## _cr14205 — INTRODUCTION and Selected Findings

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr14205 — INTRODUCTION and Selected Findings](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr14205.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr14205.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr14205.pdf.json)

---

### Assessment scope and methodology
- Assessment conducted August 26 to September 13, 2013 as part of the FSAP by Ana Carvajal (MCM) and Malcolm Rodgers (External Expert).
- Based on the IOSCO Principles and Objectives of Securities Regulation (approved 2010) and its Methodology (adopted 2011).
- Principle 38 not assessed (covered under PFMI); issues related to central counterparties as SROs not covered.
- More critical approach applied with emphasis on:
  - extent to which regulations capture risks by different participants;
  - licensing processes, off-site monitoring, on-site inspection programs, and enforcement follow-up;
  - critical analysis of SROs where jurisdictions rely on them;
  - deeper analysis under Principles 6 and 7 to identify emerging and systemic risk.
- Evidence relied upon:
  - SFC self-assessment and market data report (with HKMA and FSTB);
  - laws, regulations, codes, guidelines, licensing/inspection/enforcement files;
  - meetings with SFC and HKMA leadership, FSTB, FRC, HKICPA, HKEx, banks, intermediaries, auditors, CRA and law firm.

### High-level findings (summary)
- HKSAR has a sound securities market regulatory framework exhibiting a high level of implementation of IOSCO Principles.
- SFC and HKMA are sophisticated regulators leveraging domestic and international expertise.
- Lehman minibond experience materially improved conduct supervision across SFC and HKMA.
- SFC capacity-building on emerging risks should increase ability to react to an evolving landscape marked by:
  - increased interconnection with the Mainland China;
  - an active presence by international players;
  - increased regional competition as an international finance center.

### Short-term regulatory and supervisory strengthening priorities
- Markets regulation and HKEx oversight:
  - HKEx evolving business model makes stronger SFC oversight critical.
  - Review governance of HKEx and composition of HKEx Risk Management Committee (RMC) to ensure arm’s length relationship between regulators and HKEx.
  - SFC should develop and publish a comprehensive regulatory framework for trading platforms of all kinds.
- Auditors’ oversight:
  - Challenges from listings by issuers from Mainland and other jurisdictions with diverse legal/governance/accounting frameworks.
  - Gaps identified:
    - framework does not ensure independence of HKICPA governance;
    - framework does not provide HKICPA powers to oversee foreign auditors who audit companies listed in HKSAR;
    - enforcement framework for auditors is not strong.
  - These gaps place pressure on SFC and HKSAR reputation for robust disclosure.
- Enforcement:
  - For conduct breaches not amounting to contravention of law enabling SFC to seek court remedial orders, SFC cannot impose both punitive action and secure client compensation without trade-offs.
  - Coordination with Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) can be boosted.
  - SFC and DoJ agree efficient and unreserved cooperation is conducive to justice; high-level meetings and steps to strengthen coordination have taken place.
  - Openness of HKSAR makes it highly dependent on international cooperation, particularly with the Mainland; practical challenges remain.

### Policy recommendation highlighted in the Introduction
- Consider translating operational (de facto) independence into de-jure independence through modifications in legal governance arrangements for both SFC and HKMA.

*Source: _cr14205 - INTRODUCTION*

---

### Market structure, activity and statistics (At April 2013 and related time series)

### Listed companies and market activity (At April 2013)
- Listed companies: Number = 1,558
  - Main Board = 1,378
  - Growth Enterprise Market (GEM) = 180
  - Market capitalization of GEM = 0.39 percent of total market capitalization
- Time series selected:
  - Listed companies (Number): 2009 = 1,319; 2010 = 1,413; 2011 = 1,496; 2012 = 1,547; At April 2013 = 1,558
  - Market capitalization (US$m): 2009 = 2,297,469; 2010 = 2,709,121; 2011 = 2,254,146; 2012 = 2,821,353; At April 2013 = 2,875,895
  - Market capitalization of top 10 companies (US$m): 2009 = 925,395; 2010 = 1,000,458; 2011 = 839,785; 2012 = 1,026,936; At April 2013 = 1,032,019
  - Annual turnover (HK$m): 2009 = 15,515,249; 2010 = 17,210,078; 2011 = 17,154,074; 2012 = 13,301,050; At April 2013 = 5,555,559
  - Average daily turnover (HK$m): 2009 = 62,310; 2010 = 69,117; 2011 = 69,732; 2012 = 53,850; At April 2013 = 70,324
  - New companies listed (Number): 2009 = 73; 2010 = 113; 2011 = 101; 2012 = 64; At April 2013 = 12
- Note: figures include transfers from GEM to Main Board.

### Issuers by country/region of origin (as at April 30, 2013)
- Total = 1,558 (100 percent)
- Mainland Enterprises: Number = 737; Percent = 47.3
  - H shares: 175 (11.2 percent)
  - Red Chip: 120 (7.7 percent)
  - Mainland Private Enterprises: 442 (28.4 percent)
- Hong Kong: Number = 722; Percent = 46.3
- Others: Number = 99; Percent = 6.4

### Bond market and corporate bonds (At April 2013)
- All Debt Securities:
  - Companies with outstanding issues (Number): 2009 = 157; 2010 = 169; 2011 = 192; 2012 = 269; At Apr 2013 = 319
  - Outstanding volume (US$m): 2009 = 50,374; 2010 = 62,779; 2011 = 75,691; 2012 = 113,597; At Apr 2013 = 134,163
  - New issuing companies (Number): 2009 = 23; 2010 = 38; 2011 = 50; 2012 = 109; At Apr 2013 = 61
- Corporate Bonds (excludes bank/state/supranational issues):
  - Companies with outstanding issue (Number): 2009 = 48; 2010 = 58; 2011 = 78; 2012 = 134; At Apr 2013 = 179
  - Outstanding volume (US$m): 2009 = 18,685; 2010 = 27,793; 2011 = 36,728; 2012 = 65,500; At Apr 2013 = 85,675
  - Annual turnover (HK$mil): 2009 = 0.00; 2010 = 0.00; 2011 = 0.98; 2012 = 0.02; At Apr 2013 = 0.40
  - Number of new companies (Number): 2009 = 7; 2010 = 16; 2011 = 27; 2012 = 65; At Apr 2013 = 49

### Trading platforms, intermediaries and market share
- HKEx group has legal monopoly in operating a securities exchange in HKSAR and de facto monopoly in domestic exchange traded futures.
- Alternative trading venues:
  - 25 intermediaries (including 13 dark pool operators) permitted to operate an automated trading service (ATS).
  - Dark pool trading volume ≈ 2.5 percent of trading in listed securities (total).
  - 21 international exchanges and trading platforms authorized to provide trading services in HKSAR.
- Intermediaries (as of March 2013):
  - Licensed firms (including asset management): 1,905
  - Banks registered to conduct securities business: 117
  - Top 10 firms (Dec. 2012) accounted for 48 percent of total value of transactions in securities, and 59 percent of transactions in futures and options.
- Ownership breakdown of licensed corporations (March 31, 2013 = 1,905):
  - Domestic ownership (In percent): 2013 = 60
  - Foreign ownership (In percent): 2013 = 40
  - Affiliates of banks (in percent): 2013 = 10
  - Affiliates of insurance companies (in percent): 2013 = 2
  - Affiliates of other financial institutions (in percent): 2013 = 36
  - Others (in percent): 2013 = 52

### Funds and managers (as of March/Dec. 2012)
- Firms managing SFC authorized funds (as of March 2013): 316 firms
  - SFC licensed firms = 80; based in other jurisdictions = 236
  - Top 10 fund managers (Dec. 2012) accounted for 50.1 percent of total AUM of SFC-authorized funds.
- Collective Investment Schemes (as of March 2013):
  - Total funds authorized = 1,847
    - Hong Kong domiciled funds = 305 (17 percent)
    - Luxembourg-domiciled = 1,045 (57 percent)
    - Ireland-domiciled = 277 (15 percent)
    - Cayman-domiciled = 151 (8 percent)
    - UK-domiciled = 53 (3 percent)
- AUM of SFC Authorized Funds (Dec. 31, 2012 = 1,237,624 total):
  - Bond: 467,175 (37.75 percent)
  - Equity: 498,959 (40.32 percent)
  - Diversified: 45,726 (3.69 percent)
  - Money market: 83,609 (6.76 percent)
  - Index: 126,127 (10.19 percent)
  - Total AUM: Dec. 31, 2012 = 1,237,624

*Sources noted in unit: Stock Exchange of Hong Kong; Securities and Futures Commission; SFC materials.*

---

### Institutional structure, mandates, coordination and operational independence

### Institutional roles (key points)
- SFC:
  - Main authority for securities markets under the Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571).
  - Statutory body with board of 14 appointed by CEHK or Financial Secretary (FS) under delegated authority.
  - Funded from levies on market participants; budget must be approved by FS.
- HKMA:
  - Supervises banks' securities business under the Banking Ordinance (BO) and SFO.
  - Created Banking Conduct Department and Enforcement Department in 2010.
  - Superintendent structure; Monetary Authority (MA) appointed by FS; funded through the Exchange Fund.
  - Enforcement of securities law breaches by bank entities conducted by SFC; shared responsibilities for EOs and ReIs.
- HKEx:
  - Holds legal monopoly operating stock exchange; also operates the only futures exchange.
  - Two MoUs provide framework for HKEx regulatory functions and SFC oversight.
  - Under MoU on Listing, HKEx approves offering documents for equity/debt issuers and structured products with SFC power to object; SFC approves CIS and non listed structured products offering documents.
- Accounting, auditing and auditors’ oversight:
  - HKICPA sets accounting/auditing standards, admission criteria, ethical standards, and oversight including disciplinary actions.
  - FRC (established 2006, Cap. 588) has statutory powers to investigate reporting and auditing irregularities; governing body appointed by Government with majority lay members.
  - FRC currently funded equally by HKSAR Government, HKICPA, HKEx, and SFC.
  - Government intends to continue strengthening independence and oversight of auditors of listed entities.

### Coordination mechanisms
- Formal committees and arrangements:
  - Financial Stability Committee (FSC) — monitors functioning of financial markets; reports to FS.
  - Council of Financial Regulators (CFR) — cross-sector regulatory matters.
  - Securities and Futures Liaison Committee (SFLC) — forum for major policy initiatives.
  - Tripartite meetings between FSTB, SFC, HKEx; MoUs between SFC and HKMA and SFC and HKEx.
  - Regular technical-level contact among SFC, HKMA and HKEx.

### Operational independence, governance and accountability
- Assessors: both SFC and HKMA enjoy clear de facto operational independence but legislative features may threaten independence.
- SFC governance:
  - Chairman and non-executive directors appointed by CEHK; minimum of 8 Commission members; current composition 8 NEDs (including Chairman) and 6 EDs (including CEO).
  - CEHK reserve power to give written directions under section 11 of SFO (never invoked); direction must be in public interest, further SFC objectives, and CEHK must consult CEO of SFC.
  - CEHK power to remove Commission members (Section 13) exists but has not been used.
  - SFC budget approved by FS; SFC income for 2012-3 year budgeted at HK$1.170 billion; accumulated surpluses in excess of HK$7 billion.
- HKMA governance:
  - MA is public officer appointed by FS; section 10 of BO gives CEHK right to give directions to FS and MA.
  - EFAC advises FS on Exchange Fund; EFAC carries many board-like functions.
  - HKMA funding stable; legal protections for MA and staff analogous to SFC.

### Assessment on governance and independence
- Principle 2 — Assessment: Partly Implemented.
  - Reasons: features that are pressure points include CEHK direction powers, CEHK removal power over SFC board members without clear constraints, SFC/HKMA membership of HKEx RMC (possible conflict), part-time Commissioners' potential conflicts, and budget approval procedural elements.
  - Assessors note de facto independence, and that many concerns are mitigated in practice, but legislative clarifications and governance reforms recommended.

---

### Supervision, enforcement, investigation powers and key enforcement statistics

### Information-gathering and investigation powers
- Section 180 SFO: general power to obtain information and inspect business operations, books and records at any reasonable time (available to both SFC and HKMA).
- Section 181 SFO: require shareholders, holders, transactors, LCs or RIs to provide identity, transaction and holding details.
- Section 182 SFO: SFC may direct employees to conduct investigations where reasonable cause exists.
- Section 183 SFO: powers to compel regulated and unregulated persons to produce documents, attend interviews and provide statements; can apply to court for search warrants (section 191).
- Section 186 SFO: SFC can use investigatory powers to assist foreign regulators.
- SFC has real-time access to HKEx SMARTS system and market surveillance data.

### Enforcement powers, remedies and procedural avenues
- Criminal prosecutions:
  - SFC can initiate summary prosecutions (Magistrates’ Court); more serious indictable offences referred to DoJ/DPP.
  - Market misconduct penalties: summary conviction up to HK$1 million and 3 years’ imprisonment; conviction on indictment HK$10 million and 10 years’ imprisonment (section 303(1)).
- Market Misconduct Tribunal (MMT):
  - Independent quasi-judicial body; civil burden of proof; can make prohibition, cease and desist and disgorgement orders (not fines).
  - Institution of MMT proceedings bars criminal proceedings for same conduct (section 307).
- Civil proceedings:
  - SFC can apply for injunctive or remedial civil orders under section 213 (including freezing, rescission, ancillary orders).
  - Section 214 empowers remedies for unfair prejudice in listed companies.
- Administrative/disciplinary:
  - Sections 194 and 196 empower SFC to take disciplinary actions (revoke/suspend licence, impose fines up to HK$10 million or 3 times profit gained/loss avoided, reprimand).
  - SFC lacks power to impose disgorgement as part of disciplinary process or to directly require compensation via disciplinary route.
- Section 201(3) SFO:
  - Enables SFC to enter into enforceable agreements with LCs/RIs/individuals subject to disciplinary proceedings to secure outcomes not otherwise achievable, notably:
    - payment of compensation;
    - appointment of auditors for internal control review.
  - Use of section 201 agreements has required SFC to agree not to take formal disciplinary action to reach compensation agreements.

### Enforcement outcomes, activity volumes and trends (selected figures preserved)
- Referrals to Enforcement (from on-site/off-site):
  - 2008/2009: 19
  - 2009/2010: 34
  - 2010/2011: 27
  - 2011/2012: 22
  - 2012/2013: 29
- Number of investigations opened/completed by type (aggregate totals shown):
  - Total investigations opened: 2009-2010 = 230; 2010-2011 = 208; 2011-2012 = 234; 2012-2013 = 221
  - Total investigations completed: 2009-2010 = 184; 2010-2011 = 199; 2011-2012 = 168; 2012-2013 = 212
- Criminal prosecutions and convictions (selected aggregates):
  - SFC Magistrates’ Court prosecutions (Jan 2007 to Mar 2013): over 300 prosecutions; 50 involve more serious securities crimes; 21 imprisonment sentences among those 50 (16 < 6 months; 4 < 1 year; 1 between 1 and 2 years); immediate custodial sentences in 4 cases; suspended sentences in 17 cases.
- Administrative fines and recoveries (HK$):
  - Disciplinary fines: 2008-09: 63,648,652; 2009-10: 26,125,496; 2010-11: 21,438,800; 2011-12: 35,210,000; 2012-13: 83,500,000
  - Total fines and costs recovered: 2008-09: 80,941,278; 2009-10: 57,938,044; 2010-11: 23,991,136; 2011-12: 40,549,270; 2012-13: 114,453,411
- Civil remedies (section 213 and 214) — applications and orders granted (annual totals):
  - Applications total: 2008/09 = 17; 2009/10 = 37; 2010/11 = 13; 2011/12 = 18; 2012/13 = 16
  - Orders granted total: 2008/09 = 5; 2009/10 = 14; 2010/11 = 7; 2011/12 = 13; 2012/13 = 12
  - Example remedial outcome: Hontex case — around HK$1 billion returned to shareholders under section 213 court orders.
- Use of section 201 agreements for compensation:
  - From 2008 to 2011, compensation payments of around HK$10 billion were made to clients of distributors of Lehman related investment products.
  - Two separate 2012 cases: parties agreed to make compensation to clients of more than HK$85 million.

### Cross-border cooperation and constraints
- SFC empowered under section 378 to share information domestically and with foreign regulators (subject to secrecy safeguards and adequacy of foreign secrecy provisions).
- SFC handles foreign requests and can provide information without a dual illegality requirement.
- Practical enforcement challenges in relation to Mainland-based issuers/auditors arise from scale and cross-border evidence gathering; MoUs and cooperation with CSRC and Mainland exchanges exist and are used.

### Assessment highlights — inspection, surveillance, investigation and enforcement
- Principle 12 — Assessment: Broadly implemented.
  - Key considerations affecting effectiveness:
    1. Criminal enforcement effectiveness for serious market misconduct: public disagreement between SFC and former DPP over thresholds for prosecution; trend of fewer indictments in recent years noted; constructive engagement with current DPP underway.
    2. Practical limitation: SFC inability to concurrently secure disciplinary sanctions and client compensation via formal disciplinary route forces reliance on section 201 negotiated agreements that require SFC to forego formal disciplinary action to obtain compensation.
  - Recommendation: consider mechanisms that enable SFC to impose both remedial (compensation) and punitive disciplinary sanctions without forced trade-offs; consider granting HKMA fining powers over EOs and ReIs.

---

### Principles for exchanges, ATS, secondary markets and market integrity

### Exchanges, HKEx oversight and SRO issues (selected findings)
- HKEx has monopoly for stock exchange operations; other exchanges subject to SFC recognition.
- HKEx listing function: SEHK is front-line for listings; HKEx approves prospectuses for listed equity/debt/structured products with SFC veto power; SFC conducts oversight (approval of rules, meetings, periodic/ad-hoc reporting, on-site inspections of listing function).
- HKEx market function: robust real-time supervision; SFC conducts market surveillance to detect misconduct and plans first on-site inspection of HKEx market function in 2014.
- SFC and HKMA are members of HKEx RMC — assessors identified potential conflict as RMC membership contributes to HKEx board decision-making where SFC later must regulate; recommended SFC and HKMA should not be members of HKEx RMC to ensure arms’ length relationship.

### ATS framework and transparency
- ATS regime:
  - ATS can be authorized under Part III (recognized exchange companies) or licensed under Part V (Type 7 licence).
  - Current framework lacks formal public policy guidance to applicants on differences between types of trading platforms and applicable requirements.
  - 25 intermediaries operate ATS including 13 dark pools; dark pool volume ≈ 2.5 percent of trading in listed securities.
  - ATS that operate dark pools do not provide pre-trade transparency but must report trades to HKEx within 1 minute of execution; SFC oversight and reporting conditions vary across operators.
- Principle 33 — Establishment of trading systems: PI
  - Need for formal and transparent policy to guide applicants choosing between recognition as REC or authorization as Type III ATS; Type V ATS requirements evolved via licensing conditions but not fully in ATS Guidelines.
- Principle 34 — Ongoing regulatory supervision of exchanges and trading systems: BI
  - SFC oversight program of HKEx includes rule approvals, meetings and on-site inspections (listing function inspected regularly; market function inspection planned for 2014).
- Principle 35 — Transparency of trading: FI
  - HKEx rules require pre- and post-trade transparency; exchange participants must report off-exchange trades within 15 minutes.
  - ATS dark pools do not provide pre-trade transparency; ATS trades must be reported to HKEx within 1 minute.
  - Recommendation: criteria under which ATS dark pools are not required to provide pre-trade transparency should be kept under review, especially if off-market volumes increase.

### Market surveillance, manipulation detection and default risk
- Principle 36 — Detect and deter manipulation and unfair trading: FI
  - Market manipulation, insider trading and unfair trading prohibited under SFO; front running is misconduct under Code of Conduct.
  - SFC has robust automated market surveillance systems and dedicated team investigating alerts; enforcement faces cross-border and domestic coordination challenges.
- Principle 37 — Management of large exposures, default risk and market disruption: FI
  - Exchange participants subject to position reporting and position limits; exchanges can require reduction, close out or transfer positions for non-compliance.
  - Risk mechanisms: capital requirements for clearing participants, day and intraday margin, default fund.
  - Robust rules for short selling: prohibit naked short selling and require reporting of short positions.
  - Mandatory buy-in required for failed settlement; intermediary must pay a fine; minimal settlement failure rates reported (settlement efficiency 99.7-99.8 percent).

### Implementation grades summary (overall counts)
- Fully Implemented (FI) – 26
- Broadly Implemented (BI) – 8
- Partly Implemented (PI) – 3
- Not Implemented (NI) – 0
- Not Applicable (NA) – 1

### Selected recommended actions (verbatim where provided)
- Strengthen regulator independence and governance:
  - Consider limiting circumstances CEHK can give directions; articulate circumstances for CEHK removal of SFC Commission members; consider moving away from government appointees on HKEx board.
  - SFC and HKMA should not be members of HKEx’s RMC to ensure an arms’ length relationship.
- Enforcement and remediation:
  - Consider increasing maximum fines SFC can impose and provide mechanism to compensate investors usable alongside disciplinary process.
  - Consider providing HKMA with fining powers over EOs and ReIs.
- Exchanges and ATS:
  - SFC should publish comprehensive policy on recognition of exchange markets and authorization/licensing of trading platforms.
  - Proceed with regular on-site inspections of HKEx market functions.
  - Keep criteria for ATS dark pool pre-trade transparency under review.

*Source: Selected Principles and recommendations from assessment sections in content unit.*

---

### Principles for collective investment schemes, fund managers, valuation and related supervision

### Regulatory scope and authorization
- Operation and distribution of CIS are regulated activities requiring licence/registration.
- CIS managers licensed/registered by SFC subject to Fund Managers Code of Conduct and Unit Trust Code (UTC).
- Offering of CIS to public in HKSAR requires SFC authorization, even if authorized by foreign regulator (section 103 SFO).

### Prospectus, disclosure and reporting obligations
- Authorization requires a prospectus complying with Principles.
- Ongoing obligations: annual reports with audited financial statements, semiannual reports, disclosure of material events.
- KFS (Key Facts Statement) required (UTC 6.2A); offering documents must include specified items in UTC Appendix C and constitutive documents in Appendix D.
- Timing:
  - Annual reports: within four months of end of scheme's financial year (UTC 11.6).
  - Interim (6 monthly) reports: within two months of end of period.

### Valuation, pricing errors and winding up
- CIS must be valued on fair value basis; clear guidelines for pricing errors.
- If pricing error ≥ 0.5 percent of NAV per unit/share, trustee/custodian and SFC must be notified; individual investors compensated for losses over HK$100 unless trustee/custodian determines otherwise.
- Winding up carried out per constituent documents or with approval of general meeting; SFC can withdraw authorization (section 106(1)(a) SFO) if material application information was false/misleading.

### Hedge funds and HF managers
- HF managers subject to same licensing requirements as other managers.
- Retail HFs offered to public must meet UTC HF-specific requirements (e.g., minimum assets under management, investor minimum subscription levels, quarterly reporting).
- Inspections of hedge fund managers (yearly totals): 2008-2009 = 4; 2009-2010 = 28; 2010-2011 = 16; 2011-2012 = 23; 2012-2013 = 18.

### Supervision, inspections and statistics
- Ongoing supervision via off-site monitoring, on-site prudential visits, on-site inspections; SFC authorizes all offering documents (section 105 SFO).
- On-site inspections of fund managers — totals by year: 2008-2009 = 20; 2009-2010 = 74; 2010-2011 = 76; 2011-2012 = 61; 2012-2013 = 72.
- Pricing errors reported Jan 2008–Jul 2013: total 321 pricing errors reported to SFC; 285 related to SFC authorized funds constituted abroad.

### Assessment and enforcement
- Principle 24/25 — CIS principles: assessments in unit indicate strong regulatory framework; overall assessments for CIS responsibilities described as "Fully implemented."
- Sanctions: unauthorized offering (section 103 SFO) carries fine up to HK$500,000 or 3 years imprisonment.
- SFC uses administrative and criminal sanctions; examples include successful actions against overseas fund managers (e.g., Tiger Asia Management LLC).

*Source: IMF staff summary of SFC materials contained in the provided content unit.*

---

### Auditors, accounting standards, oversight and identified gaps

### Institutional roles and standards
- HKICPA:
  - Responsible for accounting and auditing standards, admission of auditors registered in HKSAR, ethical standards and oversight including disciplinary actions (PAO).
  - Council composition includes accountants and lay members; PAO requires at least six Council members not be full-time accounting practitioners and at least 12 out of 22 members are non-practitioners (source details preserved).
- Financial Reporting Council (FRC):
  - Statutory body established 2006 (FRCO Cap. 588) to investigate non-compliance with accounting requirements by listed entities and auditing irregularities; has statutory investigative powers but not enforcement powers; refers auditor professional conduct issues to HKICPA.
  - FRC governing body members appointed by Government; majority are lay members; funding shared equally by Government, HKICPA, HKEx and SFC.

### Assessment and implementation status
- Principle 18 (Accounting standards) — Assessment: Fully implemented (accounting standards high international quality; convergence to IFRS/HKFRS noted; CASBE convergence to IAS recognized by prior assessments).
- Principle 19 (Oversight of auditors) — Assessment: Partly Implemented.
  - Reasons:
    - HKICPA governance perceived as not sufficiently independent from accounting profession; disciplinary framework seen as limited.
    - HKICPA lacks jurisdiction to oversee foreign auditors who audit companies listed in HKSAR.
    - Enforcement limitations: disciplinary penalty cap (HK$500,000) and limited use of disciplinary panels have constrained enforcement intensity and development of precedents.
  - Recommendation: proceed with proposed reforms to establish a fully independent authority with strong enforcement powers and jurisdiction over all auditors that audit companies listed in HKSAR.

### Independence and standards (Principle 20)
- HKICPA Code of Ethics Section 290:
  - Sets conceptual framework for independence applying to firm and network; independence of mind and appearance; rotation rules (key partner rotation after seven years with two year cool off).
  - HKSQC1 requires firm-level quality control procedures and annual written confirmations of compliance.
- Audit committee requirements: Main Board Listing Rule Appendix 14 and GEM Appendix 15 require audit committees to review and monitor external auditor independence and audit effectiveness.

### Oversight programs and coverage
- HKICPA practice review program:
  - Big four inspected annually; firms with 20+ engagements have one full and one interim inspection in three years; other firms reviewed every 3 years.
  - Review teams: 12 full-time HKICPA professional staff; rotation and follow-up processes described.
- Combined HKEx/HKICPA/FRC financial statements review:
  - SEHK reviews ≈ 120 statements/year; HKICPA ≈ 80; FRC ≈ 75 — jointly covering just under 20 percent of listed issuers annually.
  - Reviews risk-based; coordination to avoid overlap; FRC uses external reviewers.

### Reform trajectory and government response
- Government preparing proposals to enhance independence of auditors' regulatory regime with public consultation planned mid-2014 and possible legislative introduction in 2014–15 legislative session.
- Authorities aim to benchmark regime against international standards including IOSCO Objectives and Principles and IMF recommendations.

---

### Final synthesis: key strengths, frictions and priority reforms

### Key strengths
- Comprehensive legal framework (SFO, BO, CO) with clear mandates for SFC and HKMA and extensive supervisory, investigatory and enforcement powers.
- Robust market infrastructure operated by HKEx with strong pre- and post-trade transparency for exchange trading; automated surveillance and low settlement failure rates (T+2 settlement; compulsory buy-in).
- Active supervisory programs: risk-based off-site monitoring, regular on-site inspections, thematic reviews, contingency planning and investor education (IEC established Nov. 2012).
- CIS regime comprehensive with UTC, Products Handbook and KFS requirements; significant AUM under management and active oversight.

### Key frictions and vulnerabilities
- Enforcement trade-off: SFC cannot readily impose both disciplinary/punitive sanctions and secure client compensation concurrently; reliance on section 201 agreements to secure compensation requires SFC to forego disciplinary action.
- Criminal prosecution path volatility: decline in indictments in recent years and prior public disagreement between SFC and former DPP highlight prosecutorial coordination challenges.
- Governance and independence pressure points: CEHK reserve powers and appointment/removal powers, SFC/HKMA membership of HKEx RMC, part-time Commissioners with potential regulated-entity affiliations.
- Auditors’ oversight fragmentation: perceived HKICPA governance independence weaknesses, limited jurisdiction over foreign auditors, and constrained enforcement powers (Partly Implemented for Principle 19).
- ATS policy opacity: lack of a public, formalized policy distinguishing recognition as an exchange vs. authorization/licensing of ATS; non-uniform conditions for Part V ATS (dark pools); recommendation to formalize and consult.

### Priority policy recommendations (selected, preserved where verbatim)
- Consider translating operational independence into de-jure independence through legal governance modifications for SFC and HKMA.
- SFC should further develop and make public a comprehensive regulatory framework for trading platforms of all kinds.
- SFC and HKMA should not be members of the HKEx’s RMC to ensure an arms’ length relationship.
- Consider increasing maximum fines SFC can impose and providing mechanism for compensating investors that can be used alongside disciplinary process.
- Consider granting HKMA fining powers over EOs and ReIs.
- Authorities should proceed with proposals to establish a fully independent authority with responsibility for oversight of the audit profession and strong enforcement power with jurisdiction over all auditors that audit companies listed in HKSAR.
- SFC should proceed with plans to carry out regular on-site inspections of the HKEx’s market functions.
- Keep under review criteria under which ATS operating as dark pools are not required to provide pre-trade transparency, especially if off-market trading volumes increase.

*Source: _cr14205 — IMF assessment materials and SFC/HKMA/HKEx data as provided in the content unit.*

### INTRODUCTION  __________________________________________________________________________________  8

### INTRODUCTION

### Assessment scope and methodology
- An assessment of the HKSAR securities market was conducted August 26 to September 13, 2013 as part of the FSAP by Ana Carvajal, Monetary and Capital Markets Department and Malcolm Rodgers, External Expert.
- The assessment was conducted based on the IOSCO Principles and Objectives of Securities Regulation approved in 2010 and its Methodology adopted in 2011.
- Principle 38 was not assessed since this principle is now covered under the Principles for Financial Market Infrastructures (PFMI). As a result issues related to the central counterparties as self-regulatory organizations (SROs) are not covered in this assessment.
- Assessors applied a more critical approach in light of the recent global financial crisis, with greater emphasis on:
  - the extent to which regulations capture risks undertaken by different participants;
  - licensing processes, off-site monitoring, on-site inspection programs, and follow-up on findings including enforcement;
  - critical analysis of SROs where jurisdictions rely extensively on them;
  - deeper analysis under Principles 6 and 7 to identify emerging and systemic risk.
- The assessors relied on:
  - a self-assessment and a report on market data prepared by the SFC with collaboration from the HKMA and the Financial Services and the Treasury Bureau (FSTB);
  - review of relevant laws, regulations, codes, guidelines and other documents provided by the regulatory agencies including licensing, inspection and enforcement files;
  - meetings with the CEO of the SFC, and senior staff from both the SFC and the HKMA, and other public authorities, in particular representatives of the FSTB, the Financial Reporting Council (FRC); as well as the HKICPA;
  - meetings with the HKEx, banks and securities intermediaries, auditing firms, a credit rating agency (CRA) and a law firm.

### High-level findings (summary)
- HKSAR has developed a sound framework for the regulation of securities markets, which exhibits a high level of implementation of the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO) Principles.
- Both the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) and the Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) are sophisticated regulators, and have been able to leverage from domestic and international expertise to develop sound supervisory practices.
- The Lehman minibond experience has led to material improvements in conduct supervision across both the SFC and the HKMA.
- Continuing efforts by the SFC to build up its capacity to identify and monitor emerging risks should increase the SFC’s ability to react in a timely manner to an evolving landscape marked by:
  - increased interconnection with the Mainland China;
  - an active presence by international players; and
  - increased regional competition as an international finance center.

