## _cr12129

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr12129](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2012/_cr12129.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2012/_cr12129.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2012/_cr12129.pdf.json)

---

### Executive summary: background and recent performance
- Real GDP growth averaged around 5½ percent a year during 2007-10; growth was driven mainly by agriculture and was inclusive (headcount poverty index fell to 48½ percent in 2010 from 58 percent in 2003).
- Inflation ranged between 2½ and 7 percent (year-on-year) during 2007-10 and averaged around 5 percent a year during 2007–11.
- Government revenues fell from nearly 17½ percent of GDP in 2007 to just under 15 percent of GDP in 2010 and were 14.9 percent of GDP in 2011.
- Expenditures (excluding donor financed projects) rose from about 14½ percent of GDP to 18 percent of GDP between 2007 and 2010.
- Domestic public debt increased to nearly 30 percent of GDP by end-2010 and to GMD 8,697 million (30.4 percent of GDP) at end-2011; three-fourths of domestic debt (GMD 6,522 million) was in T-bills with maturities of one year or less.
- Interest on debt consumed 22½ percent of government revenues in 2011, of which 18½ percentage points was paid on domestic debt; interest on domestic debt estimated to consume 18 percent of government revenues in 2011 in other tables.
- The previous ECF arrangement (approved February 2007) expired in March 2011 without completion of the final review because of a large fiscal slippage in late 2010 (about 3 percentage points of GDP).
- Execution of macroeconomic policies improved markedly in 2011: strict cash-budgeting limited net domestic borrowing to about 3 percent of GDP and nearly cleared government overdrafts from the CBG.

### Shock: 2011–12 drought and immediate near-term impact
- Crop failures: production of leading crops (rice, groundnuts, and millet) fell by 50-80 percent in the 2011-12 agricultural season.
- Human impact: over 400,000 people—about one-fourth of the population—face acute food shortages; lack of seeds threatens to prolong the crisis.
- Emergency cost: imports of food, seeds, and fertilizer expected to cost US$23-28 million (about 2½-3 percent of GDP); program projection for total cost of drought relief activities: US$23 million.
- Government initial financing: government will initially bear much of the cost and anticipate donor assistance later; government allocations for drought relief: US$4.6 million; commitments of donor assistance: US$11.2 million.
- Balance of payments support: CBG stands ready to provide foreign exchange and sterilized financing for emergency imports; official gross international reserves at end-2011 were slightly above the CBG’s target of 5 months of imports and reported as USD 182.5 million (end-2012 projection table).
- Short-term fiscal financing risk: if no emergency donor assistance is forthcoming, NDB could rise to a maximum of 3.7 percent of GDP in 2012 (program text); expected NDB during first half of 2012: GMD 799 million; for 2012 as a whole, staff projected NDB could rise to 3.8 percent of GDP in DSA assumptions.

### Near- and medium-term growth outlook and scenarios
- 2012 projection: Real GDP projected to contract by 1½-2 percent in 2012 (staff text); authorities forecast contraction of 1.7 percent in 2012.
- Recovery path: With agricultural recovery spread over 2-3 years, real GDP growth projected to boost to about 8-10 percent a year in 2013-14, conditional on effective response and support.
- Non-agricultural sector: non-agricultural GDP projected to grow at prevailing trends (about 5½ percent a year in real terms) over the medium term, with a moderate tourism setback in 2012-13.
- Alternate DSA growth assumptions: rebound to nearly 10 percent in 2013 and long-term real GDP growth of 5½ percent by 2016 (DSA Box 1 summary).
- Key macro projections (selected):
  - Nominal GDP (millions dalasi): 26,659 (2011 Act.), 28,637 (2012 Proj.), 29,435 (2013 Proj.), 34,014 (2014 Proj.), 38,815 (2015 Proj.), 43,555 (2016 Proj.).
  - GDP at constant prices (percent change): 5.5 (2011 Act.), 3.3 (2012 Proj.), -1.7 (2013 Proj.), 9.7 (2014 Proj.), 8.3 (2015 Proj.), 7.0 (2016 Proj.).
  - GDP per capita (US$): 550 (2011 Act.), 543 (2012 Proj.), 508 (2013 Proj.), 541 (2014 Proj.), 576 (2015 Proj.), 605 (2016 Proj.).
  - Consumer prices (average): 5.0 (2011 Act.), 4.8 (2012 Proj.), 4.7 (2013 Proj.), 5.5 (2014 Proj.), 5.5 (2015 Proj.), 5.0 (2016 Proj.).
  - Real GDP scenario overview in DSA: contraction ~-1½ percent in 2012, rebound to nearly 10 percent in 2013, long-run 5½ percent.

### Fiscal strategy, milestones, and revenue reforms
- Fiscal anchor: reduce government’s net domestic borrowing to ½ percent of GDP a year by 2014.
- Fiscal path and domestic debt targets:
  - Under adjustment path, stock of domestic debt projected to be about 26½ percent of GDP at end-2014 (from around 30½ percent at end-2011 and 33 percent at end-2012).
  - Government’s interest bill projected to increase in 2012 to 23½ percent of government revenue before declining thereafter.
- Revenue mobilization targets:
  - Target: tax revenue-to-GDP ratio to recover by at least 2½ percentage points by 2014 to just over 15½ percent of GDP.
  - Planned introduction of a VAT on January 1, 2013 expected to lift revenues by 1-1½ percent of GDP (upper bound potential 2½ percent of GDP); VAT policy paper Cabinet-approved and draft VAT bill completed in February 2012.
  - VAT timetable: submit VAT bill to National Assembly — End-May 2012; introduce VAT — January 1, 2013.
- Fuel pricing and subsidy reduction:
  - New fuel pricing formula introduced January 2011; monthly adjustments reinstated January 2012.
  - Pump prices were 8.3 percent (weighted average) below full pass-through in December 2011 and still 8.3 percent as of May 2012.
  - Adjustments projected to cut revenue losses from the subsidy to around 0.5 percent of GDP in 2012, down from around 0.8 percent of GDP in 2011.
- Expenditure control and PFM reforms:
  - Continue cash-budgeting in near term; strengthen IFMIS and publish quarterly budget execution reports beginning 2012:Q2.
  - Near-term PFM measures: review, update and cost strategic plans for selected line ministries and incorporate an indicative MTEF in 2013 budget papers; external auditing backlog to be cleared by mid-2013.
  - Indicative targets for poverty-reducing spending (GMD millions): 905 (Jun. 2012), 1,358 (Sep. 2012), 1,811 (Dec. 2012).

### Debt management, DSA results, and borrowing rules
- Debt risk classification: The Gambia remains at high risk of debt distress.
- External borrowing rules:
  - All new external borrowing by government will require a minimum grant element of 35 percent.
  - External borrowing by SOEs with explicit government guarantees restricted to concessional terms; SOEs without explicit guarantees excluded.
  - Under concessionality condition, moderate scope for additional borrowing of about US$38 million beyond proposed ECF to help finance PAGE.
- DSA baseline and key vulnerabilities:
  - PV of external debt to exports projected at 199 percent in 2012 (threshold 100); projected to fall below threshold only in 2031.
  - PV of external debt to GDP: just over 34 percent in 2012; declines over time with sustained growth assumptions.
  - Debt service ratios are below thresholds but sensitive to shocks.
- Alternative scenarios and stress tests:
  - Less favorable borrowing terms (interest rate +2 percentage points) substantially worsen debt indicators; stresses underscore need for concessional financing.
  - PAGE financing scenario (additional US$38 million 2012–2016) keeps sustainability broadly intact but delays breach resolution (drop below threshold around 2032).
  - Bound tests show most extreme shocks (one-time 30 percent depreciation; one-standard deviation export growth shock) cause debt indicators to breach thresholds.

### Monetary policy, exchange rate, and reserves
- Monetary objectives:
  - CBG intends to limit reserve and broad money growth in 2012 to 7 percent and 9 percent, respectively (also stated: 7 percent reserve and 9 percent broad money; elsewhere medium-term growth targets around 11–13 percent).
  - CBG target: annual inflation about 5 percent.
  - Policy instruments: use rediscount rate primarily to signal stance; study alternative policy interest rates; build capacity to target average daily reserve money.
- Fiscal dominance and central bank independence:
  - Fiscal dominance not fully eliminated in 2011: government arrears on interest due to the CBG around GMD 70 million (0.2 percent of GDP) were almost all cleared in January 2012.
  - Program: adhere to a zero limit on new CBG credit to the government at below-market terms; continue full repayment schedule for CBG-held government securities.
- Exchange rate and reserves:
  - Floating exchange rate will be maintained; interventions limited to orderly market conditions and reserve targets.
  - Gross reserves aim: about five months of imports of goods and services; gross official reserves reported as 163.3 (US$ millions) in 2011 Act. in one table and 182.5 (US$ millions) in projection table (2012 Proj.).
  - Net usable international reserves (US$ millions): 126.5 (2011 Act.), 135.1 (2012 Proj.), 128.5 (2013 Proj.), 137.4 (2014 Proj.).

### Financial sector policies and access to credit
- Banking sector health and supervision:
  - Banks are liquid and well capitalized but face eroded profitability and a substantial stock of nonperforming loans (Nonperforming loans to total gross loans: 12.9 (2011)).
  - Raise minimum capital requirement for commercial banks from GMD 150 million to GMD 200 million by end-December 2012 with no regulatory forbearance.
  - Introduce electronic reporting system (V-RegCoSS), review Manual of Guidelines, migrate to a fully risk-based supervisory framework over the medium term.
  - Require audited financial statements in IFRS by end-2013 and introduce enhanced loan classification and provisioning (special mention loans 30-90 days past due with 5 percent provisioning).
- Measures to increase access to credit:
  - Review reserve requirements; address legal/institutional obstacles to loan recovery; fix Credit Reference Bureau technical problems by mid-2012.
  - Set up a Collateral Registry by 2013.
  - Reduce stamp duty on mortgages and review Sheriffs and Mortgages Acts with IMF TA.

### PAGE and structural reforms
- PAGE (Programme for Accelerated Growth and Employment) launched December 2011 as the PRSP around five pillars; financing challenges require:
  - Rebuilt domestic revenue, donor grants, concessional borrowing, and private sector participation.
  - Institutional and regulatory frameworks to enable productive private participation.
- Structural priorities and studies:
  - Formulate national energy strategy by end-2012.
  - Initiate strategic study of GAMTEL and GAMCEL (sign contract by September 2012).
  - Explore PPPs and competition/regulation in fuel import market.
  - Prioritize PAGE projects with high rates of return and minimize contingent liabilities.

### IMF support, program structure, and monitoring
- Request and approval:
  - Authorities requested a three-year ECF arrangement totaling SDR 18.66 million (60.00 percent of quota).
  - IMF Executive Board approved a three-year ECF arrangement equivalent to SDR 18.66 million; immediate disbursement SDR 9.33 million (30.00 percent of quota).
- Disbursement schedule (SDR):
  - May 25, 2012: 9,330,000 (30.00 percent of quota) — Executive Board approval.
  - Subsequent disbursements: six equal tranches of 1,555,000 (5.00 percent of quota) on completion of semi-annual reviews.
  - Total: 18,660,000 (60.00 percent of quota); The Gambia's quota is SDR 31.1 million.
- Program emphasis: tax policy and revenue administration reforms (VAT introduction); capacity building in PFM and debt management; improvements in monetary policy operations and financial sector oversight; PAGE implementation.
- Performance criteria, targets, and TMU:
  - Quantitative performance criteria and indicative targets include ceilings on net domestic borrowing and net domestic assets, floors on net usable international reserves, floors on total government revenues and poverty-reducing expenditures.
  - TMU exchange rates (December 2011 end-of-period market rates): 30.24 GMD/USD, 1.29 USD/EUR, 1.55 USD/GBP, 1.06 USD/CHF, 1.54 USD/SDR.
  - Specific program ceilings (GMD millions, cumulative from start-2012): NDB ceiling — Jun. 2012: 799; Sep. 2012: 464 (indicative); Dec. 2012: 1,094.
  - Floor on net usable international reserves (USD millions): Jun. 2012: 112.7; Sep. 2012: 124.9; Dec. 2012: 125.5.
  - Adjusters: NDB and NDA adjusted downward by dalasi equivalent of donor-provided drought relief beyond World Bank and AfDB grants (totaling USD 8.9 million in 2012), up to USD 14.1 million; NIR adjusted upward by U.S. dollar equivalent of such donor assistance up to USD 14.1 million.

### Key fiscal and external projections (selected numeric highlights)
- Domestic revenue (percent of GDP): 14.9 (2011 Act.), 14.9 (2012 Proj.), 15.8 (2013 Proj.), 17.2 (2014 Proj.), 17.5 (2015 Proj.), 17.5 (2016 Proj.).
- Grants (percent of GDP): 4.0 (2011 Act.), 4.7 (2012 Proj.), 6.7 (2013 Proj.), 5.4 (2014 Proj.), 5.4 (2015 Proj.), 5.5 (2016 Proj.).
- Total expenditures and net acquisition of financial assets (percent of GDP): 24.9 (2011 Act.), 24.0 (2012 Proj.), 27.7 (2013 Proj.), 25.1 (2014 Proj.), 25.0 (2015 Proj.), 25.0 (2016 Proj.).
- Public debt (percent of GDP): 69.6 (2011 Act.), 71.1 (2012 Proj.), 77.3 (2013 Proj.), 71.1 (2014 Proj.), 65.9 (2015 Proj.), 62.1 (2016 Proj.).
  - Domestic public debt (percent of GDP): 29.4 (2011 Act.), 30.4 (2012 Proj.), 33.1 (2013 Proj.), 29.7 (2014 Proj.), 26.5 (2015 Proj.), 24.1 (2016 Proj.).
  - External public debt (percent of GDP): 40.2 (2011 Act.), 40.8 (2012 Proj.), 44.2 (2013 Proj.), 41.4 (2014 Proj.), 39.4 (2015 Proj.), 38.0 (2016 Proj.).
- External current account balance (including budget support, US$ millions): -151.6 (2011 Act.), -138.2 (2012 Proj.), -167.5 (2013 Proj.), -153.4 (2014 Proj.), -159.2 (2015 Proj.), -163.0 (2016 Proj.).
- Gross financing requirements (A, US$ millions): 121.7 (2011 Prel.), 170.8 (2012), 150.5 (2013), 161.5 (2014), 168.9 (2015), 166.1 (2016), 167.3 (2017).
- Sources of financing (B, US$ millions): 126.6 (2011 Prel.), 154.0 (2012), 145.7 (2013), 156.7 (2014), 166.5 (2015), 163.7 (2016), 165.0 (2017).
- Financing gap (A–B): -4.9 (2011 Prel.), 16.8 (2012), 4.8 (2013), 4.8 (2014), 2.4 (2015), 2.4 (2016), 2.3 (2017).
- IMF financing (gross): 0.0 (2011 Prel.), 16.8 (2012), 4.8 (2013), 4.8 (2014), 2.4 (2015), 0.0 (2016), 0.0 (2017).

