## _cr04393 — Lao PDR: National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES) (excerpts)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr04393 — Lao PDR: National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES) (excerpts)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2004/_cr04393.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2004/_cr04393.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2004/_cr04393.pdf.json)

---

### Overview and strategic objectives
- NGPES renamed from NPEP to better reflect substance and avoid confusion with 8 national programmes.
- Dual objective: enhancing growth and development, and reducing poverty; focus on poorest districts.
- Long-term national development goal: exit the group of LDCs by 2020 through sustained equitable economic growth and social development.
- NGPES structure: assessment of poverty (Part II); environment for sustainable economic growth (Part III); national action plans and programmes (Part IV); mobilising resources consistent with national expenditure framework (Part V); participation and implementation strategy (Part VI).

### Recent poverty trends and targets
- Poverty head count:
  - 1992/93: 45 per cent
  - 1997/98: 38.6 per cent
  - 2002/03 (preliminary): about 30 per cent
- National targets:
  - Sustain economic growth with equity at an average rate of about 7 per cent to triple per-capita income by 2020.
  - Halve poverty levels by 2005 and eradicate mass poverty by 2010.
  - Eliminate opium production by 2006 and phase-out shifting cultivation by 2010.

### Geographic targeting and prioritisation
- Official poverty identification (Instruction No 010/PM):
  - 72 districts identified as poor.
  - 47 districts selected as the core group for priority investments (2003-2005).
- Aggregated counts for 72 districts:
  - Number of poor villages: 4,126
  - Number of poor households: 160,592
  - 76 per cent of the villages in these districts are poor and 50 per cent of the households are poor.
- Government priority rationale:
  - 40 districts identified as very poor: incidence 70 per cent (deepest poverty), representing 19.7 per cent of the population but 43.2 per cent of the country’s poor.

### Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF) FY 2003-2004 to FY 2005-2006 — growth assumptions
- GDP growth rates (Government’s MTEF estimates):
  - FY 2002-2003: 5.9 per cent
  - FY 2003-2004: 6.2 per cent
  - FY 2004-2005: 6.5 per cent
  - FY 2005-2006: 7.0 per cent
- Longer-term ambition: sustained 7 per cent beyond FY 2005-2006; implied gross investment around 26 per cent of GDP with private investment "not less than 16 per cent of GDP" and public investment 10-11 per cent of GDP (of which 3.5 per cent of GDP from government budget and 7 per cent of GDP from ODA).

### Fiscal aggregates and key statistics (Billion Kip; percentages preserved exactly)
- GDP Growth Rate (presented):
  - 2002/03: 5.9%
  - 2003/04: 6.2%
  - 2004/05: 6.5%
  - 2005/06: 7%
- Budget Revenue:
  - 2002/03: 2,466.7
  - 2003/04: 2,900.6
  - 2004/05: 3,510.7
  - 2005/06: 4,244.3
- Revenue/GDP:
  - 2002/03: 11.3%
  - 2003/04: 11.9%
  - 2004/05: 12.6%
  - 2005/06: 13.4%
- Budget Expenditure:
  - 2002/03: 4,240.5
  - 2003/04: 4,627.5
  - 2004/05: 5,046.6
  - 2005/06: 5,665.5
- Expenditure/GDP:
  - 2002/03: 19.5%
  - 2003/04: 18.9%
  - 2004/05: 18.2%
  - 2005/06: 17.9%
- Total PIP:
  - 2002/03: 2,610
  - 2003/04: 2,580
  - 2004/05: 2,950
  - 2005/06: 3,200
- Domestically funded (PIP):
  - 2002/03: 960
  - 2003/04: 760
  - 2004/05: 1,000
  - 2005/06: 1,100
- ODA funded (PIP):
  - 2002/03: 1,650
  - 2003/04: 1,820
  - 2004/05: 1,950
  - 2005/06: 2,100
- PIP/GDP:
  - 2002/03: 12.2%
  - 2003/04: 10.5%
  - 2004/05: 10.6%
  - 2005/06: 10.1%

### PIP composition, sector shares and domestic allocations
- Domestic/Total PIP shares:
  - 2002/03: 36.7 %
  - 2003/04: 29.5 %
  - 2004/05: 33.9 %
  - 2005/06: 34.0 %
- Sector breakdown (shares of PIP):
  - Economic Sector:
    - 2002/03: 59.7 %
    - 2003/04: 59.7 %
    - 2004/05: 58.05 %
    - 2005/06: 56 %
  - Social Sector:
    - 2002/03: 27.6 %
    - 2003/04: 29.7 %
    - 2004/05: 31.4 %
    - 2005/06: 33.6 %
  - Education:
    - 2002/03: 11.4 %
    - 2003/04: 12 %
    - 2004/05: 13 %
    - 2005/06: 14 %
  - Health:
    - 2002/03: 8.7 %
    - 2003/04: 9.5 %
    - 2004/05: 10.15 %
    - 2005/06: 11 %
  - Other Investments (administration, etc.):
    - 2002/03: 13.0 %
    - 2003/04: 10.6 %
    - 2004/05: 10.5 %
    - 2005/06: 10.4 %
- Domestic PIP allocation FY 2003-2004 (760 billion kip):
  - 300 billion kip: debts from past PIP investments
  - 200 billion kip: on-going national projects
  - 160 billion kip: counterpart funds to ODA projects
  - 100 billion kip: poverty eradication (40 billion kip for the 47 poorest districts; 60 billion kip for extension services, market production, income generation and capacity building)
- Target mobilisation FY2003/04–FY2005/06:
  - 8,730 billion kip (approximately US $870 million)
  - Domestic resources expected to mobilise a third: 2,860 billion kip (or around US$ 290 million)

### Fiscal management and revenue prospects
- Annual revenue increases assumed at 20 per cent for coming years; revenue/GDP expected to reach 13.4 per cent in FY 2005-2006.
- Fiscal stance FY 2003-2004:
  - Year described as a transition; PIP domestic contribution reduced at least 20 per cent.
  - Top priorities: substantially increase public servant salaries, resolve outstanding debt issues, strengthen business environment, improve public enterprise sector.
  - Combination of fiscal restraint, greater revenue collection effort, and tight monetary policy.

### ODA and PIP dependency
- ODA accounts for approximately four-fifths of total public investment historically.
- 2001 ODA flows:
  - New bilateral and multilateral ODA agreements: US$ 393 million (of which grants were US$ 206 million).
  - ODA disbursements: US$ 380 million.
- ODA component in PIP FY 2002-2003: 66 per cent overall; sectoral: ~90 per cent in communications and transport, ~60 per cent for rural development.
- Government commitment: gradually lessen high dependency on ODA by broadening domestic resource mobilisation, improving tax administration, private sector development and resource-base investments (hydropower, mining, tourism, wood- and agro-processing).

### Sectoral operational priorities — selected highlights

- Agriculture/Forestry
  - Primary poverty objective: improvement of household food security.
  - Sector goals to 2020 include ensuring food security, agricultural output growth of 4-5 per cent annually, stabilising shifting cultivation by 2005 and phasing out by 2010, and achieving 60 per cent forest coverage by 2020.
  - Immediate priority projects (first group of eleven high priority projects) include aquaculture, animal health, micro-finance expansion, seed multiplication, NTFP research and processing (Table 15 list preserved in source).

- Education
  - Targets (selected):
    - Total enrolment rate: 2000: 70.2; 2005: 85; 2010: 90; 2020: 95
    - Adult literacy over 15 years (%): 2000: 70; 2005: 78; 2010: 84; 2020: 90
  - Poverty-focused district targets for the 47 poorest districts (examples):
    - Primary enrolment target for districts in 2006: 70 per cent (country 2006: 87)
    - Literacy percentage (age 15+), 2006: 78 (districts 65)
  - Short-term FY targets: raise share of consolidated budget for education from planned 10.1 per cent in 2001/02 to 15 per cent by 2005/06.

- Health
  - Per capita expenditure on health care about US$12.
  - Health sector allocation 2001/02: 5.5 per cent of national budget equal to 1.3 per cent of GDP.
  - 2005 targets for the 47 poorest districts (coverage and mortality):
    - 80-85 per cent access to PHC; 60-65 per cent access to clean water; 45 per cent access to sanitation.
    - IMR target: 60/1000 live birth; U5MR target: 80/1000 live births; MMR target: 350/100,000 live births.
  - Strategic programmes: 12 major programmes including IEC, rural health network expansion, upgrading capacity of health workers, MCH promotion, immunisation, water supply/environmental health, communicable disease control, HIV/AIDS/STD control, village drug revolving funds, food and drug safety, traditional/modern medicine cooperation, and sector sustainability.

- Transport and infrastructure
  - Road network ~32,600 km; pavement some 4,590 km.
  - Electrification: only 20 per cent of all villages and 34 per cent of households have access to electricity; Government target: 70 per cent of households electrified by 2010.
  - Transport priorities: all-weather road access for poor districts and focal areas; strengthen Road Maintenance Fund (RMF) and increase local road maintenance allocation over time.
  - RMF and maintenance budget (Table 26 figures preserved):
    - Total Maintenance (example FY 03/04–09/10 row entries): 19.1 17.2 21.1 23.0 25.1 30.3 31.4 167.2 (columns correspond to fiscal years as in source).

- Energy and hydropower
  - Hydropower potential: estimated 18,000 MW; developed so far: 623 MW.
  - Electrification: only ten per cent of rural areas on grid; target: 70 per cent of households electrified by 2010.
  - Policy: complete small/medium projects (up to about 60 MW) for domestic use; proceed with Nam Theun 2; construct a 500 KM high voltage transmission system; continue mini-developments for off-grid supply.

### Participatory planning, implementation and monitoring
- NGPES is a rolling process with continuing consultations via Roundtable process and participatory poverty assessments (PPA, RPA).
- Institutional responsibilities:
  - Committee for Planning and Co-operation (CPC): planning and investment aspects, guide implementation.
  - National Statistical Centre: central agency for monitoring the poverty situation.
  - National Steering Committee: overall co-ordination.
  - Ministry of Foreign Affairs: resource mobilisation.
  - Technical working committee (Department of General Planning): operationalisation, costing, monitoring.
- Early operational priorities:
  - Finalise participatory district planning approach; prepare district plans for the poorest districts.
  - Launch sector-wide approach in education and health.
  - Operationalise and prioritise sector/sub-sector programmes; consistent reform implementation.
- Monitoring instruments:
  - LECS I, II, III surveys (LECS III data collection completed February 2003; preliminary report expected by end-2003).
  - Quantitative measures: absolute poverty lines using food poverty line (2100 calories/day) plus 20 per cent non-food allowance.
  - Qualitative methods: PPA and RPA; vulnerability indices; village statistical monitoring (Village Statistics Book).

### Poverty measurement and vulnerability
- Food poverty line: threshold 2100 calories per day per person; overall poverty line = cost of this intake plus 20 per cent for non-food necessities.
- Vulnerability index components (six indicators): rice production per person, large livestock per person, forested area per family, use of roads (distances up to 6 kilometres), maternal and infant mortality rates, percentage of illiteracy.
- LECS III enhancements: rural prices, household assets/income modules, housing, education, health, time-use for household members, price questionnaire on 121 commodities.

### Inequality and distributional concerns
- Gini coefficient:
  - 1992-93: 28.6
  - 1997-98: 35.7
- Quintile shares (1992-93 -> 1997-98):
  - First: 9.3 -> 7.8
  - Second: 13.5 -> 11.8
  - Third: 16.9 -> 15.4
  - Fourth: 21.9 -> 20.6
  - Fifth: 38.4 -> 44.4
- Observation: inequality widened between 1992/93 and 1997/98; growth benefits accrued more to the rich than the poor.

### Governance, public sector reform and capacity building
- Governance priorities: public service improvement; redefining central-local relations; rule of law; socio-economic management.
- Public service objectives: lean, responsive, cost-effective administration; merit-based recruitment and promotion; salary improvements; ethical civil service.
- Capacity building:
  - Decree on ODA Management requires capacity building in all ODA programmes.
  - NOSPA and other training institutions to strengthen public administration and decentralisation management.
  - Emphasis on district-level capacity for planning, fiscal and implementation roles.

### National poverty-related programmes and social safeguards
- Three poverty-related national programmes (NGPES operational framework):
  - National Drug Control programme (opium elimination target by 2005; estimated US $68 million needed over next six years for opium-growing districts and programmes).
  - UXO Decontamination programme (UXO Lao and Trust Fund; priority clearance in poorest districts; "The Safe Path Forward" national strategic plan approved).
  - National Action Plan for HIV/AIDS/STD (NSP 2002–2005; surveillance, STD control, prevention among youth, mobile populations and service women; care and support; detailed budget matrices and funding gaps presented).

### Key MDG-related indicators and targets (selected)
- Poverty head count ratio:
  - 1992-1993: 45
  - 1997-1998: 39
  - 2002-2003: 30
- Infant mortality (IMR):
  - 1995: 104; 2000: 82; target 2005: 60; 2010: 40
- Under-five mortality (U5MR):
  - 1995: 170; 2000: 106; target 2005: 80; 2010: 50
- Maternal mortality (MMR):
  - 1995: 656; 2000: 530; target 2005: 350; 2010: 200
- Access to clean water:
  - 2000: 52%; target 2005: 57%; target 2010: 100%
- Education targets (selected from 2020 development vision):
  - Total population projections: 2000: 5.2 million; 2005: 5.9; 2010: 6.6; 2020: 8.2
  - GDP growth rate target: 2005/2010/2020: 7.0 per cent
  - Life expectancy at birth: 2000: 59; 2005: 63; 2010: 67; 2020: 70

### Monitoring, research and data priorities
- Strengthen NSC role for poverty monitoring; integrate quantitative LECS and qualitative PPA/RPA.
- Village-level statistical monitoring expanding: 11 provinces completed first round; need stronger procedures at local level.
- MTEF and full costing of NGPES to be developed over next two years to align PIP and recurrent expenditures with macro framework.

_Italic: Source — PART I–VI and Annex excerpts from Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES), content unit _cr04393 (PDF)._

### PART I: The National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy: An Overview ............................... 1

### PART I: The National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy: An Overview

### Preface — renaming and purpose
- The National Poverty Eradication Programme (NPEP) was renamed by the Government of the Lao PDR to the National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES) to avoid confusion with the 8 national programmes and better reflect its substance.  
- The NGPES is the strategic framework under which all of the Government’s future growth and poverty eradication programmes will be developed and implemented.  
- The NGPES is the result of a process that started in 1996 when the 6th Party Congress defined the long-term development objective as freeing the country from the status of least-developed country (LDC) by 2020.  
- The 7th Roundtable Meeting in November 2000 presented the medium-term strategic approach: “Fighting Poverty through Human Resource Development, Rural Development and People’s Participation”.  
- The NPEP was presented at the 8th Roundtable Meeting in September 2003; in October 2003 the National Assembly mandated the Government to implement it.

### Strategic objectives and rationale
- Dual objective: enhancing growth and development, and reducing poverty.  
- The strategy focuses particularly on improving the poverty situation in the poorest districts.  
- The NGPES is both a process and a document; many issues are intended to be addressed during implementation.  
- The Government’s long-term national development goal: exit the group of LDCs by 2020 through sustained equitable economic growth and social development while safeguarding the country’s social, cultural, economic and political identity.

### Foundational achievements and directions
- Foundations laid over the past 28 years of peace and development include:  
  - Moving consistently towards a market-oriented economy.  
  - Building-up the needed infrastructure throughout the country.  
  - Improving the well-being of the people through greater food security, extension of social services and environment conservation, while enhancing the spiritual and cultural life of the Lao multi-ethnic population.
- In March 2001, the 7th Party Congress specified poverty reduction targets for 2005, 2010 and 2020 and highlighted industrialisation and modernisation priorities.  
- In June 2001, the Prime Minister issued Instruction 010, identifying poverty criteria and clarifying modalities for preparing an operational poverty eradication programme.

### Recent poverty trends (key statistic)
- Poverty decreased from 45 per cent of the population in 1992/93 to about 30 per cent in 2002/03.

### Implementation framework and priorities
- Implementation requires a synergetic undertaking based on:  
  - Four main sectors (as the core of the strategy).  
  - Several supporting sectors.  
  - Cross-sector priorities.  
  - A series of specific, poverty-related national programmes.
- The NGPES expresses the Government’s commitment to gradually lessen the Lao PDR’s high dependency on official development assistance (ODA). The transition away from ODA is expected to result from:  
  - Creating a broad base for country-wide growth.  
  - Significant investments in the national resource base to yield substantial revenues to the budget over time.  
  - Greatly improved tax administration.  
  - Systematic enhancement of all economic sectors, in particular private sector development, to increase revenue flows to the budget and reduce dependency on ODA.
- Recognized constraint: until domestic revenue and resource flows materialise, the existing resource gap must be addressed to keep the momentum of growth and poverty eradication.

### Institutional linkages and policy process
- Party Congress sets guidelines and defines the way forward.  
- Government translates Party guidance into specific targets and objectives via 5-year National Socio-economic Development Plans, identifying strategic programmes and sectoral priorities.  
- Roundtable documents operationalise these plans according to resource mobilisation needs.

*Source: PART I: The National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy: An Overview (excerpt) — Lao PDR NGPES*

### references  that  will  lead  the  Lao  PDR  to  the  achievement  of  the  2020  goal.  The  NGPES  is  the

### Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES)

### Overview
- The NGPES is the Government’s operational response to the over-arching objective of achieving the 2020 goal, building on the medium-term strategic approach to poverty eradication and forming part of an overall “growth with equity” framework.
- Since the adoption of the New Economic Mechanism and the open-door policy in 1986, key social and economic indicators have improved; growth was strong through the nineties and steady since the start of the new millennium in a stable macro-economic climate.
- Implementation focus: continuous strengthening of a favourable environment for sustainable growth and development, with particular focus on poverty eradication in the poorest districts.
- NGPES structure (executive-summary Part I): assessment of poverty (Part II); environment for sustainable economic growth (Part III); national action plans and programmes (Part IV); mobilising resources consistent with national expenditure framework (Part V); participation and implementation strategy (Part VI).

### National Goals and Priorities (Chapter 1)
- Party guidance: 7th Party Congress (March 2001) guidelines emphasize balance among economic growth, socio-cultural development, and environmental preservation; balanced sectoral, regional, urban-rural development; sound macroeconomic management and institutional strengthening; regional and global integration; linkage with national security and stability.
- Long-term objectives:
  - To sustain economic growth with equity at an average rate of about 7 per cent, considered as the necessary rate for tripling per-capita income of the multi-ethnic Lao population by 2020.
  - To halve poverty levels by 2005 and eradicate mass poverty by 2010.
  - To eliminate opium production by 2006 and phase-out shifting cultivation by 2010.
- Strategic priorities to attain objectives:
  - Maintain appropriate economic growth for medium and long-term in response to demographic trends.
  - Enhance human resource development through education (basic, formal, informal) and vocational training.
  - Develop and modernise social and economic infrastructure to facilitate regional economic development and integration.
  - Facilitate access to electricity nationwide.
  - Promote industries using domestic natural resources and support SMEs and handicrafts.
  - Develop and promote all economic sectors, particularly the private sector and FDI, emphasizing export-oriented comparative advantage sectors.
  - Enhance market linkages and trade facilitation.
  - Strengthen legal and regulatory frameworks.
  - Create favourable conditions for financial institutions and capital market development.
  - Promote economic co-operation with all partners and countries.
- Eight priority government programmes: food production; commercial production; shifting cultivation stabilisation; infrastructure development; rural development; human resource development; service development; foreign economic relations.
- Demographic notes:
  - In 2020, the population is expected to reach 8.3 million.
  - People under 20 years of age represent 55 per cent of the population, and those between 20 and 40 years, 26 per cent.
  - The national development strategies emphasise youth who represent over half of the population.

### Defining Role of Poverty (Section 1.1)
- The National Poverty Assessment anchors NGPES, determining content and scope of main components and linking sector action plans to poverty analysis.
- Poverty trends:
  - National poverty reduced from about 45 per cent in 1992/93 to about 38 per cent in 1997/98.
  - Preliminary data indicate a further reduction to about 30 per cent currently.
  - Income disparities appear to have increased.
- Operational definition (Prime Minister’s Instruction No 010/PM, June 25, 2001): “Poverty is the lack of ability to fulfil basic human needs such as not having enough food, lacking adequate clothing, not having permanent housing and lacking access to health, education and transportation services.”
- Implementation and targeting:
  - Instruction No 010/PM outlines poverty indicators at household, village, district, provincial and national levels; implementation is ongoing with preliminary household/village numbers.
  - District-level poverty reduction is the priority focus; districts identified as reliable for data collection, monitoring, coordination and participation.
  - Based on Instruction No 010/PM, the Committee for Planning and Co-operation (CPC) and the provinces identified 72 districts as poor.
  - A core group of the 47 poorest districts has been selected for priority investments for the period 2003-2005.
- Note: Official data from LECS III will be available in the first half of 2004.

### Enabling Environment for Growth and Development (Chapter 2)
- The Government agrees with international financial institutions on necessary reforms to achieve a sound environment for growth; NGPES details reforms and monitoring matrices.

#### Macroeconomic Stability (Section 2.1)
- Key elements: prudent monetary, fiscal, exchange rate and interest rate policies; improved taxation, trade and industrial policies; strengthening open-door policies and ASEAN commitments.
- Reinforcement of legal framework and level playing field for economic actors; application of best corporate practice in banking to mobilise capital for SMEs and rural areas.
- High priority: improvement of the financial sector (including a national strategy and action plan for micro-credit).
- Further reform needed: state-owned enterprises and land use management.

#### Private Sector Development (Section 2.2)
- Private sector, trade, domestic and foreign direct investment (FDI) expected to drive the economy.
- Reforms and actions:
  - Enhance consultation with private sector; streamline licensing and regulatory concerns.
  - Improve transparency of the tax code and strengthen the corporate law framework.
  - Ensure Lao and English versions of laws are made available after passage and conduct consultations during drafting.
  - Prioritise procedures and incentives for FDI to promote technology transfer, management expertise and export growth.
  - Promote SMEs with policies and measures adapted to the Lao PDR.

#### Regional Integration (Section 2.3)
- Regional integration is imperative in context of peace and security.
- NGPES supports ASEAN initiatives, Greater Mekong Sub-region (GMS) participation, a “Growth Triangle Plan” with Vietnam and Cambodia, Mekong-Ganga Basin Commission, “Emerald Triangle” tourism development with Cambodia and Vietnam.
- Illustrative initiatives: agreements on border trade and promotion of the Special Economic Zone in Savannakhet-Seno.

#### Resource Development and Growth (Section 2.4)
- Resource development priorities aim to increase national revenues to support poverty eradication.
- Highest investment priorities: hydropower, mining, tourism, wood- and agro-processing industries.
- Revenues: royalties and taxes to the Government will comprise the bulk of these revenues.
- Emphasis on promoting economic growth centres nationwide to develop natural resource base (water resources, land, forestry and bio-diversity).
  - It is estimated that over two thirds of the GDP derive from natural resources.
- Regional delineation for integrated development: North, Centre, South and Border areas.
  - The Northern Region Development Strategy (ADB-supported) is cited as a model for regional planning and investment.

### Governance and the Role of Government (Chapter 3)
- Transition to market-based system requires Government responsiveness to public and private sector needs while providing policy and regulatory framework to conserve environment and improve livelihoods.
- Strengthening rule of law and continuing policy reform are integral to improved governance; ensure efficient public service delivery through improved organisation, procedures, and a motivated professional civil service with high ethical standards.

#### Governance and Poverty Reduction (Section 3.1)
- Improved governance is linked to poverty reduction by ensuring effective and efficient use of limited public resources.
- Decision-making must be community-based, transparent and accountable.
- Public administration reforms over the past decade aim to create effective, efficient and low-cost public administration with appropriate institutional and legal frameworks.
- Remaining challenges: duplication of mandates, insufficient co-ordination, inadequate management rules and procedures, and very low salaries undermining public service effectiveness.
- Government commitments: strengthen incentives for performance, refine organisational structure and role of government, enhance framework conducive to private sector growth, and maintain stability and unity to ensure growth with equity.
- Reference: Government of Lao PDR, Public Service Reform, People’s Participation, Rule of Law and Sound Financial Management: A Policy Paper of the Government of the Lao PDR on Governance Issues, April 2003.

#### Strengthening Capacity and Rule of Law (Section 3.2)
- NGPES outlines measures to strengthen Government capacity at all levels, with emphasis on the district level and redefinition of central-local relations.
- Community-based public services are expected to be more responsive to needs; emphasis on dialogue between central and local authorities, population and social organisations.
- Administrative reforms aim to improve functioning, accountability, transparency and ethical behaviour.
- Legal access measures: greater transparency and access to legal system; preparation of a master plan for integrated land management highlighting community-led decision-making and resource allocation.
- Financial management: sound, accountable and transparent financial management is integral to increasing efficiency of public management and resource allocation.
- Institutional/legal references:
  - Instruction No 010/PM (June 25, 2001) — operational poverty definition and indicators.
  - Decree NO. 193/PM, 1999 — Anti-Corruption Decree; rewards integrity and performance, curtails conflicts of interest and abuse of office.
  - A new Decree on the Civil Service Statue enables performance-oriented human resource management practices.

*Source: Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES) (content unit).*

### Chapter 4:  The NGPES’ Operational Framework

### Chapter 4: The NGPES’ Operational Framework

### Overall framework and structure
- The NGPES’ medium-term operational framework comprises:
  - Four main sectors: agriculture/forestry, education, health, and infrastructure (especially rural roads).
  - Supporting sectors (potential growth sectors): emerging industrial development through energy and rural electrification, agro-forestry, tourism, mining and construction materials industries.
  - Cross-sector priorities: environment, gender, information and culture, population and social security, with capacity building as an all-cross-cutting issue.
  - Three poverty-related national programmes: the National Drug Control programme, the UXO Decontamination programme and the National Action Plan for HIV/AIDS/STD.
- Common sectoral emphases:
  - i) macro-economic requirements to improve sector roles and mandates;
  - ii) private sector/market orientation/trade facilitation to enhance efficiency;
  - iii) capacity building priorities;
  - iv) environmental concerns;
  - v) gender equity;
  - vi) governance and institutional strengthening;
  - vii) co-ordination among sectors and agencies to achieve higher synergy.

### 4.1 Agriculture/Forestry Development
- Primary poverty-related objective: improvement of household food security.
- Policy directions:
  - Enhance market-based farming.
  - Reduce disparities between lowland and sloping land farming.
  - Enforce sustainable forest and watershed management.

### 4.2 Education and Health Development
- Education priorities:
  - Increased access to education for all people, especially the under-privileged.
  - Strengthening non-formal education and vocational training.
  - Improvement of teachers’ qualifications and relevance of school curricula.
  - Improved management of the education sector.
- Health priorities:
  - Strengthening and improving quality of health care at the grassroots level, particularly in under-served areas.
  - Safe drinking water, sanitation systems and improved nutritional standards.

### 4.3 Infrastructure Development
- Road infrastructure priorities:
  - Maintain existing primary and rural road networks through increasingly decentralised road management.
  - Further develop the rural road network and all-weather provincial/district linkages.
- Rationale:
  - Investments in infrastructure are essential to promote nation-wide economic growth and enhance regional integration.
  - Comprehensive infrastructure helps farmers access services and local, national and regional markets.
  - A functional and well-maintained road network is a precursor to transport and trade services and to the installation of electric power supply in rural areas.

### 4.4 Supporting Sectors
- Supporting sectors include rural electrification, tourism and industrial development with emphasis on small and medium-sized enterprises, trade promotion and development.
- Trade facilitation and market linkages are essential for expansion of agriculture, industry and tourism, and for poverty eradication.
- A sound and competitive banking sector encourages savings and channels financial resources to productive use; it is the foundation for all economic sectors.

### 4.5 Cross-Sector Priorities
- Environmental conservation and natural resource management are high priorities, including:
  - Conserving biodiversity.
  - Community-based forest management.
  - Upgrading deteriorated ecological areas.
  - Countering industrial pollution.
- Gender equality is reflected in the Constitution and the establishment of a National Commission for the Advancement of Women (NCAW); ensuring equal access for women to basic services and productive resources is emphasized.
- Other addressed concerns: cultural and spiritual enhancement, national identity and cultural heritage, strengthening the social security system and emergency relief.
- Population policy (including reproductive health, family planning, and hygiene) aims for balanced population growth and distribution (reference: National Population and Development Policy, 1999).
- Capacity building is of the highest importance, particularly for decentralisation management and development planning.

### 4.6 Selected National Programmes
- National programmes related to poverty eradication (to be intensified, with particular reference to the 47 poorest districts) include:
  - Drug control programme.
  - UXO decontamination programme.
  - HIV/AIDS national action plan.
- These programmes contribute to the national rural development programme which aims to systematically reduce the number of poor districts and complete the focal development area approach.

### Chapter 5: Rural Development and the Poor-District Focus — key elements
- Rural development strategy has two major components:
  - Improving access to essential factors of development (production inputs, markets, human resources, social services and rural finance).
  - Strengthening a comprehensive, poverty-focused planning process at the district level to ensure mutual support and co-ordination of initiatives.
- Emphasis on transitioning from subsistence to commercial farming and diversification away from pioneering shifting cultivation into livestock, horticulture, cash crops, forestry, agro-forestry and NTFPs.
- Capacity building needs at district and village levels include skills in land use and watershed management, and capacity for social/environmental impact analysis and mitigation.
- Targeting for priority investments:
  - 47 districts selected for priority investments over the period to 2005.
  - The remaining 25 districts (of the 72 poor districts identified) will receive priority attention following this period.
- Village and district development funds:
  - Government intends to encourage “development funds” (village and district funds) to provide support to households and villages for income-generating activities.
  - These funds aim to address the present lack of capital identified as a major cause of poverty and to enable community-driven development where government funds are used only for what people cannot do themselves.

### Chapter 6: The Thammasat Way of Development — implications and targets
- Development approach: harmonious “triangular” balance among economic growth, social/cultural development, and conservation of natural resources.
- Food security:
  - Achievement in 2000 of national rice sufficiency was a major milestone.
  - Goal to ensure all people have access to sufficient food throughout the year by addressing food insecurity at household, village and district levels via the district approach.
- Industrialisation and modernization:
  - The industrial sector (including manufacturing) accounts for about 22 per cent of GDP and is growing at around 7-8 per cent annually.
  - This growth rate is assessed as insufficient to absorb rising labour market entrants or ensure adequate national economic growth.
  - NGPES expectation: by 2010 the industrial share of GDP will have risen to about 32 per cent.
  - Priority industries for investment: electricity; agro-forestry; tourism (especially eco-tourism and handicrafts); mining (for processing and export); construction materials.
- Condition for industrialization: development of human resource capacities and scientific and technological development, with ODA programmes/projects to include capacity building activities.
- NGPES positioning: the Government’s comprehensive operational programme to achieve the 2020 goal through sustainable growth and poverty eradication, with resource-base expansion in an ecologically sustainable way.

### Chapter 7: Mobilising and Allocating Resources — fiscal coherence
- Coherence in mobilising and allocating public resources is required; a medium-term expenditure framework is important to reconcile NGPES implementation with budget realities so macroeconomic stability is not jeopardised and fiscal deficit and external debt remain manageable.
- Current limitation: it is not possible to fully estimate the cost of achieving the NGPES’ goals at present.
- Planned action: an estimation of the full implementation cost of the NGPES will be made over the next two years to enable a closer link with the macro-economic framework.

*Source: Chapter 4 (and related excerpts) — The NGPES’ Operational Framework*

### 7.1 The Medium-Term Expenditure Framework FY 2003-2004 to FY 2005-2006

### 7.1 The Medium-Term Expenditure Framework FY 2003-2004 to FY 2005-2006

### MTEF purpose and strategic context
- The medium-term public expenditure framework (MTEF) is an essential planning instrument based on realistic projection of GDP growth rates, revenue flows to the budget and of expenditure needs.
- The MTEF is embedded in the National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES) which stresses the role of all economic sectors, including the private sector as a main engine for growth.
- Private sector development, including foreign direct investment (FDI), is expected to:
  - directly contribute to financing crucial growth investments, such as hydropower and telecommunications;
  - indirectly contribute by expanding the national taxable resource base through creation of wealth as a result of a market-oriented, taxable transformation of national resources.

### Growth projections and underlying assumptions
- The Government’s MTEF (2003-2004 to 2005-2006) is based on the following estimated economic growth rates:
  - FY 2002-2003: 5.9 per cent
  - FY 2003-2004: 6.2 per cent
  - FY 2004-2005: 6.5 per cent
  - FY 2005-2006: 7.0 per cent
- These estimates reflect expected continued and vigorous expansion of the economy, banking on the positive long-term impact of recent measures to encourage production and demand.
- Growth assumptions justified by:
  - continued expansion of the private sector, including foreign investment;
  - encouragement of small and medium-sized enterprises through planned policies and measures;
  - expected recovery of the regional economy as the SARS threat retreats.
- Longer-term ambition:
  - Economic growth rates of 7 per cent beyond FY 2005-2006 described as the cruising speed for the Lao economy.
  - Implied gross investment around 26 per cent of GDP, with private investment "not less than 16 per cent of GDP" and public investment 10-11 per cent of GDP (of which 3.5 per cent of GDP from government budget and 7 per cent of GDP from ODA).

### Fiscal aggregates and key statistics (Billion Kip; percentages preserved exactly)
- Table of key fiscal aggregates (presented as bullets to preserve exact figures):
  - GDP Growth Rate:
    - 2002/03: 5.9%
    - 2003/04: 6.2%
    - 2004/05: 6.5%
    - 2005/06: 7%
  - Budget Revenue:
    - 2002/03: 2,466.7
    - 2003/04: 2,900.6
    - 2004/05: 3,510.7
    - 2005/06: 4,244.3
  - Revenue/GDP:
    - 2002/03: 11.3%
    - 2003/04: 11.9%
    - 2004/05: 12.6%
    - 2005/06: 13.4%
  - Budget Expenditure:
    - 2002/03: 4,240.5
    - 2003/04: 4,627.5
    - 2004/05: 5,046.6
    - 2005/06: 5,665.5
  - Expenditure/GDP:
    - 2002/03: 19.5%
    - 2003/04: 18.9%
    - 2004/05: 18.2%
    - 2005/06: 17.9%
  - Total PIP:
    - 2002/03: 2,610
    - 2003/04: 2,580
    - 2004/05: 2,950
    - 2005/06: 3,200
  - Domestically funded (PIP):
    - 2002/03: 960
    - 2003/04: 760
    - 2004/05: 1,000
    - 2005/06: 1,100
  - ODA funded (PIP):
    - 2002/03: 1,650
    - 2003/04: 1,820
    - 2004/05: 1,950
    - 2005/06: 2,100
  - PIP/GDP:
    - 2002/03: 12.2%
    - 2003/04: 10.5%
    - 2004/05: 10.6%
    - 2005/06: 10.1%
- Projections and revenue expectations:
  - Annual revenue increases are estimated at 20 per cent for the coming years.
  - Projected revenue growth will bring the revenue share of GDP up to 13.4 per cent in FY 2005-2006.
  - Total revenues are now expected to reach 13.4 per cent of GDP by 2005/06.

### Public Investment Programme (PIP) structure and allocations
- Total projected PIP for FYs:
  - FY 2003-2004: 2,580 billion kip
  - FY 2004-2005: 2,950 billion kip
  - FY 2005-2006: 3,200 billion kip
- Domestic contribution to PIP for FY 2003-2004 reduced by 20 per cent from 960 billion kip (FY 2002-2003) to 760 billion kip (FY 2003-2004); planned domestic contributions thereafter:
  - FY 2004-2005: 1,000 billion kip
  - FY 2005-2006: 1,100 billion kip
- Government seeks ODA support to bridge PIP resource gap until budgetary revenues for the PIP reach self-sustaining level.
  - Target mobilisation for FY2003/04 to FY2005/06: 8,730 billion kip (approximately US $870 million).
  - Domestic resources expected to mobilise a third: 2,860 billion kip (or around US$ 290 million).
- PIP investment structure (percentages and amounts preserved exactly):
  - Domestic/Total PIP:
    - 2002/03: 36.7 %
    - 2003/04: 29.5 %
    - 2004/05: 33.9 %
    - 2005/06: 34.0 %
  - Sector breakdown (shares of PIP):
    - Economic Sector:
      - 2002/03: 59.7 %
      - 2003/04: 59.7 %
      - 2004/05: 58.05 %
      - 2005/06: 56 %
    - Social Sector:
      - 2002/03: 27.6 %
      - 2003/04: 29.7 %
      - 2004/05: 31.4 %
      - 2005/06: 33.6 %
      - Education:
        - 2002/03: 11.4 %
        - 2003/04: 12 %
        - 2004/05: 13 %
        - 2005/06: 14 %
      - Health:
        - 2002/03: 8.7 %
        - 2003/04: 9.5 %
        - 2004/05: 10.15 %
        - 2005/06: 11 %
    - Other Investments (administration, etc.):
      - 2002/03: 13.0 %
      - 2003/04: 10.6 %
      - 2004/05: 10.5 %
      - 2005/06: 10.4 %
- Trends and priorities:
  - Social sector share steadily increasing to 33.6 per cent in FY 2005-2006; health and education together represent three quarters of social investments for FY 2005-2006.
  - Economic sector remains most important, absorbing 56 per cent of the PIP in FY 2005-2006.
  - Agriculture/forestry sector’s relative share of economic sector investments is steadily rising as rural development moves under MAF.
  - Transport sector remains high in absolute value but its relative share will slightly decline.

### Domestic PIP allocation details and district focus
- Domestic contribution of 760 billion kip (FY 2003-2004) allocated as:
  - 300 billion kip allocated to debts from past PIP investments;
  - 200 billion kip allocated to on-going national projects;
  - 160 billion kip to counterpart funds to ODA projects (both ongoing and new);
  - 100 billion kip to poverty eradication through enhancement of income generating activities.
    - Of this 100 billion kip:
      - 40 billion kip earmarked for the 47 poorest districts;
      - 60 billion kip for improvement of extension services throughout the country, enhancement of production for the market, income generation and capacity building.
- Geographic and institutional flow:
  - Approximately two thirds of the PIP goes to the sectors (line ministries) and one third directly to the provinces; provincial allocations are sector-wise and concern district and provincial projects.
- District poverty-focused orientation:
  - Government progressively allocating a greater share of expected new budgetary revenues to poor districts to integrate them into the national economy while maintaining investment for growth nationwide.
  - Expectation: towards the end of 2003, 8 to 10 comprehensive district plans ready; comprehensive plans should be prepared for all 47 districts to guide resource allocation.
  - The 40 billion kip for poorest districts to be channelled through village and district funds as development funds to support household and village income generation activities.
  - Emphasis on community-driven development: government funds should not substitute for what communities can do themselves.
  - Complementary frameworks: national strategy under preparation and action plan for expansion of rural finance and micro-credit.

### Recurrent expenditure and capacity building
- An in-depth exercise carried out to estimate recurrent cost involved in projects according to established sector ratios.
  - Methodology enables systematic estimation of recurrent expenditure by type (maintenance, equipment replacement, repairs, electricity and water costs, training, etc.).
  - Workshops organised to introduce methodology to different sectors.
- Government resources based on the MTEF will not fully meet recurrent needs in the medium-term.
  - Government intends to consult development partners to identify mechanisms to enable gradual assumption of responsibility for recurrent expenditures, following precedent such as the Road Maintenance Fund.
- Government funds will be used to enhance capacity at all levels in planning, management and technical capacity-building, with particular emphasis at the district level.
  - Examples of supported activities: UXO-related activities, development of alternative production schemes in support of drug elimination, reproductive health, prevention of HIV/AIDS, micro-credit and income generating activities.

### Fiscal management reforms and priorities for FY 2003-2004
- Measures to improve institutional framework of fiscal management and to strengthen legal and regulatory framework are being implemented, including:
  - strengthening of revenue collection mechanisms through adoption of standardised registration, accounting and auditing systems;
  - continuous improvement of effectiveness of the Large Taxpayers’ Unit through enhancement of capacities at central and provincial levels;
  - strict observance of the Budget Law, the Tax Law and the Customs Law as basis for improved budget management.
- Revenue prospects:
  - Increased revenues expected from improved tax administration and investments, particularly private sector investments including FDI.
  - Projections regarding expected revenues from the mining and hydropower sector described as encouraging.
  - Increased revenues will allow progressive reduction of dependency on official development assistance (ODA).
- Fiscal stance and immediate priorities:
  - A cautious approach to revenue projections implies cautious approach to managing expenditure; public expenditures must remain within country’s financial possibilities.
  - For FY 2003-2004, top priorities:
    - substantially increase the salaries of public servants;
    - resolve outstanding debt issues;
    - further strengthen the business environment;
    - improve the public enterprise sector.
  - Revenues collected in FY2003-2004 designated to resolve debt and increase public servant salaries as priority.
  - Combination of fiscal restraint and greater revenue collection effort, with tight monetary policy, to maintain prudent macroeconomic management.
  - Planned allocation for FY 2003-2004 made at expense of productive investments: amount allocated to the PIP reduced by at least 20 per cent; FY 2003-2004 described as a year of transition to streamline operations for FY 2004-2005 and beyond.

### ODA management and coordination
- ODA critical: accounts for approximately four-fifths of total public investment.
- 2001 ODA flows:
  - New bilateral and multilateral ODA agreements: US$ 393 million (of which grants were US$ 206 million).
  - ODA disbursements: US$ 380 million.
- ODA component in PIP varies by sector:
  - approximately 90 per cent for the communication and transport sector;
  - about 60 per cent for rural development.
  - Overall ODA contribution to the PIP amounted to 66 per cent in FY 2002-2003.
- Rationale and shifts:
  - Current concentration of ODA in communications and transport justified by vital need for basic infrastructure.
  - As access improves, social sector share of investment to grow; transport/communication sector to remain high in absolute value but decline in relative share.
- Aid coordination improvements:
  - Sector-wide planning, strengthened coordination and consultation between sectors and between central, provincial and district levels to enhance aid coordination and efficiency.
  - Increased and systematic use of sector coordination fora to enhance coordination and consultation between sectors and the donor community.

*Source: 7.1 The Medium-Term Expenditure Framework FY 2003-2004 to FY 2005-2006 (from the supplied IMF content unit).*

### 7.4  Participatory Planning, Implementation and Monitoring

### 7.4  Participatory Planning, Implementation and Monitoring

### Participatory planning and the NGPES process
- The NGPES is described as an on-going, “rolling character” process with consultations continuing after adoption by the National Assembly.
- The Government-launched Roundtable process involved exhaustive consultation with various segments of the Lao multi-ethnic population and with the international donor community (including bilateral, multilateral partners in development and international NGO).
- Lao culture and tradition favor continued intense consultations after completion of a policy document to ensure adaptation and implementation in the local context.

