## 1. Resolution of NPLs

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Resolution of NPLs](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13290.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13290.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13290.pdf.json)

---

### Context
- Economic fundamentals remain relatively strong, although financial sector healing is not yet fully secured.
- Real GDP growth slowed to 5 percent in 2012 from 7½ percent in 2011, reflecting declines in oil and agricultural output.
- Inflation remained within the authorities’ objective range of 6-8 percent; headline inflation stood at 6.0 percent at end-2012 and has more recently fallen to just below the authorities’ 6-8 percent target range.
- Business environment is improving based on standard international rankings; Kazakhstan’s accession to the WTO is expected this year.
- A persistently large stock of NPLs—a legacy of the global crisis—is holding back a meaningful recovery in banks’ profits, although credit growth (especially consumer lending) is picking up.
- The authorities have taken steps to address earlier policy advice (abolishing the exchange rate band in 2011; continuing prudent fiscal policy), but the policy response to high NPLs has been relatively slow.

### Recent developments — macro and external
- Real GDP growth: 5 percent in 2012; GDP growth in 2013 Q1 was 4.6 percent year-on-year.
- Employment growth: about 2½ percent annually over the last three years.
- Core inflation: around 5-5½ percent.
- Current account surplus (CAS): 3.8 percent of GDP in 2012 (almost halved from the prior year).
- Central bank international reserves: decreased by $1 billion to $28.3 billion.
- National Fund of the Republic of Kazakhstan (NFRK): $63 billion, or 30 percent of GDP, at end-June, 2012.
- Preliminary 2013 Q1 BoP: surplus of $0.3 billion (compared to $2.1 billion in 2012 Q1).
- Real exchange rate: average estimate suggests a small undervaluation of 2-3 percent (variation across measures).
- Non-oil sector export penetration: non-oil commodity exports as a share in global non-oil exports increased from 0.12 percent in 2009 to 0.16 percent in 2011.

### Recent developments — financial sector
- System NPL ratio: 30 percent (with large variation across banks).
- Return on assets (largest banks excluding troubled BTA and Alliance): barely reaching 1 percent in 2012.
- System capital adequacy ratio: increased from 17 percent to 18 percent in 2012.
- Private sector credit growth: 13 percent overall; consumer lending expanding at around 40 percent year-on-year (from a low base).
- Policy (official refinancing) rate: 5½ percent held since August 2012 after a cumulative 200 bps cut earlier in 2012.
- NBK interest rate corridor bottom: 0.5 percent.
- Banks’ excess liquidity: for long periods, key money market rates stayed very close to the bottom of the NBK interest rate corridor, accompanied by ample excess liquidity.

### Recent developments — fiscal and public sector
- Overall fiscal surplus: declined to 4.5 percent of GDP in 2012 from 5.9 percent of GDP in 2011.
- Nonoil deficit: deteriorated slightly from 8.8 to 9.0 percent of GDP in 2012; estimated sustainable level is 6 percent of GDP.
- Expenditures rose by 0.8 percent of GDP in 2012 (driven mainly by non-wage current spending).
- Oil export customs duty: increased by 50 percent in April 2013.
- Public sector reorganizations in early 2013:
  - Fiscal planning responsibilities transferred from the Ministry of Finance to the Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning.
  - New extra-budgetary entity (Baiterek) created to combine main development institutions previously part of Samruk Kazyna (SK).
- Pension funds unification: Kazakhstan’s 10 pension funds, with total assets of $22.5 billion (10 percent of GDP), are being unified; the single pension fund will be owned by an independent government agency and managed largely by the NBK.

### Outlook and risks
- 2013 GDP projection: 5¼ percent (staff projection) with full-scale production in the Kashagan oil field projected to commence in 2015 boosting medium-term growth.
- Medium-term non-oil growth convergence: non-oil growth converges to 6 percent over the medium term.
- NFRK assets projection: projected to rise to 40 percent of GDP by 2018.
- Authorities’ medium-term growth target: 6¾ percent overall GDP growth supported by industrialization and diversification programs (authorities’ projections are more optimistic than staff’s).
- Downside risks:
  - Potential global slowdown and lower oil prices.
  - Vulnerability due to close links with Russia and China.
  - Proneness to reversal in short-term capital flows (though external borrowing vulnerability by banks has declined).
  - Continued reliance on oil and unresolved NPLs as key domestic vulnerabilities.
- Authorities’ view: NFRK could be used to arrest sharp deceleration in growth in the event of large negative shocks.

### Policy discussions — overarching
- With broadly stable macroeconomic conditions, focus is on bolstering policy frameworks: addressing NPLs, revamping monetary and fiscal frameworks, and using oil wealth to diversify the economy.
- If fiscal policy proves looser than currently foreseen and inflationary pressures reemerge due to rapid private credit expansion, the policy mix will need reevaluation.

### Policy discussions — Financial Sector (NPLs)
- Authorities’ measures to address NPLs:
  - Established a centralized problem loans fund (PLF), funded by the NBK.
  - Established bank-run special purpose vehicles (SPVs).
  - Introduced NPL ceilings: 20 percent in 2013 and 15 percent in 2014.
  - Considering making the PLF more flexible and possibly increasing its size.
  - Considering extending tax exemptions on written-off loans for banks and buyers of distressed debt beyond 2013 and simplifying procedures.
- Staff recommendations / agreed actions:
  - Strict enforcement of NPL ceilings on a consolidated basis (including SPVs); banks above ceilings should present specific action plans to supervisory authorities and be held accountable.
  - Consider extending the tax exemptions on written-off loans beyond 2013 and simplifying administrative procedures.
  - Bolster on-site bank supervision, enhance liquidity and credit risk assessments, and step up the Early Warning System.
  - Strengthen macroprudential tools to contain rapidly growing consumer lending (e.g., ceilings on loan-to-value and debt-to-income ratios).
  - Planned FSAP update: full-scale update including a ROSC on all financial institutions, currently planned for late 2013 or early 2014.
- Planned government action:
  - Sale of government stakes in previously rescued banks (staff supports market-based, transparent exit to avoid systemic risks).
  - Proposed sale of BTA to Halyk: if Halyk acquires BTA, Halyk’s assets would exceed 25 percent of total banking system assets; concerns about systemic implications given BTA’s fragility and NPLs of about 87 percent as of end-December, 2012.
- Need for additional decisive measures to speed NPL resolution.

### Box 1 — Key points: Resolution of NPLs
- Problem statement:
  - High NPLs weaken banks’ profits and cash flows, undermine lending capacity, and consume significant human resources.
  - Existing framework options: sell NPLs to NBK-funded PLF, transfer to SPVs, or write off using temporary tax relief.
- Shortcomings of initial measures:
  - PLF size small (less than 1 percent of existing NPLs) and limited scope of loans it could purchase.
  - Banks reluctant to sell loans to the PLF at a discount, hoping for recovery.
  - SPVs tend to receive problematic real estate properties, limiting practical NPL reduction.
  - Burdensome procedures hinder banks’ ability to write off loans before tax exemptions expire end-2013.
- Suggested enhancements and policy options:
  - PLF could extend the range of asset purchases to real estate and construction; offer profit-sharing agreements to banks to allow upside from realized collateral.
  - PLF could create and manage pools of similar assets and offer them to specialized investors via auctions (for assets sold to or commissioned to the PLF).
  - Ensure strict implementation of NPL ceilings: require banks to provide specific plans to lower NPLs; NBK should actively monitor implementation; banks failing to comply should raise capital, face limits on operations, or additional supervisory action.
  - Consider mandatory audits of asset quality for major banks at a specified period (for example, end-2014) by independent parties to ascertain asset quality and provide assurance that true restructuring has occurred.
  - Strengthen inspections, including on-site examinations, particularly of large banks.
  - Extend the tax exemption on written-off loans and for buyers of NPLs beyond 2013, and simplify procedures to give banks more time to utilize this approach.

### Monetary policy stance and liquidity management (related cross-cutting content)
- Headline inflation projected to hover around the midpoint of the authorities’ objective range (6-8 percent).
- Core inflation expected to remain stable.
- The NBK is expected to keep its policy interest rate on hold in the coming months.
- NBK changes to minimum reserve requirements (MRR): new regulations exclude banks’ cash on hand and correspondent accounts in foreign currency from reserve assets to better assess tenge liquidity.
- NBK operational changes:
  - conducts weekly auctions for issuance of short-term notes;
  - has begun more active provision of short-term liquidity through repo operations to smooth seasonal fluctuations (e.g., relating to quarterly tax payments).
- Plans under 2013 monetary policy guidelines:
  - engage in more active open market operations (OMOs) for both provision and withdrawal of liquidity;
  - change standing facilities and introduce a new repo rate between the two standing facilities’ interest rates.
- Staff recommendation:
  - envisaged repo instrument could become the new policy rate, preferably within a narrower interest rate corridor;
  - improve communication of transition plans to active OMOs and elaborate on factors guiding interest rate decisions in post-meeting communiqués and quarterly inflation reports.

