## 1. Implementation of Tunisia 2002 FSAP Recommendations

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Implementation of Tunisia 2002 FSAP Recommendations](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2006/_cr06448.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2006/_cr06448.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2006/_cr06448.pdf.json)

---

### Summary and overall stability assessment
- Structural reforms since the 2002 FSAP: increased transparency and accountability, modernization of the banking system, strengthened regulatory framework, and promotion of nonbank financial intermediation.
- Asset quality and NPLs:
  - NPLs increased from 19 percent of total loans at end-2001 to 24 percent at end-2003.
  - NPLs declined to 23.7 percent in 2004 and to 20.9 percent by year-end 2005.
- 2005 banking performance:
  - Operating results of all banks improved markedly and banks strengthened provisions.
  - Government majority-owned commercial banks did not distribute dividends to boost loan-loss reserves.
- Post-2002 FSAP measures:
  - Increased tax deductibility of provisions for NPLs.
  - Legal reforms to accelerate sale of collateral.
  - Privatization of two government-controlled banks.
  - Recapitalization of a number of private banks by owners.
- Authorities’ strategy on credit quality:
  - All banks required to reach a provisioning ratio of 70 percent by 2009, up from 46.4 percent at end-2005; progress to be monitored semiannually.
  - Banks prohibited from distributing dividends until they meet the provisioning target.
  - Mission recommendation: set a more ambitious target of reducing NPLs to no more than 10 percent of total loans by 2009; banks unable to attain targets should undergo recapitalization.
- Governance and transparency:
  - Revised banking law (promulgated early May 2006) mandates stronger credit committees accountable to bank boards.
  - 2005 law imposes additional requirements on external auditors, strengthens publication obligations, and requires companies above a given size to establish audit committees.
- Loan workout and NPL reduction challenges and recommendations:
  - Improve procedures for loan workouts and partial write-offs, with safeguards to limit moral hazard.
  - Reduce heavy reliance on real estate collateral; address low share of NPLs subject to judicial recovery procedures.
  - Recommendations: more effective judicial system, recourse to extra-judicial procedures, tax treatment of partial write-offs (currently not tax-deductible), better collateral registration and realization (address delays in registration of real estate titles and mortgages, and in real estate transfers).
- Management of government-controlled banks:
  - Mission recommends strengthening management of the three remaining government-controlled commercial banks and making them accountable for precise targets, particularly NPL reduction.
- Stress tests and vulnerabilities:
  - Credit risk identified as the most important vulnerability.
  - Stress tests confirm vulnerability to a sharp fall in real estate collateral values; several shocks could reduce the banking system CAR below the required minimum of 8 percent, although not generating a systemic threat.
  - System not exposed to direct interest rate risk, but real interest rate fluctuations could adversely affect credit portfolio quality.
  - Foreign exchange and liquidity risks are negligible.
- Nonbank financing and market development:
  - Authorities promote equity financing for SMEs via fiscal incentives to private venture and equity capital funds; assets remain modest relative to banking resources.
  - Stock market capitalization approximately 9 percent of GDP in 2004; new issues TD 204 million in 2004 (equivalent to 0.8 percent of GDP and 3.7 percent of private investment).
  - Leasing activity expanded: assets rose by one half in 2000–04; new leasing operations TD 500 million in 2004 (equivalent to 11 percent of total private investment).

### Key recommendations (FSAP Update)
- Banking sector
  - Strengthen capital base of banks by rigorous implementation of the authorities’ target to reach 70 percent provisioning for all NPLs, without consideration of existing collateral.
  - Reduce by 2009 the ratio of NPLs to total loans to no more than 10 percent of loans through proactive loan restructuring, including partial write-offs, with safeguards to avoid moral hazard.
  - Accelerate restructuring of bank loans to the tourism sector, based on realistic assessments of borrowers’ debt repayment capacity.
  - Strengthen management of public commercial banks to ensure full independence of management, tighter risk management procedures, and improved estimates of NPLs recovery prospects.
  - Establish program contracts with management of public commercial banks including quantitative operational targets.
  - Stand ready to recapitalize public commercial banks if operating income is not sufficient to reach the 70 percent provisioning target for NPLs.
  - Improve information system for lending to SMEs and households by promoting establishment of private credit bureaus.
- Prudential supervision and regulation
  - Ensure rapid implementation of new rules on credit risk management envisaged by a draft new central bank circular on internal controls.
  - Establish prudential ratios on a consolidated basis.
- Central bank policy and systemic liquidity management
  - Deepen interbank markets by widening the central bank narrow interest rate corridor.
  - Relax restrictions on forward foreign exchange cover for commercial operators.
  - Implement decision to end requirement for banks to transfer end-of-day foreign exchange balances to the central bank.
- Corporate debt restructuring
  - Promote extra-judicial procedures for debt workouts, with preset rules for creditors and debtors to speed agreements.
  - Review preferred creditor status of tax authorities and social security agency claims.

### Macroeconomic context and financial environment
- Growth and macro indicators:
  - Real GDP grew on average by 5 percent per year in 2000–05.
  - Inflation declined to 2 percent in 2005.
  - Overall fiscal deficit remained stable at about 3 percent of GDP.
  - External reserves rose to the equivalent of four months of imports.
  - External debt-to-GDP ratio broadly stable.
- 2002 tourism shock and effects:
  - Real GDP growth slowed to 1.7 percent in 2002 following September 11, 2001 events and 2002 Djerba bombing.
  - Tourist hotel occupancy declined 22 percent in 2002 and a further 2 percent in 2003.
  - Contributed to NPL spike from 19.2 percent of total loans at end-2001 to 24 percent at end-2003; NPLs then 23.7 percent in 2004 and 20.9 percent at end-2005.
- Bank credit and financial deepening:
  - Bank credit to nongovernment sector decelerated since end-2000; ratio of bank credit to nongovernment sector 67 percent at end-2005.
  - Managed float exchange regime with reduced central bank intervention has produced trend real depreciation.
- Capital account liberalization measures (selected):
  - Since July 2004 purchases by nonresidents of treasury bills permitted within a limit of 5 percent of each issue.
  - Purchase by foreign nationals of shares in Tunisian companies fully liberalized in March 2005.
  - Since January 2005 banks free to borrow abroad at maturities longer than 12 months; companies with ratings also allowed to borrow abroad.
  - Outbound portfolio investment by residents remains subject to restrictions; accumulation of assets abroad by residents is subject to authorization.
  - Further capital account liberalization to be predicated on strengthening banking and financial system and moving to a floating exchange rate.

### Banking sector risks, vulnerabilities, and challenges
- FSIs and sectoral trends:
  - After improvements in the 1990s, key FSIs deteriorated in 2001–03, notably higher NPLs.
  - NPLs: 19.2 percent at end-2001, 24 percent at end-2003.
  - Loans to tourism accounted for one quarter of NPL increase in 2001–03; industry accounted for 35 percent of the total NPL increase.
  - Risk-weighted regulatory capital adequacy ratio declined from 11.1 percent to 9.9 percent between 2001 and 2003.
- Supervision and standards:
  - Compliance with Basel Core Principles improved compared with 2002, reflecting better licensing, tighter investment criteria, improved information sharing, improved accounting standards, and introduction of consolidated supervision.
  - AML/CFT: directives on suspicious transaction reports issued in April 2006; additional steps needed to implement an effective AML/CFT system.
- Liquidity and market development:
  - Importance of deeper money market by allowing wider fluctuations of money market rates (currently maintained in a very narrow band).
  - Development of foreign exchange market recommended, including eliminating restrictions on forward operations and permitting foreign exchange options.

---

### 22. Financial soundness indicators started improving in the second half of 2004

### Financial soundness developments and bank structure
- Aggregate CAR rose to 10.7 percent at end-2005.
- NPL ratio declined by 2.8 percentage points to 20.9 percent at end-2005.
- Provisioning ratio for the whole system was 46 percent at end-2005, up from 43 percent at end-2003.
- Commercial banks: 13 banks (excluding development banks that received universal banking licenses in 2005):
  - 10 under private ownership.
  - 3 under government majority ownership.
- At end-2005, public banks’ assets account for 44.5 percent of total commercial bank assets.
- NPL ratios at end-2005:
  - Public banks (group): 22.1 percent.
  - Private banks (group): 20 percent.
  - Private banks individual range: 7 percent to 24 percent.
  - Public banks individual range: 10 percent to 32 percent.
- Two private banks undergoing recapitalization lowered aggregate private-bank indicators.

