## _cr08315

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr08315](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08315.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08315.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08315.pdf.json)

---

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
- Dissolution agreement: promised fiscal discipline and debt relief, boosting investor confidence and growth.
- Constitutional changes rescheduled for January 2010.
- New fiscal framework: already in place in the BES islands (Bonaire, St. Eustatius, and Saba) and due to start in 2009 in Curaçao and St. Maarten.
- Authorities advancing reform proposals on tax policy, labor markets, public enterprise finances, pensions, and healthcare.
- Key elements of the dissolution agreement:
  - Debt cancellation of about 80 percent of total public debt as of December 31, 2005 by the Netherlands; details of coverage, schedule, and modality remain to be finalized.
  - Conditionality of debt relief on establishment of a fiscal framework for each island, including:
    - Introduction of medium-term budgeting.
    - Establishment of a fiscal supervisor (chaired by a Dutch appointee).
    - A balanced current budget rule with borrowing restricted to within-year cash management needs; deviations allowed only in case of a disaster, with disaster relief subject to fiscal supervisor approval.
    - Borrowing caps for capital expenditure, limiting annual interest payments to five percent of the average total revenue of the preceding three years.
  - A common central bank for Curaçao and St. Maarten responsible for monetary policy and financial sector supervision.
  - A socio-economic initiative (SEI).

### RECENT ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENTS AND MACRO OUTLOOK
- Growth and labor market:
  - Real GDP growth: 3.8 percent in 2007; preliminary indications point to continued momentum in 2008.
  - Growth estimated at about 3 percent in 2008.
  - Staff medium-term growth projection: 2½ percent by 2011.
- Inflation:
  - Inflation historically low, but jumped in 2008 due to elimination of implicit oil subsidies and full pass-through of energy price increases.
  - Inflation reached 4.2 percent in Curaçao in May 2008.
  - Staff and authorities project inflation to reach 5 percent by end-2008, then converge to U.S. levels.
- Current account and reserves:
  - Current account deficit widened sharply to 16 percent of GDP in 2007, driven by FDI related to large hotel projects and import surges.
  - The large current account deficit was more than financed by FDI, increased Dutch aid, and private sector trade credits.
  - Reserve coverage improved, fully covering short-term liabilities; expected to remain sufficient at 3½ months of imports.
- External debt and vulnerability:
  - External debt is moderate and expected to fall further after debt relief.
  - External debt projections robust to shocks (see bound tests referenced in the source).

### FISCAL DEVELOPMENTS AND PROJECTIONS
- Government finances and public debt:
  - Public debt remained close to 80 percent of GDP ahead of debt relief.
  - The current budget balance was held at 2⅓ percent of GDP during 2005–07.
  - Government retrenched finances through 2007 mainly via spending controls; interest payments kept total spending high.
- Fiscal table (In percent of GDP) — 2007 and 2008 (without debt relief):
  - Total revenue: 23.7 (2007); 23.9 (2008)
  - Total expenditure: 26.3 (2007); 27.6 (2008)
  - Capital expenditure: 0.3 (2007); 1.8 (2008)
  - Current expenditure: 26.0 (2007); 25.8 (2008)
  - Non-interest payments: 21.1 (2007); 21.1 (2008)
  - Interest payments: 4.9 (2007); 4.7 (2008)
  - Overall deficit: -2.6 (2007); -3.7 (2008)
  - Primary balance: 2.3 (2007); 1.0 (2008)
  - Current balance: -2.3 (2007); -1.9 (2008)
  - Current primary balance: 2.6 (2007); 2.8 (2008)
- 2008 fiscal outlook:
  - 2008 current budget deficit expected to decline despite delay in debt relief, due to higher revenues from stronger growth, larger dividends from enterprises, and improved tax collection.
  - Delay in debt relief adds an additional 3½ percent of GDP to expenditures.
  - Aid-financed investment cofinancing (decided when debt relief was expected in 2008) will widen the overall deficit sharply, to some 3¾ percent of GDP.

### FINANCIAL SECTOR AND MONETARY POLICY
- Monetary policy and liquidity:
  - Bank of the Netherlands Antilles (BNA) tightened monetary policy by raising reserve requirements from 12¼ to 13¼ percent since 2005 to mop up excess liquidity.
  - Credit to the private sector grew 12 percent year-on-year in May 2008.
  - BNA has exceeded its target for reserve coverage (three months of imports).
- Financial soundness:
  - Financial sector broadly healthy; adequate capitalization and profitability; nonperforming loans moderate though increased recently.
  - Banking sector assets concentrated in the top two banks; competition from smaller banks compressed lending spreads modestly.
  - International financial sector assets have begun to recover after earlier market share losses.
  - Neither domestic nor international financial sectors affected by global financial turbulence.
  - Supervision and AML/CFT efforts strengthened (Informational Annex I).

### MAIN CHALLENGES AND VULNERABILITIES
- Immediate challenge: complete the transition phase expeditiously by finalizing important details, including terms of debt relief.
- Ongoing constraints:
  - Limited macro policy tools: exchange rate peg constrains monetary policy; fiscal rule will largely eliminate discretionary fiscal policy.
  - Strain on public finances from ageing-related entitlement costs.
  - Managing liquidity injection from debt relief and its impact on financial sector balance sheets.
  - Maintaining external viability and the peg through improved competitiveness and investor confidence.
  - Labor market constraints: freedom to migrate to the Netherlands contributes to downward inflexibility in wages; high wages and structural unemployment impede cost competitiveness.
  - Small economy size limits scope for diversification and improving cost competitiveness via large-scale immigration.

### STAFF VIEWS AND POLICY PRIORITIES
- Growth outlook:
  - Staff expects growth to stay strong in 2008 and over the medium term, provided investor confidence is preserved.
  - Growth drivers include imported monetary easing and ongoing investments in infrastructure, housing, and tourism.
- Policy priorities and recommendations:
  - Implementation of planned reforms is key to preserving investor confidence.
  - Pension reforms (including raising the retirement age) and healthcare cost controls would help ensure fiscal sustainability.
  - The liquidity injection from debt relief should be managed judiciously, including through a phased reduction in capital controls.
- Authorities’ views:
  - Authorities broadly agreed with staff; several measures already taken.
  - Pension reform (raising the retirement age) and labor market reform expected to be particularly challenging.

### COMPETITIVENESS, EXCHANGE RATE, AND INSTITUTIONAL CONSIDERATIONS
- Competitiveness and REER:
  - Low inflation and a sharp depreciation vis-à-vis the euro (by virtue of the dollar peg) have implied a significant depreciation of the CPI-based real effective exchange rate (REER).
  - Estimated equilibrium REER has fallen since the beginning of the decade owing to reductions in government consumption and the terms of trade.
  - Actual REER appears broadly in line with fundamentals (3 percentage points from its estimated equilibrium rate in the past four years).
  - If planned reforms are implemented, recent gains in market share for goods exports and tourism relative to Caribbean competitors should hold up.
  - Sectoral notes: tourism has become more competitive; market share of goods exports held up since 2003 notwithstanding a one-off shock in 2007; a large increase in low-skilled immigrant labor has lowered average wages.
- Exchange rate regime:
  - Long-standing peg to the U.S. dollar remains viable given small economy size and strong ties with the U.S.
  - Staff supported St. Maarten’s decision to continue its currency union with Curaçao; creation of a separate central bank would entail high costs relative to benefits.
  - Staff urged that changes to the BNA’s charter not undermine its political independence.

