## _cr1013

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr1013](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2010/_cr1013.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2010/_cr1013.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2010/_cr1013.pdf.json)

---

### Executive Summary
- Real GDP growth: expected to slow to 1¼ percent in 2009.
- Growth outlook: rebound to about 3½ percent in 2010 contingent on global recovery and sustained domestic reform momentum.
- Inflation: expected to be about 2 percent (medium term).
- Program performance: All quantitative assessment (performance) criteria have been met.
- Fiscal stance in H1 2009: tighter than programmed owing to financing delays.
- Structural reform status: broadly on track.
- Agreed priorities:
  - Use macroeconomic and structural policies to weather the global crisis; shift fiscal stimulus to late 2009 and into 2010.
  - Normalize government financial relations with the private sector by regularizing extrabudgetary spending and paying public agency debt.
  - Pursue PFM reforms to enhance governance, transparency, and accountability.
  - Advance growth-enhancing reforms, notably in the energy sector, with development partners.
- Main risks:
  - More enduring international crisis effects on growth.
  - Uncertainty about financing and difficult expenditure trade-offs.
  - Incomplete energy sector reform.
  - Recurring governance and transparency issues.

### Recent Economic Developments, Short-term Outlook, and Program Performance
- Channels of external shock: declines in export prices; downward pressure on remittances, FDI, and tourism.
- Real GDP growth:
  - 2008: 2½ percent; 2009: expected 1¼ percent.
- Inflation:
  - Annual inflation turned negative in May 2009; core inflation fell less.
- Disruptions: electricity shortages and urban flooding in H2 2009.
- Fiscal implementation responses:
  - Spending pulled back due to revenue and financing shortfalls (no privatization receipts; reduced bank financing with SONATEL collateral).
  - End-June fiscal deficit target met by a wide margin; budgetary float below ceiling.
- Government payment and arrears (Box 1):
  - Budgetary float: CFAF 175 billion (3 percent of GDP) in October 2008 → below CFAF 45 billion (⅔ percent of GDP) in September 2009.
  - Audit (July 2009) identified extrabudgetary spending: CFAF 37 billion (0.6 percent of GDP).
  - Public agencies owed private sector: CFAF 67 billion (1 percent of GDP).
  - Blocked treasury accounts of nonfinancial public agencies: about CFAF 15 billion (¼ percent of GDP).

### Structural Benchmarks and PFM Progress (June 2009–December 2009)
- Selected benchmark outcomes:
  - Decide on regularizing or rejecting extrabudgetary expenditure — Target: July 31, 2009 — Status: Partially met.
  - Study on tax expenditures completed — Target: September 30, 2009 — Status: Met.
  - External audit of SIGFIP focused on budget execution — Target: September 30, 2009 — Status: Met.
  - Improve budget flexibility and presentation — Target: October 15, 2009 — Status: Partially met.
  - ASTER budget accounting module operationalization — Target: October 31, 2009 — Status: In progress.
  - Transfer petroleum tax collection (FSAPP) to DGID — Target: October 31, 2009 — Status: Met.
- SIGFIP and ASTER:
  - External audit and TA completed; budget accounting module (ASTER) progress slower than expected due to technical challenges.
  - Commitments to implement SIGFIP–ASTER interface and include payroll by July 31, 2010.

### Recovering from the Global Financial Crisis — Outlook and External Sector
- Growth projections:
  - 2009 = 1.2; 2010 = 3.4 (annual percentage change; selected indicators).
  - Staff projection: about 3½ percent in 2010; medium-term target: above 5 percent requires broad-based structural reforms.
- Inflation and current account:
  - Consumer prices: 2009 = -0.8; 2010 = 1.8 (annual percentage change).
  - External current account deficit (including grants): projected to stabilize under 10 percent of GDP over the medium term.
- Balance of payments (CFAF billions):
  - SDR allocation: 940 (both 2009 and 2010).
  - Current account: 2009 = -573; 2010 = -626.
  - Capital and financial account: 2009 = 620; 2010 = 544.
  - Overall balance of payments: 2009 = 48; 2010 = -82.
  - Overall BOP excluding SDR allocation: 2009 = -47; 2010 = -82.
- Changes relative to previous review:
  - GDP growth: 2009 = -2.0; 2010 = 0.0 (change relative to previous review).
  - Consumer prices: 2009 = -1.6; 2010 = -0.4.
  - Overall fiscal balance (% of GDP): 2009 = 0.1; 2010 = -1.0.
  - Current account (CFAF billions): 2009 = 169; 2010 = 92.
  - Capital and financial account (CFAF billions): 2009 = -65; 2010 = -70.
  - Overall BOP (CFAF billions) change: 2009 = 10; 2010 = 42.

### Fiscal Policy, Budget Framework, and Financing
- Key fiscal table (percent of GDP; 2008 Est. / 2009 Prog. / 2009 Proj. / 2010 Suppl. / 2010 Proj.):
  - Total revenue and grants: 21.8 / 21.6 / 22.1 / 21.9 / 21.9
  - Tax revenue: 18.3 / 18.7 / 18.8 / 18.9 / 18.9
  - Total expenditure and net lending: 26.6 / 26.3 / 26.6 / 26.9 / 27.6
  - Current expenditure: 16.5 / 15.8 / 16.0 / 15.6 / ...
  - Capital expenditure: 10.0 / 10.4 / 10.6 / 11.2 / ...
  - Overall fiscal balance: -4.6 / -4.6 / -4.5 / -4.9 / -5.7
- Memorandum items and financing instruments:
  - Settlement of payment delays (percent of GDP): 1.4 / 1.1 / 1.1 / 1.3 / 1.3
  - SDR allocation treated in financing (table notes): SDR allocation entry of 1.4 in 2009 projection column.
  - Ten-year BCEAO loan (equal to the SDR allocation) terms: maturity 10 years, three-year grace period, interest rate 3 percent.
  - Below-the-line recording of agreed settlement payments: illustrative outcome: 70 percent of extrabudgetary commitments and agency debt settled in 2010; 30 percent in 2011.
- Fiscal stance and staff view:
  - Staff supports a moderate fiscal stimulus in late 2009 and 2010 while preserving medium-term debt sustainability.
  - Basic fiscal deficit expected around 5 percent of GDP excluding settlement of extrabudgetary expenditure and agency debt.
  - Authorities committed to better liquidity management.

### PFM Reforms, Benchmarks, and Operational Rules
- Prioritized PFM actions and structural benchmarks:
  - Stop issuing 2009 payment orders — Implementation date: December 31, 2009.
  - Press release on audit results and settlement strategy — Implementation date: January 31, 2010.
  - Action plan to suppress inefficient tax expenditures — Implementation date: March 31, 2010.
  - Consolidated FSAP action plan — Implementation date: March 31, 2010.
  - Supplementary budget for 2010 authorizing settlement of identified arrears — Implementation date: May 15, 2010.
  - Include payroll in SIGFIP and implement SIGFIP-ASTER interface — Implementation date: July 31, 2010.
  - Census of all government accounts and strategy for single Treasury account — Implementation date: July 31, 2010.
  - Complete payment of at least 50 percent of extrabudgetary commitments and agency debt identified in July 2009 audit — Implementation date: September 30, 2010.
  - Incorporate general tax code and all domestic tax legislation in single document — Implementation date: October 15, 2010.
- TMU definitions and examples:
  - Basic fiscal balance excludes externally financed capital expenditure, certain on-lent loans, HIPC/MDRI resources, and expenditure related to settlement of agency debt and extrabudgetary arrears included in the first supplementary budget for 2010.
  - Numeric example: floor for the basic balance as at June 30, 2010 is minus CFAF 59 billion, calculated from budgetary revenue CFAF 621 billion and total expenditure and net lending CFAF 851.5 billion, excluding externally financed capital expenditure CFAF 136.5 billion, drawings on on-lent loans CFAF 5 billion, and HIPC/MDRI resources CFAF 30 billion.
- Reporting and monitoring:
  - Weekly SIGFIP reports and end-of-month SIGFIP tables required.
  - Ceiling on budgetary float monitored quarterly (example: ceiling 45; actual 42 at end-September 2009).
  - Quarterly ceiling on single-tender public sector contracts: indicative target 20 percent; actual 14 percent (Q2 2009) and 5 percent (Q3 2009).
  - Immediate reporting of any decisions with economic/financial implications; specified lags for monetary, fiscal, and debt data.

