## _cr06185

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr06185](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2006/_cr06185.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2006/_cr06185.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2006/_cr06185.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary — macro and social outcomes (2002–2005)
- Poverty rates decreased by 14.5 percentage points during 2002 – 2004.
- By 2004, 26.5% of the population was poor (welfare below the absolute poverty line) versus 40% in 2002.
- Extreme poverty decreased by 11.2 p.p. in 2002–2003; pace of poverty reduction slowed in 2004.
- Gini coefficient fell from 0.38 to 0.36 during 2000 – 2004.
- Estimated average poverty elasticity to average consumption growth (2003–2004): 2.1 percent (each percent of consumption growth reduces the poverty rate by 2.1%).
- Decomposition of poverty reduction 2002–2004:
  - Two thirds attributable to consumption growth.
  - One third attributable to inequality reduction (redistribution).
- 2005 macro performance and external vulnerabilities:
  - GDP increased by 7.1% in 2005.
  - Since 2000 GDP increased by over 43%.
  - GDP per capita in 2005 exceeded US$860.
  - Gross capital formation increased by 11% in 2005.
  - Remittances: 30% of GDP.
  - Imports: 77.5% of GDP.
  - Trade balance deficit: 39% of GDP.
  - Current account deficit: 9.8% of GDP (up from 2.7% in 2004).
  - Remittances growth slowed: 29% in 2005 vs. 45% in 2004.
- Key conclusion: strong consumption-driven growth with high external dependence (remittances and imports) and insufficient structural reform increases external vulnerability and risks to sustainable growth and poverty reduction.

### Poverty, distribution, and household vulnerability
- Key poverty lines and rates:
  - Extreme poverty line (2004): 258.1 MDL per month.
  - Absolute poverty line (2004): 327.0 MDL per month.
  - Relative poverty line (2004): 294.3 MDL per month.
  - International poverty line (USD 2.15 PPP/day) in MDL/person/month: 239.5 (2004).
- Time series highlights:
  - Absolute poverty rate: 67.8 (1998), 73.0 (1999), 67.8 (2000), 54.6 (2001), 40.4 (2002), 29.0 (2003), 26.5 (2004).
  - Extreme poverty rate: 37.4 (1998), 59.7 (1999), 52.2 (2000), 38.0 (2001), 26.2 (2002), 15.0 (2003), 14.7 (2004).
- Distributional snapshot (2000–2004 quintile shares and indicators reproduced exactly):
  - Quintile shares (I–V, 2000–2004 rows): 
    - I Quintile: 6.8 6.5 6.8 7.5 7.2
    - II Quintile: 11.2 10.7 11.1 11.6 11.6
    - III Quintile: 15.3 15.0 15.6 15.7 15.7
    - IV Quintile: 21.5 21.6 22.2 21.6 21.5
    - V Quintile: 45.2 46.2 44.3 43.6 43.9
  - Gini by consumption expenditures per capita: 0.380 0.388 0.372 0.356 0.361
  - 90/10 distribution, mean of consumption expenditures by adult equivalent: 10.45 10.85 9.40 8.39 9.10
- Poverty and demographics:
  - Big cities poverty risk ~ five times smaller than in small cities and rural areas; 7% of big-city population poor in 2004.
  - Rural absolute poverty: 31.2% in 2004 (rural poverty reduction stagnated in 2004).
  - Children and persons 75+ have highest poverty risk; households with 3 or more children: 40% poor.
  - Panel 2001–2004: ~31.3% chronic poor; 39.5% temporary poor.
  - Subjective measures: ~46% of households considered themselves poor (2004); subjective poverty exceeds monetary measures in many cases.

### Macroeconomic structure, external sector, and risks
- GDP and demand composition (selected 2005 figures):
  - GDP growth: 7.1% (2005).
  - Final consumption and investment: gross capital formation contribution increased from 2.4% to 2.9%; final consumption input increased from 2.2% to 9.9%.
- External sector key aggregates:
  - Remittances: 30% of GDP.
  - Imports: 77.5% of GDP.
  - Trade deficit: 39% of GDP.
  - Current account deficit: 9.8% of GDP.
  - Trade deficit grew by 51% reaching US$1.1 billion in 2005; trade deficit ratio to GDP increased from 29 to 39%.
  - Official foreign exchange reserves end-2005: US$597.4 million (covering 2.7 months of imports).
- External debt and private borrowing (2005 dynamics):
  - State debt decreased by 12%; private debt increased by 19%, causing total external debt growth of 5%.
  - Private external debt growth composition: commercial loans +29%, long-term loans +11%, direct investments credited by parent firm +50%.
  - Of private external debt growth US$192 million: US$50 million commercial loans; US$28 million long-term loans; US$92 million intra-company credits.
- Inflation and monetary aggregates:
  - December 2005 inflation: 10% year-on-year (2.5 p.p. decrease vs. Dec 2004).
  - Monetary base increased by 31.8% (2005).
  - M2 increased by 36.7%; M3 increased by 35%.
  - National currency depreciated by 3% (2005).
  - NBM FX operations in 2005: purchased more than US$170 million; issued over MDL 2.2 billion.

### Public finance, fiscal structure, and budget execution
- Fiscal pressure (revenues/GDP) 2000–2005 (exact sequence):
  - 2000 – 24.6%
  - 2001 – 24.2%
  - 2002 – 25.6%
  - 2003 – 27.3%
  - 2004 – 29.5%
  - 2005 – 31.9%
- 2005 budget execution:
  - Revenues executed at 100.6%.
  - Expenditures executed at 92.7%.
  - National public budget revenues: MDL 14.7 billion (MDL 3.3 billion or 28.8% more than in 2004).
  - State budget revenues: MDL 9.1 billion (37.9% more than 2004).
  - Preliminary total public expenditures 2005: MDL 13.9 billion (up from MDL 11.3 billion in 2004).
- Revenue composition 2005:
  - Direct taxes: MDL 5,272.1 million (35.9% of national budget revenues).
  - Indirect taxes: MDL 6,475.9 million (44.1%).
  - VAT: MDL 4,623.2 million, constituting 71.4% of indirect taxes.
    - VAT on goods and services in Moldova: MDL 1,577.6 million.
    - VAT on imported goods: MDL 4,051.8 million (87.6% of VAT).
    - VAT refunds: MDL 1,006.2 million.
  - Excises: MDL 1,171.96 million (18.1% of indirect taxes).
- Public expenditures 2005:
  - Social sectors: 63.3% of public expenditures.
    - Social insurance and assistance: 30.4%.
    - Education: 19.3%.
    - Health protection: 11.3%.
  - Economic sectors: 14.1% of public expenditures.
  - Share of public expenditures for economic sectors grew by 45.4% compared to 2004; overall public budget growth: 23.8%.
- Capital expenditures and public investment:
  - MDL 616.6 million from budget expenditures used to finance capital investments in 2005 (2.8 times 2004).
  - Share of capital investments in main expenditures increased from 4.1% (2004) to 8.9% (2005).
  - Nevertheless, expenditures for public investments and economic services remained compressed.

### Fiscal policy changes and tax administration
- Tax policy changes:
  - Corporate income tax: 18% in 2005 reduced to 15% in 2006.
  - From 2006, agricultural producers exempted from a number of taxes for five years; must pay land tax, VAT (if turnover exceeds MDL 200 thou. per year), and contributions to state social insurance.
  - Personal income tax: low and medium rates changed from 9 and 14% in 2005 to 8 and 13% in 2006; maximum rate maintained at 20%.
  - Personal annual relives: MDL 3,960 (2005) to MDL 4,500 (2006); relieves for people under care: MDL 600 (2005) to MDL 840 (2006).
- Fiscal outcomes of tax reductions:
  - Natural persons saved MDL 60 million in 2005; estimated MDL 90 million in 2006 from rate reductions/relieves.
  - Corporate income tax reductions saved MDL 70 million in 2004 and MDL 112 million in 2005; estimated MDL 100 million in 2006.
- Tax administration and revenue base concerns:
  - Reliance on consumption and import taxes remains dominant; seen as not an element of fiscal sustainability.
  - VAT on imports constitutes a very large share of VAT revenue (87.6% of VAT in 2005).
  - Cancellation of voluntary VAT registration created discriminatory conditions for SMEs — to be considered in fiscal administration reform.
  - Improvements in taxpayer risk-based selection implemented; 60% of fiscal controls used risk-based selection in 2005, target 70% for 2006.

### Financial sector and banking system (2005 indicators and quality concerns)
- Banking system growth (2005):
  - Nominal GDP increased by 14.7% in 2005.
  - Total assets of the banking system increased by 35.4%.
  - Monetary mass in MDL (M2) increased by 36.7%.
  - Credit allocations increased by 35%.
  - Deposits increased by 40%.
  - Ratio of banking system assets to GDP rose from 42% in 2004 to 49% in 2005.
- Loans and maturities (exact figures reproduced):
  - Total loans in 2005: in MDL: MDL 9.0 billion (increased compared to 2004 by 58%); in USD: 4.4    billion (increased compared to 2004 by 27%).
  - Share of loans in national currency 2003–2005: 57% (2003), 58% (2004), 63% (2005).
  - Loans granted for over one year: 46% of all loans in MDL; 60% of loans in foreign currency.
  - Absolute values for loans provided for 1 year and mostly in MDL: MDL 2.4 billion and US$8.4 million (as reported).
  - Share of bank credits in total investments in fixed capital: 2003 – 5.7%; 2004 – 4.8%; 2005 – 2.7%.
- Interest rates and profitability:
  - Deposit interest rates in MDL decreased from 15.5% to 10.6% in 2005.
  - Loan interest rates in MDL decreased from 21.1% to 17.3% in 2005.
  - Interest rate margin for loans increased from 5.6 to 6.7.
  - Net interest margin decreased from 8.46% in 2004 to 6.42% in 2005 (a 24% reduction).
  - Asset profitability decreased by 15%; banking activity efficiency indicator decreased by 3.5%.
- Sectoral allocation and risks:
  - Loans to industry and trade: 48.1% of loans (increase of 2.5 p.p. since end-2003).
  - Loans to agriculture and food industry: 24% (decrease by 4.8 p.p. over two years).
  - Consumption loans grew to 7.8% of total loans (increase of 5.1 p.p.).
  - Quality concerns: assets return rate and banking activity efficiency decreased; dynamics of interest rates do not sufficiently stimulate longer-term investment.
  - Policy implication: need to increase competition among banks, diversify banking products, and deepen non-bank financial markets to lower rates and expand access.

### Structural challenges: industry, agriculture, and enterprise performance
- Industry:
  - Cumulative industrial growth over the last five years: 67.5%.
  - Growth rates: 8.2% in 2004 and 6.3% in 2005.
  - Industry’s share in GDP remained at 17% (14.5% in Annex B processing industry share sequence).
  - Industrial sector weakly diversified: food and beverages >50%; electricity, gas and water – 12%; nonmetal items – 9%.
  - Capacity utilization: low average (22% on average), limited new investment leading to deceleration.
  - Export composition dominated by low processing agricultural products; share of these goods in total exports in 2005: 72.8%.
- Agriculture:
  - Agricultural output 2001–2005 increased by 16%; 2005 agricultural output increased by 1% (in comparable prices).
  - Agriculture: almost 18% of GDP and provides jobs to 45% of labour force.
  - Structure: vegetal products 69% of agricultural production; animal origin production 31% (animal production increased by 8.6% in 2005; vegetal production decreased by 2.1%).
  - Constraints: low productivity and remuneration, land parceling, underdeveloped land market, decapitalized rural infrastructure, vulnerability to droughts and fuel price rises.
  - Budgetary support 2005: subsidies did not exceed 3% of total state budget expenditures; Fund for subsidies and credit incentives: MDL 58.6 million.
- Enterprise performance and public patrimony:
  - Main factors constraining enterprises: deficient corporate management, inadequate productive structures, outdated capacities, limited access to finance.
  - Decapitalization observed across legal forms (state-share and private).
  - Government initiatives: draft Law on management and denationalization of public patrimony; draft amendments to law on state enterprises to introduce corporate management and dividend calculation; aim to optimize public assets management.

### Infrastructure, energy, water, transport and regional projects
- Roads and transport:
  - Total national roads: 3,325 km; 87% totally worn out; 30% in appalling technical state.
  - MTEF allocations for roads 2004–2006: MDL 784.5 million (MDL 178.6 million in 2004; MDL 291.6 million in 2005; MDL 321.6 million in 2006).
  - Actual allocations: MDL 158 million (2004); MDL 179 million (2005).
  - Implementation rates: 92.5% of projected works in 2004; 61% in 2005; 63% planned for 2006.
  - Two regional road projects estimated MDL 22.9 million; cross-border projects costs US$9.4 million — no funding secured yet.
- Energy and heating:
  - Natural gas ~80% of total energy consumption.
  - Generation capacity growth not successful; new capacities not developed; thermal power stations not upgraded.
  - Heating systems: main debtors for gas consumption, face financial problems, low collection rates, lack of investments.
  - 2005 achieved pipeline completions and gasification: in 2005, 143 localities out of 190 planned were gasified.
- Water supply and sewerage:
  - Sustainable access target (MDG): increase from 38.5% (2002) to 47.7% (2006) and 68.5% (2015).
  - 2003–2005: water systems built/reconstructed in 127 localities (~7% growth in water supply level).
  - 2005 rehabilitation projects implemented in 31 localities at cost MDL 119.6 million (state budget MDL 25 million; local budgets MDL 42.0 million; external sources MDL 52.34 million; National Ecologic Fund MDL 0.10 million).
  - 2006 planned projects in 49 localities at total cost MDL 102 million (State budget MDL 41 million; investment loans MDL 61 million).
  - Constraints: insufficient budgetary allocations and tariff policy not allowing cost recovery; need for public–private partnerships.
- Telecommunications and IT:
  - Legal framework: Laws on Electronic Document and Digital Signature (2004); Law on Electronic Commerce (2004); draft law on private data processing (2005).
  - Moldtelecom network: optical fiber length 2,000 km; broadband access ports total 2,616 (1,380 used); Internet access capacities: 1 Mbps in Chisinau, up to 256 Kbps in rural localities.
  - Fixed phone coverage levels: 26.3% overall (41.3 rural, 16.8 urban) and increase in users by 41.1 thousand (67% in rural area).

### Human development: education, health, pensions, social protection
- Education (exact enrolment figures 2004):
  - Net enrolment rate (overall): 91%.
  - Net enrolment rate (urban): 95.5%; (rural): 88.7%.
  - Net enrolment rate in gymnasium education (overall): 88.5%; urban: 92.1%; rural: 86.3%.
  - Net enrolment in preschool increased from 54% (2002) to 64% (2004).
  - Preschool enrolment (2004): urban 82%; rural 54%.
  - 90% of children aged 3–15 enrolled in 2004 regardless of residence (HBS/2004).
  - Vocational school graduates employment: 70% employed (2004).
- Health outcomes and financing:
  - Infant mortality: 18.3 per 1,000 (2000) → 12.2 (2004); stayed at same level in 2005.
  - Under-five mortality: 23.3 (2000) → 15.3 (2004).
  - Immunization coverage under 2: 99.2% in 2004.
  - Maternal mortality: 23.5 per 100,000 live births in 2004 → 18.6 in 2005.
  - TB-associated mortality increased from 16.93 per 100,000 (2000) to 18.50 (2005).
  - HIV/AIDS: 2,308 live persons with HIV/AIDS (2004); incidence 8.53 per 100,000 in 2005; sexual transmission share rose from 20% (2001) to 55.4% (2004).
  - Public health expenditures ~4% of GDP; about 60% of MHIF expenditures on hospital services.
  - MHIF revenues: over 60% from State Budget transfers; transfers increased by 28.9% in 2005 vs. 2004.
- Pensions and social assistance:
  - Average old-age pension increased by 18.2% in 2005 vs. 2004; by 82.6% vs. 2003.
  - Real size of old-age pension (CPI-adjusted): 300.9 MDL (39% increase reported).
  - Replacement coefficient for old age pensions as of January 1, 2005: 30.7% (2004 – 30.5%; 2003 – 24.5%).
  - Average old-age pension covers 59% of subsistence level.
  - Subsistence level figures: 2003 – 615.8 MDL; 2004 – 702.0 MDL; 2005 (Jan–Mar) – 771.78 MDL.
  - Social assistance costs 2004: ~28% of total social protection expenses or 829.6 million MDL; about 90% borne by State Budget.
  - Performance issues: poor targeting; 36% of population in households whose main income is social transfers is poor; 20% extremely poor.
  - Fragmented social insurance budgeting and lack of unified beneficiary database impede efficiency and transparency.

### Regional policy, monitoring, and institutional arrangements
- Regional disparities and investment concentration:
  - Total fixed capital investments 2003–2004: MDL 8.8 billion; Chisinau and Balti received MDL 5.3 billion (60%).
  - Per capita investments: center 20% below rayon average; south 28% above average.
  - Industrial production share: Chisinau 55%; Balti 12%.
  - Small business concentration (2004): Chisinau 73% of small business agents.
- Monitoring and institutionalization:
  - This is the first annual EGPRS implementation report; MET responsible for coordinating monitoring and poverty evaluation.
  - Government Decree No. 851 of 15 August 2005 establishes institutional responsibilities for MET, NBS, ministries and local authorities for poverty monitoring and reporting.
  - DevInfo database adapted by MET (UNICEF DevInfo) for EGPRS and MDG indicators; to permit high desegregation and be made available to stakeholders.
  - Household Budget Survey (HBS): annual national sample of 6,480 households; panel component used for 2001–2004 analysis.
- Monitoring outputs and schedules:
  - MET to present brief poverty summary by 15 June; Poverty and Policy Impact Report by 1 November annually.
  - NBS to provide standard poverty tables and technical note yearly by 30 April.
  - Reporting frequencies: EGPRS quarterly and annual; MDG once in two years.
- Data limitations and planned improvements:
  - HBS sampling frame historically weak; new master sample based on 2004 Census to start in 2006.
  - CPI urban bias complicates regional cost-of-living adjustments; regional CPI methodology planned.
  - Need to improve medium-term budgeting, MTEF alignment with EGPRS, and clarity of EGPRS costings and tracking.

### Policy recommendations and priorities (explicitly recommended)
- Transform consumption-driven into productivity-driven and sustainable growth by:
  - Further simplification and optimization of the regulatory framework (regulatory guillotine second stage; One Stop Shop; reduce excessive reporting).
  - Ensure stability of legal and fiscal frameworks.
  - Rehabilitate infrastructure via public–private partnerships and increased public investments.
  - Divestiture and improved management of state assets; introduce corporate management and dividend calculation in state enterprises.
  - Improve access to finance: deepen banking competition, diversify financial products, stimulate non-bank financial markets, and promote longer-term crediting.
  - Create conditions to attract funding by financial institutions and direct foreign investments to prospective projects.
  - Improve tax administration and broaden domestic tax base away from over-reliance on consumption and import taxes.
  - Strengthen social protection targeting, introduce resource-testing and unified beneficiary registries, and enhance preventive health and primary care financing.
  - Enhance monitoring and evaluation capacity: implement DevInfo, strengthen MET/NBS roles, roll out local poverty mapping, and improve MTEF integration with EGPRS.

*Italic: Extract from the Government report (EGPRS evaluation) and IMF staff report content unit _cr06185, dated 12.04.2006.*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ......................................................................................................

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Poverty, inequality, and social outcomes (2002–2004)
- Poverty rates decreased by 14.5 percentage points (p.p.) during 2002 – 2004.
- By 2004, 26.5% of the population was poor (welfare below the absolute poverty line) versus 40% in 2002.
- The largest decrease (11.4 p.p.) occurred in 2002–2003; extreme poverty decreased by 11.2 p.p. in the same period.
- The pace of poverty reduction slowed in 2004.
- Inequality declined: the Gini coefficient fell from 0.38 to 0.36 during 2000 – 2004.
- Distributional snapshot in 2004:
  - The richest 20% of households had over 40% of total consumption.
  - The poorest 40% had less than 20% of total consumption.
- Estimated average poverty elasticity to average consumption growth between 2003 and 2004 was 2.1 percent (each percent of consumption growth reduces the poverty rate by 2.1%).
- Decomposition of poverty reduction in 2002–2004:
  - Two thirds attributable to consumption growth.
  - One third attributable to inequality reduction (redistribution).