### FISCAL SUSTAINABILITY, TAX AND ENTITLEMENT REFORMS
- Fiscal rule implementation:
  - Balanced budget rule and fiscal supervision will start in 2009; successful implementation is key.
  - Annual deficit-cum-debt limits designed to constrain fiscal policy and preserve benefits of debt forgiveness.
- Tax policy and revenue measures (preliminary):
  - Authorities intend revenue-neutral rebalancing with lower direct tax rates and higher indirect tax rates.
  - Convert the turnover tax into a “VAT” by eliminating cascading.
  - Improve collections by upgrading databases, simplifying procedures and rationalizing tax rates.
  - Improve public enterprise finances via automatic tariff adjustments and better oversight.
- Tax-change details (initial proposals):
  - Cut personal and corporate income tax rates by some 5−8 percent and 8−10 percent respectively.
  - Increase the turnover tax from 5 to 12 percent.
- Entitlement and expenditure pressures:
  - Interest savings from debt relief—some 3½ percent of GDP per year—could be fully saved and would be more than sufficient to bring the current budget deficit of 2008 into balance from 2009 onwards if fully realized.
  - Absent reform, additional spending pressures starting 2009 include:
    - APNA pension premium payments set to increase due to inflation indexation.
    - Need for effectively targeted social transfers to mitigate impact of food and fuel price increases and indirect taxes.
    - Without entitlement reforms, SVB is set to face rising deficits due to increasing healthcare costs and pension payments to an ageing population; these must be met through budget transfers of some ½ percent of GDP per year during 2009–11.
  - Together, these new spending pressures would absorb debt relief-induced interest savings and require current budget surpluses of some ½ percent of GDP to be set aside every year as transfers to SVB.
- Expenditure-saving measures:
  - Authorities’ preliminary plans entail sharp real cuts in all categories of current primary spending, mainly through rationalization and greater oversight of subsidies.
  - Further civil service downsizing considered difficult; additional savings may require rationalizing the civil service and limiting wage increases to productivity growth.
  - Pension reform recommendations: raise retirement age to 65; for SVB, eliminate the regressive income ceiling for social contributions; make inflation indexation conditional on asset-liability coverage ratio; change pension base to average salary.
  - Staff stressed improving pension funds’ ability to earn higher returns by gradually easing investment restrictions without undue risk.

### PUBLIC DEBT SUSTAINABILITY AND SCENARIOS
- Public debt sustainability analysis uses bound tests with permanent one-half standard deviation shocks and combined shocks; scenarios include:
  - Growth shock.
  - Primary balance shock.
  - Interest rate shock.
  - Contingent liabilities shock and real depreciation shock: one-time real depreciation of 30 percent and 10 percent of GDP shock to contingent liabilities occur in 2009 (real depreciation defined as nominal depreciation minus domestic inflation).
- Figures in the analysis present average projections for baseline and scenarios, and ten-year historical averages; shaded areas represent actual data (as per source).

### FINANCIAL SECTOR IMPLICATIONS OF DEBT RELIEF AND POLICY RESPONSES
- Debt relief mechanics and liquidity risk:
  - Debt relief likely via government security buybacks funded by the Netherlands could flood the economy with liquidity beyond absorption capacity while the fiscal rule limits new government securities issuance.
- “60:40” rule for institutional investors:
  - Rule: local institutional investors are required to domestically invest 40 and 50 percent, respectively, of the first and second NAf. 10 million of their reserves and debts, and 60 percent of the remainder.
  - In 2006 the rule was partly relaxed, with deviations allowed but subject to a penalty (5.9 percent at end-2007).
- BNA and staff recommendations:
  - Reach agreement with the Dutch government on a sufficiently gradual schedule of debt relief payments to avoid excess liquidity.
  - Some tightening of monetary policy instruments may be appropriate, although scope is limited (reserve requirements already high and large-scale sterilization cost-prohibitive).
  - Gradually phase out the “60:40” investment rule for institutional investors; phased removal of capital controls recommended rather than abrupt removal.
- Risks and trade-offs:
  - Rapid removal of controls could generate macroeconomic imbalances.
  - Forcing institutional investors to invest large liquidity amounts locally would drive down domestic interest rates and endanger balance sheets.
  - Developing alternative domestic assets may take time and may not match institutional investors’ size and risk-return needs.
  - Banks could invest additional liquidity abroad or on-lend domestically, potentially increasing risk-taking, pressuring bank balance sheets, and fueling asset-price and import booms.
- Supervisory arrangements:
  - Financial institutions’ profit margins likely to come under pressure as risk-free investment opportunities disappear.
  - BNA considers risks more acute in smaller banks; vesting supervisory powers in the BNA post-dissolution was welcomed.

### STRUCTURAL REFORMS, LABOR MARKET, AND INSTITUTIONS
- With fiscal and monetary policy constrained, structural reforms are the chief instrument for boosting competitiveness and preserving investor confidence.
- Draft tripartite protocol and socio-economic initiative indicate support for productivity-enhancing reforms.
- Taxation:
  - Direct tax rates are high by regional standards; burden borne disproportionately by largest firms and workers.
  - Competitiveness should be considered when setting direct tax rates and streamlining procedures.
  - International financial sector representatives emphasized importance of double taxation agreements.
- Labor market reform:
  - Draft tripartite protocol emphasizes “flexicurity,” easing dismissal and work permit regulations while emphasizing training and measures to encourage labor force participation.
  - Business communities indicated willingness to accommodate labor cost increases if offset by flexibility in other areas.
- Institutional recommendations:
  - Curaçao and St. Maarten should keep agency costs down by exploiting economies of scale where possible when sharing or duplicating institutions post-dissolution.

