## _cr07263

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr07263](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07263.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07263.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07263.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary and policy setting
- Outgoing Obasanjo administration implemented ambitious structural reforms resulting in:
  - Stronger policy framework and institutions, robust growth, lower inflation, dramatic decline in debt, and accumulation of significant reserves.
- Authorities reestimated the GDP time series to integrate new data sources and methodological changes reflecting SNA 1993; staff plans to adopt the revised GDP time series at the next Article IV consultation.
  - Using the authorities’ weights, real GDP growth would be 6.2 percent in 2006, and 8.4 percent in 2007.
- Immediate policy challenge: manage the economy through the political transition to preserve gains; incoming administration took office on May 29.
- Staff recommendation: completion of the third review under the PSI with waivers and modifications (see section V).

### Macroeconomic stability, outlook, and key projections
- Background and outlook
  - Strong real and external position, but fiscal and monetary policies were more expansionary than programmed in 2006.
  - Non-oil growth accelerated in 2006; prospects for 2007 supported by agriculture, trade, electricity improvements, rebound in crude oil production, and increased gas production via the West African Gas Pipeline.
- Selected macroeconomic indicators (2004–09, selected series)
  - Real GDP (at 1990 factor cost): 6.1, 7.2, 5.1, 5.2, 7.3, 8.2, 6.7, 5.7
  - Oil GDP: 3.5, 4.2, -1.6, -2.8, 9.3, 9.9, 7.1, 3.7
  - Non-oil GDP: 7.4, 8.6, 8.2, 8.9, 6.5, 7.5, 6.5, 6.6
  - Production of crude oil (million barrels per day): 2.50, 2.51, 2.35, 2.36, 2.53, 2.53, 2.66, 2.71
  - Nominal GDP at market prices (billions of naira): 9,604; 12,939; 14,824; 14,693; 16,589; 16,124; 18,528; 20,286
  - Consumer price index (annual average): 15.0, 17.9, 9.0, 8.2, 10.3, 7.8, 9.2, 8.5
  - Consumer price index (end of period): 10.0, 11.6, 12.2, 8.5, 9.5, 9.9, 9.0, 8.0
  - Gross international reserves (billions of U.S. dollars): 17.0; 28.3; 46.5; 41.8; 62.4; 52.3; 71.6; 89.9 (selected periodic values)
  - Overall consolidated balance (commitment basis, percent of GDP): 7.7, 9.3, 12.0, 8.8, 8.0, 3.8, 8.6, 6.2

### Fiscal developments and policy
- 2006 consolidated government fiscal stance
  - Fiscal expansion added to domestic demand.
  - Assessment criterion on the federal government fiscal balance was met with a margin.
  - Target on the non-oil primary deficit of the consolidated government was exceeded by 3 percent of non-oil GDP.
  - Expansion driven by higher-than-projected SLG spending financed by one-off distribution from the excess crude account beyond the oil price fiscal rule, partial execution of the new explicit fuel subsidy scheme, and somewhat higher gas receipts.
  - Overall fiscal balance remained well in surplus, enabling further accumulation of oil savings.
  - Underexecution of import-intensive capital spending raised the proxy domestic balance beyond projected levels; identified capital spending increased relative to 2005 but remained below budget levels for the federal government and large infrastructure projects.
- Text Table 1 (Consolidated Government, percent of non-oil GDP; selected lines)
  - Non-oil revenue: 13.9, 13.1, 12.7, 13.5, 13.3
  - Non-oil expenditures: 59.5, 60.7, 62.9, 59.1, 60.0
  - Federal government capital; and large projects: 6.3, 12.6, 10.5, 11.7, 12.1
  - State and local governments: 31.0, 27.8, 31.4, 27.2, 27.8
  - Explicit fuel subsidy: 0.0, 2.1, 0.1, 2.3, 1.8
  - Non-oil primary balance (excluding fuel subsidy): -38.9, -42.0, -44.9, -40.1, -41.6
  - Proxy domestic balance: -41.5, -41.8, -45.0, -39.9, -40.7
  - Overall balance (including oil revenue and expenditure): 22.3, 24.1, 17.1, 15.5, 7.3
  - Non-oil GDP (billions of naira): 6,223; 7,305; 7,310; 8,549; 8,446
- 2007 program aims
  - Reduce the fiscal impulse by reducing the non-oil primary deficit of the consolidated government by about 3 percent of non-oil GDP.
  - Increase capital spending needed to close the infrastructure gap (including large projects with high import content) while containing other spending.
  - Achievement hinges on adherence to the oil price fiscal rule by all levels of government; implemented so far in 2007.

### Monetary policy implementation and inflation
- 2006 monetary outcomes and problems
  - Monetary targets were not met in 2006 because policy only partially offset the unexpected fiscal stimulus of late-2006.
  - Introduction of several new CBN software systems in January 2006 resulted in significant accounting errors, difficulties in preparing monetary statistics, and substantial delays in data reporting to the Fund throughout the year.
  - The external audit of the CBN’s 2006 financial accounts revealed the full extent of problems; end-December 2006 accounts reconciled and external auditors gave an unqualified audit certification for the 2006 CBN accounts.
- Monetary aggregate behavior and implications
  - Real interest rates remained negative; reserve money was on average above program targets.
  - Insufficient sterilization of balance of payments inflows, reflecting higher-than-expected government spending, meant the end-December reserve money target (assessment criterion) was exceeded.
  - Reserve money was lowered through a reduction in the cash reserve requirement (CRR) and sterilized with 91-day treasury bills; adjusting for the CRR reduction, the reserve money target would have been surpassed by a wider margin.
  - Allowing the naira to appreciate would have provided scope for greater foreign exchange sales to meet the reserve money target; naira-U.S. dollar exchange rate remained stable due to authorities’ intervention policies.
- Inflation and money demand (section 9)
  - Credit to the private sector, including long-term investment in the oil sector with limited domestic demand impact, explains about two–thirds of the broad money increase in mid-2006.
  - Core inflation accelerated somewhat in the last quarter of 2006; 50 percent of core-urban commodities registered inflation in double digits.
  - Subsequent decline in inflation in 2007 indicates those inflationary pressures have diminished.
  - Possible explanation: pick-up in money demand owing to significant reduction in headline inflation and reemerging confidence in the financial system following banking consolidation.
- 2007 monetary program and conditionality
  - Broad money is targeted to grow by about 12 percent (below nominal non-oil GDP growth).
  - If money demand in 2007 is lower than projected or the mid-2006 monetary surge's impact is yet to be felt, monetary policy would need to be tightened.
  - CBN sterilization should focus on foreign exchange sales that allow sufficient domestic credit growth to the private sector and import growth consistent with projected real appreciation.
  - Policy recommendation: greater flexibility in the nominal exchange rate and nominal interest rates in line with market conditions.
- CBN reforms to strengthen implementation
  - External advisors assisting on IT; Fund providing TA on accounting and monetary statistics.
  - Regular monthly data submissions to the Fund have resumed.
  - Internal reorganization and liquidity management improvements; Fund peripatetic expert and long-term advisor assisting.
  - New standing facility introduced (end-June 2007 assessment criterion observed well ahead of schedule) to reduce intra-month interest rate volatility.

### Asset and liability management, oil savings, and infrastructure
- Safeguarding wealth through asset and liability management
  - Emphasis on comprehensive asset and liability management to safeguard oil savings and overall wealth.
  - Preliminary indications in 2007 show improved policy implementation, including resistance to pressures to spend oil savings before the April elections.
  - For the new government, reaffirming the political agreement on the use of oil revenues is important.
  - Need to develop and implement guidelines to ensure effective use of oil savings and good quality of capital spending.
- Workshop recommendations (selected)
  - Strengthen the oil price fiscal rule by defining the budget oil price in line with macroeconomic stability and extend it to natural gas.
  - Define objective of the oil savings “excess crude” account, governance arrangements, draw-down rules, and ensure transparent implementation.
  - Develop asset management guidelines and integrate spending funded from oil savings into fiscal strategies, budgets, and accounts.
  - Make cost-benefit analysis integral to project selection and establish participatory arrangements for joint federal and state projects.
- Short-term macroeconomic policy and infrastructure spending (section 7)
  - Implementation of the 2007 budget includes extra expenditure on infrastructure; estimated 75-80 percent of the expenditure will be imports and part funded from the excess crude oil account.
  - Fiscal Liquidity Assessment Committee (FLAC) set up and now meets weekly.
  - Excess crude oil account balance expected to rise to the equivalent of 15.6 percent of GDP at end 2007 based on WEO oil price projections ($60.8 per barrel average for Nigerian oil in 2007) and a $40 per barrel benchmark price.
  - Stock of international reserves expected to rise to $52.3 billion at end 2007.

### Structural reforms, PSI monitoring, and waivers
- Structural reform status and delays
  - Structural reforms broadly advanced or completed albeit with delays in some areas.
  - Following strong record earlier, performance for this review was weaker and waivers are requested in several cases.
  - Many delayed measures are well advanced and expected completed on a revised timetable.
- Selected accomplishments
  - Oil price fiscal rule applied; Fiscal Responsibility Bill passed by both houses (awaiting harmonization); Whole Sale Dutch Auction System operational; standing facility introduced; bank consolidation completed; tariff reform reduced unweighted average tariff below 20 percent.
- Structural assessment criteria (selected status items)
  - Introduce IPPIS: Not met. Waiver requested. Substantively implemented.
  - CBN prudential standards for consolidated supervision and begin consolidated supervision: Not met. Waiver requested. Remedial measures include time-bound action plan and TA from mid-2007.
  - FIRS nationwide taxpayer enumeration including TIN: Not met. Waiver requested.
  - Appoint auditors for oil and gas sector 2005 and 2006: Not met for 2006 audit. Waiver requested. Observed for 2005 audit.
  - Management contract for Transmission Company of Nigeria: Not met. Waiver requested. Expected observed by end-May.
- PSI monitoring adjustments and waivers
  - Staff proposes waivers for two missed quantitative and five structural assessment criteria and modification of end-June 2007 monetary targets to complete the third review.
  - Nonconcessional loan of $200 million contracted in January 2006 to finance a communication satellite (0.2 percent of GDP); supplier’s contract signed in 2004 and satellite launched in May 2007.

### Debt, financial sector, and reform sequencing
- Debt management and external liabilities
  - London Club par bonds repaid in late 2006 ($1.486 billion); promissory notes divested in March 2007; efforts to buy back oil warrants.
  - External debt outstanding (billions of U.S. dollars): 35.9, 20.5, 3.5, 3.5, 3.7, 3.3, 3.9, 4.7
  - External debt as of end-2006: about 3% of GDP (mostly multilateral).
  - DMO retired par bonds and repurchased promissory notes and oil warrants; a debt management framework developed and under stakeholder discussion.
- Financial sector
  - Banking sector consolidation completed (from 89 to 25 banks).
  - Next steps: strengthen banking supervision, carry out a financial stability diagnostic, TA to support supervision of banking groups on a consolidated basis.
  - CBN developing Financial Sector Strategy (FSS 2020) with Fund and Bank input.
  - Progress on payments to depositors of failed banks: final court orders obtained in respect of 10 banks; provisions/orders in respect of others; healthy banks invited to assume deposits under Purchase and Assumption resolution.

### Inflation, money demand, and contingency risks
- Inflation dynamics
  - End-December 2006 inflation: 8.5 percent (year on year); 12-month average inflation rate: 8.2 percent.
  - Headline inflation reported as 4.7 percent year-on-year in May (IMF staff statement, June 27, 2007); core inflation fell to 2.8 percent year-on-year.
- Money and velocity
  - Broad money: large mid-2006 increase explained two-thirds by credit to private sector including long-term oil investment with limited domestic demand impact.
  - If money demand in 2007 is lower than projected or the mid-2006 monetary surge’s impact persists, monetary policy should be tightened and the reserve money target defended via sterilization (foreign exchange sales emphasized).

### Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and social indicators
- Poverty and MDG indicators (selected figures from table)
  - Target/statement: 21.4 percent of population with income less than US$1/day
  - Alternative reported figures: 42.7 percent; 52 percent (WB 2006)
- Education
  - Target: 100 percent net primary enrolment
  - Reported gross primary enrolment: 68 percent; 60 percent (WB 2006)
- Child and maternal health (selected)
  - Under-five mortality: 77 per 1,000 live births; 235 per 1,000; 201 per 1,000 (WB 2005)
  - Births attended by skilled personnel: 92 percent; 33 percent; 36 percent (WB 2005)
- Water and sanitation (selected)
  - Increase access to clean water to 68 percent; reported access: 36 percent; 42 percent (WB 2005)
  - Increase access to basic sanitation to 70 percent; reported access: 34.2 percent; 40 percent (WB 2005)
- Financing gap for NEEDS/MDG objectives: estimated financing gap of about $4 billion per annum.
- Policy to use Paris Club exit savings for MDG spending: deploy about $1 billion per annum savings (of which $750 million from Federal Government); N110 billion appropriated in 2007 budget; N100 billion allocated in 2006.

