## Executive Summary and Key Findings (Content unit: _cr14164)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [Executive Summary and Key Findings (Content unit: _cr14164)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr14164.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr14164.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr14164.pdf.json)

---

### Context and immediate shock
- March 24, 2013: seizing of power by a coalition of rebels (Séléka) triggered a political and security crisis with sharp contraction of economic activity, budgetary pressures, widespread destruction of administrative and economic infrastructures, paralysis of the public administration, intercommunity conflicts, and a major humanitarian crisis.
- By the end of 2013, ¼ of the population (1 million persons) was displaced.
- Currently more than 8,000 troops are deployed in the country; this level is planned to grow to nearly 20,000.
- New transitional government in place since the beginning of 2014 faces challenges: restoring security, reviving economic activity, and rebuilding the democratic process.
- Donor reengagement underpins a modest expected recovery in 2014, conditional on security improvements allowing resumption of agriculture activities and trade.

### Macroeconomic and humanitarian impact (key statistics and outcomes)
- Real GDP contracted by 36 percent in 2013.
- Exports fell by 44 percent and imports fell by 27 percent (in dollar terms); exports slumped 44 percent and imports were down 27.1 percent in dollar terms (Appendix figures).
- Current account deficit widened to over 10 percent of GDP in 2013 from nearly 6 percent in 2012; balance of payments deficit reached 10.4 percent of GDP in 2013.
- Consumer price index rose by 6.6 percent in 2013 (CPI averaged 6.6 percent in 2013).
- Domestic primary deficit widened to almost 7 percent of GDP in 2013 (domestic primary balance: deficit of 6.8 percent of GDP in 2013, compared to a surplus of 0.5 percent in 2012).
  - Fiscal revenue dropped by 63 percent (tax revenues: dropped 63.5 percent).
  - Domestic primary spending fell by 22 percent; current primary expenditure down 10 percent (Appendix wording).
- Government accumulated net domestic payments arrears equivalent to 2.3 percent of GDP, including 5 months of wages and salaries through end-February 2014.
- Grants dropped by 15 percent in 2013.
- With financial assistance from CEMAC countries, the new transitional government paid 2 months of salaries and 3 months of pensions in March/April 2014.
- At the January 20, 2014 meeting in Brussels, pledges amounting to about US$500 million in assistance were made; Total support pledged during the Brussels Conference and ECCAS amounted to US$572 million (humanitarian aid US$203 million; development aid US$192 million; budget support for 2014 US$177 million). Disbursements through end-April 2014 amounted to about US$44 million.

### IMF engagement and financing
- Authorities cancelled with immediate effect the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) arrangement approved June 25, 2012 (ECF amount SDR 41.78 million).
- Authorities requested a disbursement of SDR 8.355 million (15 percent of quota, or about US$12.9 million) under the Rapid Credit Facility (RCF) to meet urgent 2014 balance of payments needs.
- IMF Executive Board approved RCF financial assistance equivalent to SDR 8.355 million on May 14, 2014; RCF features: zero interest; grace period of 5½ years; final maturity of 10 years.
- A second RCF of SDR 5.570 million (10 percent of quota or US$8.5 million) could follow before the end of the year conditional on continued urgent needs and satisfactory performance under the RCF.
- Total IMF assistance history to C.A.R. during 1998–2012: SDR 160.8 million committed; disbursements amounted to SDR 101.1 million.

### Program objectives and quantitative macro targets
- Main objectives for 2014:
  - real GDP growth: 1.5 percent;
  - inflation: about 4.4 percent (from 6.6 percent in 2013);
  - domestic primary deficit: 7.6 percent of GDP (against 6.8 percent in 2013);
  - current account deficit: 14.1 percent of GDP.
- Macroeconomic objectives for 2015:
  - real GDP growth: 5.3 percent;
  - inflation: around 4 percent;
  - current account deficit: about 13 percent of GDP;
  - domestic primary deficit: around 3 percent of GDP.
- Financing gap for 2014: projected at CFAF 81 billion or 10 percent of GDP; to be covered by grants from World Bank (CFAF 12.8 billion), African Development Bank (CFAF 9.4 billion), EU (CFAF 19.7 billion), France (CFAF 7.9 billion), Angola (CFAF 4.7 billion), CEMAC countries (CFAF 20 billion), and IMF financing.

### Risks and contingencies
- Downside risks:
  - security conditions remain difficult and unpredictable;
  - potential tensions associated with presidential elections in first half of 2015;
  - weak implementation capacity and possible delay in provision of technical assistance;
  - delay in providing pledged financing.
- Upside factor:
  - United Nations approval of deployment of 12,000 peacekeepers to protect civilians and facilitate humanitarian access.

### Debt situation and sustainability
- Debt situation deteriorated significantly mainly due to collapse of output and exports.
- New debt sustainability analysis (DSA) changed the risk of debt distress from moderate to high.
- Total public debt, including domestic arrears, as of end-September 2013: 45.1 percent of GDP; additional accumulation of domestic arrears in the last quarter of 2013 estimated to bring total public debt to 50.8 percent at end-2013.
- External public and publicly-guaranteed debt as of September 2013: 27.2 percent of GDP (Non-Paris Club bilateral creditors account for 85.8 percent of this external debt).
- External debt indicators: PV of external debt-to-exports and debt service-to-exports ratios breach policy-related thresholds in the near term (PV of external debt in percent of Exports: 178.2 in 2013; PV of external debt in percent of GDP: 16.1 in 2013 as reported in Box 1 excerpts).
- Policy stance: emphasis on grant-financed emergency program and continued external assistance on concessional terms; commitment that new external loans have a grant element of at least 35 percent (continuous benchmark).

### Technical assistance (TA) needs and coordination
- Immediate TA priorities: restore tax and customs administration, public finance management, and treasury management; sizable TA is crucial to rebuild basic state functions.
- TA providers and roles:
  - IMF to coordinate TA needs and provision and restart TA activities as security permits (revenue administration and PFM); officials could meet IMF experts at AFRITAC-Center in Libreville if security conditions do not improve.
  - World Bank to provide TA on tax administration and customs, and with UNDP on civil service rationalization.
  - EU to assign two resident experts in the treasury department (ACCT and budget directorate).
  - African Development Bank to hire experts to support reform coordination and restructure PARGEF to provide urgent assistance.
  - Planned short-term TA missions by World Bank, EU, French development agency, and AfDB; monthly updates to assess TA implementation.
- TA matrix and programmatic procedures to be developed jointly by staff and donors.

### Program monitoring, safeguards, and conditionality
- Access under this RCF is limited to 15 percent of quota (SDR 8.355 million).
- Progress monitored through quarterly indicators and key structural benchmarks with indicative targets at end-June, end-September, and end-December 2014 (MEFP Table I.1 and Table II.2).
- Prior actions for Board submission included decrees establishing the Treasury Committee (CT) and the Committee to Monitor and Manage Public Finance (CSGFP), and adoption/submission of the draft 2014 budget.
- Structural benchmarks include: first-stage payroll clean-up report by end-June 2014; recruitment of the Central Accounting Officer of the Treasury and deputy by end-September 2014; reconnection of GESCO-Budget and GESCO-Comptabilité by end-September 2014.
- Data reporting deadlines to IMF specified (monthly and quarterly datasets; e.g., monetary survey within four weeks of end of each month; monthly cash flow operations within ten days of end of each month).
- Safeguards: BEAC subject to quadrennial assessment in 2013; safeguards staff visit conducted April 1–9, 2014, finding progress though risks remain elevated.

### Main policy recommendations and reform priorities
- Prepare the ground for return to a normal budgetary process:
  - limit spending executed under emergency procedures (target: not exceed 7 percent of total expenditure, excluding salaries and financial costs);
  - reconnect budget and accounting systems (GESCO-Budget and GESCO-Comptabilité).
- Ensure transparency and accountability in use of public resources:
  - establish effective functioning of a Treasury Committee (CT) and a Multi-Partners Committee (CSGFP) to monitor and manage public finances;
  - enhance traceability of tax revenue flowing from commercial banks to the Treasury Single Account (TSA).
- Implement prudent fiscal policy and restore fiscal discipline:
  - strengthen revenue mobilization (increase revenue by 0.7 percentage point of GDP targeted in budget);
  - better prioritize spending; improve cash flow management; gradually clear domestic arrears (settle domestic payments arrears equivalent to 2 percent of GDP, prioritizing salary arrears first, then pensions, and lastly commercial suppliers).
- Medium-term growth and inclusiveness:
  - foster inclusive processes for conflict resolution; create fiscal space for social and other priority spending; improve the business environment.
- Sector- and revenue-specific actions:
  - revisit taxation for oil, gold, diamonds, telecommunications, and forestry with IMF TA and development partners;
  - restore control over customs clearance chain along main import corridor; maintain Douala one-stop customs shop for imports via Cameroon.