### STATISTICAL COMPILATION, DISSEMINATION, AND KEY STATISTICS
- Statistical compilation and dissemination:
  - Improvements made (Informational Annex I), but scope remains to shorten lags and improve dissemination.
  - Production of additional core statistical indicators stalled for want of funding.
  - Earlier dissemination of preliminary financial sector data would be helpful.
  - BNA plans to automate and accelerate reporting by institutional investors.
  - Decision on producing statistics for St. Maarten after dissolution should account for overhead costs and time required to form a separate statistics agency.
- Key statistics and projections (selected exact figures preserved):
  - Population (2004): 180,870
  - Percent of population below age 15 (2005): 24.2
  - Percent of population aged 65+ (2005): 8.5
  - Literacy rate, in percent (2003): 96.7
  - Infant mortality, over 1,000 live births (2004): 10.0
  - Life expectancy at birth (2005): 75.8
  - Real GDP growth rates: 2003: 1/1.7; 2004: 1.2; 2005: 1.3; 2006: 2.4; 2007: 3.8
  - Unemployment rate (in percent): 2003: 15.3; 2004: 15.1; 2005: 16.2; 2006: 13.2; 2007: 11.1
  - General government finances (in percent of GDP): Revenue (2007): 24.1; Expenditure (2007): 26.3; Primary balance (2007): 2.3; Overall balance (2007): -2.6; Public debt (2007): 80.6
  - Balance of payments and reserves: Current account (2007): -16.1 (in percent of GDP); Reserves (in millions of U.S. dollars, end-2007): 905.4; Reserves (in months of next year’s imports of goods, 2007): 4.0
  - Financial sector indicators (2007): Capital/adjusted-asset ratio: 14.4; Nonperforming loans (in percent of total loans): 4.6; Return on assets (before taxes and dividends): 1.8; Loan-to-deposit ratio: 61.4; Total assets to total liabilities: 153.4
  - Medium-term projections (selected):
    - Real GDP projection: 2008: 3.2; 2009: 2.9; 2010: 2.7; 2011: 2.5
    - Overall balance (percent of GDP) projections: 2008: -3.7; 2009: -0.5; 2010: -0.3; 2011: -0.1
    - Public debt projections (percent of GDP): 2008: 76.8; 2009: 21.4; 2010: 19.1; 2011: 16.5
    - Reserves (in millions of U.S. dollars): 2008: 969.6; 2009: 967.7; 2010: 1,012.2; 2011: 1,064.1
  - Fiscal operations (selected, in percent of GDP): Total revenue (2007): 24.1; Tax revenue (2007): 21.4; Total expenditure (2007): 26.3; Wages and salaries (2007): 9.2; Interest payments (2007): 4.9; Capital expenditure (2007): 0.3

### FUND RELATIONS, MISSION, AND EXECUTIVE BOARD ASSESSMENT
- 2008 Article IV consultation mission: team visited June 19–30, 2008 (team composition detailed in source).
- The Netherlands Antilles does not have a separate quota or other financial relations with the Fund.
- Implementation of Fund recommendations (highlights):
  - Fiscal consolidation through 2007 based on cuts in primary spending.
  - Fiscal framework agreed in context of dissolution agreement; implementation scheduled to begin in 2009.
  - Monetary policy: peg to the U.S. dollar maintained; role of indirect instruments strengthened.
  - Financial sector: supervision to remain centralized; efforts to strengthen AML/CFT framework and harmonize supervision; draft law pending to allow central bank to impose fines.
  - Structural reforms: productivity-enhancing reforms pending; key steps for public enterprise governance and utility regulation scheduled for fall 2008.
  - Statistics: business cycle survey introduced; short-term indicators developed; plans to improve dissemination underway.
- Executive Board main assessments and recommendations:
  - Welcome to resurgence of economic growth; encouragement to use debt relief to set budget and economy on a sustainable footing.
  - Peg broadly in line with fundamentals; medium-term current account deficit appears manageable.
  - Fiscal policy recommendations: broaden tax base and rebalance tax burden; targeted income subsidies to protect poorest households; additional expenditure savings via entitlement reforms, civil service rationalization, wage restraint, and further pension reform.
  - Financial sector recommendations: seek gradual schedule of debt relief to avoid excess liquidity; tighten monetary policy where appropriate; ease capital controls gradually; central bank to monitor lending standards closely.
  - Structural reform advice: implement draft tripartite protocol and complementary reforms as a package.

*Source: _cr08315 — Staff Report for the 2008 Article IV Consultation and Informational Annex (as provided).*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### _cr08315 - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Background and implementation of the dissolution agreement
- Dissolution agreement promised fiscal discipline and debt relief, boosting investor confidence and growth.
- Constitutional changes rescheduled for January 2010.
- New fiscal framework already in place in the BES islands (Bonaire, St. Eustatius, and Saba) and due to start in 2009 in Curaçao and St. Maarten.
- Authorities advancing reform proposals on tax policy, labor markets, public enterprise finances, pensions, and healthcare.
- Key elements of the dissolution agreement include:
  - Debt cancellation of about 80 percent of total public debt as of December 31, 2005 by the Netherlands; details of coverage, schedule, and modality remain to be finalized.
  - Conditionality of debt relief on establishment of a fiscal framework for each island, including:
    - Introduction of medium-term budgeting.
    - Establishment of a fiscal supervisor (chaired by a Dutch appointee).
    - A balanced current budget rule with borrowing restricted to within-year cash management needs; deviations allowed only in case of a disaster, with disaster relief subject to fiscal supervisor approval.
    - Borrowing caps for capital expenditure, limiting annual interest payments to five percent of the average total revenue of the preceding three years.
  - A common central bank for Curaçao and St. Maarten responsible for monetary policy and financial sector supervision.
  - A socio-economic initiative (SEI).

### Recent economic developments and macro outlook
- Growth and labor market:
  - Real GDP growth accelerated sharply in 2007 to 3.8 percent, driven by investments in infrastructure, housing, and tourism and increased private consumption.
  - Preliminary indications point to continued growth momentum in 2008.
  - Growth estimated at about 3 percent in 2008.
  - Staff medium-term growth projection: 2½ percent by 2011.
- Inflation:
  - Inflation historically low, but jumped in 2008 due to elimination of implicit oil subsidies and full pass-through of energy price increases.
  - Inflation reached 4.2 percent in Curaçao in May 2008.
  - Staff and authorities project inflation to reach 5 percent by end-2008, then converge to U.S. levels.
- Current account and reserves:
  - Current account deficit widened sharply to 16 percent of GDP in 2007, driven by FDI related to large hotel projects and import surges.
  - The large current account deficit was more than financed by FDI, increased Dutch aid, and private sector trade credits.
  - Reserve coverage improved, fully covering short-term liabilities; expected to remain sufficient at 3½ months of imports.
- External debt and vulnerability:
  - External debt is moderate and expected to fall further after debt relief.
  - External debt projections are robust to shocks (see bound tests in Figure 3).

### Fiscal developments and projections
- Government finances and public debt:
  - Public debt remained close to 80 percent of GDP ahead of debt relief.
  - The current budget balance was held at 2⅓ percent of GDP during 2005–07.
  - Government retrenched finances through 2007 mainly via spending controls; interest payments kept total spending high.
- Fiscal table (In percent of GDP) — 2007 and 2008 (without debt relief)
  - Total revenue: 23.7 (2007); 23.9 (2008)
  - Total expenditure: 26.3 (2007); 27.6 (2008)
  - Capital expenditure: 0.3 (2007); 1.8 (2008)
  - Current expenditure: 26.0 (2007); 25.8 (2008)
  - Non-interest payments: 21.1 (2007); 21.1 (2008)
  - Interest payments: 4.9 (2007); 4.7 (2008)
  - Overall deficit: -2.6 (2007); -3.7 (2008)
  - Primary balance: 2.3 (2007); 1.0 (2008)
  - Current balance: -2.3 (2007); -1.9 (2008)
  - Current primary balance: 2.6 (2007); 2.8 (2008)
- 2008 fiscal outlook:
  - 2008 current budget deficit expected to decline despite delay in debt relief, due to higher revenues from stronger growth, larger dividends from enterprises, and improved tax collection.
  - Delay in debt relief adds an additional 3½ percent of GDP to expenditures.
  - Aid-financed investment cofinancing (decided when debt relief was expected in 2008) will widen the overall deficit sharply, to some 3¾ percent of GDP.