### Statistical issues and data quality (ANNEX III)
- Principal deficiencies
  - Serious deficiencies in national accounts, government finance, money and banking, and external accounts; major inconsistencies between balance of payments and customs data on trade.
  - Systemic causes include lack of data sharing, insufficient computerization, and an outdated Statistical Act (1957).
- National accounts
  - National accounts statistics poor due to deterioration in business and household surveys; many sectoral deflators unsound.
  - Base year updated to 1990 from 1984; GDP methodology amended from 2004 onward toward SNA 1993.
- Prices and CPI
  - CPI weights based on 1985–86 survey; plans to update CPI weighting to 1996/97.
- Government finance statistics (GFS)
  - Fiscal data opaque due to federal structure and off-budget funds; need to expand NCGFS, improve consistency of OAGF and CBN source data, move to GFSM 2001 guidelines.
- Monetary accounts and balance of payments
  - CBN accounting system changes in 2006 without transition produced distortions; reporting to IFS interrupted.
  - BOP weakened by low survey response rates from oil businesses and divergence between customs-based and banking-based trade data; large negative errors and omissions persist.
- Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (as of May 17, 2007) — reporting frequencies and latest observation dates preserved in source (e.g., Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation Apr 2007; CPI: Date of latest observation Mar 2007; GDP/GNP: Date of latest observation 2006).

### Staff appraisal, risks, and main policy recommendations
- Staff appraisal
  - Reform program produced robust performance: strong growth, low inflation, improved investor confidence.
  - Recent slippages in policy implementation addressed in the 2007 program to minimize macro risks.
  - Late-2006 fiscal expansion deviated from oil price fiscal rule and, with limited exchange rate flexibility, led to unanticipated liquidity injection; inflation was not excessive, partly due to increased confidence and higher money demand.
- Main recommendations for new administration
  - Maintain reform momentum and safeguard economic gains.
  - Fiscal policy must remain consistent with macroeconomic stability; reaffirm political agreement on the use of oil revenues among all levels of government.
  - Develop and implement guidelines on effective use of oil savings and ensure good quality of capital spending.
  - Continue structural reforms to preserve macro stability and growth potential; pursue trade liberalization.
  - Pursue a more flexible exchange rate policy going forward.
  - Monitor inflation closely and tighten monetary conditions if money demand is weaker than anticipated or mid-2006 monetary surge effects persist.
  - Ensure quality and timeliness of monetary data to improve policy effectiveness.
- PSI decision
  - Staff recommends completion of the third review under the PSI (with waivers and modifications described in section V).
  - Waivers proposed for two missed quantitative and five structural assessment criteria; modification of end-June 2007 monetary targets proposed.

*Source: Executive Summary and selected sections from _cr07263 (IMF staff report content unit)._

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### Executive Summary

### Policy Setting
- Ambitious structural reforms by the outgoing Obasanjo administration resulted in:
  - Stronger policy framework and institutions.
  - Robust growth, lower inflation, a dramatic decline in debt, and an accumulation of significant reserves.
- Reforms boosted confidence and sustained strong performance, but policy implementation weakened in 2006.
- The authorities reestimated the GDP time series to integrate new data sources and methodological changes reflecting SNA 1993; the staff plans to adopt the revised GDP time series at the next Article IV consultation. Using the authorities’ weights, real GDP growth would be 6.2 percent in 2006, and 8.4 percent in 2007.
- Immediate policy challenge: manage the economy through the political transition to preserve gains and provide a sound starting point for the incoming administration (which took office on May 29).

### Maintaining Macroeconomic Stability
- Background: strong real and external position, but fiscal and monetary policies were more expansionary than programmed in 2006.
- Non-oil growth accelerated in 2006; prospects for 2007 are promising due to:
  - Solid agriculture and trade growth.
  - Expected improvements in electricity production from several new power plants.
  - Rebound in crude oil production to 2005 levels projected, stemming mainly from production in new off-shore fields.
  - Increased gas production with the new West African Gas Pipeline.
- External position strengthened further following the Paris Club debt relief and higher oil prices:
  - London Club par bonds repaid in late 2006.
  - Liabilities for promissory notes divested in March 2007.
  - Efforts made to buy back oil warrants.
  - Rising investor confidence reflected in favorable sovereign ratings and interest rates on private sector external bond issuance.

### Managing Fiscal Developments
- 2006 consolidated government fiscal stance:
  - Fiscal expansion added to domestic demand.
  - Assessment criterion on the federal government fiscal balance was met with a margin.
  - Target on the non-oil primary deficit of the consolidated government was exceeded by 3 percent of non-oil GDP.
  - Expansion driven by higher-than-projected state and local government (SLG) spending financed by one-off distribution from the excess crude account beyond the oil price fiscal rule, partial execution of the new explicit fuel subsidy scheme, and somewhat higher gas receipts.
  - Overall fiscal balance remained well in surplus, enabling further accumulation of oil savings.
  - Underexecution of import-intensive capital spending raised the proxy domestic balance beyond projected levels; identified capital spending increased relative to 2005 but remained below budget levels for the federal government and large infrastructure projects.
- Text Table 1: Consolidated Government (non-oil), 2005-07 (Percent of non-oil GDP)
  - 2005 Act., 2006 Act./Prog./Est., 2007 Prog./Proj. (as provided)
  - Non-oil revenue: 13.9, 13.1, 12.7, 13.5, 13.3
  - Non-oil expenditures: 59.5, 60.7, 62.9, 59.1, 60.0
  - Interest: 6.7, 3.5, 5.2, 3.2, 3.3
  - Federal government primary recurrent and extrabudgetary: 15.5, 14.9, 15.7, 14.6, 15.0
  - Federal government capital; and large projects: 6.3, 12.6, 10.5, 11.7, 12.1
    - of which: foreign content of large infrastructure projects: 0.6, 3.2, 2.1, 3.1, 3.2
  - State and local governments: 31.0, 27.8, 31.4, 27.2, 27.8
  - Explicit fuel subsidy: 0.0, 2.1, 0.1, 2.3, 1.8
  - Non-oil primary balance (excluding fuel subsidy): -38.9, -42.0, -44.9, -40.1, -41.6
  - Proxy domestic balance: -41.5, -41.8, -45.0, -39.9, -40.7
  - Memorandum items:
    - Overall balance (including oil revenue and expenditure): 22.3, 24.1, 17.1, 15.5, 7.3
    - Balance excess crude account: 20.4, ..., 23.0, ..., ...
    - Non-oil GDP (billions of naira): 6,223; 7,305; 7,310; 8,549; 8,446
- 2007 program (reaffirmed by authorities) aims to:
  - Reduce the fiscal impulse with a reduction in the non-oil primary deficit of the consolidated government by about 3 percent of non-oil GDP.
  - Increase capital spending needed to close Nigeria’s infrastructure gap, including large infrastructure projects with high import content, while containing other spending.
  - Achievement hinges on adherence to the oil price fiscal rule by all levels of government; it has been implemented so far in 2007.

### Strengthening Monetary Policy Implementation
- Monetary targets were not met in 2006 because policy only partially offset the unexpected fiscal stimulus of late-2006.
- Key issues:
  - Problems with monetary data impeded effective analysis and limited the CBN’s ability to respond promptly to liquidity changes.
    - The simultaneous introduction of several new software systems at the CBN in January 2006 resulted in significant accounting errors, difficulties in preparing monetary statistics, and substantial delays in data reporting to the Fund throughout the year.
    - The full extent of the problems became apparent during the external audit of the CBN’s 2006 financial accounts.
    - The Fund provided technical assistance on accounting and statistics. The CBN has embarked on a comprehensive approach to resolve issues related to accounting, statistics, and information technology (IT).
    - The end-December 2006 accounts have been reconciled, including the previously-reported inconsistency on international reserves, and the external auditors gave an unqualified audit certification for the 2006 CBN accounts. Reconciliation of different sources of data on international reserves for early 2007 is ongoing.
  - Uneven implementation of monetary policy led to higher-than-programmed growth of monetary aggregates:
    - Real interest rates remained negative; reserve money was on average above program targets, and end-quarter corrections were only temporary.
    - Insufficient sterilization of balance of payments inflows, reflecting higher-than-expected government spending, meant the end-December reserve money target (assessment criterion) was exceeded.
    - Reserve money was lowered through a reduction in the cash reserve requirement (CRR)—contrary to the CBN’s Monetary Policy Committee communiqué in February 2006—but the liquidity impact was sterilized with 91-day treasury bills.
    - Adjusting for the reduction in the CRR, the reserve money target would have been surpassed by a wider margin.
    - Authorities attribute the sharp rise in reserve money in December 2006 to a surge in currency due to demands associated with political campaigns; the surge has reversed in the first months of 2007 and represents a temporary deviation from the program.
  - Allowing the naira to appreciate would have provided scope for greater foreign exchange sales to meet the reserve money target; the naira-U.S. dollar exchange rate remained stable due to authorities’ intervention policies.
- Text Table 2: Required Mop-up of Government Spending, 2004-07 (Percent of non-oil GDP)
  - Change in reserve money: 0.9, 0.5, 0.8, -0.5, 0.9, 0.1, 1.4, 2.0, 1.1, 0.5
  - Proxy for domestic balance: -37.9, -41.5, -41.8, -9.5, -11.0, -12.3, -12.2, -45.0, -39.9, -40.7
  - Mop-up (proxy): 37.1, 41.0, 41.0, 9.9, 10.1, 12.2, 10.8, 43.0, 38.8, 40.2
    - Of which: foreign exchange sales: 25.8, 21.5, 16.5, 1.4, 4.9, 6.4, 7.8, 20.5, 20.0, 26.3
    - domestic asset sales: ..., 2.4, 6.3, 3.4, -2.8, 9.4, ...
  - Note: Staff uses a proxy for central bank intervention due to inadequate historical liquidity management data; proxy is indicative.

### Safeguarding Wealth Through Asset and Liability Management
- The report emphasizes the need for comprehensive asset and liability management to safeguard oil savings and overall wealth (detailed discussion in the full text).
- Preliminary indications in 2007 show improved policy implementation, including successful resistance to intense pressures to spend oil savings in the run up to the April elections.
- For the new government, reaffirming the political agreement on the use of oil revenues is important.
- Guidelines need to be developed and implemented to ensure effective use of oil savings and good quality of capital spending.

### Consolidating Structural Reforms
- Structural reforms are broadly advanced or completed albeit with delays in some areas.
- Following a strong record in the first two reviews (only one technical waiver requested), performance for this review was weaker and waivers are requested in several cases.
- Consolidation and institutionalization of reforms are critical to sustain and improve economic performance and to support poverty reduction objectives.

### PSI Issues and Staff Recommendations
- The staff recommends completion of the third review to support policy continuity through the political transition.
- The staff proposes:
  - Waivers for two missed quantitative and five structural assessment criteria.
  - Modification of the end-June 2007 monetary targets.
- Failure to adhere to fiscal, monetary, and structural commitments could jeopardize macroeconomic stability and growth potential, which are important for Nigeria’s fight against poverty.

*Source: Executive Summary, _cr07263 - Executive Summary.*

### 9.      The inflation consequence of the growth in monetary aggregates was likely muted by

### 9.      The inflation consequence of the growth in monetary aggregates was likely muted by

### Inflation and money demand
- Credit to the private sector, including long-term investment in the oil sector with limited domestic demand impact, explains about two–thirds of the broad money increase in mid-2006.
- Core inflation (excluding food and energy) accelerated somewhat in the last quarter of 2006; the increase was broad based, with 50 percent of core-urban commodities registering inflation in double digits.
- Subsequent decline in inflation in 2007 indicates those inflationary pressures have diminished.
- Possible explanation: a pick-up in money demand owing to a significant reduction in headline inflation and reemerging confidence in the financial system following the consolidation of the banking sector.
- Graphical indicators referenced in the source: Change in Core Commodity Prices, August-December 2006 (annualized percentage change; fraction); Relationship Between Velocity and Inflation (velocity and average inflation series for 2001–2007); Real Effective Exchange Rate (2000=100) and Growth of Non-Oil Imports in US Dollars, 2004–07 (2007 Proj. and 2006 Est. included).

### 2007 monetary program and policy conditionality
- 2007 monetary program targets the CBN’s single-digit inflation objective by reversing in part the acceleration in broad money.
- Broad money is targeted to grow by about 12 percent, which is below nominal non-oil GDP growth.
- Risks and contingency:
  - If money demand in 2007 turns out to be lower than projected or the impact of the monetary surge in mid-2006 is yet to be felt, monetary policy would have to be tightened to contain inflationary pressures.
  - CBN’s sterilization efforts should support the reserve money target by focusing on foreign exchange sales that would also allow sufficient domestic credit growth to the private sector and import growth consistent with the projected real appreciation.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Greater flexibility in line with market conditions in the nominal exchange rate (compared to the current practice) and the nominal interest rates is essential.

