## _cr08177

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr08177](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08177.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08177.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08177.pdf.json)

---

### Executive Summary — Recent Developments and Program Performance
- Program status:
  - The program remains on track: all quantitative performance criteria for end-June 2006 were met.
  - A 27-month Stand-By Arrangement approved in May 2006 for SDR 65 million (65 percent of quota); authorities treating arrangement as precautionary. Outstanding Fund credit to Paraguay is zero.
  - SBA commitment fee for SDR 107,500 was paid with a three month delay on August 28, 2006.
- Macroeconomic outturns and expectations:
  - Real GDP growth: 5 percent in Q1 2006; for 2006 as a whole expected to grow at or slightly faster than the 3½ percent program objective.
  - Inflation: rose to 17 percent in Q1 2006 and annualized inflation dropped to virtually zero in the second quarter; 7 percent objective for end-2006 considered within reach.
  - Budget: budget surplus almost 1 percent of GDP higher than programmed in the first half of 2006; expectation to achieve the zero balance objective for the year.
  - Net international reserves: reached a new historic peak in August, well above the end-year objective (US$1.5 billion in August).
  - Exchange rate: the guaraní appreciated by over 10 percent vis-à-vis the U.S. dollar in the first eight months of 2006.
- Financial sector and reserves:
  - Central Bank accumulated about US$166 million in reserves in the first half of 2006 (an increase of about 13 percent).
  - LRM rates increased by 400 basis points and stock of LRMs increased by almost 30 percent.
  - Currency issue allowed to grow at an annual rate of over 15 percent through June 2006 (compared with 10 percent in the program).
  - Banking system: capital adequacy ratios fluctuate around 20 percent; nonperforming loans represent 5.8 percent of the portfolio; ROA and ROE equal to 3.4 and 33.2 percent respectively.
  - National Development Bank (BNF) CAR increased to over 8½ percent at end-June 2006 (compared with 5 percent in the structural benchmark).

### Policy Discussions and Staff Appraisal
- Fiscal policy and 2007 stance:
  - Authorities intend to continue restraining current spending and step up implementation of investment outlays financed with external resources.
  - Authorities submitted to Congress a budget with a small deficit for 2007; 2007 budget proposal included a deficit of ⅔ percent of GDP.
  - Authorities restated commitment to preserve fiscal discipline and contain expenditure to the absorptive capacity of the economy.
  - Staff urged prioritizing high-yielding capital projects and saving part of the revenue over-performance.
- Monetary policy:
  - Monetary policy geared to achieving a 7 percent inflation target in 2006; authorities concurred that an inflation objective of 4 percent would be desirable and achievable in 2007 but preferred to wait until next review to define the 2007 monetary program.
  - Mission recommended continued flexible exchange rate regime and limited FX intervention to smooth fluctuations; mission encouraged considering further interest rate increases if inflationary pressures reemerge.
- Staff recommendation:
  - Given authorities’ strong commitment and satisfactory performance, staff supports completion of the program review.

### I. Program Performance and Implementation Summary
- Growth and inflation:
  - Despite a third consecutive drought and higher international oil prices, real GDP grew 5 percent in Q1 2006; Q2 growth continued but moderated.
  - 12-month inflation rate dropped from 11½ percent in March 2006 to 8 percent in August 2006; annualized inflation fell from 17 percent in Q1 to virtually zero in the five months through August.
- Revenue and expenditure:
  - Tax revenues increased by 20 percent in the year through July, reflecting tax administration improvements and tax reform (personal income tax introduction and VAT base broadening).
  - Wage bill ceiling observed with freeze on new civil service positions; investment program execution below program projections.
  - Fiscal outturns exceeded program margins largely due to buoyant tax revenues and fiscal discipline.
- Financing and domestic debt market:
  - Ministry of Finance re-opened the domestic bond market issuing US$20 million 3-year bonds mostly in foreign currency.
  - Composition of securitized domestic public debt (as of May 2006): IRM 460; Bonds from 2003 Debt Exchange 76; Other 114; Bonds from May 2006 issue 20.
- External sector:
  - Despite a higher-than-programmed current account deficit in H1 2006, a surge in private capital inflows generated an overall balance of payments surplus and record international reserves.
  - Current account deficit projected to remain at about 2 percent of GDP in 2006, expected to be offset by private capital inflows (mostly FDI).

### II.A. Macroeconomic Framework
- 2006 and 2007 framework:
  - 2006 program envisages real GDP growth of 3½ percent and inflation of 7 percent; authorities and staff agreed no need to modify the 2006 framework.
  - 2007 projections remain unchanged: real GDP growth of 4 percent and inflation of 4 percent.
- Risks:
  - Upside risks to real GDP growth from strong H1 outturn and dynamism in sectors such as meat production, forestry and mobile telephony.
  - Upside risk to meeting the inflation target given strong inflationary pressures in Q1 2006.

### II.B. Fiscal Policy — Key Points and Statistics
- Fiscal performance and pressures:
  - Fiscal discipline facilitated large margins in observing targets; first-half 2006 surplus almost 1 percent of GDP higher than programmed.
  - Recent supplementary budget requests reveal re-emerging expenditure pressures; authorities agreed to exercise continued prudence and resist further increases in current expenditure.
  - Authorities proposed using revenue over-performance to raise capital expenditure above programmed levels while preserving an overall balance objective of zero.
- Public enterprises:
  - Public enterprises over-performed driven by lower capital spending and higher operating surpluses; PETROPAR arrears were US$11 million at end-July 2006.
  - PETROPAR working on strategy for gradual elimination of arrears; diesel subsidies policy adjusted (domestic diesel prices increased by G 250 per liter, a 6½ percent price increase, in early June).
  - Under draft legislation, temporary subsidy to public transportation capped at 0.2 percent of GDP; maximum diesel subsidy would be G 400 per liter under proposed mechanism.
- Central Government key fiscal statistics (in percent of GDP):
  - Total Revenues: 2005 Rev. 18.2; 2006 Budget 17.9; 2006 Prog. 18.6; 2006 Rev. 19.4; 2007 Proposal 18.9
  - Tax: 2005 Rev. 11.9; 2006 Budget 11.3; 2006 Prog. 12.1; 2006 Rev. 11.9; 2007 Proposal 12.1
  - Non-tax: 2005 Rev. 6.4; 2006 Budget 6.4; 2006 Prog. 6.4; 2006 Rev. 7.5; 2007 Proposal 6.8
  - Total Expenditures: 2005 Rev. 17.5; 2006 Budget 17.9; 2006 Prog. 18.6; 2006 Rev. 20.1; 2007 Proposal 18.9
  - Current: 2005 Rev. 13.5; 2006 Budget 13.7; 2006 Prog. 13.9; 2006 Rev. 14.6; 2007 Proposal 14.0
    - Wages: 2005 Rev. 7.2; 2006 Budget 7.4; 2006 Prog. 7.6; 2006 Rev. 7.8; 2007 Proposal 7.6
    - Non-wages: 2005 Rev. 6.3; 2006 Budget 6.2; 2006 Prog. 6.3; 2006 Rev. 6.8; 2007 Proposal 6.4
  - Capital: 2005 Rev. 4.0; 2006 Budget 4.3; 2006 Prog. 4.7; 2006 Rev. 5.6; 2007 Proposal 4.9
  - Discrepancy: 2005 Rev. -0.1; 2006 Budget 0.0; 2006 Prog. -0.1; 2006 Rev. 0.0; 2007 Proposal 0.0
  - Overall Balance: 2005 Rev. 0.6; 2006 Budget 0.0; 2006 Prog. 0.0; 2006 Rev. -0.7; 2007 Proposal 0.0
- Quantitative program targets for 2006 (selected exact values):
  - Overall balance of the central administration (floor, in billions of guaranies): End-June 2006 Target: 250; End-June 2006 Actual: 807; End-Sep.2006 Target: 3250; End-Dec. 2006 Target: 0
  - Wage bill of the central administration (ceiling, in billions of guaranies): End-June 2006 Target: 1,795; End-June 2006 Actual: 1,740; End-Sep.2006 Target: 2,695; End-Dec. 2006 Target: 3,880
  - Overall balance of the public sector (floor, in billions of guaranies): End-June 2006 Target: 350; End-June 2006 Actual: 1,153; End-Sep.2006 Target: 440; End-Dec. 2006 Target: 0
  - Net international reserves (floor, in millions of U.S. dollars): End-June 2006 Target: 1,297; End-June 2006 Actual: 1,463; End-Sep.2006 Target: 1,307; End-Dec. 2006 Target: 1,317
  - Net domestic assets (ceiling, in billions of guaranies): End-June 2006 Target: -5,711; End-June 2006 Actual: -6,635; End-Sep.2006 Target: -5,751; End-Dec. 2006 Target: -5,098

