increase value for money:
  - Overall INS output rose by more than 20 percent from FY 2004 to FY 2008; INS net administrative budget rose by less than 15 percent in nominal terms.
  - With overall INS employment (including contractuals) essentially unchanged, output increase reflects productivity gains (reduced research time, cuts in administrative services for participants, new technologies).
  - Flagship FPP course at HQ reduced from 8 to 7 weeks in 2006 and further to 6 weeks in 2008 through pruning and delivery efficiencies, without sacrificing key course objectives.
  - Expansion of training over past four years occurred outside Washington with additional donor support; donor contributions to participant and consultant costs rose by about 60 percent over this period.
  - Participant airfare allowances reduced in nominal terms; living allowances frozen in nominal terms (many living allowances denominated in U.S. dollars; U.S. dollar depreciation delivered additional real cuts).
  - Strengthening of curriculum endorsed by survey results and meetings of outside experts on regional needs.
  - Enhanced participant nomination and selection procedures, including outreach when candidates do not meet standards and use of regional meetings to highlight candidate attributes.
  - Improved internal procedures for recording participant performance for future course nominations.
  - Steps underway to broaden the training database to include training outside the INS program.
  - Progress in providing more detailed cost estimates with elements included in the business plan for FY 2008.

_Italic: Source: _041808 - 27. Various feedback mechanisms are used to evaluate the relevance of the training_ (PDF).

### 44. The refocusing of the Fund’s work in the context of a sharply reduced overall

### 44. The refocusing of the Fund’s work in the context of a sharply reduced overall budget envelope

### Budgetary imperatives and alignment
- Two broad imperatives for INS:
  - Training needs to be limited to that which reflects the Fund’s unique capacities, supports the Fund’s mission, and is seen as critical by member countries.
  - Training delivery needs to be parsimonious in its reliance on the IMF budget to ensure that the volume of training is protected to the extent possible.
- INS has recent curriculum development and training evaluation work that ensures alignment with the Fund’s medium-term strategy and processes to maintain that alignment.

### Budgetary outlook and required responses
- The INS real net administrative budget is reduced by 21 percent between FY 2008 and FY 2011.
- The budgetary challenge must be met on three broad fronts:
  - (1) a reduction in the volume of training;
  - (2) staff productivity gains and other efficiency savings; and
  - (3) increased reliance on external financing, in the form of participant co-payments toward the cost of training and greater donor funding.

### Planned adjustments in training volume and budgetary impact
- Planned cuts in training volume:
  - Overall cut of about 6 percent from the FY 2008 level.
  - 5 percent reduction in training for officials.
  - 10 percent reduction in internal economics training (IET).
- The reduced volume of activity will yield real savings equivalent to 7 percent of the FY 2008 net INS budget.
  - Note: The contribution in percentage points to net budget reduction is greater than the decline in training because reduced training lowers gross costs while external financing is assumed unaffected for this calculation.
- Preliminary indications: training by other departments will fall by an amount larger than INS-delivered training.

### Productivity, staffing, and non-staff savings
- Productivity and staffing:
  - Productivity gains of almost 7 percent will yield savings equivalent to 4½ percent of the net INS budget.
  - Real spending on INS staff is projected to decline by 12½ percent (with a 12 percent cut in positions) during FY 2009-2011.
  - Overall INS personnel spending, including on contractuals, will fall by a similar amount.
  - Sources of productivity gains: shifting more training overseas, organizational efficiencies (such as increasing division size), and closure of the IMF staff position at the Joint Africa Institute.
- Non-staff cost savings:
  - More than 2½ percent of the FY 2008 net INS budget in non-staff cost savings.
  - Much of this reflects a further shift in the balance of training delivery toward the RTCs.
  - Most short courses (3-weeks duration or less) will henceforth be held outside of Washington.
  - Requirement: participant costs for high–level seminars to be fully financed externally, or seminars held in conjunction with the Annual Meetings.
  - Continued tight rein on participant expenses; part of this saving realized in FY 2008 implementation.

### Curriculum reach and mitigation measures
- Moving shorter courses outside Washington reduces global reach of the INS curriculum because some courses offered at HQ have been available only at a limited number of RTCs.
- Mitigation measures:
  - Negotiate at certain RTCs to allow participants from outside the region to attend specific courses not delivered in their own region.
  - Short courses that are externally financed may still be delivered in Washington.
  - Residential segments of Fund-financed distance-learning courses will continue to be delivered in Washington until alternative arrangements can be made at the RTCs.

