## Selected Economic and Financial Indicators and PRGF Program (CR08146)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Selected Economic and Financial Indicators and PRGF Program (CR08146)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08146.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08146.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08146.pdf.json)

---

### Background and political/institutional context
- Parliamentary elections on October 14, 2007 were judged free and transparent; the European Union resumed financial assistance after a 15-year suspension.
- Principal constraints to growth and development:
  - Poor governance and low administrative capacity following prolonged sociopolitical conflict and mismanagement of public resources.
  - Excessive public debt, with external debt above the HIPC threshold, external arrears, and very large domestic arrears.
  - Fragile banks, including the highest nonperforming loan ratio in the WAEMU area and undercapitalization of several banks.
  - Severe energy crisis caused by region-wide shortages and cuts in electricity exports to Togo.
  - Loss-making state-owned cotton and phosphate enterprises producing large quasi-fiscal deficits and mounting debts.
  - Poor business environment and underinvestment in transport and energy infrastructure.
  - Deteriorated social conditions following suspension of donor support for health, education, and infrastructure.
- I-PRSP adopted March 2008: three-year program focused on fiscal governance, restructuring state-owned enterprises and banks, improving the business environment, rehabilitating transport and energy infrastructure, and improving education and health.
- Poverty context: "About 62 percent of the population fall below the poverty line." (authorities’ statement); elsewhere noted "about 60 percent" and rural/urban breakdowns.

### Macroeconomic performance and projections (selected)
- Recent performance:
  - Real GDP growth: 2005 1.3; 2006 4.1; 2007 2.1.
  - Current account deficit estimated at 6½ percent of GDP in 2007.
  - Annual inflation: 2005 6.8; 2006 2.2; 2007 1.0.
  - Broad money grew 16½ percent in 2007.
- Program projections (Program; percent of GDP unless otherwise indicated):
  - Real GDP (percent change): 2008 Est. 3.0; 2009 4.0; 2010 4.0.
  - Consumer prices (annual average, percent change): 2008 Est. 4.1; 2009 3.8; 2010 3.5.
  - Broad money (M2, percent change): 2008 Est. 10.0.
  - Total revenue and grants: 2008 Est. 19.5; 2009 21.2; 2010 22.1.
  - Revenue: 2008 Est. 17.2; 2009 17.5; 2010 17.8.
  - Total expenditure and net lending: 2008 Est. 21.9; 2009 22.9; 2010 23.4.
  - Domestic primary expenditure: 2008 Est. 17.2; 2009 16.9; 2010 16.7.
  - Overall balance (payment order basis): 2008 Est. -2.4; 2009 -1.7; 2010 -1.3.
  - Primary balance: 2008 Est. 0.0; 2009 0.6; 2010 1.1.
  - Change in domestic arrears: 2008 Est. 0.0; 2009 -0.4; 2010 -0.7.
  - Current account balance: 2008 Est. -7.9; 2009 -6.7; 2010 -6.4.
  - Exports of Goods and Services: 2008 Est. 44.4; 2009 45.3; 2010 46.2.
  - Imports of Goods and Services: 2008 Est. 68.0; 2009 69.4; 2010 70.2.
  - External public debt: 2008 Est. 64.2; 2009 60.8; 2010 36.3.
  - Note: external debt projections assume external debt/arrears relief in 2008-2010 broadly in line with potential HIPC/MDRI debt relief.
- Additional macro tables (selected exact figures):
  - Real GDP per capita (percent change): 2008 0.5; 2009 1.4; 2010 1.4.
  - GDP deflator (percent change): 2008 1.6; 2009 2.0; 2010 2.0.
  - GDP (CFAF billions): 2008 1,250.5; 2009 1,326.5; 2010 1,407.2.
  - Exchange rate CFAF/US$ (annual average): 2007 478.5.
  - Gross international reserves (months of imports): 2008 3.2; 2009 3.1; 2010 3.1.

### Fiscal strategy, 2008–10: targets and priorities
- Core fiscal aim: gradual fiscal adjustment to achieve a domestic primary surplus of about 1 percent of GDP by 2010, combined with HIPC/MDRI debt relief and increased foreign aid.
- Revenue and spending targets:
  - Revenue target: raise revenues to about 17¾ percent of GDP by 2010 (from 17.0 percent in 2007).
  - Total revenue and grants: 2008 Est. 19.5 percent of GDP; 2009 21.2; 2010 22.1.
  - Domestic spending: hold broadly constant and reallocate to priorities.
- Social and infrastructure spending:
  - Project support expected to rise to about 6 percent of GDP; spending on education, health, and investment could reach about 15 percent of GDP by 2010 (against 9¼ percent of GDP in 2006).
  - Program includes annual spending of 1–1½ percent of GDP on restructuring state-owned enterprises.
- 2008 budget specifics:
  - Targets a balanced primary fiscal position.
  - Revenues projected at 17¼ percent of GDP, supported by administration improvements and full-year effect of customs computerization (SYDONIA++).
  - Domestic expenditures kept at about 17¼ percent of GDP and reallocated toward health, education, the energy sector, and restructuring of state-owned banks and enterprises.
  - Additional external project support to finance about 3¼ percent of GDP in extra spending.
  - Exceptional financing and debt relief needed to clear external arrears and restart external debt service to multilateral creditors while reducing domestic liabilities.

### External financing, PRGF access, and arrears clearance
- Total external program financing needs for 2008–10: about $2.1 billion, 75 percent of GDP.
  - About two-thirds relates to arrears clearance in 2008 and HIPC/MDRI completion point relief in 2010.
  - Project support estimated at about 5 percent of GDP a year.
  - Annual financing gap of about 3 percent of GDP expected during restructuring and arrears reduction.
  - Gap to be closed by concessional debt rescheduling (1 percent of GDP a year) and budget support (2 percent of GDP a year), including BCEAO credit unlocked by PRGF disbursements.
- Understandings on arrears clearance:
  - World Bank: Memorandum of Understanding on clearing about $150 million in arrears through an exceptional IDA grant, envisaged for May 2008 (document also cites about $153 million operation financed by exceptional IDA allocation planned for end-May 2008, including $17.6 million as budget support).
  - AfDB: plans to help clear about $20 million in arrears through a grant under the new fragile states facility.
  - EU: allocated about $30 million to clear Togo’s arrears to the EIB through two grants, in 2008 and 2009.
  - FIDA has proposed an arrears rescheduling.
  - Paris Club has provided financing assurances; authorities expected to request rescheduling of bilateral debt on concessional terms.
- PRGF access and rationale:
  - PRGF access proposed at 90 percent of quota (SDR 66.06 million).
  - Fund’s contribution would be about 3¼ percent of GDP over three years and about 4 percent of total external financing envisaged.
  - Disbursement profile moderately frontloaded to meet 2008 financing needs and unlock BCEAO credit of about 1¼ percent of GDP in 2008.
- PRGF disbursement schedule (SDR amounts and conditions):
  - SDR 13,260,000 — April 23, 2008 — Executive Board approval of the three-year arrangement under the PRGF
  - SDR 8,800,000 — October 31, 2008 — Observance of performance criteria for June 2008 and completion of the first review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — April 30, 2009 — Observance of performance criteria for December 2008 and completion of the second review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — October 31, 2009 — Observance of performance criteria for June 2009 and completion of the third review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — April 30, 2010 — Observance of performance criteria for December 2009 and completion of the fourth review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — October 31, 2010 — Observance of performance criteria for June 2010 and completion of the fifth review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — April 30, 2011 — Observance of performance criteria for December 2010 and completion of the sixth review
- Capacity to repay (Table 8, selected):
  - Net use of Fund credit (millions of SDRs): 2008 21.0; 2009 17.6; 2010 17.6; 2011 8.8; 2013 -1.3; 2014 -5.3; 2015 -8.8.
  - Outstanding Fund credit (millions of SDRs): 2008 22.1; 2009 39.7; 2010 57.3; 2011 66.1; 2013 64.7; 2014 59.4; 2015 50.6.

### Structural reforms, financial sector, and public enterprises
- Fiscal governance measures (medium term and TMU-linked):
  - Make full use of SYDONIA++; computerize tax administration; move to risk-based audits; tighten control of the Export Processing Zone; update the customs code; streamline tax exemptions.
  - Implement a new monthly monitoring template (designed with IMF technical assistance) and move to an integrated software system.
  - Curtail payment orders without budget line identification; introduce risk-based controls; adopt a new procurement code.
  - Adopt a strategy for clearing domestic arrears; unify treasury management; introduce regular Treasury bill auctions.
  - Set up a General Inspectorate of Finance; activate the Court of Public Accounts.
  - Move to unified current and capital budgets and multiyear budgets.
- Financial sector priorities:
  - Bank restructuring critical to macro stability; priority on BTCI (state-owned):
    - New management and oversight of BTCI was a prior action for the PRGF arrangement (done February 2008).
    - Authorities plan to recapitalize BTCI, improve liquidity (including issuing government securities), address nonperforming loans to state-owned companies, and attract a strategic investor in coordination with BCEAO and WAMU Banking Commission.
  - Privatization and review of other banks: expect to privatize UTB; review options for other banks.
  - Improve banking supervision (BCEAO and Banking Commission) and develop securities market; introduce short-term Treasury bills; review pension system reforms.
- Public enterprise actions and sectoral reforms:
  - Cotton sector: transform SOTOCO into a new company partly owned by cotton producers; strengthen governance after audits; SOTOCO audits completed and arrears to cotton farmers repaid.
  - Phosphate sector: create new legal entity to receive financing; initiate audit and attract strategic investor (financial audit underway; comprehensive audit to be financed by World Bank LICUS grant).
  - Energy: rehabilitate generation capacity; contract privately financed generators linked to the West Africa gas pipeline; review CEET finances and adopt performance contract with World Bank consultation.
  - World Bank assistance to review telecommunications, roads, and port investment and reforms.
  - Improve business environment: adopt new investment code; reduce corporate tax rate; facilitate business registration; judicial reform.
- Structural benchmarks through end-2008 (selected):
  - Submit 2008 budget law to parliament — Prior action (done: December 2007).
  - Change management and oversight of BTCI — Prior action (done: February 2008).
  - Implement new framework for monthly budget monitoring (Benchmark: August 2008).
  - Create a General Inspectorate of Finance (Performance criterion: August 2008).
  - Adopt strategy/time table for clearing domestic arrears (Performance criterion: December 2008).
  - Initiate restructuring of BTCI, including raising capital via government securities (Benchmark: December 2008).
  - Initiate phosphate sector audit (Benchmark: August 2008).
  - Prepare CEET financial review (Benchmark: December 2008).

### Arrears clearance strategy and domestic arrears
- Strategy to clear domestic arrears:
  - Adopt and publish a strategy covering all overdue claims by private suppliers verified by the 2007 KPMG audit and its update and validated by the government.
  - Convert verified arrears into tradable government securities, with payments starting in 2009.
  - Strategy to set out principles for dealing with other arrears.
- Key quantitative indicators on arrears and financing (selected):
  - External debt/arrears reduction (percent of GDP): 2008 30.7; 2009 0.0; 2010 21.6; 2008-10 52.3.
  - Arrears clearance (percent of GDP): 2008 30.7; 2009 0.0; 2010 0.0; 2008-10 30.7.
  - Total external financing needs (percent of GDP): 2008 36.8; 2009 7.9; 2010 30.1; 2008-10 74.8.
  - Flow financing composition (percent of GDP): Project grants & loans: 2008 3.3; 2009 5.1; 2010 5.9; Program support: 2008 2.0; 2009 1.8; 2010 1.7; IMF (90 percent of quota): 2008 1.3; 2009 1.0; 2010 0.9.

