## _cr07283

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr07283](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07283.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07283.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07283.pdf.json)

---

### Overall assessment
- Bolivia’s macroeconomic statistics "have improved and are broadly adequate for macroeconomic analysis and policy design and monitoring."
- Authorities "have a good track record of implementing technical assistance recommendations" and participate in the GDDS since November 2000 and plan SDDS subscription.
- Key shortcomings that may detract from accurate and timely analysis:
  - Reference year for national accounts: 1990.
  - Excessive use of fixed intermediate consumption/output coefficients (1990 coefficients used widely).
  - CPI and PPI weights "have not been updated during the past 16 years."
  - Indirect estimates of illegal production (e.g., coca leaf transformation) are made in national accounts, but related exports are excluded from BOP statistics.
  - Coverage/exclusion gaps across datasets (national accounts, PPI, GFS, BOP, monetary).

### Prerequisites of quality and institutional assurances (agency highlights)
- National Statistical Institute (NSI)
  - Legal/institutional: DL 14100; Supreme Decree 21855 transferred national accounts to NSI; Article 15 mandatory reporting; Article 21 confidentiality but "no specified sanctions."
  - Resources: permanent NAD staff noted (permanent staff of 17 compiling national accounts with reference year 1990); 20 new contracted staff for modernization; budget for 2005 was "37 percent lower than for 2002."
  - Transparency: major metadata posted on NSI website for various national accounts components; legislation not posted on NSI website though reproduced in publications.
  - User consultation: formal mechanisms need strengthening.
- Ministry of Finance (MOF / UPF / GDA)
  - Legal basis: Law Nº 3351 (LOPE), Law No. 1178 (SAFCO); UPF compiles GFS above-the-line; GDA compiles GFSM 2001-based data for IMF Yearbook.
  - Resources: "commensurate with current needs but additional personnel/financing may be required" for GFSM 2001 migration.
  - Coverage gaps: "consolidated central government operations are not compiled" despite availability of component data.
  - Metadata: GFS metadata available only on IMF’s DSBB and "has not been updated since November 2005."
- Central Bank of Bolivia (CBB)
  - Legal framework: Law 1670/95; CBB publicly recognized as sole BOP compiler since 1938.
  - Resources: human resources for monetary and BOP compilation "adequate" but "insufficient for conducting needed surveys for the BOP"; limited telephone and Internet access cited.
  - Integrity: CBB Code of Conduct and "annual confidentiality agreements" for staff.
  - Pre-release: internal access to data before public release is acknowledged on CBB website and IMF’s DSBB.
- Superintendency of Banks and Financial Entities (SBFE)
  - Legal authority to collect supervisory data; fines for noncompliance "around US$62 per day."
  - Daily/monthly electronic reporting to SBFE; electronic transmission to CBB via encrypted lines.

### Methodological soundness — dataset summaries
- National Accounts
  - Framework: compiled mainly on 1968 SNA with some 1993 SNA features; supply and use tables compiled; institutional sector accounts up to capital account; NPISH "not investigated."
  - Recording basis: "Transactions recorded on an accrual basis; preliminary government estimates on cash basis then adjusted."
  - Major methodological weaknesses:
    - Reference year: 1990.
    - "Excessive use of fixed 1990 coefficients" in supply and use and extrapolations across "more than 60 percent of GDP."
    - Pension funds treatment and FISIM estimation at constant prices need improvement.
- Consumer Price Index (CPI)
  - Current CPI: weights from HBS 1990; 332 items; 15,500 monthly prices collected.
  - New CPI: CHS 2003/2004 to produce a new basket of 508 items; planned adoption of COICOP; planned base year update.
  - Shortcomings: "Weights have not been updated for the past 16 years"; imputation procedures "are not sound"; response rates and sampling errors "are not calculated."
  - Compilation: uses Lowe formula at aggregation; elementary-level imputation and formula issues identified; periodicity/timeliness meet GDDS (index published the first business day after the reference month).
- Producer Price Index (PPI)
  - Scope: manufacturing-only PPI; 35 groups; 125 generic products; 313 establishments; excludes agriculture, mining, energy, water, gas, construction, and services.
  - Weights/source: principal source Annual Economic Survey (1990); weights "have not been updated in 16 years"; basket not fully representative; compiled quarterly and disseminated with a "ten-week lag."
  - Methodology: Laspeyres formula; missing prices imputed; indices preliminary with final data after 2–3 quarters; revisions undocumented.
- Government Finance Statistics (GFS)
  - Methodology: broadly consistent with GFSM 1986; plan to migrate to GFSM 2001 not prepared.
  - Coverage problems:
    - "Consolidated central government data are not compiled" despite availability.
    - Institutional and transaction coverage incomplete for some decentralized units and local governments; only 130 of 329 municipalities report directly (representing 70 percent of total resources); remaining 199 municipalities estimated.
  - Recording basis: "Mostly on a cash basis with some adjustments to accrual."
  - Classification issues: tax refunds not netted; royalties misclassified; lending minus repayments treated as revenue/expense instead of net expense.
  - Dissemination: periodicity/timeliness meet GDDS; metadata only on IMF’s DSBB.
- Monetary Statistics
  - Methodology: broadly follows MFSM; DCS covers CBB and ODCs; SAFIs excluded though they account for "around 6 percent of the ODC’s liabilities included in broad money."
  - Classification/sectorization: some misclassifications historically (SAFIs, other resident sectors).
  - Source data: daily/monthly electronic reporting from ODCs to SBFE; validation procedures in place; automated checks (e.g., interbank positions) exist.
  - Periodicity/timeliness: meet GDDS and SDDS requirements.
- Balance of Payments (BOP)
  - Methodology: broadly follows BPM5.
  - Exclusions/gaps: excludes "unrecorded trade (contraband, shuttle trade, and illegal trade)," some government bonds held by nonresidents, and deposits of nonresidents in the financial sector.
  - Errors and omissions: "an average of 4 percent of GDP during 1995-2005"; specific years with large negatives (e.g., 2002: - US$643 million; 2004: - US$628 million).
  - Source data: CBB data, administrative data from NSI/SBFE/others, surveys; travel and FDI surveys suspended in 2004-05; CBB initiated a Foreign Private Capital (FPC) survey in November 2006.

### Source data, accuracy, and statistical techniques
- General source-data weaknesses:
  - "No comprehensive business directory."
  - Annual manufacturing, FDI, and tourism surveys suspended at times; economic censuses not regular.
  - CPI and PPI weights outdated (not updated during the past 16 years).
  - Overlapping responsibilities and nonintegrated administrative systems (SIGMA, SINCON, DMFAS) complicate GFS.
- National accounts techniques:
  - Excessive reliance on fixed 1990 coefficients; changes in inventories "obtained as residuals"; many imputations based on 1990 technical coefficients.
  - Sampling errors not estimated in some surveys.
- CPI/PPI techniques:
  - CPI: elementary-level arithmetic averaging and Lowe aggregation; recommendation to use geometric mean at elementary level and to include imputed rentals of owner-occupied dwellings.
  - PPI: arithmetic mean at elementary level; recommendation to use geometric mean; basket and weights should be updated and coverage expanded.
- Monetary/BOP validation:
  - Monetary: strong electronic validation and identity checks; revision analyses are conducted and documented (monetary revisions documented systematically).
  - BOP: source data routinely checked but some surveys missing; statistical techniques to estimate services, remittances, and private transfers need improvement.

### Serviceability, dissemination, and accessibility
- GDDS/SDDS compliance:
  - "All assessed areas except PPI and public and publicly guaranteed debt service schedule meet GDDS periodicity and timeliness."
  - GFS, monetary, and BOP datasets meet SDDS periodicity and timeliness requirements.
  - PPI: compiled quarterly and disseminated with a "ten-week lag" — does not meet SDDS monthly timeliness requirement.
- Release calendars and metadata:
  - Advance release calendar disseminated on CBB website; recommendation to "disseminate advance release calendars on all statistical agencies’ websites" (NSI and MOF).
  - Detailed metadata posted on agencies’ websites except GFS metadata (only on IMF’s DSBB).
- Revision practice:
  - Revision policies exist; preliminary and revised data identified in publications; revision cycles and analyses are "not publicized" generally; analyses of revisions documented for monetary statistics but not routinely disseminated for other datasets.
- Accessibility issues:
  - Internet access to data should be improved; user assistance generally provided.
  - Recommendation: publish revision cycles, publish analyses of revisions, publicize pre-release access and ensure simultaneous dissemination.

### SDDS comparison, remaining gaps, and path to subscription
- Bolivia "meets most recommendations for coverage, periodicity, and timeliness" under GDDS; exceptions identified.
- Major issues to address prior to SDDS subscription:
  - Real sector:
    - Employment, unemployment, wages/salaries need quarterly compilation and dissemination within "three months of the reference period."
      - Current situation: public sector employment/wages meet SDDS; private sector compiled "every six months and disseminated with a four-month lag"; unemployment compiled "annually and disseminated with a four-month lag."
    - Producer Price Index (PPI) needs monthly compilation and dissemination within "one month of the reference period."
      - Current situation: PPI compiled quarterly and disseminated with a "ten-week lag."
  - Fiscal sector:
    - "Consolidated central government operations (budgetary, extrabudgetary, and social security operations) are not compiled."
  - Financial and external sectors:
    - "All data categories meet SDDS prescriptions on coverage, periodicity, and timeliness."
- Flexibility options:
  - "Bolivia is entitled to take two flexibility options for SDDS subscription" — for any two prescribed data categories among employment, unemployment, wages/salaries, and PPI, periodicity and/or timeliness may be less than prescribed.
- Conclusion: "Bolivia should be able to meet the remaining requirements for SDDS subscription in the very short term."

### Action plan and recommended priorities (selected)
- Cross-cutting high-priority actions:
  - Improve coordination among public institutions to facilitate information sharing and intersectoral consistency.
  - Ensure statistical agencies have adequate resources to undertake developmental work.
  - Disseminate macroeconomic statistics simultaneously to all users and publicize any prior access.
  - Promote adoption of new Statistics Law and National Statistical Plan.
  - Strengthen data sources across all datasets (surveys, censuses).
- National Accounts selected planned actions (with DQAF codes and timing as in source):
  - 0.1.1: "Give high priority to the approval of the new Statistical Law." — Timing: Short term
  - 0.2.1: "Provide the resources required to establish an adequate data collection program for national accounts." — Timing: Short term
  - 2.2.1: "Give high priority to the ongoing project to update the national accounts’ reference year and implement the 1993SNA, and bring forward the targeted completion date." — Timing: Short term
  - 3.1.1: "Update the establishment /enterprise directory." — Timing: Short term
  - 3.5.1: "Carry out routinely studies of revisions." — Timing: Short term
  - 4.2.3: "Prepare and disseminate bridge table, showing how to reconcile the national accounts with BOP and GFS figures." — Timing: Short term
- CPI planned actions (selected):
  - 0.2.1: "Financing will be needed to improve the quality of the CPI." — Timing: Short term
  - 2.1.1: "Adopt the recommendations of the 1993 SNA and CPI Manual 2004." — Timing: Short term
  - 3.3.2: "Include Imputed Rentals of owner-occupied dwellings in the CPI weights; Use of the geometric mean; Calculate retroactive index series using chain linking." — Timing: Short term
  - 5.1.3: "Disseminate a preannounced schedule with the dates the statistics are to be released." — Timing: Short term
- PPI planned actions (selected):
  - 0.2.1: "Significant resources will be needed to improve the quality of the PPI." — Timing: Short term
  - 2.2.1: "Formulate a general plan for expand industrial activity coverage, compiling updated weights and reference base." — Timing: Short term
  - 4.1.1 / 4.1.2: "Improve the periodicity of the PPI" and "Improve the timeliness of the PPI." — Short term
- GFS planned actions (selected):
  - 0.1.1: "Coordination between the two units of the MOF that share the responsibility of GFS compilation should be improved." — Short term
  - 2.1.1: "Develop a plan to migrate to the GFSM 2001 analytical framework." — Medium term
  - 2.2.1: "(i) Expand the scope of institutions and transactions in the GFS to include decentralized agencies and local governments; (ii) compile local government debt." — Medium term
  - 4.2.3: "Reconcile GFS with the national accounts to ensure consistency." — Short term
  - 5.2.1: "Post detailed GFS detailed metadata and a link to the IMF’s DSBB on the MOF website." — Short term
- Monetary statistics planned actions (selected):
  - 2.2.1: "In coordination with the SPVS, expand the coverage of the ODC survey with the inclusion of SAFIs." — Short term
  - 2.2.1: "Start compiling a monthly OFC survey with accounts of insurance corporations, pension funds, and BDP." — Short term
  - 3.2.1: "Develop a routine that automatically flags substantial changes in the balances of selected accounts." — Medium term
- BOP planned actions (selected):
  - 0.2.1: "Provide additional staff to the BPD to undertake tasks associated with the FPC survey." — Short term
  - 2.2.1: "Develop a methodology to include unrecorded trade and its counterpart transactions in BOP statistics (in consultation with NSI)." — Medium term
  - 3.1.1: "Initiate quarterly FPC surveys in 2007" and "Prepare a comprehensive and up-to-date business register." — Short term
  - 4.2.3: "Prepare and disseminate a table on quarterly reserves assets reconciliation between monetary and BOP statistics in coordination with the SSMF." — Short term
  - 5.1.1: "Initiate the monthly reporting of the reserve template with one-month lag to STA for redissemination; Disseminate monthly series of the reserve template on the CBB website." — Short term

### Users’ survey — key results (Appendix IV)
- Survey logistics:
  - Questionnaires sent: 329; Responses received: 85; Response rate: 26 percent.
  - Group response rates: Media 56 percent; Public sector analysts 37 percent; Banks 31 percent; Universities 12 percent.
- Overall ratings:
  - Average rating for overall quality of official statistics (1 = poor; 5 = excellent): "3.5."
  - On a five-point scale overall dataset average: 3.5.
- Usage and satisfaction:
  - Which statistics used regularly: Prices 73 percent; Monetary 81 percent; National accounts 65 percent; GFS 62 percent; BOP 54 percent.
  - Satisfaction with timeliness (average) 54 percent; specific dissatisfaction with national accounts timeliness (38 percent satisfied).
  - Accessibility: "Overall accessibility to official statistics: 78 percent positive."
  - Metadata accessibility: "Satisfaction with accessibility to metadata: 40 percent satisfied"; only "30 percent felt that available metadata was sufficiently clear or detailed enough."
- Users’ written priorities included: update base years for national accounts and prices, expand regional breakdown (GDP by region), introduce a producer price index, increase periodicity of labor statistics, and produce forward-looking indicators.

### Key numeric/factual figures preserved from the source
- CPI: "some 15,500 monthly prices from 332 items" (current series); new CPI will collect "some 31,700 monthly prices from 508 items."
- PPI: "quarterly prices of 125 generic products... direct interviews of 313 establishments"; PPI basket not fully representative; PPI base year: "1990"; "weights have not been updated in 16 years"; PPI compiled quarterly and "disseminated with a ten-week lag"; quarterly PPI published consistently since "December 1985."
- National accounts: reference year "1990"; value added from oil and gas activity represented "6.3 percent of GDP at current prices" in 2005.
- Monetary: SAFIs account for "around 6 percent of the ODC’s liabilities included in broad money."
- GFS municipal coverage: data reported for "130 municipalities" of "329" total, representing "70 percent of the total resources."
- SBFE fines: "around US$62 per day" for delays/inaccurate reporting.
- BOP errors and omissions: "an average of 4 percent of GDP during 1995-2005"; specific years—2002: "- US$643 million"; 2004: "- US$628 million".
- Revision schedules for national accounts: preliminary posted "four months after the end of the reference year"; semi-definitive ready with a lag of "11 months" but disseminated with a lag of "16 months"; definitive ready with a lag of "24 months" but disseminated with a lag of "28 months."
- CPI publication: "index published the first business day after the reference month."
- PPI publication calendar: quarterly publication months "May, August, November, and February."
- FPC survey: initiated "November 2006"; travel survey expected to resume in "2007."
- Metadata: GFS metadata "has not been updated since November 2005"; MOF included hyperlink to IMF’s DSBB in "March 2007."
- NSI budget: "NSI’s budget for 2005 was 37 percent lower than for 2002."
- Monetary and internet access constraints: CBB staff Internet access "restricted to two hours per day"; telephone "three minutes per external call" in some descriptions.

*Source: Data Quality Assessment Framework, July 2003 — Summary Results (IMF mission assessment).*

### 1.     Data Quality Assessment Framework July 2003—Summary Results.............................10

### Data Quality Assessment Framework July 2003—Summary Results

### Overall assessment
- Bolivia’s macroeconomic statistics have improved and are broadly adequate for macroeconomic analysis and policy design and monitoring.
- Shortcomings identified that may detract from accurate and timely analysis and policy formulation.
- Authorities have a good track record of implementing technical assistance recommendations and are committed to internationally accepted standards, participating in the GDDS and planning subscription to the SDDS.
- Resources are generally commensurate with current statistical services but insufficient to implement needed improvements across most datasets.
- Methodologies broadly sound for the CPI, monetary, and BOP statistics; significant shortcomings remain for national accounts, PPI, and GFS.
- Key data source and methodological shortfalls:
  - Reference year for national accounts: 1990.
  - Excessive use of fixed intermediate consumption/output coefficients.
  - CPI and PPI weights have not been updated during the past 16 years.
  - Indirect estimates of illegal production (e.g., coca leaf transformation) are made, but related exports are excluded from BOP statistics.
  - Exclusions and coverage gaps across datasets (see Methodological soundness and Source data).

### Prerequisites of quality and assurances of integrity (by agency)
- National Statistical Institute (NSI):
  - Legal/institutional environment supports national accounts and price statistics; mandatory reporting and confidentiality established but no sanctions specified for noncompliance.
  - Resources need strengthening for a regular program of economic surveys (national accounts) and to improve the PPI.
  - Formal mechanisms to consult data users need strengthening.
  - Terms and conditions under which statistics are produced are not available on the NSI website; relevant legal precepts reproduced in publications.
  - Internal government access to data before public release is disseminated on the IMF’s DSBB.
- Ministry of Finance (MOF):
  - Legal/institutional environment supports GFS compilation and dissemination.
  - Data sharing and coordination broadly adequate; centralization of GFS compilation/dissemination could improve quality.
  - Additional personnel and financing required for developmental work, including adoption of GFSM 2001.
  - Regular procedures to consult with data users and to monitor quality need establishment.
  - Terms and conditions for GFS are publicly specified in relevant laws.
- Central Bank of Bolivia (CBB):
  - Legal framework supports mandatory reporting and confidentiality.
  - Inter-agency coordination effective; data sharing arrangements with NSI for timely survey data for BOP need improvement.
  - Human resources adequate for current monetary and BOP compilation but insufficient for conducting needed surveys for the BOP.
  - No formal mechanisms to monitor relevance or identify emerging data requirements.
  - Terms and conditions for statistics compilation and dissemination are public; internal pre-release access is disseminated on the CBB website and IMF’s DSBB.
  - CBB Code of Conduct and annual confidentiality agreements for staff reinforce integrity.
- Superintendency of Banks and Financial Entities (SBFE):
  - Legal authority to collect data from supervised financial intermediaries; laws include penalties for delays or inaccurate reporting.
  - Primary function is supervisory data collection; demonstrates willingness to meet CBB data needs.
  - Technical criteria applied in data collection; Ethics Code known to staff.

### Methodological soundness and scope
- Methodologies broadly follow international standards for CPI, monetary, and BOP statistics.
- Shortcomings and scope gaps:
  - National accounts: institutional sector accounts compiled only up to the capital account; NPISH not investigated.
  - PPI: important activities missing, including agriculture, mining, energy, water, gas, and services; basket not fully representative of current national output.
  - GFS: exclude data from some decentralized agencies and local governments; consolidated central government operations are not compiled despite availability of component data.
  - Monetary statistics: exclude Investment Funds Management Societies liabilities that should be included in broad money.
  - BOP: excludes unrecorded trade and some other transactions with nonresidents; some exports excluded (e.g., related to coca processing).
  - Classification and sectorization systems need improvement, notably in GFS (royalties, commissions, tax returns, social assistance benefits, lending minus repayments).
  - Recording practices: national accounts, prices, and monetary statistics generally follow international best practices; BOP and GFS recording could be improved, e.g., by fully adopting accrual accounting.
- Adoption of newer statistical manuals has been slower for national accounts, PPI, and GFS.

### Source data, accuracy, and statistical techniques
- Monetary statistics: ample source data and high accuracy/reliability.
- CPI: source data reasonably available.
- National accounts, PPI, GFS, BOP: source data insufficiently developed; significant room for improvement.
- Specific source data weaknesses:
  - No comprehensive business directory.
  - Annual manufacturing, foreign direct investment, and tourism surveys suspended.
  - Economic censuses not conducted regularly.
  - PPI basket and weights outdated; CPI and PPI weights not updated during the past 16 years; new products not introduced in CPI.
  - Overlapping responsibilities in GFS source data collection.
  - Coverage of certain services and financial transactions in the BOP needs expansion.
- Assessment and validation of source data: sound for GFS, monetary, and BOP; need strengthening for national accounts and price indices.
- Statistical techniques: need improvement across most datasets; excessive use of fixed coefficients in national accounts.
- Revision practices: procedures for validating intermediate and final data are sound; analyses of revisions are conducted, but only analyses of revisions to monetary statistics are documented systematically.

### Serviceability, dissemination, and accessibility
- Serviceability broadly satisfactory; user survey confirms general satisfaction.
- Periodicity and timeliness:
  - All assessed areas except PPI and public and publicly guaranteed debt service schedule meet GDDS periodicity and timeliness.
  - GFS, monetary, and BOP datasets meet SDDS periodicity and timeliness requirements.
- Consistency:
  - Statistics broadly consistent within datasets and reconcilable over a reasonable period.
  - Consistency between national accounts and other datasets needs improvement.
- Revision policies and practices: well established for most datasets; preliminary and revised data identified in publications, but revision cycles and analyses are not publicized.
- Accessibility improvements recommended:
  - Disseminate advance release calendars on all statistical agencies’ websites (currently only on the CBB website).
  - Improve Internet access to data.
  - Detailed metadata are posted on agencies’ websites and in publications, except GFS metadata which are only available on the IMF’s DSBB.
  - All data-producing agencies provide effective assistance to users.
- Advance release calendars for all data categories are disseminated at: http://www.bcb.gov.bo/sitio/estadisticast.php?n2=5&n3=9&n4

### SDDS comparison, remaining gaps, and path to subscription
- Bolivia participates in the GDDS since November 2000 and meets most recommendations for coverage, periodicity, and timeliness; exceptions identified.
- Major issues to address prior to SDDS subscription:
  - Real sector:
    - Employment, unemployment, and wages/salaries need quarterly compilation and dissemination within three months of the reference period.
      - Current situation: public sector employment and wages/salaries meet SDDS; private sector compiled every six months and disseminated with a four-month lag; unemployment compiled annually and disseminated with a four-month lag.
    - Producer Price Index (PPI) needs monthly compilation and dissemination within one month of the reference period.
      - Current situation: PPI compiled quarterly and disseminated with a ten-week lag.
  - Fiscal sector:
    - Consolidated central government operations (budgetary, extrabudgetary, and social security operations) are not compiled, despite availability of component subsector data.
    - Consolidated operations of general government and nonfinancial public sector are compiled and disseminated.
  - Financial and external sectors:
    - All data categories meet SDDS prescriptions on coverage, periodicity, and timeliness.
- Flexibility for subscription:
  - Bolivia is entitled to take two flexibility options for SDDS subscription, meaning for any two prescribed data categories among employment, unemployment, wages/salaries, and PPI, periodicity and/or timeliness may be less than prescribed.
- Conclusion: Bolivia should be able to meet the remaining requirements for SDDS subscription in the very short term.

*Source: Data Quality Assessment Framework, July 2003 — Summary Results (IMF mission assessment).*

### 13.      Assessment of the quality of six macroeconomic datasets—national accounts,

### 13. Assessment of the quality of six macroeconomic datasets—national accounts, consumer price index, producer price index, government finance, monetary, and balance of payments statistics

### Overview of the assessment framework and scope
- Assessments were conducted using the July 2003 vintage of the DQAF.
- Results are presented at the level of DQAF elements using a four-point rating scale (Table 1): O = Practice Observed; LO = Practice Largely Observed; LNO = Practice Largely Not Observed; NO = Practice Not Observed; NA = Not Applicable.
- Dimensions assessed: 0. Prerequisites of data quality; 1. Assurances of integrity; 2. Methodological soundness; 3. Accuracy and reliability; 4. Serviceability; 5. Accessibility.
- For each dataset, Dimensions “2” to “5” (methodological soundness, accuracy and reliability, serviceability, accessibility) are shown in Tables 3a–f (not reproduced here).

### Users’ survey of data quality
- Questionnaires were sent to 329 targeted users; 85 responses were received, including main users of official statistics.
- On a five point scale (1 = poor and 5 = excellent), the average rating for the overall quality of official statistics for all sectors was 3.5.
- Survey findings:
  - Majority satisfied with methodological soundness.
  - Users believed Bolivia’s statistics were comparable to neighboring countries’ statistics.
  - Users satisfied with level of coverage and detail and with periodicity.
  - General dissatisfaction expressed with accessibility to metadata and timeliness, particularly of national accounts.
  - Suggested user requests: expand level of detail (for example, GDP by region), introduction of a producer price index, increased periodicity of labor statistics, and forward-looking indicators of economic activity.
- A more detailed analysis and tabulated results are included in Appendix IV of the accompanying document Detailed Assessments Using the Data Quality Assessment Framework (DQAF).

### Summary findings from Table 1 (select element-level ratings, DQAF July 2003)
- Dimension 0. Prerequisites of quality
  - 0.1 Legal and institutional environment: National Accounts LO; Consumer Price Index O; Producer Price Index O; Government Finance Statistics LO; Monetary Statistics O; Balance of Payments Statistics LO.
  - 0.2 Resources: National Accounts LO; CPI LO; PPI LNO; GFS LO; Monetary LO; BOP LO.
  - 0.3 Relevance and 0.4 Other quality management: all datasets O.
- Dimension 1. Assurances of integrity
  - 1.1 Professionalism: all datasets O.
  - 1.2 Transparency: National Accounts LO; CPI LO; PPI O; GFS LO; Monetary O; BOP O.
  - 1.3 Ethical standards: all datasets O.
- Dimension 2. Methodological soundness (select elements)
  - 2.1 Concepts and definitions: National Accounts LO; CPI LO; PPI LO; GFS LO; Monetary O; BOP O.
  - 2.2 Scope: National Accounts LO; CPI O; PPI LNO; GFS LO; Monetary LO; BOP LO.
  - 2.3 Classification/sectorization: National Accounts LO; CPI LO; PPI LO; GFS LNO; Monetary LO; BOP LO.
  - 2.4 Basis for recording: National Accounts O; CPI O; PPI O; GFS LO; Monetary O; BOP LO.
- Dimension 3. Accuracy and reliability (select elements)
  - 3.1 Source data: National Accounts LNO; CPI O; PPI LNO; GFS LO; Monetary O; BOP LO.
  - 3.2 Assessment of source data: National Accounts LO; CPI LO; PPI LO; GFS O; Monetary O; BOP O.
  - 3.3 Statistical techniques: National Accounts LNO; CPI LNO; PPI LNO; GFS O; Monetary O; BOP LO.
  - 3.4 Assessment and validation of intermediate data and outputs: all datasets O.
  - 3.5 Revision studies: National Accounts LO; CPI LO; PPI LO; GFS LO; Monetary O; BOP LO.
- Dimension 4. Serviceability
  - 4.1 Periodicity and timeliness: National Accounts O; CPI O; PPI LNO; GFS O; Monetary O; BOP O.
  - 4.2 Consistency: National Accounts LO; CPI O; PPI O; GFS LO; Monetary O; BOP LO.
  - 4.3 Revision policy and practice: all datasets LO.
- Dimension 5. Accessibility
  - 5.1 Data accessibility: National Accounts LO; CPI LO; PPI LO; GFS LO; Monetary LO; BOP O.
  - 5.2 Metadata accessibility: National Accounts O; CPI O; PPI O; GFS LO; Monetary O; BOP O.
  - 5.3 Assistance to users: all datasets O.

### Institution-level assessment highlights (Dimensions 0 and 1)
- National Statistical Institute (NSI)
  - Legal/institutional: Provisions in DL 14100, November 5, 1976 (created the National Statistical Information System); Supreme Decree 21855, January 14, 1988, transferred compilation of national accounts from CBB to NSI; Article 15 of DL 14100 establishes mandatory data reporting; Article 21 establishes confidentiality but no specified sanctions for noncompliance; NSI has signed special agreements to facilitate data sharing.
  - Resources: allocated resources to modernize national accounts but additional resources required; staff/computing/financing adequate for CPI but inadequate for PPI; staff performance reviewed every six months.
  - Relevance: no formal mechanisms to consult data users; Institute strives to adopt best international practices.
  - Other quality management: Institutional Strategic Plan for 2005-2009 aims to obtain the ISO 9000:2000 quality certification for NSI’s main products.
  - Professionalism: NSI’s Statistical Principle of Integrity; training and technical assistance provided; National Accounts Directorate monitors media coverage and NSI entitled to comment on misinterpretations.
  - Transparency: legislation not available on NSI website though legal precepts reproduced in publications; major changes announced in advance (example: introduction of base year 1990); metadata for quarterly GDP, institutional sector accounts, and others are disseminated on the website; advance release calendar provided; internal government access to data before release is disclosed on the IMF’s DSBB but not on NSI website; adequate documentation available for price indices.
  - Ethical standards: Law No. 2027 on Public Servants and NSI’s Staff Regulation establish sanctions for improper behavior.
- Ministry of Finance (MOF)
  - Legal/institutional: Responsibility for GFS, budget, accounting data assigned by Law Nº 3351 of March 9, 2006 (LOPE) and Law No. 1178 of July 20, 1990 (SAFCO); Fiscal Programming Unit (UPF) in MOF compiles GFS, shared with General Directorate of Accounting (GDA); UPF compiles above-the-line data, CBB compiles below-the-line data; GDA compiles GFS following GFSM 2001 for IMF GFS Yearbook; laws require public entities to submit budgetary and financial statements and specify penalties for noncompliance.
  - Resources: commensurate with current needs but additional personnel/financing may be required for expanded compilation tasks and implementation of GFSM 2001 analytical framework.
  - Relevance: regular procedures to consult with data users and to monitor quality need to be established.
  - Other quality management: processes exist to focus on and monitor quality in planning the statistical program.
  - Professionalism: no specific laws explicitly addressing professional independence or prohibiting political interference, but GFS compiled on an impartial basis; culture of professionalism supported by Law No. 2027 and internal provisions; training and analytical activities encouraged; no evidence of political interference in source/method choices; MOF empowered to respond to misinterpretation/misuse.
  - Transparency: legislation establishes public access to fiscal data; laws available to the public; fiscal data products disseminated through MOF website and Statistical Bulletin but do not clearly identify compiling agencies and data sources; advance notice is not given to the public about major methodological changes.
  - Ethical standards: staff behavior guided by civil service law and administrative procedures.
- Central Bank of Bolivia (CBB)
  - Legal/institutional: Law 1670/95 (Law of the Central Bank of Bolivia) includes obligations of the Superintendency of Banks and Financial Entities (SBFE) to provide information to CBB (art. 40); mandatory reporting to CBB from banks and financial intermediaries (art. 40); CBB’s responsibility for recording public and private sector external debt (art. 21); confidentiality of received information (art. 80); provisions governing publication of economic and financial data (art. 43). Institutional arrangements in place for source data transmission from SBFE (monetary) and NSI (balance of payments), though some data sharing with NSI has not provided effective and timely survey data. Law 1670/95 does not explicitly state CBB is responsible for compiling/disseminating balance of payments, but CBB is publicly recognized as sole institution with these responsibilities and has disseminated balance of payments statistics since 1938.
  - Resources: human resources adequate for monetary and balance of payments compilation but insufficient for balance of payments surveys; technical resources and data processing equipment adequate; compilers have limited telephone and Internet access; a recent presidential decree reducing public service salaries may negatively affect staffing.
  - Relevance: no formal mechanisms to consult users, but user feedback is taken into account; CBB participates in international/regional statistical meetings.
  - Other quality management: authorities requested IMF technical assistance in monetary statistics and flow of funds; compilation/dissemination of quarterly balance of payments, IIP, private sector debt data, and monthly reserves template data, and efforts to subscribe to the SDDS indicate commitment to improvement.
  - Professionalism: statistics compiled and disseminated following strict technical criteria with professional independence; CBB provides comments/clarifications via Institutional Communications Department when statistics are misinterpreted.
  - Transparency: terms and conditions for compilation/dissemination are widely available; internal government access to data before release is acknowledged on the CBB website and IMF’s DSBB; changes in methodology and source data described in semiannual External Sector Bulletin; usually advance notice is given for major BOP changes.
  - Ethical standards: CBB Code of Conduct establishes ethical principles; Internal Staff Regulation and Law 2027/99 apply; pursuant to art. 80 of Law 1670/95, CBB staff must sign annual confidentiality agreements.