### Monetary Policy and Key Monetary Statistics
- Policy focus and concerns:
  - Monetary policy geared to achieving a 7 percent inflation target in 2006; authorities concerned whether recent foreign currency inflows are transitory or permanent.
  - Authorities view recent guaraní appreciation as a healthy correction but worry further appreciation could harm competitiveness and growth.
  - Mission recommended limited FX intervention and further interest rate increases if inflationary pressures reemerge.
- Key monetary statistics (Central Bank accounts, percent of previous period currency):
  - Currency: 2005 Prog. 17.6; 2006 Rev. 8.5; 2006 Proj. 10.0; 2007 Proj. 8.0
  - Net international reserves: 2005 Prog. 32.6; 2006 Rev. 4.3; 2006 Proj. 15.6; 2007 Proj. 8.0
  - Net domestic assets: 2005 Prog. -15.0; 2006 Rev. 4.2; 2006 Proj. -5.6; 2007 Proj. 0.0
  - Credit to public sector (net): 2005 Prog. 1.8; 2006 Rev. 6.5; 2006 Proj. 1.0; 2007 Proj. -6.0
  - Credit to banks (net): 2005 Prog. -26.1; 2006 Rev. -18.1; 2006 Proj. -6.4; 2007 Proj. 2.3
  - Reserve requirements: 2005 Prog. -5.5; 2006 Rev. -6.1; 2006 Proj. -5.9; 2007 Proj. -3.5
  - Free reserves: 2005 Prog. 13.2; 2006 Rev. 3.5; 2006 Proj. -1.7; 2007 Proj. 2.2
  - BCP bills (LRM): 2005 Prog. -33.9; 2006 Rev. -15.6; 2006 Proj. 0.9; 2007 Proj. 3.7
  - Other items (net): 2005 Prog. 9.3; 2006 Rev. 15.8; 2006 Proj. -0.3; 2007 Proj. 3.7

### External Sector, Debt, and Arrears
- External balances and reserves:
  - Current Account (percent of GDP): 2005 Prog. -2.7; 2006 Rev. -2.2; 2006 Proj. -2.5; 2007 Proj. -2.0
  - Exports: 2005 Prog. 42.8; 2006 Rev. 39.4; 2006 Proj. 40.2; 2007 Proj. 40.2
  - Imports: 2005 Prog. -50.8; 2006 Rev. -46.6; 2006 Proj. -48.4; 2007 Proj. -47.0
  - Capital Account: 2005 Prog. 1.7; 2006 Rev. 2.7; 2006 Proj. 2.0; 2007 Proj. 2.7
  - Overall Balance: 2005 Prog. 2.1; 2006 Rev. 0.6; 2006 Proj. 0.8; 2007 Proj. 0.7
- Reserves (selected memoranda and levels):
  - NIR (millions of U.S. dollars): 2003: 983; 2004: 1,168; 2005: 1,297; program projections include 1,317, 1,370, 1,350, 1,411
  - Months of imports of GNFS covered by gross reserves (mem.): 3.4; 3.4; 3.3; 3.4; 3.4; 3.6; 3.4; 3.5; 3.3
- External public debt and vulnerability indicators:
  - External public debt (percent of GDP): 2003: 49.7; 2004: 38.6; 2005: 34.4; 2006 (original): 30.3; 2006 (revised): 31.3; 2007 (prog./rev./proj.): 31.3 / 30.6 / 29.4 (as reported across tables)
  - Debt service in percent of exports of GNFS (selected years): 2003: 11.6; 2004: 7.5; 2005: 8.0
- External creditor relations and arrears:
  - Authorities submitted proposal to Belgium for debt-for-nature swap to clear interest of Ex-Herstal debt in dispute (US$7½ million).
  - Cases involving French and Swiss import verification companies under review (US$75 million).
  - Authorities considering elevating a claim related to a Swiss court ruling (US$85 million); no decision reached.
  - PETROPAR expected to clear overdue obligations with suppliers by September 2007 as diesel subsidy elimination timetable pursued.
- Program commitment on arrears:
  - Non-accumulation of external debt arrears is embedded in the program monitoring framework and schedule of IMF reviews/purchases which total 65.0 percent of Quota; 65.0 Millions of SDRs.
  - Schedule of reviews and purchases (percent of quota / Millions of SDRs) includes: September 29, 2006: 6.0 / 6.0; December 15, 2006: 6.0 / 6.0; March 15, 2007: 6.0 / 6.0; June 15, 2007: 6.0 / 6.0; September 15, 2007: 6.0 / 6.0; December 15, 2007: 2.5 / 2.5; March 15, 2008: 2.5 / 2.5; June 15, 2008: 2.5 / 2.5; August 28, 2008: 2.5 / 2.5.

### Structural Reforms and Conditionality Progress
- Key reform areas and status:
  - Tax Procedures Code: draft prepared; structural performance criterion for end-December 2006.
  - BNF (National Development Bank): audited balance sheet end-June 2006 shows CAR of 8½ percent (target 5 percent); preliminary data indicate CAR of 10 percent target for December (structural performance criterion end-March 2007) may have been achieved in July 2006.
  - Legal and regulatory banking framework: regulatory modifications well-advanced; legislative amendments to Banking Law intended to be sent to Congress by September (structural benchmark end-September 2006) though slippages possible.
  - Central Bank balance sheet: authorities intend to comply with benchmark on designing a strategy to strengthen the Central Bank balance sheet before original December 2006 date.
  - Investment climate master plan (structural benchmark end-September 2006) being prepared with IDB and USAID support.
  - Restructuring public enterprises: design and implementation of result-oriented management contracts for ANDE, COPACO, ESSAP, INC and PETROPAR (structural benchmark end-December 2006); Supervising Council to review quarterly and publish reviews and recommendations.
  - Cash transfers: targeted program to 7,000 families in extreme poverty (structural benchmark end-December 2006); by end-July program covers nearly 6,700 families; centralized electronic database being introduced.

### Program Safeguards, Monitoring, and Risks
- Safeguards:
  - Central Bank subject to a full safeguards assessment for the new arrangement; FIN mission visited Asunción in March and assessment almost concluded. Remaining weaknesses in financial and data reporting identified.
- Monitoring:
  - No changes to the program, performance criteria, or benchmarks; conditionality for 2007 to be established at next review.
  - Regular meetings of the program monitoring group recommended to detect implementation problems and serve as an early warning system.
- Risks and outlook:
  - Baseline outlook positive: projection that real GDP growth projected to rise to 5 percent by 2010 and public debt-to-GDP ratio expected to decline to below 30 percent by the end of the decade, conditional on policy implementation.
  - Key risks: sudden reversal of recent capital inflows, re-emergence of expenditure pressures, and delays in economic reforms owing to delays in approval of key legislation by Congress.
  - Authorities’ mitigation: pursue sound economic management and build up international reserves.