### Program monitoring, conditionality, and reporting obligations
- Monitoring framework:
  - Semiannual quantitative performance criteria limited to core indicators, including the primary fiscal balance and domestic financing, with adjustors to smooth expenditure in case of aid volatility.
  - Zero ceiling on central government contracting or guaranteeing new nonconcessional debt (continuous performance criterion) and standard continuous performance criterion on nonaccumulation of external arrears.
  - Indicative targets for revenue, domestic arrears, and spending on investment and social sectors.
  - Structural conditionality focuses on macro-critical measures; two prior actions completed for 2008 (2008 budget and BTCI) and seven structural measures for the rest of 2008, two of which are performance criteria.
  - First review scheduled for October 2008 and second for April 2009.
- Reporting obligations (selected, deadlines preserved):
  - Domestic primary fiscal balance: reported monthly within eight weeks of the end of the month.
  - Net domestic financing: reported monthly within eight weeks of the end of the month.
  - Government revenue: reported monthly to the IMF within four weeks of the end of the month.
  - Domestic payments arrears: change in arrears reported in the TOFE prepared monthly by the Economic Directorate of the Ministry of Finance.
  - External payments arrears: reported monthly within six weeks of the end of the month.
  - Government will report any study or official report on the economy within two weeks of publication and any decision/order/law/decree/circular with economic or financial implications as soon as published or at latest once it takes effect.
- TMU coverage: January 1, 2008 to December 31, 2010; Table 1 shows quantitative performance criteria and benchmarks for end-March 2008, end-June 2008, end-September 2008 and end-December 2008 based on cumulative changes from January 1, 2008.
- Specific data reporting templates and timelines for real sector, government finance, public investment, public debt, money and banking, and balance of payments are listed in the TMU with precise within-four-weeks or within-eight-weeks deadlines.

### Risks, mitigation, and staff appraisal
- Main risks identified:
  - Political and social tensions under tight budgets that could weaken investor confidence and delay donor reengagement.
  - Capacity constraints from decades of conflict and donor disengagement limiting implementation.
  - Fragile banks jeopardizing macro stability with possible regional spillovers.
  - Exogenous shocks: euro appreciation, higher world oil prices, worsening energy crisis, bad weather affecting agriculture.
- Mitigation measures:
  - Program discussed with broad stakeholders (parliament, trade unions, civil society) to mitigate social/political tensions.
  - Donor reengagement and technical assistance to address capacity constraints.
  - Strengthen banking sector, close monitoring of liquidity and credit growth, and BCEAO coordination on reserve requirements and monetary developments.
  - Improve competitiveness via infrastructure restoration and flexible fiscal policy response to shocks.
- Staff appraisal and overall judgment:
  - Notable progress since mid-2006 in strengthening public finances and initiating structural reforms; SMP targets largely met and domestic arrears reduced.
  - I-PRSP emphasis on political and fiscal governance appropriate; program can help consolidate macro stability and pave way for HIPC/MDRI debt relief.
  - Coordinated donor reengagement is vital for arrears clearance, debt relief, financing, and technical assistance.
  - Conclusion: Given Togo’s positive SMP track record, the strength of the authorities’ program, and prospects for reviving growth and achieving fiscal and debt sustainability, Togo warrants support with a three-year PRGF arrangement.

*Source: IMF country documentation, CR08146 (Selected Economic and Financial Indicators and accompanying sections).*

### 1. Selected Economic and Financial Indicators, 2005-10................................................17

### _cr08146 - 1. Selected Economic and Financial Indicators, 2005-10................................................17

### Background: political and institutional context
- Parliamentary elections on October 14, 2007 were judged free and transparent; the European Union resumed financial assistance after a 15-year suspension.
- Principal constraints to growth and development:
  - Poor governance and low administrative capacity following prolonged sociopolitical conflict and mismanagement of public resources.
  - Excessive public debt, with external debt above the HIPC threshold, external arrears, and very large domestic arrears.
  - Fragile banks, including the highest nonperforming loan ratio in the WAEMU area and undercapitalization of several banks.
  - Severe energy crisis caused by region-wide shortages and cuts in electricity exports to Togo.
  - Loss-making state-owned cotton and phosphate enterprises producing large quasi-fiscal deficits and mounting debts.
  - Poor business environment and underinvestment in transport and energy infrastructure.
  - Deteriorated social conditions following suspension of donor support for health, education, and infrastructure.
- I-PRSP adopted March 2008: sets a three-year program focused on fiscal governance, restructuring state-owned enterprises and banks, improving the business environment, rehabilitating transport and energy infrastructure, and improving education and health.

### Recent economic developments and SMP track record
- Growth and external sector:
  - Real GDP growth: upturn in 2006, moderated to about 2 percent in 2007.
  - Current account deficit estimated at 6½ percent of GDP in 2007.
- Inflation, monetary aggregates, and credit:
  - Annual inflation about 1 percent in December 2007, but rising in recent months due to world food prices.
  - Broad money grew 16½ percent in 2007, driven by remittances and trade-related capital inflows; rapid credit growth mainly to finance imports.
- Fiscal performance and arrears:
  - SMP performance: all end-June quantitative targets were met comfortably.
  - Primary fiscal position for 2007 was broadly balanced versus a 2006 primary deficit of 1 percent of GDP.
  - Sharp reduction in domestic arrears, including to civil servants and cotton farmers.
  - 2007 budget partly financed by a CFAF 20 billion regional bond issue (10-year maturity, 3-year grace period, 6 percent coupon) under a WAEMU infrastructure initiative.
- Governance reforms:
  - Administrative reforms since mid-2006 broadened the tax base and recovered tax arrears.
  - Audits of SOTOCO and repayment of its arrears to cotton farmers; strategy initiated to strengthen fragile banks.
  - BTCI (largest bank, state-owned) placed under new management and oversight in February 2008 under terms agreed with the regional Banking Commission.

### PRGF arrangement: objectives and strategy
- Core objectives:
  - Bring public debt to sustainable levels through (i) gradual fiscal adjustment to achieve a moderate but sustainable primary fiscal surplus by 2010 and gradually reduce domestic public debt and arrears; and (ii) comprehensive external HIPC and MDRI debt relief.
  - Reengage development partners to secure financial and technical assistance for priority projects and reforms.
  - Increase resources for health, education, and infrastructure by reallocating domestic spending and effectively using increased external assistance.
  - Strengthen fiscal governance to raise revenue and improve spending efficiency and transparency.
  - Restructure fragile state-owned banks to reduce macroeconomic risks and allow private financial sector development.
  - Initiate growth-oriented structural reforms to improve the business environment and reform public enterprises in cotton and phosphate.
- Role of PRGF: anchor the macroeconomic framework as Togo reengages internationally and progresses toward HIPC and MDRI debt relief.

### 2008–10 macroeconomic framework and projections
- Growth and macro outlook:
  - I-PRSP medium-term framework projects average annual real GDP growth of almost 4 percent for 2008–10.
  - Initial recovery drivers: donor-financed public investment, improved business confidence, growing regional trade, rebound in cotton and phosphate production.
  - Medium-term growth supported by higher FDI, improved financial intermediation, and infrastructure upgrades (especially electricity).
- Key projected indicators (Program; percent of GDP unless otherwise indicated):
  - Real GDP (percent change): 2005 1.3; 2006 4.1; 2007 2.1; 2008 Est. 3.0; 2009 4.0; 2010 4.0.
  - Consumer prices (annual average, percent change): 2005 6.8; 2006 2.2; 2007 1.0; 2008 Est. 4.1; 2009 3.8; 2010 3.5.
  - Broad money (M2, percent change): 2005 1.4; 2006 22.1; 2007 16.4; 2008 Est. 10.0.
  - Total revenue and grants: 2005 16.9; 2006 18.3; 2007 18.7; 2008 Est. 19.5; 2009 21.2; 2010 22.1.
  - Revenue: 2005 15.7; 2006 16.9; 2007 17.0; 2008 Est. 17.2; 2009 17.5; 2010 17.8.
  - Total expenditure and net lending: 2005 20.4; 2006 22.1; 2007 20.6; 2008 Est. 21.9; 2009 22.9; 2010 23.4.
  - Domestic primary expenditure: 2005 16.2; 2006 17.9; 2007 16.8; 2008 Est. 17.2; 2009 16.9; 2010 16.7.
  - Overall balance (payment order basis): 2005 -3.5; 2006 -3.8; 2007 -1.9; 2008 Est. -2.4; 2009 -1.7; 2010 -1.3.
  - Primary balance: 2005 -0.5; 2006 -1.1; 2007 0.2; 2008 Est. 0.0; 2009 0.6; 2010 1.1.
  - Change in domestic arrears: 2005 1.9; 2006 -0.4; 2007 -0.8; 2008 Est. 0.0; 2009 -0.4; 2010 -0.7.
  - Current account balance: 2005 -5.3; 2006 -6.0; 2007 -6.4; 2008 Est. -7.9; 2009 -6.7; 2010 -6.4.
  - Exports of Goods and Services: 2005 40.3; 2006 42.3; 2007 42.0; 2008 Est. 44.4; 2009 45.3; 2010 46.2.
  - Imports of Goods and Services: 2005 57.2; 2006 61.8; 2007 62.6; 2008 Est. 68.0; 2009 69.4; 2010 70.2.
  - External public debt: 2005 90.3; 2006 83.9; 2007 80.9; 2008 Est. 64.2; 2009 60.8; 2010 36.3.
  - Note: external debt projections assume external debt/arrears relief in 2008-2010 broadly in line with potential HIPC/MDRI debt relief.
- Inflation and exchange rate:
  - Inflation expected to be contained, anchored in the WAEMU currency union and fiscal prudence, but vulnerable to weather or world food/fuel price shocks.
  - Real exchange rate unlikely to be significantly overvalued given relatively low wages; international reserves expected to remain at about three months of imports.
- External risks:
  - Balance of payments vulnerable to terms of trade shocks (particularly oil prices), further euro appreciation, and confidence shocks that could lower remittances or trigger bank capital outflows.

### 2008–10 fiscal policies and spending priorities
- Fiscal strategy:
  - Aim: gradual fiscal adjustment to achieve a domestic primary surplus of about 1 percent of GDP by 2010 combined with HIPC/MDRI debt relief and increased foreign aid to reach sustainability and avoid renewed arrears.
  - Revenue target: gradually raise revenues to about 17¾ percent of GDP by 2010 (from 17 percent in 2007).
  - Domestic spending: hold broadly constant while reallocating to priorities.
- Social and infrastructure spending:
  - Project support expected to rise to about 6 percent of GDP; spending on education, health, and investment could reach about 15 percent of GDP by 2010 (against 9¼ percent of GDP in 2006), still insufficient to reach the MDGs.
  - Program includes annual spending of 1–1½ percent of GDP on restructuring state-owned enterprises.
- 2008 budget specifics:
  - Targets a balanced primary fiscal position.
  - Revenues projected at 17¼ percent of GDP, supported by administration improvements and full-year effect of customs computerization.
  - Domestic expenditures kept at about 17¼ percent of GDP and reallocated toward health, education, the energy sector, and restructuring of state-owned banks and enterprises.
  - Additional external project support to finance about 3¼ percent of GDP in extra spending.
  - Exceptional financing and debt relief needed to clear external arrears and restart external debt service to multilateral creditors while reducing domestic liabilities.

### Structural reforms and capacity building
- Reform priorities and sequencing:
  - Sustain fiscal governance reforms, safeguard against banking risks, prepare reform strategies for cotton, phosphate, transport, and energy sectors.
  - Technical assistance and donor coordination critical for institutional capacity building in revenue administration and tax policy, expenditure management, public debt and treasury management, bank restructuring, economic statistics, and public enterprise reform.
  - Fund to lead tax policy and revenue administration work; World Bank to lead public enterprise reform; Fund and World Bank to share responsibility for economic statistics.
  - Authorities created a steering committee to coordinate the reform program and technical assistance needs.
- Governance measures already underway:
  - Strengthened mechanisms for auditing recipients of transfers and subsidies to limit inefficient spending.
  - Strategy to strengthen fragile banks and actions taken for BTCI oversight.

*Source: IMF country documentation, CR08146 (Selected Economic and Financial Indicators and accompanying sections).*

### 17.      The PRGF arrangement places fiscal governance at the center of the structural

### The PRGF arrangement places fiscal governance at the center of the structural reform agenda

### Fiscal governance reforms (medium-term program)
- Strengthen revenue administration to achieve the program’s revenue objective by:
  - making full use of the new customs software;
  - computerizing tax administration;
  - moving to risk-based audits;
  - tightening control of the Export Processing Zone;
  - updating the customs code;
  - streamlining tax exemptions.
- Better monitor budget execution by:
  - implementing a new monthly monitoring template (designed with IMF technical assistance);
  - ultimately moving to an integrated software system.
- Strengthen expenditure management by:
  - curtailing payment orders without budget line identification;
  - expediting spending procedures by introducing risk-based controls;
  - adopting a new procurement code.
- Improve public debt and treasury management by:
  - adopting a strategy for clearing domestic arrears;
  - building public debt management capacity;
  - unifying treasury management;
  - strengthening cash management;
  - introducing regular Treasury bill auctions.
- Tighten internal controls by:
  - setting up a General Inspectorate of Finance under the responsibility of the Minister of Finance to conduct ex-post inspections of agencies that manage public resources;
  - activating the Court of Public Accounts to audit budget implementation.
- Improve budget preparation by:
  - unifying the current and capital budgets;
  - improving accounting;
  - moving to multiyear budgets.

