## _092311

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_092311](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2011/_092311.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2011/_092311.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2011/_092311.pdf.json)

---

### Executive Summary — Overview and Purpose
- Reviews reform options for the eligibility criteria for the SDR currency basket and responds to requests by the Executive Board, the IMFC, and the G-20 Ministers for a criteria-based path to broaden the composition of the basket.
- Analysis guided by long-standing principles underlying SDR valuation and considerations related to a stable evolution of the international monetary system (IMS).
- Examines:
  - maintaining the current "freely usable" (FU) currency criterion and clarifying its indicators;
  - a possible new criterion tailored to SDR reserve-asset characteristics (RAC);
  - issues related to the exports criterion (size);
  - the number of currencies in the SDR basket.
- Operational next steps: more operational issues—particularly those related to currency weights in the SDR basket and the SDR interest rate—will be addressed in a subsequent paper.
- Points for Board discussion include:
  - whether to retain the FU criterion with clarified indicators or to adopt the RAC;
  - the appropriate indicators under either approach;
  - whether and how to modify the exports gateway or number of currencies given practical data constraints.

### Freely Usable (FU) Currency: Concept, Role, and Indicators
- Definition and role:
  - Article XXX (f): a freely usable currency is a member’s currency that the Fund determines (i) is, in fact, "widely used" to make payments for international transactions, and (ii) is "widely traded" in the principal exchange markets.
  - FU concept formalized for SDR valuation in the 2000 decision.
- Historical/operational context:
  - FU requirement formally added in 2000; indicators first discussed in 1977.
  - Current SDR basket (since 2000) consists of the four currencies that are: (i) issued by Fund members (or monetary unions that included Fund members) which are the largest exporters, and (ii) have been determined by the Fund to be freely usable.
- Proposed FU indicators:
  - For "wide use": currency composition of official reserve holdings; currency denomination of international banking liabilities; currency denomination of international debt securities; (secondary indicator: number of countries holding a currency in reserves).
  - For "wide trading": foreign exchange spot market turnover; market depth; low transaction costs (e.g., bid-ask spreads); existence of forward markets and regular market quotations.
- Operational significance:
  - Clarifying FU indicators is important to establish a criteria-based path to expand the SDR basket if FU is maintained as the SDR-basket entry criterion.
- Governance and practice:
  - Currencies deemed "freely usable" are designated by the Board; no Board-approved set of indicators nor formal limit on number of FU currencies historically.

### Possible New Tailored Reserve-Asset Criterion (RAC)
- Rationale:
  - Alternative to FU: a criterion explicitly tailored to the reserve-asset characteristics of the SDR to safeguard those characteristics and potentially enable a broader basket more quickly.
- Three key reserve-asset characteristics proposed:
  - Liquidity in foreign exchange markets;
  - Hedgeability;
  - Availability of appropriate interest rate instruments.
- Four indicators proposed to assess RAC:
  - Currency composition of foreign exchange reserves;
  - Spot market turnover (volume of transactions in foreign exchange spot markets);
  - Derivatives market turnover (volume of transactions in foreign exchange derivatives markets and over the counter derivatives trade);
  - An appropriate market-based interest rate instrument (existence and suitability).
- Assessment caveats:
  - Data limitations and heterogeneous indicators preclude a mechanistic approach; Board judgment required to weight indicators and supplement quantitative indicators with qualitative assessment.
  - On adding financial account convertibility as an explicit eligibility condition: paper suggests not necessary or helpful; prefer assessment through direct market-based measures.

### Scenario Analysis and Key Findings
- Scenario methodologies:
  - Method 1: Project the 2015 value of indicators using average growth rates over the 2004–10 period.
  - Method 2: For currencies of the top ten exporters, calculate growth in each indicator required to reach the share of the currently fourth- or fifth-ranked currency in the projected global value.
- Indicators modeled:
  1. Global foreign exchange turnover (common to FU and RAC).
  2. Activity in derivatives markets (RAC indicator).
  3. Cross-border issuance of debt securities (FU indicator).
- Main scenario findings:
  - Inertia and network externalities imply meeting the RAC criterion may be challenging but could be achievable for some currencies within a shorter time period than under the FU "wide use" requirement.
  - Method 1: potential for considerable change in relative rankings for FX turnover and derivatives activity; several emerging market currencies could enter the top range if historical growth rates persist; changes in ranking are much smaller using international debt securities indicator.
  - Method 2: required growth rates to reach benchmark can be very large:
    - For foreign exchange turnover, simulations suggest annual growth would have to exceed 50 percent for two emerging market currencies in the illustrative scenario (when benchmark is the fifth-ranked currency).
    - If benchmark is the fourth-ranked currency, required growth rates rise to around 70 percent annually for those cases.
    - For derivatives transactions, similar high growth required.
    - For international debt securities, required growth for two emerging market currencies is around 100 percent; for developed market currencies it is less than 10 percent.
  - Caveats: exercises are mechanistic, backward-looking, and do not account for changing thresholds or second-round macroeconomic effects.

### Exports Criterion and Size-Related Considerations
- Historical role:
  - Since 1974, export shares have provided a "gateway" size criterion for SDR inclusion.
  - 1974 decision: currencies of members with export share > 1 percent included; 1980 reduced basket to five currencies; 2000 retained export criterion and added FU requirement reducing basket to four.
- Assessment of alternatives:
  - Combining exports with financial inflows desirable in principle but current data limitations (incomplete reporting, valuation issues, inability to isolate autonomous cross-border financial flows, volatility) argue against adding financial inflows now.
  - Replacing exports with market GDP considered but judged to move away from international aspects SDR size measure is meant to capture; little to be gained.
- Effect on top-five composition:
  - Export shares and combined exports-plus-financial-inflows point to the same top five currencies.
  - Adding financial inflows moves the United Kingdom from fourth to third in ranking.
  - Comparisons based on market GDP produce different rankings (example: Japan moves to third, followed by China and the United Kingdom).
- Staff view:
  - Maintain exports as the size gateway pending better financial flows data; not pre-judging the number of currencies in the basket has merit.

### Number of Currencies in the SDR Basket
- Current rule (2000 decision):
  - Specific number: 4 currencies — those issued by the largest exporters deemed freely usable.
  - Replacement rule: new currency would replace an existing one only if its relevant exports exceeded those of the currency to be replaced by more than 1 percent.
- Considerations:
  - No clear a priori optimal number; past reductions from 16 to 5 in 1980 and 5 to 4 in 1999/2000 illustrate desirability of keeping basket relatively small to limit costs and complexity.
  - Options:
    - Decide ex ante a maximum size (e.g., 5 or 6) to keep replication and hedging simple.
    - Leave future size open and decide on addition versus replacement case-by-case, potentially with a minimum weight threshold for inclusion.
  - Staff view favors flexibility and not prejudging future size while guided by stability and representativeness.

### Operational Considerations, Borrower Preferences, and FU Properties
- Operational objective:
  - FU currencies should be close substitutes so a purchasing member receiving a FU currency can use it directly through members' reserves or indirectly via market exchange without adverse exchange-rate effects.
- Recent borrower preferences:
  - Fund borrowers recently have preferred to receive only two of the four existing FU currencies (the US dollar and the euro) in most transactions.
- FU defining characteristics reiterated:
  - Widely used for international transactions and widely traded in principal exchange markets.
- Operational desiderata:
  - FU currencies should be sufficiently deep and liquid so that a member transacting a sizable amount would not cause an appreciable exchange rate change.
  - Minimal transaction costs (e.g., narrow bid-ask spreads) desirable in Fund operations.
- Recognition of inertia:
  - Substantial inertia exists; stocks change slowly and may mask faster changes in flows.

### Inertia in the International Use of Currencies (Box 4) — Drivers and Evidence
- Sources of inertia:
  - Demand-side: transactional, store of value, precautionary motives; policy credibility takes time to build; precautionary demand increases premium on liquidity.
  - Supply-side: supply of financial instruments denominated in reserve currencies determined by savings and borrowing patterns.
  - Institutional/market-structure: network externalities and regulatory/institutional organization evolve slowly.
- Empirical evidence:
  - Correlation for currency composition of debt securities between 2001 and 2004: 0.98.
  - Correlation for currency composition of debt securities between 2001 and 2010: 0.96.
  - Correlation for foreign exchange market turnover for 2001-10: 0.86.
  - FX turnover shares:
    - US dollar and euro together account for around 60 percent of total FX turnover (broadly unchanged since 2001).
    - Japanese yen and pound sterling combined share around 15 percent (relatively stable).
  - Chinese renminbi daily turnover increased by around 65 percent a year since 2004.
  - Bid-offer spreads have generally narrowed over time for most currencies; spreads relatively narrow for current FU currencies.