### Provisioning, targets, and fiscal/tax measures
- Authorities set a provisioning target of 70 percent by 2009.
- Tax measures to support provisioning:
  - Tax deductibility of provisions raised to 85 percent in 2004.
  - Tax deductibility of provisions raised to 100 percent in 2005.
- Dividend distributions were prohibited in 2005 and in 2006 to boost provisioning.
- Several private banks, accounting for 17 percent of total assets of the system, have already reached the 70 percent provisioning target (partly via recent capital injections).
- Government does not plan additional capital injections in public banks; their ability to attain the 70 percent provisioning target by 2009 remains in doubt.

### Profitability and income trends
- Public banks:
  - Net income before provisions has eroded since 2000, reflecting higher NPLs and flat non-interest income.
  - Provisions increased by about half, causing sharp drops in ROA and ROE since 2000.
- Private banks:
  - Net income before provisions more than doubled between 2000 and 2005 due to rises in both interest- and non-interest income.
  - Private banks more than doubled provisions.

### Policy measures and legal/administrative reforms (since 2001)
- Tightened rules on investments and bank licensing, increased minimum capital requirement, external auditor reports and certified financial statements on large borrowers, and tighter exposure limits (2001 banking law revision).
- 2006 revised banking law (promulgated in early May 2006):
  - Requires banks to establish an executive credit committee reporting to the board and to put in place a compliance control system under board supervision.
- 2005 law on financial transparency:
  - External auditors for stock corporations and companies above a balance sheet threshold (term limit three years); auditors must transmit reports to the central bank under specified conditions; two external auditors required for certain consolidated accounts; permanent internal audit committees for listed companies and large unlisted companies.
- Creditor rights strengthened via 2003 revision of the 1995 law on companies restructuring and revision in the civil procedure code to facilitate auctioning of real estate collateral.
- Banking system restructuring: full privatization in 2002 and 2005 of two banks; transformation of five development banks into universal banks (one under privatization).
- Mission recommendations:
  - Complement increased provisioning target with a more aggressive policy to reduce NPLs to no more than 10 percent of loans by 2009, including partial write-offs and well-designed loan restructuring.
  - Target NPL restructuring priority in the tourism sector where implementation is easier.
  - Central bank to closely monitor loan recovery and restructuring; improve judicial, legal, and tax environment to support restructuring.
  - Use extrajudicial procedures and voluntary workout processes, with rules to facilitate agreements between creditors and debtors (standstill periods, qualified majority agreements, provisions for haircuts and equity dilution).
  - Require dilution of debtors’ control over assets when debt restructuring or write-offs occur to avoid moral hazard.
  - Improve judicial procedures under the 1995 enterprise restructuring law for prompt initiation and limit debtor delaying tactics; increase role of commercial courts in settling disputes.
  - Reexamine preferred creditor position of tax and social securities authorities to encourage their forgoing part of claims in conjunction with other creditors’ write-offs.
  - Make partial write-offs tax deductible and speed up write-off process for fully provisioned loans by eliminating barriers to tax neutrality.
  - Enhance credit risk management in banks as household lending rises; establish a credit bureau for households and SMEs.

### Lending to households
- Bank lending to households: 17 percent of total loans (still low but increased rapidly since 2002).
- Anticipated faster growth in household loans necessitates improved credit risk management and a specialized credit bureau for households and small-and medium-scale enterprises.

### Stress tests — methodology and coverage
- Tests on largest 10 commercial banks (both private and state-owned, excluding former development banks), accounting for more than 90 percent of total assets of the entire banking system.
- Tests based on end-2005 balance sheet data.
- Tests examine large, low-probability shocks across foreign exchange, liquidity, interest rate, real estate collateral, and credit risk; securities are “marked-to-market.”

### Stress test findings — market and liquidity risks
- Foreign currency exposure: net open position below 1 percent of capital.
- Foreign exchange lending below 3 percent of total.
- Limited contagion risk due to a small interbank market.
- Interest rate sensitivity limited because most credits and interest-bearing deposits are indexed to the money market rate.
- An interest rate increase of about 200 basis points would cause a fall in the CAR by less than one percentage point from the end-2005 level of 10.5 percent for the sample of banks tested.
  - Exception: for two banks with large government bond portfolios, one bank suffers a fall in CAR of 3.8 percentage points.
- Interest rate increases could also reduce solvency of some creditors and the value of real estate collateral, adversely affecting system health.

### Stress test findings — real estate collateral and credit risk
- Assumed shocks and impacts:
  - 50 percent decline in real estate collateral (generalized shock) reduces system CAR to 7.3 percent; for some banks CAR falls as low as 4.6 percent.
  - Credit risk severe-shock: migration of 8 percent of performing loans to NPL loss category (past due over 360 days) decreases system CAR to 5.5 percent.
  - Simultaneous 50 percent haircut on real estate collateral with the 8 percent migration reduces CAR to 1.9 percent.
- Sectoral migration scenarios (based on 2001–03 experience):
  - Migration of either 16 percent of performing loans to tourism, or 6 percent to industry, or 4 percent to real estate into the NPL loss category.
  - Without a 50 percent collateral cut, these shocks reduce CAR to a range of 9.3 to 10 percent.
  - With a simultaneous 50 percent collateral cut, CAR declines to a range between 6 and 6.8 percent.
- Heterogeneity across banks:
  - Some banks retain solvency ratio of 8 percent or higher even under most severe shocks.
  - Others fall below the 8 percent minimum capital requirement; some become insolvent (negative CAR).
  - On average, state-owned banks fare worse than private banks, by a limited margin.
  - Two private banks in recapitalization start with low capital, pulling down private-bank averages.

### Scenario analysis and fiscal implication
- Combined scenario: 200 basis points shock on the money market rate, 4 percent migration of performing loans to loss category, and 50 percent decline in value of collateral.
  - Under this scenario, CAR drops to 3.9 percent.
  - To restore CAR to the minimum requirement of 8 percent, the system would require recapitalization equivalent to 2.2 percent of GDP, corresponding to one third of its current capital base.

### Bank regulation and supervision update
- Quality of supervision and regulation improved since the 2002 FSAP; progress in BCP implementation.
- Key improvements:
  - Requirement for commercial borrowers to submit audited financial statements when bank indebtedness exceeds a threshold.
  - New rules on banks’ equity participation.
  - Enhanced central bank monitoring of credit risk and improved inspectors’ training.
  - Significant role of external auditors in supervisory system; auditors must submit reports to the central bank and attend periodic meetings.
- Further improvements needed:
  - Strengthen banks’ credit policy, close monitoring of doubtful credits, and loan recovery.
  - Provisioning should reflect actual prospects of doubtful loan recovery and time dimension, in line with international accounting standards.
  - Draft new central bank circular (expected shortly) to require tighter internal control mechanisms: borrower ratings, quarterly exposure monitoring, stress tests, and executive credit committee implementation per 2006 revised banking law; prompt implementation recommended.
  - Improve regulations on connected lending and investment; equity participations from loan restructuring should require central bank authorization when exceeding 30 percent of capital of beneficiary company.
  - Consolidated supervision progress modest despite 2003 accounting law reform; need to monitor prudential ratios on a consolidated basis and strengthen relations with other financial sector supervisors.
  - Closely monitor NPLs transferred to fully-owned asset management companies.

### Public banks
- Authorities view banking system structure as broadly appropriate after privatization of two majority government-owned banks in 2002–05; privatization of remaining three government-majority commercial banks is not envisaged.
- The three remaining government-majority banks:
  - Banque de l’Habitat (mortgage lending specialist).
  - Banque de l’Agriculture (key lender to the agricultural sector).
  - Société Tunisienne des Banques (diversified portfolio with large exposure to tourism; the largest bank in the country).

---

### 49. Public banks: recent income trends and governance recommendations

### Public banks — findings and recommendations
- Findings:
  - "The recent trends of gross income and income before provisioning of public banks is less favorable than for private banks."
  - "Their cost-income ratio is also higher."
- Recommendations:
  - Strengthen management of the three banks by ensuring that the board of directors is completely independent from external influences.
  - Make management accountable for the attainment of precise operational targets, in particular regarding loan recovery and NPL reduction.
  - "Provided adequate progress is achieved over the next 24 months on the basis of a number of indicators, the government should stand ready to recapitalize these banks, if operating income is not sufficient to strengthen the provisioning of NPLs."

### Former development banks
- Five existing development banks received in 2004–05 universal banking licenses.
- Ownership: joint ownership by the Tunisian government and the governments of four Gulf States and Libya.
- Financial structure: very high capital-asset ratio, with equity base being the main source of funding.
- Business model: equity investment represents a larger share of assets than for commercial banks.
- Government strategy: promote their privatization, potentially followed by mergers with commercial banks.
- Mission encouragement: speed up privatization to establish stronger institutions.

