## _cr05141

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr05141](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/_cr05141.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/_cr05141.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/_cr05141.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary — state of the economy
- Growth and outlook:
  - Growth is expected to reach around 8 percent in 2004 (recovering from 1.1 percent in 2003).
  - Growth could slow to about 4 percent in 2005, close to potential.
  - Staff expects medium-term growth to average 4–5 percent.
- Labor market:
  - Unemployment fell from its 17-year high of 5½ percent in Q3 2003 to 3½ percent in Q3 2004, but remains above its historical average of around 2 percent.
  - Construction job losses continued; long-term unemployment among the unskilled has emerged.
- Inflation and prices:
  - CPI rose by 1.7 percent in the first ten months of 2004.
  - An increase in the GST rate from 4 percent to 5 percent in 2004 contributed an estimated 0.4 percentage points to the CPI.
  - Under the present monetary stance, inflation should remain within 2 percent.
- External and fiscal positions:
  - Current account surplus narrowed in the first three quarters of 2004 due to higher imports as investment picked up.
  - Official reserves rose by US$14 billion (US$110 billion at end-November covering 6 months of imports).
  - The fiscal surplus was over 6 percent of GDP last year.
  - Government net asset position estimated at about 120 percent of GDP at end-March 2004; Singapore does not have any external public debt.
- Financial and corporate sectors:
  - Corporate sector profitable with low debt-to-equity ratios.
  - Domestic banks well capitalized with rising non-interest earnings and low nonperforming loans.
  - Bank lending rose since mid-2003, driven mainly by household credit; corporate credit growth has been anemic.
  - Property price deflation appears to be bottoming out.

### Policy stance and monetary policy assessment
- Monetary policy actions and stance:
  - MAS announced a modest and gradual tightening of its monetary stance in April and maintained this position in the subsequent October policy review.
  - Operational shift from a “zero appreciation” NEER path adopted in mid-2001 to a modest and gradual appreciation.
  - The NEER had depreciated by 6½ percent since 2001, appreciated modestly in Q3 2004, but reverted to its pre-April announcement level toward end-2004.
- Staff technical assessment:
  - MAS behavior approximated by a Taylor rule with 80 percent weight on the deviation of the 9–12 month ahead expected inflation from a “target” inflation rate of 2 percent, and 20 percent weight on the output gap.
  - Staff estimates another 1–1½ percent appreciation of the NEER is needed to keep the 9–12 month ahead inflation under 2 percent, likely spread over the next 3–6 months.
- Policy transparency and credibility:
  - MAS increased transparency (publication of Monetary Policy Statement, operational information, money market data).
  - MAS does not publish the trade-weighted exchange rate index, the policy band, or its central rate; deliberate “translucence” intended to prevent market testing of the trading band.
  - Practice has not impaired credibility: low and stable inflation over almost ten years despite several large shocks.
- Recommendation on monetary stance:
  - Current tightening judged appropriate given little slack; if slowdown proves more severe, monetary policy may need to become supportive, possibly ahead of scheduled reviews.

### Fiscal policy, buffers, and recommendations
- Fiscal stance and outcomes:
  - Current fiscal stance assessed as broadly neutral (staff calculation of the fiscal impulse).
  - FY2005/06 budget plans large capital spending and GST rate increase intended to keep fiscal stance neutral.
  - FY2003 fiscal surplus: over 6 percent of GDP (noted as much higher than expected due to lower-than-budgeted capital spending).
  - Staff projections indicate FY2005/06 fiscal outturn could be better-than-budgeted by ⅓ percent of GDP due to cyclical improvement in revenue.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Room to cut the top personal income tax rate to 20 percent from 22 percent to restore parity with the corporate tax rate and to strengthen the social safety net (e.g., increase medical benefits to the elderly) in FY2005/06 without straining medium-term balanced budget objective.
  - Consider changing tax assessment to current-year income from previous-year income to fortify automatic stabilizers (mission supported this change though corporates perceived increased compliance costs).
  - Review the present 50-percent limit on the use of yearly investment income against future revenue and spending profiles.
  - Government encouraged to leverage fiscal strength to assist long-term unemployed and low-income retirees without compromising insurance need; authorities preferred retraining and job-matching schemes and were unwilling to introduce entitlement programs.

### External position, exchange rate, and current account
- Current account and reserves:
  - Current account surplus rose from around 14 percent of GDP in 2000 to nearly 31 percent of GDP in 2003; expected to moderate somewhat this year.
  - Staff expects current account surplus to narrow as export growth slows and investment increases.
  - Gross official reserves (US$ billion): 1999: 77.2; 2000: 80.4; 2001: 75.8; 2002: 82.3; 2003: 96.3; 2004: 112.8; (Table reference: 2004 Nov.: 110.1 in some tables).
- Exchange rate indicators:
  - As of November 30, 2004: US$1 = S$1.6417.
  - Trade-weighted exchange rate index (IMF calculation): depreciated by 6½ percent since 2001; appreciated by 1¼ percent in 2004.
  - Nominal effective exchange rate (period averages): 2001: 121.2; 2002: 120.2; 2003: 115.7; 2004: 114.0 (as of end-September 2004).
  - Real effective exchange rate (period averages): 2001: 108.2; 2002: 105.7; 2003: 101.0; 2004: 98.4 (as of end-September 2004).
- Staff cautions and views:
  - Staff cautioned large current account surpluses were not fully explained by private sector behavior; government and GLCs are major contributors to domestic saving and their allocation matters for exchange rate determination.
  - Present intended monetary tightening would keep the NEER on an appreciating path, helping reduce Singapore’s current account surplus and contribute to orderly global current account adjustment.