### Empirical Findings and Key Statistics (selected exact figures preserved)
- COFER (end-2011Q1, reported allocated reserves):
  - US dollars: 60.7 percent
  - Euro: 26.6 percent
  - Pound sterling: 4.1 percent
  - Japanese yen: 3.8 percent
  - Swiss franc: 0.1 percent
  - Other currencies: 4.7 percent
  - Allocated reserves share: 54.7 percent
  - Unallocated reserves share: 45.3 percent
  - Total FX reserves at EndQ1 2011: USD 9,694 billion
- COFER (end 2001, for comparison):
  - US dollars: 71.1 percent
  - Euro: 18.3 percent
  - Pound sterling: 2.8 percent
  - Japanese yen: 6.1 percent
  - Swiss francs: 0.3 percent
  - Other: 1.5 percent
  - Allocated reserves share: 78.4 percent
  - Unallocated reserves share: 21.6 percent
  - Total FX reserves at End 2001: USD1,936 billion
- Reserve-holding breadth (end of 2011Q1):
  - 96 percent of Fund members held the US dollar as part of their reserves.
  - 68 percent of Fund members held the euro as part of their reserves.
  - 45 percent of reporting members held at least 5 percent of their reserves in “other” than the five identified currencies.
- International liabilities and debt securities:
  - Combined share of the US dollar and the euro in the denomination of international liabilities has remained broadly stable since 2001 with a combined share in the 75 to 80 percent range.
  - Share of other currencies in denomination of international banking liabilities rising, reaching nearly 8 percent of total liabilities.
- Inertia measures:
  - Correlation of currency composition shares of debt securities for the top 20 currencies over past decade: around 0.96.
  - Correlation for foreign exchange market turnover: 0.86.

### Data Availability, COFER Features, and Planned Actions
- COFER:
  - Primary source for reserve currency composition; voluntary quarterly data; reported country data strictly confidential; aggregates published for World, Advanced Economies, and Emerging and Developing Economies.
  - Limitations: around 45 percent of total reserves were unallocated by end of first quarter of 2011; COFER seeks a 5-currency breakdown (the four SDR currencies and the Swiss franc); not all countries report (138 member countries reported for the 2011 Q1 survey).
- Other data sources:
  - BIS data on currency denomination of international banking liabilities (BIS member banks in 42 jurisdictions).
  - BIS international debt instruments statistics (bonds, notes, money market instruments issued cross-border).
  - BIS global triennial foreign exchange turnover survey (low frequency: every three years).
  - BIS OTC derivatives statistics: semiannual but limited currency breakdown (mostly 13 developed-economy currencies).
- COFER action plan:
  - Re-engage key countries that do not furnish COFER data and seek participation.
  - Consult with current COFER reporters on possible expansion of currencies reported, balancing reporting burden and timing; decisions to follow consultations.
- Interim approach:
  - Use reasonable, comparable proxies reflecting the underlying concept until data limitations are rectified.

### Selected Appendix Scenario and Table Highlights (exact values preserved)
- Appendix Table I1 (FX turnover projections to 2015, select entries):
  - All Currencies: 2004 1,773.3; 2010 3,981.0; Annual growth 14.4 percent; Projected 2015 8,220.5; Percent 100
  - US dollar: 2004 786.5; 2010 1,689.0; Annual growth 13.6 percent; Projected 2015 3,193.5; Percent 42.4; share 38.8
  - Chinese renminbi: 2004 0.9; 2010 17.1; Annual growth 64.3 percent; Projected 2015 205.1; Percent 0.4; share 2.5
- Appendix Table I2 (Derivatives projections to 2015, select entries):
  - All Currencies: 2004 1,152; 2010 2,488; Annual growth 13.7 percent; Projected 2015 5,217; Percent 100
  - US dollar: 2004 522.2; 2010 1,094.5; Annual growth 13.1 percent; Projected 2015 2,027.7; Percent 44.0; share 38.9
  - Chinese renminbi: 2004 0.4; 2010 13.1; Annual growth 78.1 percent; Projected 2015 234.0; Percent 0.5; share 4.5
- Appendix Table I3 (International debt securities projections to 2015, select entries):
  - All Currencies: 2004 13,934; 2010 27,674; Annual growth 12.1 percent; Projected 2015 50,250; Percent 100
  - Euro: 2004 6,528.3; 2010 12,173.6; Annual growth 10.9 percent; Projected 2015 20,461.4; Percent 44.0; share 40.7
  - US dollar: 2004 5,095.3; 2010 10,843.7; Annual growth 13.4 percent; Projected 2015 20,347.9; Percent 39.2; share 40.5
  - Chinese renminbi: 2004 1.5; 2010 19.3; Annual growth 53.0 percent; Projected 2015 161.6; Percent 0.1; share 0.3
- Appendix Table I4 (Methodology 2: FX turnover required annual growth examples):
  - Chinese renminbi: Scenario 1 = 71.2 percent; Scenario 2 = 64.3 percent; Scenario 3 = 77.1 percent.
  - Russian rouble: Scenario 1 = 69.6 percent; Scenario 2 = 62.8 percent; Scenario 3 = 75.5 percent.
  - Canadian dollar: Scenario 1 = 19.1 percent; Scenario 2 = 14.3 percent; Scenario 3 = 23.2 percent.
  - Memorandum projected FX turnover (percent of GDP of issuing country) for 2015: US dollar 11.5; Euro 6.4; Japanese yen 6.9; Pound sterling 11.4; Australian dollar 12.2.
  - Ratio of global FX turnover to global GDP in 2015 assumed: Scenario 1 = 7.8 percent; Scenario 2 = 6.3 percent; Scenario 3 = 9.2 percent.
- Appendix Table I5 (Derivatives — annual growth required to reach fifth-ranked benchmark, percent):
  - Canadian dollar: Scenario 1 = 19.7; Scenario 2 = 14.4; Scenario 3 = 24.3
  - Chinese renminbi: Scenario 1 = 65.6; Scenario 2 = 58.2; Scenario 3 = 71.9
  - Korean won: Scenario 1 = 52.8; Scenario 2 = 46.0; Scenario 3 = 58.6
  - Russian rouble: Scenario 1 = 79.0; Scenario 2 = 71.0; Scenario 3 = 85.8
  - Swiss franc: Scenario 1 = 15.1; Scenario 2 = 10.0; Scenario 3 = 19.5
- Appendix Table I5 projected derivatives volumes (percent of GDP of issuing country) — 2010 observed and 2015 projected (select):
  - 2010 observed: Canadian dollar 4.2; Chinese renminbi 0.2; Korean won 1.9; Russian rouble 0.6; Singapore dollar 9.2; Swiss franc 15.4
  - 2015 projected (Scenario 1): Canadian dollar 8.2; Chinese renminbi 1.6; Korean won 11.0; Russian rouble 5.6; Singapore dollar 53.4; Swiss franc 26.0
- Appendix Table I6 (International debt securities — annual growth required to reach fifth-ranked benchmark, percent):
  - Canadian dollar: Scenario 1 = 14.0; Scenario 2 = 9.8; Scenario 3 = 17.7
  - Chinese renminbi: Scenario 1 = 104.0; Scenario 2 = 96.5; Scenario 3 = 110.6
  - Korean won: Scenario 1 = 224.8; Scenario 2 = 212.9; Scenario 3 = 235.3
  - Swiss franc: Scenario 1 = 10.4; Scenario 2 = 6.3; Scenario 3 = 13.9
- Appendix Table I6 projected international debt securities volumes (percent of GDP of issuing country) — 2010 observed and 2015 projected (select):
  - 2010 observed: Canadian dollar 22.5; Chinese renminbi 0.3; Korean won 0.2; Russian rouble 1.1; Singapore dollar 16.0; Swiss franc 79.5
  - 2015 projected (Scenario 1): Canadian dollar 34.1; Chinese renminbi 6.8; Korean won 46.2; Russian rouble 23.3; Singapore dollar 223.6; Swiss franc 108.9

### Director Discussion Points and Concluding Remarks
- Director questions posed in paper include:
  - Do Directors agree that broad principles that guided SDR valuation in the past still remain valid?
  - Views on maintaining FU versus adopting RAC.
  - Do proposed FU indicators capture "wide use" and "wide trading"?
  - Views on merits and indicators for RAC.
  - Continued role for a size-related criterion; whether to maintain existing exports criterion given financial accounts data weaknesses; whether to augment exports with financial inflow data once data weaknesses are addressed; pace of data efforts.
  - Views on number of currencies in SDR basket and whether not to pre-judge future number.
- Concluding operational remarks:
  - A criteria-based path could incentivize issuers of candidate currencies to deepen financial markets and support international currency use, facilitate acceptance and use as reserve assets, and contribute to smooth IMS evolution.