### Short-term regulatory and supervisory strengthening priorities
- Regulation and supervision of markets:
  - HKEx has an evolving business model, making it critical that the SFC continues to implement a stronger oversight regime for the HKEx.
  - Actions highlighted include a review of the governance of the HKEx and of the composition of the HKEx risk management committee—the latter to ensure an arm’s length relationship of the regulatory authorities vis-à-vis the HKEx.
  - The SFC should further develop and make public a comprehensive regulatory framework for trading platforms of all kinds.
- Auditors’ oversight:
  - HKSAR’s geographic position and open architecture attract listings from the Mainland and other jurisdictions, creating challenges to ensure robust disclosure by issuers from different legal traditions, governance and accounting frameworks.
  - The SFC and the HKEx have relied on gatekeepers (auditors and listing sponsors), but:
    - the current framework does not ensure the independence of the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants (HKICPA);
    - the framework does not provide HKICPA with powers to oversee foreign auditors who audit companies listed in HKSAR; and
    - the framework does not establish a strong enforcement framework.
  - These gaps place pressure on the reputation of the SFC and HKSAR as an international financial center built on robust disclosure practices.
- Enforcement of securities regulation:
  - For licensed or registered intermediaries who breach the Code of Conduct in circumstances not amounting to contravention of the law enabling the SFC to seek remedial orders from the civil courts, the SFC has no means to impose both punitive action and secure compensation for clients (remedial action) without difficult trade-offs.
  - Coordination arrangements with the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) can be boosted to further enhance the effectiveness of enforcement.
  - The SFC and the Department of Justice (DoJ) agree that efficient and unreserved cooperation is conducive to the proper administration of justice and in the public interest; high level meetings and steps to strengthen coordination have taken place.
  - HKSAR’s openness makes it extremely dependent on international cooperation, in particular from the Mainland; practical challenges remain that require continued international cooperation.

### Institutional structure (key points)
- SFC:
  - The SFC is the main authority responsible for regulation and supervision of securities markets under the Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571).
  - The SFC is a statutory body with a board of directors of 14 appointed by the Chief Executive of Hong Kong (CEHK) or by the Financial Secretary (FS) under delegated authority.
  - The SFC is funded from levies on market participants, but its budget must be approved by the FS.
- HKMA:
  - The HKMA is responsible for supervision of banks in the provision of securities business under the Banking Ordinance (BO) and the SFO.
  - The HKMA created the Banking Conduct Department and the Enforcement Department in 2010, after the Lehman minibond incident.
  - The HKMA has a Superintendent structure; the Monetary Authority (MA) is appointed by the FS.
  - The HKMA is funded through the Exchange Fund.
  - Enforcement of breaches by bank entities of securities laws is conducted by the SFC, with shared responsibilities for breaches by banks’ executive officers (EOs) and relevant individuals (ReIs).
- HKEx:
  - The HKEx holds a legal monopoly in operating a securities exchange in the jurisdiction and also operates the only futures exchange.
  - Two memoranda of understanding (MoUs) provide a framework for the HKEx’s discharge of regulatory functions and for its oversight by the SFC.
  - Under the MoU on Listing, the HKEx approves offering documents for equity and debt issuers and for structured products, with the SFC having power to object; for collective investment schemes (CIS) and non listed structured products the SFC approves offering documents.
  - The HKEx conducts market surveillance to ensure fair and orderly trading; the SFC conducts surveillance to detect market abuse and other unfair trading practices.
- Accounting, auditing and auditors’ oversight:
  - The HKICPA is in charge of accounting and auditing standards, admission criteria for auditors registered in HKSAR, ethical standards, and oversight including disciplinary actions.
  - The governance of HKICPA is by a Council composed of members, lay persons, and two Government representatives; enforcement is conducted by separate panels of lay persons and accounting practitioners.
  - In 2006 the power to investigate irregularities in accounting and auditing of listed issuers was transferred to the Financial Reporting Council (FRC), an independent statutory body established by the FRC Ordinance (Cap. 588).
  - The FRC’s governing body comprises members appointed by the Government, a majority of whom (including the Chairman) are lay members.
  - The FRC has comprehensive statutory powers for independent investigations into reporting and auditing irregularities and statutory responsibility to enquire into possible non-compliances with accounting requirements by listed entities.
  - The FRC is currently funded in equal parts by the HKSAR Government, the HKICPA, the HKEx, and the SFC.
  - The Government has expressed its intention to continue strengthening the independence and oversight of the regulation of auditors of listed entities.

### Coordination mechanisms
- Formal committees and arrangements to foster coordination and cooperation include:
  - Financial Stability Committee (FSC) — monitors functioning of financial markets, assesses events with systemic implications and reports to the FS.
  - Council of Financial Regulators (CFR) — focuses on cross-sector regulatory matters to minimize regulatory gaps or duplications.
  - Securities and Futures Liaison Committee (SFLC) — forum for discussion of major policy initiatives.
  - FS meetings — used by the SFC to report major issues to the FS and the Secretary for Financial Services and the Treasury (SFST).
  - Tripartite meetings between FSTB, SFC, and HKEx — facilitate coordination and understanding on HKEx issues.
  - MoUs between SFC and HKMA, and between SFC and HKEx — provide basis for cooperation and oversight.
  - Regular technical-level contact between the SFC, HKMA and HKEx.

### Policy recommendation highlighted in the Introduction
- Consider translating the operational independence that the regulators have enjoyed into de-jure independence through modifications in the current legal governance arrangements for both SFC and HKMA.

*Source: _cr14205 - INTRODUCTION*

### 10. As of April 2013 there were 1,558 companies listed on The Stock Exchange of Hong

### _cr14205 - 10. As of April 2013 there were 1,558 companies listed on The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (SEHK)

### Listed companies and market activity (At April 2013)
- Listed companies: Number = 1,558
  - Main Board = 1,378
  - Growth Enterprise Market (GEM) = 180
  - Market capitalization of GEM = 0.39 percent of total market capitalization
- Time series (selected rows from table)
  - Listed companies (Number): 2009 = 1,319; 2010 = 1,413; 2011 = 1,496; 2012 = 1,547; At April 2013 = 1,558
  - Market capitalization (US$m): 2009 = 2,297,469; 2010 = 2,709,121; 2011 = 2,254,146; 2012 = 2,821,353; At April 2013 = 2,875,895
  - Market capitalization As % GDP: 2009 = 1077; 2010 = 1186; 2011 = 906; 2012 = 1076; At April 2013 = N/A
  - Market capitalization of top 10 companies (US$m): 2009 = 925,395; 2010 = 1,000,458; 2011 = 839,785; 2012 = 1,026,936; At April 2013 = 1,032,019
  - Market capitalization of top 10 companies As % of GDP: 2009 = 434; 2010 = 438; 2011 = 337; 2012 = 392; At April 2013 = N/A
  - Annual turnover (HK$m): 2009 = 15,515,249; 2010 = 17,210,078; 2011 = 17,154,074; 2012 = 13,301,050; At April 2013 = 5,555,559
  - Average daily turnover (HK$m): 2009 = 62,310; 2010 = 69,117; 2011 = 69,732; 2012 = 53,850; At April 2013 = 70,324
  - New companies listed (Number): 2009 = 73; 2010 = 113; 2011 = 101; 2012 = 64; At April 2013 = 12
- Note: Figures include the number of transfers of listing from GEM to Main Board.

*Source: Stock Exchange of Hong Kong.*

### Issuers by country/region of origin (as at April 30, 2013)
- Total = 1,558 (100 percent)
- Mainland Enterprises: Number = 737; Percent = 47.3
  - H shares: 175 (11.2 percent)
  - Red Chip: 120 (7.7 percent)
  - Mainland Private Enterprises: 442 (28.4 percent)
- Hong Kong: Number = 722; Percent = 46.3
- Others: Number = 99; Percent = 6.4

- Classification Criteria (as stated):
  1. H Shares and Red Chips classified as Mainland enterprises;
  2. Spin-offs classified same as Mother Company;
  3. Origin of establishment, if not in (1) and (2) above, is to be classified;
  4. Place of headquarters of companies to support criteria (3) if necessary or if (1), (2) & (3) above are not applicable.

### Bond market and corporate bonds (At April 2013)
- All Debt Securities
  - Companies with outstanding issues (Number): 2009 = 157; 2010 = 169; 2011 = 192; 2012 = 269; At Apr 2013 = 319
  - Outstanding volume (US$m): 2009 = 50,374; 2010 = 62,779; 2011 = 75,691; 2012 = 113,597; At Apr 2013 = 134,163
  - Outstanding volume As % of GDP: 2009 = 24; 2010 = 27; 2011 = 30; 2012 = 43; At Apr 2013 = N/A
  - Annual turnover (HK$m): 2009 = 4; 2010 = 2,843; 2011 = 2,771; 2012 = 670; At Apr 2013 = (blank in source)
  - New issuing companies (Number): 2009 = 23; 2010 = 38; 2011 = 50; 2012 = 109; At Apr 2013 = 61
  - Source: Stock Exchange of Hong Kong.
- Corporate Bonds (excludes debt securities issued by a bank, state, state corporation and supranational)
  - Companies with outstanding issue (Number): 2009 = 48; 2010 = 58; 2011 = 78; 2012 = 134; At Apr 2013 = 179
  - Outstanding volume (US$m): 2009 = 18,685; 2010 = 27,793; 2011 = 36,728; 2012 = 65,500; At Apr 2013 = 85,675
  - Outstanding volume As % of GDP: 2009 = 9; 2010 = 12; 2011 = 15; 2012 = 25; At Apr 2013 = N/A
  - Annual turnover (HK$mil): 2009 = 0.00; 2010 = 0.00; 2011 = 0.98; 2012 = 0.02; At Apr 2013 = 0.40
  - Number of new companies (Number): 2009 = 7; 2010 = 16; 2011 = 27; 2012 = 65; At Apr 2013 = 49

### Trading platforms and intermediaries
- HKEx group has a legal monopoly in operating a stock market in HKSAR and a de facto monopoly in domestic exchange traded futures.
- HKFE offers a relatively large number of futures contracts mainly based on equities such as equity indices.
- SEHK operates an actively traded stock options market.
- Alternative trading venues:
  - 25 intermediaries (including 13 dark pool operators) permitted to operate an automated trading service (ATS) for trading in securities.
  - Dark pool trading volume ≈ 2.5 percent of trading in listed securities (total).
  - Remaining ATS platforms primarily trade pre-IPO stocks, equity-linked notes and/or fixed income securities; only a couple primarily involved in SEHK listed shares.
  - 21 international exchanges and trading platforms (stock, futures & commodity, fixed income and structured products markets) are authorized to provide trading services in HKSAR.
- Intermediaries (as of March 2013)
  - Licensed firms to carry out regulated securities market activities (including asset management): 1,905
  - Banks registered to conduct securities business: 117
  - Top 10 firms (as of December 2012) accounted for 48 percent of the total value of transactions in securities, and 59 percent of transactions in futures and options.
- Ownership breakdown of licensed corporations
  - Total number of licensed corporations: March 31, 2013 = 1,905; March 31, 2012 = 1,840; March 31, 2011 = 1,752
  - Domestic ownership (In percent): March 31, 2013 = 60; March 31, 2012 = 62; March 31, 2011 = 62
  - Foreign ownership (In percent): March 31, 2013 = 40; March 31, 2012 = 38; March 31, 2011 = 38
- Ownership (by Business Type) of Licensed Corporations (March 31 figures)
  - Affiliates of banks (in percent): 2013 = 10; 2012 = 11; 2011 = 12
  - Affiliates of insurance companies (in percent): 2013 = 2; 2012 = 3; 2011 = 3
  - Affiliates of other financial institutions (in percent): 2013 = 36; 2012 = 35; 2011 = 35
  - Others (in percent): 2013 = 52; 2012 = 51; 2011 = 50
  - Source: Securities and Futures Commission.

### Funds, fund managers and collective investment schemes
- Firms managing SFC authorized funds (as of March 2013): 316 firms
  - Of which SFC licensed firms = 80; based in other jurisdictions = 236
  - Top 10 fund managers (Dec. 2012) accounted for 50.1 percent of total AUM of SFC-authorized funds.
- Collective Investment Schemes (as of March 2013)
  - Total funds authorized by the SFC for public offering in Hong Kong market = 1,847
    - Hong Kong domiciled funds = 305 (17 percent)
    - Luxembourg-domiciled funds = 1,045 (57 percent)
    - Ireland-domiciled funds = 277 (15 percent)
    - Cayman Islands-domiciled funds = 151 (8 percent)
    - UK-domiciled funds = 53 (3 percent)
  - Predominant fund types: Bond and equity funds
- AUM of SFC Authorized Funds by Type (Dec. 31, 2012; Dec. 31, 2011; Dec. 31, 2010)
  - Bond: Dec. 31, 2012 = 467,175 (37.75 percent of total); Dec. 31, 2011 = 324,078 (31.96 percent); Dec. 31, 2010 = 360,944 (30.38 percent)
  - Equity: Dec. 31, 2012 = 498,959 (40.32 percent); Dec. 31, 2011 = 436,280 (43.03 percent); Dec. 31, 2010 = 571,859 (48.13 percent)
  - Diversified: Dec. 31, 2012 = 45,726 (3.69 percent); Dec. 31, 2011 = 32,345 (3.19 percent); Dec. 31, 2010 = 43,005 (3.62 percent)
  - Money market: Dec. 31, 2012 = 83,609 (6.76 percent); Dec. 31, 2011 = 100,535 (9.92 percent); Dec. 31, 2010 = 86,854 (7.31 percent)
  - Fund of funds: Dec. 31, 2012 = 9,332 (0.75 percent); Dec. 31, 2011 = 7,817 (0.77 percent); Dec. 31, 2010 = 7,898 (0.66 percent)
  - Index: Dec. 31, 2012 = 126,127 (10.19 percent); Dec. 31, 2011 = 105,118 (10.37 percent); Dec. 31, 2010 = 106,192 (8.94 percent)
  - Guaranteed: Dec. 31, 2012 = 515 (0.04 percent); Dec. 31, 2011 = 712 (0.07 percent); Dec. 31, 2010 = 1,287 (0.11 percent)
  - Hedge: Dec. 31, 2012 = 630 (0.05 percent); Dec. 31, 2011 = 704 (0.07 percent); Dec. 31, 2010 = 920 (0.08 percent)
  - Other specialized: Dec. 31, 2012 = 5,551 (0.45 percent); Dec. 31, 2011 = 6,284 (0.62 percent); Dec. 31, 2010 = 9,106 (0.77 percent)
  - Total AUM: Dec. 31, 2012 = 1,237,624 (100); Dec. 31, 2011 = 1,013,873 (100); Dec. 31, 2010 = 1,188,065 (100)

### Preconditions for effective securities markets regulation
- Barriers to entry:
  - Foreign investors can invest on same conditions as domestic investors.
  - Licensing requirements for intermediaries based on fit and proper criteria.
  - By law competition in provision of trading platforms in domestic securities is limited by SEHK monopoly.
- Taxation:
  - Overall taxation of firms and individuals is low.
  - A stamp duty applies to securities transactions; certain products/transactions (mainly options and hedging) are exempted.
- Contract law:
  - Largely based on common law; no general statutory code for contract law; binding precedents are basis.
- Company law:
  - Companies Ordinance, CO (Cap. 32) modeled on English Companies Act.
  - Significant overhaul took place last year; new CO has come into effect in March 2014.
  - CO is high level and complemented by Listing Rules and/or the SFO; many listed companies are incorporated offshore (Mainland, Bermuda, British Virgin Islands, Cayman Islands).
- Insolvency law:
  - CO does not contain a framework to allow for out of the court restructuring.
- Competition law:
  - Enacted in 2012; provides judicial enforcement model via Competition Commission and Competition Tribunal; implementation in phases.
- Accounting and auditing standards:
  - High international quality; HKSAR has converged to IFRS and IAAS.
- Protection of investors’ rights:
  - Judiciary independent; class action suits not provided for in legislation.
  - Consumer Legal Action Fund (CLAF) established to provide financial support and legal assistance, but may not afford protections similar to class action suits.
  - Financial Dispute Resolution Center Limited (FDRC) came into operation in June 2012 to provide “mediation first, arbitration next”; licensing conditions for HKMA authorized institutions and Code of Conduct for SFC persons amended to require membership of FDRS.

### Main findings (Regulatory principles and supervisory observations)
- Principles for the regulator:
  - Mandates of the SFC and the HKMA are clearly stated in law.
  - Both enjoy sufficient independence in day-to-day operations, but specific legislative features potentially threaten such independence.
  - SFC’s (and HKMA) role in HKEx Risk Management Committee (RMC) could create potential conflicts vis-à-vis supervision role.
  - Strong mechanisms of accountability exist, including judicial review and high transparency with consultative policy development.
  - Risk and Strategy Unit (R&S) created in 2012 enhances risk identification and monitoring (risk-focused industry meetings, participation in IOSCO Committee on Emerging Risks, internal risk register).
- Principles for SROs:
  - Governance of HKEx and composition of its RMC could create potential conflicts of interest for oversight.
  - SFC has a strong supervisory program for HKEx listing functions: separation of listing function, approval of rules by SFC, four eye principle for listing decisions, and on-site inspections.
- Principles for enforcement:
  - SFC and HKMA have broad licensing, supervisory and investigation powers.
  - Two domestic challenges limit enforcement effectiveness:
    1. For misconduct that does not constitute a crime, framework does not easily allow SFC to seek both remedial and punitive actions, forcing trade-offs.
    2. Coordination challenges with the Department of Public Prosecutions (DPP) could limit criminal enforcement effectiveness; high-level discussions between DoJ and SFC are ongoing to enhance cooperation.
  - Cross-border market nature (issuers and auditors located offshore) is a challenge managed through international cooperation.
- Principles for cooperation:
  - SFO obliges SFC to cooperate and exchange information domestically and with foreign regulators.
  - SFC has MoUs with HKMA and HKEx; cooperation takes place at all organizational levels.
  - SFC is signatory of the IOSCO Multilateral Memorandum of Understanding (MMoU) and numerous bilateral MoUs; evidence of effective international cooperation provided.
- Principles for issuers:
  - Issuers of public offering must submit offering document in line with IOSCO Principles.
  - Review arrangements:
    - For listed products (other than listed CIS), HKEx acts as front line regulator with SFC power to object.
    - For CIS and unlisted securities, SFC is responsible for authorization of offering documents.
  - Listed securities subject to periodic and ongoing obligations (annual and semiannual reporting) and strong framework for dissemination of price sensitive information.
  - Review of compliance:
    - Reporting obligations: mainly HKEx.
    - Price sensitive information: monitored by both SFC and HKEx.
    - Structured products: annual and semi-annual reporting applies; obligation to disseminate inside information (listed) or material adverse changes (unlisted); compliance monitored by SFC.
  - Financial statements in prospectus and periodic reports must be prepared according to IFRS, HKFRS, or Chinese accounting principles; other accounting principles accepted only with reconciliation.
  - Review of financial statements carried out by HKICPA, FRC, and HKEx.
  - Monitoring of issuers’ compliance effective, though enforcement challenged by cross-border market.
- Principles for auditors, CRAs and other information service providers:
  - Auditors domiciled in HKSAR subject to competence requirements set by HKICPA; HKICPA has review program for oversight of auditors domiciled in HKSAR.
  - HKICPA governance structure does not ensure independence from accounting profession; its enforcement framework is weak.
  - Auditing standards are of high international quality (converged with IAASB).
  - HKICPA has robust independence requirements for auditors.
  - Mainland auditors for dual listing must use Chinese Auditing Standards (converged to IAS).
  - Non-Hong Kong audit firms accepted on case-by-case basis; must be independent as local auditors; HKICPA lacks oversight jurisdiction over them but exchange expects oversight by a regulatory body of a jurisdiction signatory to IOSCO MMoU.
  - Credit rating services and issuance of analysis/reports on securities and futures contracts are regulated activities subject to licensing requirements and supervised within overall program for securities intermediaries (off-site monitoring and on-site inspections).

*Italic: Source: Stock Exchange of Hong Kong; Securities and Futures Commission; material as provided in the content unit.*

### 24. Principles for Collective Investment Schemes: The operation and distribution of CIS in

### 24. Principles for Collective Investment Schemes: The operation and distribution of CIS in

### Regulatory scope and licensing
- The operation and distribution of CIS in HKSAR are regulated activities that are required to be licensed or registered.
- CIS managers operating in HKSAR and licensed/registered by the SFC are subject to the same requirements as all other intermediaries, and to additional requirements established in the Fund Managers Code of Conduct and the Unit Trust Code.
- The offering of CIS to the public in HKSAR requires authorization of the fund by the SFC, even if the fund has been authorized by a foreign regulator.

### Prospectus and disclosure requirements
- The authorization of a CIS requires the submission of a prospectus the content of which must comply with the requirements set forth in the Principles.
- CIS are subject to ongoing obligations including:
  - annual reports with audited financial statements, and semiannual reports, and the disclosure of material events.
- Material changes must be approved by investors and/or the SFC depending on the circumstances, and all material changes must be notified to investors.

### Valuation, pricing errors, and winding up
- CIS must be valued on a fair value basis, and there are clear guidelines in connection with pricing errors.
- The winding up of CIS must be carried out as provided for in its constituent documents or with the approval of a general meeting of holders.

### Hedge funds
- Hedge fund (HF) managers are subject to the same licensing requirements as any other manager of CIS.
- HFs that are offered to the public must comply with the same requirements as other CIS, and a set of additional requirements set by the SFC.

### Supervision and enforcement of CIS managers
- Ongoing supervision of CIS managers, including HF managers, is conducted within the overall program for securities intermediaries, and involves:
  - off-site monitoring (based on regular interactions with licensed firms such as periodic reporting and meetings),
  - on-site prudential visits, and
  - on-site inspections.

### Principles for Intermediaries (Section 25)
- The SFO defines a series of regulated activities, including dealing and advising on securities and futures that are subject to the licensing requirements.
- The SFC has established a common framework for the licensing of all regulated activities that is based on fit and proper criteria. The review of applications is robust.
- Banks conducting securities business are subject to a separate registration process, but the regulatory framework that applies to them is the same as for SFC licensed entities.
- Ongoing supervision for all intermediaries including banks involves both:
  - off site monitoring (based on regular interactions with licensed firms such as periodic reporting and meetings as appropriate) and
  - on-site prudential visits and inspections, which are planned using a risk-based approach.
- This monitoring gives particular attention to conduct obligations including selling practices. The SFC makes significant use of thematic inspections to complement its inspections of individual firms.
- Licensed intermediaries are subject to capital requirements based on a net capital rule which has embedded charges for market, credit risk and concentration risk, while the minimum buffer required subsumes other risks that have not been specified (mainly operational risk).
- Licensed intermediaries are subject to an early warning system.
- The SFC has in place a contingency plan which covers the failure of an intermediary and market wide simulation exercises are conducted on a biannual basis.

*PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF CHINA––HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION  INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND 19*

### 26. Principles for Secondary Markets: There are provisions in the law concerning exchanges

### 26. Principles for Secondary Markets: There are provisions in the law concerning exchanges

### Summary findings on exchanges, ATS and supervision
- There are provisions in the law concerning exchanges and ATS and the SFC has issued Guidelines in connection with ATS.
- The current framework does not provide sufficient guidance to potential applicants on:
  - the differences in nature of different types of trading platforms; and
  - the requirements applicable to different types of trading platforms.
- As part of the application process the SFC has been open in discussions with actual applicants.
- The HKEx has strong arrangements for real time supervision of the markets it operates.
- The SFC has established an oversight program of the HKEx on both its listing and market function that comprises:
  - approval of rules,
  - meetings, and
  - periodic and ad-hoc reporting.
- On-site inspections have been a regular part of oversight for the listing function; an inspection of the market function is planned for 2014.
- Resources devoted to supervision of ATS are in line with their current importance.
- There is strong pre- and post-trade transparency, fostered by the current market structure as ATS trading volumes are not significant.
- The supervisory program to detect market abuse and other unfair trading practices is robust, though cross border challenges remain, as well as domestic challenges in connection with effective criminal enforcement.
- The HKEx has arrangements for management of large exposures, including robust reporting obligations and position limits.
- Risk management mechanisms include margining and transparent default procedures.
- A robust framework for both short selling and settlement leads to a minimal rate of settlement failures.

### Implementation grades and principal findings (selected highlights)
- Principle 33 (Establishment of trading systems): PI
  - HKEx has a monopoly for operation of a stock exchange in HKSAR. Other exchanges subject to recognition by the SFC.
  - ATS can be established and, depending on nature, are subject to either authorization or licensing by the SFC.
  - Need for a more formal and transparent policy to guide potential applicants choosing between recognition as a recognized exchange company (REC) or authorization as a Type III ATS.
  - Type V ATS requirements have evolved via licensing conditions but have not been incorporated into the ATS Guidelines.
- Principle 34 (Ongoing regulatory supervision of exchanges and trading systems): BI
  - HKEx conducts real time supervision; SFC conducts market surveillance to detect misconduct.
  - SFC arrangements for HKEx supervision include meetings at different organizational levels, reporting obligations, and on-site inspections for the listing function.
  - An onsite inspection of HKEx market function planned for 2014.
  - Market supervision currently focuses on markets operated by HKEx, reasonable in light of ATS size.
- Principle 35 (Transparency of trading): FI
  - HKEx trading rules require both pre- and post-trade transparency.
  - Exchange participants must report off-exchange trades within 15 minutes.
  - Iceberg orders are not allowed; block trades allowed only in futures exchange and must be communicated immediately.
  - ATS that manage dark pools do not provide pre-trade transparency but must report all trades to the HKEx within 1 minute of execution; ATS trading volumes are not significant.
- Principle 36 (Detect and deter manipulation and unfair trading): FI
  - Market manipulation, insider trading, and unfair trading prohibited under SFO; front running is misconduct under the Code of Conduct.
  - Appropriate remedies available, including criminal prosecution (except for front running).
  - SFC has robust automated market surveillance systems and a dedicated team to investigate alerts.
  - Enforcement faces cross border challenges requiring cooperation from foreign regulators and domestic coordination challenges between SFC and DPP.
- Principle 37 (Management of large exposures, default risk and market disruption): FI
  - Exchange participants subject to position reporting and position limits.
  - Exchanges have powers to require reduction of positions, and to close out or transfer positions for non-compliance.
  - Additional risk mechanisms: capital requirements for clearing participants, day and intraday margin, and a default fund.
  - Default rules are transparent with wide powers for HKEx to close out, settle or transfer positions.
  - Robust rules for short selling: prohibit naked short selling and require reporting of short positions.
  - A mandatory buy in is required for a failed settlement and the intermediary must pay a fine, resulting in a minimal rate of settlement failures.

### Summary table of implementation (overall counts)
- Fully Implemented (FI) – 26
- Broadly Implemented (BI) – 8
- Partly Implemented (PI) – 3
- Not Implemented (NI) – 0
- Not Applicable (NA) – 1

### Recommended actions (selected, verbatim where provided)
- Principle 1
  - Authorities should proceed with the current initiatives that will ensure consistent conduct regulation of selling/distribution relating to investment-linked insurance products and other investments.
  - Authorities should consider having periodic reviews of the supervisory and enforcement outcomes of both SFC and HKMA to ensure that, regardless of which regulator is involved, poor conduct by intermediaries and their managers and representatives, is treated in a consistent fashion, especially in terms of remedial, disciplinary and enforcement responses.
- Principle 2
  - Authorities should consider strengthening the independence of the regulators by explicitly limiting the circumstances in which the CEHK can give directions to them, for example by precluding directions relating to specific cases.
  - The circumstances in which the CEHK can remove Commission members of the SFC should be articulated, preferably in legislation.
  - Consideration should be given to moving away from government appointees on the board of the HKEx.
  - SFC and HKMA should not be members of the HKEx’s RMC to ensure an arms’ length relationship.
  - Authorities should consider the desirability of moving away from part time Commissioners, or at least adopt a policy of not appointing directors of regulated entities as Commissioners.
- Principle 3
  - Authorities should give consideration to increasing the maximum fines that SFC can impose and providing a mechanism for compensating investors that can be used alongside the disciplinary process.
  - Authorities should give consideration to providing the HKMA with fining powers over EOs and ReIs.
- Principle 4
  - SFC should further develop and formalize internal policies for publication of a comprehensive policy on the recognition of exchange markets and the authorization/licensing of other trading platforms.
  - HKMA circulars about policy (rather than compliance guidance) should continue to be subject to consultation.
- Principle 6–7
  - SFC should continue to implement the mandate for the R&S to comply with Principle 6 and over time assess the level of resources required for such compliance.
- Principle 9
  - Consideration should be given to moving away from government appointees on board of HKEx and RMC.
  - SFC and HKMA should not be members of the HKEx’s RMC to ensure an arms’ length relationship.
  - Consideration should be given to subjecting decisions on the admission of participants to an appeal process (for example by SFC).
  - SFC should proceed with its plans to carry out regular on-site inspections of the HKEx’s market functions.
- Principle 11
  - Authorities should give consideration to increasing the maximum fines that SFC can impose; and providing a mechanism for compensating investors that can be used as part of the disciplinary process.
  - Authorities should give consideration to providing the HKMA with fining powers over EOs and ReIs.
- Principle 12
  - The authorities should continue working to enhancing coordination on the criminal arena.
  - Authorities should consider having periodic reviews of the supervisory and enforcement outcomes of both SFC and HKMA to ensure that, regardless of which regulator is involved, poor conduct by intermediaries and their managers and representatives is treated in a consistent fashion, especially in terms of remedial, disciplinary and enforcement responses.
- Principle 16
  - The SFC and the Exchange should implement shorter deadlines for the submission of periodic information, in particular interim reports.
- Principle 18
  - The authorities should consider centralizing the function of monitoring issuers’ compliance with accounting standards into one single authority.
- Principles 19–21
  - The authorities should proceed with their proposals to establish a fully independent authority with responsibility for the oversight of the audit profession and with strong enforcement power. Such authority should have jurisdictions over all auditors that audit companies listed in HKSAR.
- Principle 33
  - SFC should further develop and formalize internal policies for publication of a comprehensive policy on the recognition of exchange markets and the authorization/licensing of other trading platforms.
- Principle 34
  - The SFC should proceed with its plan to conduct regular on-site inspections of the market function of the SEHK.
- Principle 35
  - The criteria under which ATS that operate as dark pools are not required to provide pre-trade transparency should be kept under review, especially if trading volumes in off-market venues increase.

*PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF CHINA––HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION — INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND.*

### 27. The Hong Kong authorities appreciate the comprehensive and positive assessment of

### _cr14205 - 27. The Hong Kong authorities appreciate the comprehensive and positive assessment of

### Operational Independence of the Regulators
- Authorities concur that both the SFC and HKMA enjoy clear de facto operational independence in performing their functions.
- Reserve power vested with the Chief Executive (CE) of the HKSAR to give directions to the SFC (section 11 of the SFO) reflects Government responsibility under the Basic Law; this power:
  - has never been invoked;
  - would only be used as a tool of last resort in the most critical and extreme circumstances;
  - is subject to restrictions under the SFO: (i) the direction must be in the public interest; (ii) it must further the SFC’s regulatory objectives or the performance of any of its functions; and (iii) the CE must first consult the CEO of the SFC to afford the SFC an opportunity to be heard.
  - may be subject to judicial review.
- Authorities consider safeguards exist against arbitrary use and that the reserve power should not be seen as having potential for interference in day-to-day operations.
- On appointment of SFC non-executive directors (NEDs) and the Chairman:
  - Chairman must not be a director of any company listed in HKSAR, must not have material interest in any principal business activity or be involved in material business dealing with a company listed in HKSAR or any person/company regulated by the SFC.
  - NED appointments consider background and experience to avoid conflicts and secure independent oversight.
  - Internal procedures exist within the SFC to guard against conflicts of interest.

### Regulation and Supervision of Markets
- Authorities welcome IMF recognition that the SFC and HKMA are sophisticated regulators leveraging domestic and international expertise.
- In response to comments under Principle 9:
  - Authorities are reviewing the composition of the RMC to enhance its effectiveness relative to HKEx’s statutory functions.
  - The FS appointing members to the HKEx Board is described as necessary to safeguard public and investing public interests given HKEx’s public functions (orderly and fair market, prudent risk management).
- In relation to Principles 33–35:
  - The SFC has begun reconfiguring its supervisory approach to HKEx considering HKEx’s latest strategic plan and business model.
  - The SFC will issue further guidelines on recognition of exchanges and authorization of ATS.