### Financial sector, regulatory issues, and FSSA progress
- Financial sector soundness:
  - Bank profitability and capitalization are strong; nonperforming loans are low.
  - Three local Singapore banks control about 60 percent of deposits and have the lowest net interest rate margin in the region.
  - Domestic banks have consolidated and expanded abroad since 1999 (acquisitions in Malaysia, Hong Kong SAR, Thailand, the Philippines and Indonesia); results mixed.
- Regulatory responses and recommendations:
  - MAS set up a unit to coordinate implementation of the FSSA recommendations.
  - Progress includes lowering the minimum capital requirement for local banks from 12 percent to 10 percent.
  - Mission encouraged clarifying roles of MAS and its accountability in planned MAS Act amendments.
  - Mission supported introduction of a deposit insurance scheme, scheduled for 2005 (proposed coverage up to S$20,000 per depositor and per institution; banks to pay a risk-weighted insurance premium).
  - Authorities intend to implement the Basel II standards in tandem with the G10 countries, by end-2007.
  - MAS published the Financial Stability Review, a new bi-annual publication.
  - Recent speculative oil trading losses by a Singapore-listed subsidiary of an overseas company indicate room for further improvement in corporate governance and disclosure vigilance.
- Selected bank indicators (sequence reported 1998–1st half 2004 or as noted):
  - Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 18.1, 20.6, 19.6, 18.1, 16.9, 17.9, 15.5.
  - Nonperforming loans to total loans: ...5.3, 3.4, 3.6, 3.4, 3.2, 2.9.
  - Classified loans to total loans: 7.8, 8.5, 5.6, 5.7, 5.5, 5.1, 4.3.
  - After-tax return on assets: 0.4, 1.2, 1.3, 0.8, 0.8, 0.9, 1.4.
  - After-tax return on equity: 4.2, 10.7, 12.6, 7.7, 7.6, 8.3, 12.8.

### Structural reforms, medium-term issues, and labor market policies
- Structural reform actions:
  - Tax system changes to reduce business costs; corporate and top personal tax rates cut (to 22 percent in YA2003; corporate rate to 20 percent from YA2005).
  - GST raised from 3 percent to 4 percent on January 1, 2003, and to 5 percent on January 1, 2004; GST offset packages implemented in 2003-04.
  - Increased wage and labor market flexibility; portable medical benefits; Tripartite Taskforce encouraged flexible wage adoption—by end-June 2004 more than 60 percent of private sector workforce under some form of flexible wages.
  - Liberalization of banking, telecom, and utility sectors; enhancements to financial regulatory and supervisory framework.
  - Negotiation of bilateral free-trade agreements with major trading partners; FTAs consistent with WTO and ASEAN commitments.
- Medium-term challenges and policy recommendations:
  - Authorities emphasize dependence on new engines of growth (pharmaceuticals, biotechnology, nanotechnology, fund management, healthcare, education).
  - Mission encouraged accelerating divestment of GLCs; authorities prefer a measured, case-by-case pace and stress effective firewalls among legislative, regulatory, and participatory government roles.
  - CPF refocus: mandatory savings scheme refocused as core retirement scheme; recent measures raised minimum savings for retirement and budgetary transfers aid CPF members with insufficient resources.
  - Mission recommends reducing CPF Investment Scheme transaction costs by pooling funds under a small number of asset managers with simpler risk-return portfolios.
  - Structural unemployment concerns: loss of low-end manufacturing jobs and shift to capital-intensive industries increasing long-term unemployment risk for less-educated and less-skilled workers; authorities implementing retraining and upskilling via Workforce Development Agency.

### Data, transparency, and Fund relations
- Data improvements and gaps:
  - Authorities published net international investment position (IIP) data for 2001–2003; IIP levels appeared understated relative to large current account surpluses and have been revised upward recently.
  - Merchandise trade statistics do not fully include trade with Indonesia; partial data released for 2003 and further publication planned.
  - Government assets held abroad not published nor provided to Fund; consolidated public sector financial position not published.
  - Singapore meets SDDS specifications for coverage, periodicity, and timeliness and generally publishes economic and financial data on a timely basis.
  - Staff encourages authorities to consider a comprehensive review of the statistical base by participating in a data ROSC.
- Fund procedural facts:
  - Membership: Joined August 3, 1966; Article VIII.
  - Quota: SDR 862.50 million.
  - Fund holdings of currency: 572.98 (SDR million) (66.43 percent of quota); Reserve position in Fund: 289.56 (SDR million) (33.57 percent of quota).
  - Last Article IV consultation: discussions held December 3-15, 2003; concluded by Executive Board on March 15, 2004.
  - FSAP participation: FSAP undertaken with the 2003 Article IV consultation with missions in November 2002, July-August 2003, and September 2003.

### Key projections, indicators, and recommended follow-up
- Macroeconomic projections and key indicators:
  - Real GDP growth: 2003: 1.1; 2004: 8.1; 2005 (Proj.): 4.0.
  - CPI inflation: 2003: 0.5; 2004: 1.7; 2005 (Proj.): 1.6.
  - Unemployment rate (period average): 2003: 4.7; 2004: 3.9; 2005 (Proj.): 3.5.
  - Current account balance (US$ billion): 2001: 16.1; 2002: 18.9; 2003: 28.2; 2004: 29.8; 2005 (Proj.): 26.2.
  - Current account as percent of GDP: (2001) (18.7); (2002) (21.4); (2003) (30.9); (2004) (28.8); (2005) (23.3).
  - Gross national savings (percent of GDP): 1999: 50.6; 2000: 46.3; 2001: 43.6; 2002: 42.5; 2003: 44.2; 2004: 45.1; 2005 (Proj.): 40.3.
  - Gross capital formation (percent of GDP): 1999: 32.0; 2000: 32.0; 2001: 24.9; 2002: 21.2; 2003: 13.4; 2004: 16.3; 2005 (Proj.): 17.0.
  - Exports of goods and services (percentage change): 1999: 7.9; 2000: 14.7; 2001: -6.4; 2002: 3.6; 2003: 9.5; 2004: 18.5; 2005 (Proj.): 6.1.
  - Electronics exports (US$ billion, first three quarters): 2003: 65.1; 2004: 71.6; 2005 (Proj.): 64.9.
- Staff recommendations and follow-up:
  - The staff recommends the current exchange-rate-centered tightening to continue but to be ready to ease if downside risks materialize.
  - Implement remaining FSSA recommendations, clarify MAS roles and accountability in MAS Act amendments, and enhance regulatory vigilance of listed companies.
  - Consider targeted fiscal measures (top personal income tax cut to 20 percent; strengthening social safety net) given better-than-budgeted outturn.
  - Encourage greater transparency of public-sector investment companies (publish aggregate assets/portfolio elements without sensitive details) and consider publishing consolidated public sector accounts.
  - Next Article IV consultation recommended on the standard 12-month cycle.

