## _cr07219

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr07219](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07219.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07219.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07219.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary — background, assessment, and short-term outlook
- Growth is strong; inflation and unemployment are falling.  
- Main concerns: strong credit growth, widening current-account deficit, and increased vulnerabilities.  
- National Bank of Romania (NBR) actions in 2006: focused on improving credibility of inflation-targeting (IT) framework; upward exchange-rate pressure prompted interest-rate reductions in early 2007.  
- On current policies: end-2007 inflation target will likely be missed unless sizeable appreciation occurs; current account deficit will widen further.  
- Short-term risks: manageable.  
- Medium-term risk: absent fiscal consolidation and wage restraint, an abrupt adjustment may become necessary.

### Staff views and policy advice
- Policy objectives:
  - Minimize external and financial-sector vulnerabilities.
  - Retain positive foreign-investor sentiment.
  - Maximize benefits from EU accession.
- Fiscal recommendations:
  - Limit the budget deficit to below one percent of GDP in 2007.
  - Tighten public-sector wage policy.
- Monetary recommendations:
  - Unification of the policy and the effective rates is welcome.
  - The NBR’s aggressive series of cuts is premature.
- Rationale: achieve macroeconomic stability and relieve pressure on monetary policy.

### Authorities’ views and constraints
- Authorities broadly shared staff concerns about widening current-account deficit and vulnerabilities.
- Constraints cited:
  - Substantial infrastructure and social needs.
  - Low public debt.
  - Fragile political situation.
- Fiscal stance: authorities asserted the budget deficit would not exceed their 2.8 percent of GDP target for 2007.
- NBR stance: acknowledged upside inflation risks and external imbalance risks; agreed on need for tighter fiscal and wage policy and is prepared to raise interest rates if necessary.

### Recent macroeconomic developments — selected findings
- Real GDP growth: 7.7 percent in 2006.  
- Staff estimated sustainable annual economic growth: 5-6 percent (IMF Country Report No. 06/168).  
- CPI (end-2006): 4.9 percent.  
- CPI (recent): 3.7 percent y-o-y at end-March.  
- Core inflation: remained relatively flat at 4½ percent.  
- Current account balance: -10.3 percent of GDP in 2006.  
- FDI covered 90 percent of the current account deficit (staff finding).  
- Gross external (MLT) debt: 28.6 (percent of GDP, 2006).  
- Reserve cover (months of imports): 4.8 (2006).  
- Reserves (in percent of short-term debt): 158.8 (2006).  
- Real domestic credit growth: 66 percent in 2006.  
- General government balance: -1.7 percent of GDP in 2006.  
- Real government expenditure rose by 20 percent in 2006.  
- Government revised the budget four times, increasing deficit ceiling from 0.5 percent to 2.5 percent.  
- Public-sector wages and employment:
  - Average increases of 9-15 percent (2004-07) exceeded original allocations.
  - Government employment increased by 3⅓ percent.
  - Wage bill increased by 36 percent (including retroactive wages and bonuses).
  - Minimum wage increase contained to 6½ percent; SOE wage bill controlled.

### Monetary policy, NBR credibility, and interest-rate developments
- NBR introduced IT in August 2005.  
- 2005 initial response to surge in capital inflows: heavy FX intervention and sharp interest-rate cuts rather than allowing appreciation.  
- Subsequent shift: stopped intervening and tightened conditions; in 2006 raised reference and effective rates to unified 8.75 percent.  
- Early-2007: sharp appreciation since end-November 2006 led NBR to limit liquidity absorbed at policy rate, channel excess liquidity to low-yield deposit facility, driving effective rate below policy rate.  
- NBR reduced policy rate to 8 percent on February 9, 2007, and later to 7½ percent (subsequent action).  
- Staff view: cuts were premature; reunification of policy and effective rates urged; step up sterilization to bring effective rate in line with policy rate of 8 percent would represent moderate tightening.

### Competitiveness and real exchange rate assessment
- Equilibrium-based indicators suggest room for further appreciation at a measured pace.  
- Manufacturing wages in U.S. dollars used as RER proxy: an implied gap of some 20 percent between actual and equilibrium wage remains.  
- PPP-based measures: transition economies generally showed undervaluation during transition with trend real appreciation over the past decade.  
- Staff view: recent exchange-rate developments are structural and not yet cause for undue alarm; monitor productivity closely.

### Fiscal developments, spending patterns, and public-wage policy
- Key fiscal table entries (percent of GDP, preserving table layout where adjacent values correspond to 2006, 2007 Prel./Staff Proj. columns as presented):
  - Real GDP growth: 7.7 7.0 6.5 4.8
  - CPI (end of period): 4.9 5.5 4.5 4.8
  - Current account balance: -10.3 -11.7 -10.2 -9.6
  - General government balance: -1.7 -2.8 -0.9 -0.7
  - Reserve cover (months of imports): 4.8 4.5 5.0 4.9
  - Reserves (in percent of short-term debt): 158.8 145.8 156.8 163.9
  - Gross external (MLT) debt: 28.6 26.4 26.1 25.1
  - Public debt: 18.5 18.7 17.3 15.1
- Staff assessment of 2007 budget:
  - Authorities’ approved 2007 budget targets a deficit of 2.8 percent of GDP — staff view this as a significant expansion in the cyclically-adjusted fiscal deficit.
  - Staff projects underlying deficit of 3½ percent of GDP on current policies.
  - Recognition of additional Property-Fund claims and drawings on National Development Fund would add to cash deficit.
- Government revenue and expenditure (selected table entries, percent of GDP as presented):
  - Total revenue: 30.1 30.2 31.5 31.2 34.1 33.5 34.1
  - Tax revenue: 27.1 27.2 27.9 28.3 29.8 29.3 29.5
  - Personal income tax: 2.9 2.4 2.6 2.9 3.4 3.4 3.4
  - Corporate income tax: 3.0 2.7 2.8 2.7 3.0 3.0 3.0
  - VAT: 6.7 7.8 8.1 8.1 9.0 8.4 8.4
  - Total expenditure: 31.1 31.0 32.0 32.9 36.8 36.3 34.9
  - Current expenditure: 28.3 28.3 28.8 29.2 32.2 32.1 31.2
  - Personnel: 4.8 5.4 5.5 6.1 6.2 6.4 6.2
  - Goods and services: 7.3 7.5 6.4 6.6 7.1 7.0 6.7
  - Capital expenditure: 2.8 2.6 3.2 3.7 4.6 4.2 3.7
  - Overall balance: -1.0 -0.8 -0.5 -1.7 -2.7 -2.8 -0.9
  - Primary expenditure: 29.8 29.9 30.9 32.1 35.9 35.4 34.1
  - Primary balance: 0.2 0.3 0.6 -0.9 -1.8 -1.9 0.0
- Public-sector wage policy:
  - Government approved significant wage increases for 2007 (up to 20 percent on average) in three rounds; minimum wage raised by 18 percent.
  - Staff warned these increases are incompatible with inflation objectives and recommended reducing envisaged increases, controlling bonuses, monitoring hirings, and limiting raises to once a year incorporated in the budget.
- Structural fiscal weaknesses identified:
  - Multiple budget revisions, inadequate medium-term objectives, year-end expenditure spikes, and weak EU-fund absorption mechanisms.
  - Staff suggestions: establish mechanisms for efficient EU inflows absorption, avoid multiple revisions, improve public-spending management, and develop credible medium-term framework.

### External vulnerabilities, sudden-stop risk, and staff scenarios
- Short-term cushion: high FDI coverage, low external debt, and comfortable reserve coverage mitigate immediate sudden-stop risk.  
- Staff sudden-stop model (selected country estimates):
  - Romania: Current Account Deficit, 2006 = 10.3; Baseline growth impact of sudden stop = -7.4; Recovery in t+1 = 4.1.
  - Romania (with 5 ppt reduction in current account deficit): Growth impact = -5.9; Recovery in t+1 = 3.8.
  - Immediate GDP impact of a sudden stop could be as high as 7-8 percentage points with some recovery in the first year.
- Debt sustainability (staff baseline):
  - Sustainable current account deficit estimated at 8 percent of GDP to stabilize external debt-to-GDP ratio at 30 percent.
  - Scenario assumes continued FDI inflows and a gradual slowdown in privatization-related flows in outer years.

### Financial sector resilience and supervision
- Banking system: liquid, well capitalized, profitable; return on equity high; NPL ratios moderate.  
- Ownership: banking system almost 90 percent foreign owned.  
- Supervisory progress:
  - NBR published first Financial Stability Report in May 2006; second report due by mid-2007.
  - NBR stress tests suggest resilience to direct interest-rate and exchange-rate shocks and to a growth slowdown; indirect exposures from rapid credit growth harder to assess.
  - NBR balance-sheet analysis: corporate debt-service capacity healthy and rising; unhedged household borrowing is a concern.
  - Memoranda of Understanding signed for all foreign banks; NBR staff participate in cross-border drills.
  - Mission welcomed authorities’ desire for an FSAP update.

### Staff policy recommendations — summary
- Fiscal:
  - Withdraw fiscal stimulus in the year, target a budget deficit below 1 percent of GDP.
  - Majority of adjustment should be on expenditure; proposed adjustment: ¾ percent of GDP relative to 2006 outturn (1.9 percent relative to government target), with tighter incomes policy.
  - Strengthen revenue administration: modernize, broaden base, address Agency for Fiscal Administration shortcomings.
  - Strengthen transparency, monitoring, and develop credible medium-term fiscal framework; conduct ROSC update.
- Wage policy:
  - Strict public-sector wage policy: increases only once a year, moderate, transparent, and fully budgeted.
- Monetary and macroprudential:
  - Reunify policy and effective rates; step up sterilization to align effective rate with policy rate.
  - Stand ready to increase rates to ensure inflation targets remain within reach.
  - Maintain vigilance on credit growth; first-best response to excess demand is higher interest rates.
  - Lower reserve requirements cautiously given their high level relative to EU.
- Structural reforms:
  - Accelerate energy-sector privatization.
  - Announce schedule for domestic producer gas price adjustments toward import parity.
  - Strategy to increase labor-market participation and employment.
  - Strengthen second pension pillar preparation (planned introduction January 1, 2008).
  - Forcefully implement judicial reform agenda.