*Source: DQAF-based assessment (July 2003 vintage) and institution-specific assessments as presented in the IMF document.*

### 0. Prerequisites of quality

### 0. Prerequisites of quality

### 1. Assurances of integrity — legal, institutional, and operational arrangements
- Legal and institutional environment
  - Law 1488/93 (Law of Banks and Financial Institutions) authorizes the SBFE to request from all financial intermediaries information on their financial situation and operations (art. 93).
  - Article 99 of Law 1488/93 contemplates penalties for delays or inaccurate reporting, with fines of around US$62 per day for noncompliance.
  - Articles 86 and 89 of law 1488/95 protect confidentiality of reported data.
  - Other depository corporations (ODCs) transmit daily to the SBFE, in electronic format, their balance sheets of the previous day, plus data on interest rates.
  - ODCs transmit monthly balance sheets and sectorized accounts for monetary statistics purposes two days after the end of the reference month.
  - Institutional arrangements exist for electronic data transmission from the SBFE to the CBB via dedicated encrypted lines.
- Resources and staffing
  - Human, technical, and financial resources are described as adequate.
  - SBFE salaries historically higher than in the rest of the public sector and broadly competitive with the private sector, contributing to low staff turnover.
  - A recent presidential decree reducing public service salaries and flattening the salary scale may negatively affect staffing; several senior SBFE staff have recently left for the private sector.
- Relevance and cooperation
  - SBFE’s main function is to collect data for supervisory purposes but has accommodated CBB’s emerging data needs for monetary statistics through additional information requests and ad-hoc chart-of-accounts changes.
  - SBFE staff regularly attend meetings and international courses offered by other supervisory agencies and central banks.
- Professionalism, transparency, and ethics
  - SBFE is a technical institution with administrative and financial autonomy; technical criteria alone guide data compilers and analysts.
  - Legal terms for collecting supervisory data are specified in laws available to the public; government officials outside SBFE have no access until public release.
  - Public information (e.g., ODC balance sheets) is available on the SBFE website and in the monthly Boletín Informativo; a weekly letter with analytical description of the financial sector is published.
  - SBFE staff receive an Ethics Code covering conduct, truthfulness, responsibility, transparency, integrity, and confidentiality.

### National Accounts — Methodological soundness, accuracy, serviceability, accessibility
- Concepts and scope
  - Compiled following the 1968 SNA with some important features of the 1993 SNA incorporated.
  - Accounts cover annual and quarterly GDP by expenditure and production approaches at current and constant 1990 prices; annual GDP by income approach at current prices; annual supply and use; seasonally adjusted quarterly GDP.
  - Indirect estimates include illegal production linked to transformation of the coca leaf, some informal industrial and domestic trade activities, and shuttle trade.
  - Institutional sector accounts from production up to the capital account are included.
- Classification and recording
  - National classifications based on ISIC Rev. 3 (except agriculture) and CPC; COICOP applied to classify households' consumption; COFOG not applied.
  - Transactions recorded on an accrual basis; preliminary government estimates registered on cash basis then adjusted to accrual; intra-corporation subsidiary transactions recorded on a gross basis.
- Source data and assessment
  - Availability of economic statistics has deteriorated due to suspension of various important surveys.
  - Price and volume indices based on the quarterly manufacturing survey lost coverage due to an outdated 1990 fixed basket.
  - Economic and household surveys were recently conducted to update the base year for national accounts and the CPI.
  - Sampling errors are not estimated in some surveys; source data principally assessed in the context of revisions.
- Statistical techniques and validation
  - Sound techniques employed to adjust for scarce data sources, but the 1990 base year is outdated.
  - Excessive use of fixed 1990 coefficients in supply and use tables; changes in inventories obtained as residuals.
  - Treatment of pension funds and techniques to estimate FISIM at constant prices could be improved.
  - Intermediate data and outputs are assessed and validated against available information; revision analyses are carried out and documented, though revision studies are ad-hoc.
- Periodicity, timeliness, consistency, and revisions
  - Preliminary GDP data meet GDDS recommendations on periodicity and timeliness, but users urgently need improved timeliness.
  - Internal and intertemporal consistency of GDP verified via Supply and Use tables; quarterly GDP consistent with annual estimates.
  - Consistency with BOP and GFS not verified regularly and may be affected by lack of illegal trade estimates in BOP.
  - Revisions follow a regular, predetermined schedule but the schedule is not publicized; preliminary data clearly identified but not revised data; documentation on revisions exists (e.g., construction activity) but is not disseminated.
- Accessibility and metadata
  - National accounts disseminated on NSI website and publications with tables, charts, and analysis.
  - Advance release calendar posted on CBB website.
  - A government policy advisory committee receives data that may or may not have been publicly disseminated; practice does not affect pre-scheduled release.
  - Metadata on various national accounts components posted on the NSI website.
  - Specific contact points provided on NSI website; virtual library and catalog available; photocopies and printouts available on request; public may subscribe to receive information by e-mail.

### Consumer Price Index (CPI) — Methodological soundness, accuracy, serviceability, accessibility
- Concepts, scope, and classification
  - CPI follows the 1968 SNA household consumption concept using detailed expenditure data from the 1990 Household Budget Survey (HBS); new HBS to update CPI weights follows the 1993 SNA.
  - CPI calculated at national level and for four largest cities: La Paz, Santa Cruz, Cochabamba, and El Alto; weights representative only of urban households; new CPI will include six additional cities.
  - Goods and services classified using an adaptation of the 1968 SNA classification; new CPI basket products will be classified using COICOP.
- Basis for recording and source data
  - Prices are market prices paid by households inclusive of all taxes on goods and services.
  - 1990 HBS used for CPI weights. Some 15,500 monthly prices from 332 items are collected via direct interviews.
  - The 2003/2004 HBS will be used for new CPI weights; some 31,700 monthly prices from 508 items will be collected.
- Assessment, techniques, and weaknesses
  - Data checked for logical consistency using manual and automated validation, including checks for extreme values.
  - The share of consumption expenditure not covered by the index is 10 percent.
  - Response rates, editing rates, and sampling errors are not calculated.
  - CPI uses the Lowe formula.
  - Procedures for imputation are not sound; weights have not been updated for the past 16 years; current weight and price reference periods are not the same.
  - CPI is validated against primary price observations and aggregations.
  - Analyses of revisions are conducted but revision studies are not performed.
- Periodicity, timeliness, and accessibility
  - Periodicity and timeliness meet GDDS recommendations; index published the first business day after the reference month.
  - Some advance releases (three per month) at shorter intervals for internal use.
  - CPI disseminated via press releases and posted on NSI website with detailed tables covering country and four main cities.
  - Advance release calendar disseminated on CBB website.
  - Metadata on concepts, methodology, and data sources available on NSI website.
  - NSI provides contact information and assistance; data available by subscription or upon request.

### Producer Price Index (PPI) — Methodological soundness, accuracy, serviceability, accessibility
- Concepts, scope, and classification
  - PPI weights of manufacturing goods based on value of gross output, excluding intermediate input, broadly conforming to 1968 SNA and the PPI Manual; survey to update PPI weights conducted in 2005 and follows the 1993 SNA.
  - PPI includes prices for 35 groups of manufacturing industries; share of goods output by economic activity not covered is 15 percent.
  - Geographic coverage nationwide excluding Pando; PPI excludes agriculture, forestry, mining and quarrying, power, water, gas, construction, and commercial and other services.
  - ISIC rev. 2 used for classifying the manufacturing industry PPI (IPPIM); disaggregated by group of activity (four digits), grouping (three digits), and industrial division (two digits).
- Source data and assessment
  - Principal source for PPI baskets was the Annual Economic Survey (1990).
  - Coverage consists of groups that generate 85 percent of value added of manufacturing industry and, within each group, products representing more than 70 percent of gross value of output.
  - Quarterly prices of 125 generic products are collected through direct interviews of 313 establishments.
  - PPI basket not fully representative of current national output; source data not timely.
  - PPI subject to validation at individual price and aggregation levels; intermediate results validated against CPI.
  - Response rates to price surveys and sampling errors are not calculated.
- Techniques, revisions, and dissemination
  - Missing prices are imputed; PPI uses the Laspeyres formula.
  - Weights have not been updated in 16 years.
  - PPI validated at multiple aggregation levels; analysis of revisions conducted but revision studies not performed.
  - Periodicity and timeliness do not meet GDDS recommendations: compiled quarterly and disseminated 10 weeks after the end of the reference quarter.
  - Quarterly PPI published consistently since December 1985; chained index between old and new series available.
  - Newly released PPI data are preliminary and final data published after 2-3 quarters; revisions do not follow a regular schedule; preliminary data clearly identified but not revised data; studies and analyses of revisions are not made public.
  - PPI disseminated quarterly through Short-term Economic Indicators and annually in the Statistical Yearbook; data available via Customer Service Unit (CSU) and NSI Central Library.
  - Metadata available in NSI publication Indice de Precios, Productor Industrial Manufacturero Sistema de Metadatos posted on NSI website.
  - Contact point on NSI website; CSU provides assistance and photocopies/printouts upon request.

### Government Finance Statistics (GFS) — Methodological soundness, accuracy, serviceability, accessibility
- Methodology, scope, and classification
  - Concepts and definitions broadly consistent with GFSM 1986; authorities have not prepared a plan to migrate to GFSM 2001.
  - Institutional and transaction coverage incomplete because detailed data of some decentralized units and some local governments are not collected.
  - Departures from GFSM 1986 include: (1) consolidated central government data are not compiled even though information is available; (2) misclassification of royalties, commissions for interest, tax returns, social assistance benefits, and lending minus repayment; (3) some data not disaggregated; (4) classification of tax revenues, financing, and debt not strictly following international recommendations.
  - Basis for recording mostly on a cash basis with some adjustments to accrual; flows valued at market prices and financial stocks at nominal or face value; grossing/netting procedures not fully consistent with international standards.
- Source data and assessment
  - Source systems: Integrated System of Management and Administrative Modernization; integrated system of accounting; UPF system; External Debt Management and Financial Analysis System; independent systems of some public units.
  - These systems are not fully integrated, leading to undue burden in data collection and compilation; institutional coverage incomplete.
  - Data sources are timely and reasonably approximate recommended definitions, scope, classifications, valuations, and basis of recording.
  - Assessment of source data performed routinely by visiting data producing units, cross-checking, trend analysis, and queries to producing units.
- Techniques, validation, and revisions
  - Techniques for derivation, aggregation, valuation, currency conversion, preparation of bridge tables, and estimation are sound.
  - Final data validated against budgetary and accounting sources.
  - Revision studies and analyses are conducted but not documented.
- Periodicity, timeliness, consistency, and accessibility
  - Periodicity and timeliness meet GDDS recommendations.
  - Data dissemination lags:
    - Consolidated nonfinancial public sector and consolidated general government disseminated monthly with a lag of six weeks.
    - Foreign public debt data disseminated monthly with a lag of one month.
    - Domestic public debt data disseminated weekly with a lag of two days.
  - Fiscal data consistent within the dataset and reconcilable over a reasonable period; consistency with monetary and balance of payments statistics assessed regularly.
  - Consistency between GFS and national accounts is not verified.
  - Revision schedule predetermined and reasonably stable but not publicized; first published annual GFS data are preliminary with final data published after revisions; data tables do not include explanatory notes for revisions; revision studies and analyses not made public.
  - Accessibility could be improved in the Statistical Bulletin and MOF website to facilitate interpretation and international comparisons.
  - GFS disseminated according to a preannounced schedule available on CBB website and the IMF’s DSBB; disseminated on MOF and CBB websites simultaneously.
  - Metadata only available on the IMF’s DSBB and has not been updated since November 2005.
  - Assistance provided via a contact e-mail address posted in MOF publications and website; documents and services widely available.

*Source: _cr07283 - 0. Prerequisites of quality*

### 2. Methodological soundness

### 2. Methodological soundness

### Monetary statistics — Concepts, scope, classification, and recording
- Concepts and definitions follow the recommendations of the MFSM.
- Scope: The depository corporations survey (DCS) covers the CBB, all commercial banks, credit unions, savings and loans associations, and the private financial funds. The accounts of banks in liquidation are included.
- Exclusions/coverage gap: The DCS does not cover seven Investment Funds Management Societies (SAFIs), which issue debit cards to their clients and account for around 6 percent of the ODC’s liabilities included in broad money.
- Classification/sectorization broadly follows the MFSM, with some exceptions:
  - ODC data do not distinguish between other nonfinancial corporations and other resident sectors.
  - Transactions with SAFIs are classified as transactions with OFCs rather than with ODCs.
  - Problems exist in classification and application of residency criterion by some ODCs.
- Basis for recording: Monetary statistics are produced on an accrual basis, consistent with the MFSM. Financial instruments are valued at market prices or amortized cost. Accounts in foreign currency are converted into national currency using the market exchange rate.

### Monetary statistics — Source data, assessment, and statistical techniques
- Source data: The DC survey is based on the consolidated balance sheets of the CBB and ODCs. The SBFE provides the CBB with daily balance sheets of the ODCs and a monthly report with a detailed sectorization of the accounts.
- Assessment of source data: The Economic Policy Advisory Office (APEC) has electronic access to the accounting records of the CBB. Data for the ODCs are validated by the SBFE and electronically processed by the APEC.
- Statistical techniques: Sound statistical techniques are used. The DCS is based strictly on the balance sheets of the CBB and the ODCs, and the supplementary monthly report with more detailed sectorization of the accounts of the ODCs.
- Assessment and validation of intermediate data and statistical output:
  - Monetary data are validated through the accounting identity: net foreign assets plus net domestic assets equal broad money.
  - Interbank positions are automatically validated by the SBEF.
  - Credit to the public sector is compared with debtor’s data.
- Revision studies: Analyses and studies of revisions are conducted and documented. The results are used to improve the statistical process.

### Monetary statistics — Periodicity, consistency, revision policy, and accessibility
- Periodicity and timeliness meet GDDS recommendations and SDDS requirements.
- Consistency: Monetary data are disseminated in consistent historical series. Discrepancies arise in aggregated accounts of the ODCs because the SAFIs report claims on commercial banks for deposit certificates, which are reported as liabilities to the private sector (deposits) by commercial banks. Monetary data are consistent with balance of payments and government finance data.
- Revision policy and practice:
  - The CBB does not have a regular revision schedule because data are disseminated as final and revisions are infrequent.
  - Revision studies are not disseminated, but revisions resulting from changes in methodology are documented in footnotes to the tables.
  - Preliminary data are clearly identified.
- Data accessibility:
  - Data are presented in an aggregated form with methodological notes.
  - The CBB publishes an advance release calendar.
  - Data are posted on the CBB website and published in the CBB Monthly Bulletin.
  - A government policy advisory committee is provided with data that may or may not have been disseminated to the public; this practice does not affect the pre-scheduled release.
- Metadata accessibility: Bolivia has posted its monetary metadata on the IMF’s DSBB since November 2000. The CBB website contains metadata and provides a hyperlink to the IMF’s DSBB.
- Assistance to users: Information on the contact person for monetary statistics is available on the CBB website and also on the IMF’s DSBB. There is a catalog with CBB’s publications, documents, and other services to users.

---

### 2. Methodological soundness — Balance of Payments statistics

### Concepts, scope, classification, and recording
- Concepts and definitions broadly follow the BPM5 guidelines. Resident units are defined in conformity with BPM5.
- Scope is broadly consistent with BPM5 but excludes:
  1. unrecorded trade (contraband, shuttle trade, and illegal trade);
  2. some government bonds issued locally and held by nonresidents; and
  3. deposits of nonresidents in the financial sector.
- Classification/sectorization are broadly in line with BPM5 guidelines, but:
  - More detailed breakdown is needed for the classification of several services.
  - Instrument misclassifications exist (e.g., trade credits are included in loans).
  - Capital transfers are included in current transfers.
  - Most institutional units are attributed to the relevant sector according to BPM5.
- Basis for recording:
  - In general, the principle of market valuation is used.
  - Flows derived from stocks of nonbank deposits abroad (assets) are not adjusted for exchange rate changes.
  - Recording is mostly on an accrual basis in accordance with BPM5, but:
    - Interest on public sector external debt is recorded on a due-for-payment basis.
    - Some dividends are recorded when paid rather than when declared payable.

### Source data, assessment, and statistical techniques
- Source data are broadly sufficient to compile statistics. Data sources include:
  1. CBB data;
  2. administrative data from the NSI, the SBFE, and other government entities;
  3. surveys;
  4. direct reporting mainly by nonfinancial entities; and
  5. data from foreign/international institutions.
- Gaps: Source data for certain services and financial transactions could be improved. Survey data for travel and foreign direct investment from the NSI have not been available since 2004-05, respectively. The CBB initiated a Foreign Private Capital (FPC) survey in November 2006. The travel survey is expected to be resumed in 2007.
- Assessment of source data: Source data are routinely checked and analyzed to guide the statistical process.
- Statistical techniques: Techniques are used (some may need improvement) mainly to adjust trade data, estimate direct investment flows/stocks, and overcome insufficient coverage of services, workers’ remittances, and private transfers. The CBB does not estimate unrecorded trade, including illegal activities.
- Assessment and validation of intermediate data and statistical output: Statistical discrepancies are monitored. Data are validated against available administrative data (including balance sheets) and other datasets.
- Revision studies: Analysis of revisions informs statistical processes but they are not regularly documented.

### Periodicity, consistency, revision policy, and accessibility
- Periodicity and timeliness of balance of payments data meet GDDS recommendations and SDDS requirements.
- Consistency:
  - Balance of payments data are broadly consistent internally and over time.
  - Errors and omissions are large in some years (an average of 4 percent of GDP during 1995-2005).
  - Balance of payments and IIP data are reconciled quarterly.
  - Data are largely consistent and/or reconcilable with merchandise trade, monetary, GFS, and external debt statistics.
  - Consistency with national accounts is not verified on a regular basis and may be affected by the lack of estimates of illegal trade, which are imputed in the national accounts.
- Revision policy and practice:
  - The revision cycle is predetermined and stable, but it is not publicized.
  - Preliminary and revised data are identified.
  - Analyses of data revisions are not disseminated.
- Data accessibility:
  - Data are disseminated in a format that follows BPM5 standard components.
  - A wide range of data are readily available in different formats and detailed presentations. Time series are available on the CBB website.
  - Data are released on a preannounced schedule and made available to all users simultaneously on the CBB website and in hardcopy publications.
- Metadata accessibility: Concepts, methodology, and data sources for the balance of payments are available on the CBB website and on the IMF’s DSBB. The External Sector Bulletin includes a comprehensive sources and methods document.
- Assistance to users: The CBB website clearly identifies two contact points for balance of payments data. Contact information is also provided on the Fund’s DSBB.

*Source: _cr07283 - 2. Methodological soundness (IMF country ROSC—Data Module).*

### 1.      We appreciate the opportunity to provide comments on the ROSC data module. We

### _cr07283 - 1. We appreciate the opportunity to provide comments on the ROSC data module. We

### Overall response
- The Central Bank of Bolivia (CBB), the Ministry of Finance (MOF), and the National Statistical Institute (NSI) collaborated with the ROSC data module mission and agree broadly with the mission’s recommendations.
- Detailed action plans to adopt the mission’s recommendations are provided in Part III: Section B (national accounts) and Sections C and D (price statistics).

### National Accounts Statistics
- Section B in Part III presents a detailed action plan to adopt the mission’s recommendations in national accounts.

### Price Statistics
- Sections C and D in Part III present a detailed action plan to adopt the mission’s recommendations in price statistics.

### Government Finance Statistics (UPF / MOF)
- The ROSC was reviewed by the Fiscal Programming Unit (UPF). Comments and responses are organized by DQAF indicators:

- Indicator 0.1.1
  - Mission’s recommendation: Improve coordination between the two MOF units responsible for GFS compilation.
  - Comment: UPF describes its mission (design and follow-up of the fiscal program) and notes that the Accountant General produces public sector financial statements receiving balance sheets three months after the fiscal year. Coordination is underway to implement GFSM 2001 and the Public Expenditure and Financial Accountability methodology.

- Indicator 0.3.1
  - Mission’s recommendation: Systematically identify emerging data requirements and undertake user surveys.
  - Comment: UPF maintains constant contact with GFS users and incorporates their feedback into public information.

- Indicator 1.2.2
  - Mission’s statement: No official agency outside MOF has access prior to publication; minister or vice-minister authorizes release.
  - Comment: UPF disagrees; compilation finalizes with submission to the Minister of Finance and immediate dissemination to the general public.

- Indicator 1.2.3
  - Mission’s recommendation: Clearly identify data sources and compilers in all statistical products.
  - Comment: Recommendation will be implemented in upcoming issues of Dossier Estadístico, Boletín de Recursos HIPC II, and the MOF webpage.

- Indicator 1.2.4
  - Mission’s recommendation: Provide advance notice of methodological changes materially affecting GFS.
  - Comment: Revisions will be detailed in footnotes in upcoming publications and on the MOF webpage.

- Indicator 2.2.1
  - Mission’s recommendation: Expand institutional and transaction coverage, include decentralized agencies and local governments, compile local government debt.
  - Comment: Current coverage includes financial account transactions of all municipalities; those beyond UPF coverage are estimated from monthly transactions. Efforts are underway to include provincial municipalities; debt data for largest municipalities are processed and a Performance Program to capture local government data was created.

- Indicator 2.3.1
  - Mission’s statement: Shortcomings—no consolidated central government statistics; social security sector excludes detailed data of the Corporation of Military Social Insurance.
  - Comment: MOF is considering adopting definitions consistent with GFS manuals.

- Classification and presentation recommendations (mission)
  - Reclassify royalties, commissions for interest, tax refunds, social assistance benefits, repayments, pension payments; reclassify certain capital revenue items; collect disaggregated expense data (e.g., “universities”); classify tax revenues, financing, and debt by instrument/holder/maturity.
  - Comment: UPF is evaluating changes to data presentation per recommendations.

- Indicator 2.4.3
  - Mission’s recommendation: Include tax refunds in taxes (netting) and lending minus repayments as expenditure under GFSM 1986 methodology.
  - Comment: UPF is evaluating changes to data presentation.

- Indicator 3.1.1
  - Mission’s statement: Multiple administrative systems (SIGMA, SINCON, integrated systems) lack interfaces, causing duplication and inconsistency.
  - Comment: SIGMA and SINCON are not used by all nonfinancial public sector agencies and often are not updated. UPF uses the Monthly Flow Registry to process cash flows for municipalities and other agencies; registry is reconciled with bank statements and considered highly reliable.

- Indicator 5.1.1
  - Mission’s statement: Disseminated GFS can be improved—note data sources/compilers, harmonize table titles, include analytic text, spell out acronyms, include stock data.
  - Comment: Data source identification is addressed in 1.2.3; other recommendations are being considered for Dossier Estadístico Vol. IX, Boletín de Recursos HIPC II, and MOF webpage.

- Indicator 5.1.3
  - Mission’s recommendation: Post preannounced GFS release calendar on MOF website.
  - Comment: Advance release calendar for fiscal year 2007 posted on UPF website.

- Indicator 5.3.1
  - Mission’s statement: User assistance not monitored.
  - Comment: Assistance provided personally or via electronic mail and is monitored and assessed by relevant staff.

### Monetary Statistics (CBB SSMF)
- The ROSC was reviewed by the Monetary and Fiscal Sector Deputy Management Office (SSMF). Comments/responses by indicator:

- Indicator 0.2.1
  - Mission’s recommendation: Revise internal CBB policy on Internet access and external telephone use.
  - Comment: Unlimited internet access already authorized for monetary statistics compilers; remaining logistical support in process.

- Indicator 0.3.1
  - Mission’s statement: No periodic policy to consult users of monetary statistics.
  - Comment: CBB has posted on its website a form to request comments and suggestions; will include in hardcopy publications.

- Indicator 1.2.2
  - Mission’s statement: Latest monetary and macro data provided regularly to Macroeconomic Group; may have pre-publication access acknowledged on CBB metadata.
  - Comment: Data provided to Macroeconomic Group are tables for the Monetary and Financial Program used for policy decision making; the Group does not discuss or review monetary and financial statistics to be published. Information is produced per a Memorandum of Understanding between MOF and CBB and uses adjustments and a fixed exchange rate methodology differing from published monetary tables. Meetings do not cover data quality. Weekly monetary/financial statistics are not provided to the Macroeconomic Group. CBB dismisses the possibility of earlier governmental access influencing published monetary and financial statistics.

- Indicator 1.2.4
  - Mission’s recommendation: Give advance notice of upcoming expansion of ODC coverage, compilation of an OFC survey, and major methodological revisions.
  - Comment: Any change in methodology, source data, or statistical techniques will be previously informed on the CBB webpage.

- Indicator 2.2.1
  - Mission’s recommendation: Expand ODC survey coverage to include SAFIs.
  - Comment: Action already taken; September 2007 monthly bulletin foresees inclusion of SAFIs accounts in the ODC survey.

- Mission’s recommendation: Start compiling a monthly OFC survey covering pension funds, insurance corporations, and the state-owned Development Productive Bank; systems work to aggregate pension fund data.
  - Comment: SSMF has a program to compile pension funds data in the requested format; September 2007 monthly bulletin will include pension funds information. For insurance corporations, Systems Management Office developed a consolidation program but the Superintendency of Pensions, Securities, and Insurances faces staff shortages hampering electronic transfer of data from 2002 onwards.

- Indicator 2.3.1
  - Mission’s statement: SAFIs classified as Other Financial Corporations rather than Other Depository Corporations.
  - Comment: On October 24, 2006, CBB asked the Superintendency of Banks and Financial Entities to create sector A39 Investment Fund Management Societies, separating them from A38 Other Financial Corporations; implemented starting with the report of January 2007. Inclusion of SAFIs in ODC sector in two stages: manual upload for 2002–2006; for 2007 onwards the new chart of accounts module is prepared and discussions with the Superintendency of Pensions, Securities, and Insurances on electronic transmission are ongoing.

  - Mission’s statement: No breakdown between other nonfinancial corporations and other resident sectors.
  - Comment: On October 24, 2006, CBB asked SBFE to split account A50 Private nonfinancial sector into A51 Other nonfinancial corporations and A52 Other resident sectors; implemented starting with reporting for January 2007.

  - Mission’s recommendation: Collaborate with SBFE to eliminate sectorization mistakes in ODC accounts.
  - Comment: On February 26, 2007, SSMF provided SBFE a detailed report of misclassifications in ODC-reported data. SBFE acted; a new review was undertaken with March 2007 data on April 18, 2007.

- Indicator 3.2.1
  - Mission’s recommendation: Develop a routine to flag significant balance changes or unexpected values.
  - Comment: Under consideration; could be generated by a database currently under construction.

- Indicator 4.3.3
  - Mission’s statement: Studies/analyses of revisions are not made public.
  - Comment: September 2007 monthly bulletin will include a methodological annex of all published tables; recommendation will be fully adopted when item 1.2.4 plans are implemented.

- Indicator 5.1.4
  - Mission’s statement: Monetary data may be made available to the Macroeconomic Group prior to public dissemination.
  - Comment: Statement not pertinent; see item 1.2.2. Authorities request rating of indicator 5.1 be upgraded from LO to O.

### Balance of Payments Statistics (CBB SSE)
- The ROSC was reviewed by the External Sector Deputy Management Office (SSE). Comments/responses:

- Indicator 0.1.1
  - Comment: Report should reference Article 20 of the CBB law as the legal framework for data requirements from the private sector mentioned in indicator 0.1.4.

- Indicator 0.3.1
  - Mission’s statement: Establish procedures for user feedback (preferably surveys).
  - Comment: CBB has established procedures; a questionnaire exists on the CBB website.

- Indicator 1.2.2
  - Mission’s statement: Macroeconomic Group may receive latest monetary and financial information prior to website publication; could generate internal access prior to dissemination.
  - Comment: Any reference to earlier government access should be deleted for balance of payments because this is not the case.

- Indicator 2.2.1
  - Mission’s recommendation: Assess extent to which nonresidents’ deposits can be identified from total bank deposits in SBFE data.
  - Comment: Recommendation should be implemented in coordination with SSMF.

- Indicator 2.3.1
  - Mission’s recommendation: Align classification of services/transfers and sectorization with BPM5 guidelines.
  - Comment: Alignment of sectorization with BPM5 corresponds only to external debt transactions in the balance of payments and international investment position.

  - Mission’s recommendation: Review external debt relief recording in line with BPM5, including debt forgiveness in the capital account.
  - Comment: Superfluous—the debt relief is recorded in the balance of payments as a capital transfer with a contra-entry in the financial account. Publications cited (Balance of Payments and International Investment Position Report, January–December 2006, page 7; Monthly Bulletin, Nº 145, January 2007, Table 24) show aggregated debt relief under the MDRI: World Bank (US$ 1,511.3 million) and IMF (US$ 232.5 million); and under the HIPC: Japan (US$ 63 million); for a total of US$ 1,806.8 million.

  - Mission’s recommendation: Align reserves template classification and coverage to IMF guidelines.
  - Comment: Some recommendations were implemented during the mission. Guidance on recording capital contributions to the FLAR in the reserves template was provided after the mission in a letter from STA’s Balance of Payments and External Debt Division II to CBB’s SEE on March 5, 2007.

  - Mission’s recommendation: Exclude the RAL Fund (US$ 489.9 million) from Section I.B Other foreign currency assets and from Section III 1.B Other contingent liabilities.
  - Comment: Issue solved during the mission; verifiable in Table 30 (International Reserves and Foreign Currency Liquidity Template) of Monthly Bulletin Nº 135, January 2007.

  - Mission’s recommendation: Include all short-term foreign-currency deposits of the financial sector with the CBB as predetermined short-term net drains on foreign currency assets in Section II.1 Outflows.
  - Comment: Recommendation currently not applicable—such deposits constitute part of legal reserve requirements.

  - Mission’s recommendation: Exclude from Section II.3 Other trade credit (+) the positive balances with ALADI’s Agreement of Reciprocal Payments and Credit to avoid double counting with Section I.A.5.
  - Comment: Issue solved during the mission; verifiable in Table 30 of Monthly Bulletin Nº 135, January 2007.

- Mission’s recommendation (partial)
  - When applicable, include negative balances with ALADI’s Agreement of Reciprocal Payments and Credit as predetermined short-term net drains on foreign currency assets.
  - (No specific comment provided in the supplied excerpt for this line.)

*Source: Comments and responses submitted by CBB, MOF (UPF), and SSE as contained in the ROSC data module response document.*

### Section II.3 Other trade credit (-)

### Section II.3 Other trade credit (-)

### Mission findings and comments on reserve-template and trade-credit recommendations
- The issue regarding Other trade credit was already solved during the stay of the mission. This can be verified in Table 30 (International Reserves and Foreign Currency Liquidity Template) of the monthly bulletin (Nº 135, January 2007), posted on the CBB website.
- Recommendation: When applicable, include in Section IV. 1 b) [of the Reserves Template] short-term domestic-currency debt indexed to foreign exchange rates and short-term financial instruments denominated in foreign currency but settled in domestic currency.
  - Comment: The recommendation is currently not applicable. At present, there are no securities indexed to the U.S. dollar (value maintenance) in circulation. If in the future operations in this kind of instrument take place, they will be included in the Reserves Template.
- Recommendation: The currency composition of official reserve assets disclosed in Section IV.2 a), according to those currencies in the SDR basket and those not in the SDR basket, should match the amounts reported in Section I.A.
  - Comment: This issue was already solved during the stay of the mission. This can be verified in Table 30 (International Reserves and Foreign Currency Liquidity Template) of the monthly bulletin (Nº 135, January 2007), posted on the CBB website.
- Recommendation: Official reserve assets in gold should be reclassified from assets in currency not in the SDR basket to assets in currencies in the SDR basket within Section IV.2 a).
  - Comment: This issue was already solved during the stay of the mission. This can be verified in Table 30 (International Reserves and Foreign Currency Liquidity Template) of the monthly bulletin (Nº 135, January 2007), posted on the CBB website.

### Data-quality indicator recommendations and comments
- Indicator 3.1.3
  - Mission’s recommendation: Employ more rigorous procedures to ensure the timely receipt of respondents’ data.
  - Comment: This recommendation should refer only to service, remittances, and foreign private capital.
- Indicator 3.3.1
  - Mission’s recommendation: Review statistical techniques to adjust data for missing observations.
  - Comment: This recommendation should refer only to service, remittances, and foreign private capital.
- Indicator 4.2.3
  - Mission’s recommendation: Prepare and disseminate a table on quarterly reserve assets reconciliation between monetary and BOP statistics.
  - Comment: This recommendation should be done in coordination with SSMF.

### Action plan — overview
- Paragraphs 7–8: An action plan was designed, based on the ROSC’s recommendations and in collaboration with the mission, to increase the analytical usefulness of Bolivia’s statistics. The plan is intended to guide future work of national compiling agencies and international organizations/donors. The IMF and other international organizations and donor countries will support the proposed actions.
- A detailed action plan is presented in attached tables (not included here). Not all actions have the same importance or priority; some are conditional on reassignment of resources, funding, training, or technical assistance.

### Cross-cutting actions (priority and other key actions)
- High Priority Actions:
  - Improve coordination among and within public institutions to facilitate information sharing and to avoid potential duplication in data collection and dissemination, as well as to improve intersectoral consistency.
  - Ensure that agencies and units compiling macroeconomic statistics have adequate resources to undertake needed developmental work.
  - Disseminate macroeconomics statistics simultaneously to all users, publicizing any prior access granted to selected users.
  - Promote the adoption of the new Statistics Law and a National Statistical Plan.
  - Strengthen data sources across all datasets, including surveys and censuses.
- Other Key Actions:
  - Establish regular mechanisms to monitor the relevance of the statistics and to identify emerging data needs.
  - Provide advance notice of changes in methodology, source data, and statistical techniques and disseminate advance release calendars, revision policies, and revision studies.