### Social and budgetary allocations (2014 and 2015 projections)
- 2014 social sector allocation: CFAF 43 billion total, including CFAF 6.5 billion in current expenditure.
  - Health: CFAF 26 billion total, including CFAF 4 billion for current expenditure (malaria, EPI, PPTCT, PLHIV services).
  - Education: CFAF 3.9 billion (current and capital).
  - Water and sanitation: CFAF 12.9 billion, including CFAF 2 billion for current expenditure.
- 2015 macro/fiscal projections:
  - real GDP growth: expected at about at least 5 percent in real terms (progressively);
  - inflation: around 4 percent;
  - domestic revenue expected to reach 12.6 percent of GDP;
  - current primary expenditure expected to drop to 11.2 percent of GDP;
  - domestically financed capital spending expected to rise by 0.2 percentage point of GDP versus 2014;
  - domestic primary deficit expected to decline from 7.6 percent of GDP in 2014 to 3.2 percent of GDP;
  - financing gap of CFAF 56.4 billion, equivalent to 6.4 percent of GDP.

### Implementation sequencing and institutional arrangements
- Cash flow plan for 2014 developed and signed, stating monthly revenue and expenditure targets in priority order; CT to design and manage a weekly/ monthly treasury plan; CSGFP to conduct quarterly reviews with donors.
- Central Accounting Agency of the Treasury (ACCT) created December 30, 2012; to be made operational with recruitment of central treasury accountant and deputy by end-September 2014.
- Civil service payroll cleanup: initial clean-up and report to IMF by end-June 2014; subsequent payroll management reforms and database security measures to be implemented with partner support.

*Source: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY and excerpts from chapters and appendices of _cr14164 (May 1, 2014), International Monetary Fund.*

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

### Context
- March 24, 2013: seizing of power by a coalition of rebels (Séléka) triggered a political and security crisis with:
  - sharp contraction of economic activity, budgetary pressures, widespread destruction of administrative and economic infrastructures, paralysis of the public administration, intercommunity conflicts, and a major humanitarian crisis.
  - By the end of 2013, ¼ of the population (1 million persons) was displaced.
  - Currently more than 8,000 troops are deployed in the country; this level is planned to grow to nearly 20,000.
- New transitional government in place since the beginning of 2014 faces significant challenges: restoring security, reviving economic activity, and rebuilding the democratic process.
- As donors reengage, the economy is expected to recover slightly in 2014, subject to improvement in security conditions that would allow a resumption of agriculture activities and trade.

### Program issues and IMF engagement
- Authorities cancelled with immediate effect the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) arrangement that was approved on June 25, 2012.
- Authorities requested a disbursement of SDR 8.355 million (15 percent of quota, or about US$12.9 million) under the Rapid Credit Facility (RCF) to help meet urgent balance of payments needs and support their economic program for 2014 and reengagement with development partners.
- A successor RCF could follow before the end of the year, conditional upon the continued presence of urgent balance of payments needs and satisfactory performance under this RCF.
- Timely provision of pledged financial and technical assistance is crucial to sustain momentum and exit from the emergency situation.
- IMF assistance history:
  - Total amount committed to C.A.R. during 1998–2012: SDR 160.8 million.
  - Disbursements amounted to SDR 101.1 million.
  - The 2012 ECF arrangement (amount SDR 41.78 million) veered irretrievably off-track before the completion of the first review due to the 2012–13 conflict.

### Economic and humanitarian impact (key statistics and outcomes)
- Real GDP contracted by 36 percent in 2013.
- Exports fell by 44 percent and imports fell by 27 percent (in dollar terms).
- Current account deficit widened to over 10 percent of GDP in 2013 from nearly 6 percent in 2012.
- Consumer price index rose by 6.6 percent in 2013.
- Domestic primary deficit widened to almost 7 percent of GDP in 2013, compared with a surplus of 0.5 percent in 2012.
  - Fiscal revenue dropped by 63 percent.
  - Domestic primary spending fell by 22 percent.
- Government accumulated net domestic payments arrears equivalent to 2.3 percent of GDP, including 5 months of wages and salaries through end-February 2014.
- Grants dropped by 15 percent in 2013.
- Destruction of infrastructure and paralysis of public financial management and administration significantly worsened macroeconomic and social conditions.
- With financial assistance from CEMAC countries, the new transitional government paid 2 months of salaries and 3 months of pensions in March/April 2014.
- At the January 20, 2014 meeting in Brussels, pledges amounting to about US$500 million in assistance to C.A.R. were made.

### Main policy recommendations
- Prepare the ground for the return of a normal budgetary process:
  - Limit spending executed under emergency procedures.
  - Reconnect the budget and accounting systems.
- Ensure transparency and accountability in the use of public resources:
  - Establish effective functioning of a Treasury Committee (CT) and a multi-partner Committee (CSGFP) to monitor and manage public finances to reduce fiduciary risks.
- Implement a prudent fiscal policy and restore fiscal discipline:
  - Strengthen revenue mobilization.
  - Better prioritize spending.
  - Improve cash flow management.
  - Gradually clear domestic arrears.
- In the medium term, foster inclusive growth and create employment opportunities:
  - Develop inclusive processes for conflict resolution.
  - Create fiscal space for social and other priority spending.
  - Improve the business environment.

### Mission and consultations
- Staff visited Yaoundé during February 20–27, 2014, and Douala during March 24–April 2, 2014.
- Staff team comprised Ekué Kpodar (head), Etienne Yèhoué, Abdelrahmi Bessaha, Gustavo Ramirez, and Michel Bua (resident representative) (all AFR). Abdoulaye Tall (OED) participated in the policy discussions during both missions.
- Staff had discussions with the Minister of Finance Rémy Yakoro and his technical team and worked closely with representatives of the World Bank, the African Development Bank, the European Union, and France.

*Source: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY, _cr14164 (May 1, 2014), International Monetary Fund.*

### 6. The new transitional government adopted an emergency plan to address the

### 6. The new transitional government adopted an emergency plan to address the

### Emergency plan and political roadmap
- The emergency plan seeks to: (i) restore security; (ii) improve humanitarian assistance; and (iii) return to democracy.
- The plan is expected to set the basis for long-lasting stability based on the roadmap adopted by the international community and monitored by the International Contact Group (ICG) for C.A.R.
- Transparent and credible presidential elections are expected in the first half of 2015 to lay the basis for the consolidation of democratic institutions (MEFP, paragraph 3).

### Request for IMF assistance and financing envelope
- Authorities request financial assistance under the IMF’s RCF.
- In the attached Letter of Intent (LOI), they informed the IMF of their decision to cancel the ECF arrangement with immediate effect and request the disbursement of SDR 8.355 million under the RCF (equivalent to 15 percent of quota, or US$12.9 million), to meet the urgent balance of payments needs in 2014.
- A second RCF of SDR 5.570 million (10 percent of quota or US$ 8.5 million) could follow before the end of the year conditional upon the presence of continued urgent balance of payments needs and satisfactory performance under this RCF.
- The authorities are also seeking grants and concessional financing from multilateral and bilateral partners and neighboring countries to cover the remaining financing needs (paragraph 12).

### Macroeconomic outlook and risks
- Main objectives for 2014:
  - reach a real GDP growth rate of 1.5 percent;
  - bring down inflation to about 4.4 percent, from 6.6 percent in 2013;
  - contain the domestic primary deficit to 7.6 percent, against 6.8 percent last year;
  - maintain the current account deficit at 14.1 percent of GDP.
- Macroeconomic objectives for 2015:
  - reach a real GDP growth rate of 5.3 percent;
  - reduce inflation to around 4 percent;
  - contain the external current account deficit at about 13 percent of GDP;
  - contain the domestic primary deficit at around 3 percent of GDP.
- Downside risks:
  - security conditions remain difficult and unpredictable;
  - potential tensions associated with presidential elections in the first half of 2015;
  - weak implementation capacity and possible delay in the provision of technical assistance (TA);
  - delay in providing pledged financing.
- Upside factor:
  - United Nations approval of the deployment of 12,000 peacekeepers to protect civilians and facilitate humanitarian access.

