## _cr07389

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr07389](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07389.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07389.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07389.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary — background and context
- Current-account deficit could reach a record level of 20 percent of GDP in 2007.
- Net capital inflows in 2007 could top 30 percent of GDP; about one third of net capital inflows during 2004–07 added to international reserves.
- The external imbalance finances an investment boom; private consumption has remained contained.
- Real GDP growth: just over 6 percent.
- Headline HICP inflation surged into double digits in recent months; underlying wage growth is accelerating.
- Largely foreign-owned banking system appears well positioned, but credit growth is strong and credit portfolios should be monitored.

### Nature and drivers of the boom — key findings
- Widening current-account deficit and absorption boom largely financed by FDI and other capital inflows.
- Absorption boom primarily reflects a private investment boom:
  - Private investment-GDP ratio surged well above its historical average during 2004–06.
  - Private consumption-GDP ratio remained close to average.
- Drivers of private investment boom include:
  - Currency board anchoring stability-oriented policies and relatively low risk-free real interest rates.
  - Marked improvement in country-risk perceptions and asset prices (sovereign bonds, equity, real estate).
- About one third of net capital inflows during 2004–07 were added to international reserves.

### Macroeconomic and sectoral indicators (selected)
- Current-account deficit projected at about 20 percent of GDP in 2007.
- Net capital inflows in 2007 could top 30 percent of GDP.
- Real GDP growth: just over 6 percent.
- Inflation: headline HICP surged into double digits recently.
- Recent export volume growth: 11 percent during 2004–06.
- Real GDP (percent): 2004: 6.6; 2005: 6.2; 2006: 6.1; 2007: 6.4; 2008 (Proj.): 6.3.
- Selected macro series (2004 2005 2006 2007Proj. 2008Proj.):
  - Real domestic demand: 8.1 12.2 12.5 11.0 5.4
  - Consumer price index (HICP, average): 6.1 6.0 7.4 7.2 7.8
  - Consumer price index (HICP, end of period): 4.0 7.4 6.1 9.5 4.9
  - Nominal wages: 6.0 9.5 9.4 18.9 17.6
    - Public sector wages: 7.1 11.3 9.1 16.9 16.2
    - Private sector wages: 7.0 10.4 10.0 21.4 18.8

### External competitiveness and sustainability
- Staff equilibrium current-account deficit estimates centered around 8 percent of GDP (subject to considerable uncertainty).
- Macroeconomic balance approach suggests a current-account deficit norm somewhat above 5 percent of GDP.
- External sustainability (stabilizing net IIP at about 80 percent of GDP, ignoring EU capital grants) points to a sustainable current-account deficit of about 8 percent of GDP.
- Expected EU capital grants about 2 percent of GDP, implying sustainable deficit could be correspondingly higher.
- Real effective exchange rate appreciation has been moderate; purchasing-power-parity and dollar-wage comparisons suggest prices and costs remain broadly competitive.
- Regression-based estimates of the real equilibrium exchange rate do not indicate substantial overvaluation.

### External balance-sheet: net IIP, liabilities, and trade
- Net IIP deteriorating fast; net IIP could deteriorate to about 65 percent of GDP in 2007 (Table 4) and projected to stabilize at some 80 percent of GDP by 2012 (Table 10a).
- External liabilities rising steeply in 2007; gross external debt projected to stabilize only at about 93 percent of GDP.
- Short-term debt more than fully covered by international reserves; coverage of short-term debt by international reserves would remain above 100 percent.
- Coverage of current-account deficit by net FDI inflows projected to decline to half its present level over the medium term.
- Trade indicators (selected):
  - Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2005: -12.0; 2006: -15.7; 2007: -20.2; 2008 (Proj.): -18.5; 2012 (Proj.): -8.3.
  - Merchandise trade balance (percent of GDP): 2005: -20.2; 2006: -22.2; 2007: -26.2; 2008 (Proj.): -25.5 (from macro table).

### Banking sector, credit growth, and financial stability
- Credit growth accelerated to over 50 percent after administrative limits on bank credit lapsed at end-2006 (Tables 6-7).
- In September 2007 the BNB raised reserve requirements from 8 to 12 percent and signaled readiness to adopt additional measures if needed.
- Financial soundness indicators (2004–2007, selected):
  - Capital to risk-weighted assets: 2004: 16.6; 2005: 15.3; 2006: 14.5; 2007 (end-June): 14.4.
  - Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets: 2004: 14.4; 2005: 12.5; 2006: 11.8; 2007 (end-June): 11.6.
  - Nonperforming loans to total gross loans (percent): 2004: 2.0; 2005: 2.2; 2006: 2.2; 2007 (end-June): 2.2.
  - Return on assets (percent): 2004: 2.1; 2005: 2.0; 2006: 2.2; 2007 (end-June): 2.2.
  - Return on equity (percent): 2004: 19.6; 2005: 21.4; 2006: 25.0; 2007 (end-June): 24.4.
- Banks’ exposures to booming real estate market remain limited; purchases by nonresidents are key market driver.
- Local interbank markets small and volatile; trends follow euro markets.
- Monetary/credit indicators (selected):
  - Broad money (M3, annual % change): 2004: 23.1; 2005: 23.9; 2006: 26.9; 2007: 28.5; 2008 (Proj.): 24.3.
  - Domestic credit (annual % change): 2004: 48.7; 2005: 32.4; 2006: 24.6; 2007: 52.5; 2008 (Proj.): 26.2.
  - Domestic private sector credit, stock (percent of GDP): 2003: 27.0; 2004: 36.2; 2005: 47.4; 2006: 59.1; 2007 (Proj.): 75.7.

### Labor market and inflation dynamics
- Unemployment plummeted from about 20 percent in 2000 to less than 7 percent by 2007.
- Employment growth: 2004: 2.6; 2005: 2.7; 2006: 2.4; 2007: 2.6; 2008 (Proj.): 1.9.
- Nominal wage growth accelerated: nominal wages (2004–2008): 6.0 9.5 9.4 18.9 17.6.
- Headline inflation driven by one-off effects (summer drought, EU accession on food prices, higher global energy prices); core inflation picked up more slowly.
- Small estimated output gap of some 1 percent in 2007; capacity pressures remain moderate.

### Fiscal stance, public finances, and outlook
- Fiscal policy achieved progressively larger surpluses since 2004, mainly due to unspent revenue windfalls.
- Underlying fiscal position likely close to balance.
- Budgeted fiscal surplus of ¾ percent of GDP for 2007 based on conservative revenue projections; actual surplus likely to reach 3½ percent of GDP.
- Selected government finance series (percent of GDP or labeled):
  - Revenue: 38.4 39.8 39.0 40.5 40.5
  - Expenditure: 36.7 37.5 35.5 37.0 37.0
  - Fiscal balance: 1.7 2.3 3.5 3.5 3.5
  - Gross public debt: 40.1 31.3 24.7 21.3 20.2
  - Financial net worth: 8.8 9.3 11.8 13.8 15.6
- 2008 draft budget projects a surplus of 3 percent of GDP; staff warns risks from large public wage increases and a flat 10 percent personal income tax (estimated revenue loss of some ½ percent of GDP).

### Structural reform challenges and priorities
- Where EU legislation enforces homogeneity, reform progress is at par with peers; where EU accession provides weak anchors, progress slow.
- Main weaknesses: public sector efficiency (corruption, red tape, judiciary, education), costly administrative burdens for businesses, labor market rigidities.
- Priorities:
  - Strengthen public-sector efficiency and monitoring (education, health care).
  - Simplify licensing and permits; improve investment climate and lower cost of doing business.
  - Amend Labor Code to increase flexibility (wages, benefits, overtime, part-time work); improve intersectoral mobility; limit duration of social benefits.
  - Complete privatization efforts (including Bulgartabak Holding AD) and improve market competition, notably in energy markets.
  - Start-up of electronic commercial register on January 1, 2008.

### Outlook and scenarios
- Baseline medium-term ("soft landing") scenario assumptions and projections:
  - External environment remains favorable.
  - Capital inflows normalize as excess-return investment opportunities are exhausted, investment spending and imports sharply slow over medium term (Table 10a).
  - Current-account deficit declines to about 8 percent of GDP over the medium term.
  - Inflation recedes gradually to some 3½ percent by medium term (2012 projection for HICP average: 3.5).
  - Real effective exchange rate appreciates in line with fundamentals; sustainable currency board maintained.
- Alternative loose fiscal and incomes scenario (risks summarized):
  - Public-sector wages hiked well above productivity trends; fiscal stance turns sharply expansionary.
  - Higher domestic inflation, deterioration in external competitiveness, weakening tradables sectors, possible temporary higher GDP growth driven by nontradables.
  - Under the currency board, real exchange rate would become significantly overvalued, risking abrupt external adjustment or prolonged slow growth.
- Baseline macro projections (selected, 2005–2012):
  - Baseline real GDP growth (annual percent): 2005: 6.2; 2006: 6.1; 2007: 6.4; 2008 (Proj.): 6.3; 2012 (Proj.): 7.0.
  - Baseline current account (percent of GDP): 2005: -12.0; 2006: -15.7; 2007: -20.2; 2008 (Proj.): -18.5; 2012 (Proj.): -8.3.
  - Baseline gross international reserves (millions of euros): 2005: 7,370; 2006: 8,926; 2007: 11,674; 2008 (Proj.): 14,154; 2012 (Proj.): 20,120.

