## Executive Summary (content unit: _cr1150)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Executive Summary (content unit: _cr1150)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2011/_cr1150.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2011/_cr1150.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2011/_cr1150.pdf.json)

---

### Context: Growth and Inflation
- India’s real GDP in Q3 2010 grew at 8.9 percent y/y.
- Growth projections:
  - 2010/11: 8¾ percent.
  - 2011/12: revert to potential of about 8 percent.
- Inflation:
  - Headline inflation (WPI) in the 8½ to 10½ percent range; staff project WPI to decline to 6½ percent (March 2011); RBI projects 5.5 percent.
  - CPI inflation (industrial workers, IW): 9.8 percent y/y.
  - Core inflation (WPI excluding food and energy): 7⅓ percent y/y.
- Key domestic drivers: robust domestic demand, infrastructure investment, private consumption supported by a good harvest after drought and urbanization.
- Risks:
  - Downside: weaker global growth.
  - Upside: overly accommodative domestic policies, higher food and commodity prices, surging capital inflows complicating macroeconomic management.
- External: import growth outpaced exports; capital inflows offset the current account deficit; nominal effective exchange rate appreciated only slightly; RBI barely intervened since November 2009.

*Source: Executive Summary of the IMF staff report (content unit: _cr1150 - Executive Summary).*

### Policy Messages (High-Level)
- Complete normalization of monetary and fiscal stance promptly given robust growth and elevated inflation.
- Further monetary tightening needed to meet RBI’s inflation objectives and anchor expectations.
- Government’s renewed commitment to fiscal consolidation is welcome; receipts overperformance offers opportunity to reconstitute fiscal space faster.
- Spending reforms critical to reconcile consolidation with higher infrastructure and social spending; implement pending tax reforms.
- Monitor current account deficit closely given reversal risk in capital inflows.
- Flexible exchange rate is first line of defense; if inflows become excessive, a wide array of tools is available.
- Facilitate infrastructure investment and deepen the corporate bond market; sustain reforms.

---

### Maintaining Macroeconomic Stability — Inflation Assessment and Monetary Policy

Findings
- WPI moved from -0.7 percent y/y in June 2009 to double digits in early 2010, declining to 8.6 percent y/y in October.
- Inflation persistence/inertia significant; energy and food shocks transmit rapidly to core inflation.
- Short-term real rates using market forecasts remain negative or barely positive and are some 75-100bp below levels implied by Taylor rule calculations.
- Financing conditions hardened marginally: modest rupee appreciation; strong capital market issuance; lending rates risen less than policy rates though transmission ongoing.
- Output gap estimated closed; little slack; services prices and wages rising rapidly; growing rural incomes and inelastic food supply risk renewed food price ascent.

Monetary policy actions and recommendations
- Since December 2009: CRR raised by 100 basis points and repo rate by 150 bp to 6.25 percent.
- Policy rates need to rise further to bring real repo rate clearly into positive territory and in line with historical norms.
- Recommendation: RBI publish one-year ahead inflation forecasts on a rolling basis to better anchor expectations.
- Consider giving more weight to CPI in conduct of monetary policy over time.
- Strengthen monetary transmission by reducing width of policy rate corridor and linking administered savings rates to market rates (under RBI study).

Authorities’ views (monetary)
- Authorities project 2010/11 growth at 8.5 percent and expect return to 9 percent quickly thereafter.
- Authorities expect WPI inflation to fall to 5.5 percent by March 2011; attribute recent food price rises to structural factors concentrated in high-protein items.
- RBI signals low likelihood of immediate further rate actions but does not rule out further tightening; expects measures to push real interest rates into positive territory by March 2011.
- RBI considers the new WPI with wider coverage and updated weights appropriate for current policy while evaluating other measures.

---

### Is Fiscal Consolidation Sufficient? — Fiscal Findings and Recommendations

Fiscal outcomes and projections
- 2009/10 fiscal deficit estimated at 10.4 percent of GDP; Center’s deficit at 6.8 percent of GDP.
- Budgeted Center deficit in 2010/11: 5½ percent of GDP.
- Staff project fiscal deficit at 5 percent of GDP (authorities’ definition) for 2010/11 due to divestment and higher-than-expected proceeds from 3G and wireless spectrum auctions.
- Excluding asset sale and auction proceeds (IMF definition), the deficit would reach 6½ percent of GDP.
- Under this outcome, only about a quarter of the combined fiscal impulse of the past two years would be withdrawn.

Policy and reform progress
- Fuel price liberalization: gasoline prices liberalized; diesel prices promised to follow eventually.
- Direct Tax Code (DTC) proposal: phases out major profit-linked business exemptions and rationalizes deductions on savings.
- GST agreement not yet reached, delaying modern indirect tax implementation.

Recommendations to strengthen consolidation
- Save receipts overperformance in 2010/11 to reconstitute fiscal space; several spending measures are expiring (e.g., 6th Pay Commission arrears).
- Prefer fiscal consolidation as macro tool to cool the economy given high government debt and large capital inflows.
- Substantial adjustment in current spending required to meet medium-term consolidation; scope for rationalization by cutting subsidies (fuel and fertilizers) and improving targeting.
- Exploit Unique Identification number (UID) to improve targeting as soon as technically feasible.
- Use performance-based incentives to improve social outcomes over the longer term.
- Build on budget reforms: Government Debt Report (GDR) strengthens transparency and medium-term budget framework; authorities should detail plans quantifying how to fit rising capital and social spending into a declining budget envelope as a share of GDP.
- Amend the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act per 13th Finance Commission recommendations: tighten escape clauses and introduce a fiscal oversight committee.

Medium-term targets and challenges
- 13th Finance Commission called for general government deficits to contract by 4 percentage points of GDP between 2009/10 and 2014/15 and public debt to fall from 79 to 68 percent of GDP.
- Government’s commitment to reduce debt to 65 percent of GDP is significant; savings assumed in GDR on pensions, wages, subsidies, and interest payments could be difficult since these areas totaled only 8 percent of GDP in 2009/10.

---

### External Balances, Current Account, and Capital Flows

Key statistics and projections
- Current account deficit projections: 3.3 percent of GDP in 2010/11 and 3.5 percent next year.
- External debt: about 20 percent of GDP.
- Recent capital inflows: about 4 percent of GDP during the past year.
- CGER: rupee valued broadly in line with fundamentals; REER only 6 percent above its 10-year average.
- Reserve and flow indicators: REER appreciated modestly over five years; reserve and capital flow details in Annex/Tables.

Policy guidance and tools
- Exchange rate flexibility should remain first line of defense.
- If inflows surge, consider reserve accumulation and selective administrative measures.
- Deepen domestic financial markets (increase share supply, e.g., increase minimum float requirement for state enterprises).
- Develop corporate bond market and liberalize FDI to attract longer-term flows.
- If appreciation persistent/excessive and inflows too large/volatile, options include sterilized intervention, raising the CRR, and macroprudential measures.
- New controls should be a last resort given existing framework of capital controls (especially on debt).

Annex findings on CAD
- CAD averaged 1.1 percent of GDP in three years prior to the crisis; increased to 3.7 percent of GDP in 2010Q2.
- Expected to remain at 3-3.5 percent of GDP over next couple of years; medium-term decline to 2-2.5 percent of GDP.
- Fall 2010 CGER estimated CAD norm at 3.4 percent of GDP.
- Sensitivities:
  - A $10 increase in oil prices (~12 percent) would increase the CAD by about 0.6 percent of GDP.
  - A 10 percent depreciation of the rupee estimated to lower the trade balance by 0.2 percent of GDP in 1½-2 years.

---

### Financial Markets, Asset Prices, and Macroprudential Policy

Asset markets and systemic resilience
- Equity market gathered momentum; equity prices outperformed other BRICs with valuation ratios approaching historical highs.
- Residential real estate recovered; commercial and retail segments remain soft.
- RBI tightened prudential norms on residential mortgages; more action may be warranted if exuberance emerges.
- Banking system:
  - Recovery improved credit profile of restructured assets.
  - Banks reduced exposure to unsecured retail lending.
  - Stress tests indicate doubling of NPLs would leave banks above regulatory minimum capital requirement.
  - NPLs inched up; asset/liability mismatches increased as deposit growth lagged credit growth; infrastructure loans and residential mortgages expanded fastest.
- Priorities: monitor asset quality, raise provisioning coverage, strengthen risk management and credit assessment, especially if prudential norms for infrastructure are eased.

Regulation and supervision
- NBFCs expanding faster than banks; infrastructure NBFCs introduced.
- Authorities: prevent regulatory arbitrage; new supervision framework for financial conglomerates; RBI’s Financial Stability Report; review of financial laws and FSDC.
- FSDC role: balance independence of regulators with need to resolve regulatory disputes and financial reform differences.
- Encourage AML/CFT efforts including implementing FATF Mutual Evaluation recommendations.

Corporate bond and CP market developments
- Listed corporate bonds up 58 percent since December 2008.
- Outstanding CP almost tripled with higher trading volumes.
- Issuance dominated by highly-rated, especially public sector, companies.
- Market liquidity limited; domestic institutional investor participation low.
- Impediments: stamp duties and withholding taxes.
- Reforms: listing/reporting requirements, higher FII participation, repos with corporate bonds.

---

### Infrastructure Investment, Bottlenecks, and Reforms

Plans and targets
- 11th Plan (2007/08–2011/12) five-year target: around US$500 billion (MTA); mid-term appraisal showed targets exceeded in 2007/08 and 2008/09 due to telecoms and pipelines; roads, railways, ports lagged.
- 12th Plan (2012/13–2016/17) mooted figure: US$1 trillion to boost infrastructure investment to 9 percent of GDP and aim for private participation to rise to half the total.
- Authorities’ objective: infrastructure and human capital investment to reach 9-10 percent GDP growth over the medium term.
- Staff estimate of potential growth: 7½-8½ percent.

Roadblocks
- Financing: main constraint is availability of long-term rupee debt; bank-dominated system creates maturity mismatches.
- Land acquisition: legal, environmental, social, political constraints; bill stalled in Parliament.
- Clearances and execution capacity: overlapping levels of government and limited contracting capacity.
- Governance risks: large projects create rent-seeking opportunities; need transparency and accountability.

Financing mix and lessons
- Cross-country evidence: energy investment often financed domestically; roads more likely to tap foreign savings.
- Case studies:
  - Brazil: reliance on BNDES and public development bank lending.
  - Chile: privatized pension system and deep financial markets support private financing.
  - China: local government land premia and state-run banks channel domestic savings.
- India’s outlook:
  - Favorable demographics should ensure sufficient domestic savings over medium term, but foreign savings likely needed in near term.
  - Recent increase in FII debt limits welcome and could be extended.
  - Corporate bond market progress: increased issuance and turnover; remaining needs include greater domestic institutional participation, improved liquidity, securitization, hedging instruments, and financial inclusion.
  - New Pension System will raise contractual savings over time.

Authorities’ actions
- Under 11th Plan private sector contributed about 30 percent of financing; under 12th Plan expected to rise to half.
- Focused efforts: expand domestic investor base, create market makers, progress on land acquisition measures, standardized PPP contracts for roads and ports, national PPP capacity building at state level.

---

### Staff Appraisal and Policy Priorities

Growth outlook and risks
- India recovered from the crisis and is performing well; inflation remains elevated.
- Risks broadly balanced; downside risks mainly from global economy.
- Capital inflows manageable so far but could complicate macro management if they surge or reverse.
- Medium-term outlook favorable, supported by high investment and productivity gains.

Policy priorities
- Promptly complete normalization of monetary and fiscal stance.
- Continue calibrated exit from expansionary crisis policies.
- Use overperformance in central government budget to reconstitute fiscal space faster and reduce overheating risk.
- Fiscal policy preferred for policy tightening given high government debt and large capital inflows.
- Monetary policy: further tightening required to lower inflation to meet RBI’s objective.
  - Further increases in policy rates needed to bring real short-term interest rates in line with historical norms.
  - In absence of rapid fiscal withdrawal, monetary policy bears greater burden to cool the economy.

---

### Selected Key Statistics (highlights preserved exactly as in source)

- Real GDP (at factor cost), y/y percent change (2006/07–2010/11 Prel./Proj.): 9.7, 9.2, 6.7, 7.4, 8.8.
- Wholesale prices (2004/05 weights), y/y percent change (average): 6.5, 4.8, 8.0, 3.6, 8.5.
- CPI-IW (y/y percent change, average): 6.7, 6.2, 9.1, 12.4, 10.8.
- Gross saving (% of GDP): 34.5, 36.4, 33.9, 32.1, 34.4.
- Gross investment (% of GDP): 35.5, 37.7, 36.2, 35.0, 37.7.
- Merchandise exports (US$ billions): 128.9, 166.2, 189.0, 182.2, 229.4.
- Merchandise imports (US$ billions): 190.7, 257.6, 307.7, 299.5, 380.6.
- Current account balance (US$ billions / percent of GDP): -9.6 (-1.0), -15.7 (-1.3), -28.7 (-2.4), -38.4 (-2.9), -49.9 (-3.3).
- Foreign direct investment, net (US$ billions): 7.7, 15.9, 17.5, 19.7, 23.6.
- Portfolio investment, net (US$ billions): 7.1, 27.4, -14.0, 32.4, 31.8.
- Gross reserves (in billions of U.S. dollars, end-period): 199.2, 309.7, 252.0, 279.1, 307.7.
- Central government deficit (percent of GDP): -4.3, -3.1, -7.5, -6.8, -6.6 (2006/07–2010/11).
- General government deficit (percent of GDP): -6.1, -4.4, -10.8, -10.4, -9.6 (2006/07–2010/11).
- General government debt (percent of GDP): 77.7, 75.0, 75.0, 76.8, 75.0 (2006/07–2010/11).
- Reserve money (levels, in billions of rupees, end-period): 33,101; 40,179; 47,948; 55,998; 56,362.
- Broad money (M3) twelve-month percent change (selected): 21.3, 21.4, 19.3, 16.8, 17.7.
- Private sector credit (12-month percent change): 25.7, 21.1, 16.9, 15.9, 20.2 (October 2010).
- Risk-weighted capital adequacy ratio (CAR): 12.3, 12.3, 13.0, 13.2, 13.6 (2005/06–2009/10).
- Gross nonperforming loans (percent of outstanding loans): 3.3, 2.5, 2.4, 2.3, 2.4 (2005/06–2009/10).
- Poverty headcount ratio at national poverty line (% of population): 27.5.
- Malnutrition prevalence, weight for age (% of children under 5): 43.5.
- Literacy rate, youth total (% ages 15–24): 61.9.
- Primary completion rate, total (% of relevant age group): 63.4.