### Key structural benchmarks and reporting improvements
- Structural benchmarks (selected):
  - Submit VAT bill to National Assembly — End-May 2012; Introduce VAT — January 1, 2013.
  - Publish quarterly budget execution reports on MOFEA’s website — Continuous, beginning with Q2/2012.
  - Launch market for daily repos and reverse repos — January 2013.
  - Switch to fortnightly T-bill auction schedule — June 2013.
  - Raise minimum bank capital to GMD 200 million by end-December 2012.
  - Initiate strategic study of GAMTEL and GAMCEL — September 2012.
- Data and statistical improvements:
  - GBoS to post national accounts and CPI data with methodological information and a calendar — by June 2012.
  - Develop GDP by expenditure approach by 2013 and quarterly GDP estimates by 2014.
  - Improve BOP statistics and standardize re-exports reporting at border stations by end-2012.

### Staff appraisal summary: priorities and cautions
- Positive recognition: important steps to strengthen growth and stability; significant poverty reduction; improved fiscal discipline in 2011; timely delivery of drought relief crucial.
- Key policy recommendations:
  - Substantial fiscal adjustment to bring domestic debt under control; gradual reduction in NDB to reach ½ percent of GDP by 2014.
  - Rebuild revenue base via comprehensive tax policy and revenue administration reforms, including early introduction of a broadly based VAT.
  - Persist with monthly fuel price adjustments to eliminate costly subsidies and direct savings to programs benefiting the poor.
  - Continue steady progress on PFM reforms (MTEF, transparency, audits) and finalize debt management strategy to lower domestic debt cost and rollover risks.
  - Restrict external borrowing to concessional terms (grant element ≥35 percent) while at high risk of debt distress.
  - Strengthen CBG independence, adopt market-based liquidity management tools, and enhance financial sector supervision and stress testing.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpts, Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP), Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU), and Executive Board materials contained in document _cr12129.*

### Executive Summary ......................................................................................................

### Executive Summary

### Background and Performance Under the Previous Fund Arrangement
- Real GDP growth averaged around 5½ percent a year during 2007-10, driven mainly by agriculture.
- Growth was inclusive: the incidence of poverty fell to 48½ percent of the population in 2010, down from 58 percent in 2003.
- Inflation ranged between 2½ and 7 percent (year-on-year) during 2007-10.
- Government revenues fell from nearly 17½ percent of GDP in 2007 to just under 15 percent of GDP in 2010.
- Expenditures (excluding donor financed projects) rose from about 14½ percent of GDP to 18 percent of GDP between 2007 and 2010.
- Extrabudgetary expenditures and realized contingent liabilities were major factors behind spending surges in 2009–10.
- Large fiscal deficits in the later years were mostly financed with domestic borrowing.
- Domestic public debt increased to nearly 30 percent of GDP by end-2010, consisting mostly of treasury bills with maturities of one year or less.
- Interest on debt consumed 22½ percent of government revenues in 2011, of which 18½ percentage points was paid on domestic debt.
- The previous ECF arrangement (approved February 2007) experienced slippages; the final review was not completed due to a large fiscal slippage in late 2010 (about 3 percentage points of GDP).
- Execution of macroeconomic policies improved markedly in 2011: authorities implemented strict cash-budgeting, limiting net domestic borrowing to about 3 percent of GDP, and nearly cleared government overdrafts from the Central Bank of The Gambia (CBG).

### Recent Developments
- A severe drought produced a major crop failure in the 2011-12 agricultural season: production of leading crops (rice, groundnuts, and millet) fell by 50-80 percent from the previous year’s harvest.
- Over 400,000 people—about one-fourth of the population—face acute food shortages; lack of seeds threatens to prolong the crisis.
- The government will initially bear much of the cost of relief efforts, notably imports of food, seeds, and fertilizer costing US$23-28 million or 2½-3 percent of GDP.
- Official gross international reserves at end-2011 were slightly above the CBG’s target of 5 months of imports of goods and services.
- Real GDP growth is estimated to have fallen to just under 3½ percent in 2011.
- Inflation remained under control at 4.4 percent in 2011, reflecting continued monetary restraint by the CBG.
- Strong tourism receipts contributed to a narrowing of the external current account deficit to an estimated 14 percent of GDP in 2011.
- Net domestic borrowing (NDB) was held to 3.1 percent of GDP in 2011, slightly above the budget target of 2.8 percent of GDP.
- Government revenues kept pace with GDP growth in 2011 due to strong administration and enforcement, but revenues still fell short of budget targets largely because of implicit fuel subsidies.
- Implicit fuel subsidies emerged from pump prices lagging import prices; retail prices were 5-10 percent below full pass-through as of December.

### Near- and Medium-Term Outlook and Risks
- The Gambian economy faces two overarching policy challenges:
  - Fiscal adjustment to lower the cost and risks of domestic debt.
  - Implementation of the Programme for Accelerated Growth and Employment (PAGE) under tight financing constraints.
- Fiscal adjustment anchor: reduction of government’s net domestic borrowing to ½ percent of GDP a year by 2014.
- Fiscal savings from lower interest costs are expected to eventually help finance PAGE, but additional assistance from development partners and private investment in infrastructure will be needed.
- Establishing proper institutions and regulatory frameworks is critical to ensure productive private sector participation.
- Risks include prolonged agricultural shortfalls, pressures on public finances from emergency relief needs, and the potential for renewed fiscal slippages.

### Economic Program and Policy Measures (2012–15) — Key Elements
- Authorities committed to comprehensive tax policy, revenue administration, and public financial management reforms to support fiscal adjustment.
- Introduction of a VAT in January 2013 is a central element of the tax reform.
- Authorities committed to adjusting fuel prices to eliminate subsidies, implemented at a gradual pace with monthly pump-price adjustments.
- The CBG stands ready to provide foreign exchange and financing for emergency imports to maintain macroeconomic stability during the drought crisis.

### Fund Support Request and Staff Recommendation
- The authorities are requesting a new three-year ECF arrangement with a large initial disbursement but relatively low overall access of 60 percent of quota.
- The initial disbursement would support stability during the current drought crisis; subsequent disbursements would encourage fiscal adjustment and catalyze donor support for PAGE.
- IMF staff recommends approval of the authorities’ request for an ECF arrangement.

*Source: Executive Summary, Country Report (IMF).*

### 6.      The crop failure in 2011-12 will affect economic growth over the near and

### 6.      The crop failure in 2011-12 will affect economic growth over the near and medium term.

### Impact on growth and sectoral outlook
- Real GDP is projected to contract by 1½-2 percent in 2012, reflecting effects of the crop failure carrying over into the first half of 2012.
- With a recovery in agriculture spread over 2-3 years, real GDP growth is projected to receive a boost to about 8-10 percent a year in 2013-14, conditional on an effective response by government, aid agencies, and development partners.
- Timely purchase and distribution of seeds and fertilizer is highlighted as particularly important for a faster recovery.
- Non-agricultural GDP is projected to grow at prevailing trends (about 5½ percent a year in real terms) over the medium-term, except for a moderate setback in tourism during the 2012-13 season.
- GDP growth figures could be further elevated depending on the financial support and effectiveness of the authorities’ new poverty reduction strategy, the Programme for Accelerated Growth and Employment (PAGE), launched in December 2011.

### Medium-term macroeconomic framework and projections
- Annual inflation would be contained to about 5 percent, in line with the CBG’s objective.
- After a spike in 2012 related to emergency imports, the external current account deficit is projected to narrow gradually over the medium term to 13-14 percent of GDP by 2015, reflecting renewed growth in agricultural exports, tourism receipts, and remittances.
- Financing of the current account deficit would largely come from foreign direct investment and project grants and loans from development partners.
- The authorities would strive to maintain gross official international reserves at about 5 months of imported goods and services.

### Main risks to the outlook
- Heavy debt burden, particularly domestic debt: growth of domestic debt slowed in 2011 but the stock increased slightly relative to GDP; interest costs and rollover risks remain high. The Gambia is still at high risk of debt distress.
- Other downside risks include:
  - prolonged weakness in the global economy, particularly in Europe, which could dampen tourism and remittances;
  - terms of trade shocks, especially on food and fuel prices;
  - contingent liabilities;
  - weather-related risks to mostly rain-fed agriculture.
- Although direct exposure to financial problems in Europe is negligible, a vast majority of commercial banks in The Gambia are subsidiaries of multinational banks headquartered in the region, which warrants caution.

### Economic program for 2012–15: overarching policy challenges
- Two overarching policy challenges:
  - (i) fiscal adjustment to lower the cost and risks of domestic debt;
  - (ii) implementation of the PAGE under tight financing constraints.
- Program focus areas:
  - (i) reduction of government’s annual NDB over the medium term;
  - (ii) tax policy and revenue administration reforms to increase revenues and improve competitiveness;
  - (iii) public financial management (PFM) reforms to enhance budget procedures and expenditure control;
  - (iv) independence of the CBG—free of fiscal dominance—to allow more consistent and predictable monetary policy;
  - (v) financial sector oversight;
  - (vi) institutional reforms to enable productive private sector participation in financing the PAGE.

### Immediate relief for the crop failure (near term)
- Food, seeds, and fertilizer will need to be imported and distributed to affected households by mid-2012.
- Emergency imports of food, seeds, and fertilizer are expected to cost US$23-28 million (about 2½-3 percent of GDP).
- The government anticipates some donor assistance for drought relief and budget support later in the year, but will initially need to obtain most resources through domestic borrowing.
- To ensure stability in domestic markets, the CBG will directly lend to the government and provide foreign exchange for drought-related imports; CBG’s claims on government will be in the form of T-bills discounted at market rates (equivalent to fully sterilized government borrowing and acting partly as a bridge loan to be repaid when donor funding is delivered), but this creates an immediate balance of payments need.
- For 2012 as a whole, if no emergency donor assistance is forthcoming, NDB could rise to a maximum of 3.7 percent of GDP, well above the original target of 1.8 percent of GDP set in the budget.
- The CBG’s ample stock of official international reserves has been critical to enable the authorities to maintain macroeconomic stability during the crisis.

### Fiscal adjustment path and milestones
- Fiscal policy is expected to return to a path of gradual adjustment whereby NDB would be reduced to ½ percent of GDP a year beginning in 2014.
- Under this path, the stock of domestic debt would be reduced to about 26½ percent of GDP at end-2014 (from around 30½ percent of GDP at end-2011 and 33 percent of GDP at end-2012).
- The government’s interest bill is projected to continue to increase in 2012 (to 23½ percent of government revenue), before dropping steadily thereafter.
- A combination of higher revenue and continued expenditure restraint will be needed to achieve desired reductions in NDB.

Key fiscal policy milestones:
- Rebuild the revenue base:
  - Target: tax revenue-to-GDP ratio to steadily recover by at least 2½ percentage points by 2014 to just over 15½ percent of GDP.
  - Planned introduction of VAT in January 2013 to replace the current general sales tax; VAT expected to lift revenues by 1-1½ percent of GDP.
  - Cabinet approval of the VAT policy paper and drafting of the VAT bill to be submitted to the National Assembly around mid-2012; agenda for major improvements in revenue administration and public information programs are underway.
  - Note: On the upper bound, the VAT could boost revenues by 2½ percent of GDP. Beginning in 2013, if revenue collections exceed the program target, at least half the excess will be used for paying down domestic debt.
- Minimize subsidies on fuels:
  - Regular (monthly) implementation of fuel price adjustments has improved in 2012 and is expected to continue, though increases have been less than suggested by the pricing formula.
  - These adjustments are projected to cut revenue losses from the subsidy to around 0.5 percent of GDP in 2012, down from around 0.8 percent of GDP in 2011.
  - Authorities are committed to continue adjustments until subsidies have been eliminated and aim to limit or discontinue exemptions from fuel taxes for embassies and businesses whose special incentives are expiring.
  - As of May 2012, fuel subsidies stood at 8.3 percent (weighted average) of the full pass-through prices, the same as in December 2011.
- Conduct studies for further tax reform:
  - A thorough study of tax expenditures will be undertaken during 2012 to gauge revenue potential from eliminating subsidies and exemptions and to inform parameters for future reforms.
- Maintain cash budgeting in 2012 while improving budget processes and transparency over the medium term:
  - Continue cash-budgeting approach in the near term; strengthen IFMIS and publish quarterly reports on budget execution beginning in 2012:Q2, including PAGE-related spending.
  - Near-term PFM reforms: review, update, and cost strategic plans for selected line ministries and incorporate an indicative MTEF in the policy paper for the 2013 budget; expand MTEF coverage thereafter.
  - Seek technical assistance for comprehensive civil service reform.

### Debt management strategy
- New debt management strategy to be finalized in coming months and should be consistent with recommendations from the DSA update by Fund staff.
- Given The Gambia’s high risk of debt distress, all new external borrowing by government will require a minimum grant element of 35 percent.
- External borrowing by state-owned enterprises (SOEs) with explicit government guarantees will be restricted to concessional terms; external borrowing by SOEs not explicitly guaranteed by government is excluded at this time.
- Under the concessionality condition, there is moderate scope (about US$38 million) for additional borrowing, beyond the proposed ECF arrangement, to help finance the PAGE.
- On domestic debt, strategy advocates gradual reduction in annual NDB in line with the proposed ECF arrangement; if T-bill yields decline, opportunity to issue longer-term securities to lengthen maturity structure and lower rollover risks.

### Boxed reforms: Tax policy and revenue administration (summary)
- Objective: relatively simple tax system with a broad base and efficient revenue administration to restore buoyancy and competitiveness.
- Core taxes envisaged: broad-based VAT; simplified personal and corporate income taxes (possibly single rate); customs duties in line with ECOWAS common external tariff; consistent excise taxes including preservation of excises on fuel with import-price pass-through mechanism.
- Further work needed on income tax structure and parameters; comprehensive study of tax expenditures and elimination of “nuisance” taxes recommended.
- Revenue administration strengthening: build Gambia Revenue Authority (GRA) auditing and risk management capacity; transfer companies with turnover exceeding GMD 1 million to GRA’s Large Taxpayer Unit (LTU).
- Filing compliance with the LTU increased from around 50 percent to close to 90 percent.
- By end-2012, ASYCUDA++ will be rolled out to all customs offices across the country.