### Monitoring of Issuers’ Compliance with Accounting Standards (Principle 18)
- The FRC Ordinance vests in the FRC statutory function and power to enquire into non-compliance with accounting requirements by issuers.
- The FRC leads and coordinates with other regulators in monitoring issuers’ compliance with accounting standards.
- Authorities believe the current regime works well and see no necessity to transfer the statutory role of the FRC to the SFC.

### Oversight of External Auditors of Listed Companies (Principles 19–21)
- Government is preparing proposals to enhance the independence of the regulatory regime for auditors of listed entities from the accountancy profession.
- Proposals aim to benchmark the regime against international standards and will take into account IOSCO Objectives and Principles and IMF recommendations.
- Plan: conduct a public consultation on reform proposals in mid-2014 and, subject to consultation outcome, introduce legislation into the Legislative Council in the 2014–15 legislative session.

### Enforcement of Securities Regulation (Principle 12 and related)
- Authorities note IMF recognition that SFC and HKMA have robust supervisory regimes but acknowledge identified issues in enforcement effectiveness.
- Coordination between DoJ and SFC:
  - Consensus exists that improved coordination is beneficial.
  - High-level meetings between SFC leadership and DoJ leadership (including the DPP who assumed office in September 2013) are being held to improve arrangements; authorities expect ongoing discussions to be fruitful.
- Level of sentence:
  - Sentences in market misconduct cases are monitored and assessed under the Prosecution Code irrespective of prosecuting body (DoJ or SFC).
  - Appeal procedures exist within Hong Kong’s judicial system for sentences wrong in law/principle or manifestly inadequate/excessive; prosecutors may invoke review where appropriate.
- Remedial and punitive actions:
  - Section 213 of the SFO empowers the SFC to seek court orders requiring remedial steps to address contraventions, including restoring affected parties to their pre-transaction position.
  - Investors may seek to settle monetary disputes with financial institutions through the FDRC, established in November 2011.
- Periodic review of supervisory and enforcement outcomes:
  - An MoU between SFC and HKMA operates to ensure consistent application of regulatory measures across intermediaries supervised by either regulator.
  - The two regulators maintain close dialogue on supervisory and enforcement matters and will keep under review the need to further enhance cooperation and information exchange arrangements.

### Detailed Assessment Report — Purpose and Methodology
- Purpose: ascertain whether legal and regulatory securities market requirements and regulator operations meet IOSCO Principles; identify potential gaps, inconsistencies, weaknesses, and areas needing further powers or better implementation; establish priorities for improvement.
- Assessment categories for each Principle: fully implemented, broadly implemented, partly implemented, not implemented, and not applicable.
- IOSCO assessment methodology provides assessment criteria for each Principle, and recognizes domestic variation in means of implementation depending on context, structure, and development stage of the capital market.

### Principles Relating to the Regulator — Principle 1: The responsibilities of the regulator should be clear and objectively stated
- Structure of regulation:
  - Sectoral regulatory authorities: (a) securities and futures industry—SFC; (b) banks—HKMA; (c) insurance—Office of the Commissioner of Insurance (OCI, previously the Insurance Authority (IA)); (d) MPF industry—Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes Authority (MPFA).
  - SFC has primary responsibility for securities industry regulation and supervision.
  - Securities activities of licensed banks and deposit-taking institutions supervised by HKMA; legislative and rule framework mainly supplied by the SFO and SFC codes of conduct.
  - SFC enforces against banks for securities law breaches mainly via HKMA referrals; enforcement on EOs and ReIs is shared.
  - Regulation and supervision of auditors carried out by FRC and HKICPA: FRC investigates/reporting irregularities and non-compliance for listed companies; HKICPA supervises audit firms domiciled in Hong Kong.
  - HKEx group plays a self-regulatory role for listed companies and supervises orderly conduct of trading.
  - Specialist tribunal MMT conducts administrative proceedings relating to market misconduct (Part XIII SFO) and breaches of obligation to disclose inside information (Division 3 Part XIVA).
- SFC powers and authority:
  - Set out in legislation, enforceable; principal legislation is the SFO and subsidiary instruments; SFC also has powers under Parts II and XII of the CO, the AMLO, and the MPFSO.
  - Section 4 of the SFO sets regulatory objectives; section 5 sets general functions; section 6 sets matters SFC must have regard to.
- HKMA powers and authority:
  - Set out in the BO; some powers conferred by the SFO.
  - Supervision functions specified in section 7 of the BO.
  - Entities authorized to carry on banking business that wish to engage in regulated securities activities must register with SFC to become Registered Institutions (RIs); HKMA is frontline supervisor for RIs.
  - HKMA gives consent to appointment of EOs and maintains register particulars of ReIs.
  - HKMA’s responsibilities also set out in a 2003 exchange of letters between the FS and HKMA (published on HKMA’s website).
- Discretion to interpret authority:
  - SFC and HKMA may interpret authority consistent with statutory interpretation and relevant legislation; SFC exercises of discretion must be consistent with section 6 duties of the SFO.
  - Challenging regulatory discretion: appeal to SFAT; judicial review; complaint to Office of the Ombudsman.
  - Operations may be reviewed by ICAC.
- Gaps or overlaps:
  - No apparent gaps in overall regulatory scheme, subject to issues noted on regulation of selling practices for ILAS.
  - HKMA adopts SFC regulatory standards for RIs (e.g., Fit and Proper Guidelines issued September 2006, Guidelines on Competence).
  - MoU between HKMA and SFC delineates roles to ensure consistency and prevent overlap.
- Consistent regulation of like services and products:
  - Disclosure rules under the SFO apply to offers of ILAS and MPF products; SFC authorizes disclosure documents (sections 103 and 105 of the SFO).
  - ILAS: promoting, selling, or advising on ILAS does not require an SFC licence if the intermediary only promotes insurance products (ILAS is not a “security” under the SFO); insurance SROs provide some standards but not strong suitability rules; HKMA introduced further requirements for sale of ILAS by AIs; IA to introduce enhanced disclosure and consumer protection measures for ILAS in 2014.
  - MPF products: following MPFSO amendment in 2012, SFC, HKMA and IA are frontline regulators of intermediaries selling MPF products and have statutory powers to supervise and investigate conduct of licensed/authorized intermediaries.
- Coordination and cooperation between regulatory authorities:
  - SFC duty under section 5(1)(h) of SFO to cooperate and provide assistance to regulatory authorities; similar provision for HKMA under section 7(2)(e) of BO.
  - Section 5(3) permits SFC to rely on HKMA supervision of RIs when performing functions.
  - Legislative mutual consultation requirements include: SFC must consult HKMA before making rules, codes or guidelines that apply to RIs (sections 398(4) and 399(9) of the SFO); mutual consultation obligations apply to disciplinary matters.

*Source: _cr14205 - 27. The Hong Kong authorities appreciate the comprehensive and positive assessment of*

### section 196 of the SFO; sections 58A(1) and 71C(4) of the BO);

### _cr14205 - section 196 of the SFO; sections 58A(1) and 71C(4) of the BO);

### Coordination, MoUs, and inter-agency cooperation
- SFC must consult HKMA before directing an AI to produce books and records (section 179(10)(a) of the SFO), or commencing an investigation of an RI (section 182(1)(e)(i)).
- The SFC and HKMA have entered into an MoU providing a framework for cooperation and coordination, which:
  - Sets out regulatory and supervisory roles and responsibilities of the two regulators.
  - Establishes channels and mechanisms for exchange of information, including periodic meetings and sharing particular types of information.
  - Requires HKMA to refer to SFC if HKMA becomes aware of a material breach by an RI or its staff of any applicable provision of the SFO or any rules, codes or guidelines made or published by SFC under the SFO; SFC may (after consultation with HKMA) commence an investigation under section 182 of the SFO.
- In practice there is regular engagement beyond the MoU on policy, findings from off- and on-site programs, and referrals occur.
- Relations between SFC and the HKEx are dealt with under Principle 9 and Principles 32–36; MoUs between SFC and the HKEx set out agreed arrangements on topics including SFC’s oversight, supervision of exchange participants and market surveillance, and supervision of listed entities.
- Additional MoUs and cooperative arrangements:
  - SFC has an MoU with the IA.
  - SFC is a party to an MoU between the MPFA, SFC, IA and HKMA on the regulation of MPF intermediaries.
  - SFC is party to a tripartite MoU with the HKMA and the FDRC.
  - The CFR comprising the FS, the SFST, the Chief Executive Officer of SFC (CEO), the Chief Executive of HKMA, the Managing Director of the MPFA and the Commissioner of Insurance meets regularly to discuss cross-market regulatory and supervisory issues.

### Assessment and specific regulatory issues
- Assessment: Broadly Implemented
- Comment on grading:
  - The grade relates to the distribution of ILAS vis-à-vis Question 2 b) of the IOSCO Methodology.
  - There is a disparity in requirements for distributors of ILAS: sale of ILAS by banks and non-bank insurance intermediaries are not subject to the same standard of conduct obligations.
  - Government and regulatory authorities are working on options to address this issue.
  - Assessors found active cooperation and sharing of information between SFC and HKMA.
  - Assessors encourage periodic reviews of supervisory and enforcement outcomes of both SFC and HKMA to ensure consistent treatment of poor conduct by intermediaries and their managers and representatives in remedial and enforcement responses. (This issue was not taken into consideration in reaching the grade.)

### Principle 2 — Operational independence and accountability: SFC (description)
- Legal and institutional status:
  - SFC is a non-governmental statutory body, established by the SFC Ordinance (now repealed) and continued under the SFO as a statutory corporation; SFC is not part of the Government and its employees are not civil servants.
  - CEHK is empowered to give SFC written directions (section 11 of the SFO) but has not done so since the establishment of SFC in 1989.
  - Restrictions on CEHK directions (as set out in explanatory material and SFO Ordinance):
    - direction must be in the public interest;
    - it must further SFC regulatory objectives or the performance of any of its functions;
    - CEHK must first consult the SFC Chair to afford SFC a formal opportunity to be heard.
- Appointments and composition:
  - Under section 1 of Part 1 of Schedule 2 to the SFO the chairman, executive directors and non-executive directors of SFC are appointed by the CEHK; Government plays no part in appointment of other staff.
  - Section 1 of Part 1 of Schedule 2 requires the number of non-executive directors to be more than the number of executive directors.
  - Board meets at least once a month; non-executive directors are not involved in day-to-day operations.
  - All Board members are appointed for a fixed term by the CEHK or by the FS under delegated authority.
  - There must be a minimum of 8 members of the Commission.
  - Currently there are 8 non-executive directors, including the Chairman, and 6 executive directors (EDs), including the CEO.
  - The posts of Chairman and CEO have been separated since 2006 by legislation.
  - The Chairman’s letter of appointment stipulates he or she must not be a director of a listed company and the Government requires no material interest in principal business activity or involvement in material business dealing with a listed company or person/company regulated by the SFC.
  - Non-executive directors may have other occupations (example: currently one is a director of a listed company and 3 are legal practitioners).
  - Potential conflicts of interest are dealt with by a code of conduct; Government considers conflict avoidance and candidate background/experience when appointing non-executive directors.
- Removal and procedural protections:
  - Section 13, Part 1 of Schedule 2 gives CEHK power to remove any member of the Commission whose removal appears desirable for effective performance; this power has not been exercised to date and may be constrained by procedural fairness rules at common law.
  - Such decisions can be challenged under general administrative law as unreasonable or inappropriate.
  - EDs’ contracts specify other circumstances for removal, e.g., misconduct.
- Board functions and non-delegable powers:
  - Chairman leads Board in setting overall direction, policies and strategies; CEO has executive responsibility for day-to-day running, in accordance with Board-agreed objectives, policies and strategies.
  - Some board functions are non-delegable, including enforcement decisions such as seeking court orders under section 213 or referring a matter to the MMT, and the power to make rules.
  - A long list of non-delegable decisions is set out in Part 2 of Schedule 2 of the SFO.

### SFC interaction with government and other bodies
- SFC is required by law to consult with the Government on a number of matters; SFO requires prior consultation with the FS on a range of matters including:
  - recognition and regulation of exchanges and clearing houses, including requesting an exchange company or clearing house to make rules (sections 23(4) and 40(4));
  - making rules regulating the listing of securities (section 36(1));
  - matters relating to establishment and operation of an investor compensation company;
  - making rules requiring LCs to maintain certain financial resources (section 145);
  - making rules to prescribe circumstances in which conduct that would otherwise constitute market misconduct under Part XIII or Part XIV shall not be regarded as market misconduct (sections 282(2) and 306);
  - publishing guidelines for exemption from Part XV (Disclosure of interests in shares) (section 309(1));
  - intervening in proceedings (section 385(1)).
- Consent or approval of the FS is required in limited circumstances:
  - appointment of SFC’s auditors (section 16(1));
  - investment of funds of SFC (section 17);
  - recognizing a company as an exchange controller (section 59(2));
  - withdrawing recognition of a company as an exchange controller (section 72(1));
  - appointing a person other than an employee of SFC to conduct an investigation under section 182(1);
  - borrowing from a bank for purposes of the investor compensation fund (section 237(2)).
- Consent of the Secretary for Justice is required before:
  - publishing a report of an investigation prepared under section 183(6);
  - commencing proceedings before the MMT (section 252A(1)). The Secretary for Justice can only withhold consent if criminal proceedings for market misconduct are contemplated in respect of the same conduct; or proceedings for other indictable offences are contemplated, or have been instituted, in respect of the same conduct and institution of MMT proceedings would be likely to cause serious prejudice to the investigation or prosecution of that offence.
- Rulemaking procedure:
  - SFC’s power to make or amend rules that constitute subsidiary legislation is subject to procedural requirements under section 34 of the Interpretation and General Clauses Ordinance (IGCO):
    - amendments must be published in the Hong Kong Gazette and then tabled before the Legislative Council of Hong Kong (LegCo), which may approve, amend or reject the proposed subsidiary legislation.

### Interaction with HKEx and risk management
- SFC and the HKMA are members of the RMC of the HKEx, a statutory committee established under the SFO to formulate policies on risk management matters relating to the HKEx.
- RMC provides recommendations to the HKEx board on risk management issues, including matters which may require SFC regulatory decisions or actions, including changes to HKEx rules.

### Funding and legal protection — SFC
- Funding:
  - SFC has a stable and adequate source of funding; SFC’s budget is approved by the FS and detailed budgets including staffing levels for each operational area are prepared as part of this approval process.
- Legal protection:
  - Board members and staff of SFC and persons assisting SFC in the performance of its duties are accorded legal protection for bona fide discharge of governmental, regulatory or administrative functions by section 380 of the SFO, precluding actions in contract, tort, defamation, equity or otherwise.
  - Arrangements indemnify Board members and SFC staff, including cover for costs and expenses in obtaining legal advice and/or representation in relation to potential criminal and/or civil proceedings, whether or not proceedings ultimately take place, provided the advice/representation aims to prevent the action; relevant costs and expenses are settled directly from the litigation budget.

### Independence, governance, interaction with government, funding, and legal protection — HKMA
- Independence and powers:
  - The MA is the Chief Executive of the HKMA and is appointed by the FS under section 5A(1) of the EFO on such terms and conditions as he thinks fit; the MA is a public officer.
  - Section 5A(2)(b) and (c) of the EFO requires the MA to perform such functions as the FS may direct and perform functions imposed on or assigned to the MA by any other Ordinance.
  - The BO assigns various functions to the MA, principally promotion of the general stability and effective working of the banking system.
  - Supervisory powers in the BO are exercisable by the MA independently although prior consultation with the FS is necessary for some major decisions such as revocation of authorization and intervention under sections 22 and 52 of the BO.
  - Section 10 of the BO gives CEHK the right to give to the FS and the MA such directions as the CEHK thinks fit with respect to the exercise of the MA’s function under the BO, either generally or in any particular case.
- Governance and appointments:
  - The existing MA was appointed for a term of 5 years, determined after consultation with the Exchange Fund Advisory Committee (EFAC) Governance Sub-Committee.
  - FS has power to revoke appointment of the MA in the exercise of his or her statutory discretion pursuant to section 42 of the IGCO.
  - MA’s letter of appointment provides it is not FS’s intention to terminate the MA’s employment except for cause (examples: inability to discharge functions, not adequately carrying out functions, serious misconduct, conviction of a criminal offence punishable by imprisonment, or bankruptcy).
  - MA’s employment (and all other members of MA’s staff) may be terminated for “gross misconduct”.
- EFAC and its role:
  - HKMA does not have a board per se; EFAC carries out many functions of a management board.
  - EFAC, established under section 3(1) of the EFO, advises the FS on matters related to control of the Exchange Fund.
  - FS is ex officio chairman of EFAC and the MA is a member; other members are appointed by CEHK under section 3(1) of the EFO and are appointed ad personam for expertise and experience.
  - EFAC members include representatives from banking, legal, accounting, business and academic fields.
  - EFAC has subcommittees including a governance subcommittee; members from banking sector do not sit on the EFAC Governance Subcommittee which monitors HKMA's performance, oversees governance matters and provides advice on annual administration budget and remuneration policies for the HKMA.
  - EFAC does not provide advice on matters relating to supervision functions of the HKMA.
- Interaction with government and appeal rights:
  - Supervisory powers in the BO are exercisable by the MA independently although prior consultation with the FS is necessary for some major decisions (e.g. revocation of authorization and intervention under sections 22 and 52 of the BO).
  - Section 10 of the BO gives CEHK a right to give directions to the FS and the MA with respect to exercise of their respective functions under the BO consistent with objectives and powers in the BO.
  - Section 132A gives persons aggrieved by decisions specified in the section the right to appeal the decision to the Chief Executive in Council.
- Funding:
  - HKMA has a stable and adequate source of funding.
- Legal protection:
  - Section 127(1) of the BO provides that no liability shall be incurred by the MA and his staff as a result of anything done or omitted to be done by him or his staff bona fide in the exercise or purported exercise of any functions under the BO.
  - In line with Civil Service Regulations, the MA will provide legal representation for staff members for claims made against them with respect to actions or omissions in course of duties provided they acted in good faith.

### Accountability and transparency — SFC (mechanisms)
- SFC is accountable to LegCo, the FS and various other bodies on an ongoing basis. Accountability mechanisms include:
  - Section 12 of the SFO requires SFC to provide to the FS such information regarding the “principles, practices and policy” it is pursuing or proposes to pursue in performance of any of its functions as specified by the FS. In practice, SFC submits a quarterly report on its operations to the FS and appears before the LegCo Panel on Financial Affairs when the need arises.
  - Section 13 requires:
    - SFC to submit its estimates of income and expenditure for the next financial year to CEHK for approval; CEHK delegated this power of approval to FS in 2004.
    - the approved estimates to be placed before the legislature for discussion, but not approval.
  - Section 15 requires SFC to publish an annual report which is sent to the FS, who places it before the legislature. SFC has published quarterly reports since 2011.
  - Section 16 requires SFC to send audited financial statements to the FS, and empowers the Government auditor to examine SFC’s books and records.
  - An independent, non-statutory Process Review Panel established by the CEHK reviews and monitors SFC’s processes and internal procedures.

*Source: _cr14205 - section 196 of the SFO; sections 58A(1) and 71C(4) of the BO);*

### Section 169 of the SFO empowers SFC to issue codes of business conduct for intermediaries

### Section 169 of the SFO empowers SFC to issue codes of business conduct for intermediaries

### SFC powers to issue codes and guidelines
- Section 169 of the SFO empowers the SFC to issue codes of business conduct for intermediaries.
- Section 399 of the SFO creates a general power to issue codes and guidelines.
- SFC has used these powers to create an extensive range of codes and guidelines that are available on its website.
- Section 398 of the SFO gives SFC power to make rules; matters on which it may make rules are enumerated and include a general provision permitting rules on “any other matters for the better carrying out of the objects and purposes of” the SFO (section 398(1)(p)).
- Rules are subsidiary legislation with the force of law; their making is subject to mandatory public consultation and a requirement to place rules before LegCo which can approve or amend them.
- Codes do not of themselves have the force of law but set out what the SFC “expects” from regulated entities and persons; non-compliance is generally relevant to SFC’s consideration of whether a person has complied with the legislation.

### Legal effect of codes under section 169 and related provisions
- For codes made under section 169, section 169(4) provides that a failure by an intermediary, or a representative of an intermediary, to comply with the provisions of a code may be taken into account in considering whether the intermediary or representative is fit and proper and should remain licensed or registered.
- Codes made under sections 169 and 398 are admissible in evidence in proceedings under the SFO before any court; if any provision set out in the code appears relevant to any question in the proceedings the court must take it into account in determining that question.
- Recent jurisprudence: a violation of a Code does not create a third party right—an investor cannot sue a licensed firm for violation of a code unless the obligation in the code is also an obligation contained in the contract between the investor and the firm.
- SFC is proposing to require intermediaries to include a provision in all of their contracts with their clients to address the gap that codes alone do not create third party rights.

### Consultation practice
- As a matter of practice, SFC consults the industry and public on changes to these guidelines/codes or proposed new guidelines and codes.
- SFC is required by law to consult the public on any subsidiary legislation (and any changes to subsidiary legislation) it proposes to make.

### Accountability — HKMA (Mandate, reporting and oversight)
- Section 5A of the EFO specifies that the MA shall perform such functions as the FS may direct or functions imposed on or assigned to the MA by any other Ordinance (including the BO).
- Section 9 of the BO specifies the reporting matters that the MA shall prepare and furnish to the FS annually; the MA is directly accountable to the FS.
- The MA is a public officer and his office is regarded as a part of Government.
- Though not specifically required by law, HKMA periodically provides briefings to the Legislative Council Panel on Financial Affairs to explain the work of HKMA and to answer questions.
- Section 9(1) of the BO requires the MA to send a report to the FS on the working of the BO and the activities of his office yearly; the FS may, under section 9(5), publish the report as he thinks fit.
- HKMA’s receipt and use of funds is subject to review and audit (section 7 of the EFO).
- The Audit Sub-committee of EFAC is responsible for ensuring the proper and smooth running of the HKMA operation and management of the Exchange Fund.
- The Audit Commission of the HKSAR Government audits the financial statement of the Exchange Fund.

### Review of SFC and HKMA decisions
- SFC
  - Natural or legal persons adversely affected by SFC’s decisions or exercise of administrative authority can normally apply for judicial review.
  - “Specified decisions” are reviewed by the SFAT rather than the Court of First Instance; SFAT decisions are subject to higher appeal to the Court of Appeal on a point of law.
  - The SFAT is a full-time and independent tribunal established under Part XI of the SFO; it consists of a chairman (a judge) and two other members (who cannot be public officers and are expected to be market practitioners).
  - "Specified decisions" principally relate to licensing, discipline and operations of intermediaries, objections to listing applications and other listing matters (see Part 2 of Schedule 8 for list of specified decisions).
  - Reviews by the SFAT are reviews on the merits (a full review of the case and the decision).
  - Other means of challenge include complaints to the Ombudsman, Privacy Commissioner or the ICAC depending on subject matter.
  - An appeal to the Chief Executive in Council may be made in relation to certain decisions relating to exchange bodies and clearing houses (e.g., withdrawal of recognition or an order to cease operating facilities — see section 33 of the SFO) and in relation to withdrawal of recognition of an investor compensation company (section 86).
- HKMA
  - Decisions of HKMA are amenable to judicial review.
  - Under section 132A of the BO, a person or an AI may appeal to the CEHK in Council against a decision made by the MA (examples: refusal by the MA to give consent to a person to be chief executive of an AI under section 71(1) of the BO; proposed revocation of an AI’s authorization under section 22(1)).
  - An EO or ReI aggrieved by a disciplinary decision of HKMA may apply to the SFAT for review of the decision.

### Confidentiality and information sharing
- SFC
  - Section 378(1) of the SFO requires SFC to protect the confidentiality of information coming to its knowledge in the performance of its functions.
  - Section 378(3) permits disclosure of non-public information in summary form, and disclosure to a comprehensive list of domestic regulators and authorities specified in that section, and under section 378(3)(g) to overseas authorities.
- HKMA
  - Section 120(1) of the BO requires the MA and HKMA staff to preserve secrecy regarding affairs of any person that come to their knowledge in exercise of any function under the BO, except as necessary for exercising a function under the BO or carrying into effect its provisions.
  - Sections 120(5)(f) and (fa) permit disclosure to domestic regulatory authorities such as SFC, IA and MPFA and the FRC; for disclosure under section 120(5)(f) HKMA must be satisfied that the disclosure will enable the recipient to exercise its functions.
  - Section 121 allows HKMA to disclose information to overseas supervisory authorities provided the authority supervises banks or the securities and futures industry in its jurisdiction and is subject to adequate secrecy provisions.

### Assessment — governance and independence (Assessment: Partly Implemented)
- Assessment grade: Partly Implemented.
- Comments on the grade:
  - Grade stems from governance issues on both regulatory agencies in connection with questions 1a (HKMA) and 1a and b of the Methodology (SFC).
  - Assessors acknowledge that de facto both regulatory authorities enjoy sufficient independence in day to day operations, but identify features that can be pressure points for political or commercial influence:
    - The power of the Chief Executive to provide directions to both agencies; such directions can potentially concern handling of individual cases. Authorities emphasized these powers have not been used to date and would be a last resort in extreme circumstances.
    - The power of the CEHK to remove SFC board members without a clear framework to constrain such dismissal. Authorities noted some constraint from common law and that dismissal could be challenged under general administrative law.
    - For SFC, key decisions concerning exchanges must be consulted with (and a few approved by) the FS. Assessors note many countries keep some involvement by government in recognition of exchanges; other countries use a detailed policy framework for recognition that frames government participation. SFC (and HKMA) membership of the statutory committee on HKEx’s risk management could affect its ability to exercise independent oversight of critical aspects of HKEx’s operation because, through the RMC, it contributes to HKEx board decision making. Authorities are reviewing this issue.
    - For SFC, potential conflicts from participation of part-time board members, since the current framework allows them to be members of regulated entities and listed issuers. Part-time members bring expertise but can increase conflict-of-interest risk, especially as many decisions including enforcement decisions must be exercised directly by the board. A recusal process exists but managing frequent recusals can be challenging. Other regulators use advisory committees for expertise; SFC has an advisory committee under section 7 of the SFO.
  - At assessment outset, SFC budget approval process raised concerns about independence because it includes approval of number of positions allocated to departments. Conversations with authorities satisfied assessors that in practice this has not affected SFC’s stable funding or ability to reallocate staff; only a major “overhaul” of resources would require authorization from the FSTB. In practice, a contingency of about 10 percent is included in the SFC’s annual budget, providing some flexibility to meet unforeseen demands on resources.

### Principle 3 — powers, resources and capacity
- Description: Powers of the SFC and HKMA stem from the SFO, the BO and other legislation administered by the authorities.
- Both have broad licensing, supervision and investigation powers commensurate with mandates.
- SFC has multiple enforcement avenues including criminal and MMT proceedings, civil and administrative proceedings; enforcement powers are formally in line with Principles, with practical challenges discussed under Principle 12.
- HKMA’s enforcement powers are more limited; enforcement of securities laws and regulations is mainly a responsibility of the SFC (see further under Principle 10).

### Rules, codes and supervisory instruments in practice
- SFC:
  - Makes extensive use of rule-making and code-making powers.
  - Uses codes and guidelines to explain regulatory requirements to regulated persons and the public.
- HKMA:
  - Has power to make rules in limited BO-specified circumstances (examples: power to make rules about capital and liquidity requirements for AIs under sections 97C and 97H when it comes into operation).
  - Uses Circulars to influence conduct by regulated institutions. Examples include requiring RIs to adopt measures additional to those required under the SFO for AIs selling investment products: requiring AIs engaging in retail securities business to audio record the sale process in branches, and to physically segregate their retail securities business from their general banking business in branches.

### Funding (SFC)
- SFC is funded by levies for transactions recorded on exchanges.
- SFC also receives funding from fees or other charges related to share purchases, takeovers and mergers and applications for registration, authorization, approval, exemption, waiver or modification under the SFO.
- SFC has investment income in the form of interest income derived from investment of its reserves.
- SFC’s income for the 2012-3 year is budgeted at HK$1.170 billion.
- SFC has accumulated surpluses in excess of HK$7 billion.
- Budgets have been sufficient to enable significant increases in staff levels, especially in supervision and enforcement.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 169 of the SFO empowers SFC to issue codes of business conduct for intermediaries*

### Section 395 of the SFO provides that fees prescribed by the rules may be fixed at levels

### Section 395 of the SFO provides that fees prescribed by the rules may be fixed at levels 

### Funding, budgets, and resource allocation
- Section 395 of the SFO: fees prescribed by the rules may be fixed at levels sufficient to cover expenditure incurred, or likely to be incurred, by SFC in providing the services or performing the functions to which the fees relate. However, they are not limited to this criterion.
- The annual budget process is subject to scrutiny by the Administration and by LegCo.
- HKMA funding:
  - HKMA is funded from the Exchange Fund pursuant to sections 5A(3), 5A(4) and 6 of the EFO.
  - Annual license fees paid by AIs under section 19 of the BO also form part of the annual revenue of HKMA.
- HKMA budgeting:
  - HKMA draws up its annual budget to ensure that sufficient resources are available for carrying out its functions.
  - Budgeting takes into account both the continuing operations of HKMA and its strategic development set out in a three-year plan approved by the FS on the advice of the EFAC.
  - Budgets have been sufficient to make the necessary increases in staff levels, especially in conduct supervision and enforcement.
- Both regulators control the operational allocation of their resources.

### Staff resources and qualifications
- SFC remuneration and review:
  - SFC’s remuneration levels are broadly competitive with those of the market.
  - The Commission regularly reviews remuneration levels to calibrate the pay practices with that of a pre-determined peer group.
- SFC staffing levels (staffing level at end May 2013):
  - CEO’s Office and Central Services: 30
  - Corporate Finance: 63
  - Enforcement: 145
  - Investment Products: 89
  - Intermediaries — Licensing: 79
  - Intermediaries — Supervision: 128
  - Intermediaries total: 207
  - Supervision of markets: 33
  - Legal Services: 32
  - Corporate Affairs: 103
  - Total: 702
- Professional qualifications at SFC:
  - Approximately 28 percent of SFC staff have professional qualifications in accountancy.
  - 17 percent in law.
- HKMA staffing enhancements:
  - HKMA has increased and centralized the supervisory resources dedicated to conduct supervision.
  - A Banking Conduct Department with a current total of about 100 staff members (of which about 50 are specialized in the supervision of AIs’ conduct of securities, insurance and MPF intermediary activities) was established in April 2010.
  - An Enforcement Department with a current headcount of around 100 was established in April 2010.
  - In general, staff members possess relevant working experience in the banking or financial industry with tertiary education.

### Training
- Both SFC and HKMA provide training for staff.
- SFC staff all have individual development plans in which training needs are set out.

### Policies, governance, and procedural manuals
- SFC governance and manuals:
  - SFC has extensive policies and practice manuals and a rule book that govern the way regulatory work is carried out.
  - These include “PRP Manuals” that set out procedures to be followed in performing SFC functions.
  - Each operational division of SFC is required to have one or more procedures manuals that set out the procedures that must be followed in exercising its powers and discharging its functions.
- Process Review Panel (PRP):
  - Independent, non-statutory body comprising representatives from various community segments, the non-executive SFC Chairman and a representative from the Secretary for Justice (both in an ex-officio capacity).
  - Functions include reviewing SFC’s internal operational procedures, determining and reporting on adequacy of internal procedures and operational guidelines, and conducting reviews of files to check whether procedures are followed in practice.
  - PRP’s terms of reference cover procedures for complaint handling, licensing and inspection of intermediaries, corporate finance, disciplinary action etc., but not regulatory procedures and actions in relation to regulated markets.
  - The PRP reports at least annually to the FS. These reports are made public on the FSTB website.
- HKMA governance and manuals:
  - HKMA has an extensive policy manual (Supervisory Policy Manual {SPM}), with two parts setting out its approach to supervising AIs' securities and leveraged foreign exchange businesses.
  - Staff members follow the Operations Manual for Banking Conduct Department Division 1.
  - HKMA has enforcement procedural controls including an Event Review Committee to decide whether a case should be opened and the scope of any investigation.