### Energy Sector: Reforms, Arrears, and Strategy
- Role and urgency:
  - Energy sector reform critical to raising growth potential and containing fiscal and macroeconomic risks.
- Stock-taking (September 2009) identified root causes:
  - Technical failures raising production costs; inadequate tariff structure; weak marketing/operations; fuel supply constraints; delays in energy-saving measures; governance weaknesses.
- Arrears and financials:
  - Large arrears: CFAF 70 billion (more than 1 percent of GDP) as of September 2009 (more than half are back taxes).
  - Arrears fell from approximately CFAF 100 billion at end-December 2008 to CFAF 70 billion at end-September 2009; composition: CFAF 44 billion with central government (including CFAF 12 billion in VAT suspended and not due) and CFAF 30 billion with private suppliers and creditors.
- Tariff adjustments history:
  - Tariffs raised by 17 percent in August 2008; lowered by 12 percent in January 2009 (with oil at about US$45 a barrel); increased by 8 percent in July 2009.
- Government reform scenario and measures:
  - Restructure short-term debt; implement cost-reduction and business-performance plans; resolve GTI supplier problem; implement audit recommendations; tariff adjustment by no later than April 1, 2010; quarterly price adjustments as needed.
  - Agreed measures with World Bank and AFD include debt-crossing agreement, rescheduling on-lent debt CFAF 17 billion and suspended VAT CFAF 12 billion over 60 months, and payment schedules for compensation and budgeted access to funds (CFAF 20 billion in 2010 and CFAF 16 billion in 2011).

### Financial Sector Soundness and Reform Priorities
- Financial system assessment:
  - "Has so far coped well with the global financial crisis" but vulnerabilities from rising NPLs, credit concentration, and liquidity drying-up warrant continuous monitoring.
- Selected Financial Soundness Indicators (percent; selected series):
  - Capital to risk-weighted assets: 2002 16.0; 2003 11.7; 2004 11.5; 2005 10.8; 2006 12.9; 2007 13.5; 2008 13.8; 2009 Jun. 15.5
  - Loans to 5 largest borrowers to capital: 2002 104.9; 2003 141.0; 2004 131.4; 2005 179.9; 2006 103.7; 2007 88.5; 2008 86.9; 2009 Jun. 91.8
  - Gross NPLs to total loans 1/: 2002 18.5; 2003 13.3; 2004 12.6; 2005 11.9; 2006 16.8; 2007 18.6; 2008 19.1; 2009 Jun. 18.0
  - NPLs net of provisions to total loans 1/: 2002 5.5; 2003 3.3; 2004 3.4; 2005 3.2; 2006 8.8; 2007 8.6; 2008 9.3; 2009 Jun. 9.8
  - NPLs net of provisions to capital 1/: 2002 30.7; 2003 27.8; 2004 25.1; 2005 27.2; 2006 67.9; 2007 60.7; 2008 63.9; 2009 Jun. 62.9
  - Total deposits to total liabilities: 2002 78.5; 2003 82.0; 2004 79.6; 2005 78.3; 2006 75.8; 2007 73.6; 2008 70.3; 2009 Jun. 71.2
- Macro-financial and supervisory commitments:
  - High-frequency monitoring, regular bank stress tests, update consolidated FSAP action plan by end-March 2010, monitor new minimum capital rules (entry into force end-2010), strengthen microfinance supervision.

### Program Issues, Borrowing Policy, and Risks
- PSI/ESF review recommendations:
  - Staff recommends completion of the fourth PSI review and second ESF review.
- Nonconcessional borrowing:
  - Authorities requested raising ceiling to CFAF 90 billion (from CFAF 80 billion) for Dakar–Diamniadio toll highway (increase CFAF 10 billion; less than 0.2 percent of GDP) and issuance of a US$200 million bond.
  - Staff supports request given low risk of debt distress, but recommends nonconcessional borrowing remain linked to economically profitable projects until PFM improves.
- TMU and recording issues:
  - Basic fiscal balance definition excludes payments linked to settling extrabudgetary spending and agency debt; part of these transactions may need to be recorded above the line.
- Program risks:
  - Financing constraints in regional market; delays in regularizing payments; slower global recovery; continued energy sector problems; spillovers from Dubai World announcement.

### Staff Appraisal and Policy Recommendations (key judgments)
- Implementation: broadly satisfactory under difficult conditions; authorities managed spending and continued reforms.
- Near-term policy guidance:
  - Continue policies to weather global crisis and normalize government–private sector financial relations.
  - Shift a modest fiscal expansion into 2010 per budget and macro assumptions while preserving medium-term debt sustainability.
  - Protect emergency and priority spending for vulnerable groups.
  - Improve liquidity management to minimize procyclical fiscal risks.
  - Fast settlement of extrabudgetary spending and agency debt to restore private sector confidence and sustain PFM reform momentum.
  - Reinforce fiscal management capacity; link nonconcessional borrowing to specific economically profitable projects until PFM improves.
  - Energy sector: implement comprehensive strategy, avoid further deterioration, improve efficiency, and adjust tariffs regularly to align with costs.

*Source: IMF mission text and MEFP excerpts in the supplied content unit.*

### 2009. The views expressed in the staff report are those of the staff team and do not

### SENEGAL — Fourth Review Under the Policy Support Instrument and Second Review Under the Exogenous Shocks Facility

### Executive Summary
- Real GDP growth is expected to slow to 1¼ percent in 2009.
- Economic rebound in 2010 is projected to be gradual, tracking the global recovery, provided domestic reform momentum does not slip.
- Inflation is expected to be about 2 percent.
- Program performance: All quantitative assessment (performance) criteria have been met.
- Fiscal policy was tighter during the first half of 2009 than foreseen in the program due to delays in financing.
- Structural reforms are broadly on track.
- Authorities and staff agreed on the following priorities:
  - Use macroeconomic and structural policies to weather the global economic crisis, including shifting the fiscal stimulus to late 2009 and into 2010.
  - Finish normalizing the government’s financial relations with the private sector by regularizing extrabudgetary spending and paying public agency debt.
  - Continue to pursue structural reforms in public financial management (PFM) to enhance governance, transparency, and accountability.
  - Press ahead with other growth-enhancing reforms, especially in the energy sector, in close collaboration with development partners.
- Main risks identified:
  - The international crisis could have a more enduring impact on growth.
  - Uncertainty about available financing, which could force difficult trade-offs in prioritizing expenditure.
  - Incomplete reform of the energy sector.
  - Recurring governance and transparency issues.

### Recent Economic Developments, Short-term Outlook, and Program Performance
- Transmission of the international crisis to Senegal is mainly through drops in export prices, and downward pressure on remittances, foreign direct investment, and tourism.
- Real GDP growth:
  - Expected to slow to 1¼ percent in 2009 from 2½ percent in 2008.
- Inflation:
  - Annual inflation turned negative in May 2009, largely because food and energy prices fell.
  - Core inflation has fallen less.
- Electricity shortages and urban flooding caused economic problems in the second half of 2009.
- Program implementation:
  - Faced with shortfalls in revenues and financing (e.g., no privatization receipts and less bank financing with SONATEL shares as collateral), the authorities pulled back on spending.
  - The end-June fiscal deficit target was met by a wide margin, and the budgetary float was below its ceiling.
- Box 1 (Government Payment Delays, Extrabudgetary Spending, and Agency Debt):
  - Budgetary float reduced from CFAF 175 billion (3 percent of GDP) in October 2008 to below CFAF 45 billion (⅔ percent of GDP) in September 2009.
  - Audit completed in July 2009 identified extrabudgetary spending of CFAF 37 billion (0.6 percent of GDP).
  - Public agencies owed the private sector CFAF 67 billion (1 percent of GDP).
  - Blocked treasury accounts of nonfinancial public agencies are estimated at about CFAF 15 billion (¼ percent of GDP).
- Structural reform progress (selected):
  - A study identified tax expenditures of over 3 percent of GDP.
  - External audit and technical assistance provide a basis for improving SIGFIP (budget monitoring system).
  - Budget accounting module (ASTER) progress has been slower than expected due to technical challenges.

### Structural Benchmarks (June 2009–December 2009) — Status Highlights
- Structural benchmarks and status (as assessed in the report):
  - Decide whether extrabudgetary expenditure should be regularized or rejected — Target Date July 31, 2009 — Status: Partially met.
  - Complete a study on the basis for, and current level of, tax expenditures — Target Date September 30, 2009 — Status: Met.
  - Complete an external audit of SIGFIP focused on the budget execution database and production of output tables — Target Date September 30, 2009 — Status: Met.
  - Improve the flexibility and presentation of the budget — Target Date October 15, 2009 — Status: Partially met.
  - Make the ASTER budget accounting module operational — Target Date October 31, 2009 — Status: In progress.
  - Adopt provisions to transfer petroleum tax collection (FSAPP) to the DGID — Target Date October 31, 2009 — Status: Met.