*Source: Executive Summary and extracted sections from IMF staff paper _092311.*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### Executive Summary

### Overview and Purpose
- The paper reviews reform options for the eligibility criteria for the SDR currency basket and responds to requests by the Executive Board, the IMFC, and the G-20 Ministers for a criteria-based path to broaden the composition of the basket.
- The analysis is guided by long-standing principles underlying SDR valuation and considerations related to a stable evolution of the international monetary system (IMS).
- The paper examines: maintaining the current "freely usable" (FU) currency criterion and clarifying its indicators; a possible new criterion tailored to SDR reserve-asset characteristics; issues related to the exports criterion (size); and the number of currencies in the SDR basket.

### Freely Usable Currency: Concept, Role, and Indicators
- Definition and role:
  - Article XXX (f) defines a freely usable currency as a member’s currency that the Fund determines (i) is, in fact, "widely used" to make payments for international transactions, and (ii) is "widely traded" in the principal exchange markets.
  - The FU concept lies at the core of the Fund’s financial operations and was formalized for SDR valuation in the 2000 decision.
- Historical and operational context:
  - The FU requirement was added formally in 2000 although considerations of currency use and trading had been accounted for earlier; indicators for assessing freely usable currencies were first discussed in 1977.
  - The current SDR basket (since the 2000 decision) consists of the four currencies that are: (i) issued by Fund members (or monetary unions that included Fund members) which are the largest exporters, and (ii) have been determined by the Fund to be freely usable.
- Proposed indicators to assess FU:
  - For "wide use": the currency composition of foreign exchange reserves, international debt securities, and international bank liabilities.
  - For "wide trading": foreign exchange spot market turnover.
- Operational significance:
  - Clarifying FU indicators would be important to establish a criteria-based path to expand the SDR basket if FU is maintained as the SDR-basket entry criterion.
- Legal/operational references preserved:
  - The Second Amendment context and Fund obligations under Article V, Section 3(e) (i) are noted in relation to FU.

### Possible New Tailored Reserve-Asset Criterion
- Rationale:
  - An alternative to FU is a criterion explicitly tailored to the reserve asset characteristics of the SDR, designed to safeguard those characteristics while potentially enabling a broader basket more quickly.
- Three key reserve-asset characteristics proposed:
  - Liquidity in foreign exchange markets;
  - Hedgeability;
  - Availability of appropriate interest rate instruments.
- Four indicators proposed to assess the reserve-asset criterion:
  - Currency composition of foreign exchange reserves;
  - Spot market turnover;
  - Derivatives market turnover;
  - An appropriate market-based interest rate instrument.
- Comparative implication:
  - Scenario analysis suggests that this tailored reserve-asset criterion, while preserving SDR reserve characteristics, may provide scope to broaden the SDR basket within a shorter time frame than under the FU gateway.

### Scenario Analysis and Key Findings
- Scenario analysis:
  - Scenario work reflects inertia and network externalities that influence "wide use" of currencies and assesses the implications of the different indicator sets.
  - Illustrative scenario results are provided in the appendixes (scenario tables and methodology).
- Main findings:
  - Meeting the possible new reserve-asset criterion would be challenging but may be achievable for some currencies within a shorter time period than under the FU-focused approach.
  - The tailored criterion focuses more directly on reserve-asset functionality (liquidity, hedgeability, interest instruments) and less on "wide use" per se, which may reduce the lag associated with inertia and network externalities.

### Exports Criterion and Size Considerations
- Current practice:
  - Since the adoption of the SDR basket formula in 1974, exports have provided a "gateway" size criterion for SDR inclusion.
- Review outcome:
  - While augmenting exports with financial flows would be desirable in principle, current data limitations suggest that it may be appropriate to maintain exports as the size criterion at this stage.
- Implication:
  - Retaining exports preserves an objective, historically applied gateway pending better data on financial flows.

### Number of Currencies in the SDR Basket
- Current rule:
  - The 2000 decision provides for a specific number of basket currencies: 4.
- Paper's view:
  - There are merits in not pre-judging the number of currencies in the SDR basket.
  - Whether a new currency would replace or be added to existing SDR basket currencies could be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

### Concluding Remarks and Issues for Discussion
- A criteria-based path to broaden the SDR basket could:
  - Provide issuers of candidate currencies with incentives to pursue policy reforms that deepen financial markets and support international currency use;
  - Facilitate acceptance and use of those currencies as reserve assets, offering diversification benefits to users;
  - Contribute to a smooth evolution of the IMS by setting clear, transparent rules for SDR valuation.
- Operational next steps:
  - More operational issues—particularly those related to currency weights in the SDR basket and the SDR interest rate—will be addressed in a subsequent paper.
- Points for Board discussion include:
  - Whether to retain the FU criterion with clarified indicators or to adopt the proposed tailored reserve-asset criterion;
  - The appropriate indicators to apply under either approach;
  - Whether and how to modify the exports gateway or number of currencies given practical data constraints and operational considerations.

*Source: Executive Summary.*

### 14.      From an operational perspective, it is desirable that freely usable currencies be

### _092311 - 14.      From an operational perspective, it is desirable that freely usable currencies be

### Operational objective and recent borrower preferences
- Freely usable (FU) currencies should be close substitutes so a purchasing member receiving a FU currency can use it directly through members‘ reserves or indirectly via market exchange without adverse effects on the exchange rate.
- In practice, Fund borrowers in the recent period have preferred to receive only two of the four existing freely usable currencies (the US dollar and the euro) in most transactions.

### Two defining characteristics of Freely Usable currencies
- FU currencies are characterized by being:
  - widely used (for international transactions), and
  - widely traded (in principal exchange markets).
- Interrelation and caveat:
  - These characteristics are interrelated but not identical: a widely used currency is likely also widely traded, but a widely traded currency may not be widely used because of inertia in currency use (transaction costs of currency switching and network externalities).

### Governance and historical practice
- The currencies deemed to be “freely usable” are designated by the Board.
- There is no Board-approved set of indicators nor a formal limit on the number of FU currencies.
- Historical practice:
  - 1977 staff proposed and the Executive Board used a set of indicators (Box 2) to assess FU status.
  - In 1978, the Executive Board determined the Deutsche mark, French franc, Japanese yen, pound sterling, and the U.S. dollar were freely usable.
  - In 1998, the euro was added and the deutsche mark and French franc removed.
  - In the 2010 SDR valuation review, the Chinese renminbi was considered to not yet meet the criteria to be a freely usable currency.

### Proposed indicators going forward (assessment of wide use and wide trading)
- For wide use (capture relative importance for international transactions), staff proposes use of:
  - Currency composition of official reserve holdings (and, as a secondary indicator, the number of countries holding a currency in reserves);
  - Currency denomination of international banking liabilities;
  - Currency denomination of international debt securities.
- For wide trading, continued emphasis on:
  - market depth (sufficient so no appreciable exchange rate change when transacting a sizable amount),
  - low transaction costs (e.g., bid-ask spreads),
  - existence of forward markets and regular market quotations.