### Investor education and consumer outreach
- SFC investor education:
  - SFC conducts investor and public education using multiple media: print materials, TV and radio programmes, outreach programmes, and a dedicated investor education website.
  - Formats include publications, talks, advertising campaigns, game shows and story competitions.
  - SFC’s statutory education mandate in the SFO was broadened following public consultation and legislative amendments.
  - The Investor Education Centre (IEC) was established as a wholly-owned subsidiary of SFC in November 2012 to oversee investor education and delivery of related initiatives for the entire financial sector in Hong Kong.
  - IEC governance: independent Executive Committee (IEC ExCo) comprised of representatives from SFC, HKMA, OCI and MPFA, the Education Bureau, a representative of the financial services industry and the General Manager of the IEC; the Chair of the IEC ExCo is a non-executive director of SFC.
  - IEC aims to be the focal point for financial education in Hong Kong.
- HKMA consumer education:
  - In December 2012, HKMA launched a “Consumer Corner” on its website providing information on local banking consumer issues and the HKMA’s role in banking conduct regulation.
  - HKMA is formulating a consumer education work plan involving the use of multiple channels to communicate effectively with the public.

### Assessment: implementation status and key observations
- Assessment: Fully implemented
- Comments and observations:
  - Regulators have been given broad licensing, supervisory and investigative powers vis-à-vis their respective mandates.
  - SFC has access to different avenues to seek enforcement actions for breaches to securities laws, including criminal and MMT proceedings, civil and administrative/disciplinary proceedings.
  - For misconduct that does not constitute a crime the current framework does not easily allow the SFC to secure both remedial and punitive actions; this affects enforcement effectiveness and is considered under Principle 12.
  - Codes: there appear to be sufficient precedents that establish that codes are enforceable for administrative and disciplinary proceedings.
  - Overall legal and regulatory framework provides a high level of transparency and consistency to day-to-day decisions.
  - Important exception: recognition of exchanges and authorization of ATS — current framework is very high level and would benefit from additional detail and transparency; authorities plan to formalize internal policies into a corresponding code for ATS and potentially guidelines for recognition of exchanges (issues discussed under Principle 33).
  - Use of HKMA circulars to impose additional conduct requirements on securities markets activities conducted by banks: critical that such circulars be subject to consultation.

### Consultation, transparency, and procedural fairness
- Consultation requirements:
  - SFC is obliged to consult publicly on any proposal to make or amend rules under any provision of the SFO (section 398 of the SFO) and, as a matter of practice, consults formally and informally on proposals to adopt new policy or non-statutory codes and guidelines in accordance with the Public Consultation Procedures published on its website.
  - HKMA is required to conduct a public consultation before making rules and standard practice is to consult the banking industry before amendments to the SPM or guidelines are made or new modules/guidelines are issued; HKMA staff indicated consultation on circulars involving new regulatory measures related to securities activities and that HKMA consulted the banking industry before each circular (about policy) issued over the past two years.
- Transparency of requirements:
  - SFO, BO and the rules, codes, guidelines and circulars establish clear and sufficiently detailed criteria for requirements and obligations of regulated activities, except for recognition of exchanges and authorization of ATS (see earlier).
- Procedural fairness — obligations to provide reasons and opportunity to be heard:
  - SFC required to provide reasons and opportunity to be heard in relation to: recognition of exchanges etc and their rules (Part III); authorization of products (Part IV); licensing decisions (Part V); disciplinary decisions (Part IX); compensation decisions if it proposes to provide compensation less than the amount claimed (Part XII and section 8 of the Claims Rules); and decisions to object to a proposed listing (section 6(7) of SMLR (Cap. 571V)).
  - Takeovers Panel policy: publish its rulings (section 16.1 of the Introduction to the Takeovers Code).
  - HKMA obligations under the BO: required to give reasons for refusal to give consent to act as an EO (section 71C(3)(b)); suspension or revocation of registration or consent to act as an EO or a ReI (sections 58A and 71C). While no specific obligation to give reasons for conditions attached to consent under section 71C(3)(a), in practice HKMA issues “letters of mindedness” specifying proposed conditions and reasons.

### Cost of compliance and review of decisions
- Cost/benefit analysis:
  - SFC is not obliged to carry out detailed cost/benefit economic analysis, but uses formal and informal consultation to inform itself about cost of compliance and takes these into account when finalizing rules, policy or codes and guidelines.
  - HKMA has no obligation to carry out formal cost/benefit analysis of proposed rules or guidelines but takes account of comments received, including on cost of compliance, in formal and informal consultations.
- Review of decisions: see under Principle 2 (in source).

### Confidentiality, investigations, and public disclosure
- Legal confidentiality/secrecy obligations:
  - SFC and HKMA subject to confidentiality/secrecy obligations (section 378 of the SFO; section 120 of the BO), with exceptions set out in legislation.
- SFC public disclosure:
  - SFC may publish press releases concerning criminal actions and civil proceedings commenced by SFC or against SFC once there has been a decision by the court and the information is public.
  - Under section 194(6A) and 196(6A) of the SFO, SFC has statutory authority to disclose to the public details of disciplinary action taken against a regulated person, the reasons for it and any material facts relating to the case; typically does so when the time for appeal against the disciplinary action has expired.
- HKMA public disclosure:
  - Section 120 of the BO preserves secrecy, subject to specific gateways of disclosure, in particular section 120(5)(i) with regard to public information.
  - HKMA may publish information on legal proceedings and judgments where such information is publicly available.
  - HKMA has statutory authority under sections 58A(4A) and 71C(7A) of the BO to disclose to the public details of any decision made under section 58A(1) and section 71C(4) against a ReI or an EO, the reasons, and material facts.
  - In June 2013, HKMA published a press release concerning disciplinary action taken by the HKMA against a ReI for misconduct in the selling of an investment linked assurance scheme.
- Assessment: Fully implemented

### Staff conduct, conflicts of interest, and restrictions on securities trading
- Codes of conduct and staff obligations:
  - SFC staff required to comply with statutory provisions, SFC Employee Handbook and SFC Code of Conduct.
  - HKMA staff required to comply with HKMA Code of Conduct, Rules on Appointment and Discipline, and HKMA Administration Circular No. 2/2012 - Rules on Restrictions on Investments by HKMA Staff.
  - Staff of both SFC and HKMA subject to the Prevention of Bribery Ordinance.
- Conflicts of interest:
  - Section 379 of the SFO makes it a criminal offence for staff of SFC (including directors) to enter (directly or indirectly) into transactions which would create a conflict of interest; staff must inform SFC immediately if required to consider any matter relating to a transaction or corporation in which they have an interest or in relation to a person by whom they were employed, who is or was an associate, or of whom they are or were a client.
  - SFC Code of Conduct paragraph 2.1 requires staff to take appropriate steps to avoid actual and potential conflicts of interest, including appearance of loss of impartiality; obligations extend to transactions under investigation by an overseas financial regulator.
  - HKMA Code of Conduct provides guidelines on acceptance of advantages, conflict of interest, investment restrictions and confidentiality of information.
- Securities trading restrictions:
  - SFC Code of Conduct requirements:
    - Initial Disclosure Obligation: on commencement of employment staff must declare all direct or indirect holdings of securities and futures contracts (page 13).
    - Ongoing Disclosure Obligation: all transactions in securities or futures contracts must be disclosed within 2 trading days of the transaction (page 14).
    - Restrictions on dealing by Executive Directors (EDs):
      - No ED may deal in any securities except the Pilot Programme Securities and securities held through the medium of CIS or investment companies.
      - No ED shall in any manner transact any trading in any securities (other than through a CIS and certain US securities) and any futures contract as (page 17).
    - Restrictions on dealing by staff:
      - Minimum Holding Period: staff must hold each investment for a minimum of 30 days after it has been purchased.
      - Index List: for securities, staff may invest only in securities included in the index list prescribed by SFC.
      - Derivatives: staff must not engage in derivatives transactions (some narrow exceptions apply).
      - IPOs: staff must not subscribe for shares of corporations or interests in REITs or ETFs unless authorized by the Commission.
      - Margin Financing: staff must not use margin financing.
  - HKMA Rules on Restrictions on Investments by HKMA Staff and paragraph 4.6 of the HKMA Staff Handbook:
    - All HKMA staff required to report any purchase of shares or warrants and structured products, as well as purchases of foreign currency and funds involving HK$100,000 or more.
    - Staff in the Banking Departments and designated staff having access to data on AIs are prohibited from purchasing shares or warrants of any AI.
- Use of information and confidentiality in conduct:
  - Paragraph 25 of the HKMA Code of Conduct: staff with access to proprietary information should provide adequate safeguards to prevent abuse or misuse; unauthorized disclosure may constitute a criminal offence or disciplinary case.
  - Paragraph 26 of the HKMA Code of Conduct: staff should be mindful handling personal data; unauthorized disclosure may breach the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance.
  - SFC and HKMA staff are both subject to confidentiality obligations under the SFO and BO; HKMA staff are also subject to Parts III and IV of the Official Secrets Ordinance.

*cr14205 - Section 395 of the SFO provides that fees prescribed by the rules may be fixed at levels*

### 5.1 of the HKMA Staff Handbook deals with obligations relating to classified information.

### _cr14205 - 5.1 of the HKMA Staff Handbook deals with obligations relating to classified information

### Obligations on classified information and procedural fairness
- SFC and HKMA staff are bound by the principles of procedural fairness under common law in the performance of their functions.
- See also cross-references under Principles 2 and 4.

### Processes for dealing with violations and sanctions
- Complaints about misconduct by SFC staff:
  - Examined by the Senior Director, Corporate Affairs, who is the most senior officer not responsible for an operational division.
  - If misconduct is found, a staff member may be subject to disciplinary action, or to criminal sanctions such as those that apply to breaches of confidentiality obligations.
  - Reported instance: there has been only one case related to a violation of the ethics code. In that case the employee was issued a written warning. Consultation with the SFC Legal Services Department determined that no additional disciplinary action was needed.
- Complaints about misconduct in HKMA:
  - Examined by an appointed person at least one rank senior than the person in question.
  - Staff guilty of misconduct are liable to disciplinary action, including criminal sanctions.
  - The HKMA informed that no cases have been presented of violations to the ethical codes.
- Assessment for ethics/violations processes: Fully implemented

### Principle 6 — Regulator’s role in monitoring, mitigating and managing systemic risk
- Description: Entity responsible for systemic risk in securities markets
  - The SFC is responsible for the administration of the laws governing the securities and futures markets in Hong Kong.
  - The SFO gives the SFC the objective of reducing systemic risks in the securities and futures industry; and assisting the FS in maintaining the financial stability of Hong Kong by taking appropriate steps in relation to the securities and futures industry.
- Evolution of approach:
  - Historically relied mainly on a bottom up approach via operational departments.
  - In 2012, the R&S was created to bring a centralized approach to risk.
- Internal inputs to risk identification:
  - Supervision of markets: daily market monitoring; access to trading data, settlement reports from CCPs, large open position and short position reports, flow of funds data; exceptional market drop reports provided to FS and SFC ExCo when there are significant market corrections.
  - Corporate Finance and Investment Products: authorization records and ongoing monitoring; collection of information on exposure (example: Investment Products Division collected information from major fund managers on schemes’ exposure to European countries during the sovereign debt crisis in Europe).
  - Intermediaries Supervision: off- and on-site monitoring, thematic reviews, surveys (examples: distribution of unlisted products, activities of HF managers).
- External inputs:
  - HKMA: provides inputs on risks arising from securities market activities of banks; shares quarterly survey on products distribution; MoU meetings and informal communication.
  - Meetings with industry participants: R&S conducted risk-focused industry meetings starting March 2013 with ten global institutions; produced “Risk-focused Industry Meeting Series: G-SIFI Trends in Risk and Risk Mitigation”.
  - R&S monitors industry trends via liaison meetings, subscription to real time market data and news, industry research, and market intelligence through R&S members.
- Internal coordination mechanisms:
  - Weekly management meetings: main vehicle for sharing emerging issues.
  - Biweekly ExCo meetings: more formal; “spotlight on risk” being added.
  - Quarterly Policy Meetings of the Board: instituted recently; so far only six have taken place.
  - Cross-department/functional working groups for specific policy projects.
- R&S activities and outputs:
  - Identified tightening of US monetary policy as an emerging risk theme in mid-2012 based on (i) large bond fund sales volumes in Hong Kong and globally, and (ii) a rapid rise in the volume of issuance of high yield bonds, especially by Chinese enterprises.
  - Issued a circular on 19 November 2012 to LCs and RIs entitled “Selling of Fixed Income Products” (joint inputs from the SFC and HKMA); HKMA issued a similar circular on the same date.
  - December 2013: R&S published “G-SIFI Trends in Risk and Risk Mitigation”.
  - January 2014: R&S produced a report on Bitcoin shared with regulatory counterparties and IOSCO Committee on Emerging Risk.
  - Development and implementation of a risk register (a “living” document) and an associated Risk Heat Map; automated and accessible on the internal R&S portal.
  - R&S portal integrates reports, internal risk register, R&S Global Regulatory and Macro newsletter and other research.
- Development of expertise:
  - R&S comprises four professional staff with legal, front office derivatives trading, prudential and conduct risk governance experience.
  - SFC staff participate in the IOSCO Emerging Risk Committee and use products such as the IOSCO Risk dashboard and the annual IOSCO Securities Markets Risk Outlook.
- Coordination in connection with financial stability — committees and meeting frequencies:
  - FSC: meets monthly; participants include SFST (chair), SFC (CEO, ED, SOM), HKMA (CE), OCI (Commissioner). Responsibilities include regular monitoring of the financial system, deliberating on events with cross-sector/systemic implications, and reporting to the FS.
  - CFR: meets quarterly; membership includes FS (Chair), SFC (CEO,ED/SOM), HKMA (CE), OCI (commissioner), MPFA (managing Director), and SFST.
  - Securities and Futures Liaison Committee (SFLC): meets monthly; made up of SFST and SFC (CEO, EDs of all divisions, Chief Counsel, Commission Secretary).
  - FS Meetings: monthly meetings attended by the FS, SFST and SFC (Chairman, CEO).
  - Tripartite meetings: bi-monthly meetings among SFST, SFC (Chairman, CEO, ED, Corporate Finance Division/ED, SOM) and the HKEx.
  - RMC: statutory committee; meets monthly; composed of the HKEx Board Chairman and seven other members.
- Assessment: Broadly implemented
- Assessment comments:
  - Authorities are making significant progress; R&S centralization and the risk register improve top-down view and ExCo/Board level discussion.
  - The risk register and Heat Map aim to improve monitoring of actions and their effectiveness.

### Principle 7 — Process to review the perimeter of regulation regularly
- Description: Identification of risks and perimeter review
  - SFC relies mainly on the bottom up approach (operational divisions) complemented by external sources (HKMA, industry risk meetings).
  - Issues are discussed in weekly meetings and biweekly ExCo meetings; matters of sufficient concern are brought to the board and, when appropriate, to HKMA and other public authorities.
  - Board instituted quarterly policy meetings to enable more substantive discussions.
- External committees that assist perimeter review:
  - Advisory Committee: established under section 7 of the SFO; meets quarterly; advises on policy initiatives, listing-related matters, Mainland and international regulatory developments; non-official members from brokers, funds, listed companies, legal, and banking sectors.
  - Specialized committees (examples):
    - Committee on REITs: advises on Code on REITs and related market/development issues.
    - Products Advisory Committee: consulted on matters relating to the Products Handbook, the SFC Code on MPF Products and the Code on Pooled Retirement Funds.
    - Public Shareholders Group: advises on regulatory framework relating to shareholders’ interests; met three times in 2012 on issues including IPO regime review and a proposal on the new prospectus regime.
    - Takeovers and Mergers Panel: reviews the Takeovers Code and Rules of Procedure; recommends amendments to the SFC.
- Role of R&S and Risk Register:
  - Risk Register includes an assessment of “Perimeter”; R&S will work with other divisions, including the Legal Services Division, on items requiring perimeter analysis and/or extension.
  - The Risk Register allows prioritization and follow up of decisions, including perimeter reviews.
- Examples of perimeter adjustments:
  - ILAS: coordinated actions by Government and financial regulators to address disparity in regulatory requirements across sectors for distribution of ILAS (see Principle 1).
  - Enhancements to IPO sponsor regime: to strengthen disclosure quality and sponsor obligations; SFC requested legislative amendments to clarify civil and criminal responsibility of sponsors for due diligence.
- Other drivers of perimeter projects:
  - OTC derivatives reform, development of a resolution framework, increased interconnection with the Mainland, and the new business strategy of the HKEx.
- Assessment: Broadly implemented
- Assessment comments:
  - Need to further strengthen processes for identifying and monitoring emerging risks and for addressing perimeter issues, as planned by the SFC.
  - Assessors encourage proactive identification and addressing of challenges from increased interconnection with the Mainland and HKEx’s new business strategy (implications for supervision and competition).

### Principle 8 — Managing conflicts of interest and misaligned incentives
- Description for regulated entities:
  - Regulatory framework requires mechanisms to identify, monitor and mitigate conflicts of interest.
  - Framework for intermediaries is principles based and establishes three actions: avoidance, control and disclosure (see Principle 31).
  - Conflicts of interest obligations also apply to auditors (see Principle 20), credit rating agencies (see Principle 22), sell side analysts (see Principle 23), and SROs (see Principle 9).
  - SFC (and HKMA) review compliance via licensing and ongoing supervisory programs; at licensing stage applicant policies/procedures are reviewed; SFC can issue guidelines or take enforcement action for compliance problems.
- Specific measures:
  - 2010 measures to enhance intermediary conduct and sale of investment products: required enhanced disclosure at or prior to point of sale on intermediary capacity (principal or agent), affiliation with product issuer, and monetary and non-monetary benefits received for distribution.
  - 2010 HKMA Banking Conduct Department established; HKMA circulars require AIs engaging in retail securities business to audio record sales processes in branches and to physically segregate retail securities business from general banking business in branches.
  - Investor education initiatives by SFC: published articles, newsletters and booklets to illustrate new regulatory disclosure requirements and potential conflicts of interest.
- Issuers:
  - Main mechanism to address misalignment of incentives is public disclosure.
  - Family-owned structure of the majority of listed companies identified as a key source of conflicts of interest in HKSAR; strict framework for transactions between related parties is in place (see Principle 17).
  - Structured products: SFC Code for non listed structured products requires manufacturers to design products fairly and appropriate for intended markets.
- Assessment: Fully implemented

### Principle 9 — Oversight of Self-Regulatory Organizations (SROs)
- Description: SROs in Hong Kong
  - The HKEx and its member exchanges perform an SRO function; clearing houses owned by HKEx play supervisory functions for clearing and settlement.
  - No other Hong Kong-based entities operate exchange markets in Hong Kong. The Hong Kong Mercantile Exchange had been an ATS authorized under Part III (sections 95-101) of the SFO but its authorization was withdrawn in May 2013.
- The HKEx group:
  - HKEx is a recognised exchange controller under the SFO; owns and operates the only stock exchange and a futures exchange in Hong Kong and related clearing houses.
  - Exchanges:
    - SEHK operates a stock market in Hong Kong and under section 19(1)(a) of the SFO is the only exchange permitted to trade equity securities in Hong Kong.
    - HKFE is a REC under the SFO.
  - HKEx wholly owns the London Metal Exchange.
  - Recognised clearing houses owned/operated by HKEx:
    - Hong Kong Securities Clearing Company Limited (HKSCC)
    - The SEHK Options Clearing House Limited (SEOCH)
    - HKFE Clearing Corporation Limited (HKCC)
- Governance:
  - HKEx is a listed company; the Government of Hong Kong retains 5.8 percent of the shares.
  - Under section 77 of the SFO, the FS has power to appoint up to eight directors of HKEx when appropriate in the interest of the investing public or in the public interest.
  - Of the current board of 13 directors, 6 (including the Chairman) were appointed by the FS. The Chief Executive is the only executive director.
  - No government officials have been appointed by the FS as members of the board of directors of HKEx.
  - The boards of SEHK and HKFE are appointed by HKEx as the sole shareholder.

*Source: _cr14205 - 5.1 of the HKMA Staff Handbook deals with obligations relating to classified information.*

### Section 26 of the SFO provides that the approval of SFC is required for the appointment of the

### _cr14205 - Section 26 of the SFO provides that the approval of SFC is required for the appointment of the

### Division of responsibilities between SFC and HKEx
- CEHK power under section 25(1) of the SFO: at the request of SFC, may delegate to a recognized exchange specified regulatory functions, including licensing of participants and approval of prospectuses. In practice, only the power to approve prospectuses is delegated.
- SFC direct responsibilities:
  - a. licensing of all market participants;
  - b. monitoring market participants’ compliance with the SFO and subsidiary legislation, and SFC codes, and acting on non-compliance;
  - c. monitoring the market and acting on suspected market abuse and insider dealing;
  - d. monitoring issuers’ compliance with the obligation to disclose inside information and acting on non-compliance;
  - e. monitoring compliance with the disclosure of interests provisions in Part XV of the SRO (substantial shareholding and short positions) and acting on non-compliance;
  - f. approving prospectuses and offer documents other than for listed equity and debt securities and listed structured products. (Offer documents for listed CIS products are approved by the SFC);
  - g. approving new exchange products through the rule approval process;
  - h. monitoring exchanges’ compliance with obligations under the SFO.
- HKEx and its exchanges are responsible for:
  - a. deciding applications for admission as an exchange participant;
  - b. monitoring compliance by market participants with exchange rules and acting on non-compliance;
  - c. admitting issuers to listing;
  - d. under delegated authority, approving prospectuses and offer documents for listed equity and debt securities, and for listed structured products;
  - e. monitoring compliance by issuers with the Listing Rules and acting on non-compliance;
  - f. monitoring the market to ensure that trading is orderly.
- In practice: HKEx and the exchanges perform a self-regulatory function primarily in relation to the listing function performed by SEHK. Other regulatory functions are performed by SFC.

### Admission of participants
- Entities wishing to participate directly in trading on SEHK or HKFE must apply to become an exchange participant of the relevant market.
- SEHK or HKFE has the right to admit or refuse admission; decisions are final and cannot be appealed against.
- Eligibility requirements and ongoing obligations are stipulated in the Rules and Regulations of HKFE and SEHK.
- One eligibility criterion: persons should be corporations licensed by the SFC.

### Admission to listing and listing function
- SEHK is the front line regulator of listed companies: admits companies and products for listing, grants waivers associated with listing, and monitors and enforces disclosure requirements under the listing rules.
- SEHK administers:
  - Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on SEHK (Main Board Listing Rules);
  - Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on the GEM (GEM Listing Rules).
- Under sections 23 and 24 of the SFO, SEHK must submit any proposed rule or change of the Listing Rules to the SFC for prior approval before implementation.
- SEHK submits a monthly report to the SFC on SEHK listing activities for the Main Board and GEM.
- SFC and SEHK hold monthly meetings pursuant to the 2003 MoU to discuss the monthly report, listing regulation matters, SFC oversight, and policy matters.
- SFC conducts annual reviews of SEHK’s listing related functions in accordance with the 2003 MoU; SFC’s annual review reports are published on the SFC website.
- SFC review process focuses on procedures and processes used by SEHK’s Listing Division, reviewing sample cases and interviewing Heads of Departments.
- In 2012, SFC performed thematic review of the Listing Division’s processes regarding:
  - a. processing listing applications in respect of Initial Public Offering (IPO) of equity securities;
  - b. processing structured products listing applications; and
  - c. dissemination of listed company information.

### Rules, market rules and disciplinary powers
- Recognized exchange companies (SEHK and HKFE) establish and enforce binding rules of trading, business conduct and qualification for membership.
- All exchange participants must comply with exchange rules; breaches subject to disciplinary actions by the exchange.
- Under section 23(1) of the SFO a recognized exchange company may make rules for matters necessary or desirable for:
  - a. proper regulation and efficient operation of the market it operates;
  - b. proper regulation of its exchange participants and holders of trading rights;
  - c. establishment and maintenance of compensation arrangements for the investing public.
- Section 24 of the SFO: no rule of recognized exchange companies or any rule amendment has effect unless it has the approval in writing of the SFC.
- Section 36: SFC, after consulting the FS and relevant exchange, has authority to make statutory rules on market activity matters (e.g., listing of securities and persons who may be admitted as exchange participants); exchange rules inconsistent with statutory rules are ineffective to the extent of inconsistency.
- SEHK and HKFE have Trading Rules governing participation; rules apply equally to all participants.
- SEHK and HKFE disciplinary rules enable sanctions for non-compliance, including censure, fines, suspension or withdrawal of trading rights.

### Recognition of exchange companies and statutory duties
- Section 19 of the SFO provides for recognition of exchange companies; SFC must be satisfied recognition is appropriate in the interest of the investing public, public interest, or proper regulation of markets.
- Before granting recognition SFC must consult with the public and the FS and may impose conditions.
- Section 63(1) duty of a recognized exchange controller (or controller of a recognized clearing house) to ensure so far as reasonably practicable:
  - a. an orderly, informed and fair market in securities or futures contracts traded on the stock or futures market operated by the recognized exchange company or through its facilities;
  - b. orderly, fair and expeditious clearing and settlement arrangements for transactions cleared or settled through the facilities of the recognized clearing house;
  - c. that risks associated with its business and operations are managed prudently;
  - d. that the recognized exchange company or recognized clearing house complies with any lawful requirement placed on it under any enactment or rule of law and with any other legal requirement.
- Section 21(1) duty of a recognized exchange company to ensure:
  - a. so far as reasonably practicable, an orderly, informed and fair market for its stock market or futures market; and
  - b. that risks associated with its business and operations are managed prudently.
- Section 21(2): in discharging this duty a recognized exchange company must:
  - a. act in the interest of the public, having particular regard to the interest of the investing public; and
  - b. ensure that the interest of the public prevails where it conflicts with the interest of the recognized exchange company.

### Co-operation, MoUs and oversight activities
- SFC has MoUs with HKEx governing their relationship:
  - 2001 MoU: matters relating to SFC oversight, supervision of exchange participants and market surveillance; terms of cooperation and obligations, review of HKEx operations by SFC, data and information provision. If HKEx becomes aware of a serious matter as set out in Appendix I of the MoU, it will, to the extent permitted by law, notify the SFC as soon as practicable.
  - 2003 MoU: matters relating to listing.
- SFC market supervision functions described under the Principles for Secondary Markets; SFC maintains constant contact with exchanges for ongoing monitoring.
- 2001 MoU provides SFC may carry out onsite reviews of operations of HKEx, exchange companies and clearing houses; MoU sets cooperation procedures for onsite inspection.
- SFC planned its first onsite review of HKEx and its exchanges and clearing houses in 2014 to assess discharge of statutory duties under the SFO including monitoring and enforcement of trading and clearing rules, and handling conflicts of interest.
- Regular meetings schedule:
  - a. meetings between senior management of HKEx and SFC (monthly or bimonthly);
  - b. RMC meetings (monthly includes other parties as well as SFC and HKEx);
  - c. meetings between SFC, HKEx and FSTB (bimonthly);
  - d. meetings between SFC market supervision team and HKEx IT team (quarterly).
- SEHK listing reporting and SFC review cycle: monthly reporting by SEHK, monthly meetings under 2003 MoU, annual SFC reviews and published reports.

### Professional standards and handling conflicts of interest
- Recognized exchange controller, recognized exchange company and recognized clearing house must fulfill statutory duties in the SFO and observe secrecy provisions in Section 378 of the SFO.
- Disciplinary procedures provide right to appeal; laws of natural justice apply and right to judicial review is available.
- Handling potential conflicts of interest in the listing function:
  - a. dual filing system: SFC also reviews prospectuses and has a power of veto;
  - b. Listing Committee makes formal decision on listing applications; Listing Committee comprises 28 individuals, including 8 investor representatives; 19 persons who provide a balance of representatives of listed companies and market practitioners; and the HKEx’s CEO. Rules for conflicts of interest set out in paragraph 9 of the Guidance for Member of the Board and Committees of HKEx require a member to declare any conflicting interest and not to take part in any matter where there is such a conflict. Individuals are nominated by a Nominating Committee comprised of three HKEx directors, and the SFC’s Chairman, CEO and Executive Director Corporate Finance;
  - c. HKEx’s Listing Division is separated from the rest of HKEx by an information barrier (Chinese wall). The head of listing is not permitted to discuss listing applications with any other part of HKEx, except the CEO in his capacity as a member of the Listing Committee. HKEx board may from time to time make comment on the Listing Rules and proposals for changes to them;
  - d. Listing Division is the sole gateway for applicants for listing; SFC inquiries about a listing application are channeled through the Listing Division.
- HKEx self-listing regulation:
  - a. Chapter 38 of the Main Board Listing Rules and Chapter 36 of the GEM Listing Rules contain provisions specifically dealing with the listing of HKEx and powers/functions of the SFC in event of conflict of interest;
  - b. 2001 MoU between SFC, HKEx and SEHK addresses self-listing interactions, compliance, enforcement, SFC supervision and conflicts of interest, and market integrity.
- Section 75 of the SFO: where SFC is satisfied a conflict of interest does or may exist, SFC has powers and functions with respect to performance of regulatory powers and functions by HKEx or any company of which it is the controller.

### Oversight assessment and issues identified
- Assessment: Broadly implemented
- Comments and findings:
  - The view that HKEx is a “public utility” and the monopoly granted by the SFO has triggered a level of Government involvement with HKEx uncommon in developed jurisdictions.
  - Government involvement manifests in consultation and approval of certain exchange measures by the FS and appointment of a significant number of board members of HKEx by the FS.
  - Such involvement could pose conflicts regarding implementation of a strong oversight framework of HKEx.
  - Importance of a rigorous and transparent director appointment process and that persons selected are not government officials; assessors note that no government officials have been appointed.
  - RMC provides coordinated policy benefits but results in SFC and HKMA involvement in decision-making on matters where SFC later must make regulatory decisions or actions (example: PFMIs and resulting rule changes). Current RMC involvement does not foster an appropriate arms’ length relationship between regulators and HKEx.
  - Review concluded current arrangements for direct SRO functions of the exchange and conflict of interest handling in those functions are robust, including:
    - separation of the listing function;
    - SFC approval of HKEx rules;
    - four eye principle for decisions on new listings (SFC can object to HKEx decisions);
    - on-site inspections of the listing function.
  - On market function: SFC should consider whether decisions on the admission of participants should be subject to an appeal process (for example by SFC), particularly given HKEx’s monopoly position.
  - As HKEx implements a new business strategy, robust arrangements related to the market function become more relevant.
  - Issues of concern remain regarding limitations to competition, but these arise from SFO policies granting a monopoly to SEHK and are not considered for the grade of principle 9.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 26 of the SFO provides that the approval of SFC is required for the appointment of the (PDF).*

### Section 180 of the SFO creates a general power to obtain information from and inspect the

### _cr14205 - Section 180 of the SFO creates a general power to obtain information from and inspect the

### Information-gathering and inspection powers
- Section 180 of the SFO creates a general power to obtain information from and inspect the business operations and the books and records of regulated institutions and their associated entities at any reasonable time. This power is available both to SFC and to HKMA.
- HKMA also has powers under the BO to require production of books and records and to conduct inspections of AIs, including AIs that are also RIs (sections 55 and 56). HKMA routinely uses both SFO and BO powers in its dealing with RIs.
- On-site inspections:
  - Can be carried out without notice but the exercise of the power must be reasonable in the circumstances.
  - Judicial action is not required and inspections may be carried out on a routine basis as well as in response to a particular inquiry.
  - There is no requirement for the regulator to suspect misconduct before exercising these powers.
- Section 181 of the SFO gives SFC power to require a shareholder, a person who holds an interest in an investment product (securities, futures, CIS etc), a person who has conducted a transaction in an investment product, or an LC or RI to provide identity, transaction and holding details.
- Section 71 of the SFO allows the SFC to require any exchange company or clearing house to provide trade and client information, including information in its possession or under its control that relates to the affairs of any of its members.
- SFC conducts real-time surveillance of the trading activities of both the stock market and the futures market at the HKEx using specialised systems to monitor the markets on a real-time basis every day.