### Fiscal policy, medium-term framework, and transparency
- Revised 2013 budget (consolidated to include the NFRK) implies lower fiscal balances than initially planned due to weaker revenue performance from lower-than-expected nominal GDP and oil prices.
- Authorities actions:
  - further cut planned spending by 0.2 percent of GDP relative to the original budget;
  - overall reduction in spending of 1.4 percent of GDP relative to 2012.
- Staff recommendation:
  - no further spending cuts this year given cyclical revenue fall and already-large expenditure cuts;
  - ensure spending remains within the revised budget and adhere to plans to make up for shortfall next year.
- Authorities’ official projections:
  - state budget deficit net of the NFRK transfer will fall to 3 percent of GDP by 2020 (consistent with a sustainable consolidated nonoil deficit of 6 percent of GDP).
- Staff concerns:
  - consolidation plans rely primarily on reducing expenditure in percent of GDP and may conflict with announced large-scale public spending plans for development and diversification;
  - revenue projection assumptions do not seem to include planned measures and are not fully aligned with a credible broader macroeconomic framework;
  - fiscal framework is partial and not defined on a consolidated basis.
- Staff recommendations on transparency:
  - record development and diversification programs carried out through quasi-fiscal institutions and PPPs in a transparent manner and account for contingent liabilities properly in the broader fiscal framework;
  - fully integrate the NFRK in fiscal accounts and use the nonoil deficit of the consolidated budget to guide fiscal policy.

### Structural policy, diversification, Samruk Kazyna, and pension unification
- Authorities’ priority: economic diversification to reduce excessive reliance on oil; focus areas include infrastructure improvement, encouraging investment and innovation, boosting productivity, and targeted support to priority sectors.
- Staff cautions:
  - clarify diversification strategy and avoid vertical "picking winners" policies and increasing the role of the state in the economy.
  - implement basic structural reforms to bolster human capital and institutions where Kazakhstan lags behind successful emerging market economies.
- Samruk Kazyna (SK) specifics:
  - SK assets reached $100 billion (50 percent of GDP) in assets last year; about 72 percent of assets are in the oil, gas and financial sectors.
  - SK-related operations realized gross profits hovering around 1-1.3 trillion tenge, or 5 percent of GDP (2009-2012).
  - 2012 bottom line: 1.1 trillion tenge (about 4 percent of GDP) profit, largely related to restructuring of financial liabilities of BTA bank.
  - SK’s investment portfolio targets 100 non-oil projects valued at $81 billion; as of now, 27 projects worth $10 billion have been executed.
- Pension fund unification:
  - Kazakhstan’s 11 pension funds with total assets of US$21.2 billion (11 percent of GDP) are being unified under partial management of the central bank following a Presidential decree early in 2013.
  - Authorities’ intentions: develop a clear and sound market-based investment strategy; secure management independence with arms-length contracts (preferably with reputable international advisors); ensure that individual accounts are maintained.
  - Staff warnings: avoid exacerbating fiscal risks and undermining earlier reform efforts, including eliminating competition in pension services.

### Staff appraisal and prioritized recommendations
- Macro outlook: Average growth of 8 percent over the past decade; growth expected to rise slightly in 2013 to around 5¼ percent; medium-term growth prospects stronger, driven by projected substantial increase in oil output starting in 2015.
- Financial stability and NPLs: Greater determination needed to resolve the NPLs problem and enhance supervision and macroprudential surveillance.
- Key staff recommendations (preserve exact wording/intent):
  - follow through on consideration of redesigning the PLF and take additional action if necessary;
  - strictly enforce new ceilings on NPLs to ensure full compliance;
  - ensure planned exit from troubled banks is market-based and transparent;
  - ensure robust risk management and lending practices amid rapid growth in consumer lending;
  - strengthen on-site supervision, enhance liquidity and credit risk assessments, and step up the Early Warning System;
  - consider extending tax exemptions on written-off loans beyond 2013 and simplifying administrative procedures;
  - bolster macroprudential tools (e.g., ceilings on loan-to-value and debt-to-income ratios) to contain rapidly growing consumer lending;
  - support NBK initiatives to introduce a repo-based policy rate and more active OMOs, alongside clearer communication of transition plans.
- Need for additional decisive measures to speed NPL resolution and to limit fiscal and financial contingent liabilities.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt, "1. Resolution of NPLs" (Republic of Kazakhstan).*

### 1. Resolution of NPLs _____________________________________________________________________________ 10

### 1. Resolution of NPLs

### Context
- Economic fundamentals remain relatively strong, although financial sector healing is not yet fully secured.
- Real GDP growth slowed to 5 percent in 2012 from 7½ percent in 2011, reflecting declines in oil and agricultural output.
- Inflation remained within the authorities’ objective range of 6-8 percent; headline inflation stood at 6.0 percent at end-2012 and has more recently fallen to just below the authorities’ 6-8 percent target range.
- Business environment is improving based on standard international rankings; Kazakhstan’s accession to the WTO is expected this year.
- A persistently large stock of NPLs—a legacy of the global crisis—is holding back a meaningful recovery in banks’ profits, although credit growth (especially consumer lending) is picking up.
- The authorities have taken steps to address earlier policy advice (abolishing the exchange rate band in 2011; continuing prudent fiscal policy), but the policy response to high NPLs has been relatively slow.

### Recent developments — macro and external
- Real GDP growth: 5 percent in 2012; GDP growth in 2013 Q1 was 4.6 percent year-on-year.
- Employment growth: about 2½ percent annually over the last three years.
- Core inflation: around 5-5½ percent.
- Current account surplus (CAS): 3.8 percent of GDP in 2012 (almost halved from the prior year).
- Central bank international reserves: decreased by $1 billion to $28.3 billion.
- National Fund of the Republic of Kazakhstan (NFRK): $63 billion, or 30 percent of GDP, at end-June, 2012.
- Preliminary 2013 Q1 BoP: surplus of $0.3 billion (compared to $2.1 billion in 2012 Q1).
- Real exchange rate: average estimate suggests a small undervaluation of 2-3 percent (variation across measures).
- Non-oil sector export penetration: non-oil commodity exports as a share in global non-oil exports increased from 0.12 percent in 2009 to 0.16 percent in 2011.

### Recent developments — financial sector
- System NPL ratio: 30 percent (with large variation across banks).
- Return on assets (largest banks excluding troubled BTA and Alliance): barely reaching 1 percent in 2012.
- System capital adequacy ratio: increased from 17 percent to 18 percent in 2012.
- Private sector credit growth: 13 percent overall; consumer lending expanding at around 40 percent year-on-year (from a low base).
- Policy (official refinancing) rate: 5½ percent held since August 2012 after a cumulative 200 bps cut earlier in 2012.
- NBK interest rate corridor bottom: 0.5 percent.
- Banks’ excess liquidity: for long periods, key money market rates stayed very close to the bottom of the NBK interest rate corridor, accompanied by ample excess liquidity.

### Recent developments — fiscal and public sector
- Overall fiscal surplus: declined to 4.5 percent of GDP in 2012 from 5.9 percent of GDP in 2011.
- Nonoil deficit: deteriorated slightly from 8.8 to 9.0 percent of GDP in 2012; estimated sustainable level is 6 percent of GDP.
- Expenditures rose by 0.8 percent of GDP in 2012 (driven mainly by non-wage current spending).
- Oil export customs duty: increased by 50 percent in April 2013.
- Public sector reorganizations in early 2013:
  - Fiscal planning responsibilities transferred from the Ministry of Finance to the Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning.
  - New extra-budgetary entity (Baiterek) created to combine main development institutions previously part of Samruk Kazyna (SK).
- Pension funds unification: Kazakhstan’s 10 pension funds, with total assets of $22.5 billion (10 percent of GDP), are being unified; the single pension fund will be owned by an independent government agency and managed largely by the NBK.

### Outlook and risks
- 2013 GDP projection: 5¼ percent (staff projection) with full-scale production in the Kashagan oil field projected to commence in 2015 boosting medium-term growth.
- Medium-term non-oil growth convergence: non-oil growth converges to 6 percent over the medium term.
- NFRK assets projection: projected to rise to 40 percent of GDP by 2018.
- Authorities’ medium-term growth target: 6¾ percent overall GDP growth supported by industrialization and diversification programs (authorities’ projections are more optimistic than staff’s).
- Downside risks:
  - Potential global slowdown and lower oil prices.
  - Vulnerability due to close links with Russia and China.
  - Proneness to reversal in short-term capital flows (though external borrowing vulnerability by banks has declined).
  - Continued reliance on oil and unresolved NPLs as key domestic vulnerabilities.
- Authorities’ view: NFRK could be used to arrest sharp deceleration in growth in the event of large negative shocks.

### Policy discussions — overarching
- With broadly stable macroeconomic conditions, focus is on bolstering policy frameworks: addressing NPLs, revamping monetary and fiscal frameworks, and using oil wealth to diversify the economy.
- If fiscal policy proves looser than currently foreseen and inflationary pressures reemerge due to rapid private credit expansion, the policy mix will need reevaluation.