### Implementation roles, institutions and capacity building
- All initiatives in the NGPES include participatory planning, implementation and monitoring components.
- Development planning will increasingly be based on local participation through appropriate planning manuals and participation processes.
- Capacity building is a priority, especially at the district level.
- Government will continue to redefine central-local relations (“decentralisation”) by:
  - making villages implementation units,
  - districts planning and fiscal units,
  - and provinces strategic units.
- Appropriate monitoring criteria will be elaborated for each sector to ensure measures to reduce poverty levels are implemented and progressively refined.
- Strengthening capacities at every level is required so that participation becomes meaningful and a major tool for planning, implementation and monitoring.

### Institutional responsibilities for NGPES
- Committee for Planning and Co-operation (CPC):
  - In charge of planning and investment aspects of the NGPES,
  - Will guide implementation with active involvement of all Government agencies concerned and in co-ordination with local authorities.
- National Statistical Centre:
  - Will serve as the central agency for monitoring the poverty situation;
  - Will co-ordinate regularly with all ministries, social organisations, local authorities and partners in development.
- National Steering Committee:
  - Tasked with ensuring overall co-ordination regarding NGPES implementation.
- Ministry of Foreign Affairs:
  - Tasked with resource mobilisation for the NGPES.
- Technical working committee:
  - Headed by the Director General of the Department of General Planning;
  - Includes most members of the former NPEP Committee;
  - Will work on operationalisation, costing, and monitoring of the NGPES.

### Early operational priorities
- Finalisation of an operational approach to participatory district planning and preparation of district plans to serve pro-poor and pro-growth investment in the poorest districts.
- Launching of a sector-wide approach in education and health.
- Further operationalisation and prioritisation of all sectors and sub-sectors programmes.
- Consistent implementation of the various reform programmes.

### Poverty measurement framework and methods
- Both quantitative (Chapter 1) and qualitative measures (Chapter 2) are employed to assess poverty.
- Quantitative measurement features:
  - Use of data from the 1992/93, 1997/98, and 2002/03 Lao Expenditure and Consumption Surveys (LECS I, II and III).
  - Use of an absolute definition of poverty.
  - Use of an income-based (cost of basic needs) approach.
  - Use of consumption as the measure of individual income.
  - Use of two poverty lines: (1) the food poverty line, and (2) an overall poverty line (food plus non-food necessities).
- Food poverty line:
  - Threshold is 2100 calories per day per person.
  - Those with less than this daily calorie intake are considered to be living below the food poverty line.
  - The cost of acquiring this intake, plus 20 per cent for non-food necessities (e.g., shelter, clothing), determines the overall poverty line.
- LECS III:
  - Data collection completed in February 2003; results to be available by year end (2003).
  - More comprehensive: expanded modules on health, education, the labour force, time-use for each household member above nine years, price questionnaire concerning 121 commodities in village markets.
  - Sample size is too small for in-depth analysis below the provincial level but enables urban/rural analysis.
- Qualitative methods:
  - Rapid Poverty Assessment (RPA) techniques initiated in 1997 in three provinces (Luang Namtha, Bolikhamxay and Attapeu).
  - Participatory Poverty Assessment (PPA) in 2000 nation-wide, emphasising causation and perceptions of poverty across the multi-ethnic population.

### Key quantitative findings and trends in poverty reduction
- Regional per capita real consumption (In Kip; March 97 to Feb 98=100):
  - Vientiane municipality: 1992-93 = 34,676; 1997-98 = 59,577; Growth Rate = 10.8
  - North: 1992-93 = 20,184; 1997-98 = 25,770; Growth Rate = 4.9
  - Central: 1992-93 = 25,720; 1997-98 = 32,586; Growth Rate = 4.7
  - South: 1992-93 = 23,623; 1997-98 = 29,504; Growth Rate = 4.4
  - Lao P.D.R.: 1992-93 = 24,595; 1997-98 = 32,848; Growth Rate = 5.8
- Urban vs rural per capita real consumption (In Kip; March 97 to February 98=100 (Lao urban areas)):
  - Vientiane municipality:
    - Urban areas: 1992-93 = 36,438; 1997-98 = 62,098; Growth rate = 10.7
    - Rural areas: 1992-93 = 29,378; 1997-98 = 55,304; Growth rate = 12.7
  - Northern region:
    - Urban areas: 1992-93 = 23,498; 1997-98 = 32,914; Growth rate = 6.7
    - Rural areas: 1992-93 = 19,495; 1997-98 = 24,995; Growth rate = 5.0
  - Central region:
    - Urban areas: 1992-93 = 30,111; 1997-98 = 42,477; Growth rate = 6.9
    - Rural areas: 1992-93 = 24,872; 1997-98 = 31,197; Growth rate = 4.5
  - Southern region:
    - Urban areas: 1992-93 = 30,842; 1997-98 = 39,938; Growth rate = 5.2
    - Rural areas: 1992-93 = 22,138; 1997-98 = 28,378; Growth rate = 5.0
  - Lao P.D.R.:
    - Urban areas: 1992-93 = 31,035; 1997-98 = 48,721; Growth rate = 9.0
    - Rural areas: 1992-93 = 22,609; 1997-98 = 29,668; Growth rate = 5.4
- Observations:
  - For the Lao PDR as a whole, average annual increase in real per capita consumption was 5.8 per cent between 1992/1993 and 1997/1998.
  - Real per capita consumption increased by 5.4 per cent per year in rural areas and by 9 per cent in urban areas during the same period, indicating increased disparity between urban and rural consumption.
- Poverty incidence (head count index) and regional changes:
  - Lao PDR head count: 1992-93 = 45.0; 1997-98 = 38.6; Annual rate in decrease of poverty = -3.1
  - Vientiane municipality: 1992-93 = 24.4; 1997-98 = 12.2; Annual rate in decrease of poverty = -13.9
  - Northern region: 1992-93 = 58.4; 1997-98 = 52.5; Annual rate in decrease of poverty = -2.1
  - Examples of provincial figures (1992-93, 1997-98, Annual rate in decrease of poverty):
    - Phongsaly: 68.7; 64.2; -1.3
    - Louang Namtha: 60.3; 57.5; -1.0
    - Oudomxay: 51.1; 73.2; 7.2
    - Bokeo: 63.5; 37.4; -10.6
    - Louang Prabang: 62.7; 49.4; -4.8
    - Houa Phanh: 78.4; 74.6; -1.0
    - Xaygnaboury: 30.1; 21.2; -7.0
    - Xieng Khoang: 57.3; 34.9; -9.9
    - Vientiane province: 28.1; 24.3; -2.9
    - Borikhamxay: 10.6; 25.8; 17.8
    - Khammuane: 43.7; 41.6; -1.0
    - Savannakhet: 45.7; 37.1; -4.2
    - Xaysomboom-SZ: 55.0; (1997-98 figure not provided in source text)
    - Saravanh: 36.7; 39.6; 1.5
    - Xékong: 65.9; 45.7; -7.3
    - Champasak: 43.6; 35.6; -4.1
    - Attapeu: 72.2; 45.3; -9.3
- Observations on poverty distribution:
  - The North had the highest incidence of poverty at 52.5 per cent in 1997/98; about 830,000 people in the North are below the poverty line, accounting for about 45 per cent of the total number of poor in the Lao PDR.
  - Houa Phanh province in the North was the poorest province with 74.6 per cent of people below the poverty line in 1997/1998.
  - Some provinces have a poverty head count higher than 50 per cent.
  - Savannakhet has the highest absolute number of poor (264,000).
  - Champasak province has the highest number of poor people in the South (189,000).
  - Sekong has the highest poverty incidence in the South.

### Urban poverty and vulnerable groups
- In 1997/98:
  - Urban poverty level = 27 per cent.
  - Rural poverty level = 41 per cent.
- Urban poverty decreased more than rural poverty between 1992/93 and 1997/98, but some urban areas have difficult living conditions, with poor people dependent on cash income, low education, and no permanent jobs, increasing vulnerability.
- Vulnerable groups in Vientiane Municipality (VUDAA/ADB Study, Poverty in Vientiane, 2000):
  - Physical and mentally handicapped/blind: 18.5 %
  - Drug alcohol user: 14.5 %
  - The elderly living alone: 14.0 %
  - Female headed household: 8.4 %
  - Isolate individuals: 7.2 %
  - Young children: 6.7 %
  - Youth and school drop-outs: 5.5 %
  - Unemployed: 4 %
  - (Convicted) criminals: 4 %
  - Destitute: 2.7 %
  - Others: 2.7 %
  - Beggars: 2.2 %
  - Rural migrants and illegal migrants: 1.6 %
  - Homeless/Squatters: 1.6 %
  - Street children: 1.6 %
  - Partially, temporarily employed: 1.6 %
  - Lazy people: 1.1 %

*Source: _cr04393 - 7.4  Participatory Planning, Implementation and Monitoring*

### 1.4  Socio-Economic Aspects of Poverty

### 1.4  Socio-Economic Aspects of Poverty

### Access to basic infrastructure
- Poor people have markedly lower access to infrastructure than less-poor people.
- Selected access statistics (All areas, LECS II):
  - Road in dry season: Poor 70.8, Less-poor 84.8, Total 79.4
  - Road in wet season: Poor 38.4, Less-poor 61.5, Total 52.5
  - Electricity: Poor 17.1, Less-poor 40.0, Total 31.6
  - Pipe water: Poor 38.6, Less-poor 57.1, Total 49.9
  - Public transport: Poor 38.2, Less-poor 57.1, Total 49.7
  - Primary school: Poor 86.4, Less-poor 87.6, Total 87.1
  - Complete primary school: Poor 43.0, Less-poor 55.6, Total 50.7
  - Medical practitioner: Poor 46.8, Less-poor 57.2, Total 53.2
  - Trained nurse: Poor 63.0, Less-poor 63.7, Total 63.4
  - Immunisation: Poor 87.7, Less-poor 90.2, Total 90.9
  - Birth attendant: Poor 44.6, Less-poor 50.5, Total 48.2
  - Pharmacy: Poor 23.8, Less-poor 37.5, Total 32.1
  - Community health worker: Poor 41.7, Less-poor 45.9, Total 44.3
  - Hospital/Health centre* : Poor 84.2, Less-poor 95.7, Total 91.2  (*Less than 6 hours away)
- Rural area examples (LECS II):
  - Road in dry season: Poor 67.8, Less-poor 80.7, Total 75.2
  - Road in wet season: Poor 32.2, Less-poor 51.3, Total 43.2
  - Electricity: Poor 10.1, Less-poor 25.6, Total 19.0
  - Pipe water: Poor 34.6, Less-poor 51.9, Total 44.5
  - Public transport: Poor 32.6, Less-poor 47.2, Total 41.0
- Average distances: poor are on average 13 kilometres from a road, compared to 9 kilometres for the less-poor.

### Sector perspectives on poverty — Education
- Education is strongly correlated with welfare:
  - Multivariate analysis: every extra year of education of the head of household raised welfare by two per cent.
- School-related expenses and household labor needs discourage enrollment and continued schooling among the poor.
- Policy priorities for public investment:
  - Improve access to education for all
  - Enhance quality of education
  - Strengthen management of the education sector
  - Support non-formal education and vocational training

### Sector perspectives on poverty — Health
- Health indicators (around 2000):
  - Fertility rate: 4.6
  - Population growth rate: 2.8 per cent (2000)
  - Maternal morbidity: 530 deaths per 100,000 live births
  - Infant mortality: 82 deaths per 1,000 live births
  - Life expectancy: 59 years
- Common communicable diseases: malaria, dysentery, cholera, haemorrhagic fever (dengue), intestinal parasites, tuberculosis, acute respiratory infections, measles.
- Health priorities:
  - Improve health care on an equitable and nation-wide basis
  - Provide access to clean water for all

### Sector perspectives on poverty — Agriculture
- Agricultural systems: lowland alluvial plains (Mekong corridor) vs. rolling hills and uplands with shifting cultivation.
- Lowland areas produce the bulk of the nation's food.
- Upland/subsistence farmers rely heavily on forests and face increasing poverty as population growth reduces arable land and shortens fallow periods.
- Regional patterns:
  - Greater poverty-reduction progress in Mekong corridor/lowlands than uplands.
  - Better roads and market access in lowlands facilitate diversification and commercialization.
- Policy implication: intensify investment in rural development, especially in the poorest districts; promote improved services, sustainable land use, and increased rural incomes (area-based/focal area approach).

### Sector perspectives on poverty — Infrastructure/Transport
- Strong correlation between absence of transportation and communication infrastructure and poverty, especially in remote areas.
- Many districts and most villages are not linked to main national transportation networks; economic growth is hampered and poverty persists.
- Rural road development and improvement are:
  - A poverty alleviation objective in themselves
  - A basic condition for creating an enabling environment for a market economy

### Gender dimensions of poverty
- Women and men experience poverty differently; women generally work longer hours and bear primary responsibility for food security.
- Literacy and schooling:
  - Female literacy: 59.1 per cent; Male literacy: 81.7 per cent (National Statistical Centre, Basic Statistics of the Lao PDR 2001; LECS II and LHRD 2000)
  - Average years of schooling: women 3 years (2 years in rural areas), men 4 years
  - Young rural women aged 15-19: 4 years of school; young rural men: 5 years
  - Young urban women and men: 7 years of schooling
- Barriers to girls’ schooling: household responsibilities, cost of clothing and supplies, distance to school, language barriers for ethnic minority girls, concerns about quality/relevance.
- Risks for migrant young ethnic minority women: limited Lao language skills, few opportunities, higher risk of exploitation, limited access to family planning amid high fertility.
- Recommendations to improve women's position:
  1. Reduction of women’s heavy workload through appropriate technologies and improved access to water supply
  2. Improvement of women’s and girls’ educational levels
  3. Improvement of maternal and child health, including family planning
  4. More income generation opportunities (e.g., rice mills, handicraft production) for women through skills training and micro-finance
  5. More budgetary resources for programmes addressing women’s needs
- Urgent need to address gender disparities.

### 1.5 Evaluating poverty using Vulnerability Index
- The vulnerability index uses social and economic indicators to assess key determinants of food insecurity and vulnerability at household and village levels; objective: delineate poor districts.
- Components of the district vulnerability/poor index (six indicators):
  - Income and food production indicators (four): rice production per person, large livestock per person, forested area per family, use of roads (distances up to 6 kilometres)
  - Social development indicators (two): maternal and infant mortality rates, percentage of illiteracy
- Assessment results (of 142 districts assessed):
  - 37 districts identified as very poor (satisfying less than 2 of the 6 indicators)
  - 25 districts considered poor (met only 2 of the criteria)
  - 23 districts satisfied 5 or 6 indicators
  - 58 districts (considered medium) met 3-4 criteria
  - Summary: some 40 per cent of the districts in Lao PDR are considered poor and very poor
- The vulnerability analysis complements quantitative analysis and focuses on human security concerns and locally identified threats and risks.

### 1.6 Inequality and economic growth
- Income disparities widened between 1992/93 and 1997/98 (real consumption basis).
- Key inequality statistics:
  - Gini coefficient: 1992-93 = 28.6, 1997-98 = 35.7, Growth rate 4.4
  - Quintile shares (1992-93 vs 1997-98; Growth rate column as in source):
    - First: 9.3 -> 7.8  (Growth rate -3.5)
    - Second: 13.5 -> 11.8  (Growth rate -2.7)
    - Third: 16.9 -> 15.4  (Growth rate -1.8)
    - Fourth: 21.9 -> 20.6  (Growth rate -1.2)
    - Fifth: 38.4 -> 44.4  (Growth rate 2.9)
- Interpretation:
  - Lowest income quintile share fell from 9.3 to 7.8 between 1992/93 and 1997/98.
  - Highest quintile share rose from 38.4 to 44.4 in the same period.
  - Rise in inequality indicates benefits of growth accrued more to the rich than the poor.
- Government objective: achieve high economic growth within a context of equity; NGPES outlines an operational approach toward this objective.

### Chapter 2: Qualitative Participatory Approaches to Poverty Analysis

### Participatory Poverty Assessment (PPA) — objectives and findings
- PPA questions:
  1. Who are the Poor?
  2. Where are they located?
  3. When did they become poor?
  4. What is poverty in the eyes of the poor?
  5. Why did they become poor?
  6. In the view of the poor, how may poverty be alleviated?
- Key qualitative findings:
  - The poor are primarily ethnic minority swidden cultivators.
  - Poverty occurs throughout the country but is less severe in Xayaboury, Vientiane Province and Vientiane Municipality.
  - Villagers often do not view themselves as endemically poor; poverty is seen as a livelihood issue tied to ability to meet consumption needs. Disruptions to agro-systems can trigger poverty.

### 2.1 Causes of poverty (PPA results)
- Poverty indicator by the poor: degree of rice sufficiency; indicator of wealth: livestock.
- Main problems related to rice sufficiency:
  - Reduction of land available for swidden cultivation
  - Livestock disease
  - Ill-health
  - Hiring out labour
  - Lack of necessary technical knowledge
  - Lack of access to roads
  - Lack of clothing
  - Poor housing
- Main causes of poverty (in order of importance as reported by the poor):
  1. Problems associated with land
  2. Livestock loss because of lack of veterinary services
  3. Lack of cash investment to make livelihood improvements
  4. Natural disasters
  5. Environmental problems
  6. Lack of water for agriculture
- Other cited causes: lack of local leadership; relocation; lack of health services; too many children; lack of knowledge of the market; lack of government services; low agricultural prices; addiction to opium; UXO.
- Regional variations in causes:
  - Northern and eastern regions: land allocation and soil depletion problems
  - Southern region: natural disasters
  - Central region: large family size
  - North: opium addiction cited
  - Lack of roads and pests/livestock diseases common across regions

### 2.2 Follow-up to the PPA (2002)
- Follow-up surveyed 55 representative villages in 13 provinces (original 2000 PPA sample: 84 poor villages from 18 provinces and 43 districts).
- General outcome over two years:
  - Most villages experienced improvement; some showed no improvement or became worse off.
- Factors associated with village progress:
  - Improved roads (access to paddy land and markets)
  - Donor-assisted projects: construction of schools and health clinics, provision of medicine kits
  - Improved irrigation and UXO removal
- Observed inequality within villages:
  - Income increases were often realized by only a few households, with many households remaining the same or worse off—an intra-village inequality gap emerged.
- Reasons villages remained the same or became worse off:
  - Repeated moves
  - Lack of land (especially paddy fields)
  - UXO preventing cultivation
  - Reduction of traditional fallow cycles following new land allocation regulations leading to soil depletion and lower yields
- Regional dynamics:
  - Northern Region appears more dynamic despite overall high poverty
  - Southern Region showed less change between 2000 and 2002

*Source: _cr04393 - 1.4  Socio-Economic Aspects of Poverty*

### 2.3  Public Investment Programme Poverty Impact Study

### 2.3  Public Investment Programme Poverty Impact Study

### Public Investment Programme (PIP) participatory monitoring — key findings
- Review ongoing; selected northern provinces visited: Louang Prabang, Oudomxay, Louang Namtha, and Houa Phanh.
- Reported impacts from beneficiaries:
  - Most people say they are better off because of infrastructure investments, especially roads that allow access to the sale and purchase of goods and access to health and education services. However, forest products are being depleted.
  - Agricultural production has not improved; village relocations often result in insufficient produce for sustainable livelihoods.
  - Livestock disease remains a major problem and has not been resolved.
  - Infrastructure projects tend to result in a few individuals becoming wealthy.

### Implications for PIP design and monitoring
- Need to balance infrastructure access benefits (market, health, education) with natural resource depletion concerns.
- Resettlement and relocation components require measures to secure sustainable agricultural production and livelihoods.
- Livestock health interventions are needed to address persistent disease problems.
- Project designs should include mechanisms to limit unequal wealth concentration from infrastructure investments.

### Reference
- “Summary of the Recent Research Results on Poverty Assessment” available as Working Paper No. 3 under the NSC/ADB Participatory Poverty Monitoring and Evaluation Project.

---

### Poverty Criteria and District Poverty — official criteria
- Household level:
  - Poor households: income (or equivalent in kind) of less than kip 85,000 kip (100,000 kip for urban and 82,000 kip for rural) per person per month (at 2001 prices).
  - This sum allows the purchase of about 16 kilograms of milled rice per person per month; the balance is insufficient to cover other necessities, such as clothing, shelter, schooling and medical costs.
- Village level: Villages considered as poor are:
  - Villages where at least 51% of the total households are poor.
  - Villages without schools or schools in nearby and accessible villages.
  - Villages without dispensaries, traditional medical practitioners or villages requiring over 6 hours of travel to reach a hospital.
  - Villages without safe water supply.
  - Villages without access to roads (at least trails accessible by cart during the dry season).
- District level: Poor districts are:
  - Districts where over 51% of the villages are poor.
  - Districts where over 40% of the villages do not have local or nearby schools.
  - Districts where over 40% of the villages do not have a dispensary or pharmacy.
  - Districts where over 60% of the villages without an access road.
  - Districts where over 40% of the villages do not have safe water.

### Identification results (72 poorest districts)
- Based on these criteria, 72 districts identified as poor.
- Of the 72 districts, 47 have been identified for priority intervention during 2003-5005.
- Aggregated counts for the 72 districts:
  - Number of poor villages: 4,126
  - Number of poor households: 160,592
  - In percentage terms: 76 per cent of the villages in these districts are poor and 50 per cent of the households are poor.
- Provincial highlights:
  - Houa Phanh province has the highest (absolute) number of poor villages and households.
  - Phongsaly province has the highest percentage of poor villages.

### Table 7 (selected provincial figures preserved exactly as in source)
- Vientiane Municipality: Number of Poor Villages 27; % of Poor Villages 73.0; Number of Poor Households 191; % of Poor Households 4.4
- Phongsaly: Number of Poor Villages 369; % of Poor Villages 94.4; Number of Poor Households 9,241; % of Poor Households 53.3
- Louang Namtha: Number of Poor Villages 195; % of Poor Villages 88.6; Number of Poor Households 7,918; % of Poor Households 70.0
- Oudomxay: Number of Poor Villages 500; % of Poor Villages 91.6; Number of Poor Households 18,288; % of Poor Households 60.1
- Bokeo: Number of Poor Villages 114; % of Poor Villages 64.0; Number of Poor Households 5,082; % of Poor Households 52.6
- Louang Prabang: Number of Poor Villages 246; % of Poor Villages 76.4; Number of Poor Households 12,964; % of Poor Households 72.2
- Houa Phanh: Number of Poor Villages 636; % of Poor Villages 91.1; Number of Poor Households 21,299; % of Poor Households 65.1
- Xaygnaboury: Number of Poor Villages 136; % of Poor Villages 47.4; Number of Poor Households 8,040; % of Poor Households 30.9
- Xieng Khouang: Number of Poor Villages 204; % of Poor Villages 47.6; Number of Poor Households 9,228; % of Poor Households 35.4
- Vientiane: Number of Poor Villages 129; % of Poor Villages 84.9; Number of Poor Households 4,190; % of Poor Households 33.7
- Borikhamxay: Number of Poor Villages 134; % of Poor Villages 88.2; Number of Poor Households 10,885; % of Poor Households 71.2
- Khammouane: Number of Poor Villages 310; % of Poor Villages 82.7; Number of Poor Households 7,658; % of Poor Households 36.8
- Savannakhet: Number of Poor Villages 523; % of Poor Villages 72.5; Number of Poor Households 21,086; % of Poor Households 57.5
- Saravanh: Number of Poor Villages 119; % of Poor Villages 65.7; Number of Poor Households 5,483; % of Poor Households 61.2
- Xékong: Number of Poor Villages 153; % of Poor Villages 85.5; Number of Poor Households 3,966; % of Poor Households 82.4
- Champasak: Number of Poor Villages 160; % of Poor Villages 51.1; Number of Poor Households 5,893; % of Poor Households 19.7
- Attapeu: Number of Poor Villages 99; % of Poor Villages 86.1; Number of Poor Households 6,261; % of Poor Households 69.3
- Xaysomboun: Number of Poor Villages 72; % of Poor Villages 83.7; Number of Poor Households 2,919; % of Poor Households 58.0
- Total (72 districts): Number of Poor Villages 4,126; % of Poor Villages 76.7; Number of Poor Households 160,592; % of Poor Households 50.4
- Source: National Statistical Centre, 2003

### Poverty incidence and prioritization (Table 8 highlights)
- Average poverty incidence (proportion poor households):
  - 40 districts identified as very poor: 70
  - 32 districts identified as poor: 35
  - Total 72 identified as poor districts: 55
  - 47 districts identified as priority (2003-2005): 64
  - 25 poor districts out of 72 districts identified as poor: 38
  - Total 70 districts identified as Non-Poor: 23
  - Total 142 districts: 39
- Average Population share (district population/total population):
  - 40 districts identified as very poor: 0.5
  - 32 districts identified as poor: 0.6
  - Total 72 identified as poor districts: 0.5
  - 47 districts identified as priority (2003-2005): 0.5
  - 25 poor districts out of 72 districts identified as poor: 0.5
  - Total 70 districts identified as Non-Poor: 0.9
  - Total 142 districts: 0.7
- Average poor population share (district poor / total poor population):
  - 40 districts identified as very poor: 1.1
  - 32 districts identified as poor: 0.6
  - Total 72 identified as poor districts: 0.9
  - 47 districts identified as priority (2003-2005): 2.1
  - 25 poor districts out of 72 districts identified as poor: 0.6
  - Total 70 districts identified as Non-Poor: 0.6
  - Total 142 districts: 0.7
- Percentage of district to total population:
  - 40 districts identified as very poor: 19.7
  - 32 districts identified as poor: 18.3
  - Total 72 identified as poor districts: 37.8
  - 47 districts identified as priority (2003-2005): 24.3
  - 25 poor districts out of 72 districts identified as poor: 13.5
  - Total 70 districts identified as Non-Poor: 61.4
- Percentage of poor to total poor population:
  - 40 districts identified as very poor: 43.2
  - 32 districts identified as poor: 19.0
  - Total 72 identified as poor districts: 62.2
  - 47 districts identified as priority (2003-2005): 46.9
  - 25 poor districts out of 72 districts identified as poor: 15.3
  - Total 70 districts identified as Non-Poor: 37.8
- Percentage of poor:
  - 40 districts identified as very poor: 50.6
  - 25 poor districts out of 72 districts identified as poor: 18.9

### Government priority rationale
- The 40 poorest districts have the highest incidence of poverty (70 per cent), calculated on number of poor households.
- Government priority focuses on where poverty incidence is deepest even if the 40 poorest districts represent only 20 per cent of the population.
- In the 70 “less poor” districts, poverty concerns 19 per cent of the population, while in the 72 poorest districts more than half of the population is poor.
- Overall poverty incidence is 55 per cent for the 72 poorest districts compared to 23 per cent of the “non-poor” districts.
- Overall poverty incidence remains 55 per cent when dividing the group into 47 and 25 districts, as shown in Table 9.

---

### Poverty and Social Indicators — summary of key social statistics and disparities

- Education Indicators (2000) in percentage of total population:
  - Educational attainment index: North 59; Central 75.5; South 67.5; Vientiane 90; Lao PDR 68.5
  - Adult literacy rate: North 59; Central 75.5; South 67.5; Vientiane 90; Lao PDR 68.5
  - Adult literacy rate – women: 44; 64; 51; 84; 55
  - Adult literacy rate – men: 74; 87; 84; 96; 82
  - % schools with complete primary cycle: 32; 51; 50; 76; 43
  - Primary gross enrolment rate: 68; 83; 79; 92; 77
  - Source: NHDR 2001

- Literacy rates by Ethno-linguistic Groupings (1995):
  - Lao-Tai: Male Literacy Rate 84.4%; Female Literacy Rate 62.3%; Total Literacy Rate 72.9%
  - Mon-Khmer: Male Literacy Rate 55.6%; Female Literacy Rate 19.9%; Total Literacy Rate 36.9%
  - Hmong-Mien: Male Literacy Rate 45.7%; Female Literacy Rate 8.1%; Total Literacy Rate 26.5%
  - Tibeto-Burman: Male Literacy Rate 22.3%; Female Literacy Rate 12.0%; Total Literacy Rate 17.0%
  - LAO PDR: Male Literacy Rate 73.5%; Female Literacy Rate 47.9%; Total Literacy Rate 60.2%
  - Source: NSC 1995 Census.

- Health Indicators (2000) and selected 1995/2000 comparisons:
  - Life expectance at birth: North 57.1; Central 59.6; South 57.6; Vientiane 62.8; Lao PDR 1995 51; Lao PDR 2000 58.7
  - Under-five mortality rate: North 118; Central 99; South 107; Vientiane *; Lao PDR 1995 170; Lao PDR 2000 107
  - Maternal mortality rate: North 540; Central 440; South 700; Vientiane *; Lao PDR 1995 560; Lao PDR 2000 530
  - % villages with immunisation program: North 86; Central 88; South 72; Vientiane 95; Lao PDR n.a.; Lao PDR 87
  - % pregnant women immunised against tetanus: Lao PDR n.a.; Lao PDR 24.6 (1995); Lao PDR 45 (2000)
  - % HHs with access to primary health care: North 67; Central 78; South 82; Vientiane 78; Lao PDR n.a.; Lao PDR 75
  - % villages with hospital more than 8 hrs away: North 13; Central 5; South 6; Vientiane 0; Lao PDR n.a.; Lao PDR 8
  - % medical care in HH consumption: North 2.5; Central 2; South 2.6; Vientiane 1.8; Lao PDR n.a.; Lao PDR 2.2
  - HHs with access to piped water or protected well (%): North 32; Central 64; South 48; Vientiane 89; Lao PDR 15; Lao PDR 50
  - Prevalence of malaria (per 1,000): North 49; Central 59; South 82; Vientiane 7; Lao PDR n.a.; Lao PDR 55
  - Source: NHDR 2001; NSC 2000. (* included in Central figure)

- Gender Status Indicators (2000):
  - Live births by females age 15-49 (% last year): Urban 10; Rural 18; Lao PDR 17
  - Percentage of married women using contraception: Urban 54; Rural 27.8; Lao PDR 32.2
  - Proportion of births at home %: Urban 44.3; Rural 91.3; Lao PDR 86
  - Time use in education females (under 14): Urban 4.3; Rural 2.9; Lao PDR 3.1
  - Time use in education males (under 14): Urban 6.3; Rural 3.3; Lao PDR 3.7
  - Time use in education females 15-19: Urban 3.9; Rural 1.5; Lao PDR 1.9
  - Time use in education males 15-19: Urban 5.4; Rural 1.9; Lao PDR 2.4
  - Number of years in school female: Urban 5; Rural 2; Lao PDR 3
  - Number of years in school male: Urban 6; Rural 4; Lao PDR 4
  - Number of years in school female 15-19: Urban 7; Rural 4; Lao PDR 4
  - Number of years in school male 15-19: Urban 7; Rural 5; Lao PDR 5
  - Source: NHDR 2001, Lao Reproductive Health Survey 2000, LECS II, MOE.

---

### Poverty Research and Monitoring — priorities and approaches
- Research needs:
  - On-going poverty research to incorporate geography, ethnicity and culture.
  - Research to guide redefinition of central-local relations and formulation of the Public Investment Program.
- Capacity building:
  - Capacity building at national, provincial and district levels is a major concern.
  - Increasing capacity at the district level will enable village participation in planning.
  - Central and local officials will need training to effectively address the needs of the poor.
- Methodological approach:
  - Combine participatory exercises with traditional household surveys to integrate quantitative and qualitative analyses.
  - Strengthen linkages between quantitative and qualitative analyses in monitoring NGPES implementation.
  - NSC responsible for poverty monitoring and for monitoring NGPES poverty eradication priorities.

### Poverty Monitoring of Households via Village Level Statistical Data (5.1)
- Need for reliable district and village data, given districts are planning and fiscal units and villages are implementing units.
- “Village Statistics Book” used for monitoring socio-economic profiles of villages.
- Implementation status:
  - 11 provinces have completed the first round of household poverty monitoring.
  - This will become the basis for locating household poverty nation-wide.
- Remaining tasks:
  - Procedures regarding poverty monitoring at the local level must still be strengthened.

*Source: _cr04393 - 2.3  Public Investment Programme Poverty Impact Study (National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy, excerpts).*

### 5.2 Quantitative Poverty Monitoring Using the LECS III 2002/03 Survey

### 5.2 Quantitative Poverty Monitoring Using the LECS III 2002/03 Survey

### Quantitative monitoring: LECS III 2002/03
- The LECS III 2002/03 survey has been modified and expanded to better analyse poverty.
- Improvements include:
  - rural prices;
  - questions relating to household assets and income from agriculture and business;
  - questions relating to housing, education, health, and use of time of all household members.
- Data collection has been completed; a preliminary report will be completed by the end of 2003.

### Qualitative poverty monitoring and participatory methods
- Quantitative research must be carried out in unison with qualitative research.
- Participatory monitoring and evaluation should:
  - listen to the poor express their needs;
  - gain a thorough understanding of the gender, cultural and livelihood dimensions of their circumstances.
- Monitoring of sector programmes and initiatives requires data and measurement tools to evaluate contributions to poverty reduction.
- Projects supported by donor agencies should be reviewed from this perspective.

### Linkages between national and international efforts
- The NGPES reflects Lao PDR’s ongoing commitment to sustainable growth and poverty eradication and is consistent with the MDG Declaration and the LDC Brussels Summit.
- A national steering committee and national data bank have been established to specifically monitor progress towards meeting international goals of poverty reduction, in particular the MDGs.

### Poverty vulnerability assessments and coping strategies — overview
- Government view: households must take self-help initiatives within an enabling context provided by the State.
- Participatory poverty assessments reinforced the need to improve the enabling environment at the grassroots level, including:
  - improving access to all rural and remote areas;
  - developing rural infrastructure;
  - market integration of rural areas (market linkages, trade facilitation);
  - people-centred resource management;
  - facilitating access to quality health and education services;
  - provision of credit.
- Human security surveys / vulnerability assessments were undertaken experimentally in three provinces: Savannakhet, Luang Prabang and Vientiane provinces.
- Vulnerability analysis identifies risk patterns and coping responses and assists planners and local representatives in developing appropriate responses.

### Key findings from the three-province vulnerability assessments
- Women and men expressed four areas of vulnerability: economic, environmental, social, and cultural.
- External risks are perceived as greater than internal risks.
- Where well-developed coping strategies exist, vulnerability is perceived as less worrying.
- Vulnerability classification was based on degree of ownership, access to assets and gender of household head.
- Generally most vulnerable:
  - those who experience rice shortages;
  - landless households;
  - households headed by a woman with no means of alternative livelihood;
  - those living at the very edge of subsistence in fragile environments;
  - those experiencing health and addiction problems.
- Moderately vulnerable: experience threats but have some means to cope (assets or alternative livelihood).
- Least vulnerable: face few threats and have assets to rely on when primary livelihood is compromised.
- Households in remote villages with poor road access, resettled households that lack assets, and smaller villages dependent on subsistence agriculture are highly vulnerable.
- Poverty is essentially a question of food vulnerability.

### Sources of vulnerability (gender-differentiated perceptions)
- Economic threats:
  - Both women and men: low income and shortage of capital or credit.
  - Women: shortages of rice are of greater concern.
  - Men: shortage of cultivable land is of greater concern.
  - Other economic threats: landlessness, lack of employment opportunities, debt, and too many children to support.
- Environmental threats:
  - Concerns about weather changes and natural disasters (floods and droughts) impacting crops.
  - Women: more concerned with water shortages and water quality.
  - Other threats: poor soil quality, pests and livestock disease, unexploded ordnance (UXO), deforestation.
- Social threats:
  - Women: poor health and low education and skills.
  - Men: weak village authorities also identified as a source of vulnerability.
- Cultural and social threats:
  - Drug abuse identified as a serious concern in all three provinces.
  - Women concerned with loss of tradition; both sexes identify youth problems.
  - Theft and domestic violence seen as threats in some cases.
  - Lack of income-generation opportunities drives youth migration to urban areas, leaving ageing families vulnerable.
- Seasonality and life cycle:
  - Vulnerability to health problems and livestock disease highest in the wet season.
  - Vulnerability to crop failure highest in the dry season.
  - Children vulnerable due to lack of education and skills.
  - Aged persons without family support found highly vulnerable in some villages.

### Summarised significant aspects of vulnerability assessments
- Larger villages with good access are less vulnerable.
- Resettled populations, even in larger villages, are more vulnerable.
- Many perceived threats are external and beyond villagers' control.
- Stronger households, and in particular women, have a keener perception of threats.
- Vulnerability is directly related to the range and quality of assets owned/controlled by a household.
- The link between resource mismanagement and natural disasters, and hence vulnerability, is not perceived.
- Ethnicity and vulnerability are directly related, as certain ethnic groups have a limited range of assets and mechanisms to manage them.

### Coping strategies — classification and gender differences
- CPC/UNCRD classified coping strategies into three categories:
  1. Coping strategies that decrease vulnerability in the short and long terms;
  2. Coping strategies that decrease vulnerability in the short term but increase vulnerability in the long term; and
  3. Coping strategies that increase vulnerability in the short and long terms.
- Coping strategies should be incorporated into village and district planning; priority is to encourage category 1 strategies.
- Women use a wider range of positive coping strategies than men in almost all surveyed villages.
- Common positive coping strategies by women:
  - reducing expenses;
  - raising livestock and poultry;
  - gardening.
- Common positive coping strategies by men:
  - growing alternative crops;
  - raising livestock.
- Other positive strategies: handicraft production, vending, coordinating joint activities with neighbours, accessing health care, counselling children, making alcohol, fishing, requesting authorities for help.
- Future local planning will give increased attention to these coping strategies.

### Policy implications and Government conclusions
- Primary focus of poverty reduction programmes should remain on agriculture, education and health services, and provision of infrastructure, but more effort is needed to reduce vulnerability at the local level and to enhance coping strategies.
- Four critical areas to strengthen positive coping strategies and reduce negative coping strategies:
  - Human resources development through provision of a wide range of skills related to economic activities, community organisation, and environmental protection and management.
  - Environmental management of land, water, and forest resources, studying traditional and new techniques to improve land quality, manage water during floods and droughts, and protect and replenish forest resources starting at the village level.
  - Access to credit as key to initiating alternative livelihoods to reduce vulnerability and food shortages.
  - Community mobilisation for participation in planning and implementation of projects for livelihoods, infrastructure, environmental resource management, and cultural preservation.
- District-specific peculiarities must be taken into account: geographic location, natural resources endowment, asset ownership and management patterns, cultural and lifestyle patterns.
- Vulnerability assessment techniques have been incorporated in management and training courses, enabling many local planning officials to undertake vulnerability assessments related to economic, environmental, social and cultural concerns; training programmes must be extended throughout the country.
- Food insecurity is a central source of vulnerability; the Government intends to intensify cooperation with programmes such as the World Food Programme (WFP) which promotes “food for work” (e.g., food for schools).
- Food security must be ensured while communities engage in development activities that help them achieve longer-term sustainable development.

### Strategic linkages, objectives and targets (selected development indicators and targets)
- Table 13: ELEMENTS OF THE 2020 DEVELOPMENT VISION — Indicators and targets
  - Total population (million): 5.2 (2000), 5.9 (2005), 6.6 (2010), 8.2 (2020)
  - Population growth rate (%): 2.6 (2000), 2.5 (2005), 2.3 (2010), 2.2 (2020)
  - GDP growth rate (%): 5.8 (2000), 7.0 (2005), 7.0 (2010), 7.0 (2020)
    - Agriculture (%): 4.9 (2000), 4.5 (2005), 4.2 (2010), 3.8 (2020)
    - Industry (%): 8.5 (2000), 10 (2005), 10 (2010), 8.5 (2020)
    - Service (%): 5 (2000), 10 (2005), 10 (2010), 9 (2020)
  - Life expectancy at birth (years): 59 (2000), 63 (2005), 67 (2010), 70 (2020)
  - Adult literacy over 15 years (%): 70 (2000), 78 (2005), 84 (2010), 90 (2020)
  - Total enrolment rate: 70.2 (2000), 85 (2005), 90 (2010), 95 (2020)
  - Infant mortality under 5 (per 1,000 live births): 82 (2000), 62 (2005), 40 (2010), 20 (2020)
  - Maternal mortality (per 100,000 live births): 530 (2000), 350 (2005), 250 (2010), 130 (2020)
  - Access to clean water (% of population): 52 (2000), 57 (2005), 100 (2010), 100 (2020)

*Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES), _cr04393 - 5.2 Quantitative Poverty Monitoring Using the LECS III 2002/03 Survey*

### Chapter 1: Macroeconomic Stability as a Fundamental Requirement for

### Chapter 1: Macroeconomic Stability as a Fundamental Requirement for Growth and Poverty Eradication

### Overview of macroeconomic performance (past decade)
- Annual average rate of growth of GDP of 6.3 per cent during the past 10 years (1992-2002).
- Sectoral shares and changes:
  - Industry: about 24 per cent of GDP in 2003, up from 16.7 per cent in 1992.
  - Service: share edged up to around 26 per cent.
  - Agriculture: share fell from 58 per cent to 50 per cent.
- Foreign direct investment (FDI) disbursements were US $128 million in 1997; disbursements dropped to much lower levels after the Asian crisis.
- GDP per capita outcome:
  - Instead of increasing over the 1996 level, GDP per capita fell by almost one-fifth to US $331.
- Inflation and exchange-rate developments:
  - Inflation rose to 134 per cent in 1999.
  - Inflation reduced to 30 per cent in 2000 and to single digit levels in 2001 and 2002.
  - Exchange rate of the kip: from 900 kip to the US dollar just before the crisis to about 10,500 kip to the dollar currently.
- Internal imbalances that affected stability: high fiscal, trade and current account deficits; budget financing through the banking sector was stopped (policy action in October 1999).