### Capital markets and related developments
- Stock exchange:
  - New issues modest; capitalization remained at 9 percent of GDP.
  - Family-owned enterprises remain reluctant to list despite 2005 law on financial transparency.
- Mutual funds and venture capital:
  - Mutual fund resources expanded at an average annual rate of 9 percent in 2000–04.
  - At end-2004, 40 percent of mutual fund assets invested in government bonds and 24 percent in bonds and shares of private companies.
  - SICARs: 50 percent increase in entities from 2000 to 2004; assets threefold increase in 2000–04 up to the equivalent of 1.6 percent of GDP.
- Bond market:
  - Secondary market transactions increased but remain modest.
  - A yield curve for government paper "has been recently established" by the CMF; recommendation to disclose it more widely.
  - Efforts to establish a similar curve for private bonds.
  - Public debt directorate reopened existing bond issues and increased size of issues to create benchmark issues.
- Leasing:
  - Assets increased by 50 percent between 2000 and 2004; leasing companies among main private bond issuers and effective for SME financing.
- Capital inflows:
  - Inflows for purchases of Tunisian shares liberalized in early 2005; purchases by nonresidents limited so far.

### Insurance supervision
- 2002 FSAP finding: supervision inadequate; state-owned and mutual companies under-capitalized and under-reserved; large private companies adequate.
- Reforms implemented:
  - 2002 overhaul of insurance regulatory statute with prudential norms aligned with international practices (solvency requirements and minimum capital).
  - Supervisory agency reorganized and resources for off-site and on-site inspections strengthened.
  - Tax measures to promote life insurance: tax deductibility of premia introduced in 2002; annuity income tax exempt from 2004.
- Further actions (early 2006):
  - Revisions submitted to parliament tightening governance rules.
  - Regulatory enhancements: supervision of life insurance contracts with guaranteed minimum returns; review of life insurance premia to be updated on basis of new mortality tables under preparation.
  - Capital strengthening: opening of capital of largest state-owned company to a strategic investor under way; private companies also strengthening capital via strategic partners; recommendation to accelerate outside injections.

### Payments system and liquidity management
- Payments system:
  - Real time gross settlement system in last phase of testing; will become operational in a few months.
  - System meets best practice requirements: settlement finality, fully collateralized intraday central bank advances, and optimization procedures for queues.
- Liquidity management:
  - BCT improved forecasts of autonomous liquidity factors and increased recourse to open market operations.
  - Monthly average volume of transactions on the interbank market tripled between 2002 and 2005 (though still modest against monetary aggregates).
  - Recommendations:
    - Widen the very narrow money market interest rate band currently maintained by central bank interventions.
    - Limit BCT presence in markets to weekly credit auctions and open market operations, with much less recourse to fine-tuning operations.
    - Prepare banks for potentially larger exchange rate fluctuations in context of further exchange and capital account liberalization.
- Foreign exchange market:
  - Foreign exchange interbank market transactions volume increased by 46 percent between 2002 and 2005.
  - Forward market transactions increased, enabling hedging.
  - Recommendations: relax restrictions limiting forward cover access; allow banks to sell foreign exchange options to customers.
  - Recommendation: repeal requirement for banks to transfer end-of-day foreign exchange balances to the BCT, accompanied by close monitoring of banks’ external positions.

---

### 66. AML/CFT implementation — findings and recommendations

### AML/CFT implementation — findings
- Overall, implementation of the AML/CFT Law is still at an initial phase.
- Prosecutorial authorities have begun using the CFT component of the law, but on a limited basis.
- A Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) has been formally set up within the BCT.
- Only a handful of STRs have been filed with the FIU in more than two years.
- Key challenge: implementation and enforcement, particularly through more active supervision of financial sector compliance with AML-CFT requirements.

### Regulatory steps taken
- FIU adopted two directives in April 2006:
  - Directive 1: deals with the STR template.
  - Directive 2: details requirements on due diligence, internal controls, and suspicious transactions reporting obligations for credit institutions, off-shore banks and the Postal Office.
- The second directive needs to be complemented in the short term by circulars to be issued by the central bank.

### Analysis and gaps
- Limited use of the CFT component indicates early-stage enforcement.
- Low STR filing activity suggests weak reporting/compliance by reporting entities and/or operational issues within the FIU.
- Supervision of financial sector compliance with AML-CFT requirements is insufficiently active.
- Directives are incomplete without central bank circulars to operationalize supervisory expectations.

### Policy recommendations
- Lay out a criminal policy on the fight against money-laundering, based on a more comprehensive risk-assessment and analysis of criminal patterns in the country.
- Enhance implementation and enforcement of the AML/CFT Law through:
  - More active supervision of compliance of the financial sector with their AML-CFT requirements.
  - Issuance of central bank circulars in the short term to complement FIU directives (April 2006) and clarify supervisory expectations and operational procedures.
- Improve STR reporting to the FIU (address reporting entities’ incentives, awareness, and reporting systems).

---

### Selected FSAP Update recommendations and central bank/prudential measures (preserved verbatim where in source)
- Ensure rigorous implementation of the authorities’ target of  70 percent provisioning for all NPLs, without regard of existing collateral. MT
- Reduce by 2009 the ratio of NPLs to total loans to no more than 10 percent of loans through a proactive policy of loan restructuring, including partial write-offs, accompanied by safeguards against moral hazard. MT
- Accelerate restructuring of bank loans to the tourism sector, on the basis of a realistic assessment of debt repayment capacity of borrowers. ST
- Ensure that partial write-offs benefit of tax deductibility. ST
- Promote extrajudicial procedures for bank debt restructuring. ST
- Strengthen management of public commercial banks, ensuring full independence of management, tighter risk management procedures, and improved estimate of NPLs recovery prospects. ST
- Establish program contracts with management of public commercial banks with quantitative operational targets. ST
- Stand ready to recapitalize public commercial banks if operating income is not sufficient to reach the 70 percent provisioning targets for NPLs. MT
- Maintain prohibition of dividend distribution for banks which have inadequate NPL provisioning. ST
- Speed-up privatization and mergers of former development banks that have recently received universal banking licenses. ST
- Improve information system for lending to SMEs and households by promoting establishment of private credit bureaus. ST

Central bank, prudential, and market recommendations (selected)
- Ensure implementation of new rules on management of credit risk, envisaged by draft new central bank circular on internal controls. ST
- Assess the quality of banks internal audit functions. MT
- Establish prudential ratios on a consolidated basis. ST
- Enter in information sharing agreements with other Tunisian financial supervisors and foreign supervisors. ST
- Tighten regulations regarding equity investments, and strengthen enforcement. ST
- Revisit the disciplinary sanction regimes by vesting the power to impose sanctions in the Banking Commission envisaged in the banking law, rather than in the governor of the central bank, to promote transparency. ST
- Disclose more clearly in the BCT publications the monetary framework in terms of ultimate, intermediate and operational objectives. ST
- Deepen interbank markets by allowing wider money market rates fluctuations. ST
- Publicize more widely newly established bond yield curve. ST
- Repeal the current requirement for banks to transfer end-of-day-foreign exchange balances to the central bank. ST
- Relax restrictions on forward foreign exchange cover for commercial operators. ST

---

### 67. Assessment of the BCT’s compliance with the Basel Committee’s Core Principles

### Assessment scope and institutional context
- Assessment dates: January 16-31 and March 27-31, 2006.
- Assessment team: Jean-Luc Couetoux and Didier Debals.
- Basis: review of laws, regulations, best practices, discussions with BCT and stakeholders, and use of Core Principles Methodology.
- Financial system indicators:
  - Total financial system assets: 125 percent of GDP.
  - Banking system accounts for 70 percent of financial system assets.
- Market structure counts:
  - 13 commercial banks (three majority government-owned).
  - 5 former development banks.
  - 8 off-shore banks.
  - 1 public micro-finance institution.
  - 1 public bank specialized in lending to small- and medium-scale enterprises.
  - 11 leasing companies.
  - 3 factoring companies.
- Preconditions and weaknesses:
  - Most preconditions for effective supervision exist.
  - Weaknesses: delays in judicial procedures, lack of effective out-of-court settlement mechanisms, delays in registration of real estate and mortgages.
  - External auditors’ role strengthened; 2005 law requires banks to have two auditors.
  - No credit bureau specialized in assigning ratings to single counterparties yet established.