### Policy discussions — Financial Sector (NPLs)
- Authorities’ measures to address NPLs:
  - Established a centralized problem loans fund (PLF), funded by the NBK.
  - Established bank-run special purpose vehicles (SPVs).
  - Introduced NPL ceilings: 20 percent in 2013 and 15 percent in 2014.
  - Considering making the PLF more flexible and possibly increasing its size.
  - Considering extending tax exemptions on written-off loans for banks and buyers of distressed debt beyond 2013 and simplifying procedures.
- Staff recommendations / agreed actions:
  - Strict enforcement of NPL ceilings on a consolidated basis (including SPVs); banks above ceilings should present specific action plans to supervisory authorities and be held accountable.
  - Consider extending the tax exemptions on written-off loans beyond 2013 and simplifying administrative procedures.
  - Bolster on-site bank supervision, enhance liquidity and credit risk assessments, and step up the Early Warning System.
  - Strengthen macroprudential tools to contain rapidly growing consumer lending (e.g., ceilings on loan-to-value and debt-to-income ratios).
  - Planned FSAP update: full-scale update including a ROSC on all financial institutions, currently planned for late 2013 or early 2014.
- Planned government action:
  - Sale of government stakes in previously rescued banks (staff supports market-based, transparent exit to avoid systemic risks).
  - Proposed sale of BTA to Halyk: if Halyk acquires BTA, Halyk’s assets would exceed 25 percent of total banking system assets; concerns about systemic implications given BTA’s fragility and NPLs of about 87 percent as of end-December, 2012.
- Need for additional decisive measures to speed NPL resolution.

### Box 1 — Key points: Resolution of NPLs
- Problem statement:
  - High NPLs weaken banks’ profits and cash flows, undermine lending capacity, and consume significant human resources.
  - Existing framework options: sell NPLs to NBK-funded PLF, transfer to SPVs, or write off using temporary tax relief.
- Shortcomings of initial measures:
  - PLF size small (less than 1 percent of existing NPLs) and limited scope of loans it could purchase.
  - Banks reluctant to sell loans to the PLF at a discount, hoping for recovery.
  - SPVs tend to receive problematic real estate properties, limiting practical NPL reduction.
  - Burdensome procedures hinder banks’ ability to write off loans before tax exemptions expire end-2013.
- Suggested enhancements and policy options:
  - PLF could extend the range of asset purchases to real estate and construction; offer profit-sharing agreements to banks to allow upside from realized collateral.
  - PLF could create and manage pools of similar assets and offer them to specialized investors via auctions (for assets sold to or commissioned to the PLF).
  - Ensure strict implementation of NPL ceilings: require banks to provide specific plans to lower NPLs; NBK should actively monitor implementation; banks failing to comply should raise capital, face limits on operations, or additional supervisory action.
  - Consider mandatory audits of asset quality for major banks at a specified period (for example, end-2014) by independent parties to ascertain asset quality and provide assurance that true restructuring has occurred.
  - Strengthen inspections, including on-site examinations, particularly of large banks.
  - Extend the tax exemption on written-off loans and for buyers of NPLs beyond 2013, and simplify procedures to give banks more time to utilize this approach.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt, "1. Resolution of NPLs" (Republic of Kazakhstan).*

### 19.      The monetary policy stance remains appropriate. With headline inflation projected to

### _cr13290 - 19.      The monetary policy stance remains appropriate. With headline inflation projected to

### Monetary policy stance and inflation outlook
- Headline inflation projected to hover around the midpoint of the authorities’ objective range (6-8 percent).
- Core inflation expected to remain stable.
- The NBK is expected to keep its policy interest rate on hold in the coming months.
- The stance may need reevaluation if:
  - excess liquidity in the banking system translates into more rapid private sector credit expansion, or
  - fiscal policy turns out looser than currently expected by staff.

### Liquidity management and central bank operations
- NBK changes to minimum reserve requirements (MRR):
  - new regulations exclude banks’ cash on hand and correspondent accounts in foreign currency from reserve assets to better assess tenge liquidity.
- NBK operational changes:
  - conducts weekly auctions for issuance of short-term notes;
  - has begun more active provision of short-term liquidity through repo operations to smooth seasonal fluctuations (e.g., relating to quarterly tax payments).
- Plans under 2013 monetary policy guidelines:
  - engage in more active open market operations (OMOs) for both provision and withdrawal of liquidity;
  - change standing facilities and introduce a new repo rate between the two standing facilities’ interest rates.
- Staff support for these initiatives to enhance NBK’s ability to control money market interest rates.

### Policy rate, signaling, and communication
- Official refinancing rate has played little role in guiding key market interest rates.
- Staff recommendation:
  - envisaged repo instrument could become the new policy rate, preferably within a narrower interest rate corridor;
  - the new policy rate should better guide key money market rates and bolster signaling of monetary policy.
- Acknowledged trade-off: adopting the repo as policy rate may imply additional interest cost, but this should be manageable.
- Communication enhancements urged:
  - more open and clear communication of transition plans to active OMOs;
  - elaboration on factors guiding interest rate decisions in post-meeting communiqués and quarterly inflation reports.
- NBK agreed on the need to communicate plans openly to ensure effective transition.

### Exchange rate flexibility
- Authorities agreed to consider allowing greater exchange rate flexibility over the medium term.
- Constraints and considerations:
  - economy’s dollarization (roughly 40 percent of bank deposits are dollar denominated) complicates monetary policy and makes formal inflation targeting inappropriate at this juncture;
  - scope to increase reliance on the interest rate lever and reduce the role of the exchange rate as a policy instrument.
- Authorities’ stance on FX interventions:
  - interventions aimed at smoothing sharp fluctuations in supply and demand for foreign currency, including impacts on NBK’s management of the NFRK;
  - authorities agreed to consider staff’s recommendations.

### Fiscal policy: 2013 revised budget and near-term stance
- Revised 2013 budget (consolidated to include the NFRK) implies lower fiscal balances than initially planned due to weaker revenue performance from lower-than-expected nominal GDP and oil prices.
- Authorities actions:
  - further cut planned spending by 0.2 percent of GDP relative to the original budget;
  - overall reduction in spending of 1.4 percent of GDP relative to 2012.
- Result: overall balance expected to stay broadly unchanged from last year (compared with an improvement of 0.5 percent of GDP in the original budget).
- Staff recommendation:
  - no further spending cuts this year given cyclical revenue fall and already-large expenditure cuts;
  - ensure spending remains within the revised budget and adhere to plans to make up for shortfall next year.

### Medium-term fiscal framework and consolidation concerns
- Authorities’ official projections:
  - state budget deficit net of the NFRK transfer will fall to 3 percent of GDP by 2020 (consistent with a sustainable consolidated nonoil deficit of 6 percent of GDP).
- Staff concerns with projections:
  - consolidation plans rely primarily on reducing expenditure in percent of GDP and may conflict with announced large-scale public spending plans for development and diversification;
  - revenue projection assumptions do not seem to include planned measures and are not fully aligned with a credible broader macroeconomic framework;
  - fiscal framework is partial and not defined on a consolidated basis.
- Authorities’ intended revisions by end of year:
  - include some development and diversification spending plans in the new framework with some increases in transfer from the NFRK through 2018;
  - ensure tax revenue projections are consistent with a realistic macro framework and incorporate planned tax policy measures aimed at reducing medium-term reliance on oil, including:
    - increasing excise taxes on alcohol and tobacco products;
    - limiting use of preferential tax regimes in agriculture and in the SME sector;
    - introducing a new luxury tax;
    - revising the personal income tax to make it more progressive;
    - streamlining the property tax.
  - intend to keep their 2020 deficit target unchanged.
  - consider concentrating macroeconomic and budget planning within the Ministry of Economy and Budget Planning to ensure consistency.

### Fiscal transparency, the NFRK, and contingent liabilities
- Staff recommendations:
  - record development and diversification programs carried out through quasi-fiscal institutions and PPPs in a transparent manner and account for contingent liabilities properly in the broader fiscal framework;
  - fully integrate the NFRK in fiscal accounts and use the nonoil deficit of the consolidated budget to guide fiscal policy.
- Authorities’ position:
  - acknowledged deficiencies from excluding the NFRK from fiscal accounts;
  - look forward to collaborating with forthcoming IMF TA to improve fiscal statistics coverage and compliance with the GFS manual.
- Debt and financing:
  - gross public debt projected to stay at low levels over the medium term, but unrecorded contingent liabilities may pose a risk;
  - government chooses to maintain a domestic debt market despite negative gross financing needs from continuing fiscal surpluses;
  - Ministry of Finance plans to issue a Eurobond of $1 billion this year to establish a benchmark for national companies.
- Staff welcomed intentions to introduce budgetary provisions to keep broader public sector debt under control, e.g., setting ceilings for total government and quasi-fiscal debt.