### Financial sector
- Bank restructuring is critical for safeguarding macroeconomic stability.
- Key priority: strengthen Togo’s largest bank, state-owned BTCI.
  - New management and oversight structure is a prior action for the PRGF arrangement.
  - Authorities plan to recapitalize BTCI and improve its liquidity, including by issuing government securities and addressing nonperforming loans to state-owned companies, in close coordination with the BCEAO and the WAMU Banking Commission, with the ultimate goal of attracting a strategic investor.
- Privatization and review of other banks:
  - Expect to privatize UTB, a state-owned bank that has already been strengthened.
  - Review options for other banks.
- Improve banking supervision and develop the securities market:
  - Supervision led by the BCEAO and the Banking Commission will monitor undercapitalized banks and risks from rapid credit growth.
  - Intend to introduce short-term Treasury bills and review options for reforming the pension system.
  - Recommendations of the recent regional FSAP will be discussed in future program reviews.

### Public enterprises and the business environment
- Public enterprise reform is a long-term challenge; sectoral actions include:
  - Cotton sector: transform state-owned SOTOCO into a new company partly owned by cotton producers; strengthen governance following financial and strategic audits.
  - Phosphate sector: create a new legal entity to receive financing from the Islamic Development Bank to upgrade equipment; prepare to audit the sector in coordination with the World Bank to review options for sector reform, including attracting a strategic investor.
  - Energy sector: rehabilitate generation capacity; contracted privately financed construction of generators that can be linked to the new West Africa gas pipeline; review finances of and adopt a performance contract with the local electricity distribution company in consultation with the World Bank.
  - World Bank assistance to review options for investment and reforms in telecommunications, roads, and the port.
- Improve the business environment to raise external competitiveness and attract investment:
  - Fiscal program will accommodate upgrades of public infrastructure (especially transport and energy).
  - Make revenue administration more efficient and avoid new arrears to suppliers to restore business confidence.
  - Additional reforms: adopt a new investment code; reduce the relatively high corporate tax rate; facilitate business registration; judicial reform.

### Program financing, design, and risks
- External financing
  - Total external program financing needs for 2008–10 are projected at about $2.1 billion, 75 percent of GDP.
  - About two-thirds of this relates to arrears clearance in 2008 and HIPC/MDRI completion point relief in 2010.
  - Project support is estimated at about 5 percent of GDP a year.
  - Annual financing gap of about 3 percent of GDP as Togo restructures state-owned banks and enterprises, addresses the energy crisis, resumes external debt service, and begins reducing domestic debt including arrears to suppliers and long-term bonds.
  - Gap expected to be closed by concessional debt rescheduling (1 percent of GDP a year) and budget support (2 percent of GDP a year), including BCEAO credit unlocked by PRGF disbursements.
  - Understandings reached on arrears clearance:
    - World Bank: Memorandum of Understanding on clearing about $150 million in arrears through an exceptional IDA grant, envisaged for May 2008.
    - AfDB: plans to help clear about $20 million in arrears through a grant under the new fragile states facility.
    - EU: allocated about $30 million to clear Togo’s arrears to the EIB through two grants, in 2008 and 2009.
    - FIDA has proposed an arrears rescheduling.
    - Paris Club has provided financing assurances; authorities expected to request rescheduling of bilateral debt on concessional terms.
- PRGF access and rationale
  - PRGF access is proposed at 90 percent of quota (SDR 66.06 million).
  - Reasons for comparatively high access:
    - External financing needs are very large because of: (i) recent exogenous shocks, especially the energy crisis and higher world oil prices; (ii) more than a decade of donor disengagement creating pent-up demand for infrastructure and social spending; (iii) high cost of restructuring state-owned enterprises and clearing past arrears to suppliers; (iv) need to service and lower Togo’s public debt to a sustainable level.
    - Togo’s development partners expected to provide very substantial financing (including through arrears clearance and debt relief). The Fund’s contribution would be about 3¼ percent of GDP over three years and about 4 percent of the total.
    - Program envisages a significant domestic fiscal adjustment: spending outside social and infrastructure areas to be cut by about 2 percent of GDP; revenues to increase by 1 percent of GDP during 2007–10.
    - Domestic financing constrained by lack of a Treasury bill market, BCEAO ceiling on bond issuance, limited government deposits, and need to service large domestic debt.
    - Risks to Fund resources considered low because of: (i) BCEAO’s international reserve position of 5¼ months of imports; (ii) Togo’s positive SMP track record; (iii) strength of the program with prospect that debt will be sustainable by 2010; (iv) Togo’s debt to the Fund has been fully repaid so outstanding Fund credit would be less than in a country with consecutive PRGF arrangements.
- Disbursement profile and program design
  - Disbursements proposed to be moderately frontloaded given good fiscal performance since mid-2006 and large financing needs in 2008.
  - Program envisages a large drawdown of government deposits at the central bank (1 percent of GDP) and postpones repayment of supplier arrears until 2009.
  - IMF disbursements will unlock BCEAO credit of about 1¼ percent of GDP in 2008.
  - Semiannual quantitative performance criteria limited to core indicators, including the primary fiscal balance and domestic financing, with adjustors to smooth expenditure in case of aid volatility.
  - Zero ceiling on central government contracting or guaranteeing new nonconcessional debt and standard continuous performance criterion on nonaccumulation of external arrears.
  - Indicative targets established for revenue, domestic arrears, and spending on investment and social sectors.
  - Structural conditionality focuses on macro-critical measures to strengthen fiscal governance, mitigate macroeconomic risks from banks, and set conditions for private investment and state-owned enterprise reform; structural conditionality for 2008 includes two completed prior actions (on the 2008 budget and BTCI) and seven structural measures for the rest of 2008, two of which are performance criteria.
- Program risks and mitigation
  - Political and social tensions could intensify under tight budget constraints, weakening investor confidence, slowing reforms, and delaying donor reengagement; mitigation: program discussed with a broad spectrum of stakeholders including parliament, trade unions, and civil society.
  - Capacity constraints from decades of political conflict and donor disengagement limit implementation capacity; mitigation: donor reengagement including technical assistance is vital.
  - Fragile banks jeopardize macroeconomic stability with possible regional spillovers; mitigation: continued work to strengthen banking sector and close monitoring of liquidity and credit growth to prevent imprudent lending practices.
  - Exogenous shocks could stymie recovery, including: (i) further appreciation of the euro against the U.S. dollar; (ii) deterioration in the terms of trade, especially further rise in world oil prices; (iii) worsening energy crisis affecting the budget and growth; (iv) bad weather affecting agriculture. Mitigation: improve competitiveness by restoring infrastructure, strengthen governance, and ensure fiscal policy responds flexibly to shocks.

### Staff appraisal
- Progress since mid-2006:
  - Notable progress in strengthening public finances and initiating structural reforms.
  - Fiscal governance reforms have boosted tax revenues and improved expenditure control, resulting in a near-balanced primary position and reversing the accumulation of domestic arrears.
  - The 2008 budget consolidates gains and increases resources for growth-critical sectors.
  - Reforms begun in cotton, phosphate, and energy sectors; governance of Togo’s largest bank strengthened; improved political environment has encouraged donor reengagement.
- I-PRSP assessment:
  - The authorities’ economic reform program set out in the I-PRSP should revive economic growth and improve social conditions.
  - Emphasis on political and fiscal governance is appropriate given past problems.
  - I-PRSP identifies the need to improve the business environment and advance structural reforms in cotton, phosphates, energy, transport, and financial sectors.
  - I-PRSP envisages a major boost in spending on health and education while keeping the fiscal envelope realistic.
- Importance of donor reengagement:
  - Coordinated reengagement with donors and multilateral agencies is vital due to eroded institutional capacity and pent-up demand for spending on health, education, and infrastructure.
  - Arrears clearance, debt relief, program and project financing, and technical assistance are critical for implementing reforms to revive growth and improve social conditions.
- Overall judgment:
  - The PRGF-supported program can help Togo consolidate macroeconomic stability, achieve fiscal and debt sustainability, and pave the way for HIPC/MDRI debt relief.
  - Program supports a medium-term fiscal framework aiming for fiscal and debt sustainability and a sharp increase in resources for priority sectors.
  - PRGF arrangement will facilitate a coordinated boost in external assistance by donors and other creditors and move Togo toward debt relief.
  - Structural intent: consolidate fiscal governance reforms, reinforce Togo’s fragile financial sector, and pursue reform of state-owned enterprises and enhancement of the business environment, monitored mainly by the World Bank.

*IMF staff report excerpt (CR/08/146, section 17–32).*

### 33.      Risks to the program, though significant, are manageable. The risks of political

### _cr08146 - 33.      Risks to the program, though significant, are manageable. The risks of political

### Program assessment and risks
- Risks identified: political tensions, weak implementation capacity, exogenous shocks, fragile banks.
- Mitigation: sound policies and effective reforms, close coordination with Togo’s main development partners to build domestic and international confidence.
- Conclusion: Given Togo’s positive track record on the SMP, the strength of the authorities’ program, and the prospect of reviving economic growth and achieving fiscal and debt sustainability, Togo warrants support with a three-year PRGF arrangement.

### Macroeconomic outlook (selected indicators, 2005–10)
- Real GDP (percent change): 2005: 1.3; 2006: 4.1; 2007: 2.1; 2008: 3.0; 2009: 4.0; 2010: 4.0
- Real GDP per capita (percent change): 2005: -1.3; 2006: 1.5; 2007: -0.4; 2008: 0.5; 2009: 1.4; 2010: 1.4
- GDP deflator (percent change): 2005: 7.6; 2006: 0.2; 2007: 0.9; 2008: 1.6; 2009: 2.0; 2010: 2.0
- Consumer price index (annual average): 2005: 6.8; 2006: 2.2; 2007: 1.0; 2008: 4.1; 2009: 3.8; 2010: 3.5
- GDP (CFAF billions): 2005: 1,112.0; 2006: 1,159.9; 2007: 1,194.9; 2008: 1,250.5; 2009: 1,326.5; 2010: 1,407.2
- Exchange rate CFAF/US$ (annual average): 2005: 526.95; 2006: 522.44; 2007: 478.5
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2005: -5.3; 2006: -6.0; 2007: -6.4; 2008: -7.9; 2009: -6.7; 2010: -6.4
- Exports (goods and services, percent of GDP): 2005: 40.3; 2006: 42.3; 2007: 42.0; 2008: 44.4; 2009: 45.3; 2010: 46.2
- Imports (goods and services, percent of GDP): 2005: 57.2; 2006: 61.8; 2007: 62.6; 2008: 68.0; 2009: 69.4; 2010: 70.2
- External public debt (percent of GDP): 2005: 90.3; 2006: 83.9; 2007: 80.9; 2008: 64.2; 2009: 60.8; 2010: 36.3
- Of which: arrears (percent of GDP): 2005: 28.6; 2006: 29.5; 2007: 32.2; 2008: 0.0; 2009: 0.0; 2010: 0.0
- External public debt service (percent of exports): 2005: 10.6; 2006: 9.2; 2007: 9.1; 2008: 6.7; 2009: 5.3; 2010: 4.9
- Gross international reserves (months of imports): 2005: 2.0; 2006: 3.1; 2007: 3.5; 2008: 3.2; 2009: 3.1; 2010: 3.1