### Data availability and limitations
- Data availability has improved since 1977 but important limitations remain.
- COFER (Currency Composition of Official Foreign Exchange Reserves) is the primary source for reserve currency composition but has limitations:
  - An increasingly significant proportion of reserves is unallocated: about 45 percent of total reserves by the end of the first quarter of 2011.
  - COFER currently seeks a 5-currency breakdown (the four SDR currencies and the Swiss franc), limiting scope of assessment.
  - Not all countries report to COFER (138 member countries reported for the 2011 Q1 survey).
- Other data sources now available that were not in 1977:
  - BIS data on currency denomination of international banking liabilities (BIS member banks in 42 jurisdictions).
  - BIS international debt instruments statistics (bonds, notes, money market instruments issued cross-border).

### Empirical findings and key statistics (preserve values exactly)
- COFER-related figures (end-2011Q1, reported allocated reserves):
  - US dollars: 60.7 percent
  - Euro: 26.6 percent
  - Pound sterling: 4.1 percent
  - Japanese yen: 3.8 percent
  - Swiss franc: 0.1 percent
  - Other currencies: 4.7 percent
  - Allocated reserves share: 54.7 percent
  - Unallocated reserves share: 45.3 percent
  - Total FX reserves at EndQ1 2011: USD 9,694 billion
- COFER-related figures (end 2001, for comparison):
  - US dollars: 71.1 percent
  - Euro: 18.3 percent
  - Pound sterling: 2.8 percent
  - Japanese yen: 6.1 percent
  - Swiss francs: 0.3 percent
  - Other: 1.5 percent
  - Allocated reserves share: 78.4 percent
  - Unallocated reserves share: 21.6 percent
  - Total FX reserves at End 2001: USD1,936 billion
- Reserve-holding breadth:
  - At end of 2011Q1, 96 percent of Fund members held the US dollar as part of their reserves.
  - At end of 2011Q1, 68 percent of Fund members held the euro as part of their reserves.
  - At end of 2011Q1, 45 percent of reporting members held at least 5 percent of their reserves in “other” than the five identified currencies.
- International banking liabilities and debt securities:
  - Combined share of the US dollar and the euro in the denomination of international liabilities has remained broadly stable since 2001 with a combined share in the 75 to 80 percent range.
  - The share of other currencies in the denomination of international banking liabilities is on the rise, reaching nearly 8 percent of total liabilities.
- Inertia measures:
  - Over the past decade, correlation of currency composition shares of debt securities for the top 20 currencies has been around 0.96, indicating a very stable structure of currency denomination.
  - Correlation for foreign exchange market turnover (an indicator of “wide trading”) is 0.86, lower than the stock measures, indicating more change in trading patterns than in use-denominated stocks.

### COFER features and planned actions
- COFER collects voluntary quarterly data on the currency composition of official foreign exchange reserves and classifies reported country data as strictly confidential; aggregates for World, Advanced Economies, and Emerging and Developing Economies are published.
- COFER action plan to address shortcomings:
  - Re-engage key countries that do not furnish COFER data and seek their participation.
  - Consult with current COFER reporters on possible expansion of currencies reported, balancing reporting burden and timing; decisions on expanding currency breakdown will follow consultations.

### Operational considerations for Fund transactions
- Key operational desiderata:
  - FU currencies should be sufficiently deep and liquid so that a member transacting a sizable amount would not cause an appreciable exchange rate change.
  - Minimal transaction costs in FU currency transactions conducted in connection with Fund operations are desirable.
- Recognition of inertia:
  - Substantial inertia exists in currency use for international transactions; stocks change slowly and may mask faster changes in flows.

*Source: _092311 - 14.      From an operational perspective, it is desirable that freely usable currencies be*

### Box 4. Inertia in the International Use of Currencies

### Box 4. Inertia in the International Use of Currencies

### Sources of inertia
- Demand, supply, institutional factors, and network externalities contribute to inertia in the international use of currencies.
- Demand-side drivers:
  - Transactional, store of value, and precautionary motives.
  - Volume of international transactions closely associated with the importance of the issuer country in the world economy.
  - Store of value depends on policy credibility, which takes longer to establish and contributes to inertia.
  - Precautionary demand places a high premium on liquidity of a reserve asset in adverse circumstances, reinforcing network externalities and inertia.
- Supply-side drivers:
  - Supply of financial instruments denominated in reserve currencies, including liquidity and depth in financial markets, tends to be relatively stable because it is broadly determined by saving patterns and borrowing needs of issuer countries.
- Institutional and market-structure drivers:
  - Network externalities reflecting market structure and institutional organization, including regulatory aspects, evolve slowly and add to inertia.

### Empirical evidence of inertia
- Correlations in currency composition over time show high stability:
  - Correlation for currency composition of debt securities between 2001 and 2004: 0.98.
  - Correlation for currency composition of debt securities between 2001 and 2010: 0.96.
  - Correlation displayed by foreign exchange turnover for 2001-10: 0.86, indicating a smaller degree of inertia for trading activity than for wide currency use.
- Stocks (levels outstanding) provide the best indication of market depth; flows may show lower inertia.
- FX market structure observations:
  - The US dollar and euro together account for around 60 percent of total foreign exchange (FX) turnover, a broadly unchanged share since 2001.
  - The combined share of the Japanese yen and pound sterling has been relatively stable, at around 15 percent.
  - Turnover of key emerging market currencies remains relatively small, though the Chinese renminbi’s daily turnover has increased by around 65 percent a year since 2004.
- Bid-offer spreads:
  - Spreads reflect transaction costs and have generally narrowed over time for most currencies.
  - Spreads are relatively narrow for the current freely usable currencies.
  - Spread data must be interpreted cautiously for large transactions and when access restrictions or market liquidity limits apply.

### Indicators proposed for “widely traded” and for reserve-asset assessment
- For widely traded currencies (indicators with comprehensive and timely data):
  - Volume of transactions in foreign exchange spot markets.
  - “Bid-offer” spreads (secondary indicator).
- For a possible new “reserve asset criterion” (RAC) tailored to SDR characteristics, the RAC seeks to ensure attractiveness of the SDR as a reserve asset by reflecting that a reserve asset is a foreign currency–denominated external claim that is readily available and liquid. Specific characteristics include:
  - Liquidity in foreign exchange markets.
  - Hedgeability (availability of derivative instruments or alternative hedging facilities, including possibly central bank facilities).
  - Availability of appropriate high quality interest rate instrument (domestic asset with a well-defined interest rate accessible to reserve managers).
- Four indicative metrics to assess the RAC:
  - Volume of transactions in foreign exchange spot markets.
  - Volume of transactions in foreign exchange derivatives markets and over the counter derivatives trade.
  - Existence of an appropriate market-based interest rate instrument.
  - Currency composition of official reserve holdings (and, as a secondary indicator, the number of countries holding a currency in reserves and where relevant broader measures of foreign currency holdings).

### Considerations for interest-rate instrument assessment
- Key dimensions for evaluating appropriate interest rate instruments:
  - Representativeness:
    - Be broadly representative of the range of financial instruments actually available to investors in a particular currency.
    - Carry an interest rate responsive to changes in underlying credit conditions in the corresponding money market.
  - Risk characteristics:
    - Have credit risk characteristics similar to the official standing of the SDR (highest quality).
    - Reflect revealed reserve asset choices of reserve managers (form of instrument, liquidity, maturity).
- Past SDR basket reviews (2000 and 2005) inform these dimensions.

### Data limitations and role of Board judgment
- Data limitations and heterogeneous indicators preclude a mechanistic approach; Board judgment is required to:
  - Weight indicators relative to each other.
  - Supplement quantitative indicators with qualitative assessment of institutional and policy aspects important for reserve assets.
  - Assess the extent to which restrictions on financial account transactions could raise transaction costs and limit hedging options.
  - Judge whether financial development is adequate, backed by sound and credible macroeconomic policies and a robust institutional framework.
  - Evaluate whether an exchange rate regime (e.g., a peg or high correlation with existing currencies) could reduce SDR diversification benefits; note pegged currencies have been included in the SDR basket in the past.
- On adding financial account convertibility as an explicit eligibility condition: the paper suggests this would not be necessary or helpful given jurisdictional limits and preference to assess through direct market-based measures.

