## _cr05105

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr05105](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/_cr05105.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/_cr05105.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/_cr05105.pdf.json)

---

### Executive Summary — key macro-fiscal and structural problems
- NFPS deficit has been 5½ percent of GDP in recent years.
- Public debt rose above GDP in 2003.
- Primary cause: significant decline in the ratio of tax revenue to GDP.
- NPC losses increased the fiscal strain.
- Banking system undercapitalized with one-quarter of assets nonperforming.
- Increased exposure of banks to government securities.
- Large external financing requirements and high debt levels increase vulnerability to changes in market sentiment and global financial market conditions.

### Reform actions taken since July 2004
- Congress passed higher alcohol and tobacco excises, expected to yield about 0.2 percent of GDP in annual revenue.
- VAT rate hike (expected yield 0.5 percent of GDP) under discussion in Congress; authorities decided to seek immediate increase from 10 to 12 percent.
- Power sector: provisional 40 percent hike in generation tariffs (P 0.98 per kWh) estimated to yield about 0.7 percent of GDP; sale of a large generation plant announced; government decision to absorb P 200 billion in NPC debts from the beginning of 2005.
- Banking sector: disposal of nonperforming assets begun using the SPV framework; legal amendments to strengthen bank supervision submitted to Congress.
- Mining: Supreme Court decision that foreign control of mining projects is not unconstitutional, opening the way for FDI.

### Assessment of progress and market reaction
- Reforms implemented to date represent a small part of what is required; markets remain sensitive.
- One rating agency downgraded the sovereign rating in January 2005 citing inadequate tax reforms.
- Vulnerabilities will remain high until fiscal and structural problems are solved and reform implementation improves.

### Recent economic developments (2004–2005)
- GDP growth: little over 6 percent in 2004 (reported as 6.1 percent); 2003 was 4¾ percent (reported as 4.7 percent).
- Employment increased by 3.6 percent in 2004; unemployment averaged 11.8 percent, up from 11.4 percent a year earlier.
- Poverty: almost one sixth of the population living on less than $1 a day (Annex VII).
- Inflation (1994 base): rose to 7.9 percent (y/y) in December 2004 from 3.1 percent (y/y) in December 2003; average inflation rose to 5.5 percent.
  - 2000-based CPI: rose to 8.6 percent in December 2004 (y/y) and averaged 6.0 percent for the year.
  - Official core inflation reached 7.6 percent (y/y) in December (1994 base).
- BSP kept policy rates on hold pending clearer evidence of generalized inflation.
- National government deficit (authorities’ definition) estimated at 3.8 percent of GDP in 2004 (below budget target of 4.2 percent), down from 4.6 percent of GDP in 2003.
- NPC losses: expanded from 1.1 percent of GDP in 2003 to 1.5 percent of GDP in 2004.
  - NFPS deficit estimated at 5.3 percent of GDP in 2004, compared to 5.6 percent of GDP in 2003.
- Balance of payments: current account surplus estimated at 4½ percent of GDP in 2004.
- Reserves, adjusted for pledged assets, ended 2004 at $15 billion (119 percent of short-term debt by residual maturity).
- BSP reduced NDF position built in early 2004 by about $0.8 billion.

### Near-term outlook and risks
- GDP projected at 4¾ percent in 2005.
- Key downside risks:
  - Disorderly depreciation of the U.S. dollar leading to weaker global growth.
  - Oil prices retracing toward US$60 per barrel.
  - Markets losing patience with reform implementation speed.
- Key upside conditions:
  - Oil prices falling from current levels.
  - Stronger-than-expected reform implementation (with benefits mainly over the medium term).
- External financing vulnerability:
  - Staff estimate public sector external commercial borrowing needs at $4–4½ billion (5-6 percent of GDP) if reserves are to be maintained at comfortable levels.
  - An increase in global interest rates of 100 basis points would add about $0.3 billion to interest payments in 2005.

### Policy recommendations emphasized by staff
- Fiscal policy
  - Fiscal consolidation should be significantly front-loaded to signal commitment to tackling the fiscal problem.
  - Passage of further tax measures with clear revenue impact (e.g., VAT rate increase) is required.
  - Much of the additional revenue should be saved (i.e., used to improve primary balances).
- Power sector
  - Accelerate reforms, with priority on privatization of transmission and generation assets.
- Monetary policy
  - The BSP should raise interest rates to guide inflationary expectations down.
- Financial sector
  - Expedite passage of amendments to the BSP Charter to strengthen bank supervision and facilitate recapitalization of the banking sector.

### A. Fiscal Policy — diagnosis, measures, and staff recommendations
- Main cause: long-term decline in the revenue effort; NFPS revenue fell by 6 percentage points of GDP between 1997 and 2003.
- Factors for revenue decline: weak tax administration; nonindexation of excises to inflation; failure to combine trade liberalization with offsetting revenue measures; 2002 cap on electricity tariff increases.
- Capital spending squeeze: fell from almost 4 percent of GDP in the late 1990s to about 2¾ percent of GDP in 2004.
- Recent tax administration actions: registration checks, prosecution of tax evaders, lifestyle checks, dismissal of corrupt tax officials, computerized matching of VAT receipts.
  - Outcome to date: arrested the decline in tax-to-GDP ratio but no increase yet.
- Staff recommended reduction of NFPS deficit by about 2 percentage points of GDP in 2005.
  - 2005 budget aim: reduce national government deficit to 3.6 percent of GDP, primarily via spending restraint, including no general wage increase.
  - Staff projection: combined with lower NPC losses, NFPS deficit would decline by about 1 percent of GDP to 4½ percent of GDP in 2005.
  - Staff further recommended saving a sufficient portion of new revenue so as to lower NFPS deficit to 3½ percent of GDP in 2005.
- Legislative progress and measures:
  - Higher alcohol, cigarette, and tobacco excises yielding about 0.2 percent of GDP (signed into law December 2004).
  - Petroleum excise duties low by international standards; duties on oil and petroleum imports raised by Executive Order from 3 to 5 percent from January 1, 2005 (expected yield 0.1 percent of GDP).
  - Authorities decided to seek immediate increase in VAT rate from 10 to 12 percent.
- Fiscal incentives reform proposals:
  - Eliminate incentives from many disparate economic laws; repeal nonstandard VAT exemptions (potential yield 0.2–0.3 percent of GDP).
  - Consolidate investment incentives into a single law; draft bill would place a 20-year limit on currently open-ended incentives.
- Staff concerns:
  - Oppose proposed tax amnesty.
  - Doubts about revenue benefits of incentives-for-collectors scheme.
  - Concern that telecom franchise tax plus VAT exemption could break VAT chain; proposal set aside.
- Civil service reform:
  - EO (October 2004) ordered rationalization plans; preliminary estimates: perhaps 2–4 percent of public employees affected, severance payments costing 0.1–0.3 percent of GDP.
  - Staff recommendation: limit generous severance payments to preserve budget gains.
- Public pension funds:
  - Currently running small cash surpluses.
  - Risks: weak asset management, high benefit replacement rates, insufficient contribution rates could deplete funds as early as 2015.
  - Authorities established a working group to consider reform options.

### B. Power Sector — measures, privatization, and impact
- Legal framework: EPIRA (2001) to restructure electricity market and privatize power sector assets to encourage competition and private investment.
- Recent measures to strengthen NPC finances:
  - Provisional average tariff increase granted to NPC by ERC in September: P 0.98 per kWh.
  - Tariff increase estimated to yield about 0.7 percent of GDP in annual revenue.
  - Government decision to absorb P 200 billion in NPC debts from the beginning of 2005.
  - Effect: lower interest costs and tariff hike expected to help NPC reduce its deficit from 1½ percent of GDP in 2004 to ¾ percent of GDP in 2005.
- Privatization progress and plans:
  - Authorities aim to privatize 70 percent of generation assets by end-2005.
  - Introduction of wholesale spot market expected in mid-2006.
  - Announced privatization so far: one large and five small power plants worth about $570 million in total.
  - Under EPIRA, privatization proceeds to be used to retire power sector debt.
- Regulatory improvements:
  - ERC conducted transparent process awarding NPC tariff increase (provisional pending final ruling and appeals).
  - ERC reviewed generation rate adjustment mechanism for distribution utilities.
  - Phasing out of cross subsidies among consumer classes.

### C. Monetary Policy — BSP stance and staff view
- BSP view: inflation jump driven by supply side factors; monetary policy not appropriate response unless supply shocks are transcending; BSP announced criteria for response and kept policy neutral.
- Staff assessment:
  - Several measures of core inflation suggested initial price pressure spreading to other sectors.
  - Level of core inflation remained well above BSP’s target range.
  - About a third of the increase in headline inflation since end-2003 was due to factors other than identifiable supply side factors.
  - Capacity utilization rising; credit growth low but decoupled from GDP growth.
  - Staff argued for policy tightening to guide inflationary expectations down.
- Staff noted: inflation promised to remain above the target at least until 2006; recent upward shift in the yield curve suggestive of higher inflationary expectations.

### D. Financial Sector Policy — vulnerabilities and reforms
- Banking system concerns:
  - Deficiencies in accounting and loan classification practices overstate capital adequacy.
  - Several large banks downgraded by an international rating agency due to latent losses on NPAs.
  - Large assistance by PDIC to several banks raises questions about capacity to absorb losses.
- SPV framework and NPA resolution:
  - Transactions concluded or near conclusion likely disposing of P 30 billion in NPAs out of a total stock of roughly P 500 billion.
  - Asset disposal process moved slowly; staff urged more pressure on banks to recognize latent losses and inject fresh capital.
- BSP Charter amendments:
  - Proposed amendments to provide supervisors legal protection, enhance prompt corrective action and bank resolution frameworks.
- Interest-rate risk and capital buffers:
  - Regular bank units and FCDUs have large exposure to long-term fixed-rate government securities.
  - Staff encouraged BSP to strengthen monitoring of interest-rate risks and enhance data collection.
  - Stress testing note: an interest rate shock of 300 basis points could reduce capital adequacy ratio of a sample of 11 large banks, currently 13½ percent, by as much as 3 percentage points if all securities were marked to market.
- Other reforms: clearer rules for trust funds business; enhancement of internal credit risk rating systems; domestic capital market development emphasized.

### E. Medium-Term Outlook — scenarios, projections, and fiscal/debt implications
- Staff view: competitiveness measured by real effective exchange rate not the major obstacle; take-off likely requires strong fiscal and structural reforms.
- Growth scenarios:
  - Authorities’ MTPDP projections of 7–8 percent growth viewed as optimistic.
  - Staff projection under strong reforms: growth would trend up to 6 percent.
  - Staff projection under moderate reform scenario: growth of about 4 percent is more likely.
- Fiscal and debt implications:
  - Strong reform scenario: balanced budget by 2010; NFPS debt fall to 73 percent of GDP (almost 30 percentage points lower than present level).
  - Moderate reform scenario: NFPS deficit would fall no lower than 4 percent of GDP; debt would edge down and vulnerabilities remain high.
- MTPDP macro targets excerpt (as presented):
  - GDP Growth (%) by year: 2004: 4.9-5.8; 2005: 5.3-6.3; 2006: 6.3-7.3; 2007: 6.5-7.5; 2008: 6.8-7.8; 2009: 7.0-8.0; 2010: 7.0-8.0.
  - Exports of goods and services ($Bn): 2004: 43.1; 2005: 47.4; 2006: 52.3; 2007: 58.2; 2008: 65.4; 2009: 74.3; 2010: 84.3.
  - Investment-to-GDP 1/: 2004: 20.1; 2005: 20.3; 2006: 21.4; 2007: 22.5; 2008: 24.1; 2009: 25.8; 2010: 27.7.
  - Inflation (%) by year: 2004: 4.0-5.0; 2005: 4.0-5.0; 2006: 4.0-5.0; 2007: 3.0-4.0; 2008: 3.0-4.0; 2009: 3.0-4.0; 2010: 3.0-4.0.
  - NG Deficit/GDP: 2004: 4.2; 2005: 3.6; 2006: 2.9; 2007: 2.0; 2008: 1.1; 2009: 0.2; 2010: 0.0.
  - CPSD/GDP 2/: 2004: 6.7; 2005: 6.0; 2006: 5.3; 2007: 4.6; 2008: 3.9; 2009: 3.0; 2010: 1.0.

### Box 3 — Benefits of Reform (summary of key quantified outcomes)
- Moderate-reform scenario:
  - Growth trends down towards 4 percent over the medium term.
  - Nonfinancial public sector debt falls to 93 percent of GDP.
- Strong-reform scenario:
  - Growth could accelerate to 6 percent.
  - Public debt would decline to about 73 percent of GDP.
  - Government balances the budget by 2010.
- Employment effects (strong reforms):
  - Additional 1.7 million jobs by 2010.
  - Would bring unemployment back to below 11 percent.
  - Assumptions: labor force growth 3.5 percent per year; job creation elasticity 0.7.
- Poverty and incomes (strong reforms):
  - Move an additional 2 million people out of poverty (US$2 a day threshold).
  - Assumptions: population growth 2 percent a year; average income US$170 higher in real terms by 2010 under strong reforms (based on 2000 Family Income and Expenditure survey and assuming no change in income distribution).
- Public spending:
  - Higher revenue under strong-reform scenario would provide resources for P 130 billion in additional public spending by 2010 without compromising fiscal consolidation targets.
  - Potential uses: recruit 200,000 teachers; recruit 20,000 health workers; increase infrastructure spending by 40 percent; purchase an extra 15 million textbooks every year.