### Record keeping, client identity, and AML/CTF requirements
- Record keeping:
  - Securities and Futures (Keeping of Records) Rules require all SFC intermediaries and RIs and their associated entities to keep records containing sufficient details to explain their business activities and operations and account of their client assets, and to keep these records for not less than 7 years.
- Customer identity:
  - SFC’s Code of Conduct requires LCs and RIs to obtain and keep information on the ownership and control of transaction accounts and prohibits them from executing transactions on behalf of clients unless they hold the required information (see paragraph 5.4 of the Code).
  - SFC’s Client Identity Rule Policy provides for a no action approach where it is not practicable to obtain details of an ultimate beneficiary before a transaction (for example where the client is an overseas financial institution’s omnibus client account). In that case, it is sufficient if the relevant information is provided to SFC or one of the Hong Kong exchanges within 2 days of a request.
- Anti-Money Laundering / Counter-Terrorist Financing:
  - Section 20 of Schedule 2 to the AMLO requires financial institutions (including LCs and RIs), in relation to each transaction carried out by them, to keep the original or a copy of the documents and a record of the data and information obtained in connection with the transaction.
  - The Guideline on Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing requires that the records be sufficient to permit reconstruction of individual transactions and establish a financial profile of any suspect account or customer.
  - These records must be kept for 6 years from transaction date, and SFC can require a longer period.
- SFC has access to records and customer information using its information gathering powers.
- Section 179 of the SFO gives SFC the power to require production of records and documents concerning listed corporations.

### Outsourcing of inspections
- SFC does not outsource or grant inspection or enforcement authority to any third party.
- SFC may occasionally engage external consultants to assist in performing inspections on LCs in some specialised areas; such engagements specify scope and procedures in the letter of engagement and require SFC prior agreement for any material adjustments.
- Consultants are bound by the confidentiality obligations under section 180 of the SFO.
- HKMA uses its own staff to carry out inspections.

### SFC investigation powers (Principle 11)
- Section 179 (Issuers):
  - Power to compel a corporation that was or is listed, its related companies, banks, auditors and any other person to produce records and documents specified by the SFC investigator.
  - Power to require explanations or statements in respect of the records or documents (section 179(3)).
  - Circumstances for exercise include situations suggesting: a corporation’s business conducted with intent to defraud creditors; for fraudulent or unlawful purpose; in a manner oppressive to members; corporation formed for fraudulent purpose; misconduct in listing process; management misconduct; or members not given expected information.
- General investigation power (section 182):
  - SFC can direct employees to conduct investigations where it has reasonable cause to believe a person may have engaged in defalcation, fraud, misfeasance or other misconduct in connection with:
    - dealing in any securities or futures contract or trading in any leveraged foreign exchange contract;
    - the management of investment in any securities, futures contract or leveraged foreign exchange contract;
    - offering or making any structured product, leveraged foreign exchange contract or CIS;
    - giving advice in relation to allotment, acquisition, disposal or investment in securities, structured products, futures contracts, leveraged foreign exchange contracts, or interests therein;
    - any transaction involving securities margin financing;
  - or where market misconduct may have taken place; or where the manner of engagement is not in the interest of the investing public or public interest.
- Powers following commencement of an investigation (section 183):
  - Power to compel both unregulated and regulated natural and non-natural persons to produce information and documents relevant to the investigation, including bank records, telephone and any electronic records.
  - Power to compel regulated and unregulated individuals to attend interviews and provide statements.
  - Power to apply to the court for search warrants at premises of supervised and unregulated persons, including listed companies (section 191).
  - Section 183 allows compulsion of contemporaneous records sufficient to reconstruct all securities and derivatives transactions, including records of all funds and assets transferred into and out of bank and brokerage accounts relating to those transactions.
- Telecommunications and bank records:
  - Using section 183, SFC has access to telecommunications providers’ information about whether telephone calls between parties under investigation and others have occurred.
  - Under section 183(4), SFC can require a bank to disclose information or produce records relating to the affairs of a customer where the SFC is satisfied that the customer may give information relevant to the investigation and that disclosure/production is necessary for the purposes of the investigation and certifies this in writing.
- Compelling persons to provide information (section 183(1)–(3)):
  - SFC can require a person under investigation or anyone believed to possess relevant information to attend an interview and answer truthfully questions relating to matters under investigation.
  - Individuals must answer questions but may claim privilege so that answers may not be used in evidence against them in subsequent criminal proceedings.
  - SFC can require the interviewee to verify statements by statutory declaration or to verify by statutory declaration that required information was not within his knowledge or possession (sections 183(2) and (3)).

### HKMA investigation powers and limits
- HKMA powers to investigate are contained in:
  - Section 55, 63(2) and 72A(2) of the BO which empower the HKMA to conduct examination and investigation of the books, accounts and transactions of AIs and to require ReIs and EOs to submit information to the HKMA; and
  - Section 180(1)(c) of the SFO which gives similar powers to the HKMA to make inquiries of intermediaries, associated entities, related corporations, or any other person whom it has reasonable cause to believe has information or records relevant to the investigation. These persons are required under section 180(4) to give access to and produce records and documents and answer any question raised by the HKMA.
- Limitations:
  - Under the BO or the SFO the HKMA does not have some of the investigation powers available to the SFC under section 183 of the SFO, such as the power to compel a regulated or unregulated person to give a written statement.
  - Senior HKMA staff indicated that the absence of this power does not constitute a limitation in practice, given that under the current legal framework the enforcement function in connection with breaches arising from the securities markets activities of banks belongs to the SFC.

### SFC enforcement powers and sanctions
- Overview:
  - SFC has a range of enforcement powers to take criminal, MMT, civil, administrative and other actions.
- Criminal prosecutions:
  - SFC can initiate criminal prosecutions at the Magistrates’ Court for offences to be tried summarily (section 388(1)). For more serious offences triable on indictment, SFC refers cases to the DoJ. Article 63 of the Basic Law provides that the DoJ has overall control over criminal prosecutions.
  - Many breaches of the SFO are criminal offences, including:
    - market misconduct (six types, including insider dealing, false trading, price rigging, disclosure of information about prohibited transactions, disclosure of false or misleading information inducing transaction, and stock market manipulation) (Part XIII and Part XIV);
    - conduct of unauthorized markets (section 19(1));
    - unauthorized offers of investment products (section 103(1));
    - unlicensed conduct of regulated activities (section 114).
  - Market misconduct offences are indictable and can be tried summarily or on indictment. Penalties:
    - Summary conviction for market abuse offences: maximum penalty of HK$1 million dollars and 3 years’ imprisonment.
    - Conviction on indictment: HK$10 million and 10 years imprisonment (section 303(1)).
  - Additional criminal-proceeding remedies:
    - Ban a convicted person from being a director or manager of any listed corporation or from taking part in management for a maximum period of 5 years.
    - Ban a convicted person from dealing in securities in Hong Kong for a maximum period of 5 years.
    - Issue an order recommending professional disciplinary action (section 303).
- Market Misconduct Tribunal (MMT) proceedings:
  - SFC can institute proceedings in the MMT for market misconduct (sections 252 and 252A). Institution of MMT proceedings bars criminal proceedings for the same conduct (section 307).
  - MMT is an independent quasi-judicial body (section 251), chaired by a judge or former judge of the High Court who sits with two members.
  - MMT jurisdiction covers all six types of market misconduct and listed corporations’ breaches of disclosure of price sensitive information.
  - Decisions use the civil burden of proof (balance of probabilities).
  - MMT can make prohibition and cease and desist orders (section 257) and disgorgement orders not exceeding the amount of any profit gained or loss avoided as a result of the market misconduct. MMT cannot impose fines.
  - Failure to comply with MMT orders is an offence with maximum sanction of a fine of $1,000,000 and imprisonment for 2 years (section 257(10)).
- Civil proceedings:
  - SFC can apply to the civil court for injunctive or other remedial civil orders (section 213), including injunctions, remedial orders, ancillary orders (including freezing of assets or appointment of an administrator or receiver), and statutory rescission (reversal of transactions).
  - SFC can apply for orders to remedy unfair prejudice in a listed company (section 214): injunctions, disqualification orders, compensation orders to the company, and orders to require the listed company to bring action against directors.
  - SFC may present a petition for bankruptcy against a licensed or registered person or apply to the Court of First Instance for company winding up (section 212).
- Administrative/Disciplinary proceedings:
  - Sections 194 and 196 empower SFC to take disciplinary action against regulated entities (including LCs and their responsible officers (ROs) and representatives, and RIs and their EOs and ReIs) for failure to supervise properly subordinate personnel whose activities violate the securities laws. Available sanctions include:
    - revoke a license or registration wholly or in part;
    - suspend or partially suspend a license or registration;
    - revoke approval to be a RO;
    - suspend approval to be a RO;
    - prohibit a person from applying for a license or registration;
    - prohibit a person from applying to become a RO, EO or ReI;
    - impose a fine (up to the maximum of HK$10 million or 3 times of the profit gained/loss avoided, whichever is the higher);
    - reprimand.
  - SFC has power to impose restrictions on a licensed or registered person as regards its business activities or dealing with assets or maintenance of assets (sections 204 to 210).
  - SFC does not have the power to impose disgorgement or to require compensation of clients that have suffered losses.
- SFC power to require information:
  - Section 183 allows compulsion of production of contemporaneous records sufficient to reconstruct securities and derivatives transactions, including records of all funds and assets transferred into and out of bank and brokerage accounts relating to those transactions.
  - SFC has broad powers to obtain records and information from regulated entities and other persons, including details about the owners and beneficiaries of transaction accounts, dealing instructions, transactions etc.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 180 of the SFO creates a general power to obtain information from and inspect the*

### Section 201(3) of the SFO also gives SFC formal power to enter into an agreement with an LC,

### _cr14205 - Section 201(3) of the SFO also gives SFC formal power to enter into an agreement with an LC,

### SFC formal agreement powers
- Section 201(3) of the SFO gives the SFC formal power to enter into an agreement with an LC, and RI or a licensed individual who is the subject of administrative or disciplinary proceedings under section 194, 195, 196 or 197 of the SFO.
- These agreements allow the SFC to seek undertakings to achieve outcomes not achievable under other statutory powers, notably:
  - the payment of compensation; and
  - the appointment of auditors to conduct an internal control review.
- These agreements can be enforced.

### Takeovers Panel and enforcement actions under the Takeovers Codes
- Under the Hong Kong Takeovers Codes (the Takeovers Code and the Share Repurchase Code), the SFC, acting as the Executive, may refer suspected breaches to the Takeovers Panel (a committee of the SFC made up of independent persons).
- The Panel can inquire into breaches and impose penalties, including:
  - public censure; and
  - “cold shoulder” orders (an order that denies any person who has failed to comply with the Takeovers Codes access to the securities markets for a specified period).
- The SFC also has the power to impose cold shoulder orders.
- Relevant reference: paragraphs 12.1-12.3 of the Introduction to the Takeovers Codes.

### Suspension of trading and exchange closure
- SFC power to suspend trading in a security listed on the stock exchange if the SFC believes that:
  - a. there has been inadequate disclosure;
  - b. it is necessary or expedient to maintain a fair and orderly market;
  - c. it is in the public interest, the interest of the investing public or appropriate for the protection of investors; or
  - d. there has been a breach of a condition imposed by the SFC when allowing a previously suspended security to recommence trading
- Legal basis: Rule 9 of the Securities (Stock Exchange Listing) Rules.
- If an exchange fails to comply with certain statutory requirements, the SFC may direct the exchange to be closed for the transaction of dealings (section 28 of the SFO).

### HKMA enforcement powers (securities-related)
- HKMA generally refers securities-related cases involving its regulated entities to the SFC.
- HKMA-specific powers:
  - a. Under section BO 71C of the BO, HKMA has the power to consent to the appointment of EOs by RIs; in specified circumstances (including misconduct by an EO) it may withdraw or suspend that consent after consultation with the SFC.
  - b. Under section 58A of the BO, the HKMA has power to remove or suspend ReIs (staff of RIs engaging in regulated activities) from the register in the prescribed circumstances after consultation with the SFC.
- HKMA cannot impose fines on individuals or on ReIs but can use “naming and shaming” as a disciplinary measure.
- The HKMA can refer cases to the SFC, which can impose fines on executive directors and ReIs of banks in relation to securities breaches under section 196 of the SFO.
- Assessors recommend considering granting the HKMA fining powers over EOs and ReIs to allow more efficient prosecution of breaches.

### Private rights of action
- Under section 281(1) of the SFO, an affected person has the right to bring an action to recover compensation whether the loss arises from having entered into a transaction or dealing at a price affected by market misconduct.
- There need not be market misconduct proceedings before the MMT and a person need not have been found by the MMT to have engaged in market misconduct to be liable under section 281(1) (section 281(5) of SFO).
- Section 305 of the SFO gives a person who suffers pecuniary loss as a result of any form of market misconduct the right of civil action to seek compensation.
- The SFC has power to intervene in proceedings between private litigants (section 385 of the SFO).

### Information sharing and investigatory powers
- SFC’s investigatory powers under Part VIII of the SFO are generally sufficient for investigative purposes; SFC rarely needs to rely on other Hong Kong authorities to obtain information.
- SFC has broad power to share information with other authorities, including:
  - other financial market regulators;
  - the Commissioner of Police;
  - the Commissioner of the ICAC;
  - the MMT and the SFAT;
  - prosecutorial authorities.
- Other regulators can provide information to SFC if required; HKMA has power to share information with SFC about RIs and individuals acting for RIs such as EOs and ReIs.
- Information sharing arrangements are set out in MoUs, but there is no requirement for an MoU for an exchange of information to take place.

### Assessment and overall comments
- Assessment: Fully implemented
- Comments and findings:
  - Regulatory authorities have been given broad licensing, supervisory and investigative powers vis-à-vis their mandates.
  - SFC can use criminal, MMT, civil, and administrative/disciplinary avenues; enforcement powers are formally in line with the Principles (they do not require disgorgement or restitution powers).
  - Practical challenges exist in the use of these avenues that could affect enforcement effectiveness; this issue was considered in grading Principle 12.
  - Difference in investigative and enforcement powers between HKMA and SFC acknowledged; assessors concur with HKMA that the current allocation does not create a gap given responsibilities and referral mechanisms.
  - System considered “complete”; no downgrade applied.
  - Recommendation: consider granting HKMA fining powers over EOs and ReIs for more efficient prosecution.

### Principle 12 — Inspection, surveillance, investigation and enforcement (overview)
- Description: The regulatory system should ensure effective and credible use of inspection, investigation, surveillance and enforcement powers and implementation of an effective compliance program.

Subsections and supervisory practices:
- Licensed intermediaries:
  - SFC’s Approach to Supervision publicly available; risk-based approach described under Principles 24 and 31.
  - HKMA’s approach to supervision of RIs described under Principle 31.
  - Both SFC and HKMA use robust off-site monitoring and regular on-site inspections; SFC carries out thematic, routine and for-cause inspections.
  - HKMA has focused on selling practices of RIs in distribution of investment products, including ILAS that do not fall under SFO securities definition.
- Referrals to Enforcement Division resulting from SFC on-site inspections and off-site monitoring (Referrals to Enforcement):
  - 2008/2009: 19
  - 2009/2010: 34
  - 2010/2011: 27
  - 2011/2012: 22
  - 2012/2013: 29
  - Source: SFC

### Supervision: corporate finance, investment products, and market surveillance
- Corporate finance:
  - SEHK reviews all prospectuses and offer documents for listed securities and listed structured products.
  - SFC reviews all IPO prospectuses and listing documents, and where SEHK asks, listing documents for listed structured products and debt securities, including novel structured products or debt securities.
  - SFC monitors issuers’ obligations to disclose inside information, disclosure of substantial shareholdings, related derivatives and short positions, and directors and executives shareholdings.
  - SFC staff, as the Takeovers Executive, review documentation relating to takeovers and changes of control transactions.
  - Financial statements of issuers reviewed by HKEx, HKICPA and the FRC on a risk based selection process.
- Investment activity:
  - All disclosure documents for investment products, including CIS, structured products, ILAS and MPF products are reviewed by the SFC’s Investment Products Division.
- Unusual transactions on regulated markets:
  - SFC uses dedicated automated systems with adjustable parameters to detect unusual orders and transactions.
  - Specialized SFC team monitors and follows up exception reports generated by these systems.
  - A 2001 MoU between HKEx and SFC sets arrangements and procedures; SFC has real time electronic access to HKEx’s SMARTS system and daily Market Surveillance System (MSS) data; for options and futures, real time access to HKEx’s CIBOIS terminal and a daily data feed.

### Requirements for supervisory and compliance systems
- Intermediaries (LCs and RIs) required to have adequate supervisory and compliance systems.
- Code of Conduct (paragraph 14.1) requires senior management to manage risks, including periodic evaluation of risk management processes.
- Management, Supervision and Internal Control Guidelines (ICG):
  - Part I requires an effective management and organizational structure to ensure operations are conducted in a sound, efficient and effective manner; requires regular and effective communication within the firm covering operations, financial position, qualitative and quantitative risks, non-compliance, and adherence to business objectives.
  - Part V requires policies and procedures to ensure compliance with legal/regulatory requirements and internal policies, and where practicable an independent compliance function.
- SFC tests adequacy and functioning of these arrangements in on-site inspections.

### Supervision of employees and disciplinary powers
- Code of Conduct Paragraph 4.2 (Capabilities – Staff supervision) requires licensed or registered persons to ensure adequate resources to supervise diligently and to supervise diligently persons employed or appointed to conduct business.
- Sections 194 and 196 give SFC power to take disciplinary action against regulated entities and their management for failure to supervise subordinate personnel whose activities violate securities laws.

### Mechanisms to detect and investigate market abuse
- SFC Enforcement Division has a dedicated market surveillance team using specialized systems with adjustable parameters; staff review and follow-up exception reports in real time; daily and regular meetings to discuss market news and intelligence.
- If further enquiries are warranted, staff prepare a recommendation for the head of the team who may commence a formal enquiry under section 181 of the SFO to seek identity of persons and trade details.
- If suspicion of market or price manipulation remains after section 181 enquiry, the RO of surveillance team prepares a case assessment report recommending referral to the Division’s investigation team.

### Intelligence, complaints handling, and inter-agency referrals
- Intelligence logged in the Investigation Management System (case management and intelligence system) which provides electronic filing and intelligence database.
- Public complaints logged in the Investigation Management System by External Relations Department, with summaries prepared by officers.
- Complaints Control Committee (CCC) meets weekly; comprised of senior executives from each operational division and chaired by the Senior Director of Corporate Affairs; CCC decides handling of complaints and minutes distributed to Complaints Liaison Officers.
- SFC receives intelligence from the Joint Financial Intelligence Unit (JFIU), other domestic law-enforcement agencies and overseas regulators; JFIU manages suspicious transaction reports (STRs) regime and disseminates to appropriate investigative unit.
- Referrals from JFIU or other agencies logged and assessed; assessment referred to senior management to decide on further action such as commencing a formal investigation.

### SFC Enforcement structure and investigation process
- Enforcement at SFC comprises four teams: Surveillance, Investigation, Disciplinary, and Policy & International.
- As of August 2013, Enforcement had 145 staff members.
- Enforcement staff multidisciplinary: legal, accounting, finance, forensic and investigative skills; Legal Services Division provides legal advice; IT Department has forensic IT experts.
- Referral and investigation workflow:
  - Divisions detecting possible breaches assess and may recommend referral to Enforcement.
  - Gathering information under sections 180 or 181; if actionable breach suspected, case assessment report prepared and considered by Enforcement Steering Committee (ESC).
  - ESC (senior executives from investigation, surveillance, policy & international and disciplinary teams) meets weekly; once approved, investigation commenced under section 182 of the SFO.
  - Investigation plan prepared, presented to ESC; upon approval, a section 182 Direction to Investigate issued by a senior executive (Director or above).
  - Investigation officers empowered to use SFC investigative powers including section 183 (compel production of information and documents, attendance of interviews, taking of statements).
  - In urgent cases, a section 182 direction can be issued before ESC approves an investigation plan under authorization of most senior Enforcement staff.
  - ESC receives regular progress reports and monitors investigations.
- When sufficient evidence of actionable breach exists, a decision is made on appropriate action.

### Number of SFC investigations – by type of misconduct (financial year summary)
- Table of investigations opened and completed (exact figures preserved):
  - Corporate governance issues:
    - 2009-2010 Opened 19 Completed 14
    - 2010-2011 Opened 27 Completed 19
    - 2011-2012 Opened 28 Completed 16
    - 2012-2013 Opened 27 Completed 22
  - Disclosure of interests:
    - 2009-2010 Opened 26 Completed 16
    - 2010-2011 Opened 23 Completed 27
    - 2011-2012 Opened 23 Completed 24
    - 2012-2013 Opened 22 Completed 18
  - Insider dealing:
    - 2009-2010 Opened 23 Completed 21
    - 2010-2011 Opened 28 Completed 24
    - 2011-2012 Opened 33 Completed 20
    - 2012-2013 Opened 37 Completed 28
  - Intermediary misconduct:
    - 2009-2010 Opened 68 Completed 73
    - 2010-2011 Opened 63 Completed 47
    - 2011-2012 Opened 74 Completed 58
    - 2012-2013 Opened 65 Completed 68
  - Market manipulation:
    - 2009-2010 Opened 50 Completed 34
    - 2010-2011 Opened 35 Completed 36
    - 2011-2012 Opened 58 Completed 33
    - 2012-2013 Opened 51 Completed 59
  - Unlicensed activities:
    - 2009-2010 Opened 44 Completed 26
    - 2010-2011 Opened 32 Completed 46
    - 2011-2012 Opened 18 Completed 17
    - 2012-2013 Opened 19 Completed 17
  - Total:
    - 2009-2010 Opened 230 Completed 184
    - 2010-2011 Opened 208 Completed 199
    - 2011-2012 Opened 234 Completed 168
    - 2012-2013 Opened 221 Completed 212
  - Source: SFC

### Enforcement remedies and strategy
- General principle: if evidence suggests a criminal offence can be proved, SFC will not use administrative or civil proceedings as a substitute for criminal action.
- In important cases, both criminal and non-criminal remedies may be used.
- SFC disciplinary limits:
  - SFC does not have power, as part of formal disciplinary process against an intermediary, to require it to compensate clients for losses resulting from intermediary misconduct (such as mis-selling).
  - The maximum fine it can impose in disciplinary proceedings is only HK$10 million or 3 times of the profit gained/loss avoided, whichever is higher.
- Policy response: where client losses are significant, SFC is prepared to use its other powers (including agreements under section 201(3)) to seek compensation and other remedies.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 201(3) of the SFO also gives SFC formal power to enter into an agreement with an LC,*

### section 201 of the SFO to enter into agreements with an intermediary to achieve client

### _cr14205 - section 201 of the SFO to enter into agreements with an intermediary to achieve client

### Section 201 agreements and remedial actions
- Section 201 of the SFO has been used to enter into agreements with an intermediary to achieve client compensation and other remedial actions (such as the appointment of independent experts to review internal controls, compliance systems etc).
- To reach agreement, it has proved necessary for the SFC to agree not to take formal disciplinary action in these cases.
- The fact of these agreements and their contents are made public.
- Examples:
  - From 2008 to 2011, compensation payments of around HK$10 billion were made to clients of distributors of Lehman related investment products.
  - In two separate cases in 2012, parties agreed to make compensation to clients of more than HK$85 million.

### Criminal enforcement: institutional arrangements and practice
- The current SFO came into operation on 1 April 2003.
- The SFC and the DPP agreed in 2007 that the SFC would refer the more serious cases and in particular those related to market misconduct to the DPP.
- In practice:
  - SFC submits a brief of evidence and often a recommendation as to whether the case should be prosecuted by the DPP in the District Court or a higher court, or by the SFC in the Magistrates Court.
  - The DPP reviews the evidence and decides whether a prosecution should be initiated in accordance with the Prosecution Code and whether the trial should be in the Magistrates Court (with jurisdictional limit of 3 years’ imprisonment for market misconduct cases) or on indictment in the District Court or above.
  - If the DPP decides Magistrates Court, the case is referred back to the SFC to conduct the prosecution.
  - If the DPP decides District Court or above, the DoJ will prosecute the case.
  - Criteria used by the DPP include whether there is a reasonable prospect of conviction, whether it is in the public interest to initiate a prosecution and whether it is likely that the sentence will be one only a higher court can impose.
- Similar arrangements exist between the DoJ and other law enforcement agencies; in those cases the DoJ conducts all prosecutions.
- Historical pattern and tensions:
  - In the early years after the arrangements commenced, the DPP prosecuted a number of cases on indictment and some substantial prison sentences were achieved (including a sentence of six years for insider trading).
  - In the last 2 years or so (relative to the report), the former DPP decided not to prosecute any new cases on indictment, considering none warranted such a course.
  - The SFC disagreed, viewing relatively low sentences as a reflection of limited jurisdiction of the courts rather than insufficient deterrence; the SFC noted appeals and retrials where magistrate decisions were sent back by the High Court.
  - These differences resulted in a very public disagreement between the SFC and the former DPP. The SFC and the current DPP are taking constructive steps to strengthen coordination.

### Number of SFC cases referred to DPP (DoJ decisions)
- Number of cases referred:
  - 2008: 10
  - 2009: 13
  - 2010: 17
  - 2011: 17
  - 2012: 9
  - 2013 up to 6 Sept: 5
- Number of cases DPP decided to prosecute on indictment:
  - 2008: 3
  - 2009: 3
  - 2010: 1
  - 2011: 1
  - 2012: 0
  - 2013 up to 6 Sept: 0

### Number of SFC cases prosecuted by DoJ (District Court cases)
- District Court cases (date of plea):
  - 2008: 5
  - 2009: 1
  - 2010: 1
  - 2011: -
  - 2012: -
  - 2013: -
- Convictions (date of conviction):
  - 2008: -
  - 2009: 3
  - 2010: 2
  - 2011: (blank)
  - 2012: 1
  - 2013: -
- Acquittals:
  - 2008: -
  - 2009: -
  - 2010: -
  - 2011: -
  - 2012: 1
  - 2013: -
- Source: DoJ

### Number of SFC cases prosecuted – by offence category
- Market manipulation:
  - 2008: 2
  - 2009: 1
  - 2010: 1
  - 2011: -
  - 2012: -
  - 2013: -
- Insider dealing:
  - 2008: 2
  - 2009: -
  - 2010: -
  - 2011: -
  - 2012: -
  - 2013: -
- Other:
  - 2008: 1
  - 2009: -
  - 2010: -
  - 2011: -
  - 2012: -
  - 2013: -
- Source: DoJ

### Charges, convictions, imprisonment and acquittals in higher courts
- Number of people charged:
  - 2008: 13
  - 2009: 1
  - 2010: 1
  - 2011: -
  - 2012: -
  - 2013: -
- Number of people convicted:
  - 2008: -
  - 2009: 11
  - 2010: 4
  - 2011: -
  - 2012: 1
  - 2013: -
- Number of people sentenced to imprisonment:
  - 2008: 0
  - 2009: 8
  - 2010: 4
  - 2011: -
  - 2012: 1
  - 2013: -
- Number of people acquitted:
  - 2008: -
  - 2009: -
  - 2010: -
  - 2011: -
  - 2012: 1
  - 2013: -
- Note: The total number of people convicted is larger than the total number of people charged because one person was convicted in two separate cases in two years.
- Source: DoJ

### SFC Magistrates’ Court prosecutions (Jan 2007 to Mar 2013)
- The SFC conducted over 300 criminal prosecutions in the Magistrates Courts in the period from January 2007 to March 2013.
- Of those prosecutions, 50 cases involve more serious securities crimes (insider dealing and market manipulation).
- Out of these 50 cases:
  - 21 imprisonment sentences were ordered, of which:
    - 16 involve sentences of less than 6 months,
    - 4 of less than 1 year,
    - 1 case a sentence between 1 and 2 years.
  - Immediate custodial sentences were only imposed in 4 cases.
  - Suspended sentences in 17 cases.

### Number of entities on trial and convicted (criminal proceedings)
- Number of entities (individuals and non-natural persons) on trial:
  - 2008/09: 36
  - 2009/10: 35
  - 2010/11: 52
  - 2011/12: 40
  - 2012/13: 40
- Number of entities convicted:
  - 2008/09: 33
  - 2009/10: 32
  - 2010/11: 51
  - 2011/12: 37
  - 2012/13: 36
- Number of entities acquitted:
  - 2008/09: 3
  - 2009/10: 3
  - 2010/11: 1
  - 2011/12: 3
  - 2012/13: 4

### Civil enforcement and remedies (SFC)
- Civil cases address insider dealing, market manipulation, failures by listed companies to keep the market properly informed, undisclosed related party dealings and other breaches of duty by listed company directors.
- Applications for civil remedies — by type of remedies sought (annual figures):
  - Injunction and other remedial orders (section 213 of SFO):
    - 2008/09: 6
    - 2009/10: 24
    - 2010/11: 6
    - 2011/12: 5
    - 2012/13: 6
  - Listed companies: banning and other remedial orders (section 214 of SFO):
    - 2008/09: 9
    - 2009/10: 10
    - 2010/11: 6
    - 2011/12: 13
    - 2012/13: 8
  - Others:
    - 2008/09: 2
    - 2009/10: 3
    - 2010/11: 1
    - 2011/12: 0
    - 2012/13: 2
  - Total:
    - 2008/09: 17
    - 2009/10: 37
    - 2010/11: 13
    - 2011/12: 18
    - 2012/13: 16
  - Source: SFC
- Court orders granted:
  - Section 213 orders granted:
    - 2008/09: 1
    - 2009/10: 2
    - 2010/11: 1
    - 2011/12: 0
    - 2012/13: 7
  - Section 214 orders granted:
    - 2008/09: 2
    - 2009/10: 9
    - 2010/11: 5
    - 2011/12: 13
    - 2012/13: 5
  - Others:
    - 2008/09: 2
    - 2009/10: 3
    - 2010/11: 1
    - 2011/12: 0
    - 2012/13: 0
  - Total orders granted:
    - 2008/09: 5
    - 2009/10: 14
    - 2010/11: 7
    - 2011/12: 13
    - 2012/13: 12
  - Source: SFC
- Illustrative remedial outcome:
  - Hontex case (section 213 SFO proceeding): SFC secured orders reversing share subscriptions of several thousand investors; around HK$1 billion was returned to shareholders under these court orders.