### Balance of payments highlights (billions of CFA francs; selected flows)
- Exports (goods and services, billons CFAF): 2005: 314.2; 2006: 339.8; 2007: 336.5; 2008: 373.3; 2009: 400.8; 2010: 434.0
- Domestic exports (billions CFAF): 2005: 269.7; 2006: 284.1; 2007: 289.9; 2008: 311.9; 2009: 328.6; 2010: 359.6
  - Of which: Cotton: 2005: 33.9; 2006: 15.6; 2007: 10.2; 2008: 16.4; 2009: 19.1; 2010: 19.8
  - Of which: Phosphates: 2005: 18.1; 2006: 20.6; 2007: 18.0; 2008: 32.0; 2009: 40.5; 2010: 43.4
  - Of which: Cement & clinker: 2005: 52.8; 2006: 58.5; 2007: 60.5; 2008: 63.5; 2009: 66.7; 2010: 70.0
- Imports, f.o.b. (billions CFAF): 2005: -497.0; 2006: -561.1; 2007: -575.8; 2008: -666.6; 2009: -722.9; 2010: -776.8
  - Of which: Petroleum products: 2005: -182.6; 2006: -213.6; 2007: -222.0; 2008: -279.3; 2009: -288.9; 2010: -297.5
- Current account balance (billions CFAF): 2005: -58.9; 2006: -69.6; 2007: -76.4; 2008: -98.2; 2009: -89.2; 2010: -90.1
- Capital and financial account (percent of GDP): 2005: -3.8; 2006: 9.5; 2007: 72.6; 2008: 49.1; 2009: 67.1; 2010: 69.2
- Direct investment (billions CFAF): 2005: 24.2; 2006: 39.8; 2007: 30.1; 2008: 41.3; 2009: 53.1; 2010: 63.3
- Overall balance (billions CFAF): 2005: -62.7; 2006: 19.9; 2007: -3.8; 2008: -49.1; 2009: -22.1; 2010: -20.8

### Fiscal stance and government operations (selected items, percent of GDP and billions of CFAF)
- Total revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 2005: 16.9; 2006: 18.3; 2007: 18.7; 2008: 19.5; 2009: 21.2; 2010: 22.1
- Total expenditure and net lending (percent of GDP): 2005: 20.4; 2006: 22.1; 2007: 20.6; 2008: 21.9; 2009: 22.9; 2010: 23.4
- Domestic primary expenditure (percent of GDP): 2005: 16.2; 2006: 17.9; 2007: 16.8; 2008: 17.2; 2009: 16.9; 2010: 16.7
- Overall balance (payment order basis, percent of GDP): 2005: -3.5; 2006: -3.8; 2007: -1.9; 2008: -2.4; 2009: -1.7; 2010: -1.3
- Primary balance (percent of GDP): 2006: -0.5; 2007: -1.1; 2008: 0.2; 2009: 0.0; 2010: 0.6; 2010 (Table 3 prog): 1.1
- Selected 2009–10 budget items (billions CFAF, H1-Prog./Prog.):
  - Revenue and grants: 2009 Prog.: 243.6; 2010 Prog.: 281.2; 2010 H1-Prog.: 311.6 (Table 3 continuation)
  - Total revenue (billions CFAF): 2009 Prog.: 214.6; 2010 Prog.: 232.1; 2010 H1-Prog.: 251.1
  - Tax revenue (billions CFAF): 2009 Prog.: 203.5; 2010 Prog.: 225.6; 2010 H1-Prog.: 247.0
  - Expenditures and net lending (billions CFAF): 2009 Prog.: 273.9; 2010 Prog.: 303.3; 2010 H1-Prog.: 329.9
  - Wages and salaries (billions CFAF): 2009 Prog.: 72.2; 2010 Prog.: 78.0; 2010 H1-Prog.: 85.4
  - Public investment (billions CFAF): 2009 Prog.: 59.9; 2010 Prog.: 83.0; 2010 H1-Prog.: 99.9

### External financing, debt relief, and financing needs (2008–10)
- Total external financing needs (percent of GDP): 2008: 36.8; 2009: 7.9; 2010: 30.1; 2008-10: 74.8
- Stock operations: External debt/arrears reduction (percent of GDP): 2008: 30.7; 2009: 0.0; 2010: 21.6; 2008-10: 52.3
  - Arrears clearance (percent of GDP): 2008: 30.7; 2009: 0.0; 2010: 0.0; 2008-10: 30.7
  - HIPC Completion Point debt reduction (percent of GDP): 2008: 0.0; 2009: 0.0; 2010: 21.6; 2008-10: 21.6
- Balance of payments flow financing needs (percent of GDP): 2008: 6.1; 2009: 7.9; 2010: 8.5; 2008-10: 22.5
  - Current account deficit (excl. interest & grants): 2008: 9.0; 2009: 9.8; 2010: 10.2; 2008-10: 29.0
  - External debt service (incl. regional bond, percent of GDP): 2008: 2.6; 2009: 2.4; 2010: 2.3; 2008-10: 7.3
- Flow financing (composition, percent of GDP):
  - Project grants & loans: 2008: 3.3; 2009: 5.1; 2010: 5.9; 2008-10: 14.2
  - Program support: 2008: 2.0; 2009: 1.8; 2010: 1.7; 2008-10: 5.4
  - IMF (90 percent of quota with frontloading): 2008: 1.3; 2009: 1.0; 2010: 0.9; 2008-10: 3.1
- Debt flow relief (percent of GDP): 2008: 0.9; 2009: 1.0; 2010: 1.0; 2008-10: 2.9

### PRGF financing and disbursement schedule
- Requested PRGF arrangement: SDR 66.06 million (equivalent to 90 percent of quota).
- Proposed schedule of disbursements under PRGF arrangement, 2008–11 (SDR amounts and conditions):
  - SDR 13,260,000 — April 23, 2008 — Executive Board approval of the three-year arrangement under the PRGF
  - SDR 8,800,000 — October 31, 2008 — Observance of performance criteria for June 2008 and completion of the first review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — April 30, 2009 — Observance of performance criteria for December 2008 and completion of the second review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — October 31, 2009 — Observance of performance criteria for June 2009 and completion of the third review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — April 30, 2010 — Observance of performance criteria for December 2009 and completion of the fourth review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — October 31, 2010 — Observance of performance criteria for June 2010 and completion of the fifth review
  - SDR 8,800,000 — April 30, 2011 — Observance of performance criteria for December 2010 and completion of the sixth review
- Table 8 indicators (capacity to repay the Fund, selected years):
  - Net use of Fund credit (millions of SDRs, projections): 2008: 21.0; 2009: 17.6; 2010: 17.6; 2011: 8.8; 2012: -; 2013: -1.3; 2014: -5.3; 2015: -8.8
  - Outstanding Fund credit (in millions of SDRs): 2006: 5.4; 2007: 1.1; 2008: 22.1; 2009: 39.7; 2010: 57.3; 2011: 66.1; 2012: 66.1; 2013: 64.7; 2014: 59.4; 2015: 50.6

### Performance under the Staff-Monitored Program (October 1, 2006—June 30, 2007)
- Selected SMP performance (cumulative changes from Dec. 31, 2005; billions of CFA francs):
  - Domestic primary fiscal balance (floor): SMP target vs Outturn — Dec. 2006: -19.3 vs -12.3; Mar. 2007: -21.8 vs 11.3; June 2007: -26.3 vs -1.2
  - Total revenue (floor): Dec. 2006: 185.9 vs 195.9; Mar. 2007: 230.9 vs 246.1; June 2007: 280.9 vs 298.0
  - Arrears on external debt to official creditors (ceiling) 1: Dec. 2006: 30.0 vs 27.8; Mar. 2007: 35.4 vs 32.7; June 2007: 45.8 vs 41.8
  - Net domestic financing (ceiling): Dec. 2006: 27.9 vs 27.4; Mar. 2007: 31.3 vs 15.2; June 2007: 37.6 vs 30.7
- Note: 1 Excludes estimated late interest on stock of arrears.

### Structural benchmarks, reforms, and implementation status (Oct. 1, 2006—June 30, 2007)
- Expenditure management:
  - Submit preliminary audit report of domestic government debt and arrears: Feb. 2007 — Done.
  - Close 2006 budget expenditure commitments by end-November 2006 and finish issuance of payment authorizations by end-December 2006: Dec. 2006 — Done.
  - Provide monthly data on expenditure based on exceptional payment orders and limit those without prior budgetary line indication for Jan.–June 2007 at 6 percent of total expenditure: June 2007 — Done.
- Revenue administration:
  - Issue decree on tax administration setting up external tax audit service and internal audit unit: Feb. 2007 — Done.
  - Make SYDONIA++ operational in customs administration: April 2007 — Done (October).
- Banking sector and public enterprise reforms:
  - Establish mechanism for Minister of Finance to monitor liquidity of BTCI and UTB daily: Continuous from Dec. 2006 — Done.
  - Design comprehensive time-bound restructuring plan for BTCI and UTB: June 2007 — Understandings reached in March '07; committee to prepare restructuring set up in June '07.
  - Complete financial audit of SOTOCO by February 2007 and strategic audits by April 2007: April 2007 — Done (financial audit finalized in July; strategic audit submitted in August).
  - Launch financial and strategic audit of phosphate sector: June 2007 — Underway (financial audit part of liquidation process; comprehensive audit to be financed by World Bank LICUS grant).

### Envisaged structural reforms for 2009–10 (areas and selected actions)
- Fiscal governance and PFM:
  - Elaborate a timebound PFM action plan based on PEMFAR and IMF PFM TA recommendations.
  - Introduce pluriannual budgeting with budgetary data in line with GFS methodology.
  - Audit bank accounts of the public sector; centralize and consolidate treasury management.
  - Start servicing domestic arrears to suppliers based on a published arrears clearance strategy.
  - Activate the Court of Public Accounts.
  - Elaborate a new procurement code in line with international standards.
- Financial sector:
  - BTCI and UTB: bring accounting and risk management in line with WAEMU prudential regulations.
  - BTCI: adopt decision on mechanism for long-term restructuring with aim of transferring bank to private management.
  - UTB: start privatization process in a transparent framework.
  - Prepare a financial sector strategy; commence regular Treasury bill auctions.
  - Phosphate sector: complete the audit and initiate restructuring.
- Business environment and public enterprise reforms:
  - Strengthen Export Processing Zone controls (SYDONIA++ activation and legal updates).
  - Adopt a new investment code that streamlines procedures and implement legal/regulatory changes to streamline business registration.
  - Prepare and start implementing strategy to remove bottlenecks to the business environment.
- Note: Items marked * are shared responsibilities with the World Bank and/or other development partners; items marked ** are to be led by World Bank or other development partners.

### Monetary and banking indicators (Monetary Survey, selected)
- Net foreign assets (Dec. 2005): 145.1 (billions CFAF); BCEAO: 91.9; Commercial banks: 53.2
- Money supply (M2, Dec. 2005): 321.7 (billions CFAF)
  - Currency in circulation (Dec. 2005): 63.2 (billions CFAF)
  - Bank deposits (Dec. 2005): 258.5 (billions CFAF)
- Annual change in broad money (M2, percent of beginning-of-period broad money): 2006: 1.4; 2007: 22.1; 2008 (program): 16.4; 2010 (program): 10.0
- Credit to the rest of the economy (Dec. 2005): 195.1 (billions CFAF)

### Social and Millennium Development indicators (selected, 1990–2005)
- Malnutrition prevalence, weight for age (% of children under 5): 1990: 24.6; 1995: 19.0; 2005: 25.1
- Primary completion rate, total (% of relevant age group): 1990: 35; 1995: 39; 2000: 61; 2005: 65
- Immunization, measles (% of children ages 12–23 months): 1990: 73; 1995: 53; 2000: 58; 2005: 70
- Mortality rate, infant (per 1,000 live births): 1990: 88; 1995: 83; 2000: 80; 2005: 78
- Prevalence of HIV, total (% of population ages 15–49): 2005: 3.2
- GNI per capita (Atlas method, current US$): 1990: 380; 1995: 280; 2000: 270; 2005: 350
- Population, total (millions): 1990: 4.0; 1995: 4.5; 2000: 4.5; 2005: 4.6; 2005: 6.1 (table shows 6.1 under a later column)

### Policy commitment and program documentation
- Letter of Intent dated March 28, 2008 requests a three-year PRGF arrangement of SDR 66.06 million and requests first disbursement SDR 13.26 million after Executive Board approval.
- The enclosed Memorandum on Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP) describes the economic program for 2008–10; program reviews scheduled in October 2008 and April 2009 based on performance criteria and structural benchmarks.
- Government commitment: provide all data required to monitor the program on a timely basis and publish the Letter of Intent and MEFP and regularly report on progress.