### Main findings by Core Principle groups (summary)
- Overall progress: important progress in updating regulatory and supervisory framework over past four years; upgrades in CP1.4, CP1.6, CP3, CP5, CP20, CP21.
- CP7 and CP8 compliance contingent on issuance of BCT draft circular on internal controls following revised banking law (early May 2006).
- Remaining obstacles: notably in consolidated supervision.

Key element highlights:
- CP 1 (Objectives, Autonomy, Powers, and Resources):
  - Objectives defined in law; staff qualified; BCT has sufficient resources.
  - Independence could be enhanced by specifying grounds for removal from office of governing body.
  - Formal information sharing agreements require revision of central bank law in parliament.
- CPs 2–5 (Licensing and Structure):
  - Licensing criteria adequate; BCT authority to review transfers of ownership; recommendation to establish a cumulative ceiling for investments by credit institutions.
- CPs 6–15 (Prudential Regulations):
  - Minimum capital requirement and CAR established; recommendation to calculate CAR on a consolidated basis.
  - No regulatory provision specifically addressing credit risk management; gap to be addressed by draft circular on internal controls.
  - Loan classification rules aligned with best practices; loan loss provisioning remains weak.
  - Provisioning target: 70 percent of NPLs by 2009; dividend prohibitions in 2005 and 2006 for weakly provisioned banks.
- CPs16–20 (Ongoing Supervision):
  - Framework adequate; recommendations: lay down procedures for on-site exams in a manual; president of supervised institution should receive full inspection report.
  - Weaknesses in consolidated supervision: need consolidated prudential norms and formalized information sharing agreements.
- CP 21 (Information Requirement):
  - Tunisia largely complies; reporting generally complies with IAS; Tunisian standard for NPLs does not take into account time needed for loan recovery.
  - External auditors have statutory duty to inform supervisory agency of matters of significant importance.
- CP 22 (Formal Powers of Supervisors):
  - Banking law provides sanctions, but penalties never applied formally; Banking Commission has power to impose severe sanctions but has never been convened.
  - Recommendations: confer sanctioning powers to Banking Commission; governor should have power to issue injunctions; establish waivers; publicize sanctions.
- CPs 23–25 (Cross-Border Banking):
  - Limited foreign activity; foreign banks in Tunisia subject to local prudential regulations.
  - Relations with foreign supervisors informal because central bank law does not allow information sharing agreements; parliamentary revision should address this.

### Key statistics and legal references (as in source)
- Assessment dates: January 16-31 and March 27-31, 2006.
- Financial system assets: 125 percent of GDP.
- Banking system share of financial system assets: 70 percent.
- Market structure counts: see above.
- Legal instruments cited:
  - Law 58-90 creating and organizing the BCT.
  - Law 2001-65 on credit institutions (modified in 2006).
  - 2005 law on financial security (requires two auditors).
  - 2006 banking law (promulgated in early May 2006).
  - 2003-75 law on AML/CFT; directives 2006-01 and 2006-02.
- Provisioning target: 70 percent of NPLs by 2009.
- Dividend prohibitions: banks with weak provisioning prohibited from paying dividends in 2005 and 2006.

### Recommended Action Plan (condensed)
- CP 5: Establish a cumulative ceiling for investments by credit institutions, in addition to individual ceilings.
- CP 6: Introduce consolidated prudential solvency ratios.
- CP 7: Issue draft circular on internal controls following promulgation of revised banking law.
- CP 8: Strengthen surveillance of doubtful loans and recovery of overdue loans; ensure provisioning accounts for actual recovery prospects and time factor.
- CP 13: Increase frequency of information systems inspections.
- CP 14: Ensure application of new rules after issuance of circular on internal controls.
- CP 16: Provide full inspection reports to institution presidents.
- CP 20: Establish consolidated ratios and conclude information sharing agreements with other supervisors.
- CP 21: Explicitly account for time needed for loan recovery in NPL valuation.
- CP 22: Strengthen sanctioning system, establish Banking Commission on a permanent basis, apply formal sanctions when needed, and publicize sanctions.

### Authorities’ response
- BCT broadly agreed with assessments and recommendations.
- BCT noted:
  - Implementation of circular on internal control to be issued shortly will cover current regulatory gaps in credit decisions and monitoring procedures (CP 7).
  - Measures are being taken to strengthen consolidated supervision; draft revised central bank law in parliament will authorize information sharing agreements with other domestic and foreign supervisors (CP 20).
- BCT did not agree with recommendations to:
  - Transform the Banking Commission into a permanent body, noting it can be convened rapidly when needed.
  - Devolve all sanctioning powers to the Commission; they consider the current split of sanctioning powers between the Governor and the Commission appropriate.

*This summary is based exclusively on the content of the specified IMF staff report chapter in the provided PDF content unit.*

### 1. Implementation of Tunisia 2002 FSAP Recommendations.................................................20

### 1. Implementation of Tunisia 2002 FSAP Recommendations.................................................20

### Summary and overall stability assessment
- Since the 2002 FSAP a number of structural reforms have been carried out to increase transparency and accountability, modernize the banking system, strengthen the regulatory framework, and promote nonbank financial intermediation.
- Growth slowdown in 2002 and a marked recession in the tourism sector adversely affected banking asset quality:
  - NPLs increased from 19 percent of total loans at end-2001 to 24 percent at end-2003.
  - NPLs declined to 23.7 percent in 2004 and to 20.9 percent by year-end 2005.
- In 2005 operating results of all banks improved markedly and banks strengthened provisions; government majority-owned commercial banks did not distribute dividends to boost loan-loss reserves.
- Post-2002 FSAP measures taken include:
  - Increased tax deductibility of provisions for NPLs.
  - Legal reforms to accelerate sale of collateral.
  - Privatization of two government-controlled banks.
  - Recapitalization of a number of private banks by owners.
- Authorities’ strategy on credit quality:
  - All banks required to reach a provisioning ratio of 70 percent by 2009, up from 46.4 percent at end-2005; progress to be monitored semiannually.
  - Banks prohibited from distributing dividends until they meet the provisioning target.
  - Mission recommendation: set a more ambitious target of reducing NPLs to no more than 10 percent of total loans by 2009; banks unable to attain targets should undergo recapitalization.
- Governance and transparency improvements:
  - Revised banking law (promulgated early May 2006) mandates establishment of stronger credit committees accountable to bank boards.
  - New 2005 law imposes additional requirements on external auditors, strengthens publication obligations, and requires companies above a given size to establish audit committees.
- Loan workout and NPL reduction challenges:
  - Need improved procedures for loan workouts and partial write-offs, with safeguards to limit moral hazard.
  - Banks have relied heavily on real estate collateral; low share of NPLs subject to judicial recovery procedures indicates forbearance.
  - Recommendations include more effective judicial system, recourse to extra-judicial procedures, more favorable tax treatment of partial write-offs (currently not tax-deductible), and better collateral registration and realization (address delays in registration of real estate titles and mortgages, and in real estate transfers).
- Management of government-controlled banks:
  - Mission recommends strengthening management of the three remaining government-controlled commercial banks and making them accountable for precise targets, particularly NPL reduction.
- Stress tests and vulnerabilities:
  - Credit risk identified as the most important vulnerability.
  - Stress tests confirm vulnerability to a sharp fall in real estate collateral values; several shocks could reduce the banking system CAR below the required minimum of 8 percent, although not generating a systemic threat.
  - System not exposed to direct interest rate risk, but real interest rate fluctuations could adversely affect credit portfolio quality.
  - Foreign exchange and liquidity risks are negligible.
- Nonbank financing and market development:
  - Authorities promote equity financing for SMEs via fiscal incentives to private venture and equity capital funds; assets remain modest relative to banking resources.
  - Stock market capitalization approximately 9 percent of GDP in 2004; new issues TD 204 million in 2004 (equivalent to 0.8 percent of GDP and 3.7 percent of private investment).
  - Leasing activity expanded: assets rose by one half in 2000–04; new leasing operations TD 500 million in 2004 (equivalent to 11 percent of total private investment).