### Implementing fiscal policy to restore stability and revive growth
- Transitional authorities’ objectives in the RCF-supported program:
  - prepare the ground for the return of a normal budgetary process;
  - restore revenue mobilization capacity and rationalize and enhance monitoring of cash flow management;
  - conduct an immediate cleanup of the database of civil servants payroll (with support from the World Bank and UNDP);
  - clear domestic arrears;
  - ensure transparency regarding the use of public resources;
  - revisit taxation from oil, gold, diamonds, telecommunications, and forestry activities with TA from the IMF and development partners.

### Fiscal policy and reforms (detailed)
- Fiscal policy will aim at containing the domestic primary deficit through stepped-up revenue efforts and better prioritization and control of spending.
- Budget targets:
  - increase in revenue by 0.7 percentage point of GDP;
  - wage bill kept constant at 7.1 percent of GDP through a staff rationalization plan;
  - a 1 percentage point of GDP increase in transfers and subsidies;
  - current primary spending projected to rise to 13.3 percent of GDP, up from 12.4 percent of GDP the previous year;
  - domestically-financed capital spending projected at 0.7 percent of GDP;
  - domestic primary deficit projected at 7.6 percent of GDP, against 6.8 percent in 2013.
- Financing gap:
  - projected at CFAF 81 billion or 10 percent of GDP;
  - to be covered by grants from the World Bank (CFAF 12.8 billion), African Development Bank (CFAF 9.4 billion), EU (CFAF 19.7 billion), France (CFAF 7.9 billion), Angola (CFAF 4.7 billion), CEMAC countries (CFAF 20 billion), and IMF financing.
- Box 2 summary (pledges and disbursements):
  - Total support pledged during the Brussels Conference and support from countries belonging to the ECCAS amounted to US$572 million, including humanitarian aid (US$203 million), development aid (US$192 million), and budget support for 2014 for an amount of US$177 million.
  - Disbursement of budgetary aid through end-April 2014 amounted to about US$44 million, including Angola (US$10 million grant) and ECCAS (equivalent to US$34 million).
  - A loan agreement on concessional terms was signed with Angola for an amount of US$20 million to fund security-related spending.
  - These resources were used mainly to pay 2 months of salaries and 3 months of pensions.

### Revenue mobilization, arrears clearance, and transparency measures
- Revenue measures:
  - increase tax revenue collection through thorough reviews of taxpayer statements, enhanced controls of VAT, and limits on tax and customs exemptions to those allowed by law (MEFP, paragraph 9).
  - take control of the customs chain along the main import corridor with support from international forces;
  - keep in operation the Douala (Cameroon) one-stop customs shop for imported goods;
  - strengthen customs controls.
- Public administration measures:
  - rationalize the civil service roster with support from the World Bank and UNDP to eliminate “ghost civil servants”.
- Arrears:
  - authorities will clear all outstanding external arrears, which will help restore donor confidence;
  - settle domestic payments arrears equivalent to 2 percent of GDP, prioritizing salary arrears first, then pensions, and lastly commercial suppliers.
- Transparency and cash management measures:
  - enhance traceability of tax revenue flowing from commercial banks to the Treasury Single Account (TSA), including ceasing signing new debt conventions that would reduce government intake, enforcing those in place, posting tax agents in banks, and reconciling banks’ statements and TSA entries on a regular basis;
  - limit to 7 percent the volume of spending executed under the emergency mode;
  - reconnect the integrated budget and accounting softwares (GESCO-Budget and GESCO-Comptabilité);
  - implement a cash management plan to better allocate available resources;
  - establish an institutional framework including: (i) the Treasury Committee (under the chairmanship of the Minister of Finance) to design and manage a weekly treasury plan; (ii) the Multi-Partners Committee (under the authority of the Prime Minister) to conduct quarterly reviews of public resource spending with donors; and (iii) the central treasury agency ACCT to improve treasury operations and ensure traceability of resources and spending.
- Appropriate TA is already underway to help complete these measures (paragraph 16 and Box 3).

### External debt situation
- Debt situation has deteriorated significantly mainly due to the collapse of output and exports.
- A new debt sustainability analysis (DSA) finds the risk of debt distress was changed from moderate to high.
- Emphasis on implementing a grant-financed emergency program and need for continued external assistance on concessional terms.

### Technical assistance needs and donor coordination
- Sizable TA is crucial to rebuild basic state functions and lay the ground for reconstruction.
- Immediate priorities for TA: restore tax and customs administration, public finance management, and treasury management.
- TA providers will include the IMF, World Bank, African Development Bank, EU, and France.
- Coordination roles:
  - IMF took the lead in coordinating TA needs and provision.
  - World Bank to provide TA on tax administration and customs, and together with UNDP on civil service rationalization.
  - EU will assign two resident experts in the treasury department (central unit ACCT and budget directorate); recruitment of the two experts is under way.
  - African Development Bank will hire experts to support reform coordination.
  - IMF will restart its own TA activities as soon as security conditions permit, notably in revenue administration and public financial management; alternatively, officials could meet IMF experts at AFRITAC-Center in Libreville if security conditions do not improve soon.
- Staff and donors will work on a TA matrix, programmatic procedures for government to avail itself of TA, and well-defined priorities.

### Program monitoring, access, and safeguards
- Access under this RCF is limited to 15 percent of quota equivalent to SDR 8.355 million to help cover urgent balance of payments needs.
- Progress under the RCF will be monitored through quarterly indicators and key structural benchmarks.
- Understandings reached on quantitative indicative targets for end-June, end-September and end-December 2014 (MEFP, Table I.1) and a limited number of structural benchmarks to rebuild core public financial management (MEFP, Table II.2).
- A second RCF amounting to 10 percent could follow within six to eight months conditional upon continued urgent balance of payments need and satisfactory performance under this RCF.
- C.A.R.’s capacity to repay the IMF remains adequate (Table 6), but risks to program implementation include security and political risks, weak implementation capacity, and possible delay in TA provision and financial assistance (paragraph 10).
- Safeguards: BEAC subject to a quadrennial assessment in 2013; risks remain elevated but progress noted. A safeguards staff visit to the BEAC was conducted from April 1–9, 2014; staff concluded BEAC has made good progress implementing recommendations though challenges on institutional autonomy and governance remain.

*Source: _cr14164 - 6. The new transitional government adopted an emergency plan to address the (PDF chapter/section).*

### 20. The transitional government is facing daunting challenges. Reversing the policy paralysis

### _cr14164 - 20. The transitional government is facing daunting challenges. Reversing the policy paralysis

### Major challenges and context
- Key objectives of the government emergency plan: reversing the policy paralysis of 2013, restoring security in the country, rebuilding basic state functions, engineering an economic revival, and preparing the 2015 presidential elections.
- Acute shortage of resources to implement the emergency plan.
- Slow restoration of security—“poised to improve after the arrival in September of the international peacekeepers”—could delay the return of refugees and internally displaced persons and slow economic recovery and growth.
- Rebuilding basic state functions expected to proceed slowly as expertise and equipments will likely be available only in the second half of the year.

### 2014 budget stance and fiscal priorities
- The 2014 budget “strikes a balance between the need for emergency services and the need to address the country basic social and infrastructure gaps.”
- Financing will come mainly from external support in form of grants and concessional loans.
- Staff view: the fiscal stance reflected in the first budget of C.A.R. post-conflict situation is appropriate and should lay the ground for macroeconomic stability.
- Important operational guidance:
  - Secure resources and use them appropriately for basic services.
  - Adhere to spending objectives and be ready to adjust them to available resources.

### Revenue mobilization and immediate priorities
- “Actions to enhancing revenue collection need to take immediate priority.”
- Authorities are focusing on rebuilding basic revenue administration systems and enhancing revenue collection.
- Key measures recommended by staff:
  - Better controls and limited exemptions during the rebuilding phase.
  - Better coordination with the banks that collect taxes.
  - Put in place other revenue-enhancing measures.
  - Move fast with the reactivation of the budget and accounting softwares.

### Reconstructing public financial management (PFM)
- “Reconstructing PFM is crucial.”
- Staff welcomes measures to establish swiftly treasury and cash management capacity.
- A recently created central treasury agency is expected to be made operational in the second half of the year with development partner help.
- Expected benefits: framework for better cash management and adequate accounting operations.
- Staff urges close cooperation with the donor community to complete this operation in a timely fashion.

### Role of development partners
- Financing needs will remain large in the years ahead to revive the economy and rebuild basic state functions.
- Development partners are reengaging and seek a comprehensive macroeconomic framework and productive use of their support.
- Authorities established a joint committee to monitor the overall use of public resources; staff “urges the authorities to make this committee operational by early May.”
- IMF stands ready to help catalyze support.