*Source: Togolese authorities; and Fund staff estimates and projections, as presented in the IMF staff report content unit.*

### 1.      As Togo finally emerges from its long socio-political crisis, the time has come to

### _cr08146 - 1.      As Togo finally emerges from its long socio-political crisis, the time has come to

### Background and diagnosis
- Living standards and social conditions were relatively high in the 1970s; the economy experienced volatility in the 1980s and deteriorated thereafter due to socio-political conflict, economic and financial mismanagement, overindebtedness, and external shocks.
- Recent corrective measures (past two years) included: replacing top managers of the tax and customs administrations; closing bank accounts used for offbudget operations; limiting use of exceptional spending procedures; auditing the state-owned cotton company and the government’s domestic debt; and clearing arrears to cotton farmers.
- Outcomes of recent efforts: boosted fiscal revenues, controlled expenditures, reduced the fiscal deficit, and reduced domestic arrears; met all quantitative targets and almost completed all structural benchmarks under the recent Staff-Monitored Program (October 2006 – June 2007).
- Remaining legacy problems:
  - Excessive public debt and large arrears undermining supplier and creditor confidence.
  - Poor management and mounting losses in state-owned enterprises (notably cotton and phosphate).
  - Banking sector stresses: high nonperforming loans and some highly undercapitalized banks.
  - Decades of underinvestment in infrastructure (transport and energy) and poor governance.
  - Declined institutional capacity and donor disengagement.
  - Deteriorated education and health services due to poor expenditure management and a decade-long freeze in foreign aid.
  - Recent shocks: severe energy crisis, high world oil prices, rapid euro appreciation, and flooding in certain parts of the country.

### Program objectives (I-PRSP)
- Overarching aim: revive economic growth and raise living standards.
- Poverty and social context:
  - "About 62 percent of the population fall below the poverty line."
  - Health system lacks qualified personnel, medical supplies, and infrastructure; high infant and maternal mortality and infant malnutrition.
  - Teacher shortages and overburdened school infrastructure eroding education quality.
  - Lack of public investment reduced access to basic social services and constrained economic opportunities.
- Strategic axes of the I-PRSP:
  - Political and economic governance:
    - Strengthen public financial management to channel fiscal spending into priority areas, use foreign aid more effectively, and restore private sector confidence.
    - Fiscal strategy: gradual fiscal adjustment, resumption of concessional donor support, comprehensive debt relief under the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries (HIPC) Initiative and the Multilateral Debt Relief Initiative (MDRI).
    - Political governance measures: build strong civil society, reform public administration, strengthen the judicial system, and fight corruption.
  - Economic revival and sustainable development:
    - Restructure loss-making state-owned enterprises (especially cotton and phosphate) and ailing state-owned banks.
    - Stabilize electricity supply and improve transport infrastructure through investment and sectoral reforms.
    - Facilitate business and property registration and streamline tax and regulatory procedures.
    - Foster regional integration, reform agriculture, improve natural resource management, and protect the environment.
  - Social sectors and human development:
    - Enhance access to education and health services, rehabilitate infrastructure, improve education quality, increase food security among the poor, expand access to water and sanitation, and promote gender equality, employment, and social protection.

### Macroeconomic program and projections
- Growth target:
  - "Our program targets real GDP growth of at least 3¾ percent a year in 2008–10."
  - Initial recovery drivers: donor-financed investment projects, improved business confidence, stronger cotton and phosphate production.
  - Medium-term sustainers: higher foreign direct investment, growing regional trade, improved financial intermediation, and upgrades to public infrastructure (especially electricity and transport).
- Inflation and monetary framework:
  - Inflation expected to remain well contained, anchored in the WAEMU currency union and supported by prudent fiscal policies.
  - Monetary policy, exchange rate policy, and banking supervision conducted at the regional level; monetary authorities will closely monitor money and credit growth in Togo and may increase reserve requirements if necessary.
- Balance of payments and reserves:
  - Exports expected to recover gradually as state-owned enterprises are restructured and the business climate improves.
  - Current account deficit is unlikely to decline in the near term because higher external assistance and private investment will boost imports.
  - "We expect Togo’s gross international reserves to remain at around three months of imports."
- Risks and constraints:
  - Dependence on electricity imports causing frequent energy shortages.
  - External competitiveness vulnerable to higher oil prices, lower cotton or phosphate prices, and further euro appreciation.
  - Shocks in neighboring countries (given Togo’s role as a regional trade hub and financial linkages across the WAEMU) could negatively affect prospects.
  - Commitment to remain vigilant and prudent in fiscal, economic, and financial sector policies to mitigate potential fallout.

### Fiscal policy targets and priorities
- Guiding principle: keep domestic spending within the domestic resource envelope.
- Revenue and fiscal balance targets:
  - "Plan to raise revenue collection to 17¾ percent of GDP by 2010."
  - Target "a primary domestic fiscal surplus of about 1 percent of GDP."
  - Contingency spending cuts identified to safeguard the primary surplus if revenue or financing falls short.
- Social and investment spending:
  - Scale up spending on health, education, and vital public infrastructure (notably energy and transport).
  - Finance increases by reallocating domestic expenditures and, as donors resume assistance, raising foreign-financed project spending to "at least 6 percent of GDP a year."
  - After a decade-long salary freeze, the public wage bill will increase moderately, largely in health and education, but remain within a realistic budgetary framework consistent with WAEMU convergence criteria.
  - Budgets for 2008–10 will accommodate restructuring of ailing state-owned banks and enterprises.
- Debt sustainability:
  - Objective to bring public debt to a sustainable level via domestic fiscal adjustment, measures to reduce domestic debt and arrears, concessional donor assistance (mostly grants), and comprehensive debt relief under HIPC and MDRI.

### External financing needs and creditor engagement
- Domestic financing limits: constrained by BCEAO’s ceiling on issuing rediscountable bonds, limited government deposits, and the need to service domestic debt and arrears.
- Four areas of requested support from development partners:
  1. Enhanced technical assistance to rebuild institutional capacity.
  2. Assistance to finance vital projects in education, health, and infrastructure — mostly grants, remainder concessional loans.
  3. Rescheduling and reduction of Togo’s debt and arrears, including under HIPC and MDRI.
     - Expectation: reach the HIPC decision point "after six months," and the HIPC completion point "before the end of the program period."
  4. Program financing from the IMF and others to close projected balance of payments and budget gaps.
- Immediate priorities and creditor arrangements:
  - Signed Memorandum of Understanding with the World Bank specifying actions through March 2008; requested clearance of Togo’s arrears to the Bank through an exceptional IDA allocation soon thereafter and requested new program financing to cover future debt service.
  - Understandings with the African Development Bank (AfDB) for arrears clearance under its forthcoming facility for fragile states; expect donor support to cover contributions.
  - EU agreed to clear arrears to the European Investment Bank through grants under the ninth and tenth EDFs.
  - FIDA proposed to reschedule most arrears with a three-year moratorium period without debt service.
  - Contacted other multilateral creditors (BADEA, OPEC, IsDB, BIDC, BOAD, FSA, Fegece) to negotiate arrears clearance and rescheduling.
  - Seeking generous treatment from Paris Club creditors to clear arrears and reschedule debt service during the program period.
  - Will request renegotiation of debt and arrears with all other bilateral creditors on terms comparable to the Paris Club’s.

### Structural reform agenda (priority areas and sequencing)
- Overall approach:
  - Comprehensive structural reform agenda specified in the I-PRSP.
  - Priority reforms monitored under the PRGF arrangement center on: fiscal governance reforms, financial sector development, and reforms of state-owned enterprises and the business environment.
  - Initial focus: improve public expenditure management, initiate bank restructuring, and prepare reform strategies in key sectors (cotton, phosphate, and energy).
  - Second phase: implement sectoral reform strategies and improve the business environment while continuing to strengthen public financial management and the banking sector.
  - Technical assistance and close coordination with development partners are critical.
  - Increased retirement age for certain civil servants "from 55 to 60 years" to prevent an anticipated wave of retirement of skilled personnel.
- Fiscal governance — planned measures and operational steps:
  - Public financial management action plan to be drafted based on recent IMF technical assistance recommendations and the 2006 Public Expenditure Management and Financial Accountability Review; plan to indicate where technical assistance and external project financing are needed.
  - Intend to set up an integrated information technology system for public finance.
- Revenue administration measures:
  - Continue to strengthen revenue administration to secure the targeted increase in revenue collection.
  - Recent reforms already implemented: strengthened tax and customs administrations; closed offbudget bank accounts; collected tax arrears; reorganized the tax department, including units for internal audit and tax inspections; completed installation of an advanced computer software system ("Sydonia ++") in the main customs offices and started using the system; introduced an internal audit unit in customs.
  - 2009–10 plans:
    - (i) Strengthen human resources through training and recruitment of qualified personnel.
    - (ii) Computerize the tax administration.
    - (iii) Move toward more selective, risk-based ex-ante and ex-post tax audits.
    - (iv) Strengthen control of the Export Processing Zone by activating the Sydonia++ segment recording goods and services in and out from the Zone and updating the law regulating the Zone to provide the audit unit of the tax and customs administrations the authority to perform inspections.
    - (v) Update the tax code to streamline tax exemptions.
    - (vi) Update the customs code.
    - (vii) Introduce a computerized, double accounting system at all levels of revenue administration.
- Public expenditure management reforms:
  - Curtail exceptional payments authorizations without ex-ante budget line identification ("ordres de paiement sans telegramme lettre") to use such procedures only for unforeseen emergencies.
  - Closed expenditure commitments ("engagements") at end-November and payment authorizations ("ordonnancements") by end-December in both the 2006 and 2007 budget cycles.
  - Ensure suspense accounts ("comptes des consignations") are used only in exceptional cases; subsidies to be committed based on quarterly allocations for recipients.
  - Medium-term goal: restore regular and predictable expenditure procedures via streamlined and expedited procedures using simplified risk-based controls.
  - Work with the World Bank to adopt a new procurement code in line with WAEMU standards.
  - Audit the civil service pension fund (CRT) and conduct a census of civil servants.
- Budget preparation, monitoring, and accounting:
  - Set up a monitoring committee that compiles monthly data.
  - Introduce a new framework for monitoring budget execution using a template from IMF technical assistance to review monthly data (commitments, authorizations, and payments by budget category, including priority sectors) within 15 days after month-end to compare outturns to program targets and take corrective action.
  - Medium-term objective: introduce an integrated software system to monitor budget execution in real time.
  - Unified budget preparation for current and capital expenditures under the Director of Budget in the Ministry of Economy and Finance; medium-term objective to move to multi-year budgets with classifications in line with IMF’s Government Finance Statistics methodology (GFSM 2001).
- Internal audits, controls, and oversight:
  - Resources set aside in the 2008 budget to set up and staff a General Inspectorate of Finance under the direct responsibility of the Minister of Finance.
  - Inspectorate will conduct selective ex-post inspections, prepare a yearly work program, report inspections and recommendations to the Minister of Finance, disseminate an annual report, and after a trial phase start full operations in 2009.
  - Conduct a comprehensive audit of all banking system deposits and liabilities of public agencies.
  - Activate the Court of Public Accounts in time for the review of the execution of the 2009 budget and subsequently submit to parliament laws on budget execution ("lois de reglement").
- Public debt and treasury management:
  - Strengthen the Directorate of Public Debt to improve data management and payments procedures as regular debt service resumes.
  - Compiled an improved dataset on public external debt, trained staff, and clarified payments procedures.
  - Intend to enforce the WAEMU Directive (Reglement) that only the Minister of Finance has the authority to contract or guarantee external debt.
  - Commitment: "We will not contract or guarantee any nonconcessional external debt, as defined in the TMU, throughout the program period."

*Document: IMF staff report chapter on Togo’s economic program and reforms.*

### 27.      To restore supplier confidence, we will adopt and publish a strategy for clearing

### _cr08146 - 27.      To restore supplier confidence, we will adopt and publish a strategy for clearing

### Strategy to clear domestic arrears
- Adopt and publish a strategy for clearing domestic arrears covering all overdue claims by private suppliers that have been verified by the 2007 KPMG audit and its subsequent update, and have been validated by the government.
- Convert these verified arrears into tradable government securities, with payments starting in 2009.
- Strategy will set out principles for dealing with other arrears.