---

*Source: IMF staff report excerpts and annexes (content unit: _cr1150).*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### Executive Summary

### Context: Rapid Growth and Elevated Inflation
- India’s real GDP in Q3 2010 grew at 8.9 percent y/y.
- Growth is projected at 8¾ percent in 2010/11; projected to revert to potential of about 8 percent in 2011/12.
- Headline inflation (WPI) is in the 8½ to 10½ percent range; WPI projected to decline to 6½ percent (March 2011) in staff projections (RBI projects 5.5 percent).
- CPI inflation (industrial workers, IW) is at 9.8 percent y/y; core inflation (WPI excluding food and energy) is at 7⅓ percent y/y.
- Key drivers: robust domestic demand, especially infrastructure investment; private consumption supported by a good harvest after drought and urbanization trends.
- Risks: downside from weaker global growth; upside from accommodative domestic policies maintained for too long; higher food and commodity prices; surging capital inflows that could complicate macroeconomic management.
- External: import growth has outpaced export expansion; capital inflows have offset the current account deficit; nominal effective exchange rate has appreciated only slightly; the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has barely intervened since November 2009.

### Policy Messages (High-Level)
- Prompt completion of normalization of the monetary and fiscal stance is warranted given robust growth and elevated inflation.
- Further monetary tightening is needed to meet the RBI’s inflation objectives and anchor inflation expectations.
- The government’s renewed commitment to fiscal consolidation is welcome; receipts overperformance this year offers an opportunity to reconstitute fiscal space faster.
- Spending reforms are critical to square consolidation objectives with the need for higher infrastructure and social spending; implementing tax reforms in the works could also contribute.
- Authorities should monitor the current account deficit closely given the increased potential impact of a reversal in capital inflows.
- India’s flexible exchange rate helps manage capital inflows; if inflows become excessive, a wide array of tools could be used.
- Efforts to facilitate infrastructure investment, especially measures to deepen the corporate bond market, are bearing fruit and will need to be sustained.

### A. Maintaining Macroeconomic Stability — Inflation Assessment and Monetary Policy
Findings
- Inflation has been high and generalized: WPI moved from -0.7 percent y/y in June 2009 to double digits in early 2010, declining to 8.6 percent y/y in October.
- Inflation persistence and inertia are significant; energy and food price shocks transmit rapidly to core inflation (Annex 1).
- Short-term real rates using market forecasts remain negative or barely positive and are some 75-100bp below levels implied by Taylor rule calculations (Annex 2).
- Financing conditions have hardened only marginally: rupee appreciation modest, strong capital market issuance, lending rates risen less than policy rates though transmission is ongoing.
- Output gap estimated closed; little slack in the economy; services prices and wages increasing rapidly; growing rural incomes and inelastic food supply risk renewed food price ascent.

Monetary policy actions and recommendations
- Since December 2009 the cash reserve ratio (CRR) has been raised by 100 basis points (bp) and the repo rate by 150 bp to 6.25 percent.
- Policy rates need to rise further to bring the real repo rate clearly into positive territory and in line with historical norms.
- The RBI has enhanced communications and provided forward guidance; recommendation that the RBI could publish one-year ahead inflation forecasts on a rolling basis to better anchor expectations.
- Over time, consider giving more weight to the CPI in monetary policy conduct, since CPI can diverge from WPI and has higher food weight affecting households’ consumption.
- Strengthen monetary transmission by reducing the width of the policy rate corridor and linking administered savings rates to market rates (issues under RBI study).

Authorities’ views (monetary)
- Authorities forecast slightly lower growth for 2010/11 (project 8.5 percent) but expect return to 9 percent quickly thereafter.
- Authorities expect WPI inflation to fall to 5.5 percent by March 2011 and attribute recent food price rises to structural factors concentrated in high-protein items.
- RBI signals low likelihood of immediate further rate actions but does not rule out further tightening; expects measures taken to push real interest rates into positive territory by March 2011.
- RBI considers the new WPI with wider coverage and updated weights as the most appropriate inflation measure for current policy purposes, while continuing to evaluate an array of inflation measures.

### Is Fiscal Consolidation Sufficient? — Fiscal Findings and Recommendations
Fiscal outcomes and projections
- 2009/10 fiscal deficit estimated at 10.4 percent of GDP; Center’s deficit at 6.8 percent of GDP.
- Budgeted Center deficit in 2010/11 was 5½ percent of GDP (Annex 3).
- Staff project the fiscal deficit at 5 percent of GDP (authorities’ definition) for 2010/11 due to divestment and higher-than-expected proceeds from 3G and wireless spectrum auctions.
- Excluding proceeds of asset sales and auctions (IMF definition), the deficit would reach 6½ percent of GDP.
- Under this outcome, only about a quarter of the combined fiscal impulse of the past two years would be withdrawn, making India’s consolidation one of the smallest among emerging markets despite high public debt.

Policy and reform progress
- First step in fuel price liberalization: gasoline prices liberalized; diesel prices promised to follow eventually.
- Direct Tax Code (DTC) proposal: retains some incentives while phasing out major profit-linked business exemptions and rationalizes deduction on savings to broaden tax base.
- Goods and Services Tax (GST) agreement has yet to be reached, delaying implementation of a modern indirect tax.

Recommendations to strengthen consolidation
- Save receipts overperformance in 2010/11 to reconstitute fiscal space; several spending measures are expiring this year (e.g., 6th Pay Commission arrears) offering consolidation opportunity.
- Fiscal consolidation preferred as macro tool to cool the economy given high government debt and large capital inflows.
- Substantial adjustment in current spending will be required to meet medium-term consolidation; scope for rationalization exists especially by cutting subsidies (fuel and fertilizers) and improving targeting.
- Effective use of the Unique Identification number (UID) should be exploited as soon as technically feasible to improve targeting.
- Greater use of performance-based incentives could improve social outcomes over the longer term.
- Building on budget reforms: Government Debt Report (GDR) strengthens transparency and the medium-term budget framework; authorities should detail plan quantifying how to fit rising capital and social spending into a declining budget envelope as a share of GDP.
- Amend the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act as the 13th Finance Commission recommended, including tightening escape clauses and introducing a fiscal oversight committee to minimize risk of reversals.

Medium-term fiscal targets and challenges
- 13th Finance Commission called for general government deficits to contract by 4 percentage points of GDP between 2009/10 and 2014/15 and public debt to fall from 79 to 68 percent of GDP.
- Government’s commitment to reduce debt to 65 percent of GDP is significant and envisaged revenue buoyancy is plausible.
- Savings assumed in the Government Debt Report on pensions, wages, subsidies, and interest payments could be difficult to achieve since these areas totaled only 8 percent of GDP in 2009/10.
- States are expected to meet the Finance Commission’s targets.

### Structural Change and Reform: the Infrastructure Challenge (summary points drawn from Executive Summary)
- Infrastructure investment has been an important growth driver and is expected to remain so.
- Measures to facilitate infrastructure investment, including efforts to deepen the corporate bond market, are producing results but need to be sustained to meet ambitious infrastructure goals.
- Other structural reforms—taxes, financial legislation, land acquisition—have been delayed and are important for enabling higher and more efficient investment.
- Achieving high and inclusive growth relies on expanding social programs and a big push for infrastructure development; weaknesses remain in poverty and malnutrition indicators despite progress toward Millennium Development Goals.

### Staff Appraisal (high-level)
- India’s economy recovered from the crisis and is performing well, but inflation remains elevated.
- Risks to growth are broadly balanced; downside risks mainly relate to the global economy.
- Capital inflows to date are manageable but could complicate macroeconomic management if they surge or reverse.
- The medium-term outlook is favorable, supported by high investment and productivity gains.
- Policy priority: complete normalization of monetary and fiscal stance promptly, pursue spending and tax reforms to reconcile consolidation with development needs, and continue structural reforms to sustain growth and manage inflationary pressures.

*Source: Executive Summary of the IMF staff report (content unit: _cr1150 - Executive Summary).*

### 23.      The authorities are confident of achieving this year’s consolidation target of

### _cr1150 - 23.      The authorities are confident of achieving this year’s consolidation target of

### Fiscal consolidation, fiscal stance, and debt
- Central government deficit consolidation target: 5.5 percent of GDP for this year.
- Authorities’ view: the size of supplementary demands for grants reflects larger-than-expected receipts; without higher revenue receipts, expenditure would have been kept to budgeted levels and the deficit target would still have been met.
- Additional spending prioritized for rural infrastructure; future spending will remain commensurate with resources.
- Consolidated general government deficit (authorities’ definition): estimated at 9.7 percent of GDP in 2009/10.
- Medium-term debt target in the GDR: lowered to 65 percent of GDP from the 68 percent recommended by the FC.
- Fiscal consolidation drivers identified: stronger growth boosting revenue; declines in shares of GDP of wages, pensions, interest, and subsidies.
- Streamlining expenditures highlighted:
  - Continued reduction of subsidies as a percentage of GDP expected.
  - Growth in social sector programs to be accommodated without derailing fiscal consolidation.
  - Introduction of UID expected to improve targeting of social programs and food program expansions.

### External balances, current account, and capital flows
- Current account deficit projections: 3.3 percent of GDP in 2010/11 and 3.5 percent next year.
- External vulnerability: external debt at only 20 percent of GDP.
- Current account deficit norm for India: estimated to be about 3.5 percent of GDP based on empirical relationships (footnote).
- Recent capital inflows: about 4 percent of GDP during the past year.
- Key risk: capital inflows exceeding absorptive capacity by a large margin could pressure exchange rate, asset prices, and monetary and credit aggregates.
- Exchange rate and policy guidance:
  - Exchange rate flexibility should remain the first line of defense.
  - Reserve accumulation and selective administrative measures may be appropriate if inflows surge.
  - IMF CGER: rupee valued broadly in line with fundamentals.
  - Real effective exchange rate (REER) has appreciated modestly over the last five years and is only 6 percent above its 10-year average.
  - Some appreciation deemed non-disruptive and would reduce incentives for additional inflows.
  - Tighter fiscal policy would reduce real appreciation.
- Measures to expand absorptive capacity and channel inflows productively:
  - Deepen domestic financial markets (increase share supply, e.g., increase minimum float requirement for state enterprises).
  - Further develop the corporate bond market.
  - Liberalize FDI to encourage longer-term, less volatile flows.
  - If appreciation is persistent and excessive and inflows too large and volatile, options include sterilized intervention, raising the CRR, and macroprudential measures.
  - Existing framework of capital controls (especially on debt) implies new controls should be a last resort; existing ECB regulations could be tightened if necessary.

### Financial markets, asset prices, and macroprudential policy
- Equity and real estate dynamics:
  - Equity market gathered momentum; equity prices have outperformed other BRICs with valuation ratios approaching historical highs.
  - Residential real estate recovered smartly; commercial and retail segments remain soft.
  - RBI tightened prudential norms on residential mortgages; more action could be warranted if asset markets become exuberant.
- Banking system resilience and risks:
  - Recovery improved credit profile of restructured assets.
  - Banks reduced exposure to unsecured retail lending.
  - Stress tests indicate that doubling of non-performing loans (NPLs) would leave banks above the regulatory minimum capital requirement (Annex 5).
  - NPLs have inched up; asset/liability mismatches increased as deposit growth lagged credit growth; infrastructure loans and residential mortgages expanded fastest.
  - Priorities: monitor asset quality, raise provisioning coverage, strengthen risk management and credit assessment capabilities, especially as prudential norms for infrastructure are eased.
- Regulatory and systemic issues:
  - Non-bank financial companies (NBFCs) expanding faster than banks; infrastructure NBFCs introduced.
  - Authorities’ steps: prevent regulatory arbitrage; new supervision framework for financial conglomerates; RBI’s Financial Stability Report; announced review of financial laws and the Financial Stability and Development Council (FSDC).
  - FSDC role: balance independence of regulators with need to resolve regulatory disputes and differences on financial reforms.
  - Encouragement to continue AML/CFT efforts, including implementing recommendations of FATF’s AML/CFT Mutual Evaluation Report.

### Authorities’ views on external balances and financial stability
- Current account deficit seen by authorities as transitory; could be somewhat higher this year and next than in 2009/10 if growth differentials persist.
- RBI’s medium-term objective: reduce the medium-term deficit to 3 percent of GDP; a deficit above 3 percent of GDP is deemed difficult to sustain over the medium term.
- Financing focus: ensure larger short-term deficits are financed mainly by long-term and stable capital inflows.
- Capital inflows: distinction made between positive role for growth and short-term risks from large, volatile inflows; current inflows considered within absorptive capacity.
- Policy stance on capital inflows: continue macroprudential tools; no planned reversal of liberalized capital inflow policy unless flows exceed current levels by a large margin.
- Financial system indicators cited:
  - Capital adequacy exceeds 14 percent with tier one at 10 percent.
  - Increased provisioning cover.
  - RBI does not see systemic risks from a possible increase in NPLs of microfinance institutions.
  - Liquidity risk manageable given SLR, CRR, and retail-deposit-centered business model.
  - New RBI guidelines on asset liability management issued.
  - Strengthening macro-prudential surveillance, minimizing regulatory arbitrage, improving information systems to monitor interconnectedness, and strengthening supervision of non-bank institutions are underway.
  - FSDC expected to contribute importantly.