### Reform frameworks and programs supporting stability
- Macroeconomic Policy and Reform Framework released in 2000, integral to the NGPES.
- Three main reform programmes included:
  - Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF – IMF).
  - Financial Management Adjustment Credit (FMAC – WB) and associated Financial Management Capacity Building Credit (CB-FMAC).
  - Banking Sector Reform Programme (BSRP – ADB).
- PRGF components:
  - Encouraging credit restraint, fiscal prudence, and a flexible exchange rate regime.
  - Improvement of the treasury system, enhanced fiscal reporting and accountability, and tax measures to increase revenues.
  - Trade and private sector measures.
- FMAC focus areas:
  - Public sector reform (budget accounting and control, natural resource management).
  - Reform of state-owned enterprises (strengthening oversight capacity, enterprise restructuring, rate charges).
  - Financial sector reform (banking, micro-finance).
  - CB-FMAC: capacity building to implement these reforms.
- BSRP focus areas:
  - Restructuring of SOCBs, strengthening legal framework and the commercial court, capacity building and policy development.
- A recent Public Expenditure Review has contributed further to the reform process.
- Overall assessment: All these reform programmes are well underway and are yielding good results; through time they will contribute strongly to economic growth and poverty reduction.

### Macroeconomic policy measures and poverty reduction
- Government-defined detailed macroeconomic policy measures cover:
  - i) fiscal policy,
  - ii) monetary and exchange rate policy,
  - iii) investment promotion policy.
- Fiscal policy priorities and measures:
  - Improvement of debt management, both internal and external.
  - Strengthening of the revenue system and modernization of the tax system.
  - Tightening of expenditure management with a longer-term view to gradually balance current and capital expenditures.
  - Substantially increase wages and salaries and strengthen social security.
  - Public investment must be more effective and resources safeguarded for the social sectors, particularly for the poorest districts.
  - Strengthen management and co-ordination of ODA to maximise effectiveness.
  - Sufficient budgetary resources must be mobilised to coherently implement the NGPES.
  - Encourage all economic sectors, including the private sector and FDI, to expand the taxable resource base.
- Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF):
  - A strict MTEF will preside over revenue and expenditure management and define the country’s financial possibilities.
  - Part V provides a detailed analysis of the MTEF of FY2003-2004 to FY 2005-2006.
- Strengthening the national revenue base through:
  - Continuous improvement of revenue collection and modernisation of the tax system.
  - Enhancement of private sector development, including FDI.
  - Increased revenue flow to the Treasury from valuing the national resource base (such as mining, hydropower, plantation industry).
- Addressing structural weaknesses in the fiscal system:
  - Lack of ability and competence, inexperience, insufficient mastering of fiscal decentralisation, and suboptimal monitoring at the provincial level.
  - Measures: improve institutional framework for fiscal management, strengthen legal and regulatory framework, enhance capacity at all levels, expand use of management technology, clarify institutional responsibilities and job descriptions.

### Monetary, exchange rate, and financial sector priorities
- Price stability and financial sector reform are high priorities:
  - Monetary policy will focus on restraining inflation.
  - Bank of the Lao PDR (BOL) will refrain from deficit financing and excessive expansion of the money supply.
  - The exchange rate will continue to be managed on a floating basis while ensuring that the spread with the parallel market rate remains small.
- Banking system reform measures:
  - Establishing and enforcing prudential lending practices; stopping credit to bad borrowers.
  - Credit to be extended on a commercial basis to institute and maintain market discipline.
  - Extend financial services throughout rural areas and to the private sector.
  - Strengthen governance of SOCBs and corporate management to improve banking practices.
  - La Banque pour le Commerce Extérieur Lao and the newly merged Lao Development Bank: improved management to allow rationalisation in branch and head office operations.
  - Governance agreements with BOL, Ministry of Finance and SOCB boards/management to define principles, responsibilities, and provision for independent audits.
  - Defaults in loan repayment will be pursued vigorously with new prudential regulations and supervision and a revamped legal/judicial system for commercial cases.
  - High levels of non-performing loans, especially of SOEs, must be redressed.
  - Limitations on asset growth will apply to SOCBs with high ratios of non-performing loans.
  - Phased recapitalisation will ensure greater soundness.
  - Increased competition among banks, including private banks, will lead to a commercially-based banking system.
- Legal and judicial reforms for commercial cases:
  - Improve documentation requirements for loan applications and understanding of contract provisions.
  - Introduce a commercial division in the court system to expedite rulings on creditor/debtor disputes.
  - These reforms will provide leverage to force compliance with contract provisions and support credit discipline.

### Investment promotion, private sector development, and growth targets
- National growth target:
  - Targeted economic growth rate of 7 per cent per annum over the next decade to achieve the 2020 goal of exiting least developed country status.
- Investment and savings requirements:
  - Necessary investment level estimated at 26-28 per cent of GDP.
  - Of this investment, some 10-11 per cent of GDP will be by the public sector.
  - The remaining 16-17 per cent of GDP will be by the private sector, including FDI.
  - Large-scale projects (e.g., Nam Theun 2 hydropower project and mining projects) will contribute to achieving this investment level.
- Role of sectors:
  - All sectors must perform strongly to increase domestic savings and finance investment.
  - Private sector growth is essential to bring new technologies, know-how, and competitive products.
  - Development of natural resource-based industries will create jobs and income opportunities, including in poor and remote areas.

### Macroeconomic stability and financial flows to the private sector
- Macroeconomic stability is fundamental to creating a positive environment for private sector enterprise:
  - Fiscal, monetary, and exchange rate policies must be in harmony, including credit limits consistent with price stability.
  - An efficient and effective public sector is essential for business enterprise.
- Banking and financial sector reforms are vital to encourage the private sector:
  - Resource mobilisation and financial intermediation are market means for guiding and supporting the private sector.
  - A sound financial system, based on strong corporate management, will encourage small and medium-sized enterprises.
  - The private sector will increasingly link growth and poverty reduction and help narrow the rural-urban gap.
- Private sector consultation:
  - Identification of support dimensions has been assisted by close consultation with the private sector, including foreign investors.

### Specific measures to accelerate private sector development
- Four major areas identified by private sector consultations (First Foreign Investment Forum, May 2002):
  - Information and consultation.
  - Legal, regulatory and administrative streamlining.
  - Macroeconomic management.
  - Co-ordination and management capacity.
- Information and consultation measures:
  - Accelerate publication of English versions of all laws and regulations regarding investment.
  - Publish a newsmagazine on investment activities.
  - Regular publication of important economic documents such as the national budget.
  - Regularised direct consultation with the Department for the Promotion and Management of Domestic and Foreign Investment, the Lao Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LCCI) and the GMS Business Forum Secretariat.
  - Strengthen the National Steering Committee for the Production of Commercial Goods as a high-level body for coordinating economic policies and private sector development.
- Legal, regulatory and administrative streamlining measures:
  - Reform licence renewals, ceilings on tax-deductible investment expenditures, approval system for imports and exports, and business registration and licensing.
  - Establish a central register of all legal document instruments related to private sector development.
- Macroeconomic and financial measures to support private sector:
  - Restructuring of the financial sector and improved credit risk management.
  - Study and implement enforcement of the Secured Transaction Law and amendments to the Decree on Commercial Banks to permit establishment of foreign bank branches outside Vientiane.
- Co-ordination and management capacity improvements:
  - Enforcement of laws concerning bankruptcy, secured lending, dispute resolution and debt recovery.
  - Enforcement of the new Tax Law to contribute to transparency, fairness, and facilitate collection at the local level.
  - Phase-out of the lump sum tax method for small businesses.
  - Training of tax officials to improve overall administration.
  - Strict penalties for businesses and individuals that do not comply with the Tax Law.
- Privatization and private sector involvement:
  - The Government has increasingly involved the private sector in areas previously public responsibilities or state enterprise; this trend will continue as highlighted in sector action plans.

### Consolidating public sector governance
- Governance objectives tied to macroeconomic stability and equitable growth:
  - Efficiency, transparency and accountability in public sector management are important for stability and equitable growth.
- Government policy on governance:
  - The Government’s policy document on governance issues provides a comprehensive approach for improving public sector management and has been fully integrated into the NGPES.
  - Sound governance is essential to achieving a stable and open society with rights guaranteed by efficient administration of the law.
- Four priority areas for consolidation of public sector management:
  - i) public service improvement,
  - ii) central-local relations,
  - iii) legal framework,
  - iv) socio-economic management.

*Source: Chapter 1, _cr04393 - Chapter 1: Macroeconomic Stability as a Fundamental Requirement for (NGPES).*

### 3.1 Public Service Improvement

### 3.1 Public Service Improvement

### Objectives and rationale
- Improved public service requires increasing the knowledge, ability and qualifications of civil servants in accordance with short and long-term needs.
- Public service improvement also requires preventing negative social phenomena to ensure a peaceful society and a stable political situation.
- Priority is meeting the needs of the multi-ethnic Lao people in the most effective and efficient manner possible.
- Improved governance reduces waste of scarce public resources and unnecessary procedures and costly expenses that disproportionately burden the poor.

### Governance and institutional arrangements
- The Government has established a Committee for Governance and Public Administration Reform under the direct supervision of the Prime Minister.
- The Government has no plans to fundamentally change the structure of the Government organisation but strives to ensure lines of authority and division of responsibility best meet the needs of the country.
- To ensure ministries are correctly fulfilling their functions and to support the Decree on Anti-Corruption (Decree No.193/PM, 2/11/1999), the Government has established Departments of Inspection in each ministry.
- Increased transparency and streamlined government decision-making are identified as necessary elements for improving public sector functioning.

### Civil service pay, motivation and personnel management
- Since the Asian financial crisis in 1997/98, budgetary constraints, internal macroeconomic instability and high rates of domestic inflation resulted in serious erosion of civil service salaries, undermining motivation and causing absenteeism and in some cases the levying of unofficial fees or other charges.
- The Government has been reviewing the pay and compensation system; salary levels have been increased (significantly in 2000) to the extent possible within existing budget constraints.
- The Government is gradually introducing a merit-based appointment and promotion system to ensure a more highly qualified civil service at all levels.

### Stated priorities
- Development of a lean, responsive and cost-effective public administration.
- Modernisation of civil service personnel management, including job descriptions and merit-based recruitment and promotion, and the use of PMIS.
- Development of a productive and highly motivated and customer-oriented civil service.
- Development of an honest and ethical civil service.
- Training and development to enhance professionalism in the civil service.
- ICT to facilitate, streamline and create communication networks across the Government.

*Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES), excerpt*

### PART IV: National Sector Plans to Promote

### PART IV: National Sector Plans to Promote Sustainable Growth and Poverty Eradication

### Overview and policy context
- The NGPES incorporates and elaborates the Government’s “growth with equity” framework, highlighting:
  - Main sectors: agriculture/forestry, education, health, and transport (esp. road infrastructure).
  - Supporting sectors: trade, tourism, manufacturing and energy.
  - Cross-sector priorities: environment, gender, population and capacity building.
  - National poverty-related priority programmes such as drug control, UXO decontamination and HIV/AIDS.
- By careful investment, sound macroeconomic management and improved governance, the Government expects:
  - Food security, which is perceived as an essential accomplishment for poverty reduction.
  - Human resource development, enabling diversification and modernisation of the economy.
  - National integration, reducing regional and rural/urban income gaps.
  - Social progress, leading to quality education and healthcare for all, improved status of children, women and ethnic minorities.
- Targeted geographic focus: the 47 poorest districts and a further 25 less-poor districts have been identified through a consultation process and PM Instruction 010 to concentrate interventions and access improvements.

### Chapter 1: Poverty-Focused Agriculture/Forestry — goals
- Top priority: modernise agriculture and forestry to meet sustainable practices, achieve food security and better livelihoods.
- Sector goals to 2020 (designed to contribute to poverty alleviation):
  - Ensure food security for all Lao people.
  - Maintain a growth rate in agricultural output of 4-5 per cent annually.
  - Promote commodity production, especially for export.
  - Stabilise shifting cultivation and eradicate poppy cultivation.
  - Diversify and modernise the agricultural and forestry sector.
  - Conserve the natural environment and protect threatened species and habitats.
  - Maintain a healthy and productive forest cover as an integral part of the rural livelihood system, and generate a sustainable stream of forest products.
  - Improve rural livelihoods.

### Situation analysis — key statistics and characteristics
- The agriculture and forestry sector:
  - Provides the economic, social and cultural base for more than 80 per cent of the population.
  - Accounts for more than 50 per cent of GDP.
- Household dependence:
  - An estimated 620,000 households depend on agriculture, of which some 490,000 rely on subsistence farming.
- Dominant farming systems:
  - Dry-land rice cultivation (shifting cultivation in northern and eastern mountain regions).
  - Paddy rice cultivation along the Mekong River.
  - Horticulture crops in the highland areas of the south.
- Crop importance and livelihood sources:
  - Rice is the single most important crop, accounting for 40 per cent of agricultural output.
  - Rural households also obtain basic food needs from livestock, fishery and gathering non-timber forest products (NTFP).
- Recent output trends:
  - Agricultural output has risen steadily over the past decade, by 4-5 per cent annually on average.
  - Rice output has increased following irrigation investments and other initiatives since the mid 1990s.
  - Livestock production has increased by 50 per cent.
  - Fishery has increased by 160 per cent.
- Constraints and vulnerabilities:
  - Stable food supply remains uncertain because of inappropriate farming and domestic marketing systems.
  - Crop sub-sector characterised by low use of improved varieties, fertilisers or pesticides; limited irrigation and double cropping; inadequate agricultural support (extension) due to budget and technical limitations; crop yields per hectare below regional averages; weak harvest and post-harvest technologies.
  - Poor market access reflecting lack of all-weather roads linking rural areas to domestic and international markets; distribution networks largely undeveloped.
  - Lowlands are more mechanised, use more inputs, and are more market-oriented than uplands.
  - Reassessment of the land-forest allocation programme is needed, particularly for upland areas where shifting cultivation is widespread; shortened fallow periods and population pressures have resulted in declining yields and hardship in some upland areas.
  - Preliminary results from the most recent survey (2000-2002) suggest that forest cover has further diminished from the level in 1992.

### Strategic responses — overall approach
- Strategy combines building on recent successes while introducing new thrusts to speed modernisation and strengthening of the sector.
- Differentiated responses for lowlands and uplands: market-based approaches in lowlands; more proactive government support in uplands due to lack of infrastructure, widespread poverty and limited local capacity.
- Area-focused development approach: high priority on sustainable land use, agro-ecological classification, and integrating forest conservation with agricultural development to protect river basins and watersheds and maintain bio-diversity.

### Table 14 (Alternative Agricultural Development Strategies) — major interventions (preserved by theme)
- Lowlands / Mekong Corridor:
  - Improve and diversify farming systems with increased and intensified cash crop, livestock and fisheries production.
  - Plan land-use zoning based on bio-physical (slope and land capability) and socio-economic parameters.
  - Expand and intensify value added processing by promoting local and foreign investment.
  - Accelerate participatory land allocation and land use occupancy entitlement.
  - Develop market research and information systems and regional market links between producers and wholesale and retail buyers throughout the region.
  - Develop internationally accepted product grades and standards.
  - Promote community management of natural resources.
  - Strengthen demand driven extension programs.
  - Rehabilitate, expand and intensify irrigation schemes with community based management.
  - Strengthen and expand rural credit facilities through free competition and market determined interest rates.
  - Strengthen rural and agribusiness lending by SOCBs and private commercial banks.
  - Strengthen the capacity and legal framework of SOCBs in commercial banking transactions.
  - Open community market access by upgrading and expanding feeder roads and market information.
- Sloping / Uplands:
  - Diversify farming systems and agro-forestry development through adaptive research, trials and demonstrations on farmers’ fields.
  - Promote community management of natural resources.
  - Sustainable land use management with soil erosion control, afforestation, plantation forestry and conservation management.
  - Strengthen demand driven extension programs.
  - Expand and intensify small-scale community managed irrigation schemes.
  - Develop and expand rural savings and credit systems; target credit to support technology adoption by the poor.

### Government’s seven key themes guiding sector strategy
1. Participatory Planning — ensure sensitivity to local needs; prepare district plans for lowland areas and integrated watershed plans for upland areas; village and district level action as main catalyst for growth.
2. Lowland Transformation — leverage lowland strengths (market access, modern farming techniques) to expand exports (Commodity Production Programme).
3. Sustainable Development of Sloping Lands and Environmental Management — protect National Bio-Conservation Areas (NBCAs), regulate NTFP harvesting, and apply multi-sector, community-based land allocation and management.
4. Stabilisation of Shifting Cultivation — aim to stabilise shifting cultivation by 2005 through on-farm and off-farm activities and district extension workers promoting alternative livelihoods.
5. Expansion of Irrigation — manage projects more effectively and expand the area under irrigation.
6. Human Resource Development — upgrade MAF staff, especially at district level, to improve participatory planning, extension techniques and market understanding.
7. An Enabling Environment for Business Development — central to promoting economic growth with equity.

### Area-focused development — principles and implementation challenges
- Area-focused development aims to provide alternatives to remote communities (livestock-based farming, NTFP-based upland farming systems, viable land allocation systems) so people can improve livelihoods locally without moving.
- The approach addresses population mobility dynamics by preparing focal areas for village movements and providing necessary services (roads, electricity, schools, medical facilities, water, sanitation).
- Emphasis on participatory and consultative preparation of village movements to reduce hardship and improve outcomes; community participation is central to success.
- Implementation constraints: limited public financial and human resources; requires close coordination across sectors to focus resource allocation within coherent district development plans.

*Source: PART IV: National Sector Plans to Promote Sustainable Growth and Poverty Eradication (NGPES).*

### Chapter  8  of  Part  IV  of  the  NGPES  elaborates  on  the  area-focused  rural  development

### Chapter 8 — Area-focused rural development and district planning (excerpt)

### 1.4 Poverty-Focused Agriculture/Forestry Development Priorities
- National and local policies must address countrywide factors (e.g., trade regime, national transportation network, framework infrastructure) to modernise and commercialise the agricultural sector and reduce poverty.
- Government reassesses policies and programmes affecting agriculture and forestry to serve the sector effectively while favouring the interests of both the poorest and less poor people.
- Land–Forest Allocation Programme is being reassessed through an established policy dialogue process.
- Priority geographic focus:
  - First concern: improving conditions and opportunities in the 47 poorest districts.
  - Second priority: the other 25 districts identified as poor.
  - Remaining pockets of poverty will be addressed once these districts’ circumstances improve.
- Agriculture-related aspects of poverty to be addressed following principles of sustainable resource utilisation and land-use planning.

Food security and Food self-sufficiency
- Through the Food Production Programme, the Government is committed to meeting its obligation made at the 1996 World Food Summit (FAO, Rome): to reduce the number of undernourished people by 50 per cent of the 1996 level by no later than 2015.
- From villagers’ perspective, fundamental causes of poverty are those that affect rice yields and numbers of livestock.

Poverty-focused agricultural development measures (special emphasis on poor households)
- Participatory surveys in districts and villages, to clarify local needs and adjust extension services in response to socio-economic/agro-ecological conditions.
- Distribution of improved paddy seed to increase yields.
- Training district level extension agents/farmers on improved cultivation techniques.
- More effective use of existing irrigation systems.
- Strengthening the animal health control system through distribution of vaccines and training farmers in their use.
- Strengthening livestock and fisheries extension systems.
- Strengthening information networks on productivity, disease, and markets.

Reduction in vulnerability (measures)
- Controlling unsustainable harvesting and export of NTFPs.
- Improving agricultural practices and land management to ensure sustainable use, together with disease and pest control.
- Rehabilitating and improving the operation and maintenance of irrigation schemes, and development of groundwater resources.
- Construction of flood protection structures in flood prone areas.
- Improvement of access roads and access to credit.
- Improvement of information on local and regional market conditions.

Increasing the value of outputs — Commodity Production Programme measures
- Market incentives for farmers, including private sector contract farming.
- Establishment of a grading and classification system to improve product quality.
- Participatory land use planning and resource management.
- New crops based on agro-zoning and market-based private sector investment.
- Application of area-based applied technology.
- Strengthening of the participatory agricultural extension system; also private sector extension services, farmer vocational training and model family farms.
- Livestock health and fisheries promotion programs.
- Development and distribution of area-based applied technology.

Strengthening rural communities (measures to increase earnings from value-added processing)
- Programmes for strengthening community-based institutions, rural finance and credit programmes, market data collection and dissemination, and the organisation of farmer groups.
- Support for access to and availability of market and price information.
- Strengthening land use rights and villagers’ ownership of land use rights through review of procedures for land allocation to farmers and land titling.
- Formation and training of farmer organisations, including water users/irrigation associations, and joint liability credit and contract farming producer groups.
- Construction of district feeder roads and improvement of market access roads.
- Rural finance mobilisation tailored to meet farmer needs (i.e., credit for improved seeds, fertilisers, agricultural chemicals, draught animals, etc.), based on market determined interest rates and open competition.
- Training for villagers in organisation and management of contract farming and village savings and credit groups; also, support for Village Development Funds.
- Facilitating agro-processing at the household, community, and rural levels.

### 1.5 Agriculture Policy Priorities

Overview
- Main elements: market orientation, participation, human resource development, decentralisation, diversification, technology transfer, sustainability, and integrated watershed management.
- Forestry is addressed in a subsequent section.

Market Orientation — principal elements
- Removal of distortions for agribusiness development in the functioning of factor markets, such as subsidised credit and fertiliser, and clarification of laws and regulations (e.g., licensing) to reduce impediments and transaction difficulties experienced by the private sector.
- Increased credit availability through a strengthened Agriculture Promotion Bank and other financial institutions; structured loans to meet farmers’ needs and facilitate micro-finance.
- Facilitation of land occupancy entitlement, land tenure, titling and village management.
- Training of MAF staff at all levels in principles of market-based agricultural system.
- Strengthening the ability of communities to compete in local and regional markets, including through establishment of a market information system.
- Establishment of a grading and certification system for commercial crops and NTFP.
- Support for establishment of agro-processing by private sector and farmers’ groups.
- Trade facilitation and regional economic integration; expand the Common Effective Preferential Tariff Inclusion List.
- Formalising cross-border trade flows.

Participation and Human Resource Development — main elements
- Fully decentralised “bottom-up” participatory planning.
- Strengthen capacity of communities to participate in development planning and to take responsibility for natural resources management.
- Extend and improve the quality of the school system, as an investment in upgrading the skills of farmers and their ability to participate effectively in community interests.
- Extend and improve the informal education system, to improve literacy in rural areas, especially in the poorest districts.
- Introduce farmer vocational training and on-the-job training, particularly in the poorest districts.
- Support women’s groups to participate in the review of training and extension services.
- Train provincial and district agricultural personnel in planning, monitoring and evaluation, project formulation and implementation.
- Review of the Land-Forest Allocation Programme to make it more participatory and community-led, including:
  - Technical assistance to improve the land allocation process.
  - Develop capacity at provincial and district levels to better address land allocation.
  - Undertake periodic reviews of allocation procedures concerning NBCAs.
- Promote community-based irrigation plans and farmer organisations.

Decentralisation — MAF role and responsibilities
- Redefine central-local government relations: “the provinces as the strategic units, the districts as the planning and fiscal units, and the villages as the implementation units”.
- MAF will:
  - Develop procedures and capabilities for participatory land-use planning within area-based programmes and projects.
  - Strengthen the overall capacity of PAFOs and DAFOs, especially the latter.
  - Transform MAF to become a farmer-service organisation, capable of responding quickly to farmers’ needs in a market-based economy.
  - Continue to expand upon decentralisation of development planning, research and extension functions; also, community-managed irrigation systems.
- Integrated management of watersheds and transformation of lowlands — responsibilities:
  - Provincial level:
    - Ranking of watersheds.
    - Strategic development options.
    - Priorities for sub-watersheds.
  - District level:
    - Watershed zoning.
    - Specific development interventions.
    - Identification of buffer zones and conservation areas.
  - The village level is the implementing unit.

Diversification — government actions
- Strengthen multi-sector approach to reduce shifting agriculture.
- Indicative planning based on comparative advantage and rural socio-economic indicators.
- Assist shifting cultivation farmers to become successful sedentary farmers.
- Assist poppy growers to develop alternative livelihoods.
- Strengthen and extend irrigation systems, for both sloping and lowland areas.
- Design and implement pilot groundwater irrigation schemes.
- Promote seed multiplication services.
- Strengthen the animal health control system and livestock extension system.
- Introduce a meat inspection system.
- Provide technical assistance to private sector for animal improvement and breeding.
- Establish participatory extension systems to promote inland fisheries.
- Promote private sector participation in plantation forestry and agroforestry.
- Promote cultivation of NTFPs.

Technology Transfer — planned actions
- Develop an integrated extension system to transfer agricultural production technologies to the poor people and upgrade the capacity of NAFES in extension, particularly for uplands areas.
- Ensure that research (NAFRI) and extension services (NAFES) are demand-driven.
- Extension programme for adaptive research and demonstrations on farmers’ fields.
- Introduce basic post-harvest handling and processing methods to farm families and communities.
- Develop area-based applied technology and agro-zoning.
- Develop suitable technologies for overall improvement in livestock production.
- Develop applicable technology for inland fisheries, including pond management and feeding. Also, develop improved varieties of inland fish.

Sustainability — measures to balance growth and conservation
- Raise awareness of government officials and farmers regarding need for sustainable practices.
- Strengthen the capacity of provincial and district offices to undertake natural resource planning and management.
- Education and training in modern agricultural technology, and in local farming techniques and knowledge.
- Promote farming systems best suited to soil and hydrologic structures, to prevent degradation and minimise siltation and runoff.
- Prevent encroachment, illegal activities and bio-diversity degradation in NBCAs by law enforcement, capacity building and village participation in conservation.
- Control unsustainable harvesting and exporting of NTFPs.
- Map flood risk areas and strengthen and extend flood control structures.
- Identify and conserve local aquatic resources.
- Sustainable forestry management is addressed separately.

Integrated Watershed Management — commitments and actions
- Decentralise responsibilities as indicated earlier.
- Implement integrated area-based natural resources management centred on watersheds.
- Pilot projects (three conducted so far) in integrated watershed management.
- Develop integrated watershed management models, adapted to different geographical locations and reflecting different socio-economic and biophysical conditions.
- Develop IWM plans for 8 northern provinces (location of the priority watersheds).

### 1.6 Sustainable Forestry Management
- Government commitment: reversing deforestation and achieving 60 per cent forest coverage by 2020.
- Forests are an important source of food, medicine, energy, and income for the people, particularly for the poor and ethnic minorities in remote mountainous areas.
- Forests contribute 7-10 per cent of the GDP, and 15-20 per cent of the non-agricultural GDP.
- The forestry industry accounts for about one-third of total exports; forest royalties account for about 11 per cent of total government revenues.
- Employment in the wood processing industry makes up one-quarter of all manufacturing jobs.
- Forests conserve bio-diversity and protect soils, watersheds, and water resources.
- Historical and strategic context:
  - 1st National Conference on Forests in 1989 called for a comprehensive forestry legal system, ecosystem/wildlife conservation, and strengthened forest institutions and human resource development.
  - The 7th Party Congress in 2001 set development targets for 2005, 2010, and 2020, subsequently endorsed by the National Assembly: 60 per cent forest cover by 2020; stabilise shifting cultivation by 2005 and phase it out completely by 2010; rehabilitate and reforest approximately 1.5 million hectares via tree plantations for commodity production; accelerate classification and delineation of forests for protection, conservation and production purposes.
- Actions taken:
  - National Conservation forests established, covering more than 12 per cent of the total land area.
  - Strengthened legal framework: Forestry Law, related laws, implementing regulations, Prime Minister Orders and Decrees controlling harvesting and sales of forest products.
  - Annual harvest of logs reduced from a peak of 734,000 m3 in 1999 to some 260,000 m3 in both 2000/01 and 2001/02.
  - Noteworthy reduction in area under shifting cultivation over the past ten years.
  - Establishment of the National Agriculture and Forestry Research Institute and the National Agriculture and Forestry Extension Service to provide co-ordinated and field-oriented research and extension services, contributing to alternatives to shifting cultivation.
  - Over the past five years some 113,000 ha have been planted with trees.
  - It is estimated that approximately 75,000 hectares have survived, constituting the current national stock of standing tree plantations. Individual farmers or entrepreneurs account for almost 50 per cent of the planted area, with plantations averaging 20-30 ha.
  - Over the five years to 2000, land and forest allocation was carried out in more than 5,300 villages; this included allocation of degraded land for farming and tree plantations, and the allocation of forests for protection or other uses.
- Remaining challenges:
  - Forest cover is clearly much less than it was in the mid-1960s (about 70 per cent) and it appears to be somewhat less than in 1992 (47 per cent).
  - In many areas, forest degradation is as serious as deforestation.
  - Management needs strengthening to address lack of an integrated land and forest management system, insufficient law enforcement, weak institutional capacity and the lack of funds and resources.
- Strategy development:
  - Government will take strong measures to revitalise forests and ensure the forestry industry operates within allowable harvest limits.
  - A strategy paper has been drafted under the leadership of MAF, supported by SIDA and JICA, and is being considered by the cross ministerial steering committee assigned to guide the strategy’s development.
  - The strategy incorporates lessons learned from production, conservation, reforestation, and forestry plantation projects. The Government recognises the need for extensive consultation with community groups and all other stakeholders.

*Source: Chapter 8 of Part IV, NGPES (excerpt) — _cr04393_ (PDF chapter/section)*

### 2000. The Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry has been assigned as the lead agency and a cross ministerial steering

### _cr04393 - 2000. The Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry has been assigned as the lead agency and a cross ministerial steering

### Forestry: lessons, objectives, and measures
- Lessons learnt include the success of participatory forest management.
- Ongoing and proposed programmes:
  - A Sustainable Forestry and Rural Development programme to develop models for participatory management of production forests and community forestry, and reform timber royalties and prices.
  - A Tree Plantation for Livelihood Improvement project being formulated at the Department of Forestry.
- Programme aims:
  - Develop alternative sources of income for rural households and contribute to the reduction of poverty.
- Government measures to alleviate poverty and ensure more sustainable management of Lao forests:
  - Enhance village-based natural resource management for poverty alleviation.
  - Revise the system for harvest determination, from focus on capacity of the wood industry to focus on sustainable supply.
  - Restructure the wood industry in Lao PDR to bring processing capacity into closer accord with a sustainable raw material supply.
  - Control unsustainable harvest and export of NTFPs by unregulated traders and promote sustainable participatory management and processing of NTFPs.
  - Promote tree planting; formulate mechanisms (through collaboration among MAF/DOF, NAFRI, and STEA) for certifying sustainably managed tree plantations.
  - Prevent encroachment, illegal activities and bio-diversity degradation by effective law enforcement, capacity building, and the participation of villagers in conservation activities.
  - Formulate a national land use policy and introduce land use planning at both the macro and field levels.

### Improved forest management and utilisation program: implementation measures
- Define forest management units and prepare management plans.
- Strengthen the legal and regulatory framework.
- Increase reliance on market approaches and mechanisms.
- Restructure state-owned enterprises.
- Complete the decentralisation process and capacity building at local level, facilitating community-based forestry management.
- Effective mobilisation of resources and international co-operation.
- Strategic vision: preserve significant areas of natural forests to conserve biological diversity and protect regional environmental assets.
- Area-based and decentralised development approach centred on integrated watershed/river basin management.
- Establishment of agro-ecological zones nation-wide to delineate land for lowland/flatland and sloping land agriculture, bio-diversity conservation, and watershed and sloping land suitability classification.
- Land and Forest Allocation Programme is being modified to be more community-led.
- Support for increased private sector participation in plantation forestry and agroforestry to relieve pressure on natural forests.
- Expected environmental outcomes: expansion of forest cover, reduction of soil erosion, and other biophysical indicators.

### Priority Programmes for Agriculture and Forestry (master plan to year 2020)
- MAF identified numerous projects to enhance agricultural productivity, upgrade product quality, and reduce vulnerability of poor communities.
- The first group of eleven high priority projects includes activities related to fisheries, livestock, non-timber forest products (NTFP), seed multiplication, horticulture, and rural finance.
- Rationale: implementable almost immediately, significant impact on value added, generate increased income and create employment opportunities for poor households in rural areas.
- The projects with the highest priority are listed (Table 15):
  1. LF-10 Aquaculture Improvement and Extension Project
  2. LF-11 Fish Seed Centre Rehabilitation / Expansion Project
  3. LF-2 Animal Health and Quarantine Improvement
  4. RF-11 Expansion of Micro-Finance Activities
  5. LF-12 Rural Aquaculture Development Project
  6. SC-4 Research on Sustainable Management/Utilisation of NTFPs
  7. AC-5 Outer City Horticulture Promotion Program
  8. AC-1 Rice Seed Multiplication Improvement Project
  9. MR-8 Processing and Marketing of NTFPs
  10. AC-21 Basic Seed Production Technology Improvement Project
  11. LF-6 National Animal Health Centre Improvement

### Short- and medium-term factors to be addressed through high priority projects
- Aquaculture projects:
  - Insufficient investment in freshwater fisheries activities.
  - Lack of knowledge and technical capacity to practice alternative livelihoods.
  - Lack of knowledge of integrated fish-paddy farming system.
  - Low protein intake of rural people due to dependency on diminishing wildlife.
- Livestock projects:
  - High mortality rates of livestock from ordinary and epidemic diseases.
  - Limited knowledge among farmers of livestock diseases.
  - Low level of investment compared to the importance of the subsector.
  - Limited coverage and low quality of animal health activities.
  - Low protein intake of the general population.
- Non-timber forest products projects:
  - Income from NTFPs is largely derived from unprocessed primary products, due to lack of knowledge of processing possibilities.
  - Lack of awareness of the need for harvesting of NTFPs on a sustainable basis.
- Seed projects:
  - Lack of private sector investment in seed technology.
  - Absence of private sector traders in seed varieties suitable to local conditions.
  - Small local market for hybrid seed varieties.
  - High cost, low quality, and poor suitability of imported seeds.
  - Lack of local sources of improved varieties of basic seeds.
  - Lack of research and extension services re improved varieties of rice.
- Micro-finance projects:
  - Only a small percentage of the rural population has access to credit.
  - Credit for irrigation, rural access roads, crop storage, processing facilities etc. is limited.
  - Guidelines and procedures for borrowing are not readily available.
  - Financial institutions are inexperienced in managing micro-finance programmes.
  - Borrowers (farmers and SME investors) have little experience in financial management.
- Outer City Horticulture Programme:
  - Tracts of land nearby towns suitable for horticulture remain under-utilised.
  - Migrants from rural areas to towns are unable to access these tracts.
  - Urban employment often does not meet the needs of poor households in suburban areas.
  - Migrants lack access to credit for investment in peri-urban agricultural activities.
  - Suburban horticultural crop producers lack knowledge of urban marketing techniques.

### Second level priority projects (Table 16)
- Priority Reference to Master Plan / Name of Project / Programme:
  1. SC-3 On-farm Agroforestry Adaptive Research for Sustainable Upland Farming Systems
  2. AC-4 Crop Diversification Programme
  3. AC-10 Sericulture Development Project
  4. AC-16 Fruit Cultivation Technology Research Programme
  5. AC-15 Vegetable Cultivation Technology Research Programme
- Emphasis: research, extension, and crop diversification to facilitate increased diversification of the agriculture sector and offer livelihood alternatives (such as sericulture) for rural poor people.

### Overall coherence, institutional development, and capacity building
- The poverty-focused agricultural/forestry development plan applies seven thematic approaches and area-specific development reflecting local socio-economic and agro-ecological conditions.
- Objectives:
  - Ensure food security while diversifying agriculture, reducing poverty through income generation and employment.
  - Strengthen capacity of farmers, provincial and district agriculture officers, and agricultural researchers and technicians to modernise the agriculture sector and compete in a market-oriented economy.
- Promotion of agro-industrial development, including SMEs, concentrated in lowland/flatland and selected borderland areas.
- Key enabling measures:
  - Establishment of a positive business environment while promoting ecologically sound development.
  - Strengthen the financial system (notably the Agriculture Promotion Bank) and streamline lending procedures.
  - Establish a mobile credit network to circulate among rural villages to bring banking services to farmers.
  - View credit access as critical to facilitating growth of small-scale enterprises leading to value-added agricultural products.
- Cross-sector coherence: linkages with transportation, education, energy, and trade sectors to reduce impediments to agricultural/forestry growth and competitiveness.
- Human resource development priorities:
  - Strengthen capacity of staff to serve and support the agricultural/forestry sector and build skills of farmers and participants to compete in open market conditions.
  - Aim to have farming system generalists at the grassroots level capable of providing adaptive research-based extension services to farmers.
  - Reassess education and training systems, research and extension services to ensure human resource development is “fast-tracked”.
  - Initial training focus: training of trainers and a core research staff in areas such as seed multiplication and fish breeding, followed by further training of research technicians and district extension agents.
  - Establish vocational training schools.
- Gender priorities referenced in Part IV, Chapter 6.
- Annex 3 (Table 3.1) provides a detailed policy/programme development matrix for the agriculture/forestry sector.

### Education: goals, principles, and targets
- Education is a major determinant in meeting the goals of poverty eradication; aims include literacy and knowledge of modern agricultural methods and other skills.
- Government principles: increased equitable access, improved quality and relevance, and strengthened management to achieve “education for all”.
- Decentralisation to enable greater efficiency and effectiveness in providing education services.
- Government commitment to gradually increase the share of education in the national budget and encourage stakeholder participation.
- Goals for education and training (selected):
  - Universalisation of quality basic education at the primary level and continued expansion at lower secondary level.
  - Eradication of illiteracy.
  - Expansion of vocational, technical and higher education.
  - Training of skilled workers, technicians, professionals, and intellectuals.
  - Gradual improvement of the quality of national education to international standards.
  - Establish education as core of human resource development and as a right and responsibility of all people.
- Specific targets for education and training to the year 2020 (Table 17: Selected Education Targets)
  - Columns: Country / Districts (table header includes "Whole 47" as presented in source)
  - Target data rows (as presented):
    - Pre-school (per cent): 2005: 10; 2006: 11; 2006 (Districts): 12; 2010: 16; 2015: 22; 2020: 30
    - Primary (per cent): 2005: 86; 2006: 87; 2006 (Districts): 70; 2010: 90; 2015: 95; 2020: 98
    - Lower Secondary (per cent): 2005: 52; 2006: 53; 2006 (Districts): 42; 2010: 63; 2015: 74; 2020: 85
    - Upper Secondary (per cent): 2005: 26; 2006: 27; 2006 (Districts): 20; 2010: 28; 2015: 31; 2020: 34
    - Higher Education (per 100,000 pop.): 2005: 480; 2006: 500; 2006 (Districts): 90; 2010: 520; 2015: 650; 2020: 850
    - Literacy percentage (age 15-40 years): 2005: 87; 2006: 87; 2006 (Districts): 75; 2010: 90; 2015: 93; 2020: 95
    - Literacy percentage (age 15+): 2005: 78; 2006: 78; 2006 (Districts): 65; 2010: 83; 2015: 87; 2020: 90
- Additional education targets:
  - Reduce repetition and drop-out rates by 2-3 per cent per annum.
  - Upgrade untrained teachers to achieve basic qualifications.
  - Improve management of the education sector.

*Source: Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES), excerpts from the provided content unit.*

### 2.2 Current Education Status

### _cr04393 - 2.2 Current Education Status

### Achievements over the past decade
- Net enrolment rate (NER) for primary school rose from 58 per cent to nearly 80 per cent during the 1990s.  
- Net intake rate (NIR) has been steadily rising.  
- Proportion of formally qualified teachers has risen considerably.  
- Repetition and dropout rates have fallen significantly, contributing to greater internal efficiency of the school system.  
- Increasing percentages of children are completing all five grades.  
- LECS 3 2002/03 household survey is expected to show further improvements in enrolment rates and qualifications of teachers.  
- Development assistance since the early 1990s has provided extensive support, especially for school construction.  
- In 2001/02 about 1.2 million children and young people were enrolled in the education system.  
- In 2002, the number of high school graduates reached 29,000 (1975: 440).

### Key weaknesses and deficiencies (most serious problems to be redressed)
- 15 per cent of villages in the Lao PDR are without a primary school, and most villages lack a complete primary school (i.e., all five grades); the situation in the Northern Region is of particular concern; nation-wide, 90 per cent of schools in the poorest districts are incomplete, and more than 40 per cent of students attend an incomplete school; urban areas have much better school facilities than rural areas.  
- Based on national school census data over the past five years, differences in access between the poorest districts and the less-poor districts are lessening, but differences in quality appear to be widening; the proportion of trained teachers is rising steadily in the less-poor districts, but it is falling in the poorest districts.  
- Shortages of qualified teachers are acute in many districts; approximately 20 per cent of primary school teachers are unqualified to teach.  
- Textbook shortages: one textbook per 2.3 pupils in the 47 poorest districts, compared to one textbook per 1.5 pupils in the less-poor districts.  
- Net enrolment rates vary widely, from almost 100 per cent in Vientiane to little more than 50 per cent in some northern and southern provinces; primary school age children are twice as likely to be out of school in the poorest districts as in the less-poor districts.  
- Gender disparities: girl/boy share of primary school students is 45 per cent versus 55 per cent for the country as a whole; gender disparities are significant in some areas, notably the Northern Region; gender differences have not diminished in the 47 poorest districts.  
- Language barrier: ethnic minorities have much lower net enrolment rates and much higher dropout and repetition rates due to language.  
- Late school entry is common; some 60 per cent of six-year olds in the 47 poorest districts are not enrolled in school.  
- Low completion and progression: only about 50 per cent of children complete primary school, about 20 per cent enrol in secondary education, and about five per cent complete the full six years; vocational training opportunities are limited; less that 2 per cent of Lao children go to university.  
- Lack of perceived relevance of formal education among many poor families discourages attendance, particularly among some ethnic groups living in upland areas.  
- Overall adult literacy is about 70 per cent; some 70 per cent of the labour force have either no education or never completed primary school.

### System overview and key statistics
- Total enrolled in education system in 2001/02: about 1.2 million children and young people.  
- Share of total population enrolled in school system in 2001/02: some 23 per cent.  
- Share of under 19 age group enrolled in school: some 50 per cent of school age children and young persons.  
- High school graduates in 2002: 29,000 (1975: 440).  
- Adult literacy: about 70 per cent.  
- Labour force with either no education or never completed primary school: some 70 per cent.

### Poverty-focused education priorities and financing targets (section 2.3)
- Government commitment to increase resources for the education system to help eradicate poverty.  
- Current imbalance between recurrent and capital expenditures is about 55:45; Government target is a ratio of 70:30 by 2008.  
- Government commitment to raise the share of the consolidated (central plus provincial) budget for the education sector from 10.1 per cent (planned) for 2001/02 to 15 per cent by 2005/06.  
- Somewhat less than 50 per cent of total public recurrent expenditure on education is allocated to primary education; Government target of 50 per cent by 2004.  
- Education budget shares: 16 per cent allocated to lower secondary education, 8 per cent to upper secondary education, and 7 per cent to higher education. (Of the balance, 4 per cent is for pre-school, 3 per cent is for teacher training, and 11 per cent for MOE administration.)  
- Government’s education development plan will focus on the 47 poorest districts with targets: 70 per cent enrolment rate for primary education, 42 per cent enrolment rate for lower secondary, 20 per cent enrolment rate for upper secondary, and literacy rate raised to 65 per cent.