### Macroeconomic performance and growth structure (2005 data)
- GDP increased by 7.1% in 2005 versus 5% provided in the EGPRS.
- Since 2000 the GDP increased by over 43%.
- In 2005 GDP per capita exceeded US$860.
- Gross capital formation increased by 11% in 2005, exceeding:
  - Final consumption growth by 9.5%.
  - GDP growth as a whole by 7.1%.
- Impact on GDP:
  - Gross capital formation contribution increased from 2.4% to 2.9%.
  - Final consumption input increased from 2.2% to 9.9%.
- Current account and external balances (2005):
  - Remittances: 30% of GDP.
  - Imports: 77.5% of GDP.
  - Trade balance deficit: 39% of GDP.
  - Current account deficit: 9.8% of GDP (up from 2.7% in 2004).
- Remittances growth rate slowed (29% in 2005 vs. 45% in 2004).

### Inflation, fiscal execution, and public finance
- Inflation:
  - December 2005 inflation was 10% year-on-year (vs. December 2004), a decrease by 2.5 p.p. relative to the same period of 2004.
  - Drivers: food price growth rate down by 4.4 p.p.; tariffs for services down by 5.2 p.p.; non-food price growth rate increased by 3 p.p.
- 2005 budget execution:
  - Revenues executed at 100.6%.
  - Expenditures executed at 92.7%.
- Revenue composition in 2005:
  - Direct taxes: 35.9% of revenues.
  - Indirect taxes: 44.1% of revenues.
  - In indirect taxes, VAT: 71.3% of indirect taxes; of that VAT for imported goods is 88%.
- Public expenditures in 2005:
  - Social sectors: 63.2% of public expenditures.
    - Social insurance and assistance: 30.3%.
    - Education: 19.4%.
    - Health care: 11.3%.
  - Economic sectors: 14.1% of public expenditures.
- Fiscal pressure (share of fiscal revenues in GDP) over five years:
  - 2000 – 24.6%
  - 2001 – 24.2%
  - 2002 – 25.6%
  - 2003 – 27.3%
  - 2004 – 29.5%
  - 2005 – 31.9%
- Assessment: consumption and import taxes remain the main base for public revenues; this reliance is not considered a budget sustainability element.

### External dependency and vulnerability
- High dependency of growth on external factors is signaled by:
  - Remittances at 30% of GDP.
  - Large import share and trade deficit.
- Given deficient economic reform and low investment levels, external vulnerability has increased and sustainable growth and poverty reduction are uncertain without immediate corrective actions.

### Structural challenges, investment, and production
- Growth occurred with slow restructuring of the national economy and reduced growth rates in industry and agriculture.
- Industry:
  - Cumulative industrial growth over the last five years: 67.5%.
  - Growth rates: 8.2% in 2004 and 6.3% in 2005.
  - Industry’s share in GDP remained at 17%.
  - Limited industrial progress contributes to low export performance.
- Import dependence:
  - The inherited structure is 70% dependent on imports.
  - More than half of imported goods, including goods indispensable for development, cannot be substituted domestically.
  - There is growth in imports of current consumption goods (chemicals, textiles, foodstuff, drinks and tobacco, plastics, vegetal products).
  - Domestic producers benefit very little from increased demand; advantages of growth accrue largely to foreign economies.

### Financial sector and banking system (2005)
- Nominal GDP increased by 14.7% in 2005.
- Banking sector nominal aggregates:
  - Total assets of the banking system increased by 35.4%.
  - Monetary mass in MDL (M2) increased by 36.7%.
  - Credit allocations increased by 35%.
  - Deposits increased by 40%.
  - Ratio of banking system assets to GDP rose from 42% in 2004 to 49% in 2005.
  - Economy monetization level increased.
- Qualitative concerns:
  - Assets return rate and banking activity efficiency decreased.
  - Credit interest rate dynamics do not sufficiently stimulate longer-term, increased investment.
  - Share of bank credits in total investments in fixed capital decreased from 4.8% in 2004 to 2.7% in 2005.
  - Risk: reducing interest rates without accelerating reforms and diversifying the banking system could reduce banking return rates.
  - Recommendation implied: increase competition among banks and diversify banking products to lower interest rates and broaden access to finance.

### Regulatory reform, fiscal measures, and policy recommendations
- State Regulatory Reform (initiated 2004, continued 2005) objectives:
  - Create an open, flexible, cost-effective business environment to facilitate investment and innovation.
  - 2004–2005 actions included:
    - Simplifying and centralizing licensing procedures.
    - Optimizing registration procedures.
    - Reducing conflicts between inspections and control agents.
  - A Law on revising and optimizing the regulatory framework for entrepreneurial activity (regulatory guillotine) was developed and implemented, reducing the number of normative acts and authorization costs.
- Need for continued reform:
  - Transform regulatory reform into a continued, comprehensive, systematic Government-wide effort with sector-specific reforms.
  - Success depends on commitment of local and central public institutions; some institutions show lack of will to ease regulatory burdens or relinquish income under the current system.
- Fiscal and tax policy changes:
  - Corporate income tax reduced from 18% in 2005 to 15% in 2006.
  - From 2006, agricultural producers are exempted from a number of taxes for five years and must pay only:
    - Land tax (annual share maintained),
    - VAT (if turnover exceeds MDL 200 thou. per year),
    - Contributions to state social insurance budget.
- Recommended priorities to transform growth toward productivity-driven and sustainable pathways:
  - Further simplification and optimization of the regulatory framework.
  - Ensure stability of legislative and fiscal frameworks.
  - Rehabilitate infrastructure by promoting public-private partnerships and increasing public investments.
  - Divestiture and efficient use of public assets.
  - Improve access to finance.

### Conclusions drawn in the summary
- Economic growth and income redistribution policies under the EGPRS contributed to higher incomes, improved access to social services, higher living standards, and poverty reduction.
- Despite progress, the slowdown of the poverty reduction pace, high external dependency (remittances and imports), insufficient structural reform, low investment levels, limited industrial progress, and banking sector quality concerns create risks to sustainable growth and poverty reduction unless immediate policy actions are taken.

*Executive Summary (CR06185), 12.04.2006*

### 19. The  main  factors  that  determine  the  low  performance  of  domestic  enterprises  are  as

### _cr06185 - 19. The main factors that determine the low performance of domestic enterprises are as

### Enterprise performance and public patrimony
- Main factors determining low performance of domestic enterprises:
  - deficient corporative management
  - inadequate productive structures
  - outdated production capacities
  - limited access to financial resources
- Both legal entities with some state-owned shares and completely private ones face problems of assets decapitalization.
- Government actions initiated to improve public patrimony management and denationalization:
  - Concept of the Law on management and denationalization of the public patrimony developed with priorities:
    - enhancement of the public patrimony accounting
    - optimization of dimensions, structures and methods for the management of public property
    - introducing corporative management principles
  - Draft law on amending the law on state enterprises aimed at implementing corporate management principles in relevant enterprises

### Agriculture
- Agricultural output dynamics:
  - Agricultural output in 2001-2005 increased by only 16%.
  - In 2005, agricultural output increased by only 1% (in comparable prices) as compared to the previous year.
- Structural importance and challenges:
  - Agriculture represents almost 18% of GDP.
  - Agriculture provides jobs to 45% of the total labour force.
  - Agriculture characterized by the lowest productivity and remuneration level.
  - Low productivity and small growth in agriculture diminished prospects for the rest of the economy.
  - Agriculture plays an important role in poverty reduction; it is the core activity for many people concentrated close to the poverty line.

### Infrastructure and financing
- Key infrastructure sectors affecting market-economy growth: road network, water supply system, heating system, energy sector, telecommunications.
- After declaration of independence, public investments in infrastructure were limited and most were provided from external resources.
- Recovery and maintenance of infrastructure:
  - Implies high costs not fully coverable by the national public budget.
  - Delays in recovery are dangerous for economic and social development and lead to higher future recovery costs.
  - Recommended actions: increase public investments (especially where private sector is not interested) and develop alternative financing mechanisms such as private-public partnership.
- Transport network:
  - Transport network infrastructure was considerably depreciated in the transition period.
  - Current efforts to maintain, recover and build roads are insufficient to upgrade the road network.

### Energy and heating
- Energy security remains a serious challenge.
- Increase in price for energy resources directly affects competitiveness of domestic production and population welfare.
- Electric energy sector:
  - Efforts to increase energy generation capacities failed.
  - Local power stations were not upgraded.
  - New energy generation capacities were not developed.
- Heating system:
  - Main debtor for gas consumption and in a more critical situation.
  - Faces financial problems, low level of collection, and lack of investments in most localities.

### Water supply and sewerage
- Reform being implemented under EGPRS and MDG commitments to “halving the number of people with no sustainable access to potable water by 2015”.
- Implications for access to sustainable water sources:
  - Increase from 38 % in 2002 up to 47.7 % in 2006 and 68.5 % in 2015.
- Actions undertaken to date are not sufficient; achievement of objectives remains a challenge.

### Education
- Access to education slightly improved in recent years; enrolment rates generally stable except primary enrolment from rural areas (NBS data).
- Disparities:
  - Children from poor and rural households start school later and leave earlier than other children; they miss pre-school and start primary school with a lag.
- Main reasons for 3-16 year-olds not going to school:
  - Schools that are not functioning: 33%
  - Financial difficulties: 27%
- Education and poverty linkage:
  - Households headed by people without secondary education face a considerably higher poverty risk.
  - Poor children lacking opportunities beyond mandatory education are likely to remain poor.
- Policy tool:
  - Provision of food to children within education institutions is an effective tool to attract children from poor families.

### Health
- Progress on MDG health objectives:
  - Infant mortality rate reduced from 18.3 per 1000 newborn in 2000 to 12.2 in 2005.
  - Under-five mortality rate reduced from 23.3 per 1000 newborn in 2000 to 15.3 in 2004.
  - Immunization coverage of children under two amounted to 99.2% in 2004.
  - Maternal mortality rate reduced from 23.5 per 100,000 live births in 2004 up to 18.6 in 2005.
- Concerns:
  - No considerable progress in decreasing TB-associated mortality rate.
  - Increased HIV/AIDS prevalence is a special concern.
  - Non-contagious disease prevention remains an important problem; non-contagious diseases are the main cause of morbidity, disability and premature death in Moldova.

### Pensions and social assistance
- Pension system reform implemented slowly; financial stability of the Social Insurance Budget raises concern.
- Issues include slowdown in implementation of Individual Records system and lack of motivation system for employers and employees.
- Pension figures:
  - Average old-age pension in 2005 was adjusted by 18.2 %.
  - Amount of the old-age pension (adjusted to the consumption price index) was 300.9 MDL, and represented an increase by 39%.
- Social assistance programs:
  - Have the highest share in total public expenditures.
  - In 2000-2005, share of transfers to the population in total discretionary expenditures increased from 28.9% to 31.6%, and their share in GDP increased from 8.7% to 10.4%.
  - Performance of social assistance programs remained low due to inadequate targeting of resources.
  - Poverty profile:
    - 36% of population that live in households whose main income is from social transfers is poor and 20% - extremely poor.
    - Households headed by pensioners have a higher poverty risk (31%).

### Regional policy
- Progress on regional policies insufficient; no regional development policy defined so far.
- With support of development partners, a study and a main draft law were developed for a legal framework.
- Suggested action: specify main functions of different central administrative bodies in the field of regional development.

### Report purpose and methodology (Introduction)
- This is the first annual report evaluating EGPRS implementation since its approval by the Parliament on December 2, 2004.
- Main purpose: evaluate progress in achieving set objectives and assess trends in economic and social development.
- The report evaluates relevance, efficiency, effectiveness, sustainability and impact; recognizes many policies show outcomes only after several years.
- The report analyzes development in the last two years and, for certain phenomena, identifies trends for the last five years.
- The report represents the position of the Government of the Republic of Moldova and is based on studies and analysis by development partners, civil society and academia; developed with support of the UNDP/UNICEF/SDC Joint Programme “Support to Strategic Policy Formulation, Monitoring and Evaluation”.
- Draft Report presented at EGPRS National Forum on March 23, 2006; finalized after incorporating feedback.

### Poverty and inequality evolution (2002–2004)
- Poverty measurement:
  - Two poverty lines defined: extreme and absolute (Annex A1). HBS data used.
- Poverty trends:
  - Seventy one percent of the Moldovan population was poor in 1999 based on the absolute poverty line.
  - By 2004, 26.5% of the Moldovan population was poor (below the absolute poverty line).
  - Most important decrease occurred between 2002 - 2003; extreme poverty rate decreased by 11.2 p.p. in that period.
- Poverty depth and severity decreased after economic recovery (Annex A2).
- Inequality:
  - Gini coefficient decreased from 0.38 in 2000 to 0.36 in 2004.
  - Distribution examples (share of consumption expenditures by quintile):
    - I Quintile: 6.8 6.5 6.8 7.5 7.2 (2000 2001 2002 2003 2004)
    - II Quintile: 11.2 10.7 11.1 11.6 11.6
    - III Quintile: 15.3 15.0 15.6 15.7 15.7
    - IV Quintile: 21.5 21.6 22.2 21.6 21.5
    - V Quintile: 45.2 46.2 44.3 43.6 43.9
    - Gini by consumption expenditures per capita: 0.380 0.388 0.372 0.356 0.361
    - 90/10 distribution, mean of consumption expenditures by adult equivalent: 10.45 10.85 9.40 8.39 9.10
  - In 2004, the richest 20% of households had more than 40% of total consumption; the poorest 40% had less than 20%.
- Growth-poverty linkage:
  - Estimated average elasticity of poverty with respect to growth in average consumption was – 2.1 over 2003 and 2004.
  - For each one percent increase in growth, poverty rates fall by 2.1%.
  - This is slightly less than the –2.9 estimated by the World Bank for 2000 to 2002.
  - Between 2002 and 2004, poverty rates decreased by 14.5 p.p.; two thirds attributed to growth in consumption and one third to lower inequality.
  - Greatest poverty reduction occurred in small towns: 18.6 p.p., largely due to increase in population’s consumption (17.2%); one sixth due to decrease in inequality.
  - In 2003–2004, poverty reduction slowed; 2.5 p.p. change from 2003 to 2004 determined by decrease in inequality.
- MDG monitoring and poverty lines:
  - Millennium Development Goals aim at halving poverty rate until 2015 using international poverty line of 2.15 USD PPP per capita per day.
  - International poverty line of 2.15 US dollars PPP per capita /day (MDL/per capita /month): 167.5 183.9 193.7 216.2 239.5 (2000 2001 2002 2003 2004)
  - Poverty rate (income per capita): 64.5 52.4 29.9 28.9 27.8 (2000 2001 2002 2003 2004)
  - Poverty rate (expenditures per capita): 63.5 50 25.6 25.1 23.9 (2000 2001 2002 2003 2004)
  - Due to unreliability of income data in HBS, poverty should be assessed using consumption expenditures.

*Source: Extract from the Government report (EGPRS evaluation), as presented in the document dated 12.04.2006.*

### 46. Area  of  residence,  source  of  income,  household  composition  and  the  characteristics  of

### 46. Area of residence, source of income, household composition and the characteristics of the household head

### Area of residence and poverty risk
- The most essential poverty reduction has been registered in the big cities. Poverty risk in the big cities, Chisinau and Balti, is about five times smaller than in small cities and rural areas.
- Just 7% of the population of big cities was considered poor in 2004, compared to one third in the other regions.
- The consumption level of the households in the big cities is estimated to be 30% higher than in the rural areas.
- Households in small cities: each third person was living in absolute poverty in 2004; poverty depth approached the level of poverty depth in rural areas in 2004.
- Rural areas: poverty reduction stagnated in 2004. Rural residents earn the main income from the agricultural activity and social transfers.
- Farmers and employees in the agricultural sector represent 40% and 18% accordingly out of the total poor population in the rural area.
- About 66% of the households of small towns, and the majority of rural households, have land plots; the drought from 2003 and deterioration of rural material situation in 2004 generated an increase of extreme poverty.
- The increased prices for fuel also contributed to production expenditures increase, as they constitute the biggest part out of the total expenditures of the agricultural producers.

### Household composition, age groups and poverty
- Individuals over 75 years and children have the highest risk of living in poverty.
- Children living in rural areas face a 2.6 times higher poverty risk than those living in urban areas.
- Poverty rates increase with the number of children present in a household: 40% of the households with 3 or more children are considered poor.
- The risk associated with the presence of children in the household is much higher in the rural area than in the urban area.

### Education, employment, and income sources
- Education influences poverty: most of the poor individuals (41%) are living in households with a head with incomplete secondary or primary education.
- Employment does not ensure adequate protection against poverty: 68% of the poor live in households whose heads are employed.
- Persons from households whose heads are employed in agricultural activities, especially as agricultural workers, are exposed to the highest risk of poverty; these are usually unskilled workers with much lower income than other socio-economic groups.
- Households in which social benefits represent the main source of income face the biggest poverty risk: more than 36% of these households are poor.

### Chronic and temporary (subjective) poverty
- Panel analysis (HBS) 2001–2004: approximately one third of sampled households have been chronically poor, and two fifths were occasionally poor in the period of 2001-2004.
- Chronic poverty is especially severe in small towns: over a half of households were chronically poor in 2001-2004.
- Temporary poverty is a larger problem in rural areas: 43% of households were considered poor at least once in four years, even though their average consumption over the period was above the poverty line.
- Income volatility in agricultural households is a main factor explaining relatively high share of temporarily poor households.
- Table 3 (Persistent poverty by area of residence, 2001-2004, %): (values presented as in the source)
  - Big cities — Structure: 13.7 (Chronic Poverty); Incidence: 5.9; Structure: 13.5 (Temporary poverty); Incidence: 10.8; Structure: 31.1 (Non-poor); Incidence: 26.1; Total: 55.5
  - Small cities — Structure: 17.5; Incidence: 28.8; Structure: 51.7; Incidence: 14.9; Structure: 33.8; Incidence: 8.7; Total: 14.6
  - Rural — Structure: 68.8; Incidence: 65.3; Structure: 29.7; Incidence: 74.3; Structure: 42.6; Incidence: 65.2; Total: 27.7
  - Total — Structure: 100.0; Chronic Poverty: 31.3; Temporary poverty: 39.5; Non-poor: 29.2
  - Source: MET, on the basis of HBS panel data
- Chronic poverty increases with number of children: about 6 out of 10 households with 3 or more children lived in chronic poverty during the research period; such households are about two times more exposed to chronic poverty than those with one child or none.
- Biggest temporary poverty incidence rate: households with two children and households with no children — about 44% of households with 2 children had average consumption expenditures above the poverty line but were at least once poor in 4 years.
- Subjective perception (2004): approximately 46% of interviewed households considered themselves poor.
  - Rural: 48% consider themselves poor; Urban: 43% consider themselves poor.
  - Subjective poverty rates exceed monetary measures: 75% of households that consider themselves poor are not poor according to the monetary indicator; 29% of households that consider themselves not poor are objectively poor.
- For the majority of respondents, the notion of poverty is associated with low income (78%); other aspects include bad health, insufficient nutrition, bad living conditions, low educational level and economic insecurity.

### Conclusions on poverty (summary findings)
- Economic growth policies and income redistribution undertaken in the context of EGPRS implementation contributed to increase in income and improved access to social services.
- Overall trend: decreasing poverty and inequality continued in 2004.
  - 27% of the population lived in absolute poverty in 2004, with welfare less than MDL 328 per month per adult.
  - 15% were extremely poor (consumption below extreme poverty line of MDL 257 per month).
- Inequality rates reduced, but to a smaller and less consistent extent than poverty rates.
- Moldova is accomplishing intermediary MDG poverty reduction targets, but slowdown of poverty reduction pace in 2004 raises concerns.
- Over 2002–2004, poverty rates decreased by 14.5 percentage points: about two third of the decrease attributed to economic growth, and one third to redistribution between households.
- Redistribution from wealthier to poor households contributed to reduction of poverty, especially in rural areas; economic growth was more important in small towns.
- Poverty profile characterized by large urban–rural differences: poverty reduction in rural areas stagnated in 2004 and slightly increased; drought in 2003 is identified as main factor for disappointing rural poverty developments.
- Children and very old people (75+) are the most vulnerable groups; infants in rural areas are especially vulnerable — to be considered when promoting social protection policies targeted to the poor.
- Between 2001 and 2004: one third of the population was chronically poor; 40% lived in transitory poverty (poor at least once per year).
- Small towns: more than half of population chronically poor; one fourth chronically below extreme poverty line. In two major cities, only 13% of population in this condition.
- Poverty is not deep and most households are concentrated close to the poverty line; efficient targeted policies toward the poor can have significant impact in achieving poverty reduction objectives.