### External balance-sheet vulnerabilities and medium-term projections
- Net IIP projected to stabilize at some 80 percent of GDP by 2012 (Table 10a).
- Gross external debt projected to stabilize at about 93 percent of GDP by 2012.
- Medium-term current-account deficit excluding interest payments would need to shrink to some 4 percent of GDP to stabilize gross external debt (Appendix I).
- Gross international reserves (GIR, percent of GDP): 2005: 33.7; 2006: 35.6; 2007: 40.5; 2008 (Proj.): 42.9; 2012 (Proj.): 40.6.
- Gross external debt (in percent of GDP): 2005: 69.0; 2006: 78.4; 2007: 87.6; 2008 (Proj.): 92.7; 2012 (Proj.): 93.3.

### Financial sector policy, supervision, and capital markets
- Administrative limits on bank credit growth were ineffective; rapid credit growth warrants careful monitoring.
- Authorities’ supervisory strategy:
  - Prudent implementation of Basel II: keep minimum capital-adequacy ratio at 12 percent; maintain standardized approach until sufficient data for internal ratings.
  - Re-evaluate banks’ internal risk-management systems; strengthen cross-border cooperation with parent supervisors.
  - Active participation in EU financial stability coordination and planned FSAP update in 2008.
- Capital market development:
  - Expand role of local private debt and stock markets to reduce maturity mismatch and reliance on foreign funding.
  - Authorities should increase enforcement of regulations, educate the public on stock market risks, and consider tighter listing requirements.

### Statistical data quality and recommendations
- Overall assessment: data provision adequate for surveillance but significant weaknesses remain.
- Key data weaknesses:
  - Sectoral flow-of-funds data for households and nonfinancial corporates are sketchy.
  - Employment and wage data difficult to interpret due to grey economy measurement problems.
  - Balance of payments and trade data subject to frequent and substantial revisions; INTRASTAT implementation created data uncertainties (40 percent of first-half reporters recorded zero).
- Recommended improvements:
  - Further improvements in national accounts coverage (particularly private sector).
  - Develop sectoral flow-of-funds accounts for households and nonfinancial corporations.
  - Improve employment and wage data quality and reconcile high-frequency activity data with quarterly/annual national accounts.
  - Clarify trade data uncertainties since EU accession.

### Staff views — broad conclusions and policy priorities
- Major concerns:
  - Current-account deficit ballooned to unprecedented levels and must be reduced to avoid unsustainable increases in external net liabilities.
  - Rapid credit growth and rising inflationary pressures increase vulnerability to risk-premia reassessments.
  - Delayed structural reforms constrain sustainable real convergence.
- Policy recommendations (selected):
  - Maintain prudent fiscal and incomes policies; avoid procyclical demand pressures.
  - Strengthen and accelerate structural reforms to raise public-sector efficiency and productivity of human and real resources.
  - Monitor bank credit portfolios and risk management closely; ensure sufficient buffers in banking sector.
  - Reorient spending toward public infrastructure and human capital; keep medium-term expenditure-GDP ratio below 40 percent of GDP.
  - Preserve wage discipline in the public sector; partly offset large public wage increases by reducing public-sector employment.
  - Strengthen capital market regulation and supervision; enforce regulations and consider tighter listing requirements.
  - Build buffers against adverse shocks while sustaining external competitiveness and supporting currency-board arrangement and euro adoption objective.

### Authorities’ position and IMF relations
- Authorities broadly agreed with staff diagnosis and policy proposals; see no viable alternative to currency board arrangement.
- Authorities intend to maintain exchange rate peg to euro (lev 1.95583 per €1) and pursue ERM2 entry and fast-track euro adoption while acknowledging challenges (Maastricht Treaty low-inflation criterion).
- Article IV mission: October 4–16, 2007, in Sofia.
- IMF-related financial arrangements and status as reported (selected):
  - Stand-by 08/06/2004 — 03/31/2007 — Amount approved (SDR million) 100.00 — Amount drawn (SDR million) 0.00
  - Previous arrangements and EFF noted in Fund records.

*Source: _cr07389 — IMF staff report and Public Information Notice excerpts (Article IV consultation, October–December 2007).*

### Executive Summary

### Executive Summary

### Background and context
- Driven by massive capital inflows, the current-account deficit could reach a record level of 20 percent of GDP in 2007.
- The external imbalance finances an investment boom; private consumption, reflecting restrained fiscal and incomes policies, has remained contained.
- Net capital inflows in 2007 could top 30 percent of GDP; about one third of net capital inflows during 2004–07 added to international reserves.
- Real GDP growth has remained steady at just over 6 percent, with a still moderate output gap estimate.
- Headline inflation (HICP) has surged into double digits in recent months, mainly owing to food- and energy-price shocks; underlying wage growth is accelerating due to a tightening labor market.
- The largely foreign-owned banking system appears well positioned to absorb adverse shocks, but credit growth is strong and credit portfolios should be monitored carefully.

### Key findings: nature and drivers of the boom
- The widening current-account deficit and absorption boom are largely financed by foreign direct investment (FDI) and other capital inflows.
- The absorption boom primarily reflects a private investment boom:
  - The private investment-GDP ratio surged well above its historical average during 2004–06.
  - The private consumption-GDP ratio remained close to average.
- Bulgaria’s private investment boom likely reflects a one-off re-assessment of the country as an investment location, linked to:
  - A currency board that has anchored stability-oriented policies and relatively low risk-free real interest rates.
  - A marked improvement in country-risk perceptions and asset prices (sovereign bonds, equity, real estate) in recent years.
- About one third of net capital inflows during 2004–07 were added to international reserves, so capital inflows have financed both the external deficit and reserve accumulation.

### Macroeconomic and sectoral indicators (selected)
- Current-account deficit projected at about 20 percent of GDP in 2007.
- Net capital inflows in 2007 could top 30 percent of GDP.
- Real GDP growth: just over 6 percent.
- Inflation: headline HICP surged into double digits recently.
- During 2004–06, changes in savings-investment balances indicate foreign savings financed a boom in private investment.
- The tradables sectors’ investment share has held up well during the investment boom; acquisition of capital assets by sectors shows substantial investment allocation to nontradables but tradables investment share remained broadly unchanged.

### Risks and vulnerabilities
- Main challenge: maintaining prudent fiscal and incomes policies to avoid procyclical demand impulses that could exacerbate external vulnerabilities.
- Failure to keep fiscal and incomes policies in line with the stringent requirements of the currency board could result in:
  - A misaligned real exchange rate, likely entailing an abrupt external adjustment or a prolonged period of slow growth.
- Rapid credit growth during boom conditions may mask underlying credit quality weaknesses.
- Recent asset price appreciations and lower country-risk scores could reflect reassessed investor perceptions; however, much FDI has been absorbed by nontradables sectors, raising concerns about export prospects.

### Staff views and policy recommendations
- Maintain prudent fiscal and incomes policies to avoid adding procyclical demand impulses.
- Strengthen and accelerate long-delayed structural reforms, particularly those raising public sector efficiency.
- Monitor credit portfolios closely to detect and address possible deterioration in credit quality amid the boom.
- Policies should provide a solid basis for sustaining the currency-board arrangement and achieving Bulgaria’s medium-term ambition of accelerated real convergence and deeper EU integration, including euro adoption.
- Build buffers against adverse shocks while keeping policies consistent with sustaining external competitiveness.

### Authorities’ position
- The authorities broadly agreed with the staff’s diagnosis and policy proposals.
- They see no viable alternative to the currency board arrangement; policies must therefore remain consistent with sustaining external competitiveness while increasing buffers against adverse shocks.

*Source: _cr07389 - Executive Summary.*

### 6.      The widening current-account deficit has not been accompanied by a

### _cr07389 - 6.      The widening current-account deficit has not been accompanied by a

### External competitiveness and the current-account
- Staff estimates of Bulgaria’s equilibrium current-account deficit are centered around 8 percent of GDP, subject to considerable margins of uncertainty (Box 2).
- The macroeconomic balance approach (panel data for 38 industrial and transition countries for 1992–2006) suggests Bulgaria’s current-account deficit norm is somewhat above 5 percent of GDP.
- External sustainability considerations based on stabilizing the net international investment position (IIP) at a medium-term level of about 80 percent of GDP (ignoring EU capital grants) point to a sustainable current-account deficit of about 8 percent of GDP.
- Bulgaria is likely to receive EU capital grants amounting to about 2 percent of GDP, implying the sustainable current-account deficit could be correspondingly higher.
- Real effective exchange appreciation over recent years has been moderate relative to conventional relationships between the exchange rate and the current account.
- Purchasing-power-parity and dollar-wage comparisons across countries, and recent trends in export market shares, suggest Bulgaria’s prices and costs remain broadly competitive.
- Regression-based estimates of the real equilibrium exchange rate do not indicate signs of substantial overvaluation.

