## _cr04200

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr04200](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2004/_cr04200.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2004/_cr04200.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2004/_cr04200.pdf.json)

---

### INTRODUCTION — overview, purpose, and coordination
- Kyrgyz Republic one of 13 pilot countries for a Comprehensive Development Framework (CDF) to 2010; CDF approved in May 2001.
- National Poverty Reduction Strategy, 2003-2005 (NPRS) is first phase of CDF implementation; adopted as a medium-term action program to ensure human development, reduce poverty and avoid food insecurity.
- CDF and NPRS formulated in partnership with all branches of state authority and civil society, in close cooperation with the World Bank, IMF, and other international institutions; based on National Food Security Policy approved October 1999.
- NPRS endorsed at October 2002 Consultative Group meeting in Bishkek.
- IMF Executive Council and World Bank Board approved three-year country assistance programs in February 2003 aligned with NPRS priorities.
- This document: first progress report on NPRS implementation, covering main outcomes of reforms in 2002-2003 and reflecting measures under PRGF and World Bank Country Assistance Strategy.
- Government intentions for 2004: prioritize NPRS measures, raise effectiveness of financial resource use; President declared 2004 a year for social mobilization and good governance.

### II. REDUCTION OF POVERTY IN 2002-2003 — data sources and trends
- Concept and measurement:
  - Human poverty concept used with monetary and non-monetary measures.
  - Monetary poverty indicators from selective survey of over 3000 households by National Statistics Committee (NSC) using World Bank–agreed methodology.
  - Welfare criteria: a) per capita expenditures (baseline), b) per capita consumption, c) per adult equivalent consumption. Poverty level and extreme poverty level computed for all three.
- Trends (2000–2003):
  - 2002 poverty level declined by 3,2%.
  - Poverty reduction relative to 1999 amounted to 10,9%.
  - Preliminary 2003 poverty level: 40,8% (decline of 3,6% compared with 2002); final 2003 data to be ready end-April 2004.
  - Rural poverty 2002: 47% (1999 = 60%; 2001 = 51%).
  - Urban poverty 2002: 39,6% (1999 = 42,4%; 2001 = 41,2%).
  - Rural poor account for 70% of total poor; rural population share = 65,3%.
  - In 2002, poverty fell in all oblasts except Batken oblast; Issyk-Kul and Talas oblasts achieved over 10% reduction.
- Extreme poverty and inequality:
  - Extreme poverty: 13,8% in 2002; 13,5% in 2001 (increase 0,3% within measurement accuracy).
  - Extreme poverty rural: 15,6% (2001) → 14,7% (2002).
  - Extreme poverty urban: 9,6% (2001) → 12,0% (2002) (mostly Bishkek and internal migrants).
  - Gini coefficient of expenditures: 0,320 (2001) → 0,328 (2002).
    - Urban Gini: 0,313 → 0,336.
    - Rural Gini: 0,351 → 0,321.
  - Quintile coefficient: 4,8 (2001) → 5,2 (2002).
  - Pattern: reforms benefit those near the poverty line more than the poorest; internal migration contributes.
- Non-monetary indicators and services:
  - Infant mortality 2002: 21,2‰ (declined by 0,5‰ in 2002); in 2003 infant mortality further declined by 1.4% compared with 2002.
  - Birth rate: 19,8‰ (2001) → 20,2‰ (2002).
  - Preliminary 2003 (first nine months): increase in average nutritional value of food consumed by poorest three quintiles.
  - Accessibility indicators:
    - Literacy, %: 2001 = 98,7; 2002 = 98,7
    - Coverage of children with basic education (grades 1-9), %: 2001 = 95,0; 2002 = 94,6
    - Access to clean drinking water, %: 2001 = 79,6; 2002 = 78,9
  - Note: Kyrgyz methodology for infant mortality differs from WHO; absolute figures not suitable for international comparisons.
- Household survey redesign and statistics improvements:
  - From 2003 NSC restructuring household survey under DFID-funded “Development of Statistics in Support of the CDF/NPRS Process.”
  - Planned changes:
    - increase sample selection from 3000 to 5000 households and move from monthly to quarterly frequency;
    - change procedures for registering incomes/expenditures; introduce new questionnaires including labor use;
    - improved sample selection methodology and rotation; revamped field-work methods.
  - Expected outcomes: better data quality, more accurate oblast-level indicators, new information on employment and living standards.
  - First results for expanded survey to become available in 2004.

### FUNDAMENTAL AREAS OF NPRS DEVELOPMENT — strategic pillars and financing
- Strategic pillars:
  - promote sustainable economic growth;
  - form an effective state;
  - build a fair society providing protection and human development.
- Donor pledges and financing needs:
  - October 2002 Consultative Group pledges: $700 million foreign assistance; about $500 million materialized but further project identification needed (PIP and BOP support).
  - Further Paris Club debt relief needed to resolve external debt problem.
  - Overall financing need for 2005-2010: $900-1000 million, including further Paris Club concessional debt relief.
  - To ensure external debt sustainability, donor assistance should be grants where possible.

### Fiscal framework, public investment, reserves, and competitiveness (Appendix 1 summary)
- Fiscal framework:
  - Gradual decline in overall fiscal deficit to 3 percent in second half of decade; moderate increase in tax revenue relative to GDP.
  - Public investment around 4.5 percent of GDP to support infrastructure.
  - Donor financing to cover gaps enabling increased social program spending in health, education, agriculture.
- Reserves and imports:
  - Maintain gross official reserves around 4.5-5 months of imports.
  - Imports projected to decline from 37 percent of GDP in 2003 to 30 percent in 2010.
- Growth and sector performance:
  - 2002: Real GDP growth = zero; excluding Kumtor and electric power sectors real GDP growth > 3,9%.
  - 2002 sectoral: light industry, food industry, trade grew 8-10% p.a.
  - 2002 GDP components: gross fixed capital accumulation declined by 7,4%; government consumption declined by 0,2%; private consumption rose by 4,7%.
  - 2003: Real GDP growth = 6.7% (exceeding IMF third-year agreements by 1,5%); excluding Kumtor growth = 4,9%.
  - 2003 sectoral production growth: hospitality and catering 22,6%; processing industries 19,2%; trade 11,8%; financial sector 6,0%; transport and communications 5,5%.
  - Agriculture real value added 2003: 3,8% (tendency to slow).
- Inflation, money supply, exchange rate:
  - CPI changes: 2,3% (Dec 2002 vs Dec 2001) in 2002; 5,6% in 2003.
  - Drivers in 2003: October-November bread price jump (bad regional harvest) and oil price increases.
  - Som strengthening vs US$ : 3,4% (2002) and 4,2% (2003).
  - Narrow money supply rose 42,9% (2002) and 31,6% (2003); M2X rose 34,1% (2002) and 33,5% (2003).
  - Monetization (M2X year end): 11,1% of GDP (2001) → 14,6% (2002) → 17,6% (2003).
  - NBKR managed floating exchange rate; currency purchase first nine months of 2003 = 18.1 millions of US dollars.
- Fiscal outcomes and PIP:
  - Consolidated state budget deficit (including current consolidated state budget, PIP, Social Fund): 5,8% GDP (2002) → 5,0% GDP (2003).
  - Tax revenues: 12,4% GDP (2001); 13,9% GDP (2002); 14,8% GDP (2003).
  - Current social expenditures rose from 8,0% to 10,1% of GDP between 2001 and 2002.
  - PIP expenditures: 5,3% GDP (2001) → 5,9% GDP (2002).
  - Debt-service reduction: US$99 million cut in 2001-2004 due to Paris Club restructuring March 2002.
  - Total PIP spending 2003: 3366.6.2 million Soms (81% relative to 2002 level).
  - PIP 2003 allocation: agriculture 37%; education and healthcare 25%; transportation and communication 25%.
  - Realized external funding of investment projects (without grants): 97% of planned; internal co-financing realized 99% of planned.
- Budget transparency and tax administration reforms:
  - Program-based budgeting transfer ongoing but insufficient.
  - Parliamentary hearings extended with civil society participation; budget information published online and in quarterly bulletin.
  - 2003 consolidated budget revenues (incl. official transfers) increased 12,1% nominal vs 2002; tax revenues +13,8%; revenues of budget organizations from paid services +16,6%.
  - Consolidated state budget income reached 19,4% of GDP in 2003; tax revenues 14,3% of GDP.
  - Tax law changes: single profit tax rate 20%; new real estate tax replacing tax on unused production/trade facilities; 100 percent of real estate tax to local budgets.
  - VAT for agricultural products introduced while fixed VAT offset abolished; administrative problems hindered registration of large agricultural producers as VAT payers.
  - Measures: make VAT registration more inclusive; introduce VAT invoices; develop new Tax Code edition in 2004.
  - Institutional reforms: Committee on Revenues replaced state tax and customs inspections; Division on Control over Large Tax-Payers and Participants of External Economic Activity established; new Customs Code adopted; one-stop-shop company registration; common VAT payer personal accounts.

### External debt, trade, current account, capital flows, and reserves
- External debt dynamics:
  - Overall external debt ~110% of GDP during 2001-2003 (132% in 1999).
  - Public foreign debt = 94% of GDP end-2003.
  - Debt-restructuring negotiations under Paris Club Agreement March 7, 2002; agreements with India at signing stage; negotiations with Kuwait continue.
  - Paris Club allows debt conversion into social/environmental programs (example: Germany swapped half of consolidated debt Euro 350,000 into TB program funding).
  - Government plans to seek additional Paris Club relief under “good will stipulation” contingent on PRGF and subsequent IMF-coordinated reform program.
- Trade and current account:
  - 2002: exports of goods +3,7%; exports of services +72,4%; imports of goods (CIF) +25,2%; imports of non-factor services +15,1%.
  - 2002 current account deficit: 2,2% GDP (up from 1,2% in 2001).
  - 2003: exports of goods +18,5%; imports +21,9%; export growth mainly from gold supply; excluding Kumtor export growth = -0,2%.
  - Preliminary 2003: current account deficit declined to 1,6% of GDP due to improving services and factor income balances.
  - Gross direct foreign investment: US$90,1 million (2001) → US$115,7 million (2002).
  - Jan–Sep FDI: US$62.1 million (Jan–Sep 2002) → US$77,5 million (Jan–Sep 2003).
  - NBKR raised gross foreign reserves to 5,7 months of imports; preliminary first nine months 2003 reserves = 5,6 months.
- Balance of Payments and external financing (Appendix 1 — selected exact yearly figures):
  - Current Account: -121 (2002), -104 (2003), -133 (2004), -173 (2005), -150 (2006), -122 (2007), -165 (2008), -198 (2009), -198 (2010), -1365 (Total).
  - Trade Balance: -54 (2002), -83 (2003), -116 (2004), -160 (2005), -161 (2006), -144 (2007), -200 (2008), -245 (2009), -266 (2010), -1429 (Total).
  - Exports: 498 (2002), 590 (2003), 633 (2004), 658 (2005), 703 (2006), 766 (2007), 770 (2008), 784 (2009), 827 (2010), 6230 (Total).
  - Imports: -552 (2002), -673 (2003), -749 (2004), -819 (2005), -864 (2006), -911 (2007), -970 (2008), -1029 (2009), -1093 (2010), -7659 (Total).
  - Private Transfers (Net): 0 (2002), 17 (2003), 21 (2004), 25 (2005), 28 (2006), 28 (2007), 30 (2008), 30 (2009), 35 (2010), 214 (Total).
  - Debt Rescheduling (Paris Club Flow Relief): 19 (2002), 44 (2003), 48 (2004), 0 (2005), 0 (2006), 0 (2007), 0 (2008), 0 (2009), 0 (2010), 111 (Total).
  - Additional Financing Needed: 0 (2002), 0 (2003), 0 (2004), 76 (2005), 142 (2006), 166 (2007), 183 (2008), 186 (2009), 179 (2010), 932 (Total).

### Financial sector developments, banking reform and non-bank institutions
- Banking and NBKR:
  - NBKR average rate: 7,95% (2001); 4,4% (2002); 4,0% (2003).
  - Weighted average interest on commercial bank loans in national currency: 36,4% (2001); 30,2% (2002); 25,1% (2003).
  - Interest rate on loans in foreign currency: 25,0% (2001); 22,6% (2002); 19,2% (2003).
  - Bank lending volumes: +26,6% (2002 vs 2001); +44% (2003 vs 2002).
  - Deposit base increased: +29,6% (2002); +30% (2003).
  - Financial intermediation and service quality remain below needs for accelerated growth.
  - Payment system improvements: automated clearing with e-documents operational in 2003; Central Treasury connecting.
  - Banking regulation per Banking Reform Strategy to strengthen capital base, efficiency, depositor protection (Law on Protection of Deposits), and supervision.
  - Regulatory capital adequacy (as of September 1, 2003): aggregate capital adequacy coefficient = 33.8%; lowest admissible level = 12% for one bank.
  - Privatization measures: bids for Kairat bank; three commercial proposals received.
- Non-bank financial institutions:
  - KAFC loan portfolio 2003: increased by 27,6% to Soms 1276,2 million.
  - Microfinance organizations (MFOs) as of January 1, 2004: 72 registered; total loan portfolio Soms 433,9 million (0,5% of GDP).
  - Credit unions as of January 2004: 303 registered; 24,7 thousand members; credit portfolio Soms 288,8 million; assets Soms 317,2 million (15–19% higher than last year).
  - Securities market: legislative acts developed to integrate corporate and state securities markets, expand instruments, protect investors; EuropeAid TACIS project to support non-bank sector.
- Deposit protection: Concept of Deposit Protection System and law being elaborated.

### Investment climate, privatization, enterprise restructuring
- Investment promotion:
  - Third Investment Summit chaired by President; Investment Matrix IV underway after fulfilling three matrices.
  - Advisory Council on Foreign Investments transformed into regular working body.
  - FDI grew 28% in 2002 vs 2001; first nine months 2003 FDI +24,8% vs same period 2002.
- Privatization and enterprise management:
  - International tender for sale of 51% of JSC Kyrgyztelekom in June 2003.
  - Activities to transfer JSC Severelektro to concession or trustee management; tender for JSC Kyrgyzneftegas trustee management invited.
  - Program of Privatization of State Property 2004-2006 finalized for Jogorku Kenesh approval.
  - As of January 1, 2004:
    - Share of privatized enterprises in economy: 70,7%
    - Share of GDP produced by private sector: 85%

### Electric energy sector and quasi-fiscal deficit (QFD)
- Electric energy sector constrained by high QFD threatening macro stability and social programs.
- Government considers QFD reduction integral to stabilization and NPRS implementation.
- 2003: quantitative QFD parameters in electric energy sector established within PRGF.
- 2004 QFD reduction measures: lower commercial losses and raise level of cash payments.

### Medium-Term Budget Framework (MTBF) 2005-2007 — macro strategy, projections, and targets
- MTBF purpose: focus state resources on NPRS priorities and increase resource-use efficiency.
- Macroeconomic outlook and policy stance:
  - MTBF projects average economic growth of 5% per year during projection period.
  - Growth drivers: private investment (domestic and foreign direct investment) and exports.
  - Anticipated Kumtor downturn partly offset by Taldy-Bulak Levoberezhnyi and Jerui deposits.
  - Policies: strict monetary policy to keep annual inflation at 4%; managed floating exchange rate; attract FDI; strengthen financial intermediation; structural reforms to raise productivity; governance reforms targeted at transparency and corporate governance; social policy targeting social security, employment, education and healthcare accessibility.
- MTBF quantitative excerpts (Table 2 — preserve exact figures as presented):
  - Header: 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 (Actual | Expected | Forecasted)
  - Nominal GDP, bln. Soms: 83.491.8100.5 110.5 121.47
  - Real GDP growth rate, %: 6.74.04.5 5.3 5.2
  - GDP composition, %:
    - Private consumption: 68.36968.5 67.4 66.0
    - Government consumption: 17.517.917.7 17.7 17.1
    - Gross investments: 18.018.119.8 20.3 20.6
    - Public investment: 5.33.93.5 3.1 3.2
  - PIP (external funding): 4.43.53.2 2.9 2.8
  - Private investment: 12.714.216.3 17.2 17.4
  - Net export: -0.3-5.2-6.1 -5.4 -3.7
  - Export of goods and services: 36.737.436.3 35.3 35.2
  - Import of goods and services: 3742.642.4 40.7 38.9
  - Rates of production growth by industries, %:
    - Agriculture: 3.84.24.6 4.6 4.4
    - Industry: -17.40.10.0 5.3 5.8
    - Construction: -6.86.07.0 7.0 8.0
    - Services: 6.05.66.2 5.9 5.9
  - Inflation rate, CPI, %: 5.63.84.0 4.0 4.0
  - Public foreign debt, % of GDP: 93.185.182.6 79.3 74.0
  - Poverty level, %: 40.838.636.0 32.9 30.2
  - Consolidated state budget deficit, % of GDP: 5.04.44.0 3.2 2.9
  - Quasi-fiscal deficit in electric power, % of GDP: 10.49.27.7 6.2 4.8
- MTBF fiscal strategy and debt management:
  - Maintain state revenue ~2003 levels while increasing internal income share and lowering external grants share; decrease state spending via improved budget processes and reduced PIP.
  - Revenue measures: tax administration improvements, corruption reduction, tax base expansion, step-by-step abandonment of production tax, reductions in Social Fund payment rates, increased role for indirect taxes.
  - External debt strategy:
    - Reduce PIP to 3% of GDP by 2006.
    - New borrowing only on sufficiently concessional terms with at least 45% grant element.
    - Three quarters of privatization revenues to be used for advance payments to creditors.
    - Explore settling non-concessional loans in exchange for assets.
    - Even under optimistic assumptions, NPV of debt to export ratio not expected to fall below 150% until 2010.
    - Improvement requires Paris Club Naples terms restructuring in December 2004.
- Risks and scenarios:
  - MTBF base case relatively optimistic about external shocks.
  - Downside risks: weak export growth or low state revenues could worsen external debt servicing, reduce growth, and impede social program implementation.
  - Government priority: maintain macro stability and achieve CDF/NPRS MTBF targets.

