## _cr09194

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr09194](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09194.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09194.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09194.pdf.json)

---

### Executive Summary — macro performance, program implementation, and staff appraisal
- Macroeconomic performance and outlook:
  - Real GDP growth in 2008: 1.1 percent.
  - Staff projects real GDP growth of about 1.7 percent in 2009 and 2.1 percent in 2010.
  - Inflation: peak 15.8 percent (12-month) in August 2008; estimated 8.4 percent (average) by year-end 2008.
  - Current account deficit in 2008: 6.6 percent of GDP; expected to narrow to about 6 percent in 2009 with improving terms of trade.
  - Money growth increased by 16 percent in 2008.
  - Public investment to rise about 2 percentage points of GDP in 2009, partly offset by the global recession.
- Program implementation and recent developments:
  - PRGF-supported program implementation in 2008: generally strong; all quantitative targets and structural benchmarks met except:
    - Indicative target for social and investment spending undershot (shortfall: more than 1 percent of GDP).
    - Delay in launching phosphate sector study due to procurement/capacity constraints.
  - Fiscal performance 2008:
    - Domestic primary balance (performance criterion): +0.4 percent of GDP (program floor: −0.5 percent).
    - Net domestic financing (PC) met with an ample margin: 0.4 percent of GDP (accumulation of government deposits).
    - Capital spending under-executed; procurement and implementation capacity constraints affected emergency repairs after floods.
- Staff appraisal and policy guidance:
  - Program performance commended given severe flooding and global price shocks.
  - Fiscal prudence maintained; some over-performance reflects underspending on emergency repairs.
  - Priority structural reforms: fiscal governance, financial sector restructuring, public enterprise reform, with emphasis on measures directly impacting growth.
  - Staff recommends completion of the second review of the PRGF arrangement and revision of end-June quantitative PCs based on observed performance.

### Liquidity for businesses, domestic arrears, and support measures
- Domestic arrears and clearance strategy:
  - Domestic arrears (KPMG audit): nearly 3 percent of GDP.
  - 2009 budget provides for settling ½ percent of GDP in cash to smaller suppliers.
  - Remainder originally to be settled by issuing medium-term securities to businesses.
  - Authorities prefer to increase cash settlements financed by donor grants and domestic financing of ½ percent of GDP.
  - Staff supports increasing cash settlements as affordable, addressing pressing liquidity needs, and having a small impact on public finances.
  - Fiscal impact details:
    - Increasing the 2009 arrears cash clearance will not have an impact on the primary balance.
    - Additional domestic financing required limited to about 0.3 percent of GDP, compatible with government’s available deposits.
  - Audit footnotes:
    - A discount of 20 percent will be applied to the verified domestic arrears.
    - Amounts not cleared in cash will be settled with government securities with a maturity of 5 to 7 years at below-market interest rates.
- Support for vulnerable populations and cotton sector:
  - Staff supported budget-consistent measures to protect vulnerable segments, notably increased subsidies for subsistence agriculture inputs.
  - Government intends to absorb projected net operating losses for the cotton sector (less than 0.1 percent of GDP).
    - Footnote: net loss assumes sale of unsold cotton stock worth about 0.2 percent of GDP.
  - Government intends to help new cotton company obtain financing for fertilizer and seeds for 2009/2010 (projected at less than 0.2 percent of GDP).
  - Staff supported these interim measures if consistent with the fiscal framework and urged longer-term arrangements.
- Petroleum products contingent liability:
  - Contingent liabilities to oil distributors from limited pass-through in 2007–08: equal to 1.5 percent of GDP.
  - Government commitment: maintain a margin for distributors to eliminate the contingent liability within 20 months and review the pricing mechanism.

### Fiscal policy, budget priorities, and spending composition
- 2009 budget objectives:
  - Strengthen priority spending while preserving debt sustainability.
  - Target domestic primary deficit of only 0.6 percent of GDP (domestic primary deficit = 0.6 percent of GDP).
  - Increase share of priority spending on social and physical capital in line with PRS objectives.
- Selected spending by priority sectors (percent of GDP):
  - Primary spending: 2007 = 18.6; 2008 = 17.8; 2009 = 20.3; 2010 = 22.1; 2011 = 22.2; 2012 = 22.2.
  - Spending in priority sectors: 2007 = 6.4; 2008 = 7.0; 2009 = 9.4; 2010 = 12.4; 2011 = 12.4; 2012 = 12.7.
  - Health: 2007 = 1.8; 2008 = 2.2; 2009 = 3.3; 2010 = 5.1; 2011 = 5.2; 2012 = 5.3.
  - Education: 2007 = 3.7; 2008 = 3.9; 2009 = 5.0; 2010 = 5.7; 2011 = 6.1; 2012 = 6.4.
  - Capital spending (priority sectors): 2007 = 0.9; 2008 = 1.3; 2009 = 3.2; 2010 = 5.3; 2011 = 5.4; 2012 = 5.4.
  - Other spending: 2007 = 12.1; 2008 = 10.8; 2009 = 10.9; 2010 = 9.7; 2011 = 9.8; 2012 = 9.5.
  - Capital spending (other): 2007 = 2.1; 2008 = 2.2; 2009 = 2.4; 2010 = 1.8; 2011 = 1.6; 2012 = 1.6.
- Authorities’ measures to protect vulnerable groups:
  - 2008: targeted measures (subsidies for seeds and fertilizers; sales of food stocks; accelerated pension arrears payments; increase in minimum wage).
  - 2009: increased subsidies for agricultural inputs and cuts to personal and corporate taxes.

### Capacity constraints, procurement, and implementation actions
- Implementation bottlenecks:
  - Slow procurement and project execution impeded timely emergency repairs after 2008 floods, prolonging economic costs to bridges and roads.
- Authorities’ action plan (with staff assistance):
  - Expedite priority projects.
  - Make a higher share of the annual budget available at the beginning of the fiscal year.
  - Reduce overlapping controls in the spending chain.
  - Provide training for project execution.
- Carryover and supplementary budget:
  - Authorities plan to carry over underspent emergency repair resources from 2008 to increase domestic investment spending in 2009 (about ½ percent of GDP carried over), with a supplementary budget to be submitted.

### Progress on structural reforms, banking sector, and NPL management
- Structural reform progress 2008/09:
  - Nearly all program benchmarks met on or ahead of schedule; slight delay in initiating strategic audit of phosphate sector (initiated Jan. 2009).
  - 2009 structural agenda: four measures planned before next review; two benchmarks already completed (restructuring of BTCI and reducing tax exemptions); two measures concern Treasury reform (structural PC) and phosphate development strategy (structural benchmark).
- Treasury and fiscal governance advances:
  - Treasury reorganized; planned accounting reforms (PC for June 2009) on track.
  - General Finance Inspectorate set up.
  - Framework for regular Treasury bill auctions established in September 2008 (SB met three months early).
  - 2009 budget law reduced tax exemptions; fiscal administration given more authority over the Free Economic Zone (FEZ).
- Bank restructuring and NPLs:
  - Three state-owned banks, including BTCI, fully recapitalized with government securities in December 2008 (March 2009 SB met early).
  - Securities issued in exchange for NPLs of three large undercapitalized public banks: about 27 percent of total loans (about 7 percent of GDP).
  - Operation restored banks’ compliance with prudential indicators.
  - Authorities intend, with World Bank support, to set up a mechanism for recovering and settling NPLs now in government possession; completion postponed to December 2009 (revised SB).
  - Authorities plan to work with the BCEAO to develop a secondary market for the securities.
  - Authorities aim to accelerate privatization of four state-owned banks; staff urged expedited transfer of bad loan management to a separate agency and continued strict oversight pre- and post-privatization.

### State-owned enterprises — phosphate, electricity, and cotton
- Phosphate sector:
  - Consulting company selected for strategic audit in January 2009 (October 2008 SB mildly delayed); report expected April 2009.
  - Government began restructuring operations; benchmark to prepare development strategy based on audit (Benchmark September 2009 On track).
- Electricity (CEET):
  - Draft report reviewing finances and operations submitted December 2008; strategic and financial audit planned for May.
  - CEET: rates slightly below cost of production and large payment arrears; staff discussed improving CEET management.
- Cotton sector:
  - SOTOCO liquidated in 2008 after inability to pay farmers; farmers paid off in cash; debt to domestic banks securitized by government bonds.
  - New cotton company NSCT created; government intends to assist financing for 2009/2010 season (less than 0.2 percent of GDP).
  - Staff urged longer-term arrangements to minimize public money use.

### Macroeconomic outlook, medium-term growth scenario, and debt sustainability
- Medium-term growth outlook:
  - Real GDP growth could reach about 4 percent annually by 2011 given planned growth-enhancing reforms.
  - Main growth sources: agricultural production (especially food), construction from higher public investment, recovery in phosphate production, competitive cement industry, recovery in trade-related services (regional hub role).
  - Risks: protracted delay in structural reforms, particularly restructuring state-owned banks and enterprises.
- Fiscal framework and projections:
  - Domestic primary balance projected to reach to 1 percent of GDP by 2011 (medium-term program target).
  - Average overall deficit (including grants) expected to rise to about 2.5 percent of GDP for 2009/11, before falling back to a medium-term average of 1 percent (or about 5 percent excluding grants).
  - Envisaged fiscal loosening in 2009 described as modest, temporary, and pro-growth; not expected to harm long-term debt indicators.
- External sector and terms of trade:
  - External current account deficit expected to improve in 2010 and beyond with export growth.
  - Terms of trade expected to strengthen strongly in 2009, with part of gains reversing in 2010.
  - Projected current deficits in medium-term scenario noted as "5-6 percent of GDP"; sustainability depends on increased aid inflows or non-debt-creating inflows such as FDI.
- Debt sustainability assessment (DSA) findings:
  - Updated DSA incorporating domestic debt shows NPV of total debt over GDP around 30 percent in the steady state.
  - PV of debt to revenue and debt service-to-revenue ratio stabilize at comfortably low levels under baseline.
  - Sensitivity analysis: vulnerable to substantial reductions in official aid, lower concessionality, and macro shocks, particularly lower growth.
  - Recommendation: rely on concessional debt, limit fiscal deficits to sustainable levels, and concentrate on boosting growth.

### Cash and debt management, tax policy, and public investment
- Cash and debt management improvements:
  - New template to assess cash needs; testing Integrated Budget Execution and Reporting System (SIGFIP).
  - Issued short-term bills on regional market in September 2008; issuance of 0.8 percent of GDP well received by domestic banks; additional issuances planned for 2009 to expedite cash clearance of domestic arrears.
  - Staff recommendations: better coordination between line ministers and Treasury; improve and centralize debt data; define a debt strategy and centralize authority to contract debt.
- Growth-friendly tax policy:
  - Tax system described as complex with excessive rates and numerous exemptions.
  - Authorities recognize need to streamline the tax system and reduce rates (corporate and income tax).
  - Management and computerization efforts reducing tax evasion; scope for further progress.

### Competitiveness, REER assessment, and external balance
- REER and competitiveness:
  - REER has mirrored WAEMU-wide trends since 1994 devaluation; econometric EREER suggests real exchange rate not seriously misaligned despite a recent trend toward overvaluation.
  - FEER estimation indicates most long-term REER fluctuation explained by fundamentals; slight overvaluation since 2005 intensified in 2008.
  - With deceleration in inflation, Euro depreciation, and terms of trade improvement, REER expected to revert toward equilibrium.
- External balance:
  - Current account deficits financed by capital and financial inflows, notably project grants and concessional loans.
  - Macroeconomic balance approach: projected current account deficit in line with norms for a low-income African country receiving aid inflows; sustainability depends on aid and non-debt-creating inflows.