### Net IIP and external liabilities
- Bulgaria’s net IIP is deteriorating fast.
- External financial liabilities continued their steep upward climb in 2007, and the net IIP could deteriorate to about 65 percent of GDP (Table 4).
- External liabilities represent mostly FDI and long-term debt.
- Short-term debt is more than fully covered by international reserves.
- The widening currency mismatch position of nonfinancial corporates (excluding intercompany loans) is a concern, reflecting rapidly growing and at least partly unhedged corporate borrowing abroad.

### Trade and exports
- Recent export volume growth was 11 percent during 2004-06.
- Export market shares have increased in all major export destinations.
- A constant market share analysis at SITC 1-digit product level indicates some erosion of competitiveness relative to other low- and middle-income countries during 2004–05, albeit following large gains during 2001–03.

### Banking sector, credit growth, and financial stability
- Since administrative limits on bank credit lapsed at end-2006, credit growth has accelerated to over 50 percent (Tables 6-7).
- In September 2007 the BNB raised reserve requirements from 8 to 12 percent and noted readiness to adopt additional measures to moderate credit growth if needed.
- Financial soundness indicators suggest the largely foreign-owned banking sector remains well capitalized and profitable (Figure 4, Table 8).
- Nonperforming loan ratios remain low, though partly reflecting rapid loan portfolio growth.
- Banks’ exposures to the booming real estate market remain limited, as purchases by nonresidents have been the key market driver.
- Since late July (2007), sovereign-bond spreads and credit-default swap rates have widened from a very low base, mirroring developments in other vulnerable transition economies.
- Local interbank markets have been small and volatile but have followed trends in euro markets.

### Labor market and inflation dynamics
- Unemployment has plummeted, but Bulgaria’s employment rate remains relatively low.
- Public-sector employment has been cut back significantly, while private-sector employment has expanded considerably.
- Nominal wage growth accelerated across sectors, with the private sector in the lead.
- Recent increases in headline HICP inflation reflect in large part one-off effects from the summer drought, EU accession on food prices, and higher global energy prices.
- Core inflation has picked up in response to rising labor cost, albeit at a much slower pace than headline inflation.
- Overall capacity pressures remain moderate, with the small estimated output gap of some 1 percent in 2007.

### Fiscal stance and public finances
- Since 2004, fiscal policy has achieved progressively larger surpluses, mainly due to unspent revenue windfalls associated with the absorption boom.
- Staff calculations suggest the present underlying fiscal position is likely close to balance.
- The budgeted fiscal surplus of ¾ percent of GDP for 2007 was based on highly conservative revenue projections (Table 5).
- Notwithstanding recent policy decisions (pensions raised by an additional 10 percent effective October 1; social contribution rate cut by 3 percentage points), the surplus is likely to reach 3½ percent of GDP.
- Bulgaria’s general government balance sheet is strong, with gross public debt (about 20 percent of GDP) and other liabilities more than offset by the fiscal reserve and other assets.

### Structural reform challenges
- Progress on structural reforms is at par with peers where EU legislation enforces regulatory homogeneity (price liberalization, trade, foreign exchange system).
- Where EU accession provides a weak reform anchor, progress has been slow:
  - Public sector efficiency is low (indicators for corruption, red tape, quality of judiciary, education standards).
  - Businesses face costly administrative burdens, particularly a complex registration system.
  - Labor market rigidities hinder reallocation of labor from low- to higher-productivity sectors and raise concerns about wage flexibility under adverse shock scenarios.
- Sustainable real convergence ultimately depends on raising productivity of human and real resources.

### Outlook and external stability risks (baseline medium-term scenario)
- A soft landing remains a viable baseline medium-term scenario under which:
  - The external environment, including global growth, remains favorable.
  - Capital inflows normalize as excess-return investment opportunities are exhausted, entailing sharply slowing investment spending and imports over the medium term (Table 10a).
  - Absorption growth would gradually decline below GDP growth, lowering the current-account deficit to about 8 percent of GDP, broadly consistent with staff’s equilibrium estimates (Box 2).
  - After the sharp increase in inflation in the current year, inflation is projected to recede gradually to some 3½ percent as the absorption boom dissipates, supported by stability-oriented fiscal and incomes policies, low import-price inflation, and steady progress on structural reforms.
  - External competitiveness would be preserved, with the real effective exchange rate appreciating in line with medium-term fundamentals, consistent with a sustainable currency board.

*Source: Fund staff estimates.*

### 17.      But the economy would remain saddled with significant external balance-sheet

### _cr07389 - 17.      But the economy would remain saddled with significant external balance-sheet

### External balance-sheet vulnerabilities and projections
- The net IIP would deteriorate further, albeit at a slowing pace, stabilizing at some 80 percent of GDP by 2012 (Table 10a).
- Gross external debt would only stabilize at about 93 percent of GDP.
- The medium-term current-account deficit excluding interest payments would need to shrink to some 4 percent of GDP to stabilize gross external debt (Appendix I).
- Coverage of the current-account deficit by net FDI inflows is projected to decline to half its present level over the medium term.
- Coverage of short-term debt by international reserves would remain above 100 percent.
- Such a legacy of high external indebtedness would markedly increase Bulgaria’s vulnerability to future adverse shocks, particularly if euro adoption were delayed beyond 2012.

### Risks, alternative scenarios, and transmission channels
- Staff cautioned that a soft landing may not necessarily materialize, even under prudent policies, because:
  - If the investment boom reflects irrational exuberance regarding expected risks and returns, a correction of capital and credit flows could be sharp and sudden, mimicking a boom-bust cycle.
  - Given already significant external balance-sheet vulnerabilities, such a correction could be particularly damaging.
- Authorities’ view: vulnerabilities, including in the corporate sector, would be well matched by large precautionary buffers in the balance sheets of the central bank, the government, and the banking system—provided policies remain prudent.
- Analytical limits: both authorities and staff agreed the analytical and empirical understanding of what drives Bulgaria’s high external deficits remains imperfect; historical analogies (e.g., 1990s Asian crisis) could be misleading.
- Alternative loose fiscal and incomes scenario (summary from Figure 9 and text):
  - Public-sector wages could be hiked well above productivity trends, boosting private-sector wages.
  - Fiscal stance could turn sharply expansionary (Table 10b, Figure 9).
  - Consequences: higher domestic inflation, deterioration of external cost and price competitiveness, weakening tradables sectors, possible temporary higher GDP growth driven by nontradables.
  - Under the currency board constraint, the real exchange rate would become significantly overvalued, possibly entailing an abrupt external adjustment or prolonged slow growth to restore competitiveness.

### Euro adoption objective
- Early euro adoption remains the authorities’ umbrella objective.
- Immediate goal: joining ERM2; authorities willing to provide firm and detailed policy commitments to their European partners.
- Authorities aim to adopt the euro on a fast-track basis after ERM2 entry, but acknowledge the road could be prolonged and difficult, with the Maastricht Treaty’s low-inflation criterion an especially formidable hurdle.

### Fiscal policy framework and recommendations
- Authorities’ commitments and strategy:
  - Maintain a broadly balanced structural fiscal position over the medium term.
  - Keep the medium-term expenditure-GDP ratio below 40 percent of GDP.
  - Reorient spending toward public infrastructure and human capital formation, supported by EU grants.
  - Continue shifting the tax structure toward indirect taxation; reduce direct tax rates (notably on labor) while broadening tax bases to combat the grey economy.
- Staff cautions and specific points:
  - Recent surge in the tax-GDP ratio is likely temporary.
  - Recent steep cuts in social contribution rates already require substantial budget transfers to keep the pay-as-you-go pension system afloat.
  - Urged allowing automatic fiscal stabilizers to operate fully during the remainder of 2007; resist pressures to increase spending given rising inflationary pressures.
- 2008 budget considerations and risks:
  - Draft 2008 budget approved by the cabinet projects a surplus of 3 percent of GDP, roughly in line with an unchanged fiscal stance.
  - Risks identified by staff:
    - Wages: Teachers were granted a wage increase of about 45 percent; assuming no further strikes with similar hikes, average budget wages still projected to increase by 16 percent.
      - Authorities plan to limit wage-bill impact by stepping up cuts in public employment, though this could prove difficult.
    - Personal income tax: Draft 2008 budget envisages a flat 10 percent personal income tax (10 percent corporate tax already in place), eliminating most exemptions.
      - Staff estimated likely revenue loss of some ½ percent of GDP and suggested compensating measures, including raising real-estate taxation.
      - Authorities believe revenue losses will be smaller due to shrinkage of the grey economy and higher excises on tobacco and fuel.
    - Capital budget: Draft budget projects capital spending to rise to about 7 percent of GDP in 2008, up from 6 percent of GDP in 2007, financed by a similar increase in EU grants.
      - Staff concern: increased infrastructure spending could add undesirable demand impulses to an already overheated construction sector; authorities noted early signs of slowing residential construction outside Sofia.
- Fiscal transparency progress:
  - 2008 draft budget will be based on a single surplus target during preparation and authorization.
  - Discontinuation of prior practice of across-the-board sequestration; inclusion of a contingency reserve in the 2008 budget.
  - Staff: important to establish clear and transparent rules for contingency reserve use.