### Governance, public administration, judiciary, and decentralization reforms
- Constitutional and legislative reforms:
  - New Constitution 2003 transferred many powers from President to Jogorku Kenesh, Government, judiciary and local self-government.
  - Decree “On Measures for Practical Implementation of the New Constitution ... and Targets for Sustainable Development and Poverty Reduction for 2003” set legislative and administrative tasks.
- Public administration reform:
  - National Council on Good Governance develops strategy to reform public administration for effective social benefit delivery.
  - Regulation on Law Drafting approved; Center for Coordination of Government Law Drafting established in Ministry of Justice; State Commission for Revision of Laws and Regulations established.
  - Ministry of Justice built centralized legislative database with World Bank Legal Information System Project; holds over 24,000 laws and regulatory documents.
- Judiciary and law enforcement:
  - Merger of Supreme Court and Highest Arbitration Court envisaged; local court judges elected by Jogorku Kenesh; new rights/procedures for Supreme Court and citizen participation introduced.
  - Diagnostic study of judiciary prepared with ADB support; pilot automation and electronic databases for courts under World Bank grant.
  - Reforms in law enforcement and penitentiary: Chief Division for Penalty Execution moved to Ministry of Justice; concept papers and presidential decrees on prosecution bodies and disciplinary responsibility implemented.
- Civil service reform and decentralization:
  - Thirty ministries and state agencies underwent functional reviews; nine divisions, 57 departments and 39 subunits eliminated; 110 functions eliminated; 125 functions transformed.
  - Jogorku Kenesh adopted Law “On Government of Kyrgyz Republic” structuring government into twelve ministries and two State Committees; planned reorganization includes Ministry of Economic Development, Industry and Trade.
  - National Strategy for Decentralization and Development of Local Self-Government until 2010 approved (Presidential decree December 17, 2002); Coordination Council chaired by First Vice Prime Minister.
  - Real estate tax enabled in urban areas; salaries of heads of aiyl okmotu doubled; Finance & Economic Departments established in all aiyl okmotu.
  - Staff rationalizations in 2002 cut government staff by 7,3%; savings Soms35,0 million.
- Public financial management:
  - Concept paper on Reforming Ministry of Finance System and Central Treasury 2002-2005 developed with IMF technical support.
  - Central Treasury improvements: cash flow forecasting, control of obligations, state financial accounts ordering.
  - GTAC to fully automate treasury operations.

### Public financial management, budgeting, and procurement
- Program-based budgeting:
  - Ministries and state agencies instructed to submit program-based budgets.
  - 2-year Resource Agreement pilot between Ministry of Education and Culture and Ministry of Finance granted management and HR flexibilities.
  - DFID-developed formats to be included in 2005 budget to integrate capital and current resource allocations.
- Treasury and off-budget accounts:
  - Committee on forming of financial plan under Central Treasury regulates cash and inclusion of off-budget accounts (State Property Fund, State Fund of Material Reserves, Economic Development Fund, SME Support Fund).
- Procurement and audit:
  - Restructuring of State Committee on State Procurement and Material Reserves; regular bulletin published.
  - Chamber of Accounts restructuring to align with INTOSAI standards; ministries created external audit departments.
- Tax and customs reforms:
  - Strategy of Fiscal Reform to 2005 and new Tax Code edition prepared; Law limiting enactment timing of Tax Code amendments adopted (changes approved by 1 November and enforced after 1 January).
  - Draft new Customs Code harmonized with international standards submitted to Jogorku Kenesh.

### Civil service, corporate governance, anti-corruption, and transparency
- Civil service reforms:
  - National Committee on Civil Service created February 7, 2004.
  - Two draft laws to divide political and public career positions and create mechanisms for honesty in high posts prepared with World Bank coordination.
  - Recruitment via competitive selection: 70% central ministries, 57% regional government, 69,3% government administration and local self-governance bodies.
  - Attestation in 2003: ~7000 civil servants certified; 1179 central specialists; 5776 regional specialists; 513 local government specialists.
  - 74% of newly hired specialists have higher education in technical sciences, economics, agriculture, or law; women account for 43% of hires via competition in 2002.
  - Two learning centers created under Academy of Management; 15 mln. soms envisaged for training in 2004 state budget.
- Corporate governance:
  - Law "On Joint Stock Companies" enacted; Laws "On Accounting" and "On Auditing Activities" adopted in 2002 to support IAS/IFRS introduction.
  - Draft Concept Paper on Development of Corporate Governance to 2006 developed.
  - Amendments to banking law to strengthen corporate governance, creditor rights, valuation, board committees, and conflict of interest rules.
- Anti-corruption and good governance:
  - State Program for Strengthening Public Order and Fighting Corruption regularly updated.
  - Law "On Fighting Corruption" in force; draft Law on “Fighting financing of terrorism and laundry of income received by dishonest way” prepared.
  - National Council for Good Governance established (chaired by Prime Minister; 25 members) with Secretariat for Good Governance; sessions open to media unless closed by Council decision.
  - Assessment: anticorruption activities to date “have not achieved their goals and the work must be substantially intensified.”

### Anti-corruption, deregulation, and business environment
- Deregulation:
  - Concept of economy deregulation approved to realize constitutional rights to private property and economic freedom, define state interference types and deny excessive bureaucratic regulation.
  - Law on basics of technical regulation expected to advance deregulation; institutional capacity required.
- Measures against interference and corruption:
  - Prosecutors’ offices tasked to act against civil servants breaching decrees, including dismissals.
  - Central Department on fighting economic crime and corruption of Ministry of Internal Affairs reorganized.
  - Tougher income declaration requirements for civil servants under preparation.
- Business environment outcomes:
  - Privatization and regulatory reforms aim to reduce state interference and increase investment friendliness.

### Social policies — protection, pensions, employment, education, health, gender, environment
- Social protection and targeting:
  - Social security benefits and allowances increased by 20%.
  - Privileged target groups defined for cash compensations for medicines and coal.
  - Draft Law “On State Social Benefits” and draft Law “On Amendments to Several Laws” envisaging targeted benefits prepared.
  - UMB: share of population receiving UMB in 2003 increased by 1,1% vs 2002.
    - Preliminary calculations: revised regulation will decrease UMB recipients by 17% and allocated sum by 21%; savings to increase guaranteed minimal consumption level (GMCL).
    - Ratio GMCL to minimal consumption budget in 2003: 8,6% (2001 = 10,1%).
  - Social passportization covers almost 100% of poor families (>650 thousand families); enhanced form to be introduced in 2004.
  - Compensations for energy tariff rises: resources increased by 78% in 2003 vs previous year; pilot simplified electric power compensations in three districts; Bishkek subsidies: 5000 people received them in 2003.
  - State Program “New Generation” to 2010 implemented; Family Code adopted; Code on Children being developed.
- Pensions and social insurance:
  - Average retirement pension benefits increased by 10%; minimum pension for servicemen increased by 15%; personal retirement account savings indexation +11,8%.
  - Recalculation of pensions for working pensioners made annually; growth rates: 100% (2003) vs 101% (2002).
  - Planned 2004 average pension increase: 9%.
  - Concept Paper for phased transition to accumulative pension system; accumulative principle not for those with <10 years to retirement.
  - Draft law “On investment of funds to finance accumulative pension component...” prepared.
  - Non-Government Pension Funds: 1 operating fund; draft law to grant commercial status prepared.
  - Social Fund: 10,8% increase in collected social insurance premiums in 2003 vs 2002; pension payments made without delays.
  - Base part of retirement pension ratio to minimal consumption budget: decreased from 19,7% (2000) to 17,0% (2003); base part set at 226,6 soms since Jan 2004 (+11%).
- Labor market and employment:
  - Unemployment level: 8,7% (2003).
  - Labor Market Policy Paper to 2010 drafted with EC TACIS support.
  - Law simplifying unemployment benefit eligibility passed.
  - Selective household survey on employment with DFID support.
  - New Labor Code adopted in first reading to liberalize labor relations.
  - Active measures: training unemployed; paid public/community works; micro-lending for start-ups; business incubators regionally.
- Education:
  - Education Development Concept to 2010 implemented; Law “On education” adopted.
  - Preschool coverage: 9,9% (2003) vs 9,5% (2001).
  - Basic secondary education coverage: 94,8% (2003) vs 94,6% (2002).
  - 800 000 textbooks planned for 2004.
  - Nationwide testing for graduates (USAID support); independent testing agency established, to be self-financed from 2005.
  - Vocational schools: 113; Development Strategy for Vocational and Higher Professional Education adopted.
- Health:
  - National healthcare programs: “Healthcare of Kyrgyzstan in XXI Century”, Manas National Healthcare Reform II.
  - Health sector state budget funding 2003: 2.0% of GDP (2000 = 2.1%).
  - New financing approaches in Jalal-Abad, Batken, Bishkek, Osh effective Jan 1, 2004.
  - Result: medicines provision spending increased 2,2 times on average; hospital wages growth 1,7 times; primary level wages growth 1,3 times.
  - Law “On Single Payer System in Healthcare Finance” approved; Mandatory Medical Insurance Fund established.
  - MMI coverage: 81,8% (2003) vs 86,2% (2002).
  - Additional MMI medicines program reduced population payments to average 46.1% of medicine cost (2002 = 50,8%).
  - Immunization: 96-97% coverage planned; no new poliomyelitis, tetanus, diphtheria cases.
  - HIV/AIDS cases: 132 new cases in 2003 (125 citizens); 160 cases in 2002 (146 citizens).
- Gender equity:
  - New Constitution secured gender equity principle.
  - National Plan for Gender Equity 2002-2006 implemented.
  - Laws: “On Social and Legal Protection against Family Violence”; “On Basics of State Guarantees for Gender Equity”; Law joining Optional Protocol to CEDAW.
  - Development Index with gender factor: 0,723 (2003) vs 0,718 (2002).
  - Education shares (girls): primary 49%; secondary 50,2%; secondary special vocational 64,4%; higher education 53,9%.
  - Employment shares (women): healthcare/social 74,5%; education 73,9%; agriculture 42,8%; trade 45,7%.
- Environment and disaster risk:
  - In 2002, 62.2 mln tons of toxic wastages accumulated; 75% classified as most harmful.
  - Environmental legislation improved: Law “on Environmental Examination”; draft Law on Production wastage.
  - Disaster prevention measures and state programs for floods, seismic security, and other emergencies being drafted.
  - Central Asian Institute of Applied Earth Studies established in Bishkek.

### Public investment, sectoral spending, and MTBF expenditure ceilings (2004-2007 selected figures)
- State expenditures (% of GDP) (selected figures from Table 3):
  - Total: 27.4 (2004), 27.2 (2005), 26.8 (2006), 26.1 (2007)
  - incl. investment expenditures: 4.4 (2004), 4.6 (2005), 4.6 (2006), 4.5 (2007)
  - Social services: 15.4 (2004), 15.9 (2005), 16.3 (2006), 16.5 (2007)
    - Education: 4.2 (2004), 4.6 (2005), 5.0 (2006), 5.3 (2007)
      - incl. investment expenditures: 0.3 (2004), 0.4 (2005), 0.7 (2006), 0.8 (2007)
    - Health care: 2.0 (2004), 2.1 (2005), 2.3 (2006), 2.4 (2007)
      - incl. investment expenditures: 0.4 (2004), 0.3 (2005), 0.3 (2006), 0.4 (2007)
    - Social insurance and social security: 7.6 (2004), 7.6 (2005), 7.5 (2006), 7.5 (2007)
  - Government services: 1.0 (2004), 1.0 (2005), 0.9 (2006), 0.8 (2007)
  - Economic services: 6.2 (2004), 6.0 (2005), 5.5 (2006), 5.2 (2007)
    - Agriculture: 2.1 (2004), 2.0 (2005), 1.9 (2006), 1.4 (2007)
      - incl. investment expenditures: 1.6 (2004), 1.4 (2005), 1.0 (2006), 0.9 (2007)
    - Transport and communications: 2.0 (2004), 2.0 (2005), 1.8 (2006), 1.7 (2007)
      - incl. investment expenditures: 1.1 (2004), 1.0 (2005), 1.1 (2006), 0.9 (2007)
  - Payment of interest on public debt: 1.2 (2004), 0.9 (2005), 0.9 (2006), 0.7 (2007)
- Sectoral spending growth and reform measures:
  - Education funding projected +46% over three years in real terms; investment spending to grow rapidly; teachers’ wages to rise subject to higher standard teaching loads.
  - Healthcare expenditures to grow by 39% during 2004-2007; completion of network restructuring; single payer system rollout; improved medicines policy and MMI.
  - Social insurance and security to grow ~14% over three years; focus on UMB and support for poorest strata.
  - Aggregate social spending of consolidated state budget to grow by 1.1% of GDP in 2004-2007 or by 24% in real terms; share in consolidated budget to rise from 56% (2004) to 63% (2007).
  - Economic services expenditures to decrease by 1% of GDP over three years reflecting privatization and self-financing transitions.

### Public Investment Program (PIP), donor coordination, and commitments
- PIP adjustments and pipeline:
  - Decrease in PIP expenditures needed to reduce external debt.
  - Expected PIP loans: US$ 60-80 billion per year conforming to PRGF terms.
  - During projection period: 18 new loan-financed projects and 7 grant projects expected; focus on agriculture, transport, energy, education, healthcare, regional development.
  - World Bank and ADB to play major PIP financing roles; timely co-financing required; development grants important for state-budget funding.
- Selected donor commitments and figures:
  - IMF: total credits 21,2.mln SDR in 2003; 1st installment 11,7 mln. SDR (March 5, 2003); 2nd installment 9,6 mln. SDR (July 30, 2003).
  - World Bank: Board approved Strategy 2003-2006 (May 15, 2003); total aid for three years = 171 mln.; US$ 65,0 mln. grant-based.
  - ADB: Memorandum June 2003 for 2004-2006 — US$ 90 mln. loans with privileged terms; annual technical assistance ~US$ 2 mln.
  - EU Food Security Program: annual grant 9,5 mln. Euro since 1996.
  - MID (UK): 10 projects in 2003 totaling 9,7 mln. pounds sterling.
  - Islamic Development Bank: 2003 technical assistance grant US$ 130 000 for micro-financing development.
  - Switzerland: grants and support — 2002-2003 received US% 5 mln. for social security; in 2003 provided around US$19 mln. for projects.
  - Germany: Technical cooperation resources 4 mln. Euro (2003-2004); financial cooperation 16,0 mln. Euro (9,0 mln. loan, 7 mln. grant, 3 mln. attendant measures).
  - Japan: grant aid US$ 10,5 (2002 realized in 2003); JICA technical assistance for training and expert support.

### Monitoring, evaluation systems, institutional capacity and MES rollout
- Monitoring and evaluation systems:
  - Special software to be installed to conduct and manage monitoring and evaluation processes (Paragraph 236).
  - Concrete plan for further development of MES being developed; donor coordination on MES envisaged (Paragraph 241).
- Institutional capacity and training:
  - Fundamental problems: lack of knowledge/skills in data collection, analysis and interpretation among administrators (Paragraph 237).
  - Planned response: use international experts for seminars and training on MES methods (Paragraph 238).
- Web transparency and stakeholder engagement:
  - Official CDF/NPRS website established including MES key elements; forum for discussion with population organized online (Paragraph 239).
  - MES results to be provided to all interested parties for discussion and feedback (Paragraph 240).
- MES components and structure:
  - MES tracks NPRS indicators, line programs, legal documents, NGO surveys, financial resource distribution, donor aid database, media materials, and seminars/round tables.
  - Two indicator databases: one for data collection/analysis; second for Internet publication.
  - National Statistics Committee included and fills its component; line ministries and regions to be included.
  - MES rollout: five information rings covering Bishkek, Osh, oblasts, rayons, aiyl okmotu and villages; users include state agencies, private sector, NGOs and population; 20 public access centers exist for MES work.

### NPRS monitoring indicators (Appendix 2 — selected exact figures)
- International indicators:
  - Human development index: 0,719 (2000); 0,723 (2001); 0,724∗ (2002); 0,728∗ (2003)
  - Population poverty index: 8,4 (2000); 8,7 (2001); 13,4∗ (2002)
  - Development index with gender factor: 0,715 (2000); 0,717 (2001); 0,718∗ (2002); 0,723∗ (2003)
  - Note: ∗ Preliminary data
- Macroeconomic performance:
  - Real GDP growth rate (%): 105,4 (2000); 105,3 (2001); 100,0 (2002); 106,7 (2003)
  - CPI (% to same period previous year): 118,7 (2000); 106,9 (2001); 102,0 (2002); 103,1 (2003)
  - Avg official US$-som exchange rate (soms per US$): 47,7 (2000); 48,4 (2001); 46,9 (2002); 43,7 (2003)
  - Current account % of GDP: -5,8 (2000); -1,2 (2001); -2,0 (2002); 2,6 (2003)
- Public finance and budget:
  - State budget revenue /GDP (%): 15,3 (2000); 17,0 (2001); 19,1 (2002); 18,3 (2003)
  - Tax inflows /GDP (%): 11,7 (2000); 12,4 (2001); 13,9 (2002); 14,3 (2003)
  - Volume of tax receipts from privatized enterprises (mln. soms): 925,4 (2000); 1048,9 (2001); 1099,2 (2002); 225,1 (2003)
- Financial system:
  - Gross foreign reserves NBKR (mln. US$): 261,1 (2000); 285,2 (2001); 316,7 (2002); 389,0 (2003)
  - Monetization (avg annual) (%): 10,6 (2000); 10,0 (2001); 12,5 (2002); 15,1 (2003)
  - Share of loans /GDP (%): 3,4 (2000); 3,7 (2001); 4,5 (2002); 14,6 (2003)
  - NBKR rate (%): 38,3 (2000); 8,0 (2001); 4,4 (2002); 4,0 (2003)
- Labor, poverty and social outcomes:
  - Unemployment total (%): 7,5 (2000); 7,8 (2001); 8,6 (2002); 8,7 (2003)
  - Poverty level (%): 52,0 (2000); 47,6 (2001); 44,4 (2002); 40,8 (2003)
  - Extreme poverty level (%): 17,8 (2000); 13,5 (2001); 13,8 (2002); 9,4 (2003)
  - Gini coefficient (index): 0,449 (2000); 0,441 (2001); 0,419 (2002); ...
  - Share population receiving UMB (%): 9,8 (2000); 10,3 (2001); 9,5 (2002); 10,6 (2003)
- Children, education, health (selected):
  - Coverage preschool (%): 8,7 (2000); 9,0 (2001); 9,5 (2002); 9,9 (2003)
  - Coverage basic secondary (grades 1–9) (%): 95,9 (2000); 95,0 (2001); 94,6 (2002); 94,8 (2003)
  - Literacy (15+), %: 98,7 (2000); 98,7 (2001); 98,7 (2002); 98,7 (2003)
  - Share covered by mandatory medical insurance (%): 73,0 (2000); 83,7 (2001); 86,2 (2002); 81,8 (2003)
  - Number HIV/AIDS cases (total/citizens): 16/4 (2000); 149/134 (2001); 160/146 (2002); 132/125 (2003)

### Key policy directions and 2004 priorities (programmatic conclusions)
- 2004 main economic policy focuses:
  - strengthen macroeconomic stabilization;
  - support sustainable pro-poor economic growth;
  - improve coordination of budgetary and monetary policies;
  - improve transparency of state financial management;
  - reduce external debt burden;
  - create favorable investment environment.
- Structural and fiscal priorities:
  - reduce quasi-fiscal deficit in electric power sector;
  - strict expenditure control and focus resources on NPRS priorities;
  - program-based budgeting introduction at sectoral and local levels;
  - revenue policy: predictability and transparency via tax administration improvements and tax base expansion;
  - monetary policy target: keep inflation under 4% with floating exchange rate and targeted interventions.
- Social policy priorities in 2004:
  - job creation and labor market liberalization under State Labor Market Policy to 2010;
  - focus social security on poorest strata and social mobilization;
  - implement pension reform concept paper and expand non-government pension system;
  - implement Education Development Concept to 2010 and Manas Healthcare Reform II to increase accessibility and quality.
- Monitoring, evaluation and institutional reform continuation:
  - install MES software, train administrators, expand MES coverage and web transparency; prioritize activities according to NPRS goals and raise effectiveness in use of financial resources.

