## _cr0764

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr0764](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr0764.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr0764.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr0764.pdf.json)

---

### Executive Summary
- Output growth in 2006–07 looks set to be the strongest since 2001.
- Recovery in first three quarters of 2006: about 2¼ percent (annualized), driven by exports, fixed investment, employment, and moderate consumption growth.
- Potential growth rates have declined from around 4 percent in the early 1970s to about 1¼ percent currently.
- Structural constraints: extensive product market regulation and protection, a slow legal system, and a heavy tax burden.
- Export market share: market share declined some 38 percent since 1993 (real exports), and by 23 percent in value terms over the same period.
- Real effective exchange rate and competitiveness:
  - Unit labor cost–based real effective exchange rate appreciated by some 20 percent since 1998 and 2005.
  - Staff estimates a competitiveness gap in the range of 5 to 8 percent at end-2005.
- Labor market developments:
  - Earlier reforms (2003 “Biagi” and earlier laws) led to significant increases in employment.
  - Unemployment rate fell to 7 percent by 2006:Q2.
  - Share of long-term unemployment has remained unchanged (half); unemployment among the old and young remains high; participation rate remained at 63 percent since 2003.
  - “Atypical” contracts reduce labor costs by about 20 percent (estimates).
  - Employment levels and composition (Istat data):
    - Total employment: 2004 = 22,438; 2005 = 22,651; 2006 (Q2) = 23,187.
    - Employees: 2004 = 16,141; 2005 = 16,522; 2006 (Q2) = 17,015.
    - Flexible contracts: 2004 = 3,482; 2005 = 3,756; 2006 (Q2) = 4,078.
    - Self-employed: 2004 = 6,297; 2005 = 6,129; 2006 (Q2) = 6,172.

### Fiscal performance and outlook
- 2006 fiscal performance:
  - Staff estimates general government deficit, net of two large one-off operations, declined to 3.0 percent of GDP in 2006.
  - Headline deficit estimated to have risen to 5.0 percent of GDP in 2006.
  - Two large one-off operations amounting to some 2 percent of GDP (European court-mandated VAT refund on company cars; government’s assumption of railroad-related debt).
- Revenue developments:
  - Revenue buoyancy in 2006 is broad based; a substantial part seems structural.
  - Authorities attribute part of revenue gains to commitment to eschew tax amnesties and combat tax evasion (2007 budget does include a limited amnesty for social security contributions).
- 2007 budget:
  - Targets a headline deficit of 2.8 percent of GDP.
  - Official calculation: cumulative underlying adjustment of 1½ percent of GDP in 2006–07.
  - Staff estimates underlying adjustment of some 1 percent of GDP.
  - Staff judges the headline target is likely to be met given the favorable 2006 base.
  - Public debt/GDP ratio projected by staff to remain broadly unchanged in 2007, at around 107 percent.
- Primary spending trends:
  - Primary spending ratio grew by 2½ percentage points of GDP in 1995–2005.
  - Drivers: use of lower interest burden for new spending; overruns relative to own-spending targets; rapid rise in other current spending (wages, goods and services) since late 1990s; lack of a comprehensive expenditure framework.
- Fiscal risks and composition:
  - Persistent upward drift in primary outlays noted by staff.
  - Staff cautions against treating redirection of severance fund flows as genuine adjustment (flows estimated at 0.4 percent of GDP in 2007 and create future liabilities).

### Growth outlook and risks
- Staff expects growth to slow from 1.7 percent in 2006 to 1.4 percent in 2007.
- Demand composition:
  - Continued moderate consumption growth supported by increased disposable income, employment gains, and healthy balance sheets.
  - Investment growth expected to decelerate but remain positive.
  - Contribution of net exports expected to be flat.
- Risks to the outlook:
  - Downside: slowing partner country growth (including a sharper than expected slowdown in the United States); unwinding of global imbalances entailing euro appreciation; adverse confidence effects from 2007 budget’s revenue reliance.
  - Upside: ongoing economic restructuring (some observers view it as relatively advanced, though hard data are limited).

### Inflation, wages, and labor market slack
- Headline CPI inflation recently edged down to 2 percent.
- Core inflation edged above that of the euro area, to 2 percent.
- Staff projects wage growth of 3 percent in 2007.
- Staff notes relatively high inflation may indicate economic slack is overstated in labor market measures.
- Risk: generous public-sector wage increases could exert demonstration effects on private sector wages.

### Structural challenges and reform priorities
- Core challenges:
  - Insufficient domestic competition.
  - Still-rigid labor markets.
  - Discouraging business environment.
  - Relatively undeveloped capital markets (need to deepen corporate bond and equity markets).
  - Unsustainable fiscal accounts.
- Staff view: current environment is “as good as it gets” to implement reforms—“if not now, when?”
- Main policy priorities:
  - Sustained expenditure-based fiscal consolidation (staff view that the 2007 budget relies excessively on higher revenues).
  - Modernized budget processes and a multiyear spending framework with clear outer-year targets.
  - Decisive action to foster domestic competition and follow-up liberalizing initiatives.
  - A second wave of labor reform while preserving and extending employment gains.
  - Deepening of corporate bond and equity markets; strengthen enforcement of legal framework to develop nonbank funding sources.

### Assessment of the 2007 budget and specific fiscal measures
- Staff assessment:
  - 2007 budget promises no net reduction in spending; targeted adjustment comes entirely from an increase in the revenue ratio.
  - Contains some first steps to address medium-term spending pressures but falls short in public administration, local authorities, health care, and pensions.
- Specific areas:
  - Public administration: reorganization, reduce ministerial offices, regroup agencies, gradually reduce public employment; staff cautions savings could be offset by wage renewals and conversions of temporary contracts.
  - Local authorities: new Domestic Stability Pact replaces expenditure ceilings with explicit deficit targets, grants greater taxing leeway while cutting state transfers.
  - Health care: new “health pact” with regions establishes multiyear financing envelopes; regions breaching spending limits may face automatic increases in some regional tax rates.
  - Pensions: budget raises contribution rates for the self-employed; Memorandum of Understanding envisages additional pension reform by March 2007; staff stresses any agreement must preserve financial impact of already approved reforms.
- Revenue-side measures by authorities:
  - Significant portion of revenue increase expected from measures to reduce tax evasion and avoidance.
  - Planned unification of tax rates for final withholding on various types of financial income.
  - Cut in the tax on labor to help enterprise competitiveness.
- Staff recommendation: greater reliance on expenditure restraint and enhancing its quality; explicit commitment to use revenue overperformance solely for deficit reduction would be useful.