### Strategic framework for development of the education sector (section 2.4)
- Three major pillars:
  - (a) Increasing equitable access;
  - (b) Improving quality and relevance;
  - (c) Strengthening education management and improving efficiency.

- Increasing equitable access to education
  - Main constraints: poverty; location (remote areas); population density (urban vs rural); gender; language.  
  - Government target: universal quality primary education by 2015, with equitable access and completion as medium-term objectives.  
  - Large investments required: extensive construction of new classrooms, training of new teachers, production of new instructional materials, plus addressing geographic and gender disparities, delays in school entry, incomplete schools, internal efficiency, and quality and relevance for remote, poor, and ethnic minority communities.  
  - Multi-grade teaching introduced at provincial level where student numbers are low.  
  - Candidates for new primary teachers should normally be at least lower secondary school graduates and preferably upper secondary school graduates; they will attend teacher-training colleges (TTCs). Teachers of these future teachers should normally be at least TTC graduates and (for upper secondary school teachers and TTC teachers) university graduates.  
  - Expansion must be balanced across levels; resource requirements must include costs to Government and costs to families and communities.

- Improving the quality and relevance of education
  - Education must produce literate and numerate workforce with increasing demand for commercial, technical, and professional skills.  
  - Perceptions of relevance by parents and communities are crucial to participation; Compulsory Education Decree of 1996 mandates participation but non-enrolment, late starting and high dropout rates persist.  
  - Curriculum and syllabi content must reflect priority outcomes and be meaningful to communities; teachers and instructional materials must deliver content in a manner and language students can efficiently assimilate.  
  - Primary curriculum allows “about 20 per cent of local curriculum can be added”; this option is seldom applied and Government will encourage district and village authorities to exercise it.  
  - Measures to strengthen teaching/learning process: (a) steer teachers to teach in remote areas; (b) provide teacher training to persons from remote and ethnic minority communities who will return and teach; (c) improve efficiency and effectiveness of teaching/learning in ethnic minority communities.  
  - Salary incentives for teaching in remote and mountainous areas: supplement ranges from 15 – 25 per cent of gross salary and is not subject to taxation.  
  - Salary supplement for multigrade teaching ranges from 25 – 50 per cent of the base salary.  
  - In combination, these two supplements provide a typical primary school teacher with an incentive increment in take-home pay of approximately 70 per cent. Graduates from teacher colleges receive an additional bonus of 10 per cent.  
  - Government policy to increase the number of qualified ethnic minority teachers, supported by development co-operation projects. Over the past three years, the proportion of ethnic minority primary school teachers has risen gradually, at approximately the same rate as the proportion of ethnic minority students.  
  - Language of instruction is a critical issue; Government has approved an Ethnic Group Development Plan and will support language policy and practice concerning teaching non-Lao speaking primary grade students.

- Strengthening education management
  - Decentralised management: MOE delegates and shares responsibilities with Provincial Education Services (PES) and District Education Bureaus (DEB) under decrees initiating decentralisation (MOE Decree No. 1500/DOP.02, March 3, 2002; Prime Minister Decree No. 01/PO, March 11, 2000).  
  - Decentralised management covers planning management; budget formulation and financial management; personnel management; management of property, equipment, and materials; and academic and technical management.  
  - Goal: make the education system, especially primary and lower secondary levels and non-formal education, more responsive to community needs and improve relevance to the poor; increase “poverty-awareness” among education officials, including cultural sensitivity to ethnic minorities.  
  - Management and organisational development: strengthen administrative and management capacity at all levels (central, provincial, district, community, institutional), including information-based planning, finance and procurement management, personnel management, management of property and equipment, and academic and technical management.  
  - Information-based policy development: create a Policy Analysis Division within MOE responsible for policy support, management of the policy analysis program, and staff development in policy analysis; finance policy studies including education sector financing and language policy/practice for non-Lao speaking primary students.  
  - Strengthen capacity to use tools: education management information system (EMIS), geographic information system (GIS) and information and communication technology (ITC) within the local area network (LAN).  
  - Reform of the inspection system: develop and conduct annual training courses for school staff to strengthen academic and management performance.

*Source: _cr04393 - 2.2 Current Education Status*

### 2.5  Poverty-focused Application of the Strategic Framework

### _cr04393 - 2.5  Poverty-focused Application of the Strategic Framework

### Poverty-focused Education: district-targeted actions
- Government will undertake additional steps for the 47 districts identified as requiring priority attention over the next two years.
- Measures summarized in Tables 19-21 (district-focused education priorities) address three pillars: Improving Equitable Access; Improving Quality and Relevance of Education; Strengthening Education Management.

Improving Equitable Access (Table 19)
- Long term objective: Achieve Education for All by 2015.
- Short term objective 1: Significantly increase access to complete primary schooling, especially in 47 poorest districts. Promote multi-grade teaching. Encourage enrolment at correct age, and of girls and ethnic minorities. Provide special training for teachers in remote and ethnic minority areas.
- Short term objective 2: Reduce illiteracy, especially among adult women, and promote skills training. Use formal and informal methods, and improve Community Learning Centres.
- Long term objective (economic): Facilitate economic growth, reduce regional differences and eradicate poverty.
- Short term objective 1 (completion): Increase primary completion rate, especially in the 47 poorest districts. Improve internal efficiency by reducing repetition and dropout rates; establish remedial classes in selected schools.
- Short term objective 2: Reduce differences in major indicators between 47 poorest districts and national averages.
- Short term objective 3: Expand post-primary schooling. Develop primary and lower secondary cluster schools. Establish vocational schools in poor regions and provinces. Encourage private provision of education.

Improving Quality and Relevance of Education (Table 20)
- Long term objective 1: Reach international standards in quality of education at all levels of education.
- Short term objective 1: Ensure qualified teachers are assigned to schools in poor districts and villages. Introduce bilingual teaching processes, especially for the first grades of primary schooling. Also, training in multi-grade teaching.
- Short term objective 2: Improve school conditions and access to instructional materials. Renovate schools and ensure availability of textbooks. Ensure content of instruction meets the needs of the poor. Focus on curriculum aspects in which the poor have most difficulty and on which they would benefit differentially. Provide more localised support instruction material. Strengthen linkages between education and labour market demand.
- Short term objective 3: Improve regulations and raise level of inspections. Improve staffing for schools by developing a new establishment formula for schools to provide additional teachers in small and incomplete schools. Reform the inspection system to provide more systematic support for schools.
- Short term objective 4: Improve and strengthen pedagogical support systems for primary and secondary. Provide pedagogical assistants and in-service training for teachers. Reform the teacher education system. Develop teaching/learning aids for Lao language teaching to ethnic minority children and distribute Lao language teacher guides.

Strengthening Education Management (Table 21)
- Long term Objective 1: Sustain institutional development towards pro-poor policy development and sector decentralised management.
- Short term objective 1: Improve central and regional management and administration of education sector. Strengthen planning capacity (e.g., EMIS) across all levels of education delivery.
- Short term objective 2: Appoint well trained administrators and school directors for the management of schools and institutions. Provide management and administrative training courses.
- Short term objective 3: Improve deployment of teachers. Improve selection of candidates for teacher training and the allocation of both permanent and contract teachers. Review current quota systems for allocation of teachers to provinces, districts and schools.
- Short term objective 4: Promote community participation in schools. Promote establishment of pupil-parent associations at all levels of education.
- Long term Objective 2: Allocate sufficient resources to enable the education sector to achieve its long term objectives.
- Short term objective 1: Improve resource use in education sector. Better balance recurrent/capital expenditures and plan donor projects on a sector-wide basis. Training in information-based policy analysis. Implement decentralisation of education. Provide capacity building.
- Short term objective 2: Improve the flow of funds to schools and institutions. Improve financial management of PES and DEB offices. Establish an education development fund.

### Emerging and cross-sector issues involving education
- HIV/AIDS: MOE will develop instructional and reading materials on life skills for preventing spread of the disease.
- Drugs and Drug Control: In collaboration with MOH and other ministries, MOE will develop awareness programmes to help eradicate drug use among school students.
- Information and Communications Technology (ICT): Government will encourage investment in computer technology and facilitate use of the internet, particularly in remote and poor areas. Education and training in ICT will be promoted.
- Distance Education: Government planning to create a distance education centre at the National University of the Lao PDR.
- Unexploded Ordinances (UXO) Decontamination: UXO awareness mainstreamed into standard teaching schedules.
- School Feeding Programme: MOE promotes primary school participation of poor and vulnerable children, especially girls, in food-insecure areas through a school feeding programme. (Supported by the United Nations World Food Programme.)
- Population: MOE strengthening research and instructional capacity to support Government policy of balancing population growth and socio-economic development.
- Health Education: MOE aims to integrate health education and promotion into the primary and secondary curriculum, and to expand school sanitation.
- Gender Equity: MOE mainstreams gender equity into virtually all its activities; it also has a number of specific “pro-girls” activities.
- Children with Special Needs: MOE focuses on inclusive education.

### Roles, responsibilities and partnerships in education sector development
- MOE responsible for formal and non-formal education at all levels; responsibility shared with Provincial Education Services (PES) and District Education Services (DEB). Provincial authorities responsible for secondary and vocational education; district authorities responsible for pre-school, primary and informal education. MOE responsible for higher education, technical schools and teacher training colleges.
- Communities often support primary education through construction and maintenance of facilities, employment of teachers, and payment of teacher salaries or other assistance (land, housing).
- Private sector increasing: numerous private schools at pre-school, primary, secondary levels; private vocational schools for language, computer skills, business administration and management; private colleges in urban areas. Government welcomes private participation to enhance opportunity and free public funds for poor/remote areas.
- International assistance: In 2001/02, $38 million was disbursed to the education sector by multilateral, bilateral and NGO organisations. This represented slightly more than 10 per cent of total international assistance to the Lao PDR.
  - 20 per cent of assistance from international NGOs was directed to the education sector.
  - Bilateral and multilateral agencies directed 12 and 8 per cent, respectively, of their assistance to the education sector.
  - Collectively, international assistance financed more than 70 per cent of capital expenditures (mainly schools) for education.
- Government has welcomed establishment of the MOE-Partner Co-ordination Forum to strengthen partnership with international community and to ensure balanced development of the education sector.
- A five-year policy/programme development matrix for the education sector is attached in Annex 3 (Table 3.2).

### Poverty-focused Health Development: goals and MDG-related targets
- Health sector overarching goals:
  - A nation-wide health service that is fair and equal according to gender, age, social rank, tradition, religion, ethnicity, and geographic location.
  - Basic health services that respond to people’ needs and expectations and that gain people’s trust.
  - Substantial improvement in people’s health status, especially of the poor.
- Priorities: “access with quality” while emphasising preventive health care. Primary health care will be the focus.
- Health-related MDG targets and current status highlights (Table 22):
  - Goal 1 (hunger): Target to reduce malnutrition in children under 3 years from 40% (2001) to 30% (2005).
  - Goal 4 (child mortality): U5MR was 170 in 1995 and 106 in 2000; target of 80 for 2005 and 50 by 2010. IMR was 104 in 1995 and 82 in 2000; target of 60 by 2005 and 40 by 2010.
  - Goal 5 (maternal health): MMR was 656 in 1995 and 530 in 2000; target is 350 by 2005 and 200 by 2010.
  - Goal 6 (HIV/AIDS, malaria, other diseases):
    - National policy to have 90% of pop. aware of HIV prevention methods by 2005; condom use to reach 80 % among high-risk groups.
    - National policy to reduce morbidity and mortality rates to 13/1000 and 3.4/1000, respectively, by 2005 — representing sharp decreases from levels in 2000 (53/1000 and 6.7/1000 for morbidity and mortality, respectively).
    - TB morbidity and mortality rates to be reduced by 30% by 2005. DOTS to achieve 85% cure rate.
  - Goal 7 (environmental sustainability): National policy to increase access to clean water from 52% (2000) to 57% (2005), and to achieve 80% coverage by 2010. Access to sanitation to increase to 45% by 2005, and to 55% by 2010.

### Current health status, progress and challenges
- Life expectancy at birth increased from less than 50 years before the 1990s to about 59 years currently.
- Progress in improving the health system and indicators:
  - The number of health facilities has increased by 75 per cent compared to five years ago.
  - The Lao PDR has been declared free of poliomyelitis since 2000.
  - Neonatal tetanus, measles, pertussis, and diphtheria have substantially decreased.
  - Mortality from malaria has been reduced by 60 per cent in rural areas (compared to 1996).
  - Leprosy decreased from 1.5/10,000 in 1995 to 0.6/10000 currently.
  - Access to clean water in rural areas increased from 31.8 per cent in 1995 to 56 per cent currently.
  - Access to latrines increased from 29.6 per cent in 1995 to 36.3 per cent currently.
  - Maternal, infant and under five infant mortality rates:
    - 1995 / 2000
      - MMR: 656 / 530
      - IMR: 104 / 82
      - U5MR: 170 / 106
- Challenges ahead:
  - Health status compares poorly by regional standards; serious disparities in indicators and access/quality of services.
  - Infant and under five mortality rates are twice as high in rural areas compared to urban areas; maternal mortality rates are more than three times higher; disparities more marked in remote mountainous areas and among ethnic minorities.
  - Limited access: almost 30 per cent of the population in the north (the poorest region) live 16 km from a health centre; language barriers impede use of services.
  - Severe poverty, malnutrition, illiteracy, superstition, non-hygienic lifestyles and opium growing reduce utilization of public health services.
  - Low quality of services and limited health personnel, especially doctors concentrated in urban areas; shortage of female health workers discourages women from using health centres.
  - Availability of four essential drugs (chloroquine, paracetamol, antibiotics and ORS) is much less in rural areas; only 40 per cent of villages have ready access to these drugs; drug revolving funds are poorly managed.
  - Only a third of the population makes use of public health services; households meet more than 50 per cent of their health costs through out-of-pocket expenses — mainly for drugs; Government financing accounts for only 10 per cent of total health expenditure.
  - Heavy reliance on private health care drives the poor deeper into poverty.

*Source: _cr04393 - 2.5  Poverty-focused Application of the Strategic Framework*

### 3.3 Poverty-focused Health Priorities

### 3.3 Poverty-focused Health Priorities

### Overview and financing
- Per capita expenditure on health care is about US$12; most health expenditure in the Lao PDR is privately financed.  
- In 2001/02, the health sector was allocated 5.5 per cent of the national budget; this was equal to 1.3 per cent of GDP.  
- Official development assistance accounted for 35 per cent of total health expenditure in 1999/00.  

### Priority geographic focus and targets for 2005 (47 poorest districts)
- Coverage and service access targets:
  - 80-85 per cent of the population will have access to PHC.
  - 60-65 per cent have access to clean water.
  - 45 per cent have access to sanitation.
  - Availability of essential drugs at reasonable prices and of safe quality.
- Mortality targets:
  - Infant mortality will fall to 60/1000 live birth.
  - Under-five mortality rate to 80/1000 live births.
  - Maternal mortality rate to 350/100,000 live births.

### Targets for 2010 (all 72 poor districts) and national mortality expectations
- Coverage and service access targets:
  - 100 per cent of the population in all the 72 poor districts will have access to PHC.
  - 75 per cent will have access to clean water and 55 per cent to sanitation.
- National mortality expectations by 2010:
  - IMR will have dropped to 40/1000 LB.
  - U5MR to 50/1000LB.
  - MMR to 200/100,000.

### Strategic responses — summary of 12 major strategic programmes
- Strategic Programme 1: Information, Education, and Communication (IEC).
- Strategic Programme 2: Expansion of the Rural Health Service Network.
- Strategic Programme 3: Upgrading the Capacity of Health Workers (with emphasis on ethnic minority health workers, and gender and locational balance).
- Strategic Programme 4: Maternal and Child Health Promotion.
- Strategic Programme 5: Immunisation.
- Strategic Programme 6: Water Supply and Environmental Health.
- Strategic Programme 7: Communicable Disease Control.
- Strategic Programme 8: HIV/AIDS/STD Control.
- Strategic Programme 9: Village Drug Revolving Funds Development.
- Strategic Programme 10: Food and Drug Safety.
- Strategic Programme 11: Promotion of Traditional/Modern Medicine Co-operation.
- Strategic Programme 12: Strengthen Sustainability of Health Sector.

### Health Information, Education and Communication (IEC) — objectives and activities
- Objective: Communicate policy directives on health to the Lao multiethnic population, particularly in remote, hard to reach areas; emphasise hygiene and the ‘3 cleans’ principle: boiled water drinking, cooked food, and hands washing before eating and after using latrine.
- Coverage target: By 2005, the IEC campaign will reach out to at least 85 per cent of total villages.
- Planned activities:
  - Re-organise and improve IEC activities at all levels, focusing on high-risk areas.
  - Initiate health broadcasts for local radio stations in Lao and ethnic languages in selected provinces (Oudomxay, Xiengkhouang, Borikhamxay, Khammouane, Xekong, Attapeu).
  - Initiate health programmes and material for TV channels and newspapers; also, initiate videos and other material for public distribution.
  - Co-ordinate with the Ministry of Education to integrate health education and health promotion into the primary and secondary school curriculum.
  - Expand the primary school sanitation programme.
  - Mobilise the LWU, Youth Union, Trade Union, National Front, and Buddhist monks to conduct the IEC campaign with the people.

### Expansion of the Rural Health Service Network — problems and targets
- Key constraints identified:
  - PHC services lacking in many rural and remote areas; where present, quality is often low.
  - Shortage of qualified health workers at district and health centre levels; language barriers between providers and patients.
  - Unclear job descriptions and functions for prevention and health promotion centres and hospitals; low staff morale.
  - Lack of or substandard medical equipment; many different brands complicating maintenance.
  - Low utilisation of health centres reflecting low quality of service.
- Coverage and infrastructure targets:
  - By 2005, the PHC network will be extended to reach more than 80 per cent of villages.
  - Eighty per cent of remote villages should have health providers, drug kits and a village health committee.
  - Add another 100 health centres by 2005 and another 213 by 2010, for a total of 913.
  - Upgrade the quality and skills of the three regional hospitals to serve as 2nd and 3rd level referral hospitals.
  - Upgrade 13 provincial hospitals to become 2nd level referral hospitals with emergency surgery and essential obstetric care capacity.
  - Improve district hospitals to become 1st level referral hospitals, with details on type A and B district hospitals in the background document.
- Measures to reach targets:
  - Formulate initiatives drawing on lessons learned from current and previous programmes.
  - Strengthen district health systems through incentives for health staff to occupy posts in remote areas, with emphasis on attracting female and ethnic minority health workers.
  - Establish village health committees (VHC) in each village with strong female representation reflecting ethnic composition.
  - Provide essential equipment and staff to district hospitals and health centres.
  - Promote the role of women in PHC expansion via mobilising LWU for reproductive health and related projects; increase female membership in Village Health Committees and train them for community health promotion; involve both males and females in decision making; ensure active participation of women in health sector organisational structures at all levels.

### Upgrading the Capacity of Health Workers — priorities and actions
- Rationale:
  - Need for doctors able to provide comprehensive services (emergency surgery, emergency obstetrics, public health programme management) in rural and remote areas.
  - MOH envisages a two-year internship in primary health care after completion of medical school.
  - Insufficient skilled staff, frequent absence, lack of medicine and distance discourage use of public services; recruits from poor districts and ethnic minorities are underrepresented.
- Immediate priority: increase number of health personnel at village and district levels, with emphasis on the poorest 47 districts; improve morale and capacity in parallel with provision of essential drugs and medical equipment.
- Specific priorities:
  - Expansion of the number of nursing schools (Oudomxay and Xiengkhouang).
  - Rehabilitation of several nursing schools.
  - Establishment of primary health care training centres in the Northern Region (Luangnamtha, Xayaboury, Phongsaly, Houaphanh and Bokeo) with efforts to attract trainees from ethnic minority groups.
  - Village health providers (VHV/TBA): 50 per cent of trainees (especially Village Health Providers) should be women.
  - Organise health management training courses for district health officials.
  - Provide refresher courses for postgraduate specialists and doctors.
  - Distribute widely to medical staff at all levels manuals on National Treatment Standards, and information regarding health laws, guidelines, rules and regulations.

### Promotion of Maternal and Child Health (MCH) — context, constraints, and targets
- Progress and context:
  - Fertility rate has dropped from 6-7 in the early 1990s to 4.9 currently.
  - About a third of families now use modern family planning methods.
  - Lao PDR declared polio free since 2000.
- Reasons MMR, IMR, and U5MR remain high:
  - Only 35 per cent of pregnant women attend any antenatal care.
  - Delivery at health facilities and with assistance by medical staff or by a trained TBA represent only 16-18 per cent of deliveries.
  - Fertility rate still high, especially for ethnic minorities in remote areas.
  - Women marry at an early age with a median age of first marriage of 18.7 years.
  - Less than 25 per cent of children under five are regularly given health and nutrition check-ups.
  - 40 per cent of children have severe to moderate malnutrition or stunting.
  - Coverage for children under 1 year old and for pregnant women has not yet reached the control level of 80 per cent.
  - Exclusive breast-feeding up to the age of 4 months is low; many infants fed with rice or other food at less than 4 months.
  - Use of ORS to treat diarrhoeal diseases of children is low (24 per cent).
  - Use of reproductive health services is limited by lack of access, qualified female personnel, and language and cultural barriers.
- Targets to achieve by 2005 for MCH:
  - Reduce the IMR from 82/1,000 LB (2000) to 58/1,000 LB.
  - Reduce the U5MR from 106/1,000 LB (2000) to 80/1,000 LB.
  - Reduce the MMR from 530/100,000 LB to 355/100,000 LB.
  - Increase the use of modern family planning technique to 45 per cent.
  - Increase the quality of life of mothers and children gradually by promoting health and providing a quality health service.
- More specific service targets and measures:
  - Raise use of ANC services to 50 per cent.
  - Increase delivery with medical staff to 30 per cent.
  - Raise routine immunisation coverage to 80 per cent.
  - Measures to be undertaken:
    - Improve quality of MCH services by upgrading skills/capability of health staff.
    - Strengthen the MCH network by organising mobile teams to assist high-risk mothers and children and improve the referral system.
    - Increase awareness and understanding of MCH and safe motherhood.
    - Control ARI diseases and diarrhoea among children under 5.
    - Promote breast-feeding, supplementation of vitamin A and iron, iodised salt use.
    - Promote better nutrition.
    - Monitor, supervise and evaluate MCH activities.

### Immunisation (EPI) — status, constraints, and 2003–2005 target
- Current status:
  - Routine immunisation now covers about 60 per cent of the target population, below the control level of 80 per cent.
- Constraints to full vaccination among remote poor populations:
  - Lack of vaccinators and lack of transport for outreach.
  - Insufficient funds.
  - Poor communications, including language barriers.
  - Beliefs and superstitions of people, particularly some ethnic groups.
  - Dependence on external funding has led to planning and implementation constraints.
  - Immunisation has remained separate from other health services, missing opportunities for mutual enhancement.
- Target:
  - From 2003 to 2005, special efforts will be made by the Government to achieve 85 per cent vaccination coverage of mothers and children in rural areas.
- Priorities include supplemental immunisation activities and organisation of a national immunisation day for measles vaccine.

*Source: _cr04393 - 3.3 Poverty-focused Health Priorities*

### introduction of the hepatitis B vaccine into the routine immunisation schedules, expansion of the

### introduction of the hepatitis B vaccine into the routine immunisation schedules, expansion of the

### Water Supply and Environmental Health
- Current access and infrastructure:
  - About 55 per cent of the population have access to piped or protected well water.
  - Less than 40 per cent of households have sanitary latrines.
  - Less than 10 per cent of primary schools have proper latrines.
- Consequences:
  - These conditions have resulted in outbreaks of diarrhoeal diseases and/or cholera in several areas; the number of patients and deaths has been high.
- 2003–2005 targets and expected impacts:
  - Increase access to clean water to 65-70 per cent of the population.
  - Increase use of hygienic latrines to 45-50 per cent of the population.
  - Equip at least 20 per cent of primary schools with hygienic latrines.
  - More ready access to clean water will decrease time spent collecting water and ease the burden for women who are the major water carriers.

### Control of Communicable Diseases

- Malaria Control
  - Recent program coverage and impact:
    - All 18 provinces have participated.
    - Programme reached 118 districts and 5,824 villages.
    - Almost 1.6 million people in the target villages have been protected by IBN.
    - No malaria outbreak in recent years.
    - Morbidity rate reduced to 46/1,000 LB.
    - Mortality rate reduced to 4.5/100,000.
    - Parasite index rate is 11 per cent (2001 latest indicator).
  - Limitations:
    - Only one-third of villages have so far benefited from the programme.
    - Supplies of chemoprophylaxis in highly endemic areas has not been adequate.
  - Targets for 2005:
    - Reduce the parasite index rated to 8-10 per cent.
    - Reduce morbidity to 12.8/1,000 LB.
    - Reduce mortality to 3.4/100,000.
    - Increase number of people using IBN to over 60 per cent of the population.
  - Priority activities:
    - Strengthen treatment and referral capabilities.
    - Maintain assistance for retreatment of bed-nets for the poor and vulnerable.
    - Continue dissemination of information, expansion of IBN programme, and upgrading of medical staff.

- Dengue Fever Control
  - Recent incidence:
    - Outbreaks have continued since 1998, with children 6-15 being the most affected.
    - 1,718 cases and 4 deaths in 2002.
  - Constraints:
    - Campaign to eradicate disease has not been as active as it should be.
    - Provincial and district surveillance systems limited, especially at HC and village levels.
    - Lack of co-ordination between epidemiology, disease control, and health education units.
  - Objective and priority activities:
    - Control dengue fever and ensure that deaths are minimal.
    - Train medical staff in case management.
    - Enhance health education focusing on the three clean principles.
    - Cover all water receptacles, use larvicide regularly where appropriate.
    - Provide information on how to neutralise Aedes aegypti and establish early detection surveillance.

- Acute Diarrhoeal Diseases (ADD)/Cholera
  - Recent burden:
    - In 2000, there were 12,440 cases and 520 deaths (case fatality rate >4 per cent).
  - Causes:
    - Lack of clean water, non-hygienic eating habits, and lack of application of the ‘3 cleans’ principle.
  - Government response:
    - Mobilise people in endemic areas to practice the ‘3 cleans’ principle.
    - Produce IEC materials translated into local languages.
    - Make supplies of VHV and ORS available in outbreak areas to prevent dehydration and shock.
    - Strengthen early detection.

- Tuberculosis (TB)
  - Situation and constraints:
    - TB is an increasing problem, especially among the poor.
    - Not all provinces have been surveyed; TB network has not reached remote rural areas.
    - Supervision system from central to provinces, districts, and villages is insufficient.
  - Government goals and priorities:
    - Achieve an 85 per cent cure rate (treatment expected to be effective in achieving this).
    - Expand TB control network to 5 provinces not yet covered.
    - Train health workers in all provinces and districts on DOTS fundamentals.
    - Upgrade diagnostic skills.

- Control of Intestinal Parasitism
  - Infection rates:
    - Infection rate of school-age children by soil transmitted helminths is more than 50 per cent.
    - Infection rate of the overall population from food transmitted helminths (such as Taeniasis and liver flukes) is more than 50 per cent.
  - Causes and challenges:
    - Reflects poor hygiene and lack of practice of the ‘3 cleans’.
    - Campaigns warning against eating raw fish and meat have not been sufficiently effective.
  - Objective and priority activities:
    - Reduce these rates by half by 2005.
    - Conduct national surveys of the extent of the problem.
    - Implement health education in schools.
    - Develop a policy and action plan for parasite control.

- Communicable Disease Control, Surveillance and Response
  - Rationale:
    - Improved surveillance is critical; SARS highlights need for capable surveillance for known and unknown diseases.
  - 2005 target:
    - Achieve a nationwide system whereby disease detection is more assured, allowing time for preventive measures.
  - Major activities (2003–2005):
    - Improve disease reporting system, especially village → district → province.
    - Train medical staff at central, regional and provincial hospitals on disease surveillance and outbreak response.
    - Develop laboratory capacity of regional and provincial hospitals for detection.
    - Establish an Early Warning of Outbreak and Recognition System among central, provincial and district hospitals.

### Control of HIV/AIDS/STD
- Current assessment and risks:
  - Prevalence of HIV infection in the Lao PDR is low compared to neighbouring countries.
  - Data on HIV/STD infection are limited.
  - STD prevalence is approaching 50 per cent in certain high risk populations.
  - Increasing cross-border movements increase exposure to the AIDS pandemic.
  - Participatory Poverty Assessment (ADB-2001) showed low levels of HIV awareness in rural and remote regions.
  - Strong link between poverty and vulnerability to HIV/AIDS; migration of young people increases risk through prostitution and unsafe sex practices.
- Government stance:
  - Control of HIV/AIDS is one of the national programmes.
  - A detailed cross-sector action plan is provided in Chapter 7 of Part IV.

### Village Drug Revolving Fund (DRF)
- Role and coverage:
  - DRFs provide medical assistance in remote areas; many villagers face many hours by foot to reach nearest facility.
  - Some villages have drug kits; 5,400 villages have no access to health facilities and do not have drug kits.
- Risks and management issues:
  - Improper use of drugs supplied by DRFs could worsen poverty.
  - Most DRFs have mechanisms to exempt the very poor, but these mechanisms need study and strengthening.
  - Many DRFs barely function due to weak management.
- Government near-term objective and priority activities:
  - Provide drug kits to people in remote areas and train village staff to use kits properly.
  - Priority activities:
    - Expansion of district drug revolving funds.
    - Provision of drug kits to villages in remote areas.
    - Training of VHV for drug kit management under strict supervision by district hospitals.
    - Printing and dissemination of training manuals for trainers and drug kit guidelines to be distributed to VHV.

### Improving Food and Drug Safety
- Drug safety issues:
  - Many common drugs are imported, most by private companies; quality control is uncertain and often substandard.
  - 5,400 villages have no access to health facilities and do not have drug kits.
  - Most villagers rely on drug sellers, many without license or registration; most purchases (70 per cent) are without consultation with a medical officer.
  - Poor are most vulnerable to illegal and fake drugs.
  - Drug use in state and private facilities is often improper; financial incentives promote overuse, contributing to anti-microbial resistance and adverse interactions.
- Food safety issues:
  - Producers and importers do not always ensure quality or safety.
  - Contamination or addition of harmful substances (pesticide residues, formaldehyde, food colours) is still common.
  - Consumers often lack know-how; expiry checks usually overlooked.
  - Monitoring system for food safety and food-borne diseases is weak, including at border points.
- Government priorities:
  - Train workers in food and drug industry in quality and safety management.
  - Ensure proper regulations and laws concerning food and medical products.
  - Develop standards for food and drugs.
  - Establish or reform food and drug inspection units at immigration check points.
  - Enforce strict regulatory control of food and drug advertisements by the private sector.

### Promotion of Co-operation Between Traditional and Modern Medicine
- Context and rationale:
  - 41 per cent of the Lao PDR is densely forested; an even larger area has some forest cover with rich plant life.
  - Protection and use of medicinal plant life have not been effectively regulated.
  - Traditional medicines can be beneficial and combined with modern medicine; some traditional practices are expensive and potentially harmful.
- Government actions and priorities:
  - Encourage inclusion of traditional medicines in health centres and drug kits.
  - Promote traditional medicine plantations to replace tobacco and opium plantations in northern provinces.
  - Promote plantations of Anoectochilus formausos (King of medicine of Taiwan).
  - Use traditional medicine at hospitals and health centres at all levels.
  - Co-operate with countries such as Vietnam, China, Japan, USA, and Korea to develop traditional medicines for local production and export.
  - Develop law for protection and management of medicinal plants.
  - Promote traditional medicine for local consumption and research into expanding use.

### Strengthen Sustainability of the Health Sector

- Establishing Community Health Insurance (CHI)
  - Current financing context:
    - Cost recovery via drug revolving funds and fees for diagnostic examinations practised since 1995.
    - Major hospitals can cover as much as 60 per cent of their budgets from fees.
    - Dependence on out-of-pocket payments may limit access for the poor despite exemption mechanisms.
  - CHI objectives and targets:
    - Establish a pre-payment and risk pooling system to prevent large medical expenses pushing people into poverty.
    - By 2005, voluntary community health insurance hoped to cover 10 to 15 per cent of the population.
    - Pre-payment expected to encourage early care seeking and promote stable financing of providers via regular capitation payments.
    - Recognises extremely poor unlikely to afford monthly payments; recommends mechanisms such as equity funds from the Government to pay for the poor.
  - Priority activities:
    - Data collection and analysis of three pilot projects.
    - Mobilisation of understanding about the fund.
    - Establishment of a committee for management of the fund.
    - Training of key management personnel.

- Improving Management of the Health Sector
  - Priority activities:
    - Review and incorporate recommendations from Lao Health Master Planning Study and the public expenditure review.
    - Support health staff working in hard-to-reach and remote areas.
    - Clarify statutes or bylaws for hospitals and health centres at all levels.
    - Prepare a draft law on curative medicine.
    - Organise a medical society and increase status of health workers.
    - Regular supervision and monitoring of the health service network.
    - Conduct a survey of the health status of the population.
    - Increase co-ordination among MOH levels, government departments, and donor-supported projects.
    - Increase co-ordination with the private sector to integrate health activities at district and health centre levels.
  - Financing and legal framework:
    - Sustainable financing is a major issue; the health system is dependent on donor funding and out-of-pocket payments.
    - Health budget will steadily increase, as will its share of GDP.
    - Improved planning and service integration will improve efficiency versus project approaches.
    - Insurance schemes, both mandatory and voluntary, would increase stability of financing.
    - Improve legal and regulatory framework: stronger enforcement of public health law, development of curative law, realistic and enforceable regulations (waste management, drinking water quality).
    - Improve professional standards via development of medical and nursing councils for licensing and quality assurance.
    - Issue regularly updated and enforceable guidelines to standardise delivery of preventive and curative care.

*Source: _cr04393 - introduction of the hepatitis B vaccine into the routine immunisation schedules, expansion of the*

### Annex 3 (Table 3.3) provides a detailed policy/programme development matrix for the health sector.

### _cr04393 - Annex 3 (Table 3.3) provides a detailed policy/programme development matrix for the health sector.

### Role of the Ministry and strategic context
- The Ministry of Communication, Transport, Post and Construction (MCTPC) is responsible for planning, budgeting and development of the communication network and all modes of transport and associated infrastructure, including roads and road transport, inland waterways and ports, railways and aviation and airports. MCTPC remit also includes urban water supply and sanitation, post and telecommunications, and urban development.
- Continued improvements in Lao’s transportation system are fundamental to supporting economic growth and realising the goals and objectives of the NGPES.
- Lao PDR is shifting from being viewed as “landlocked” to a “land link” for Mekong River countries; NR13 now runs the length of the country connecting with China in the north and Cambodia in the south.
- Donor support has helped upgrade arterial links and corridors to Thailand, Viet Nam and Myanmar, upgrade airports, and strengthen transport agencies.

### Goals for the transportation sector (main and specific)
- Main goal: fully integrate the economy, providing an enabling environment for trade and commerce and access for all Lao people to basic services.
- Specific/additional goals:
  - All-weather road access for poor districts and “focal areas”: objectives include access to health and education services, access to markets and strengthening economic development; also drug eradication and help for ethnic minorities.
  - Strengthen transport linkages with neighbouring countries to bolster regional integration and trade opportunities.
  - Institutional capacity building: strengthen MCTPC and provincial departments to plan and manage the transport/communications sector; progressively implement more accountable management.
  - Road maintenance: first priority is maintenance of the all-weather road network critically linked to an efficient operation of the Road Maintenance Fund.
  - Road-use regulation: enforce measures and regulations concerning overweight vehicles to protect road assets.
  - Protect the environment and ensure social equity: fully apply MCTPC’s Environmental Guidelines, implement resettlement and construction mitigation plans, and undertake post-construction monitoring.
  - Road safety: establish a National Road Safety Council and introduce low cost, high return road safety measures.
  - Private sector participation: strengthen the domestic contracting industry to compete effectively for construction and maintenance projects.
  - Community participation: involve local communities in road planning, construction and maintenance.

### Current status and modal shares
- Dominant transport mode: road — about 70 per cent of freight traffic and 85-90 per cent of passenger traffic; river transport accounts for most remaining freight traffic and about 8 per cent of passenger traffic; domestic air links urban areas and other parts of the country.
- Freight traffic table highlights (million kilometre tons):
  - 1990 total 149.5 (Motor Vehicles 97.7; Water Ways 51.6; Airways 0.2) — Percentage share Motor 65.4; River 34.5; Air 0.1.
  - 1995 total 165.6 (Motor 81.6; Water 82.2; Air 1.8) — Percentage share Motor 49.3; River 49.6; Air 1.1.
  - 2000 total 221.7 (Motor 162.2; Water 58.9; Air 0.6) — Percentage share Motor 73.2; River 26.6; Air 0.3.
  - 2001 total 235.5 (Motor 171.1; Water 64.0; Air 0.4) — Percentage share Motor 72.7; River 27.2; Air 0.2.
  - 2002 total 266.7 (Motor 163.4; Water 102.7; Air 0.6) — Percentage share Motor 61.3; River 38.5; Air 0.2.
- Passenger traffic table highlights (millions of passenger-km and percentage shares):
  - 1990 total 13,177.8 (Motor 12,588.0; River 469.0; Airways 120.8) — Motor 95.5; River 3.6; Air 0.9.
  - 1995 total 13,788.8 (Motor 13,243.0; River 436.0; Airways 109.8) — Motor 96.0; River 3.2; Air 0.8.
  - 2000 total 18,760.9 (Motor 16,426.0; River 1,835.0; Airways 499.9) — Motor 87.6; River 9.8; Air 2.7.
  - 2001 total 21,425.6 (Motor 19,124.0; River 1,855.0; Airways 446.6) — Motor 89.3; River 8.7; Air 2.1.
  - 2002 total 25,743.2 (Motor 23,251.0; River 2,025.0; Airways 467.2) — Motor 90.3; River 7.9; Air 1.8.
  - Source: National Statistical Centre, 2003, Statistical Year Book 2002.

### Road network inventory and recent investments
- Total road network ~32,600 km comprising:
  - 7,160 km of national roads,
  - 8,950 km of provincial roads,
  - 6,620 km of district roads,
  - estimated 9,800 km of community/access roads.
- Pavement status: some 4,590 km paved; remaining sections gravel or earth (MCTPC, 2002).
- East-west corridor projects: NR6 and NR7 complete or near-complete; NR8 and NR9 expected to be complete by 2004; Northern Economic Corridor (NR3) expected to be completed by 2007.
- Table 25 (Road Inventory and Pavement Type in Lao PDR, 2002) regional breakdown (values preserved as in source):
  - North: National Roads Paved 1,4157 Gravel 1,061 Earth 340 Total 2,816; Provincial Roads Paved 2 Gravel 1,119 Earth 1,612 Total 2,734; Urban/District/Community Paved 78 Gravel 735 Earth 2,383 Total 3,197.
  - Centre: National Roads Paved 1,355 Gravel 578 Earth 242 Total 2,175; Provincial Roads Paved 232 Gravel 1,571 Earth 1,726 Total 3,530; Urban/District/Community Paved 224 Gravel 2,101 Earth 3,514 Total 5,840.
  - South: National Roads Paved 1,059 Gravel 478 Earth 630 Total 2,168; Provincial Roads Paved 102 Gravel 1,256 Earth 1,327 Total 2,660; Urban/District/Community Paved 120 Gravel 757 Earth 6,595 Total 7,518.
  - Lao PDR totals: National Roads 3,830 2,118 1,212 7,160; Provincial Roads 337 3.947 4,666 8,952; Urban/District/Community 423 3,595 12,492 16,529.
  - Source: MCTPC (2003) - Summary of Road Statistics for 2002.

### Challenges and constraints (preserved statements and numeric detail)
- Only just over 50 percent of the national road network is paved with about 70 per cent of the national road network trafficable throughout the year.
- Restricted trafficability of provincial and district road network during the rainy season; less than 60 per cent of district centres have year-round access.
- According to the 1997/98 LECS 2 survey, more than 40 per cent of villages are six kilometers or more from a main road and nearly half are not accessible during the rainy season.
- Villages in the Northern Region are particularly isolated; some have no access to social services and markets, even during the dry season.
- Despite growth rates of about 17 per cent annually, traffic on the road system is light; on the national road network the average traffic flow varies between 250-1000 vehicles daily, while on district/community roads the average traffic flow is one tenth of these levels.
- The Lao PDR has one of the lowest road densities in the region (13.7km/km2) reflecting its relatively large land area and small population. Traffic volumes are very low in part because the small yet widely dispersed population and the mountainous terrain make provision costly.
- Financing of maintenance of the local road network remains uncertain. The Road Maintenance Fund is directed firstly to maintaining national roads with funding for maintenance of local road networks increasing progressively as arterial requirements are covered.
- Overweight vehicles are a serious problem contributing to road deterioration.
- Road accidents have increased sharply, underscoring the need for educational programmes on road safety and other measures.
- Rail development: high development costs make rail likely limited in the short/medium term to the short link planned into the Thai rail system.
- Domestic and cross-border transit agreements must be facilitated to avoid hampering transport system use and trade growth.
- Institutional capacity to manage the overall transportation system continues to require strengthening, especially at provincial and district levels.

### Poverty-focused transport priorities and planned targeting
- LECS 2 and participatory poverty assessments show high correlation between lack of road access and severe poverty. The very poor (17 per cent of the population) live in areas where infrastructure is especially scarce; on average, the very poor are at least 15 kilometres from a main road and 70 per cent have no road access during the rainy season.
- Travel times for remote villages: it may take 1-3 days for villagers to reach health facilities and between 2-3 hours for children to reach the nearest primary school; secondary school attendance normally requires boarding in a distant village or town.
- Main focus: upgrade the local road network to integrate all villages into the national economy, with priority first on ensuring access for the 47 poorest districts identified as priorities during the 2003/05 period.
  - MCTPC progress: completed all-weather links to five districts; construction of access roads ongoing for five other districts; projects planned short/medium term for six other districts. Remaining districts to be addressed on a priority basis in the medium term, dependent on ODA funding availability.
  - The additional 25 poor districts will be the focus in following years.
- Rationale: upgrading rural roads and facilitating maintenance is a major component of poverty reduction — reduced transport costs and better access will enable rural areas to modernise and diversify economies, leading to more productive and higher-earning activities.

