## _cr09219

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr09219](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09219.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09219.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09219.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary — key findings and policy messages
- Recent growth high, fueled by oil-financed government spending and improved security.
- Global crisis impact limited domestically through trade, investment or finance; main adverse impact through lower oil prices which, if persistent, could reduce the sustainable level of public spending.
- Medium-term outlook highly uncertain and contingent on: the path of petroleum revenue, the security situation, the magnitude and quality of public spending, and progress on business-enabling reforms.
- Policy challenge: manage petroleum wealth sustainably to stimulate non-oil sector growth and support poverty reduction.
- Staff recommendations and views:
  - Moderate fiscal expansion as signaled in the 2010 Budget circular; bring spending in line with the sustainable level by 2012.
  - Fiscal prudence to support external sustainability and avoid real exchange rate appreciation.
  - Maintain official dollarization.
  - Prioritize productivity-enhancing public spending and reforms to improve the investment climate.
  - Preserve Petroleum Fund transparency, accountability, and long-run sustainability if investment portfolio is widened; subject any foreign borrowing to the same principles.
  - Carefully prioritize, sequence, assess and monitor public works within a medium-term budget framework.
  - Strengthen financial supervision, pass legislation (including land law), and promote financial development.

### I. Recent economic developments — main facts and statistics
- Poverty: 50 percent of the population living in poverty in 2007.
- Non-oil real GDP growth: almost 13 percent in 2008.
- Real non-oil GDP per capita: expanded by more than 14 percent over the last two years (to report period).
- Private investment in the non-oil sector remains at very low levels.
- Financial sector: embryonic; foreign parents of three commercial banks in strong financial position.
- Inflation: peaked at over 10 percent y/y in mid-2008; headline inflation fell to 2.7 percent y/y in March 2009.
- Currency movements: depreciation of Indonesian and Australian currencies vis-à-vis the U.S. dollar led to a real exchange rate appreciation.
- Petroleum-related revenue (including interest from petroleum savings): almost doubled in 2008 to $2.4 billion (about 5 times non-oil GDP).
- Contributors to higher petroleum receipts in 2008:
  - surge in international oil prices in the first half of 2008;
  - a 15 percent increase in production volumes;
  - Petroleum Fund earnings doubled on a higher base and conservative investment strategy that generated a 6.9 percent return.
- Central government surplus in 2008: 384 percent of non-oil GDP.
- Petroleum Fund assets reached $4.2 billion and continued rising in 2009.
- Central government spending increased substantially in 2008 (rice subsidies, capital spending, current transfers).
- On a cash basis, 2008 spending broadly in line with its sustainable level (non-oil revenue + ESI) and Petroleum Fund withdrawals remained within the limit.
- External current account surplus in 2008: about four times non-oil GDP, driven by petroleum receipts financing a large trade deficit.
- Financial sector indicators:
  - Three commercial banks are branches of foreign parents and reach only a small segment of the population.
  - Deposits increasing; private sector credit stagnant since late 2005.
  - Lending-deposit rate spread: about 11 percent.
  - Loans account for under one-third of bank assets; surplus funds held mainly in liquid assets abroad.
  - Nonperforming loans: 27 percent, covered twice over by provisions.
  - As branches of foreign parents, commercial banks are not subject to capital adequacy requirements; IMfTL has capital well above the regulatory minimum.
  - Microfinance shows potential; state-owned IMfTL has experienced substantial growth in credit but remains a small player.

### II. Policy discussions — outlook, near-term projections, and scenarios
- Policy focus areas:
  - near and medium-term projections;
  - ensure fiscal sustainability and improve efficiency and quality of public spending;
  - maintain stability and promote financial sector development;
  - external sustainability and reforms to spur competitiveness and private investment.

- Near-term projections and fiscal outlook:
  - Staff project central government expenditure growth: about 13 percent in 2009 and 4 percent in 2010.
  - Spending would remain above the sustainable level.
  - Real non-oil GDP growth projected at about 7½ percent in 2009–10, supported by public spending and private investment.
  - Inflation projected to stay at low single digit levels.
  - Oil prices expected to remain below their 2008 average, triggering a sharp decline in fiscal and current account surpluses.
  - Note: The 2010 projection is based on the limit set for the 2010 Budget ($637 million for the general government; $622 million for the central government). The actual increase in cash spending in 2009 is likely to be larger than reported in Table 3.

- Medium-term staff scenarios and key series (strong policy versus weak policy)
  - Strong policy scenario (assumptions: public spending peaks in 2010 and returns to sustainable path by 2012; significant improvement in business environment; improved quality and composition of public spending; growth converges to long-term fundamentals):
    - Real non-oil GDP growth (percent): 12.8 7.4 7.5 7.4 6.6 6.2 5.9 3.9
    - CPI inflation (percent, year average): 7.6 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0
    - Non-oil balance of the central government (percent of non-oil GDP): -96.8 -90.7 -85.4 -71.3 -56.9 -51.6 -47.0 -39.3
    - Petroleum Fund assets (US$ millions): 4,197 5,109 6,197 7,888 9,871 11,608 13,435 24,134
    - Current account balance (percent of non-oil GDP): 404.8 190.9 171.0 234.0 239.9 190.3 182.9 97.3
  - Weak policy scenario (assumptions: extrapolation of recent 2006–08 public spending trends; no major reforms):
    - Real non-oil GDP growth (percent): 12.8 7.9 9.2 6.6 6.5 6.0 5.5 3.5
    - CPI inflation (percent, end-period): 7.6 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0
    - Non-oil balance of the central government (percent of non-oil GDP): -96.8 -96.1 -121.1 -126.8 -130.8 -132.8 -132.8 -119.7
    - Petroleum Fund assets (US$ millions): 4,197 5,109 5,859 7,028 8,213 8,952 9,583 9,267
    - Current account balance (percent of non-oil GDP): 404.8 183.4 135.5 167.6 133.6 73.1 56.4 -41.6

- Scenario implications:
  - Strong policy: non-oil fiscal deficit halves between 2008 and 2014 to about 45 percent of non-oil GDP; Petroleum Fund assets continue expanding; economic growth about 6–7 percent per year over 2011–14.
  - Weak policy: lower non-oil GDP growth, government spending diverges further from sustainable level, non-oil deficit increases, Petroleum Fund eventually depleted.

- Key uncertainties and risks:
  - Path of oil and gas revenue (volatile international prices and uncertain production potential).
  - Security and political stability.
  - Magnitude and quality of public spending.
  - Pace and significance of business environment reforms.

### Petroleum Fund — performance, rules, and outlook (Box 3 highlights)
- Legal framework and investment policy:
  - All Timor-Leste’s income from oil and gas production must go to the Petroleum Fund (PF).
  - Withdrawals from the PF can only be made to the state budget.
  - The PF is invested entirely abroad, based on the Norwegian model.

- Main drivers of medium-term PF evolution:
  - oil output and prices, and
  - the rate of withdrawals.

- Sensitivity to oil prices:
  - From current levels, a $10/barrel fall in the price of crude oil reduces Timorese government receipts by about 25 percent.

- Estimated Sustainable Income (ESI) and withdrawal rules:
  - ESI is defined under the PF Law as 3 percent of the total petroleum wealth (the current PF balance plus the net present value of future oil/gas receipts).
  - In principle, withdrawals should be guided by the ESI.
  - Actual withdrawals can be higher than the ESI, provided the Government gives Parliament a detailed explanation of why it is in the long-term interest of the country.
  - Reflecting higher oil prices, ESI increased substantially since the first estimate for FY2005/06 and withdrawals have so far remained within the limit.
  - With spending continuing to increase, the report notes the current year is likely to be the first where withdrawals exceed ESI.

### Fiscal policy — context, strategy, and recommendations
- Authorities:
  - Broadly agreed with staff’s near-term outlook; more optimistic about medium-term growth based on reforms and private investment.
  - Estimated net present value of proven petroleum wealth: about $15.2 billion (about $14,000 per capita).
  - Committed to principles of fiscal sustainability and inter-generational equity; have avoided external borrowing.
- Key fiscal challenge: manage petroleum wealth sustainably to stimulate non-oil growth and support poverty reduction.
- Medium-term strategy should:
  - (i) ensure sustainability and improve quality of spending;
  - (ii) strengthen fiscal revenue; and
  - (iii) improve public financial management.
- Sustainability and quality of public spending — findings and specific recommendations:
  - 2010 envelope consistent with staff’s “strong policy” scenario; entails significant cuts: goods and services (30 percent) and minor capital (65 percent) and no change in wages and salaries relative to the 2009 Budget, while allowing for increase in capital investment (mostly contractual for a large electricity project).
  - Staff urged bringing public spending in line with sustainable level by 2012.
    - Spending in 2009–10 projected to exceed the sustainable level by 15–20 percent.
    - One-off expenditures and lower commodity prices offer opportunities for future savings.
    - Continued commitment to wage restraint recommended.
  - Benefits of returning to sustainable path by 2012:
    - smooth spending path; avoid depletion of petroleum wealth and need for large-scale borrowing or drastic cuts that could undermine private investment and growth;
    - boost Petroleum Fund assets and interest income;
    - provide space to address immediate social and security needs and priority infrastructure spending.
  - Public spending priorities: health, education, security, infrastructure.
  - Reduce transfers and subsidies and reallocate toward welfare-enhancing uses (cash-for-work, pensions to elderly).
  - Electricity tariff: adopt structure aimed at full recovery of operational costs, with concessions only for the neediest.

- Revenue generation:
  - Tax-to-non-oil GDP ratio: about 8 percent.
  - Staff encouraged:
    - improve tax administration and combat evasion (e.g., reconcile customs and income tax information);
    - broaden tax base by rationalizing investment incentives.
  - Recent efforts to assess and optimize taxation of oil and gas welcomed; despite tax rate cuts in mid-2008, domestic tax revenue increased in 2008 with an expanded base.

