## _cr1404 - 4.6 percent in 2014. Inflation has been declining, following a good harvest, and should stay

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr1404 - 4.6 percent in 2014. Inflation has been declining, following a good harvest, and should stay](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr1404.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr1404.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr1404.pdf.json)

---

### Recent developments and outlook
- Political context
  - Cabinet reshuffled in early September to reinvigorate reform implementation and prepare local elections scheduled for the spring of 2014.
- Growth and inflation
  - GDP growth on track to reach 4 percent in 2013, up from 3.5 percent in 2012.
  - Growth expected to increase to 4.6 percent in 2014 because of a somewhat more favorable external environment and completion of large mining and infrastructure projects.
  - Consumer price inflation below 1 percent in 2013 owing to good harvests; inflation expected to remain moderate and below 2 percent in 2014.
- External sector and monetary conditions
  - External current account deficit expected to decline to 9.4 percent of GDP after a large increase in 2012, reflecting mainly an improvement in the terms of trade, lower food imports, and higher remittances.
  - Broad money growth in line with nominal GDP.
  - Credit to the private sector decelerated significantly in 2013, likely reflecting financial difficulties in the hydrocarbon sector.
- Risks
  - Main domestic risks: revenue shortfalls, insufficient reform momentum, opposition from vested interests, and electoral-timing effects.
  - Main external risk: possible further increase in the cost of international borrowing related to the unwinding of unconventional monetary policies and uncertainty in large advanced economies.

### Program performance
- Overall assessment
  - All quantitative program targets for mid-2013 were met, including the budget deficit target.
  - Structural reform implementation slowed significantly during the summer; most structural benchmarks were not met by their respective deadlines.
  - Critical reforms not covered by benchmarks experienced limited progress (notably in the energy sector and SAR refinery strategy postponement).
- Selected structural benchmarks (status and reasons)
  - Roll out on-line filing and on-line payment of taxes by large enterprises: deadline June 30, 2013 — Implemented in November 2013 for taxes on imports; implementation expected in December 2013 for other taxes. Delay reasons: e-payment required more coordination with banks; accidental death of a resident expert.
  - Produce a plan for restructuring all agencies and comparable entities: deadline July 31, 2013 — Implemented in November 2013. Delay reason: longer time to prepare a fully-owned strategy; coordination issues.
  - Use cost-benefit assessment for investment exceeding CFAF 10 billion to be included in the budget for 2014: deadline July 31, 2013 — Not met. Reason: No such new projects included in the 2014 budget; capacity to do cost-benefit analysis has been built up.
  - Roll out the new payroll management software: deadline August 31, 2013 — Not met. Delay: delivery delayed because of payment issues with the supplier; coordination issues.
  - Submit new Customs Code to Parliament: deadline September 30, 2013 — Implemented in November 2013. Delay: private sector requested more time for consultation.

### Fiscal outlook and policy recommendations
- Deficit targets and strategy
  - 2013 deficit target of 5.4 percent of GDP is projected to be met.
  - Deficit projected to decrease to 4.9 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - Authorities intend to lower the deficit to below 4 percent of GDP in 2015.
  - The 2014 deficit target is 0.2 percent of GDP higher than projected at the time of the previous review (at 4.9 percent) to accommodate additional public investment and possible costs from agency restructuring.
- Revenue mobilization and tax policy
  - A revenue shortfall of about 0.5 percent of GDP occurred in the first half of 2013, mostly in the first quarter.
  - Immediate priority: complete major tax reform launched in 2013, including introduction of cash refunds for VAT credits and completion of all implementing regulations.
  - Complementary tax administration reforms: changes to remuneration of tax inspectors, increased staffing to resolve tax arrears, comprehensive audit of VAT credits, and more intensive use of information sources.
  - These measures, together with a few specific tax policy measures, should increase the tax revenue ratio by 0.3 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - An indicative revenue target has been introduced in the program; authorities committed to taking early corrective measures should a shortfall be expected at the time of the 7th review.
- Expenditure measures
  - Substantial current expenditure streamlining in 2014: a decrease in the current expenditure ratio of 0.8 percentage point of GDP.
  - Streamlining will allow higher public investment and development of the social safety net (e.g., Family Security Allowance and progress towards universal health coverage).
  - Areas targeted: government utility bills, wage bill (wage moderation to offset new hiring), transfers (e.g., agriculture), and higher education (improved targeting of scholarships and increased tuitions).
  - Restructuring of public agencies may produce medium-term savings but generate short-term costs (termination of contracts, reallocation of employees).
- Financing
  - Eurobond issuance postponed to 2014 due to sharp tightening of international financial conditions since the last review.
  - Financing of the 2013 deficit secured through a syndicated loan equivalent to CFAF 250 billion arranged by a regional bank: 7-year maturity, 6.5 percent interest (or an effective rate slightly above 7 percent once other costs are factored in). The loan will be mostly denominated in CFA franc (about 60 percent), with the rest in euro.
  - Further financing from the regional market will be needed in 2014.
  - Senegal re-classified as a “higher-capacity” country under the IMF’s debt limits policy; design of debt limits in the program to be reconsidered at the next review based on an updated debt sustainability analysis and the new discount rate.

### Reforming the State and public financial management
- Objectives and scope
  - Reform aims to rationalize the proliferation of public agencies to improve transparency of public spending, expenditure control, fiscal management, and efficiency of public spending.
  - Study surveyed more than 50 agencies managing about CFAF 820 billion (about the size of the entire investment budget).
  - Agencies employ about 3000 staff; average remuneration about twice that in the civil service (and higher for senior managers).
- Measures and timelines
  - Suppression or merging of a number of agencies; better supervision of remaining agencies; stricter rules for creating new agencies with cost-benefit analysis required before any decision.
  - Monitoring capacity being built at the ministry of finance; quarterly financial reports on agencies expected from spring 2014.
  - Authorities committed to developing strategies and performance contracts for the 5 largest agencies by mid-2014.
  - Expand use of cost-benefit analysis to about one third of investment expenditures included in the 2015 budget.
  - Share cost-benefit analyses for the five largest investment projects with the national assembly (new structural benchmark).
  - Control over the wage bill expected to improve with roll out of new payroll software, new database from physical audit of civil service, and Fund technical assistance.
- Public financial management improvements
  - Single treasury account to be operational by end-2013 (after delays) to improve liquidity management.
  - Move progressively to more transparent fiscal accounts with less frequent netting out of certain expenditure items from revenue.
  - Interface between SIGFIP and ASTER for monthly reconciliation to be completed no later than end-June 2014.

### Energy sector: fiscal impact, progress, and recommendations
- Fiscal impact and pricing
  - Implicit and explicit electricity subsidies exceeded 2.5 percent of GDP in 2012 (about CFAF 180 billion).
  - Electricity prices are about 40 percent below production costs.
  - Retail electricity prices remain among the highest in sub-Saharan Africa at about US$0.25 per kWh (or twice the level in the U.S.).
  - Explicit subsidy budgeted at CFAF 80 billion for 2013.
  - Explicit subsidy budgeted at CFAF 60 billion for 2014.
  - Most projects to introduce more cost-effective production technologies will take a few years to come on stream and therefore will not durably reduce electricity subsidies in the absence of tariff adjustment.
- Progress on sector reforms and governance
  - A performance contract for SENELEC was signed in June; SENELEC’s 2012 accounts were certified in November 2013.
  - Limited progress in implementing the investment plan; authorities agreed implementation needed to accelerate but defended an ambitious capacity-increase plan.
  - Authorities agreed to publish periodic reports to communicate better with stakeholders on sector condition, reform strategy, and implementation.
- Authorities’ reform strategy and complementary measures
  - Strategy elements: improve efficiency of SENELEC; introduce more cost-effective production technologies (e.g., coal-based plants built and operated by private operators).
  - Complementary reforms: updated action plan on improved access to credit for households and small businesses to be completed by end-2014; three-year program to improve business environment; new legal framework for public-private partnerships expected soon.
- Staff recommendations on energy
  - Adopt a realistic timeline for implementation of the investment plan and focus efforts on a few large projects that are most critical.
  - Improve communication with all stakeholders on the sector’s situation, the reform strategy, and its implementation.
  - Staff stresses the need to communicate the true fiscal cost of supporting the electricity sector, not only the explicit budgeted subsidy.