### Executive Board assessment — main findings and guidance
- Commended: strong output and export growth, substantial disinflation, low external debt, comfortable international reserves, and EU accession achievement.  
- Key vulnerabilities reiterated: widening current-account imbalance, rapid credit growth, and procyclical fiscal and incomes policies.  
- Fiscal guidance:
  - Urged tighter fiscal stance in 2007 to contain domestic demand.
  - Emphasized permanent revenue-raising measures, strengthening tax administration, and prudent medium-term fiscal goals.
  - Warned against multiple budget revisions and back-loaded expenditure.
- Wage policy guidance:
  - Considered envisaged wage increases incompatible with inflation objective; urged single annual moderate increases fully budgeted.
- Monetary guidance:
  - Considered recent interest-rate cuts premature; urged raising interest rates as needed to attain inflation targets and avoid divergence between policy and effective rates.
- Financial supervision:
  - Emphasized importance of effective domestic and cross-border supervision; welcomed FSAP update.

### Selected indicators and projections (selected table snapshots, preserving numeric values)
- Real GDP (change in percent): 2002: 5.1; 2003: 5.2; 2004: 8.5; 2005: 4.1; 2006: 7.7; 2007 Prel./Baseline/Staff projections: 6.0/6.5.  
- CPI (end of period): 2002: 17.8; 2003: 14.1; 2004: 9.3; 2005: 8.6; 2006: 4.9; 2007 Baseline: 5.5; 2007 Staff: 4.5.  
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2002: -3.3; 2003: -5.8; 2004: -8.4; 2005: -8.7; 2006: -10.3; 2007 Baseline: -11.7; 2007 Staff: -10.2.  
- Current account balance (in millions of euros): 2006: -9,973; 2007 Baseline: -14,124; 2007 Staff: -12,385.  
- Exports (millions of euros): 2006: 25,850; 2007 Baseline/Staff: 29,995.  
- Imports (millions of euros): 2006: -37,609; 2007 Baseline: -46,269; 2007 Staff: -45,123.  
- Gross official reserves (end-year, US$ million): 2006: 28,155; 2007 Baseline: 30,030; 2007 Staff: 32,288.  
- Reserve cover (months): 2006: 4.8; 2007 Baseline: 4.5; 2007 Staff: 5.0.  
- Total external debt (millions of €): 2006: 41,141; 2007 Baseline: 47,521; 2007 Staff: 47,493.  
- Total external debt/GDP: 2006: 42.4; 2007 Baseline: 39.5; 2007 Staff: 39.2.  
- Revenue (percent of GDP): 2006: 31.2; 2007 Baseline: 33.5; 2007 Staff: 34.1.  
- Expenditure (percent of GDP): 2006: 32.9; 2007 Baseline: 34.9; 2007 Staff: 36.3.  
- Overall balance (percent of GDP): 2006: -1.7; 2007 Baseline: -2.8; 2007 Staff: -0.9.  
- Total public debt (percent of GDP): 2006: 18.5; 2007 Baseline: 17.3; 2007 Staff: 17.3.  
- Nominal domestic credit (end of year, percent change): 2006: 66.1; 2007 Staff: 58.4; 2007 Staff (alternate table): 39.5.  
- Real domestic credit (composite adjusted / table contexts): 2006: 29.4; 2007 Staff: 42.4/36.0.  
- NBR interest rate (end of period): 2006: 8.8; subsequent cuts to 8.00 percent and then to 7.5 percent noted in 2007 narrative.  
- Financial soundness indicators (selected): CAR: 2006: 17.8; NPLs/Gross Loans: 2006: 8.4; Return on Average Assets: 2006: 1.7.

### Key policy priorities and actionables
- Immediate:
  - Tighten fiscal and incomes policies to relieve burden on monetary policy.
  - Reunify policy and effective interest rates and step up sterilization to align effective rate with policy rate.
  - Stand ready to increase interest rates if inflation targets are at risk.
- Medium term:
  - Aim for budget deficit below 1 percent of GDP in 2007 through expenditure-based adjustment.
  - Implement strict public-sector wage policy: single annual, moderate raises fully budgeted.
  - Strengthen tax administration and broaden tax base; resist tax cuts (except social contributions) and distortionary exemptions.
  - Improve public-spending management, avoid multiple budget revisions, and establish credible medium-term fiscal framework.
  - Accelerate structural reforms: energy-sector privatization, gas-price adjustments toward import parity, labor-market reforms, second pension pillar introduction, judicial reform.
- Financial-sector safeguards:
  - Maintain effective supervision and high capital ratios; encourage conservative provisioning.
  - Monitor rapid credit growth, especially unhedged foreign-currency lending to households.
  - Proceed cautiously on lowering reserve requirements.

*Source: Executive Summary and selected sections, _cr07219 — IMF staff report and Executive Board assessment (document excerpts provided).*

### Executive Summary

### _cr07219 - Executive Summary

### Background and overall assessment
- Growth is strong, while inflation and unemployment are falling.  
- Concerns stem from strong credit growth, a widening current-account deficit, and attendant increase in vulnerabilities.  
- During 2006, the National Bank of Romania (NBR) focused on improving the credibility of the inflation-targeting framework, but upward exchange rate pressure has prompted it to reduce interest rates.  
- On current policies, the end-2007 inflation target will likely be missed, unless sizeable appreciation occurs, and the current account deficit will widen further.  
- Short-term risks are manageable but, in the absence of a change in macroeconomic policies, an abrupt adjustment may become necessary.

### Staff views and policy advice
- Policy objectives: minimize external and financial-sector vulnerabilities, retain positive foreign-investor sentiment, and maximize benefits from EU accession.  
- Fiscal recommendations:
  - Limit the budget deficit to below one percent of GDP in 2007.  
  - Tighten public-sector wage policy.  
- Monetary recommendations:
  - Recent unification of the policy and the effective rates is welcome.  
  - The NBR’s aggressive series of cuts is premature.  
- Rationale: to achieve macroeconomic stability and relieve some pressure off monetary policy.

### Authorities’ views
- Authorities broadly shared the staff’s assessment and agreed that the widening current account deficit and its attendant vulnerabilities are cause for concern.  
- Constraints cited by authorities:
  - Substantial infrastructure and social needs.  
  - Low public debt.  
  - Fragile political situation.  
- Fiscal stance: authorities noted that the budget deficit would not exceed their 2.8 percent of GDP target this year.  
- NBR stance: acknowledged upside risks in the inflation outlook and risks of larger external imbalances; agreed with the need for tighter fiscal and wage policy and is prepared to raise interest rates if need be.

### Recent macroeconomic developments (selected findings)
- Economic growth:
  - Real GDP growth: 7.7 percent in 2006 (Table 1).  
  - Staff estimated sustainable annual economic growth of 5-6 percent (as outlined in IMF Country Report No. 06/168).  
- Inflation:
  - CPI: 4.9 percent (end-2006).  
  - CPI was 3.7 percent y-o-y at end-March (recent).  
  - Core inflation remained relatively flat at 4½ percent.  
- External balances and reserves:
  - Current account balance: -10.3 percent of GDP in 2006.  
  - FDI covered 90 percent of the current account deficit (staff finding).  
  - Gross external (MLT) debt: 28.6 (percent of GDP, 2006).  
  - Reserve cover (months of imports): 4.8 (2006).  
  - Reserves (in percent of short-term debt): 158.8 (2006).  
- Credit and domestic demand:
  - Real domestic credit grew by 66 percent in 2006.  
  - Rapid credit expansion included both leu- and foreign-currency denominated credit.  
- Competitiveness and real exchange rate:
  - Romania experienced significant appreciation in 2005 after adopting greater exchange-rate flexibility and capital-account liberalization; real appreciation moderated in 2006.  
  - Staff analysis indicates Romania’s exchange rate remains competitive and that there exists margin for further appreciation at a measured pace without unduly impacting the external balance.  
- Fiscal developments:
  - General government balance: -1.7 percent of GDP in 2006 (annual deficit).  
  - Fiscal stance: policy remained tight until November 2006; a substantial loosening took place in December 2006.  
  - More than 40 percent of the capital budget was spent in December 2006 alone.  
  - Real government expenditure rose by 20 percent in 2006.  
  - The government revised the budget four times, increasing the deficit ceiling from 0.5 percent of GDP to 2.5 percent.  
- Public sector wages and employment:
  - Substantial real increases in government wages during 2004-07 outpaced private sector wages.  
  - Average increases of 9-15 percent exceeded original wage allocations.  
  - Government employment increased by 3⅓ percent.  
  - The wage bill increased by 36 percent (including retroactive wages for teachers and judges and payment of bonuses).  
  - The government kept the minimum wage increase to 6½ percent and controlled SOEs’ wage bill.