_Italic: Source — INTRODUCTION; I. REDUCTION OF POVERTY IN 2002-2003; II. FUNDAMENTAL AREAS OF NPRS DEVELOPMENT; Appendix 1; Appendix 2 and selected sections (excerpts) of the Kyrgyz Republic NPRS progress report (PDF content unit)._

### INTRODUCTION ...........................................................................................................

### INTRODUCTION

### Overview and purpose
- The Kyrgyz Republic is one of 13 pilot countries where a Comprehensive Development Framework (CDF) paper for the Kyrgyz Republic was developed to the year 2010; it was approved in May 2001.
- The National Poverty Reduction Strategy, 2003-2005 (NPRS) is the first phase in the implementation of the CDF in the Kyrgyz Republic. It was adopted as a medium-term action program for the Government of the Kyrgyz Republic to conduct dynamic economic, social, and political reforms to ensure human development and the reduction of poverty and avoid food insecurity.
- The CDF and NPRS were formulated on the basis of a partnership involving all branches of state authority and civil society of the Kyrgyz Republic, in close cooperation with the World Bank, IMF, and other international institutions, and on the basis of the National Food Security Policy approved in October 1999.
- The NPRS was endorsed at the October 2002 Consultative Group meeting in Bishkek.

### Donor coordination and program alignment
- In February 2003, the IMF Executive Council and World Bank Board of Directors approved three-year country assistance programs for Kyrgyzstan developed in consideration of NPRS priorities; the NPRS was endorsed at that time.
- Programs with other multilateral and bilateral donors are developed in a similar manner, consistent with agreements reached in Johannesburg, Monterrey, London, and Rome.
- The goals and objectives of CDF and NPRS are consistent with the Millennium Declaration Development Goals; Kyrgyzstan prepared a National Report on the Achievement of Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) in September 2003.

### Content and basis of this report
- This document is the first progress report on implementation of the NPRS in the Kyrgyz Republic and includes main outcomes of reforms conducted in 2002-2003.
- The report reflects implementation of policy measures envisaged in agreements signed under the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) with the IMF, as well as the World Bank Country Assistance Strategy and accompanying memorandums.
- The analysis finds that, despite difficulties and unresolved issues, measures undertaken under the CDF and NPRS have helped create a foundation for promising results in economic growth, governance quality, and poverty reduction.
- In 2004 the Government intends to make additional efforts to prioritize measures in accordance with NPRS goals and raise the effectiveness of the use of available financial resources.
- The President declared 2004 a year for social mobilization and good governance; planned measures will focus on maximum mobilization of the country’s capacity to implement CDF and NPRS priorities.
- The report was prepared by ministries and state agencies and CDF/NPRS expert working groups; materials were discussed by expert working groups and approved by CDF/NPRS coordination committees and regional councils.
- The report is also based on studies and analytical materials developed by the World Bank, IMF, other international institutions and NGOs within the CDF/NPRS partnership.

*Source: INTRODUCTION (pages 3-5) of the Kyrgyz Republic NPRS progress report*

### II. REDUCTION OF POVERTY IN 2002-2003

### Conceptual approach and data sources
- NPRS activities are based on the concept of human poverty, using monetary and non-monetary poverty measures.
- Monetary poverty indicators are based on a selective survey of over 3000 households conducted by the National Statistics Committee (NSC) using a methodology agreed with the World Bank.
- Welfare measurement criteria used: a) per capita expenditures (baseline criterion), b) per capita consumption, and c) per adult equivalent consumption. Main poverty indicators (poverty level and extreme poverty level) are calculated for all three criteria.

### Trends in monetary poverty (2000–2003)
- The report documents a significant reduction in poverty under any criterion.
- In 2002 the poverty level declined by 3,2%.
- Poverty reduction relative to 1999 (peak poverty year) amounted to 10,9%.
- Preliminary 2003 data indicate a poverty level of 40,8% and a decline of 3,6% compared with 2002; final 2003 data were to be ready at the end of April of that year.
- Rural poverty in 2002 amounted to 47% (compared to 60% in 1999 and 51% in 2001).
- Urban poverty in 2002 was 39,6% (compared to 42,4% in 1999 and 41,2% in 2001).
- The poor in rural areas account for 70% of the total number of poor (the share of the rural population in the population of the country is 65,3%).
- In 2002, poverty reduction was recorded in all oblasts except Batken oblast (measurement problems in 2001 noted). Over 10% poverty reduction was achieved in Issyk-Kul oblast and Talas oblast.

### Extreme poverty and distributional change
- Level of extreme poverty in 2002: 13,8%; in 2001: 13,5% (increase of 0,3% is within measurement accuracy).
- Extreme poverty in rural areas declined from 15,6% in 2001 to 14,7% in 2002.
- Extreme poverty in urban areas rose from 9,6% in 2001 to 12,0% in 2002 (mostly due to Bishkek and internal migrants).
- Gini coefficient of expenditures increased from 0,320 in 2001 to 0,328 in 2002.
  - Urban Gini rose from 0,313 to 0,336.
  - Rural Gini declined from 0,351 to 0,321.
- Quintile coefficient (ratio of average expenditure of the wealthiest 20% to the poorest 20%) increased from 4,8 in 2001 to 5,2 in 2002.
- The pattern suggests reforms allow those closer to the poverty line to benefit more than the poorest strata; internal migration from rural to urban areas is a contributing factor.

### Non-monetary indicators and basic services
- Infant mortality in 2002: 21,2‰ (declined by 0,5‰ in 2002). In 2003, compared to 2002, infant mortality further declined by 1.4%.
- Birth rate: increased from 19,8‰ in 2001 to 20,2‰ in 2002.
- Preliminary 2003 results for the first nine months report an increase in the average nutritional value of food consumed by the three poorest quintiles.
- Accessibility indicators (Table 1):
  - Literacy, %: 2001 = 98,7; 2002 = 98,7
  - Coverage of children with basic education (grades 1-9), %: 2001 = 95,0; 2002 = 94,6
  - Access to clean drinking water, %: 2001 = 79,6; 2002 = 78,9
- Note: Methodology for measuring infant mortality in Kyrgyzstan differs from WHO, so absolute figures are not suitable for international comparisons.

### Improvements in poverty statistics and household survey redesign
- Starting in 2003 the National Statistics Committee commenced restructuring the household survey (main source of poverty data) under the DFID-funded project “Development of Statistics in Support of the CDF/NPRS Process.”
- Planned improvements include:
  - increasing sample selection from 3000 to 5000 households with transition from monthly to quarterly survey frequency;
  - changing procedures for registering income and expenditures by households;
  - introducing new survey questionnaires including labor use and various poverty indicators;
  - improved methodology of sample selection and rotation of households;
  - revamped methods of organizing and conducting field work.
- Expected outcomes: better data quality; greater accuracy and consistency of indicators (especially at oblast level); new information on poverty aspects, employment and living standards; expanded analytical opportunities.
- Consideration is being given to the possibility of obtaining data in the old format to ensure comparability over time.
- First results for the expanded household survey will become available in 2004.

*Source: I. REDUCTION OF POVERTY IN 2002-2003 (pages 5-8) of the Kyrgyz Republic NPRS progress report*

### II. FUNDAMENTAL AREAS OF NPRS DEVELOPMENT

### Strategic pillars and priorities
- The Government groups policy priorities around three main NPRS objectives:
  - promoting sustainable economic growth;
  - formation of an effective state;
  - building a fair society providing protection and human development.
- The Government recognizes the need to concentrate efforts and resources on fundamental development areas to achieve best results.

### Financing requirements and donor pledges
- At the October 2002 Consultative Group meeting in Bishkek, donors pledged $700 million of foreign assistance to support the Kyrgyz Republic’s Poverty Reduction Strategy. Most of these pledges are being materialized (about $500 million) but further identification of projects is still needed, particularly for the Public Investment Program and balance-of-payments support.
- For resolving the external debt problem, further debt relief is needed.
- The overall financing need for the period 2005-2010 amounts to $900-1000 million, including a further Paris Club debt relief on concessional terms.
- To ensure external debt sustainability during this decade, as much as possible of donor assistance should come in the form of grants.

*Source: II. FUNDAMENTAL AREAS OF NRPS DEVELOPMENT (pages 8-9) of the Kyrgyz Republic NPRS progress report*

### Appendix  1  is  consistent  with  our  Medium-term  Fiscal  Framework  (Chapter  II.1.2)  which  is

### Appendix 1 is consistent with our Medium-term Fiscal Framework (Chapter II.1.2) which is

### Fiscal framework, public investment, and social spending
- Framework based on a gradual decline in the overall fiscal deficit to 3 percent in the second half of the decade and a moderate increase in tax revenue relative to GDP.
- Ensures public investment at about 4.5 percent of GDP to support infrastructure upgrades that would positively affect private sector growth.
- Covering the financing gap through donor assistance would allow increases in spending on social programs and poverty reduction relative to GDP and cover expenses in priority sectors—health, education, and agriculture (see Section III).

### Reserves, imports, and competitiveness
- Donor assistance would allow maintaining gross official reserves at around 4.5-5 months of imports to mitigate vulnerability to external shocks, volatile gold and oil prices, and future external debt obligations.
- Imports of goods projected to decline from 37 percent of GDP in 2003 to 30 percent in 2010.
- Requires domestic producers to maintain cost competitiveness and gain market shares; with sound macroeconomic policies, imports should increasingly concentrate on capital goods and technological transfer to support investment and growth.

### GDP growth developments and sectoral performance
- 2002: Real GDP growth equaled zero, affected mainly by shocks in gold mining (Kumtor) and electric power sectors; real GDP growth excluding these two sectors increased by more than 3,9%.
- Notable growth (8-10% per annum) in light industry, the food industry, and trade in 2002.
- Components of GDP in 2002 vs 2001: gross fixed capital accumulation declined by 7,4% and government consumption declined by 0,2%, while private consumption rose by 4,7%.
- 2003: Real GDP growth amounted to 6.7%, exceeding the IMF third year agreements by 1,5% (within PRGF framework); excluding Kumtor, real growth equaled 4,9%.
- 2003 sectoral production growth: hospitality and catering 22,6%; processing industries 19,2%; trade 11,8%; financial sector 6,0%; transport and communications 5,5%.
- Agricultural sector: real value added increased by only 3,8% (2003), with a tendency of slowing growth rates.

### Inflation, money supply, and exchange rate policy
- Consumer price index changes: 2,3% (December 2002 to December 2001) in 2002; 5,6% in 2003.
- Inflation increase in 2003 driven by October-November jump in bread prices (bad regional harvest) and oil price increases.
- Strengthening of the som vs US dollar: 3,4% in 2002 and 4,2% in 2003.
- Money supply increases: narrow money supply rose by 42,9% in 2002 and by 31,6% in 2003; monetary aggregate М2X rose by 34,1% in 2002 and by 33,5% in 2003.
- Monetization (М2X at year end) rose from 11,1% of GDP in 2001 to 14,6% in 2002 and 17,6% in 2003.
- NBKR continued managed floating of the exchange rate, intervening to moderate temporary fluctuations; for the first nine months of 2003 currency purchase amounted to 18.1 millions of US dollars.
- Anti-inflationary monetary policy will be maintained and may need to compensate for price effects of fiscal and structural measures (e.g., VAT extension to large agricultural enterprises or changes in administratively regulated prices).
- Real exchange rate: strengthening of the nominal som did not cause substantial changes in the real exchange rate with respect to currencies of main importers of Kyrgyzstan's goods and services.

### Fiscal outcomes, budget composition, and PIP
- Consolidated state budget deficit (including current consolidated state budget, PIP, and Social Fund budget): 5,8% GDP in 2002 (a 0,4% reduction relative to 2001); reduced to 5,0% GDP in 2003.
- Tax revenues: 12,4% GDP in 2001; 13,9% GDP in 2002; 14,8% GDP in 2003.
- Current social expenditures rose from 8,0% to 10,1% of GDP between 2001 and 2002.
- PIP expenditures climbed from 5,3% GDP in 2001 to 5,9% GDP in 2002.
- Debt-service reduction enabled increased social spending (US$99 million cut in 2001-2004 due to Paris Club restructuring in March 2002).
- Total volume of spending for PIP investment projects amounted to 3366.6.2 million Soms in 2003 (81% relative to 2002 level).
- Realized external funding of investment projects (without grants) was 97% of planned levels; realized internal co-financing was 99% of planned levels.
- PIP expenditure allocation in 2003: agriculture 37% of all PIP expenditures; education and healthcare 25%; transportation and communication 25%.
- Government measures: strict control over state current and capital spending; balancing pay increases by optimizing civil service numbers; moratorium on increases in government spending; need to economize on other debit items to balance additional expenditures.

### Budget transparency and budgeting process
- Transfer of the Republican budget to a program basis continues, though insufficiently.
- Increased transparency: extended Parliamentary hearings of the draft Republican budget for 2002 and 2003 with civil society participation; budget information available on the Ministry of Finance website and published in the quarterly Financial and Economic Bulletin.
- Expansion of budget hearings at the local community level.

### Revenue collection and tax administration reforms
- 2003 consolidated budget total revenues (including official transfers) increased by 12,1% in nominal terms vs 2002.
- 2003 tax revenues increased by 13,8%; revenues of budget organizations from paid services rose by 16,6%.
- Total income of the consolidated state budget reached 19,4% of GDP in 2003, with tax revenues at 14,3% of GDP.
- Tax legislation changes: single profit tax rate of 20% introduced from start of year; new real estate tax replaced tax on unused production and trade facilities; 100 percent of real estate tax revenue to go to local budgets.
- VAT changes: VAT for supply of agricultural products introduced with simultaneous abolishment of the fixed VAT offset for agricultural products; unsatisfactory results due to problems in administration and unwillingness of large agricultural producers to register as VAT payers.
- Measures to improve tax administration: make VAT registration more inclusive per IMF mission recommendations; introduction of VAT invoices for stricter reporting.
- Decision to develop a new edition of the Tax Code to address discrepancies and gaps; it needs to be drafted and passed in 2004.
- Institutional reforms: Committee on Revenues replaced state tax and customs inspections; Division on Control over Large Tax-Payers and Participants of External Economic Activity established.
- Other reforms: adoption of new Customs Code; introduction of tax on exploration of mineral resources; one-stop-shop company registration mechanism by the Committee of Revenues; creation of common VAT payer personal accounts to simplify payment and offsetting of VAT.

### External debt dynamics and Paris Club agreements
- Overall external debt (including Government debt, debt to the IMF and private sector debt) remained around 110% of GDP during 2001-2003 (132% of GDP in 1999).
- Public foreign debt equaled 94% of GDP at the end of 2003.
- Government conducting debt-restructuring negotiations with bilateral creditors under the Paris Club Agreement of March 7, 2002 (agreements with India at signing stage; negotiations with Kuwait continue).
- Paris Club Agreement allows conversion of debt into social, environmental, and other programs (example: Germany agreed to swap half of Kyrgyzstan’s consolidated debt (Euro 350,000) into increased funding of a tuberculosis program).
- Government plans to appeal to the Paris Club for additional debt relief under the “good will stipulation” contingent on successful PRGF implementation and approval of a subsequent IMF-coordinated reform program.

### Foreign trade, current account, and capital flows
- 2002 trade: exports of goods increased by 3,7%; exports of services increased by 72,4%; imports of goods (CIF) rose by 25,2%; imports of non-factor services rose by 15,1%.
- 2002 current account deficit rose from 1,2% GDP in 2001 to 2,2% GDP in 2002.
- 2003 trade: exports of goods increased by 18,5%; imports increased by 21,9%; exports growth driven mainly by rise in gold supply; excluding Kumtor, export growth amounted to -0,2%.
- Preliminary 2003 data suggest current account deficit relative to GDP declined to 1,6% due to improving services and factor income balances.
- Gross direct foreign investment: US$90,1 million in 2001 to US$115,7 million in 2002.
- January-September foreign direct investment: US$62.1 million in January-September 2002 to US$77,5 million in same period of 2003.
- NBKR raised gross foreign reserves to 5,7 months of imports; preliminary first nine months of 2003 reserves amounted to 5,6 months of imports.