*Source: Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES), Annexes and Chapters excerpted in the supplied content.*

### 4.4  Principles of Poverty-Focused Transport Interventions

### 4.4 Principles of Poverty-Focused Transport Interventions

### Market Orientation
- Legislation and administrative mechanisms are in place for commercialisation/privatisation of remaining state and provincial enterprises; Government prefers commercialisation as first step to privatisation.
- Business Law No. 03/NA, 1994: makes State Enterprises financially autonomous; responsible for paying dividends to the Government and developing their own goals and plans consistent with a market-based economic system.
- Decree No.95/CM on Government Procurement and MOF Implementing Rules and Regulations No.2642/MF:
  - All civil works to be let, as far as possible, through competitive bidding procedures.
  - Contractor responsible for procuring materials, money, men and machines.
  - Local consultants to be employed for detail engineering and construction supervision services.
  - MCTPC, or respective DCTPC, acts as the employer.
- Road Law 04/NA/99: enables domestic contracting and consulting industry creation/registration and provision for an association of road engineering companies; implementing legislation drafted by MCTPC.
- Major local contractors are mainly former SOE’s established with equipment supplied under ADB, WB, Japan, SIDA and UNDP funding; availability of that equipment is declining as it reaches end of useful life, jeopardising domestic firms’ ability to compete.
- MCTPC in discussions with ADB on establishing an equipment financing scheme linked to a project loan.
- Commercial transport controlled by Road Transport Law (1997) and Regulations on the Establishment of Transport Businesses (1996); except Vientiane municipal bus services and Lao State Fuel Company, commercial operations are private sector.
- Business licences issued nationally or provincially; transport operations generally administered through transport associations.

### Participation
- Local communities encouraged to participate in planning, construction and maintenance of local road networks to ensure planners are aware of community concerns and communities informed of impacts.
- Communities participate in maintenance of access and feeder roads; local people supply labour and Government provides technical expertise and equipment.
- Local communities are to be paid in cash for labour on feeder roads to avoid unfairly diverting productive subsistence activities.
- Community participation process used for selection of feeder/access roads and project identification; village survey collects baseline data and identifies priority zones.
- Community participation in road projects involves each village:
  - Identifying and prioritising village road infrastructure needs.
  - Identifying activities needed to meet these needs.
  - Indicating who is willing to participate and/or take responsibility and detailing individual inputs.
  - Selecting a project manager to prepare the work plan for implementation.
- Note: Such a participatory approach will be followed when planning access/community roads.

### Decentralisation
- MCTPC has increasingly delegated responsibility to DCTPC in provinces, giving provinces ownership and involvement at all levels; some 60 per cent of the Ministry’s staff are now based in the provinces.
- MCTPC staff responsibilities: management and construction of national roads, internationally financed construction of local roads, transport policy, overall network monitoring, and (with Provincial Governors) appointment of Director and Deputy Director of DCTPC.
- Provincial authorities appoint remaining DCTPC staff.
- DCTPC responsibilities: land acquisition; settlement of conflicts between contractor and local people; maintenance of national roads; management of local road construction and maintenance.

### Sustainability
- Road Maintenance Fund (RMF) established under Decree No.09/PM, 2001 to ensure sufficient and stable domestic revenue for road maintenance.
- RMF allocations under the decree:
  - 10 percent of RMF annual revenue to local road network (provincial, district and community roads).
  - 0.5 percent to road safety programs.
  - Up to 90 percent, after allowing administration cost of the fund, to national roads.
  - Amount to local roads will be increased once full cost of maintaining national road network is covered by the fund.
- RMF revenues derived from fuel levy, heavy vehicles surcharge, international transit fees and other road user charges, together with on-going donor assistance in the medium term.
- RMF operates a dedicated bank account, managed by a seven member advisory board with a secretariat for day to day administration.
- First annual increase in the fuel levy, delayed due to adverse international oil market, is now due in October 2003.
- Ongoing donor assistance will continue to be required in the short and medium term.

- Table 26: Road Maintenance Fund and Maintenance Budget (figures as presented)
  - Fiscal Year columns: 03/04 04/05 05/06 06/07 07/08 08/09 09/10 Total
  - Maintenance National roads: 12.1 9.4 12.5 13.6 14.9 19.5 20.0 102
  - Maintenance Local roads: 7.0 7.8 8.6 9.4 10.2 10.8 11.4 65.2
  - Total Maintenance: 19.1 17.2 21.1 23.0 25.1 30.3 31.4 167.2
  - External Funding: 10.1 6.6 8.0 6.0 6.5 6.0 0 43.2
  - RMF Income: 4.0 5.7 8.6 12.3 18.7 26.0 34.3 109.6
  - Total: 14.1 12.3 16.6 18.3 25.2 32.0 34.3 152.8
  - National Roads: 12.1 10.5 14.4 15.9 22.1 28.1 30.2 133.3
  - Local Roads (10%): 1.41 1.23 1.66 1.83 2.52 3.20 3.43 15.28
  - Road Safety (0.5%): 0.07 0.06 0.08 0.09 0.12 0.16 0.17 0.75
  - Expenses: 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 3.50
  - RMF Shortfall/surplus National Roads: 0 +1.1 -1.9 +2.3 +7.2 +8.5 +11.2 -1.9
  - RMF Shortfall/surplus Local Roads: -7.0 -6.7 -10.5 -7.1 -3.0 -2.3 -0.2 -36.8

### Multi-sector Approach
- Road improvements catalyse delivery of other services: safe water supply and sanitation, drainage improvement, alternative cropping programs in drug growing areas, non-formal education, HIV/AIDS awareness along corridors, installation of electric power supplies in rural areas.
- MCTPC will liaise with other agencies to include cross-sector activities in projects, including urban water supply and sanitation, telecommunications, village dwellings, local airstrips, healthcare, educational training, tourism, and electrical power.
- Examples of cross-sector interventions:
  - Water and sanitation, clean water and airstrip associated with roads in Phongsaly.
  - Roads to historic sites in Xieng Khouang to support tourism-related economic growth.
  - Access roads linked to international road corridors stimulating socio-economic activities.
  - Feeder roads in Houaphan to encourage alternative cropping to drug growing.
  - River bank protection through transferred techniques providing alternative employment and contributing to poverty eradication.

### Policies to be Promoted
- Road sector investment priorities to consider: contribution to poverty reduction; capital and ongoing maintenance costs; number of people served; access to markets, education and healthcare; reduction in vehicle operating costs and travel time; economic development potential; national integration.
- Investment policy balance: improvement of existing roads, provision of strategic access, reduction in transport costs, development of maintainable access to rural communities.
- Given significant constraints on sector funding, investment projects will target high priority roads extending access to rural areas and support multi-sector objectives.
- Government’s road-related initiatives to improve access to poor districts:
  - Further improvement of the all-weather arterial road network including international roads connecting neighbouring countries through the Lao PDR.
  - Rehabilitation/construction of community feeder roads as components of main civil works projects, following existing alignments to minimise environmental and resettlement impacts.
  - Connect "Focal Development Areas" to the all weather network to provide access to markets, agricultural support, healthcare, educational services, and non-agricultural employment.
  - Encourage community participation in planning and execution of road sector activities.
  - Encourage the employment of local people and ensure no gender discrimination.
- Medium-term objective: mobilise resources to complete all-weather roads linking national capital to provincial capitals; six provincial capitals and the special zone still without sealed roads providing all-weather access: Attapeu, Oudomsay, Luang Namtha, Houayxai, Phongsaly, Sayaboury and Xaysomboun.
- Completion of these links expected to facilitate access to rural areas and stimulate economic development and upgrading of local road network.
- Road links connecting remaining provincial capitals to international borders are on-going or planned in Saravane, Sekong, Attapeu, Oudomsai, Xaisomboun, and Luang Prabang.
- Long-term aim: complete NR1, the central north-south spine, as a key internal and external trade corridor.
- MCTPC is discussing with other sectors (Ministry of Finance, Prime Minister's Office, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Customs, etc.) the role of roads in facilitating trade and movement of goods internally, in transit and internationally.
- Aviation: four main airports reasonable standard; six provincial airports due to be upgraded to improve navigational aids, runways and terminal buildings; strengthening Lao Airlines’ image to promote tourism and trade.
- Water transport: four-country agreement (Myanmar, Lao PDR, Thailand and PR of China) to facilitate navigation on the upper Mekong will help create riverine economic corridors in northern Lao PDR, providing alternative access especially in wet season.
- Recent transport initiative: announced Thai/Lao rail link.

### Budget and Funding Requirements
- Average expenditure on road network in late 80's: circa US$37m per annum; in the 90's average above US$60m per annum.
- Fiscal years 00/01 and 01/02: budgetary to actual disbursements were US$61.5m to US$44.9m and US$34.6m to US$46.1m respectively.
- Budget requirements to meet Government strategies and associated capital investments in the medium-term, together with air, waterways and rail sub-sectors, are indicated in Annex 3 (Table 3.4).

### Investment Support, Institutional Strengthening and Capacity Building
- Government will continue to depend on development partners: World Bank, Asian Development Bank, SIDA, Japan/JICA, OPEC, IFAD, KfW, UNCDF and EU for rehabilitation/reconstruction projects.
- Costs of extending, upgrading and maintaining transport system are very high; cost per km of road varies from over US $200,000 per kilometre to a low of US $20,000 per kilometre depending on type and terrain.
- Continued training required for DCTPCs, contractors and consultants in areas including:
  - Working in a competitive bidding environment.
  - Understanding contractual conditions and obligations.
  - Understanding the technical specifications required.
  - Planning and financial management.
  - The procurement process.
  - Operational control costs.
  - Equipment management.
  - Site safety and safe working practises.
  - Contract management.
  - Environmental impact and mitigation.
- Eight priorities for enabling business environment and national road construction capacity:
  - Further development of the regulatory framework.
  - Management system development.
  - National Transport Safety Strategy implementation.
  - Capacity development of central MCTPC level institutions.
  - Capacity development of local level (provincial/district) institutions.
  - Financial management development.
  - Procedures/routines for inter-sector issues.
  - Continual development of sustainable financing mechanisms (e.g., RMF).

*Source: _cr04393 - 4.4 Principles of Poverty-Focused Transport Interventions*

### 5.1  Energy and Rural Electrification

### 5.1 Energy and Rural Electrification

### Hydropower potential and electrification status
- Only 623 Megawatts (MW) of an estimated 18,000 MW of hydropower potential has so far been developed.  
- The Lao PDR has one of the lowest levels of electrification in Asia: only 20 per cent of all villages and 34 per cent of households have access to electricity.  
- Only ten per cent of rural areas are provided with grid electricity.  
- Government target: ensure that 70 per cent of the households have electricity by 2010.  
- Energy consumption of the main economic sectors is increasing on average 10 per cent per year.

### Key challenges in accelerating power development
- A better and a more transparent integration of social and environmental concerns.  
- Curtailing possible over-dependency of the economy on hydropower development.  
- Increasing domestic tariffs to cover financial production costs, at least in urban areas, with a transparent subsidy scheme for poor rural areas.  
- More effective sub-regional co-operation in producing and distributing electricity.  
- Prioritisation of proposed hydropower projects and development of suitable financing.  
- Improvement of the regulatory framework and encouragement for increased private sector investment.  
- Institutional strengthening, especially in financial planning, management, and negotiation capacity with developers.

### Electrification methods and policy/investment priorities
- Expand the electricity network to full coverage, starting with provinces and districts with very limited access to electricity.  
- Complete construction of small and medium-scale projects (up to about 60 MW) for domestic utilisation using government investment funds.  
- Proceed with the Nam Theun 2 project with international investors.  
- Construct a 500 KM high voltage electric transmission system.  
- Continue mini-developments (micro-hydropower, solar and wind energy projects for off-grid power supply in remote areas).  
- Expand electrification in remote areas by: i) expanding the grid to comparatively easily accessible areas; and ii) providing off-grid supplies to remote areas where grid expansion is difficult due to environment or cost reasons.  
- From a gender equity perspective, easier access to electricity will facilitate the lives of women, reduce household chores, and contribute to poverty eradication by reducing time spent gathering fuel wood.

---

### 5.2–5.3 Agro-forestry and Tourism (summarised)

### Agro-forestry industry priorities
- Promote medium and small-scale agro-forestry industries consistent with regional capacity.  
- Target products/activities: food processing; semi-ready-made and ready-made manufactured products such as vegetable oils, cotton and silk, hand-weaving, traditional medicine manufacturing, household utensils, decoration and furnishing items, and souvenirs.  
- Combine potentiality, cultural values and traditional factors of production with modern techniques for domestic and export markets.

### Tourism industry growth and strategy
- International arrivals grew from 14,400 in 1990 to 735,600 arrivals in 2002.  
- Tourism contribution to national income: 7-9 per cent of GDP.  
- Strategy favours pro-poor, community-based tourism development, enhancement of tourism-related infrastructure, and sub-regional tourism co-operation.  
- Current activities: awareness initiatives on tourism benefits, environmental and cultural conservation, HIV/AIDS prevention, prevention of sexual exploitation and trafficking of women, and dissemination of successful regional experiences.  
- Other elements include identification and development of tourism products, small-scale tourism-related infrastructure, capacity building for tourism micro-enterprises and communities, gender-specific programmes, participation programmes for ethnic minorities, training in marketing and eco-tourism, and promotion of community-based tourism networks.  
- Human resources development needs: language training and decentralised training in hotel/guesthouse management, tourism guiding, housekeeping, and site management. Proposed establishment of a national committee for tourism education and training.  
- Sub-regional cooperation: establish tourism marketing and promotion boards within the Greater Mekong Sub-region and the ASEAN framework; seek cooperation to improve tourist facilities at border posts and streamline immigration and customs regulations.

---

### 5.4 Mining Sector

### Recent developments and resource endowment
- Commencement of operations in 2003 of the Oxiana Gold Mine in Sepon, Savannakhet; the mine is proving highly profitable and is generating royalties for the Government.  
- Tax revenues from the mine will increase sharply when the tax concessions are completed in 2-4 years time.  
- The Oxiana mine is expected to start producing copper in the near future.  
- Other mines, including a gold mine in the Northern Region, are under assessment.  
- Mineral endowment includes gold, copper, tin (Khammouane), anthracite (Saravan, Vientiane, Phongsaly), lignite (northern provinces), salt and gypsum (Savannakhet), potash (Vientiane basin), Phou Nhouan iron ore (Xieng Khouang), Ban Houei Sai sapphire, and cement limestones, glass sand, and clay deposits in various provinces.

### Social and environmental safeguards and community partnership
- Government will ensure mining development is environmentally and socially sustainable while contributing to economic development. In partnership with private sector interests, the Government will work with communities to ensure:  
  - A full understanding of the impacts.  
  - A climate of trust and co-operation.  
  - Guidelines for development and operation of the mine.  
  - Resettlement and compensation for any loss of assets and earnings.  
  - Assistance programs centred on asset creation and human capital formation.  
- These principles are applied to the Oxiana Gold Mine and will apply to future mining activities.

---

### 5.5 Construction Materials Industry

### Current status and production
- In 2001, recorded consumption of construction materials was US$56 million, of which domestic production accounted for US$31 million. (Bricks and other materials for local use are not included.)  
- Domestic production mainly consists of plastic tubes, pipes, cement, corrugated roofing, iron bars, gravel and marble; also produced locally are concrete electricity poles, wire, nails and some other products.  
- Lao PDR will need to continue to import bulk construction materials that are based on capital intensive and large-scale production.

### Government emphasis to strengthen the industry
- Human resource development.  
- Science and technology development.  
- Infrastructure development for transit services.  
- Reform of the legal and judicial framework for private sector enterprise.  
- Review of Government procurement procedures to ensure domestic suppliers get a fair chance to compete with foreign suppliers.

---

### 5.6 Action Plan for Industrial Development and SMEs

### Strategic Action Plan objectives and inputs
- Government preparing a Strategic Action Plan for Industrial Development to promote sustainable manufacturing activities as a means of creating employment and reducing poverty.  
- The Plan will be the subject of a policy dialogue meeting as part of the Government’s roundtable process.  
- Inputs included studies on: food processing and packaging; construction materials; wood processing; handicraft; textile and garment; integration into ASEAN; industrial land development; technology needs; and SME development.

### Industrial and handicrafts policy elements
- Efficient utilisation of the Lao PDR’s natural resources as the basis for the industry and handicraft sector.  
- Encourage manufacturing and handicraft industry that mainly use domestic factor inputs.  
- Combine modern techniques with local creativeness and traditional techniques.  
- Promote and strengthen small and medium-sized enterprises adapted to potential and ability of people.  
- Initiatives supporting industrialisation including land policy, training, and trade facilitation.  
- Infrastructure to integrate rural/urban areas to give poor people opportunities in new manufacturing/handicraft-related activities.  
- Identify potential areas for investment and business enterprise.  
- Ensure sustainable development in poor communities.  
- Handicraft production will be encouraged by including it as a priority sector in the law on domestic investment.

### Regional distribution of manufacturing output
- Vientiane Municipality accounts for 55 per cent of total manufacturing output.  
- Khammouane province: 15 per cent.  
- Savannakhet province: 9 per cent.  
- Vientiane province: 8 per cent.  
- Champassak province: 6 per cent.  
- Northern Region (seven provinces) accounts for only 2.5 per cent of total manufacturing output, even though it accounts for 34 per cent of all manufacturing businesses.

### SME support priorities and institutional arrangements
- Government preparing a Prime Minister’s Decree on Support for the Development of Small and Medium-sized Enterprises. Priority areas identified:  
  - An enabling legal, regulatory and administrative environment for SMEs.  
  - Enhancing competitiveness of SMEs.  
  - Expanding domestic and international markets for SMEs.  
  - Improving access to financing by SMEs.  
  - Improving access to appropriate work premises.  
  - Creating favourable conditions for establishment of business organisations.  
  - Encouraging entrepreneurial attitudes within the society.  
- Government working with the Lao National Chamber of Commerce and Industry (LNCCI), local Chambers, and Business Groups under the LNCCI to advise on initiatives and to set up institutional and advisory frameworks to design and implement SME programmes and ensure women and ethnic minorities participate fully.

---

### 5.7 Banking and Financial Support Sector

### Reform objectives and rural finance
- Strengthening the financial and banking sector is necessary for sustained growth, macro-economic stability, poverty reduction, and support for enterprise and trade.  
- Success in strengthening the sector will spur growth of SMEs and private investment and assist in the global campaign against money laundering.  
- Improved financial services to rural areas are of special concern; currently only a small percentage of farmers have access to such services.  
- The Agricultural Promotion Bank (APB) will be transformed into a self-sustaining, market-oriented rural financial institution. Policy-based lending will be phased out in favour of strictly commercial criteria within 3 years.  
- Rural and micro-finance institutions will fall within regulations and guidelines established by the BOL. A variety of micro-finance institutions will be encouraged. A national strategy for rural credit and micro-finance and a corresponding action plan are under preparation. The second draft of the strategy and action plan has broad stakeholder support.

### Major objectives of the rural and microfinance strategy and action plan
- Support for market-oriented reforms.  
- Creating a legal space for a variety of sustainable micro-finance institutions (MFI’s).  
- Ensuring MFI autonomy in setting interest rates and making other business decisions.  
- Creating an MFI Forum.  
- Restructuring APB into a financially self-sustainable rural finance institution.

### Banking sector medium-term reform priorities
- Improve performance of state-owned commercial banks (SOCB) by:  
  - Resolving the stock of non-performing loans (NPLs).  
  - Strengthening prudential supervisory regulations and compliance.  
  - Enhancing SOCB corporate governance.  
  - Undertaking legal reform and judicial strengthening.  
  - Reforming state-owned enterprises.  
  - Extending financial services to rural areas.  
  - Developing the private sector.

---

### 5.8 State-owned enterprise reform programme

### Objectives and expected contributions
- Reform programme aims to strengthen financial management of existing SOE, enterprise restructuring and utility tariff reforms.  
- Implementation will contribute to financial sector reforms, particularly elimination of non-performing loans in the banking system (a limited number of SOEs have disproportionately contributed to NPLs).  
- Utility tariff reforms will enable public entities to function on a cost-recovery basis, particularly in electricity, water, transport and telecommunications—vital for industrialisation and modernisation.  
- Reforms will help equalise conditions between the private sector and SOEs, enhancing growth and poverty eradication.

*Source: Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES), section 5.1–5.8.*

### 5.9 Poverty-focused Trade Development

### 5.9 Poverty-focused Trade Development

### Trade as an engine for growth and poverty reduction
- Trade is described as "an essential, all-encompassing factor" for expansion and development of key and supporting sectors.
- Increased trading activities create supply-side responses across all sectors, leading to new investment opportunities, higher output (particularly in agriculture and industry), growth in services (transport, banking, insurance, communication, tourism), increased employment and incomes, and stronger demand-side responses.
- The Government recognises trade’s importance to poverty reduction and has incorporated trade and commerce elements into most sectoral poverty eradication strategies.

### Integrated Framework (IF)
- The Integrated Framework (IF) is an initiative of the WTO and other core multilateral agencies to provide technical assistance to improve trade-related capacity of LDCs and integrate them more effectively into the world economy.
- The IF aims to promote trade and development and thus contribute to poverty eradication by mainstreaming trade into national development and poverty eradication strategies.
- The Government is fully committed to using the IF to enhance trade facilitation and market linkages and is preparing a strategic approach.

### Pro-poor Trade Development Strategy — key elements
- The Government’s pro-poor trade strategy focuses on encouraging poor people to engage in trade through the following elements:
  - Continuing sustainable trade policy reforms.
  - Mainstreaming trade into national growth and poverty reduction strategies.
  - Rationalising and streamlining trade administration procedures.
  - Upgrading the capacity of service delivery system in the trade sector.
  - Improving trade facilitation.
- The main government function in trade policy is to provide a healthy policy environment that reduces obstacles and hindrances, encouraging productive sector investment, production and marketing in a free market environment.
- The Ministry of Commerce (MOC) has a strengthened role in trade policy administration; terminology shifts to "import administration" (instead of "import controls") and "price surveillance" (instead of "price controls") reflect strategic trade facilitation and administration approaches.
- Import licensing and trade policy will consider current account balance and balance of payments consistent with competitive market system principles.

### Policy improvements: Rationalising policy on protection
- Government objective: protect and promote new domestic industries during infancy but phase out industry protection beyond the infancy period.
- Consideration will be given to replacing protective quantitative restrictions with tariffs, "wherever possible," because they "work through the market system."
- More vulnerable traditional activities, particularly in agriculture, may receive longer protection for adjustment.

### Foreign trade and regional integration
- Expansion of foreign trade to be achieved through:
  - Establishment of more bilateral trade relations and regional and international integration.
  - Enhancement of border trade with neighbouring countries under a land-linked programme, development of border trade zones and special economic zones.
  - Development of North-South and East-West corridors with improved national road and checkpoint networks.
- The Government will implement CEPT under AFTA by reducing tariffs on a range of products to "0-5 per cent by 2008," aimed at almost eliminating remaining trade barriers with ASEAN counterparts and attracting foreign, particularly export-orientated, investment.
- The Government has finalised arrangements to sign a bilateral trade agreement with the USA; signing is expected to establish normal trade relations with the USA and help attract more foreign investment.

### Import administration
- Sustainable development requires living within means: import expenditure should approximate total income from exports of goods and services, foreign aid receipts and net capital inflows.
- Containing imports is mainly a function of macroeconomic management; the Government will provide a sound import administration system consistent with a liberal and free market trade regime and obligations under AFTA and other international requirements.
- Application of quantitative and other restrictions on imports will be minimal and only to the extent required for social security and infant industry protection.

### Export development
- Lao PDR has GSP status from "35 countries," with China noted as the latest country to have granted preferential status.
- Recent GSP-related concessions: New Zealand, Canada and Australia have granted Lao exports duty free entry (footnote).
- Measures to promote export development and production activities include:
  - Rationalising export administration procedures to reduce processing time for license applications.
  - Researching products in which Laos would have a comparative advantage.
  - Disseminating market intelligence on overseas market opportunities, procedures, GSP and other tariff concessions to prospective exporters.
  - Providing information on investment opportunities and facilities to domestic and foreign investors via mass media and ICT networking, primarily through the Lao Trade Promotion Centre information service.
  - Improving trade facilitation.

### Domestic trade development
- Development of domestic trade is vital to overall economic development; the private sector will be encouraged and supported to facilitate unrestricted distribution of goods and services nationwide to prevent shortages and unnecessary price increases.
- Measures to encourage production and marketing of domestic goods include:
  - Regularly organising exhibitions and trade fairs within and outside the country to create market opportunities.
  - Publishing information on availability of domestic products and prevailing prices.
  - Providing producers and traders with information on GSP availability to Lao PDR from several developed countries.
  - Promoting development of trade-related infrastructure: rural marketplaces, transport and communication.
  - Promoting availability of banking, finance and credit facilities, particularly for medium and small-scale enterprises.

### New initiatives and institutional measures
- Fair Trading Commission
  - Government will promote competition and fair-trading practices to ensure the benefits of trade liberalisation are realised and to prevent restrictive practices by dominant firms.
  - Action is being taken to introduce an anti-monopoly and competition law.
  - Consumer protection legislation is being pursued to protect consumers from hazardous products and unethical trade practices.
  - A Fair Trading Commission will be established under the MOC, supported administratively by a Fair Trading Unit within MOC.
  - Assistance for legislation preparation, staff training and community awareness is being obtained from UNCTAD and other aid agencies; community awareness will be raised through seminars, workshops and public awareness programs.

- Commercial law reforms
  - Existing laws relating to trade and commerce, particularly the Business Law of 1994, are being reviewed and revised to provide an appropriate legal framework for the liberalised trade and commercial regime.

- Train-For-Trade Programme
  - Train-For-Trade is a UNCTAD-sponsored technical assistance project for the Lao PDR and Cambodia aimed at trade-related capacity building.
  - The project is a "four-year" project scheduled to start in "September 2003."
  - UNCTAD will conduct training and other technical assistance to improve skills of Lao officials and staff engaged in trade-related activities during the project.

- Trade Training Centre (TTC)
  - The Ministry of Commerce’s TTC will provide short-term courses for MOC staff and staff of other relevant ministries and provincial governments to upgrade trade-related skills.
  - The TTC will be utilised by the IF Initiative and the Train-For-Trade Programme for skills training.
  - UNCTAD is arranging supply of computers, audio-visual and other equipment to make the TTC fully operational.

- Lao Chamber of Commerce
  - The Government has taken steps to make the Chamber of Commerce independent to enhance its role in promoting trade and business development.
  - In conjunction with the Lao Chamber of Commerce, the Government intends to use the Greater Mekong System (GMS) Business Forum in Vientiane to promote regional trade and business relations.

*Source: 5.9 Poverty-focused Trade Development, Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES).*

### Annex 3 (Table 3.5).

### Annex 3 (Table 3.5).

### 6.2 Environment Conservation and Poverty Eradication — Issues
- The Government’s Five-Year Socio-Economic Development Plan (2001-2005) emphasises environmental conservation as vital for long-term sustainable economic growth and poverty eradication.
- Environment and natural resources are the foundation for livelihoods of most rural people, particularly the poor and ethnic minorities.
- Environmental degradation (deforestation, soil erosion) leads to natural disasters (floods) and consequences that disproportionately impact the poor.
- Urban poor are affected by unclean water, lack of proper sanitation, and indoor smoke from cooking due to lack of access to electricity.
- Government priority: integrate environmental principles across all sectors; sector action plans must be ecologically sound and enhance social and cultural development.
- The National Environmental Action Plan 2000 (NEAP) and the Environment Strategy for 2003-2020 are integral to the NGPES.
- Science, Technology and Environment Agency (STEA) is responsible for monitoring national environmental targets.
- Environment and natural resource management will be integrated within all sector strategies and community-based initiatives focused on the 47 poorest districts.

### Current Environmental Trends (STEA, 2001)
- Five areas of environmental concern identified:
  - Deforestation and Forest Quality Degradation:
    - Forest coverage declined from more than 70 per cent of total land area up to the mid 1960s to about 47 per cent in 1998.
    - Department of Forestry is determining trends since 1998 based on satellite data collected during 2000-02.
    - Rural people comprise 80 per cent of the population and are highly dependent on forests.
    - Villagers may obtain half of their income and half of their dietary protein from forest products.
  - Land Degradation:
    - Swidden (dry-rice) cultivation with lower yields is predominantly practised by poor villagers in highland areas.
    - More than one-third of the country area has a slope of more than 30 per cent.
  - Access to Water Resources:
    - Lao P.D.R. has the highest per capita renewable freshwater resources in Asia.
    - Only 60 per cent of the urban population and 51 per cent of the rural population has direct access to a good water supply.
    - Only 35 per cent of cultivated land has access to irrigation.
  - Threats to Bio-diversity:
    - Deforestation and forest quality degradation have contributed to bio-diversity losses over the past three decades.
    - Causes include unsustainable forest management, wildlife trades, excess/inappropriate fishing, and growing demand for agricultural and residential areas.
  - Decline in Urban Environment:
    - Need for proper urban planning to avoid exacerbating pollution and harming urban well-being.
    - Solid waste and wastewater management require further attention.

### Poverty and the Environment — Findings for Poorest Districts
- Data source: S. Dasgupta, et al., 2002 Poverty-Environment Nexus in Cambodia, Lao PDR and Viet Nam.
- Key findings:
  - Deforestation and Agricultural Land:
    - Deforestation rate for the poorest districts is about the same as the national average.
    - Poorest districts have experienced a far greater decline in agricultural land.
    - On average, poorest-district households have 52 ha of high-density forest area per household.
  - Land Degradation:
    - About half of the total land area in the poorest districts has an average slope of more than 30 per cent.
    - Poor households rely on dry-rice cultivation with low yields and increasingly on declining NTFPs (non-timber forest products).
  - Water Resources and Environmental Health:
    - Poorest districts have less than half the national average of daily water use due to limited access for personal use and irrigation.
    - Water- and sanitation-related health problems are acute; acute respiratory infections and indoor air pollution are serious problems.
  - Bio-diversity:
    - 13 districts out of the poorest districts have more than half of their total land area covered by forest; many are located in the National Bio-diversity Conservation Areas.
    - The poor rely heavily on NTFPs, wood and other forest products; bio-diversity conservation is crucial for their livelihood.
  - Vulnerability from Natural Disasters:
    - Over the past decade, Lao P.D.R. suffered severe droughts and floods.
    - In the year 2000, 1,104 km2 in seven provinces were flooded, affecting 450,000 people.

### Strategic Responses — Overall Objective and Three Main Strategies
- Overall objective of draft National Environment Strategy 2003-2020:
  - “to sustainably utilise natural resources and protect and conserve the environment to ensure the sustainable development of the country while reducing poverty and enhancing the quality of life and health of the Lao people.”
- Three main strategies identified:

  1. Improve the management of natural resources through increased participation and protection:
     - Strengthen participation, especially by the poor, in preparation and implementation of national and local plans, policies and strategies.
     - Co-manage environmental services and resources with the poor by strengthening community management.
     - Protect access the poor already have to critical resources (entitlement to land, water, trees, pastures, fishing grounds).
     - Expand the natural asset base of the poor (community forest rights).
     - Reduce subsidies for environmental services that benefit the less-poor.
     - Undertake ecological zoning of the Lao PDR.

  2. Improve the institutional framework and its capacity through strengthening the institutional framework and raising public awareness and political commitment:
     - Develop a sound legislative and legal framework for property rights, water resources, forestry, land management and bio-diversity.
     - Use market based instruments as much as possible.
     - Build capacity for more effective environmental management.
     - Deepen public awareness and political commitment.
     - Improve public access to environmental information.
     - Introduce environmental education as standard part of the curriculum.
     - Integrate environmental concerns into private sector decision-making; promote industry-wide codes of conduct and environmental auditing.

  3. Improve the environmental management in industrial and construction sectors:
     - Promote environmental infrastructure and technology that benefit the poor.
     - Promote development of environmentally friendly private sector products such as clean technology, energy efficiency technology and eco-tourism.

### Policy and Programme Priorities
- Policy and programme priorities for the environment are summarised in Annex 3 (Table 3.6).

### 6.3 Population Policy for Poverty Reduction — Goals and Programmes
- National Population and Development Policy (NPDP) adopted in 1999; aligned with Cairo 1994 Programme of Action.
- Main policy goals of the NPDP:
  - Support measures to achieve a rate of population growth compatible with socio-economic development and employment opportunities.
  - Ensure safe motherhood and enable couples to responsibly decide the number and spacing of their children.
  - Improve the status of women and multi-ethnic populations by improving access to education, health, social welfare and socio-economic development.
  - Promote a balanced distribution of population between rural and urban areas and between different parts of the country.
  - Incorporate population factors into all social and economic policies, plans and programmes.
- Service expansion since 1993:
  - Mother and Child Health and birth spacing services introduced at 542 primary health care facilities and all referral hospitals.
  - Health volunteers in more than one third of the country’s villages received basic training on reproductive health and family planning.
- Challenges: disparities persist in rural areas where poverty and fertility rates are higher; age of marriage earlier; expansion sometimes at expense of quality and limited integration.
- Two main programmes: Reproductive Health and Population and Development.
  - Reproductive Health Programme purposes:
    - Increase use of reproductive health services and information for responsible and safe sexual behaviour.
    - Create enabling environment for provision of quality, integrated services and counselling.
    - Activities include special focus on ethnic groups and institutional strengthening and training.
  - Population and Development Programme outputs:
    - Strengthened advocacy capacity of key organisations (e.g., National Co-ordinating Committee for Population and Development) for NPDP implementation.
    - Strengthened capacity of CPC and other agencies for data collection, analysis, training, research and dissemination on gender and population issues.
    - Strengthened capacity of NCCPD, CPC and other organisations for co-ordination and implementation of the national population programme.

### 6.4 An Efficient Social Security System to Prevent Poverty
- Long-term objective: establish an efficient social security system for all Lao people.
- Public servants covered by provisions including pensions and health care financed partly through a six per cent deduction from salaries and partly from the state budget.
- 1999 Decree on Social Security System for Enterprise Employees established foundation of a National Social Security Scheme; Social Security Organisation (SSO) began operating in June 2001.
- SSO administers the Social Security Scheme for enterprise workers in private and SOE sectors.
- Scheme provides protection coverage for:
  - Access to health care from an approved health care provider by insured workers and their families.
  - Long-term pensions in respect of old age, invalidity and surviving dependants.
  - Short-term benefits in respect of incapacity for work by virtue of sickness or maternity.
  - Benefits in respect of incapacity for work by virtue of an employment-related injury, sickness or death.
- Initial coverage focus:
  - Workers in private and state-owned enterprises with 10 employees and more in Vientiane Municipality.
  - Coverage will gradually extend to workers of smaller-size enterprises and to other provinces.
  - Note: This extension is being assisted by the Government of Belgium and the UNDP.
- Strengthening and extension of social security is an element of the poverty eradication programme.

### 6.5 Information and Culture
- Improved information by all Ministries supports community-based development and transparency.
- Ministry of Finance releases budgetary documents as part of commitment to openness and dialogue.
- Ministry of Culture and Information will increasingly use mass media to disseminate information and enhance public awareness of Government policies and programmes.
- Efforts to ensure information reaches the poor and that the poor can communicate back to public officials and community leaders.
- Cultural priorities:
  - Preservation of national cultural heritage, historic sites, heritage towns and temples to attract tourists and generate income for local people.
  - Rehabilitation and construction of art and musical schools and cultural villages will continue.

### 6.6 Capacity Building
- Capacity building is an essential element of the NGPES and a major requirement for improved public administration, strengthened legal and regulatory frameworks, and good governance.
- Most sectors have developed, or are developing, capacity building programmes and projects, incorporating capacity building into activities.
- Decree on ODA Management and Utilisation (No208/PM/Oct.30, 2002) stipulates all ODA programmes and projects must contain capacity building elements.
- National Organisation for the Study of Politics and Administration (NOSPA) created to train middle and high-ranking government officials in public administration and governance; role to be strengthened.
- New priority area: decentralisation management and development planning capacity building in line with PM Instruction 01 (‘decentralisation’) and PM Instruction 010 (‘poverty eradication’).
- Steps to ensure efficiency and effectiveness of capacity building:
  - Develop an inventory of current capacity building initiatives, programmes and projects for government staff funded and implemented by Government and development partners.
  - Identify and prioritise capacity building requirements at all levels and prepare a framework for implementation responding to needs across time and place.
  - Create a comprehensive capacity building strategy based on the inventory and ranking of needs.
  - Implement the capacity building strategy through a coordinated approach with close coordination between line ministries and provincial, district and village authorities, and development partners.
- Expected outcomes:
  - High level of synergy, complementarity and efficiency.
  - Better monitoring of capacity building programmes and responsiveness to NGPES priorities.
  - Especially benefits district and provincial levels by improving planning, management, fiscal management and development planning capacities.
- Appropriate institutional arrangements at micro and macro levels to carry out and coordinate these activities are being studied.
- The Government seeks support for coordinated capacity building to ensure improved competence throughout the country.

*Annex 3 (Table 3.5). Source: Lao PDR – National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES).*

### Chapter 7:  Poverty-Related National Programmes

### Chapter 7:  Poverty-Related National Programmes

### 7.1 The National Drug Control Programme
- Key linkages and concerns:
  - Illicit drug supply is linked with illicit drug demand; financing of demand reduces household assets and may lead to petty thefts, domestic violence, large scale organised drug trafficking, and entrenched organised crime that can affect security, stability and peace — conditions necessary for poverty eradication.
  - Supply and demand of both opium and Amphetamine Type Stimulants (ATS) is a major concern.
  - UNODC publication “World Global Illicit Drug Trends 2002” identified the Lao PDR as the world’s second largest consumer of opiates in per capita terms.
  - ATS have been spreading rapidly among young people; injecting drug use appears to be still low, but ATS abuse may result in high-risk behaviour, increasing vulnerability to HIV/AIDS.
  - Drug abuse and HIV/AIDS affect health and work productivity, increasing vulnerability to poverty.

- Opium statistics and distribution:
  - In 2002, opium production occurred in 67 districts.
  - Of these 67 districts: 32 are among the 47 poorest districts and 45 are among the 72 poor districts.
  - Opium is produced by approximately 50,000 households in about 1,600 villages.
  - Production is mostly in the remote highlands of ten Northern provinces, which account for 90 per cent of total production for the country.
  - UNODC (June 2003) figures indicate approximately 12,000 ha are under opium cultivation, a 15 per cent decline compared to 2002.
  - Raw opium production amounts to approximately 112 metric tons.
    - 65 tons (58 per cent) are consumed domestically for addiction, social and medical purposes.
    - 47 tons are exported.
  - More than 52,000 people in the areas concerned are drug addicts, with weak health and unable to perform productive activities.

- Amphetamine Type Stimulants (ATS):
  - The Lao PDR is now facing a serious ATS epidemic.
  - ATS abuse is mainly an urban problem, spreading to rural areas, common among the student population and other groups, and a potential factor in the spread of HIV/AIDS.
  - Footnote definition: “The word ATS has been adopted to refer to synthetic central nervous system stimulant drugs such as amphetamine, metamphetamine and the chemically related ‘ecstacy group’ (MDMA). In the Lao PDR, ATS is mainly metamphetamine and is called ‘ya-baa’ (crazy drug).”

- Strategic responses and programme structure:
  - Goal: eradicate opium poppy cultivation by the year 2005 through an accelerated rural development programme in major opium producing districts.
  - Government preparing a comprehensive Master Plan on Drug Control balancing alternative development, demand reduction and law enforcement.
  - Alternative development components: replace opium production with alternative income sources; develop irrigation, transportation, credit access, health, education; improve cropping and livestock practices; explore non-traditional employment such as forestry-derived employment, processing of local products, handicraft production and tourism.
  - Community-based drug demand reduction: raise community knowledge of harmful effects, focus assistance on reducing incidence of new addiction, concentrate on detoxification and community-based rehabilitation programmes; prevention, counselling, treatment and rehabilitation for ATS and other drugs.
  - Law enforcement operates in parallel with alternative development and demand reduction.
  - Implementation: Lao National Commission for Drug Control and Supervision (LCDC) within the Prime Minister’s Office coordinates; overall programme implemented by LCDC in collaboration with UNDCP; individual projects executed with local authorities by UN agencies, bilateral and multilateral agencies, and NGOs.

- Policy and programme priorities and targets:
  - Government committed to implementing international conventions and resolutions; UN goal of eliminating or significantly reducing opium production by 2008.
  - 7th Party Congress (2001) approved targets to eliminate poppy cultivation by 2005.
  - LCDC coordinates central-level information collection, yearly target setting, project preparation, and mobilisation of domestic and international resources.
  - To achieve elimination by 2005, future priorities will focus on:
    - Provide each locality with necessary annual budget to implement their opium poppy cultivation elimination plan.
    - Continue mobilising funds, domestically and internationally, to support rural development projects replacing opium-growing activities.
    - Facilitate access to credit for other productive activities, such as animal raising and handicrafts production.
    - Facilitate detoxification and rehabilitation programmes and initiatives.
    - Continue drug awareness programmes and other initiatives to prevent return to opium poppy growing.
    - Facilitate voluntary relocation to areas offering better services and more diversified economic opportunities.
  - An estimated US $68 million will be needed over the next six years to carry out investments in the opium growing districts, for new drug control projects and complementary projects.

- Core activities required to eliminate opium cultivation in the 47 poorest districts:
  - Awareness programmes and law enforcement.
  - Creation of alternative income sources, giving equal or better returns than possible from poppy cultivation.
  - Treatment and rehabilitation for addicts.
  - Monitoring action to stop opium cultivation, drug consumption and trade.

- Institutional arrangements and capacity building:
  - A Programme Facilitation Unit (PFU) established jointly by LCDC and UNDCP.
  - A National Anti-Drug Trust Fund has been established.
  - A national training and resource unit will be established under the Ministry of Labour and Social Welfare to develop/provide drug counselling courses.
  - Private enterprises will be encouraged to establish drug counselling activities.
  - The drug control programme is being mainstreamed into national development priorities, linking practical alternative development approaches for improving village livelihoods to mainstream national development efforts.
  - Top government priority: provide necessary social and economic infrastructure and help establish income alternatives to reduce reliance on poppy cultivation, improving health status and contributing to poverty reduction.

- Annex reference:
  - Annex 3 (Table 3.7) provides a list of completed, on-going and planned projects concerning eradicating poppy cultivation.

