## _cr13149 - 1. Average Monthly Household Monetary Income

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr13149 - 1. Average Monthly Household Monetary Income](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13149.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13149.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13149.pdf.json)

---

### I. Introduction — recent credit expansion and risk context
- Total credit to GDP has risen by almost 25 percentage points of GDP—to about 49 percent of GDP.
- Consumer credit now represents 46 percent of total credit (compared to 43 percent in 2005 and 23 percent in 2002).
- Consumer credit growth: 22.4 percent in 2010 and 20.7 percent in 2011.
- Credit deepening started at a relatively low level: credit to GDP stood at about 20 percent in 2004.
- International evidence: Dell’Ariccia et al. (2012) find that about one in three booms have been followed by a period of sub-par growth or a banking crisis.
- Despite size and duration of the expansion, “the vast majority of Brazilian banks are in a position to withstand substantial levels of stress including sizable credit shocks.”
- Caveat: household-level analysis uses survey data with last observation effectively 2008–09; consumer credit continued to grow rapidly in 2010–2011.

### II. Consumer credit in Brazil — stylized facts and drivers
- Aggregate leverage and debt servicing:
  - Consumer indebtedness (as a percentage of disposable income) has steadily increased and currently exceeds 40 percent of income—according to Brazil Central Bank estimates.
  - Consumer debt service ratio on Brazil is 23 percent of disposable income.
- Interest rates and portfolio composition:
  - The interest rates levied on unearmarked loans "average around 50 percent", ranging from 30 percent for loans on durables to 175 percent for overdrafts.
  - Mortgages are a small share of the consumer portfolio (about 20 percent of the total), compared to more than 60 percent in Mexico, Chile and Colombia.
- Housing credit dynamics:
  - Housing credit increased by 50 percent per year during 2010–11.
  - Housing now accounts for about 20 percent of consumer credit compared to around 11 percent in 2005.
  - On average, about 20 percent of consumer debt is secured with housing collateral; an additional 40 percent are secured by a durable good or payroll deduction.
  - Real house prices in Brazil increased almost 20 percent during August 2010 to June 2011 (with data caveats).

### III. Lending products, penetration, and household-level distribution (survey-based)
- Data and scope:
  - Analysis uses the Household Budget Surveys (Pesquisa de Orçamentos Familiares) rounds for 2003–04 and 2008–09.
  - The survey contains household total income, financial expenditures (loan payments, mortgage payment, banking fees), modalities for purchasing durables (installments and credit cards), and house ownership/financing status.
  - The survey does not contain information on outstanding debt.
- Lending penetration (selected figures and patterns):
  - On average, about 28 percent of households had some type of financial debt service obligations (banking products), ranging from 5 percent of households in the low income groups to 60 percent in the higher income groups.
  - Including other forms of borrowing (for example, purchasing in installments through retailers), lending penetration increases to 63 percent and is more evenly spread in the population.
  - Credit cards and overdraft accounts are widespread: about 25 percent of households are credit card holders and around 15 percent have overdraft accounts.
  - A more strict definition of loan (financial loan) yields 16 percent penetration and is concentrated among mid and high income groups.
  - Mortgages remain limited: less than 1 percent of the low income households accessed mortgage financing (little change 2003–2009).
  - Acquisitions of automobiles are concentrated in higher income groups, but reliance on automobile financing is similar across household groups.
- Changes 2003–2009 (survey comparisons; selected deltas reported in tables):
  - Credit card holder share increased by 7.3 percentage points (2003–2009, aggregate change reported).
  - Loan (financial) penetration increased by 5.0 percentage points (2003–2009, aggregate change reported).
  - Loan (some form of loan) penetration increased by 18.3 percentage points (2003–2009, aggregate change reported).
- Use of installments and nonbank financing:
  - On average, 70 percent of households use installments when purchasing durables—capturing retailer-financing in addition to bank loans.
  - The central bank estimates of debt and indebtedness are a lower bound because some retail financing and direct developer financing are not captured.

### IV. Signs of household strain and policy-relevant observations
- Aggregate signals of strain:
  - Increases in nonperforming loans on consumer credits.
  - Number of bounced checks has started to pick up.
- Structural drivers that raise household debt-service burdens:
  - High consumer interest rates on many loan types (fixed-rate majority) and relatively short tenors increase debt-service burdens.
  - Portfolio composition with a small mortgage share and substantial unsecured or short-term credit (overdrafts, credit cards) contributes to high aggregate debt service.
- Data gaps and analytical limitations:
  - Household survey lacks outstanding debt measures; authorities may address this in new surveys.
  - The household-level snapshots end in 2008–09 and do not capture the strong consumer credit expansion during 2010–2011 when consumer credit growth averaged 21 percent per year.

