## _062615a - 2014. The oil trade balance rose to

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_062615a - 2014. The oil trade balance rose to](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2015/_062615a.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2015/_062615a.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2015/_062615a.pdf.json)

---

### Canada — Oil trade balance and current account
- Oil trade balance rose to 3.5 percent of GDP in 2014, up from 2.9 percent in 2013.
- Projection: oil trade balance projected to fall to 2.5 percent of GDP in 2015.
- Risk/offsets for 2015:
  - Persistently low oil prices could worsen the current account balance.
  - A rebound in non-energy exports on the back of a weaker currency and strong US demand could mitigate this effect.

### Canada — Savings-Investment (S-I) balance and CA gap
- Current account deterioration was consistent with worsening of the general government (S-I) balance.
- Since 2010, government savings has been growing and the gap has shrunk.
- EBA estimates a CA gap of -2 percent of GDP for 2014 (from -3.4 percent of GDP for 2013), but staff view this likely overstates desirable external adjustment.
- Staff-assessed current account gap: range of 0 to -1.5 percent of GDP (accounting for cyclical position and oil trade/terms-of-trade measurement).

### Canada — Real exchange rate (REER)
- REER movements:
  - Appreciated by 31 percent between 2000 and 2011.
  - Depreciated by 6 percent from 2013 to 2014.
  - Following a sharp drop in energy prices in 2014Q4, depreciated a further 4 percent through May 2015.
  - REER depreciated by about 2 percent (q-o-q) in 2014Q4.
- Assessment:
  - EBA REER index model estimates REER gap of -0.5 percent for 2014 (against 10 percent for 2013).
  - Staff assessment: 0 to 5 percent overvaluation for 2014 (down from 5 to 10 percent in July 2014 Pilot ESR).

### Canada — Capital and financial accounts; FX intervention and reserves
- Financing: CA deficit financed primarily by net portfolio inflows attracted by strong growth prospects, heavy oil and gas investment, and relatively high interest rates.
- Policy/assessment:
  - Canada has a fully open capital account.
  - Vulnerabilities limited by credible floating exchange rate and strong fiscal position.
  - Bank of Canada has limited reserves but standing swap arrangements with the Federal Reserve and four other major central banks; no FX intervention since September 1998 (except internationally concerted actions).
  - Policies in this area judged appropriate.

### Canada — Technical background notes (selected)
- Two reasons EBA may overestimate CA norm:
  - Uses output gap relative to world rather than relative to the United States, understating Canada’s cyclical strength.
  - Uses WEO global oil prices rather than lower market prices for Canadian heavy crude, overstating trade balance.
- EBA REER level model estimates gap at -10.6 percent, mostly due to residual (-10.1 percent).

### China — Current account, REER, capital accounts, and reserves
- Current account:
  - CA was 2.1 percent of GDP in 2014 (2.5 percent of GDP cyclically adjusted).
  - Gross national saving ~50 percent of GDP.
  - 2015: ToT gains from lower commodity prices—estimated at about 1 percent of GDP—expected to increase CA surplus to 3.0 percent of GDP.
  - Staff assessment: CA in 2014 is 1-3 percent of GDP stronger than implied by fundamentals and desirable policies; uncertainty justifies a 2 percent range for the gap.
  - Identified policy gaps contribution: 1.8 percent of GDP (versus 2.2 percent in 2013).
- REER:
  - REER appreciating trend since 2005; gained average of 5 percent a year during 2006–14 (3 percent in 2014).
  - By May 2015, REER appreciated by 11 percent against the 2014 average.
  - RMB appreciated 16 percent vs euro, 13 percent vs yen, and 0.5 percent vs USD (by May 2015).
  - Assessment: 2014 average REER assessed 3-12 percent below level consistent with fundamentals and desirable policies; subsequent sizable appreciation suggests exchange rate no longer undervalued.
- Capital and financial accounts:
  - Continued liberalization, but broad-based restrictions remain (external borrowing regulated; portfolio flows channeled through quota/approval programs).
  - Opening capital account likely to lead to sizable gross capital outflows over medium term.
- FX intervention and reserves:
  - BOP data: accumulation of USD 119 billion in 2014, USD 314 billion less than 2013.
  - Sales of reserves: USD 29 billion in 2014 Q4 and USD 80 billion in 2015 Q1.
  - Reserves: about 149 percent of IMF composite metric unadjusted for capital controls at end-2014 (down from 160 percent in 2013); 238 percent relative to metric adjusted for capital controls (down from 254 percent in 2013).
  - Further accumulation unnecessary from reserve adequacy perspective under either metric.

### China — Technical notes (selected)
- Total CA gap from EBA is 2.5 percent of GDP for 2014 (up from 1.5 percent in 2013) due to change in residual.
- Staff places more weight on identified policy gaps; contribution of policy gaps 1.8 percent of GDP; actual CA 2.1 percent of GDP; cyclically adjusted CA 2.5 percent of GDP.

### Indonesia — CA norm, REER, capital flows, and reserves
- CA norm: staff believes a CA norm of -0.5 to -2.5 percent of GDP appropriate; implies CA gap range ~0 to -2 percent of GDP for 2014.
- REER:
  - On average, REER depreciated by about 6 percent in 2014 vs 2013 average.
  - REER appreciated in late 2014 due to temporary inflation from reduction in domestic fuel subsidies.
  - REER steadied in Q1 2015, resulting in a 4 percent appreciation in May 2015 vs 2014 average.
  - EBA results suggest undervaluation of about 8 and 10 percent (level and index respectively); staff assesses REER overvalued by 0 to 10 percent in 2014.
- Capital and financial accounts:
  - Gross external financing requirement expected ~10 percent of GDP in 2015; amortization about 7 percent of GDP.
  - Net direct investment (FDI) and new borrowing projected at 2.1 percent and 8.8 percent of GDP, respectively.
  - Net and gross flows appear sustainable but could reverse with large shocks.
  - Policy priorities: strengthen fiscal position; keep inflation in check; ease supply bottlenecks.
- Reserves and FX:
  - As of end-May 2015, reserves stood at US$110.8 billion (equal to 143 percent of IMF’s reserve adequacy metric—assuming a floating exchange rate—and about 6.6 months of prospective imports of goods and services).
  - Authorities have contingencies and swap lines equivalent to around US$76 billion.
  - Assessment: current reserve level should be sufficient to absorb most shocks; intervention should smooth volatility while allowing exchange rate adjustment.

### Italy — External position, CA, REER, and policy responses
- NIIP and external balance:
  - NIIP net liabilities of 28 percent of GDP versus 7 percent at end 2000; gross assets and liabilities 136 and 164 percent of GDP respectively.
  - External debt represents about ¾ of gross external liabilities; half owed by public sector.
  - 2014 CA surplus 1.9 percent of GDP (up from 1 percent in 2013); trade surplus >3 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - 2015 CA surplus projected 2.3 percent of GDP.
- Assessment:
  - External sustainability not a major concern given modest CA surpluses, but vulnerability to financial contagion remains.
  - Staff assesses a CA gap of -1.5 to 0 percent of GDP for 2014.
- REER:
  - REER depreciated relative to 2014 average by about 5 percent as of May 2015.
  - EBA models suggest 2014 REER overvaluation: 3 percent (Index) and 6½ percent (Level); CA regression yields about 5 percent overvaluation.
  - Staff: a real effective depreciation of 0-10 percent would support adjustment.
- Policy responses:
  - Implement structural reforms to improve competitiveness and boost potential growth.
  - Continue medium-term fiscal consolidation to close competitiveness gap and maintain investor confidence.

### Japan — NIIP, CA, REER, and policy guidance
- NIIP trajectory:
  - NIIP nearly doubled to close to 70 percent of GDP in 2013 (assets: 166 percent; liabilities: 98 percent).
  - Projected to rise toward 75 percent with higher CA surpluses in medium term.
- Current account:
  - 2014 CA surplus fell to 0.5 percent of GDP.
  - 2015 surplus expected to rise to 2 percent of GDP due to lower oil prices improving oil balance (from –3.6 percent of GDP in 2014 to -2.5 percent projected in 2015).
  - Staff underlying cyclically-adjusted CA for 2014: 2-2 ¼ percent of GDP.
  - Staff norm adjustment: EBA 3.1 percent of GDP; staff adjust to norm of 1 ¼ to 2 percent of GDP.
- REER:
  - REER depreciated 5 ¾ percent between 2013 and 2014; further 7 percent through May 2015 vs 2014 average.
  - EBA Level model estimates 2014 average REER 21 percent weaker; Index model 26 percent weaker (large unexplained residual).
  - Staff assessment: 2014 REER gap midpoint -5 percent with range 0 to -10 percent.
- Policy guidance:
  - Forceful structural reforms to raise growth and lift prices; fiscal consolidation anchored by concrete medium-term plan.

### Korea — NIIP, CA, REER, capital flows, and policies
- NIIP: increased from -2.9 percent of GDP in 2013 to 5.8 percent in 2014.
- Net external debt: -16.7 percent of GDP in 2014.
- Current account:
  - CA in 2014 around 6¼ percent of GDP.
  - EBA regression model: 2014 CA about 6¼ percentage points of GDP above cyclically-adjusted norm of 0.9 percent.
  - Staff assessment: 2014 CA gap at 2½ to 5 percent of GDP after adjustments.
- REER:
  - Won appreciated by 6 percent in 2014 vs 2013 average; REER as of May 2015 appreciated by 3 percent from 2014 average.
  - Staff assesses 2014 REER to be 5 to 13 percent weaker than level consistent with fundamentals and policies.
- Capital flows and reserves:
  - Net and gross flows appear sustainable; reserves broadly stable around 130 percent of IMF composite reserve adequacy metric.
  - Recommendation: intervention limited to smoothing excessive volatility; exchange rate market-determined.

### Malaysia — External position, CA, REER, and policy recommendations
- NIIP and positions:
  - NIIP 4.6 percent of GDP at end 2013.
  - Assets about 133 percent of GDP in 2013; gross liabilities about 138 percent of GDP at end 2013.
  - Total external debt 68 percent of GDP at end of 2014; 49 percent short-term debt; foreign-currency debt 41 percent of GDP.
- Current account:
  - CA surplus declined to 4.6 percent of GDP in 2014 (down 5 percentage points since 2011).
  - LNG exports represent 9 percent of total exports.
  - Likely income loss of lower oil prices at constant volumes estimated at 2 percent of GDP; 2015 CA projected at 2.1 percent of GDP.
  - Staff assesses CA norm 1.5 percent of GDP and CA gap 3.9 percent of GDP (±1 percent) in 2014.
- REER:
  - Average REER in 2014 similar to 2013; by May 2015 REER depreciation vs 2014 average was 3 percent; ringgit depreciated 9 percent vs USD.
  - EBA REER index regression estimates REER 21 percent below warranted level (mostly unexplained residual); level REER 15 percent undervaluation.
  - Staff assessment REER undervaluation for 2014: 13 percent (±5 percent).
- Capital flows and reserves:
  - Malaysia typically records net capital outflows; net FDI abroad increased to 4.8 percent of GDP in 2014; net FDI outflows 1.7 percent of GDP.
  - Reserves at end-December 2014 ~83 percent of IMF composite reserve adequacy metric; covered 81 percent and 27 percent of short-term external debt and broad money, respectively.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Strengthen social safety nets and remove investment bottlenecks to moderate CA surplus.