### Infrastructure investment, bottlenecks, and reforms
- Authorities’ objective: infrastructure and human capital investment to reach 9-10 percent GDP growth over the medium term.
- Staff estimate of potential growth: 7½-8½ percent.
- Infrastructure investment plans and targets:
  - 11th Plan (2007/08 to 2011/12) Mid-Term Appraisal: aggregate targets exceeded in 2007/08 and 2008/09 due to telecoms and pipelines; roads, railways, and ports lagged.
  - Five-year target to 2011/12: around US$500 billion (MTA).
  - 12th Plan (2012/13-2016/17) mooted figure: US$1 trillion would boost infrastructure investment to 9 percent of GDP and aim for private participation to rise to half the total.
- Roadblocks to infrastructure targets: availability of finance/financing instruments, land acquisition, multiple clearances, capacity constraints, governance issues, and sector-specific concerns.
- Lessons from other EMs and financing mix:
  - Infrastructure booms in most EMs are financed publicly; private participation rises with financial sophistication.
  - Korea and Brazil relied on budgetary resources and public development banks; China used local government land premia; Chile intermediated foreign savings through open business environment and developed financial markets.
- India’s savings and financing needs:
  - Favorable demographics should ensure sufficient domestic savings over medium term, but foreign savings need to rise in near term.
  - Private savings likely to continue rising gradually; public savings expected to rise.
  - Meeting public sector infrastructure goals while following fiscal consolidation requires strict containment of unproductive spending.
  - Near-term domestic savings may be insufficient, necessitating a transitory widening of the current account deficit.
  - Recent increase in foreign institutional investors (FII) debt limits is welcome and could be further extended as limits approach full utilization.
- Corporate bond market and financial intermediation:
  - Progress: increased issuance and turnover; some takeout finance transactions; foreign investors allowed to provide credit enhancements.
  - Remaining needs: much greater participation by domestic institutional investors; change investment allocations; reduce public sector borrowing requirement; maintain credit enhancements and investor protection; boost bond market liquidity; develop securitization and hedging instruments; financial inclusion to intermediate more savings.
  - New Pension System will raise contractual savings, but effects will take time.
- Governance and transparency:
  - Large infrastructure projects can create opportunities for rent-seeking; mitigate via robust frameworks, transparency, strengthened accountability, and increased competition.
- Authorities’ actions and views:
  - Under the 11th Plan private sector contributed about 30 percent of financing so far; under the 12th Plan private participation expected to rise to half.
  - Authorities expect a financing shortfall unless more long-term debt sources can be mobilized.
  - Focused efforts to remove bottlenecks to corporate debt market development: expand domestic investor base (retail and banks), create a robust system of market makers.
  - Progress on land acquisition: considering ways to expedite implementation while minimizing displacements and improving compensation assessments.
  - Speeding up approvals: introducing standardized PPP contracts for roads and ports and a national program for capacity building in PPP formulation at the state level.

### Staff appraisal and policy priorities
- Growth outlook:
  - India’s growth remains among the strongest in the world; medium-term prospects favorable.
  - Economy expected to grow above trend this year and continue to expand rapidly over the medium term, supported by high investment and productivity gains.
  - Social indicators improving; risks to growth broadly balanced.
- Policy recommendations and priorities:
  - Promptly complete normalization of monetary and fiscal stance given robust growth and elevated inflation.
  - Continued calibrated exit from expansionary crisis policies.
  - Overperformance in this year's central government budget provides opportunity to reconstitute fiscal space faster and reduce overheating risk.
  - Fiscal policy is the preferred focus for policy tightening given high government debt and large capital inflows.
  - Monetary policy: lower inflation to meet RBI’s objective requires further monetary tightening.
    - RBI has raised policy rates and the CRR over the last year; transmission to long-term rates is still taking place.
    - Further increases in policy rates are needed to bring real short-term interest rates in line with historical norms.
    - India’s controls on debt flows expected to dampen effect of wider interest rate differentials on capital inflows.
  - In absence of more rapid withdrawal of fiscal stimulus, monetary policy bears a greater burden to cool the economy and counter perceptions that inflation has shifted to a higher level.

*Source: _cr1150 - 23.      The authorities are confident of achieving this year’s consolidation target of*

### 48.      The government’s renewed commitment to fiscal consolidation is welcome, but

### The government’s renewed commitment to fiscal consolidation is welcome, but

### Fiscal consolidation and spending reforms
- The government has laid out an ambitious roadmap to reduce public debt and deficits.
- High growth is expected to contribute toward this goal, but the need to raise public investment, especially in infrastructure, and expand social programs will make this challenging.
- With the tax reforms designed to be revenue neutral, subsidy reform will have to continue, especially by liberalizing diesel and fertilizer prices, and spending efficiency will have to improve.
- Strengthening budget frameworks along the FC's recommendations will be important to minimize the risk of reversals in fiscal consolidation.

### Current account and capital flows
- The authorities are rightly monitoring the current account deficit.
- The current account deficit has been financed mainly by FDI and equity flows and is expected to narrow over the medium term as exports expand on the back of productivity gains.
- However, the potential impact of a reversal in capital inflows has risen, requiring vigilance.

### Exchange rate policy and absorptive capacity
- India's flexible exchange rate serves the country well in managing capital inflows.
- So far, the rupee has appreciated only modestly and is deemed to be broadly in line with fundamentals.
- Given yield and growth differentials, capital inflows could exceed India’s absorptive capacity by a large margin.
- If inflows exceed absorptive capacity, exchange rate appreciation should remain the first line of defense.
- Were appreciation to become too large, sterilized intervention or macroprudential measures could also be taken.
- Over time, deepening the corporate bond market, increasing the supply of shares, and further liberalizing FDI would increase absorptive capacity and the share of relatively stable capital inflows.

### Financial sector resilience and supervision
- Financial policies and reforms are balancing financial stability considerations with the need to finance investment and growth.
- Although the financial sector has been resilient and is benefiting from robust growth, the authorities' vigilance on asset quality and liquidity risk is appropriate.
- Deeper interconnectedness, increasing sophistication of the Indian financial system, as well as the measures taken to promote infrastructure financing, will continue to put a premium on integrated supervision.

### Infrastructure investment and enabling reforms
- Efforts to facilitate infrastructure investment are bearing fruit and will need to be sustained to meet the authorities' ambitious goals.
- Domestic savings are expected to rise due to India’s favorable demographics and rapid growth, but greater recourse to foreign savings is also likely needed in the near term.
- More efficient intermediation of domestic savings will require continued financial reforms, chief among these a vibrant corporate bond market, which has shown considerable development.
- Lowering the costs of doing business—especially by streamlining land acquisition, addressing governance issues, and reducing red tape—is critical to boost private sector participation in infrastructure.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpts (paragraphs 48–52).*

### 53.      It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation take place on the

### _cr1150 - 53.      It is recommended that the next Article IV consultation take place on the

### Conjunctural Developments
- GDP growth has relied mainly on domestic demand; contributions to real GDP growth shown for Priv. Consumption, Net Exports, Investment, Gov. Consumption.
- Consumer durables and cement production suggest buoyant domestic demand; indicators: IP: Consumer durables (y/y percent change) and Cement consumption (millions of tons, 3mma).
- Corporate performance strengthened: Gross profit/sales and After tax profit/sales improved; Interest coverage (ratio) increased.
- High-frequency indicators point to robust growth going forward: Manufacturing PMI and Service PMI series.
- Inflationary pressures have risen significantly: WPI and CPI-IW shown as y/y percent change; WPI, y/y (RHS) and CPI-IW, y/y (RHS).

### External Developments
- Current account and trade:
  - Current account balance and Trade balance series show widening deficits as domestic demand boosted imports.
  - Exports and non-oil imports have accelerated; merchandise exports and imports data available in Tables 2–3.
- Capital flows:
  - FDI inflows still cover nearly half of the current account deficit (FDI/CA (RHS)).
  - Portfolio inflows have picked up substantially (net FII flows and ECBs series).
  - External Commercial Borrowing and FII flows (3mma; in billions of US$) tracked.
- Exchange rate and reserves:
  - With no RBI intervention until September, the rupee appreciated but remained lower than pre-crisis levels; Rupee/US$ (inverted, RHS) and Intervention (Bill. US$) series shown.
  - Foreign exchange reserves (Table 3 memorandum): Foreign exchange reserves 199.2, 309.7, 252.0, 279.1, 307.7 (in billions of U.S. dollars, end-period).

### Monetary and Financing Conditions
- Policy rates and money market:
  - Call money rate increased by more than policy rates and currently hovers above the repo.
  - Repo, Reverse repo, Call rate series plotted; Monetary settings described as remaining accommodative.
- Credit and liquidity:
  - Credit growth picked up even as interest rates rose: Non-food credit growth (y/y, RHS) and 3-mo Tbill rate.
  - Broad money (M3) growth (Table 4): Twelve-month percent change M3 series 21.3, 21.4, 19.3, 16.8, 17.7.
- Financial conditions:
  - Monetary Conditions Index (MCI) and Financial Conditions Index (FCI) presented; yield curve flattened as short-term rates rose.
  - Domestic issuance and capital inflows have been strong (net FII, ECBs, and FDI; Domestic issuance in billions of U.S. dollars).

### Fiscal Indicators and Public Debt
- Government aims to reduce debt over the medium term while raising capital spending.
- Challenge: reversing large deficits of past two years and returning to 2002/03–2007/08 consolidation path; controlling current spending will be key.
- Central and general government fiscal outcomes (Table 5 and Table 6):
  - Overall balance (IMF definition), percent of GDP: -4.3, -3.1, -7.5, -6.8, -6.6 (2006/07–2010/11).
  - Central government deficit (percent of GDP): -4.3, -3.1, -7.5, -6.8, -6.6 (2006/07–2010/11).
  - General government debt (percent of GDP): 77.7, 75.0, 75.0, 76.8, 75.0 (2006/07–2010/11).
- Projections and consolidation path (Figure/Table): Consolidation Path Envisaged by 13th Finance Commission; projections of Fiscal Deficit, Public Debt, Capital Expenditure across 2009/10–2014/15.

### Millennium Development Goals (Table 1 excerpts)
- Poverty and nutrition:
  - Poverty headcount ratio at national poverty line (% of population): 27.5.
  - Malnutrition prevalence, weight for age (% of children under 5): 43.5.
- Education and gender:
  - Literacy rate, youth total (% ages 15–24): 61.9.
  - Primary completion rate, total (% of relevant age group): 63.4; other entries: 84.2, 86.1.
  - Ratio of girls to boys in primary and secondary education (%) entries include 70.0, 90.0, 90.0, 92.2.
  - Proportion of seats held by women in national parliament (%): 5.0, 9.0, 8.3, 9.1, 10.7.
- Health:
  - Immunization, measles (% of children ages 12–23 months): 56.0, 61.0, 64.0, 70.0.
  - Mortality rate, infant (per 1,000 live births): 82.7, ..., 57.8, 52.3.
  - Mortality rate, under-5 (per 1,000): 116.4, ..., 77.4, 68.8.
- Environment and infrastructure:
  - CO2 emissions (metric tons per capita): 0.8, 1.3.
  - Improved sanitation facilities (% of population with access): 14.0, ..., 28.0.
  - Improved water source (% of population with access): 71.0, ..., 89.0.
- General indicators:
  - GNI per capita, Atlas method (current US$): 370.0, 630.0, 820.0, 1,040.0.
  - Population, total (millions): 849.5, 1,079.7, 1,109.8, 1,140.0.
  - Trade (% of GDP): 15.7, 37.9, 47.4, 50.7.

### Selected Economic Indicators (Table 2 highlights)
- Growth and prices:
  - Real GDP (at factor cost), y/y percent change: 9.7, 9.2, 6.7, 7.4, 8.8 (2006/07–2010/11 Prel./Proj.).
  - Industrial production: 11.5, 8.5, 6.7, 10.5, ...
  - Wholesale prices (2004/05 weights), y/y percent change (average): 6.5, 4.8, 8.0, 3.6, 8.5.
  - Consumer prices - industrial workers (2001 weights), y/y percent change (average): 6.7, 6.2, 9.1, 12.4, 10.8.
- Saving and investment (% of GDP):
  - Gross saving: 34.5, 36.4, 33.9, 32.1, 34.4.
  - Gross investment: 35.5, 37.7, 36.2, 35.0, 37.7.
- External trade and BOP:
  - Merchandise exports (US$ billions): 128.9, 166.2, 189.0, 182.2, 229.4.
  - Merchandise imports (US$ billions): 190.7, 257.6, 307.7, 299.5, 380.6.
  - Current account balance (US$ billions): -9.6, -15.7, -28.7, -38.4, -49.9 (percent of GDP: -1.0, -1.3, -2.4, -2.9, -3.3).
  - Foreign direct investment, net (US$ billions): 7.7, 15.9, 17.5, 19.7, 23.6.
  - Portfolio investment, net (equity and debt) (US$ billions): 7.1, 27.4, -14.0, 32.4, 31.8.
  - Gross reserves (in billions of U.S. dollars, end-period): 199.2, 309.7, 252.0, 279.1, 307.7.

### Balance of Payments (Table 3 key numbers)
- Current account balance (US$ billions): -9.6, -15.7, -28.7, -38.4, -49.9 (2006/07–2010/11).
- Merchandise trade balance (US$ billions): -61.8, -91.5, -118.7, -117.3, -151.2.
- Oil imports (US$ billions): 56.9, 79.7, 93.7, 87.1, 106.6.
- Non-oil imports (US$ billions): 133.7, 177.9, 214.0, 212.4, 274.0.
- Non-factor services balance receipts and payments: Receipts 73.8, 90.3, 101.7, 93.8, 112.4; Payments 44.3, 51.5, 52.0, 59.6, 66.0.
- Capital account and financing:
  - Capital account balance: 45.2, 106.6, 7.2, 53.6, 78.5.
  - Direct investment, net: 7.7, 15.9, 17.5, 19.7, 23.6.
  - Portfolio investment, net: 7.1, 27.4, -14.0, 32.4, 31.8.
  - Overall balance (US$ billions): 36.6, 92.2, -20.1, 13.4, 28.6.
- Increase in gross reserve stock (including valuation changes): -47.6, -110.5, 57.7, -27.1, -28.6.

### Reserve Money and Monetary Survey (Table 4 selected figures)
- Reserve money (levels, in billions of rupees, end-period): 33,101; 40,179; 47,948; 55,998; 56,362; series across months shown (reserve money monthly entries e.g., 7,089, 9,283, 9,880, 11,557, 11,275, 11,594, 11,708, 11,708).
- Broad money (M3) (levels): 33,101; 40,179; 47,948; 55,998; 56,362; 56,857; 56,859; 58,322.
- Net foreign assets of RBI (levels): 9,132; 12,951; 13,522; 12,815; 12,681; 13,004; 12,884; 13,338.
- Net domestic assets and Domestic credit series presented; Credit to commercial sector and Net credit to government detailed in levels and percent contributions.