### Boxed reforms: Public Financial Management (PFM) (summary)
- PFM reforms aim to modernize budget preparation, execution, monitoring, and auditing to improve value-for-money from government spending and support PAGE.
- Cash budgeting remains essential short-term; strengthened IFMIS and quarterly budget execution reports and internal auditing will enhance transparency and control.
- With EU-financed Fund technical assistance, develop annual budget framework papers and medium-term expenditure frameworks (MTEFs) for line ministries, to be consolidated into a national MTEF over time.
- Move to program budgeting is a long-term goal requiring capacity building.
- External auditing: 2007 audited government accounts submitted to the National Assembly; National Audit Office expected to clear backlog of audits by mid-2013.
- A debt management strategy seeking to lower the domestic debt burden is being developed.

*Source: IMF staff report chapter on The Gambia’s 2012–15 economic outlook and program.*

### 17.      Monetary policy will continue to focus on maintaining low inflation by targeting

### 17.      Monetary policy will continue to focus on maintaining low inflation by targeting

### Monetary policy stance and operations
- CBG intends to limit reserve and broad money growth in 2012 to 7 percent and 9 percent, respectively.
- These growth rates "considerably exceed nominal GDP" but are viewed as consistent with a "somewhat restrained monetary stance" to guard against potential inflationary pressures.
- Despite government’s heavy borrowing in 2012, CBG provided sterilized financing for the drought relief effort, allowing sufficient space for a comfortable expansion of credit to the private sector.
- Credit growth in the coming years will benefit from the reduction in NDB.
- Recent progress toward eliminating fiscal dominance and strengthening central bank independence provides an opportunity to improve monetary policy conduct.
- Fiscal dominance was not completely eliminated in 2011, as evidenced by government arrears on interest due to the CBG of about GMD 70 million (0.2 percent of GDP); these arrears were almost all cleared in January 2012.
- CBG actions and plans:
  - Improve liquidity forecasting rather than reacting to fiscal surprises.
  - Launch market tools for daily liquidity management.
  - Enhance competition in T-bill auctions.
  - Build capacity to target average daily reserve money (on a monthly basis) over the medium term, given its more stable relationship with broader money aggregates than end-period reserve money.
  - Use the rediscount rate primarily to signal policy stance, while studying alternative policy interest rates that could have a greater influence on market rates.
- CBG plans to conduct a study of alternative policy interest rates. [MEFP ¶23-24]

### Exchange rate policy and reserves
- The floating exchange rate regime has served The Gambia well, complemented by a healthy stock of international reserves to guard against shocks.
- Flexibility in 2011 allowed a moderate depreciation of the dalasi in real effective terms, adjusting from a prevailing overvaluation and helping preserve competitiveness.
- CBG intervenes in the foreign exchange market mainly to:
  - Safeguard orderly market conditions,
  - Mop up liquidity injections caused by foreign-financed government spending,
  - Occasionally purchase foreign exchange to meet reserve targets.
- During the drought crisis, maintaining an ample stock of reserves ensured macroeconomic stability.
- Over the medium term, CBG aims to maintain gross reserves at about five months of imports of goods and services, consistent with reserve adequacy analysis for The Gambia. [MEFP ¶23]

### Financial sector policies
- Policy objectives: strengthen financial stability and enhance access to credit for the private sector.
- Key issues:
  - Banks are liquid and well capitalized but face eroded profitability and a substantial stock of nonperforming loans due to fierce competition for a small customer base.
  - High concentration of both loans and deposits is a concern.
- Planned supervisory and regulatory measures:
  - Launch an electronic reporting system for commercial banks.
  - Review Manual of Guidelines and Instructions.
  - Introduce amendments to the Banking Act 2009.
  - Raise the minimum capital requirement for commercial banks from GMD 150 million to GMD 200 million by end-December 2012, with no regulatory forbearance.
  - Continue consultation with banking supervisors from countries where banks’ headquarters are located.
  - Apply intensive surveillance to banks that exceed critical numbers of risk factors, including participation by headquarters’ management of foreign-owned banks, if necessary.
  - Gradually migrate from a hybrid (compliance and risk-based) to a fully risk-based supervisory framework in the medium term. [MEFP ¶25-26]

### Measures to increase access to credit
- Authorities intend to:
  - Review reserve requirements.
  - Encourage commercial banks to become more efficient.
  - Reduce legal and institutional obstacles in recovering loans and realizing collateral.
- CBG will resolve technical problems at the Credit Reference Bureau to help contain nonperforming loans and enable borrowers with good credit histories to access financing on better terms.
- With IMF technical assistance and stakeholder consultation, CBG will review the Sheriffs and Mortgages Acts for amendments to reduce cost, uncertainty, and complexity in dealing with non-performing loans.
- Authorities intend to set up a Collateral Registry by 2013. [MEFP ¶27]

### PAGE and other structural reforms
- PAGE (Programme for Accelerated Growth and Employment) 2012–2015 launched December 2011; PAGE is the country’s PRSP and organized around five pillars.
- Financing challenges:
  - Substantial financial resources required for medium-term investment plans.
  - Some scope for additional concessional external borrowing consistent with debt sustainability, but authorities must seek alternative funding sources: domestic revenue mobilization, external grants, and private sector participation in infrastructure projects.
  - Pursuing planned fiscal adjustment will create additional fiscal space for PAGE priorities.
- Institutional requirements for productive private participation include effective frameworks and regulatory agencies.
- Planned studies and strategies:
  - Formulate a national energy strategy in consultation with development partners to ensure a financially viable electric utility company.
  - Initiate a strategic study of GAMTEL and GAMCEL, considering the option to re-privatize GAMCEL in line with PAGE objectives.
  - Increase competition or strengthen regulation of the fuel import market to reduce energy costs.
- Structural reforms aim to eliminate major sources of contingent liabilities that have impaired government finances. [MEFP ¶28]

### Economic statistics
- Data quality: generally adequate but room for improvement.
- Next steps:
  - Develop GDP statistics by the expenditure approach.
  - Produce quarterly GDP statistics.
  - Update CPI statistics based on the 2010 integrated household survey.
  - Improve BOP statistics, particularly re-exports and FDI.
- Authorities will continue capacity-building and welcome Fund technical assistance. [MEFP ¶29]

### New ECF arrangement and program monitoring
- Authorities request a new three-year ECF arrangement with large initial disbursement but relatively low overall access:
  - Requested access totaling 60 percent of quota (SDR 18.66 million).
  - 30 percent of quota (SDR 9.33 million) available for immediate disbursement following Board approval.
  - Remainder disbursed in six equal tranches of 5 percent of quota (SDR 1.555 million), one following each of the six semi-annual reviews.
- Rationale:
  - Relatively low overall access appropriate given gradual reform approach.
  - Large initial disbursement comparable to emergency support to meet an acute balance of payments need during the drought crisis.
  - Subsequent disbursements to encourage gradual fiscal adjustment and catalyze PAGE support from development partners.
- Program emphasis: tax policy and revenue administration reforms; capacity building in PFM and debt management; improvements in monetary policy operations and financial sector oversight; PAGE implementation.
- Performance criteria and structural benchmarks agreed (see MEFP Tables 2 and 3) covering: introducing a VAT; publishing quarterly budget execution reports; launching the market for daily REPO instruments; publishing national accounts and CPI data with methodological information and a data calendar.

### Debt, repayment capacity, and risks
- Repayment capacity:
  - Total outstanding loans from the Fund, once the ECF is disbursed, will amount to 5.5 percent of GDP or about 27 percent of gross international reserves at end-2012.
  - Debt service-to-revenue ratio excluding grants is 12 percent in 2012, below the threshold of 18 percent over the repayment period.
- Principal risks to the program:
  - Shocks to import prices of fuel could outpace gradual pump price adjustments and cut into government revenues.
  - Delay in the introduction of the VAT could adversely affect tax revenues.
  - Realization of a large contingent liability could pressure government spending.
- Mitigating actions:
  - Continued implementation of cash budgeting and expenditure control to achieve NDB targets, which the authorities commit to as the anchor of macroeconomic policies.
  - If needed, additional revenue measures and/or expenditure cuts to stay within NDB limits.
  - Structural measures to strengthen financial viability of key government-owned enterprises to minimize contingent liabilities.

### Staff appraisal highlights
- Positive steps and achievements:
  - Important steps taken to strengthen growth and stability and significantly reduce poverty in recent years.
  - Improved fiscal discipline in 2011 welcomed as necessary to curb domestic debt growth.
  - Authorities’ actions to provide drought relief are noted; timely delivery is crucial to help vulnerable households.
  - Ample international reserves critical to ensuring stability during the crisis.
- Policy recommendations and cautions:
  - Substantial fiscal adjustment still needed to bring domestic debt fully under control; gradual approach may be effective but slippages would weaken credibility.
  - Rebuild government revenue base through comprehensive tax policy and revenue administration reforms; broadening the tax base is necessary to keep tax rates low.
  - Swift progress toward introducing a broadly based VAT early next year would be welcome.
  - Persist with monthly fuel price adjustments to minimize costly subsidies; if import prices increase sharply, stronger adjustments may be needed.
  - Direct additional revenues from reduced fuel subsidies toward programs or drought relief benefiting the poor.
  - Continue steady progress on PFM reforms: medium-term planning, transparency, improved execution and monitoring, and audits.
  - Move ahead with market-based instruments for liquidity management and strengthen financial sector supervision (stress testing, regional supervisor engagement, intensified supervision where risks are elevated).
  - Ensure smooth implementation of upcoming increase in minimum capital requirement for banks.
  - Finalize the revised debt management strategy soon; focus on reducing cost and risks of domestic debt by gradually reducing net domestic borrowing and, if conditions permit, issuing longer-term securities.
  - Restrict external borrowing to concessional terms while The Gambia remains at high risk of debt distress.
  - For PAGE financing, prioritize projects with high rates of return and ensure institutions/regulatory agencies are in place for productive private participation; complete strategic studies for GAMTEL/GAMCEL and a national energy strategy; consider privatization of GAMCEL to minimize contingent liabilities.

*Source: Excerpt from IMF staff report (MEFP and Staff Appraisal) contained in document _cr12129.*

### 34.      Staff encourages the authorities to make progress on the quality and regularity of key

### _cr12129 - 34.      Staff encourages the authorities to make progress on the quality and regularity of key

### Statistical and institutional recommendations
- Staff encourages the authorities to make progress on the quality and regularity of key economic statistics.
- Staff urges the authorities to begin to compile comprehensive employment statistics.
- Staff recommends approval of the authorities’ request for a new three-year ECF arrangement.

### Macro outlook and key projections (selected)
- Nominal GDP (millions of dalasi): 26,659 (2011 Act.), 28,637 (2012 Proj.), 29,435 (2013 Proj.), 34,014 (2014 Proj.), 38,815 (2015 Proj.), 43,555 (2016 Proj.).
- Nominal GDP (percent change): 10.5 (2011 Act.), 7.4 (2012 Proj.), 2.8 (2013 Proj.), 15.6 (2014 Proj.), 14.1 (2015 Proj.), 12.2 (2016 Proj.).
- GDP at constant prices (percent change): 5.5 (2011 Act.), 3.3 (2012 Proj.), -1.7 (2013 Proj.), 9.7 (2014 Proj.), 8.3 (2015 Proj.), 7.0 (2016 Proj.).
- GDP per capita (US$): 550 (2011 Act.), 543 (2012 Proj.), 508 (2013 Proj.), 541 (2014 Proj.), 576 (2015 Proj.), 605 (2016 Proj.).
- GDP deflator: 4.7 (2011 Act.), 4.0 (2012 Proj.), 4.6 (2013 Proj.), 5.3 (2014 Proj.), 5.3 (2015 Proj.), 4.9 (2016 Proj.).
- Consumer prices (average): 5.0 (2011 Act.), 4.8 (2012 Proj.), 4.7 (2013 Proj.), 5.5 (2014 Proj.), 5.5 (2015 Proj.), 5.0 (2016 Proj.).
- Consumer prices (end of period): 5.8 (2011 Act.), 4.4 (2012 Proj.), 5.0 (2013 Proj.), 6.0 (2014 Proj.), 5.0 (2015 Proj.), 5.0 (2016 Proj.).

### External sector and balance of payments (selected)
- Exports, f.o.b. (percent change): 3.8 (2011 Act.), 16.1 (2012 Proj.), -5.2 (2013 Proj.), 9.0 (2014 Proj.), 7.5 (2015 Proj.), 7.8 (2016 Proj.).
- Domestic exports (percent change): 26.0 (2011 Act.), 30.6 (2012 Proj.), -44.5 (2013 Proj.), 29.0 (2014 Proj.), 11.2 (2015 Proj.), 6.9 (2016 Proj.).
- Imports, f.o.b. (percent change): 5.3 (2011 Act.), 7.4 (2012 Proj.), 10.0 (2013 Proj.), -0.7 (2014 Proj.), 6.6 (2015 Proj.), 6.9 (2016 Proj.).
- Current account balance (excluding budget support, US$ millions): -151.6 (2011 Act.), -138.2 (2012 Proj.), -176.4 (2013 Proj.), -158.5 (2014 Proj.), -164.6 (2015 Proj.), -168.7 (2016 Proj.).
- Current account balance (including budget support, US$ millions): -151.6 (2011 Act.), -138.2 (2012 Proj.), -167.5 (2013 Proj.), -153.4 (2014 Proj.), -159.2 (2015 Proj.), -163.0 (2016 Proj.).
- Overall balance of payments (US$ millions): -25.7 (2011 Act.), 15.4 (2012 Proj.), -7.3 (2013 Proj.), 8.4 (2014 Proj.), 15.1 (2015 Proj.), 17.1 (2016 Proj.).
- Gross official reserves (US$ millions): 163.3 (2011 Act.), 182.5 (2012 Proj.), 191.6 (2013 Proj.), 203.3 (2014 Proj.), 220.0 (2015 Proj.), 233.6 (2016 Proj.).
- Reserves in months of next year's imports of goods and services: 4.6 (2011 Act.), 4.7 (2012 Proj.), 4.9 (2013 Proj.), 4.9 (2014 Proj.), 5.0 (2015 Proj.), 5.0 (2016 Proj.).

### Monetary and credit developments
- Broad money (percent change): 13.7 (2011 Act.), 11.0 (2012 Proj.), 9.0 (2013 Proj.), 14.9 (2014 Proj.), 14.1 (2015 Proj.), 13.4 (2016 Proj.).
- Net foreign assets (percent change): 1.3 (2011 Act.), 5.6 (2012 Proj.), 2.5 (2013 Proj.), 5.3 (2014 Proj.), 6.4 (2015 Proj.), 6.3 (2016 Proj.).
- Net domestic assets (percent change): 12.3 (2011 Act.), 5.4 (2012 Proj.), 6.5 (2013 Proj.), 9.6 (2014 Proj.), 7.7 (2015 Proj.), 7.1 (2016 Proj.).
- Credit to the government (net, percent change): 16.6 (2011 Act.), 8.2 (2012 Proj.), 6.6 (2013 Proj.), 1.9 (2014 Proj.), 0.8 (2015 Proj.), 0.7 (2016 Proj.).
- Credit to the private sector (net, percent change): 4.7 (2011 Act.), 2.8 (2012 Proj.), 5.6 (2013 Proj.), 8.0 (2014 Proj.), 7.1 (2015 Proj.), 6.6 (2016 Proj.).
- Velocity (level): 2.0 (2011 Act.), 1.9 (2012 Proj.), 1.8 (2013 Proj.), 1.8 (2014 Proj.), 1.8 (2015 Proj.), 1.8 (2016 Proj.).
- Net usable international reserves (in millions of U.S. dollars): 126.5 (2011 Act.), 135.1 (2012 Proj.), 128.5 (2013 Proj.), 137.4 (2014 Proj.), 153.0 (2015 Proj.), 170.5 (2016 Proj.).