### Program monitoring, conditionality, and risks
- Program monitoring:
  - Revised quantitative and structural indicators agreed to monitor PRGF-supported program through 2009.
  - End-June quantitative PCs revised; new PCs for end-December 2009 agreed.
  - Continuous PCs on nonaccumulation of domestic arrears and prohibition on contracting or guaranteeing nonconcessional external debt maintained.
  - Structural PC and benchmarks for June–December 2009 on PFM, financial sector, and public enterprises remain unchanged except for revised timing on NPLs.
- Main near-term risks:
  - Worsening global financial crisis or greater external impact could jeopardize revenue performance and delay private-sector involvement in restructuring.
  - Political uncertainty ahead of presidential elections in the first quarter of 2010 could complicate program implementation.
  - Authorities committed to forceful program implementation throughout the electoral period.

### HIPC process, PRS, and donor assistance
- HIPC process:
  - Progress toward HIPC floating completion point triggers is good; final PRS expected by end of April.
  - Government adopted the PRS after consultations; macro framework consistent with PRGF program.
  - Court of Auditors to begin operations in June 2009; Procurement Regulatory Agency planned by end April 2009.
  - Regular publication of revenues received from and payments to the phosphate company initiated.
- Donor support:
  - Committed budget support of about 2 percent of GDP from the World Bank, the EU, and the AfDB to help meet 2009 financing needs.
  - Authorities seek continued and increased donor support to finance investments essential for infrastructure, social services, poverty reduction, and MDGs.

### Key tables and selected indicators (highlights and exact figures preserved)
- Medium-term real GDP (percent change): 2007: 1.9; 2008: 1.1; 2009: 1.7; 2010: 2.1; 2011: 4.1; 2012–2014: 4.0.
- Consumer price index (annual average): 2007: 2.2; 2008: 1.0; 2009: 8.4; 2010: 2.8; 2011: 2.1.
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2006: -2.9; 2007: -3.9; 2008: -6.6; 2009: -6.1; 2010: -5.9.
- Exports (goods and services, percent of GDP): 2008: 23.5; 2009: 21.5; 2010: 26.7.
- Gross international reserves (months of imports): 2006: 3.4; 2007: 3.0; 2008: 4.4; 2009: 5.0; 2010: 4.7.
- External public debt (percent of GDP): 2006: 83.9; 2007: 79.2; 2008: 56.6; 2009: 53.0; 2010: 30.5.
- Domestic arrears verified: nearly 3 percent of GDP; cash settlement provided for ½ percent of GDP in 2009 budget.

### Statistical issues, data quality, and dissemination
- Data adequacy: broadly adequate for surveillance but weaknesses in quality and timeliness hamper analysis.
- Specific weaknesses:
  - National accounts and balance of payments rely on limited information; scarce data on primary agriculture and private services.
  - Government finance statistics derived from a weak accounting system.
  - Monetary data reported by BCEAO with a two-month lag.
- Improvements and actions:
  - WAEMU SNA implementation underway; NA base year (2000) completed in 2005; training conducted March 2009; authorities committed to implement 1993 SNA.
  - Balance of payments compilation improved; STA technical assistance noted progress on informal trade coverage.
  - Inconsistencies in domestic arrears records audited; new database being set up.

### Executive Board conclusions and operational decisions
- Executive Board: 2009 Article IV consultation concluded April 21, 2009; second review of PRGF arrangement completed.
- Disbursement: immediate disbursement equivalent to SDR 17.9 million (about US$26.6 million), bringing total disbursements to SDR 49.2 million (about US$72.9 million).
- Directors’ guidance:
  - Commended authorities for strong policy implementation despite shocks.
  - Supported modest fiscal loosening for 2009, shifting unspent emergency funds to 2009, and increasing cash arrears clearance.
  - Recommended strengthening project execution and procurement; review of oil pricing mechanism; continued priority on fiscal governance, phosphate sector reform, and financial sector restructuring.
  - Emphasized need for projected increases in external assistance and prudent debt management.

### Conclusion — capacity challenges, HIPC targets, and financing needs
- Capacity and infrastructure challenges persist; continued international support required.
- Authorities committed to meeting HIPC completion point triggers and to implementing PRGF program and full PRSP while maintaining political and social stability.
- Fresh concessional resources critically needed to finance investments and reforms under the PRGF-supported program and the PRSP.

*IMF staff executive summary and selected excerpts from the source content.*

### Executive Summary.......................................................................................................

### Executive Summary

### Key findings: macroeconomic performance and outlook
- Real GDP growth in 2008: 1.1 percent.
- Staff projects real GDP growth of about 1.7 percent in 2009 and 2.1 percent in 2010.
- Inflation peaked at 15.8 percent (12-month) in August 2008 and fell to an estimated 8.4 percent (average) by year-end 2008.
- Current account deficit in 2008: 6.6 percent of GDP; improving terms of trade in 2009 expected to narrow the current account deficit to about 6 percent.
- Money growth increased by 16 percent in 2008.
- The global recession is expected to offset a nascent recovery driven by a rebound in subsistence agriculture and rising public investment (about 2 percentage points of GDP in 2009).

### Program implementation and recent developments
- PRGF-supported program implementation in 2008: generally strong; all quantitative targets and structural benchmarks met except:
  - Indicative target for social and investment spending was undershot (shortfall: more than 1 percent of GDP).
  - Delay in launching a study of the phosphate sector due to procurement/capacity constraints.
- Fiscal performance in 2008:
  - Domestic primary balance (performance criterion): +0.4 percent of GDP (program floor: −0.5 percent).
  - Target on net domestic financing (PC) met with an ample margin: 0.4 percent of GDP, associated with accumulation of government deposits.
  - Capital spending under-executed, reflecting procurement and implementation capacity constraints—particularly affecting emergency repairs after floods.
- External and price developments:
  - Surging world food and oil prices pushed inflation up mid-2008; subsequent fall in world oil and food prices mitigated inflationary pressures, improved terms of trade, and limited deterioration of the current account.

### Staff appraisal
- Program performance deemed commendable given the severe flooding and global price shocks.
- Fiscal prudence maintained despite exogenous shocks and slower growth; part of the over-performance attributed to underspending on emergency repairs, highlighting capacity weaknesses.
- Strong progress on structural reforms, with many benchmarks achieved early; priority areas include fiscal governance, financial sector restructuring, and public enterprise reform, with increasing emphasis on measures that directly impact growth.
- Staff recommends completion of the second review of the PRGF arrangement and revision of the end-June quantitative PCs based on observed performance.

### Fiscal policy and budgetary priorities
- 2009 budget aims to strengthen priority spending while preserving debt sustainability:
  - Targets a domestic primary deficit of only 0.6 percent of GDP (domestic primary deficit = 0.6 percent of GDP).
  - Intends to increase the share of priority spending on social and physical capital in line with PRS objectives.
- Selected spending by priority sectors (percent of GDP):  
  - Primary spending: 2007 = 18.6; 2008 = 17.8; 2009 = 20.3; 2010 = 22.1; 2011 = 22.2; 2012 = 22.2.  
  - Spending in priority sectors: 2007 = 6.4; 2008 = 7.0; 2009 = 9.4; 2010 = 12.4; 2011 = 12.4; 2012 = 12.7.  
  - Health: 2007 = 1.8; 2008 = 2.2; 2009 = 3.3; 2010 = 5.1; 2011 = 5.2; 2012 = 5.3.  
  - Education: 2007 = 3.7; 2008 = 3.9; 2009 = 5.0; 2010 = 5.7; 2011 = 6.1; 2012 = 6.4.  
  - Of which capital spending (priority sectors): 2007 = 0.9; 2008 = 1.3; 2009 = 3.2; 2010 = 5.3; 2011 = 5.4; 2012 = 5.4.  
  - Other spending: 2007 = 12.1; 2008 = 10.8; 2009 = 10.9; 2010 = 9.7; 2011 = 9.8; 2012 = 9.5.  
  - Of which capital spending (other): 2007 = 2.1; 2008 = 2.2; 2009 = 2.4; 2010 = 1.8; 2011 = 1.6; 2012 = 1.6.
- Authorities’ budget measures to protect the vulnerable:
  - 2008: full pass-through of rising international food prices mitigated by targeted measures (subsidies for seeds and fertilizers; sales of food stocks; accelerated pension arrears payments; increase in minimum wage).
  - 2009: increased subsidies for agricultural inputs and cuts to personal and corporate taxes.
  - Contingent liabilities to oil distributors from limited pass-through in 2007–08: equal to 1.5 percent of GDP; with current prices, margins have become higher than normal, gradually reducing this contingent liability.

### Capacity constraints, procurement, and implementation actions
- Slow procurement and project execution impeded timely emergency repairs after 2008 floods, prolonging economic costs (notably to bridges and roads).
- Authorities’ action plan (with staff assistance) to strengthen and streamline project execution and procurement:
  - Expedite priority projects.
  - Make a higher share of the annual budget available at the beginning of the fiscal year.
  - Reduce overlapping controls in the spending chain.
  - Provide training for project execution.
- Authorities plan to carry over underspent emergency repair resources from 2008 to increase domestic investment spending in 2009 (about ½ percent of GDP carried over), with a supplementary budget to be submitted.

### Risks and policy priorities
- Main risks:
  - A worse global recession or heavier external impact could further depress growth and revenues and delay private-sector involvement in restructuring state-owned banks and enterprises.
  - Political uncertainty associated with the run-up to the 2010 presidential elections could complicate program implementation.
- Policy priorities emphasized by staff and authorities:
  - Keep the economy stable despite the global recession, supporting demand consistent with debt sustainability.
  - Pursue fiscal policy reforms to improve budget execution, strengthen sustainability, and support growth.
  - Tackle structural bottlenecks in the financial and export sectors and utilities; immediate priority is addressing the liquidity and credit shortage in the private sector.
  - Accelerate growth-enhancing structural reforms to improve productivity and external competitiveness.

*IMF staff executive summary as provided in the source content.*

### 8.      To increase liquidity for businesses, the authorities intend to increase the portion

### _cr09194 - 8.      To increase liquidity for businesses, the authorities intend to increase the portion

### Liquidity for businesses and domestic arrears clearance
- Domestic arrears verified by an audit conducted by KPMG amount to nearly 3 percent of GDP.
- The 2009 budget provides for settling ½ percent of GDP in cash to smaller suppliers, based on a plan developed in consultation with Fund staff.
- The remainder was to be settled by issuing medium-term securities directly to businesses, which would provide limited help for pressing liquidity needs.
- Authorities prefer to increase the portion of settlements in cash, to be financed by:
  - grants from donors, and
  - domestic financing of ½ percent of GDP.
- Staff supports increasing cash settlements as:
  - affordable,
  - addressing pressing liquidity needs,
  - having a small impact on public finances.
- Fiscal impact details:
  - Increasing the 2009 arrears cash clearance will not have an impact on the primary balance.
  - The additional domestic financing required is limited to about 0.3 percent of GDP, compatible with the government’s available deposits.
- Footnote clarifications from the audit:
  - A discount of 20 percent will be applied to the verified domestic arrears.
  - Amounts not cleared in cash will be settled with government securities with a maturity of 5 to 7 years at below-market interest rates.