### Longer-term fiscal sustainability and scenarios
- Staff projections indicate that without deficit reduction beyond EDP commitment to bring deficit below 3 percent of GDP in 2007, public debt will be on an explosive path.
- Staff projects a deficit of 3.0 percent of GDP in 2008 in the absence of further measures.
- Authorities’ medium-term objective: reduce public debt to below 100 percent of GDP by 2011 by rebuilding the primary surplus to just under 5 percent of GDP by 2011.
- Box 3 scenarios (summarized):
  - Baseline scenario – debt explosion:
    - Assumes current policies through 2010, modest rise in labor productivity growth to 1¼ percent annually, long-run annual real GDP growth of ¾ percent.
    - Debt ratio would explode to almost 300 percent in 2050 if policies remain unchanged.
  - Adjustment scenario – debt stabilizes below the Maastricht threshold:
    - Staff’s adjustment scenario features further structural consolidation of 0.8 percentage point of GDP every year in 2008–10 through spending cuts, reaching a small overall surplus.
    - With modest productivity gains, the debt ratio would fall to around 55 percent by 2035 and then stabilize.
- Key numeric fiscal and debt projections (selected, exact values preserved):
  - 2006 overall balance (Table 2): -5.0 (percent of GDP).
  - Public debt ratio (Table 2, staff series): 2006 = 107.1 (percent of GDP).
  - Table 5 — Baseline public sector debt projections (In percent of GDP): 2006: 107.1; 2010: 107.0; 2020: 114.7; 2030: 147.2; 2040: 212.7; 2050: 296.3.
  - Table 5 — Staff adjustment scenario public sector debt (In percent of GDP): 2006: 107.1; 2009: 103.8; 2010: 100.7; 2020: 72.4; 2030: 56.7; 2040: 55.4; 2050: 56.1.

### Public enterprises and contingent fiscal risks (Box 4)
- Historical downsizing and privatization:
  - About 80 major privatizations, totaling some €125 billion, completed during 1993–2005.
  - Receipts were channeled to the Debt Retirement Fund, created in 1993.
- Current portfolio and performance:
  - State holdings in four listed and some twenty unlisted companies.
  - Listed companies’ market value estimated at €32 billion (about 2 percent of GDP) at end-October 2006.
  - Some state-owned companies are loss-making (ANAS; FFSS) financed by state transfers and reserve drawdowns.
- Fiscal risks and contingent liabilities:
  - Despite corporate law, loss-making firms are likely to be considered “too big to fail”; jointly employ more than 100,000 workers.
  - Government has reversed deep cuts in transfers when infeasible, showing political pressure to support firms.
- Reform priorities and safeguards:
  - Restructuring of loss-making enterprises needed and will take time.
  - Early steps: secure timely reporting; enhance transparency of financial positions and operations.

### Financial sector and macro-financial stability
- Financial conditions described as sound:
  - Bank profits edged up and loan portfolio quality improved.
  - Household balance sheets robust despite double-digit consumer credit growth.
  - Household debt at 34 percent of GDP (well below euro-area average).
  - Delinquency rates low despite uptick in servicing costs.
  - Corporate leverage increased as corporations locked in low interest rates.
- October 2006 sovereign downgrade:
  - Minimal impact on long-term spreads, which remain at about 30 basis points relative to German Bunds.
- Public debt maturity:
  - Continued lengthening in average public debt maturity reduced sensitivity of debt service to upward interest rate movements.
- Banking sector developments and regulation:
  - Ten-year consolidation: about 450 banks involved representing 80 percent of total assets; foreign banks hold 17 percent of total assets.
  - Cost-income ratio: 1 percentage point below EU area average.
  - ROA in line with EU average; ROE slightly below EU average.
  - Private sector credit (12-month growth, adjusted for securitizations): 2006 = 12.0 (2006 data refer to August).
  - Government bond rate, 10-year: 2006 = 4.0 (percent).

### Institutional and procedural recommendations
- Budget procedures: shift from legal/financial input focus to program orientation; introduce pilot program-oriented budgeting.
- Adopt a multiyear spending framework with clear outer-year targets and structural expenditure-saving measures effective before the next budget round.
- Increase institutional independence of budget assessments and projections; introduce explicit rule assigning revenue overperformance to deficit reduction.
- Competition and regulatory reform: pursue ambitious liberalizing initiatives across sectors with explicit timeframes and well-coordinated strategy.
- Labor market: safeguard and extend labor contracting reforms; do not roll back prior liberalizations; develop enhanced social safety nets and conditional unemployment support.
- Financial markets: deepen nonbank funding sources, including venture capital; improve enforcement of legal framework to foster capital markets and corporate bond issuance.
- Pension reform: preserve financial impact of already-legislated reforms; incentivize lengthening average working life and improve elderly participation rates.

### Key macroeconomic indicators (selected exact values)
- Real GDP growth: 2002 = 0.3; 2003 = 0.0; 2004 = 1.1; 2005 = 0.0; 2006 = 1.7.
- Unemployment rate (in percent): 2002 = 8.6; 2003 = 8.5; 2004 = 8.1; 2005 = 7.7; 2006 = 7.0.
- CPI (average): 2002 = 2.6; 2003 = 2.8; 2004 = 2.3; 2005 = 2.2; 2006 = 2.2.
- Current account balance (in percent): 2006 = -2.2.
- General government balance (percent of GDP): 2006 = -5.0.
- General government debt (percent of GDP): 2006 = 107.1.
- Euro per U.S. dollar (January 31, 2007): 0.77.
- Real effective rate (2000=100; based on CPI): 2006 = 111.9.