### Netherlands — CA, REER, and capital accounts
- CA gap:
  - Staff assesses CA gap smaller than EBA due to country-specific factors (fully funded pension system, household deleveraging, FDI income measurement).
  - Staff assessment of CA gap in range 0-3 percent of GDP.
- REER:
  - ULC and CPI-based REER depreciated by 2.1 and 1.7 percent respectively in 2014.
  - As of April–May 2015, REER depreciated by 5½ percent from 2014 average.
  - Staff assesses REER remained undervalued by around 5 percent within range 0-10 percent.
- Capital and reserves:
  - Net FDI and portfolio outflows dominate financial account; euro is a global reserve currency.
  - Reserves held by Euro area typically low relative to standard metrics; currency free floating.

### Poland — NIIP, CA, REER, and policy guidance
- NIIP: large negative NIIP stabilized at 60 percent of GDP in 2014 (assets 42 percent; liabilities 103 percent).
- CA:
  - CA deficit declined from ~5 percent of GDP in 2010-11 to 1.4 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - CA projected to improve marginally in 2015.
  - Staff CA gap centered on +0.5 (±1) percent of GDP for 2014.
- REER:
  - REER appreciated 0.8 percent in 2014 vs 2013; depreciated 2 percent as of May 2015.
  - EBA models suggest undervaluation between 2 and 11 percent; staff assesses REER close to level consistent with fundamentals, centered on -2.5 with range -7.5 to +2.5.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Modest fiscal consolidation; vigilance on bank funding and FX liquidity; modest additional reserve accumulation appropriate.

### Russia — NIIP, CA, REER, reserves, and policy responses
- NIIP and external debt:
  - NIIP positive at end-December 2014 at about 18 percent of GDP (up from 6 percent in 2013); gross assets 70 percent; liabilities 52 percent; total external debt 36 percent of GDP.
- Current account:
  - CA improved to 3.1 percent in 2014 and 4.5 percent in 2015.
  - Staff assesses 2014 CA gap between -3 to 0 percent of GDP.
  - Staff calls for higher savings; fiscal tightening recommended to rebuild buffers and counter Dutch disease.
- REER:
  - REER depreciated 8 percent between 2013 and 2014, and a further 2 percent through May 2015 vs 2014 average.
  - EBA CA regression suggests 2014 average REER 7 percent overvalued; REER level regression 10 percent undervalued; index approach 13 percent undervalued (index discarded for commodity exporters).
  - Staff assesses REER overvaluation 0-10 percent on average during 2014; recent depreciation moved REER closer to fundamentals.
- Reserves and capital flows:
  - CBR intervened in large volumes in 2014 then moved to floating regime; reserves above 150 percent of IMF composite reserve adequacy metric.
  - Recommendation: continue accumulation of fiscal savings in oil funds; small regular reserve purchases justified; large FX interventions limited to market distress.

### Saudi Arabia — External balance, CA, REER, and policy guidance
- External assets substantial at estimated 140 percent of GDP mid-2014; total external liabilities 36 percent of GDP.
- NIIP/GDP ratio between 85 and 105 percent during 2007–mid-2014.
- 2014 CA surplus narrowed to 10.9 percent of GDP (from 18.2 percent in 2013); oil export revenues decline by 14 percent of GDP in 2015 projecting a small CA deficit in 2015.
- REER: Riyal pegged to USD at 3.75 since 1986; REER appreciated by 16 percent over past year and ~20 percent above decade average.
- Assessment and guidance:
  - External balance sheet very strong; external adjustment must be driven by fiscal adjustment rather than exchange rate.
  - Fiscal consolidation needed to close CA gap; reduce current spending and increase non-tax revenues; ensure efficient government investment.

### Singapore — NIIP, CA, REER, reserves, and assessment
- NIIP: 182 percent of GDP at end-2014.
- CA: surplus 19.1 percent of GDP in 2014; expected CA increase in 2015 by about 1-1.5 percent of GDP due to oil price decline.
- Staff assesses 2014 CA stronger than consistent with fundamentals by 2 to 8 percent of GDP.
- REER:
  - Appreciated 26 percent since 2005; depreciated 0.2 percent in 2014; 0.5 percent lower as of May 2015 vs 2014 average.
  - REER around 4-16 percent weaker than warranted by fundamentals and policies.
- Reserves:
  - Official reserves ~87 percent of GDP in 2014; official reserves declined by 10 percent (USD 28.5 billion) since mid-2014.
  - Assessment: current reserve levels adequate; no case for further accumulation for precautionary purposes.

### South Africa — External position, CA, REER, risks, and policy recommendations
- External liabilities and NIIP:
  - Gross external debt increased to 41 percent of GDP in 2014 (from 26 percent in 2008); 10 percent of GDP short-term.
  - Gross external liabilities 130 percent of GDP at end-2014; net IIP -11.5 percent of GDP at end-2014.
- Current account:
  - CA deficit narrowed to 5.4 percent of GDP in 2014 (from 5.8 percent in 2013); projected to narrow to 4.8 percent in 2015.
  - EBA estimates CA norm -1.9 percent of GDP and gap -3.5 percent of GDP for 2014.
  - Staff assesses CA 1½ to 3½ percentage points weaker than implied by fundamentals and desirable policies in 2014.
- REER:
  - CPI-based REER depreciated by 21 percent since end-2010; REER little changed from 2014 average as of May 2015.
  - Staff assesses REER overvaluation of 5-20 percent for 2014.
- Risks and recommendations:
  - Large gross external liabilities pose risks mitigated by external assets.
  - Policy priorities: improve energy availability; implement National Development Plan; labor and product market reforms; fiscal consolidation; reserve build-up.

### United Kingdom — NIIP, CA, REER, capital flows, and policy recommendations
- NIIP and external position:
  - NIIP shows declining external position from 2011; official NIIP projected to stabilize around -45 percent by 2020 in staff projections; gross assets/liabilities more than 500 percent of GDP.
  - External position in 2014 weaker than implied by fundamentals and desirable policies.
- Current account:
  - CA deteriorated from -3 to -5½ percent of GDP during recovery; staff assesses 2014 cyclically-adjusted CA 1½ -3½ percent weaker than CA norm.
  - EBA CA regression approach estimates CA gap around -4.5 percent of GDP for 2014.
- REER:
  - REER 8 percent more appreciated in 2014 vs 2013; as of May 2015 REER strengthened by 6.5 percent from 2014 average.
  - Staff assesses 2014 REER 5–15 percent above level consistent with fundamentals and desirable policies.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Rebalance toward private-sector led demand; continue fiscal consolidation within medium-term framework; maintain accommodative monetary policy; structural reforms to boost productivity and competitiveness.

### United States — NIIP, CA, REER, capital flows, and policy recommendations
- NIIP:
  - NIIP declined from -18.7 percent of GDP in 2010 to -34.5 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - Under staff baseline, U.S. NIIP projected to deteriorate by ~10 percentage points of GDP over next five years.
- Current account:
  - CA deficit narrowed to 2.4 percent of GDP in 2014 from pre-crisis highs.
  - EBA model estimates cyclically-adjusted CA gap -1.2 percent of GDP for 2014.
  - Staff view: 2014 cyclically-adjusted CA between 0 and 1 ¼ percent weaker than level implied by fundamentals and desirable policies.
- REER:
  - REER appreciated in 2014 by about 2 percent vs 2013; appreciated >6 percent in H2 2014; as of May 2015 REER ~9 percent above 2014 average.
  - Staff assesses 2014 average REER overvalued within range 0 to 10 percent.
- Capital and reserves:
  - Net financial outflows ~0.8 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - Fully open capital account; vulnerabilities limited by dollar’s reserve currency role.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Medium-term fiscal consolidation targeting general government primary surplus ~¾ percent of GDP (federal government primary surplus ~1 percent of GDP).
  - Structural policies to raise productivity and labor force growth; exploit unconventional energy production benefits.

*Italic: Source: IMF content unit _062615a (excerpts and staff assessments).*

### 2014. The oil trade balance rose to

### _062615a - 2014. The oil trade balance rose to

### Oil trade balance and current account
- The oil trade balance rose to 3.5 percent of GDP in 2014, up from 2.9 percent in 2013.
- Looking forward to 2015, persistently low oil prices could worsen the current account balance but a rebound in non-energy exports on the back of a weaker currency and strong US demand could mitigate this effect.
- Projection: the oil trade balance is projected to fall to 2.5 percent of GDP in 2015.

### Savings-Investment (S-I) balance
- In terms of the savings-investment (S-I) balance, the current account deterioration was consistent with the worsening of the general government (S-I) balance.
- Since 2010, government savings has been growing and the gap has shrunk.

### Assessment of current account (CA) gap
- The EBA estimates a CA gap of -2 percent of GDP for 2014 (from -3.4 percent of GDP for 2013), but this estimate likely overstates the desirable external adjustment.
- The EBA underestimates the strength of Canada’s cyclical position and overestimates its oil trade balance and terms of trade.
- Accounting for these factors puts the staff-assessed current account gap at a range of 0 to -1.5 percent of GDP.

### Real exchange rate (REER)
Background and recent movement:
- The real effective exchange rate (REER) appreciated by 31 percent between 2000 and 2011 as energy prices soared.
- From 2013 to 2014, the REER depreciated by 6 percent as the interest rate differential with the US narrowed and capital inflows tapered.
- Following a sharp drop in energy prices in 2014Q4, the REER depreciated a further 4 percent through May 2015.
Assessment:
- The EBA REER index model estimates a REER gap of -0.5 percent for 2014 (against 10 percent for 2013).
- This compares with the staff assessment of 0 to 5 percent overvaluation (down from 5 to 10 percent overvaluation reported in the July 2014 Pilot External Sector Report) given the smaller staff-assessed CA gap.