### Central Government Operations (Table 5 highlights)
- Total revenue and grants (in billions of rupees): 4,500; 5,919; 5,576; 5,998; 7,407.
  - Net tax revenue: 3,532; 4,413; 4,451; 4,683; 6,075.
  - Nontax revenue: 943; 1,478; 1,097; 1,284; 1,311.
- Total expenditure and net lending (in billions of rupees): 5,926; 7,188; 8,946; 10,138; 12,277.
  - Current expenditure: 5,302; 6,101; 8,112; 9,288; 10,924.
  - Capital expenditure and net lending: 624; 1,088; 835; 850; 1,353.
- Overall balance:
  - Authorities' definition (in billions of rupees): -1,495; -1,320; -3,431; -3,923; -3,719.
  - IMF definition (in billions of rupees): -1,829; -1,550; -4,196; -4,243; -4,870.
- Financing (in billions of rupees): 1,426; 1,269; 3,370; 4,140; 4,870.
  - External (net): 859; 311; 0; 165; 224.5.
  - Domestic (net): 1,341; 1,176; 3,260; 3,975; 4,646.

### General Government Operations and Projections (Table 6 & Table 7)
- Consolidated general government (in billions of rupees and percent of GDP) data provided with projections to 2014/15.
- Key macro projections (Table 7):
  - Real GDP growth projections: 8.1, 8.1, 8.1, 8.1 for 2011/12–2014/15.
  - Wholesale prices (1993/94 weights) projections: 5.0, 4.0, 4.0, 4.0.
  - Consumer prices projections: 6.9, 5.0, 4.0, 4.0.
  - General government balance (percent of GDP) projections: -9.0, -8.1, -7.4, -6.9 for 2011/12–2014/15.
  - General government debt (percent of GDP) projections: 74.9, 74.4, 73.1, 71.6 for 2011/12–2014/15.

### Indicators of External Vulnerability (Table 8)
- Financial and external indicators (2006/07–2010/11):
  - General government debt (percent of GDP): 77.7, 75.0, 75.0, 76.8, 75.0.
  - Broad money (12-month percent change): 21.3, 21.4, 19.3, 16.8, 17.7 (October 2010).
  - Private sector credit (12-month percent change): 25.7, 21.1, 16.9, 15.9, 20.2 (October 2010).
  - 91 day T-bill yield (end-period): 8.0, 7.2, 5.0, 4.4, 6.9 (November 2010).
  - Foreign currency reserves (billions of US$): 199.2, 309.7, 252.0, 279.1, 294.0 (November 2010).
  - Official reserves (months of imports): 7.7, 10.3, 8.4, 7.5, 7.3 (Projection).
  - Total short-term external debt to reserves (percent): 17.6, 27.2, 35.9, 37.6, 40.6 (Projection).
  - Current account balance (percent of GDP): -1.0, -1.3, -2.4, -2.9, -3.3 (Projection).

### Indicators of Financial System Soundness (Table 9)
- Capital adequacy and asset quality (2005/06–2009/10):
  - Risk-weighted capital adequacy ratio (CAR): 12.3, 12.3, 13.0, 13.2, 13.6.
  - Net nonperforming loans (percent of outstanding net loans): 1.2, 1.0, 1.1, 1.1, 1.1.
  - Gross nonperforming loans (percent of outstanding loans): 3.3, 2.5, 2.4, 2.3, 2.4.
  - Net profit of commercial banks (percent of total assets): 0.9, 0.9, 1.0, 1.0, 0.9.
- Balance sheet structure:
  - Loan/deposit ratio: 70.1, 73.5, 74.6, 73.9, 73.6.
  - Investment in government securities/deposit ratio: 31.9, 28.0, 27.9, 28.7, 28.8.
  - Lending to sensitive sectors (percent of loans and advances), e.g., Real estate: 17.2, 18.8, 18.4, 17.5, 16.6.

### Additional Tables and Annex
- Extensive tables provide time series and projections for macroeconomic framework (Table 7), indicators of external vulnerability (Table 8), and financial system soundness (Table 9).
- Annex 1: INFLATION DYNAMICS IN INDIA indicated as present.

*Source: IMF staff calculations and country authorities as presented in the provided content.*

### Introduction

### Introduction

### Recent inflation trends
- Since 2007, India’s inflation has been trending upwards.
- During 2000-09, India’s consumer price inflation (CPI industrial workers, IW) averaged 5½ percent, but 9.5 percent in 2008-09.
- Comparative inflation in 2008-09: 2 percent in China, 7 percent in Brazil, and 14 percent in Russia.

### Inflation volatility and drivers
- Volatility of headline (WPI) inflation increased since 2007:
  - 12-month rolling standard deviation increased twofold, from 2 percent before 2005 to an average of 4 percent in 2008-09.
- Headline inflation is significantly correlated with international commodity prices:
  - Energy (fuel) component of the WPI comoves strongly with international oil prices; comovement stronger when international oil prices are lagged by three months.
  - Domestic energy component of the WPI is significantly correlated with domestic core inflation.
  - Correlation between international food prices and domestic food prices is much smaller and more volatile, largely due to barriers to trade, price controls, and other public policies.

### New Keynesian Phillips Curve (NKPC) estimation for India
- Framework and specification:
  - NKPC: Πt = λmct + βEtΠt+1, where Πt = pt – pt-1, λ = (1 – θ)(1 – βθ)/θ.
  - Augmented NKPC with lagged inflation: Πt = λmct + γfEtΠt+1 + γbΠt-1.
- Empirical implementation:
  - Proxy for marginal costs: output gap (used due to data availability).
  - Expected inflation: estimated by GMM, instrumenting expected inflation with past inflation and other lagged regressors.
  - Open-economy augmentation: include measures of import prices / international commodity prices. Three measures considered (estimates robust across measures):
    1. Index of oil prices in domestic currency.
    2. Index of fuel and non-fuel commodity prices in domestic currency.
    3. Same index as (2) relative to domestic CPI for industrial workers (IW).
- Data and sample:
  - Fit to headline (WPI) inflation and core (WPI excluding food and energy) inflation.
  - Inflation measure: quarter-on-quarter annualized change; data seasonally adjusted.
  - Sample: 1996-Q2 to 2010-Q1.
  - Baseline: core inflation with output gap from non-agriculture GDP at factor costs.
- Main empirical findings from NKPC estimates (core inflation baseline):
  - Inflation inertia is significant: coefficient of lagged inflation generally large and statistically significant; estimated effect typically exceeds 0.70.
  - Expected inflation effect smaller than past inflation: a one percentage point increase in expected inflation leads to 0.2 to 0.4 percentage point increase in inflation depending on specification.
  - Output gap effect economically significant and ranges between 0.4-0.8 across specifications; statistical significance varies by inflation and output gap measures.
  - International commodity prices are an important cost-push factor, exerting effects on inflation beyond expectations and past inflation.
  - Domestic food prices act as a cost-push factor:
    - A one percentage point increase in food inflation translates into 0.15 percentage point increase in core inflation (not statistically significant in all specifications, but improves model fit).
    - Long-term response of core inflation to a one percentage point increase in food inflation is in the order of 0.4 percentage points.
  - Example table (Open-economy NKPC with lagged core inflation) — selected reported estimates:
    - Expected inflation (γf): 0.24** (t-statistic 2.11)
    - Output gap (λ): 0.89** (t-statistic 2.58)
    - Relative commodity price index: 0.03** (t-statistic 3.09)
    - Domestic food inflation: 0.14 (t-statistic 1.41)
    - Lagged inflation (γb): 0.76** (t-statistic 6.57)
    - J-statistic = 0.18 (p-value=0.46), adjusted R-square = 0.42
  - Notes: sample period 1996-Q2–2010-Q1; (*) and (**) denote significance at 10 and 5 percent; coefficients on lagged and forward inflation constrained to add up to one.
- Model fit:
  - In-sample fit of the open-economy NKPC is good and captures turning points in core inflation reasonably well.
  - Model under-predicts inflation in late 2009 and early 2010.
  - Fit is marginally worse without the commodity price measure.

### Food prices, transmission, and normative implications
- Food price shocks:
  - Volatility of food price shocks is higher; large upward shocks are more common and persistent.
  - Transmission from food to nonfood prices is stronger in India than in rich countries.
  - Between September 2008 and July 2010, rapid food price rises (poor monsoon, rising rural incomes) greatly affected headline inflation; if transmission had followed U.S. patterns, overall inflation would have been only 3 percent during this period.
- Policy implications:
  - When food is a major part of the consumption basket and financial frictions exist (e.g., many credit-constrained households), a welfare-maximizing central bank should target headline CPI inflation while assigning some weight to the output gap (Prasad and Anand, 2010).
  - This is relevant for India given the high share of food expenditure in total spending and limited ability to smooth consumption.

### Monetary policy stance, output gap, and inflation expectations
- RBI policy actions since late 2009:
  - Withdrawing monetary accommodation: raised Statutory Liquidity Requirement to 25 percent (pre-crisis level); eliminated/reduced special liquidity facilities.
  - Since beginning of 2010: raised repo (reverse repo) policy rate by 150 (200) basis points and cash reserve ratio (CRR) by 100 basis points.
  - Allowed banks to use up to 2 percent of their government securities portfolio to borrow from special liquidity adjustment facility windows (effectively lowering the SLR by 2 percentage points).
  - Provided forward guidance, including signaling a pausing of interest rate hikes in the immediate future.
- Short-term money market and real rates:
  - Short-term money market rates increased more than policy rates as interbank liquidity became scarcer.
  - Despite rate hikes, monetary conditions remain accommodative:
    - RBI had previously cut reverse repo by 275 basis points and repo by 425 basis points during the crisis and has only partially reversed those cuts.
    - Latest headline inflation at 8.6 percent y/y; the real call money rate is still at -2.3 percent, between 350-500 basis points below its historical average (about 1½ percent).
    - Short-term rates projected to remain negative in real terms for the rest of the fiscal year, as inflation projected to decline gradually to around 6.5 percent y/y by March 2011 and 6 percent (average) in 2011/12. Using RBI’s inflation projection of 5.5 percent for March 2011 would leave the real repo rate at 0.75 percent.
- Taylor-rule benchmarks and stance:
  - Taylor rule calculations (data 1996-2010) suggest short-term interest rate is below neutral/historical benchmarks accounting for output gap and inflation.
  - Two Taylor rules used:
    1. Calibrated Taylor rule (responses to inflation gap and output gap: 1.5 and 0.5; includes inertia).
    2. Estimated rule with India data (responses 0.7 and 1.6; higher inertia).
  - Calibrated rule: call money rate some 100 basis points below rule-implied level; estimated rule: discrepancy 75 basis points.
- Inflation expectations:
  - One-year ahead expected inflation from professional forecasters increased by a full percentage point between March 2009 and March 2010.
  - Since early 2010, distribution of expected inflation from Consensus Forecasts shifted right and became more fat-tailed, indicating increased uncertainty.
  - Ten-year ahead expected inflation measures (CPI and WPI) from RBI survey increased by about 1 percentage point to 5.5-6.5 percent (annual inflation), above RBI’s medium-term objective of 4-4.5 percent.
- Output gap and inflation correlation:
  - Rapid rebound from crisis virtually eliminated output gap between actual and potential GDP.
  - All measures point to a closed output gap; measure excluding agriculture consistent with this.
  - Correlations between output gap and inflation (sequential terms, sample 1996-Q2–2010-Q1):
    - 0.15 percent for WPI inflation.
    - 0.22 percent for core inflation (WPI excluding food and energy).
    - Correlation highest (0.26) between GDP at factor costs excluding agriculture and core inflation.
  - Phillips curve estimates indicate a one percentage point increase in the output gap could increase inflation by 0.8 percentage points.
- Exchange rate:
  - In nominal effective terms the rupee has appreciated by 4 percent since end-2009.

### Conclusions (summary of main findings)
- India’s inflation has increased recently, with both demand and supply factors playing important roles.
- Unlike food prices, which are driven by domestic factors, the comovement between the energy component of headline inflation and lagged international prices is strong. Domestic energy inflation is highly correlated with headline inflation.
- Phillips curve estimates suggest the backward-looking component of inflation expectations is large, but the output gap and (forward looking) expected inflation are also important.
- International commodity prices help deliver a good fit, but their effect on core and headline inflation operates with long lags.
- Inclusion of domestic food prices as a second cost-push factor improves in-sample fit of the model.
- In poorer countries, food prices are more volatile and spill over onto nonfood prices more than in richer countries.

*Prepared by Roberto Guimarães; source: IMF staff estimates and annex material in the provided content.*

### References

### _cr1150 - References

### Background
- After two years of very high deficits, the 2010/11 budget was intended to begin the process of fiscal consolidation.
- General government deficits in 2008/09 and 2009/10 exceeded ten percent of GDP; central government deficits exceeded 6¾ percent of GDP.
- The 2010/11 budget of the Center began consolidation recommended by the 13th Finance Commission (FC) and reiterated by the November 2010 Government Debt Report.
- State government budgets were expected to improve as the recovery came underway.
- Revenues have rebounded strongly, but rising expenditures necessitated supplementary budgets. The August and November supplementary demands for grants amounted to 1.3 percent of GDP.
- Revenue developments:
  - Personal income tax collections are on track to exceed their 2007/08 peak as a share of GDP despite rate reductions.
  - Revival of corporate profits and foreign trade buoyed corporate income taxes and customs revenue.
  - Partial rollback of the excise tax cut taken during the crisis supported indirect tax revenues.
- Current expenditure:
  - Non-interest current expenditure was slated to grow by 3.4 y/y percent in 2010/11, but in the first half of the year rose by 14.7 percent.
- Subsidies:
  - Subsidies reached 2.3 percent of GDP in 2008/09; budgeted to fall to 1.6 percent in 2010/11 with only a nominal amount for fuel subsidies, but actual subsidies in 2010/11 are still expected to be around 2 percent of GDP.
- Capital spending:
  - Nonmilitary capital spending was budgeted to rise by 18 percent; its growth so far exceeds this rate.
- One-off proceeds:
  - 3G auction raised twice its expected target of Rs 350 billion.
  - Government budgeted proceeds from divestment of shares in public enterprises of Rs 400 billion for 2010/11, and this target is likely to be easily met.
  - Note: The Indian government classifies proceeds from wireless and broadband auction licenses and proceeds from share sales as revenue while IMF guidelines call for classification as financing.
- State budgets:
  - 2009/10 deficit estimated at 3.7 percent of GDP should improve to around 3.3 percent of GDP in 2010/11.
- IMF staff forecasts place the deficit above the budgeted target; authorities’ methodology includes proceeds of asset sales as revenue, altering comparability.