### Statistical Issues and Data Quality
- Real sector:
  - New national accounts series (benchmark/base year 1994) released in 2005; concerns: 1994 reference year becoming obsolete, excessive use of fixed coefficients, inventories estimated residually, informal activities not monitored.
  - CPI and PPI: CPI geographic coverage limited to Asunción; CPI base weight period 1992; PPI base weight December 1995.
  - Household budget survey 2005–06 planned to update CPI basket and weights.
- Fiscal sector:
  - GFS broadly consistent with GFSM 1986; consolidated central government and general government statistics not prepared.
  - Deviations in treatment of some social insurance schemes and inclusion of Postal Service Directorate in central administration.
  - Internal debt data available on request; discrepancy exists in fiscal data reported by monetary and fiscal authorities.
- Money, banking, and external sector:
  - Money and banking statistics broadly reliable; coverage gap: credit cooperatives not covered (account for around 25 percent of deposits and loans).
  - Quarterly and annual balance of payments and IIP data available from 2001 onwards; classification follows BPM5.
  - ROSC recommendations include sample surveys for unrecorded BOP items, review of estimation techniques for unrecorded trade, and quarterly reconciliation of external public debt flows and stocks with MOF.
- Data availability (selected dates as of August 2006): Exchange Rates latest observation 8/11/06; Broad Money latest observation 6/30/06; Consumer Price Index latest observation Jul. 2006; Revenue/Expenditure latest observation Jun. 2006; GDP/GNP latest observation 2005.

### IMF SBA Timetable, Reviews, and Outcomes
- SBA and review schedule and access:
  - Approval of arrangement: May 31, 2006 — Purchase: 25.0 percent of Quota; Amount of Purchase: 25.0 Millions of SDRs.
  - Schedule of reviews and purchases through August 28, 2008 totals 65.0 percent of Quota; 65.0 Millions of SDRs.
- Missions and board meetings:
  - First SBA Review: Mission Jul 19–Aug 1, 2006; Board Meeting September 29, 2006.
  - Second SBA Review and 2006 Article IV Consultation: Mission Nov 29–Dec 12, 2006; Board Meeting January 29, 2007.
  - Third SBA Review: Mission Feb 14–28, 2007; Board Meeting March 30, 2007.
- IMF press release (September 29, 2006):
  - IMF Executive Board completed the first review under the SBA; completion makes SDR 31 million (about US$46 million) immediately available.
  - Authorities continue to treat the arrangement as precautionary; review undertaken on a lapse of time basis.
  - Safeguards Assessment not concluded by review date due to Central Bank delay; staff judged delay did not warrant holding up completion of the review.

*Source: IMF staff report (content unit: _cr08177).*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### Executive Summary

### Recent Developments and Program Performance
- The program remains on track: all quantitative performance criteria for end-June 2006 were met.
- The June 2006 structural benchmark on the design of an action plan to strengthen budget preparation, develop expenditure controls and streamline the Treasury account system was observed.
- Macroeconomic outturns:
  - Real GDP growth: 5 percent in Q1 2006; for 2006 as a whole expected to grow at or slightly faster than the 3½ percent program objective.
  - Inflation: after rising to 17 percent in Q1 2006, annualized inflation dropped to virtually zero in the second quarter; 7 percent objective for end-2006 is considered within reach.
  - Budget: the budget surplus was almost 1 percent of GDP higher than programmed in the first half of 2006; expectation is to achieve the zero balance objective for the year.
  - Net international reserves: reached a new historic peak in August, well above the end-year objective (US$1.5 billion in August).
  - Exchange rate: the guaraní appreciated by over 10 percent vis-à-vis the U.S. dollar in the first eight months of 2006.
- Program implementation details:
  - A 27-month Stand-By Arrangement approved in May 2006 for SDR 65 million (65 percent of quota); authorities treating arrangement as precautionary. Outstanding Fund credit to Paraguay is zero.
  - All performance criteria and the structural benchmark for end-June 2006 were observed, although the SBA commitment fee for SDR 107,500 was paid with a three month delay on August 28, 2006.
  - Fiscal outturns exceeded program margins largely due to buoyant tax revenues and fiscal discipline.
  - Central Bank re-opened the domestic bond market and issued Treasury bonds for US$20 million with a 3-year maturity mostly denominated in foreign currency.
  - Central Bank accumulated about US$166 million in reserves in the first half of 2006 (an increase of about 13 percent); LRM rates increased by 400 basis points and stock of LRMs increased by almost 30 percent; currency issue allowed to grow at an annual rate of over 15 percent through June 2006 (compared with 10 percent in the program).
  - Banking system: capital adequacy ratios fluctuate around 20 percent (well above minimum regulatory threshold of 10 percent); nonperforming loans represent 5.8 percent of the portfolio; ROA and ROE equal to 3.4 and 33.2 percent respectively. National Development Bank (BNF) CAR increased to over 8½ percent at end-June 2006 (compared with 5 percent in the structural benchmark).
  - External position: despite a higher-than-programmed current account deficit in H1 2006, a surge in private capital inflows generated an overall balance of payments surplus and record international reserves.

### Policy Discussions and Staff Appraisal
- Broad agreement on continuing strong macroeconomic policies:
  - Authorities intend to continue restraining current spending and step up implementation of investment outlays financed with external resources, as envisaged in the financial plan for 2006.
  - Staff and authorities are concerned about rapid currency growth and potential inflationary impact, while recognizing higher-than-programmed money demand and a stronger-than-anticipated external position.
  - Authorities need to be prepared to tighten monetary policy further if evidence of renewed inflationary pressures emerges.
- 2007 fiscal stance:
  - Authorities submitted to Congress a budget with a small deficit for 2007, driven by conservative tax revenue projections and increased social and capital expenditures.
  - The 2007 budget proposal included a deficit of ⅔ percent of GDP, reflecting budgeted spending to address social needs (especially in the health sector) and higher capital expenditure to support growth.
  - Authorities restated commitment to preserve fiscal discipline and contain expenditure to the absorptive capacity of the economy.
- Structural reforms:
  - Momentum in implementing the structural reform agenda; internal mechanisms established to ensure implementation and progress made across all areas of the structural reform agenda.
  - Presidential decree 7712 (June) delegates implementation of specific structural measures and provides control and monitoring mechanisms.
  - Structural benchmark for June 2006 on budget action plan design was met; the plan benefited from FAD technical assistance and authorities intend to start adopting some elements later in the year.
  - Diesel subsidies: draft legislation sent to Congress in May 2006 to introduce a temporary subsidy to public transportation (capped at 0.2 percent of GDP); authorities increased domestic diesel prices by G 250 per liter (a 6½ percent price increase) in early June. The maximum diesel subsidy would be G 400 per liter under the proposed mechanism.

- Political and social context:
  - Political and social environments remain tense; opposition to reform efforts persists.
  - President Duarte-Frutos consolidated leadership within the Colorado party; Congress remains unenthusiastic and can hamper reform advancement.
  - President announced plans for constitutional reform including possibility of presidential re-election.
  - Poverty indicators appear to be improving slowly; the conditional cash transfer program (US$15 to US$30 a month to families in extreme poverty) began operations.

- Staff recommendation:
  - Given authorities’ strong commitment and satisfactory performance, staff supports completion of the program review.

