## _cr09293

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr09293](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09293.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09293.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09293.pdf.json)

---

### Executive Summary — Overview and key policy issues
- The Dominican economy suffered major damage from natural disasters in the last two years and has been further and severely impacted by the global downturn and turmoil in international financial markets.
- External spillovers: slower growth in the U.S. and Europe reduced tourism arrivals, FDI inflows and remittances; failure of CL Financial Group in Trinidad and Tobago increased requests for withdrawals of deposit-like liabilities of its insurance subsidiaries in Dominica.
- Government request: disbursement under the Rapid-Access Component of the Fund’s Exogenous Shocks Facility equivalent to SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota) to help deal with balance of payments effects.
- Key policy challenges:
  - Stem the decline in economic activity resulting from the global downturn.
  - Maintain a sustainable fiscal stance given the high public debt.
  - Improve competitiveness and reduce vulnerabilities to exogenous shocks.

### Fiscal policy, public debt, and outlook
- Fiscal stance judged appropriately consistent with reducing high public debt; temporary fiscal easing in FY 2008/09 and FY 2009/10 financed reconstruction, protection of the poor, and mitigation of the global downturn.
- Authorities plan to reduce capital spending back to historical levels to return to primary surplus target of 3 percent of GDP after temporary easing.
- Public debt dynamics and recent figures:
  - Public debt/GDP ratio: 2003 = 128 percent; 2008 = 87 percent of GDP.
  - Primary fiscal surplus: FY 2007/08 = 4½ percent of GDP; FY 2008/09 = 1 percent of GDP.
- Fiscal figures (selected projections and estimates):
  - Real GDP growth (percent): 2007 = 1.8; 2008 = 3.2; 2009 (Proj.) = 1.1; 2010 (Proj.) = 2.0
  - Inflation (end period, percent): 2007 = 6.0; 2008 = 1.9; 2009 (Proj.) = 1.8; 2010 (Proj.) = 1.5
  - Total revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 2007 = 44.7; 2008 = 43.6; 2009 (Proj.) = 41.0; 2010 (Proj.) = 40.7
  - Total expenditure (percent of GDP): 2007 = 42.5; 2008 = 44.4; 2009 (Proj.) = 42.3; 2010 (Proj.) = 40.4
  - Capital expenditure (percent of GDP): 2007 = 14.2; 2008 = 15.6; 2009 (Proj.) = 12.7; 2010 (Proj.) = 10.8
  - Overall balance (percent of GDP): 2007 = 2.2; 2008 = -0.8; 2009 (Proj.) = -1.4; 2010 (Proj.) = 0.3
  - Primary balance (percent of GDP): 2007 = 4.6; 2008 = 1.0; 2009 (Proj.) = 1.4; 2010 (Proj.) = 3.0
  - Public sector debt (percent of GDP): 2007 = 90.9; 2008 = 86.9; 2009 (Proj.) = 84.5; 2010 (Proj.) = 81.4
  - Of which: external debt (percent of GDP): 2007 = 63.6; 2008 = 57.6; 2009 (Proj.) = 56.0; 2010 (Proj.) = 54.8
  - Imputed net international reserves (millions of U.S. dollars): 2007 = 50.4; 2008 = 44.8; 2009 (Proj.) = 41.5; 2010 (Proj.) = 41.9
- Authorities negotiating with hold-out creditors; payments continue into escrow per 2005 debt restructuring agreement.
- Fiscal outlook and near-term projections:
  - Primary fiscal surplus expected to increase modestly to 1.4 percent of GDP in FY 2009/10.
  - Wage bill contained at 12 percent of GDP.
  - Total revenue projected to increase by about 0.5 percent of GDP reflecting higher yields on VAT and excise taxes.
  - Revenue losses from the income tax reform: about 1 percent of GDP in FY 2007/08; expected to rise to about 1½ percent per year over the medium term.
  - Authorities budgeted revenue conservatively and would resist modifications to the VAT.
  - Capital expenditure for rehabilitation expected to be financed mainly by external grants.
  - Authorities to develop fiscal contingency measures if global recession is more severe or protracted.