### Financial sector policy and supervision
- Credit controls and credit growth:
  - Administrative limits on bank credit growth proved ineffective; while banks observed limits during 2005–06, corporations and households found alternative credit sources and overall credit extension remained brisk.
- Supervisory stance and measures:
  - Rapid bank credit growth warrants careful monitoring.
  - Authorities envisage prudent implementation of Basel II:
    - Keep the minimum capital-adequacy ratio at 12 percent (the highest ratio among new member states).
    - Maintain the standardized approach until sufficient data are available for internal ratings.
  - Authorities re-evaluating banks’ internal risk-management systems.
  - Strengthened cross-border cooperation with parent supervisors of foreign banks and intend active participation in future EU financial stability coordination exercises.
- Additional supervisory notes:
  - Basel II capital-adequacy standards apply since January and should help encourage more risk-based management of credit portfolios.
  - With foreign banks centralizing liquidity and risk management, cross-border cooperation with other supervisors needs further strengthening.
  - Bulgaria’s active participation in future efforts to improve the EU’s cross-border crisis management arrangements is welcome.
- Capital market development:
  - Scope to expand role of local private debt and stock markets to reduce maturity mismatch and reliance on foreign funding in the banking sector.
  - Nonfinancial enterprises not expected to be major local bond issuers in short term; rise in local IPOs indicates greater use of stock market for capital.
  - Concern that a large stock-market correction could damage market development, reputational costs, and pension-fund performance.
  - Authorities should further increase enforcement of regulations, educate the public about stock market risks, and consider tighter listing requirements in the local stock market.
  - Planned FSAP update in 2008 should provide an opportunity to assess strengths and vulnerabilities.

### Structural reform priorities
- Improve business climate:
  - Start-up of the electronic commercial register on January 1, 2008.
  - Further simplify licensing and permit systems.
  - Progress on privatization (including Bulgartabak Holding AD) and improving market competition, particularly in energy markets.
- Labor market reforms:
  - Amend the overly prescriptive Labor Code to provide social partners more flexibility to set wages, benefits, seniority bonuses, overtime and part-time work.
  - Improve intersectoral mobility.
  - Improve incentives for education and training.
  - Put limits on duration of social benefits to stimulate work effort.
- Public-sector efficiency:
  - Design action plans for reviewing spending and programs in key budget sectors, notably education and health care.
  - Introduce effective systems for monitoring and evaluating policy implementation in the public sector.
- Improve investment climate by lowering the cost of doing business.

### Staff appraisal: broad conclusions and policy priorities
- Macroeconomic performance:
  - Real GDP growth averaged about 6 percent during 2003–06; unemployment dropped sharply.
- Major concerns:
  - The current-account deficit has ballooned to unprecedented levels and must be reduced to avoid unsustainable increases in external net financial liabilities and payment obligations.
  - Recent credit tensions highlight vulnerability to rapid reassessments of risk premia.
  - Inflationary pressures rising, reflecting one-off shocks and accelerating wage increases.
  - Important structural reforms to raise public-sector efficiency have been delayed.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Maintain a prudent policy framework while tackling difficult structural reforms.
  - Fiscal and incomes policies should avoid procyclical demand pressures; retool spending and tax levers to accelerate real convergence and productivity growth, including efficient absorption of EU funds.
  - Banking supervisors should closely monitor banks’ risk management and ensure sufficient buffers to absorb large adverse shocks.
  - Implement long-delayed structural reforms to raise efficiency of human and real resources and provide incentives to expand available resources.
  - Uphold prudent fiscal and incomes policies as the first line of defense to preserve the sustainability of the currency board; maintain wage discipline in the public sector and compensate large public wage increases partly by reducing public-sector employment.
  - Strengthen capital market regulation and supervision; enforce regulations, educate the public about stock market risks, and consider tighter listing requirements.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt (chapter text provided).*

### 36.      While Bulgaria’s statistical data are broadly adequate for surveillance, there

### _cr07389 - 36.      While Bulgaria’s statistical data are broadly adequate for surveillance, there

### Statistical data quality: strengths and weaknesses
- While Bulgaria’s statistical data are broadly adequate for surveillance, there are significant weaknesses.
- Sectoral flow-of-funds data:
  - The sectoral flow-of-funds data for households and nonfinancial corporates are sketchy, impeding the understanding of vulnerabilities in these sectors.
- Labor market and wages:
  - Bulgaria’s employment and wage data are difficult to interpret, partly reflecting difficult-to-measure changes in the grey economy.
- External sector data:
  - Given the focus on Bulgaria’s widening external imbalance, clarification of uncertainties regarding the trade data that have emerged since EU accession would be desirable.

### Surveillance schedule
- It is proposed that the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

### Output, prices, and labor market (selected series: 2004 2005 2006 2007Proj. 2008Proj.)
- Real GDP: 6.6 6.2 6.1 6.4 6.3
- Real domestic demand: 8.1 12.2 12.5 11.0 5.4
- Consumer price index (HICP, average): 6.1 6.0 7.4 7.2 7.8
- Consumer price index (HICP, end of period): 4.0 7.4 6.1 9.5 4.9
- Employment: 2.6 2.7 2.4 2.6 1.9
- Nominal wages: 6.0 9.5 9.4 18.9 17.6
  - Public sector wages: 7.1 11.3 9.1 16.9 16.2
  - Private sector wages: 7.0 10.4 10.0 21.4 18.8

### General government finances (percent of GDP or as labeled)
- Revenue: 38.4 39.8 39.0 40.5 40.5
- Expenditure: 36.7 37.5 35.5 37.0 37.0
- Fiscal balance: 1.7 2.3 3.5 3.5 3.5
- Privatization proceeds: 3.0 3.4 1.5 0.5 0.6
- External financing: -1.6 -5.6 -1.9 -0.5 0.9
- Domestic financing: -3.2 0.0 -3.1 -3.5 -5.5
- Gross public debt: 40.1 31.3 24.7 21.3 20.2
- Financial net worth: 8.8 9.3 11.8 13.8 15.6

### Money, credit, and interest rates
- Broad money (M3): 23.1 23.9 26.9 28.5 24.3
- Domestic credit: 48.7 32.4 24.6 52.5 26.2
- Euro, six-month LIBOR: 2.1 2.2 3.1 4.0 4.1
- Interbank rate: 2.6 2.0 2.7 ...... 
- Lending rate: 8.8 8.7 8.9 ...... 
- Real lending rate (HICP adjusted): 2.6 2.5 1.4 ......

### Balance of payments and external sector
- Current account balance: -6.6 -12.0 -15.7 -20.2 -18.5
- Merchandise trade balance: -14.9 -20.2 -22.2 -26.2 -25.5
- Capital and financial account balance: 14.3 15.1 21.5 30.6 26.0
- Foreign direct investment balance: 7.9 17.7 16.8 14.6 9.6
- International investment position: -30.8 -43.1 -52.8 -64.7 -72.7
- Gross official reserves: 34.5 33.7 35.6 40.5 42.9
- Gross external debt: 63.8 69.0 78.4 87.6 92.7

### Exchange rates and competitiveness
- Leva per euro
- Leva per U.S. dollar (end of period): 1.46 1.65 1.48 ...... 
- Real effective exchange rate
  - CPI based (percentage change): 5.0 0.6 4.3 5.3 5.7
  - GDP deflator based (percentage change): 3.6 1.8 6.3 6.3 5.6

### Social indicators (reference year in parentheses)
- Per capita GNI (Atlas method, 2006): US $3,990
- Poverty rate (2001): 12.8 percent
- Life expectancy at birth (2005):

*Source: _cr07389 - 36.      While Bulgaria’s statistical data are broadly adequate for surveillance, there*

### 72.6 years;

### _cr07389 - 72.6 years;

### Social indicators
- Life expectancy: 72.6 years;
- Infant mortality per 1,000 live births (2005): 12;
- Income distribution (Gini index, 2003): 29.2;
- Primary education completion rate (2005): 98.3;
- Sources: Bulgarian authorities; Fund staff estimates and projections; and World Development Indicators database.