### I. Program Performance and Developments (Key Points)
- Program design and objectives:
  - Program aims: entrench macroeconomic stability, remove impediments to growth, alleviate poverty; reduce debt-to-GDP ratio to 30 percent by end of the decade; reduce inflation to industrial country levels.
- Implementation summary:
  - Despite a third consecutive drought and higher international oil prices, real GDP grew 5 percent in Q1 2006; Q2 growth continued but moderated.
  - Inflation: 12-month rate dropped from 11½ percent in March 2006 to 8 percent in August 2006; annualized inflation fell from 17 percent in Q1 to virtually zero in the five months through August.
  - Revenues: tax revenues increased by 20 percent in the year through July, reflecting tax administration improvements and tax reform (personal income tax introduction and VAT base broadening).
  - Expenditures: wage bill ceiling observed with freeze on new civil service positions; other current outlays contained; investment program execution below program projections.
  - Financing: larger-than-programmed surplus reduced financing requirement; Ministry of Finance re-opened domestic bond market issuing US$20 million 3-year bonds mostly in foreign currency.
  - Monetary response: combination of greater exchange rate flexibility and reserve accumulation; guaraní appreciated by over 10 percent in first eight months of 2006; accumulation of US$166 million in reserves in H1 2006 required active sterilization and higher LRM rates.
  - Banking system: well-capitalized, profitable, relatively liquid; BNF recapitalization underway.
  - External sector: resilience to May–June emerging market turbulence; overall balance of payments surplus in H1 2006 and record reserves.

### II. Review Issues — A. Macroeconomic Framework
- Current framework for 2006 and 2007 remains valid:
  - 2006 program envisages real GDP growth of 3½ percent and inflation of 7 percent; authorities and staff agreed no need to modify the 2006 framework.
  - Upside risks to real GDP growth exist given strong H1 outturn and dynamism in sectors like meat production, forestry and mobile telephony.
  - Upside risk to meeting the inflation target exists given strong inflationary pressures in Q1 2006.
  - 2007 projections remain unchanged: real GDP growth of 4 percent and inflation of 4 percent.

### II. Review Issues — B. Fiscal Policy
- Fiscal performance and policy stance:
  - Fiscal discipline facilitated large margins in observing targets.
  - First-half 2006 surplus almost 1 percent of GDP higher than programmed due mainly to buoyant tax revenues.
  - Tax reform and improved tax administration underpinned a 20 percent increase in tax revenues through July.
  - Authorities emphasize containing expenditure to the absorptive capacity of the economy and preserving fiscal discipline.

*Source: IMF staff summary contained in the Executive Summary (pages provided).*

### 12.      The fiscal program remains appropriate. Despite the expansionary 2006 budget

### _cr08177 - 12.      The fiscal program remains appropriate. Despite the expansionary 2006 budget

### Fiscal program and 2006 outturn
- Authorities maintained fiscal discipline during the first half of 2006 through a financial plan and strong tax revenue performance despite an expansionary 2006 budget approved by Congress.
- Recent supplementary budget requests reveal re-emerging expenditure pressures; authorities agreed with staff recommendation to exercise continued prudence and resist further increases in current expenditure.
- Authorities proposed using revenue over-performance to raise capital expenditure above programmed levels while preserving an overall balance objective of zero; staff urged prioritizing high-yielding capital projects and saving part of the revenue over-performance.
- Authorities noted some revenue over-performance would be reduced by the appreciation of the guaraní.

### Public sector and public enterprises
- Public enterprises showed considerable over-performance driven by lower capital spending and higher operating surpluses; part of this reflects the strength of the guaraní lowering the cost of dollar-denominated inputs.
- PETROPAR: working on a strategy for gradual elimination of arrears to suppliers; PETROPAR’s arrears were US$11 million at end-July 2006; financial outlook improved due to lower diesel import prices (as Venezuela becomes main supplier) and higher domestic prices (June diesel price adjustment and possible future adjustments as government moves to remove generalized subsidy).
- Authorities reaffirmed commitment to strengthening operations and finances of public enterprises.

### Key fiscal statistics (Central Government, in percent of GDP)
- Total Revenues: 2005 Rev. 18.2, 2006 Budget 17.9, 2006 Prog. 18.6, 2006 Rev. 19.4, 2007 Proposal 18.9
- Tax: 2005 Rev. 11.9, 2006 Budget 11.3, 2006 Prog. 12.1, 2006 Rev. 11.9, 2007 Proposal 12.1
- Non-tax: 2005 Rev. 6.4, 2006 Budget 6.4, 2006 Prog. 6.4, 2006 Rev. 7.5, 2007 Proposal 6.8
- Total Expenditures: 2005 Rev. 17.5, 2006 Budget 17.9, 2006 Prog. 18.6, 2006 Rev. 20.1, 2007 Proposal 18.9
- Current: 2005 Rev. 13.5, 2006 Budget 13.7, 2006 Prog. 13.9, 2006 Rev. 14.6, 2007 Proposal 14.0
  - Wages: 2005 Rev. 7.2, 2006 Budget 7.4, 2006 Prog. 7.6, 2006 Rev. 7.8, 2007 Proposal 7.6
  - Non-wages: 2005 Rev. 6.3, 2006 Budget 6.2, 2006 Prog. 6.3, 2006 Rev. 6.8, 2007 Proposal 6.4
- Capital: 2005 Rev. 4.0, 2006 Budget 4.3, 2006 Prog. 4.7, 2006 Rev. 5.6, 2007 Proposal 4.9
- Discrepancy: 2005 Rev. -0.1, 2006 Budget 0.0, 2006 Prog. -0.1, 2006 Rev. 0.0, 2007 Proposal 0.0
- Overall Balance: 2005 Rev. 0.6, 2006 Budget 0.0, 2006 Prog. 0.0, 2006 Rev. -0.7, 2007 Proposal 0.0

### 2007 budget proposal
- 2007 budget submitted in late August 2006 shows a deficit of ⅔ percent of GDP, largely due to conservative tax projections and higher social and capital expenditures.
- Authorities view the conservative projection as realistic to address ongoing expenditure pressures and reduce future supplementary budget requests.
- Authorities reiterated commitment to fiscal discipline; staff believes fiscal balance can be achieved in 2007 but will recommend a financial plan if the Congress-approved budget is inconsistent with program objectives. Fiscal targets for 2007 to be set at next review.

### Monetary policy and inflation objectives
- Monetary policy geared to achieving a 7 percent inflation target in 2006.
- Authorities concerned whether recent foreign currency inflows are transitory or permanent; some international reserve accumulation attributed to regional financial market turbulence and possible unwinding in second half of year.
- Authorities view recent guaraní appreciation as a healthy correction but worry further appreciation could harm competitiveness and growth.
- Mission recommended continued flexible exchange rate regime and limited FX intervention to smooth fluctuations; staff noted concern about pace of currency growth and acknowledged possible strengthening in real demand for money.
- Mission encouraged considering further interest rate increases if inflationary pressures reemerge.
- For 2007 authorities concurred that an inflation objective of 4 percent would be desirable and achievable; they preferred to wait until next review to define the 2007 monetary program because of uncertainty about rise in real demand for money.