### CBN measures to improve monetary policy implementation
- Outstanding monetary data problems are being addressed:
  - External advisors are assisting the CBN with IT issues.
  - The Fund is providing technical assistance on accounting and monetary statistics.
  - Regular data submissions of monthly data to the Fund have resumed.
- Monetary decision-making process is being strengthened:
  - Internal reorganization of the CBN.
  - Liquidity management improved through effective operations of the fiscal and liquidity assessment groups to provide timely information on liquidity injections.
  - The Fund’s peripatetic expert and long-term advisor are assisting the process.
- Intra-month interest rate volatility should be reduced by the new standing facility (end-June 2007 assessment criterion observed well ahead of schedule).

### III. Safeguarding wealth through asset and liability management
- Nigeria reinforced management of its oil wealth in recent years:
  - The oil price fiscal rule limiting use of oil revenues and participation in the EITI were critical reforms.
  - Approval of the Fiscal Responsibility and NEITI Bills by both houses of the parliament (awaiting harmonization) are welcomed steps toward institutionalizing reforms.
  - Priorities recognized: set oil price fiscal rule consistent with macroeconomic stability, possible expansion to natural gas, and pursue fiscal responsibility bills for states.
- Key challenge: develop and implement guidelines on the use of Nigeria’s oil savings.
  - Workshop recommendations (Oil Savings and the Infrastructure Gap) include clarifying principles guiding use of oil savings, improving cost-benefit analysis and budget management to ensure high quality of spending, especially for joint federal and state large infrastructure projects.
- Box 2 workshop recommendations (selected):
  - Strengthen the oil price fiscal rule by defining the budget oil price in line with macroeconomic stability and extend it to natural gas.
  - Define objective of the oil savings “excess crude” account (stabilization and/or savings), governance arrangements, draw-down rules, and ensure transparent implementation.
  - Develop asset management guidelines.
  - Integrate all spending funded from oil savings into fiscal strategies, budgets, and accounts.
  - Make cost-benefit analysis integral to project selection.
  - Establish participatory arrangements for joint national and state projects and ensure due process standards.

### Debt and financial sector management
- A comprehensive debt management framework is being prepared to preserve recent gains in debt sustainability; it will guide borrowing strategy, procedures, and acceptable loan terms and conditions.
- The new government will need to ensure effective implementation of the framework, including at subnational levels.
- Banking sector consolidation completed (from 89 to 25 banks); next steps:
  - Strengthen banking supervision and carry out a financial stability diagnostic.
  - Fund technical assistance to support supervision of banking groups on a consolidated basis.
  - CBN developing a medium-to-long-term financial sector strategy (FSS 2020) with Fund and Bank input.

### IV–V. Structural reforms, PSI monitoring, and waivers
- Under the PSI, authorities implemented ambitious structural reforms focused on public sector efficiency and enabling private sector growth (NEEDS-based).
- Key accomplishments (selected):
  - Oil price fiscal rule applied.
  - Fiscal Responsibility Bill passed by both houses (awaiting harmonization).
  - Whole Sale Dutch Auction System operational; exchange markets unified.
  - Standing facility introduced.
  - Bank consolidation and recapitalization completed.
  - Tariff reform reduced unweighted average tariff below 20 percent.
- Implementation delays:
  - Several final steps delayed; one structural assessment criterion for the third review observed on time, five criteria delayed.
  - Of structural benchmarks for December 2006 and March 2007: four observed, one observed with delay, two delayed.
  - Many delayed measures are well advanced and expected to be completed on a revised timetable.
- Structural assessment criteria table highlights (selected items and status):
  - Establish database of pensioners and estimate size of pension arrears (September 2006): Observed.
  - Introduce Integrated Personnel and Payroll Information System (IPPIS) (September 2006): Not met. Waiver requested. Substantively implemented.
  - CBN to establish prudential standards for consolidated supervision and begin to supervise banking groups on a consolidated basis (December 2006): Not met. Waiver requested. Remedial measures include a time-bound action plan and long-term technical assistance from mid-2007.
  - FIRS to conduct nationwide taxpayer enumeration including TIN (December 2006): Not met. Waiver requested.
  - Appoint auditors to conduct the audit of the oil and gas sector for 2005 and 2006 (March 2007): Not met. Waiver requested. Observed for 2005 audit; delay for 2006 audit.
  - Management contract for the Transmission Company of Nigeria to be awarded (March 2007): Not met. Waiver requested. Expected observed by end-May.

- PSI monitoring adjustments proposed through end-June 2007:
  - Assessment criterion on the non-oil primary balance of the federal government set at the second review is reconfirmed.
  - Reserve money and net foreign assets targets are revised in light of new information for 2006 and new oil price projections.
  - All structural assessment criteria and structural benchmarks set at the second review remain valid.
- Waivers recommended:
  - Waivers of nonobservance for five structural assessment criteria and two quantitative assessment criteria on reserve money and nonconcessional external borrowing are recommended to complete the third PSI review.
  - Note: a nonconcessional loan of $200 million was contracted in January 2006 to finance a communication satellite (0.2 percent of GDP); supplier’s contract signed in 2004 and satellite launched in May 2007.

### VI. Staff appraisal and main policy recommendations
- Staff appraisal:
  - The reform program led to robust macroeconomic performance: strong growth, low inflation, and improved investor confidence.
  - Recent slippages in policy implementation are addressed in the 2007 program, minimizing macroeconomic risks.
  - The fiscal expansion at consolidated government level in late 2006 resulted from deviation from the oil price fiscal rule and, with lack of exchange rate flexibility, led to an unanticipated liquidity injection.
  - This did not result in excessive inflationary pressures, due largely to increased confidence and likely higher money demand.
- Main challenges and recommendations for the new administration:
  - Maintain reform momentum and safeguard economic gains.
  - Focus areas:
    - Fiscal policy must remain consistent with macroeconomic stability; reaffirm political agreement on the use of oil revenues among all levels of government.
    - Continue developing and implementing guidelines on the effective use of oil savings and ensure good quality of capital spending.
    - Continue structural reforms to preserve macroeconomic stability and future growth potential.
  - Staff urges the new authorities to commit to and pursue a more flexible exchange rate policy going forward.
  - Monitor inflation closely and tighten monetary conditions if money demand is weaker than anticipated or if the mid-2006 monetary surge still has effects.
  - Ensure good quality of monetary data to improve monetary policy effectiveness.

*Source: IMF staff report content unit titled "9.      The inflation consequence of the growth in monetary aggregates was likely muted by" (PDF chapter/section).*

### 24.      The staff recommends completion of the third review under the PSI (with the

### _cr07263 - 24.      The staff recommends completion of the third review under the PSI (with the

### Staff recommendation and rationale
- The staff recommends completion of the third review under the PSI (with the waivers and modifications described in section V).
- The completion of this review will support Nigeria’s efforts to entrench macroeconomic stability and pursue ongoing strong structural reforms.

### Key macroeconomic indicators (selected, 2004–09)
- Real GDP (at 1990 factor cost): 6.1, 7.2, 5.1, 5.2, 7.3, 8.2, 6.7, 5.7
- Oil GDP: 3.5, 4.2, -1.6, -2.8, 9.3, 9.9, 7.1, 3.7
- Non-oil GDP: 7.4, 8.6, 8.2, 8.9, 6.5, 7.5, 6.5, 6.6
- Production of crude oil (million barrels per day): 2.50, 2.51, 2.35, 2.36, 2.53, 2.53, 2.66, 2.71
- Nominal GDP at market prices (billions of naira): 9,604; 12,939; 14,824; 14,693; 16,589; 16,124; 18,528; 20,286
- Nominal non-oil GDP at factor cost (billions of naira): 5,005; 6,223; 7,305; 7,310; 8,549; 8,446; 9,781; 11,262
- Nominal GDP per capita (U.S. dollars): 501; 674; 773; 770; 850; 827; 930; 1,001
- GDP deflator: 20.3, 25.7, 9.1, 7.8, 4.3, 1.5, 7.7, 3.5
- Non-oil GDP deflator: 14.5, 14.5, 8.5, 7.8, 9.9, 7.5, 8.7, 8.1
- Consumer price index (annual average): 15.0, 17.9, 9.0, 8.2, 10.3, 7.8, 9.2, 8.5
- Consumer price index (end of period): 10.0, 11.6, 12.2, 8.5, 9.5, 9.9, 9.0, 8.0

### Investment and savings (percent of GDP)
- Gross national savings: 27.8, 30.5, 34.2, 33.8, 35.2, 33.0, 31.1, 29.8
- Public savings: 20.8, 22.0, 25.0, 21.6, 23.5, 19.9, 22.1, 19.4
- Private savings: 7.0, 8.5, 9.3, 12.1, 11.7, 13.1, 9.0, 10.4
- Investment: 22.5, 21.2, 21.8, 22.0, 24.8, 25.9, 23.7, 23.7
- Public investment: 9.1, 9.6, 10.4, 10.3, 12.7, 13.4, 11.4, 11.2
- Private investment: 13.4, 11.6, 11.4, 11.7, 12.1, 12.5, 12.4, 12.6
- Current account balance: 5.3, 9.2, 12.5, 11.8, 10.4, 7.0, 7.4, 6.0

### Consolidated government operations (percent of GDP)
- Total revenues and grants: 43.0, 43.4, 45.4, 43.7, 46.2, 43.7, 42.6, 41.3
- Of which: oil and gas revenue: 34.9, 36.8, 38.9, 37.1, 39.2, 36.8, 35.5, 33.6
- Total expenditure and net lending (commitment basis): 35.3, 34.2, 33.4, 34.9, 38.2, 39.9, 34.0, 35.1
- Overall balance (commitment basis): 7.7, 9.3, 12.0, 8.8, 8.0, 3.8, 8.6, 6.2
- Non-oil primary balance (percent of non-oil GDP): -34.2, -38.9, -42.0, -44.9, -40.0, -41.6, -40.5, -40.4

### Fiscal (cash basis) levels — selected lines (billions of naira)
- Total revenue: 4,127; 5,621; 6,731; 6,376; 7,663; 7,050; 7,887; 8,375
- Oil and gas revenue: 3,355; 4,759; 5,770; 5,445; 6,511; 5,926; 6,586; 6,813
- Government crude receipts: 1,440; 1,938; 2,032; 1,994; 2,044; 1,981; 2,014; 2,060
- Petroleum profit tax and royalty: 1,184; 1,905; 2,276; 2,038; 2,919; 2,430; 3,001; 3,116
- Non-oil revenue: 773; 863; 960; 931; 1,152; 1,123; 1,302; 1,562
- Total consolidated expenditure: 3,177; 4,234; 4,971; 5,125; 6,342; 6,432; 6,300; 7,112
- Overall balance (cash basis): 951; 1,387; 1,760; 1,251; 1,321; 618; 1,587; 1,263
- Financing (cash basis): -925; -1,183; -1,673; -1,468; -1,321; -618; -1,587; -1,263

### Federal government budget (selected, 2005–07; billions of naira)
- Federal total revenue (2005 Act): 2,058; (2006 Prog): 2,588; (2006 Est): 2,424; (2007 Prog): 2,895; (2007 Proj): 2,633
- Petroleum revenue (2005 Act): 1,794; (2006 Prog): 2,290; (2006 Est): 2,166; (2007 Prog): 2,529; (2007 Proj): 2,283
- Nonpetroleum revenue (2005 Act): 264; (2006 Prog): 298; (2006 Est): 258; (2007 Prog): 366; (2007 Proj): 350
- Total expenditure (2005 Act): 1,445; (2006 Prog): 1,859; (2006 Est): 1,815; (2007 Prog): 2,044; (2007 Proj): 2,016
- Recurrent expenditure (2005 Act): 1,192; (2006 Prog): 1,288; (2006 Est): 1,311; (2007 Prog): 1,435; (2007 Proj): 1,413
- Overall balance (cash basis) (2005 Act): 612; (2006 Prog): 729; (2006 Est): 609; (2007 Prog): 851; (2007 Proj): 617

### Monetary and central bank (selected)
- Broad money (percent change since year's end): 14.0, 16.0, 8.2, 34.3, 39.9, 28.4, 39.9, 10.1, 5.8, 13.8, 14.5, 11.8, 11.8
- Net foreign assets (percent of beginning-of-period broad money): 62.3, 61.8, 38.0, 55.5, 55.8, 62.7, 68.6, 3.2, 27.1, 6.7, 21.4, 60.1, 36.3
- Net domestic assets (percent of beginning-of-period broad money): -49.9, -45.8, -29.8, -21.2, -15.9, -34.3, -28.7, 6.9, -21.3, 7.1, -6.9, -48.3, -24.5
- Net credit to the consolidated government (percent of beginning-of-period broad money): -42.1, -17.4, -20.7, -30.9, -26.0, -35.1, -34.5, 4.9, -18.3, 2.7, -8.8, -42.6, -20.9
- Claims on private sector (percent of beginning-of-period broad money): 15.7, 19.5, -1.9, 10.1, 19.0, 8.4, 20.0, 3.2, 5.6, 6.4, 9.6, 11.4, 12.8
- Reserve money (levels and targets appear in Table 6): 732; 763; 729; 798; 806; 820; 911; 841; 866; 860; 880; 914; 955 (selected periodic values)