### Tax Reforms
- GST (Goods and Services Tax) proposal (aimed for April 2012 implementation):
  - Will be implemented as a value-added tax to replace existing state- and national-level excise, sales and value added taxes and move from origin- to destination-based taxation.
  - Proposed central government rates: goods at 10 percent, services at 8 percent, and essential items at 6 percent; recommendation that states add identical rates.
  - Within three years these rates are expected to converge to 8 percent.
  - Entire consumption base taxed by bringing imports into the base while excluding exports.
  - Businesses with annual sales below Rs 1 million will be exempt.
  - Taxation of fuels and alcohol will remain outside the GST for the time being.
- Revenue neutrality and expected effects:
  - Reform is designed to be revenue neutral, but simplification relative to current system should increase revenues in the long run via increased compliance and possible positive impact on growth.
  - FC recommended compensating states that would collect less under the GST until 2014/15.
- Approval challenges:
  - Changing allocation of taxation responsibilities requires constitutional amendment needing a qualified supermajority in Parliament and approval by a majority of the states.
  - Parliamentary opposition and many state legislatures have raised objections; prospects for passage are not clear.
- Direct Tax Code (DTC) expected to be passed soon; intended to modernize income and corporate tax framework (last updated 1961) and expected to come into effect on April 1, 2012.
  - Corporate Income Tax:
    - Corporate income tax rate maintained at 30 percent despite initial proposals to reduce rate to 25 percent; elimination of various cesses and surcharges will reduce the effective rate.
    - Residence of corporations to be determined by place of “effective management.”
    - Corporate book profits will be taxed rather than corporate assets or realized profits.
  - Personal Income Tax:
    - Capital gains will now be taxed as income; foreign investors without labor income will be taxed at the equivalent marginal rate on earnings, with a deduction for assets held more than one year.
    - Capital gains taxes will not apply to equity shares held for more than one year.
    - Retirement and certain other long-term savings will be taxed neither when earned nor when withdrawn; reinvested capital gains will also not be taxed.
    - Narrower tax brackets included in the 2010/11 budget have been slightly modified, further lowering marginal tax rates on some income ranges.

### Inclusive Growth and Fiscal Costs
- Government supports a broad range of social programs due to relatively low social indicators despite rapid growth.
- Spending composition and social indicators:
  - Subsidies (primarily fuels and fertilizers, also food) account for a share of general government spending comparable to health and rural development combined.
  - Table 1 (selected indicators, most recent available since 2005) highlights India:
    - Percentage of population earning below $1 (PPP) per day: 41.6
    - Ratio of Employment to Population: 55.6
    - Percentage of Population Undernourished: 22.0
    - Net Enrollment in Primary Education (Girls): 93.6
    - Infant Mortality per 1000 Live Births: 52.0
  - Average: selected Asia indicators shown for comparison.
- Social program expansions announced; reconciling expansion with commitment to reduce overall spending is a challenge.
- NREG (National Rural Employment Guarantee Act):
  - Enacted February 2006, fully implemented across rural India in 2008, provides 100 days of work to any rural household that requests it.
  - 2010/11 program budget: Rs 401 billion (0.5 percent of GDP).
  - Wages averaged around Rs 90 per day in 2009/10; recommendation earlier in year to raise wages to Rs 100 a day or link to states’ minimum wages.
  - In 2009/10, 53 million households requested employment under the scheme.
  - Program seen as a safety net rather than employment replacement.
- NREGA uneven implementation and expansion cost:
  - In five states with largest percentage enrollment, program enrolled around 85 percent of working age poor persons; in the rest of the country only 21 percent.
  - Expanding NREGA in low-penetration states to levels of most-implemented states would cost around 0.8 percent of GDP, more than doubling current program cost.
  - Tying wage rates to minimum wages could raise costs.
- Right to Education Act (RTE):
  - Law aims universal high quality education for children up to age 14; early expenditures likely under Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan (SSA).
  - Implementation shared between central government and states.
  - States with highest 2007 literacy rates (Goa, Himachal Pradesh, Kerala, Mizoram, Tripura) averaged 95 percent and budgeted Rs 6100 per child on education in 2009/10; the rest of states averaged Rs 4200 per child.
  - Raising per-child expenditures for 23 states with lowest literacy rates to same level as highest literacy states would entail additional costs of 0.9 percent of GDP.
- Food Security Act (FSA):
  - No timetable yet; main point to provide 35 kg of rice or wheat each month to eligible households at subsidized cost of Rs 3 a kilo.
  - Recent increase in poverty line raised estimate of poor households from 64 to 85 million.
  - Broader criteria discussed, including proposals for universal subsidized food grains in poorer parts of country.
- Efficiency and leakages:
  - Leakages from social programs often large; Comptroller General reports noted discrepancies and lack of transparency in NREG and national food distribution.
  - One study finds two-thirds of publicly distributed wheat does not reach eligible persons, with large state variation.
  - National Population Register and introduction of Unique Identification number (UID) expected to help reduce leakages and increase program efficiency.

### Outlook for Medium-Term Consolidation
- 13th Finance Commission (FC) report focused on fiscal consolidation and recommended other fiscal reforms:
  - For the first time, a public sector debt target established at 68 percent of GDP (45 percent for the central government).
  - Path of fiscal consolidation presented for central and general governments (Table 2):
    - Fiscal Deficit (General Government) 2009/10–2014/15 (authorities' definition):
      - 2009/10: 9.6
      - 2010/11: 8.3
      - 2011/12: 7.3
      - 2012/13: 6.7
      - 2013/15: 5.4
      - 2014/15: 5.4
    - Central Government fiscal deficit (percent of GDP):
      - 2009/10: 6.8
      - 2010/11: 5.7
      - 2011/12: 4.8
      - 2012/13: 4.2
      - 2013/15: 3.0
      - 2014/15: 3.0
    - States fiscal deficit (percent of GDP):
      - 2009/10: 2.8
      - 2010/11: 2.6
      - 2011/12: 2.5
      - 2012/13: 2.5
      - 2013/15: 2.4
      - 2014/15: 2.4
    - Outstanding Debt (General Government) (percent of GDP):
      - 2009/10: 78.8
      - 2010/11: 78.3
      - 2011/12: 76.6
      - 2012/13: 74.3
      - 2013/15: 70.8
      - 2014/15: 67.8
    - Central Government outstanding debt (percent of GDP):
      - 2009/10: 54.2
      - 2010/11: 53.9
      - 2011/12: 52.5
      - 2012/13: 50.5
      - 2013/15: 47.5
      - 2014/15: 44.8
    - States outstanding debt (excluding debt to central government) (percent of GDP):
      - 2009/10: 24.6
      - 2010/11: 24.4
      - 2011/12: 24.1
      - 2012/13: 23.8
      - 2013/15: 23.3
      - 2014/15: 23.0
  - FC recommendations included:
    - Increasing central government borrowing and revenue sharing during downturns rather than raising states’ borrowing limits.
    - Establishing an independent review mechanism to evaluate fiscal reforms.
    - Making the Medium Term Fiscal Plan required under the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act (FRBMA) “a statement of a commitment rather than a statement of intent.”
    - Amending the FRBMA to spell out clearly under what circumstances its targets could be relaxed.
- Government Debt Report (GDR), November 2010:
  - Higher nominal GDP growth reduced debt-to-GDP ratios and brought FC debt target closer.
  - Authorities committed to continue the deficit path laid out by the FC; higher GDP would bring general government debt down to 65 percent of GDP by 2014/15, below the FC target.
  - GDR improved transparency by discussing structure, terms and holding patterns of state and central government debt and presenting a five-year path for spending and revenues based on bottom-up estimates.
- Consolidation challenges:
  - Tax reforms intended to be revenue neutral; capital spending slated to increase for infrastructure; pressing social needs remain.
  - Fiscal consolidation must rest on tight control of nonproductive expenditure.
  - Fund research suggests current expenditure has a lower multiplier than tax or development expenditure.
  - Spending on interest, defense and transfers to states accounts for 40 percent of total 2010/11 spending; capital expenditure accounts for 5 percent; non-subsidy social spending accounts for 16.5 percent.
  - Since 2004, spending in remaining areas, including subsidies, has risen on average by 17 percent per year. Based on Fund staff forecasts, growth in these areas would need to fall to 13 percent between 2010/11 and 2014/15.
  - Despite one-off items falling off (e.g., 6th Pay Commission arrears and the farmers’ debt waiver), the required moderation in spending growth is likely out of reach for 2010/11.
- Recent subsidy reform actions:
  - 2010/11 budget rationalized fertilizer subsidies by moving basis to nutrient content reimbursement.
  - In June, wholesale prices for kerosene and LNG were raised by 33 and 11 percent, respectively; diesel raised by 5 percent; gasoline prices fully liberalized with immediate effect.
  - Government reserved right to reverse measures if international oil prices climb to excessive levels; announced intention to free diesel prices in future.
  - Measures reduce likely subsidy bill for remainder of 2010/11; fertilizer and fuel subsidies still likely to cost 1.2 percent of GDP in 2010/11.
  - Full liberalization of gasoline, and eventually diesel, will reduce variability of subsidies and ongoing fiscal risks.

*Prepared by James P. Walsh*

### ANNEX 4. CURRENT ACCOUNT AND EXTERNAL STABILITY

### ANNEX 4. CURRENT ACCOUNT AND EXTERNAL STABILITY

### Current account trends and projections
- The current account deficit (CAD) averaged 1.1 percent of GDP in the three years prior to the crisis and increased to 3.7 percent of GDP in 2010Q2.
- The CAD is expected to remain at 3-3.5 percent of GDP over the next couple of years.
- Over the medium term the CAD is expected to decline to 2-2.5 percent of GDP as import growth moderates in line with overall economic growth and productivity gains in the tradable sector spur export growth.
- The fall 2010 CGER estimates India’s CAD norm at 3.4 percent of GDP.
- Projected CAD is expected to be close to the norm in 2010/11 and 2011/12 at around 3.3-3.5 percent of GDP.

### Main drivers of the CAD
- The CAD has been primarily the result of the trade deficit, which has hovered around 9 percent of GDP.
- The trade deficit has been partly offset by:
  - a surplus in the services balance of about 3 percent of GDP, and
  - net factor income including transfers of about 3 percent of GDP.
- Export growth has remained resilient and has averaged 28 percent so far in 2010.
- Import growth has also been rapid, particularly of capital goods.
- India’s exports (goods and services) have risen as a share of world exports, reflecting gains in productivity and increased integration with the global economy.
- India’s domestic recovery has been led by investment:
  - Gross fixed investment rose from 31 percent of GDP in 2006/07 to 32½ percent in 2009/10.
  - The CAD rose from 1 percent of GDP in 2006/07 to nearly 3 percent of GDP in 2009/10.
- Domestic consumption share of GDP has declined to 57 percent of GDP in 2009/10, almost 9 percentage points below the level recorded in 2004.

### External debt sustainability (ext-DSA) benchmark
- India’s external debt is about 20 percent of GDP.
- The non-interest CAD that stabilizes external debt is in the order of 4 percent of GDP, compared to a non-interest CAD of 2.2 percent in 2009/10.
- Even a combination of adverse shocks would still leave external debt under 30 percent of GDP, given high average growth and low external debt.

### Sensitivities to oil prices, exchange rate, and growth differentials
- The income elasticity of the trade balance is higher with respect to foreign income than domestic income (based on an ECM estimated for 1980-2009).
- A $10 increase in oil prices (about 12 percent) would lead to an increase in the CAD of about 0.6 percent of GDP.
- A 10 percent depreciation of the rupee is estimated to lower the trade balance by 0.2 percent of GDP in 1½-2 years.
- India’s CAD is particularly sensitive to oil prices and growth differentials.

### Financing of the CAD and capital flow risks
- The CAD has been financed mainly by FDI and portfolio equity inflows:
  - FDI has recently averaged 1-1.5 percent of GDP, covering nearly half of the recent CADs.
  - FDI could finance a third of India’s CAD even if it remains in the range of 3-4 percent of GDP.
  - Portfolio equity investment has financed about a third of the CAD in recent years but has been more volatile than FDI.
- Capital flow volatility, particularly in $ terms, has increased and could lead to sizable adjustments in domestic investment in the case of a sudden stop in inflows or large outflows as in 2008/09.
- Portfolio equity flows have been strongly associated with investment; a decline in inflows would likely lead to a decline in investment and overall activity growth.
- In the case of a sudden stop in capital inflows, reserves could be used and the exchange rate could provide some relief through depreciation, but the effect of the REER on the trade balance is relatively small and would take time to materialize.

### External vulnerability indicators
- Reserve coverage is 182 percent of short-term debt and current account deficit.
- External debt equals 94 percent of exports.
- Private external debt is 15 percent of GDP.
- The real effective exchange rate (REER) is close to equilibrium.
- Several indicators suggest India’s external vulnerability compares well to other emerging markets, but the likelihood of a sudden stop in capital flows is difficult to assess.

*Prepared by Roberto Guimarães (annex) — source content as provided.*

### 14. The corporate bond and CP market has expanded quickly. Growth in corporate

### _cr1150 - 14. The corporate bond and CP market has expanded quickly. Growth in corporate

### Corporate bond and commercial paper (CP) market developments
- Listed corporate bonds have risen 58 percent since December 2008.
- Outstanding CP has almost tripled, with higher trading volumes.
- Corporate bond issuance is dominated by highly-rated companies, especially public sector ones.
- Market liquidity is limited.
- Domestic institutional investors’ participation remains low.
- Issues surrounding stamp duties and withholding taxes hamper market deepening.
- Reforms that contributed to growth include listing and reporting requirements, higher FII participation, and repos with corporate bonds.