### External sector, balance of payments, and ESF request
- Natural disaster and global downturn effects:
  - Two hurricanes in 2007 and 2008 caused cumulative damage estimated at close to 35 percent of GDP.
  - Hurricane Dean (2007) major damage to agriculture; Hurricane Omar (2008) affected tourism, fishing and coastal infrastructure.
- Current account and financing:
  - Current account deficit widened to about 32 percent of GDP in 2008 due to reconstruction imports and lower exports.
  - Large current account deficit mostly financed by external grants and FDI.
- 2009 projections and shocks:
  - Real GDP growth projected: 2009 = 1 percent; 2010 = about 2 percent.
  - Inflation expected to remain stable below 2 percent.
  - Stayover arrivals projected to decline by about 15 percent; tourism receipts expected to decline by more than arrivals.
  - Remittances projected to decline; tourism-related FDI projects to slow significantly.
  - Decline in FDI-related and fuel imports expected to partially offset tourism and remittance declines.
  - Overall balance on the balance of payments projected to rise to US$10.7 million in 2009, with an external financing gap of about US$8 million (about 2 percent of GDP) after exceptional financing.
  - Net foreign assets of the banking system projected to decline by around EC$39 million (US$14.4 million).
- Estimated net impact table highlights (millions of U.S. dollars):
  - Current account balance: 2008 = -117.7; 2009 (Proj.) = -121.7; Difference = -4.1
  - (A) Exports: 2008 = 35.7; 2009 (Proj.) = 34.2; Difference = -1.5
  - (B) Imports: 2008 = -188.6; 2009 (Proj.) = -177.1; Difference = 11.5
    - (C) FDI related (fuel and non-fuel): 2008 = -35.9; 2009 (Proj.) = -18.0; Difference = 17.9
    - (D) Fuel and food price effects: 2008 = -80.9; 2009 (Proj.) = -62.6; Difference = 18.4
  - (E) Travel (net): 2008 = 64.3; 2009 (Proj.) = 46.6; Difference = -17.7
  - (F) Private transfers: 2008 = 29.2; 2009 (Proj.) = 23.9; Difference = -5.2
  - Capital and financial account: 2008 = 110.9; 2009 (Proj.) = 111.0
    - (G) Foreign direct investment: 2008 = 59.9; 2009 (Proj.) = 30.0; Difference = -29.8
  - Overall balance: 2008 = -6.7; 2009 (Proj.) = -10.7
  - Financing: 2008 = 6.7; 2009 (Proj.) = 10.7
  - Change in imputed reserves: 2008 = 5.6; 2009 (Proj.) = 3.2
  - Exceptional financing: 2008 = 1.1; 2009 (Proj.) = 2.4
  - Request for ESF: 2009 (Proj.) = 5.1 (included in financing assumptions)
  - Memorandum:
    - Request for ESF (In percent of GDP): 2009 (Proj.) = 1.4
    - Nominal GDP (U.S. dollars): 2008 = 364.4; 2009 (Proj.) = 375.6
    - Imputed reserves 1/: 2008 = 44.8; 2009 (Proj.) = 41.5
    - Imputed reserves (in months of imports of goods): 2008 = 2.8; 2009 (Proj.) = 2.8
  - 1/ Imputed reserves include ESF financing in 2009 assuming disbursement of 40 percent of quota.
- ESF access and rationale:
  - Authorities requested Fund financing equivalent to SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota) under the RAC-ESF.
  - Borrowing represents approximately 1¼ percent of GDP and about 1 week of imports of goods and services.
  - Level of access would cover about 30 percent of the estimated net impact on the balance of payments attributable to exogenous shocks (US$16.5 million).
  - Requested financing would prevent Dominica’s imputed reserves from falling further below 3 months of imports of goods.
  - Executive Board approved disbursement equivalent to SDR 3.28 million (about US$5.1 million).

### Financial sector and nonbank vulnerabilities
- Banking sector performance and indicators:
  - Private sector credit increased by 8½ percent in 2008 while broad money grew by 5 percent.
  - Additional lending financed by reducing deposits at the ECCB, leading to a decline in imputed reserves by US$5½ million to US$44.8 million.
  - Domestic interest rates largely unchanged; sovereign spreads spiked to 2200 basis points at end-2008 before declining to 1700 basis points by end-March 2009.
  - Banking system remains profitable and well-capitalized: capital to risk-weighted assets about 15 percent (ECCU minimum requirement = 8 percent).
  - Banking indicators (selected years):
    - Number of banks: 2004–2008 = 4
    - Capital to risk-weighted assets (percent): 2004 = 23.5; 2005 = 26.2; 2006 = 20.8; 2007 = 16.9; 2008 = 15.0
    - Unsatisfactory assets to total loans (percent): 2004 = 22.5; 2005 = 22.0; 2006 = 9.3; 2007 = 8.1; 2008 = 7.1
    - Provisions to NPLs (percent): 2004 = 7.3; 2005 = 5.9; 2006 = 2.4; 2007 = 2.4; 2008 = 1.5
    - Return on assets (percent): 2004 = 1.2; 2005 = 1.2; 2006 = 1.5; 2007 = 1.5; 2008 = 0.7
    - Liquid assets to deposits (percent): 2004 = 55.9; 2005 = 49.9; 2006 = 56.3; 2007 = 59.8; 2008 = 50.8
- Nonbank financial sector risks and exposures:
  - Collapse of CL Financial Group exposed deficiencies in regulation of nonbanks.
  - Credit unions and insurance companies compete with commercial banks for deposits and loans but lack similar supervisory standards.
  - Insurance companies offered deposit-type products yielding annual interest rates far in excess of commercial banks, reflecting riskier investment activities by head offices.
  - Total exposure of Dominican residents to deposit-like liabilities of CL Financial insurance companies: about EC$80 million (8 percent of GDP).
  - Requests for withdrawals have been deferred so far; authorities expect fiscal implications to be much lower than total exposure even under pessimistic asset value assumptions.
  - Credit unions hold deposits equivalent to about 40 percent of bank deposits and are lightly regulated.
- Regulatory and regional response:
  - Resolving insurance sector difficulties will require a regional approach.
  - Authorities should coordinate with other ECCB member countries on legislation to strengthen regulation and supervision of the nonbank financial sector.
  - Act establishing a single regulatory unit (SRU) has been passed; efforts underway to strengthen the Financial Services Unit (FSU).
  - Staff encouraged enactment of remaining legislation (including new laws for insurance and credit union sectors) slated to be presented to parliament before end-2009.

### Structural policies, recovery strategy, and reforms
- Structural reform priorities to improve competitiveness and reduce vulnerabilities:
  - Improve the business climate and reduce the cost of doing business as central to recovery strategy.
  - Address infrastructure bottlenecks, inefficient contract enforcement, and land registration processes; program being developed with EU assistance.
  - Strengthen tax administration and maintain the integrity of the value added tax.
  - Implement the third phase of ongoing income tax reform.
- Recovery measures implemented by authorities:
  - Financial assistance to hotels affected by Hurricane Omar; import duty concessions on capital items used in rehabilitation.
  - Exploring alternatives, including ferry services, to compensate for loss of airlift.
  - Accelerated implementation of capital projects to ameliorate unemployment impacts.
  - Targeted social spending to protect the most vulnerable.
  - Authorities have avoided broad incentive packages for tourism offered by other regional governments.
  - Tourism-related infrastructure and improved air access and roads prioritized to resuscitate growth.
- Expected medium-term effects:
  - Move toward a medium-term expenditure framework (MTEF) to improve predictability of capital expenditure and consistency with medium-term fiscal objectives.
  - Under DSA baseline assumptions (real GDP growth rising to 3 percent annually; primary fiscal surplus recovering to 3 percent of GDP from FY 2010/11; projected grant financing at around 8½ percent of GDP), Dominica would reach ECCB target of 60 percent debt-to-GDP around 2016.

