## _cr07133

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr07133](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07133.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07133.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07133.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction
- Mission contacts: first deputy prime minister; ministers of economy and trade; governor of the Central Bank of Uzbekistan (CBU); other senior government officials; parliamentarians; representatives of banking and diplomatic communities.
- Mission team: Mmes. Eken (head), Bacalu (both MCD), Vera Martin (PDR); Mr. Saker (MCM); assisted by Ms. Kostina (IMF office in Tashkent). Mr. Moser, Executive Director, participated in policy meetings.
- Uzbekistan accepted the obligations of Article VIII, Sections 2(a), 3, and 4 as of October 15, 2003.
- De facto exchange rate regime: conventional peg.
- Main policy discussion areas: reducing inflation; developing the banking sector; liberalizing foreign trade.

### Recent economic developments
- Growth and external position
  - GDP growth (official): just over 7 percent in 2005–06.
  - Current account: large surpluses in 2006; surplus likely overstated given large negative errors and omissions.
  - Official reserves: increased steadily to 12 months of import cover at end-2006.
- Inflation and monetary developments
  - Inflation: picked up in 2005 and remained high in 2006.
  - Monetary policy: accommodative in 2005; tightened in 2006 via increased deposits from banks, resumption of central bank paper issuance, and accumulation of government deposits including through the Fund for Reconstruction and Development (FRD).
  - Result: growth of monetary aggregates decelerated in 2006.
- Exchange rate and intervention
  - Sum de facto pegged to the U.S. dollar during second half of 2006, stable within a two percent band since mid-2006.
  - CBU interventions were one-sided and led to steady reserve accumulation.
- Fiscal performance and structural reforms
  - 2005 consolidated budget: surplus of 1.3 percent of GDP (authorities reported a small deficit versus budgeted deficit of over 3 percent of GDP; statistical discrepancy over 1½ percent of GDP partly reflects off-budget deposits).
  - 2006 consolidated balance: estimated small surplus; overall fiscal surplus including the FRD estimated at 3.1 percent of GDP.
  - Recent fiscal policy: two consecutive 20 percent rises in public sector wages and pensions and an additional 30 percent wage increase in health and education, largely offset by lower capital expenditures.
  - Structural reforms: tax and treasury reforms; licensing, inspections, and reporting streamlined; restructuring of agricultural enterprises into private farms mostly completed; eased restrictions on banks’ correspondent accounts and cash withdrawals; real time gross settlement system introduced. Privatization stalled; low FDI inflows; underdeveloped banking system.

### Economic outlook and projections
- Short-term projections and authorities’ targets
  - Authorities project GDP growth to exceed 7½ percent in 2007.
  - Current account surplus projected to remain very large; official reserves expected to continue to increase.
  - Authorities target a decline in inflation in 2007 via further monetary tightening and cautious fiscal policy.
- Medium-term objectives (WISP) and staff view
  - WISP envisages annual growth of 8–8½ percent by the end of the decade; private sector share rising to 55 percent of GDP by 2010 from about 40 percent in 2006; poverty level declining 50 percent by 2015.
  - Staff view: these objectives conditional on substantial trade liberalization, pickup in private sector credit, improved banking confidence, and better business environment; absent these, staff projects GDP growth to remain at about 7 percent.
  - Terms of trade assumption: During 2007–11, Uzbekistan’s terms of trade (TOT) will improve by 20 percent; a 10 percent decline in gold and cotton prices during the same period will narrow the annual current account surplus by about 1¼ percent of GDP on average.
- Debt sustainability: external and public debt should remain manageable under standard stress tests.

### Policy challenges — priorities and recommendations
- Overview: three priority areas — reducing inflation; reforming the banking system; liberalizing foreign trade.

- Policies to reduce inflation
  - Identified causes:
    - Rapid reserve accumulation and consequent monetary expansion.
    - Almost doubling of public sector wages and pensions in the past two years.
    - Administered price increases of 35 percent during the past two years.
  - Authorities’ 2007 monetary stance:
    - Limit reserve money growth to about 30 percent in 2007 by sterilizing excess liquidity using indirect monetary instruments and accumulating deposits in the FRD.
    - Keep the refinance rate at 14 percent (noted as not an effective instrument given weak transmission).
    - Expect continuation of declining velocity; allow small increase in credit to the private sector assuming strong balance of payments and stable cash-to-deposit ratio.
  - Exchange rate policy interaction and staff advice:
    - Staff recommends combining proactive monetary instruments with a flexible exchange rate policy; allow nominal appreciation by reducing official intervention to relieve pressure on indirect monetary instruments and create room for credit growth.
    - Evidence suggests the sum could be significantly undervalued; authorities target a small nominal depreciation in 2007 but are prepared to consider more flexibility.
    - Authorities report first-round pass-through of nominal appreciation to inflation of about 15 percent, but pass-through difficult to assess due to import restrictions.
  - Box — assessment of exchange rate level (key findings):
    - Current account surplus: nearly 20 percent of GDP in 2006.
    - Non-commodity exports growth in 2006: 43 percent; commodity export growth: 11 percent.
    - PPP approach suggests the REER is undervalued by about 30 percent compared with predicted level given Uzbekistan’s relative income.
    - Structural current account estimated at a surplus of about 4 percent of GDP, much lower than recent surpluses.

- Fiscal policy stance and medium-term implications
  - Overall government budget (including the FRD) projected surplus of 2.9 percent of GDP in 2007 despite tax reductions to promote private sector activity.
  - This implies fiscal loosening of 0.7 percent of GDP, though continued over-performance relative to the budget may not be reflected.
  - Given low public debt, lower inflation would provide room over the medium term for small fiscal deficits to finance higher social and infrastructure expenditures.
  - Authorities intend to continue tax reforms; strengthen fiscal management; and consolidate the FRD’s operations into fiscal reporting in 2007.
  - Staff encouragement: shift toward more capital expenditure by moderating increases in public sector salaries and pensions; introduce a multi-year budgetary framework; consolidate FRD under treasury control.

- Banking sector reform and vulnerabilities
  - Prudential ratios reported to exceed minimum standards; banks expanding in consumer lending, real estate, and SME financing; move to local currency and longer-term lending observed.
  - Official data indicate risk-weighted capital adequacy ratios well above minimum requirement; non-performing loans declining; solvency ratios robust to exchange rate shocks and a rise in NPLs.
  - Caveat: strength partly reflects large share of government-guaranteed loans (zero risk weight); government no longer issuing guarantees — banks must manage balance sheets conventionally; authorities increased minimum capital requirements.
  - Scenario: "A 55 percent appreciation of the sum against the dollar and a doubling of non-performing loans would bring the capital adequacy ratio close to the minimum level of 10 percent."
  - Financial intermediation constraints:
    - Monetization remains low; cash-in-circulation growth faster than deposits; credit growth low and credit-to-GDP ratio declining.
    - Confidence constraints: restrictions on cash withdrawals (reported by participants), obligation for enterprises to make daily deposits of cash receipts, and interference by local authorities.
  - Staff recommendations for banking sector:
    - Completely remove all remaining restrictions on cash withdrawals from banks.
    - Discontinue banks’ role in financial oversight and implementing non-core treasury activities.
    - Eliminate undue interference in banking activities.
    - Request an FSAP to help prioritize banking sector reforms.

- Trade liberalization
  - Regime characteristics: protective and complex, with barriers to shelter domestic production; import tariffs among highest in the region.
  - Selected tariff measures for 2005:
    - Uzbekistan: Simple average rate 14.8; Weighted average rate 16.6; Standard deviation 11.6; Maximum rate 30; Number of tariff bands 4.
    - Comparative simple average rates (2005): Azerbaijan 5.7; China 9.8; Kazakhstan 7.4; Kyrgyz Republic 5.0; Mongolia 4.5; Tajikistan 7.5.
  - Other trade-related distortions:
    - Direct and indirect taxes on imports; implicit tax from differentiated excise application; complex and time-consuming import process.
  - Economic consequences: distort resource allocation; reduce competition; contribute to difficult business environment; create opportunities for corruption; encourage smuggling.
  - Staff trade recommendations:
    - Move toward comprehensive trade liberalization to improve productivity and external trade potential.
    - Lower and unify tariffs; eliminate differences in excise taxes on imported and domestic goods; reduce costs related to international trade; streamline customs procedures; accelerate WTO accession.

- Statistics, convertibility, and data needs
  - Reported restrictions/delays in currency convertibility in H2 2006; authorities attributed delays to implementation of Anti-Money Laundering Law and expected automated information exchange system to eliminate delays by early 2007.
  - Data quality weaknesses:
    - Large differences among CPI, PPI, and GDP deflator.
    - National accounts valuation methods inadequate and inconsistent with external and fiscal data.
    - Large errors and omissions in balance of payments and fiscal accounts.
  - Staff strongly supports authorities’ request for technical assistance and recommends participation in the GDDS and publication of economic data.