### Supervision and regulatory initiatives
- A mechanism for monitoring financial conglomerates has been in place since 2004.
- The RBI has started quarterly on-site inspections using the CAMELS framework.
- An enhanced revised off-site reporting system has been introduced.
- Financial conglomerates are now required to deduct from their capital investments in excess of 20 percent of a subsidiary’s equity, compared with a previous 30 percent.
- The RBI is seeking convergence of regulation of banks and financial conglomerates to prevent regulatory arbitrage.
- The RBI has issued a discussion paper on new banking licenses that:
  - Discusses pros and cons of licensing new banks, allowing conversion of NBFCs into banks, and allowing large industrial houses to own banks.
  - Notes safety, soundness and legal concerns with non-financial companies owning banks.
  - Emphasizes the critical importance of the ability to supervise the banking activity of non-financial companies.
  - Recommends a proper supervisory structure requiring banking activities of the non-financial group be conducted within a tiered holding company subject to prudential regulation with thick firewalls between its banking activities and the group’s other activities.
- Regulatory reform progress:
  - Authorities’ 2009 self-assessment on financial stability was followed by the 2010/2011 budget announcement of a Financial Sector Legislative Reforms Commission to rewrite and streamline financial sector laws.
  - The government has proposed a Financial Stability and Development Council (FSDC) chaired by the Finance Minister to deal with inter-regulatory coordination, financial stability as well as financial development issues.
  - Close consultation with financial regulators is noted as important to dispel concerns about regulatory independence.

### India’s infrastructure plans and financing challenges (Eleventh Plan context)
- Policy priority: increased investment in infrastructure is one of the government’s top policy priorities.
- Eleventh Plan (2007/08 to 2011/12) aims and framing:
  - The Eleventh Plan (2007-08 to 2011-12) aims at a sustainable growth rate of 9 per cent with emphasis on a broad-based and inclusive approach that would improve the quality of life and reduce disparities across regions and communities.
  - To overcome infrastructure constraints, an ambitious programme of infrastructure investment, involving both public and private sector, is being developed for the Eleventh Plan.
- Historical and target figures:
  - During the period of the 10th Plan, infrastructure investment totaled 5.1 percent of GDP.
  - The 11th Plan goal: raise infrastructure investment to 7.6 percent of GDP.
  - Total: approx. US$520 billion, 7.6 percent of GDP.
  - Investment in electricity was slated to account for 32 percent of infrastructure spending.
  - Roads accounted for 14 percent; Railways 10 percent; Telecoms 17 percent; Other 28 percent.
  - The Planning Commission aimed for increased private sector participation with a goal of ensuring 1/3 private participation in most categories.
- Mid-Term Appraisal and adjustments:
  - With final data for 2007/08 and 2008/09, overall infrastructure investment exceeded original targets by a small margin.
  - Private investment in telecommunications greatly exceeded original targets; investment in roads was disappointing.
  - Costs in many areas were higher than originally forecast, mainly due to difficulties with land acquisition and higher capital equipment prices.
  - Despite overperformance in investment in power generation capacity, the output target of 78.7 GW has now been reduced to 62 GW.
- Forward-looking targets and scale:
  - To reach revised 11th Plan targets, infrastructure investment would likely have to rise from an estimated 7.2 percent of GDP in 2008/09 to around 8.4 percent of GDP in 2011/12, the final year of the 11th Plan.
  - A target of US$ 1 trillion for infrastructure has been widely discussed for the next Plan, likely entailing infrastructure investment of 9-10 percent of GDP.

### Roadblocks to accelerating infrastructure investment
- Finance:
  - Difficulty of financing large infrastructure projects given India’s bank-dominated financial system, shallow corporate debt market, capital account controls, and fiscal dominance.
  - Main constraint: availability of long-term rupee debt financing, which so far has been provided by banks, exposing them to maturity mismatches.
  - Authorities have begun to address these constraints.
- Public sector capacity:
  - Execution capacity has reportedly been a constraint in areas where PPPs could be successful (e.g., railway stations, ports, roads).
- Government clearances:
  - Overlapping levels of government and many public sector stakeholders add to implementation risks.
  - Some states (e.g., Tamil Nadu) have simplified procedures and unified oversight into a single office, but such progress has not been broadly imitated.
- Land acquisition:
  - Difficulties obtaining clearances where land acquisition is involved due to numerous restrictions related to environmental, social, political and economic concerns, sometimes requiring separate legal settlement.
  - A bill in Parliament to address this has been stalled for some time.
- Limited capacity of contractors:
  - Few domestic companies can engage in very large infrastructure projects; many are subsidiaries of large diversified conglomerates, concentrating risks.
  - Smaller construction companies face difficulties in hiring skilled labor, dealing with regulatory complexity and access to finance.
  - Foreign companies are discouraged by regulatory and implementation risk.

### Cross-country findings on financing infrastructure
- IMF staff study approach:
  - Analyzes macroeconomic behavior during infrastructure booms using a dataset of 105 countries spanning 1980 to 2009.
  - Identifies booms as three-year periods when growth in mileage of paved roads or installed electrical generation capacity exceeded long-run averages by specified standard-deviation thresholds.
- General findings:
  - Large infrastructure investments are often preceded by periods of rapid growth.
  - Energy generation investment is generally preceded by strong current account performance and is not associated with deteriorating current account positions, implying domestic savings are the marginal source of finance.
  - Road construction is more likely to tap foreign savings or reallocate domestic savings; roads investment tends to be preceded by strong current account balances but often involves foreign savings.
  - Booms in energy generation capacity tend to follow periods of improving fiscal balances; this improvement tends to dissipate during the boom as capital spending rises.
  - Roads investment lags superior fiscal performance but does not typically lead to deficit financing.
  - Periods of rapid investment in energy and roads capacity do not appear linked to periods of unusual expansion of credit from banks or debt markets, suggesting infrastructure booms do not lead to appreciable financial deepening on average.
- Heterogeneity across countries:
  - Case studies of Brazil, Chile, China, and Korea show highly heterogeneous experiences in financing infrastructure.
  - Lack of significance of private sector financial variables in aggregate results conceals important country differences.

### Case study highlights (selected points)
- Brazil:
  - Long-term finance relies substantially on BNDES, a state-owned national development bank.
  - BNDES lending rates are well below market rates and have been adjusted to stimulate lending for infrastructure.
  - Dominance of a state-owned lender has raised concerns about distortion of the financial sector and slowing development of a traditional long-term debt market.
  - Energy sector dominated by state-run Elétrobras; government holds 52 percent of common shares.
  - Around 8 percent of national highways are run by concessionaires on a for-profit basis.
  - Debt finance remains dominated by BNDES; multilateral lending is important for long-term debt.
- Chile:
  - Infrastructure investment dominated by the private sector, aided by privatized pension system and financial liberalization.
  - Pension funds’ assets under management totaled 65 percent of GDP in 2009; insurance industry held an additional 22 percent.
  - Equity market capitalization at 144 percent of GDP.
  - Energy sector entirely privatized with extensive foreign participation.
  - Roads construction and upgrading largely done through PPPs; contingent liabilities of PPPs disclosed in the budget.
  - Main source of financing for PPPs has been debt, often wrapped by foreign monoline insurers to broaden investor base.
- China:
  - State-run financial system is the primary source of infrastructure finance; banks devote large shares of loan portfolios (ranging from 18 up to 40 percent) to infrastructure.
  - The China Development Bank focuses largely (74 percent of assets) on infrastructure investments.
  - Corporate bonds with credit guarantees have become more important recently.
  - Local governments finance themselves via land premium and guarantee much infrastructure lending.
  - Energy generation is dominated by five state-owned enterprises, though many small private companies also exist.
  - Around one third of funding for road construction comes from local governments directly, another third from bank loans; private SPVs have become quite large with many issuing debt in local markets and 20 now listed on equity exchanges.

*Source: _cr1150 - 14. The corporate bond and CP market has expanded quickly. Growth in corporate*

### 22.      While Korea’s financial sector is large and sophisticated, infrastructure investment

### _cr1150 - 22.      While Korea’s financial sector is large and sophisticated, infrastructure investment

### Infrastructure investment: historical overview and current pattern
- Infrastructure investment grew rapidly during the country’s sustained boom from the 1960s to 1980s, but has tapered off in recent years.
- In 1994, a law was passed to facilitate private investment in infrastructure projects, but its coverage was limited.
- Following an amendment in 1999, private involvement in infrastructure rose to around 20 percent of the total.
- Infrastructure investment remains largely a public-sector phenomenon.

### Energy sector — KEPCO
- The Korean Electric Power Corporation (KEPCO) dominates the energy sector.
- KEPCO was fully state-owned from 1981 to 1989, when 21 percent of shares were sold.
- There are restrictions on the number of shares foreigners can buy.
- There is a legal requirement that the share of government ownership not fall below 51 percent.
- KEPCO has access to the full array of financing sources and actively issues investment-grade debt domestically and abroad.

### Highway construction and private participation
- Until recently, highway construction was undertaken almost entirely by public sector entities.
- The Korean highway network expanded rapidly during the 1960s, financed almost entirely by a national highway corporation which borrowed money from banks and multilateral lenders, as well as by issuing sovereign-backed bonds.
- Another boom occurred during the 2000s, but with greater use of bond issuance, both domestic and international.
- With the improved environment for private participation, around one quarter of the mileage added during this period was built by private companies, some of which enjoyed support from a public infrastructure fund.

### Lessons for India — financing capacity and international participation
- Large infrastructure needs can be met domestically, though foreign participation can be beneficial.
- Capacity increases such as India envisages for the remainder of the 11th Plan and the 12th Plan have in many countries been accommodated within a country’s domestic savings envelope, particularly for energy investments.
- Companies like KEPCO and Elétrobras have used international debt issues to finance infrastructure investments; Elétrobras also has foreign listings to raise equity finance abroad.
- FDI has been an important source of funding for roads and energy in Chile.

### Catalyzing private funds into infrastructure
- With fiscal space relatively scarce, India will have to improve the environment for private sector investment in infrastructure.
- Fiscal resources can be leveraged via guarantees, as local governments in China do with bank loans for infrastructure projects, or via PPPs, as Chile has done.
- China and Brazil also both use public financial enterprises to channel lending into infrastructure projects, though this can create other problems.
  - BNDES’ dominance of the long-term lending market in Brazil worries many observers.
  - The concentration of lending risk in infrastructure in China may raise financial risks.

### Business climate and institutional factors
- The business climate for private investment is very important:
  - In China, private investment in energy has been slowed by government red tape and the varying pace of price liberalization across different markets.
  - In Korea, the PPP industry did not take off until the government passed laws that broadened the scope of the original legislation.
  - Chile has been extremely successful at mobilizing private finance for infrastructure; a World Economic Forum report on its successes cited not only its open equity market, relatively well-developed corporate bond sector and general economic stability but also its “extremely well-developed e-government services, clear information on policy changes, transparency and openness of statistics publications, and dialogue and decision-making process.”

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt (chapter section provided).*

### 1. India’s private saving has risen

### _cr1150 - 1. India’s private saving has risen

### Trends in private saving
- Private saving increased from 24 percent of GDP in 2000 to 35 percent of GDP in 2009.
- The increase in India’s saving ratio is sizable when compared against a large panel of emerging and advanced economies.
- The rise in private saving has coincided with the rise in investment, and more recently with the acceleration in growth.

### Motivation and policy relevance
- Since investment is forecast to continue to grow faster than GDP, understanding the determinants of private saving is key to assess the extent to which India will need to tap foreign saving to finance investment.
- While the current account deficit has widened in recent years, several factors point to a continuation of rising private saving, at least over the medium term.
- Demographic change: India’s saving will continue to benefit from the increase in the working-age dependency ratio. Growth in income should help increase the overall saving ratio as many households surpass their subsistence level of consumption.
- Fiscal consolidation: Private saving may decline as a result of fiscal consolidation, but this will depend on the extent to which Ricardian equivalence holds. Examples given:
  - In a country with low debt levels (and a low Ricardian offset) a 1 percent of GDP decline in public saving is likely to lead to less than 1 percent of GDP increase in private saving, which would contribute to an overall decline in national saving.
  - In the case of a highly indebted country, the increase in private saving may match the decline in public saving, with no effect on national saving.

### Empirical model and data
- Estimated a dynamic panel regression covering 130 countries spanning the period 1970-2009.
- The empirical model posits that private saving is determined by:
  - its lagged value,
  - GDP per capita (log of GDP per capita),
  - growth in GDP per capita (GDP per capita growth),
  - public saving (public saving rate),
  - young-age dependency ratio (age dependency ratio, young, % of working-age population),
  - old-age dependency ratio (age dependency ratio, old, % of working-age population),
  - life expectancy at birth, total (years),
  - real interest rate (%),
  - financial development (M2/GDP (%) and domestic credit to private sector (% of GDP)),
  - terms of trade (changes in terms of trade (%)),
  - other variables including proxies for macroeconomic stability (inflation volatility, s.d. of monthly CPI % changes; business cycle fluctuation),
  - time- and country-fixed effects.
- Data sources: IMF’s WEO and the World Bank’s WDI.
- Times series results for India yield mostly insignificant coefficients; panel regression estimates are more precise and robust.