### 7.2 The UXO Decontamination Programme
- Issue overview and impact:
  - UXO contamination is a very serious problem for the Lao PDR, causing human suffering, loss of life, and blocking development in large areas.
  - During 1964 to 1973, intense ground battles and aerial bombings left an estimated 30 per cent of ordnance unexploded.
  - Severe UXO contamination still affects 15 provinces, particularly Savannakhet, Xiengkhouang, Saravane, Khammouane, Sekong, Champassak, Huaphan, Attapeu, and Luang Phrabang.
  - Affected areas represent over 50 per cent of all agricultural land.
  - UXO denies access to land, deters planting and grazing, hinders collecting fuel and water, discourages movement between villages, slows transport/communication works, and undermines social and development activities.
  - Three decades after the Indochina War, many people continue to be killed or badly crippled by ordnance.

- Strategic responses and programme activities:
  - Increased action required to clear contaminated land and raise awareness of UXO threats.
  - Lao National UXO Programme (“UXO Lao”) established in 1996, supported by a Trust Fund administered by UNDP.
  - UXO Lao trains, equips and employs de-mining staff, surveys contaminated areas, educates impacted communities, and clears unexploded bombs and landmines.
  - UXO Lao’s activities save lives and increase social and economic opportunities for some of the poorest districts.

- Main challenges and priorities:
  - Main challenge: mainstream UXO/mine action into developmental programming to:
    - Ensure planning of operations relates closely to national priorities such as poverty reduction, phasing out shifting cultivation and opium elimination.
    - Increase the pace of clearance to open land for agricultural production.
    - Mobilise resources required for humanitarian UXO action programming.
  - UXO Lao currently operates in 9 of the 17 provinces targeted.
  - Additional survey work is urgently needed in districts with high contamination rates to determine required UXO clearing programmes.
  - Priority attention will be given to the poorest districts.
  - UXO actions will be planned, budgeted and conducted in close co-ordination with all stakeholders.
  - A national strategic plan “The Safe Path Forward” has been approved.
  - Institutional and managerial arrangements are being strengthened.

- Annex reference:
  - Annex 3 (Table 3.8) provides UXO Contamination Data by Province/District.

### 7.3 National Plan of Action for HIV/AIDS/STD
- Current status and overall objective:
  - The Lao PDR is largely free of the HIV/AIDS pandemic but vigilance is required; HIV seroprevalence in the Lao PDR is remarkably low as compared with neighbouring countries; less than 1 per cent of the surveyed population.
  - Government determined to maintain and improve upon the low rates of prevalence and incidence.

- Planning and operational framework:
  - In January 2002, the Government formulated a National Strategic Plan (NSP) on HIV/AIDS/STD for 2002 to 2005.
  - The Government will develop a National Plan of Action to operationalise the NSP and assist in resource mobilisation.

- Top priorities reflected in the NSP:
  - Surveillance:
    - Reliable epidemiological data is critical; more survey work is required.
  - STD prevention and treatment:
    - Sexually-transmitted infections among service women and truck drivers are high; this could lead to a fast-evolving HIV/AIDS epidemic.
    - The Global Fund for HIV/AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria will help fund STD prevention projects in five provinces.
  - Prevention of HIV among youth:
    - Adequate preparation of young people before sexual activity is essential; life skills education concerning sexual health is a high priority.
  - Prevention of HIV among mobile populations:
    - Mobile population groups are among the more vulnerable to STD, including HIV; some migrants go to surrounding countries which have much higher HIV prevalence than Lao PDR.
  - Prevention of HIV among service women:
    - Commercial sex work is illegal in the Lao PDR but educational and other prevention activities must be openly directed to service women.
  - Care, support and treatment:
    - Some 1,020 patients are currently ill with HIV/AIDS; non-discriminatory care is important.
    - Home-based care is practical and has been piloted in Savannakhet.

- Prevention measures and other issues:
  - Prevention of STDs includes advocacy of safe sexual behaviour (condom use) and ensuring that blood supplies are safe.
  - Other issues: prevention of mother-to-child transmission, HIV among drug users, HIV among the general population and ethnic minorities.

- Managerial and institutional priorities:
  - Policy development and advocacy.
  - Strengthening institutional arrangements.
  - Strengthening country-wide surveillance and other research.
  - Address emerging issues of importance (drug use and gender aspects).

- Institutional commitments and actions:
  - Government recognises need for a strong institutional framework and will:
    - Take a multi-sector approach in which responsibilities/activities will be decentralised to the provinces but well co-ordinated.
    - Strengthen the legal framework.
    - Build the capacity of the National Committee for the Control of AIDS (NCCA) to take decisions quickly and with authority and act decisively in transmitting information and resources to fight the epidemic.
  - Government will need assistance from development partners in this programme.

- Annex reference:
  - Annex 3 (Table 3.9) provides a policy/programme matrix for the prevention and treatment of HIV/AIDS.

*Source: Chapter 7, “Poverty-Related National Programmes,” _cr04393 - Chapter 7:  Poverty-Related National Programmes_*

### Chapter 8: Community-Driven Rural Development, Poor Districts and

### Chapter 8: Community-Driven Rural Development, Poor Districts and Poverty Eradication

### Issues
- PM Instruction 001 (March 2000) and PM Instruction 010 (June 2001) redefine central-local relations:
  - Provinces: strategic planning units; expected to formulate 5-year strategic plans and corresponding budgets consistent with the national 5-year socio-economic development plan, the NGPES and the fiscal framework.
  - Districts: programme and project planning and budgeting units; responsible for planning and budgeting in accordance with national and provincial plans and fiscal framework.
  - Villages: main focus for programme and project implementation; responsible for revenue collection based on production, collection of socio-economic data, self-classification as well-off / self-sufficient / poor, and monitoring impact of development on household income improvement and poverty reduction.
- PM Instruction 010 official poverty definitions:
  - Poor households: insufficient income to secure a minimal food ration of 2,100 calories/capita/day, equivalent to 85,000 kip/capita/month.
  - Poor villages: more than 51 per cent of the households are poor and have limited access to schools, health facilities, roads and clean water.
  - Poor districts: more than 51 per cent of the villages are poor and 40 per cent have no access to schools, health, or clean water and 60 per cent have no access to roads.
- Area-focused development approach:
  - Targets remote areas with endemic poverty and areas with growth potential.
  - Concentrates rural development in clusters or zones (khet/tasseng) combining agriculture, social services, institutional capacity building, infrastructure and markets to boost household income and eradicate poverty.
- Institutional responsibility:
  - PM Instruction 013 (May 2002): Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry responsible for planning and co-ordinating rural development.
- Regional differences and implications:
  - Lowlands (Mekong corridor): better transport and market access; commercialisation of agriculture; improved education and health leading to lower fertility and lower dependency ratio.
  - Uplands: mountainous terrain; poor road access; limited irrigation; widespread shifting cultivation; subsistence farming predominates; vulnerability to opium cultivation as coping strategy.
- Natural resource dependence:
  - For remote mountainous households, as much as 40-60 per cent of household income is derived from non-timber forest products (NTFPs).
  - Over-harvesting of NTFPs and forests, and pressure for agricultural land, deplete natural resource base; proper forest management can provide renewable resources, NTFPs, sustainable revenues, and agro-forestry opportunities.
- Market opportunities:
  - Greater Mekong Subregion has a population approaching 300 million with growing demand for protein and other food products, presenting export opportunities for rice, livestock, vegetables, NTFPs, handicrafts, and agro-forestry products.
  - Ethnic-specific skills (e.g., Tai Dam sericulture; Hmong cattle raising; Khmou forest knowledge; Akha herbal medicines) to be incorporated into rural programmes.

### Strategic Responses
- Rural poverty linked to access to resources and availability of social services. Resource access includes land, forest and NTFP tenure, livestock security, access to agricultural inputs (credit and irrigation) and markets. Social services include education, health, clean water and sanitation.
- Major development constraints identified:
  - Inadequate infrastructure.
  - Limited and poorly developed human resources.
  - Poor health conditions.
  - Inadequate potable water and facilities.
  - Poor agricultural support and delivery services.
  - Limited access to inputs and markets.
  - Lack of medium and short term credit.
- Government strategy emphasizes community-based, highly participatory planning with two major components:
  - Improving access to essential development factors.
  - Comprehensive, poverty-focused planning at the district level to ensure complementary initiatives.
- Five pillars for improving access:
  - Production inputs and sustainable natural resource management technologies (‘supply–side’).
  - National and regional markets through physical (roads and trade facilitation) and institutional linkages (‘demand-side’).
  - Human resource and community institutional development.
  - Social services development.
  - Rural finance mobilisation.
- Interrelationships and sequencing:
  - Human resource and community institutional development, social services, and rural finance are preconditions/catalysts for supply and demand initiatives.
  - Food insecurity must be addressed as a first priority, especially in the 47 poorest districts.
- Focus on focal development areas and the 47 poorest districts to ensure economic growth with equity and poverty reduction.

### Priorities and Actions for the 47 Poorest Districts
- Major constraints on poverty eradication in the poorest districts:
  - Lack of communications and access to markets.
  - Inadequate social services, poor health and low educational levels.
  - Linguistic barriers.
  - Large families and high dependency ratios.
  - Low productivity.
  - Inadequate infrastructure including roads and irrigation.
  - Lack of extension services and knowledge of new technologies.
  - Lack of access to markets and market information.
  - Absence of rural credit and veterinary services.
- Priority improvements emphasized:
  - Production capacity: inputs and technology, including improved rice seeds, crop diversification, animal health care, strengthening of the district extension service, and improved operations of existing irrigation systems.
  - Rural infrastructure to facilitate access to markets and rural credit.
  - Human and village/district institutional development.
  - Social services: education, health, clean water, sanitation.
- Community-driven, poverty-eradication operational principles:
  - Development should be people-centred; community self-development is the overarching goal; projects should facilitate implementation of village development plans.
  - No physical works without prior establishment of participatory beneficiary institutions (e.g., Water-user Associations, Road Maintenance Groups, School Committees) and provision for O&M expenditures.
  - Labour-based construction technology to maximise rural employment and community ownership.
  - Food security as a top priority through rice intensification; irrigation should be people-centred and small scale.
  - Projects operate within existing district and village institutions.
  - Rural financial services should support short-term lending for farmers and medium-term lending for village-based rural enterprises.
  - Project planning should include accurate investment cost estimates and provision for recurrent costs.
  - Institutional capacity building must be incorporated in all projects.

### Community Self-Development Vision and Institutional Measures
- Vision elements:
  - Capacity building of local institutions, with emphasis on empowerment.
  - Development process that is community-owned and community-supported; resource allocation aligned with community-level strategic visions.
  - Local plans and institutional empowerment as preconditions for external Government or donor-financed assistance.
  - External resources should complement, not substitute for, locally provided resources and management.
  - Food self-sufficiency as a precondition for activating rural development processes.
  - A “national innovation system” for rapid dissemination of research and experimentation successes (e.g., village-level vaccination techniques, new forage techniques).
- Identification and sequencing of investment priorities for the 47 poorest districts:
  - Preparation of district profiles to identify issues, status of factors and review present interventions.
  - Development of participatory district plans to guide future interventions.
  - Development of integrated focal area development plans.
  - Identification of community-based initiatives for priority support.
  - Sequencing of interventions to ensure coordinated approach.
- Institutional capacity building to strengthen village and district institutions is of utmost importance.
- Highest priority given to increasing livestock production through strengthened research, extension services and disease prevention; successful innovations to be shared nation-wide.
- Promotion of SMEs, foreign investment, and development of small towns linked to rural areas; a National Urban-Rural Basic Infrastructure Development Strategy is under preparation to extend urban benefits nationwide.
- Real resources will be transferred to districts to give meaning to empowerment:
  - For FY 2003-2004, 40 billion kip will be channelled directly to the 47 districts through local funds.
- Establishment of community development funds and the Poverty Reduction Fund (PRF-Decree PM/073, May 2002) to deliver resources to poor villages and enable communities to assess needs and priorities.
- Government target and facilitation:
  - Workable community-driven district profiles for all 47 districts expected within the next 18 months.
  - Broad participation, facilitation and training to ensure poor villagers, including women, participate in decision-making and benefit from project inputs.

*Source: Chapter 8, Community-Driven Rural Development, Poor Districts and Poverty Eradication (excerpts).*

### Part V: Mobilising and Allocating Resources – Reconciling

### Part V: Mobilising and Allocating Resources – Reconciling Development Priorities with the Budgetary Resource Envelope

### Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF): baseline and revised scenario
- Baseline (framework of the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF)) forecasted:
  - annual economic growth rates of 6.5 – 7.5 per cent for 2001-2005
  - a one-digit inflation target
  - gradual increase of the revenue/GDP ratio up to 15 per cent by 2005
- Events required re-estimation of the resource gap:
  - original revenue targets for 2002-2003 to 2005-2006 judged optimistic
  - external shocks included the outbreak of SARS and slower regional/global recovery
  - inflation rose to double-digit levels, partly due to severe floods in 2002
- Revised MTEF (reference for FY 2003-2004 to FY 2005-2006) based on:
  - estimated economic growth rates of 5.9 per cent for FY 2002-2003, 6.2 per cent for FY 2003-2004, 6.5 per cent for FY 2004-2005, and 7.0 per cent for FY 2005-2006
  - inflation targeted at single digit levels throughout the period
  - forecast revenue growth of 20 per cent for FY 2003-2004 and for following years
  - revenue as a share of GDP expected to rise to 13.4 per cent by FY 2005-2006
- Government considers FY 2003-2004 a year of transition, testing approaches, and preparing for NGPES implementation up to 2020

### Fiscal adjustments, revenue and expenditure measures taken
- Revenue measures introduced in 2002-2003 and enforcement actions expected to increase revenues by approximately 53 billion kip for FY 2002-2003:
  - enforcement of import duties and excise and turnover taxes on imported petroleum products
  - introduction of a new, inflation-based excise tax on luxury goods (e.g., mobile phones)
  - enforcement of fees and collection of other service charges, including stamp duty
- Expenditure adjustments for FY 2002-2003:
  - reduction of expenditures by approximately 30 billion kip by postponing projects not yet initiated
  - planned 30 per cent increase in basic wages for public servants reduced to 15 per cent, yielding a further reduction in expenditure by 50 billion kip
  - savings of 22 billion kip in external debt service charges resulting from India’s cancellation of debts and changes in the SDR/US $ exchange rate
- Fiscal outlook for FY 2003-2004:
  - total expenditures will increase by 6 per cent to 4,627.5 billion kip, amounting to 18.9 per cent of GDP
  - expenditures for FY 2002-2003 are forecast at 19.5 per cent of GDP
  - domestically-funded public investment allocation will drop to 760 billion kip for FY 2003-2004 (from 960 billion kip in FY 2002-2003) before rising in FY 2004-2005 and beyond
  - foreign-funded PIP expenditures expected to increase throughout the period, with a sharp increase in grants offsetting a decline in loans
  - overall public investment projected to stabilise at about 10 per cent of GDP by 2005-2006, with the domestically-funded share at 3.7 per cent of GDP and the foreign-funded share at 6.6 per cent

### Growth and investment targets, and role of the private sector
- Government growth projection: 7 per cent annually after 2005
- To sustain economic growth, total investment (public and private) will have to increase to some 26-28 per cent of GDP
- NGPES emphasises:
  - the private sector, including foreign direct investment, as a main engine for growth and partner in financing critical investments (e.g., hydropower and telecommunications)
  - enhancement of a favourable business environment as a pillar of macro-economic stability and growth
  - continued external partner support to keep momentum for growth, environmental conservation, and improved quality of life

### Institutional capacity, fiscal decentralisation, and public investment quality
- Identified causes of weak revenue performance:
  - lack of capacity at all levels of government, especially local, for tax administration
  - insufficient preparation for fiscal decentralisation and lack of clarity on responsibilities for tax collection at each government level
  - less than strict monitoring of revenue and expenditure management at the provincial level
  - very liberal application of tax and customs exemptions under revision
  - insufficient mastery of budget preparation and management
- Remedies and support:
  - measures being addressed through the Financial Management Adjustment Credit (World Bank-supported)
  - efforts to strengthen capacity: transfer of knowledge, skills improvement, expanded use of management technology, clarification of institutional responsibilities
  - implementation of new budget nomenclature to facilitate tracking of recurrent expenditures
  - close monitoring of increases in the money supply to maintain price and exchange rate stability

### Further revenue considerations and reforms
- Long-term revenue mobilisation strategy:
  - broaden and deepen the national revenue base through continuous improvement of revenue collection, modernisation of the tax system, and growth of the revenue base
  - adoption and preparation for a VAT system:
    - number of enterprises established, draft law being finalised, and impact data being refined
    - VAT to greatly enhance tax administration efficiency once necessary conditions are in place
  - strengthening revenue collection mechanisms via standardised registration, accounting and auditing systems
  - improving effectiveness of the Large Taxpayers’ Unit through training at central and provincial levels
  - strict observance of the Budget Law, the Tax Law and the Customs Law as the basis for improved budget management
- Expected revenue sources and projections:
  - revenues from the gold and copper mining industry expected to contribute more than 14 per cent of tax revenues from FY 2006-2007 onwards
  - together with expected revenues from the Nam Theun 2 hydropower project, these two sources projected to represent about one quarter of total revenues from FY 2009-2010 onwards
  - additional revenues will accrue from royalties and the profits tax
  - annexed conservative assessment of expected long-term revenues referenced in Annex 4, Table 4.1
- Risks and adjustments:
  - need for new tax sources and improved tax collection heightened by expected loss in customs revenues from implementation in 2008 of the Common Effective Preferential Tariff (CEPT) under the ASEAN Free Trade Area (AFTA)
  - combination of improved tax effort and larger revenue base expected to enable strengthening public services while progressively reducing dependency on official development assistance (ODA)

*Source: Part V, "Mobilising and Allocating Resources – Reconciling Development Priorities with the Budgetary Resource Envelope", NGPES document.*

### Chapter  2 : Resource Allocation and Investment Requirements

### Chapter  2 : Resource Allocation and Investment Requirements

### Fiscal framework, costing and medium-term planning
- Prudent fiscal management requires that public expenditures remain within the country’s financial capabilities; a strict expenditure management plan is needed, incorporating priorities under the NGPES.
- “Costing of the NGPES” (estimation of the implied costs of achieving the NGPES goals up to 2020) is beyond the Government’s capacity at this juncture; the NGPES is intended to be a dynamic programme.
- The Government favours an intermediate, medium-term approach to budget reconciliation while preparing an in-depth, longer-term approach through:
  - an annually adjusted medium-term expenditure framework (MTEF), and
  - a 3-year “rolling” PIP (public investment programme).

### Targeting poor districts and spatial distribution of investment
- Public investments under the NGPES have a dual purpose: to enhance conditions for sustainable growth and development and to eradicate poverty; neither objective should be achieved at the expense of the other.
- Focus on the 72 poor districts (first phase: the 47 poorest) stems from the national poverty assessment which showed half of the country’s districts at risk of being “left behind” or “de-linked”.
- Historical public investment distribution:
  - Approximately 65 per cent of the public investment programme over the past decade allocated to “growth and development” investments (transport and communication, irrigation, infrastructure).
  - Approximately 35 per cent considered “social development” investments (health, education, rural development, social welfare).
- Based on spatial distribution of ODA disbursements:
  - Approximately one third of ‘growth investments’ and one fifth of ‘social development investments’ under the PIP benefit the 72 poor districts.
  - The 72 poor districts’ share of total public investment over the years has been approximately 30 per cent.
  - If one third of this share has accrued to the 47 poorest districts, their share of total public investment would be approximately 10 per cent.
- Low share for the 47 poorest districts reflects difficult access; a large share of the PIP for transport infrastructure will continue to be necessary to improve access.

### PIP composition, sectoral shares and provincial allocations
- The PIP includes public investments at provincial and district/local levels and is consistent with the consolidated budget for all levels of Government.
- Economic sectors:
  - Accounted for 50.9 per cent of PIP outlays in FY 2001-2002.
  - Projected to reach 59.7 per cent in FY 2003-2004.
  - Projected to decline to 56 per cent by FY 2005-2006.
- Agriculture/forestry share in the PIP is shown as steadily rising as rural development is now under MAF.
- Transport sector remains at the same high level in absolute value; relative share will slightly decline.
- Social sectors:
  - PIP allocations steadily grow from 27.4 per cent in FY 2001-2002 to 33.6 per cent in FY 2005-2006.
  - Health and education will represent more than 75 per cent of social investment in 2005-2006, compared to 66 per cent in FY 2001-2002.
- Allocation channels:
  - Approximately two thirds of the PIP goes through the sectors (line ministries).
  - Approximately one third goes directly to the provinces (which in turn allocate funds to their districts).
  - Currently no detailed information available regarding district investments; this shortcoming is being addressed.

### Recurrent costs, maintenance and rules
- Concern: inadequate provision for operating and maintenance expenditures undermines returns from public investment (health, education, roads, capital equipment).
- PM Decree 058 stipulates large investment projects must explicitly cite associated recurrent costs.
- Research with World Bank support established approximate ratios between expected recurrent expenditures and capital costs:
  - Recurrent costs are on average about 15 per cent of the capital costs of ODA-funded projects.
  - Recurrent costs are on average about 12 per cent of the capital costs of domestically-funded projects.
  - Annual provision should be made – over the lifetime of the project – for recurrent expenditures averaging at 12-15 per cent of the project costs.
- Findings and revised MTEF indicate Government resources are too limited to make adequate provision; Government will consult with development partners to better balance support between recurrent and capital expenditures.
- Example model: establishment of the Road Maintenance Fund.

### Strict PIP guidelines (adopted July 2003)
- Implementation of Decrees 135 and 058 concerning preparation of the National Development Plan and the public investment programme.
- Freezing of all public investments for offices and administrative buildings.
- Re-evaluation of several projects regarding their necessity and efficiency.
- Freezing of some bigger projects that have no immediate positive economic and social impact.
- Systematic freezing of any unnecessary investment at all levels.
- Requirement of a conclusive feasibility study for approval of all new projects before they can be approved.
- Prioritisation of projects nearing completion.
- Elaboration of technical standards and unit costs for infrastructure investments.
- Improved monitoring and reporting regarding implementation of projects.
- Judicious allocation of Government counterpart funds.
- Improved debt management.

### Resource allocation for FY 2003-2004 (domestic contribution to PIP)
- Domestic contribution to the PIP will drop to 760 billion kip for FY 2003-2004, from 960 billion kip in FY 2002-2003.
- Allocation of the 760 billion kip:
  - 300 billion to assume the debts, especially provincial debts, of past PIP investments.
  - 200 billion for on-going and new national projects.
  - 160 billion for counterpart funds to ODA projects (on-going and new projects).
  - 100 billion for poverty eradication through enhancement of income generating activities; of this amount:
    - 40 billion kip are earmarked for the 47 poorest districts.
    - 60 billion kip for improvement of extension services throughout the country, enhancement of market production (income generation) and capacity building.
- Excluding the amount allocated for paying past investment arrears, almost 22 per cent (100 billion of 460 billion) of domestic investment funds will be directed to poverty eradication.
- Approximately 1 billion kip has, in principle, been allocated to each of the 47 poorest districts (some of these districts are covered by the Poverty Reduction Fund or other means).
- Government funds will support capacity at all levels (planning, management, technical capacity-building), with particular emphasis at the district level, and will support on-going projects (e.g., UXO-related activities, alternative production schemes in support of drug elimination).
- Priority social and livelihood activities: reproductive health, prevention of HIV/AIDS, micro-credit activities and income generating activities.
- Government expects that towards the end of FY 2003-2004, 8 to 10 comprehensive district plans will be ready; comprehensive district plans will be prepared for all 47 districts to guide resource allocations.
- 40 billion kip earmarked for the poorest districts will be used as a “development fund” channelled through village and district funds to support households and villages in income generating activities; government emphasizes community-driven development and replication of successful initiatives.
- National strategy and action plan for expansion of rural finance and micro-credit (presently under preparation) will provide a framework for future use of these funds.
- Institutional and managerial requirements to efficiently run these funds and initiatives must be given highest priority.

### Role of infrastructure and sector-wide planning
- Investments in infrastructure are essential to promote economic growth, enhance national integration, and complement regional corridor investments.
- Comprehensive infrastructure is critical for farmers’ access to services and local, national and regional markets; reflected in the Government’s 5-pillar approach to rural development emphasizing market opportunities and individual initiative.
- The Government considers sector-wide planning (rather than programme or project-driven planning) essential to develop coherent and complementary use of scarce public resources.
- Given reduced PIP allocations and committed counterpart funds, relatively little new investment is scheduled for FY 2003-2004; sector priorities must reflect sustainability under prolonged budgetary constraints and maximize synergies between sector investments.
- The Government will determine sector envelopes based on assessments and expected domestic revenues to guide line ministries and provincial authorities in defining top priorities and allocating ODA effectively.

### Investment priorities of main sectors (short and medium-term)
1. Agriculture/Forestry
- More analysis needed of land use zoning to harmonise resource allocation and provide guidance to investors.
- Governance and capacity building are major priorities, especially at the district level; research and extension services prioritized.
- Immediate priorities in the poorest districts include animal health (vaccination), small irrigation schemes, small animal raising and fish ponds.
- Access to markets and production inputs are on-going priorities for the poorest districts.

2. Education
- Universal primary education is the first priority, followed by pre-school and lower secondary education.
- The poorest districts and ethnic minority girls need greater support.
- Supply of learning materials, of qualified teachers and of schools need improvement.
- School management, including clarification of roles under decentralisation, is a priority.
- An improved payment system is needed to ensure that teachers are paid on time.

3. Health
- Implementation of the 12 strategic programmes is the overarching set of priorities.
- In the poorest districts, priority is expansion of the health services network to provide better access to quality care and to drugs and other essential medical supplies.
- Skills of health workers need upgrading, with greater emphasis on ethnic minority workers.
- Continued emphasis on mother and child health care is needed to reduce high rates of mother and child morbidity and mortality in remote areas.
- Water supply and environmental health programmes are priorities to prevent diarrhoeal and/or cholera.

*Chapter  2 : Resource Allocation and Investment Requirements*

### 4. Transport and Communications

### 4. Transport and Communications

### Transport priorities and needs
- Strengthen linkages between the national and rural road networks.
- For the poorest districts, strengthening of the rural road system is the top priority to give access to markets and critical services (health, education).
- Improvement of road maintenance is a priority.

### Telecommunications priorities
- Extension of telecommunications services to the poorest districts is needed to improve information exchanges, technology transfer, and access to markets.

### Operational implications (cross-sector)
- Sector priorities and their costs must be thoroughly assessed, including the longer-term national financial implications.

---

### Chapter 3: Strengthening Effectiveness and Accountability

### Key implementation actions (timing and scope)
- Prepare comprehensive plans for the poorest districts.
- During FY 2003-2004, undertake long-term programming and costing for core sectors, especially health and education.
- Develop sector-wide action plans during FY 2003-2004.
- Reconcile priority expenditures (both recurrent and capital) with expected budgetary resources for the next 5 to 10 years.
- Improve NGPES linkage between the macro-economic framework and growth and poverty eradication programmes (e.g., sector resource envelopes).

### Capacity, data, and donor engagement
- Donor support is needed for long-term programming, costing, and sector-wide action plan development.
- Technical assistance would be most helpful for the complex, time-consuming exercise of reconciling expenditures with projected resources.
- Improvements will be based on an improved public expenditure programme and improved budget formulation, execution and monitoring.
- Prioritisation of sector programmes will be completed, with further effort on gender, rural-urban differences and ethnic dimensions of poverty.
- Estimate the full implementation cost of the NGEPS and assess Government implementation capacity.
- Identify demand-driven funding priorities in accordance with sector and poor district investment prioritisation.
- As a first step to costing, refine PIP data and overall sector expenditures to set the stage for realistic sector resource envelope projections.

---

### Part VI: Participation, Monitoring, Evaluation

### Participatory process and consultation history
- NGPES preparation began before the First National Workshop on Poverty Alleviation in 1996 and the 6th RT Meeting in 1997.
- Consultations include Rapid Poverty Assessments (in 1997), the 7th RT Meeting (in 2001) and the Participatory Poverty Assessments (from 2000-02).
- The Roundtable (RT) process engages bilateral, multilateral and NGO partners within national ownership, transparency and accountability frameworks.
- The 7th RT Meeting strongly endorsed the Government’s “Fighting Poverty through Human Resource Development, Rural Development and People’s Participation”.
- Consultations broadened to include private sector development and Nam Theun 2.
- Consultation with international NGOs was extensive; many NGO proposals, especially on rural development, are reflected in the NGPES.
- A policy dialogue on governance addressed civil service reform, public sector management, central-local relations (decentralisation) and the rule of law.
- Discussions have been ongoing on agriculture/forestry, health, education and transport sectors.

### Institutional arrangements for coherence
- A Steering Committee composed of all key ministries and agencies was created, including: CPC, MOF, MOE, BOL, MOH, MOAF, MCTPC, STEA, National Statistics Centre, the Ethnic Minority Committee of the National Assembly and three mass organisations; members also include MIH, MOC and other cross-cutting agencies (STEA, Department of Public Administration and Civil Service, MOLSW and the Prime Minister’s Office).

### Ongoing nature and dissemination
- NGPES is “a work in progress” with a “rolling” character requiring constant updating and revision.
- Lao culture and tradition require continuous consultations after publication to ensure local adaptation and implementation.
- All NGPES priorities include participatory planning, implementation and monitoring.
- Capacity building for participatory planning is a top priority, with emphasis on local participation and planning manuals.
- Capacity building for the 47 poorest districts is essential so they can prepare district-wide development plans urgently.
- Once approved by the National Assembly, the Government will distribute the NGPES to all district and provincial offices and to all ministries and agencies at the central level.
- The English translation of the document will be made widely available to Lao PDR’s partners in development and other stakeholders; the Government will organise workshops, mostly at the local level, and sector workshops to develop familiarity and understanding.

### Monitoring and evaluation
- Monitoring and evaluation are integral elements of the NGPES and essential to effective and efficient implementation while maintaining the social, cultural and environmental character of the country and national unity and stability.
- Monitoring progress toward the Millennium Development Goals will provide the ultimate test for the NGPES’ success.

---

### Role of Mass Organisations

### Lao Women’s Union (planned activities once NGPES is endorsed)
- Disseminate the NGPES to LWU staff in 3 regions particularly within the 47 poorest districts using radio, television, newspaper and training.
- Assist establishment of poverty reduction funds by providing financial management skills training in the 47 poorest districts.
- Monitor and evaluate the mainstreaming of gender issues into social and economic sectors, including education, health, agriculture/forestry and infrastructure.
- Strengthen capacity of the LWU at the grassroots level through training workshops.
- Promote employment activities through training on food preparation and nutrition, transforming raw materials into finished products or goods for further processing.
- Promote health care knowledge, especially health care for women.

### Lao Front of National Construction (planned activities once NGPES is endorsed)
- Provide support to poor families to enable them to understand their environment, find coping strategies and help them climb out of poverty.
- Promote participation of all strata of society and all social organisations in poverty reduction throughout the country, especially in the 47 poorest districts, by providing examples of good experiences and encouraging investments that promote production and income-generating activities.
- Disseminate the NGPES to all strata of society and social organisations.

---

### Annex 1: Poverty-Related Information — Definition of Poverty Lines (methodology steps)
- Identify a household survey with reliable and detailed household expenditure data to determine the baseline year.
- Develop a reference food basket listing per capita expenditures on food items (including home-produced food) among low-income consumers.
- Convert expenditures to physical quantities by dividing expenditure on each food item by its price.
- Multiply physical quantities by calorie conversion factors to calculate total calories in the reference food basket.
- Compute cost per calorie by dividing total expenditure on the food basket by estimated number of calories; adjust for regional price differences using a spatial price index for food.
- Multiply estimated cost per calorie in each region by the minimum daily number of calories needed by an average person (e.g., 2,100) to estimate the “food poverty line” (daily or monthly).
- Estimate the cost of minimal non-food basic needs (clothing, housing, transportation, education and health care) as the “non-food allowance,” usually based on the non-food share of total consumption of persons near the food poverty line; recommend a single national non-food allowance adjusted for spatial and temporal price differences.
- The baseline period “poverty line” in each region is the sum of the food poverty line and the non-food allowance.

*Source: _cr04393 - 4. Transport and Communications (chapter excerpt) — Lao PDR National Growth and Poverty Eradication Strategy (NGPES).*

### 10. Poverty lines for other periods are obtained by adjusting the baseline period poverty line for food

### _cr04393 - 10. Poverty lines for other periods are obtained by adjusting the baseline period poverty line for food

### Poverty lines methodology
- Poverty lines for other periods are obtained by adjusting the baseline period poverty line for food and non-food price changes, using suitable price indexes.
- Some studies adjust the food poverty line for price changes but then obtain a new non-food allowance; this practice is not recommended because it violates the principle of applying a uniform national poverty standard to both periods.

### Causes of poverty by region and priority (Table 1.2) — key themes
- Recurring causes across North, Central, East, South regions include:
  - Livestock disease
  - Land allocation and shortened fallow cycles leading to soil depletion and environmental decline
  - Pests (insects, rats, birds, wild pigs) and crops destroyed by pests
  - Lack of credit and lack of roads to market produce
  - Insufficient land area for rice production; no paddy land or no land for rice production
  - Lack of irrigation and water supply
  - Poor health and inaccessible health facilities
  - Lack of technical knowledge and skills; lack of knowledge of market & commerce
  - Natural disasters: flooding and drought; UXOs (noted in southern entries)
  - Social issues: too many children, opium addiction, resettlement, out-migration of labour to cities or Thailand
- Specific local problems listed in various priorities include: theft of cattle/buffaloes, ban on opium production, no revolving funds to improve livelihood, no market for certain crops, lack of leadership, no village chief, and poor education.

### List of 72 poor districts by provinces — household poverty (Table 1.3) — highlights and totals
- Aggregate totals (bottom row):
  - Total population: 1,956,681
  - Of which women: 972,432
  - Total number of households: 318,877
  - Number of poor households: 160,592
  - Percentage of poor households: 50.4
  - Number of household poor by criteria:
    - Lack of rice: 93,917
    - lack of clothes: 41,333
    - Lack of shelter: 98,603
    - Insufficient to cover the cost of medical treatment: 58,446
    - Insufficient to cover the cost of children schooling cost: 58,803
  - Percentage of household poor by criteria:
    - Lack of rice: 58.5
    - lack of clothes: 25.7
    - Lack of shelter: 61.4
    - Insufficient to cover the cost of medical treatment: 36.4
    - Insufficient to cover the cost of children schooling cost: 36.6
- Selected district-level examples (preserve exact figures as listed):
  - Sanxay district (Attapeu): Total population 15,293; Of which women 7,899; Total number of households 2,589; Number of poor households 2,558; Percentage of poor households 98.8; Lack of rice 420; lack of clothes 480; Lack of shelter 580; Insufficient medical 590; Insufficient schooling 550; Percentages 16.4, 18.8, 22.7, 23.1, 21.5.
  - Kaleum district (Xekong): Total population 10,736; Of which women 5,650; Total number of households 1,673; Number of poor households 1,613; Percentage of poor households 96.4; Lack of rice 1,468; lack of clothes 290; Lack of shelter 565; Insufficient medical 1,129; Insufficient schooling 323; Percentages 91.0, 18.0, 35.0, 70.0, 20.0.
  - Ta oi district (Saravanh): Total population 20,662; Of which women 10,607; Total number of households 3,663; Number of poor households 3,042; Percentage of poor households 83.0; Lack of rice 3,042; lack of clothes 3,042; Lack of shelter 3,042; Insufficient medical 3,042; Insufficient schooling 3,042; Percentages 100, 100, 100, 100, 100.
- Many districts report extreme concentration of specific deprivations (examples shown above where one criterion equals the number of poor households, yielding 100 or near-100 percent values).

### List of 72 poor districts by provinces — poor village indicators (Table 1.4) — highlights and totals
- Aggregate totals (bottom row):
  - Total Villages: 5,382
  - Number of poor villages: 4,126
  - Percentage of Poor villages: 76.7
  - Number of villages by criteria:
    - Number of villages where percentage of HHs poor equal or bigger then 51%: 3,072
    - Number of villages without dispensaries, traditional medical practitioners or villages requiring over 6 hours of travel to reach a hospital: 2,106
    - Number of Villages without schools within the village or schools in nearby and accessible villages: 1,280
    - Number of Villages without safe water supply: 3,209
    - Number of Villages without access to roads (at least trails accessible by cart during the dry season): 2,225
  - Percentages of poor villages by criteria:
    - % of poor villages where percentage of HHs poor equal or bigger then 51%: 74.5
    - % of villages without dispensaries/... over 6 hours to hospital: 51.0
    - % of Villages without schools within the village or schools in nearby and accessible villages: 31.0
    - % of Villages without safe water supply: 77.8
    - % of Villages without access to roads: 53.9
- Selected district-level examples (preserve exact figures as listed):
  - Sanxay district (Attapeu): Total Villages 59; Number of poor villages 55; Percentage of Poor villages 93.2; Criteria counts: 55, 40, 45, 55, 55; Criteria percentages: 100.0, 72.7, 81.8, 100.0, 100.0.
  - Pakbeng district (Oudomxay): Total Villages 73; Number of poor villages 70; Percentage of Poor villages 95.9; Criteria counts: 80, 36, 26, 61, 57; Criteria percentages: 114.3, 51.4, 37.1, 87.1, 81.4.
  - Nong district (Savannakhet): Total Villages 80; Number of poor villages 75; Percentage of Poor villages 93.8; Criteria counts: 75, 75, 75, 75, 75; Criteria percentages: 100.0, 100.0, 100.0, 100.0, 100.0.
  - Moonlapamok district (Champasak): Total Villages 66; Number of poor villages 50; Percentage of Poor villages 75.8; Criteria counts: 27, na, na, na, na; Criteria percentages: na for several indicators (data not available in source table).

### Women’s and men’s perceptions of sources of vulnerability (Tables 1.5 & 1.6) — summary of commonly reported vulnerabilities
- Economic vulnerabilities frequently reported by both women and men across villages:
  - Shortage of rice; Low income; Lack of capital (including poor housing conditions); No sources to borrow money; Irregular income; Lack of employment; Debt; Too many children.
- Environmental vulnerabilities:
  - Flooding; Drought; Weather changes; Shortage of water; Unclean water; Crops destroyed by insects and animals; Poor soil quality; Livestock disease; Deforestation; UXO noted in some villages.
- Social vulnerabilities:
  - Low education; Low skills; Lack of opportunities for skills development; Lack of employment opportunities; Health problems; Low inter/intra-village communication; Resettlement; Weak village authority; Drug abuse; Problems with youth behaviour.
- Cultural vulnerabilities:
  - Theft; Prostitution; Conflict with spouse; Loss of tradition.
- Note: Tables indicate presence of vulnerability items by village using markers (preserve village-specific markers in source); notes indicate wild animals and cattle included under animals, and poor housing conditions included under lack of capital.

### Coping strategies — women’s perceptions (Table 1.7) — reported actions
- Short-term and longer-term coping strategies reported by women across sampled villages include:
  - Reduce expenses; Suspend birth giving (listed as an item in the table); Grow other crops; Raise/sell livestock/poultry; Rely on off-season farming; Gardening; Handicrafts; Exchange products; Coordinate with neighbours/villagers; Learn from friends/relatives; Run business; Vending; Make alcohol; Fishing.
  - Health and production actions: Vaccinate animals; Go to hospital; Take medicine; Try to dig well; Use water pump; Use natural fertiliser; Try to live healthily.
  - Education and social actions: Encourage children to study; Educate children on discipline, drugs, etc.; Decrease vulnerability in short & long terms; Request help from authorities.
- Source and timing: CPC/UNCRD, April 2002 (as cited in the tables).

*Source: National Statistical Center, Poverty Statistical Reports, Provincial Committees/Authorities as of March 2003; CPC/UNCRD, April 2002*

### 1.           The           symbol

### _cr04393 - 1.           The           symbol

### Coping strategies — men's perception (summary of Table 1.8)
- The symbol is used where help from authorities was requested by villagers. The extent of government response is not known; therefore this factor is placed under coping strategies 1, 2, and 3.
- “Raise livestock/poultry” was placed under Coping Strategies 1 and 2 because it is not clear whether buffaloes are included or not in the villagers’ definition of animals.
- Boxes for both women and men are shaded where a similar number of women and men use the same coping strategies.
- Examples of coping strategies reported in Table 1.8 (men’s perception) include:
  - Suspend birth giving
  - Reduce expenses
  - Grow other crops
  - Raise/sell livestock/poultry
  - Rely on off-season farming
  - Gardening
  - Handicrafts
  - Exchange products
  - Co-ordinate with neighbours/villagers
  - Learn from friends/relatives
  - Run business
  - Vending
  - Make alcohol
  - Fishing
  - Vaccinate animals
  - Go to hospital
  - Take medicine
  - Use water pump
  - Try to dig well
  - Try to live healthily
  - Use natural fertiliser
  - Encourage children to study
  - Educate children on discipline, drugs, etc.
- COPING STRATEGIES 1: Decrease vulnerability in short & long terms; Request help from authorities.
- Source attribution in table: CPC/UNCRD, April 2002.

*Notes from Table 1.8*
- Reiteration: The symbol is used where help from authorities was requested by villagers; extent of government response unknown; factor placed under coping strategies 1, 2, and 3.
- Reiteration: “Raise livestock/poultry” placed under Coping Strategies 1 and 2 because inclusion of buffaloes is unclear.
- Reiteration: Boxes for both women and men are shaded where a similar number of women and men use the same coping strategies.