### Social protection, health coverage, and expenditure priorities
- Social programs and targets
  - Family Security Allowance (Bourse de Sécurité Familiale—BSF): pilot payment of CFAF 25,000 per quarter to 50,000 targeted households by end-2013; expansion to reach 250,000 households at end-2017.
  - Universal health coverage objective: provide health risk coverage for more than 65.5 percent of the population by 2017.
- Fiscal contingency planning
  - Projections for 2014 are more conservative; if revenue shortfalls occur, additional revenue measures should be implemented no later than mid-2014 and discussed with IMF staff during the seventh program review.
- Expenditure rationalization measures (selected)
  - Expected savings of CFAF 11 billion in 2014 on telephone bills alone.
  - Expected estimated savings of CFAF 6.4 billion in agriculture through better targeting of subsidies.
  - Wage bill control measures subject to macro framework; finalization of civil service audit to eliminate ghost workers.

### Program monitoring, quantitative targets, and financing parameters
- Staff recommendation
  - Staff recommends completion of the sixth PSI review and modification of the end-2013 assessment criterion on semi-concessional debt.
- Macroeconomic projections (selected indicators)
  - GDP at constant prices (annual percent change) series for 2011–18: 2.1, 3.5, 4.0, 4.0, 4.6, 4.8, 5.1, 5.1, 5.1.
  - Consumer prices (annual average) series: 3.4, 1.4, 1.5, 0.8, 1.4, 1.7, 1.7, 1.9, 1.9.
  - Current account balance (official transfers included, percent of GDP) series: -7.9, -10.3, -9.3, -9.4, -8.9, -7.9, -7.6, -7.2, -6.9.
  - Gross official reserves (imputed, US$ billions) series: 2.0, 2.1, 2.1, 2.2, 2.3, 2.5, 2.6, 2.7, 2.9.
- Fiscal and debt indicators (selected)
  - Revenue (percent of GDP) series: 20.2, 20.4, 20.7, 20.9, 20.8, 21.0, 21.2, 21.3, 21.3.
  - Overall fiscal balance, payment order basis, including grants (percent of GDP) series: -6.7, -5.9, -5.3, -5.4, -4.9, -3.9, -3.7, -3.5, -3.2.
  - Total public debt (percent of GDP) series: 40.5, 43.4, 45.4, 45.9, 47.4, 48.1, 48.4, 48.5, 48.3.
  - Financing (percent of GDP) series: 6.7, 5.9, 5.3, 5.4, 4.9, 3.9, 3.7, 3.5, 3.2.
- Debt and borrowing parameters
  - Ceiling on contracting or guaranteeing new nonconcessional external debt by the government: US$800 million over 2011–14 (series and application as set out in TMU).
  - Proposal to raise ceiling on external borrowing with grant element between 15 and 35 percent from CFAF 67 billion to CFAF 132 billion to facilitate financing of high-return investment projects.
  - Discount rate for future concessionality calculations to be set at 5 percent (per the Executive Board’s recent decision).

### Program transparency, reporting, and TMU requirements
- Public disclosure commitments (monthly)
  - Publish preliminary TOFE and transition tables with delay of 2 months; SIGFIP execution table with delay of 2 weeks; airport tax amounts with delay of 1 month.
  - Provide full information on FSE operations, power sector investment projects and financing, and balance of the Eurobond escrow account within specified short delays.
- TMU reporting requirements (selected)
  - Monthly provisional data on overall fiscal balance to Fund staff with lag no more than 30 days; final data no later than two months after provisional reporting (Treasury account basis).
  - Weekly and monthly SIGFIP tables to monitor budgetary float and payment processes.
  - Immediate reporting (within 3 days) of any decision or law with economic or financial implications.
  - Central bank reporting: monthly balance sheet (lag one month); consolidated monthly balance sheet of banks (lag two months); monetary survey monthly (lag two months); prudential indicators quarterly (lag two months).

### Implementation milestones and new structural benchmarks (selected)
- Reprogrammed new deadlines and benchmarks for 7th and 8th reviews:
  - Start using the new payroll management software by January 1, 2014 — 7th review.
  - Roll out e-filing and e-payment of taxes for all taxpayers in the Dakar area by January 1, 2014 — 7th review.
  - Transmission to parliament of a draft law on assets disclosure by January 1, 2014 (done in November 2013) — 7th review.
  - Publication and coverage of SENELEC performance contract monitoring and sector audit: first publication by March 31, 2014 — 7th review.
  - Approve strategies for the 5 largest agencies and related performance contracts by June 30, 2014 — 8th review.
  - Share cost-benefits analyses of 5 largest investment projects in the 2015 budget with the National Assembly by October 15, 2014 — 8th review.

*International Monetary Fund — Excerpt from Senegal staff report and MEFP (December 5, 2013).*

### 4.6 percent in 2014. Inflation has been declining, following a good harvest, and should stay

### _cr1404 - 4.6 percent in 2014. Inflation has been declining, following a good harvest, and should stay

### Recent developments and outlook
- Political context
  - Cabinet reshuffled in early September to reinvigorate reform implementation and prepare local elections scheduled for the spring of 2014.
- Growth and inflation
  - GDP growth on track to reach 4 percent in 2013, up from 3.5 percent in 2012.
  - Growth expected to increase to 4.6 percent in 2014 because of a somewhat more favorable external environment and completion of large mining and infrastructure projects.
  - Consumer price inflation below 1 percent in 2013 owing to good harvests; inflation expected to remain moderate and below 2 percent in 2014.
- External sector and monetary conditions
  - External current account deficit expected to decline to 9.4 percent of GDP after a large increase in 2012, reflecting mainly an improvement in the terms of trade, lower food imports, and higher remittances.
  - Broad money growth in line with nominal GDP.
  - Credit to the private sector decelerated significantly in 2013, likely reflecting financial difficulties in the hydrocarbon sector.
- Risks
  - Main risks are domestic: revenue shortfalls, insufficient reform momentum, opposition from vested interests, and electoral-timing effects.
  - Main external risk: possible further increase in the cost of international borrowing related to the unwinding of unconventional monetary policies and uncertainty in large advanced economies.

### Program performance
- Overall
  - All quantitative program targets for mid-2013 were met, including the budget deficit target.
  - Structural reform implementation slowed significantly during the summer; most structural benchmarks were not met by their respective deadlines.
  - Critical reforms not covered by benchmarks experienced limited progress (notably in the energy sector and SAR refinery strategy postponement).
- Structural benchmarks (selected status and reasons)
  - Roll out on-line filing and on-line payment of taxes by large enterprises: deadline June 30, 2013 — Implemented in November 2013 for taxes on imports; implementation expected in December 2013 for other taxes. Delay: e-payment required more coordination with banks; accidental death of a resident expert.
  - Produce a plan for restructuring all agencies and comparable entities: deadline July 31, 2013 — Implemented in November 2013. Delay: longer time to prepare a fully-owned strategy; coordination issues.
  - Use cost-benefit assessment for investment exceeding CFAF 10 billion to be included in the budget for 2014: deadline July 31, 2013 — Not met. Reason: No such new projects included in the 2014 budget; capacity to do cost-benefit analysis has been built up.
  - Roll out the new payroll management software: deadline August 31, 2013 — Not met. Delay: delivery delayed because of payment issues with the supplier; coordination issues.
  - Submit new Customs Code to Parliament: deadline September 30, 2013 — Implemented in November 2013. Delay: private sector requested more time for consultation.

### Fiscal outlook and policy recommendations
- Deficit targets and strategy
  - 2013 deficit target of 5.4 percent of GDP is projected to be met.
  - Deficit projected to decrease to 4.9 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - Authorities intend to lower the deficit to below 4 percent of GDP in 2015.
  - The 2014 deficit target is 0.2 percent of GDP higher than projected at the time of the previous review (at 4.9 percent) to accommodate additional public investment and possible costs from agency restructuring.
- Revenue mobilization and tax policy
  - A revenue shortfall of about 0.5 percent of GDP occurred in the first half of 2013, mostly in the first quarter.
  - Immediate priority: complete major tax reform launched in 2013, including introduction of cash refunds for VAT credits and completion of all implementing regulations.
  - Complementary tax administration reforms: changes to remuneration of tax inspectors, increased staffing to resolve tax arrears, comprehensive audit of VAT credits, and more intensive use of information sources.
  - These measures, together with a few specific tax policy measures, should increase the tax revenue ratio by 0.3 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - An indicative revenue target has been introduced in the program; authorities committed to taking early corrective measures should a shortfall be expected at the time of the 7th review.
- Expenditure measures
  - Substantial current expenditure streamlining in 2014: a decrease in the current expenditure ratio of 0.8 percentage point of GDP.
  - Streamlining will allow higher public investment and development of the social safety net (e.g., Family Security Allowance and progress towards universal health coverage).
  - Areas targeted: government utility bills, wage bill (wage moderation to offset new hiring), transfers (e.g., agriculture), and higher education (improved targeting of scholarships and increased tuitions).
  - Restructuring of public agencies may produce medium-term savings but generate short-term costs (termination of contracts, reallocation of employees).
- Financing
  - Eurobond issuance postponed to 2014 due to sharp tightening of international financial conditions since the last review.
  - Financing of the 2013 deficit secured through a syndicated loan equivalent to CFAF 250 billion arranged by a regional bank: 7-year maturity, 6.5 percent interest (or an effective rate slightly above 7 percent once other costs are factored in). The loan will be mostly denominated in CFA franc (about 60 percent), with the rest in euro.
  - Further financing from the regional market will be needed in 2014.
  - Senegal re-classified as a “higher-capacity” country under the IMF’s debt limits policy; design of debt limits in the program to be reconsidered at the next review based on an updated debt sustainability analysis and the new discount rate.