### Support for vulnerable populations and the cotton sector
- Staff supported planned measures consistent with the budget to protect vulnerable segments, especially the increase in subsidies for inputs for subsistence agriculture.
- Government intends to absorb projected net operating losses for the cotton sector (less than 0.1 percent of GDP).
  - Footnote: The net loss assumes the sale of the stock of unsold cotton, worth about 0.2 percent of GDP.
- Government also intends to help the new cotton company obtain financing (either a domestic loan guarantee or a direct loan) for fertilizer and seeds for the 2009/2010 season (projected at less than 0.2 percent of GDP).
- Staff supported these efforts as interim measures provided they remain consistent with the program’s fiscal framework and urged longer-term arrangements for the cotton sector to minimize public money use.
- Petroleum products: staff expressed serious concern about the current contingent liability and future risks.
  - Government commitment: maintain a margin for distributors that will eliminate the contingent liability within 20 months and review the pricing mechanism to avoid large liabilities in the future.
- Context on former cotton company (footnote):
  - The former publicly owned cotton ginning company, SOTOCO, was liquidated in 2008 after it was unable to pay more than 250.000 farmers for their 2004/2005 crop.
  - After audit, farmers were paid off in cash and its debt to domestic banks was securitized by government bonds.
  - A new cotton ginning company, NSCT (New Cotton Company of Togo), has been created as part of reforms.

### Progress on structural reforms (2008/09)
- Authorities made good progress, meeting nearly all program benchmarks on or ahead of schedule.
- Slight delay in initiating the strategic audit of the phosphate sector (initiated Jan. 2009).
- Structural reform agenda for 2009:
  - Four measures planned for completion before next review.
  - Two structural benchmarks already completed: initiating restructuring of BTCI and reducing tax exemptions.
  - Two measures concern reform of the Treasury (structural performance criterion) and preparation of development strategy for the phosphate sector (structural benchmark).
- Advances on public financial management:
  - Treasury reform:
    - Reorganized Treasury.
    - Planned accounting reforms (PC for June 2009) are on track.
    - General Finance Inspectorate set up to monitor use of public resources.
    - Framework for regular Treasury bill auctions established in September 2008 (SB, met three months early).
  - Tax policy:
    - 2009 budget law reduced tax exemptions.
    - Fiscal administration given more authority to control the Free Economic Zone (FEZ) (SB for June 2009, met early).
  - Domestic arrears clearance and domestic debt:
    - Mechanism to monitor domestic debt established.
    - Principles for an arrears clearance strategy adopted.
    - Intergovernmental committee set up to define concrete steps.
    - Authorities plan to initiate settlement well before year-end (SB for end-2009).

### Bank restructuring and NPL management
- Three state-owned banks, including BTCI, were fully recapitalized with government securities in December 2008 (March 2009 SB, met early).
- Securities were issued in exchange for the NPLs of three large undercapitalized public banks, representing about 27 percent of total loans (about 7 percent of GDP).
- Operation restored banks’ compliance with prudential indicators.
- Authorities intend, with World Bank support, to set up a mechanism for recovering and settling NPLs now in government possession; completion postponed to December 2009 because of complexity and need to procure advisory services (revised SB for December 2009).
- With World Bank technical support, authorities plan to work with the BCEAO to help develop a secondary market for the securities.
- Authorities determined to accelerate privatization of four state-owned banks and hope to launch the initial call for bids earlier than planned (SB for December 2009); staff strongly supported this goal.
- Staff urged expedited transfer of management of bad loans from banks to a separate agency so banks can restart credit flow.
- Staff emphasized continued strict management oversight of state-owned banks after recapitalization and before privatization; if privatization delayed or unsuccessful, heightened oversight would continue.

### State-owned enterprises: phosphate and electricity
- SOE reforms progressed but need continuation until concrete results achieved.
- Phosphate sector:
  - Consulting company selected for strategic audit in January 2009 (October 2008 SB, mildly delayed due to procurement difficulties).
  - Report expected to be completed in April 2009.
  - Government has begun restructuring phosphate company operations.
  - Benchmark: Prepare a development strategy based on the results of the strategic audit (Benchmark September 2009 On track).
- Electricity (CEET):
  - Draft report reviewing finances and operations submitted to government and World Bank for comments in December 2008 (SB).
  - Launch of a strategic and financial audit, in consultation with the World Bank, planned for May.
- Authorities concurred that lags in restructuring key sectors may jeopardize growth recovery and prioritized attracting strategic investors.

### Program monitoring, fiscal framework, and risks
- Revised quantitative and structural indicators to monitor PRGF-supported program through 2009 agreed (Appendix I, Tables 1 and 3).
- End-June quantitative PCs were revised and understandings reached on new PCs for end-December 2009.
- Performance criteria on the domestic primary balance and net domestic financing reflect a modest relaxation of the fiscal framework in 2009, as do indicators for priority spending.
- Continuous PCs on nonaccumulation of domestic arrears and central government not contracting or guaranteeing nonconcessional external debt are maintained.
- Structural PC and benchmarks for June–December 2009 on strengthening public financial management, financial sector, and public enterprises remain unchanged except for revised timing on NPLs.
- Main near-term program risks:
  - Global financial crisis worsening or impacting Togo more than expected could jeopardize revenue performance and generate new spending pressures.
  - Political uncertainty ahead of presidential elections in the first quarter of 2010 could complicate program implementation or weaken economic confidence.
  - Multiparty talks on organizing the elections have been contentious.
  - Authorities committed to forceful program implementation throughout the electoral period.

### HIPC process and related reforms
- Progress toward meeting HIPC floating completion point triggers is good, particularly with completion of the final PRS by the end of April.
- Government officially adopted the PRS after extensive consultations; the strategy describes poverty-reducing policies, their costing, and expected domestic and external financing.
- Macro framework of PRS is consistent with the PRGF-supported program.
- Government noted the Court of Auditors will begin operations in June 2009 and the Procurement Regulatory Agency is planned to be set by end April 2009.
- Data on revenues received from and payments to the phosphate company are being published regularly.

### Macroeconomic outlook and vulnerabilities: impact of the global crisis
- Impact of the global crisis expected to be moderate in 2009 and 2010, given Togo’s limited international financial integration and depressed exports.
- First signs: declining export prices and volumes.
- Country-specific mitigating factors:
  - Rebound in production after flood damage.
  - Increased public investment.
  - Less internationally integrated banking system.
  - Decline in energy and food prices expected to reduce inflationary pressures, improve the terms of trade, and narrow the current account deficit.
- Box 1: Expected transmission channels of the global crisis to Togo
  - Lower demand and prices for exports: cotton and phosphate share in total exports declined from 50 percent at the end of the 1990s to just 13 percent in 2008.
  - Cement exports represent about 20 percent of total exports.
  - Decreasing trade-related activities at the Port of Lomé may occur from lower transit and re-export to Burkina Faso, Niger, and Mali.
  - Lower remittances: remittances make up 10 to 15 percent of GDP and could drop sharply if host-country conditions worsen.
    - As of December 2008, no drop-off was evident.
  - Lack of interest of strategic investors could delay restructuring of banking and phosphate sectors.
  - Lower aid flows: Togo is not heavily dependent on donor flows, but expects increased donor support; committed budget support of about 2 percent of GDP from the World Bank, the EU, and the AfDB to help meet 2009 financing needs.
  - Declining fiscal revenues if slowdown is greater than expected.
- Mitigating country-specific factors reiterated:
  - Low international exposure of the financial sector; microfinance institutions represent 15 percent of total credits and have experienced decreasing funding from international institutions.
  - No major decrease in committed donor support; public investment in 2009 expected to pick up due to new commitments.
  - Subsistence agriculture accounts for about 25 percent of GDP and may act as a shock absorber; staff projects a rebound in subsistence production following the 2008 floods.
  - Declining energy and food prices expected to reduce inflationary pressures, improve the terms of trade, and narrow the current account deficit in 2009.

*Source: _cr09194 (selected excerpts).*

### 23.      Given planned growth-enhancing reforms, the economy could achieve real GDP

### 23.      Given planned growth-enhancing reforms, the economy could achieve real GDP

### Medium-term growth outlook and fiscal framework
- Real GDP growth could reach about 4 percent annually by 2011 given planned growth-enhancing reforms.
- Main sources of medium-term growth:
  - Agricultural production (especially food).
  - Construction fueled by higher public investment.
  - Recovery in phosphate production.
  - Competitive cement industry.
  - Recovery in trade-related services leveraging Togo’s role as a regional hub.
- Risks: Protracted delay in structural reforms, especially restructuring state-owned banks and enterprises, would undermine the projection.
- Fiscal targets and projections:
  - Domestic primary balance projected to reach to 1 percent of GDP by 2011 (the medium-term target under the program).
  - Average overall deficit (including grants) expected to rise to about 2.5 percent of GDP for 2009/11, before falling back to a medium-term average of 1 percent (or about 5 percent excluding grants).
  - The envisaged fiscal loosening in 2009 is described as modest, temporary, and pro-growth; not expected to harm long-term debt indicators.
  - Inflationary pressures projected to be moderate through the medium term.

### External sector outlook
- External current account deficit expected to improve in 2010 and beyond as a result of export growth.
- Expected developments in 2010:
  - Increase in the volume and prices of main exports, such as phosphate and cement.
  - Imports expected to grow in value in 2010 (although less so than exports), driven by modest economic recovery and higher prices for commodities such as oil and food.
- Terms of trade:
  - Expected to strengthen strongly in 2009, with part of the gains reversing in 2010.
- Projected current deficits noted as "5-6 percent of GDP" in the medium-term scenario; sustainability depends on increased aid inflows (consistent with donor pledges) or non-debt-creating inflows such as FDI.

### Policy response, authorities’ views, and risks
- Authorities concerned that major reforms were not yet translating into higher economic growth.
- Staff views:
  - 2009 and 2010 growth projections are prudent given uncertainties from the global financial crisis.
  - A modest acceleration in growth could be considered a measure of success.
  - Global financial crisis poses serious downside risks.
  - Many reforms’ impacts on growth are still limited at this early stage and could be higher in the future.
- Agreement: Togo has potential for higher growth, attainable—barring a deepening global crisis—through sustained economic stability and deeper structural reforms, supported by the international community.

### Debt sustainability assessment (DSA) and HIPC implications
- Updated DSA (including new data on domestic debt) indicates sustainability depends on faster growth and prudent fiscal policies, even after full HIPC relief.
- Findings:
  - Updated public debt indicators incorporated the revised macroeconomic framework and, for the first time, the impact of domestic debt (including bank recapitalization and domestic arrears clearance).
  - Analysis confirmed substantial reduction of the NPV of total (external and domestic) debt over GDP to around 30 percent in the steady state.
  - The PV of debt to revenue and the debt service-to-revenue ratio would also stabilize at comfortably low levels.
- Sensitivity analysis: Debt dynamics are particularly vulnerable to substantial reductions in official aid, lower concessionality, and macroeconomic shocks—particularly a reduction in growth.
- Recommendation: Keep debt sustainable by relying on concessional debt, limiting fiscal deficits to sustainable levels, and concentrating on boosting growth.

### Strengthening medium-term fiscal policy and spending capacity
- Fiscal policy objectives:
  - Target a moderate domestic primary balance.
  - Refocus domestic spending toward priority sectors.
  - Increase overall outlays in health, education, and public infrastructure with increased external support.
  - Use fiscal policy, supported by increased external assistance, temporarily to counter the decline in global demand—if well-targeted, implemented by sound institutions, and consistent with debt sustainability.
- Public capital spending:
  - Togo’s public capital spending among the lowest in WAEMU and sub-Saharan Africa.
  - Staff emphasized reallocating spending toward public infrastructure and priority social spending to underpin long-term growth and implement the PRS.
- Authorities’ stance:
  - Agree public investment spending needs to be boosted; for the medium term this boost expected to be financed by higher external grants and highly concessional loans.
  - Encouraged to reduce share of nonpriority current spending (such as untargeted transfers) and increase outlays on public infrastructure and human capital.
  - Action plan to strengthen project execution is important.