*Source: _cr0764 — IMF staff report excerpt (Italy), Executive Summary, selected sections, and Annexes (as excerpted).*

### Executive Summary

### Executive Summary

### Background: cyclical upswing and structural malaise
- Output growth in 2006–07 looks set to be the strongest since 2001.
- Recovery in first three quarters of 2006: about 2¼ percent (annualized), driven by exports, fixed investment, employment, and moderate consumption growth.
- The current pick-up is more broad-based and balanced between domestic and foreign sources than the aborted recoveries of 2003–04.
- Potential growth rates have declined from around 4 percent in the early 1970s to about 1¼ percent currently.
- Structural constraints cited: extensive product market regulation and protection, a slow legal system, and a heavy tax burden.
- Italy has suffered a substantial loss of export market share; Box 1 notes market share declined some 38 percent since 1993 (real exports), and by 23 percent in value terms over the same period.
- Italy’s unit labor cost–based real effective exchange rate appreciated by some 20 percent since 1998 and 2005; staff estimates a competitiveness gap in the range of 5 to 8 percent at end-2005 (methodologies and assumptions noted as having shortcomings).
- Initial signs of structural transformation: recent pick-up in exports in value terms, including in some traditional sectors and highly competitive emerging markets; anecdotal evidence of increased outsourcing by firms.
- Labor market developments:
  - Earlier reforms (2003 “Biagi” and earlier laws) led to significant increases in employment, with employment under new flexible contracts growing briskly and accounting for the bulk of new hires.
  - Unemployment rate fell to 7 percent by 2006:Q2.
  - Share of long-term unemployment has remained unchanged (half), unemployment among the old and young remains high, and the participation rate has remained at 63 percent since 2003.
  - Estimates indicate “atypical” contracts reduce labor costs by about 20 percent.
  - Employment levels and composition (2004–2006): total employment 22,438 (2004), 22,651 (2005), 23,187 (2006 1/); employees 16,141, 16,522, 17,015; flexible contracts 3,482, 3,756, 4,078; self-employed 6,297, 6,129, 6,172. (Data source: Istat; 1/ Data for 2006 refer to Q2.)
- Productivity and competitiveness indicators:
  - Low productivity growth illustrated by charts and text: TFP growth cumulative (2001–2005) and ULC growth comparisons; output stagnation despite employment gains; loss of market shares tied to real appreciation and low competition.

### Fiscal performance and outlook
- 2006 fiscal performance: remarkably strong budget revenues translated into appreciable fiscal overperformance (net of one-offs), despite substantial spending overruns.
  - Staff estimates general government deficit, net of two large one-off operations, declined to 3.0 percent of GDP in 2006 (versus an original budget target of 3½ percent of GDP).
  - Headline deficit is estimated to have risen to 5.0 percent of GDP in 2006.
  - Two large one-off operations noted: European court-mandated refund of VAT collected on the sale of company cars and the government’s assumption of railroad-related debt, amounting to some 2 percent of GDP.
- Revenue developments:
  - Revenue buoyancy in 2006 is broad based; a substantial part seems structural.
  - Authorities suggest that commitment to eschew tax amnesties and combat tax evasion is enhancing compliance (though 2007 budget does include a limited amnesty for social security contributions to facilitate emergence of irregular work).
- 2007 budget:
  - Targets a headline deficit of 2.8 percent of GDP and, in official calculations, a cumulative underlying adjustment of 1½ percent of GDP in 2006–07.
  - Staff estimates the underlying adjustment to be some 1 percent of GDP (less than official calculation), but staff judges the headline target is likely to be met given the favorable 2006 base.
  - Public debt/GDP ratio projected by staff to remain broadly unchanged in 2007, at around 107 percent.
- Primary spending trends:
  - Italy’s primary spending ratio grew by 2½ percentage points of GDP in 1995–2005, in marked contrast to other large euro-area countries.
  - Drivers of spending growth highlighted: use of lower interest burden for new spending, overruns relative to own-spending targets (explaining deficit slippages in 2001–05), rapid rise in other current spending (wages, goods and services) since late 1990s, and lack of a comprehensive expenditure framework.
- Fiscal risks and composition:
  - Staff notes persistent upward drift in primary outlays.
  - A Selected Issues Paper (referenced in source) examines structural causes of spending growth and fiscal sustainability (Box 3 and Box 4 referenced in contents).

### Challenges and constraints to sustained growth
- Core challenges identified:
  - Insufficient domestic competition.
  - Still-rigid labor markets.
  - Discouraging business environment.
  - Relatively undeveloped capital markets (need to deepen corporate bond and equity markets).
  - Unsustainable fiscal accounts.
- Consequences of lax fiscal policy and hesitant structural reform:
  - Prolonged period of anemic productivity, weakening competitiveness, and stagnant growth.
  - “Job-rich” stagnation: labor reforms boosted employment without translating into higher output due to declining productivity growth.

### Staff views: urgency and policy priorities
- Key judgment: The current environment is probably “as good as it gets” for implementing reforms needed to enhance Italy’s growth potential—“if not now, when?”
- Progress to date:
  - A set of liberalizing reforms in July 2006 and appreciable deficit reduction over 2006–07 represent a start.
- Main requirements (policy priorities):
  - Sustained expenditure-based fiscal consolidation (staff view that the 2007 budget relies excessively on higher revenues).
  - Modernized budget processes.
  - Decisive action to foster domestic competition.
  - A second wave of labor reform.
  - Deepening of corporate bond and equity markets.

### Authorities’ views and policy differences
- Broad agreement with staff analysis but authorities emphasize recent efforts and political constraints.
- Authorities view the 2007 budget as an important first step toward medium-term expenditure restraint and consider the structural reform process to be on track.
- Main disagreement centers on labor market reform:
  - Authorities express concerns about nontraditional employment contracts and propose measures to constrain their use.

### Financial sector and macro-financial stability
- Financial conditions described as sound:
  - Bank profits have edged up and loan portfolio quality has improved.
  - Household balance sheets robust despite double-digit consumer credit growth in recent years.
  - Household debt at 34 percent of GDP, well below the euro-area average.
  - Delinquency rates are low despite uptick in servicing costs.
  - Corporate leverage increased as corporations locked in low interest rates.
- October 2006 sovereign downgrade:
  - Had a minimal impact on long-term spreads, which remain at about 30 basis points relative to German Bunds.
- Public debt maturity:
  - Continued lengthening in average public debt maturity has reduced sensitivity of debt service to upward interest rate movements.

*Source: _cr0764 - Executive Summary*

### 8.      Staff expects growth to slow from 1.7 percent in 2006 to 1.4 percent in 2007.

### _cr0764 - 8.      Staff expects growth to slow from 1.7 percent in 2006 to 1.4 percent in 2007.

### Growth outlook
- Staff expects growth to slow from 1.7 percent in 2006 to 1.4 percent in 2007.
- Continued moderate consumption growth supported by increased disposable income, employment gains, and healthy balance sheets.
- Investment growth expected to decelerate but remain positive, sustained by domestic and foreign demand, increases in capacity utilization, and favorable financing conditions.
- Contribution of net exports expected to be flat.

### Risks to the outlook
- Downside risks cited:
  - Slowing partner country growth, including a sharper than expected slowdown in the United States.
  - An unwinding of global imbalances entailing euro appreciation.
  - Adverse confidence effects provoked by the 2007 budget’s reliance on the revenue side.
- Upside risks:
  - Ongoing economic restructuring, which some observers view as relatively advanced (noting lack of hard data).