### Financial sector and monetary policy
- Monetary policy and liquidity:
  - Bank of the Netherlands Antilles (BNA) tightened monetary policy by raising reserve requirements from 12¼ to 13¼ percent since 2005 to mop up excess liquidity.
  - Credit to the private sector grew 12 percent year-on-year in May 2008.
  - BNA has exceeded its target for reserve coverage (three months of imports).
- Financial soundness:
  - Financial sector broadly healthy and compares favorably with the region.
  - Adequate capitalization and profitability; nonperforming loans moderate by Caribbean standards though increased recently.
  - Banking sector assets concentrated in the top two banks; competition from smaller banks has compressed lending spreads modestly.
  - International financial sector assets have begun to recover after earlier market share losses.
  - Neither domestic nor international financial sectors affected by global financial turbulence.
  - Supervision and AML/CFT efforts strengthened (Informational Annex I).

### Main challenges and vulnerabilities
- Key immediate challenge: complete the transition phase expeditiously by finalizing important details, including terms of debt relief.
- Ongoing challenges:
  - Economic management constrained by limited macro policy tools: exchange rate peg constrains monetary policy; fiscal rule will largely eliminate discretionary fiscal policy.
  - Strain on public finances from ageing-related entitlement costs.
  - Managing the liquidity injection from debt relief and its impact on financial sector balance sheets.
  - Maintaining external viability and the peg through improved competitiveness and investor confidence.
  - Labor market constraints: freedom to migrate to the Netherlands contributes to downward inflexibility in wages in key sectors; high wages and structural unemployment impede cost competitiveness.
  - Small economy size limits scope for diversification and improving cost competitiveness via large-scale immigration.

### Staff views and policy priorities
- Growth outlook:
  - Staff expects growth to stay strong in 2008 and over the medium term, provided investor confidence is preserved.
  - Growth drivers include imported monetary easing and ongoing investments in infrastructure, housing, and tourism.
- Policy priorities and recommendations:
  - Implementation of planned reforms is key to preserving investor confidence.
  - Pension reforms (including raising the retirement age) and healthcare cost controls would help ensure fiscal sustainability.
  - The liquidity injection from debt relief should be managed judiciously, including through a phased reduction in capital controls.
- Authorities’ views:
  - Authorities broadly agreed with staff; several measures already taken.
  - Pension reform (raising the retirement age) and labor market reform expected to be particularly challenging.

*Source: _cr08315 - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY*

### 13.      Provided reforms are implemented, the improvement in various competitiveness

### _cr08315 - 13.      Provided reforms are implemented, the improvement in various competitiveness

### Competitiveness and real exchange rate
- Low inflation and a sharp depreciation vis-à-vis the euro (by virtue of the dollar peg) have implied a significant depreciation of the CPI-based real effective exchange rate (REER).
- The estimated equilibrium REER has fallen since the beginning of the decade owing to reductions in government consumption and the terms of trade.
- The actual REER appears to be broadly in line with fundamentals (3 percentage points from its estimated equilibrium rate in the past four years).
- If planned reforms are implemented, recent gains in market share for goods exports, and tourism market shares relative to Caribbean competitors, should hold up.
- Observed sectoral developments:
  - The tourism sector has become more competitive.
  - Market share of goods exports has held up since 2003, notwithstanding a one-off shock in 2007.
  - A large increase in low-skilled immigrant labor has lowered average wages.

### Exchange rate regime and institutional considerations
- The long-standing peg to the U.S. dollar remains viable given the economy’s small size and strong economic and commercial ties with the U.S.
- Authorities view the peg as a durable and effective nominal anchor, instrumental in keeping inflation and inflationary expectations low, and fostering trade and investment by allowing long-term investment planning.
- Maintenance of a nominal peg is consistent with policies in similarly situated competitor countries.
- Staff supported St. Maarten’s decision to continue its currency union with Curaçao; creation of a separate central bank would entail high costs relative to seigniorage and monetary policy benefits.
- Staff urged that changes to the BNA’s charter not undermine its political independence.

### Fiscal sustainability and fiscal rule implementation
- The balanced budget rule and fiscal supervision will start in 2009; implementation will be key.
- The annual deficit-cum-debt limits are designed to constrain fiscal policy and ensure benefits of debt forgiveness are not undercut by new public borrowing.
- The fiscal rule may be more successful given the merger of different layers of government and a reduced expectation of future bailouts.
- Authorities view Dutch government participation in the supervisory body and escalation channels to the Kingdom of Netherlands as important deterrents to fiscal slippage.
- Staff stressed ensuring proper accountability and insulating the supervisory body from political pressure.

### Fiscal policy trade-offs, revenues, and spending pressures
- Fiscal policy must balance preserving competitiveness and remaining sustainable within the fiscal rule constraints; competitiveness argues for lower tax, wage, and social contribution rates relative to competitors, yet wages, pensions, and safety nets must remain competitive with the Netherlands.
- Public debt will be sustainable post-debt relief (see public debt sustainability analysis).
- Preliminary balanced budget plans for 2009-11 assume revenue-neutral tax policy changes:
  - Authorities intend to broaden the tax base through revenue-neutral rebalancing with lower direct tax rates4 and higher indirect tax rates.
  - Convert the turnover tax into a “VAT” by eliminating cascading.
  - Continue improving collections by upgrading databases, simplifying procedures and rationalizing tax rates.5
  - Improve public enterprise finances by introducing automatic adjustment of tariffs and better oversight of balance sheets.
- Tax-change details (initial proposals):
  - Cut personal and corporate income tax rates by some 5−8 percent and 8−10 percent respectively.
  - Increase the turnover tax from 5 to 12 percent.
- Tax revenues could be further bolstered after the eventual privatization of the state-owned oil refinery.

- On spending, additional measures would be required to balance the current budget:
  - Interest savings from debt relief—some 3½ percent of GDP per year—could be fully saved and would be more than sufficient to bring the current budget deficit of 2008 into balance from 2009 onwards if fully realized.
  - Absent reform, additional spending pressures starting 2009 include:
    - APNA pension premium payments set to increase due to inflation indexation.
    - Need for effectively targeted social transfers to mitigate impact of food and fuel price increases and indirect taxes.
    - Without entitlement reforms, SVB is set to face rising deficits due to increasing healthcare costs and pension payments to an ageing population; these must be met through budget transfers of some ½ percent of GDP per year during 2009–11.
  - Together, these new spending pressures would absorb debt relief-induced interest savings and require current budget surpluses of some ½ percent of GDP to be set aside every year as transfers to SVB.