### External sector and balance of payments (selected)
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): 3.8, 9.1, 14.4, 13.6, 13.6, 8.9, 10.8, 9.7, 14.1
- Exports, f.o.b. (annual percent change): 36.8, 42.6, 11.3, 15.9, 8.5, 3.3, 10.5, 2.5
- Oil export volume (annual percent change): 2.5, -3.5, -7.0, -2.7, 8.7, 6.8, 2.0, 1.8
- Imports, f.o.b. (annual percent change): 13.1, 30.5, 19.5, 21.5, 20.6, 26.5, 8.1, 7.3
- Terms of trade (annual percent change): 20.5, 38.0, 16.5, 16.4, -2.3, -5.6, 5.4, -1.5
- Price of Nigerian oil (U.S. dollars per barrel): 38.3, 55.3, 64.4, 64.3, 63.3, 60.8, 64.8, 64.5
- Nominal effective exchange rate (end of period): -2.8, 10.4, ..., -6.0, ............
- Real effective exchange rate (end of period): 4.0, 19.7, ..., -0.5, ............
- External debt outstanding (billions of U.S. dollars): 35.9, 20.5, 3.5, 3.5, 3.7, 3.3, 3.9, 4.7
- Gross international reserves (billions of U.S. dollars): 17.0; 28.3; 46.5; 41.8; 62.4; 52.3; 71.6; 89.9 (selected periodic values)
- Gross official reserves, end-of-period: 17.0; 28.3; 46.5; 41.8; 62.4; 52.3; 71.6; 89.9; 112.5 (mem. items)

### Balance of payments composition (percent of GDP; selected)
- Trade balance: 17.8, 27.8, 28.3, 30.8, 27.0, 24.6, 28.1, 26.8, 31.3
- Exports (percent of GDP): 37.3, 53.1, 58.7, 61.6, 63.7, 63.6, 70.2, 78.0, 78.5
- Imports (percent of GDP): -19.4, -25.4, -30.4, -30.8, -36.6, -39.0, -42.1, -45.2, -47.2
- Services (net): -5.9, -6.7, -5.9, -5.9, -6.4, -6.5, -8.2, -8.4, -8.8
- Income (net): -10.9, -15.3, -11.4, -14.6, -10.4, -12.6, -12.6, -12.1, -11.9
- Transfers (net): 2.8, 3.4, 3.4, 3.4, 3.4, 3.4, 3.4, 3.4

### Non-oil savings-investment balances (percent of non-oil GDP, Table 5)
- Income: 103.1, 104.3, 106.2, 105.9, 107.0, 106.4, 105.7, 105.4
- Consumption: 104.2, 103.2, 102.4, 102.9, 104.6, 107.9, 104.0, 102.7
- Savings: -1.1, 1.1, 3.8, 3.1, 2.4, -1.5, 1.7, 2.8
- Investment: 30.0, 31.4, 32.9, 32.9, 33.5, 34.3, 35.0, 34.6
- Current account: -31.1, -30.3, -29.0, -29.8, -31.1, -35.8, -33.3, -31.8

### Quantitative assessment criteria and indicative targets (2006, Table 6)
- Federal government non-oil primary balance (floor): -939; -939; -940; -1,316; -1,316; -1,228 (Adjusted Estimates / Targets / Assessment entries)
- Reserve money (ceiling): 810; 810; 806; 820; 820; 911 (Adjusted Estimates / Targets / Assessment entries)
- Net foreign assets of the CBN (floor): 5,003; 3,558; 4,902; 5,135; 4,611; 5,312 (Adjusted Estimates / Targets / Assessment entries)
- New nonconcessional external debt by the public sector (ceiling): 0 0 25   0 0 25 (formatted as in source)
- External arrears: 0 0 0   0 0 0 (formatted as in source)
- Memorandum items (selected): Oil production (million barrels per day): 2.52; ...; 2.39; 2.37; ...; 2.29
- Memorandum items (selected): Oil price (U.S. dollars per barrel): 60.5; ...; 61.2; 64.4; ...; 64.3
- Note: "The net foreign assets target will be adjusted upward (downward) for positive (negative) deviations of oil prices, oil and gas production, and petroleum profit tax collection, and for negative (positive) deviations for debt service payments from program assumptions."

### Millennium Development Goals (beginning of Table 7)
- Table heading: Nigeria: Selected Millennium Development Goals
- MDG Goal: Halve proportion of people whose income is less than US$1/day
- Columns present: Target for Nigeria; Status in 1990; Current Status
- (Table 7 content begins but is not fully provided in the supplied excerpt.)

*Sources: Nigerian authorities, and Fund staff estimates and projections.*

### 21.4 percent of population with income less than US$1/day

### 21.4 percent of population with income less than US$1/day

### Millennium Development Goals (MDG) targets and indicators
- Poverty
  - Target/statement: 21.4 percent of population with income less than US$1/day
  - Alternative reported figures in source:
    - 42.7 percent of population with income less than US$1/day
    - 52 percent of population with income less than US$1/day (WB 2006)
- Primary education
  - Target: Provide primary education for all children
  - Targets and enrolment rates:
    - 100 percent net primary enrolment
    - 68 percent gross primary enrolment
    - 60 percent gross primary enrolment (WB 2006)
- Child mortality
  - Target: Reduce by two-thirds the under five mortality rate
  - Reported under-five mortality figures:
    - Under-five mortality of 77 per 1,000 live births
    - Under-five mortality of 235 per 1,000 live births
    - Under-five mortality of 201 per 1,000 live births (WB 2005)
- Maternal health
  - Target: Reduce by three-quarters the maternal mortality rate
  - Births attended by skilled personnel:
    - 92 percent of births attended by skilled personnel
    - 33 percent of births attended by skilled personnel
    - 36 percent of births attended by skilled personnel (WB 2005)
- HIV/AIDS and major diseases
  - Target: Halt and begin to reverse incidence of HIV/AIDS, malaria and other major diseases
  - HIV/AIDS incidence:
    - Keep HIV/AIDS incidence at no higher than 1.8 percent
    - HIV/AIDS incidence of 1.8 percent
    - HIV/AIDS incidence of 5 percent (WB 2005)
- Water and sanitation
  - Target: Halve proportion of people without access to safe drinking water and basic sanitation
  - Targets:
    - Increase access to clean water to 68 percent of population
    - Increase access to basic sanitation to 70 percent
  - Reported access figures:
    - Access to clean water: 36 percent
    - Access to basic sanitation: 34.2 percent
    - Access to clean water: 42 percent (WB 2005)
    - Access to basic sanitation: 40 percent (WB 2005)
- Sources cited for MDG figures:
  - United Nations Development Programme, Millennium Development Goals Report Nigeria, 2004
  - World Bank, Nigeria’s Opportunity of a Generation: Meeting the MDGs, Reducing Indebtedness, April 2005 (WB 2005)
  - World Bank, Nigeria: Poverty Assessment, draft, June 2006 (WB 2006)

### Structural assessment criteria and benchmarks (Tables 8a and 8b)
- Key assessment criteria status highlights (expected dates preserved)
  - Introduce Integrated Personnel and Payroll Information System (IPPIS).
    - Expected Date of Achievement: Mar 2006 → Sep 2006
    - Status: Not met. Software installation in the 6 ministries and 6 central agencies of the 1st phase completed in March. Test payroll processing with the new system commenced in April, and deployment expected soon.
  - Establish database of pensioners and estimate size of pension arrears.
    - Expected Date of Achievement: Mar 2006 → Sep 2006
    - Status: Observed. Database established and arrears estimated.
  - FIRS to conduct nationwide taxpayer enumeration ... including TIN.
    - Expected Date of Achievement: Mar 2006 → Dec 2006
    - Status: Not met. Scale of necessary work was expanded and expected observed by July 2007. Delay due to an unanticipated second exercise to verify basic taxpayer information.
  - Central Bank of Nigeria to establish prudential standards for consolidated supervision and begin consolidated supervision.
    - Expected Date of Achievement: Mar 2006 → Dec 2006
    - Status: Not met. Remedial measures include a time-bound action plan by the time of the fourth review, and plans for a long-term technical assistance expert from mid-2007.
  - Management contract for the Transmission company of Nigeria to be awarded.
    - Expected Date of Achievement: Dec 2006 → Mar 2007
    - Status: Not met. Expected observed by end-May. Delays caused by procedure requirements in this World Bank sponsored project.
  - Appoint auditors to conduct the audit of the oil and gas sector for 2005 and 2006.
    - Expected Date of Achievement: Dec 2006 → Mar 2007
    - Status: Not met. Observed for 2005 audit. Delay with contract unlikely to hold up the 2006 audit. For the 2006 audit, open procurement has been launched.
- Structural benchmarks (selected)
  - Continue publication of revenue allocation to the three tiers of Government.
    - Expected Date: Oct 2005 → Continuous
    - Status: Observed. Data published regularly on the MoF website.
  - Financial bid opening of Port Harcourt and Kaduna refineries.
    - Expected Date: Mar 2006 → Jun 2006
    - Status: Not met. Negotiations resumed; Kaduna offered as integrated package to CNPC of China; Port Harcourt received eight expressions of interest.
  - Produce quarterly report of spending in MDG-related sectors (Health, Education, Power, Water, Roads, and Agriculture) to cover Q1 and Q2.
    - Expected Date: Mar 2006 → Sep 2006
    - Status: Not met. Preparation commenced but reports not automated due to delays in full implementation of computerized accounting system ATRRS in the OAGF.
  - Finalize and issue procurement manual.
    - Expected Date: Mar 2006 → Sep 2006
    - Status: Not met. Draft manual prepared; can be finalized once the Procurement Bill is passed.
  - Conduct transparency and anti-corruption survey in at least six pilot states.
    - Expected Date: Mar 2006 → Dec 2006
    - Status: Observed. National survey for the 2006 SEEDS benchmarking covered corruption issues and completed by end-December 2006 in 33 states.
  - Set up a tax policy unit in the Ministry of Finance.
    - Expected Date: Mar 2006 → Dec 2006
    - Status: Observed. Tax Policy Unit established under the Fiscal Policy Department.
  - Settle contractor arrears in cash for creditors with claim of up to N100 million and issue bonds to cover 50 percent of debts owed to larger creditors.
    - Expected Date: Mar 2006 → Dec 2006
    - Status: Observed with delay. All verified pre-2005 contractors' arrears have been paid; first wave of claims settled by end-December; additional waves concluded by March 2007; bonds issued for large contractors and all large contractor arrears have now been settled.
  - Continue reform of Nigeria Customs Service by expanding operations of Large Importers/Exporters Unit to handle at least 50 percent of the trade.
    - Expected Date: Mar 2006 → Dec 2006
    - Status: Not met. Expansion covered only about 30 - 40 percent of trade; delays due to maintaining appropriate safeguards.
  - Complete payment of severance benefits and training programs for retirees resulting from Civil Service reform program in MDAs.
    - Expected Date: Dec 2006 → Mar 2007
    - Status: Not met. More than 30,000 officers completed retraining but payment of severance benefits for about 3,000 officers pending verification; additional disengagements (10,000 from core civil service, 11,000 from parastatals) ongoing, with 10,000 officers already retrained.
  - Complete restructuring of 11 core Ministries as set out in paragraph 9 of the statement.
    - Expected Date: Dec 2006 → Mar 2007
    - Status: Observed. 12 ministries in the delineation in effect until January 2007 were reorganized by end-March; additional restructuring necessary for five ministries to complete merger initiated in January 2007.
- Table 8b: Benchmarks for May - June, 2007 (selected)
  - Complete restructuring of MDAs as set out in paragraph 9 of the statement.
    - Expected Date: Dec 2006 → May 2007
    - Status: Pending. 12 MDAs restructured by end-March; significant preparatory work expected completed by end-May but finalization now expected by the new administration.
  - Bid opening for sale of the Abuja Electricity Distribution Plc.
    - Expected Date: Dec 2006 → Jun 2007
    - Status: On track. Expressions of interest have closed.
  - Issue report on SEEDS Benchmarking for 36 States.
    - Expected Date: Dec 2006 → Jun 2007
    - Status: On track. Draft report under review and expected to be published in Q2 2007.
  - FIRS to complete implementation of human resource management system, including installation of HRM hardware and software for nationwide access, and conduct a competence assessment exercise.
    - Expected Date: Dec 2006 → Jun 2007
    - Status: Pending. Preparations underway; consultant replacement likely delaying the project.
  - Central Bank to introduce a new Standing Facility to help reduce interest rate volatility.
    - Expected Date: Dec 2006 → Jun 2007
    - Status: Observed. The facility was introduced in mid-Dec 2006.
  - Other observed/on-track benchmarks:
    - Complete restructuring of five parastatals in terms of right-sizing and right-staffing (Dec 2006 → May 2007): On track. Reorganization of CBN, NBS, and Center for Management Development completed; NNPC and FIRS reorganizations at advanced stage.
    - Bid opening for sale of 8 Oil Service Companies (Dec 2006 → Jun 2007): Observed. The 8 companies were sold in January.
    - Nigerian Customs Service to conduct staff survey for rationalization and right-sizing (Dec 2006 → Jun 2007): Observed. Staff survey and competency assessment conducted; draft report with management.