### Inflation, wages, and labor market slack
- Headline CPI inflation recently edged down to 2 percent.
- Core inflation edged above that of the euro area, to 2 percent.
- Staff projects wage growth of 3 percent in 2007.
- Staff notes the relatively high level of inflation in Italy suggests the staff’s estimate of economic slack could be overstated, at least in the labor market.
- Risk: generous public-sector wage increases with a demonstration effect on the private sector could threaten the inflation/wage outlook.

### Political and structural constraints
- Newly elected center-left government’s parliamentary majority is thin and coalition spans a broad spectrum of economic views.
- Government has overcome the budget hurdle but concessions leave the outlook for fundamental fiscal adjustment and economic reform uncertain.
- Market concerns are reflected in credit ratings downgrades.

### High-frequency indicators (summary)
- Confidence indicators, industrial production, capacity utilization, and orders shown as supportive of continued moderate growth (figures and charts cited from Istat, ISAE).

### Policy recommendations and priorities
- Overarching priorities stressed by staff:
  - Embark on and sustain expenditure-based fiscal consolidation.
  - Return to growth by stepping up structural reforms.
  - Further develop the financial system, while maintaining financial stability.
- Staff view: 2007 budget puts too little emphasis on expenditure control; structural reform process needs momentum and strategic coherence.
- Staff argued for early action to exploit the cyclical upswing and revenue overperformance to pursue fiscal adjustment.

### Fiscal policy assessment and measures
- Staff assessment of 2007 budget:
  - Promises no net reduction in spending; targeted adjustment comes entirely from an increase in the revenue ratio.
  - Budget contains some first steps to address medium-term spending pressures but falls short in key areas: public administration, local authorities, health care, and pensions.
- Specific areas:
  - Public administration: plans to reorganize public sector, reduce ministerial offices, reduce duplication, regroup agencies, and gradually reduce public employment; staff cautions savings could be offset by generous wage renewals and large-scale conversions of temporary contracts to open-ended employment.
  - Local authorities: new Domestic Stability Pact replaces expenditure ceilings with explicit deficit targets and grants greater taxing leeway while cutting state transfers.
  - Health care: a new “health pact” with regions establishes multiyear financing envelopes; regions breaching spending limits may face automatic increases in some regional tax rates.
  - Pensions: budget raises contribution rates for the self-employed but contains no cost-saving measures; Memorandum of Understanding with trade unions envisages additional pension reform by March 2007; staff stressed any agreement must preserve the financial impact of already approved reforms and help raise elderly participation rates.
- Revenue-side measures highlighted by authorities:
  - Significant portion of revenue increase expected from measures to reduce tax evasion and avoidance (estimated efficiency gains and not involving increases in tax rates).
  - Planned unification of tax rates for final withholding on various types of financial income.
  - Cut in the tax on labor to help enterprise competitiveness.
- Staff recommendation: greater reliance on expenditure restraint and enhancing its quality; caution that higher revenue-to-GDP ratio risks providing leeway for additional spending and that successful durable adjustment typically relies on curbing current expenditure.

### Specific fiscal technical points
- Staff took exception to treating redirection of workers’ severance fund flows as “adjustment.”  
  - The measure would automatically direct workers’ contributions to firm-based severance funds to a private pension fund in 2007 unless the worker opts otherwise.
  - For firms with over 50 employees choosing continued accumulation of severance funds, contributions (recorded as revenue) would accrue to a special account at the Social Security Institute to finance public infrastructure.
  - Staff noted such flows are estimated at 0.4 percent of GDP in 2007 and give rise to a liability to provide workers with severance payments in the future; the diversion to the state would be costly (government matching of previous returns and compensation to enterprises for loss of cheap financing).

### Longer-term fiscal sustainability and scenarios
- Staff projections show that without deficit reduction beyond the EDP commitment to bring the deficit below 3 percent of GDP in 2007, public debt will be on an explosive path.
- Staff projects a deficit of 3.0 percent of GDP in 2008 in the absence of further measures; official forecasts see the deficit creeping back up to 2.9 percent of GDP without further measures.
- Authorities’ medium-term objective: reduce public debt to below 100 percent of GDP by 2011 by rebuilding the primary surplus to just under 5 percent of GDP by 2011.
- Staff called for a multiyear spending framework with clear outer-year targets and structural expenditure-saving measures defined soon to be effective before the next budget round, with the aim of bringing fiscal accounts into balance at least by 2010.
- Box 3 scenarios (summary):
  - Baseline scenario – debt explosion: assumes current policies through 2010, modest rise in labor productivity growth to 1¼ percent annually, long-run annual real GDP growth of ¾ percent; debt ratio would explode to almost 300 percent in 2050 if policies remain unchanged.
  - Adjustment scenario – debt stabilizes below the Maastricht threshold: staff’s adjustment scenario features further structural consolidation of 0.8 percentage point of GDP every year in 2008–10 through spending cuts, reaching a small overall surplus; with modest productivity gains, the debt ratio would fall to around 55 percent by 2035 and then stabilize.
- Conclusion: achieving debt sustainability depends on both further fiscal consolidation and growth-promoting structural reforms.

*IMF staff report excerpt (Italy), pages excerpted from the original PDF.*

### Box 4. Fiscal Risks from Italy’s Public Enterprises

### Box 4. Fiscal Risks from Italy’s Public Enterprises

### Historical downsizing and privatization
- In 1992, 12 of the 20 largest Italian firms (by sales) were state-owned, and the state’s holding companies were among the largest employers in the country.
- About 80 major privatizations, totaling some €125 billion, were completed during 1993–2005.
- Receipts were channeled to the Debt Retirement Fund, created in 1993, significantly reducing public debt.

### Current portfolio and financial performance
- The state’s current portfolio includes holdings in four listed companies and some twenty unlisted companies.
- Listed companies’ market value was estimated at €32 billion (about 2 percent of GDP) at end-October 2006.
  - The airline company Alitalia is a notable exception to generally good performance among listed firms.
- The Ministry of Economy and Finance intends to divest the most profitable unlisted companies over the next few years (with an estimated value of about 2 percent of GDP).
- Some state-owned companies are loss-making:
  - The road company (ANAS) and the railway holding company (FFSS) are running losses financed by state transfers and reserve drawdowns.