### Treasury and public finance management reforms (2009–10)
- Centralize and unify treasury management under the sole responsibility of the treasurer.
- Conduct a reconciliation of all banking system accounts of government and autonomous public agencies.
- Strengthen cash management by introducing monthly forecasts of revenue and spending.
- Prepare and commence regular Treasury bill auctions.
- Integrate monitoring and management of external and domestic public debt.
- Initiate regular reporting of debt management operations and projections.

### Financial sector restructuring and measures
- Restructure ailing state-owned banks is critical for macroeconomic stability and effective financial intermediation.
- Actions taken under the SMP:
  - Strengthened monitoring of several banks and initiated bank restructuring based on recommendations of the WAMU Banking Commission and the March 2007 IMF technical assistance mission with World Bank participation.
  - Changed management and oversight of BTCI based on terms of references prepared in consultation with the WAMU Banking Commission.
- Near-term priorities:
  - Recapitalize BTCI and UTB, including issuing government securities and addressing nonperforming loans to state-owned enterprises in the cotton and phosphate sectors.
  - Restore UTB’s board of directors and identify a strategic investor.
- Consult with the BCEAO on its assessment of monetary developments and possible measures to mitigate risks from rapid credit growth, including adjustments to reserve requirements (see paragraph 7).
- Planned 2009–10 actions:
  - Continue strengthening BTCI and UTB by aligning accounting and risk management with WAEMU prudential regulations.
  - Adopt an action plan for long-term restructuring of BTCI, with the long-term goal of turning the bank over to private management.
  - Start the privatization process for UTB in a transparent framework.
  - Prepare a financial sector strategy, taking into account the findings of a future FSAP with the IMF and World Bank.
  - Strengthen supervision of microfinance institutions.
  - Examine reform options for the pension system.
  - Commence regular T-bill auctions in a predictable and transparent framework.

### Public enterprises, sectoral reforms, and business environment
- Completed under the SMP:
  - Financial and strategic audits of SOTOCO (state-owned cotton company), replaced the financial director, and repaid all arrears to cotton farmers.
  - Transform SOTOCO into a new company partly owned by cotton producers per audit recommendation.
  - Formed a new legal entity in the phosphate sector and received external financing to upgrade equipment.
  - Started repairing existing energy capacity and contracted privately-financed construction of new generators linked to the Nigeria-Ghana gas pipeline.
  - Introduced a new institutional and regulatory structure for CEET and will prepare a review of its finances and operations.
  - Set up a one-stop window for enterprises (CFE) to shorten regulatory procedures.
- Plans for 2009–10:
  - Adopt a new investment code to facilitate foreign direct investment while ensuring a level playing field for all enterprises.
  - Institute legal and regulatory changes to make it easier to register businesses and properties.
  - Reduce Togo’s relatively high corporate tax rate as part of a broadly revenue neutral package while enlarging the tax base.
  - Sector follow-through:
    - Complete the phosphate audit, implement its recommendations, and attract a strong strategic investor.
    - Complete the restructuring of SOTOCO.
    - Initiate financial and technical rehabilitation of the energy sector in close collaboration with the World Bank and regional partners.
    - Audit and reform the operation of the state road fund (FER).
    - Audit and strengthen the Port of Lomé.
    - Prepare and initiate an agricultural reform strategy to help export crops recover.

### Program monitoring framework
- PRGF-supported program monitored by:
  - Agreed quantitative targets (Table 1), structural performance criteria and benchmarks (Table 2), and semiannual program reviews.
  - Quantitative targets for end-June 2008 and end-December 2008 are performance criteria; end-March 2008 and end-September 2008 are indicative targets.
  - First review scheduled for October 2008 and second for April 2009.
  - Reporting requirements, performance criteria, and program benchmarks are contained in the attached Technical Memorandum of Understanding.
- Institutional arrangements:
  - An inter-ministerial steering committee will supervise the economic reform program, issue monthly progress reports, liaise with domestic agencies and development partners, and track technical assistance needs.

### Key quantitative performance figures (from Table 1; cumulative changes from end of preceding calendar year; Billions of CFA francs)
- Domestic primary fiscal balance (floor): 2.5 (Mar), 9.7 (Jun), -4.5 (Sep), -3.7 (Dec), 0.0 (Est/Prog column headings context)
- Nonaccumulation of external arrears: 1 20.7 (Mar)............
- Net domestic financing (ceiling): 2 14.8 (Mar), -6.7 (Jun), 1.9 (Sep), -1.1 (Dec), -7.5 (Est/Prog)
- Central government contracting or guaranteeing of nonconcessional external debt (ceiling) ¹: ...0.0 (Mar), 0.0 (Jun), 0.0 (Sep), 0.0 (Dec)
- Indicative Targets:
  - Total revenue (floor): 203.3 (Mar), 51.1 (Jun), 103.6 (Sep), 158.4 (Dec), 214.6 (Est/Prog)
  - Domestic payments arrears, changes in stock (ceiling): -9.8 (Mar), 0.0 (Jun), 0.0 (Sep), 0.0 (Dec), 0.0 (Est/Prog)
  - Domestically financed social and capital spending (floor): ...24.5 (Mar), 48.9 (Jun), 73.4 (Sep), 97.8 (Dec)
  - Projected program financing: 0.0 (Mar), 9.6 (Jun), 16.2 (Sep), 24.7 (Dec)
- Notes:
  - 1 Continuous performance criterion.
  - 2 Excluding BCEAO credit to government linked to IMF financing. The ceiling on net domestic financing will be adjusted to offset deviations from projected external program financing, subject to a cap of CFAF 5 billion.

### Structural reform schedule and selected benchmarks (through end-2008)
- Fiscal governance measures:
  - Submit 2008 budget law to parliament — Prior action (done: December 2007).
  - Implement a new framework for monthly monitoring of budget execution, and report data for April–June 2008 based on a new template — Benchmark: August 2008.
  - Create a General Inspectorate of Finance under the responsibility of the Minister of Finance — Performance criterion: August 2008.
  - Adopt a strategy and time table for clearing domestic arrears — Performance criterion: December 2008.
- Financial sector measures:
  - Change management and oversight of BTCI based on terms of reference prepared in consultation with the WAMU Banking Commission — Prior action (done: February 2008).
  - Initiate restructuring of BTCI, including by raising its capital through issuance of government securities — Benchmark: December 2008.
  - Adopt an action plan for introducing regular Treasury bill auctions in 2009 — Benchmark: December 2008.
- Public enterprise measures:
  - Initiate an audit of the phosphate sector, based on competitive selection of an audit company, in consultation with the World Bank — Benchmark: August 2008.
  - Prepare a review of the finances of the national electricity company (CEET), in consultation with the World Bank — Benchmark: December 2008.

### TMU definitions and reporting requirements (selected)
- TMU covers January 1, 2008 to December 31, 2010; Table 1 of the MEFP shows quantitative performance criteria and benchmarks for end-March 2008, end-June 2008, end-September 2008 and end-December 2008 based on cumulative changes from January 1, 2008.
- Definitions:
  - Debt: current liability under contractual arrangement as specified in Point 9 of the Guidelines on Performance Criteria with Respect to Foreign Debt (IMF, August 24, 2000), including loans, suppliers’ credits, and leases; arrears, penalties, and judicially awarded damages arising from failure to make payment under a contractual obligation that constitutes debt are debt.
  - Government: central government of the Republic of Togo; excludes political subdivisions, the central bank, or any government-owned entity with separate legal personality.
- Reporting deadlines:
  - Domestic primary fiscal balance: reported monthly within eight weeks of the end of the month.
  - Net domestic financing: reported monthly within eight weeks of the end of the month.
  - Government revenue: reported monthly to the IMF within four weeks of the end of the month.
  - Domestic payments arrears: change in arrears reported in the TOFE prepared monthly by the Economic Directorate of the Ministry of Finance.

*Source: Excerpt from the March 28, 2008 memorandum and Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU) in the IMF document _cr08146_*

### 14.      The data on the stock, accumulation (including changes in Treasury balances

### _cr08146 - 14.      The data on the stock, accumulation (including changes in Treasury balances

### Reporting requirements for arrears and external loans
- Domestic payments arrears:
  - The data on the stock, accumulation (including changes in Treasury balances outstanding), and repayment of domestic payments arrears will be reported monthly within eight weeks of the end of the month.
- Government external loans and guarantees:
  - The details on any government external loan will be reported monthly within six weeks of the end of the month.
  - This rule also applies to guarantees granted by the government.

### E. Arrears on External Government Debt — Definition and reporting
- Definition:
  - The government will not accumulate any arrears on external debt (continuous performance criterion).
  - External government debt refers to central government debt to external creditors included in the database of the Directorate of Public Debt under the Ministry of Finance.
  - Excluded from the criterion are any arrears where debt is under dispute or renegotiation.
  - Excluded from the criterion are all arrears covered under domestic payments arrears (Section II.D).
  - The data source will be the Directorate of Public Debt.
- Reporting deadlines:
  - Data on the stock, accumulation, and repayment of external payments arrears will be reported monthly within six weeks of the end of the month.

### F. Central government contracting or guaranteeing of nonconcessional external debt
- Definition:
  - The government undertakes not to contract or issue a financial guarantee for any external debt with an initial term of one year or more that has a grant element of less than 35 percent (continuous performance criterion).
  - Nonconcessional debt is by definition all debt with a grant element of less than 35 percent.
  - The concessionality of loans with a maturity of at least 15 years will be calculated using a discount rate based on the average of the OECD’s published commercial interest reference rates (CIRR); for loans with a maturity of less than 15 years, the average CIRR over six months is used.
  - This performance criterion applies not only to debt as defined in point 9 of the Guidelines on Performance Criteria with Respect to Foreign Debt adopted by the Executive Board of the IMF on August 24, 2000, but also to any obligation contracted or guaranteed for which no value has been received.
  - This performance criterion does not apply to reschedulings in the form of new debt, or to Treasury bills or bonds in CFA francs issued on the WAEMU regional financial market.
- Reporting deadlines:
  - The details on any government external loan will be reported monthly within six weeks of the end of the month. This rule will also apply to guarantees granted by the government.

### G. Social spending — Definition, targets, and reporting
- Definition:
  - Domestically financed social spending is calculated, for each category of the current account (wages, goods and services, transfers and subsidies, other) as:
    - (1) expenditure executed by the Minister of Health (under “health”);
    - (2) expenditure executed by the Minister of Education and National Research and, the National Institute for Professional Education , and the Minster of Advanced Education and Research (under education);
    - (3) expenditure executed by the (4) the Minister of Environment and Forestry and the Minister of Agriculture ( “other social spending”, and limited to subsidies and transfers).
  - Domestically financed social spending is classified according to the above categories (health, education, other social spending) based on a classification of each projects presented in the 2008 budget into health, education, other social spending.
- Targets:
  - Total domestically financed social spending, for the periods from end-December 2007 to end-March 2008 (indicative target), end-June 2008 (performance criteria), end-September 2008 (indicative target) and end-December, 2008 (performance criteria) respectively, should be equal to or higher than the amounts shown in Table 1 of the MEFP.
  - The data provided by the Economic Directorate will be considered authoritative in the context of the program.
  - The floor on domestically financed social spending is an indicative target throughout the program period.
- Reporting deadlines:
  - The data on domestically financed social spending will be reported monthly within eight weeks of the end of the month.