### Financial sector developments and access to finance
- NBKR average rate: 7,95% in 2001; 4,4% in 2002; 4,0% in 2003.
- Weighted average interest rate on commercial bank loans in national currency: 36,4% in 2001; 30,2% in 2002; 25,1% in 2003.
- Interest rate on loans in foreign currency: 25,0% in 2001; 22,6% in 2002; 19,2% in 2003.
- Kyrgyz Agricultural Finance Corporation (KAFC) reduced its rate by 3% starting from 1 July 2003.
- Bank lending volumes: increased by 26,6% in 2002 vs 2001; increased by 44% in 2003 vs 2002.
- Deposit base increased by 29,6% in 2002 and by 30% in 2003 despite lower deposit interest rates.
- Financial intermediation and quality/range of financial services remain below levels needed for accelerated growth.
- Development of non-cash settlement system through bank accounts underway to improve public access to quality banking services.
- Expanding collateral-free crediting and microfinance in regions.
- Deposit protection measures: Concept of the Deposit Protection System and appropriate Law are being elaborated.

*Source: Appendix 1 (as provided in the content unit).*

### 38.   The  Government  and  NBKR  continue  their  work  on  the  development  of  the  financial

### _cr04200 - 38.   The  Government  and  NBKR  continue  their  work  on  the  development  of  the  financial

### Financial sector development and banking reform
- Regulation of the banking system by the NBKR is carried out in accordance with the Banking Reform Strategy and aims to:
  - strengthen the capital base of banks to ensure their stability and solvency.
  - increase the efficiency of commercial banks.
  - create a system for protection of depositors’ interests (including enactment of the Law on Protection of Deposits).
  - strengthen bank supervision.
- Measures to privatize state financial institutions are being implemented; bids to buy the Kairat bank have been invited and three commercial proposals have been received to date.
- The payment system has been improved: an automated clearing system, including the use of e-documents, was made operational in 2003; the Central Treasury is being connected to this system.
- World Bank assistance for development of the payment system has been described as extremely important.
- Regulatory capital adequacy (footnote):
  - As of September 1, 2003, aggregate capital adequacy coefficient for the total capital of all banks amounted to 33.8% with the lowest admissible level of this coefficient at 12% for one bank.

### Non-bank financial institutions, KAFC, microfinance and securities market
- KAFC (Kyrgyz Agricultural Financial Corporation) developments:
  - In 2003, its loan portfolio increased by 27,6% and reached Soms 1276,2 million.
- Microfinance organizations (MFOs):
  - As of January 1, 2004, 72 MFOs were registered.
  - Their total loan portfolio amounts to Soms 433,9 million soms, or 0,5% of GDP.
- Credit unions:
  - As of January 2004, 303 credit unions were registered, bringing together some 24,7 thousand people.
  - The credit portfolio and assets of credit unions amounted to 288,8 million soms and 317,2 million soms respectively.
  - The levels of these indicators of credit union activity are 15-19% higher than last year.
- Securities market development:
  - Legislative acts are being developed to increase market attractiveness, integrate corporate and state securities markets, expand financial instruments, and protect investors.
  - EuropeAid project under the TACIS program is expected to contribute to non-bank financial sector development.

### Investment climate, privatization and enterprise restructuring
- Investment promotion:
  - The Third Investment Summit was chaired by the President.
  - Three investment matrices (short-term priority plans) have been fulfilled; Investment Matrix IV is underway.
  - Implementation involves government cooperation with private sector, business associations, public, foreign investors, and international organizations.
  - The Advisory Council on Foreign Investments under the President was transformed into a regular working body.
- Legislative improvements in 2003:
  - Sixty-five laws were drafted; 40 of them were passed, including laws On Investments in the Kyrgyz Republic, On Introduction of Amendments and Addenda to the Law On Licensing, On External Migration and others.
- Investment outcomes:
  - Foreign direct investments grew by 28% in 2002 compared to 2001.
  - According to results for the first nine months of 2003, FDI increased by 24,8% compared with the corresponding period last year.
- Privatization and enterprise management:
  - Privatization of state property and improvement of management at state enterprises continues; international tender for sale of 51% of state shares of JSC Kyrgyztelekom took place in June 2003.
  - Activities (with World Bank experts) to transfer JSC Severelektro into a concession or to trustee management are underway; tender on transferring state shares to trustee management of JSC Kyrgyzneftegas is being invited.
  - The Program of Privatization of State Property for 2004-2006 has been finalized and will be sent to the Jogorku Kenesh for approval; amendments to laws (Land Code, On Education, On State Support of Cinematography, On Extra-budgetary Activity of State Health Care Institutions) are being introduced to eliminate constraints on privatization in the service sector.
  - Regulation “On Conduction of Competition for Vacancy Replacement in Management Bodies of Joint Stock Companies and Enterprises of the Kyrgyz Republic” adopted in 2002 led to withdrawal of civil servants from management and replacement by competitively elected state representatives.
  - As of January 1, 2004:
    - the share of privatized enterprises in the economy amounted to 70,7%,
    - the share of the GDP produced by the private sector reached 85%.

### Electric energy sector and quasi-fiscal deficit (QFD)
- The electric energy sector is constrained by a high quasi-fiscal deficit (QFD), threatening macroeconomic stability, growth, and social program implementation.
- The Government considers reduction of the QFD integral to stabilization and NPRS implementation.
- In 2003, quantitative QFD parameters in the electric energy sector were successfully established within the PRGF program.
- To reduce QFD in 2004, necessary measures include lowering commercial losses and raising the level of cash payments.

### Medium-term Budget Framework (MTBF), 2005-2007 — macroeconomic strategy and projections
- Purpose: ensure focus of state resources on priority NPRS areas and increase efficiency of resource utilization.
- Macroeconomic outlook:
  - The MTBF projects an average rate of economic growth of 5% per year during the projection period.
  - Growth expected across sectors, especially industry (excluding gold production), construction, and services.
  - Principal growth drivers: 1) private investment (domestic and direct foreign investment) and 2) exports.
  - Anticipated downturn in Kumtor gold extraction expected to be partly offset by launching Taldy-Bulak Levoberezhnyi and Jerui deposits.
  - Electric power supply to Russia expected to grow rapidly; tourism exports expected to grow significantly; export increases facilitated by reduction in foreign trade barriers due to agreements with Kazakhstan.
  - Private and government consumption expected to increase moderately; government investments to be gradually reduced due to cuts in externally funded PIP.
- Policy stance:
  - Continuation of strict monetary policy to keep annual inflation at 4%.
  - Managed floating exchange rate maintained.
  - Attract direct foreign investment and improve investment climate.
  - Financial sector development to strengthen financial intermediation.
  - Structural reforms to increase productivity and competitiveness.
  - Governance reform activities (including WB GSAC/GTAC) targeted at transparency, corporate governance and judicial reform.
  - Social policy to target social security, sustainability of social insurance, promote employment, ensure accessibility of education and healthcare, and support financial sustainability of these sectors.
- Poverty and fiscal targets:
  - Implementation of policies expected to reduce poverty level to 30.2% by 2007.
  - MTBF projects reduction of the consolidated state budget deficit to below 3% by 2007.

### MTBF — Key quantitative figures (Table 2 excerpts as presented)
- Table 2. Medium-term Budget Framework Figures, 2005-2007
  - Header columns: 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007
  - Row: Actual | Expected | Forecasted
  - Nominal GDP, bln. Soms 83.491.8100.5 110.5 121.47
  - Real GDP growth rate, % 6.74.04.5 5.3 5.2
  - GDP composition, %
    - Private consumption 68.36968.5 67.4 66.0
    - Government consumption 17.517.917.7 17.7 17.1
    - Gross investments 18.018.119.8 20.3 20.6
    - Public investment 5.33.93.5 3.1 3.2
  - PIP (external funding) 4.43.53.2 2.9 2.8
  - Private investment 12.714.216.3 17.2 17.4
  - Net export -0.3-5.2-6.1 -5.4 -3.7
  - Export of goods and services 36.737.436.3 35.3 35.2
  - Import of goods and services 3742.642.4 40.7 38.9
  - Rates of production growth by industries, %
    - Agriculture 3.84.24.6 4.6 4.4
    - Industry -17.40.10.0 5.3 5.8
    - Construction -6.86.07.0 7.0 8.0
    - Services 6.05.66.2 5.9 5.9
  - Inflation rate, CPI, % 5.63.84.0 4.0 4.0
  - Public foreign debt, % of GDP 93.185.182.6 79.3 74.0
  - Poverty level, % 40.838.636.0 32.9 30.2
  - Consolidated state budget deficit, % of GDP 5.04.44.0 3.2 2.9
  - Quasi-fiscal deficit in electric power, % of GDP 10.49.27.7 6.2 4.8

### Fiscal policy, debt strategy and QFD reduction measures
- Fiscal strategy to maintain state revenue approximately at 2003 levels while:
  - increasing share of internal income and lowering share of external grants,
  - decreasing state spending through improved budget processes and reduction in PIP scale.
- Measures to increase internal budget revenues:
  - improvements in tax administration and reduction of corruption in tax and customs agencies,
  - expansion of the tax base,
  - tax system adjustments including step-by-step abandonment of the production tax and reductions in payment rates to the Social Fund,
  - simultaneous increase in role of indirect taxes and revenues from compulsory patent-based activities.
- QFD reduction:
  - MTBF envisages QFD reduction to 4.8% of GDP in 2007.
  - A set of measures planned (many to be implemented within World Bank GSAC credit).
- External debt management strategy:
  - Reduce PIP to 3% of GDP by 2006.
  - All new borrowing only on sufficiently concessional terms, with at least a 45% grant element.
  - Three quarters of revenues from privatization (including JSC Kyrgyztelekom, JSC Kyrgyz Aba Joldoru, JSC Kyrgyzgaz and JSC Kyrgyzenergo) will be used for advance payments to creditors.
  - Government will explore settling non-concessional loans in exchange for assets of state-owned enterprises.
  - Even under optimistic assumptions, NPV of debt to export ratio is not expected to fall below threshold value of 150% until 2010.
  - Improvement of debt indicators consistent with debt stability requires restructuring by Paris Club creditors under Naples terms in December 2004.

### Risks, scenarios and priorities
- The MTBF base case scenario is based on relatively optimistic assumptions about external shocks.
- Downside risks:
  - Unfavorable confluence of circumstances or insufficient government efforts (notably weak export growth or low state revenues) could increase difficulties servicing external debt, reduce economic growth, and impede full implementation of social programs and poverty reduction.
- Government priority: highest priority attached to maintaining macroeconomic stability and achieving targeted figures for growth, budget and exports as outlined in the CDF/NPRS and detailed in the MTBF.

### Governance, constitutional and legislative reforms
- Governance reforms undertaken in past two years aimed at building modern state institutions; UN declared 2003 Year of Kyrgyz Statehood.
- President declared 2004 as the Year of Social Mobilization and Good Governance.
- Legislative reform highlights:
  - Adoption of the new Constitution in 2003 transferred many powers from the President to Jogorku Kenesh, the Government, judiciary and local self-government.
  - More than 1,5 million citizens participated in discussion of proposed Constitutional amendments.
  - Decree “On Measures for Practical Implementation of the New Constitution ... and Targets for Sustainable Development and Poverty Reduction for 2003” set legislative and administrative tasks to implement the new Constitution and CDF/NPRS.
  - Priority task: consider and pass laws addressing key economic issues to facilitate good governance and social support.

* _cr04200 - 38.   The  Government  and  NBKR  continue  their  work  on  the  development  of  the  financial*

### 56.  At present, the National Council on Good Governance develops a strategy of reforming of

### _cr04200 - 56.  At present, the National Council on Good Governance develops a strategy of reforming of

### Public administration reform and law drafting
- National Council on Good Governance develops a strategy to reform the public administration system; main goal is to increase effectiveness of the state supply of social benefits and services to population within the framework of constitutional guarantees.
- Kyrgyz Government approved Regulation on Law Drafting to improve law drafting practices, techniques, and raise the quality of draft laws; aims to prevent delays in drafting and coordination of strategically important laws.
- Center for Coordination of the Government Law Drafting established in the Ministry of Justice to strengthen planning, monitoring and coordination of law drafting in the Government; works jointly with legal departments of government agencies to improve law drafting on a regular basis.
- State Commission for Revision of Laws and Regulations established by Government Resolution to provide a basis for systematic and program-based approach to revision of legislation and identification of priorities.
- Proposal: draft laws that directly affect citizens and regulate business activities must be published; other important laws may be published to stimulate public discussions and involve civil society.
- December 2003: some amendments to the Law “On Normative and Judicial Acts” were made to give a certain period of time to raise public awareness on Law and prepare comments to draft laws.
- Ministry of Justice built a centralized database of legislative information with World Bank-financed Legal Information System Project support; database is accessible to unlimited number of users and currently holds over 24,000 laws and regulatory documents.

### Improving the judiciary and law enforcement agencies
- New Constitution envisages:
  - merger of Supreme Court and Highest Arbitration Court;
  - election of local court judges by Jogorku Kenesh of the Kyrgyz Republic;
  - introduction of right of citizens to participate in administration of the law;
  - procedure for dismissal of judges;
  - introduction of the right of the Supreme Court to reconsider a sentence of lower-level courts and pass the final sentence in accordance with the established procedures defined by law.
- Consultative Commission on Judiciary and working groups established, including representatives of judicial, legislative and executive branches, independent lawyers, scholars, academia, and private sector.
- Diagnostic study on the judicial system prepared with technical assistance from the Asian Development Bank under the Corporate Governance Reform II Program; study identified needs including transparency and openness of appointment procedures, independence of judges, logistical support, and improvement of legal procedures.
- Concept paper for unified legal information database of courts of general jurisdiction being developed; grant agreement signed with the World Bank to implement pilot automation in several courts, provide judges access to electronic database of laws, regulations and court decisions, and increase transparency by opening access to court decisions.
- Law on Supreme Court of the Kyrgyz Republic developed and passed to define scope, arrangement and procedures of Supreme Court and local courts; directed towards integration of Arbitration Courts into common judicial system and extension of Supreme Court authorities.
- Institute of Third Party Arbitration Courts established; new Constitution created foundation for extrajudicial settlement of economic disputes; new Law “On amendments to the Civil Code for Legal Procedures” developed in 2003 with provisions for enforcement of decisions passed by foreign and local third-party arbitration courts.
- Draft laws in preparation: Constitutional Law (Law on the Status of Judges) for specialized administrative courts; amendments and addenda to Arbitration Procedural Code, Criminal Procedural Code and Criminal Execution Code; adoption of amendments into the Civil Code for Legal Procedures and the Criminal Code for Legal Procedures.
- Presidential decrees addressed disciplinary responsibility of court judges, introduction of qualification categories and salary raise for judges to ensure greater independence and adequate remuneration; Qualification Boards to consider disciplinary responsibility were formed.
- State budget expenditures for maintenance of the judicial system increased: in 2003 the expenditures allocated for this purposes were by 32% higher than in 2001 and by 45% higher than in 2001.

### Law-enforcement, penitentiary and prosecution reform
- Draft concept paper on reforming interior bodies developed to improve effectiveness and ensure public security.
- Chief Division for Penalty Execution transferred from the Ministry of Internal Affairs to the Ministry of Justice as part of reform of law-enforcement agencies and penitentiary system and to align legislation with unified human rights and freedoms.
- Concept paper for development of the prosecution bodies approved by Presidential decree to strengthen the General Prosecutor’s Office and focus on cooperation with courts and proper representation of state prosecution in courts.

### Reforming the executive branch
- Thirty ministries and state agencies underwent functional reviews to better justify and comprehensively guide governance reform; working groups established in state agencies for implementation; technical assistance provided by UNDP, European Commission, and UK Department for International Development.
- Practical measures led to rationalizations: management structures formed on functional approach; laws and legal documents regulating government agencies reviewed; overlapping and obsolete functions eliminated; some functions transferred to affiliated agencies, subsidiaries and local self-government authorities; staff reduced.
- Eliminated: nine divisions, 57 departments and 39 subunits.
- Functions changed: 110 functions eliminated as not corresponding to market developments; 125 functions transformed to other Ministries, departments and local authorities.
- Future plans: staff rationalizations at local level in health care and education sectors include completion of functional review by March-April of this year.
- Jogorku Kenesh adopted a Law “On Government of Kyrgyz Republic” providing government structure includes twelve ministries and two State Committees; Law envisages establishment of the Ministry of Economic Development, Industry and Trade formed from consolidation of multiple former bodies.
- Next reorganization steps: Ministry of Agriculture and Ministry of Labor and Social Security.
- Functional selection aligns ministries to sector strategies (examples provided for Ministries of Economic Development, Labor and Social Security, and Agriculture); donor aid on reforming public administration requires better coordination.
- Government issued Decree the plan of administrative procedures to improve administrative procedures affecting private sector and exclude repeating; activities continue within investment matrices.
- Staff rationalizations in 2002 cut government staff by 7,3%; this move saved Soms35,0 million for the state budget.
- Functional reviews ongoing in regional government agencies, particularly territorial departments of Ministries of Health Care, Education and Labor and Social Security.
- Governance Structural Adjustment Credit (GSAC) and Governance Technical Assistance Credit (GTAC) launched with World Bank support to carry out structural changes; implementation hampered because previous agreements within GSAC/GTAC missions not fully executed; problems exist in organizational structure and lack of collaboration between working groups.
- Government approved State Action Plan for Implementation of the Information and Communication Technologies Program to achieve presidential tasks on gradual transition to e-government model; draft Law on Electronic Signatures developed.
- U.S. Government provided a grant to support transition to e-government model.
- 2003: State Agency of Information Resources and Technologies created under the Government to support unified state information resources, form national information infrastructure and improve documentation turnover.

### Decentralization and local self-government (LSG)
- National Strategy for Decentralization and Development of Local Self-Government until 2010 approved by Presidential decree on December 17, 2002; corresponding Action Plan sets concrete tasks for ministries, state agencies, local state administrations and LSGs on democratization and performance improvement; Coordination Council chaired by the First Vice Prime Minister established to control implementation.
- Legal framework improvements: two main laws (“On Financial and Economic Foundation of Local Self-Governments” and “On Amendments to the Tax Code”) adopted enabling real estate tax in urban areas; Government developed draft Law “On Municipal Service” submitted to parliament.
- Salaries of heads of aiyl okmotu were increased by two times; salaries of other specialists of the sector increased by 30%.
- Finance & Economic Departments established in all aiyl okmotu to improve organizational structure and ensure effective use of budget funds.
- Measures envisaged to increase motivation of local councils and municipal employees, including provision of material and technical foundation (office supplies, maintenance, equipment).
- Trainings carried out to improve knowledge and skills of LSG staff based on programs developed by the Congress of Local Communities.
- Rural Investment Project jointly implemented with the World Bank; social and institutional assessments of LSGs are being conducted and pilot projects in local communities will be carried out based on study findings.