### Fiscal measures under consideration and staff positions (selected)
- VAT rate increase: raise VAT from 10 to 12 percent; staff strongly support.
- Repeal of some VAT exemptions: estimated revenue impact 0.2–0.3 (percent of GDP); staff support.
- Consolidation of fiscal incentives: direction/impact unclear; staff support transparency goals but House version may not reduce large incentives.
- Simplified net income tax for businesses: disallows some deductions and would cut corporate rate from 32 to 28 percent; staff oppose.
- Higher petroleum excises: estimated yield 0.4–0.5 (percent of GDP); staff support raising petroleum excises.
- Telecommunications tax (turnover tax replacing VAT): estimated yield 0.2 (percent of GDP); staff oppose.

### Key macroeconomic and summary indicators (selected exact figures)
- Nominal GNP (2003): $85.2 billion
- Population (2003, est.): 81.1million
- GNP per capita (2003, est.): $1,051
- IMF quota: SDR 879.9 million
- Real GDP growth (percentage change): 2000: 4.4; 2001: 1.8; 2002: 4.3; 2003: 4.7; 2004: 6.1; 2005 (Staff Est.): 4.7
- Nominal GDP (in billions of pesos): 2000: 3,355; 2001: 3,631; 2002: 3,960; 2003: 4,300; 2004: 4,843; 2005 (Staff Est.): 5,399
- CPI (1994 base; annual average): 2000: 4.3; 2001: 6.1; 2002: 3.0; 2003: 3.0; 2004: 5.5; 2005 (Staff Est.): 6.8
- National government balance (authorities definition) (percent of GDP): 2000: -4.0; 2001: -4.0; 2002: -5.3; 2003: -4.6; 2004: -3.8; 2005 (Staff Est.): -3.5
- Nonfinancial public sector debt (percent of GDP): 2001: 88.4; 2002: 93.9; 2003: 101.1; 2004: 99.2; 2005 (Staff Est.): 96.8
- Current account (percent of GDP): 2000: 8.2; 2001: 1.9; 2002: 5.7; 2003: 4.2; 2004: 4.5; 2005 (Staff Est.): 3.5
- BSP Gross Reserves (adjusted, US$ billions): 2000: 13.4; 2001: 13.2; 2002: 14.3; 2003: 14.7; 2004: 15.1; 2005 (Staff Est.): 14.9

### Debt sustainability analysis — baseline and sensitivities (selected exact outcomes)
- Baseline (moderate reforms): debt around 93 percent of GDP.
  - Baseline assumptions: average real GDP growth 4¼ percent over 2005–10 and a primary balance adjustment of 1 percent of GDP in 2005–06.
- Alternative Scenario 2 (policy slippage): primary balance unchanged; average real GDP growth 3¾ percent over 2005–10; debt would continue to climb.
- Alternative Scenario 3 (strong reforms): primary balance adjustment of 2¾ percentage points of GDP over 2005–07 (major part in 2005) and average real GDP growth 5¼ percent would put debt on a firmly downward path.
- Sensitivity to shocks (Bounds Tests): high sensitivity, especially to exchange rate and growth shocks.
  - B5 (One time 30 percent real depreciation in 2005): Nonfinancial public sector debt jumps to 129.6 in immediate test year and remains elevated (sequence: 129.6; 127.8; 127.4; 127.1; 127.1; 127.2).
- Identified debt-creating flows (2005 baseline entries, percent of GDP):
  - Primary deficit: -2.2
  - Revenue and grants: 21.7
  - Primary (noninterest) expenditure: 19.4
  - Automatic debt dynamics contribution: -1.3
  - Contribution from exchange rate depreciation: 2.3
  - Residual, including asset changes: 1.2

### Key balances and external financing needs (selected exact figures)
- Current account balance (US$ billions): 2000: 6.3; 2001: 1.3; 2002: 4.4; 2003: 3.3; 2004: 3.9; 2005 (Staff Est.): 3.3
- Trade balance (US$ billions): 2000: 3.8; 2001: -0.7; 2002: 0.4; 2003: -1.3; 2004: -1.0; 2005 (Staff Est.): -1.4
- Gross external financing needs (US$ billions): 2005: 10.4; projected to rise to 15.3 by 2010.

### Statistical issues and data quality — main weaknesses
- National accounts: large discrepancies between expenditure and production sides; outdated benchmark (1988) and fixed I-O ratios at 1985 prices; many new establishments not covered.
- Balance of payments: improved measurement of imports but significant weaknesses remain; errors and omissions sizable; FCDU secrecy rules create reporting gaps.
  - Errors and omissions and “trade credits” accounted for outflows of US$4.4 billion (5.6 percent of GDP) in 2002.
- Monetary statistics: framework largely conforms to Fund methodology but coverage and valuation issues remain.
- Fiscal data: budget on obligations basis while deficit reported on cash basis; consolidated outturns beyond central government limited.

### Millennium Development Goals and social indicators (selected exact figures)
- Population below $1 per day (percent): 20.0; 18.0; 14.6
- Net enrolment ratio (percent): 97.5; 100.0; 93.0
- Under five mortality rate (per 1,000): 63.0; 50.0; 40.0; 37.0
- Access to an improved water source (percent of population): 87.0; 86.0
- Fixed telephone lines and cellular subscribers (per 1,000 population): 10.0; 27.7; 197.8; 232.9
- Poverty headcount (percent of population): 40.6
- Population (million): 61.0; 68.3; 78.3; 79.9

### IMF staff representative update (March 7, 2005) — market and policy notes
- Moody’s downgraded Philippines long-term sovereign ratings by 2-notches in mid-February to B1.
- Markets in 2005 to date: peso up by 2 percent against the U.S. dollar; sovereign spreads on EMBI+ Philippines index declined broadly in line with EMBI+ Global index.
- Authorities revised 2005 national government deficit target from 3.6 percent of GDP to 3.4 percent of GDP after increases in excises.
- Authorities revised 2005 inflation target to 5–6 percent to reflect 2000-based CPI and supply-side pressure.
- Philippines removed from FATF list of Non-Cooperative Countries and Territories; FATF announced AML measures being effectively implemented.

### Authorities’ view, appointments, and priorities
- New appointments: Mr. Cesar Purisima as Secretary of Finance; Mr. Amando M. Tetangco, Jr. to become BSP Governor in July; Mr. Juan Santos as Secretary of Trade and Industry; Mr. Raphael Lotilla as Secretary of Energy.
- Authorities emphasize prompt and bold action to reduce medium-term vulnerabilities in fiscal, financial, and energy sectors while addressing social challenges.
- Fiscal consolidation remains top priority; phased-in and multi-pronged strategy emphasized with awareness of political economy constraints.

*Source: _cr05105*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Key macro-fiscal and structural problems
- Nonfinancial public sector (NFPS) deficit has been 5½ percent of GDP in recent years.
- Public debt rose above GDP in 2003.
- Primary cause: significant decline in the ratio of tax revenue to GDP.
- NPC (National Power Corporation) losses increased the fiscal strain.
- Banking system undercapitalized with one-quarter of assets nonperforming.
- Increased exposure of banks to government securities.
- Large external financing requirements and high debt levels increase vulnerability to changes in market sentiment and global financial market conditions.

### Reform actions taken since July 2004
- Congress passed two of President Arroyo’s proposed tax measures, including an increase in alcohol and tobacco excises expected to yield about 0.2 percent of GDP in annual revenue.
- A VAT rate hike (expected yield 0.5 percent of GDP) is under discussion in Congress.
- In the power sector: a 40 percent hike in generation tariffs (yielding 0.7 percent of GDP) has been provisionally awarded; sale of a large generation plant announced.
- In the banking sector: disposal of nonperforming assets has begun using the special purpose vehicle (SPV) framework; legal amendments to strengthen bank supervision submitted to Congress.
- In mining: Supreme Court decision that foreign control of mining projects is not unconstitutional, opening the way for FDI.

### Assessment of progress and market reaction
- Reforms implemented to date represent a small part of what is required; markets remain sensitive.
- One rating agency downgraded the sovereign rating in January 2005 citing inadequate tax reforms.
- Vulnerabilities will remain high until fiscal and structural problems are solved and reform implementation improves.

### Recent economic developments (2004–2005)
- GDP grew by a little over 6 percent in 2004, up from 4¾ percent in 2003.
- Employment increased by 3.6 percent in 2004; unemployment averaged 11.8 percent, up from 11.4 percent a year earlier.
- Poverty: almost one sixth of the population living on less than $1 a day (Annex VII).
- Inflation (1994 base): rose to 7.9 percent (y/y) in December 2004 from 3.1 percent (y/y) in December 2003; average inflation rose to 5.5 percent, above the BSP’s target range of 4–5 percent.
  - Inflation measured using the 2000 based CPI rose to 8.6 percent in December 2004 (y/y) and averaged 6.0 percent for the year.
  - Official core inflation reached 7.6 percent (y/y) in December (1994 base).
- BSP kept policy rates on hold pending clearer evidence of generalized inflation.
- National government deficit (authorities’ definition) estimated at 3.8 percent of GDP in 2004 (below budget target of 4.2 percent), down from 4.6 percent of GDP in 2003.
- Revenue estimated broadly unchanged as a share of GDP in 2004; primary spending compressed.
- NPC losses expanded from 1.1 percent of GDP in 2003 to 1.5 percent of GDP in 2004.
  - NFPS deficit estimated at 5.3 percent of GDP in 2004, compared to 5.6 percent of GDP in 2003.
- Balance of payments: current account surplus estimated at 4½ percent of GDP in 2004.
- Reserves, adjusted for pledged assets, ended 2004 at $15 billion (119 percent of short-term debt by residual maturity).
- BSP reduced NDF position built in early 2004 by about $0.8 billion.

### Near-term outlook and risks
- GDP projected at 4¾ percent in 2005 (down from 2004’s little over 6 percent).
- Key downside risks:
  - Disorderly depreciation of the U.S. dollar leading to weaker global growth.
  - Oil prices retracing toward US$60 per barrel.
  - Markets losing patience with reform implementation speed.
- Key upside conditions:
  - Oil prices falling from current levels.
  - Stronger-than-expected reform implementation (with benefits mainly over the medium term).
- External financing vulnerability:
  - Staff estimate public sector external commercial borrowing needs at $4–4½ billion (5-6 percent of GDP) if reserves are to be maintained at comfortable levels.
  - An increase in global interest rates of 100 basis points would add about $0.3 billion to interest payments in 2005.

### Policy recommendations emphasized by staff
- Fiscal policy
  - Fiscal consolidation should be significantly front-loaded to signal commitment to tackling the fiscal problem.
  - Passage of further tax measures with clear revenue impact (e.g., VAT rate increase) is required.
  - Much of the additional revenue should be saved (i.e., used to improve primary balances).
- Power sector
  - Accelerate reforms, with priority on privatization of transmission and generation assets.
- Monetary policy
  - The BSP should raise interest rates to guide inflationary expectations down.
- Financial sector
  - Expedite passage of amendments to the BSP Charter to strengthen bank supervision and facilitate recapitalization of the banking sector.

### Implementation and political economy considerations
- Staff noted some reforms have political economy roots (Box 1) and urged the authorities to capitalize on strengthened majorities in Congress to take bold upfront actions.
- Staff cautioned that reforms become more difficult as the administration’s term progresses and political attention shifts toward the next election.

*Source: _cr05105 - Executive Summary*

### 12.      The authorities, by contrast, considered reforms to be proceeding at a

### _cr05105 - 12.      The authorities, by contrast, considered reforms to be proceeding at a

### A. Fiscal Policy
- Main cause of fiscal problems: long-term decline in the revenue effort. NFPS revenue fell by 6 percentage points of GDP between 1997 and 2003.
- Factors cited for revenue decline: weak tax administration, nonindexation of excises to inflation, failure to combine trade liberalization with offsetting revenue measures, and the government’s decision in 2002 to cap increases in electricity tariffs.
- One policy response: squeeze on capital spending, which fell from almost 4 percent of GDP in the late 1990s to about 2¾ percent of GDP in 2004.
- Recent administration actions to strengthen tax administration: registration checks, prosecution of tax evaders, lifestyle checks, dismissal of corrupt tax officials, and computerized matching of VAT receipts.
- Outcome to date: efforts have arrested the decline in the tax to GDP ratio but have yet to cause any increase.
- Staff support: welcomed the new administration’s goal of raising significant additional revenue through new tax measures, and extra revenue accruing to NPC from the tariff increase.
- Staff recommendation: reduce the NFPS deficit by about 2 percentage points of GDP in 2005.
- 2005 budget aim: reduce the national government deficit to 3.6 percent of GDP, primarily via spending restraint, including no general wage increase.
- Staff projection: combined with lower NPC losses, NFPS deficit would decline by about 1 percent of GDP to 4½ percent of GDP in 2005.
- Staff further recommendation: save a sufficient portion of new revenue so as to lower the NFPS deficit to 3½ percent of GDP in 2005.
- Legislative progress and revenue measures:
  - Only one clear revenue-impact tax measure passed to date: higher alcohol, cigarette, and tobacco excises yielding about 0.2 percent of GDP.
  - Petroleum excise duties noted as low by international standards; authorities raised duties on oil and petroleum imports by Executive Order from 3 to 5 percent from January 1, 2005, expected to yield annual revenue of 0.1 percent of GDP.
  - Authorities decided to seek an immediate increase in the VAT rate from 10 to 12 percent.
- Fiscal incentives rationalization:
  - Proposal to eliminate incentives from many disparate economic laws, including those given to cooperatives (potentially substantial revenue).
  - Proposal to remove nonstandard VAT exemptions such as for petroleum products, yielding 0.2–0.3 percent of GDP.
  - Proposal to consolidate investment incentives into a single law (could result in net expansion of incentives); draft bill would place a 20-year limit on currently open-ended incentives.
- Staff concerns on certain measures:
  - Opposition to proposed tax amnesty because of likely adverse effects on compliance.
  - Doubts about the revenue benefits of a scheme to improve incentives for revenue collectors.
  - Concern that a proposed franchise tax on telecom companies combined with a VAT exemption could break the VAT chain; proposal has been set aside, as has the earlier proposal to introduce a Gross Income Tax.
- Civil service reform:
  - Executive order (October 2004) ordered agencies to prepare rationalization plans; personnel in redundant positions can opt for severance payments or reassignment.
  - Preliminary estimates: perhaps 2–4 percent of public employees affected, with severance payments costing 0.1–0.3 percent of GDP.
  - Staff recommendation: limit generous severance payments to preserve budget gains; authorities working with the World Bank on specifics.
- Public pension funds:
  - Currently running small cash surpluses.
  - Risks: weak asset management, high benefit replacement rates, insufficient contribution rates could deplete pension funds as early as 2015.
  - Authorities established a working group to consider reform options.