### Aggregate debt-service and distributional findings (financial inclusion and accumulation)
- Among those with some form of leverage in the sample survey, total debt service to income ratio averages about 12 percent (compared to the central bank’s estimate of about 16 percent during 2008–09).
- Mortgages and loans (financial costs and payments) weight heavily as a percentage of disposable income; credit cards and overdraft accounts show elevated financial costs for users.
- Table 4 (2008–2009 Survey, staff calculations using Pesquisa de Orçamentos Familiares):
  - About 4.5 percent of the households holding some form of debt had debt-service commitments above 40 percent of their disposable income.
  - 16 percent of households had debt-service-to income exceeding 20 percent.
  - Total percentage of households with some type of loan: 63.4.
  - Income-percentile breakdowns and debt-service buckets are preserved in source tables.

### Household financial stress and sensitivity analysis
- Several studies use a threshold of debt service to income of 40 percent to determine financial distress; alternative thresholds noted in literature.
- Stress test: a 30 percent drop in disposable income implies:
  - The number of households with debt-service to disposable income ratio exceeding 40 percent would increase by 4 percent.
  - Using a tighter threshold, the number of households at risk would increase by nearly 12 percent, bringing the total number at risk to about 28 percent of the total households with a loan.
- Caveat: the stress test ignores whether households could use assets to pay off debt.

### Recent consumer credit developments (post–2009 survey)
- Financial inclusion and accumulation of loans:
  - Nova Central de Risco data: the average number of lending products per borrower with loans exceeding R$5,000 was 3.4 by December 2011.
  - The number of borrowers with loans exceeding R$5,000 increased by 36 percent during 2009–2010, and by 9.5 percent in 2011.
  - Serasa Experian credit report request data: during 2010 demands for credit by low-income households (those with less than R$500 per month) significantly increased, followed by mid-high (R$5,000–10,000) and high income (more than R$ 10,000) households.
- Credit growth and composition:
  - The stock of credit to consumers decelerated slightly during 2011, growing by 20.7 during 2011 compared to 22.4 during 2010.
  - New credit decelerated to 13 percent in 2011 from 22 percent in 2010.
  - While macroprudential measures reduced duration and volume of new durable-goods loans, consumers increased usage of credit cards and overdraft borrowing.
- Household leverage and debt-service:
  - The central bank’s debt service-to-income was broadly stable until mid-2008, then picked up during 2011 reflecting additional credit, some financial tightening, and higher use of more expensive products (credit cards and overdraft).
  - The report notes "average debt service-to-income estimated above 20 percent" as an indication that some households are already under financial distress.

### Delinquency and distress indicators
- By early 2012, the non-performing loans ratio for unearmarked consumer credit reached 7.6 percent (up by 1.9 since December 2010 and only slightly below the 8½ percent ratio achieved in mid-2009).
- The surge in non-performing loan rates is common across all categories of consumer credit, particularly sharp for loans for durables, overdraft accounts and credit cards.
- Other distress indicators: bounced checks picked up; delinquency rates by origination increased, particularly for vehicle loans.
- Origination NPL indicator: NPL after 6 months (percent of consumer loans of that type originated on the same date) shows higher early delinquency for vehicle and some personal loans.