### Staff appraisal — findings and prioritized recommendations
- Macroeconomic findings
  - Real GDP growth high; external current account surplus large; official reserves rising; inflation picked up in 2005 and started declining in 2006 but remains high.
  - Main macro challenge for 2007: reduce inflation further.
- Policy recommendations (summary)
  - Adopt a flexible exchange rate policy to alleviate pressure on indirect monetary instruments and create room for credit expansion to private sector; allow nominal appreciation of the exchange rate consistent with indications the sum is undervalued.
  - Maintain cautious fiscal stance in 2007 to support anti-inflation efforts; over the medium term lower inflation would allow room for moderate fiscal loosening to finance social and infrastructure spending.
  - Fiscal management: shift toward more capital expenditure by moderating large increases in public sector salaries and pensions; introduce a multi-year budgetary framework; consolidate FRD operations under treasury control.
  - Banking sector: promote financial deepening; remove restrictions on cash withdrawals; discontinue banks’ role in non-core functions; eliminate undue interference; request an FSAP.
  - Trade policy: lower and unify tariffs; eliminate excise tax differentials; streamline customs procedures; accelerate WTO accession.
  - Statistics: urgently strengthen price indices, national accounts, and balance of payments; request and receive Fund technical assistance; participate in the GDDS and publish data.

### Key macroeconomic aggregates and projections (selected)
- Nominal GDP (in sum, billions): 2003: 9,838; 2004: 12,261; 2005: 15,210; 2006 Est.: 19,616; 2007 Proj.: 23,952.
- Nominal GDP (in US$ million): 2003: 10,116; 2004: 11,941; 2005: 13,582; 2006 Est.: 16,044; 2007 Proj.: 18,776.
- GDP at constant prices (annual percentage change): 2003: 4.2; 2004: 7.7; 2005: 7.0; 2006: 7.2; 2007: 7.7.
- GDP deflator (percent): 2003: 26.7; 2004: 15.7; 2005: 15.9; 2006: 20.3; 2007: 13.4.
- Consumer price index (eop, official): 2003: 3.7; 2004: 3.8; 2005: 7.8; 2006: 7.0; 2007: 5.0-7.0 (range reported).
- Consumer price index (eop, alternative): 2003: 7.7; 2004: 15.5; 2005: 18.8; 2006: 15.2; 2007: 12.5.
- Average wage (sums per month, eop): 2003: 45,184; 2004: 73,528; 2005: 108,610.

### Selected monetary, external, and fiscal indicators (selected series and values as presented)
- Money and credit (annual percentage change)
  - Broad money: 2003: 27.1; 2004: 47.8; 2005: 54.3; 2006: 37.0; 2007: 30.0.
  - Net foreign assets: 2003: 45.6; 2004: 48.8; 2005: 44.0; 2006: 68.9; 2007: 37.5.
  - Net domestic assets: 2003: -87.8; 2004: -50.5; 2005: -28.4; 2006: -127.1; 2007: -45.6.
  - Credit to the economy: 2003: 6.9; 2004: 10.8; 2005: 15.8; 2006: 2.1; 2007: 2.6.
  - Income velocity of average broad money (level): 2003: 10.5; 2004: 9.5; 2005: 8.0; 2006: 7.2; 2007: 6.6.
- External sector (selected)
  - Exports of goods and services (US$ million): 2003: 3,775; 2004: 4,836; 2005: 5,416; 2006: 6,610; 2007: 7,612.
  - Imports of goods and services (US$ million): 2003: 3,097; 2004: 3,927; 2005: 4,101; 2006: 4,600; 2007: 5,321.
  - Current account (percent of GDP): 2003: 8.7; 2004: 10.2; 2005: 14.3; 2006: 19.5; 2007: 19.6.
  - Gross official reserves (US$ million): 2003: 1,659; 2004: 2,146; 2005: 2,895; 2006: 4,604; 2007: 6,104.
  - Gross official reserves (months of imports of GNFS): 2003: 6.4; 2004: 6.6; 2005: 8.5; 2006: 12.0; 2007: 13.8.
- Government finance (consolidated, selected)
  - Consolidated revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 2003: 33.4; 2004: 32.2; 2005: 32.2; 2006: 32.7; 2007: 31.7.
  - Consolidated expenditure and net lending (percent of GDP): 2003: 33.9; 2004: 32.1; 2005: 32.5; 2006: 32.6; 2007: 32.3.
  - Consolidated budget balance (percent of GDP): 2003: 0.1; 2004: 0.6; 2005: 1.3; 2006: 0.4; 2007: -0.6.
  - Augmented government balance (percent of GDP): 2003: 0.1; 2004: 0.6; 2005: 1.3; 2006: 3.6; 2007: 2.9.
  - Public debt (percent of GDP): 2003: 41.6; 2004: 35.1; 2005: 29.5; 2006: 22.6; 2007: 18.6.

### Public and external debt sustainability and stress tests (selected)
- Total external debt outstanding (percent of GDP): 2003: 42.0; 2004: 36.2; 2005: 30.4; 2006: 24.5; 2007: 20.6; projected decline to 9.6 by 2011 (baseline).
- External debt service ratio (percent of exports): 2003: 20.8; 2004: 17.1; 2005: 14.1; 2006: 11.3; 2007: 9.4.
- NPV of external debt (percent of GDP, projections): 2007: 24.1; 2008: 19.0; 2009: 15.7; 2010: 13.0; 2011: 10.6.
- Selected stress test note: Alternative scenario A1 reports external NPV debt-to-GDP in 2011: 70.2 (table values reported); Bound test B6 (one-time 30 percent nominal depreciation in 2007) reports external NPV debt-to-GDP in 2011: 3.6 (table values reported).

### Financial soundness indicators (selected)
- Banking sector capital adequacy: Total regulatory capital/risk-weighted assets: 2002: 41.9; 2003: 39.9; 2004: 28.0; 2005: 25.0; Sept-2006: 21.5.
- NPLs/total gross loans (percent): 2002: 8.5; 2003: 10.9; 2004: 9.3; 2005: 8.9; Sept-2006: 7.3.
- FX loans to residents (percent of total loans): 2002: 80.0; 2003: 77.0; 2004: 73.0; 2005: 65.9; Sept-2006: 58.5.
- Liquidity: Loans to deposits: 2002: 424.6; 2003: 334.1; 2004: 240.4; 2005: 213.5; Sept-2006: 156.6.
- Real GDP growth (percent): 2002: 4.0; 2003: 4.2; 2004: 7.7; 2005: 7.0; 2006 Est.: 7.2.
- CPI inflation (official, period average, percent): 2002: 27.3; 2003: 10.2; 2004: 1.7; 2005: 6.5; 2006 Est.: 7.4.

### Fund relations and technical assistance (Appendix I, selected)
- Membership: Date of membership: September 21, 1992; Status: Article VIII; Uzbekistan accepted Article VIII Sections 2(a), 3 and 4 on October 15, 2003.
- Quota: 275.60 SDR million — Percent Quota: 100.00.
- Stand-by arrangement (historical): Approval date: 12/18/95; Expiration date: 3/17/97; Amount approved (SDR million): 124.70; Amount drawn (SDR million): 65.45.
- Exchange rate arrangements (As of December 31, 2006): Exchange rate determination: interbank foreign exchange market; De facto regime reclassified: “conventional peg” due to one-sided CBU intervention and stability within a two percent band in H2 2006.
- Technical assistance and training: Fund departments involved: MAE, FAD, STA, LEG, and INS; focus areas include budget and treasury reforms; data weaknesses in price indices, national income accounts, and balance of payments; resident advisors and multiple missions cited.

### Executive Board assessment and concluding recommendations (Article IV, concluded February 9, 2007)
- Key assessments:
  - Real GDP growth over 7 percent in 2005–06.
  - External current account large surpluses; official reserves reached 12 months of import cover at end-2006.
  - Inflation picked up in 2005; started coming down in 2006 after monetary tightening but remains high.
  - Exchange rate de facto pegged in H2 2006 after gradual depreciation in 2005 and early 2006.
- Directors’ recommendations (selected):
  - Support further monetary tightening in 2007 to contain inflation.
  - Adopt a more flexible exchange rate policy to reduce pressure on indirect monetary instruments and allow greater credit expansion; allowing some nominal appreciation seen as compatible with indications that the sum is undervalued.
  - Continue cautious fiscal policy in 2007; consider better-targeted subsidies instead of large salary/pension increases.
  - Encourage tax and treasury reforms; introduce a multi-year budget framework; integrate FRD into government budget.
  - Promote financial deepening and banking reforms; remove cash withdrawal restrictions; discontinue banks’ non-core roles; undertake an FSAP.
  - Advance trade liberalization: reduce and unify tariffs; eliminate excise tax differences; streamline customs; accelerate WTO accession.
  - Strengthen statistics: provide technical assistance on national accounts, price, and balance of payments statistics; participate in the GDDS; publish economic data.
  - Directors welcomed authorities’ reiteration of commitment to current account convertibility and hoped transitory convertibility problems related to anti-money laundering implementation would be resolved in early 2007.