### Reforming the State
- Objectives and scope
  - Reform aims to rationalize the proliferation of public agencies to improve transparency of public spending, expenditure control, fiscal management, and efficiency of public spending.
  - Study surveyed more than 50 agencies managing about CFAF 820 billion (about the size of the entire investment budget).
  - Agencies employ about 3000 staff; average remuneration about twice that in the civil service (and higher for senior managers).
- Measures and timelines
  - Suppression or merging of a number of agencies; better supervision of remaining agencies; stricter rules for creating new agencies with cost-benefit analysis required before any decision.
  - Monitoring capacity being built at the ministry of finance; quarterly financial reports on agencies expected from spring 2014.
  - Authorities committed to developing strategies and performance contracts for the 5 largest agencies by mid-2014.
  - Expand use of cost-benefit analysis to about one third of investment expenditures included in the 2015 budget.
  - Share cost-benefit analyses for the five largest investment projects with the national assembly (new structural benchmark).
  - Control over the wage bill expected to improve with roll out of new payroll software, new database from physical audit of civil service, and Fund technical assistance.
- Public financial management
  - Single treasury account to be operational by end-2013 (after delays) to improve liquidity management.
  - Efforts to improve quality of accounting, budgetary, and financial data; better projection of key items (such as the wage bill) and less optimism in revenue projections.
  - Move progressively to more transparent fiscal accounts with less frequent netting out of certain expenditure items from revenue.

### Energy sector
- Status and risks
  - Slow reforms in the energy sector represent a major obstacle to economic growth and carry substantial fiscal risks.
  - Insufficient progress recorded in implementing the authorities’ strategy to introduce more cost-effective production technologies and improve efficiency of SENELEC.
  - Delays in implementation of large investment projects to boost power production and reduce costs.
- Recommendations
  - Adopt a realistic timeline for implementation of the investment plan and focus efforts on a few large projects that are most critical.
  - Improve communication with all stakeholders on the sector’s situation, the reform strategy, and its implementation.

### Program monitoring and next steps
- Structural benchmarks reprogrammed or added for 7th and 8th PSI reviews include:
  - Start using the new payroll management software by January 1, 2014 (reprogrammed from August 31, 2013) — 7th review — Strengthen public financial management.
  - Roll out e-filing and e-payment of taxes for all taxpayers in the Dakar area by January 1, 2014 — 7th review — Improve efficiency of public policy and the business climate.
  - Transmission to parliament of a draft law on assets disclosure by January 1, 2014 (done in November 2013) — 7th review — Increase transparency of public finances.
  - Perform cost-benefits analysis before the creation of new agencies — Continuous — Improve the quality of public expenditure.
  - Publication and coverage of SENELEC performance contract monitoring and sector audit: first publication by March 31, 2014 — 7th review — Promote private sector development.
  - Approve strategies for the 5 largest agencies and related performance contracts by June 30, 2014 — 8th review — Improve the quality of public expenditure.
  - Share cost-benefits analyses of 5 largest investment projects in the 2015 budget with the National Assembly by October 15, 2014 — 8th review — Improve the quality of public expenditure.

- IMF staff recommendation
  - Staff recommends completion of the sixth PSI review.

*Staff recommends completion of the sixth PSI review. December 5, 2013*

### 13.      Reforming the energy sector remains a macroeconomic priority. Beyond

### 13.      Reforming the energy sector remains a macroeconomic priority. Beyond

### Energy sector fiscal impact and pricing
- Implicit and explicit electricity subsidies exceeded 2.5 percent of GDP in 2012 (about CFAF 180 billion).
- Electricity prices are about 40 percent below production costs.
- Retail electricity prices remain among the highest in sub-Saharan Africa at about US$0.25 per kWh (or twice the level in the U.S.).
- Total fiscal support to the sector would decrease somewhat in 2013 and 2014, reflecting mostly a better production mix and, to a lesser extent, efficiency gains at SENELEC and the fight against fraud.
- Total support will remain very large and will substantially exceed the amount budgeted for the explicit subsidy:
  - Explicit subsidy budgeted at CFAF 80 billion for 2013.
  - Explicit subsidy budgeted at CFAF 60 billion for 2014.
- Most projects to introduce more cost-effective production technologies will take a few years to come on stream and therefore will not durably reduce electricity subsidies in the absence of tariff adjustment.
- (MEFP ¶24-26)

### Progress on sector reforms and governance
- A performance contract for SENELEC was signed in June, intended to improve financial and operational management.
- An independent audit of the contract’s implementation was expected in early 2014.
- SENELEC’s 2012 accounts were certified in November 2013, enabling refinement of loss estimates and the design of a restructuring plan.
- Limited progress has been made on implementing the investment plan.
- Authorities agreed implementation needed to accelerate but defended an ambitious capacity-increase plan given the very low efficiency of existing units.
- Authorities agreed to publish periodic reports to communicate better with stakeholders on sector condition, reform strategy, and implementation.
- Staff stressed the need to communicate the true fiscal cost of supporting the electricity sector and cautioned that focusing only on the explicit subsidy in the budget gives a distorted view.

### Authorities’ reform strategy and complementary measures
- Strategy elements:
  - Improve efficiency of SENELEC.
  - Introduce more cost-effective production technologies (e.g., coal-based plants built and operated by private operators).
- Complementary reforms to improve financing and business environment:
  - Updated action plan on improved access to credit for households and small businesses with planned completion by end-2014.
  - Three-year program to improve the business environment, focusing on facilitating business creation, computerization or suppression of procedures for building permits and real estate transactions, and legal protection of investment.
  - New legal framework for public-private partnerships expected soon.

### Program monitoring and related numeric policy parameters
- Proposed change to ceilings on external borrowing with grant element between 15 and 35 percent:
  - Raise ceiling from CFAF 67 billion to CFAF 132 billion to facilitate financing of high-return investment projects (would require modification of the assessment criterion for end-2013).
- Discount rate for future concessionality calculations to be set at 5 percent (per the Executive Board’s recent decision).
- An indicative target on the level of tax revenue would be introduced.
- Quantitative assessment criteria and structural benchmarks for the 7th and 8th PSI reviews are proposed in the authorities’ MEFP.

### Staff appraisal: performance, priorities, and recommendations
- Program performance mixed: all quantitative program targets for mid-2013 were met, but structural reform implementation slowed significantly during the summer and most structural benchmarks were not met by deadlines.
- Staff welcomes authorities’ intention to:
  - Stay the course on reduction of the fiscal deficit.
  - Improve composition and quality of public expenditures.
- Fiscal targets and measures:
  - Maintain the 2013 deficit target of 5.4 percent of GDP despite significant revenue shortfalls.
  - Reduce the deficit by 0.5 percent of GDP in 2014.
  - Revenue mobilization efforts to hinge on tax administration reforms.
  - Substantial current expenditure streamlining expected in 2014 to allow for increased public investment and development of the social safety net.
- Public financial management reforms:
  - Reform of agencies to improve transparency, expenditure control, fiscal management, and efficiency.
  - Need for forceful implementation, better supervision of remaining agencies, stricter rules on creating new agencies, and buildup of monitoring capacity at the ministry of finance.
  - Greater use of cost-benefit analysis for investment selection and better control over the wage bill.
- On the energy sector specifically:
  - Slow reforms represent a major obstacle to growth and carry substantial fiscal risks.
  - Staff supports the authorities’ strategy to introduce cost-effective production technologies and improve SENELEC efficiency.
  - Staff urges adoption of a realistic timeline for the investment plan and a focus on a few large, critical projects.
  - Staff stresses the need to communicate the true fiscal cost of supporting the electricity sector, not only the explicit budgeted subsidy.