### National Accounts — planned actions (selected items, DQAF codes preserved)
- Prerequisite of Quality
  - 0.1.1: Give high priority to the approval of the new Statistical Law. — Timing: Short term
  - 0.1.2: Take actions to improve data sharing and coordination relations with the CBB and the MOF. — Timing: Short term
  - 0.2.1: Provide the resources required to establish an adequate data collection program for national accounts. — Timing: Short term
  - 0.3.1: Establish a mechanism to contact users and identify their opinion on the usefulness of the national accounts and their new and emerging data requirements. — Timing: Medium term
- Methodological Soundness
  - 2.2.1: Give high priority to the ongoing project to update the national accounts’ reference year and implement the 1993SNA, and bring forward the targeted completion date. — Timing: Short term
  - 2.2.1: Apply COFOG to classify the government’s expenses. — Timing: Medium term
- Accuracy and Reliability
  - 3.1.1: Update the establishment /enterprise directory. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.1.1: Formulate a program of economic annual and quarterly surveys, to support the regular compilation of national accounts. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.1.1: Improve the quality of volume and price indices for manufacturing activities. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.1.2: Uniform the use of ISIC rev.3 by different source data applying an economic activity classification. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.2.1: On the basis of updated establishments/ enterprises directories apply scientific sampling methods in establishments/enterprises surveys. — Timing: Medium term
  - 3.3.1: Assess the possibility of using the households survey, and other sources, whereas available, to estimate the participation of the informal sector, and changes through time, in employment and income generation. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.3.2: Define fixed cells in the S&U table where available data permits. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.3.2: Apply the recommended 1993SNA treatment of pension funds. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.3.2: Apply a better method to estimate FISIM at constant prices. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.5.1: Carry out routinely studies of revisions. — Timing: Short term
- Serviceability
  - 4.2.3: Prepare and disseminate bridge table, showing how to reconcile the national accounts with BOP and GFS figures. — Timing: Short term
  - 4.3.1: Disseminate a schedule for the revision cycle of the national accounts and explain reasons for its adoption. — Timing: Short term
  - 4.3.2: Identify revised data in the publications and explain the reasons for revisions. — Timing: Short term
- Accessibility
  - 5.1.4: Inform the public on the access of the government to data, prior to their dissemination to the public. — Timing: Short term
  - 5.1.5: Make the public aware on the availability of additional statistics, and of the procedures for obtaining them. — Timing: Short term

### Consumer Price Index — planned actions (selected items, DQAF codes preserved)
- Prerequisite of Quality
  - 0.2.1: Financing will be needed to improve the quality of the CPI. — Timing: Short term
  - 0.3.1: Establish regular mechanisms to consult data users to monitor the relevance of the statistics and to identify their information needs. — Timing: Short term
  - 0.4.2: Prepare monthly reports to inform management of the quality of surveys’ data (surveys’ response rate, coverage, response errors, etc.). — Timing: Short term
- Methodological Soundness
  - 2.1.1: Adopt the recommendations of the 1993 SNA and CPI Manual 2004. — Timing: Short term
  - 2.3.1: Define the basket of a new CPI using systems broadly consistent with internationally accepted standards, in accordance with 1993 SNA and Classification of Individual Consumption by Purpose (COICOP). — Timing: Short term
- Accuracy and Reliability
  - 3.2.1: Improvement the efficiency of sampling techniques trough asses CPI data source to prices surveys. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.2.1: Asses CPI data source and calculate response rate, coverage, response errors, etc. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.3.1: Employ better statistical techniques to improve treatment of seasonal products, missing items, quality changes, and introduction of new products. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.3.2: Adopt the following 1993 SNA and the new CPI Manual, 2004 recommendations:
    - Include Imputed Rentals of owner-occupied dwellings in the CPI weights.
    - Use of the geometric mean for price changes.
    - Calculate retroactive index series using chain linking, between old a new series. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.5.1: Update of the new basket of the index, and conduction of studies about the difference between the both new and old CPI. — Timing: Short term
- Serviceability
  - 4.3.3: Document of the comparative studies between the new and the old CPI. — Timing: Short term
- Accessibility
  - 5.1.3: Disseminate a preannounced schedule with the dates the statistics are to be released. — Timing: Short term

### Producer Price Index — planned actions (selected items, DQAF codes preserved)
- Prerequisite of Quality
  - 0.2.1: Significant resources will be needed to improve the quality of the PPI. — Timing: Short term
  - 0.3.1: Establish regular mechanisms to consult data users to monitor the relevance of the statistics and to identify their information needs (preferably through users’ surveys). — Timing: Medium term
  - 0.4.2: Prepare monthly reports to inform management of the quality of surveys’ data (surveys’ response rate, coverage, response errors, etc.). — Timing: Short term
- Methodological Soundness
  - 2.1.1: Adopt the concepts and definitions following the 1993 SNA, such as the inclusion of new PPI weights, changes in inventories, and own-account production for final use. — Timing: Medium term
  - 2.2.1: Formulate a general plan for expand industrial activity coverage, compiling updated weights and reference base, following international standards. — Timing: Short term
  - 2.3.1: Define the basket of a new CPI using systems broadly consistent with internationally accepted standards, in accordance with 1993 SNA, International Standard Industrial Classification (ISIC Rev.3), and Central Product Classification (CPC). — Timing: Medium term
- Accuracy and Reliability
  - 3.1.1: Formulate a general plan for increase basket of goods coverage, using data from the supply/use tables based on the new national accounts series. — Timing: Medium term
  - 3.2.1: Asses PPI data source to prices surveys and improvement the efficiency of sampling techniques. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.2.1: Asses PPI data source and calculate response rate, coverage, response errors, etc. — Timing: Short term
  - 3.3.1: Employ better statistical techniques to improve treatment of seasonal products, missing items, quality changes, and introduction of new products. — Timing: (timing implied short term in source)

*Source: _cr07283 - Section II.3 Other trade credit (-), IMF staff report content as provided.*

### introduction of new products.

### introduction of new products

### Price Statistics (Producer Price Index — PPI)
- 3.3.2 • Adopt the recommendations in the 1993 SNA and the new PPI Manual 2004, including:
  - Use of the geometric mean for price changes
  - Calculation of retroactive index series using chain linking, between old a new series.
  - Timing: Medium term
- 3.5.1 • Undertake periodic revision studies.
  - Timing: Short term
- 3.5.1 • Base PPI updates on a program of regular censuses and surveys.
  - Timing: Long term
- Serviceability
  - 4.1.1 • Improve the periodicity of the PPI. — Short term
  - 4.1.2 • Improve the timeless of the PPI. — Short term
  - 4.3.1 • Normalize the revisions periodicity. — Short term
  - 4.3.3 • Document and disseminate the analysis of differences between revised and preliminary data. — Medium term
- Accessibility
  - 5.1.3 • Disseminate a preannounced schedule with the dates the statistics are to be released, and release statistics according to the preannounced schedule. — Short term

### Government Finance Statistics (GFS)
- Prerequisite of Quality
  - 0.1.1 • Coordination between the two units of the MOF that share the responsibility of GFS compilation should be improved for comprehensive collection, compilation and dissemination of GFS. — Short term
  - 0.1.2 • Intra and inter-agency data sharing and coordination between the MOF and data-producing public entities should be improved. — Short term
  - 0.2.1 • Additional personnel, computing, and financing resources are required to perform new collection, compilation, and dissemination tasks to improve GFS quality, such as an expansion of the institutional and transaction coverage of the GFS already compiled, and the implementation of the GFSM 2001 analytical framework. — Medium term
- Assurances of integrity
  - 1.2.3 • Clearly identify data sources and the entity in charge of data compilation in all statistical products. — Short term
  - 1.2.4 • Provide advance notice of all methodological and other relevant changes that materially affect the GFS. — Short term
- Methodological Soundness
  - 2.1.1 • Develop a plan to migrate to the GFSM 2001 analytical framework. Current GFS compilation using the GFSM 2001 methodology by the GDA should be coordinated among relevant units and institutions involved in the GFS compilation. — Medium term
  - 2.2.1 • (i) Expand the scope of institutions and transactions in the GFS to include comprehensive and detailed data of the operations of some decentralized agencies and local governments; (ii) make special efforts to compile debt data of local governments; and (iii) expand coverage of domestic debt. — Medium term
  - 2.3.1 • Adopt sectorization and classification systems recommended in the GFS manuals, including:
    - Compile and disseminate data for central government including budgetary, extrabudgetary, and social security operations. — Short term
    - Compile GFS for the social security sector, including data of the Corporation of Military Social Insurance. — Medium term
    - Reclassify royalties as other revenue item; commissions for interest as good and service item; tax refunds as a revenue item; social assistance benefits as transfers to households; repayments as an expense item and present a net item, lending minus repayments; and payments for pensions as compensation of employee item. — Short term
    - Reclassify as other capital revenue two categories wrongly classified as current revenue, “other capital revenue” and “other revenues”, the part corresponding to capital revenue. — Medium term
    - Collect and compile disaggregated data for some items included in expenses, such “universities” and “others”, to obtain an adequate economic classification. — Medium term
  - 2.4.1 • Value public external and domestic debt at face value if the GFSM 1986 methodology is used or at market prices if the GFSM 2001 methodology is used. Nominal values can be shown as memorandum items. — Medium term
  - 2.4.2 • Compile GFS data on noncash and cash bases. Both bases of recording are relevant for policy analysis and they should be consistent. — Medium term
  - 2.4.3 • Taxes should include tax refunds, and be netted from the correspondent tax, if possible, and lending minus repayment should be included as an expense category (when using the GFSM 1986 methodology). — Short term
- Accuracy and Reliability
  - 3.1.1 • (i) devote financial, human, and computing resources to integrate data sources for improving consistency of the GFS and for reducing the collection and compilation burden, and (ii) expand institutional coverage of the SIGMA to include information collected by the SINCON and other financial systems. — Medium term
  - 3.5.1 • Document revision studies and analysis of revisions. — Medium term
- Serviceability
  - 4.2.3 • Reconcile GFS with the national accounts to ensure consistency. — Short term
  - 4.3.1 • Make the revision schedule known to the public. — Short term
  - 4.3.3 • Include explanatory notes of revisions in published tables and disseminate studies and analysis of revisions. — Short term
- Accessibility
  - 5.1.1 • Improve the presentation of GFS on the website or in hard copy. — Short term
  - 5.2.1 • Post detailed GFS detailed metadata and a link to the IMF’s DSBB on the MOF website. — Short term

### Monetary Statistics
- Prerequisite of Quality
  - 0.1.2 • Improve the timeliness of transmission of ODC’s monthly data from the GEF to the SSMF. — Short term
  - 0.2.1 • Provide for automatic centralized back-up of the files stored in personal computers. — Medium term
- Assurance of Integrity
  - 1.2.4 • Announce in advance any major changes in the compilation of monetary statistics (e.g., the expansion of the coverage of the ODC to include SAFIs, or the compilation of an OFC survey). — Short term
- Methodological Soundness
  - 2.2.1 • In coordination with the SPVS, expand the coverage of the ODC survey with the inclusion of SAFIs. — Short term
  - 2.2.1 • In coordination with the SBFE, remove the detected shortcomings in the reporting of some ODCs, in particular the improper use of the residence criterion2. — Short term
  - 2.2.1 • In coordination with the SPVS, start compiling a monthly OFC survey with accounts of insurance corporations, pension funds, and BDP. — Short term
- Accuracy and Reliability
  - 3.2.1 • Develop a routine that automatically flags substantial changes in the balances of selected accounts, or balances that do not correspond with the expected values. — Medium term
- Serviceability
  - 4.3.3 • Publish studies and analyses of revisions. — Short term

  (Footnote present in source: "2 Every three months, the CBB will send to the SBFE notes with the observations.")

### Balance of Payments (BOP) Statistics
- Prerequisite of Quality
  - 0.1.4 • Include in CBB’s questionnaires and direct reporting forms for BOP compilation references to the legal basis for collecting information, including the confidentiality of reported data. — Short term
  - 0.2.1 • Provide additional staff to the BPD to undertake tasks associated with the recent introduction of the CBB’s Foreign Private Capital (FPC) survey. — Short term
  - 0.2.1 • Improve BPD staff telephone communications and Internet access. — Medium term
  - 0.4.2 • Prepare monthly reports to inform management of the quality of data based on direct reporting and surveys. — Short term
- Assurances of Integrity
  - 1.2.1 • Enhance the description in the External Sector Bulletin of the terms and under which BOP statistics are compiled and disseminated. — Short-term
  - 1.2.4 • Reinforce the practice of providing advanced notice of major changes in the compilation of BOP statistics. — Short term
- Methodological Soundness
  - 2.2.1 • In consultation with the NSI, develop a methodology to include unrecorded trade and its counterpart transactions in BOP statistics. — Medium term
  - 2.2.1 • Identify in coordination with the MOF ways to gather information on the ultimate holder of government bonds issued locally. — Medium term
  - 2.2.1 • Assess the extent to which nonresidents’ deposits could be identified from total bank deposits in SBFE data in coordination with the SSMF. — Medium term
  - 2.3.1 • Classify transactions in services and transfers, and sectorize institutional units for external debt transactions according to BPM5 guidelines. — Short term
  - 2.4.1 • Adjust flow data derived from BIS stocks data on nonbank deposits abroad for exchange rate valuation changes. — Short term
  - 2.4.2 • In coordination with the GOI, apply the accrual principle for recording interest on public external debt. — Medium term
  - 2.4.2 • Record dividends when declared payable. — Short term
- Accuracy and Reliability
  - 3.1.1 • Initiate quarterly FPC surveys in 2007, identifying improvements in design, data validation, and sample techniques, based on the results of the 2006 FPC survey. — Short term
  - 3.1.1 • Prepare a comprehensive and up-to-date business register for sample surveys. — Short term
  - 3.1.1 • Reinforce the use of surveys and direct reporting data for services. — Short term
  - 3.1.1 • Resume in 2007 the semiannual travel survey, jointly conducted by NSI and CBB. — Short term
  - 3.1.3 • Subject to staff availability and improvements in the telephone communications, the CBB may employ more rigorous follow-up procedures to ensure the timely receipt of respondents’ data on services, remittances, and foreign private capital. — Short term
  - 3.3.1 • Review statistical techniques to adjust data for missing observations on services, remittances, and foreign private capital. — Medium term
  - 3.3.2 • Continue efforts to improve data collection and estimation techniques for workers’ remittances and other transfers, and certain services and financial transactions. — Medium term
  - 3.3.2 • Review estimates on direct investment with the view to avoid overestimation of investment income and reinvested earnings. — Medium term
  - 3.4.3 • In coordination with the GOI, compare data on selected external debt transactions with the Joint BIS-IMF-OECD-World Bank external debt table and the BIS locational banking statistics. — Short term
  - 3.4.3 • Reconcile regularly trade data using partner-country data to adjust for possible miss coverage of exports and imports. — Medium term
  - 3.5.1 • Document studies and analysis of revisions and use these results to inform the statistical process. — Short term
- Serviceability
  - 4.2.1 • Closely monitor the BOP errors and omissions. — Short term
  - 4.2.1 • Produce and disseminate on a regular basis a summary table on BOP and IIP data consistency (identifying initial stock, transactions, other changes, and final stock). — Short term
  - 4.2.2 • Revise the data series prior to 2006 in order to reclassify Bolivia’s contributions to FLAR from reserve assets to other CBB’s external assets. — Short term
  - 4.2.3 • Establish regular mechanisms for enhancing data consistency with national accounts statistics. — Medium term
  - 4.2.3 • Prepare and disseminate a table on quarterly reserves assets reconciliation between monetary and BOP statistics in coordination with the SSMF. — Short term
  - 4.3.1 • Strengthen data revision policies and practices. — Short-term
  - 4.3.1 • Publicize the revision cycle for BOP data on the CBB website. — Medium term
- Accessibility
  - 5.1.1 • In coordination with the GOI, initiate the dissemination of the public- and publicly-guaranteed external debt service schedule recommended by the GDDS on the CBB website. — Medium term
  - 5.1.1 • In coordination with the GOI, initiate the dissemination of the SDDS prescribed external debt position data category (by institutional sector of the debtor, maturity, and type of instrument) on the CBB website. — Short-term
  - 5.1.1 • In coordination with the GOI, initiate participation in the World Bank’s quarterly external debt statistics (QEDS) database, by reporting the SDDS prescribed external debt table. — Short-term
  - 5.1.1 • In coordination with the GOI, compile and disseminate other QEDS tables relevant for Bolivia in the CBB website. — Medium term
  - 5.1.1 • Initiate the monthly reporting of the reserve template with one-month lag to STA for its redissemination on the IMF website. — Short term
  - 5.1.1 • Disseminate monthly series of the reserve template on the CBB website. — Short term

*INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND — BOLIVIA; Detailed Assessments Using the Data Quality Assessment Framework (DQAF); Prepared by the Statistics Department; Approved by Robert W. Edwards and Anoop Singh; August 2, 2007*

### 0. Prerequisites of quality

### _cr07283 - 0. Prerequisites of quality

### 0.1 Legal and institutional environment

- Responsibility for compiling national accounts:
  - Decree-Law (DL) 14100, November 5, 1976, creates the National System of Statistical Information but did not assign national accounts compilation to the National Statistics Institute (NSI).
  - Supreme Decree 12352, April 8, 1975 — previously assigned accounts to the Central Bank of Bolivia (CBB).
  - Supreme Decree 21855, January 14, 1988 — transferred responsibility to the NSI; compilation performed by the National Accounts Directory (NAD).
  - NSI is a decentralized entity currently allocated to the Ministry of Development Planning.

- NSI powers under DL 14100:
  - Article 5: manage, plan, execute, supervise, and coordinate the System’s activities.
  - Article 8: issue technical standards to standardize statistical compilation and avoid duplication.
  - Article 15: mandatory submission of data by all individuals and legal entities in Bolivia, residents and nonresidents, when requested by the NSI.
  - Article 25: NSC authorized to determine internal disciplinary measures independently of Criminal Code and other provisions.

- Practical limitations:
  - DL 14100’s authority is weakened by newer laws of higher legal power that limit NSI access to information generated by other public entities.
  - A new Statistics Law project has been prepared and will be presented to the Ministry of Development Planning and then to Congress.

- Recommendation:
  - Give high priority to the approval of the new Statistics Law.

- Data sharing and coordination:
  - Bilateral agreements exist between NSI and institutions including CBB, Vice Ministry of Migration, Vice Ministry of Tourism, Superintendency of Communications, and Ministry of Hydrocarbons.
  - Coordination with CBB and Ministry of Finance (MOF) could be improved.
  - Tax authority database access is not allowed; aggregate tax data are provided with confidentiality protections.
  - Access to tax authority enterprise lists and addresses has been denied, impeding update of NSI’s Enterprise Directory.

- Confidentiality and statistical use:
  - DL 14100 Article 21: “data and information obtained by the System shall be strictly confidential and used only for statistical purposes. No individualized data or information may be disclosed...”
  - Article 22: institutions and employees prohibited from providing data in violation of confidentiality.
  - Article 23: staff must use only approved questionnaires and maintain absolute reserve.
  - Article 24: computing files and databases must contain security systems and protection.
  - NSI practices to protect confidentiality: restricted access, special aggregation rules, secure storage and destruction of forms, controlled building access, penalties in Staff Rules.
  - Respondents are informed of legal obligation, confidentiality, and statistical-use-only in all census and survey questionnaires; interinstitutional agreements include confidentiality clauses.

- Statistical reporting and encouragement of response:
  - Article 15 provides legal support for data collection; confidentiality ensured.
  - Reporting is mandatory but legislation lacks sanctions for noncompliance or misreporting.
  - NSI employs voluntary cooperation measures: analyze response burden, include contact points in questionnaires.

### 0.2 Resources

- Staffing and recent changes:
  - NAD permanent staff reduced from 19 to 15 persons (prior to changes).
  - NAD presently has a permanent staff of 17 employees compiling national accounts with reference year 1990.
  - Preparatory work to update reference year and implement 1993 SNA started in October 2006; 20 new employees have been hired and assigned to the NAD.
  - Permanent professional employees hold university degrees in statistics, economics, and related areas; average of eight years of work at the NSI.
  - Three of the new contracted staff previously worked in the NAD.

- Training and compensation:
  - Training via internal and international seminars, workshops, and on-the-job training with international experts.
  - Specialist wages increased in 2006 but remain uncompetitive; difficulties recruiting qualified candidates due to compensation versus job requirements.

- Computing and facilities:
  - 27 new computers recently acquired with state-of-the-art software for the national accounts reference year update project.
  - Adequate protection provided for computer resources.
  - NSI central building recently renewed but requires urgent repairs; technical area moved heavy documentation to avoid collapse risk.
  - Regional offices overcrowded and in need of repairs and furniture.
  - Technical assessments done; Japanese government donation started work in Beni and Santa Cruz departmental offices; work in central and other departmental offices to start in a few months.

- Funding and budget trends:
  - NSI experienced serious budget constraints in recent years affecting economic statistics scope and interrupting activities (e.g., annual manufacture survey conducted since 1992 but interrupted in 2003).
  - NSI’s budget for 2005 was 37 percent lower than for 2002, at current prices.
  - International support secured for statistical activities in NSI’s Institutional Strategic Plan for 2005–2009.
  - NAD staff increased recently to implement national accounts modernization project.

- Recommendations:
  - Provide resources to establish an adequate data collection program of regular surveys for compiling annual and quarterly national accounts.
  - Make wages paid to NSI’s technicians more competitive.

- Measures to ensure efficient use of resources:
  - New personnel contracted following the Law of the Public Servant, Servicio Nacional de Administración de Personal norms, and Superintendencia del Servicio Civil.
  - Staff performance evaluated three times per year.
  - 2005–2009 Institutional Strategic Plan and Annual Operative Plans define tasks and projects; budgeting used to allocate limited resources.
  - Extensive use of international technical assistance: IMF, United Nations, Dutch, Sweden, and French cooperation programs.
  - NAD specialists participate in Andean Community of Nations (CAN) seminars; seven seminars held in recent years to improve quality and comparability of national accounts and quarterly GDP estimates.

### 0.3 Relevance

- Efforts to increase relevance:
  - Project to modernize national accounts and implementation of GDDS; work to improve timeliness to subscribe to SDDS.
  - NSI professionals participate in public institution meetings; contributed to government’s National Development Plan.
  - No structured and periodic process to directly consult main national accounts data users exists.
  - User needs are considered when planning censuses, surveys, and variable/questionnaire design.
  - Some user requirements received via NSI website e-mail address and the Customers Service Unit.

- Departmental-level initiative:
  - Project on dissemination of statistical information and training of producers and users with UK Ministry for International Development support: 23 workshops in 18 months with approximately one thousand participants.
  - Experience to be used to develop a System of Municipal Information.

- Recommendation:
  - Establish a structured and periodic process of consultation with the principal data users to review usefulness of national accounts series and identify new/emerging data requirements for the modernization project.

### 0.4 Other quality management

- Focus on quality:
  - Quality is one of NSI’s Statistical Principles; disseminated in publications and on website.
  - November 2003 metadata revision and evaluation assisted by Canadian Executive Service Organization; NAD metadata on quarterly GDP, annual GDP, and departmental GDP aggregates covered.
  - Participation in CAN seminars and technical assistance from international organizations improved compilation processes despite resource constraints.
  - Training for updating reference year and implementing SNA 1993 has taken place, including subject on relations between enterprise financial statements and national accounting according to 1993 SNA; institutional sector accounts included.

- Monitoring quality of statistical program:
  - Performance of Annual Operative Plan tasks monitored and assessed to track accomplishments and delays.
  - Commitments to CAN Statistical Secretariat and timing of data provision are monitored.
  - Survey data collection and processing efficiency monitored daily.
  - Swedish cooperation funds a permanent consultant evaluating national accounts and making quality improvement recommendations.

- Quality in planning:
  - Institutional Strategic Plan 2005–2009 contemplates starting ISO 9000:2000 quality certification process for main statistical products, implying monitoring of statistical processes and programming required quality improvements.

### 1. Assurances of integrity

#### 1.1 Professionalism

- Impartial production:
  - NSI’s Statistical Principle on Integrity emphasizes technical considerations, scientific principles and professional ethic in data recollection, compilation and dissemination.
  - Professionalism promoted via training courses, specialized seminars abroad, and international technical assistance.
  - Appointment of present Executive Director resulted from a transparent process emphasizing professional qualifications and performance.

- Source and technique choices:
  - Choices of sources, statistical methods, and dissemination decisions are based on technical criteria and cost considerations.
  - Due to budget restrictions, less use of hard copy publications; preference for posting national accounts material on the INS website (data, analyses, metadata).

- Right to comment on misuse:
  - Disseminated documents include data and analysis to prevent misinterpretation (e.g., quarterly Analysis of the Economic Activity includes a section on coverage limitations).
  - NSI monitors media coverage of its data through NAD; NSI Director issues comments as needed.

_Italic: Source: _cr07283 - 0. Prerequisites of quality (PDF)_.

### 1.2       Transparency

### 1.2       Transparency

### Terms and conditions for collection, processing, and dissemination
- Various NSI publications and documents, disseminated through its website, reproduce relevant legal topics.
- The NSI’s Institutional Strategic Plan for the period 2005–2009 contains a section on legal norms related to the Institute’s statistical activity.
- Users who want to access the Institute’s database are informed of the specific terms and conditions for statistics dissemination, and they must accept them.
- The legislation governing the terms and conditions under which statistics are collected until being disseminated by the NSI is posted on the website.
- An advance release calendar for NSI products is disseminated on the CBB website.

### Internal governmental access to statistics prior to release
- The Macroeconomic Group receives the latest available monetary and financial information that may or may not have been published; this can generate internal government access prior to public dissemination but does not interfere with pre-scheduled public dissemination.
- Internal government access to data before their release to the public is made known to the public on the CBB and IMF websites, but not on the NSI website.
- Recommendation: Make the public aware of the internal government access to statistics prior to their release to the public on the NSI website.
- Note on composition: The Macroeconomic Group is comprised by the Minister of Finance, the CBB President, the Minister of Planning, the Deputy Ministers of Budget, Treasury, Tax Policy, Public Investment, and Pensions, and the Executive Directors of the NSI, UDAPE, UPF, and the Fiscal Analysis Network (RAF).

### Identification of NSI products
- Data disseminated to the public by the NSI are clearly identified as NSI’s products by name and logo.
- Article 20 of DL 14100 establishes the obligation of attribution when the data produced by one institution are disseminated by other institutions.

### Advance notice of major methodological changes
- Major changes in conceptual framework, source data and statistical techniques of the national accounts (for example, the introduction of the reference year 1990) are announced to the public in advance.

### Ethical standards for staff
- Law No. 2027, on the Statute of the Public Servant, from October 27, 1999, establishes rights and obligations of public servants, including guidelines on conflict of interest situations.
- Article 13 mandates all public entities to adopt an Ethical Code and to implement mechanisms for practical evaluation of its dispositions.
- The NSI’s internal Staff Regulations attend this institutional obligation; Law No. 2027 and the Staff Regulations emphasize adherence to ethical standards.
- Sanctions for improper behavior are established in the NSI’s internal Staff Regulations, in accordance with Law No.1178, on Governmental Administration and Control.
- Staff are reminded periodically of these standards; new staff are informed upon joining and must observe them from that time.

### Methodological soundness — Concepts and definitions
- The national accounts are compiled using the 1968 SNA as the conceptual framework, with important features of the 1993 SNA incorporated, among them:
  - compilation of annual supply and use tables,
  - valuation of output at basic prices,
  - oil fields exploration registered as gross fixed capital formation (GFCF).

### Scope of the national accounts
- Coverage includes:
  - annual and quarterly GDP by expenditure and production approaches at current and constant 1990 prices,
  - annual total GDP by income approach at current prices,
  - annual supply and use tables for 35 economic activities and 35 groups of products at current and constant prices,
  - quarterly GDP estimates including seasonally adjusted data.
- Indirect estimates are made on illegal production linked to transformation of the coca leaf in special supply and use accounts for a “coca enclave,” and for informal industrial and domestic trade activities and foreign trade smuggling.
- Departmental level: annual production and GDP data by economic activity at current and constant prices for all nine departments.
- Institutional sector accounts are included from production up to capital account for: public administration, public nonfinancial enterprises, financial institutions, households, and private nonfinancial corporations. Private nonfinancial corporations and households are not separately disseminated; NPISH data are not compiled. Pension funds are included in the general government.
- Annual rest of the world accounts (until net lending) and the four Consolidated Accounts from the 1968 SNA are included.
- Regularly compiled items that ISWGNA recommends: quarterly value added and GDP at current and constant prices by activity, quarterly expenditures of GDP at current and constant prices, and annual supply and use tables.
- Delimitation of constituent units follows international recommendations; included as part of the economy are territorial enclaves in the rest of the world, free zones, and workers who work part of the year in another country.
- Production boundary includes (in accordance with 1993 SNA recommendations, independently of actual full coverage): own-account production of all goods for own final consumption, output of goods for own-account fixed capital formation and mineral exploration, illegal output sold to willing buyers; exclusions include production of computer software; research and development on own account; production of entertainment, literary, or artistic originals.
- Asset boundary exclusions (not yet included): defense related assets usable for civilian purposes (treated as intermediate consumption per 1968 SNA), valuables, agricultural work-in-progress (except increase in livestock for meat), systems and standard applications computer software and databases (purchased or built in-house). Mineral exploration (successful or not) is incorporated in the asset boundary.
- Oil and gas activities:
  - Production boundary includes production of crude oil, natural gas and related products and value of production of oil field exploration services (part treated as GFCF).
  - A supply and use account is compiled for oil and gas products.
  - Only foreign enterprises were operating before they were nationalized in May 2006; they are now administered by the state-owned oil company Yacimientos Petrolíferos Fiscales Bolivianos (YPFB).
  - During 2005, the value added generated by the crude oil and natural gas activity represented 6.3 percent of GDP at current prices.
  - Complete information may be obtained from YPFB, including income flows, although the last ones are not separately identified in the disseminated institutional sector accounts.

### Classification and sectorization
- National classifications:
  - economic activities: based on ISIC Rev. 3 (except for agriculture activities),
  - products: based on Central Product Classification (CPC),
  - household consumption by purpose: COICOP.
- Functional classification of government expenditures (COFOG) has not been applied.
- Institutional sector classification is an adaptation of the 1968 SNA: public enterprises and quasi-corporate enterprises, private enterprises and quasi-corporate enterprises and households, financial institutions, government, and rest of the world. Households are not classified separately; NPISH are not investigated.
- Transaction classification does not cover financial transactions related to financial assets and liabilities, as they are still not incorporated in the System; no classification for other flows (changes in assets and liabilities not generated by transactions).
- Recommendation: Apply COFOG to classify government expenditures by functions.

### Basis for recording
- Valuation rules broadly follow the 1993 SNA:
  - Production generally valued at basic prices; intermediate consumption and other uses at purchaser prices.
  - Output for own use valued at equivalent market prices; corrections made when transfer prices are detected; total imports and exports valued on an f.o.b. basis.
  - Foreign trade transactions valued in dollars are converted using the exchange rates applied to exports and imports respectively, which implicitly include financial services.
- Recommendation: Apply the mid-point exchange rate prevailing in the market at the moment transactions take place, in order to not incorporate financial services when converting dollars into national currency.
- Oil and gas activities valuation: output at basic prices, exports at f.o.b prices, imports at c.i.f prices.
- Recording basis:
  - Transactions are recorded, in principle, on an accrual basis.
  - Preliminary estimates of government related transactions are recorded on a cash basis; when accrual data become available they are incorporated in revised national accounts figures.
- Grossing/netting procedures: Transactions between establishments belonging to the same enterprise are recorded on a gross basis, to the extent allowed by the data sources.

*Source: _cr07283 - 1.2       Transparency*

### 3.1       Source       data

### 3.1       Source       data

### 3.1.1 Source data are obtained from comprehensive data collection programs that take into account country-specific conditions

- Historical and recent weakness in supply of economic statistics due to broad fiscal restraint that drastically reduced NSI’s resources and forced suspension of annual manufacturing, foreign direct investment, and tourism surveys.
- Programmed economic census needed for improving national accounts accuracy was not conducted.
- Annual manufacturing survey suspended in 2003; annual estimates for manufacturing were based on the quarterly manufacturing survey, which:
  - has lower coverage and investigates fewer variables;
  - uses a 1990 fixed basket of products and has lost coverage.
- Much private market activity data are based on partial indicators and fixed 1990 coefficients rather than regular surveys or current enterprise financial statements.
- Authorities started a project to modernize national accounts by updating the reference year and widening implementation of the 1993 SNA; resulting new statistical activities include:
  - a wide survey covering mining, manufacture and services recently conducted to update the national accounts reference year;
  - a household survey conducted in 2004 to update the Consumer Price Index (CPI)’s base year.
- Several household surveys:
  - Integrated Households Survey (1989–95) replaced in 1996 by National Employment Survey; survey conducted in 1997 but not in 1998.
  - MECOVI replaced National Employment Survey in 1999 and has been conducted practically every year since then.
  - Household survey conducted from November 2003 to November 2004 to update CPI base year:
    - sample of 9,770 households selected using 2001 National Population and Housing Census as sample frame;
    - target population: households in private dwellings (collective dwellings excluded), distributed in capital cities, rest of urban, and rural area;
    - two-stage stratified random sampling applied; proper imputation methods used for non-responses; grossing-up factors derived scientifically.
- Government finance statistics data are comprehensive and include operations of extra-budgetary funds, all defense-related expenditures, and local government operations; data permit measurement of output, intermediate consumption, fixed capital formation, and final consumption expenditure of government services.
  - Estimates of government capital stock are not generated, preventing estimation of consumption of fixed capital via perpetual inventory method.
  - Preliminary government estimates are provided on a cash basis by MOF’s Fiscal Programming Unit (UPF); data on accrual basis are available approximately eleven months after the end of the reference year from the State General Accounting Office.
- Administrative source data collected by NSI:
  - Very good quality for financial institutions, crude oil and natural gas, electricity, gas, and water supply.
  - Very weak for construction (low coverage of building permits from municipalities) and community, social, and personal services.
  - Tax Authority provides aggregate data by economic activity but high aggregation level does not meet NAD requirements; inconsistency between taxpayer classification by economic activity and national accounts classification needs resolution.
- Price statistics:
  - CPI (base year 1990) basket: 332 products representing approximately 90 percent of households’ final consumption expenditure in the base year.
  - New household survey (2004) will produce a new CPI basket of 508 products.
  - Construction Cost Index covers costs by type of construction and type of activity.
  - Manufacturing Producer Price Index (base year 1990) fixed basket: 125 products representing 85 percent of manufacturing value added in 1990; has lost coverage due to outdated basket.
  - Import Unit Value index basket: approximately 830 products, based on annual sample selection weighted by foreign trade.
  - Export unit value index basket: 138 products, similar characteristics to import unit value index.
  - NAD generally does not apply unit value indices and instead uses international prices for imported machinery and other various imported products.
  - NSI is revising foreign trade unit value indices methodology with Swedish cooperation.
- Sub-annual surveys and indicators for quarterly GDP:
  - Quarterly manufacturing survey provides a production volume index and a manufacturing producer price index.
  - Production volume index dissemination suspended in 2003 but compiled and later disseminated in 2005 NSI Yearbook covering missing period.
  - Monthly index of economic activity compiled but discontinued in 2003 due to coverage problems; authorities plan to resume compilation of monthly index.
  - Price statistics weak for most economic outputs and products; manufacturing producer price index coverage deteriorated.
- Labor market surveys:
  - NSI survey on employment, wages and compensations by economic activity, occupational group, and region conducted every six months (June and December); had quarterly periodicity until 2003 but reduced to semester due to budget cuts.
  - Quarterly survey on public sector employment and wages complements private labor market information.
- Entrepreneurial opinion surveys: NSI and CBB conduct quarterly surveys used by NAD to assess reliability of quarterly GDP estimates.
- Press and research papers are monitored to identify activities relevant to national accounts.
- Availability and coverage issues imply data are insufficient for compiling reliable quarterly GDP as various indices with base year 1990 have lost coverage.
- Oil and gas activities:
  - Data for crude petroleum and natural gas provided by YPFB.
  - For exploration services, YPFB provides investment in shared-risk contracts by enterprise and by region; compiled monthly with a lag of two months after reference period.
  - YPFB main source for intermediate consumption and added value measurements; however, only output at current prices is used.