### Macroeconomic performance, policies, and government program (Attachment I, May 2007)
- Program context and objectives
  - The Policy Statement covers the fourth and final phase of the Policy Support Instrument (PSI) and summarizes reforms, progress with structural assessment criteria and benchmarks, and short- and medium-term objectives.
  - The reform program is based on the National Economic Empowerment and Development Strategy (NEEDS) and focuses on fiscal discipline through an oil price-based fiscal rule, improved public expenditure management, better public procurement systems, improved revenue collection, tax reforms, customs reforms, anti-corruption efforts (EFCC), and transparency in the oil and gas industry (N-EITI).
- Growth and output (exact figures preserved)
  - 2006 real GDP growth: 5.6 percent
  - 2006 oil GDP change: 4.7 percent decline
  - 2006 non-oil GDP growth: 8.9 percent
  - 2005 and 2004 overall GDP growth rates: 6.5 percent and 6.6 percent respectively
  - 2004 and 2005 non-oil GDP growth: 7.8 percent and 8.6 percent respectively
- Fiscal outcomes and reserves
  - Consolidated fiscal surplus for 2006: about 9 percent of GDP
  - Consolidated fiscal surpluses in 2005 and 2004: 11 percent and 10 percent of GDP respectively
  - Balance on the excess crude oil account as of end December 2006: $8.3 billion and N627.5 billion (the latter reflecting the balance for the domestic crude oil component)
  - Foreign reserves as of end 2006: $42.3 billion (from $28.3 billion a year earlier)
- Inflation and monetary policy
  - Inflation at end-December 2006 (year on year): 8.5 percent (compared to 11.6 percent at end 2005)
  - CPI composition note: foodstuff constitutes about 64% percent of the CPI basket
  - 12-month average inflation rate: 8.2 percent
  - Reserve money target: exceeded by about 11 percent (largely reflecting unexpected growth in currency in circulation in Q4)
  - CBN introduced a new Monetary Policy Rate (MPR) in December 2006 to reduce interest rate volatility; preliminary data indicate calming effect on rates
- External debt and ratings
  - Nigeria’s external debt as of end-2006: about 3% of GDP (most of this being multilateral debt)
  - London Club/Par Bonds and Oil Warrants actions:
    - Redeemed the Par Bonds ($1.486 billion) and repurchased promissory Notes; repurchased about ⅓ of its Oil Warrants
  - Sovereign ratings: Two international rating agencies (Fitch and Standard & Poor’s) awarded BB- with stable outlook in 2005; 2006 rating exercise confirmed the 2005 rating
- 2007 budget and fiscal framework
  - 2007 budget passed and signed in December 2006 (first time passed in advance of the new fiscal year)
  - Budget based on average price of $40 per barrel for Nigerian crude oil, following the price-based fiscal rule in operation since 2004
  - Strategy priorities: build on past gains, adhere to the medium term expenditure framework (MTEF), prudent public expenditure management, observance of due process in public procurement, intensify anti-corruption, continue privatization and deregulation, focus on employment generation, promote real sector activities and human capital development, and develop infrastructure partly funded from accumulated oil savings
  - Implementation caveat: Government aims to safeguard macroeconomic stability and ensure high quality of spending, while selecting projects with high import content consideration

*Sources: Nigerian authorities, United Nations Development Programme, World Bank, and Fund staff assessment.*

### 7. Short-term macroeconomic policy will revolve around the implementation of the

### 7. Short-term macroeconomic policy will revolve around the implementation of the

### Short-term macroeconomic policy and infrastructure spending
- Implementation of the 2007 budget includes extra expenditure on infrastructure to strengthen roads, railways, electricity, and dredging of the River Niger to facilitate inland waterways transportation.
- An estimated 75-80 percent of the expenditure will be in the form of imports and part of it will be funded from the excess crude oil account.
- A workshop on “Infrastructure Gap and Management of Oil Savings in Nigeria: Issues and Challenges” was organized in February in collaboration with the IMF, World Bank, Government of Norway and other development partners; the outcome document provides a roadmap and an action plan for implementation will be developed by the Government.
- The Due Process Office will continue oversight to underpin quality of spending.
- Interaction between fiscal and monetary authorities is being intensified so the Central Bank can have up-to-date information on the domestic component of extra spending and take timely action on liquidity management.
- A Fiscal Liquidity Assessment Committee (FLAC) comprising representatives of the Ministry of Finance, Budget Office, CBN, OAGF, NNPC, and FIRS has been set up to monitor expenditure developments and their liquidity implications; the FLAC now hold weekly meetings to review developments and provide advice.
- Provision has been made in the budget to fund the cost of liquidity mop-up.

### Specific elements of the macroeconomic framework (short term)
- Crude oil production is projected to average 2.50 Mb/d in 2007, taking into account the gradual recovery from the disruption to production in the Niger Delta.
- An oil price-based fiscal rule will continue to underpin the budgeting process; for the 2007 budget, the exact benchmark price was $40 per barrel.
- The targeted primary expenditure of the Federal Government in 2007 is estimated at about 10.9 percent of GDP.
- Nigeria will strive to attain the programmed consolidated non-oil primary deficit of 42 percent of non-oil GDP in 2007 (also taking account of the fuel subsidy), including by careful management of spending of the overflow of the 2006 capital budget, and by prudent implementation of the 2007 budget.
- The 2007 budget does not take account of any changes that might occur as a result of the transition to a new Government.
- The Government expects to continue to implement the structural targets set in the 2nd review.
- Excess revenue on the crude oil account will continue to be saved. It is estimated that the balance on the excess crude oil account would rise to the equivalent of 15.6 percent of GDP at end 2007 on the basis of current WEO oil price projections (of $60.8 per barrel average for Nigerian oil in 2007) and a $40 per barrel oil benchmark price.
- Based on the above, the stock of international reserves is expected to rise to $52.3 billion at end 2007.
- With continued prudent fiscal policy and a proactive monetary policy, inflation is estimated to remain in single digits, following the 8.2 percent level achieved at end 2006.
- Broad money growth rate of about 28 percent targeted for the year by the CBN was exceeded by about 12 percentage points.
- The CBN is committed to an exchange rate policy in line with the monetary policy objective of single-digit inflation.
- A real non-oil GDP growth rate in the range of 7-10 percent is being targeted by the Government for 2007, with the non-oil sector expected to continue to be the main driver.
- All 36 States have developed their counterpart to the NEEDS program, the State Economic Empowerment and Development Strategy (SEEDS); Government is engaging States to deepen reforms at the sub-national level, particularly in public expenditure management, debt management, public procurement, tax reforms, and privatization.
- Passage of key legislation, such as the Fiscal Responsibility Bill and Public Procurement Bill, will underpin reforms generally and push public expenditure reforms to the State level.
- The monetary program continues to be based on zero net lending to the Government by the CBN although in exceptional circumstances, it would lend to the Government but keep such lending at no more than 5.0 percent of the previous year’s retained revenue, and the loan must be cleared to zero by the end of the quarter.
- The CBN has introduced a new policy instrument, the monetary policy rate (MPR) to help reduce interest rate volatility; initial evidence shows that volatility has, indeed, started to decline.
- The CBN has prepared a draft framework for consolidated supervision of banks and is discussing it with key stakeholders (SEC, NAICOM and NDIC); a workshop by OSFI, Canada was hosted during April 16-19, 2007. By the time of the fourth review of the PSI, there will be a time-bound action plan for the introduction of consolidated banking supervision.
- The CBN continues internal restructuring to refocus work towards a more effective conduct of monetary policy.
- The CBN is on course in its restructuring of the Nigerian Security Printing and Minting (NSPM, Plc) and the four lower currency denominations (5, 10, 20, and 50 Naira) and the issuing of new coins (50 kobo, N1, and N2) to reduce the cost of currency issuance.

### Medium-term macroeconomic policy
- Crude oil production is expected to continue to increase in the medium term, possibly reaching about 2.70 Mb/d in 2008, and thereafter rise further in line with current Government plans to increase the production capacity.
- The oil price based fiscal rule will continue to underpin the budgeting process, particularly with the recent passage of the Fiscal Responsibility Bill by the National Assembly.
- The targeted primary expenditure of the Federal Government in 2008 is projected at about 10.9 percent of GDP.
- The monetary program in the medium term will continue as envisaged under the short term program with regard to broad monetary targets, and the new monetary policy framework, with priority continuing to be given to price stability.

### Structural reforms and privatization
- Several public enterprises listed for privatization in 2006 and 2007 were successfully sold, including eight oil service companies, while others are on target for sale.
- With the unbundling of the Power Holding Company of Nigeria (PHCN), Government is working to privatize all eleven of the distribution companies; work on the contract for the management of the Transmission Company of Nigeria is ongoing with bid documents issued to four pre-qualified investors and expected to be completed by end-May 2007. The bid opening for the Abuja Electrical Distribution Plc will be done by end-June 2007.
- Kaduna Refinery has been offered as an integrated package to CNPC of China; Port Harcourt is expected to be offered for sale in 2Q 2007.
- 8 oil service companies slated to be offered for sale in 2Q 2007 were successfully sold ahead of schedule (in January).
- 9 LPG plants will be offered for sale in 3Q 2007.

### Other structural reforms (selected)
- Following adoption of the five-band customs tariff in October 2005 under the CET of ECOWAS, Government will work towards reducing or eliminating the prohibition list by a date consistent with ECOWAS convergence criteria; the 50 percent tariff rate will be reviewed by end-2007 following a study on the impact of the tariff reform.
- Reform of the Nigeria Customs Service (NCS) continues; a staff survey and competency assessment have been conducted and a draft report is being considered by management. An estimated 30-40 percent of goods now pass through the fast track channel.
- The National Planning Commission commenced the 2nd SEEDS benchmarking in November 2006 using independent assessors; work is expected to be completed soon with publication of the outcome by the end of the second quarter of 2007.
- The Government is computerizing the Budget Office and Office of the Accountant General of the Federation (OAGF) to interconnect with BMPIU and CBN to reinforce the Accounting Transaction Recording and Reporting System (ATRRS), to be made consistent with the Integrated Financial Management System (IFMS) being developed with World Bank support.
- A Chart of Accounts developed by OAGF is now in full operation; the ATRRS is being extended to Nigerian Missions/Embassies abroad.
- Quarterly reports on debt relief expenditure have commenced following tagging and tracking of debt relief savings, though automation is pending full ATRRS implementation in OAGF.
- Significant progress on payment of contractor arrears: contractors owed up to N100 million have been fully paid off; bonds issued to cover debt to contractors owed over N100 million.
- A database of pensioners has been established and clearing of arrears is ongoing with cash payment for arrears for 2005 and bonds for pre-2005 arrears.
- The Debt Management Office (DMO) retired par bonds by paying $1.486 billion and also the promissory notes and oil warrants; a debt management framework has been developed and is under stakeholder discussion, with Fund technical assistance to be requested for further refinement.
- BMPIU has completed a draft procurement manual which will be finalized and published once the Public Procurement Bill is passed into law.
- Progress in payments to depositors of 14 failed banks: final court orders obtained in respect of 10 banks; a provision court order in respect of another; three others still pending. Healthy banks have been invited to assume private sector deposits under Purchase and Assumption resolution.
- With international oil prices in 2007 lower than in 2006, the amount of oil subsidy has declined; after the upward adjustment of the ex-depot price of diesel in July, 2006, fuel subsidy is minimal at present, limited mostly to kerosene. Government will continue to work towards liberalization of the sector.
- Recapitalization of Community banks is progressing (from N5 million to N20 million within a time frame of 18 months).
- Civil Service reforms: full disengagement of 30,000 staff; payment of severance benefits and training nearly completed, with full training provided by end March.
- A new salary structure has been introduced to motivate retained civil servants and attract good quality staff.
- 12 core Ministries have been restructured; Government reduced the number of Ministries in January by merging some of them.
- Complete restructuring of ministries, departments and agencies (MDAs) and parastatals targeted in 2nd Quarter, 2007; reorganization of the CBN, NBS, and Center for Management Development completed; reorganizations of NNPC and FIRS are at an advanced stage.
- FIRS is implementing nationwide taxpayer enumeration preparatory to automated tax administration and TIN; a consultant engaged in late 2006 is conducting the enumeration exercise with project expected to be completed in July 2007.
- A Tax Policy Unit has been set up in the Ministry of Finance; capacity strengthening is ongoing to avoid role duplication with FIRS.
- The National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) is being strengthened internally and working towards introduction of quarterly GDP data, having completed a comprehensive economic survey with the CBN.