### Cash and debt management improvements
- Treasury is strengthening cash and debt management:
  - Implementing a new template to assess cash needs on an ongoing basis.
  - Testing a new Integrated Budget Execution and Reporting System (SIGFIP) to track revenue and spending throughout budget execution.
  - Issued short-term bills on the regional market for the first time in September 2008; issuance of 0.8 percent of GDP was well received by domestic banks.
  - Government planning additional issuances for 2009, partly to expedite clearance in cash of domestic arrears.
- Staff recommendations:
  - Ensure better coordination between line ministers and the Treasury on tracking priority spending.
  - Improvements needed before SIGFID/SIGFIP can become fully operational.
  - Improve and centralize debt data; explicitly define a debt strategy coordinated with cash flow needs that minimizes borrowing costs.
  - Centralize authority to contract debt on behalf of the government.

### Growth-friendly tax policy
- Current tax system described as complex and costly to administer, with an excessive number of rates and numerous exemptions.
- Authorities recognize need to streamline the tax system and further reduce rates, particularly for corporate and income tax.
- Management and computerization efforts reported to be reducing tax evasion, with scope for further progress.
- Plans discussed to enhance communication with the business community.

### Enhancing productivity, banking sector, and SOEs reforms
- Priorities to boost productivity and external competitiveness:
  - Restructure state-owned banks and enterprises.
  - Invest in public infrastructure and human capital.
  - Create a more favorable business environment.
- Banking sector:
  - High level of NPLs has hamstrung intermediation for decades; microfinance has partly compensated, especially in rural areas.
  - Securitization needed to restore credit flow; further steps required to resume sound lending to the private sector and address impediments to lending to SMEs and households.
  - Agreed priorities to improve credit access:
    - Implement recommendations of the regional banking commission on management and oversight.
    - Create a more predictable business environment.
    - Address bottlenecks to a well-developed collateral market, particularly impediments to land and real estate property rights.
    - Improve creditor protection and credit information.
  - Need for continued technical cooperation, including a possible FSAP once restructuring is complete.
- State-owned enterprises (electricity, water, telecommunications, phosphate):
  - Service quality low by regional standards, hampering growth and competitiveness; electricity shortages remain a medium-term risk despite new generators.
  - Staff encouraged aggressive steps to increase coverage and quality of electricity, water, and telecommunications.
  - Plans welcomed to increase electricity supply in 2009 through an independent power producer and to explore gas from Nigeria.
  - CEET: rates slightly below cost of production and large payment arrears from private and public sectors; staff discussed improving CEET management.
  - Mobile telephony could benefit from entry of a new provider to compete with the dominant state-owned provider.
- Phosphate sector:
  - High-quality phosphate production currently at less than a quarter of potential capacity.
  - Authorities plan to finalize a long-term reform strategy based on a World Bank-financed audit to attract strategic investors; achieving full capacity could increase GDP by as much as 2 percent.
  - Staff urged rapid rehabilitation of the phosphate sector and continued monitoring of SNPT finances and management.

### Competitiveness, REER, and external balance assessments
- Macro analyses suggest current account balance and exchange rate broadly in line with fundamentals:
  - REER has largely mirrored WAEMU-wide trends since devaluation; econometric estimates of EREER suggest the real exchange rate is not seriously misaligned despite a recent trend toward overvaluation.
  - Current account deficit comfortably financed by inflows through the capital and financial account, in particular project grants and concessional loans.
  - Macroeconomic balance approach indicates projected current account deficit would be in line with norms for a low income African country receiving aid inflows; sustainability depends on expected increase in aid inflows or non-debt-creating inflows such as FDI.
- Box 3 summary on REER:
  - REER on an upward trend since the 1994 devaluation; appreciation accelerated with the strength of the Euro.
  - Estimation using FEER approach (fundamentals: terms of trade, government spending, openness, real GDP per capita) suggests most long-term fluctuation explained by fundamentals.
  - Results indicate a slight overvaluation of the REER since 2005 that intensified in 2008.
  - Recent widening between REER and EREER attributed to 2008 inflationary pressures in Togo combined with Euro appreciation; with deceleration in inflation, Euro depreciation, and terms of trade improvement, REER expected to revert toward its equilibrium.

*Source: _cr09194 - 23.      Given planned growth-enhancing reforms, the economy could achieve real GDP*

### 44.      Policy Response and Authorities’ Views: The mission supported the authorities’

### Policy Response and Authorities’ Views: The mission supported the authorities’ plans to boost competitiveness and growth potential as embodied in the PRS

### Strategy priorities and competitiveness
- Authorities’ strategy focuses on three priorities:
  - (i) rehabilitating transport infrastructure;
  - (ii) providing quality education to more of the population (following the advice of the World Bank);
  - (iii) improving the business environment (through a new investment code, corporate tax reform, easier business registration, better allocation and recording of property rights, and—with the support of the EU—a more effective judicial system).
- On competitiveness:
  - Staff noted current account and real exchange rate appear sustainable, despite a recent trend toward real appreciation.
  - Togo’s competitiveness benefits from its low wage levels, especially considering educational attainment, relative to other WAEMU countries.
  - Staff advised that membership in the WAEMU currency zone continues to serve Togo’s economic interests as an anchor of stability; emphasis should be on implementation of agreed fiscal and structural policies to promote growth and productivity.

### Medium-term growth projections (selected items from Table 5 and Table 1)
- Real GDP (percent change): 2007: 1.9; 2008: 1.1; 2009: 1.7; 2010: 2.1; 2011: 4.1; 2012: 4.0; 2013: 4.0; 2014: 4.0.
- Real GDP per capita: 2007: 1.4; 2008: -0.6; 2009: -1.4; 2010: -0.8; 2011: -0.4.
- GDP deflator (percent change): 2007: 0.3; 2008: 1.3; 2009: 6.4; 2010: 1.8; 2011: 2.0.
- Consumer price index (annual average): 2007: 2.2; 2008: 1.0; 2009: 8.4; 2010: 2.8; 2011: 2.1.
- GDP (CFAF billions): 2006: 1,159.8; 2007: 1,197.7; 2008: 1,288.5; 2009: 1,333.7; 2010: 1,389.6.
- Exchange rate CFAF/US$ (annual average): 2006: 522.4; 2007: 478.5; 2008: 445.8.
- Real effective exchange rate (annual average): 2006: -1.4; 2007: 0.5; 2008: 0.1.
- Terms of trade (deterioration = –): 2006: 5.0; 2007: -10.5; 2008: -2.3; 2009: 7.2.

### Fiscal stance, revenue, and expenditure (selected items from Table 3)
- Total revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 2006: 18.3; 2007: 18.7; 2008: 18.7; 2009: 19.1; 2010: 21.9.
- Revenue (percent of GDP): 2006: 16.9; 2007: 17.0; 2008: 17.0; 2009: 16.9; 2010: 17.6.
- Total expenditure and net lending (percent of GDP): 2006: 22.1; 2007: 20.6; 2008: 19.7; 2009: 22.2; 2010: 23.9.
- Domestic primary expenditure (percent of GDP): 2006: 18.0; 2007: 16.7; 2008: 16.7; 2009: 17.5; 2010: 17.0.
- Overall balance (payment order basis, percent of GDP): 2006: -3.8; 2007: -1.9; 2008: -1.0; 2009: -3.1; 2010: -2.0.
- Primary balance  (revenue minus expenditure, excluding grants, interest, and foreign-financed expenditure): 2006: (not shown); 2007: -1.1; 2008: 0.2; 2009: 0.5; 2010: -0.6; 2011: 0.6 (as shown in Table 1 notes and columns).
- In CFAF billions (Table 3, 2010 column examples):
  - Revenue and grants: 223.7 (2007 actual), 232.8 (2008 prelim.), 241.0 (2009), 128.0 (H1-Prog.), 278.4 (Proj.), 254.3 (1st Rev.), 304.3 (Proj.).
  - Total revenue: 203.3; 209.8; 220.7; 108.0; 228.4; 225.7; 244.6.
  - Tax revenue: 195.9; 198.7; 211.2; 103.0; 215.4; 215.4; 233.4.
  - Grants (projects): 20.4; 23.0; 20.3; 20.0; 50.0; 28.7; 59.8.
  - Expenditures and net lending: 246.5; 269.3; 253.3; 154.9; 312.1; 296.2; 331.5.
  - Domestic primary expenditures: 200.5; 217.3; 214.8; 118.7; 228.4; 233.5; 236.2.
  - Wages and salaries: 64.3; 73.2; 69.1; 33.7; 78.0; 78.0; 83.2.
  - Public investment: 24.1; 63.4; 44.9; 51.0; 93.9; 74.2; 98.7.

### External sector, current account, trade, and reserves (selected items from Table 2 and Table 1)
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2006: -2.9; 2007: -3.9; 2008: -6.6; 2009: -6.1; 2010: -5.9.
- Exports (goods and services, percent of GDP): 2006: 24.7; 2007: 26.3; 2008: 23.5; 2009: 21.5; 2010: 26.7.
- Imports (goods and services, percent of GDP): 2006: 37.2; 2007: 40.0; 2008: 41.0; 2009: 37.6; 2010: 42.6.
- Trade balance (billions CFAF, Table 2): 2007: -119.7; 2008: -178.1; 2009: -179.3; 2010: -176.2.
- Exports (billions CFAF): 2007: 557.6; 2008: 470.9; 2009: 422.6; 2010: 556.6; 2011: 599.2; 2012: 646.8; 2013: 697.6; 2014: 752.6.
- Domestic exports (billions CFAF): 2007: 263.6; 2008: 245.9; 2009: 236.1; 2010: 317.0; 2011: 343.1; 2012: 366.0; 2013: 391.3; 2014: 417.7.
  - Of which cotton (billions CFAF): 2007: 12.0; 2008: 12.1; 2009: 7.0; 2010: 6.9; 2011: 7.3; 2012: 7.8; 2013: 8.2; 2014: 8.6.
  - Of which phosphates (billions CFAF): 2007: 15.0; 2008: 21.9; 2009: 16.9; 2010: 17.3; 2011: 18.8; 2012: 19.7; 2013: 20.9; 2014: 22.2.
  - Of which cement & clinker (billions CFAF): 2007: 71.9; 2008: 59.5; 2009: 59.5; 2010: 62.0; 2011: 65.8; 2012: 69.8; 2013: 74.0; 2014: 78.5.
- Transit and reexport (billions CFAF): 2007: 294.0; 2008: 225.0; 2009: 186.5; 2010: 239.6; 2011: 256.1; 2012: 280.8; 2013: 306.2; 2014: 334.9.
- Imports, f.o.b. (billions CFAF): 2007: -677.3; 2008: -649.0; 2009: -601.9; 2010: -732.8; 2011: -775.7; 2012: -830.9; 2013: -891.4; 2014: -952.9.
- Gross international reserves (months of imports): 2006: 3.4; 2007: 3.0; 2008: 4.4; 2009: 5.0; 2010: 4.7.