### Key recommendations (FSAP Update)
- Banking sector
  - Strengthen capital base of banks by rigorous implementation of the authorities’ target to reach 70 percent provisioning for all NPLs, without consideration of existing collateral.
  - Reduce by 2009 the ratio of NPLs to total loans to no more than 10 percent of loans through proactive loan restructuring, including partial write-offs, with safeguards to avoid moral hazard.
  - Accelerate restructuring of bank loans to the tourism sector, based on realistic assessments of borrowers’ debt repayment capacity.
  - Strengthen management of public commercial banks to ensure full independence of management, tighter risk management procedures, and improved estimates of NPLs recovery prospects.
  - Establish program contracts with management of public commercial banks including quantitative operational targets.
  - Stand ready to recapitalize public commercial banks if operating income is not sufficient to reach the 70 percent provisioning target for NPLs.
  - Improve information system for lending to SMEs and households by promoting establishment of private credit bureaus.
- Prudential supervision and regulation
  - Ensure rapid implementation of new rules on credit risk management envisaged by a draft new central bank circular on internal controls.
  - Establish prudential ratios on a consolidated basis.
- Central bank policy and systemic liquidity management
  - Deepen interbank markets by widening the central bank narrow interest rate corridor.
  - Relax restrictions on forward foreign exchange cover for commercial operators.
  - Implement decision to end requirement for banks to transfer end-of-day foreign exchange balances to the central bank.
- Corporate debt restructuring
  - Promote extra-judicial procedures for debt workouts, with preset rules for creditors and debtors to speed agreements.
  - Review preferred creditor status of tax authorities and social security agency claims.

### Macroeconomic context and financial environment
- Growth and macro indicators
  - Real GDP grew on average by 5 percent per year in 2000–05.
  - Inflation declined to 2 percent in 2005.
  - Overall fiscal deficit remained stable at about 3 percent of GDP.
  - External reserves rose to the equivalent of four months of imports.
  - External debt-to-GDP ratio broadly stable.
- 2002 tourism shock and effects
  - Sharp growth slowdown to 1.7 percent in 2002 following September 11, 2001 events and 2002 Djerba bombing.
  - Tourist hotel occupancy declined 22 percent in 2002 and a further 2 percent in 2003.
  - Contributed to NPL spike from 19.2 percent of total loans at end-2001 to 24 percent at end-2003; NPLs then 23.7 percent in 2004 and 20.9 percent at end-2005.
- Bank credit and financial deepening
  - Bank credit to nongovernment sector decelerated since end-2000; ratio of bank credit to nongovernment sector 67 percent at end-2005.
  - Managed float exchange regime with reduced central bank intervention has produced trend real depreciation.
- Capital account liberalization measures (selected)
  - Since July 2004 purchases by nonresidents of treasury bills permitted within a limit of 5 percent of each issue.
  - Purchase by foreign nationals of shares in Tunisian companies fully liberalized in March 2005.
  - Since January 2005 banks free to borrow abroad at maturities longer than 12 months; companies with ratings also allowed to borrow abroad.
  - Outbound portfolio investment by residents remains subject to restrictions; accumulation of assets abroad by residents is subject to authorization.
  - Further capital account liberalization to be predicated on strengthening banking and financial system and moving to a floating exchange rate.

### Banking sector risks, vulnerabilities, and challenges
- Recent FSIs and sectoral trends
  - After improvements in the 1990s, key FSIs deteriorated in 2001–03, notably higher NPLs.
  - NPLs: 19.2 percent at end-2001, 24 percent at end-2003.
  - Loans to tourism accounted for one quarter of NPL increase in 2001–03; industry accounted for 35 percent of the total NPL increase.
  - Risk-weighted regulatory capital adequacy ratio declined from 11.1 percent to 9.9 percent between 2001 and 2003.
- Supervision and standards
  - Assessment of observance of the Basel Core Principles shows marked improvement in compliance compared with 2002, reflecting improved licensing regulation, tighter investment criteria, better information sharing, improved accounting standards, and introduction of consolidated supervision.
  - AML/CFT: important directives on suspicious transaction reports issued in April 2006; additional steps needed to implement an effective AML/CFT system.
- Liquidity and market development
  - Mission highlighted importance of deeper money market by allowing wider fluctuations of money market rates (currently maintained in a very narrow band).
  - Development of foreign exchange market recommended, including eliminating restrictions on forward operations and permitting foreign exchange options.

_This summary is based exclusively on the content of “1. Implementation of Tunisia 2002 FSAP Recommendations.................................................20” from the provided IMF PDF chapter._

### 22.      Financial soundness indicators started improving in the second half of 2004, and

### 22.      Financial soundness indicators started improving in the second half of 2004, and

### Financial soundness developments
- Aggregate CAR rose to 10.7 percent at end-2005.
- NPL ratio declined by 2.8 percentage points to 20.9 percent at end-2005.
- Provisioning ratio for the whole system was 46 percent at end-2005, up from 43 percent at end-2003.

### Bank structure and intergroup differences
- Commercial banks (excluding development banks that received universal banking licenses in 2005): 13 banks.
  - 10 under private ownership.
  - 3 under government majority ownership (public banks).
- At end-2005, public banks’ assets account for 44.5 percent of total commercial bank assets.
- NPL ratios at end-2005:
  - Public banks (group): 22.1 percent.
  - Private banks (group): 20 percent.
  - Private banks individual range: 7 percent to 24 percent.
  - Public banks individual range: 10 percent to 32 percent.
- CAR ratios and rates of return on equity and on assets are not very different between public and private groups on average, but intragroup variations are significant.
- Two private banks undergoing recapitalization lowered aggregate private-bank indicators.

### Provisioning, targets, and fiscal/tax measures
- Authorities set a provisioning target of 70 percent by 2009.
- Tax measures to support provisioning:
  - Tax deductibility of provisions raised to 85 percent in 2004.
  - Tax deductibility of provisions raised to 100 percent in 2005.
- Dividend distributions were prohibited in 2005 and in 2006 to boost provisioning.
- Several private banks, accounting for 17 percent of total assets of the system, have already reached the 70 percent provisioning target (partly via recent capital injections).
- Government does not plan additional capital injections in public banks; their ability to attain the 70 percent provisioning target by 2009 remains in doubt.

### Profitability and income trends
- Public banks: net income before provisions has eroded since 2000, reflecting higher NPLs and flat non-interest income; provisions increased by about half, causing sharp drops in ROA and ROE since 2000.
- Private banks: net income before provisions more than doubled between 2000 and 2005 due to rises in both interest- and non-interest income; private banks more than doubled provisions.

### Policy measures and legal/administrative reforms
- Since 2001, measures to strengthen credit culture and financial transparency include:
  - Tightened rules on investments and bank licensing, increased minimum capital requirement, external auditor reports and certified financial statements on large borrowers, and tighter exposure limits (2001 banking law revision).
  - 2006 revised banking law (promulgated in early May 2006) requires banks to establish an executive credit committee reporting to the board and to put in place a compliance control system under board supervision.
  - 2005 law on financial transparency introduced: external auditors for stock corporations and companies above a balance sheet threshold (term limit three years); tighter information obligations for companies raising funds from the public; auditors must transmit reports to the central bank under specified conditions; two external auditors required for certain consolidated accounts; permanent internal audit committees for listed companies and large unlisted companies.
  - Creditor rights strengthened via 2003 revision of the 1995 law on companies restructuring and revision in the civil procedure code to facilitate auctioning of real estate collateral.
  - Banking system restructuring: full privatization in 2002 and 2005 of two banks; transformation of five development banks into universal banks (one under privatization).
- Mission recommendations (policy emphasis):
  - Complement increased provisioning target with a more aggressive policy to reduce NPLs to no more than 10 percent of loans by 2009, including partial write-offs and well-designed loan restructuring.
  - Target NPL restructuring priority in the tourism sector where implementation is easier.
  - Central bank to closely monitor loan recovery and restructuring; improve judicial, legal, and tax environment to support restructuring.
  - Use extrajudicial procedures and voluntary workout processes, with rules to facilitate agreements between creditors and debtors (standstill periods, qualified majority agreements, provisions for haircuts and equity dilution).
  - Require dilution of debtors’ control over assets when debt restructuring or write-offs occur to avoid moral hazard.
  - Improve judicial procedures under the 1995 enterprise restructuring law for prompt initiation and limit debtor delaying tactics; increase role of commercial courts in settling disputes.
  - Reexamine preferred creditor position of tax and social securities authorities to encourage their forgoing part of claims in conjunction with other creditors’ write-offs.
  - Make partial write-offs tax deductible and speed up write-off process for fully provisioned loans by eliminating barriers to tax neutrality.
  - Enhance credit risk management in banks as household lending rises; establish a credit bureau for households and SMEs.

### Lending to households
- Bank lending to households: 17 percent of total loans (still low but increased rapidly since 2002).
- Anticipated faster growth in household loans necessitates improved credit risk management and a specialized credit bureau for households and small-and medium-scale enterprises.

### Stress tests — methodology and coverage
- Stress tests conducted on the largest 10 commercial banks in Tunisia (both private and state-owned, excluding former development banks), accounting for more than 90 percent of total assets of the entire banking system.
- Tests based on end-2005 balance sheet data.
- Tests examine large, low-probability shocks across foreign exchange, liquidity, interest rate, real estate collateral, and credit risk; securities are “marked-to-market.”

