## _cr08262 — Executive Summary and Selected Chapters

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr08262 — Executive Summary and Selected Chapters](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08262.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08262.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08262.pdf.json)

---

### Overall assessment and context
- Monetary union hailed as a success; economic union remains work in progress.
- Lisbon Treaty rejection in a country referendum has dampened sentiment.
- Over the past decade, inflation expectations have remained well anchored and employment growth robust despite large terms of trade shocks.
- Official forecasts expect demand to slow owing to high energy and food prices, tighter financial conditions, slowing global activity, and the euro’s real effective appreciation—to a level beyond that justified by medium-run fundamentals.

### Monetary policy: stance, risks, and guidance
- Key hinge factors for policy: evolution of wages and inflation expectations given elevated energy and food prices, and the dampening effect of the forecast slowdown.
- Market and staff assessment:
  - Markets have implemented appreciable tightening since summer 2007; market-relevant interest rates (except ECB policy rates and government bond yields) are already noticeably above “neutral,” which staff estimates in a broad range centered around 4–4½ percent.
  - Markets priced in a 25bp hike in July, with a small probability of another 25bp move by end-year.
- ECB action and view:
  - ECB raised its policy rate by 25 basis points to 4.25 percent on July 3.
  - ECB states increase was “taken to prevent broadly based second-round effects and to counteract the increasing upside risks to price stability over the medium term.”
  - ECB sees upside risks to price stability and points to a possible need to raise rates.
- IMF staff view and recommendation:
  - Staff: no compelling case for further tightening; see value in keeping rates on hold unless forward-looking indicators cease to point to growing slack or 2009 wage settlements hint at accelerating labor costs.
  - Conditional staff inflation projection: headline inflation to move below 2 percent some time in 2009 (staff forecasts later revised to 3.4 percent for 2008 and 2.4 percent for 2009 in the July 18 supplement).

### Liquidity management and market normalization
- ECB liquidity framework has acted as a crucial stabilizer: broad eligible collateral and counterparties, flexible reserve requirements, fine-tuning operations, increased three-month refinancing share, and introduction of six-month operations.
- Additional measures: currency swap lines with the Federal Reserve for U.S. dollar liquidity; possibility for banks to post originated asset-backed securities as collateral.
- Assessment and further steps:
  - Interbank term spreads remain elevated; little more left for liquidity management per se to do to foster normalization, but framework under active review.
  - Recommendation: accompany systemic liquidity management with a more rules-based approach to managing stress at individual banks; longer-term development of secured interbank markets and integration of clearing and settlement systems.

### Cyclical developments, near-term prospects, and projections
- Recent cycle peaked in 2006; after a strong 2008Q1, real GDP growth is decelerating.
- Key near-term drags:
  - High and rising oil and food prices that will strain consumption despite unemployment rates near 25-year lows.
  - Investment moderating as interest rates and risk premia rise and external demand weakens.
  - Financial turmoil has directly affected parts of the financial system; US linkages remain important.
- Staff central scenario and projections:
  - Real GDP growth moderating from an annual pace of about 1¾ percent in 2008H1 to just over ½ percent in 2008H2, before reaccelerating to a 1½ percent pace and above starting in 2009Q2.
  - Staff projects annual average growth of 1.7 percent in 2008 and 1.2 percent in 2009.
  - Output gap projected to widen to about 1 percent of potential GDP in 2009.
  - July 18 supplement: Q1 2008 growth revised to 2.9 percent (quarterly annualized), with headline inflation reaching 4.0 percent in June.
- Risks:
  - Downside: further commodity price increases; accelerated deleveraging and asset price deflation; abrupt unwinding of global imbalances and sharp appreciation of the euro.
  - Upside: buoyant employment boosting consumption; potential declines in commodity prices.
  - Staff considered risks broadly balanced; EC and ECB staff saw them as tilted to the downside relative to their slightly higher projections.

### Inflation, wages, and labor costs
- Headline inflation elevated by energy and food; staff forecast headline inflation to recede appreciably in 2009 assuming commodity prices stabilize.
- Labor cost dynamics:
  - Compensation per employee has grown around 2½ percent per annum since 1999.
  - Negotiated wages: 2.8 percent (2008Q1), up from 2.2 percent (2007).
  - Staff and Commission project unit labor cost growth settling below 2 percent in 2009.
- Inflation expectations and measures:
  - ECB surveys: analysts’ long-term point estimate holding at 1.9 percent.
  - Measures of underlying inflation have increased, but inflation excluding energy and all food prices remained 1.8 percent in June (supplement).
- Upside risks: second-round wage indexation effects; staff views indexation risk as relatively contained given scheme details.
- Monetary-policy implication: keep rates on hold absent signs of no-widening slack or accelerating wage settlements.

### External competitiveness and exchange rate assessment
- Real effective exchange rate:
  - Euro currently some 15 percent higher than its 1993–2006 average; appreciated about 10 percent since end-2006.
  - Staff conclusion: the real effective exchange rate of the euro is at least 10 percent stronger than warranted by medium-run fundamentals.
  - CGER assessment range: overvaluation in a range of 5–20 percent.
  - Staff estimates (Box 2): appreciation might shave off at least ¼ percent from real GDP growth over the near term.
- Projected medium-run current account dynamics:
  - Projected medium-run current account deficit stands at about ¾ percent of GDP; real exchange rate models put equilibrium at a surplus of 0.2 percent of GDP.

### Financial sector conditions, risks, and policy responses
- System entered turmoil from a position of strength; turmoil materially impacted bank profitability but capital buffers largely intact.
- Funding and interbank markets:
  - Funding costs increased considerably, particularly for lower-rated banks; interbank markets dried up at longer maturities; spreads rose as banks hoarded liquidity and brought off-balance-sheet exposures onto balance sheet.
  - 12-month interbank rates up 1 percentage point, reaching 5½ percent (financial conditions paragraph).
  - Risk premia widened by 50–200bp in various segments.
- Credit standards and lending:
  - ECB bank lending survey reports appreciable tightening of credit standards.
  - Household credit has slowed significantly; lending to households behaving in line with normalizing housing markets.
  - Bank lending to non-financial corporations continued to expand but expected to slow.
- Empirical stress–credit–growth links (Box 3):
  - A two standard deviation drop in distance to default for large euro-area banks (decline observed July 2007–May 2008) associated with a 3 percentage point reduction in real credit growth.
  - A 1 percentage point decrease in bank loan supply corresponds to a 0.1 percentage point decline in real GDP in the euro area.
  - Developments in large euro-area banks’ stocks imply a -0.3 percentage point impact on output; combining with April 2008 GFSR loss estimates implies a -0.2 percentage point impact on output.
  - VAR: maximum impact of higher interest rates on loan volumes comes with a lag of 6 quarters; first 3 quarters show very little impact on corporate credit.

### Housing markets and balance-sheet vulnerabilities
- House price rises in many countries similar to the United States; residential investment well above long-term average and now slowing.
- Housing market risks judged mainly medium-run; slumps in “hot spots” could trigger broader declines via financial linkages.
- Corporate balance sheets stronger than at onset of last credit cycle downturn; businesses more leveraged than US peers and relatively dependent on bank lending.
- Household leverage rising but appreciably lower than in the United States or the United Kingdom; personal savings around 14 percent of household income.
- Pockets of household vulnerability in countries with rapid house price appreciation and common variable-rate mortgages.

### Fiscal policy, the SGP, and medium-term fiscal pressures
- Fiscal outcomes:
  - Structural fiscal accounts of the euro area reached a close-to-balanced position in 2007.
  - All excessive deficit procedures vis-à-vis euro-area countries have been closed.
  - About half of countries reached or exceeded their medium-term objectives (MTO); general government debt ratio continued to fall.
- Near-term fiscal risks and guidance:
  - Some countries risk exceeding the 3 percent Maastricht deficit limit; Commission advised France to strengthen consolidation and cited narrow safety margins for Italy and Portugal.
  - Appropriate stance under reformed SGP:
    - Allow automatic stabilizers to operate freely except where breaches of the Maastricht reference value could occur.
    - Countries that have reached MTOs could consider additional discretionary loosening.
    - Other countries need to continue to adjust at a pace of at least ½ percent of GDP per annum, unless in “bad times” under the revised SGP.
  - Staff recommendation: tax policy should not be used to limit pass-through of rising energy prices; protective measures should be short-term, targeted, and non-distortionary.
- Demographic pressures:
  - Population aging-related outlays projected to add some 3¾–5 percent of GDP to public expenditure by 2050.

### Financial stability governance, EU-wide accountability, and supervisory reform
- Core issue: national fiduciary duties limit incentives to adopt common EU-wide financial stability frameworks needed for full integration.
- Recent steps:
  - Adoption of important common principles emphasizing collective crisis cost minimization and burden sharing; Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) commits member states to minimize “potential harmful economic impacts at the lowest overall collective costs” and share direct budgetary net costs on equitable and balanced criteria.
  - MoU to be tested with a crisis simulation exercise in 2009.
- Concerns and recommendations:
  - Non-binding MoU may not resolve tensions in severe crises; risk of complex committee structures rather than a true multilateral approach.
  - Staff mission recommendations for rapid progress:
    - Establish a multilateral platform for real-time sharing of systemically relevant supervisory information among supervisors and central banks, including the ECB.
    - Improve Deposit Guarantee Schemes: raise standards for speed of payouts, limit co-insurance, and improve depositor information.
    - Determine common criteria for early intervention and reorganization measures for cross-border groups; progress toward a convergent bankruptcy framework.
    - Give “teeth” to the planned European dimension in national supervisory mandates, clearly ruling out “beggar-thy-neighbor” policies and supporting appropriate accountability.
  - Strengthen Level-3 Committees (CEBS, CESR, CEIOPS) by more resources, scope for qualified majority voting, and stronger national application of Level 3 guidelines.

### Structural reform priorities and trade policy
- Structural reform priorities:
  - Accelerate services market reform and financial integration to address large intra-area divergences and to boost productivity.
  - National Reform Programs under Lisbon Agenda need greater focus on making single market a reality, particularly opening national services markets.
  - Commission proposes a peer review mechanism to take account of fiscally costly but adjustment-friendly structural reforms when implementing the SGP.
- Trade policy and food prices:
  - EU seeks to conclude Doha Round substance before end-2008; Commission cautiously hopeful.
  - Recommended policy response to high food prices: lower agricultural trade barriers and subsidies, discourage export taxes, mobilize targeted development aid, and ensure market incentives for supply response.
  - EU measures: suspending the “set-aside” for 2008–09 to increase cultivated farmland by about 10 percent.

### Key quantitative indicators and table highlights (selected exact figures)
- ECB policy rate: 4.25 percent (after 25 basis point increase on July 3).
- Short-term interbank rates: 12-month interbank rates up 1 percentage point, reaching 5½ percent.
- Staff annual GDP projections: 2008: 1.7 percent; 2009: 1.2 percent.
- Staff headline inflation projections (July 18 supplement): 2008: 3.4 percent; 2009: 2.4 percent.
- Staff central growth projections within report:
  - Real GDP growth moderating from about 1¾ percent in 2008H1 to just over ½ percent in 2008H2; reaccelerating to 1½ percent pace starting 2009Q2.
- Euro real effective exchange rate:
  - Some 15 percent higher than 1993–2006 average; about 10 percent appreciation since end-2006.
  - Staff conclusion: at least 10 percent stronger than warranted by medium-run fundamentals.
- Medium-run current account: projected deficit about ¾ percent of GDP; equilibrium models place surplus at 0.2 percent of GDP.
- Household personal savings: around 14 percent of household income.
- Demographic fiscal cost to 2050: population aging-related outlays add some 3¾–5 percent of GDP.
- Fiscal adjustment pace recommended for countries not at MTO: at least ½ percent of GDP per annum.
- VAR and stress estimates (Box 3):
  - Two standard deviation drop in distance to default → 3 percentage point reduction in real credit growth.
  - 1 percentage point decrease in bank loan supply → 0.1 percentage point decline in real GDP.
  - Large euro-area banks’ stock developments imply -0.3 percentage point output impact; combining with GFSR losses implies -0.2 percentage point output impact.