### External public debt and arrears (selected items from Table 1 and Table 6)
- External public debt (percent of GDP): 2006: 83.9; 2007: 79.2; 2008: 56.6; 2009: 53.0; 2010: 30.5.
- External arrears (percent of GDP, of which: arrears in Table 1): 2006: 29.5; 2007: 31.4; 2008: 0.0; 2009: 0.0; 2010: 0.0.
- External public debt service (percent of exports): 2006: 8.9; 2007: 7.5; 2008: 5.6; 2009: 5.9; 2010: 4.5.
- Table 6 (Official External Debt, 2007–10) (selected aggregates, exact formatting preserved in source):
  - Total nominal stock: 2,204.8 (CFAF Billions).
  - Multilateral: 1,124.1 (nominal stock).
  - Bilateral and commercial: 1,080.7 (nominal stock); Of which Paris Club: 964.3.
  - NPV of Debt and debt service rows are provided in the table (see source table for full breakdown by creditor).

### Monetary developments (Table 4 and Table on Monetary Survey)
- Net foreign assets (CFAF billions, Dec 2009 prelim. and projections):
  - Net foreign assets: 212.2 (2007), 215.9 (2008), 240.8 (2009), 249.5 (Dec. prelim.); Nov/Dec proj. 249.5.
  - BCEAO net foreign assets: 170.2; 165.5; 172.6; 195.6; 195.6.
  - Commercial banks net foreign assets (assets minus liabilities data included).
- Money supply (M2, CFAF billions): 464.5 (2007); 490.3 (2008); 481.3 (2009); 538.5 (H1-Prog.); 592.3 (Proj.).
- Annual change in money supply (percent of beginning-of-period broad money): Net foreign assets contribution: 1.4; 0.8; 6.2; 8.0; 0.0. Net domestic assets contribution: 16.9; 4.7; -2.5; 7.9; 10.0. Money supply (M2) growth: 18.2; 5.6; 3.6; 15.9; 10.0.
- Credit to the rest of the economy (annual change percent): 14.9; -0.7; 0.7; -2.5; 6.8.

### Program financing, PRGF disbursement schedule, and Fund obligations (Tables 7 and 8)
- Proposed schedule of disbursement under PRGF Arrangement, 2008–11 (Table 7, amount in SDRs and conditions):
  - SDR 13,260,000 (Original program), April 30, 2008: Executive Board approval of the three-year arrangement under the PRGF arrangement (April 23, 2008).
  - SDR 17,975,000 (with augmentation split): September 22, 2008; April 30, 2009 — contingent on observance of performance criteria and completion of respective reviews.
  - Subsequent disbursements of SDR 8,800,000 on October 31, 2009; April 30, 2010; October 31, 2010; April 30, 2011 — conditional on observance of performance criteria and completion of reviews under the PRGF arrangement.
- Indicators of capacity to repay the Fund (Table 8, 2006–16 projections summary highlights):
  - Fund obligations and outstanding Fund credit are presented in millions of SDRs and CFAF; detailed annual principal and charges projections provided for 2006–16.
  - Examples: Principal (SDRs) entries: 2006: 4.3; 2007: 4.3; 2008: 1.1; 2015: 6.3; 2016: 6.3; Charges and interest entries also shown.
  - Outstanding Fund credit (in millions of SDRs): 2006: 5.4; 2007: 1.1; 2008: 3.1; 2009: 8.0; 2010: 7.5; 2011: 6.8; 2012: 4.4; 2013: 4.4; 2014: 3.1; 2015: 5.0; 2016: 2.6; 2017: 4.6 (table extends through projections).
  - Memorandum items: Nominal GDP, Exports of goods and services, Government revenue, and Debt service (in CFAF billions) presented for projection years.

### WAEMU convergence criteria compliance (Table 9, selected ratios)
- Basic fiscal balance / GDP: 2004: 3.2; 2005: -1.0; 2006: -1.9; 2007: -0.6; 2008: 0.1; 2009 (Proj.): -1.5.
- Inflation (annual average percentage change): <=3 criterion; actual: 2004: 0.4; 2005: 6.8; 2006: 2.2; 2007: 1.0; 2008: 8.4; 2009 (Proj.): 2.8.
- Total nominal debt / GDP (<=70): 2004: 115.0; 2005: 110.8; 2006: 109.6; 2007: 103.9; 2008: 77.2; 2009 (Proj.): 78.9.
- Domestic arrears accumulation (in billions of CFA francs, <=0): 2004: 5.0; 2005: 20.7; 2006: -5.2; 2007: -9.3; 2008: 0.0; 2009 (Proj.): -12.6.
- External arrears accumulation (in billions of CFA francs, <=0): 2004: 12.1; 2005: 21.8; 2006: 21.2; 2007: 20.7; 2008: 0.3; 2009 (Proj.): 0.0.
- Secondary criteria such as Wages / fiscal revenue, Domestically financed investment / fiscal revenue, Current account deficit excl. official transfers / GDP, and Fiscal revenue / GDP are tabulated for 2004–09.

### HIPC floating completion point triggers (Table 10)
- Required measures for reaching the HIPC floating completion point include:
  - PRSP: Prepare a full PRSP through a participatory process and implement satisfactorily its recommended actions for at least one year, evidenced by an Annual Progress Report submitted by the Government to IDA and the IMF.
  - Macroeconomic stability: Maintain macroeconomic stability as evidenced by satisfactory performance under a PRGF-supported program.
  - Public financial management:
    - Adopt a mechanism to track public expenditures for poverty reduction on the basis of a functional expenditure classification and publish quarterly reports on these expenditures executed over at least six months preceding the completion point.
    - Nominate and install the judges for the Cour des Comptes, and submit the draft of the Loi de règlement and draft General Treasury Balance (Balance générale du Trésor) for a given fiscal year to the Cour des Comptes and Parliament within the statutorily-specified period (9 months after the end of that fiscal year) for at least one year immediately preceding the completion point.
    - Adopt a decree creating the Procurement Regulatory Authority in conformity with the WAEMU Procurement Directives, nominate its managerial staff, and provide them with an adequate budget; and monthly publication in a public procurement gazette or on a government website of all signed contracts, including sole source contracts and public concessions, for at least six months immediately preceding the completion point.
  - Governance:
    - Regular public reporting of payments to, and revenues received by, the government for the phosphates sector in line with the EITI criteria, including an annual report for at least the year immediately preceding the completion point.
  - Debt Management:
    - Consolidate external and domestic debt data under a single unit charged with all public debt management tasks.
    - Publish an annual report on a government website providing accurate and complete data on external and domestic public debt, including information on debt stocks, actual debt service, and new loans within six months after the end of the year, for at least one year immediately preceding the completion point.
  - Social sectors:
    - Increase domestically-funded health expenditures in the year prior to the completion point to at least 7.5 percent of actual domestic non-interest expenditures (the 2007 ratio was 5.7 percent).
    - Start implementation of the national education sector plan as evidenced by completing the training of at least 500 new teachers and the remedial training of at least 4,000 existing teachers.
- Note: The first two triggers (PRSP implementation and satisfactory macroeconomic performance) are requirements for reaching the completion point under the IMF PRGF-HIPC Trust Instrument.

### Social and MDG indicators (selected from Table 11)
- Employment to population ratio, 15+, total (%): 1990–2007 series entries include 65, 64, 63 (years indicated in table).
- Primary completion rate, total (% of relevant age group): 1990: 35; 1995: 39; 2000: 61; 2007: 67.
- Immunization, measles (% of children ages 12-23 months): 1990: 73; 1995: 53; 2000: 58; 2007: 83.
- Mortality rate, infant (per 1,000 live births): 1990: 88; 1995: 86; 2000: 78; 2007: 69.
- Mortality rate, under-5 (per 1,000): 1990: 149; 1995: 139; 2000: 124; 2007: 108.
- GNI per capita, Atlas method (current US$): 1990: 380; 1995: 280; 2000: 270; 2007: 360.
- Fertility rate, total (births per woman): 1990: 6.4; 1995: 5.5; 2000: 4.9.
- Life expectancy at birth, total (years): 58 (series entries).

*Source: IMF staff report material provided in the chapter "Policy Response and Authorities' Views" and associated tables from the IMF country report.*

### 1.      Further to my letter dated September 12

### 1.      Further to my letter dated September 12

### Background
- Program launched in 2006 as part of the government’s strategy to overcome the prolonged social, political, and economic crisis; aims to restore macroeconomic stability, rationalize public finances, and boost economic growth to raise living standards.
- Program is underpinned by the Interim Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (I-PRSP).
- Achievements: significant results toward restoring macroeconomic stability and rationalizing public finances despite external shocks (steep rise in world food and oil prices; severe flooding in August 2008).
- Program contributed to normalizing relations with external creditors and reaching the HIPC decision point in November 2008, opening the way for significant debt relief and financial and technical support.
- Program entering phase placing greater emphasis on accelerating growth and reducing poverty; economic growth outcomes have been mixed and the global slowdown threatens the expected pickup in growth.

### Recent economic developments
- Growth and inflation:
  - Growth rate in 2008 hovered around 1.1 percent, below the five-year average.
  - Inflation rose to a peak of 15.8 percent in August (year-on-year) before falling back to 8.4 percent at the end of the year.
- External and monetary developments:
  - Current account deficit projected at 6.6 percent of GDP in 2008, compared to 3.9 percent in 2007.
  - Increase in foreign assets and slow growth in domestic credit due to economic stagnation.
  - Money supply rose by 16 percent.
- Household purchasing power eroded following economic deterioration and rising prices.

### Implementation of the PRGF-supported program (outcomes and structural reforms)
- Overall program performance:
  - Strict implementation provided a flexible and sound macroeconomic environment, enabling management of external shocks and contributing to program objectives.
  - All performance criteria and quantitative indicators for end-December 2008 met, except the indicative target for the minimum level of domestically-financed social and capital spending.
  - All structural benchmarks achieved on time except one benchmark with a three-month delay.
- Public finances and fiscal management:
  - Improvement driven by strong mobilization of domestic resources and solid control over recurrent expenditure; execution of capital expenditure was low.
  - Primary balance stands at 0.4 percent of GDP.
  - Government’s net position with the banking system improved.
  - No accumulation of payment arrears; government has neither issued nor guaranteed external debt on non-concessional terms.
  - Revenue collection strengthened by tax and customs administration reforms and progressive computerization of customs operations.
- Public financial management reforms:
  - Strategy for clearing domestic arrears adopted by the Council of Ministers in December 2008 (met a performance criterion); national commission to clear domestic debt set up.
  - 2009 budget includes measures to reduce tax and customs exemptions in the Free Economic Zone (met a structural benchmark six months ahead of schedule).
  - General Tax Code being updated to incorporate amendments made since 1998.
- Financial sector repair and bank restructuring:
  - In November and December (year implied 2008), government initiated securitization of non-performing loans (NPLs) validated as at December 31, 2007, under a Memorandum of Understanding with the banking pool (BTCI, UTB, BIA-TOGO, and ECOBANK-TOGO) — met a structural benchmark.
    - 35 percent discount on government loans.
    - Bonds amount to 7 percent of GDP.
    - Allowed three banks to meet the 8 percent minimum coverage requirement for the risk-to-equity ratio.
    - Bonds eligible for refinancing by the Central Bank (BCEAO) and will be reimbursed over a period of seven years, after a one-year grace period.
  - Government exploring, with the World Bank, creation of a structure/mechanism to recover banks’ NPLs on behalf of the government.
- State-owned enterprise (SOE) reforms:
  - Strategic audit of the phosphate sector launched with World Bank support in January 2009, three months later than planned; final report could be available by the end of April 2009.
  - Review of CEET’s financial situation completed in December 2008 and a performance-based contract signed (met a structural benchmark); strategic and financial audit of CEET to begin in consultation with the World Bank.
  - Cotton sector: SOTOCO liquidated; new cotton company set up and to be rescaled for financial viability; mechanism for indexing cottonseed producer prices to world prices endorsed and to be operational during the 2009/10 crop season.
- Measures to protect vulnerable populations in 2008:
  - No price controls imposed; targeted measures included subsidies on seeds and fertilizers, swift payment of retirement pension arrears, sale of security stockpiles of foodstuffs in most affected areas.
  - Lump-sum grants issued to civil servants for last five months of 2008; replaced in 2009 budget by a cut in personal income tax (IRPP).
  - Guaranteed Minimum Wage (SMIG, SMAG) raised as of August 1, 2008.
  - Corporate tax rate reduced by seven percentage points; maximum rate is 33 percent as of January 2009.
- Fuel pricing mechanism and contingent liabilities:
  - Price adjustment mechanism between government and oil companies uses benchmark import price range (changes exceeding plus or minus 5 percent); oil companies’ operating margin set at 35 CFA francs per liter.
  - Government kept retail fuel prices at November 2006 level during rising world oil prices, generating accumulated shortfalls to oil distributors.
  - Audit calculated net shortfalls incurred by fuel importers totaled 1.5 percent of GDP.
  - Government decided to keep retail price above world levels; resulting surpluses will be used to clear deficit to oil companies within 20 months, in consultation with companies.
  - Government intends to review pump price setting mechanism to avoid creating a contingent liability.