### Stress test findings — market and liquidity risks
- Foreign currency exposure: net open position below 1 percent of capital.
- Foreign exchange lending below 3 percent of total.
- Limited contagion risk due to a small interbank market.
- Interest rate sensitivity limited because most credits and interest-bearing deposits are indexed to the money market rate.
- An interest rate increase of about 200 basis points would cause a fall in the CAR by less than one percentage point from the end-2005 level of 10.5 percent for the sample of banks tested.
  - Exception: for two banks with large government bond portfolios, one bank suffers a fall in CAR of 3.8 percentage points.
- Interest rate increases could also reduce solvency of some creditors and the value of real estate collateral, adversely affecting system health.

### Stress test findings — real estate collateral and credit risk
- Assumed a 50 percent decline in real estate collateral (generalized shock) reduces system CAR to 7.3 percent; for some banks CAR falls as low as 4.6 percent.
- Credit risk severe-shock scenario: migration of 8 percent of performing loans to NPL loss category (past due over 360 days) decreases system CAR to 5.5 percent.
- Simultaneous 50 percent haircut on real estate collateral with the 8 percent migration reduces CAR to 1.9 percent.
- Sectoral migration scenarios (based on 2001–03 experience) involve:
  - Migration of either 16 percent of performing loans to tourism, or 6 percent to industry, or 4 percent to real estate into the NPL loss category.
  - Without a 50 percent collateral cut, these shocks reduce CAR to a range of 9.3 to 10 percent.
  - With a simultaneous 50 percent collateral cut, CAR declines to a range between 6 and 6.8 percent.
- Stress tests show high heterogeneity across banks:
  - Some banks retain solvency ratio of 8 percent or higher even under most severe shocks.
  - Others fall below the 8 percent minimum capital requirement; some become insolvent (negative CAR).
  - On average, state-owned banks fare worse than private banks, by a limited margin.
  - Two private banks in recapitalization start with low capital, pulling down private-bank averages.

### Scenario analysis and fiscal implication
- Combined scenario tested: 200 basis points shock on the money market rate, 4 percent migration of performing loans to loss category, and 50 percent decline in value of collateral.
  - Under this scenario, CAR drops to 3.9 percent.
  - To restore CAR to the minimum requirement of 8 percent, the system would require recapitalization equivalent to 2.2 percent of GDP, corresponding to one third of its current capital base.

### Bank regulation and supervision update
- Quality of supervision and regulation improved since the 2002 FSAP; progress in BCP implementation (Annex referenced for summary).
- Key improvements:
  - Requirement for commercial borrowers to submit audited financial statements when bank indebtedness exceeds a threshold.
  - New rules on banks’ equity participation.
  - Enhanced central bank monitoring of credit risk and improved inspectors’ training.
  - Significant role of external auditors in supervisory system; auditors must submit reports to the central bank and attend periodic meetings.
- Further improvements needed:
  - Strengthen banks’ credit policy, close monitoring of doubtful credits, and loan recovery.
  - Provisioning should reflect actual prospects of doubtful loan recovery and time dimension, in line with international accounting standards.
  - Draft new central bank circular (expected shortly) to require tighter internal control mechanisms: borrower ratings, quarterly exposure monitoring, stress tests, and executive credit committee implementation per 2006 revised banking law; FSAP mission recommends prompt implementation.
  - Improve regulations on connected lending and investment; equity participations from loan restructuring should require central bank authorization when exceeding 30 percent of capital of beneficiary company.
  - Consolidated supervision progress modest despite 2003 accounting law reform; need to monitor prudential ratios on a consolidated basis and strengthen relations with other financial sector supervisors.
  - Closely monitor NPLs transferred to fully-owned asset management companies.

### Public banks
- Authorities view banking system structure as broadly appropriate after privatization of two majority government-owned banks in 2002–05; privatization of remaining three government-majority commercial banks is not envisaged.
- The three remaining government-majority banks:
  - One specialized in mortgage lending (Banque de l’Habitat).
  - One is the key lender to the agricultural sector (Banque de l’Agriculture).
  - One has a diversified portfolio with large exposure to tourism (Société Tunisienne des Banques, the largest bank in the country).

*IMF staff report content (extracted from the specified chapter).*

### 49.      The recent trends of gross income and income before provisioning of public

### _cr06448 - 49.      The recent trends of gross income and income before provisioning of public

### Public banks: recent income trends and governance recommendations
- Finding: "The recent trends of gross income and income before provisioning of public banks is less favorable than for private banks."
- Finding: "Their cost-income ratio is also higher."
- Policy recommendations:
  - Strengthen management of the three banks by ensuring that the board of directors is completely independent from external influences.
  - Make management accountable for the attainment of precise operational targets, in particular regarding loan recovery and NPL reduction.
  - "Provided adequate progress is achieved over the next 24 months on the basis of a number of indicators, the government should stand ready to recapitalize these banks, if operating income is not sufficient to strengthen the provisioning of NPLs."

### Former development banks
- Background: "The five existing development banks received in 2004–05 universal banking licenses."
- Ownership: "Each of these institutions is jointly owned by the Tunisian government and the governments of four Gulf States and Libya."
- Financial structure: "They carry a very high capital-asset ratio, with their equity base being the main source of funding."
- Business model: Historically specialized in medium- and long-term financing; "their equity investment represents a larger share of assets than for commercial banks."
- Government strategy and mission advice:
  - Government strategy: "to promote their privatization, which could be followed by mergers with commercial banks."
  - Mission encouragement: "to speed up this process, in order to establish stronger institutions."

### Capital markets
- Finding: Mixed results in recent years.
  - "New issues on the stock exchange have been modest, and the capitalization of the stock exchange has not increased in recent years, remaining at 9 percent of GDP."
  - Some family-owned enterprises remain reluctant to list, despite the "2005 law on financial transparency" reducing information and certification differences between listed and unlisted companies.
- Mutual funds and venture capital:
  - "Mutual fund resources have expanded at an average annual rate of 9 percent in 2000–04."
  - "At end-2004, 40 percent of their assets were invested in government bonds and 24 percent in bonds and shares of private companies, with the remainder placed in liquid assets."
  - SICARs (venture capital funds): increase of 50 percent in entities from 2000 to 2004; assets "threefold increase in 2000–04 up to the equivalent of 1.6 percent of GDP."
- Bond market developments:
  - Secondary market transactions increased but remain modest.
  - A yield curve for government paper "has been recently established" by the CMF; recommendation: "It would be beneficial to disclose this yield curve more widely to financial market participants."
  - Efforts to establish a similar curve for private bonds to facilitate issuance of private debt paper indexed to benchmarks.
  - Public debt directorate has made progress by reopening existing bond issues and increasing the size of issues to create benchmark issues.
- Leasing: "developed in a successful manner, with a 50 percent increase in assets between 2000 and 2004," and leasing companies are among main private bond issuers; effective for SME financing.
- Capital inflows: "Inflows of foreign capital for purchases of Tunisian shares were liberalized in early 2005, but purchases of nonresidents have been limited so far."

### Regulation and supervision of insurance companies
- 2002 FSAP finding: "supervision of insurance companies was inadequate."
  - State-owned and mutual companies were "under-capitalized and under-reserved"; large private companies maintained adequate capital and reserves.
  - "The insurance regulatory statute also exhibited significant weaknesses, and supervisory resources were insufficient."
- Reforms implemented:
  - 2002 overhaul of the insurance regulatory statute with prudential norms aligned with international practices (solvency requirements and minimum capital).
  - Supervisory agency reorganized and resources for off-site and on-site inspections significantly strengthened.
  - Tax measures to promote life insurance: "tax deductibility of premia paid by employees and employers was introduced in 2002, and annuity income became tax exempt from 2004."
- Further actions and issues (early 2006):
  - Revisions submitted to parliament involving tighter companies’ governance rules.
  - Regulatory/supervisory enhancements include:
    - "(i) the supervision of life insurance contracts with guaranteed minimum returns, which are creating risks for companies given the interest rates decline; and (ii) the review of life insurance premia, which have to be updated on the basis of new mortality tables under preparation."
  - Capital strengthening: "The opening of the capital of the largest state-owned company to a strategic investor is under way." Private companies also strengthening capital via strategic partners; recommendation: accelerate outside injections to place operating companies on a sound financial basis.