*Source: _cr07133 - IMF staff report, 2006 Article IV Consultation (excerpt).*

### 2006. The mission met with the first deputy prime minister, ministers of economy and

### _cr07133 - 2006. The mission met with the first deputy prime minister, ministers of economy and 

### Introduction
- Mission contacts: first deputy prime minister; ministers of economy and trade; governor of the Central Bank of Uzbekistan (CBU); other senior government officials; parliamentarians; representatives of banking and diplomatic communities.
- Mission team: Mmes. Eken (head), Bacalu (both MCD), Vera Martin (PDR); Mr. Saker (MCM); assisted by Ms. Kostina (IMF office in Tashkent). Mr. Moser, Executive Director, participated in policy meetings.
- Uzbekistan accepted the obligations of Article VIII, Sections 2(a), 3, and 4 as of October 15, 2003.
- De facto exchange rate regime: conventional peg.
- The 2006 Article IV consultation was streamlined.
- Main policy discussion areas: reducing inflation, developing the banking sector, liberalizing foreign trade.

### Recent Economic Developments
- Growth and external position
  - GDP growth (official): just over 7 percent in 2005–06, driven by agriculture, industry, and transport and communications.
  - Current account: large surpluses in 2006 supported by favorable commodity prices, growth in non-commodity exports, increased remittances, and restricted imports; surplus likely overstated given large negative errors and omissions.
  - Official reserves: increased steadily to 12 months of import cover at end-2006.
- Inflation and monetary developments
  - Inflation: picked up in 2005 and remained high in 2006 (multiple indices show elevated inflation).
  - Monetary policy: accommodative in 2005; tightened in 2006 via increased deposits from banks, resumption of central bank paper issuance, and accumulation of government deposits including through the Fund for Reconstruction and Development (FRD).
  - Result: growth of monetary aggregates decelerated in 2006.
- Exchange rate and intervention
  - Sum was de facto pegged to the U.S. dollar during the second half of 2006, stable within a two percent band since mid-2006.
  - CBU interventions were one-sided and led to steady reserve accumulation.
- Fiscal performance and structural reforms
  - 2005 fiscal outturn: budget financing shows a surplus of 1.3 percent of GDP in 2005; authorities reported a small deficit compared to a budgeted deficit of over 3 percent of GDP; implied statistical discrepancy over 1½ percent of GDP mainly reflects increased deposits in off-budgetary accounts.
  - 2006 fiscal: consolidated balance estimated to have registered a small surplus compared to the budgeted deficit of 3 percent of GDP; overall fiscal surplus including the FRD estimated at 3.1 percent of GDP.
  - Recent fiscal policy: two consecutive 20 percent rises in public sector wages and pensions and an additional 30 percent wage increase in health and education, largely offset by lower capital expenditures.
  - Structural reforms: tax and treasury reforms; licensing, inspections, and reporting streamlined; restructuring of agricultural enterprises into private farms mostly completed; eased restrictions on banks’ correspondent accounts and cash withdrawals; real time gross settlement system introduced. Privatization stalled; poor investment climate; low FDI inflows; underdeveloped banking system.

### Economic Outlook
- Short-term projections
  - Authorities project GDP growth to exceed 7½ percent in 2007, supported by strong external demand and industrial production (petrochemicals, machinery, textiles).
  - Current account surplus projected to remain very large; official reserves expected to continue to increase.
  - Authorities target a decline in inflation in 2007 via further monetary tightening and cautious fiscal policy.
- Medium-term objectives and staff view
  - WISP envisages annual growth of 8–8½ percent by the end of this decade; private sector share rising to 55 percent of GDP by 2010 from about 40 percent in 2006; poverty level declining 50 percent by 2015.
  - Staff view: these objectives would materialize only if trade is substantially liberalized, credit to the private sector picks up, confidence in the banking system is enhanced, and the business environment improves. Absent these changes, staff projects GDP growth to remain at about 7 percent, supported by external demand.
  - External outlook: import growth projected to remain at about current levels; export growth expected to moderate reflecting terms of trade and external demand forecasts.
  - Debt sustainability: analysis indicates external and public debt should remain manageable under standard stress tests.
  - Terms of trade assumption: During 2007–11, Uzbekistan’s terms of trade (TOT) will improve by 20 percent, outpacing other CIS countries’ TOT. A 10 percent decline in the prices of gold and cotton during the same period will narrow the annual current account surplus by about 1¼ percent of GDP on average.

### Policy Challenges
- Overview
  - Three priority areas: reducing inflation; reforming the banking system; liberalizing foreign trade.

- A. Policies to Reduce Inflation
  - Causes of inflationary pressures identified:
    - Rapid reserve accumulation and consequent monetary expansion.
    - Almost doubling of public sector wages and pensions in the past two years.
    - Administered price increases of 35 percent during the past two years.
  - Authorities’ monetary policy stance for 2007:
    - Intend to limit reserve money growth to about 30 percent in 2007 by sterilizing excess liquidity using indirect monetary instruments and accumulating deposits in the FRD.
    - Expect continuation of declining velocity; policy should be consistent with a further reduction in inflation in 2007.
    - Given the strong balance of payments outlook and assuming a stable cash-to-deposit ratio, policy would allow a small increase in credit to the private sector.
    - CBU expects the fiscal outturn to be better-than-projected and the cash-to-deposit ratio to decline, creating more room for credit.
    - Authorities intend to keep the refinance rate at its current level of 14 percent.
    - Note: The refinance rate is not an effective policy instrument given the weak transmission mechanism.
  - Exchange rate policy interaction:
    - Authorities aim for small nominal depreciation of the sum to achieve small depreciations of the real effective exchange rate (REER) to maintain competitiveness; this strategy led to rapid monetary expansion and high inflation without achieving real depreciation.
    - Staff recommendation: combining proactive use of monetary instruments with a flexible exchange rate policy would help combat inflation; allowing nominal appreciation by reducing official intervention would relieve pressure on indirect monetary instruments and create room for credit growth.
    - Evidence suggests the sum could be significantly undervalued; efforts to resist real appreciation would likely be unsuccessful and inflationary.
    - Authorities currently target a small nominal depreciation during 2007 but are prepared to consider a more flexible exchange rate policy if warranted.
    - Exchange rate pass-through: According to the authorities, first-round pass-through of nominal appreciation to inflation is about 15 percent, but exchange rate pass-through is difficult to assess due to import restrictions.

- Box: Assessment of the Exchange Rate Level (key findings)
  - Current account surplus: nearly 20 percent of GDP in 2006.
  - Non-commodity exports growth in 2006: 43 percent; commodity export growth: 11 percent.
  - Despite strong balance of payments, REER and NEER stable since 2003 depreciation; moderate REER appreciation since 2005 due to higher inflation has not adversely affected export performance.
  - Equilibrium analysis: PPP approach suggests the REER is undervalued by about 30 percent compared with predicted level given Uzbekistan’s relative income.
  - Structural current account estimated at a surplus of about 4 percent of GDP, much lower than recent surpluses.

### Other Policy Areas (summary)
- Banking sector: underdeveloped; some easing of restrictions on banks’ correspondent accounts and cash withdrawals; real time gross settlement system introduced. Detailed banking reform recommendations and vulnerabilities are set out in the main report (Tables and Figures referenced).
- Trade liberalization: advice to liberalize international trade has not yet been taken up; staff sees substantial trade liberalization as central to achieving higher medium-term growth and private sector development.