### Structural policy: diversification, public investment, and Samruk Kazyna (SK)
- Authorities’ priority: economic diversification to reduce excessive reliance on oil; focus areas include infrastructure improvement, encouraging investment and innovation, boosting productivity, and targeted support to priority sectors.
- Staff cautions:
  - clarify diversification strategy and avoid vertical "picking winners" policies and increasing the role of the state in the economy.
  - implement basic structural reforms to bolster human capital and institutions where Kazakhstan lags behind successful emerging market economies.
  - improve business environment and public service delivery to support broad-based, private-sector-led growth.
- Public investment guidance:
  - ensure prudent management of oil revenues and carry out public investment in line with absorptive capacity and high efficiency standards;
  - conduct careful cost-benefit analysis and evaluation of outcomes for programs across modalities (general government budget, quasi-fiscal institutions, PPPs).
  - risks of excessive public spending include Dutch disease, erosion of buffers, or accumulation of costly external debt.
- Samruk Kazyna (SK) specifics:
  - SK assets reached $100 billion (50 percent of GDP) in assets last year; about 72 percent of assets are in the oil, gas and financial sectors.
  - SK managed over $78 billion in assets in 2010, rising to over $100 billion by end 2012 (about 50 percent of GDP).
  - Liability composition: bulk of liabilities—42 percent of the total—shared between oil/gas and financial sectors.
  - Roughly one third of corporate deposits in banks belong to SK.
  - SK profitability and scale:
    - SK-related operations realized gross profits hovering around 1-1.3 trillion tenge, or 5 percent of GDP (2009-2012).
    - 2012 bottom line: 1.1 trillion tenge (about 4 percent of GDP) profit, largely related to restructuring of financial liabilities of BTA bank.
  - SK’s role in pension fund unification expected to be small (mediatory role).
  - SK’s investment portfolio targets 100 non-oil projects valued at $81 billion; as of now, 27 projects worth $10 billion have been executed.

### Pension fund unification
- Draft law to unify private pension funds approved by parliament.
- Authorities’ intentions to mitigate risks:
  - develop a clear and sound market-based investment strategy for the assets;
  - secure management independence with arms-length contracts (preferably with reputable international advisors);
  - ensure that individual accounts are maintained.
- Staff warnings:
  - avoid exacerbating fiscal risks and undermining earlier reform efforts, including eliminating competition in pension services.
- Potential market effects:
  - unification may reduce demand for government paper from pension funds, with expected increase in banks’ and non-bank financial institutions’ participation, potentially supporting NBK’s move to more active OMOs.
- Ministry of Finance highlighted need for full collaboration with NBK for successful outcomes.

### Staff appraisal: growth prospects and financial sector stability
- Macro outlook:
  - Average growth of 8 percent over the past decade.
  - Growth expected to rise slightly in 2013 to around 5¼ percent.
  - Medium-term growth prospects stronger, driven by projected substantial increase in oil output starting in 2015.
- Policy opportunity: favorable outlook offers chance to bolster policy architecture for durable and inclusive growth while reducing vulnerabilities.
- Financial stability and nonperforming loans (NPLs):
  - Greater determination needed to resolve the NPLs problem and enhance supervision and macroprudential surveillance.
  - Staff recommendations:
    - follow through on consideration of redesigning the PLF and take additional action if necessary;
    - strictly enforce new ceilings on NPLs to ensure full compliance;
    - ensure planned exit from troubled banks is market-based and transparent;
    - ensure robust risk management and lending practices amid rapid growth in consumer lending;
    - strengthen on-site supervision, enhance liquidity and credit risk assessments, and step up the Early Warning System.

*Source: IMF staff report text provided in the content unit.*

### 35.      Further bolstering the monetary policy framework requires a new policy rate,

### 35.      Further bolstering the monetary policy framework requires a new policy rate,

### Monetary policy framework and communication
- Introduce a policy rate that signals better the stance of policy to anchor expectations.
- Enhance communication: the NBK should communicate more openly and clearly the transition plans to active open market operations (OMOs) and elaborate on the factors guiding interest rate decisions in public communications.
- Re-evaluate the role of the exchange rate within the broader monetary policy framework and allow for greater flexibility over the medium term.
- Strengthen regulation of banking system liquidity to support the new framework.

### Open market operations and market development
- Active OMOs should become a cornerstone of the revamped monetary policy framework.
- Secure increased financial institutions’ participation in the market for government paper to support active OMOs; this requires close collaboration between the NBK and the Ministry of Finance.

### Private pension funds unification
- Unification of the private pension funds must avoid exacerbating fiscal risks and undermining earlier reform efforts.
- Adopt a clear and sound market-based investment strategy for the assets while ensuring that individual accounts are maintained.
- Close NBK–Ministry of Finance collaboration is essential to support market development for government paper and OMOs.

### Fiscal consolidation and non-oil deficit
- Lowering the non-oil deficit over the medium term is a key priority that necessitates a credible fiscal consolidation strategy.
- The consolidation plans outlined in the current medium-term fiscal framework may be inconsistent with announced (but non-budgeted) large scale public spending plans related to the government’s development and diversification programs.
- Assumptions underlying both expenditure and revenue projections need full alignment with a macroeconomic framework that accounts for the effects of envisioned fiscal measures.

### Fiscal framework coverage and transparency
- Integrate fully the NFRK with fiscal accounts and use consolidated budget balances for guiding fiscal policy.
- Improve transparency of quasi-fiscal operations, including those related to the government’s development and diversification programs, given the large scale of the quasi-fiscal sector.
- The authorities’ intention to monitor more closely the external debt of the quasi-fiscal sector is welcome.

### Diversification and long-term growth
- Reducing the economy’s dependence on oil remains a primary long-term objective.
- Successful diversification and promotion of broad-based, private-sector led growth require bolstering human capital, the business environment, and institutions.
- Ensure continued commitment to prudent management of oil revenues and carry out critical investment in line with absorptive capacity and high standards of efficiency.

*Source: _cr13290 - 35.      Further bolstering the monetary policy framework requires a new policy rate,*

### 40.      It is proposed that the next Article IV consultation take place on the standard 12–

### _cr13290 - 40.      It is proposed that the next Article IV consultation take place on the standard 12–

### Macroeconomic developments
- Growth decelerated throughout 2012 and early 2013, but remains solid.
- 2012 Real GDP (Year-on-year percent change) — chart labels include country abbreviations (e.g., KAZ).
- Real growth measures shown: Real growth y/y (left axis) and Real growth q/q SA.
- Industrial production (Year-on-year percent change) components shown: All Industry, Mining, Manufacturing.
- Employment and inflation:
  - Unemployment rate and Employment growth y/y (right scale) are plotted.
  - Inflation (y/y growth) series: Core, Headline, Food, with an Inflation objective range indicated.
- Sources: Kazakhstani authorities and IMF staff estimates.

### Banking sector developments
- Size and composition:
  - Bank Assets to GDP (smoothened ratio) series from Mar-08 to Dec-12.
  - Bank Assets to GDP reached a more sustainable level following large deleveraging.
- Credit and deposits:
  - Credit, year-on-year percent change series (Feb-11 to Feb-13).
  - Loans to deposits ratio series.
  - Credit to the economy (percent of GDP) in Table 1: 50.2 (2009), 39.5 (2010), 35.9 (2011), 37.2 (2012), 40.1 (2013 proj.), 41.4 (2014 proj.), 42.4 (2015 proj.), 42.7 (2016 proj.), 43.0 (2017 proj.), 43.3 (2018 proj.).
- Asset quality and capital:
  - Capital adequacy ratio has reached pre-crisis levels; capital adequacy ratio (End of Period) plotted.
  - Non Performing Loans (End of Period) and Provisions / Overdue Loans (RHS) plotted; NPLs (90-day).
- Currency composition and flows:
  - Commercial banks' FX deposits (percent of total) and FX loans (percent of total) series.
  - Confidence in the tenge has supported a moderate decline in foreign exchange deposits.
  - Deposit growth (3mma, RHS) and breakdown of deposits (in billions of tenge) by Households, Private corporates, Public entities.
- Selected prudential indicators (Table 5 highlights):
  - Capital adequacy ratio (K2, percent of risk weighted assets): 14.9 (2008), -8.2 (2009), 17.9 (2010), 17.4 (2011), 18.7 (2012), 17.5 (Q1).
  - Non performing loans to total loans: 8.1 (2008), 36.5 (2009), 32.6 (2010), 35.1 (2011), -- (2012).
  - Share of resident deposits denominated in FX: 40 (2008), 43.9 (2009), 35.6 (2010), 31.7 (2011), 31.4 (2012), 33.7 (Q1).
  - FX loans in percent of FX deposits: 254.2 (2008), 192.7 (2009), 179.2 (2010), 181.5 (2011), 140.1 (2012), 130.1 (Q1).