### Capital and financial accounts: flows and policy measures
Background:
- The CA deficit has been financed primarily by net portfolio inflows, attracted by Canada’s strong growth prospects, heavy investment in oil and gas extraction, and relatively high interest rates which made Canada a safe-haven and carry trade destination.
- Until recently, portfolio inflows had added upward pressure on the exchange rate.
Assessment:
- Canada has a fully open capital account.
- Vulnerabilities are limited by a credible commitment to a floating exchange rate and a strong and credible fiscal position.

### FX intervention and reserves level
Background:
- Canada has a free floating exchange rate regime, and the central bank has not intervened in the foreign exchange market since September 1998 (with the exception of participating in internationally concerted interventions for other purposes).
- The Bank of Canada has limited reserves but has standing swap arrangements with the Federal Reserve and four other major central banks (it has not drawn on these swap lines in the past).
Assessment:
- Policies in this area are appropriate to the circumstances of Canada.

### Technical background notes (selected)
- Two reasons why the EBA may have overestimated the CA norm:
  - The model adjusts for the business cycle using Canada’s output gap relative to the world (GDP-weighted average) output gap, while a more relevant measure for Canada is the output gap relative to the United States. Using the U.S as the benchmark would reduce the CA “norm” for Canada because the output gap for the United States is currently larger (more negative) than the world output gap. Canada’s cyclical strength is therefore underestimated by the EBA model.
  - The EBA overestimates Canada’s trade balance by using the WEO global oil prices rather than the lower market price for Canadian oil, particularly, heavy crude oil from western Canada’s oil sands (the lower price reflects lower quality and infrastructure bottlenecks).
- The REER depreciated by about 2 percent (q-o-q) in 2014Q4.
- The EBA REER level model estimates the gap to be -10.6 percent, most of which is due to the residual (-10.1 percent).

### Transition note on China (extracted observations)
- Gross foreign assets were 62 percent of GDP at end-2014 and are dominated by foreign reserves, while gross liabilities were 42 percent of GDP and mainly represent FDI liabilities.
- Net IIP declined to around 20 percent of GDP at end-2014.
- Assessment: The NIIP to GDP ratio is expected to be slightly above 20 percent of GDP over the medium term, with a modest rise of the current account in 2015. Vulnerabilities are low with large foreign exchange reserves and FDI-dominated liabilities.
- Overall Assessment: The external position in 2014 was moderately stronger compared with the level consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policy settings, and the renminbi was moderately undervalued. Since then, substantial appreciation has brought the exchange rate to a level no longer undervalued, and foreign exchange intervention has dropped sharply; nevertheless, the trade surplus has risen and domestic policy gaps remain.
- Potential policy responses: Priorities include creating a more market-based financial system; opening markets to more competition and SOE reform; improving the social safety net; and achieving a flexible, market-based exchange rate.

*Source: IMF content unit _062615a - 2014. The oil trade balance rose to*

### 2.1 percent of GDP in 2014 (2.5 percent of GDP cyclically ad

### China

### Current account (CA) — developments and assessment
- CA was 2.1 percent of GDP in 2014 (2.5 percent of GDP cyclically adjusted).
- Gross national saving has remained around 50 percent of GDP.
- The decline in the CA reflects strong investment growth, REER appreciation, weakness in major advanced economies, and a trend widening of the services deficit (mainly due to strong outbound tourism and education spending).
- In 2015, Terms-of-trade (ToT) gains from lower commodity prices—estimated at about 1 percent of GDP—are expected to increase the CA surplus to 3.0 percent of GDP.
- Assessment:
  - The CA in 2014 is 1-3 percent of GDP stronger than implied by fundamentals and desirable policies.
  - This assessment is unchanged from the last ESR; the actual CA, cyclically adjusted CA, and identified policy gaps are somewhat smaller than last year.
  - Uncertainty about the cyclical adjustment justifies a range of 2 percent for the gap.
  - The CA gap is mainly attributed to low social spending, reserve accumulation, and capital controls.
  - Reforms, if successfully implemented, will lower private saving and reduce the CA gap.

### Real exchange rate (REER) — background and assessment
- Background:
  - REER has been on an appreciating trend since the 2005 exchange rate reform, gaining an average of 5 percent a year during 2006–14 (3 percent in 2014).
  - By May 2015, the REER appreciated by 11 percent against the 2014 average.
  - RMB appreciated against the euro (16 percent) and yen (13 percent); and appreciated 0.5 percent against the USD.
  - China continues to manage closely its exchange rate and conducts intervention on an intermittent basis.
- Assessment:
  - The REER appreciation through 2014 has been broadly consistent with changing fundamentals (especially faster productivity growth than in trading partners).
  - The EBA models and staff judgment, consistent with the CA gap, suggest that the 2014 average REER was 3-12 percent below the level consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies.
  - The subsequent sizable REER appreciation appears to be more than would be suggested by changes in fundamentals (productivity growth and improved ToT), which suggests the exchange rate is no longer undervalued.

### Capital and financial accounts — flows and policy measures
- Background:
  - China continues liberalizing its capital account, but restrictions remain broad-based (external borrowing regulated; portfolio flows primarily channeled through programs that are subject to quotas and approvals).
  - Actual gross flows of FDI and other investments have been sizable.
- Assessment:
  - Over the medium term, a well-sequenced loosening of capital controls that supports domestic financial liberalization would be appropriate.
  - The opening of the capital account is likely to lead to sizable gross capital outflows reflecting domestic savers’ desire for portfolio diversification over the medium term.
  - The adjustment path is hard to predict and could vary depending on prevailing market and economic conditions.

### FX intervention and reserves level
- Background:
  - Intervention declined in 2014, with BOP data suggesting an accumulation of USD 119 billion, USD 314 billion less than 2013.
  - Data suggest minimal intervention in 2014 Q3 and, since then, sales of reserves of USD 29 billion in 2014 Q4 and USD 80 billion in 2015 Q1.
- Assessment:
  - Reserves were at about 149 percent of the IMF’s composite metric unadjusted for capital controls at end-2014 (down from 160 percent in 2013).
  - Relative to the metric adjusted for capital controls, reserves were at 238 percent, down from 254 percent in 2013.
  - Given China’s progress and plans with capital account liberalization, the appropriate metric is shifting toward the unadjusted one; under either metric, further accumulation is unnecessary from a reserve adequacy perspective.

### Technical background notes (selected)
- 1/ The total CA gap from EBA is 2.5 percent of GDP for 2014, up from 1.5 percent of GDP in 2013 due to a change in the residual. The staff assessment puts more weight on the identified policy gaps. The contribution of identified policy gaps is 1.8 percent of GDP (versus 2.2 percent of GDP in 2013), actual CA is 2.1 percent of GDP (versus 1.6 percent of GDP in 2013); and cyclically adjusted CA is 2.5 percent of GDP.
- 2/ A range of 3–12 percent for the REER is consistent with the range of 1–3 percent of GDP for the CA using inverse elasticities of 3-4 (that is, 3-4 percent REER appreciation is equivalent to a 1 percent of GDP decline in the current account surplus). The EBA Index REER model for 2014 data shows a total REER gap of minus 6.5 percent and the contribution of identified policy gaps of minus 7.5 percent, both in the range of 3–12 percent assessed by staff. The EBA Level model estimates a total REER gap 6.8 percent (that is, REER is stronger than the level consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policy settings) and identified policy gaps of minus 3.5 percent; however, that estimate is discarded from consideration as the Level model estimates appear implausible for China.

*Source: Excerpt from IMF country assessment text.*

### 2.6 percent of GDP and a norm of -0.7 percent of GD

### 2.6 percent of GDP and a norm of -0.7 percent of GD

### Current account norm and gap
- Staff believes a CA norm of -0.5 to -2.5 percent of GDP is appropriate, taking uncertainties and Indonesia’s investment needs into account.
- This implies a CA gap range of about 0 to -2 percent of GDP for 2014.
- The CA gap reflects:
  - Domestic policy gaps in social spending.
  - External policy gaps, particularly fiscal deficits in partner countries.
- Note: an earlier estimate of the CA norm was -0.7 percent of GD (as in the title), but staff’s assessed appropriate range is -0.5 to -2.5 percent of GDP.

### Real exchange rate (REER)
Background
- On average, the REER depreciated by about 6 percent in 2014 relative to the 2013 average.
- The REER appreciated in late 2014, reflecting a temporary increase in inflation related to the reduction in domestic fuel price subsidies.
- The REER steadied in the first quarter of 2015, resulting in a 4 percent appreciation in May 2015 relative to the 2014 average.

Assessment
- EBA level and index REER results suggest an undervaluation of about 8 and 10 percent, respectively.
- Using the CA gap assessment above and standard elasticities, staff assesses the REER to be overvalued by 0 to 10 percent in 2014.
- This assessment is consistent with the erosion in Indonesia’s terms of trade and projected falls in oil and gas production over the long run.

### Capital and financial accounts: flows and policy measures
Background
- Indonesia’s gross external financing requirement is expected to be about 10 percent of GDP in 2015, with amortization at about 7 percent of GDP.
- Net direct investment (FDI) and new borrowing are projected at 2.1 percent and 8.8 percent of GDP, respectively.

Assessment
- Net and gross financial flows appear sustainable, but could dissipate or reverse in the event of large domestic or external shocks.
- Policy priorities to help sustain capital inflows in the medium term include:
  - Strengthening the fiscal position.
  - Keeping inflation in check.
  - Easing supply bottlenecks.

### FX intervention and reserves level
Background
- Since mid 2013, Indonesia has had a more flexible exchange rate policy framework.
- Its floating regime has better facilitated adjustments in exchange rates to market conditions.
- As of end-May 2015, reserves stood at US$110.8 billion (equal to 143 percent of IMF’s reserve adequacy metric—assuming a floating exchange rate—and about

*Source: IMF staff analysis, from the provided content unit.*

### 6.6 months of prospective imports of goods and services). In

### _062615a - 6.6 months of prospective imports of goods and services). In

### Reserves, FX intervention, and reserve adequacy
- Authorities have contingencies and swap lines equivalent to around US$76 billion.
- Assessment:
  - Volatile capital flows could cause reserves to decline significantly.
  - The current level of reserves should be sufficient to absorb most shocks, with predetermined drains also manageable.
  - Intervention should aim primarily at smoothing volatility, while allowing the exchange rate to adjust to external shocks.
  - For the euro area: Reserves held by the euro area are typically low relative to standard metrics, but the currency is free floating.
  - For Japan: Reserves are about 25 percent of GDP, on legacy accumulation. There has been no FX intervention in recent years. The exchange rate is free floating. Interventions are isolated (last in 2011) to reduce short-term volatility and disorderly exchange rate movements.