### External financing targets and implications
- Medium-term plan envisages an increase in real external financing equivalent to almost 7 percent of the INS FY 2008 net budget.
  - About 3½ percentage points expected from charging for training (co-payments for participant costs).
  - Balance from boosting donor financing.
- Result: IMF contribution to participant costs in FY 2011 is planned to be almost 60 percent lower in real terms than in the FY 2008 budget.
  - The projection for FY 2011 envisages IMF spending on participant costs of about US$2.8 million.
- If planned external financing does not materialize, training volumes would need to be cut considerably.

### Charging for training: proposed design and scale
- General design considerations and scope:
  - Co-payments proposed only for training at HQ (not for overseas/RTC training).
  - Fund’s cost recovery to be related to participant costs—mainly travel, per diems and accommodation— including an imputation for Concordia.
  - Implemented through a standard weekly participant fee calibrated to cover the average cost per participant (preferred over fees based on actual travel and living costs).
  - Charges differentiated by per capita income level of participant’s country of origin, using the same charging scale as for TA outside program countries.
  - High-income countries pay 100 percent of the standard fee.
- Proposed scale of charges (based on expected costs in FY 2009):
  - Charge per participant week, in US$: 260 (Low-Income), 520 (Lower-Middle-Income), 780 (Upper-Middle-Income), 1,300 (High-Income).
  - In percent of total participant cost: 20 (Low-Income), 40 (Lower-Middle-Income), 60 (Upper-Middle-Income), 100 (High-Income).
- Revenue and examples:
  - Revenue yield from above scale of fees would be about US$1¼ million, based on the HQ course program for FY 2009 and assuming unchanged composition of participants by country income group.
  - Example for a standard six-week course: charges would range from US$1,560 for a low-income country to US$7,800 for a high-income country.
- Rationale for basing charge on participant costs rather than comprehensive course-delivery costs:
  - Avoids large relative price differential between HQ and RTCs that could reduce demand for HQ training.
  - Reduces risk of diminishing involvement of upper middle-income and high-income countries in HQ training.
  - Prevents distortions in distribution of training among central banks and other agencies within countries.
  - Aligns with practice of other training institutions that typically do not charge tuition but expect participants to cover expenses with varying subsidization.
  - Ensures some co-payment for all countries to promote country buy-in and budgeting attention.
- Review and monitoring:
  - If co-payment scheme introduced, experience will be reviewed after one year to assess influence on level and country composition of demand and success in boosting donor financing.

### Boosting donor financing: strategy and operational elements
- Immediate focus: boost external financing of existing training to support the planned medium-term budget.
- Three key elements in fund-raising strategy:
  - Increase availability of donor funding for training where it is relatively weak (notably Africa, the Middle East, Latin America).
  - Attract donor funding for HQ training—encourage donors with regional interests to support participants from those regions at HQ courses.
  - Broaden range of costs covered by donors beyond participant costs to include staff travel costs and, as Fund policy permits, staff time.
- Coordination and channels:
  - INS to work closely with OTM to align donor strategy with corporate fundraising.
  - Specific actions include coordinating approaches to donors for regional funding, leveraging potential donor interest in proposed topical funds, and using RTACs where cost-effective.
- Use of RTACs:
  - Increased use offers efficiency benefits (sharing facilities/administration, attracting donors) but depends on addressing RTAC limitations:
    - Geographical coverage of RTACs often smaller than ideal for diverse curriculum delivery.
    - RTAC locations may have suboptimal flight connections or training facilities.
  - Effective RTAC use requires collaboration among RTACs and between RTACs and other training organizations and possibly locating regional training where logistics are better than RTAC administration site.

### Issues for discussion (items posed for Executive Directors)
- Are the objectives of IMF training properly aligned with the Fund’s forward-looking institutional strategy?
- Are recent curriculum development initiatives consistent with the Fund’s medium-term priorities?
- Are adequate oversight, feedback, and administrative mechanisms in place to ensure member countries receive good value from IMF training?
- How can the “right” volume of regional training be assessed in the absence of market signals?
  - Is feedback from relevant government agencies a good guide?
  - Does donor funding provide a signal of perceived marginal value of training?
- In adapting training strategy to the tighter budgetary environment, is the right balance being struck among:
  - changes in volume,
  - changes in course location,
  - introduction of country co-payments, and
  - increases in donor financing?
  - Specific sub-questions:
    - Is it preferable to base charges on a standard weekly fee rather than actual travel costs?
    - Is there a danger that co-payments will shift demand away from longer flagship HQ courses?
    - Could co-payments shift participant composition toward central banks and away from government ministries/agencies?
    - Could differentiated co-payments reduce country diversity with detrimental effects?
    - Given high cost of high-level seminars, is it reasonable to require participant costs be covered by donors or sending agencies?
    - Is the planned increase in donor financing desirable?

*Source: 44. The refocusing of the Fund’s work in the context of a sharply reduced overall budget envelope*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2008/_041808.pdf_