*Source: _cr05141 — Executive Summary and selected excerpts from IMF staff report (content unit provided).*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### Executive Summary

### State of the Economy
- Singapore’s economy recovered rapidly since mid-2003 after a series of adverse shocks (Asian crisis, technology bubble, SARS).
- Growth performance:
  - Growth is expected to reach around 8 percent in 2004 (recovering from 1.1 percent in 2003).
  - Growth could slow to about 4 percent in 2005, close to potential.
  - Staff expects medium-term growth to average 4–5 percent.
- Labor market:
  - Unemployment fell from its 17-year high of 5½ percent in Q3 2003 to 3½ percent in Q3 2004, but remains above its historical average of around 2 percent.
  - Construction job losses have continued; long-term unemployment among the unskilled has emerged.
- Inflation and prices:
  - CPI rose by 1.7 percent in the first ten months of 2004.
  - An increase in the GST rate from 4 percent to 5 percent in 2004 contributed an estimated 0.4 percentage points to the CPI.
  - Under the present monetary stance, inflation should remain within 2 percent.
- External and fiscal positions:
  - The current account surplus narrowed in the first three quarters of 2004 due to higher imports as investment picked up.
  - Official reserves rose by US$14 billion (US$110 billion at end-November covering 6 months of imports).
  - The fiscal surplus was over 6 percent of GDP last year.
  - Public finances: government net asset position estimated at about 120 percent of GDP at end-March 2004; Singapore does not have any external public debt.
- Financial and corporate sectors:
  - Corporate sector profitable with low debt-to-equity ratios.
  - Domestic banks well capitalized with rising non-interest earnings and low nonperforming loans.
  - Bank lending rose since mid-2003, driven mainly by household credit; corporate credit growth has been anemic.
  - Property price deflation appears to be bottoming out.

### Policy Stance
- Monetary and fiscal policies have focused on orderly and gradual withdrawal of recent stimulus.
- MAS monetary policy:
  - In April (year unspecified in excerpt), MAS announced a modest and gradual tightening of its monetary stance and maintained this position in the subsequent October policy review.
  - Operational shift from a “zero appreciation” path of the nominal effective exchange rate (NEER) adopted in mid-2001 to a modest and gradual appreciation.
  - The NEER had depreciated by 6½ percent since 2001, appreciated modestly in Q3 2004, but reverted to its pre-April announcement level toward end-2004.
- Fiscal stance:
  - Current fiscal stance assessed as broadly neutral (staff calculation of the fiscal impulse).
  - This year’s budget plans large capital spending and GST rate increase intended to keep fiscal stance neutral.
  - The authorities have been cautious in expanding the social safety net despite large reserves.

### Recent Developments (summary)
- Recovery drivers:
  - Recovery mainly driven by exports (strong global electronics demand) and since early 2004 by domestic investment.
  - Four straight quarters of double-digit growth from Q3 2003 to Q2 2004; pace slackened in Q3–Q4 2004.
- Labor and wages:
  - Rapid productivity growth outstripped real wage increases, producing a substantial decline in labor cost to date.
  - The National Wages Council recommended moderate wage increases for 2004/05—the first proposed rise in three years.
- Inflation composition:
  - Inflation led by rising education, health, and food costs.
  - High global oil prices had only a modest effect on CPI because of retailer margin compression and low weight of oil-dependent goods in the consumption basket.

### Economic Prospects and Risks
- Near-term outlook:
  - Activity expected to moderate; softening global demand and cresting world electronic cycle could reduce GDP growth to about 4 percent in 2005.
  - Domestic demand to play a larger role, including restocking of inventories.
  - Little slack expected in the economy; labor market tightening and rising real wages will raise inflationary pressures; high energy prices add to upside risk.
  - Current account surplus should narrow as export growth slows and investment increases.
- Uncertainty and risk factors:
  - Key external risks: volatility in oil prices, extent of downturn in global electronics cycle, level of activity in China, geopolitical tensions and security threats.
  - Scenario sensitivities noted: on current forecast, global semiconductor sales expected to remain flat in 2005 after growing by nearly 30 percent in 2004; estimates suggest that a 10 percent decline in semiconductor sales growth can reduce GDP growth by 1 percentage point.
  - Despite risks, strong external and fiscal positions and a resilient financial system make the risk of a crisis low.

### Structural Reforms and Medium-Term Issues
- Reforms undertaken to diversify the economy and enhance competitiveness:
  - Tax system changes to reduce business costs.
  - Increased wage and labor market flexibility.
  - Liberalization of banking, telecom, and utility sectors.
  - Enhancements to financial regulatory and supervisory framework.
  - Negotiation of free-trade agreements with major trading partners.
- Structural outcomes and new sectors:
  - Manufacturing moving up the quality ladder; market share of electronics exports has increased.
  - New industries such as pharmaceuticals expanding rapidly.
  - Role as an international hub for goods and services is expanding; financial and trading sectors diversifying into new businesses.
  - Staff judges medium-term growth prospects hinge on the strength of new engines of growth in the face of regional competition.