### B. Power Sector
- Legal framework: Electric Power Industry Reform Act (EPIRA) of 2001 aims to restructure the electricity market and privatize power sector assets to encourage competition and private investment.
- Earlier impediments: pro-consumer tariff decisions undermined NPC financial viability; Transco privatization biddings failed twice.
- Recent measures to strengthen NPC finances:
  - Provisional average tariff increase granted to NPC by ERC in September: P 0.98 per kWh.
  - Tariff increase estimated to yield about 0.7 percent of GDP in annual revenue.
  - Government decision to absorb P 200 billion in NPC debts from the beginning of 2005.
  - Effect: lower interest costs and the tariff hike expected to help NPC reduce its deficit from 1½ percent of GDP in 2004 to ¾ percent of GDP in 2005.
- Privatization progress and plans:
  - Authorities terminated bilateral Transco negotiations in October and reopened competitive bidding.
  - Authorities aim to privatize 70 percent of generation assets by end-2005.
  - Introduction of wholesale spot market expected in mid-2006.
  - Announced privatization so far: one large and five small power plants worth about $570 million in total.
  - Under EPIRA, privatization proceeds to be used to retire power sector debt.
- Regulatory improvements:
  - ERC conducted transparent process awarding NPC tariff increase (tariff award provisional pending final ERC ruling and possible appeals).
  - ERC reviewed generation rate adjustment mechanism for distribution utilities to allow more timely cost recovery.
  - Phasing out of cross subsidies among consumer classes to improve consumption efficiency.
  - Authorities agree rules-based regulatory framework would facilitate privatization and ensure adequate investment.

### C. Monetary Policy
- BSP view: inflation jump driven by supply side factors; monetary policy not appropriate response. BSP called for administrative measures to ease supply bottlenecks in importation and distribution.
- Observation: oil shock had a relatively large effect because there was no attempt to use subsidies or other measures to reduce pass-through of international oil prices to domestic inflation.
- BSP stance on tightening: not yet reached. BSP announced criteria for monetary policy response: inflation pressures beyond supply shocks; emerging demand-side pressures on inflation; risk of prolonged exchange market pressure. BSP judged these criteria not clearly met.
- BSP assessment: evidence for second-round effects of supply shocks weak; increase in core inflation likely temporary; consumption growing rapidly but private credit growth remained moderate; high unemployment and absence of wage pressures indicate continued slack.
- Staff assessment: balance of risks suggested need for policy tightening.
  - Several measures of core inflation suggested initial price pressure spreading to other sectors.
  - Level of core inflation remained well above the BSP’s target range.
  - About a third of the increase in headline inflation since end-2003 was due to factors other than identifiable supply side factors.
  - Capacity utilization was rising (short time series but tended to co-move with inflation).
  - Credit growth remained low but had decoupled from GDP growth in recent years.
- Staff further notes:
  - Continued high inflation, even if supply-driven, might affect inflationary expectations.
  - Inflation promised to remain above the target at least until 2006.
  - Recent upward shift in the yield curve suggestive of higher inflationary expectations for longer periods.
  - Market concerns about macroeconomic framework given overriding fiscal problem; a rate increase would signal BSP commitment to inflation target.
  - Authorities noted bond markets illiquid at longer tenors and downplayed yield curve information content but were attentive to the risk of deteriorating inflation expectations.

### D. Financial Sector Policy
- Staff welcomed priority on financial sector reform: revised supervisory enforcement frameworks and corporate debt restructuring proposals to improve system resilience.
- Measures to increase transparency and confidence: clear rules for trust funds business; enhancement of internal credit risk rating systems of banks.
- Emphasis on domestic capital market development to provide alternate finance sources for private and public sectors.
- Concerns on bank capitalization:
  - Deficiencies in accounting and loan classification practices overstate capital adequacy, particularly for certain banks.
  - Several large banks recently downgraded by an international rating agency due to latent losses on NPAs.
  - Large assistance by PDIC to several banks raises questions about capacity to absorb losses.
- SPV framework and NPA resolution:
  - Some transactions concluded or near conclusion, likely disposing of P 30 billion in NPAs out of a total stock of roughly P 500 billion.
  - Asset disposal process has moved slowly; staff urged more pressure on banks to recognize latent losses and inject fresh capital.
  - Authorities noted major progress requires strengthening powers of bank supervisors.
- BSP Charter amendments:
  - Proposed amendments fundamental to strengthening banking system: provide supervisors adequate legal protection, enhance prompt corrective action and bank resolution frameworks to make intervention credible.
  - Staff encouraged by changes in proposed amendments; authorities hopeful legislators will respond more positively.
- Interest-rate risk and capital buffers:
  - Regular bank units and FCDUs have large exposure to government securities; exposures are long-term and fixed-rate, creating vulnerability should rates rise.
  - Staff encouraged BSP to strengthen monitoring of interest-rate risks and enhance data collection.
  - Stress testing note: an interest rate shock of 300 basis points could reduce the capital adequacy ratio of a sample of 11 large banks, currently 13½ percent, by as much as 3 percentage points if all securities were marked to market.

### E. Medium-Term Outlook
- Need for reforms: economic reforms necessary to invigorate growth; agriculture and services buoyant, industry less vigorous.
- Staff view: competitiveness as measured by real effective exchange rate not the major obstacle; take-off likely requires strong fiscal and structural reforms to improve business climate, increase investment, productivity, and GDP growth.
- Authorities’ Medium-term Philippine Development Plan, 2004-2010 (MTPDP): sustained and accelerated growth will require addressing the fiscal problem and enhancing competitiveness through measures to boost productivity, improve infrastructure, reduce corruption, and simplify business procedures.
- Growth scenarios and staff projections:
  - Authorities’ MTPDP projections that growth could rise to 7–8 percent appear optimistic.
  - Staff projection under strong reforms: growth would trend up to 6 percent.
  - Staff projection under moderate reform scenario (reform momentum slower and dissipates by mid-administration term): growth of about 4 percent is more likely.
- Fiscal and debt implications under scenarios:
  - Under strong reform scenario: authorities would achieve balanced budget objectives by 2010, and nonfinancial public sector debt would fall to 73 percent of GDP, almost 30 percentage points lower than the present level.
  - Under moderate reform scenario: NFPS deficit would fall no lower than 4 percent of GDP, debt would edge down, and vulnerabilities would remain high.
- MTPDP macroeconomic targets excerpt (as presented):
  - GDP Growth (%) by year: 2004: 4.9-5.8; 2005: 5.3-6.3; 2006: 6.3-7.3; 2007: 6.5-7.5; 2008: 6.8-7.8; 2009: 7.0-8.0; 2010: 7.0-8.0.
  - Exports of goods and services ($Bn): 2004: 43.1; 2005: 47.4; 2006: 52.3; 2007: 58.2; 2008: 65.4; 2009: 74.3; 2010: 84.3.
  - Investment-to-GDP 1/: 2004: 20.1; 2005: 20.3; 2006: 21.4; 2007: 22.5; 2008: 24.1; 2009: 25.8; 2010: 27.7. (Fighting target: achieve investment-to-GDP ratio of 28 percent in 2 years.)
  - Inflation (%) by year: 2004: 4.0-5.0; 2005: 4.0-5.0; 2006: 4.0-5.0; 2007: 3.0-4.0; 2008: 3.0-4.0; 2009: 3.0-4.0; 2010: 3.0-4.0.
  - NG Deficit/GDP: 2004: 4.2; 2005: 3.6; 2006: 2.9; 2007: 2.0; 2008: 1.1; 2009: 0.2; 2010: 0.0.
  - CPSD/GDP 2/: 2004: 6.7; 2005: 6.0; 2006: 5.3; 2007: 4.6; 2008: 3.9; 2009: 3.0; 2010: 1.0.

*Italic: IMF staff report excerpt: _cr05105 - 12.      The authorities, by contrast, considered reforms to be proceeding at a*

### 35.      The case for reform might resonate with a wider audience in the Philippines if

### _cr05105 - 35.      The case for reform might resonate with a wider audience in the Philippines if

### Reform case and labor-market outcomes
- Presentation of reform benefits in terms of tangible social indicators (employment creation, poverty reduction) could broaden political and public support.
- Staff finding: GDP growth of 4–4½ percent per annum (the staff’s moderate reform scenario) seemed insufficient to halt the upward trend in unemployment.
- A decline in the unemployment rate was likely to require growth rates of at least 6 percent.
- Simple calculations indicated that strong reforms could imply substantial benefits in terms of poverty reduction and provide more fiscal room for socially beneficial spending.
- Box figure: "Number of people moving above a US$2 a day income (cumulative, in millions)" plotted for 2005–2010 with scenarios labeled "Strong reform" and "Moderate reform."

### Trade, external sector, and AML
- Authorities remain committed to the multilateral trading system while pursuing regional and bilateral trade agreements where appropriate.
- Major elements of a bilateral FTA with Japan reportedly concluded, including phased tariff reductions for a number of products (including some agricultural products) and easing of restrictions on employment of Philippine nationals in Japan.
- ASEAN discussions on FTAs with China and India are under way.
- Staff analysis: the ending of the Multi-Fiber Agreement will have negative effects on the Philippines, but these should be relatively moderate given that garments and textiles account for less than 7 percent of total exports.
- Following selective tariff increases in 2004, the average tariff rate increased to 7.5 percent from 6.2 percent in 2003.
- The Philippines continued to be classified as noncooperative with regard to its AML framework; authorities noted that the AML framework, as amended in March 2003, was now consistent with international standards and awaited FATF evaluation of implementation.

### Fiscal policy assessment and recommendations
- Progress on reforms has begun, but major parts of the reform agenda remain unfinished and vulnerabilities remain high.
- Staff recommendation for 2005: a reduction in the NFPS deficit of about 2 percentage points of GDP to signal commitment to fiscal correction while recognizing growing difficulty over the administration’s term.
- Projection: the NFPS deficit is expected to decline to about 4½ percent of GDP in 2005, reflecting targeted cuts in the national government deficit and lower NPC losses as a result of the higher electricity tariff. This is a reduction of about 1 percentage point of GDP over 2004.
- The 2005 projection does not incorporate revenue from various tax measures still under consideration; a substantial revenue yield from these measures is essential to allow additional priority spending and more aggressive deficit reduction.
- High quality tax measures should be the first priority:
  - To date only one tax measure with a clear revenue impact has been passed by Congress.
  - Staff welcome consideration of the higher VAT rate and the repeal of special tax exemptions (for example, the VAT exemption of petroleum).
  - Further tax-administration improvements recommended, including improved audit strategies and increased prosecution of evaders.
- Durable fiscal consolidation requires restructuring government and strengthening pension schemes; severance packages paid under civil service reform should not be overly generous.

### Power sector, monetary policy, and financial sector
- Power sector:
  - Significant provisional increase in NPC’s generation tariffs awarded in September is an important step.
  - Recently announced sale of a large power plant and plans to sell transmission assets as soon as possible and the majority of generation assets by the end of 2005.
  - Need to build adherence to a predictable rules-based energy regulatory framework to improve the investment climate.
- Monetary policy:
  - Supply shocks were the root cause of missing the inflation target in 2004, but signs indicate price pressures have spread.
  - Staff view: the balance has tipped toward requiring an increase in rates to guide inflationary expectations down.
  - Staff welcome the BSP’s commitment to be guided by its inflation objective and to manage the exchange rate flexibly (and not defend any particular exchange rate level).
- Financial sector:
  - Banks are beginning to use special purpose vehicle framework to dispose of nonperforming assets.
  - Amendments to the BSP Charter to strengthen bank supervision have been submitted to Congress.
  - Steps taken to strengthen regulation of banks’ trust operations; reforms should facilitate consolidation and recapitalization of the banking system.
  - Concern remains because past attempts to empower bank supervisors have repeatedly failed.