### Managing and reforming state financial management
- With IMF technical support, Government developed a Concept paper on Reforming the Ministry of Finance System and Central Treasury for 2002-2005; main goal is to build an effective public finance management system through medium-term forecasting and program-based budgeting.
- Primary tasks: strengthen administrative and institutional capacities of the Ministry of Finance, strengthen budgeting process, build capacity of the Treasury, and raise effectiveness of state budget revenue collection.
- Central Treasury improvements: improved cash flow forecasting, control of obligations and putting state financial accounts in order.
- Modernization of the Treasury will continue under the Governance Technical Assistance Credit (GTAC), which will fully automate treasury operations.

*IMF country report section as provided in the source content unit.*

### 87.   The  Government  Budget  Commission  instructed  ministries  and  state  agencies  to  submit

### _cr04200 - 87.   The  Government  Budget  Commission  instructed  ministries  and  state  agencies  to  submit

### Public financial management and budgeting reforms
- Ministries and state agencies were instructed to submit their budgets as program-based budgets.
- A 2-year Resource Agreement was signed between the Ministry of Education and Culture and the Ministry of Finance as a pilot project.
  - Under the Agreement the Ministry of Education and Culture has more rights to reorganize its structure, carry out its human resource policy, and allocate budget funds.
  - The Ministry of Education and Culture received a right to pay bonuses to most outstanding employees beyond the salary scale originally set by the law.
- The current budget format "does not demonstrate the resources for realization of sector measures and providing services" and creates impediments to develop line programs.
- To address this, appropriate formats developed by DFID specialists will be included into the 2005 budget to facilitate integration of capital and current resource allocations to institutions and programs.

### Medium-Term Budget Framework (MTBF) and fiscal priorities
- The Economic Policy Council approved a Medium-Term Budget Framework (MTBF) for 2004-2006.
  - The MTBF aims to increase adequacy and timeliness of resource allocations for social and economic reforms, and make the state financial system more transparent and accountable.
  - The MTBF was used as a basis for the development of the 2004 state budget by the Kyrgyz Government, coordinated with the IMF and approved by Jogorku Kenesh.
- According to the MTBF and as NSPR envisages, social expenditures "will be growing there faster than GDP."
  - Realization of this position in the context of gradual budget consolidation requires thorough selection of prioritized expenditures in other areas.

### Treasury, off-budget accounts, and procurement transparency
- A Committee on forming of financial plan was created under the Central Treasury to strengthen state financial flows control.
  - It regulates cash in Central Treasury as well as inclusion of the off-budget accounts of bodies such as the State Property Fund, the State Fund of Material Reserves, the Economic Development Fund and Small and Medium Enterprise Support Fund.
- Measures to ensure transparency of the state procurement system are envisaged.
  - Restructuring and strengthening of functions of State Committee on State Procurement and Material Reserves have been conducted.
  - A respective bulletin is regularly published.

### External and internal audit; fiscal administration reforms
- Restructuring of the Chamber of Accounts is being conducted to define its role and organizational structure as supreme audit body in accordance with a new edition of a Law.
  - Adoption of standards of International Organization of Supreme Audit Institutions (INTOSAI) is envisaged.
- Ministries of Finance, Labor and Social Security, Agriculture have created departments of external audit.
  - It is necessary to develop a strategy of establishment of effective function of internal audit in all state bodies.
- To improve customs and tax legislation and strengthen tax administration:
  - The Strategy of Fiscal Reform in Kyrgyz Republic to 2005 and a concept paper of improving tax policy have been approved, and a new edition of the Tax Code has been prepared.
  - Substantial changes were made into the Tax Code of Kyrgyz Republic to increase transparency of tax collection, including measures to strengthen tax administration and editorial amendments excluding double interpretation of some articles.
  - A Law on Entering of Amendments into the Tax Code of Kyrgyz Republic was adopted to create predictable terms for business by internal and external investors:
    - Any law or decree which enters changes and amendments into the Tax Code may be approved not later than 1 of November of the current year and enforced not earlier than 1 of January of the following year.
  - A draft of a new Customs Code, harmonized with International standards, was approved by government and submitted to the Legislative Board of the Jogorku Kenesh for consideration.

### Professional, effective, accountable civil service
- The National Committee on Civil Service was created by the President Decree on February 7, 2004 to reform the civil service system and improve professional skills.
  - The Committee will shorten arbitrariness of heads of ministries and departments and provide fair conditions for hiring and promotion of civil service workers.
- Two Laws have been prepared to improve institutional capacity, transparency, and accountability of the civil service:
  - The first law divides civil service positions into political and public careers and introduces state secretaries to provide stability of state departments.
  - The second law envisages creation of institutional mechanism to facilitate honesty of persons on high state posts.
  - These laws are being coordinated with the World Bank and then will be submitted to Jogorku Kenesh of Kyrgyz Republic.
- Further development is required for mechanisms to regulate political impact on the civil service and to protect civil service workers from unjustified dismissals.
- Salary reform considerations:
  - In 2005-2007, the fund of salaries financed by the state budget will be growing slower than GDP rates.
  - Improving the civil service employment structure is expected to provide a real growth of salaries to civil service workers.
- Recruitment and attestation outcomes:
  - Commissions for Attestation and Competitive Selection have been widely established.
  - Share of specialists hired through competitive recruitment:
    - 70% in central ministries and state agencies;
    - 57% for regional government agencies;
    - 69,3% for government administration and local self-governance bodies.
  - The government web-portal regularly posts information on vacancies in state agencies.
  - Attestation activity in 2003:
    - "around 7000 civil servants worked in 31 ministries, state committees, administrative departments and state commissions" were certified.
    - 1179 specialists of central departments and 5776 specialists of regional government agencies participated in the attestations.
    - 513 people worked in local government administrations and self-governance bodies were certified as well.
  - Quality of hires:
    - 74% of newly hired specialists have higher education degree in technical sciences, economics, agriculture, or law.
    - Women account for 43% of all specialists hired through competition procedure in 2002.
    - 33,9% of women held management positions in local state administrations and 30,4% of women in mayor offices in Kyrgyz Republic.
- Youth recruitment:
  - Regulation for Competitive Selection of Graduates of Higher Educational Institutions defines qualification requirements for hiring talented youth; most ministries and state agencies have quotas for hiring young specialists.
- Training and capacity building:
  - A Program of Training and Qualification Advancement was approved.
  - Two learning centers were created under the Academy of Management under the President of Kyrgyz Republic in Bishkek and Osh.
  - 15 mln. soms envisaged for training of civil service workers and municipal employees in the 2004 state budget.

### Development of corporate governance
- Activities aimed at strengthening corporate governance and financial management continued under Corporate Governance Reform II, financed by the Asian Development Bank.
- Legislative and standards changes:
  - A Law "On Joint Stock Companies" was enacted to set high standards for corporate governance, fill gaps in regulation of joint stock company management, expand shareholders' rights, and increase protection of rights of shareholders and investors. Amendments to this Law are being drafted due to conflicts with other laws and regulations.
  - Laws "On Accounting" and "On Auditing Activities" were adopted in 2002 to provide legislative support for introducing International Accounting Standards (IAS) and International Standards of Financial Reporting.
    - However, not all enterprises have transited to these standards, causing problems with transparency.
  - A draft Law "On Valuation Activities" was developed to further develop the real estate market, introduce mortgage systems, and market-based valuation; it has been submitted to parliament.
  - Activities are ongoing to reconsider selection procedures for state representatives in joint stock companies, and a gradual process is carried out for withdrawal of civil servants from management boards of joint stock companies in line with prohibitions on civil servants representing state interests in enterprises.
  - Managers of enterprises study effective management principles; a program "Advisory and Management Support of Enterprises" envisages wide-ranging training for joint stock company managers.
  - Amendments to "On Banks and Banking Activities" were made to strengthen corporate governance in commercial banks, protect creditor rights, develop valuation activities, strengthen boards of directors by establishing committees, and define rules to avoid conflicts of interest and make transactions with affiliated entities more transparent and controlled.
- A draft Concept Paper on Development of Corporate Governance in the Kyrgyz Republic until 2006 was developed and is under government review.

### Fighting corruption and good governance initiatives
- The Government regularly updates a State Program for Strengthening Public Order and Fighting Corruption (programs existed for 1995–1996, 1997–2000, and 2001–2003).
- International cooperation and diagnostics:
  - Practices from other countries and international organizations are being studied.
  - An International Conference on Fighting Corruption was held in 2002 with Transparency International.
  - Surveys show that the size of corruption in the republic remains still high.
- Legal and institutional developments:
  - Laws and regulations regulating the Government, ministries, and other agencies are being revised to comply with the new Constitution; expert examination of legislation to propose amendments to strengthen anticorruption efforts has started.
  - The Law "On Fighting Corruption" has come into force; it was developed taking into account international practices.
  - A draft Law on “Fighting financing of terrorism and laundry of income received by dishonest way” has been prepared.
- Parliamentary and executive actions:
  - On February 21, 2002, the parliamentarian Assembly of People’s Representatives established a Committee on Fighting Corruption, Shadow Economy and Organized Crime to develop laws and programs and support enforcement.
  - A Security Council session in March, 2003 adopted the Plan for implementation of the National Strategy “Kyrgyzstan is a Country with Good Governance” (the anticorruption strategy). Measures aim to eliminate unjustified and excessive interference of state agencies in business, increase openness and accessibility of public services, build anticorruption attitudes in the public, and increase responsibility of civil servants and managers.
  - Regional discussions helped identify main anticorruption directions; a Plan of Organizational and Practical Measures for Fighting Corruption in state agencies is being developed to overcome the syndrome of impunity and bring business activities from the shadow economy into legal practices.
- Law enforcement and coordination:
  - The Ministry of Internal Affairs is being reformed and non-mission functions transferred to other bodies.
  - The Agency of the Kyrgyz Republic for Drug Control has been established.
  - Cooperation between law-enforcement agencies and fiscal bodies with foreign counterparts is being expanded.
  - The Concept Paper for Development of Prosecution Bodies until 2005 identifies fighting corruption as a top task; measures to coordinate law-enforcement activities on corruption-related crimes are being developed.
  - An Interdepartmental Committee on Public Security and Fighting Corruption was established to coordinate executive agency actions.
- Assessment and new structures:
  - Anticorruption activities to date "have not achieved their goals and the work must be substantially intensified."
  - The National Council for Good Governance was established by Presidential Decree as a new driving force in fighting corruption and ensuring good governance:
    - Chaired by the Prime Minister and consists of 25 members representing government agencies, NGOs, and business community.
    - Has legal status of a consultative body acting on basis of cooperation with government bodies, local self-governments, civil society, private sector, and international organizations.
    - Main purpose: to form and introduce mechanisms ensuring good, open, and responsible governance as state anticorruption policy.
    - Main tasks include development and implementation of measures to form and develop quality public administration as an effective anticorruption strategy.
    - Openness: Council sessions are open to media representatives (close sessions decided by National Council members).
    - Secretariat for Good Governance — an executive body of the National Council — has been created.

*Source: _cr04200 - 87.   The  Government  Budget  Commission  instructed  ministries  and  state  agencies  to  submit (IMF PDF).*

### 117.  Decrease  of  various  types  of  interference  of  state  agencies  in  business  and  economic

### _cr04200 - 117.  Decrease  of  various  types  of  interference  of  state  agencies  in  business  and  economic

### Anti-corruption, deregulation, and state interference in business
- Decrease of various types of interference of state agencies in business and economic activities is identified as one of the fundamental directions of fighting corruption.
- Special attention is to be paid to interior, tax and customs structures where concrete facts of corruption were recorded.
- Additional measures envisaged to further implement state policy supporting investment and other business activities and eliminating barriers to their development.
- A Concept of economy deregulation (approved by Presidential Decree) aims to:
  - realize constitutional rights on private property and economic freedom;
  - define types of state interference in business and economic activities;
  - deny excessive bureaucratic regulation.
- Law on basics of technical regulation in the Kyrgyz Republic expected to provide key progress in economic deregulation; adequate institutional framework and capacity required for effective implementation.
- Prosecutors’ offices tasked with immediate measures against civil servants breaking the Decree, including dismissal of civil servants breaking the legislation.
- Government reorganized the Central Department on fighting economic crime and corruption of Ministry of Internal Affairs due to interference by its employees and other state department workers into business activities and abuse of power.
- Ministry of Internal Affairs objectives include fighting abuse of power, precautions and decrease of crime.
- Further improvements to mechanism of declaration of income of civil servants envisaged:
  - tougher requirements planned under the “Provision on a procedure, conditions and terms of submitting of information by the civil servants on received income and belonged property”;
  - a Law facilitating the process is being prepared for submission to Jogorku Kenesh.

### Democratic institutions and civil society participation
- Democratic institutions have significantly increased capacity and developed further over the reporting period; activities, independence, and institutional capacity are growing.
- There are more than 4500 nongovernment organizations and public foundations in the republic involved in social support, protection for women and children, human rights, environment, education, gender issues, and other areas.
- Presidential initiative: Kyrgyzstan proposed as the Country of Human Rights; a Human Rights National Program has been developed and is being implemented.
- Democratic Security Council established to coordinate democracy-strengthening efforts and includes civil society representatives.
- A draft Democratic Code was prepared and published for open discussion and was approved at the Second World Kurultai of the Kyrgyz People in August 2003.
- Legal base for reforms in social and political sphere significantly strengthened.
- New Constitution advanced principles for building a democratic state, advanced freedoms and rights, and secures Government duty to cooperate with civil society; political parties have enhanced role and status including rights to promote parliamentary candidates and work locally.
- Ombudsman institute established in 2002; Ombudsman supervises observance of human rights and freedoms within the Kyrgyz Republic and in accordance with international agreements.
- Presidential Decree on Measures for Development of Social Mobilization for Poverty Alleviation adopted to increase civil society participation in CDF/NPRS implementation; Decree envisages large-scale dissemination of positive experience in social mobilization.
- Law “On Administrative Procedures” developed and passed in Jogorku Kenesh in the beginning of March if 2004 to strengthen government-community interaction.
- Creation of Social-Information Center (SIC) planned to intensify civil society participation; financing sources and location under consideration.
- Drafts of new editions of election-related laws (Code on the Elections, Central Commission on the Elections and Conducting Referendums, Law on the Government) developed and submitted to Jogorku Kenesh.

### Building a fair society — social protection and targeted social security
- Comprehensive social reforms under CDF and NPRS aim to build a fair society with effective social security and human development covering healthcare, education, retirement pensions, social security for target groups, job creation, environmental management, and gender equity.
- Steps taken to raise social protection and promote targeting:
  - social security benefits and allowances were increased by 20%;
  - Government Resolutions defined privileged target groups eligible for cash compensations for medicines and coal;
  - a draft Law “On State Social Benefits in the Kyrgyz Republic” envisaged a system of providing benefits to low income people;
  - a draft Law “On Amendments to Several Laws of the Kyrgyz Republic” stipulates targeted principle of rendering social benefits for employees of the Ministry of Interior Affairs and the Ministry of Defense for energy and utilities tariffs.
- Problem: incomplete recording of family or individual’s income when calculating the uniform monthly benefit (UMB).
  - Planned development of a Methodology of defining income from agricultural activities and pilot projects in several regions.
  - Draft Regulation “On Procedure of Defining Aggregate Family Income for Allocation of Uniform Monthly Benefit to Poor Families and Citizens” to be revised to stipulate consideration of land plot sizes and cattle breeding activities.
  - Share of population receiving UMB in 2003 (in the beginning of the year) increased by 1,1% in comparison with 2002.
  - Preliminary calculations show the regulation will decrease number of UMB recipients by 17%, and the total allocated sum for this purpose – by 21%.
  - Saved resources will be allocated to increase of the guaranteed minimal consumption level (GMCL).
  - In 2003, the ratio of GMCL to minimal consumption budget amounted to 8,6% in comparison to 10,1% in 2001 or decreased by 1,5%.
- Social passportization system covers almost 100% of the poor families (more than 650 thousand families); an enhanced social passport form will be introduced in 2004 for more effective income calculation.
- Low-income families receive compensations for rise in energy tariffs:
  - resources directed to compensations increased by 78% in 2003 compared with the previous year;
  - experiment with simplified application procedure for electric power compensations based on social passports being carried out in three pilot districts; results to be disseminated nationally;
  - Low-income families in Bishkek receive subsidies for public utility services; in 2003, 5000 people received the subsidies.
- Child protection and poverty alleviation:
  - State Program “New Generation” to 2010 implemented;
  - Family Code adopted; Code on Children being developed;
  - measures to attract off-budget resources for children institutions envisaged;
  - pilot Family and Children Support Units and Rehabilitation and Patronage Centers for neglected children being created.
- Disability support:
  - Rehabilitation centers being established under National Program for Support of the Disabled People;
  - vocational training for disabled people provided in vocational education schools and lyceums; syllabuses for children with special needs being developed;
  - problem of providing wheelchairs remains.
- Draft Law “On the state minimal standards” directed at unified approach to forming social sector budgets prepared.
- Social mobilization:
  - development of credit unions, self-help groups, community organizations, public foundations and charities supported;
  - with international support, poor families receive humanitarian aid;
  - 88,1 thousand families improved economic conditions using Social mobilization mechanisms;
  - declaration of year 2004 as a Year of Social Mobilization and Good Governance planned to boost efforts.