### Fiscal outcomes and projections (central government)
- Domestic revenue (taxes and other revenues, percent of GDP): 14.9 (2011 Act.), 14.9 (2012 Proj.), 15.8 (2013 Proj.), 17.2 (2014 Proj.), 17.5 (2015 Proj.), 17.5 (2016 Proj.).
- Grants (percent of GDP): 4.0 (2011 Act.), 4.7 (2012 Proj.), 6.7 (2013 Proj.), 5.4 (2014 Proj.), 5.4 (2015 Proj.), 5.5 (2016 Proj.).
- Total expenditures and net acquisition of financial assets (percent of GDP): 24.9 (2011 Act.), 24.0 (2012 Proj.), 27.7 (2013 Proj.), 25.1 (2014 Proj.), 25.0 (2015 Proj.), 25.0 (2016 Proj.).
- Net incurrence of liabilities (percent of GDP): 5.8 (2011 Act.), 4.0 (2012 Proj.), 5.1 (2013 Proj.), 2.5 (2014 Proj.), 2.1 (2015 Proj.), 2.0 (2016 Proj.).
  - Foreign component: 1.5 (2011 Act.), 0.8 (2012 Proj.), 1.6 (2013 Proj.), 1.5 (2014 Proj.), 1.6 (2015 Proj.), 1.5 (2016 Proj.).
  - Domestic component: 4.3 (2011 Act.), 3.2 (2012 Proj.), 3.6 (2013 Proj.), 1.0 (2014 Proj.), 0.5 (2015 Proj.), 0.5 (2016 Proj.).
- Basic balance (percent of GDP): -3.3 (2011 Act.), -2.2 (2012 Proj.), -3.4 (2013 Proj.), -0.1 (2014 Proj.), 0.3 (2015 Proj.), 0.3 (2016 Proj.).
- Public debt (percent of GDP): 69.6 (2011 Act.), 71.1 (2012 Proj.), 77.3 (2013 Proj.), 71.1 (2014 Proj.), 65.9 (2015 Proj.), 62.1 (2016 Proj.).
  - Domestic public debt (percent of GDP): 29.4 (2011 Act.), 30.4 (2012 Proj.), 33.1 (2013 Proj.), 29.7 (2014 Proj.), 26.5 (2015 Proj.), 24.1 (2016 Proj.).
  - External public debt (percent of GDP): 40.2 (2011 Act.), 40.8 (2012 Proj.), 44.2 (2013 Proj.), 41.4 (2014 Proj.), 39.4 (2015 Proj.), 38.0 (2016 Proj.).
  - External public debt (millions of US$): 377.1 (2011 Act.), 386.0 (2012 Proj.), 400.8 (2013 Proj.), 416.2 (2014 Proj.), 434.1 (2015 Proj.), 452.1 (2016 Proj.).

### Central government operations (levels, selected)
- Revenue (local currency): 5,026 (2010 Act.), 5,619 (2011 Act.), 6,376 (2012 Budget), 6,633 (2013 Proj.), 7,680 (2014 Proj.), 8,888 (2015 Proj.), 10,016 (2016 Proj.).
- Taxes (local currency): 3,528 (2010 Act.), 3,780 (2011 Act.), 4,191 (2012 Budget), 4,111 (2013 Proj.), 5,211 (2014 Proj.), 6,043 (2015 Proj.), 6,774 (2016 Proj.).
- Grants (local currency): 1,065 (2010 Act.), 1,355 (2011 Act.), 1,669 (2012 Budget), 1,982 (2013 Proj.), 1,822 (2014 Proj.), 2,080 (2015 Proj.), 2,384 (2016 Proj.).
- Expenditures (local currency): 6,466 (2010 Act.), 6,871 (2011 Act.), 7,342 (2012 Budget), 8,175 (2013 Proj.), 8,528 (2014 Proj.), 9,701 (2015 Proj.), 10,881 (2016 Proj.).
- Net lending (+)/borrowing (–) (local currency): -1,440 (2010 Act.), -1,252 (2011 Act.), -966 (2012 Budget), -1,542 (2013 Proj.), -848 (2014 Proj.), -813 (2015 Proj.), -865 (2016 Proj.).

### Balance of payments detail (2012–16 projections, selected)
- Current account (US$ millions, goods and services): -176.7 (2012 Act.), -163.0 (2013 Proj.), -205.5 (2014 Proj.), -190.2 (2015 Proj.), -201.4 (2016 Proj.), -208.8 (2017 Proj.).
- Trade balance (US$ millions): -213.9 (2012 Act.), -221.3 (2013 Proj.), -260.6 (2014 Proj.), -248.4 (2015 Proj.), -263.6 (2016 Proj.), -280.5 (2017 Proj.).
- Exports, f.o.b. (US$ millions): 98.4 (2012 Act.), 114.2 (2013 Proj.), 108.2 (2014 Proj.), 118.0 (2015 Proj.), 126.9 (2016 Proj.), 136.8 (2017 Proj.).
- Imports, f.o.b. (US$ millions): -312.2 (2012 Act.), -335.4 (2013 Proj.), -368.8 (2014 Proj.), -366.4 (2015 Proj.), -390.5 (2016 Proj.), -417.3 (2017 Proj.).
- Capital and financial account (US$ millions): 139.0 (2012 Act.), 112.2 (2013 Proj.), 105.9 (2014 Proj.), 112.0 (2015 Proj.), 119.6 (2016 Proj.), 119.5 (2017 Proj.).
  - Foreign direct investment (US$ millions): 85.6 (2012 Act.), 60.1 (2013 Proj.), 73.1 (2014 Proj.), 66.5 (2015 Proj.), 69.8 (2016 Proj.), 73.3 (2017 Proj.).

### Financial soundness indicators (2011)
- Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 25.0 (2011).
- Tier-1 capital to risk-weighted assets: 26.1 (2011).
- Nonperforming loans to total gross loans: 12.9 (2011).
- Nonperforming loans net of provisions to capital: 4.7 (2011).
- Return on assets (average): 0.3 (2011).
- Return on equity (average): 1.8 (2011).
- Net Interest income to gross income: 37.1 (2011).
- Operating expenses to gross income: 59.5 (2011).
- Liquid assets to total assets: 41.5 (2011).
- Liquid assets to short-term liabilities: 64.2 (2011).
- Net open FX position to capital: -1.0 (2011).

### Fund financing and schedule under proposed ECF arrangement
- Proposed new ECF arrangement: three-year duration.
- Proposed schedule of reviews and disbursements (SDR):
  - May 25, 2012: 9,330,000 (30.00 percent of quota) — Executive Board approval of new ECF arrangement.
  - November 1, 2012: 1,555,000 (5.00 percent of quota) — Completion of first review.
  - May 1, 2013: 1,555,000 (5.00 percent of quota) — Completion of second review.
  - November 1, 2013: 1,555,000 (5.00 percent of quota) — Completion of third review.
  - May 1, 2014: 1,555,000 (5.00 percent of quota) — Completion of fourth review.
  - November 1, 2014: 1,555,000 (5.00 percent of quota) — Completion of fifth review.
  - March 15, 2015: 1,555,000 (5.00 percent of quota) — Completion of sixth review.
  - Total: 18,660,000 (60.00 percent of quota).
- The Gambia's quota is SDR 31.1 million.

### Indicators of capacity to repay the Fund (2012–20, selected)
- Disbursements under prospective ECF financing (SDR millions): 10.9 (2012), 3.1 (2013), 3.1 (2014), 1.6 (2015).
- Repayments (principal, SDR millions): 0.2 (2012), 1.0 (2013), 2.1 (2014), 3.8 (2015), 4.3 (2016), 4.3 (2017), 3.5 (2018), 2.4 (2019), 0.7 (2020).
- Outstanding Fund credit (SDR millions): 33.2 (prel. 2011), 35.4 (2012), 36.4 (2013), 34.1 (2014), 29.8 (2015), 24.6 (2016), 18.8 (2017), 13.2 (2018), 9.1 (2019), 2.3 (2020).
- Net use of Fund credit (millions of SDRs): 10.7 (2012), 2.1 (2013), 1.0 (2014), -2.3 (2015), -4.3 (2016), -5.2 (2017), -5.9 (2018), -5.5 (2019), -4.1 (2020).

### External financing requirements and sources (2011–17, selected)
- Gross financing requirements (A, US$ millions): 121.7 (2011 Prel.), 170.8 (2012), 150.5 (2013), 161.5 (2014), 168.9 (2015), 166.1 (2016), 167.3 (2017).
  - Current account deficit: 138.2 (2011 Prel.), 167.5 (2012), 153.4 (2013), 159.2 (2014), 163.0 (2015), 166.2 (2016), 169.7 (2017).
  - Amortization, net: 12.5 (2011 Prel.), 12.9 (2012), 14.3 (2013), 14.5 (2014), 15.0 (2015), 13.0 (2016), 13.1 (2017).
  - Private capital, net: -44.4 (2011 Prel.), -19.1 (2012), -30.4 (2013), -32.1 (2014), -28.6 (2015), -36.6 (2016), -38.9 (2017).
  - Reserves accumulation (increase): 15.4 (2011 Prel.), 9.5 (2012), 13.2 (2013), 19.9 (2014), 19.5 (2015), 23.5 (2016), 23.3 (2017).
- Sources of financing (B, US$ millions): 126.6 (2011 Prel.), 154.0 (2012), 145.7 (2013), 156.7 (2014), 166.5 (2015), 163.7 (2016), 165.0 (2017).
  - Capital grants and transfers: 46.2 (2011 Prel.), 54.3 (2012), 49.8 (2013), 54.3 (2014), 54.7 (2015), 60.6 (2016), 51.8 (2017).
  - Foreign Direct Investment, net: 60.1 (2011 Prel.), 73.1 (2012), 66.5 (2013), 69.8 (2014), 73.3 (2015), 79.0 (2016), 82.9 (2017).
  - New borrowing, gross: 21.4 (2011 Prel.), 27.7 (2012), 29.6 (2013), 32.4 (2014), 33.0 (2015), 33.3 (2016), 34.0 (2017).
- Financing gap (A–B): -4.9 (2011 Prel.), 16.8 (2012), 4.8 (2013), 4.8 (2014), 2.4 (2015), 2.4 (2016), 2.3 (2017).
- IMF financing (gross): 0.0 (2011 Prel.), 16.8 (2012), 4.8 (2013), 4.8 (2014), 2.4 (2015), 0.0 (2016), 0.0 (2017).
- Residual external financing gap: 0.0 (2011 Prel.), 0.0 (2012), 0.0 (2013), 0.0 (2014), 0.0 (2015), 2.4 (2016), 2.3 (2017).

*Source: Gambian authorities and Fund staff estimates and projections contained in the provided IMF document.*

### 1.      The policies implemented by the Government of The Gambia (GoG) in recent years

### _cr12129 - 1.      The policies implemented by the Government of The Gambia (GoG) in recent years

### Macroeconomic overview and program background
- The GoG policies were supported by an IMF arrangement under the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) approved in February 2007, augmented in February 2009 and February 2010; the arrangement expired in March 2011 without completion of the final review because of fiscal slippages.
- The GoG requests a new three-year ECF arrangement in an amount equivalent to SDR 18.66 million (60 percent of quota), with the first disbursement upon approval equivalent to SDR 9.33 million (30 percent of quota).
- The attached Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP) and Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU) describe recent developments and the GoG’s policy agenda for 2012–2014.

### Recent growth, inflation, reserves, and poverty outcomes
- Real GDP growth averaged around 5.5 percent a year during 2007–2010.
- Growth in 2011 is estimated to have fallen to about 3 percent.
- Inflation averaged around 5 percent a year during 2007–11.
- Gross international reserves at end-2011: USD 182.5 million, equivalent to 5.1 months of imports of goods and services.
- Headcount poverty index (USD 1.25 a day): 48.5 percent in 2010, compared with 58 percent in 2003.

### Recent shock: 2011–12 severe drought and fiscal impact
- Harvest yields of key crops fell by 50-80 percent in the 2011-12 season.
- The GoG anticipates additional spending needs of around 2½–3 percent of GDP for emergency food imports and immediate purchases of seeds and fertilizer.
- Exports of groundnuts (main cash crop) will collapse in the current year owing to the crop failure.

### Domestic and external debt risks
- Domestic debt stood at nearly 30 percent of GDP at end-2010 and at GMD 8,697 million (30.4 percent of GDP) at end-2011.
- Three-fourths of domestic debt (GMD 6,522 million) was in T-bills with maturities of one year or less, creating very high rollover risks.
- Interest on domestic debt consumed about 18 percent of government revenues in 2011.
- Government revenues fell from 17.3 percent of GDP in 2007 to 14.9 percent of GDP in 2011.
- In 2010, net domestic borrowing (NDB) rose to GMD 1,245 million (4.7 percent of GDP).
- In 2011, disciplined cash-budgeting and a surge in tax revenues reduced NDB to GMD 899 million (3.1 percent of GDP) for the year.

### Revenue measures and tax administration reforms
- Fuel pricing:
  - New fuel pricing formula introduced January 2011; monthly adjustments through April 2011.
  - Pump prices were 8.3 percent (weighted average) below the full pass-through level in December 2011.
  - Regular monthly adjustments were re-instated in January 2012.
  - By May 2012, the weighted average subsidy again stood at 8.3 percent of the full pass-through price.
- Excise and arrears collection:
  - Since May 2011, Gambia Revenue Authority (GRA) enforced excise taxes on domestically produced manufactured goods; two large companies remained non-compliant.
  - By December 2011, GRA collected outstanding arrears on GSM license fees.
  - Arrears on sales and PAYE taxes owed by large taxpayers through December 2011 were settled by early 2012.
  - GRA compliance plan for large taxpayers resulted in around 87 percent of large taxpayers filing 2010 income tax returns by early 2012, up from less than 50 percent in mid-2011.
- Other tax measures:
  - Holders of expired Special Investment Certificates (SICs) were being brought into the tax net.
  - Tax waivers on sugar and cement were removed; fuel concession to Gambia Port Authority (GPA) discontinued.
  - Plan to introduce a quota system for duty exemptions on fuel for diplomatic missions.
- Domestic arrears:
  - Comprehensive survey found claims totaling GMD 479 million (about 1.6 percent of GDP); verification required before developing a payment schedule.
- Customs modernization:
  - ASYCUDA++ rolled out to headquarters, the airport, and the 3 busiest border stations.
  - GRA’s Customs and Excise Department launched its risk management committee in April 2011.
  - Members of the Tax and Customs Tribunals appointed in early 2012.