### Fiscal risks and contingent liabilities
- Despite corporate law implying the government would not be directly responsible for their liabilities in case of default, these companies are likely to be considered “too big to fail.”
- These companies jointly employ more than 100,000 workers, increasing the political and fiscal pressure to provide support.
- The government has also been transferring risks to these companies by cutting their capital transfers:
  - Deep cuts in the 2006 budget had to be reversed with midyear supplementary allocations when they proved unfeasible.

### Reform priorities and recommended safeguards
- Restructuring of loss-making enterprises is needed and will take time.
- Early steps emphasized as key to reform success:
  - Secure timely reporting of these companies’ operations.
  - Enhance transparency of their financial positions and operations.
- Improved reporting and transparency are presented as foundational to any broader privatization or restructuring effort.

*Box 4. Fiscal Risks from Italy’s Public Enterprises — IMF staff report content*

### 35.      While a start has been made, the current economic recovery and the beginning

### 35.      While a start has been made, the current economic recovery and the beginning

### Opportunity for adjustment and reform
- Growth is picking up and buoyant revenues are helping the fiscal outturn.
- International experience suggests reforms are best undertaken early in a legislature's mandate.
- The current economic environment is likely to prove “as good as it gets” for fully implementing the authorities’ ambitious medium-term economic plan.

### Fiscal outturn and risks
- 2006 deficit: "remarkably strong revenues pushed the 2006 deficit below its original target."
- Primary current spending: "The ratio of primary current spending to GDP is at its highest level in at least a quarter century."
- Rebuilding the primary surplus and driving down debt requires addressing the factors behind the persistent rise in spending.
- 2007 budget objective: reduce the deficit to below 3 percent of GDP—achievement "relies entirely on higher revenues."
- Accounting measure risk: transfer of severance fund contributions to the public sector creates scope for additional spending without underlying adjustment.

### Assessment of the 2007 budget and revenue measures
- The 2007 budget would arrest (but only just) the trend of rising primary current expenditure because envisaged savings are offset by new expenditure initiatives.
- Positive revenue measures highlighted:
  - Curbing evasion to improve equity and eliminate distortions that reduce growth potential.
  - Commitment to abandon tax amnesties to encourage better tax compliance—widening the tax base could create scope for further tax reductions if spending is durably reduced.
- Recommendation: explicit commitment to use revenue overperformance solely for deficit reduction would be useful.

### Structural spending reforms and priorities
- Immediate initiation recommended for structural reforms in priority spending areas to make them effective before the next budget round.
- Civil service reform: begin discussions promptly to reduce the relatively high wage bill and enhance efficiency, including increasing mobility for planned territorial reorganization.
- Domestic Stability Pact: revisions shifting from spending to deficit limits are positive, but Italy remains far from a fiscally responsible system of federalism.
- Health pact: agreed pact should be rigorously implemented.
- Pension reforms: a series of pension reforms adopted over the years will—if implemented faithfully—significantly reduce fiscal costs associated with aging. Essential that the pension agreement sought by March 2007 "fully preserve the financial impact of already legislated reforms."
- State enterprises: several need restructuring to reduce drains on public resources.

### Budget procedures and fiscal institutions
- Current budget procedures concentrate on legal requirements and financial inputs, not results; a shift to a program orientation can generate greater efficiency and accountability.
- Recommendations:
  - Introduce pilot projects to start program-oriented budgeting.
  - Adopt a multiyear spending framework with clear targets for outer years.
  - Increase institutional independence of budget assessments and projections.

### Competition, regulation, and liberalization
- Excessive regulation and protection raise prices and reduce competitiveness—described as "a tax imposed on the majority for the benefit of the few."
- Liberalizing decrees of summer 2006 provided an initial signal; these should be followed by ambitious liberalizing initiatives across areas under consideration.
- Reform agenda should be well-coordinated with explicit timeframes and proceed on a broad front to build consensus.

### Labor market and social safety nets
- Reforms to labor contracting have been critical to employment growth and should be safeguarded and extended.
- Fixed-term contracts have been an important path to open-ended employment, but concerns about precariousness exist.
- Recommended approach: do not scale back labor-market reforms; instead develop an adequate safety net that offers better, appropriately conditional unemployment support while paring employment protection further.

### Pensions and aging
- Population aging threatens Italy’s growth potential, particularly given low participation rates for older individuals.
- Reforms to:
  - Establish a closer link between pension contributions and benefits,
  - Eliminate rules barring retirees from working while receiving pensions,
  would incentivize lengthening average working life and enhance growth potential while improving elderly living standards.

### Financial sector development and vulnerabilities
- Financial sector needs to move beyond heavy reliance on bank intermediation; nonbank funding sources—particularly venture capital—are important for financing new firms.
- Action needed across a broad front to remove impediments, including measures to improve enforcement of the legal framework.

### Banking sector developments
- Recent developments positive: financial soundness indicators have improved and credit growth remained robust.
- Progress implementing the 2005 FSSA recommendations:
  - Responsibility for regulating anticompetitive behavior transferred to the Antitrust Authority.
  - Bank of Italy’s Statute modified to increase transparency and accountability.
- Bank of Italy’s encouragement of bank consolidation is promoting efficiency; increased contestability including cross-border players is encouraging.
- Greater transparency in banks’ interactions with clients expected to increase competition; Antitrust Authority committed to monitor.

### Key numeric fiscal and debt projections (selected, exact values preserved)
- 2006 overall balance (Table 2): -5.0 (percent of GDP).
- Public debt ratio (Table 2, staff series): 2006 = 107.1 (percent of GDP).
- Table 5 — Baseline public sector debt projections (In percent of GDP):
  - 2006: 107.1
  - 2010: 107.0
  - 2020: 114.7
  - 2030: 147.2
  - 2040: 212.7
  - 2050: 296.3
- Table 5 — Staff adjustment scenario public sector debt (In percent of GDP):
  - 2006: 107.1
  - 2009: 103.8
  - 2010: 100.7
  - 2020: 72.4
  - 2030: 56.7
  - 2040: 55.4
  - 2050: 56.1

### Institutional follow-up
- Proposal: the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

*Prepared by the European Department, Staff Report for the 2006 Article IV Consultation—Informational Annexes (January 16, 2007).*

### Appendix I. Italy: Fund Relations

### Appendix I. Italy: Fund Relations (As of November 30, 2006)

### Membership and Fund Resources
- Membership status: Joined 3/27/1947; Article VIII.
- General Resources Account (SDR Million; Percent Quota):
  - Quota: 7,055.50 — 100.00
  - Fund holdings of currency: 6,403.47 — 90.76
  - Reserve position in Fund: 652.08 — 9.24
- SDR Department (SDR Million; Percent Allocation):
  - Net cumulative allocation: 702.40 — 100.00
  - Holdings: 180.62 — 25.72