### Retirement pension benefits system reforms and financial stability
- Presidential decrees and measures taken to increase pensioners’ living standards:
  - average 10% increase of the level of retirement pension benefits decreed;
  - 15% increase of the minimum size of retirement pension benefit to servicemen decreed;
  - payments extra to retirement pension benefits for the disabled and participants of the World War II have been raised;
  - savings accumulated at personal retirement pension accounts were subject to inflation indexation and were increased by 11,8%.
- Recalculation of retirement pension benefits for working pensioners made annually according to social insurance fees; growth rates of the general size of retirement pension benefit amounted to 100% in 2003 in comparison with 101% in 2002.
- In 2004, planned increase of the average size of retirement pension benefit by 9%.
- Concept Paper for Further Reform of the Retirement Pension Benefits System provisions a phased transition to the accumulative pension system:
  - proposed that every employed person pays additional retirement insurance fees for the accumulated share of personal retirement benefits;
  - accumulative principle will not apply to those with less than 10 years to retirement age; they will receive benefits based on existing collective pension system;
  - Government approved a concrete Action Plan; draft laws prepared to define mechanisms for introducing accumulative principles and ensure adequacy of pension benefits.
- Draft law “On investment of funds to finance accumulative pension component under the state social insurance.” outlines measures for protection of worker’s contributions, control over formation and investment of pension savings, and institutional and legal framework for investment of pension funds.
- Problem: absence of qualified actuaries for new pension model calculations; GSAC/GTAC project financed by the World Bank will partly solve the problem.
- A law simplifying procedure of calculation and payment of retirement pension benefit was adopted.
- Non-Government Pension Funds:
  - currently one Non-Government Pension Fund operates in the republic;
  - draft law “On amendments to the Law on non-government pension funds.” prepared and submitted to parliament to develop non-government pension insurance services; draft law grants non-government pension funds status of commercial (profit making) organizations.
- Social Fund financials:
  - measures resulted in a 10,8% increase in the total volume of collected social insurance premiums in 2003 compared to the previous year;
  - payments of retirement pension benefits are being made without delays and paid in kind only according to pensioners wish.
- Base part of retirement pension benefit:
  - ratio of base part to minimal consumption budget of a pensioner decreased from 19,7% to 17,0% between 2000 and 2003;
  - since January 2004 base part set at 226,6 soms based on social insurance resources; the increase amounted to 11%.
- Enterprise debts on social insurance payments are a problem; responses include monthly notifications to debtors, agreements on deferred payments, and Criminal Code changes envisaging penalties for evasion of mandatory insurance fees and non-execution of Social Fund legal requirements.

### Labor market, job creation, and wage reforms
- Unemployment level of 8,7% (continuously high) motivates additional measures and employment legislation improvements.
- Labor Market Policy Paper to 2010 being drafted with support from the European Commission - Tacis Program.
- Parliament passed a Law which simplifies eligibility requirements for unemployment benefits thereby increasing social protection of the unemployed.
- A selective household survey on employment problems conducted with support of the UK Department on International Development.
- Legal framework enhanced for wage reform and labor relations:
  - Law developing social partnership among government bodies, employer associations and labor unions when carrying out social and economic policy;
  - New version of the Labor Code developed and adopted in the first reading by parliament; it aims to liberalize labor relations, develop the private sector and create more jobs.
  - Concept Paper on Wage Reform for 2003-2010 being implemented to restore and develop stimulating, reproducing, regulating and social functions of wages and develop market mechanisms of wage regulation.
- Active measures for increasing employment:
  - training unemployed in demanded skills and professions;
  - paid public and community works organized to rehabilitate social infrastructure;
  - micro-lending system for the unemployed being developed to provide micro credits for start-ups and job creation;
  - business incubators organized in most regions and shown to be a good initiative for creation of permanent jobs.

*Source: _cr04200 - 117.  Decrease  of  various  types  of  interference  of  state  agencies  in  business  and  economic*

### 148.  A  mechanism  of  social  partnership  among  the  State,  employers’  associations  and  labor

### 148.  A  mechanism  of  social  partnership  among  the  State,  employers’  associations  and  labor

### Employment and social partnership
- A mechanism of social partnership among the State, employers’ associations and labor unions is being used to improve regulation and coordination of employment issues.
- Active measures to assist the unemployed:
  - Training courses, round tables, and seminars provide information and advisory services.
  - Youth labor exchanges operate in big towns to provide young people with employment opportunities.
  - Departments in higher educational institutions are being established to foster employment of graduates; targeted contracted education is also used.
- Employer incentives:
  - Employer contributions to the Social Fund are getting lower for every person hired.
  - For each new job created employers receive a lump-sum payment equal to six months unemployment benefits for one person.
- Labour-market information and planning:
  - A lack of reliable determination of real needs for specialists of different qualifications negatively affects employment.
  - The Ministry of Labor and Social Security will provide a detailed study of the labor market and forecast forthcoming needs for human resources.

### Access to Quality Education
- Strategic frameworks and laws:
  - An Education Development Concept until 2010 is being implemented to ensure accessibility and quality of education.
  - The Law “On education” was adopted, setting multiplicity of sources of education financing and supporting non-government education.
  - The National Action Plan Education for All is being implemented.
- Early childhood and preschool:
  - In 2003, 9,9% of children of appropriate age were receiving preschool education, compared with 9,5% in 2001.
  - Community-Based Early Childhood Development Project (ADB financed) is implemented to increase access; community, family and private pre-school types with part-time schedules are being developed.
- Rural and teacher support programs:
  - Rural School Program adopted; World Bank plans a US$15 mln. grant project (Rural Education Project) to develop performance-based teacher evaluation and a new salary scale.
  - Mechanism of assigning state-funded higher-education graduates to secondary schools is used; measures include providing housing and increased salaries.
  - Republican budget annually provisions categorial grants to supplement salaries following the law “On the status of teachers in the Kyrgyz Republic”.
  - GSAC/GTAC program will help formulate minimum service provision standards to calculate categorial grants.
  - It is planned to form a state order for training required specialists based on labor market study.
- Access to basic secondary education and materials:
  - Jetkinchek National Program on Access to Education addresses non-attendance and overcrowding; in 2003, 94,8% of children received basic secondary education compared to 94,6% in 2002.
  - Number of children not attending school decreased by 22% in 2003; provision of schools with textbooks increased by 14%.
  - In 2004 it is planned to publish 800 000 textbooks for secondary schools.
- Higher education and testing:
  - Nationwide testing of school graduates in 2003 (USAID support) increased accessibility to higher education; highest scoring graduates admitted to leading national universities without entrance exams and demonstrate progress reaching 90-95% in some universities.
  - An independent testing agency established with USAID support will become fully self-financed starting from 2005.
- Vocational and higher professional education:
  - There are 113 vocational schools; levels of training and material-technical base are below modern requirements.
  - Measures on reforming vocational training will be taken within the Development Strategy for Vocational Education.
  - A Development Strategy for Higher Professional Education was adopted; credit hours system is being introduced.
  - Bachelors are trained in 20 universities and masters in 13 universities; distance teaching is being introduced.
  - An information database and a working group (the Brain Center) will be created to match university supply with employer demand.
- Science, culture, and libraries:
  - State Program on Reforming Sciences and Research for 2003-2005 approved to integrate science, education and industry, form competitive state orders and increase wages in science.
  - State Program for Development of Culture and Arts, 2001-2005, and a draft Law “On Protection and Support of Cultural Activities in the Kyrgyz Republic” guide cultural support and repairs.
  - A Concept Paper on Development of Libraries and Policy on Books will be developed.

### Access to Quality Health Services
- Strategic frameworks:
  - National Program and “Healthcare of Kyrgyzstan in XXI Century” define fundamentals of healthcare policy until 2010.
  - Healthcare Funding Reform Concept until 2006 and Healthcare Development Concept until 2010 were developed to address underfinancing.
- Service delivery and reforms:
  - Family medical centers, family group practitioners and obstetrical-medical centers operate; in 2003 number of in-patient medical institutions and hospitals reduced from 175 to 153.
  - Healthcare Reform II (World Bank financed) trains family medical service personnel and rehabilitates and computerizes institutions.
  - Reforms helped reach a stable trend of increasing life expectancy index (0,73 in 2002 compared with 0,728 in 2001).
- Health financing and insurance:
  - In 2003, health sector funding from the state budget accounted to 2.0% of GDP, compared to 2.1% in 2000.
  - New financing approaches introduced in Jalal-Abad and Batken oblasts and in Bishkek and Osh cities effective January 1, 2004.
  - Introduction of the new financing approach resulted in an increase of spending for medicines provision by 2,2 times in average and the rate of growth of wages of medical workers in hospitals by 1,7 times and the primary level – by 1,3 times.
  - The Law “On Single Payer System in Healthcare Finance in the Kyrgyz Republic” was approved; Mandatory Medical Insurance Fund under the Ministry of Health possesses rights and responsibilities of the Single Payer.
  - In 2003, health care funding from local budgets was at the level of 96,1% of the planned amount, compared to 92,6% in 2002.
  - In 2003 the system of Mandatory Medical Insurance (MMI) covered 81,8% of population compared to 86,2% in 2002; this reflects a decrease in working population from 1.598 million in 2002 to 1.470 million in 2003 while total population increased.
  - Provisions were made in the 2004 republican budget for medical insurance of pensioners per newly enacted law “On amendments and addenda to the Law on Medical Insurance of the Citizens of the Kyrgyz Republic.”
  - An additional MMI program for provision of medicines reduced population payments to an average 46.1% of the total cost of medicines, compared to 50.8% in 2002.
  - Problems of delayed transfers of insurance fees from the Social Fund to MMI and arrears for 2002 have been almost solved.
- Public health programs and outcomes:
  - Two pilot projects introduced WHO-recommended criteria for live births statistics; decision made to disseminate new criteria nationwide.
  - National Preventive Immunization Program for 2001-2005 vaccinated 96-97% of children against the planned level; no new cases of poliomyelitis, tetanus, and diphtheria registered.
  - Brucellosis cases are increasing; a National Program “Brucellosis” is being developed. Echinococcus cases remain stable; a Targeted Complex Program on Fighting Parasitical Illnesses is being implemented.
  - Iron deficiency increased to 4,0% in 2003 compared to 3,0% in 2002; iodine deficiency increased to 4,7% in 2003 compared to 4,2% in 2002.
  - Presidential Decree “On National Council (alliance) on fortification of food under the President of Kyrgyz Republic” directed provision of food enriched with microelements and vitamins; flourmills are installing equipment to enrich flour with iron additives and public information campaigns and medical training seminars are conducted.
  - State Program on HIV/AIDS, Sexually Transmitted Diseases and Diseases Transmitted by Blood for 2001-2005 and National Tuberculosis-II Program for 2001-2005 are implemented.
    - 132 new HIV/AIDS cases (including 125 citizens of the Kyrgyz Republic) were registered in 2003; 160 cases (including 146 citizens) in 2002.
- Water, sanitation and sports:
  - Property rights of rural water consumer associations on water supply systems are being secured; state control over supply of water to residential areas continues.
  - Planned measures include improving material and technical infrastructure of the Center for State Sanitary and Epidemiological Supervision, creating a unified system of monitoring quality of potable water, and training necessary personnel.
  - Council on Physical Training and Sports under the Government established to implement Physical Training and Sports Development Concept until 2010; accreditation resolution adopted; material and technical basis of sports institutions being strengthened and mass sports events organized.

### Rational Environmental Management
- Legislation and institutional measures:
  - Environmental legislation is being improved and harmonized with international legislation.
  - A draft Law “On Single Environmental Tax” was developed to introduce an environmental tax instead of existing fees and payments.
  - Kyrgyz parliament ratified the Charter of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) as part of joining the Nuclear Safety Convention (IAEA).
- Air quality and climate change:
  - The first National Communication on Climate Change was prepared with Global Environmental Fund and UNDP support; it outlined climate-change scenarios and proposed greenhouse gas control measures.
  - Ozone Center established to coordinate the State Program on Abating Use of Ozone-Destructive Substances in 2002-2005.
  - Measures aim to increase the share of alternative and renewable energy sources from 0,15% of the total energy produced in 2001 to 3,5% in 2005, including development of solar heating systems and solar energy collectors.
- Water and land resource management:
  - Draft Water Code promotes rational use and regulation of water resources; Water Resource Management Information System is being introduced regionally; Water Cadastre development promises more effective monitoring.
  - Information and consulting systems are being established in regions to ensure rational use of surface and underground waters.
  - A Land Survey (Cadastre) is being developed for better registration of land resources.
  - Around 25% of pasture became more or less degraded, with average productivity decreased by 15%.
  - A draft Water Strategy aims to increase productivity of watered land by 10% to 2010.
- Mining and biodiversity:
  - Permit applicants for mineral deposits must submit financial guarantees for reclamation activities; new requirements include state environmental examination and design papers for mine closure and land reclamation.
  - Measures and training programs to secure biodiversity and create nature reserves are underway.
  - Over 90% of the territory tends to desertification; forest planting activities organized annually for one month.
  - In 2003, the share of specially protected territories in the total territory reached 4,2% compared with 4,1% in 2001.
  - The share of forests in the total territory in 2003 was 4,32%, compared with 4,25% in 1998.
  - Collaboration with the European Union and its member countries is being developed to secure biodiversity and monitor the environment.
- Regional cooperation:
  - Central Asia Mountains Charter was signed by Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan, and Tajikistan during the Global Mountain Summit to coordinate sustainable mountain development actions.
  - Kyrgyz-Tajik Regional Mountains Center was set up in Bishkek to study pollution of air, glaciers, lakes and water resources.

*Source: _cr04200 - 148.  A  mechanism  of  social  partnership  among  the  State,  employers’  associations  and  labor (IMF PDF).*

### 180.  Consumption  residue  and  production  waste  cause  particular  concern.  In  2002,  62.2  mln

### _cr04200 - 180. Consumption residue and production waste cause particular concern. In 2002, 62.2 mln

### Environmental contamination and disaster risk management
- In 2002, 62.2 mln tons of toxic wastages were accumulated in the republic.
- 75% of them is the most harmful waste.
- Legal and institutional measures:
  - Law “on Environmental Examination” now requires state expert examinations of land development plans and various social, economic, research and development programs that can affect the environment.
  - Appropriate legislature is being developed to implement a Law on Production wastage.
- Disaster prevention and monitoring:
  - Measures are taken to monitor districts prone to emergencies (man-caused emergencies, floods, mudslides, snowfalls, landslides, avalanches, and earthquakes).
  - Preventive measures are taken to forecast natural disasters at a nationwide level.
  - Several state programs are being drafted on protection of the population and areas from floods, and seismic security of population and infrastructure.
- Institutional capacity:
  - Central Asian Institute of Applied Earth Studies was established in Bishkek to work in geodynamics, geocatastrophe studies, environmental protection and water studies.

*Key finding: Large stock of toxic waste (62.2 mln tons in 2002) with 75% classified as most harmful; active legal, monitoring, preventive and institutional responses underway.*

### Gender equity: legal framework and social measures
- Constitutional and programmatic foundations:
  - The new Constitution of the Kyrgyz Republic secured the principle of gender equity in all areas of life.
  - National Plan for Gender Equity for 2002-2006 is being implemented in Kyrgyzstan.
- Laws and institutional measures:
  - Law “On Social and Legal Protection against Family Violence” aims to regulate social and legal protection of victims of domestic violence; government resolutions are being prepared to implement it and state crisis centers, advisory and prophylactic centers are being opened.
  - Law “On Basics of State Guarantees for Gender Equity” (came into force) outlines state guarantees on ensuring equal rights and opportunities of women and men; a Commission to make a gender examination of legislation and programs is being created.
  - Law “On Joining the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women” provides women opportunities of accessing international human rights protection systems.
- Gender-adjusted development outcome:
  - Development Index taking into account gender factor reached 0,723 in 2003 compared to 0,718 in 2002.

### Education and employment by gender (selected statistics)
- Education enrollment shares:
  - Girls account for 49% of students in primary schools.
  - Girls account for 50,2% of students in secondary schools.
  - Girls account for 64,4% of students in secondary special vocational schools.
  - Girls account for 53,9% of students in higher educational institutions.
- Employment sector shares (women):
  - 74,5% of workers in healthcare and social sectors are women.
  - 73,9% of workers in the education sector are women.
  - Agricultural sector: women account for 42,8% of employment.
  - Trade: women account for 45,7% of employment.
- Male predominance:
  - Men prevail in mining industry, energy sector, construction, transport and public administration.
- Organizational and support ecosystem:
  - Over 150 women-led nongovernment organizations focus on women’s issues.
  - Training programs organized especially for unemployed women; special television and radio programs; statistical booklet “Women and Men of the Kyrgyz Republic” is being published.
  - Program of Measures on Fighting Illegal Export of People and Trade on 2002-2005 envisages preventive, researching, legislative and organizational measures; crisis centers, shelters, advisory and prophylactic centers render free legal advice, psychological and other services to victims.

### Cost and consistency of policy measures of the NPRS (fiscal framework and priorities)
- Fiscal strategy and assumptions:
  - Priorities and principal policy measures of the NPRS are reflected in the state spending programs envisaged by the MTBF.
  - Forecast for total value of spending is based on realistic assessment of internal resources, necessity to reduce external debt and possible debt restructuring by the Paris Club at the end of 2004.
  - Total value of spending will gradually decrease, but expenditures on social needs will continue to grow.
- Expenditure ceilings and growth:
  - To define ceilings for 2005-2007 the Government followed CDF/NPRS goals; total expenditures in the state budget with consideration of PIP will grow by 4% a year in real terms, taking into consideration strict budget restrictions in 2005-2007.
  - Reform measures will require substantial short-term expenses to be compensated by possible savings.
- Reallocation priorities:
  - Important changes include:
    - Increase in share of expenditures on education and healthcare.
    - Increase in expenditures on maintenance of infrastructure created within PIP projects.
    - Decrease in share of expenditures used to maintain government bureaucracy and to finance the industrial sector.
    - Reduction in the PIP.
  - Public Expenditure Review by the World Bank was taken into consideration.