### Structural and institutional issues; investment climate
- Authorities are strengthening statistics; staff look forward to further implementation of Fund technical assistance recommendations on balance of payments and public debt statistics.
- Box 1 (Political economy of fiscal reforms):
  - Fiscal deterioration attributed to tax policy changes, weakening tax administration, and underlying political factors—particularly political fractionalization.
  - Literature suggests political fractionalization (lack of legislative cohesion) leads to poor fiscal discipline.
  - Empirical observation: the Ramos presidency’s fiscal improvement coincided with a more cohesive legislature; increased fragmentation after the 1998 election coincided with fiscal decline and public debt growth.
- Box 2 (Investment climate):
  - Average growth in the Philippines in 1999-2003 was four percent.
  - Lower growth partly explained by lower capital formation.
  - World Economic Forum’s 2004 GCI placed the Philippines’ competitiveness ranking at the 76th (out of 104).
  - The Philippines fares poorly relative to comparators on quality of public institutions (corruption, regulatory and contracts environment) and on the macroeconomic environment (government waste and macroeconomic stability); competitive on technology indicators.
  - World Bank’s Doing Business in 2005 indicates the labor market is less flexible in the Philippines than in the comparator group.
  - The Medium-Term Philippine Development Plan (MTPDP) 2004–10 calls for balancing the budget by 2010, addressing corruption, simplifying business procedures, and introducing more flexibility in the Labor Code.

### Procedural recommendation
- It is recommended that the next Article IV Consultation with the Philippines be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpts in _cr05105 - 35.      The case for reform might resonate with a wider audience in the Philippines if*

### Box 3. Benefits of Reform

### Box 3. Benefits of Reform

### Overview
- Staff frame benefits of up-front fiscal consolidation and strong reforms in terms of faster GDP growth and better debt dynamics.
- Under current policies (moderate-reform scenario), GDP growth will trend down towards 4 percent over the medium term, reducing the nonfinancial public sector debt to 93 percent of GDP.
- If the government improves the investment climate through needed reforms and balances the budget by 2010 (strong-reform scenario), growth could accelerate to 6 percent and public debt would decline to about 73 percent of GDP.
- Communicating benefits in terms of social outcomes or outlays may better resonate with the public and help build a broader constituency for reform.

### Growth and debt scenarios
- Moderate-reform scenario:
  - Growth trends down towards 4 percent over the medium term.
  - Nonfinancial public sector debt falls to 93 percent of GDP.
- Strong-reform scenario:
  - Growth could accelerate to 6 percent.
  - Public debt would decline to about 73 percent of GDP.
  - Government balances the budget by 2010.

### Employment effects
- Strong reforms would create an additional 1.7 million jobs by 2010.
- This would reverse the rising trend in unemployment and bring it back to below 11 percent.
- Assumptions:
  - Labor force growth of 3.5 percent per year.
  - Elasticity of job creation of 0.7.

### Poverty and incomes
- Faster growth under the strong-reform scenario would raise average incomes and move an additional 2 million people out of poverty.
- Assumptions and estimates:
  - Population growth of 2 percent a year.
  - Average income would be US$170 higher in real terms by 2010 under the strong-reform scenario.
  - Based on the 2000 Family Income and Expenditure survey and assuming no change in the income distribution, the US$170 improvement would move two million additional people currently living under US$2 a day out of poverty.

### Public spending and social outcomes
- Higher revenue under the strong-reform scenario would provide resources for P 130 billion in additional public spending by 2010 without compromising the government’s fiscal consolidation targets.
- Potential uses of additional P 130 billion:
  - Recruitment of an additional 200,000 teachers.
  - Recruitment of an additional 20,000 health workers.
  - Increase in infrastructure spending of 40 percent.
  - Purchase of an extra 15 million textbooks every year.

### Assumptions and data sources referenced in the box
- Labor force growth assumption: 3.5 percent per year.
- Job creation elasticity: 0.7.
- Population growth assumption: 2 percent a year.
- Poverty threshold referenced: US$2 a day.
- Income survey referenced: 2000 Family Income and Expenditure survey.

### Table: Status of Revenue Measures Proposed by New Administration (summarized)
- Higher alcohol and tobacco excises
  - Status: Signed into law in December 2004
  - Yield: 0.2
  - Description/Staff View: The rates of increase vary by product but, on average, imply roughly a 10 percent increase in retail prices. There is no automatic indexation, but the excises will be increased by 6–8 percent every two years until 2011. Staff support higher excises but also argued for indexation.
- Incentives for tax administrators
  - Status: Signed into law in January 2005
  - Yield: Unclear
  - Description/Staff View: Allows tax and customs administrators to keep a percentage of revenue in excess of target (although the Bureau of Internal Revenue can already keep 5 percent of its excess revenue). Staff expressed concern that this measure might promote an excessive focus on revenue collection at the expense of other desirable objectives (speedy processing of returns, fair administration of tax laws, etc.). The authorities responded that such concerns could be addressed through the operational indicators specified in the implementing regulations.
- Higher oil import tariff
  - Status: Adopted by Executive Order; starting January 2005
  - Yield: 0.1
  - Description/Staff View: Increases the oil import tariff on petroleum from 3 to 5 percent. Staff support higher taxes on petroleum but would have preferred higher excises to higher tariffs.
- Tax amnesty
  - Status: Approved by House; some opposition in Senate
  - Yield: Small short-term gain; possible long-term loss
  - Description/Staff View: Forgives all taxes from 2003 and prior years in exchange for payment of 3 percent of net worth plus 25 percent of tax due (excluding interest and penalties) from existing final assessments or cases pending in court. Staff oppose, arguing that repeated amnesties hurt taxpayer compliance.
- Higher VAT rate
  - Status: Approved by House; in committee in Senate
  - Yield: (not specified)

*Sources: Data provided by the Philippine authorities; and CEIC; and Fund staff estimates.*

### 0.5 Raises the VAT rate from 10 to 12 percent. Staff strongly

### _cr05105 - 0.5 Raises the VAT rate from 10 to 12 percent. Staff strongly

### Fiscal policy measures under consideration and staff positions
- VAT rate increase
  - Proposal: Raises the VAT rate from 10 to 12 percent.
  - Staff position: Staff strongly support a higher rate for the VAT, which is moderately progressive given the exemption of small businesses and unprocessed food (disproportionately consumed by low-income households).
- Repeal of some VAT exemptions
  - Status: Approved out of committee in House; in committee in Senate.
  - Estimated revenue impact: 0.2–0.3 (In percent of GDP).
  - Staff position: Staff support this measure, which repeals several nonstandard VAT exemptions, including petroleum.
- Consolidation of fiscal incentives
  - Status: Approved by House; in committee in Senate.
  - Direction/impact: Direction unclear; modest impact either way.
  - Staff position: Staff support goals of consolidating different fiscal incentives into a single, more transparent law and repealing small incentives embodied in 19 different laws. However, the House version of the bill does not significantly reduce the largest incentives (e.g. tax holidays for exporters and exemptions for cooperatives) and may even result in a net expansion of incentives.
- Simplified net income tax for businesses
  - Status: Has not yet garnered significant support in Congress.
  - Direction/impact: Unclear.
  - Proposal details: Disallows some normally deductible business expenses, such as those for administration, and would cut the corporate tax rate from 32 to 28 percent.
  - Staff position: Staff oppose on the grounds that will increase distortions and complicate administration.
- Higher petroleum excises
  - Status: Set aside for now.
  - Estimated revenue impact: 0.4–0.5 (In percent of GDP).
  - Staff position: Staff support raising petroleum excises, which are low by international standards. This translates into roughly a 10 percent increase in retail prices, but the poor would be shielded due to small or no increases on kerosene and liquefied petroleum gas.
- Telecommunications tax
  - Status: Set aside for now.
  - Estimated revenue impact: 0.2 (In percent of GDP).
  - Proposal details: Replaces the VAT on telecommunications companies with a 7 percent turnover tax.
  - Staff position: Staff oppose, since it would likely increase distortions. Spectrum fees should be increased instead.

### Key macroeconomic and summary indicators (selected)
- Nominal GNP (2003): $85.2 billion
- Population (2003, est.): 81.1million
- GNP per capita (2003, est.): $1,051
- IMF quota: SDR 879.9 million
- Real GDP growth (percentage change)
  - 2000: 4.4
  - 2001: 1.8
  - 2002: 4.3
  - 2003: 4.7
  - 2004: 6.1
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 4.7
- Nominal GDP (in billions of pesos)
  - 2000: 3,355
  - 2001: 3,631
  - 2002: 3,960
  - 2003: 4,300
  - 2004: 4,843
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 5,399
- CPI (1994 base; annual average)
  - 2000: 4.3
  - 2001: 6.1
  - 2002: 3.0
  - 2003: 3.0
  - 2004: 5.5
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 6.8
- National government balance (authorities definition) (percent of GDP)
  - 2000: -4.0
  - 2001: -4.0
  - 2002: -5.3
  - 2003: -4.6
  - 2004: -3.8
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): -3.5
- Nonfinancial public sector debt (percent of GDP)
  - 2000: ...
  - 2001: 88.4
  - 2002: 93.9
  - 2003: 101.1
  - 2004: 99.2
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 96.8
- Current account (percent of GDP)
  - 2000: 8.2
  - 2001: 1.9
  - 2002: 5.7
  - 2003: 4.2
  - 2004: 4.5
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 3.5
- BSP Gross Reserves (adjusted, US$ billions)
  - 2000: 13.4
  - 2001: 13.2
  - 2002: 14.3
  - 2003: 14.7
  - 2004: 15.1
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 14.9

### Public finance snapshots (selected)
- National Government Cash Accounts (Revenue and grants; percent of GDP)
  - 2001: 15.7
  - 2002: 14.4
  - 2003: 14.6
  - 2004: 14.4
  - 2005 (Auth. Propose dModerate Prog. Prel. Budget Reform): 14.5 / 14.9 / 14.5 (table shows multiple columns)
- Tax revenue (percent of GDP)
  - 2001: 13.5
  - 2002: 12.5
  - 2003: 12.5
  - 2004: 12.7
  - 2005 (Auth./Proposed): 12.3 / 13.2 / 12.7 (table shows multiple scenario columns)
- Expenditure and net lending (percent of GDP)
  - 2001: 20.3
  - 2002: 20.0
  - 2003: 19.6
  - 2004: 18.9
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 18.4

### Medium-term outlook — scenarios and projections
- Strong reform scenario (Table 6; Staff Proj.)
  - Real GDP growth (2005–2010): 4.9, 5.1, 5.2, 5.4, 5.7, 6.0 (years 2005–2010 listed as 4.9, 5.1, 5.2, 5.4, 5.7, 6.0 in table heading order)
  - GDP per capita (US$) path (2005–2010): 1,029; 1,127; 1,207; 1,273; 1,334; 1,403; 1,479 (table lists values across 2005–2010)
  - CPI (1994 base; year average) 2005–2010: 5.5; 7.0; 5.4; 4.2; 3.5; 3.5; 3.5 (table entries)
  - Nonfinancial public sector balance (percent of GDP) path (2005–2010): -3.4; -2.4; -1.7; -1.4; -1.2; -0.9
  - Nonfinancial public sector debt (percent of GDP) 2005–2010: 93.2; 88.6; 84.7; 81.0; 76.9; 72.7
  - Reserves, adjusted (US$ billions) 2005–2010: 15.1; 16.3; 17.8; 18.5; 19.3; 20.4
- Moderate reform scenario (Table 7; Staff Proj.)
  - Real GDP growth (2005–2010): 4.7; 4.5; 4.3; 4.2; 4.1; 4.0
  - Nonfinancial public sector balance (percent of GDP) 2005–2010: -4.4; -4.0; -3.9; -4.1; -4.2; -4.3
  - Nonfinancial public sector debt (percent of GDP) 2005–2010: 96.8; 95.0; 94.3; 93.6; 93.1; 92.6
  - Current account (percent of GDP) 2005–2010: 3.5; 2.7; 2.6; 1.9; 1.5; 1.5