### Macroprudential measures and policy actions
- Tighter financial conditions since mid-2010 through mid-2011:
  - Central bank hiked policy rates.
  - Macroprudential tightening targeted specific lending products in late 2010.
- December 2010 measures:
  - Announced increase of the minimum payment for credit card bills to 15 percent (previously 10 percent), effective in June 2011; anticipated another hike to 20 percent by December 2011 (later revised).
  - Increase of capital requirements for long term consumer loans: the risk weight for such exposures was increased from 100 percent to 150 percent.
  - Capital requirement (in percent) examples from Annex II (December 2010 summary table):
    - Vehicles (financing and leasing) with Maturity between 24 and 36 months and LTV > 80 percent: 16.5
    - Other consumer loans: 11
    - Other consumer loans classified as retail: 8.5
- April 2011:
  - Increase of the IOF on consumer credit operations to 3 percent (previously 1.5 percent).
- November 2011:
  - Maintain the minimum payment for credit card bills at 15 percent (previously programmed to increase to 20 percent in December).
  - Redefinition of risk weights applied to consumer loan exposures involving longer maturities, regardless of loan-to-value amounts: reduced capital requirements for consumer loans with maturity between 24 and 60 months, increased requirements for maturity above 60 months, and elimination of different capital requirements for car loans with maturities between 24 and 60 months according to down payment.
- December 2011:
  - IOF tax on credit for consumption changed from 3 to 2.5 percent.
- Annex II (post-November 2011 summary) capital requirement entries (operation, maturity, and capital requirement):
  - Vehicles: Maturity under 60 months and classified as retail (RW 75%) 8.25%
  - Vehicles: Maturity under 60 months and not classified as retail (RW 100%) 11%
  - Vehicles: Maturity higher than 60 months (RW 150%) 16.5%
  - Consumer loans: Maturity under 36 months (RW 75%) 8.25%
  - Consumer loans: Maturity between 36 and 60 months (RW 150%) 16.5%
  - Consumer loans: Maturity higher than 60 months (RW 300%) 33%
  - Other consumer loans (risk weight: 100 percent) 11%
  - Other consumer loans classified as retail (risk weight: 75 percent) 8.5%
  - Note: includes agricultural loans, payroll deduction loans, home financing, loans funded by Government programs in specified categories.

### Policy implications and recommendations (staff conclusions)
- Continued monitoring by the central bank is key to avoid additional vulnerabilities emerging from consumer credit growth.
- Macroprudential tools targeted to specific lending products are appropriate (as used in late 2010 for consumer and vehicle loans when maturities and loan-to-value raised sustainability concerns).
- Broad-based macroprudential tools may be needed to limit the sensitivity of credit to the economic cycle.
- Credit risk scoring by commercial banks should incorporate information on existing indebtedness and the array of products held by potential customers; recent SCR changes (lowering the threshold that identifies individuals) will help banks identify highly indebted individuals and incorporate product-holdings into risk scoring models.
- Caution is warranted in the mortgage market given very strong growth rates and banks' efforts to gain market share.

*Source: _cr13149 - 1. Average Monthly Household Monetary Income; canonical URL: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13149.pdf*

### 1. Average Monthly Household Monetary Income ................................................................... 7

### _cr13149 - 1. Average Monthly Household Monetary Income ................................................................... 7

### I. Introduction — recent credit expansion and risk context
- Total credit to GDP has risen by almost 25 percentage points of GDP—to about 49 percent of GDP.
- Consumer credit now represents 46 percent of total credit (compared to 43 percent in 2005 and 23 percent in 2002).
- Consumer credit growth: 22.4 percent in 2010 and 20.7 percent in 2011.
- Credit deepening started at a relatively low level: credit to GDP stood at about 20 percent in 2004.
- International evidence: Dell’Ariccia et al. (2012) find that about one in three booms have been followed by a period of sub-par growth or a banking crisis.
- Despite size and duration of the expansion, “the vast majority of Brazilian banks are in a position to withstand substantial levels of stress including sizable credit shocks.”  
- Caveat: household-level analysis uses survey data with last observation effectively 2008–09; consumer credit continued to grow rapidly in 2010–2011.

### II. Consumer credit in Brazil — stylized facts and drivers
- Aggregate leverage and debt servicing:
  - Consumer indebtedness (as a percentage of disposable income) has steadily increased and currently exceeds 40 percent of income—according to Brazil Central Bank estimates.
  - Consumer debt service ratio on Brazil is 23 percent of disposable income.
- Interest rates and portfolio composition:
  - The interest rates levied on unearmarked loans "average around 50 percent", ranging from 30 percent for loans on durables to 175 percent for overdrafts.
  - Mortgages are a small share of the consumer portfolio (about 20 percent of the total), compared to more than 60 percent in Mexico, Chile and Colombia.
- Housing credit dynamics:
  - Housing credit increased by 50 percent per year during 2010–11.
  - Housing now accounts for about 20 percent of consumer credit compared to around 11 percent in 2005.
  - On average, about 20 percent of consumer debt is secured with housing collateral; an additional 40 percent are secured by a durable good or payroll deduction.
  - Real house prices in Brazil increased almost 20 percent during August 2010 to June 2011 (with data caveats).