### Key monetary statistics (Central Bank accounts, in percent of previous period currency)
- Currency: 2005 Prog. 17.6, 2006 Rev. 8.5, 2006 Proj. 10.0, 2007 Proj. 8.0
- Net international reserves: 2005 Prog. 32.6, 2006 Rev. 4.3, 2006 Proj. 15.6, 2007 Proj. 8.0
- Net domestic assets: 2005 Prog. -15.0, 2006 Rev. 4.2, 2006 Proj. -5.6, 2007 Proj. 0.0
- Credit to public sector (net): 2005 Prog. 1.8, 2006 Rev. 6.5, 2006 Proj. 1.0, 2007 Proj. -6.0
- Credit to banks (net): 2005 Prog. -26.1, 2006 Rev. -18.1, 2006 Proj. -6.4, 2007 Proj. 2.3
- Reserve requirements: 2005 Prog. -5.5, 2006 Rev. -6.1, 2006 Proj. -5.9, 2007 Proj. -3.5
- Free reserves: 2005 Prog. 13.2, 2006 Rev. 3.5, 2006 Proj. -1.7, 2007 Proj. 2.2
- BCP bills (LRM): 2005 Prog. -33.9, 2006 Rev. -15.6, 2006 Proj. 0.9, 2007 Proj. 3.7
- Other items (net): 2005 Prog. 9.3, 2006 Rev. 15.8, 2006 Proj. -0.3, 2007 Proj. 3.7

### External sector and balance of payments
- Current account deficit projected to remain at about 2 percent of GDP in 2006, expected to be offset by private capital inflows (mostly FDI).
- Strong export performance expected to continue for the rest of 2006, especially for meat given Argentina’s decision to limit meat exports.
- Import growth expected to moderate for rest of 2006 provided world oil prices stabilize.
- Net public borrowing will remain limited; net international reserves expected to increase by some US$75 million (more than three times the programmed accumulation).

### Key balance of payments statistics (in percent of GDP)
- Current Account: 2005 Prog. -2.7, 2006 Rev. -2.2, 2006 Proj. -2.5, 2007 Proj. -2.0
- Exports: 2005 Prog. 42.8, 2006 Rev. 39.4, 2006 Proj. 40.2, 2007 Proj. 40.2
- Imports: 2005 Prog. -50.8, 2006 Rev. -46.6, 2006 Proj. -48.4, 2007 Proj. -47.0
- Other: 2005 Prog. 5.3, 2006 Rev. 5.1, 2006 Proj. 5.7, 2007 Proj. 4.9
- Capital Account: 2005 Prog. 1.7, 2006 Rev. 2.7, 2006 Proj. 2.0, 2007 Proj. 2.7
- Public sector (net): 2005 Prog. -0.8, 2006 Rev. 0.1, 2006 Proj. 0.0, 2007 Proj. 0.2
- Private sector (net): 2005 Prog. 2.5, 2006 Rev. 2.6, 2006 Proj. 2.0, 2007 Proj. 2.5
- Overall Balance: 2005 Prog. 2.1, 2006 Rev. 0.6, 2006 Proj. 0.8, 2007 Proj. 0.7
- Overall Financing: 2005 Prog. -2.1, 2006 Rev. -0.6, 2006 Proj. -0.8, 2007 Proj. -0.7
- Net international reserves: 2005 Prog. -2.0, 2006 Rev. -0.2, 2006 Proj. -0.8, 2007 Proj. -0.4
- Exceptional financing: 2005 Prog. -0.1, 2006 Rev. -0.3, 2006 Proj. 0.0, 2007 Proj. -0.3

### External creditor relations and debt disputes
- Authorities submitted proposal to Belgium for debt-for-nature swap to clear interest of Ex-Herstal debt in dispute (US$7½ million).
- Cases of French and Swiss import verification companies continue under review (US$75 million); contracts signed with local subsidiaries.
- Government abandoned efforts to find a lost South African supplier (US$0.03 million) with no macroeconomic implications.
- Authorities considering elevating a claim by a syndicate of European and American banks to the International Court of Justice related to a Swiss court ruling (US$85 million); no decision reached and claim disputed by authorities.
- PETROPAR expected to clear overdue obligations with suppliers by September 2007 as diesel subsidy elimination timetable pursued.

### Structural reforms and conditionality progress
- Tax Procedures Code: draft prepared; being reviewed by legal experts; preparatory work benefited from FAD/LEG technical assistance; structural performance criterion for end-December 2006.
- National Development Bank (BNF): financial situation improved; audited balance sheet end-June 2006 shows CAR of 8½ percent (target 5 percent); preliminary data indicate CAR of 10 percent target for December (structural performance criterion end-March 2007) may have been achieved in July 2006.
- Legal and Regulatory Banking Framework: regulatory modifications (not requiring legislative amendments) well-advanced (provisioning regulations, sanctions, capital requirements); legislative amendments to Banking Law intended to be sent to Congress by September (structural benchmark end-September 2006) though slippages possible.
- Central Bank financial position: authorities intend to comply with benchmark on designing a strategy to strengthen the Central Bank balance sheet before original December 2006 date; discussions to cover amount and structure of financial support and legal/accounting aspects.
- Investment climate master plan (structural benchmark end-September 2006) being prepared by Unit of Business Climate with IDB and USAID support; plan focuses on (i) simplifying procedures (one-stop shop, property registration modernization); (ii) incentives for business and exports (WTO-compatible); (iii) infrastructure and logistics; and (iv) institutional strengthening (contract enforcement, judicial security, investor protection, labor regulations).
- Restructuring public enterprises: implementation of result-oriented management contracts with ANDE, COPACO, ESSAP, INC and PETROPAR (structural benchmark end-December 2006); Supervising Council to review quarterly and publish reviews and recommendations.
- Cash transfers: targeted program to 7,000 families in extreme poverty (structural benchmark end-December 2006); by end-July program covers nearly 6,700 families; centralized electronic database being introduced to improve monitoring and evaluation.

### Program issues, safeguards and conditionality
- No changes to the program, performance criteria, or benchmarks; conditionality for 2007 to be established at next review.
- Central Bank subject to a full safeguards assessment for the new arrangement; FIN mission visited Asunción in March and assessment almost concluded. Significant progress made but remaining weaknesses in financial and data reporting (including timely publication of Central Bank financial statements and valuation of international reserves); staff encouraged addressing these weaknesses.

### Program outlook and risks
- Baseline outlook positive given authorities’ commitment to sound policies and supportive external environment.
- Baseline assumptions: continuation of measures to consolidate macroeconomic stability; lock in improvements in tax collection and administration; mobilize resources to reduce poverty; implement lasting structural reforms; improve private investment environment.
- Projection: real GDP growth projected to rise to 5 percent by 2010; macroeconomic and financial stability expected to be maintained; public debt-to-GDP ratio expected to decline to below 30 percent by the end of the decade.
- Key risks: sudden reversal of recent capital inflows (deterioration in investor sentiment), re-emergence of expenditure pressures, and delays in economic reforms owing to delays in approval of key legislation by Congress.
- Authorities’ mitigation: pursue sound economic management and build up international reserves.

*Source: IMF staff report (content unit: _cr08177).*

### 24.      The new program is off to a good start with improved macroeconomic

### 24.      The new program is off to a good start with improved macroeconomic performance and a strengthened resolve to undertake structural reform

### Macroeconomic performance and program implementation
- The macroeconomic situation had deteriorated markedly at the beginning of 2006, with world oil prices increasing further, inflationary pressures intensifying, the drought persisting, and an expansive and underfinanced budget being approved by Congress.
- Authorities have succeeded in turning the situation around, improving market confidence, addressing inflationary pressures and strengthening fiscal performance.
- All performance criteria and a structural benchmark for end-June were observed.
- Economic growth has picked up, inflation is declining, and fiscal discipline is becoming entrenched.
- Authorities built consensus within the cabinet of ministers to implement reforms included in the structural agenda; ownership of the program was evident in discussions with different ministries and public entities.