### Macroeconomic outlook and 2009 projections
- Growth and inflation:
  - Growth in 2009 projected at 1.7 percent, described as sluggish owing to the global economic slowdown.
  - Recent easing of externally induced inflationary pressures should help bring inflation below the 3 percent threshold set in the WAEMU pact.
- External accounts:
  - Significant improvement in the terms of trade expected to reduce current account deficit to about 6.1 percent of GDP despite higher capital spending.
- Risks:
  - Expected reductions in migrants’ remittances, declines in demand for transit and warehousing services, and drops in phosphate, cement, and clinker exports.
  - Close monitoring of development assistance and private transfers for possible declines.

### Implementation of the PRGF-supported program in 2009 — fiscal stance, financing, and reform priorities
- Fiscal projections and financing:
  - Government revenues projected at 16.9 percent of GDP (comparable to last year) due to fiscal reforms, tax base broadening (including Free Economic Zone), and administrative capacity building; global crisis is a downside risk to revenue projections.
  - Expenditures projected at 22.2 percent of GDP, i.e., up by 2.5 percentage points from 2008.
  - Primary fiscal balance projected to remain at a level equivalent to −0.6 percent of GDP.
  - Increase planned in cash-settled arrears from 0.5 to 1.0 percent of GDP; government has approached development partners to explore additional budget support to increase this amount.
  - Financing of deficit expected from budget support from partners including the European Union (EU), the World Bank, the African Development Bank, France, China, and other bilateral partners.
  - To accelerate emergency repairs and clearance of domestic arrears, plan to issue in the first half of the year a six-month T-bill for about 1.3 percent of GDP.
  - Investment spending financed domestically and externally will be boosted by one percentage point of GDP each; part of the increase will come from a supplementary budget (collectif budgétaire) planned for Q2 to use remaining emergency 2008 spending exclusively for priority infrastructure projects.
- Key structural and public financial management reforms planned for 2009:
  - Treasury reform and information:
    - Before end-June 2009, make operational the new Treasury structure consistent with WAEMU directives (structural performance criterion).
    - Treasury to validate entry items in the Treasury balance sheet and start producing monthly treasury balances with a lag of one month, as of April.
  - Domestic arrears:
    - Implement strategy to clear domestic arrears by the amounts provided in the budget and supplementary budget; securitize arrears to suppliers validated by the KPMG audit by December 2009 (structural benchmark).
  - Public debt management:
    - Ensure financing needs met through grants or highly concessional loans to preserve public debt sustainability.
    - National Public Debt Committee set up to develop, coordinate, and monitor national policy for assumption and management of public debt (contributes to structural benchmark).
  - Aid absorptive capacity and cash management:
    - Action plan launched to strengthen capacity for quick and effective project implementation to enhance aid absorptive capacity for Emergency Program and flood repairs; measures to be accompanied by cash management reforms to ensure resource availability.
  - Public procurement and audit:
    - New public procurement law to be passed in June 2009 to enhance public expenditure control and efficiency of public investment outlays.
    - Remaining structural reforms for June 2009 include enactment of new law on the Court of Auditors, appointment of judges to this body, preparation of 2007 management accounts, and the Loi de règlement (budget reconciliation law) for 2007—actions to move Togo toward the HIPC completion point.
- Bank restructuring measures for 2009:
  - Strategic investors:
    - Initial call for proposals for strategic investors in four major state-owned banks to be completed before end of year (structural benchmark); government to engage investment banks with World Bank support.
    - Government to maintain close oversight of banks’ management through the process.
  - NPL management mechanism:
    - By December, government will set up structure and mechanism for managing NPLs exchanged against government bonds (revised structural benchmark); timetable extended by four months given operation complexity and World Bank technical assistance.
    - Mechanism intended to allow government to recover part of cost of recapitalizing banks and reduce cross-debts, helping to revitalize credit channels.

*Italic: Source document — content unit _cr09194 - 1.      Further to my letter dated September 12 (IMF PDF).*

### 21.      Maintaining sound public finances and reviving growth will require reforms to state-

### _cr09194 - 21.      Maintaining sound public finances and reviving growth will require reforms to state-

### Reforms to state-owned enterprises (SOEs)
- Objective: restore financial health of SOEs, guard against future losses, and promote gains in production and productivity.
- Cotton company:
  - The government intends to assist the new cotton company to obtain the credit necessary to complete its operations in its first year, but that assistance will remain consistent with the current fiscal framework.
- Phosphate sector:
  - The government will prepare a development strategy for the phosphate sector based on the strategic audit, no later than September 2009 (structural benchmark).
  - The final report could be available by the end of April 2009.
  - The strategic audit will help shape the overall restructuring of the sector and facilitate the search for a strategic partner.
  - The strategic audit is under way; the World Bank is supporting government efforts in this area.
- Energy sector:
  - A review of the finances of the national electricity company (CEET) was completed; the preliminary report was submitted in December 2008 and the final report was concluded on February 12, 2009 and submitted to the World Bank.

### External support, debt, and HIPC initiative
- Development partner support:
  - Continued support is needed from development partners who agreed in Brussels in September 2008 to mobilize resources in the context of the resumption of international cooperation and in accordance with the principles of the Paris Declaration and the Accra Agenda for Action.
  - Beyond resources required for clearance of arrears and debt servicing, Togo needs immediate new resources (in the form of grants or concessional loans) to finance investments essential to improve economic infrastructure, deliver social services, reduce poverty, and achieve the MDGs.
  - Partners have decided to increase the level of aid and to ensure maximum flexibility in their procedures.
- HIPC initiative:
  - Togo is determined to meet its floating completion point triggers under the HIPC initiative as early as possible in 2010.
- HIPC implementation data (as presented):
  - Assistance committed by all creditors (US$ Million): 270.000
  - Of which: IMF assistance (US$ million): 0.31
  - (SDR equivalent in millions): 0.21
  - Completion point date: Floating
  - Disbursement of IMF assistance (SDR Million): Total disbursements: 0.04

### Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP) progress
- Status: Work on preparing the full Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper is far advanced.
- Process:
  - Participatory approach involving all segments of society; thematic studies with input from civil society organizations.
  - Regional consultations on the preliminary draft of the F-PRSP have been held.
- Timeline:
  - The document will be sent to the National Assembly for consideration before submission for national validation and adoption by the Council of Ministers, no later than April 30, 2009.

### PRGF-supported program monitoring and requests
- Monitoring:
  - Progress under the PRGF-supported program will be monitored against the revised end-June PC and end-December 2009 quantitative PCs understandings reached with the mission.
  - The government would like the fourth review under the arrangement to be completed by the end of April, 2010.
- Requests:
  - The government requests the completion of the second review.
  - The government requests disbursement of the third loan, including the augmentation approved by the IMF Board during the first PRGF review.
- Government commitment:
  - The government is convinced that the measures and policies set out in the Letter of Intent are sufficient to achieve the program’s objectives and stands ready to take any additional steps needed.
  - The government will consult with the IMF in advance of any additional measure or revisions to the policies set out in the Letter of Intent.
  - The government authorizes the IMF to publish its staff report and the Letter of Intent related to the discussions on the second review of the program.

### Quantitative performance criteria and indicative targets (Billion CFA francs, cumulative from end of preceding year)
- Table header context: 2009 June Prog., Dec. 2008 June 30, 2008 - December 31, 2009
- Performance criteria (for end-June, end-December 2008, and end-June 2009; indicative targets otherwise):
  - Domestic primary fiscal balance (floor): -4.5 28.3 -7.6 5.6 -10.7 -7.8
  - Nonaccumulation of external arrears (Continuous performance criterion): 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
  - Net domestic financing (ceiling): -3.1 -31.5 -7.5 -12.6 10.0 4.0
  - Central government contracting or guaranteeing of nonconcessional external debt (ceiling): 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
- Indicative Targets:
  - Total revenue (floor): 103.6 109.6 209.8 220.7 108.0 225.7
  - Domestic payments arrears, changes in stock (ceiling): 0.0 -3.1 -3.1 0.0 0.0 0.0
  - Domestically financed social and capital spending (floor): 48.9 34.7 99.7 82.8 50.3 120.7
  - Projected program financing...: 16.4 32.3 32.3 24.1 37.4

### Structural conditionality and status (selected measures from 2008 and 2009)
- Fiscal governance (2008 measures and status):
  - Implement a new framework for monthly monitoring of budget execution and report data for April-June 2008 based on a new template. Benchmark August 2008. Status: Done: July 2008.
  - Create a General Inspectorate of Finance under the responsibility of the Minister of Finance. Performance criterion August 2008. Status: Done. Decree adopted on July 23. The Inspector General was appointed on August 29.
  - Adopt a new strategy and timetable for clearing domestic arrears. Performance criterion December 2008. Status: Done. Strategy approved on December 9 2008.
- Financial sector (2008 measures and status):
  - Change management and oversight of BTCI based on terms of reference prepared in consultation with the WAEMU Banking Commission. Prior action for PRGF approval. Status: Done: February 2008.
  - Adopt an action plan for introducing regular Treasury bill auctions in 2009. Benchmark December 2008. Status: Done. The Treasury has agreed with the BCEAO on a framework for issuing T-bills on a regular basis in 2009, following one initial issue this year.
- Public enterprises (2008 measures and status):
  - Initiate an audit of the phosphate sector, based on competitive selection of an audit company, in consultation with the World Bank. Benchmark October 2008. Status: Done late. Audit firm selected and work under way.
  - Prepare a review of the finances of CEET in consultation with the World Bank. Benchmark December 2008. Status: Done. Preliminary report submitted December 2008; final report concluded on February 12, 2009 and submitted to the World Bank.
- Structural conditionality for 2009 (selected measures and status):
  - Reduce tax and customs exemptions and strengthen tax and customs control, including enterprises licensed in the Free Economic Zone. Benchmark June 2009. Rationale: To limit leakage of tax-exempt goods into the domestic economy and reduce fiscal revenues loss. Status: Done. Tax exemptions reduced in the 2009 budget law; customs and tax authorities have inspection power in the Free Economic Zone.
  - Make operational a new Treasury structure based on WAEMU directives. Performance criterion June 2009. Rationale: Create a functioning Treasury for timely payments and avoid arrears. Status: On track. The Treasury reorganization began in 2008.
  - Start implementing the domestic arrears clearance strategy by securitizing validated arrears and setting up a mechanism for monitoring domestic debt. Benchmark December 2009. Rationale: Move toward a sustainable debt position and prevent new arrears. Status: On track. Overall strategy adopted in November 2008; National Debt Management Council instituted in January 2009.
  - Initiate restructuring of BTCI, including by raising its capital through issuance of government securities. Benchmark March 2009. Rationale: Support BTCI rehabilitation and prepare it for privatization. Status: Done. Remarkable progress in preparing the exchange of BTCI's NPLs against government securities as part of a broader multi-bank scheme.
  - Set up a structure and mechanism for managing the NPLs exchanged against government securities. Benchmark December 2009 (revised from August). Rationale: Recover part of the budgetary cost of securitizing NPLs and reduce stock of SOE arrears and cross-debts. Status: On track; timetable extended by four months.
  - Initiate the process of identifying strategic investors for state-owned banks. Benchmark December 2009. Rationale: Reduce risks to macroeconomic stability caused by loss-making state-owned banks and support expansion of financial intermediation. Status: On track. World Bank supporting efforts.
  - Phosphate sector: Prepare a development strategy based on the strategic audit. Benchmark September 2009. Rationale: Promote transparency; sector could generate additional exports of up to 10 percent of GDP at current world prices. Status: On track. Strategic audit is under way; World Bank support noted.