*Italic: IMF staff summary based solely on provided content.*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### _cr08262 - Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### Overall assessment and context
- Discussions took place around the 10th anniversary of EMU; monetary union hailed as a success while economic union remains work in progress.  
- The rejection of the Lisbon Treaty in a country referendum has dampened sentiment.  
- Over the past decade, inflation expectations have remained well anchored and employment growth robust despite large terms of trade shocks.  
- All official forecasts expect demand to slow owing to high energy and food prices, tighter financial conditions, slowing global activity, and the euro’s real effective appreciation—to a level beyond that justified by medium-run fundamentals.

### Monetary policy: policy stance and considerations
- The appropriate monetary response hinges on how wages and inflation expectations evolve given elevated energy and food prices, and on whether the forecast economic slowdown exerts a sufficiently dampening effect.  
- While persistence of high headline inflation entails risks of second-round effects, markets have already implemented appreciable tightening since summer 2007 and, in a still strained financial environment, further tightening carries risks.  
- Staff view: the case for a policy shift does not appear compelling; staff sees value in keeping rates on hold.  
- ECB view: based also on a forecast of somewhat higher growth, the ECB sees upside risks to price stability and points to a possible need to raise rates.

### Liquidity management and market normalization
- The ECB’s liquidity management framework has acted as a crucial stabilizer. Refinements remain under review.  
- The area’s financial system remains sound, although the outlook is described as “highly uncertain.”  
- Addressing the turmoil requires active implementation of recommendations by the Financial Stability Forum and others.

### Fiscal policy
- General satisfaction with the operation of the SGP and with the further fiscal adjustment recorded in 2007, though many countries continue to fall well short of their medium-run commitments.  
- Broadly shared view: a policy approach cast within the SGP serves countries best. Policies to protect vulnerable groups should avoid distorting adjustment to higher energy prices.

### Financial stability, integration, and EU-wide accountability
- For longer-term financial stability in the EU, the main question is how to instill greater joint accountability and responsibility for EU-wide stability, consistent with creating a single financial market.  
- Important common principles emphasizing collective crisis cost minimization and burden sharing have been adopted. The challenge is to fully align legal underpinnings of national financial stability frameworks with these principles.  
- For economic union, the main concern is addressing large intra-area divergences; national reform programs need greater emphasis on accelerating services market reform and financial integration. The European Commission proposes enhancing internal surveillance.

### Cyclical developments and near-term prospects
- The euro-area external current account is still close to balance, fiscal policy has generally been sound, and structural reforms are advancing, but prospects have deteriorated.  
- After a strong showing in 2008Q1, real GDP growth is decelerating following several adverse shocks; the current cycle peaked in 2006.  
- Key near-term drags:
  - High and rising oil and food prices that will strain consumption despite unemployment rates near 25-year lows.  
  - Investment moderating as interest rates and risk premia rise and external demand prospects weaken.  
  - Financial turmoil has directly affected parts of the area’s financial system; linkages with the United States remain important.  
- Trade with emerging market economies, where growth has remained relatively robust thus far, has been a supportive factor.

### External competitiveness and exchange rate assessment
- The real effective exchange rate of the euro is currently some 15 percent higher than its 1993–2006 average, having appreciated by about 10 percent since end-2006, carrying the euro beyond its medium-run fundamentals.  
- Staff estimates (Box 2): the appreciation might shave off at least ¼ percent from real GDP growth over the near term.  
- CGER assessment range: staff notes CGER estimates place the euro’s overvaluation in a range of 5–20 percent.  
- Projected medium-run current account deficit stands at about ¾ percent of GDP, while real exchange rate models put the equilibrium at a surplus of 0.2 percent of GDP.  
- Staff conclusion: the real effective exchange rate of the euro is at least 10 percent stronger than warranted by medium-run fundamentals.

### Spillovers with the United States (Box 1 key findings)
- Co-movement in activity and financial variables between the euro area and the United States is high and has increased over time.  
- Synchronization: all significant US downturns have either coincided with or been followed by sharp slowdowns in the euro area.  
- Spillover magnitude: on average a one percentage point decline in US real GDP growth shaves off ¼ percentage point of euro area growth within two quarters, with a maximum impact of close to ½ percentage point after one year.  
- Common shocks: the share of euro-area real GDP growth explained by common shocks increased from 37 percent in 1980–1993 to 54 percent during 1994–2007.  
- Both trade and financial transmission channels have become stronger over time, with the trade channel likely working mainly via third country effects.

### Housing markets and balance-sheet vulnerabilities
- Many euro-area countries experienced house price rises similar to those seen in the United States; residential investment has been well above its long-term average. Prices are now slowing and residential investment is forecast to weaken noticeably.  
- Housing market risks are seen mainly as medium-run rather than short-run risks; house price slumps in “hot spots” could, via financial linkages, trigger broader declines in other euro-area countries. EC and ECB representatives underscore that effects on area-wide growth would be contained given limited non-prime lending, relatively low loan-to-value ratios, and few opportunities for equity withdrawal.  
- Corporate balance sheets: stronger than at the onset of the last credit cycle downturn; scant evidence of a significant investment overhang. However, European businesses are relatively dependent on bank lending and are more leveraged than their US peers, making investment vulnerable to tightening credit. Default rates expected to rise from historically low levels, with highly-leveraged corporations and real-estate related businesses particularly vulnerable.  
- Household sector: household leverage has been rising but remains appreciably lower than in the United States or the United Kingdom; personal savings around 14 percent of household income. Pockets of vulnerability exist among households in countries with rapid house price appreciation, particularly where variable-rate mortgages are common.

### Financial sector conditions and risks
- The euro-area financial system entered the turmoil from a position of strength, but the turmoil has materially impacted bank profitability; capital buffers remain largely intact.  
- Funding costs increased considerably, particularly for lower-rated banks; balance sheet constraints tightened as several market segments closed down.  
- Interbank markets have dried up at longer maturities and spreads have risen as banks hoarded liquidity and brought off-balance sheet exposures back on balance sheet. Loan losses have started to increase; banks have retrenched from risk-taking and significantly tightened lending standards.  
- The ECB sees the outlook for financial stability as depending on: developments in asset markets (notably in the US and other housing markets) and the broader economy; banks’ responses to the more challenging operating environment; and the extent to which initiatives and measures aimed at restoring confidence and strengthening financial system resilience are implemented.

*Source: _cr08262 - Executive Summary.*

### 7.      Household credit has slowed significantly and credit to non-financial

### 7.      Household credit has slowed significantly and credit to non-financial corporations, which has shown buoyant growth thus far, is generally expected to follow.

### Household and Corporate Credit
- Household credit has slowed significantly; ECB staff viewed lending to households as behaving in line with normalizing conditions in euro-area housing markets.
- Bank lending to euro-area non-financial corporations has continued to expand, seemingly unimpaired thus far by the financial turmoil.
- Euro-area bank lending survey reports appreciable tightening of credit standards (Figure 11).
- Unlike in recent episodes, expected tightening of bank credit would probably not be offset by increased availability of bond and equity financing.
- Staff analysis indicates tightening financial conditions tend to have a significant impact on credit with a noticeable lag (Box 3).
- ECB representatives agreed corporate credit growth would likely slow.

### Financial Sector Stress, Credit Volume, and Spillovers (Box 3)
- A two standard deviation drop in distance to default for large euro area banks (the decline observed in July 2007–May 2008) can be associated with a 3 percentage point reduction in real credit growth.
- A 1 percentage point decrease in bank loan supply corresponds to a 0.1 percentage point decline in real GDP in the euro area.
- Based on these estimates, developments in large euro-area banks’ stocks since last summer imply a -0.3 percentage point impact on output.
- Combining these estimates with April 2008 GFSR data on estimated losses in large euro area banks implies a -0.2 percentage point impact on output.
- Euro-area banks account for 37 percent of the “European bank” losses in the GFSR; the rest are mostly Swiss and U.K. banks, implying effects may be larger if non-euro-area bank losses have appreciable euro-area impact.
- VAR calculations: maximum impact of higher interest rates on loan volumes comes with a lag of 6 quarters; the first 3 quarters show very little impact on corporate credit and a small “hump” in household credit.

### Spillovers to Emerging Europe
- Real and financial linkages between the euro area and emerging Europe have become much stronger in recent years.
- Econometric models suggest the accelerated growth in emerging Europe in the past five years and the increased share of the euro area have contributed 0.2–0.4 percentage points to euro area annual growth (Regional Economic Outlook: Europe, November 2007).
- Emerging Europe convergence is projected to continue, albeit at a slower pace; growth rates in recent years have been above estimates of potential for most countries and an adjustment is under way.
- Risks: emerging European economies are more vulnerable to a global slowdown due to openness, and vulnerabilities could be amplified through financial channels.
- So far, spillovers from euro-area financial and real sector developments to emerging Europe have been limited.

### Growth Projections and Risk Balance
- Central scenario: significant slowdown, but no recession or prolonged sluggish activity like 2002–05.
- Staff projections: real GDP growth moderating from an annual pace of about 1¾ percent in 2008H1 to just over ½ percent in 2008H2, before reaccelerating to a 1½ percent pace and above starting in 2009Q2.
- Output gap projected to widen to about 1 percent of potential GDP in 2009.
- EC and ECB projections foresee a broadly similar pattern but with higher growth at the trough, mainly due to more robust consumption.
- Risks around projections are large.
  - Downside risks: further increases in energy and food prices (including related protectionist pressures); accelerated deleveraging triggering broader asset price deflation and a global credit crunch; abrupt unwinding of global imbalances and sharp appreciation of the euro.
  - Upside risks: buoyant employment leading to higher-than-projected consumption; potential declines in energy and food prices if speculative forces have played some role.
- Overall, staff considered risks broadly balanced; EC and ECB staff saw them as tilted to the downside relative to their slightly higher real GDP projections.

### Inflation and Monetary Policy
- Headline inflation kept around 3½ percent mainly by high energy and food prices; staff forecast headline inflation to move below 2 percent some time in 2009 (ECB and EC representatives considered this “slightly optimistic”).
- Key considerations:
  - Energy and food prices assumed to stabilize in 2009 and inflation expectations have remained anchored.
  - ECB surveys suggest the average of analysts’ point estimates is holding at 1.9 percent for long-term inflation.
- Labor and costs:
  - Compensation per employee has been growing at around 2½ percent per annum since 1999 despite large price shocks and falling unemployment.
  - Negotiated wages increased 2.8 percent according to 2008Q1 data, up from 2.2 percent in 2007.
  - Staff projects that with below potential output growth through 2009, any further acceleration in wages will remain contained; Commission forecast similar with unit labor cost growth settling below 2 percent in 2009.
- Inflation outlook uncertainty:
  - ECB representatives see risks clearly on the upside, noting repeated upside surprises in energy and food prices and headline inflation at decade highs.
  - Upside risks include second-round wage indexation effects; staff viewed these risks as relatively contained given details of most indexation schemes.
  - Downside risks become more relevant beyond the near term and relate to greater-than-projected weakening of activity, further euro appreciation, and reversal of commodity prices.
  - All interlocutors except employers and trade unions saw upside risks prevailing.
- Monetary policy stance:
  - Amid robust money and credit growth, the ECB has kept rates on hold thus far.
  - Financial conditions have tightened since summer 2007: 12-month interbank rates are up 1 percentage point, reaching 5½ percent; risk premia have widened by 50–200bp; the real effective exchange rate has appreciated by some 5 percent.
  - Markets priced in a 25bp hike in July, with a small probability of another 25bp move by end-year.
  - Staff view:
    - No compelling case for further tightening; central projections foresee real GDP slowing to below potential and inflation declining appreciably to very close to 2.0 percent by end-2009 (or less per IMF staff).
    - Market-relevant interest rates (except ECB policy rates and government bond yields) are already noticeably above “neutral”, which staff estimates in a broad range centered around 4–4½ percent.
    - Recommendation: rates should stay on hold; tightening would be appropriate if forward-looking indicators no longer pointed to significantly growing slack, or 2009 wage settlements hinted at accelerating labor costs.
- Monetary analysis framework:
  - ECB defends two-pillar approach, emphasizing monetary analysis to capture medium-term trends in money associated with inflation.
  - ECB work is refining monetary analysis to better understand financial sector and asset price developments and their relation to growth and inflation.
  - IMF staff: welcome broadening monetary analysis but see room to clarify the relative role of monetary aggregates in presenting monetary policy decisions; signals from monetary aggregates are overemphasized and not independent of non-monetary factors.
  - Suggestion: unify economic and monetary analysis in policy presentation to clarify the role of monetary aggregates.