- Recommendation (from 3.1.1): Update the establishment/enterprise directory and formulate a program of annual and quarterly economic surveys to support the regular compilation of the quarterly and annual national accounts.

### 3.1.2 Source data reasonably approximate the definitions, scope, classifications, valuation, and time of recording required

- Source data broadly consistent with national accounts definitions, scope, and classifications; generally consistent with time of recording, reference periods, and valuation.
- Exceptions:
  - Some activity classifications in source data remain ISIC Rev. 2 while national accounts use ISIC Rev. 3; a correspondence table allows reclassification.
  - Some enterprises’ financial statements use calendar year, others use April 1 to March 31 reporting period; annual surveys request calendar year data directly.
- Agriculture:
  - Production recorded by source in calendar year of harvest; NAD estimates output on accrual basis by distributing costs through time using 1990 cost structures.
  - New cost structures for key agricultural products investigated for year 2000; to be updated and used in new reference year.
- Government investment: source definition includes components that need exclusion by NAD compilers to apply GFCF concept.
- Government statistics preliminary data valued on cash basis used for preliminary quarterly GDP; accrual basis data available eleven months after end of reference year.
- Recommendations:
  - (1) Incorporate data for government expenditures on accrual basis in the semi definitive accounts.
  - (2) Classify taxpayers by economic activity, with support of the NSI.
- Oil and gas: transactions recorded on an accrual basis and coverage is very good.

### 3.1.3 Source data are timely

- NSI enforces timely receipt of source data through rigorous follow-up and formal agreements with institutions containing timing clauses; survey respondents informed of reporting deadlines.
- Government expenditures on accrual basis provided with good coverage approximately eleven months after end of reference year.
- Oil and gas enterprises provide data to YPFB monthly, two months after end of reference period; transport-related activity data provided by relevant enterprise.

### 3.2 Assessment of source data

- NSI survey data accuracy well assessed via editing procedures that identify outliers and atypical differences; extreme values are confirmed with respondents.
- Accuracy of other surveys and administrative sources analyzed in the context of revisions.
- National accounts revision cycle:
  - preliminary, semi definitive, and definitive estimates.
  - Preliminary data posted on website four months after end of reference year.
  - Semi-definitive data ready with a lag of 11 months, but disseminated with a lag of 16 months together with revised quarterly data.
  - Definitive data ready with a lag of 24 months, but disseminated with a lag of 28 months together with institutional sector accounts.
  - Annual GDP data for the past three years are still marked as preliminary; same applies to quarterly GDP data for these years, as quarterly data are revised only when annual data are revised.
- Oil and gas source data are strictly controlled due to tax collection considerations:
  - Oil is valued at international prices collected in five markets.
  - Gas price results from negotiations between government and purchasing corporations.

*Source: _cr07283 - 3.1       Source       data*

### 3.3       Statistical       techniques

### 3.3       Statistical       techniques

### 3.3.1 Data compilation and imputation
- Findings:
  - The NSI has established sound compilation procedures to minimize processing errors such as coding, editing, and tabulation errors.
  - Adjustments to unit records are made only when clearly warranted.
  - Procedures for imputation and adjustment for nonresponse in some establishment surveys consist of repeating the response of the previous period and are not adequate.
- Recommendation:
  - Apply adequate imputation and adjustment procedures.

### 3.3.2 Treatment of unobserved activities and special estimates
- Findings:
  - National accounts cover part of unobserved activities, including some illegal and informal activities.
  - Estimates on production and distribution of coca leaf are generated within a special Supply and Use Table (S&U table) to record the “coca enclave” transactions with the Bolivian economy and the rest of the world.
  - A 1990 joint study produced an input-output matrix for coca leaf and derivatives and provided 1990 technical coefficients used for indirect estimates of informal activities (meat, dairy, bakery, etc.).
  - Informal and formal trade are estimated using fixed distribution margin coefficients; smuggling estimates generate adjustments for underreporting and enclave transactions.
  - Indirect estimates use 1990 technical coefficients and fixed 1990 intermediate consumption/output coefficients in many places.

### Production approach and S&U framework
- Findings:
  - Supply is estimated at the most disaggregated level for 233 products; at the aggregate S&U level output is estimated for 35 activities and 35 products.
  - Output at constant prices is obtained by extrapolating base year values using output volume indices; intermediate consumption product composition is obtained by applying fixed 1990 intermediate consumption/output coefficients; gross value added is obtained as a difference.
  - Fix cells are not included in the intermediate consumption submatrix.
  - Aggregates at current prices are obtained by multiplying constant price outputs and intermediate consumption products by corresponding price indices; gross value added at current and constant prices are obtained by difference.
  - Excessive use is made of fixed coefficients more than five years old in compiling value added and across aggregates representing more than 60 percent of GDP.
  - Specific measurement methods:
    - Agriculture: reference year values based on cultivated area, yield per hectare, and prices; consecutive years extrapolated using quantity indices of main products.
    - Manufacturing: three methods — (1) direct method (enterprise data); (2) processing chain method using 1990 fixed technical coefficients; (3) expansion method using average productivity by enterprise.
    - Electricity, gas, water: volumes sold multiplied by current year and 1990 year prices to estimate output at current and constant prices.
    - Housing construction: permits, studies on duration, distribution of costs through duration, and construction cost index are used.
    - Transport: change rate in number of automobiles by department and type of vehicle used as proxy; coverage is very poor.
  - Specific GDP compilation issues:
    - Owner-occupied dwellings measured as estimated rentals tenants would pay (1993 SNA recommendation).
    - Livestock reared for food recorded as work in progress.
    - Changes in inventories are not adjusted for holding gains because they are obtained as residuals.
    - Consumption of fixed capital is not estimated because stocks of fixed capital are not estimated.
  - Taxes on products at constant prices are extrapolated from reference year taxes by a volume index of supply to domestic users.
  - Trade margins output volumes extrapolated from 1990 trade margins using volume indices of sales or output.
  - Financial intermediation services indirectly measured (FISIM) at constant prices are obtained by deflating current price values by CPI, although a more adequate method could be applied.
  - In the S&U framework, government final consumption expenditure, GFCF, exports, and imports are initially incorporated as independent estimates; household final consumption at constant prices is derived by applying 1990 household consumption percentages to total supply of each of the 35 products and deflated with CPI indices.
  - Changes in inventories are obtained as residuals for each product with a restriction that they cannot exceed five percent of the total supply of the corresponding product.
  - Classification practices:
    - Household final consumption classified by COICOP and by products in S&U.
    - Government final consumption is not classified by function (COFOG).
    - GFCF compiled by type of assets but not by economic activities (commodity flow method used).
    - Exports and imports classified by product in S&U.
  - Volume measures and deflation:
    - Household consumption implicit deflator consistent with CPI.
    - Government final consumption deflated by cost components except compensation of employees which is extrapolated by a volume index of government employment.
    - Imported components of GFCF, exports, and imports deflated by unit value indices adjusted by an exchange rate index.
    - Volume measures of changes in inventories obtained as the difference between total supply and all other uses at constant prices.
  - Temporal reconciliation and seasonal adjustment:
    - Fernández multivariant method used to combine annual and quarterly series.
    - Di Fonzo method used to reconcile multiple economic activity series temporally and transversally.
    - Seasonal adjustment uses ARIMA modeling of Gomez and Maravall, processed with TRAMO/SEATS and DEMETRA 2.0.
  - Oil and gas:
    - Constant price estimates obtained by multiplying output in fine metric tons by 1990 reference year price; intermediate consumption estimated using 1990 input/output coefficients; value added obtained as a difference.
    - Suggestion: information could be obtained on components of the production account at current prices.

### 3.4 Assessment and validation of intermediate data and statistical outputs
- 3.4.1 Findings on validation:
  - NAD prepares an annual inventory of available source data to detect unused but relevant data for assessing source reliability.
  - Cross-checks performed include:
    - Coca enclave production data cross-checked with Special Counternarcotics Force seizures.
    - Production data cross-checked with exports and input imports.
    - Private final consumption by flow of goods cross-checked with household survey consumption levels.
    - Population projections used as reference.
  - Construction uses indirect indicators such as cement production and consumption, construction cost index, and imports of construction materials.
- 3.4.2 Findings on assessment of discrepancies:
  - No systemic routine procedure established to assess potential discrepancies in intermediate data, but detected discrepancies are assessed, investigated, and reconciled using available information.
- 3.4.3 Findings on investigating discrepancies in outputs:
  - The S&U framework is used to investigate and eliminate discrepancies during table balancing, resulting in consistency between GDP by production activities and GDP by expenditure components.
  - GDP data can be validated against unofficial estimates that employ plausible assumptions and methods.

### 3.5 Revision studies
- Findings:
  - Ample analysis of revisions is carried out at each stage of the national accounts dissemination cycle.
  - Studies of revisions are made routinely only for the construction activity; documentation is prepared for this study.

### 4 Serviceability — periodicity, timeliness, and consistency
- 4.1 Periodicity and timeliness:
  - Periodicity of quarterly and annual GDP estimates follows GDDS recommendations and meet SDDS requirements.
  - Timeliness of quarterly GDP estimates follows GDDS recommendations and meet SDDS requirements.
- 4.2 Consistency:
  - 4.2.1 Internal consistency:
    - Internal and intertemporal consistency of GDP figures achieved via balanced S&U tables at current and constant prices; some components obtained as residuals ensure consistency of GDP by activity and expenditure approaches.
    - Quarterly GDP estimates are consistent with annual GDP; same concepts, definitions, and classifications are used and benchmarking techniques are applied.
  - 4.2.2 Time-span consistency:
    - Consistent annual time series available from 1988 to 2005.
    - Quarterly GDP data are consistent from 1988 to third quarter of 2006.
    - The present series with reference period 1990 was reconstructed back to 1980.
  - 4.2.3 Reconciliations with other frameworks:
    - Government GFCF and final consumption reconcilable with UPF cash-basis data after adjustments used to move from investment to gross capital formation.
    - Accrual basis data from MOF’s Accounting Office, once adjusted, are used in revised estimates.
    - Rest of the world account data are generally reconcilable with BOP data for same aggregates.
    - NSI provides exports and imports of goods to the CBB; BOP compilers adjust these by excluding/including given flows.
    - Estimates for smuggling in national accounts are not included in the balance of payments.
  - Recommendation:
    - Generate and disseminate bridge tables to reconcile NA with GFS and BOP data.

### 4.3 Revision policy and practice
- 4.3.1 Revision schedule and disclosure:
  - The revision and dissemination cycle is predetermined and reasonably stable:
    - Preliminary data posted four months after the end of the reference year.
    - Semi-definitive data ready with a lag of eleven months but disseminated with a lag of 16 months, together with revised quarterly data.
    - Definitive data ready with a lag of 24 months but disseminated with a lag of 28 months together with institutional sector accounts.
  - The cycle timing is driven by timeliness of source data, timing of related dataset revisions, and timing for preparing economic policy documents.
  - Neither the revision cycle nor the reasons for establishing it have been made known to the public; partial information appears in the advance dissemination calendar on the CBB website. Documentation of revisions is prepared but not disseminated.
  - Recommendation:
    - Provide to the public information on the revision cycle, reasons for establishing it, and documentation on revisions.
- 4.3.2 Labelling of preliminary and revised data:
  - Preliminary nature is noted by a (p); users are not informed whether other disseminated data have been revised.
  - Annual GDP data for the last three years are still marked as preliminary; quarterly GDP data for these years are only revised when annual data are revised.
  - Recommendation:
    - At dissemination, identify also the data that have been revised and become semi definitive or definitive.
- 4.3.3 Public dissemination of revision studies:
  - Analyses of differences between semi-definitive and preliminary data are made for major aggregates and documented but not disseminated.
  - Recommendation:
    - Disseminate results of analyses of revisions to allow assessment of the reliability of disseminated data.

### 5 Accessibility
- 5.1 Data accessibility and dissemination practices:
  - 5.1.1 Presentation:
    - National accounts are disseminated in documents that include analysis, tables, charts, and explanations on data sources and main limitations.
    - Time series starting from 1988 are easily accessed on the NSI website.
  - 5.1.2 Media and format:
    - Data are disseminated in formats facilitating media redistribution, e.g., press releases posted on the website.
    - Oil and gas aggregates are disseminated in corresponding product rows and activity columns of the S&U table.
  - 5.1.3 Preannounced schedule:
    - An advance release calendar for annual and quarterly GDP data is posted on the CBB website; releases follow the preannounced schedule.
  - 5.1.4 Simultaneous availability:
    - A government policy advisory committee is provided with data that may or may not have been disseminated to the public; this practice does not affect the prescheduled public dissemination.
  - 5.1.5 Nonroutine requests:
    - Other general statistics are made available upon request, subject to confidentiality protections.
    - The public is not made aware of availability of additional statistics or procedures for obtaining them.
    - Recommendation:
      - Make the public aware of the availability of additional statistics and of the procedures for obtaining them.

*Source: _cr07283 - 3.3       Statistical       techniques*

### 5.2       Metadata       accessibility

### 5.2       Metadata       accessibility

### 5.2.1 Documentation on concepts, scope, classifications, basis of recording, data sources, and statistical techniques
- The National Accounts Bulletin 1988-1997, issued in February 2001, describes source data and compilation methods; it contains mainly a description on concepts and definitions.
- NSI website metadata for national accounts include documents on sources and methods applied to compile:
  - institutional sector accounts,
  - quarterly GDP at current and constant prices,
  - seasonally adjusted quarterly GDP figures,
  - regional GDP,
  - input-output tables,
  - various censuses and economic surveys,
  - statistics on economic activities (construction, energy, transport, etc.),
  - main price and volume indicators generated by the NSI.
- Most of these statistics and indicators are used as inputs to compile the national accounts.
- The metadata are posted together in a special section on the NSI website and are readily accessible.
- GDDS metadata posted on the IMF website is being updated and reformulated with a view to preparing the subscription to the SDDS.

### 5.2.2 Levels of detail are adapted to the needs of the intended audience
- Some metadata are general and useful for a wider public; others target specialized users.
- The National Accounts Bulletin 1988–1997 and more recent national accounts publications may be accessed; the Bulletin may be accessed by contacting the NSI’s Customer Service Unit.
- A general information brochure about the national accounts has not been prepared due mainly to financial restrictions.
- Access to national accounts statistics and metadata is described as very easy on the NSI website.

### 5.3 Assistance to users

#### 5.3.1 Contact points for each subject field are publicized
- The Institute’s Customer Service Unit provides prompt and efficient assistance to users.
- Contact points with the NAD are not directly provided on the NSI website; however, they appear in national accounts metadata on the website where names, phone numbers, and e-mail addresses are given.
- The information on contact points is updated when metadata are updated.
- Recommendation: Provide direct contact points for national accounts on the NSI website.

#### 5.3.2 Catalogs of publications, documents, and other services, including information on any charges, are widely available
- A virtual library and a catalog of the NSI’s publications and other documents are available on the website and in the Central Library.
- Photocopies and printouts of tables are available to the public upon request.
- The public can subscribe to a distribution list free of charge to receive information by e-mail.
- A 2006 catalog of publications is available.
- The Customer Service Unit provides information on prices and assistance in placing orders; prices charged cover only the publications cost.

### Data Quality Assessment Framework (National Accounts) — Summary findings and plans (selected)
- Compiling Agency: National Statistic Institute
- Key observations and planned improvements (selected from Table 1):
  - 0.1 Legal and institutional environment: DL 14100 has partially lost its relevance due to the limited legal power of a decree vis-à-vis a law; decree 21855 transferred compilation of national accounts from the CBB to NSI. Plans: NSI prioritizes approval of a new Statistical Law; reinforce data sharing and coordination with the CBB and the MOF.
  - 0.2 Resources: Funding required for important economic surveys suspended due to budgetary restrictions; efforts in place to obtain resources to establish an adequate data collection program for quarterly and annual national accounts.
  - 0.3 Relevance: Structured and periodic processes of consultation with main users are needed; adequate mechanisms will be defined and established (medium-term).
  - 1.2 Transparency: Internal governmental access to statistics prior to public release is made public on CBB and IMF websites, but not on NSI website. Plan: Make government’s prior access to statistics public on the NSI website (short-term).
  - 2.1 Concepts and definitions: National accounts compiled mainly using the 1968 SNA; important features of the 1993 SNA have been incorporated. Plan: Project to more widely apply the 1993 SNA and to actualize the national accounts reference year.
  - 2.2 Scope: Institutional sector accounts compiled only up to the capital account; NPISH sector not investigated.
  - 2.3 Classification/sectorization: Government expenditures are not classified by functions. Plan: Adopt COFOG classification to classify government expenditures by functions (medium-term).
  - 3.1 Source data: An adequate data collection program is not in place; important surveys (annual manufacture, FDI, tourism) were suspended; FDI survey now conducted by the CBB; quarterly manufacture survey lost coverage due to 1990 fixed basket; dissemination of the quarterly volume index based on this survey was suspended in 2003 but series was disseminated in the 2005 NSI yearbook. A wide survey covering mining, manufacture, and services was conducted in 2005 to update the 1990 reference year. A household survey was recently conducted to update the CPI’s 1990 base year. Source data assigns agriculture output to harvest’s year. Some sources still apply ISIC rev.2 despite national accounts applying ISIC rev. 3. Plans: Establish program of annual and quarterly surveys (medium-term); uniform the use of an updated ISIC by data sources (short-term).
  - 3.2 Assessment of source data: Sampling errors not estimated in some surveys. Plan: Use updated directories as frames and apply adequate sampling methods (short-term).
  - 3.3 Statistical techniques: Indirect estimates for partial informal activities could be extended; reference year 1990 is outdated; excessive use of fixed 1990 input-output coefficients; households final consumption at constant prices estimated via horizontal fixed coefficients in use side of S&U table; changes in inventories obtained as residuals; pension funds treatment and FISIM estimation at constant prices could be improved. Plans: Assess use of household survey and other sources to estimate informal sector participation and employment/income changes (short-term); incorporate fixed cells in S&U table where data permit (short-term); apply 1993 SNA recommendations for pension funds (short-term); adopt a better method to estimate FISIM at constant prices (short-term).
  - 3.5 Revision studies: Analysis of revisions routinely carried out for all activities, but detailed studies only for construction. Plan: Extend revision studies to other activities (short-term).
  - 4.2 Consistency: Consistency with BOP and GFS needs enhancement. Plan: Prepare bridge tables linking national accounts with BOP and GFS figures (short-term).
  - 4.3 Revision policy and practice: Partial information on the revision cycle is included in the advance release calendar; documentation prepared for internal use but not disseminated; users are not informed if disseminated data have been revised; results of analyses of revisions and partial studies documented but not disseminated. Plan: Provide public information on revision cycle, reasons, and documentation on revisions (short-term).
  - 5.1 Data accessibility: A government policy advisory committee is provided with data that may or may not have been disseminated; public is not made aware of availability of additional statistics or procedures for obtaining them. Plan: Inform public on availability of nondisseminated but nonconfidential statistics and procedures for obtaining them (short-term).
  - 5.2 Metadata accessibility: Assessed as observed with metadata available on the NSI website.
  - 5.3 Assistance to users: Customer Service Unit provides assistance; contact details for national accounts exist in metadata but not directly on site (see recommendation above).

### Price Statistics (Consumer Price Index) — selected findings

### 0. Prerequisites of quality — Legal and institutional environment
- The CPI has been compiled by the National Statistics Institute (NSI) since 1966.
- DL 14100 of November 5, 1976 created the National Statistical Information System (SNIE); NSI is a decentralized entity with administrative and operational autonomy.
- Supreme Decrees 24009, 26772, 26973, and 27732 affirmed NSI accountability and supervision arrangements.
- Chapter III, Article 8(c) of DL 14100 assigns NSI functions including compiling, preparing, analyzing, and publishing statistics indicated in the National Operating Plan.
- NSI Strategic Institutional Plan 2005-2009 includes statistical products: (1) the CPI, (2) the producer price index (PPI), (3) the construction cost index, and (4) salaries and remuneration.

### 0.1.2 Data sharing and coordination among data-producing agencies
- Chapter III, Articles 10 and 11 of DL 14100 provide for Technical Committees on Statistical Coordination; in practice these committees are set up for interinstitutional studies but do not function on a permanent basis.

### 0.1.3 Confidentiality and use of individual reporters’ data
- Chapter II, Article 21 of DL 14100: data obtained by SNIE are confidential, may be used only for statistical purposes, and may not be revealed in individualized form.
- Article 22: institutions and officials are prohibited from providing data in violation of confidentiality provisions.
- Access to individual data restricted to specialists responsible for compilation; published statistics are aggregated with no identification of reporting units.
- Report forms are filed for approximately two years before transfer to NSI central archives.

### 0.1.4 Statistical reporting and response encouragement
- Title V, Chapter I, Article 15 of DL 14100 requires individuals/legal entities to submit required data within prescribed periods, with penalties for violations, though implementation is not mandatory and respondents may refuse participation.
- For Household Budget Survey (HBS) 1990 and Continuous Household Survey (CHS) 2003/2004, NSI conducted direct interviews to explain objectives and encourage voluntary cooperation; refusals were followed up by supervisors and substitution from replacement dwellings used if refusal persisted.
- Survey instruments included questionnaires and daily expenditure notebooks; instruments designed to be simple and limited in extent.
- Price collection forms are adapted to each establishment, including up to six products with full descriptive details (name, characteristics, packaging, form, color, weight, brand, origin, and unit of measurement).
- Price collectors act as customers and do not identify themselves as NSI officials except for some services.
- The survey plan rotates price collectors so they visit the same retail establishment every six months.

*Source: _cr07283 - 5.2       Metadata       accessibility*

### 0.2       Resources

### 0.2       Resources

### 0.2.1 Staff, facilities, computing resources, and financing are commensurate with statistical programs
- Organizational structure:
  - Directorate of Statistics and Economic Indicators (DEIE) comprises three units: (1) External Sector Records, Statistics, and Indicators, (2) Price Records, Statistics, and Indicators (UREIP), and (3) Economic Activity Statistics and Indicators (UEIAE).
- UREIP staffing for CPI compilation:
  - Head of unit, six full-time specialists, and 25 regular employees compiling the CPI at the national level:
    - one national manager,
    - one national expert,
    - two general supervisors (Cochabamba and Santa Cruz),
    - 21 technical field operatives—La Paz y Alto (9), Cochabamba (6), and Santa Cruz (6).
- Technical field operatives responsibilities:
  - compile price and rent surveys, transcribe data.
- Supervisors and national expert roles:
  - supervisors verify price variations, present periodic reports, forward information to central office;
  - national expert coordinates compilation with regional offices and analyzes gathered and transcribed information;
  - national manager formulates study methodologies and coordinates/plans CPI compilation activities from information capture to presentation.
- Special team for new CPI (one-year recruitment):
  - 86 members: three technical specialists, nine regional managers, 11 supervisors, 43 price collectors, 10 transcribers, and 10 drivers.
  - Supervisors and specialists participated in seminars and workshops hosted by ECLAC and the National Statistics Institute of Spain.
- International Comparison Program (ICP) support:
  - Between 2005 and the first half of 2006, UREIP received technical assistance from Canada’s National Statistical Agency and ECLAC.
- Compensation and experience:
  - Compensation based on civil servant salary scale.
  - Average length of service: more than ten years for specialists and six years for field workers.
- Computer resources and software:
  - Purchase of ten computers for compiling the new CPI.
  - Processing system developed on Microsoft’s Windows 2000 platform.
  - CPI application (base year 1991) developed using Visual Basic Professional version 6.0; Access 2000 used as the database.
  - Application consists of three installable modules: (1) CPI system, (2) data export and import module, (3) CPI tools module.
  - System capabilities: periodic data entry, detail updates by reporter, on-screen queries, report printing, data migration to Excel.
  - Supervisors and experts trained to operate the system; technical field operatives trained to key in information.
- Office environments and communications:
  - Appropriate office environments and equipment allocated in each town where CPI is conducted.
  - Supervisors and technical field operatives in regional offices do not have access to e-mail, limiting coordination.
- Vehicles for price collection:
  - Number of vehicles assigned sufficient: La Paz y Alto (2), Cochabamba (1), Santa Cruz (1).
  - No regular budget allocated for vehicle maintenance.
- Budget and financing:
  - Budget planning subject to NSI’s Annual Operating Plan; sum allocated for the CPI (base year 1991) kept constant in recent years.
  - Plan covers salary expenses of full-time personnel and contractors and regular expenses (fuel, communications, courier services, office supplies).
  - No budget allocation for systematic supervision of data collection in the country’s hinterland.
  - For compilation of the new CPI, external financing received for administrative costs, human resource recruitment, and purchase of computer equipment.
- Recommendations:
  - (1) Increase the staff of the UREIP and raise the allocation of budgetary resources to maintain the improvements planned for the new CPI (wider geographical coverage, expanded basket, and systematic control of the quality of field operations, development of a new processing system);
  - (2) assess the methodological improvements proposed for proper planning of technological and programming resources.

### 0.2.2 Measures to ensure efficient use of resources are implemented
- Performance evaluation:
  - CPI personnel performance evaluated every six months, coordinated by human resource unit with participation of Director of DEIE, head of UREIP, and Indicator manager.
  - Competences evaluated: analytical capacity, communication, performance under pressure, specific abilities, work organization, interpersonal skills, quality of service.
  - Administrative Services Directorate carries out half-yearly assessments of UREIP progress in accordance with the Annual Operating Plan.

### 0.3 Relevance
- Use and applications:
  - The CPI is the official inflation indicator in Bolivia and is widely used in economic, legal, and social areas: as a deflator of the national accounts system, updating social benefits, salary negotiations.
  - The CBB uses it for constructing the Housing Promotion Unit (UFV) and calculating underlying inflation.
- User consultation and outreach:
  - No formal mechanism established with participation of various economic sectors; seminars for academic economists held once or twice a year on CPI themes.
  - Activities include seminars for journalists and audiovisual/press interviews to inform on importance and scope of the CPI.
  - Executive Directorate of the NSI launched meetings to inform government institutions about change of base year and updating of weights in the CPI and planned methodological improvements.
- Recommendations:
  - (1) Organize a formal mechanism, with the participation of users, to consult them on their information needs, clear up doubts regarding the interpretations, applications, and limits of the CPI, and inform them of any methodological improvements incorporated in the indicator and any major changes in the basket of products and their weights;
  - (2) publish on the NSI website the methodological document containing the entire project, including the HBS 2003–2004, and links between series at the same time the new indicator series is launched.

### 0.4 Other quality management

#### 0.4.1 Processes are in place to focus on quality
- Strategic Institutional Plan 2005–2009 mission statement: “To produce and disseminate useful, timely, and reliable official statistics on the national situation.”
- Core principles identified: service, integrity, quality, confidentiality, and organization.
- Principles included in NSI documents, orientation programs, and methodological documents/manuals for price collectors and supervisors for HBS and CPI.

#### 0.4.2 Processes are in place to monitor the quality of the statistical program
- Multi-stage quality monitoring by UREIP technical staff:
  - (1) technical field operatives produce initial consistency checks by reviewing prices across markets;
  - (2) supervisor identifies price increases/reductions and checks for specification changes;
  - (3) regional manager analyzes price histories by product and reporter, compares with other reporters and reference prices surveyed in randomly selected shops;
  - (4) price specialist performs validation and supplements with analysis of changes and impacts by product.
- Limitations:
  - No regular programs to monitor quality of domestic price collection due to budgetary constraints.
- Technical assistance:
  - Two outside consultants provided assistance for CPI (base year 1991) consumer price collection and processing procedures.
  - For change of base and updating weights, plan to engage an international advisor during 2007.
- Recommendations:
  - (1) Assess the advantages and disadvantages of acting as a customer when collecting CPI prices, bearing in mind that this collection model makes it difficult to carry out subsequent verification of atypical prices and supervision of the price collectors activities;
  - (2) design a processing system that facilitates monitoring of missing prices by product/establishment, and the reasons thereof, and keep a record of those reasons, to use this information in the process of continuous CPI quality improvement.

#### 0.4.3 Processes are in place to deal with quality considerations in planning the statistical program
- Work plan for CPI improvement:
  - (1) 2003–2004: Continuous Household Survey conducted (with ECLAC support) to update basket and weights, using households’ income and expenditure, coverage of all main towns, COICOP classification, following concepts/definitions of household consumption expenditure in 1993 SNA;
  - (2) 2005–2006: survey of specifications to select specific goods and services by town;
  - (3) 2006–2007: prices being captured to generate average prices for the base period;
  - (4) 2007: rental survey will begin.
- New CPI plans:
  - New CPI will use base year 2007.
  - Methodological improvements: geographical coverage, expansion of the basket, calculation of the geometric mean of the price relatives.
  - Improvements in database design and processing programs planned.
- Financing:
  - Improvement program financed by the Steering Committee of the Bolivia-Canada Central Social Fund, set by the Canadian International Development Agency and the Vice Ministry of Public Investment and External Financing.

### 1. Assurances of integrity

#### 1.1 Professionalism

- 1.1.1 Statistics are produced on an impartial basis:
  - NSI is an autonomous entity; compilers are independent in selection of data sources and processing methods.
  - Executive Director of the NSI authorized to present the CPI.
  - Title VII, Chapter II, Article 26 of DL 14100 governs statistical personnel in SNIE institutions.
  - Specialists compiling the CPI have 10–15 years’ experience and training in-country and in international courses (Spain’s National Statistics Institute, ECLAC, CAN).

- 1.1.2 Choices of sources, techniques, and dissemination:
  - Methods, sources, methodologies, concepts, and statistical procedures conform to international standards and adopted on statistical considerations.
  - Results disseminated solely on statistical considerations; methodological documentation prepared and made available to the public.

- 1.1.3 Right to comment on misuse:
  - NSI monitors media coverage and provides timely public clarifications in case of erroneous interpretations.

#### 1.2 Transparency

- 1.2.1 Terms and conditions public:
  - NSI website includes methodological aspects relating to CPI (base year 1991) and HBS 1990.
  - CHS 2003-2004 methodology and results published on NSI website and in its library.
  - Methodological documents include data security and integrity section; protections under Article 21 of DL 14100 of the SNIE.

- 1.2.2 Internal governmental access prior to release is identified:
  - CPI estimates (preliminary and final) presented to the Macroeconomic Group (President of the CBB, Minister of Development Planning, Minister of Finance, Executive Directors of NSI, UDAPE, UPF, RAF).
  - Prior access may occur but does not interfere with public dissemination; practice openly identified in metadata on CBB and IMF websites.
  - CPI methodological document states indicator is published on the first business day of each month; publication dates given in Calendario Anual de Estadísticas Económicas on CBB website.
  - Recommendation: Include the Calendario Anual de Estadísticas Económicas on the NSI website.

- 1.2.3 Products clearly identified:
  - Title V, Chapter I, Article 20 of DL 14100 requires statistical publications to indicate original sources.
  - NSI publications bear NSI name and logo; reproduction authorized if data source cited.

- 1.2.4 Advanced notice of major changes:
  - At start of CPI series (base year 1991), CPI importance/scope publicized via seminars and media.
  - Methodological document on NSI website provides general information on planned methodological improvements for change of base.

#### 1.3 Ethical standards

- 1.3.1 Staff behavior guidelines:
  - NSI by-laws specify rights, duties, prohibitions, incompatibilities, and disciplinary measures for public servants; informed during orientation.
  - Methodological documents and manuals emphasize legal principles of discretion and confidentiality.

### 2. Methodological soundness

#### 2.1 Concepts and definitions
- 2.1.1 Alignment with international standards:
  - HBS 1990 conceptual framework and CPI (base year 1991) basket and weights adhere to concepts and definitions of household consumer spending of 1968 SNA and ILO recommendations.
  - Concepts and definitions generally follow Consumer Price Index Manual (2004).
  - Prices collected are market prices paid by households and include all taxes levied.
  - CPI basket (base year 1991) disaggregation: nine chapters, 25 groups, 54 subgroups, and 332 goods and services differentiated for each town.
  - System allows replacement of specifications when items cease to be available or change over time.
- Recommendation:
  - Adopt the international recommendations on definitions for household consumption expenditures in the 1993 SNA, the 1995 European System of Accounts or in the Consumer Price Index Manual, 2004.

#### 2.2 Scope
- 2.2.1 Consistency with international practice:
  - Domain of study: urban area.
  - Geographical coverage of basket and weights includes residential households in main towns: La Paz, Santa Cruz, Cochabamba, and El Alto, which accounted for 60 percent of the urban population and 35 percent of the total population in 1990 (NSI estimates).
  - HBS exclusions: collective households (prisons, hospitals, barracks, convents and monasteries, etc.), satellite units of the spending unit (domestic servants and pensioners).
  - HBS applied to representative sample of individual households, capturing monetary and nonmonetary consumer spending and expenditure not attributable to consumption, per 1968 SNA framework.
  - Household consumer expenditure excludes goods/services produced by household for own consumption and wages paid in kind.
  - Excluded expenditures: capital expenditures, dwelling remodeling and expansion, purchase of real estate, participation in games of chance, donations, theft, losses, transfers to third parties, purchase of vehicles.
  - CPI basket excludes expenditures not for consumption (financial services, legal services, contributions, transfers to third parties) and social transfers from government to households, in line with SNA recommendations.