- Public financial management:
  - Petroleum Fund should remain cornerstone: insulate spending from volatile revenue, provide transparency and accountability, promote long-run sustainability, reduce absorption pressures.
  - Limits on PF investment portfolio to be revisited in 2010; staff suggested cautious move to riskier assets to allow time to gain experience.
  - Foreign borrowing: some consideration to borrow from multilateral or bilateral official sources to fund infrastructure as alternative to tapping PF; mission recommended such borrowing be transparent, subject to parliamentary approval, and take into account all terms including non-interest costs.
  - Progress and recommendations:
    - welcome moves to cash-based budgeting, monitorable performance targets, macroeconomic framework for medium-term projections, and strategic development plan;
    - subject project design to prioritization and cost-benefit analyses (including recurrent costs);
    - introduce medium-term fiscal framework linked to the budget;
    - improve monitoring and auditing of projects;
    - step up capacity building on procurement, budget execution, auditing at line ministry level and ahead of decentralization.

### Financial sector — findings and recommended reforms
- Supervision and legislation:
  - Continue strengthening financial supervision: improve data collection and analysis for prudential supervision, on-site and off-site surveillance.
  - Encourage cooperation (memoranda of understanding) with home supervisors of foreign banks.
  - Passage priorities: land law; central bank law to safeguard BPA operational autonomy; banking, payments, anti-money laundering legislation; and insurance regulations.
- Public involvement in credit:
  - Authorities interested in providing subsidized credit directly or with private financials; staff recommended any public sector involvement be transparent and subject to same regulatory and supervisory standards as commercial banking.
- Microfinance and financial development:
  - IMfTL expanded: total loans $4.0 million as of March 2009 (compared with $2.3 million as of December 2007); deposits around $1.4 million by March (IMfTL).
  - IMfTL lending: salary loans account for 75 percent of total loans; alternative products rising.
  - Low overall provision for non-performing loans: 2.2 percent of total value of loans (IMfTL).
  - Other microfinance providers: Moris Rasik (loans $2.2 million as of December 2007; deposits $0.8 million), Tuba Rei Martin (deposits $0.4 million; loans $0.4 million as of July 2008).
  - Unmet micro-credit demand estimated up to 80,000 loans worth more than US$50 million.
  - Interest rates: IMfTL lends at 16 percent to 18 percent per annum; Tuba Rei Martin rates up to 70 percent per annum.
  - Proposed responses: INFUSE project proposed for low cost wholesale funds and technical support; caution that foreign funds should not impede deposit taking.
  - Policy on national development bank: staff caution against displacement of existing institutions and fiscal risk; recommend targeted programs through existing institutions and technical support to borrowers.

### Competitiveness, external sustainability, and exchange rate policy
- Given official dollarization, fiscal policy is essential for external sustainability.
  - Current account mainly driven by oil/gas revenue and relatively inelastic to the real exchange rate.
  - Medium-term sustainability of the current account is primarily a function of fiscal policy: keeping spending on a sustainable path reduces imports and avoids demand-driven real exchange rate appreciation.
- Structural competitiveness weak:
  - Needed reforms: pass pending land law, resolve conflicting land claims, improve contract enforcement (judicial reform and alternative dispute resolution), simplify registration and licensing procedures.
  - One-stop-shop initiative for investors welcomed.
  - Public wage restraint in 2010 Budget envelope should help private sector development by lowering cost of attracting skilled labor.
- Exchange rate regime:
  - Authorities committed to retaining official dollarization.
  - Official dollarization provided strong nominal anchor for inflation expectations and eliminated speculative attack risk.
  - Introduction of a new currency would require developed financial markets, risk currency substitution, and divert scarce administrative capacity.

### Statistical issues and data limitations
- Data shortcomings remain, especially national accounts, significantly hampering macroeconomic analysis and surveillance.
- Progress: monetary and balance of payments statistics published; SRFs introduced for monetary reporting beginning February 2008.
- Encouraged actions:
  - allocate sufficient resources to improve economic data;
  - prioritize annual household income and expenditure surveys for expenditure-based national accounts;
  - participate in IMF’s General Data Dissemination System.
- Key data points and series (selected):
  - GNI per capita (2007): 1,650 (US$).
  - Non-oil GDP per capita (2007): 379 (US$).
  - Total population (2006): 1.015 (millions).
  - Poverty rate (2007): 49.9 percent.
  - Access to improved water (2007): 64.7 percent.
  - Petroleum Fund balance (end-period, US$ millions): 2004 143; 2005 701; 2006 1,012; 2007 2,086; 2008 4,197; 2009 5,109; 2010 6,197.
  - Real non-oil GDP growth (percentage change): 2004 4.2; 2005 6.2; 2006 -5.8; 2007 8.4; 2008 12.8; 2009 7.4; 2010 7.5.
  - Inflation (CPI, end-period): 2004 2.5; 2005 1.0; 2006 6.7; 2007 7.6; 2008 6.1; 2009 2.3; 2010 4.0.
  - Central government revenues (US$ million): 2004 67; 2005 128; 2006 205; 2007 343; 2008 490; 2009 279; 2010 257.
  - Petroleum revenue (US$ million): 2004 46; 2005 107; 2006 195; 2007 330; 2008 480; 2009 126; 2010 248.
  - Central government overall balance (US$ million): 2004 46; 2005 102; 2006 174; 2007 284; 2008 384; 2009 178; 2010 162.
  - Current account (US$ million): 2004 64; 2005 260; 2006 540; 2007 1,177; 2008 2,021; 2009 1,127; 2010 1,127.

### Staff appraisal — consolidated recommendations and next steps
- Near term: non-oil GDP growth remain high; limited exposure to global crisis due to limited external linkages.
- Medium run: growth will converge to supply-side fundamentals; decline in commodity prices since mid-2008 will narrow fiscal and external positions unless new oil/gas fields come on stream.
- Key policy prescriptions:
  - Public spending should return to a sustainable path over the medium term and be targeted to growth promotion and poverty reduction.
    - With public spending in 2009 above the sustainable level, further rapid increases would deplete the Petroleum Fund.
    - Bring government spending in line with a sustainable path as soon as existing commitments allow.
    - Improve efficiency and targeting to create room for strengthened spending on health, education, infrastructure, and poverty-reducing transfers.
  - Fiscal prudence to support competitiveness and external sustainability.
    - Moderate public spending increases would keep the current account on a sustainable path and reduce pressure on the real exchange rate.
    - Productivity-enhancing spending and business climate reforms are crucial.
    - Maintain official dollarization.
  - Petroleum Fund should remain central to petroleum-based revenue management with key principles:
    - all petroleum revenues go to the Fund;
    - withdrawals go through the budget and are consistent with wealth preservation for future generations.
    - introduce medium-term expenditure framework; prioritize and carefully cost capital investment projects.
    - any foreign borrowing subject to Parliamentary approval and proper justification.
  - Financial sector: strengthen supervision, cooperate with home supervisors of foreign banks, pass legislation to safeguard BPA autonomy, and improve property rights to promote financial development.
- Recommendation for next consultation:
  - Staff recommends the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

*Italic: IMF staff report — Appendix I (excerpt provided in the content unit).*

### Appendix I.

### Appendix I.

### Exchange system and Publication
- Exchange system: Timor-Leste uses the U.S. dollar as its official currency; its exchange rate regime is therefore classified as an arrangement with no separate legal tender. The country has accepted the obligations of Article VIII, Sections 2, 3, and 4, and maintains an exchange rate system free of restrictions on payments and transfers for current international transactions.
- Publication: The authorities indicated their intention to publish the staff report. A press statement was issued at the end of the consultation.

### Executive Summary — Key findings and policy messages
- Recent growth has been high, fueled by oil-financed government spending and improved security conditions.
- The global crisis has had no major impact on the domestic economy through trade, investment or finance; the main adverse impact has been through lower oil prices, which, if persistent, could reduce the sustainable level of public spending.
- The medium-term outlook is very uncertain and contingent upon: the path of petroleum revenue, the security situation, the magnitude and quality of public spending, and progress on business-enabling reforms.
- Policy challenge: manage petroleum wealth sustainably to stimulate non-oil sector growth and support poverty reduction.
- Staff welcomed the authorities’ intention to moderate fiscal expansion as signaled in the 2010 Budget circular, and urged bringing spending in line with the sustainable level by 2012.
- Fiscal prudence is needed to support external sustainability and help avoid real exchange rate appreciation.
- Official dollarization has helped contain inflation expectations; staff recommended maintaining the regime.
- To boost competitiveness, the mission stressed productivity-enhancing public spending and reforms to improve the investment climate.
- Petroleum Fund: should remain the cornerstone for public financial management; the forthcoming revision to its law to widen investment portfolio should preserve transparency, accountability, and long-run sustainability. Any foreign borrowing should be subject to the same principles.
- Staff recommended careful prioritization, sequencing, assessment and monitoring of public works, in line with a medium-term budget framework.
- Financial sector: embryonic; staff recommended continued strengthening of financial supervision and swift passage of legislation and reforms to promote financial development, including the land law.

### I. Recent Economic Developments — Main facts and statistics
- Poverty: 50 percent of the population living in poverty in 2007.
- Non-oil real GDP growth reached almost 13 percent in 2008.
- In per capita terms, real non-oil GDP has expanded by more than 14 percent over the last two years.
- Private investment in the non-oil sector remains at very low levels.
- Global crisis impact: limited immediate impact due to very small foreign investment outside oil and very small non-oil exports; financial sector at an embryonic stage; foreign parents of the three commercial banks are in a strong financial position.
- Inflation: peaked at over 10 percent y/y in mid-2008; headline inflation fell to 2.7 percent y/y in March 2009.
- Currency movements: depreciation of the Indonesian and Australian currencies vis-à-vis the U.S. dollar led to a real exchange rate appreciation.
- Petroleum-related revenue (including interest from petroleum savings) almost doubled in 2008 to $2.4 billion (about 5 times non-oil GDP).
- Contributors to higher petroleum receipts in 2008: surge in international oil prices in the first half of 2008; a 15 percent increase in production volumes; Petroleum Fund earnings doubled on a higher base and conservative investment strategy that generated a 6.9 percent return.
- Central government surplus in 2008: 384 percent of non-oil GDP.
- Petroleum Fund assets reached $4.2 billion and continued rising in 2009.
- Central government spending increased substantially in 2008, driven by rice subsidies, capital spending, and current transfers (cash payments to displaced persons and pensions).
- On a cash basis, spending was broadly in line with its sustainable level (sum of non-oil revenue and the estimated sustainable income (ESI) from petroleum), and withdrawals from the Petroleum Fund remained within the limit.
- External current account surplus in 2008: about four times non-oil GDP, driven by petroleum receipts (recorded as income in the current account) financing a large trade deficit.
- Merchandise imports rose sharply in 2008 due to higher public spending; exports (mainly coffee and tourism) remained small.
- Financial sector indicators:
  - Three commercial banks are branches of foreign parents and reach only a small segment of the population.
  - Deposits have been increasing; private sector credit has been stagnant since late 2005.
  - Lending-deposit rate spread: about 11 percent.
  - Loans account for under one-third of bank assets; surplus funds held mainly in liquid assets abroad.
  - Nonperforming loans: 27 percent, covered twice over by provisions.
  - As branches of foreign parents, commercial banks are not subject to capital adequacy requirements; IMfTL has capital well above the regulatory minimum.
  - Microfinance shows potential; state-owned IMfTL has experienced substantial growth in credit but remains a small player.