### Mission, Staff, and Country Interlocutors
- Mission: Rome, November 2–13, 2006.
- Staff team: Messrs. Leipold (Head), Gerson, Lissovolik, Drummond (all EUR), Ms. Fedelino (FAD) and Ms. Ivaschenko (EUR). Mr. Sadun, Executive Director, also participated in most meetings.
- Country interlocutors included: The Minister of Economy and Finance; the Governor of the Bank of Italy; the Minister of Economic Development; the Minister of Labor; the Minister of Regional Affairs; the Minister of International Trade and European Affairs; the Vice Minister of Finance; the Director General of the Treasury; Securities and Exchange Commission (CONSOB); the Antitrust Authority; the National Statistics Institute (Istat); the Confederation of Italian Industry (Confindustria); the Economic Analysis Institute (ISAE); the National Association of Insurers (ANIA); the Regional Governors Conference; the Court of Auditors (Corte dei Conti); the Italian Banking Association (ABI); representatives of labor unions; state enterprises; and research centers.

### Fund Relations, Data, and Reporting
- Previous consultation discussions: October 19–November 2, 2005.
- Italy accepted the obligations under Article VIII and, apart from certain security restrictions, maintains an exchange rate system free of restrictions.
- Data: Italy subscribes to the Fund’s Special Data Dissemination Standard (SDDS); comprehensive economic data are available on a timely basis (Appendix II).
- Article IV consultation cycle: Standard 12-month consultation cycle.

### Financial Arrangements and Obligations
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans: None.
- Financial Arrangements: None.
- Projected Obligations to Fund (SDR million; based on existing use of resources and present holdings of SDRs):
  - Charges/Interest:
    - 2006: 21.12
    - 2007: 21.18
    - 2008: 21.12
    - 2009: 21.12
  - Total:
    - 2006: 21.12
    - 2007: 21.18
    - 2008: 21.12
    - 2009: 21.12

### Exchange Rate Arrangement
- Italy entered the final stage of European Economic and Monetary Union on January 1, 1999, at a rate of 1,936.27 Italian lire per 1 euro.
- Italy maintains an exchange system free of restrictions on current international transactions, except for exchange restrictions imposed solely for the preservation of national or international security, as notified pursuant to Executive Board Decision No. 144-(52/51).

### ROSCs and Safeguards
- ROSCs:
  - Fiscal Transparency: Standard Code Assessment — October 9, 2002 — Country Report No. 02/231
  - Data: Standard Code Assessment — October 18, 2002 — Country Report No. 02/234
  - FSAP: March 14, 2006 — Country Report No. 06/112
  - Data Update: expected February 2006
- Implementation of HIPC Initiative: Not applicable.
- Safeguards Assessments: Not applicable.

### Statistical Information: Quality, Strengths, and Remaining Weaknesses
- Overall: Economic database is comprehensive, generally of high quality, and adequate for surveillance purposes. Italy subscribes to the SDDS and has posted metadata on the DSBB, meeting nearly all specifications.
- Key statistical practices and improvements:
  - Adopted the European System of Accounts 1995 (ESA95).
  - Shift to chain-weighted indices for national accounts largely completed in 2006.
  - Under the Coordinated Compilation Exercise for FSIs, authorities produced indicators broadly consistent with the Fund's FSI Compilation Guide.
  - Since the 2002 ROSC (Data Module), improvements include:
    - Istat now responsible for disseminating general government statistics.
    - Benchmark revision of national accounts implemented in 2005, updating the benchmark to 2000, revising calculation/allocation of financial services indirectly measured, introducing chained volume and price measures, and improving many compilation methods.
    - Advanced work on implementing random sampling techniques for CPI collection and aligning price collection period to the reference month.
    - Enhanced consistency of GFS constituents through better interagency coordination.
    - Publication of quarterly data for general government balance, expenditure, and revenue on an accruals basis (in line with ESA95).
    - A more detailed labor force survey and progress reconciling cash-based net borrowing requirement with accrual budget deficit.
- Remaining weaknesses:
  - Quarterly national accounts: changes in inventories are derived residually, along with the statistical discrepancy, hampering business cycle analysis.
  - PPI: weaknesses in weighting data sources and scope to improve statistical techniques used in index compilation.
  - Validation process at Istat constrained by important time lags in assessing economic nature of transactions, limiting revisions and potentially causing inconsistencies with GFS components under the Bank of Italy.
  - Fiscal data quality and timeliness, particularly on expenditure by local governments, still need improvement.