### Recovering from the Global Financial Crisis — Outlook and Risks
- 2010 outlook:
  - Economic growth of about 3½ percent should be possible in 2010 based on projected world recovery, stabilization of remittances, settlement of extrabudgetary spending, and payment of agency debt.
  - In 2010 growth in Senegal would still be weaker than in other WAEMU countries.
  - Over the medium term, broad-based structural reforms are needed to boost growth to above 5 percent.
- Inflation:
  - Likely to return to the historical level of about 2 percent over the medium term.
- External sector:
  - External current account deficit (including grants) projected to stabilize over the medium term at under 10 percent of GDP.
  - Narrowing of the current account deficit in 2009 is primarily due to reduced imports related to subdued growth and lower food and fuel prices.
  - Overall balance of payments projected to be in deficit in 2009 (excluding the SDR inflow above the line) and in 2010, and to show small surpluses over the medium term.
- Selected indicators and changes relative to the previous review (as reported):
  - GDP growth: 2009 = 1.2; 2010 = 3.4; Change relative to previous review: 2009 = -2.0; 2010 = 0.0 (Annual percentage change).
  - Consumer prices: 2009 = -0.8; 2010 = 1.8; Change relative to previous review: 2009 = -1.6; 2010 = -0.4 (Annual percentage change).
  - Overall fiscal balance (% of GDP): 2009 = -4.5; 2010 = -4.9; Change relative to previous review: 2009 = 0.1; 2010 = -1.0.
  - Current account (CFAF billions): 2009 = -573; 2010 = -626; Change relative to previous review: 2009 = 169; 2010 = 92.
  - Capital and financial account (CFAF billions): 2009 = 620; 2010 = 544; Change relative to previous review: 2009 = -65; 2010 = -70.
  - SDR allocation: 940 (CFAF billions) in both years.
  - Overall balance of payments (CFAF billions): 2009 = 48; 2010 = -82; Change relative to previous review: 2009 = 10; 2010 = 42.
  - Overall balance of payments, excluding SDR allocation (CFAF billions): 2009 = -47; 2010 = -82; Change relative to previous review: 2009 = 10; 2010 = 22.
- Uncertainty and risks:
  - External risks: slower global recovery; delayed and prolonged full impact of the global crisis.
  - Domestic risks: financing constraints in the regional market limiting fiscal support; delays in settling agency debt and extrabudgetary spending; deepening challenges in the energy sector.
  - Other risks: weather, pests, commodity price shocks, and recurring governance and transparency concerns.

### Program Issues, Policy Directions, and Staff Recommendations
- Program status:
  - Staff recommends completion of the PSI/ESF Reviews.
  - All quantitative assessment/performance criteria have been met and most structural conditionality has been observed.
- Program discussions:
  - Held in Dakar November 4–18, 2009. Mission team composition and meetings with senior officials, development partners, private sector, trade unions, and civil society are documented.
  - Outreach included presentations on: changes in the Fund’s financial architecture for low-income countries; changes in the low-income country debt sustainability framework and debt limits in Fund-supported programs; vulnerabilities of the Senegalese banking system; and the impact of cyclical fluctuations on government revenues.
- Policy emphasis going forward:
  - Shift fiscal stimulus toward late 2009 and into 2010 to support the recovery while preserving fiscal sustainability.
  - Normalize government financial relations with the private sector by regularizing extrabudgetary spending and paying agency debt.
  - Deepen PFM structural reforms to enhance governance, transparency, and accountability, including completing SIGFIP-related audits and making ASTER operational.
  - Implement growth-enhancing structural reforms, notably in the energy sector, in close collaboration with development partners.

*Prepared by the African Department (In consultation with other departments); Approved by Roger Nord and Dominique Desruelles; December 7, 2009.*

### 6.      Policy discussions focused on how to return quickly to higher growth and to

### 6.      Policy discussions focused on how to return quickly to higher growth and to

### A. Overall policy focus and PSI objectives
- Program dedicated to helping Senegal surmount the impact of the global economic crisis and normalize the government’s financial relations with the private sector in the year remaining until the PSI ends.
- The PSI Program's Four Pillars:
  - Containing the fiscal deficit to underpin macroeconomic stability and safeguard debt sustainability.
  - Improving fiscal governance and transparency so as to enhance policy credibility and sustain external assistance.
  - Encouraging private sector activity by improving the business environment and addressing structural impediments to higher economic growth.
  - Limiting financial sector vulnerabilities and raising the sector’s contribution to the economy.
- Given continued economic weakness and some new financing, staff supports a moderate fiscal stimulus in late 2009 and 2010.
- The PSI expires on November 1, 2010.

### B. Macroeconomic policies and fiscal stance
- Program aims to mitigate global crisis impact and normalize government–private sector financial relations (Text Table).
- Staff’s cautious macroeconomic assumptions suggest the deficit will reach about 5 percent of GDP (excluding settlement of extrabudgetary expenditure and payment of agency debt).
- A temporary increase in the deficit in late 2009 and 2010 is supported as it "would not jeopardize Senegal’s hard-won gains in debt sustainability."
- Authorities reiterated commitment to fiscal policy that keeps debt sustainable over the medium term.
- Staff underscored the need to better manage liquidity.

### C. Fiscal developments and budget numbers (2008–10) — key figures preserved exactly as in source
- Illustrative budget table (2008 Est. / 2009 Prog. / 2009 Proj. / 2010 Suppl. / 2010 Proj. as percent of GDP):
  - Total revenue and grants: 21.8 / 21.6 / 22.1 / 21.9 / 21.9
  - Of which: Tax revenue: 18.3 / 18.7 / 18.8 / 18.9 / 18.9
  - Total expenditure and net lending: 26.6 / 26.3 / 26.6 / 26.9 / 27.6
  - Current expenditure: 16.5 / 15.8 / 16.0 / 15.6 / ...
  - Capital expenditure: 10.0 / 10.4 / 10.6 / 11.2 / ...
  - Overall fiscal balance: -4.6 / -4.6 / -4.5 / -4.9 / -5.7
- Memorandum items:
  - Settlement of payment delays: 1.4 / 1.1 / 1.1 / 1.3 / 1.3
  - Below-the-line settlement: 1.4 / 1.1 / 1.1 / 1.3
  - SDR allocation: ---- / ---- / 1.4 / ----
  - Above-the-line settlement: --------0.8
  - Of which: Settlement of extrabudgetary spending and agency debt: 2010 (Percent of GDP) listed in table (illustrative outcome: 70 percent of extrabudgetary commitments and agency debt settled).
- Ten-year CFAF loan from the BCEAO (equal to the SDR allocation) helped offset other financing shortfalls. The terms: maturity of 10 years, three-year grace period, and interest rate of 3 percent.

### D. Scope for easing fiscal policy and financing considerations
- Fiscal policy in the first half of 2009 was tighter than programmed due to delays in mobilizing financing and tight controls to avoid payment delays; strong revenue administration efforts stabilizing tax revenues as a share of GDP.
- The BCEAO ten-year CFAF loan partially offset financing shortfalls.
- Staff supports moderate short-run fiscal expansion in late 2009 and 2010 to support aggregate demand given sluggish growth.
- Settlement of extrabudgetary spending and agency debt is critical to fully restore private sector confidence and improve the business environment.
- Social expenditure is expected to increase, though somewhat below PRSP objectives.
- Pending finalization of modalities and amounts, payments for extrabudgetary spending and agency debt are for the time being recorded below the line, 70 percent in 2010 and 30 percent in 2011 (Tables 3 and 4).

### E. Deepening PFM structural reforms — benchmarks and actions
- Authorities intend to:
  - Announce their strategy by end-January 2010 (structural benchmark).
  - Submit to parliament a corresponding supplementary budget by mid-May 2010 (structural benchmark).
  - Pay at least 50 percent of extrabudgetary expenditure to be settled and agency debt by end-September 2010 (structural benchmark). If sufficient financing is available, the remainder will be settled in 2010 but no later than 2011.
- Staff emphasized expeditious clearing and improved resource management; associated liquidity injection would support aggregate demand; overheating risk limited given sluggish outlook.
- Structural benchmarks (selection from "Structural Benchmarks, 2009–10"):
  - For the Fifth PSI Review:
    - Stop issuing 2009 payment orders. Policy Measure 15. Implementation date: December 31, 2009. Rationale: Improve transparency of budget execution and prevent recurrence of past budgetary slippages.
    - Issue a press release summarizing results of the audit of extrabudgetary commitments and agency debt and government’s settlement strategy; Action Measure 10. Implementation date: January 31, 2010. Rationale: Continue normalization of financial relations with the private sector.
    - Draw up an action plan to suppress tax expenditures with significant budgetary impact, aiming to incorporate first changes in the 2011 budget. Policy Measure 21. Implementation date: March 31, 2010. Rationale: Enhance transparency of tax system and increase revenues.
    - Prepare a consolidated action plan to implement the FSAP recommendations. Policy Measure 27. Implementation date: March 31, 2010. Rationale: Reduce vulnerability and strengthen development of the financial sector.
    - Submit to parliament a draft supplementary budget for 2010 including specific entries authorizing settlement in 2010 of extrabudgetary arrears and agency debt identified in July 2009 audit. Policy Measure 10. Implementation date: May 15, 2010. Rationale: Help normalize financial relations with the private sector.
  - For the Sixth PSI Review:
    - Improve SIGFIP by including payroll expenditure and implementing SIGFIP-ASTER interface. Policy Measure 17. Implementation date: July 31, 2010. Rationale: Strengthen monitoring of budget execution.
    - Conduct a census of all accounts held by general government institutions with balances as of December 31, 2008 and 2009 to adopt strategy for single Treasury account. Policy Measure 19. Implementation date: July 31, 2010. Rationale: Improve cash management and transparency.
    - Complete payment of at least 50 percent of extrabudgetary commitments and public institution and agency debt identified in July 2009 audit according to announced modalities. Policy Measure 10. Implementation date: September 30, 2010. Rationale: Help normalize financial relations with the private sector and enhance business climate.
    - Include in a single document the general tax code and all legislation governing domestic taxation. Policy Measure 21. Implementation date: October 15, 2010. Rationale: Simplify tax system and make it more transparent.
- Other PFM measures:
  - Timely end to issuance of payment orders for the 2009 budget year.
  - Better budget execution and accounting systems.
  - Movement toward a single treasury account to improve cash management and transparency of operations.
  - Reinforcing tax administration and following up on tax expenditure study; extend study and prepare action plan to rationalize some tax expenditures (structural benchmark) with aim to increase revenues and fiscal space.