### Administrative enforcement — SFC disciplinary actions
- Number of licensees disciplined by type of misconduct (annual totals):
  - Improper trading activities in breach of Code of Conduct:
    - 2008/09: 5
    - 2009/10: 13
    - 2010/11: 8
    - 2011/12: 3
    - 2012/13: 2
  - Other trading malpractices:
    - 2008/09: 6
    - 2009/10: 9
    - 2010/11: 7
    - 2011/12: 1
    - 2012/13: 2
  - Internal control weaknesses:
    - 2008/09: 21
    - 2009/10: 8
    - 2010/11: 9
    - 2011/12: 9
    - 2012/13: 5
  - Misappropriation:
    - 2008/09: 5
    - 2009/10: 3
    - 2010/11: 1
    - 2011/12: 2
    - 2012/13: 3
  - Facilitating unlicensed activities:
    - 2008/09: 0
    - 2009/10: 6
    - 2010/11: 1
    - 2011/12: 7
    - 2012/13: 0
  - Breach of client identity rules:
    - 2008/09: 0
    - 2009/10: 1
    - 2010/11: 7
    - 2011/12: 2
    - 2012/13: 1
  - Corporate finance related matters:
    - 2008/09: 6
    - 2009/10: 1
    - 2010/11: 0
    - 2011/12: 0
    - 2012/13: 3
  - Breach of Financial Resources Rules:
    - 2008/09: 0
    - 2009/10: 2
    - 2010/11: 2
    - 2011/12: 2
    - 2012/13: 0
  - Other miscellaneous misconduct:
    - 2008/09: 11
    - 2009/10: 15
    - 2010/11: 13
    - 2011/12: 12
    - 2012/13: 12
  - Total licensees disciplined:
    - 2008/09: 54
    - 2009/10: 58
    - 2010/11: 48
    - 2011/12: 38
    - 2012/13: 28
  - Note: Licensees includes individuals, such as representatives, as well as LCs.
  - Source: SFC
- Fines and costs recovered from defendants (HK$):
  - Disciplinary fines:
    - 2008-09: 63,648,652
    - 2009-10: 26,125,496
    - 2010-11: 21,438,800
    - 2011-12: 35,210,000
    - 2012-13: 83,500,000
  - Prosecution fines:
    - 2008-09: 1,519,000
    - 2009-10: 25,032,535
    - 2010-11: 677,000
    - 2011-12: 1,159,000
    - 2012-13: 1,420,455
  - MMT - fines:
    - 2008-09: 7,981,156
    - 2009-10: -
    - 2010-11: 74,474
    - 2011-12: -
    - 2012-13: 21,167,913
  - MMT - costs orders:
    - 2008-09: 7,792,470
    - 2009-10: 6,780,013
    - 2010-11: 1,800,863
    - 2011-12: 4,180,270
    - 2012-13: 8,365,043
  - Total:
    - 2008-09: 80,941,278
    - 2009-10: 57,938,044
    - 2010-11: 23,991,136
    - 2011-12: 40,549,270
    - 2012-13: 114,453,411
  - Source: SFC
- SFC imposed fines ranged:
  - For corporations: HK$100,000 to HK$6 million.
  - For individuals: HK$1,500 to $1.46 million.
  - In three cases the fines exceeded HK$10 million (these cases involve multiple and separate acts of misconduct).

### MMT Proceedings (insider dealing, market manipulation, etc)
- Number of people found culpable by MMT:
  - Insider dealing:
    - 2008/09: 3
    - 2009/10: 3
    - 2010/11: 2
    - 2011/12: 1
    - 2012/13: 2
  - Market manipulation:
    - 2008/09: (blank)
    - 2009/10: 6
    - 2010/11: 0
    - 2011/12: 0
    - 2012/13: 2
  - Disclosure of false or misleading information:
    - 2008/09: 3
    - 2009/10: 0
    - 2010/11: 0
    - 2011/12: 0
    - 2012/13: 0
  - Total:
    - 2008/09: 12
    - 2009/10: 3
    - 2010/11: 2
    - 2011/12: 1
    - 2012/13: 4
  - Source: SFC

### HKMA enforcement activity and coordination with SFC
- HKMA’s Enforcement Department:
  - Deals with investigation and enforcement actions in relation to AIs, including those who are RIs.
  - Consists of approximately 100 people.
  - Currently has around 800 outstanding cases (some general banking complaints, most are investigations into mis-selling by AIs and RIs of investment products, including securities and ILAS).
- Referral and investigation process:
  - Cases are referred to Enforcement by the Banking Conduct and other supervisory areas of the HKMA. Referral criteria include whether offending conduct is continuing, number of complaints received and impact on customers.
  - HKMA routinely uses its powers under the BO and powers under section 180 of the SFO in investigations.
  - Because of current allocation of responsibilities:
    - Enforcement of breaches of conduct rules by firms and by former EOs and ReIs are dealt with by the SFC.
    - HKMA focuses on current EOs and ReIs.
  - HKMA enforcement staff ordinarily carry out the investigation of all conduct, and then pass appropriate cases to the SFC.
  - Procedures for referral and investigation were set up as a result of the commencement of the SFO in 2003.
  - HKMA Enforcement handles cases in accordance with the Disciplinary Procedures Manual, which mirrors the SFC procedures as far as practicable.
  - HKMA Enforcement will assess information and submit the case to an internal standing committee (Event Review Committee) to decide whether an investigation should be opened. If opened, HKMA Enforcement notifies the SFC and keeps SFC informed of progress and results.
  - In determining disciplinary action and sanctions, the HKMA Disciplinary Committee applies criteria set out in the Disciplinary Proceedings at a Glance issued by the SFC and considers actions taken by SFC or HKMA in precedent cases.
- Backlog and referrals:
  - HKMA’s Enforcement Department is still dealing with a large backlog of cases from the Lehman’s issue, but is reducing that backlog and streamlining procedures.
  - HKMA referrals to SFC:
    - 2010: 691
    - 2011: 1
    - 2012: 7
    - To August 2013: 22
    - (Lehman minibond related referrals: 12 in table context)
  - A number of these referrals resulted in significant enforcement remedies obtained by the SFC.

### Mechanisms to ensure consistent enforcement outcomes
- Mechanisms in place:
  - Under the law, the HKMA will consult the SFC before exercising disciplinary powers or refer cases to the SFC for taking disciplinary actions. Similarly, if the SFC initiates an investigation or proposes to impose disciplinary sanction on a registered institution (RI) or its staff, the SFC will consult the HKMA.
  - The SFC and the HKMA will exchange views and share information on major investigations from time to time during regular MoU meetings.
  - For cases closed by the HKMA, the SFC may from time to time review samples of such cases to ensure consistency of standards.
  - Persons aggrieved by a decision of the SFC or the HKMA may apply to the SFAT for review. Decisions of both authorities are also subject to review by the Office of the Ombudsman, the Court of Appeal as well as judicial review (where appropriate) depending on the subject matter of the decision.

### Assessment, principal concerns and recommendations
- Assessment grade: Broadly implemented.
- Two key considerations affecting effectiveness:
  1. Effectiveness in producing robust outcomes for serious misconduct, especially market misconduct (market manipulation and insider trading).
     - There has been a public disagreement between the SFC and the former DPP over thresholds for prosecution in higher courts.
     - The SFC and the current DPP are taking constructive steps to strengthen cooperation.
     - Assessors note the DPP should be free to decide prosecutorial matters; it is not the assessors' role to assess adequacy of DPP decisions.
     - From an outcomes perspective, criminal enforcement is being used, but concern exists that the strong deterrence message might not be effectively conveyed given relatively low levels of sanctions and the prevalence of suspended sentences.
     - Assessors note prosecutors do not seek particular sentences; sentencing is a matter for the court in common law jurisdictions such as Hong Kong SAR.
  2. Practical challenges for SFC when dealing with licensed or registered intermediaries whose conduct breaches the Code of Conduct but does not contravene law enabling civil remedial orders, and SFC’s inability to require disgorgement or restitution.
     - Result: SFC uses section 201 negotiated agreements to secure compensation; these agreements typically require SFC to agree not to take disciplinary action against the LC/RI and its management and staff.
     - Consequence: To secure client compensation, opportunity to take disciplinary action is foregone, limiting the practical availability of both compensation and disciplinary sanctions concurrently.
     - Implication: The deterrent message of disciplinary sanctions may be fettered if both routes are not practically available.
- Additional matters:
  - Assessors note the backlog of cases at the HKMA and encourage continued efforts to address this situation.
  - Cross-border challenges:
    - Hong Kong’s cross-border markets and interactions with the Mainland pose significant and continuing challenges for enforcement (e.g., obtaining evidence in the Mainland, interaction between two legal systems).
    - This complexity affects the effectiveness of enforcement in Hong Kong securities markets.
  - Need for level playing field and transparency:
    - Because supervision of securities market activity by intermediaries is divided between SFC and HKMA, it is important to ensure a level playing field between banks supervised by HKMA and securities firms supervised by SFC.
    - Requires high transparency between regulators, continuing flow of information about regulated entities and supervisory strategies, and periodic assessment to ensure consistency is achieved in practice.
    - There appears to be a good flow of information between SFC and HKMA; nonetheless periodic assessment is important.

*Source: _cr14205 - section 201 of the SFO to enter into agreements with an intermediary to achieve client*

### Section 378 of the SFO imposes an obligation on SFC and its staff to preserve the secrecy of

### _cr14205 - Section 378 of the SFO imposes an obligation on SFC and its staff to preserve the secrecy of

### Secrecy obligations and permitted exceptions
- Section 378 of the SFO imposes an obligation on SFC and its staff to preserve the secrecy of information that comes into its possession in the performance of its functions.
- Exceptions permit SFC to share information with a variety of domestic authorities:
  - prosecutorial authorities (section 378(2)(b));
  - a variety of financial regulators such as HKMA, the IA and MPFA (section 378(e) and (f));
  - the MMT and the SFAT (section 378(3)(c) and (d));
  - a recognized exchange company, a recognized clearing house, a recognized exchange controller and a recognized investor compensation company (section 378(3)(f)).
- Types of information SFC may share (domestic):
  - matters of investigation and enforcement;
  - determinations in connection with licensing and authorization;
  - surveillance;
  - market conditions and events;
  - client identification, including beneficial ownership information;
  - regulated entities;
  - listed companies and companies seeking listing.
- This information can be shared without the need for external approval.
- SEHK is bound by the secrecy provisions in section 378 in relation to its supervisory functions; it has more limited power to share but can provide information to prosecutorial authorities and others mentioned in sections 378(2) of the SFO, as well as to SFC, and does not require SFC’s approval to share in these circumstances.

### International information sharing and cooperation
- SFC is responsible for responding to all requests for information from foreign regulators in the area of securities markets.
- Section 378(3)(g) permits SFC to share any information in its possession with foreign regulators provided SFC is satisfied that:
  - the overseas regulatory authority performs a function similar to a function of the SFC or the Registrar of Companies, or regulates, supervises or investigates banking, insurance or other financial services or the affairs of corporations; and
  - the overseas regulator is subject to adequate secrecy provisions (section 378(6) of the SFO).
- Disclosure preconditions (section 378(5)):
  - the information is disclosed in the interest of the investing public or the public interest; or
  - the disclosure will enable or assist the overseas regulatory authority to perform its functions and it is not contrary to the interest of the investing public or the public interest that the information should be so disclosed.
- In practice, overseas requests are likely to satisfy the second alternative; SFC can share all information described under domestic information sharing using this provision.
- No external approval is required for SFC to share information with foreign regulators.
- SFC can provide information to domestic and foreign regulators on an unsolicited basis.
- No requirement for dual illegality: SFC can share information even if the alleged conduct would not constitute a breach of Hong Kong law; there are no “dual illegality” requirements for information sharing under section 378(3)(g)(i) or for investigatory cooperation under section 186 of the SFO.
- Bank account information:
  - SFC can share with domestic regulators information and records identifying the person or persons beneficially owning or controlling bank accounts related to securities and derivatives transactions and brokerage accounts as well as the information necessary to reconstruct a transaction, including bank records (sections 378(2)(b), (3)(e), (3)(f), (3)(g)(ii) and 378(3)(i) of SFO).
  - Using 378(3)(g)(i), SFC can also share information of this kind with foreign regulatory organizations.

### Confidentiality safeguards and permissible onward use
- Domestic recipients: under section 378(7) domestic authorities receiving confidential information from the SFC must not disclose except if:
  - the SFC consents to the disclosure;
  - the information or the part thereof has already been made available to the public;
  - the disclosure is for the purpose of seeking advice from, or giving advice by, counsel or a solicitor or other professional adviser acting or proposing to act in a professional capacity in connection with any matter arising under any of the relevant provisions;
  - the disclosure is in connection with any judicial or other proceedings to which the person or the recipient is a party;
  - the disclosure is in accordance with an order of a court, or in accordance with a law or a requirement made under a law.
- Foreign regulators: section 378(6)(b) requires SFC to be satisfied that the foreign regulator is subject to adequate secrecy provisions before disclosing non-public information.
  - For regulators with co-operative agreements, secrecy assessments are performed during negotiation or by the IOSCO MMoU Screening Group (for IOSCO MMoU signatories).
  - For regulators without co-operative arrangements, assessments are case-by-case.
  - For every disclosure, SFC specifies permissible use of the information and reminds the recipient of its duty to preserve confidentiality and that prior written consent from SFC is required before any onward disclosure other than as set out in the IOSCO MMoU or bilateral co-operative agreement.
- Information received by SFC from foreign regulators is subject to the general obligation of confidentiality under section 378(1); if required to disclose information contained in the request, SFC will first consult the requesting authority and, in the event of a legally enforceable demand for disclosure, will notify the requesting foreign authority and use legal exemptions and privileges to resist disclosure.
- Recipients of SFC’s notices to produce issued under section 183 of SFO (such as banks or brokers) are people assisting the SFC and are prohibited under section 378 from informing their clients about the existence and content of the notice to produce.

### Operational practice and use statistics
- The International & Policy team in SFC’s Enforcement Division handles and acts as the liaison point for requests for assistance from overseas regulators. If investigatory assistance is requested, the International team refers the request to the Investigation team for further actions.
- Activity statistics:
  - During the three years from 1 April 2009 to 31 March 2012, the SFC handled 306 licensing-related requests for assistance from foreign regulators and made 2,879 licensing-related requests for assistance.
  - In the three years from 1 April 2009 to 31 March 2012, the SFC handled 370 requests for assistance, and made 179 requests of assistance to overseas regulators.

### Powers to assist foreign regulators and investigatory reach
- Any information that SFC holds or can acquire through its information gathering powers can be shared with foreign regulators.
- Section 186 of the SFO enables SFC to use its powers of investigation (sections 182 and 183) to obtain information, including documents and records, and require both regulated and unregulated persons to answer questions and make statements under oath.
- These powers permit production of books and records that permit reconstruction of securities and derivatives transactions, and records of funds and assets transferred into and out of bank accounts and details of securities and derivatives transactions.
- Court orders: SFC cannot obtain court orders (such as injunctive and other remedial orders under section 213) if only a breach of a relevant law in a requesting foreign jurisdiction is suspected, but it could still provide assistance such as assisting a foreign regulator to secure local legal representation.
- No requirement for independent interest: use of SFC’s powers to compel production or information does not require SFC to have an independent interest in the subject of a foreign regulator’s request.
- SFC can provide information about regulatory processes, including the authorization process, investigations in progress and sanctions imposed.
- Financial conglomerates: SFC can provide information in its possession and use its information gathering and investigation powers to obtain information from regulated entities and compel information from unregulated persons about financial conglomerates subject to its supervision.
- Information from other domestic authorities: if information is held by other domestic authorities, SFC can assist by asking the relevant authority on a foreign regulator’s behalf; other regulators can supply this information if requested by SFC under domestic information sharing arrangements and applicable laws.

### Disclosure and issuer-related context (selected points)
- Most Hong Kong listed companies are “overseas issuers”: as at 31 January 2013, about 87 percent (1,346 out of 1,555) of Hong Kong listed companies were incorporated outside HK: 11 percent in the Mainland; 42 percent in the Cayman Islands; and 32 percent in Bermuda. A further 2 percent were incorporated in other jurisdictions.
- SEHK operates a Main Board and GEM (around 200 companies listed on GEM).
- Public offers governed by:
  - Parts II and XII of the CO;
  - Part IV of the SFO for public offers of structured products;
  - the Listing Rules of HKEx (Main Board and GEM).
- Prospectus and disclosure regime highlights:
  - Prospectus requirements set out in the Third Schedule of the CO; prospectus must enable a reasonable person to form a valid and justifiable opinion of the shares or debentures and the financial condition and profitability of the company at the time of issue.
  - Listing Rules Appendix 1 provides detailed requirements for new and existing issuers; Rule 11.07 requires listing documents to include particulars and information necessary for an investor to make an informed assessment.
  - All new applications for listing of equity securities must have a sponsor (Rule 2.09 and Chapter 3A); sponsor must be a corporate adviser licensed under the SFO and use reasonable endeavors to ensure information provided to SEHK is true in all material respects and does not omit any material information.
  - Structured products: unlisted structured products must be authorized by SFC under section 104A of the SFO; SEHK approves listed structured products. SIP Code requires offering documents to enable investors to make an informed judgment and to include a Product Key Fact Statement (paragraphs 6.1 and 6.3).
  - If significant changes arise after issuance of prospectus or listing document, issuer must provide disclosure in a supplemental prospectus or listing document approved by SEHK.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 378 of the SFO imposes an obligation on SFC and its staff to preserve the secrecy of*

### Section 122 of the CO requires directors of public companies to lay before its shareholders at

### _cr14205 - Section 122 of the CO requires directors of public companies to lay before its shareholders at

### Annual accounts, directors’ report, and Listing Rules requirements
- Section 122 of the CO requires directors of public companies to lay before its shareholders at its annual general meeting a profit and loss account and a balance sheet.
- The accounts must not be more than 6 months out of date.
- By section 129D, the balance sheet must include a directors’ report containing the information specified in that section.
- Requirement in the previous two bullets applies only to HK incorporated companies.
- Overseas companies registered with the Companies Registrar must deliver their latest published accounts which comply with the laws of their place of incorporation to the Registrar.
- For listed companies (both Main board and GEM), Rule 13.46 of the Listing Rules requires every listed company to send to its shareholders a copy of either:
  - its annual report including its audited annual or group accounts; or
  - its summary financial report (provided that it complies with Section 141 of the CO and the Companies (Summary Financial Reports of Listed Companies) Regulation;
  - not less than 21 days before the company’s Annual General Meeting and in any event not more than four months after the end of the financial year to which they relate.
- The company’s annual report must comply with the disclosure requirements set out in Appendix 16 to the Listing Rules.

### Structured products — annual reporting
- For listed products, Rule 15A.21 of the Listing Rules requires the annual report of the issuer and, where appropriate, the guarantor, to be submitted to SEHK within 4 months after the date to which the financial statements relate. The issuer must also make the reports publicly available.
- For unlisted products, SIP Code 7.6 (a) requires the issuer to make available to investors not later than four months after the date to which they relate, the annual report and audited financial statements in respect of the issuer, the guarantor and/or the key product counterparty, as applicable, and where group accounts are prepared, the relevant group accounts, together with the auditor’s report.

### Half yearly and quarterly reports
- Listing Rules require listed companies to send to shareholders either an interim report or a summary interim report that complies with the Companies (Summary of Financial Reports for Listed Companies) Rules.
- For main board companies:
  - must send the half-year report within 3 months after the end of the half year.
  - must publish preliminary half-year results announcements within two months from the end of the half-year.
  - half-year report contains the cashflow statement and a statement of changes in equity, and comparative figures for the corresponding previous period; results announcement and half-year report generally contain similar information, except for the Chairman’s statement.
  - hard copies of half-year reports must be sent to shareholders (shareholders have the choice of receiving electronic copies instead).
- For GEM companies:
  - the report must be published within 45 days of the end of the relevant half year.
  - must provide quarterly reports for each of first 3 and nine month period of the financial year by no later than 45 days after the period end.
  - Content requirements for quarterly reports are set out in GEM Listing Rules 18.68-18.77.
- Main board companies are not required to prepare quarterly reports, but quarterly reporting is recommended as best practice under Appendix 14 (Recommended Best Practices C.1.6 and C.1.7).
- For listed structured products, Rule 15A.21 requires the annual report and half yearly report of the issuer and, where appropriate, the guarantor, to be submitted to SEHK within 4 months after the date to which the financial statements relate; the issuer must also make the reports publicly available.
- For unlisted structured product issuers, SIP Code 7.6(a)(ii) requires half yearly reports to investors as soon as practicable and not later than four months after the close of the relevant period; many unlisted structured products are short dated with a life of 6 to 9 months.

### Disclosure of inside information (material events)
- Part XIVA of the SFO sets out requirements for listed companies to disclose material information as soon as reasonably practicable when the information has, or ought to reasonably have come to the knowledge of their directors, managers or company secretary.
- Section 307B of the SFO requires listed companies to disclose to the public price sensitive information (called “inside information”) as soon as reasonably practicable.
- “Inside information” (Section 307A of the SFO) is defined to mean specific information that:
  - is about:
    - the corporation;
    - a shareholder or officer of the corporation; or
    - the listed securities of the corporation or their derivatives; and
  - is not generally known to the persons who are accustomed or would likely to deal in the listed securities of the corporation but would if generally known to them be likely to materially affect the price of the listed securities.
- The requirement to disclose inside information under Part XIVA came into effect on 1 January 2013.
- The Listing Rules also require an issuer to announce any information needed to correct or prevent a false market in its securities (Listing Rule 13.09(1)), a broader test than the SFO.
- SFC senior staff indicated the SFO change provides “teeth” to the regime and has led to more rigorous issuer processes to determine market communication.
- For structured products:
  - listed products: Part XIVA applies; Listing Rules require announcements necessary to avoid a false market; Paragraphs 2 and 2A of Appendix 7H require guarantors of guaranteed products to make announcements about any information that may have a material effect on its ability to meet obligations;
  - unlisted products: SIP Code 7.6 requires the issuer to inform the SFC and all investors as soon as reasonably practicable of changes in the financial condition of the issuer or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to have a material adverse effect on the ability of the issuer or, if applicable, the guarantor or a key product counterparty, to fulfill commitments of the structured product.
- The MMT has jurisdiction over the inside information disclosure provisions in the SFO.

### Shareholder voting decisions and meeting notices
- Sections 114 and 116 of the CO set out timing requirements for notices of general meetings:
  - annual general meeting - 21 days' notice in writing;
  - meetings at which it is proposed to pass a special resolution - 21 days;
  - meetings that are neither an annual general meeting nor a meeting for the passing of a special resolution - 14 days.
- For listed companies, the Listing Rules include detailed provisions for disclosure to shareholders on matters requiring shareholder approval, including:
  - “notifiable transactions” (Chapter 14) including major and very substantial transactions that require shareholder approval;
  - “connected transactions” (Chapter 14A) relating to related party transactions.
- If a transaction requires shareholders’ approval, the listed company must send a circular to its shareholders at the same time or before the company gives notice of the general meeting to approve the transaction (Rule 14.41).
- If material information comes to directors’ attention after issue of the circular, the listed company must send a revised or supplementary circular and provide at least 10 business days before the date of the relevant general meeting (Rules 13.73 and 14.42).
- Detailed content requirements for circulars about transactions requiring shareholder approval are set out in Listing Rules 14.66-14.71A.
- Rule 13.39 requires listed companies to announce the results of their general meetings as soon as possible, but in any event at least 30 minutes before the earlier of either the commencement of the morning trading session or any pre-opening session on the business day after the meeting.

### Advertising and publicity materials
- Section 103(1) of the SFO makes it an offence to issue advertisements, invitations or documents which are or contain a public offer of securities or structured product unless it falls within one of the safe harbors in Section 103(2) or (3) of the SFO.
- Safe harbors include a complying prospectus or an advertisement, invitation or document relating to securities the listing of which SEHK has approved and which comply with the Listing Rules.
- Section 38B of the CO makes it unlawful to publish an advertisement unless it has been approved by the SFC or it is within the exemptions in Schedule 19 of the CO. The advertisement must contain:
  - a statement that the advertisement is issued by the company to which the advertisement relates;
  - a warning statement that potential investors should read the prospectus for detailed information about the company and the proposed offering before deciding whether or not to invest in the shares or debentures concerned; and
  - a statement that the advertisement does not constitute an offer or an invitation to induce an offer by any person to acquire, subscribe for or purchase the shares or debentures concerned.
- Rules 9.08 and 24.08 of the Listing Rules require all publicity material released in HK relating to an issue of securities and debt securities by a new applicant to be reviewed by the SEHK before release; materials must not be released until the SEHK has confirmed it has no further comments.
- For structured products:
  - listed products: Rule 15A.53 permits issuers to release publicity material relating to their products if it complies with all relevant legislation and rules; issuers are required to adopt the disclosure and presentation principles in the SEHK’s Guidelines on Marketing Materials for Listed Structured Products;
  - unlisted products: under Part IV of the SFO, advertisements in respect of publicly offered structured products must be authorized by the SFC. Criteria for authorisation are set out in the SIP Advertising Guidelines (Appendix D to the SIP Code).

### Responsibility for information in regulated offer documents — civil and criminal liability
- Civil liability under Sections 40 and 342E of the CO: those responsible for the issue of a prospectus are liable to pay compensation to any person who subscribes for shares or debentures for losses or damages as a result of any untrue statement in the prospectus. Liable parties include:
  - directors of the company at the time of the issue of the prospectus;
  - every person named in the prospectus as a director or prospective director;
  - promoter of the company; and
  - every person who authorized the issue of the prospectus, including any experts whose statements are incorporated in the prospectus (liable only for any untrue statement they make as an expert).
- Section 108 of the SFO provides a statutory right for persons to seek compensation for any pecuniary loss sustained as a result of their reliance on any fraudulent, reckless or negligent misrepresentation made to induce that person to invest in an unlisted structured product.
- Criminal liability:
  - SFO provisions make it a criminal offence to provide false or misleading information or omissions in offer documents, or in offers to induce transactions in securities under the SFO and the CO. See especially sections 107 and 298 of the SFO; and sections 40A and 342E of the CO.
  - Penalties under the SFO include fines up to HK$1 million or imprisonment of up to 10 years.
  - Under the CO penalties include HK$700,000 and 3 years.
  - Disciplinary penalties also apply under the listing rules (Rules 2A.09 and 2A.10).
  - Under the CO provisions, criminal liability attaches to any person who authorized the issue of the prospectus.
  - The SFC has publicly consulted about and is currently working on legislative proposals to amend the CO to clarify that sponsors have criminal and civil liability for false statements in a prospectus.

### Derogations and waivers
- SFC can grant an exemption from the prospectus disclosure requirements in sections 38 and 342 of the CO if it considers that the exemption will not prejudice the interest of the investing public and compliance with any or all of those requirements:
  - would be irrelevant or unduly burdensome; or
  - is otherwise unnecessary or inappropriate. (section 38A of the CO).
- In practice, this exemption power is used only in narrow circumstances, for example the period covered by the latest audited financial statements to be included in a prospectus if the prospectus is expected to be issued within a short time after the end of a company’s fiscal year.
- Under Rule 2.04, SEHK can also grant a waiver from Listing Rule requirements, but a waiver of general effect applying to more than one company requires the prior approval of the SFC.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 122 of the CO requires directors of public companies to lay before its shareholders at*

### Section 307D sets out certain exceptions when listed companies would not be required to

### _cr14205 - Section 307D sets out certain exceptions when listed companies would not be required to

### Safe-harbor exceptions to inside information disclosure (Section 307D)
- Exceptions when listed companies would not be required to disclose any inside information:
  - a. if and so long as the disclosure is prohibited under, or would constitute a contravention of a restriction imposed by, an enactment or a court order;
  - b. if and so long as the company takes reasonable precaution to preserve the confidentiality of the information and the confidentiality is preserved where:
    - i. the information concerns an incomplete proposal or negotiation;
    - ii. the information is a trade secret;
    - iii. the information concerns the provision of liquidity support from the Exchange Fund or the HKMA or other monetary authorities which perform the functions of a central bank to the company or a member of its group of companies;
  - c. the SFC has waived disclosure of the information under Section 307E of the SFO.
- Condition: these safe harbor exceptions are subject to a condition requiring the company to take reasonable measures to preserve the confidentiality of the information.
- Practice note: The SFC has not used its powers to grant waivers.

### Suspension of trading and trading halts
- Inside information provisions in Part XIVA of the SFO do not provide for mandatory suspension of trading.
- Rule 13.10A of the Listing Rules requires a company to apply for a trading halt as soon as reasonably practicable where it cannot make an announcement promptly about information necessary to correct or prevent a false market (Rule 13.09) or confidentiality has been lost in respect of information within the inside information safe harbor.
- If a listed company fails to publish periodic financial information within reporting deadlines in the Listing Rules, SEHK normally suspends trading in the company’s securities until the information is published (Listing Rule 13.50).
- Under Listing Rule 6.01 SEHK can direct a trading halt or suspend trading when SEHK considers that the company materially fails to comply with the Listing Rules.
- Under sections 7 and 8 of the SMLR, SFC can direct SEHK to suspend dealings where it appears to SFC that:
  - a. a document issued in connection with the listing, or an announcement, is materially false, incomplete or misleading information; or
  - b. a suspension is necessary in the interest of maintaining an orderly and fair market, or in the interest of the investing public or for the protection of investors.

### Restrictions on trading by persons with superior information
- Insider dealing provisions in sections 270 and 291 of the SFO prohibit a person with superior inside information from:
  - trading in the securities of the relevant company; and
  - disclosing that information to a third party.

### Cross-border listing and enforcement matters
- Prospectus and continuous disclosure provisions apply in full to all companies, regardless of domicile.
- SEHK requires companies seeking listing to be incorporated or otherwise established in a jurisdiction where standards of shareholder protection are at least equivalent to those in Hong Kong (Listing Rule 19.05(1)(b)).
- 2007 Joint Policy Statement by SFC and SEHK: overseas applicants must benchmark home-jurisdiction shareholder protection standards to Hong Kong’s standards; shortfalls can be compensated by changes to constitutional documents.
- Requirement: Hong Kong regulators must have reasonable access to information relating to a listed overseas company in its home jurisdiction to facilitate regulatory action. Key requirement for overseas companies to list in Hong Kong: incorporation in a jurisdiction where the statutory securities regulator has adequate arrangements with the SFC for mutual assistance and exchange of information (either by IOSCO MMoU or an adequately comprehensive bilateral agreement with the SFC).
- SEHK publishes guidance about acceptable jurisdictions for incorporation; SEHK lists acceptable overseas jurisdictions and companies incorporated there that have listed on the Main Board.
- Operational note: Currently there are no overseas companies listed on GEM.
- Cross-border enforcement: Remedies available to the SFC under the SFO and the CO apply to any foreign issuer listed in HKSAR; recent enforcement actions include civil remedial actions and winding up petitions against multiple overseas issuers named in the source.

### Regulatory practice and supervisory resources
- Dual filing system: listing applicants file copies of listing applications (including the prospectus) with the SFC at the same time as SEHK; SFC queries and comments are channeled through SEHK; formal approval decision made by SEHK’s Listing Committee taking SFC comments into account.
- Staffing cited:
  - SEHK has a staff of more than 40 people dealing with listing applications.
  - IPO team of the SFC’s Corporate Finance Division has 20 staff.
  - Primary Market Information, Fixed Interest and Structured Products teams at the SEHK consist of 35 people, 10 of whom deal with applications for listed structured product.
  - The SFC has a team of 13 staff dealing with unlisted structured products.
- SFC prospectus review focus: adequacy of information in prospectuses/listing documents.
- SEHK review focus: eligibility and suitability for listing, compliance with Listing Rules, including adequacy of disclosure.
- Reviews of financial reports of listed entities are carried out by HKEx, HKICPA and the FRC.
- Inside information monitoring:
  - SFC oversees the inside information disclosure regime with a team of 6 staff monitoring compliance by reviewing market announcements and making written inquiries of companies.
  - HKEx, by agreement with SFC, plays front-line regulatory role for enquiries concerning unusual price or trading volume movements, possible false markets, or matters under Listing Rule 3.10; HKEx makes daily reports to the SFC on these disclosure issues.

### Prospectus, annual and periodic reporting practices and timelines
- Company Ordinance (CO) allows annual reports to be made available to shareholders up to 6 months after balance date.
- Listing Rules require listed companies’ report and related financial statements to be made available within 4 months of balance date for companies that have raised funds from the public.
- Semi-annual reports for main board companies must be made available within 3 months of the close of the relevant period.
- Announcements must be made within two months; content of announcement is substantially similar to interim report.
- Material information about a company’s financial position must be disclosed as soon as practicable.

### Assessment and supervisory concerns (assessment: Fully implemented)
- Assessment: Fully implemented.
- Comments:
  - CO’s 6-month allowance for annual reports is not timely for Key Question 2(c); however, Listing Rules’ 4-month requirement applies in practice to companies that have raised funds from the public.
  - Semi-annual and announcement timing: semi-annual reports within 3 months; announcements within two months—assessors do not consider this a deficiency warranting downgrade because announcements’ content is substantially similar to interim reports.
  - Significant market concern exists about the quality and reliability of disclosure by Mainland companies and the SFC’s capacity to enforce compliance through enforcement actions.
  - Reforms to the sponsor regime aim to address challenges from cross-border companies.
  - SFC has used available tools to enforce issuer compliance, including for overseas companies, but SFC staff acknowledge practical cooperation challenges (for example, the sheer size of China) as distinct from legal impediments or lack of cooperation by Chinese authorities.