### Risks to the program
- Downside risks:
  - Slow restoration of security and delays in technical assistance (TA) provision could weaken the rebuilding of state functions and further slow reconstruction and economic revival.
- Upside factors:
  - The upcoming international force is expected to improve security and delivery of humanitarian aid.
  - The new government’s strong resolve to rebuild basic state functions, restore PFM, and enhance transparency in the use of public resources is welcome.

### IMF support recommendation and outlook
- Staff supports the authorities’ request for assistance under the RCF given:
  - Currently limited capacity to implement policies of an upper credit tranche-quality economic program.
  - Large and urgent balance of payments needs.
  - Catalytic effect of IMF support on other external assistance.
- If implemented successfully, the program could be used as a stepping stone for a future arrangement to assist authorities address medium-term challenges.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt (Central African Republic).*

### Appendix I. Letter of Intent

### Appendix I. Letter of Intent

### Context and program decision
- On June 25, 2012, the Executive Board approved a three-year arrangement under the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) in the amount of SDR 41.78 million.
- Since December 2012 and especially as of March 24, 2013, C.A.R. experienced a severe multifaceted crisis (political, security, social, humanitarian, and economic) that led to:
  - mass displacement of 1 million people, a quarter of the population of C.A.R.;
  - widespread insecurity, looting, and paralysis of government operations and economic infrastructure.
- As a result of these shocks, the authorities decided to cancel the ECF-supported program with immediate effect and requested:
  - a disbursement of SDR 8.355 million under the Rapid Credit Facility (RCF) upon Board approval to meet urgent 2014 balance of payments needs; and
  - a second RCF of SDR 5,570 million to be requested before the end of the year, conditional upon continued balance of payments needs and satisfactory implementation of the needs this RCF.
- The transitional government submitted a Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies (MEFP) and authorized publication of the IMF staff report, the MEFP, the TMU, and the debt sustainability analysis once the Executive Board approves the RCF.

### Recent economic and financial developments (2013) — key outcomes
- Real GDP: decline of 36 percent in real terms.
- Exports: slumped 44 percent in dollar terms.
- Imports: down 27.1 percent in dollar terms.
- Grants: fell 15 percent.
- Current account (balance of payments) deficit: increased from 5.6 percent of GDP in 2012 to 10.4 percent of GDP in 2013.
- Tax revenues: dropped 63.5 percent.
- Current primary expenditure: down 10 percent (due largely to higher security spending).
- Domestic primary balance: deficit of 6.8 percent of GDP in 2013 compared to a surplus of 0.5 percent in 2012.
- Accumulation of domestic payment arrears: 2.3 percent of GDP (including 5 months of wages and salaries at end February 2014).
- Consumer price index: averaged 6.6 percent in 2013 (twice the inflation rate over the four years preceding the conflict).
- Agricultural sector: accounts for close to half of GDP and employs up to 80 percent of the workforce; the subsistence component was severely damaged, threatening to plunge a quarter of the population into a food crisis in 2014.

### Performance under the ECF-supported program
- The ECF-supported program was derailed by the crisis beginning March 2013; discussions/papers for the first review were finalized but could not be considered by the Executive Board because of the events that shook the country.
- Continuation of the program was hampered by the worsening crisis, especially in late 2013.

### Program for 2014 — macroeconomic outlook
- The transitional government adopted the Emergency Program for Sustainable Recovery (PURD-RCA) for 2014–16, aligned with the Revised Transition Roadmap and ECCAS guidelines.
- Macroeconomic projections for 2014:
  - Real GDP growth: 1.5 percent (driven by the opening of the cotton ginning plant in Bossangoa, lifting of the embargo on diamond exports, and return of government operations).
  - Consumer price index: increase of 4.4 percent on average (compared to 6.6 percent in 2013).
  - Primary deficit: projected to reach 7.6 percent of GDP (compared to 6.8 percent in 2013).
  - Balance of payments current account deficit: projected to be capped at 14.1 percent of GDP.

### Emergency public finance program — priorities and measures for 2014
- Core priorities:
  - improve tax revenue performance;
  - secure revenues;
  - enhance cash flow management and monitoring to ensure greater control over revenue and expenditure;
  - establish the Central Accounting Agency of the Treasury (Agence Comptable Centrale du Trésor – ACCT) as the key institution to manage cash flow and ensure audit trails.
- Fiscal context and challenges:
  - Tax revenue rate: 5.2 percent of GDP in 2013 (C.A.R. ranked lowest in the world in 2013 in terms of tax revenue collection).
  - Causes of low tax revenue: looting and disruption of revenue entities; loss of control over clearance processes; difficulty for the Directorate General of Taxation to monitor returns; damage to economic operators.
- Specific measures for central revenue structures:
  - Directorate General of Taxes and Government Property:
    - remove from the 2014 draft budget all references to post-conflict special investment incentives pending evaluation by the IMF Fiscal Affairs Department;
    - strengthen monitoring of filing of returns by taxpayers;
    - improve control over taxes on flows, particularly the VAT, focusing fiscal control operations on VAT;
    - limit exemptions strictly within the framework of the Law.
  - Directorate General of Customs and Domestic Tariffs:
    - regain control of the customs clearance process with support of international forces throughout the country;
    - maintain the single customs clearance window (guichet unique) in Douala for goods transiting through Cameroon by regularly rotating staff;
    - step up post-clearance audits and actions to combat fraud;
    - implement stricter monitoring of exemptions by increasing controls of destinations.
  - Safeguarding tax revenue and TSA traceability:
    - implement recommendations from two technical assistance reports on improved cash flow management (financed by the European Union);
    - not sign any new agreements relating to debt, debt buybacks, or securitization with commercial banks;
    - review all existing agreements binding the government and commercial banks and identify in accounting entries claims already posted in the system;
    - improve monitoring of taxes paid by placing personnel inside banks to track, in close detail and for each taxpayer, taxes paid to reconcile them with revenue paid back into the Treasury Single Account (TSA) pending implementation of the GESCO taxation software;
    - regularly monitor reconciliations among agencies, commercial banks, and the Treasury.
- Cash flow planning and oversight:
  - More than two thirds of revenue required for execution of the 2014 budget will come from external financing: CFAF 80.9 billion out of a total of CFAF 107.8 billion in current primary expenditure.
  - Two committees created:
    - Treasury Committee (Comité de trésorerie – CT): set priorities and monitor cash flow management monthly.
    - PFM and Oversight Committee (Comité de suivi et de gestion des finances publiques – CSGFP): monitor use of public resources and implementation of the cash flow plan quarterly or more frequently as needed.
  - Adoption of legislation establishing the CT and the CSGFP and effective implementation are prerequisites to submission of the IMF staff report to the IMF Executive Board.
  - The transitional government developed and signed a cash flow plan for all of 2014, stating monthly revenue and expenditure targets in order of priority; the plan will track resources received and disbursements on a cash basis and provide detailed statements to enable reconciliation with flows posted in the TSA at the BEAC.
- Central Accounting Agency of the Treasury (ACCT):
  - ACCT was officially created on December 30, 2012, but not yet operational.
  - Purpose: provide autonomy and better coverage for cash flow management and government accountability, centralize and oversee government cash flow, and monitor/consolidate accounting operations.
  - Structural benchmark: recruit a Central Accounting Officer of the Treasury and his deputy by end September 2014 (one of three structural benchmarks for monitoring the RCF).
- Civil service and payroll management reforms:
  - Commit to modernize government personnel and wage management; update government personnel roster (including defense and security forces) to streamline the civil servant payroll roster.
  - Structural benchmark: initial clean-up of the roster and a report to the IMF by end-June 2014 (end-June structural benchmark) to enable payments to civil servants in accordance with regulations; attendance certificates to be checked and certified by a joint committee.
  - After roster clean-up, staff not in good standing may justify their situation; contentious cases to be examined by appropriate civil service officials.
  - Plan to secure databases, implement procedures for managing civil servant positions and careers (from payroll to retirement), create an interface to link to the PFM system, and ensure strict management of recruitment for priority sectors by end-2014 with partner support.
  - Authorities will clarify the situation of non-statutory staff (Hors Statuts) and aim to attract qualified talent, including from the diaspora.
  - Concern: prior mass hiring of non-statutory staff increased workforce in a way inconsistent with expenditure control objectives.