### Risks, vulnerabilities, and downside scenarios
- Key risks and vulnerabilities:
  - Downside risks from volatility of grant inflows; lower grants would require scaling back capital expenditure to achieve a 3 percent primary surplus.
  - Most extreme shock scenario (lower GDP growth, weaker exports, lower GDP deflator, fall in non-debt-creating flows) would push NPV of debt-to-GDP above the 50 percent threshold over 2011–13.
  - Most extreme export shock (export growth at one standard deviation below historical average in 2009–2010) would push NPV of debt-to-exports ratio slightly above the 200 percent threshold in one year.
  - A sustained widening of sovereign spreads would raise interest payments by about 0.5 percent of GDP.
  - Possible contingent liabilities from resolution of CL Financial insurance subsidiaries could raise the required primary surplus.
- Positive mitigating factors:
  - Gross financing needs decreasing due to saving under prudent fiscal policy, lengthening of maturities from debt restructuring, and large reliance on concessional multilateral borrowing (65 percent of total external debt outstanding).
  - Authorities’ resolve to maintain prudent fiscal policies and foster private sector-led growth; commitment to continued close cooperation with the Fund and expectation of continued international support.

### Fund appraisal, support, and recommendations
- Staff support: Authorities’ request for Fund financing under the RAC-ESF in the amount of SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota) supported by Fund staff.
- Rationale for support:
  - Large balance of payments impact of the shock.
  - Authorities’ past track record in meeting policy commitments under the recently expired PRGF arrangement.
  - Soundness of authorities’ policies.
- Staff appraisal and recommended priorities:
  - Commendation for sound macroeconomic and structural policies that improved resilience and allowed limited fiscal stimulus supporting positive real GDP growth in 2009.
  - Prioritize capital projects and bring expenditure back to sustainable levels while planning contingency measures for a more severe or prolonged global downturn.
  - Continue structural reforms to reduce cost of doing business and ease infrastructure bottlenecks to enhance private sector growth.
  - Strengthen regulatory framework for the nonbank financial sector through the single regulatory unit and complementary legislation to avoid regulatory arbitrage.
  - Work with regional counterparts to resolve CL Financial while minimizing fiscal costs and securing private sector participation.
- Access and repayment capacity:
  - ESF request: SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota); Executive Board disbursement: SDR 3.28 million (about US$5.1 million).
  - Fund credit outstanding relative to quota would reach about 153 percent including the prospective ESF.
  - Bunching of repayments to the Fund in 2011-13: annual principal repayment/repurchase increases from slightly less than US$1 million in 2010 to an average of US$2 million annually in 2011–13.
  - Envisaged fiscal path and recovery in growth would improve debt servicing capacity; downside risks remain if global downturn is deeper or more protracted.

### Key quantitative summary (selected figures)
- Hurricane Dean damage: nearly 20 percent of GDP.
- Combined hurricanes damage: roughly 35 percent of GDP, nearly US$130 million.
- ENDA purchase (February 2008): SDR 2.05 million (25 percent of quota).
- Request under RAC-ESF: SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota).
- Balance of payments deficit projected 2009: US$10.7 million.
- External financing gap: about US$8 million.
- GDP growth: 2008 = 3 percent; 2009 (Proj.) ≈ 1 percent; 2010 (Proj.) ≈ 2 percent.
- Inflation: expected to remain modest at 2 percent.
- Primary fiscal surplus: estimated 1 percent of GDP in 2008/09; targeted 1.4–1.5 percent of GDP in FY 2009/10; medium-term target at least 3 percent of GDP.
- Public debt-to-GDP: 2003 = 128 percent; 2008 ≈ 87 percent; target 60 percent (approach around 2016 under baseline assumptions).
- Wage bill target: 12 percent of GDP.
- Banking capital to risk-weighted assets: 2004 = 23.5 percent; 2008 = 15.0 percent.
- ECCU minimum capital adequacy requirement: 8 percent.

*IMF staff report content from _cr09293*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### Executive Summary

### Overview and Key Policy Issues
- The Dominican economy suffered major damage from natural disasters in the last two years and has been further and severely impacted by the global downturn and turmoil in international financial markets.
- External spillovers: slower growth in the U.S. and Europe has reduced tourism arrivals, FDI inflows and remittances; failure of CL Financial Group in Trinidad and Tobago increased requests for withdrawals of deposit-like liabilities of its insurance subsidiaries in Dominica.
- The government requested a disbursement under the Rapid-Access Component of the Fund’s Exogenous Shocks Facility in an amount equivalent to SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota) to help deal with balance of payments effects.
- Key policy challenges:
  - Stem the decline in economic activity resulting from the global downturn.
  - Maintain a sustainable fiscal stance given the high public debt.
  - Improve competitiveness and reduce vulnerabilities to exogenous shocks.