### Payments system
- Real time gross settlement system: "is now in the last phase of testing. The system will become operational in a few months."
- System meets best practice requirements, including settlement finality, fully collateralized intraday central bank advances, and optimization procedures for queues.

### Liquidity management
- Central bank progress: "The BCT has achieved significant progress in terms of liquidity management."
  - Improvements in forecasts of autonomous liquidity factors and increased recourse to open market operations.
  - Efforts to strengthen the interbank market: BCT refrained from providing liquidity through weekly credit auctions on several occasions in 2005 to encourage interbank market usage.
  - "The monthly average volume of transactions on the interbank market tripled between 2002 and 2005, although it remains modest when scaled against monetary aggregates."
- Recommendations to further strengthen interbank market:
  - "Widen the very narrow money market interest rate band currently maintained by central bank interventions" to increase incentives for commercial banks to manage liquidity more effectively.
  - Limit BCT presence in markets to weekly credit auctions and open market operations, with much less recourse to fine-tuning operations.
  - Prepare banks for potentially larger exchange rate fluctuations in the context of further exchange and capital account liberalization.
- Foreign exchange market:
  - "The foreign exchange interbank market has deepened considerably in recent years, as the transactions’ volume increased by 46 percent between 2002 and 2005."
  - Forward market transactions increased, enabling hedging.
  - Recommendations:
    - Relax some restrictions which currently limit how companies can obtain forward cover.
    - Allow banks to sell foreign exchange options to their customers to widen hedging instruments.
  - Recommendation: "The decision to proceed to a full repeal of the current requirement that banks transfer end-of-day foreign exchange balances to the BCT should be rapidly implemented." This should be "accompanied by close monitoring of banks’ external positions to ensure that any exposure thereby incurred falls within prudential norms."

### AML/CFT
- Progress: Tunisia ratified recent relevant international and regional instruments and "adopted in December 2003 a comprehensive AML-CFT Law, which goes a long way toward meeting international standards."
- Strengths: Criminalization of money laundering and the financing of terrorism "are generally in line with current international standards."
- Key remaining weaknesses:
  - Legal basis for freezing funds in accordance with United Nations Security Council Resolution 1267 and 1373.
  - Inability of financial and insurance sector supervisors to engage in international cooperation.
  - Requirements for identification of beneficial owners.
  - Ambiguities in the suspicious transaction report (STR) system and in the coverage of the designated Non-Financial Businesses and Professions (DNFBPs).
- Recommendation: "The Tunisian authorities should quickly address these weaknesses, particularly those related to their UN-related obligations and to the STR system, as these are central to an effective AML-CFT system."

*IMF staff report content as provided in the source PDF.*

### 66.      Overall, the implementation of the AML/CFT Law is still at an initial phase. The

### _cr06448 - 66.      Overall, the implementation of the AML/CFT Law is still at an initial phase. The

### AML/CFT implementation — findings
- Overall, the implementation of the AML/CFT Law is still at an initial phase.
- The prosecutorial authorities have begun using the CFT component of the law, but on a limited basis.
- A Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) has been formally set up within the BCT.
- Only a handful of STRs have been filed with the FIU in more than two years.
- The key challenge going forward lies in implementation and enforcement, in particular through a more active supervision of compliance of the financial sector with their AML-CFT requirements.

### Regulatory steps taken
- The FIU adopted two directives in April 2006:
  - Directive 1: deals with the STR template.
  - Directive 2: details requirements on due diligence, internal controls, and suspicious transactions reporting obligations for credit institutions, off-shore banks and the Postal Office.
- The second directive needs to be complemented in the short term by circulars to be issued by the central bank.

### Analysis and identified gaps
- Limited use of the CFT component by prosecutorial authorities indicates early-stage enforcement.
- Low STR filing activity with the FIU (only a handful in more than two years) suggests weak reporting/compliance by reporting entities and/or operational issues within the FIU.
- Supervision of financial sector compliance with AML-CFT requirements is insufficiently active.
- Directives are a welcome step but are incomplete without central bank circulars to operationalize supervisory expectations.

### Policy recommendations (explicitly stated or implied)
- Lay out a criminal policy on the fight against money-laundering, based on a more comprehensive risk-assessment and analysis of criminal patterns in the country.
- Enhance implementation and enforcement of the AML/CFT Law through:
  - More active supervision of compliance of the financial sector with their AML-CFT requirements.
  - Issuance of central bank circulars in the short term to complement FIU directives (April 2006) and clarify supervisory expectations and operational procedures.
- Improve STR reporting to the FIU (address reporting entities’ incentives, awareness, and reporting systems).

### Selected FSAP Update recommendations (key items and timeframes preserved verbatim)
- Ensure rigorous implementation of the authorities’ target of  70 percent provisioning for all NPLs, without regard of existing collateral. MT
- Reduce by 2009 the ratio of NPLs to total loans to no more than 10 percent of loans through a proactive policy of loan restructuring, including partial write-offs, accompanied by safeguards against moral hazard. MT
- Accelerate restructuring of bank loans to the tourism sector, on the basis of a realistic assessment of debt repayment capacity of borrowers. ST
- Ensure that partial write-offs benefit of tax deductibility. ST
- Promote extrajudicial procedures for bank debt restructuring. ST
- Strengthen management of public commercial banks, ensuring full independence of management, tighter risk management procedures, and improved estimate of NPLs recovery prospects. ST
- Establish program contracts with management of public commercial banks with quantitative operational targets. ST
- Stand ready to recapitalize public commercial banks if operating income is not sufficient to reach the 70 percent provisioning targets for NPLs. MT
- Maintain prohibition of dividend distribution for banks which have inadequate NPL provisioning. ST
- Speed-up privatization and mergers of former development banks that have recently received universal banking licenses. ST
- Improve information system for lending to SMEs and households by promoting establishment of private credit bureaus. ST

### Central bank, prudential, and market recommendations (selected)
- Ensure implementation of new rules on management of credit risk, envisaged by draft new central bank circular on internal controls. ST
- Assess the quality of banks internal audit functions. MT
- Establish prudential ratios on a consolidated basis. ST
- Enter in information sharing agreements with other Tunisian financial supervisors and foreign supervisors. ST
- Tighten regulations regarding equity investments, and strengthen enforcement. ST
- Revisit the disciplinary sanction regimes by vesting the power to impose sanctions in the Banking Commission envisaged in the banking law, rather than in the governor of the central bank, to promote transparency. ST
- Disclose more clearly in the BCT publications the monetary framework in terms of ultimate, intermediate and operational objectives. ST
- Deepen interbank markets by allowing wider money market rates fluctuations. ST
- Publicize more widely newly established bond yield curve. ST
- Repeal the current requirement for banks to transfer end-of-day-foreign exchange balances to the central bank. ST
- Relax restrictions on forward foreign exchange cover for commercial operators. ST

*Source: IMF staff assessment and tables contained in the provided content unit.*

### 67.      This assessment of the BCT’s compliance with the Basel Committee’s Core

### This assessment of the BCT’s compliance with the Basel Committee’s Core Principles for Effective Banking Supervision (BCP)

### Assessment scope and methodology
- Assessment dates: January 16-31 and March 27-31, 2006.
- Assessment team: Jean-Luc Couetoux (external consultant, French Banking Commission) and Didier Debals (World Bank, formerly with the French Banking Commission).
- Basis of assessment:
  - Review of relevant laws, regulations, standards of best practices and other guidelines related to the financial sector.
  - Discussions with BCT and other relevant authorities and stakeholders including commercial banks, the bankers association, and the accounting and auditing profession.
  - Use of the assessment methodology prescribed in the Core Principles Methodology published by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision.
- Cooperation: The BCP team received full cooperation from the Tunisian authorities and the private sector.

### Institutional, market structure, and preconditions
- Legal and institutional framework:
  - BCT’s supervisory mandate specified in Law 58-90 creating and organizing the BCT and Law 2001-65 on credit institutions, further modified in 2006.
  - Directorate General for Banking Supervision (DGSB) is responsible for supervision of credit institutions within the BCT.
  - BCT is an autonomous agency with a high degree of financial independence; governor reports to the president of the Republic.
  - Ministry of Finance issues banking licenses on the basis of a report prepared by the BCT.
  - Banking Commission is a disciplinary authority; lower penalties are within the power of the BCT governor.
- Financial system structure and scale:
  - Total financial system assets: 125 percent of GDP.
  - Banking system accounts for 70 percent of financial system assets.
  - Market participants:
    - 13 commercial banks, of which three are majority government-owned.
    - 5 former development banks (joint ventures between the government and several Gulf states and Libya; all former development banks received universal banking licenses in 2004-05).
    - 8 off-shore banks.
    - 1 public micro-finance institution.
    - 1 public bank specialized in lending to small- and medium-scale enterprises.
    - 11 leasing companies.
    - 3 factoring companies.
  - Nonbank financial institutions: postal saving and checking agency, insurance companies, collective investment companies, and investment companies.
- General preconditions:
  - Most pre-conditions for effective banking supervision exist, including a stable macroeconomic environment and generally well-developed public infrastructure.
  - Weaknesses: delays in judicial procedures, lack of effective out-of-court settlement mechanisms, delays in registration of real estate and mortgages.
  - External auditors’ role strengthened; 2005 law requires banks to have two auditors.
  - BCT has established information bureaus on companies’ financial statements, payment incidents, and indebtedness; no credit bureau specialized in assigning ratings to single counterparties yet established.