*IMF staff report, 2006 Article IV Consultation (excerpt).*

### 13.      The authorities feel that fiscal policy should support the anti-inflation effort.

### 13.      The authorities feel that fiscal policy should support the anti-inflation effort.

### Fiscal policy stance and medium-term implications
- The overall government budget (including the FRD) is projected to register a surplus of 2.9 percent of GDP in 2007, despite a reduction in taxes to promote private sector activity.
- This would imply fiscal loosening of 0.7 percent of GDP, but this estimate may not fully reflect prospects for continued significant over-performance relative to the budget.
- Given the low level of public debt, lower inflation would provide room over the medium term for small fiscal deficits, implying scope for moderate fiscal loosening to finance higher social and infrastructure expenditures.
- The authorities do not favor shifting toward more capital expenditure by refraining from large increases in public sector salaries and pensions.
- The authorities intend to:
  - continue their tax reforms;
  - strengthen fiscal management; and
  - consolidate the FRD’s operations into the fiscal reporting in 2007.

### Reform of the banking system — structural changes and prudential position
- Prudential ratios exceed minimum standards (see referenced Tables 11 and 12).
- Banks are expanding in consumer lending, real estate, and SME financing, with some move to more local currency and longer-term lending to private sector.
- Banks have been active in channeling remittances into Uzbekistan.
- According to official data:
  - banks’ risk-weighted capital adequacy ratios are well above the minimum requirement;
  - non-performing loans are declining; and
  - solvency ratios seem robust to exchange rate shocks and a rise in non-performing loans.
- Caveat: the strength of banks’ balance sheets partly reflects the large proportion of government-guaranteed loans, which carry a zero risk weight.
- With the government no longer issuing guarantees for loans and foreign funding, the banking system will need to manage its balance sheets more conventionally; the authorities recently increased the minimum capital requirements.
- Scenario note: "A 55 percent appreciation of the sum against the dollar and a doubling of non-performing loans would bring the capital adequacy ratio close to the minimum level of 10 percent."

### Financial intermediation and confidence constraints
- Financial intermediation remains subdued:
  - Monetization remains low;
  - Growth in cash-in-circulation is faster than that of deposits;
  - Credit growth is low and the credit-to-GDP ratio continues to decline.
- Two main factors limiting intermediation:
  - Strong growth in net foreign assets has limited the room for credit expansion given the tight monetary framework designed to control the growth of reserve money; and
  - The low level of confidence in banks discourages deposits, limiting banks’ ability to grow.
- Market participants identify additional constraints:
  - restrictions on cash withdrawals from banks (reported by some participants);
  - obligation for enterprises to make daily deposits of cash receipts; and
  - interference by local authorities in banking activities.
- The authorities' views and intended actions:
  - prefer incentives over administrative measures to enhance banks’ role;
  - indicate problems with cash withdrawals no longer existed;
  - suggest the Anti-Money Laundering legislation (bringing large transactions under inspection) could be discouraging deposits; and
  - intend to relieve banks from non-core activities following completion of government treasury reforms, expected by end-2007.

### Trade liberalization — regime characteristics and distortions
- Uzbekistan’s trade regime is described as protective and complex, with barriers to trade to shelter domestic production.
- Import tariffs are among the highest in the region (Text Table 1). Selected tariff measures for 2005:
  - Uzbekistan: Simple average rate 14.8; Weighted average rate 16.6; Standard deviation 11.6; Maximum rate 30; Number of tariff bands 4.
  - Comparative entries in Text Table 1 (2005): Azerbaijan Simple average rate 5.7; China Simple average rate 9.8; Kazakhstan Simple average rate 7.4; Kyrgyz Republic Simple average rate 5.0; Mongolia Simple average rate 4.5; Tajikistan Simple average rate 7.5. (All figures presented as in-text.)
- Other trade-related taxes and processes:
  - Direct and indirect taxes are levied on imported goods;
  - An implicit tax on imports originates from the differentiated application of excise taxes to imported and domestically produced goods;
  - The import process is complex and time-consuming.
- Economic consequences of current trade policies:
  - distort resource allocation;
  - reduce competition;
  - contribute to a difficult business environment;
  - create opportunities for corruption; and
  - encourage smuggling.
- The authorities indicated the new customs code, to be submitted to the Cabinet of Ministers in early 2007, would consolidate regulations and bring them in compliance with international standards, but would not include measures to liberalize trade.
- The authorities noted multilateral trade liberalization would be considered in the context of WTO accession.

### Other issues — currency convertibility and statistics
- Reports surfaced of restrictions on currency convertibility in the second half of 2006:
  - Foreign exchange sales for imports of consumer goods remained relatively constant at a low level since mid-2006, and a small premium appeared in the curb foreign exchange market.
  - The authorities denied restrictions and attributed delays in foreign exchange availability to the implementation of the Anti-Money Laundering Law in mid-2006, which imposed additional reporting requirements on transactions above a certain limit.
  - The authorities indicated such delays would be eliminated by early 2007, when an automated information exchange system is expected to be in place.
  - The authorities reiterated their commitment to unrestricted convertibility for current account transactions.
- Data quality and statistical weaknesses:
  - Large differences among various inflation indicators (CPI, PPI, and GDP deflator) hinder evaluation of inflationary pressures;
  - National income accounts employ inadequate valuation methods and are inconsistent with external sector and public finance data;
  - Large errors and omissions in the balance of payments and fiscal accounts point to inadequate coverage and classification issues.
- The authorities have requested Fund technical assistance, preferably in the form of a resident advisor, to resolve data deficiencies.

### Staff appraisal — findings and recommendations
- Recent macro performance:
  - Real GDP growth was high;
  - The external current account surplus was large;
  - Official reserves continued to rise;
  - With the tightening of monetary policy in 2006, inflation has recently started coming down, but remains high.
- Main macroeconomic challenge for 2007: reduce inflation further.
- Staff welcomes authorities’ intentions to further tighten monetary policy and maintain a cautious fiscal stance.
- Staff recommends:
  - adopt a flexible exchange rate policy to help take some pressure off indirect policy instruments in slowing money growth and curbing inflation, while creating room for adequate credit expansion to the private sector;
  - allow a nominal appreciation of the exchange rate, which would be compatible with indications that the sum is undervalued.
- Fiscal policy assessment:
  - The authorities’ fiscal stance is appropriate given monetary tightening and consideration of exchange rate flexibility to reduce inflation.
  - Over the medium term, adequate monetary tightening and lower inflation would provide more room to finance social and infrastructure expenditures without compromising fiscal sustainability.
  - The staff commends progress in tax and treasury reforms and encourages:
    - shifting toward more capital expenditure by moderating increases in public sector salaries and pensions;
    - introducing a multi-year budgetary framework; and
    - consolidating the FRD’s operations under treasury control.
- Growth objectives:
  - Authorities’ medium-term growth objectives are very ambitious and would materialize only if:
    - inflation is contained;
    - credit to the private sector picks up;
    - confidence in the banking system is enhanced; and
    - the difficult business environment improves, including through substantial trade liberalization.
- Banking sector recommendations:
  - Financial deepening is essential to strengthen the monetary transmission mechanism and enhance banks’ role;
  - Staff supports authorities’ efforts to strengthen the banking sector and recommends:
    - completely remove all remaining restrictions on cash withdrawals from banks;
    - discontinue the role of banks in financial oversight and implementing non-core activities; and
    - eliminate undue interference in the activities of the banking system;
    - request an FSAP to help prioritize banking sector reforms.
- Trade recommendations:
  - Move toward comprehensive trade liberalization to improve productivity and realize external trade potential;
  - Staff advises authorities to:
    - lower and unify tariffs;
    - eliminate differences in excise taxes on imported and domestic goods;
    - reduce costs related to international trade;
    - streamline customs procedures; and
    - accelerate WTO accession.
  - Staff urges full adherence to Article VIII of the Fund’s Articles of Agreement and welcomes authorities’ reiteration of full commitment to unrestricted currency convertibility for current account transactions.
- Statistics recommendations:
  - Urgent need to enhance the quality of statistics;
  - Staff strongly supports authorities’ request for technical assistance to address weaknesses in price indices, national income accounts, and the balance of payments;
  - Staff urges participation in the GDDS and publication of economic data.

*Source: _cr07133 - 13.      The authorities feel that fiscal policy should support the anti-inflation effort.*

### 29.      It is proposed that the next Article IV consultation with Uzbekistan takes place on the

### _cr07133 - 29.      It is proposed that the next Article IV consultation with Uzbekistan takes place on the

### Main proposal
- It is proposed that the next Article IV consultation with Uzbekistan takes place on the standard 12-month cycle.