### Italy — Overall assessment and external position
- Background:
  - NIIP has deteriorated since joining the Euro area: net liabilities of 28 percent of GDP versus 7 percent at end 2000.
  - Gross assets and liabilities reached 136 and 164 percent of GDP respectively (39 and 60 percent higher than in 2000).
  - External debt represents about ¾ of gross external liabilities; half of external debt is owed by the public sector.
  - Modest current account surpluses forecast over the medium-term will gradually shrink Italy’s net liability position as a share of GDP.
- Assessment:
  - In light of the current account’s shift into a surplus, overall external sustainability is not a major concern.
  - Italy remains vulnerable to financial contagion given its large stock of government debt and sizable holdings of public and private debt by non-residents.
- Overall Assessment (2014):
  - The external position in 2014 was broadly consistent but likely still weaker than suggested by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policy settings.
  - Developments as of May 2015 point toward some strengthening of the external position due to the depreciation of Italy’s REER.
  - Weak productivity and competitiveness indicators support this assessment.
- Potential policy responses:
  - Implementation of structural reforms to improve competitiveness and boost potential growth.
  - Continued progress in medium-term fiscal consolidation to help close the competitiveness gap and maintain investor confidence.
  - Combined measures expected to support growth and employment over the medium-term.

### Italy — Current account
- Background:
  - CA averaged a deficit of 1½ percent of GDP in the decade after euro adoption.
  - Starting in 2012 moved into balance; by 2014 registered a surplus of 1.9 percent of GDP (up from 1 percent of GDP in 2013).
  - Trade surplus reached more than 3 percent of GDP in 2014 owing to higher exports and subdued imports.
  - 2015 current account surplus projected to rise to 2.3 percent of GDP, reflecting the lower oil bill and euro depreciation.
  - Declining investment accounted for about 60 percent of the improvement in the current account since 2010; higher public and private saving contributed the rest.
- Assessment:
  - EBA model: cyclically-adjusted level stood at 0.7 percent of GDP in 2014, about 1.3 percent of GDP below the norm implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policy settings.
  - Staff assesses a gap of -1.5 to 0 percent of GDP for 2014.

### Italy — Real exchange rate
- Background:
  - Stagnant productivity and rising labor costs have resulted in gradual REER appreciation since joining the Euro area.
  - Appreciation over 2000-2014 exceeded the Euro area average by about 0 to 10 percent, depending on measure; unit labor cost measures show a wider gap.
  - REER depreciated relative to the 2014 average by about 5 percent as of May 2015 due to U.S. dollar strengthening vis-à-vis the euro.
- Assessment:
  - EBA regression methods suggest a 2014 REER overvaluation of 3 percent (EBA Index REER model) and 6½ percent (EBA Level REER model).
  - CA regression method yields an overvaluation of about 5 percent.
  - Staff assessed that a real effective depreciation of 0-10 percent would support further adjustment and address economic imbalances over the medium-term.

### Italy — Capital and financial accounts
- Background:
  - Portfolio and other-investment inflows typically financed the current account deficit and a modest net FDI outflow.
  - 2014 saw a strong return of foreign investment in portfolio securities in the first half of the year, led by investment in government securities.
  - TARGET2 liabilities accumulated by banks over 2011-12 have declined.
- Assessment:
  - While supported by QE, Italy remains vulnerable to a loss in market confidence due to large refinancing needs of sovereign and banking sectors and tight credit conditions from financial fragmentation.

### Japan — Overall assessment and NIIP trajectory
- Background:
  - NIIP nearly doubled in the last ten years to close to 70 percent of GDP in 2013 (assets: 166 percent; liabilities: 98 percent).
  - Projected in the medium term to rise toward 75 percent with higher CA surpluses, before stabilizing as valuation effects are offset by dis-saving as the population ages.
- Assessment:
  - Vulnerabilities are limited; equity and direct investment comprise a rising share of liabilities, now at 35 percent of total.
  - NIIP generates annual investment income at 3-3 ½ percent of GDP, keeping the current account balance positive despite the rising trade deficit.
- Overall Assessment (2014 and as of May 2015):
  - 2014 external position broadly consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies.
  - Key developments relative to 2014: reduction in the oil import bill, REER depreciation, some pickup in exports.
  - REER depreciation compared to the average of 2014 has been beneficial given low inflation and deflation risks.
  - REER has moved toward a moderately weaker level than would be consistent with fundamentals suggested in the 2014 assessment.
- Potential policy responses:
  - Forceful structural reforms to raise growth and lift prices: boost labor supply, reduce labor market duality, enhance risk capital provision, accelerate agricultural and services sector deregulation.
  - Fiscal consolidation should proceed anchored by a concrete plan to achieve the medium-term target, attuned to economic conditions.
  - Desirable policies expected to support growth, boost domestic demand, imports and prices without overreliance on yen depreciation.

### Japan — Current account
- Background:
  - 2014 CA surplus fell to 0.5 percent of GDP.
  - Export volumes grew 0.6 percent y/y (4 ¾ percent in value) in 2014.
  - Import volumes grew 0.7 percent (5 ¾ percent in value).
  - 2015 surplus expected to rise to 2 percent of GDP under current policies due to lower oil prices (oil balance deficit improves from – 3.6 percent of GDP in 2014 to -2.5 percent projected in 2015) and export growth pickup.
- Assessment:
  - EBA estimates 2014 cyclically-adjusted CA at 0.6 percent of GDP.
  - Staff adjust for temporary factors to get an underlying cyclically-adjusted CA of 2-2 ¼ percent of GDP.
  - EBA estimates 2014 CA norm at 3.1 percent of GDP; staff adjust to a norm of 1 ¼ to 2 percent of GDP.
  - The underlying CA in 2014 is assessed to be 0-1 percent of GDP larger than the norm — broadly consistent with desirable policies and medium-term fundamentals.

### Japan — Real exchange rate
- Background:
  - REER depreciated 5 ¾ percent between 2013 and 2014; a further 7 percent through May 2015 (relative to the 2014 average).
  - Depreciation mainly due to nominal depreciation from widening interest rate differentials (10y JGB yields suppressed below 60 bps for most of 2014; dipped as low as 30 bps after BoJ accelerated QQE in October).
- Assessment:
  - EBA REER Level model estimates 2014 average REER to be 21 percent weaker (EBA Index REER model: 26 percent weaker) than level consistent with fundamentals and desirable policies, mainly from a large unexplained residual.
  - Because fiscal policy is not included, estimated policy gap is close to zero.
  - EBA REER model not used in Japan’s assessment due to missing factors; staff assess a 2014 REER gap midpoint of -5 percent with an indicative range of 0 to -10 percent, using the staff-assessed CA gap range as reference.

### Japan — Capital and financial accounts
- Background:
  - Pick-up in portfolio outflows as institutional investors diversify overseas.
  - Net short yen positions eased from extreme highs but remain an important driver of exchange rate movements.
- Assessment:
  - Vulnerabilities are limited (inward investment tends to be equity-based and home bias of Japanese investors remains strong).
  - No large spillovers from QQE to domestic financial conditions in other economies so far.
  - If outflows accelerate, they could offset tightening in domestic financial conditions in regional economies facing policy normalization elsewhere.

### Korea — Overall assessment and NIIP trajectory
- Background:
  - NIIP increased from -2.9 percent of GDP in 2013 to 5.8 percent in 2014; expected to strengthen further as current account is in strong surplus.
  - Net external debt position was -16.7 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - Banks’ short term external debt remains below pre-crisis levels; currency mismatch risks limited as bulk of short term external debt is matched with forward hedging mainly by exporters.
- Assessment:
  - NIIP position and dynamics present little risk to external sustainability.
- Overall Assessment (2014):
  - External position in 2014 was substantially stronger than implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies.
  - Developments as of May 2015 point to a broadly similar external position in 2015.
  - Assessment subject to uncertainty related to persistence of large fall in oil prices (Korea is a large oil importer) and sharp movements of relevant cross rates.
- Potential policy responses:
  - Boost near-term growth momentum; recent monetary, fiscal, and other policy steps to boost domestic demand are steps in the right direction.
  - Durable reduction of imbalances requires a steady shift away from heavy reliance on manufacturing exports—raising productivity in the non-traded sector aided by structural reforms would help.
  - Expansionary fiscal policy stance could narrow imbalances, especially if coupled with expanded social safety net to reduce precautionary savings.
  - Fiscal rebalancing in advanced economies would also help.
  - Real exchange rate appreciation over time should play a role; rate should remain market determined with intervention limited to smoothing excessive volatility.

### Korea — Current account
- Background:
  - CA in 2014 was around 6¼ percent, broadly unchanged from 2013 but significantly above the average over the last 5 years.
  - In 2015 CA likely to increase due to sharp fall in global oil prices (Korea’s oil trade deficit at 7% in 2013).
  - CA expected to decline moderately in the medium term reflecting stronger projected domestic demand, structural reforms, and demographic changes reducing savings.
- Assessment:
  - EBA regression model: 2014 current account about 6¼ percentage points of GDP above the estimated cyclically-adjusted norm of 0.9 percent.
  - Staff assess the 2014 current account gap at 2½ to 5 percent of GDP after accounting for factors not fully captured by the model.

### Korea — Real exchange rate
- Background:
  - Won appreciated on a trade-weighted basis since 2012; appreciated by 6% in 2014 relative to 2013 average.
  - REER as of May 2015 appreciated by 3% from its 2014 average.
  - Cross-rate movements: won climbed against the yen but weakened against the U.S. dollar since last July.
- Assessment:
  - Despite some real appreciation, the 2014 REER is assessed to be 5 to 13 percent weaker than the level consistent with fundamentals and desired policies.
  - Staff note high uncertainty due to difficulty predicting export response to exchange rate movements and diversity of EBA model estimates.
  - EBA index model points to won roughly consistent with fundamentals and desired policies at 0.1 percent; level model points to substantially weaker won at 13.8 percent. Staff’s assessed range uses EBA implied calculations and staff-estimated elasticities.

### Korea — Capital flows, FX intervention, and reserves
- Background:
  - Increase in net portfolio outflows and decrease in net banking outflows (about 1¾ percent of GDP for both) offset each other, leaving overall net capital flow deficit at 5 percent of GDP.
  - A proposed technical change to an existing bank levy (predicted later in 2015) does not substantially alter macroprudential policy setting.
  - Korea has a floating exchange rate.
  - Reserves increased steadily since the sharp decline in 2008 and have been broadly stable at around 130 percent as a share of the IMF’s composite reserve adequacy metric during most of this period.
  - In dollar terms reserves increased by $35 billion in the first half of 2014 but have declined since then reflecting valuation losses.
- Assessment:
  - Korea’s net and gross flows appear sustainable.
  - Intervention should be limited to smoothing excessive volatility.
  - The stock of reserves should be sufficient to buffer against a range of possible external shocks.