### Transparency and anti–corruption efforts
- The final result of the 1999-2004 audit of the oil and gas sector under NEITI (a structural assessment criterion) was submitted to the President-in-Council in December 2006 and shared with the public; post-audit remedial measures were approved by the Cabinet and are being put in place, including designing standard reporting templates for relevant agencies and oil companies.
- The Department for Petroleum Resources (DPR) is working with international partners, including Norway, on systems to improve metering infrastructure in the upstream.
- The contract of the Hart Group has been extended through a ‘change order’ for the 2005 audit; the extension contract was signed in March and work has commenced. Procurement for the 2006 and value-for-money audit was launched in April and tenders have been called for.
- Publication of revenue allocation to the 3 tiers of Government is being continued.
- The EFCC has continued progress in arrest and prosecution of corrupt public officials and screening of politicians; EFCC and other agencies are intensifying work on internet fraudsters and anti-money laundering to sustain Nigeria’s de-listing from the category of non-cooperating countries and territories under the FATF.
- A nationwide corruption survey was conducted as part of the 2006 SEEDS benchmarking with focus on public procurement, transparency and prosecution of corruption cases.

*Source: _cr07263 - 7. Short-term macroeconomic policy will revolve around the implementation of the*

### 10. The push to get relevant bills in the National Assembly passed has intensified in

### 10. The push to get relevant bills in the National Assembly passed has intensified in

### Legislative progress and expectations
- Passage status of key bills:
  - Fiscal Responsibility Bill: passage by the Senate took place in February. The Lower House has now also passed the bill.
  - Public Procurement Bill: passed by both Houses of the National Assembly; including on the basis of another study tour in late 2006 by the relevant Committees.
  - Tax Reform Bills: Six of the eight Tax Reform Bills have been passed by the National Assembly; efforts are on to pass the other two.
  - NEITI bill: following more intensive engagement with the Senate, the NEITI bill was passed by the Senate in March; the House of Representatives had already passed its own version of the bill.
- Expectation: harmonization will be concluded and all bills signed into law before the end of the current session.

### Growth strategy, MDGs, and financing needs
- Policy emphasis:
  - Transmit reform gains to everyday benefits for ordinary Nigerians to secure continued public support.
  - Promote economic growth particularly in the non-oil sector: agriculture, solid minerals, and tourism.
  - Achieve MDG targets as captured under the NEEDS program—poverty reduction, wealth creation, employment generation.
  - Greater investment in physical and human infrastructure (education and health), productive activities, and a more vigorous pursuit of the Nigerian content agenda.
- Growth targets and financing gap:
  - Government targeting an annual real GDP growth rate of about 7-10 percent.
  - It is estimated that a 7 percent growth rate is needed in order to achieve the objectives of NEEDS.
  - Current estimates indicate that there is a financing gap of about $4 billion per annum if Nigeria is to meet the NEEDS/MDG objectives.
- Program development:
  - The development of the second phase of the NEEDS program (2008-2011) is at an advanced stage.

### Use of savings from Paris Club exit for MDG spending
- Policy: Deploy savings arising from exiting the Paris Club debt (about $1 billion per annum, of which $750 million is from the Federal Government) into MDG-related spending.
- Budget appropriations:
  - In the 2007 budget, a total of N110 billion was appropriated for this purpose.
  - In 2006, N100 billion was allocated for this purpose.

### Program monitoring and IMF engagement (PSI)
- PSI arrangement:
  - Continued use of quantitative targets, assessment criteria and structural benchmarks up to the first half of 2007 and in the context of the agreed framework.
  - Targets will continue to be used to assess the performance of Government policy and reform implementation.
  - Government envisages that the fourth and final review to assess the performance up to June 2007 will be no later than October 16, 2007.
- Government commitment on financing:
  - Reiterates commitment to seek only concessional financing to help finance any gap in its investment program.
  - An exceptional loan is being taken from China in the amount of $2.5 billion towards the cost of building a railway system and other infrastructure projects for which a framework has been agreed.
  - Terms under discussion; interest rate likely to be about 3%, with a grace period of 3-5 years and a term of 15-25 years depending on the particular project.
  - Government believes this one-off arrangement is essential to strengthen infrastructure and that implementation of Nigeria’s home-grown program supported under the PSI and its financing will help achieve the MDGs.
  - Government renews commitment not to request for the use of IMF or PRGF resources in the course of implementation of its home-grown program.

### Key quantitative assessment criteria for June '07 (Table 1)
(Billions of naira, unless otherwise indicated)
- Assessment Criteria — Revised / Criteria
  - Federal government non-oil primary balance (floor) — -728 / -728
  - Reserve money (ceiling) — 866 / 860
  - Net foreign assets of the CBN (floor) — 6,048 / 5,560
  - New non-concessional external debt by the public sector (ceiling) — 00 / 00
  - External arrears — 00 / 00
- Memorandum items:
  - Oil production (in million barrels per day) — 2.49 / 2.39
  - Oil price (in U.S. dollars per barrel) — 3 63.3 / 64.3
  - Petroleum Profit Tax — 1,111 / 566
  - External debt service — 38 / 66
  - State and local government non-oil primary balance — -878 / -858
- Notes and adjustments:
  - Sources: Nigerian authorities and staff estimates and projections.
  - 1 Cumulative until the end of the period and includes the fuel subsidy.
  - 2 Applies on a continuous basis.
  - 3 Actual and projected prices lagged by two months to allow for pass-through to government revenue.
  - Note: The net foreign assets target will be adjusted upward (downward) for positive (negative) deviations of oil prices, oil and gas and Petroleum Profit Tax collection, and for negative (positive) deviations for debt service payments from program assumptions.

### Structural benchmarks and assessment criteria (Table 2) — May–June 2007 under the PSI Program
- Structural assessment criteria (selected items, expected date and status):
  - Bid opening for sale of the Abuja Electricity Distribution Plc as set out in paragraph 9 of the statement — End June 2007 — Ongoing; on target
  - Issue report on SEEDS Benchmarking for 36 States to be published as set out in paragraph 9 of the statement — End June 2007 — Ongoing
  - Complete restructuring of MDAs as set out in paragraph 9 of the statement — End-May 2007 — Ongoing
  - FIRS to complete implementation of human resource management system, including installation of HRM hardware and software for nationwide access, and conduct a competence assessment exercise to determine training needs — End-June 2007 — Ongoing
  - The Central Bank to introduce a new Standing Facility to help reduce interest rate volatility as stated in paragraph 7 of the statement — End-June 2007 — Done
- Structural benchmarks (selected items):
  - Continue publication of revenue allocation to the three tiers of Government — Continuous — Ongoing
  - Complete restructuring of five parastatals in terms of right-sizing and right-staffing — End-May 2007 — Ongoing
  - Bid opening for sale of 8 Oil Service Companies — End-June 2007 — Done
  - Nigerian Customs Service to conduct staff survey to determine suitability of personnel for minimum requirements of service in preparation for rationalization, realignment and right-sizing its human resource system — End-June 2007 — Done
- Footnote:
  - 1 Assessment criteria will also apply on a continuous basis to exchange and import measures as in Fund supported programs.

### Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU) — Performance target definitions and reporting standards (selected highlights)
- A. Floor on Federal Government Non-Oil Primary Balance
  - Definition: measured on a cash basis; defined as non-oil-and-gas-related revenue minus total expenditure excluding interest payments.
  - Non-oil-and-gas-related revenue: federal government’s share of imports and excise duties, companies’ income tax, and value-added tax, as well as the federal government’s independent revenue.
  - Federal government expenditure includes recurrent and capital expenditure, any clearance of expenditure arrears and recapitalizations.
  - Supporting material: OAGF to provide monthly federally collected revenue and federal expenditure to the Fund within six weeks of the end of each month; monthly federal government capital account balances within six weeks; quarterly summary of capital releases and utilization within six weeks of the end of each quarter.
- B. Ceiling on Reserve Money
  - Definition: Reserve money = currency in circulation and deposit money banks’ deposits at the CBN; target defined as the end-of-period stock.
  - Supporting material: CBN balance sheet transmitted monthly to the Fund within six weeks of the end of each month.
- C. Floor on Net Foreign Assets of the CBN
  - Definition: NFA = foreign assets minus short-term foreign liabilities of the CBN; target defined as the end-of-period stock.
  - Adjustment clauses: floor adjusted for cumulative deviations from program assumptions on (a) oil revenue and (b) external debt service payments; upward (downward) adjustments for higher (lower) oil/gas prices and production volumes and petroleum profit tax collections; adjustments for external debt service deviations.
  - Supporting material: CBN and OAGF to provide monthly data on NFA, foreign assets, foreign liabilities, oil revenue into the federation account, and petroleum profit tax collection within six weeks of the end of each month; DMO to supply data on external debt service payments within four weeks of the end of each month.
- D. Non-Accumulation of External Arrears
  - Definition: federal government and the CBN will not incur any payment arrears on external debt service obligations to creditors during the PSI; assessment target continuous.
  - Supporting material: DMO to report details of arrears accumulated on interest and principal payments to the Fund within two weeks from the due date of the missed payment.
- E. Ceiling on Contracting or Guaranteeing of New Non-Concessional External Debt by the Federal Government and the CBN
  - Definition: non-concessional external loans = loans with a grant element < 35 percent; grant element calculated using OECD (CIRRs) currency-specific discount rates; for maturities < 15 years use six-month averages of commercial interest rates; for maturities > 15 years use 10-year averages.
  - Applicability: applies to debt and commitments contracted or guaranteed for which value has not been received; previously contracted non-concessional external debt that has been rescheduled excluded.
  - Supporting material: Ministry of Finance to provide details of all new commitments and government guarantees for external borrowing monthly within two weeks of the end of each month.
- Memorandum item F. Floor on Non-oil Primary Balance of States and Local Governments (SLGs)
  - Definition: SLG non-oil primary balance = non-oil-and-gas-related revenue minus primary expenditure; revenue components defined similarly to federal definition; primary expenditure computed per formula in paragraph 13.
  - Supporting material: OAGF to provide SLG revenue data monthly within six weeks; CBN to provide data on changes in net claims on SLGs by the banking system.

*Source: IMF country document (May 2007).*

### 1.      The Nigerian government has been making progress with implementation of the

### _cr07263 - 1.      The Nigerian government has been making progress with implementation of the

### NEEDS/SEEDS reform framework and Country Partnership Strategy (CPS)
- The National Economic Empowerment and Development Strategy (NEEDS) at the Federal level works in parallel with State Economic Empowerment and Development Strategies (SEEDS) to improve the environment for development assistance and strengthen aid effectiveness.
- The World Bank/DFID Country Partnership Strategy (CPS) (approved June 25, 2005) guides assistance for FY06 to FY09 and supports priorities under three pillars of the NEEDS/SEEDS framework:
  - (i) empowering people through improved service delivery for human development;
  - (ii) promoting private enterprise through improved business environment for non-oil growth and improved access to productive infrastructure;
  - (iii) changing the way government does its work through improved transparency and accountability.
- CPS approach:
  - Deepening engagement with Nigeria in response to improved policy environment and Nigeria’s importance for meeting the MDGs in Africa.
  - More support provided to states where constitutional responsibility for MDG-related functions lies.
  - More selective assistance concentrated at the Federal level and in a set of lead states; Bank has signed State Partnership Agreements with four lead states.
- IDA lending envelope under CPS increased:
  - from about US$500 million to about US$750 million for FY07-10.
  - This envelope is expected to increase as Nigeria’s policy performance continues to improve.
  - Indicative lending plans for the remaining two years of the CPS to be set during the mid-term review of the CPS in 2007.

### World Bank–IMF relations and joint analytical work
- IMF and World Bank staffs maintain close collaboration on Nigeria, coordinating policy advice in areas including the financial sector, public financial management, and statistics through analytical work and joint technical assistance missions.
- Joint activities:
  - 2005: Bank and IMF collaborated on a Debt Sustainability Analysis and prepared a Joint Staff Assessment Note on NEEDS discussed by both Boards.
  - 2006: Bank and IMF jointly updated the Debt Sustainability Analysis.
  - Bank staff regularly join IMF macroeconomic missions.
- New workstream:
  - Bank and IMF staffs beginning work with Government on the macroeconomics of scaling up to analyze options for scaling up to meet the MDGs in a manner consistent with macroeconomic stability.