### III. STRUCTURAL BENCHMARKS — Key benchmarks and timelines
- a. Implement a new framework for monthly monitoring of budget execution, and report data for April-June 2008 based on a new template (Benchmark August 2008).
  - Template allows review of monthly data (commitments, authorizations, and payments by budget category, including data on priority sectors) within three weeks after the end of each month, and compare the outturn to program targets, and take corrective action if necessary.
  - IMF technical assistance advised detailed breakdowns (wages, goods and services, transfers and subsidies, restructuring expenditure, foreign financed current expenditure, interest on domestic and external debt, domestically financed investment, foreign financed investment spending) and additional items (debt amortization payments, grants received, loans disbursed, change in Treasury deposits at the BCEAO, change in deposits held by the Treasury, local administrations, and autonomous agencies with domestic commercial banks).
- b. Create a General Inspectorate of Finance under the responsibility of the Minister of Finance. (Performance criterion August 2008).
  - Inspection Générale des Finances should conduct selective ex-post inspections, prepare a yearly work program, report inspections and recommendations to the Minister of Finance, and disseminate an annual report.
  - After a trial phase, the unit should start full operations in 2009.
- c. Adopt a strategy and time table for clearing domestic arrears. (Performance criterion December 2008).
  - Strategy should cover all overdue claims by private suppliers verified by the 2007 KPMG audit and subsequent updates, validated by the government.
  - Strategy should provide that most of these arrears will be converted into tradable government securities, with payments starting in 2009.
  - Strategy should set out principles for dealing with other domestic arrears; it is expected that the strategy should be published and that payments (in cash and through securities) should begin in 2009.
- d. Initiate restructuring of BTCI, including by raising its capital through the issuance of government securities. (Benchmark December 2008).
  - Recapitalization includes issuance of new government securities, treatment of nonperforming assets (removal from the balance sheet and/or provisioning).
  - Most government securities would have a maturity of five years or more; short-term securities should be tradable.
  - Government could provide other assets and short-term liquidity support.
  - One option: exchange new government securities against BTCI’s holdings of nonperforming loans to state-owned (and possibly private) enterprises, including cotton and phosphate sectors, and combine recapitalization with a write-down of existing shareholders’ capital to zero, as set out by the 2007 IMF technical assistance mission.
- e. Adopt an action plan for introducing regular Treasury bill auctions in 2009. (Benchmark December 2008).
  - Plan should be developed in consultation with the IMF, the World Bank and the BCEAO and allow initiation of regular Treasury bill auctions by 2009.
- f. Phosphate sector: Initiate an audit of the phosphate sector, based on the competitive selection of an audit company, in consultation with the World Bank (Benchmark August 2008).
  - Benchmark includes preparation of terms of references agreed with the World Bank; publication of a call for expression of interest; a request for proposals from shortlisted companies; and selection of an audit firm based on received proposals.
  - Signing of the contract and the subsequent audit are not covered under the benchmark; work envisaged to begin in the second half of 2008.
- g. Energy: Prepare a review of the finances of the national electricity company (CEET), in consultation with the World Bank. (Benchmark December 2008).
  - Benchmark covers preparation of a draft report providing estimates of CEET’s financial assets and liabilities, including vis-à-vis the government and information to project the financial gap of CEET for 2009.
  - Information should include:
    - (i) financial assets and liabilities of CEET to the government and others;
    - (ii) revenues and expenditures;
    - (iii) import, production, transmission, distribution, and consumption quantities for different categories of suppliers and consumers;
    - (iv) tariffs and collection rates for different categories of consumers; and
    - (v) unit costs for different categories of suppliers and producers.

### IV. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FOR PROGRAM MONITORING — Reporting obligations

- A. Real Sector — the government will report:
  - a. the monthly disaggregated consumer price indices, within four weeks of the end of each month;
  - b. the provisional GDP estimates by sector and expenditure in both real and nominal terms, within four months of the end of the year, and a revised estimate within ten months of the end of the year;
  - c. bi-annual data on the cotton sector (in June and December of each year) showing seed cotton production, cotton fiber production, cultivated area, producer prices, average cotton fiber price, SOTOCO’s profit or loss for the current campaign and the estimates for the next one;
  - d. monthly data on the phosphate sector to be provided in August for January –June and in February for January-December of the previous year showing total tonnage extracted and total sales in CFAF and USD;
  - e. monthly data on the activity of the Port of Lomé (tonnage and value in CFAF) to be provided in August for January –June and in February for January-December of the previous year;
  - f. monthly data on the activity of the air transportation sector (tonnage, value in CFAF and number of passengers) to be provided in August for January –June and in February for January-December of the previous year;
  - g. monthly data on the cement and clinker sector to be provided in August for January –June and in February for January-December of the previous year showing the total production and exports in tonnage and CFA francs;
  - h. monthly data on the energy sector to be provided in August for January –June and in February for January-December of the previous year showing the production of electricity, imports of electricity, sale prices (low and medium tension) by KWh for the CEB and the CEET, average production cost by KWh, invoiced energy by the CEET in CFAF and KWh, number of subscribers by category (industrial and non-industrial).

- B. Government Finance — the government will report:
  - a. tax and nontax revenue collected by the General Directorate of Taxes: (1) assessments and collections (émissions et recouvrements) of tax revenues; (2) assessments and collections of nontax revenues; (3) a breakdown of collections of taxes and levies in previous years (recouvrements sur exercices antérieurs des impôts et taxes); and (4) a detailed table of payments and offsetting transactions (apurements et compensations); these data will be reported on a monthly basis within four weeks of the end of the month;
  - b. the statement of direct and indirect taxes assessed and collected by the Customs Administration; these data will be reported on a monthly basis within four weeks of the end of the reference month;
  - c. monthly data on execution of the general budget/statement of commitments (engagements) and payment authorizations (ordonnancements): current expenditure on goods and services (dépenses de matériels) of ministries and units; these data will be reported on a monthly basis within four weeks of the end of the month;
  - d. monthly data on the statement of personnel commitments (engagements) and payment authorizations (ordonnancements); these data will be reported on a monthly basis within four weeks of the end of the month;
  - e. monthly data on payment orders (ordres de paiements) on a transaction by transaction basis, with or without an express payment order sent to the directorate of finance (télégramme lettre) issued by the Treasury, broken down by category of expenditure, within four weeks of the end of the reference month;
  - f. monthly data on the general balance of the Treasury accounts (balance générale des comptes du Trésor); these data will be reported on a monthly basis within eight weeks of the end of the month;
  - g. detailed monthly data on the deposits of the Treasury with the BCEAO and with commercial banks (form P-10) and on the deposits of the public sector with commercial banks (form D-11); these data will be reported on a monthly basis within four weeks of the end of the month;
  - h. a detailed monthly template (tableau de bord de suivi de l’execution budgetaire) on the monitoring of budget execution, including a summary on major line items, with information on spending allocations, commitments, authorizations, and payments; these data will be reported on a monthly basis within two weeks of the end of the month;
  - i. detailed monthly data on revenue and expenditure, and on domestic and external financing, including payments of domestic and external arrears (TOFE); these data will be reported monthly within eight weeks of the end of the month;
  - j. monthly statement of Treasury payments, cumulative summary statements of monthly payments, and monthly statements of Treasury outstanding balances (restes à payer) (settlement section –section réglement); these data will be reported on a monthly basis within four weeks of the end of the reference month;
  - k. detailed monthly statement of the deposit accounts of Treasury correspondents (dépôts des correspondants au Trésor);
  - l. detailed monthly data on a transactions by transactions on the spending financed through the use of suspense account (comptes des consignations), with a breakdown into credit and debits (consigations/deconsignation) for each of the following accounts of the Balance Generale du Tresor: 466 120 (produits a verser a des tiers), 466 133 (consignations judiciaires); 466 134 (saisies et cessions volontaires), 466 135 (cautions aux elections), 466 291 (Provisions/commande a executer), 474 11 (Credits des Ambassades), and 474 31 (Credit des Prefectures); these data will be reported monthly within eight weeks of the end of the month.

- C. Public Investment Program — the government will report:
  - a) monthly data on the implementation of the Public Investment Program (PIP), including a breakdown of the sources of domestic and external financing (by donor and distinguishing grants and loans); these data will be reported on a monthly basis within eight weeks of the end of the quarter.

- D. Public Debt — the government will report:
  - a. monthly data on disbursements from external sources for budgetary support and projects; these data will be reported on a monthly basis within eight weeks of the end of the quarter;
  - b. monthly data on external debt service (amounts due and payments made, by creditor and by currency); these data will be reported within four weeks of the end of the reference month;
  - c. monthly data on the stock of public debt and domestic and external payments arrears; these data will be reported within four weeks of the end of the reference month.
  - d. monthly data on the public debt service payable during the duration of the program.

- E. Money and Banking — the authorities will report:
  - Monthly, within eight weeks of the end of each month:
    - a. comprehensive survey of monetary institutions, central bank survey, survey of depositary corporations, and net government position vis-à-vis the banking system. The survey of depositary corporations should include:
      - (i) a line showing the monthly stock of Togolese government bonds and treasury bills held on the balance sheet of commercial banks;
      - (ii) a line showing claims on the government resulting from the assumption of nonperforming loans held on the balance sheet of commercial banks;
      - (iii) a breakdown of net claims on the public sector into net claims on central government, deposits held for externally financed projects, net claims on CNSS and net claims on autonomous agencies;
    - b. average lending and borrowing rates of the banking sector.
  - Within four weeks of the end of each month:
    - a. a table on the change in the required and constituted reserves of the BTCI, UTB and BIA held with the BCEAO, on the basis of daily data;
    - b. the monthly balance sheet (report form DEC 2000) of the BTCI, UTB, and BIA;
    - c. the yearly additional provisioning required by the WAMU banking commission (report form DEC 2060) for the BTCI, UTB, and BIA. Any changes in the report should be communicated within 4 weeks;
    - d. monthly change in deposits of the BTCI and UTB, by customer type (private and public).
  - Within four weeks of the end of each month:
    - a table on the monthly change in deposits, credits, non performing loans and the level of effective provisioning and the provisioning requested by the Banking Commission for the overall banking sector by type of bank (i.e. private and public banks).

- F. Balance of Payments — the government will report:
  - a. partial and preliminary annual balance of payments data, within six months of the end of the year in question, a revised preliminary annual balance of payments data within ten months of the end of the year in question, and a final annual balance of payments data within 15 months of the end of the year in question;
  - b. any revision to the balance of payments data (including services, private transfers, official transfers, capital transactions) as soon as they are revised.
  - Monthly, within eight weeks of the end of each month, monthly data on:
    - a. private transfers, including assessments of rapid funds transfer activities.
    - b. exports and imports of goods, prepared by the directorate general of customs;
    - c. exports and imports of goods, prepared by BCEAO if data are different from those provided by the directorate general of customs.

*Source: _cr08146 - 14.      The data on the stock, accumulation (including changes in Treasury balances*

### 34.      The government will report to Fund staff:

### 34.      The government will report to Fund staff:

### Reporting obligations — scope and timing
- The government will report to Fund staff:
  - a. any study or official report on the economy of Togo, including state-owned enterprises, within two weeks of its publication;
  - b. any decision, order, law, decree, ordinance, or circular with economic or financial implications, as soon as it is published or, at the very latest, once it takes effect.

### Contextual placement in the document
- This reporting provision appears as item 34 in the IMF informational annex for Togo, within a broader Request for Three-Year Arrangement Under the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility—Informational Annex prepared by the African Department (March 28, 2008).
- The annex includes related institutional and technical-material sections such as Appendix I—Relations with the Fund, Appendix II—Relations with the World Bank, and Appendix III—Statistical Issues.

### Related institutional details (selected exact figures and dates retained from the annex)
- Membership Status: Joined August 1, 1962; Article VIII.
- Quota: 73.40 (SDR million) — 100.00 percent of quota.
- Fund holdings of currency: 73.07 (SDR million) — 99.55 percent.
- Reserve position in the Fund: 0.33 (SDR million) — 0.45 percent.
- Net cumulative allocation (SDR Department): 10.98 (SDR million) — 100.00 percent.
- Holdings (SDR Department): 0.09 (SDR million) — 0.80 percent.
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans: None.
- Financial Arrangements (selected entries):
  - PRGF: Approval Date 09/16/94; Expiration Date 06/29/98; Amount Approved 65.16 (SDR million); Amount Drawn 54.30 (SDR million).
  - PRGF: Approval Date 05/31/89; Expiration Date 05/19/93; Amount Approved 46.08 (SDR million); Amount Drawn 38.40 (SDR million).
  - Structural Adjustment Facility (SAF): Approval Date 03/16/88; Expiration Date 05/30/89; Amount Approved 26.88 (SDR million); Amount Drawn 7.68 (SDR million).
- Projected Payments to the Fund (SDR million; based on existing use of resources and present holdings of SDRs) — Forthcoming:
  - 2008 Principal 0.00; Charges/interest 0.25.
  - 2009 Principal 0.00; Charges/interest 0.33.
  - 2010 Principal 0.00; Charges/interest 0.33.
  - 2011 Principal 0.00; Charges/interest 0.33.
  - 2012 Principal 0.00; Charges/interest 0.33.
  - Total 0.25 0.33 0.33 0.33 0.33 (as shown in the tabulation).