### F. Growth-enhancing structural reforms and energy sector
- Energy sector reforms are critical to raising Senegal’s growth potential; challenges remain significant.
- A comprehensive reform plan needed to limit fiscal costs and contain economic risks; SENELEC needs to be made financially sound permanently to ensure adequate electricity distribution.
- Strategy elements under discussion with World Bank and AFD: debt restructuring, audits, restoration of production capacity of GTI (important private supplier of SENELEC), tariff adjustments to reflect supply and production costs while limiting impact on vulnerable consumers, compliance with Bank and AFD conditionality for release of second tranche of financial assistance (CFAF 15 billion), and a government contribution in the form of debt restructuring and a budgetary transfer not received in 2008.
- Box 2 — Energy Sector Reform: September 2009 stock-taking mission identified causes of difficulties:
  - Technical failures raising production costs.
  - Inadequate tariff structure.
  - Insufficient marketing and operational performance.
  - Constraints in fuel supply and delays in energy-saving measures.
  - Large arrears: CFAF 70 billion, more than 1 percent of GDP, as of September 2009 (more than half are back taxes).
  - High debt-servicing costs weighing on cash flow and weaknesses in internal governance.
- Tariff history note: Tariffs were raised by 17 percent in August 2008, lowered by 12 percent in January 2009 (with oil at about US$45 a barrel), and increased again by 8 percent in July 2009.

### G. Financial sector soundness and reform priorities
- Direct impact of global crisis on banking system limited due to limited international integration, but slowdown in domestic growth has increased nonperforming loans; several banks are not meeting some prudential regulations.
- Authorities stepped up high-frequency monitoring of financial sector risks and intend to prepare an updated consolidated financial sector action plan (structural benchmark) taking into account progress since 2004 national FSAP and 2007 regional FSAP.
- Financial Soundness Indicators for the Banking Sector, 2002–09 (selected series; percent):
  - Capital to risk-weighted assets: 2002 16.0; 2003 11.7; 2004 11.5; 2005 10.8; 2006 12.9; 2007 13.5; 2008 13.8; 2009 Jun. 15.5
  - Loans to 5 largest borrowers to capital: 2002 104.9; 2003 141.0; 2004 131.4; 2005 179.9; 2006 103.7; 2007 88.5; 2008 86.9; 2009 Jun. 91.8
  - Gross NPLs to total loans 1/: 2002 18.5; 2003 13.3; 2004 12.6; 2005 11.9; 2006 16.8; 2007 18.6; 2008 19.1; 2009 Jun. 18.0
  - NPLs net of provisions to total loans 1/: 2002 5.5; 2003 3.3; 2004 3.4; 2005 3.2; 2006 8.8; 2007 8.6; 2008 9.3; 2009 Jun. 9.8
  - NPLs net of provisions to capital 1/: 2002 30.7; 2003 27.8; 2004 25.1; 2005 27.2; 2006 67.9; 2007 60.7; 2008 63.9; 2009 Jun. 62.9
  - Total deposits to total liabilities: 2002 78.5; 2003 82.0; 2004 79.6; 2005 78.3; 2006 75.8; 2007 73.6; 2008 70.3; 2009 Jun. 71.2
- Priority reforms to raise growth potential (Accelerated Growth Strategy):
  - Reduce cost of transferring property, increase investor protection and contract enforcement, modernize labor market legislation, simplify customs procedures, and create credit bureaus.
  - Improve business climate to complement high-profile investment projects (airport, economic zone, Dakar port).
- Authorities committed to strengthen governance: publish budget execution regularly, ensure audit and regulatory agencies have adequate resources, and revise property law.

### H. Program issues, borrowing policy, and risks
- Authorities expressed interest in using Fund’s revised policy on nonconcessional borrowing and requested to raise the ceiling to finance Dakar-Diamniadio toll highway project by CFAF 10 billion to CFAF 90 billion to accommodate higher costs and issue a bond in international markets of US$200 million.
- Given Senegal’s low risk of debt distress, staff supports this request.
- Authorities interested in borrowing more externally on nonconcessional terms with untied limits for economically and socially profitable projects.
- TMU adjustment: the definition of the basic fiscal balance excludes payments linked to settling extrabudgetary spending and agency debt; an unknown part of these transactions will need to be recorded above the line.
- Staff recommendation: nonconcessional borrowing should stay linked to specific economically profitable projects for which sufficient concessional financing could not be mobilized; untied limits could become possible after PFM improves.
- Program risks:
  - Financing of the deficit could be undermined by liquidity shortages in the regional bond market.
  - Delays in regularizing outstanding payments could slow recovery.
  - A slower than expected global recovery, continued problems in the energy sector, or spill-overs from the announcement related to Dubai World could suppress growth and put pressure on the fiscal target.

### I. Staff appraisal (key judgments and recommendations)
- Program implementation has been broadly satisfactory in difficult circumstances; authorities carefully managed spending and continued structural reforms.
- Economic outlook requires continued vigilance; risks include pace of global recovery and domestic governance and transparency problems.
- Near-term policy guidance:
  - Continue policies to weather the global crisis and normalize government–private sector financial relations.
  - Shift a modest fiscal expansion into 2010 in line with 2010 budget and staff macroeconomic assumptions, while preserving medium-term debt sustainability.
  - Protect emergency and priority spending for vulnerable populations.
  - Improve liquidity management to minimize procyclical fiscal risks.
  - Fast settlement of extrabudgetary spending and payment of agency debt to normalize private sector relations and sustain PFM/accountability reform momentum.
  - Reinforce fiscal management capacity; keep nonconcessional borrowing linked to specific economically profitable projects until PFM improves.
  - In the energy sector: implement a comprehensive strategy, avoid further deterioration, improve efficiency, and adjust tariffs regularly to keep them aligned with costs to guard against an energy sector drain on the budget.

*Source: IMF mission text and MEFP excerpts in the supplied content unit.*

### 26.      The financial system has so far coped well with the global financial crisis, but

### _cr1013 - 26.      The financial system has so far coped well with the global financial crisis, but

### Financial system assessment
- The financial system "has so far coped well with the global financial crisis", but vulnerabilities could arise from:
  - an increase in nonperforming loans;
  - credit concentration;
  - a drying-up of liquidity.
- Recommendation: continually monitor these vulnerabilities at both national and regional levels.
- Banking-sector indicators (selected, 2003–09):
  - Capital to risk-weighted assets: 11.7; 11.5; 10.8; 12.9; 13.5; 13.8; 15.5 (2003–2009 sequence).
  - Gross NPLs to total loans: 13.3; 12.6; 11.9; 16.8; 18.6; 19.1; 18.0.
  - Provisions to NPLs: 75.3; 75.7; 75.4; 52.0; 53.8; 51.5; 50.5.
  - NPLs net of provisions to total loans: 3.3; 3.4; 3.2; 8.8; 8.6; 9.3; 9.8.
  - Concentration: loans to 5 largest borrowers to capital: 141.0; 131.4; 179.9; 103.7; 88.5; 86.9; 91.8.
  - Sectoral distribution of loans (selected series): Industrial 41.1; 33.6; 35.5; 28.9; 25.1; 19.5; 25.3; Retail and wholesale trade 19.9; 19.3; 17.0; 18.9; 14.4; 18.5; 16.5; Services, transportation and communication 17.2; 27.4; 28.0; 30.0; 29.6; 31.1; 35.4.
- Note: NPL changes in 2006 due to ICS; in 2008 ICS recapitalized and government guarantee lifted, but loans remain classified as non-performing without the need to provision.