### IMF Executive Board Assessment (Public Information Notice No. 07/20; February 15, 2007)
- Background findings:
  - Economy experiencing a broad-based, if modest, cyclical upswing.
  - Output estimated to have grown by 1¾ percent in 2006 — the strongest pace since the beginning of the decade.
  - Inflation close to that of the euro area; financial conditions favorable; unemployment falling; current account deficit moderate.
  - Growth projected to ease to around 1½ percent in 2007 due to sluggish potential.
  - Unexpectedly strong revenues improved the fiscal outturn in 2006; net of two large one-off operations, the deficit estimated well below original target of 3½ percent of GDP.
  - 2007 budget likely to bring the headline deficit under 3 percent of GDP; public debt ratio after rising in 2005–06 should broadly stabilize at around 107 percent.
  - Some structural spending containment initiatives in the 2007 budget, though key aspects yet to be finalized.
  - Progress on structural reform: deregulation of selected services; follow-up liberalization package approved; recent labor contracting initiatives may partially roll back earlier liberalizing reforms; banking sector consolidation and competition boosted; reforms to enhance financial sector transparency progressed; product and labor markets remain rigid; nonbank financial intermediation relatively undersized.
- Directors’ views and recommendations:
  - Welcome the upturn and employment gains; urge not to miss the opportunity offered by cyclical upswing and early phase of new government’s mandate to boost productivity and competition.
  - Fiscal policy:
    - Encouraged by better-than-anticipated 2006 fiscal outturn excluding one-offs; noted stronger revenue buoyancy appears partly structural.
    - Concern about primary spending appreciably exceeding original budget targets, indicating expenditure control problems.
    - Viewed the 2007 budget as securing the milestone of bringing the deficit below 3 percent of GDP; welcomed revenue measures combating evasion and widening the tax base.
    - Emphasized the 2007 adjustment relies heavily on revenues; called for rapid progress in structural spending reforms in public employment, local government finances, and health care.
    - Safeguarding financial impact of already-legislated pension reforms is essential.
    - Several state enterprises require restructuring to reduce drain on public resources.
    - Recommended stronger efforts to control spending to rebuild the primary surplus, drive down debt, and ensure durability of re-entry under the 3 percent of GDP deficit threshold.
    - For long-term sustainability given aging population and high public debt, fiscal consolidation needs to be pursued considerably further for longer-term sustainability.
    - Encouraged prompt adoption of a multi-year spending framework with clear outer-year targets, backed by explicit expenditure-saving and efficiency-oriented measures.
    - Suggested overhauling cumbersome budget procedures, strengthening budgetary governance, and introducing an explicit rule assigning revenue overperformance to deficit reduction.
  - Structural reforms:
    - Urged vigorous pursuit of reforms to reduce regulation, increase competition, and improve the business environment to raise productivity and growth.
    - Welcomed recent and planned product market liberalization and competition-enhancing initiatives; called for accelerated progress across a broad front with well-coordinated strategy and explicit timeframes.
    - Cautioned against reversing prior labor contracting liberalizations; recommended developing an adequate safety net with improved unemployment support to mitigate effects of greater employment flexibility.
    - Noted pension reform can provide incentives to lengthen average working life and support growth and welfare.
  - Financial sector:
    - Noted the financial system remains sound and well supervised; welcomed actions to enhance competition and transparency.
    - Greater contestability in the banking sector and ongoing consolidation expected to improve efficiency and quality of services.
    - Welcomed progress implementing recommendations of the 2005 Financial System Stability Assessment.
    - Recommended broad measures to increase role of capital markets, including improving enforcement of the legal framework.
  - External policy:
    - Encouraged authorities to increase official development assistance toward the UN target of 0.7 percent of gross national income.

### Italy: Selected Economic Indicators (staff estimates and projections unless otherwise noted)
- Real economy (change in percent):
  - Real GDP: 2002: 0.3; 2003: 0.0; 2004: 1.1; 2005: 0.0; 2006: 1.7
  - Total domestic demand: 2002: 1.3; 2003: 0.9; 2004: 1.0; 2005: 0.3; 2006: 1.7
  - Current account balance (in percent): 2002: -0.7; 2003: -1.3; 2004: -0.9; 2005: -1.6; 2006: -2.2
  - CPI (average): 2002: 2.6; 2003: 2.8; 2004: 2.3; 2005: 2.2; 2006: 2.2
  - Unemployment rate (in percent): 2002: 8.6; 2003: 8.5; 2004: 8.1; 2005: 7.7; 2006: 7.0
- Public finance (in percent of GDP):
  - General government balance: 2002: -2.9; 2003: -3.4; 2004: -3.4; 2005: -4.1; 2006: -5.0
  - General government debt: 2002: 105.5; 2003: 104.3; 2004: 103.9; 2005: 106.6; 2006: 107.1
- Monetary and financial indicators:
  - Private sector credit (12-month growth, adjusted for securitizations): 2002: 7.8; 2003: 9.1; 2004: 6.7; 2005: 10.1; 2006: 12.0 (2006 data refer to August)
  - National contribution to euro area M3 (excludes currency in circulation held by nonbank private sector): 2002: 10.7; 2003: 9.4; 2004: 5.1; 2005: 6.3; 2006: 6.7 (2006 data refer to November)
  - 6-month interbank rate (percent, end of period): 2002: 3.3; 2003: 2.3; 2004: 2.1; 2005: 2.6; 2006: 3.8 (2006 data refer to December)
  - Government bond rate, 10-year (percent): 2002: 5.0; 2003: 4.2; 2004: 4.3; 2005: 3.5; 2006: 4.0
- Fund position (as of December 31, 2006):
  - Holdings of currency (percent of quota): 90.8
  - Holdings of SDRs (percent of allocation): 25.7
  - Quota (millions of SDRs): 7,055.5
- Exchange rates:
  - Exchange rate regime: Member of EMU
  - Euro per U.S. dollar (January 31, 2007): 0.77
  - Nominal effective rate (2000=100): 2002: 101.6; 2003: 105.8; 2004: 107.2; 2005: 107.3; 2006: 107.8
  - Real effective rate (2000=100; based on CPI): 2002: 104.3; 2003: 111.4; 2004: 113.8; 2005: 112.2; 2006: 111.9

*Source: _cr0764 - Appendix I. Italy: Fund Relations (IMF), as of November 30, 2006; Public Information Notice No. 07/20 (February 15, 2007)._

### 1. Overview

### 1. Overview

### Key messages
- Recent improvements in economic performance reflect—to a large extent—structural changes initiated long ago.
- The new government's economic strategy priorities:
  - Consolidation of fiscal accounts via the supplementary budget (middle of last year) and a very stringent budget for 2007.
  - Implementation of a reform agenda including liberalizations of product and service markets, with further initiatives expected for the energy sector and local utilities.
  - Changes in financial and banking sectors to enhance investor protection, improve corporate governance, and strengthen cooperation among financial regulators.
- Persistent challenges: fiscal accounts must be consolidated further; regional disparities reduced; efficiency of public administration enhanced; productivity and potential growth increased.
- Authorities commit to supporting the transformations reshaping the economy.

### 2. Economic Outlook

### Recent performance and drivers
- After stagnating in 2005, GDP rebounded sharply in 2006 driven by recovery in domestic demand.
- Main drivers: private consumption (rising disposable income and improved confidence) and investment in machinery and equipment.
- Foreign sector contribution limited: significant increase in exports offset by higher imports, particularly energy.

### Projections and labor market
- Authorities’ growth projections: 2006: 1.6 percent; 2007: 1.3 percent; 2008–11: expected to accelerate steadily to 1.7 percent.
- Employment: 2006 employment growth accelerated to 1 percent; unemployment rate: 6.9 percent.
- Inflation: 2006: 2.2 percent; expected to ease to 2.1 in 2007 and to 1.7 in 2008.
- Outlook: overall favorable, with a slight slowdown expected in 2007 in line with other EU countries.

### 3. Competitiveness

### Assessment
- Boosting productivity and promoting wage moderation are critical to restore competitiveness and raise growth potential.
- Staff analysis: loss of constant-price market shares; competitiveness gap between Italy and major euro-area partners estimated between 5 and 8 percent.
- Alternative interpretation: measured at current prices, Italy’s market shares have remained fairly stable, suggesting firms moved production up the value-added ladder and commanded premium prices.