### Relations with the Fund (selected operational and financial data, as of February 28, 2009)
- Membership status: Joined August 1, 1962; Article VIII.
- General Resources Account (SDR million; Percent of quota):
  - Quota: 73.40 (100.00)
  - Fund holdings of currency: 73.07 (99.55)
  - Reserve Position: 0.33 (0.45)
- SDR Department (SDR million; Percent of allocation):
  - Net cumulative allocation: 10.98 (100.00)
  - Holdings: 0.05 (0.50)
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans (SDR million; Percent of quota):
  - PRGF Arrangements: 31.24 (42.55)
- Financial Arrangements (selected):
  - PRGF: Approval Apr 21, 2008; Expiration Apr 20, 2011; Amount Approved 84.41 (SDR million); Amount Drawn 31.24 (SDR million).
- Projected payments to the Fund (SDR million; based on existing use of resources and present holdings of SDRs):
  - Principal forthcoming 2009: 1.33
  - Charges/Interest forthcoming 2009–2013: 0.20 0.22 0.22 0.22 0.22
  - Total forthcoming 2009–2013 (as shown): 0.20 0.22 0.22 0.22 1.54
- Exchange arrangement:
  - Togo is a member of WAEMU; common currency CFA franc pegged to the euro at CFAF 655.957 = EUR 1.
  - On April 28, 2006, the rate of the CFA franc in terms of SDR was CFAF 769.68 = SDR 1.0.
  - Effective January 1, 2007, the exchange arrangement of the WAEMU countries reclassified to the category of conventional pegged arrangement.
- Safeguards assessments:
  - Most recent safeguards assessment of the BCEAO completed on November 4, 2005; progress noted and vulnerabilities remain in internal control systems and legal structure.
- Article IV Consultation:
  - Togo is on the standard 24-month Article IV consultation cycle. The Executive Board completed the last 2007 Article IV consultation on June 8, 2007.

*Prepared by the African Department, April 8, 2009 — INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND: TOGO — 2009 Article IV Consultation and Second Review Under the Three-Year Arrangement Under the Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility—Informational Annex*

### 1.      Over the last decade and a half, Togo has been trapped in a cycle of political

### 1.      Over the last decade and a half, Togo has been trapped in a cycle of political instability, economic decline, rising poverty, and donor disengagement.

### Background and re-engagement
- Togo was in non-accrual status with the International Development Association (IDA) from May 2002 to May 2008.
- During the non-accrual period, the Bank continued analytical and advisory activities (AAA) on key aspects of socioeconomic development and supported Government efforts to prepare its I-PRSP and development strategies in health, education, agriculture and rural development, and HIV/AIDS.
- Prior to the May 2008 re-engagement, the Bank’s principal means of support was grants under the Low Income Country Under Stress (LICUS) Initiative. Since 2005, six grants have been provided.
- Three of these six grants supported a community-driven Emergency Program for Poverty Reduction (EPPR) aimed at halting the decline into extreme poverty and deterioration of social indicators.
- Three additional LICUS projects aimed to:
  - (a) reform and revive key sectors and create an environment for private sector-led growth (focusing on phosphates, cotton, coffee, cocoa, and energy as well as on public procurement reforms);
  - (b) preserve human capital (by minimizing the threat posed by Avian Influenza);
  - (c) achieve quick visible results on the ground (through an urban poverty infrastructure grant).

### World Bank Group strategy (Interim Strategy Note, May 2008)
- The ISN sets out the Bank Group’s plan to help Togo recover from instability and lay foundations for sustained, shared growth over the medium term (June 2008 through FY10).
- ISN support is under three main pillars in line with the I-PRSP priorities:
  - (i) improve governance and transparency;
  - (ii) promote the return to private sector-led growth;
  - (iii) provide for urgent social needs.
- The ISN builds on a Development Policy Needs Review (DPNR) prepared and discussed with the Government in early 2008.
- The three pillars are supported through:
  - (i) assistance for the clearance of Togo’s arrears to IDA;
  - (ii) investment projects, development policy operations and LICUS trust fund grants to provide financial and technical support for the Government’s reform program under the three pillars;
  - (iii) analytical and advisory activities to inform policy dialogue and the Government’s reform agenda, including preparation of the full PRSP.
- Complementary regional activities: transport and transit facilitation, energy and mining.

Pillar 1 — Improve Governance and Transparency
- Focus on supporting Government reforms to improve governance, transparency and efficiency in public expenditure management and structural reforms in phosphates, energy, cotton and financial sector.
- Expected outcomes: strengthened fiscal sustainability, enhanced transparency of State institutions and processes, improved economic governance and increased economic growth.
- Instruments and activities:
  - first ERGG (Economic Recovery and Governance Grant) approved on May 29, 2008, that enabled Togo to clear its arrears to IDA and normalize relations with the Bank;
  - two annual development policy operations;
  - a Financial Sector and Governance Reform Technical Assistance project to support banking, social security and microfinance institutions restructuring and recovery;
  - ongoing analytical and advisory work including a Trust Fund grant for Statistical Capacity Building, support to strengthen debt management capacity, and an updated Public Expenditure Management and Financial Review (PEMFAR).

Pillar 2 — Promote the Return to Private Sector-led Growth
- Private-sector development identified as critical to recovery and growth.
- Diagnostic and analytical tools: Country Economic Memorandum on the Sources of Growth, an Investment Climate Assessment and a Diagnostic Trade Integration Study.
- Lending and projects:
  - Support to Growth-inducing Sectors Project (focus: agricultural productivity and diversification; port infrastructure);
  - Emergency Infrastructure Rehabilitation and Energy project (energy investments; upgrade roads and sanitation in selected urban areas);
  - participation in the regional Abidjan-Lagos Transit and Transport Facilitation Project and a possible Adjarala Hydroelectric Project.
- Energy sector: ongoing advisory assistance in support of the West Africa Regional Power Pool.

Pillar 3 — Provide for Urgent Social Needs
- Focus on increasing supply of, and improving access to, basic social services for the most vulnerable and delivering visible results.
- Activities: rebuild local basic services delivery systems, improve access to economic opportunities, address urgent infrastructure rehabilitation in poorest areas of Lomé.
- Scale-up: Community Development Project approved in June 2008 to build on approaches implemented since 2004 through LICUS grants.
- Additional financing: In October 2008, IDA approved an additional US$7 million grant under the Global Food Crisis Response Program to complement the Community Development Project and support efforts to manage global food price shocks.

Other social and analytical support
- Strengthening poverty diagnosis, information systems, and statistical capacities:
  - Core Welfare Indicator Questionnaire survey carried out in 2006.
  - Background study on the sources of growth conducted with UNDP as input to the full PRSP.
  - Preparation of a Country Environmental Assessment Note to monitor ISN activities’ environmental impact.

### IMF–World Bank collaboration
- During re-engagement, IMF and World Bank staffs established collaborative support for the Government’s macroeconomic and structural reforms, following guidelines for enhanced Bank-Fund collaboration.
- Coordination features:
  - Bank staff participation in Fund program review missions;
  - IMF staff participation in Bank internal review meetings on key operations or studies.
- Division of lead roles:
  - IMF leads on macroeconomic stabilization;
  - World Bank leads on social and structural areas;
  - close collaboration on structural areas critical to macroeconomic stability (notably financial sector reforms).
- Consistency: Fund’s dialogue and conditionality are consistent with structural programs agreed with the Bank; Bank’s policy framework is elaborated consistent with the Government’s macroeconomic framework agreed with the Fund.
- Joint work: regional Financial Sector Assessment; cooperation in debt analysis and bringing Togo to the HIPC Decision Point in November 2008.

- Contact person: Madani Tall, Country Director (225-22400401), and Philip English, Lead Economist (202-473-6483).

*Source: IMF/World Bank staff report excerpt.* 

### Statistical issues and data quality
- General adequacy: Data provision is broadly adequate for surveillance, but weaknesses in quality and timeliness hamper staff analysis.
- Specific weaknesses:
  - National accounts and balance of payments statistics compiled based on very limited information, with only few surveys and scarce data on primary agriculture and private sector services.
  - Government finance statistics derived from a weak accounting system.
  - Monetary data reported by the BCEAO with a two-month lag.
- GDDS participation: Country has participated in the General Data Dissemination System (GDDS) since November 2001. Metadata last updated in December 2004.

National accounts and CPI
- WAEMU SNA implementation: Togo embarked in late 2002 on implementing the System of National Accounts 1993 (1993 SNA) using ERETES software.
- NA base year and updates:
  - NA for the new base year (2000) were completed in 2005.
  - Program suspended thereafter; NA for 2001 was not finalized.
  - A West Afritac mission in March 2009 trained staff in 1993 SNA and ERETES, and recommended compiling NA for 2007 and then preparing NA series for missing years as an abridged version.
- Commitment and publications:
  - Authorities demonstrated stronger commitment to implement the 1993 SNA.
  - National Statistics Office (NSO) website has not been updated since June 2008.
  - There is no hard copy publication on NA.

External sector statistics
- Balance of payments and international investment position compiled from bank reports, enterprise survey, and customs data; compiled with a six-month delay and revised twice a year.
- STA technical assistance mission in September 2008 found significant recent progress, particularly on informal trade, following establishment of subregional unit for reconciliation of intra-WAMU trade.
- Trade in services and remittances appear well covered.
- External trade on oil products was the subject of a BCEAO study leading to important revisions and more appropriate reporting by the National Accounts Directorate.
- Data on treatment of regional banknotes provided by BCEAO headquarters need review at Headquarters level.

Government accounts and public debt data
- Improvements underway in Government finance statistics accounting system.
- New WAEMU budget nomenclature permits economic and functional classification of expenditure.
- Monthly TOFE (Table of Central Government Financial Operations) is based on a mixture of administrative and accounting data and is sent to AFR with a two-month lag.
- Inconsistencies in domestic arrears records held by different units of the Ministry of Finance and the stock of domestic debt have been audited and a new database is being set up.
- Comprehensive external debt data and projections on a loan by loan basis are compiled regularly.
- Only budgetary central government data are reported for publication in the Government Finances Statistics Yearbook (GFSY); government finance high frequency data are not reported for publication in the IFS.