### Real GDP, demand composition, and implicit deflators (2004–08, selected)
- Currency board peg to euro at lev 1.956 per euro.
- Real GDP growth (percent): 2004: 6.6; 2005: 6.2; 2006: 6.1; 2007: 6.4; 2008 (Proj.): 6.3.
- Contribution to real GDP growth, annual percent:
  - Domestic demand: 2004: 8.1; 2005: 12.2; 2006: 12.5; 2007: 11.0; 2008 (Proj.): 5.4.
  - Net exports (contribution): 2004: -4.5; 2005: -6.7; 2006: -9.3; 2007: -8.0; 2008 (Proj.): -1.3.
- Gross investment (percent change): 2004: 13.5; 2005: 23.3; 2006: 17.6; 2007: 19.7; 2008 (Proj.): 6.4.
- Private investment (including inventories, percent change): 2004: 12.6; 2005: 21.4; 2006: 20.0; 2007: 16.0; 2008 (Proj.): 3.2.
- GDP deflator (percent change): 2004: 5.1; 2005: 3.8; 2006: 8.1; 2007: 8.0; 2008 (Proj.): 7.5.

### Balance of payments and external sector (2005–12, selected)
- Current account balance (millions of euros): 2005: -2,622; 2006: -3,935; 2007: -5,817; 2008 (Proj.): -6,087; 2012 (Proj.): -4,119.
- Merchandise trade balance (millions of euros): 2005: -4,410; 2006: -5,562; 2007: -7,549; 2008 (Proj.): -8,404; 2012 (Proj.): -8,526.
- Exports (f.o.b., millions of euros): 2005: 9,466; 2006: 12,012; 2007: 12,971; 2008 (Proj.): 14,941; 2012 (Proj.): 23,103.
- Imports (f.o.b., millions of euros): 2005: -13,876; 2006: -17,574; 2007: -20,520; 2008 (Proj.): -23,345; 2012 (Proj.): -31,629.
- Services balance (millions of euros): 2005: 818; 2006: 971; 2007: 1,268; 2008 (Proj.): 1,726; 2012 (Proj.): 4,279.
- Income balance (millions of euros): 2005: 151; 2006: -6; 2007: -189; 2008 (Proj.): -313; 2012 (Proj.): -845.
- Capital and financial account balance (millions of euros): 2005: 3,306; 2006: 5,399; 2007: 8,819; 2008 (Proj.): 8,568; 2012 (Proj.): 4,821.
- Foreign direct investment balance (millions of euros): 2005: 3,871; 2006: 4,227; 2007: 4,199; 2008 (Proj.): 3,156; 2012 (Proj.): 1,983.
- Gross international reserves (increase = -, millions of euros): 2005: -324; 2006: -1,506; 2007: -2,747; 2008 (Proj.): -2,481; 2012 (Proj.): -702.
- Memorandum (percent of GDP): Current account balance: 2005: -12.0; 2006: -15.7; 2007: -20.2; 2008 (Proj.): -18.5; 2012 (Proj.): -8.3.
- GDP (millions of euros): 2005: 21,882; 2006: 25,100; 2007: 28,849; 2008 (Proj.): 32,963; 2012 (Proj.): 49,542.

### External financial assets and liabilities (2005–12, selected)
- International investment position (millions of euros): 2005: -9,427; 2006: -13,240; 2007: -18,666; 2008 (Proj.): -23,956; 2012 (Proj.): -39,684.
- Financial assets (millions of euros): 2005: 13,391; 2006: 16,880; 2007: 18,950; 2008 (Proj.): 21,962; 2012 (Proj.): 30,578.
- Financial liabilities (millions of euros): 2005: 22,818; 2006: 30,120; 2007: 37,616; 2008 (Proj.): 45,918; 2012 (Proj.): 70,261.
- Gross international reserves (GIR, millions of euros): 2005: 7,370; 2006: 8,926; 2007: 11,674; 2008 (Proj.): 14,154; 2012 (Proj.): 20,120.
- GIR (in percent of GDP): 2005: 33.7; 2006: 35.6; 2007: 40.5; 2008 (Proj.): 42.9; 2012 (Proj.): 40.6.
- Net international investment position (in percent of GDP): 2005: -43.1; 2006: -52.8; 2007: -64.7; 2008 (Proj.): -72.7; 2012 (Proj.): -80.1.
- Gross external debt (in percent of GDP): 2005: 69.0; 2006: 78.4; 2007: 87.6; 2008 (Proj.): 92.7; 2012 (Proj.): 93.3.

### General government operations and balance sheet (2004–08, selected)
- Revenue (millions of leva): 2004: 14,918; 2005: 17,030; 2006: 19,140; 2007 (Proj.Budget): 20,411; 2008 (Proj.): 26,210.
  - Taxes (millions of leva): 2004: 11,869; 2005: 13,579; 2006: 15,513; 2007 (Proj.Budget): 16,583; 2008 (Proj.): 18,558.
  - Social security contributions (millions of leva): 2004: 3,171; 2005: 3,505; 2006: 3,496; 2007 (Proj.Budget): 3,601; 2008 (Proj.): 3,880.
- Expenditure (millions of leva): 2004: 14,249; 2005: 16,056; 2006: 17,416; 2007 (Proj.Budget): 20,060; 2008 (Proj.): 20,871.
  - Current expenditure (millions of leva): 2004: 12,640; 2005: 13,569; 2006: 14,742; 2007 (Proj.Budget): 16,957; 2008 (Proj.): 17,209.
  - Social benefits (millions of leva): 2004: 5,445; 2005: 5,987; 2006: 6,766; 2007 (Proj.Budget): 7,425; 2008 (Proj.): 7,386.
  - Pensions (millions of leva): 2004: 3,457; 2005: 3,715; 2006: 4,149; 2007 (Proj.Budget): 4,390; 2008 (Proj.): 4,498.
- Capital expenditure (millions of leva): 2004: 1,473; 2005: 2,039; 2006: 2,325; 2007 (Proj.Budget): 2,797; 2008 (Proj.): 3,355.
- Fiscal balance (millions of leva): 2004: 670; 2005: 974; 2006: 1,724; 2007 (Proj.Budget): 351; 2008 (Proj.): 1,979.
- Gross public debt (millions of leva): 2004: 15,559; 2005: 13,387; 2006: 12,120; 2007 (Proj.): ...; 2008 (Proj.): ...
- Nominal GDP (millions of leva): 2004: 38,823; 2005: 42,797; 2006: 49,091; 2007 (Proj.): 51,141; 2008 (Proj.): 56,424.

### Monetary accounts and credit (2005–12, selected)
- Monetary survey (millions of leva):
  - Net foreign assets: 2005: 13,221; 2006: 18,634; 2007: 19,860; 2008 (Proj.): 18,819; 2012 (Proj.): 38,146.
  - Broad money (M3): 2005: 25,260; 2006: 32,061; 2007: 38,233; 2008 (Proj.): 41,185; 2012 (Proj.): 96,896.
  - Deposits (millions of leva): 2005: 19,864; 2006: 25,831; 2007: 31,302; 2008 (Proj.): 33,970; 2012 (Proj.): 85,080.
- Base money (millions of leva): 2005: 8,351; 2006: 10,482; 2007: 12,684; 2008 (Proj.): 13,163; 2012 (Proj.): 20,118.
- Domestic private sector credit (annual percent change): 2003: 9.1; 2004: 12.2; 2005: 14.6; 2006: 17.7; 2007 (Proj.): 24.3.
  - Households credit growth (annual percent change): 2003: 3.2; 2004: 4.8; 2005: 6.4; 2006: 7.5; 2007 (Proj.): 9.3.
- Domestic private sector credit, stock (percent of GDP): 2003: 27.0; 2004: 36.2; 2005: 47.4; 2006: 59.1; 2007 (Proj.): 75.7.

### Financial soundness and banking sector indicators (2004–07, selected)
- Capital adequacy:
  - Capital to risk-weighted assets: 2004: 16.6; 2005: 15.3; 2006: 14.5; 2007 (end-June): 14.4.
  - Tier 1 capital to risk-weighted assets: 2004: 14.4; 2005: 12.5; 2006: 11.8; 2007 (end-June): 11.6.
- Asset quality:
  - Nonperforming loans to total gross loans (percent): 2004: 2.0; 2005: 2.2; 2006: 2.2; 2007 (end-June): 2.2.
- Profitability:
  - Return on assets (percent): 2004: 2.1; 2005: 2.0; 2006: 2.2; 2007 (end-June): 2.2.
  - Return on equity (percent): 2004: 19.6; 2005: 21.4; 2006: 25.0; 2007 (end-June): 24.4.
- Liquidity:
  - Liquid assets to total assets (percent): 2004: 30.1; 2005: 28.7; 2006: 31.0; 2007 (end-June): 24.9.
  - Liquid assets to short-term liabilities (percent): 2004: 34.7; 2005: 33.1; 2006: 35.7; 2007 (end-June): 29.0.