*International Monetary Fund — Individual Economy Assessments (excerpts).*

### 4.6 percent of GDP at end 2013. Assets were about

### _062615a - 4.6 percent of GDP at end 2013. Assets were about

### External position and NIIP
- NIIP: 4.6 percent of GDP at end 2013.
- Assets: about 133 percent of GDP in 2013, of which about one-third are direct investment assets.
- Gross liabilities (including both ringgit- and foreign currency-denominated liabilities): about 138 percent of GDP at end 2013.
- Total external debt: 68 percent of GDP at the end of 2014, of which 49 percent is short-term debt.
- Foreign-currency debt: 41 percent of GDP.
- Assessment:
  - The NIIP is not a major source of risk; it is projected to rise in the medium term reflecting the projected current account surpluses.
  - The country has large institutional investors that have behaved countercyclically in past episodes of outflows.
  - Overall assessment: The external position in 2014 was stronger than that consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policy settings.
  - Developments as of May 2015 (notably the decline in energy prices amid limited depreciation of the REER) suggest a softening of the external position.
  - Bilateral depreciation against the US$ has mitigated the loss of export income from the lower price of oil and gas.
  - In 2015 the external position will remain stronger than warranted by fundamentals and desirable policy settings, albeit weaker than in 2014.

### Potential policy responses
- External rebalancing:
  - Over the medium-term, increased public sector saving will be offset by sustained private consumption and investment activity and is expected to result in a current account surplus of 0-2 percent of GDP over the medium-term, gradually closing the gap with the norm.
- Staff views any remaining current account and real exchange rate gaps as reflecting:
  - inadequate social protection (beyond that captured by public health expenditure),
  - the need to improve the risk sharing characteristics of the pension system,
  - investment bottlenecks,
  - infrastructure gaps,
  - labor force skill mismatches,
  - rigidities in the labor market.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Stronger social safety nets and efforts to remove bottlenecks to investment would help to further moderate the current account surplus.
  - Consistent with the authorities’ intentions, implement stronger social safety nets and remove investment bottlenecks.

### Current account
- Background:
  - Malaysia’s current account (CA) surplus has declined by 5 percentage points since 2011 to 4.6 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - From a saving-investment perspective, about two thirds of the CA adjustment was due to a strong surge in private investment and ETP-related investment projects.
  - Terms of trade are expected to fall by 4 percent in 2015.
  - LNG exports represent 9 percent of total exports.
  - The likely income loss of lower oil prices at constant volumes is estimated at 2 percent of GDP. The exchange rate depreciation mitigates the effect.
  - The current account surplus for 2015 is projected at 2.1 percent of GDP.
- Assessment:
  - The EBA CA regression approach estimates the cyclically-adjusted CA is stronger (by about 5.5 percent of GDP) than consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies.
  - The estimated policy gap is about zero, so nearly the entire gap is a residual requiring interpretation.
  - Malaysia’s CA surplus partly reflects factors not well captured in the EBA: insufficient social safety nets and bottlenecks to investment leading to relatively low private investment.
  - Staff assesses the norm to be 1.5 percent of GDP and the CA gap to be 3.9 percent of GDP (plus or minus 1 percent of GDP) in 2014.
  - In 2015, a lower price of gas exports may reduce the surplus by 2 percent of GDP.
  - The gap under the external sustainability approach is 1.2 percent of GDP.

### Real exchange rate (REER)
- Background:
  - The average REER in 2014 was similar to 2013.
  - By May 2015, the REER depreciation with respect to the 2014 average was 3 percent, the ringgit had depreciated by 9 percent against the USD.
- Assessment:
  - The EBA REER index regression estimates Malaysia’s REER to be 21 percent below levels warranted by fundamentals and desirable policies, though most of the gap is an unexplained residual.
  - The analysis of the level REER provides an estimate of 15 percent undervaluation.
  - Staff’s assessment: REER undervaluation for 2014 is 13 percent (plus or minus 5 percent), based on staff’s view of the CA gap and the semi-elasticity of the current account with respect to the REER.

### Capital and financial accounts: flows and policy measures
- Background:
  - Malaysia has typically recorded net capital outflows.
  - Net FDI flows are generally small, but gross FDI flows are large, reflecting the growing importance of Malaysia as a direct investor abroad.
  - In 2014, net FDI abroad increased to 4.8 percent of GDP and net FDI outflows were 1.7 percent of GDP.
  - Net total outflows were about 7.3 percent of GDP, with portfolio outflows accounting for about half of it.
  - Half of the portfolio outflows were recorded in the last quarter, when oil prices fell dramatically.
- Assessment:
  - The authorities have continued to liberalize FX administration, including via greater flexibility for resident companies to undertake FDI abroad and obtain loans from related resident and nonresident companies.

### FX intervention and reserves level
- Background:
  - Malaysia maintains a flexible exchange rate regime; BNM intervention seeks to limit excess volatility and generally has been two-sided.
  - From end-September 2014 through mid-April 2015 reserves have declined by US$21.7 billion.
- Assessment:
  - At the end of December of 2014, official reserves stood at about 83 percent of the IMF’s composite reserve adequacy metric, and covered 81 percent and 27 percent of short-term external debt and broad money, respectively.
  - Reserves in excess of the current level proved useful in 2014 and the authorities may increase reserves in favorable occasions.

### Technical background notes (selected)
- 1/ Ringgit-denominated debt held by nonresidents, including Malaysian government securities and Bank Negara Bills and Notes, increased rapidly since the global financial crisis; during the second half of 2014 foreign investors largely reduced their exposures to Bank Negara Bills and Notes. Short-term foreign-currency denominated external debt has risen in the last few years, largely due to banking sector activity, it is matched by an increase in short-term external assets and is covered by foreign reserves.
- 2/ The non-oil current account deficit fell from -2.1 percent in 2013 to -1.4 percent in 2014.
- 3/ Since 2000, movements in the REER have been driven almost entirely by the nominal exchange rate rather than inflation differentials.
- 4/ The semi-elasticity is estimated at 0.29 and takes into account Malaysia’s trade openness and commodity exports.
- 5/ During the global financial crisis foreign reserves fell by about 28 percent between August 2008 and March 2009, but then registered a strong increase in early 2011; a decline was again recorded in August–September 2011. Gradual increases continued until mid 2013, when reserves declined. In the last quarter of 2014 reserves fell by 15 percent.

*Source: IMF staff assessment and technical notes from the provided content unit.*

### 2014.  Assessment

### 2014.  Assessment

### The Netherlands — Current account
- Staff assesses that the current account gap is smaller than that estimated in the EBA model due to country-specific factors:
  - (i) unlike many other advanced economies, the Netherlands has a fully funded pension system which has increased household saving rates;
  - (ii) following the real estate collapse, household deleveraging has also kept saving rates high; and
  - (iii) statistical issues related to the income measurement of large FDI flows.
- Taking account of these factors, staff assessment of the current account gap is in the range of 0-3 percent of GDP.
- In the medium term the CA surplus is likely to decline, supported by:
  - a recovery in domestic demand;
  - progress in household deleveraging; and
  - demographic trends.

### The Netherlands — Real exchange rate
- Background:
  - Both the ULC and CPI based REERs depreciated by 2.1 and 1.7 percent respectively in 2014, mainly due to the 1.6 percent nominal effective depreciation, primarily reflecting the euro depreciation.
  - As of April May 2015, the REER depreciated by 5½ percent from its 2014 average.
- Assessment:
  - The EBA REER gaps estimates for 2014 are -1.4 percent and -10.1 percent respectively for the EBA index and level models.
  - Taking into account the EBA REER results and also the current account gap implication of around 4½ percent REER gap, staff assesses that the REER remained undervalued by around 5 percent within a range of 0-10 percent.
  - The further depreciation of the euro in 2015 is likely to have increased the undervaluation of the exchange rate.

### The Netherlands — Capital and financial accounts; FX intervention and reserves
- Background:
  - Net FDI and portfolio outflows dominate the financial account.
  - FDI outflows are driven by the investment of corporate profits abroad.
  - On average, gross FDI outflows largely match corporate profits.
  - The euro has the status of a global reserve currency.
- Assessment:
  - The strong external position limits vulnerabilities from capital flows.
  - The financial account is likely to remain in deficit as long as the corporate sector continues to invest substantially abroad.
  - Reserves held by the Euro area are typically low relative to standard metrics, but the currency is free floating.

### The Netherlands — Technical Background Notes (selected)
- In comparison with last year, the EBA-estimated CA gap in 2014 (unexplained residual plus the contribution of identified policy gaps) narrowed by 1.1 percentage point to 3.6 percent of GDP.
- The smaller gap reflects a lower cyclically adjusted CA surplus (down from 9.7 to 9.2 percent of GDP) and a higher estimated CA norm of 5.7 percent of GDP (after 5.0 percent in 2013).
- The larger external balance sheet, presence of large international corporations, and issues related to the measurement of the current account add uncertainty to this assessment. According to the DNB, half of the positions in assets and liabilities are attributable to subsidiaries of foreign multinationals, which are identified as Special Financial Institutions (SFIs).

*Source: IMF staff assessment (2014. Assessment)*

---

### Poland — Foreign asset and liability position and trajectory
- Background:
  - A large negative net international investment position (NIIP) stabilized at 60 percent of GDP in 2014 (assets at 42 percent and liabilities at 103 percent of GDP).
  - Amid a moderate widening of the current account (CA) deficit, financed largely by non-debt creating EU flows, the NIIP is projected to improve to 58 percent of GDP by 2020.
- Assessment:
  - Vulnerabilities exist, but sustainability concerns surrounding the large negative NIIP are mitigated by:
    - diversified FDI liabilities and associated intra-company lending (over 40 percent of foreign liabilities are FDI);
    - the projected improvement of the NIIP under the baseline.
  - Broadly adequate reserves and the FCL arrangement help mitigate liquidity risks (ST debt is 20 percent of total).

### Poland — Overall assessment and policy responses
- Overall assessment:
  - The external position in 2014 was broadly consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies.
  - As of May 2015, it appears that the impact of lower oil prices is being more than offset by strong domestic demand growth; this does not change the overall assessment going forward.
  - Desirable policies include continued modest fiscal consolidation. Reserves are broadly adequate. The FCL arrangement provides an added buffer.
- Potential policy responses:
  - Modest fiscal consolidation in Poland, and in the rest of the world in aggregate, should continue.
  - Vigilance with respect to bank funding (including foreign exchange swaps) is warranted including by standing ready to extend FX liquidity in the event of external shocks.
  - Modest additional reserve accumulation would be appropriate to further bolster buffers.
  - The exchange rate should be allowed to play its appropriate cushioning role.