*Source: IMF staff report content unit _cr06185 — extracted sections 46–73 and conclusions*

### 74. Another factor that on the one hand, contributed to the increase of import value and on

### _cr06185 - 74. Another factor that on the one hand, contributed to the increase of import value and on

### Imports, composition, and fuel-price effects
- Rise in fuel prices contributed to an increase of import value and a decrease of export competitiveness.
- Mineral products (fuel, electricity, etc.) imported in 2005 increased by 31.3% and accounted for 22% of total imports.
- Other prevailing import categories in 2005:
  - automobiles and devices, electric appliances and parts thereof: 13.9%
  - products of the chemical industry: 10.1%
  - textile items and products: 7.8%
  - common metals: 7.0%
- Most of these goods are non-substitutable.
- Moldova inherited an economic structure that is dependable on imports in amount of 70%.

### Inflation objective and developments in 2005
- Medium term objective: decrease of inflation to ensure favorable conditions for free initiative, investment activities, and protection of population’s real incomes; stable price level as prerequisite for sustained economic growth.
- April 2005 inflation: 5.5% higher compared to December 2004 and exceeded 14% compared to April 2004.
- From November 2004 until January 2005, NBM purchased more than US$85 million, increasing the money supply by more than MDL 1 billion.
- In the first two months of the previous year, money supply increased by 1% (MDL 117 million) and bank reserves grew by 44% (MDL 710 million).
- Risk noted: huge liquidity flow could speed up inflationary process.
- By applying sterilization market tools (issuance of NBM certificates and deposit auctions), by June 2005 NBM reduced the currency base and bank reserves by 2% and by 10% respectively, compared to the beginning of year level.
- Average monthly amount of financial means attracted in 2005 exceeded MDL 700 million; in the previous year attracted financial means made up MDL 230 million (including operations with state securities).
- Result: inflation declined; seasonal summer decrease of prices for fruits and vegetables created deflation.
- December 2005 inflation: 10% compared to December 2004, registering a 2.5 p.p. decrease compared to the respective period of 2004.
  - Reduction influenced by decrease in growth rate of food products by 4.4 p.p. and tariffs for services by 5.2 p.p.
  - Prices for non-food items grew by 3 p.p.

### Exchange rate policy, foreign exchange operations, and monetary aggregates
- National currency exchange rate policy is important for macroeconomic stability and defines external aspect of national currency stability.
- NBM policy concerning MDL exchange rate targeted to lessen and avoid sudden fluctuations by using indirect tools for management of monetary liquidity.
- An important factor of liquidity growth was remittance inflows from Moldovan citizens working abroad.
- NBM prevented excessive appreciation of MDL through purchase of surplus currency, helped avoid sudden changes of MDL exchange rate, largely due to sterilization tools.
- Throughout the year, NBM purchased more than US$170 million on the foreign exchange market and issued over MDL 2.2 billion.
- 2005 monetary statistics:
  - monetary base increased by 31.8%
  - money supply M2 increased by 36.7%
  - money supply M3 increased by 35%
  - national currency depreciated by 3%
- Official foreign exchange reserves at the end of 2005: US$597.4 million covering 2.7 months of imports.

### External sector dynamics, trade, remittances, and current account
- Trade deficit grew by 51% versus 21% in 2004 and reached the level of US$1.1 billion.
- Trade deficit ratio to GDP increased from 29 to 39%.
- 2004 vs 2005 comparison:
  - 2004: remittances grew by US$217 million and trade balance deficit by US$131 million.
  - 2005: remittances growth US$188 million and trade balance deficit growth US$386 million.
- Result: current account deficit increased more than twice and amounted to US$213 million, with its ratio in the GDP increasing from 2.7 to 9.8%.
- Two tendencies in 2005:
  - pace of remittances growth decreased: 27% in 2005 versus 45% in 2004
  - incomes of Moldovan citizens working abroad and increases in labor retribution and other incomes are sufficient to fund consumption imports
- Imports of investment goods and raw materials exceed capacities of the domestic economy; export and remittance revenues are not sufficient to pay for them.
- Part of investment imports and raw materials is funded by credits, leading to an increase of external debt.

### External debt and private-sector borrowing
- While state debt decreased by 12%, private debt increased by 19%, causing a 5% growth of external debt.
- Structure of private debt growth:
  - commercial loans grew by 29%
  - long-term loans grew by 11%
  - direct investments credited by the parent firm increased by 50%
- Of total growth of private external debt amounting to US$192 million:
  - US$50 million account for commercial loans
  - US$28 million account for long-term loans
  - US$92 million are direct investments credited by the head firm
- Increase of imports and trade deficit financed not only by consumption demand fuelled by remittances but also by increased demand for investment goods and raw materials funded from loans (increased debt), contributing to essential increase of current account deficit.

### Investment trends and foreign direct investment (FDI)
- Investments play an important role in ensuring sustainable economic growth.
- Relatively high interest rates and reduced lending terms increase the role of direct foreign investments.
- 2005 FDI dynamics:
  - value of direct foreign investments increased by 44%
  - investments in economy grew by 41%
  - investments in social capital decreased from US$116 million in 2004 to US$65 million in 2005 (44%)
  - growth mainly caused by increase of investments in other capital (loans from parent firms) from “minus” US$16 to 84 million
  - re-invested revenue increased by 15% up to US$53 million
- Analysis of FDI over the last 7 years: serious growth of investment in social capital occurs especially in the context of privatization through capital increase at purchase and later at fulfillment of investment commitments; during passive privatization, foreign investments in social capital remain modest.

### Conclusions and recommended actions
- 2005: GDP growth exceeded EGPRS parameters, but attempts to improve growth quality and reverse alarming macroeconomic trends failed.
- Economic and investment growth occurred against slow economic restructuring and decreased industrial growth rate, especially in processing industry.
- Imports grew faster than GDP, increasing the share of net taxes on products and imports.
- Gross capital formation increased by 11%, exceeding GDP growth and slightly greater than final consumption growth.
- Growth of households’ final consumption is virtually equal to increase of investments in fixed capital.
- Final consumption and gross capital formation are largely driven by remittances and partially by wage growth; domestic and aggregate demand largely satisfied by imports.
- Measures to limit imports may lead to GDP decrease and reductions in final consumption and investments; need for rational policy to stimulate exports of goods and services.
- The import of investment goods and raw materials is funded from export revenues and partially from increased external debt; increase of trade deficit not fully offset by other current account components, leading to significant current account deficit increase.
- Exports to eastern markets are affected by emergence of new barriers, especially to Russia.
- Moldovan products' competitiveness is reduced because of non-compliance of the national quality system with European standards and differences in systems of preferences and structural funds.
- Key aggregate indicators cited:
  - remittances: 30% of the GDP
  - imports: 77.5% of GDP
  - deficit of trade balance: 39% of the GDP
  - deficit of the current account: 9.8% of GDP
- Recommended immediate actions for recovery:
  - real optimization of business climate
  - create conditions favoring funding by financial institutions, including commercial banks, and direct foreign investments of prospective investment projects
  - improve management of state assets
  - promote public and private partnerships in creating production infrastructure

### Public finance management and budgetary developments
- Budgetary policy focused on introducing elements of medium term financial planning and extending program budgeting; fiscal and budgetary legislation reform continued.
- Link ensured between budgetary process and regulatory reform, reducing paid services rendered by state bodies funded from special means.
- Medium Term Expenditures Framework (MTEF) 2006-2008: development and improvement, extending strategic planning of public expenditures; agricultural sector added by drafting technical note; MTEF piloted at local level in Orhei, Ungheni and Glodeni.
- Efforts to develop treasury system and enhance budget execution procedures continued in 2005.
- Public Financial Management Project under preparation; loan agreement with IDA ratified by Parliament in November 2005.
- Mechanism of executing revenues of state social insurance budget through the treasury system developed with National Social Insurance House; starting January 1, 2006 these revenues managed through treasury system.
- Ministry of Finance started adjustment of budgetary classification to GFS 2001 standards; adjustment of methodological norms regarding accounting in the public system to international standards initiated.
- Draft Law on public debt and state guarantees, and draft Law on audit were developed.
- Annual Report on budget execution for 2004 included program execution analysis through performance indicators; a quarterly financial report regarding execution of program budgets was created in 2005 and published on Government’s web page.
- 2005 public budget outcomes:
  - national public budget revenues: MDL 14.7 billion, which is MDL 3.3 billion or 28.8% more than in 2004
  - state budget revenues: MDL 9.1 billion, which is 37.9% more than in the respective period of the previous year
  - main revenues: MDL 7.8 billion, exceeding by 40% the level of collections from 2004
  - revenue part of ATUs budgets in 2005 increased by MDL 843 million or by 28.7% compared to 2004
- Preliminary estimates: total public expenditures grew from MDL 11.3 billion in 2004 to MDL 13.9 billion in 2005.
- Structure of budgetary revenues:
  - direct taxes: MDL 5,272.1 million or 35.9% of national budget revenues
  - indirect taxes: MDL 6,475.9 million (44.1%), collected at 100.4% compared to annual reviewed provisions
  - other revenues (including special means, funds, grants, privatization proceeds) collected at 102% compared to budget provisions; their share in national budget: 20% (by 2.4% more than in 2004)
- Indirect tax breakdown:
  - VAT constitutes 71.4% of indirect taxes: VAT total MDL 4,623.2 million
    - VAT on goods and services rendered in Moldova: MDL 1,577.6 million
    - VAT on imported goods: MDL 4,051.8 million (87.6% of VAT)
    - VAT refunds on exported goods and services and delivered at decreased rates: MDL 1,006.2 million (22%)
  - Excises: MDL 1,171.96 million or 18.1% of indirect taxes
  - Taxes on external trade and operations: 10.6% of total indirect taxes
- Observations:
  - Taxes on consumption and import continue to represent the basis for budget revenues—seen as not an element of fiscal sustainability.
  - Medium term forecast 2006-2008: structure of national budget revenues will not change; share of taxes in GDP maintained at 35%-36%; taxes on consumption and import will prevail.
- Public expenditures in 2005:
  - did not achieve forecasted amount of 7.3%
  - almost 63.3% of public expenditures account for socio-cultural expenses:
    - social assistance and insurance: 30.4%
    - education: 19.3%
    - health protection: 11.3%
  - approximately 14.1% of public expenditures account for economy-related expenditures
  - compared to 2004:
    - socio-cultural public expenditures increased by 24.9%
    - public expenditures for economic development increased by 45.4%
    - general growth of national public budget: 23.8%

*Source: _cr06185 - 74. Another factor that on the one hand, contributed to the increase of import value and on*

### 106. In  2005,  MDL  616.6  million  from  budget  expenditures  were  used  to  finance  capital

### _cr06185 - 106. In  2005,  MDL  616.6  million  from  budget  expenditures  were  used  to  finance  capital

### Capital expenditures and public investment
- In 2005, MDL 616.6 million from budget expenditures were used to finance capital investments, by 2.8 times more than in 2004.
- Share of capital investments in the total amount of main expenditures of the state budget increased from 4.1% in 2004 to 8.9% in 2005.
- Expenditures for public investments and economic services remained compressed.
- Given the unsatisfactory and deteriorated state of public infrastructure, this low level of expenditures inhibits the prospects for an economic growth in the future.

### Public debt and debt servicing
- Public debt decreased from 73% of GDP in 2000 to 33.2% in 2005.
- External public debt decreased from 60% of GDP to 23% during the same period.
- In 2005 state debt totaled MDL 12.2 billion, increasing by MDL 262 million compared to the beginning of the year as a result of increased internal debt and exchange rate fluctuations.
- In 2005, US$ 52.4 million were used to service the external debt.
- A special account was opened to pay off the debt to the Paris Club; at the end of the year, almost MDL 100 million were deposited on this account, with another MDL 100 million planned to be collected this year.

### Funding EGPRS priorities: allocation and tracking
- Total allocated amount for the areas included in EGPRS was MDL 2,042.7 million of which MDL 1,392 million were allocated in 2005.
- Tracking limitations:
  - (i) Costs of actions and programs in the EGPRS are rather approximate due to reduced capacities for medium term budget formulation.
  - (ii) Current budget classification does not allow tracking allocations separately by actions.
  - Within the previous MTEF, some public institutions formulated priorities different from those agreed in the EGPRS.
- Allocations tracked (specific actions):
  - Private sector development: MDL 104.8 million allocated versus MDL 83.8 million as provided by the strategy. Most funds allocated for optimization of customs procedures, creation of the informational climate in the customs sector and creation of the real estate cadastre.
  - Public administration reform: out of MDL 26.3 million set out in the strategy, MDL 17.7 million were allocated. Public finance management and legal system enhancement were prioritized.
  - Development of infrastructure, industry and agriculture: MDL 910.4 million allocated versus MDL 610.6 million as provided in the strategy.
  - Environment protection: MDL 54.6 million allocated versus MDL 108.5 million as provided in the strategy.
  - Education, health protection, social protection, labor market development and youth policy: MDL 256 million allocated versus MDL 314.9 million as provided in the strategy.
  - Tax administration enhancement and financial sector development: MDL 4 million allocated compared to forecasted amounts of MDL 4.1 million.
- Funding sources:
  - Actions in EGPRS were funded from the national public budget and from external sources, enabled by changes to the national budget format and inclusion of loans and grants.
- Monitoring conclusions:
  - Need to specify the cost of priority actions, taking into account all funding sources.
  - Need to enhance the current system of planning and budget forecasting.
  - Social area is to a certain extent an exception in terms of cost specification.

### MTEF, institutional capacity, and planned improvements
- The MTEF should define allocation of funds for strategy goals within real budgetary and fiscal limits.
- The problem of enhancing strategic methods used in planning public revenues and expenditures is to be addressed during 2006-2007 by the Ministry of Finance with support of the World Bank.
- Better collaboration among relevant public institutions is needed to better quantify EGPRS costs and better adjust MTEF priorities to EGPRS.
- Improved linkage between mandates (qualitative and quantitative indicators) of respective bodies and funding is required.

### Fiscal outcomes and structure of revenues and expenditures (Conclusions)
- Budget execution: 100.6% for the revenues part and 92.7% for the expenditures part.
- Tax composition:
  - Direct taxes made up 35.9% and indirect taxes 44.1% of total tax revenue.
  - VAT constituted 71.4% of indirect taxes, which makes up MDL 4,623.2 million, of which VAT on imported goods – (87.6%).
  - Excises accounted for 18.1% of the total amount of indirect taxes.
  - Taxes on external trade and external operations accounted for 10.6% of total indirect taxes.
- Reliance on consumption and import taxes continues to represent the basis for budget revenues, noted as not an element of tax sustainability.
- Public expenditure allocation:
  - Social sectors accounted for 63.3% of public expenditures:
    - Insurance and social assistance accounted for 30.4%.
    - Education accounted for 19.4%.
    - Health protection accounted for 11.3%.
  - Approximately 14.1% of public expenditures account for expenditures for economic sectors.
  - Compared to 2004, expenditures for economic sectors registered a growth of 45.4% versus the general 23.8% growth of public budget expenditures.
- Despite MTEF improvement and broadening, the expenditure framework was not fully adjusted to EGPRS priorities.
- MTEF for 2006-2008 and the budget for 2006 remain socially oriented, ensuring reasonable coverage of EGPRS priorities in social sectors including funding of social infrastructure.
- Expenditures for public investments that could favor economic growth remain compressed; this inhibits prospects for future economic growth.

### Economic infrastructure and structural reform priorities
- Current growth is mainly consumption-driven, satisfied from imports and largely funded from remittances; trade balance and current account deficits are unsustainable without addressing domestic supply.
- To transform productivity into the driving force of growth, structural reforms are required:
  - (a) further simplification and optimization of the regulatory framework;
  - (b) ensuring the stability of the legal and fiscal framework;
  - (c) infrastructure rehabilitation, including promotion of public and private partnerships and increase of public investments;
  - (d) ensuring the consolidation of the innovative dimension of development;
  - (e) divesture of state property and improving management of state assets;
  - (f) improving access to financing.

### Regulatory framework reforms and progress
- State regulatory reform initiated in 2004 and continued in 2005 aimed at creating an open, flexible, and cost-reduced business climate.
- Two major stages envisaged: (i) deregulation and simplification, and (ii) consolidation of the capacity of good regulation within Government institutions.
- Actions in 2004-2005 (first stage) included:
  - simplification and centralization of licensing procedure;
  - optimization of the registration procedure;
  - reduction of conflicts of interest between inspections and testing role of control agencies.
- Law on reviewing and optimizing the legal framework regarding regulation of business activity (regulatory guillotine) was drafted to reduce the number of normative acts and decrease the cost of authorization documents.
- A List of authorizations, permits and certificates for business activities was approved comprising 125 authorization documents of which 82 are issued free of charge.
- Outcomes:
  - Number of licensed activities decreased to 37.
  - Number of authorizations and licensing permission reduced from 360 to 49.
  - Validity term for 7 types of authorizations increased from 1 to 3-5 years.
  - Term of issuing documents reduced from 30 to 10 days at most (except where laws, agreements and international conventions provide otherwise).
- A Concept of regulatory reform based on the regulatory guillotine was developed as the road map of the long term reform.
- Draft national Strategy and implementation action plan are being finalized and will be proposed for discussion in the first half of the current year.
- The second stage of the regulatory guillotine will start following Parliament approval of the Law on basic principles and mechanisms of regulating the business activity and will be completed by the end of 2007.
- Capacity building planned: creation of regulatory management system, improvement of transparency, laws and regulations enforcement, and institutionalization of regulatory impact assessment to be initiated during the current year.
- Implementation challenges:
  - Some public institutions may be unwilling to ease regulatory burdens or renounce additional income under the current system.
  - Public administration continues to introduce new, sometimes contradictory, regulations.
- Specific regulatory issues remaining:
  - Need to introduce One Stop Shop principle in licensing procedure and examine declarative principle for some activities.
  - Need to analyze issuance of "authorizations" similar to licenses that appeared after licensed activities were reduced.
  - Enterprise liquidation procedure remains a major problem: liquidation currently lasts more than one year and requires many documents and payments; no progress yet on simplification.
  - Excessive reporting is a serious issue for enterprises, especially small companies; absence of a centralized information system increases costs and time for manual filling of forms across authorities.

### Fiscal policy measures and impacts
- 2005 fiscal policy aligned with EGPRS objectives: gradual reduction of natural persons income tax rate, increase of personal and special relieves, reduction of income tax rate on business activity, liquidation of unjustified fiscal facilities on indirect taxes, enhancement of tax legislation application, and optimization of tax administration.
- Personal income tax changes:
  - Low and medium income tax rate on natural persons reduced (with no modifications to the annual tax grid) from 9 to 14% set for 2005, to 8 and 13% in 2006.
  - Maximum rate of natural persons’ income tax maintained at 20%.
  - Personal annual relieves increased from MDL 3,960 in 2005 to MDL 4,500 in 2006.
  - Annual relieves for people under care increased from MDL 600 in 2005 to MDL 840 in 2006.
- Impact of personal income tax reduction:
  - In 2005, natural persons saved an additional MDL 60 million.
  - According to estimations for 2006, the amount will make up approximately MDL 90 million from the reduction of income tax rates and relives increase.
- Corporate/business tax changes:
  - Income tax rate on business activity reduced from 20% in 2004 to 18% in 2005 and 15% in 2006.
  - This contributed to saving MDL 70 million in 2004 and MDL 112 million in 2005. These funds were allocated for industry development and reduction of arrears to the budget.
  - According to 2006 estimates, funds from the reduction of income tax rate will amount to MDL 100 million.
  - Fiscal facilities on income tax for investments in fixed funds and constructions, and for small business entities contributed to savings from MDL 240 million to MDL 280 million, or 35% from this tax collections to the budget.
- Behavioral observations:
  - A large group of inert activities showed no reaction to fiscal facilities: the measure had no influence on 47% of economic agents involved in business activity because their activity was non-profitable during the referenced periods.
  - Analysis of cost price structure shows direct taxes (excluding social fund and medical insurance) made up 0.5% of cost price for 9 months of 2004 and 0.6% for the same period of 2005.
  - Including compulsory payments to social and medical insurance, these values made up 4.4% for 9 months of 2004 and 4.8% for 9 months of 2005.
  - Stability of social expenses in the cost price indicates that policy aimed at transferring fiscal burden from economic agents to natural persons virtually did not change fiscal behavior of economic agents; such expenditures were limited by reduced growth of labor retribution fund.