### Fiscal Policy and Public Debt
- Fiscal stance is judged appropriately consistent with reducing high public debt.
- Authorities plan to reduce capital spending back to historical levels to return to their primary surplus target of 3 percent of GDP after temporary easing in FY 2008/09 and FY 2009/10.
- Temporary fiscal easing in FY 2008/09 and FY 2009/10 financed:
  - Rehabilitation of infrastructure.
  - Protection of the poor from the 2008 spike in food and fuel prices.
  - Mitigation of the impact of the global downturn.
- Expenditure reallocated to strengthen sea defenses and enhance tourism-related infrastructure; tourism-related infrastructure largely financed with external concessional resources to help ensure sustainability of public debt.
- Public debt dynamics and recent figures:
  - Public debt/GDP ratio declined from 128 percent in 2003 to 87 percent of GDP in 2008.
  - Primary fiscal surplus declined from 4½ percent of GDP in FY 2007/08 to 1 percent of GDP in FY 2008/09.
  - Fiscal figures (selected projections and estimates):
    - Real GDP growth: 2007 = 1.8, 2008 = 3.2, 2009 (Proj.) = 1.1, 2010 (Proj.) = 2.0 (percent)
    - Inflation (end period): 2007 = 6.0, 2008 = 1.9, 2009 (Proj.) = 1.8, 2010 (Proj.) = 1.5 (percent)
    - Total revenue and grants: 2007 = 44.7, 2008 = 43.6, 2009 (Proj.) = 41.0, 2010 (Proj.) = 40.7 (percent of GDP)
    - Total expenditure: 2007 = 42.5, 2008 = 44.4, 2009 (Proj.) = 42.3, 2010 (Proj.) = 40.4 (percent of GDP)
    - Capital expenditure: 2007 = 14.2, 2008 = 15.6, 2009 (Proj.) = 12.7, 2010 (Proj.) = 10.8 (percent of GDP)
    - Overall balance: 2007 = 2.2, 2008 = -0.8, 2009 (Proj.) = -1.4, 2010 (Proj.) = 0.3 (percent of GDP)
    - Primary balance: 2007 = 4.6, 2008 = 1.0, 2009 (Proj.) = 1.4, 2010 (Proj.) = 3.0 (percent of GDP)
    - Public sector debt: 2007 = 90.9, 2008 = 86.9, 2009 (Proj.) = 84.5, 2010 (Proj.) = 81.4 (percent of GDP)
    - Of which: external debt: 2007 = 63.6, 2008 = 57.6, 2009 (Proj.) = 56.0, 2010 (Proj.) = 54.8 (percent of GDP)
    - Imputed net international reserves (millions of U.S. dollars): 2007 = 50.4, 2008 = 44.8, 2009 (Proj.) = 41.5, 2010 (Proj.) = 41.9
- Authorities continue to negotiate with hold-out creditors; payments continue into escrow per 2005 debt restructuring agreement.

### Background and Recent Developments
- Natural disasters:
  - Two hurricanes in 2007 and 2008 caused cumulative damage estimated at close to 35 percent of GDP.
  - Hurricane Dean (2007): major damage to the agricultural sector.
  - Hurricane Omar (2008): affected tourism, fishing and coastal infrastructure.
- Economic performance:
  - Real GDP growth slowed to around 1¾ percent in 2007 and recovered to about 3 percent in 2008.
  - Inflation peaked at 7½ percent in September 2008; receded to around 2 percent by end-2008; inflation for 2008 averaged around 6 percent.
- Donor and concessional financing: disaster relief grants and concessional financing from the Caribbean Development Bank supported reconstruction of essential infrastructure.
- Fiscal developments:
  - Total revenue broadly in line with budget; total expenditure higher than budgeted due to rehabilitation, social assistance scale-up, and support to economic activity.
  - Public sector wage growth contained by stringent wage agreements (one percentage point increase annually for 2009 and 2010).

### External Sector and Balance of Payments
- Current account:
  - Current account deficit widened to about 32 percent of GDP in 2008 due to higher reconstruction-related imports and lower exports.
  - Large current account deficit mostly financed by external grants and FDI.
- 2009 projections and shocks:
  - Real GDP growth projected to slow to 1 percent in 2009; projected recovery to about 2 percent in 2010.
  - Inflation expected to remain stable below 2 percent.
  - Stayover arrivals projected to decline by about 15 percent; tourism receipts expected to decline by more than arrivals due to discounting and lower tourist spending.
  - Remittances projected to decline; activity in tourism-related FDI projects to slow significantly.
  - Decline in FDI-related and fuel imports expected to partially offset tourism and remittance declines.
  - Overall balance on the balance of payments projected to rise to US$10.7 million in 2009, with an external financing gap of about US$8 million (about 2 percent of GDP) after exceptional financing.
  - Net foreign assets of the banking system projected to decline by around EC$39 million (US$14.4 million).
- Estimated net impact table highlights (in millions of U.S. dollars):
  - Current account balance: 2008 = -117.7; 2009 (Proj.) = -121.7; Difference = -4.1
  - (A) Exports: 2008 = 35.7; 2009 (Proj.) = 34.2; Difference = -1.5
  - (B) Imports: 2008 = -188.6; 2009 (Proj.) = -177.1; Difference = 11.5
    - (C) FDI related (fuel and non-fuel): 2008 = -35.9; 2009 (Proj.) = -18.0; Difference = 17.9
    - (D) Fuel and food price effects: 2008 = -80.9; 2009 (Proj.) = -62.6; Difference = 18.4
  - (E) Travel (net): 2008 = 64.3; 2009 (Proj.) = 46.6; Difference = -17.7
  - (F) Private transfers: 2008 = 29.2; 2009 (Proj.) = 23.9; Difference = -5.2
  - Capital and financial account: 2008 = 110.9; 2009 (Proj.) = 111.0
    - (G) Foreign direct investment: 2008 = 59.9; 2009 (Proj.) = 30.0; Difference = -29.8
  - Overall balance: 2008 = -6.7; 2009 (Proj.) = -10.7
  - Financing: 2008 = 6.7; 2009 (Proj.) = 10.7
  - Change in imputed reserves: 2008 = 5.6; 2009 (Proj.) = 3.2
  - Exceptional financing: 2008 = 1.1; 2009 (Proj.) = 2.4
  - Request for ESF: 2009 (Proj.) = 5.1 (included in financing assumptions)
  - (H) Gross impact (E+F+G): Net impact (I) and memorandum items show:
    - (H) Gross impact leading to -52.8 (implicit in table)
    - (I) Net impact (H+C+D) leading to -16.5 (implicit in table)
  - Memorandum:
    - Request for ESF (In percent of GDP): 2009 (Proj.) = 1.4
    - Nominal GDP (in U.S. dollars): 2008 = 364.4; 2009 (Proj.) = 375.6
    - Imputed reserves 1/: 2008 = 44.8; 2009 (Proj.) = 41.5
    - Imputed reserves (in months of imports of goods): 2008 = 2.8; 2009 (Proj.) = 2.8
  - 1/ Imputed reserves include ESF financing in 2009 assuming disbursement of 40 percent of quota.