_Appendix I. Letter of Intent (Bangui, May 1, 2014)_

### 14.      A technical assistance (TA) program will help the authorities complete the emergency plan.

### 14.      A technical assistance (TA) program will help the authorities complete the emergency plan.

### Technical assistance (TA) program: scope and providers
- Authorities solicited partners to mobilize short- and medium-term TA so that the emergency plan could be completed in the various areas concerned.
- Most assistance has already been identified and the dates set.
- Two long term TA providers will be made available during the second half of the year by the European Union for the ACCT and Directorate General of Budget, respectively, to support implementation of the ACCT and the return to fiscal discipline.
- The World Bank intends to lend to the transitional authorities two TA providers for customs and tax revenue collection agencies, respectively, and will provide other technical support to the Directorate General of Civil Service.
- Planned short-term TA missions: World Bank, European Union, French development agency (Coopération française), and the AfDB.
- AfDB agreed with the authorities on a restructuring of the institutional support project on public finances (Project to Build Economic and Financial Management Capacity (PARGEF in French)) to provide urgent assistance to financial administrations.
- Monthly updates will be provided to assess TA implementation and progress toward set objectives.

### 2015 Fiscal Program milestones and macroeconomic projections
- 2015 budget year characterized as transitional, aiming to stabilize public finances and restore normalcy.
- Economic growth: expected to continue to edge up progressively to about at least 5 percent in real terms, likely driven by agriculture and services.
- Inflation: expected to be further contained at around 4 percent.
- Government finance:
  - Domestic revenue expected to reach 12.6 percent of GDP.
  - Current primary expenditure expected to drop to 11.2 percent of GDP.
  - Domestically financed capital spending expected to rise by 0.2 percentage point of GDP compared to 2014.
  - Domestic primary deficit expected to decline from 7.6 percent of GDP in 2014 to 3.2 percent of GDP.
  - Financing gap of CFAF 56.4 billion, equivalent to 6.4 percent of GDP.

### Medium-term reforms and return to fiscal discipline
- Transitional government objectives:
  - Reinstate normal budget procedures as soon as possible.
  - Limit to 7 percent the amount of expenditure executed by way of the exceptional procedure (budgetary payment order). Such spending includes missions, transportation, health-related evacuations, student travel, repatriations of diplomats and mortal remains.
- Reconnection of systems:
  - Reconnect GESCO-Budget and GESCO-comptabilité during the second half of the year.
  - Undertaking, with partner support, to have them back up by end-September 2014 (structural benchmark).
- Petroleum sector:
  - Conditions for collecting petroleum taxes to be redefined.
  - Transitional government will seek support from partners to entrust an international audit firm with reconstructing all cross-debt between the government and petroleum sector operators.
  - IMF TA available to revise the petroleum product price structure.
- Revenues from specific sectors:
  - Collection of fiscal revenue review required for gold, diamonds, mobile telephony, and forestry products.
  - Commitment to produce, starting in January 2014, a monthly detailed statistical overview of all tax and nontax revenues received for these sectors.

### Social component (budget allocations and focus)
- From 2014, social sectors are a top priority.
- Budget provides for CFAF 43 billion, including CFAF 6.5 billion in current expenditure.
- Health: CFAF 26 billion total, including CFAF 4 billion for current expenditure to combat malaria, strengthen the Expanded Program on Immunization (EPI), expand prevention of parent-to-child transmission (PPTCT), and provide overall services to people living with HIV (PLHIV).
- Education: appropriations for current expenditure and capital amount to CFAF 3.9 billion; focus on capacity building in preschool education, basic education 1, basic education 2, secondary education, and technical and vocational training.
- Water and sanitation: CFAF 12.9 billion, including CFAF 2 billion for current expenditure to enhance national management and planning capabilities, and to build and rehabilitate drinking water supply and sanitation structures.
- Support to vulnerable groups, particularly women and children, for community development is programmed.

### Other structural reforms (private sector, governance)
- Immediate measures:
  - Joint evaluation of damages sustained by public and private enterprises and support measures for affected entities.
  - Facilitate return of displaced individuals, notably traders and farmers.
  - Revitalize the joint committee for improving the business climate and the permanent framework for government-private sector cooperation.
- Medium-term reforms include:
  - Lowering the cost of credit and providing access to financing.
  - Strengthening the judicial governance framework.
  - Revising the investment charter.
  - Building capacities of consular chambers.
- Governance:
  - Consider issuing implementing decrees to give legal standing to the National Authority for Combating Corruption (Autorité Nationale de Lutte contre la Corruption – ANLC).
  - Together with donors, mobilize human and physical resources to jumpstart ANLC operations by the end of the year.

### Sustainable debt policy
- IMF/World Bank EDS analysis: external debt situation deteriorated considerably due to political crisis, collapse of economic activity, significant drop in exports, slow recovery, and loans contracted during the crisis to cover wages and financing needs.
- Worsening of external debt-to-export and debt service to export ratios exposes the country to a high risk of debt distress, including in the baseline scenario.
- Turnaround possible if economic growth, exports, and foreign direct investment resume; these ratios would return to sustainable levels.
- Transitional government commitment: meet the bulk of financing needs through grants and the rest through concessional loans with a grant element of at least 35 percent (continuous benchmark, Table 1).

### Program monitoring, indicators, and benchmarks
- Program monitored using quantitative indicators and structural benchmarks at June 30, September 30, and December 31, 2014.
- Indicators and benchmarks defined in the Technical Memorandum of Understanding (TMU), which sets nature and frequency of data to be provided.
- Institutional framework:
  - Interministerial Steering Committee on Economic and Financial Reforms (CIPREF), headed by the Prime Minister, is the political body for reform strategy and direction.
  - Technical monitoring overseen by the Minister of Budget, supported by CS-REF (Cellule de Suivi des Reformes Economiques et Financières) and the PRSP National Technical Secretariat (Secrétariat Technique National du DRSP).

### Indicative targets and TMU assumptions (selected figures)
- Table I.1. indicative targets (cumulative from beginning of the year), End-Dec. 2014: Floor on total domestic government revenue and Floor on domestic primary fiscal balance shown in CFAF billion in the source tables.
- Program exchange rates (TMU):
  - CFAF/US$ 475.00
  - CFAF/euro 655.96
  - CFAF/SDR 732.43
- Oil price assumption: average price per barrel of oil of US$104.17 for 2014.
- Definitions retained in the TMU:
  - Government refers to central government of C.A.R., excluding local governments, the central bank, or public entities with separate legal personality not included in the TOFE.
  - Debt definition follows point 9 of Decision No. 6230-(79/140), as amended by decision No. 14416-(09/91).
  - Guaranteed debt defined as an explicit legal obligation by the government to service a debt in the event of nonpayment.
  - Concessional debt: grant element at least 35 percent, NPV calculated with a 5 percent discount rate.
- Floors and ceilings:
  - Domestic revenue and domestic primary balance and other targets and continuous monitoring items specified in the TMU and Table I.1.

*Source: IMF staff report text as provided in the chapter titled "14.      A technical assistance (TA) program will help the authorities complete the emergency plan."*

### 10. Net domestic financing of the government is defined as the sum of: (i) the net government

### _cr14164 - 10. Net domestic financing of the government is defined as the sum of: (i) the net government

### Definition of net domestic financing and net government position
- Net domestic financing of the government is the sum of:
  - (i) the net government position vis-à-vis the banking system as defined below;
  - (ii) the amount of issues of government securities (net of redemptions) subscribed by individuals or legal entities outside the banking system or nonresident banks domiciled in the CEMAC; and
  - (iii) privatization proceeds or exceptional revenue recorded “above the line.”
- The net government position is defined as the balance between the debts and claims of the government vis-à-vis the central bank and commercial banks. The scope follows the Bank of Central African States (BEAC) practice and is broader than the TMU paragraph 4 definition, including local governments and some projects and administrative public entities.
- Government claims include the CFA franc cash balance, postal checking accounts, customs duty bills, and all deposits with the BEAC and commercial banks of public entities except industrial or commercial public entities (EPICs) and government corporations, which are excluded. Government debt to the banking system includes all debts vis-à-vis these same financial institutions.

### Policy commitments on new borrowing and arrears
- No non-concessional loans will be contracted or guaranteed by the government. During program reviews (after approval by the Executive Board of the IMF), changes may be made to the ceiling for specific investment projects if:
  - the projects’ financial viability and profitability have been evaluated and approved by the World Bank or the African Development Bank; and
  - the loan does not significantly exacerbate debt vulnerabilities according to the joint World Bank–IMF debt sustainability analysis.
- Non-accumulation of new external payment arrears:
  - External payment arrears are payments in respect of external debt of the government or guaranteed by the government that are due and not paid at contract maturity.
  - The government undertakes not to accumulate external payment arrears except for arrears relating to debt that is the subject of renegotiation or rescheduling. This performance criterion applies on a continuous basis.
- Non-accumulation of new domestic payment arrears:
  - The government undertakes not to accumulate domestic payment arrears as defined in paragraph 17. This applies on a continuous basis.