### Poland — Current account
- Background:
  - The CA deficit declined from around 5 percent of GDP in 2010-11 to 1.4 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - Underlying the improvement is increased savings and a reduction in investment from the highs due to front loaded absorption of EU funds.
  - The moderate CA deficit in 2014 largely reflects income repatriation by multinational companies’ domestic affiliates and a trade surplus of 1.8 percent of GDP.
  - In 2015, the CA is projected to improve only marginally, despite the improvement in the oil trade deficit (3.4 percent of GDP in 2013) which is more than offset by higher non-oil imports due to strong domestic demand.
- Assessment:
  - The CA is broadly consistent with the level consistent with fundamentals and desirable policies.
  - The CA approach estimates a gap of around 0.6 percent of GDP, reflecting the sum of offsetting domestic and partners’ policy gaps (a reduction in Poland’s structural fiscal deficit will be needed to reduce its domestic policy gap) and a residual.
  - The cyclically-adjusted CA is estimated at -1 percent of GDP, and the CA norm is -1.6 percent of GDP.
  - The staff assessment is similar, with a CA gap range for 2014 centered on +0.5 (plus or minus 1) percent of GDP.

### Poland — Real exchange rate
- Background:
  - The real effective exchange rate (REER) appreciated 0.8 percent in 2014 relative to 2013.
  - It depreciated 2 percent as of May 2015 largely reflecting nominal depreciation vis-à-vis the US dollar and the Swiss Franc.
  - Capital inflows following ECB QE action could result in appreciation of the zloty, though the 50 bp cut in March could mitigate the impact.
- Assessment:
  - The EBA models suggest undervaluation of between 2 and 11 percent.
  - The ES estimate of the REER gap is 5 percent; 2 percent using the REER index and 11 percent using level REER.
  - Based on these inputs, and the assessment of the CA, staff assesses Poland’s real exchange rate in 2014 to be close to a level consistent with fundamentals and desirable policy settings, with a REER gap centered on -2.5 with a range of -7.5 to +2.5.

### Poland — Capital and financial accounts; FX intervention and reserves
- Background:
  - The capital account is dominated by EU structural fund inflows.
  - In recent years, inflows in the financial account were centered on portfolio flows (government bonds), as FDI slowed.
  - Capital inflows remained weak in 2014, in tandem with narrowing of the CA deficit.
  - Reserves have increased from USD 93 bln in 2010 to 100 bln in 2014. The zloty has floated freely.
- Assessment:
  - High foreign holdings, 40 percent of total government bonds, suggest potential vulnerability.
  - Pension modifications, which mechanically increased the share of foreign investors in the domestic government bond market, may exacerbate the vulnerabilities.
  - The diversified investor base is a mitigating factor.
  - Reserves are broadly adequate, standing at about 114 percent of the IMF’s composite reserve adequacy metric.
  - Nonetheless, additional reserve accumulation would be appropriate to further bolster buffers.
  - The FCL also provides insurance against external risks.

### Poland — Technical Background Notes (selected)
- Poland has a total current account gap (including residual) of 0.6 percent. The contribution of identified policy gaps are -0.5 percent.
- The domestic fiscal policy gap is -1 percent but is offset by fiscal gaps in trading partners that result in a total contribution of -0.1 of fiscal policies to the current account gap.
- The various EBA model approaches suggest a modest undervaluation of between 2 and 11 percent (the ES estimate of the REER gap is 5 percent; and the estimated undervaluation using the REER index regression approach is 2 percent and 11 percent using the REER in level).
- With a qualitatively unchanged policy gaps across the two approaches, but a higher regression residual of 11 percent in the REER levels approach, staff gives more weight to the EBA index REER approach. Staff’s assessment of the CA gap range suggests that the REER is centered on -2.5 with a range of -7.5 to +2.5.

*Source: IMF staff assessment (2014. Assessment)*

---

### Russia — Foreign asset and liability position and trajectory
- Background:
  - The net international investment position (NIIP) was positive at end-December 2014 at about 18 percent GDP (up from 6 percent in 2013); with gross assets of 70 percent of GDP and liabilities of 52 percent of GDP.
  - Total external debt was 36 percent of GDP.
  - Historically, the NIIP position has not kept pace with the CA surpluses due to unfavorable valuation changes and the treatment of “disguised” capital outflows.
- Assessment:
  - The projected current account surpluses mean that Russia will continue to maintain a positive international investment position, which minimizes risks to external stability.
  - Recent deleveraging reduces risks further.

### Russia — Overall assessment and potential policy responses
- Overall assessment:
  - The external position in 2014 was moderately weaker than the level consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policy settings.
  - Relative to the 2014 assessment period, the REER has depreciated. This in part reflects the adjustment to a new norm with substantially lower oil prices and sanctions that are affecting medium term growth.
  - The structural implications of the sanctions create exceptional uncertainty when assessing the external position.
  - Staff’s initial view is that the depreciation has moved the REER toward a level closer to medium-term fundamentals that have changed materially since the last ESR.
- Potential policy responses:
  - The nonoil fiscal deficit remains significantly higher than its long-term desirable level and needs to adjust to facilitate a rebalancing from public to private activity, and a re-allocation of government expenditure from current to capital spending.
  - This rebalancing—coupled with a renewed emphasis on structural reforms to invigorate the private sector—would help increase public saving that would be matched by both higher private and public sector investment over the medium-term.

### Russia — Current account
- Background:
  - From 2000 to 2013, the current account (CA) surplus fell from 18 to 2 percent of GDP despite increasing oil prices, as consumption increased rapidly.
  - A correction is underway with the CA improving to 3.1 percent in 2014 and 4.5 percent in 2015.
  - This improvement took place despite the negative terms of trade shock, as reduced oil export revenue (approximately 5 percent of GDP) was offset by falling absorption due to the real depreciation of the ruble, and tightening of financial conditions.
- Assessment:
  - There are particular uncertainties with the external assessment when oil plays such a dominant role in the economy, compounded now by the uncertain long-term impact of sanctions in saving-investment decisions and therefore the normative external position.
  - Staff believes higher uncertainty warrants higher savings, hence a stronger current account norm than implied by the model.
  - Against this background, staff assesses that the 2014 CA gap was between -3 to 0 percent of GDP.
  - In the medium term, fiscal policy should be tightened to rebuild buffers, save more of the oil wealth for future generations, and counter Dutch disease.

### Russia — Real exchange rate
- Background:
  - The sustained oil price boom and related expansion of domestic demand led to a strong real effective exchange rate (REER) appreciation between 2000 and 2013.
  - The REER has since depreciated 8 percent between 2013 and 2014, and through May 2015, by a further 2 percent on average relative to the average for 2014, despite significant inflation differentials with trading partners.
  - This reflects lower oil prices, sanctions, and the move to a floating exchange rate regime in November 2014.
- Assessment:
  - EBA estimates that the average REER in 2014 was 7 percent overvalued based on the CA regression approach and 10 percent undervalued based on the REER level regression approach (and 13 percent based on the index approach).
  - The index approach is less reliable in commodity-exporting countries over a period in which commodity prices have been exceptionally high and is discarded from the staff assessment.
  - Based on the current account gap, and taking into account the uncertainties discussed in the current account assessment, staff assesses that the REER was overvalued by 0-10 percent on average during 2014.
  - Staff assess that the recent depreciation has moved the REER toward a level closer to medium-term fundamentals.

### Russia — Capital and financial accounts; FX intervention and reserves
- Background:
  - Net private capital outflows have picked-up, as the non-bank sector has increasingly found it difficult to rollover existing debt and confidence has deteriorated.
  - Geopolitical tensions and lower oil prices will continue to weigh on the outlook.
  - Over the medium term, structural outflows are expected to decline if Russia improves its investment climate.
  - The CBR intervened according to its FX intervention rule in large volumes in 2014 dampening the pace of depreciation before abandoning its managed float policy.
  - The CBR has since moved to a floating exchange rate regime and limited intervention, and in May 2015, started rebuilding reserves as uncertainty remains elevated.
- Assessment:
  - While Russia is exposed to risks of accelerated capital outflows and sudden stop of external funding because of the exceptional current geopolitical tensions, large international reserves provide substantial buffers and the new floating exchange rate regime help absorb these shocks.
  - The current level of foreign reserves is adequate according to a range of reserve coverage indicators and is above 150 percent of the IMF’s composite reserve adequacy metric.
  - Accumulation of fiscal savings in the oil funds should continue and the current policy of small regular reserve purchases to replenish reserves could be justified by the heightened level of uncertainty related to sanctions and as a buffer given Russia’s vulnerability to oil shocks.
  - Large FX interventions should be limited to episodes of market distress.

### Russia — Technical Background Notes (selected)
- Unfavorable valuation changes arise because the Russian stock market has performed very well in the last 15 years as the oil price soared, boosting the valuation of foreign-owned assets.
- “Disguised” capital outflows include transactions such as pre-payments on import contracts where the goods are not delivered, repeated large transfers abroad that deviate from standard remittances behavior, or securities transactions at inflated prices.
- The Central Bank of Russia includes estimates of “disguised” capital outflows in the financial account but not in the foreign asset position of the reported NIIP. Hence, the actual NIIP position could be higher than the reported level and this treatment of “disguised” outflows may explain part of the discrepancy between accumulated CA surpluses and the reported NIIP position.
- EBA-estimated 2014 CA norm was 5 percent of GDP; and the cyclically adjusted CA was 2.9 percent.
- The lower model-based gap relative to 2013 reflects both an improvement in the 2014 CA (from 1.6 percent in 2013) and a small reduction in the estimated current account norm (from 5.2 percent in 2013).
- This change in the norm broadly reflects two offsetting factors, with lower oil prices reducing the norm by 1 percent and lower medium-term growth increasing the norm by 0.5 percent.
- The EBA estimated CA norm of 4.8 percent of GDP rests mostly on the need to save out of income from non-renewable oil exports. Staff’s assessment shares this basic logic in also calling for a CA surplus for Russia, but acknowledges that such saving (i.e., refraining from consumption) would not necessarily have to take a financial form, and could in part take the form of productive investment spending, which could justify a somewhat lower CA surplus than the EBA-estimated norm.
- Sanctions and geopolitical tensions have introduced an additional level of complexity in the external assessment, as they introduce exceptional uncertainty in model based estimates.