### Financial Sector and Nonbank Vulnerabilities
- Banking sector:
  - Private sector credit increased by 8½ percent in 2008 while broad money grew by 5 percent.
  - Additional lending financed by reducing deposits at the ECCB, resulting in a decline in imputed reserves by US$ 5½ million to US$ 44.8 million.
  - Domestic interest rates largely unchanged; Dominica’s sovereign spreads spiked to 2200 basis points at end 2008 before declining to 1700 basis points by end-March 2009.
  - Banking system remains profitable and well-capitalized:
    - Capital to risk-weighted assets about 15 percent (ECCU minimum requirement = 8 percent).
  - Banking indicators (selected years):
    - Number of banks: 2004–2008 = 4
    - Capital to risk-weighted assets: 2004 = 23.5; 2005 = 26.2; 2006 = 20.8; 2007 = 16.9; 2008 = 15.0 (percent)
    - Unsatisfactory assets to total loans: 2004 = 22.5; 2005 = 22.0; 2006 = 9.3; 2007 = 8.1; 2008 = 7.1 (percent)
    - Provisions to NPLs: 2004 = 7.3; 2005 = 5.9; 2006 = 2.4; 2007 = 2.4; 2008 = 1.5 (percent)
    - Return on assets: 2004 = 1.2; 2005 = 1.2; 2006 = 1.5; 2007 = 1.5; 2008 = 0.7 (percent)
    - Liquid assets to deposits: 2004 = 55.9; 2005 = 49.9; 2006 = 56.3; 2007 = 59.8; 2008 = 50.8 (percent)
- Nonbank financial sector risks:
  - Collapse of CL Financial Group exposed deficiencies in regulation of nonbank financial sector.
  - Credit unions and insurance companies compete with commercial banks for deposits and loans but are not subject to similar supervisory standards.
  - Insurance companies offered deposit-type products yielding annual interest rates far in excess of commercial banks, reflecting riskier investment activities by head offices.
  - Total exposure of Dominican residents to deposit-like liabilities of CL Financial insurance companies amounts to about EC$80 million (8 percent of GDP).
  - Requests for withdrawals have been deferred so far; authorities expect fiscal implications to be much lower than total exposure even under pessimistic asset value assumptions.
  - Credit unions hold deposits equivalent to about 40 percent of bank deposits and are lightly regulated.
- Regulatory and regional response:
  - Resolving insurance sector difficulties will require a regional approach.
  - Authorities should coordinate with other ECCB member countries on legislation to strengthen regulation and supervision of the nonbank financial sector.

### Structural Policies and Recovery Strategy
- Structural reforms prioritized to improve competitiveness and reduce vulnerabilities.
- Authorities emphasize improving the business climate and reducing the cost of doing business as central to the economic recovery strategy.
- Recovery measures implemented by authorities:
  - Financial assistance to hotels affected by Hurricane Omar.
  - Exploring alternatives, including ferry services, to compensate for loss of airlift.
  - Accelerated implementation of capital projects to ameliorate unemployment impacts.
  - Targeted social spending to protect the most vulnerable.
  - Authorities have avoided broad incentives packages for tourism offered by other regional governments.
  - Tourism-related infrastructure and improved air access and roads prioritized to resuscitate growth.

*IMF staff report: Executive Summary*

### 14.      Following the sharp decline in FY 2008/09, the primary fiscal surplus is expected

### _cr09293 - 14.      Following the sharp decline in FY 2008/09, the primary fiscal surplus is expected

### Fiscal outlook and near-term projections
- Primary fiscal surplus expected to increase modestly to 1.4 percent of GDP in FY 2009/10.
- Total expenditure projected to be lower as reconstruction-related capital outlays would taper off.
- Wage bill will be contained at 12 percent of GDP.
- Total revenue projected to increase by about 0.5 percent of GDP reflecting higher yields on VAT and excise taxes.
- Revenue losses from the income tax reform initiated in January 2008 have been about 1 percent of GDP in FY 2007/08 and are expected to rise to about 1½ percent per year over the medium term.
- Authorities have budgeted revenue from this tax conservatively and would strongly resist modifications to the VAT to ensure robustness of revenue projections.
- Capital expenditure to rehabilitate and enhance infrastructure is expected to be financed mainly by external grants.
- Authorities concurred on the need to develop fiscal contingency measures should the global recession prove more severe or protracted than currently expected.

### Medium-term fiscal commitments and framework
- Authorities indicated they would seek to achieve primary surpluses of at least 3 percent of GDP beginning in FY 2010/11.
- Capital expenditure planned for FY 2009/10 remains at historically high levels, providing scope for some reduction post-rehabilitation through further prioritization of projects.
- Government will continue to move towards a medium-term expenditure framework (MTEF) to improve predictability of capital expenditure and its consistency with medium-term fiscal objectives.
- Expected effects:
  - Contribute to a declining trend in the public debt-to-GDP ratio.
  - Contribute to narrowing of the external current account deficit to levels compatible with the availability of grant financing and projected FDI inflows.