### Exchange arrangement and safeguards (exact excerpts)
- Togo is a member of the West African Economic and Monetary Union (WAEMU) and has no separate legal tender.
- The CFA franc is pegged to the euro at a rate of CFAF 655.957 = EUR 1.
- On April 28, 2006, the rate of the CFA franc in terms of SDR was CFAF 769.68 = SDR 1.0.
- Effective January 1, 2007, the exchange arrangement of the WAEMU countries has been reclassified to the category of conventional pegged arrangement from the category of exchange arrangement with no separate legal tender.
- The most recent safeguards assessment of the BCEAO was completed on November 4, 2005.

*Source: Request for Three-Year Arrangement Under the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility—Informational Annex (Prepared by the African Department, March 28, 2008).*

### 1. Data provision is broadly adequate for surveillance, but weaknesses in the quality and

### 1. Data provision is broadly adequate for surveillance, but weaknesses in the quality and timeliness of data hamper staff’s analysis.

### Data provision — overall findings
- National accounts and balance of payments statistics are compiled based on very limited information, with only few surveys and scarce data on primary agriculture and private sector services.
- Government finance statistics are derived from a weak accounting system.
- Monetary data are reported by the BCEAO with a two-month lag.

### Participation in statistical frameworks
- The country has participated in the General Data Dissemination System (GDDS) since November 2001.
- Metadata on the national statistical system, including plans for improvement posted to the Fund’s Dissemination Standard Bulletin Board, were last updated in December 2004.

### National accounts and consumer price index (CPI)
- Activity in the informal and service sectors is likely underestimated due to the lack of reliable data sources.
- A full set of national accounts is currently compiled by extrapolating the results of the last comprehensive exercise in 1993.
- In late 2002, the country embarked on implementing the 1993 SNA and the first series of NA for 2000 were prepared and work on the 2001 NA was initiated.
- The program has been suspended since 2005 and the NA for 2001 have not been finalized.
- The National Statistics Office is willing to resume the implementation of the 1993 SNA and is expecting technical and financial support from AFRISTAT and the West African Economic and Monetary Union Commission.
- AFRITAC West is providing TA to help resume the preparation of the NA.
- The last AFRITAC West mission of December 2007 helped initiating an intensive training in the 1993 SNA concepts and methods, as well as training in the application of the ERETES software for the newly-recruited statisticians.

### External sector statistics
- Balance of payments statistics and international investment position data are compiled based on bank reports, a survey of enterprises, and customs data.
- Informal trade, trade in services, and remittances are underestimated.
- Statistics are compiled with a six-month delay and are revised twice a year.
- A STA technical assistance mission in balance of payments statistics is scheduled to visit Lomé in early FY 2009.

### Government accounts and public debt data
- Government finance statistics are derived from a weak accounting system.
- The monthly TOFE (Table of Central Government Financial Operations) is based on a mixture of administrative and accounting data and is sent to AFR with a two-month lag.
- Current budget nomenclature does not permit the economic and functional classification of expenditure.
- There are inconsistencies in domestic arrears records held by different units of the Ministry of Finance and the stock of domestic debt is in the process of being audited.
- The Government Finance Statistics Advisor of AFRITAC West conducted a one-week mission in October 2007 to develop an action plan to address, among other things, the above-mentioned weaknesses in the source data.
- Comprehensive external debt data and projections on a loan by loan basis are compiled regularly.
- Only budgetary central government data are reported for publication in the Government Finances Statistics Yearbook (GFSY); government finance high frequency data are not reported for publication in the IFS.

### Monetary statistics
- Monthly data for Togo, along with data for other members of the West African Monetary Union, are regularly disseminated by the Central Bank of the West African Monetary Union (BCEAO) with a lag of about two months.
- Data on lending and borrowing rates, charged by domestic banks, are not compiled.
- In August 2006, as part of the authorities’ efforts to implement the methodology in the Monetary and Financial Statistics Manual, the BCEAO reported to STA monetary data for June 2006 for all member countries (including Togo) using Standardized Report Forms (1SR-central bank, 2SR-other depository corporations, and 5SR-monetary aggregates).
- In response to STA’s comments, the BCEAO recently provided a revised 1SR and indicated that 2SR was being revised.

### Key statistics from "Togo: Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (As of March 12, 2008)"
- Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation February 2008; Date received March 2008; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Not published.
- International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: Date of latest observation June 2007; Date received September 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Reserve/Base Money: Date of latest observation October 2007; Date received February 2008; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Broad Money: Date of latest observation October 2007; Date received February 2008; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Central Bank Balance Sheet: Date of latest observation October 2007; Date received February 2008; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: Date of latest observation October 2007; Date received February 2008; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting SA; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Interest Rates: Date of latest observation January 2008; Date received February 2008; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Consumer Price Index: Date of latest observation October 2007; Date received December 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting SA; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing – General Government: Date of latest observation June 2007; Date received October 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing– Central Government: Date of latest observation June 2007; Date received October 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt: Date of latest observation June 2007; Date received October 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication Not published.
- External Current Account Balance: Date of latest observation 2006; Date received March 2007; Frequency of Data A; Frequency of Reporting OM; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Exports and Imports of Goods and Services: Date of latest observation Dec 2006; Date received March 2007; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting OM; Frequency of publication Not published.
- GDP/GNP: Date of latest observation 2006; Date received March 2007; Frequency of Data A; Frequency of Reporting OM; Frequency of publication Not published.
- Gross External Debt: Date of latest observation June 2007; Date received October 2007; Frequency of Data A; Frequency of Reporting OM; Frequency of publication Not published.

### Statement by the IMF Staff Representative (April 21, 2008)
- The new information summarized does not change the thrust of the staff appraisal.
- Food and oil prices have risen rapidly in Togo over the past few months, pushing annual consumer price inflation to 4 percent in February 2008, from near zero in October 2007, driven mainly by a 17 percent increase in food prices over the past five months.
- The Togolese authorities are concerned about the economic and social impact of these pressures.
- Authorities have initiated a social dialogue on the price shocks and cleared old wage arrears to assist (mostly urban) civil servants.
- Authorities intend to help the rural population by supporting subsistence agriculture.
- An upcoming IMF staff mission will discuss the economic implications of the recent price shocks and possible policy responses.

*IMF staff report content (April 21, 2008).*

### 3.      The Togolese government has completed all prior actions and signed the minutes of

### 3.      The Togolese government has completed all prior actions and signed the minutes of

### Arrears clearance and donor reengagement
- Agreed arrears clearance operation with the World Bank of about $153 million, financed in full by an exceptional IDA allocation, planned for end-May 2008.
- Operation will also include $17.6 million as budget support out of the regular IDA allocation.
- Signed a protocol with the AfDB on an arrears clearance operation financed under its new Fragile States Facility, with a 1 percent contribution by Togo (about $0.2 million) for which the authorities are seeking a grant from donors.

### IMF PRGF approval and program financing
- IMF Executive Board approved a three-year arrangement under the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) for Togo equivalent to SDR 66.06 million (about US$$108.4 million) to support the government’s economic program for 2008–10.
- An initial disbursement of SDR 13.26 million (about US$21.8 million) will become available immediately.
- PRGF loan terms stated: annual interest rate of 0.5 percent, repayable over 10 years with a 5½-year grace period on principal payments.

### Program objectives and policy priorities
- Central objectives:
  - Bring Togo’s excessive public debt to a sustainable level through gradual fiscal adjustment and debt relief.
  - Preserve macroeconomic stability while reviving economic growth and reducing poverty.
  - Increase spending on infrastructure, health, and education to promote growth and improve living conditions.
- Short-term structural priorities:
  - Consolidate fiscal governance reforms and strengthen the financial sector.
  - Reform state-owned enterprises in cotton and phosphate sectors.
  - Address energy supply problems and invest in transport infrastructure.
  - Improve the business environment.
- Emphasis on coordinated reengagement with donors and creditors to secure significant increases in concessional financing and stepped-up technical assistance.

### Recent economic developments and macroeconomic performance
- Real GDP growth:
  - Averaged 2.5 percent over 2005-07.
  - 4.1 percent in 2006.
  - Moderated to about 2 percent in 2007.
- Current account deficit estimated at 6½ percent of GDP (2007); elsewhere characterized around 6.0-6.5 percent of GDP.
- Inflation (CPI measure):
  - Nearly 7 percent in 2005.
  - 2.2 percent in 2006.
  - 1 percent in 2007.
- Factors affecting performance: severe region-wide energy crisis, localized flooding, frequent power outages, higher remittances offsetting a widening trade gap.
- SMP performance: all quantitative targets met at end-December 2006, end-March 2007 and end-June 2006; nearly all structural benchmarks completed.

### Projections and medium-term macroeconomic framework (2008-10)
- Growth projections:
  - 3 percent in 2008.
  - 4 percent in 2009 and 2010 (annual growth rate of 4 percent over the medium term cited elsewhere).
  - Real GDP growth projected to reach an average of 4 percent over the medium term.
- Inflation expectation: contained between 3.5 and 4.1 percent.
- Revenues and fiscal stance:
  - Revenues are projected at 17¼ percent of GDP for 2008.
  - Authorities aim to bring revenue collection to 17¾ percent of GDP over the program period.
  - Target primary domestic fiscal surplus: about 1 percent of GDP over the three-year period.
- Policy stance: keep domestic spending within the domestic resource envelope; identify contingency spending cuts if revenue or financing fall short.

### Key structural reform agendas
- Fiscal governance:
  - Enhance revenue administration.
  - Better monitor budget execution and strengthen expenditure management.
  - Improve public debt and treasury management; tighten internal controls; advance budget preparation, monitoring and accounting.
- Financial sector:
  - Strengthen monitoring of banks.
  - Restructure Banque Togolaise pour le Commerce International (BTCI) and Union Togolaise de Banque (UTB): turn BTCI over to private management and start UTB privatization process.
  - Improve treasury cash management; introduce T-bill auctions to create more tradable financial instruments.
  - Monitor money and credit development in consultation with BCEAO; consider reserve requirement changes if needed.
  - Prepare a financial sector strategy based on a future FSAP; strengthen supervision of microfinance institutions.
- Public enterprises, infrastructure, and business environment:
  - Improve financial controls, pricing and productivity in the cotton sector; consider partial ownership of the cotton company by cotton farmers.
  - Prepare a comprehensive financial and strategic audit of the phosphate sector (to be financed by a World Bank grant); review options for attracting a strategic investor.
  - Rehabilitate generation capacity in the energy sector.
  - Review options for investment and reforms in roads, the port, and telecommunications.
  - Improve business registration, secure property rights, and prepare a new investment code.
  - Avoid new arrears to suppliers to improve business environment.

### Poverty reduction strategy
- Interim Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (I-PRSP) designed through a broad participatory process.
- Three strategic pillars:
  - Improve political and economic governance.
  - Strengthen economic recovery and sustainable development via structural reforms focused on regional integration and multilateralist policies.
  - Enhance social sectors, human resources and employment through programs in education and training, health services, nutrition, access to safe water and sanitation, gender equity, employment, social protection and grassroots community development.
- Poverty and human development indicators:
  - About 60 percent of the population living below the poverty line.
  - In rural areas, three-quarters of households are poor.
  - In urban areas, two-thirds of households are poor.
- Cost of implementing the I-PRSP over the next three years: CFAF 514 billion, to be financed by domestic and external resources.

### Risks, external shocks, and implementation capacity
- External risks: high and rising world oil and food prices, adverse competitiveness, FDI-driven imports.
- Domestic constraints: excessive public debt; financial soundness of public enterprises; deteriorated infrastructure in transport and energy; constrained institutional capacity; quality of education and health services; business environment weaknesses.
- Authorities resisted using fiscal measures such as tax exemptions and price controls to contain social impacts from high food and commodity prices and seek regional responses within WAEMU.

### Conclusion and calls for support
- Program rationale: PRGF arrangement to preserve macroeconomic stability, revive growth, reduce poverty, and help Togo reach HIPC decision and completion points and benefit from MDRI.
- External financing: concessional donor financing and technical assistance are critical to finance growth-oriented investment and social expenditures and to rebuild institutional capacity.
- Authorities have consented to the publication of the staff report and the I-PRSP.

*IMF document: Press Release No. 08/90 and accompanying staff and authorities' statements (April 21, 2008).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08146.pdf_