*IMF staff report content as provided in the source document.*

### 135. Hence,  for  1  MDL  indicated  in  the  profit  balance  in  the  overall  economy,  the  fiscal

### _cr06185 - 135. Hence,  for  1  MDL  indicated  in  the  profit  balance  in  the  overall  economy,  the  fiscal

### Fiscal pressure, tax policy, and fiscal administration
- For 1 MDL indicated in the profit balance in the overall economy, the fiscal burden:
  - for the first 9 months of 2004 made up 1.9 MDL,
  - for 9 months of 2005 -1.8 MDL (fiscal payments less the payments for the social and medical insurance were taken into account).
- Fiscal pressure as a proportion between fiscal payments and GDP during 2005:
  - 1st quarter: 32.5%
  - 2nd quarter: 31.3%
  - 3rd quarter: 25.1%
  - overall fiscal pressure was about 32%.
- Broadening of the fiscal base via indirect tax policy:
  - reduction of fiscal facilities for equipment, drugs and other imported goods and local goods,
  - reduction of unjustified fiscal facilities estimated at MDL 555 million for 2006 and MDL 1.018 million in 2004.
  - Saved funds were used primarily for support, development and improvement of agricultural sector infrastructure.
- VAT and small/medium enterprises:
  - Canceling voluntary registration of VAT payers created discriminatory conditions for small and medium business entities.
  - This issue will be considered in the context of developing a strategy on fiscal administration reform.
- Property tax and local budgets:
  - Levied taxes on natural persons, dwellers of non-privatized apartments in 2005.
  - Real estate tax grew by 18.9% during 2000-2005 to MDL 36.5 million in 2005 despite growth in real estate constructions and commercial properties.
  - Improvement of fiscal administration did not allow for an essential increase of revenues from this tax in 2004-2005, effectively transferring fiscal pressure from owners of high-comfort properties to owners of simple properties.
- Evolution of fiscal pressure (share of taxes in GDP) over 2000–2005:
  - 2000: 24.6%
  - 2001: 24.2%
  - 2002: 25.6%
  - 2003: 27.3%
  - 2004: 29.5%
  - 2005: 31.9%
- Drivers and elasticity:
  - Increase of fiscal burden determined by increase of imports and, to a smaller extent, elimination of some inefficient tax facilities.
  - Estimated: reduction of imports by at least 1% may lead to loss of budget revenues in amount of MDL 63 million.
  - By all estimates, fiscal burden in Moldova is relatively low compared to countries in the region.
- Tax administration improvements:
  - In 2005 formulas developed for computerized selection of taxpayers subject to verification using error compilation and overall risk degrees.
  - Number of fiscal controls carried out on the basis of risk factors for 2005 was 60%; envisaged to select 70% of economic agents in 2006.
- Operational changes:
  - From January 1st, 2006 permanent fiscal posts liquidated within enterprises producing ethyl alcohol and strong alcoholic beverages; fiscal control will be carried out by fiscal bodies through operative verifications.
  - Series of IT enhancement actions in the fiscal area planned.
- Policy linkage:
  - Fiscal policy as a tool for economic growth and poverty reduction is linked to public administration reform, institutional and legal reform; essential results will emerge only after implementing those reforms.

### Financial system: banking, crediting, and non-bank financial markets
- Banking system assessment and indicators:
  - FSAP mission assessed banking supervision and regulation as comprehensive enough and generally compliant with main principles of Basel Committee.
  - Consolidated assets of the banking system increased by 35.4% in 2005 compared to 25% in 2004.
  - As a share of GDP, bank assets increased from 42% to 49%.
  - Monetization of the economy (ratio M2 to GDP) increased from 25% in 2004 to 30% in 2005.
  - Degree of banking operations dolarization decreased from 56% in 2003 to 44% in 2005.
  - Capital multiplier: in 2003 one unit of capital accounted for assets valued at 4.76%; in 2005 it was 5.98.
- Loan composition and growth:
  - Approximately 60% of banking system assets are composed of loans and they ensure 60% of banks’ income.
  - During 2004-2005, loans to the economy in national and foreign currency increased by 1.8 and respectively 1.4 times.
  - Total amount of loans granted in 2005:
    - in MDL: MDL 9.0 billion (increased compared to 2004 by 58%)
    - in USD: 4.4 billion (increased compared to 2004 by 27%) — note: USD figure appears in source as "4.4    billion" (preserve exact text).
  - Share of loans in national currency in total loans:
    - 2003: 57%
    - 2004: 58%
    - 2005: 63%
  - Share of deposits in MDL in total deposits grew from 50 and 55 to 58% accordingly.
- Sectoral loan distribution as of 31.12.2005:
  - Loans to industry and trade: 48.1% (increase of 2.5 p.p. compared to end-2003)
  - Loans to agriculture and food industry: 24% (decrease in last two years by 4.8 p.p.)
  - Consumption loans grew by 5.1 p.p., accounting for 7.8% of total loans as of 2005 year end.
- Loan maturities and investment orientation:
  - Loans granted for over one year:
    - 46% of all loans in MDL
    - 60% of loans provided in foreign currency
  - Growth from previous year: share of these loans grew from 31 to 46%.
  - Absolute values for loans provided for 1 year and mostly in MDL:
    - MDL 2.4 billion and US$8.4 million (as absolute values reported in source).
  - Approximately 60% of loans in MDL are offered for up to one year, limiting investment activity.
  - Share of bank loans in total investments in fixed capital decreased:
    - 2003: 5.7%
    - 2004: 4.8%
    - 2005: 2.7%
- Interest rates, margins, and profitability:
  - Deposit interest rates in MDL decreased in 2005 from 15.5 to 10.6% (by 31%).
  - Loan interest rates in MDL decreased by 18% from 21.1 to 17.3%.
  - Interest rate margin for loans increased from 5.6 to 6.7%.
  - Net margin of the interest rate reduced from 8.46% in 2004 to 6.42% in 2005 i.e. by 24%.
  - As a result, assets profitability decreased by 15% and the banking activity efficiency indicator decreased by 3.5%.
  - Trade-off: decrease of interest rates without reform and diversification may reduce banks’ profitability and jeopardize banking system stability.
- Competition and financial market structure:
  - Increased banking margin and decreased banking sector efficiency indicate a reduced level of competition in the banking sector and lack of competitive environment between banking and other financial market segments.
  - Need to stimulate creation of a competitive environment on the financial services market by improving regulatory mechanisms and consolidating supervision of non-banking segments to increase competitiveness and attractiveness of non-banking financial instruments.
- Insurance market developments:
  - Actions taken to revitalize insurance market; assets of insurance companies in 3rd quarter 2005 increased by 17% compared to same period 2004.
  - Market structure changes in 2005 (compared to 2004):
    - Share of compulsory insurance in total insurance grew from 14.1% in 2004 up to 20.7% in 3rd quarter 2005.
    - Share of voluntary insurance of assets grew from 17.4% up to 31.5%.
    - Civil insurance share grew from 8.6% in 2004 to 32% in 3rd quarter 2005.
  - Share of insured assets of agricultural producers grew within voluntary insurance; Government established funding arrangements in 2005 to insure agricultural production risks through insurance agencies.
  - Legal and normative framework for insurance being improved; regulation and supervision of financial assets of insurance companies enhanced.
- Movable estate (capital) market:
  - Total amount of registered issues decreased in 2003 versus 2004 by 4.4 times.
  - Transactions amount: MDL 216.3 million, making up 77% compared to 2004 registered on the stock market.
  - Share of movable estate market in GDP in 2005 accounted for less than 1%.
  - Objective and subjective causes of unsatisfactory results listed (concentration of control stock; monopoly of banks; discriminatory tax provisions; over-regulation; lack of policy vision; suspension of clearing and settlements; delays in approvals).
  - National Committee on Movable Estate developed a market development Strategy providing measures to enhance investment attraction mechanisms and investor rights protection.

### Conclusions and policy implications
- Business climate:
  - Implementation of reforms in business activity regulation, consistent tax policy, enhancement of legal and normative framework in insurance, and banking sector consolidation gradually improves business climate.
- Regulatory reform:
  - Regulatory reform needs to be ongoing, comprehensive, and systematic across Government, supplemented by sector-specific reforms.
  - Capacity building requires creation of regulatory management system, verification of quality of laws and regulations, improved transparency, enforcement, and institutionalization of regulatory impact assessment.
  - Successful implementation depends on commitment of local and central institutions; some may be unwilling to ease regulatory burden or give up additional incomes.
- Fiscal system status:
  - Increase in fiscal burden is due to increase in imports and elimination of inefficient tax facilities.
  - Fiscal burden in Moldova is relatively low compared to regional countries, but fiscal system development is incomplete and objective of ensuring fiscal stability is not fully met.
- Tax structure and direct taxes:
  - Reduction of income tax rate had positive results for natural persons and economic agents.
  - Analysis of cost price structure in 2004 and 2005 shows share of direct taxes in cost price (excluding compulsory payments to social fund and medical insurance) is insignificant:
    - For 9 months of 2004, direct taxes made up 0.5% in the cost price.
    - For the same period of 2005, direct taxes made up 0.6% in the cost price.
- Banking sector performance and risks:
  - Absolute indicators of bank system functioning correspond to economic development in 2005 and create necessary monetary conditions:
    - Nominal GDP grew by 14.7% in 2005.
    - Total assets of bank system grew by 35.4%.
    - Monetary mass in MDL (M2) increased by 36.7%.
    - General monetary mass (M3) increased by 35%.
    - Loans granting increased by 35%, including in national currency – by 46.4%.
    - Deposits increased by 40% of which in MDL – by 48%.
    - Share of banking system assets in GDP increased from 42% in 2004 up to 49% in 2005.
  - Certain quality features worsened: profitability of assets and banking activity efficiency decreased.
  - Dynamics of interest rates does not fully correspond to objectives for increasing investments and longer-term crediting.
  - Without immediate reform and banking activity diversification, decrease of interest rates may reduce banks’ profitability and jeopardize system stability; more serious competition between banks needed to diversify products and reduce interest rates.
- Insurance sector policy need:
  - Create a competitive environment on the insurance services market so insurance activity focuses on prevention and liquidation of negative consequences, especially in agriculture and infrastructure sectors.

### Real sector: industry and agriculture (introductory findings)
- Industrial sector role and performance:
  - Industry began recovering since 2000 after a threefold reduction during the 90s.
  - Aggregate growth of industry over the last five years made up 67.5%.
  - Growth rates in 2004-2005 were decreasing:
    - 2004: 8.2%
    - 2005: 6.3%
  - Share of industry in GDP remained at a relatively low level – 17%.

*Source: _cr06185 - 135. Hence,  for  1  MDL  indicated  in  the  profit  balance  in  the  overall  economy,  the  fiscal (IMF PDF content).*

### 169. Moreover,  the  industrial  sector  is  weakly  diversified  –  food  production  and  beverages

### _cr06185 - 169. Moreover,  the  industrial  sector  is  weakly  diversified  –  food  production  and  beverages

### Industrial sector structure and recent changes
- Food production and beverages account for more than 50%.
- Electricity, gas and water – 12%.
- Nonmetal items – 9%.
- Production types that lost share during 2000-2004:
  - Tobacco products manufacturing: from 6.1 down to 2.5%.
  - Vegetables and fruits processing and canning: from 5.1 down to 2.5%.
  - Bakery products: from 2.0 down to 0.6%.
  - Glass manufacturing and related items: from 5.1 down to 3.2%.
- Production types whose share increased in aggregate industrial production during 2000-2004:
  - Wines: from 16.9 to 20.6%.
  - Oil: from 0.8 to 3.0%.
  - Paper and cardboard: from 0.7 to 2.3%.
  - Furniture: from 0.9 to 1.4%.

### Industrial growth dynamics, capacity utilization, and export performance
- Tobacco products manufacturing had a discouraging evolution during 2000-2005.
- Food and beverage industry had a downward trend during 2000-2005.
- During 2005, the following registered significant growth (low shares except the last):
  - Extraction industry.
  - Sugar.
  - Carpets.
  - Shoes.
  - Chemical industries.
  - Other products made from non metal minerals.
- Capacity utilization:
  - Most sectors registered a low level of capacities utilization (22% on average) after a decline from the previous decade.
  - Degree of capacities utilization grew significantly with the economic re-launch, but possibilities depleted gradually and too little investment was made in new capacities, explaining the slowdown of growth in the sector.
- Export structure and concentration:
  - Food products, beverages and tobacco, textiles, vegetal products, leather, fur and related products were exported in 2005.
  - The share of this group of goods in total exports in 2005 increased to 72.8% versus 72.5% in 2004.
  - Local exporters generally produce and export alcoholic drinks and foods with a reduced degree of processing, lacking competitiveness relative to goods with a high degree of added value.
  - Exports are dominated by agricultural and food products, namely: wine made out of grapes, wine material, sunflower oil, spirits of wine or spent grains etc.

### Imports dependency and domestic production linkages
- Moldova inherited a system dependent on imports at a level of 70%.
- More than half of currently imported goods indispensable for economic development cannot be substituted.
- Moldova imports large quantities of: chemical products, textile materials, food products, beverages, plastic materials, vegetal products, etc.
- Domestic producers benefit little from increasing regional demand; benefits accrue to foreign economies to a large extent, indicating major problems of enterprise activity organization.

### Enterprise performance, investment and public assets management
- Factors behind low industrial performance: low profits, arrears pile up, market loss, deficient corporate management, poorly organized production structures, obsolete production capacities, limited access to financial resources.
- Investments in fixed capital:
  - 9% growth in 2005 compared to 2004.
  - Non-government sector of enterprises accounts for 65% from the total amount of investments in fixed capital, 62% from building and assembly jobs and 97% from commissioned apartment houses.
  - Main sources of funding investment activity: private funds of economic agents and population (69%) and foreign investments (19%).
  - Budget funds made up about 9% from the total amount of assimilated resources.
- De-capitalization of enterprise assets, especially where Government owns assets.
  - Average rate of net profit of enterprises with Government participation during 1999-2005 did not exceed the level of 4%.
  - In enterprises where the State holds between 10 and 33%, the Government virtually cannot impact the management process; Government share represents an element of distrust impeding investors.
  - Enterprises where Government’s share is between 33 and 51% show inefficient management.
  - Better performance is registered at enterprises where Government’s share exceeds 51%; this group’s situation is significantly determined by Moldtelecom, which holds more than 20% from assets and generates about 20% from the net annual profit.
- Government actions on public asset management and devolution:
  - Draft Law on devolution and management of public assets priorities: consolidation of public assets accounting, optimization of scale/structure/methods of managing public property, introduction of principles of corporate management.
  - Draft Law amending law on state enterprises to implement corporate management at state enterprises: state enterprises will calculate dividends and be managed by councils with participation of representatives of Ministry of Finance and Ministry of Economy and Trade.
  - Requirement to calculate dividends intended to improve public finance management and identification of potential resources for public investments.
- Private sector asset issues and policy options:
  - Many privatized assets are not actively used by owners.
  - Options to mobilize dormant assets: privatization of Government assets to create competition on assets market; increase taxes on production estate to impose efficient use or relinquishment to more efficient owners.
  - Enhancement of insolvency and restructuring of enterprises identified as a government task.

### Standards, competitiveness, and sectoral policy clarity
- Conversion of compulsory and voluntary technical standards in process; national Program on the development of technical regulations for 2005-2007 approved, comprising 103 documents needing adjustment to European directives.
- Reform aims: MSTQ organizations of Moldova to join corresponding international and EU organizations; system of quality assurance recognized by EU.
- Concept of quality infrastructure developed to remove trade barriers related to quality infrastructure and establish efficient, competent, reliable system of quality assessment.
- Reform implemented with World Bank support within the private sector development project – Competitiveness Enhancement.
- EGPRS identifies development priorities of the competitive industrial segment and calls for concrete policies; currently no clarity on sub-sectors with comparative advantage or policies/tools to support them.
- Information technology sector example:
  - Fiscal facilities introduced at beginning of 2005; companies reported shortcomings hampering enforcement.
  - Amendments to legislation made regarding granting fiscal facilities to software creators and their employees.
  - Preliminary assessment showed more activity: increased number of employees, increased average wages, and extension of activity domestically and externally.

### Agriculture: role, performance, constraints and policy directions
- Agriculture's role:
  - Important for poverty reduction and as a source for industry and export growth.
  - Agriculture share in GDP: 18%.
  - Agriculture employs 45% of the labor force.
- Agricultural production performance:
  - Agricultural production increased 16% in 2001-2005.
  - In 2005, agricultural production registered 1% growth (in comparable prices) compared to the previous year.
  - Structure of agricultural production: vegetal products account for 69% of total agricultural production; animal origin production accounts for 31%.
  - In 2005, animal origin production increased by 8.6% compared to 2004; vegetal production decreased by 2.1%.
  - Agriculture characterized by lowest level of productivity and labor retribution.
- Constraints beyond reduced access to funding:
  - Slow restructuring of the processing industry.
  - Excessive parceling of land plots.
  - Underdeveloped land market.
  - Concentration of agricultural assets in hands of unskilled managers.
  - Growth of fuel prices.
  - Reduced internal markets and high demands on external markets.
  - Reduced investment leading to destruction of rural roads network, market infrastructure, and irrigation systems.
  - Vulnerability to natural disasters.
- Budgetary support in 2005:
  - Budget subsidies for agriculture did not exceed 3% from total state budget expenditures.
  - Largest share allocated to Fund for subsidies and credit incentives to economic agents from agriculture: MDL 58.6 million.
  - Other allocations: partial funding of certain production activities, agricultural projects implementation Unit, education and scientific research institutions.
  - Strategic objectives and priority directions for agricultural subsidies developed: support of vegetables growing sector, subsidizing sugar beets producers, stimulating tobacco branch, supporting ecologic agro-food production, subsidizing users of phytosanitary products and fertilizers (mineral fertilizers), supporting cattle breeding sector, stimulating creation of technological and machinery stations, ensuring production related risks.
  - Reviewed subsidizing scheme to be defined on basis of these acts.
- Policy recommendations and approaches:
  - Regional experience suggests re-launch of growth via vertical integration providing loans, investment loans, inputs, bank loans, guarantees, etc.
  - Processing enterprises are often better positioned to support primary agricultural development to secure quality raw materials; in Moldova this occurs to a certain extent within the winemaking branch.
  - Given reduced budgetary funds, Government policies should orient towards promotion of vertical coordination.
- Capacity building and extension activities in 2005:
  - Awareness campaigns, professional trainings, consultancy and funding of small and micro-enterprises carried out with NGOs.
  - Investment project for agricultural business development has 10 information and consultancy centers distributing information to farmers.
  - During 9 months of 2005, 132 trainings for farmers were organized on advanced technologies in agriculture, marketing, legal aspects, and round tables.

### Infrastructure: priorities, financing constraints, and roads
- Infrastructure modernization identified as one of main Government objectives and one of seven EGPRS priorities; covers roads network, water supply, heating, energy, telecommunications.
- Post-independence public investments in infrastructure were limited and largely from external sources; gasification funded internally including local budgets.
- Re-establishment and maintenance of infrastructure require enormous costs beyond national budget capacity; delay jeopardizes development and raises future rehabilitation costs.
- Need to increase public investments and develop alternative funding arrangements, including public-private partnerships.
- Roads and transportation reform under EGPRS (2004-2006) objectives:
  - Implement program for reconstruction and stopping degradation of roads network.
  - Create sustainable and transparent system of funding.
  - Modernize technical assessment of roads.
  - Negotiate with international financial bodies for crediting rehabilitation of national roads of European significance.
- Road network condition and technical standards:
  - Total national roads: 3,325 km.
  - 87% are totally worn out.
  - 30% are in an appalling technical state.
  - Approximately 95% of roads are asphalted but most do not comply with technical standards.
- MTEF allocations for roads for 2004-2006: MDL 784.5 million total, specifically:
  - MDL 178.6 million in 2004.
  - MDL 291.6 million in 2005.
  - MDL 321.6 million in 2006.
- Actual allocations made:
  - MDL 158 million in 2004.
  - MDL 179 million in 2005.
- Implementation rates:
  - 92.5% of projected works carried out in 2004.
  - 61% in 2005.
  - 63% planned for 2006.