### Fiscal sector developments and outlook
- Overall budget and non-oil balance:
  - The overall budget surplus is expected to remain stable.
  - Non-oil deficit is expected to improve only marginally.
  - Overall fiscal balance (in percent of GDP), Figure 3 timeline: 2008–2013 preliminary and 2013 proj. shown.
- Revenues and expenditures:
  - Tax revenue from oil sector and non-oil sector shares plotted; oil accounts for an increasingly large share of fiscal revenues.
  - Revenue performance is not expected to improve in the near term, while expenditures are expected to decline as a share of GDP.
- Fiscal indicators (Table 3, selected rows in percent of GDP):
  - Total revenue and grants: 22.1 (2009), 23.9 (2010), 27.7 (2011), 27.0 (2012), 25.6 (2013), 24.3 (2014), 24.0 (2015), 23.2 (2016), 22.0 (2017), 21.0 (2018).
  - Of which: oil revenues: 9.2 (2009), 11.7 (2010), 14.7 (2011), 13.5 (2012), 13.1 (2013), 11.5 (2014), 11.0 (2015), 9.9 (2016), 8.6 (2017), 7.5 (2018).
  - Expenditures and net lending: 23.5 (2009), 22.5 (2010), 21.8 (2011), 22.5 (2012), 21.1 (2013), 20.6 (2014), 20.3 (2015), 20.0 (2016), 19.7 (2017), 19.5 (2018).
  - Overall fiscal balance: -1.4 (2009), 1.4 (2010), 5.9 (2011), 4.5 (2012), 4.6 (2013), 3.4 (2014), 3.6 (2015), 3.1 (2016), 2.3 (2017), 1.5 (2018).
  - Non-oil fiscal balance (percent of GDP): -10.6 (2009), -10.3 (2010), -8.8 (2011), -9.0 (2012), -8.5 (2013), -8.1 (2014), -7.4 (2015), -6.7 (2016), -6.3 (2017), -6.0 (2018).
- Public debt:
  - General government gross debt remains low, while net debt is negative (Figure 3).
  - Public sector debt (Table 6, Baseline: Public sector debt in percent of GDP): 6.5 (2008), 10.2 (2009), 10.7 (2010), 10.4 (2011), 12.4 (2012), 13.4 (2013), 13.8 (2014), 13.7 (2015), 13.9 (2016), 14.4 (2017), 15.5 (2018).

### External sector developments and outlook
- Current account and trade:
  - High commodity prices led to increased current account surplus, which is projected to decline slightly in 2013.
  - Trade Balance and Current Account Balance plotted (percent of GDP) for 2008–2013 prelim./proj.
  - Current account balance (percent of GDP), Table 1: -3.6 (2009), 0.9 (2010), 6.5 (2011), 3.8 (2012), 3.1 (2013 proj.), 1.9 (2014 proj.), 2.2 (2015 proj.), 2.2 (2016 proj.), 1.8 (2017 proj.), 1.6 (2018 proj.).
- Financial account and capital flows:
  - Financial account benefitted from FDI inflows; Net FDI (percent of GDP) series plotted.
  - Net FDI (Table 2, in billions of U.S. dollars): 10.1 (2009), 3.7 (2010), 9.3 (2011), 12.4 (2012), 12.8 (2013), 13.9 (2014), 13.9 (2015), 12.6 (2016), 12.2 (2017), 11.9 (2018).
- Reserves and National Oil Fund:
  - NBK foreign exchange reserves (GIR) have declined slightly, while NFRK assets continued to increase.
  - NBK gross reserves (eop), Table 1: 23.1 (2009), 28.3 (2010), 29.3 (2011), 28.3 (2012), 34.4 (2013 proj.), 41.0 (2014 proj.), 48.2 (2015 proj.), 54.2 (2016 proj.), 59.6 (2017 proj.), 63.6 (2018 proj.).
  - NFRK assets (eop), Table 1: 24.4 (2009), 31.0 (2010), 43.6 (2011), 57.8 (2012), 72.8 (2013 proj.), 86.5 (2014 proj.), 100.9 (2015 proj.), 116.4 (2016 proj.), 131.9 (2017 proj.), 149.0 (2018 proj.).
- External debt:
  - External debt continues to decline (Figure 4).
  - Total external debt (Table 1): 112.9 (2009), 118.2 (2010), 125.2 (2011), 137.1 (2012), 146.7 (2013 proj.), 156.3 (2014 proj.), 164.5 (2015 proj.), 172.9 (2016 proj.), 181.0 (2017 proj.), 188.8 (2018 proj.).
  - External debt in percent of GDP (Table 7, Baseline): 93.9 (2007), 79.8 (2008), 97.9 (2009), 97.9 (2010), 66.6 (2011), 67.6 (2012), 66.0 (2013), 62.9 (2014), 58.8 (2015), 55.1 (2016), 51.3 (2017), 47.5 (2018).

### Debt sustainability and stress tests
- Public debt sustainability (Figure 5 and Table 6):
  - Public sector debt-to-revenue ratio: 23.4 (2008), 46.2 (2009), 44.6 (2010), 37.6 (2011), 46.0 (2012), 52.4 (2013), 56.8 (2014), 56.9 (2015), 60.0 (2016), 65.4 (2017), 73.4 (2018).
  - Identified debt-creating flows (Table 6, line): -2.6 (2008), 1.4 (2009), -3.7 (2010), -8.2 (2011), -5.5 (2012), -5.8 (2013), -5.1 (2014), -5.3 (2015), -4.7 (2016), -3.9 (2017), -3.2 (2018).
  - Primary deficit (percent of GDP): -1.4 (2008), 1.0 (2009), -1.8 (2010), -6.3 (2011), -4.9 (2012), -5.1 (2013), -4.1 (2014), -4.1 (2015), -3.6 (2016), -2.8 (2017), -2.1 (2018).
  - Automatic debt dynamics contribution: -1.0 (2008), 0.4 (2009), -1.8 (2010), -1.8 (2011), -0.5 (2012), -0.6 (2013), -1.0 (2014), -1.1 (2015), -1.1 (2016), -1.1 (2017), -1.1 (2018).
- External debt sustainability (Figure 6 and Table 7):
  - Identified external debt-creating flows (percent of GDP): -23.1 (2007), -36.6 (2008), 5.8 (2009), -30.5 (2010), -30.9 (2011), -15.3 (2012), -13.0 (2013), -12.0 (2014), -11.9 (2015), -10.5 (2016), -9.0 (2017), -8.1 (2018).
  - Automatic debt dynamics: -15.8 (2007), -19.1 (2008), 16.7 (2009), -19.9 (2010), -15.4 (2011), -3.3 (2012), -1.8 (2013), -1.7 (2014), -2.0 (2015), -1.8 (2016), -1.4 (2017), -1.3 (2018).
  - Gross external financing need (in billions of U.S. dollars): 38.4 (2007), 21.6 (2008), 28.2 (2009), 22.8 (2010), 9.6 (2011), 14.6 (2012), 17.3 (2013), 22.3 (2014), 22.4 (2015), 23.2 (2016), 25.3 (2017), 28.1 (2018).
- Stress scenarios and shocks:
  - Public debt stress tests include interest-rate shock, growth shock, primary balance shock, combined shock, contingent liabilities shock (one-time real depreciation of 30 percent and 10 percent of GDP shock to contingent liabilities occur in 2010).
  - External debt stress tests include interest rate shock, growth shock, noninterest current account shock, combined shock, and real depreciation shock (30 percent depreciation in 2013).

### Key projections and indicators (selected from Tables)
- National accounts and prices (Table 1, Real GDP annual percent change): 1.2 (2009), 7.3 (2010), 7.5 (2011), 5.0 (2012), 5.2 (2013 proj.), 5.3 (2014 proj.), 6.1 (2015 proj.), 5.8 (2016 proj.), 5.4 (2017 proj.), 5.4 (2018 proj.).
- Consumer price index (p.a): 7.3 (2009), 7.1 (2010), 8.3 (2011), 5.1 (2012), 6.3 (2013 proj.), 6.3 (2014 proj.), 6.2 (2015 proj.), 6.0 (2016 proj.), 6.0 (2017 proj.), 6.0 (2018 proj.).
- Oil price (U.S. dollars per barrel, Table 1, memorandum): 61.8 (2009), 79.0 (2010), 104.0 (2011), 105.0 (2012), 100.1 (2013 proj.), 95.4 (2014 proj.), 92.0 (2015 proj.), 89.5 (2016 proj.), 87.5 (2017 proj.), 86.0 (2018 proj.).
- Nominal GDP (in billions of U.S. dollars, Table 1 memorandum): 115.3 (2009), 148.0 (2010), 188.0 (2011), 202.6 (2012), 222.4 (2013 proj.), 248.7 (2014 proj.), 279.8 (2015 proj.), 314.2 (2016 proj.), 353.1 (2017 proj.), 397.3 (2018 proj.).

*Source: IMF staff presentation and tables in the Republic of Kazakhstan Article IV staff report (figures, tables, and projections as cited).*

### Annex I. Kazakhstan: Risk Assessment Matrix

### _cr13290 - Annex I. Kazakhstan: Risk Assessment Matrix

### Global slowdown affecting China and Russia
- Nature/source:
  - Russia, China, and the EU are the main trading partners. Risk indicators tend to move in line with those of Russia. China is a major source of investment.
- Likelihood of realization in the next three years:
  - Staff assessment: Medium
  - Latest Fund staff’s projections suggest that growth in China and Russia is slowing. Risks to prolongation (or further weakening) of the Euro-area crisis remain an additional downside risk.
  - Staff assessment: Medium
- Expected impact on the economy if risk is realized:
  - Kazakhstan would be affected through trade, finance, and investment channels. A deterioration of market conditions in the EU or Russia could have an impact on trade flows, FDI and portfolio inflows.

### Large and prolonged decline in oil prices
- Nature/source:
  - The economy remains highly dependent on oil for export proceeds and budget revenues.
- Likelihood of realization in the next three years:
  - Staff assessment: Low
  - A global recession with a protracted slow growth could depress demand for energy and cause a sharp fall in oil prices.
  - Staff assessment: High
- Expected impact on the economy if risk is realized:
  - While reserves are sufficient to contain an immediate shock, growth in the non-oil sectors would be negatively affected.