### Policy Discussions and Staff Recommendations
- General view:
  - Discussions centered on the appropriate policy stance to support growth while keeping inflationary pressures under check, and on the direction and early impact of structural reforms to strengthen competitiveness.
- Monetary policy:
  - The current tightening of monetary policy is judged appropriate as there is little slack in the economy.
  - If the slowdown proves more severe, monetary policy may need to become supportive.
- Fiscal and social policy:
  - This year’s higher-than-expected growth provides room to cut the personal income tax rate and further strengthen the existing social safety net in next year’s budget (as discussed by staff/authorities).
- Structural agenda:
  - A wide range of structural reforms is being implemented to enable new sources of growth to take hold.
  - Several schemes have been put in place to retrain and upgrade the skills of the unemployed in response to the rise in long-term unemployment.
  - The government is negotiating bilateral free-trade agreements with neighboring countries.
- Financial sector:
  - Financial sector remains robust; MAS has implemented many FSSA recommendations and taken steps to enhance transparency of the monetary policy framework.
  - Progress on FSSA recommendations noted; bank profitability and capitalization are strong.

*Source: _cr05141 - Executive Summary*

### 17.      With little slack in the economy going forward, the staff supported MAS’s

### _cr05141 - 17.      With little slack in the economy going forward, the staff supported MAS’s

### Monetary policy stance and risks
- Staff supported MAS’s announced monetary policy tightening to allow an orderly and gradual withdrawal of recent stimulus.
- Inflationary pressures were likely to be moderate, but staff noted monetary policy should become more supportive, perhaps even ahead of the scheduled policy review in April 2005, if downside risks became ominous.
- Authorities: would change policy between bi-annual reviews if needed (as after September 11, 2001); the band around the target NEER path provides some room to accommodate unexpected developments.
- Authorities did not view increased exchange rate flexibility in regional currencies (particularly the renminbi) as complicating monetary policy because they use a trade-weighted exchange rate as an intermediate target.
- Staff technical assessment (footnote): MAS behavior approximated by a Taylor rule with 80 percent weight on the deviation of the 9–12 month ahead expected inflation from a “target” inflation rate of 2 percent, and 20 percent weight on the output gap; staff estimates that another 1–1½ percent appreciation of the NEER is needed to keep the 9–12 month ahead inflation under 2 percent, likely spread over the next 3–6 months.

### Policy transparency and credibility
- Mission welcomed MAS’s ongoing efforts to increase transparency: publication of Monetary Policy Statement and dissemination of operational information and data on money market transactions.
- MAS does not publish the trade-weighted exchange rate index, the policy band, or its central rate; this deliberate “translucence” is intended to prevent market testing of the trading band and to allow correction of policy mistakes without severe disruption.
- Practice has not impaired credibility: evidenced by low and stable inflation over almost ten years despite several large shocks.

### Current account surge, REER, and drivers
- Current account surplus rose from around 14 percent of GDP in 2000 to nearly 31 percent of GDP in 2003; expected to moderate somewhat this year.
- Over the period noted, the real exchange rate depreciated by about 8 percent.
- Authorities view surge in current account surplus and current REER as in line with fundamentals: spike reflects households’ and corporate sector’s market-based response to increased uncertainty; domestic investment reduced (by over 18 percentage points of GDP) while investment abroad increased.
- Authorities and mission agreed surplus likely to decline as prospects stabilize but remain fairly high given Singapore’s demographics.
- Staff cautioned large current account surpluses were not fully explained by private sector behavior: government and GLCs are major contributors to domestic saving and their allocation between domestic and foreign investment matters for exchange rate determination.
- No perceptible signs of major REER misalignment in commodity or asset prices: inflation stable and low; equity and real estate markets not showing overheating.
- Present intended monetary tightening would keep the NEER on an appreciating path, helping reduce Singapore’s current account surplus and contribute to orderly global current account adjustment.

### Fiscal policy, buffers, and recommendations
- Mission commended judicious fiscal support in early 2000s; fiscal policy since has been broadly neutral.
- FY2005/06 budget: staff projections indicate this year’s fiscal outturn could be better-than-budgeted by ⅓ percent of GDP due to cyclical improvement in revenue.
- Staff suggested room to cut the top personal income tax rate to 20 percent from 22 percent to restore parity with the corporate tax rate and to strengthen the social safety net (e.g., increase medical benefits to the elderly) in FY2005/06 without straining the medium-term balanced budget objective.
- Authorities considering measures including strengthening social assistance.
- Authorities exploring ways to fortify automatic stabilizers to reduce reliance on discretionary measures: consideration to change tax assessment to current-year income from previous-year income; mission supported this change though corporates perceived increased compliance costs.
- Authorities considering treating ex ante spending limits on certain spending and transfers more flexibly to improve cyclical response.
- Government values high fiscal reserves for investor confidence, capacity to finance tax cuts and infrastructure spending, and as a buffer against rising health costs with aging population.
- Mission observed government could leverage fiscal strength to assist long-term unemployed and low-income retirees without compromising insurance need; authorities preferred retraining and job-matching schemes and were unwilling to introduce entitlement programs.
- Staff suggested reviewing the present 50-percent limit on the use of yearly investment income against future revenue and spending profiles; authorities considered the limit important to safeguard reserves.

### Public-sector investment companies and transparency
- Mission welcomed first public review of Temasek’s operations; review shows Temasek’s portfolio well diversified across sectors and countries.
- Staff suggested government could consider publishing, without sensitive details, aggregate assets of GIC, broad portfolio elements, and overall returns; authorities argued GIC operations were strategic, had sufficient internal oversight, and saw no benefit in disclosing market value of GIC’s assets.
- Authorities reluctant to compile consolidated public sector accounts; agreed in principle to participate in fiscal ROSC exercise but needed to assess resource costs before committing to a timetable.

### Temasek profile and governance (Box 2)
- Temasek manages a portfolio of about US$53 billion (55 percent of GDP), roughly equally divided between domestic and foreign investments; Temasek companies account for some 13 percent of Singapore’s GDP.
- Total shareholder’s return: 18 percent per annum over the past 30 years; returns lower, 3 percent to 6 percent, in the last 5–10 years.
- Temasek attributes success to a corporate governance framework with operational autonomy; board accountable to the President; President approves appointment/removal of board members and the CEO.
- Concerns: presence of Temasek companies in certain sectors may hinder private participation; Temasek charter directs divestment of non-strategic holdings without setting a time frame.
- Recent publication of Temasek’s charter and review seen as a welcome move toward greater transparency as Temasek expands overseas.