### Expenditure-saving measures and entitlement reforms
- Authorities’ preliminary plans entail sharp real cuts in all categories of current primary spending, mainly through rationalization and greater oversight of subsidies.
- Further civil service downsizing was considered difficult given past cuts and lack of streamlined work processes; staff noted additional savings may require rationalizing the civil service and limiting wage increases to productivity growth.
- Entitlement reform progress and recommendations:
  - Recent actions to control healthcare costs and reform APNA are welcomed: making inflation indexation conditional on the asset-liability coverage ratio, and changing the pension base to the average salary.
  - Staff urged completion of remaining reforms under consideration, namely raising the retirement age to 65 and, for SVB, eliminating the regressive income ceiling for social contributions.
  - These reforms would bring pension parameters in line with those in the Netherlands and could create room for future reduction in contribution rates and pension premiums.
  - Staff stressed improving pension funds’ ability to earn higher returns by gradually easing investment restrictions without undue risk.

### Public debt sustainability (scenarios and shocks)
- Public debt sustainability analysis uses bound tests with permanent one-half standard deviation shocks and combined shocks; scenarios considered include:
  - Growth shock.
  - Primary balance shock.
  - Interest rate shock.
  - Contingent liabilities shock and real depreciation shock: one-time real depreciation of 30 percent and 10 percent of GDP shock to contingent liabilities occur in 2009, with real depreciation defined as nominal depreciation minus domestic inflation.
- Figures in the analysis present average projections for baseline and scenarios, and ten-year historical averages; shaded areas represent actual data.

### Financial sector development and stability
- Debt relief likely in the form of government security buybacks funded by the Netherlands could flood the economy with liquidity beyond its absorption capacity while the fiscal rule limits new government securities issuance.
- Main holders of existing government securities are local institutional investors, subject to the “60:40” rule.
  - The “60:40” rule: local institutional investors are required to domestically invest 40 and 50 percent, respectively, of the first and second NAf. 10 million of their reserves and debts, and 60 percent of the remainder.
  - In 2006, the rule was partly relaxed, with deviations allowed but subject to a penalty (5.9 percent at end-2007).
- BNA responses and proposals adopted by staff:
  - Reach agreement with the Dutch government on a sufficiently gradual schedule of debt relief payments to avoid excess liquidity.
  - Some tightening of monetary policy instruments may be appropriate, although scope is limited since reserve requirements are already quite high and conventional sterilization on a large scale would be cost-prohibitive and hurt the BNA’s balance sheet and the budget.
  - Gradually phase out the “60:40” investment rule for institutional investors; phased removal of capital controls to accommodate liquidity impact recommended rather than abrupt removal.
- Risks and trade-offs:
  - Rapid removal of controls could generate macroeconomic imbalances in an economy used to captive funding sources.
  - Forcing institutional investors to invest large liquidity amounts locally would drive down domestic interest rates and endanger balance sheets.
  - Developing alternative domestic assets may take time and may not match institutional investors’ size and risk-return needs.
  - Banks could invest additional liquidity abroad or on-lend domestically, potentially increasing risk-taking, pressuring bank balance sheets, and fueling asset-price and import booms.
- Phased removal of capital controls would foster financial sector competition, improve operational efficiency, and diversify income sources; greater financial integration with Caribbean countries and consolidation of smaller banks would aid this process.
- Supervisory arrangements:
  - Financial institutions’ profit margins likely to come under pressure as risk-free investment opportunities disappear.
  - BNA considered the risks more acute in smaller banks; vesting supervisory powers in the BNA post-dissolution was welcomed given its expertise.

### Structural reforms and labor/tax policy
- With fiscal and monetary policy locked in, structural reforms are the chief instrument for boosting competitiveness and preserving investor confidence.
- The draft tripartite protocol (labor, government, businesses) and the social economic initiative indicate strong support for wide-ranging productivity-enhancing reforms.
- Taxation:
  - Direct tax rates are high by regional standards, with the burden borne disproportionately by the largest firms and workers, deterring foreign investors and skilled labor.
  - Competitiveness considerations should be taken into account when setting direct tax rates and streamlining procedures.
  - Representatives of the international financial sector stressed the importance of double taxation agreements.
- Labor market reform:
  - The draft tripartite protocol emphasizes “flexicurity,” easing dismissal and work permit regulations while emphasizing training and measures to encourage labor force participation.
  - Business communities indicated willingness to accommodate labor cost increases (e.g., planned minimum wage hike) if offset by flexibility in other areas.
- Institutional recommendations:
  - When determining institutions and regulatory bodies to share or duplicate post-dissolution, Curaçao and St. Maarten authorities should keep agency costs down by exploiting economies of scale where possible.

*Source: _cr08315 - 13.*

### 28.      While improvements have been made in compilation (Informational Annex I),

### _cr08315 - 28.      While improvements have been made in compilation (Informational Annex I),

### Statistical compilation and dissemination
- Improvements have been made in compilation (Informational Annex I), but scope remains to:
  - Shorten the lag in producing statistics.
  - Improve dissemination.
- The production of additional core statistical indicators remains stalled for want of funding.
- Earlier dissemination of preliminary financial sector data would be helpful.
- The BNA’s plans to automate and accelerate the frequency of reporting by institutional investors are welcome.
- The pending decision on how to produce statistics for St. Maarten after dissolution should account for the large overhead costs and time required to form a separate statistics agency.

### Staff appraisal — constitutional changes, opportunities, and priorities (paras. 29–36)
- Prospective dissolution of the Netherlands Antilles poses both opportunities and challenges:
  - A large write-down of public debt provides a unique opportunity to put the budget and the economy on a sustainable footing once for all.
  - The push to enact reforms should proceed expeditiously.
  - Priority: complete the transition to the new economic structure by clarifying unresolved issues (notably debt relief and post-dissolution institutional structures).
- Growth and external policy:
  - Balanced growth should continue provided investor confidence—instigated by prospective fiscal discipline and debt relief—can be maintained.
  - Medium-term growth will likely moderate from its current pace but is expected to remain above historical norms as export markets recover and fiscal tightening promotes private sector crowding-in.
  - With medium-term current account deficits expected to be manageable and given recent improvements in competitiveness indicators, the dollar peg remains appropriate.
- Fiscal framework and governance:
  - Conditions are favorable for introducing a balanced-budget rule; implementation will be key.
  - Envisaged measures to underpin the fiscal framework are reassuring.
  - Proper accountability and insulation of the fiscal supervisory body from political pressure are necessary.
- Fiscal consolidation and expenditure policy:
  - Additional expenditure savings will be needed to achieve balanced budgets from 2009, including by completing entitlement reforms.
  - Plans to sustain revenues—by broadening the tax base, rebalancing the tax burden, and improving collections—are appropriate.
  - Expenditure savings must go beyond proposed cost-containment measures to make room for targeted income subsidies to the poor (to mitigate higher oil and food prices and indirect taxes) and to address rising entitlement costs absent reform.
  - Recent steps to control healthcare costs and reform the pension system should partly alleviate strains on public finances.
  - Additional savings should come from civil service rationalization, wage restraint, and further pension reforms (raising the retirement age and changing regressive contribution thresholds).
- Managing debt relief and financial sector implications:
  - Managing the impact of debt relief on financial sector balance sheets will be crucial.
  - The BNA endorses a three-part policy response:
    - Seek agreement with the Dutch government on a more graduated schedule of debt relief to avoid excess liquidity.
    - Some monetary tightening.
    - Gradual easing of capital controls on institutional investors.
  - Gradual easing of capital controls will allow institutional investors to earn higher returns, easing the fiscal burden and improving financial sector competition on the funding side.
- Financial sector risks and supervision:
  - The financial sector is broadly healthy, but institutions and supervisors must be vigilant in a more difficult environment.
  - The BNA will need to guard against deterioration in lending standards as financial institutions undertake more risky lending to preserve profitability when faced with:
    - A gradual reduction in risk-free government securities.
    - A decline in interest rates due to excess liquidity.
- Structural reforms and competitiveness:
  - Given limited macro policy tools, implementation of structural reforms is key to preserving investor confidence and external competitiveness.
  - Pro-competitive tax and labor market policies are vital.
  - In setting tax rates (which—for direct taxes—are high by regional standards), the authorities should ensure revenue neutrality and business competitiveness.
  - The draft tripartite protocol proposes a broad spectrum of reforms; implementing the package as a whole would reap maximum benefits and foster buy-in.
- Fund engagement:
  - Next Article IV consultation is expected on a 24-month cycle.
  - If constitutional changes and dissolution occur within this 24-month period, the Fund’s modalities of engagement will be revisited in consultation with the authorities concerned.