*Source: _cr06185 - 169. Moreover,  the  industrial  sector  is  weakly  diversified  –  food  production  and  beverages*

### 197. To  compensate  the  limited  resources  allocated  from  the  budget  for  the  ongoing

### _cr06185 - 197. To  compensate  the  limited  resources  allocated  from  the  budget  for  the  ongoing

### Roads and regional projects
- Two regional projects for the rural population were developed and discussed with the World Bank; three projects within the framework of cross-border cooperation were also developed.
- Regional project coverage:
  - First project: network of public roads from Ialoveni and Hincesti, combined with the national road Chisinau–Hincesti.
  - Second project: network of public roads in Balti, Telenesti and Singerei rayons.
- Estimated amount for works in the regional roads sector: MDL 22.9 million.
- Cross-border cooperation projects (rehabilitation of Chisinau-Hincesti, Hincesti-Luseni, Leuseni-Leova): costs amounting to US$9.4 million.
- Status: So far, no funding was secured for respective projects.
- Risk: If immediate action is not taken, Moldova risks being removed from the European road corridors; Romania and Ukraine are carrying out major road construction projects and may identify routes that will by-pass Moldova, resulting in major loss from transit transportation.
- Maintenance optimization:
  - Implementation of modern systems for assessment of technical state of roads and optimization of maintenance and repair priorities is important.
  - Pilot projects started (Roads JSC: Straseni, Orhei, Anenii Noi) for maintenance of roads on a contract base with external technical assistance provided by Swedish International Development Agency.

### Railways
- EGPRS objective: rehabilitation and streamlining of rail-roads transportation.
- Debt settlements under Council of Creditors–Moldovan Railways Memorandum:
  - Frozen debt of Moldovan Railways in amount of MDL 25 million to the country’s consolidated budget and the social insurance fund have been paid off.
  - US$9 million paid to Ukrainian Railways.
  - Historical debt to Russian Railways reduced to the amount of 12.2 million Swiss Francs according to a coordinated schedule.
- Ministry of Transportation: to develop public railways transportation reform Strategy in compliance with European requirements.
- Infrastructure progress:
  - Completion of construction of 45 km long railway Revaca-Cainari.
  - The segment facilitates circulation of trains on European arteries and by-passes the railway junction Bender.
  - Current traffic on the re-established route: accommodates 2-3 goods-trains and passenger trains that make round trips from Chisinau to Basarabeasca.
  - Objective: increase the speed of trains on Revaca-Cainari railroad up to projected parameters.

### Energy
- Ensuring the country’s energy system security remains a serious challenge; events of the last two years and significant increase of energy costs emphasized the issue of energy sources diversification.
- Impact: Increasing prices for energy sources directly affect local production competitiveness and the overall situation of the population.
- Diversification constraints:
  - Limited room for action regarding diversification of gas supply; greater possibilities exist for other energy branches but progress has been modest.
- Generation capacity and modernization:
  - Growth of capacities to generate electricity and intentions to modernize existing thermal power stations (CET) or construct new capacities were not successful.
  - 2005 progress: completion of construction and commissioning of the 34 km long 110 KV line “Anenii-Nou – Causeni”.
- Thermal power generation problems:
  - Thermal power generation is the main debtor in terms of gas consumption.
  - In most localities, heating systems face financial problems, low level of collections, and lack of investments.
  - Government developed the national program of renewal and devolution of heating systems in Moldova; main principle: modernization of urban systems of heating supply.
- Projects with development partners:
  - Thermal power stations built for rayons: Leova, Ialoveni, Nisporeni, Briceni, Floresti and for the lyceum from Leova.
  - Metering of consumed thermal energy continued for all categories of consumers from Chisinau and Balti.
  - Rehabilitation and modernization presuppose huge costs; necessary to attract private funds for rehabilitation projects.
- Gas infrastructure and gasification:
  - Natural gas makes up around 80% of the total consumption of energy sources.
  - Priority EGPRS objective: extension of the gas pipeline and branch pipes by building inter city gas pipelines distribution stations.
  - Gas pipelines finalized and commissioned in 2005 for: Floreşti-Soroca, Şendreni-Ungheni, Antonovca-Şuri.
  - In 2005, 143 localities out of 190 planned were gasified.

### Water supply and sewerage
- System condition: infrastructure worsened across the country; most utilities face financial problems, low level of collections and tariffs, and big losses of water in the network.
- Water quality: almost 40% of the water delivered through these systems does not comply with sanitary, chemical or biological criteria.
- Household impact: purchase of good quality water represents a disproportionate level of household expenditures, increasing the burden for the poor population.
- EGPRS and MDG commitments:
  - MDG target: “Halving the number of people with no sustainable access to potable water by 2015”.
  - Targeted increase in ratio of people with sustainable access to improved water sources: from 38.5% in 2002 up to 47.7% in 2006 and 68.5% in 2015.
- Implementation and financing (2003–2005 and 2005 specifics):
  - In 2003–2005 water supply systems were built, reconstructed and renovated in 127 localities (about 7% growth in the level of water supply).
  - In 2005, projects for rehabilitation of water supply systems were implemented in 31 localities (out of 156 localities set forth in the strategy) at a cost of MDL 119.6 million, including:
    - State budget: MDL 25 million
    - Local budgets: MDL 42.0 million
    - External sources: MDL 52.34 million (FISM, projects of the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation)
    - National Ecologic Fund: MDL 0.10 million
  - Regional Development Agency renewed negotiations on the technical credit granted by the Polish Government for rehabilitation and development of water supply systems in listed localities; signing of the Credit Agreement envisaged for the first quarter of 2006.
- Plans and allocations for 2006:
  - Implement water supply projects in 49 localities at a total cost of MDL 102 million, including MDL 41 million from the State budget and 61 million MDL from investment loans.
  - Within the FISM project for 2006: planned water supply works at a cost of MDL 31.2 million.
  - AEDC to finance aqueducts construction activities in 4 villages at a cost of US$883 thousand.
  - Program of water supply and sewerage of localities from Moldova approved until 2015.
- Constraints and policy considerations:
  - Actions are not enough to accomplish planned objectives; chances to achieve MDGs targets are reduced.
  - Insufficient allocations from budgets at all levels combined with a tariffs policy that does not allow costs covering contribute to further deterioration.
  - Given scarce resources of current owners (municipalities) and high costs, alternative solutions such as public–private partnership are necessary.
- Regulatory and operational developments:
  - 2005: Regulation on collection of used wastewater, development of technical conditions and authorizations of discharging wastewater was developed and approved.
  - Draft regulations being developed/approved:
    - On technical operating of water supply and sewerage systems.
    - On purchasing, planning, installing, accepting and operating the measurement equipment of drinking water and hot house water.
- Implementation results and pilots:
  - In the previous year, more than 77 thousand wells or 83% from the total planned were cleaned and arranged.
  - 2005 pilot projects for ground water treatment (elimination of hydrogen sulphate and ammonia azote by biological methods) and for mechanical and biological wastewater treatment did not start due to lack of financial resources.
  - Supervisory actions: 280 water wells examined by Stat Hydremeteorological Service; 167 were repaired; passports for underground water deposits are being developed for another 6; 26 authorizations issued for planning of artesian wells.
  - Legal framework enhanced by developing two regulations on water supply and sewerage and two instructions on applying tariffs and entering into agreements between suppliers and consumers.

### Telecommunications and information technologies
- Key legal and strategic developments:
  - 2004: Law on Electronic Document and Digital Signature and Law on Electronic Commerce approved.
  - 2005: Draft law “On processing private data” developed and approved by the Government; approved in accordance with principles of the European Convention for protection regarding automated processing of private data.
  - National Strategy for the creation of an information society – “Electronic Moldova” was developed with UNDP financial support; an action plan and a “Regulation on the mechanism of carrying out ‘Electronic Moldova’” were developed.
- Public access and pilot projects:
  - Proposals for pilot-projects to secure technical assistance from foreign donors included in the National Program for technical assistance for 2005-2006; aim to establish seven collective access points to information based on post offices, schools, libraries etc.
  - Operational public access points to Internet created: six points operational — two in Chişinău, one in Bălţi, Drochia, Başcalia post office, Basarabeasca rayon; in December 2005, one point opened in the post office of Plopi, Donduşeni rayon.
- Budgets and programs:
  - For development of the implementation program of communication technologies, public administration bodies planned to spend US$ 0,2 million. During 2005, these funds were not allocated.
  - Action plan for National Strategy “Electronic Moldova” 2nd Compartment “Electronic Government and democracy” includes actions related to implementation of information technologies within public administration bodies.
  - Project “Implementation of e-Government Component” initiated with UNDP support and funding from the Government of Japan; main goal: support Government in promoting ICT use in government processes and services, facilitating access to public sources and improving quality of public services.
- Moldtelecom network and services (status as of reporting period):
  - Moldtelecom JCS strategy to implement NGN network and broadband access due to start in 2006.
  - Optical fiber network length: 2,000 km, ensuring communication with all main rayon telephone offices.
  - Networks extended: “Metro-Ethernet”, broadband access network “MaxDSL”, overlapped network of digital circuits “CrossNet”.
  - Broadband access network created in urban localities, including all rayon centers in 2005.
  - Total capacity of the network: 2,616 ports of which 1,380 are used.
  - Internet access capacities: 1 Mbps in Chisinau and up to 256 Kbps in all other rural localities.
  - Number of fixed phones users increased by 41.1 thousand of which (67%) in the rural area.
  - Fixed phone coverage levels: 26.3% overall (41.3 in the rural area, 16.8 in the urban area).
- Services and limitations:
  - A Call Center, traditional free information services and 5 new added value services were created.
  - The national numeration plan was almost fully realized.
  - Access of the population to a larger range of informational services remains limited.

### Conclusions and overarching policy implications
- Industry and trade:
  - Aggregate growth of industry during the last five years made up 67.5%.
  - Growth pace in 2004–2005: 8.2 and 6.3% respectively.
  - Industry’s share in GDP remained relatively low at 17%.
  - Modest evolution of industry explains low export performance; exports viewed as source of sustainable growth.
- Imports and domestic supply:
  - Imports performance is closely linked to development of the real sector, especially industry.
  - Increase in import of non-substitutable goods and current consumption goods shows weak domestic supply response to internal demand increase.
- Enterprise sector weaknesses:
  - Moldovan enterprises face low profits, arrears pile up, market loss.
  - Contributing factors: deficient corporate management, poorly organized production structures, obsolete production capacities, limited access to financial resources.
  - Low level of investment led to decapitalization of enterprise assets in both state-owned and private sectors.
- Agriculture:
  - Growth of agricultural sector is modest: amount of agricultural production in 2001–2205 increased only by 16%.
  - In 2005, agricultural production registered a 1% increase (in comparable prices) compared to the previous year.
  - Composition: vegetal products account for 69% of agricultural production; animal production accounts for 31%.
- Infrastructure financing and public investment needs:
  - Rehabilitation and maintenance of infrastructure presuppose huge costs that the national budget cannot fully afford.
  - Necessity to increase public investments in areas where private sector is not interested and to develop alternative funding arrangements, i.e. public–private partnership.
- Roads maintenance performance:
  - 92% of the amount of projected works was carried out in 2004, only 61% in 2005 and the same 63% ceiling was planned for 2006.
  - Attempts to secure external resources to compensate limited budget allocations for ongoing road maintenance were made; none were successful.
- Energy security:
  - Accomplishment of the objective related to ensuring the country’s energy system security remains a serious challenge.
  - Increasing prices for energy sources directly affect local production competitiveness and the overall situation of the population.

*Italic: Source: _cr06185 - 197. To  compensate  the  limited  resources  allocated  from  the  budget  for  the  ongoing*

### 234. The growth of capacities to generate electricity in the energy sector was not successful,

### _cr06185 - 234. The growth of capacities to generate electricity in the energy sector was not successful,

### Energy sector: electricity and heating
- The growth of capacities to generate electricity in the energy sector was not successful, as well intentions to modernize existent combined thermal power stations as well as for the construction of new generation capacities.
- The heating distribution field faces a more difficult situation: it is the main debtor in terms of gas consumption, and in most localities the heating system faces financial problems, low level of collections, and lack of investments.
- More serious efforts are needed to ensure the achievement of MDGs indicator of improving the access of the population to water supply and sewage.

*12.04.2006 — page references 36–37*

### Education: strategic objective and reforms
- General objective of EGPRS: Ensuring access to quality education and ensuring sustainable functioning of the education system in a way that facilitates its role in the development of human resources and the economy.
- One of the Millennium Development Objectives: “accomplishing universal access to gymnasium education”.
- Moldova adhered to the Bologna Process; legal and regulatory bases revised and adjusted over the last two years prior to the report.
- European Transferable Credit System made compulsory in higher education institutions; Supplement to Diploma introduced and issued obligatorily to each graduate student starting with the 2005 graduates.
- Catalogue of professional fields and specialties for the first Cycle approved, replacing previous narrow-specialty catalogues to better reflect local and European labor market requirements.

### Programs, projects and legal measures
- Draft Law on General Secondary Education developed to strengthen community funds for school enrolment and to stipulate parental responsibility for school attendance; as of December 2005 the number of children who did not attend any school was 157 (0.036%).
- Draft Project “Better Education to rural areas of the Republic of Moldova” developed with World Bank support; objectives: (i) improvement of the education process quality in rural schools, (ii) enhanced efficiency in the use of resources, and (iii) strengthened planning and monitoring capacities in the field of Education. The Project’s approved budget accounts for 10 million US dollars; it will be launched in July 2006.
- Plans for optimization of education institutions network (establishing “constituency schools”): during the 2005 school year 16 secondary schools were reorganized in lyceums, two institutions were reorganized in gymnasiums and two new gymnasiums were established.
- Action Plan for preschool improvement approved (Government Decision No.1057 from October 12, 2005): priority directions include stable functioning of preschool institutions; increasing financing for preschool sustenance; enrolment of children between 5-7 years for mandatory preparation; modification of tutor staff; remuneration of educators according to didactic staff norms; ensuring free-of-charge didactic supports and necessary materials.

### Access, enrolment and coverage (exact figures)
- As of 2004:
  - Net enrolment rate (overall): 91%
  - Net enrolment rate (urban): 95.5%
  - Net enrolment rate (rural): 88.7%
  - Net enrolment rate in gymnasium education (overall): 88.5%
  - Net enrolment rate in gymnasium education (urban): 92.1%
  - Net enrolment rate in gymnasium education (rural): 86.3%
  - Net enrolment rate in preschool education increased from 54% in 2002 to 64% in 2004.
- Preschool enrolment (2004):
  - Urban area: 82% of children of preschool age enrolled
  - Rural area: 54% of children of preschool age enrolled
- Comparison benchmarks: enrolment rate at preschool level remains low compared with EU member countries and Central and Eastern Europe countries (over 70%), and with the average enrolment rate registered in the CIS countries (65%).
- Primary level: net enrolment rate in rural areas reached 89% in 2004.
- Secondary education: net enrolment rate reached 89% or 93% at the global level (reported as an insignificant increase).
- Net enrolment rate dynamics since 2000: rural areas increase accounted for 3.4%; urban area increase accounted for 0.1%.
- HBS/2004 finding: 90% of children aged between 3 and 15 years were enrolled in school in 2004 regardless of residence.
- School abandonment and migration:
  - Over 3,700 cases of school abandon were registered during 2004 due to children leaving the country with their parents.
  - Estimated number of children left with neighbors/relatives while parents work abroad: 21,000 (estimate); another source suggests this figure may reach 40,000 children.
- Reasons for non-enrolment and early abandonment:
  - Children from poor families start attending school later (age 7-8) and abandon earlier (age 15).
  - World Bank research: during nine years of studies circa 13% of pupils left school within one school promotion; highest abandonment rates in grades VIII and IX.
  - Among those aged 16-24 not attending education institutions: 37% mentioned they do not like studying; rate higher among teenagers at 45%.
  - Annually 12-16 thousand graduates from secondary schools aged between 15-16 years abandon the education system without any professional qualification.
- Vocational school graduates: from the total number of graduates from the vocational school only 70% were employed in 2004.

### Children with special educational requirements and boarding institutions
- There are 63 special institutions and boarding schools in Moldova, comprising 11,180 children, most aged between 10 and 14 years.
- Reasons for enrolment in boarding schools (percent shares):
  - 36% due to health condition (diseases or disabilities)
  - 16% after the decease of their parents
  - 27% due to poverty of their parents
  - 8% due to problems in their family
  - 4% due to unemployment of their parents
  - 1.6% due to poor performance at regular school
  - 0.2% due to absence of any primary school in their community
- Policy shift: efforts directed toward moving from residential institutional support to community-level social services to keep children within families or in alternative family-type environments.

### Family-type houses and protection services
- Current stock: 30 family-type children houses in the republic.
- Developments: during 2003 two alternative services launched; in 2005 six family-type children houses established within the Joint Program “Concordia – The Town of Childhood”.
- Financial arrangements: funds for children nutrition, clothing, footwear, personal hygienic supplies, medicines, compensations and allocations transferred monthly to individual accounts of parents-educators per government procedures.
- Regulatory gaps and concerns:
  - No mechanism developed for parents-educators’ contribution to social insurance system and state compulsory medical insurance, affecting rights to sick leave and old age pension.
  - Parents-educators’ rights and duties toward children not fully defined; children’s rights and obligations within these services not defined.
  - No information available on children’s status within those houses: level of adaptability, cases of child abuse by parents-educators, including exploitation through work.

### Public financing and household contributions
- Public expenditures on education:
  - In 1996–1997 the share of expenditures for education amounted to 10% of GDP.
  - Today it makes up 6.8% of GDP.
- School financing: public appropriations are based on a financial formula for unit MDL/pupil and vary 2-3 times from one school to another; most appropriated amounts are used for teachers’ wages, then materials, repairing, furniture etc.
- Private sector and household contributions:
  - Today 35% of universities and 21% of colleges are private.
  - Circa 77% of students from the higher education institutions pay education fee.
  - Average monthly expenses on education: 29 MDL in 2003; 33 MDL in 2004.
  - In 2004 poor families spent 0.3% of their total budget on education; non-poor families spent 1.2%.
  - Families from large towns spent 2.5 times more than families from rural areas and 6 times more than those from small towns.
  - A prosperous household spends 20 times more than a poor family on education.

### Teacher wages, materials and human resources
- Teaching staff wages: in 2004 wages in preschool, primary, gymnasium and lyceum systems were increased by 30%, representing an average increase by 3.5% in comparison with 2000.
- Despite increases, in 2004 the nominal average wage of an employee from the education system accounted for only 64.4% of the average wage in the economy as a whole compared to 68.5% in 2003.
- Material shortages: allocated financial means are not sufficient for necessary material needs; lack of didactic materials and modern means of teaching reduces quality of studies and assimilation of new information.
- Workforce and staffing challenges:
  - Out of the total number of didactic staff in the educational system over six thousand are persons at pension age.
  - Estimated number of necessary staff: 2,400 persons.
  - Only 58% of graduates from pedagogical institutions were employed in 2004.

*12.04.2006 — extracted pages 37–41*

### 262. Healthcare is a fundamental need during all life cycles, from the naissance till death. Its

### 262. Healthcare is a fundamental need during all life cycles, from the naissance till death. Its

### Healthcare policy objective and reform context
- Main objective of the EGPRS with regard to healthcare policies: Strengthening the access of population, and, especially, of the poor, to basic health services through the development of primary medical care.
- The healthcare system is in transition; compulsory medical insurance introduced since January 2004.
- Medical assistance under mandatory medical insurance is based on a unique Program of mandatory medical insurance covering: emergency pre-hospital, primary, ambulatory specialized, hospital, adjacent services.
- At present it is difficult to assess the impact of the new policy approach regarding population access, especially of the poor, to medical services.

### Coverage of state free medical insurance
- State free medical insurance mechanism focused on category principle.
- Initially insured categories: (i) children of preschool age; (ii) pupils from primary, gymnasium, lyceum and secondary education; (iii) students from secondary vocational education; (iv) full-time students from secondary specialty education (colleges); (v) full-time students from higher university education; (vi) residents from mandatory postgraduate studies; (vii) children not enrolled in the education system until age 18.
- During 2004, three additional categories added: pregnant women and those on postpartum care, and officially registered unemployed persons.