### Macroeconomic performance and projections (selected)
- GDP at constant prices (annual percent change): 2.4; 4.8; 2.5; 3.1; 1.2; 3.4; 4.4; 4.8; 4.9; 4.9 (2006–2014 sequence as shown).
- Nonagriculture GDP (annual percent change): 4.0; 6.2; 1.3; 3.1; 0.7; 3.4; 4.5; 4.9; 5.0; 5.0.
- GDP deflator (annual percent change): 4.0; 5.5; 7.1; 2.1; -0.3; 2.1; 2.1; 2.1; 2.1; 2.1.
- Consumer prices (annual average): 2.1; 5.9; 5.8; 0.8; -0.8; 1.8; 2.2; 2.2; 2.2; 2.2.
- Gross domestic product (CFAF billions): 4,893; 5,408; 5,935; 6,264; 5,983; 6,336; 6,756; 7,230; 7,743; 8,292.

### External sector (selected)
- Exports, f.o.b. (CFA francs, annual percent change): 0.1; -3.7; 14.1; -12.1; -12.6; 14.6; 6.7; 5.5; 7.6; 7.7.
- Imports, f.o.b. (CFA francs, annual percent change): 9.6; 19.5; 7.7; -7.8; -11.9; 10.8; 8.3; 6.4; 7.8; 7.6.
- Export volume (annual percent change): -14.1; 0.2; -3.8; 9.0; 6.3; 10.5; 4.0; 4.0; 4.6; 5.0.
- Import volume (annual percent change): 6.4; 11.7; -2.7; 2.5; -2.3; 5.1; 5.5; 5.0; 5.2; 5.2.
- Terms of trade ("–" = deterioration): 13.0; -10.3; 7.5; -11.0; -8.7; -1.6; -0.1; 0.0; 0.3; 0.3.
- Current account deficit including current official transfers (percent of GDP): -9.5; -11.8; -10.4; -11.8; -9.6; -9.9; -9.7; -9.5; -9.6; -9.6.
- Current account deficit excluding current official transfers (percent of GDP): -10.5; -13.2; -11.4; -13.0; -10.9; -10.8; -10.6; -10.4; -10.5; -10.5.
- Gross official reserves (imputed, billions of US$): 1.3; 1.6; 1.5; 1.8; 1.7; 1.8; 1.9; 2.0; 2.1.

### Fiscal outlook and public finances
- Total revenue and grants (CFAF billions): 1,036; 1,277; 1,293; 1,354; 1,323; 1,390; 1,495; 1,621; 1,750; 1,890.
- Revenue (CFAF billions): 963; 1,139; 1,153; 1,201; 1,160; 1,242; 1,343; 1,458; 1,575; 1,703.
- Tax revenue (CFAF billions): 922; 1,088; 1,088; 1,172; 1,125; 1,199; 1,297; 1,409; 1,523; 1,647.
- Grants (CFAF billions): 73; 138; 140; 153; 162; 148; 152; 163; 174; 187.
- Total expenditure and net lending (CFAF billions): 1,331; 1,491; 1,579; 1,645; 1,592; 1,703; 1,803; 1,932; 2,062; 2,218.
- Primary fiscal balance (percent of GDP): -5.2; -3.3; -4.2; -3.7; -3.7; -4.1; -3.7; -3.3; -3.0; -2.9.
- Basic fiscal balance (percent of GDP): -3.4; -1.0; -0.8; -1.9; -2.0; -1.9; -1.4; -1.2; -1.0; -0.8.
- Overall fiscal surplus (+) or deficit (–), payment order basis excluding grants (percent of GDP): -7.2; -6.2; -7.0; -7.1; -7.2; -7.3; -6.8; -6.6; -6.3; -6.2.
- Overall fiscal balance (including grants) (CFAF billions): -279; -198; -273; -291; -269; -313; -308; -311; -313; -328.
- Financing gap in 2009 and 2010 to be filled with ESF drawings (indicator repeated in notes).

### Monetary developments and banking system
- Broad money (M2, CFAF billions): 1,553; 1,751; 1,973; 2,007; 2,192.
- Net foreign assets (BCEAO and commercial banks, CFAF billions): BCEAO 487; 569; 644; 653; 739. Commercial banks 173; 210; 207; 109; 115.
- Net domestic credit (CFAF billions): 1,032; 1,122; 1,324; 1,467; 1,570.
- Credit to the economy (CFAF billions): 1,067; 1,111; 1,228; 1,440; 1,506.
- Credit to the economy (percentage growth, table earlier): 24.5; 4.2; 10.5; 17.2; 4.6.
- Central bank refinance rate (eop/latest; percent): 4.00; 4.25; 4.25; 4.75; 4.25.

### PSI and ESF program reviews and Fund engagement
- Staff recommends completion of:
  - the fourth review of the PSI;
  - the second review of the ESF arrangement.
- Implementation has been "generally satisfactory", and "major new commitments have been made for the period ahead."
- Quantitative assessment criteria and indicative targets (selected, June 30 and September 30, 2009 reporting):
  - Floor on the basic fiscal balance: Indicative target -60; Actual Status -19; Assessment: Met.
  - Ceiling on contracting or guaranteeing of new nonconcessional external debt by the government: Indicative target 80; Actual Status 5/0; Assessment: Met.
  - Ceiling on spending undertaken outside normal and simplified procedures: Indicative target 0; Actual Status 0; Assessment: Met.
  - Ceiling on government external payment arrears (stock): Indicative target 0; Actual Status 0; Assessment: Met.
  - Ceiling on the amount of the float (dépenses liquidées non payées par le Trésor): Indicative target 45; Actual Status 42; Assessment: Met.
  - Quarterly ceiling on single-tender public sector contracts (percent): Indicative target 20; Actual Status 14; Assessment: Met.

### IMF obligations and capacity-to-repay indicators (selected)
- Total existing and prospective obligations to the Fund (millions of SDRs): 0.8; 0.4; 1.1; 2.9; 4.2; 4.2; 12.3; 24.8; 26.2; 24.7; 24.6; 16.3; 3.3 (2008–2020 series as shown).
- Total Fund credit outstanding (millions of SDRs): 41.6; 106.3; 138.3; 136.3; 132.8; 129.3; 117.8; 93.6; 68.0; 43.7; 19.4; 3.2; 0.0.
- Total Fund credit outstanding (millions of U.S. dollars): 63.3; 165.5; 215.1; 211.6; 206.1; 200.5; 182.2; 145.0; 105.2; 67.7; 30.1; 5.0; 0.0.
- Memorandum items (selected): Exports of goods and services (millions of US$) series shown (e.g., 3,343; 2,767; 3,153; ...); Debt service (millions of US$) series shown (e.g., 170; 177; 203; ...); Gross official reserves (millions of US$) series shown (e.g., 1,668; 1,788; 1,738; ...); GDP (millions of US$) series shown (e.g., 13,316; 12,526; 13,608; ...).

*Source: Senegalese authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections (tables and text from the provided content).*

### 1. The attached Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP) reviews recent

### _cr1013 - 1. The attached Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP) reviews recent

### Program scope and formal requests
- MEFP updates Senegal’s program under the three-year Policy Support Instrument (PSI) for 2007–10 and the Exogenous Shocks Facility (ESF) arrangement since December 2008.
- Request for completion of the fourth review of the PSI and the second review of the ESF arrangement with a disbursement of SDR 32.36 million.
- Government expects the fifth review of the PSI and third review of the ESF to be completed by May 28, 2010.
- Government authorizes IMF publication of the letter, the attached Memorandum, and the related Staff Report.

### Recent macroeconomic developments and program performance
- Real GDP growth:
  - Business activity flat (year-on-year) for first three quarters of 2009 (general activity index, excluding agriculture and administration).
  - Growth expected to be around 1.2 percent in 2009.
  - Growth projected at about 3½ percent in 2010 (assuming continued global recovery).
- Inflation:
  - Consumer price inflation (year-on-year) turned negative in May 2009.
  - Inflation is expected to return to about 2 percent in 2010.
- External accounts:
  - External current account deficit projected to improve compared to 2008 due to decline in oil and food prices.
- Quantitative program performance (met):
  - All quantitative program criteria for end-June 2009 and indicative targets for end-September 2009 were met.
  - Basic fiscal deficit at end-June 2009: CFAF 19.2 billion (program ceiling: CFAF 60 billion).
  - Budgetary float:
    - Declined to CFAF 41 billion (⅔ percent of GDP) at end-June 2009 from CFAF 175 billion (3 percent of GDP) in October 2008.
    - End-September 2009: CFAF 42 billion (below ceiling of CFAF 45 billion).
  - No external payment arrears accumulated.
  - No nonconcessional borrowing contracted or guaranteed since the second PSI review (including the CFAF 80 billion for the autoroute permitted under the program).
  - No Treasury cash advances approved since end-2008; budget expenditure executed under normal and simplified procedures.
  - Single-tender contracts limited to 14 percent of procurement in Q2 2009 and 5 percent in Q3 2009 (program ceiling: 20 percent).
- Fiscal outcome 2009:
  - Basic fiscal deficit expected to remain within the quantitative assessment criterion at end-December 2009: CFAF 119 billion.