### Competitiveness and structural indicators (selected rankings)
- EBRD transition indicators (selected): Price liberalization: 2005–2007: 100; Trade and foreign exchange system: 2005–2007: 100.
- World Bank Doing Business survey (selected positions change): Getting credit: 2005: 89; 2006: 93; 2007: ...; Protecting investors: 2005: 82; 2006: 82; 2007: ... .
- Transparency International Corruption Perception Index: 2005: 40; 2006: 40; 2007: 41; 2008: 46; 2009: 49; 2010: 51.

### Macroeconomic framework — Baseline and Alternative scenarios (2005–12, selected)
- Baseline real GDP growth (annual percent): 2005: 6.2; 2006: 6.1; 2007: 6.4; 2008 (Proj.): 6.3; 2012 (Proj.): 7.0.
- Baseline consumer price index (HICP, average): 2005: 6.0; 2006: 7.4; 2007: 7.2; 2008 (Proj.): 7.8; 2012 (Proj.): 3.5.
- Baseline broad money (annual percent change): 2005: 23.9; 2006: 26.9; 2007: 28.5; 2008 (Proj.): 24.3; 2012 (Proj.): 13.6.
- Baseline current account (percent of GDP): 2005: -12.0; 2006: -15.7; 2007: -20.2; 2008 (Proj.): -18.5; 2012 (Proj.): -8.3.
- Baseline gross international reserves (millions of euros): 2005: 7,370; 2006: 8,926; 2007: 11,674; 2008 (Proj.): 14,154; 2012 (Proj.): 20,120.
- Alternative scenario highlights (Table 10b): Real GDP growth (2008–12, annual percent): 2008 (Proj.): 7.9; 2009 (Proj.): 8.1; 2012 (Proj.): 7.8; Nominal GDP (millions of euros) 2008 (Proj.): 34,319; 2012 (Proj.): 62,744.

### Debt sustainability (external and public sector, 2005–12, selected)
- Baseline external debt (percent of GDP): 2005: 69.0; 2006: 78.4; 2007: 87.6; 2008 (Proj.): 92.7; 2012 (Proj.): 93.3.
- Change in external debt (percent of GDP): 2006: 5.2; 2007: 9.4; 2008 (Proj.): 9.2; 2009 (Proj.): 5.2; 2012 (Proj.): -3.9.
- Identified external debt-creating flows (percent of GDP): 2005: 0.4; 2006: -2.1; 2007: 4.0; 2008 (Proj.): 5.2; 2012 (Proj.): -1.2.
- External debt-to-exports ratio (percent): 2005: 115.8; 2006: 121.8; 2007: 143.3; 2008 (Proj.): 150.1; 2012 (Proj.): 143.0.
- Gross external financing requirement (in percent of GDP): 2005: 40.5; 2006: 40.2; 2007: 45.9; 2008 (Proj.): 46.9; 2012 (Proj.): 46.8.
- Baseline public sector debt (percent of GDP): 2005: 31.3; 2006: 24.7; 2007: 21.3; 2008 (Proj.): 20.2; 2012 (Proj.): 14.8.
- Change in public sector debt (percent of GDP): 2006: -8.8; 2007: -6.6; 2008 (Proj.): -3.4; 2009 (Proj.): -1.1; 2012 (Proj.): -3.3.
- Identified public debt-creating flows (percent of GDP): 2005: -2.6; 2006: -9.3; 2007: -4.7; 2008 (Proj.): -4.3; 2012 (Proj.): -1.5.
- Primary deficit (percent of GDP): 2005: -3.9; 2006: -4.8; 2007: -4.7; 2008 (Proj.): -4.6; 2012 (Proj.): -1.7.
- Public sector debt-to-revenue ratio (percent): 2005: 78.6; 2006: 63.3; 2007: 52.6; 2008 (Proj.): 49.8; 2012 (Proj.): 38.1.
- Key macro assumptions underlying baseline:
  - Real GDP growth (percent): 2005: 6.2; 2006: 6.1; 2007: 6.4; 2008 (Proj.): 6.3; 2012 (Proj.): 7.0.
  - Nominal external interest rate (percent): 2005: 3.2; 2006: 3.0; 2007: 3.3; 2008 (Proj.): 3.4; 2012 (Proj.): 4.6.
  - Growth of exports (US dollar terms, percent): 2005: 16.1; 2006: 25.0; 2007: 17.3; 2008 (Proj.): 17.5; 2012 (Proj.): 14.3.
  - Current account balance excluding interest payments (percent of GDP): 2005: -10.1; 2006: -13.9; 2007: -18.1; 2008 (Proj.): -15.9; 2012 (Proj.): -4.3.

*Sources: Bulgarian authorities; BNB; NSI; Ministry of Finance; WEO; Fund staff estimates and projections.*

### APPENDIX II: BULGARIA: FUND RELATIONS

### APPENDIX II: BULGARIA: FUND RELATIONS

### Article IV mission and IMF team
- Date and place of Article IV mission: October 4–16, 2007, in Sofia. The concluding statement of the mission was posted at www.imf.org on October 16, 2007.
- Country interlocutors: Prime Minister Stanishev, Minister of Finance Oresharski, Minister of Economy and Energy Dimitrov, Minister of Labor and Employment Maslarova, BNB Governor Iskrov, other senior officials, representatives of parliament, international organizations including the European Commission and European Central Bank, financial sector, and think tanks. Mr. Yotzov (OED) attended the discussions.
- IMF team: Messrs. Jaeger (head) and Herderschee, Ms. Zhou (all EUR), Ms. Rahman (PDR), Ms. Arvai (MCM), Mr. Fernandez-Ansola (Senior Regional Resident Representative), and Ms. Mihaylova (Resident Economist).

### Political and data context
- Political developments: In recent local elections, a new party Citizens for Bulgaria’s European Development (GERB) performed strongly. Parliamentary elections are scheduled for 2009, but the GERB party has called for early parliamentary elections.
- Previous Article IV consultation: The previous consultation was concluded on August 2, 2006, and the reports were posted at www.imf.org on August 8, 2006.
- Data: Bulgaria subscribes to the SDDS, and economic data are adequate to conduct effective surveillance (Appendix III).

### Exchange rate arrangement and membership
- Exchange rate arrangement: The currency of Bulgaria is the Bulgarian lev. Since July 1, 1997, the Bulgarian National Bank has operated a currency board arrangement. The peg currency is the euro at the rate of lev 1.95583 per €1.
- Payments system: Bulgaria maintains an exchange system that is free of restrictions on the making of payments and transfers for current international transactions, except for restrictions that are maintained for security reasons and that have been notified to the Fund pursuant to Executive Board Decision No. 144-(52/51).
- Membership status: Joined 09/25/1990; Article VIII.

### IMF financial position and arrangements
- Quota and Fund position (as printed):
  - Quota 640.20; 100.00
  - Fund holdings of currency 606.9594.81
  - Reserve position 33.28; 5.20
- SDR Department:
  - Holdings 0.58N/A
  - 48
- Implementation of HIPC Initiative: Not Applicable.
- Implementation of Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative (MDRI): Not Applicable.
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans: None.
- Latest financial arrangements (as printed):
  - Stand-by 08/06/2004 — 03/31/2007 — Amount approved (SDR million) 100.00 — Amount drawn (SDR million) 0.00
  - Stand-by 02/27/2002 — 03/15/2004 — Amount approved (SDR million) 240.00 — Amount drawn (SDR million) 240.00
  - EFF 09/25/1998 — 09/24/2001 — Amount approved (SDR million) 627.62 — Amount drawn (SDR million) 627.62
- Projected Payments to Fund: None.

*Source: APPENDIX II: BULGARIA: FUND RELATIONS, as of October 31, 2007.*

---

### APPENDIX III. BULGARIA: IMF-WORLD BANK RELATIONS

### Partnership and Country Partnership Strategy (CPS)
- World Bank CPS discussed June 13, 2006 (roadmap for FY07-09) — strategic priorities:
  - (i) productivity and employment;
  - (ii) fiscal sustainability and absorption of EU funds;
  - (iii) social inclusion.
- CPS includes a three-year program of three development policy loans (DPLs) of up to US$150 million each to support institutional reforms in the social sectors.
- CPS program includes a pipeline of investment lending in road and municipal infrastructure, trade and transport facilitation for South East Europe, social inclusion, and regional development.

### Division of labor between IMF and World Bank
- IMF lead: macroeconomic stability, fiscal, income, and external sector policies; analyses feed World Bank policy formulation and advice.
- World Bank lead: core structural aspects of reforms (education, health, social protection). Shared responsibility: financial sector, public expenditure management and budgeting, tax administration.