### Debt sustainability analysis — key findings and sensitivities (Annex I)
- Baseline (moderate reforms) outcome
  - Under a baseline scenario of moderate reforms, debt would remain high at around 93 percent of GDP.
  - Baseline assumptions: assumed average real GDP growth of 4¼ percent over 2005–10 and a primary balance adjustment of 1 percent of GDP in 2005–06.
  - Recent tax and tariff measures and tight control of spending in 2005 are judged sufficient to achieve such an adjustment.
- Alternative scenarios
  - Alternative Scenario 2 (policy slippage): If the primary balance is essentially unchanged, debt would continue to climb, assuming somewhat slower real GDP growth (average of 3¾ percent over 2005–10).
  - Alternative Scenario 3 (strong reforms): A stronger primary balance adjustment of 2¾ percentage points of GDP over 2005–07 (with the major part occurring in 2005) and higher average real GDP growth of 5¼ percent would put debt on a firmly downward path.
- Sensitivity to shocks (Bounds Tests)
  - Under the moderate reforms scenario, Bounds Tests indicate considerable sensitivity of the projected debt ratio to shocks, especially to the exchange rate and growth.
  - Debt dynamics would be more resilient under strong and front-loaded reforms.
- External vulnerability and external debt projections
  - Baseline (moderate reforms): external debt would decline gradually to about 62 percent of GDP by 2010 (Table A2).
  - Gross external financing requirements would continue to increase in US$ terms and relative to GDP, partly due to a declining projected current account surplus.
  - Alternative Scenario A2 (front-loaded fiscal consolidation, stronger reform): external debt could fall to 51 percent of GDP by 2010, aided by a recovery in FDI and equity inflows and relatively lower interest rates.
- Nonfinancial public sector debt trajectory (Table A1 baseline moderate reform projections)
  - Actual and projected nonfinancial public sector debt (percent of GDP):
    - 2001: 88.4
    - 2002: 93.9
    - 2003: 101.1
    - 2004: 99.2
    - 2005 (Est.): 96.8
    - 2006 (Proj.): 95.0
    - 2007 (Proj.): 94.3
    - 2008 (Proj.): 93.6
    - 2009 (Proj.): 93.1
    - 2010 (Proj.): 92.6
  - Debt-stabilizing primary balance (percent of GDP): 1.4 (table reports "1.4" in Debt-stabilizing primary balance row)
- Stress tests (selected outcomes from Table A1 and Table A2)
  - B1 (Real interest rate at baseline plus two standard deviations in 2005 and 2006): Nonfinancial public sector debt rises to 102.7 by 2006 (table shows B1 sequence ending 100.7 with +1.5 change over horizon; check table entries for year-by-year values).
  - B2 (Real GDP growth at baseline minus two standard deviations in 2005 and 2006): Nonfinancial public sector debt rises, with cumulative increases shown (table indicates significant sensitivity; e.g., 101.3; 104.8; etc. in B2 sequence).
  - B5 (One time 30 percent real depreciation in 2005): Nonfinancial public sector debt jumps to 129.6 in immediate test year and remains elevated (table shows 129.6, 127.8, 127.4, 127.1, 127.1, 127.2 across horizon).
  - External debt stress tests (selected):
    - B3 (Change in US dollar GDP deflator at historical average minus two standard deviations in 2005 and 2006) produces a large increase in external debt indicators (Table A2 shows B3 results such as 89.9; 114.5; 116.1; 118.9; 122.0; 124.7 across horizon).
    - B6 (One time 30 percent nominal depreciation in 2005) raises external debt trajectories moderately (Table A2 shows results such as 97.0; 96.1; 96.5; 97.9; 99.6; 101.0 across horizon).
- Identified debt-creating flows (Table A1, 2005 baseline entries)
  - Primary deficit (percent of GDP): -2.2 (2005)
  - Revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 21.7 (2005)
  - Primary (noninterest) expenditure (percent of GDP): 19.4 (2005)
  - Automatic debt dynamics contribution (percent of GDP): -1.3 (2005)
  - Contribution from exchange rate depreciation (percent of GDP): 2.3 (2005)
  - Residual, including asset changes (percent of GDP): 1.2 (2005)

### Key balances and external financing needs (selected)
- Current account balance (US$ billions; Table 4)
  - 2000: 6.3
  - 2001: 1.3
  - 2002: 4.4
  - 2003: 3.3
  - 2004: 3.9
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 3.3
- Trade balance (US$ billions)
  - 2000: 3.8
  - 2001: -0.7
  - 2002: 0.4
  - 2003: -1.3
  - 2004: -1.0
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): -1.4
- Exports, f.o.b. (US$ billions)
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 41.6
- Imports, f.o.b. (US$ billions)
  - 2005 (Staff Est.): 43.1
- Gross external financing needs (US$ billions; Table A2 projections)
  - 2005: 10.4
  - Projected growth in gross external financing needs to 2010: rising to 15.3 (Table 6/7 memorandum items and Table A2 projections)

*Sources: Philippine authorities; and Fund staff estimates, projections, and debt sustainability analysis.*

### 1405. The bill seeks to exempt government

### _cr05105 - 1405. The bill seeks to exempt government

### Overview
- "The bill seeks to exempt government officials and employees from the prohibition against disclosure of or inquiry into deposits with any banking institutions. (As of 24 August 2004)."

### Strengthen banks by raising capital and encouraging consolidation
- The BSP required banks to report their accounts on a consolidated basis starting September 2001, but weaknesses in the reporting framework complicates supervision on a consolidated basis.
- The BSP issued amendments to its risk-based capital framework to incorporate market risk (March 2004) and expand coverage to include quasi-banks (September 2003).
- The BSP issued guidelines on the capital treatment of credit-linked notes and similar credit derivative products (January 2004).
- The BSP issued rules and regulations governing the use of banks’ internal credit risk rating systems to ensure that banks’ credit risk management processes are sound and effective. According to the rules, all universal and commercial banks must have in place a formal internal credit risk rating system for the underwriting and ongoing administration, initially, of corporate credit exposures (Circular No. 439 dated July 5, 2004).
- Thrift banks which are actually operating Foreign Currency Deposit Units (FCDUs) are given two years from March 7, 2002 within which to comply with the minimum capital requirement for FCDUs. This requirement can be substituted by a capital build-up program for a period of not more than five years or only up to December 31, 2007, subject to approval by the Monetary Board (Circular No. 449 dated September 6, 2004).

### Tighten provisioning requirements and regulatory oversight
- Starting October 1997, general loan loss provisions were required over and above existing provisioning requirements for classified accounts. Provisioning requirements were rationalized with further differentiation depending on security, risk and status.
- The BSP has issued regulations regarding the management of large exposures, credit risk concentrations, single borrower’s limits, connected and/or related party transactions, and other governance-related measures.
- With regard to foreclosed assets, banks are required to reappraise values every two years beginning January 2002. Provisioning levels, however, remain low.

### Level the playing field between foreign currency and peso intermediation
- Regulatory issuances included guidelines on the conversion and transfer of foreign currency-denominated loans, and foreclosed assets on the books of FCDUs/EFCDUs to peso loans and foreclosed assets on the books of regular banking unit.

### Deal effectively with problem banks
- The General Banking Act of 2000 increased the BSP’s capacity to take prompt corrective action.
- In July 2004, the Philippine Deposit Insurance Company’s (PDIC) charter was amended to strengthen its ability to deal with problem banks.
- Rehabilitation of the Philippine National Bank (PNB) has made significant progress. PNB has professionalized its management, and has recently started to book modest profits.
- Stress testing of commercial banks is being undertaken to determine how banks would react to various scenarios. The results of these tests are relayed to concerned banks, who may then be required to take remedial action. Prompt corrective actions currently in place include monetary penalties, assignment of resident examiners and other non-monetary penalties.
- The BSP, through its Legislative Liaison Research Committee (LLRC) is initiating legislative efforts to amend RA 7653 (otherwise known as the New Central Bank Act) to further expand and strengthen the legal protection afforded to BSP personnel.

### Provide legal framework to encourage banks to sell nonperforming assets to third parties
- The Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV) Act was passed in January 2003. The IRR of the SPV Act was approved in March 2003. Banks and quasi-banks have been reminded of the timelines for availing of the tax incentives under the SPV law.
- In March 2004, the Securitization Act was passed, providing scope for a strengthening of the SPV framework.
- The BIR issued Revenue Regulations in connection with the SPV tax incentives in June 2004.
- As of September 2004, 68 Certificates of Eligibility (COE) have been issued by the BSP to 18 banks, creating a scope for Non-Performing Asset (NPA) transfers totaling P 4.5 billion.
- Three banks have pending applications for COEs with the BSP involving bank sale of 10.1 billion worth of NPAs.
- Thirty-six SPVs have thus far registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), making them eligible to acquire NPAs until April 8, 2005.
- Availment of incentives under the SPV Law to dispose of NPAs is finally gaining momentum after a slow start.

### Grant legal protection for the BSP and PDIC supervisors
- The amended PDIC Charter provides for additional legal protection, in the form of advance indemnification for litigation costs and expenses for acts done in the performance of official functions and duties, but these measures do not grant full legal protection.
- A draft bill is pending in the Committee of Banks, Financial Institutions and Currencies, Constitutional Amendments and the Ways and Means that seeks to amend the New Central Bank Act to further achieve greater autonomy and enhance the BSP’s exercise of its regulatory and supervisory functions.

### Further liberalize the banking system
- A proposed bill entitled “An Act to Liberalize the Operations of Rural Banks Amending for that Purpose”, which seeks to amend RA No. 7353, otherwise known as the New Rural Banks Act of 1992, is currently pending at the committee level.

### Fiscal and Governance Reforms — Improve operations of the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR)
- Taxpayer compliance control systems were improved and computerization program was reinvigorated through the following measures:
  - stepped up tax compliance verification (or “tax mapping”);
  - strengthened audit and related enforcement programs;
  - organizational adjustments; and
  - intensified use of third-party information.

### Rationalize fiscal incentives
- The government has proposed a law to 1) harmonize all investment incentives to avoid “double-dipping,” 2) allow preferred activities to draw their tax incentives from one law for administrative simplicity, and 3) focus the grant of tax incentives to a list of activities that best mirror the government’s development priorities.
- The government has also proposed repealing special non-investment related incentives that have become costly, inefficient, non-transparent, and difficult to administer and monitor.
- However, the fiscal incentives bill passed by the House would not affect the largest incentives and may even result in a net expansion of incentives.
- The government has also proposed repealing certain nonstandard VAT exemptions such as for petroleum. This reform is also currently under discussion in congress.

### Reform financial sector taxation
- The Documentary Stamp Tax (DST) law rationalizing the taxation of debt and equity instruments was signed into law under Republic Act No. 9243 on February 17, 2004.
- VAT on financial transactions and taxation of FCDU/OBUs, which took effect in 2003, were repealed recently by law.

### Improve expenditure management
- The Organizational Performance Indicator Framework (OPIF) is being implemented to enable agencies to focus on strategic programs and projects and establish the linkage of their programs and projects with their major final outputs (MFOs) and sector/sub-sector and/or national objectives.
- A series of workshops was conducted in 2004 to formulate the 2005 OPIF-based budgets of eleven departments, enabling these departments to finalize their MFOs, align their programs and projects and formulate outcome-based performance indicators for these MFOs.
- The mid-year Agency Performance Reviews (APR) for FY 2004 was conducted on October 11-22, 2004. The results of the APR will determine the overall performance of the national government in terms of fund utilization, revenue generation, and output accomplishments. The results will be used as a basis for future resource allocation decisions.
- The e-Budget and other new database systems are being rolled out in the Department of Budget and Management’s (DBM) central offices starting December 15, 2004. The system automates the budget execution phase of the government’s budget process, i.e., the processing of budget releases, transmittal to agencies, and preparation of accountability reports.
- Starting March 2004, agencies with Maintenance and Other Operating Expenditure (MOOE) budgets of P 50 million and below have been authorized to undertake the following without need of DBM approval:
  - staffing modifications;
  - use of savings; and
  - realignment of savings from personal services to MOOE/capital outlay (CO) and MOOE to CO only to augment an existing item, project, activity, or purpose in the agency’s budget.
- For monitoring purposes, agencies have been required to submit quarterly reports of budgetary actions taken.

### Government Procurement Reform Act (GPRA) implementation
- Provision of training for different agencies to fully disseminate procurement reforms embodied in the GPRA. As of end-December 2004:
  - 58.4 percent of National Government Agencies (NGAs) were already trained on the GPRA;
  - 40.1 percent of GOCCs were already trained on the GPRA;
  - 87.7 percent of LGUs were already trained on the GPRA; and
  - 100 percent of SUCs were already trained on the GPRA.
- Development of a generic procurement manual and a set of standard bidding documents. A first draft of the Procurement Manual for Goods, Civil Works and Consulting Services has been completed and is due for a final review prior to its release to procuring entities and to pilot testing.
- Full operationalization of the Government-Electronic Procurement System (G-EPS) as the central portal. Presently, the G-EPS is operating all three features in its “Pilot Phase” — the Electronic Bulleting Board, the Supplier Registry and the Electronic Catalogue.
- Enhancement of the Pilot G-EPS is ongoing, including data migration and is targeted for implementation on the third quarter of 2005.
- The full implementation of the G-EPS, which includes features such as Virtual Store, Electronic Bidding and Electronic Payment is being targeted for implementation in the third quarter of 2006.

### Move forward the Government Rationalization and Reengineering Program
- Two bills were filed in the 13th Congress to seek authority for the President to reorganize the Executive Branch, subject to defined principles and parameters. The proposed bills also offer appropriate incentives for personnel who may be affected by the reengineering effort.
- The DBM is working on a refined version of the Reengineering Bill that would authorize the President to reengineer the executive branch and implement massive and transformational reforms in the bureaucracy.
- While awaiting the passage of the Reengineering Bill, the DBM together with the Civil Service Commission (CSC), is pursuing a rationalization program to have an immediate impact on improving public service delivery and institutional capacity through rationalization of functions and agencies of the executive branch.
- Executive Order (EO) No. 366 dated 04 October 2004 directs all departments to conduct a strategic review of the operations and organizations of all their component units, including agencies and GOCCs/GFIs attached to or under their administrative supervision. Each department is required to prepare a Rationalization Plan.
- Personnel who may be affected by the program would be given two options:
  - remain in government service and be placed in other agencies needing additional personnel; or
  - avail of the retirement/separation benefits, if qualified, plus the applicable incentive.
- Those with temporary appointment attested by the CSC may opt to remain but are guaranteed tenure up to expiration of their appointment only.
- The DBM is finalizing the implementing regulations of EO 366 to guide departments/agencies in the implementation of said directive. The regulations would be issued by the DBM upon finalization of the program’s communication plan.