### Prior actions and indicative benchmarks
- Prior actions:
  - Adoption of the decree establishing effectively the Treasury Committee (TC) and communication of the minutes of the first meeting validating and approving the annual cash flow plan. The TC will monitor implementation of the annual cash flow plan, which should incorporate all monthly cash revenue and expenditure.
  - Signing of the decree establishing the Committee to Monitor and Manage Public Finance and communication of the minutes of the first meeting to staff. The committee plans and monitors use of public resources in coordination with technical and financial partners.
  - Adoption by the transitional government of the draft budget 2014 and its submission to the National Transitional Council.
- Indicative benchmarks:
  - Completion of the first stage of payroll clearance for civil servants: identify civil servants per existing rules; certificate-of-attendance holders to be tested and certified by an ad hoc committee; contested cases reviewed by public services.
  - Reconnection of the IT applications GESCO-budget and GESCO-accounting to enable reconciliation of budgetary and accounting information and limit use of exceptional budgetary procedures (OP - Cash and OP - Budget). During the fiscal year, the use of exceptional budgetary procedures should not exceed 7 percent of total expenditure, excluding salaries and financial costs.
  - Recruitment of the Central Treasury Accountant and his deputy: the Central Accounting Agency of the Treasury is set up to centralize the treasury and ensure compliance; benchmark complete when recruitment finalized.

### Data reporting to the IMF (Table III.1 deadlines)
- Quarterly report assessing the quantitative indicators and structural measures (Table 1.2. of the MEFP), along with supporting documentation: Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
- Monetary survey, monthly accounts of the central bank and commercial banks: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
- Table of monthly cash flow operations: Within ten days of the end of each month.
- Fiscal reporting table (TOFE): Within four weeks of the end of each month.
- Monthly total domestic payments arrears on goods and services and wages, including unpaid pensions and bonuses: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
- End-of-period stock of external debt: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
- Breakdown of expenditure included in the TOFE (goods and services, wages, interest, etc.): Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
- Summary table of real expenditure in the priority sectors, specifically health, education, and security: Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
- Breakdown of current and capital expenditure, both domestically- and externally-financed: Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
- Breakdown of revenue by institution and economic classification: Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
- Revenue and expenditure offset against each other without cash settlements (by type of expenditure and revenue): Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.
- Breakdown of debt service and external arrears, in particular by interest and principal and by main creditors: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
- Amount of new concessional and non-concessional external debt contracted or guaranteed by the government: Within four weeks of the end of each month.
- Actual disbursements for projects and programs benefiting from foreign financial aid and external debt relief granted by external creditors (including the date, amount, and creditor): Within four weeks of the end of each quarter.

### Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA) findings and macro assumptions
- DSA framework: Based on the joint IMF–World Bank debt sustainability framework for low-income countries (LIC DSA).
- Risk assessment:
  - Rating revised from "moderate" to "high risk of debt distress" due to a sharp decline in exports in 2013 resulting from the protracted political and security crisis.
  - The baseline present value (PV) of external debt-to-exports ratio breaches the policy-related threshold during 2013–19.
  - The baseline debt service-to-exports ratio breaches the threshold during 2014–16.
- Drivers and recommendations:
  - Main drivers of the revision: relatively moderate levels of highly concessional external debt combined with the collapse in output and exports.
  - C.A.R. is highly vulnerable to terms-of-trade shocks.
  - C.A.R. should maintain the minimum concessionality requirement for future borrowing.
  - C.A.R. needs to pursue prudent fiscal policies over the medium term while reconstruction and rebuilding of government institutions demand substantial financial resources, mostly from international development partners.
- Background and specific macro assumptions:
  - The protracted political and security crisis led to an output loss estimated at about 36 percent and a significant decline in exports in 2013.
  - The discount rate has been revised up to 5 percent.
  - Financing needs of the transitional government are assumed to be covered by highly concessional loans and grants.
  - Exports declined by about 44 percent in dollar value in 2013; exports are expected to return to a sustained growth trajectory in 2014–15.
  - The suspension of the Kimberly process is expected to be lifted sometime in late 2014 or early 2015.
  - Some natural resource exports are expected to start after 2020 with a positive impact on FDI.
  - Over the longer term, C.A.R. is expected to achieve steady-state growth of around 6 percent.
  - Real GDP growth is expected to rise above 5 percent over the next few years and reach around 6 percent by 2033.
  - The external current account deficit is expected to improve over time to around 2½ percent of GDP, financed initially by grants and highly concessional project loans, and issuance of some government securities.
  - Fiscal anchor: domestic primary balance (excludes grants and foreign-financed capital spending) requires significant effort; the primary balance including grants will initially be negative (2014) but will turn to a small surplus in the years after the crisis.

### Key statistics and data points (as reported)
- Total public debt, including domestic arrears, as of end-September 2013: 45.1 percent of GDP.
- External public and publicly-guaranteed debt as of September 2013: 27.2 percent of GDP.
  - Non-Paris Club bilateral creditors account for 85.8 percent of external public and publicly-guaranteed debt.
- Domestic public debt represents 18 percent of GDP, comprising:
  - outstanding credits to the government from domestic commercial banks: 6.7 percent of GDP;
  - government debt with the BEAC: 47.5 percent (share of domestic debt composition);
  - other creditors: 45.8 percent (share of domestic debt composition).
- Additional accumulation of domestic arrears in the last quarter of 2013 estimated to bring total public debt to 50.8 percent at end-2013 (an increase of 5.7 percent of GDP).
- Specific loans mentioned:
  - Loan from the Republic of Congo: CFAF 25 billion signed in June 2013 (considered domestic debt because the operation was made through the BEAC).
  - External loan from Angola: US$ 20 million scheduled for the second half of 2014.

*Prepared by the International Monetary Fund and the International Development Association, May 1, 2014.*

### Box 1. Central African Republic: Baseline Macroeconomic Assumptions

### Box 1. Central African Republic: Baseline Macroeconomic Assumptions

### Baseline macroeconomic assumptions and projections
- Real GDP growth:
  - Average annual real GDP growth for 2014–33 is projected at 5.9 percent.
  - Projection assumptions: expected resolution of the political and security crisis, return of displaced people, resumption of transfers from international donors.
  - Baseline excludes potentially higher growth from large scale exploitation of natural resources due to high uncertainty about reserves and timelines.
  - Sustained growth driven by increase in private investment (forestry, agriculture, mining, telecommunications) and increased public investment reaching about 8 percent of GDP per year in 2033.
  - Domestic transformation relies on continued security and political stability, structural transformation, reconstruction, and FDI inflows once democratic institutions and rule of law are reestablished.

- Inflation:
  - After unusually high inflation in 2013, the GDP deflator is projected at 2¼ percent on average for 2014–33.
  - Average CPI inflation in 2014 is expected to reach 4.5 percent and then decline towards the assumed 2 percent rate.
  - Projected CPI inflation is in line with the CEMAC convergence criterion of 3 percent.

- Current account balance:
  - Current account deficit (including grants) is projected to average 6 percent of GDP for 2014–33.
  - Trade balance expected to improve over time due to recovery of tradable sectors, better competitiveness, structural reforms, and infrastructure expansion; services balance deficits would remain large.
  - Financing of current account deficits is expected to come primarily from highly concessional official development assistance (project loans) and some FDI in natural resources.

- Government balance and public finances:
  - Domestic primary fiscal balance would improve to a surplus of 0.3 percent of GDP by 2018 and then remain around balance on average between 2019 and 2033.
  - Overall fiscal balance (including grants) would average about -¾ percent of GDP for 2014–33.
  - Domestic revenue projected to rise from about 11½ percent of GDP (2012) to 20 percent of GDP at end–2033.
  - Domestic primary expenditures projected to rise from about 11 percent of GDP in 2012 to 21 percent of GDP in 2033, with most increases concentrated in capital spending.

- External assistance and concessional financing:
  - After substantial increase in donor support in 2014 and 2015, grant-equivalent financing is assumed at about 5½ percent of GDP annually in the long run, accounting for 90 percent of total external assistance over 2016–33.
  - Grant element of new external loans expected to be at least 35 percent for the period.
  - Negotiations with non-Paris Club creditors expected to be concluded on similar terms as Paris Club creditors, resulting in clearance of existing external payment arrears.

- Domestic borrowing:
  - Government began issuing treasury bills in 2012; crisis led to rollovers with substantial interest costs.
  - Servicing an emergency loan from the Republic of Congo carries a steep cost in the first post-crisis years.
  - Some rebalancing needed to make domestic debt burden more sustainable.
  - In the long run, the average real interest rate on domestic currency debt should converge to about 3.