### VAT introduction and implementation timetable
- Value Added Tax (VAT) planned for introduction in January 2013 in line with ECOWAS commitments.
  - Policy paper with main VAT design features discussed and approved by Cabinet in February 2012, with a costed VAT implementation plan.
  - Draft VAT bill (extending coverage to electricity and services such as equipment rental and repair and maintenance) completed in February 2012; to be submitted to the National Assembly by end-May 2012.
  - Public communications campaign for the VAT launched in February 2012.

### Public financial management (PFM) and budget execution reforms
- IFMIS:
  - Integrated Financial Management Information Systems (IFMIS) fully rolled out to all 29 budget entities in January 2011.
  - IFMIS interface with CBG’s national payments system became operational in December 2011, enabling real-time access to government accounts and the automated Securities Settlement System.
- Financial reporting:
  - Audited government accounts for 2007 submitted to the National Assembly in October 2011.
  - Accounts for 2008-10 to be submitted to the National Audit Office by end-April 2012; accounts for 2011-12 by end-April 2013.
- Poverty-focused spending:
  - Education amounted to 15 percent of all spending financed by The Gambia Local Fund (GLF).
  - Agriculture amounted to 5 percent of total GLF-financed spending.

### Central Bank actions, monetary policy, and financial infrastructure
- Monetary aggregates and reserve requirements:
  - Growth rates of end-period reserve and broad money were limited to 12 and 11 percent, respectively, in 2011.
  - Stock of average daily reserve money in December 2011 was 3 percent above its level a year ago.
  - Reserve requirement reduced by 2 percentage points to 12 percent in late April 2011.
- Credit and government borrowing from the CBG:
  - Credit to the private sector grew by 9 percent in 2011.
  - Since June 2011, government largely refrained from accessing credit from the CBG at below-market interest rates; November 2011 was an exception but the breach was small and reversed immediately.
  - Entire overdrawn balance in the Treasury Expenditure Account was fully eliminated through sales of T-bills by end-September 2011.
  - New arrears of around GMD 70 million on interest due to the CBG late in 2011; most cleared in January 2012.
- Market operations and transparency:
  - CBG started forecasting auction sizes one month ahead in September 2011 on a pilot basis.
  - CBG began announcing publicly rolling quarterly projections for estimated T-bill auction sizes (by maturity) in January 2012; projections to be updated monthly.
- Payment and securities systems:
  - Real-Time Gross Settlement System (RTGS) and Automated Cheque Processing and Clearing House (ACP/ACH) launched in December (year implied 2011).
  - Core Banking Application (CBA) became operational in January (year implied 2012).
  - Work on the National Switch and Securities Settlement System (SSS) progressing; expected operational by end of 2012.
  - Court order requirement prior to liquidating collateral on NPLs (notably mortgages) increases cost and risk of lending.

### Statistics and data quality improvements
- BOP statistics:
  - CBG conducted surveys of tourist expenditures and re-exports in 2011 and is undertaking a survey of trade credits.
  - Regular quarterly meetings on re-exports now take place among GBoS, CBG, GRA’s Customs and Excise Department, and the National Transport Union; chairmanship to shift from GRA to CBG during first half of 2012.

### Medium-term program objectives and fiscal anchor
- Program anchor:
  - Gradual reduction of the Government’s annual net domestic borrowing requirement to ½ percent of GDP by 2014.
  - Note: In light of additional domestic borrowing required to address the severe crop failure in 2012, if domestic revenues exceed their targets in 2013 and 2014, at least half of the additional revenue will be directed toward domestic debt reduction.
- Financing strategy for PAGE and medium-term investments:
  - Rebuild government revenues and modernize tax administration.
  - Achieve savings from reduced interest costs on domestic debt.
  - Increase access to external financing with improved debt and public financial management.
  - Harness private sector participation in viable sectors, working closely with development partners to ensure transparency and productivity.
- Key policy agenda items (2012–2014):
  - Pursue gradual fiscal adjustment to reduce interest costs and rollover risks, and to create fiscal space.
  - Pursue tax and revenue administration reforms to increase revenues, simplify the tax system, and improve the business environment.
  - Further strengthen public financial management, focusing on budget planning, execution, and fiscal transparency.
  - Strengthen central bank independence and improve conduct of monetary policy.
  - Promote financial stability and increase access to credit for the private sector.
  - Catalyze private sector development and competition.
  - Improve economic statistics.

*Memorandum on Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP), The Gambia, May 4, 2012.*

### 16.      Given these objectives, the key parameters of the medium-term policy framework

### _cr12129 - 16.      Given these objectives, the key parameters of the medium-term policy framework

### Medium-term policy framework: macro targets and exchange rate
- At least 5-6 percent annual growth in real GDP.
- 5 percent annual inflation.
- NDB gradually declining to ½ percent of GDP by 2014.
- A growth rate for broad money slightly higher than the growth rate of nominal GDP, to allow for financial deepening (around 13 percent in the medium term).
- A growth rate for reserve money consistent with the growth rate for broad money (around 11 percent in the medium term).
- Maintain gross international reserves at around 5 months of imports of goods and services.
- Maintain a flexible exchange rate to help preserve The Gambia’s external competitiveness, with central bank interventions in the foreign exchange market only to maintain orderly market conditions; other CBG operations conducted in a manner that minimizes the impact on the exchange rate.

### Fiscal policy and related structural reforms
- Government will seek external grants and concessional loans to finance infrastructure with a minimum grant element of 35 percent.
- Government will not incur any new external payments arrears and will not contract or guarantee any new non-concessional external debt or any external debt with original maturity of one year or less.
- Government will explore productive opportunities for public-private partnerships and, as market conditions allow, aim to extend the maturity of domestic public debt by launching longer-term bonds.
- Annual debt sustainability analyses will continue in consultation with the IMF and World Bank to ensure all debt indicators will fall and remain below corresponding thresholds.

Tax policy and revenue administration reforms
- Launch of a VAT in January 2013 as the cornerstone of reforms.
- Pursue comprehensive tax reform aimed at broadening the tax base, eliminating certain taxes that do not meet a cost-benefit test, and simplifying direct taxes (reducing number of tax brackets and levels of tax rates).
- Important studies to be conducted:
  - A comprehensive survey and estimate of tax expenditures in 2012. (High Priority)
  - A comprehensive study of tax reform informed by the tax expenditures study to assess scope for broadening the income tax base and lowering tax rates—possibly to a single rate of 15 percent for both the personal and corporate income taxes—consistent with revenue targets; review the tax on allowances with a view toward eventually applying it consistently to all civil servants and private sector employees; assess effectiveness and impact of withholding tax on interest income, as well as a creditable 1 percent income tax withholding on imports for casual and noncompliant importers.
  - Re-engage IMF technical assistance to assess the need to realign excise taxes on alcohol, tobacco, and other products.
  - Simplify small business taxation by imposing a single 0.5 percentage point tax on turnover of all businesses not registered for income tax or the VAT. For the smallest businesses (with turnover below GMD 25,000), simplify the current rate schedule of 16 different rates to one with a flat fee of around GMD 500.

Additional revenue and administration measures
- Rebuild revenues from fuel taxes by steadfastly adjusting fuel prices on the 26th day of the month to gradually allow full pass-through of import prices to retail prices.
- Design and implement a compliance improvement plan for medium and small taxpayers by June 2012.
- Submit to the National Assembly by end-June 2012 amendments to shift the setting of law enforcement parameters to regulations to maximize filing compliance by large taxpayers.
- Strengthen the GRA’s Large Taxpayer Unit (LTU) to 50 people by July 2012 and 60 people by January 2013.
- Update and better utilize the Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) register, e.g., by linking to national ID numbers.
- Customs administration: roll out ASYCUDA++ to all border stations; GRA’s Board to approve a risk management program and training and technical assistance plan for the Customs and Excise Department by end-December 2012; by end-2013 move toward self-assessment and reduce physical inspections to 50 percent or less.

Expenditure controls and poverty-focus
- Tighten expenditure controls while maintaining focus on poverty reduction; wage bill increases depend on effective civil service reform.
- Refine monthly cash budgeting framework introduced in 2011; unforeseen spending pressures limited to contingency reserve; if necessary, adjust annual budget through a supplementary bill while maintaining the target for NDB.
- Track poverty-reducing expenditures in PAGE with improved data, definition, and targeting:
  - A minimum of 44 percent of total GLF-financed expenditure dedicated to poverty-reducing spending identified in PAGE.
  - To meet donor support requirements, 20 percent of total current expenditures (excluding interest payments) directed to education.
  - Plan to raise spending on agriculture from six to ten percent of total government expenditures (Maputo Declaration target).

Budget planning, transparency, and PFM steps
- Publish quarterly budget execution reports starting in Q2 of 2012.
- Prepare a budget framework paper for 2013 with indicative budget projections for 2013-2015, to be submitted to the National Assembly by end-October 2012, including an indicative Medium-Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF).
- Update and prioritize the strategic plan of the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education in 2012; review, update, and cost MOFEA’s strategic plan and that of one other line ministry.
- Pilot an MTEF in 2013 at the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education.

### Monetary and exchange rate policies
- CBG to continue using a money targeting framework to pursue price stability (inflation at or below 5 percent).
- CBG intends to limit reserve and broad money growth to 7 percent and 9 percent, respectively, in 2012.
- Continue to use the rediscount rate to signal policy changes. CBG will monitor energy and food prices and be prepared to tighten monetary policy if shocks to energy and food prices feed into the general price level.
- Maintain a flexible exchange rate; intervene only to maintain orderly market conditions or to mop up liquidity injections caused by foreign-financed government spending; may purchase foreign exchange to meet targets for international reserves.
- Maintain international reserves at around 5 months of imports of goods and services.

Measures to improve monetary predictability and liquidity management
- Adhere to a zero limit, on a monthly basis, on new credit from the central bank at below-market interest rates, including a zero balance on overdrafts; adhere strictly to the schedule for payments of principal and interest on CBG-held government securities.
- MOFEA to collaborate with CBG to strengthen liquidity forecasting through interagency committee participation and improved weekly forecasts of the public sector borrowing requirement.
- With IMF technical assistance, CBG plans to launch the market for daily repos in January 2013; CBG will bear interest costs of repo operations.
- Availability of a working tool for daily liquidity management will allow CBG to switch to a fortnightly schedule for T-bill auctions by end-June 2013 to make auctions more competitive and help lower interest rates.

### Financial intermediation and banking sector reforms
- Continue capacity building and staffing for Financial Supervision Department (FSD).
- Correct technical problems at the Credit Reference Bureau by mid-2012 to update borrowers’ credit information.
- Launch V-RegCoSS, an electronic reporting system for commercial banks by August 2012 to enable timely statutory returns and real-time access to bank information.
- Review the Manual of Guidelines and Instructions by June 2012 and begin regular collection of new data, including term structure of assets/liabilities, weighted interest rates on loans and deposits, and largest credit exposures.
- Raise the minimum capital requirement for commercial banks from GMD 150 million to GMD 200 million by end-December 2012; enforce with no forbearance. CBG to review each bank’s plan for raising resources by end-June 2012 and encourage banks to meet at least 50 percent of the capital increase by end-September 2012.
- By June 2013, submit to the National Assembly amendments to the Banking Act 2009 to tighten loan classification and provisioning rules by introducing “special mention loans” (30-90 days past due) with a provisioning rate of 5 percent; tighten provisioning for loans more than 90 days past due if necessary; introduce hard limits on individual and aggregate large exposures; require disclosure of ultimate beneficial shareholders; require fit and proper tests for shareholders holding more than 5 percent; empower FSD to suspend shareholder rights of unfit shareholders.
- Require all commercial banks by end-2013 to prepare audited financial statements and annual reports in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS).
- Enhance capacity for macro-prudential analysis, including stress testing, through IMF technical assistance.
- Gradual migration from a hybrid (compliance and risk-based) to a fully risk-based supervisory framework.

Measures to increase access to credit and reduce interest rates
- CBG will continue reviewing the reserve requirement in context of liquidity conditions.
- CBG will push the banking sector to reduce overheads and increase competition.
- Ministry of Local Government will reduce the value of stamp duty on new mortgages (currently set at 5 percent of the value of each mortgage).
- With IMF technical assistance and stakeholder consultation, CBG will review the Sheriffs and Mortgages Acts in 2013 to reduce cost, uncertainty, and complexity in resolving non-performing loans.
- Encourage commercial banks to create a market for distressed loans by 2013.
- Work with MOFEA and Ministry of Justice to develop a Collateral Registry operational by 2013.

### Other structural reforms
- Initiate a strategic study of GAMTEL and GAMCEL by September 2012 (in consultation with the World Bank) to generate policy options, including re-privatization of GAMCEL.
- Explore PPP opportunities for public enterprises (GAMTEL, Banjul seaport, GGC, NAWEC, ferries, roads, bridges); MOFEA to set up a qualified PPP assessment unit in 2012.
- In consultation with the World Bank, elaborate a national energy strategy by end-2012; strengthen regulatory bodies such as PURA and improve performance and financial health of NAWEC.
- Explore restructuring the fuel import market to introduce greater competition or stricter regulation to protect consumers from unnecessarily high energy prices.

### Statistics: improving macroeconomic data quality
- Strengthen GBoS by recruiting additional qualified staff at the NA and price units and provide more resources for training and IT.
- CBG to build capacity in the BOP unit at the Economic Research Department per IMF technical assistance recommendations.
- Line ministries to contribute to sectoral statistics (agriculture, health, education, transport, construction) and cooperate with GBoS; resume the annual conference on official statistics.
- CBG to conduct a new survey of FDI in the first half of 2012 to improve BOP statistics.
- By June 2012, GBoS to start posting on its external website Excel files with national account and CPI data, detailed methodological information, and a calendar of upcoming data releases.
- By June 2012, GBoS to draft a strategy for backing-up and protecting its data with a costed implementation plan to be approved by MOFEA and implemented by end-2012.
- In consultation with GBoS, CBG, and the National Transport Union, GRA to standardize procedures and reports for border stations by end-2012, focusing on recording re-exports correctly and consistently.
- GBoS will update the Business Register based on the list of establishments provided by the GRA.
- NA unit at GBoS will develop GDP estimates by the expenditure approach by 2013 and quarterly GDP estimates by 2014.