### Boxed staff evaluation highlights (summary of Box 1 and Box 2)
- Fund Policy Recommendations and Implementation (Box 1):
  - Authorities broadly followed Fund advice historically, but recent policies diverged: fiscal loosening in December 2006 and a procyclical 2007 budget; substantial government wage increases in 2004-07 that exacerbated demand pressures; monetary policy generally aligned with Fund advice and successful in lowering inflation; progress on privatization but domestic gas prices remain below international prices and judicial reform implementation is pending.  
- Competitiveness assessment (Box 2, referenced):
  - Trend real appreciation is expected as price levels in Romania are still only half the euro-zone average; rising manufacturing profitability, strong productivity gains, good export performance, and substantial foreign investment support a measured pace of further appreciation without unduly harming external balances.

### Risks and adjustment scenarios
- Short-term risks: manageable given FDI coverage of deficits, low external debt, and comfortable reserve coverage.  
- Medium-term risks: continued loose fiscal and wage policy combined with rapid credit growth could necessitate an abrupt adjustment.  
- Staff view: absent changes in macroeconomic policies—fiscal consolidation and wage restraint—vulnerabilities from widening current-account deficits and financial-sector exposure will increase.

*Source: Executive Summary, _cr07219 - Executive Summary*

### 6.      Following an inauspicious start, the NBR improved the credibility of its inflation

### _cr07219 - 6.      Following an inauspicious start, the NBR improved the credibility of its inflation

### Monetary policy and inflation-targeting credibility
- The NBR introduced IT in August 2005.
- Initial policy response to a surge in capital inflows: intervened heavily in the foreign exchange market and reduced interest rates sharply, rather than allowing further appreciation.
- Subsequent policy shift: the NBR stopped intervening and tightened monetary conditions.
- In 2006, the NBR raised the reference policy interest rate, as well as the effective rate, to a unified level of 8.75 percent.
- Early-2007 developments:
  - Sharp appreciation since end-November 2006 led the NBR to limit the amount of liquidity absorbed at the policy rate and channel excess liquidity into the NBR’s low-yield deposit facility.
  - This drove the effective interest rate below the policy rate.
  - The NBR reduced the policy rate to 8 percent on February 9.
  - The re-emergence of a gap between the effective and policy rates strengthened the perception that the inflation-targeting NBR is also concerned about the pace of appreciation.

### Competitiveness and real exchange rate (RER) assessment
- Equilibrium-based indicators suggest room for further appreciation, at a measured pace.
- Manufacturing wages in U.S. dollars used as a proxy for the RER.
- Results:
  - Romania’s RER was significantly undervalued throughout the 1990s.
  - Although undervaluation narrowed since 2000, an implied gap of some 20 percent between the actual and the equilibrium wage remains.
- PPP-based measures yield similar results: transition economies showed undervalued exchange rates for most of the transition, with a trend real appreciation over the past decade.
- Staff view: recent exchange-rate developments are part of a larger structural process and should not yet be viewed with undue alarm, while authorities should monitor productivity developments closely.

### Fiscal developments, public-sector wages, and spending patterns
- Recent fiscal consolidation described as "good", but revenue is low, spending uneven, and a significant loosening is planned.
- Key fiscal figures and staff projections (percent of GDP unless otherwise indicated):
  - Real GDP growth: 7.7 7.0 6.5 4.8 (presented in table as 2006, 2007, 2008 Prel./Staff Proj. columns)
  - CPI (end of period): 4.9 5.5 4.5 4.8
  - Current account balance: -10.3 -11.7 -10.2 -9.6
  - General government balance: -1.7 -2.8 -0.9 -0.7
  - Reserve cover (months of imports): 4.8 4.5 5.0 4.9
  - Reserves (in percent of short-term debt): 158.8 145.8 156.8 163.9
  - Gross external (MLT) debt: 28.6 26.4 26.1 25.1
  - Public debt: 18.5 18.7 17.3 15.1
- Staff assessment of the approved 2007 budget and staff projections:
  - Budget targets a deficit of 2.8 percent of GDP, which staff view as a significant expansion in the cyclically-adjusted fiscal deficit.
  - Staff projects underlying deficit of 3½ percent of GDP on current policies.
  - Staff note recognition of additional Property-Fund claims and drawings on the National Development Fund would add further to the cash deficit.
- Detailed government revenue and expenditure (selected entries, in percent of GDP and preserving table entries):
  - Total revenue: 30.1 30.2 31.5 31.2 34.1 33.5 34.1
  - Tax revenue: 27.1 27.2 27.9 28.3 29.8 29.3 29.5
  - Personal income tax: 2.9 2.4 2.6 2.9 3.4 3.4 3.4
  - Corporate income tax: 3.0 2.7 2.8 2.7 3.0 3.0 3.0
  - VAT: 6.7 7.8 8.1 8.1 9.0 8.4 8.4
  - Total expenditure: 31.1 31.0 32.0 32.9 36.8 36.3 34.9
  - Current expenditure: 28.3 28.3 28.8 29.2 32.2 32.1 31.2
  - Personnel: 4.8 5.4 5.5 6.1 6.2 6.4 6.2
  - Goods and services: 7.3 7.5 6.4 6.6 7.1 7.0 6.7
  - Capital expenditure: 2.8 2.6 3.2 3.7 4.6 4.2 3.7
  - Overall balance: -1.0 -0.8 -0.5 -1.7 -2.7 -2.8 -0.9
  - Primary expenditure: 29.8 29.9 30.9 32.1 35.9 35.4 34.1
  - Primary balance: 0.2 0.3 0.6 -0.9 -1.8 -1.9 0.0
- Public-sector wage policy and employment:
  - Government approved significant wage increases for 2007 (up to 20 percent on average) in three rounds; the minimum wage raised by 18 percent.
  - Monitoring of SOEs’ wage bill has eased.
  - Staff warned risks: incompatibility with inflation objectives, recommendation to reduce envisaged increases, control bonuses, closely monitor hirings, and limit frequency of raises to once a year and incorporate into the budget.
- Structural fiscal weaknesses identified:
  - Multiple budget revisions undermine credibility.
  - Medium-term policies and objectives not adequately elaborated.
  - Expenditures increase sharply at year-end.
  - Staff suggestions: establish mechanisms for efficient allocation and absorption of EU inflows, avoid multiple budget revisions, improve public-spending management, develop a credible medium-term framework.

### External vulnerabilities, sudden-stop risk, and staff scenarios
- Concerns about widening external imbalance and overheating economy:
  - Overheating combined with envisaged fiscal and incomes policy would add to demand, widen the current account deficit, and increase inflationary pressures.
  - Delay in strengthening macroeconomic policies increases risk of a change in market sentiment, reduction in capital inflows, and a destabilizing swing in the exchange rate.
  - Potential outcomes include growth slowdown, depreciation, weakened debt-service capacity of households and enterprises, and strain on the banking system.
- Box 3: Impact of a Sudden Stop
  - Staff model focuses on: i) external vulnerability (real exchange rate adjustment needed if deficit brought to zero); and ii) internal vulnerability (currency-related balance-sheet mismatches).
  - Results suggest risks of a stop are kept in check by Romania’s strong FDI financing, but FDI can slow sharply.
  - Immediate impact on GDP growth from a sudden stop could be as high as 7-8 percentage points, with some recovery in the first year after the crisis.
  - Estimation results for a sudden stop (growth impact and recovery):
    - Romania: Current Account Deficit, 2006 = 10.3; Baseline growth impact of sudden stop = -7.4; Recovery in t+1 = 4.1. With a 5 ppt reduction in the current account deficit: Growth impact = -5.9; Recovery in t+1 = 3.8.
    - Bulgaria: Current Account Deficit, 2006 = 15.9; Baseline growth impact = -8.5; Recovery in t+1 = 4.2. With a 5 ppt reduction: Growth impact = -7.2; Recovery in t+1 = 4.1.
- Debt sustainability and baseline staff scenario:
  - Staff updated debt sustainability analysis points to a sustainable current account deficit of 8 percent of GDP, which would stabilize the external debt-to-GDP ratio at 30 percent.
  - Scenario assumes continued FDI inflows, shift away from privatization-related flows, followed by a gradual slowdown in the outer years.

### Staff policy recommendations and authorities’ positions
- Staff recommendations:
  - Tighten fiscal and incomes policies to relieve some burden on monetary policy.
  - Advocate withdrawal of fiscal stimulus and a smooth path for medium-term consolidation.
  - Given limits to revenue measures this year, majority of adjustment should fall on expenditure.
  - Proposed adjustment: ¾ percent of GDP relative to the 2006 outturn (1.9 percent relative to the government target), accompanied by tighter incomes policy.
  - Resist tax cuts except for relatively-high social contributions tax and distortionary exemptions (e.g., reduced VAT rate, exemption of reinvested profits, differentiated car-registration tax).
  - Strengthen revenue administration: modernize administration, broaden tax base, address organizational and legal shortcomings of the Agency for Fiscal Administration.
  - Strengthen transparency, monitoring, and develop a credible medium-term fiscal framework; conduct a ROSC update.
- Authorities’ positions:
  - Acknowledged need for fiscal restraint but highlighted pressing infrastructure and social needs, political constraints, and favorable debt position.
  - Felt confident the 2.8 percent deficit ceiling would not be exceeded and found staff-proposed adjustment infeasible.
  - Noted planned significant wage increases and difficulty attracting high-skilled staff; emphasized tax-administration improvements rather than tax changes.
  - Agreed on need to strengthen budgetary process but hesitant to adopt medium-term expenditure ceilings.

*Source: _cr07219 - 6.      Following an inauspicious start, the NBR improved the credibility of its inflation*

### 18.      The NBR faces a challenging environment. Its policy guidelines call for entry into

### 18.      The NBR faces a challenging environment. Its policy guidelines call for entry into 

### Monetary policy framework and euro adoption timetable
- Policy guidelines call for entry into ERM-II by 2010-12, and euro adoption by 2012–14.
- Staff view: the timetable is feasible and appropriate, but implies the NBR has only 4-6 years to bring nominal-convergence criteria down to Maastricht levels.
- Long-run sustainable solution: lower nominal interest rates by firmly anchoring inflationary expectations through a credible inflation-targeting framework.