### State expenditures in 2004-2007 (selected figures from Table 3; % of GDP)
- Total and investment:
  - Total: 27.4 27.2 26.8 26.1
  - incl. investment expenditures: 4.4 4.6 4.6 4.5
- Social services (2004 2005 2006 2007):
  - Social services: 15.4 15.9 16.3 16.5
  - Education: 4.2 4.6 5.0 5.3
    - incl. investment expenditures: 0.3 0.4 0.7 0.8
  - Health care: 2.0 2.1 2.3 2.4
    - incl. investment expenditures: 0.4 0.3 0.3 0.4
  - Social insurance and social security: 7.6 7.6 7.5 7.5
- Government services:
  - Government services: 1.0 1.0 0.9 0.8
- Economic services:
  - Economic services: 6.2 6.0 5.5 5.2
  - Agriculture: 2.1 2.0 1.9 1.4
    - incl. investment expenditures: 1.6 1.4 1.0 0.9
  - Transport and communications: 2.0 2.0 1.8 1.7
    - incl. investment expenditures: 1.1 1.0 1.1 0.9
- Payment of interest on public debt: 1.2 0.9 0.9 0.7

### Sectoral spending growth and reform measures
- Education:
  - Projected funding increase: 46% over three years in real terms.
  - Rapid growth in investment spending to prevent degradation of educational infrastructure.
  - Decrease role of special means in financing basic secondary education to improve access for poorest children.
  - Teachers’ wages are to rise substantially, predicated on an increase in the standard teaching load.
- Healthcare:
  - During 2004-2007, expenditures on healthcare will grow by 39%.
  - Key reform elements:
    - Completion of restructuring of the medical institutions network.
    - Transfer to the “single payer system” in all regions.
    - Improvement in quality of medical assistance.
    - Reform of the epidemiological service.
    - New policy on provision of medicines, increase in mandatory medical insurance and pilot new financing methods.
- Social insurance and security:
  - Will grow by approximately 14% over the three-year projection period.
  - Resources directed mainly to increasing the unified monthly benefit and other benefits to the poorest strata and to offset anticipated increases in electric power tariff rates.
- Aggregate social spending:
  - Social expenditures of the consolidated state budget will grow by 1.1% of GDP in 2004-2007 or by 24% in real terms.
  - Their share in the consolidated state budget will increase from 56% in 2004 to 63% in 2007.
- Government services and public administration reforms:
  - Budget expenditures on state services will be decreased by 0.2% of GDP in 2007 compared to 2004.
  - Reforms planned in labor remuneration in government sector: increase in wages, reduction in number of civil servants, incentives to improve professional qualifications and differentiation of wages by productivity and responsibility.
- Economic services:
  - Budget expenditures on economic services will decrease by 1% of GDP over three years.
  - Policy reflects privatization and transition of state/communal enterprises to self-financing; tariff increases conditional on offsetting measures for poorest strata.

### Public Investment Program (PIP) and co-financing
- PIP adjustments:
  - A decrease in PIP expenditures is needed to help reduce the state’s external debt.
  - Expected PIP loans: US$ 60-80 billion per year, conforming to PRGF program terms and conditions.
- Project pipeline:
  - During the projection period, 18 new projects will be initiated financed by loans and 7 grant projects.
  - Infrastructure projects in agriculture, transport, energy, education and healthcare will be prominent.
  - A substantial share of new projects will facilitate regional development and growth of villages and small towns.
- Donor roles and co-financing:
  - World Bank and Asian Development Bank resources will continue to play a major role in the PIP.
  - MTBF acknowledges need to co-finance the PIP timely and fully from the state budget or sometimes using means of population; co-financing includes resources to maintain and repair new infrastructure.
  - Development grants will be an important mechanism to obtain state-budget funding for PIP needs, supporting projects by local authorities and civil society.

### Coordination with the donor community (selected commitments and figures)
- International Monetary Fund:
  - In February of 2003, IMF Executive Council approved a Program of aid to Kyrgyz Republic within a three year program of Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction (PEGPR).
  - Total sum of credits provided by IMF amounted to 21,2.mln SDR in 2003.
  - First installment: 11,7 mln. SDR on March 5, 2003.
  - Second installment: 9,6 mln. SDR on July 30, 2003.
- World Bank:
  - Board approved Strategy of Assistance to Kyrgyz Republic on 2003-2006 on May 15, 2003.
  - Total sum of provided aid for three years will be amounted to 171 mln.
  - US$ 65,0 mln. of the total sum will be given on a grant basis.
- Asian Development Bank:
  - Memorandum on Understanding signed in June, 2003 for Strategy and Programs on 2004-2006.
  - Provision envisaged: US$ 90 mln. in loans with privileged terms.
  - Annual technical assistance: around US$ 2 mln.
  - Memorandum on Understanding between Government and Joint Mission on Survey of Portfolio of ADB and World Bank signed on September 4, 2003.
- European Union:
  - Since 1996 and within Food Security Program (FSP) providing annual grant amounting 9,5 mln. Euro to the Kyrgyz Republic.
  - FSP budget support shifting from macroeconomic approach towards sector programme approach.
  - TACIS program moved from project approach to program approach focused on prioritized development directions.
- United Nations Development Program:
  - In March 2003, UNDP conducted a medium-term survey on second frame basis of cooperation 2000-2004 showing remarkable results.
  - Around 100 000 people were jointed into Self-Help Groups.
  - In 2003, a new Country Program on 2005-2010 was developed.
- Ministry of International Development (MID, UK):
  - In 2003 MID continued realization of 10 projects of technical assistance totaling 9,7 mln. pounds sterling.
  - Aid is technical assistance focused on health care, agriculture, public administration and social sector.
- Islamic Development Bank:
  - In 2003 provided technical assistance grant of US$ 130 000 for development of micro-financing in Kyrgyz Republic.

*Italic: Source — _cr04200 - 180. Consumption residue and production waste cause particular concern. In 2002, 62.2 mln (excerpt).*

### 205. The  Government  of  Switzerland  is  one  of  a  few  donors  providing  grant  assistance  on

### 205. The  Government  of  Switzerland  is  one  of  a  few  donors  providing  grant  assistance  on

### Donor assistance: Switzerland, Germany, Japan
- Switzerland:
  - In 2002-2003, Kyrgyz Republic received a grant amounted to US% 5 mln. directed at support of the budget in a part of social security.
  - The Government of Switzerland continues to support development of healthcare, energy, improvement of national statistics, agriculture and timber industry, support of private initiatives in rural and mountainous regions, and regional cooperation.
  - In 2003 the Government of Switzerland provided around US$19 mln. for implementation of the projects.
- Germany:
  - In May 2003 Inter-Government Agreements on Financial and Technical Cooperation on 2003-2004 were carried out and resulted in approval of a Strategy of Aid to the country until 2005.
  - Additional resources in technical assistance amounted to 4 mln. Euro assigned on 2003-2004.
  - Total sum of assignations in the area of technical cooperation amounted to 43,44 euro.
  - In financial cooperation, the government of Germany assigned 16,0 mln. Euro, from which 9,0 mln. Euro constitutes a loan with privileged terms, 7 mln. Euro – grant and 3 mln. Euro – on attendant measures.
- Japan:
  - The Government of Japan provided a grant aid amounted to US$ 10,5 within the framework of Official Assistance on Development in 2002 and which was realized in 2003.
  - Medical equipment was supplied under the Common Grant for the project “Improvement of medical equipment of birth-giving institutions of Kyrgyz Republic”.
  - Non-Project Grant on Increase of Food Production (KP-2) increased the fleet of agricultural technical means and municipal vehicles (refrigerator trucks, seeding machines, tractors, combine harvesters and trolleybuses).
  - Japanese International Cooperation Agency (JICA) supports large technical assistance: training of Kyrgyz specialists and civil servants in Japan, provision of Japanese experts in Kyrgyz ministries and departments, and volunteers in universities and regional schools.

### Regional cooperation and trade integration (2003–early 2004)
- CIS integration and trade:
  - During 2003 some positive changes occurred in economic integration among CIS countries, including Central Asian states.
  - Inter-Government Trade and Economic Commissions intensified in 2003: twelve inter-government actions conducted in 2003 resulted at signing of covenants and achieving two-sided agreements in trade and economic, scientific and technical, tourism, education, energy, transport and use of hydro-energetic resources.
- Kazakhstan agreements (December 2003):
  - Agreements on off-permit order of crossing Kazakh territory by Kyrgyz transport, application of in-Kazakhstan rail-road tariffs to transit shipments of Kyrgyzstan goods, and regulation of disputable issues of Kazakhstan property located in Kyrgyzstan.
  - Kazakhstan initiated joint customs control at the Kyrgyz-Kazakh border; Kyrgyz side supported and planned to complete preliminary activities for realization during the first quarter of 2004.
- WTO-related negotiations:
  - Kyrgyzstan, as a WTO member, completed negotiations with Russia and Kazakhstan and continues negotiations with Ukraine and Vietnam to receive preferential access and eliminate trade barriers.
- Key bilateral and multilateral activities:
  - Most important foreign trade partner: Russia; agreement and beginning of export of electrical power from Kyrgyzstan to Russia.
  - Continued development of trade and economic cooperation with Uzbekistan, Tadjikistan, Ukraine, China, India, Turkey and Iran through inter-government commissions.
  - Kyrgyzstan participates in regional programs by World Bank, ADB, UNDP, EBRD, European Union, and others; hosted Economic Forum of Central Asian community (May 2003).
  - Ongoing regional priorities: water industry, energy and trade cooperation.
- Export promotion:
  - Government of Kyrgyz Republic, with support of the government of Switzerland, initiated a National Strategy on promotion of export of Kyrgyzstan made goods and services within the Comprehensive Development Framework of Kyrgyz Republic till 2010.

### Institutional aspects of NPRS implementation — Partnership and participation
- Objective:
  - Major goal: consolidation of efforts of the government, civil society and international organizations within the Matrix on Partnership and Participation presented in the NPRS.
- Main mechanisms of consolidation:
  - Participation in legislative activities.
  - Development of sectoral and regional policy.
  - Participation of non-government, non-for-profit organizations, government agencies and local self-government agencies in tackling social and economic issues.
  - Participation in monitoring and assessment of measures.
- Legal and institutional developments:
  - New Constitution norms enhance Government interaction with civil society and expand opportunities for NGO participation in the CDF, NPRS and other national programs.
  - Tripartite General Agreement (2002-2004) signed between Government, Federation of Labor Unions of Kyrgyzstan and Republican Union of Employers to foster dialogue and partnership.
- Key participatory events and outcomes (selected):
  - Second Poverty Reduction Forum (February 2003): identified poverty reduction tasks and discussed monitoring mechanisms engaging NGOs and surveys.
  - Kurultai “Peace and Stability in the Year of Kyrgyz Statehood” (March 2003): discussed dialogue and partnership between State and society.
  - April 2003 round table on MDGs with UNDP: linked MDGs and CDF/NPRS; report prepared by CASE-Kyrgyzstan NGO.
  - International seminar “Poverty Reduction Course: Role of the Civil Society in the CDF–NPRS Program in Central Asia” (June 2003): strengthen civil society capacity in implementing, monitoring and evaluating reforms.
  - First International Forum of Businesswomen (June 2003): consolidation for women entrepreneurship development.
  - Partnership Forum “Kyrgyz Statehood of the Third Millennium” (July 2003): adoption of Declaration reflecting ways to develop democratic institutes.
  - Hearing on financial support to NPRS at regional level (August 2003): improved budgeting transparency and poverty focus.
  - Forum “Shady Kyrgyz Republic or sunny Kyrgyzstan” (March 2004) by Bishkek Business Club and Institute of Economic Policy: discussed legalization of shadow economy.
- Media and civil society participation:
  - Contest among journalists on CDF/NPRS coverage; awards given.
  - Round table (May 2003) “Participation of Kyrgyzstan’s Media in Implementation of the CDF and NPRS” included heads/representatives of 45 media agencies plus international and non-government organizations.
  - NGOs actively participate in monitoring and some NPRS indicators were formed and evaluated with NGO involvement.
- Youth engagement:
  - Ongoing work with youth and student organizations on youth policy, rural youth employment, youth computerized information centers, and regional youth centers.
  - The Voice of the Youth TV debates (Jashtar Unu) organized in 2002 discussed youth role in CDF/NPRS.
- Community mobilization and civil society structures:
  - “From the rich to the poor people’s initiative” charity and mutual help mechanisms widely developed.
  - Local administrations and communities set up extra-budgetary savings funds.
  - Establishment counts resulting from social mobilization: 6000 jaamats, 3500 self-help groups, and 4400 community associations.
- Communications and outreach:
  - “New Prospects” Journal of the National CDF Council published quarterly from start of 2003 with World Bank support to popularize reform policy and monitor CDF/NPRS effectiveness.
- Next steps for partnership:
  - Focus on creating effective mechanisms to tap civil society and NGO potential for socially important programs and innovative projects.
  - Improve social partnership principles among government agencies, local self-governments and NGOs.

### Institutional aspects of NPRS implementation — Monitoring and Evaluation System (MES)
- Purpose and scope:
  - MES developed to monitor and supervise program implementation, enable timely adjustment of target parameters, and coordinate activities of public administration, civil society and donor community within NPRS priorities.
- MES components:
  - Tracking NPRS indicators.
  - Approved and implemented line programs.
  - Legal regulatory documents.
  - Conducted analytical surveys and research of non-government organizations.
  - Distribution of financial resources by priority CDF/NPRS areas.
  - Donor aid database.
  - Media materials.
  - Seminars and round tables conducted jointly with NGOs and other organizations.
- Information files and responsibilities:
  - Corresponding information files created, expanded and updated per executive specialists’ regulations.
  - Public administration organs fill out files on a mandatory basis; NGOs on a partnership basis.
  - Specially designed working groups using public access centers (which now number twenty) will conduct this work with representation from government, civil society and private sector.
  - Special technical tasks with detailed instructions and responsibilities developed for all executive specialists on filling MES information files.
- Indicator databases:
  - Information system on the “indicators” component includes two databases:
    - First database: necessary information for data collection and analysis on indicators.
    - Second database: additional information on key indicators for Internet publication.
  - National Statistics Committee is included and fills out its component on indicators at a particular time.
  - Line ministries and regions planned to be included in the system will be able to fill their components within the MES.
- Current limitations and rollout plans:
  - Some MES components lack appropriate real-time electronic information systems; these components use traditional paper-based technology leading to potential delays in timely information on NPRS implementation status.
  - MES structure will be created step-by-step by administration of five information rings covering Bishkek city and Osh city, oblasts, rayons, aiyl okmotu and villages, and including private sector, NGOs and population.
  - Users of information rings will include state agencies, association of the private sector, NGOs and population.
  - Development of information rings envisages use of electronic working sites in local public administrations, line ministries and departments, and information network in the education system (universities, technical schools, secondary schools, libraries), public sector (corporate information network, Internet-cafe, etc.), and NGOs on partnership and participation principles.

*Source: _cr04200 - 205. The Government of Switzerland is one of a few donors providing grant assistance on (IMF PDF content).*

### 236. Special software will be installed to conduct and manage the processes of monitoring and

### _cr04200 - 236. Special software will be installed to conduct and manage the processes of monitoring and

### Monitoring and evaluation systems
- Special software will be installed to conduct and manage the processes of monitoring and evaluation. (Paragraph 236)
- A concrete plan of measures on further development of the system of monitoring and evaluating the realization of the NPRS is being developed. Coordination of donor aid on monitoring and evaluating the realization of the NPRS is being envisaged. (Paragraph 241)

### Institutional capacity, training, and use of experts
- Fundamental problems: lack of knowledge and skills on the methodology of data collection, analysis and interpretation of the basic directions of the NPRS by administrators, and inadequate understanding of existing functions in conformity with the monitoring and evaluation system. (Paragraph 237)
- Planned responses:
  - Use of international experts within implemented projects to conduct seminars and training sessions on methods of analysis and interpretation of data and adoption of monitoring and evaluation skills for all participants of the MES. (Paragraph 238)

### Web transparency and stakeholder engagement
- An official web-site of the CDF/NPRS including key elements of the system of monitoring and evaluation was established and functions at present. The main results of the system of monitoring and evaluation of the implementation of the NPRS will be demonstrated on a regular basis. A forum for discussion of program projects with the population of the republic has been organized on the web-site. (Paragraph 239)
- Results of monitoring and evaluating the realization of the CDF/NPRS are being provided to all interested parties for wide-ranging discussion, improving feedback mechanisms between administrators and final users. (Paragraph 240)

### Programmatic conclusions and governance reforms
- The CDF process has created a framework for coordination among State, civil society, private sector, and donor community; it has improved focusing of internal resources on quality reforms and influenced donor assistance to account for national interests. The overarching CDF goal is halving the level of poverty by year 2010. (Paragraph 242)
- Public administration reforms:
  - NPRS policy will intensify reform of all branches and levels of public administration; structure, functions and responsibilities to be optimized and clearly defined by legislation. (Paragraph 243)
  - Continue reforming central and local executive organs based on de-centralization and strengthening local communities; transform parts of public functions to private sector and NGO where appropriate. (Paragraph 244)
  - Promote joint development and implementation of development programs by government, non-government organizations, and local communities. (Paragraph 245)

### Macroeconomic developments and 2004 policy priorities
- 2003 trends: generally strengthened macroeconomic stabilization and improvement in the economic situation; recovery of economic growth after the recession in 2002 and alignment with the IMF three-year economic program. (Paragraph 246)
- In 2004, main economic policy focus under NPRS:
  - A further strengthening of macroeconomic stabilization;
  - Support of sustainable pro-poor economic growth;
  - Significant improvement in the coordination of budgetary and monetary policies;
  - Improving the transparency of state financial management;
  - Reduction of the external debt burden;
  - Creation of a favorable investment environment. (Paragraph 247)

### Structural, fiscal, revenue, and monetary policies
- Structural policy: aim to reduce the level of quasi-fiscal deficit in the electric power sector. (Paragraph 248)
- Budgetary policy in 2004 will focus on supporting macroeconomic balance and ensuring financial stability through:
  - Exercising strict control over expenditures;
  - Focusing financial resources on priority NPRS tasks;
  - Improving effectiveness of social expenditures;
  - Introduction of program-based budgeting at sectoral and local levels;
  - Effective system of inter-budgetary relations, reform of the Treasury;
  - Introduction of international standards for state financial statistics. (Paragraph 249)
- Revenue policy objective: ensure predictability and transparency of the tax system by improving tax collection, expanding the tax base, raising effectiveness of tax administration, simplifying the tax system, and transferring authority to collect some taxes to local authorities. (Paragraph 250)
- Expenditure policy: optimize transfers and grants, raise effectiveness of investments and funding of priority development areas. (Paragraph 251)
- Monetary policy: aimed at keeping inflation under 4%. The National Bank of the Kyrgyz Republic will pursue a floating exchange rate with interventions to alleviate temporary nominal exchange rate fluctuations and strengthen foreign currency reserves. (Paragraph 252)
- Debt management: improve effectiveness of implementation of the comprehensive debt strategy, continue restructuring foreign debts jointly with the Paris Club creditors, trim the Public Investment Program, and improve coordination of donor assistance and effectiveness of external borrowings. (Paragraph 253)
- Investment climate: measures to improve governance and reform the financial sector to attract foreign and domestic investments. (Paragraph 254)