### Debt sustainability, restructuring, and risks
- Public debt-to-GDP ratio declined from 128 percent in 2003 to about 87 percent in 2008, or by an average of 8 percentage points annually.
- Under the assumption of annual GDP growth of 3 percent and a primary surplus of 3 percent of GDP beyond FY 2009/10, Dominica would reach the ECCB target of 60 percent for the debt-to-GDP ratio around 2016.
- Government will continue efforts to complete the debt-restructuring initiated in 2004 and will stay current in all debt-service payments; debt service payments would continue to be made into an escrow account at the ECCB if holdouts agree to restructured terms.
- DSA baseline scenario assumptions:
  - Real GDP growth rising to 3 percent annually over the medium term.
  - Primary fiscal surplus recovering to 3 percent of GDP from FY 2010/11.
  - Projected grant financing at around 8½ percent of GDP over the medium term (decline from recent surge to an average of 12 percent in 2007–08; historical average close to 5 percent for 1990–2006).
- Risks and vulnerabilities highlighted:
  - Downside risks from volatility of grant inflows; if grants are lower, capital expenditure would need to be scaled back to achieve a 3 percent primary surplus.
  - Most extreme shock scenario (lower GDP growth, weaker exports, lower GDP deflator, fall in non-debt-creating flows) would push NPV of debt-to-GDP above the 50 percent threshold over 2011–13.
  - Most extreme export shock (export growth at one standard deviation below historical average in 2009–2010) would push NPV of debt-to-exports ratio slightly above the 200 percent threshold in one year.
  - A sustained widening of sovereign spreads would raise interest payments by about 0.5 percent of GDP.
  - Possible contingent liabilities from resolution of CL Financial insurance subsidiaries could raise the required primary surplus.
- Positive factors:
  - Gross financing needs decreasing due to saving under prudent fiscal policy, lengthening of maturities from debt restructuring, and large reliance on concessional multilateral borrowing, which accounted for 65 percent of total external debt outstanding.

### Structural policies and financial sector measures
- Government committed to structural reforms to promote private-sector-led growth and lower poverty, amplifying the Growth and Social Protection Strategy to reduce the cost of doing business and improve energy sector efficiency.
- Constraints to private investment: infrastructure bottlenecks, inefficient contract enforcement, and land registration processes; program being developed with EU assistance to address these constraints.
- Strengthening financial sector regulation prioritized:
  - Authorities working with ECCB to strengthen banking supervision and improve regulatory framework for nonbanks.
  - Act establishing a single regulatory unit (SRU) has been passed; efforts underway to strengthen the Financial Services Unit (FSU).
  - Staff encouraged enactment of remaining legislation (including new laws for insurance and credit union sectors) slated to be presented to parliament before end-2009.
- Resolution of CL Financial insurance subsidiaries is an urgent near-term challenge; staff concurred with regional approach and emphasized minimizing fiscal cost via significant private sector participation.

### Access to Fund financing and external support
- Authorities requested Fund financing equivalent to SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota) under the RAC-ESF.
  - This borrowing represents approximately 1¼ percent of GDP and about 1 week of imports of goods and services.
  - Level of access would cover about 30 percent of the estimated net impact on the balance of payments attributable to the exogenous shocks (US$16.5 million).
  - Requested financing would also prevent Dominica’s imputed reserves from falling further below 3 months of imports of goods.
- Dominica will continue to seek assistance from international development partners; Fund financing expected to help catalyze donor support.
- Authorities will participate in a planned regional effort to approach the European Union to speed up disbursement of programmed financing.

### Fund credit, repayment capacity, and downside risks
- Fund credit outstanding relative to quota would reach about 153 percent including the prospective ESF.
- There is a bunching of repayments to the Fund in 2011-13.
  - Annual principal repayment/repurchase increases from slightly less than US$1 million in 2010 to an average of US$2 million annually in 2011–13 with repayment of the PRGF loan and repurchases of the ENDA falling due from 2011.
- Envisaged fiscal path and recovery in growth would improve debt servicing capacity.
- Downside risks: a deeper or more protracted global downturn would reduce tourism receipts, remittances, external grants, and FDI relative to projections.

### Staff appraisal and recommendations
- Staff commend authorities for sound macroeconomic and structural policies that improved resilience and allowed limited fiscal stimulus supporting positive real GDP growth in 2009.
- Recovery plans appropriately build on 2008 Growth and Social Protection Strategy, focusing on improving investment climate and enhancing infrastructure.
- Authorities’ commitment to maintaining a primary surplus target of at least 3 percent of GDP over the medium term is welcomed following fiscal easing.
- Recommended actions and priorities:
  - Prioritize capital projects and bring expenditure back to sustainable levels while planning contingency measures for a more severe or prolonged global downturn.
  - Continue structural reforms to reduce cost of doing business and ease infrastructure bottlenecks to enhance private sector growth.
  - Strengthen regulatory framework for the nonbank financial sector through the single regulatory unit and complementary legislation to avoid regulatory arbitrage.
  - Work with regional counterparts to resolve CL Financial while minimizing fiscal costs and securing private sector participation.

*Italicized source attribution: IMF staff report content from _cr09293 - 14.      Following the sharp decline in FY 2008/09, the primary fiscal surplus is expected*

### 28.      The staff supports the authorities’ request for Fund financing under the RAC-

### _cr09293 - 28.      The staff supports the authorities’ request for Fund financing under the RAC-

### Fund decision and rationale
- The staff supports the authorities’ request for Fund financing under the RAC-ESF in the amount of SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota).
- Rationale:
  - Large balance of payments impact of the shock.
  - Authorities’ past track record in meeting policy commitments under the recently expired PRGF arrangement.
  - Soundness of authorities’ policies.
- Identified risks:
  - Still high public debt and susceptibility to external shocks pose some risks to the Fund’s resources.
  - These risks are mitigated by:
    - Authorities’ resolve to maintain prudent fiscal policies and foster private sector-led growth.
    - Authorities’ commitment to continued close cooperation with the Fund.
    - Expectation of continued support from the international community.