### Medium-term growth strategy and structural issues
- Authorities emphasize dependence on new engines of growth; regional competition (China and India) eroding traditional advantages via increased openness and low-cost structures.
- Government adopted Economic Review Committee (ERC) recommendations (2003) to enhance competitiveness, promote private entrepreneurship, and facilitate diversification; progress made on wage flexibility, reducing business costs, outward expansion of firms, and promoting Singapore as a business hub.
- Mission encouraged accelerating divestment of GLCs; authorities prefer a measured, case-by-case pace and stress effective firewalls among legislative, regulatory, and participatory government roles.
- Competition Law recently legislated; staff urged review of sector-specific competitive conditions.
- Singapore pursuing bilateral FTAs to access new markets and strengthen multilateral trade system; FTAs considered consistent with WTO principles and not conflicting with multilateral and ASEAN agreements.
- CPF refocus: mandatory savings scheme being refocused as core retirement scheme rather than a discretionary countercyclical instrument; recent measures raised minimum savings for retirement and budgetary transfers aid CPF members with insufficient resources.
- Mission view: further cuts in contribution rates limited without compromising wage replacement rates; recommend reducing CPF Investment Scheme transaction costs by pooling funds under a small number of asset managers with simpler risk-return portfolios.
- Government plans to align CPF rates of return with long-term government security yields to improve returns over time.
- Structural unemployment concerns: loss of low-end manufacturing jobs and shift to capital-intensive industries increasing long-term unemployment risk for less-educated and less-skilled workers.
- Authorities addressing structural unemployment via retraining and skills upgrading programs; Workforce Development Agency (formed in 2003) coordinates and strengthens these programs.

*Source: _cr05141 - 17.      With little slack in the economy going forward, the staff supported MAS’s*

### 32.      The mission held extensive discussions on the regulatory challenges arising from

### _cr05141 - 32.      The mission held extensive discussions on the regulatory challenges arising from

### Regulatory challenges from banks’ overseas expansion and asset management growth
- Mission observations and authorities' views:
  - Bank profitability and capitalization remained strong.
  - Local banks have responded to increased domestic competition from foreign banks by consolidating at home and expanding abroad.
  - Expansion abroad could pose new risks and regulatory challenges, including differing objectives between parent banks and local institutions and potential lack of information for local supervisors.
  - MAS monitors risks from these developments and maintains regular contact with regulators in host countries.
  - Client accountability was stressed in regulating asset managers and hedge funds, while financial exposure of banks to these firms was closely monitored.
- Household and labor context relevant to financial stability:
  - Over 90 percent of households are homeowners.
  - Total net household wealth is over 150 percent of GDP in residential property; overall net wealth of households is around 350 percent of GDP.
  - Net household wealth held as equity in pension funds (including CPF) is around 65 percent of GDP.
  - The natural rate of unemployment has been estimated by the authorities to be creeping up to around 3–3½ percent in recent years from around 2 percent before the Asian crisis.
- Box 3 summary: Overseas expansion of domestic banks
  - The three local Singapore banks control about 60 percent of deposits and have the lowest net interest rate margin in the region.
  - Competitive pressures have led domestic banks to consolidate and expand abroad.
  - Advantages for expansion: sound regulatory environment, high capitalization, and low NPLs.
  - Since 1999, Singapore banks have acquired interest in Malaysia, Hong Kong SAR, Thailand, the Philippines and Indonesia; results of overseas acquisitions have been mixed.
  - MAS is actively seeking cooperation with host-country regulators and home regulators of foreign banks active in Singapore.

### Key financial indicators and regulatory changes
- MAS implementation and FSSA recommendations:
  - MAS set up a unit to coordinate implementation of the FSSA recommendations.
  - Progress includes lowering the minimum capital requirement for local banks from 12 percent to 10 percent, a step endorsed by the FSSA.
  - The mission encouraged clarifying the roles of the monetary authority and its accountability in planned amendments to the MAS Act.
  - The mission supported the introduction of a deposit insurance scheme, scheduled for 2005.
  - The authorities were encouraged to regularly update and publish financial soundness indicators.
  - MAS published the Financial Stability Review, a new bi-annual publication.
  - Authorities intend to implement the Basel II standards in tandem with the G10 countries, by end-2007.
  - The FSSA concluded that regulatory and supervisory practices were close to international standards and codes, including in accounting standards; initiatives to improve corporate governance and disclosure practices had been taken.
  - Recent speculative oil trading losses by a Singapore-listed subsidiary of an overseas company indicate room for further improvement in corporate governance and disclosure vigilance.
- Selected numeric indicators for local banks (as reported):
  - Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 18.1, 20.6, 19.6, 18.1, 16.9, 17.9, 15.5 (1998–1st half 2004 sequence as in source).
  - Nonperforming loans to total loans: ...5.3, 3.4, 3.6, 3.4, 3.2, 2.9 (sequence).
  - Classified loans to total loans: 7.8, 8.5, 5.6, 5.7, 5.5, 5.1, 4.3 (sequence).
  - After-tax return on assets: 0.4, 1.2, 1.3, 0.8, 0.8, 0.9, 1.4 (sequence).
  - After-tax return on equity: 4.2, 10.7, 12.6, 7.7, 7.6, 8.3, 12.8 (sequence).
- Deposit insurance design note:
  - Proposed scheme would cover up to S$20,000 per depositor and per institution, with banks paying a risk-weighted insurance premium.

### Data improvements and net IIP issues
- Data releases and quality:
  - Authorities published net international investment position (IIP) data for 2001–2003.
  - Mission noted the IIP levels appeared understated relative to large current account surpluses since the 1990s; officials suggested differing market values of portfolios of foreign and resident investors and limited survey coverage as possible causes.
  - IIP positions have been revised upward recently.
  - Officials responded positively to staff suggestion of conducting a comprehensive review of the statistical bases by participating in a data ROSC; modalities and resource cost are being reviewed before a final decision.