### Baseline regression results (full panel sample) — selected coefficients and significance
- Lagged private saving rate (% of GDP):
  - Pooled OLS: 0.524 [0.0891]***
  - FE with lagged variable: 0.344 [0.0664]***
  - Difference GMM: 0.3433 [0.1207]***
  - System GMM: 0.2723 [0.1130]**
- log of GDP per capita:
  - Pooled OLS: 0.0849 [0.4207]
  - FE with lagged variable: 3.4449 [1.6406]**
  - Difference GMM: 0.4029 [4.1174]
  - System GMM: 1.2832 [2.2156]
- GDP per capita growth (%):
  - Pooled OLS: 0.1399 [0.0481]***
  - FE with lagged variable: 0.1223 [0.0409]***
  - Difference GMM: 0.1566 [0.0760]**
  - System GMM: 0.1921 [0.0648]***
- Public saving rate (% of GDP):
  - Pooled OLS: -0.0816 [0.0548]
  - FE with lagged variable: -0.2633 [0.1384]*
  - Difference GMM: -0.5586 [0.2191]**
  - System GMM: -0.5121 [0.2780]*
- Age dependency ratio, young (% of working-age population):
  - Pooled OLS: -0.0658 [0.0271]**
  - FE with lagged variable: -0.065 [0.0652]
  - Difference GMM: -0.1652 [0.0960]*
  - System GMM: -0.182 [0.0895]**
- Age dependency ratio, old (% of working-age population):
  - Pooled OLS: -0.1469 [0.0681]**
  - FE with lagged variable: -0.2895 [0.1470]*
  - Difference GMM: -0.2962 [0.2208]
  - System GMM: -0.5753 [0.2755]**
- Life expectancy at birth, total (years):
  - Pooled OLS: 0.0934 [0.0465]**
  - FE with lagged variable: 0.2446 [0.0649]***
  - Difference GMM: 0.2287 [0.1078]**
  - System GMM: 0.1372 [0.1958]
- Real interest rate (%):
  - Pooled OLS: -0.0501 [0.0191]***
  - FE with lagged variable: -0.0578 [0.0199]***
  - Difference GMM: -0.0642 [0.0428]
  - System GMM: -0.0704 [0.0224]***
- M2/GDP (%):
  - Pooled OLS: 0.0217 [0.0121]*
  - FE with lagged variable: -0.0028 [0.0186]
  - Difference GMM: -0.0118 [0.0427]
  - System GMM: 0.0221 [0.0389]
- Domestic credit to private sector (% of GDP):
  - Pooled OLS: -0.0109 [0.0099]
  - FE with lagged variable: -0.0311 [0.0119]**
  - Difference GMM: -0.0253 [0.0150]*
  - System GMM: -0.0654 [0.0229]***
- Inflation volatility, s.d. of monthly CPI % changes:
  - Pooled OLS: -0.0024 [0.0008]***
  - FE with lagged variable: -0.0016 [0.0004]***
  - Difference GMM: -0.002 [0.0010]**
  - System GMM: -0.0017 [0.0007]**
- Business cycle fluctuation:
  - Pooled OLS: 0.0676 [0.0772]
  - FE with lagged variable: 0.1567 [0.0787]**
  - Difference GMM: 0.2079 [0.1038]**
  - System GMM: 0.2191 [0.0994]**
- Changes in terms of trade (%):
  - Pooled OLS: 0.0283 [0.0134]**
  - FE with lagged variable: 0.0277 [0.0145]*
  - Difference GMM: 0.0307 [0.0123]**
  - System GMM: 0.0317 [0.0134]**

- Panel diagnostics and sample:
  - Test for AR(1) in first differences (p-value): FE with lagged variable not applicable; Difference GMM: 0.000; System GMM: .006
  - Test for AR(2) in first differences (p-value): Difference GMM: 0.077; System GMM: 0.222
  - Number of Instruments (System GMM): 6875
  - Hansen test of overid. Restrictions (p-value): Difference GMM: 0.101; System GMM: 0.1
  - Observations: Pooled OLS: 2544; FE: 2544; Difference GMM: 2358; System GMM: 2544
  - R-squared: Pooled OLS: 0.68; FE: 0.76
  - Number of Countries: 130

### Key empirical findings (interpretation consistent with life-cycle theories)
- Demographics:
  - A 1 percentage point decrease in young-age dependency ratio increases private saving by 0.2 percentage points.
  - A 1 percentage point decrease in old-age dependency ratio increases private saving by 0.6 percentage points.
- Fiscal policy and Ricardian equivalence:
  - Results do not support full Ricardian equivalence: a 1 percentage point decrease in public saving increases private saving by about 0.5 percentage points.
  - The effect is significantly larger for countries with large public debt; for highly-indebted countries an increase in the fiscal deficit is almost fully offset by a concomitant increase in private saving.
- Interest rates and financial development:
  - Interest rates generally have a small effect on saving.
  - The effect of financial development is generally ambiguous and statistically insignificant.
- Heterogeneity:
  - Quantile regression estimates show that the impact of public saving and demographic ratios on private saving are larger for low-savers.

### Projections and scenarios
- The empirical model indicates that the rise in private saving in India could continue for 5-10 years.
- Baseline projections: India’s saving rate could increase by further 2-4 percentage points over the next 10 years as it would continue to benefit from favorable demographics for two more decades.
- Conditional forecasts (assuming most regressors are constant at their end point value) point to a moderation of the recent trend.
- Projection assumptions:
  - constant growth in GDP per capita,
  - unchanged level of public saving.
- Policy interaction:
  - On balance, the envisaged fiscal consolidation should help increase national saving, but according to the empirical model, the effect of consolidation would be partly offset by private saving.

*Source: Prepared by Roberto Guimarães; data and estimates from IMF staff (WEO, WDI) as presented in the informational annex._

### Section 2(a): restrictions related to the nontransferability of balances under the India-Russia debt

### Section 2(a): restrictions related to the nontransferability of balances under the India-Russia debt

### Executive Board approval status
- The Executive Board has not approved:
  - restrictions related to the nontransferability of balances under the India-Russia debt agreement;
  - restrictions arising from unsettled balances under inoperative bilateral payments arrangements with two Eastern European countries;
  - a restriction on the transfer of amortization payments on loans by non-resident relatives.

### Article IV consultation (timing)
- The previous Article IV consultation discussions were held in December 2009.
- The staff report (IMF Country Report No. 10/73) was discussed by the Executive Board on January 25, 2010.

### FSAP Participation and ROSCs
- The data model of the ROSC (IMF Country Report No. 04/96) was issued in April 2004.
- A fiscal transparency ROSC (available at http://www.imf.org/external/np/rosc/ind/fiscal.htm) was issued in February 2001.
- The authorities have agreed to a second FSAP in 2011.

### Technical assistance (departments, purpose, date)
- MAE: Government securities market — 2/94
- MAE: Foreign exchange market — 2/95
- FAD: Expenditure control — 5/95
- FAD: Public expenditure management — 8/95
- FAD: Public expenditure management (follow-up) — 5/96
- MAE: Government securities market (follow-up) — 7/96
- STA: SDDS and statistics — 12/96
- STA: Balance of payments statistics — 12/97
- STA: SDDS and statistics — 2/98
- FAD: State level fiscal database and debt register — 11/04
- FAD: Pilot study on public private partnerships — 12/04
- STA: Balance of payments statistics — 9/05
- LEG: AML/CFT — 5/08
- LEG: AML/CFT — 10/08

### Outreach and other activities (APD)
- APD: Training: Revenue Forecasting — 5/05
- APD: Seminar: Going Global: India’s Emerging Role in the World Economy at Centro di Studi Internazionali sull’Economia e lo Sviluppo — 6/06
- APD: Book: India Goes Global: Its Expanding Role in the World Economy — 8/06
- APD: Brookings Institution Panel: Is India’s High Growth Sustainable? — 4/07
- APD: Book: India: Managing Financial Integration and Growth — 6/08
- APD: Seminar: “Have We Seen this Movie Before? Comparing The Crisis of 2008 with East Asia 1998”, presented at ICRIER/IM-Welt conference and Yale Initiative on Asian and International Relations — 11/08
- APD: Seminar: “Forecasting Growth and Inflation: China and India”, presented in New Delhi — 10/09
- APD: Seminars: “What are the Effects of Fiscal Policy Shocks in India?” and “The global financial crisis: Explaining cross-country differences in the output impact”, presented at the 6th NIPFP-DEA Research Conference, New Delhi — 03/10

### Resident representative
- A resident representative’s office was opened in November 1991.
- Mr. Sanjaya Panth has been Senior Resident Representative since August 2008.

### India—Relations with the World Bank Group (FY2010 highlights)
- In Bank FY2010 (July 1-June 30):
  - IBRD/IDA lending totaled $9.31 billion, compared with $2.24 billion in FY2009.
  - IFC committed $1.8 billion in FY2010, up from $947 million in FY2009.
- The WBG Country Strategy (CAS) for India for 2009-2012 focuses on fast-tracking infrastructure development and supporting the seven poorest states.
- CAS envisaged a total proposed IBRD lending program of US$14.6 billion for the four-year CAS period, with approximately $3 billion additional IBRD financing projected in response to the financial crisis.
- The International Development Association (IDA) V allocation was $4.79 billion (SDR equivalent of 2.919 billion).
- The pace of IBRD lending accelerated, bringing India closer to its Single Borrower Limit (SBL) of $17.5 billion earlier than anticipated.
- Revised lending scenario projected approximately US$8 billion in IBRD lending in FY11 and FY12.
- Government agreed on purchases of IBRD Special Private Placement Bonds to help maintain India’s IBRD net exposure within the SBL.
- IFC is managing exposure via mobilization and selectivity; IFC’s management agreed, on an exceptional basis, to allow India to exceed the economic capital limit set for BRIC countries.

### World Bank Group strategic focus and program orientation
- CAS overarching objective: scale up development impact of Bank Group assistance to help India achieve rapid, inclusive growth and sustainable development, and improve service delivery while strengthening project implementation and public spending effectiveness.
- Differentiated approach:
  - Low-income states and lagging regions: focus on achieving the MDGs, relying primarily on IDA resources and non-lending TA.
  - More advanced states and central level: focus on strengthening institutions, relying on IBRD lending and analytical work.
- IFC strategy: support inclusive growth by increasing access to infrastructure and finance, focusing on low-income, rural, and fragile regions, and making climate change central.
- Program focus: large transformative development programs (e.g., River Basin, Rural Roads II, National Livelihoods), innovative pilots (e.g., Karnataka Watershed), and leveraging Bank resources.

### India—World Bank Group financial operations (2009/10, in millions of U.S. dollars)
- Commitments 2/: 7,115
  - IBRD: 5,481
  - IDA: 1,634
- Disbursement: 2,360
  - IBRD: 1,319
  - IDA: 1,041
- Repayments: 1,264
  - IBRD: 457
  - IDA: 807
- Debt outstanding and disbursed: 34,070
  - IBRD: 8,613
  - IDA: 25,457
- Notes:
  - 1/ On an Indian fiscal year basis beginning April 1.
  - 2/ Based on loan approval date.
- Source: World Bank.

### India—Relations with the Asian Development Bank (AsDB) (cumulative through 24 November 2010)
- AsDB operations in India began in 1986.
- Cumulative public sector loan commitments totaled $22.3 billion as of 24 November 2010 for 139 loans.
- Additional $1.6 billion in private sector loans (without government guarantee), bringing total loan commitments to $23.9 billion.
- Equity investments approved amounting to $0.3 billion.
- AsDB lending and equity activities table (calendar periods and amounts in millions of U.S. dollars, as of 24 November 2010):
  - 1986–90: OCR Commitments 2,317.6; Equity 15.9; Disbursements 338.7
  - 1991–95: OCR Commitments 3,364.0; Equity 59.5; Disbursements 2,131.3
  - 1996: OCR Commitments 763.0; Equity --; Disbursements 591.7
  - 1997: OCR Commitments 563.0; Equity 15.5; Disbursements 645.0
  - 1998: OCR Commitments 250.0; Equity --; Disbursements 620.4
  - 1999: OCR Commitments 625.0; Equity --; Disbursements 605.3
  - 2000: OCR Commitments 1330.0; Equity --; Disbursements 487.0
  - 2001: OCR Commitments 1,500.0; Equity --; Disbursements 269.9
  - 2002: OCR Commitments 1,163.6; Equity 15.0; Disbursements 576.5
  - 2003: OCR Commitments 1,411.0; Equity 0.7; Disbursements 658.0
  - 2004: OCR Commitments 1,200.0; Equity 29.7; Disbursements 381.4
  - 2005: OCR Commitments 367.3; Equity 15.0; Disbursements 641.0
  - 2006: OCR Commitments 1,260.0; Equity 67.6; Disbursements 701.4
  - 2007: OCR Commitments 1,232.1; Equity --; Disbursements 1,363.5
  - 2008: OCR Commitments 1,777.6; Equity 18.6; Disbursements 1,507.7
  - 2009: OCR Commitments 1,711.0; Equity 40.0; Disbursements 1,338.9
  - 2010 (as of 24 Nov): OCR Commitments 1422.6; Equity 0.0; Disbursements 1,188.4
  - Total: OCR Commitments 22,257.8; Equity 277.3; Disbursements 14,046.1
- AsDB CPS (2009-2012) strategic pillars:
  - (i) Support for inclusive and environmentally sustainable growth;
  - (ii) Catalyzing investment through innovative business and financing modalities;
  - (iii) Strengthening results orientation of project design and implementation and emphasizing knowledge solutions;
  - (iv) Support for regional cooperation.
- CPS designed to support Government of India's efforts in facilitating inclusive growth and speeding up poverty reduction and social development as emphasized in the Eleventh Five-Year Plan (2007-2012).
- CPS emphasis: results-based framework, strengthen AsDB support for infrastructure in poorer states, promote public private partnerships in infrastructure, support climate change adaptation and mitigation, encourage innovative financing modalities (non-sovereign loans and cofinancing).

### Statistical issues (summary of assessment and data strengths/weaknesses)
- Overall adequacy:
  - Macroeconomic statistics are adequate for surveillance, but weaknesses remain in timeliness and coverage of certain series.
  - India produces a vast quantity of data covering most sectors of the economy.
- SDDS subscription and observance:
  - India subscribed to the SDDS on December 27, 1996.
  - Started posting metadata on the Dissemination Standards Bulletin Board on October 30, 1997.
  - India is currently in observance of the SDDS, using flexibility options for timeliness of data on general government operations and for periodicity and timeliness of labor market data.
- ROSC data module:
  - Data module of the ROSC (IMF Country Report No. 04/96) published in April 2004; assesses dissemination practices and quality of six datasets based on the DQAF.
- National accounts and employment:
  - CSO releases new national accounts series with base year 2004–2005; quarterly releases dissemination lag of two months.
  - Estimates of value added in constant prices for public administration and defense may be biased upwards (based on government wage bill with arrears counted in the year paid) deflated by the Wholesale Price Index (WPI).
  - Employment data deficiencies: available only on an annual basis with substantial lag; cover only formal sector.
- Price statistics:
  - Since January 2006, Labour Bureau publishes a CPI for industrial workers with a 2001 base year.
  - A revised CPI with new weights expected in early 2011.
  - Presently four CPIs: industrial workers, urban and nonmanual employees, agricultural laborers, rural laborers; published with a lag of about one month.
  - Except for industrial workers CPI, other indices based on weights over ten years.
  - WPI recently revised with a 2004/05 base year; primary articles components published weekly with a lag of two weeks.
  - Real estate and housing price data are not available on a timely basis and have limited geographic coverage.
- External sector statistics:
  - Concepts and definitions broadly in line with BPM5, but RBI presentation does not strictly follow BPM5.
  - Trade data have quality, valuation, timing, and coverage problems; trade prices, volumes, and composition data not regularly available on a timely basis.
  - Only trade credit extended for more than 180 days is included in BOP (and IIP and external debt); trade credit is often less than 180 days in most countries.
  - Bilateral services export data to the United States and other developed countries are manifold higher than counterpart services imports published by those countries.
  - External debt statistics available quarterly with a one quarter lag.
  - Estimates of short-term external debt are presented on an original maturity basis; short-term maturity attribution on a residual maturity basis is only available annually (and excludes residual maturity of medium- and long-term nonresident Indian accounts).
  - IIP statistics cover BPM5-prescribed sectors and annual data are disseminated within six months of the reference period.
  - Coverage of direct investment position data is hampered by absence of appropriate legal or institutional authority.
  - India began disseminating the Data Template on International Reserves and Foreign Currency Liquidity as prescribed under the SDDS in December 2001.
  - Up-to-date information on certain variables (total foreign reserves, foreign currency assets, gold, SDRs) available weekly as part of a weekly statistical supplement on the RBI web site.
- Monetary and financial statistics:
  - RBI website and RBI Bulletin publish a wide array of monetary and financial statistics, including reserve money and components, RBI’s survey, monetary survey, liquidity aggregates (outstanding amounts), interest rates, exchange rates, foreign reserves, and government securities auction results.
  - Frequency and quality of data dissemination have improved substantially in recent years.
- Concepts and definitions vs. MFSM:
  - RBI concepts and definitions broadly conform with MFSM but with deviations:
    - Resident sector data do not provide sufficient information on sectoral distribution of domestic credit due to sectorization scheme (central government; state government; commercial sector including other financial corporations, public and other nonfinancial corporations, and other resident sectors).
    - Commercial banks add accrued interest to credit and deposit positions on a quarterly basis only (instead of the prescribed monthly basis).
- Reporting and technical cooperation:
  - RBI reports monetary data for IFS regularly.
  - Since October 2006, RBI initiated electronic reporting of monetary data (an improvement over paper-based reporting).
  - India submitted test data (starting from December 2001 data) on the Standardized Report Forms (SRFs) developed to implement MFSM methodology.
  - STA is working with the authorities to resolve outstanding data issues on development of the SRFs.