### Failure to improve the health of the banking system
- Nature/source:
  - The banking system is saddled with very high NPLs. A forced merger of Halyk and BTA banks could raise systemic risks.
- Likelihood of realization in the next three years:
  - Staff assessment: Medium
  - Attempts to resolve banking sector issues have not been successful so far. Schemes to resolve the high NPLs need to be improved.
  - Staff assessment: Medium
- Expected impact on the economy if risk is realized:
  - Financial sector stress could put pressure on deposits, leading to a possible credit crunch. Potential capital shortfalls represent a large contingent liability for the government.

### Political uncertainty
- Nature/source:
  - Political incentives may be misaligned with economic priorities.
- Likelihood of realization in the next three years:
  - Staff assessment: Low to medium
  - Following episodes of social unrest in late 2011 the authorities succeeded in consolidating power. However, the recently proposed changes to the pension system have generated public discontent.
  - Staff assessment: Medium to high
- Expected impact on the economy if risk is realized:
  - Political factors may hinder effective policymaking and affect growth and stability.

---

### Annex II. Kazakhstan: Business Environment and Governance — Key findings and indicators

### Ease of doing business and governance trends
- Doing Business ranking:
  - 2013: 49 (out of 185)
- Ease of Doing Business (Percentile rank) graphical data:
  - DB-2013 percent rank shown for countries including BRATURGEOKAZMYSMEXCZEPOL (visual chart in source).
- Changes in World Governance Indicator Composite (WGI-4) 2000–2011:
  - WGI-4 (Percentile rank) for countries including KAZ, CCA, MEX, BRA, TUR, POL, CZE, etc.; source indicates improvement measures (visual chart in source).

### Firm-level business constraints (BEEPS)
- Categories shown in source chart (percent of firms):
  - Ta x, Ta x administration, License, Corruption, Crime, Court, Irregular competition, Finance, Electricity, Customs, Labor regulation, Worker skill.
- Comparative positioning includes countries KAZ, GEO, IDN, MEX, CCA, POL, CZE, TUR, BRA, FRA, MYS (visual chart in source).

### Labor market and demographics
- Labor Market Efficiency and Young Population Ratio (Population ratio for those of 14 years or younger):
  - Sources: World Development Indicators (2012) and World Economic Forum Global Competitiveness Report (2012).
- Starting a Business (Number of days) comparative data shown for POL, CZE, LTU, KAZ, BGR, LVA, HUN, GEO (visual chart in source).

### Political transformation and democracy indicators
- Voice and Accountability (Percentile rank) 2000–2011: comparative chart for KAZ, CCA, MYS, TUR, MEX, BRA, CZE, POL.
- Political Stability and Absence of Violence/Terrorism (WGI), Political Transformation (BTI), Democracy (EIU) shown in comparative charts for KAZ, POL, TUR, BRA, MYS, IDN.

### Selected transparency, governance, and institutional indicators (text panel)
- WB World Governance Indicator Composite 1/2011: 34 (0-100, higher is better); 2000: 22 (0-100)
- WEF Global Competetiveness Indicator Ranking 2011: 51 (out of 144); 2011: 72 (out of 142); 2009: 67 (out of 133)
- WEF Labor Market Composite 2/2012: 38 (out of 144); 2011: 47 (out of 142)
- Corruption Perception Index 2012: 38 (out of 144); 2011: 47 (out of 142)

### Fiscal, financial, and extractive industry transparency notes
- Fiscal sector:
  - Comprehensive coverage of public finance statistics
  - Insufficient transparency of quasifiscal and SOE operations
  - Government reports on performance versus objectives: MTEF has limited impact on fiscal decision making
  - Sovereign Wealth Fund: Disclosure of assets, but not of investments
- Extractive Industries:
  - Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI): Membership expected by end of 2013
- Financial sector:
  - Availability of detailed bank data: Yes
  - Transparency on financial transactions of Central Bank: No reporting of interventions

---

### Relations with the Fund; statistical and financial data; technical assistance

### Membership and exchange arrangements (as of May 31, 2013)
- Joined: 07/15/92
- Accepted Article VIII, Sections 2, 3, and 4 in 1996 and maintains an exchange system free of restrictions on the making of payments and transfers for current international transactions.
- De jure exchange rate arrangement: managed float
- De facto arrangement: crawl-like
- Notes on historical regimes and changes: trading band histories and devaluation events described (e.g., February 2009 devaluation by 18 percent against the US dollar; trading band T150/US$ +/- 3 percent; February 2010 band asymmetric T150/US$ +10/-15 percent; February 2011 trading band abolished).

### Fund financial positions and arrangements
- Quota and Fund holdings (General Resources Account):
  - Quota 365.70100.00
  - Fund holdings of currency 365.70100.00
  - Reserve position in the Fund 0.010.00
- SDR Department:
  - Net cumulative allocation 343.65100.00
  - Holdings 345.63100.57
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans:
  - None
- Latest Financial Arrangements (In millions of SDR):
  - ECF 12/13/99–3/19/02 Amount Approved 329.10 Amount Drawn 0.00
  - ECF 7/17/96–7/16/99 Amount Approved 309.40 Amount Drawn .154.70
  - Stand-By 6/05/95–6/04/96 Amount Approved 185.60 Amount Drawn 185.60
- Projected Payments to Fund:
  - None
- Safeguards Assessments:
  - Not applicable to the National Bank of Kazakhstan (NBK) at this time.

### Article IV Consultation and FSAP participation
- Article IV Consultation cycle:
  - Kazakhstan is on the standard 12-month consultation cycle. The last consultation was concluded on June 18, 2012 (IMF Country Report No. 12/164).
- FSAP:
  - Participated in FSAP in 2000; FSSA issued on November 27, 2000 (FO/DIS/00/142).
  - FSAP Update missions: February 2004; March 2008.
  - ROSC modules and data ROSC updates described; fiscal transparency module completed October 2002; data ROSC report published March 2003 and updated February 2008.
- AML/CFT assessment:
  - Evaluated by the Eurasian Group; final mutual evaluation report adopted in June 2011.
  - Main sources of criminal proceeds: crimes related to fraud and abuse of public office.
  - Deficiencies noted: customer due diligence measures and the reporting of suspicious transactions.

### Technical assistance and advisory engagement (high-level timeline and areas)
- Total IMF technical assistance and training: about 90 technical assistance missions during 1993–2013 across FAD, LEG, MCM, STA, and the IMF Institute; resident advisors provided to NBK, Agency of Statistics, Ministry of Finance, peripatetic expert to Financial Supervision Agency.
- Monetary and Capital Markets Department assistance highlights:
  - September 2004: Bringing banking prudential regulation up to EU standards.
  - September 2004: Implementing inflation targeting: next steps.
  - November 2007: Strengthening banking supervision and risk assessment.
  - 2009–12: Developing banking sector stress testing; initial mission January 2009 and follow-ups.
  - November 2010: Reducing nonperforming loans in the banking system (joint with LEG).
  - February 2013-2014: Resolving banking system problem assets. Posting of a long-term expert (one year) to the Fund for Problem Loans, financed by the Japanese government (JSA).
- Fiscal Affairs Department assistance highlights:
  - April 2003: Customs administration
  - September 2004: Treasury reform process
  - 2011-2013: Regular technical assistance provided by IMF regional advisor on Public Financial Management.
- Statistics assistance highlights:
  - January 2006: Real sector and balance of payments statistics.
  - August 2006: Real sector statistics.
  - December 2006: ROSC Update mission (and DQAF).
  - April 2008: GFSM 2001 implementation.
  - January 2009: Monetary statistics.
  - April 2011: BOP statistics.
- Legal Department assistance highlights:
  - April 2008: Reforms to tax law
  - April 2010: Anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism (jointly with the World Bank and UNODC).
  - November 2010: Reducing nonperforming loans in the banking system (joint with MCM).

*Source: _cr13290 - Annex I. Kazakhstan: Risk Assessment Matrix (IMF staff report excerpts).*

### 4.      July 2011: Bankruptcy legislation

### 4.      July 2011: Bankruptcy legislation

### IMF capacity building and presence
- IMF Institute:
  - Kazakhstani officials have participated in courses in Washington and at the Vienna Institute in the areas of macroeconomic management, expenditure control, financial programming, taxation, statistics, and others.
  - The IMF Institute has conducted courses in the region.
  - Seminars and training sessions have also been conducted by MCM and STA technical assistance missions.
- Resident Representative:
  - The position was terminated in August 2003, but the Fund maintains a local office in Almaty.