### Key macroeconomic aggregates and projections (selected)
- Nominal GDP (in sum, billions): 2003: 9,838; 2004: 12,261; 2005: 15,210; 2006 Est.: 19,616; 2007 Proj.: 23,952.
- Nominal GDP (in US$ million): 2003: 10,116; 2004: 11,941; 2005: 13,582; 2006 Est.: 16,044; 2007 Proj.: 18,776.
- GDP at current prices (percent): 2003: 32.0; 2004: 24.6; 2005: 24.1; 2006: 29.0; 2007: 22.1.
- GDP at constant prices (annual percentage change): 2003: 4.2; 2004: 7.7; 2005: 7.0; 2006: 7.2; 2007: 7.7.
- GDP deflator (percent): 2003: 26.7; 2004: 15.7; 2005: 15.9; 2006: 20.3; 2007: 13.4.
- Consumer price index (eop, official): 2003: 3.7; 2004: 3.8; 2005: 7.8; 2006: 7.0; 2007: 5.0-7.0 (range reported).
- Consumer price index (eop, alternative): 2003: 7.7; 2004: 15.5; 2005: 18.8; 2006: 15.2; 2007: 12.5.
- Average wage (sums per month, eop): 2003: 45,184; 2004: 73,528; 2005: 108,610.

### Money and credit (selected)
- Broad money (annual percentage change): 2003: 27.1; 2004: 47.8; 2005: 54.3; 2006: 37.0; 2007: 30.0.
- Net foreign assets (annual percentage change): 2003: 45.6; 2004: 48.8; 2005: 44.0; 2006: 68.9; 2007: 37.5.
- Net domestic assets (annual percentage change): 2003: -87.8; 2004: -50.5; 2005: -28.4; 2006: -127.1; 2007: -45.6.
- Net claims on government (annual percentage change): 2004: -115.8; 2005: -87.0; 2006: -107.6; 2007: -52.3.
- Credit to the economy (annual percentage change): 2003: 6.9; 2004: 10.8; 2005: 15.8; 2006: 2.1; 2007: 2.6.
- Income velocity of average broad money (level): 2003: 10.5; 2004: 9.5; 2005: 8.0; 2006: 7.2; 2007: 6.6.

### External sector (selected)
- Exports of goods and services (US$ million): 2003: 3,775; 2004: 4,836; 2005: 5,416; 2006: 6,610; 2007: 7,612.
- Imports of goods and services (US$ million): 2003: 3,097; 2004: 3,927; 2005: 4,101; 2006: 4,600; 2007: 5,321.
- Real effective exchange rate (official rate, alternative CPI; - deprec.): 2003: -19.8; 2004: -6.4; 2005: 5.9.
- Current account (in percent of GDP): 2003: 8.7; 2004: 10.2; 2005: 14.3; 2006: 19.5; 2007: 19.6.
- Gross official reserves (US$ million): 2003: 1,659; 2004: 2,146; 2005: 2,895; 2006: 4,604; 2007: 6,104.
- Gross official reserves (months of imports of GNFS): 2003: 6.4; 2004: 6.6; 2005: 8.5; 2006: 12.0; 2007: 13.8.
- Nominal GDP per capita (US$): 2003: 396; 2004: 462; 2005: 519; 2006: 606; 2007: 701.
- External debt outstanding (US$ million, memorandum): 2003: 4,249; 2004: 4,322; 2005: 4,133; 2006: 3,938; 2007: 3,860.
- Exchange rates (sums per U.S. dollar; eop, official): 2003: 979; 2004: 1,058; 2005: 1,180.

### Balance of payments (selected, 2003–11 projections)
- Current account balance (US$ million): 2003: 881; 2004: 1,215; 2005: 1,949; 2006: 3,136; 2007: 3,673; 2008 Proj.: 4,044; 2009 Proj.: 4,587; 2010 Proj.: 4,842; 2011 Proj.: 5,004.
- Merchandise exports (US$ million): 2003: 3,240; 2004: 4,263; 2005: 4,757; 2006: 5,842; 2007: 6,791; 2008 Proj.: 7,656; 2009 Proj.: 8,730; 2010 Proj.: 9,636; 2011 Proj.: 10,552.
  - Cotton fiber: 2003: 739; 2004: 876; 2005: 1,033; 2006: 1,009; 2007: 1,096.
  - Energy: 2003: 454; 2004: 602; 2005: 623; 2006: 810; 2007: 932.
  - Gold: 2003: 1,046; 2004: 1,242; 2005: 1,315; 2006: 1,471; 2007: 1,508.
- Imports of goods (US$ million): 2003: -2,405; 2004: -3,061; 2005: -3,310; 2006: -3,787; 2007: -4,444; 2008 Proj.: -5,188; 2009 Proj.: -6,066; 2010 Proj.: -7,091; 2011 Proj.: -8,301.
- Overall balance (US$ million): 2003: 467; 2004: 512; 2005: 768; 2006: 1,709; 2007: 1,500; 2008 Proj.: 1,800; 2009 Proj.: 2,100; 2010 Proj.: 2,100; 2011 Proj.: 2,300.
- Financing (gross reserves increase and use of Fund credit): Gross reserves (- increase): -444 (2003), -487 (2004), -748 (2005), -1,709 (2006), -1,500 (2007); Use of Fund credit: -23 (2003), -25 (2004), -200 (2005), 0 (2006 onward reported as 0).

### Government finance (consolidated, selected)
- Consolidated revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 2003: 33.4; 2004: 32.2; 2005: 32.2; 2006: 32.7; 2007: 31.7.
- Consolidated expenditure and net lending (percent of GDP): 2003: 33.9; 2004: 32.1; 2005: 32.5; 2006: 32.6; 2007: 32.3.
- Consolidated budget balance (- = deficit, percent of GDP): 2003: 0.1; 2004: 0.6; 2005: 1.3; 2006: 0.4; 2007: -0.6.
- Augmented government balance (percent of GDP): 2003: 0.1; 2004: 0.6; 2005: 1.3; 2006: 3.6; 2007: 2.9.
- Public debt (percent of GDP): 2003: 41.6; 2004: 35.1; 2005: 29.5; 2006: 22.6; 2007: 18.6.
- Budget revenue and grants (in billions of sum): 2003: 3,288; 2004: 3,945; 2005: 4,729; 2006 Est.: 4,900; 2007 Proj.: 5,872.
- Budget expenditure and net lending (in billions of sum): 2003: 3,337; 2004: 3,938; 2005: 5,216; 2006 Est.: 4,945; 2007 Proj.: 6,423.
- Tax revenue (in billions of sum): 2003: 2,234; 2004: 2,770; 2005: 3,176; 2006 Est.: 3,312; 2007 Proj.: 3,820.
- Value-added tax (in billions of sum): 2003: 536; 2004: 655; 2005: 749; 2006 Est.: 815; 2007 Proj.: 1,017.

### Public and external debt sustainability (selected indicators and projections)
- Total external debt outstanding (percent of GDP): 2003: 42.0; 2004: 36.2; 2005: 30.4; 2006: 24.5; 2007: 20.6; projected declines to 9.6 by 2011 in the baseline.
- External debt service ratio (percent of exports of goods and services): 2003: 20.8; 2004: 17.1; 2005: 14.1; 2006: 11.3; 2007: 9.4.
- NPV of external debt (percent of GDP, projections): 2007: 24.1; 2008: 19.0; 2009: 15.7; 2010: 13.0; 2011: 10.6.
- Baseline public and publicly guaranteed external debt sensitivity (NPV of debt-to-GDP ratio, percent): 2006 Est.: 20.6; 2007: 16.0; 2008: 12.7; 2009: 10.2; 2010: 7.9; 2011: 6.0.
- Public sector debt (percent of GDP): 2003: 41.7; 2004: 35.1; 2005: 29.5; 2006: 22.6; 2007: 18.6; projections: 2011: 7.6.
- Change in public sector debt (percent of GDP): 2003: -12.9; 2004: -6.5; 2005: -5.6; 2006: -7.0; 2007: -3.9.
- Primary deficit (- = surplus, percent of GDP): 2003: -0.6; 2004: -1.1; 2005: -1.7; 2006: 0.0; 2007: 1.4; 2008: -4.0 (projection pattern in table).

### Sensitivity analyses and stress tests (selected)
- Debt Sustainability Framework, Baseline Scenario (external, percent of GDP): 2006 Est.: 20.6; 2007: 16.0; 2008: 12.7; 2009: 10.2; 2010: 7.9; 2011: 6.0.
- Alternative scenario A1 (key variables at historical averages in 2007-11): external NPV debt-to-GDP in 2011: 70.2 (table reports scenario values; see full table).
- Bound test B6 (one-time 30 percent nominal depreciation relative to baseline in 2007): external NPV debt-to-GDP in 2011: 3.6 (table reports scenario values).
- Public debt sensitivity (NPV of Debt-to-GDP ratio, baseline): 2006 Est.: 22.4; 2007: 17.5; 2008: 13.7; 2009: 10.9; 2010: 8.5; 2011: 6.4.
- Table 10 scenarios show alternative paths for public debt, NPV debt-to-revenue ratio, and debt service-to-revenue ratio under shocks (detailed scenario values reported in Table 10).