### Inflation outlook and policy priorities
- Staff urged the NBR to focus on inflation and reunify the policy and effective interest rates as soon as possible.
- At the time of the mission:
  - Effective rate was about 6½ percent.
  - Official policy rate was 8 percent.
- Staff recommendation:
  - Step up sterilization operations to bring the effective rate in line with the policy rate of 8 percent.
  - This would reassert the signaling role of the official policy rate and represent a moderate monetary tightening.
  - With appropriate fiscal restraint, consistent with meeting authorities’ inflation targets for 2007 and 2008 of 4.0 and 3.8 percent, respectively.
- Staff view: these targets are feasible and reflect a realistic balance between rapid disinflation and ongoing structural change.
- Risks: significant risks to the inflation outlook; if authorities do not tighten fiscal and incomes policies, the NBR may have to increase interest rates further.

### NBR reaction and assessments of monetary conditions
- NBR assessment:
  - Agreed with staff overall but suggested that previous appreciation and higher reserve requirements meant monetary conditions were tighter than staff allowed.
  - Agreed Romania enjoyed a margin of competitiveness.
  - Did not accept that concern about pace of appreciation is necessarily inconsistent with an inflation-targeting commitment.
  - Concern: excessive short-term appreciation could leave the economy vulnerable to a sudden reversal, adversely impacting disinflation and financial-sector health.
- Subsequent action:
  - Following the mission, the NBR reduced the official policy rate further to 7½ percent.
  - Market interpretation: move highlighted NBR’s focus on recent appreciation rather than future inflation.
- Staff view on the cut:
  - Considered aggressive loosening premature.
  - An effective nominal rate of 7½ percent is, in real terms, only marginally above the estimated neutral rate and will do little to close the output gap.
  - Under staff baseline, if rates are maintained at this level and fiscal and incomes policies proceed as planned:
    - Resulting rise in excess demand will likely push inflation above the upper band of the NBR target range.
    - Will lead to a further widening of the current account deficit.
- Staff recommendation: NBR should stand ready to increase rates to ensure inflation targets remain within reach.

### Credit growth, reserve requirements, and macroprudential considerations
- Both sides expressed concern about the ongoing pace of credit growth.
- Staff observations:
  - Real convergence will naturally require an expanding financial sector, but current credit demand partly reflects strength of excess demand.
  - Overly-rapid credit growth can magnify distortions and raise medium-term vulnerabilities.
  - Administrative measures are often less effective over time and ill-suited to macro stabilization; first-best response to excess demand is higher interest rates.
  - On reserve requirements: levels in Romania are significantly higher than in the EU; efforts to lower them should proceed cautiously.
    - High reserve requirements impose added cost on domestic banks and encourage disintermediation.
    - Authorities should take care that lowered reserves do not add to macroeconomic imbalances.
- Staff urged vigilance and maintenance of effective supervision and regulation.

### Financial sector resilience and supervisory capacity
- Banking sector position:
  - Banking system remains liquid, well capitalized, and profitable.
  - Rates of return on equity and capital-adequacy ratios are high; non-performing loan (NPL) ratios remain at moderate levels.
  - Banking system is now almost 90 percent foreign owned.
  - Foreign banks: aggressive lenders with relatively sophisticated risk-management policies and potential external support in local liquidity problems.
- Supervisory progress:
  - NBR published its first Financial Stability Report in May 2006 and will release a second report by mid-2007.
  - NBR stress tests suggest resilience to direct impact of interest-rate and exchange-rate movements, and to a growth slowdown.
  - Indirect exposures through loan portfolios amid rapid credit growth are more difficult to assess.
  - NBR balance-sheet analysis indicates corporate-sector debt-service capacity is healthy and rising; unhedged household borrowing is a concern.
  - Staff urged authorities to encourage high capital ratios and conservative provisioning practices.
  - Memoranda of Understanding have been signed for all banks with presence in Romania; NBR staff participate in drills with other authorities for coordinated cross-border responses.
  - Mission welcomed authorities’ desire to have an FSAP update this year.

### Structural policies and reforms to support real convergence
- Agreement: structural reforms are crucial for real convergence.
- Authorities acknowledged need to:
  - Continue domestic gas price adjustments in line with opportunity cost developments and commitment to achieve import parity, though hesitant to announce a specific schedule.
  - Increase labor-market participation and employment rates through improved education, training, and enhanced labor-market flexibility.
  - Strengthen preparations for the second pension pillar and aimed to introduce it on January 1, 2008.
  - Proceed with privatization in the energy sector (staff regretted CEC privatization postponement and noted need to proceed with energy-sector privatizations).
  - Develop the capital market.
  - Tackle corruption and forcefully implement the judicial reform agenda.

### Staff appraisal and policy recommendations (summarized)
- Overall assessment:
  - Romania’s prospects remain bright, but outlook clouded by widening imbalances driven by domestic demand, rapid credit growth, and procyclical fiscal and incomes policies.
  - Current juncture presents an opportunity to implement reforms to enhance growth potential and narrow income gap with the EU.
- Fiscal policy:
  - Aim at withdrawing fiscal stimulus this year, targeting a budget deficit of below 1 percent of GDP.
  - Majority of adjustment must fall on expenditure; scope for revenue measures is limited.
  - Caution urged on using National Development Fund and additional Property Fund claims (would result in a larger deficit).
  - Case for permanently strengthening revenue through broadening the tax base and modernizing tax administration; resist calls for tax reduction (except social contributions) and distortionary exemptions.
- Wage policy:
  - Strict public-sector wage policy needed for successful disinflation and macro stability.
  - Approved public-sector wage increases deemed incompatible with inflation objective.
  - Wage policy should feature wage increases only once a year, moderate, transparent, and fully incorporated in the budget.
- Institutional and budgetary improvements:
  - Improve fiscal transparency, monitoring, and adopt a credible medium-term framework.
  - Improve efficiency of absorbing EU funds; avoid multiple budget revisions; improve expenditure management to ensure uniform spending pattern over the year.
- Financial and monetary policy reiteration:
  - Central bank faces difficult environment; immediate challenge is to firmly anchor inflationary expectations.
  - Recent aggressive interest-rate cuts appear premature given strong excess demand and potential reemergence of inflationary pressures.
  - Staff welcomes reunification of policy and effective interest rates but considers 7½ percent insufficient to curb excess demand.
  - Lowering reserve requirements should proceed cautiously.
- Structural reform acceleration:
  - Accelerate privatization in the energy sector.
  - Announce schedule for increased domestic producer gas prices in line with opportunity costs.
  - Put together strategy to increase labor-market participation and employment rates.
  - Strengthen efforts for introduction of the second pension pillar.
  - Forcefully implement judicial reform agenda.

*Source: IMF staff report content provided in the supplied PDF excerpt.*

### 34.      It is proposed that the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-month

### _cr07219 - 34.      It is proposed that the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-month

### Article IV consultation cycle
- Romania is on a 12-month consultation cycle.
- The last consultation was concluded on April 26, 2006.
- It is proposed that the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

### Real economy: recent outcomes and staff projections (selected indicators)
- Real GDP (change in percent): 2002: 5.1; 2003: 5.2; 2004: 8.5; 2005: 4.1; 2006: 7.7; 2007 (Prel./Baseline/Staff projections): 6.0/6.5.
- Final domestic demand (change in percent): 2002: 5.5; 2003: 8.3; 2004: 10.4; 2005: 10.1; 2006: 12.5; 2007 Baseline: 10.8; 2007 Staff: 9.1.
- CPI (end of period): 2002: 17.8; 2003: 14.1; 2004: 9.3; 2005: 8.6; 2006: 4.9; 2007 Baseline: 5.5; 2007 Staff: 4.5.
- CPI (period average): 2002: 22.5; 2003: 15.3; 2004: 11.9; 2005: 9.0; 2006: 6.6; 2007 Baseline: 4.8; 2007 Staff: 4.4.
- Unemployment rate (end of period; percent): 2002: 8.4; 2003: 7.2; 2004: 6.2; 2005: 5.8; 2006: 5.4; 2007 Baseline: 5.1; 2007 Staff: 5.1.

### Balance of payments and external sector (selected figures)
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2002: -3.3; 2003: -5.8; 2004: -8.4; 2005: -8.7; 2006: -10.3; 2007 Baseline: -11.7; 2007 Staff: -10.2.
- Trade balance (percent of GDP): 2002: -5.7; 2003: -7.5; 2004: -8.8; 2005: -9.8; 2006: -12.1; 2007 Baseline: -13.5; 2007 Staff: -12.5.
- Current account balance (in millions of euros): 2002: -1,623; 2003: -3,060; 2004: -5,099; 2005: -6,883; 2006: -9,973; 2007 Baseline: -14,124; 2007 Staff: -12,385.
- Current account balance plus FDI (percent of GDP): 2002: 0.2; 2003: -2.1; 2004: 0.0; 2005: -2.1; 2006: -0.9; 2007 Baseline: -5.3; 2007 Staff: -3.8.
- Exports (in millions of euros): 2002: 14,675; 2003: 15,614; 2004: 18,935; 2005: 22,255; 2006: 25,850; 2007 Baseline: 29,995; 2007 Staff: 29,995.
- Imports (in millions of euros): 2002: -17,427; 2003: -19,569; 2004: -24,258; 2005: -30,061; 2006: -37,609; 2007 Baseline: -46,269; 2007 Staff: -45,123.
- Gross official reserves (end-year, US$ million / table values): 2002: 7,137; 2003: 9,208; 2004: 15,999; 2005: 21,648; 2006: 28,155; 2007 Baseline: 30,030; 2007 Staff: 32,288.
- Reserve cover (months of prospective imports, in € terms): 2002: 3.8; 2003: 3.3; 2004: 4.1; 2005: 5.1; 2006: 4.8; 2007 Baseline: 4.5; 2007 Staff: 5.0.
- Total external debt (in millions of €): 2002: 16,157; 2003: 17,734; 2004: 21,762; 2005: 31,093; 2006: 41,141; 2007 Baseline: 47,521; 2007 Staff: 47,493.
- Total external debt/GDP: 2002: 33.3; 2003: 33.7; 2004: 35.8; 2005: 39.3; 2006: 42.4; 2007 Baseline: 39.5; 2007 Staff: 39.2.