### Fiscal performance
- Fiscal performance has been better than programmed, notwithstanding strong expenditure pressures.
- The central government has been able to control spending through a financial plan, and is on track to meet the targeted fiscal balance this year, despite a budgeted deficit of 2 percent of GDP.
- Operational surpluses in the public enterprises (other than the oil company PETROPAR) have contributed to a strong overall fiscal position.
- A cash surplus in the social security system, reflecting still favorable demographics, has also supported the public finances.
- Concern: the drain on PETROPAR from continued diesel subsidies.
- Staff recommendations and outlook:
  - It will be important for the government to continue to adhere to the financial plan, and to be prepared to adopt any corrective measures that may become necessary.
  - Authorities’ commitment to fiscal discipline in 2007, including their objective of reaching broad fiscal balance, is welcome.
  - If the approved budget is inconsistent with program objectives, a financial plan may be necessary to anchor fiscal discipline.

### Monetary policy
- Monetary policy has been effective in addressing inflationary pressures in recent months.
- With a stronger than expected balance of payments position, the Central Bank has struck an appropriate balance between accumulating reserves and allowing the guaraní to appreciate.
- The mix between sterilization and monetization has been adequate to accommodate a potential increase in the real demand for money.
- Staff commends the Central Bank for the successful reduction in inflationary pressures observed in recent months, and encourages it to remain vigilant and respond promptly to a changing external environment.
- Staff welcomes the higher exchange rate flexibility, which was key in reducing inflationary pressures.

### Structural reform agenda
- Authorities need to maintain the momentum on the structural reform agenda.
- Staff welcomes the renewed commitment and impetus in implementing structural reform measures, an important improvement over the experience under the previous arrangement.
- Measures requiring considerable coordination and determination include:
  - The strategy to strengthen the financial position of the Central Bank.
  - The reform of the public enterprises.
  - The design of a tax procedures code.
- The mechanisms currently in place and the authorities’ resolve augur well for timely implementation.

### Risks and program monitoring
- Vulnerabilities and risks remain, deriving from political and social uncertainties, as well as from possible external shocks.
- Staff encourages authorities to strengthen their efforts to improve their communication policy to shield the program from political pressures in the run up to municipal elections in November.
- Regular meetings of the program monitoring group should continue to detect implementation problems and serve as an early warning system.
- Steadfast implementation of the program should strengthen Paraguay’s resilience to external shocks.

### Staff recommendation
- The staff supports completion of the first review under the SBA, noting the authorities’ strong commitment to the program and good performance.

### Composition of Securitized Domestic Public Debt (in millions of U.S. dollars as of May 2006)
- IRM: 460
- Bonds from 2003 Debt Exchange: 76
- Other: 114
- Bonds from May 2006 issue: 20

### Box 1 — Paraguay: Re-opening the Domestic Bond Market (summary)
- In December 2002 Paraguay’s market for public bonds nearly collapsed amid a financial crisis.
- The government faced debt service obligations in the amount of nearly US$70 million (1¼ percent of GDP) in 2003.
- A debt exchange was offered; in 2004 public bonds in the amount of US$132 million (96 percent of the outstanding old bonds) were exchanged for securities with maturities extending to 2008.
- Market weaknesses persisted: medium-term public bonds are illiquid, there is no secondary market for treasury debt, and institutional deficiencies include lack of a securities depository and deficient registration and listings systems.
- Sterilization papers (LRM) issued by the central bank account for about 70 percent of securitized domestic public debt.
- May 2006 bond issue:
  - Government placed public bonds in the amount of US$15 million and G 30 billion (equivalent to about US$5 million) in early May.
  - Maturities: three years.
  - Interest rates: 9 percent for dollar-denominated titles and 15 percent for guaraní-denominated titles.
  - The dollar-denominated bond was heavily oversubscribed; only about 80 percent of the guaraní–denominated bond could be placed.

- Footnote details from the exchange offer (preserved as in source):
  - The exchange offer was made in December 2003 and the bulk of it completed in July 2004. Past due interest were paid in cash.
  - Bond holders were offered a bundle of 5 bonds with maturities of about 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5 years, at interest rates of 7, 7, 8, 9, and 9½ percent respectively (paid quarterly) and allocated according to the following fixed proportions: 6.5, 15.2, 24.6, 29.0, and 24.7 percent respectively.

### Box 2 — Paraguay: Restructuring of Public Enterprises (summary)
- Public enterprises (PE) dominate electricity, water, transport, telecommunications, fuels, and cement.
- Low efficiency, quasi-fiscal activities, and underinvestment in PE add costs to other sectors and hamper productivity.
- Prior privatization attempts were politically unsuccessful; a 2002 draft privatization bill approved by Congress was nullified through another law following social unrest.
- Authorities designed a comprehensive strategy to improve efficiency, transparency and the quality and coverage of PEs’ services.

- Main elements of the authorities’ strategy:
  - Comprehensive management audits of PE and other public entities; the President instructed publication of full audit results on the website of the line ministries.
  - Line ministries must present to the economic cabinet an action plan for each PE aimed at improving managerial and financial performance; Presidential decree No 6892/December 2005 established compliance.
  - Design Result-Oriented Management Contracts starting with five PE (ANDE, PETROPAR, COPACO, INC, and ESSAP) by end-December 2006 (a structural benchmark for the SBA) and for DINAC and ANNP in early 2007. Monitoring to be undertaken jointly by an independent technical committee and the Planning Ministry, with results published.
  - Evaluate private sector participation in management of some PE on a case by case basis through modalities such as management in exchange for a “success fee,” private-public partnerships (PPP), or outsourcing specific units.

- Audit results and implications:
  - The majority of comprehensive management audits have been finalized and summary results published.
  - Audits confirm a very fragile financial and managerial position for at least three PE: PETROPAR, ESSAP and INC.
  - DINAC and ANNP show poorer profitability and managerial indicators despite not being as weak financially.
  - Results stress the need for decisive implementation of the authorities’ strategy to improve PE performance.

### Summary Financial Indicators of the Audits (2004) — extracted figures preserved as presented
- Summary chart labels: Profit/Losses; Net Worth
- Aggregate label: US$690 mill.

### Table 1. Paraguay: Quantitative Program Targets for 2006 (preserving table values exactly)
- Fiscal targets
  - 1. Overall balance of the central administration (floor, in billions of guaranies)
    - End-June 2006 Target: 250
    - End-June 2006 Actual: 807
    - End-Sep.2006 Target: 3250
    - End-Dec. 2006 Target: 0
  - 2. Wage bill of the central administration (ceiling, in billions of guaranies) 1/
    - End-June 2006 Target: 1,795
    - End-June 2006 Actual: 1,740
    - End-Sep.2006 Target: 2,695
    - End-Dec. 2006 Target: 3,880
  - 3. Overall balance of the public sector (floor, in billions of guaranies) 1/
    - End-June 2006 Target: 350
    - End-June 2006 Actual: 1,153
    - End-Sep.2006 Target: 440
    - End-Dec. 2006 Target: 0

- Monetary targets
  - 4. Net international reserves (floor, in millions of U.S. dollars) 2/
    - End-June 2006 Target: 1,297
    - End-June 2006 Actual: 1,463
    - End-Sep.2006 Target: 1,307
    - End-Dec. 2006 Target: 1,317
  - 5. Net domestic assets (ceiling, in billions of guaranies) 2/
    - End-June 2006 Target: -5,711
    - End-June 2006 Actual: -6,635
    - End-Sep.2006 Target: -5,751
    - End-Dec. 2006 Target: -5,098

- Public debt and arrears targets
  - 6. Contracting or guaranteeing of nonconcessional external debt by the NFPS (ceiling, in millions of US$) 1/
    - End-June 2006 Target: 5000
    - End-June 2006 Actual: 5000
    - End-Sep.2006 Target: 500
    - End-Dec. 2006 Target: 500