*International Monetary Fund — Excerpt from Senegal staff report (MEFP ¶24-29; staff appraisal).*

### 22.      Staff recommends completion of the sixth PSI review and modification of the end-

### 22. Staff recommends completion of the sixth PSI review and modification of the end-2013 assessment criterion on semi-concessional debt

### Recommendation
- Staff recommends completion of the sixth PSI review and modification of the end-2013 assessment criterion on semi-concessional debt.
- Notwithstanding slower than expected progress in reforms since the last review, staff considers that the program’s main objectives remain within reach with the delivery of the authorities’ policy commitments.

### Macroeconomic outlook (selected indicators and projections)
- GDP at constant prices (annual percent change): 2.1, 3.5, 4.0, 4.0, 4.6, 4.8, 5.1, 5.1, 5.1 (series for 2011–18 as shown).
- Nonagriculture GDP (annual percent change): 4.8, 2.6, 3.7, 3.7, 4.3, 4.7, 5.0, 5.0, 5.1.
- GDP deflator (annual percent change): 4.2, 1.7, 2.2, 0.3, 2.2, 2.3, 2.2, 2.3, 2.3.
- Consumer prices (annual average): 3.4, 1.4, 1.5, 0.8, 1.4, 1.7, 1.7, 1.9, 1.9.
- Broad money (annual percent change): 6.7, 6.8, 6.8, 4.9 (series reported).

### External sector (selected levels and projections, CFAF billions unless otherwise indicated)
- Exports, f.o.b. (CFA francs): 15.4, 8.0, 5.6, 8.4, 3.3, 7.5, 8.5, 10.2, 11.0 (series for 2011–18 as shown).
- Imports, f.o.b. (CFA francs): 19.7, 17.5, 0.4, 3.2, 3.8, 4.1, 8.0, 8.5, 9.0.
- Export volume (annual percent change): 10.2, 3.7, 4.1, 7.4, 5.0, 8.0, 6.4, 7.5, 7.7.
- Import volume (annual percent change): 8.9, 13.3, 4.2, 6.5, 6.3, 6.2, 6.3, 6.8, 6.3.
- Current account balance (official transfers included, percent of GDP): -7.9, -10.3, -9.3, -9.4, -8.9, -7.9, -7.6, -7.2, -6.9.
- Gross official reserves (imputed, US$ billions): 2.0, 2.1, 2.1, 2.2, 2.3, 2.5, 2.6, 2.7, 2.9.

### Fiscal outlook and public finances (percent of GDP and CFAF billions)
- Revenue (percent of GDP): 20.2, 20.4, 20.7, 20.9, 20.8, 21.0, 21.2, 21.3, 21.3.
- Grants (percent of GDP): 2.2, 2.9, 2.7, 2.8, 2.8, 2.6, 2.6, 2.5, 2.4.
- Total expenditure and net lending (percent of GDP): 29.1, 29.1, 28.7, 29.1, 28.6, 27.6, 27.5, 27.3, 26.9.
- Overall fiscal balance, payment order basis, excluding grants (percent of GDP): -8.9, -8.7, -8.0, -8.2, -7.7, -6.6, -6.3, -6.0, -5.6.
- Overall fiscal balance, payment order basis, including grants (percent of GDP): -6.7, -5.9, -5.3, -5.4, -4.9, -3.9, -3.7, -3.5, -3.2.
- Primary fiscal balance (percent of GDP): -5.2, -4.4, -3.8, -3.8, -3.3, -2.0, -1.7, -1.5, -1.2.
- Total revenue and grants (CFAF billions): 1,526; 1,670; 1,784; 1,770; 1,891; 2,030; 2,192; 2,360; 2,530 (2011–18 series).
- Total expenditure and net lending (CFAF billions): 1,980; 2,090; 2,190; 2,176; 2,287; 2,366; 2,537; 2,707; 2,870 (2011–18 series).

### Public debt and financing
- Total public debt (percent of GDP): 40.5, 43.4, 45.4, 45.9, 47.4, 48.1, 48.4, 48.5, 48.3.
- Domestic public debt (percent of GDP): 11.3, 12.4, 11.6, 12.0, 12.0, 12.9, 13.9, 14.7, 15.3.
- External public debt (percent of GDP): 29.2, 31.0, 33.9, 33.9, 35.4, 35.2, 34.6, 33.8, 33.0.
- External public debt service:
  - Percent of exports: 13.2, 7.3, 6.9, 7.8, 6.8, 10.2, 10.2, 9.9, 9.4.
  - Percent of government revenue: 17.2, 9.6, 8.7, 10.4, 8.8, 13.0, 12.8, 12.6, 12.2.
- Financing (percent of GDP): 6.7, 5.9, 5.3, 5.4, 4.9, 3.9, 3.7, 3.5, 3.2.

### Monetary and financial sector indicators
- Broad money (CFAF billions): 2,540; 2,711; 2,896; 3,037 (2010–13 series).
- Net foreign assets (annual change, percent of beginning-of-period broad money): 5.8, -2.3, -1.9, 1.2 (2010–13 series).
- Net domestic assets (annual change, percent of beginning-of-period broad money): 8.3, 9.0, 8.7, 3.7 (2010–13 series).
- Credit to the economy (annual percent change): 10.4, 18.8, 9.6, 6.1.
- Financial soundness indicators (selected, percent):
  - Capital to risk-weighted assets: 13.8, 16.3, 18.0, 16.0, 16.7 (2008–12).
  - Ratio of non-performing loans (NPLs) to total loans: 17.4, 18.7, 20.2, 16.2, 18.4 (2008–12).
  - Ratio of provisions for NPLs to total NPLs: 51.5, 53.1, 54.9, 54.0, 56.1 (2008–12).
  - After-tax return on average assets: 1.4, 1.3, 1.6, 2.2, 1.7 (2008–12).

### Structural and competitiveness notes (from figures and indicators)
- Financial system structure (2012): Banks 84.6 percent; Microfinance institutions 7.0 percent; Pension funds 4.4 percent; Non-deposit financial taking institutions 4.0 percent.
- Sectoral distribution of loans (June 2012): Services, transportation and communications 34%; Retail and wholesale trade 19%; Industrial 22%; Other 25%.
- Doing Business indicators and rankings (selected):
  - Overall ranking: 111, 117, 113 (series shown).
  - Getting credit rankings and indexes: Getting credit: 126, 129, 130; Depth of credit information index: 1, 5, 5; Public registry coverage: 4.6, 56.3, 0 (percent of adults series shown).
- Real effective and nominal effective exchange rate: series indicate moderate depreciation since 2008; export performance has not substantially improved (figure commentary).

*Sources: Senegal authorities; and IMF staff estimates and projections.*

### Appendix I. Letter of Intent

### Appendix I. Letter of Intent

### Program request and government commitments
- Request for completion of the sixth review under the Policy Support Instrument (PSI).
- Attached MEFP takes stock of program performance at end-June 2013, defines macroeconomic objectives for the rest of 2013 and for 2014, and updates structural reforms monitored under the program.
- Program implementation characterized as satisfactory; despite significant tax revenue shortfalls, "all quantitative criteria and indicative targets under the program at end-June 2013 were met, including the budget deficit target."
- Government commitment highlights:
  - Continue reduction of the fiscal deficit in 2013 and into 2014 and beyond, improving efficiency of public expenditure and making it more growth friendly.
  - Accelerate pace of reform implementation to raise growth potential and improve living standards.
  - Request to increase ceiling on semiconcessional borrowing (financing having a grant element of 15–35 percent) from CFAF 67 billion to CFAF 132 billion; requires modification of the assessment criterion for end-2013.
  - Government will consult with the IMF before adoption of additional measures or revisions to policies in the MEFP, and will provide information the IMF may request.
- Attachments: Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP) and Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU).