### II. Policy Discussions — Outlook and Risks (selected projections and scenarios)
- Policy discussion focus areas:
  - near and medium-term projections;
  - ensuring fiscal sustainability and improving efficiency and quality of public spending;
  - policies to maintain stability and promote financial sector development;
  - external sustainability and reforms to spur competitiveness and private investment.

- Near-term projections and fiscal outlook:
  - Staff project a slowdown in central government expenditure growth to about 13 percent in 2009 and 4 percent in 2010.
  - Spending would remain above the sustainable level.
  - Real non-oil GDP growth projected at about 7½ percent in 2009–10, supported by public spending and private investment.
  - Inflation projected to stay at low single digit levels.
  - Oil prices expected to remain below their 2008 average, triggering a sharp decline in fiscal and current account surpluses.
  - Note: The 2010 projection is based on the limit set for the 2010 Budget ($637 million for the general government; $622 million for the central government). The actual increase in cash spending in 2009 is likely to be larger than reported in Table 3.

- Medium-term scenarios (staff projections):
  - Strong policy scenario (assumptions: public spending peaks in 2010 and returns to sustainable path by 2012; significant improvement in business environment; improved quality and composition of public spending; growth converges to long-term fundamentals):
    - Real non-oil GDP growth (percent): 12.8 7.4 7.5 7.4 6.6 6.2 5.9 3.9
    - CPI inflation (percent, year average): 7.6 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0
    - Non-oil balance of the central government (percent of non-oil GDP): -96.8 -90.7 -85.4 -71.3 -56.9 -51.6 -47.0 -39.3
    - Petroleum Fund assets (US$ millions): 4,197 5,109 6,197 7,888 9,871 11,608 13,435 24,134
    - Current account balance (percent of non-oil GDP): 404.8 190.9 171.0 234.0 239.9 190.3 182.9 97.3
  - Weak policy scenario (assumptions: extrapolation of recent 2006–08 public spending trends; no major reforms):
    - Real non-oil GDP growth (percent): 12.8 7.9 9.2 6.6 6.5 6.0 5.5 3.5
    - CPI inflation (percent, end-period): 7.6 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0
    - Non-oil balance of the central government (percent of non-oil GDP): -96.8 -96.1 -121.1 -126.8 -130.8 -132.8 -132.8 -119.7
    - Petroleum Fund assets (US$ millions): 4,197 5,109 5,859 7,028 8,213 8,952 9,583 9,267
    - Current account balance (percent of non-oil GDP): 404.8 183.4 135.5 167.6 133.6 73.1 56.4 -41.6
- Scenario implications:
  - Strong policy: non-oil fiscal deficit halves between 2008 and 2014 to about 45 percent of non-oil GDP; Petroleum Fund assets continue expanding; economic growth about 6–7 percent per year over 2011–14.
  - Weak policy: lower non-oil GDP growth, government spending diverges further from sustainable level, non-oil deficit increases, Petroleum Fund eventually depleted.

- Key uncertainties and risks:
  - Path of oil and gas revenue (dependent on volatile international prices and uncertain production potential).
  - Security and political stability.
  - Magnitude and quality of public spending.
  - Pace and significance of reforms to improve the business environment.

*IMF staff report — Appendix I.*

### 12.      The authorities broadly agreed with the staff’s near-term outlook, but were

### The authorities broadly agreed with the staff’s near-term outlook, but were more optimistic about medium-term growth

### Fiscal Policy — overview
- Authorities agreed with staff’s near-term outlook; more optimistic about medium-term growth based on reform efforts, well-targeted spending, and private investment supporting double-digit real GDP growth.
- Authorities optimistic about prospects for revenue from future oil, gas, and other mineral developments.

### Fiscal context and petroleum wealth
- The net present value of the country’s proven petroleum wealth, comprising the Petroleum Fund balance and discounted future revenue streams, is estimated at about $15.2 billion (about $14,000 per capita).
- Petroleum wealth provides considerable wealth, although “not enough to make it rich.”

### Key fiscal challenge and medium-term strategy
- Key fiscal challenge: manage petroleum wealth sustainably to stimulate non-oil growth and support poverty reduction.
- Medium-term strategy should: (i) ensure the sustainability and improve the quality of spending; (ii) strengthen fiscal revenue; and (iii) improve public financial management.

### Sustainability and quality of public spending — findings and recommendations
- The 2010 envelope is consistent with staff’s “strong policy” scenario.
  - It entails significant cuts in goods and services (30 percent) and minor capital (65 percent) and no change in outlays for wages and salaries relative to the 2009 Budget, while allowing for an increase in capital investment (most of which is contractually committed to a large electricity project).
- Staff urged bringing public spending in line with the sustainable level by 2012.
  - Spending in 2009–10 is projected to exceed the sustainable level by 15–20 percent.
  - One-off expenditures (e.g., payments to resettle displaced persons) and lower commodity prices (allowing reduction in rice subsidies) offer opportunities for future savings.
  - Continued commitment to wage restraint recommended.
- Benefits of returning to sustainable path by 2012:
  - Keep spending on a smooth upward path; avoid depletion of petroleum wealth and the need for large-scale borrowing or drastic cuts that could undermine private investment and growth.
  - Reduce need for larger adjustments in future; boost Petroleum Fund assets and their interest income.
  - Provide space to address immediate social and security needs and priority infrastructure spending.
- Public spending should be prioritized and targeted to promote growth and reduce poverty:
  - Prioritize spending on health, education, security, and infrastructure.
  - Reduce transfers and subsidies and divert toward more efficient welfare-enhancing uses (e.g., expansion of the cash-for-work program and pensions to the elderly).
  - Subsidy policies, including for food and electricity, should consider distortionary impacts and include exit strategies.
  - Recommended adopting a tariff structure for electricity aimed at full recovery of operational costs, with concessions only for the neediest.

### Authorities’ stance on spending and revenue prospects
- Authorities noted temporary nature of recent spending increases and stressed commitment to fiscal sustainability.
- Did not commit to staff’s recommended fiscal path beyond 2010, citing confidence that revenue from new oil/gas fields or other mineral resources will increase sustainable spending levels above current projections.

### Revenue generation — findings and recommendations
- Mission recommended measures to boost fiscal revenue.
- Recent efforts to assess and optimize taxation of oil and gas welcomed.
- Despite tax rate cuts in mid-2008, domestic tax revenue increased in 2008 with an expanded base.
- Tax-to-non-oil GDP ratio is about 8 percent; lower than other low and middle-income oil exporting countries and the low-income country group as a whole.
- Staff encouraged:
  - Improve tax administration and combat evasion (e.g., reconciling customs and income tax information).
  - Broaden the tax base by rationalizing investment incentives.

### Public financial management — findings and recommendations
- Petroleum Fund should remain cornerstone for managing oil-based resources:
  - Insulates spending from volatile revenue flows, provides transparency and accountability framework, promotes long-run sustainability, and reduces pressures on absorption capacity.
- Limits on Petroleum Fund investment portfolio must be revisited in 2010; authorities considering more diversified investment strategy and other possible changes to the law.
  - Staff suggested moving cautiously to allow time for experience in managing riskier assets.
  - Authorities stated any reform would leave basic principles intact.
- Foreign borrowing considerations:
  - Some elements considering borrowing from multilateral or bilateral official sources to fund infrastructure as alternative to tapping Petroleum Fund.
  - Mission recommended any such borrowing: (i) be transparent and subject to parliamentary approval; and (ii) take into account all terms and conditions of the loan, including non-interest costs.
- Progress and recommendations on public financial management reforms:
  - Welcomed moves to cash-based budgeting, adopt monitorable performance targets, introduce a macroeconomic framework for medium-term projections, and prepare a strategic development plan.
  - To operationalize the plan, mission recommended:
    - Subject project design to prioritization and careful cost-benefit analyses, including of recurrent costs.
    - Introduce a medium-term fiscal framework with clear links to the budget.
    - Improve monitoring and auditing of projects.
    - Step up capacity building on procurement, budget execution, and auditing at line ministry level and ahead of any decentralization to district-level governments.
  - Authorities requested an extension of the IMF-funded treasury advisor, a fiscal ROSC mission, and a PEFA assessment.

### Financial sector — findings and recommendations
- Mission recommended continued strengthening of financial supervision:
  - Need to strengthen data collection and analysis for prudential supervision, and on-site and off-site surveillance methods.
  - Encourage cooperation (e.g., memoranda of understanding) with home supervisors of foreign banks.
- Passage of legislation and reforms needed to promote stability and development:
  - Priorities: land law; central bank law to safeguard the Banking and Payments Authority’s (BPA) operational autonomy; banking, payments, anti-money laundering legislation; and insurance regulations.
- Authorities expressed interest in providing subsidized credit directly or with private financials.
  - Staff recommended any public sector involvement be subject to transparency checks and the same regulatory and supervisory standards as commercial banking activities.