### Public finance (general government) — levels, balances, and projections
- Revenue (percent of GDP): 2002: 29.6; 2003: 28.7; 2004: 30.0; 2005: 30.2; 2006: 31.2; 2007 Baseline: 33.5; 2007 Staff: 34.1.
- Expenditure (percent of GDP): 2002: 32.3; 2003: 30.9; 2004: 31.1; 2005: 31.0; 2006: 32.9; 2007 Baseline: 34.9; 2007 Staff: 36.3.
- Overall balance (percent of GDP): 2002: -2.6; 2003: -2.2; 2004: -1.0; 2005: -0.8; 2006: -1.7; 2007 Baseline: -2.8; 2007 Staff: -0.9.
- Primary balance (percent of GDP): 2002: 0.4; 2003: -0.2; 2004: 0.2; 2005: 0.3; 2006: -0.9; 2007 Baseline: -1.9; 2007 Staff: 0.0.
- Total public debt (percent of GDP; includes domestic and external public debt, public and publicly guaranteed): 2002: 26.0; 2003: 23.6; 2004: 23.2; 2005: 19.9; 2006: 18.5; 2007 Baseline: 17.3; 2007 Staff: 17.3.
- The 2007 budget deficit target (authorities') is 2.8 percent of GDP. This is equivalent to 2.7 percent using the staff's baseline-scenario GDP.
- Table 3 (consolidated government, selected 2005–07 levels in millions of Lei and percent of GDP): Total revenue 2005 Actual: 86,964.4; 2006 Approved Budget: 101,481.6; 2007 Approved Budget: 109,632.8 / Total expenditure 2005 Actual: 89,218.3; 2006 Approved Budget: 103,093.6; 2007 Approved Budget: 117,999.8 / Overall Balance 2005 Actual: -2,253.9; 2006 Approved Budget: -1,612.0; 2007 Approved Budget: -8,367.0.

### Monetary and financial sector indicators
- Broad money (percent change, 12-month): 2002: 38.2; 2003: 23.3; 2004: 34.4; 2005: 40.1; 2006: 33.8; 2007 Staff: 29.4.
- Nominal domestic credit (end of year, percent change): 2002: 38.1; 2003: 64.4; 2004: 40.5; 2005: 37.2; 2006: 66.1; 2007 Staff: 58.4; 2007 (another table) Staff: 39.5 (two table contexts).
- Real domestic credit (composite adjusted): 2002: 38.2; 2003: 23.3; 2004: 40.1; 2005: 33.8; 2006: 29.4; 2007 Staff: 42.4/36.0 (table-dependent).
- NBR interest rate (end of period; NBR effective policy rate, compounded): 2002: 21.5; 2003: 23.4; 2004: 18.8; 2005: 7.2; 2006: 8.8.
- Treasury bill rate (end of period): 2002: 17.4; 2003: 18.4; 2004: 11.5; 2005: 5.5; 2006: 5.5.
- Financial soundness indicators (selected 2003–06): Number of banks: 2003: 38; 2004: 39; 2005: 39; 2006: 37. CAR: 2003: 20.0; 2004: 18.8; 2005: 20.2; 2006: 17.8. NPLs/Gross Loans: 2003: 8.3; 2004: 8.1; 2005: 8.3; 2006: 8.4. Return on Average Assets: 2003: 2.7; 2004: 2.5; 2005: 1.9; 2006: 1.7.

### Debt sustainability and vulnerability assessments
- Public sector debt (percent of GDP): 2002: 26.0; 2003: 23.6; 2004: 23.2; 2005: 19.9; 2006: 18.5; 2007: 17.3; projections decline to 11.6 by 2012 (Table 10).
- Debt-stabilizing primary balance (percent of GDP): -0.7 (projection headline).
- Change in public sector debt (percent of GDP): 2002: -1.5; 2003: -2.4; 2004: -0.3; 2005: -3.4; 2006: -1.3; 2007 projection: -1.3.
- Identified debt-creating flows (percent of GDP): 2002: -3.1; 2003: -4.5; 2004: -5.5; 2005: -2.1; 2006: -5.8; 2007 projection: -1.9.
- External debt (percent of GDP): 2002: 33.3; 2003: 33.7; 2004: 35.8; 2005: 39.2; 2006: 42.4; 2007: 39.2; projections trending down to 32.3 by 2012 (Table 11).
- Gross external financing need (in percent of GDP): 2002: 10.1; 2003: 11.7; 2004: 15.7; 2005: 15.9; 2006: 20.2; 2007 projection: 23.5; later years decline.

### Policy context, Fund relations, and technical assistance
- Romania has accepted the obligations of Article VIII, Sections 2-4 with effect from March 25, 1998.
- Romania subscribes to the SDDS; data quality is deemed appropriate for surveillance purposes.
- Exchange-rate framework: de jure inflation-targeting since August 2005; authorities characterize the exchange-rate approach as a managed float and have intervened often in response to perceived excessive exchange rate movements. The official reference rate published by the NBR is an average of rates reported for interbank and client transactions.
- The Fund has provided substantial technical assistance with more than 40 missions since 1990 in areas including fiscal reforms, modernization of the central bank and the banking system, market-oriented legal structure, training, and improving statistics.
- Safeguards assessment: completed on June 17, 2004; safeguards at the NBR appear generally adequate, but weaknesses were identified in internal audit and controls and recommended measures were provided.
- AML/CFT: legislative framework updated for EU accession, but severe shortcomings remain in supervision outside the banking sector and in oversight of non-financial sector; additional training of reporting entities and competent authorities is necessary.
- Fund engagement: Stand-By Arrangements listed with approval and expiration dates; as of the document, a Stand-By approved 07/07/04 expired 07/06/06 (SDR 250.00 approved, drawn 0.00). Romania has had a resident representative in Bucharest since 1991; Mr. Juan Jose Fernandez-Ansola became senior regional resident representative in September 2006.

### Social and structural indicators (reference year specifics)
- Main export products: textiles and light machinery.
- Per capita GDP (2005): $4,445.
- Income distribution (GINI coefficient, 2000): 30.3.
- Poverty rate (2005): 13 percent.
- Primary education completion rate (2004): 94 percent.
- Gender pay gap (2003): 18 percent.
- Life expectancy at birth (2004): 71.3.
- Infant mortality per 1000 live births (2004): 16.8.

*Sources: Romanian authorities; and Fund staff estimates and projections.*

### 1. The Romanian authorities are pursuing a strategy designed to achieve

### _cr07219 - 1. The Romanian authorities are pursuing a strategy designed to achieve

### Strategy and reform priorities
- Objective: achieve macroeconomic stability, establish sustainable economic growth and poverty reduction, and allow closer integration with the rest of the European Union.
- Key elements:
  - tightening payments discipline throughout the economy, especially in the energy sector;
  - hardening budget constraints for state-owned enterprises;
  - actively pursuing enterprise and banking privatization and restructuring;
  - strengthening the social safety net.
- Medium-term conditionality: continuation of the economic recovery depends critically on maintenance of reform momentum and progress in governance and private sector development reforms, including:
  - transparency and accountability in government;
  - judicial reforms;
  - improvements in the business environment;
  - strengthening regulation and oversight of financial and capital markets.

### IMF role and engagement
- IMF focus: fiscal framework, monetary policy, and structural reforms with direct macroeconomic bearing.
- Main program vehicles referenced:
  - Stand-By Arrangement (SBA) covering the period October 31, 2001 to October 15, 2003;
  - a precautionary SBA which ended in June 2006.
- Current status: the authorities have not sought a further program with the IMF; dialogue continues in the context of Article IV Reviews.
- IMF responsibilities where it leads and World Bank is not directly involved:
  - monetary policy;
  - interest rates;
  - the exchange rate regime;
  - the balance of payments;
  - related statistical and measurement issues.
- IMF leads dialogue on fiscal matters and policies to contain public sector expenditures, including:
  - wage-setting in the public service and SOEs;
  - budgets of SOEs.
- IMF and World Bank jointly: conducted a Financial Sector Assessment Program completed in June 2003.

### World Bank role and engagement
- World Bank lead areas: structural issues, poverty reduction measures, private sector development, institution building and governance.
- Instruments and programs used:
  - PSAL 1 and PSAL 2;
  - a series of Programmatic Adjustment Loans, the first of which went to the Bank Board in September 2004;
  - sector investment operations;
  - analytical work: Public Expenditure and Institutions Review; Country Economic Memorandum on restructuring for EU integration;
  - other instruments cited: Social Sector Development Loan, two Social Development Fund Loans, two Mine Closure Loans, Social Inclusion Loan approved June 2006.
- Bank guidance is used as input to the fiscal framework for measures with fiscal implications (for example: energy sector reform and restructuring).
- Bank-led formal joint responsibilities include the Financial Sector Assessment Program (FSAP).