### IDA lending activities and portfolio performance
- IDA commitment growth:
  - about US$1.5 billion in FY05,
  - US$1.8 billion in FY06,
  - currently (FY07) stands at about US$2.3 billion.
- Portfolio at risk:
  - about 18 percent (FY07), improved from 79 percent in FY03 and 43 percent in FY05.
- Sectoral composition of the portfolio (percent):
  - Health and Social Services 25 percent
  - Education 8 percent
  - Transportation 6 percent
  - Energy and Mining 14 percent
  - Public Administration/Law 18 percent
  - Agriculture 4 percent
  - Water Supply/Sanitation/Flood Protection 23 percent
  - Finance 1 percent
  - Industry and Trade 1 percent
- Disbursements and efficiency:
  - As of April 2007, about US$842 million disbursed out of total IDA commitment of US$2.3 billion.
  - Current disbursement ratio of 19.4 percent.
  - Portfolio’s resource utilization likely to meet or surpass the 23 percent level achieved at end of FY06.
  - Recent improvement attributed to intensified project supervision and maturity of portfolio (average project age of over three years).
  - Bank focus: mitigating portfolio risks and strengthening monitoring and evaluation (M&E) arrangements to ensure projects achieve development objectives.

### IDA Credit Portfolio (selected figures from Table 1, as of April 23, 2007, US$ million)
- TOTAL: IDA Approved 2,279.1; Disbursed 842.5; Undisbursed 1,590.4
- Selected projects (Project Name — Fiscal Year — Approved — Disbursed — Undisbursed):
  - Local Empowerment & Environment Management — 2004 — 70.0 — 43.0 — 36.0
  - Community-based Urban Development — 2002 — 110.0 — 34.9 — 97.6
  - 2nd Health Systems Development — 2002 — 127.0 — 115.2 — 36.2
  - HIV/AIDS Program Development — 2002 — 90.3 — 86.6 — 18.4
  - Privatization Support Project — 2001 — 114.3 — 63.4 — 70.6
  - Urban Water Sector Reform I — 2004 — 120.0 — 18.3 — 104.9
  - Transmission Development — 2002 — 100.0 — 82.9 — 33.2
  - Lagos Urban Transport Project — 2003 — 150.0 — 76.5 — 86.7
  - Polio Eradication — 2003 — 80.4 — 75.7 — 3.3
  - Micro, Small & Medium Enterp. — 2004 — 32.0 — 4.4 — 29.5
  - Sustainable Management of Mineral Resources — 2005 — 120.0 — 17.2 — 102.9
  - Economic Reform and Governance — 2005 — 140.0 — 25.0 — 116.2
  - Urban Water Sector Reform II — 2006 — 200.0 — 11.8 — 188.9
  - National Energy Development Project — 2006 — 172.0 — 5.4 — 166.7
  - Avian Influenza Control — 2006 — 50.0 — 20.4 — 32.2
  - Lagos Metropolitan Development and Governance — 2007 — 200.0 — 0.0 — 210.2
  - Community-based Poverty Reduction Project — 2000 — 85.0 — 68.0 — 25.1
  - Malaria Control Booster Project — 2006 — 180.0 — 0.0 — 184.2

### Proposed IDA lending summary, FY2008/10 (as of April 23, 2007, US$ million)
- FY 08 proposed total: 750
  - Fadama 3 200
  - Federal Roads 250
  - State Education 50
  - Rural Access and Mobility (RAMP 1) 70
  - Commercial Agriculture 100
  - State Level Growth Pole & Infrastructure Facilities 80
- FY 09 proposed total: 750
  - State Health or Polio Immunization Project 50
  - Support for Sustainable development of Power Sector 80
  - Federal Roads 250
  - State and Local Government/Justice project 50
  - Community Social Development project 200
  - HIV/AIDS 100
  - Lagos-Abidjan Transport and Transit (Regional) 20
- FY 10 proposed total: 750
  - Commercial Agriculture/Rural Finance 100
  - Federal Roads 2 250
  - State Education 3 50
  - State Water 100
  - State Health 50
  - Rural Access and Mobility (RAMP 2) 150
  - Conditional Cash Transfer /Maternal and Child Health 100

### Non-lending activities and analytical program
- Expanded Economic and Sector Work (ESW) focus: public expenditure management, competitiveness and growth, regional integration agenda, poverty analysis, social sector trends.
- Key proposed analytical pieces and timing:
  - Fiscal Federalism study (FY08)
  - Agriculture Financing Review (FY08)
  - Agriculture PER (FY08)
  - Employment and Growth study (FY09)
  - Poverty Assessment (FY10)
  - Trade and Regional Integration study (FY10)
- Non-lending summary (FY2008/10) — proposed and ongoing work (as of April 23, 2007):
  - FY08 proposed highlights: Polio Eradication ICR; Economic Management and Capacity-building Project (EMCAP) ICR; Agriculture Public Expenditure Review; Fiscal Federalism Study; Niger Delta Social and Conflict Analysis; Financing Agriculture Study; Human Development Strategy Note; Health Insurance Study; Petroleum Pricing Study; NEITI Report; Governance of Service Delivery Review.
  - FY09 proposed highlights: Employment and Growth Study; Transport and Economic Growth Study; Nutrition Study; Access to Justice study.
  - FY10 proposed highlights: Poverty Assessment; Trade and Regional Integration Study; Non-Bank Financial Institutions Study.
  - Ongoing FY07–09 activities include Education Sector Review - States; Health Sector review - States; Investment Climate Assessment - State; Corruption and Governance Risks Assessment; Natural Resources Management/Environmental Policy Dialogue; Nigeria Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative (NEITI); Legal reforms—Technical Assistance (TA); Niger Delta Community Foundation; Results Monitoring IDF; Country Portfolio Performance Review (CPPR); Implementation support—M&E and PFMU; Human Development Outcome Dialogue; Non-oil Growth Outcome Dialogue; Governance Outcome Dialogue; Donor Harmonization; Economic Monitoring; Support to the National Assembly; Civil Society Outreach; Private Sector Outreach; Communication Outreach and Academia.

### International Finance Corporation (IFC) activities and portfolio (as of March 31, 2007)
- Nigeria is IFC’s largest commitment portfolio in Sub-Sahara Africa with an outstanding portfolio of US$612 million in private sector investments as of March 2007.
- Nigeria represents approximately 26 percent of the Sub-Sahara Africa region’s portfolio, having grown from US$143 million in 2001.
- IFC sectoral highlights:
  - Financial sector:
    - Over the past five years, IFC disbursed over US$220 million to five Nigerian banks as long-term credit lines.
    - Signed five Nigerian banks as issuing banks under the IFC Global Trade Finance Program.
    - Total utilization of trade finance facilities approximately US$200 million in FY07.
    - IFC provides specialized financing facilities and technical assistance targeting women entrepreneurs and construction finance; diversifying to non-bank financial institutions (insurance, asset management).
    - IFC provided naira long-term financing facilitated by long-term cross-currency swaps from naira into convertible currencies.
  - General manufacturing services:
    - Under African Enterprise Funds, IFC invested in general manufacturing projects and disbursed part of a long-term loan of US$75 million for Obajana Cement Company — a green field cement plant with annual capacity of 4.4 million tons; project includes a 135MW power plant, a 92 KM natural gas pipeline, a water supply dam and support facilities.
  - Oil and gas, mining and petrochemicals:
    - IFC targets services linkages to oil majors and indigenous oil and gas production and services companies.
    - Approved a US$75 million investment for Eleme petrochemicals project for rehabilitation and expansion of capacity.
  - Advisory and technical assistance:
    - Private Enterprise Partnership (PEP) Africa initiative supports investment climate improvement, investment opportunity identification, and SME development.
    - Leading projects in Nigeria: SME Entrepreneurship Development Initiative; Oil Sector SME Linkages Project (with INSOK, Norway); bond market development.
    - IFC is lead adviser to government for privatization of Nigeria airports (beginning with Abuja airport).
    - Joint World Bank/IFC Energy Team working with federal government on power sector reform and privatization strategies.
- Selected IFC portfolio totals (Table 4, Statement at March 31, 2007):
  - Total IFC commitments: 611.54 (US$ millions)
  - Total Loan: 313.62
  - Total Equity: 48.71
  - Total Quasi-loan/Quasi equity: 150.18
  - Total Guarantee: 99.05

### World Bank Institute (WBI) and MIGA activities
- WBI:
  - Nigeria is a WBI Focus Country.
  - WBI partners to build capacity for programs that empower communities, improve economic governance and ensure non-oil private sector development.
  - WBI objectives include strengthening national parliament, increasing civil society participation via youth programs, facilitating pluralistic media, supporting science and technology (AIST).
  - A Global Distance Learning Network (GDLN) center expected to be completed and functional in Abuja before mid-2007.
  - WBI training programs support Federal Center for Health Systems Studies and other programs: Support for NEEDS Implementation, HIV/AIDS, and building capacity in Nigerian youth organizations.
- MIGA:
  - MIGA offers guarantees against noncommercial risks to foreign investors and has issued guarantees in Nigeria totaling about US$91.5 million in gross exposure (1.88% of the Agency’s gross portfolio).
  - Major stakes concentrated in services sector: guarantees for SGS and Cotecna totaling US$81 million in FY06 to modernize port screening facilities.
  - MIGA played an effective role in resolving a potential investment dispute between Government of Nigeria and one insured investor.

*Italic: Source: _cr07263 - 1.      The Nigerian government has been making progress with implementation of the (PDF content unit provided).*

### ANNEX III. STATISTICAL ISSUES

### ANNEX III. STATISTICAL ISSUES

### Overview: principal deficiencies and institutional context
- Nigeria’s statistical base suffers from serious deficiencies that hamper surveillance, policy design, and monitoring, particularly affecting national accounts, government finance, money and banking, and the external accounts, including major inconsistencies between balance of payments and customs data on trade.
- Key systemic causes: lack of data sharing between data producing and collecting agencies, insufficient computerization, and an outdated Statistical Act (1957) that does not address data collection and dissemination within a federal structure.
- Nigeria began participation in the Fund’s General Data Dissemination System (GDDS) in April 2003 and posted metadata on the DSBB; metadata were updated towards the end of 2005 and the beginning of 2006.
- Numerous Fund missions (1999 multisector, 2000–2006 follow-ups, and specialist missions) identified recommendations; progress has been uneven and limited in many areas.

### National accounts
- Findings:
  - National accounts statistics are of poor quality largely due to deterioration in business and household surveys.
  - Estimates of value added for agriculture, mining (oil), industry, transportation, and financial and other services rely on old surveys and extrapolations using out-of-date ratios and indicators.
  - Many sectoral deflators are not soundly based and exhibit inconsistencies.
  - Use of the official exchange rate historically resulted in a gross understatement of value added in the oil and export sectors.
  - Expenditure accounts suffer from unreliable external trade and government budgetary data.
  - Annual national accounts are published by the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS) with about a one-year lag.
- Developments and reforms:
  - A July 2003 mission found progress and significant technical assistance from DfID and other institutions.
  - Results of a 2003 household living standards survey are available.
  - The base year was updated to 1990 from 1984.
  - GDP methodology amended for estimates from 2004 onward to move toward SNA 1993 and incorporate new data sources; revisions under review in the IMF/DFID GDDS Phase 2 Project for Anglophone Africa.

### Prices
- Findings:
  - Official monthly consumer price index (CPI) is a composite of urban and rural data, with consumption weights based on the 1985–86 National Consumer Survey.
  - Producer price data are incomplete and no producer price index is compiled.
  - Some GDP deflators rely on consumer price subindices and ad hoc assumptions; expenditure deflators suffer methodological shortcomings.
- Plans:
  - Update CPI weighting to 1996/97 using a National Consumer Survey.

### Government finance (GFS)
- Findings:
  - Fiscal data have been opaque due to the federal structure, multiplicity of off-budget funds, and accounting practices that underestimate public expenditure.
  - Pressing shortcomings: inadequate data coverage, lack of monthly and quarterly compilation, and inadequate timeliness (noted in the September 1999 multisector mission).
  - 2001 GFS mission found few recommendations from 1999 implemented; inconsistencies across data sources; substantial room for improvement in consistency and reconciliation between above- and below-the-line data.
  - Annual fiscal data are not reported for the GFS Yearbook; aggregated fiscal data are reported for the IFS, but no quarterly or monthly financing data are reported.
- Action plan (2002 mission) recommendations:
  - Expand the National Committee on Government Finance Statistics (NCGFS) and increase GFS unit staffing.
  - Improve consistency of OAGF and Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) source data.
  - Expand CBN work to reconcile government financing data.
  - Have the GFS unit document an inventory of source data.
  - Improve coverage to include state and local government operations and dissemination of GFS data.
  - Move to fuller application of GFSM 2001 guidelines.
- Follow-up:
  - July 2003 mission found very few recommendations implemented, though specific CBN-related work showed progress.

### Monetary accounts
- Findings:
  - Past steps taken toward implementing STA money and banking TA recommendations, but problems remain: inconsistent interbank positions, central government deposits, and large unexplained other items net.
  - Reporting of monetary data to the IFS was interrupted because of major unresolved accounting problems at the CBN.
  - Throughout 2006 the CBN changed its core accounting system without a transition period; this produced serious distortions including erroneous recording of some asset balances as liabilities and failure to capture large foreign currency transactions.
  - The most recent data published in the STA database are for September 2006.