### External debt sustainability findings
- Under the baseline scenario:
  - PV of debt-to-exports and debt service-to-exports ratios are above thresholds in a protracted manner in the first years.
  - PV of debt-to-exports ratio exceeds the threshold for 2014 to 2019.
  - Debt service-to-exports ratio remained above the threshold from 2014 to 2017.
  - Ratios initially elevated mainly due to sharp decline in exports in 2013 and slow recovery, and by large outstanding debt with non-Paris Club creditors.
  - Debt service-to-revenue ratio starts above threshold in 2014 but returns to sustainable levels as government operations normalize and revenue mobilization improves.
  - All debt indicators show stable downward trends over the forecasted period.

- Key policy-based thresholds and baseline ratios (Text Table 2 excerpts):
  - Thresholds (weak policy performer):
    - PV of external debt in percent of GDP: 30.0
    - PV of external debt in percent of Exports: 100.0
    - PV of external debt in percent of Revenue: 200.0
    - External debt service in percent of Exports: 15.0
    - External debt service in percent of Revenue: 18.0
  - 2013 actuals and 2014–33 projections (simple average and projected peak where shown):
    - PV of external debt in percent of: GDP 16.1 (2013); 12.4 (2014–33 simple average); 19.1 (2014–33 projected peak)
    - PV of external debt in percent of: Exports 178.2 (2013); 88.7 (2014–33 simple average); 225.8 (2014–33 projected peak)
    - PV of external debt in percent of: Revenue 282.9 (2013); 65.2 (2014–33 simple average); 296.9 (2014–33 projected peak)
    - External debt service in percent of: Exports 11.0 (2013); 1.7 (2014–33 simple average); 6.8 (2014–33 projected peak); 20.8 (projected peak shown)
    - External debt service in percent of: Revenue 18.0 (2013); 18.5 (2014–33 simple average); 4.6 (2014–33 projected peak); 18.5 (projected peak shown)

- Vulnerabilities and risks:
  - Volatility in the dollar vis-à-vis the euro increases vulnerability to exchange rate fluctuations and affects external demand for diamonds and wood.
  - Suspension of Kimberley certification and stagnation in timber exploitation severely damaged exports.
  - Non-traditional exports (gold and cotton) halted due to security problems, reducing foreign currency generation to service external debt.
  - Persistent negative shocks to exports could exacerbate debt distress risks.

### Stress tests, scenarios, and public debt dynamics
- Stress test outcomes:
  - Bound tests and extreme stress scenarios (exchange rate depreciation, exports shock) lower export values but do not produce an unsustainable path for main external debt indicators in the forecast period.
  - With exports representing only 9 percent of GDP in 2013, a one standard deviation shock on 2014 and 2015 exports would lead to a large and protracted breach of PV of debt-to-exports thresholds; however this scenario is considered highly unlikely given baseline already captures severe crisis impact.

- Public debt sustainability (baseline and alternatives):
  - Under baseline with lower program grants (1 percent of GDP over the long term) and highly concessional financing, domestic debt indicators expected to decline gradually.
  - Assumptions: government restores capacity for prudent fiscal policy, reduces primary deficit to a primary balance over long term, mobilizes higher domestic revenues, and maximizes low-cost financing.
  - PV of public debt-to-GDP ratio could decline by more than 36 percentage points, from 46 percent of GDP in 2011, and stabilize at close to 9.8 percent of GDP in the long run.
  - PV of public debt-to-revenue (including grants) could fall from 426 percent to 35 percent over the same period.

- Alternative adverse scenarios:
  - A negative shock affecting government revenues (low revenue mobilization) would increase primary deficits and keep PV of public debt-to-GDP ratio above the threshold for most of 2014–33.
  - A temporary growth decline—real GDP growth of 3.3 percentage points less than the 2015–16 growth in the baseline for two consecutive years—represents an extreme scenario; impacts include:
    - PV of debt-to-GDP ratio slightly above baseline by 2033.
    - PV of debt-to-revenue ratio would be 88 instead of 34 percent.
    - Debt service-to-revenue ratio would remain mostly unchanged.
  - Baseline is sensitive to growth assumptions; high growth standard deviation reflects historical volatility including an outlier related to the civil war in 2003.

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Secure high levels of new concessional loans to finance the fiscal gap generated by the crisis; high concessionality helps shield PV of debt-to-GDP from interest rate increases.
- Avoid high-cost emergency financing that could raise debt vulnerability.
- Prioritize government expenditure closely linked to available resources to guarantee medium- and long-term financial soundness.
- Support public finance management reforms and improve domestic revenue mobilization to avoid deterioration of debt ratios.
- Maximize low-cost financing and restore capacity for prudent fiscal policy to achieve a primary balance over the long term and reduce debt vulnerabilities.

*Source: Box 1. Central African Republic: Baseline Macroeconomic Assumptions (excerpts).*

### 17.      C.A.R. has a high risk of debt distress, and high loan concessionality is required. The reversal

### 17. C.A.R. has a high risk of debt distress, and high loan concessionality is required.

### Risk assessment and fiscal vulnerability
- C.A.R. is under "high risk of debt distress."
- The reversal of improvements achieved after the 2009 HIPC completion point and MDRI debt relief highlights vulnerability to large shocks in output and exports and associated collapse in fiscal revenues.
- Accumulation of large domestic payments arrears exposed government difficulties covering primary current expenses.
- Public debt is sensitive to slower GDP growth and increases in debt-creating flows, confirming the need to pursue prudent fiscal policies over the medium-term.
- External debt indicators are particularly sensitive to export growth and terms-of-trade volatility.

### Policy priorities and development partner support
- Decisive support from development partners is needed to:
  - (i) fill the temporary financing needs of the transition government; and
  - (ii) contribute additional resources to restore democratic institutions and finance a long-term strategy to sustain economic growth, investment, employment creation, and better living standards.
- Such support needs to be provided without harming debt sustainability, making a "high degree of concessionality a priority for the medium-and long-run."
- Policies to preserve external debt sustainability include:
  - diversify and expand the export base;
  - improve the business climate for foreign direct investment;
  - reduce transport costs;
  - enhance productivity;
  - practice prudent borrowing.
- To consolidate the basis for growth C.A.R. needs to:
  - foster domestic security;
  - establish the basis for adequate private and public investment;
  - improve institutional and administrative capacity.

### IMF assistance under the Rapid Credit Facility (RCF)
- IMF Executive Board approved financial assistance under the RCF equivalent to SDR 8.355 million (about US$12.9 million) on May 14, 2014.
- The immediate disbursement of the full amount is equivalent to 15 percent of C.A.R.’s quota in the IMF.
- RCF features:
  - zero interest;
  - grace period of 5½ years;
  - final maturity of 10 years.
- The RCF provides rapid concessional financial assistance with limited conditionality to low-income countries with an urgent balance of payments need.
- The Executive Board noted cancellation of the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) arrangement approved on June 25, 2012 (Press Release No. 12/237).
- Renewal of financing under the RCF can be considered before year-end provided C.A.R. meets policy requirements for repeated use, including establishing a track record of adequate macroeconomic policies for a period of normally six-months prior to a new request.
- Timely provision of pledged financial and technical assistance is deemed crucial to sustain recovery momentum, strengthen government capacity, and exit the emergency situation.

### Program objectives and conditional actions (as stated)
- With IMF RCF support, transition authorities aim to:
  - restore macroeconomic stability;
  - rebuild basic state functions;
  - improve domestic revenue mobilization;
  - return to normal budgetary procedures;
  - clear domestic arrears;
  - ensure regular payments of salaries and pensions to civil servants;
  - improve transparent management of public resources including external support;
  - better prioritize spending and improve treasury management;
  - preserve debt sustainability.
- IMF will coordinate international efforts in providing financial support and technical assistance to rebuild key financial functions of government.