### Social policy outcomes and indicators
- Human development and health:
  - Human Development Index increased to 0,728 in 2003 from 0,724 in 2002. (Paragraph 255)
  - Lifetime Index exhibited a tendency to increase. (Paragraph 255)
  - Infant Mortality in 2003 declined by 1,4% in comparison to 2002. (Paragraph 255)
  - Development index taking into account gender factor shows steady growth. (Paragraph 255)
- Social reforms contributed to economic growth with real impact on poverty reduction; improvements in welfare, employment, and personal income are reported. (Paragraph 255)

### 2004 social policy measures (planned actions)
- Creation of new jobs and liberalization of the labor market and labor relations based on the State Labor Market Policy to the year 2010 (under development) and other line programs.
- Further improvement in focusing social security on the poorest strata, together with social mobilization of population.
- Effective implementation of the concept paper for further reform of the retirement benefit system; raising pension levels and development of a non-government pension insurance system.
- Effective implementation of the Education Development Concept to 2010 and other educational projects and programs to improve accessibility and quality of education; raising teacher salaries.
- Increase accessibility of quality healthcare through realization of the Manas National Healthcare Reform II Program, Healthcare of Kyrgyzstan in XXI Century Program, and other healthcare projects and programs.
- Development of legal framework for rational environmental management; build capacity of government agencies in monitoring and forecasting emergencies.
- Foster conditions that ensure gender equity in all areas through active implementation of the National Plan for Gender Equity for 2002-2006. (Paragraph 256)

### Infrastructure, feedback, and prioritization in 2004
- Development of infrastructure and improvement of monitoring and evaluation will continue nationwide; plans to improve feedback mechanisms for active population participation in the CDF/NPRS process. (Paragraph 257)
- Additional efforts in 2004 to prioritize activities according to NPRS goals and tasks and to raise effectiveness of using financial resources for priority CDF/NPRS areas. (Paragraph 258)

### Appendix 1 — Balance of Payments and external financing (selected exact figures)
- Current Account: -121 (2002), -104 (2003), -133 (2004), -173 (2005), -150 (2006), -122 (2007), -165 (2008), -198 (2009), -198 (2010), -1365 (Total).  
- Trade Balance: -54 (2002), -83 (2003), -116 (2004), -160 (2005), -161 (2006), -144 (2007), -200 (2008), -245 (2009), -266 (2010), -1429 (Total).  
- Exports: 498 (2002), 590 (2003), 633 (2004), 658 (2005), 703 (2006), 766 (2007), 770 (2008), 784 (2009), 827 (2010), 6230 (Total).  
- Imports: -552 (2002), -673 (2003), -749 (2004), -819 (2005), -864 (2006), -911 (2007), -970 (2008), -1029 (2009), -1093 (2010), -7659 (Total).  
- Services (Net): -67 (2002), -38 (2003), -38 (2004), -38 (2005), -17 (2006), -6 (2007), 4 (2008), 17 (2009), 33 (2010), -149 (Total).  
- o/w interest: -32 (2002), -26 (2003), -38 (2004), -52 (2005), -48 (2006), -46 (2007), -44 (2008), -43 (2009), -42 (2010), -370 (Total).  
- Private Transfers (Net): 0 (2002), 17 (2003), 21 (2004), 25 (2005), 28 (2006), 28 (2007), 30 (2008), 30 (2009), 35 (2010), 214 (Total).  
- Capital Account: 23 (2002), -1 (2003), 4 (2004), -46 (2005), -27 (2006), -15 (2007), 9 (2008), 29 (2009), 61 (2010), 38 (Total).  
- Amortization: -58 (2002), -99 (2003), -64 (2004), -80 (2005), -91 (2006), -76 (2007), -71 (2008), -77 (2009), -65 (2010), -681 (Total).  
- FDI and Other: 45 (2002), 81 (2003), 98 (2004), 68 (2005), 34 (2006), 64 (2007), 61 (2008), 80 (2009), 106 (2010), 126 (Total), 718 (Aggregate reported).  
- Increase in Gross Reserves (-): -57 (2002), -54 (2003), -65 (2004), 4 (2005), 8 (2006), -25 (2007), -16 (2008), 3 (2009), -20 (2010), -223 (Total).  
- Financing Requirement: 154 (2002), 159 (2003), 194 (2004), 215 (2005), 169 (2006), 162 (2007), 173 (2008), 166 (2009), 157 (2010), 1550 (Total).  
- Identified Financing (annual entries shown as a sequence in table): 154 (2002), 159 (2003), 194 (2004), 140 (2005), 27 (2006), -4 (2007), -10 (2008), -20 (2009), -22 (2010), 618 (Total).  
- Existing Bilateral Commitments: 133 (2002), 111 (2003), 122 (2004), 126 (2005), 55 (2006), 20 (2007), 10 (2008), 0 (2009), 0 (2010), 576 (Total).  
- Loans: 74 (2002), 65 (2003), 73 (2004), 80 (2005), 50 (2006), 20 (2007), 10 (2008), 0 (2009), 0 (2010), 373 (Total).  
- Grants: 19 (2002), 9 (2003), 14 (2004), 12 (2005), 5 (2006), 0 (2007), 0 (2008), 0 (2009), 0 (2010), 58 (Total).  
- Grants in kind: 40 (2002), 36 (2003), 36 (2004), 34 (2005), 0 (2006), 0 (2007), 0 (2008), 0 (2009), 0 (2010), 145 (Total).  
- Balance of Payments Support from IFIs: 46 (2002), 2 (2003), 5 (2004), 23 (2005), 14 (2006), -28 (2007), -24 (2008), -20 (2009), -20 (2010), -22 (Total), -69 (Aggregate reported).  
- Debt Rescheduling (Paris Club Flow Relief): 19 (2002), 44 (2003), 48 (2004), 0 (2005), 0 (2006), 0 (2007), 0 (2008), 0 (2009), 0 (2010), 111 (Total).  
- Additional Financing Needed: 0 (2002), 0 (2003), 0 (2004), 76 (2005), 142 (2006), 166 (2007), 183 (2008), 186 (2009), 179 (2010), 932 (Total).

*Source: CDF/NPRS implementation report excerpts and Appendix 1 balance of payments table as provided in the PDF content unit.*

### APPENDIX 2. NPRS MONITORING INDICATORS

### APPENDIX 2. NPRS MONITORING INDICATORS

### International Indicators
- Human development index (index): 0,719 (2000); 0,723 (2001); 0,724∗ (2002); 0,728∗ (2003)
- Population poverty index (index): 8,4 (2000); 8,7 (2001); 13,4∗ (2002)
- Development index taking into account gender factor (index): 0,715 (2000); 0,717 (2001); 0,718∗ (2002); 0,723∗ (2003)
- Note: ∗ Preliminary data

### National macroeconomic performance
- Real GDP growth rate (%): 105,4 (2000); 105,3 (2001); 100,0 (2002); 106,7 (2003)
- Real GDP growth rate per capita (%): 104,4 (2000); 104,5 (2001); 99,2 (2002); 105,7 (2003)
- Consumer price index (% to the same period of previous year): 118,7 (2000); 106,9 (2001); 102,0 (2002); 103,1 (2003)
- Average official US$-som exchange rate (soms to 1 US$): 47,7 (2000); 48,4 (2001); 46,9 (2002); 43,7 (2003)
- Current account in % to GDP (%): -5,8 (2000); -1,2 (2001); - 2,0 (2002); 2,6 (2003)
- State budget deficit /GDP (%): -2,0 (2000); 0,4 (2001); -1,0 (2002); -0,8 (2003)
  - plus PIP (%): -9,2 (2000); -4,0 (2001); -5,6 (2002); -5,8 (2003)

### Public finance and budget indicators
- State budget revenue /GDP (%): 15,3 (2000); 17,0 (2001); 19,1 (2002); 18,3 (2003)
- State budget expenditure /GDP (%): 17,3 (2000); 16,6 (2001); 20,2 (2002); 20,3 (2003)
- Tax inflows /GDP (%): 11,7 (2000); 12,4 (2001); 13,9 (2002); 14,3 (2003)
- Volume of tax receipts transferred to the budget from privatized enterprises (mln. soms): 925,4 (2000); 1048,9 (2001); 1099,2 (2002); 225,1 (2003)
- State consumption /GDP (%): 20,1 (2000); 17,5 (2001); 18,6 (2002); 19,6 (2003)
- Private consumption /GDP (%): 65,7 (2000); 64,8 (2001); 67,6 (2002); 68,8 (2003)
- Consumption /GDP (%): 85,8 (2000); 82,3 (2001); 86,2 (2002); 88,4 (2003)

### Growth structure and investment
- Share of value added by industry /GDP (%): 25,0 (2000); 23,1 (2001); 17,9 (2002); 18,0 (2003)
- Share of value added by agriculture /GDP (%): 34,2 (2000); 34,5 (2001); 34,4 (2002); 35,2 (2003)
- Share of services /GDP (%): 31,8 (2000); 31,7 (2001); 35,8 (2002); 35,1 (2003)
- Investments in fixed capital /GDP (%): 16,6 (2000); 13,3 (2001); 12,5 (2002); 10,5 (2003)
- SME production /GDP (%): 42,7 (2000); 42,9 (2001); 44,3 (2002); 47.5 (2003)

### Financial system and monetary indicators
- Gross volume of foreign reserves of the NBKR (mln. US$): 261,1 (2000); 285,2 (2001); 316,7 (2002); 389,0 (2003)
- Level of monetization (average annual) (%): 10,6 (2000); 10,0 (2001); 12,5 (2002); 15,1 (2003)
- Share of loans /GDP (%): 3,4 (2000); 3,7 (2001); 4,5 (2002); 14,6 (2003)
- Share of deposits to M2 (%) : 44,1 (2000); 38,8 (2001); 37,5 (2002); 36,5 (2003)
- Interest rates of commercial banks (weighted average for the period):
  - on deposits and accounts in the national currency (%): 14,5 (2000); 8,1 (2001); 4,1 (2002); 2,5 (2003)
  - on deposits and accounts in the foreign currency (%): 2,6 (2000); 1,0 (2001); 0,6 (2002); 0,5 (2003)
  - on loans in the national currency (%): 46,8 (2000); 36,4 (2001); 30,2 (2002); 25,1 (2003)
  - on loans in the foreign currency (%): 30,6 (2000); 25,0 (2001); 22,6 (2002); 17,4 (2003)
- NBKR rate (%): 38,3 (2000); 8,0 (2001); 4,4 (2002); 4,0 (2003)
- Share of investment credits in the total credit portfolio (%): 0 (2000); 37 (2001); 56 (2002); 46 (2003)

### Labor market, employment, and social protection
- Unemployment level — total (%): 7,5 (2000); 7,8 (2001); 8,6 (2002); 8,7 (2003)
- Unemployment level — official (%): 3,0 (2000); 3,1 (2001); 3,1 (2002); 2,9 (2003)
- Number of newly employed to the total number of registered unemployed (%): 42,3 (2000); 46,5 (2001); 54,5 (2002); 45,3 (2003)
- Coverage of unemployed by temporary public works (%): 30,3 (2000); 29,0 (2001); 28,0 (2002); 23,7 (2003)
- Average duration of unemployed citizens’ participation in public works (months): 9,4 (2000); 3,2 (2001); 2,7 (2002); 2,5 (2003)
- Share of newly employed youth in total young applicants to employment services (%): 37,1 (2000); 44,7 (2001); 53,4 (2002); 45,0 (2003)
- Share of employment of unemployed women in total women applicants to employment services (%): 45,2 (2000); 47,4 (2001); 54,5 (2002); 53,4 (2003)

### Poverty, social outcomes, and targeted social protection
- Poverty level (%): 52,0 (2000); 47,6 (2001); 44,4 (2002); 40,8 (2003)
- Extreme poverty level (%): 17,8 (2000); 13,5 (2001); 13,8 (2002); 9,4 (2003)
- Poverty depth (%): 17,7 (2000); 13,9 (2001); 13,2 (2002); 9,0 (2003)
- Gini coefficient (index): 0,449 (2000); 0,441 (2001); 0,419 (2002); ...
- Share of the population receiving UMB of the total number of the population (%): 9,8 (2000); 10,3 (2001); 9,5 (2002); 10,6 (2003)
- Share of poor families who received a lump-sum UMB for the whole year in the total number of UMB recipients (%): 0 (2000); 0 (2001); 0,02 (2002); 0,08 (2003)
- Ratio of the guaranteed minimum consumption level to the minimum consumer budget per capita (%): 8,3 (2000); 9,1 (2001); 10,1 (2002); 8,6 (2003)
- Volume of funds allocated for payment of compensation to poor strata for increased energy tariffs (mln. soms): 0,126 (2000); 27,3 (2001); 48,8 (2002)

### Children, education, and health
- Number of homeless children rehabilitated through social establishments (persons): 2708 (2000); 2978 (2001); 2982 (2002); 976 (2003)
- Volume of funds allocated for protection of children — education (mln. soms): 1,3 (2000); 1,6 (2001); 1,8 (2002); 1,0 (2003)
- Volume of funds allocated for protection of children — medical insurance of children under 16: 20,0 (2000); 24,7 (2001); 46,3 (2002); 9,5 (2003)
- Presence of expenditure items for childhood protection in the Law on the Budget (count): 14 (2000); 14 (2001); 14 (2002); 14 (2003)
- Coverage of children of appropriate age by pre-school education (%): 8,7 (2000); 9,0 (2001); 9,5 (2002); 9,9 (2003)
- Coverage of children of appropriate age by incomplete secondary education (grades 1-9) (%): 95,9 (2000); 95,0 (2001); 94,6 (2002); 94,8 (2003)
- Literacy rate among persons aged 15 and above (%): 98,7 (2000); 98,7 (2001); 98,7 (2002); 98,7 (2003)
- Percentage of the population with no access to healthcare services (due to expensiveness and remote location) (%): 11,4 (2000); 9,3 (2001); 26,0 (2002); ...
- Access of the population to clean potable water (%): 81,5 (2000); 79,6 (2001); 78,9 (2002); ...
- Share of the population covered by mandatory medical insurance (%): 73,0 (2000); 83,7 (2001); 86,2 (2002); 81,8 (2003)
- Share of children by age groups who fell ill with certain vaccine-preventable diseases (%): 0,06 (2000); 0,02 (2001); 0,06 (2002); 0,1 (2003)
- Share of the population with iodine deficiency (%): 0,4 (2000); 3,4 (2001); 4,2 (2002); 4,7 (2003)
- Share of the population with iron deficiency (%): 3,0 (2000); 3,4 (2001); 3,0 (2002); 4,0 (2003)
- Number HIV/AIDS cases (total/citizens of the Kyrgyz Republic) (persons): 16/4 (2000); 149/134 (2001); 160/146 (2002); 132/125 (2003)

### Retirement system and social insurance
- Ratio of the average pension to the average wage (%): 37,7 (2000); 40,1 (2001); 33,3 (2002)
- Ratio of the base pension to the minimum pensioner’s consumer budget (%): 19,7 (2000); 18,2 (2001); 17,5 (2002); 17 (2003)
- Growth rate of the total size of the pension (%): 120 (2000); 121 (2001); 101 (2002); 110 (2003)
- Number of nongovernment pension funds (quantity): 1 (2000); 1 (2001); 1 (2002); 1 (2003)
- Changes in the number of social insurance premium payers — legal entities (%): 73 (2000); 117 (2001); 95,9 (2002); 117 (2003)
- Changes in the number of social insurance premium payers — individuals (%): 72 (2000); 108 (2001); 129 (2002); 122 (2003)

### Business environment, privatization, and trade
- Number of privatized entities (quantity): 168 (2000); 88 (2001); 102 (2002); 64 (2003)
- Changes in the volume of export (%): 111,2 (2000); 94,4 (2001); 102,0 (2002); 119,8 (2003)
- Changes in the volume of foreign trade turnover (%): 100,5 (2000); 89,1 (2001); 113,7 (2002); 121,1 (2003)
- Trade balance (mln. US$): -49,6 (2000); 8,9 (2001); -101,3 (2002); -135,2 (2003)
- Changes in the volume of production output (physical volume of output to previous year) (%): 106,0 (2000); 105,4 (2001); 89,1 (2002); 114,0 (2003)

### Security, migration, and other social risks
- Number of registered violations of law connected with drug abuse and drug trafficking (cases): 3539 (2000); 3205 (2001); 3018 (2002); 3106 (2003)
- Number of refugees (1000 persons): 10,6 (2000); 9,2 (2001); 7,6 (2002); 7,5 (2003)
- Internal migration (incoming + outgoing) (persons): 44728 (2000); 43645 (2001); 49235 (2002); 51780 (2003)
- Number of reported employment accidents (persons): 309 (2000); 282 (2001); 263 (2002); ...
- Expenses for compensation of damage from employment accidents (mln. soms): 24,6 (2000); 11,3 (2001); 8,3 (2002); ...
- Budget funding /total expenditures for ensuring external security (%): 3,5 (2000); 4,3 (2001); 4,5 (2002); 2,7 (2003)
- Budget funding /total expenditures for prevention of natural calamities (%): 2,0 (2000); 1,6 (2001); 1,5 (2002); 1,8 (2003)
- Level of juvenile delinquency (%): 3,2 (2000); 2,5 (2001); 5,3 (2002); 3,3∗ (2003)
  - Note: ∗ Data of 2003 is preliminary

_Appendix 2. NPRS MONITORING INDICATORS (tables and figures as presented in the source)._

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2004/_cr04200.pdf_