*Source: _cr12129 - 16.      Given these objectives, the key parameters of the medium-term policy framework*

### 30.      Because of poor weather conditions in many parts of the country, key crops (rice,

### _cr12129 - 30.      Because of poor weather conditions in many parts of the country, key crops (rice,

### Impact of drought on agriculture and immediate fiscal/financial response
- Key crops (rice, millet, and groundnuts) suffered losses of 50-80 percent during the 2011-12 crop season, compared with production in 2010-11.
- The Government publicly declared a state of food and seed emergency and requested assistance from development partners and aid agencies.
- Projected cost of food aid and seeds and fertilizer for the upcoming crop season: USD 23 million.
- Government measures to generate resources to address the crisis:
  - Gradual increase in fuel prices to reduce and eventually eliminate subsidies and collect the full value of the fuel excise tax.
  - Issuance of higher-than-budgeted amounts of T-bills in 2012:Q1.
  - Expected net domestic borrowing (NDB) during the first half of 2012: GMD 799 million.
  - Additional borrowing to be reduced over the course of the year as donor assistance becomes available.
  - Expected budget support grants: World Bank (about USD 6 million) and African Development Bank (USD 2.9 million).
  - Official international reserves of the CBG will be used to meet additional foreign exchange requirements of emergency imports; reserves will be restored as donor assistance is received.

### Program monitoring for 2012 (overview)
- Program monitoring instruments:
  - Quantitative performance criteria (ceilings, floors, continuous ceilings, monthly ceilings).
  - Indicative targets (floors on total government revenues and poverty-reducing expenditures).
  - Structural benchmarks.
- Timeline for program reviews:
  - First program review to be completed before end-December 2012, based on end-June 2012 test date.
  - Second review to be completed before end-June 2013, based on end-December 2012 test date.
- Definitions and reporting requirements are contained in the attached Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU).

### Proposed quantitative performance criteria and indicative targets (selected figures)
- Table entries (Cumulative flows from the beginning of 2012; unless otherwise indicated):
  - Ceiling on net domestic borrowing of the central government:
    - Jun. 2012: 799 (GMD millions)
    - Sep. 2012: 464 (GMD millions)
    - Dec. 2012: 1,094 (GMD millions)
  - Ceiling on the stock of net domestic assets of the central bank:
    - Jun. 2012: 1,608 (GMD millions)
    - Sep. 2012: 1,257 (GMD millions)
    - Dec. 2012: 1,429 (GMD millions, TMU exchange rates)
  - Floor on the stock of net usable international reserves of the central bank:
    - Jun. 2012: 112.7 (USD millions, TMU exchange rates)
    - Sep. 2012: 124.9 (USD millions, TMU exchange rates)
    - Dec. 2012: 125.5 (USD millions, TMU exchange rates)
  - Continuous ceilings (USD millions unless indicated otherwise):
    - New external payments arrears of the central government: 0 (continuous)
    - New nonconcessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the central government: 0 (continuous)
    - Outstanding stock of external public debt with original maturity of one year or less: 0 (continuous)
  - Monthly ceiling on new central bank credit to the central government at non-market terms: 0 (GMD millions)
  - Indicative targets:
    - Floor on total government revenues:
      - Jun. 2012: 2,473 (GMD millions)
      - Sep. 2012: 3,644 (GMD millions)
      - Dec. 2012: 4,651 (GMD millions)
    - Floor on poverty-reducing expenditures:
      - Jun. 2012: 905 (GMD millions)
      - Sep. 2012: 1,358 (GMD millions)
      - Dec. 2012: 1,811 (GMD millions)

- Notes affecting targets:
  - Numbers for June and December 2012 are performance criteria. Numbers for September 2012 are indicative targets.
  - Adjuster for NDB and net domestic assets targets: to be adjusted downward by the dalasi equivalent of donor-provided drought relief beyond the budget support grants from the World Bank and the African Development Bank (totaling USD 8.9 million in 2012), up to a maximum of USD 14.1 million.
  - Adjuster for net usable international reserves: to be adjusted upward by the U.S. dollar equivalent of donor-provided drought relief beyond the budget support grants from the World Bank and the African Development Bank (totaling USD 8.9 million in 2012), up to a maximum of USD 14.1 million.
  - Zero ceiling applies to outstanding credits at non-market terms effected since the beginning of 2012 as of the end of each month during the quarter.

### Proposed structural agenda, June 2012 – June 2013 (selected measures, implementation dates, and rationale)
- Broadening the Tax Base and Strengthening Revenue Administration:
  - Submit VAT bill to the National Assembly — End-May 2012.
  - Introduce VAT — January 1, 2013.
  - Submit to Parliament amendments to shift law enforcement parameter settings to regulations — End-June 2012.
  - GRA Board approval of a risk management program, and a training and technical assistance plan — End-December 2012.
- Strengthening Budget Preparation, Execution and PFM:
  - Publish quarterly budget execution reports on MOFEA’s website — Continuous, beginning with Q2/2012.
  - Submit a budget framework paper for 2013 with indicative budget projections for 2013-2015 to the National Assembly — End-October 2012.
  - Submit updated strategic plan of the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education to the High Level Economic Committee — End-December 2012.
  - Submit for audit the government accounts for 2011-12 to the National Audit Office — End-April 2013.
- Improving the Conduct of Monetary Policy:
  - Launch the market for daily repos and reverse repos — January 2013.
  - Switch to a fortnightly schedule for T-bill auctions — June 2013.
- Strengthening Financial Stability:
  - Review the Manual of Guidelines and Instructions — June 2012.
  - Submit to the National Assembly amendments to the Banking Act 2009 — June 2013.
- Improving Macroeconomic Statistics:
  - Start posting on the GBoS external website national account and CPI data, methodological information, and a calendar of upcoming data releases — June 2012.
  - Standardize procedures and reports for border stations to record re-exports correctly and consistently — December 2012.
- Other Structural Reforms:
  - Initiate a strategic study of GAMTEL and GAMCEL — September 2012.

### Technical Memorandum of Understanding — definitions, adjusters, and reporting
- Net domestic borrowing of the Central Government:
  - Definition: net claims on the Central Government by the domestic monetary sector plus the discounted value of domestic government securities held by the non-monetary sector; includes other net dalasi claims and government arrears on domestic debt service obligations. Excludes local and regional governments and public enterprises. Project accounts listed in Table 1 and ECOWAS levy revenue accounts at the CBG are excluded.
  - Adjuster: Quarterly targets adjusted downward by the dalasi equivalent of donor-provided drought relief beyond budget support grants from the World Bank and the African Development Bank (totaling USD 8.9 million in 2012), up to a maximum of USD 14.1 million.
  - Reporting: Part of consolidated budget report.
- Net Domestic Assets (NDA) of the CBG:
  - Definition: NDA = reserve money − net foreign assets of the CBG. Reserve money = currency issued by the CBG + deposits of commercial banks at the CBG.
  - Exchange rates for program monitoring (December 2011 end-of-period market rates): 30.24 GMD/USD, 1.29 USD/EUR, 1.55 USD/GBP, 1.06 USD/CHF, 1.54 USD/SDR. Other currencies converted to USD then to dalasi at these rates.
  - Adjuster: Quarterly NDA targets adjusted downward by the dalasi equivalent of donor-provided drought relief beyond the World Bank and AfDB budget support grants (totaling USD 8.9 million in 2012), up to USD 14.1 million. Additional budget support converted at the rates listed above.
  - Reporting: Balance sheet of the CBG (compiled based on TMU rates) monthly within four weeks of end of each month; balance sheet on a current-rate basis also submitted.
- Net Usable International Reserves (NIR) of the CBG:
  - Definition: NIR = usable reserve assets − reserve liabilities; usable reserve assets include SDRs, foreign currency cash, foreign currency securities, deposits abroad, and reserve position at the IMF; excludes pledged/encumbered assets, claims on residents, claims from derivatives vis-à-vis domestic currency, precious metals, assets in nonconvertible currencies, and illiquid assets.
  - Exchange rates: Use the rates listed for December 2011.
  - Adjusters:
    - Quarterly NIR targets adjusted upward by the U.S. dollar equivalent of donor-provided drought relief beyond the World Bank and AfDB budget support grants (totaling USD 8.9 million in 2012), up to USD 14.1 million.
    - In case of an allocation of SDRs by the IMF, NIR will be adjusted upward by the amount of the SDR allocation.
  - Reporting: Detailed reserve statement with end-month data on NIR transmitted within seven days of end of each month.
- New external payments arrears of the Central Government:
  - Definition: Stock of external arrears on loans contracted or guaranteed by the Central Government, except on debts subject to rescheduling or a stock of debt operation; assessed continuously.
  - Reporting: Accounting of non-reschedulable external arrears (if any) by creditor countries, monthly within four weeks of end of each month.
- New non-concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the Central Government:
  - Definition: New non-concessional external debt, including commitments for which value has not been received; excludes IMF purchases and loans with a grant element of at least 35 percent. Assessed continuously.
  - Reporting: Loan-by-loan accounting quarterly within four weeks of end of each quarter.
- Outstanding stock of external public debt with original maturity of one year or less:
  - Definition: Stock of outstanding external public sector debt with original maturity of one year or less owed or guaranteed by the public sector; excludes normal import-related credits.
  - Reporting: Comprehensive record quarterly within four weeks of end of each quarter.
- New central bank credit to the Central Government at non-market terms:
  - Definition: Consolidated balance on Treasury Expenditure Account, Consolidated Revenue Fund, and other revenue accounts; covers all gross claims on the Central Government on the central bank balance sheet with materially different terms than market Treasury bills and bonds at acquisition; covers overdue payments of principal and interest on Central Government securities held by the central bank.
  - Assessment frequency: End of each month.

*Source: Excerpt from the provided IMF document.*

### 21. Supporting material: Reporting on new central bank credit to the government at

### _cr12129 - 21. Supporting material: Reporting on new central bank credit to the government at

### Quantitative Indicative Targets
- Total government revenues
  - Definition: sum of tax revenues and non-tax revenues.
  - External grants are not included.
  - Revenue from the ECOWAS levy is not included.
  - Supporting material: reporting on total government revenues will form part of the consolidated budget report described in paragraph 32.
- Poverty-reducing expenditures
  - Definition: expenditures financed out of The Gambia Local Fund (GLF) on the following areas: Agriculture and Natural Resources; Education; Health; Nutrition, Population and HIV-AIDS; Infrastructure Programme; Social Fund for Poverty Reduction; Implementation and Monitoring of Poverty Reduction Programmes; Support to Cross-Cutting Programmes; ICT Research and Development; Decentralization and Local Government Capacity Building; Governance and Civil Service Reform Programme.
  - Supporting material: a monthly report on poverty-reducing expenditures will be transmitted within four weeks of the end of each month.

### Structural Benchmarks
- VAT
  - “Introduction of the VAT” refers to the law’s taking effect.
- Review of Manual of Guidelines and Instructions
  - Benchmark met when the CBG Manual of Guidelines and Instructions is amended so that the CBG starts the regular collection of data on:
    - the term structure of commercial banks’ assets and liabilities,
    - weighted interest rates on loans and deposits,
    - the largest credit exposures.
- Amendments to the Banking Act 2009
  - Benchmark met when the CBG submits to the National Assembly amendments which:
    - tighten loan classification and provisioning rules by introducing a new category of “special mention loans” capturing loans which are 30-90 days past due, with a provisioning rate of 5 percent;
    - introduce hard limits on individual and aggregate large exposures (with equal treatment for secured and unsecured loans);
    - require the disclosure of banks’ ultimate beneficial shareholders;
    - require shareholders holding more than 5 percent interest to be subjected to a fit and proper test;
    - empower the CBG’s Financial Supervision Department to suspend the shareholder rights of unfit and improper shareholders.
- Strategic Study of GAMTEL and GAMCEL
  - “Initiate” refers to the signing of a contract with consultants who will conduct the study.

### Other Data Requirements and Reporting Standards — Summary of Reporting Timelines and Content
- Prices
  - Monthly disaggregated consumer price index, including weights for each major category, with August 2004 = 100, transmitted within three weeks of the end of each month.
- Government accounts data
  - Monthly consolidated central government budget report (analytical table) on budget execution for the month and cumulatively from the beginning of the year, transmitted within four weeks of the end of each month. The report will cover:
    - (i) revenue data by major items (such as taxes on income, profits, and capital gains; domestic taxes on goods and services; taxes on international trade and transactions; other taxes; non-tax revenue);
    - (ii) external grants by type (e.g., budget support grants, project grants);
    - (iii) details of recurrent expenditure (including goods and services, interest payments, and subsidies and other current transfers);
    - (iv) details of capital expenditure and net lending (including data on externally financed capital expenditure, expenditure from the Gambia Local Fund, and net lending);
    - (v) the overall balance and the basic balance;
    - (vi) details of budget financing (including net domestic and net external borrowing and their components).
  - End-week data on net domestic borrowing transmitted weekly within five business days of the end of each week.
- Monetary sector data
  - Balance sheet of the CBG, prepared on the basis of current and program exchange rates, transmitted monthly within four weeks of the end of each month. The balance sheet will explicitly identify all claims on, and liabilities to, the government. Claims include overdrafts, holdings of treasury bills, government bonds, advances to the government in foreign currency, and other claims on the government. Liabilities include balances in the treasury main account, the treasury expenditure account, the consolidated revenue fund and other revenue accounts, the treasury bill special deposit account, the privatization proceeds account, and other deposit accounts.
  - Consolidated balance sheet of the commercial banks and a monetary survey (consolidation of accounts of the CBG and commercial banks), including foreign currency deposits held by residents of The Gambia with commercial banks, transmitted within four weeks of the end of each month.
  - Daily data on reserve money transmitted weekly within five business days of the end of each week.
- Treasury bill market and interbank money market
  - Weekly data on amounts offered and issued, net issuance, over/under subscription, and yields transmitted weekly within five business days of the end of each week.
  - Data on treasury bills outstanding (both at face value and at discounted value, including distribution by bank and non-bank holders) transmitted monthly within six weeks of the end of each month.
  - Weekly Short-Term Liquidity Forecast transmitted following each meeting of the Treasury Bills Committee.
  - Monthly Liquidity Management Report, reflecting data as of the last working day of the month, transmitted within seven days after the end of each month.
  - One month ahead forecasts of T-bill auctions, broken down by date and maturity, transmitted monthly.
  - Daily data on the interbank money market (interest rates, maturities, and volumes of transactions) transmitted weekly within five business days of the end of each week.
- External sector data
  - CBG will forward monthly data on transactions in official reserves within four weeks of the end of each month; foreign exchange liquidity forecast following each meeting of the Foreign Reserves Management Committee.
  - Daily interbank market exchange rates (simple average of the daily weighted average buying and selling rates) transmitted weekly within five business days of the end of the week.
  - Weekly interbank market exchange rates (simple average of the weekly weighted average buying and selling rates) transmitted monthly within seven days of the end of the month.
  - CBG’s monthly average and end-month exchange rates, including those for all currencies in which foreign assets and liabilities are denominated, transmitted within seven days after the end of each month.
  - Daily data on foreign exchange intervention by the central bank transmitted weekly within five business days of the end of each week.
  - Detailed reserve statement with end-week data on net usable international reserves of the CBG transmitted weekly within five business days of the end of each week.
  - Monthly data on the volume of transactions (purchases, sales, and total) in the foreign exchange market by each major group of participants (CBG, commercial banks, and foreign exchange bureaus) in dalasi transmitted within seven days of the end of each month.