### Key statistics and projections (selected exact figures preserved)
- Population (2004): 180,870
- Percent of population below age 15 (2005): 24.2
- Percent of population aged 65+ (2005): 8.5
- Literacy rate, in percent (2003): 96.7
- Infant mortality, over 1,000 live births (2004): 10.0
- Life expectancy at birth (2005): 75.8
- Real GDP growth rates:
  - 2003: 1/1.7
  - 2004: 1.2
  - 2005: 1.3
  - 2006: 2.4
  - 2007: 3.8
- Unemployment rate (in percent):
  - 2003: 15.3
  - 2004: 15.1
  - 2005: 16.2
  - 2006: 13.2
  - 2007: 11.1
- General government finances (in percent of GDP):
  - Revenue (2007): 24.1
  - Expenditure (2007): 26.3
  - Primary balance (2007): 2.3
  - Overall balance (2007): -2.6
  - Public debt (2007): 80.6
- Balance of payments and reserves:
  - Current account (2007): -16.1 (in percent of GDP)
  - Reserves (in millions of U.S. dollars, end-2007): 905.4
  - Reserves (in months of next year’s imports of goods, 2007): 4.0
- Financial sector indicators (2007):
  - Capital/adjusted-asset ratio: 14.4
  - Nonperforming loans (in percent of total loans): 4.6
  - Return on assets (before taxes and dividends): 1.8
  - Loan-to-deposit ratio: 61.4
  - Total assets to total liabilities: 153.4
- Medium-term projections (selected):
  - Real GDP projection:
    - 2008: 3.2
    - 2009: 2.9
    - 2010: 2.7
    - 2011: 2.5
  - Overall balance (percent of GDP) projections:
    - 2008: -3.7
    - 2009: -0.5
    - 2010: -0.3
    - 2011: -0.1
  - Public debt projections (percent of GDP):
    - 2008: 76.8
    - 2009: 21.4
    - 2010: 19.1
    - 2011: 16.5
  - Reserves (in millions of U.S. dollars):
    - 2008: 969.6
    - 2009: 967.7
    - 2010: 1,012.2
    - 2011: 1,064.1
- Fiscal operations (selected, in percent of GDP):
  - Total revenue (2007): 24.1
  - Tax revenue (2007): 21.4
  - Total expenditure (2007): 26.3
  - Wages and salaries (2007): 9.2
  - Interest payments (2007): 4.9
  - Capital expenditure (2007): 0.3

*Prepared by the European Department; Staff Report for the 2008 Article IV Consultation — Informational Annex (August 18, 2008).*

### ANNEX I.  KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS—NETHERLANDS ANTILLES:

### ANNEX I.  KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS—NETHERLANDS ANTILLES: FUND RELATIONS (As of  August 18, 2008)

### Fund relations and mission
- 2008 Article IV consultation mission: A team comprising Ms. Banerji (head), Mr. Daal, and Mr. Moore (all EUR), joined by Mr. Schilperoort (the Executive Director’s office), visited the Netherlands Antilles during June 19–30, 2008.
- The team met with the Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Economic and Labor Affairs, Central Bank (BNA), labor unions, and private sector participants (banks and businesses).
- The Netherlands Antilles does not have a separate quota or other financial relations with the Fund.
- The Kingdom of the Netherlands’ acceptance of Article VIII, Sections 2, 3, and 4 also applies to the Netherlands Antilles.

### Implementation of Fund policy recommendations
- Fiscal policy:
  - The authorities continued fiscal consolidation through 2007, based on cuts in primary spending.
  - A fiscal framework, including rules designed to ensure fiscal sustainability after the dissolution of the federation, has been agreed in the context of the dissolution agreement.
  - Implementation is scheduled to begin in 2009.
  - Plans to rationalize and control healthcare costs as well as pension reform plans have been drawn up and some reforms have been implemented.
- Monetary policy:
  - The long-standing peg to the U.S. dollar has been maintained and the role of indirect monetary policy instruments has been strengthened.
  - Curaçao and St. Maarten will remain in a monetary union under the new constitutional arrangements.
- Financial sector reform:
  - Financial sector supervision will remain centralized in a single central bank after the breakup of the federation.
  - The authorities have continued efforts to strengthen financial sector supervision and the AML/CFT framework.
  - A draft law to harmonize supervision and allow the central bank to impose fines—as envisaged at the previous Article IV consultation—is now pending in parliament.
  - The BNA plans to conduct its own stress tests on bank balance sheets in the future to improve risk assessment.
  - Most key recommendations from the 2004 Assessment of the Supervision and Regulation of the Financial Sector were implemented around the time of the previous consultation.
  - Specific legislation to criminalize financing of terrorism and increase penalties for money laundering was adopted in mid-2008.
- Structural reforms:
  - A range of productivity-enhancing structural reforms are pending, in line with the need to maintain competitiveness in the context of the peg to the U.S. dollar.
  - Key steps to improve corporate governance and the finances of public enterprises are scheduled for implementation in fall 2008, including rules on the appointment process for company directors, norms on public enterprise dividend policies, and the establishment of an independent regulatory board for utilities.
  - The authorities have engaged social partners in a dialogue on the need for greater labor market flexibility.
  - The Labor Force Development Commission of Curaçao—reflecting tripartite participation from government, employers, and unions—is finalizing a comprehensive protocol for improving labor force flexibility and skills, and increasing employment.
  - The draft protocol draws on OECD recommendations.
- Statistics:
  - A business cycle survey has been introduced and short-term indicators developed to better forecast GDP.
  - Long-standing plans to improve dissemination are now underway.