### Monetary and central bank accounts (selected)
- Net international reserves (billion US$) progression: Mar-2003: 1.6; 2004: 2.1; 2005: 2.9; 2006 Mar: 3.2; 2006 Jun: 3.6; 2006 Sep: 4.0; 2006 Oct: 4.1; 2006 Dec: 4.6; 2007 Proj.: 6.1.
- Gross international reserves (billion US$) same series reported.
- Official exchange rate (sum/U.S. dollar, eop): 2003: 980; 2004: 1,058; 2005: 1,180; 2006 Oct: 1,230; 2006 Dec: ...; 2007 Proj.: ...
- Reserve money (levels, billions of sum): 2003: 508; 2004: 704; 2005: 1,321; 2006 Est. Dec: 1,809; 2007 Proj.: 2,352.
- Broad money (levels, billions of sum): 2003: 1,009; 2004: 1,491; 2005: 2,299; 2006 Est. Dec: 3,150; 2007 Proj.: 4,095.
- Currency ratio (percent) and other monetary aggregates reported in Tables 3–4.

### Financial soundness and vulnerabilities (selected)
- Banking sector capital adequacy: Total regulatory capital/risk-weighted assets: 2002: 41.9; 2003: 39.9; 2004: 28.0; 2005: 25.0; Sept-2006: 21.5.
- NPLs/total gross loans (percent): 2002: 8.5; 2003: 10.9; 2004: 9.3; 2005: 8.9; Sept-2006: 7.3.
- FX loans to residents (percent of total loans): 2002: 80.0; 2003: 77.0; 2004: 73.0; 2005: 65.9; Sept-2006: 58.5.
- Return on average assets (percent): 2002: 1.5; 2003: 1.5; 2004: 1.5; 2005: 0.9; Sept-2006: 1.6.
- Liquidity metrics: Loans to deposits: 2002: 424.6; 2003: 334.1; 2004: 240.4; 2005: 213.5; Sept-2006: 156.6.
- Selected vulnerability indicators (2002–06): Real GDP growth (percent) - 2002: 4.0; 2003: 4.2; 2004: 7.7; 2005: 7.0; 2006 Est.: 7.2. CPI inflation (official, period average, percent) - 2002: 27.3; 2003: 10.2; 2004: 1.7; 2005: 6.5; 2006 Est.: 7.4.
- Total gross external debt (percent of GDP): 2002: 55.0; 2003: 42.0; 2004: 36.2; 2005: 30.4; 2006 Est.: 24.5.
- Augmented government budget balance (percent of GDP): 2002: -1.9; 2003: 0.1; 2004: 0.6; 2005: 1.3; 2006 Est.: 3.6.

### Memoranda and cross-cutting projections
- Key macro assumptions used across debt sustainability and fiscal projections include:
  - Real GDP growth (percent): 2003: 4.2; 2004: 7.7; 2005: 7.0; 2006: 5.2; projections for 2007–11 reported in tables (e.g., 2007: 1.7 in one table and alternative series in others; see tables for context).
  - GDP deflator in US dollar terms (change in percent) and effective interest rate (percent) reported in Table 7 and Table 9 with series over 2003–11.
- Memorandum items include nominal GDP (billions of US$): 2003: 10.1; 2004: 11.9; 2005: 13.6; 2006: 16.0; 2007: 18.8.

*Sources: Uzbek authorities; and Fund staff estimates and projections.*

### APPENDIX I: FUND RELATIONS

### APPENDIX I: FUND RELATIONS

### I. Membership and Status
- Date of membership: September 21, 1992
- Status: Article VIII
- Uzbekistan accepted the obligations of Article VIII Sections 2(a), 3 and 4 of the Fund’s Articles of Agreements with effect on October 15, 2003.

### II. General Resources Account and SDR Department
- Quota: 275.60 SDR million — Percent Quota: 100.00
- Fund holdings of currency: 275.60 SDR million — Percent: 100.00
- Reserve position in the Fund: 0.01 SDR million — Percent: 0.00
- SDR Department holdings: 0.01 SDR million — Percent: N/A

### III. Outstanding Purchases and Loans
- None

### IV. Financial Arrangements
- Stand-by arrangement
  - Approval date: 12/18/95
  - Expiration date: 3/17/97
  - Amount approved (SDR million): 124.70
  - Amount drawn (SDR million): 65.45

### V. Projected Obligations to the Fund
- None

### VI. Implementation of Debt Relief Initiatives
- HIPC Initiative: Not applicable
- Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative: Not applicable

### VII. Exchange Rate Arrangements (As of December 31, 2006)
- Exchange rate determination: interbank foreign exchange market
- De facto regime reclassified: “conventional peg” (from previous “managed floating with no pre-determined path for the exchange rate”)
- Explanation: one sided intervention by the Central Bank of Uzbekistan leading to exchange rate stability against the U.S. dollar in the second half of 2006 within a two percent band.

### VIII. Article IV Consultation
- 2005 Article IV consultation completed by the Executive Board on May 16, 2005 (Staff Report SM/05/146, 05/147).
- Consultation cycle: standard 12-month consultation cycle.
- Recent Article IV consultations and related dates listed under Staff Visits (see next section).

### IX. Staff Visits and Policy Discussions (since January 1, 2001)
- June 2001: Staff Visit.
- July/August 2001: Staff Visit.
- December 2001: Article IV Consultation/Discussion of Staff-Monitored Program.
- June 2002: Staff Visit.
- September 2002: Staff Visit.
- February 2003: Article IV Consultation.
- June 2003: Staff Visit.
- October 2003: Staff Visit.
- March 2004: Article IV Consultation.
- December 2004: Staff Visit.
- February/March 2005: Article IV Consultation.
- November/December 2005: Staff Visit.
- November/December 2006: Article IV Consultation.

### X. Safeguards Assessment
- The CBU is currently not subject to safeguards assessment policy since Uzbekistan is not expected to have a financial arrangement with the Fund in the near future.

### XI. Technical Assistance and Training
- Fund departments involved: MAE, FAD, STA, LEG, and INS.
- Focus areas: budget and treasury reforms; data weaknesses in price indices, national income accounts, and balance of payments.
- Monetary and exchange affairs:
  - April 2002 mission: External public debt management (with World Bank consultant; within joint IMF–Swiss regional project financed by the Government of Switzerland).
  - October 2003: MFD participation in a staff visit to review the foreign exchange system and identify foreign exchange restrictions and multiple currency practices to be abolished before acceptance of Article VIII obligations.
- Fiscal affairs:
  - October/November 2002 mission: Public expenditure management review.
  - September 2004 mission: Public expenditure management review.
- Statistical issues:
  - March 2000 mission: Balance of payments statistics.
  - April 2000 mission: Money and banking statistics.
  - November 2003 mission: National accounts and price statistics.
  - August/September 2004 mission: National accounts statistics.
- Legal issues:
  - LEG reviews of foreign exchange regulations in 2000 and 2002.
  - October 2003: LEG participation to assist government identify foreign exchange restrictions and multiple currency practices to be abolished before Article VIII acceptance.
- Training:
  - Uzbek officials participated in courses in Washington, at the IMF-Singapore Training Institute, and at the Joint Vienna Institute on macroeconomic management, financial programming, taxation, public expenditure and treasury management, monetary statistics and policy, and balance of payments analysis.
  - In-country courses organized in Tashkent: June 1993, May 1994, and April/May 1998.

### XII. Resident Representation and Advisors
- Resident Representatives:
  - Istvan Szalkai: Tashkent from September 1993 to September 1995.
  - Mark O’Brien: November 1995 to December 1997.
  - Christoph Rosenberg: January 1998 to April 2001.
  - Currently: no resident representative; Fund maintains a locally staffed office in Tashkent.
- Resident Advisors:
  - Richard Grzebinski: advisor on computerization to the State Tax Committee, January 1994 to January 1995.
  - Emmanuel Sigler: served April to June 1995.
  - Alexander Agafonoff: advisor on monetary policy at the Central Bank of Uzbekistan, November 1994 to December 1995.
  - Jim Stevenson: advisor on treasury operations at the Ministry of Finance, began September 1996; assignment terminated in July 1998.
  - John Zohrab: advisor to the ministry of finance beginning January 2003; relocated to Tashkent in November 2006 to assist with (i) PFM project implementation, (ii) continuation of treasury reform, and (iii) PFM legal framework strengthening.