*Source: _cr07283 - 0.2       Resources*

### 2.3       Classification/sectorization

### _cr07283 - 2.3       Classification/sectorization

### 2.3 Classification/sectorization systems used
- The standard CPI basket (base year 1991) was classified using an adaptation of the Classification of Household Consumption Expenditure by Purpose, in accordance with 1968 SNA.
- The index is calculated for nine chapters:
  - (1) food and drink
  - (2) clothing and footwear
  - (3) housing
  - (4) household equipment and operation
  - (5) healthcare
  - (6) transport and communication
  - (7) education
  - (8) recreation and culture
  - (9) sundry goods and services
- The CHS 2003/2004 classified household consumption in accordance with 1993 SNA, using the Classification of Final Consumption by Purpose adapted to Bolivia.
- The CHS 2003/2004 classification will be used for the new CPI basket.

### 2.4 Basis for recording
- Market prices
  - Prices collected in the CPI are the market prices paid by households and include all taxes levied on the goods and services traded.
  - Prices of merchandise in liquidation are excluded.
- Accrual basis
  - Household final consumption expenditure for CPI weights was measured on a purchase or accrual basis: includes goods and services received in the period covered by the HBS, regardless of payment timing or use.
- Grossing/netting practices
  - The CPI basket (base year 1991) does not include automobiles or purchases of durable consumer goods on the secondary market.

### 3. Accuracy and reliability — Source data

- HBS 1990 design and coverage
  - HBS used to construct CPI (base year 1991) was carried out by NSI over 50 weeks between February 1990 and January 1991.
  - Sampling framework updated for the 1988 population and housing census.
  - Four towns investigated: La Paz, Santa Cruz, Cochabamba, and El Alto.
  - Sampling: two-stage with stratification of the primary sample unit; self-weighted on a stratum level.
  - Primary sample unit: set of 50 or more dwellings; final sample unit: individual dwelling.
  - Investigations were conducted at 6,093 dwellings:
    - La Paz: 1,484 dwellings
    - Santa Cruz: 1,813 dwellings
    - Cochabamba: 1,699 dwellings
    - El Alto: 1,097 dwellings
  - Of 1,080 goods and services identified in 1990, the basket contained 332 generic products representing 90 percent of household expenditure.
  - Reporting establishments selected using HBS data on points of sale with most supply and competition; CPI methodology allows replacement by similar establishments in same zone.

- Price collection operations (CPI base year 1991)
  - Prices collected directly at various points of sale:
    - La Paz: 2,176 price collection points
    - Santa Cruz: 1,601 price collection points
    - Cochabamba: 2,013 price collection points
    - El Alto: 1,345 price collection points
  - Approximately 15,540 price valuations are made per month.
  - Monopoly services have one reporter; price valuations take place once a month.
  - Rent prices investigated via direct household survey of 1,393 households, classified by zone, type of dwelling, and type of rent; sample rotated every four months.
  - Prices investigated daily for the first 28 business days of the month.

- CHS 2003/2004 design and basket for new CPI
  - Frame based on 2001 population and housing census.
  - Primary sample unit: conglomerations of dwellings; secondary units: census segments of ~45 dwellings.
  - Sample size: 9,770 dwellings (towns, other urban centers, and rural areas).
  - Sample size determined to achieve sampling errors of less than 10 percent for specified variables.
  - Preliminary basket from 2003–2004: 508 generic products representing 95 percent of household expenditure (according to COICOP); selection criteria included relative share in total household spending and frequency of purchase (5 percent or more of households).
  - HBS 2003/2004 will be used to update basket and weights; methodology to follow 1993 SNA and COICOP.

### 3.1.2 Timeliness and recording
- CPI processes carried out in accordance with a monthly timetable to guarantee dissemination on the first business day of the reference month in Actualidad Estadística and on the NSI website.

### 3.2 Assessment of source data — coverage and errors
- Response and nonresponse
  - Response rate for HBS 1990: 90 percent.
  - Percentage of non-responses in CPI price collection: 3 percent.
  - Final household consumption expenditure not covered by CPI basket (base year 1991): approximately 10 percent; amount distributed among selected products.
- Monitoring and validation
  - Processing system assigns special codes to identify missing prices and causes (seasonal product, definitive absence, temporary absence).
  - CPI processing programs generate historical price reports; flagged prices are validated by price collectors with horizontal and vertical analysis; outliers verified through supervision visits.
  - Processing programs for CPI (base year 1991) do not include calculations of relative errors; design of prices sample was not based on analysis of relative errors.

- Recommendations (coverage and sampling error monitoring)
  - Introduce improvements in CPI processing system to monitor coverage and reasons for nonresponse by product/commercial establishment, including:
    - proportion of prices actually collected
    - proportion of imputed prices
    - reasons for imputation
    - proportion of unexplained atypical data
    - proportion of codes substituted because of quality changes
  - Include calculation of standard errors in the price relatives from one month to the next, by type of commercial establishment, to help periodically assess sample sizes by item and establishment type.

### 3.3 Statistical techniques — compilation and adjustments

- Compilation practices and imputation
  - Indices for individual products are calculated using a simple arithmetic average of price relatives series (short-term price relatives: current month vs previous month).
  - Instances of nonresponse: missing price attributed to immediately preceding period; no adjustments made for differences in quality.
  - Product replacements:
    - Varieties that disappear permanently are replaced after two consecutive months of missing prices by supervisors.
    - Reporting establishments replaced when they do not carry product in a number of observation periods, supply nongenuine data, cease to be representative, or close permanently. Replacements are establishments of similar size in the same area.
  - Data input module links reporter code with specific products, previous price, and collection code; facilitates identification of special situations (temporary absence, permanent absence, seasonal product, changes of specification, sale or promotion price).

- Methodological assessments and formulae
  - Conceptual framework for HBS 1990 and CPI (base year 1991) weights follow 1968 SNA guidelines.
  - Weights include household purchases in all markets, including informal market.
  - CPI weights exclude:
    - (1) imputed rent of owner-occupied dwellings
    - (2) financial transactions and investments
    - (3) construction of dwellings
  - Exclusions from recorded consumption: goods/services produced by household for own consumption (primary products, in-kind withdrawals/self-supply), grants in kind received, and social benefits.
  - Elementary-level formula: short-term price relative; method for integrating elementary indices to generic product: simple arithmetic mean of linked price relatives for specific products (may introduce bias due to sensitivity to extreme values).
  - Aggregation at subgroup, group, chapter, and general levels: Lowe formula (index with fixed weights: quantities consumed in 1990 and reference prices from subsequent period 1991 average). Weights for HBS 1990 were not valued at average prices for 1991.
  - National index: weighted average of indices of the four towns; weights fixed based on each town’s share of total national consumption expenditure according to HBS 1990.
  - Index weights have not been updated in the past 16 years.
  - Monthly historical series for national index starts in 1935; coefficients will be established to chain new CPI series with prior series.

- Recommendations (statistical techniques and quality adjustments)
  - Include imputed rentals of owner-occupied dwellings in new CPI basket, in accordance with System of National Accounts.
  - Use geometric mean of short-term price relatives at the elementary level (specific products/establishment) for the new CPI.
  - Value the new basket of goods and services at reference period prices for the new CPI; update the new basket using CPI variations between the two periods.
  - Introduce processing procedures to facilitate imputations for quality changes using implicit methods as needed (equivalent quality method, adjustments for changes in quantity, overlapping, linking or chaining), and imputation of the average for the class.
  - Introduce a calculation routine for imputing prices of missing specific products depending on reason for omission (seasonality, temporary shortage, reluctance, difficulty of interview, total unavailability).
  - Use the geometric mean of short-term price relatives observed in the field.

### 3.4 Validation of intermediate results
- Cross-checks and discrepancy analysis
  - A posteriori comparisons are made with corresponding products of the PPI.
  - Atypical variations in the index are assessed; specific products and reporting units contributing to variations are identified; both reference period and historical trend are analyzed; comparisons drawn between establishments; analysis supplemented by press information; discrepancies verified and reasons explained.
  - Discrepancies in price variations between towns are assessed at subgroup, group, chapter, and general levels.

### 3.5 Revision studies
- Current practice
  - CPI figures are final when first published.
  - No routine studies are made to investigate sources of errors in the data.
  - Periodic revisions of weights are not analyzed to determine effects of substitution bias on the CPI.

- Recommendations (revision analysis and testing)
  - Compare the two baskets (1990 and 2003/2004), assess changes in consumption structure, and evaluate their impact at the general level and for classes.
  - During testing period for the new CPI, process both indicators (old and new) simultaneously; weight month-to-month price changes of coinciding items; calculate aggregate class, group, division, and general changes; analyze and explain differences.

### 4 Serviceability — periodicity, timeliness, consistency

- Periodicity and timeliness
  - Periodicity follows GDDS recommendations and complies with SDDS requirements.
  - CPI compilation begins in first week of the month and ends on the last business day of the reference month; CPI published not later than the first day of the following month.

- Internal consistency
  - CPI estimates use various classifications: (1) type of expenditure; (2) transportable vs nontransportable products; (3) national accounts classification system.
  - National indicator calculated by aggregating indices of various towns; aggregated indices across classifications are the same.

- Time consistency and historical chaining
  - Current CPI series began in March 1992 and has been published monthly since.
  - Series of the general index has been chained with prior national series since 1935.
  - Formula for chaining with the CPI (base year 1966) is published in methodological documents.

- Reconciliation with other statistics
  - CPI results are reconciled with PPI for products appearing in both.

*Source: _cr07283 - 2.3       Classification/sectorization*

### 4.3 Revision policy and practice

### 4.3 Revision policy and practice

### Revisions: policy and practice
- CPI figures are not subject to revision following their publication.
- The household income and expenditure survey, which provides the source data for selection of the basket and weights for the CPI, is conducted at intervals of more than ten years.
- At the time of disclosure, users are told that the information is final and not subject to modification.
- The document entitled Metodología del Cambio de Año Base (Methodology for the Change in Base Year) compares the baskets for 1966 and 1991 and analyzes the major changes occurring at the level of coinciding groups.
- Recommendation: Include in the methodological document on the new CPI an analysis of the differences between the two baskets and their weights and the results of the analyses carried out.

### 5. Accessibility

### 5.1 Data accessibility — presentation and dissemination
- The CPI is readily accessible to the public and is disseminated either in published form or through direct services to users.
- The CPI methodology (1991) has been circulated as an NSI publication entitled Sistema de Metadatos - Índice de Precios al Consumidor (Metadata System – Consumer Price Index).
- The NSI publishes the monthly CPI in tabular and graphic forms consistent with internationally accepted presentations. Publications include:
  - monthly CPI series and the changes compared with the month prior to the reference month,
  - changes compared with December of the preceding year,
  - and changes compared with the same month of the previous year.
- Indicators are published by town and for the country as a whole, at the various levels of aggregation. Other classifications are also presented, such as transportable goods and nontransportable goods.
- Each month, the publication Actualidad Estadística includes an analysis of trends for the current period, detailed estimates, and chronological series; results are presented so as to facilitate dissemination in the press and audiovisual media.
- Recent data and longer time series can be consulted in the NSI electronic database. More comprehensive and/or detailed statistics are disseminated in hardcopy and/or in electronic format.
- The statistics are released punctually, in accordance with a preannounced schedule. The preannounced schedule for dissemination is posted on the CBB website.
- The CPI estimates, both preliminary and definitive, are presented to the Macroeconomic Group, which meets periodically to monitor macroeconomic developments; this practice can, in some cases, produce early access to the information, but it does not interfere with its dissemination to the public.
- Apart from routinely disseminated statistics, special requests from public or private institutions and private individuals are met. Consultation documents are available in the NSI library. The availability of additional statistics and the procedures to obtain them are publicized on the NSI website.

### 5.2 Metadata accessibility — documentation and level of detail
- The metadata for HBS 1990 and the CPI 1991 are published in printed documents and on the NSI website. These documents provide information on:
  - the conceptual framework,
  - areas of study,
  - classification systems,
  - data sources,
  - statistical techniques used for the compilation of the CPI,
  - data collection instruments,
  - calculation formula,
  - the basket, and its weights.
- The methodology and results of CHS 2003/2004 are also available on the NSI website and in the library and the NSI public relations office.
- The NSI website contains a section on its economic research and publications, including:
  - Sistema de Metadatos Indice de Precios al Consumidor,
  - Encuesta de Presupuestos Familiares 1990 (Household Budget Survey 1990),
  - and Encuesta Continua a los Hogares 2003–2004 (Continuous Household Survey 2003–2004).
- The methodological documents may be consulted at the NSI library. Reference documents used in formulating the indicator, such as ILO’s Consumer Price Index Manual, the 1968 SNA, the 1993 SNA, and classification systems (COICOP, ISIC, CPC), may also be consulted at the library.
- Levels of detail are adapted to the needs of the intended audience via the website and library access.

### 5.3 Assistance to users — contacts, response times, and catalogs
- The CPI metadata published on the NSI website identifies the person responsible for the indicator, his/her mailing address, telephone number, and e-mail address for contact regarding any question or request about the CPI.
- Information requests sent in writing or by e-mail are answered within three days, in accordance with NSI rules.
- For formal requests that elicit responses requiring signatures of NSI authorities, more time is needed.
- Catalogues of publications, documents, and other user services are available at the NSI Customer Service Office and on the NSI website, and are updated periodically. Charges for statistical products and services are publicized, and ordering assistance is provided.

### Table 2 (Data Quality Assessment Framework, July 2003): Selected findings and plans for improvement for Price Statistics (CPI and PPI)

### Overall assessment highlights (selected)
- Staff, computing, and financing resources are adequate for current tasks, but not for needed work to improve the quality of the CPI.
- There is no formal mechanism to consult data users on their information needs. Ad-hoc efforts are made to maintain the relevance of the CPI. The NSI has currently launched meetings to inform government institutions about the change of base year, the updating of weights in the CPI, and to identify their information needs.
- Internal government access to data before their release to the public is made known to the public on the IMF’s DSBB and on the CBB website, but not on the NSI website.
- The CPI follows the 1968 SNA household consumption concept. Nevertheless, an HBS (2003–2004), used to establish the new CPI weights, follows the 1993 SNA. The new CPI will adopt the recommendations of the 1993 SNA and CPI Manual 2004 (short-term).
- The current CPI basket of goods and services is classified using the 1968 SNA classification of consumption expenditure of households by purpose. The new CPI basket will be classified using the COICOP (medium-term).
- Response rates to price surveys, editing rates, and sampling and nonsampling errors are not calculated. The efficiency of the new CPI sampling techniques will be improved through assessing CPI data source to prices surveys (short-term).
- Procedures for imputation and adjustment for nonresponse are not sound. New products are not introduced as they gain market share. Imputed rentals of owner-occupied dwellings are missing. Weights have not been updated for 16 years. The weight reference period (1990) and price reference period (1991=100) are not the same.
- Periodic weight revisions are not undertaken to determine the bias of the CPI. The CPI bias may increase as the weights become out of date.
- Weights, product replacements, and biases are not revised. Studies are conducted but not made public.
- A government policy advisory committee is provided with data that may or may not have been disseminated to the public. However, this practice does not affect the prescheduled release.

### PPI compilation — resources and operational findings
- The NSI has been responsible for compiling the producer price index (PPI) since 1966.
- The DEIE comprises three units: (1) External Sector Records, Statistics, and Indicators; (2) Price Records, Statistics, and Indicators (UREIP); and (3) Economic Activity Statistics and Indicators (UEIAE).
- The UREIP is responsible for compiling indicators of producer prices, consumer prices, construction costs, average wages, salaries, and employment. It has a head of unit, six full-time specialists, and 25 regular employees compiling the PPI.
- The UEIAE, responsible for collecting prices from producers, coordinates QMS field operations.
- To conduct the QMS, 20 collectors and four regional supervisors are hired quarterly to conduct field work for one month.
- Turnover among field personnel is rather high, with each collector being given an average of three contracts.
- For each specialist and one of every two field supervisors a computer is assigned. The equipment does not have sufficient capacity. The application used for data entry and indicator calculation, MS Excel, is somewhat limited.
- Vehicles are not assigned for collecting QMS data. There is a transportation budget for collectors and field supervisors, which covers four bus fares per collector per day.
- Budget planning is subject to the NSI’s Annual Operating Plan, and the amount allocated for the PPI is the same from one year to the next. There is no budget allocation for the supervision of data collection in the country’s hinterland.
- Using available resources, specialists have instituted procedures for planning and evaluating field operations and generating a price database. A schedule of visits by geographical area is drawn up each quarter. Data collection is completed within one month, with two additional weeks to generate a price database, and three weeks to process, analyze, and publish the indicator.

### PPI recommendations (as stated)
- (1) Make the necessary improvements for PPI compilation (expand coverage of economic activities and products, produce monthly data, adjust timetable to reflect data disclosure standards, improve data collection processes, standardize quality control for field operations, and develop a new processing system);
- (2) allocate the necessary resources to the units responsible for the indicator (DEIE and UREIP);
- (3) allocate resources for conducting a comprehensive survey.

*Source: _cr07283 - 4.3 Revision policy and practice*

### 0.3       Relevance

### 0.3       Relevance

### Relevance and practical utility of existing statistics
- The PPI is the indicator of price trends in the manufacturing sector, an advance indicator of inflation, and widely used as a deflator in the system of national accounts.
- Main methodological aspects, results, and applications of the PPI are available on the NSI website.
- No formal mechanism has been established, with the participation of various economic sectors, for discussions on the requirements for producer price information.
- The NSI responds to user requests (by phone or electronic mail) for information on average prices and explanations of indices and changes; it frequently receives requests from public entities, the press, national bodies, students, and national and foreign analysts.
- Queries from the communications media are forwarded to a press office and subsequently handled by the UREIP.
- Recommendation: Establish a formal mechanism, with the participation of users, to consult them on their information needs, clear up doubts regarding the interpretations, applications, and limits of the PPI, and inform them of any methodological improvements incorporated in the indicator.

### Other quality management
- NSI Strategic Institutional Plan 2005–2009 defined the mission: “To produce and disseminate useful, timely, and reliable official statistics on the national situation,” and identified core principles of service, integrity, quality, confidentiality, and organization.
- These principles are diffused throughout NSI documents and publications, orientation programs for new staff, and methodological documents and manuals for QMS price collectors and supervisors.

Processes to monitor quality of the statistical program
- Procedures established for PPI quality control across stages: planning and supervision of price collection, inputting of collected prices, analysis of prices by establishment for four or more consecutive periods, comparison of prices and changes across establishments, and reviews and analysis of changes from one month to the next by product.
- Supervisors organize and distribute work to price collectors and verify visits to reporting establishments have been carried out per schedule and standards; supervisors and price collectors identify errors and inconsistencies, clear doubts, and correct omissions.
- Monitoring systems track establishments assigned to each price collector and their visit schedule; a processing system is used to monitor lack of responses by product and by establishment and causes for nonresponse (seasonal product, refusal, temporary closure, change in quality).
- In 2004, the UREIP received advice from an international expert on improving the quality of data collected and index compilation methods.
- Recommendations:
  - (1) Design a processing system that facilitates monitoring of missing prices by product/establishment, and the reasons therof; and
  - (2) keep a record of those reasons, so that the information can be used for continuous PPI quality improvement.

Processes to deal with quality considerations in planning the statistical program
- The NSI’s National Accounts Directorate (NAD) has begun changing the national accounts base year.
- Plan: update the base year and the PPI weights in accordance with 1993 SNA.
- PPI coverage will be expanded to include other relevant activities and products, such as crude oil and natural gas, as well as electricity, gas, and water utilities.

### Assurances of integrity

Professionalism and impartiality
- The NSI is an autonomous entity responsible for compiling and presenting the PPI; criteria applied are strictly technical and compilers are independent in selection of data sources and processing methods.
- The Director General of the NSI is authorized to present the PPI.
- Title VII, Chapter II, Article 26 of DL 14100: officials assigned to statistical work in all SNIE institutions are statistical personnel and governed by relevant decree-law provisions on the National System of Administrative Careers and Personnel.
- Specialists compiling short-term economic indicators have over ten years’ experience; UREIP specialists have followed specialized international courses provided by organizations such as Spain’s National Statistics Institute and ECLAC.

Choices of sources, techniques, and dissemination
- Selection of data sources, methodologies, concepts, and statistical procedures for PPI are in accordance with international standards and adopted by the NSI based on strictly statistical considerations.
- Results are disseminated solely on statistical considerations; methodological documentation is prepared and made available to users.

Commenting on erroneous interpretation and misuse
- The NSI closely monitors media coverage and, in the event of erroneous interpretations, provides timely public clarifications using available means.

Transparency
- The NSI website contains economic research and publications, including major methodological aspects relating to compilation of the PPI for manufacturing (base year 1990).
- The government does not have access to information prior to its release to the public.
- The methodological document on the PPI (base year 1990) states the indicator is published two months after the end of the quarter and identifies the publications in which it will appear. A timetable for presentation is not published.
- Publication dates are indicated in Calendario Annual de Estadísticas Económicas published on the CBB website.
- Title V, Chapter I, Article 20 of DL 14100 states statistical publications must indicate original sources.
- Methodological documents, tables and graphs, Actualidades Estadísticas, and press releases bear the NSI’s name and logo; NSI authorizes full or partial reproduction provided the data source is cited.
- At the beginning of the current PPI series (base year 1990), importance and scope were publicized through seminars for journalists and media interviews.

Ethical standards
- By-laws governing NSI personnel set regulations on relationships of public servants, rights, duties, prohibitions, incompatibilities, and disciplinary measures; Article 28(c) of Law 1178 has been incorporated into the by-laws.
- Personnel are informed of by-laws during orientation; methodological documents and manuals emphasize discretion and confidentiality.

### Methodological soundness

Concepts and definitions
- Concepts and definitions used in the PPI are generally in line with the 1968 SNA and the Producer Price Index Manual, 2004.
- The PPI basket (base year 1990) is disaggregated to monitor manufacturing price trends for 35 branches (4 digits), groups (3 digits), and divisions (2 digits) in accordance with ISIC Rev. 2.
- Other special classifications prepared in areas such as agroindustry and other manufacturing industries; indices classified by economic use.
- Products at each establishment are described in terms of quality, unit of measurement, and presentation; system is dynamic allowing specification replacement over time.
- Prices measured are producers’ factory-gate selling prices, excluding distribution markups and product taxes (VAT or other similar deductible tax billed to the purchaser).
- For some groups, selling prices are not monitored; price changes for main products are imputed for printing offices, editorial and related industries, plastic products, glass and glass manufactured products, structural metallic products, jewelry, and similar articles.
- Recommendations:
  - (1) Adopt the international recommendations in the 1993 SNA and in the Producer Price Index Manual, 2004, particularly to determine the weights, which should be linked to the market output of finished goods; market output should be valued at significant prices and include changes in inventory and production for own final use; and
  - (2) estimate indices by type of economic activity (4 digits, ISIC Rev. 3) and for the main products, depending on the extent to which the country has adapted the CPC.

Scope
- Bolivia’s PPI relates to manufacturing and does not cover agriculture, forestry, mining, energy, water, construction, commercial services, and other services.
- Producer price indices measure changes in selling prices on the domestic market; coverage limited to goods produced by 35 branches (four digits), 125 generic products (six digits), and 218 specific manufacturing products.
- Product selection aimed to cover at least 70 percent of gross output value of each branch, as done in the 1990 industrial survey.
- Sample includes manufacturing companies located in all departments (except Pando), and accounted for at least 75 percent of the output value of the product investigated.
- Small enterprises (incorporated or not) and illegal markets are not included.
- Methodological notes (base year 1990) are explicit on coverage of weights and prices investigated, but limitations compared with 1968 SNA or 1993 SNA scope are not mentioned.
- Recommendation: Expand the coverage of the PPI so that it represents a larger proportion of the total production of resident establishments and companies, initially including, in addition to manufacturing, other relevant activities and products, such as crude oil and natural gas, as well as electricity, gas, and water utilities.

Classification/sectorization
- Establishments classified by main economic activity in accordance with ISIC Rev. 2; country-specific code derived from six-digit breakdown of ISIC Rev. 2 used for generic products.
- Price indices are calculated for primary economic activity of establishments and companies, but not for groups of products.
- Recommendation: Adopt the 1993 SNA guidelines, specifically ISIC Rev. 3, to classify main economic activity, and the CPC or a compatible national classification to classify products.

Basis for recording
- Value of output, used as a weighting variable, is expressed in producer prices; prices collected are producers’ factory-gate selling prices excluding VAT and similar deductible taxes and distribution margins—consistent with international practices.
- Weighting variable (value added) is derived from national accounts where transactions are recorded at market prices and on an accrual basis.
- Transactions between establishments within the same enterprise are recorded on a gross basis.

### Accuracy and reliability

Source data
- PPI for manufacturing is based on a quarterly survey of a sample comprising 313 establishments, selected from 1,300 companies investigated in the 1990 industrial survey.
- 1990 survey supplemented with administrative records and estimates of national accounts for 1990.
- Beginning in 2002, a statistical gap appears in annual surveys of companies and establishments, complicating addition of new establishments and products.
- PPI comprises 35 branches (four digits), 125 generic products (six digits), and 218 specific products.
- According to national accounts estimates, the branches researched accounted for 85 percent of the manufacturing value added for 1990.
- Prices compiled quarterly, based on data from 313 establishments reporting monthly prices for 633 specific products.
- Sample is stratified and targeted: mandatory inclusion stratum for establishments with over 15 employees; random stratum for establishments with 5–14 employees.
- Sample framework is not updated, limiting suitable sampling methods; NSI began preparing a directory containing data from Inland Revenue and Fundaempresa (current membership of 14,000 businesses).
- Recommendations:
  - (1) Continue updating the directory of businesses and establishments, which will serve as the framework for sampling designs;
  - (2) expand PPI coverage in terms of branches studied, to guarantee coverage representing over 80 percent of value added; within each branch selected, the survey should focus on products that account for at least 80 percent of output value (supply and use tables); the PPI basket should be broken down so that the index can be estimated at the three- and four-digit levels;
  - (3) stratify the framework of businesses and establishments and use scientific techniques of random sampling to select businesses and establishments in the small and medium-sized strata; and
  - (4) periodically evaluate the sample size by branch and by product.

Source data consistency and timeliness
- Source data for PPI selection of basket and weights taken from 1990 Annual Industrial Survey conducted per international recommendations and supplemented by national accounts estimates following 1968 SNA.
- Prices researched are producers’ factory-gate selling prices; transactions between establishments of same enterprise are not recorded.
- Quarterly timetable:
  - (1) price investigations begin in the second week of the month following the reference quarter and prices are collected on the 15th or nearest business day of each month in the quarter;
  - (2) data are recorded, and processing is completed in the six weeks following the reference quarter; and
  - (3) the PPI is published two months after the end of the quarter and is distributed to internal and external users.
- Recommendation: Adjust the processes for collecting and processing the PPI so that the index can be estimated monthly and with the timeliness required for disseminating this type of indicator (1-2 months after the end of the reference month).

Assessment of source data quality
- PPI response rate is approximately 95 percent for establishments and 90 percent for specific products.
- Lack of responses by product and establishment, and causes (seasonal product, definitive absence, temporary absence, change in quality), can be monitored by using an indicator spreadsheet; this information is used solely for decisions to replace products or establishments for calculation purposes, not for changing the design.
- Validation includes horizontal consistency (analyzing establishment data over time for atypical changes) and vertical consistency (comparing changes across establishments).
- PPI processing program generates reports showing outlying prices and variations; analysts evaluate, validate, and supervisors verify outliers; confirmed or modified prices are recorded with observations.
- External data and adjustments in prices of refined petroleum products are validated using data from the Superintendency of Hydrocarbons.
- The activities comprising the PPI basket account for 13.9 percent of GDP.
- Recommendation: Introduce improvements in the PPI processing system to monitor coverage and the reasons for nonresponse by product/commercial establishment, such as: proportion of prices actually collected, proportion of imputed prices, reasons for imputation, proportion of unexplained atypical data, and proportion of codes substituted because of quality changes.

*Source: _cr07283 - 0.3*

### 3.3       Statistical       techniques

### 3.3       Statistical       techniques

### Data compilation and validation (primary data level)
- Price collection forms have a preassigned reporter’s code; coding is performed by the supervisor and verified by the specialist.
- Data input module facilitates:
  - addition of new establishments,
  - assignment of related products,
  - creation of printed forms from the database.
- Validation at collection:
  - collectors verify any increases or decreases of more than 20 percent using a price list and discuss causes with the reporter;
  - forms include a section for reporters to explain causes and describe changes in brand, unit of measurement, or origin.
- Missing prices:
  - The percentage of missing prices is about 10 percent (temporary or definitive absence, non-response, seasonality).
  - Missing prices are imputed; the price change for similar specific products is applied.
  - Imputation is performed using analysis; no automated program is used.
  - When similar products show minor changes, the price for the previous month is repeated.
- Treatment of disappearing products:
  - Specific products that permanently disappear from an establishment are replaced in the same establishment by a specific product with similar characteristics.
  - Specific products that disappear permanently from the market are replaced, after two consecutive months of missing prices, by the specialist responsible for validating, analyzing, and calculating the indicator.

Recommendations:
- (1) Include in the new processing system a calculation procedure for imputing specific product prices where they are missing; use of this procedure will depend on the reason for omission (seasonality, temporary shortage, reluctance, difficulty of conducting the interview, total unavailability).
- (2) Impute the geometric mean of short-term price relatives for similar products (same establishment, same generic product, same type of activity).

### Other statistical procedures (weights, formulas, and aggregation)
- Basket weights:
  - Based on the gross value of output at producer prices from the annual Industrial Survey conducted by the NSI in 1990.
  - Weights for branches (ISIC Rev. 2, four digits) are based on value added estimated by the system of national accounts for 1990, calculated in accordance with international recommendations and compliant with the guidelines of 1968 SNA.
- Elementary level formula:
  - The formula used to calculate the indices at the elementary level (specific products/establishment) is the short-term price relative, comparing current month to the previous month.
- Integration to generic product level:
  - Method used is the simple arithmetic mean of the linked price relatives for specific products; noted that the arithmetic mean can introduce biases because it is affected by extreme values.
- Aggregation above generic product:
  - Calculation at aggregated branch, group, division, and general levels is based on the Laspeyres formula.
- Base year and weights:
  - The base year for PPI prices is 1990.
  - The weights are valued at the prices for the index reference period and have not been updated in 16 years, leading to substantial loss in representativeness.
- Series combination:
  - There are PPI series combined with the earlier series of the index (PPI base year 1985) at the general level by branch (four digits).

Recommendations:
- (1) Update the PPI basket and weights as part of the program to change the base year for the national accounts.
- (2) Use the geometric mean for short-term price relatives for calculating indices at the elementary level (specific products/establishment).
- (3) Combine the PPI series (base year 1990) with the new PPI, in accordance with the recommendations of the Producer Price Index Manual, 2004.

### 3.4 Assessment and validation of intermediate data and statistical outputs

### Validation against other sources
- Intermediate PPI results are validated against CPI results; export price indices are validated against products appearing in both indices.
- Trends in “relative prices” are analyzed by comparing changes at the aggregate level for different types of activities.

### Investigation of discrepancies and outliers
- The PPI specialist:
  - validates raw data,
  - reviews and compares two successive periods (t and t-1),
  - evaluates outlying prices,
  - checks reporters’ explanations,
  - makes necessary adjustments and checks their impact.
- Analysis is supplemented by other price data sources and the press; discrepancies are analyzed and reasons explained.
- Discrepancies in price variations between levels of disaggregation and PPI classification (economic use; agro-industry and other manufacturing industries) are analyzed.

### 3.5 Revision studies

- Recurrent price fluctuations trigger investigations into collection errors; necessary adjustments are made and the indicator is recalculated.
- For this reason, the PPI is considered preliminary for two or three consecutive periods.
- No periodic reviews assess how changes in the weighting structure may affect the PPI.

Recommendations:
- (1) Assess the impact of imputing missing prices on PPI estimates at the aggregate level.
- (2) Document PPI revisions, indicating the reason for them and their impact on the index at the various aggregation levels.
- (3) Assess the changes noted in the weighting structure of the manufacturing industry PPI for the various aggregation levels.
- (4) During the testing period for the new PPI, process both indicators simultaneously, weight the changes in prices of overlapping products from one month to the next, calculate the aggregate change for each basket, compare results, determine the impact of the changes at the various levels of aggregation, analyze the results, and explain the differences.

### 4. Serviceability

### Periodicity and timeliness
- Current periodicity:
  - Prices for the PPI are collected and compiled quarterly, not consistent with SDDS and not compliant with GDDS.
  - Recommendation: Compile the PPI on a monthly basis, in compliance with the SDDS and the GDDS.
- Timeliness:
  - PPI compilation begins in the second week after the end of the reference quarter.
  - The PPI is published ten weeks after the end of the reference quarter; SDDS and GDDS requirements are not observed.
  - Recommendation: Disseminate the monthly PPI no later than one month after the close of the reference month (SDDS) or no later than two months after the close of the reference month (GDDS).

### Consistency
- Internal consistency:
  - PPI estimates are performed for classifications by economic activity, economic use, and sector; aggregated indices for these classifications are the same.
- Time consistency:
  - Current PPI series began in January 1991 and has been published regularly every quarter since then.
  - The new series was chained with the previous series (base year 1985) at the general level and for overlapping activities; chained series published in the NSI Statistical Yearbook 2003.
- Cross-framework consistency:
  - PPI results are reconciled with CPI results for products appearing in both indices.

### Revision policy and practice
- No program for regular updating of the PPI; the study used for basket selection and weights is conducted at intervals exceeding ten years.
- Figures remain preliminary for a period exceeding that indicated in the PPI metadata (two to three periods).