### Structural reforms and transparency measures (progress and main findings)
- Extrabudgetary and agency debts:
  - Independent external audit (July 2009) identified:
    - Extrabudgetary spending: CFAF 37 billion.
    - Public agency and institution debt: CFAF 67 billion (as of December 31, 2008).
  - Government made initial assessment of claims to be settled (structural benchmark, end-July 2009).
- Procurement transparency:
  - First audit reports of ARMP completed to enhance budget transparency and governance.
- Tax expenditures:
  - Report prepared on tax expenditures (structural benchmark, end-September 2009) highlights key tax expenditures possibly equivalent to 3¾ percent of GDP.
- Expenditure tracking and SIGFIP/ASTER:
  - External audit and expert review of SIGFIP completed (structural benchmark, end-September 2009).
  - ASTER auxiliary expenditure module delayed (structural benchmark end-October 2009); CAD auxiliary expenditure accounting module to be operational in 2010.
  - General expenditure accounting module operational at senior accounting unit level; preliminary SIGFIP–ASTER interface testing under way.
  - High-level information systems steering committee established within the Ministry of Economy and Finance.
- Petroleum funds (FSIPP/FSAPP):
  - By end-October 2009, provisions adopted to transfer FSIPP/FSAPP collection from SAR to the DGID for transparent monitoring and improved accounting.
  - Since November 2009:
    - FSAPP revenues on imported finished petroleum products collected by DGID directly from oil companies and deposited in a Treasury account.
    - FSAPP revenues related to refinery operations collected by SAR and transferred to DGID, which deposits funds in a Treasury account at the BCEAO.
    - FSAPP revenues from refinery operations used to pay SAR’s debt balance and for petroleum sector and SAR investments.
    - Any subsidy or transfer to SAR or strategic investments in the petroleum sector must be transparently reflected in the government budget and subject to public procurement rules.
- Budget presentation improvements for 2010 (structural benchmark, October 15, 2009):
  - Budget contains:
    - A contingency expenditure line of 5 percent of current expenditure excluding personnel outlays.
    - An annex with execution and forecast data for each agency, para-public enterprise, and other public entity receiving budgetary allocations > CFAF 5 billion.
    - SIGFIP data on budget execution for the past year and first six months of the current year.
  - Government will include TOFE-based execution data and a contingency line of 5 percent of capital expenditure (excluding externally funded expenditure) in future budgets.

### Fiscal policy stance and commitments for 2010
- 2010 budget framework and outcomes:
  - Overall budget deficit (including grants) could reach about 5 percent of GDP in 2010.
  - Budget aims to increase capital expenditure to about 11 percent of GDP.
  - Protecting social outlays: increase from 33 percent at end-2008 to 35 percent of total expenditure in 2010; government will strive to reach PRSP target of 40 percent of total expenditure.
- Settlement of arrears and cash management:
  - Government eliminated payment delays in the regular expenditure chain and commits to settling extrabudgetary arrears and public institution and agency debt identified in the July 2009 audit.
  - Structural benchmarks and timelines:
    - Press release summarizing audit results and settlement strategy to be issued (structural benchmark, January 31, 2010).
    - Supplementary budget submitted to parliament no later than May 15, 2010 (structural benchmark, May 15, 2010) including specific entries authorizing settlement in 2010 of identified arrears and debts; debts not requiring budgetary allocation to be presented in an annex.
    - Government commits to settle at least 50 percent of extrabudgetary arrears and public institution and agency debt identified in the July 2009 audit by end-September 2010 (structural benchmark, end-September 2010). Additional resources in 2010 will be used to pay remaining amounts.
  - Treasury correspondent accounts:
    - Transfers to agencies’ bank accounts and/or payments to enterprises must be made no later than 90 days after the Treasury receives the check; checks for which the 90-day period has passed will be settled by end-September 2010 under a specific plan.
    - Process enhancements: (i) cash flow plan established and updated between Treasury and correspondents; (ii) transfer or payment intentions reported to Treasury at least thirty days before withdrawal or payment date.
- Debt policy and issuance:
  - Rolling two-year government issuance calendar to be updated quarterly or after each issuance, in cooperation with the BCEAO.
  - Government will signal to WAEMU Council of Ministers the need to improve coordination of Member States’ access to the regional financial market.
  - Medium-term commitment: limit overall fiscal deficit to 4 percent of GDP.
  - Semi-annual public debt sustainability analysis to include risk assessment for contingent liabilities from government guarantees to PPPs and public enterprise operations.
  - General approach: focus on concessional financing; avoid contracting or guaranteeing external nonconcessional borrowing except for specific economically profitable projects when concessional financing cannot be mobilized.

### Dakar–Diamniadio toll highway financing
- Government requests raising the ceiling for non-concessional borrowing for the Dakar-Diamniadio toll highway:
  - Existing ceiling: CFAF 80 billion (quantitative assessment performance criterion).
  - Requested ceiling: CFAF 90 billion (increase of CFAF 10 billion; less than 0.2 percent of GDP).
  - Purpose: accommodate possibly higher costs and enable issuing a bond in international markets of US$200 million (typically seen as a minimum size for this type of transaction).
  - Government states the small increase would have no negative impact on debt sustainability.
  - Government will consult with IMF staff in advance regarding any other exceptions to this program criterion.

### Risks and conditionality
- Downside risks:
  - Adverse developments in the international environment could reduce private transfers, official development assistance, exports, or foreign direct investment and negatively affect growth.
  - Energy sector issues pose material risks that need fast resolution to avoid a growing adverse impact on economic activity.
- Consultation commitment:
  - Government will consult with the IMF—at its own initiative or whenever the Managing Director requests—before adopting additional measures or changes to the policies described in the MEFP.
  - Government will provide IMF with requested information on progress in implementing policies and achieving program objectives.

*Source: Memorandum on Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP), Dakar, December 4, 2009.*

### 15.      With progress made, the government remains committed to continuing its ambitious

### _cr1013 - 15.      With progress made, the government remains committed to continuing its ambitious

### Budget reforms and execution
- Reforms are based on a fiscal reform program supported by the government and development partners, including the IMF technical assistance report and the PEFA report, to enhance budget efficiency and transparency and protect macroeconomic stability.
- Closing provisions for budget execution and accounting:
  - November 30 cut-off date for making budget commitments (engagements).
  - Administrative phase of budget execution (payment orders) ends on December 31 (structural benchmark).
  - Accounting phase (payments) ends at end-February of the subsequent year.
  - Beyond February 28, any operation from the previous budget year with an impact on government cash flows must be included in the accounts for the current year.
  - SIGFIP data for each budget year will be frozen and published in detail on a Ministry of Economy and Finance website latest by April 30. For any payment after April 30, a new payment order needs to be issued and imputed to the current fiscal year.
  - A payment of CFAF 5 billion, still outstanding when accounting for the 2008 budget was closed, should have been recorded in the 2009 Treasury accounts but was recorded retroactively in 2008.
  - Preliminary SIGFIP and TOFE end-month data will be published on a Ministry of Finance website within 10 and 45 days, respectively, beginning with the TOFE for November 2009 and the SIGFIP for end-December 2009.

### SIGFIP improvements and Treasury suspense accounts
- Treasury suspense accounts will be cleared to the extent information allows, aiming to reduce transactions in suspense accounts to a strict minimum by end-February to allow timely closure of Treasury accounts.
- SIGFIP enhancement commitments:
  - Implement recommendations of IMF PFM TA missions following the audit of SIGFIP and two PFM TA missions in late 2008.
  - Follow-up IMF technical assistance tentatively scheduled for February 2010.
  - Short-term intent to extend SIGFIP to cover all operational line ministries.
  - Improve SIGFIP by incorporating payroll expenditure and implementing the SIGFIP-ASTER interface (structural benchmark, end-July 2010).

### Draft budget reviews and census of government accounts
- Draft budget review law for 2008 will be forwarded to the Audit Court by end-December 2009; the one for 2009 by end-September 2010.
- Census of all government accounts (including public institutions and agencies) conducted by Financial Audit Inspectorate (IGF) in 2006, to be updated:
  - All administration, public institution and agency accounts, including bank accounts, will be listed exhaustively.
  - For each account include number, name of the holder, and balance as at December 31, 2008 and 2009 (structural benchmark, July 2010).
  - Ministries and public institutions/agencies will be asked for lists and permission for banks to provide information to the Treasury.
  - Census is a step toward establishing a single Treasury account for improved daily liquidity management.