### Electric Power Sector Reform
- The Electric Power Industry Reform Act (EPIRA) of 2001 was enacted in June 2001, followed by its implementing rules and regulations in February 2002. The EPIRA provides a framework for the restructuring of the power sector, including privatization of National Power Corporation (NPC) assets and deregulation of the power sector.
- The Power Sector Assets and Liabilities Management Corporation has been created to oversee privatization of NPC’s transmission and generation assets.
- The Energy Regulatory Commission has been established to replace the Energy Regulatory Board.
- Philippine Electricity Market Corporation has been established to launch and manage the Wholesale Electricity Spot Market.
- One large and five small generation plants (in total worth about $ 570 million) were sold to private investors.
- Cross subsidies among consumer classes have been partially removed.
- The government has assumed P 200 billion in NPC debts.

### Trade Liberalization
- Reduce average tariffs to about 9 percent in 2000
- The average tariff rates were reduced from

*Italic: Source — Philippines: Progress on Structural Reform Agenda (Annex II), extracted content from the provided PDF.*

### 8.1 percent in 2000 to 7.7 percent in 2001, and

### _cr05105 - 8.1 percent in 2000 to 7.7 percent in 2001, and

### Trade policy and tariffs
- Average tariff rates:
  - 8.1 percent in 2000
  - 7.7 percent in 2001
  - 6.0 percent in 2002
  - Adjusted upward to 6.2 percent in 2003
  - Adjusted upward to 7.5 percent in 2004

### Corporate sector regulatory reforms and capital markets
- Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) reforms and corporate restructuring:
  - Procedure on Corporate Rehabilitation effective December 2000.
  - SEC shifted quasi-judicial powers to the courts and is taking steps to minimize debt restructuring incidents by:
    - imposing more stringent financial disclosure requirements, including bringing accounting system up to international standards;
    - regulating external auditors more closely; and
    - implementing the code of corporate governance (applies to all corporations whose securities are registered or listed), which requires formulation, submission (to SEC), adoption, and stockholder-accessible Manuals of Corporate Governance, to be adhered to under penalty of law.
  - Securitization Act passage in March 2004 to permit asset management companies to finance acquisitions of distressed assets through capital markets and institutional investors; expected to facilitate restructuring and contribute to corporate bond market development by overcoming small issuer size and low credit quality.

- Financial Sector Forum (FSF):
  - Established by SEC, BSP, IC and PDIC as a voluntary cooperative framework to coordinate supervision and regulation while preserving each agency’s mandate.
  - FSF focus areas:
    1) harmonization and coordination of supervisory and regulatory methods and policies, identification and filling of gaps and elimination of overlapping functions;
    2) reporting and information exchange and dissemination, including disclosure rules to enhance transparency, harmonizing regulatory reporting requirements, and creating database linkages; and
    3) consumer protection and education to curb unlawful and unethical business practices and financial scams.

- Legislative initiatives:
  - Executive branch pushing a house bill to amend the Securities Regulation Code (Republic Act No. 8799) to revise provisions including mandatory tender offers; minimum capital requirements; broker-director prohibition; and limitation on ownership of an exchange.
  - Revised Investment Company Act (13th Congress) aims to:
    1) promote fiduciary principles in investments and management of investment companies;
    2) prevent abuses and protect investing public; and
    3) establish the Investment Company Investors Protection Fund to compensate investors for financial injury for reasons other than market price decline.
  - Draft bill on corporate recovery (Corporate Recovery Act) originally submitted in 2001, filed anew in the 13th Congress, intended to offer comprehensive approach to enterprises unable to pay debts, emphasizing enterprise survival while preserving rights of debtors and creditors.

- Philippine Stock Exchange (PSE) governance and procedures:
  - Demutualization completed in August 2001, transforming PSE into a publicly-held corporation governed by a majority of non-brokers.
  - PSE introductory listing on the bourse on 15 December 2003.
  - Rules Governing Trading of PSE Shares effective 30 December 2003; SEC directed PSE to observe Securities Regulation Code limitations including industry ownership limit of 20 percent of outstanding capital stock.
  - SEC approved in December 2004 PSE’s new rules for listed companies under corporate rehabilitation:
    - Listed companies must submit to SEC and PSE copies of the petition for corporate rehabilitation, documents and proposed rehabilitation plan within 24 hours of actual filing with the courts.
    - Once court approves the rehabilitation plan, the company must submit comprehensive corporate disclosure on effects on capital structure within 48 hours from the court’s approval.
    - Exchange will lift trading suspension on company’s shares five days from release of its comprehensive disclosure.

- Bank governance and internal controls:
  - BSP Circular No. 456 dated October 4, 2004 requires banks to have:
    1) audit committee to oversee financial reporting, control, internal and external audit functions;
    2) corporate governance committee to review board nominees, ensure board effectiveness and observance of corporate governance principles, and oversee periodic performance evaluation; and
    3) risk management committee responsible for development and oversight of the institution's risk management program.

### Financial relations with the IMF (As of December 31, 2004)
- Membership status:
  - Joined: December 27, 1945; Article VIII.
- General Resources Account:
  - Quota: 879.90 SDR Million (100.0 percent)
  - Fund holdings of currency: 1,279.41 SDR Million (145.40 percent)
  - Reserve position in Fund: 87.43 SDR Million (9.94 percent)
- SDR Department:
  - Net cumulative allocation: 116.60 SDR Million (100.00 percent)
  - Holdings: 0.65 SDR Million (0.55 percent)
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans:
  - Stand-by arrangements: 397.85 SDR Million (45.21 percent of quota)
  - Extended arrangements: 89.09 SDR Million (10.12 percent of quota)
- Financial arrangements (type, approval date, expiration date, amount approved, amount drawn) — selected entries:
  - Stand-by: 04/01/1998 to 12/31/2000; Amount Approved 1,020.79 (SDR Million); Amount Drawn 783.23 (SDR Million)
  - EFF: 06/24/1994 to 03/31/1998; Amount Approved 791.20 (SDR Million); Amount Drawn 791.20 (SDR Million)
  - Stand-by: 02/20/1991 to 03/31/1993; Amount Approved 334.20 (SDR Million); Amount Drawn 334.20 (SDR Million)
- Projected Obligations to Fund (SDR Million; based on existing use of resources and present holdings of SDRs):
  - Principal: 214.87 125.78 125.78 20.50 (Forthcoming 2005 2006 2007 2008)
  - Charges/Interest: 14.51 9.23 5.31 2.85 2.58
  - Total: 229.38 135.01 131.09 23.35 2.58
- Exchange arrangement and exchange rate history:
  - Peso determined in interbank foreign exchange market; Bangko Sentral intervenes to smooth undue short-term fluctuations.
  - From November 1995 to June 1997 the peso was effectively fixed around P 26.2–P 26.4 per U.S. dollar.
  - On July 11, 1997, peso depreciated to P 29.45 per U.S. dollar when allowed to find its own level.
  - Subsequently gradually depreciated; during the last few months it fluctuated around P 55–56½ per U.S. dollar.
- Article IV Consultation (2003 Article IV discussed March 5, 2004):
  - Directors noted important economic reforms but remaining key weaknesses and vulnerabilities in fiscal, banking, and power sectors.
  - Urged urgent implementation of comprehensive reforms to set economy on high and sustainable growth trajectory, reduce poverty, improve debt sustainability, and resilience to shocks.
  - Urged authorities not to loosen policies in the pre-election environment.
- FSAP and ROSC participation:
  - MFD FSAP conducted Q4 2001; final report discussed June 2002; FSSA discussed in September 2002.
  - FAD ROSC on fiscal transparency discussed September 2002 and published October 2002; update published June 2004.
  - STA ROSC Data Module mission September 2003; report published August 2004.
- Technical assistance highlights:
  - MFD resident banking supervision advisor stationed in Manila since May 2003.
  - STA peripatetic missions July–August 2003 and January–February 2004 on balance of payments and IIP statistics and ROSC Data Module recommendations.
  - FAD missions: briefing to new tax commissioner April–May 2001; VAT and excise administration review December 2001; staff participated in July PPM mission.
  - LEG legal expert visited Manila to discuss anti-money laundering initiatives in March 2002.
- Resident Representative:
  - Resident Representative stationed in Manila since January 1984.
  - Mr. Vikram Haksar assumed the post in September 2002.
- Fourth Amendment to the Articles of Agreement:
  - Authorities formally communicated acceptance; ratified by the Senate in August 2001.

### Relations with the World Bank (As of December 31, 2004)
- Current portfolio:
  - 23 projects amounting to $1.16 billion (net of cancellations), of which $505 million disbursed.
  - Cumulative commitments since operations began: $9.56 billion under IBRD loans and $239 million under IDA credits (less cancellations).
- Portfolio by sector (net commitments):
  - Rural Development: 34 percent
  - Education, Health & Social Development: 18 percent
  - Transport: 18 percent
  - Urban Development: 13 percent
  - Energy: 3 percent
  - Environment: 12 percent
  - Governance: 2 percent
- Country Assistance Strategy (CAS) FY03–05:
  - Base case lending program about $1.1 billion for FY03–05; actual volume anticipated to be much lower due to Government’s restraint on borrowing.
  - New CAS being formulated for FY06-08.
- World Bank approvals in FY04 (loan name and amount):
  - Judicial Reform: $21.9 million
  - Rural Power: $10 million
  - Laguna Lake Institutional Strengthening and Community Development: $5 million
  - Diversified Farm Income and Market Development: $60 million
- Non-lending and technical assistance:
  - Non-lending outputs: Education Policy Notes, Natural Disaster Management Study, Natural Resource Management Study, Discussion Briefs.
  - Technical assistance areas: pension reform; governance institutions; international competitiveness; public financial management capacity; city development strategies; sustainable mining; corporate governance.
  - Country and project specific grants mobilized in FY04 about $8.2 million.
  - Active grants as of December 31, 2004: 77 active grants totaling about US$34.4 million, of which about US$9.8 million disbursed.
  - FY04 co-financing grants: $9 million GEF (Rural Power); $5 million Netherlands (Laguna Lake); $12 million GEF (Electric Cooperative System Loss Reduction).
- Outreach and knowledge sharing:
  - Eight Knowledge for Development Centers (KDCs) nationwide.
  - Partnership with Asian Institute of Management (AIM) for Global Distance Learning Network.
  - External country website maintained by the Bank.

- Selected Board approvals between July 1, 2000 and December 31, 2004 (IBRD amounts and effective dates):
  - Land Administration Management Project (LIL): 4.79; 1/9/01
  - Metro Manila Urban Integration Project: 60.00; 12/6/01
  - LGU Finance and Development 2: 30.00; 5/16/02
  - Social Expenditure Management-2: 100.00; 12/11/02
  - Kalahi Community Development Project: 100.00; 12/16/02
  - Second Agrarian Reform Communities Project: 50.00; 6/4/03
  - ARMM Social Fund: 33.60; 5/19/03
  - Judicial Reform: 21.90; 12/04/03
  - Rural Power: 10.00; 05/06/04
  - Laguna de Bay Institutional Strengthening and Community Participation: 5.00; 04/02/04
  - Diversified Farm Income and Market Development: 60.00; 10/29/04

- Financial relations (IBRD/IDA as of December 31, 2004):
  - Total disbursed: IBRD 8,835; IDA 244; Total 9,079 (In millions of U.S. dollars)
  - Total commitments: IBRD 9,562; IDA 239; Total 9,802
  - Total undisbursed: IBRD 608; IDA 0; Total 608
  - Total repaid: IBRD 6,844; IDA 38; Total 6,882
  - IFC commitments held by IFC and participants: 847.4 (In millions of U.S. dollars)
  - IFC commitments held by IFC alone: 539.2 (In millions of U.S. dollars)

### Relations with the Asian Development Bank (As of December 31, 2004)
- Cumulative ADB support since 1966:
  - 192 loans totaling $8.62 billion
  - 311 technical assistance grants amounting to $137 million
  - 48 percent of loans for energy and agriculture sectors
- 2004 approvals:
  - Two loans for health sector development program totaling $213 million
  - Ten technical assistance grants totaling $5.995 million
- ADB private sector operations:
  - $509.5 million including 15 loans of $474.3 million and 18 equity investments of $35.2 million
- Cumulative ADB lending by sector (Number of loans; Amount of loans; Percent):
  - Energy: 25 loans; 2,221.1 (In millions of U.S. dollars); 25.8 percent
  - Agriculture and natural resources: 62 loans; 1,915.7; 22.2 percent
  - Social infrastructure: 41 loans; 1,612.4; 18.7 percent
  - Transport and communications: 23 loans; 996.9; 11.6 percent
  - Finance: 17 loans; 823.0; 9.5 percent
  - Others: 3 loans; 296.0; 3.4 percent
  - Multisector: 6 loans; 283.7; 3.3 percent
  - Private sector: 15 loans; 474.3; 5.5 percent
  - Total: 192 loans; 8,623.1; 100.0 percent

### Statistical issues and data quality
- General observation:
  - Data generally published timely but serious weaknesses in statistical base hamper macroeconomic analysis.
  - Most serious deficiencies: national accounts and balance of payments statistics.
  - Philippines subscribed to SDDS; metadata posted on DSBB.