### National Development Framework: Targets and main performance indicators (Table 2.1)
- Priority development targets and performance indicators (selected items and numerical targets, time frame 2003–2005 and 2005):
  - Overall poverty incidence declines (from 38.6%) to <25 % — 2005
  - Poverty incidence in Northern region declines (from 52.5%) to 35% — 2005
  - Life expectancy increases (from 59 years) to 63 years — 2005
  - No of rural villages with access to clean water raises to 60 % (from 45%) — 2005
  - Under 5 child mortality declines (from 106) to 82 / 1000 — 2005
  - Maternal mortality declines (from 530) to 350 / 1000 — 2005
  - 80 % of rural districts linked with all-weather roads to provincial capital — 2005
  - 60 % of rural villages with access to power (from 35%) — 2005
  - Public spending on rural infrastructure increases by 2%/year in real terms — Annual
  - Village funds extend to cover all 46 districts — 2004
  - Reduce unsustainable shifting cultivation to less then 30 per cent — 2005
  - Eliminate poverty-related opium production — 2005
  - Education expenditure will raise to 15 % of total budget — 2005
  - Net overall primary enrolment increased (from 77 %) to 85 % — 2005
  - Proportion of female/primary enrolment > 45 % — 2005
  - Proportion of female/lower secondary enrolment >40 % — 2005
  - Overall adult literacy increases (from 74 %) to 80% — 2005
  - Female adult literacy increases (from 60%) to 65% — 2005
  - Health expenditure will raise to 10% of total budget — 2005
  - Average annual growth of 6-7 per cent — Annual (target)
  - Annual inflation less than 10 per cent — Annual (target)
  - Revenues increase (from 12.8 %) to 14-15 % — 2005
  - Budget deficit reduced to <4.5-5% of GDP — 2005
  - Annual export growth rate at 10 % — 2005 (target)
  - Agriculture output growth steady at 4.0% year; industry growth rate increasing to 10%/2005; services sector growth increasing to 9%/2005 — 2005
  - Overall investment ratio to GDP attains 34-35 per cent, with public investment at 12-13 percent and private investment at 22-23 per cent — 2005
  - Government saving increased to 4-5 per cent of GDP — 2005

### Main economic and financial indicators of Lao PDR (1992–2002 actual; 2003–2005 projections) — selected figures from Table 2.2
- 1. Total GDP Growth (%): 1992: 7.0; 1993: 5.9; 1994: 7.7; 1995: 7.5; 1996: 6.9; 1997: 6.9; 1998: 4.0; 1999: 7.3; 2000: 5.8; 2001: 5.8; 2002: 5.9; 2003: 5.8; 2004: 6.5; 2005: 7.0
- Sectoral growth/share examples (selected entries as presented):
  - Agriculture examples: 8.3/58.0; 8.3/56.6; 3.1/54.3; 2.8/52.2; 7/52.2; 3.1/51.8; 8.2/52.2; 4.9/51.8; 3.8/50.8; 4.0/49.9; 2.2/48; 3.5/47.2; 4.5/47.3
  - Industry examples: 7.5/16.7; 10.3/17.4; 10.7/17.8; 13.1/18.8; 17.3/20.6; 8.1/20.8; 9.2/21.9; 8/22.0; 8.5/22.6; 9.7/23.4; 10.1/24.5; 11.5/26; 11.4/26.6; 10/25.2
  - Services examples: 3.9/25.3; 7.7/26.3; 3.9/25.6; 12.0/26.9; 8.5/27.2; 7.5/27; 5.5/26.3; 6.7/25.8; 4.9/25.5; 5.7/25.8; 5.7/25.0; 7.5/25; 7.4/26.2; 9/27.5
- 2. GDP at constant prices ( billion of kip): 1992: 681.80; 1993: 721.84; 1994: 777.72; 1995: 835.69; 1996: 893.26; 1997: 955.01; 1998: 993.16; 1999: 1,065.45; 2000: 1,127.1; 2001: 1,192.1; 2002: 1,262; 2003: 1,335; 2004: 1,421; 2005: 1,520
- 3. GDP at current prices ( billion of kip): 1992: 844.35; 1993: 953.29; 1994: 1,107.75; 1995: 1,430.36; 1996: 1,725.69; 1997: 2,200.71; 1998: 4,240.20; 1999: 10,328.60; 2000: 13,669.5; 2001: 15,701.8; 2002: 18,390.4; 2003: 22,536.1; 2004: 24,616; 2005: 25,695
  - GDP in million of Dollar (selected rows): 1992: 1,179.26; 1993: 1,329.55; 1994: 1,542.83; 1995: 1,747.54; 1996: 1,863.60; 1997: 1,746.60; 1998: 1,286.47; 1999: 1,453.50; 2000: 1,742.4; 2001: 1,770.0; 2002: 1,819.2; 2003: 2,132.7; 2004: 2,333.2; 2005: 2,335.9
- 4. Inflation ( average annual rate ) (%): 1992: 9.9; 1993: 6.3; 1994: 6.8; 1998: 14.35; 1999: 18.8; 2000: 14.2; 2001: 61.38; 2002: 128.4; 2003: 23.1; 2004: 7.84; 2005: 10.7; projection entries: 15.6; 12.6; 12.0 (as presented)
- 5. Growth of money supply - M2 ( % ): 1992: 49; 1993: 64.59; 1994: 31.9; 1995: 16.43; selected later entries: 26.76; 65.76; 113.3; 78.36; 45.53; 20.06; 26.8; 18.0; 18.0; 18.0 (as presented)
- 6. Exchange rate ( Kip/ one of US Dollar): 1992: 716; 1993: 717; 1994: 718; 1995: 819; 1996: 926; 1997: 1,260; 1998: 3,296; 1999: 7,106; 2000: 7,846; 2001: 8,871; 2002: 10.109; 2003: 10,567; 2004: 10,551; 2005: 11,000
- 7. Total government revenue ( Billion of Kip): 1992: 130.5; 1993: 156.0; 1994: 208.7; 1995: 241.1; 1996: 283.7; 1997: 334.9; 1998: 822.9; 1999: 1,403.3; 2000: 2,484.9; 2001: 2,317.1; 2002: 2,858.3; 2003: 3,121.4; 2004: 3,743.0; 2005: 4,415.0
  - excluding grant row: 1992: 90.5; 1993: 117.8; 1994: 140.5; 1995: 171.1; 1996: 223.1; 1997: 237.9; 1998: 442.8; 1999: 1,071.8; 2000: 1,729.0; 2001: 2,011.0; 2002: 2,270.5; 2003: 2,671.4; 2004: 3,273.0; 2005: 3,915.0
- 8. Total government expenditure (Billion of kip): 1992: 175.0; 1993: 188.6; 1994: 266.0; 1995: 310.1; 1996: 374.7; 1997: 463.1; 1998: 1,145.7; 1999: 1,708.7; 2000: 3,016.2; 2001: 3,054.6; 2002: 3,748.7; 2003: 4,336.2; 2004: 4,827.3; 2005: 5,616.0
  - current expenditure (Billion of Kip) examples: 1992: 93; 1993: 130.2; 1994: 147.6; 1995: 166.4; 1996: 172.7; 1997: 199.5; 1998: 299.1; 1999: 541.4; 2000: 1,094.8; 2001: 1,295.6; 2002: 1,419.3; 2003: 1,755.3; 2004: 2,144.1; 2005: 2,800.0
- 9. Overall budget deficit ( As % of GDP): 1992: -0.6; 1993: -3.8; 1994: -5.2; 1995: -4.8; 1996: -5.3; 1997: -5.8; 1998: -7.6; 1999: -3; 2000: -3.9; 2001: -4.7; 2002: -4.9; 2003: (5.9); 2004: (4.7); 2005: (4.7)
  - Deficit excluding grant ( As % of GDP) entries include: -1.0; -8.3; -11.3; -9.7; -8.8; -10.2; -16.6; -6.2; -9.4; -6.7; -8.1; (8.1); (6.8); (6.6) (as presented)
- 10. Total value of exports ( Million of US $): 1992: 133; 1993: 240.5; 1994: 300.4; 1995: 307.6; 1999: 317.2; 2000: 312.7; 2001: 336.8; 2002: 301.5; 2003: 330.3; 2004: 311.1; 2005 projections: 306.6; 359.3; 347.0; 370.0 (as presented)
- 11. Total value of imports ( Million of US $): 1992: 165; 1993: 265.6; 1994: 431.9; 1995: 564.1; 1999: 588.8; 2000: 689.6; 2001: 647.9; 2002: 552.8; 2003: 535.3; 2004: 523.1; projections: 446.9; 482.0; 571.0; 600.0 (as presented)
- 12. Current account balance ( Million of US $ ): 1992: -52; 1993: -41.2; 1994: -96.7; 1995: -132.8; later entries: -229.6; -177.6; -33.6; -75.7; -8.5; -78.6; -41.5; (33.3); (30.4); (17.7) (as presented)
  - Deficit as % of GDP examples: (4.41); (3.10); (6.27); (7.60); (12.32); (10.17); (2.61); (5.21); (0.49); (4.45); (2.29); (1.63); (1.40); (0.76)
- 13. Official gross reserves ( in months/ imports): 1992: 2; 1993: 2; 1994: 2; 1995: 3; 1996: 2; 1997: 2; 1998: 3; 1999: 2.3; 2000: 3.2; 2001: 3.9; 2002: 5.7; 2003: 4.8; 2004: 5.2; 2005: 5.3
- 14. National savings ( as % of GDP ): selected entries include n.a; later values: 19.4; 17.0; 18.1; 20.1; 21.9; 22.5
  - Government savings (as% of GDP) examples: -0.3; -1.5; -0.6; 0.3; 2.9; 1.7; 3.4; 5.1; 4.6; 4.6; 4.7; 4.5; 4.1; 4.3
- 15. Total Investment ( Billion of kip): selected entries: n.a; 2,857.30; 3,275.03; 3,706.67; 4,581.2; 6,472.5; 8,916.2
  - Government-PIP ( Billion of Kip) selected: 86.0; 101.9; 118.0; 166.1; 205.5; 248.7; 290.5; 1,295.1; 1,914.0; 2,115.4; 2,136.4; 2,610.0; 2,918.9; 3,289.0
  - Government-PIP as % of GDP examples: 10.2; 10.7; 10.7; 11.6; 11.9; 11.3; 6.9; 12.5; 14.0; 13.5; 11.7; 12.3; 12.5; 12.8
  - Private ( Billion of Kip) examples: 943; 1,160; 1,570; 2,066; 3,614; 5,627
  - Private as % of GDP examples: 6.9; 7.4; 8.6; 10.1; 15.8; 21.9
- 16. Total FDI approved ( Million of US $ ): 1992: 335.1; 1993: 347.8; 1994: 2,598.3; 1995: 804.9; 1996: 1,292.65; selected later entries: 138.78; 122.3; 116.8; 20.4; 42; 493.8; 550.0; 500.0; 500.0
  - Real FDI inflow through Bank ( Million of US $ ) examples: 7.8; 35.8; 59.2; 88.4; 128; 86.3; 45.3; 51.6; 6.3; 2.6; 24.3; 48.7; n.a.; n.a.
- 17. ODA ( Million of US Dollar): selected entries: n.a; 416.6; 370.9; 240; 354.5; 331.45; 385.7; 378.4; 438.7; 428.1; 440.9
  - Of which: grants examples: n.a; 241.3; 200.4; 148.3; 252.2; 227.8; 285.2; 236.3; 213.9; 256.0; 263.7
- 18. Total foreign debt service ( M $US ): 9.6; 9.4; 9; 13.3; 15.5; 19; 21.3; 28.4; 28.8; 34.9; 37.4; 37.5; 38.5; 37.0 (as presented)
- 19. Population ( 1000’.persons ): 1992: 4,360; 1993: 4,474; 1994: 4,591; 1995: 4,605; 1996: 4,723; 1997: 4,847; 1998: 4,975; 1999: 5,108; 2000: 5,245; 2001: 5,380; 2002: 5,520; 2003: 5,660; 2004: 5,800; 2005: 5,940
- 20. GDP per capita (US $ / person ): 1992: 270.47; 1993: 297.17; 1994: 336.06; 1995: 379.49; 1996: 394.58; 1997: 360.35; 1998: 258.59; 1999: 284.55; 2000: 332.21; 2001: 328.33; 2002: 328.81; 2003: 375.5; 2004: 385.55; 2005: 393.25

Notes appended to Table 2.2:
- 1/. Updated data provided by NSC, MoF, BoL, CPC annual and 5-year socio-economic reports
- 2/ Projections of main indicators are according to Government’s commitment to PRGF proposal report. These consist of real and nominal GDP, inflation targets, savings and investments (with some adjustments)

### Policy matrix for revenue collection (Table 2.3) — selected objectives and measures
- Objectives / targets:
  - Ensure fiscal stability and budget healthy through the control of inflation single digit level.
  - Increase revenue by 14 to 16% of GDP (increase on average by 0.5 –1% annually). In FY 2004/2005, revenue must be not less than 15% of GDP. (Based on Baseline Scenario)
  - Reducing fiscal deficit by 0.5 to 1% of GDP annually.
  - Centrally and strictly manage foreign exchange revenue; ensure that foreign reserve is strengthened; strictly implement national saving policy in all areas, in order to gradually eradicate unnecessary subsidies and reduction of fiscal deficit in accordance with the target.
  - Stop or cancel direct policy lending.
  - Stop or reduce accumulated debt of state-owned enterprises (SOEs).
  - Stop the continuous credit to inefficient SOEs.
  - Prepare the Medium Term Expenditure Framework including demand for foreign financing.
  - Mobilise all resources to ensure the requirement of total expenditure and poverty eradication.
  - Improve fiscal policy in line with creating favourable condition for economic growth; actively enhance commercial production to provide basis for labour, goods and money market expansion.
  - Improve fiscal and credit regulation to enhance and facilitate the expansion of sound economic activities of medium and small-scale enterprises.
- Measures (strategies) listed:
  - Reapply 5 % for turnover tax on petroleum products (as stated in Tax Law)
  - Increase excise duties on luxury goods
  - Study exemptions in order to reduce them
  - Start improvement of custom-tax management and administration including LTUs, and reduce exception range.
  - Continue collection of lose loans.
  - Continue to implement a decentralisation policy accordingly to Decree 192/P.M

*Source: CPC/UNCRD, April 2002; tables and text as presented in the document.*

### Introduction VAT to supersede turnover tax

### Introduction VAT to supersede turnover tax

### Policy objective and macro-fiscal targets
- Immediate actions planned; implementation status entries include: Immediate, Under way, On-going, FY 2002/03-2004/05, 2005-2006, 2006-2007.
- Target: Capacity of revenue from tax increasing 1.5% of GDP yearly.
- From now to 2005, recurrent expenditure in total public expenditure framework will be 49% and investment spending will be 51%.
- Increase saving to GDP from 4% in FY 2000/2001 to 6-7% in FY 2004/2005, or increase by 0.5%-1% on average each year, in order to achieve investment from public saving at 6-7% of GDP in the end of this 5 year budgeting plan.
- Requirement: mobilise external fund of 5-6% of GDP in order to totalise public investment at the level of 12% -13% of GDP.

### Socio-economic and sectoral objectives
- Ensure continuous socio-economic growth; improve economic structure in accordance with sectors—agriculture, industry/handicraft and service; facilitate those sectors to be flexibly active to achieve the 5 year socio-economic development target.
- Solve vague debt, particularly debt occurred between the budget and the bank, between the budget and enterprises, and treasury’s debt.
- Ensure appropriate spending structure covering salary payment, bonus payment for official staffs, solders, polices, recurrent expenditure, maintenance cost of equipment and government assets, expenditure on national defense, cultural and social expenditure, and appropriate public investment.
- Arrange a reasonable investment structure in each sector, region and economic sector to rapidly increase investment efficiency; upgrade productivity, quality and efficiency in production; strengthen competitiveness of Lao products in domestic, regional and global market.
- Develop fiscal policy consistent with enhancement and protection of production, closely related to poverty reduction, and create social balance.
- Create a reasonable expenditure policy (including production and individual expenditure) to ensure promotion of production in accordance with economic capacity in each period; strictly economise spending to increase saving.
- Maintain relationship with foreign countries and increase international economic co-operation for regional integration and mobilisation of fund, technology and management skill on a self mastery, self dependent and self strengthening basis.
- Promote foreign direct investment; increase management and mobilisation of foreign grant.
- Develop information system; use advanced technology to ensure effective collection of budget revenue and create transparency in budgeting sector.

### Key monitoring indicators and reporting frequencies
- Change in Consumer Price Index: -
- Percentage of Revenue, expenditure and fiscal Deficit to GDP: -
- Debt service Ratio: -
- Change in sectoral investment to GDP: -
- Increase in saving to GDP: -
- Number of prioritised projects: -
- Successfulness of business operation: -
- Reporting frequencies listed: Monthly; Quarterly; Every 6 months; Annually.
- Reporting and implementation agencies include: National Audit Agency; Budget Department; Fiscal Policy Department; Tax Department; Treasury Department; Investment Department; The Committee for Planning and Cooperation.

### Matrix of Action Plan for Improving Public Expenditure Management — Overview
- Policy Area: Enhance the role of the National Treasury to more effectively record revenues, expenditures, and bank and non-bank financing of the budget.
- Components: A. Regulation and procedure; B. Fiscal Reporting; C. Government Banking; D. Arrears.
- Reporting agencies: Treasury Department; All provinces; Ministry of Finance/BOL; Budget Department; Accounting Department; Audit and Control; State Authority (SAA); National Assembly.

### Regulation, procedures and fiscal reporting — planned measures and timetable
- Decide/clarify on key strategic issues in the design of the Treasury system and the role of commitment controls. (Short term technical assistance could facilitate discussion of the option).
- Complete draft of treasury Regulations and manual of procedures, consistent with the agreed detailed approach to treasury reform. (Peripatetic technical assistance may be required).
- Integrate the treasury and Accounting Regulations in a single set of regulations, while resolving inconsistencies with various accounting regulations, based on board guidelines and subsequent experience. (Technical assistance may be required).
- Integrate Treasury staff engaged within the Ministry of Finance, to be accountable to the head of the central Treasury, especially regarding central government bank accounts; have the central Treasury provide management services for treasury operations in provinces and districts where appropriate.
- Timetable entries include: 2003; 2004; 2004-2005; 2005-2006.
- Monitoring indicators and reporting frequency: Ministerial order issued; Monthly reporting; Annual reporting.

### Fiscal data transmission and monthly reporting targets
- Every district to transmit data on revenue, expenditure and treasury balances to provinces within 10 days after month-end (with a longer time frame, such as 15 days, for specified remote districts), to enable provinces to produce consolidated monthly reports and transmit them to the central treasury within 15-20 days after month-end, to allow the production of a preliminary consolidated fiscal report, fully reconciled with banking data, within 25-30 days after the end of each month. (Training of district staff needed.)
- Close monthly accounts at end-month uniformly for all levels of the government, instead of closing them in some districts on the 20PthP of the month. (Substantial training required.)
- Identify all extrabudgetary funds and require financial reporting and accounting similar to that required for the budget (e.g for the Road Fund, the Environmental Fund, the Unexploded Ordinance Fund, and Poverty Fund).
- Timetable entries: 2003; 2003-2004; 2004-2005.
- Reporting: Monthly; Annual. Reporting agencies: Treasury Department; All provinces.

### Government banking and arrears — measures and timelines
- Publish the budgets of all extrabudgetary funds at the same time as the annual budget plan. Progressively integrate into the budget framework all retained revenues and their corresponding expenditures.
- Introduce a register of all government accounts operated with the authority of the Ministry of Finance. Update the register of government bank accounts as new accounts are opened and old accounts are closed.
- Continue process of closing bank accounts established without treasury authorisation.
- Minimise delays in provincial transfers of central government revenues by establishing central government bank accounts at commercial banks located in large revenue centres without BOL branches, and promptly sweep those balances into BOL accounts.
- Establish a system of daily consolidation of data on key treasury bank balances.
- Consolidate government bank accounts for each of government.
- Link all treasury accounts (with adequate communications links) into a single network of treasury accounts. (Technical assistance may be required.)
- Arrears actions:
  - Complete a census/survey of expenditure arrears as at September 30, covering all types of expenditure nationwide, including all enterprises’ balances with the treasury.
  - Formulate a time bound action plan to (1) clear arrears accumulated up until September 30 (including revenue sources); and (2) ensure that no new arrears are accumulated.
  - Monitor accounts payable, enterprises’ balances at the treasury, and other arrears on a monthly basis.
  - Gradually eliminate the stock of arrears revealed in the census; this could be partly achieved through issuance of treasury paper.
  - Update the census of expenditure as of September including any new arrears accumulated during fiscal years.
- Timetable entries include: 2002-2003; 2003; 2003-2004; 2003-2005; 2004-2005.
- Status indicators noted: Register completed in March 2003; Bank accounts closed by Sept.; Reports being reviewed.
- Reporting agencies: Treasury Department of MOF/BOL; Treasury/Budget Departments.

### Accounting, budget classification and computerisation
- Continue improvements in the accounting system by extending the nomenclature system and applying these systems as computerisation continues.
- Budget classification measures:
  - Revise the budget classification for expenditures to: (1) simplify the present classification by type of expenditure; (2) identify administrative units within ministries; and (3) introduce a level of government classification (central, provincial, and district).
  - Harmonise the accounting codes with the proposed revised budget nomenclature.
  - Utilise the classification of expenditure by administrative units in the education and health sectors. (Technical assistance may be required.)
  - Extend use of revised classification to other sectors in line with computerisation. (Technical assistance may be required.)
  - Adopt a multi-module budget and accounting classification system in line with the computerisation of all central ministries’ and provinces’ budgets, and budget execution systems. In particular, introduce the functional classification of expenditure (as defined in the IMF’s GFS Manual) and “cost centres.”
  - Introduce a single system of coding for budgeting and accounting to be used in the computerised system being developed.
- Timetable entries: 2003; 2003-2004; 2004-2005; 2005-2006.
- Reporting agency: Accounting Department.

### Budget preparation, commitment controls and internal audit
- Revise budget preparation procedure to bring forward the budget preparation cycle to provide a more specific expenditure framework early in the fiscal year.
- Review commitment controls for effectiveness and efficiency.
- Clarify various regulation and instructions on expenditure control, especially on pre-disbursement controls (including on commitment) and its degree of centralisation in conjunction with line ministries and provinces.
- Experiment with streamlining expenditure controls by the Budget and the External Financial Relations Departments for selected line ministries and provinces, while preserving overall fiscal management.
- Audit and control actions:
  - Transmit to the State Authority (SAA) the budget outcome.
  - The SAA to report to the National Assembly on the consolidated fiscal account.
  - Review the role and responsibilities of various internal control and audit agencies in the MOF, the Prime Minister’s Office, and in spending ministries.

_Italic: Excerpt from _cr04393 - Introduction VAT to supersede turnover tax_ (source PDF content)._

### 4. Rationalize the various inspecti

### 4. Rationalize the various inspection and internal audit agencies.

### Financial sector: Consolidated Matrix regarding policy priorities (Table 2.5)
- Policy Area: Bank Credit Allocation
  - Objectives/Targets:
    - Control of domestic asset net through managing money supply indicated as M2/GDP. M2 growth should not be increased by 18% in annual average
    - Credit should not increase more than 21% as an annual average.
    - Induced credit culture by ensuring that formal governance structure are applies
    - Ensure greater access to financing by creditworthy private sector borrowers
  - Measures (Strategies, Policies):
    - Implementation of multi policy measures by using more indirect instrument ( open market, reserve requirement, credit ceiling )
    - All Credits allocation to meet commercial basis to support
    - Use an appropriate interest rate according to the money demand and supply
    - Improved Credit Risk management and commercial analysis for credit generation
    - Improved financial disclosure by borrowers
  - Planned Timetable:
    - 2003-2005
    - 2003-2005
  - Monitoring indicators:
    - Percentage change of M2 and M2/GDP
    - Change of reserve requirement rate
    - Volume and value of Bonds issued
    - Growth of credit for 2003 will be limited to 18%
    - Interest rate monitoring report
  - Reporting frequency / Reporting agency:
    - Monthly, quarterly and annual report on Monetary survey and BOL official report
    - Monthly, quarterly an annual report on Interest rate monitoring statistics report, Monetary survey, supervision report
    - Quarterly — BoL and IFIs review mission report
    - Quarterly — BoL, MOF , SOCB and IFIs review mission report
    - BOL prudential Supervision reports and compliance on asset quality and risk management by on site and off- site audits. Financial reports and audited accounts.

- Policy Area: Exchange rate policy / Banking Sector Reform programme
  - Objectives/Targets:
    - Floating managed exchange rate
    - Provide for an efficient financial intermediation and sound banking system to support economic growth and extend banking services and outreach;
    - Improvement the commercial environment for all financial institutions;
    - Consolidation of SOCBs and undertake operational restructuring to improvement performance
    - More effective banking environment, improvement competition
  - Measures:
    - The exchange rate determined by daily interbank rate market mechanism
    - To limit the gap between Bank and parallel market rate under 2 per cent
    - BoL will intervene when its necessary
    - Promotion and used Lao kip as a main instrument for domestic transaction
    - SOCB undertake operational restructuring against performance targets , reduce NPL through collection and effective resolution process;
    - Improve Governance – appointment or boards and board committee and board to institute controls , prudent management and operational improvements
    - Financial restructuring (recapitalization) is to be phased subject to meeting governance and operational improvements
    - Reduce NPL situation, through a disciplined credit risk management, collection and by improving creditor-debtor informal arrangements.
    - The reduction of three SOCBs to two
    - Shrinking of SOCBs’ balance sheet
    - Strengthening asset quality
    - Improvement financial disclosure by private sector firms;
    - Better spread of banking business and exposure
    - Expansion of private banks’ and foreign banks’ branches outside of Vientiane
  - Planned Timetable:
    - 2003-2005
    - 2003-2005
    - 2003-2005
  - Monitoring indicators:
    - Nominal exchange rate change and level of fluctuation
    - Increase of months for reserved import
    - Number of NPL cases resolved through court system courts and informal resolution
    - Appointed of new board , and higher oversight by BOL
    - Signed Governance agreement
    - Performance targets under the governance agreement
    - Cash collection and reduction of NPL ratio
    - Governance Agreement
    - Reduction of NPL ratio and improvement of SOCB’s balance sheet
    - SOCB and BOL reports
  - Reporting frequency / Reporting agency:
    - Daily, Weekly, and Monthly — Commercial Banks and BoL
    - Quarterly and Annually — SOCB, MOJ
    - Quarterly — BOL
    - Quarterly — MOF, BOL< SOCB
    - Quarterly — MOF, BOL & SOCB
    - Yearly — MOJ, BOL
    - Quarterly — MoF and BoL; BOL, SOCBs; SOCB and BOL; BOL and SOCB; MOJ , BOL SOCB

- Policy Area: Financial Services for Rural and Micro-finance for poverty reduction
  - Objectives/Targets:
    - Diversify financial services into grassroots through establishing micro-credit institutions
    - Restructuring APB aims to enable management autonomy, market orientation and self-sustainable under an appropriate prudential regulation framework
    - Strengthening of prudential regulation and oversight
    - Strengthening of legal environment and judicial enforcement and oversight.
  - Measures:
    - Prepare a vision statement for the rural and microfinance sector; identify impediments to sustainable, market-oriented rural and micro-finance
    - Prepare a strategy and a corresponding action plan for micro-finance
    - BOL to license three commercially oriented member-owned pilot savings and credit unions ( SCUs)
    - Prepare legal and regulatory framework
    - Diagnostic review, financial audit, corporate vision and operational restructuring plan consistent with the corporate vision for APB.
    - APB will phase out policy lending from policy lending
  - Planned Timetable:
    - 2003-2005
    - 2003-2005
    - 2003-2004
  - Monitoring indicators:
    - BOL and SOCB reports
    - Court cases, MOJ reports
    - Increase proportion of rural people with access to formal financial services
    - Adopted and implemented regulatory framework for microfinance institutions and enhance SCU regulation based participatory process
    - Adopted vision by Prime Minister
    - All necessary instruction to allow APB freeing set interest rate on loans and deposits to be subject to commercial criteria
  - Reporting frequency / Reporting agency:
    - Quarterly — BoL and IMF TA
    - Yearly — MOJ and BOL
    - According to Bank reform framework and output result — BOL MOF
    - Quarterly reports — BOL , MOF

### Governance Programme: Main Priority Initiatives 2003-2010 (Table 2.6)

- Component 1: Public Service Improvements
  - Strategic objective:
    - Development of a cost-effective and people’s centered public administration and development of a productive, highly motivated, professional and ethical public service;
  - Expected outcomes:
    - Staff attitudes shifted from compliance into commitment to citizen’s satisfaction
    - Personnel expenditures reduced and under control, more rational and efficient use of CS human resource
    - Enhanced motivation, involvement and productivity of civil servants
    - Promotion of examples of good customer service, creativity and innovation in the CS
    - Reduced corruption and more honest, transparent and accountable the Civil Service
    - Development of the civil service ethos and civil servant involvement in high quality governance
    - Implementation of citizens’ right to complain
  - Priority initiatives, outputs, timelines and agencies (selected):
    - Approval of the Law on Local Administration and review of laws, decrees and regulations on the organization and functioning of the government
      - Outputs: Law on Local Administration adopted; Laws and regulations on the organization of the government revised
      - Indicative time table: 2003-2004
      - Responsible: DPACS, MoJ, all ministries
    - Functional reviews and process improvements
      - Outputs: Missions, objectives, functions, structures and processes of pilot offices and organizations revised and their needs of HR assessed
      - Indicative time table: ST (2003) ST (2004)
      - Responsible: DPACS and organizations concerned
    - Civil service rightsizing & redeployment (from central to local levels) and accompanying measures
      - Outputs: Number of civil servants reduced about 5%
      - Indicative time table: 2005
      - Responsible: DPACS and all O&P Dep.
    - Establish service standards, and ensure broader public access to the government organizations’ performance reports
      - Outputs: Service standards for selected service delivering offices
      - Timetable: M&LT
      - Responsible: As above
    - Publication of manuals and information brochures on organization and mandates
      - Outputs: Manuals, brochures and directories of services published and disseminated
      - Timetable: S&MT
      - Responsible: As above
    - Development of more service oriented public servant training programs
      - Outputs: Revised training programs
      - Timetable: 2004
      - Responsible: DPACS and NOSPA
    - Implementation of the new salary scale
      - Outputs: New salary scale adopted and implemented
      - Timetable: MT
      - Responsible: MOF (DB) & DPACS
    - Upgrading PM anticorruption decree to the level of Law
      - Outputs: Draft anticorruption Law
      - Timetable: MT
      - Responsible: MOJ, PMC
    - Improve the system of handling grievances and procedures protecting whistleblowers
      - Outputs: Department of Public Grievances of the State Inspection Authority created and operational
      - Timetable: S&MT
      - Responsible: SIA

- Component 2: People’s Participation
  - Strategic objective:
    - Promoting a dynamic, more open, transparent and participatory society
  - Expected outcomes:
    - Legal framework facilitating further development of the CSA
    - Increased participation of women in national and local governance
    - Increased opportunities for Lao youth to express their concerns, expectations and ideas
    - Increased citizen knowledge of government policies and programs
    - Greater public awareness of critical social and economic issues
    - Public administration more transparent, accessible and understandable for public
  - Priority initiatives (selected), outputs, timelines, responsible agencies:
    - Development of legal framework for civil society associations (CSA)
      - Outputs: Transparent rules for approval and cooperation with civil society associations
      - Timetable: MT
      - Responsible: MOJ, National Assembly
    - Development and implementation of Gender Mainstreaming Strategy
      - Outputs: Gender Mainstreaming Strategy adopted; Seminars for government officials
      - Timetable: ST S&MT
      - Responsible: Lao Women’s Union
    - Regulations opening access to information on public administration activities for the public
      - Outputs: PM decree drafted and adopted
      - Timetable: M-LT
      - Responsible: PMO
    - Increase availability and dissemination of laws and regulations, government policies and programs
      - Outputs: Regularly updated legal data base in the Internet website informing about government policies
      - Timetable: ST M&LT
      - Responsible: POM, MÓJ
    - Establishment of “Information Centers” for the public in district administration office
      - Outputs: Information Centers progressively established, equipped, staffed and operating
      - Timetable: M&LT
      - Responsible: MIC

  - Strategic objective: Redefining central-local relations – bringing services closer to the people
    - Selected initiatives and outputs:
      - Develop capacity of provincial level as strategic unit responsible for macro-management at local levels
        - Outputs: Functional and organizational reviews, process re-engineering, staffing plans and job descriptions, process and job oriented training
        - Timetable: S&MT
        - Responsible: CPC, DPACS, Governors
      - Transform district with high economic potential into separate budgetary units
        - Outputs: Identification and classification of the districts with high economic potential, definition of the legal framework and progressive implementation
        - Timetable: M&LT
        - Responsible: MOF, DPACS, concerned governors
      - Develop districts’ capacity as main level of development project implementation
        - Outputs: Development of Guidelines for Planning and Management of Development Project
        - Timetable: M&LT
        - Responsible: Provincial authorities, DPACS, CPC
      - Promote development of kum ban and project planning and implementation on kum ban level
        - Outputs: Kum Ban promoted and developed, guidelines for selection of villages in view to create kum ban
        - Timetable: S&MT PA
        - Responsible: CPC
      - Develop legal framework for farther development of Local Administration and creation of municipalities
        - Outputs: Law on Local Administration adopted; Instruction 01/PM reviewed and upgraded as decree; Municipal Law drafted and approved
        - Timetable: 2003-4
        - Responsible: National Assembly, CPC, DPACS, MOF & MOJ

- Component 3: Rule of Law and Access to Justice
  - Strategic objective 1:
    - Establishment of a complete, clear and coherent legal framework, ensuring predictable and transparent mechanisms for legal enforcement
  - Expected outcomes:
    - Increased public awareness of laws and the role of the legal sector
    - Increased transparency in court decisions
    - Better qualified judges giving consistent and transparent decisions
    - Improve effectiveness and efficiency of courts
    - Increased awareness of laws among the population at large
  - Priority initiatives, outputs, timelines, responsible agencies (selected):
    - Strengthen the capacity of the National Assembly to propose, evaluate and approve sound legislation
      - Outputs: Legislative skills training, policy research and impact assessment support
      - Timetable: S M LT
      - Responsible: NA
    - Continue the comprehensive compilation and regular updating and large dissemination of legislation
      - Outputs: More frequent publication and wider distribution of the Official Gazette CD-Rom containing legal data base of all decrees and laws
      - Timetable: 2004 S M LT
      - Responsible: MOJ
    - Establish manual of legal guidelines for ministries and justice official at provincial and district levels
      - Outputs: Manual produced; Training on use of manual prepared and presented
      - Timetable: 2003/4
      - Responsible: MOJ/MOF
    - Systematic publication of law books and manuals and supply them to public facilities across the country
      - Outputs: Books in each area published and distributed; Publication of practical manual for legal dissemination; Establish law journal
      - Timetable: 2003 PA, MT
      - Responsible: MOJ
    - Strengthen knowledge of the law through the local schooling system
      - Outputs: Legal awareness components in secondary school curriculum established
      - Timetable: S MT
      - Responsible: MOJ/ MOE
    - Provide legal training for legal staff at central and local levels
      - Outputs: Action plan and curriculum for training of trainers, short and long term training plan for judges
      - Timetable: S MT
      - Responsible: MOJ/PSC/OPP
    - Speed up case resolution and improve decision-making
      - Outputs: Progressive reduction in number of district courts to ensure sufficient number of qualified judges at each court
      - Timetable: 2003/4 MT
      - Responsible: MOJ/PSC

  - Strategic objective 2: Improving the ability of all the peoples of Lao PDR to access the justice system
    - Expected outcomes:
      - Strengthening the informal and formal mechanisms for dispute resolution
      - Easier access of the public to the legal services, streamlining of their delivery, facilitation of the training for public officials
      - Better access to justice for disadvantaged groups
      - Better understanding on the part of officials of the needs of priority groups
      - More efficient and cost-effective alternatives to the formal court system
      - Increased public confidence in the court system
    - Priority initiatives (selected), outputs, timelines, responsible agencies:
      - Create appeals courts and people’s courts at the provincial level, as well as mediation and military courts. Strengthen mediation units at the village level.
        - Outputs: Establishment of appellate court with trained judges, infrastructure and supporting staff appointed
        - Timetable: M LT
        - Responsible: NA/PSC
      - Improve capacity of village mediation units
        - Outputs: Training of mediators and establishing district justice officers that facilitate and supervise the work of mediators
        - Timetable: MT
        - Responsible: MOJ
      - Strengthen the Bar Association to enable it to better provide legal services to disadvantaged group
        - Outputs: Build management structure and capacity, establish regulations for collecting and disbursing own revenue
        - Timetable: S MT
        - Responsible: MÓJ
      - Implement the policy of free legal assistance provided by justice departments and district level to those in need
        - Outputs: Regulations on priority assistance drafted and approved
        - Timetable: S M LT
        - Responsible: MOJ
      - Develop translation services for people of different language background
        - Outputs: Feasibility study completed
        - Timetable: ST
        - Responsible: MOJ
      - Restructure and update the office responsible for providing legal advice to women
        - Outputs: Office upgraded
        - Timetable: ST
        - Responsible: Lao Women's Union
      - Research, enhance and monitor the implementation of measures to ensure the respect of women and children’s rights
        - Outputs: Reports on the fulfillment of Lao PDR's international commitments; Collaborate with regional neighbors in monitoring of trafficking in women and children
        - Timetable: PA
        - Responsible: Lao Women's Union / MOJ/ Min Labor and Social Welfare/ MOFA

*Source: _cr04393 - 4. Rationalize the various inspection and internal audit agencies.*

### Part 4: Sound Financial Management Accountability and Transparency in Financial Management  1.

### Part 4: Sound Financial Management Accountability and Transparency in Financial Management

### Strategic objective 1: Development of a sound fiscal policy and implementation of equitable revenue collection
- Strategic outcomes:
  - Planned national revenues ensured and remitted to the central treasury on a timely basis
  - Increased tax base
  - Rationalize fairly the incomes between various strata of society
  - Taxpayers identified and treated in a fair and equitable fashion across all provinces
  - Effective decentralisation of revenue collection
- Priority Governance Initiatives, expected products (outputs), indicative timetable, responsible agency:
  - Revise definition of national, provincial, and district taxes and monitor implementation at the provincial and district level; draft and approve new laws (e.g. Tax Law)
    - Outputs: New tax laws in place; Decree #192 amended; Monitoring system developed and in place
    - Indicative timetable: MT / ST
    - Responsible agencies: MoF; DPACS
  - Review performance of the existing tax rates
    - Outputs: Development of review methodology; Implementation of review
    - Indicative timetable: PA
    - Responsible agency: MoF
  - Consider the strengthening of the personal income tax system
    - Outputs: Review and revision of personal income tax system
    - Indicative timetable: LT
    - Responsible agency: MoF
  - Review policy to promote growth of SMEs
    - Outputs: Ongoing review of SME growth support policy
    - Indicative timetable: PA
    - Responsible agency: MoF
  - Introduce more efficient and transparent procedures for collecting taxes from the small taxpayer community
    - Outputs: New procedures/guidelines for small taxpayer collection
    - Indicative timetable: PA
    - Responsible agency: MoF
  - Develop a comprehensive training program, including establishment of a tax and customs training center
    - Outputs: Needs assessment completed, training program developed; Training center opened
    - Indicative timetable: ST
    - Responsible agency: MoF

### Strategic objective 2: Development of transparent and accountable practices for expenditure planning and management and modernisation of the accounting system
- Strategic outcomes:
  - Spending patterns reflecting local priorities
  - Budget preparation based on decentralized and bottom-up process
  - Timely central government transfers to deficit provinces
  - Application of new public sector procedures across the country at ministry and provincial level
  - More effective revenue collection, more realistic, rational expenditure planning
- Priority Governance Initiatives:
  - Take steps to control or prevent new expenditure arrears. If resources are available, take steps to clear stock of existing arrears
    - Outputs: Guidelines on prevention of expenditure arrears; Reduced level of expenditure arrears
    - Indicative timetable: ST
    - Responsible agency: MoF
  - Start to report expenditure arrears on a monthly basis
    - Outputs: Monthly report on arrears
    - Indicative timetable: ST
    - Responsible agency: MoF
  - Develop a plan and secure donor support for extending public accounting regulations, procedures and system to all ministries and all provinces
    - Outputs: New accounting regulations, procedures and systems in all ministries and provinces
    - Indicative timetable: MT
    - Responsible agencies: MoF, and other ministries

### Strategic objective 3: Ensuring accountable and transparent management of ODA
- Strategic outcomes:
  - Improved project management at local level
  - More harmonised project documentation, accounting, procurement and reporting system
  - Co-ordination of monitoring and evaluation capacity across CPC and line ministries
  - All ODA to have a capacity-building component
  - All projects and programs designed taking into account past experience
- Priority Governance Initiatives:
  - Strengthen the capacity of the CPC and the line ministries for the monitoring and evaluation of projects
    - Outputs: Needs analysis and resultant training programs; Revised M&E procedures; Regular impact evaluation reports
    - Indicative timetable: ST / MT
    - Responsible agency: CPC
  - Develop and implement training program for improving project planning and project management at the local levels
    - Outputs: Training materials and program
    - Responsible agencies: MT; CPC
  - Streamline and harmonise project planning, budgeting and monitoring procedures and methodologies, in concert with the donors
    - Outputs: Projects incorporated in ledgers and monthly reports; all disbursements of donor-supported projects included in treasury ledgers; all project accounts are transferred to the national treasury
    - Indicative timetable: ST
    - Responsible agency: CPC
  - Promotion of government-donor partnerships related to the governance program and the NGPES
    - Outputs: Streamlined co-ordination and reporting procedures
    - Indicative timetable: ST
    - Responsible agency: CPC
  - Streamline the distribution of responsibilities between government agencies involved in the management and co-ordination of aid
    - Outputs: Clearly documented delineation of responsibilities
    - Indicative timetable: MT
    - Responsible agency: CPC

### Strategic objective 4: Improving efficiency in land management and administration
- Strategic outcomes:
  - Full harmonisation of all laws and regulations
  - Alternative approaches for land use allocation
- Priority Governance Initiatives:
  - Harmonize the different laws with a view to improving the coherence of the various laws. Draft and approve related regulations
    - Outputs: Regulations in place
    - Indicative timetable: MT
    - Responsible agency: MoF
  - Take steps, over time, to finalize land use rights in the country
    - Outputs: To be defined
    - Indicative timetable: MT
    - Responsible agency: MoF
  - Examine methodology used for land allocation, and given the problems experienced, develop alternative approaches
    - Outputs: Research document presenting alternatives
    - Indicative timetable: ST
    - Responsible agency: MoF
  - Carryout planned policy dialogue to review policies and strategies for land administration
    - Outputs: Policy dialogue meeting
    - Indicative timetable: ST
    - Responsible agency: MoF