### Service use indicators and access trends (monitoring under MHIF)
- Implementation of mandatory medical insurance presumes monitoring of: access to primary medical care, calls for emergent medical assistance, doctor visits, number of hospitalized patients and number of days spent at hospital, birth rate and death rate.
- During 2005 the number of calls for emergent medical assistance increased by 18% in comparison with 2004, including the 1.4 times rise in the rural communities; rural–urban discrepancy in access to emergent medical care was diminished substantially.

### Affordability and household medical spending disparities
- Continuous rise of costs for medical services created difficulties for very poor households accessing services.
- Circa one third of very poor households do not have the possibility to buy an insurance policy.
- According to HBS:
  - Prosperous households spend on medical services 8 times more than poor households, and 17 times more compared to extremely poor households.
  - Expenses for medical assistance made up 1.5% of the total budget in poor families, while non-poor families spent 4% of their total budget.
  - A non-poor family from the urban area spends circa 30 MDL per month, while a poor family from the rural area spends only 3 MDL.

### Public spending on healthcare and MHIF resource use
- Expenditures for public medical assistance remained at a relatively stable level during the last few years, making up approximately 4% of GDP.
- About one fifth of the total expenditures of the social sector are used for medical assistance.
- The allocated proportion on this regard remained similar to the level spent in 2002 - 17%.
- In 2004, 76% of the consolidated budget intended for healthcare was allocated to mandatory medical insurance funds.
- Resource use within MHIF:
  - Services rendered at hospitals are very expensive and accounted for 60% of the total amount spent by the mandatory health insurance funds (MHIF).
  - Risk of concentrating resources on curative services rather than preventive medicine financed from the State Budget.
- Proposal: implement regulatory and control mechanisms over financial flows and service quality, ensuring transparency in the functioning of the National Company of Medical Insurance.

### MHIF revenues and State Budget transfers
- Increase of MHIF inflows during the last few years generated by nominal average monthly wage increase and contribution size kept at 4% (2+2).
- Raised transfers from the State Budget for population categories insured by State through MHIF (pensioner, the unemployed people, children aged up to 18 years, students, disabled people and other categories).
- Transfers from the State Budget make up the prevalent part of MHIF revenues – over 60%, registering a 28.9% increase in 2005 in comparison with 2004.

### National Health Programs and priority fields
- Priority directions: children’ health and death, maternal health and death, fighting and prophylactic measures against HIV/AIDS, sexually transmitted infections and TB.

### Child and maternal health outcomes
- Infantile mortality rate decreased from 18.3 per 1,000 of new-born children in 2000 to 12.2 in 2004 (staying at the same level in 2005).
- Mortality coefficient of children up to five years decreased from 23.3 to 15.3 per 1,000 for the same period.
- Program “Promotion of perinatal services” contributed to improvements via enhancement of regional perinatal medical care, promotion of quality services, continuous education of medical staff, development of perinatal care supervision system.
- Vaccination:
  - Ratio of vaccinated children under the age of two years reached 99.1% in 2004.
  - Share of funds allocated for procurement of vaccines and syringes increased from 12% in 2000 to 84% in 2004.
- Maternal mortality:
  - Objective for 2006 being 23.
  - Maternal mortality rate was 18.6 per 100,000 life births in 2005, compared with 23.5 registered in 2004.
  - Main reasons of Maternal Mortality: risky miscarriages (30%), hemorrhages (19%), puerperal sepsis (18%), embolism (17%), conditions related to pregnancy (9%).
  - One forth of incidences of Maternal Mortality happened at home.

### Tuberculosis (TBC) and HIV/AIDS
- Tuberculosis:
  - Mortality rate associated with Tuberculosis increased from 16.93 per 100,000 people in 2000 to 18.50 in 2005.
  - Over one third of total TBC cases registered amongst children and youth.
  - TBC incidence amongst men is threefold higher than amongst women.
  - TBC incidence in prisons: 43 times more than the country average.
  - During 2002-2003, number of TBC cases amongst children up to 14 years old varied from 5.8% to 7%.
  - Severe (destructive) forms represent 15-23% of new TBC cases diagnosed amongst children.
- HIV/AIDS:
  - According to 2004 data, total number of live persons who have got HIV/AIDS reached 2,308 people.
  - Incidence of 8.53 per 100,000 inhabitants in 2005 places Moldova on the fifth place amongst the most affected CIS countries.
  - Transmission through sexual contacts increased from 20% in 2001 to 55.4% in 2004.
  - Projection if no immediate measures undertaken: by 2011 circa 2% of the country population would be contaminated with HIV/AIDS.

### Non-communicable diseases and population health perception
- Non-contagious affections main reasons of morbidity, invalidity and premature death:
  - Cardiovascular diseases cause more than half of decease cases (57%).
  - Cancer - 11.6% of total number of deceases.
- HBS data on chronic disease incidence by income group:
  - Affections of digestive tract and arterial hyper blood pressure prevail amongst the non-poor respondents.
  - Renal and cardio-pathological diseases are more frequent amongst the poor along with the group of “other” diseases claimed by poor respondents.
- Subjective health perception (2004 HBS):
  - 35% of population responded that their health status was good or excellent.
  - 49% were satisfied by their health status.
  - 16% assessed their health status as non-satisfactory or critical.
  - More than 50% of population aged 65 years and higher think they have a satisfactory health status, while 43% think their health status is non-satisfactory or even critical.
  - Share of women who think they have non-satisfactory health status exceeds the share of men who perceive their own health status as satisfactory or even good.
  - Poverty does not have anything in common with the perception of health status due to ratios for both groups being similar.

### Social protection and pension system (linked social insurance context)
- Social Protection in the Republic of Moldova comprises Social Insurance and Social Assistance.
- Social Insurance payments are based on contributions; Social Assistance provided through social compensations and social services.
- EGPRS objectives for social protection: financial strengthening, concordance among risk, contributions and allocations, improvement of computation methodology and review of quantum of social insurance contributions, access principles to Social Insurance System, more efficient management of budgetary resources.
- State Social Insurance Budget:
  - Revenues as a share of GDP: 9.2% in 2004 and 10% in 2005.
  - Expenditures: 8.7% in 2004 and 10% in 2005.
- Revenue rise generated by: (i) increase of wages; (ii) implementation of redistributing contribution fee between employer and employee; (iii) change in principle for computing contribution of landowners by applying fee of 1.7 MDL per a grade/hectare.
- Pension Fund:
  - 77% of total expenses incurred by the Pension Fund were used to pay old age pensions and pensions to disabled people.
  - In 2004 31,587 new pensions were set up; number of registered pensioners decreased by 1% compared with 2003.
  - Indexation by 22% in April 2004 and recasting in November led to average size of old age pensions of 336.75 MDL as of January 1, 2005, registering a 55% increase compared to the previous year.
  - Minimal pensions indexed and recasted; starting with November 1, 2005 the minimal pension for agricultural workers reached 219 MDL and 246 MDL for the other beneficiaries.
- Family (with Children) Protection Fund:
  - Expenditures made up 111.37 million MDL in 2004.
  - Nominal value was 61% more relative to 2003.
  - Real increase of Fund expenditures accounted for 43.1%.
  - Number of beneficiaries receiving compensations rose by 22.6% compared to 2003; costs for such payments increased 2.3 fold.

### Demographics, life expectancy and pension-age policy considerations
- Life expectancy:
  - Men: 64.5 years in the Republic of Moldova (2004) compared to 61.8 years in CIS.
  - Women: 72.2 in the Republic of Moldova in 2004; 72.9 in CIS in 2001.
  - EU comparators cited: 68 years for men and 79 years for women.
- Demographic ageing should be considered when formulating retirement system policies and assessing impact on State Social Insurance Budget financial stability.
- Pension reform history:
  - Many countries increased standard retirement age by 5 years to minimize bankruptcy risks.
  - In the Republic of Moldova, increase in retirement age for men and women was stopped in 2003, sticking to 62 and 57 years respectively.
  - Decision impact: number of newly established pensions in 2003 was 2.5 times more compared with 2002; in 2004 that increase amounted 14%.

*Source: _cr06185 - 262. Healthcare is a fundamental need during all life cycles, from the naissance till death. Its*

### 285. The  average  old  age  pension  increased  by  18.2%  in  2005  compared  to  2004,  and  by

### _cr06185 - 285. The  average  old  age  pension  increased  by  18.2%  in  2005  compared  to  2004,  and  by

### Pensions and social insurance
- The average old age pension increased by 18.2% in 2005 compared to 2004, and by 82.6% in comparison with the 2003 level.
- The real size of the old age pension (with the adjustments for the Consumer Price Index) made up 300.9 MDL, recording a 39% increase.
- The replacement coefficient was 30.7% for the old age pensions as of January 1, 2005 (in 2004 – 30.5%, in 2003 - 24.5%).
- The average old age pension for this category of population covers 59% of the subsistence level.
- Subsistence level figures: 2003 – 615.8 MDL, 2004 – 702.0 MDL, 2005 (January – March) – 771.78 MDL.
- At the beginning of the social insurance system general reform the taxpayer/pensioner ratio was 1.7; at the beginning of 2004 the ratio was 0.8.
- Contribution and rate changes aimed at financial sustainability in 2004–2005:
  - General contribution rate reduced from 30% in 2004 to 29% in 2005.
  - In 2005 the employer’s contribution was 27%, and the employee’s contribution was 2%.
- Participation issues in agriculture:
  - Employees from the agricultural sector contribute just 6% to the State Social Insurance Budget revenues, while benefiting from 53% of them.
  - Proposed solution: Strategy on reforming the retirement system for persons working in the agricultural sector providing transition to the principle of fixed amount contribution from the derived income, including partial subsidies from the State.
  - Potential effects: recovery of resources spent within the State Social Insurance Budget from the State Budget (positive) and increased pressure on the State Budget (negative).
- Recasting and indexation in 2004:
  - Use of cumulative measures and annual indexation required additional financial resources and led to depletion of funds and economic instability of the State Social Insurance Budget.
  - Indexation procedure interfered with a changed formula for pension computation for the realized period until 1999, causing system errors.
  - Small pensions that did not reach at least 25% of the established pension level after recasting were increased to reach the established pension level, creating fairness issues.
- Average wage figures cited: 2003 – 890.8 MDL, 2004 – 1,104 MDL, 2005 (April – June) – 1,296.1 MDL.

### Social assistance system performance and coverage
- Main shortcomings of the Social Assistance System identified in EGPRS:
  - Establishment of social benefits is based on category principle, except for two types of benefits based on testing of resources.
  - Social services are weak and not adjusted to local community needs, targeted to a limited number of groups.
  - Lack of financial resources limits satisfaction of demand for social services, resulting in expensive care rendered broadly.
- Costs and financing:
  - Costs of social assistance programs in 2004 amounted to circa 28% of the total expenses for social protection or 829.6 million MDL.
  - About 90% of expenses on social assistance is borne by the State Budget; a small part is borne by administrative-territorial unit budgets.
  - In 2004, social assistance benefits paid from transfers from the state budget through the National Social Insurance House amounted to 455 million MDL.
  - 272 thousand persons benefited from assistance in the amount of 41 million MDL, rendered from the means of the Republican Fund of Social Support to Population.
- System composition and beneficiary distribution:
  - The social assistance system comprises 15 cash benefits regulated by 16 legal and normative acts.
  - Individual compensations represent 45% of costs; compensations for children 19%; state social allocations and monthly state allocations to veterans and war participants 12%.
  - The largest annual average is represented by state monthly allocations delivered to a small number of people.
- Data and targeting issues:
  - Lack of a single database of all social assistance beneficiaries prevents identification of the number of beneficiaries and number of benefits rendered to them (one beneficiary may receive up to 11 types of benefits).
  - Lack of a family recording mechanism prevents evaluation of total state assistance to vulnerable groups.
  - The state social insurance budget is fragmented and not transparent in fund flows; money circulates among funds depending on payment needs, impeding program performance analysis.
- Proposed reforms and limitations:
  - Concept on efficiency increase proposes introducing a system based on a filter combined with simple testing of resources to reduce inclusion and exclusion errors.
  - The Concept does not provide clear policy steps for integral reorganization during the next year.
- Poverty and benefit incidence:
  - Poverty profile: 36% of population in households whose income is derived from social transfers is poor; 20% extremely poor.
  - Households managed by pensioners have increased risk to poverty (31%).
  - HBS-based analysis suggests the age-based poverty approach may lead to hyper inclusion; persons aged over 75 are a separate high-dependency risk group.
  - Incidence of benefits remained unchanged during 2003–2004; in 2004, 53% of all households benefited from social transfers.
  - In 2004 only 16% of households benefited from Social Assistance Transfers.
  - Individual compensations program includes 12 categories of beneficiaries; more than half of beneficiaries are people with disabilities; 16% are participants to the Second World War; 14% are single pensioners.
  - Distributional imbalance in 2004: the richest 15% of households received 30% of allocations total value; the poorest quintile received 13%.
- Child-related compensations:
  - Compensations for Children Program has limited impact due to small quantum and variation from inflation.
  - In 2004, 12% of all families with children aged up to 16 years benefited from compensations for children compared to 9% in 2003.
  - In 2004 the real value of monthly compensations for children care marked a 114% increase for the insured persons and a 60% increase for the non-insured persons.
  - The value of compensations for children care aged up to 16 years based on income testing increased by 114% in comparison with 2000.
  - In 2004 the nominal value of compensations for children aged up to 16 years was raised, resulting in a real 78% increase compared to 2003, but no increase was applied to compensations for child care, whose real value was reduced by 11% relative to 2003.
- Social services and institutional care:
  - The “State Basic Package” includes residential services, care services at home and services rendered by social canteens.
  - No state mechanism exists to certify social assistance services and control their quality.
  - Institutionalization rate grew by 1.2% compared to 2003, and by 14.7% compared to 2000.
  - Out of total inmates: 55% chronic psychic diseases, 22.6% aged people, 22.4% children with deficiencies.
  - In 2004 the number of served persons increased by 7.2% relative to 2003.
  - The number of beneficiaries using social canteens grew by 25% in 2004 relative to 2003, and twofold compared to 2000.
  - As of January 2004, number of functioning canteens was 54; by the end of the year the number reached 73.

### Labor market
- Labor market characterized by rigid, inflexible structure with structural, territorial, occupational and professional imbalances.
- After the 1998 economic crisis, reduction of workplaces, increase of unemployment and migration occurred; economic growth since 2000 did not trigger essential enhancement of employment opportunities; population economic activity rates continued to be reduced.
- EGPRS policy aim: economic growth should be followed by more active labor force participation, enhancement of employment rate, and increasing role of wage revenues in poverty reduction.
- Activity and occupation rates:
  - In 2003 the general rate of active population was only 2 p.p. lower than in the 25 EU member states (56.5%).
  - The occupation rate was about 54% during 1999–2002, decreasing to 49.7% in 2004.
  - The decline of the occupation rate for men is 9 p.p.; for women 7 p.p.
  - Youth occupation rate registered a reduction of about 15 p.p. between 1990 and 2004.
- Employment by sector (changes 1999–2004):
  - Agriculture: 1999 – 50% of total employment; 2004 – 41%.
  - Services sector in 2004 accounted for 47% of employments.
  - Employment composition: 78% formal sector, 13% non-formal, 9% in household sector (household production).
- 2005 employment composition and agriculture specifics:
  - In 2005, employees made up 62.9% of occupied population (a reduction of 12.6% compared to 2000).
  - Rate of occupied un-paid population grew from 37.2% to 39.1%.
  - Of the total 495 thousand in agriculture, 406 thousand unpaid people are occupied in agriculture (self-employed 73.5%; employers, non-paid family assistants 4.2%; cooperative members).
  - Only 135 thousand (23%) of people occupied in agriculture are employed in agricultural units and receive salaries.

*Source: _cr06185 (extracted content).*

### 312. In  2004,  the  unemployment  rate  remained  at  a  relatively  low  level,  representing  8.1%,

### _cr06185 - 312. In  2004,  the  unemployment  rate  remained  at  a  relatively  low  level,  representing  8.1%,

### Labor market and unemployment
- 2004 unemployment rate: 8.1%, an insignificant reduction by 0.5% compared to 2003.
- 2005 unemployment rate (BIM methodology, country level): 7.3%.
- 2005 unemployment by gender (BIM methodology):
  - Men: 10%
  - Women: 6.3%
- Unemployment among population aged 15 to 29 is twice as high compared to the country’s average.
- Urban vs rural unemployment (2004): urban 10.7%, rural 3.4%.
- Economically active population in 2005: 41.9% of total population, reduced by 14% compared to 2000.
- Labor force ocuparea decreased to 49.7% in 2004 (decrease in 2003–2004). Analysis indicates decreasing tendency for both men and women.
- In 2005, people who left abroad as a share of population:
  - 27.7% of the economically active population
  - 18% of the economically inactive population
- Number of migrants grew by 14.3% in 2005 versus 2004. Compared to 2000, the growth is 85.95.

### Employment, income sources, and wages
- Main sources of income for able bodied population aged 15–64:
  - Private agricultural household: 28%
  - Employment in the private sector: 27%
  - Social transfers: main source for 15% of the active population
- 2004 average monthly wage of an employee grew by 2.7 times overall:
  - Real sector: grew by 2.55 times
  - Budget sector: grew by 2.83 times
- January–October 2005: average wage increased by 19.3% compared to same period of 2004.
- Minimum state remuneration guarantees increased (minimum wage in the economy and tariff wage for the 1st qualification category in the real sector).

### Poverty, education, and child welfare
- Employment is not a guarantee against poverty: poverty rates are higher for people who work than for invalids, sick, or students.
- Children from poor and rural households:
  - Start school attendance at later stages and abandon school earlier than other children.
  - Start studies with arrears due to not attending preschool institutions.
- Main reasons children aged 3–16 do not attend school:
  - Schools do not function in their community: 33%
  - Financial difficulties: 27%
- Education level strongly related to living standards: households whose head has not completed secondary school are more exposed to poverty.
- Policy note: children alimentation within educational institutions represents an efficient mechanism to attract children from poor families into the educational system.
- Institutionalization of children is commonly used where family problems or lack of specialized educational services exist; family-type children houses would be a solution if they comply with minimal quality Standards.

### Migration and labor mobility
- Preliminary 2004 census results: about 367,000 thousand Moldovan citizens work aboard. 
- Growing emigration: in 2005 migrants made up 27.7% of the economically active population and 18% of the economically inactive population.
- Migrant population rose by 14.3% in 2005 versus 2004; growth of 85.95 compared to 2000.

### Healthcare outcomes and financing
- Public medical assistance expenditures remained approximately 4% of GDP in recent years.
- About one fifth of total expenditures of the social sector are used for medical assistance.
- Increased MHIF resources attributed to nominal average monthly wage increases and raised State Budget transfers for insured categories (pensioner, the unemployed people, children aged up to 18 years, students, disabled people and other categories).
- Analysis of MMIF spending by ambulatory service type: hospital services are very expensive; delivered services not always targeted to most serious diseases; hospital spending estimated at 60% of total amount spent by MMIF.
- Health outcome indicators:
  - Ratio of vaccinated children under two years old reached 99.1% in 2004.
  - Maternal mortality rate was 18.6 per 100,000 live births in 2005.
- No significant results yet in reduction of mortality due to TBC or stopping increase of HIV/AIDS incidence.
- Prevention of non-contagious diseases is an important problem due to insufficient financing of informative and preventive activities, reduced initiative of medical workers in primary care, and lack of informative and educational materials.

### Social insurance and pensions
- Retirement system reform is being implemented slowly; financial stability of the State Social Insurance Fund is a concern.
- Delay in implementing personal records and lack of adequate incentive systems for employers and employees.
- Average old age pension increased by applying an indexation rate of 18.2%.
- Real size of the old age pension (with CPI adjustment) made up 300.9 MDL, recording a 39% increase.
- Replacement coefficient for old age pensions as of October 1, 2005: 30.7%.
- Average old age pension covers 59% of the subsistence level.
  - Subsistence minimum: 2003 – 615.8 MDL, 2004 – 702.0 MDL, 2005 (January – March) – 771.78 MDL.
- Historical taxpayer/pensioner ratio: at start of reform it was 1.7; at beginning of 2004 the ratio was 0.8.
- Agricultural sector participation to social insurance is problematic: employees from agricultural sector contribute just 6% to SSIB revenues while benefiting from 53% of them; accumulated contributions do not cover even one third of necessary resources to be paid to them.
- Policy implementation notes: redistribution of contributions between employer and employee is being implemented; personalized recording of payers to the Social Insurance System planned from 2000 has not been completed in full.