### Balance of payments
- Findings:
  - BOP statistics compiled from banking-system foreign exchange records and surveys are weakened by low survey response rates from oil businesses; in non-oil sectors only enterprises with foreign capital participation are surveyed.
  - Non-oil imports of goods and services are estimated from banking data; private capital movements are under recorded.
  - Trade data reported by the NBS (customs-based) sharply differ from CBN (banking-based) data; customs-based data likely significantly under-report informal trade vs. counterparty data.
  - Large negative errors and omissions in BOP statistics, probably reflecting underestimation of current account debit transactions.
  - Compilation continues to be affected by organizational weaknesses and resource constraints in NBS, customs, and CBN.
  - Authorities have not initiated compilation of international reserves data in line with the Data Template on International Reserves and Foreign Currency Liquidity; staff unable to assess consistency of official reserve asset data with the template.

### External debt
- Progress and gaps:
  - United Kingdom–financed TA launched October 1998 to address external debt data issues.
  - Debt Management Office established August 2000; progress made in verifying individual loan accounts and improving debt management efficiency.
  - Correctness and duplication audit carried out after merging Federal Ministry of Finance and CBN databases.
  - Reconciliation with multilateral creditors began September 2000; Paris Club verifications following December 13, 2000 agreement were reported complete by October 2001.
  - Authorities do not collect data on private sector external debt and should extend coverage to include private sector liabilities.

### Nigeria: Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (As of May 17, 2007)
- Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation Apr 2007; Date received May 2007; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication D
- International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities1: Date of latest observation Feb 2007; Date received Apr 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M
- Reserve/Base Money: Date of latest observation Feb 2007; Date received Apr 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M
- Broad Money: Date of latest observation Feb 2007; Date received Apr 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M
- Central Bank Balance Sheet: Date of latest observation Feb 2007; Date received Apr 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M
- Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: Date of latest observation Feb 2007; Date received Apr 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M
- Interest Rates2: Date of latest observation Apr 2007; Date received May 2007; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of publication D
- Consumer Price Index: Date of latest observation Mar 2007; Date received Apr 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing3 – General Government4: Date of latest observation Feb 2007; Date received Apr 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing3 – Central Government: Date of latest observation Mar. 2007; Date received May 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M
- Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt5: Date of latest observation Dec 2006; Date received Feb 2007; Frequency of Data A; Frequency of Reporting A; Frequency of publication A
- External Current Account Balance: Date of latest observation Dec 2006; Date received Feb 2007; Frequency of Data A; Frequency of Reporting A; Frequency of publication A
- Exports and Imports of Goods: Date of latest observation Mar 2006; Date received Feb 2007; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication A
- GDP/GNP: Date of latest observation 2006; Date received Feb 2007; Frequency of Data A; Frequency of Reporting A; Frequency of publication A
- Gross External Debt: Date of latest observation Dec 2006; Date received Feb 2007; Frequency of Data A; Frequency of Reporting A; Frequency of publication A

(Notes from table retained verbatim: 1 Includes reserve assets pledged or otherwise encumbered as well as net derivative positions. 2 Both market-based and officially-determined, including discount rates, money market rates, rates on treasury bills, notes and bonds. 3 Foreign, domestic bank, and domestic nonbank financing. 4 The general government consists of the central government (budgetary funds, extra budgetary funds, and social security funds) and state and local governments. 5 Including currency and maturity composition. 6 Daily (D), Weekly (W), Monthly (M), Quarterly (Q), Annually (A); Irregular (I); Not Available (NA))

### IMF staff and Executive Board findings and policy implications (June 2007)
- IMF staff representative (Statement, June 27, 2007) key points:
  - Monetary program broadly on-track: broad money growth remained below projections; currency issued was higher-than-expected in April; credit to the private sector rose further.
  - Money data were provided in line with program understandings; reconciliation of different data sources is ongoing and supported through Fund technical assistance.
  - Inflation: headline inflation was 4.7 percent year-on-year in May; core inflation fell to 2.8 percent year-on-year.
  - Fiscal management during political transition: allocation of revenues to the states was suspended temporarily in May; new capital spending authorizations at the federal level were largely halted in April and May.
  - Staff estimates: the non-oil primary deficit of the federal government was above its April path by about 0.3 percent of non-oil GDP due to higher capital spending utilization early in the year.
  - Legislation enacted: Fiscal Responsibility Bill approved by both Houses; NEITI, the public procurement, the central bank, and the VAT acts among others signed into law.
  - Tax and fuel policy actions under discussion: outgoing administration doubled VAT rate to 10 percent and increased gasoline prices by 15 percent; subsequent partial rollbacks decided—kerosene price to be reduced to original levels, gasoline increase to be halved, and the increase in VAT rates to be rolled back.
  - Structural reform progress: sale of 51 percent of government stakes in the Port Harcourt and Kaduna oil refineries (June-2006 benchmark) was completed; draft framework for consolidated supervision (December-2006 assessment criterion) produced; selection for management contract for Transmission Company of Nigeria made (contract can be awarded once a “no objection” from the World Bank is received); bids for conducting the 2006 audit of the oil and gas sector (March-2007 assessment criterion) received and under review.
  - A draft National Economic Empowerment and Development Strategy for 2008-2011 (NEEDS 2) was completed and should inform medium-term policies.
- IMF Executive Board (Press Release No. 07/146, June 28, 2007) conclusions and policy guidance:
  - The third review under the two-year Policy Support Instrument (PSI) for Nigeria was completed on June 27, 2007; waivers were agreed for nonobservance of five structural assessment criteria and two quantitative assessment criteria on reserve money and nonconcessional borrowing.
  - Program aims to balance spending needs with maintaining macroeconomic stability and is guided by the National Economic Empowerment and Development Strategy.
  - The Board commended authorities for reforms that led to robust growth, low inflation, and improved investor confidence, but noted uneven recent performance.
  - The late-2006 fiscal expansion resulted from deviation from the oil price fiscal rule and led to an unanticipated liquidity injection, which did not produce excessive inflationary pressures.
  - Recommendations and priorities emphasized by the Acting Chair:
    - Ensure accuracy and quality of monetary data.
    - Maintain fiscal policy consistent with macroeconomic stability.
    - Reaffirm political agreement on use of oil revenues among all levels of government.
    - Develop guidelines on effective use of oil savings and ensure good quality of capital spending.
    - Continue structural reforms including trade liberalization.
  - The Board noted past inaccuracies in information provided on nonconcessional borrowing but judged these did not significantly undermine debt sustainability; given authorities’ efforts to strengthen debt management, the Board maintained a positive assessment of past program performance under the PSI.

*Source: _cr07263 - ANNEX III. STATISTICAL ISSUES (IMF staff report and associated statements), as provided in the content unit.*

### 1.      The Nigerian authorities express their appreciation to the Fund for continuous

### _cr07263 - 1.      The Nigerian authorities express their appreciation to the Fund for continuous

### Recent Macroeconomic Developments and Performance
- Authorities attribute program achievements under the PSI to strong commitment to macroeconomic stability, structural reforms, a generally favorable external environment, and Fund TA support.
- Reported program outcomes:
  - Overall real GDP growth: estimated 5.2 percent in 2006; projected 8.2 percent in 2007.
  - Non-oil GDP growth: from 8.9 percent in 2006 to 7.5 percent in 2007.
  - Oil GDP growth: from -2.8 percent in 2006 to a projected 9.9 percent in 2007.
  - Inflation: estimated 8.2 percent in 2006; projected 7.8 percent in 2007 (single-digit objective).
  - Sovereign rating: BB-.
- Contributing factors to growth: high agricultural output (good weather and supportive policies), strong communications, construction and service sectors.
- Fiscal operations anchored on oil price-based fiscal rule resulted in overall budget surplus and accumulation of substantial reserves.

### Performance under the PSI
- Structural reform implementation continued successfully; outgoing government prepared policy strategy documents handed to new administration (took office on May 29, 2007).
- Some final steps of structural measures were delayed; delays often due to expanded scope of work. Most delayed measures have either been completed or are well advanced; remedial measures taken.
- Staff assessment: missed quantitative and structural criteria do not undermine the thrust of the PSI policy framework.
- Misreporting issue:
  - Government contracted a US$200 million non-concessional loan, signed on January 12, 2006.
  - Authorities agree with Fund concerns, responded to Management’s letter, and provided relevant documentation.
  - Loan arrangement was part of a supplier’s contract executed on December 15, 2004 (PSI had not come into effect) and underwent protracted negotiations through 2005.
  - Authorities regretted the oversight in not providing information during first and second reviews; attributed to changes in key personnel in the Ministry of Finance, poor debt database, and weak debt management capacity at the time.
  - Authorities have strengthened debt management practices following this experience.

### Macroeconomic Policies for 2007/08 and the Medium-term
- Authorities recognize remaining challenges and are adopting strong policy measures.
- Electricity supply constraint being addressed: several new power plants brought into operation to stabilize and enhance electricity production and reduce costs.
- Continued TA on Statistics and data reconciliation to refine monetary data.
- Key legislations enacted into law to institutionalize reforms; a high-level national conference convened to address the Niger Delta problem.
- Growth projections:
  - Real GDP growth projected at 8.2 percent in 2007 and 6.7 percent in 2008.
  - Drivers: rising gas production, expected recovery in oil output to 2005 levels, improved infrastructure, robust non-oil sector performance.
- Inflation policy: inflationary pressures to be contained and inflation kept at single digits through stronger fiscal position and monetary growth lower than non-oil sector growth.

### Fiscal Policy
- Overall fiscal balance was in surplus in 2006, allowing further accumulation of savings, but a larger-than-projected expansion in consolidated government level added to domestic demand.
- Authorities reaffirmed commitment to 2007 fiscal program (relying on the MTEF) set during the second review.
- Fiscal strategy includes:
  - Reduction in fiscal impulse by envisaging a reduction in non-oil primary deficit of the consolidated government spending by about 3 percent of non-oil GDP.
  - Increased capital spending on key infrastructure (including projects with high import content) while containing other spending.
  - Adherence to the oil-price fiscal rule as primary determinant of achieving consolidated government target.
- Debt management:
  - Comprehensive Debt Management Framework prepared to preserve recent gains in debt sustainability.
  - The DSF provides guidance on borrowing strategy, procedures, acceptable terms and conditions of loans, their disposition and servicing.

### Monetary Policy
- Monetary policy partially offset the unexpected fiscal stimulus of late 2006; problems with monetary data impeded more effective analysis and limited CBN’s ability to respond promptly.
- Monetary aggregates grew higher than programmed:
  - Reserve money rise in December 2006 attributed to a surge in currency demands associated with political campaigns.
  - Broad money rise in mid-2006 mainly explained by large credits to the private sector, including investment in the oil sector.
- 2007 monetary program targets:
  - Target broad money growth: about 12 percent (below nominal non-oil GDP growth).
  - Aim: achieve Central Bank’s single-digit inflation objective by reversing, in part, the acceleration in broad money.
  - Sterilization efforts to rely on foreign exchange sales and other monetary policy instruments.
- Financial sector measures:
  - Continue improving prudential standards and more effective supervision to enhance banking and financial industry soundness.
  - Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) is refining a Financial Sector Strategy 2020 (FSS 2020) to support further development of the Nigerian financial sector and markets.

### Other Structural Reforms
- Strengthened oil-wealth management:
  - Adoption of the oil-price fiscal rule and participation in the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI).
  - Fiscal Responsibility and NEITI Bills enacted into law to institutionalize reforms.
  - Near-term priority: having states pass their respective fiscal responsibility bills.
- Oil savings and transition management:
  - Guidelines introduced for the use of Nigeria’s oil savings and management of the economy through the political transition.
  - Reputable domestic and foreign asset management institutions are involved in managing Nigerian oil savings.
  - Oil-price fiscal rule considered a welcome and transparent budget management tool.
- Political transition:
  - National elections completed in April; inauguration of the new President on May 29, 2007.
  - New President reaffirmed commitment to ongoing economic policies and reforms, improved governance, and fight against corruption.
  - New government seeks continued support from development partners to complement structural reform efforts.

### Conclusion and Requests
- Authorities remain strongly committed to implementing sound macroeconomic and structural reform policies to consolidate gains under the PSI, including macro stability, high sustainable GDP growth for poverty reduction, and progress towards attainment of the MDGs.
- Authorities committed to taking additional measures to address other challenges and risks.
- Authorities welcome the Fund’s engagement, including policy dialogue, advice and TA, and request:
  - Granting of waivers for the missed quantitative and structural assessment criteria.
  - Approval for modification of the end-June 2007 monetary targets.
  - Completion of the third review of performance under the PSI.

* _cr07263 - 1.      The Nigerian authorities express their appreciation to the Fund for continuous*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07263.pdf_