### III. Lending products, penetration, and household-level distribution (survey-based)
- Data and scope:
  - Analysis uses the Household Budget Surveys (Pesquisa de Orçamentos Familiares) rounds for 2003–04 and 2008–09.
  - The survey contains household total income, financial expenditures (loan payments, mortgage payment, banking fees), modalities for purchasing durables (installments and credit cards), and house ownership/financing status.
  - The survey does not contain information on outstanding debt.
- Lending penetration (selected figures and patterns):
  - On average, about 28 percent of households had some type of financial debt service obligations (banking products), ranging from 5 percent of households in the low income groups to 60 percent in the higher income groups.
  - Including other forms of borrowing (for example, purchasing in installments through retailers), lending penetration increases to 63 percent and is more evenly spread in the population.
  - Credit cards and overdraft accounts are widespread: about 25 percent of households are credit card holders and around 15 percent have overdraft accounts.
  - A more strict definition of loan (financial loan) yields 16 percent penetration and is concentrated among mid and high income groups.
  - Mortgages remain limited: less than 1 percent of the low income households accessed mortgage financing (little change 2003–2009).
  - Acquisitions of automobiles are concentrated in higher income groups, but reliance on automobile financing is similar across household groups.
- Changes 2003–2009 (survey comparisons; selected deltas reported in tables):
  - Credit card holder share increased by 7.3 percentage points (2003–2009, aggregate change reported).
  - Loan (financial) penetration increased by 5.0 percentage points (2003–2009, aggregate change reported).
  - Loan (some form of loan) penetration increased by 18.3 percentage points (2003–2009, aggregate change reported).
- Use of installments and nonbank financing:
  - On average, 70 percent of households use installments when purchasing durables—capturing retailer-financing in addition to bank loans.
  - The central bank estimates of debt and indebtedness are a lower bound because some retail financing and direct developer financing are not captured.

### IV. Signs of household strain and policy-relevant observations
- Aggregate signals of strain:
  - Increases in nonperforming loans on consumer credits.
  - Number of bounced checks has started to pick up.
- Structural drivers that raise household debt-service burdens:
  - High consumer interest rates on many loan types (fixed-rate majority) and relatively short tenors increase debt-service burdens.
  - Portfolio composition with a small mortgage share and substantial unsecured or short-term credit (overdrafts, credit cards) contributes to high aggregate debt service.
- Data gaps and analytical limitations:
  - Household survey lacks outstanding debt measures; authorities may address this in new surveys.
  - The household-level snapshots end in 2008–09 and do not capture the strong consumer credit expansion during 2010–2011 when consumer credit growth averaged 21 percent per year.

*Source: _cr13149 - 1. Average Monthly Household Monetary Income; canonical URL: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13149.pdf*

### 12. Financial inclusion and accumulation of loan products by households has

### 12. Financial inclusion and accumulation of loan products by households has

### Aggregate debt-service and distributional findings
- Among those with some form of leverage in the sample survey, total debt service to income ratio averages about 12 percent (compared to the central bank’s estimate of about 16 percent during 2008–09).
- Mortgages and loans (financial costs and payments) weight heavily as a percentage of disposable income; credit cards and overdraft accounts show elevated financial costs for users.
- Table 4 (2008–2009 Survey, staff calculations using Pesquisa de Orçamentos Familiares):
  - About 4.5 percent of the households holding some form of debt had debt-service commitments above 40 percent of their disposable income.
  - 16 percent of households had debt-service-to income exceeding 20 percent.
  - Total percentage of households with some type of loan: 63.4 (Total row; percentage with some type of loan).
  - Income-percentile breakdown (percentage with some type of loan, and debt-service buckets) preserved in source tables (see Table 4).

### Household financial stress and sensitivity analysis
- Several studies use a threshold of debt service to income of 40 percent to determine financial distress; alternative thresholds noted in literature (examples preserved in source).
- Stress test: a 30 percent drop in disposable income implies:
  - The number of households with debt-service to disposable income ratio exceeding 40 percent would increase by 4 percent.
  - Using a tighter threshold, the number of households at risk would increase by nearly 12 percent, bringing the total number at risk to about 28 percent of the total households with a loan.
- Caveat: the stress test ignores whether households could use assets to pay off debt.

### Recent consumer credit developments (post–2009 survey)
- Financial inclusion and accumulation of loans:
  - Nova Central de Risco data: the average number of lending products per borrower with loans exceeding R$5,000 was 3.4 by December 2011.
  - The number of borrowers with loans exceeding R$5,000 increased by 36 percent during 2009–2010, and by 9.5 percent in 2011.
  - Serasa Experian credit report request data: during 2010 demands for credit by low-income households (those with less than R$500 per month) significantly increased, followed by mid-high (R$5,000–10,000) and high income (more than R$ 10,000) households.
- Credit growth and composition:
  - The stock of credit to consumers decelerated slightly during 2011, growing by 20.7 during 2011 compared to 22.4 during 2010.
  - New credit decelerated to 13 percent in 2011 from 22 percent in 2010.
  - While macroprudential measures reduced duration and volume of new durable-goods loans, consumers increased usage of credit cards and overdraft borrowing.
- Household leverage and debt-service:
  - The central bank’s debt service-to-income was broadly stable until mid-2008, then picked up during 2011 reflecting additional credit, some financial tightening, and higher use of more expensive products (credit cards and overdraft).
  - The report notes "average debt service-to-income estimated above 20 percent" as an indication that some households are already under financial distress.