*Source: APPENDIX I: FUND RELATIONS (As of December 31, 2006)*

### 3.      The November 2003 STA mission found that developments in price statistics since

### _cr07133 - 3.      The November 2003 STA mission found that developments in price statistics since

### Price statistics and CPI
- November 2003 STA mission: developments in price statistics since 1998 were satisfactory, but two main issues identified:
  - incorrect treatment of secondary products in the producer price index;
  - use of variable monthly weights in the new CPI.
- Break in the CPI between December 2002 (constructed using the old methodology) and January 2003 (new methodology introduced).
- Staff urged the SSC to provide detailed calculations of the new index for 2002-03 during 2004 Article IV discussions.
- February 2005 Article IV mission and follow-up visit to Washington: technical assistance provided on international standards for treatment of seasonal goods in the CPI.
- Assessment: the method used to treat seasonal goods was considered to seriously understate overall inflation.
- Recommendation to change the seasonal-goods methodology has not been taken up by the SSC.

### External trade statistics
- Exports of cotton and other bulk exports are valued on a c.i.f. basis rather than f.o.b.
- Adjustments are made to capture informal cross-border trade and shuttle trade.
- Two parallel systems for compiling trade data:
  - customs declarations;
  - enterprise surveys.
- STA recommendation: use customs data for compiling merchandise trade statistics and use enterprise reports to collect data on trade in services only.

### Government finance statistics (GFS)
- MoF compiles detailed data on revenue and expenditure of the consolidated government budget on a monthly basis; available after a processing time of about four weeks.
- Extra budgetary funds data: available quarterly with a longer delay; include only broad categories of revenue and expenditure of the four largest funds.
- Authorities occasionally provide fiscal tables that conform to GFS guidelines by including net lending and foreign-financed investment, and details on financing of the deficit.
- Budget expenditure data: organized largely by functional classification; economic classification available only annually and quality is inadequate.
- MoF occasionally provides data on tax arrears.
- Information availability:
  - Total proceeds from privatization operations and Treasury bills: provided on a quarterly basis.
  - Data on issuance and repayments of Treasury bills: available monthly on request.
- Institutional reform:
  - FAD exploratory mission October 2002; resident advisor in February 2003 to assist with expenditure management, budget and treasury reforms.
  - Progress: development of a new Chart of Accounts conforming to GFS guidelines; Treasury Law revised and approved by Parliament in August 2004.
  - Authorities published data on 2005 Budget execution and on the 2006 Budget on the official MoF website.
- Reporting: Uzbekistan does not report GFS to STA.

### Money and banking
- New charts of accounts introduced for the CBU and commercial banks in 1997.
- Multiple monetary and financial statistics missions assisted the CBU in compiling monetary statistics using the new charts of accounts and IMF recommended methodology.
- Implementation of major recommendations led to considerable progress toward inclusion in a proposed Uzbekistan page in IFS.

### Balance of payments and external debt
- Uzbekistan does not report any balance of payments data to STA and does not disseminate balance of payments data to the public.
- March 2000 STA mission (follow-up to February 1998) reported considerable progress in compiling balance of payments statistics:
  - improvements in compilation of the financial account and external debt;
  - preparation of quarterly balance of payments data in U.S. dollars;
  - classification closely in line with IMF Balance of Payments Manual (BPM5);
  - inclusion of shuttle trade statistics in recorded international trade data;
  - estimates for migrant transfers and other adjustments to exports and imports data.
- Remaining problems: large errors and omissions item; reporting of travel data and construction services; availability of enterprise-based data on direct, portfolio, and other investment.
- External debt data:
  - Data provision improved considerably since 2003 and is broadly satisfactory.
  - Ministry of Finance provides data on external government and government-guaranteed debt, including projections of future debt service obligations.
  - Data provided in U.S. dollars and decomposed by currency; loan-by-loan data provided in the currency of denomination.
  - Frequency: submitted on a quarterly frequency, though often with some delay.
  - Aggregates broken down into government and government-guaranteed debt and classified by type of lender (multilateral, bilateral, and commercial).
  - Authorities do not indicate separately amount of debt extended on concessional terms, or amount of private debt owed or intermediated by banks.
  - Data include projections of future debt service obligations under existing agreements.
- Central bank provides data on external private debt not guaranteed by the government, including projections of future debt service obligations and new loan agreements; aggregate data submitted quarterly.
- Recommendation: debt projections should distinguish between debt service obligations due under existing agreements and those arising from newly-contracted debt.

### Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (As of December 31, 2006) — data frequency and dates (selected)
- Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation 10/31/06; Date received 12/02/06; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication W.
- International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: 10/31/06; 11/22/06; M; M; NA.
- Reserve/Base Money: 10/31/06; 11/22/06; M; M; NA.
- Broad Money: 10/31/06; 11/22/06; M; M; NA.
- Central Bank Balance Sheet: 10/31/06; 11/22/06; M; M; NA.
- Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: 10/31/06; 11/22/06; M; M; NA.
- Interest Rates: 09/30/06; 12/19/06; M; M; NA.
- Consumer Price Index: 11/30/06; 12/20/06; M; M; NA.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing – General Government: 09/30/06; 12/02/06; M; M; NA.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing – Central Government: 11/30/06; 12/07/06; M; M; NA.
- Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt: 09/30/06; 12/02/06; M; M; NA.
- External Current Account Balance: 09/30/06; 12/02/06; Q; Q; NA.
- Exports and Imports of Goods and Services: 09/30/06; 12/02/06; Q; Q; NA.
- GDP/GNP: 09/30/06; 10/24/06; Q; Q; NA.
- Gross External Debt: 09/30/06; 12/02/06; Q; Q; NA.

### Executive Board assessment and policy recommendations (Article IV, concluded February 9, 2007)
- Macroeconomic context and recent performance:
  - Real GDP growth: official data indicate real GDP growth was over 7 percent in 2005–06, driven by agriculture, industry, and transport and communications, supported by buoyant external demand.
  - External current account: large surpluses due to favorable commodity prices, strong growth in non-commodity exports, increased remittances, and restricted imports.
  - Official foreign exchange reserves: continued to rise and reached 12 months of import cover at end-2006.
  - Inflation: picked up in 2005; started coming down in 2006 after monetary tightening, but remains high.
  - Exchange rate: after gradual depreciation in 2005 and early 2006, the sum was de facto pegged to the U.S. dollar during the second half of 2006.
  - Real effective exchange rate: appreciated in the past two years due to higher inflation.
- Monetary policy:
  - 2005: accommodative; sharp accumulation of net foreign assets by CBU was only partially sterilized, resulting in surging reserve and broad money.
  - 2006: authorities tightened monetary policy via increased deposits from banks, accumulation of government deposits (including through the newly created Fund for Reconstruction and Development (FRD)), and resumption of issuance of central bank paper.
  - Result: growth of monetary aggregates decelerated by end-2006; reserve money growth declined from 88 percent in 2005 to 37 percent in 2006.
- Banking sector:
  - Undergoing structural changes with expansion of business areas and move to local currency lending.
  - Prudential ratios exceed minimum standards and non-performing loans are declining.
  - Constraints: low monetization, cash-in-circulation growth faster than deposits, ratio of credit-to-GDP continues to decline.
  - Banking system constrained by limited room for credit expansion given strong growth in net foreign assets and need to control reserve money growth; banks' involvement in financial oversight and implementing government treasury operations affects confidence.
- Fiscal policy:
  - Outperformed budget projections in 2005–06.
  - Despite tax cuts, revenue collection strong due to tax reforms.
  - Expenditure: large increases in public sector wages and pensions mainly offset by lower capital expenditures.
  - Consolidated budget: registered a surplus of 1.3 percent of GDP in 2005; estimated to have registered a small surplus in 2006 (budgeted deficits were about 3 percent of GDP in both years).
  - Overall fiscal surplus, including the FRD, is estimated at about 3½ percent of GDP in 2006.
- Structural reforms and governance:
  - Continued gradual reforms: tax reforms, treasury reforms, streamlining licensing/inspections/reporting, restructuring of agricultural enterprises into private farms largely completed.
  - Eased restrictions on banks’ access to correspondent accounts and cash withdrawals; introduction of a real time gross settlement system.
  - Weaknesses: stalled privatization, difficult investment climate, low FDI inflows, protective and complex trade regime, remaining weaknesses in economic data.
- Executive Directors’ recommendations:
  - Contain inflation: support for further tightening of monetary policy in 2007.
  - More flexible exchange rate policy recommended to reduce pressure on indirect monetary instruments and allow greater credit expansion; allowing some nominal appreciation deemed compatible with indications the sum is undervalued.
  - Continue cautious fiscal policies in 2007 to help reduce inflation; lower inflation would allow room for moderate fiscal loosening and small deficits in the medium term to finance higher social and infrastructure expenditure.
  - Concern over recent increases in public sector salaries and pensions limiting resources for investment; income objectives could be better served by well-targeted subsidies to the poor.
  - Encourage further tax and treasury reforms, introduce a multi-year budget framework, and integrate the FRD into the government budget.
  - Financial deepening: remove all remaining restrictions on cash withdrawals; discontinue banks’ role in financial oversight and government treasury functions; a Financial Sector Assessment Program would help prioritize banking sector reforms.
  - Trade policy: reduce and unify tariffs; eliminate differences in excise taxes on imported and domestic goods; reduce administrative costs related to international trade; streamline customs procedures; accelerate efforts to join the World Trade Organization.
  - Data and transparency: welcome authorities’ intention to enhance the quality of statistics and request technical assistance in national accounts, price, and balance of payments statistics; urge participation in the General Data Dissemination Standards and publication of economic data, including in the IFS.
- Convertibility: Directors welcomed authorities’ reiteration of commitment to current account convertibility amid reports of delays in 2006; hoped transitory convertibility problems associated with the anti-money laundering law implementation would be resolved in early 2007.