### Relations with the World Bank (IBRD/IDA/IFC)
- Membership and role:
  - Kazakhstan became a member of the IBRD and IDA in July 1992 and a member of the IFC in September 1993.
  - In 2010 Kazakhstan became an IDA donor under the IDA16 replenishment.
  - Kazakhstan is the largest client of the IFC in Central Asia.
- IBRD lending program (as of June 2013):
  - Eleven active projects with a total commitment of $3.55 billion, of which $1.28 billion has been disbursed.
  - 90 percent of the commitments are concentrated in the on-going South-West roads project and the new East-West roads project (became effective on June 14, 2013).
  - Two-thirds of the projects focused on institutional building.
  - Nine other active projects include: forest protection and reforestation; technology commercialization; customs development; tax administration reform; health sector technology transfer and institutional reform; technical and vocational education modernization; statistical capacity building; Ust-Kamenogorsk environmental remediation; and Alma electricity transmission.
- Joint Economic Research Program (JERP) (FY13):
  - JERP amounted to over $4.5 million.
  - Comprised 24 largely interrelated and programmatic activities focused on: competitiveness agenda (including counter-cyclical macroeconomic policy options, trade integration, transport logistics and investment climate improvement, enterprise modernization, and insolvency regime); public finance management (including introduction of the result oriented budget, improvement of inter-budgetary relations, and internal audit system); and social modernization (including development of the framework for better human capital outcomes, improvement of social safety network, ensuring adequacy of pension income, and bringing the quality education to international standards).
- IFC operations:
  - Role under CPS for FY12-17: support private sector to advance economic diversification and growth, particularly in non-extractive sectors and frontier regions; short-term focus on strengthening financial sector and infrastructure (including PPPs).
  - IFC’s PPP Transaction Advisory team is helping structure the first PPP in the road sector for the Almaty Ring Road.
  - Investment program growth:
    - Grew tenfold between FY05 and FY08 (to $110 million) and nearly doubled again in FY09.
    - In FY10, IFC invested $336 million in five projects in the financial and agribusiness sectors.
    - Post-crisis investment level averaged about $100 million per year in FY11-13.
  - As of June 2013:
    - Total committed portfolio of $385 million, of which $264 million has been disbursed.
    - Investment portfolio mostly concentrated in the financial sector and general manufacturing, with beginning investments in agribusiness and infrastructure.

### Relations with the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD)
- Status and aggregate figures (as of 30 June 2013):
  - EBRD’s total investments in Kazakhstan, including co-financing, stood at €12 billion, with the Bank’s own share totaling €4.8 billion (both figures include approximately €1.3 billion in cumulative Trade Facilitation Program turnover).
  - EBRD’s portfolio in Kazakhstan amounted to €1.9 billion.
  - During 2012, the EBRD signed 18 projects for a total amount of EBRD finance €374 million.
  - During the first half of 2013, the EBRD signed seven operations with a total annual bank investment of €155 million.
- Main operational objectives for 2013:
  - Corporate sector: support investment in manufacturing and agribusiness; promote modernization and diversification; promote best business and environmental practices; energy efficiency.
  - Financial sector: work with authorities and IFIs to strengthen the financial sector; re-engage and expand partner banks; assist with resolving banks’ NPL problem; identify and implement policy reforms to promote de-dollarization, develop local capital markets, and increase availability of sustainable local currency financing.
  - Infrastructure: restructure national railway company and support energy-efficiency program; improve municipal infrastructure; expand into solid waste and district heating; support municipal sector reform and innovative financing in the water segment.
  - Power and energy: support clean energy financing for modern generating facilities; reduce distribution losses via rehabilitation of power lines; develop pilot renewable energy projects with private operators (subject to bankability and integrity).
- EBRD portfolio breakdown (as of May 1, 2012) — millions of euros:
  - Energy, Private: 257 (Commitments) / 182 (Portfolio)
  - Energy, State: 361 / 264
  - Financial Institutions, Private: 2,098* / 304
  - Financial Institutions, State: 0 / 0
  - Industry, Commerce, and Agribusiness, Private: 895 / 439
  - Industry, Commerce, and Agribusiness, State: 46 / 0
  - Infrastructure, Private: 78 / 77
  - Infrastructure, State: 853 / 604
  - TOTAL: € 4.8 billion (Commitments) and €1.9 billion (Portfolio)
  - Note: * Including € 1.3 billion in cumulative Trade Facilitation Program lines

### Relations with the Asian Development Bank (ADB)
- Membership and historical focus:
  - Kazakhstan became a member of ADB in 1994.
  - Early ADB focus: sustain higher growth, promote environmentally friendly development, support private sector, encourage regional integration.
- Cumulative commitments (as of 1 July, 2013):
  - Cumulative public sector loan commitments: $2.68 billion, of which about $1.7 billion has been disbursed.
  - Commitments cover 24 public sector loan operations in agriculture and natural resources, education, finance, transport and communications, water supply and sanitation, irrigation, and SMEs.
  - Complemented with 67 TA projects amounting to about $30.5 million.
  - Kazakhstan is no longer eligible for concessional resources from ADB’s Asian Development Fund and became a donor with a $5.2 million contribution in 2012.
- CPS for 2012–2016:
  - Aims to support economic diversification and increased competitiveness; support regional cooperation, private sector development, inclusive growth, and knowledge solutions.
  - KEEP (Knowledge and Experience Exchange Program) established in 2013 commits to a 50% cost-sharing arrangement with total financing of $2.5 million during 2013–2015.
- Ongoing and planned operations:
  - Road transportation, SMEs, urban infrastructure, and energy efficiency.
  - Two MFFs totaling $1.5 billion to improve road networks in Zhambyl and Mangystau along CAREC Transport Corridors 1 and 2.
  - $300 million Astana Light Rail Transport (phase 1) project being prepared for 2013 approval.
  - $500 million MFF for SME Investment Program approved in 2010; Tranche 1 of $150 million provided to DAMU Entrepreneurship Development Fund and fully disbursed in April 2013; tranche 2 discussed for 2013.
  - 2012: $1 million TA for Karaganda District Heating Network Rehabilitation approved.
  - Other TA: preparation of CAREC road projects in 2009 ($825,000); capacity development to support SME development approved in 2010 ($650,000); preparation of Astana LRT project ($565,000) approved in 2011.
- Private sector operations:
  - Began in 2006; private sector financing to six entities in financial and agribusiness sectors amounting to $415.2 million approved to-date.
  - Near-term prospects: private infrastructure and energy sectors.
- Regional engagement:
  - Kazakhstan was one of 4 founding partners of CAREC in 1997.
  - CAREC-related investments in partner countries totaled $21 billion over 2001–12.
  - Four of six CAREC corridors traverse Kazakhstan.
  - Kazakhstan to host CAREC 12th Ministerial Conference in Astana in October 2013.
  - Kazakhstan to host the ADB Annual Meeting of the Board of Governors in May 2014; over 3,000 participants expected.

### Statistical issues and data adequacy (as of July 1, 2013)
- General assessment:
  - Data provision has some shortcomings, but is broadly adequate for surveillance.
  - Most affected areas: monetary and balance of payments statistics, with remaining deficiencies in coverage of fiscal statistics and national accounts.
- National accounts:
  - Quality of GDP statistics affected by limited coverage of small businesses in selected activities such as retail and construction.
  - Progress made in compiling and reporting GDP by final expenditure consistent with output-based measures.
  - Dissemination of quarterly GDP series is irregular.
- Government finance statistics:
  - Progress in classification consistent with GFSM 2001.
  - Statistics on the enlarged government (including public enterprises) is not available.
- Monetary statistics:
  - SRF-based monetary statistics compiled by the central bank have a few inconsistencies.
- Balance of payments:
  - Authorities transitioning to BPM6 compilation.
  - Deficiencies remain in FDI statistics because local branch offices of foreign companies operating in construction are considered nonresident entities, leading to discrepancies with national accounts where activity is treated as domestic production.
  - External debt statistics show discrepancies between data compiled by different governmental agencies owing to methodological differences.
  - Statistical treatment of trade within the customs union is not accurate, contributing to large and increasing errors and omissions; authorities are cooperating with customs union partners to resolve these problems.
- Data Standards and Quality:
  - Participant in the Special Data Dissemination System (SDDS) since March 2003.
  - Data ROSC published in 2008.
- Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (as of June 28, 2012) — sample dated observations and frequencies (preserved exactly as in source):
  - Exchange Rates: Date of latest observation 06/25/13; Date received 06/25/13; Frequency of Data D; Frequency of Reporting D; Frequency of publication M.
  - International Reserve Assets and Reserve Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities: 05/31/13; 06/07/13; M; M; M.
  - Reserve/Base Money: 05/31/13; 06/27/13; M; M; M; Quality: O, O, LO, LO (Methodological Soundness) and O, O, O, O, O (Accuracy and Reliability).
  - Broad Money: 05/31/13; 06/27/13; M; M; M.
  - Central Bank Balance Sheet: 05/31/13; 06/27/13; M; M; M.
  - Consolidated Balance Sheet of the Banking System: 05/31/13; 06/25/13; M; I; I.
  - Interest Rates: 05/31/13; 06/28/13; I; I; I.
  - Consumer Price Index: 05/31/13; 06/03/13; M; M; M; Quality: O, O, O, O (Methodological Soundness) and O, O, LO, O, O (Accuracy and Reliability).
  - Revenue, Expenditure, Balance, and Composition of Financing — General Government: 04/30/13; 06/06/13; M; M; M; Quality: O, LO, LO, LO and O, O, O, O, LNO.
  - Revenue, Expenditure, Balance, and Composition of Financing — Central Government: 04/30/13; 06/06/13; M; M; M.
  - Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt: Q1/2013; 05/06/13; Q; Q; Q.
  - External Current Account Balance: Q1/2013; 04/30/13; Q; Q; Q; Quality: LO, O, O, O (Methodological Soundness) and O, O, O, O ,O (Accuracy and Reliability).
  - Exports and Imports of Goods and Services: Q1/2013; 04/30/13; Q; Q; Q.
  - GDP/GNP: Q1/2013; 04/30/13; Q; Q; Q; Quality: O, O, O, LO and LO, O, LO, O, O.
  - Gross External Debt: Q1/2013; 04/30/13; Q; Q; Q.
  - International Investment Position: Q1/2013; 04/30/13; Q; Q; Q.