- Continuous PCs
  - 7. Contracted or guaranteed short-term external debt by the NFPS
    - End-June 2006 Target: 0
    - End-June 2006 Actual: 0
    - End-Sep.2006 Target: 0
    - End-Dec. 2006 Target: 0

*Based on IMF staff report content.*

### 8. Non-accumulation of external debt arrears 0000

### 8. Non-accumulation of external debt arrears 0000

### Program framework and commitments
- Approval of arrangement: May 31, 2006 — Purchase: 25.0 percent of Quota; Amount of Purchase: 25.0 Millions of SDRs.
- Schedule of reviews and purchases (percent of quota / Millions of SDRs):
  - September 29, 2006: 6.0 / 6.0 (First review and end-June 2006 performance criteria)
  - December 15, 2006: 6.0 / 6.0 (Second review and end-September 2006 performance criteria)
  - March 15, 2007: 6.0 / 6.0 (Third review and end-December 2006 performance criteria)
  - June 15, 2007: 6.0 / 6.0 (Fourth review and end-March 2007 performance criteria)
  - September 15, 2007: 6.0 / 6.0 (End-June 2007 performance criteria)
  - December 15, 2007: 2.5 / 2.5 (Fifth review and end-September 2007 performance criteria)
  - March 15, 2008: 2.5 / 2.5 (End-December 2007 performance criteria)
  - June 15, 2008: 2.5 / 2.5 (Sixth review and end-March 2008 performance criteria)
  - August 28, 2008: 2.5 / 2.5 (End-June 2008 performance criteria)
- Total: 65.0 percent of Quota; 65.0 Millions of SDRs.

### External debt and arrears positions (selected indicators)
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans: None.
- External public debt (in percent of GDP, selected years):
  - 2003: 49.7
  - 2004: 38.6
  - 2005: 34.4
  - 2006 (original): 30.3
  - 2006 (revised): 31.3
  - 2007 (prog./rev./proj.): 31.3 / 30.6 / 29.4 (as reported across tables)
- Debt service in percent of exports of GNFS (selected years):
  - 2003: 11.6
  - 2004: 7.5
  - 2005: 8.0
  - Program projections: 8.7, 8.6, 8.1, 7.6 (various table entries)
- Reschedulings: reported as zeros across the reschedulings line (Reschedulings 000000000).
- Exceptional Financing: Arrears deferral (+)/clearance (-) series (in Table 9 Exceptional Financing / Arrears deferral):
  - 2003: 91
  - 2004: -88
  - 2005: -6
  - 2006 (Jan–Jun): -150
  - 2006 (Jan–Dec): -2600
  - Subsequent entries: 0, -27 (as shown in the Exceptional Financing line of Table 9).

### External sector balances and reserves (key figures)
- Current account (in millions of U.S. dollars, Table 9):
  - 2003: 125
  - 2004: 55
  - 2005: -204
  - 2006 (original): 172
  - 2006 (revised): -178
  - Projections: -180, -225, -170, -185 (across columns)
- Current account (percent of GDP, Table 9 / Table 10):
  - 2003: 2.3 percent of GDP
  - 2004: 0.8 percent of GDP
  - 2005: -2.7 percent of GDP
  - Program projections: -2.2, -2.5, -1.9, -2.0 (various years)
- Net International Reserves (NIR) and gross reserves (Table 6 / Table 9 memorandum):
  - NIR (in millions of U.S. dollars, memorandum): 2003: 983; 2004: 1,168; 2005: 1,297
  - Gross reserves (millions of U.S. dollars): 2003: 983; 2004: 1,168; 2005: 1,297; program projections include 1,317, 1,370, 1,350, 1,411
  - NIR (increase -) line in Balance of Payments: -302, -181, -152, 0, -166, -20, -73, -33, -41 (as reported across columns)
- Months of imports of GNFS covered by gross reserves: 3.4, 3.4, 3.3, 3.4, 3.4, 3.6, 3.4, 3.5, 3.3 (Table 9 memorandum).

### Program performance and fiscal context related to arrears avoidance
- Commitment under the program: Non-accumulation of external debt arrears is embedded in the program monitoring framework and scheduling of reviews and purchases.
- Financing from external sources (Consolidated public sector, Table 5):
  - External financing net (percent of GDP): 2003: 1.3; 2004: -0.1; 2005: -1.0; 2006: -0.5; 2006 (rev): -0.6; 2007 prog./rev./proj.: -0.1 / -0.4 / -0.2 / 0.0
  - Disbursements and amortizations (levels in Table 5 and Table 4) shown to reflect net external financing needs and scheduled debt service.

### Indicators of external vulnerability relevant to arrears risk
- External public debt (percent of GDP, Table 10): 2001: 38.3; 2002: 50.3; 2003: 49.7; 2004: 38.6; 2005: 34.4.
- Debt service (in percent of exports GNFS, Table 10): 2001: 10.8; 2002: 9.1; 2003: 11.6; 2004: 7.5; 2005: 8.0.
- Short-term external debt indicators (Table 10):
  - Over short-term external debt (percent): 2001: 1.2; 2002: 1.0; 2003: 1.6; 2004: 1.8; 2005: 1.9.
  - Over foreign currency deposits in domestic banks: 0.6, 0.7, 1.0, 1.1, 1.1 (2001–2005).

### Operational implications and monitoring points (drawn from the data)
- The program projects stable-to-declining external public debt ratios over the projection horizon (multiple table entries show declines from 49.7 to mid-30s and low-30s).
- Reserve coverage remains around 3.3–3.6 months of imports of GNFS in projections, supporting external payment capacity.
- Scheduled IMF purchases and reviews (totaling 65.0 percent of quota / 65.0 Millions of SDRs) establish a monitoring framework tied to performance criteria at specific dates through August 28, 2008, creating checkpoints to help ensure non-accumulation of arrears.
- Exceptional financing and arrears-deferral/clearance entries in the Balance of Payments table show episodic arrears adjustments (e.g., 91, -88, -6, -150, -2600, 0, -27), indicating past arrears transactions that program monitoring aims to avoid repeating.

*Source: _cr08177 - 8. Non-accumulation of external debt arrears 0000.*

### 1. As of August 11, 2006, the active loan portfolio amounts to US$497.4 million, with

### _cr08177 - 1. As of August 11, 2006, the active loan portfolio amounts to US$497.4 million, with

### IDB Portfolio, Technical Cooperation, and Strategy
- Active loan portfolio: US$497.4 million (as of August 11, 2006).
- Undisbursed loan balance: US$242.6 million.
- Active Technical Cooperation operations: 55 operations for US$21.6 million.
- Undisbursed Technical Cooperation balance: US$11.5 million.
- Strategy: IDB’s Country Strategy with Paraguay is presently being reviewed. Main focus for 2006–2008 includes support to economic growth, investment in human capital and poverty alleviation.

### IDB Lending Pipeline (2006-A)
- Strengthening of the Judiciary System II, US$6.3 million (approved).
- Strengthening of Civil Service, US$4.2 million.
- Electric Power Transmission and Distribution Program, US$80 million.
- Integration Corridor and Road Rehabilitation Program, Phase I, US$134.1 million.
- Institutional Strengthening of the National Institute of Cooperatives (INCOOP), US$4.4 million.
- Modernization of the Agriculture Public Sector Management, US$31.5 million.