### Liquidity Management
- ECB initiatives to ease money market tensions:
  - Broad list of eligible collateral and counterparties, relatively high but flexible reserve requirements, and adaptable toolkit.
  - Conducted fine-tuning operations, increased share of liquidity via three-month refinancing operations, and introduced six-month operations.
  - Result: maturity of refinancing operations increased significantly, although no net injection of liquidity over respective reserve maintenance periods.
- Additional measures:
  - Currency swap lines established with the Federal Reserve to facilitate provision of U.S. dollar liquidity in euro area markets.
  - The possibility for banks to use as collateral asset-backed securities they originated themselves likely helped prevent a complete shutdown of primary markets in the medium term; ECB stood ready to review this practice if necessary to restart markets.
- Assessment and further steps:
  - Interbank term spreads remain elevated, reflecting liquidity hoarding, balance-sheet stress, and counterparty risk, though these have been diminishing.
  - Little more was left for liquidity management per se to do to foster market normalization, but framework remains under active review.
  - Collateral framework and received collateral remain under continuous assessment to ensure Eurosystem risk tolerance and strict application of collateral rules.
  - Staff noted liquidity management at the systemic level should be accompanied by a more rules-based approach to managing stress at the individual bank level.
  - Longer-term recommendation: further integrate and develop secured interbank markets (e.g., integrate clearing and settlement systems) to reduce risk and impact of similar stress.

*Source: _cr08262 - 7.      Household credit has slowed significantly and credit to non-financial (IMF staff report content provided).*

### 20.      The fiscal position of the euro area improved in 2007 and now compares

### 20.      The fiscal position of the euro area improved in 2007 and now compares favorably to that in other parts of the world, marking a success for the reformed Stability and Growth Pact (SGP)

### Fiscal outcomes and structural position
- In structural terms, the fiscal accounts of the euro area as a whole reached a close-to-balanced position.
- All excessive deficit procedures vis-à-vis euro-area countries have been closed.
- About half of the countries reached or exceeded their “close to balance or surplus” medium-term objectives (MTO).
- The general government debt ratio continued to fall.

### Remaining fiscal challenges and demographic pressures
- A number of countries still face appreciable fiscal challenges, partly as a result of insufficient adjustment during the upswing.
- Countries that have not reached their MTO include almost all those with high public debt.
- Population aging-related outlays are set to accelerate soon after 2010 and add some 3¾–5 percent of GDP to public expenditure by 2050.
- The structural balance for 2007 may be lower than presently estimated if tax elasticities have been procyclical.
- Overall stimulus in 2008 could be somewhat larger than the modest boost planned thus far, given pressures to support citizens’ purchasing power amid ever higher commodity prices.
- Staff argued that tax policy should not be used to limit the pass-through of rising energy prices.
- At the June ECOFIN, Ministers reiterated their Manchester commitment of 2005 to avoid policies that prevent adjustment; regarding energy and food price-related challenges facing poorer segments of the population, the commitment calls for interventions to remain short-term, targeted, and non-distortionary.
- More recently, interpretations of this commitment appear to be varying across countries.

### Near-term deficit risks and surveillance
- Some countries’ fiscal deficits risk exceeding the Maastricht limit over the near term, potentially testing the reformed Pact’s excessive deficit procedure.
- The Commission has issued a fiscal policy advice to France, calling for strengthening the pace of budgetary consolidation so as to ensure that a suitable safety margin against breaching the 3 percent of GDP deficit threshold is soon attained.
- Under EC and staff forecasts, other countries’ safety margins (e.g., Italy, Portugal) also risk being rather narrow.

### Appropriate fiscal stance under the reformed SGP
- Broad agreement that the SGP rules provide the appropriate compass for fiscal policy in dealing with the current downturn.
- Automatic stabilizers should be allowed to play freely, except where this might lead to breaches of the Maastricht reference value.
- Countries that have reached their MTOs could consider additional discretionary loosening.
- Other countries need to continue to adjust at a pace of at least ½ percent of GDP per annum, unless in “bad times” (as defined under the revised SGP).
- Considerations supporting this approach:
  - (i) A more activist stance would undermine benefits of gradual moves toward a more rules-based fiscal policy.
  - (ii) Medium-run fiscal adjustment plans in Stability Programs still need to be backed up with measures.
  - (iii) Fiscal space needs to be preserved for higher aging-related outlays in the future.
  - (iv) Implementation of fiscal actions that are high-quality, timely, temporary, and well-targeted faces high political economy hurdles in many countries.
  - (v) Stimulus may lead to a further widening of government bond spreads in some countries while running counter to real exchange rate desiderata.

### Authorities’ commitments and timelines
- Country authorities reiterated support for the SGP.
- Last year’s commitment to reach MTO by 2010 had been made on the understanding that “good times” prevailed, notwithstanding negative output gaps in parts of the area.
- Italy aims to attain its MTO in 2011.
- France aims to attain its MTO in 2012.
- In virtually all countries, reaching these objectives will require adoption of measures that have yet to be specified in Stability Programs.

### EU financial stability framework: diagnosis and reform momentum
- Core issue: national authorities’ fiduciary responsibilities are toward national governments and parliaments, limiting incentives to work toward a common EU-wide stability framework essential for full financial integration.
- Growing recognition of limitations of existing arrangements and tensions with financial integration, combined with financial turmoil, has forged a convergence of views in favor of reform.
- Staff recommendations include more information sharing; better crisis prevention, management, and resolution frameworks (including at national levels); and greater joint accountability and responsibility for EU-wide financial stability.

### Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) and cost-sharing
- New policy principles and an MoU ask member states to look beyond national borders when managing and resolving crises.
- The MoU commits member states to act in crises to minimize the “potential harmful economic impacts at the lowest overall collective costs.”
- If public resources are needed to achieve a cost-minimizing solution, then “direct budgetary net costs are shared among Member States on the basis of equitable and balanced criteria.”
- Formal recognition of collective responsibility and cost-sharing is an innovative step.
- Concerns:
  - Tensions between national interests in severe crises would probably not be resolved via a non-binding MoU.
  - The MoU risks adding a large number of bilateral, trilateral, etc. committees to an already complex supervisory cross-border set-up, rather than taking a true multilateral approach that would facilitate international coordination.
- The MoU is to be tested with a crisis simulation exercise in 2009.

### Strengthening supervisory convergence and EU-level mandates
- EU Directives typically provide considerable latitude for country-specific regulatory and supervisory policies and practices; broad latitude creates unnecessary costs for market participants and may hinder completion of the single market.
- Current reform program seeks to reinforce the EU Committees of Supervisors (CEBS, CESR, CEIOPS) by:
  - giving them more resources;
  - introducing scope for qualified majority voting;
  - strengthening national application of the “Level 3 guidelines,” while keeping their non-binding “comply or explain” nature.
- May ECOFIN called on member states to endow supervisors’ statutes with a European mandate so they “are able to take into account the EU dimension in the performance of their duties, including having regard to the financial stability concerns in other Member States in exercising their duties.”

### Targeted initiatives following financial turmoil
- Initiatives include developing proposals to:
  - speed up convergence of regulatory and financial reporting;
  - improve Deposit Guarantee Schemes and allow authorities to apply early intervention and reorganization measures to cross-border groups;
  - assess obstacles to asset transferability that could hinder crisis management of cross-border groups, to forestall counter-productive ring-fencing of assets.
- Response priorities to the latest turmoil (in cooperation with international standard setters) cover four areas:
  - enhancing transparency;
  - improving valuation of financial products;
  - strengthening prudential requirements;
  - making markets function better.
- Priorities include introducing international standards for liquidity regulation; reducing incentives for regulatory arbitrage, off-balance sheet exposures, and exposure concentration; strengthening oversight of credit rating agencies.

### Mission recommendations for rapid progress
- Establish a multilateral platform for real-time sharing of systemically relevant supervisory information among supervisors and central banks, including the ECB.
- Improve Deposit Guarantee Schemes: raise standards for speed of payouts, limit co-insurance, and improve depositor information, without major legislative action.
- Determine common criteria for applying early intervention and reorganization measures, especially to cross-border groups; ultimately supplement with progress toward a convergent bankruptcy framework (acknowledging substantial legal difficulties).
- Give “teeth” to the planned European dimension in national supervisory mandates, clearly ruling out “beggar-thy-neighbor” policies, supported by appropriate accountability.

### Box 4 — A “European Mandate” for Financial Sector Supervisors (summary of discussion points)
- The European mandate should focus on financial sector stability and efficiency, with an overall objective and a more specific list of “dos and don’ts.”
- At minimum, member institutions of Level 3 Lamfalussy Committees (supervisors and regulators) and the Committees themselves should be covered.
- The mandate should preferably have the force of law and have precedence in case of conflict with national mandates; voluntary mechanisms may seize up in stress situations.
- Accountability must match the mandate; the EU Commission (with assistance of Lamfalussy Committees) would be competent to review observance of a European mandate enshrined in an EU legal instrument.
- The private sector should be empowered to assess whether authorities are fulfilling their mandates and to challenge those that are not.

### Ten years of EMU: monetary success, economic union incomplete
- Monetary union has been a distinct success; economic union remains work in progress.
- Labor market performance has been better than anticipated; labor utilization is no longer far off a trajectory that hits the 2010 Lisbon target (an employment-to-working age population ratio of 70 percent).
- Living standards have been improving but less than might have been hoped.
- Productivity growth has been lackluster; labor productivity growth has been described as lackluster in the period shown.
- The euro area is still experiencing large internal imbalances, reflecting both adjustment dynamics from convergence and remaining structural differences that constitute a source of vulnerability.

### Structural reform priorities and surveillance
- National Reform Programs (NRP) under the Lisbon Agenda need to focus more on making the single market a reality, particularly by opening up national services markets, including financial services, to competition from EU partners.
- Productivity growth has been particularly sluggish in services; differences in services price inflation account for a large part of inflation and competitiveness divergences.
- Financial market reforms could facilitate other structural reforms by helping advance their payoffs.
- Reforms need to focus on facilitating labor market adjustment in response to shocks.
- The Commission proposes establishing a peer review mechanism based on the Lisbon Strategy’s analytical framework to take account of fiscally costly but adjustment-friendly structural reforms when implementing the SGP.
- The Commission highlighted the need to enhance the euro area’s international role by developing common positions and consolidating representation, ultimately leading to a single seat in relevant international financial institutions and fora.
- Staff supported improving internal surveillance but cautioned against allowing a trade-off between fiscal adjustment under the SGP and structural reforms, noting:
  - Fiscal adjustment and structural reforms are often complements.
  - Allowing such a trade-off could undermine the benefits of a rules-based fiscal framework and peer pressure to respect the SGP.
  - The Commission was confident these problems could be avoided with a rigorous monitoring framework.