*Source: Box 4. Inertia in the International Use of Currencies (extracted content).*

### 37.      There are considerable overlaps, but also some differences between the

### _092311 - 37.      There are considerable overlaps, but also some differences between the

### FU versus Reserve Asset (RAC) indicators
- FU indicators focus on the criteria set out in the Articles: that a currency is in fact widely used to make payments for international transactions and widely traded in principal foreign exchange markets.
- RAC indicators focus on reserve-asset characteristics of the SDR: availability of sufficiently liquid and deep markets in the currency, ability to hedge currency exposures, and availability of an appropriate domestic investment vehicle.
- Comparison (selected indicators as presented):
  - Widely Used
    - FU: 1. Currency composition of reserves (Possible supplementary indicator: number of countries holding a currency in reserves)
    - RAC: 1. Currency composition of reserves (Possible supplementary indicators: (i) number of countries holding a currency in reserves; and (ii) other foreign currency holdings by monetary authorities)
    - FU: 2. Currency denomination of international banking liabilities
    - RAC: 2. Volume of transactions in foreign exchange derivatives markets and over the counter derivatives trade
    - FU: 3. Currency denomination of international debt securities
    - RAC: 3. Appropriate market based interest rate instrument
  - Widely Traded
    - FU: 4. Volume of transactions in foreign exchange spot markets (Supplementary Indicator: Bid - Offer spreads)
    - RAC: 4. Volume of transactions in foreign exchange spot markets (Supplementary Indicator: Bid - Offer spreads)

### Scenario analysis and implications for broadening the SDR basket
- Scenario analysis suggests the possible new reserve asset criterion (RAC) may provide scope to broaden the SDR basket within a shorter time frame than relying solely on the FU criterion.
- Past experience indicates very few currencies can be expected to attain the status of a freely usable currency in the foreseeable future because of specific operational requirements in the Fund‘s Articles, particularly the “wide use” requirement.
- Scenarios were run for selected currencies on three indicators:
  - global FX turnover in spot markets (FU indicator: widely traded; and RAC indicator),
  - activity in derivatives markets (possible RAC indicator),
  - currency composition of international debt securities (FU indicator: widely used).
- Results:
  - Due in part to inertia, meeting the possible RAC criterion may be achievable for some currencies within a shorter time period, while meeting the FU “wide use” requirement remains very difficult.
  - Nonetheless, the decision to replace the FU criterion with a new RAC rests on broader considerations beyond the timeframe to expand the SDR basket.

### Box 5 — Scenario Analysis: methodology and illustrative results
- Methodologies:
  - Method 1: Project the 2015 value of the indicator using average growth rates over the 2004–10 period.
  - Method 2: For currencies of the top ten exporters, calculate growth in each indicator required to reach the share of the currently fourth- or fifth-ranked currency in the projected global value.
- Key illustrative findings:
  - Method 1: Potential for considerable change in relative rankings for FX turnover and derivatives activity; several emerging market currencies could enter the top range if historical growth rates persist. Changes in ranking are much smaller using the international debt securities indicator.
  - Method 2: Required growth rates to reach a target (e.g., the share of the fifth-ranked currency) can be large:
    - For foreign exchange turnover, simulations suggest annual growth would have to exceed 50 percent for two emerging market currencies in the illustrative scenario.
    - For derivatives transactions, similar high growth would be required.
    - For international debt securities, required growth is markedly higher and more variable: for two emerging market currencies it would be around 100 percent; for developed market currencies it would be less than 10 percent.
  - Observed low ratios of foreign exchange turnover to a country‘s own GDP for emerging market currencies imply scope for “catch-up growth.”

### Export shares as the size-related (gateway) criterion
- Historical role:
  - Export shares have been central to SDR basket selection since the 1973–74 Board discussions.
  - 1974 decision: SDR basket composed of currencies of all Fund members with a share greater than 1 percent of total exports of goods and services.
  - 1980 decision: SDR from 1981 would include currencies of the five member countries with the largest exports of goods and services; basket size reduced from sixteen to five currencies.
  - 2000 decision: retained export criterion and added the requirement that a currency be “freely usable”; basket reduced from five to four currencies reflecting the euro.
- Advantages of continuing to use export shares:
  - Broad measure of size and importance in the global economy.
  - Offers continuity and stability in ranking of currencies.
- Limitations of export shares:
  - Do not capture autonomous cross-border financial flows (flows not the financial counterpart of trade), which have generally increased faster than exports.
  - Export data do not fully reflect an issuer‘s role in global financial markets.

### Options and assessment for alternative size-related criteria
- Options considered:
  - Continue using exports of goods and services.
  - Combine exports with international financial inflows (foreign direct investment, portfolio inflows, other inflows as measured in the balance of payments).
  - Replace exports by market GDP.
- Assessment of financial inflows:
  - Potentially desirable to capture global financial importance and capacity to generate internationally traded assets.
  - Serious data shortcomings limit cross-country comparability:
    - Reporting incomplete with marked cross-country variation and valuation issues.
    - Conceptual issues: inability to identify the autonomous component of cross-border financial transactions; potential double-counting of what exports measure; financial center data reflecting transactions originating elsewhere; high volatility in flows and rankings.
    - Financial inflows are recorded on a net basis, often yielding measures significantly smaller than trade flows.
  - Conclusion: While desirable in principle, inclusion of financial inflows should be revisited after key data issues are addressed; for now, it is prudent not to add available financial inflow data to exports as the size criterion.
- Assessment of market GDP:
  - Readily available and not affected by some limitations of financial inflows.
  - Not a close proxy of an issuer‘s role in global trade and finance, thus moving away from the international aspects the SDR size measure is meant to capture.
  - On balance, little to be gained from replacing export shares by GDP.
- Effect on top-five composition:
  - Export shares and combined exports-plus-financial-inflows would point to the same top five currencies for the SDR basket.
  - Adding financial inflows moves the United Kingdom from fourth to third in ranking, reflecting its role as an international financial centre.
  - Comparisons based on market GDP produce different rankings among the top five (e.g., Japan moves to third, followed by China and the United Kingdom).
  - From 2001–05 to 2006–10, China‘s share among the top twenty currencies increased by an average 3 percentage points under the export shares measure and when financial inflows are combined with exports. Australia, Korea, India, Russia, and Singapore also gained share in 2006–10.

### Key statistics from Table 5 (Exports and Financial Inflows: Top-20 Exporters, averages)
- Total (columns shown): 5,588 100; 9,204 100; 7,940 100; 13,102 100
- Selected country-level levels and shares (2006–2010 and 2001–2005 averages presented in table; examples preserved exactly as shown):
  - Euro Area: 1,345 24.1; 2,167 23.6; 2,006 25.3; 3,226 24.6
  - United States: 1,033 18.5; 1,547 16.8; 1,777 22.4; 2,508 19.1
  - China 4/: 491 18.8; 1,100 12.0; 987 7.5; 1,365 10.4
  - United Kingdom: 506 9.1; 706 7.7; 1,008 12.7; 1,533 11.7
  - Japan: 464 8.3; 635 6.9; 717 7.2; 926 2.0
  - Canada: 265 4.7; 343 3.7; 301 3.8; 436 3.3
  - Korea: 182 3.2; 163 3.4; 199 2.5; 353 2.7
  - Singapore: 164 2.9; 242 3.2; 182 2.3; 339 2.6
  - Russia: 128 2.3; 291 3.2; 149 1.9; 365 2.8
  - Switzerland: 159 2.8; 252 2.7; 192 2.4; 362 2.8
  - Mexico: 138 2.5; 188 2.0; 161 2.0; 217 1.7
  - India: 71 1.3; 182 2.0; 83 1.1; 235 1.8
  - Sweden: 113 2.0; 181 2.0; 133 1.7; 245 1.9
  - Saudi Arabia: 83 1.5; 174 1.9; 86 1.1; 194 1.5
  - Australia: 80 1.4; 154 1.7; 127 1.6; 253 1.9
  - Malaysia 5/: 92 1.6; 141 1.5; 97 1.2; 155 1.2
  - United Arab Emirates: 56 1.0; 138 1.5; ........
  - Norway: 79 1.4; 136 1.5; 103 1.3; 192 1.5
  - Brazil: 67 1.2; 133 1.4; 86 1.1; 194 1.5
  - Thailand: 72 1.3; 127 1.4; 81 1.0; 139 1.1
- Notes accompanying table (preserve exact wording and numbering in source):
  - 1/ Levels are in SDR billions; shares are in percentage of the total. Countries ranked based on 2006-2010 average of Exports of Goods and Services.
  - 2/ Includes income credit and debit. Data for the euro area adjusted to exclude intra euro area trade.
  - 3/ Sum of trade of goods and services and the absolute values of direct investment in the reporting economy, portfolio investment liabilities, and other investment liabilities. Due to lack of data on financial inflows, UAE is not included in this measure.
  - 4/ Includes Mainland China and Hong Kong SAR. For exports of goods and services, excludes intra-trade of goods.
  - 5/ Financial inflow data are only available through 2009; respective average is based on 2006-2009 data.