*Amadou Ba, Minister of Economy and Finance — Dakar, December 5, 2013.*

### Recent economic developments and program implementation (summary)
- Economic activity:
  - General economic activity index registered cumulative growth of 3.7 percent for the first seven months of 2013 (proxy for non-agricultural GDP).
  - Tertiary sector growth: +6 percent for the first seven months of 2013.
  - Projected real GDP growth in 2013 maintained at 4.0 percent, compared with 3.5 percent in 2012.
- Inflation:
  - Average prices during the first eight months of 2013 compared with the corresponding period in 2012 amounted to 0.7 percent.
- Trade and money:
  - Slight improvement in the trade deficit in 2013 owing to rapid growth in exports and modest growth in imports.
  - Increase in money supply described as quite moderate.
- Fiscal execution:
  - Substantial revenue shortfalls in first eight months of 2013, largely attributable to nontax revenue, VAT, and individual income tax.
  - Decline in individual income tax greater than expected (giving taxpayers more purchasing power).
  - Decline in VAT revenue partly reflects tax reform eliminating VAT withholding by government agencies on large enterprises.
  - Despite revenue shortfalls, all quantitative criteria and indicative targets under the program at end-June 2013 were met, including the budget deficit target.
- Structural reform progress (selected items):
  - Treasury single account: comprehensive survey and resistance tests completed; impact study completed; autonomous units notified of account streamlining measures.
  - Electronic filing and electronic payment of taxes by large enterprises: ~20 large enterprises have used electronic filing; electronic payment operational for taxes on imports in November 2013 and expected operational for other taxes in December 2013.
  - Use of cost-benefit analysis for large investments in the 2014 budget: no projects exceeding CFAF 10 billion forwarded to the Directorate-General of Planning (DGP); DGP organized two training sessions in July and August 2013.
  - Reorganization plan for agencies: experts’ report completed in July 2013 and validated; government adopted a strategy in November.
  - New payroll management software: software development completed; implementation to begin on January 1, 2014 (delayed due to supplier payment and delivery problems).
  - New customs code: draft validated by the Directorate-General of Customs, sharing seminar organized, joint monitoring committee established; adopted by the Council of Ministers and submitted to parliament in November.
  - Draft law on asset declarations: adopted by the Council of Ministers on July 11, 2013 and submitted to the assembly in November 2013.

### Macroeconomic context and projections for 2013–2014
- External outlook:
  - External environment expected to be more buoyant in 2014.
  - Factors supporting acceleration: modest acceleration in the world economy, improved sociopolitical situation in the subregion, good rainfall in 2013.
- GDP and inflation projections:
  - GDP growth expected to increase to 4.6 percent in 2014, compared with 4 percent in 2013.
  - Inflation expected to remain moderate at approximately 2 percent in 2014.
- Growth drivers in 2014:
  - Investments in agriculture.
  - Infrastructure: extension of the northern road in Dakar; highway from Diamniadio to the Blaise Diagne International Airport (AIBD) and from the AIBD to Mbour; continuation of works at the AIBD.
  - Energy: improved electricity distribution.
  - Mining projects: heavy minerals project in Grande Côte (zirconium) and gold mine projects.
  - Continuation of projects financed by the Millennium Challenge Account (MCA) and execution of projects in the social sectors.
- Balance of payments:
  - Current account deficit expected to remain substantial because of investments in energy and mining.
- Risks:
  - External: sharper-than-expected slowdown in emerging countries; continued toughening of financial conditions on international markets; rise in world interest rates already affecting budget financing costs.
  - Domestic: insufficient fiscal consolidation; delays in implementing reforms to make public expenditure and the energy sector more efficient.

### Fiscal policy and debt objectives
- Fiscal deficit targets and trajectory:
  - Objective to reduce the fiscal deficit for 2013 remains unchanged.
  - Budget deficit will be reduced to 4.9 percent of GDP in 2014 and to less than 4 percent in 2015.
  - Modest downward revision in the deficit target for 2014 reflects a significant effort to increase public investment.
- Means to reduce deficit:
  - Significant effort to increase revenue and rationalize expenditure, with special emphasis on current expenditure.
  - Savings expected in the wage bill, public debt interest payments, and postponement until 2014 of new investment projects financed with domestic resources.
- Revenue-strengthening measures (high level):
  - Strengthened tax control and expanded tax base through intensive use of available information sources.
  - Tax policy measures envisaged (details in Box 1).
  - Plan to discontinue use of tax stabilization measures to support prices for petroleum products.

### Box 1 — Measures to Increase Revenue (as presented)
- Tax policy measures (expected gain of 0.1 percent of GDP):
  - Application of a uniform tax rate of 45 percent on all cigarettes (increase applies only to low-price cigarettes; current rate for those is 40 percent to be increased to 45 percent).
  - Increase in the minimum lump-sum tax limit from CFAF 5 million to CFAF 20 million.
  - Elimination of the VAT exemption for indirect exports, particularly by land.
- Measures to strengthen the tax and customs administration (expected gain of 0.2 percent of GDP):
  - Strengthen Directorate-General of Taxes and Government Property (DGID) staff dedicated to survey, assessment, and supervision by assigning approximately 100 staff (approximately 40 persons from the treasury and contractual staff who have received adequate tax training).
  - Key actions:
    - Definition by end-January 2014 of a strategy to resolve tax arrears based primarily on risk analysis; implementation in 2014 and assessment at end-2014.
    - Comprehensive audit of VAT credits by mid-2014 and application of punitive assessments to cases of fraud identified.
    - More active use of all information sources and the national registration number for enterprises and associations (NINEA).
  - Note: IMF technical assistance reports underscored staff shortages affecting revenue collection; preliminary assessments found widespread fraud in VAT credits on a sample.

### Box 2 — Measures to Rationalize Expenditure (as presented)
- Operating expenditure:
  - Implementation of an expenditure management module shared with concession holders (SENELEC, SDE, and SONATEL) and sectoral ministries.
  - Use and validation of invoice data at central and decentralized levels.
  - Formalization and approval of mobile telephone line attribution; implementation underway.
  - Expected savings of CFAF 11 billion in 2014 on telephone bills alone.
  - Replace staff housing provided to senior civil servants and members of government with a housing allowance to increase transparency and regulation.
- Wage bill:
  - Civil service workforce will increase in 2014 because of hiring measures announced in 2013 (mostly in security forces) and continued granting of tenure to contractual staff in education.
  - Government will take measures on wages only within the bounds of the macroeconomic framework, without affecting capital expenditure.
  - Finalization of the civil service audit to eliminate ghost workers.
- Agencies:
  - Rationalization of agencies expected to lead to substantial long-term savings through greater efficiency and transparency; may entail short-term restructuring costs (including dismissal-related outlays).
  - In 2014, agencies receiving substantial resources related to special fees (sufficient to cover operating requirements) will no longer receive operating subsidies.
- Agriculture:
  - Continue efforts begun in 2013 (with technical and financial partners) to target subsidies more effectively to inputs.
  - Expected estimated savings of CFAF 6.4 billion.
- Education:
  - Wages for contractual personnel will be controlled more effectively after implementation in January 2013 of the Finpronet system allowing real-time monitoring of workforce changes and staff distribution by school district.
  - Survey of education staff enables redeployment of teachers from oversupplied schools to those with shortages.
  - Higher education: scholarships and assistance made contingent on merit and household resources; review of policy for granting international scholarships (targeting preparatory classes, engineering schools, and sectors of national interest) and national aid/scholarships to promote student performance.
  - Beneficiaries to participate in financing through reasonable increases in student registration fees; policies to take effect in the 2013–2014 university year to provide more resources for public higher education and to comply with budget allocations.

*Source: Appendix I. Letter of Intent — Dakar, December 5, 2013.*

### 14. The savings generated with this approach will also be used to finance priority

### _cr1404 - 14. The savings generated with this approach will also be used to finance priority

### Social protection and health coverage
- Priority programs to benefit the poor: (i) Family Security Allowance (Bourse de Sécurité Familiale—BSF); (ii) Caisse Autonome de Protection Sociale Universelle—CAPSU; and (iii) universal health coverage (CSU).
- BSF design and rollout:
  - Monetary transfer conditional on school enrollment and health care for school-age children.
  - Pilot phase: payment of CFAF 25,000 per quarter to 50,000 targeted households by end-2013.
  - Expansion: reach 250,000 households at end-2017.
- Universal health coverage objectives and short/medium-term reforms:
  - Aim to provide health risk coverage for more than 65.5 percent of the population by 2017.
  - Plans include reform of mandatory health insurance via health provident institutions; development of basic universal health coverage through mutual health associations; strengthened management of existing free care policies (caesarian procedures, Plan Sésame, HIV, Expanded Programme of Immunisation—PEV, etc.); implementation of new free health care initiative for children under five.

### Fiscal contingency planning and revenue risk
- Need for contingent measures to meet 2014 budget targets if risks materialize due to revenue uncertainty.
- Projections for 2014 are more conservative to reduce downward risks.
- If revenue shortfalls occur, additional revenue measures should be implemented no later than mid-2014; such measures to be discussed with IMF staff during the seventh program review.
- Historical pattern: revenue shortfalls frequently led to capital expenditure adjustments at year-end.