### ANNEX II. KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS—NETHERLANDS ANTILLES: STATISTICAL ISSUES

### General
- Data provision has some shortcomings, but is broadly adequate fro surveillance.
- Most data are published with considerable lags and are often subject to large measurement errors and revisions.
- The central bank (BNA) continues to provide comprehensive reviews of the economy in its Annual Reports and Quarterly Bulletins, and through data disseminated on its website.
- In December 2000, both the Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS) and the BNA adopted data release calendars and signed a detailed protocol of cooperation on statistics.

### Real sector statistics
- National accounts are compiled from the production and expenditure sides in current prices only; no deflators or official estimates of real GDP are available.
- No national accounts data are reported to the Statistics Department for publication in the International Financial Statistics (IFS).
- The CBS has been publishing estimates of real GDP growth on the basis of selected indicators of production and trade.
- Private sector employment figures are based on annual labor market surveys and are subject to large revisions; for government employment, several inconsistent series are available.
- The national consumer price index is generally adequate and published with a lag of two months by the CBS.
- Separate consumer price indices for each of the three main islands are published by the BNA on its website with a slightly longer lag.
- A consistent time series on minimum wages is available in a timely manner.

### Government finance statistics
- Data on the cash budget execution of the central government and the island government of Curaçao are publicly available, with a lag of about six weeks.
- Coverage still needs to be extended to the other islands and several autonomous public institutions.
- Data on unpaid expenditure commitments are spotty for island governments.
- No public finance data is reported to STA for publication in the IFS or Government Finance Statistics Yearbook.

### Monetary and financial statistics
- Summary indicators of monetary and financial statistics are published on the BNA’s website with a delay of two to three months.
- Monetary and financial data are provided to the Fund and published in the IFS.
- These data in the format of the Standardized Report Forms (SRF) have not been reported and are not published in the IFS Supplement.

### External sector statistics
- Balance of payments statistics are reported on a transactions basis in accordance with the fifth edition of the Balance of Payments Manual, but some problems remain.
- The small size and undiversified nature of the economy impart considerable volatility to individual items, making it difficult to interpret trends.
- The diversified and ever-changing structure of the offshore sector makes an appropriate classification of capital account inflows and outflows problematic.

### Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (As of July 25, 2008) — Selected entries
- Exchange rates: Latest observation 7/25/2008; Date received 7/25/2008; Frequency of data Daily and Monthly; Frequency of reporting Daily and Monthly; Frequency of publication Daily and Monthly.
- International reserve assets and reserve liabilities of the monetary authorities: Latest observation 7/15/2008; Date received 7/24/2008; Frequency of data Weekly; Frequency of reporting Weekly; Frequency of publication Weekly.
- Reserve/base money: Latest observation May 2008; Date received 7/17/2008; Frequency of data Monthly; Frequency of reporting Monthly; Frequency of publication Monthly.
- Broad money: Latest observation May 2008; Date received 7/17/2008; Frequency of data Monthly; Frequency of reporting Monthly; Frequency of publication Monthly.
- Central bank balance sheet: Latest observation Jun 2008; Date received 7/22/2008; Frequency of data Monthly; Frequency of reporting Monthly; Frequency of publication Monthly.
- Consolidated balance sheet of the banking system: Latest observation May 2008; Date received 7/17/2008; Frequency of data Monthly; Frequency of reporting Monthly; Frequency of publication Monthly.
- Interest rates: Latest observation May 2008; Date received 7/17/2008; Frequency of data Monthly; Frequency of reporting Monthly; Frequency of publication Monthly.
- Consumer price index: Latest observation Feb 2008; Date received Mar 2008; Frequency of data Monthly; Frequency of reporting Monthly; Frequency of publication Monthly.
- Revenue, expenditure, balance and composition of financing — general government: Latest observation Q1 2008; Date received 7/18/2008; Frequency of data Quarterly; Frequency of reporting Quarterly; Frequency of publication Quarterly.
- Revenue, expenditure, balance and composition of financing — central government: Latest observation Apr 2008; Date received Jul 2008; Frequency of data Monthly; Frequency of reporting Monthly; Frequency of publication Monthly.
- Stocks of central government and central government-guaranteed debt: Latest observation Apr 2008; Date received Jul 2008; Frequency of data Monthly; Frequency of reporting Monthly; Frequency of publication Monthly.
- External current account balance: Latest observation Q4 2007; Date received 5/7/2008; Frequency of data Quarterly; Frequency of reporting Quarterly; Frequency of publication Irregular.
- Exports and imports of goods and services: Latest observation Q4 2007; Date received 5/7/2008; Frequency of data Quarterly; Frequency of reporting Quarterly; Frequency of publication Irregular.
- GDP/GNP: Latest observation 2007; Date received 6/17/2008; Frequency of data Annual; Frequency of reporting Annual; Frequency of publication Annual.

### Public Information Notice (PIN) No. 08/119 — Executive Board action and background
- FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE September 18, 2008
- IMF Executive Board Concludes 2008 Article IV Consultation with the Kingdom of the Netherlands—Netherlands Antilles:
  - On September 15, 2008 the Executive Board of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) concluded the Article IV consultation with the Kingdom of the Netherlands—Netherlands Antilles.
- Background:
  - A long period of stagnation has ended in the Netherlands Antilles as investor confidence has been boosted by the prospect of large-scale debt relief and fiscal responsibility under the December 2005 constitutional agreement.
  - Economic growth accelerated sharply in 2007 to

*Source: _cr08315 - ANNEX I.  KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS—NETHERLANDS ANTILLES (As of August 18, 2008).*

### 3.8 percent, driven by investments in infrastructure, the housing and tourism sectors, and

### _cr08315 - 3.8 percent, driven by investments in infrastructure, the housing and tourism sectors, and

### Economic performance and outlook
- Real GDP growth accelerated to 3.8 percent in 2007, driven by investments in infrastructure, the housing and tourism sectors, and increased private consumption.
- Preliminary indications are that the growth momentum is continuing in 2008.
- Latest (post-mission) data: real GDP increased by 1.7 percent y-o-y in the first quarter of 2008, compared to 2.6 percent in the first quarter of 2007.
- Outlook for 2008: growth expected to moderate in a less benign global environment and rising inflation; staff note inflation could reach 6.0%-6.5% by the end of 2008 based on recent island data.

### Inflation and price developments
- Inflation broadly tracks U.S. inflation due to the exchange rate anchor.
- Inflation, historically low, is set to jump sharply due to the elimination of implicit oil subsidies in place since 2006.
- Inflation increased to 3.4 percent on an annual basis at the end of the first quarter of 2008, reflecting rising world prices for food and energy, the strong euro, and a decision by the government of Curaçao to increase domestic gasoline and utility prices.
- Consumer Prices (period average): 1.6 (2005); 1.6 (2006); 3.7 (2007); 2.8 (2008, Prel.); 2.8 (2009, Proj.); 5.0 (2008 entry in table); 2.0 (2009 entry in table).