Recommendations:
- (1) Standardize the PPI revision cycle in accordance with best practices: the indices should be preliminary only for one period, so that when data for the next period are published, the data published in the preceding period are confirmed or revised.
- (2) In cases where numbers are revised to correct identified errors, inform the public about it.
- Identification of revisions:
  - The letter (p) denotes preliminary data in PPI tables.
  - When data are revised, the letter is removed but it is not explicitly stated that the data have been revised; significant revisions are explained in a footnote.
  - Recommendation: Publications should identify the data that have been revised.
- Studies of revisions:
  - No periodic reviews are carried out to assess effects of changes in weighting structure.
  - When adjustments are made to compensate for collection errors or missing prices, explanations are provided and corrected data are clearly identified.

Recommendations:
- (1) Use a footnote to indicate the coverage of both the preliminary data and the revised data.
- (2) Perform comparative analysis of discrepancies between original and final data, and record a series of such discrepancies to assess the reliability of preliminary data, based on their coverage.
- (3) Document these analyses.

### 5. Accessibility

### Data accessibility (presentation, dissemination, schedule, equal access)
- Presentation:
  - The quarterly PPI is published in table format including: quarterly series by branch; economic use; sector; changes from the quarter preceding the reference quarter; cumulative changes; and changes compared with the previous year.
- Dissemination media and format:
  - Results at the general level and by branch are published in the NSI yearbook, available in print and on CD-ROM.
  - The yearbook is available on the NSI website and in pdf format.
  - More disaggregated outputs are produced in response to user requests.
- Release schedule:
  - An annual release calendar of economic statistics is posted on the CBB website, showing publication dates for the quarterly PPI (May, August, November, and February).
  - The Press Office sends tables to external users; data are available at the NSI library; special requests handled by e-mail, in writing, or by telephone.
- Simultaneous availability:
  - No government officials outside the NSI have access to the information prior to public release.
- Non-routine data:
  - Special requests from public or private institutions or individuals are met; reference documents are available at the NSI library; availability and procedures are publicized on the NSI website.

### Metadata accessibility
- Documentation:
  - PPI metadata (base year 1990) for the manufacturing industry are published in print and on the NSI website, containing the conceptual framework, areas of study, classification systems, data sources, statistical techniques, data collection instruments, calculation formula, basket, and weights.
- Level of detail:
  - NSI website contains economic studies and publications such as the Annual Survey of the Manufacturing Industry and the Metadata System for the Industrial Manufacturing Producer Price Index.
  - Reference documents available at the library include the ILO’s Consumer Price Index Manual, the 1968 SNA, the 1993 SNA, and classification systems (COICOP, ISIC, CPC).

### Assistance to users
- Contact points:
  - The PPI Metadata System on the NSI website identifies the person responsible for the indicator with mailing address, telephone number, and e-mail address.
  - Requests submitted in writing or by e-mail are processed within three days per NSI procedure; formal requests requiring official signatures need more processing time.
- Catalogues and charges:
  - Catalogues of publications, documents, and user services are available at the NSI Customer Service Office and on the NSI website and are updated periodically.
  - Charges for statistical products and services are publicized and ordering assistance is provided.

### Key numeric and factual points (preserved exactly)
- Percentage of missing prices: about 10 percent.
- Threshold for collector verification: more than 20 percent.
- Base year for PPI prices: 1990.
- Weights have not been updated in 16 years.
- PPI considered preliminary for two or three consecutive periods.
- PPI compilation published ten weeks after the end of the reference quarter.
- Recommendation for SDDS timeliness: monthly PPI no later than one month after the close of the reference month (SDDS) or no later than two months after the close of the reference month (GDDS).
- Current PPI series began in January 1991.
- Chained with previous series (base year 1985); chained series published in the NSI Statistical Yearbook 2003.
- Quarterly PPI publication months: May, August, November, and February.
- PPI basket size noted as 125 items.
- Share of value added not covered by the index: 86 percent.
- NSI response time for written or e-mail requests: within three days.

*Source: _cr07283 - 3.3 Statistical techniques (Price Statistics: Producer Price Index).*

### 5.1  Data accessibility

### 5.1  Data accessibility

### Key findings on data dissemination
- Data only published in the annual yearbook. Quarterly dissemination has been suspended.
- An advance release calendar is available on the IMF’s DSBB and the CBB website, but not on the NSI website.
- The NSI will disseminate the advance release calendars on its website (short-term).
- Metadata accessibility: X
- Assistance to users: X

### Legal and institutional responsibilities (GFS)
- Government finance statistics (GFS) are collected, compiled, and disseminated by the Ministry of Finance (MOF).
- MOF responsibilities are supported by:
  - Law on the Organization of the Executive Branch (Law No. 3351 of February 21, 2006) and its regulation decree (Decree No. 28631 of March 09, 2006)
  - Law of Government Administration and Control (Law No. 1178 of July 20, 1990)
  - Decree that creates and establishes functions of the Fiscal Programming Unit (UPF) in the MOF (Decree No. 27372 of February 17, 2004)
  - Law of Budgetary Administration (Law No. 2042 of December 1, 2005)
  - Basic Norms of Budgetary System (Resolution No. 225558 of March 04, 2005)
  - Basic Norms of Integrated Accounting (Resolution No. 222957 of March 04, 2005)
  - Basic Norms of Public Credit
  - Law of Municipalities (Law No. 2028 of October 28, 1999)
  - Decree on the Creation of the Integrated System of Management and Administrative Modernization (SIGMA) (Decree No. 25875 of August 18, 2000) and the Decree on the Use of the SIGMA (Decree No. 26455 of December 19, 2001)
  - Organic Law of the Central Bank of Bolivia (CBB) (Law No. 1670 of October 31, 1995) and its Regulation for the Recording of Public and Private Debt (Directory Resolution No. 113/2003)
  - Decree-Law of the National System of Statistical Information (SNIE) (Decree-Law No. 14100 of October, 1976)
  - Law on Transparency and Access to Government Information (Decree No. 27329 of January 31, 2004)
  - Constitution of April 13, 2004
- The responsibility for GFS collection, compilation, and dissemination is shared by two MOF units:
  - Fiscal Programming Unit (UPF) (Articles 3 and 4 of Decree No. 27372; internal MOF manual of functions)
  - General Directorate of Accounting (GDA) (Article 43 of Resolution No. 222957)

### Recommendation (responsibility/coordination)
- Improve coordination between the two units of the MOF that share the responsibility of GFS compilation, to achieve comprehensive collection, compilation, and dissemination of GFS.

### Functions and systems relevant to GFS compilation
- Vice Ministry of Budget and Accounting responsibilities include:
  - Design and produce provisions, manuals, and procedures for the budget process
  - Preparation of budgetary classifications and central administration financial statements
  - Administration of the SIGMA
- Vice Ministry of Treasury and Public Credit responsibilities include:
  - Preparation and follow-up of fiscal and financial programming through consolidation of public sector cash flows (coordinated with CBB)
- Decree No. 27372 assigns the UPF within the Vice Ministry of Treasury and Public Credit to:
  - Collect and compile economic and financial information of public sector entities
  - Prepare fiscal programming via preparation, consolidation, and forecasting of public sector financial information
  - Guarantee consistency of fiscal programming with the general budget, balance of payments, national accounts, and financial system aggregates
  - Determine, monthly, the deficit/surplus of the public sector
  - Publish, periodically, fiscal information
  - Participate in discussions and negotiations with international organizations regarding fiscal programming
  - Analyze trends of revenues, expenses, and financing of public sector
  - Compile and disseminate monthly GFS, including data to meet the GDDS recommendations, and prepare fiscal analysis reports that include tables and graphics
  - Disseminate this information on the MOF website
- Law No. 2042 (Law of Budgetary Administration) provides general norms for the budgetary process; the fiscal year goes from January 1 to December 31.
- Resolution No. 225558: budgetary classifications prepared and approved by MOF every fiscal year; a single set of budget classifications is used for compilation, approval, and execution of public sector budget (institutional classification; resource classification by items; expense classification by object; classification of expense by function and purpose; classification by sources of financing; others).
- Resolution No. 222957 (Integrated Accounting System) key provisions:
  - Article 2: application to all public sector entities
  - Article 3: institutional structure of public sector
  - Article 9: concepts and definitions include budgetary, economic, financial, and net worth records
  - Article 13: SIGMA is the management system of the records indicated in Article 9
  - Article 21: basis of recording of resources (estimation, accrual, and received) and expenses (appropriation, commitment, accrual, and paid)
  - Article 28: structure of the Chart of Accounts
  - Article 43: GDA should prepare the GFS for the public sector
- Basic Norms of Public Credit:
  - Article 4: scope of application
  - Article 8: operating units in the MOF follow up and assess public credit operations
  - Article 11: CBB performs official recording of external public debt
  - Article 17: definition of public debt includes emission of securities, loans, accounts payable, and other debts
  - Article 18: definitions of domestic and external debt, and short-term and long-term debt
  - Article 20: management of public credit operations should be through the Debt Management and Financial Analysis System (DMFAS)
  - Article 49: DMFAS, under CBB control, should be linked to the integrated accounting system
- SIGMA (Decree 25875) comprises budgetary, accounting, treasury, public credit, and other subsystems and is the primary source for compilation of budgetary data and GFS.
- CBB responsibilities:
  - Article 21 of Organic Law No. 1670: CBB will keep records of public and private external debt; Article 43: CBB will publish periodically statistical and economic information
  - Directory Resolution No. 113/2003: CBB records new external debt in DMFAS and provides MOF summaries of public external debt 20 days after the end of the reference month
  - Article 21 of Directory Resolution No. 113/2003: publication of External Debt information through monthly, quarterly, and annual publications, and the CBB website
- DL No. 14100 (NSI):
  - Created NSI to collect, assess, process, and provide statistical information
  - Article 2: NSI comprised by individuals and public and private entities that carry out statistical activities or compile relevant data
  - Article 14: institutions in SNIE should not produce or disseminate statistical information without authorization of the National Council of Statistics

### Data sharing, coordination, and reconciliation
- Data sharing and coordination are adequate between:
  - UPF and Public Debt Directorate in MOF
  - UPF and the Fiscal and Monetary Sector (SSMF) and the External Sector (SSE) Deputy Management Offices of the Economic Policy Advisory Office (APEC) in the CBB
- Working arrangements ensure regular reconciliation of above-the-line data compiled by the UPF and financing data compiled by the Fiscal and Monetary Sector in the CBB.
- Financing data compiled by the UPF are used to validate or complement those compiled by the CBB.
- Similar procedures are applied for reconciliation of GFS with balance of payments.
- NSI uses GFS compiled by the UPF as an input to produce national accounts; a reconciliation exercise between these two macroeconomic datasets is not performed.
- Budgetary and accounting systems record online operations of the central administration and some decentralized public institutions, regional governments, large local governments and nonfinancial public corporations through the SIGMA.
- Some small local governments’ operations are recorded through the Integrated Accounting System (SINCON).6
- The rest of the nonfinancial public sector’s operations are recorded through their own management systems.

Recommendation (data sharing)
- Improve intra and inter-agency data sharing and coordination between the MOF and data-producing public entities.

### Confidentiality and legal protection of reporters’ data
- Confidentiality of data reported to the MOF is protected by:
  - Decree No. 14100 (Decree of the SNIE), Article 21: data and information collected by the SNIE are confidential, should be used exclusively for statistical purposes, and should not be disseminated on an individual way
  - Internal Regulation of the MOF, Articles 39 and 44:
    - Article 39: prohibited to provide confidential information and documentation without a management approval
    - Article 44: unauthorized disclosure of confidential information of the MOF or entities under its control could result in dismissal from the civil service
- Operational confidentiality measures:
  - Data sources are restricted to MOF staff who use the information for their statistical duties
  - Access to the MOF building where confidential data are stored is restricted
  - Computing systems have security systems, such as passwords

### Legal mandates and measures to ensure reporting
- Article 11 of Law No. 2042: all public entities and all units that receive transfers from the Treasury have the obligation to report to the MOF information used to follow up and assess the budget program and execution, and financing and debt.
- Budget execution information (revenue, expense and public investment data) should be reported to the MOF, specifically to the GDA, ten days after the end of the reference month.
- Public investment information should be reported to the Vice Ministry of Public Investment and External Financing.
- Failure to report data to the MOF carries sanctions:
  - Vice Ministry of Treasury and Public Credit will discontinue Treasury transfers and immobilize resources in the financial system
  - Vice Ministry of Budget and Accounting will not receive requests for budgetary modifications and the statements of payments
- Article 33: from the beginning of the financing operations, national, departmental, and municipal public entities should provide relevant information about these operations to the Vice Ministry of Treasury and Public Credit; debt (financing) includes direct and indirect debt, and short, medium, and long-term contingencies with several creditors; debt definition includes accrual expenses
- Articles 42 and 43, modified by the Law on Modification to the Law No.2042 (Law No. 2137 of October 23, 2000): central administration financial statements should be presented to the President for his consideration and to be submitted to the Congress 180 days after the end of the reference fiscal year; these financial statements will include information of operations performed until April 30 of the reference fiscal year
- Decree No. 23318–A (Regulation Decree on Responsibility for the Public Function), Article 5: public officials should perform activities transparently and (1) disseminate information before, during, and after execution of their acts and (2) provide processed information on demand
- Law No. 2028, Article 44: mandate to disseminate and publish, at least once a year, municipal reports with financial and nonfinancial information
- Resolution No. 222957:
  - Article 39: list of financial statements to be presented to the GDA (balances, statement of resources and expenses, statement of cash flows, statement of changes in the net worth, statement of budget execution for resources and expenses, and others)
  - Article 48: timing (three (3) months after the end of the reference year) for mandatory reporting of financial information to the GDA
- Directory Regulation No. 113/2003 annex requires:
  - From the MOF: timely reporting of the debt (loan) contract and legal provisions that authorize external financing to any public and private entity that used government guarantee
  - From private entities that obtain external financing with government guarantee: submission of a copy of debt contract and additional relevant documentation
  - From creditors: submission of statements and liquidations of the debt service

*Source: _cr07283 - 5.1  Data accessibility*

### 0.2       Resources

### 0.2       Resources

### 0.2.1 Staff, facilities, computing resources, and financing are commensurate with statistical programs

- Staffing structure involved in GFS collection, compilation, validation, and dissemination:
  - one general director
  - two directors
  - five professional specialists that include area responsible analysts and specialized professional analysts
  - 25 professional analysts
  - five nonprofessional analysts
- Some professional analysts work in departmental locations outside the UPF headquarters.
- Assessment of staff:
  - Number of staff, qualifications, and salaries are adequate to perform current statistical activities, but not to perform new collection, compilation, and dissemination tasks to improve GFS quality (for example, expansion of institutional and transaction coverage, and implementation of the GFSM 2001 analytical framework).
  - MOF staff participation in training: GFS courses at IMF headquarters, regional courses on GFSM 2001 methodology, internal mentoring, and domestic courses/seminars.
  - Staff turnover is manageable; most officials have been working in the UPF for more than five years.
  - Nonformal measures exist to encourage retention; salaries of managers and analysts are competitive with those in other public institutions.
- Computing and IT resources:
  - 38 personal computers
  - two mainframe
  - Internet access available; software such as Excel and Word adequate for current needs; each official has an individual computer.
  - UPF has an information and computing unit that created a system for aggregation and consolidation of nonfinancial public sector operations; this system is being updated.
  - The unit provides anti-virus, software updates, and keeps back-up of the GFS produced in the UPF.
- Physical facilities and financial resources are adequate for current GFS collection, compilation, and dissemination; funding may be insufficient if GFS activities increase.
- Recommendation:
  - Allocate additional personnel, computing, and financing resources to perform new collection, compilation, and dissemination tasks to improve GFS quality, such as an expansion of the institutional and transaction coverage of the GFS already compiled, and the implementation of the GFSM 2001 analytical framework.

### 0.2.2 Measures to ensure efficient use of resources are implemented

- Legal and assessment framework:
  - Article 9 of Law No.1178: System of Personnel Administration will determine working positions and financial means, and implement mechanisms for personnel assessment and training.
  - Annual assessment of staff performance conducted based on Article 27 of Law on Public Officials of October 27, 1999 (Law No. 2027). Assessment produces a report with ratings provided to the official and stored in personnel files; not used for promotion and salary increases.
  - The MOF has calculated costs or carried out budgeting exercises associated to the GFS compilation.

### 0.3 Relevance

- Monitoring of relevance and practical utility:
  - The MOF has not undertaken specific and formal actions, such as surveys, to obtain feedback on relevance and practical utility of fiscal data for analytical purposes and research or to identify new and emerging data requirements.
  - Authorities encourage UPF participation in statistical meetings and seminars and maintain close contacts with users to help ensure GFS meet users’ needs.
- Recommendation:
  - Make more systematic efforts to identify new and emerging data requirements and undertake surveys to obtain feedback about the relevance and practical utility of fiscal data.

### 0.4 Other quality management

- Focus on quality:
  - UPF mission and vision posted on MOF website indicating recognition of data quality and coordination with the CBB and other fiscal entities.
  - MOF aware that quality is cornerstone of budgetary, accounting, and statistical processes; recent efforts to collect, compile, and disseminate a more complete set of fiscal data with increased coverage.
  - Recognition of trade-offs such as timeliness versus accuracy.
- Monitoring quality:
  - Mechanisms in place include review and revision of preliminary data, periodic visits of UPF analysts to data providers, assessment of data collection and compilation processes, and cross-checking data sources.
- Planning for quality:
  - Medium term plans to improve data quality include actions to improve institutional coverage, statistical presentation of publications, additional training, and ongoing familiarization with the GFSM 2001 analytical framework.

### 1. Assurances of integrity

- Professionalism:
  - No specific laws formally guaranteeing professional independence of GFS, but no evidence of partiality; culture of professionalism recognized in MOF internal provisions and Law No. 2027.
  - Choice and tenure of managers based on an independent process; recruitment and promotion based on merit, competency, transparency (Articles 23 and 31 of Law No. 2027).
  - Professionalism promoted via training abroad, on-the-job training, methodological publications, lectures, and seminars.
- Statistical choices and dissemination:
  - No evidence of political interference in choice of data sources, statistical methods, or dissemination decisions; changes based on statistical reasons.
- Commenting on misuse:
  - MOF is empowered to respond to misinterpretation/misuse of fiscal data and will prepare and disseminate explanatory notes when needed.

### 1.2 Transparency

- Legal framework:
  - Broad legal framework for collection, compilation, and dissemination of fiscal data specified in relevant laws and available to the public.
- Internal access prior to release:
  - No official agency outside the MOF has access to data prior to publication.
  - Procedures for authorizing dissemination of GFS are made public only in a limited manner; the Minister or Vice Minister of the MOF authorizes release of GFS.
- Identification of products:
  - Fiscal data products disseminated through MOF website and Statistical Bulletin do not clearly identify producing agencies and data sources.
  - Recommendation: Clearly identify data sources and the entity in charge of data compilation in all statistical products.
- Advance notice of methodological changes:
  - Advance notice is not given to the public about major changes in methodology or other relevant changes that materially affect the GFS; no explanatory notes provided when changes are introduced.
  - Recommendation: Provide advance notice of all methodological and other relevant changes that materially affect the GFS.

### 1.3 Ethical standards

- Ethical framework:
  - Ethical standards contained in Law No. 2027, Chapter III, and Ministerial Resolution No. 1268 of October 13, 1999.
  - Articles cited: Article 12 (principles and ethical values), Article 13 (conduct policies and Ethical Code), Article 14 (prohibition on gifts), Article 17 (disciplinary regimen), Article 53 (declaration of goods and rents), Article 55 (Comptroller oversight). Article 38 of Ministerial Resolution No. 1268 establishes ethical norms for MOF officials.
- Awareness:
  - MOF staff is generally aware of ethical provisions regulating their work.

### 2. Methodological soundness

2.1 Concepts and definitions

- Analytical framework:
  - GFS concepts and definitions broadly consistent with GFSM 1986 analytical framework.
  - Authorities have not yet prepared a plan to migrate to GFSM 2001.
  - The GDA prepared bridge tables between budgetary/accounting national classifications and GFSM 2001 and compiles GFS for the IMF’s GFS Yearbook; the preparation of these bridge tables and GFS compilation are not coordinated or reconciled with data compiled by the UPF.
- Recommendation:
  - Develop a plan to migrate to the GFSM 2001 analytical framework.
  - Coordinate current GFS compilation using GFSM 2001 methodology by the GDA among relevant units and institutions involved in GFS compilation.

2.2 Scope

- Institutional coverage:
  - Institutional scope of the GFS covers partially units of the nonfinancial public sector and its subsectors (general government and nonfinancial corporations as defined by the authorities); not fully in line with GFS manual recommendations because subsectors of general government do not include consolidated accounts for the central government as recommended by GFSM 1986 or 2001.
  - For some decentralized units, operations (flows) reported to MOF are not available; UPF records only government transfers as revenue and expense for these units, assuming no deficit or surplus balances; other revenue sources (own resources, grants, disbursements) are not recorded.
- Local governments:
  - Data reported or collected include information of 130 municipalities, of a total of 329, which represent 70 percent of the total resources.
  - Information for the remaining 199 municipalities is estimated using government transfers (revenues) and distributed by expense categories using the expense structure of municipalities that report data.
- Domestic debt:
  - For domestic debt (stocks), data are not collected due to legislation constraints.
- Presentation and tables:
  - UPF presentation broadly follows Summary Table of Major Components in GFSM 1986; disseminated tables for consolidated general government and consolidated nonfinancial public sector follow formats of tables A and C.
  - No tables for functional classification of expenditures, financing by type of debt instrument (tables B and E), and debt data in UPF reports.
- Debt compilation:
  - Debt data, external and domestic, compiled and disseminated by the CBB.
  - External debt presented by creditor and subsectors; domestic debt presented by financial instrument, term, and currency and includes only securities issued by the Treasury.
  - Domestic debt data do not include local government debt, floating debt, fiscal tax certificates, and other securities such as deposit refund certificates.
  - General Directorate of Public Credit compiles domestic debt data for internal use.
- Recommendations:
  - (1) Expand the scope of institutions and transactions in the GFS to include comprehensive and detailed data of the operations of some decentralized agencies and local governments.
  - (2) Make special efforts to compile debt data of local governments.
  - (3) Expand coverage of domestic debt.

2.3 Classification/sectorization

- Sectorization approach:
  - UPF prepares sectorization at two levels:
    - (1) general government consolidating central government (as defined by the authorities), regional governments, local governments, and social security funds;
    - (2) nonfinancial public sector consolidating general government and several nonfinancial public corporations.
  - The consolidated central government sector (as defined by the authorities) consolidates treasury, some decentralized units, universities, and MOF units (e.g., Vice-Ministry of Public Investment and External Financing) but does not include social security funds and therefore does not follow international recommendations.
  - Regional government data include all regional/departmental (10 regional/departmental) governments.
  - Local government sector includes only 130 municipalities.
  - Social security fund sector includes data of three funds of a total of four funds that should be included: the National Fund of Health, the Petroleum Fund of Health, and the National Institute of Insurance of Health; the social security subsector does not present complete institutional coverage.
  - GFS shortcomings relative to GFS manuals:
    - (1) statistics on the consolidated central government are not prepared;
    - (2) statistics on the social security sector do not include detailed data of the Corporation of Military Social Insurance. (UPF only included expense data for pensions of the Corporation of Military Social Insurance; these pensions are paid using central government financial resources.)
- Classification issues (revenues, expenditures, financing, debt):
  - Revenue classification:
    - Current revenue includes tax revenue, sales of oil products, sales of other public corporations, current transfers, and other current revenue; capital revenue classified separately.
    - Departures from recommendations:
      - tax classification does not follow international recommendations;
      - taxes include royalties;
      - tax refunds are not subtracted;
      - other revenues include “repayment of loans,” an expense category;
      - other capital revenue does not include two categories of capital revenue currently classified as current revenue (“other capital revenue” and the part corresponding to capital revenue currently classified in other revenues).
  - Expenditure classification:
    - Current expenditure and capital expenditure.
    - Current expenditure broken down into personnel services, goods and services, external debt interest, domestic debt interest, current transfers, other current expenses, and expenses not identified.
    - Departures from recommendations:
      - personnel services include social assistance benefits;
      - interest includes commissions;
      - current transfers include tax refunds;
      - other current expenses include expense data by institutional units instead of economic categories;
      - expenditures do not include a net category, lending minus repayment, because repayment is included as revenue category.
    - A separate category for pensions is included with data disaggregated by current revenue and expenses; GFSM 2001 recommends compiling payments to pension funds as expense, specifically as compensation of employees.
  - Financing classification:
    - Net external credit includes disbursements, amortizations, interest not paid, arrears, HIPC debt relief, and others (including deposits of a nonfinancial public corporation and capitalizations).
    - Net domestic credit includes central bank, providers, floating debt, and others (including securities such as fiscal certificates, bonds of the pension administration funds, non current deposits, and others).
    - Floating debt includes the difference between expense on accrual basis and expense on a cash basis.
    - Currently, Bolivia has not arrears and interest not paid is zero.
  - Debt classification:
    - External debt classified by debtor and payer with breakdowns for nonfinancial public sector and financial public sector; MOF prepares external debt by creditors (international organizations and foreign governments).
    - No compilation of external debt by financial instrument, or domestic debt by debt holder.
  - Functional classification:
    - UPF does not compile a functional classification for expenditures; DGA compiles functional classification for GFS reporting to IMF’s GFS Yearbook.
- Recommendations: Adopt sectorization and classification systems recommended in the GFS manuals, including:
  - Compile and disseminate data for central government including budgetary, extrabudgetary, and social security operations.
  - Compile GFS for central government excluding data of the FNRD, which should be classified in the financial corporations sector.
  - Compile GFS for the social security sector, including detailed data of the Corporation of Military Social Insurance.
  - Reclassify royalties as other revenue item; commissions for interest as goods and services item; tax refunds as a revenue item; social assistance benefits as transfers to households; repayments as an expense item and present a net item, lending minus repayments; and payments for pensions as compensation of employee item.
  - Reclassify as other capital revenue two categories wrongly classified as current revenue, “other capital revenue” and the part corresponding to capital revenue in “other revenues.”
  - Collect and compile disaggregated data for some items included in expenses, such as “universities” and “others,” to obtain an adequate economic classification.
  - Classify tax revenues, financing, and debt by instrument, holder and maturity following the recommendations of the GFS manuals.

*Source: _cr07283 - 0.2       Resources*

### 2.4 Basis for recording

### _cr07283 - 2.4 Basis for recording

### Valuation of flows and stocks
- Market prices are recommended by the GFSM 2001 to value flows and stocks.
- Under GFSM 1986:
  - Domestic debt is recorded at face value (i.e., the undiscounted amount of principal to be repaid at the end of the contract).
  - External debt is not recorded at face value; recorded using nominal value (i.e., the amount that the debtor owes to the creditor at any moment and reflects the value of the instrument at creation and subsequent economic flows).
- Recommendation:
  - Value public external and domestic debt at face value if the GFSM 1986 methodology is used or at market prices if the GFSM 2001 methodology is used.
  - Nominal values can be shown as memorandum items.

### Basis and timing of recording
- The UPF compiles GFS on a mixed basis: revenue on a cash basis and expenditure and financing on a mixture of cash and noncash bases.
- Debt records:
  - Outstanding debt balances are recorded in the DMFAS using the original currency and converted to U.S. dollars using an exchange rate fixed for the reference period.
  - Disbursements are recorded at the date of the creditor’s disbursement.
  - Payments of the debt services are recorded at the date of the payment by the CBB.
- Recommendation: Compile GFS data on noncash and cash bases; both bases are relevant for policy analysis and should be consistent.

### Grossing/netting practices
- Some transactions that should be shown net (per GFSM 1986 and GFSM 2001) are shown gross (example: lending minus repayment).
- Tax refunds should be shown net within the corresponding tax category rather than as an expenditure.
- Recommendation:
  - Include tax refunds in the taxes, netted from the corresponding tax, if possible.
  - When using GFSM 1986 methodology, include lending minus repayment as an expenditure category.

### Data sources, coverage, and systems (Accuracy and reliability)
- Two-stage GFS compilation:
  - Stage 1: Area of Statistics and Consolidation (UPF) collects and compiles cash flows of the consolidated nonfinancial public sector from administrative systems (SIGMA, SINCON, some integrated public-unit systems) and UPF-developed collection systems.
  - Stage 2: Area of Analysis and Follow-up (UPF) adjusts cash data toward accrual recording, includes floating debt, and reconciles above-the-line GFS with below-the-line GFS from the CBB.
- Data systems are not integrated; no interphases to reconcile data, causing duplication of collection and compilation efforts.
- Recommendations:
  - Allocate financial, human, and computing resources to integrate and standardize data sources to improve consistency of GFS and reduce collection/compilation burden.
  - Expand institutional coverage of SIGMA to include information collected by SINCON and other financial systems.
- Main financing sources:
  - DMFAS covers domestic and external debt; shared by MOF and CBB.
  - CBB compiles and disseminates internal financing and debt.
  - Domestic financing data sources include: MOF Integrated Financial Information system of the Treasury; CBB Open Market Operation Manager Office; CBB-COIN accounting system for pension administration funds.

### Classification, timeliness, and source-data assessment
- Sectorization:
  - MOF uses two sectorization versions; UPF’s version is adjusted for GFS compilation and approximates GFS manuals.
  - Institutional classification levels: public administration; territorial administration; nonfinancial public corporations.
- Classification:
  - SIGMA, SINCON, and decentralized systems use budgetary classification and chart of accounts broadly aligned with GFSM 1986.
  - DMFAS uses classifications recommended in GFSM 1986 for debt compilation.
- Timeliness:
  - Article 11 of Law No. 2042 requires public units to report financial data to the DGA in the MOF with a ten day lag after the end of the reference month.
  - SIGMA and SINCON data are timely due to automation; for other units UPF has administrative procedures to cope with delays and improvements noted.
- Verification and assessment:
  - Verification procedures exist for SIGMA, SINCON, DMFAS; GDA has not assessed accuracy of reported data and is unaware of degree of misreporting.
  - Preliminary data are published when reasonably complete and replaced with final data when produced; status of data for each period is noted in disseminated GFS.

### Statistical techniques, adjustments, and reconciliation
- Compilation techniques used: derivation, consolidation, aggregation, valuation, currency conversion, balance indicators, bridge tables, and estimation methods are sound.
- Two-stage adjustments:
  - Stage 1: conversion tables between budgetary execution reports and “effective operation of cash” formats; conversion to “Government Finance Statistics” (cash basis).
  - Stage 2: adjustments to produce mixed-basis GFS (“Fiscal Programming” data), including moving above-the-line items toward accrual recording; increasing transaction coverage (deposits of nonfinancial corporations, some grants, resources of regional governments and universities); inclusion of securities, fiscal certificates, floating debt; compensating administrative recording delays; matching transfers between providers and recipients.
- Validation:
  - Budgetary data are validated against accounting data; banking statements are reconciled; cross-checking with CBB on deposit changes is performed.
  - Financing and debt stock data compiled from accounting systems are not fully validated against DMFAS.
  - All discrepancies between GFS and budgetary data and between budgetary and accounting series are investigated.
  - Procedures exist to investigate large fluctuations, classification, and sectorization errors; UPF-MOF and CBB make efforts to reconcile financial flow data with stock data.
- Recommendation: Document revision studies and analyses of revisions.

### Revisions, periodicity, and timeliness (Serviceability)
- Data collection and preliminary publication schedule:
  - Sources collected within two weeks after the end of the reference month; one additional week for cross-checking and validation; another week for adjustments and reconciliation with CBB financing data.
  - Preliminary data published first; final data published following revisions, generally in the next publication.
- Periodicity and timeliness meet GDDS recommendations for general government operations and central government debt.
- Revisions:
  - Revisions follow a regular schedule known by users; information is publicly disseminated.
  - Preliminary and final data are clearly identified in publications for flows and external public debt; both disseminated with the same detail and media.
  - Revision studies and analyses are undertaken but not made public.
- Recommendations:
  - Make the revision schedule known to the public.
  - Include explanatory notes of revisions in published tables and disseminate studies and analysis of revisions.

### Consistency and cross-dataset reconciliation
- Internal consistency:
  - Concepts, definitions, and classifications for sub-annual GFS are the same, ensuring dataset consistency.
  - MOF compiles financing data to reconcile fiscal and monetary data though CBB is responsible for financing compilation and dissemination.
- Historical consistency:
  - Consistent historical data published since 1990 for general government and nonfinancial public sector; some series available on MOF website; events affecting time series are annotated and published.
- Cross-framework reconciliation issues:
  - No efforts to reconcile GFS with national accounts despite MOF being main provider to NSI; discrepancies arise from differences in basis of recording and institutional coverage.
  - Monetary statistics and GFS are regularly reconciled; institutional coverage, exchange rate, and basis of recording for above-the-line data (MOF) and financing (CBB) are the same; changes in nonfinancial public sector deposits are cross-checked with depository corporations.
  - BOP and GFS use DMFAS but no formal reconciliation is undertaken by MOF and CBB; key variables needing reconciliation include external transfers and capital and external financing.
  - GFS on cash and noncash basis (UPF-MOF) and accrual basis (GDA-MOF) are not reconciled.
- Recommendation: Reconcile GFS with national accounts to ensure consistency.

### Accessibility and dissemination
- Presentation:
  - Disseminated GFS allow identification and comparison of major aggregates, but improvements recommended: note data sources and units in charge, harmonize table titles, include analytical text, spell out acronyms or include acronym list, include stock data such as domestic and external debt by sector.
  - Data disseminated on MOF website present coverage and detail set out in GFSM 1986 and are available for extensions in coverage and detail.
  - Recommendation: Improve presentation of GFS on website or hard copy as suggested.
- Dissemination media and schedule:
  - Main dissemination: Statistical Bulletin (explanatory notes, charts, tables, time series since 1990); UPF-IMF website with annual time series since 2000 and monthly and quarterly series for recent years.
  - Bolivia reports GFS data for central government, general government, and subsectors to the IMF GFS Yearbook; these data are compiled by the GDA.
  - GFS are disseminated according to a preannounced calendar shown on the IMF’s DSBB and on the CBB website.
  - Recommendation: Post the preannounced calendar for dissemination of GFS on the MOF website. (MOF posted the pre-announced calendar on the MOF website in March 2007.)
- Equal access and special requests:
  - Fiscal data are made available to all users at the same time.
  - Nonpublished, nonconfidential, disaggregated data are made available upon request; procedures for obtaining them are made known on the MOF website.
  - Upon request, MOF provides methodological and statistical information though no formal mechanisms exist to ensure close contact between GFS compilers and users. MOF maintains routine communications with international agencies.