### Delinquency and distress indicators
- By early 2012, the non-performing loans ratio for unearmarked consumer credit reached 7.6 percent (up by 1.9 since December 2010 and only slightly below the 8½ percent ratio achieved in mid-2009).
- The surge in non-performing loan rates is common across all categories of consumer credit, particularly sharp for loans for durables, overdraft accounts and credit cards.
- Other distress indicators: bounced checks picked up; delinquency rates by origination increased, particularly for vehicle loans.
- Origination NPL indicator: NPL after 6 months (percent of consumer loans of that type originated on the same date) shows higher early delinquency for vehicle and some personal loans (source: SCR at Central Bank and IMF staff calculations).

### Macroprudential measures and policy actions
- Tighter financial conditions since mid-2010 through mid-2011:
  - Central bank hiked policy rates.
  - Macroprudential tightening targeted specific lending products in late 2010.
- December 2010 measures:
  - Announced increase of the minimum payment for credit card bills to 15 percent (previously 10 percent), effective in June 2011; anticipated another hike to 20 percent by December 2011 (later revised).
  - Increase of capital requirements for long term consumer loans: the risk weight for such exposures was increased from 100 percent to 150 percent.
  - Capital requirement (in percent) examples from Annex II (December 2010 summary table):
    - Vehicles (financing and leasing) with Maturity between 24 and 36 months and LTV > 80 percent: 16.5
    - Other consumer loans: 11
    - Other consumer loans classified as retail: 8.5
- April 2011:
  - Increase of the IOF on consumer credit operations to 3 percent (previously 1.5 percent).
- November 2011:
  - Maintain the minimum payment for credit card bills at 15 percent (previously programmed to increase to 20 percent in December).
  - Redefinition of risk weights applied to consumer loan exposures involving longer maturities, regardless of loan-to-value amounts: reduced capital requirements for consumer loans with maturity between 24 and 60 months, increased requirements for maturity above 60 months, and elimination of different capital requirements for car loans with maturities between 24 and 60 months according to down payment.
- December 2011:
  - IOF tax on credit for consumption changed from 3 to 2.5 percent.
- Annex II (post-November 2011 summary) capital requirement entries (operation, maturity, and capital requirement):
  - Vehicles: Maturity under 60 months and classified as retail (RW 75%) 8.25%
  - Vehicles: Maturity under 60 months and not classified as retail (RW 100%) 11%
  - Vehicles: Maturity higher than 60 months (RW 150%) 16.5%
  - Consumer loans: Maturity under 36 months (RW 75%) 8.25%
  - Consumer loans: Maturity between 36 and 60 months (RW 150%) 16.5%
  - Consumer loans: Maturity higher than 60 months (RW 300%) 33%
  - Other consumer loans (risk weight: 100 percent) 11%
  - Other consumer loans classified as retail (risk weight: 75 percent) 8.5%
  - Note: includes agricultural loans, payroll deduction loans, home financing, loans funded by Government programs in specified categories.

### Policy implications and recommendations (staff conclusions)
- Continued monitoring by the central bank is key to avoid additional vulnerabilities emerging from consumer credit growth.
- Macroprudential tools targeted to specific lending products are appropriate (as used in late 2010 for consumer and vehicle loans when maturities and loan-to-value raised sustainability concerns).
- Broad-based macroprudential tools may be needed to limit the sensitivity of credit to the economic cycle.
- Credit risk scoring by commercial banks should incorporate information on existing indebtedness and the array of products held by potential customers; recent SCR changes (lowering the threshold that identifies individuals) will help banks identify highly indebted individuals and incorporate product-holdings into risk scoring models.
- Caution is warranted in the mortgage market given very strong growth rates and banks' efforts to gain market share.

*Source: IMF staff calculations using Pesquisa de Orçamentos Familiares, Banco Central do Brasil, Nova Central de Risco, Serasa Experian, and related annexes in the original chapter.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13149.pdf_