### Debt management and external financing
- Medium-term debt management objective: reduce vulnerabilities by gradually increasing average debt maturities in market borrowing.
- 2013 progress: first 10-year bond on the regional market.
- Eurobond decision:
  - Previously envisaged: US$500 million Eurobond in 2013.
  - Postponed to 2014 because international market conditions were less favorable.
- Syndicated financing: CFAF 250 billion (including equivalent of CFAF 100 billion in euro) used to complete 2013 budget financing.
  - Syndicated financing terms: interest rate 6.5 percent; maturity 7 years.
- Semiconcessional loans program:
  - Increased from CFAF 67 billion to CFAF 132 billion to execute three priority investment projects.
  - Target projects offering returns of 14-20 percent and concessionality rate of 22–32.5 percent.

### Tax policy and revenue mobilization
- New tax code effective January 2013; implementation on course despite early 2013 issues.
- VAT credits cash reimbursement will begin in January 2014.
- Reforms to complete tax modernization to be initiated in 2014, including:
  - Rationalization of stamp duties.
  - Comprehensive taxation of the financial (banking and insurance) and telecommunication sectors.
  - Imposition of taxes on e-commerce.
  - Environmental taxation.
  - Taxation of natural resources.
- Rationalization of tax expenditure: incentives in the new tax code to be the only ones applicable, with limited, targeted exceptions for interim measures supporting major government projects.
- Tax administration modernization to be finalized by end-2013, accompanied by human resource recruitment to reduce the current deficit.

### Public financial management and governance
- Agency restructuring strategy adopted: some agencies will be eliminated or merged; restructuring to be completed by end-2014.
  - Short-term costs expected; long-term substantial savings anticipated.
  - Remunerations to be rationalized to narrow gap between agencies and average civil service pay.
  - New continuous structural benchmark: apply legislation requiring in-depth cost-benefit analysis for any new agency creation.
  - New structural benchmark: five largest agencies to submit strategies to form the basis for performance contracts beginning in 2014.
  - Ministry of Economy and Finance to conduct infra-annual financial monitoring of agencies; quarterly reports to be produced and shared with IMF staff.
- WAEMU directive implementation:
  - Quarterly budget outturn reports regularly forwarded to the National Assembly and published.
  - Multi-year Economic and Budgetary Programming Document (DPBEP 2014–2016) produced (not yet discussed by the National Assembly).
  - Final report on execution of budget laws for 2011 fiscal year submitted to National Assembly in August 2013.
  - Draft settlement law for 2012 submitted to the Audit Court for assessment.
- Accounting, budget, and financial information tools:
  - Requirement to transmit quarterly reports on budget outturn to the treasury by the parastatal sector.
  - Interface between budget management system (SIGFIP) and accounting system (ASTER) for monthly reconciliation; interface to be completed no later than end-June 2014.
  - Draft instruction to clean up old treasury account balances to be validated by end-2013 for cleanup in 2014.
  - Plan under study to implement double-entry accounting for accountants responsible for collections (DGCPT).
  - Single treasury account (CUT) implementation: system to be established by end-April 2014 for access to bank account balances at BCEAO.
- Wage bill management:
  - New payroll management software planned for beginning of January 2014.
  - Forecasting and control tool for wage bill execution in partnership with AFRITAC West.
  - Integration of wage bill into SIGFIP via interface with new payroll software.
  - Payroll register cleanup following publication of physical and biometric audit results.
- Cost-benefit analysis requirement:
  - Objective: one third of capital expenditure included in the 2015 budget to be subject to cost-benefit analyses.
  - Analyses on the five largest investment projects in the 2015 budget to be forwarded to the National Assembly with the draft budget law (new structural benchmark).

### Private sector development — energy sector
- Energy production plan for 2013–2017 based on a mix of coal, natural gas, hydroelectricity, and renewable energy sources to expand capacity and reduce production costs.
- Electricity sector expected to exceed 2 percent of GDP again in the current year.
- Planned installations and timelines:
  - 15 MW Félou hydroelectric power station in 2013.
  - 70 MW IPP in Tobéne (Taiba Ndiaye) in 2015.
  - 125 MW coal-fired IPP (Sendou) at end-2015.
  - 80 MW imports from Mauritania natural gas plant at end-2015.
  - 250 MW coal-fired IPP with Kepco in 2017–18.
  - Renewable energy projects.
- Fallback projects negotiated due to delays:
  - Agreement with Africa Energy for a 300 MW coal-fired IPP in Mboro in 2016.
- Investments planned in transmission and distribution: networks, substations, high tension lines.
- Rural electrification objective: reach 60 percent rural electrification by 2016; a three-year priority rural electrification program (2014-2016) being prepared.
- SENELEC performance contract:
  - Signed June 2013; monitoring committee to meet at least quarterly.
  - Reports and performance agreement audit to be published; first publication to include an electricity sector survey and authorities’ reform strategy (new structural benchmark).
  - SENELEC 2012 accounts certified in November 2013.
- SAR (Société Africaine de Raffinage) strategic reform study awarded to consultant; conclusions to be examined at SAR general shareholders’ meeting scheduled for end-2013.

### Private sector development — financial sector and business climate
- Updated action plan for national consultation on credit produced end-May 2013:
  - Comprises 65 operational measures: 47 with fixed deadlines (24 completed) and 18 continuous.
  - Implementation to be completed by end-2014.
  - Key measures include promotion of factoring; reduction in delays for registration of guarantees/pledges; reduction of lags in obtaining statements on liens from courts; register for nontrade entities to register mortgages/pledges; accelerated implementation of risk reporting and analysis center for microfinance institutions (SFDs).
- Land reform:
  - Commission on land reform established end-2012; will be completed in 2015 to increase transparency in rural and urban land management.
- Business climate and competitiveness reforms (2013–2015):
  - Business establishment: 24 hours for corporations; full electronic process planned by end-2013.
  - New entrepreneurial regulations to be incorporated into Senegalese legislation by end-2013.
  - Electronic filing/assessment of construction permit applications to enable permits in Dakar in 28 days.
  - Merger of property registration and publishing procedures reduced ownership transfer rate from 15 percent to 10 percent and eliminated transaction authorizations, reducing delays by 50 days.
  - Improvements in commercial justice reduced contract execution delays.
  - Legal and institutional framework for public-private partnerships under revision; adoption of new law planned for November 2013.
  - Full use of automated procedure for cross-border trade effective from March 2013 for pre-customs and customs clearance; import/export periods reduced to a maximum of nine days.
- Tax digitalization:
  - Roll out of on-line filing and on-line payment of taxes for Dakar area implemented in November 2013 for import taxes; full implementation expected December 2013 for other taxes.
  - Roll out for large enterprises ongoing with application date January 1, 2014.

### Program monitoring, quantitative targets, and structural benchmarks
- Proposed adjustments and monitoring:
  - End-June 2014 quantitative assessment criteria and targets for end-December 2014 proposed.
  - Ceiling on semiconcessional borrowing (grant element 15–35 percent) increased from CFAF 67 billion to CFAF 132 billion; requires modification of assessment criterion for end-2013.
  - Seventh PSI review expected concluded by end-June 2014 and the eighth review by December 2, 2014.
- Selected quantitative assessment figures (as presented in tables):
  - Table 1 (2012—2013) examples:
    - Floor on the overall fiscal balance (CFAF billions, cumulative since the beginning of the year): -425 (Dec 31, 2012 Prog.), -101 (Sep 30, 2013 Prog.), -20 (Sep 30, 2013 Act., Status met), -203 (Dec 31, 2013 Prog.), -190 (Dec 31, 2013 Adj.), -155 (Dec 31, 2013 Act., Status met), -304, -406.
    - Ceiling on contracting or guaranteeing new nonconcessional external debt by the government (US$ millions): 500 (Dec 31, 2012 Prog.), 500 (Sep 30, 2013 Prog.), 300 (Sep 30, 2013 Act., Status met), 800 (Dec 31, 2013 Prog.), ... , 300 (Dec 31, 2013 Act., Status met), 800, 800.
    - Ceiling on nonconcessional debt with minimum grant element of 15 percent: 44 (Dec 31, 2012 Prog.), 44 (Sep 30, 2013 Prog.), 40 (Sep 30, 2013 Act., Status met), 67 (Dec 31, 2013 Prog.), ... , 0 (Dec 31, 2013 Act., Status met), 67, 132.
    - Floor on social expenditures (percent of total spending): 35 (various periods).
  - Table 2 (2013–2014 projections and targets) examples:
    - Ceiling on contracting or guaranteeing new nonconcessional external debt by the government (US$ millions): 800 for December 31, 2013 and for each projection through December 31, 2014.
    - Ceiling on nonconcessional debt with minimum grant element of 15 percent: 132 for each projection through December 31, 2014.
    - Floor on tax revenue (CFAF billions): 1,434 (Dec 31, 2013 Prog.), 374 (Mar 31, 2014 Prog.), 781 (Jun 30, 2014 Prog.), 1,156 (Sep 30, 2014 Proj.), 1,561 (Dec 31, 2014 Proj.).
    - Memorandum items—Program grants and concessional loans: program grants 38 10 21 32 42 (various periods); concessional loans 22 16 5 11 19 17 8 23 7 (as shown in table).
- Structural benchmarks and status (selected):
  - Submit new Customs Code to Parliament (MEFP §18): Rescheduled to September 30, 2013; Implemented in November 2013.
  - Produce plan to restructure all agencies and comparable entities (MEFP §22): July 31, 2013 (6th review benchmark); Implemented in November 2013.
  - Roll out new payroll management software (MEFP §12): August 31, 2013 (6th review benchmark); Not met.
  - Use cost-benefit assessment for investment projects exceeding CFAF 10 billion to be included in the budget for 2014 (MEFP §24): July 31, 2013 (6th review benchmark); Not met.
  - Submit draft law on disclosure of assets to Assembly (MEFP §19): January 1, 2014 (7th review); Implemented in November 2013.
  - Roll out on-line filing and on-line payment of taxes for all taxpayers in Dakar (MEFP §17): June 30, 2013 (6th review); Implemented in November 2013 for import taxes; implementation expected December 2013 for other taxes.
- New structural benchmarks (selected):
  - All agency creation subject to in-depth cost-benefit analysis (MEFP §19): Continuous application; objective: improve quality of public expenditure and transparency.
  - Presentation by five largest agencies of strategies and implementation of performance contracts (MEFP §19): Application date June 30, 2014; benchmark for eighth review.
  - Cost-benefit analyses on five largest investment projects in 2015 budget to be sent to National Assembly with draft budget law (MEFP §23): Application date October 15, 2014; benchmark for eighth review.
  - Reports of SENELEC performance contract monitoring committee and audit to be published, first report by March 31, 2014 (MEFP §25); benchmark for eighth review to promote private sector development.