### Trade policy and food prices
- The EU seeks to conclude on the substance of a Doha Round agreement before the end of 2008; Commission representatives saw significant progress on agricultural products and were cautiously hopeful a broad agreement could be reached in 2008.
- The EU has entered into interim or final economic partnership agreements with more than thirty African, Caribbean, and Pacific (ACP) countries and will seek more final agreements in the coming year to replace the Cotonou preferences with WTO-consistent free trade agreements (FTAs).
- The EU is pursuing FTA negotiations with India, Korea, and the ASEAN and Mercosur countries, and is negotiating international investment agreements on behalf of member states.
- To address rising food prices, the Commission’s strategy includes:
  - helping developing countries cope through targeted development aid;
  - ensuring market incentives are in place for a supply response;
  - discouraging export taxes and other barriers to international trade.
- Measures taken include suspending the “set-aside” for 2008–09, which should increase cultivated farmland by about 10 percent.
- The Commission views the reformed Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) as offering appropriate incentives to trigger a supply response from European farmers, contributing to a good harvest.

*IMF staff report content as provided in the source document*

### 2008. A “health check” of the CAP will be conducted next year, and will include

### 2008. A “health check” of the CAP will be conducted next year, and will include

### EMU: achievements and remaining work
- Ten years after its launch, monetary union is a distinct and promising success.
- EMU’s macroeconomic policy framework has brought stability, both inside and outside the euro area.
- The union has been expanding, with Slovakia set to become its newest member.
- Despite major terms of trade shocks, labor costs have been subdued and employment growth remarkably strong over the past decade.
- The relative protection offered by EMU must not detract from building a vibrant economic union to realize monetary union’s full potential; this remains work in progress.

### Near-term outlook and risks
- The 10th anniversary of EMU coincided with the euro-area economy being strained by decelerating activity and uncomfortably high inflation.
- Contributing shocks: high commodity and food prices; tighter financial conditions; weakening real estate markets; slowing external demand; appreciation of the real effective exchange rate of the euro, now on the strong side of medium-run fundamentals.
- Projection: growth will likely slow substantially in the coming quarters, before reaccelerating toward trend in 2009 as the effects of the various shocks unwind.
- Uncertainty: the uncertainties around this baseline projection are large.

### Monetary policy guidance
- Monetary policy must balance the risk of a broad-based increase in inflation with the prospect of gradually building disinflationary forces from the economic slowdown.
- Key hinge factors: evolution of labor costs and inflation expectations.
- Mechanisms: as the economy slows, reduced demand for labor and pressure on employers’ margins should restrain inflation.
- Conditional projection: assuming stabilizing commodity and food prices, inflation should recede appreciably in 2009—as reflected in official forecasts.
- Risks: uncertainties around inflation are exceptionally large; risks of second-round effects remain; conversely, further tightening of financial conditions could harm prospects.
- Policy stance recommendation:
  - A case for tightening would arise if forward-looking indicators no longer pointed to significantly widening slack or if 2009 wage settlements hinted at accelerating labor costs and rising inflation expectations.
  - In the absence of such signals, policy rates are best kept on hold.

### ECB analysis, liquidity management, and market infrastructure
- Further development of the ECB’s monetary analysis would strengthen the policy framework.
  - Ongoing efforts to broaden analysis of determinants of inflation, including financial market and asset price developments, are welcome.
  - Recommendation: work could lead to a unified presentation of policy decisions that integrates monetary and economic analysis to clarify the role of monetary aggregates.
- ECB liquidity management assessment:
  - The ECB’s liquidity management has been timely and proactive; its framework—while possibly subject to refinements—has proven flexible and robust.
  - Broad lists of eligible collateral and counterparties and relatively high but flexible reserve requirements have acted as helpful stabilizers from the start of the turmoil.
  - Banks’ balance-sheet stresses and fears of liquidity shortages are likely to keep interbank term spreads high for some time.
  - The ECB is appropriately keeping its operational framework under continuous review, assessing collateral and ensuring strict application of rules.
- Market infrastructure recommendation:
  - Longer-term development of secured interbank markets could reduce the risk and impact of similar stress.
  - Urgent need to integrate clearing and settlement systems.

### Financial stability governance and crisis management
- Political leadership and a strong multilateral spirit are needed to move toward greater joint responsibility and accountability for EU financial stability implied in recent ECOFIN decisions.
- Agreed principles for cross-border crisis management are mould-breaking; key challenge is aligning national legal underpinnings with commonly agreed principles.
- Progress noted: Memorandum of Understanding on crisis management and intention to strengthen Level-3 Committees of Supervisors.
- Recommendations for stronger arrangements:
  - Complement recent steps with more binding arrangements.
  - Planned introduction of a European dimension in national supervisory mandates should clearly rule out “beggar-thy-neighbor”-type policies and provide appropriate accountability.
  - Establish a multilateral platform for real-time sharing of systemically-relevant supervisory information among supervisors and central banks, including the ECB—urgently needed.
  - Medium-term: firmer arrangements to underpin collective crisis cost minimization and sharing of fiscal costs based on equitable and balanced criteria.
- Political implication: these steps require strong political leadership akin to that which led to creation of the common currency and should facilitate collaboration with non-EU countries given globalized cross-border financial institutions.

### Fiscal policy guidance
- A rules-based fiscal policy serves countries best, notably in today’s uncertain environment.
- Assessment of SGP: the SGP has improved fiscal discipline, although about half of the euro area countries still face persistent challenges in meeting its objectives.
- Policy guidance:
  - Room for policy adjustment in response to the current downturn must be a function of leeway allowed by the SGP.
  - Tax policy should not be used to hamper adjustment to rising energy and food prices.
  - Looking further ahead, stronger national fiscal rules and domestic governance mechanisms could help achieve more predictable and efficient fiscal policies in countries that struggle with relatively high public deficits and debt.

### Structural reforms and trade policy
- Structural reform momentum should be kept up and re-oriented in a coordinated manner to improve adjustment to intra-area disparities and progress on commitments under the Fund’s Multilateral Consultations.
- Ongoing reforms have contributed to marked growth in employment and improved productivity in liberalized sectors.
- Remaining gaps: large parts of the services sector remain unaffected, forfeiting important income, resilience, and inflation benefits.
- Lisbon Agenda emphasis: accelerate services market reform and financial integration for the euro area as a whole.
- Recommendation: greater consistency of National Reform Programs with euro-area recommendations is needed, requiring enhanced policy coordination.
- Trade policy recommendation:
  - Prompt action is needed to conclude the Doha Round and bolster multilateral liberalization.
  - The right response to high food prices is to lower agricultural trade barriers and subsidies to foster production and free trade of agricultural products.
  - Resist approaches emphasizing self-sufficiency in food production and keep biofuels policies under review.
  - EU leadership in facilitating an ambitious and balanced conclusion to the Doha Round can counter rising protectionist pressures.

*Source: _cr08262 - 2008. A “health check” of the CAP will be conducted next year, and will include*

### 45.      It is proposed that the next consultation on euro-area policies in the context of the

### _cr08262 - 45.      It is proposed that the next consultation on euro-area policies in the context of the

### Consultation timing
- It is proposed that the next consultation on euro-area policies in the context of the Article IV obligations of member countries follow the standard 12-month cycle.

### Leading indicators (Figure 1)
- Sources: Eurostat, Reuters, IFO, INSEE, National Bank of Belgium, and staff calculations.
- Charts and series shown: Output; New orders; Industrial production 1/; PMI Manufacturing and Industrial Production; National Leading Indicators 2/.
- Country indicators shown: German IFO business indicator; French INSEE business indicator; Belgian BNB business indicator.
- Employment and PMI: Manufacturing employment; Services employment; PMI: Employment — Actual, Bridge Model, Forecast.
- Preliminary WEO GDP growth, q-o-q series plotted (periods include 2001Q2 through 2009Q2).

### Labor market indicators (Figure 2)
- Sources: Eurostat; OECD; EC Quarterly Business and Consumer Survey; and IMF staff estimates.
- Notes: 1/ Excluding Greece, Luxembourg, and Slovenia. 2/ Prime-age males, 25-54 years old.
- Unemployment (in percent of total labor force) plotted across 1997Q4–2007Q4 with NAIRU series.
- Employment/participation: Employment/population ratio and Employment/working age population ratio (1997Q4–2007Q4).
- Employment (annual percentage change): Total employment and Full-time employment.
- Part-time and Temporary Employment (in percent of total employment) show increase in part-time and temporary work.
- Capacity utilization and Prime-age employment ratio (in percent) plotted (1997Q4–2007Q4).
- Percentage of firms citing labor as factor limiting production plotted alongside unemployment rate (1997Q4–2007Q4).

### Financial market indicators (Figure 3)
- Sources: Bloomberg; and Datastream.
- Spreads of three-month interbank rates to three-month expected policy rates (Jul-07 through May-08) for US Dollar, Sterling, Euro.
- 5-Year Investment Grade CDX Credit Spreads: US and Europe (Jan-06 through Apr-08).
- Selected IBoxx Spreads 1/ by rating (3-5 years; 3-5 year A/AA/AAA/BBB) plotted (Jan-06 through Apr-08).
- 10-Year Government Bond Spreads with German Bunds for Italy, Spain, Belgium, France (Jan-06 through Apr-08).
- 1/ IBoxx corporate bond rates over German benchmark bond yields.

### External developments (Figure 4)
- Sources: ECB; Haver Analytics; IMF, World Economic Outlook.
- Staff estimate for medium-term equilibrium real effective exchange rate based on time series estimate with stochastic trend, macroeconomic balance, and external sustainability assessment (footnote 1/).
- Euro-dollar exchange rate (right scale) shows appreciation.
- Net FDI and portfolio flows (in billions of euro, 3-quarter moving average).
- Nominal effective exchange rates (Log levels, 2002.1=0) for Euro and U.S. dollar.
- Current account balances (in billions of U.S. dollars) plotted for United States, Euro area 3/, Rest of the world 2/.
- Real effective exchange rate (CPI; 1993-2006=100) and long-term average (1993-2006, ± 1 SD).

### Co-movements: Euro area and United States (Figure 5)
- Sources: Haver, IFS, Eurostat, and IMF staff calculations.
- US versus Euro area: Real GDP Growth (year-on-year, in percent) plotted (1980Q2–2007Q4).
- Peaks and troughs in euro area and US shown.
- US versus Euro area: Stock Prices (year-on-year, in percent) — United States (Nasdaq composite) and Euro area (DJ Stoxx).
- Correlations: Euro area and US real GDP growth; Euro area and US: GDP and Trade Correlations (in percent, 5-year moving average).

### Export margins by destination (Figure 6)
- Sources: Eurostat, OECD, IMF staff calculations.
- Export unit value relative to ULC in manufacturing, 2000=100 for destinations: Extra-area, US, UK, Japan, Russia, China, OPEC, ASEAN.
- Series: Total exports and Manufactured products (95Q1–07Q1 ranges plotted).

### Leverage ratios (Figure 7)
- Sources: Haver Analytics; and IMF staff calculations.
- Euro area households: Total debt to net financial wealth; Total debt to GDP (1999Q1–2007Q1).
- U.S. households: Total debt to net financial wealth; Total debt to GDP (1999Q1–2007Q1).
- Non-financial corporations: Total debt to equity for Euro area and U.S. (1999Q1–2007Q1).