### Selected economic indicators (selected series and values as presented)
- Production and prices (Annual percentage change):
  - Real GDP: 2002 4.0 2003 4.2 2004 7.7 2005 7.0 2006 7.2
  - Consumer price index (e.o.p) 1/: 2002 21.6 2003 3.7 2004 3.8 2005 7.8 2006 7.0
  - GDP deflator 1/: 2002 45.4 2003 26.7 2004 15.7 2005 15.9 2006 20.3
  - Producer price index (e.o.p) 1/: 2002 46.1 2003 27.4 2004 26.5 2005 28.2 2006 27.0
- General government (In percent of GDP) 2/:
  - Total revenue and grants: 2002 35.7 2003 33.4 2004 32.2 2005 32.2 2006 35.8
  - Total expenditure and net lending: 2002 37.2 2003 33.9 2004 32.1 2005 32.5 2006 32.6
  - Overall balance (-=deficit) 3/: 2002 -1.9 2003 0.1 2004 0.6 2005 1.3 2006 3.6
- Monetary indicators (Annual percentage change):
  - Reserve money: 2002 25.2 2003 26.7 2004 38.7 2005 87.5 2006 37.0
  - Broad money: 2002 29.7 2003 27.1 2004 47.8 2005 54.3 2006 37.0
  - Velocity of average broad money (level): 2002 10.8 2003 10.5 2004 9.5 2005 8.0 2006 7.2
- External sector (In million of U.S. dollars, unless otherwise specified):
  - Export of goods: 2002 2,510 2003 3,240 2004 4,263 2005 4,757 2006 5,842
  - Import of goods: 2002 2,186 2003 2,405 2004 3,061 2005 3,310 2006 3,787
  - Current account: 2002 117 2003 881 2004 1,215 2005 1,949 2006 3,136
    - In percent of GDP: 2002 1.2 2003 8.7 2004 10.2 2005 14.3 2006 19.5
  - Gross international reserves: 2002 1,215 2003 1,659 2004 2,146 2005 2,895 2006 4,604
    - In months of imports: 2002 5.1 2003 6.4 2004 6.6 2005 8.5 2006 12.0
- Sources for indicators: Uzbek authorities; and IMF staff estimates.
- Notes accompanying table:
  - 1/ Official estimates.
  - 2/ Including the Fund for Reconstruction and Development created in 2006.
  - 3/ Based on below-the-line financing data.

*Source: IMF staff report and Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 07/37, March 23, 2007 (Article IV consultation materials contained in the supplied content).*

### 1. My authorities wish to express their appreciation to the mission team for their

### _cr07133 - 1. My authorities wish to express their appreciation to the mission team for their

### Overview
- Authorities express appreciation for the mission team's "extremely constructive approach and the productive policy dialogue."
- Authorities concur with staff’s assessment that "Uzbekistan’s great economic potential remains to be fully exploited" and are "committed to a continued implementation of their gradual reform agenda."
- Authorities consent to publication of the staff report and request Fund assistance to comprehensively address data issues in price indices, national income accounts, and balance of payments.

### Macroeconomic performance and outlook
- Since liberalization of the foreign exchange system in late 2003 (undertaken with IMF advice and assistance), Uzbekistan’s macroeconomic performance "has been very strong."
- Annual real GDP growth accelerated to over 7 percent, "well above Fund projections," with increasing contribution from capital intensive sectors.
- Non-commodity exports now account for "more than half of Uzbekistan’s total exports" and contributed to high GDP growth and strengthened sustainability.
- External debt declined to "24.5 percent of GDP."
- Authorities and staff view that economic growth and the balance of payments "are likely to remain strong."
- Authorities aim to accelerate annual real GDP growth to "8 percent" under the Welfare Improvement Strategy (WISP, the equivalent of a PRSP).

### Fiscal policy
- In 2006, the consolidated budget registered a small surplus, with an overall fiscal surplus of "about 3 percent of GDP."
- Authorities intend to continue cautious fiscal and borrowing policy in 2007.
- New Tax Code submitted to parliament envisages: further reduction of the tax burden, broadening of the tax base, and streamlining of tax administration; authorities expect significant improvement in the business climate based on tax rate reductions in 2005 and 2006, which resulted in an increase in tax revenues.
- Public Finance Management project aims to:
  - Establish a Treasury Single Account for the general government sector, including local government budgets and extra-budgetary funds.
  - Establish a modern Treasury Information System.
  - Bring budget classification and accounting in line with international standards ("GFS 2001 and IPSAS").
  - Introduce a Medium Term Budget Framework (preparations made).
- Completion of reforms expected to relieve the banking sector from remaining non-core functions (financial oversight and treasury operations).

### Monetary and exchange rate policy
- Central Bank of Uzbekistan (CBU) is "fully aware of the need to keep inflation under control" and committed to do so.
- In response to increasing inflationary pressures, the CBU tightened monetary policy considerably during 2006 and intends to tighten further in 2007.
- Newly established Fund for Reconstruction and Development (FRD) will support CBU efforts to sterilize excess money supply; the FRD will finance investment projects only through commercial banks and only for imports of investment goods.
- Exchange rate policy will continue to aim at limiting real appreciation; authorities are prepared to consider a more flexible exchange rate policy if warranted by economic developments.
- Authorities remain fully committed to currency convertibility for current account transactions, in line with Article VIII of the Fund’s Articles of Agreement.
- Comfortable official reserves, a considerable increase of the current account surplus, and tight monetary and fiscal policies "obviate the need for any administrative measures on the foreign exchange market."
- Reported sporadic irregularities in conversion transactions attributed to transitory problems related to introduction of new anti-money laundering legislation.

### Structural reforms and private sector development
- Restructuring of agricultural enterprises (shirkats) into private farms "has been mostly completed."
- New legislative acts and amendments adopted, including laws on mortgage, electronic payments, microfinancing, and collateral.
- Government orders implemented to:
  - Introduce "one-stop" registration procedures based on notification only.
  - Drastically reduce licensing requirements and streamline licensing procedures.
  - Eliminate overlap between different agencies and local governments.
  - Simplify and reduce frequency of enterprise reporting requirements.
  - Limit interferences of regulatory agencies; limit scope and frequency of inspections; make most sanctions subject to court decisions.
- These measures helped encourage SME sector growth: in 2006 alone SMEs created "440,000 new jobs" and now account for "about 42 percent of GDP."
- Authorities value IFC’s "Doing Business" report but note it "does not represent a comprehensive assessment" and should be treated with caution; they appreciate staff reference to the joint World Bank/EBRD enterprise survey, which "ranks favorably Uzbekistan’s business climate" and shows advancement in covered areas.
- Comprehensive privatization program for 2006-08 envisages privatization of "more than 1500 enterprises," including in strategic sectors (energy, chemical and transport).
  - In 2006 about "600 enterprises" were privatized, yielding privatization revenues "20 percent higher than in 2005."
  - By end-2006 the private sector’s contribution to GDP reached "79.4 percent."

### Trade integration and welfare
- Authorities agree with staff that Uzbekistan needs to advance trade liberalization to sustain long-run growth.
- Completing legal procedures related to joining EurAsEc agreements to reinforce regional integration, lower trade barriers, and grow inter-regional trade.
- Latest household surveys indicate high economic growth translates into better living standards; preliminary assessments indicate the share of poor "steadily declined over the last years."
- Authorities plan to present a full version of their Welfare Improvement Strategy (PRSP) "in the course of 2007."

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt provided in content unit _cr07133*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07133.pdf_