### Staff appraisal: macro outlook, policy stances, and recommendations
- Near-term outlook and macro risks:
  - Singapore’s economy recovered rapidly since mid-2003; job creation gathered strength following large productivity gains.
  - Favorable external environment, strong global electronics demand, supportive macroeconomic policies, and structural reforms underpinned the recovery.
  - Output growth could slow to about 4 percent in 2005, taking into account a softening in global demand and cresting of the global electronic cycle.
  - Considerable uncertainty remains, especially on the external front; little slack likely in the economy given recent rapid growth.
  - Tightening in the labor market and high energy prices could raise inflationary pressures.
- Monetary policy assessment:
  - Current tightening stance of monetary policy is appropriate to pave the way for orderly and gradual withdrawal of stimulus; if slowdown is larger than expected, monetary policy may need to become more supportive.
  - MAS’s exchange-rate-centered monetary policy framework has worked well to keep inflation low and stable; efforts to increase transparency are commendable.
- Exchange rate and current account:
  - No apparent signs of real exchange rate misalignment.
  - Rise in recent current account surpluses not fully explained by private sector behavior; foreign investment by the government and GLCs could have helped ward off upward pressures on the real exchange rate.
  - With expected increase in domestic investment and the authorities’ intended appreciation of the nominal effective exchange rate, current account surpluses should narrow in the near term.
- Fiscal policy and transparency:
  - Fiscal policy has been judiciously used to support the economy; fiscal position this year likely to be better than budgeted given higher-than-expected growth.
  - Better-than-budgeted outturn could provide room to cut the top personal income tax rate in the next budget and strengthen the social safety net.
  - Singapore’s fiscal-policy framework of maintaining a balanced budget over the medium term remains appropriate; framework could be improved by setting the limit on the use of annual investment income within the context of Singapore’s future revenue potential and spending needs.
  - Recent public review of Temasek’s operations is a milestone for fiscal transparency; staff suggested publishing, without disclosing strategic and sensitive details, GIC’s aggregate assets, broad portfolio elements, and overall returns; publishing consolidated public sector accounts in line with international accounting standards was recommended.
- Structural and competitiveness policies:
  - Authorities implemented reforms to enhance competitiveness: increased labor market and wage flexibility, reduced business taxes and costs, and promoted outward expansion of Singapore firms.
  - Quality upgrading and diversification in manufacturing and expansion into regional asset management, health, and education services are underway.
  - Staff encourages stepping up the GLC divestment process to promote entrepreneurship and increase the role of the private sector.
  - Newly legislated Competition Law should help strengthen separation of government roles as referee and player.
- Financial sector regulatory recommendations:
  - Authorities encouraged to implement remaining FSSA recommendations, including clarifying MAS roles and accountability in planned amendments to the MAS Act.
  - Recent speculative trading losses by a listed company suggest need for increased regulatory vigilance of companies trading on the Singapore exchange.
- Pension and retirement policy recommendations:
  - Given the aging population, ensuring adequate provision for the retired is a key challenge.
  - Measures to refocus CPF as a core retirement scheme are welcome.
  - Increasing use of flexible wage contracts has reduced need for discretionary changes in contribution rates for countercyclical purposes.
  - CPF investment scheme’s high transaction costs could be reduced by pooling funds under a single or a small number of asset managers with simpler choices of risk-return portfolios, allowing more extensive use of the scheme.
- Data dissemination recommendation:
  - Singapore is in observance of the SDDS and generally publishes economic and financial data on a timely basis; staff encourages authorities to consider a comprehensive review of the statistical base by participating in a data ROSC.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt (content unit provided).*

### 45.      The staff recommends that the next Article IV consultation with Singapore be

### _cr05141 - 45.      The staff recommends that the next Article IV consultation with Singapore be

### Recommendation
- The staff recommends that the next Article IV consultation with Singapore be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

### Macroeconomic performance and recent history
- Real GDP growth: 2003: 1.1; 2004: 8.1; 2005 (Proj.): 4.0.
- Drivers of 2004 turnaround: exports (strong global electronics demand) and domestic investment.
- Four straight quarters of double-digit growth from 2003 Q3 through 2004 Q2; growth moderated thereafter.
- Inflation: CPI inflation 2003: 0.5; 2004: 1.7; 2005 (Proj.): 1.6.
- Unemployment rate (period average): 2003: 4.7; 2004: 3.9; 2005 (Proj.): 3.5.
- Current account balance (US$ billion): 2001: 16.1; 2002: 18.9; 2003: 28.2; 2004: 29.8; 2005 (Proj.): 26.2.
- Current account as percent of GDP (selected years shown in table): (2001) (18.7); (2002) (21.4); (2003) (30.9); (2004) (28.8); (2005) (23.3).

### Outlook and risks
- Staff baseline: output growth could slow to about 4 percent in 2005.
- Medium-term IMF staff expectation: growth to average around 4-5 percent.
- Risks: downside risks from external factors; tightening labor market and high energy prices could raise inflationary pressures.
- Policy stance: MAS announced a modest and gradual tightening of monetary stance in April 2004 and maintained it in October 2004; if downside risks materialize, monetary policy might need to become more supportive.

### Fiscal position and policy
- Central government (percent of GDP): Revenue 2003: 20.8; 2004: 20.7; 2005 (Proj.): 20.5.
- Central government expenditure (percent of GDP): 2003: 14.4; 2004: 17.6; 2005 (Proj.): 17.5.
- Overall balance (percent of GDP): 2001: 3.5; 2002: 4.2; 2003: 6.3; 2004: 3.1; 2005 (Proj.): 3.0.
- FY2003 fiscal surplus: over 6 percent of GDP (noted as much higher than expected due to lower-than-budgeted capital spending).
- Authorities’ approach: budget contains large planned capital outlay and an increase in the goods and services tax rate to keep fiscal stance broadly neutral.
- Executive Directors: commended use of fiscal policy to support the economy while adhering to balanced operational budget over the medium term; some Directors suggested scope for additional targeted social spending and personal income tax reductions.