### Corporate bond rates and equity prices (Figure 8)
- Sources: Thomson Financial/DataStream; and Bloomberg.
- Selected IBoxx Yields (yields in percent): IBOXX Euro Corporates A/AA/AAA/All Maturities/BBB (series across 2007–2008).
- Selected IBoxx Spreads 1/ (basis points) by rating across 2007–2008.
- Stock prices: Euro Stoxx 50, Index, Jan. 1, 2007=100.
- Implied volatility (in percent, right scale).
- 1/ IBoxx corporate bond rates over German benchmark bond yields.

### Credit markets (Figure 9)
- Sources: Thomson Financial/DataStream; Bloomberg; and CitiBank.
- iTraxx CDS Europe Index (basis points) main and HiVol series (1/1/07–6/1/08).
- Credit Default Swaps 5-Year Spreads for Financial and Nonfinancial sectors (1/1/07–6/1/08).
- Individual bank CDS: UBS, Deutsche bank, BNP Paribas, Banco Santander, Citigroup (1/1/07–6/1/08).
- Commercial Paper Due (US $bn) across weekly windows: May 12 - May 18, 2008; May 19 - May 25, 2008; May 26 - June 1, 2008; June 2 - June 6, 2008.
- Paper types: European Asset-Backed CP; European Non-Asset-Backed CP; US Asset-Backed CP; US Non-Asset-Backed CP.

### Bank loans and securities issuance (Figure 10)
- Source: ECB.
- Bank Loans to Non-financial Corporations and Households (annual growth rates): Loans to non-financial corporations; Loans to households (Jan-03–Jan-08).
- Debt Securities Issuance (annual growth rates): Non-financial corporations; MFIs; Non-monetary financial institutions (Jan-03–Jan-08).
- Equities Issuance (annual growth rates): Non-financial corporations; Non-monetary financial institutions; MFIs (Jan-03–Jan-08).

### Changes in credit standards (Figure 11)
- Source: European Central Bank.
- Changes in credit standards applied to approval of loans to enterprises (net percentages reporting tightening) — Realized and Expected and drivers (Costs related to bank's capital; Expectations regarding general economic activity; Industry or firm-specific outlook; Competition from other banks) across 2003Q1–2007Q4.
- Changes in credit standards for loans to households for house purchase — Realized and Expected and drivers (Housing market prospects; Expectations regarding general economic activity; Cost of funds and balance sheet constraints; Competition from other banks) across 2003Q1–2007Q4.

### Inflation and labor costs (Figure 12)
- Sources: Eurostat; ECB; and Haver Analytics.
- 1/ Excludes energy, food, alcohol, and tobacco.
- Inflation (year-on-year) Headline HICP and Core HICP 1/ (1999–2008) with note: Headline inflation reached record highs.
- Components inflation (year-on-year): Non-energy industrial goods; Energy (right scale); Food, alcohol, and tobacco (right scale).
- Services (overall index excluding goods).
- Labor costs (4-quarter change): Unit labor costs; Compensation per employee; Hourly labor costs (2000Q4–2007Q4).
- Wage growth described as still subdued.
- Inflation measures (year-on-year change): Weighted trimmed inflation; Weighted median inflation — measures of underlying inflation have increased.

### Money and credit (Figure 13)
- Sources: ECB; Datastream; Bloomberg; and IMF staff calculations.
- 1/ Deviations from 1990-2004 mean.
- 2/ Based on M3 corrected for estimated impact of portfolio shifts. Real money gap (right scale) measured as deviation (in percent of actual real stock, deflated by HICP) from estimate of long-run real stock assuming constant nominal M3 growth at reference value 4.5 percent and HICP inflation in line with ECB's definition of price stability, December 1998 base period.
- M3 growth and Real money gap series (1999–2008) with comment: ECB perceives a liquidity "overhang" as an upside inflation risk.
- Money velocity plotted with trend breaks (1980Q4–2007Q4).
- ECB reference range (4-quarter percent changes) for loans: Loans to households; Consumer credit; Loans for house purchases; Loans to nonfinancial corporations — loan growth to nonfinancial corporations remains high, while that to households continues to decline.
- Monetary conditions index and Real interest rate contribution plotted (1999–2008) with comment: Monetary conditions have become tighter.

### Monetary policy and market expectations (Figure 14)
- Sources: Bloomberg; Datastream; ECB; Eurostat; and IMF staff calculations.
- 1/ Survey of Professional Forecasters.
- Policy rates: Euro area and United States (1999–2008) with note: The ECB kept rates unchanged at 4 percent since June 2007.
- EONIA swap curves (2/29/08; 4/8/08; 6/9/08) and Actual 3-month EURIBOR and Main refinancing rate.
- Markets expectations shifted toward a possible hike in policy rates.
- 10-year break-even inflation rate and Analysts' inflation expectations series (2000–2008) — analysts' inflation expectations remain well anchored.
- Break-even inflation rates for EU 10-year, US 10-year, UK 10-year — break-even inflation has moved up lately.

### Fiscal developments (Figure 15)
- Sources: European Commission; IMF, World Economic Outlook; and IMF staff calculations.
- Overall balance (in percent of GDP) for Euro area, US, Japan, UK (1995–2009).
- Primary structural balance (in percent of potential GDP) series plotted (1981–2009).
- Structural balance, 2007 outturns (in percent of potential GDP) shown by country codes (GRE, PRT, ITA, FRA, AUT, BEL, DEU, IRL, NLD, ESP, FIN).
- Structural balance targets in Stability Programs (in percent of potential GDP) with vintages: Dec. 2006, Dec. 2002, Dec. 2003, Dec. 2004, Dec. 2005, Dec. 2007.
- General government debt (in percent of GDP) (1999–2009).
- Staff projections vs Stability Programs Dec. 2007 and Cumulative fiscal adjustment (2008–2010 range plotted).

### Main economic indicators (Table 1)
- Table header: Euro Area: Main Economic Indicators (in percent change).
- Selected series (2000–2009): (values preserved exactly)
  - Private consumption: 3.1 2.0 0.9 1.3 1.6 1.6 1.8 1.5 1.3 1.1
  - Public consumption: 2.4 2.1 2.4 1.8 1.4 1.5 2.0 2.2 2.1 2.0
  - Gross fixed investment: 4.9 0.5 -1.4 1.4 2.4 3.0 5.0 4.3 3.5 1.2
  - Final domestic demand: 3.4 1.7 0.7 1.4 1.7 1.8 2.5 2.3 2.0 1.3
  - Stockbuilding 1/: 0.0 -0.5 -0.3 0.1 0.2 0.0 0.1 0.0 -0.2 -0.1
  - Domestic Demand: 3.4 1.2 0.4 1.5 2.0 1.9 2.6 2.2 1.7 1.2
  - Foreign balance 1/: 0.4 0.7 0.5 -0.7 0.2 -0.2 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.1
  - Exports 2/: 12.2 3.9 1.8 1.2 7.2 4.7 7.9 6.0 5.1 3.8
  - Imports 2/: 11.1 2.1 0.4 3.3 7.0 5.4 7.7 5.2 5.2 3.8
  - Real GDP: 3.8 1.9 0.9 0.8 2.1 1.6 2.8 2.6 1.7 1.2
  - Potential GDP: 2.2 2.2 2.1 2.0 2.0 1.9 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0
  - Output gap: 1.7 1.4 0.2 -0.9 -0.8 -1.1 -0.3 0.2 0.0 -0.8
  - Employment: 2.4 1.4 0.9 0.7 0.7 0.9 1.5 1.9 0.9 0.4
  - Unemployment rate 3/: 8.1 7.8 8.2 8.7 8.8 8.6 8.2 7.4 7.3 7.4
  - GDP deflator: 1.3 2.4 2.6 2.2 1.9 1.9 1.9 2.2 2.2 1.9
  - Consumer prices: 2.2 2.4 2.3 2.1 2.1 2.2 2.2 2.1 3.2 2.3
  - General government balance: -1.0 -1.9 -2.6 -3.1 -2.9 -2.6 -1.3 -0.6 -1.0 -1.1
  - General government structural balance: -1.6 -2.3 -2.6 -2.7 -2.4 -2.1 -1.2 -0.8 -1.1 -0.8
  - General government gross debt: 69.4 68.3 68.2 69.3 69.7 70.3 68.5 66.4 65.2 64.4
  - Short-term deposit rate: 4.5 4.1 3.3 2.3 2.1 2.3 3.2 4.2 ...... 
  - Long-term government bond yields: 5.4 4.9 4.8 4.0 4.0 3.4 3.9 4.4 ...... 
  - U.S. dollar per euro: 0.92 0.90 0.94 1.13 1.24 1.25 1.26 1.37 1.55 ...
  - Nominal effective rate (2000=100): 100.0 101.6 105.1 117.6 122.0 121.7 122.6 128.9 136.4 ...
  - Real effective rate (2000=100) 6/: 100.0 100.7 106.6 122.3 130.0 129.1 128.8 134.8 142.3 ...
  - Current account balance: -1.5 -0.3 0.8 0.4 0.8 0.2 0.0 0.3 -0.5 -0.6
  - Trade balance 8/: 0.1 1.0 1.7 1.4 1.3 0.6 0.2 0.6 -0.1 -0.2
- Notes: Sources: IMF, World Economic Outlook; Eurostat, ECB Monthly Bulletin. Footnotes as in table.

### Balance of payments (Table 2)
- Table: Euro Area: Balance of Payments.
- Selected aggregated figures (2000–2007Q4) in levels and percent of GDP preserved exactly as presented:
  - Current account (levels): -101.9 -21.9 57.2 33.7 59.8 7.1 -13.7 14.9 -4.9
  - Goods (levels): 5.6 73.4 128.3 105.5 102.6 48.0 22.2 59.5 11.2
  - Services (levels): -9.8 -3.0 17.7 22.5 28.5 31.6 35.3 42.6 8.9
  - Income (levels): -48.2 -41.0 -39.2 -37.0 -10.3 0.5 5.6 -4.7 1.0
  - Current transfers (levels): -49.6 -51.2 -49.6 -57.7 -60.8 -72.9 -76.9 -82.6 -26.1
  - Capital account (levels): 11.3 6.2 10.1 12.1 16.4 11.4 9.0 14.4 5.9
  - Financial account (levels): 75.4 -28.2 -15.3 -15.3 -16.8 24.3 117.9 1.7 -117.3
  - Direct investment (levels): -14.4 -109.8 22.7 -10.3 -66.9 -208.8 -136.5 -108.3 10.9
  - Portfolio investment (levels): -100.9 72.9 138.0 55.7 72.1 141.3 276.3 232.5 -45.9
  - Financial derivatives (levels): -10.0 -0.7 -12.2 -13.7 -8.4 -16.3 2.5 -123.1 -51.1
  - Other investment (levels): 183.4 -8.5 -160.9 -74.6 -26.3 90.0 -23.3 5.5 -35.6
  - Reserve assets (levels): 17.7 18.0 -2.5 28.0 12.6 18.2 -1.1 -4.7 4.5
  - Errors and omissions (levels): 13.1 44.0 -51.9 -30.0 -61.5 -44.1 -114.1 -29.2 102.9
  - Current account (percent of GDP): -1.5 -0.3 0.8 0.4 0.8 0.1 -0.2 0.2 -0.2
  - Memo: GDP (in billions of euros): 6759.8 7054.6 7300.9 7517.2 7822.6 8098.9 8478.9 887.5 2237.1 (values shown as in table).
- Sources: ECB; Eurostat; Datastream; IMF, World Economic Outlook. 1/ End of period stocks.