- National accounts weaknesses:
  - Large discrepancies between GDP from expenditure side and production side; difference in growth rates about 3 percent on average over last two years.
  - Causes identified by ROSC:
    - Deaths and births of establishments not adequately measured; latest annual survey data from 1998 NSO annual survey of establishments, so many new establishments (e.g., electronics and IT) are not covered.
    - Compilation relies on outdated benchmark year and fixed input-output ratios (1988 benchmark; fixed input-output at 1985 prices). New benchmark I-0 by NSCB scheduled for release in September 2005.
    - Inadequate statistical techniques for estimating GDP at constant prices; many production account components not compiled and constant price estimates derived by applying price deflators to current price value added; merchandise exports/imports constant price estimates constructed at 1985 unit values multiplied by quantity data (kilos), producing suspiciously high implicit deflators for electric machinery products compared with world market prices.

- Balance of payments weaknesses:
  - Important progress made (improved measurement of imports to correct underestimation of consignment imports of electronic goods) but significant weaknesses remain.
  - Errors and omissions remain sizable due to reporting gaps and misclassifications, making data difficult to interpret.
  - External debt and reserves data generally good, though ROSC mission identified some weaknesses.
  - Revisions to imports have narrowed gap with partner country data; interagency task force on import statistics established July 2002 for electronics sector (accounts for about 43 percent of trade flows); import figures revised substantially back to 2000.
  - Trade balance revision: estimated trade balance for 2001 changed from a surplus of 3.8 percent of GDP to a deficit of 1 percent of GDP after revisions.
  - Remaining differences with partner country data on gross exports and imports: partner country import flows about 15 percent higher than corresponding national data.
  - ROSC data module confirmed coverage and compilation problems:
    - Increasing use of nontraditional channels (e.g., Foreign Currency Deposit Units (FCDUs) account for about 70–75 percent of foreign exchange settlements) with strict secrecy rules and no mandated reporting, creating major gap.
    - Enterprise surveys introduced but voluntary and will take time.
    - If FCDU secrecy rules not modified, balance of payments quality likely to remain poor.
    - Resource constraints at BSP have limited compilers’ ability to implement IMF TA recommendations; periodicity switched from monthly to quarterly (effective with release of Q3 2003 data in December 2003) and decision to establish separate Department of Economic Statistics within BSP.
  - Note: Errors and omissions and “trade credits” accounted for balance of payments outflows of US$4.4 billion (5.6 percent of GDP) in 2002.
  - Trade credit data unreliable and grouped with errors and omissions in IMF presentation.
  - Data from 1996–99 have not been revised and remain underestimated.

- Monetary statistics:
  - Framework largely conforms to Fund methodology, but structural changes after liberalization affected data for central bank, commercial banks, and nonbank financial intermediaries.
  - ROSC shortcomings: coverage and quality of monetary aggregates.
  - Progress: Depository Corporations Survey now includes thrift and rural banks; uniform procedures for converting foreign currency denominated accounts to local currency in monetary aggregates.
  - Remaining weaknesses: treatment of non-operational banks, valuation of securities, and treatment of accrued interest in monetary statistics need alignment with international norms.

- Fiscal data:
  - Philippines meets many fiscal transparency requirements but ROSCs found areas needing strengthening.
  - Important problem: budget presented on obligations basis while deficit reported on cash basis, complicating comparisons.
  - Consolidated fiscal outturns beyond central government not generally available for items other than fiscal balance; stock and flow information not well-reconciled.

### Core statistical indicators (as of January 12, 2005)
- Dates of latest observations (selected):
  - Exchange Rates: Jan.12/05 (Date received Jan.12/05)
  - International Reserves: Jan.12/05 (Date received Jan.12/05)
  - Reserve/Base Money: Jan. 3/05 (Date received Jan.6/05)
  - Central Bank Balance Sheet: Oct./04 (Date received Nov. 30)
  - Broad Money: Oct./04 (Date received Nov. 30)
  - Interest Rates: Jan.12/05 (Date received Jan.12/05)
  - Consumer Price Index: Dec.04 (Date received Jan. 5)
  - Exports/Imports: Nov.04/Oct./04 (Date received Jan. 11/5 and Dec.22)
  - Current Account Balance: June/04 (Date received Sep. 23)
  - Federal Government Balance: Nov.04 1/ (Date received Dec. 10 1/)
  - GDP/GNP Q3/04 2/ (Date received Nov. 15 2/)
  - External Debt Q3/04 (Date received Nov. 30)
  - Source and frequency metadata summarized in table (modes: A, N, C, E; frequencies: D, W, M, Q, A).

*Source: IMF staff report text as provided in the content unit.*

### 1. Population below $1 per day (percent)20.018.014.6...

### _cr05105 - 1. Population below $1 per day (percent)20.018.014.6...

### Millennium Development Goals — Key indicator outcomes and targets (Philippines)
- 1. Population below $1 per day (percent): 20.0, 18.0, 14.6
- 2. Poverty gap ratio at $1 per day (percent): 4.2, 3.9, 2.7
- 3. Share of income or consumption held by poorest 20 percent (percent): 5.4
- Target 2 (Hunger): Halve, between 1990 and 2015, the proportion of people who suffer from hunger
  - 4. Prevalence of child malnutrition (percent of children under 5): 33.5, 29.6
  - 5. Population below minimum level of dietary energy consumption (percent): 26.0, 23.0, 22.0
- Goal 2 (Universal primary education) — Target 3: Ensure that, by 2015, children everywhere, boys and girls alike, will be able to complete a full course of primary schooling
  - 6. Net enrolment ratio (percent of relevant age group): 97.5, 100.0, 93.0
  - 7. Cohort reaching grade 5 (percent): 79.3
  - 8. Youth literacy rates (percent, ages 15-24): 97.3, 98.1, 95.1
- Goal 3 (Promote gender equity) — Target 4: Eliminate gender disparity in primary and secondary education, preferably by 2005, and in all levels of education no later than 20
  - 9. Ratio of girls to boys in primary and secondary education (percent): 97.2, 98.8, 102.3
  - 10. Ratio of young literate females to males (percent, ages 15-24): 100.4, 100.4, 101.3
  - 11. Share of women employed in non-agricultural sector (percent): 40.4, 40, 42.2
  - 12. Proportion of seats held by women in national parliament (percent): 9.0, 11.0, 12.0, 18.0
- Goal 4 (Reduce child mortality) — Target 5: Reduce by two thirds, between 1990 and 2015, the under-five mortality rate
  - 13. Under five mortality rate (per 1,000): 63.0, 50.0, 40.0, 37.0
  - 14. Infant mortality rate (per 1,000 live births): 45.0, 36.0, 30.0, 28.0
  - 15. Immunization, measles (percent of children under 12 months): 85.0, 72.0, 75.0, 73.0
- Goal 5 (Improve maternal health) — Target 6: Reduce by three quarters, between 1990 and 2015, the maternal mortality ratio
  - 16. Maternal mortality ratio (modeled estimate, per 100,000 live births): 280, 240, 200
  - 17. Births attended by skilled health personnel (percent of total): 52.8, 58.0
- Goal 6 (Combat HIV/AIDS and other diseases) — Target 7: Have halted by 2015 and begun to reverse the spread of HIV/AIDS
  - 18. Prevalence of HIV, female (percent, ages 15-24): (no data reported)
  - 19. Contraceptive prevalence rate (percent of women, ages, 15-49): 36.1, 48.1, 47.0
  - 20. Number of children orphaned by HIV/AIDS: 4,100
  - Target 8: Have halted by 2015 and begun to reverse the incidence of other major diseases
    - 21. Incidence of tuberculosis (per 100,000 population): 297, 320
    - 22. Tuberculosis cases detected under DOTS (percent): 3.0, 58.0, 57.6

### Goal 7 (Environmental sustainability) and access targets
- Target 9: Integrate the principles of sustainable development into country policies and programs and reverse the loss of environmental resources
  - 23. Forested land area (percent of total land area): 22.4, 19.4
  - 24. Nationally protected area (percent of total land area): 4.9, 4.9
  - 25. GDP per unit of energy use (PPP$ per Kg oil equivalent): 6.8, 6.6, 7.6
  - 26. Carbon dioxide emissions (metric tons per capita): 0.7, 0.9, 1.0
- Target 10: Halve, by 2015, the proportion of people without sustainable access to safe drinking water and sanitation
  - 27. Access to an improved water source (percent of population): 87.0, 86.0
  - 28. Access to improved sanitation (percent of population): 74.0, 83.0
- Target 11: By 2020, to have achieved a significant improvement in the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers
  - 29. Access to secure tenure (percent of population): (no data reported)

### Goal 8 (Develop a global partnership for development) and technology/access indicators
- Target 16: In cooperation with developing countries, develop and implement strategies for decent and productive work for youth
  - 30. Youth unemployment rate (percent of total labor force, ages, 15-24): 15.4, 16.1, 19.0
- Target 18: In cooperation with the private sector, make available the benefits of new technologies, especially information and communication
  - 31. Fixed telephone lines and cellular subscribers (per 1,000 population): 10.0, 27.7, 197.8, 232.9
  - 32. Personal computers (per 1,000 population): 3.5, 9.6, 21.7, 27.7

### Other social and demographic indicators (selected)
- General
  - Surface area (sq. km.): 300,000, 300,000, 300,000, 300,000
  - GDP per capita (1995 U.S. dollars): 1,091, 1,085, 1,182, 1,209
  - Poverty headcount (percent of population): 40.6
  - Income distribution: lowest 20 percent: 5.4; highest 20 percent: 52.3
- Demographic
  - Population (million): 61.0, 68.3, 78.3, 79.9
  - Population growth rate (percent): 2.3, 2.3, 2.2, 2.1
  - Population density (per sq km): 204.7, 229.2, 262.7, 268.1
  - Urban population (percent of total): 48.8, 54.0, 59.3, 60.1
  - Life expectancy at birth (years): 65.6, 67.7, 69.8
  - Birth rate, crude (per 1,000 population): 32.4, 29.7, 25.6
  - Death rate, crude (per 1,000 population): 6.7, 5.8, 5.6
- Labor force
  - Total labor force (million): 24.6, 28.1, 33.3, 34.2
  - Agriculture employment (percent of total): 45.2, 44.1, 37.4, n.a.
  - Industry employment (percent of total): 15.0, 15.6, 15.6, n.a.
  - Services employment (percent of total): 39.7, 40.3, 47.0, n.a.
- Education
  - Adult literacy (percent of population, ages 15 and above): 91.7, 93.5, 92.6, n.a.
  - Pupil-teacher ratio, primary school (percent): 32.9, n.a., 35.2, 35.4
  - School enrollment (percent of age group, gross)
    - Primary: 111.3, 114.1, 112.5, 112.1
    - Secondary: 73.2, 77.5, 77.1, 81.9
    - Tertiary: 28.2, 29.0, 30.5, 30.4

### IMF Staff Representative statement (March 7, 2005) — summary of recent developments
- Purpose: Information about recent developments available since the Staff Report circulated on February 7, 2005; does not alter the thrust of the staff appraisal.
- Financial markets and ratings
  - Moody’s downgraded the Philippines’ long-term sovereign ratings by 2-notches in mid-February to B1.
  - Moody’s noted some improvement in tax collections but concern about reform outlook as Congress grapples with politically difficult choices.
  - Markets remained firm in 2005 to date: the peso is up by 2 percent against the U.S. dollar, mainly due to increased portfolio inflows.
  - Sovereign spreads on the EMBI+ Philippines index have declined broadly in line with the EMBI+ Global index.
  - Appetite for the government’s $1.5 billion sovereign bond issue at the end of January was strong.
- Fiscal position and tax reform
  - The authorities revised the 2005 national government deficit target (authorities’ definition) from 3.6 percent of GDP to 3.4 percent of GDP, reflecting increases in excises on alcohol and tobacco and other measures approved at the end of last year.
  - The VAT bill passed by the House of Representatives in January would increase the standard rate from 10 to 12 percent; it faced considerable opposition in the Senate.
  - Alternative VAT reforms under consideration include widening the VAT base; the House passed a bill that would eliminate some VAT exemptions (including for medical and legal services) while introducing lower VAT rates for other sectors.
- Inflation
  - Authorities revised up the 2005 inflation target to 5–6 percent to reflect the shift to the recently introduced 2000-based CPI and continuing supply-side pressure.
  - In 2004, inflation averaged 0.5 percentage points higher on the basis of the new CPI than the 1994-based CPI due to changes in components and weights.
  - The new CPI based inflation was 8.5 percent (y/y) in February, up 0.1 percentage point from January.
  - Core inflation rose slightly to 8.1 percent (y/y).
- Anti-money laundering
  - The Philippines was removed from the Financial Action Task Force’s (FATF) list of Non-Cooperative Countries and Territories.
  - FATF announced on February 11 that anti-money laundering (AML) measures were being effectively implemented to remedy earlier identified deficiencies.