### Monetary and exchange rate policy
- Exchange rate regime: managed floating system; MAS monitors against an undisclosed basket and intervenes to maintain value within an undisclosed band; U.S. dollar is intervention currency.
- As of November 30, 2004: US$1 = S$1.6417.
- Trade-weighted exchange rate index (IMF calculation): depreciated by 6½ percent since 2001; appreciated by 1¼ percent in 2004.
- Nominal effective exchange rate (period averages): 2001: 121.2; 2002: 120.2; 2003: 115.7; 2004: 114.0 (as of end-September 2004).
- Real effective exchange rate (period averages): 2001: 108.2; 2002: 105.7; 2003: 101.0; 2004: 98.4 (as of end-September 2004).
- Executive Directors: viewed the real exchange rate as broadly appropriate; recommended keeping exchange rate policy biased toward appreciation and greater flexibility to help narrow current account surpluses.

### External and reserve positions
- Gross official reserves (US$ billion): 1999: 77.2; 2000: 80.4; 2001: 75.8; 2002: 82.3; 2003: 96.3; 2004: 112.8; (Table reference: 2004 Nov.: 110.1 in some tables).
- Gross external debt (US$ billion): 1999: 34.2; 2000: 32.2; 2001: 33.9; 2002: 33.6; 2003: 36.3; 2004: 38.8 (as of end-March 2004).
- Net international investment position (memorandum): (In billions of U.S. dollars) 67.9; 76.0 (years shown in table).

### Financial sector and stability assessment (FSSA)
- Financial sector: bank profitability and capitalization are strong; nonperforming loans are low.
- Three-month interbank rate (percent, end-year): 2001: 1.30; 2002: 0.80; 2003: 0.80; 2004: 1.40 (as of Nov. 2004).
- Broad money (M3) end-period percent change: 2001: 4.0; 2002: -0.8; 2003: 5.9; 2004: 4.6 (as of end-October 2004).
- Credit to private sector (end-period percent change): 2001: 16.3; 2002: -8.6; 2003: 5.4; 2004: 5.1 (as of end-October 2004).
- FSSA recommendations (Table 8) and status highlights:
  - Macro-prudential monitoring: further strengthen MAS monitoring of risks (some progress; MAS published Financial Stability Review in January 2005).
  - Regulatory and supervisory enhancements: review of capital requirements completed; insurers to comply with new risk-based capital framework from January 1, 2005 (implemented).
  - MAS accountability and independence: working group to propose MAS Act amendments targeted for 2005 (in progress).
  - Transparency: two monographs published on supervisory objectives and MAS roles (under review).
  - AML/CFT: ongoing MLAT negotiations; regional MLAT signed November 2004 with seven ASEAN countries (in progress).
  - Capital market development: review of constraints on corporate bond market (under review).

### Structural reforms and Economic Review Committee (ERC) implementation
- ERC key recommendations and status (selected):
  - Taxation: corporate and top personal tax rates cut (to 22 percent in YA2003; corporate rate to 20 percent from YA2005). GST raised from 3 percent to 4 percent on January 1, 2003, and to 5 percent on January 1, 2004. GST offset packages implemented in 2003-04; additional ERS to be distributed in 2005.
  - Central Provident Fund (CPF): refocus CPF; employer contribution cuts from 16 percent to 13 percent from October 1, 2003; various CPF and Medisave adjustments; tax relief ceiling for voluntary top-up raised by 17 percent from 2005.
  - Labor market: wage flexibility measures; portable medical benefits introduced; Tripartite Taskforce encouraged flexible wage adoption—by end-June 2004 more than 60 percent of private sector workforce under some form of flexible wages.
  - Entrepreneurship and internationalization: GLCs reviewed for divestiture every three years; competition law to come into force in 2005; tax measures to support start-ups and overseas investment losses.
  - Manufacturing and services: incentives extended for pioneer incentive and regional HQ; foreign-sourced income remitted by resident individuals exempt from tax from YA2005; Singapore promoted as business hub and wealth-management center.
  - Human capital: Singapore Workforce Development Agency established September 2003; increased tax relief for course fees; Skills Development Levy salary ceiling raised by 20 percent from July 2004.

### Vulnerabilities and indicators (selected figures)
- Gross national savings (percent of GDP): 1999: 50.6; 2000: 46.3; 2001: 43.6; 2002: 42.5; 2003: 44.2; 2004: 45.1; 2005 (Proj.): 40.3.
- Gross capital formation (percent of GDP): 1999: 32.0; 2000: 32.0; 2001: 24.9; 2002: 21.2; 2003: 13.4; 2004: 16.3; 2005 (Proj.): 17.0.
- Exports of goods and services (percentage change): 1999: 7.9; 2000: 14.7; 2001: -6.4; 2002: 3.6; 2003: 9.5; 2004: 18.5; 2005 (Proj.): 6.1.
- Electronics exports (US$ billion, first three quarters for 2004): 2003: 65.1; 2004: 71.6; 2005 (Proj.): 64.9 (Table 2 notes: For the first three quarters).

### Statistics, data dissemination, and quality
- Singapore meets SDDS specifications for coverage, periodicity, and timeliness; authorities have improved data quality and published more disaggregated data.
- Rebased SNA to reference year 1995 from 1990 in early 2003; improvements in methodology and treatment of GST.
- Merchandise trade statistics do not fully include trade with Indonesia; partial data released for 2003 and further publication planned in connection with WCO Harmonized System accession.
- BOP services account reporting updated in December 2003 to align with BPM5 (except communication services); Survey on International Trade in Services used for compilation.
- Data gaps: government assets held abroad not published nor provided to Fund; consolidated public sector financial position not published; official external public sector debt reported as zero while private external debt data from official sources not available (survey launched to improve reporting).
- Annual BOP data reported to STA; since September 2004 quarterly gross direct and portfolio investment inflows provided following Q1 2004 Quarterly Economic Survey of Singapore dissemination.