### Competitiveness, external sustainability, and exchange rate policy
- Given official dollarization, fiscal policy is essential to ensure external sustainability.
  - Standard analyses of exchange rate misalignment are neither feasible nor very meaningful for Timor-Leste due to lack of data.
  - Current account mainly driven by oil/gas revenue and likely relatively inelastic to the real exchange rate.
  - Medium-term sustainability of the current account is primarily a function of fiscal policy: keeping spending on a sustainable path supports external sustainability directly (by reducing imports) and indirectly (by avoiding demand-driven real exchange rate appreciation).
- Structural competitiveness is weak:
  - Broader indexes indicate business environment remains uncompetitive, even among other low income countries.
  - Needed reforms: pass pending land law, resolve conflicting land claims, improve contract enforcement via judicial reform and alternative dispute resolution, simplify registration and licensing procedures.
  - One-stop-shop for investors initiative welcomed.
  - Commitment to public wage restraint in 2010 Budget envelope should help private sector development by lowering cost of attracting skilled labor.
- Exchange rate regime:
  - Authorities committed to retaining official dollarization.
  - Official dollarization provided strong nominal anchor for inflation expectations and eliminated speculative attacks risk.
  - Introduction of a new currency, particularly under a flexible exchange rate, would require developed financial markets, risk currency substitution, and divert scarce administrative capacity.

### Statistical issues
- Data provision shortcomings remain, especially on national accounts, significantly hampering macroeconomic analysis and surveillance.
- Moderate progress made in collection and coverage of monetary and financial statistics; recent publication of monetary and balance of payments statistics welcomed.
- Mission encouraged allocation of sufficient resources to improve economic data and to give priority to annual household income and expenditure surveys for constructing expenditure-based national accounts.
- Encouraged participation in IMF’s General Data Dissemination System.

### Staff appraisal — summary findings and policy recommendations
- Non-oil GDP growth will remain high in the near term; limited exposure to global crisis due to limited external linkages.
- In the medium run, growth will gradually converge to supply-side fundamentals; decline in commodity prices since mid-2008 will narrow fiscal and external positions unless new oil/gas fields come on stream.
- Public spending should return to a sustainable path over the medium term and be targeted to growth promotion and poverty reduction.
  - With public spending already in 2009 above the sustainable level, further rapid increases would deplete the Petroleum Fund.
  - Government spending should be brought in line with a sustainable path as soon as existing commitments allow.
  - Improve efficiency and targeting to create room for strengthened spending on health, education, infrastructure, and poverty-reducing transfers.
- Fiscal prudence is needed to support competitiveness and external sustainability.
  - Moderate public spending increases would keep the current account on a sustainable path and reduce pressure on the real exchange rate.
  - Productivity-enhancing spending and business climate reforms are crucial.
  - Official dollarization should be maintained.
- Petroleum Fund recommendations:
  - Petroleum Fund should remain central to petroleum-based revenue management.
  - Key principles: all petroleum revenues go to the Fund; withdrawals go through the budget and are consistent with wealth preservation for future generations.
  - Introduce a medium-term expenditure framework; prioritize and carefully cost capital investment projects.
  - Any foreign borrowing should be subject to Parliamentary approval and proper justification.
- Financial sector recommendations:
  - Strengthen financial sector supervision, cooperation with home supervisors of foreign banks, and pass legislation to safeguard BPA autonomy.
  - Reforms to enhance property rights needed to promote financial development.
- Recommendation for next consultation:
  - Staff recommends that the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

*Source: IMF country report excerpt provided in the content unit.*

### Box 3. Petroleum Fund Performance and Outlook

### Box 3. Petroleum Fund Performance and Outlook

### Legal framework and investment policy
- All Timor-Leste’s income from oil and gas production must go to the Petroleum Fund (PF).
- Withdrawals from the PF can only be made to the state budget.
- The PF is invested entirely abroad, based on the Norwegian model.

### Main drivers of medium-term PF evolution
- The medium-term evolution of the PF will depend mainly on:
  - oil output and prices, and
  - the rate of withdrawals.

### Sensitivity to oil prices
- Oil and gas production is expected to stay near current levels for the next several years but revenue is highly sensitive to prices (with some lag).
- From current levels, a $10/barrel fall in the price of crude oil reduces Timorese government receipts by about 25 percent.

### Estimated Sustainable Income (ESI) and withdrawal rules
- ESI is defined under the PF Law as 3 percent of the total petroleum wealth (the current PF balance plus the net present value of future oil/gas receipts).
- In principle, withdrawals should be guided by the ESI.
- Actual withdrawals can be higher than the ESI, provided the Government gives Parliament a detailed explanation of why it is in the long-term interest of the country.
- Reflecting higher oil prices, ESI has increased substantially since the first estimate for FY2005/06 and withdrawals have so far remained within the limit.
- With spending continuing to increase, this year is likely to be the first where withdrawals exceed ESI.

### Data notes and graphical observations
- The accompanying chart shows Estimated Sustainable Income and PF Withdrawals (In US$ millions) for periods 05/06, 06/07, 07H2, 2008, 2009 with series for ESI, Withdrawals, and Government spending.
- Note: Figures for 2007H2 (transition budget) have been annualized.
- Note: Figures for 2009 based on budget but more recent data point to ESI being about $50m higher than depicted.

*Source: Box 3. Petroleum Fund Performance and Outlook (extracted from the provided IMF content).*

### 3. Data for other countries are latest available estimates.

### _cr09219 - 3. Data for other countries are latest available estimates.

### Government employment and wages
- Government employees (1,000 persons) series and projections for 04/05, 05/06, 06/07, 07/08, 08/09 proj., 10 proj.; breakdown by Temporary employees and Permanent employees.
- Real average annual pay rate and Wage bill shown in $ (2001 prices); series scale up to $2,000 (2001 prices).
- Wage bill shown as percent of non-oil GDP with series for 04/05, 05/06, 06/07, 07/08, 08/09 proj., 10 proj.
- Share of non-oil GDP and Real value (in $ million (2001 prices)) presented.
- Ratio of average pay rate to non-oil GDP per capita: scale 0 to 6 for 04/05 through 10 proj.
- Cross-country comparisons (percent of GDP and Ratio to GDP per capita) include: Indonesia, Cambodia, Singapore, Lao P.D.R., Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand, Timor-Leste (09).

### Selected social indicators (Table 1 excerpts)
- Gross national income per capita (US$) 2/: East Asia and Pacific 16,502; Low income countries 2,180; Timor-Leste 578.
- GDP per capita (PPP, current US$): East Asia and Pacific 7,764; Low income countries 4,939; Timor-Leste 1,530.
- Total population (in millions) 2007: East Asia and Pacific 1.0; Low income countries 1.9; Timor-Leste 1.914; Island countries 1,296.
- Population growth (percent, average 2000-07) 3/: East Asia and Pacific 3.2; Low income countries 0.9; Timor-Leste 2.3.
- Life expectancy at birth (years) 4/: East Asia and Pacific 59; Low income countries 71; Timor-Leste 57.
  - Male: East Asia and Pacific 58; Low income countries 69; Timor-Leste 56.
  - Female: East Asia and Pacific 60; Low income countries 73; Timor-Leste 58.
- Infant mortality (per thousand live births) 4/: East Asia and Pacific 52; Low income countries 24; Timor-Leste 85.
- Under 5 mortality rate (per thousand live births) 4/: East Asia and Pacific 61; Low income countries 29; Timor-Leste 135.
- Literacy rate 5/: East Asia and Pacific 47; Low income countries 91; Timor-Leste 61.
  - Male literacy: 56 (East Asia and Pacific); 95 (Low income countries); Timor-Leste 72.
  - Female literacy: 39 (East Asia and Pacific); 87 (Low income countries); Timor-Leste 50.
- Gross primary school enrollment rate: East Asia and Pacific 107; Low income countries 110; Timor-Leste 94.
- Immunization rate (children <5):
  - Measles: East Asia and Pacific 57; Low income countries 89; Timor-Leste 76 (figures for 2006).
  - DPT: East Asia and Pacific 68; Low income countries 89; Timor-Leste 77 (figures for 2006).
- Population below the poverty line: East Asia and Pacific 50; Timor-Leste not specified (......).
- Households with access to electricity: East Asia and Pacific 36; Timor-Leste not specified (......).
- Population with access to improved water source: East Asia and Pacific 65; Low income countries 87; Timor-Leste 68 (figures for 2006).

### Timor-Leste: Selected Social and Economic Indicators (Table 2 highlights)
I. Social and Demographic Indicators
- GNI per capita (in U.S. dollars, 2007): 1,650
- Non-oil GDP per capita (in U.S. dollars, 2007): 379
- Total population (in millions, 2006): 1.015
- Population growth (in percent, 2006): 3.2
- Life expectancy at birth (years, 2006): 59
- Literacy rate (in percent, 2007): 47.3
- Infant mortality rate (per 1000 births, 2007): 68
- Poverty rate (in percent, 2007): 49.9
- Access to improved water (in percent, 2007): 64.7
- Access to electricity (in percent, 2007): 36.1

II. Economic Indicators (selected time series and levels)
- GNI at current prices (US$ million): 2004 460; 2005 695; 2006 972; 2007 1,728; 2008 2,915; 2009 2,198; 2010 2,312.
- Non-oil GDP at current prices (US$ million): 2004 309; 2005 332; 2006 327; 2007 398; 2008 499; 2009 590; 2010 659.
- Real non-oil GDP growth (percentage change): 2004 4.2; 2005 6.2; 2006 -5.8; 2007 8.4; 2008 12.8; 2009 7.4; 2010 7.5.
  - Including United Nations 1/: 2004 0.4; 2005 2.3; 2006 -3.4; 2007 16.8; 2008 12.2; 2009 8.0; 2010 2.0.
- Inflation (CPI, end-period): 2004 2.5; 2005 1.0; 2006 6.7; 2007 7.6; 2008 6.1; 2009 2.3; 2010 4.0.
- Savings and investment (percent of non-oil GDP): Gross investment 2004 2/ 2; 2005 12; 2006 12; 2007 3; 2008 26; 2009 46; 2010 51 (table formatting indicates series).
- Gross national savings (US$ million): 2004 42; 2005 99; 2006 188; 2007 322; 2008 451; 2009 242; 2010 225.
- External savings (US$ million): 2004 -21; 2005 -78; 2006 -165; 2007 -296; 2008 -405; 2009 -191; 2010 -171.