### Social assistance programs and coverage
- Performance of social assistance programs was inefficient recently, especially due to irrelevant channeling of resources.
- 2004 costs of social assistance programs:
  - About 28% of total expenses for social protection
  - 829.6 million MDL
  - About 90% of expenses on social assistance borne by State Budget; small part by administrative-territorial unit budgets.
- Social assistance system comprises 15 cash benefits regulated by 16 legal and normative acts.
- Composition of social assistance costs and beneficiaries:
  - Individual compensations: 45% (most representative by number of beneficiaries and costs)
  - Compensations for children: 19%
  - State social allocations and monthly state allocations to veterans and war participants: 12%
- Poverty among households receiving social transfers:
  - 36% of population in such households is poor
  - 20% is extremely poor
- Households managed by pensioners have increased poverty risk: 31%.
- Institutional gaps: lack of a single database of all social assistance beneficiaries and lack of a family-focused recording mechanism impede identification of total beneficiaries and total assistance amounts.
- State social insurance budget remains fragmented and little transparent regarding money flow among funds.
- Current “State Basic Package” of social services includes residential, care services at home, and services rendered by social canteens.
- Alternative services developed by civil society exist, but no state mechanism to certify social assistance services and control quality.

### Public administration reform
- Reform launched in first half of 2005 to create a modern and efficient system of central public administration in line with good governance principles of EU member-countries; reform aims include reorganization, optimization of decision making, enhancement of human resource management and public finance.
- Strategy development and measures:
  - Participatory council developed and approved the Strategy of public administration reform.
  - Strategy envisages: (i) redefining competences and attributions of central bodies of public administration; (ii) reconfiguring central executive structure considering Government priorities.
  - First stage functional analysis and decision making process analysis in central bodies carried out; sector assessment of public service undertaken.
  - Public administration reform comprises 28 specialized public bodies of public administration from the central executive.
- Decision making enhancements envisaged:
  - (i) improving development, approval, implementation and assessment of normative acts and policies
  - (ii) developing ministries’ capacities to develop, analyze and monitor policies implementation
  - (iii) streamlining planning and reporting systems
  - (iv) improving quality of approved documents
- Strategy provides for development and promotion of draft Law on public service and status of civil servant to regulate: (i) functioning of central administrative body responsible for public service management; (ii) ensuring and promoting people in civil service on basis of competition; (iii) separating political functions from administrative ones.
- Competences, functions and organizational structures will be targeted to focus on Government priorities (Government activity program “Country modernization – people’s welfare”, EGPRS, Moldova–EU Action Plan).
- Government and ministries will focus on policy making, monitoring and control, delegating policy implementation and micro-management functions to subordinate institutions.
- Adoption of an adequate legal framework will define types of central public administration organizations, main competences and mutual relations for monitoring, control and clear reporting.
- Implementation of public administration reform is a precondition for development and successful implementation of structural reforms in all EGPRS areas.

### Regional development
- EGPRS priority: balanced and sustainable social and economic development across the country and reduction of disparities, especially between capital and rest of country.
- Rayon and municipal Councils developed and approved action plans for EGPRS implementation for respective regions, in conformity with Government Decision nr. 116 from February 3, 2005; plans identify medium term social-economic regional development objectives (2005–2006).
- Progress in regional policies insufficient; clear policies and priorities lacking.
- A study supported by development partners produced a law draft for a system of future laws in regional development; the draft law suggests specifying main functions of central administrative bodies in regional development.
- Fundamental priority in draft law: principle of devolution—transfer of administrative responsibility and authority from central to local level.
- Lack of clear and detailed delimitation of functions between central and local public administration bodies, and between city-level and rayon-level territorial-administrative units.
- Major constraints on regional development:
  - Lack of economic base for budget revenue formation.
  - Unsatisfactory economic and social infrastructure inhibiting business development and tax base growth.
  - Hostile attitude of local authorities sometimes discourages businesses initiating activities in regions.

*Source: NBS; data and analysis as presented in the supplied content.*

### 352. The  current  situation  is  worsened  by  a  chronic  lack  of  investments.  During  2003-2004

### _cr06185 - 352. The  current  situation  is  worsened  by  a  chronic  lack  of  investments.  During  2003-2004

### Regional investment distribution and infrastructure
- Total investments in fixed capital during 2003-2004: MDL 8,8 billion.
- Chisinau and Balti received MDL 5,3 billion or 60% of the total; rural sector received MDL 3,5 billion.
- Share of investments in fixed capital except for Chisinau and Balti (2003-2004):
  - North: 32%
  - Center: 38%
  - South: 40%
- Per capita investments in fixed capital:
  - Lowest level in the center: 20% less than the average in rayons.
  - South: 28% above the average.
- Public roads density:
  - Highest levels in the north, which is by 28% larger compared to south and by 23% compared to center.

### Fiscal transfers and local budgets
- Transfers from the state budget account on average for about 48-75% of the total budgetary revenues of rayons.
- Transfers did not prove to be a flexible mechanism of financial support for territories able to change their capacity to self financing.

### Regional economic performance and disparities
- Industrial production share:
  - Chisinau: 55%
  - Balti: 12%
- Small business concentration (2004):
  - Chisinau accounted for 73% of small business agents in 2004.
  - Balti: 5%.
- In 2/3 of rayons, the total average value of indicators (industry, agriculture, trade, paid services to the population, investments in fixed capital, density of public roads) calculated per capita is below the average for rayons (statistical data for 2004).
- Per capita industrial production (lowest rates):
  - Rayons with rates within the 250 limit in 2004: Briceni, Criuleni, Leova, Ocniţa, Rîşcani, Teleneşti.
  - MDL 4,930 observed for Cahul, Taraclia, Găgăuzia ATU.
- Business opportunities except for Chisinau and Balti concentrate almost equally in central and southern rayons:
  - Central and southern rayons each account for about 8% in the total amount of revenues from sales per capita.
  - Northern part: 6%.
- Retail sales per capita:
  - Highest level registered in the center, followed by northern regions and south.
  - Regional difference within 2-5%.
- Monthly nominal average wage (statistical data for 2004):
  - Center and south: same level.
  - Northern rayons: about 4% lower compared to center and south.
- Unemployment rate:
  - Center and south: virtually the same level.
  - Northern part: about 20% lower compared to center and south.
- Workplace creation during 2003-2005:
  - South accounted for about 40% of total workplaces.
  - North and center account for 30% each.
  - Most jobs created in Gagauzia ATU (Gagauz-Yeri), and Cahul, Căuşeni, Hînceşti, Orhei, Soroca rayons.

### Conclusions on regional development
- Investment factor is dominant for regional development.
- Ultra-concentration of national investment potential in Chisinau and Balti does not reflect Government objectives in regional development.
- The phenomenon of two investment epicenters (Chisinau and Balti) may be viewed as a counter social and economic performance in terms of regional development.
- Regional development policy is based on elements of social and financial cohesion; fiscal tools, the private sector, and social and economic infrastructure are landmarks for quantifying policy impact.
- There is an absence of continuity in public authorities' attempts to promote a well thought policy based on the same principles and objectives.

### Communication and participation process (EGPRS)
- Participation Council tasks (in conformity with EGPRS provisions):
  - (i) provide EGPRS transparent implementation;
  - (ii) involve and train different partners in the process of Strategy implementation;
  - (iii) create an environment for discussions with participation of different parties;
  - (iv) facilitate participative monitoring and independent evaluation of obtained results;
  - (v) ensure drafting and implementation of an efficient communication strategy related with interested parties.
- Secretariat of the Participation Council instituted as its executive body.
- Participation Council self-organized after EGPRS implementation launch; new members co-opted from Parliament, civil society, private sector and development partners.
- Objectives assigned to the Participation Council:
  - (i) draft and implement a Communication Strategy for EGPRS implementation, monitoring and evaluation;
  - (ii) initiate public discussions on draft laws, strategies, studies, policies impact evaluation reports;
  - (iii) consolidate civil society representatives’ capacities within the EGPRS monitoring process.
- Communication outputs and reach in 2005:
  - EGPRS Information Bulletin: five editions; distributed as a supplement to 17 local and national newspapers; each edition included about 90,000 copies (in Romanian and Russian).
  - Radio broadcast cycle “EGPRS – steps to a better life”: weekly on National Radio (100.5 FM and 873 AM).
  - Web page www.scers.md: during 2005 accessed by 7,000 users; awarded III place within “WEBTOP” 2005 in category “Public Administration and Law”.
  - Booklet “EGPRS in Brief. Practical Guide for those who wish to know what is EGPRS”: 8,000 copies in Romanian and 2,000 in Russian published.
- Communication shortcomings:
  - Communication activities organized by public institutions since EGPRS approval have been sporadic and have not emerged into a well formulated strategy; limited to publishing information on institutional web pages or using Participation Council instruments.
- Draft Communication Strategy and Actions Plan for 2006-2009 internal objectives:
  - (a) create a functional mechanism of population efficient information explaining reforms;
  - (b) draft and transmit correctly directed messages to target groups;
  - (c) provide reforms transparency by disseminating genuine information regarding step by step implementation;
  - (d) provide continuity of the information flux;
  - (e) establish an climate of confidence in the future, in real growth of population welfare and poverty reduction;
  - (f) increase the level of state institutions credibility among population.
- External objectives: present the Republic of Moldova by an efficient country communication profile and increase truthful information to raise donors’ attention and attract foreign businessmen.
- Public engagement in 2005:
  - 22 public debates organized on regional development, SMEs development, access of poor population to potable water and sewerage, policies impact on poverty evaluation, etc.
  - Participation Council committed to facilitate independent monitoring and evaluation by developing complementary reports; Government confirms availability to provide official reports, monitoring indicators data, and to launch public debates.
- Regional discussions planned following national draft Report debates to ensure larger involvement of local public administration, local businesses and NGOs; partnerships between central and local public institutions and NGOs welcomed.

### Monitoring and evaluation system
- Building an efficient participative monitoring and evaluation system requires:
  - Strong public institutions;
  - High degree of cooperation among institutions;
  - Improvement of public service capacities and personnel training in data collection, monitoring and analysis methods.
- Government Program of activity for 2005-2009 “Country Modernization – People Welfare” establishes priority: integral and in due term implementation of EGPRS.
- A special unit created: General Division for Macroeconomic Policies and Development Programs within the Ministry of Economy and Trade (MET) to coordinate monitoring and evaluation of development programs, especially EGPRS and MDG; poverty monitoring included in its competences.
- Decision of the Government regarding poverty monitoring system establishing (no. 851 from August 15, 2005):
  - Delimited functions of the Ministry of Economy and Trade, the National Bureau of Statistics and other Government institutions.
  - Beginning on 2006, the NBS calculates the poverty rates and the respective unit of the MET analyzes the evolution of poverty indices and evaluates impact of policies on poverty level.
- MET drafted Regulation regarding the procedure of poverty absolute thresholds calculation.
- MET prepared the Poverty Report and Social Policies Impact analyzing poverty evolution for 2003-2004 and evaluating impact of social policies on poverty indices; findings discussed with public institutions and interested parties.
- Deprivation indices process initiated in 2005 to calculate geographic distribution of poverty up to commune level; questionnaires drafted and distributed to create economic and social development Passports for each locality, to be filled during the first half of 2006.
- Pilot project to constitute policy and analysis units within six Ministries (Agriculture and Food Industry, Transports, Industry and Infrastructure, Justice, Education, Youth and Sports, Health and Social Protection) modeled on MET Directorate:
  - Proposal to transfer monitoring functions of EGPRS commitments and Plan RM - EU to these Directorates.
  - Plan to create these units de facto, provide personnel training and technical equipment within the year.
- Goals for improved monitoring and evaluation:
  - (i) improve coordination by unifying format and reporting terms of different national programs to eliminate duplication;
  - (ii) transition from simple action reporting to a system of results evaluation and formulation of proposals for policy improvement/correction.
- MET prepared draft Instructions regarding EGPRS monitoring and evaluation to be discussed in the next period.
- Outputs to date: preliminary report on EGPRS implementation from September 2005 and the first annual report represent results of efforts to improve policy impact evaluation and development tendencies analysis.

*Italic: IMF staff report content (excerpts as provided).*

### 386. Both for EGPRS monitoring indicators (Annex B) and for the Millennium Development

### _cr06185 - 386. Both for EGPRS monitoring indicators (Annex B) and for the Millennium Development

### Data systems and monitoring platforms
- The MET adapted the DevInfo data basis (offered by UNICEF) to stock and disseminate all intermediary and final monitoring indicators for EGPRS monitoring indicators (Annex B) and for the Millennium Development Objectives (MDG).
- During the current year, this data basis, permitting a high level of desegregation (may include indices up to the level of commune), will be made available for all central and local public institutions, as well as for other stakeholders, enabling participative monitoring and evaluation of EGPRS, MDG and other strategic documents implementation.

### Main data sources and survey design
- Household Budget Survey (HBS)
  - Conducted by the NBS since 1997 on a regular (annual) basis on a nation-wide representative probability sample.
  - Sample contains 6480 households distributed equally (by 540 households) over 12 months, using monthly rotations system.
  - Data collected via main household questionnaire (by specially trained persons, during three visits in the survey month) and a diary with daily records (income, expenditure, food consumption from own production).
  - Panel component included; panel data analyzed for 2001-2004.
- Households' opinion about poverty
  - Selective survey “Households' opinion about poverty phenomenon” conducted by the NBS since 2001 with UNDP support, each year in August within the HBS network on a monthly sample of 540 households.
  - Captures perceptions on causes of poverty, concept of “being poor”, coping strategies, and perspectives.
- Administrative data
  - About fifty socio-economic indicators collected (demographic, health care, education, public expenditures for education and health, employment) at various disaggregation levels (total per country, urban-rural, sex, age groups).
  - Data are calculated and summarized by ministries, departments, and other state bodies.

### Poverty measurement methodology
- Unit of analysis: household as defined in the Household Budget Survey.
- Welfare measure: household consumption expenditures (includes food consumption, imputed market value of own-production items, non-food items, and payment for services).
- Seasonal/inflation adjustment: income and expenditure indicators adjusted to January using monthly Consumer Price Index (CPI) for each component: food products, non-food items and services.
- Equivalence scale: OECD equivalence scale (first adult = 1; each other adult = 0.7; each child under 15 = 0.5) used to compute per adult equivalent consumption.
- Poverty classification: an individual is considered poor if consumption per adult equivalent is below the poverty line; all household members assumed to share same living standard.
- Poverty measures: FGT (Foster-Greer-Thorbecke) family used — poverty headcount, poverty gap, and squared poverty gap (severity). Measured annually on HBS data.

### Poverty lines used
- International poverty line: USD 2.15 per capita per day, converted to Moldovan Lei and adjusted for purchasing power parities.
- Extreme poverty line
  - Based on monetary value of food items corresponding to minimum daily calorie intake equal to 2282 Kcаl per household member per day.
  - Calculation based on consumption pattern of deciles 2nd to 4th of distribution of total consumption expenditure per capita.
  - Households with per adult equivalent consumption below basic food basket cost are classified as extremely poor.
  - In 2004 the extreme poverty line was equal to 258.1 MDL per month.
- Absolute poverty line
  - Estimated by increasing the food poverty line with a supplement for non-food items and services.
  - Non-food component estimated for sampled households with consumption expenditure per capita within one standard deviation 10% (+/-) from food poverty line.
  - Absolute poverty line for 2004 was estimated at 327.0 MDL.
- Relative poverty line
  - Set at 50 percent of average household equivalized consumption expenditure.
  - Equalled 294.3 MDL according to HBS data for 2004.
- Subjective poverty line
  - Estimated using self-assessments of material well-being (Leiden method) using HBS data and household self-assessment included in the selective survey “Household opinion about poverty phenomenon”.

### Issues and limitations in poverty monitoring
- Sampling frame limitations: ‘weak’ sampling frame used in lieu of census files (non-computerized electoral district lists 1996), small number of primary sampling units (PSUs) affecting overall accuracy, small-scale stratification (cities, towns, rural areas).
- Planned improvement: Starting with 2006 the NBS will launch the survey on a new master sample developed on the basis of population Census data for 2004, which will allow a deeper assessment and study.
- Price statistics limitation: CPI is based on information collected in urban areas only (in selected 750 price-watch centres dispersed over 11 towns), complicating establishment of separate cost-of-living indices for urban and rural households.
  - HBS reports actual local market prices paid by households, but lack of regional CPI may lead to underestimation or overestimation of household consumption expenditures by area of residence.
  - If methodology for computing the regional consumer price Index is implemented, consumption expenditures may be adjusted using the regional price deflator to improve comparability across areas.

### Key poverty statistics and trends (selected figures from 1998–2004)
- Absolute Poverty Line (MDL p.a.e. per month): 128.9 (1998), 179.2 (1999), 234.8 (2000), 257.3 (2001), 270.7 (2002), 303.5 (2003), 327.0 (2004).
- Absolute Poverty Rate: 52.0 (1998), 73.0 (1999), 67.8 (2000), 54.6 (2001), 40.4 (2002), 29.0 (2003), 26.5 (2004).
- Absolute Poverty Gap: 19.5 (1998), 32.3 (1999), 27.0 (2000), 19.3 (2001), 12.4 (2002), 7.3 (2003), 6.8 (2004).
- Absolute Poverty Severity: 9.8 (1998), 17.7 (1999), 13.7 (2000), 9.1 (2001), 5.2 (2002), 2.7 (2003), 2.5 (2004).
- Extreme Poverty Line (MDL p.a.e. per month): 101.0 (1998), 140.4 (1999), 183.9 (2000), 201.5 (2001), 212.0 (2002), 235.5 (2003), 258.1 (2004).
- Extreme Poverty Rate: 37.4 (1998), 59.7 (1999), 52.2 (2000), 38.0 (2001), 26.2 (2002), 15.0 (2003), 14.7 (2004).
- Extreme Poverty Gap: 12.4 (1998), 22.7 (1999), 17.6 (2000), 11.6 (2001), 6.6 (2002), 3.1 (2003), 3.2 (2004).
- Extreme Poverty Severity: 5.9 (1998), 11.4 (1999), 8.2 (2000), 5.1 (2001), 2.4 (2002), 1.0 (2003), 1.1 (2004).
- Relative poverty line (MDL p.a.e. per month): 82.1 (1998), 80.3 (1999), 115.9 (2000), 158.4 (2001), 202.3 (2002), 257.5 (2003), 294.4 (2004).
- Relative Poverty Rate: 25.8 (1998), 25.4 (1999), 22.3 (2000), 23.7 (2001), 23.6 (2002), 19.4 (2003), 20.3 (2004).
- Subsistence Minimum, MDL, p.a.e.: 274.1 (2000), 309.5 (2001), 413.11 (2002), 468.7 (2003), 538.4 (2004), 628.1 (2005), 679.9 (2006) [table shows multiple years; values as listed].
- International Line $2.15 PPP per person/day (MDL/person/month): 91.6 (1998), 127.6 (1999), 167.5 (2000), 183.9 (2001), 193.7 (2002), 216.2 (2003), 239.5 (2004).
- Poverty rate (expenditures per equivalent) relative to International Line: 31.9 (1998), 53.2 (1999), 45.0 (2000), 32.3 (2001), 21.0 (2002), 11.5 (2003), 11.4 (2004).