*Source: IMF staff assessment (2014. Assessment)*

---

### Saudi Arabia — Overall assessment and foreign asset and liability position
- Background:
  - External assets are substantial at an estimated 140 percent of GDP in mid-2014, while total external liabilities were 36 percent of GDP (portfolio and other investments were 8.3 percent of GDP).
  - All external debt is private.
  - The net international investment position (NIIP) stood between 85 and 105 percent of GDP during 2007-mid-2014.
  - The average return on assets was relatively low at about 2½ percent compared to 5 percent on liabilities during the period.
  - External assets are dominated by international reserves, but details on the composition of external assets are not available.
  - Projections suggest that the NIIP/GDP ratio will remain broadly stable over the medium term.
- Assessment:
  - The external balance sheet is very strong.
  - Substantial accumulated assets represent both savings of the exhaustible resource revenues for future generations and protection against vulnerabilities from oil price volatility.

### Saudi Arabia — Overall assessment and policy guidance
- Overall assessment:
  - The external position in 2014 was broadly consistent with fundamentals. This assessment takes account of the dominant role of fiscal policy in determining the external position.
  - Projections for 2015 suggest the current account may be weaker than estimated norms.
  - Fiscal policy adjustment will be needed to close the current account gap.
  - The decline in the oil price reduced the current account surplus in 2014 and is expected to result in a small deficit in 2015.
  - With the forecast trend improvement in oil prices, the current account is projected to improve over the medium term.
  - While a current account gap is projected in 2015, the very strong external balance sheet including high foreign exchange reserves and no significant concerns about capital flows are strong mitigating factors.
  - The current account deficit projected for this year is very small in relation to available buffers.
  - Given the structure of the Saudi economy, with exports dominated by oil and oil-related products, external adjustment will need to be driven by fiscal adjustment rather than exchange rate adjustment.
- Potential policy responses:
  - While sizeable fiscal buffers mean there is no need for a sharp cut in government spending in the face of lower, but uncertain, oil prices, fiscal consolidation is needed.
  - The non-oil fiscal deficit remains significantly above the level implied by intergenerational equity models and at current spending levels fiscal buffers will be significantly depleted.
  - Fiscal adjustment is the key to increasing the current account over the medium-term in line with intergenerational equity needs.
  - Government investment on infrastructure and education is appropriate, but it is important to ensure that this spending is efficiently meeting development needs.
  - Efforts are needed to reduce current spending and increase non-tax revenues.

### Saudi Arabia — Current account (partial)
- Background:
  - The current account (CA) surplus in 2014 narrowed to 10.9 percent of GDP from 18.2 percent in

*Source: IMF staff assessment (2014. Assessment)*

### 2013. This reflected lower oil revenue

### _062615a - 2013. This reflected lower oil revenue

### Saudi Arabia — Current account and outlook
- Oil export revenues decline by 14 percent of GDP in 2015, projecting a small current account deficit in 2015.
- CA surpluses expected to recover to 5 percent of GDP in 2020 as oil prices partially recover over the medium term.
- Long-term determinants of the CA:
  - (i) Fiscal strategy: balance between saving to create an income stream for future generations versus spending on consumption and investment.
  - (ii) Pace of oil extraction and future oil prices.
- Staff assessment for 2014:
  - Negative current account gap in 2014; estimated gap varies by methodology from -8.5 to -0.5 percent of GDP, with an average gap of -3 percent of GDP.
  - The gap is driven by current fiscal policy settings; projections suggest the current account gap may widen in 2015.

### Saudi Arabia — Real exchange rate
- Riyal pegged to the U.S. dollar at a rate of 3.75 since 1986.
- REER appreciated by 16 percent over the past year and is currently about 20 percent above its average over the past decade.
- REER mainly influenced by the U.S. nominal exchange rate vis-à-vis trade partners and oil price dynamics (via government and consumer spending).
- Assessment: Exchange rate movements have limited impact on competitiveness; external adjustment will come via fiscal policy effects on domestic demand and imports.

### Saudi Arabia — Capital and financial accounts
- Inflows dominated by FDI; outflows largely trade credits and portfolio investment.
- Capital account restrictions and underdeveloped domestic capital markets limit portfolio and investment inflows; steps to allow increased foreign investment in the equity market are ongoing.
- Assessment: No immediate risks or vulnerabilities associated with capital flows.

### Saudi Arabia — FX intervention and reserves level
- Saudi Arabia does not have a Sovereign Wealth Fund; government foreign assets are held at the central bank within international reserves.
- International reserves were about 97 percent of GDP (36 months of imports) at end-2014, although they declined modestly in the final months of 2014.
- Reserves serve precautionary motives and as savings for future generations.
- Assessment: Reserve assets are more than adequate for precautionary purposes (measured by the Fund’s metrics). A larger current account surplus and resulting NIIP accumulation would be needed to ensure an equitable intergenerational transfer of oil revenues in real per capita terms.

### Saudi Arabia — Technical background notes (selected numeric points)
- Errors and omissions are estimated at -2 percent of GDP in 2014.
- EBA methodology assessments are not available for Saudi Arabia. Current account norms for 2014 range from 19.4 percent of GDP (external sustainability or ES approach) to 11.6 percent of GDP (MB approach from IMF Country Report No. 13/229) to 11.4 percent of GDP (EBA-lite approach).
- Corresponding current account gaps for 2014 are estimated at, respectively, -8.5 percent, -0.7 percent, and -0.5 percent.
- Estimated fiscal gap in 2014 is 17.7 percent of GDP. If this fiscal gap is closed, the current account gap is eliminated under the ES approach.
- EBA-lite estimated CA gap reflects a fiscal policy gap of about -7.5 percent and a large unexplained residual of about +7 percent.

---

### Singapore — Overall assessment and current account
- NIIP stood at 182 percent of GDP at end-2014, relatively flat since 2011 and lower than the pre-GFC peak of 254 percent of GDP in 2006.
- Current account surplus was 19.1 percent of GDP in 2014, an increase of 1.2 percent of GDP relative to 2013.
- Recent oil price decline led to a significant increase in the oil trade balance at end-2014 and Q1 2015 and is expected to contribute to an increase in the CA in 2015 by about 1.5 percent of GDP assuming the price decline is sustained.
- Overall, the CA is expected to increase by about 1-1.5 percent of GDP in 2015.
- Staff assesses the 2014 CA as stronger than the level consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies, by 2 to 8 percent of GDP.

### Singapore — Real exchange rate
- REER appreciated 26 percent since 2005; REER depreciated by 0.2 percent in 2014 and is 0.5 percent lower as of May 2015 relative to the 2014 average.
- Recent halt in REER appreciation expected to reverse over time as temporary impact of oil price shock on inflation is reversed in 2016.
- Assessment: REER is around 4-16 percent weaker than warranted by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies (estimate relies on CA assessment and a semi-elasticity of the CA with respect to the REER of about 0.5).

### Singapore — Capital and financial accounts; reserves
- Fully open capital account. Financial account deficit tends to co-move with the global financial cycle.
- Financial flows encompass sizable net inward FDI and smaller but more volatile net bank-related flows.
- Official reserves declined by 10 percent (28.5 billion USD) since mid-2014, reflecting valuation changes; large decline in central bank’s FX swap positions by 23.5 billion USD.
- At end-Q4 2014, official reserves covered about 25 percent of short-term external debt; reserves are far in excess of thresholds for other adequacy metrics.
- Assessment: Current reserve levels appear adequate and there is no case for further accumulation for precautionary purposes.

### Singapore — Technical background notes (selected numeric points)
- Singapore’s official reserves amounted to about 87 percent of GDP in 2014.
- Net oil trade balance was -5.6 percent of GDP in 2013.
- Monetary policy easing in January involved a slight decline in the trend appreciation of the NEER band from an estimated 2 percent to 1 percent per annum.

---

### South Africa — Overall assessment and current account
- Gross external debt increased to 41 percent of GDP in 2014 from 26 percent in 2008; 10 percent of GDP was short-term.
- Total gross external liabilities amounted to 130 percent of GDP at end-2014: about 34 percent direct investments, 35 percent portfolio equity liabilities, 15 percent portfolio debt liabilities, remainder other investments.
- Net IIP position was -11.5 percent of GDP at end-2014.
- Overall assessment: External position in 2014 was weaker than implied by desirable policy settings and medium-term fundamentals. Subsequent developments as of May 2015 would tend to strengthen the external position, but not enough to change the overall assessment.
- CA deficit narrowed to 5.4 percent of GDP in 2014 from 5.8 percent in 2013, driven by weak non-oil imports.
- South Africa is a net oil importer by more than 4 percent of GDP in 2014 and will benefit from lower oil prices; CA deficit projected to narrow to 4.8 percent of GDP in 2015.
- EBA estimates a CA norm of -1.9 percent of GDP and a gap of -3.5 percent of GDP for 2014. Staff assesses the CA to be 1½ to 3½ percentage points weaker than implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policy settings in 2014.

### South Africa — Risks and policy recommendations
- Large gross external liabilities pose risks but are mitigated by a large external asset position.
- The decline in oil prices is anticipated to lower the CA deficit in 2015, but the deficit will remain elevated and mainly financed by non-FDI flows.
- Structural constraints are slowing CA adjustment despite REER depreciation.
- Gross external financing requirements are relatively high, posing vulnerabilities; a reduction in capital inflows could complicate financing and induce a significant growth slowdown.
- Potential policy responses:
  - Improve energy availability to boost exports and lower the CA deficit.
  - Implement the authorities’ National Development Plan to improve competitiveness over the medium term.
  - Additional labor and product market reforms are essential.
  - Fiscal consolidation to help alleviate external vulnerabilities.
  - Build-up of reserves to strengthen the ability to deal with FX liquidity shocks.

*INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND — _062615a - 2013. This reflected lower oil revenue*

### 2015. However, the CA deficit is projected to remain above th

### South Africa

### Real exchange rate
- Background.
  - The CPI-based REER depreciated by 21 percent since end-2010 (6 percent on average in 2014 compared to the 2013 average), having almost reversed the appreciation of 2009-10.
  - The ULC-based REER has registered a similar depreciation since end-2010, but remains 25 percent more appreciated than at end-2008.
  - The EBA REER regressions (which use the CPI-based REER) point to undervaluation for 2014.2 However, other indicators, including the EBA CA regression approach and South Africa’s declining share in world’s exports, suggest overvaluation.
  - As of May 2015 the REER was little changed from its 2014 average.
- Assessment.
  - Consistent with the assessment of the CA gap, staff assesses a REER overvaluation of 5-20 percent for 2014.3
  - If the CA gap narrows as expected in 2015, the assessed overvaluation would decline.
  - The extent of overvaluation is difficult to pinpoint and adjustment will mainly have to come from reforms that tackle the economy’s structural impediments.