Central government finances (cash and commitment basis, selected items)
- Revenues (US$ million): 2004 67; 2005 128; 2006 205; 2007 343; 2008 490; 2009 279; 2010 257.
- Domestic revenues (US$ million): 2004 10; 2005 11; 2006 10; 2007 11; 2008 9; 2009 10; 2010 9.
- Petroleum revenue (US$ million): 2004 46; 2005 107; 2006 195; 2007 330; 2008 480; 2009 126; 2010 248.
- Expenditure (cash basis, US$ million): 2004 20; 2005 26; 2006 32; 2007 59; 2008 106; 2009 101; 2010 94.
- Recurrent expenditure (US$ million): 2004 17; 2005 19; 2006 27; 2007 46; 2008 70; 2009 63; 2010 53.
- Capital expenditure (US$ million): 2004 3; 2005 7; 2006 13; 2007 63; 2008 84; 2009 41; 2010 ... (table formatting).
- Overall balance (US$ million): 2004 46; 2005 102; 2006 174; 2007 284; 2008 384; 2009 178; 2010 162.
- Non-oil fiscal balance (percent of non-oil GDP): 2004 1; 2005 -5; 2006 -21; 2007 -46; 2008 -97; 2009 -91; 2010 -85.

External sector (selected items, US$ million)
- Current account: 2004 64; 2005 260; 2006 540; 2007 1,177; 2008 2,021; 2009 1,127; 2010 1,127.
- Merchandise exports (US$ million): 2004 8; 2005 8; 2006 9; 2007 7; 2008 14; 2009 ...; 2010 13 (formatting indicates series).
- Merchandise imports (US$ million): 2004 122; 2005 112; 2006 101; 2007 176; 2008 353; 2009 440; 2010 469.
- Donor development assistance (% of non-oil GDP): series includes 55, 49, 39, 30, 37, 34, 30.
- Crude oil price ($ per barrel) 5/: 2004 38; 2005 53; 2006 64; 2007 71; 2008 97; 2009 76; 2010 175.
- Oil/gas receipts (US$ million): 2004 14; 2005 134; 2006 96; 2007 121; 2008 1,258; 2009 2,284; 2010 1,498.
- Petroleum Fund balance (end-period, US$ million) 6/: 2004 143; 2005 701; 2006 1,012; 2007 2,086; 2008 4,197; 2009 5,109; 2010 6,197.
- Petroleum Fund balance (percent of non-oil GDP) 6/: series includes 5, 112, 310, 525, 841, 866, 940.

### Central Government Budget FY2004/05–2010 (Table 3 highlights)
- Revenue (US$ million, selected): 2004/05 337; 2005/06 516; 2006/07 733; 2007 Supl./Prel. 1,045; 2008 Budget 575; 2008 Proj. 692; 2009 1,379; 2010 1,979; 2011 2,444; 2012 1,312; 2013 1,648; 2014 1,692 (table layout reflects multi-year columns).
- Petroleum revenue and Oil/gas receipts (US$ million) examples: 2004/05 petroleum revenue 266; oil/gas receipts 265; 2007 oil/gas receipts 519; 2008 oil/gas receipts 640; 2009 oil/gas receipts 1,250.
- Interest (US$ million): series includes 1, 13, 40, 37, 37, 32, 109, 93, 115, 90, 122.
- Grants: 2004/05 34; 2005/06 110; other years 100/000000 (table indicates limited grant receipt).
- Expenditure (commitment basis and cash basis): commitment basis example 2004/05 741; recurrent expenditure 627; wages and salaries 25; goods and services 314; capital expenditure and net lending 124.
- Expenditure (cash basis) and carry-over details presented; overall balance and non-oil balance series provided with precise figures (e.g., Overall balance 2004/05 266; 2005/06 424; etc.).
- Financing breakdown includes Petroleum Fund withdrawals (e.g., 02602604040260687396589589494 series as shown) and Changes in cash balances (increase = '-').

Notes from table footnotes:
- Fiscal year: July-June until June 2007; calendar year starting 2008.
- Revenue from government rice sales estimated at $17 million in 2008 and $10 million in 2009 excluded; only net subsidy included in recurrent expenditure.
- Budget moved toward cash basis in 2008; of $528 million reported as spent in 2008, an estimated $80 million was actually paid out in 2009.
- Definition notes for non-oil balance, petroleum fund figures, and sustainable income/spending calculations provided.

### Combined Sources Budget 2004–2010 (Table 4 highlights)
- Revenue (in millions of US dollars): series includes 727, 942, 605, 368, 73 (years and columns presented in table).
- Domestic revenue 1/: series includes 30, 37, 34, 42, 45, 61, 59.
- Direct taxes (US$ million): series includes 71, 110, 131, 91, 114.
- Grant financing (budget support) (US$ million): series includes 35, 33, 11, 0, 0, 0, 0.
- Expenditure (cash basis) (in millions of US dollars): 205, 222, 238, 349, 720, 804, 833.
- Recurrent expenditure (in millions of US dollars): 154, 157, 180, 263, 513, 544, 525.
- Capital expenditure and donor projects broken down (central government and autonomous agencies; donor projects).
- Overall balance (in millions of US dollars): -133, -144, -196, -289, -667, -736, -759.
- Oil fund financing of central govt. non-oil fiscal deficit (in percent of non-oil GDP) and project financing by donors details included.

### Balance of Payments 2004–2010 (Table 5 highlights)
- Current account (in millions of US dollars): 2004 64; 2005 260; 2006 540; 2007 1,177; 2008 2,021; 2009 1,127; 2010 1,127.
- Trade balance (in millions of US dollars): 2004 -115; 2005 -104; 2006 -91; 2007 -169; 2008 -339; 2009 -431; 2010 -457.
  - Exports of goods 1/: examples 2004 8; 2005 8; 2007 10; 2008 13.
  - Coffee exports included (series 7, 8, 9, 6, 12, 7 depending on year).
  - Imports of goods: 122, 112, 101, 176, 353, 440, 469.
- Services (net): -187, -131, -199, -263, -407, -437, -385.
  - Services exports and imports series provided; UN and donor related import component included (e.g., UN and donor related 20, 11, 37, 20, 42, 86, 69, 403, 334 depending on rows).
- Income (net): 151, 363, 645, 1,331, 2,415, 1,608, 1,653 (includes oil/gas receipts and interest).
- Current transfers (net): 215, 133, 185, 278, 351, 386, 316 (Of which: International assistance 215, 133, 184, 281, 355, 386, 315).
- Capital and financial accounts: 57, -289, -609, -1,031, -2,041, -1,080, -1,196.
- Public foreign assets (end-period, in millions of US$): 135, 524, 1,096, 2,316, 4,407, 5,367, 6,385.

### Monetary developments (Table 6 highlights)
Banking System (in millions of US$)
- Net foreign assets: 184, 159, 113, 318, 393 (2004–2008).
- Assets 1/: 227, 206, 144, 356, 422.
- Gross reserves: 182, 153, 84, 230, 210.
- Net domestic assets: -116, -80, -11, -172, -187.
- Claims on government (net): -187, -151, -83, -219, -230.
- Claims on private sector: 88, 106, 111, 101, 102.
- Broad money 2/: 66, 78, 100, 144, 193.
- Narrow money: 32, 39, 54, 75, 104.
- Demand deposits: 31, 38, 52, 73, 102.
- Memorandum items:
  - Petroleum Fund balance (US$ millions): ... , 370, 1,012, 2,086, 4,197.
  - Net foreign assets (percentage change): 70.0, -13.4, -28.8, 181.1, 23.4.
  - Credit to the private sector (percentage change): 237.2, 19.8, 5.2, -9.8, 1.9.
  - Credit ratio to non-oil GDP (percent): 28.6, 31.9, 34.1, 25.3, 20.5.
  - Broad money ratio to non-oil GDP (percent): 21.3, 23.5, 30.6, 36.1, 38.6.

Notes:
- Oil fund created in September 2005; deposits moved off-shore.
- Broad money excludes coinage issues detail; no data for notes due to dollarization.

### Medium-term outlook, 2006–2014 (Strong Policy Scenario) (Table 7 highlights)
Staff Projections (selected)
- GNI at current prices (US$ millions): 2006 972; 2007 1,728; 2008 2,915; 2009 2,198; 2010 2,312; 2011 2,982; 2012 3,266; 2013 3,102; 2014 3,281.
- Non-oil GDP (US$ millions): 2006 327; 2007 398; 2008 499; 2009 590; 2010 659; 2011 733; 2012 808; 2013 889; 2014 978.
- Petroleum revenue (US$ millions): 2006 63; 2007 71; 2008 1,312; 2009 2,399; 2010 1,588; 2011 1,633; 2012 2,236; 2013 2,445; 2014 2,200; 2015 2,290 (table shows multi-year series).
- Real non-oil GDP growth (percentage change): 2006 -5.8; 2007 8.4; 2008 12.8; 2009 7.4; 2010 7.5; 2011 7.5; 2012 7.4; 2013 6.6; 2014 6.2; 2015 5.9 (series through 2014).
  - Including United Nations 1/: 2006 -3.4; 2007 16.8; 2008 12.2; 2009 8.0; 2010 2.0; 2011 -1.4; 2012 5.8; 2013 5.6; 2014 5.9.
- Inflation (period average): 2006 4.1; 2007 8.9; 2008 7.6; 2009 1.3; 2010 4.0; projections stable at 4.0 thereafter.
- Investment-saving balance (percent of non-oil GDP): Gross investment 2/ series includes 23, 26, 46, 51, 47, 36, 35, 33.
- Gross national saving (US$ millions): 2006 188; 2007 322; 2008 451; 2009 242; 2010 225; subsequent years series provided.
- External saving (US$ millions): -165, -296, -405, -191, -171, -234, -240, -190, -183.
- Central government finances (in percent of non-oil GDP): Revenues 20, 5, 34, 49, 0, 27, 3, 15, 31 (table layout shows year-specific series).
- Overall balance (US$ millions): 2006 174; 2007 284; 2008 384; 2009 178; 2010 162; 2011 234; 2012 246; 2013 196; 2014 187.
- Non-oil fiscal balance (series): -21, -46, -97, -91, -85, -71, -57, -52, -47.
- Current account balance (US$ millions): 2006 540; 2007 1,177; 2008 2,021; 2009 1,127; 2010 1,127; 2011 1,715; 2012 1,938; 2013 1,693; 2014 1,788.
- Public foreign assets (end-period, US$ millions): 1,096; 2,316; 4,407; 5,367; 6,385; 8,073; 10,050; 11,791; 13,622.
- Crude oil price ($ per barrel) 5/ (memorandum): 64, 71, 97, 61, 75, 78, 80, 81, 83 (series as shown).
- Petroleum Fund withdrawals (series): 0, -75, -79, -100, -75, -71, -56, -52, -47.
- Petroleum Fund balance (end-period): 310, 525, 841, 866, 940, 1,076, 1,222, 1,305, 1,374.
- Public debt: 0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0.