### Net investment position (Table 3)
- Table: Euro Area: Net Investment Position (in percent of GDP).
- Assets (2000–2007Q4): 103.3 110.9 102.5 106.7 113.0 136.5 148.4 155.7
  - Direct investment abroad: 25.9 29.7 27.6 29.0 29.8 34.9 36.5 38.9
  - Portfolio investment abroad: 35.2 35.7 31.5 35.5 39.0 48.1 52.6 53.7
  - Financial derivatives: 1.6 1.8 1.8 2.0 2.0 2.8 3.4 0.0
  - Other investment abroad: 35.0 38.1 36.5 36.2 38.6 46.8 52.1 58.6
  - Reserve assets: 5.8 5.6 5.0 4.1 3.6 4.0 0.0 4.0
- Liabilities (2000–2007Q4): 110.7 116.4 112.2 117.3 124.4 146.9 160.5 170.9
  - Direct investment in the EU: 20.7 23.7 25.1 27.8 28.8 30.4 31.5 33.9
  - Portfolio investment in the EU: 47.6 47.8 44.6 47.9 52.4 63.4 70.7 76.1
  - Financial derivatives: 1.5 1.8 2.0 2.3 2.5 3.3 3.9 4.9
  - Other investment in the EU: 40.8 43.2 40.5 39.3 40.7 49.8 54.4 60.9
- Net investment position (2000–2007Q4): -7.3 -5.5 -9.7 -10.6 -11.4 -10.4 -12.1 -15.3
  - Direct investment (net): 5.3 6.0 2.5 1.1 1.0 4.5 4.9 5.0
  - Portfolio investment (net): -12.4 -12.0 -13.1 -12.4 -13.4 -15.3 -18.1 -22.4
  - Other investment (net): -5.8 -5.1 -4.0 -3.1 -2.1 -3.0 -2.4 -2.3
  - Reserve assets (net): 5.6 5.6 5.0 4.1 3.6 4.0 3.9 4.0
- Source: European Central Bank. 1/ Data correspond to the end of the indicated period.

### Medium-term current account (Table 4)
- Table: Euro Area: Medium-term Current Account (projections and levels).
- Levels (in billions euros) 2003–2013: 33.4 62.2 18.2 -1.2 26.2 -45.8 -61.0 -62.9 -65.5 -69.4 -83.0
  - Goods (levels): 43.8 90.6 114.2 73.4 71.0 55.5 59.8 84.6 41.7 37.4 47.1
  - Services (levels): -0.1 15.1 71.4 74.5 80.9 53.9 29.4 46.9 55.0 61.5 60.4
- Percent of GDP projections 2003–2013:
  - Current account: 0.4 0.8 0.2 0.0 0.3 -0.5 -0.6 -0.6 -0.6 -0.6 -0.7
  - Goods: 0.6 1.2 1.4 0.9 0.8 0.6 0.6 0.9 0.4 0.3 0.4
  - Services: 0.0 0.2 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.6 0.3 0.5 0.5 0.6 0.5
- Memorandum: Gross national saving series 2003–2013: 20.7 21.6 21.2 21.9 22.5 21.9 21.4 21.4 21.5 21.6 21.5
- Source: World Economic Outlook.

### Policy progress and plans relevant to IMFC strategy (Table 5)
- Product market
  - Limited progress so far; some initiatives in the pipeline.
  - Deadline for transposing the Services Directive at the national level is 17 months away. The Commission has published an implementation handbook. Countries are proceeding with preparatory work. It will be important to track their interim progress to ensure full and timely implementation.
  - Network services: progress in deregulation limited to few euro area countries: rail (the Netherlands), energy (Spain, Netherlands), telecom (Finland, Greece, Slovenia). In February, the German utility company E.ON offered to sell its electricity grid, which may be a breakthrough.
  - Retail services: progress limited, though measures taken in Spain, Italy and expected in France.
  - Professional services: measures taken in some countries (Spain, Belgium, Finland, Italy, the Netherlands) but competition remains insufficient in several countries. Reform initiatives on the table in France and Italy.
  - Recommendation: Reduce market regulation, improve business environment.
  - Commission initiatives: new postal directive to remove outstanding “reserved segments”; creating a European Telecom Market Authority; package of legislative proposals in the energy sectors aimed at effective separation of supply and transmission activities.
- Labor market
  - More progress in some areas and countries than others.
  - Increasing fiscal incentives to work and adjusting benefits systems: active labor market policies strengthened (Austria, Belgium); social security systems improved (Belgium, Germany). French reform package contains elements in these areas. Germany had some reform reversals (higher minimum wage for postal workers, longer unemployment benefit period for older workers).
  - Fostering flexibility and security: some countries moving toward integrated flexicurity (Austria, Finland, Ireland, the Netherlands); others taking steps (France, Italy).
  - Aligning wage and productivity: gradual move toward more wage and working time flexibility; signs of more decentralized wage bargaining in some countries (Austria, Spain, Finland, Italy). France reform package includes making the 35-hour workweek less binding.
  - Promoting labor mobility: EU initiatives include recommendations on European Qualifications Framework and European Job Mobility Action Plan; country-level cross-border mobility progress generally limited, with exceptions.
  - Priorities align with Lisbon National Action Plans to boost labor utilization and productivity.
- Financial market
  - Progress more pronounced.
  - Payment Services Directive published in EU Journal; to be transposed nationally by November 2009.
  - Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID) became effective in November 2007; some non-euro area countries yet to transpose it.
  - Target 2 replaced Target as payments platform in November 2007. Target2 Securities project development proceeding; final report to Governing Council in summer 2008.
  - Implementation of Financial Services Action Plan at national level close to completion. Several countries yet to transpose the Transparency Directive.
  - Financial stability arrangements: common principles for cross-border financial crisis management and measures to improve the Lamfalussy process adopted by ECOFIN in October and December. Common principles incorporated into EU-wide Memorandum of Understanding on cross-border crisis management and resolution.
  - Solvency (II) Directive preparations ongoing; amended proposal adopted Feb 2008; tentative timetable extends to 2012.
  - Integration of EU markets for housing finance: Commission released White Paper on Integration of EU Mortgage Markets on December 18.

_Italic: IMF staff summary based solely on provided content._

### 2007. However, the White Paper proposes further investigation

### _cr08262 - 2007. However, the White Paper proposes further investigation

### Financial conditions of large and complex banking groups (Table 6: 2004 – H1 2007)
- Return on equity (percent)
  - 2004: min. 4.30, 1st quartile 10.39, median 16.35, average 16.78, weighted average 17.22, 3rd quartile 20.48, max. 33.20
  - 2005: min. 9.00, 1st quartile 14.88, median 17.40, average 18.74, weighted average 19.12, 3rd quartile 23.13, max. 37.00
  - 2006: min. 7.24, 1st quartile 16.70, median 18.53, average 18.75, weighted average 18.99, 3rd quartile 21.20, max. 37.60
  - H1 2007: min. 5.11, 1st quartile 17.90, median 21.00, average 20.19, weighted average 20.21, 3rd quartile 22.50, max. 36.00
- Return on risk-weighted assets (percent)
  - 2004: min. 0.20, 1st quartile 0.92, median 1.11, average 1.13, weighted average 1.17, 3rd quartile 1.49, max. 2.03
  - 2005: min. 0.81, 1st quartile 1.06, median 1.38, average 1.40, weighted average 1.43, 3rd quartile 1.73, max. 2.26
  - 2006: min. 0.77, 1st quartile 1.11, median 1.42, average 1.48, weighted average 1.51, 3rd quartile 1.84, max. 2.66
  - H1 2007: min. 0.81, 1st quartile 1.51, median 1.84, average 1.86, weighted average 1.87, 3rd quartile 2.20, max. 3.22
- Net interest income (% total assets)
  - 2004: min. 0.43, 1st quartile 0.71, median 0.90, average 1.04, weighted average 0.93, 3rd quartile 1.30, max. 1.87
  - 2005: min. 0.48, 1st quartile 0.58, median 0.68, average 0.93, weighted average 0.89, 3rd quartile 1.28, max. 1.84
  - 2006: min. 0.24, 1st quartile 0.55, median 0.69, average 0.95, weighted average 0.87, 3rd quartile 1.28, max. 2.03
  - H1 2007: min. 0.22, 1st quartile 0.54, median 0.74, average 0.91, weighted average 0.80, 3rd quartile 1.25, max. 1.98
- Net interest income (% total income)
  - 2004: min. 24.07, 1st quartile 36.70, median 51.43, average 48.63, weighted average 47.66, 3rd quartile 56.51, max. 69.54
  - 2005: min. 23.53, 1st quartile 29.59, median 46.95, average 44.57, weighted average 45.39, 3rd quartile 58.69, max. 68.70
  - 2006: min. 14.07, 1st quartile 38.14, median 48.71, average 45.80, weighted average 43.48, 3rd quartile 53.92, max. 70.24
  - H1 2007: min. 10.02, 1st quartile 40.00, median 47.39, average 43.75, weighted average 40.55, 3rd quartile 52.27, max. 64.61
- Trading income (% total income)
  - 2004: min. 2.69, 1st quartile 7.58, median 9.41, average 11.74, weighted average 12.91, 3rd quartile 15.66, max. 28.73
  - 2005: min. 2.58, 1st quartile 6.88, median 10.37, average 13.32, weighted average 14.47, 3rd quartile 16.43, max. 37.14
  - 2006: min. 2.45, 1st quartile 6.35, median 12.95, average 14.80, weighted average 16.97, 3rd quartile 19.09, max. 46.83
  - H1 2007: min. 7.20, 1st quartile 13.70, median 19.49, average 21.28, weighted average 23.63, 3rd quartile 21.38, max. 53.67
- Fees and commissions (% total income)
  - 2004: min. 15.90, 1st quartile 20.84, median 29.45, average 29.32, weighted average 28.97, 3rd quartile 36.12, max. 44.15
  - 2005: min. 17.12, 1st quartile 22.30, median 29.45, average 28.07, weighted average 28.11, 3rd quartile 34.79, max. 40.02
  - 2006: min. 18.20, 1st quartile 23.36, median 27.61, average 28.87, weighted average 29.50, 3rd quartile 31.18, max. 43.03
  - H1 2007: min. 11.31, 1st quartile 24.97, median 29.18, average 28.38, weighted average 28.69, 3rd quartile 33.59, max. 35.98
- Other income (% total income)
  - 2004: min. -3.07, 1st quartile 2.79, median 4.93, average 6.87, weighted average 6.22, 3rd quartile 7.53, max. 26.70
  - 2005: min. -0.76, 1st quartile 2.82, median 4.71, average 5.71, weighted average 6.24, 3rd quartile 2.82, max. 16.73
  - 2006: min. -0.15, 1st quartile 1.42, median 5.26, average 6.53, weighted average 6.64, 3rd quartile 11.00, max. 21.54
  - H1 2007: min. 0.76, 1st quartile 2.04, median 3.51, average 4.47, weighted average 4.73, 3rd quartile 5.64, max. 13.21
- Net loan impairment charges (% total assets)
  - 2004: min. 0.03, 1st quartile 0.06, median 0.07, average 0.11, weighted average 0.09, 3rd quartile 0.09, max. 0.40
  - 2005: min. -0.02, 1st quartile 0.02, median 0.05, average 0.08, weighted average 0.08, 3rd quartile 0.11, max. 0.29
  - 2006: min. 0.01, 1st quartile 0.03, median 0.05, average 0.11, weighted average 0.10, 3rd quartile 0.18, max. 0.36
  - H1 2007: min. 0.00, 1st quartile 0.02, median 0.06, average 0.09, weighted average 0.09, 3rd quartile 0.11, max. 0.37
- Cost-income ratio (percent)
  - 2004: min. 48.60, 1st quartile 62.05, median 68.05, average 66.63, weighted average 68.49, 3rd quartile 70.90, max. 85.30
  - 2005: min. 43.20, 1st quartile 58.70, median 63.65, average 63.37, weighted average 63.76, 3rd quartile 66.95, max. 89.40
  - 2006: min. 39.60, 1st quartile 54.70, median 61.10, average 60.51, weighted average 61.69, 3rd quartile 68.00, max. 79.80
  - H1 2007: min. 38.70, 1st quartile 50.20, median 58.80, average 58.40, weighted average 59.67, 3rd quartile 63.20, max. 77.70
- Tier 1 ratio (percent)
  - 2004: min. 6.32, 1st quartile 7.10, median 7.80, average 8.02, weighted average 7.88, 3rd quartile 8.38, max. 10.90
  - 2005: min. 6.70, 1st quartile 7.58, median 8.15, average 8.45, weighted average 8.25, 3rd quartile 8.95, max. 11.60
  - 2006: min. 6.70, 1st quartile 7.42, median 7.80, average 8.33, weighted average 8.16, 3rd quartile 8.90, max. 10.50
  - H1 2007: min. 6.09, 1st quartile 7.55, median 7.90, average 8.21, weighted average 8.00, 3rd quartile 8.40, max. 10.80
- Overall solvency ratios (percent)
  - 2004: min. 8.46, 1st quartile 10.43, median 11.35, average 11.40, weighted average 11.04, 3rd quartile 12.69, max. 13.30
  - 2005: min. 8.50, 1st quartile 10.80, median 11.55, average 11.70, weighted average 11.42, 3rd quartile 12.47, max. 16.30
  - 2006: min. 10.00, 1st quartile 10.60, median 11.10, average 11.40, weighted average 11.36, 3rd quartile 11.74, max. 15.60
  - H1 2007: min. 10.20, 1st quartile 11.01, median 10.70, average 11.20, weighted average 11.13, 3rd quartile 11.70, max. 15.10