*Attachment II: Technical Memorandum of Understanding — Dakar, December 5, 2013.*

### 1. This technical memorandum of understanding (TMU) defines the quantitative assessment

### _cr1404 - 1. This technical memorandum of understanding (TMU) defines the quantitative assessment

### Overview
- The TMU defines the quantitative assessment criteria, indicative targets, and structural benchmarks to monitor implementation of the Fund-supported program under the Policy Support Instrument (PSI) in 2011–2014.
- The TMU establishes terms and time frames for transmitting data needed for Fund staff to monitor program implementation.

### Program conditionality
- Quantitative assessment criteria for end-December 2013 and end-June 2014, and quantitative targets for end-March and end-September 2014, are shown in Tables 1 and 2 of the MEFP, respectively.
- Structural benchmarks are presented in Table 3 and Table 4 of the MEFP.

### Definitions, adjusters, and data reporting

H3: A. The Government
- “Government” means the central administration of the Republic of Senegal and excludes local administrations, the central bank, or any other public or government-owned entity with autonomous legal personality not included in the government flow-of-funds table (TOFE), unless otherwise indicated.

H3: B. Overall Fiscal Balance (Program Definition)
- Definition:
  - The overall fiscal balance including grants (program definition) = government’s total revenue (revenue and grants) − total expenditure and net lending.
  - Operations of the Energy Sector Support Fund (FSE) are integrated in the government TOFE.
  - Revenues exclude privatization receipts and sales of mobile phone licenses or of any other state-owned assets.
  - Government expenditure is defined on the basis of payment orders accepted by the Treasury (dépenses ordonnancées prises en charge par le Trésor) and expenditures executed with external resources.
  - Assessment criterion is set as a floor on the overall fiscal balance including grants as of the beginning of the year.
- Example:
  - Floor as of December 31, 2012 = minus CFAF 420 billion, calculated as total government revenue (CFAF 1,670 billion) − total expenditure and net lending (CFAF 2,090 billion).
- Adjustments:
  - Adjust downward by the amount that budget grants fall short of program projections up to a maximum of CFAF 15 billion at current exchange rates (see MEFP Tables 1 and 2).
  - Adjust downward/upward by the amount that concessional loans exceed/fall short of their programmed amount, up to a maximum of CFAF 50 billion at current exchange rates (see MEFP, Tables 1 and 2). Concessional loans denominated in CFAF and in foreign currency are taken into account.
- Reporting requirements:
  - Authorities will report provisional data on the overall fiscal balance (program definition) and its components monthly to Fund staff with a lag of no more than 30 days.
  - Data on revenues and expenditure included in the calculation, and on expenditure financed with HIPC- and MDRI-related resources, will be drawn from preliminary Treasury account balances.
  - Final data provided as soon as final Treasury account balances are available, but not later than two months after provisional data reporting.

H3: C. Social Expenditure
- Definition:
  - Social spending = spending on health, education, the environment, the judicial system, social safety nets, sanitation, and rural water supply.
  - Criterion is a floor in percent relative to total spending (including the FSE) excluding capital expenditure related to the extension of the autoroute and investment projects of the power sector reform plan.
- Reporting requirements:
  - Authorities will report semiannual data to Fund staff within two months following the end of each period.

H3: D. Budgetary Float
- Definition:
  - Budgetary float (instances de paiement) = outstanding stock of government expenditure for which bills have been received and validated but not yet paid by the Treasury (dépenses liquidées − dépenses payées).
  - Assessment criterion is set as a ceiling on the budgetary float, monitored at the end of the quarter.
- Reporting requirements:
  - Authorities will transmit weekly (end of each week) and at the end of each month a SIGFIP table showing: committed expenditures (dépenses engagées); certified expenditures not yet cleared for payment (dépenses liquidées non encore ordonnancées); payment orders (dépenses ordonnancées); payment orders accepted by the Treasury (dépenses prises en charge par le Trésor); and payments made by the Treasury (dépenses payées).
  - SIGFIP table will exclude delegations for regions and embassies and will list any payments without a cash impact on Treasury accounts.

H3: E. Spending Undertaken Outside Simplified and Normal Procedures
- Scope:
  - Applied continuously to any procedure other than normal and simplified procedures to execute spending.
  - Excludes spending undertaken on the basis of a supplemental appropriation order (décret d’avance) in cases of absolute urgency and need in the national interest (Article 12 of the Organic Budget Law). Such spending requires signatures of the President of the Republic and Prime Minister.
- Reporting:
  - Authorities will report any such procedure, together with the SIGFIP table defined in paragraph 12, to Fund staff monthly with a maximum delay of 30 days.

H3: F. Government External Payments Arrears
- Definition:
  - External payments arrears = sum of payments owed and not paid on external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government. The definition of external debt in paragraph 17 applies.
  - Assessment criterion monitored on a continuous basis.
- Reporting requirements:
  - Authorities will promptly report any accumulation of external payments arrears to Fund staff.

H3: G. Contracting or Guaranteeing of New Nonconcessional External Debt by the Government
- Definition of debt (Executive Board Decision No.6230-(79/140), revised August 31, 2009 (Decision No. 14416-(09/91))):
  - Debt = direct, non-contingent liability created under a contractual arrangement through provision of value in assets (including currency) or services, requiring obligor payments per a repayment schedule to discharge principal and/or interest.
  - Primary forms: i. loans (including deposits, bonds, debentures, commercial loans, buyers’ credits, repurchase agreements, official swap arrangements); ii. suppliers’ credits; iii. leases (debt = present value at lease inception of all lease payments expected during agreement, excluding operation/repair/maintenance payments).
  - Arrears, penalties, and judicially awarded damages arising from failure to make payment under contractual obligation that constitutes debt are debt.
- Debt guarantees:
  - Guarantee arises from any explicit legal obligation of the government to service a debt in the event of nonpayment by the debtor (payments in cash or in kind).
- Debt concessionality:
  - Debt is concessional if it includes a grant element of at least 35 percent.
  - Grant element = (PV of debt − nominal value) / nominal value, expressed as a percentage of nominal value.
  - PV at contracting is calculated by discounting future debt service payments using a discount rate of 5 percent.
  - Calculation takes into account maturity, grace period, payment schedule, upfront commissions, and management fees.
- External debt definition:
  - External debt = debt borrowed or serviced in a currency other than the CFA franc. Applies to debt among WAEMU countries.
- Debt-related assessment criteria:
  - Apply to contracting and guaranteeing of new nonconcessional external debt by government, local governments, SENELEC, FSE, and any other public or government-owned entity.
  - Apply to debt and commitments contracted or guaranteed for which value has not yet been received, and to private debt with official guarantees (contingent liability).
  - Measured cumulatively from PSI approval by the Executive Board. ACs monitored continuously. No adjuster applied.
- Special provisions:
  - Exclusions: (i) debt rescheduling of debt existing at PSI approval; (ii) debt contracted by AIBD for new Dakar Airport construction; (iii) short-term external debt (maturity < one year) contracted by SENELEC to finance petroleum product purchases.
  - Ceiling: total ceiling of US$800 million applies over 2011–14 for nonconcessional external debt financing for investment projects (roads, energy, urban water and sanitation) and to reduce recourse to regional market financing.
  - After issuance of a Eurobond in May 2011 with an exchange offer for the outstanding 2009 Eurobond, remaining ceiling for non-concessional borrowing for 2013–14 is US$500 million.
  - Separate ceiling equivalent to CFAF 132 billion in 2011–14 applies for untied nonconcessional external debt financing with a grant element of at least 15 percent.
  - Projects financed under the CFAF 132 billion provision expected to meet same economic and social profitability criteria as other capital spending. Government will inform Fund staff in a timely manner before contracting such debt, provide information to verify concessionality, and provide brief project summaries and profitability evaluations. Government will report use of funds and project implementation in subsequent MEFPs.
- Reporting requirements:
  - Government will report any new external borrowing and its terms to Fund staff as soon as external debt is contracted or guaranteed, but no later than within two weeks of contracting or guaranteeing.