### The Gambia: Relations with the Fund (As of March 31, 2012) — Key Facts and Figures
- Membership status
  - Joined September 21, 1967.
  - Accepted the obligations under Article VIII, Sections 2(a), 3, and 4 on January 21, 1993.
  - Maintains an exchange system free of restrictions on current international transactions.
- General Resources Account (SDR Million)
  - Quota: 31.10 (100.00 percent)
  - Fund holdings of currency: 29.59 (95.14 percent)
  - Reserve Tranche Position: 1.54 (4.96 percent)
- SDR Department (SDR Million)
  - Net cumulative allocation: 29.77 (100.00 percent)
  - Holdings: 24.57 (82.54 percent)
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans (SDR Million)
  - ECF arrangement: 22.55 (72.50 percent of quota)
- Latest Financial Arrangements (selected)
  - ECF Feb. 21, 2007–Mar. 31, 2011: Amount Approved 24.88 (SDR Million); Amount Drawn 22.55 (SDR Million)
  - ECF Jul. 18, 2002–Jul. 17, 2005: Amount Approved 20.22; Amount Drawn 2.89
  - ECF Jun. 29, 1998–Dec. 31, 2001: Amount Approved 20.61; Amount Drawn 20.61
- Projected Payments to Fund (SDR million; based on current use of resources and present holdings of SDRs)
  - 2012 Principal: 0.20
  - 2013 Principal: 1.00
  - 2014 Principal: 2.11
  - 2015 Principal: 3.84
  - 2016 Principal: 4.28
  - Charges/interest: 2012 0.01; 2013 0.01; 2014 0.06; 2015 0.05; 2016 0.04
  - Total: 2012 0.21; 2013 1.01; 2014 2.17; 2015 3.89; 2016 4.32
- HIPC Initiative and MDRI
  - Enhanced HIPC: Decision point date Dec. 11, 2000; Completion point date Dec. 19, 2007.
  - Assistance committed (year-end 2000 NPV terms): Total assistance US$ 66.60; IMF assistance SDR equivalent, million 2.30 and 1.80 noted in separate lines.
  - Disbursement of IMF assistance (SDR million) 2.29; Assistance disbursed to the member 1.80; Interim assistance 0.44; Completion point balance 1.36; Additional disbursement of interest income 0.49.
  - MDRI-eligible debt (SDR million) 9.42; Financed by MDRI Trust 7.44; Remaining HIPC resources 1.98.
- Safeguards assessments
  - Completed in February 2004, February 2007, and November 2009.
  - 2007 assessment recommended additional measures to strengthen internal controls and financial reporting; 2009 update concluded good progress and recommended formalizing a framework for extension of credit to government to ensure compliance with statutory limits.
  - The term of the previous audit firm expired and the Auditor General appointed a new external auditor for a three-year term starting in 2011.
  - The update assessment is being conducted in the context of The Gambia’s request for a new ECF arrangement and will be finalized before the first review of the program.
- Exchange rate arrangement
  - Until January 20, 1986, dalasi pegged to pound sterling at D5 = £1.
  - Interbank market introduced January 20, 1986; since then exchange rate determined by market forces.
  - Effective February 2, 2009, de facto classification changed from managed floating with no predetermined path for the exchange rate to floating, retroactively to April 30, 2008.
  - De jure exchange rate arrangement is free floating.
  - As of end–March 2012, midpoint exchange rate in the interbank market was D30.44 per U.S. dollar.
- Last Article IV consultation
  - Executive Board concluded the 2011 Article IV consultation (Country Report No. 12/17) on January 18, 2012.
- Technical assistance (selected recent items)
  - Fiscal Affairs Department: February/March 2012 — A couple of experts advised on PFM; January/February 2012 — IMF regional advisor visited twice to provide TA on revenue administration and VAT preparations; December 2011 — LEG expert helped draft the new VAT law.
  - Monetary and Capital Markets Department: January 2012 — Technical expert advised the CBG on amending its Manual of Guidelines and Instructions to strengthen bank supervision; September 2011 — TA mission conducted stress testing.
  - Statistics Department: January/February 2012 — Technical expert advised on improving the compilation of price statistics; September 2011 — DfID-funded TA mission advised on improving BOP statistics.
  - Others: February 2012 — An LEG expert held a VAT workshop for stakeholders and helped finalize the new VAT law and related background materials.

*IMF — The Gambia: Request for a Three-Year Arrangement Under the Extended Credit Facility — Informational Annex (May 9, 2012)*

### 13. Resident Representative

### Resident Representative

### Appointment
- Mr. Meshack Tjirongo was appointed the Fund’s Resident Representative to The Gambia in January 2010.

### Joint Bank-Fund Work Program (March 2012 – March 2013)
- Bank work program (next 12 months)
  - Economic Management and Public Financial Management
    - 1. Economic Governance Reform Grant — February/March 2012
    - 2. IFMIS: Additional Financing — July 2012
  - Growth and Competitiveness
    - 3. Commercial Agriculture and Value Chain Project — July 2012; April/May 2012; January 2013; July 2013 (timing entries as presented)
- Fund work program (next 12 months)
  - Policy Advice
    - 1. Negotiations for a new ECF — February/March 2012
    - 2. First review under new ECF — August/September 2012
    - 3. Second review under new ECF — March 2013
  - Technical Assistance
    - 1. VAT preparations — March/April 2012; April 2012; resident advisor beginning in June 2012; resident advisor beginning in June 2012
    - 2. Public financial management — May/June 2012
    - 3. Improving liquidity management — April/May 2012
    - 4. Monetary and financial statistics — May 2012; November 2012; May 2013
- Mutual information exchange requests
  - Fund request to Bank: Periodic updates on: CPIA, PFM reform, and civil service reform.
  - Bank request to Fund: Periodic updates on macroeconomic framework.
- Joint products next 12 months
  - JSAN on new PRSP — February/March 2012; May 2012

### Debt Sustainability Analysis — Key Findings and Recommendations
- External debt risk and recent history
  - External debt indicators suggest that The Gambia remains at high risk of debt distress.
  - Based on current projections, The Gambia’s external debt is on a sustainable path, with scope for moderate additional external borrowing on concessional terms for productive investments.
  - Domestic debt has grown substantially, is costly, and poses high rollover risks.
  - Interest on domestic debt consumes nearly one-fifth of government revenues and far exceeds the cost of interest on external debt.
- Historical debt relief and stock figures
  - Nominal external public debt reduced from US$676.7 million (133.1 percent of GDP) to US$299.4 million (41.7 percent of GDP) after HIPC and MDRI relief.
  - In present value (PV) terms, stock at end-2007 decreased from US$439 million to US$347 million after HIPC relief and to US$165 million after MDRI relief.
  - External debt-to-exports ratio at completion point was about 113 percent.
  - As of end-2011, nominal external stock amounted to US$386 million; PV external debt amounted to US$290 million (or 217 percent of exports).
  - Domestic debt stock stood at just over 30 percent of GDP as of end-2011.
  - Interest payments on domestic debt estimated to consume 18 percent of government revenues in 2011.
- Staff recommendations
  - Authorities should restrict external financing to grants and highly concessional loans with a grant element of at least 35percent and reduce new domestic borrowing.

### Macroeconomic Framework Assumptions Underlying the DSA (Box 1 summary)
- Growth and inflation
  - Real GDP projected to contract about -1½ percent in 2012 due to severe crop failure from drought; rebound to nearly 10 percent in 2013; long-term projected growth rate of 5½ percent by 2016.
  - CPI inflation expected about 4½ percent in 2012; rise to 5½ percent in 2013 and 2014; long-term stable around 5 percent.
- Fiscal and financing assumptions
  - Overall fiscal deficit assumed to widen temporarily to 3½ percent of GDP in 2012.
  - Tax revenues expected to rise to 15½ percent of GDP in 2014.
  - Net domestic borrowing expected to increase to 3.8 percent of GDP in 2012 and reach 0.5 percent by 2014.
  - Donor support (including project grants) expected to increase by 6.6 percent in 2012 compared to 4.7 percent in 2011; medium-term grant growth to 4½ percent of GDP.
  - DSA assumes IMF ECF borrowing equal to 60 percent of The Gambia’s quota: 30 percent disbursed up front and 30 percent equally distributed over 6 reviews.
- External sector and reserves
  - External current account deficit (including budget support) expected to rise to 18 percent of GDP in 2012 from about 14 percent in 2011; decline to about 12 percent medium term and to 10 percent by 2028.
  - Exports projected to shrink by 3 percent in 2012; groundnut export volume assumed about 20 percent of 2011 (value about 30 percent due to higher international price).
  - Tourism growth expected about 2 percent in 2012 (vs. 19 percent in 2011).
  - Imports expected to rise by 13 percent in 2012; drought-related additional imports of US$ 23 million assumed.
  - Remittances expected to rise about 12 percent from 2011.
  - Gross international reserves expected to remain roughly at 5 months of imports and services (2012–2031).
  - Nominal exchange rate vis-à-vis the U.S. dollar projected to depreciate by 4 percent in 2012 onwards.

### External Debt Sustainability — Baseline Results
- Key baseline breaches and trajectories
  - PV of external debt to exports ratio projected at 199 percent in 2012 (threshold 100); projected to fall below threshold only in 2031.
  - PV of external debt to GDP: just over 34 percent in 2012; declines to about 16 percent by 2032 with 5½ percent annual real GDP growth.
  - Debt service ratios are below thresholds and continue to decline over the medium and long term.
- Text Table 1 summary (selected indicators)
  - PV of external debt in percent of GDP: Medium-term (2012-17) 30; Long-term (2018-32) 34 30 20 (table presented as in source).
  - PV of external debt in percent of exports: Threshold 100; 2012 baseline 199; medium-term 179; long-term 118 (note: "2/ The ratio drops below threshold from 2031 onwards.")
  - PV of external debt in percent of revenues: Threshold 200; 2012 baseline 217; medium-term 176; long-term 115.
  - Debt service in percent of exports: Threshold 15; 2012 baseline 12; medium-term 12; long-term 7.
  - Debt service in percent of revenues: Threshold 18; 2012 baseline 13; medium-term 12; long-term 7.
- Policy-dependence of thresholds
  - The Gambia classified as a "weak performer" with average (2008-10) CPIA rating of 3.28; thresholds are at lowest levels and more likely to be breached.
  - If CPIA improves and the country becomes a "medium performer", higher thresholds would apply and the debt distress assessment could be revisited.

### Role of Remittances
- Remittances estimated to exceed 30 percent of exports (excluding re-exports), equivalent to over 4½ percent of GDP in 2012.
- Including remittances reduces the debt-to-exports ratio substantially and shortens the period of breach, but the ratio still breaches the threshold until about 2020 with a peak of about 150 percent in 2012.
- The framework notes concerns about under-reporting and sensitivity of remittances to host-country economic conditions.

### Alternative Scenarios and Stress Tests
- Historical scenario
  - Variables revert to historical levels: debt-to-GDP lower by less than a ½ percentage point in 2022; debt-to-exports and debt-to-revenue ratios below baseline by approximately 2 and 1 percentage point, respectively; debt service indicators worsen marginally.
- Less favorable borrowing terms scenario
  - Assumes interest rate on new borrowing 2 percentage points higher than baseline (grace and maturity same): all debt indicators worsen substantially; debt-to-exports breaches threshold for all projected years (low of about 141 percent in 2032); debt-to-revenue increases (for example, by almost 35 percentage points in 2022) but stays under threshold.
  - Highlights need to seek highly concessional financing.
- PAGE financing scenario (additional borrowing for Programme for Accelerated Growth and Employment)
  - Assumes about US$38 million increase in new borrowing from multilateral creditors distributed 2012–2016; positive growth effect on real GDP about 0.2 percentage point for each percentage point of GDP of investment with a one-year lag.
  - Debt-to-exports breaches threshold until 2031, declining to 98 percent in 2032; overall path suggests debt sustainability maintained despite temporary breaches.
- Bound tests (shocks)
  - Of six bound tests, four involve shocks to key variables in the second and third years; the fifth is a combination; the sixth assumes a one-time 30 percent depreciation in the nominal exchange rate.
  - Most extreme shocks vary by indicator between a one-time 30 percent depreciation and a one-standard deviation downward shift from historical export growth; most debt indicators breach respective thresholds under these shocks.
  - Results emphasize adherence to a prudent borrowing plan and an approved medium-term debt management strategy (MTDS).

*Source: IMF staff DSA annex to "Request for a Three-Year Arrangement Under the Extended Credit Facility — Debt Sustainability Analysis—Update", May 9, 2012.*

### 10.      Over the medium-to-long term, domestic debt is projected to fall from just

### 10.      Over the medium-to-long term, domestic debt is projected to fall from just

### Medium-to-long term domestic debt projection
- Domestic debt is projected to fall from just over 33 percent of GDP at the end of 2012 to just over 24 percent of GDP in 2015, and to continue to fall thereafter, reflecting sustained fiscal discipline.
- The authorities have expressed their intention to achieve a gradual fiscal adjustment over the medium term in order to curb new domestic borrowing.
- The goal is to reduce new domestic borrowing to half of a percentage point of GDP in 2014 and beyond.
- The authorities are pursuing a comprehensive tax reform anchored around the introduction of a VAT in January 2013.
- The tax reform is projected to be moderately revenue enhancing which would improve the debt-to-revenue ratio.
- Fiscal discipline is expected to help lower domestic interest rates and provide fiscal space to increase basic primary expenditures.

### Baseline public debt projections
- Under the baseline scenario, the PV of total public debt is projected to decline from about 68 percent of GDP in 2012 to just over 47 percent in 2017 and to about 23 percent in 2032.
- As a ratio of domestic revenues and grants, the PV of public debt is projected to fall from about 301 percent in 2012 to 109 percent by the end of the projection period.
- The largest factor contributing to the near-term decline in the PV of public debt is the projected fall in new domestic borrowing.