Sources for Table 6: Individual institutions' financial reports and ECB calculations.

### Statistical issues and euro area statistics developments (Appendix I)
- General assessment
  - Euro area (and EU-27) statistics are produced by Eurostat and the ECB, generally on the basis of data reported by the statistical services of member states.
  - Statistics are of sufficient quality, scope, and timeliness to allow effective macroeconomic surveillance, but gaps and weaknesses remain due to institutional complexities and national idiosyncrasies affecting comparability.
  - The IMF's Dissemination Standards Bulletin Board (DSBB) provides comprehensive information on the Euro area’s statistical practices for the SDDS data categories.
- Recent and ongoing developments (selected)
  - NACE rev. 2
    - NACE rev. 2 came into force on January 1, 2008, and will be introduced gradually during the 2008–11 period.
    - It provides a better and more detailed classification of economic activities, will better capture services and outsourcing, and will lead to an increase in the measured share of services in output.
    - For short-term statistics, Eurostat is working with member states to ensure time series are recalculated back to 2000; in other areas limited potential for backcasting means significantly shorter dataseries or statistical breaks and interruptions during the transition period.
  - Principal European Economic Indicators
    - Under review; consideration being given to adding housing market indicators and tightening timeliness standards.
    - Production guidelines for seasonal and calendar day adjustments approved and to come into effect in the second half of the year.
    - Work to harmonize revision policies and on euro area vintage data is ongoing.
  - National accounts
    - ESA 95 transmission program changed substantially at end-2007, requiring member states to report more harmonized data in greater detail.
    - Guidelines for seasonal adjustment and calendar adjustment issued; responsibility for quarterly and annual sectoral accounts merged and timeliness improved.
    - Work ongoing to extend annual series backward to 1995 and quarterly series to 1999.
    - Nonfinancial balance sheets work ongoing as a long-term project; Eurostat discontinued publication of national accounts at constant prices in favor of chain-linked data at previous year’s prices.
  - HICP and owner-occupied housing
    - Commission Regulation (EC) No. 1334/2007 issued November 2007 focusing HICP on “consumption segments” rather than products; prescribes quality adjustments and gives Eurostat ability to issue standards for quality adjustment case-by-case.
    - Pilot work on an HICP index at constant tax rates not completed; regulation being prepared to harmonize treatment of seasonal items; an HICP Manual should be finalized shortly.
    - Work continues on harmonized HICP data on prices for owner-occupied housing; pilot project covering 12 countries completed, followed by a stage including 26 of the EU’s 27 member states; Eurostat produced a manual on owner-occupied housing and initiated a two-year project to produce an international manual for residential real estate prices.
  - Government finance and fiscal monitoring
    - Eurostat started release of a quarterly Government Finance Statistics publication using the summary page presentation and historic EDP data on deficits and debt.
    - Tightened statistical accounting rules for securitization operations by governments; looking into treatment of government guarantees to financial institutions and of government debt issued to swap against private financial assets.
    - Stepped-up monitoring of member states’ fiscal accounts; resources for fiscal monitoring increased significantly, with available staff doubling between 2004 and 2008.
  - Labour, short-term and business statistics
    - New framework regulation introduced to harmonize compilation of quarterly data on job vacancies (European Parliament and Council Regulation (EC) No 4533/2008).
    - Work to enhance measurement quality of “hours worked” and to improve models for monthly unemployment rates.
    - Short-term statistics work focuses on prices and services output; workshops organized to harmonize Services Producer Price Indices reporting; aim to produce an index of services production by 2012.
    - New series on import prices published, compiled on reporting by importers, allowing differentiation between import prices and unit values.
    - Structural business statistics: new regulation covering statistics on business services and business demographics; ad-hoc survey ongoing on international sourcing; survey on access to financial services by SMEs being considered.
    - MEETS (Modernization of European Enterprise and Trade Statistics): comprehensive 5-year overhaul about to start to improve coverage and quality while reducing reporting burden.
  - Intrastat and Extrastat
    - Regulations being revised to reduce reporting burden on enterprises; asymmetries in intra-EU trade and BOP statistics persist, with data confidentiality an obstacle; revision of basic statistical legislation expected to facilitate exchange of confidential data between Member States and Eurostat.

### Supplementary information and macroeconomic update (staff supplement dated July 18, 2008)
- Purpose
  - Supplement provides an update of economic and policy developments since release of the staff report (7/2/08); the thrust of staff appraisal remains unchanged.
- Recent economic developments and forecasts
  - Recent data confirm a marked slowdown in economic activity, as forecast by staff, but also somewhat higher inflation.
  - Growth in 2008:Q1 was revised down modestly, to 2.9 percent on a quarterly annualized basis (2.1 percent over 2007:Q1).
  - Industrial production data for May and purchasing managers’ indices for manufacturing and services in June point to very weak activity ahead.
  - Recent trade data for May show several euro area countries’ exports slowing sharply, in particular to the United States.
  - Inflation
    - Inflation excluding energy and all food prices remained contained at 1.8 percent in June.
    - Headline inflation reached 4.0 percent in June, essentially because of further sharp energy price increases.
    - Staff has raised its inflation forecast for 2008 and 2009 slightly upward, to 3.4 percent and 2.4 percent, respectively.
- Financial conditions
  - Financial conditions have deteriorated: financial stocks have fallen substantially, borrowing costs and credit default spreads have risen, and term spreads in money markets have remained at elevated levels.

*Prepared by the European Department; Approved by Alessandro Leipold and Adnan Mazarei; July 18, 2008.*

### 4.      As foreshadowed in the staff report, the ECB raised its policy rate by 25 basis

### 4. As foreshadowed in the staff report, the ECB raised its policy rate by 25 basis

### Monetary policy action and staff view
- The ECB raised its policy rate by 25 basis points to 4.25 percent on July 3.
- Markets essentially do not expect further moves; the decision was fully priced in by markets.
- The ECB stated the rate increase was “taken to prevent broadly based second-round effects and to counteract the increasing upside risks to price stability over the medium term.”
- The ECB considers that “the monetary policy stance following today’s [July 3] decision will contribute to achieving our objective of price stability”—language interpreted by markets as implying no further changes.
- Staff continues to believe that, going forward, policy rates are best kept on hold while, as stated by the ECB, continuing “to monitor very closely all developments over the period ahead.”

### Inflation outlook and risks
- Despite the staff’s upward revision, inflation is still projected to fall below 2 percent by end-2009, assuming stabilizing energy prices, in line with oil futures markets data.
- Headline inflation has recently reached its highest levels since the launch of EMU, pushed up by energy and food prices.
- Underlying inflation and labor costs have been well contained thus far, reflecting the high credibility of the ECB.
- Risks: upside risks to price stability remain, particularly if wage settlements imply accelerating labor costs in 2009; financial turmoil and commodity price volatility add uncertainty.

### Staff growth projections and recent performance (selected indicators)
- Staff projects annual average growth of 1.7 percent in 2008 and 1.2 percent in 2009.
- Real GDP (annual percent change): 2003: 0.8; 2004: 2.1; 2005: 1.6; 2006: 2.8; 2007: 2.6; 2008: 1.7; 2009: 1.2.
- Consumer prices (annual percent change): 2003: 2.1; 2004: 2.1; 2005: 2.2; 2006: 2.2; 2007: 2.1; 2008: 3.4; 2009: 2.4.
- Potential GDP (percent): 2003: 2.0; 2004: 2.0; 2005: 1.9; 2006: 2.0; 2007: 2.0; 2008: 2.0; 2009: 2.0.
- Output gap (percent): 2003: -0.9; 2004: -0.8; 2005: -1.1; 2006: -0.3; 2007: 0.2; 2008: 0.0; 2009: -0.8.
- Unemployment rate (percent): 2003: 8.7; 2004: 8.8; 2005: 8.6; 2006: 8.2; 2007: 7.4; 2008: 7.3; 2009: 7.4.
- General government gross debt (percent of GDP): 2003: 69.3; 2004: 69.7; 2005: 70.3; 2006: 68.6; 2007: 66.5; 2008: 65.2; 2009: 64.4.

### Financial conditions and stability
- Rising risk premia have pushed up key money market interest rates to levels last reached during the mid-1990s.
- The outlook for financial stability is highly uncertain, although the area’s financial system remains sound.
- Progress has been made with respect to banks' loss recognition and recapitalization, but many financial markets have yet to return to normal and the global financial turmoil has led to a tightening of financial conditions.
- Pressure on firms and households from higher risk premia and stricter lending standards will likely build considerably over time, though nonfinancial balance sheets still seem relatively robust.
- Key near-term challenge: restore the depth and orderly functioning of interbank markets.
- The ECB’s liquidity management framework has proven flexible and robust; Directors welcomed plans to keep the operational framework under continuous review, notably with respect to the collateral it accepts, and to ensure strict application of the framework’s rules.

### Fiscal positions and recommendations
- The fiscal position of the euro area improved in 2007, reaching close to balance in structural terms.
- About half of the euro-area countries still face persistent challenges in meeting their medium-term fiscal objectives.
- Directors stressed that the room for fiscal policy responses to the current downturn should be a function of the leeway allowed by the Stability and Growth Pact (SGP).
- Recommendations:
  - For countries with limited fiscal space, maintain fiscal discipline to meet medium-term objectives and population aging-related fiscal challenges expected to mount rapidly after 2010.
  - Support for more vulnerable sectors should be well targeted and not distort price signals.
  - Strengthen national fiscal rules and domestic governance mechanisms to achieve more predictable and efficient fiscal policies in countries with relatively high public sector deficits and debt.