* _cr07283 - 2.4 Basis for recording_*

### 5.2       Metadata       accessibility

### 5.2       Metadata       accessibility

### Documentation on concepts, scope, classifications, basis of recording, data sources, and statistical techniques
- Only metadata for budgetary and accounting data are made public.
- For GFS, detailed metadata are posted only on the IMF’s DSBB.
- Posted metadata include information about the concepts, data sources, definitions, classifications, compilation methods, and others.
- Bridge tables showing the links between source data and GFS are not prepared.
- Differences from internationally accepted standards are not identified.
- Metadata have not been updated since November 2005.
- Recommendation: Post detailed GFS metadata and a link to the IMF’s DSBB on the MOF website.
- Note: In March 2007, the MOF included a hyperlink to the IMF’s DSBB on the MOF website.

### Levels of detail adapted to the needs of the intended audience
- GFS metadata on the IMF’s DSBB provide enough detail for the intended audience.

### Assistance to users (5.3)
- Contact electronic address, website, telephone number, and address are provided on the MOF website and publications.
- The MOF provides support on technical matters to users requesting assistance.
- Material to raise awareness on the use of statistics is available, but assistance to users is not monitored.
- The MOF website provides a list of available publications.
- The Statistical Bulletin is distributed free of charge.

### Specific recommendation summary
- Post detailed GFS metadata and a link to the IMF’s DSBB on the MOF website.
- Improve monitoring of assistance provided to users.

### Key dates and notes
- Metadata not updated since November 2005.
- Hyperlink to IMF’s DSBB included on MOF website in March 2007.

---

### Table 4: Bolivia — Data Quality Assessment Framework (July 2003): Summary of Results for Government Finance Statistics (Compiling Agency: Ministry of Finance)
- Assessment key: NA = Not Applicable; O = Practice Observed; LO = Practice Largely Observed; LNO = Practice Largely Not Observed; NO = Practice Not Observed; SDDS = Complies with SDDS Criteria.
- Selected assessment highlights and comments:
  - 0.1 Legal and institutional environment: X — Responsibility shared by the UPF and the GDA; intra and inter-agency data sharing broadly adequate but compilation and dissemination of GFS should be centralized. MOF has started coordinating with data-producing public entities.
  - 0.2 Resources: X — Additional personnel, computing, and financing resources required for expanding institutional and transaction coverage and implementing the GFSM 2001.
  - 0.3 Relevance: X — MOF does not monitor emerging data requirements systematically; surveys to obtain feedback are not conducted.
  - 1.2 Transparency: X — Data products do not identify data sources or compilation unit; advance notice of methodological and other relevant changes not publicly disseminated. MOF plans to identify data sources and provide advance notice (short-term and medium–term).
  - 2.1 Concepts and definitions: X — A plan to migrate to the GFSM 2001 analytical framework has not been developed.
  - 2.2 Scope: X — Institutional and transaction scope of GFS are incomplete; detailed operations of some decentralized agencies and local governments not included.
  - 2.3 Classification/sectorization: X — Sectorization and classification not consistent with international recommendations; specific misclassifications and structural inconsistencies noted. MOF is assessing and planning implementation of recommendations.
  - 2.4 Basis for recording: X — Public external debt at nominal value and public internal debt at facial value; taxes not net of tax refunds; lending included as a revenue category and repayment included as an expense category. MOF assessing recommendations.
  - 3.1 Source data: X — Source data include SIGMA, SICON, UPF, DMFAS, and integrated systems of some public units; non-integrated systems increase collection effort and have incomplete institutional coverage.
  - 3.5 Revision studies: X — Revision studies and analyses are conducted, but not documented.
  - 4.2 Consistency: X — GFS are consistent with BOP and monetary statistics, but are not reconciled with the national accounts.
  - 4.3 Revision policy and practice: X — Revision schedule predetermined and reasonably stable, but not publicized; tables do not include notes of revisions; studies and analysis of revisions not made public.
  - 5.1 Data accessibility: X — GFS permit identification and comparison of major aggregates of flows and stocks, but room for improvement. Advance release calendar available on the CBB website and the IMF’s DSBB. MOF posted the preannounced calendar for dissemination of GFS on the MOF website in March 2007.
  - 5.2 Metadata accessibility: X — GFS metadata disseminated on the IMF’s DSBB, but not on the MOF website. Metadata need more regular updates. MOF included a hyperlink to the IMF’s DSBB on the MOF website in March 2007.
  - 5.3 Assistance to users: X.

---

### Monetary Statistics (selected sections included in this content unit)

### 0. Prerequisites of quality — Legal and institutional environment
- Responsibility for collecting, compiling, and disseminating monetary statistics is shared between the Central Bank of Bolivia (CBB) and the Superintendency of Banks and Financial Entities (SBFE).
- Law of the Central Bank of Bolivia 1670/95:
  - Article 40: SBFE obliged to provide CBB with all periodic information it receives from banks and other entities.
  - Article 43: CBB will periodically publish statistical and economic information.
- Law of Banks and Financial Entities (1488/93):
  - Article 93: SBFE can request reports from financial intermediation entities.
- Functional Manual of the CBB:
  - APEC supervises compilation, transmission, and dissemination of monetary, financial, and fiscal statistics.
  - SSMF responsible for compilation and dissemination of monetary statistics.
- SBFE and other agencies also disseminate monetary statistics; NSI and UDAPE reproduce CBB tables citing the source.
- Discrepancy noted: transferable deposits published by the SBFE follow a slightly different approach than the CBB’s data.

### 0.1.2 Data sharing and coordination
- SSMF interacts within CBB with SC, GOM, and GEF (contact point with SBFE).
- SSMF receives electronically from SC the daily monetary balance and has on-line access to CBB accounting records.
- SSMF has on-line access to GOM database on auctions of central government and CBB bonds and notes.
- ODCs transmit daily and monthly reports electronically to SBFE; SBFE forwards data to GEF: one-day lag for daily data, by the fifth day of the next month for monthly data.
- Some delays reported in forwarding monthly data, affecting timeliness.
- SBFE has shown readiness to attend CBB requests, produce ad-hoc chart of accounts changes, and instruct ODCs to correct reporting mistakes.

### 0.1.3 Confidentiality and data security
- Article 80 of Law 1670/95 guarantees confidentiality of information reported to the CBB; breaches lead to dismissal and possible civil or penal responsibilities.
- Staff Internal Regulation Article 51: sanctions including fine, suspension, discharge; Ethics Code Article 3 and annual confidentiality pledge required.
- SBFE: Law 1488/93 articles 88 and 89 require preservation of confidentiality; SBFE Ethics Code article 17 specifies protection steps.
- Data transmission:
  - ODCs to SBFE via dedicated encrypted lines with firewalls.
  - SBFE to GEF via intranet encrypted line.
  - No external access to data stored at the CBB; protected with firewalls and passwords; access levels decided by GEF.

### 0.1.4 Reporting mandates and compliance
- SBFE resolutions mandate electronic reporting by ODCs:
  - Daily: balance sheet, regional distribution of deposits, liabilities to other financial corporations, capital/assets ratio, interest rates.
  - Weekly: analysis of liquidity limits and projected cash-flow.
  - Monthly: balance sheet; financial statements; capital/assets ratio; deposits grouped by volume, maturity, and currency; sectoral accounts; loans by sector; foreign exchange position; additional report on nonperforming loans.
- Article 99 of Law 1488/93: penalties for noncompliance; fines reach approximately US$62.00 per day of noncompliance. In practice, ODCs report regularly.
- SSMF conducted nationwide seminars explaining concepts, definitions, sectorization, valuation criteria, and reporting importance.

### 0.2 Resources — staff, facilities, computing, financing
- At end-January 2007:
  - SBFE had 159 professional, technical, and administrative staff, with 69 in risk supervision.
  - Area responsible for collecting data (Intendency of Studies and Norms) had 16 persons.
  - SBFE staff consider resources adequate.
- SSMF had at end-January 2007:
  - Total of nine professional and two administrative staff, including the deputy manager and a division chief.
  - Three professional staff dedicated full-time to compilation and dissemination of monetary and financial statistics.
- Salary and staffing issues:
  - SBFE historically paid higher salaries; 2006 presidential decree reduced higher-rank public salaries causing loss of senior staff.
  - CBB salary flattening: manager earns only around US$20.00 per month more than a deputy manager.
  - Some SSMF staff ranked below academic/professional level, possibly affecting morale.
- Computing and communications:
  - Each staff has a personal computer; Internet access restricted to two hours per day.
  - Telephone use restricted to three minutes per external call.
  - Recommendation: Revise internal CBB policy on access to the Internet and use of telephone for external calls.
- Back-ups and contingency:
  - SBFE: data backed-up once a week; once a month three copies burned on magnetic supports and stored in three locations; alternative facility available.
  - CBB: daily data copied into three magnetic supports; one stored in commercial bank vaults; mirror on-line back-up outside headquarters; external center functioning as alternative storage and soon alternative operational site; no data are destroyed.
  - Weakness: lack of automatic back-ups for data on personal computers; September 2006 incident where a hard disk crashed and data could not be recovered.
  - 2007 administrative budget foresees acquisition of servers to centralize information and provide automatic back-up to desktops.

### 0.2.2 Measures to ensure efficient use of resources
- Data transmission processes (SBFE → GEF → SSMF) are fully automated.
- Compilation processes for central bank and ODC surveys fully automated at SSMF.
- Staff performance evaluated twice a year; appraisal used when evaluating internal candidates but carries relatively low weight.
- CBB lacks policy of periodically evaluating resources dedicated to statistical processes to prioritize activities; lower-cost activities often prioritized irrespective of relevance.

*Source: _cr07283 - 5.2       Metadata       accessibility*

### 0.3       Relevance

### 0.3       Relevance

### 0.3.1 Relevance monitoring and user engagement
- The CBB does not have a policy of periodically consulting users of monetary statistics about their needs, but has continually shown commitment to improve relevance.
- The SSMF:
  - Takes into account suggestions provided by users through its website.
  - Participates in international meetings.
- The SBFE:
  - Collects data mainly for supervisory purposes and is the main user of the data it collects.
  - Adapts its reporting requirements from ODCs to meet CBB’s emerging needs on monetary statistics.
  - Publishes financial data on its website and provides analytical tools to users.
  - Staff regularly attend technical meetings on banking supervision.

### 0.4 Other quality management

#### 0.4.1 Processes to focus on quality
- SSMF staff are aware of dimensions of data quality and have processes to check quality of published data.
- Normally no trade-off between timeliness and accuracy; where a trade-off existed, SSMF prioritized data accuracy.
- SBFE developed a five-year strategic plan covering 2002–2007 with objectives to:
  - Measure and monitor systemic risks.
  - Provide a prudential framework promoting transparency.
  - Foster efficiency.

#### 0.4.2 Monitoring the quality of the statistical program
- The CBB does not have an established process for systematically monitoring the quality of the statistical program.
- The CBB relies almost exclusively on IMF technical assistance for external advice on monetary statistics.

#### 0.4.3 Quality considerations in planning
- The CBB annual operational program outlines developmental and functional objectives often related to data quality (e.g., expansion of coverage, inclusion of nonbank financial institutions).
- Quality improvement needs are typically identified through staff training or receipt of technical assistance.

### Recommendations (quality management)
- Give advance notice to the users of the upcoming expansion of the coverage of the ODC survey, the compilation of an OFC survey, and any other major methodological revision. (From section 1.2.4)
- Expand the coverage of the ODC survey to include the accounts of the SAFIs. (From section 2.2.1)
- Start compiling a monthly OFC survey with data from pension funds, insurance corporations, and the three state-owned financial corporations. To automate the process, the Systems Management Office should develop a computing routine to aggregate the data of the two pension funds. (From section 2.2.1)
- In collaboration with the SBFE, undertake efforts to eliminate the detected mistakes in the sectorization of the accounts of ODCs. (From section 2.3.1)

---

### 1. Assurances of integrity

### 1.1 Professionalism

#### 1.1.1 Impartial production of statistics
- The CBB and the SBFE are independent, autarkic institutions.
- Technical criteria alone are applied by data compilers and analysts; they are independent in choice of data collection methods.
- Staff are hired on a permanent basis following a competitive process; internal promotions are competitive and consider professional capabilities and past performance.
- These contractual conditions protect staff against undue pressures, ensuring professional independence.

#### 1.1.2 Sources, techniques, and dissemination determined by statistical considerations
- Source data for monetary statistics: balance sheets of the CBB, 12 commercial banks, six banks in liquidation, 24 credit unions, nine savings and loans associations, and six private investment funds.
- Full coverage of units in each subsector restricts manipulation via sample changes.
- Financial statistics not based on accounting records (e.g., interest rates) are produced using responses by all institutions of the system.
- SSMF follows the Monetary and Financial Statistics Manual (MFSM) for classification of financial instruments and sectorization.
- Dissemination follows an established procedure with deadlines announced in an advance release calendar; periodicity and timing were not hampered by pressures from other government agencies.

#### 1.1.3 Right to comment on misuse or erroneous interpretation
- In cases of misinterpretation or misuse, the CBB provides comments and clarifications mainly through its Institutional Communications Department.
- The CBB issues press releases and technical reports to avoid misinterpretations; no recent cases of misinterpretation reported.
- The Institutional Communications Department reviews daily media information and issues clarifications when needed.

### 1.2 Transparency

#### 1.2.1 Terms and conditions publicly available
- Bolivia participates in the IMF’s General Data Dissemination System (GDDS).
- Monetary statistics metadata are accessible on the IMF’s DSBB and were last updated in December 2005.
- The CBB website contains a Metadatos window with monetary statistics metadata in Spanish and a link to the IMF’s DSBB.
- Laws 1670/95 and 1488/93 detail legal terms and conditions for collecting monetary information and are posted on the CBB and SBFE websites.
- The brochure Definiciones de Términos Empleados en la Información Estadística Semanal is available on the CBB website and distributed in hardcopy to schools and fairs.

#### 1.2.2 Internal governmental access prior to release
- Latest monetary data and other macroeconomic data are provided regularly to the Macroeconomic Group.
- Depending on the release calendar, the Macroeconomic Group may or may not have access prior to public dissemination; earlier access does not interfere with scheduled release.
- The CBB acknowledges on its website the possibility of selected access prior to release.
- Composition of the Macroeconomic Group includes the Minister of Finance, the CBB President, the Minister of Planning, the Deputy Ministers of Budget, Treasury, Tax Policy, Public Investment, and Pensions, and the Executive Directors of NSI, UDAPE, Fiscal Policy Unit (UPF), and the Fiscal Analysis Network (RAF).

#### 1.2.3 Identification of agency products
- All CBB and SBFE publications are clearly identified with logos and addresses.
- All tables in CBB publications contain the data source and unit responsible for compilation.
- CBB data may be reproduced if the source is quoted; CBB controls compliance with this requirement.

#### 1.2.4 Advance notice of major methodological changes
- Advance notice is not given to the public when there are major changes in methodology.
- When SSMF revises monetary data due to IMF recommendations or other methodological changes, detailed notes explain series breaks and effects on monetary variables.
- Current methodological developments:
  - Expansion of ODCs survey coverage to include Investment Funds Management Societies (SAFIs).
  - Compilation of an other financial corporations (OFCs) survey covering insurance corporations, pension funds, and other financial intermediaries.
- Recommendation: Give advance notice to the users of the upcoming expansion of the coverage of the ODC survey, the compilation of an OFC survey, and any other major methodological revision.

### 1.3 Ethical standards

#### 1.3.1 Staff behavior guidelines
- Law on Public Servants (2027/99) regulates legal situation of permanent and contractual public employees, including CBB staff.
- CBB Internal Staff Regulation (2001) contains ethical rules: rights and obligations (arts. 4–6), incompatibilities and conflict of interest (arts. 7–10), and sanctions (arts. 48–52).
- Regulation forbids CBB staff to work elsewhere in public sector except as university professor, to enter private contracts related to their functions, or breach confidentiality.
- The CBB Code of Conduct (distributed to entire staff) reflects the regulation and addresses integrity, professional independence, fidelity, confidentiality, mutual respect, transparency, and foresees an ethics committee of three full and three alternate members appointed by the President, General Manager, and CBB staff.
- SBFE Ethics Code covers truthfulness, justice, mutual respect, responsibility, transparency, and integrity; establishes an ethics committee of three full and two alternate members (one designated by the Superintendent, four elected by staff). The Ethics Code is obligatory knowledge for all SBFE staff.

---

### 2. Methodological soundness

### 2.1 Concepts and definitions

#### 2.1.1 Alignment with international standards
- The SSMF’s methodological framework for the central bank survey and the ODC survey is consistent with MFSM guidelines; some discrepancies resolved after the 2006 IMF monetary and financial statistics mission.
- A depository corporations survey (DCS) consolidates the central bank survey with the ODC survey.
- Main monetary and credit aggregates defined:
  - Base money: notes and coins in circulation and deposits of ODCs with the CBB.
  - M1: notes and coins in circulation outside the banking system and current account and sight deposits in national currency of the private sector with ODCs.
  - M1’: M1 and current account and sight deposits in foreign currency and national currency with value maintenance of the private sector with ODCs.
  - M2: M1 and savings deposits in national currency of the private sector with ODCs.
  - M2’: M1’ and savings deposits in national currency, foreign currency, and national currency with value maintenance of the private sector with ODCs.
  - M3: M2 and time deposits and other deposits in national currency of the private sector with ODCs.
  - M3’: M2’ and time deposits and other deposits in national currency, foreign currency, and national currency with value maintenance of the private sector with ODCs.
  - M4: M3 and treasury bills in national currency held by the nonfinancial private sector.
  - M4’: M3’ and treasury bills in national currency, foreign currency, and national currency with value maintenance held by the nonfinancial private sector.
  - CBB’s net international reserves, CBB’s net credit to the public sector, CBB’s credit to the banking sector.
  - Net foreign assets of the ODCs, ODC’s net credit to the public sector, ODCs’ credit to the private sector.

### 2.2 Scope

#### 2.2.1 Coverage consistency with international practice
- At end-January 2007, Bolivia’s depository corporations sector comprised:
  - the CBB,
  - 12 commercial banks,
  - 24 credit unions,
  - nine savings and loans associations,
  - six private investment funds,
  - six banks in liquidation,
  - 7 SAFIs.
- SAFIs:
  - Are not under SBFE supervision; regulated by the Superintendency of Pensions, Securities, and Insurances (SPSI).
  - Belong to commercial banks and manage private sector portfolio investments, issuing a debit card to withdraw funds, making them a close substitute of money.
  - Liabilities to their investors account for around six percent of broad money.
- The central bank survey is based on the CBB’s “monetary balance,” a reclassified and adjusted trial balance transmitted daily from the SC to the SSMF.
- All entities regulated by the SBFE are included in the ODC survey, covering headquarters and all domestic branches. Banks in liquidation are included; SAFIs are not included because the financial system regards ODCs as only those supervised by the SBFE.

Recommendations (scope)
- Expand the coverage of the ODC survey to include the accounts of the SAFIs.
- Start compiling a monthly OFC survey with data from the two pension funds, eight insurance corporations regulated by the SPSI, and the two state-owned financial corporations NAFIBO and FONDESIF.
- Develop a computing routine in the Systems Management Office to aggregate individual monthly data of the two pension funds.

### 2.3 Classification/sectorization

#### 2.3.1 Consistency with standards and identified issues
- Sectorization generally follows MFSM recommendations; repurchase agreements classified as loans, prepaid insurances as insurance technical reserves, forwards and futures as financial derivatives.
- At end-2006, migration to new standardized report forms for the central bank and ODCs eliminated almost all classification and sectorization problems.
- The ODC chart of accounts follows international accounting standards but reflects prudential standards that do not allow adequate sectorization. Sectoral accounts (additional monthly report) group main balance sheet accounts by economic sector and institutional unit and are used by SSMF to prepare ODC sectoral balance sheet following MFSM methodology.
- Financial instruments are classified by type, maturity, and currency denomination (local, local with maintenance of value, U.S. dollars, and indexed to the U.S. dollar).
- Some misreporting issues identified:
  - Some ODCs report accounts of nonresidents (e.g., embassies) as accounts of residents.
  - Incorrect sectorization of accounts of public nonfinancial corporations or of the private nonfinancial sector.
  - Until December 2006, ODCs reported SAFIs as OFCs due to lack of category in sectoral accounts; private nonfinancial resident units were reported as a single Other resident category, not distinguishing private enterprises and households/NPISHs.
- SBFE instructed ODCs in November 2006 that, starting with their report for January 2007, SAFIs should be identified in a new category and private nonfinancial resident accounts should be separated into private enterprises and other resident sectors.

Recommendation (classification)
- In collaboration with the SBFE, undertake efforts to eliminate detected mistakes in sectorization of ODC accounts.

### 2.4 Basis for recording

#### 2.4.1 Market valuation of flows and stocks
- SBFE instructions: financial assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currency, in local currency adjusted to the U.S. dollar, and indexed by the CPI should be adjusted at least at month-end using the buyer market exchange rate informed by the CBB and the UFV, respectively.
- In practice, ODCs adjust these balances daily; the CBB also adjusts daily its assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currency or indexed to the US dollar or the UFV; this includes gold holdings (valued at market prices), SDR holdings, and reserve position in the IMF.
- ODCs supervised by SBFE value securities at the lower of amortized cost or market price. The CBB values its holdings of securities at amortized cost.

#### 2.4.2 Accrual recording
- The CBB records accounts on an accrual basis and registers accrued interest with its underlying instrument.
- ODCs record daily balances on an accrual basis but present all accrued interest in Accrued products on both liability and asset sides. Monthly “sectorized accounts” disaggregate accrued interest and classify it with the underlying instrument.
- SBFE instructions: interest cannot be accrued on loans overdue for more than 91 days, or loans to debtors with nonperforming loans in other institutions.

#### 2.4.3 Grossing/netting procedures
- Assets and liabilities of the CBB and ODCs are presented on a gross basis with no netting of claims against liabilities to the same transactor or group.
- Overdrafts are recorded as loans to the corresponding sector.
- Loans recorded gross with provisions for loan losses reported as a negative asset; SSMF reclassifies these provisions to liability side as Other accounts payable for survey compilation, following MFSM recommendations.
- For the ODC survey and DCS, consolidation of accounts:
  - Accounts of commercial banks, credit unions, savings and loans associations, and investment funds are consolidated in Other items net.
  - In the DCS, accounts of the CBB are consolidated with ODC accounts also in Other items net.

---

*Source: _cr07283 - 0.3       Relevance*

### 3. Accuracy and reliability

### 3. Accuracy and reliability

### 3.1 Source data
- Source data are obtained from comprehensive data collection programs that take into account country-specific conditions.
- The chart of accounts for ODCs:
  - Is based on a ten-digit code.
  - Is geared towards prudential goals and does not contain a code to sectorize the accounts.
- Because adding an extra code for sectorization was nonviable, in July 2002 the SBFE requested from the ODCs a monthly “sectorized accounts” report. These:
  - Group public sector accounts into: Treasury; central government except Treasury; social security; public decentralized entities; departments; municipalities; and public nonfinancial corporations.
  - Divide the financial sector into: central bank; commercial banks; savings and loans associations; credit unions; private investment funds; insurance corporations; pension funds; stock exchange; financial service corporations; and second-tier financial corporations.
  - Classify the private nonfinancial sector in only one category, without separating enterprises, households, and NPISHs.
  - Classify accounts of nonresidents into: embassies and other official representations; foreign corporations; overseas financial corporations; overseas headquarters and branches; and other nonresidents.
- The DCS is based on actual accounting records of the CBB and the ODCs; no sampling or estimations are employed by the SSMF.
- ODCs follow international accounting standards when recording transactions.
- Audits:
  - The monetary balance sheet of the CBB is audited quarterly by the Internal Audit Management Office.
  - The CBB’s financial statements are audited by an external accounting firm selected through a competitive process that rotates every year.
  - The 2005 annual balance sheet was audited by a local firm correspondent of an international accounting firm and was approved with an unqualified opinion.
- Timeliness of reporting:
  - The SC prepares the CBB’s monetary balance sheet on a daily basis and transmits it electronically to the SSMF, which has online access to the accounting records.
  - ODCs transmit electronically their daily balance sheets (plus other information) to the SBFE before 2:00 p.m. of the following day.
  - Each month ODCs report their monthly balance sheets plus the sectorized accounts two working days after the end of the reference month.
  - The SBFE transmits to the GEF the daily data the next day and the monthly data within five days after the end of the reference month.
  - The automated process allows the SSMF to produce timely monetary data, although communication between the GEF and the SSMF can be improved because sometimes the monthly data were not immediately forwarded.

### 3.2 Assessment of source data
- SBFE validation and consistency checks performed after electronic submissions include:
  - Comparison of assets and liabilities.
  - Detection of balances with the wrong sign in selected accounts.
  - Detection of unusual movements in balances.
  - Cross-checking of the interbank position via a contagion matrix.
  - If data fail checks, they are returned to reporting institutions for revision.
- SSMF reviews:
  - Visual review of data at individual institution level.
  - Comparisons with internal and external sources such as auctions of Treasury and CBB securities.
  - Verification of ODCs’ positions vis-à-vis the CBB.
  - These controls detect unusual movements and sectorization mistakes but lack an automated routine to flag substantial movements or unexpected balances.
- Recommendation:
  - Develop a routine that automatically flags significant changes in the balances of selected accounts, or balances that do not correspond with the expected values.
- Limitations due to bank secrecy:
  - SSMF does not have access to supplementary information (e.g., lists of largest depositors or debtors by institution) that would allow verification of sectorization.
  - SBFE receives account-identifying information but not holders’ identities.
- Staff view:
  - SSMF staff are comfortable with ODC data quality but acknowledge needed improvements in sectorization by some institutions.

### 3.3 Statistical techniques
- Data compilation:
  - Balance sheets of individual ODCs, their “sectoral accounts,” and the CBB’s balance sheet are processed electronically, minimizing risk of mistakes.
  - Data reported by ODCs are complete; SSMF does not estimate missing information. If data are missing, SSMF postpones publication and waits for missing data.
- Estimation for banks in liquidation:
  - For three banks in liquidation, SSMF receives monthly updates of balance sheets.
  - For the remaining three, SSMF estimates balances of foreign currency, U.S. dollar adjusted, and CPI-indexed accounts on the basis of the market exchange rate and the UFV, respectively.
  - When notified of movements in some accounts (e.g., loan recovery), SSMF adjusts the balance sheet accordingly.
  - This estimation for banks in liquidation is the only regular case where estimation is needed for monetary statistics.

### 3.4 Assessment and validation of intermediate data and statistical outputs
- Cross-checks and validations:
  - ODCs’ positions vis-à-vis the CBB are verified with CBB accounting records.
  - Interbank positions are automatically validated by SBFE’s contagion matrix.
  - Securities reported by ODCs are cross-checked against GOM auction data; SSMF contacts MOF for information on securities sold directly to the public.
  - SSMF is unable to follow securities beyond the first buyer; an ongoing project will allow automatic access to Securities Enterprise information to identify final holders.
  - Below-the-line financing of general government is cross-checked with CBB accounting records and ODC credit/deposit data; SSMF maintains permanent contact with the Fiscal Programming Unit (UPF) of the Ministry of Finance.
  - CBB’s monetary balance sheet contains ad-hoc adjustments to government accounts to reflect transactions not yet booked in the trial balance.
- Validation identities used:
  - Monetary Base = Net International Reserves + Net Credit to Government + Credit to the Economy + Other Items Net (includes non reserve net foreign assets)
  - Broad Money = Net Foreign Assets + Net Credit to Government + Credit to the Economy + Other Items Net
- Additional validation tools:
  - ODCs’ month-end stock data validated with flow data from daily balance sheets.
  - Quarterly intersectoral matrix compiled by SSMF comprising ten economic sectors used to verify accuracy.
- Investigation of discrepancies:
  - When discrepancies are detected, SSMF contacts reporting institutions directly to inquire and resolve problems.
  - Examples: differences between ODC-reported securities and GOM auction records; significant account balance changes; suspected misclassifications.
  - SSMF prefers resolving issues by direct contact to spare institutions fines from SBFE; if errors persist, SSMF informs SBFE.

### 3.5 Revision studies
- Main source of revisions:
  - Technical assistance from IMF monetary and financial statistics missions in 1999, 2001, and 2006 drove the main revisions.
  - SSMF implemented most mission recommendations and migrated to new standardized report forms at end-2006.
- Revisions executed:
  - Data were revised from December 2001 onwards for the CBB and from July 2002 onwards for ODCs.
  - Revisions in time series and their impact on monetary aggregates were explained in notes accompanying Boletín Mensual tables.
- Documentation:
  - SSMF keeps a file documenting the most common detected mistakes, actions taken, and effects of revisions on monetary and financial data.
- Public disclosure of revision studies:
  - Studies and analyses of revisions are not made public, but explanatory notes are added to tables when data are revised.

*Source: _cr07283 - 3. Accuracy and reliability.*

### 0.    Prerequisites    of    quality

### 0. Prerequisites of quality

### 0.1 Legal and institutional environment
- CBB recognized as sole institution responsible for BOP statistics since 1938.
- Legal basis: Law of the Central Bank of Bolivia (Law 1670 of October 31, 1995).
  - Article 40: obligation of the Superintendency of Banks and Financial Entities (SBFE) to provide the CBB with all information received from banks and other financial institutions; mandatory data reporting to the CBB of all information requested by the CBB from banks and other financial intermediaries.
  - Article 21: CBB’s responsibility for recording public and private external debt.
  - Article 43: CBB shall publish periodically economic and financial statistics within its scope.
- Within the CBB, the Balance of Payments Department (BPD) is responsible for compiling Bolivia’s BOP and international investment position (IIP) statistics. The BPD belongs to the External Sector Deputy Management Office (SSE) of the Economic Policy Advisory Office (APEC).
- Working arrangements exist between the BPD, other CBB departments, and other data-producing agencies; the CBB’s Functions and Procedures Manual of October 2005 establishes responsibilities (manual not disseminated to the public).

- Data sharing and coordination:
  - Official data-producers regularly providing administrative source data: National Statistics Institute (NSI); Vice Ministry of Public Investment and External Financing; state-owned oil company Yacimientos Petrolíferos Fiscales Bolivianos (YPFB); SBFE; Superintendency of Pensions, Securities, and Insurances (SPSI); several ministries.
  - BPD established working arrangements with NSI for international travel and FDI surveys. Last travel survey conducted in 2003; last FDI survey in 2005.
  - In 2006, CBB decided to directly conduct the Foreign Private Capital Survey (FPC survey) requesting FDI and other external assets and liabilities data (portfolio investment and other investments), as well as selected international services.
  - NSI and CBB renewed agreement for resuming international travel survey during 2007.

- Confidentiality:
  - CBB Law Article 80: Board members and staff must keep secret all matters and operations of the CBB and financial institutions; obligations apply after retirement/separation; penalties include destitution and legal sanctions.
  - CBB Internal Regulation of Personnel (Board Resolution 037/2002): bans breaches of confidentiality (Article 7); establishes sanctions including fines and destitution (Article 51). All CBB staff must sign a Confidentiality Commitment form yearly.
  - CBB Code of Conduct (Board Resolution 090/2001) Article 3: establishes ethical principles including confidentiality.
  - Data from surveys and direct reporting are kept confidential; data submitted for statistical purposes are disseminated only in aggregate. Access to the CBB database is guarded; BPD staff computers require passwords; Department of Systems Security manages computer system security.

- Statistical reporting mandate and measures to encourage response:
  - While no explicit legislation forces private sector reporting for BOP, Article 40 and Article 20 of the CBB Law provide legal basis. Article 20 authorizes CBB to regulate international financial operations of individuals and entities; BPD invokes Article 20 when legal basis questioned.
  - The CBB receives responses to private sector forms regularly. In late 2006, the CBB initiated a comprehensive quarterly FPC survey. Response rate to the FPC survey is about 80 percent (deadline not yet reached).
  - Measures to encourage response include: staff visits to surveyed entities; inclusion of previously reported data in forms; provision of consolidated information to surveyed enterprises; making CBB’s statistical publications available; prompt assistance from BOP compilers.
- Recommendation: Include in CBB’s questionnaires and direct reporting forms for BOP compilation references to the legal basis for collecting information, including the confidentiality of reported data.

### 0.2 Resources
- BPD human resources and qualifications:
  - BPD comprised of nine professionals (including the department head).
  - All professional staff have university degrees in economics and post-graduate degrees in economics or related fields.
  - Average individual experience in BOP statistics is six to seven years.
  - Staff have participated in IMF and regional training (IMF Washington D.C., Regional Training Center in Brasilia, CEMLA).
  - Human resources allocated to survey activities have not been sufficient; CBB has agreements with other public entities (e.g., NSI) to carry out surveys.

- Facilities and IT:
  - Working space, computer resources, and equipment adequate for regular duties.
  - Staff have individual computers connected to a main server with backup and system protection procedures.
  - Staff have access to e-mail and Internet, although Internet access is restricted to two hours per day.
  - Access to local phone calls is limited to three minutes per call, which may constrain survey implementation.
  - Financial resources allocated to BOP compilation have proved adequate.

- Recommendations:
  - Provide additional staff resources to the BPD to undertake tasks associated with the recent introduction of the CBB’s Foreign Private Capital (FPC) survey.
  - Improve BPD staff telephone communications and Internet access.

- Efficiency measures:
  - CBB evaluates staff performance once a year.
  - CBB has used outside technical assistance (IMF, CEMLA, Debt Relief International (DRI), Development Finance International (DFI)) to evaluate methodologies and systems.
  - Efficiencies sought through continuous reviews of work processes and encouraging consistent concepts and methodologies across CBB units.