### Alternative scenarios and stress tests — summary of vulnerabilities
- Public debt and debt service ratios are mostly sensitive to:
  - lower GDP growth over the long run,
  - persistent primary fiscal deficits,
  - one-time depreciation of the nominal exchange rate.
- Of three alternative scenarios, public debt ratios are mostly affected by a persistent fiscal deficit, indicating that a status quo in fiscal policy results in a damaging debt path.
- The most extreme stress test is a temporary deceleration in real GDP growth.

### Alternative scenarios — quantified outcomes
- Primary balance kept constant for the projection period (at a deficit of about 1½ percent of GDP):
  - PV of debt to GDP ratio would decrease from 68 percent in 2012 to only 35 percent in 2032 (baseline decline to 23 percent in 2032).
  - PV of debt to revenue would decrease from 301 percent in 2012 to 165 percent in 2032 (baseline decline to 109 percent in 2032).
- Scenario with reduced real GDP growth while the primary balance is at historical averages:
  - The present values of all public debt indicators decline over time, but less pronounced than under the baseline.
  - PV of debt to GDP ratio declines from 57 percent in 2011 to 40 percent in 2031 (as compared to 22 percent in the baseline).
  - PV of debt to revenue ratio declines from 309 percent to 204 percent between the same years (as against 115 percent in the baseline).
- Historical averages note: real GDP growth is 4 percent while the primary deficit is 0.2 percent of GDP.

### Bound tests — quantified outcomes
- Most extreme bound test: real GDP growth at one standard deviation less than its historical average:
  - PV of debt to GDP ratio would worsen to 55 percent in 2032 compared to 23 percent under the baseline.
  - PV of debt to revenue ratio would worsen to 252 percent compared to 109 percent under the baseline.
- Combination of shocks (to growth and the primary balance) and a one-time 30 percent depreciation:
  - Combination of shocks: PV of debt-to-GDP ratio would rise to 48 percent in 2032 (baseline 23 percent).
  - One-time 30 percent depreciation: PV of debt-to-GDP ratio would rise to 28 percent in 2032 (baseline 23 percent).

### The authorities' view
- The authorities broadly agreed with the overall assessment.
- In their own debt sustainability exercise, they have greater room for additional borrowing in their stepping-up scenario to help finance the PAGE.
- This outcome is a result of more optimistic assumptions on the growth impact of investment on long-term real GDP and exports.

### Debt distress classification and conclusions
- The Fund staff view: The Gambia remains at high risk of debt distress based on external debt indicators and the results of the stress tests.
- This assessment reflects:
  - the significant and protracted breach of the policy-dependent indicative threshold by the PV of debt to exports ratio,
  - the vulnerability of other debt indicators to alternative scenarios.
- Debt indicators could deteriorate significantly if new borrowing were contracted on less favorable terms, or if the exchange rate depreciates significantly.
- While an assessment of domestic debt does not affect a country’s classification of debt distress, The Gambia’s large domestic debt stock (just over 29 percent of GDP as of end-2010) and high debt service payments on domestic debt (18 percent of government revenues in 2011) provide further evidence that the country’s overall debt vulnerabilities are high.
- There is considerable risk that without a lasting fiscal adjustment, further accumulation of costly domestic debt would be likely.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt (text provided).*

### 15.      A number of policy recommendations emanate from this assessment and

### _cr12129 - 15.      A number of policy recommendations emanate from this assessment and

### Policy recommendations
- Develop a medium-term debt management strategy that aims for a combination of grants and concessional borrowing for external financing and a borrowing policy consistent with debt sustainability.
- Curb new domestic borrowing to address the high cost of domestic debt.
- As pressure on yields subsides, seek to refinance maturing T-bills with longer-term treasury bonds to extend the maturity profile of the debt and reduce rollover risks.
- Consider policies aimed at diversifying the economy and increasing competitiveness to raise the country’s export potential.
- Set the minimum grant element on external borrowing at not less than 35 percent.

### Major risks to debt sustainability
- Lower than expected economic and/or export growth.
- Higher than expected new borrowing.
- Slippages in fiscal performance.

### Debt indicators and stress-test context
- The DSA results reflect an assumption that new external borrowing that was not subject to established terms had a grant element of 35 percent.
- IMF guideline: a country is considered to be at high risk of debt distress when the baseline scenario indicates a protracted breach by one or more debt indicators, and exacerbated by stress tests, but the country does not currently face payment difficulties.
- The most extreme stress test is defined as the test that yields the highest ratio in 2022 (varies by indicator; e.g., Combination shock; Exports shock; One-time depreciation shock).

### Selected key statistics (external debt and financing)
- Debt service-to-exports ratio (in percent): 13.4, 13.8, 12.0, 12.1, 11.6, 12.2, 13.0, 12.6, 11.0, 8.1, 5.1.
- Grant element of new public sector borrowing (in percent): 32.8, 35.5, 35.2, 35.8, 36.6, 36.7, 35.4, 36.9, 36.9, 36.9.
- Aid flows (in Millions of US dollars) 7/: 130.4, 62.2, 67.7, 83.3, 76.0, 84.2, 90.2, 82.2, 80.9, 111.6, 203.5.
  - o/w Grants: 38.3, 38.5, 46.2, 63.2, 55.0, 60.2, 66.3, 57.8, 55.0, 78.7, 159.0.
  - o/w Concessional loans: 92.1, 23.6, 21.4, 20.0, 21.0, 24.0, 23.8, 24.4, 25.9, 33.0, 44.6.
- Grant-equivalent financing (in percent of GDP) 8/: 8.3, 6.5, 6.5, 6.5, 5.4, 4.9, 4.7, 4.4, 4.6 (selected series shown).
- Total gross financing need (Millions of U.S. dollars): 50.1, 78.6, 90.6, 108.5, 102.6, 107.3, 110.7, 108.9, 106.7, 131.6, 277.8.

### Selected public sector debt sustainability indicators (levels and dynamics)
- PV of PPG external debt (percent of exports): 178.6, 199.0, 189.6, 183.6, 175.3, 166.1, 157.9, 126.7, 94.2 (selected series).
- PV of external debt (in percent of GDP, selected values): 30.6, 34.4, 32.4, 30.7, 29.2, 27.8, 26.6, 21.4, 16.3.
- PV of public sector debt (in percent of GDP, selected values): 61.0, 67.5, 62.0, 57.2, 53.3, 50.1, 47.1, 35.1, 23.1.
- Debt service-to-revenue and grants ratio (in percent): 22.4, 23.5, 24.4, 23.5, 21.1, 19.4, 18.4, 18.2, 16.8, 11.8, 6.8 (selected series).
- Gross financing need 2/ (in percent of GDP, selected): 4.5, 7.4, 5.7, 6.6, 4.0, 3.7, 3.7, 3.8, 3.3, 2.8, 1.6.

### Key macroeconomic assumptions (selected series)
- Real GDP growth (in percent): 6.7, 5.5, 3.3, 3.7, 3.6, -1.7, 9.7, 8.3, 7.0, 5.6, 5.6, 5.8, 5.6, 5.6, 5.6.
- GDP deflator in US dollar terms (change in percent): -13.2, 0.8, -1.8, 1.7, 9.9, -2.2, -0.4, 1.0, 0.8, 1.1, 1.5, 0.3, 1.8, 1.8, 1.8.
- Effective interest rate (percent) 5/: 2.0, 2.0, 2.0, 1.5, 0.5, 1.4, 1.1, 1.1, 1.2, 1.2, 1.2, 1.2, 1.4, 1.5, 1.4.
- Growth of exports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent): -4.5, 0.0, 15.9, 4.3, 9.1, -3.1, 8.0, 7.3, 7.4, 7.5, 7.6, 5.8, 7.6, 7.8, 7.7.
- Growth of imports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent): -5.5, 10.1, 2.9, 8.0, 9.3, 11.3, -0.7, 6.6, 5.4, 5.6, 5.9, 5.7, 7.4, 7.6, 7.4.

*Sources: Country authorities; and staff estimates and projections.*

### 1.      This statement provides information that has become available since the issuance of

### Statement and Executive Board Materials on The Gambia (May 2012)

### New information since staff report
- The new information does not alter the thrust of the staff appraisal.
- Government allocations for drought relief: US$4.6 million (purchases of groundnut seeds and fertilizer).
- Commitments of donor assistance: US$11.2 million.
- Program projection for total cost of drought relief activities: US$23 million, much of which was to take place during the first half of 2012.
- At the Monetary Policy Committee meeting on May 10, the reserve requirement was reduced by 2 percentage points, to 10 percent of deposit liabilities.

### IMF Executive Board approval and program scope
- Executive Board approved a three-year Extended Credit Facility (ECF) arrangement equivalent to SDR 18.66 million (about US$28.3 million).
- Immediate disbursement: SDR 9.33million (about US$14.2 million).
- Program objectives:
  - Meet acute balance of payments need arising from recent crop failure due to drought.
  - Catalyze support from development partners for the Programme for Accelerated Growth and Employment (PAGE).
  - Over the medium term, ease the government’s heavy debt burden through fiscal adjustment and implement a strong economic reform agenda in support of PAGE.
- Policy emphasis in Board statement:
  - Fiscal adjustment to curb government domestic borrowing.
  - Limit external borrowing to concessional loans to reduce risk of debt distress.
  - Rebuild government revenue base, notably introduction of a VAT and reductions in fuel subsidies.
  - Enhance Central Bank independence and capacity for financial sector supervision, particularly stress testing.
  - Leverage private sector participation in infrastructure investment while guarding against contingent liabilities through robust institutions and regulatory frameworks.
  - Reforms needed in key sectors such as energy and telecommunications.

### Recent economic developments (performance and impact of drought)
- Real GDP growth during 2007–10 averaged 5.5 percent.
- Real GDP growth: 2009 at 6.7 percent; 2010 at 5.5 percent; 2011 declined to 3.3 percent.
- Headcount poverty index (US$ 1.25/day): decreased from 58.0 percent in 2003 to 48.5 percent in 2010 (2010 household income survey).
- Inflation: 5.4 percent annual in June 2011; reduced to 4.4 percent at end 2011 and to 3.9 percent at end-March 2012.
- External current account deficit: 15.7 percent of GDP in 2010 to 14.1 percent of GDP in 2011.
- Gross international reserves: stood above 5 months of imports cover at the end of 2011.
- Crop failure in 2011–12 put about one-fourth of the population at risk and will affect economic growth near- and medium-term.
- Real GDP projected to contract by 1½–2 percent in 2012 in staff report text; authorities forecast a contraction of 1.7 percent in 2012.
- With agricultural recovery spread over 2–3 years, real GDP projected at about 8–10 percent a year in 2013–14, conditional on effective drought response and sound macroeconomic policies.
- Downside risks: heavy debt burden, prolonged weakness in the global economy (particularly Europe), terms of trade shocks (food and fuel prices), and weather-related shocks.

### Fiscal developments and policy stance
- Fiscal deficit widened in latter years of previous ECF due to erosion of revenues and large extra-budgetary spending, resulting in sharp increase in costly domestic debt.
- Government corrective measures in 2011:
  - Fiscal tightening reduced bank and non-bank financing to 2.3 percent of GDP compared to 3.8 percent of GDP in 2010.
  - Spending fell below target by 21 percent.
  - Revenue collection rose by 6.9 percent.
- Authorities’ medium-term fiscal agenda (PAGE priorities):
  - Contain public debt and related interest payments to sustainable levels.
  - Introduce VAT in 2013.
  - Monthly implementation of fuel price adjustments.
  - Strengthen tax legislation to broaden the tax base and enforce compliance.
  - Conduct comprehensive tax assessment with IMF to evaluate elimination of subsidies and exemptions.
  - Continue strict implementation of the cash budget system to contain non-statutory spending.
  - Introduce medium term expenditure framework (MTEF) on a pilot basis at two ministries in 2013; budget framework paper and MTEF draft guidelines/manual prepared and discussed.

### Monetary and exchange rate policies
- Monetary policy focus: contain inflation below 5 percent and anchor inflationary expectations; policy stance consistent with economic activity and supported by fiscal consolidation.
- Cooperation between Ministry of Finance and Economic Affairs and the Central Bank of The Gambia (CBG) to improve liquidity forecasting and weekly public sector borrowing requirement forecasts.
- Monetary Policy Committee decisions (May 10, 2012):
  - Policy rate left unchanged at 14 percent.
  - Reserve requirement reduced by 2 percentage points to 10 percent to boost private sector credit and growth.
- CBG to maintain floating exchange rate regime and intervene only to preserve orderly market conditions; limited foreign exchange interventions to mop up liquidity from donor-financed spending.

### Financial sector policies and infrastructure
- Capital augmentation timeline:
  - First phase to D150 million completed in December, 2010.
  - Second phase to D200 million scheduled for December 2012.
  - As at end April, 2012, four banks out of thirteen have met the D200 million requirement; remaining banks expected to meet it by the due date.
  - CBG resolved not to grant forbearance in case of non-compliance.
- Regulatory and supervisory systems:
  - Implementation of Valtech regulatory compliance surveillance system (V-RegCOSS) scheduled to commence following successful User Acceptance Test (UAT).
  - Commercial banks finalizing interfaces between core banking applications and V-RegCOSS.
  - New system expected to make bank supervision and financial stability assessment more efficient and reliable.
  - Securities settlement system expected to go live before end-June 2012.
  - National switch expected to be operational by the end of 2012.
- Credit Reference Bureau (CRB) corrective measures:
  - Contract signed with Valtech for implementation of corrective measures.
  - CRB and V-RegCOSS to share the same server and VNP platforms.
- Supervision model and capacity building:
  - CBG operating a hybrid model of Risk Based Supervision (RBS) — mixture of Risk and Compliance based supervision.
  - RBS manual developed; full implementation contingent on V-RegCOSS.
  - CBG to provide staffing and training to improve macro-prudential analysis capacity.

### Debt management
- Authorities concur with staff assessment that The Gambia remains at a high risk of debt distress.
- Policy commitments:
  - Careful management of external and domestic debt to enhance external stability and increase fiscal savings.
  - Promote donor engagement and cautious borrowing to finance PAGE priorities and address infrastructure gaps without compromising debt sustainability.
  - Source new borrowing from highly concessional windows and attract non-debt creating resource inflows.
  - Continue debt sustainability analysis based on the Fund-Bank framework to ensure debt indicators fall and remain within corresponding thresholds.
  - Enhance debt management capacity while finalizing new debt management strategy.

### Conclusion and program request
- Authorities acknowledge past fiscal slippages that affected completion of the last ECF arrangement and have implemented revenue and expenditure measures to achieve fiscal savings and reduce domestic debt burden and related interest expenses.
- Given large resource requirements to finance PAGE and emergency provision of food, seeds, and fertilizer, authorities consider assistance from the Fund and other development partners critical.
- Authorities seek Executive Board approval for a new three-year ECF arrangement.

*IMF Executive Board materials and authorities’ statement (May 25, 2012).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2012/_cr12129.pdf_