### Request and operations
- Government request: purchase equivalent to SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota) under the rapid-access component of the Exogenous Shocks Facility (ESF).
- Press Release: IMF Executive Board approved a disbursement in an amount equivalent to SDR 3.28 million (about US$5.1 million) under the rapid-access component of the ESF.
- Table 8 assumption: RAC-ESF access in an amount of SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota) is assumed in indicators of capacity to repay the Fund.

### Economic impact of shocks and near-term projections
- External and real sector effects:
  - Tourism arrivals are projected to decline by 15 percent in 2009 compared with the same period last year.
  - Discounting of hotel room rates and lower spending by visitors would raise the loss in tourism receipts to about US$18 million (3.6 percent of GDP).
  - Family remittances have declined sharply; FDI inflows have been reduced by about one half.
  - Real output growth is projected at about 1 percent in 2009 despite ongoing post-hurricane reconstruction.
  - External current account deficit expected to remain very high.
- Fiscal projections and targets:
  - Primary fiscal surplus estimated to have declined to 1 percent of GDP in the 2008/09 fiscal year.
  - Primary fiscal surplus likely to recover modestly to 1½ percent of GDP in FY 2009/10.
  - Government will continue to target, in subsequent years, annual primary surpluses of at least 3 percent of GDP.
  - Government objective to reduce public debt-to-GDP ratio to 60 percent over time.
- Social and policy responses:
  - Immediate relief provided to those affected by recent natural disasters.
  - Financial assistance to hotels affected by Hurricane Omar; import duty concessions on capital items used in rehabilitation.
  - Accelerated implementation of capital projects to ameliorate unemployment impact.
  - Increased social spending to protect the most vulnerable groups.
  - Reallocation of expenditure to supplement outlays financed by external concessional resources.

### Policy framework and structural reforms
- Growth and Social Protection Strategy (GSPS) remains core to medium-term policies:
  - Maintain prudent fiscal policy to keep public debt ratios on a downward trajectory.
  - Strengthen oversight of the financial sector.
  - Structural reforms to reactivate the economy and better target social assistance.
- Fiscal structural reforms to continue:
  - Strengthening tax administration.
  - Maintaining the integrity of the value added tax.
  - Implementing the third phase of ongoing income tax reform.
- Financial sector measures:
  - Implementation of the Financial Services Unit (FSU) Act to provide a uniform supervisory framework for nonbank financial institutions.
- Competitiveness and business climate:
  - Projects to improve competitiveness as a tourist destination, including enhancing air and sea access and improving access to tourism sites.
  - EU-assisted programme to address constraints identified in the World Bank Doing Business Report.
- Social safety nets:
  - Strengthening through a World Bank-financed enhanced registry of beneficiaries.

### Debt, financing, and repayment capacity indicators (selected figures)
- ESF request and outcome:
  - Request: SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota).
  - Executive Board disbursement: SDR 3.28 million (about US$5.1 million).
- Fiscal and debt metrics cited:
  - Loss in tourism receipts: US$18 million (3.6 percent of GDP).
  - Primary balance: estimated 1 percent of GDP in 2008/09; projected 1½ percent of GDP in FY 2009/10; target at least 3 percent of GDP in subsequent years.
  - Public debt reduction target: reduce public debt-to-GDP ratio to 60 percent.
- Indicators of Capacity to Repay the Fund, selected projections (Table 8 basis):
  - Outstanding Fund credit (in millions of U.S. dollars): historical values listed (e.g., 15.2; 19.5; 18.4; 15.5; 11.5; 8.7; 7.1).
  - Total obligations based on existing and prospective credit: values provided in SDRs and U.S. dollars and shown as shares of exports, debt service, GDP, quota, and net international reserves.
  - Memorandum items include nominal GDP, exports of goods and services, external debt service, imports of goods, and net imputed international reserves for projection years.

### Board and authorities’ statements
- Statement by Mr. Murilo Portugal, Deputy Managing Director and Acting Chair:
  - Reiterated that authorities are responding appropriately, plan modest recovery in FY 2009/10, and are committed to target annual primary surpluses of at least 3 percent of GDP.
  - Emphasized that Fund financing will help reduce the decline in external reserves and catalyze donor support in the near term; medium-term strategy aims to improve business climate and infrastructure for higher growth and poverty reduction.
- Letter of Intent (June 26, 2009) from PRIME MINISTER AND MINISTER FOR FINANCE AND SOCIAL SECURITY, HON. ROOSEVELT SKERRIT:
  - Requests purchase of SDR 3.28 million (40 percent of quota) under RAC-ESF to meet immediate foreign exchange needs and ease pressure on external reserves.
  - Confirms Government will stay current on debt-service payments and continue good-faith efforts to conclude debt restructuring with remaining hold-out creditors.
  - Confirms commitment not to impose new or intensify existing current account restrictions, trade restrictions for balance of payments purposes, or enter bilateral payments agreements inconsistent with Article VIII of the Fund’s Articles of Agreement.

*Source: IMF staff report and attachments (Dominica), including Letter of Intent and Press Release, as provided in the content unit.*

### 2008. Overlaying and compounding these challenges has been the global economic downturn

### _cr09293 - 2008. Overlaying and compounding these challenges has been the global economic downturn

### Impact of natural disasters and global downturn
- Hurricane Dean damage estimated by ECLAC/UNDP at nearly 20 percent of GDP.
- Combined cost of Hurricane Dean and Hurricane Omar now expected to be roughly 35 percent of GDP, nearly US$130 million.
- Global economic downturn adversely affected Dominica’s tourism receipts, remittances and FDI inflows.
- Decline of export receipts and weaker capital account flows have negatively impacted Dominica’s external account; tourism receipts have fallen while reconstruction imports have risen.
- Overall deficit in the balance of payments projected to rise to US$10.7 million in 2009, with an external financing gap of about US$ 8million.