### Structural reform and EU-level financial framework
- Ten years after launch, monetary union is a distinct success, but economic union remains work in progress.
- Improved wage setting and labor market reforms have contributed to the creation of some 16 million jobs over the past decade.
- Product market reforms and the single market program have raised productivity in affected sectors, but large parts of the services sector still remain to be opened to EU-wide competition.
- Directors emphasized maintaining and re-orienting the structural reform momentum in a coordinated manner to address intra-area disparities.
- Directors welcomed steps to strengthen the EU’s financial stability framework and looked forward to further moves toward greater joint responsibility and accountability for EU financial stability.
- Near-term priorities: align national financial stability frameworks with EU principles for crisis prevention, management, and resolution; improve information sharing among supervisors and central banks, including the ECB.
- Directors noted ongoing work to enhance the ECB’s monetary analysis and suggested this could lead to a unified presentation of policy decisions integrating monetary and economic analysis.

*IMF Executive Board Concludes 2008 Article IV Consultation on Euro Area Policies; Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 08/98; August 4, 2008.*

### conclusion of the Doha Round. They viewed lower agricultural trade barriers and lower

### _cr08262 - conclusion of the Doha Round. They viewed lower agricultural trade barriers and lower

### Executive Directors’ view on Doha Round and agricultural policies
- Directors viewed lower agricultural trade barriers and lower subsidies as the right approach to foster production and respond to high food prices.
- They looked forward to the review of the Common Agricultural Policy next year.
- Directors welcomed the EU’s intention to keep its biofuels policies under review.

### Public Information Notices (PINs)
- PINs form part of the IMF's efforts to promote transparency of the IMF's views and analysis.
- With consent of the country (or countries) concerned, PINs are issued after Executive Board discussions of:
  - Article IV consultations with member countries,
  - Surveillance of developments at the regional level,
  - Post-program monitoring,
  - Ex post assessments of member countries with longer-term program engagements,
  - General policy matters, unless otherwise decided by the Executive Board.
- The staff report for the 2008 Article IV Consultation on Euro Area Policies is also available.

### Euro Area: Main Economic Indicators (in percent change) — Staff projections
- Demand and Supply
  - Private consumption: 1.3 1.6 1.6 1.8 1.5 1.3 1.1
  - Public consumption: 1.8 1.4 1.5 2.0 2.2 2.1 2.0
  - Gross fixed investment: 1.4 2.4 3.0 5.0 4.3 3.5 1.2
  - Final domestic demand: 1.4 1.7 1.8 2.5 2.3 2.0 1.3
  - Stockbuilding 1/: 0.1 0.2 0.0 0.1 0.0 -0.2 -0.1
  - Domestic Demand: 1.5 2.0 1.9 2.6 2.2 1.7 1.2
  - Foreign balance 1/: -0.7 0.2 -0.2 0.2 0.3 0.0 0.1
  - Exports 2/: 1.2 7.2 4.7 7.9 6.0 5.1 3.8
  - Imports 2/: 3.3 7.0 5.4 7.7 5.2 5.2 3.8
  - Real GDP: 0.8 2.1 1.6 2.8 2.6 1.7 1.2

- Resource Utilization
  - Potential GDP: 2.0 2.0 1.9 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0
  - Output gap: -0.9 -0.8 -1.1 -0.3 0.2 0.0 -0.8
  - Employment: 0.7 0.7 0.9 1.5 1.9 0.9 0.4
  - Unemployment rate 3/: 8.7 8.8 8.6 8.2 7.4 7.3 7.4

- Prices
  - GDP deflator: 2.2 1.9 1.9 1.9 2.2 2.2 1.9
  - Consumer prices: 2.1 2.1 2.2 2.2 2.1 3.4 2.4

- Public Finance 4/
  - General government balance: -3.1 -2.9 -2.6 -1.3 -0.6 -1.0 -1.1
  - General government structural balance: -2.7 -2.4 -2.1 -1.2 -0.8 -1.1 -0.8
  - General government gross debt: 69.3 69.7 70.3 68.6 66.5 65.2 64.4

- Interest Rates
  - Short-term deposit rate: 2.3 2.1 2.3 3.2 4.2 ... ...
  - Long-term government bond yields: 4.0 4.0 3.4 3.9 4.4 ... ...

- Exchange Rates 5/
  - U.S. dollar per euro: 1.13 1.24 1.25 1.26 1.37 1.55 ...
  - Nominal effective rate (2000=100): 117.6 122.0 121.7 122.6 128.9 136.4 ...
  - Real effective rate (2000=100) 6/: 122.3 130.0 129.1 128.8 134.8 142.3 ...

- External Sector 4/ 7/
  - Current account balance: 0.4 0.8 0.2 0.0 0.3 -0.5 -0.6
  - Trade balance 8/: 1.4 1.3 0.6 0.2 0.6 -0.1 -0.2

- Sources and notes included in the original table:
  - Sources: IMF, World Economic Outlook; Eurostat, ECB Monthly Bulletin.
  - 1/ Contribution to growth.
  - 2/ Includes intra-euro area trade.
  - 3/ In percent.
  - 4/ In percent of GDP.
  - 5/ US dollar rate, as of June 23, 2008; nominal and real effective rates, as of May 2008.
  - 6/ Based on normalized unit labor costs.
  - 7/ Based on ECB data, which exclude intra-euro area flows.
  - 8/ Data for goods.

### Statement by Klaus Stein, Executive Director for Germany (on behalf of the Euro Area Authorities) — key points (July 22, 2008)
- Opening
  - Statement reflects the common view of the euro-area Member States and the European Union (EU) in their respective fields of competence.
  - Authorities welcome IMF staff's assessment but note some differing views on issues.

- 10 years of EMU
  - Authorities welcome staff's positive assessment of the first 10 years of EMU.
  - Stability-orientated macroeconomic framework helped maintain stability during turbulent times.
  - Single currency has helped develop Single Market and financial market integration.
  - Euro has established itself as second most important international reserve and investment currency.
  - Authorities agree economic union is not yet fully delivering—output and productivity growth defied expectations—so further structural reforms and addressing economic divergences are needed.

- Short-term economic outlook
  - Global economy is cooling down markedly; euro-area slowdown so far relatively modest.
  - First quarter growth surprised on the upside; moderation expected in second quarter.
  - Survey indicators show deterioration in economic sentiment since peak last summer.
  - Negative commodity and financial market news could affect activity more than expected.
  - Euro-area authorities share IMF analysis that the euro is now clearly on the strong side relative to fundamentals.
  - Outlook depends on financial market stress unfolding and oil price developments.
  - Authorities see tighter financing conditions and higher risk aversion weighing on investment and consumption, and energy price increases weighing on consumption and investment.
  - Authorities concur with staff that uncertainty is high and risks are on the downside.

- Monetary policy and price stability
  - Governing Council of the ECB raised the key ECB interest rate by 25 basis points on July 3 to prevent broad-based second-round effects and counter medium-term risks to price stability.
  - Inflation reached around 4 percent in mid 2008, mainly due to oil and food price increases.
  - Upside risks to price stability include further commodity price rises, possible broad-based second-round effects, nominal wage indexation schemes, unanticipated increases in administered prices and indirect taxes.
  - Monetary analysis shows sustained strength of monetary and credit expansion created upside risks to price stability.
  - Correction in financial markets has not significantly affected availability of bank credit to the private sector so far.
  - ECB action since end-2005 aims to keep long-term inflation expectations anchored in line with price stability.

- Liquidity management
  - ECB continued existing framework for liquidity operations to alleviate euro money market tensions and steer short-term rates.
  - Measures included frontloading liquidity supply, renewing supplementary three-month LTROs, introducing six-month supplementary LTROs in April and July 2008, and conducting term auction facilities in cooperation with US Federal Reserve and other central banks to provide US dollar liquidity (secured with Eurosystem eligible collateral).
  - Broad access to large scale refinancing operations against a wide range of eligible collateral allowed ECB to counter stressed short-term money market conditions without changing the framework.

- Fiscal developments and fiscal policy
  - Authorities share staff assessment of improved budgetary situation in 2007 but note significant challenges ahead.
  - Reformed Stability and Growth Pact (SGP) functioning positively; no euro-area Member State currently subject to excessive deficit procedure.
  - Some countries need more ambitious fiscal consolidation due to insufficient progress toward medium-term objectives during upswing; safety margins vis-à-vis the 3 percent of GDP reference value may be insufficient.
  - Risk of reversal of accrued windfall revenues highlighted; reversal would strain budgets of those not using upturn to improve positions.
  - Authorities confirm strong commitment to reformed SGP; stability-oriented fiscal policies support sustainable fiscal positions and confidence.
  - Member States are developing strategies to improve spending efficiency using performance indicators and medium-term budgetary frameworks.
  - In line with June 2008 ECOFIN and Manchester 2005 ECOFIN principles, tax policy should not be used to limit pass-through of rising energy prices; compensating tax cuts would distort necessary adjustment and risk adding to terms-of-trade loss.
  - Other targeted policies to protect vulnerable groups are likely more effective.

- Financial sector issues
  - Financial stability is a key focus; EU financial-stability arrangements remain largely national-based despite financial integration.
  - Measures taken to adapt arrangements to cross-border financial activity; strengthening Lamfalussy framework and Level-3 Committees to foster supervisory convergence.
  - 2005 EU-wide Memorandum of Understanding between national supervisors, central banks and finance ministries extended from July 1, 2008 — coverage extended to insurance and securities supervisors and content extended to include principles for cross-border crisis management, framework for assessing systemic cross-border crises, and procedural guidelines.
  - Use of colleges of supervisors for cross-border financial groups to be extended.
  - ECOFIN roadmap to enhance EU financial stability arrangements addresses home/host supervisor relations, transfer of assets within groups, criteria for early intervention and reorganization for cross-border financial groups, and deposit guarantee scheme improvements.
  - Reforms are complex, politically sensitive, and will require strong political leadership and commitment.

- Structural reform
  - Lisbon Strategy is the basis for steering reform in the euro area and individual countries.
  - Recommendations and country-specific recommendations within Integrated Guidelines of the Lisbon Strategy coordinate structural reforms.
  - Assessments show substantive structural reforms, but urgent challenges remain including public finance sustainability and increasing competition in product, services and labor markets.
  - Authorities agree National Reform Programs should pay more attention to euro area recommendations to facilitate economic adjustment in the monetary union.
  - Concerns about intra-area divergences; broadened and deepened internal surveillance would help identify macroeconomic imbalances and competitiveness trends early.
  - Important to provide incentives for national structural reforms and enhance synergies between fiscal policies and structural reforms.

### International issues and trade policy
- EU will continue to strive for a comprehensive, ambitious and balanced conclusion of the Doha Round.
  - EU representatives are "cautiously hopeful" that an agreement can be reached this year.
  - EU believes successful conclusion would support global growth in the longer term.
  - Successful negotiations require other participants to be forthcoming and constructive.

- Parallel trade negotiations
  - EU pursuing free trade agreement negotiations with India, Korea, Latin America and the ASEAN countries, and regional partnerships with African, Caribbean and Pacific countries.
  - These agreements complement multilateral trade liberalization and are viewed as stepping stones to further trade integration.

- Food prices and agricultural policy
  - Food prices are a major worldwide concern; EU launched initiatives addressing challenges for Member States and other countries.
  - European Council endorsed short- and long-term policy responses:
    - Short term: mobilize resources for humanitarian aid to developing countries, examine competitiveness in EU food supply chain, and examine role of speculation in recent price developments.
    - Long term: promote sustainable production of biofuels and sustainable productivity growth in agriculture; undertake a review of the Common Agricultural Policy phasing out restrictions to production, making European farmers more responsive to price signals and strengthening food security; enhance support to investments in agriculture in developing countries.
  - EU aims to lift barriers to international trade by targeting development aid, ensuring market incentives for supply response, and discouraging export taxes so consumers and producers better respond to price signals and market developments.

*Statement by Klaus Stein, Executive Director for Germany, on behalf of the Euro Area Authorities (July 22, 2008).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08262.pdf_