### Tax administration and tax expenditure reforms
- Preserve strong performance of Senegalese tax system; resolution of government payment delays and transfer of direct tax collection from the Treasury to the DGID should strengthen revenue collection.
- Measures following tax expenditures analysis aiming for changes in the 2011 budget:
  - Establish an action plan to eliminate ineffective/inefficient tax expenditures with significant budgetary cost (structural benchmark, March 2010).
  - Beginning January 1, 2010, carry out an ex ante impact assessment prior to any adoption of new tax expenditures.
  - By October 15, 2010, incorporate into one single document the general tax code and all legislation governing domestic taxation (structural benchmark, October 31, 2010).

### Energy sector reform, SENELEC stabilization, and measures
- Background and financing:
  - Letter of development policy for the energy sector adopted in 2008 to ensure quality energy supply at lowest cost.
  - Sector reform plan identified financing requirement of CFAF 109 billion.
  - Government participation in 2007: CFAF 65 billion.
  - World Bank and AFD disbursed an initial tranche of CFAF 37 billion in 2008 as budgetary assistance, of which CFAF 15 billion remains to be disbursed (CFAF 6 billion in additional recapitalization, and CFAF 9 billion in subordinated equity loans).
- Challenges and arrears reduction:
  - Frequent electricity outages in August 2009 due to SENELEC’s strained cash-flow; World Bank and AFD emergency mission in early September 2009.
  - Reasons identified for outages include technical faults (GTI, Kounoune, TAG2, TAG3), pricing mismatch and unpaid government compensation for 2008, below-budget commercial and operational performance, fuel supply constraints, delays in demand management policy, arrears and debt servicing burdens, insufficient internal warning systems and governance weaknesses.
  - Arrears fell from approximately CFAF 100 billion at end-December 2008 to CFAF 70 billion at end-September 2009, comprising CFAF 44 billion with central government (including CFAF 12 billion in VAT suspended and not due) and CFAF 30 billion with private suppliers and creditors.
- Government-chosen reform scenario (comprehensive measures):
  - (a) Restructuring of SENELEC’s short-term debt.
  - (b) Implementation of action plan to reduce nontechnical losses and costs (cost reduction plan).
  - (c) Improvement of business performance.
  - (d) Prosecution of fraud.
  - (e) Assessment of fuel supply and human resource management functions.
  - (f) Updating if necessary and implementation of audit recommendations on financial and accounting procedures.
  - (g) Resolution of GTI private supplier problem via return to service of the power station and contract revision, with financial, legal and technical assistance.
  - (h) Implementation of detailed action plan to meet conditions of second tranches of World Bank and AFD budget support relating to sector restructuring.
  - (i) Tariff adjustment by no later than April 1, 2010, plus other measures if necessary to avoid significant impact on vulnerable segments of the population.
  - (j) Quarterly price adjustments, if necessary, to reflect variations in costs of production or purchase of energy.
- Additional measures agreed with World Bank and AFD for long-term stability:
  - (i) Debt-crossing agreement (convention de dette croisée) between government and SENELEC.
  - (ii) Rescheduling of on-lent debt (dette rétrocédée) of CFAF 17 billion and suspended VAT set at CFAF 12 billion over 60 months.
  - (iii) Exemption from VAT on new investments pursuant to the 2007-25 law.
  - (iv) Payment of balance of CFAF 36 billion for 2008 compensation, and commitment to provide in 2011 and 2012 budgets access to funds: CFAF 20 billion in 2010 and CFAF 16 billion in 2011 through the financial system.
  - Government reserves right to take immediate steps, including tariff adjustment, if warranted by exceptional circumstances to ensure sector viability.
- Program objectives:
  - Reduce quasi-fiscal risks and enable regular tax payments by SENELEC to government.
  - Complete unbundling of SENELEC activities (production, transportation, distribution) and increase participation by local and foreign private sector, consumers and workers in SENELEC capital, in line with the Letter of Development Policy.

### Financial sector reforms and supervision
- Recognition of difficulties due to domestic factors and global crisis: increases in nonperforming loans and some banks not meeting selected prudential regulations.
- Government undertakings to maintain financial stability:
  - (a) Continue close monitoring of banking sector solvency and liquidity, including analysis of assets/liabilities, financing source concentration, liquidity relationships with parent companies or group establishments abroad, and overall liquidity; intensify exchanges with WAEMU authorities and foreign supervisors.
  - (b) Focus on macro-financial risks from financing linkages among government, private sector, and financial system; major banks to undergo regular stress tests; intensify consultations with government and banks on financing and cash requirements.
  - (c) Closely monitor entry into force of new minimum capital rules by end-2010.
  - (d) Further strengthen capacity and resources of the directorate regulating and supervising microfinance institutions within the Ministry of Economy and Finance.
  - (e) Accelerate implementation of FSAP recommendations jointly with WAEMU authorities; prepare a consolidated action plan for Senegal by end-March 2010 (new structural benchmark). Action plan to take stock of progress since 2004 national FSAP update and 2007 regional FSAP, determine priorities, assign responsibilities, and include an indicative timetable. Coverage to include banking, insurance, microfinance, other intermediaries, cash flow management, legal environment, and access to financial services.

### Private sector development and governance measures
- Accelerated Growth Strategy (AGS) implementation is required to raise growth; government commits to improve business environment and reach international standards.
- Specific commitments:
  - (a) Improve commercial justice efficiency by providing courts necessary resources and implementing identified administrative measures.
  - (b) Reduce delays and costs in transfer of property rights per 2008 office memoranda; adopt and implement Prime Minister circular reducing time for construction permits and hookups for water, sanitation, electricity, and telephones.
  - (c) Extend possibilities for renewing fixed-term labor contracts.
  - (d) Hold second national forum on credit by end-March 2010, followed by implementation of recommendations per an agreed timetable.
- Governance improvements:
  - By end of first quarter of 2010, finalize legislation on government property and real estate: (i) law on real estate ownership and its implementation decree; (ii) update pricing scales for government-owned property.
  - Strengthen Audit Court by providing appropriate resources and promoting judge training with donor help.
  - Make sufficient financing available for procurement regulatory agency (ARMP).

### Program monitoring, performance criteria, and timelines
- Quantitative assessment (performance) criteria set for end-December 2009 and end-June 2010 and quantitative indicators for end-March 2010; assessment of energy sector reform will be a focus of program reviews.
- Expected reviews and consultations:
  - Fifth PSI review, third ESF review and next Article IV consultation expected to be concluded by May 28, 2010.
  - Sixth and last PSI review to take place by end-October 2010.
- (Tables referenced in the source list specific performance criteria, indicative targets, and structural benchmarks for 2009–10, including numeric ceilings/targets and definitions, and dates such as March 31, 2010, June 30, 2010, December 31, 2009, and specified monitoring provisions.)

*Source: _cr1013 - 15.      With progress made, the government remains committed to continuing its ambitious*

### 1. Stop issuing 2009 payment orders.  15 December 31, 2009 Improve

### _cr1013 - 1. Stop issuing 2009 payment orders.  15 December 31, 2009 Improve

### Prior actions and structural benchmarks (selected measures and deadlines)
- 1. Stop issuing 2009 payment orders. 15 December 31, 2009 — Improve transparency of budget execution and prevent recurrence of past budgetary slippages.
- 2. Issue a press release summarizing the results of the audit of extrabudgetary commitments and agency debt, the government’s strategy for settling payments in the first supplementary budget for 2010 submitted to parliament no later than May 15, 2010, and describing the settlement procedures. 10 January 31, 2010 — Continue the normalization of financial relations with the private sector in a transparent fashion.
- 3. Draw up an action plan to suppress tax expenditures with a significant budgetary impact that are ineffective and/or inefficient, with the aim of incorporating the first changes in the 2011 budget. 21 March 31, 2010 — Enhance the transparency of the tax system and increase revenues.
- 4. Prepare a consolidated action plan for implementing the FSAP recommendations. 27 March 31, 2010 — Reduce the vulnerability and strengthen the development of the financial sector.
- 5. Submit to parliament a supplementary budget for 2010 that includes specific entries/items authorizing the Ministry of Finance to settle in 2010 the extrabudgetary arrears and public institution and agency debt identified in the July 2009 audit that have not yet been included in a budget. Any debt settlement not requiring a budget entry will be presented in an annex to the supplementary budget. 10 May 15, 2010 — Complete the normalization of financial relations with the private sector.
- 6. Improve SIGFIP by including payroll expenditure and implementing the SIGFIP-ASTER interface. 17 July 31, 2010 — Strengthen the monitoring of budget execution.
- 7. Conduct a census of all the accounts held by general government institutions, and include for each account the number, name of the holder, and the balance as of December 31, 2008 and 2009, with a view to adopting a strategy to establish a single Treasury account. 19 July 31, 2010 — Improve the management of cash flows, as well as the transparency of operations.
- 8. Complete payment of at least 50 percent of extrabudgetary commitments and public institution and agency debt identified in the July 2009 audit according to the modalities of the strategy announced by the government in January. 10 September 30, 2010 — Complete the normalization of financial relations with the private sector and improve the business climate.
- 9. Incorporate in a single document the general tax code and all legislation governing domestic taxation. 21 October 15, 2010 — Further simplify the tax system.