Notes:
- Projections assume a strong policy scenario; footnotes clarify inclusion of UN compensation, exclusion of oil/gas sector investment, and definitions for combined sources.

### Vulnerability indicators (Table 8)
Financial sector risk indicators
- Public debt 1/: 0.0 (2004–2008).
- Broad money (percent change, 12-month basis) 2/: 18.3, 28.2, 43.9, 34.1 (2004–2008).
- Private sector credit (percent change, 12-month basis): 19.8, 5.2, -9.8, 1.9.
External indicators
- Goods exports (percent change, 12-month basis in U.S. dollars): 0, 314, -28, 111.
- Goods imports (percent change, 12-month basis in U.S. dollars): 6, -8, -11, 75, 101 (series indicates volatility).
- Current account balance (in percent of non-oil GDP): 217, 816, 529, 640, 5 (table formatting).
- Public foreign assets (in millions of US$) 3/: 18, 25, 241, 1,096, 2,316, 4,407.
- Public foreign assets (in months of corresponding imports of goods): 1, 8, 5, 6, 13, 11, 58, 15, 0 (table series formatting).
- Net foreign assets of commercial banks (in millions of US$): 162, 98, 88, 182.
- Total external debt 1/: 0,0,0,0,0.
- External debt-service (in percent of exports of goods and services): 0,0,0,0,0.

Notes:
- No external or domestic debt contracted.
- Broad money excludes currency in circulation for which no data are available.
- Public foreign assets include investments of Petroleum Fund assets overseas.

### Advice from the 2008 Article IV Discussions and Action Taken
- Maintain current monetary and exchange regime until institutional capacity is built.
  - Action taken: Continued commitment to build up institutional capacity before any policy change.
- Preserve the basic principles of the Petroleum Fund framework.
  - Action taken: Petroleum Fund Law under review to allow greater diversification; basic principles expected to stay.
- Address obstacles to budget execution, especially in investment spending.
  - Action taken: Spending sharply increased, with improved execution of capital budget, but quality uneven.
- Enhance planning by moving budget to cash basis, introducing medium-term fiscal framework, and updating NDP.
  - Action taken: Budget moved to cash basis, medium-term framework developed, and strategic framework targeted for completion by end-year.
- Pass pending financial sector laws and facilitate contract enforcement.
  - Action taken: Central Bank and AML laws being considered by Cabinet; other legislation still pending.
- Continue strengthening of banking supervision and introduce credit registry.
  - Action taken: Banking supervision enhancement continuing and credit registry ready for introduction.
- Ensure that public involvement in sector is on commercial terms and supervised under law.
  - Action taken: Government assumed ownership of IMFTL; authorities affirm plans to run on commercial basis.
- Improve environment for private activity.
  - Action taken: Land law progressing but other steps still pending.
- Strengthen statistical capacity.
  - Action taken: BOP statistics published and resources provided for national accounts.

*Italic: Source: _cr09219 - 3. Data for other countries are latest available estimates.*

### Appendix I. Authorities’ Response to Recent Fund Policy Advice

### Appendix I. Authorities’ Response to Recent Fund Policy Advice

### Fund Relations
- Membership Status: Joined 7/23/2002; Article VIII.
- General Resources Account (SDR Million / % Quota):
  - Quota: 8.20  100.00
  - Fund holdings of currency: 8.20  100.00
  - Reserve position in Fund: 0.00      0.01
- SDR Department:
  - Holdings: 0.00      N/A
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans: None
- Latest Financial Arrangements: None
- Projected Obligations to Fund: None
- Exchange Rate Arrangements:
  - On January 24, 2000, the U.S. dollar was adopted as the official currency of then East Timor by the United Nations Transitional Administration in East Timor (UNTAET).
  - The arrangement has been maintained after Timor-Leste’s independence on May 20, 2002.
  - The monetary authority does not undertake foreign exchange transactions; they are handled by commercial banks on the basis of rates quoted in the international markets.
- Article IV Consultations:
  - The 2008 Article IV consultation discussions were held during April 16–30, 2008; the consultation was concluded on June 25, 2008.
  - Public Information Note: http://www.imf.org/external/np/sec/pn/2008/pn0878.htm.
- Technical Assistance (TA) highlights by IMF department:
  - FAD:
    - Early multi-topic missions to establish and develop the Central Fiscal Authority (CFA, February 2000) which developed into the Ministry of Planning and Finance.
    - Assistance: budget preparation, tax policy and administration, treasury and expenditure management, oil sector fiscal regimes.
    - Long-term resident advisors assigned to the Ministry of Planning and Finance and the Revenue Service (partly under cost sharing with the UN).
    - Over August 2004–July 2005, a FAD resident advisor assisted in design and establishment of the Petroleum Fund (started operations in August 2005).
    - FAD resident advisor to the Treasurer started December 2006; replacement continued since July 2008.
    - 2007 FAD TA mission provided guidance on future reform of the non-oil tax regime.
    - April 2009 FAD TA mission provided advice on implementation of the fiscal regimes for petroleum.
  - LEG:
    - Missions advising on tax legislation, budget and financial management law, and banking regulations.
    - Joint assistance with MFD/MCM on drafting AML/CFT Law.
    - Assistance (with FAD) on drafting the Petroleum Fund Act and tax consolidation; (with MCM) on drafting the Central Bank Law.
  - MCM:
    - Early missions to establish Central Payments Office (CPO, January 2000) transformed into Banking and Payments Authority (BPA) (November 2001).
    - Assistance: payments system, banking legislation, banking supervision, asset management, accounting, organization and management, dollar-based currency system, issuance of domestic coins.
    - Recent assistance: draft insurance law and insurance supervision framework; strengthen banking supervision; AML/CFT issues; establish and train investment unit for Petroleum Fund asset management (funded by Norway; resident adviser commenced March 2005; replacement continued from November 2008); prepare for establishment of central bank; organizational design at BPA; modernize payment systems and Petroleum Fund accounting.
    - Up until 2006 long-term resident advisors (payments, accounting, supervision) assigned to BPA under UN cost-sharing; a long-term resident advisor assisted BPA General Manager Feb 2005–Feb 2008; subsequently support provided peripatetically funded by a Japanese grant.
  - STA:
    - Multi-sector statistical mission in November 2000 to assess macroeconomic data and help establish Statistical Division in Ministry of Planning and Finance.
    - Long-term statistical advisors during November 2001–October 2005; peripatetic statistical advisor since 2007 for balance of payments statistics; responsibility for BOP transferred to BPA in 2007.
    - Provisional annual balance of payments statements for 2006 and 2007 published in December 2008.
    - Early 2008 MFS mission helped introduce standardized report forms (SRFs) and integrated monetary database; Timor-Leste published a country page in IFS for the first time.
    - March 2009 follow-up MFS mission assisted in expanding institutional coverage of depository corporations to include microfinance institutions and revising the call report form used to collect balance sheet data.
- Resident Representative:
  - Resident representative office established in Dili in August 2000.
  - Current resident representative: Mr. Tobias Rasmussen (assumed post February 2006).
  - Resident representative office closed at end-June 2009.

### Relations with the World Bank Group
- Membership and eligibility:
  - Timor-Leste joined the World Bank Group on July 23, 2002; eligible for IDA assistance on October 9, 2002.
  - To date, there has been no lending to Timor-Leste reflecting the authorities’ policy to avoid external borrowing, including concessional loans.
  - Timor-Leste joined IFC in September 2004; an IFC office was opened in Dili in 2006 (together with Pacific Enterprise Development Facility).
- Role in reconstruction and financing:
  - World Bank acted as trustee and co-manager of the Trust Fund for East Timor (TFET), established December 1999 for reconstruction and development grant assistance.
  - Under TFET (co-managed with ADB), World Bank administered projects in social services, agriculture, private sector development, community development and governance, economic capacity building, and petroleum sector development.
  - Pledges to TFET: total funds reaching $178 million (donors’ contributions $167 million including $10 million by the World Bank; investment income $9 million). TFET projects expected to wind down by end-2010.
- Budget support and programs:
  - Transition Support Program (TSP) FY2003–2005 provided about $30 million annually in budget support (about $5 million financed by IDA; balance by 9 bilateral partners).
  - Consolidation Support Program (CSP) to FY2006/07 provided around $10 million annually (about $0.5 million financed by IDA).
  - TSP and CSP thematic focus: (1) good governance; (2) service delivery for poverty reduction (education, health); (3) job creation (private sector, agriculture, basic infrastructure).
  - As budget support no longer required given increase in petroleum revenue, CSP replaced by donor support for Government’s National Priorities Program launched in 2008 and continued in 2009 with seven priority areas: (i) agriculture and food security; (ii) rural development; (iii) human resources development; (iv) social protection and social services; (v) public safety and security; (vi) clean and effective Government; (vii) access to justice.
- Analytical and advisory work:
  - World Bank produced Country Economic Memorandum, Poverty Assessment, Public Expenditure Management and Accountability Note, Public Expenditure Review, Education Sector Review, Paper on Strengthening the Institutions of Governance, and Doing Business reports (2006, 2007, 2008).
  - Short reports: Key Lessons from the Creation of Veterans Policy in Timor-Leste (September 2008); Policy Note on Population Growth and its Implications in Timor-Leste (October 2008); Timor-Leste: Poverty in a Young Nation (November 2008).
- Commitments and projects (as of March 2009):
  - Total commitment: US$69.8 million (including IDA commitment of US$12.4 million) with 9 active projects in health and education, agriculture, youth development, planning and public financial management, and energy.
- Development Partners Meeting:
  - The eighth Timor-Leste Development Partners Meeting (TLDPM) took place on April 2–4, 2009; World Bank helped prepare Government background paper for TLDPM.