### 0.3 Relevance
- User consultation and relevance monitoring:
  - No structured and periodic consultation process with data users regarding specific aspects of BOP data; users consulted on an ad-hoc basis.
  - Example: methodological seminar on the new FPC survey in 2006 provided useful feedback.
  - Data users can direct inquiries via the CBB website.
  - CBB staff participate regularly in regional and international BOP meetings (CEMLA, DRI, DFI, IMF, CAN).
- Recommendation: Establish regular procedures to obtain users’ feedback on the relevance of BOP statistics and emerging data needs (preferably through users’ surveys).

### 0.4 Other quality management
- Focus on quality:
  - CBB management and staff recognize quality as essential and encourage technical training.
  - Staff share training outcomes with colleagues via internal lectures.
  - Participation in seminars/workshops on BOP, FDI, international trade in services, external debt, remittances (ANDESTAD, World Bank-BIS, CEMLA-IDB).
- Monitoring quality:
  - Each BPD staff member provides external sector management with details of data reported by sectors under their responsibility.
  - Compilation and dissemination of quarterly BOP, IIP, and private sector debt data, and efforts to subscribe to the SDDS, demonstrate commitment to quality.
  - CBB establishing a comprehensive macroeconomic database including BOP and IIP data.
  - Recommendation: Prepare monthly reports to inform management of data quality based on direct reporting and surveys (surveys’ response rate, coverage, response errors, etc.).
- Planning and quality considerations:
  - Quality issues are considered in statistical program planning and survey implementation (trade-offs among timeliness and accuracy/reliability).
  - Introduction of quarterly FPC survey in November 2006 demonstrates responsiveness to identified data problems.
  - Compilation and dissemination of quarterly BOP, IIP, external debt, and monthly reserves template data support quality focus.

### 1. Assurances of integrity

- Professionalism
  - Statistics produced impartially; professional considerations guide methods and dissemination.
  - Article 1 of CBB Law: CBB is public autonomous institution and the only monetary and foreign exchange authority of Bolivia.
  - Independence in data compilation is recognized and supported by CBB management.
  - Recruitment and promotion follow standards on academic credentials, aptitude, knowledge, and experience.
  - Staff training from IMF, CAN, CEMLA, DFI, DRI in BOP, external debt, FDI, services, remittances, and international reserves template statistics.
  - Research/analysis encouraged (CBB’s Analysis Magazine contains staff-prepared articles).

- Transparency and statistical decision-making
  - Choice of sources, methodologies, and dissemination decisions are based solely on statistical considerations in line with BPM5.
  - Active participation in regional workshops to coordinate methodologies and share compilation experiences.

- Commenting on misuse
  - CBB monitors media coverage and comments on erroneous interpretation or misuse when necessary.
  - The CBB provides explanatory material and brief analysis in its publications to prevent misinterpretation of BOP statistics.

### Methodological soundness, Accuracy, Serviceability, Accessibility (summary notes)
- Methodological soundness elements raised in assessment:
  - SAFIs not included in the ODC survey; in coordination with the SPSI, accounts of SAFIs will be included in the ODC survey (short-term).
  - SAFIs classified as OFCs rather than as ODCs; no breakdown between other nonfinancial corporations and other resident sectors; problems of sectorization and improper use of the residence criterion by ODCs.
  - SBFE instructed ODCs to report SAFIs in a new category and to separate accounts of nonfinancial corporations and other resident sectors; SSMF will work with SBFE and reporting institutions to correct mistakes (short-term).

- Accuracy and reliability (assessment components noted as observed):
  - Source data, assessment of source data, statistical techniques, assessment and validation of intermediate data and outputs, and revision studies all indicated in the assessment.

- Serviceability:
  - Periodicity and timeliness, consistency, and revision policy and practice addressed.
  - No systematic revision studies; revision studies not made public, but statistical tables contain detailed explanations of revised figures.

- Accessibility:
  - Possible earlier access by a governmental advisory group, which does not affect the scheduled release calendars.
  - Metadata accessibility and assistance to users are addressed.

*Source: "Balance of Payments Statistics" — 0. Prerequisites of quality (compilation and assessment material provided by the Central Bank of Bolivia).*

### 1.2       Transparency

### 1.2       Transparency

### 1.2.1 The terms and conditions under which statistics are collected, processed, and disseminated are available to the public
- General terms under which BOP statistics are collected and disseminated are available to the public on the CBB website (www.bcb.gov.bo), including the criteria of data confidentiality.
- The semiannual publication External Sector Bulletin (available in print and on the CBB website) provides information about the terms and conditions under which BOP statistics are produced, including methodology, and source data.
- Recommendation: Enhance the description in the External Sector Bulletin of the terms under which BOP statistics are compiled and disseminated.

### 1.2.2 Internal governmental access to statistics prior to their release is publicly identified
- Quarterly BOP data are presented twice yearly for informative purposes to the CBB's Board of Directors meeting immediately prior to their public release on the CBB website, which takes place 45 days after the end of the reference quarter.
- The Macroeconomic Group that meets periodically to monitor the macroeconomic and financial developments receives the latest available monetary and financial information that may or may not have been published on the CBB website. This practice may generate in some cases internal government access prior to their dissemination to the public, but with no interference with their pre-scheduled public dissemination.
- This practice is publicly identified in the CBB metadata posted on the CBB website.
- If requested, quarterly BOP data provided for the Macroeconomic Group meeting correspond to the latest published data.

### 1.2.3 Products of statistical agencies/units are clearly identified as such
- BOP statistics are clearly identified as a CBB product, with CBB publications identifying the specific unit responsible for their compilation, and when applicable, other institutions that provide the main source data (e.g., NSI for data on goods export and imports).

### 1.2.4 Advanced notice is given of major changes in methodology, source data, and statistical techniques
- Important changes in the methodology and source data to compile BOP statistics are made known to the public in advance. For example, the introduction of the FPC survey in 2006 was informed in advance to the public through an official communiqué of the CBB.
- Otherwise, changes are informed to the public at the time of the first release of the publication External Sector Bulletin.
- Recommendation: Reinforce the practice of providing advanced notice of major changes in the compilation of BOP statistics.

### 1.3 Ethical standards

#### 1.3.1 Guidelines for staff behavior are in place and are well known to the staff
- The CBB’s Code of Conduct, approved by Board Resolution 090/2001, establishes ethical principles for CBB staff, including integrity, fidelity, impartiality, professional independence, confidentiality, objectivity, prudence, respect, responsibility, transparence, and truthfulness.
- The Code of Conduct also establishes obligations, prohibitions and incompatibilities, sanctions, and an Ethics Committee.
- The CBB’s Internal Regulation of Personnel establishes the rights and obligations for CBB staff. CBB staff have been provided with a copy of the Code of Conduct and the Internal Regulation of Personnel.
- The CBB as part of the public sector is subject to the Law of Public Personnel (Law 2027), which sets out the legal framework for public service’s rights and responsibilities, including ethical standards applicable to all public sector employees.

*Source: _cr07283 - 1.2 Transparency*

### 3.1       Source       data

### 3.1       Source       data

### Overview of source data and adequacy
- Source data are obtained from comprehensive data collection programs that take into account country-specific conditions.
- The data collection programs to compile BOP statistics are adequate, but source data for certain services and financial transactions may be improved.
- Surveys are not used extensively for international trade in services due to limitations in human resources and lack of a comprehensive and up-to-date business register.

### Core source data and institutional providers
- Core data sources: (1) CBB data; (2) administrative data from other government agencies; (3) surveys; (4) direct reporting mainly from nonfinancial enterprises; and (5) information from foreign and international financial institutions.
- BPD obtains statistical data from other CBB areas:
  - International Operations Management Office (GOI): public and private sector external debt data (flows and stocks) based on the DMFAS database.
  - Monetary and Fiscal Sector Deputy Management Office (SSMF): assets and liabilities of the financial sector, based on detailed data submitted by the SBFE and CBB records.
  - Accounting Deputy Management Office: CBB’s reserve assets (flows and stocks data), contributions to international organizations, and official grants disbursed through CBB’s accounts.
  - Financial Entities Management Office: financial services of banks and other financial sector institutions.
- BPD obtains information from other government agencies:
  - National Statistics Institute (NSI): goods exports and imports (including freight, insurance, and other expenses) based on Customs data; number of international passengers by type of transport (disaggregated between nationals and foreigners) based on National Service of Migration information.
  - Ministry of Foreign Affairs: government services n.i.e., official transfers, and Bolivian migrants to other economies.
  - Ministry of Mining: detailed information on mineral exports (value, volume, unit price, etc.).
  - Ministry of Hydrocarbons: detailed information on hydrocarbons exports (value, volume, unit price, etc.).
  - Treasury: contributions to international organizations.
  - Vice Ministry of Public Investment and External Financing: data on official current transfers.
  - Yacimientos Petrolíferos Fiscales Bolivianos (YPFB): detailed information on hydrocarbons exports and investment in the sector.
  - SPSI: data on insurance services other than freight, and investment income.
  - Superintendency of Telecommunications: data on communication services (credits and debits).
  - National Post Office: information on postal and courier services.
  - Ministry of Labor: information on border and seasonal workers in Bolivia and in neighboring countries.
- Additional direct reporting and international sources:
  - Nonfinancial enterprises: communications, financial, and other services.
  - Foreign embassies and international organizations accredited in Bolivia: government services and current transfers.
  - Private and official donors: grants (current and capital).
  - Banks and money transfer companies (such as MoneyGram and Western Union): workers’ remittances (credits and debits).
  - Private banks and other financial institutions: quarterly data on other investment.
  - Bank for International Settlement (BIS): stock data of nonbank deposits in nonresident banks.

### Surveys, recent initiatives, and coverage gaps
- NSI surveys under working agreement with CBB:
  - Quarterly FDI surveys during 1998–2004. Implementation problems led the CBB to estimate FDI flows and stock data in 2005 based on a questionnaire sent to a small number of enterprises.
  - In November 2006, BPD, jointly with GOI, initiated a Foreign Private Capital Survey (FPC survey) requesting information on FDI, portfolio investment, other external assets and liabilities, and international services to more than 300 enterprises. The FPC survey will be conducted by the CBB quarterly.
  - NSI travel surveys conducted in 2000 and 2003; travel survey to be resumed by NSI in 2007, conducted both in high and in low season, updated questionnaires based on previous results. Travel survey targeted to residents traveling abroad and nonresidents visiting Bolivia.
- Direct reporting from YPFB used for services, investment income, direct investment, and other financial transactions related to hydrocarbons.
- Customs administration is the only source for exports and imports of natural gas, petroleum, and related products.

### Recommendations on source data collection and surveys
- Initiate quarterly FPC surveys in 2007, identifying improvements in design, data validation, and sample techniques, based on the results of the 2006 FPC survey.
- Prepare a comprehensive and up-to-date business register for sample surveys.
- Reinforce the use of surveys and direct reporting data for services.
- Resume in 2007 the semiannual travel survey, jointly conducted by NSI and CBB.
- Subject to staff availability and improvements in telephone communications, employ more rigorous follow-up procedures to ensure timely receipt of respondents’ data.

### Consistency with BPM5 definitions, scope, and valuation
- Source data (administrative records, private sector surveys, and direct reporting) are broadly consistent with BPM5 guidelines.
- External debt information from GOI broadly in line with BPM5 and the External Debt Guide.
- CBB staff aware of differences between source data definitions and those required for BOP compilation; adjustments are made where necessary to improve coverage, classification, and valuation (e.g., excluding goods crossing borders without change in ownership such as aircraft under operational leasing).

### Timeliness and periodicity
- Merchandise exports and imports available one month after the period of reference.
- Public external debt data available 15 days after the period of reference.
- Preliminary quarterly BOP first disseminated 45 days after the end of the reference period through the Report on Balance of Payments and International Investment Position. Preliminary annual BOP data are released when fourth quarter statistics are disseminated.
- Bolivia disseminates quarterly IIP data 45 days after the reference quarter.
- Recommendation: employ more rigorous follow-up procedures to ensure timely receipt of respondents’ data.

### Assessment, validation, and treatment of intermediate data
- Accuracy of survey and direct reporting data routinely assessed; FPC survey data confronted with other sources (balance sheets, industry reports) for consistency.
- Effects of questionnaire changes assessed; extreme values confirmed with respondents.
- Administrative data accuracy routinely assessed (public and private external debt, international trade of goods, financial sector flows and stocks, reserve assets).
- Intermediate results validated against independent sources such as financial press for high-value direct investment and other transactions; FDI and private external debt confronted with balance sheets and industry reports.
- Statistical discrepancies: series behavior routinely assessed but not always systematically (e.g., c.i.f. and f.o.b. values confronted with freight ratios; financial flow data crosschecked with stock changes; Customs exports confronted with YPFB and sectoral data; public external debt compared with creditors’ data).

### Statistical techniques, adjustments, and special estimations
- Compilation procedures minimize coding, editing, and tabulation errors; procedures for imputation and estimation for nonresponse and missing information are employed, but improvements could be made.
- Adjustments to align source data with BPM5:
  - NSI trade data adjusted for coverage, valuation, and timing.
  - Passengers’ land transportation services calculated using NSI information and average ticket prices.
  - Travel services calculated based on NSI administrative data on passengers and average length and cost of stay estimated from the travel survey conducted in 2003.
  - Government services n.i.e. based on number of employees in foreign embassies and consulates and average wage estimates.
  - Data on investment income of FDI based on estimated rates of return.
  - Workers’ remittances through informal channels estimated to amount up to 20 percent of those made through formal channels.
  - Estimates for migrant transfers made based on administrative data from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
- Recommendations:
  - Review statistical techniques to adjust data for missing observations.
  - Continue efforts to improve data collection and estimation techniques for workers’ remittances and other transfers, and certain services and financial transactions.
  - Review estimates on direct investment to avoid overestimation of investment income and reinvested earnings.

### Revisions, documentation, and use of revision analysis
- CBB staff routinely analyze revisions of BOP data to improve quality; important revisions are well documented, but in general no adequate documentation is maintained.
- Examples: correction since 2005 for NSI natural gas exports not being valued on a f.o.b. basis; revisions to vehicle import timing to conform with BPM5.
- Recommendation: document studies and analyses of revisions and use these results to inform the statistical process.

### Serviceability: periodicity, timeliness, and dissemination standards
- Bolivia is a GDDS participating country; dissemination of quarterly BOP statistics meets SDDS prescribed quarterly periodicity (GDDS periodicity for BOP is annual).
- Timeliness meets SDDS timeliness of one quarter after the reference period.
- GDDS timeliness for BOP data is six months after the reference period.
- Recommendation: produce and disseminate on a regular basis a summary table on BOP and IIP data consistency (identifying initial stock, transactions, other changes, and final stock).

### Consistency within dataset and with other datasets; errors and omissions
- BOP statistics are consistent within the dataset; concepts, definitions, and classifications same for quarterly and annual statistics.
- Quarterly reconciliation table prepared every quarter reconciling BOP transactions with changes in IIP position; minor differences identified for 2004-2005.
- Net errors and omissions:
  - 1996: - US$23 million
  - 2000: - US$54 million
  - 2002: - US$643 million
  - 2004: - US$628 million
  - During 1995–2005, errors and omissions averaged -4 percent of the gross domestic product (GDP), -8.5 percent of the international trade of goods and services, and were equivalent to 146 percent of Bolivia’s current account deficit.
- The CBB estimates that the errors and omissions item will be relatively low in 2006.
- Recommendations:
  - Closely monitor the BOP errors and omissions.
  - Produce and disseminate regularly a summary table on BOP and IIP data consistency.
  - In coordination with the GOI, compare data on selected external debt transactions with the Joint BIS-IMF-OECD-World Bank external debt table and the BIS locational banking statistics.
  - Reconcile regularly trade data using partner-country data to adjust for possible differences in coverage.
  - Establish regular mechanisms for enhancing data consistency with national accounts statistics.
  - Prepare and disseminate a table on quarterly reserve assets reconciliation between monetary and BOP statistics.
  - Revise the data series prior to 2006 to reclassify Bolivia’s contributions to FLAR from reserve assets to other CBB’s external assets.

### Specific note: natural gas, petroleum, and related products
- Customs administration is the sole source for exports and imports of natural gas, petroleum, and related products.
- Other BOP transactions related to hydrocarbons (services, investment income, direct investment, and other financial transactions) compiled by CBB based on surveys and direct reporting from YPFB.
- BOP data on exports and imports of natural gas, petroleum and related products are consistent with merchandise trade statistics; adjustment made to imports to obtain f.o.b. values. Customs data are reconciled with hydrocarbons’ exports and imports data provided by YPFB.

*Source: _cr07283 - 3.1       Source       data*

### 4.3 Revision policy and practice

### 4.3 Revision policy and practice

### 4.3.1 Revisions follow a regular and transparent schedule
- In general, the data revisions are associated with the availability of source data.
- The revision cycle is predetermined and reasonably stable from year to year.
- Each quarter, BOP data for the previous four quarters are revised, and annual revisions are carried out when needed and applied to historical data as appropriate.
- Nevertheless, the revision cycle and the reasons underlying the cycle are not formally made known to the public.
- Recommendations:
  - (1) Strengthen data revision policies and practices; and
  - (2) publicize the revision cycle for BOP data on the CBB website.

### 4.3.2 Preliminary and/or revised data are clearly identified
- At the time of data dissemination, statistics are clearly identified as preliminary or revised.

### 4.3.3 Studies and analyses of revisions are made public (see also 3.5.1)
- Analyses of revisions are mainly available within the CBB.
- When major data revision occur, comments and explanations are included in the corresponding CBB’s BOP publication.

*Source: _cr07283 - 4.3 Revision policy and practice*

### Appendix III. DATA QUALITY ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK—GENERIC FRAMEWORK

### Appendix III. DATA QUALITY ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK—GENERIC FRAMEWORK (JULY 2003 FRAMEWORK)

### Prerequisites of quality
- 0.1 Legal and institutional environment—The environment is supportive of statistics
  - 0.1.1 The responsibility for collecting, processing, and disseminating the statistics is clearly specified.
  - 0.1.2 Data sharing and coordination among data-producing agencies are adequate.
  - 0.1.3 Individual reporters’ data are to be kept confidential and used for statistical purposes only.
  - 0.1.4 Statistical reporting is ensured through legal mandate and/or measures to encourage response.
- 0.2 Resources—Resources are commensurate with needs of statistical programs.
  - 0.2.1 Staff, facilities, computing resources, and financing are commensurate with statistical programs.
  - 0.2.2 Measures to ensure efficient use of resources are implemented.
- 0.3 Relevance—Statistics cover relevant information on the subject field.
  - 0.3.1 The relevance and practical utility of existing statistics in meeting users’ needs are monitored.
- 0.4 Other quality management—Quality is a cornerstone of statistical work.
  - 0.4.1 Processes are in place to focus on quality.
  - 0.4.2 Processes are in place to monitor the quality of the statistical program.
  - 0.4.3 Processes are in place to deal with quality considerations in planning the statistical program.

### Assurances of integrity
- 1.1 Professionalism—Statistical policies and practices are guided by professional principles.
  - 1.1.1 Statistics are produced on an impartial basis.
  - 1.1.2 Choices of sources and statistical techniques as well as decisions about dissemination are informed solely by statistical considerations.
  - 1.1.3 The appropriate statistical entity is entitled to comment on erroneous interpretation and misuse of statistics.
- 1.2 Transparency—Statistical policies and practices are transparent.
  - 1.2.1 The terms and conditions under which statistics are collected, processed, and disseminated are available to the public.
  - 1.2.2 Internal governmental access to statistics prior to their release is publicly identified.
  - 1.2.3 Products of statistical agencies/units are clearly identified as such.
  - 1.2.4 Advance notice is given of major changes in methodology, source data, and statistical techniques.
- 1.3 Ethical standards—Policies and practices are guided by ethical standards.
  - 1.3.1 Guidelines for staff behavior are in place and are well known to the staff.

### Methodological soundness
- 2.1 Concepts and definitions—Concepts and definitions used are in accord with internationally accepted statistical frameworks.
  - 2.1.1 The overall structure in terms of concepts and definitions follows internationally accepted standards, guidelines, or good practices.
- 2.2 Scope—The scope is in accord with internationally accepted standards, guidelines, or good practices.
  - 2.2.1 The scope is broadly consistent with internationally accepted standards, guidelines, or good practices.
- 2.3 Classification/sectorization—Classification and sectorization systems are in accord with internationally accepted standards, guidelines, or good practices.
  - 2.3.1 Classification/sectorization systems used are broadly consistent with internationally accepted standards, guidelines, or good practices.
- 2.4 Basis for recording—Flows and stocks are valued and recorded according to internationally accepted standards, guidelines, or good practices.
  - 2.4.1 Market prices are used to value flows and stocks.
  - 2.4.2 Recording is done on an accrual basis.
  - 2.4.3 Grossing/netting procedures are broadly consistent with internationally accepted standards, guidelines, or good practices.

### Accuracy and reliability
- 3.1 Source data – Source data available provide an adequate basis to compile statistics.
  - 3.1.1 Source data are obtained from comprehensive data collection programs that take into account country-specific conditions.
  - 3.1.2 Source data reasonably approximate the definitions, scope, classifications, valuation, and time of recording required.
  - 3.1.3 Source data are timely.
- 3.2 Assessment of source data—Source data are regularly assessed.
  - 3.2.1 Source data—including censuses, sample surveys, and administrative records—are routinely assessed, e.g., for coverage, sample error, response error, and nonsampling error; the results of the assessments are monitored and made available to guide statistical processes.
- 3.3 Statistical techniques—Statistical techniques employed conform to sound statistical procedures.
  - 3.3.1 Data compilation employs sound statistical techniques to deal with data sources.
  - 3.3.2 Other statistical procedures (e.g., data adjustments and transformations, and statistical analysis) employ sound statistical techniques.
- 3.4 Assessment and validation of intermediate data and statistical outputs—Intermediate results and statistical outputs are regularly assessed and validated.
  - 3.4.1 Intermediate results are validated against other information where applicable.
  - 3.4.2 Statistical discrepancies in intermediate data are assessed and investigated.
  - 3.4.3 Statistical discrepancies and other potential indicators or problems in statistical outputs are investigated.
- 3.5 Revision studies—Revisions, as a gauge of reliability, are tracked and mined for the information they may provide.
  - 3.5.1 Studies and analyses of revisions are carried out routinely and used internally to inform statistical processes (see also 4.3.3).

### Serviceability
- 4.1 Periodicity and timeliness—Periodicity and timeliness follow internationally accepted dissemination standards.
  - 4.1.1 Periodicity follows dissemination standards.
  - 4.1.2 Timeliness follows dissemination standards.
- 4.2 Consistency—Statistics are consistent within the dataset, over time, and with major datasets.
  - 4.2.1 Statistics are consistent within the dataset.
  - 4.2.2 Statistics are consistent or reconcilable over a reasonable period of time.
  - 4.2.3 Statistics are consistent or reconcilable with those obtained through other data sources and/or statistical frameworks.
- 4.3 Revision policy and practice—Data revisions follow a regular and publicized procedure.
  - 4.3.1 Revisions follow a regular and transparent schedule.
  - 4.3.2 Preliminary and/or revised data are clearly identified.
  - 4.3.3 Studies and analyses of revisions are made public (see also 3.5.1).

### Accessibility
- 5.1 Data accessibility—Statistics are presented in a clear and understandable manner, forms of dissemination are adequate, and statistics are made available on an impartial basis.
  - 5.1.1 Statistics are presented in a way that facilitates proper interpretation and meaningful comparisons (layout and clarity of text, tables, and charts).
  - 5.1.2 Dissemination media and format are adequate.
  - 5.1.3 Statistics are released on a preannounced schedule.
  - 5.1.4 Statistics are made available to all users at the same time.
  - 5.1.5 Statistics not routinely disseminated are made available upon request.
- 5.2 Metadata accessibility—Up-to-date and pertinent metadata are made available.
  - 5.2.1 Documentation on concepts, scope, classifications, basis of recording, data sources, and statistical techniques is available, and differences from internationally accepted standards, guidelines, or good practices are annotated.
  - 5.2.2 Levels of detail are adapted to the needs of the intended audience.
- 5.3 Assistance to users—Prompt and knowledgeable support service is available.
  - 5.3.1 Contact points for each subject field are publicized.
  - 5.3.2 Catalogs of publications, documents, and other services, including information on any charges, are widely available.

*Source: Appendix III. DATA QUALITY ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK—GENERIC FRAMEWORK (JULY 2003 FRAMEWORK) from provided content.*

### Appendix IV. USERS’ SURVEY — Bolivia (January 2007)

### Survey design and response
- Questionnaires sent to a broad range of users including academics, banks, nonbank financial institutions, government agencies, business associations, international organizations, and the media.
- Surveys were sent to 329 targeted users, with 85 of them submitting responses resulting in a 26 percent response rate.
- Reported respondent groups and response rates by group (as presented):
  - Banks: Sent 39, Received 12, Response Rate 31%
  - Business associations: Sent 33, Received 11, Response Rate 33%
  - International Organizations: Sent 10, Received 3, Response Rate 30%
  - Media: Sent 25, Received 14, Response Rate 56%
  - Nonbank financial corporations: Sent 48, Received 12, Response Rate 25%
  - Private nonfinancial corporations: Sent 17, Received 3, Response Rate 18%
  - Public sector analysts: Sent 97, Received 36, Response Rate 37%
  - Universities: Sent 60, Received 7, Response Rate 12%
  - Total: Sent 329, Received 85, Response Rate 26%

### Uses of official statistics (Table 9)
- Which official statistics are used regularly:
  - National accounts (NA) 65%
  - Prices 73%
  - Government finance statistics (GFS) 62%
  - Monetary statistics (Monetary) 81%
  - Balance of payments (BOP) 54%
  - Other series and percentages:
    - Production indices 36%
    - Labor market 33%
    - Merchandise trade 28%
    - International reserves and foreign currency liquidity 43%
    - External debt 49%
    - International investment position 35%
    - Other 12%
- Where users obtain official statistics:
  - Official press releases and publications on macroeconomic statistics 81%
  - Private sector summaries and analyses 54%
  - Official policy papers 47%
  - Publications from international organizations about the country 56%
  - Other sources 25%
- Reference to official descriptions of sources and methods:
  - Yes 67%
  - No 33%
- Purposes for use (multiple responses allowed):
  - Analysis of current developments for short-term decision making 77%
  - Analysis of trends for longer-term policy formulation 73%
  - Econometric model building and forecasting 32%
  - Economic research 63%
  - Comparison with economic developments in other countries 42%
  - General economic background 53%
  - Other 17%

### Overall user evaluations and sectoral variations
- Average rating for the overall quality of official statistics on a five point scale (1 = poor and 5 = excellent): 3.5.
- Variation among dataset averages: up to 0.9 difference between the highest (monetary) and the lowest (government finance statistics).
- Perception of comparability with neighboring countries:
  - 66 percent of all respondents felt Bolivia’s statistics were of comparable quality to those disseminated by neighboring countries.
  - 28 percent rated the quality as worse.

### Methodological soundness, accuracy, and reliability (user perceptions)
- 81 percent of respondents felt that the statistics were reliable.
- 62 percent felt that official statistics are unbiased and accurate.
- Accuracy/reliability by dataset (highest and lowest reported):
  - Monetary statistics: 75 percent rated accuracy and reliability highest.
  - Government finance statistics: 52 percent rated accuracy and reliability lowest.

### Coverage, detail, periodicity, timeliness, and accessibility (Table 9 summary)
- Coverage and level of detail (overall averages):
  - Satisfied with coverage (average) 85%
  - Satisfied with level of detail (average) 80%
- Periodicity and timeliness:
  - Satisfied with frequency of compilation (average) 76%
  - Satisfied with timeliness (average) 54%
  - Dataset-specific timeliness:
    - National accounts: 38% satisfied with timeliness
    - Monetary statistics: 69% satisfied with timeliness
- Dissemination practices and revisions:
  - Awareness of publicly disseminated release calendar: 15% overall (Yes), 85% overall (No)
  - Perception that releases follow announced dates: 33% overall (Yes), 67% overall (No)
  - Sufficient information about revisions: 55% overall (Yes), 45% overall (No)
- Accessibility and metadata:
  - Overall accessibility to official statistics: 78% positive response rate (satisfactory).
  - Satisfaction with accessibility to metadata: 40% satisfied.
  - Only 30% felt that available metadata was sufficiently clear or detailed enough to be useful.
  - Primary means of access:
    - Official websites: 76% of respondents relied on this method.
    - Next most popular: hard copy publications.

### Written user comments and priorities (grouped)
- Users requested greater regional breakdown of statistics, particularly for national accounts.
- Requests for more detailed government finance statistics.
- Calls for improved periodicity and timeliness for most datasets.
- Interest in new data series such as a producer price index and forward-looking indicators.
- Additional user suggestions were grouped under:
  - (1) prerequisites of quality
  - (2) methodological soundness
  - (3) accuracy and reliability
  - (4) serviceability
  - (5) accessibility
  - (6) general comments

*Source: Appendix IV. Users’ Survey and Tables extracted from the provided content.*

### 8. Accessibility

### _cr07283 - 8. Accessibility

### Accessibility: survey results
- 8.1 Can you easily access the official statistics?
  - Yes 73% 76% 65% 91% 84% 60% 78%
  - No 27% 24% 35% 9% 16% 40% 22%
- 8.2 Can you easily access information pertaining to official statistics you use (explanatory notes, methodological descriptions, reference concerning concepts, classification, statistical practice)?
  - Yes 38% 49% 30% 44% 38% 14% 40%
  - No 62% 51% 70% 56% 62% 86% 60%
- 8.3 Is the above information on methodology sufficiently clear and at an adequate level of detail to be useful to you?
  - Yes 30%
  - No 42%
  - No Opinion 28%

### How users access official statistics (8.4)
- Official releases 35%
- Hard copy publications 59%
- Data specifically requested 23%
- Official website 76%
- Other 4%
- E-mail requests 22%

### Overall assessment (Section 9)
- 9.1 In your opinion, is the underlying methodology of official statistics sound and appropriate?
  - Yes 75% 81% 75% 89% 83% 100% 81%
  - No 25% 19% 25% 11% 17% 0% 19%
- 9.2 In general, do you consider the official statistics to be unbiased and accurate?
  - Yes 61% 58% 52% 75% 62% 50% 62%
  - No 39% 42% 48% 25% 38% 50% 38%
- 9.3 How would you compare the quality of official statistics of the country with those of other countries in the region?
  - Better 3% 5% 3% 15% 4% 0% 6%
  - Same 66% 67% 57% 70% 70% 57% 66%
  - Worse 31% 28% 40% 15% 26% 43% 28%
- 9.4 How do you assess the overall quality of the official statistics? (1 rated = poor; 5 = excellent)
  - 3.3 3.5 3.1 4.0 3.6 1.7 3.5

(Note: NA = National Accounts; Prices refer to: CPI (Consumer Price Index) and PPI (Producer Price Index); GFS = Government Finance Statistics; MS = Monetary Statistics; and BOP = Balance of Payments Statistics)

### Appendix V. Bolivia: Comments by Users of Macroeconomic Statistics
- 1. Prerequisites of quality
  - Improvements in the quality of official statistics should be given greater priority by increasing resources for censuses and surveys, such as in the areas of employment, manufacturing, and investment.
  - Other surveys should be conducted that permit economic programming in the short, medium, and long-term horizon.
  - Household surveys are not apparently included in the budget of the NSI and they depend on external financing for this activity. I hope that this policy is not viewed as correct since household surveys are major function of the NSI.
- 2. Methodological soundness
  - The base year for national accounts and prices should be updated.
  - Government finance statistics have been improving in terms of their coverage, timeliness, quality, and transparency thanks to the continued efforts of government agencies in charge of data compilation. Nonetheless, there still needs to be improvements in the statistics in order to meet international standards.
  - There have been advances in availability and accessibility of official statistics; however, methodologies applied, periodicity of the data, and timeliness should be improved.
- 3. Accuracy and reliability
  - It is necessary to improve the quality of the balance of payments and national accounts statistics.
  - Statistics on public investment are deficient in terms of reliability, timeliness, and detail.
- 4. Serviceability
  - The greatest concern is poor timeliness in publication of official statistics, which lessens usefulness.
  - Data disseminated by the NSI suffer from poor timeliness, reducing its prestige as a statistical provider of excellence.
  - Coverage and timeliness of national accounts statistics should be improved.
  - Labor statistics should have greater periodicity (monthly or quarterly) and be timely; current labor statistics are clearly deficient.
  - Balance of payments statistics lack final historical data and show significant inconsistencies among different government agencies.
  - Data provided by the Ministry of Finance could be improved in presentation, clarity, timeliness, and level of detail; presenting improved data on their website would be significant.
  - Existing discrepancies in official statistics should be explained; there should be greater coordination among providers.
- 5. Accessibility
  - Information on methodology should be clear and easily accessible. Public, private, and foreign investment data should be produced.
  - The NSI should have a faster website; downloads take too long even with broadband.
  - Statistics on national accounts and government finance require better information on methodology and notification of release dates.
  - It is difficult to obtain methodological information on the CBB website; it takes longer to search for information on the CBB’s website compared with other similar websites.
  - Monetary and financial statistics should be disseminated on a daily basis, with greater detail.
  - The internet should be used more often to disseminate data and metadata; delivery could be more effective and personalized.
  - There is not enough information on the type of data available and the means of access.
  - Source data should be made available for users, when requested.
  - Official statistics should be disseminated more widely, not only on the internet but also via other means such as the radio, magazines, etc.
- 6. General comments
  - The new regional context of the country requires precise and timely statistics by region and, if possible, by municipality.
  - Greater detail in national accounts statistics should be produced to facilitate sectoral analysis.
  - More detailed data is needed, especially for national accounts, government finance, and balance of payments.
  - Forward leading indicator surveys should be developed to obtain references of level of economic activity.
  - Provision of producer price indices or wholesale price indices would be of great use.
  - In general, there is ease of access to official statistics; however, the level of detail is not sufficient in many datasets (e.g., some data are only available on an annual basis when monthly evolution is necessary).
  - Monetary and financial statistics are of excellent quality thanks to the efforts of the CBB and SBFE.
  - Merchandise trade data requires greater detail in terms of region, product, and country.
  - Statistics on household income by region are needed.
  - Official statistics should be more in line with international standards to enhance comparability.

*Source: _cr07283 - 8. Accessibility*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07283.pdf_