### Areas in which the World Bank leads (no direct IMF involvement)
- Social safety net and social sectors:
  - Bank dialogue includes poverty monitoring, social assistance, pension reform, health sector reforms, labor retraining and redeployment.
  - Supported by Social Sector Development Loan, two Social Development Fund Loans, two Mine Closure Loans, and a Social Inclusion Loan approved June 2006.
  - Analytical support: Pension Reform Study; ongoing poverty monitoring.
- Rural economy and agriculture:
  - Programs: Rural Finance Loan; Rural Development Loan; planned Farm Restructuring Loan; Integrated Nutrient Pollution Control Loan (with GEF Grant); Irrigation Rehabilitation loan; MAKIS project.
  - Supporting analytical work: Regional Development Policy Note.
- Institution building and governance:
  - Builds on reforms in local public finance, taxation and decentralization.
  - Informed by the Public Expenditure and Institutions Review and Country Financial Accountability Assessment (CFAA).
  - Diagnostic Survey of Corruption completed prior to Government’s National Program for Prevention of Corruption.
  - First Programmatic Adjustment Loan approved September 2004 focused on institutional and governance reforms and public expenditure management.
  - Supported by an $18.6 million Private and Public Sector Institution Building Loan.
  - Other support: cadastral and land titling project; hazards mitigation project cofinanced by a GEF grant; loan financing modernization of the judiciary.
- Business environment reforms:
  - Through PSAL 1, PSAL 2, and PAL 1: reducing barriers to entry, implementing internationally recognized accounting standards, improving bankruptcy and liquidation procedures.
  - Technical assistance provided under the PPIBL.
- Transport and infrastructure:
  - Transport Restructuring Loan ($225 million) and Transport Sector Support Loan ($180 million).
  - New operation under preparation to finance water and wastewater infrastructure investments and build capacity to access EU grant funds.

### Areas where World Bank analysis informs IMF program
- Privatization and enterprise restructuring:
  - PAL program supports GOR’s privatization program with targets and timelines for privatization of commercial SOEs and financial institutions.
  - PAL builds on PSALs 1 and 2 which identified pools of SOEs and specific enterprises including Alro, Alprom, and Petrom.
  - PAL includes further targets for privatization in energy and banking sectors.
- Energy sector reform:
  - Bank leads dialogue on restructuring, reform and privatization of electricity, district heating and gas industries, and on regulatory legislation.
  - Supports energy tariff reforms, reforms in electricity, district heat and gas sectors, and privatization of electricity distribution enterprises.
  - Coordination with IMF on energy sector provisions in SBAs: tariff setting, arrears clearance and collection rates.
  - Bank leads IFI dialogue on power generation sector restructuring and integration with the South East European Regional Electricity Market and with the EU’s electricity market.
  - Technical assistance provided to the Ministry of Industry on pricing and taxation of gas.
  - Dialogue facilitated by the recently completed Energy and Infrastructure Strategy paper and operational recommendations.

### Financial sector responsibilities and actions
- Bank leadership: regulation, restructuring, privatization and liquidation of banks.
  - Under PSAL 1: Law on Bank Privatization modified; transparent privatization procedures established.
  - Tighter liquidity and solvency requirements of the NBR; improved compliance with prudential regulations; external audits according to International Accounting Standards.
  - Legal and institutional reforms for disposition of non-performing assets.
  - Outcomes: liquidation of Bancorex; restructuring and privatization of Bank Agricola; privatization of two smaller state owned banks; continuation under PAL including privatization of BCR.
  - Ongoing dialogue on improving legal and regulatory framework for securities and insurance; PPIBL to provide funding.

### Shared responsibility and coordination
- High degree of consultation and coordination between IMF and World Bank on privatization and energy sector reforms due to:
  - IMF interest in privatization revenues for retiring public debt and containing quasi-fiscal deficits of SOEs that threaten macroeconomic stability.
  - Bank focus on market efficiency, enterprise operation, service delivery, financial performance and transparency of processes.
- Joint activities: Financial Sector Assessment Program completed June 2003.

### World Bank Group strategy and lending operations
- Country Partnership Strategy (CPS) presented to the World Bank’s Board on May 16, 2006, built on three pillars:
  - (a) accelerating structural and institutional reforms to support sustainable growth;
  - (b) addressing fiscal vulnerabilities and modernizing the public sector;
  - (c) targeting poverty reduction and promoting social inclusion.
- Lending program envelope: a flexible lending program of $450 million to $550 million per year envisaged, using a mix of investment lending and programmatic Development Policy Loans.
  - Base case lending includes investment projects subject to pre-conditions of appropriate sector policy and an acceptable medium term sector expenditure framework.
  - High case lending would be a combination of investment and development policy lending where the latter would require maintenance of an appropriate macroeconomic framework as per Bank guidelines and periodic review in consultation with the IMF.
- Implementation notes:
  - Since CPS start, several investment loans made; no further DPLs concluded; after PAL 1, the PAL program is being dropped.
  - World Bank involvement in Romania since 1991; portfolio as of January 1, 2007:
    - 23 projects with aggregate net commitments totaling $1.785 billion;
    - total undisbursed balance of $1.27 billion.
    - Sector composition by net commitments: environment and socially sustainable development 35 percent (12 projects); energy and infrastructure 39 percent (5 projects); social sectors 14 percent (four projects).
- Portfolio performance:
  - Implementation slowed in recent years: in FY06 and FY07 Romania’s annual disbursement ratio fell below its 16 percent historical average and from a peak of 27 percent in FY03.
  - 86 percent of the portfolio’s net commitments have been approved in the last four FYs, and three-quarters of them are less than three years old.
  - New loans typically do not start disbursing much during the first two years, accounting for about 80 percent of the portfolio disbursement slowdown.
  - Bank and the Ministry of Finance are working together to address implementation and disbursement issues.

### IFC activities
- IFC commitments and activities to date:
  - committed over US$772 million of its own funds in 42 projects and arranged over $241 million in syndications to support projects in financial markets, information technology, food and beverage, general manufacturing, health care and infrastructure.
  - as of January 2007, IFC portfolio in Romania stood at $411 million.
  - Advisory assignments supporting privatization and restructuring of large state-owned enterprises, public utilities and the health sector.

### Statistical issues and data quality
- Overall: data collection and reporting adequate for surveillance and program monitoring, but quality of national accounts, price, fiscal, and balance of payments data needs improvement.
- Progress: authorities made progress with technical assistance; Romania began participating in the GDDS in February 2001 and graduated to subscription to the SDDS in May 2005.
- Real sector:
  - National accounts produced by National Institute for Statistics (INS) using ESA95.
  - Estimates are methodologically sound and reported timely to the Fund for IFS publication.
  - Quarterly and annual national accounts are not harmonized regularly; late revisions have sometimes been significant.
  - Provisional and semi-final versions are disseminated in the Statistical Yearbook and other publications, and on the web (www.insse.ro).
  - CPI: subject to standard annual re-weighting and considered reliable.
  - January 2004: INS changed PPI coverage to include domestic and export sectors.
- Public finance:
  - Annual GFS data reported on an accrual basis derived from cash data using various methods: tax revenues adjusted using the time-adjusted cash method; expense data adjusted using due-for-payments data; interest payments calculated on an accrual basis.
  - Beginning in 2002, several Special Funds were included in the state budget: Special Fund for Development of the Energy System; Special Fund for Public Roads; Special Fund “Romanian Agriculture Development”; Special Fund “Romania”; while Special Fund for Insured Protection was eliminated from general government accounts.
  - Reported data excluded data on the Agency for Recovery Bank Assets.
  - The authorities introduced a new budget classification for the 2006 budget and produced 2004-05 budget outturns on the basis of the new classification.
  - Consolidated central government operations data are reported for GFS Yearbook inclusion with a significant time lag; consolidated general government data were reported for the first time for inclusion in the 2005 GFS Yearbook.
  - Quarterly data are not reported for IFS, but the Ministry of Finance agreed to participate in the high frequency data project to submit monthly and quarterly cash data on the central government according to the GFSM 2001 framework.
- Monetary and financial statistics:
  - National Bank of Romania (NBR) reports monetary and financial statistics regularly and timely for IFS.
  - Since December 2004, NBR reports monetary data to STA using Standardized Report Forms (SRFs) per the Monetary and Financial Statistics Manual (MFSM).
  - Monetary data in SRF format published in the new IFS Supplement beginning with the first issue (September 2006).
  - Need to reconcile monetary statistics with government finance statistics: in line with 1993 SNA and MFSM, accrued interest on deposits and loans, and securities other than shares should be incorporated in the corresponding outstanding amount of the financial instrument.

*Source: _cr07219 - 1. The Romanian authorities are pursuing a strategy designed to achieve*

### 8.      Romania is one of the first 40 countries whose data and metadata for financial

### _cr07219 - 8.      Romania is one of the first 40 countries whose data and metadata for financial

### Financial Soundness Indicators (FSIs)
- Romania is one of the first 40 countries whose data and metadata for financial soundness indicators (FSIs) are posted on the IMF’s website (http://www.imf.org/external/np/sta/fsi/eng/cce/index.htm).

### Balance of Payments and Reporting
- The NBR routinely reports balance of payments statistics to the Fund in a timely fashion.
- A 2003 STA mission reviewed the NBR’s compilation methodology for balance of payments and international investment position statistics, developed in consultation with Eurostat, and concluded that the proposed system is broadly appropriate.
- The STA mission supported implementation of this compilation system in 2004, along with a new FDI survey.

### Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (as of April 10, 2007) — Selected entries
- Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation: Mar. 2007; Date received: Apr. 2007; Frequency of Data: D and M; Frequency of Reporting: D and M; Frequency of Publication: D and M.
- International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities1: Date of latest observation: Mar. 2007; Date received: Apr. 2007; Frequency of Data: D and M; Frequency of Reporting: W and M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- Reserve/Base Money: Date of latest observation: Jan. 2007; Date received: Mar. 2007; Frequency of Data: D and M; Frequency of Reporting: W and M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- Broad Money: Date of latest observation: Jan. 2007; Date received: Mar. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- Central Bank Balance Sheet: Date of latest observation: Jan. 2007; Date received: Mar. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: Date of latest observation: Jan. 2007; Date received: Mar. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- Interest Rates2: Date of latest observation: Mar. 2007; Date received: Apr. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- Consumer Price Index: Date of latest observation: Feb. 2007; Date received: Mar. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing3 – General Government4: Date of latest observation: Dec. 2006; Date received: Feb. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing3 – Central Government: Date of latest observation: Jan. 2007; Date received: Feb. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt5: Date of latest observation: Dec. 2006; Date received: Feb. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- External Current Account Balance: Date of latest observation: Dec. 2006; Date received: Jan. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: Q.
- Exports and Imports of Goods and Services: Date of latest observation: Jun. 2006; Date received: Jan. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: M.
- GDP/GNP: Date of latest observation: Q4 2006; Date received: Mar. 2007; Frequency of Data: Q; Frequency of Reporting: Q; Frequency of Publication: Q.
- Gross External Debt: Date of latest observation: Dec. 2006; Date received: Feb. 2007; Frequency of Data: M; Frequency of Reporting: M; Frequency of Publication: Q.

Footnotes (as presented in table):
- 1 Includes reserve assets pledged or otherwise encumbered as well as net derivative positions.
- 2 Both market-based and officially-determined, including discount rates, money market rates, rates on treasury bills, notes and bonds.
- 3 Foreign, domestic bank, and domestic nonbank financing.
- 4 The general government consists of the central government (budgetary funds, extra budgetary funds, and social security funds), and state and local governments.
- 5 Including currency and maturity composition.
- 6 Daily (D), weekly (W), monthly (M), quarterly (Q), annually (A), irregular (I); and not available (NA).

### External and Public Debt Sustainability — Key findings and projections (Appendix IV)
A. External Sustainability
- Baseline: external debt-to-GDP ratio is expected to decrease slightly to about 32 percent over the medium term.
- Romania’s gross external financing needs are projected to increase from 20¼ to 23½ percent of GDP in 2007, after which they are expected to fall steadily, reaching 17½ percent of GDP by the end of the projection period.
- Standard stress tests (B1-B4) show external debt would remain under control in all scenarios; in all cases, debt ratios would end up well below 40 percent at the end of the projection period.
- Highest ratio: current account shock would lead to a debt-to-GDP ratio of 37¼ percent.
- Real depreciation scenario: debt levels would initially jump to 55½ percent of GDP, then fall back to 31½ percent by the end of 2012.
- Policy implication: policies to contain domestic demand (through lower consumption and import growth) remain key to maintain Romania’s external sustainability.

B. Fiscal Sustainability
- Public sector debt is expected to remain under control over the medium term.
- With appropriate policies, the primary balance would remain in surplus over the medium term.
- This fiscal path would lead to a fall in public sector debt from the current level of 18½ percent of GDP to about 11½ percent of GDP by 2012.
- A primary deficit of 0.7 percent of GDP would stabilize public debt at this level.
- Stress tests indicate vulnerability to real GDP growth and interest rate shocks:
  - If GDP growth slows from 7.7 percent to around 3 percent over the medium term, public debt would reach 26.1 percent of GDP by 2012.
  - If the interest rate increased by one standard deviation, debt would reach 25.6 percent of GDP.
  - Shocks to the real exchange rate, the primary balance, or combined shocks would nonetheless leave debt ratios below 25 percent of GDP throughout the projection period.

- Notes on stress-test scenarios and shocks (as presented):
  - Individual shocks are permanent one-half standard deviation shocks.
  - Some scenarios apply permanent 1/4 standard deviation shocks to real interest rate, growth rate, and current account balance.
  - One-time real depreciation of 30 percent occurs in 2008 in the specified scenario.
  - For public debt tests: one-time real depreciation of 30 percent and 10 percent of GDP shock to contingent liabilities occur in 2008, with real depreciation defined as nominal depreciation (measured by percentage fall in dollar value of local currency) minus domestic inflation (based on GDP deflator).

### Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 07/61 — IMF Executive Board Concludes 2007 Article IV Consultation with Romania (May 30, 2007)
Background highlights:
- On May 23, 2007, the Executive Board concluded the Article IV consultation with Romania.
- Romania acceded to the European Union on January 1, 2007.
- Output growth: 7.7 percent for 2006.
- Headline inflation: 3.7 percent (year-to-year) in March 2007 compared to 8.4 percent for the same period last year.
- For most of 2006, authorities maintained fiscal consolidation due to strong revenue collections and underutilization of the capital budget.
- The National Bank of Romania focused on strengthening the credibility of Romania’s inflation-targeting framework, tightening monetary conditions and successfully meeting its end-2006 inflation goal.
- Despite healthy export growth, the current account deficit widened to 10.3 percent of GDP in 2006, driven by growing excess demand, rising wages, and strong credit growth causing a surge in imports.
- Fiscal policy was loosened significantly in December 2006, moving the budget balance from a surplus in November to an end-year deficit of 1.7 percent.
- The fiscal deficit target for 2007 is 2.8 percent, and substantial government wage increases have been approved (up to 20 percent) along with an 18-percent minimum-wage hike for 2007.
- Appreciation pressures in early 2007 contributed to a loosening of the key monetary policy instrument; the policy interest rate was cut (rate change details continue beyond the excerpt provided).

*IMF staff report and related tables, as presented in the source document.*

### 8.75 percent to 8.00 percent in February and by a further 50 basis points to 7.5 percent in

### _cr07219 - 8.75 percent to 8.00 percent in February and by a further 50 basis points to 7.5 percent in

### Executive Board Assessment — main findings and concerns
- Commended accomplishments: strong output and export growth, substantial disinflation, low external debt, and a comfortable level of international reserves—factors that paved the way for Romania’s recent accession into the EU.
- Key vulnerabilities and risks:
  - Widening current account imbalance.
  - Risk of resurgence of inflationary pressures from strong domestic demand fueled by rapid credit growth and procyclical fiscal and incomes policies.
- Policy imperatives emphasized:
  - Need for consistent and prudent fiscal, incomes, and monetary policies, and vigorous implementation of structural reforms to reduce vulnerabilities, support sustainable growth, and maximize EU membership gains.
  - Raise per capita income (noted as well below the EU average) and lay groundwork for eventual euro adoption.
- Fiscal policy guidance:
  - Concern about recent procyclical fiscal loosening and the possibility Romania may fail to meet the Maastricht criteria in its first year of EU membership.
  - Urged a tighter fiscal stance in 2007 to contain domestic demand and establishment of prudent medium-term fiscal goals.
  - Stressed permanent revenue boosts given pressing expenditure needs and low revenue ratio; welcomed plans to strengthen tax administration and broaden the tax base.
  - Urged strengthening public financial management, restraining expenditure growth, and enhancing quality and composition of public spending; avoid multiple budget revisions and back-loaded expenditure.
  - Encouraged development of a credible medium-term fiscal framework to enhance transparency, effectiveness of budget planning and execution, and efficiency of absorbing EU funds.
- Wage policy guidance:
  - Considered envisaged wage policy (sharp minimum wage increase and three rounds of government wage increases) incompatible with inflation objective and with spillover risks to private sector.
  - Urged wage increases only once a year, ensuring they are moderate, transparent, and fully incorporated in the budget.
- Monetary and exchange-rate guidance:
  - Commended the central bank’s commitment to price stability and success in reducing inflation.
  - Considered recent interest rate cuts premature; urged raising interest rates as needed to attain inflation targets.
  - Noted that exchange rate remains competitive and appreciation would help contain inflation, despite potential upward pressure from higher rates.
  - Advised avoiding deviation between policy and effective interest rates and to reduce reserve requirements cautiously.
- Financial sector supervision and stability:
  - Financial soundness indicators and stress tests point to a relatively healthy and resilient financial system.
  - Concern that rapid growth of credit to the private sector, particularly foreign currency credit, can magnify medium-term vulnerabilities.
  - Emphasized importance of effective domestic and cross-border supervision and regulation; commended central bank progress in capacity to assess overall stability.
  - Welcomed authorities’ interest in a Financial Sector Assessment Program update.

### Executive Board Assessment — structural reform priorities
- Accelerate privatization in the energy sector and announce schedule for adjusting domestic producer gas prices in line with opportunity costs.
- Address low labor-market participation and employment rates via improved education and enhanced labor-market flexibility.
- Strengthen efforts to introduce a second pension pillar.
- Improve legal framework to reduce corruption and enhance the business environment.