### Areas of collaboration and specific programs
- Financial Sector:
  - Joint IMF-World Bank FSAP for Bulgaria in late 2001; follow-up by Fund staff in March–April 2004; update scheduled for 2008.
  - Key FSAP findings used as conditionalities under SBA and PAL program.
- Revenue Administration:
  - Joint efforts led to the Revenue Administration Reform Project (€31.9 million), approved 2003.
  - New National Revenue Agency operational on January 1, 2006, integrating tax and social security revenue collection.
- Public Expenditure Management:
  - World Bank led reviews: Public Expenditure and Institutional Review (2002) and Public Finance Policy Review (2006); a second Public Finance Policy Review forthcoming.
- Education:
  - First DPL approved March 2007 supports deepening of education reforms, strengthening institutional capacity of the Ministry of Education and Sciences, school governance and financing.
  - Second Public Finance Policy Review outlines options for vocational education and training and tertiary education reforms.
- Health:
  - Bank supported government through two investment operations and the DPL program; first DPL focused on financial sustainability of national health insurance and efficiency of public spending on pharmaceuticals.
- Social protection:
  - Wide coverage of pensions, labor market programs, social assistance, and family benefits.
  - First DPL supports employment promotion program and changes to eligibility criteria of some social assistance programs to incentivize job search and reduce reliance on welfare.
  - Multi-year poverty monitoring program underway; Bank and government preparing a Social Inclusion Loan to address longer term constraints and facilitate absorption of European Social Fund grants.

### World Bank Group lending and operations statistics
- To date: 41 IBRD operations with a total original commitment of US$2,314 million equivalent:
  - 13 adjustment loans (US$1,225.8 million)
  - 21 investment projects (US$750.7 million)
  - 1 debt reduction loan (US$125.0 million)
  - 4 Bank-managed GEF grants
  - 2 Bank-managed PCF operations
- Of these 41 operations: 29 completed (eleven partially cancelled during implementation), 11 operations currently under implementation.

### Active World Bank operations (selected list and amounts)
- 1. Health Sector Reform — US$63.3 million — Board Date 2000
- 2. Registration and Cadastre — US$30.0 million — Board Date 2001
- 3. Wetlands Restoration and Pollution Reduction (GEF Grant) — US$7.5 million — Board Date 2002
- 4. Social Investment and Employment Promotion — US$50.0 million — Board Date 2002
- 5. Revenue Administration Reform Project — US$34.2 million — Board Date 2003
- 6. District Heating Project — US$34.2 million — Board Date 2003
- 7. District Heating Project (PCF) — US$5.0 million — Board Date 2003
- 8. Energy Efficiency (GEF Grant) — US$10.0 million — Board Date 2005
- 9. First Social Sectors Institutional Reform Development Policy Loan (SIR DPL 1) — US$150.0 million — Board Date 2007
- 10. Second Trade and Transport Facilitation in Southeast Europe (TTFSE 2) — US$52.8 million — Board Date 2007
- 11. Road Infrastructure Rehabilitation — US$122.5 million — Board Date 2007

### IFC activities
- As of July 2007, IFC has 12 projects with total commitments of US$204 million for its own account and an additional US$60 million syndicated from partner banks.
- IFC support includes specialized SME banks, Bulgaria’s first micro lending bank, venture capital fund targeting SMEs, manufacturing investments (cement, electronic assembly, wood panel production, copper processing), retail sector investments, and about US$90 million committed to post-privatization restructuring of a steel mill and two glass processing plants.

*Source: APPENDIX III. BULGARIA: IMF-WORLD BANK RELATIONS.*

---

### APPENDIX IV: BULGARIA: STATISTICAL ISSUES

### Overall assessment
- Data provision is adequate for surveillance purposes.
- Bulgaria moved from participation in the GDDS to SDDS subscription in 2003.
- Despite a comprehensive database, remaining problems include:
  - Further improvements needed in national accounts coverage (particularly private sector).
  - Balance of payments statistics subject to frequent and substantial revisions.
  - Need to reconcile high-frequency activity data with quarterly and annual national accounts.
  - Desirable to develop sectoral flow-of-funds accounts for the household sector and non-financial corporation sector.
  - Improve quality of employment and wage data.
  - Clarify uncertainties regarding trade data since EU accession.

### Real sector statistics
- National accounts:
  - NSI compiles national accounts consistent with SNA 1993 and ESA 1995; GDP data by activity and expenditure compiled and reconciled within an annual supply and use framework.
  - Government output and final consumption are estimated on a cash basis.
  - Published national accounts include current and capital accounts for five main domestic sectors: general government, financial corporations, nonfinancial corporations, nonprofit institutions serving households, and households.
  - Work underway on compiling financial accounts and balance sheets.
- Quarterly GDP:
  - NSI has compiled estimates of quarterly GDP by production and expenditure approaches in current and constant prices since 1994.
  - Preliminary data are disseminated 80 days after the end of the reference quarter with final figures disseminated after approximately 5 quarters.
  - Problems remain in coverage of private sector activities and constant price estimates of capital formation and external trade.
  - Significant progress has been made in development of export and import deflators; estimates at constant prices use chain-linked indices.
- Price indices:
  - NSI produces domestic CPI, HICP according to Eurostat methods, and PPI; all updated monthly.
  - CPI series begins in 1995, PPI in 2000 and HCPI in 2005 (for earlier years it is set equal to the CPI).
  - CPI coverage extended but still excludes owner-occupied housing and health and life insurance; financial services included since 2004.
  - Geographical coverage of the index restricted to 27 urban areas which account for an estimated 65 percent of sales.
- Trade and customs:
  - Flow of customs data has improved significantly; a new system for processing customs records is near completion.
  - Development of export and import unit value indices progressing, with additional Eurostat support expected.
  - NSI Import and Export Division meets monthly with BNB to review data issues and ensure consistency with balance of payments data.
- Labor statistics:
  - Lack of comprehensive labor statistics hampers assessment of employment and wages, especially in private sector, though there have been recent improvements.
  - Annual data collected by NSI using a census of all establishments.
  - Current monthly estimates obtained from a quarterly survey of establishments using all public enterprises and a sample of private employers that excludes establishments with less than five employees.
  - Sample included 14,500 private employers out of approximately 142,000 qualifying private enterprises.
  - Main shortcomings: (i) under-reporting of private sector wages; (ii) reporting of average gross earnings only, not wages for time worked and wages by occupation; (iii) lack of coverage of the self-employed and employment in small firms.
  - NSSI administrative data used to estimate wages by occupation and age and the number of self-employed and employment in small firms.
  - Household budget survey could provide an alternative source for private sector wages.
  - NSI household labor force survey conducted four times a year; improvements needed to make it more consistent with establishment survey, especially regarding agricultural employment.
- Population census:
  - A Population Census conducted in early 2001 is a source for redesigning household surveys, particularly the household budget survey and the labor force survey.

### Government finance statistics
- Progress made on implementing accrual accounting for government, budgetary and statistical systems following combined STA/FAD mission and EU accession fiscal reporting requirements.
- Consolidated data on central government operations routinely reported for publication in the GFS Yearbook and in IFS.
- For the GFS Yearbook 2006, 2005 data for the general government sector and its subsectors were reported on a cash basis.
- Ministry of Finance prepares consolidated government budget execution data monthly; these data do not conform to GFS standards and, while not published in a bulletin format, are posted on the Ministry of Finance’s website.
- Authorities have made progress in presenting data on a disaggregated basis, including expenditure by functional classification; a full economic classification of expenditure is available and provided on an annual basis back to 1998.

*Source: APPENDIX IV: BULGARIA: STATISTICAL ISSUES.*

### 10.       In 2002, the BNB began to harmonize progressively its data collection and

### 10. In 2002, the BNB began to harmonize progressively its data collection and compilation methods in line with the ECB’s framework for monetary statistics.

### Harmonization with ECB framework
- The BNB began progressive harmonization in 2002 of its data collection and compilation methods in line with the ECB’s framework for monetary statistics.
- Recent work in mid-2006 aimed at fully meeting the remaining ECB requirements beginning in February 2007.

### Revised data and publication
- The revised data for June 1995 and onward resulting from these efforts are published in IFS.

### Institutional coverage and standards
- Harmonization efforts were undertaken in accordance with 1995 ESA.
- The institutional coverage of monetary financial institutions includes money market funds.

### Consistency of BNB and bank positions
- Consistency in the coverage of the BNB’s claims on banks (which included claims on liquidated banks) and the banks’ liabilities to the BNB improved in January 2003 after the BNB wrote off most of the claims on the liquidated banks.

*Source: _cr07389 - 10. In 2002, the BNB began to harmonize progressively its data collection and compilation methods in line with the ECB’s framework for monetary statistics.*

### 11.      Bulgaria reports monthly balance of payments and external debt data on a regular

### 11.      Bulgaria reports monthly balance of payments and external debt data on a regular

### Data reporting and quality
- Bulgaria reports monthly balance of payments and external debt data on a regular and timely basis.
- Data on reinvested earnings by foreign-owned companies are subject to large revisions due to incomplete responses on surveys used for preliminary estimates.
- In early 2006, the authorities revised the methodology for estimating trade-related transportation receipts and payments to align it more closely with actual costs.
- Since joining the EU in January 2007, trade data with EU countries are being collected following the INTRASTAT system.
- The INTRASTAT implementation created considerable data uncertainties: 40 percent of those who reported trade data for the first half of the year reported a value of zero.
- The authorities expect some revisions in the 2007 trade data later in the year as more complete information becomes available.