### Shareholder rights and equitable treatment (Principle 17)
- Legal framework:
  - CO provides general framework; Listing Rules supplement with detailed provisions.
  - General principle for listed companies: all holders of listed securities must be treated fairly and equally (Rule 2.03(4)).
  - Rule 13.75 requires equality of treatment for holders of securities of the same class who are in the same position.
  - Takeovers Code General Principle 1: all shareholders to be treated even-handedly and all shareholders of the same class to be treated similarly.
- Election of directors:
  - Section 157A of the CO: appointments of directors of companies other than a private company or a company not having a share capital must be voted on individually (slate voting prohibited).
  - Rule 13.70: when a listed company receives a shareholder notice proposing a person for election after publication of the meeting notice, the company must publish an announcement or issue a supplementary circular including particulars of the proposed director.
- Fundamental corporate changes:
  - Changes to constitutive documents and other fundamental changes require shareholders’ approval: special resolution (requiring at least 75 percent majority vote in favor) rather than ordinary resolution (simple majority of over 50 percent).
  - Dissenting members may apply to court to cancel resolutions relating to specified matters (alteration to objects, articles, variation of class rights, giving financial assistance for share acquisition, payment out of capital for redemption/purchase of private company’s shares, arrangements upon liquidation).
  - Delisting proposals:
    - Delist with only Hong Kong listing requires special resolution; if alternative listing exists, ordinary resolution suffices (Listing Rules 6.11–12).
    - Companies with only a secondary listing in Hong Kong do not require shareholder approval to delist in Hong Kong but must give at least three months’ notice to shareholders (Rule 6.16).
- Corporate transactions requiring shareholder approval:
  - Chapter 14: shareholder approval required for major acquisitions and disposals, very substantial disposals or acquisitions, and certain reverse takeovers; detailed threshold tests in the Chapter.
- Connected transactions:
  - Chapter 14A governs transactions with connected persons (Rule 14A.13); connected person defined in Rule 14A.11.
  - Connected transactions and continuing connected transactions above specified minima require approval by independent shareholders on a simple majority basis.
- General meetings and voting:
  - Notice requirements under CO:
    - a. 21 days’ notice in writing for annual general meeting and extraordinary general meetings at which a special resolution is called;
    - b. 14 days’ notice in writing for any other general meetings.
  - Rule 13.73: listed companies must provide any further material information arising after the circular at least 10 business days before the general meeting.
  - Rule 13.39(5): after a general meeting, require announcement of voting results as soon as possible, but in any event at least 30 minutes before the earlier of either the commencement of the morning trading session or any pre-opening session on the business day after the meeting.
  - Section 63A: where shares have different rights, resolutions prejudicing those rights must also be approved by a special meeting of those holders.
  - Section 113: members holding at least 5 percent of paid up capital have right to requisition a general meeting.
  - Section 114C: any member entitled to attend and vote may appoint a proxy.
  - Rule 13.38: proxy forms must be sent with meeting notice, allowing directional or discretionary voting.
  - Electronic voting: investors with accounts in CCASS can give voting instructions or arrange to attend and vote electronically through the CCASS Internet System.
- Ownership registration and transfer:
  - Section 28: membership by entry in register of members.
  - Section 68: registration of transfers of shares.
  - Rule 8.13: securities for which listing is sought must be freely transferable.
  - Rule 8.13A: securities must be accepted as eligible by Hong Kong Securities Clearing Company for deposit, clearance and settlement in CCASS.
  - Shareholding at broker level in each security listed on SEHK is publicly accessible via HKEx’s website.
  - Rules 13.59 and 13.60: issuer/share registrar must provide registration services with minimum service levels and maximum fees; share registrars must be members of an association of share registrars approved by the SFC under Sections 12-14 of the SMLR.
  - Overseas issuers must provide for a register of holders to be maintained in Hong Kong (Rules 19.05(3) and 19.30(4)).
- Dividends:
  - Articles generally provide directors may recommend a dividend but declaration must be approved by shareholders at a general meeting (model article 115 in Table A).
  - All common shareholders entitled to distribution once dividend is declared.
  - No requirement specifying when a declared dividend must be paid.

### Disclosure to shareholders and transaction circular requirements
- Rule 2.13: announcements and corporate communication must be accurate, complete in all material respects, not misleading or deceptive, and clearly presented in plain language.
- Rules 14.63 and 14A.58 require circulars for notifiable and connected transactions to include:
  - a. a clear, concise and adequate explanation of the subject matter;
  - b. all information necessary to allow shareholders to make a properly informed decision;
  - c. emphasis of the importance of the document and advice to shareholders to consult appropriate independent advisers;
  - d. a recommendation from directors (or independent board committee where independent shareholders’ approval is required) as to voting action, indicating whether the proposed transaction is, in the directors’ opinion, fair and reasonable and in the interests of shareholders as a whole;
  - e. a separate letter from any independent financial adviser (where independent shareholders’ approval is required - Rules 13.39(7) and 14A.58(3)(d)).
- Directors must confirm in circulars for notifiable transactions requiring shareholders’ approval that, to the best of their knowledge, after all reasonable enquiry, the counterparty and ultimate beneficial owner of the counterparty are third parties independent of the listed company and its connected persons (Rule 14.63(3)).

### Takeovers, share repurchases and administration of the Codes
- Takeovers Code and Share Repurchase Code govern takeovers, mergers and share repurchases affecting public companies in Hong Kong, companies with primary listing in Hong Kong, and REITs with primary listing in Hong Kong.
- Codes’ primary purpose: fair treatment of shareholders affected by takeovers, requiring equality of treatment, timely and adequate disclosure, and a fair and informed market.
- Takeovers Code is not law and has no statutory enforcement powers; SFC can investigate suspected breaches.
- Administration:
  - A team of 14 SFC staff are the “Takeover Executive” responsible for daily administration, vetting takeovers-related announcements and documents, and giving rulings.
  - Takeover Executive decisions are subject to review by the Takeovers Panel at request; Panel members are appointed by SFC and consist of 31 members.
  - A Panel consists of at least 5 persons, including a chairman (legally qualified) and 4 experts.
  - Disciplinary hearings are held in public except in exceptional circumstances; Panel has heard only 1 or 2 cases a year in recent years.
  - Takeover Executive may refer novel, important or difficult matters to the Takeovers Panel.
  - Sanctions range from public criticism or public censure to a “cold shoulder” order denying access to Hong Kong securities markets for a stated period; Takeover Executive can impose sanctions directly if the other party agrees.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 307D sets out certain exceptions when listed companies would not be required to_*

### Introduction to the Takeovers Code.

### Introduction to the Takeovers Code

### Takeovers: mandatory offers, timing, and pricing
- Rule 26.1 requires a person who acquires 30 percent or more of the voting shares in a company to make a takeover bid addressed to all holders.
- Partial bids require the consent of the Takeover Executive (Rule 28.1).
- An offer must also be made by a person who holds between 30 percent and 50 percent of shares, and increases their holding by more than 2 percent in any 12 month period.
- These rules apply also to persons acting in concert who collectively meet the thresholds.
- The offer must be posted within 21 days of the announcement of the terms of the offer (35 days for share exchange offers), Rule 8.2 of the Takeovers Code.
- The offer must be open for at least 21 calendar days following the date on which the offer document is posted.
- Rule 26.3: mandatory offers must be at a price not less than the highest price paid by the bidder, and by persons acting in concert with the bidder, for shares acquired during the offer period and within 6 months prior to its commencement.
- If no purchase against payment of securities of the same class was made in the period indicated, the takeover bid is implemented for that class of securities at a price no less than the weighted market average over the previous twelve months or shorter available period.
- General Principles 5 and 6: shareholders should be given sufficient information, advice and time to reach an informed decision; there should be full and prompt disclosure of all relevant information and precaution should be taken to avoid the creation or continuance of a false market.
- The Code sets out required content for the bidder's statement and the target statement (Schedules 1 and 2).
- The Code requires the target company to establish an independent board committee comprised only of independent directors to make a recommendation to the shareholders as to whether the offer or other transaction is fair and reasonable and as to acceptance and voting.
- The Code requires the appointment of an independent financial adviser to advise the independent board committee.
- The written advice of the independent financial adviser and the recommendations of the independent board committee must be set out in the circular to shareholders.
- Rule 9.3 requires all announcements and documents to shareholders to include a statement that all directors of the company issuing the announcement or document jointly and severally accept full responsibility for the accuracy of information and confirm that there is no omission of facts which would make any statement in the announcement or document misleading.
- Rule 4 prohibits the use of frustrating actions by a target company.
- General Principle 8 requires directors, in providing advice to shareholders, to act only in the interests of shareholders and to disregard personal and family shareholdings.
- Schedule 9 provides for “squeeze out” of minority shareholders if a purchaser acquires not less than 90 percent of the shares for which the offer is made, within four months from the date of the offer.

### Other change of control transactions
- The Takeovers Code applies to other change of control transactions typically subject to shareholders’ approval at a general meeting; at these general meetings the Takeovers Code requires voting to be conducted by way of poll.
- The principles and rules under the Takeovers Code are generally equally applicable to these transactions.
- Examples of other change of control transactions which require shareholders’ approval at a general meeting:
  - privatizations by way of a scheme of arrangement under companies law;
  - “whitewash” transactions involving a waiver of a general offer obligation arising as a result of the issue of new shares by the company (e.g. through subscription of new shares or acquisition of assets by the company with issuance of new shares as consideration etc.);
  - waivers of general offer obligation arising from a share repurchase - the same procedure as for “whitewash” transactions are used.
- When using a scheme of arrangement or capital reorganization to acquire or privatize a company, in addition to satisfying any voting requirements imposed by law:
  - the scheme or capital reorganization is approved by at least 75 percent of the votes attaching to the disinterested shares that are cast either in person or by proxy at a meeting of disinterested shareholders; and
  - the number of votes cast against the proposed scheme or capital reorganization is not more than 10 percent of the votes attaching to all disinterested shares. (Rule 2.10)
- Schemes of arrangement are under the supervision of the court.

### Holding the company and its directors responsible; enforcement powers
- Part IVAA of the CO provides statutory derivative actions: under sections 168BA to 168BI a member may bring proceedings on behalf of the company or intervene if:
  - the cause of action or right to continue, discontinue or defend the proceedings is vested in the company and relief is sought on behalf of the company;
  - the bringing of proceedings is in respect of misfeasance committed against the company (misfeasance is defined under section 168BB(2) to include fraud, negligence, default in compliance with any enactment or rule of law or breach of duty);
  - the company fails to bring proceedings or diligently continue, discontinue or defend the proceedings; and
  - leave is granted by the Court to bring or intervene in such proceedings.
- The SFC has the power to apply to intervene in proceedings between private litigants (section 385 of the SFO).
- The SFC can apply to the court for civil orders including injunctions, disqualification orders and other remedial orders if in its view the business or affairs of a listed company have been conducted in a manner:
  - that is oppressive to its members or any part of its members;
  - involving defalcation, fraud, misfeasance or other misconduct towards it or its members or any part of its members;
  - resulting in its members or any part of its members not having been given all the information with respect to its business or affairs that they might reasonably expect; or
  - that is unfairly prejudicial to its members or any part of its members (Section 214 of the SFO).
- The SFC also has power to apply to the court for injunctive and remedial orders (including rescission and restitution orders) and any ancillary order which the Court considers necessary (including injunctions, freezing of assets or the appointment of an administrator or receiver) (Section 213 of the SFO).
- This power is not limited to persons licensed or registered by the SFC, and the power applies to unregulated persons as well.
- If the bidder is a listed company, the SFC could approach a court to seek remedial or injunctive orders under section 214 of the SFO.

### Bankruptcy or insolvency of the company
- The CO provides detailed procedures for the winding up of companies, including in the event of their insolvency (Part V of the CO).
- Any surplus capital after settling all a company’s debt is distributed pari passu to its shareholders pursuant to Rule 143 of the Companies (Winding-up) Rules.

### Insiders and substantial holdings disclosure of interests in shares of listed corporations
- Prospectus disclosure:
  - Paragraph 30 of the Third Schedule of the CO requires a prospectus to contain a statement of the holdings of persons holding or beneficially interested in a substantial part of the share capital of the company.
  - Although the CO does not define a substantial holding for these purposes, in practice the 5 percent threshold used in Part XV of the SFO is used.
- Listing applicants must disclose in their listing documents the interests (which include interests in the underlying shares of equity derivatives) and short positions of each of their directors and chief executives and any associated companies in accordance to the disclosure of interest requirements in Part XV of the SFO (Paragraph 45 of Part A of Appendix 1 to the Listing Rules).
- Part XV of the SFO:
  - defines a substantial shareholding as 5 percent or more of any class of voting shares.
  - in counting shareholdings, derivatives over shares are taken into account (sections 311).
  - requires further disclosure where increases above specified thresholds occur (for example, a 1 percent change).
  - requires disclosure of short positions held by substantial shareholders (section 312).
  - applies where there is an agreement between two or more persons which includes provisions for the acquisition by any one or more of them of interests in shares in the relevant share capital of a particular listed corporation (Sections 317 to 319).
- Holdings of voting securities by directors and senior management:
  - Section 341 of the SFO requires directors and chief executives of a listed corporation to disclose their interests, and short positions in any shares and any debentures they in the listed company and its associated companies.
  - These disclosures are made public through the SEHK’s website.
  - Holdings of this kind must be disclosed in a prospectus and listing document, and in annual reports.

### Timing of disclosure
- Upon listing, directors, chief executives and substantial shareholders must disclose their interests within 10 business days of a company being listed.
- After that, disclosure must be made within 3 business days after the day on the duty to disclose arises (Sections 325 and 348 of the SFO).
- Listed companies are required to disclose in annual reports the interests and short positions of substantial shareholders (Listing Rule 13.47 and paragraph 13 of Appendix 16).

### Supervision and enforcement of disclosure requirements
- The SEHK regularly forwards to the SFC details of SFO Part XV disclosures that appear to be late.
- A team of SFC staff handle late disclosure referrals from the SEHK. SFC officers check:
  - whether the information to which the disclosure relates is already in the public domain;
  - whether the calculation on the percentage figure of the interest is correct by reference to the issued share capital at the time of the notification;
  - the disclosure history of the director/substantial shareholder.
- The SFC may commence investigation with a view to prosecution if:
  - the person was involved in late disclosure on a previous occasion;
  - the time delay is significant and the aggregated value of the interests is more than HK$1 million; or
  - the late disclosure concealed materially price sensitive information.
- The SFC has achieved a large number of convictions in the Magistrates Courts for breaches of these obligations.

### Cross-border application and definitions of public company
- The prospectus provisions, the Listing Rules and the SFO apply to overseas as well as domestic companies.
- The listing documents of overseas issuers must contain:
  - a summary of all provisions of the constitutive documents of the overseas issuer insofar as they may affect shareholders’ rights and protections and directors’ powers (Rule 19.10(2));
  - a summary of the relevant regulatory provisions (statutory or otherwise) of the jurisdiction in which the overseas issuer is incorporated or otherwise established (Rules 19.10 (3) and 19.34(2)).
- The SFC Takeovers Code applies to public companies in Hong Kong, companies with a primary listing of their equity securities in Hong Kong and REITs with a primary listing of their units in Hong Kong.
- Whether a company is a public company in Hong Kong is determined by applying an economic or commercial test which involves consideration of factors such as the number of shareholders in Hong Kong, the extent of share trading in Hong Kong and so on (Section 4.2 of the Introduction to the Takeovers Code).

### Assessment and observed market practice
- Assessment: Fully implemented
- Comments:
  - It is common for Hong Kong listed companies to have a dominant shareholder, frequently a family. In these circumstances, the rules relating to connected transactions play an important role in regulating the potential conflict between the dominant shareholder and other investors.
  - The rules are strongly policed by SFC and there is good evidence of its willingness to use enforcement remedies to deal with non-compliance.
  - The number of takeovers in Hong Kong is small relative to the size of the market: there were 29 takeovers in 2010-11, 29 in 2011-12, and 24 in 2012-13.
  - Contested takeovers are rare. Privatization transactions—especially with a dominant shareholder taking a company private—are achieved through schemes of arrangement.
  - Notwithstanding the non-statutory nature of the Takeovers and Share Repurchase Codes, the system appears to work effectively in the Hong Kong environment.
  - Appeals to the Takeovers Panel against decisions of the SFC are uncommon.

### Accounting standards, reporting and review
- Principle 18: Accounting standards used by issuers to prepare financial statements should be of a high and internationally acceptable quality.
- Audited financial statements must contain all the detail required by the applicable accounting standards (HKFRS, IFRS or CASBE), including a statement of financial position, a statement of operational results and statement of cash flow, and details about changes in equity ownership.
- Public offers of securities: issuers of public offering and listed structured products, as well as issuers of unlisted structured products must include their audited financial statements in public offering and listing documents, pursuant to the Listing rules and the SIP code respectively.
- Annual report and financial reports: listed companies (Listing Rules), listed structured products (Listing Rules) and unlisted structured products must submit an annual report which should include the audited financial statements. For listed issuers such documents are available via the SEHK website. For unlisted issuers they are available on the SFC website.
- Use of unaudited financial statements: Half yearly reports and (for GEM listed companies) quarterly reports are not required to be audited. The accounting principles applicable to interim reports are the same as those applying to the annual financial statements.
- Accounting standards accepted for public offerings/listings (Rule 4.11 of the Listing Rules):
  - HKFRS; or
  - IFRS; or
  - Pursuant to a special arrangement with the Mainland, Mainland incorporated companies listed in HKSAR may choose to prepare their financial statements according to CASBE (41 issuers use these standards).
- From 1 January 2005, all HKFRS are word-for-word identical to the IFRS, except that the word “IFRS” is changed to “HKFRS”. In a small number of cases, standards have been added to deal with Hong Kong specific issues not covered by the international standards.
- The HKICPA has statutory responsibility for setting HKFRS and adopts IASB-issued standards after public consultation through exposure drafts.
- Use of other international standards:
  - SEHK accepts Australian GAAP, Canadian GAAP, Japanese GAAP, Singapore Financial Reporting Standards and UK GAAP for dual-primary and secondary listed companies provided the overseas listing applicant includes a reconciliation statement in its accountants’ report and all subsequent financial statements to show the financial effect of the material differences (if any) from either HKFRS or IFRS.
  - Rules 19.39 and Note 2.4 to Paragraph 2 of Appendix 16 to the Main Board Listing Rules, and Rules 7.13 to 7.15, and 18.05 and 18.06 of the GEM Listing Rules allow the use of US GAAP or other accounting standards where the listed company is also listed on NYSE and NASDAQ.
  - Where SEHK allows reports to be drawn up using other accounting standards, SEHK may require the report to contain a statement of the financial effect of the material differences (if any) from either of HKFRS or IFRS.
- Oversight, interpretation and independence:
  - HKICPA is a professional industry body with statutory functions under the Professional Accountants Ordinance (PAO).
  - Interpretation issues are dealt with through the IFRS Interpretations Committee (IFRIC), the interpretative body of the IASB.
- Review of issuers’ compliance with accounting standards:
  - Review programs are run by HKICPA, the FRC and SEHK, coordinated to avoid overlap.
  - SEHK carries out 120 reviews each year, HKICPA around 80 and the FRC 75.
  - Given the work done by all three bodies, just under 20 percent of the population of listed issuers is reviewed each year.
  - Risk based criteria are used to select financial reports for review, with each organization using different risk criteria.
  - The FRC uses two external reviewers for each review. Reviewers are drawn from the large accounting firms, some mid-tier firms and some academic accountants. HKICPA also engages external reviewers to conduct the review while the HKEx conducts its reviews in-house.
  - Each year, the three oversight bodies host a joint reporting forum providing feedback to issuers on areas of concern revealed by the reviews. HKEx and HKICPA also publish a report on their Financial Statements Review Program annually.
  - If a financial report reveals material non-compliance or irregularities, the HKEx and HKICPA refer it to the FRC. The FRC is responsible for investigating non compliance and irregularities in accounting and auditing. The FRC in turn refers investigated cases that indicate concern about the professional conduct of the auditor to the HKICPA for disciplinary action. More rarely, the FRC may report a problem to the SFC.
- Material deficiencies in information available to the market are acted on by the SFC under the relevant powers described elsewhere in this document.

*Source: Introduction to the Takeovers Code.*

### Part XIVA of the SFO or the HKEx under the Listing Rules.

### Part XIVA of the SFO or the HKEx under the Listing Rules.

### Assessment summary
- Assessment status for the portion discussed at the start: Fully Implemented.
- Assessment status for auditors' oversight (Principle 19): Partly Implemented.
- Key contextual notes:
  - Issuers are permitted to use Mainland accounting standards without a reconciliation statement.
  - Assessors did not separately assess whether Chinese accounting standards are “of high international quality”.
  - The World Bank and IOSCO assessments (2011 FSAP) concluded that CASBE has substantially converged with IFRS.
  - Current arrangements for monitoring and enforcement of accounting standards are fragmented across various agencies; coordination steps have been taken.
  - Recommendation: ideally supervision and enforcement should be vested in a single authority (commonly the securities regulator, coordinated with criminal authorities when warranted).

### Background and scope (Principle 19)
- Listing requirements:
  - Domestic companies listed on the exchange must be audited by an auditor registered in HK.
  - Under a special arrangement with the Mainland of 2010:
    - Mainland incorporated companies listed in HKSAR may prepare financial statements using Mainland accounting standards and engage Mainland audit firms approved for auditing such financial statements.
    - 11 Mainland audit firms are allowed to audit the financial statements of Mainland incorporated companies under the special arrangement.
    - 42 Mainland companies listed in HKSAR were audited by those Mainland audit firms.
  - For other overseas companies, the Exchange may accept non HKSAR audit firms on a case by case basis if the firm:
    - (i) has an international name and reputation,
    - (ii) is member of a recognized body of accountants,
    - (iii) is subject to independent oversight by a regulatory body of a jurisdiction that is signatory of the IOSCO MMoU.
    - As of the time of assessment, 18 non HKSAR firms from countries different from Mainland had been accepted by the Exchange.

### Domestic framework and institutional roles
- Primary statutes and bodies:
  - PAO and FRCO set out the current framework for oversight of auditors who audit listed companies.
  - HKICPA responsibilities (under PAO):
    - Set accounting and auditing standards, admission requirements for auditors, ethical standards, and oversight including disciplinary actions for auditors registered in HK.
  - FRC responsibilities (under FRCO):
    - Investigation of non-compliance with accounting standards by listed companies and irregularities with auditing standards by their auditors (including overseas auditors).
- Reform trajectory:
  - Evolution towards greater independence of oversight; end objective to become member of the International Forum of Independent Audit Regulators.
  - Government benchmarking against other countries; legislative reforms being developed with stakeholder engagement and full public consultation intended within the legislature period (2016).

### HKICPA — structure, registration, and disciplinary processes
- Governance and composition:
  - HKICPA Council composed of 18 accountants (including two government ex officio members) and four lay members appointed by the Government.
  - PAO specifies at least six Council members must not be full-time accounting practitioners; at least 12 out of 22 members are non practitioners (a majority).
- Revenue sources:
  - Member subscription, student fees, firm registration fees, fees for practicing certificates.
- Registration and qualification:
  - Requirements to become a certified public accountant:
    - Hold an accountancy degree or equivalent qualification accredited/recognized by the Institute,
    - Pass the Institute’s qualification programme,
    - Gain relevant practical experience.
  - All certified public accountants must comply with HKICPA Statement 1.500 Continuing Professional Development (CPD) in accordance with Section 28(2)(c) of the PAO.
  - Statement 1.500 conforms with the International Education Standard for Professional Accountants 7.
  - Auditors in HK required to hold a practising certificate (PC); to obtain a PC a person must be a certified public accountant and may be required to pass examinations in local law and taxation (and where applicable auditing), and fulfil relevant accounting experience requirements.
  - Membership statistics: about 36,000 members of the Institute, of which about 4,190 hold a PC.
- Market concentration:
  - The big four audit firms audit listed companies that make up 98 percent of HKEx market capitalization.
  - Total firms auditing listed companies: about 64 audit firms.
- Disciplinary function:
  - Compliance reports go to the Professional Conduct Committee (PCC); PCC recommendations and independent investigation committee referrals can be made to the Council.
  - Council discretion to refer cases to a Disciplinary Committee; complainant can compel appointment unless Council deems case frivolous.
  - Disciplinary Committee composition:
    - Convened by a lay person appointed by the Government who selects members from two panels:
      - Panel A: lay persons appointed by the Government.
      - Panel B: accountants appointed by the Institute.
    - Each Disciplinary Committee: three members from panel A (including chairman) and two from panel B; majority including chairman are lay persons appointed by the Government.
  - Disciplinary powers under PAO (if complaint substantiated):
    - (i) removal from the register;
    - (ii) reprimand;
    - (iii) penalty not exceeding HK$500,000;
    - (iv) cost order;
    - (v) cancellation of the practising certificate;
    - (vi) denial of the issuance of a practising certificate permanently or for a specified period.
  - Current limitation: Committee cannot impose conditions on a license.
  - Hearings are open to the public; disciplinary decisions made public by way of HKICPA press release.
  - Compliance department publishes general statistics on reviews and enforcement actions, with no names.

### Financial Reporting Council (FRC) — investigative role and funding
- Establishment and powers:
  - FRC established in 2006 to strengthen independence of the investigative function.
  - In charge of investigation of non-compliance with accounting and auditing standards for financial statements of listed issuers.
  - Has full investigative powers, including power to request information from auditors and listed companies, extending to overseas auditors auditing HK listed entities.
  - FRC does not have enforcement powers; cases with grounds are referred to HKICPA for disciplinary action.
- Governance and funding:
  - All FRC members appointed by the Government, including three ad personam appointees nominated by HKICPA, HKEx and SFC respectively, and two ex-officio members (Registrar of Companies and CEO of FRC).
  - FRCO (Cap. 588) stipulates majority of members must be lay members.
  - FRC funded on equal cost sharing basis by HKSAR Government (through Companies Registry), HKICPA, HKEx and SFC.
  - General reserve fund of HK$20 million for FRC to deploy for recurrent funding inadequacies and other exigencies.

### Auditors’ oversight activities and programs
- HKICPA practice review program:
  - Process reengineered in 2007 and stated to meet IFAC SMO 1 requirements.
  - Practice review committee develops an annual plan.
  - Inspection cycle for auditors of listed issuers:
    - The big four are inspected annually;
    - Firms with portfolios of 20 or more engagements have one “full” inspection and one interim inspection (follow up or thematic) in the three year period (around 10 more firms);
    - The remaining firms with engagements with listed issuers are reviewed every 3 years (around 50 more firms).
  - Review team:
    - Consists of 12 fully qualified accountants, all full-time HKICPA employees mainly with big four experience.
    - Rotation requirements: leaders of teams that audit the big four are rotated after three years; a first full rotation took place last year.
    - At the end of last year HKICPA had completed two three year cycles.
  - Inspection scope and sampling:
    - Each inspection reviews environment of control, policies, procedures, and specific audit engagement files.
    - Sample for big four: six to eight files.
    - Team size for large firm: four or five staff; on-site component lasts three weeks.
  - Outcomes and follow up:
    - Inspection reports delivered to practice review committee with recommendations for follow up.
    - Committee can recommend actions, order follow up inspections, or make a complaint to Disciplinary Committee.
    - Recommendations are followed up by inspection or desk-top review.
    - Senior management indicated reviews rarely result in disciplinary actions: enforcement actions taken in three or four cases; only one suspension has taken place.
    - HKICPA lacks powers to request information from listed companies; deficiencies related to audits of listed companies are shared with FRC and disciplinary actions are kept on hold pending FRC investigation.
    - Stakeholders questioned disciplinary panels’ structure as not fostering development of expertise nor precedents.

- HKICPA, HKEx and FRC program of review of financial statements:
  - Joint objective: improve financial reporting; if auditing irregularities found, FRC would investigate; HKICPA would consider follow-up actions if irregularities substantiated.
  - Coverage:
    - Jointly the three organizations cover less than 18 percent of the financial statements of listed issuers in a year.
    - HKEx reviews 120 financial statements a year.
    - FRC reviews 75 financial statements per year.
    - HKICPA reviews around 80 financial statements per year.
  - Coordination and methodology:
    - Lists are exchanged to avoid overlap.
    - HKEx conducts reviews through in-house staff.
    - FRC uses professional staff from large and mid-tier accounting firms and academics who do it pro-bono and on an anonymous basis; each statement usually sent to two reviewers.
    - HKICPA engages external reviewers.
    - All three follow a risk based approach and include a thematic focus each year.
    - Joint reporting forum hosted annually to provide feedback on areas of concern.
  - FRC observation: reviews have not found major failures where misapplication of standards left the market misinformed.

- Complaints handling:
  - FRC indicated complaints against listed companies are not frequent.
  - Complaints related to corporate misconduct are sent to SFC or DPP.
  - Complaints related to misapplication of accounting and auditing standards are dealt with by FRC.

### Findings, deficiencies, and assessors’ comments (Principle 19)
- Main reasons for Partly Implemented grade:
  - Governance structure of HKICPA (question 3 of methodology): perceived as self-regulatory due to presence of practitioners on its board and on disciplinary panels.
  - Enforcement framework (question 7 of methodology): perceived limitations in enforcement.
- Specific concerns:
  - Disciplinary panels’ current arrangements do not seem to foster development of expertise and precedents, potentially affecting enforcement effectiveness.
  - Range of enforcement actions appears limited, in particular due to limitations on the amount of fines (penalty not exceeding HK$500,000).
  - HKICPA lacks jurisdiction to review auditors not registered in HK who audit foreign companies listed in HK.
- Positive notes:
  - Progress acknowledged in strengthening framework for auditors’ oversight.
  - Special arrangement exists for Mainland auditors; other non HK auditors accepted under condition of being subject to independent oversight by an IOSCO MMoU signatory jurisdiction, providing tools for the SFC to require information.
  - Authorities are aware of challenges and committed to further improvements.

### Independence of auditors (Principle 20) — brief description
- Independence framework:
  - Under PAO, HKICPA issues auditing and ethical standards for auditors registered in HKSAR.
  - Standards for auditor independence set out in HKICPA’s Code of Ethics for professional accountants.
  - HKICPA Code of Ethics is substantially the same as the International Code of Ethics promulgated by the International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants and deals with all aspects required by Principle 20.

*Source: Part XIVA of the SFO or the HKEx under the Listing Rules (excerpt).*

### Section 290 of the HKICPA Code of Ethics deals explicitly with independence obligations.

### Section 290 of the HKICPA Code of Ethics deals explicitly with independence obligations.

### Conceptual framework and core definitions
- Independence applies to the firm and its network.
- Independence is defined as comprising (i) independence of mind, and (ii) independence of appearance.
- The Code lays out a conceptual framework to be applied by professional accountants to:
  - (a) Identify threats to independence;
  - (b) Evaluate the significance of the threats identified; and
  - (c) Apply safeguards, when necessary, to eliminate the threats or reduce them to an acceptable level.
- When the audit firm determines that appropriate safeguards are not available or cannot be applied to eliminate the threats or reduce them to an acceptable level, the firm is required to eliminate the circumstance or relationship creating the threats or decline or terminate the audit engagement.
- An audit firm must use professional judgment in applying the conceptual framework.