### Selected Economic and Social Indicators — key statistics (as presented)
- Real economy (change in percent):
  - Real GDP: 5.1 (2002), 5.2 (2003), 8.5 (2004), 4.1 (2005), 7.7 (2006), 7.0 (Prel. 2007), 6.5 (Staff Projections Baseline 1/ Adj. Estimate)
  - Final domestic demand: 5.5 (2002), 8.3 (2003), 10.4 (2004), 10.1 (2005), 12.5 (2006), 10.8 (Prel. 2007), 9.1 (Staff Projections)
  - CPI (end of period): 17.8 (2002), 14.1 (2003), 9.3 (2004), 8.6 (2005), 4.9 (2006), 5.5 (Prel. 2007), 4.5 (Staff Projections)
  - CPI (period average): 22.5 (2002), 15.3 (2003), 11.9 (2004), 9.0 (2005), 6.6 (2006), 4.8 (Prel. 2007), 4.4 (Staff Projections)
  - Unemployment rate (end of period; percent): 8.4 (2002), 7.2 (2003), 6.2 (2004), 5.8 (2005), 5.4 (2006), 5.1 (Prel. 2007), 5.1 (Staff Projections)
  - Gross national saving (percent of GDP): 18.3 (2002), 16.0 (2003), 15.4 (2004), 14.0 (2005), 14.0 (2006), 13.4 (Prel. 2007), 14.9 (Staff Projections)
  - Gross domestic investment (percent of GDP): 21.7 (2002), 21.8 (2003), 23.8 (2004), 22.7 (2005), 24.2 (2006), 25.1 (Prel. 2007), 25.1 (Staff Projections)
- Public finance (general government, percent of GDP):
  - Revenue: 29.6 (2002), 28.7 (2003), 30.0 (2004), 30.2 (2005), 31.2 (2006), 33.5 (Prel. 2007), 34.1 (Staff Projections)
  - Expenditure: 32.3 (2002), 30.9 (2003), 31.1 (2004), 31.0 (2005), 32.9 (2006), 36.3 (Prel. 2007), 34.9 (Staff Projections)
  - Overall balance: -2.6 (2002), -2.2 (2003), -1.0 (2004), -0.8 (2005), -1.7 (2006), -2.8 (Prel. 2007), -0.9 (Staff Projections)
  - Primary balance: 0.4 (2002), -0.2 (2003), 0.2 (2004), 0.3 (2005), -0.9 (2006), -1.9 (Prel. 2007), 0.0 (Staff Projections)
  - Total public debt: 26.0 (2002), 23.6 (2003), 23.2 (2004), 19.9 (2005), 18.5 (2006), 18.7 (Prel. 2007), 17.3 (Staff Projections)
- Money and credit (end of year, percent change):
  - Nominal domestic credit: 38.1 (2002), 64.4 (2003), 40.5 (2004), 37.2 (2005), 66.1 (2006), 58.4 (Prel. 2007), 39.5 (Staff Projections)
  - Real domestic credit 5/: 38.2 (2002), 23.3 (2003), 40.1 (2004), 33.8 (2005), 29.4 (2006), 42.4 (Prel. 2007), 36.0 (Staff Projections)
  - Broad money: 38.2 (2002), 23.3 (2003), 40.1 (2004), 33.8 (2005), 29.4 (2006), 36.0 (Prel. 2007), 30.0 (Staff Projections)
- Interest rates (percent) 6/:
  - NBR interest rate (end of period): 21.5 (2002), 23.4 (2003), 18.8 (2004), 7.2 (2005), 8.8 (2006), - (Prel. 2007), - (Staff Projections)
  - Treasury bill rate (end of period): 17.4 (2002), 18.4 (2003), 11.5 (2004), 5.5 (2005), 5.5 (2006), - (Prel. 2007), - (Staff Projections)
- Balance of payments (percent of GDP):
  - Trade balance: -5.7 (2002), -7.5 (2003), -8.8 (2004), -9.8 (2005), -12.1 (2006), -13.5 (Prel. 2007), -12.5 (Staff Projections)
  - Current account balance: -3.3 (2002), -5.8 (2003), -8.4 (2004), -8.7 (2005), -10.3 (2006), -11.7 (Prel. 2007), -10.2 (Staff Projections)
  - Foreign direct investment: 3.1 (2002), 3.7 (2003), 8.4 (2004), 6.6 (2005), 9.3 (2006), 5.9 (Prel. 2007), 6.4 (Staff Projections)
  - External debt: 30.8 (2002), 29.9 (2003), 30.6 (2004), 31.1 (2005), 28.6 (2006), 26.4 (Prel. 2007), 26.1 (Staff Projections)
  - Official reserves (end-year, US$ million): 7,137 (2002), 9,208 (2003), 15,999 (2004), 21,648 (2005), 28,155 (2006), 30,030 (Prel. 2007), 32,288 (Staff Projections)
  - Reserve cover (months of prospective imports, in € terms)): 3.8 (2002), 3.3 (2003), 4.1 (2004), 5.1 (2005), 4.8 (2006), 4.5 (Prel. 2007), 5.0 (Staff Projections)
- Exchange rate:
  - Lei per euro (end of period): 3.51 (2002), 4.17 (2003), 3.96 (2004), 3.66 (2005), 3.41 (2006), - (Prel. 2007), - (Staff Projections)
  - Lei per US$ (end of period): 3.35 (2002), 3.30 (2003), 2.91 (2004), 3.08 (2005), 2.58 (2006), - (Prel. 2007), - (Staff Projections)
  - NEER appreciation (+) (percent): -14.4 (2002), -11.1 (2003), -5.1 (2004), 10.5 (2005), 2.7 (2006), - (Prel. 2007), - (Staff Projections)
  - REER appreciation (+) (CPI-based, in percent, period average): 0.8 (2002), -3.2 (2003), 2.6 (2004), 18.0 (2005), 7.6 (2006), - (Prel. 2007), - (Staff Projections)
  - REER appreciation (+) (ULC-based, in percent, period average): -6.5 (2002), -5.5 (2003), 5.1 (2004), 24.9 (2005), 3.8 (2006), 7/ - (Prel. 2007)
- Main export products: textiles and light machinery.
- Social indicators (reference year):
  - Per capita GDP (2005): $4,445
  - Income distribution (GINI coefficient, 2000): 30.3
  - Poverty rate (2005): 13 percent
  - Primary education completion rate (2004): 94 percent
  - Gender pay gap (2003): 18 percent
  - Life expectancy at birth (2004): 71.3
  - Infant mortality per 1000 live births (2004): 16.8

### Statement by the Authorities — key points and policy stance (Age Bakker and Lucian Croitoru; May 23, 2007)
- Broad appraisal:
  - Authorities appreciate staff report as realistic and balanced; agree on need to address imbalances and aim for a policy mix that preserves macrostability while sustaining strong growth consistent with EU convergence.
  - Growth reached 7.7 percent in 2006; CPI inflation fell to 3.8 percent y/y at end-April (below NBR’s 2007 target of 4 percent); core inflation remained around 4½ percent.
  - Domestic credit grew sharply from a low base, associated with expanding domestic demand and a widening current account deficit (10.2 percent of GDP last year).
  - FDI covered 90 percent of the current account deficit, supporting overall balance-of-payments strength.
  - Exports remained robust; reserve cover described as comfortable.
- Macroeconomic policy history and recent actions:
  - Fiscal policy maintained a budgetary surplus until November last year; spending surge in December turned surplus into an annual deficit of 1.7 percent of GDP.
  - Since October 2005 the NBR stopped intervening in foreign exchange market and tightened monetary conditions via full sterilization.
  - In 2006 NBR raised policy interest rate to 8.75 percent; with disinflation and upward exchange-rate pressure since end-November 2006, NBR limited liquidity absorbed at policy rate and reduced policy interest rate three times, to 7.25 percent between February and May 2007.
  - Banking system is 90 percent foreign-owned, healthy and robust.
- Fiscal policy stance and measures:
  - Authorities view a deficit of 2.8 percent of GDP in 2007 as consistent with macrostability; meeting infrastructure needs with a lower deficit would have been possible with additional revenue measures, but recent revised Fiscal Code and need for tax-legislation stability limit scope for revenue measures.
  - Authorities will not reduce tax rates except for relatively high social-contributions tax and will not allow tax exemptions.
  - Plans to strengthen tax administration, modernize it, broaden the tax base, and address shortcomings in the Agency for Fiscal Administration’s organizational structure and legal mandate.
  - Commit to limit number of budget revisions to one in 2007 (compared to four last year) per medium-term budgetary framework; working to ensure efficient allocation of resources and absorption of EU inflows to support uniform spending patterns.
- Wage policy:
  - A looser wage policy envisaged for 2007 versus prior year; reductions in envisaged increases not feasible, so focus will be on controlling bonuses and monitoring additional hirings.
  - Aim to limit wage increases to once a year starting in 2008.
- Monetary policy and financial stability:
  - NBR strongly committed to inflation targeting: CPI target of 4 percent for 2007 and 3.8 percent for 2008 (central values at end-year with ±1 percent band).
  - Recent policy rate cuts should not be viewed as loosening commitment; monetary conditions remain tight due to previous appreciation and relatively high reserve requirements.
  - NBR concerned about excessive short-term appreciation and small departure from full sterilization described as temporary; plans to reunify policy and effective interest rates as soon as possible.
  - Vigilant regarding strong credit growth; removed debt-to-income caps at bank level for household credit; considering cautious reduction of reserve requirements (currently much above EU levels).
  - Strengthening capacity for assessing financial-sector stability: publishes Financial Stability Report (second to be issued by mid-2007); NBR stress tests suggest banking system resilient to direct impact of interest-rate and exchange-rate movements and growth slowdown.
  - Encouraging high capital ratios and conservative provisioning; enhanced cross-border cooperation with Memoranda of Understanding in place; NBR staff participating in drills; plan for an FSAP update this year.
- Structural reforms and convergence:
  - Authorities committed to continuing structural reforms for real convergence.
  - Plan to continue adjustments to eliminate gap between domestic gas prices and international prices by end-2008 (no detailed calendar announced).
  - Determined to continue privatization of CEC and energy-sector companies.
  - Preparing to introduce the second pension pillar on January 2008.
  - Will continue implementation of judicial reform agenda.

*Source: Executive Board Assessment, Selected Economic and Social Indicators, and Statement by Age Bakker and Lucian Croitoru (May 23, 2007).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07219.pdf_