### Recent macroeconomic developments (authorities' statement, Dec 17, 2007)
- Real GDP accelerated in the first half of 2007 to 6.4 percent, led primarily by fixed capital investment and to a much lesser extent by private consumption.
- The previously expected growth rate of 6 percent for 2007 is likely to be exceeded.
- Private investment-to-GDP ratio has been surging while the private consumption-to-GDP ratio remains broadly stable.
- CPI increased by almost 7 percent during the summer draught shock; headline inflation in 2007 is expected to exceed earlier projections.
- Core inflation has picked up at a significantly slower pace.
- Unemployment fell from about 20 percent in 2000 to less than 7 percent now.
- Fiscal Reserve Account increased; accumulated reserves were used to buy back and retire all outstanding Brady bonds, make early repurchases to all outstanding loans to the Fund, and prepay a portion of World Bank loans.
- External public debt ratio is expected to fall below 15 percent of GDP by the end 2007.
- Gross external debt has been on the rise since 2003 as private sector debt grew rapidly; a significant part of private external debt (more than one third) is inter-company debt owed to mother companies.
- Authorities plan to uphold the currency board arrangement at the existing exchange rate until Bulgaria joins the EMU and to maintain a zero deviation of the exchange rate after joining ERM II.

### External sector (authorities' view)
- Rapid private investment has translated into a sizable current account deficit.
- In 2007 the external current account deficit may well reach 20 percent of GDP.
- Officials acknowledge uncertainties about the nature, cause, and implications of the external imbalance; view one-off private investment boom as main driver.
- Official foreign reserves have been growing in line with higher imports; reserve coverage has remained broadly stable.
- Short-term debt is fully covered by reserves.

### Fiscal policy (authorities' view)
- Under the currency board arrangement, fiscal policy is key to macroeconomic stability and reducing vulnerabilities.
- Authorities intend to keep running budget surpluses to curb domestic demand and moderate the external account imbalance.
- Revenue in 2007 soared significantly above budget due to growing economic activity, increased employment, higher imports, higher inflation, and improved tax collection.
- By end-November 2007 data, the fiscal surplus was approaching 7 percent of GDP.
- Authorities used part of the revenue windfall to step up investment in infrastructure, EU co-financing, strategic oil-reserves and oil-storage facilities, river-bed corrections, and landslide prevention; extraordinary spending was publicized and approved by parliament.
- Even after extra spending, the overall budget surplus will again be higher than the 3.5 percent recorded in the previous year, and far beyond the 2 percent of GDP initially budgeted.
- The 2008 budget envisages a surplus of at least 3 percent of GDP and introduces a flat 10 percent personal income tax and retains a 10 percent corporate tax rate; most exemptions will be eliminated to broaden the tax base; higher excises on tobacco and fuel are expected to compensate for revenue loss.
- Authorities eliminated across-the-board spending sequestration and introduced a contingency reserve; plan to save most of a possible revenue overperformance.

### Financial sector
- Rapid bank credit expansion has been observed over the last years; credit expansion financed mostly by a strong increase in deposits rather than foreign borrowing.
- Financial soundness indicators show no signs of deterioration; banks remain well capitalized and highly profitable.
- Authorities introduced measures to moderate credit growth: enhancing information, strengthening prudential and regulatory framework, lowering liquidity by administrative limits to bank credit growth.
- Measures proved insufficient; central bank raised minimum reserve requirements from 8 to 12 percent in September and signaled readiness to adopt additional measures if needed.
- Predominance of subsidiaries of foreign banks calls for strengthening cooperation with supervisory authorities of parent banks.
- Authorities participate in efforts to improve the EU's cross-border crisis management arrangement and plan an update of Bulgaria’s FSAP in 2008.

### IMF Executive Board assessment and recommendations (Public Information Notice No. 07/142, December 19, 2007)
- Bulgaria’s current account deficit could reach a record level of 20 percent of GDP in 2007.
- Net international investment position projected to deteriorate to about 65 percent of GDP; gross external debt could soar to about 88 percent of GDP.
- International reserves likely to top 40 percent of GDP by end-2007.
- Real GDP growth in 2007 likely to remain just over 6 percent; headline HICP inflation increased sharply to over 10 percent, mainly owing to food and energy price shocks; core inflation rose more slowly.
- 2007 fiscal surplus projected to reach at least 3½ percent of GDP; gross public debt about 20 percent of GDP.
- Bank credit expansion resumed after lapsing of administrative credit limits; banks well capitalized with low nonperforming loan ratios.
- Directors noted that the current account deficit is unsustainable and must be reduced significantly over the medium term to contain external vulnerabilities.
- Directors supported the authorities’ strategy of maintaining the exchange rate peg until euro adoption and cautioned to guard against loss of external competitiveness.
- Directors welcomed the authorities’ intention to target a large budget surplus in 2008; several Directors suggested an even more restrictive fiscal policy may be needed.
- Importance emphasized of maintaining wage discipline in the public sector and of reviewing spending priorities in education and health care.
- Directors encouraged close monitoring of banks’ risk management and stronger cooperation with parent bank supervisors; welcomed participation in improving EU cross-border crisis management.
- Directors urged decisive progress on structural reforms to raise public sector efficiency, promote labor market participation and adaptability, simplify licensing and permit systems, and activate the electronic commercial register on January 1, 2008.
- Directors concluded Bulgaria’s statistical data are broadly adequate for surveillance but encouraged further enhancements in employment, wage, and trade data and compiling flow of funds for households and nonfinancial corporations.

### Key statistics and projections (as reported)
- Real GDP: 2007 Q2 (Quarterly); 2006 (Annual) — 2007 Q2 growth 6.4 percent; year projection "just over 6 percent" and previously expected 6 percent.
- Inflation: headline HICP over 10 percent in 2007; CPI (average) 2007 projection 7.2; CPI (end of period) 2007 projection 9.5.
- Unemployment: from about 20 percent in 2000 to less than 7 percent now.
- Fiscal surplus: end-November 2007 approaching 7 percent of GDP; 2007 projected at least 3½ percent of GDP; 2006 recorded 3.5 percent of GDP; 2008 budget envisages surplus of at least 3 percent of GDP.
- Gross public debt: about 20 percent of GDP; projected public external debt ratio to fall below 15 percent of GDP by end 2007.
- Current account balance: 2007 may reach 20 percent of GDP (also reported as -20.2 percent in selected indicators table).
- Net international investment position: projected to deteriorate to about 65 percent of GDP.
- Gross external debt: could soar to about 88 percent of GDP.
- International reserves: likely to top 40 percent of GDP by end-2007; gross international reserves reported 40.5 (percent of GDP) in selected indicators table.
- Selected historical indicators (from table "Bulgaria: Selected Economic Indicators, 2002-07"):
  - Real GDP (annual percentage change): 2002 4.5; 2003 5.0; 2004 6.6; 2005 6.2; 2006 6.1; 2007 6.4
  - Consumer price index (average): 2002 5.8; 2003 2.3; 2004 6.1; 2005 6.0; 2006 7.4; 2007 7.2
  - Consumer price index (end of period): 2002 3.8; 2003 5.6; 2004 4.0; 2005 7.4; 2006 6.1; 2007 9.5
  - Employment (annual % change): 2002 0.2; 2003 3.0; 2004 2.6; 2005 2.7; 2006 2.4; 2007 2.6
  - General government overall balance (percent of GDP): 2002 -0.8; 2003 -0.2; 2004 1.7; 2005 2.3; 2006 3.5; 2007 3.5
  - Gross public debt (percent of GDP): 2002 56.2; 2003 48.1; 2004 40.1; 2005 31.3; 2006 24.7; 2007 21.3
  - Financial net worth (percent of GDP): 2002 -10.4; 2003 6.1; 2004 8.8; 2005 9.3; 2006 11.8; 2007 13.8
  - Broad money (M3) (annual % change): 2002 11.9; 2003 19.6; 2004 23.1; 2005 23.9; 2006 26.9; 2007 28.5
  - Credit claims on non-government sector (annual % change): 2002 44.0; 2003 48.3; 2004 48.7; 2005 32.4; 2006 24.6; 2007 52.5
  - Merchandise trade balance (percent of GDP): 2002 -11.3; 2003 -13.7; 2004 -14.9; 2005 -20.2; 2006 -22.2; 2007 -26.2
  - Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2002 -2.4; 2003 -5.5; 2004 -6.6; 2005 -12.0; 2006 -15.7; 2007 -20.2
  - Gross international reserves (percent of GDP): 2002 27.6; 2003 30.5; 2004 34.5; 2005 33.7; 2006 35.6; 2007 40.5
  - Exchange rate regime: Currency board arrangement; Lev 1.956 per Euro

*Source: IMF staff report and Public Information Notice for the 2007 Article IV Consultation with Bulgaria (December 2007).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr07389.pdf_