### Main findings by Core Principle groups
- Overall progress:
  - Important progress in updating regulatory and supervisory framework over the past four years.
  - Upgrades in ratings for: CP1.4 (enforcement powers), CP1.6 (information sharing), CP3 (licensing criteria), CP5 (investment criteria), CP20 (consolidated supervision), and CP21 (accounting standards).
  - CP7 and CP8 compliance contingent on issuance of BCT draft circular on internal controls following promulgation of revised banking law in early May 2006.
  - Remaining obstacles: notably in consolidated supervision.

- Objectives, Autonomy, Powers, and Resources (CP 1)
  - Objectives for bank supervision clearly defined in relevant laws.
  - BCT management and staff: good qualifications, knowledgeable, receive regular training.
  - Staff protection from liability provided by central bank regulation; advisable to include this protection in law.
  - BCT has sufficient resources, but independence could be enhanced by specifying grounds for removal from office of its governing body.
  - Formal information sharing agreements will be authorized only by revision of central bank law now in parliament.

- Licensing and Structure (CPs 2–5)
  - Financial institutions licensed for banking activities and subject to supervision clearly defined.
  - Licensing criteria described in banking law and considered adequate.
  - BCT authority to review and reject transfers of significant ownership or controlling interest; 2001 modification defines notification thresholds.
  - BCT has criteria for review of major acquisitions and clear assessment criteria for authorization and waivers.
  - Recommendation: establish a cumulative ceiling for investments by credit institutions, in addition to individual ceilings.

- Prudential Regulations and Requirements (CPs 6–15)
  - Banking law and prudential regulations establish minimum capital requirement and a capital adequacy ratio, with actions/sanctions tied to capital shortfalls.
  - Recommendation: capital adequacy ratio should be calculated on a consolidated basis.
  - No regulatory provision specifically addressing credit risk management by credit institutions; gap to be addressed by draft circular on internal controls to be issued shortly following 2006 banking law.
  - Loan classification rules are in line with best practices (CP8); loan loss provisioning remains weak.
  - Provisioning target communicated to banks: raise provisioning to 70 percent of NPLs by 2009.
  - Banks with weak provisioning prohibited from paying dividends in 2005 and 2006.
  - Need to strengthen surveillance of doubtful loans and recovery of overdue loans.
  - Definition of large exposure (CP 9) should be based on consolidated exposure; to be implemented with draft circular on internal control.
  - Draft circular will also contain guidelines on market risks (CP 12).
  - To monitor other banking risks (CP 13): increase frequency of information technology audits during on-site inspections.
  - Guidelines on internal control systems (CP 14) to be strengthened with issuance of circular on internal controls.
  - 2006 banking law introduces requirement for banks to establish an executive loan committee responsible to the board and to introduce compliance control systems.
  - AML/CFT: legal provisions in 2003-75 law and related directives 2006-01 and 2006-02.

- Methods of Ongoing Supervision (CPs16–20)
  - Framework for on-site and off-site supervision is adequate.
  - Recommendations:
    - Procedures for on-site examinations should be laid down in a manual.
    - President of supervised institution should receive full inspection report, not only a summary of key results.
  - Weaknesses in consolidated supervision:
    - Banking groups required to compile consolidated accounts starting with 2004 accounts, but BCT lacks full resources for consolidated surveillance, including consolidated prudential norms (consolidated capital and overall exposure limits) and formalized information sharing agreements with other supervisors.
    - Revision in central bank law now in parliament will permit information sharing agreements.

- Information Requirement (CP 21)
  - Tunisia largely complies.
  - Reporting generally complies with IAS; Tunisian standard for NPLs does not take into account estimate of time needed for loan recovery.
  - External audits to be conducted according to International Auditing Practices; audits cover loan quality, loan loss identification and provisioning, asset valuation, trading activities, and internal controls.
  - External auditors have statutory duty to inform supervisory agency within a stated timeframe of matters of significant importance.

- Formal Powers of Supervisors (CP 22)
  - Banking law provides for sanctions, but penalties have never been applied formally.
  - Banking Commission has power to impose more severe sanctions, including revocation of license, but has never been convened.
  - Recommendations:
    - Confer all sanctioning powers to the Banking Commission to separate supervisory and sanctioning powers.
    - Governor of the BCT should have power to issue injunctions.
    - Establish a system of waivers for modest violations of regulatory limits.
    - Sanctions imposed should be publicized.

- Cross-Border Banking (CPs 23–25)
  - Tunisian banks have limited foreign activity.
  - Foreign banks in Tunisia subject to local prudential regulations.
  - Relations with foreign supervisory counterparts are informal because current central bank law does not allow information sharing agreements; revision of law in parliament will address this and support CP 25 compliance.

### Key statistics and legal references (preserved as in source)
- Assessment dates: January 16-31 and March 27-31, 2006.
- Financial system assets: 125 percent of GDP.
- Banking system share of financial system assets: 70 percent.
- Market structure counts and classifications:
  - 13 commercial banks (three majority government-owned).
  - 5 former development banks.
  - 8 off-shore banks.
  - 1 public micro-finance institution.
  - 1 public bank specialized in lending to small- and medium-scale enterprises.
  - 11 leasing companies.
  - 3 factoring companies.
- Legal instruments and directives cited:
  - Law 58-90 creating and organizing the BCT.
  - Law 2001-65 on credit institutions (modified in 2006).
  - 2005 law on financial security (requires two auditors).
  - 2006 banking law (promulgated in early May 2006).
  - 2003-75 law on AML/CFT; directives 2006-01 and 2006-02.
- Provisioning target: 70 percent of NPLs by 2009.
- Dividend prohibitions: banks with weak provisioning prohibited from paying dividends in 2005 and 2006.

### Recommended Action Plan (condensed from Table 9)
- CP 5: Establish a cumulative ceiling for investments by credit institutions, in addition to individual ceilings.
- CP 6: Introduce consolidated prudential solvency ratios.
- CP 7: Address gaps in credit risk management guidelines by issuing draft circular on internal controls following promulgation of revised banking law.
- CP 8: Banks should strengthen surveillance of doubtful loans and recovery of overdue loans; BCT should ensure compliance with off-balance sheet exposure provisioning; provisioning should account for actual recovery prospects and time factor.
- CP 13: Increase frequency of inspections of information systems and highlight areas needing improvement.
- CP 14: Ensure all institutions apply new rules following issuance of circular on internal controls.
- CP 16: After each examination, the president of the institution should receive the full inspection report, not only a summary.
- CP 20: Establish consolidated ratios and conclude information sharing agreements with other financial sector supervisors.
- CP 21: Explicitly account for time needed for loan recovery in valuation of NPLs.
- CP 22: Strengthen sanctioning system by applying formal sanctions when needed; establish system of waivers; install Banking Commission on a permanent basis; publicize sanctions imposed each year.

### Authorities’ response
- BCT broadly agreed with the assessments and recommendations and expressed appreciation for the assessment team’s work.
- BCT noted:
  - On CP 7 (Credit Policy): implementation of the circular on internal control to be issued shortly will cover current regulatory gaps in credit decisions and monitoring procedures.
  - On CP 20 (consolidated supervision): measures are being taken to strengthen consolidated supervision; draft revised central bank law in parliament will authorize the central bank to enter into information sharing agreements with other domestic and foreign financial supervisors, facilitating effective consolidated supervision and compliance with CP 25.
- BCT did not agree with recommendations to:
  - Transform the Banking Commission into a permanent body, noting it can be convened rapidly when needed.
  - Devolve all sanctioning powers to the Commission; they consider the current split of sanctioning powers between the Governor and the Commission appropriate.

*Assessment prepared as part of the joint IMF/World Bank FSAP Update (assessment dates: January 16-31 and March 27-31, 2006).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2006/_cr06448.pdf_