### Fund relations and procedural facts
- Membership: Joined August 3, 1966; Article VIII.
- Quota: SDR 862.50 million.
- Fund holdings of currency: 572.98 (SDR million) (66.43 percent of quota); Reserve position in Fund: 289.56 (SDR million) (33.57 percent of quota).
- SDR Department net cumulative allocation: 16.48 (SDR million); Holdings 188.86 (SDR million).
- Outstanding purchases and loans: None; Financial arrangements: None; Projected payments to Fund: None.
- Exchange rate arrangement details: managed float, intervention currency US dollar; disclosure as of November 30, 2004: US$1 = S$1.6417.
- Last Article IV consultation: discussions held December 3-15, 2003; concluded by Executive Board on March 15, 2004.
- FSAP participation: FSAP undertaken with the 2003 Article IV consultation with missions in November 2002, July-August 2003, and September 2003.
- Technical assistance: None; Resident representative: None.

*Source: Excerpt from IMF staff report and Public Information Notice (PIN) on the 2004 Article IV Consultation with Singapore (as contained in the supplied content)._

### Introduction

### _cr05141 - Introduction

### Recent Economic Developments and Outlook
- GDP growth reached a four-year high of 8.1 percent in 2004, with double-digit growth in the first half of the year and slower growth in the second half.
- The rebound created 66,200 jobs in 2004.
- Unemployment rate fell to 3.7 percent in Q4 2004, down from 4.6 percent as at end-2003.
- GDP growth is likely to be 3-5 percent in 2005, reflecting weaker growth in external economies and the global IT industry.
- Overall CPI inflation was 1.7 percent in 2004.
- CPI inflation for 2005 is likely to come in at 1-2 percent, reflecting pass-through of high commodity prices and firming domestic cost pressures.
- Structural policy focus:
  - Continued development of technologically advanced industries and applications such as pharmaceuticals, biotechnology and nanotechnology.
  - Move up the “quality ladder” to stay competitive in the region.
  - More than 3,600 high-tech business start-ups in Singapore in the prior year; at least a quarter were foreign enterprises from countries in the Asia-Pacific region.
  - Progress in developing niche areas in fund management, healthcare, and education.

### Monetary and Fiscal Policy
- Fiscal and monetary policies were expansionary in 2002 and 2003 to assist businesses and workers and facilitate recovery; stimulus was gradually withdrawn in 2004 as the output gap turned positive by mid-year.
- Monetary policy:
  - In April 2004, the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) shifted from a neutral to a tighter monetary policy stance.
  - The appreciating policy stance targets a modest and gradual appreciation of the Singapore dollar nominal effective exchange rate (S$NEER); this stance was reaffirmed in October 2004.
  - MAS will review the policy stance in April 2005 and is ready to adjust the stance if the outlook changes significantly; the exchange rate policy band provides flexibility to accommodate unexpected slowdowns.
  - Authorities disclose historical movements of the S$NEER and key parameters of the policy band where disclosure would not compromise management or disrupt markets; since 2001 public release of the Monetary Policy Statement has enhanced transparency.
- Fiscal policy:
  - Fiscal stance set to be appropriately neutral, in line with expectations for the economy to grow at its potential in 2005.
  - Government will seek to restore budget balance and ensure fiscal sustainability going forward.
  - The FY2005 Budget will be announced on February 18, 2005, and is expected to address: enhancing economic competitiveness; assisting vulnerable groups such as the elderly and unemployed; and assuring fiscal sustainability.
  - Measures for vulnerable groups will target those most in need while avoiding erosion of the work ethic.
  - Announced support measures include top-ups to a newly-established Community Care Fund and the existing Medifund.
  - A new Re-employment Assistance Programme will be launched to help older, less skilled workers through job redesign, job referrals, and skills upgrading.
  - Previous re-employment scheme experience: some 21,000 mature workers acquired new jobs during the recent economic downturn.

### Financial Sector Issues
- FSSA recommendations:
  - Many FSSA recommendations have been implemented.
  - On anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism, Singapore has an ongoing programme of Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty (MLAT) negotiations with several countries, with a few near completion.
  - In November 2004, Singapore signed a regional MLAT with seven ASEAN countries.
  - MAS will address other recommendations where appropriate.
- Corporate governance and disclosure:
  - Regulatory regime for listed companies premised on accurate and timely disclosures by issuers, and effective enforcement when laws are breached.
  - Disclosure, accounting and corporate governance standards have been substantially enhanced and are in line with international best practices.
  - Failure by listed companies to disclose material information on a timely basis has attracted criminal and civil liabilities under the Securities and Futures Act since 2002.
  - Quarterly reporting for larger listed companies (with a market capitalisation above S$75 million) and mandatory compliance with accounting standards aligned with International Accounting Standards were introduced in 2003.
  - All listed companies must explain deviations from the Code of Corporate Governance in their annual reports.
  - The China Aviation Oil case is under investigation; appropriate enforcement actions will be taken if laws or regulations are found to have been breached. Once investigations are clear, MAS will review the need for changes to rules and standards of corporate governance and market conduct.
- Government-linked Companies (GLCs):
  - Temasek’s companies’ performance contrasts with the view of unprofitable and inefficient state-controlled enterprises, reflecting commercial operation without favours or guarantees from the government.
  - Temasek has divested stakes in 36 companies over the last two years.
  - Competition remains a key tenet of Singapore’s economic strategy; the Competition Commission of Singapore was established in January (year implied by context) following the enactment of the Competition Act.

### Other Issues
- Central Provident Fund (CPF):
  - Government refocusing CPF as a core retirement scheme to ensure sufficient savings for retirement.
  - CPF Board explored introducing privately-managed pension plans (PPPs) as an option under the CPF Investment Scheme to improve long-term returns, reduce investment costs and provide simpler choices.
  - Following an extensive industry and public consultation, the CPF Board will assess the framework for PPPs and study other pension funds to determine the most appropriate model for the majority of CPF members’ needs.

*Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/_cr05141.pdf*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2005/_cr05141.pdf_