### Relations with the Asian Development Bank (AsDB)
- Membership and lending:
  - Timor-Leste joined AsDB on July 24, 2002.
  - To date, there has been no lending to the country; AsDB active in reconstruction and development since late 1999.
- TFET involvement and projects:
  - Prior to 2008 AsDB co-managed TFET with World Bank.
  - Under TFET, AsDB managed six projects with total funding of $51.7 million:
    - Emergency Infrastructure Rehabilitation Project ($29.8 million);
    - Emergency Infrastructure Rehabilitation Project 2 ($9 million);
    - Water Supply and Sanitation Rehabilitation Project ($4.5 million);
    - Water Supply and Sanitation Rehabilitation Project 2 ($4.5 million);
    - Hera Fisheries Port Facilities Rehabilitation Project ($1 million);
    - Microfinance Development Project (originally $4 million, reduced to $2.7 million).
  - Projects focused on rehabilitation of physical infrastructure (urban and rural power, national roads, ports, water and sanitation) and development of microfinance.
- Country Operations Business Plan (2008–2010) and funding:
  - Infrastructure development and management identified as primary focus.
  - Ongoing projects: road rehabilitation ($10 million grant) and Dili water supply ($6 million grant) funded through ADF IX.
  - ADF X allocates approximately $20 million for the first biennial period 2009-2010, entirely on a grant basis, mostly for road maintenance, rehabilitation, and improvement.
  - Additional AsDB technical assistance will average approximately $2 million per annum.
  - AsDB’s Infrastructure Project Management TA: $15 million four-year package co-financed with AusAID to finance international and domestic project engineers, procurement specialists, and others to work within the Ministry of Infrastructure.
- Pipeline and support:
  - AsDB preparing a new ADF-funded road network development project and a community-based roads maintenance project drawing on the Japan Fund for Poverty Reduction.
  - A regional private sector development support program can support access to finance (micro-finance and secured transactions) and public-private-partnerships in infrastructure.
  - AsDB intensifying efforts to strengthen and divest the Microfinance Institute of Timor-Leste (IMfTL).
  - AsDB designing technical assistance program to support statistics and macroeconomic management.

### Statistical Issues (As of June 30, 2009)
- Overall assessment:
  - Data provision to the Fund has serious shortcomings that significantly hamper surveillance.
  - Weaknesses remain in macroeconomic data, especially national accounts.
  - A multi-sector Fund statistics mission visited Dili in November 2000; Statistical Division established in Ministry of Planning and Finance in 2001.
  - Long-term resident statistical advisor assisted during November 2001–February 2004; succeeded by new resident advisor until September 2005.
  - Technical assistance in balance of payments (peripatetic) and monetary statistics to BPA began mid-2007 and January 2008 respectively; will continue through at least FY 2010.
- National accounts:
  - World Bank-financed BIDE produced national accounts data for 2000 and GDP estimates for 2001-03; estimates suffer from limited source data and substantial extrapolation.
  - Statistics Directorate has not been able to replicate BIDE estimation exercise.
  - Fund staff, in cooperation with the Macroeconomic Unit in the Ministry of Finance, prepared GDP estimates (including for the oil sector).
  - To improve national accounts data: appropriate staff and substantial efforts in data collection and compilation are needed.
  - Using World Bank funding and commencing in April 2009, authorities are employing a consultant to develop annual estimates of GDP.
- Price statistics:
  - CPI compiled for Dili since December 2001 and for whole country since June 2003.
  - Prices for all items collected monthly in Dili; elsewhere quarterly for representative selection of regions.
  - Interim monthly price movements for items outside Dili estimated using Dili item price movements as indicator series.
  - CPI basket and weighting scheme revised in mid-2003 under donor-supported project to address inappropriate and outdated weights.
  - Further update of CPI weights based on Timor-Leste Living Standards Survey (2006/7) expected to commence later in 2009.
  - An update of products and outlets is also needed.
- Labor market statistics:
  - Annual data on public sector employment and wages available in official budget documentation.
  - No regular official data on private sector employment and wages except partial data from household surveys by UNDP, ILO, ADB, and World Bank.
- Government finance statistics (GFS):
  - Official data on central government revenue and expenditure published quarterly.
  - Audited annual financial statements of executed budget made available to APD as soon as released, normally three months after fiscal year end.
  - Monthly data available on request through budget, treasury, and revenue services.
  - Compilation follows Manual on Government Finance Statistics (GFSM 1986) classification (including both functional and economic classification).
  - Only partial data available on fiscal and quasi-fiscal activities undertaken by bilateral donors outside central government budget.
  - Currently four non-financial public enterprises treated as government agencies; data available in audited annual financial statements.
  - No data currently reported for the GFS Yearbook and the International Financial Statistics.
- Monetary statistics:
  - Monetary statistics compiled by BPA generally following Monetary and Financial Statistics Manual methodology.
  - Data incomplete due to absence of official data on public currency holdings (difficult under current currency regime) and banks’ positions with public nonfinancial corporations.
  - BPA publishes current monetary data on its website regularly, a quarterly bulletin, and an annual report with key monetary aggregates.
  - Detailed monthly monetary data now available from July 2002 onward.

*International Monetary Fund. DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF TIMOR-LESTE. Staff Report for the 2009 Article IV Consultation––Informational Annex. July 8, 2009.*

### introduction of the standardized report forms (SRFs). Beginning in February 2008, monetary

### _cr09219 - introduction of the standardized report forms (SRFs). Beginning in February 2008, monetary

### Monetary reporting and SRFs
- Beginning in February 2008, monetary data are reported to the IMF for publication in the International Financial Statistics.
- SRF-based data are used for the Fund’s operational and publication purposes.
- The BPA is planning:
  - to introduce a new chart of accounts for the BPA in the coming months;
  - to introduce a revised call report form (CRF) in mid-2009 to obtain balance-sheet information from other depository corporations (ODCs).
- A March 2009 mission assisted the authorities in finalizing the design of the CRF and expanded the institutional coverage of the ODCs to include all microfinance institutions.
- A follow-up mission has been tentatively scheduled during FY 2010 to assist authorities in:
  - introducing the SRFs for the central bank based on the new chart of accounts of the BPA;
  - introducing the SRFs for the ODCs based on the revised CRF and including the credit unions in the institutional coverage of the ODCs.

### Balance of payments statistics
- Monthly merchandise exports and imports:
  - Produced starting March 2000, based on customs reports with a breakdown for major commodity categories.
  - Data do not include oil and gas exports or an estimate of the large, unrecorded border trade.
  - Monthly trade data are now published regularly but there are significant gaps in the series for 2006 and 2007.
- In Fund staff estimates, data on oil/gas revenue are currently recorded as current income based on fiscal data.
- With technical assistance from the IMF’s Statistics Department:
  - Annual balance of payments data for 2006 and 2007 were published by the BPA in December 2008.
  - The 2008 estimates have not yet been finalized.
- Methodology and further development:
  - Methodology for basic annual estimates is in place.
  - Further development work is anticipated to address limitations in existing data sources, specifically grants, merchandise trade statistics, and travel exports.
- Survey and coverage gaps:
  - Coverage of the survey of foreign direct investment enterprises needs to be expanded.
  - Exploration and extraction activities in the Joint Petroleum Development Area and in the exclusive territory will require continuous coverage.
  - Limited information on remittances from Timorese working abroad; improvement in estimation/compilation procedures for remittances should be pursued.
- Financial stocks and IIP:
  - Some data on stocks of financial assets and liabilities have been collected as balance of payments development has taken place.
  - Annual international investment position statements should be finalized.
  - Development of quarterly statistics should be pursued.

### Data standards and dissemination
- Not a General Data Dissemination System participant.
- No data ROSC is available.

### Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (selected entries, As of June 24, 2009)
- Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation 5/2009; Date received 6/2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: Date of latest observation 5/2009; Date received 6/2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Reserve/Base Money (excludes currency in circulation): Date of latest observation 5/2009; Date received 6/2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Broad Money (excludes currency in circulation): Date of latest observation 5/2009; Date received 6/2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Central Bank Balance Sheet: Date of latest observation 5/2009; Date received 6/2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: Date of latest observation 5/2009; Date received 6/2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Interest Rates: Date of latest observation 5/2009; Date received 6/2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- Consumer Price Index: Date of latest observation 3/2009; Date received 5/2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication Q.
- Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing – Central Government: Date of latest observation 3/2009; Date received 6/2009; Frequency of Data Q; Frequency of Reporting Q; Frequency of publication Q.
- External Current Account Balance: Date of latest observation 2007; Date received 12/2008; Frequency of Data A; Frequency of Reporting A; Frequency of publication A.
- Exports and Imports of Goods and Services: Date of latest observation 4/2009; Date received 6/2009; Frequency of Data M; Frequency of Reporting M; Frequency of publication M.
- GDP/GNI: Date of latest observation 2003; Date received 10/2004; Frequency of Data ...; Frequency of Reporting ...; Frequency of publication ...
- Gross External Debt: Not applicable.
- International Investment Position: Not available.
- Notes on table entries:
  - Footnote: Includes reserve assets pledged or otherwise encumbered as well as net derivative positions.
  - Footnote: Both market-based and officially-determined, including discount rates, money market rates, rates on treasury bills, notes and bonds.
  - Footnote: Foreign, domestic bank, and domestic nonbank financing.
  - Footnote: For Timor-Leste the general government includes public spending from donors, on which regular data on execution are not available.
  - Footnote: Exports and imports entry includes only goods; there are significant gaps in the series and no information on services is available.
  - Frequency codes: Daily (D), Weekly (W), Monthly (M), Quarterly (Q), Annually (A); NA: Not Available.
  - International Investment Position includes external gross financial asset and liability positions vis-à-vis nonresidents.