### Number of currencies in the SDR basket
- Under the 2000 decision:
  - The SDR basket comprises the four currencies issued by the largest exporters (or currency unions) that are deemed freely usable.
  - A new currency meeting requirements would replace an existing one only if at the time of determination its relevant exports exceeded those of the currency to be replaced by more than 1 percent.
- Considerations going forward:
  - The criteria-based path to broadening suggests revisiting the four-currency rule; no clear a priori optimal number exists.
  - Past reductions: from 16 to 5 in 1980 and from 5 to 4 in 1999/2000 illustrate desirability of keeping the basket relatively small to limit costs and complexity.
  - A larger basket would be less stable over time and adding currencies with small weights may offer little benefit.
- Possible approaches:
  - Decide ex ante a maximum size (e.g., 5 or 6 currencies) to keep replication and hedging simple and capture major global currencies, at the expense of case-by-case flexibility.
  - Leave future size open and decide on addition versus replacement on a case-by-case basis, potentially with a minimum weight threshold for inclusion.
- Staff view:
  - Merit in not prejudging future size; retain flexibility to adjust the number of SDR basket currencies over time while guided by principles of stability and representativeness and keeping the basket relatively small to avoid excessive costs and complexity.

*Source: _092311 - 37. PDF (canonical URL as provided in source metadata).*

### 54.       This paper responds to the request by the Executive Board to review several

### _092311 - 54.       This paper responds to the request by the Executive Board to review several

### Purpose and scope
- Reviews aspects of SDR valuation and addresses the IMFC and G-20 call for a criteria-based path to broaden the composition of the SDR basket.
- Explores whether to:
  - Maintain the current requirement that a currency be "freely usable" (FU) for SDR basket entry; or
  - Replace it with a new criterion tailored to the reserve asset characteristics of the SDR (RAC).
- Discusses potential indicators under both approaches, the export criterion, and the limit on number of currencies in the SDR basket.

### Review of the Freely Usable (FU) criterion
- Notes FU concept is set out in the Articles of Agreement and was added as a formal SDR basket criterion in 2000.
- Clarifies indicators that could be used to assess a freely usable currency, taking into account market structure and data availability developments since the late 1970s.
- Raises questions for Directors on whether proposed indicators capture the twin elements of "wide use" and "wide trading" adequately.

### Proposed Reserve Asset Criterion (RAC) alternative
- Develops a possible alternative tailored explicitly to reserve asset characteristics of the SDR.
- Discusses advantages and limitations of replacing the FU criterion with the RAC.
- Compares possible indicators for RAC with those for FU.
- Seeks Directors' views on the specific characteristics and proposed indicators for a RAC.

### Scenario analysis: implications for broadening the SDR basket
- Scenarios illustrate medium-term evolution of selected indicators for FU and RAC criteria using historical trends.
- Three indicators modeled where broader data exist:
  1. Global foreign exchange turnover (common to FU and RAC).
  2. Activity in derivatives markets (RAC indicator).
  3. Cross-border issuance of debt securities (FU indicator).
- Two methodologies:
  - Methodology 1: Project 2015 value using average growth rates over 2004–10 (shows trend continuation).
  - Methodology 2: For top-ten exporters, compute growth required to reach a target share (target = fourth- or fifth-ranked currency in 2010) given projected global indicator/GDP ratios and WEO GDP projections.
- Key scenario findings:
  - Both FU and RAC options expected to safeguard reserve asset characteristics of the SDR.
  - Inertia and network externalities imply meeting the RAC criterion may be challenging but possibly achievable for some currencies within a shorter time-period.
  - Methodology 1 results suggest potential for considerable change in relative ranking of currencies; several emerging market currencies may move toward top distribution for modeled indicators.
  - Methodology 2 results vary by indicator and target:
    - For FX turnover, if benchmark is the fifth-ranked currency, some top-ten exporter currencies would require very rapid growth; in Scenario 2, two emerging market currencies would require annual growth to exceed 50 percent (Appendix Table I4).
    - If benchmark is the fourth-ranked currency, required growth rates would be higher (around 70 percent annually).
    - For derivatives activity, required growths are similar to FX turnover results.
    - For international debt securities (debt issuance), required growth for two emerging market currencies is around 100 percent, while for developed market currencies it's less than 10 percent.
  - Caveats: exercises are mechanistic, rely on backward-looking growth rates and assumed indicator/global GDP ratios, do not account for changing required entry thresholds, and cannot capture second-round macroeconomic effects from rapid shifts in currency use.

### Exports criterion and number of currencies
- Suggests advantages to maintaining the exports criterion to ensure representativeness and continuity.
- Regarding number of currencies in the SDR basket: merits in not pre-judging the number at this time.
- Seeks Directors' views on:
  - Continued role for a size-related criterion.
  - Maintaining the existing exports criterion given ongoing weaknesses in financial accounts data.
  - Augmenting the exports criterion with data on financial inflows once financial accounts data weaknesses are addressed.
  - Efforts to address data issues "as expeditiously as practical."
  - Whether it is desirable not to pre-judge the future number of currencies in the basket.

### Selected empirical highlights from appendices (indicative numbers preserved)
- Appendix Table 1 (COFER): Percent reporting countries holding more than 5 percent of reserves in each currency (presented in table form in source).
- Appendix Table 2 (Average daily FX spreads vs. US dollar in New York, percent of ask price; data shown through July 28, 2011):
  - Euro 2001-2005: 0.0288; 2006-2010: 0.0161; 2011: 0.0036
  - Japanese yen 2001-2005: 0.0319; 2006-2010: 0.0130; 2011: 0.0059
  - Chinese renminbi 2001-2005: 0.0206; 2006-2010: 0.0172; 2011: 0.0276
  - (Full table contained in source.)
- Appendix Table 3 (OTC derivatives currency composition, levels in billions of US dollars and shares percent):
  - Total levels and shares for All Currencies: 2001-2005 Levels 5,424.5 Shares 100.0; 2010 Levels 17,090.8 Shares 100.0
  - US dollar levels and shares across periods: 2001-2005 2,031.0 (37.4); 2006-2010 6,439.1 (44.5); 2009 6,177.8 (38.4); 2010 7,149.3 (41.8)
  - Euro levels and shares across periods: 2001-2005 2,222.3 (41.0); 2006-2010 4,974.0 (34.3); 2009 6,504.5 (40.4); 2010 6,270.3 (36.7)
  - (Full table contained in source.)
- Appendix Tables I1–I3 (Methodology 1 projections to 2015 for FX turnover, derivatives, and international debt securities):
  - Appendix Table I1 (FX turnover projections to 2015, billions of US dollars and percent shares):
    - All Currencies: 2004 1,773.3; 2010 3,981.0; Annual growth 14.4 percent; Projected 2015 8,220.5; Percent 100
    - US dollar: 2004 786.5; 2010 1,689.0; Annual growth 13.6 percent; Projected 2015 3,193.5; Percent 42.4; share 38.8
    - Chinese renminbi: 2004 0.9; 2010 17.1; Annual growth 64.3 percent; Projected 2015 205.1; Percent 0.4; share 2.5
    - (Full table contained in source.)
  - Appendix Table I2 (Derivatives projections to 2015, billions of US dollars and percent shares):
    - All Currencies: 2004 1,152; 2010 2,488; Annual growth 13.7 percent; Projected 2015 5,217; Percent 100
    - US dollar: 2004 522.2; 2010 1,094.5; Annual growth 13.1 percent; Projected 2015 2,027.7; Percent 44.0; share 38.9
    - Chinese renminbi: 2004 0.4; 2010 13.1; Annual growth 78.1 percent; Projected 2015 234.0; Percent 0.5; share 4.5
    - (Full table contained in source.)
  - Appendix Table I3 (International debt securities projections to 2015, billions of US dollars and percent shares):
    - All Currencies: 2004 13,934; 2010 27,674; Annual growth 12.1 percent; Projected 2015 50,250; Percent 100
    - Euro: 2004 6,528.3; 2010 12,173.6; Annual growth 10.9 percent; Projected 2015 20,461.4; Percent 44.0; share 40.7
    - US dollar: 2004 5,095.3; 2010 10,843.7; Annual growth 13.4 percent; Projected 2015 20,347.9; Percent 39.2; share 40.5
    - Chinese renminbi: 2004 1.5; 2010 19.3; Annual growth 53.0 percent; Projected 2015 161.6; Percent 0.1; share 0.3
    - (Full table contained in source.)
- Appendix Table I4 (Methodology 2: Annual growth in FX turnover required to reach benchmark in 2015; benchmark = fifth-ranked currency unless otherwise noted):
  - For the Chinese renminbi: Scenario 1 required annual growth 71.2 percent; Scenario 2 required 64.3 percent; Scenario 3 required 77.1 percent.
  - For the Russian rouble: Scenario 1 69.6 percent; Scenario 2 62.8 percent; Scenario 3 75.5 percent.
  - For the Canadian dollar: Scenario 1 19.1 percent; Scenario 2 14.3 percent; Scenario 3 23.2 percent.
  - Memorandum projected FX turnover (percent of GDP of issuing country) for 2015: US dollar 11.5; Euro 6.4; Japanese yen 6.9; Pound sterling 11.4; Australian dollar 12.2.
  - Ratio of global FX turnover to global GDP in 2015 assumed: Scenario 1 = 7.8 percent; Scenario 2 = 6.3 percent; Scenario 3 = 9.2 percent.
  - (Full table contained in source.)