### Capital and financial accounts: flows and policy measures
- Background.
  - Net FDI declined to -0.4 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - Portfolio, other investment flows, and unrecorded transactions accounted for most of the financing of the CA deficit.
  - Gross external financing needs amounted to 16.5 percent of GDP in 2014.
- Assessment.
  - The risks posed by the reliance on non-FDI flows and nonresident holdings of local financial assets are significant, but mitigated by:
    - the floating exchange rate,
    - the fact that the portfolio inflows go into long-term local currency bonds and equities,
    - the large share of index-tracking investors, and
    - the large domestic institutional investor base.
  - Nevertheless, a sharp slowdown or sudden reversal of capital inflows would complicate the financing of the CA deficit.

### FX intervention and reserves level
- Background.
  - South Africa has a floating exchange rate regime.
  - Foreign exchange intervention is rare.
  - Reserves cover about 94 percent of gross external financing needs and over five months of imports, but are below the IMF’s composite adequacy metric (at 80 percent of the metric without considering capital flow management measures, and 88 percent of it considering them).
  - Gold reserves account for about 11 percent of reserves.
- Assessment.
  - As financing conditions allow, reserve accumulation is desirable (with or without considering capital flow management measures), subject to maintaining the primacy of the inflation objective.

### Current account and external position (summary from related notes)
- Technical Background Notes (selected points).
  - The CA gap presented here results from the CA regression approach and the External Sustainability (ES) approach.
  - The ES approach compares the CA balance expected to prevail in the medium term with the one that would stabilize South Africa’s stock of net foreign assets at its EM peers’ benchmark (-35 percent of GDP). According to this approach, to stabilize South Africa’s net IIP at the peers’ level, South Africa’s CA deficit would need to be less than 2 percent of GDP, compared to staff’s projection of a CA deficit of about 4- 4½ percent of GDP over the medium term.
  - The CA regression approach yields a gap for 2014 of -3.5 percent of GDP. Hence, the staff’s gap range for 2014 is centered on -2½ percent of GDP.
  - The EBA REER Index regression approach gives an undervaluation of 23 percent for 2014. The newly introduced REER Level regression approach estimates an undervaluation of 7 percent for 2014, even with a significant decline of the fitted real effective exchange rate since 2005.
  - Gauging the appropriate exchange rate for South Africa is challenging due to its structural changes since 1994 and high REER volatility. Structural impediments including electricity shortages, prolonged strikes, and concentrated product markets hamper adjustment.
  - Using the CA gap range and applying a long-run elasticity estimate would suggest a REER overvaluation of about 5-12 percent. However, considering the uncertainty regarding the elasticity and the possibility that it may be lower, the overvaluation range is assessed to be 5-20 percent.

*Italic: Source: IMF staff assessment excerpts for South Africa (2014–2015) from the provided content unit.*

### 2014. The revised series

### 2014. The revised series

### External position and NIIP
- Shows a declining external position from 2011.
- Staff projections for the current account and GDP suggest that the official NIIP to GDP ratio would stabilize at around -45 percent by 2020. 1/
- Gross assets and liabilities are more than 500 percent of GDP, reflecting the international activities of large financial institutions.
- Assessment: The NIIP and sustainability issues are not yet a concern. But fluctuations in the underlying gross positions are a source of external vulnerability to the extent that they could lead to large changes in the net position.
- Technical background note: The official NIIP data might understate the true position—attempts to value FDI at market values suggest an NIIP of around 20 percent of GDP. Market value estimates of FDI assets assume that values move in line with equity market indices in the UK and abroad. These estimates are uncertain as actual FDI market values could evolve differently from equity markets.

### Overall assessment (United Kingdom)
- The external position in 2014 was weaker than implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policy settings.
- The real exchange rate appreciation seen so far in 2015 may further weigh on the external position.
- External deficits reflect insufficient public and private saving rates.
- The external position is influenced by the lack of competitiveness and limited export diversification.

### Policy recommendations (UK)
- Rebalance away from public support toward private-sector led demand, along with greater reliance on external demand.
- Continue the current fiscal consolidation plan implemented within a medium-term framework.
- Maintain an accommodative monetary policy stance to contribute to external rebalancing.
- Implement further structural reforms focused on broadening the skill base and investing in public infrastructure to boost productivity and improve competitiveness.

### Current account (United Kingdom) — background and assessment
- Background:
  - During the recovery from the crisis, the CA balance has deteriorated from -3 to -5½ percent of GDP.
  - The decline in the CA balance is accounted for primarily by a lower income balance, reflecting a fall in earnings on the UK’s foreign direct investment abroad, notably earnings on investment exposed to the euro area.
  - The trade balance has been stable around -2 percent of GDP, despite a 9½ percent real exchange rate depreciation between 2007 and 2014.
  - In 2015, the recent oil price drop is expected to contribute to a lower trade deficit.
  - Household and non-financial sector saving-investment balances have declined, more than offsetting the slight improvement in the general government balance.
- Assessment:
  - The EBA CA regression approach estimates a CA gap of around -4.5 percent of GDP for 2014.
  - The recent deterioration in the income balance is not expected to be all permanent, suggesting a smaller underlying CA deficit and smaller CA gap than implied by the EBA model.
  - Taking this and other factors into account, staff assesses the 2014 cyclically-adjusted CA balance to be 1½ -3½ percent weaker than the current account norm.

### Real exchange rate (United Kingdom) — background and assessment
- Background:
  - Sterling appreciated in real effective terms in the first half of 2014 before stabilizing; for 2014 as a whole, the average REER was 8 percent more appreciated than for 2013.
  - As of May 2015, the REER has strengthened by 6.5 percent from its average level in 2014.
  - This appreciation may reflect the UK’s relatively strong domestic demand and differences in interest rates (both current and prospective) between the UK and many advanced economies.
- Assessment:
  - For 2014, the EBA exchange rate assessment implied by the EBA CA regression model indicates an overvaluation of 18 percent.
  - The EBA REER regressions estimate an overvaluation of 2.3 percent (REER Level model) and 5.6 percent (REER Index model).
  - Staff assesses the 2014 REER as 5–15 percent above the level consistent with fundamentals and desirable policy settings; this assessment is informed by and consistent with the staff’s CA assessment.

### Capital and financial accounts (United Kingdom)
- Background:
  - Given the UK’s role as an international financial center, portfolio investment and financial derivatives are the key components of the financial account.
- Assessment:
  - Large fluctuations in capital flows are inherent to financial transactions in countries with a large financial services sector.
  - This volatility is a potential source of vulnerability.

### FX intervention and reserves (United Kingdom)
- Background:
  - The pound has the status of a global reserve currency.
- Assessment:
  - Reserves held by the UK are typically low relative to standard metrics, and the currency is free floating.

### United States — external position and NIIP
- Background:
  - The NIIP declined from -18.7 per cent of GDP in 2010 to -34.5 percent of GDP in 2014, reflecting sustained current account deficits, stronger performance of the U.S. stock market relative to trading partners, and valuation changes of foreign currency denominated assets. 1/
  - Under staff’s baseline scenario, U.S. NIIP would deteriorate by about 10 percentage points of GDP over the next five years predominantly due to projected current account deficits.
- Assessment:
  - A decline in foreign demand for U.S. debt securities (for example, by a protracted failure to restore long-run fiscal sustainability) would raise financial stability risks, but at the same time weaken the exchange rate and strengthen the trade balance.
  - Given the dollar’s reserve currency status, such financial stability concerns are limited.
  - Most U.S. foreign assets are denominated in foreign currency and over 50 percent are in the form of FDI and portfolio equity claims, whose value tend to decline when global growth and stock markets are weak, as well as when the U.S. dollar appreciates.
- Overall assessment:
  - The U.S. external position was broadly consistent with medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies in 2014.
  - As of May 2015, sizable recent REER appreciation has weakened the U.S. external position. This is partially offset by lower oil prices.
  - The U.S. REER is currently moderately above the level consistent with medium-term fundamentals.
  - As of May, the REER was about 9 percent above its average value of 2014.

### Policy recommendations (United States)
- Over the medium term, fiscal consolidation should aim for a general government primary surplus of about ¾ percent of GDP (a federal government primary surplus of about 1 percent of GDP).
- Implement structural policies to raise productivity and labor force growth, including taking steps to fully exploit the benefits of the boom in unconventional energy production.
- These policies would be consistent with maintaining external stability and achieving full employment.

### Current account (United States) — background and assessment
- Background:
  - The U.S. current account (CA) deficit has narrowed from its pre-crisis height of 6 percent of GDP to 2.4 percent of GDP in 2014, reflecting a sharp reduction in the fiscal deficit, higher private saving, lower investment in the aftermath of the financial crisis, and a stronger energy trade balance (due to the rapid increase of unconventional energy production). 2/
  - The CA deficit is expected to decline moderately but steadily from 2015 through the medium-term as the effects of a stronger U.S. economy and a more appreciated U.S. dollar are only partly offset by lower oil prices.
- Assessment:
  - The EBA model estimates a cyclically-adjusted CA gap of -1.2 percent of GDP for 2014.
  - The calculation does not fully account for the increase of unconventional energy production and the effects of the 2014 price decline on domestic energy production and the oil balance.
  - The staff view is that the 2014 cyclically-adjusted CA is between 0 and 1 ¼ percent weaker than the level implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies. 3/

### Real exchange rate (United States) — background and assessment
- Background:
  - The REER appreciated in 2014 by about 2 percent compared to 2013.
  - The REER appreciated by more than 6 percent in the second half of 2014.
  - As of May 2015, the REER was about 9 percent stronger than its average value over 2014.
- Assessment:
  - Indirect estimates of the REER suggest the exchange was overvalued by about 5 percent in 2014.
  - Direct REER analyses suggest an overvaluation of between 2 and 8 percent.
  - Considering all estimates and uncertainties, staff assess the 2014 average REER as overvalued, within a range of 0 to 10 percent, compared to the level implied by medium-term fundamentals and desirable policies.

### Capital and financial accounts (United States)
- Background:
  - Net financial outflows were about 0.8 percent of GDP in 2014. 5/
  - Portfolio inflows increased by about 40 percent, year over year, in 2014 but were offset by weaker direct investment and other inflows.
  - On the outflow side, there were further increases in U.S. portfolio investment overseas, but much less so than the previous year.
  - The stronger outlook for the U.S. economy compared to its key trading partners, the dollar reserve currency status and safe haven motives continue to boost foreign demand for U.S. Treasury securities.
- Assessment:
  - The U.S. has a fully open capital account.
  - Vulnerabilities are limited by the dollar’s status as a reserve currency and the U.S. role as a safe haven.

### FX intervention and reserves (United States)
- Assessment:
  - The dollar has the status of a global reserve currency.
  - Reserves held by the U.S. are typically low relative to standard metrics, but the currency is free floating.

*Source: _062615a - 2014. The revised series (IMF).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/np/pp/eng/2015/_062615a.pdf_