### Export performance
- 2006 exports projected to increase by 5 percent in real terms—the biggest increase in several years; recovery broadly based, including traditional sectors.

### 4. Fiscal Policy

### Overall objective
- First priority: meet the 2005 EU Council Recommendations and achieve a structurally balanced budget by 2010.
- Fund and EU Commission acknowledge Italy is well positioned to reduce the deficit-to-GDP ratio to below 3 percent in 2007.
- Preliminary estimates indicate central government deficit, net of one-offs, may have declined below the Maastricht threshold in 2006.

### The 2007 Budget: composition and impacts
- Overall package size: about 2.3 percent of the GDP.
  - Growth-enhancing measures: 1.3 percentage points.
  - Structural budgetary adjustments: 1 percentage point.
- The cyclically-adjusted balance, net of one-offs, will be reduced by almost 1.5 percentage points.
- Revenue-side emphasis:
  - Revenue increase stems mostly from greater tax compliance and base broadening rather than rate hikes.
  - Top tax brackets increased marginally; rates harmonized across various financial instruments in line with EU standards.
  - Tax allowances and subsidies for low-income households raised.
  - Budget provides for a significant reduction, estimated at about 5 percentage points, in the labor-tax wedge.
- Expenditure-side measures:
  - Structural cuts in current expenditures of about 0.5 percent of GDP.
  - Current expenditures expected to decline by 0.7 percent of GDP both in 2007 and 2008.
  - Savings achieved through downsizing and consolidation of several government agencies.
  - Agreement between Central Government and Regions to contain public health expenditures; incentives for administrations meeting budgetary guidelines; co-payments slightly increased.
  - Strict sanctioning mechanism to curb over-spending retained.
- Domestic stability pact (excludes healthcare costs) strengthened by setting fiscal targets for the whole budget rather than for individual expenditure categories.

### Second Pillar Pension Scheme
- Major steps to foster private pension funds; future payments to employees' severance accounts channeled to private pension funds or a State Fund.
- Estimated resources to State Fund: 0.4 percent of GDP in 2007 and 0.3 percent in the following years.
- Resources to finance public projects for infrastructure and growth.

### Debt and sustainability targets
- Objective: increase the primary surplus steadily until it reaches 5 percent of GDP in 2011.
- Debt-to-GDP ratio expected to start falling in 2007; pace of reduction to accelerate from 2008 onward.
- December 2006 Stability Program projections: debt-to-GDP dip to below 100 percent in 2010 and to below 60 percent in 2020.
- Pension expenditures: highest ratio among EU countries, but expected to increase only marginally through 2050, provided previous reforms are implemented.
- EU Commission stress tests using sustainability gap and required primary balance indicate meeting Stability Program fiscal targets will ensure long-run sustainability.

### 5. Structural Reforms

### Enhancing competition
- Recent liberalization packages cover telecommunications, transportation, insurance, gasoline distribution networks, and the wholesale natural gas market.
- Measures to streamline public administration and remove burdens on business, including simplified procedures to start new businesses.
- Further measures expected for energy markets and local public utilities.
- Strategy: liberalize several sectors simultaneously to create synergies and balance stakeholder interests.

### Labor market reforms
- Italy experienced robust job creation and a substantial fall in unemployment over the last decade due to labor market reforms increasing flexibility and female participation.
- New measures aim to:
  - Increase safeguards for non-traditional workers.
  - Provide incentives to convert temporary employment into permanent contracts.
  - Rely on flexible contracts to help market entry and promote transition to stable employment.
- Authorities concur with staff on the need for a well-balanced and strong social safety net as a pre-condition to reducing labor rigidities.

### 6. Banking Sector Developments and Financial Regulation

### Banking sector structure and performance
- Last ten years: intense consolidation involving approximately 450 banks representing 80 percent of total assets.
- Foreign banks hold 17 percent of total assets.
- Cost-income ratio: 1 percentage point below EU area average.
- ROA: in line with EU average.
- ROE: slightly below EU average.
- Areas for improvement: consumer credit and asset management.
- Italian Banks’ Association (ABI) initiatives facilitate price comparability and free portability of current accounts.

### Financial stability and regulation
- First half of 2006 prudential indicators favorable: stock of NPLs and flows of new NPLs historically low; capital adequacy ratio increased marginally.
- System positioned to introduce Basel II; new capital requirements directive formally implemented in December 2006.
- Saving Law (2005) improved corporate governance, transparency, consumer protection, and coordination among regulators; Consob’s resources and sanction power increased.
- Review of Bank of Italy’s statute promoted by the Saving Law recently approved.
- Government discussing a bill to allow ownership revision of the Bank of Italy within one year instead of three; current arrangements include specific legal safeguards preventing conflicts of interest.
- Reform aims to preserve Bank of Italy independence and reduce number of financial regulators by consolidating functions of UIC, Isvap, and Covip in the Bank of Italy and Consob.

### 7. Corporate Governance and Development of an Arm’s-Length Financial Market

### Corporate ownership and market access
- Corporate governance characterized by shareholders’ coalitions and ownership concentration; family-based firms reluctant to go public.
- Few companies are rated, limiting access to international corporate bond markets.
- Easy access to other financing forms has mitigated the need to tap capital markets, reducing firm contestability and increasing management insulation.

### Regulatory framework and implementation
- Regulatory framework judged among the most advanced and incorporating best international practices:
  - Minority shareholders strongly protected.
  - Takeover regulations more stringent than EU directive.
  - Insider trading norms implemented at the most rigorous level of EU guidelines.
  - Accounting standards and disclosure in line with European standards.
- Bankruptcy Law increased chances of recovery and rapid restructuring and streamlined liquidation procedures.
- Italian listing rules and costs in line with peer European stock exchanges.
- Main problems lie in implementation due to inefficiencies in judiciary and administrative systems; authorities committed to addressing shortcomings.
- Development of private pension pillar expected to have positive implications for institutional investors and capital market development.

### 8. Other Issues

### Official Development Assistance (ODA)
- 2005 Italian ODA: 0.29 percent of GNI, doubling 2004 results.
- Based on current estimates, Italian ODA expected to decrease in 2006.
- Italy adheres to EU commitment to reach an ODA-to-GNI ratio of 0.51 percent (individual target) by 2010.
- Related budget appropriations will gradually increase within constraints of budgetary consolidation.
- Government plans a full-fledged reform to boost Italian development cooperation.

*IMF staff report — 1. Overview*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2007/_cr0764.pdf_