### Director discussion points (as posed in the paper)
- Do Directors agree that broad principles that guided SDR valuation in the past still remain valid?
- Views on maintaining the existing FU criterion versus adopting an alternative RAC criterion.
- Do proposed FU indicators capture "wide use" and "wide trading"?
- Views on the merits and specific characteristics of a RAC and its proposed indicators.
- Continued role for a size-related criterion; whether to maintain the existing exports criterion given financial accounts data weaknesses; whether to augment exports criterion with financial inflow data once data weaknesses are addressed; and the pace of efforts to address data issues.
- Views on the number of currencies in the SDR basket and whether it is desirable not to pre-judge the future number.

*Source: IMF staff paper (content as provided in the supplied excerpt).*

### Appendix Table I5. Illustrative Scenarios: Derivative Transactions (Methodology 2)

### Appendix Table I5. Illustrative Scenarios: Derivative Transactions (Methodology 2)

### Methodology and key assumptions
- Source: Staff Calculations.
- Benchmark definition and displacement assumption:
  - It is assumed that the benchmark is reached by displacing SDR basket currencies only; all other currencies maintain the shares of foreign exchange derivatives observed in 2010.
  - The benchmark was defined as the fourth or fifth ranked currency's share in 2010.
- Scenario definitions:
  - Scenario 1: assumes the 2004 - 2010 average annual change in the share of global foreign exchange derivatives to global GDP.
  - Scenario 2: assumes the share of global foreign exchange derivatives to global GDP observed in 2010.
  - Scenario 3: assumes twice the annual change used in Scenario 1.
- Ratio of global foreign exchange derivatives to global GDP in 2015:
  - Scenario 1: 5 percent
  - Scenario 2: 4 percent
  - Scenario 3: 6 percent
- Data on World GDP are from WEO.
- Notes:
  - Results reported are based on the fifth ranking currency. When the benchmark is the fourth currency, growth rates are correspondingly higher (example provided in note 2).
  - Note 3 clarifies entries refer to the fifth ranked currency.

### Scenario results — Annual growth required to reach benchmark in 2015 (percent)
- Annual growth of Foreign Exchange Derivatives required to reach benchmark in 2015 (1/) — by currency and scenario:
  - Canadian dollar: Scenario 1 = 19.7; Scenario 2 = 14.4; Scenario 3 = 24.3
  - Chinese renminbi: Scenario 1 = 65.6; Scenario 2 = 58.2; Scenario 3 = 71.9
  - Korean won: Scenario 1 = 52.8; Scenario 2 = 46.0; Scenario 3 = 58.6
  - Russian rouble: Scenario 1 = 79.0; Scenario 2 = 71.0; Scenario 3 = 85.8
  - Singapore dollar: Scenario 1 = 51.6; Scenario 2 = 44.8; Scenario 3 = 57.3
  - Swiss franc: Scenario 1 = 15.1; Scenario 2 = 10.0; Scenario 3 = 19.5

### Projected volume of Foreign Exchange Derivatives (percent of GDP of issuing country)
- 2010 (observed):
  - Canadian dollar: 4.2
  - Chinese renminbi: 0.2
  - Korean won: 1.9
  - Russian rouble: 0.6
  - Singapore dollar: 9.2
  - Swiss franc: 15.4
- 2015 (projected under scenarios):
  - Canadian dollar: Scenario 1 = 8.2; Scenario 2 = 6.5; Scenario 3 = 9.8
  - Chinese renminbi: Scenario 1 = 1.6; Scenario 2 = 5.1; Scenario 3 = 2.0
  - Korean won: Scenario 1 = 11.0; Scenario 2 = 8.8; Scenario 3 = 13.3
  - Russian rouble: Scenario 1 = 5.6; Scenario 2 = 4.4; Scenario 3 = 6.7
  - Singapore dollar: Scenario 1 = 53.4; Scenario 2 = 42.5; Scenario 3 = 64.4
  - Swiss franc: Scenario 1 = 26.0; Scenario 2 = 20.7; Scenario 3 = 31.3

### Memorandum — Major currencies projected volumes (percent of GDP of issuing country) in 2015
- US dollar: Scenario 1 = 7.5; Scenario 2 = 10.1; Scenario 3 = 8.0; Scenario 4? = 12.1 (table presents as "7.5 10.1 8.0 12.1" under Memorandum — preserve values as listed)
- Euro: 3.5; 4.9; 3.9; 6.0
- Japanese yen: 4.2; 5.9; 4.7; 7.1
- Pound sterling: 6.7; 8.1; 6.5; 9.8
- Australian dollar 3/: 7.7; 9.8; 7.8; 11.8

### Contextual note on ranking sensitivity
- When the benchmark is the fourth currency, growth rates are correspondingly higher; example given:
  - For Scenario 2, growth rates would be 73.2 percent and 87.2 percent for renminbi and rouble, respectively (compared to 58.2 and 71 percent as shown in the table).

---

### Appendix Table I6. Illustrative Scenarios: International Debt Securities (Methodology 2)

### Methodology and key assumptions
- Source: Staff Calculations.
- Benchmark definition and displacement assumption:
  - It is assumed that the benchmark is reached by displacing SDR basket currencies only; all other currencies maintain the shares of international debt securities observed in 2010.
  - The benchmark was defined as the fourth or fifth ranked currency's share in 2010.
- Scenario definitions:
  - Scenario 1: assumes the 2004 - 2010 average annual change in the share of global international debt securities to global GDP.
  - Scenario 2: assumes the share of global international debt securities to global GDP observed in 2010.
  - Scenario 3: assumes twice the annual change used in Scenario 1.
- Ratio of global international debt securities to global GDP in 2015:
  - Scenario 1: 53.1 percent
  - Scenario 2: 44.0 percent
  - Scenario 3: 62.2 percent
- Data on World GDP are from WEO.
- Notes:
  - Results reported are based on the fifth ranking currency. When benchmark is the fourth currency, growth rates are correspondingly higher (example provided in note 2).
  - Note 3 clarifies entries refer to the fifth ranked currency.