*Source: Statement by the IMF Staff Representative, March 7, 2005, and accompanying Millennium Development Goals data (Philippines).*

### 6.      New appointments to the economic team have been announced. The President has

### _cr05105 - 6.      New appointments to the economic team have been announced. The President has

### Key Points
- While macroeconomic fundamentals remain sound, the strong implementation of high-quality measures is needed to address underlying weaknesses, particularly in the fiscal, power, and financial sectors.
- Fiscal consolidation remains the top priority. Disciplined fiscal policy has started to deliver results.
- Decisive implementation of well thought-out structural reforms should strengthen the prospects for medium-term growth and lead to a more participatory development process.

### Recent appointments
- Mr. Cesar Purisima (former Secretary of Trade and Industry) appointed as Secretary of Finance.
- Mr. Amando M. Tetangco, Jr. (currently Deputy Governor) announced to become Governor of the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas at the end of Governor Buenaventura’s term in July.
- Mr. Juan Santos appointed as the new Secretary of Trade and Industry.
- Mr. Raphael Lotilla appointed as the new Secretary of Energy.

### Macroeconomic overview and performance
- GDP growth: 6.1 percent in 2004, up from 4.7 percent in 2003.
- Employment increased by 3.6 percent in 2004, mainly reflecting rapid creation of services sector jobs.
- Growth drivers: agriculture and services including telecommunications, business process outsourcing, and tourism.
- External position: healthy external account, low interest rates, and a stronger peso cited as evidence of sound macroeconomic performance.
- Export outlook: benefited from continued product and market diversification; remittances from overseas Filipino workers remain robust.
- Exchange rate regime: flexible exchange rate system facilitates adjustments to external shocks and structural changes.

### Fiscal situation and consolidation strategy
- National Government (NG) deficit in 2004: 3.8 percent of GDP compared to the target of 4.2 percent.
- Fiscal consolidation objectives:
  - Bring public debt ratios on a decisive downward trend.
  - Create fiscal space for infrastructure, public services, and social programs.
- Revenue measures enacted and proposed:
  - Rise in excise taxes on liquor and cigarettes enacted.
  - Implementation of a pre-announced hike in import duties on fuel.
  - Increases in fees charged by government agencies.
  - Enactment of a bill to ensure optimum performance in revenue collection agencies through a system of rewards and sanctions.
  - Legislative pipeline: a proposal to raise the value added tax, rationalization of fiscal incentives for investments, and elimination of a range of VAT exemptions.
- Expenditure measures and governance reforms:
  - Paring down the size of the bureaucracy.
  - Improving the management of government-owned and controlled enterprises (GOCCs).
  - Implementing the devolution provision of the Local Government Code.
  - Legislative program aimed at spending restraint: a fiscal responsibility bill, rationalization of public pension schemes, removal of automatic guarantees for GOCCs.
- Authorities’ stance: phased-in and multi-pronged fiscal reform strategy, with awareness of the need to front load fiscal adjustment while avoiding overpromising that could overwhelm public tolerance for reform.

### Monetary policy
- Authorities view near-term inflation as primarily influenced by supply factors and expect inflation to revert to manageable levels and ease back toward the target by next year.
- Monetary policy stance: kept on neutral mode due to absence of strong demand-side pressures; readiness to respond promptly and at a measured pace to threats to price stability.
- Monitoring priorities: potential second-round effects of supply-side shocks, inflation expectations, and demand indicators as the economy accelerates.

### External financing and debt structure
- Large external financing requirements render the country vulnerable to changes in global financial market conditions.
- Short–term external debt accounts for only about a tenth of total external debt.
- Medium- to long-term debt maturities averaging more than 17 years.
- Bangko Sentral maintains a comfortable level of reserves to sufficiently cover short-term debt.
- Prudent external debt management cited as a cushion against reversals in market sentiment.

### Financial sector reforms and banking system stability
- Continued disposal of non-performing assets (NPAs) through special purpose vehicles; slow but steady progress.
- Bangko Sentral issued a circular prescribing higher risk weights for NPLs and NPAs to make it more costly for banks to retain them.
- Priority legislative measures: amendments to the Bangko Sentral charter to strengthen supervisory and enforcement powers and legal protection of supervisory personnel.
- Other reforms: creation of a comprehensive and reliable credit information system, strengthening corporate governance and transparency in banks, improving domestic capital market infrastructure, and harmonizing supervisory and regulatory practices across financial services.
- Financial inclusion: flagship microfinance program to broaden access of the poor to financial services.

### Power sector restructuring and fiscal implications
- Energy sector seen as key to balancing the budget and ensuring competitiveness.
- Reforms noted as the first major attempt among Asian developing countries to build a fully liberalized and competitive power market.
- Privatization and restructuring actions:
  - Privatization of the National Power Corporation (NPC) through sale of generation assets and concession of the transmission company (Transco) prioritized.
  - Government expects to award a concession contract to operate the Transco grid this year.
  - Sale of first large generation plant in December last year, plus five small hydropower plants.
  - Energy officials plan to front load the privatization of generation companies in 2005.
- Tariff adjustments:
  - 98-centavo provisional average tariff increase awarded to NPC.
  - Public Information Notice references a 40 percent hike in generation tariffs as provisionally awarded.
- Social protection: same lifeline rate for small consumers remains in effect as a social safety net.

### Governance, competitiveness, and social inclusion
- Structural reforms aimed to boost competitiveness and investor confidence: improve adjudication process, simplify business procedures, crack down on corruption, and improve transparency.
- Good governance measures: strengthen Anti-Graft Commission and the Office of the Ombudsman; create a database to facilitate analysis of assets and liabilities and net worth of public officials and employees.
- Social objective: reforms intended to make growth more inclusive and help reduce poverty by expanding employment opportunities and integrating the poor into the economic mainstream.
- Labor market challenge: more than a tenth of the labor force is not gainfully employed.

### Authorities’ outlook and policy priorities
- Authorities emphasize prompt and bold action to reduce medium-term vulnerabilities in the fiscal, financial, and energy sectors while addressing social challenges.
- Continued commitment to sound macroeconomic policies to render economic growth more robust and sustainable and achieve more inclusive development gains.
- Recognition of the need to generate political and popular acceptance for reforms and to sequence and prioritize measures to minimize short-term dislocations and ensure equitable burden-sharing.

*Statement by Jong Nam Oh, Executive Director for the Philippines and Cyd Amador, Senior Advisor to Executive Director, March 7, 2005; Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 05/35, March 20, 2005.*

### 11.8 percent in 2004, up from 11.5 percent in 2003.

### _cr05105 - 11.8 percent in 2004, up from 11.5 percent in 2003.

### Inflation and monetary policy
- Headline: "11.8 percent in 2004, up from 11.5 percent in 2003."
- Inflation developments:
  - CPI inflation (1994 base) climbed to 7.9 percent y/y in December, from 3.1 percent y/y in December 2003.
  - Average inflation increased to 5.5 percent, above the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP)’s target range of 4-5 percent.
  - Primary causes: succession of supply shocks led by a jump in meat and fish prices, followed by the surge in world oil prices and a hike in power tariffs.
  - Signs of broader inflationary pressures emerged, including a rise in core inflation.
- Monetary policy response:
  - The BSP kept policy rates on hold, preferring to wait for more definitive evidence that inflation is becoming generalized before adjusting policy.
  - Directors were split: some supported continued monitoring by the BSP; many others believed an increase in policy rates was required to guide inflationary expectations down.
  - BSP committed to guiding monetary policy by the inflation objective and to continuing to manage the exchange rate flexibly.

### Fiscal position and public finances
- National government deficit (authorities’ definition):
  - Estimated at 3.8 percent of GDP in 2004, below the budget target of 4.2 percent of GDP, and down from 4.6 percent of GDP in 2003.
- Revenue and spending:
  - Revenue estimated to have remained broadly unchanged as a share of GDP.
  - Primary spending compressed; major expenditure savings from personnel services (absence of general wage increase for second consecutive year) and transfers to local government units fixed in nominal terms due to re-enactment of the 2003 budget.
- Public sector losses and broader deficit:
  - Power sector losses expanded to 1.5 percent of GDP in 2004, from 1.1 percent of GDP in 2003.
  - Nonfinancial public sector deficit estimated at 5.3 percent of GDP in 2004, down from 5.6 percent of GDP in 2003.
- IMF/Directors’ fiscal policy recommendations:
  - Full and quick implementation of the authorities’ reform package to reduce vulnerabilities and achieve public debt sustainability.
  - Passage of further tax measures with clear and certain revenue yield; Directors welcomed consideration of raising the VAT rate and repealing VAT exemptions.
  - Emphasis on a strong and front-loaded fiscal adjustment in 2005 to signal commitment to tackling the fiscal problem.
  - Improve tax administration (improved audit strategies, increased prosecution of evaders); several Directors warned against a tax amnesty.
  - Allow some additional spending in priority areas including infrastructure and social programs if substantial revenue yield is achieved.
  - Reform civil service with affordable severance packages; pursue pension reforms to place public pensions on sustainable footing.

### Balance of payments and reserves
- Current account and external flows:
  - Strong growth of exports, tourism receipts, and remittances more than offset higher oil imports.
  - Current account surplus increased slightly to an estimated 4½ percent of GDP in 2004.
  - For much of the year the surplus looked insufficient to finance net capital outflows and negative errors and omissions, and a loss of foreign exchange reserves was expected.
- Reserves outcome:
  - In the fourth quarter a weak U.S. dollar eased pressure on the peso allowing the BSP to make modest purchases of foreign exchange.
  - Reserves, adjusted for pledged assets, ended the year up slightly at US$15 billion (119 percent of short-term debt by residual maturity).
- Directors’ external vulnerability concerns:
  - Vulnerabilities remain high due to large external debt and financing requirements; economy susceptible to external shocks, especially changes in market sentiment and increases in global interest rates and oil prices.
  - Importance of maintaining reform momentum to meet large external borrowing needs.

### Structural reforms, banking, and power sector
- Reform agenda and recent steps:
  - Authorities laying out comprehensive package addressing fiscal, power, and banking sectors and reducing high debt levels.
  - Recent developments: passage of bill raising alcohol and tobacco excises; increase in duties on oil and petroleum imports; provisional tariff increase awarded to the National Power Corporation (NPC); announced sale of a large power plant.
- Power sector:
  - Directors viewed significant increase in generation tariffs provisionally awarded to NPC as important for fiscal consolidation.
  - Urged acceleration of power sector privatization to restore financial viability and facilitate needed investments.
  - Expected objectives: sell transmission assets as soon as possible and privatize majority of generation assets by the end of 2005.
  - Need for a predictable rules-based regulatory framework to improve investment climate.
- Banking and financial sector:
  - Banks have begun using the special purpose vehicle framework to dispose of nonperforming assets.
  - Submission to Congress of amendments to the BSP Charter to strengthen bank supervision; tightening regulation of banks’ trust operations welcomed.
  - Directors urged ensuring acceptance of supervisory empowerment measures and continuing consolidation and recapitalization.
  - Commended strengthening of anti-money laundering regime and removal of the Philippines from the Financial Action Task Force’s list of Non-Cooperative Countries and Territories.
  - Encourage further deepening of financial markets, including the domestic capital market.

### Near-term outlook and risks
- Staff projection:
  - GDP expected to grow at 4¾ percent in 2005 (more moderate than rapid 2004 growth).
  - Staff expects inflation (using the new 2000 base) to remain above the target range of 5–6 percent in 2005.
- Key uncertainties and risk factors:
  - Oil price movements.
  - Strength of world demand, particularly slowing global demand in the information technology sector.
  - Rising interest rates.
  - Weather conditions affecting agricultural production.
- Policy emphasis:
  - Full and quick implementation of reforms to reduce vulnerabilities, improve investment climate, and support medium-term debt sustainability.
  - Consideration of safety nets and absorption capacity when implementing reforms.

### Selected economic indicators (2000–05) — key figures preserved exactly as presented
- GDP growth: 4.4 1.8 4.3 4.7 6.1 4.7
- CPI inflation (1994 base; annual average): 4.3 6.1 3.0 3.0 5.5 6.8
- National government balance (authorities definition): -4.0 -4.0 -5.3 -4.6 -3.8 -3.5
- National government balance (IMF definition) 1/: -4.5 -4.6 -5.6 -5.0 -4.2 -3.9
- Nonfinancial public sector balance 2/: -4.7 -4.9 -5.7 -5.6 -5.3 -4.4
- Revenue and grants 3/: ... 23.0 20.9 20.9 20.7 21.7
- Expenditure 4/: ... 28.0 26.6 26.5 25.9 26.1
- Broad money (M3) 5/: 4.6 6.8 9.5 3.3 9.2 ...
- Credit to the private sector (net): 8.1 -3.0 1.2 1.8 4.7 ...
- Interest rate (91-day Treasury bill, end period, in percent): 12.9 8.9 5.2 6.5 7.8 7.4 6/
- Trade balance: 5.0 -1.0 0.5 -1.6 -1.2 -1.5
- Current account balance: 8.2 1.9 5.7 4.2 4.5 3.5
- Gross international reserves (in billions of U.S. dollars): 15.0 15.6 16.2 16.9 16.0 ...
- Adjusted reserves (in billions of U.S. dollars) 7/: 13.4 13.2 14.3 14.7 15.1 ...
- Adjusted reserves (in percent of short-term liabilities) 8/: 128.1 114.3 119.5 122.4 118.7 ...

*Source: The Philippine authorities; IMF staff estimates and projections.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/_cr05105.pdf_