### IMF Executive Board — Article IV consultation (Press Release No. 13/308, August 14, 2013)
- On August 2, 2013, the IMF Executive Board concluded the Article IV consultation with the Republic of Kazakhstan and considered and endorsed the staff appraisal under the lapse of time procedure.
- Macroeconomic conditions:
  - Real GDP growth slowed from 7½ percent in 2011 to 5 percent in 2012.

*IMF staff report content as provided in the source document.*

### 4.6 percent year-on-year during the first quarter of 2013. The strong growth has allowed

### _cr13290 - 4.6 percent year-on-year during the first quarter of 2013. The strong growth has allowed

### Real activity and labor market
- Real GDP growth: 4.6 percent year-on-year during the first quarter of 2013.
- Employment: expanded at about 2½ percent annually over the last three years.
- Recent official projections: Real GDP 2013: 5¼ percent; 2014: 5.3 (from tabulated projections).

### Inflation and monetary policy
- Headline inflation: fallen to just below the 6-8 percent target range.
- Core inflation: remained stable at around 5-5½ percent.
- Central bank policy rate: following a cumulative 200-basis points cut early in 2012, the refinancing rate has been on hold at 5½ percent since August 2012.
- NBK actions and guidance from Directors:
  - Welcome enhanced regulation of banking system liquidity.
  - Urged introduction of a new policy interest rate that signals better the stance of policy.
  - Recommended more open and clear communication on transition plans to active open market operations (OMOs) and factors guiding interest rate decisions.
  - Encouraged collaboration between the NBK and the Ministry of Finance to increase financial institutions’ participation in the market for government paper to support active OMOs.
  - Noted scope to re-evaluate the role of the exchange rate with a view to allowing for greater flexibility over the medium term.

### Financial sector and non-bank reforms
- Banking sector performance:
  - Banks’ profits improved over the past year but remain weak.
  - Return on assets ratio for the largest banks (excluding BTA and Alliance banks) reached just 1 percent last year.
  - System capital adequacy ratio increased from 17 percent to 18 percent in 2012 following external debt restructuring and state-funded recapitalization of BTA.
  - Private sector credit growth: moderate overall; consumer lending expanding rapidly (from a low base), concentrated in small- and medium-sized banks.
  - Nonperforming loans (NPLs): large stock; efforts to resolve ongoing but with limited impact so far.
- Supervisory and resolution recommendations from Directors:
  - Greater determination needed to resolve the NPL problem.
  - Consider redesigning the Problem Loans Fund and strictly enforce new ceilings on NPLs to achieve full compliance.
  - Ensure risk management and lending practices are sufficiently robust to avoid exacerbating the NPL problem.
  - Strengthen supervision and macroprudential tools: shore up on-site supervision, enhance liquidity and credit risk assessments, and step up the Early Warning System.
  - Planned exit from troubled banks should be market-based and transparent to bolster system-wide stability and avoid new risks.
- Non-bank sector changes:
  - Kazakhstan’s 11 pension funds with total assets of US$21.2 billion (11 percent of GDP) are being unified under partial management of the central bank following a Presidential decree early in 2013.
  - Directors cautioned that unification must avoid exacerbating fiscal risks and undermining earlier reform efforts; recommended a clear and sound market-based investment strategy while ensuring individual accounts are maintained.

### Fiscal position and public finances
- Fiscal shift in 2012:
  - Fiscal position worsened somewhat in 2012 mainly due to weaker oil sector performance and tax exemptions for new oil projects.
  - Expenditures rose by 0.8 percent of GDP.
  - Non-oil deficit: deteriorated slightly from 8.8 to 9.0 percent of GDP, compared to estimated medium-term sustainable level of 6 percent of GDP.
- Early 2013: revenue performance relatively weak; expenditures subdued.
- Authorities’ medium-term plans: large investment projects in the broader public sector to boost development and diversification.
- Directors’ fiscal policy guidance:
  - Lowering the non-oil deficit over the medium term is a key priority; requires a credible fiscal consolidation strategy.
  - Consolidation plans in the medium-term fiscal framework need to be consistent with announced (but non-budgeted) large scale public spending plans.
  - Assumptions underlying expenditure and revenue projections must align with a macroeconomic framework reflecting effects of envisioned fiscal measures.
  - Revamp medium-term fiscal framework to improve coverage and transparency.
  - Fully integrate the National Fund of the Republic of Kazakhstan (NFRK) with fiscal accounts and use consolidated budget balances to guide fiscal policy.
  - Improve transparency of quasi-fiscal operations, including those related to development and diversification programs.
  - Monitor more closely the external debt of the broader public sector.

### Growth outlook and risks
- 2013 growth expectation: GDP expected to grow at 5¼ percent, only moderately above 2012, reflecting recovery in oil and agricultural output.
- Medium-term growth driver: full scale production in the Kashagan oil field projected to commence in 2015 will strengthen overall growth.
- Main downside risks:
  - Potential slowdown in the global economy, particularly in Russia and China.
  - Lower oil prices than currently projected.

### Structural reform priorities
- Reduce economy’s dependence on oil through:
  - Bolstering human capital, the business environment, and institutions.
  - Ensuring critical public investment aligns with absorptive capacity and high standards of efficiency and oversight.
- Public investment and diversification programs should be subject to improved oversight and transparency to avoid hidden fiscal or quasi-fiscal risks.

### Selected economic indicators (as presented)
- Real economy (Changes in percent):
  - Real GDP: 2010: 7.3; 2011: 7.5; 2012: 5.0; 2013 (Proj.): 5.2; 2014 (Proj.): 5.3
  - CPI (end-of-period): 2010: 7.8; 2011: 7.4; 2012: 6.0; 2013 (Proj.): 6.0; 2014 (Proj.): 6.2
- Public finance (In percent of GDP):
  - Government revenue and grants: 2010: 23.9; 2011: 27.7; 2012: 27.0; 2013 (Proj.): 25.6; 2014 (Proj.): 24.3
  - Government expenditures (and net lending): 2010: 22.5; 2011: 21.8; 2012: 22.5; 2013 (Proj.): 21.1; 2014 (Proj.): 20.6
  - General government balance 2/: 2010: 1.4; 2011: 5.9; 2012: 4.5; 2013 (Proj.): 4.5; 2014 (Proj.): 3.7
  - General government non-oil balance: 2010: -10.3; 2011: -8.8; 2012: -9.0; 2013 (Proj.): -8.6; 2014 (Proj.): -7.8
  - General government debt (end-of-period) 3/: 2010: 10.7; 2011: 10.4; 2012: 12.4; 2013 (Proj.): 13.4; 2014 (Proj.): 13.8
- Money and credit (Changes in percent) 4/:
  - Base money: 2010: 5.0; 2011: 10.3; 2012: 1.9; 2013 (Proj.): 17.9; 2014 (Proj.): 15.8
  - Broad money: 2010: 13.3; 2011: 15.0; 2012: 7.9; 2013 (Proj.): 10.8; 2014 (Proj.): 13.8
  - Credit to the economy 5/: 2010: 5.8; 2011: 15.2; 2012: 11.3; 2013 (Proj.): 19.5; 2014 (Proj.): 12.4
  - NBK refinance rate (end-of-period; percent): 2010: 7.0; 2011: 7.5; 2012: 5.5
- Balance of payments (In percent of GDP) 6/:
  - Trade balance: 2010: 19.3; 2011: 24.9; 2012: 21.3; 2013 (Proj.): 18.8; 2014 (Proj.): 15.7
  - Current account balance: 2010: 0.9; 2011: 6.5; 2012: 3.1; 2013 (Proj.): 1.9
  - External debt: 2010: 79.9; 2011: 66.7; 2012: 67.7; 2013 (Proj.): 66.0; 2014 (Proj.): 62.8
  - Excluding intra-company loans: 2010: 44.5; 2011: 34.5; 2012: 34.9; 2013 (Proj.): 31.8; 2014 (Proj.): 28.4
  - Gross international reserves (In billions of U.S. dollars, end of period): 2010: 28.3; 2011: 29.3; 2012: 28.3; 2013 (Proj.): 34.4; 2014 (Proj.): 41.0
  - Reserves in months of next year’s imports of goods and nonfactor services: 2010: 6.6; 2011: 5.7; 2012: 5.3; 2013 (Proj.): 6.1; 2014 (Proj.): 6.9
- Exchange rate (Changes in percent) 7/:
  - Tenge vs. U.S. dollar (end of period): 2010: -0.7; 2011: 0.4; 2012: 1.5
  - Real effective exchange rate (p.a) 8/: 2010: 1.5; 2011: 0.3; 2012: 3.6

*International Monetary Fund staff report (2013 Article IV consultation with Kazakhstan).*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2013/_cr13290.pdf_