### Scenario results — Annual growth required to reach benchmark in 2015 (percent)
- Annual growth of International Debt Securities required to reach benchmark in 2015 (1/) — by currency and scenario:
  - Canadian dollar: Scenario 1 = 14.0; Scenario 2 = 9.8; Scenario 3 = 17.7
  - Chinese renminbi: Scenario 1 = 104.0; Scenario 2 = 96.5; Scenario 3 = 110.6
  - Korean won: Scenario 1 = 224.8; Scenario 2 = 212.9; Scenario 3 = 235.3
  - Russian rouble: Scenario 1 = 111.6; Scenario 2 = 103.8; Scenario 3 = 118.4
  - Singapore dollar: Scenario 1 = 80.4; Scenario 2 = 73.7; Scenario 3 = 86.1
  - Swiss franc: Scenario 1 = 10.4; Scenario 2 = 6.3; Scenario 3 = 13.9

### Projected volume of International Debt Securities (percent of GDP of issuing country)
- 2010 (observed):
  - Canadian dollar: 22.5
  - Chinese renminbi: 0.3
  - Korean won: 0.2
  - Russian rouble: 1.1
  - Singapore dollar: 16.0
  - Swiss franc: 79.5
- 2015 (projected under scenarios):
  - Canadian dollar: Scenario 1 = 34.1; Scenario 2 = 28.3; Scenario 3 = 39.9
  - Chinese renminbi: Scenario 1 = 6.8; Scenario 2 = 5.6; Scenario 3 = 7.9
  - Korean won: Scenario 1 = 46.2; Scenario 2 = 38.3; Scenario 3 = 54.1
  - Russian rouble: Scenario 1 = 23.3; Scenario 2 = 19.3; Scenario 3 = 27.3
  - Singapore dollar: Scenario 1 = 223.6; Scenario 2 = 185.3; Scenario 3 = 261.8
  - Swiss franc: Scenario 1 = 108.9; Scenario 2 = 90.2; Scenario 3 = 127.5

### Memorandum — Major currencies projected volumes (percent of GDP of issuing country) in 2015
- US dollar: Scenario 1 = 74.0; Scenario 2 = 97.7; Scenario 3 = 81.0; Scenario 4? = 114.4 (table presents as "74.0 97.7 81.0 114.4")
- Euro: 99.8; 137.6; 114.1; 161.2
- Japanese yen: 14.3; 20.0; 16.6; 23.4
- Pound sterling: 98.6; 118.4; 98.1; 138.6
- Swiss franc 3/: 79.5; 108.9; 90.2; 127.5

### Contextual note on ranking sensitivity
- When the benchmark is the fourth currency, growth rates are correspondingly higher; example given:
  - For Scenario 2, growth rates would be 123 percent and 131.3 percent for renminbi and rouble, respectively (compared to 96.5 and 103.8 percent as shown in the table).

---

### Appendix II: Data Issues — Summary assessments and indicator availability

### General data availability points
- Data availability is key in determining indicators used to assess freely usable and proposed reserve asset criteria.
- Main gaps:
  - Limited currency coverage of COFER (currency composition of foreign exchange reserves).
  - Limited BIS data currency coverage on international banking liabilities and OTC derivative amounts outstanding.
- Board and G-20 actions:
  - Board broadly supported efforts to expand currency and country coverage of COFER, considering reporting burdens.
  - The Board and G-20 have requested enhancements in BIS financial data (Data Gap Initiative); unclear whether this includes greater currency data coverage.
- BIS foreign exchange market turnover data are published every three years in Triennial Reviews — a relatively low frequency.
- Interim approach:
  - Until data limitations are rectified, reasonable, comparable proxies reflecting the underlying concept could be considered.

### Assessment by indicator

- Global foreign exchange market turnover: spot and derivative transactions
  - Definition: gross value of all deals concluded (during the month of April), measured as nominal/notional amount of contracts.
  - Data source: BIS global triennial central bank survey of foreign exchange and derivatives market activity; includes spot and derivative transactions—turnover by currency pair, outright forwards, foreign exchange swaps, currency options, and currency swaps.
  - 2010 triennial survey:
    - Conducted in April and June 2010.
    - Participating central banks collected data from about 4,000 reporting financial institutions.
    - April 2010 Survey: 53 central banks and monetary authorities participated, collecting data from about 1,300 dealers on turnover in foreign exchange instruments and OTC interest rate derivatives.
    - End-June: data collected in 42 countries on outstanding notional amounts and gross market values of foreign exchange, interest rate, equity, commodity, credit (including credit default swaps contracts) and other OTC derivatives instruments.
  - Assessment:
    - Very comprehensive and reliable data.
    - Main limitation: availability at low frequency (every three years only).

- Foreign exchange OTC derivatives
  - BIS publishes semiannual statistics on OTC derivatives markets in the G-10 countries and Switzerland, including notional amounts outstanding and gross market values of foreign exchange OTC derivatives (forwards, swaps, and options).
  - Data source: Semiannual OTC derivatives statistics, Tables 20B and 21B.
  - Assessment:
    - Comprehensive data.
    - Limitation: limited currency breakdown used to report composition of foreign exchange OTC derivatives — currency composition identified for thirteen currencies, mostly issued by developed economies.

- International banking liabilities
  - BIS publishes quarterly data on international banking liabilities (liability positions denominated in any currency to non-residents plus liabilities in foreign currency to domestic residents).
  - Data compiled from information reported by central banks and monetary authorities from 43 countries and international banking centers.
  - Data source: BIS locational banking statistics, Table 5A.
  - Assessment:
    - High quality data, with high frequency.
    - From SDR valuation perspective, two limitations:
      - (i) For the euro area, data do not adjust for intra-euro transactions between member countries (do not exclude banking liabilities denominated in euro issued in one member country and purchased by a resident of another member country).
      - (ii) Limited currency breakdown used to report composition of reporting banks liabilities to official monetary authorities and other holders of foreign exchange reserves; currency composition identified for only five currencies: the US dollar, the euro, the pound sterling, the Japanese yen, and the Swiss franc.

- International debt securities
  - BIS publishes quarterly data on international debt securities.
  - Definition:
    - (i) bonds and notes and money market instruments issued internationally, which include all foreign currency issues in a given country, by both residents and non-residents; and
    - (ii) all domestic currency issues launched in the domestic market by non-residents.
    - Additionally, domestic currency issues in the domestic market by residents are considered international issues if specifically targeted at non-resident investors.
  - Data compilation:
    - Data on about 165,000 international bond issues and 870,000 international notes and money market instruments are compiled by the BIS from various national, market, and institutional data sources (Dealogic, Thomson Financial Securities Data, market service division of the International Capital Market Association, Bank of England, Euroclear).
  - Data source: BIS Securities Statistics, Tables 13A and 13B (international money market instruments and bonds and notes).
  - Assessment:
    - High quality data, with high frequency.
    - Limitation: for the euro area, data do not exclude debt securities denominated in euro that are issued in one member country and purchased by a resident of another member country.

- Official Reserve Holdings (COFER)
  - IMF publishes aggregated country group COFER data quarterly.
  - Currencies identified in COFER surveys: the U.S. dollar, the euro, pound sterling, the Japanese yen, the Swiss franc, and "claims in other currencies."
  - Definition used: official foreign exchange reserves as outlined in the sixth edition of the IMF‘s Balance of Payments and International Investment Position Manual; same as used in IMF‘s International Financial Statistics (IFS).
  - COFER aggregates published for: world, advanced economies, and emerging and developing economies.
  - Assessment:
    - COFER provides the best available data on currency composition of reserves.
    - Limitations from SDR Review perspective:
      - Large and increasing importance of Unallocated Reserves (difference between allocated reserves in COFER and total reserves reported to IFS), which by end of first quarter of 2011 represented about 45 percent of total reserves.
      - Limited currency breakdown used to report composition of official foreign exchange reserves.
    - Initiatives underway to attempt to ameliorate the two limitations.
    - Survey reporting instruction: monetary authorities report foreign currency reserves holdings consistent with BPM6 statistical definition (see paragraph 6.72).
      - This means total foreign currency holdings of monetary authorities are not considered; only foreign exchange reserve assets per BPM6 are reported.
      - For Reserve Asset Criterion (RAC) purposes, other foreign currency holdings of monetary authorities could be considered as a supplementary indicator.

*Source: Appendix Table I5 and I6, Staff Calculations, and Appendix II: Data Issues (extracted content).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2011/_092311.pdf_