### External sector and reserves
- Current account deficit widened markedly in 2007 to 16 percent of GDP, reflecting a surge in FDI flows related to large hotel projects.
- The large current account deficit was more than financed by Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), increased Dutch aid, and private sector trade credits.
- Official reserves (in millions of U.S. dollars), end of period: 505.3 (2003); 567.2 (2004); 624.5 (2005); 699.4 (2006); 905.4 (2007); 969.6 (2008, Prel.); 967.7 (2009, Proj.).
- Official reserves (in months of merchandise imports): 2.5 (2003); 2.5 (2004); 2.5 (2005); 2.5 (2006); 3.1 (2007); 3.1 (2008, Prel.); 3.0 (2009, Proj.).
- Trade balance (goods and nonfactor services) as percent of GDP: -34.4 (2003); -38.6 (2004); -41.0 (2005); -44.0 (2006); -50.8 (2007); -48.8 (2008, Prel.); -48.1 (2009, Proj.).

### Public finances and debt
- Government retrenched finances mainly through controls on spending; despite income tax cuts, revenues held steady due to improved collections.
- Spending cuts focused on curtailing current primary expenditure through reductions in the civil service and spending on goods and services, and low wage increases.
- Total spending remained high because of interest payments.
- Public debt remains close to 80 percent of GDP ahead of debt relief.
- Current budget balance held at 2⅓ percent of GDP during 2005–07, and is expected to decline further in 2008.
- General government balance (percent of GDP): -4.5 (2003); -6.1 (2004); -2.6 (2005); -3.1 (2006); -2.6 (2007); -3.7 (2008, Prel.); 1.3 (2009, Proj.).
- Public debt (percent of GDP): 79.8 (2003); 81.2 (2004); 78.4 (2005); 79.7 (2006); 80.6 (2007); 76.8 (2008, Prel.); 21.4 (2009, Proj.—reflecting debt relief assumptions).
- In current situation, annual interest payments eat up almost 25% of tax revenue.
- As part of constitutional dissolution agreement, the Netherlands has agreed to take over a large part of total public debt; complementary rules: multi-annual budgeting, current budget (net of investments) should be in balance or surplus, and interest expenditures shall not exceed 5% of revenues.

### Monetary and financial sector conditions and policies
- Exchange rate regime: Fixed exchange rate (1.79 NA f. per U.S. dollar).
- Directors and staff consider the peg to the U.S. dollar has served the economy well and remains appropriate.
- Central bank (BNA) changed policy rates in line with US Fed decisions; reserve requirement tightened; larger auctions of certificates of deposits used to mop up excess liquidity.
- Monetary policy challenge: upcoming debt relief will inject substantial liquidity once the Dutch government pays holders of outstanding debt; risk of excess liquidity endangering financial stability if not sterilized.
- Authorities’ three-fold policy approach to liquidity from debt relief:
  - Discuss a gradual schedule of debt relief payments with the Dutch government, in line with maturity schedule of outstanding government securities.
  - Ease investment rule for institutional investors to allow more foreign investment.
  - Mop up any remaining excess liquidity through tightening reserve requirement and CD auctions if necessary.
- Constitutional changes: monetary responsibility for Bonaire, St. Eustatius, and Saba to be transferred to De Nederlandsche Bank; agreement on one central bank for Curaçao and Sint Maarten (monetary union).
- Financial sector soundness: banking system well-capitalized; financial soundness indicators show adequate capitalization, profitability and low nonperforming loans; total assets of commercial banking sector increased in 2007 and 2008 with improvement in capital adequacy ratios.
- Competitive pressures: banking sector assets concentrated in top two banks; limited competition on funding due to capital controls on institutional investors; increasing competition from smaller banks compressed lending spreads modestly; consolidation example: GIRO acquired mortgage bank CHB.

### Structural reforms and institutional change
- Constitutional dissolution foreseen for January 2010 (implementation started): Curaçao and Sint Maarten to become autonomous countries within the Kingdom; Bonaire, St. Eustatius, and Saba to become part of the Netherlands.
- Implementation measures already in place in Bonaire, St. Eustasius, and Saba: balanced budget rule and fiscal supervision; similar measures about to begin in St. Maarten and Curaçao starting 2009.
- Broad range of reforms in draft tripartite protocol (government, employers, labor) to improve productivity and the social economic initiative indicate strong support for comprehensive reform.
- Structural reform priorities: labor market flexibility and training, investment needs in infrastructure and education co-financed by the Netherlands, entitlement reforms (including consideration of increasing retirement age to 65), pension cost containment, and health care reform.
- Staff and Directors recommend implementing reforms as a package to facilitate acceptance.

### Executive Board / Directors’ main assessments and recommendations
- Executive Directors welcomed the resurgence of economic growth and commended authorities for implementing key reforms ahead of dissolution.
- Encouraged authorities to use large debt relief from the Netherlands to set budget and economy on a more sustainable footing.
- Directors noted the peg is broadly in line with fundamentals and the size of the current account deficit expected over the medium term appears manageable.
- Fiscal policy recommendations:
  - Sustain revenues by broadening the tax base and rebalancing the tax burden.
  - Take account of costs of targeted income subsidies to mitigate impact on poorest households of higher prices and indirect taxes.
  - Additional expenditure savings needed via entitlement reforms, civil service rationalization, wage restraint, and further pension reform.
- Financial sector recommendations:
  - Manage impact of debt relief on financial sector balance sheets: seek gradual schedule of debt relief to avoid excess liquidity; tighten monetary policy; ease capital controls on institutional investors gradually.
  - Central bank should monitor bank lending standards closely to guard against greater risk-taking as risk-free government securities opportunities decline and lending margins narrow.
- Structural reform advice:
  - Given limited macroeconomic policy tools, structural reforms including supportive tax and labor market policies are key to preserving investor confidence and external competitiveness.
  - Implement the draft tripartite protocol and complementary reforms as a package.

### Key statistics (selected, preserved exactly as reported)
- Real GDP growth: 1.7 (2003); 1.2 (2004); 1.3 (2005); 2.4 (2006); 3.8 (2007); 3.2 (2008 Prel.); 2.9 (2009 Proj.).
- Unemployment rate (in percent of labor force): 15.3 (2003); 15.1 (2004); 16.2 (2005); 13.2 (2006); 11.1 (2007); 10.9 (2008 Prel.); 10.7 (2009 Proj.).
- Broad money growth: 8.4 (2003); 10.2 (2004); 9.4 (2005); 10.0 (2006); 12.1 (2007); 13.4 (2008 Prel.); 8.8 (2009 Proj.).
- Domestic credit growth: 5.4 (2003); 11.4 (2004); 10.6 (2005); 13.6 (2006); 11.5 (2007); 10.4 (2008 Prel.); 9.5 (2009 Proj.).
- Interest rate on 12 month deposit (in percent): 3.5 (2003); 3.0 (2004); 2.8 (2005); 2.8 (2006); ... (2007); ... (2008); ... (2009).
- Government bond yield (in percent): 6.7 (2005); 7.1 (2006); 6.5 (2007); 6.8 (2008); ...; ...; ....
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): 0.1 (2003); -2.8 (2004); -3.2 (2005); -7.6 (2006); -16.1 (2007); -11.4 (2008 Prel.); -9.7 (2009 Proj.).

*Source: IMF staff report and Executive Board assessment as presented in the provided document.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2008/_cr08315.pdf_