### Program definitions, quantitative assessment criteria, and examples
- The Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU) defines quantitative assessment (performance) criteria, indicative targets, and structural benchmarks for monitoring the Fund-supported program under the Policy Support Instrument (PSI) in 2009. Quantitative program targets also serve as performance criteria under the ESF.
- Government definition: central administration of the Republic of Senegal; excludes local administration, the central bank, and government-owned entities with separate legal personality (e.g., public universities and hospitals).
- Basic Fiscal Balance (program definition):
  - Definition: difference between the government’s budgetary revenue and total expenditure and net lending, excluding:
    - externally-financed capital expenditure (financed by donors),
    - drawings on on-lent loans (except on-lent loans to the energy sector financed through donor budget support),
    - expenditure funded with HIPC- and MDRI-related resources,
    - expenditure related to the settlement of agency debt and extrabudgetary arrears identified in the July 2009 audit and included in the first supplementary budget for 2010.
  - Budgetary revenue excludes privatization receipts and sales of mobile telephone licenses or other government assets.
  - Government expenditure is defined on the basis of payment orders accepted by the Treasury (dépenses prises en charge par le Trésor).
  - The assessment (performance) criterion is set as a floor on the cumulative basic fiscal balance since the beginning of the year.
- Example (numeric fidelity preserved):
  - The floor for the basic balance (program definition) as at June 30, 2010 is minus CFAF 59 billion.
  - It is calculated as the difference between budgetary revenue (CFAF 621 billion) and total expenditure and net lending (CFAF 851.5 billion), excluding:
    - externally financed capital expenditure (CFAF 136.5 billion),
    - drawings on on-lent loans (CFAF 5 billion),
    - expenditure funded with HIPC- and MDRI-related resources CFAF 30 billion).

### Budgetary float, reporting frequencies, and monitoring rules
- Budgetary float (instances de paiement):
  - Definition: outstanding stock of government expenditure for which bills have been received and validated but not yet paid by the Treasury (difference between dépenses liquidées and dépenses payées).
  - Assessment criterion: ceiling on the budgetary float, monitored at the end of the quarter.
- SIGFIP reporting requirements:
  - Authorities will report weekly (end of each week) and at the end of each month a SIGFIP table showing:
    - all committed expenditures (dépenses engagées),
    - all certified expenditures not yet cleared for payment (dépenses liquidées non encore ordonnancées),
    - all payment orders (dépenses ordonnancées),
    - all payment orders accepted by the Treasury (dépenses prises en charge par le Trésor),
    - all payments made by the Treasury (dépenses payées).
  - The SIGFIP table will exclude delegations for regions and embassies and will list any payments that do not have a cash impact on the Treasury accounts.
- Spending outside simplified and normal procedures:
  - Criterion applies continuously to any procedure other than simplified and normal procedures to execute spending.
  - Excludes spending on the basis of an advance decree for absolute urgency and need in the national interest (Article 12 of the Organic Budget Law), which requires signatures by the President and Prime Minister.
  - Monitored effective the time of the second PSI review.
  - Authorities will report monthly with a maximum delay of 30 days any such procedure, together with the SIGFIP table.
- Government external payment arrears:
  - Definition: sum of payments owed and not paid on the external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government (definition of external debt given in paragraph 13 of the TMU).
  - Assessment (performance) criterion monitored on a continuous basis.
  - Authorities will promptly report any accumulation in external payment arrears.

### External debt, concessionality, and contracting rules
- Contracting or guaranteeing new nonconcessional external debt by the government:
  - Applies to debt as defined in Point No. 9 of the Guidelines on Performance Criteria with Respect to Foreign Debt and commitments contracted or guaranteed by the government for which funds have not been received.
  - Exemptions include:
    - (i) CFAF debt contracted or guaranteed by the government with WAEMU residents;
    - (ii) CFAF debt initially contracted or guaranteed by the government with WAEMU residents subsequently acquired by nonresidents;
    - (iii) CFAF government or government-guaranteed debt where the agreement is between the government and a resident WAEMU entity and there is no ensuing contractual obligation between the government and a nonresident entity, regardless of whether the resident WAEMU entity resells the debt to a nonresident;
    - (iv) debt rescheduling transactions of debt existing at the time of the approval of the PSI;
    - (v) external debt contracted by the airport project company (AIDB) to finance construction of the new Dakar Airport.
  - Criterion is measured on a cumulative basis since approval of the second program review and applies continuously.
  - The ceiling is raised to accommodate CFAF 90 billion to finance exclusively the Dakar-Diamniadio toll highway project. No adjuster will apply to this criterion.
  - Government scope for this criterion (paragraph 14): includes central government as defined earlier and public institutions of an industrial and commercial nature (EPIC), public administrative institutions (EPA), public institutions of a scientific and technical nature, public institutions of a professional nature, public health institutions, local administrations, public enterprises, and government-owned or controlled independent companies (sociétés nationales).
  - Concessionality test: Any external debt whose present value, calculated with the reference interest rates mentioned, is greater than 65 percent of nominal value (grant element of less than 35 percent) is considered nonconcessional, with the exception of IMF lending.
    - For debt with maturity > 15 years: ten-year reference market interest rate published by the OECD is used.
    - For debt with shorter maturities: six-month reference market rate is used.
  - Reporting requirement: government will report any new external borrowing and its terms to Fund staff as soon as external debt is contracted or guaranteed by the government.

### Public procurement and single-tender contract monitoring
- Public sector contracts signed by single tender:
  - Definition: administrative contracts for procurement of supplies, services, or works subject to the procurement code; considered single-tender when signed without competitive tender.
  - Quarterly indicative target applies to public sector contracts examined by the Direction Centrale des Marchés Publics (DCMP).
  - Reporting requirement: government will report quarterly, with a lag of no more than one month from the end of the observation period, the total value of contracts signed by all ministries and agencies and the total value of all single-tender contracts signed by these ministries and agencies.

### Additional program monitoring and data transmission
- Immediate reporting: any decision, circular, edict, decree, ordinance, or law having economic or financial implications for the current program (effective immediately).
- With a maximum lag of 30 days, preliminary data on:
  - Tax receipts and tax and customs assessments by categories, accompanied by the corresponding revenue;
  - The monthly amount of expenditures committed, certified, and for which payment orders have been issued;
  - The quarterly report of the Debt and Investment Directorate (DDI) on execution of investment programs;
  - The monthly preliminary government financial operations table (TOFE), based on the Treasury accounts (balances de compte);
  - The provisional balance of the Treasury accounts;
  - A reconciliation table between the SIGFIP table and the Treasury accounts, between the Treasury accounts and the fiscal reporting table (TOFE) for revenues, between the Treasury accounts and the fiscal reporting table (TOFE) for total expenditure and net lending, and between the TOFE and the net government position (NGP), on a quarterly basis.
- Final data: provided as soon as final balances of the treasury accounts are available, but not later than one month after reporting of provisional data.
- Monthly reporting during the program on current nonwage noninterest expenditures and domestically financed capital expenditures executed through advance payments and treasury advances, with a lag of no more than 30 days; data drawn from preliminary consolidated treasury account balances; final data no more than one month after provisional reporting.
- Additional financial sector and monetary reporting:
  - Monthly central bank balance sheet, maximum lag of one month;
  - Consolidated balance sheet of banks, maximum lag of two months;
  - Monetary survey, quarterly, maximum lag of two months;
  - Lending and deposit interest rates of commercial banks, monthly;
  - Prudential supervision and financial soundness indicators for bank financial institutions, quarterly (Table: Situation des Etablissements de Crédit vis-à-vis du Dispositif Prudentiel).
- Airport tax monitoring: government will update monthly on the website the amount of airport tax—redevance de développement des infrastructures aéroportuaires (RDIA)—collected, deposited in the escrow account, and used for the repayment of the loan financing the construction of the new airport.

### IMF Board decisions and ESF/PSI disbursements (Press Release No. 09/462)
- Press Release date: December 16, 2009.
- The Executive Board completed the second review of Senegal’s performance under an ESF arrangement and approved a disbursement equivalent to SDR 32.36 million (about US$51 million).
- This disbursement brings total disbursements under the ESF arrangement to SDR 88.99 million (about US$141 million).
- Earlier action: on June 19, 2009 the Executive Board approved a financial increase under the ESF by SDR 72.81 million (about US$115 million) to SDR 121.35 million (about US$192 million) and an extension from 12 to 18 months.
- The Board also completed the fourth review under the Policy Support Instrument (PSI).
- The ESF for Senegal was approved on December 19, 2008.
- The Board’s decision was taken on a lapse of time basis and will become effective on December 22, 2009.

*Source: _cr1013 - 1. Stop issuing 2009 payment orders.  15 December 31, 2009 Improve (extracted content).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2010/_cr1013.pdf_