### Selected disaggregated poverty patterns (2000–2004 and 2004 cross-sections)
- By area (Absolute poverty rate) — sample snapshots shown across City, Town, Rural for 2000–2004 (values presented in table format in source).
  - City absolute poverty rate examples: 40.0 (2000), 30.0 (2001), 16.5 (2002), 12.8 (2003), 6.9 (2004).
  - Town absolute poverty rate examples: 80.7 (2000), 73.1 (2001), 46.8 (2002), 42.4 (2003), 34.9 (2004).
  - Rural absolute poverty rate examples: 73.9 (2000), 58.2 (2001), 45.1 (2002), 31.1 (2003), 31.2 (2004).
- By household characteristics (2004, sampled population) — structure and poverty rates reported across multiple dimensions (residence, household size, household type, household composition, socio-economic groups, main source of income, number of employees, educational level of household head, age group, sex of household head). Selected figures:
  - Residence (2004): Urban structure 37.2 with Poverty rate 18.5; Rural structure 62.8 with Poverty rate 31.2.
  - Extreme poor (2004): Urban 9.0 (structure 26.0); Rural 18.0 (structure 74.0).
  - Household size (2004) examples: 1 person — structure 11.2 with Poverty rate 24.6; 6 and more persons — structure 7.2 with Poverty rate 47.4.
  - Household composition (2004) examples: Household with 3 children — structure 6.9 with Poverty rate 40.7; Household without children — structure 41.6 with Poverty rate 23.8.
  - Social-economic groups (2004) examples: Farmers — structure 23.6 with Poverty rate 35.0; Non-agricultural employees — structure 34.8 with Poverty rate 19.2; Pensioners — structure 26.2 with Poverty rate 30.7.
  - Main source of income (2004) examples: Remunerated activity — structure 36.9 with Poverty rate 24.2; Individual agricultural activity — structure 32.9 with Poverty rate 33.1; Social allowances — structure 17.5 with Poverty rate 36.3.
  - Educational level of HH head (2004): Higher and incomplete higher education — structure 11.4 with Poverty rate 7.6; Incomplete secondary and primary education — structure 28.6 with Poverty rate 39.4.
  - Age group of HH head (2004) examples: 35 - 44 year old — structure 25.3 with Poverty rate 27.4; 65 and more year old — structure 18.0 with Poverty rate 31.2.
  - Sex of HH head (2004): Male — structure 66.5 with Poverty rate 28.1; Female — structure 33.5 with Poverty rate 26.4.
- Note: Detailed tables and full cross-tabulations are presented in the Statistical Annex; values above are reproduced exactly as reported.

*Source: MET calculations based on HBS*

### ANNEX A3. Government Decree on establishing the poverty monitoring and evaluation

### ANNEX A3. Government Decree on establishing the poverty monitoring and evaluation system

### Purpose and legal basis
- Purpose: monitoring poverty and assessing the impact of anti-poverty policy; implement provisions of art. 2 of the Law no.398-XV of 2 December 2004 on the approval of the Economic Growth and Poverty Reduction Strategy (2004-2006).
- Decision date and reference in document: Chisinau, 15 August 2005, No. 851.
- Published: Official Monitor of the Republic of Moldova, no.110-112 of 19 August 2005, art. 916.

### Mandated institutional responsibilities — Ministry of Economy and Trade
- Develop and approve, within two months jointly with the National Bureau of Statistics and other interested institutions, with support of the UNDP/UNICEF Joint Programme “Support for formulation, monitoring and evaluation of strategic policies in Moldova”, Instructions on the method of calculation of absolute poverty lines.
- Establish and manage an integrated data base on basic poverty indicators.
- Monitor and analyse poverty and the impact of anti-poverty policies, also various stakeholders.
- Present to the Government, on an annual basis:
  - by 15 June, a brief summary (short report) on poverty in Moldova;
  - by 1 November, a Poverty and Policy Impact Report.
- Jointly with the National Bureau of Statistics, relevant ministries and scientific institutions, improve, upon need, the methods of poverty calculation.
- Jointly with local public authorities and scientific institutions, continue activities in the field of poverty mapping and local poverty monitoring and make the results available to local public authorities for local policy development.
- Determine, within one month from the date of entry into force of this decision, community socio-economic indicators and develop relevant explanations (descriptions) for each indicator.
- Provide methodological and practical support to local public authorities in the development and calculation of socio-economic indicators for poverty monitoring.
- Supervise the execution of this decision.

### Mandated institutional responsibilities — National Bureau of Statistics (NBS)
- Ensure the collection of data required and improvement of the toolkit for the Household Budget Survey (HBS), which is the main source for poverty analysis.
- Calculate the absolute poverty lines.
- Calculate basic indicators for poverty monitoring and evaluation.
- Develop and present to the Ministry of Economy and Trade, on a yearly basis by 30 April, a standard set of tables with annual data on poverty trends and an explanatory (technical) note on the method of calculation of poverty lines and poverty indicators.
- Ensure continuity in collecting, processing and presenting information for poverty analysis as well as data accessibility for users.
- Ensure data accessibility for users, placement of the HBS database (after adjustment and depersonification of individual data) and the Explanatory (Technical) Note, with the standard set of tables, on the National Bureau of Statistics web-site.
- Create an internal subdivision comprising 2 persons with their main duties stipulated in paragraph 2 of the decision, within the staff of the head office of the National Bureau of Statistics (approved by Government decision no.560 of 10 June 2005).

### Mandated responsibilities — Ministries, central and local public authorities
- Ministries and other central public authorities responsible for sector policy monitoring and evaluation:
  - Evaluate jointly with the Ministry of Economy and Trade the socio-economic indicators required for analysis of non-monetary dimensions of poverty and policy impact on poverty.
  - Provide to the Ministry of Economy and Trade, on a yearly basis by 1 July, information for the analysis of the impact of sector policies on poverty.
- Local public authorities:
  - On a yearly basis by 1 July, collect and provide to the Ministry of Economy and Trade additional data on community socio-economic indicators.

### Informing civil society and data dissemination
- The Ministry of Economy and Trade, on a yearly basis by 20 December, will inform central and local public authorities, research institutions and donors on the results of poverty analysis by posting them on the web-site.
- The National Bureau of Statistics will ensure data accessibility for users and place the HBS database (after adjustment and depersonification) plus the Explanatory (Technical) Note and standard tables on its web-site.

### Cancellation of prior decisions
- The Government Decisions stipulated in the annex are cancelled. The Annex lists:
  - Government Decision no.564 of 14 June 2000 “On the approval of the National Poverty Alleviation Programme”.
  - Government Decision no.639 of 12 July 2001 “On the progress of the National Poverty Alleviation Programme in January-May 2001”.

### Annex B — Selected monitoring indicators and key statistics (years 2000–2005 as presented)
- Objective I: Inclusive and sustainable economic growth
  - GDP growth rate, %: 2.1, 6.1, 7.8, 6.6, 7.4, 7.1
  - Total external debt as share of GDP, %: 133.0, 115.1, 111.2, 92.1, 73.6, 69.1
  - Final consumption of households as a share of GDP, %: 87.6, 86.0, 82.0, 89.5, 87.8, 91.6
  - Fixed capital investment as a share of GDP, %: 15.4, 16.7, 16.3, 18.6, 21.2, 24.4
  - Processing industry as a share of GDP, %: 14.2, 15.8, 14.9, 15.4, 14.5, 14.5

- Objective II: Reducing poverty and inequality
  - Share of population under the absolute poverty line (total per country), %: 67.8, 54.6, 40.4, 29.0, 26.5, ...
  - Share of population under the food poverty line (total per country), %: 52.2, 38.0, 26.2, 15.0, 14.7, ...
  - Share of population under the poverty line at the level of 2.15$/day (to PPP), MDL per month (incidence), (total per country), %: 64.5, 52.4, 39.8, 28.9, 27.8, ...
  - Share of first quintile in national consumption, %: 6.7, 6.6, 6.8, 7.5, 7.2, ...
  - Gini Coefficient by consumption expenditures: 0.4, 0.4, 0.4, 0.4, 0.4, ...
  - Unemployment rate, ILO, %: 8.5, 7.3, 6.8, 7.9, 8.1, 7.3

- Objective III: Development of Human Resources
  - Life expectancy at birth, years — Men: 63.9, 64.5, 64.4, 64.5, 64.5, ...
  - Life expectancy at birth, years — Women: 71.2, 71.7, 71.7, 71.6, 72.2, ...
  - Mortality rate (per 1000 residents): 11.3, 11.0, 11.6, 11.9, 11.6, 12.4
  - Net rate of enrolment in primary education, %: 93.5, 92.4, 92.4, 92.4, 91.0, ...
  - Gross rate of enrolment in primary education, %: 99.4, 99.5, 99.5, 99.8, 97.9, ...
  - Net rate of enrolment in secondary education, %: 87.0, 86.8, 87.9, 87.5, 88.5, ...
  - Gross rate of enrolment in secondary education, %: 90.2, 91.1, 92.3, 92.2, 92.5, ...

- Macroeconomic and fiscal indicators (selected)
  - Nominal GDP, billion MDL: 16,020, 19,052, 22,556, 27,619, 32,032, 36,755
  - Rate of growth of Consumer Prices (end of year), %: 18.4, 6.3, 4.4, 15.7, 12.5, 10.0
  - Rate of growth of Consumer Prices (year average), %: 31.2, 9.6, 5.2, 11.6, 12.4, 11.9
  - Trade balance as a share of GDP, %: -22.8, -21.3, -22.7, -31.5, -29.0, -39.1
  - Share of transfers of Moldovan citizens from abroad in GDP, %: 13.8, 16.4, 19.4, 24.4, 27.0, 30.5
  - Average exchange rate, MDL/USD: 12.4334, 12.8668, 13.5730, 13.9426, 12.3283, 12.6003
  - National public budget deficit (-) as a share of GDP, %: -1.6, 1.0, -1.2, 1.4, 0.5, 2.1
  - Current account balance as a share of GDP, %: -7.6, -1.8, -4.0, -6.8, -2.7, -9.8
  - Official reserves in foreign currency, in months of import: 2.8, 2.5, 2.5, 2.1, 2.7, 2.7

- Poverty reduction (detailed incidence and gap, selected)
  - Share of population under the absolute poverty line (incidence), % — total: 67.8, 54.6, 40.4, 29.0, 26.5, ...
  - Absolute poverty incidence — Cities: -, -, 16.5, 12.8, 6.9, ...
  - Absolute poverty incidence — Towns: -, -, 46.8, 42.4, 34.9, ...
  - Absolute poverty incidence — Rural areas: -, -, 45.1, 31.1, 31.2, ...
  - Share of population under the food poverty line (incidence), % — total: 52.2, 38.0, 26.2, 15.0, 14.7, ...
  - Poverty gap ratio for the absolute poverty line, %, total: 27.0, 19.3, 12.4, 7.3, 6.8, ...
  - Poverty gap ratio for the food poverty line, %, total: 17.6, 11.6, 6.6, 3.1, 3.2, ...

- Private sector and enterprise indicators (selected)
  - Share of private sector in GDP, %: 75.0, 76.0, 70.5, 69.7, 68.6, ...
  - Share of private sector employees in total national economy employees, %: 68.4, 71.0, 72.3, 70.9, 69.4, 69.6
  - Share of small business enterprises in the total number of enterprises, %: ..., 89.4, 89.7, 90.0, 91.7, 92.2
  - Employees of small business enterprises staffed up to 50 persons as a share of total national economy employees, %: ..., 23.6, 25.4, 28.0, 30.2, 30.7

- Public sector and budget policy (selected)
  - Share of servants of public central administration in total employed population (beginning of the year), %: 0.6, 1.5, 1.6, 1.4, 1.4, 1.6
  - Average monthly salary in public central administration, MDL: 518, 742, 989, 1050, 1205, 1364
  - Revenues of the national public budget as a share of GDP, %: 34.8, 32.6, 33.1, 34.5, 35.6, 40.0
  - Revenues of the state budget (base) as a share of GDP, %: 19.0, 15.1, 14.6, 16.4, 17.3, 21.1
  - Tax income of national public budget as a share of GDP, %: 24.7, 24.2, 25.6, 27.3, 29.4, 32.0
  - Share of social sector expenditures in the national public budget, %: 53.2, 56.7, 62.6, 62.4, 62.6, 63.3
  - Share of social sector expenditures in GDP, %: 19.4, 17.9, 21.4, 20.7, 22.0, 24.0

- Finance sector (selected)
  - Commercial banks assets as a share of GDP, %: 29.1, 31.4, 35.1, 37.2, 41.5, 49.0
  - Rate of growth of bank credits to the economy, %: 40.12, 35.36, 35.17, 44.45, 22.20, 35.02
  - Share of unfavorable credits in total banking credits provided by banks in Moldova, %: 20.6, 10.4, 7.6, 6.4, 6.9, 4.3
  - Interest rate of credits in MDL, %: 33.29, 28.46, 23.14, 19.18, 20.96, 18.93
  - Monetization of economy (M3 as share of GDP), %: 21.91, 25.13, 28.86, 30.81, 36.59, 43.06

*Annex A3, Government Decision no.851 of 15 August 2005 (ANNEX A3. Government Decree on establishing the poverty monitoring and evaluation system).*

### 7. Infrastructure development

### 7. Infrastructure development

### Hard-surface roads
- Share of length of hard-surface roads in the total length of public roads, % (Source: NBS):
  - 2000: 99.9
  - 2001: 99.9
  - 2002: 99.8
  - 2003: 99.8
  - 2004: 99.8
  - 2005: ...

### Housing and utilities
- Housing, million square meters (Source: NBS):
  - 2000: 75.60
  - 2001: 75.90
  - 2002: 76.20
  - 2003: 76.77
  - 2004: 76.8
  - 2005: ...
- Share of housing with gas supply, % (Source: NBS):
  - Total: 2000: 82.6; 2001: 83.2; 2002: 83.3; 2003: 84.4; 2004: 85.1; 2005: ...
  - Urban areas: 2000: 91.0; 2001: 91.2; 2002: 91.1; 2003: 91.4; 2004: 91.8; 2005: ...
  - Rural areas: 2000: 78.2; 2001: 78.9; 2002: 79.4; 2003: 80.7; 2004: 81.6; 2005: ...
- Share of housing with sewerage, by area of residence, % (Source: NBS):
  - Total: 2000: 29.4; 2001: 29.9; 2002: 30.0; 2003: 30.4; 2004: 30.6; 2005: ...
  - Urban areas: 2000: 75.9; 2001: 76.3; 2002: 76.6; 2003: 77.8; 2004: 77.8; 2005: ...
  - Rural areas: 2000: 4.7; 2001: 5.2; 2002: 5.4; 2003: 5.5; 2004: 6.0; 2005: ...
- Share of housing with water supply, % (Source: NBS):
  - Total: 2000: 33.4; 2001: 33.2; 2002: 33.4; 2003: 33.9; 2004: 34.3; 2005: ...
  - Urban areas: 2000: 77.0; 2001: 77.2; 2002: 77.5; 2003: 78.7; 2004: 78.9; 2005: ...
  - Rural areas: 2000: 10.3; 2001: 9.8; 2002: 10.0; 2003: 10.4; 2004: 11.0; 2005: ...

### Electric power
- Electric power consumption (million KW-hour) (Source: MII):
  - 2000: 3,386.1
  - 2001: 3,400.8
  - 2002: 3,793.6
  - 2003: 4,636.3
  - 2004: 4,389.6
  - 2005: 4,500.0
- Share of electric power losses in electric power consumption, % (Source: NBS):
  - 2000: 26.8
  - 2001: 12.9
  - 2002: 10.9
  - 2003: 8.0
  - 2004: 12.5
  - 2005: ...

### Telecommunications and services infrastructure
- Number of home telephone sets in the public network or with access to it (per 100 resident) (Source: NBS):
  - Total: 2000: 14.1; 2001: 15.6; 2002: 17.3; 2003: 19.3; 2004: 21.2; 2005: ...
  - In urban network: 2000: 24.5; 2001: 26.1; 2002: 27.5; 2003: 29.2; 2004: 30.3; 2005: ...
  - In rural network: 2000: 6.9; 2001: 8.1; 2002: 10.1; 2003: 12.2; 2004: 14.7; 2005: ...
- Share of length of optical fiber lines in the total length of interurban cable telecommunication lines, % (Source: NBS):
  - 2000: 23.9
  - 2001: 43.1
  - 2002: 43.3
  - 2003: 43.6
  - 2004: 43.6
  - 2005: ...
- Share of export of services in the total exports, % (Source: NBM):
  - 2000: 25.7
  - 2001: 23.2
  - 2002: 24.7
  - 2003: 24.0
  - 2004: 25.3
  - 2005: 27.2

*Source: _cr06185 - 7. Infrastructure development*

### 2. Monitoring is a continued function of systematic collection of data for the EGPRSP and MDG

### 2. Monitoring is a continued function of systematic collection of data for the EGPRSP and MDG

### Purpose and definitions
- Monitoring: continued function of systematic collection of data for the EGPRSP and MDG indicators and of information about the implementation of actions and policies to provide decision-makers and stakeholders with information on the progress in the achievement of development strategy/programme objectives and the efficient use of allocated resources.
- Evaluation: systematic and objective analysis of development strategies/programmes, aimed at identifying the relevance and the achievement of their objectives, their efficiency, effectiveness, impact and sustainability.

### Participants and institutional arrangements
- Participants to the monitoring and evaluation process:
  - central and local public authorities,
  - other organizations responsible for the implementation of actions stipulated in the EGPRSP/MDG,
  - other stakeholders.
- Institutionalization:
  - policy and analysis units shall be created within ministries, agencies, and other institutions of the central public administration;
  - at the local level, monitoring shall be conducted by the economic divisions of the municipal/rayon councils.
- Coordination:
  - The coordination of the monitoring process at the interministerial and national level will be carried out by the Ministry of Economy and Trade (MET).

### Reporting schedule and obligations
- Reporting frequencies:
  - Quarterly and annually, for the EGPRSP.
  - Once in two years, for the MDG.
- Action plan submission:
  - Institutions of the central and local public administration shall develop, on the basis of EGPRSP/MDG, annual action plans and present them to the Government Administration and the Ministry of Economy and Trade by 15 January of the reporting year.
- Analysis deadline for financial coverage:
  - The results of the analysis of financial coverage for the previous year shall be submitted to the Ministry of Economy and Trade by 15 January of the year that follows the reporting year.

### Components of monitoring and evaluation
- Monitoring of financial coverage.
- Monitoring of trends.
- Impact evaluation.

### Monitoring of financial coverage
- Carried out by stakeholders, in line with Annex 6 to the EGPRSP:
  - Consequently for each year;
  - By financial sources:
    - i. from budgetary resources;
    - ii. from credits, donations, technical assistance.
- Analysis of financial coverage:
  - carried out on a permanent basis by participants to the process of monitoring and evaluation jointly with the Ministry of Finance.
- Regional level:
  - Analysis of financial coverage of priority actions at the regional level is carried out by the local public authorities within the approved branch programmes and by financial sources.

### Monitoring of trends
- Activities consist of:
  - (i) collection and analysis of indicators which characterize trends in the field of economic growth and poverty reduction (Annex 5);
  - (ii) analysis of implementation of the Policy Matrix (Annex 6).
- Policy and analysis units reporting schedule:
  - quarterly, by the 15th day of the month following the reporting month;
  - annually, by 15 January of the year following the reporting year.
- Data submission by line institutions:
  - National Bureau of Statistics, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Health and Social Protection, Ministry of Industry and Infrastructure, Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources, and NBM submits indicators from Annex 5 to the MET, on a quarterly basis, not later than the 25th day of the month following the reporting period.

### DevInfo database
- MET shall create and maintain a pilot database (DevInfo) which will contain quantitative indicators collected throughout the trends monitoring process.
- DevInfo:
  - is a database system for the consolidated monitoring of quantitative indicators classified by objectives and targets related to one or more development strategies/programmes.
  - MET shall update the database with quantitative trends monitoring indicators on a quarterly basis.
- Footnote: DevInfo System was developed by UNICEF, adopted by the UN and was implemented for over 80 national databases.

### Policy impact evaluation
- Scope:
  - The impact of sector policies on the achievement of EGPRSP objectives shall be evaluated by the stakeholders in the framework of policies and actions stipulated in action plans, taking into account the EGPRSP priorities.
- Results of policy impact evaluation shall reflect:
  - the degree of compliance of policy outputs with strategy priorities;
  - policy strengths and weaknesses.

### Outputs of monitoring and evaluation
- The outputs are a system of reports on the implementation of EGPRSP/MDG and socio-economic development of the country:
  - Biennial MDG Report
  - Annual Report on EGPRSP Implementation. The structure of the report shall be specified each year.
  - Anual Poverty Report
  - Quarterly EGPRSP Reports
  - Annual Reports on the socio-economic situation in the sector/territory.
  - Database with quantitative trends monitoring indicators, updated on a quarterly basis.
- Publication:
  - Outputs of monitoring and evaluation (reports and database with quantitative trends monitoring indicators) will be made public.

*Source: _cr06185 - 2. Monitoring is a continued function of systematic collection of data for the EGPRSP and MDG*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2006/_cr06185.pdf_