### 6. Monthly data for Togo, along with data for other members of the West African

### _cr09194 - 6. Monthly data for Togo, along with data for other members of the West African

### Monthly data dissemination and monetary statistics
- Monthly data for Togo and other members of the West African Monetary Union are regularly disseminated by the Central Bank of the West African Monetary Union (BCEAO) with a lag of about two months.
- Data on lending and borrowing rates charged by domestic banks are not compiled.
- In August 2006 the BCEAO reported to STA monetary data for June 2006 for all member countries (including Togo) using Standardized Report Forms (1SR-central bank, 2SR-other depository corporations, and 5SR-monetary aggregates).
- In response to STA’s comments, the BCEAO provided a revised 1SR and indicated that 2SR was being revised.
- Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (As of March 31, 2009) — selected reporting details:
  - Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation December 2008; Date received February 2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Not published.
  - International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: Date of latest observation December 2008; Date received March 2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Not published.
  - Reserve/Base Money: December 2008; March 2009; M; Q; Not published.
  - Broad Money: December 2008; March 2009; M; Q; Not published.
  - Central Bank Balance Sheet: December 2008; March 2009; M; Q; Not published.
  - Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: December 2008; March 2009; M; SA; Not published.
  - Interest Rates: December 2008; March 2009; M; Q; Not published.
  - Consumer Price Index: December 2008; February 2009; M; SA; Not published.
  - Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing – General Government: December 2008; February 2009; M; M; Not published.
  - Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing – Central Government: December 2008; February 2009; M; M; Not published.
  - Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt: December 2008; February 2009; M; M; Not published.
  - External Current Account Balance: 2007; August 2009; A; OM; Not published.
  - Exports and Imports of Goods and Services: Dec 2008; February 2009; M; OM; Not published.
  - GDP/GNP: 2007; June 2008; A; OM; Not published.
  - Gross External Debt: December 2008; February 2009; A; OM; Not published.
  - International Investment Position: 2007; July 2008.

### Executive Board conclusions, PRGF review, and disbursement
- IMF Executive Board concluded the 2009 Article IV consultation with Togo on April 21, 2009, and completed the second review of Togo’s performance under its Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility (PRGF) arrangement.
- The Executive Board completed the second review and approved an immediate disbursement equivalent to SDR 17.9 million (about US$26.6 million), bringing total disbursements to SDR49.2 million (about US$72.9 million).
- The three-year PRGF arrangement for Togo was approved in April 2008 in an amount equivalent to SDR 66.06 million (about US$108.4 million). In September 2008, the Board approved an increase by SDR18.3 million (about US$29 million).

### Background, recent performance, and risks
- Since 2006 Togo embarked on political and economic reforms; PRGF-supported program implemented strongly since its launch in 2008 despite global price shocks and heavy flooding.
- Growth reached 1.1 percent in 2008.
- All quantitative targets and structural benchmarks for the second review were met, except:
  - Indicative target for social and investment spending was undershot.
  - Delay in launching a study of the phosphate sector.
- Priority spending fell below target largely due to slow implementation of emergency repairs after the 2008 floods, highlighting capacity constraints.
- Inflation peaked in August 2008 and dropped back to 8.4 percent by year-end.
- Current account deficit in 2008 was 6.6 percent of Gross Domestic Product.
- Outlook and risks:
  - Growth projected at 1.7 percent in 2009 and 2.1 percent in 2010.
  - Improving terms of trade in 2009 expected to narrow the current account deficit slightly to about 6 percent.
  - Major risks: worsening global recession, heavier-than-expected impact depressing growth and revenues, delays in private sector involvement in restructuring state-owned banks and enterprises, and potential political uncertainty related to the run-up to the 2010 presidential elections.

### Executive Board assessment and policy guidance
- Directors commended Togolese authorities for strong implementation of economic policy and reforms despite adverse circumstances.
- Near-term: manage lower demand for export commodities and maintain prudent fiscal response.
- Supported modest fiscal loosening for 2009, including:
  - Shifting unspent money intended for emergency projects from 2008 to 2009.
  - Increasing the share of domestic arrears cleared in cash.
- Encouraged strengthening project execution and procurement processes with development partners’ support.
- Recommended reviewing the oil pricing mechanism to avoid accumulation of contingent public liabilities.
- Supported structural reform priorities:
  - Consolidating fiscal governance.
  - Reforming state-owned phosphate sector following strategic audit.
  - Restructuring the financial sector, including recapitalization of state-owned banks and attracting strategic investors.
- Emphasized improvements in the investment climate, delivery of basic services, and public investment in education, health and infrastructure.
- Noted projected increases in external assistance are essential to finance increased investment and social spending sustainably.
- Underlined importance of prudent debt management strategy to maintain robust debt sustainability over the medium term.

### Program agenda and policy measures for 2009 (authorities’ priorities)
- Increase public investment spending to support growth, financed by growing external assistance and shifting unspent 2008 emergency funds to 2009.
- Address capacity constraints in project execution with development partners’ support.
- Accelerate structural reforms in the banking sector, public finances, and state-owned enterprises.
- Increase the share of domestic arrears cleared in cash to alleviate liquidity and credit shortage in the private sector.
- Fiscal policy objectives:
  - Improve absorptive capacity and support recovery while preserving macro stabilization gains.
  - Issue six-month T-bills amounting to about 1.3 percent of GDP to accelerate emergency infrastructure repairs and clearance of domestic arrears.
  - Key fiscal reforms: make operational the new Treasury structure (in conformity with WAEMU directives); enhance efficiency of investment outlays and public financial management through procurement reform; make operational the Cour des Comptes.
- Bank restructuring:
  - Complete proposals for strategic investors in the four major state-owned banks.
  - Set up, with World Bank and Fund technical assistance, a mechanism for managing NPLs exchanged against government bonds.
- SOE reforms:
  - Continue reforms in cotton and electricity sectors.
  - Support new cotton company in obtaining credit.
  - Prepare a development strategy for the phosphate sector based on the strategic audit.
- Poverty reduction and HIPC:
  - Full PRSP to be submitted for national validation and adoption by the Council of Ministers by end of the month (month referenced in source).
  - Procurement Regulatory Agency to be set by end-April 2009.
  - Cour des Comptes operational in June 2009.
  - Annual report on revenues from, and payments to, the phosphate company, in line with EITI criteria, to be published.

### Selected economic and financial indicators (2006–10) — key figures
- Real GDP: 2006 Act. 3.9; 2007 Prel. 1.9; 2008 Proj. 1.1; 2009 Proj. 1.7; 2010 Proj. 2.1.
- Real GDP per capita: 2006 1.4; 2007 -0.6; 2008 -1.4; 2009 -0.8; 2010 -0.4.
- GDP deflator: 2006 0.3; 2007 1.3; 2008 6.4; 2009 1.8; 2010 2.0.
- Consumer price index (annual average): 2006 2.2; 2007 1.0; 2008 8.4; 2009 2.8; 2010 2.1.
- GDP (CFAF billions): 2006 1,159.8; 2007 1,197.7; 2008 1,288.5; 2009 1,333.7; 2010 1,389.6.
- Exchange rate CFAF/US$ (annual average): 2006 522.4; 2007 478.5; 2008 445.8.
- Terms of trade (deterioration = –): 2006 5.0; 2007 -10.5; 2008 -2.3; 2009 7.2.
- Monetary survey (percent of broad money at the beginning of the period):
  - Net foreign assets: 2006 19.2; 2007 1.4; 2008 8.0; 2009 0.0; 2010 4.7.
  - Credit to government: 2006 -0.7; 2007 1.1; 2008 15.4; 2009 2.7; 2010 -0.3.
  - Credit to the nongovernment sector: 2006 0.4; 2007 14.9; 2008 -2.5; 2009 6.8; 2010 7.1.
  - Broad money (M2): 2006 22.1; 2007 18.2; 2008 15.9; 2009 10.0; 2010 10.0.
  - Velocity (GDP/ end-of-period M2): 2006 3.0; 2007 2.6; 2008 2.4; 2009 2.3; 2010 2.2.
- Investment and savings (Percent of GDP):
  - Gross domestic investment: 2006 12.8; 2007 12.1; 2008 12.2; 2009 15.8; 2010 16.6.
  - Government investment: 2006 3.4; 2007 2.0; 2008 3.5; 2009 5.6; 2010 7.1.
  - Nongovernment investment: 2006 9.4; 2007 10.1; 2008 8.7; 2009 10.2; 2010 9.5.
  - Gross national savings: 2006 9.9; 2007 8.2; 2008 5.5; 2009 9.7; 2010 10.7.
- Government budget (Percent of GDP):
  - Total revenue and grants: 2006 18.3; 2007 18.7; 2008 18.7; 2009 19.1; 2010 21.9.
  - Revenue: 2006 16.9; 2007 17.0; 2008 17.1; 2009 16.9; 2010 17.6.
  - Total expenditure and net lending: 2006 22.1; 2007 20.6; 2008 19.7; 2009 22.2; 2010 23.9.
  - Domestic primary expenditure: 2006 18.0; 2007 16.7; 2008 16.7; 2009 17.5; 2010 17.0.
  - Overall balance (payment order basis): 2006 -3.8; 2007 -1.9; 2008 -1.0; 2009 -3.1; 2010 -2.0.
  - Primary balance (revenue minus expenditure, excluding grants, interest, and foreign-financed expenditure): 2006 -1.1; 2007 0.2; 2008 0.5; 2009 -0.6; 2010 0.6.
  - Change in domestic arrears: 2006 -0.4; 2007 -0.8; 2008 0.0; 2009 -0.9; 2010 -0.7.
- External sector (Percent of GDP):
  - Current account balance: 2006 -2.9; 2007 -3.9; 2008 -6.6; 2009 -6.1; 2010 -5.9.
  - Exports (goods and services): 2006 24.7; 2007 26.3; 2008 23.5; 2009 21.5; 2010 26.7.
  - Imports (goods and services): 2006 37.2; 2007 40.0; 2008 41.0; 2009 37.6; 2010 42.6.
  - External public debt: 2006 83.9; 2007 79.2; 2008 56.6; 2009 53.0; 2010 30.5.
  - Of which: Arrears: 2006 29.5; 2007 31.4; 2008 0.0; 2009 0.0; 2010 0.0.
  - External public debt service (percent of exports): 2006 8.9; 2007 7.5; 2008 5.6; 2009 5.9; 2010 4.5.
  - Gross international reserves (months of imports): 2006 3.4; 2007 3.0; 2008 4.4; 2009 5.0; 2010 4.7.

*Source: IMF staff report content in the supplied document.*

### CONCLUSION

### CONCLUSION

### Capacity and infrastructural challenges
- Togo continues to face capacity and infrastructural challenges.
- All the efforts made and committed by the authorities, especially in the context of an unfavorable environment, will require the continued support of the international community.

### HIPC completion point requirements and policy commitments
- Our Togolese authorities will do their utmost to meet soon the HIPC completion point requirements.
- These include continuing a good implementation of the PRGF program, putting in place the full poverty reduction strategy and meeting the trigger points under the enhanced HIPC Initiative.
- They will do so while promoting a climate of political and social stability, and peace.

### Financing and support needs
- Fresh resources to finance investments and reforms are critically needed to achieve the objectives laid out in the PRGF-supported program and the country’s PRSP.

### Recommendation to the Executive Board
- Based on our authorities’ continued good track record and their renewed determination to pursue sound policies and reforms going forward, we call on the Executive Board to support the proposed decision.

*Source: CONCLUSION*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09194.pdf_