### Authorities’ emergency financing and request
- In February 2008 the Board approved the Dominican authorities’ request for a purchase equivalent to SDR 2.05 million (25 percent of quota) under the Fund’s policy of Emergency Assistance for Natural Disasters (ENDA).
- The Government of Dominica is requesting a purchase equivalent to SDR 3.28 million  (40 percent of quota) under the rapid-access component of the Fund’s Exogenous Shock Facility to ease near-term foreign exchange pressures.

### Authorities’ response and priorities
- Two-pronged strategy:
  - Repairing critical infrastructure (roads, bridges, and seawalls) and providing assistance to those who suffered abrupt losses in earnings (with donor assistance).
  - Revising and updating the medium-term Growth and Social Protection Strategy (GSPS) to engage multilateral agencies and the donor community.
- Immediate measures taken:
  - Reallocation of expenditures.
  - Assistance to hotels.
  - Focus on critical capital projects intended to have lasting economic impact and reinforce defences against natural disasters.
  - Import duty concessions on capital items used in rehabilitating properties.
- Policy stance:
  - Eschewing broad incentive packages for tourism in favor of improving the business climate and enhancing critical infrastructure.

### Economic outlook and risks
- GDP:
  - Dominica posted GDP growth of 3 percent in 2008 despite agricultural damage from Hurricane Dean.
  - Preliminary estimates suggest GDP growth will come in at around 1 percent in 2009 due to combined hurricanes and the global downturn.
  - Authorities expect the economy to rebound in 2010 and to achieve roughly 2 percent growth.
  - Forecast risks are on the downside and predicated on achieving global economic recovery at the end of 2009 and strengthening tourism receipts and FDI flows.
- Inflation:
  - Expected to remain modest at 2 percent, but could be subject to volatility depending on the direction of commodity prices.

### Fiscal position and medium-term targets
- Short-term fiscal outcomes:
  - Authorities intend to post a primary fiscal surplus of 1.5 percent in 2009/10 (compared to an estimated primary fiscal surplus of 1 percent in 2008/09).
  - Higher-than-expected revenues from VAT and import duties contributed to the ability to post the surplus.
- Medium-term fiscal goals:
  - Committed to a fiscal target of a primary surplus of 3 percent of GDP.
  - Objective of bringing the public debt-to-GDP ratio to 60 percent, in line with regional initiatives to reach that level by 2020.
  - Track record: reduced debt-to-GDP ratio from 128 percent in 2003 to about 87 percent in 2008; commitment to reach 60 percent, four years ahead of schedule (in 2016).
- Fiscal policy measures to achieve targets:
  - Bring capital expenditures back to historical levels as rehabilitation work tapers off.
  - Improve targeting of social assistance to the most vulnerable.
  - Contain the wage bill at 12 percent of GDP.
  - Finance tourism-related infrastructure, including enhanced air access and roads to tourist attractions, largely through concessional resources to ensure sustainability of public debt.
  - Remain current on all debt service payments and continue good faith efforts toward collaborative debt restructuring agreements with remaining holdout creditors.

### Structural reforms and financial sector developments
- Structural reform priorities:
  - Enhance competitiveness by expanding the role of the private sector.
  - Address constraints identified in the World Bank index of doing business by reducing costs of doing business, addressing infrastructure constraints, and improving contract enforcement and land registration.
  - Utilize EU funding to develop a program to address these constraints.
  - Continue movement toward a medium-term expenditure framework to improve capital expenditure planning and consistency with medium-term fiscal objectives.
- Financial sector:
  - Non-performing loans have seen a sharp drop.
  - Capital to risk-weighted assets declined from 23.5 percent in 2004 to roughly 15 percent in 2008.
  - Capital adequacy ratio remains roughly double the ECCU minimum requirement of 8 percent.
  - Authorities monitoring the non-bank financial sector and working with the ECCB to improve the regulatory regime for non-banks.
  - Strengthening the Financial Services Unit (FSU) to enforce the FSU Act and limit excessive risk taking by insurance companies.
  - Monitoring developments with CL Financial Insurance subsidiaries and pursuing a regional approach to resolve this matter.

### Key quantitative summary
- Hurricane Dean damage: nearly 20 percent of GDP.
- Combined hurricanes damage: roughly 35 percent of GDP, nearly US$130 million.
- ENDA purchase in February 2008: SDR 2.05 million (25 percent of quota).
- Request under Exogenous Shock Facility rapid-access: SDR 3.28 million  (40 percent of quota).
- Balance of payments deficit projected 2009: US$10.7 million.
- External financing gap: about US$ 8million.
- GDP growth: 3 percent in 2008; around 1 percent in 2009; roughly 2 percent in 2010.
- Inflation: 2 percent (expected).
- Primary fiscal surplus targets: 1.5 percent in 2009/10; 1 percent estimated in 2008/09; medium-term target 3 percent of GDP.
- Public debt-to-GDP: 128 percent in 2003; about 87 percent in 2008; target 60 percent by 2020 (aim to reach by 2016).
- Wage bill target: 12 percent of GDP.
- Banking capital to risk-weighted assets: 23.5 percent in 2004; roughly 15 percent in 2008.
- ECCU minimum capital adequacy requirement: 8 percent.

Conclusion
- Fund financing would make a valued contribution to Dominica’s rehabilitation effort alongside additional funds from other sources.
- Authorities request emergency assistance in the amount of 40 percent of quota under the rapid-access component of the Fund’s Exogenous Shock Facility and would greatly appreciate a favourable response by the Board.

*Source: _cr09293 - 2008. Overlaying and compounding these challenges has been the global economic downturn*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2009/_cr09293.pdf_