### Selected macroeconomic assumptions and key figures (baseline and recent observations preserved)
- Recent contraction: the economy contracted by 36 percent in the crisis year (referenced as -36.0 percent real GDP growth in tables).
- Key macroeconomic assumptions (as presented):
  - Real GDP growth (various entries): 3.0; 3.3; 4.1; 2.2; 3.3; -36.0; 1.5; 5.3; 5.7; 5.7; 5.8; -2.0; 6.1; 5.9; 6.3 (values as listed across years).
  - GDP deflator in US dollar terms (change in percent): -2.7; 7.0; -5.0; 6.5; 8.8; 10.7; 8.7; 6.4; 4.1; 3.8; 3.7; 6.2; 2.2; 1.5; 1.2.
  - Effective interest rate (percent) entries: 1.2; 1.3; 0.6; 1.1; 0.5; -0.3; -0.1; -0.1; 0.0; 0.0; 0.0; -0.1; 0.4; 0.1; 0.1.
  - Growth of exports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent): 11.4; 26.1; -3.6; 6.8; 15.5; -45.7; 3.2; 12.7; 9.5; 8.6; 9.1; -0.4; 10.4; 11.4; 20.4.
  - Growth of imports of G&S (US dollar terms, in percent): 14.3; 0.6; -4.4; 8.2; 12.1; -19.2; 18.4; 10.0; -24.8; 10.1; 5.9; 0.1; 10.5; 7.7; 14.0.
  - Grant element of new public sector borrowing (in percent): 55.3; 55.3; 52.2; 55.3; 55.3; 55.3; 54.8; 55.3; 55.3; 55.3 (entries as shown).
  - Government revenues (excluding grants, in percent of GDP) entries: 11.6; 10.8; 11.5; 5.7; 6.4; 18.9; 19.6; 20.2; 20.5; 27.0; 28.7; 28.6.
  - Aid flows (in Billions of US dollars): 0.1; 0.1; 0.1; 0.1; 0.2; 0.1; 0.1; 0.1; 0.1; 0.2; 0.3.
  - Grant-equivalent financing (in percent of GDP) entries: 4.6; 8.9; 5.3; 4.6; 4.5; 4.6; 5.2; 4.1; 5.0.
- Debt and financing indicators (selected, exact entries preserved where shown):
  - External debt (nominal) entries include: 19.8; 23.2; 24.6; 36.6; 43.3; 40.1; 36.3; 33.3; 31.0; 30.8.
  - PV of external debt entries shown: 10.8; 16.1; 19.1; 17.6; 15.7; 14.4; 13.4; 13.5; 8.2.
  - PV of debt-to-exports ratios shown: 91.7; 179.0; 226.6; 207.3; 185.9; 172.0; 161.4; 67.3; 23.0.
  - PV of PPG external debt-to-revenue (percent) entries: 93.9; 284.1; 297.9; 93.3; 80.1; 71.1; 65.6; 49.8; 28.7.
  - PPG debt service-to-exports ratio (in percent) entries: 11.7; 14.1; 19.0; 20.8; 14.7; 12.7; 3.5; 1.6 (as presented in tables).
  - Total gross financing need (Billions of U.S. dollars) entries: 0.1; 0.1; 0.0; 0.2; 0.3; 0.2; 0.1; 0.1; 0.1; 0.1; -0.1.
  - Nominal GDP (Billions of US dollars) entries: 2.0; 2.2; 2.2; 1.5; 1.7; 1.9; 2.1; 2.3; 2.5; 3.3; 7.5.
  - PV of public sector debt (selected entries): 33.7; 30.4; 44.2; 38.1; 31.6; 28.3; 25.6; 22.0; 10.9.
  - Public sector debt (in percent of GDP) entries: 44.2; 47.7; 47.5; 50.8; 68.4; 60.5; 52.2; 47.2; 43.2; 39.3; 18.8 (as listed across years).

### Sensitivity analysis and stress tests (high-level)
- External and public debt indicators were stress-tested under multiple scenarios:
  - Alternative scenarios (e.g., key variables at historical averages; new public sector loans on less favorable terms).
  - Bound tests (e.g., real GDP growth at historical average minus one standard deviation; export value growth shock; one-time 30 percent nominal depreciation).
- Tables and figures show that the "most extreme stress test" yields the highest ratios on or before 2023 for various indicators.
- Results indicate that adverse shocks (lower growth, export shocks, depreciation, less favorable loan terms) push debt indicators substantially higher, underscoring sensitivity to macroeconomic shocks and financing terms.
- Memorandum item: Grant element assumed on residual financing is presented as a series of entries "52" repeated (labelled 6/ in tables) for stress scenarios except A2.

### Implementation and governance emphasis
- The authorities’ emergency plan priorities (as stated by authorities):
  - i) restoring security;
  - ii) addressing the humanitarian crisis;
  - iii) restoring administrative capacity throughout the territory and holding elections;
  - iv) economic recovery and sound public financial management (PFM).
- Transparent management of public resources, better prioritization of spending, and improving treasury management are highlighted as critical for program success.

*Source: IMF staff report (Content unit: _cr14164 - 17. C.A.R. has a high risk of debt distress, and high loan concessionality is required.).*

### 2013. Exports declined by 44 percent, leading to a doubling of the balance of payments

### 2013. Exports declined by 44 percent, leading to a doubling of the balance of payments

### Macroeconomic impact (2013)
- Exports declined by 44 percent.
- Balance of payments deficit doubled and reached 10.4 percent of GDP in 2013.
- Inflation doubled, reflecting disruptions of supplies and agricultural activities.
- Public financial management (PFM) was severely impacted by destructions of government property and a difficult security environment for tax and customs agents.
- Revenues dropped sharply by 54 percent relative to their level in 2012.
- Payment arrears were accumulated.

### Request for Disbursement under the Rapid Credit Facility (RCF) and program objectives
- The authorities request a disbursement under the RCF in an amount equivalent to 8.3 million SDR (15 percent of quota).
- The RCF will support the authorities’ emergency economic program for the period 2014–16 by:
  - Helping meet urgent balance of payments needs.
  - Playing a catalytic role in mobilizing donors’ support.
  - Addressing the most pressing needs of the population, restoring stability, and laying the foundation for sound fiscal management framework and practices.

### Fiscal policy — priorities and actions
- Urgent priority: rebuild physical and human capacity needed to implement sound fiscal policies due to destruction of tax and customs agencies, treasury facilities, and the expenditure management system.
- Authorities request urgent technical assistance to restore fiscal controls and capacity to design and implement well calibrated fiscal policies.
- International community support now represents two thirds of the 2014 budget.
- Commitments:
  - Improve transparency in the management of public resources.
  - Normalize budget processes and strengthen fiscal controls to reassure donors that adequate safeguards are in place.
- Institutional measures:
  - Draft 2014 budget adopted along lines agreed with IMF staff and submitted to the provisional parliament.
  - Committee to Monitor and Manage Public finances installed; chaired by the Prime Minister and includes representatives of the donors’ community; vested with wide ranging powers to monitor and ensure domestic resources and external assistance are well managed.
  - Treasury committee installed and operational to improve cash management.
- Revenue measures:
  - Immediate goal to re-equip and resume operations of tax and customs agencies as security permits, with a focus on the corridor Douala-Bangui.
- Spending measures:
  - Ensure salary payments are resumed and that priority spending is executed in a timely fashion.
- Social provisions:
  - Provisions made to address urgent social needs in education, health services, water and sanitation.

### Debt sustainability
- Authorities are mindful of increased debt vulnerability following the collapse of exports and the crisis-related decline in economic activity.
- Debt sustainability indicators are expected to improve as the economy recovers and after the lifting of the diamond export ban.
- Financing strategy:
  - Seek financing preferably in the form of grants and concessional financing.
  - Make good faith efforts to reach out to creditors to seek forbearance and additional debt reduction or rescheduling.
- Authorities appreciate Executive Directors’ support in facilitating creditor engagement.

### Structural reforms
- Focus on rebuilding business confidence to resume economic activity.
- Planned actions:
  - Conduct an assessment of the damage sustained by private and state owned enterprises to provide assistance.
  - Facilitate the return of the displaced population to contribute to the resumption of commerce and farming activities.
  - Improve the climate for business, including strengthening the framework for government-private sector cooperation and capacity building of the consular chambers.

### Successor program and medium-term engagement
- Authorities are interested in a successor program with the IMF to support further economic stabilization and reconstruction and to catalyze donors’ assistance.
- Initial plan: request another RCF to face urgent external financing needs.
- Envision continued IMF engagement in the form of an Extended Credit Facility as capacity is built and the medium term poverty reduction and growth agenda is implemented.

### Conclusion and request to Executive Directors
- Authorities are determined to maintain prudent macroeconomic policies while responding to the sizable economic shock related to the civil conflict.
- They are taking proactive steps to address program risks, including security, food shortages, and capacity risks.
- A sustained and adequate support of the international community is needed for success.
- Based on urgent needs and the authorities’ commitment to sound policies (evidenced by implementation of all prior-actions agreed with staff), the request is for Executive Directors’ support for IMF assistance to C.A.R. under the RCF and through technical assistance.

*Source: _cr14164 - 2013. Exports declined by 44 percent, leading to a doubling of the balance of payments*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr14164.pdf_