### Statistical Issues — Real Sector
- A new national accounts series (benchmark/base year 1994) released in 2005; broadly consistent with 1993 SNA.
- Improvements: more complete industry coverage, an input-output matrix, expanded data sources.
- Major concerns:
  - 1994 reference year is becoming obsolete.
  - Excessive use of fixed coefficients for value added and household consumption.
  - Changes in inventories obtained residually.
  - Informal activities not monitored.
  - Supply and use tables compiled only until 1997.
- Periodicity: annual GDP meets GDDS recommendations but not timeliness (data disseminated with 11-months lag).
- CPI and PPI: reported regularly and timely; CPI geographic coverage limited to Asunción; CPI base weight period 1992; PPI base weight December 1995.
- Household budget survey 2005–06 will be used to update CPI basket and weights and to develop the index in line with 1993 SNA classification and valuation systems.
- PPI basket: 150 items; not fully representative—electricity, water, gas, and services not covered.
- Employment/unemployment statistics: improved since 1998 regular household survey; frequency annual and publication lag close to one year; wage indices updated twice a year.
- ROSC data mission finding: resources insufficient for real sector statistics, constraining further development and full adoption of 1993 SNA.

### Statistical Issues — Fiscal Sector
- Paraguay’s GFS broadly consistent with GFSM 1986; no plan yet to migrate to GFSM 2001.
- Monthly data available for central administration (budgetary central government); local government operations not included in GFS.
- Asset position of social security system available on a daily basis.
- Deviations from GFS recommendations:
  - Consolidated central government and general government statistics not prepared.
  - Central administration statistics include Postal Service Directorate (a nonfinancial public corporation).
  - Nonfinancial public sector definition includes financial public corporations (four employer social insurance schemes).
- Treatment inconsistency: these social insurance schemes treated as financial corporations in monetary and financial accounts.
- External debt: medium- and long-term external debt data reliable and available monthly.
- Internal debt data: available on request, need better integration with external debt database.
- Deficiencies: registration of short-term supplier and commercial credit of public sector.
- Discrepancy exists in fiscal data reported by monetary and fiscal authorities; measures being taken to improve transparency.
- Reporting to GFS Yearbook: annual data covering only budgetary central government through 2004 reported; since 1994 no outstanding debt data and no breakdowns for expenditure by function provided for GFS Yearbook.
- Monthly and quarterly data not reported for publication in IFS; resumption of reporting recommended.

### Statistical Issues — Money and Banking Sectors
- Money and banking statistics broadly reliable following 1995 new accounting plan for commercial banks and finance companies.
- A unified compilation and reporting system established, harmonizing data for CBP use and STA reporting.
- Revision of classification criteria reduced discrepancies in interbank positions.
- Coverage gap: credit cooperatives not covered; they account for around 25 percent of deposits and loans of the banking sector.
- Plan: technical assistant mission in fiscal year 2007 to include credit cooperatives in the other depository corporation’s survey.
- The superintendency of banks publishes a detailed and informative report on financial system soundness.

### Statistical Issues — External Sector
- Quarterly and annual balance of payments and IIP data available from 2001 onwards on the central bank website and reported to STA.
- Annual IIP data compiled and disseminated for 1995–2004.
- Classification follows Balance of Payments Manual, 5th edition.
- Improvements: quality of capital flow data (notably foreign direct investment) and recording of external debt transactions in BOP and IIP.
- Central bank produces a highly informative bulletin with balance of payments statistics.
- Special studies improved estimation methods for remittances and unregistered trade, but serious deficiencies remain.
- Private capital outflows: deficiencies in registration due to open capital account.
- Major ROSC data mission recommendations:
  - Design and conduct sample surveys to capture currently excluded or poorly covered BOP items (e.g., some services, direct and portfolio investment abroad, real estate).
  - Review and update statistical techniques to estimate unrecorded trade.
  - Prepare periodical reports to inform CBP management of survey data quality (response, coverage, response errors).
  - Initiate quarterly reconciliation of flows and stocks of medium- and long-term external public debt with the MOF.

### Table of Common Indicators — Selected data availability (as of August 14, 2006)
- Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation 8/11/06; Date received 8/14/06; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of publication D.
- International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: Date of latest observation 8/11/06; Date received 8/14/06; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of publication D.
- Reserve/Base Money: Date of latest observation 8/11/06; Date received 8/14/06; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of publication D.
- Broad Money: Date of latest observation 6/30/06; Date received 7/24/06; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Central Bank Balance Sheet: Date of latest observation 8/11/06; Date received 8/14/06; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of publication D.
- Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: Date of latest observation 6/30/06; Date received 7/24/06; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Interest Rates: Date of latest observation 6/30/06; Date received 8/08/06; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Consumer Price Index: Date of latest observation Jul. 2006; Date received 8/02/05; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing – General Government: Date of latest observation Jun. 2006; Date received 7/24/06; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing – Central Government: Date of latest observation Jun. 2006; Date received 7/24/06; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt: Date of latest observation Jun. 2006; Date received 7/24/06; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Q.
- External Current Account Balance: Date of latest observation June. 2006 prov.; Date received 3/3/06; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Q.
- Exports and Imports of Goods and Services: Date of latest observation June 2006 prov.; Date received 3/3/06; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- GDP/GNP: Date of latest observation 2005; Date received 3/15/06; Frequency of Data A; Frequency of Reporting A; Frequency of publication A.
- Gross External Debt: Date of latest observation Dec. 2005 prov.; Date received 3/03/06; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Q.

### Work Program and IMF SBA Timetable
- First SBA Review: Mission Jul 19–Aug 1, 2006; Board Meeting September 29, 2006.
- Second SBA Review and 2006 Article IV Consultation: Mission Nov 29–Dec 12, 2006; Board Meeting January 29, 2007.
- Third SBA Review: Mission Feb 14–28, 2007; Board Meeting March 30, 2007.
- Memorandum item: Approval of SBA May 31, 2006.

### Attachment: Letter from Paraguayan Authorities (Asunción, September 12, 2006)
- The letter updates the May 8, 2006 letter and reiterates commitment to the multi-year program supported by a Stand-By Arrangement (SBA) approved May 31, 2006.
- Program status and implementation:
  - All quantitative PCs and the structural benchmark for end-June 2006 were observed.
  - Economic growth buoyant; inflationary pressures eased in Q2 2006.
  - External position strengthened: international reserves at record highs; guaraní appreciated.
  - Fiscal policy implemented according to program; diesel subsidies cut by almost one half in June via domestic diesel price increases.
  - Short-term rates on monetary instruments (LRMs) almost doubled earlier in the year to address inflationary pressures.
  - Structural reform agenda implemented as scheduled.
- Payment issue: commitment fee on the SBA could not be discharged on time due to unforeseen legal difficulties under new budgetary procedures for the Central Bank; payment was made within the legal framework.
- Authorities request completion of the first review under the SBA and reaffirm commitment to May 2006 policies and memorandum.

- PETROPAR note: While PETROPAR’s financial position strengthened due to domestic price adjustments, higher world prices will make it difficult for PETROPAR to eliminate overdue obligation to oil suppliers by end-2006 as previously anticipated. Expected PETROPAR overdue obligations to be cleared by September 2007.

### IMF Review and Press Release (September 29, 2006)
- IMF staff expected the Safeguards Assessment for Paraguay to be concluded by September 29; a delay in the Central Bank response means the assessment was not completed at review time.
- Staff view: delay does not warrant holding up completion of the review given relatively limited scope of recommendations; next review should follow up on implementation of staff recommendations.
- IMF Executive Board completed the first review of Paraguay’s performance under a 27-month, SDR 65 million (about US$97 million) Stand-By Arrangement, initially approved May 31, 2006.
- Completion of the review makes SDR 31 million (about US$46 million) immediately available.
- The authorities continue to treat the arrangement as precautionary.
- The review was undertaken on a lapse of time basis.

*Prepared by the staff of the IDB and IMF staff report material (as provided in the source content).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08177.pdf_