*Source: _cr1150 - Section 2(a): restrictions related to the nontransferability of balances under the India-Russia debt*

### 9.      Fiscal operations: The Ministry of Finance (MoF) posts selected central government

### 9. Fiscal operations: The Ministry of Finance (MoF) posts selected central government monthly fiscal data and quarterly debt data on its web site.

### Data availability and presentation
- MoF posts selected central government monthly fiscal data and quarterly debt data on its web site.
- No monthly data on fiscal performance at the state level are available.
- Annual data are available only with an 8-month to 10-month lag.
- Consolidated information is unavailable on local government operations.
- Data on the functional and economic classification of expenditures are available with considerable lag.
- The presentation of fiscal accounts could be improved analytically:
  - Current classification of government expenditure between developmental/nondevelopmental and plan/nonplan obscures the economic nature and impact of fiscal actions.
- MoF reports central government data on a cash basis for publication in the Government Finance Statistics Yearbook (latest reported data correspond to 2006).

### Findings from Article IV summary (IMF Public Information Notice No. 11/2, January 5, 2011)
- Growth and inflation
  - India’s economy projected to grow by 8¾ percent in real terms in 2010/11, moderating to about 8 percent the following year.
  - Inflation measures are in the 8½ to 10½ percent range (context: limited slack, exit from policy stimulus, structural factors affecting food prices).
- Drivers and outlook
  - Recovery since mid-2009 led by domestic demand, especially infrastructure investment.
  - Rebound in agriculture and pickup in private consumption supporting 2010/11 growth.
  - Infrastructure expected to remain an important growth driver; corporate investment likely to accelerate.
  - Medium-term growth prospects described as strong, supported by high investment and productivity gains.
- Risks and policy priorities
  - Risks broadly balanced; downside risks mainly from global economy.
  - Surging capital inflows could spur investment but complicate macroeconomic management.
  - Sustaining rapid medium-term growth depends on reforms to facilitate infrastructure investment (e.g., deepening corporate bond market, lowering cost of doing business) and improving social indicators while carrying out fiscal consolidation.
  - Improving social outcomes and infrastructure are key pillars of the government’s strategy.

### Executive Board assessment and recommendations
- Commendations and concerns
  - Directors commended authorities for economic stewardship—strong growth, improving social indicators, favorable medium-term prospects.
  - Near-term challenges: elevated inflation, fiscal consolidation needs, buoyant capital inflows.
- Monetary policy
  - Directors commended RBI’s efforts to tighten monetary conditions.
  - Short-term real interest rates remain below historic norms; most Directors recommended further steps to bring the real repo rate clearly into positive territory.
  - Welcomed RBI’s increased frequency of policy reviews and more guidance on future actions.
  - Most Directors saw merit in improving the CPI (including a new national CPI) and using it in policymaking to influence inflation expectations.
  - Structural reforms highlighted as important in containing food price inflation.
- Fiscal consolidation
  - Directors welcomed commitment to fiscal consolidation and plans to streamline spending.
  - Envisaged Goods and Services Tax and new Direct Tax Code expected to increase tax efficiency.
  - Given buoyant growth, most Directors favored further strengthening of consolidation; saving this year’s overperformance in revenue and one-off receipts could help reconstitute fiscal space.
  - Recommended more substantial current spending adjustment—mainly by further cutting subsidies and improving targeting—to achieve social goals with medium-term fiscal consolidation.
  - A few Directors favored balancing consolidation pacing with sustaining growth via infrastructure investment and social spending.
- Capital inflows and external policy
  - Low yields in advanced economies and India’s favorable growth differentials could raise capital inflows above absorptive capacity.
  - Exchange rate flexibility should remain first line of defense; reserve accumulation and macroprudential measures could be used if strong inflows continue.
  - Absorptive capacity could be improved by deepening financial markets or liberalizing FDI, consistent with gradual capital account liberalization.

### Financial stability and infrastructure
- Financial stability
  - Directors supported focus on strengthening financial stability, macroprudential regulations to cool residential real estate market, and ensuring regulatory level playing field.
  - India’s banking system described as resilient and well capitalized; monitoring asset quality remains important, especially if prudential norms for infrastructure are eased.
  - Commended RBI’s Financial Stability Report, review of financial laws, creation of the Financial Stability and Development Council, and forthcoming Financial Sector Assessment Program.
- Infrastructure
  - Directors welcomed emphasis on investment in infrastructure and human capital.
  - Supported measures to increase availability of long-term finance for infrastructure, especially developing corporate bond market; noted short-run need for foreign savings.
  - Supported reforms in land acquisition and government clearances; stressed strong accountability and transparency over large infrastructure projects.

### Key statistics and indicators (selected figures from India: Selected Economic Indicators, 2006/07–2010/11)
- Growth (y/y percent change)
  - Real GDP (at factor cost): 2006/07: 9.7; 2007/08: 9.2; 2008/09: 6.7; 2009/10: 7.4; 2010/11: 8.8
  - Industrial production: 2006/07: 11.5; 2007/08: 8.5; 2008/09: 6.7; 2009/10: 10.5; 2010/11: ...
- Prices (y/y percent change, average)
  - Wholesale prices (2004/05 weights): 2006/07: 5.5; 2007/08: 4.6; 2008/09: 8.3; 2009/10: 3.5; 2010/11: 8.5
  - Wholesale prices (2004/05 weights, end of period): 2006/07: 6.8; 2007/08: 7.7; 2008/09: 1.5; 2009/10: 10.2; 2010/11: 6.5
  - Consumer prices - industrial workers (2001 weights): 2006/07: 6.7; 2007/08: 6.2; 2008/09: 9.1; 2009/10: 12.7; 2010/11: 10.8
- Saving and investment (percent of GDP)
  - Gross saving: 2006/07: 34.5; 2007/08: 36.4; 2008/09: 33.9; 2009/10: 32.1; 2010/11: 34.4
  - Gross investment: 2006/07: 35.5; 2007/08: 37.7; 2008/09: 36.2; 2009/10: 35.0; 2010/11: 37.7
- Fiscal position (percent of GDP)
  - Central government deficit: 2006/07: -4.3; 2007/08: -3.1; 2008/09: -7.5; 2009/10: -6.8; 2010/11: -6.6
  - General government deficit: 2006/07: -6.1; 2007/08: -4.4; 2008/09: -10.8; 2009/10: -10.4; 2010/11: -9.6
  - General government debt: 2006/07: 77.7; 2007/08: 75.0; 2008/09: 75.0; 2009/10: 76.8; 2010/11: 75.0
- Money and credit (y/y percent change, end-period)
  - Broad money: 2006/07: 21.3; 2007/08: 21.4; 2008/09: 19.3; 2009/10: 16.8; 2010/11: 17.7
  - Credit to commercial sector: 2006/07: 25.7; 2007/08: 21.1; 2008/09: 16.9; 2009/10: 15.9; 2010/11: 20.2
- Financial indicators (percent, end-period)
  - 91-day treasury bill yield: 2006/07: 8.0; 2007/08: 7.2; 2008/09: 5.0; 2009/10: 4.4; 2010/11: 6.9
  - 10-year government bond yield: 2006/07: 8.0; 2007/08: 7.9; 2008/09: 7.0; 2009/10: 7.8; 2010/11: 8.1
  - Stock market (y/y percent change, end-period): 2006/07: 15.9; 2007/08: 19.7; 2008/09: -37.9; 2009/10: 80.5; 2010/11: 15.3
- External trade (US$ billions)
  - Merchandise exports: 2006/07: 128.9; 2007/08: 166.2; 2008/09: 189.0; 2009/10: 182.2; 2010/11: 229.4
    - y/y percent change: 2006/07: 22.6; 2007/08: 28.9; 2008/09: 13.7; 2009/10: -3.6; 2010/11: 25.9
  - Merchandise imports: 2006/07: 190.7; 2007/08: 257.6; 2008/09: 307.7; 2009/10: 299.5; 2010/11: 380.6
    - y/y percent change: 2006/07: 21.4; 2007/08: 35.1; 2008/09: 19.4; 2009/10: -2.7; 2010/11: 27.1
- Balance of payments (US$ billions)
  - Current account balance: 2006/07: -9.6; 2007/08: -15.7; 2008/09: -28.7; 2009/10: -38.4; 2010/11: -49.9
    - (in percent of GDP): 2006/07: -1.0; 2007/08: -1.3; 2008/09: -2.4; 2009/10: -2.9; 2010/11: -3.3
  - Foreign direct investment, net: 2006/07: 7.7; 2007/08: 15.9; 2008/09: 17.5; 2009/10: 19.7; 2010/11: 23.6
  - Portfolio investment, net (equity and debt): 2006/07: 7.1; 2007/08: 27.4; 2008/09: -14.0; 2009/10: 32.4; 2010/11: 31.8
  - Overall balance: 2006/07: 36.6; 2007/08: 92.2; 2008/09: -20.1; 2009/10: 13.4; 2010/11: 28.6
- External indicators
  - Gross reserves (in billions of U.S. dollars, end-period): 2006/07: 199.2; 2007/08: 309.7; 2008/09: 252.0; 2009/10: 279.1; 2010/11: 307.7
    - (In months of imports): 2006/07: 7.7; 2007/08: 10.3; 2008/09: 8.4; 2009/10: 7.5; 2010/11: 7.3
  - External debt (percent of GDP, end-period): 2006/07: 18.2; 2007/08: 18.3; 2008/09: 19.1; 2009/10: 19.5; 2010/11: 19.2
    - Of which: short-term debt: 2006/07: 3.7; 2007/08: 6.8; 2008/09: 7.5; 2009/10: 8.0; 2010/11: 8.2
  - Ratio of gross reserves to short-term debt (end-period): 2006/07: 5.7; 2007/08: 3.7; 2008/09: 2.8; 2009/10: 2.7; 2010/11: 2.5
  - Gross reserves to broad money (percent; end-period): 2006/07: 26.2; 2007/08: 30.9; 2008/09: 26.6; 2009/10: 22.4; 2010/11: ...
  - Debt service ratio: 2006/07: 4.9; 2007/08: 5.3; 2008/09: 5.2; 2009/10: 5.0; 2010/11: 5.1
  - Real effective exchange rate (y/y percent change, period average for annual data): 2006/07: -1.7; 2007/08: 7.3; 2008/09: -7.7; 2009/10: -0.5; 2010/11: ...
  - Exchange rate (rupee/US$, end-period): 2006/07: 43.5; 2007/08: 40.1; 2008/09: 50.7; 2009/10: 45.0; 2010/11: 45.9

### Key policy statements from authorities (Statement by Arvind Virmani and Michael Patra, December 22, 2010)
- Potential growth
  - Authorities estimate potential growth/underlying trend growth at 8.5 to 9.0 percent.
  - Full year projection for 2010/11 stated as 8.75 percent (+/- 0.35 percent).
- Inflation and monetary policy
  - RBI expects inflation to come down further to 5.5 percent by March 2011.
  - Policy rate at the time stated as 6.25 percent; described as positive in real terms given inflation projection.
- Fiscal policy and consolidation
  - Since FRBM Bill (2004), commitment to reducing fiscal deficit emphasized.
  - Central Government’s fiscal deficit reached 2.6 percent of GDP and State Governments’ fiscal deficit 1.5 percent of GDP pre-crisis.
  - Fiscal expansion of 3.3 percent of GDP in 2008-09 and of 3.9 percent of GDP in 2009-10 undertaken in response to the global crisis.
  - Authorities assert they will meet fiscal deficit target of 5.5 percent in 2010-11 and targets for the next two years.
  - States’ combined fiscal deficit targeting 3 percent of GDP within next four years per thirteenth Finance Commission recommendations.
  - Target to reduce general government debt/GDP from current level of 73 percent to 65 percent by 2014-15.
  - Over April–October 2010, fiscal deficit was 42.6 percent of the budget estimates for the full year; revenue deficit was 34.3 percent.
  - Net tax revenues grew by 26 percent in that period; non-tax revenues rose by 119 percent due to 3G and broadband wireless spectrum auctions.
  - Authorities caution against drastic reductions in public expenditure that could harm recovery; propose using windfall gains also for physical and social infrastructure.
- External sector and capital account
  - A rise of the current account deficit above 3 percent would increase risks from capital flow volatility.
  - Policy of building reserves over last few years defended.
  - Capital account liberalization viewed as a gradual, context-dependent process; both quantity and price-based instruments have been used historically to moderate debt flows.
  - Exchange rate policy described as flexible with interventions to manage excessive volatility.

_Extracted and summarized from the provided IMF content unit._

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2011/_cr1150.pdf_