### Poverty reduction and the role of infrastructure
- Poverty and living standards:
  - A 2001 household income and expenditure study estimated that 36 percent of the population lived below the national poverty line, almost all in rural areas.
  - A 2007 update suggests many key dimensions of living standards have improved (self-assessments, school enrolment rates, immunization rates, availability of many basic services).
  - The share of the population living below the poverty line was found to have increased to about 50 percent in 2007.
  - Half of the children less than five years were underweight in 2007, with 12 percent to 18 percent of children under five years severely underweight.
  - About three quarters of the poor live in rural areas.
- Infrastructure and access:
  - At the national level, 64 percent of the poor have access to all weather roads, compared with 76 percent of the non-poor.
  - In rural areas, the proportion of poor with access to all weather roads is 58 percent compared with 68 percent of the non-poor.
- Road network and transport:
  - Road is the primary mode of transport, carrying 70 percent of freight and 90 percent of passengers.
  - Timor-Leste has an extensive road network of about 6,000 km, half of which are currently undeveloped rural tracks.
  - The core network comprises 1,400 km of national roads connecting the 13 districts and 900 km of district roads linking major population centers to the national roads.
  - About 80 percent (or 1,800 km) of core roads are, or used to be, paved.
  - Almost the whole core road network needs rehabilitation to restore to a maintainable condition due to premature deterioration from lack of routine and preventive maintenance, intense rainfalls, and unstable geotechnical conditions causing frequent landslides.
  - Asian Development Bank road condition survey: about 22 percent of the core roads are in poor condition and about 70 percent in very poor condition.
  - Estimated annual maintenance expenditure needs for the whole core road network are in the order of $20–30 million under current road conditions.
- Power and water:
  - Power and water supply and sanitation infrastructure are degraded.
  - Access to regular power supply in urban areas has deteriorated.
  - Access to clean water remains problematic in both urban and rural areas.
- Contributing factors to infrastructure shortfalls:
  - Poor and deteriorating physical infrastructure.
  - Cost and logistical issues in accessing rural areas.
  - Weak public sector capacity in infrastructure planning, management and prioritization.

### Prospects for financial development — emerging role of microfinance
- Banking sector constraints:
  - High level of excess liquidity in the financial system, yet commercial banks are reluctant to lend to local businesses.
  - Foreign banks cannot own land and must rely on land leases or other assets as security.
  - Uncertainty over legitimacy of land titles and nascent system of land leases make land difficult to use as collateral.
  - Absence of a local insurance industry hinders use of other assets as collateral.
  - Civil court system is still developing and is slow and heavily overworked, adding to uncertainty in accessing security in the event of loan default.
  - These difficulties contributed to a quick emergence of a non-performing loan problem following a surge in domestic credit.
- Microfinance sector:
  - Microfinance has narrow coverage but is showing adaptability within the constrained environment.
  - The largest microfinance institution, Instituição de Micro Finanças de Timor-Leste (IMfTL), has operated since 2002.
  - IMfTL built its lending around loans secured by public sector salaries; many loans were for housing and household needs and also used within extended families to start small-scale business enterprises (small trading and taxi operations).
  - A $1 million ceiling on deposits under the Banking and Payments Authority (BPA) Act delayed expansion plans; IMfTL was the only microfinance institution regulated by the BPA.
  - The ceiling was lifted to $3 million after the government took sole ownership of, and recapitalized, IMfTL in December 2008.
  - Deposits with IMfTL, from around 23,000 depositors, had reached $1.4 million by March.

*Italic source attribution: IMF staff report content provided in the supplied PDF excerpt.*

### 2009. Total loans of $4.0 million as of March 2009 were well above the $2.3 million of

### _cr09219 - 2009. Total loans of $4.0 million as of March 2009 were well above the $2.3 million of

### Microfinance sector: structure, performance, and unmet demand
- Total loans of IMfTL (Instituição de Micro Finanças de Timor-Leste) were $4.0 million as of March 2009, compared with $2.3 million as of December 2007.
- Seven district offices are established with offices planned for all districts by 2011.
- Product composition:
  - Salary loans account for 75 percent of total loans.
  - Alternative products rising: micro finance group loans, market vendor loans, agriculture loans, and micro enterprises loans.
- Asset quality:
  - Low overall provision for non-performing loans of only 2.2 percent of the total value of loans.
- Other microfinance institutions:
  - Moris Rasik: operates solely in rural areas, lends only to women (Grameen Bank approach); total loans were $2.2 million as of December 2007; deposits from 11,500 accounts totaled $0.8 million.
  - Tuba Rei Martin: held around $0.4 million in deposits from almost 3,000 accounts as of July 2008, with loans of $0.4 million.
- Complementary providers: credit unions, pawn shops, money lenders, and small donor-funded loan facilities.
- Unmet demand:
  - Recent assessment estimated a shortfall as much as 80,000 micro-credit loans worth more than US$50 million.
  - Lack of credit is a particularly important constraint to agriculture, which accounts for about 80 percent of employment.
  - Agribusiness constrained because loans are generally unavailable for purchase of farm inputs or improvements, or for trade in farm products.
  - Micro-savings services are under-supplied.

### Costs, lending rates, and proposed interventions
- Interest rate indications:
  - IMfTL lends at 16 percent to 18 percent per annum.
  - Rates at Tuba Rei Martin are up to 70 percent per annum.
- Primary driver: high cost of providing large numbers of small transactions.
- Proposed response:
  - Inclusive Finance for the Under-Served Economy (INFUSE) project proposed as a source of low cost wholesale funds (and technical support).
  - Caution: need to ensure inflow of foreign funds does not impede deposit taking.

### Policy discussion: national development bank versus targeted support
- Long-standing proposals for a government-owned national development bank raise key issues:
  - Potential to displace rather than supplement existing financial operations.
  - Potential fiscal downside of carrying too much risk to kick-start development.
  - Question of desirability of government ownership of financial institutions.
- Alternative approach recommended in the text:
  - Provide support through new, targeted programs implemented through existing institutions.
  - Emphasis on helping potential borrowers develop and implement good loan projects rather than just providing cheap loans to maximize development impact.

### Broader financial sector and macro context (selected points)
- Commercial banking sector: three foreign bank branches; sector remains very small.
- Credit conditions: credit has remained stagnant, hampered by a high share of non-performing loans and lack of effective contract enforcement.
- Only a small, state-owned microfinance institution experienced significant credit growth.
- Executive Board view and macro context:
  - Non-oil real GDP growth reached almost 13 percent in 2008.
  - The global crisis had little immediate impact due to limited transmission channels (trade, investment, finance).
  - Inflation peaked at over 10 percent year-on-year in mid-2008 and has since declined.
  - Central government spending rose sharply in 2008; petroleum revenue expansion drove fiscal and external surpluses.
  - Near-term outlook: real non-oil GDP growth expected to moderate but remain high; oil prices expected to remain below their 2008 average, prompting a sharp decline in fiscal and external surpluses.
- Key structural reform priorities noted:
  - Use oil and gas revenue to develop a sustainable non-oil economy and alleviate poverty while maintaining macroeconomic stability.
  - Bring expenditure in line with sustainable income as soon as existing commitments allow.
  - Strategic Development Plan to guide a medium-term budget framework for fiscal sustainability, improving quality of government spending and public financial management, and strengthening transparency and controls.
  - Enhance fiscal revenue by improving tax administration, broadening tax base, and charging appropriate tariffs for utilities, including electricity.
  - Maintain the Petroleum Fund as the cornerstone of public financial management; support prudent widening of its investment portfolio; subject foreign borrowing to parliamentary approval and ensure concessional terms and net positive rate of return.
  - Strengthen financial sector supervision, cooperation with home supervisors of foreign banks, and pass legislation to safeguard the Banking and Payment Authority’s autonomy.
  - Passage of pending land law, strengthening contract enforcement (judicial reform and alternative dispute resolution), and easing business regulation (simplifying registration and licensing) to boost competitiveness and financial deepening.
- Selected numeric indicators (as reported in the source):
  - Non-oil real GDP growth: 4.2, 6.2, -5.8, 8.4, 12.8, 7.4, 7.5 (2004–2010 series).
  - Inflation (CPI, end-period): 2.5, 1.0, 6.7, 7.6, 6.1, 2.3, 4.0 (2004–2010 series).
  - Investment-saving balance, gross investment (percent of non-oil GDP): 21, 21, 23, 26, 46, 51, 54 (2004–2010 series).
  - Central government revenues (percent of non-oil GDP): 67, 128, 205, 343, 490, 279, 257 (2004–2010 series).
  - Petroleum revenue (percent of non-oil GDP): 46, 107, 195, 330, 481, 269, 248 (2004–2010 series).
  - Overall balance (percent of non-oil GDP): 46, 102, 174, 284, 384, 178, 162 (2004–2010 series).
  - Petroleum Fund balance (percent of non-oil GDP, end-period): 5, 112, 310, 525, 841, 866, 940 (2004–2010 series).

*International Monetary Fund — 2009 Article IV Consultation materials excerpt*

### 2.2  Government’s current financing strategy

### 2.2  Government’s current financing strategy

### Current financing approach
- The country has relied on its own resources and avoided embarking on an external borrowing strategy.
- The Petroleum Fund Law allows drawings to exceed the estimated sustainable income, if necessary and justifiable as being in the long-term interest of the country, under approval by the parliament, through a highly responsible and transparent process.

### 2009 financing request and parliamentary approval
- To finance and fully implement the ambitious program of the 2009 Budget, the government requested parliamentary approval to withdraw up to $589.8 million from the Petroleum Fund.
- The requested withdrawal represented $181.2 million in excess of the estimated sustainable income.
- The request complied with all the legal requirements defined in the Petroleum Fund Law.
- The parliament recognized the request as being in the long-term interest of the country — and therefore profitable for future generations — and approved it.

### Fiscal principles and commitments
- The authorities remain committed to the principles of fiscal sustainability and inter-generational equity.

*Source: _cr09219 - 2.2  Government’s current financing strategy*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09219.pdf_