H3: H. Public Sector Contracts Signed by Single Tender
- Definition:
  - Public sector contracts = administrative contracts entered into by government or entities subject to procurement code for supplies, services, or execution of work.
  - “Single-tender” = contracting agent signs with chosen contractor without competitive tender.
  - Quarterly indicative target applies to total public sector contracts entered into by government or any entity subject to procurement code.
  - Ceiling excludes fuel purchases by SENELEC for electricity production (reflects new regulation requiring SENELEC to buy fuel directly from SAR).
- Reporting requirements:
  - Government will report quarterly to Fund staff, with lag no more than one month from end of observation period, the total value of public sector contracts and the total value of all single-tender public sector contracts.

H3: I. Tax Revenue
- Definition:
  - Tax revenue = sum of revenue from taxes on income, goods and services, and petroleum products.
  - Indicative target assessed on basis of data for such revenue provided in the quarterly TOFE.

### Additional information for program monitoring
- Authorities will transmit the following to Fund staff, in electronic format if possible, with the maximum time lags indicated:
  - Within 3 days after adoption: any decision, circular, edict, supplemental appropriation order, ordinance, or law having economic or financial implications for the current program (including acts that change budget allocations, create new agencies or funds).
  - With a maximum lag of 30 days, preliminary data on:
    - Tax receipts and tax and customs assessments by categories, accompanied by corresponding revenue on a monthly basis;
    - Monthly amount of expenditures committed, certified, and for which payment orders have been issued;
    - Monthly situation of checks issued by agencies from their deposit accounts at the Treasury but not paid to beneficiaries, with dates of issuance of the checks;
    - Quarterly report of the Debt and Investments Directorate (DDI) on execution of investment programs;
    - Monthly preliminary government TOFE based on Treasury accounts;
    - Provisional monthly balance of the Treasury accounts;
    - Reconciliation tables (quarterly) between: SIGFIP table and consolidated Treasury accounts; consolidated Treasury accounts and TOFE for "budgetary revenues"; consolidated Treasury accounts and TOFE for "total expenditure and net lending"; and between TOFE and net government position (NGP).
  - Final data provided as soon as final Treasury account balances are available, but not later than one month after provisional data reporting.
- Additional monthly reporting during program period:
  - Provisional data on current nonwage noninterest expenditures and domestically financed capital expenditures executed through cash advances, drawn from preliminary consolidated Treasury account balances, with lag no more than 30 days. Final data no more than one month after provisional reporting.
- Central bank reporting to Fund staff:
  - Monthly balance sheet of the central bank, maximum lag of one month;
  - Consolidated monthly balance sheet of banks, maximum lag of two months;
  - Monetary survey, monthly, maximum lag of two months;
  - Lending and deposit interest rates of commercial banks, monthly;
  - Prudential supervision and financial soundness indicators for bank financial institutions (Situation des Etablissements de Crédit vis-à-vis du Dispositif Prudentiel), quarterly, maximum delay of two months.

*Source: _cr1404 - 1. This technical memorandum of understanding (TMU) defines the quantitative assessment*

### 30. The government will update on a monthly basis on the website established for this purpose

### _cr1404 - 30. The government will update on a monthly basis on the website established for this purpose

### Monthly public disclosures required (paragraph 30)
- The government will update on a monthly basis on the website established for this purpose the following information:
  - a) Preliminary TOFE and transition tables with the delay of 2 months.
  - b) SIGFIP execution table, the table for the central government and a summary table including regions, with the delay of 2 weeks
  - c) The amount of the airport tax collected, deposited in the escrow account, and used for the repayment of the loan financing the construction of the new airport, with the delay of 1 month.
  - d) Full information on:
    - (i) the operations of Energy Sector Support Fund (FSE);
    - (ii) investment projects in the power sector;
    - (iii) planning and execution of these projects;
    - (iv) details of financing and updated costs; and
    - (v) the balance of the escrow account with the resources of the Eurobond issued in 2011 (within 3 weeks).

### Program assessment and macroeconomic context (selected excerpts)
- "GDP growth is on track to reach 4 percent in 2013."
- "Consumer price inflation below 1 percent."
- "Growth is expected to increase further in 2014 while inflation would remain moderate."
- "All quantitative program targets for mid-2013 have been met, structural reform implementation has slowed significantly and most structural benchmarks have been met with delay."
- Fiscal objectives and projections:
  - "The fiscal deficit target for 2013 remains within reach, and a further reduction of the deficit is expected in 2014."
  - Authorities aim "to contain its share of GDP below 5 percent."
- Key program priorities and recommendations:
  - Strengthen the revenue base and streamline current expenditure while allowing for an increase in public investment and the development of the social safety net.
  - More rapid implementation of the structural reform agenda, including public financial management reforms.
  - Greater use of cost-benefit analysis for the selection of investment projects.
  - Better control over the wage bill to eliminate inefficiencies and create room for social spending.
  - Accelerate introduction of cost-effective technologies in the energy sector; focus the investment plan on a few critical projects with a realistic implementation timeline.
  - Clearly communicate the situation of the energy sector—including the true fiscal cost of supporting it—the reform strategy, and its implementation to stakeholders.

### Policy measures and reform actions (selected commitments)
- Public financial management and revenue:
  - Finalization of a plan for restructuring public agencies; establishment of the Treasury single account; cabinet adoption of a new customs code and submission to parliament; launch of electronic filing and payment systems.
  - Launch of a new payroll management system "at the beginning of next year."
  - Annex cost-benefit analyses for the five largest investment projects to the 2015 draft budget law when submitted to parliament.
- Expenditure control:
  - Arrangements made to curb the increasing trend of public sector phone and utility bills.
  - Suspension of salaries of about 11,000 unaccounted civil servants pending authentication.
  - Restructuring plan for agencies including merger and elimination of some agencies and alignment of staff remuneration with the average salary of other civil servants.
- Social protection:
  - Strengthen the social safety net, including broadening of basic health insurance coverage, assistance to farmers, and pro-poor allocation of conditional cash transfers.
- Energy and private sector development:
  - Strategic investments in the energy sector expected to sharply increase power generation and distribution capacities in the medium term, reduce production costs, make electricity consumption more affordable, improve competitiveness, and reduce fiscal risks and energy subsidies.
  - Strengthen accountability of SENELEC through regular issuance of monitoring reports on its performance contract with the State and make these monitoring reports public.

*Source: IMF staff report and related statements in the Senegal PSI documentation (December 2013).*

### Conclusion

### Conclusion

### Objectives and policy emphasis
- The objectives of Senegal’s Policy Support Instrument (PSI) reflect the emphasis put by the country authorities on the importance of preserving macroeconomic stability, creating space for pro-poor and pro-growth spending, and promoting private sector development.
- The authorities have continued to implement steadfastly the policies and reforms designed to achieve these objectives.

### Role of Fund assistance
- Fund’s assistance has been critical in support of their efforts.

### Outstanding needs and commitment
- Much more needs to be done despite these achievements.
- The authorities remain fully committed to pursuing the reform process and implementing a transformative growth strategy.

### Staff recommendation
- In light of Senegal’s program performance and the strong commitment of the Senegalese authorities to the program objectives, we call on Directors to support the Senegalese authorities’ request for the completion of the sixth review under the PSI.

*Source: _cr1404 - Conclusion*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr1404.pdf_