### Annex highlights: Education Sector 2003-2006 (Table 3.2) — Improving Equitable Access Programme
- Overarching goal: Achieve Education For All by 2015
- Selected measures, targets, programs, responsible agencies, monitoring indicators, time frame:
  - Develop Multi grade training components for pre and in service training
    - Target: In service and Pre service MGT training modules prepared by Sept 2003
    - Agencies: MOE/DGE/DPC/TDC
    - Indicator: Number of instructional materials completed and printed
    - Time frame: 2003-2006
  - Recruit multigrade teacher trainees from communities where they are required
    - Target: 260 MGT trainees graduate by 2005
    - Program: Basic Education for Girl Project (BEGP)
    - Agencies: DTT/PESs / DEBs
    - Indicator: Number of MGT have been trained
  - Establish and expand school clusters in 47 poorest districts
    - Target: Clusters established/expanded in 47 poorest districts
    - Program: Education Quality Improvement Project
    - Indicator: Number of Graduates from TTCs and TTSs
    - Time frame: 2003-2005
  - Increase proportion of students in complete schools by 20 per cent
    - Program: EQIP-II
  - Review and upgrade incomplete schools in 47 poorest districts; upgrade 25 schools to complete schools annually
    - Program: Education Development Project (EDP-II)
    - Indicators: Annual school statistics
  - Literacy and community learning targets in 47 poorest districts:
    - Reduction of 20 per cent in number of illiterate adults in 47 poorest districts
    - 2,760 literate trainees; 2,760 new literates
    - Construct 94 CTC for providing training programmes
    - Provide 2 volunteer teacher/trainers in each village of 47 districts
    - 20% of villagers in 47 districts will be trained in basic skills (188 trainers/years)
  - Food and boarding support targets:
    - More than 161,000 primary students in 47 poorest districts will benefit from the project
    - More than 17,500 students in boarding schools will benefit from the project
    - More than 73,500 girls will benefit from the project
  - Teacher and administrator training targets:
    - At least one trainer for 47 poorest districts and all principals and teachers in target schools will be trained
    - 300 teachers and 100 administrators will be trained
  - Completion, enrolment and vocational targets:
    - Recruit 260 ethnic teachers and 200 MGT contracted teachers in poorest districts
    - 20 new ECCD Centres will be established in 47 poorest districts
    - Reduce repetition rate by 50% by 2005 in participating schools
    - Reduce gender gap to 2 per cent or less
    - Expand pre-school classes within primary schools by 30% in poorest districts
    - Construct and rehabilitate 1 Lower Secondary School in each poorest district
    - Completed survey report of labour market needs
    - Enrollment 800-1000 students in 6-8 courses for each upgraded TVE school
    - Enrollment 500-600 students; introduce two new courses; 30% of young people out of school attend skills training and have supported a community revolving fund

### Annex highlights: Health Sector Five-Year Action Programmes for Poverty-Focused Health Sector Development
- Policy area: Health Education and Information
  - Objective/target: 85% of rural and remote villages are reached by IEC activities and behaviour change occurs
  - Measures: Reorganization of IEC; IEC campaigns; IEC in ethnic languages; Multi-sectoral cooperation
  - Planned timetable: 2003-05
  - Monitoring indicators: 1.1 A framework is in place; 1.2 % of the remote/rural reached; 1.3 # materials in ethnic languages; 1.4 Curriculum and activities for IEC integrated into school curriculum
  - Reporting frequency: Yearly
  - Agency: MOH
- Policy area: Expansion of the service network and health promotion in remote areas
  - Objectives/targets:
    - 1. 80% of rural and remote villages have a village health provider, essential drug kit, and a village health committee.
    - 2. 80% of district hospitals and health centers have essential equipment and staff.
  - Measures include strengthening PHC with emphasis on 46 poor districts, 150 new HC, 3 regional hosp,, 13 provincial hosp, 10 Type A DH, and 46 DH poor districts
  - Planned timetable: 2003-05
  - Monitoring indicators: Reports; guidelines; % of active village health committees; # of new health centers developed; # regional hosp improved; # provincial hosp upgraded; # districts hospitals (DH) upgraded to Type A; # DH in poor areas upgraded; # and % of committees c/women
  - Reporting frequency: Yearly
  - Agency: MOH
- Policy area: Upgrading the skills of health staff and increasing the number of staff from ethnic minorities
  - Objective/target: To increase the proportion of health workers at village and district levels by 75%
  - Measures: Build 2 nursing schools and rehab 2; train PHC workers; development of about 4000 village health providers; post grad medical training for about 312 individuals; refresher training once yearly
  - Planned timetable: 2003-05
  - Monitoring indicators: # of schools built or rehabilitated; # training centers built and functioning; # VHP functioning; # HC staff trained and return to their HC; # managers trained; % health staff receiving one training course per year; # individuals receive postgraduate training; % of facilities using standard treatment guidelines
  - Reporting frequency: Yearly
  - Agency: MOH
- Policy area: Promotion of maternal and child health
  - Targets: Infant mortality reduced to 58/1000; Child mortality reduced to 80/1000; Maternal mortality reduced to 355/100000; Contraceptive prevalence increased to 45%
  - Measures: Upgrade skills of MCH staff; strengthen MCH network; expansion of ARI and CDD network; EOC available at 18 PH and 142 DH; promotion of key package of interventions; monitoring/supervising
  - Planned timetable: 2003-05
  - Monitoring indicators: Percentage of HC and DH staff trained in EOC, ANC, FP and MCH; Percentage of PH, DH, HC, and VHP providing EOC; Percentage of villages receiving HE; # provinces, # districts, and # villages in the network; # hospitals where EOC available; % villages receiving package; Percentage supervision occurring
  - Reporting frequency: Yearly
  - Agency: MOH
- Policy area: Immunization for women and children in remote areas
  - Target: 90% coverage of mothers and children in remote areas with the core antigens
  - Measures: Supplement OPV imm. in 116 districts and 2888 villages; National immunization days for measles in 2004-05; Routine immunizations to achieve 90% coverage; Introduce hepatitis B imm. 7 provinces/2003 and 8/2004; Expansion of rabies immunization to all provinces; Training of provincial and district EPI managers
  - Planned timetable: 2003-05
  - Monitoring indicators: % coverage of target population; % coverage for measles; % coverage of basic antigens; % of all remote villages visited 4 times/year; # provinces introduced in 2003 and # provinces in 2004; # provinces Rabies vaccine available
  - Reporting frequency: Yearly
  - Agency: MOH
- Policy area: Water supply and environmental health
  - Targets: 65-70% clean water access; 45-50% hygienic latrine access; 19-22% hygienic latrines in primary schools
  - Measures:
    - 6.1 C330 gravity fed water systems, 1500 bore holes, 1032 shallow wells, 1250 jars for water collection, 32 piped water schemes, and 30 protected springs
    - 6.2 Latrine expansion-81,000 family, 600 school latrines
    - 6.3 Community mobilizaton and gender awareness
    - 6.4 Training 4-7 staff in each province and 2-3/district
    - 6.5 Monitoring/supervision
  - Planned timetable: 2003-05
  - Monitoring indicators: # of water points developed; # of family latrines, # of school latrines; % coverage of model village program, # of school sanitation programs; # trained staff; % of planned supervision visits/year actually conducted
  - Reporting frequency: Yearly
  - Agency: MOH

*Source: _cr04393 - Part 4: Sound Financial Management Accountability and Transparency in Financial Management*

### 7. Communicable disease control 7.1 Malaria       7.2 Dengue     7.3.1 ADD-Cholera

### 7. Communicable disease control 7.1 Malaria 7.2 Dengue 7.3.1 ADD-Cholera

### 7.1 Malaria — objectives, targets, strategies, monitoring
- Objectives / targets:
  - Parasite infection rate reduced to 8-10%
  - Morbidity reduced to 12.8/1000 LB
  - Mortality reduced to 3.4./100000
  - Insecticide treated bed net - 63.1% cover
- Strategies / measures:
  - 7.1.1 Improved IEC through multiple means
  - 7.1.2 Expansion of malaria network
  - 7.1.3 To upgrade the skills of health workers
  - 7.1.4 Monitoring /supervision
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 7.1.1 % aware of means to treat and control malaria
  - 7.1.2 % of targets reached
  - 7.1.3 # village health volunteers trained, # laboratory workers trained, and # frontline health workers trained.
  - 7.1.4 # supervision visits at each level
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

### 7.2 Dengue — objectives, strategies, monitoring
- Objective / target:
  - Dengue outbreaks are prevented and if they occur the case fatality rate will be less than 1%
- Strategies / measures:
  - 7.2.1 Case manage training
  - 7.2.2 Social mobilization
  - 7.2.3 Mosquito/larva control
  - 7.2.4 Improved surveillance
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 7.2.1 # staff trained
  - 7.2.2 % of population aware
  - 7.2.3 # staff trained
  - 7.2.4 % of surveillance reports wkly
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

### 7.3.1 Cholera (ADD-Cholera) — objectives, strategies, monitoring
- Objective / target:
  - Cholera outbreaks will be prevented and if they occur the case fatality rate will be less than 2%
- Strategies / measures:
  - 7.3.1.1 Health education
  - 7.3.1.2 Access to ORS/VHV
  - 7.3.1.3 Upgrading of 3 labo
  - 7.3.1.4 Improved surveillance
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 7.3.1.1 % of population aware
  - 7.3.1.2 % villages with ORS/VHV
  - 7.3.1.3 # regional laboratories
  - 7.3.1.4 % of surveillance reports wkly
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

### 7.3.2 TB and 7.3.3 Intestinal parasites — objectives, strategies, monitoring
- TB objectives / targets:
  - By 2005 morbidity and mortality reduced by 30%, 70% of Sputum + identified, and DOTS will achieve an 85% cure
- TB strategies / measures:
  - 7.3.2.1 Expand TB network to all provinces by 2005
  - 7.3.2.2 Upgrade skills of staff
- TB monitoring indicators:
  - 7.3.2.1 # uncovered provinces are added to network by 2005
  - 7.3.2.2 # Health workers trained
- Intestinal parasites objectives / targets:
  - By 2005 intestinal parasites reduce by 50%
- Intestinal parasites strategies / measures:
  - 7.3.3.1 National survey
  - 7.3.3.2 Develop a national parasite control plan
  - 7.3.3.3 To develop with MoE preventive and treatment activities in schools
- Intestinal parasites monitoring indicators:
  - 7.3.3.1 Baseline data available
  - 7.3.3.2 Plan in place
  - 7.3.3.3 # of primary schools involved; Number of deworming days and % participation of target population
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

### 7.4 Generalized surveillance – known and new diseases
- Objectives / targets:
  - By 2005 outbreaks are detected early and the case fatality rate is below 2%
- Strategies / measures:
  - 7.4.1 Integrated surveillance system from village to center
  - 7.4.2 Training of staff
  - 7.4.3 Improved laboratory at 5 regional and 6 provincial
  - 7.4.4 Establish EWORS
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 7.4.1 Surveillance system and guidelines in place
  - 7.4.2 # staff trained at various levels
  - 7.4.3 # labs operating
  - 7.4.4 # facilities where EWORS established
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

---

### 8. HIV/AIDS/STD control

### Objectives, strategies, monitoring
- Objectives / targets:
  - 90% of the target groups will be aware of methods of HIV/AIDS prevention and will change their behaviors.
  - 80% increase in condom use among high-risk
  - 18 provincial laboratories and 80% of blood transfusions safe
- Strategies / measures:
  - 8.1 HIV/AIDS/STD network to 18 provinces/70 districts
  - 8.2 Surveillance of target groups in 6 provinces in 2004.
  - 8.3 Health ed for all and target-80% condoms in hi risk
  - 8.4 Improved routine surveillance through blood bank - 80% of transfusions are screened in 18 PH
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 8.1 # of districts and provinces covered
  - 8.2 Surveillance report
  - 8.3 Surveillance reports and survey reports
  - 8.4 # PH with testing facility and % of transfusions screened
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

---

### 9. Drug revolving fund (DRF) expansion

### Objectives, strategies, monitoring
- Objective / target:
  - DRF established in 5960 villages in remote areas by 2005.
- Strategies / measures:
  - 9.1 Expand DRF in 30 additional districts, 2013 trained VHV, 2013 drug kits by 2003, 5960 by 2005.
  - 9.2 Supervision of DRF
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 9.1 # of villages covered
  - 9.2 # monitoring visits yearly from central to province, province to district, and district to village.
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

---

### 10. Improved food and drug safety

### 10.1 Drug safety — objectives, strategies, monitoring
- Objectives / targets:
  - To meet Good Manufacturing Practice Standards for 1-2 drug factories.
  - To produce essential drugs so that 50% are supplied by local manufacture.
  - To control the price of essential drugs
- Strategies / measures:
  - 10.1.1 Train staff
  - 10.1.2 Laws and regulations.
  - 10.1.3 Drug registration
  - 10.1.4 Reduction in category 3 private pharmacies.
  - 10.1.5 Regulate import
  - 10.1.6 Drug stores at provincial and district levels
  - 10.1.7 Establish 2 medical equipment workshops
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 10.1.1. # of workers trained
  - 10.1.2 # laws /regulations issued.
  - 10.1.3 % of drugs registered
  - 10.1.4 % reduction in private pharmacies registered
  - 10.1.5 One state company formed for import at central and provincial level.
  - 10.1.6 # of state drug stores formed at provinces and districts
  - 10.1.7 2# medical equip workshops
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

### 10.2 Food safety — objectives, strategies, monitoring
- Objective / target:
  - The Lao people consume food of high quality and safety
  - To register 100% food product factories
- Strategies / measures:
  - 10.2.1 Train workers
  - 10.2.2 Laws and regulations.
  - 10.2.3 Register 100% food product factories
  - 10.2.4 Establish and reform inspection units at border.
  - 10.2.5 Improved laboratory monitoring - 1 central and 2 provincial
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 10.2.1 # of workers trained
  - 10.2.2 # of laws approved and regulations issued.
  - 10.2.3 % of factories registered
  - 10.2.4 # of number of active food inspection units at borders
  - 10.2.5 # of laboratories
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

---

### 11. Promotion of traditional medicine

### Objectives, strategies, monitoring
- Objective / target:
  - By 2005 to strengthen the promotion of the culture of traditional medicine (TM)
- Strategies / measures:
  - 11.1 Promote traditional medicine plantations
  - 11.2 Develop law and regulations for TM
  - 11.3 Develop human resources for TM
  - 11.4 Rehabilitate TM centers
  - 11.5 Conduct research on TM
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 11.1 # TM plantations established by 2005.
  - 11.2 # laws and regulations in place.
  - 11.3 # numbers trained in various specialities.
  - 11.4 # TM centers rehabilitated
  - 11.5 # Research studies completed
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

---

### 12. Strengthened financing, management, quality assurance, and legal framework

### Objectives, strategies, monitoring
- Objective / target:
  - 15 % of population covered by community insurance
  - Legal and management framework improved
- Strategies / measures:
  - 12.1.1 Completion of 3 pilot projects by end of 2004.
  - 12.1.2 Developed framework for CBHI expansion
  - 12.2 Develop legal framework for curative law
  - 12.3 Medical society started
  - 12.4 Improved procedures for health finance/management
- Monitoring indicators:
  - 12.1.1 - # of pilots established
  - 12.1.2 # of new projects and estimate of population coverage
  - 12.2 # laws and regulations developed
  - 12.3 Medical society in place
  - 12.4 Procedural manual available
- Planned timetable: 2003-05
- Reporting frequency: Yearly
- Agency: MOH

---

*Source: _cr04393 - 7. Communicable disease control 7.1 Malaria 7.2 Dengue 7.3.1 ADD-Cholera*

### 3. Education Sector

### 3. Education Sector

### Education — Objectives and Targets
- Improve access, quality and relevance of education services to poor girls & women, especially from ethnic minority groups (make progress toward 2005, 2010 & 2020 targets for adult literacy, & 2005 enrollment targets).

### Education — Planned Measures (3.1–3.2)
- 3.1 Mainstream gender concerns in MoE policies, planning, staffing and activities (see 1.2 above).
- 3.2 Take specific measures outlined in education section & matrix (examples listed in source):
  - increase number of ethnic minority teachers;
  - improve relevance of primary school materials;
  - provide incentives for girls to attend school;
  - encourage provinces & districts to develop locally appropriate materials to supplement core curriculum;
  - adjust school schedules to accommodate student’s home responsibilities;
  - experiment with distance learning;
  - “bridge” courses to prepare students for vocational & technical schools;
  - inclusion of functional literacy/numeracy training in extension and small business support programs.
- Responsible agency: MoE.

### Health Sector (Section 4) — Objective and Targets
- Improve poor women’s access to primary health care, especially reproductive health services in remote and ethnic minority areas (make progress toward 2005, 2010 & 2020 life expectancy targets; 2005 targets for maternal, infant & child mortality, immunization & clean water).

### Health Sector — Planned Measures (4.1–4.2)
- 4.1 Mainstream gender concerns in MoH policies, planning, staffing and activities (see 1.2 above).
- 4.2 Take specific measures outlined in health section & matrix (examples listed in source):
  - training & promotion of more ethnic minority staff and health care providers, especially at provincial & district levels;
  - gender focal points in provincial & district PHCs;
  - at least 50% women on village health committees;
  - gender and ethnic balance in in-service and specialized training;
  - incentives for health care workers in remote areas;
  - men & youth targeted for health care messages on birth spacing and prevention of STDs/HIV/AIDS;
  - expanded reproductive health services to ethnic minority women.
- Responsible agency: MoH.

### Transport Sector (Section 5) — Objective
- Ensure that poor women and men benefit from improvements in roads, transport facilities & other infrastructure.

### Transport Sector — Planned Measures (5.1 and examples)
- 5.1 Mainstream gender concerns in MCTPC policies, planning, staffing and activities (see 1.2 above).
- Take specific measures outlined in transport section & matrix (examples listed in source):
  - consultations with local communities, including women, on design of roads and transport facilities;
  - gender analysis included in EIA/SIA for new transport & infrastructure projects;
  - community development projects to ensure local benefits from road & other infrastructure projects;
  - sex-disaggregated monitoring of project impacts;
  - health awareness campaigns in construction camps, along road corridors & at transit stops.
- Responsible agency: MCTPC.

### Other Sectors & Subsectors (Section 6)
- Promote opportunities for poor women as well as men in trading, handicraft production, tourism & other fields; legal and safe employment in manufacturing (e.g., garment industry).
- 6.1 Under NCAW-Lao, relevant ministries will mainstream gender concerns in their policies, planning and activities.
- 6.2 See discussion of other sectors & subsectors elsewhere in NPEP document & matrix.
- Planning horizon: 2003 onwards.
- Responsible agencies: Various ministries.

### National Programs (Section 7)
- Address particular vulnerabilities and needs of women & girls related to HIV/AIDS risk, migration and trafficking, drug abuse, UXO and other national concerns.
- Refer to separate sections on national programs related to HIV/AIDS, trafficking in women and girls, drug control and UXO.
- Responsible agencies: Various ministries.

### Governance (Section 8) — Objectives and Actions
- Expand opportunities for women to participate in decision-making at all levels, and strengthen women’s legal literacy and access to justice.
- 8.1 Increase percentage of women in senior government positions at national, provincial and district levels.
- 8.2 Encourage village leaders and committees to include more women in local decision-making.
- 8.3 Promote awareness of legal rights and remedies (e.g., relating to land, employment and personal security) among women, especially rural and ethnic minority women.
- Timeframes and monitoring (as given in source):
  - 2003-05; 2004; 2003-05.
  - Indicators: Public sector employment statistics; Number of women on village committees; Attendance reports on training workshops; radio broadcasts, distribution of fliers & posters; survey of women after legal awareness campaign; land title records; survey of factory employees; reports of domestic abuse.
- Responsible agencies: MoJ/LWU/GRID.

### Environment Sector Matrix (Table 3.6) — Vision and Goals
- Vision for 2020:
  - The socio-economic development shall be efficiently and continuously carried out, assuring the proportionality of the economic growth, the socio-cultural development and the sustainable conservation.
  - Improved and environmentally sustainable management of renewable natural resources.
  - Improved environmental management within the industrial and construction sectors.
  - Improved institutional framework and capacity building.
  - Government service agencies responsive to participatory development processes with an improved capacity to manage and support development.
  - Reduced environmental degradation through improved natural resource management.
  - Public spending and investment reflects the economic policy emphasis in accordance with different development goals and sectors.

- Purpose 2003-2005:
  - To reduce poverty in a sustainable manner through improved food and income production, better infrastructure and services and reduce environmental degradation through improved natural resource management.
  - Enhanced food & livelihood security opportunities.
  - Improved maternal & child and primary healthcare.
  - Increased educational attainment of primary-school-aged children, improved literacy, diversified vocations.
  - Improved and environmentally sustainable management of renewable natural resources.
  - Improved environmental management within industrial and construction sectors.
  - Improved institutional framework and capacity.

### Environment Sector — Key Components and Outputs
- Indicators and outcome measures listed in source (exact phrasing preserved):
  - Proportion of population below $1 per day (PPP-values).
  - Poverty gap ratio [incidence x depth of poverty].
  - Share of poorest quintile in national consumption.
  - Prevalence of underweight children (under-five years of age).
  - Proportion of population below minimum level of dietary energy consumption.
  - Proportion of land area covered by forest.
  - Land area protected to maintain biological diversity.
  - GDP per unit of energy use (as proxy for energy efficiency).
  - Carbon dioxide emissions (p. capita).
  - Proportion of population with sustainable access to an improved water source.
- Outputs and activities (selected, as in source):
  - Training in participatory processes complete.
  - Participatory processes used in production of work plans; community priorities indicated; communities participate in evaluation.
  - Community regularly visited by service agencies, agric., health, education.
  - Provide basic health services.
  - Establishment of Village development committees and activity groups.
  - Treated by Health service and supplied clean water.
  - Income levels and stability.
  - Status of Natural resource: % forest, water table, % land with soil conservation, crop diversification data.
  - Food security.
  - Improved adult & primary education.
  - Communities enjoy improved quality of life through access to services.
  - Community based structures are empowered to articulate development needs and priorities and develop improved capacity for technology transfer.

### Environment Sector — Strategic Actions (numbered in source)
- 1. Participatory management of Natural Resources and the Environment:
  - Strengthen participation by the poor in decision making related to access to environmental resources and services.
  - Co-manage and co-invest in environmental services and resources with the poor; assist the poor to overcome high initial costs for better quality environmental services (such as water supply and sanitation, energy and waste management).
  - Outputs include staff allocated, organogram and job descriptions established; survey completed, data input; training program implemented; buffer zone boundaries identified and mapped under a participatory process; improved systems and recommendations available; staff and community training completed; farming systems data collected & documented; community planning committees for integrated plans prepared and implemented; technologies disseminated and implemented by village poor communities; documentation of dissemination from project to non-project poor villages; environmental monitoring setup completed and relevant data disseminated and acquired; reduced rates of soil fertility decline, fishery and wildlife losses, and old-growth forest decline verified; improved enforcement and punishment capacity in relevant laws and decree implementation recorded and verified; pilot activities in poor village-based forest resource management initiated and verified (including sustained yield principles); eco-tourism development in partnership with local stakeholders initiated and verified.

- 2. Protected current natural asset base of the poor:
  - Protect access the poor already have to critical resources.
  - Expand the natural asset base of the poor through transferring ownership of natural assets to the poor.
  - Make resource transfers to the poor through reducing subsidies for environmental services that benefit the non-poor and increasing investments in areas in which the poor live and work.
  - Devise a system for an ecological zoning of Lao.

- 3. Promoted environmental infrastructure and technology that benefits the poor:
  - Tackle environmental problems and hazards that impact most upon the health and livelihoods of the poor; develop affordable and environmentally sound technologies needed by and usable by the poor.
  - Promote environmentally friendly private sector products such as clean technology, energy efficiency technology and nature tourism.
  - Provide access to alternative sources of energy.
  - Provide access to energy efficient appliances.

- 4. Improved institutional framework and its capacity:
  - Recognize opportunities for people to participate in both national and local levels in decisions that affect them and a sound legislative framework which incorporate property rights, especially for poor people.
  - Encourage resources-based legal frameworks for water resources, forestry, land management and biodiversity.
  - Encourage government agencies to shift to a more participatory management regime with attention to resource conservation as well as production.
  - Use market based instruments as much as possible and pursue environmental policies which minimize administrative burden, recognizing that environment agency in our country is newly established, relatively weak with small budgets and administrations.
  - Build capacity for more effective environmental management within institutions and for more effective participation in relevant national environmental laws implementation.
  - Update economic policies to protect the environment by ending environmentally damaging subsidies, introducing and raising user charges, increasing low resource use taxes, increasing charges for environmentally damaging activities and using incentives for environmentally beneficial activities.
  - Encourage public participation and action on environmental issues.

- 5. Raised awareness and Capacities:
  - 5.1 Promote environmental awareness.
  - 5.2 Improve public access to environmental information.
  - 5.3 Make environmental education a standard part of the curriculum.
  - 5.4 Help build political will.

*Source: _cr04393 - 3. Education Sector*

### 5.5         Promote         the

### _cr04393 - 5.5         Promote         the

### Environmental management and private sector engagement
- 5.5 Promote the understanding of the strong linkage between poverty and environmental management.
- 5.6 Encourage the private sector to integrate environmental concerns into their decision making by assistance to industry organizations, promotion of industry codes of conduct and environmental auditing standards, introduction of polluter pays principle and more effective enforcement and public participation.
- 5.7 Encourage environmental beginner enterprises to follow the lead of the environmentally experienced companies.

### Opium supply and demand projects (Table 3.7)
- Total A Completed Projects: 33,975,080 (US$)
  - 1 Palaveck Highland Integrated Development Project, Saysomboun Special Region. — 6,250,000 — 1988 - 1997 — UNDCP
  - 2 Drug Supply and Demand Reduction Project in Xiengkhouang, (Phase I) — 6,258,000 — 1992 - 1998 — UNDCP:1.704.400$, IFAD   : 3.740.561$, GOL :    313.357$
  - 3 Opium Detoxification and Rehabilitation in Luangprabang — 97,200 — July1999-June 2000 — UNDCP
  - 4 Pilot Alternative Development Project in Bokeo and Luang Namtha — 1,050,000 — 1993 -1995 — UNDCP, -NCA
  - 5 Alternative Development Project in Bokeo and Luang Namtha, Phase I — 1,711,355 — 1995- 1996 — UNDCP, NCA
  - 6 Long Alternative Development Project in Luang Namtha, Phase 2 — 1,077,000 — 1999 - 2000 — UNDCP
  - 7 Lao-American Integrated Rural Development Project in Houaphanh Province — 16,631,525 — 1989 - 2001 — USA
  - 8 Beng Alternative Development Project, Oudomxay Province — 900,000 — Sept 1999-Dec -2001 — UNDCP

- Total B On-going Projects: 28,814,716 (US$)
  - Programme Facilitation Unit (PFU) — 5.191.000 — July 2000-June 2006 — UNDCP
  - Nonghet Alternative Development Project, Xiengkhouang Province — 3.635.000 — March 1999-Dec –2003 — UNDCP
  - Village-based Development Component in ADB Shifting Cultivation Stabilization Pilot Project in Houaphanh.Province — 7,800,000 — March 2000-Feb 2005 — ADB: 5.700.000 $, UNDCP: 2.100.000 $
  - Lao-German Drug Control Project: Project Coordination Unit — 1,250,000 — Phase I: 1999 - 2001 — GERMANY/BMZ
  - Lao-German Drug Control Project: Drug Control Component (Luang Namtha, Bokeo, Xiengkhouang) — 1,250,000 — Phase I: 1999 - 2001 — GERMANY/BMZ
  - Poverty Oriented Development Project in Luang Namtha Province — 1,500,000 — Apr 2001 - Mar 2004 — GERMANY/BMZ
  - Opium Detoxification and Rehabilitation Project in Luangprabang Province — 220,716 — Aug2001-July2004 — JAPAN/CONSORTIUM
  - Opium Elimination Project — 650,000 — Jan 2001-Dec2003 — USA
  - Long Alternative Development Project in Luang Namtha Province — 220,000 — Jan-August 2001 — NCA
  - Meung & Namjuam Alternative Development Project in Bokeo Prov. — 600,000 — 1999 - 2001 — NCA
  - Lao-American Integrated Rural Development Project in Phongsaly Province — 5,598,000 — 1998-2001 — USA
  - Long Alternative Development Project, in Luang Namtha Province Phase III — 2,030,500 — Oct 2001 - August 2004 — UNDCP, NCA
  - Northern Phongsaly Alternative Development Project — 2,200,000 — July 2001 - June 2003 — UNDCP

### UXO contamination (Table 3.8) — summary findings
- TOTAL (Impact Survey summary): 755 269 1,024
- Based on the findings of the 1997 Impact Survey, and of a total of 11,939 villages:
  - 1,707 villages are considered "High Impact"
  - 856 villages are considered "Moderate Impact"
- Selected province-level examples from the Impact Survey (Impacted Villages based on 1997 Impact Survey; columns: High Moderate TOTAL; All Bombing Records):
  - Luang Phrabang Province (159+70) — Yes — 62 15 77 — 2,260
  - Huaphanh Province (126+40) — Yes — 84 34 118 — 3,828
  - Xiengkhuang Province (238+63) — Yes — 82 9 91 — 32,188
  - Khammuane Province (183+92) — Yes — 90 9 99 — 35,699
  - Savannakhet Province (352+192) — Yes — 260 97 357 — 61,554
  - Sekong Province (196+49) — Yes — 70 25 95 — 16,334
  - Attapeu Province (71+27) — Yes — 35 10 45 — 13,643
  - Xaysomboun Special Region (28+17) — No — 6 4 10 — 2,612

### HIV/AIDS/STI Priority Matrix (Table 3.9) — priorities, key activities and budget subtotals
- Priority issue 1: Second Generation Surveillance of HIV/STD and Research
  - Key activity: Conduct second generation surveillance (BSS, HSS, SPPS) in 4 provinces: LB, VTM, SVK, CHS and more provinces may be added — Estimated cost 600,000 — Funds available 280,500 — Funds non-available 319,500 — FHI:150000, WHO: 13000, ADB: (not fully specified)
  - Other activities: Attend international conferences for surveillance lesson learned — 72,000 (Funds available 0, Funds non-available 72,000) ; Improve case reporting on HIV/AIDS/STD — 336,800 (Funds available 152,000, Funds non-available 184,800)
  - SUB-TOTAL: 1,008,800 — 432,500 — 576,300

- Priority issue 2: Prevention and Treatment of STDs
  - Strategy goal: Ensure appropriate management of STDs in at least 50% of health care system by 2005
  - Step 1. Provide training to HCW in public and private health system on the correct management of STDs — 2,112,980 — Funds available 2,085,230
  - Step 2. Ensure the availability of appropriate STD Drugs — 253,000 — Funds available 50,000 — Funds non-available 203,000
  - Step 3. Integrate STD services into primary health care — 212,000 — Funds available 111,000 — Funds non-available 101,000
  - Step 4. Strengthen STD case finding in antenatal clinics — 15,000 — Funds available 8,000 — Funds non-available 7,000
  - Step 5. Promote health care seeking behaviour for the diagnosis and treatment of STD — 45,000 — Funds available - — Funds non-available 45,000
  - Step 6. Include the promotion of safer sexual behaviour, including condom use, as integral part of treatment of STDs — 34,000 — Funds available 22,000 — Funds non-available 12,000
  - SUB TOTAL: 2,671,980 — 2,276,230 — 395,750

- Priority issue 3: Prevention of HIV among service women
  - Step 1: Reduce HIV vulnerability of service women (awareness campaigns, user friendly health services, reduction of stigma, etc.) — 328,490 — Funds available 37,090 — Funds non-available 291,400
  - Step 2: Reduce STD prevalence among service women through massive presumptive treatment of STD — 350,200 — Funds available 350,000 — Funds non-available 200
  - SUB TOTAL: 678,690 — 387,090 — 291,600

- Priority issue 4: Prevention of HIV Among Mobile Population
  - Strategy 1: Reduce the vulnerability of mobile population group to HIV infection — 445,395 — Funds available 160,195 — Funds non-available 285,200
  - Strategy 2: Make STD services and condoms available to mobile populations — 50,567 — Funds available 567 — Funds non-available 50,000
  - SUB TOTAL: 495,962 — 160,762 — 335,200

- Priority issue 5: Prevention of HIV/AIDS/STD/Drugs among Youth (In and out of school)
  - Strategy 1: Reduce the vulnerability of Youth in schools to HIV/AIDS/STD/drugs — 1,551,800 — Fund available 1,005,800 — Fund non-available 546,000
  - Strategy 2: Reduce the vulnerability of Youth out-of-schools to HIV/AIDS/STD/drugs — 1,185,700 — Fund available 502,940 — Fund non-available 682,760
  - SUB TOTAL: 2,737,500 — 1,508,740 — 1,228,760

- Priority issue 6: Condom Promotion and Availability
  - Step 1. Promote condom use in ways that respect cultural values — 11,000 — Funds available - — Funds non-available 11,000
  - Step 2: Ensure overall availability of condoms throughout the country — 806,000 — Funds available 200,000 — Funds non-available 606,000
  - SUB TOTAL: 817,000 — 200,000 — 617,000

- Priority issue 7: Prevention of HIV through blood safety
  - Strategy 1: Ensure 100% safe blood transfusion in health care setting — 96,340 — Funds available 66,340 — Funds non-available 30,000
  - Strategy 2: Reduce unnecessary and inappropriate transfusions — 6,000 — Funds available - — Funds non-available 6,000
  - Strategy 3: Promote universal precautions — 50,000 — Funds available 50,000 — Funds non-available -
  - SUB TOTAL: 152,340 — 116,340 — 36,000

- Priority issue 8: CARE AND SUPPORT
  - Strategy: Expand and develop health sector and community based care systems for PLWHA
  - Selected activities and costs:
    - Organize information workshops to fight stigmatisation and discrimination in 20 villages in 4 provinces per year — 11,000 — Funds available 11,000
    - Train health care workers (5 per province) for home based care in Vientiane Mun., Bokeo, Champasak — 6,000 — Funds available 6,000
    - Train family and community members of PLWHA in basic home based care — 6,000 — Funds available 6,000
    - Develop and distribute guidelines on treatment drugs, herbal medecine and general care for PLWHA — 12,000 — Funds available 12,000
    - Extend support to PLWHA associations from 1 to 4 provinces — 15,000 — Funds available 15,000
    - Involve PLWHA in projects (PCCA, DCCA projects and workshops) — 7,500 — Funds available 7,500
    - Establish Income Generation Activities (IGA) for PLWHA — 20,000 — Funds available 20,000
    - Monitor and Evaluate activities listed — 10,000 — Funds available 10,000
    - Care and Support Project in Savannakhet Hospital — 700,000 — Funds available 555,000 — Funds non-available 145,000 — MSF Switzerland (90%), CIDA (10%)
    - Care & support for affected children and families — 257,000 — Funds available 150,000 — Funds non-available 107,000 — UNICEF
  - SUB TOTAL: 1,044,500 — 705,000 — 339,500

- Priority issue 9: Prevention of Transmission of HIV from Mother to Child
  - 9.1 Implement a project on prevention of MTCT in Mother and Child Health Centers (MCHC) — 32,145 — Funds available 32,145
  - 9.2 Train 54 trainers on ante-natal care (3 trainers in each of the 18 provinces) and refresher course 2 years later — 27,000 — Funds available 27,000
  - 9.3 Trainers train HCW in ANCs in their respective Provinces (2 workshops for 20 HCW per province per year) — 5,000 — Funds available 5,000
  - 9.4 Include HIV/AIDS education in IEC materials targeting girls and women for LWU, LYU — 9,000 — Funds available 9,000
  - 9.5 Implement a project supported by UNICEF — 50,000 — Funds available 30,000 — Funds non-available 20,000 — UNICEF
  - SUB TOTAL: 123,145 — 62,145 — 61,000

- Priority issue 10: Prevention of HIV Among General Population and Ethnic Minorities (Time table: 2002 2003 04 05)
  - Example activities:
    - 10.1 Production of IEC materials: 100 000 pamphlets, 2000 posters, 40 bill boards, 5000 stickers; Estimated cost 35,000 — Funds available 35,000
    - 10.2 Radio programme : LNR, LPB, SVK, CPS weekly programme — Estimated cost 140,000 — Funds available 61,000 — Funds non-available 79,000 — UNICEF
    - 10.3 HIV prevention among general public in 5 provinces including Savannakhet, Bokeo, Champasak, Sekong, Luangnamtha — Estimated cost 88,890 — Funds available 88,890 — NCA Norway 50000, NORAD 38890
  - SUB TOTAL: 263,890 — 149,890 — 114,000

*Source: _cr04393 - 5.5         Promote         the*

### 1.  Institutional framework development

### 1. Institutional framework development

### Budget overview
- TOTAL BUDGET: 783,540
- FUNDS AVAILABLE: 276,340
- FUNDS NON-AVAILABLE: 507,200

### Strategy 1: Develop the capacity of coordinating bodies
- Estimated cost (US$): 176,040
- Funds available: 94,340
- Funds non-available: 81,700
- Objective: Improve ability to meet regularly and function in collaborative ways.

### Strategy 2: Expand and strengthen partnerships among all national and international actors
- Estimated cost (US$): 63,000
- Funds available: 0 (implied)
- Funds non-available: 63,000

### 2. Policy development and advocacy for an expanded response to HIV/AIDS/STD
- Estimated cost (US$): 94,500
- Funds available: 0 (implied)
- Funds non-available: 94,500
- Stated strategy: Strengthen policy development and advocacy targeting decision makers, for an expanded response to HIV/AIDS/STD

### 3. Capacity development
- Estimated cost (US$): 285,000
- Funds available: 174,000
- Funds non-available: 111,000

### 4. Monitoring and Evaluation of the entire National response
- Total for section 4 (implied): not explicitly stated (dash)
- 4.1 Development of monitoring and evaluation system
  - Implementing agency: NCCAB
  - Estimated cost (US$): 165,000
  - Funds available: 8,000
  - Funds non-available: 157,000

---

### Matrix of Poverty-focused Trade Development: Strategy, Policies and Programs

### Goals and objectives
- Primary goal: Contribute to economic growth and employment generation (use trade as an engine of growth)

### Strategies and measures
- 1) Enhancing economic and trade integration
  - Measures:
    - Implementing AFTA-CEPT Scheme
    - Expediting WTO Accession Process
    - Improving WTO negotiation capabilities
  - Focal/Target areas/Sub-sector Objectives:
    - Legislative reforms to meet pre-WTO accession requirements
    - Commercial Law reforms
    - Action to replace non-tariff restrictions with equivalent tariffs
  - Monitoring indicators and timeframes:
    - Scheduled timetable — 2003-2004
    - Office being set up (Lao rep office in Geneva) — 2003-2004
    - Identified personnel of negotiating teams — 2003-2004
    - Legislative Reform Action Plan — 2003-2005
    - Review and propose necessary changes to commercial laws — 2004-2005
    - Study on equivalent tariffs rates to replace some non-tariff barriers — 2004-2005
    - Study to identify activities in which Laos has comparative advantage — 2003-2004
    - Arrange for publishing availability of published information — on-going

- 2) Adopt fair trading practices
  - Measures:
    - Arrange legislative institutional means for fair trading practices
    - Introduce legislation on competition and consumer protection
    - Seek external assistance for developing policies and drafting laws on competition and consumer protection
    - Set up a Fair Trading Commission under MOC and a Fair Trading Unit within MOC for implementing
    - Undertake staff training programs, seminars for public awareness
  - Monitoring indicators and timeframes:
    - Completion of policy and legal framework, drafting of legislation, setting up of Fair Trading Commission and Fair Trading Unit, and training of staff — Sep 2003-Aug 2007

- 3) Promoting export development
  - Measures:
    - Identifying potential export production activities
    - Providing market information for producers
    - Organizing trade exhibitions locally and abroad
  - Monitoring indicators and timeframes:
    - Number of exhibitions held — 2003-2004
    - Completion of study to identify activities in which Laos has comparative advantage — 2003-2004

- 4) Improving trade facilitation
  - Measures:
    - Study to identify constraints to trade and commercial development
    - Examine ways and means of simplifying procedures
  - Monitoring indicators and timeframes:
    - Completion of study — 2003-
    - Simplified procedures — being completed

- 5) Trade related skills development
  - Measures:
    - Arrange for skills training in trade related services
    - TrainFor Trade Project
  - Monitoring indicators and timeframes:
    - Improved trade related skills — ongoing

- Mainstreaming trade into national and sectoral economic growth and poverty reduction strategies
  - Measures:
    - Coordinating more effectively with line agencies for incorporating trade into their poverty-focused development programs
    - Introducing awareness programs about the importance of trade development for poverty reduction
  - Monitoring indicators:
    - Improvements in poverty reduction — ongoing

---

### Indicators Related to Selected Millennium Development Goals (MDGs)

- MDG 01: Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger
  - Poverty head count ratio (per cent):
    - 1992-1993: 45
    - 1997-1998: 39
    - 2002-2003: 30
  - Net enrolment ratio in primary education (per cent):
    - 2001: 80.3
    - 1996: 71.9

- MDG 02: Achieve universal primary education
  - Proportion of pupils starting Grade 1 who reach Grade 5 (per cent):
    - 2000: 59.9
    - 1996: 56.6
  - Ratio of literate females to males of 15 to 24 years old:
    - 2000: 84.6
    - 1995: 81.2

- MDG 03: Promote gender equality and empower women
  - Proportion of seats held by women in national parliament (per cent):
    - 2002: 22.7
    - 1995: 9.4

- MDG 04: Reduce child mortality
  - Under-five mortality rate (deaths per 1,000 live births):
    - 1994: 142
    - 1999: 106.9
  - Infant mortality rate (deaths per 1,000 live births):
    - 1994: 113
    - 1999: 82.2

- MDG 05: Improve maternal health
  - Proportion of 1 year old children immunized against measles (per cent):
    - 2000: 61.5
    - 1996: 41.8
  - Maternal mortality ratio (deaths per 100,000 live births):
    - 1995: 749
    - 2000: 530

- MDG 06: Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases
  - Death rate associated with malaria (per 100,000 people):
    - 1995: 13.5
    - 2002: 3.5
  - Proportion of tuberculosis cases detected under DOTS (per cent):
    - 2002: 47
    - 1996: 24
  - Proportion of tuberculosis cases cured under DOTS (per cent):
    - 2002: 82
    - 1996: 72

- MDG 07: Ensure environmental sustainability
  - Ratio of area protected to maintain biological diversity to total surface area (per cent):
    - 2000: 14.3
    - 1996: 13.3
  - Proportion of population with access to an improved water source (per cent):
    - 2002: 58
    - 1990: 28
  - Proportion of [urban] population with access to improved sanitation (per cent):
    - 2002: 41.6
    - 1990: 11

*Source: _cr04393 - 1.  Institutional framework development*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2004/_cr04393.pdf_