### Practical application (specific paragraphs and issues)
- Paragraphs 290.102 to 290.231 of Section 290 describe specific circumstances and relationships that create or may create threats to independence (practical application of the conceptual framework).
- The paragraphs deal with issues such as the significance of:
  - (i) financial interests,
  - (ii) loan or guarantees,
  - (iii) business relationships,
  - (iv) family and personal relationships:
  - (v) recent services provided to an audit client.
- The paragraphs describe:
  - the potential threats and the types of safeguards that may be appropriate to eliminate the threats or reduce them to an acceptable level; and
  - identify certain situations where no safeguards could reduce the threats to an acceptable level.
- The paragraphs do not describe all of the circumstances and relationships that create or may create a threat to independence. The firm and the members of the audit team must evaluate the implications of similar, but different, circumstances and relationships and determine whether safeguards can be applied when necessary to eliminate the threats to independence or reduce them to an acceptable level.

### Long association, partner rotation, and non‑assurance services
- The Code has explicit provisions on long association of senior personnel (including partner rotation) with an audit client.
- Paragraphs 290.150 ss require rotation of the key partner after seven years and a cool off period of two years.
- Threats related to long association of other partners must also be evaluated and depending on the circumstance rotation or regular independent quality reviews must be performed.
- The Code also has explicit provisions of non assurance services to clients, including a list of services that should not be provided.

### Requirements for non-HK reporting accountants and auditors
- Non HK reporting accountants and auditors must be independent of both overseas company and any other company concerned to the same extent required of an auditor under the CO and in accordance with the HKICPA Guidance on Independence or the Statements on Independence issued by the IFA.

### Mechanisms to ensure auditor independence
- Review by the own firm
  - The HK Standard on Quality Control 1 requires an audit firm to establish policies and procedures designed to provide it with reasonable assurance that the firm, its personnel and, where applicable, others subject to independence requirements (including experts contracted by the firm and network firm personnel), maintain independence as required by the Code.
  - Such policies and procedures should enable the firm to:
    - Communicate its independence requirements to its personnel and where applicable, others subject to them; and
    - Identify and evaluate circumstances and relationships that create threats to independence, and to take appropriate action to eliminate those threats or reduce them to an acceptable level by applying safeguards, or, if considered appropriate, to withdraw from the engagement.
  - Such policies and procedures should require:
    - Engagement partners to provide the firm with relevant information about client engagements, including the scope of services, to enable the firm to evaluate the overall impact, if any, on independence requirements;
    - Personnel to promptly notify the firm of circumstances and relationships that create a threat to independence so that appropriate action can be taken; and
    - The accumulation and communication of relevant information to appropriate personnel so that:
      - The firm and its personnel can readily determine whether they satisfy independence requirements;
      - The firm can maintain and update its records relating to independence; and
      - The firm can take appropriate action regarding identified threats to independence. Appropriate action by the firm and the relevant engagement partner includes applying appropriate safeguards to eliminate the threats to independence or to reduce them to an acceptable level, or withdrawing from the engagement.
  - In addition, the firm provides independence education to personnel who are required to be independent.
  - At least annually, the firm should obtain written confirmation of compliance with its policies and procedures on independence from all firm personnel required to be independent by the Code.

- Audit Committee
  - Under the Main Board Listing Rule 3.21 and GEM Listing Rule 5.28 of HKEx every listed issuer must establish an audit committee made up only of non-executive directors.
  - HKICPA’s “A Guide for Effective Audit Committees” sets out guidance on the establishment of an audit committee, in which paragraph 51 states that members of the Committee may have useful experience in assessing the quality of the service and the reasonableness of the fees charged by the external auditors and they should make recommendations to the board on the appointment of the external auditors, the audit fee, and any questions of resignation or dismissal.
  - Pursuant to Rule 3.21 Listed issuers may adopt the terms of reference set out in that guide, or they may adopt any other comparable terms of reference for the establishment of an audit committee.
  - Rule 3.22 requires the board of directors of the listed issuer to approve and provide written terms of reference for the audit committee which clearly establish the committee’s authority and duties.
  - In addition, there are specific provisions in the Code of Corporate Governance Practices in

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 290 of the HKICPA Code of Ethics deals explicitly with independence obligations.*

### Appendix 14 of the Main Board Listing Rule and Appendix 15 of the GEM Listing Rule of HKEx

### Appendix 14 of the Main Board Listing Rule and Appendix 15 of the GEM Listing Rule of HKEx

### Audit committees, auditor independence, and resignations
- Appendix 14 and Appendix 15 require that the audit committee’s terms of reference should include at least a duty to review and monitor the external auditor’s independence and objectivity and the effectiveness of the audit process in accordance with applicable standards.
- Market participants' observations:
  - The role of audit committees has improved over time; in practice how proactive they are varies considerably from company to company.
  - Variation in proactivity is not necessarily correlated with the size of the company.
  - Expectation that the role will continue to strengthen as recent reforms to the CO have strengthened provisions concerning fiduciary duties of directors.
- Resignation and disclosure requirement:
  - Under the Main Board Listing Rule 13.51(4) and the GEM Listing Rule 17.50(4) of HKEx an issuer must publish an announcement as soon as practicable in regard to any change in its auditors, the reason(s) for the change and any other matters that need to be brought to the attention of holders of securities of the issuer.
- Issues identified in practice:
  - Audits of companies from the Mainland pose greater challenges linked to the sheer size of the country and difficulties getting a good understanding of a company's business.
  - Problems with the quality of financial reporting mainly connected with smaller non-state-owned enterprises listed in Hong Kong.
  - Problems with secrecy provisions relating to listed entities that are state-owned enterprises; an ongoing court case involving an auditing firm was noted.
  - Anecdotal evidence suggests large auditors are cautious in taking Mainland engagements, as suggested by resignations during the pre-filing period.
- Assessment: Broadly implemented
  - Comments: The grade stems from the current enforcement framework in connection with question 7 of the methodology.
  - Current independence requirements are robust, and mechanisms exist to oversee auditors’ compliance. However, the disciplinary framework does not appear to be strong enough. Quality of engagement of audit committees varies, but evolution is positive.

### Audit standards, standard setting, and mechanisms to ensure compliance
- Standards required:
  - The CO and the Main Board Listing Rules require that financial statements included in public offering and listing particulars documents and publicly available annual reports shall be audited in accordance with the auditing standards in Hong Kong.
  - Such standards are converged with the International Standards on Auditing.
  - Under the special arrangement described in Principle 19, Mainland companies with a dual listing can choose to use the Mainland accounting standards as well as to use a Mainland incorporated auditing firm which would use the Chinese Standards on Auditing.
  - For overseas companies the Listing Rules require auditors to conduct their audits based on a standard comparable to that required by the HKICPA or the IAASB of the IFA. To date the Exchange has accepted the following standards:
    - (i) Australian Auditing Standards,
    - (ii) Canadian GAAP,
    - (iii) Professional auditing standards applicable in France,
    - (iv) Italian Auditing Standards,
    - (v) Singapore Standards on Auditing,
    - (vi) the Standards for Investment Reporting Issued by the Auditing Practice Board of the UK, and
    - (vii) US Public Company Accounting Oversight Board auditing standards.
- Standard setting:
  - The HKICPA is the standard setting body. The process is open and transparent.
  - HKICPA opens consultation for exposure drafts of the IASSB at the same time the IASSB does its own consultation.
  - Stakeholders consulted include members and member practices of HKICPA, companies in Hong Kong, HKEx, regulatory and legal authorities, academics and other interested individuals and organizations. Comments are sent to the IASSB.
  - Upon approval of the standards by the IASSB, the HKICPA approves them also for Hong Kong.
  - HK Standards on Auditing and minutes/submissions are available on the HKICPA website.
- Mechanisms to ensure compliance with auditing standards:
  - Own firm (HKSQC1 requirements): The HKSQC1 requires audit firms to establish a System of Quality Control that includes policies and procedures that address each of the following elements:
    - Leadership responsibilities for quality within the firm.
    - Relevant ethical requirements.
    - Acceptance and continuance of client relationships and specific engagements.
    - Human resources.
    - Engagement performance.
    - Monitoring.
  - The firm must document its policies and procedures and communicate them to the firm’s personnel. Compliance with this obligation is reviewed during the HKICPA reviews.
  - HKICPA review program: HKICPA has in place a program of reviews of audit firms.
  - HKICPA and FRC financial statements review program: Programs of reviews of financial statements of listed issuers aimed at detecting auditing irregularities and non-compliances with accounting standards.
- Assessment: Broadly Implemented
  - Comments: The grade stems from the current enforcement framework vis-à-vis question 4 of the methodology.
  - Auditing standards in place are of high international quality, and the HKICPA has instituted a program that reviews auditors’ compliance with them that is in line with programs established in other jurisdictions. However, the enforcement framework has limitations.
  - Mainland companies with dual listing can use the Chinese Standards on Auditing; the assessors did not conduct an independent assessment of such standards but note the WB ROSC mentioned in Principle 20 concluded such standards were largely comparable to IAASB-issued ISA.

### Credit rating agencies (CRAs): licensing, regulatory framework, and supervision
- Requirement for a license:
  - Effective June 1 2011, a firm that wants to provide credit rating services in Hong Kong must be licensed for Type 10 regulated activity under the SFO (Chapter 571). In addition, the individual analysts are subject to licensing as representatives.
  - Both the provision of credit rating services and credit ratings are defined terms under Part 2 of Schedule 5 to the SFO.
  - The obligation to obtain a license stems from carrying on a business in the regulated activity in Hong Kong; regardless of whether such ratings are going to be used for regulatory purposes or not.
  - Ratings are used in Hong Kong for regulatory purposes but only in limited cases: mainly for purposes of determining capital requirements for banks and securities firms. Only the ratings of the global CRAs (Fitch, Standard & Poor's and Moody’s) can be used for regulatory purposes. The reference predates the regulation of CRAs, and that is why the names of these CRAs are “hardwired” into the legal framework.
- Regulatory framework applicable to CRAs:
  - Provision of credit rating services is regulated in the SFO under the general framework for securities intermediaries; all obligations and requirements imposed on securities intermediaries are applicable to CRAs at licensing and on an ongoing basis.
  - SFC powers applicable to CRAs include: refuse a license, request information, conduct investigations and inspections and impose disciplinary actions.
  - SFC has developed a Code of Conduct for CRAs fully aligned with the IOSCO’s Code of Conduct Fundamentals for Credit Rating Agencies, divided into four sections:
    - Obligations related to the quality and integrity of the rating process, including requirements that a CRA should (i) adopt, implement, and enforce written procedures, (ii) use ratings that are rigorous, systematic and where possible, which result in ratings that can be subject to some form of objective validation, (iii) keep records, (iv) use representatives who individually and collectively have appropriate knowledge and experience, (v) ensure that it has sufficient resources, (vi) establish a review function;
    - Independence and avoidance of conflicts of interest: A CRA should (i) refrain from carrying on businesses which can reasonably be considered to give the rise to conflicts of interest; (ii) refrain from entering into any contingent fee arrangement, (iii) adopt policies and mechanisms to identify, eliminate or manage conflicts of interest, (iv) disclose actual or potential conflicts in a complete manner, (v) disclose compensation arrangements, (vi) ensure that reporting lines and compensation for representatives are designed to eliminate conflicts.
    - Responsibilities to the investing public and rated entities: A CRA should (i) publicly disclose all ratings and updates of such ratings in a timely manner; (ii) disclose policies for distributing of ratings and updates, (iii) ensure that clear and easily comprehensible information on its procedures, methodologies and assumptions is publicly available, (iv) where sufficient historical data exists, publish information about the historical default rates of rating categories and about ratings transition frequency, and whether the default rates of rating categories has changed over time, (v) disclose any material modification to its methodologies; (vi) adopt procedures and mechanisms to protect confidential information, (vii) use confidential information only for purposes related to its rating activities, (viii) ensure that its representatives and employees do not selectively disclose any non public information about ratings.
    - Disclosure of a CRA’s own code of conduct and communication with market participants: A CRA should have its own code of conduct and should disclose it to the public.
- Practice: registration and on-going supervision
  - Since implementation of the CRA regulatory regime, seven CRAs have been granted licenses. Major global CRAs are present; additionally 2 CRAs with Mainland background (start-up stage), and a very small domestic CRA (start-up stage).
  - Formal application process lasted roughly three months; CRAs approached the SFC informally before applications to align governance, policies and procedures with SFC expectations.
  - Staff review focused on five core areas: (i) business, (ii) internal controls and compliance, (iii) substantial shareholders, (iv) management team/ROs, and (v) vetting of individual applicants.
  - Licensing process was thorough; SFC staff made substantive inquiries related to policies and procedures, and fitness and properness of ROs.
  - Ongoing supervision performed by the Intermediaries Supervision Department; no separate unit, but teams include persons with relevant background and training.
  - Off-site monitoring focuses on three areas: business model, conduct supervision and industry developments.
  - Risk-based approach in practice has focused bulk of work on the three global CRAs; initial data collection established baselines and stratified rating portfolios.
  - A key input for conduct supervision and inspection planning is the annual report of the internal control environment and methodology required from CRAs. SFC had received reports for two years; second year’s reports were better after feedback.
  - SFC monitors actions of major regulators and samples rating publications and sector reports; conducts analysis of past performance focused on structured products (perceived more problematic) including rating population, downgrades and rating transition, comparing Asia Pacific against global structured finance.
  - Since implementation of the CRA licensing regime, the SFC has inspected two of the big three CRAs; inspections covered all major areas and letters of deficiencies were sent to the CRAs.
- Assessment: Fully implemented
  - Comments: [no additional comments in source]

### Analysts and other evaluative services (Principle 23)
- Analysts:
  - Issuance of analysis or reports on securities and futures contracts falls under Type 4 regulated activity (advising on securities) and Type 5 regulated activity (advising on futures contracts) and therefore is subject to licensing requirements. Analysts are subject to individual licensing as representatives.
  - Firms and analysts must satisfy the fit and proper criteria in section 129 of the SFO, including demonstrating that they are financially sound, competent, honest, reputable and reliable and in compliance with relevant laws, codes and guidelines.
  - Intermediaries providing advisory services must have processes and procedures to address conflicts of interest per the SFC’s Fit and Proper Guidelines and the Guidelines on Competence.
  - Specific guidelines for analysts, developed and implemented in 2005 based on the IOSCO’s Statement of Principles for Addressing Sell-side Analyst Conflicts of Interest, are included in the Code of Conduct.
  - The guidelines were reviewed and strengthened in 2011 to extend the Code of Conduct to pre-deal research published by connected analysis and REITS.
- Code of Conduct key obligations (aligned with Principle 23):
  - Analysts trading and financial interest: Firms must (i) establish trading policies, (ii) place limitations on dealing by analysts, and (iii) impose obligations to disclose relevant relationships and relevant financial interest.
  - Firm financial interest and business relationships: Firms must (i) disclose financial interest; relevant market making activities; relevant relationships; and relevant business relationships in the research report, (ii) not deal or trade ahead of the issuer, (iii) not provide assurances to issuers of favourable reviews, and (iv) not issue research within certain specific periods of an offering.
  - Analysts reporting lines and compensation: Firms should ensure that (i) reporting lines and compensation of analysts are not linked to the investment banking function, (ii) there is no preapproval of research by the investment banking function; and (iii) analysts do not participate in business activities designed to solicit investment banking business.
  - Firm compliance systems: Firms must maintain (i) policies and control procedures to eliminate, avoid or manage actual and potential conflicts of interest, and (ii) procedures to ensure analysts are not provided with material information not reasonably expected to be included in the prospectus or publicly available.
  - Outside influence: Firms must disclose whether the issuer or a third party has provided or agreed to provide any compensation or other benefits in connection with investment research.
  - Clarity, specificity and prominence of disclosure: Disclosures should be clear, concise, specific, given adequate prominence and released in a timely and fair manner.
  - Integrity and ethical behavior: An analyst should have reasonable basis for his analysis and recommendations, and should define the terms used in its research.
- Supervision:
  - Conflicts of interest is a focus area in SFC ongoing supervision of intermediaries. Provision of research is examined in the context of the general framework for risk based supervision.
  - In practice, research in Hong Kong is mainly provided by larger intermediaries; few independent research houses.
  - SFC monitors compliance via on-site inspections and review of public information; on-site inspections examine compliance with policies and procedures, especially relationship with investment banking (reporting lines and compensation).
  - There have been a few enforcement actions against an analyst; the most recent was triggered by a complaint and involved conflicts of interest.
- Other evaluative services:
  - IPO sponsors are required to hold a licence for Type 6 regulated activity (advising on corporate finance).
  - SFC detected weaknesses with IPO sponsors' expected role in the listing process through its ongoing supervisory program; as a result the SFC launched a consultation in May 2012 on proposals to enhance the regulatory regime for IPO sponsors. The conclusions were published in December.

*Source: _cr14205 - Appendix 14 of the Main Board Listing Rule and Appendix 15 of the GEM Listing Rule of HKEx*

### 2012. The new requirements aim to ensure that sponsors conduct thorough due diligence on

### _cr14205 - 2012. The new requirements aim to ensure that sponsors conduct thorough due diligence on

### Reforms to IPO sponsorship and prospectus liability
- New requirements apply to listing applications submitted from 1 October 2013 onwards.
- Reforms emphasize:
  - early, comprehensive due diligence by sponsors on any company aspiring to access Hong Kong’s securities market before making a listing application;
  - a properly drafted prospectus to accompany the application;
  - sponsors taking a responsible, proactive and constructive role when leading IPOs.
- The SFC recommended that the CO be amended to clarify that the existing civil and criminal prospectus liability provisions apply to IPO sponsors.
- The SFC is working with the Government on the proposed legislative amendments.
- Assessment: Fully implemented
- SFC staff informed that no other evaluative service has prompted adjustments to the perimeter of regulation.

### Principles for Collective Investment Schemes (CIS) — overview
- Principle 24: The regulatory system should set standards for the eligibility, governance, organization and operational conduct of those who wish to market or operate a CIS.
- Authorization, marketing and operation of CIS are governed by the SFO and its subsidiary legislation.
- CIS activity is also regulated through provisions applying to securities and financial products generally (Schedule 1 of the SFO defines “securities” to include CIS and “financial product” to include – among other things – CIS).
- Codes made by the SFC under s. 399 of the SFO play an important part in the regulation of CIS, notably:
  - Section II of the SFC Handbook for Unit Trusts and Mutual Funds, ILAS and Unlisted Structured Investment Products (the Products Handbook) establishes guidelines for the authorization of schemes and eligibility requirements for scheme operators;
  - The FMCC provides guidance on minimum standards of conduct specifically for fund managers licensed by or registered with the SFC.

### Industry structure and key statistics
- At March 2013:
  - 316 firms managing SFC authorized funds, of which 80 were firms licensed by SFC and 236 were based in other jurisdictions.
  - These management firms are classified into 101 fund management groups.
- A total of 1,847 funds were authorized by the SFC for public offering in the Hong Kong market, of which 305 (17 percent) were Hong Kong domiciled funds.
  - Of the 305 SFC authorized funds domiciled in HK, there were 50 SFC licensed firms managing them.
  - 1,045 (57 percent) were funds domiciled in Luxembourg.
  - 277 (15 percent) were domiciled in Ireland.
  - 151 (8 percent) were domiciled in the Cayman Islands.
  - 53 (3 percent) were domiciled in the UK.
- At end of 2012, total assets under management was US $1,237 billion, of which 120 (9.7 percent) billion was attributable to Hong Kong investors.
- As at 31 July 2013, there were a total of 10 SFC-authorized REITs listed on SEHK, with a total market capitalization of approximately HK$176 billion, representing about 0.8 percent of the total market capitalization of all listed securities on SEHK.
- Funds management is shared between bank and non-bank groups, but the selling of funds is heavily dominated by banks.

### Regulatory framework — licensing, authorization and marketing
- Marketing a CIS:
  - A person carrying on a business in regulated activities as defined under Schedule 5 to the SFO in Hong Kong, including the marketing of securities such as CIS, is required to be licensed by or registered with the SFC.
- Operating a CIS:
  - Section 103 of the SFO makes it a criminal offence for any scheme to be offered to the public in Hong Kong without SFC’s prior authorization.
  - A scheme sold only to professional investors (as defined in the SFO) is exempted.
  - CIS operators domiciled in Hong Kong are required to be licensed by or registered with the SFC and hold a licence or registration for Type 9 regulated activity (asset management).
  - Operators not carrying on any businesses in regulated activities in Hong Kong (e.g., overseas fund managers) are not required to be licensed/registered by the SFC but must have each scheme offered to the public in HKSAR authorized by the SFC.
  - Under UTC 5.1, every scheme for which authorization is requested must appoint a management company acceptable to the SFC.
  - A non-Hong Kong domiciled management company, or investment adviser to which the investment management function is delegated, must be based in a jurisdiction with an AIR.

### Eligibility criteria for management companies (UTC Chapter 5)
- UTC 5.2 requires a management company to:
  - a. be engaged primarily in the business of fund management;
  - b. have sufficient financial resources at its disposal to enable it to conduct its business effectively and meet its liabilities, in particular it must have a minimum issued and paid-up capital and capital reserves of HK$1 million or its equivalent in foreign currency;
  - c. not lend to a material extent; and
  - d. maintain at all times a positive net asset position.
- A scheme operator intending to carry on regulated activities in Hong Kong must satisfy the same minimum entry requirements that apply to other market intermediaries to be licensed or registered with the SFC.

### Specialist funds and product-specific criteria
- UTC contains detailed criteria for specialist funds, including:
  - UTC 8.4A futures and options funds;
  - UTC 8.5 guaranteed funds;
  - UTC 8.6 index funds;
  - UTC 8.7 HFs including funds of HFs;
  - UTC 8.8 structured funds;
  - UTC 8.9 funds that invest extensively in financial derivative instruments.

### Integrity, competence and internal management
- UTC 5.4: directors of the management company must be of good repute and possess necessary experience in the opinion of the SFC.
- UTC 5.5: key personnel of the management company are expected to be dedicated full-time staff with at least 5 years investment relevant experience managing public funds with reputable institutions.
  - Sufficient human and technical resources must be at the disposal of the management company without relying solely on a single individual’s expertise.
  - SFC must be satisfied with the overall integrity of the management company including reasonable assurance on adequacy of internal controls and existence of written procedures.
  - Ongoing supervision and monitoring of competence of delegates is required to ensure accountability to investors is not diminished.
- Financial capacity: licensed or registered applicants must comply with the financial resources requirements specified in the Securities and Futures Rules (Financial Resources) Rules (FRR) or other relevant regulatory requirements.
- Internal management procedures:
  - The Guidelines on Competence apply to all licensees concerning human resources, risk management and internal control systems.
  - FMCC paragraph 1.2(c): a licensed fund manager should maintain satisfactory internal controls and written compliance procedures addressing all applicable regulatory requirements.
  - UTC 5.5(d): conflicts of interests must be properly addressed; there must be reasonable assurance about adequacy of internal controls and written procedures regularly monitored by senior management.

### Trustees and custodians
- UTC 4.1 and UTC 4.7 require every scheme to appoint a trustee/custodian independent of the management company.
- A trustee/custodian must be one of:
  - a. a bank licensed under section 16 of the BO;
  - b. a trust company which is a subsidiary of such a bank;
  - c. a trust company registered under Part VIII of the Trustee Ordinance; or
  - d. a banking institution or trust company incorporated outside Hong Kong acceptable to the SFC.
- In limited circumstances, trustee/custodian and management company can have the same ultimate holding company (UTC 4.8).
- UTC 4.5 general obligations of trustee/custodian include safekeeping of assets and taking reasonable care to ensure the scheme is managed in accordance with constitutive documents.
  - UTC 4.5(f) requires the trustee/custodian to issue a report to holders to be included in the annual report of the scheme on:
    - a. whether, in the trustee/custodian’s opinion, the management has in all material respects managed the scheme in accordance with the provisions of the scheme’s constitutive documents; and
    - b. if the management company has not done so, the respects in which it has not done so and the steps which the trustee/custodian has taken.
- In practice, trustees/custodians of SFC authorized CIS are usually banks licensed in HK (supervised by HKMA), overseas banks (supervised by overseas regulators acceptable to SFC), or subsidiaries of such banks.

### International cooperation and AIR (Acceptable Inspection Regime)
- Non-Hong Kong managers may be situated outside Hong Kong provided they are based in an AIR.
- SFC assesses acceptability of an overseas supervisory authority as an AIR by checking:
  - a. whether the overseas regulatory authority or its delegate carries out inspections of investment management firms in a manner generally consistent with the SFC; and
  - b. whether the SFC and the overseas regulatory authority have satisfactory procedures for timely exchange of information regarding investment management firms.
- SFC conducts due diligence before signing an MOU with a jurisdiction and normally verifies registration and compliance status with the home regulator before authorizing an applicant. SFC maintains ongoing dialogue regarding the scheme while authorized.
- For trustees: Appendix G of the UTC requires the overseas supervisory authority to carry out regular inspection of trustees/custodians or ensure regular review in a manner generally consistent with SFC.

### Sanctions, enforcement and monitoring unauthorized activity
- Under section 103 of the SFO, offering an unauthorized CIS or engaging in unlicensed funds management is an offence liable to a fine of up to HK$500,000 or 3 years imprisonment.
- Overarching Principle (OP) 1.6: failure to comply with any provision of the Products Handbook may cause SFC to consider withdrawal of authorization, impose additional authorization conditions, or restrict further offering.
- SFC monitors the market to detect unauthorized offerings, including reviewing advertisements on randomly selected days of the month.
- Sanction powers available for breaches by fund managers include administrative action and, in serious cases, criminal sanctions.

### Supervision, ongoing monitoring and authorization process
- SFC has sole responsibility for regulation of CIS activity in Hong Kong, except HKMA’s role in supervision of securities activities of licensed banks and deposit-taking institutions.
- SFC powers for CIS include:
  - a. authorize schemes to be offered to the public in Hong Kong (section 104(1) of the SFO);
  - b. seek information from and conduct on-site inspections of CIS operators licensed by the SFC (section 180 of the SFO);
  - c. conduct investigations (sections 182-183);
  - d. withdraw authorization of schemes (section 106); and
  - e. take remedial, disciplinary and other forms of action for breaches (Parts IX and X of the SFO).
- Authorization and licensing process:
  - Applicants must provide evidence they can and will comply with UTC provisions.
  - For fund managers from an AIR, SFC checks with the home regulator as part of the authorization process.
  - The process is set out in written procedures and involves a thorough review of proposed operations, owners, directors and senior management.
- Product approval involves review of disclosure documents (including Product Key Facts Statements, KFS) and proposed advertising by Investment Products Division; where concerns arise, the Division issues “mindedness” letters 9 months after take up indicating intention to reject if problems not rectified.
- This review process applies to all funds, even if approved by home regulators.

### Ongoing monitoring, inspections, pricing errors and enforcement statistics
- Ongoing supervision uses combination of off-site monitoring and on-site inspections with a formal risk and impact assessment to select targets.
- For fund management, asset classes and fund manager track record are important inputs in the risk and impact assessment.
- SFC pays particular attention to trustees/custodians reports and auditor’s reports for all HK authorized funds, including those whose managers do not perform activities in HK.
- Pricing errors:
  - If an error results in an incorrect price of 0.5 percent or more of the NAV per unit/share, investors must be compensated and trustee/custodian and SFC must be notified.
  - During January 2008 to July 2013 a total of 321 pricing errors were reported to the SFC, of which 285 pricing errors were related to SFC authorized funds constituted abroad. All pricing errors were processed by the SFC and completed in accordance with the Code on Unit Trust and Mutual Funds.
- On-site inspections of fund managers (that operate in HK) — total inspections by year and type:
  - Hedge fund managers inspections by year: 2008-2009: 4; 2009-2010: 28; 2010-2011: 16; 2011-2012: 23; 2012-2013: 18.
  - Other fund managers inspections by year: 2008-2009: 16; 2009-2010: 46; 2010-2011: 60; 2011-2012: 38; 2012-2013: 54.
  - Total inspections by year: 2008-2009: 20; 2009-2010: 74; 2010-2011: 76; 2011-2012: 61; 2012-2013: 72.
- Enforcement sanctions on fund managers — by type of misconduct and year:
  - Insider dealing: 2008/09: 0; 2009/10: 5; 2010/11: 1; 2011/12: 1; 2012/13: 2.
  - Market manipulation: 2008/09: 0; 2009/10: 2; 2010/11: 0; 2011/12: 2; 2012/13: 0.
  - Issuing unauthorized advertisement: 2008/09: 2; 2009/10: 2; 2010/11: 3; 2011/12: 4; 2012/13: 2.
  - Providing misleading information to SFC: 2008/09: 0; 2009/10: 1; 2010/11: 1; 2011/12: 0; 2012/13: 2.
  - Unlicensed activities: 2008/09: 0; 2009/10: 1; 2010/11: 0; 2011/12: 2; 2012/13: 0.
  - Other misconduct: 2008/09: 3; 2009/10: 3; 2010/11: 5; 2011/12: 0; 2012/13: 4.
  - Total sanctions: 2008/09: 5; 2009/10: 14; 2010/11: 10; 2011/12: 9; 2012/13: 10.
- Examples of successful actions against overseas fund managers include actions against Tiger Asia Management LLC and George Stairs (US based asset managers) where SFC obtained orders in relation to insider dealing.

*Source: IMF staff summary of SFC materials contained in the provided content unit.*

### Section 3(1)(a) and section 1 of the Schedule to the Securities and Futures (Keeping of

### _cr14205 - Section 3(1)(a) and section 1 of the Schedule to the Securities and Futures (Keeping of

### Record keeping and statutory standards
- Section 3(1)(a) and section 1 of the Schedule to the Securities and Futures (Keeping of Records) Rules (KRR) require licensed or registered scheme operators to maintain accounting, trading and other records "as are sufficient to explain and reflect the financial position and operation of businesses which constitute any regulated activities."
- Section 130(3) of the SFO provides for SFC’s prior approval of premises to be used for keeping records and documents.
- Paragraph 5.1 of the FMCC requires a licensed or registered fund manager to keep its accounts and records properly and in line with all applicable statutory requirements, and specifies the standard to be used.
- UTC 5.10 makes the management company responsible for maintaining the books and records of a scheme and preparing the scheme's accounts and reports.
- For Non-Hong Kong based schemes, UTC 9.1 requires appointment of a representative in Hong Kong if the management company is not incorporated and does not have a place of business in Hong Kong; UTC 9.3 requires the representative to deliver to the SFC, on request, all accounts and records relating to the sale and redemption of units/shares of the scheme in Hong Kong.
- All records required under the KRR must be kept in a form which is readily accessible.

### Reporting frequency, timelines and filing obligations
- UTC 11.6 requires at least two reports to be published for each financial year:
  - annual reports and accounts: Appendix E must be published and distributed to holders "within four months of the end of the scheme's financial year";
  - interim (6 monthly) reports: must be published and distributed to holders "within two months of the end of the period they cover."
- UTC 11.8 requires that financial reports produced by or for the scheme, its management company and trustee/custodian must be filed with the SFC within the time frame specified in UTC 11.6.
- Sections 3 and 4 of the Securities and Futures (Accounts and Audit) Rules require licensed corporations including SFC-licensed fund managers to prepare audited financial statements on an annual basis.
- Additional reporting requirements:
  - money market funds (UTC 8.2(d)): file with the SFC "within 7 days from the last working day of each month" details of total subscriptions that month and total funds under management at the end of that month;
  - HFs (UTC 8.7(w)): funds required to issue regular reports to holders of the scheme activities "at least on a quarterly basis"; reports must be prepared and distributed in accordance with UTC Appendix H and filed with the SFC.
- UTC 4.1 and UTC Appendix G require the trustee/custodian to file a copy of the auditor’s report and the trustee/custodian report relating to internal controls and systems prepared pursuant to UTC Appendix G "within four months from the end of the period under review."

### Changes in management, approvals and notifications
- Licensed/registered scheme operators are subject to ongoing obligations and to prior approval/notification requirements under the SFO and the Securities and Futures (Licensing and Registration) (Information) Rules:
  - seek prior approval of the SFC for any appointment of ROs;
  - notify the SFC of any cessation of ROs "within 7 business days after the cessation takes effect";
  - notify the SFC of any change in their board of directors "within 7 business days after the change takes place";
  - notify the SFC of significant changes in the nature of the business and type of services "within 7 business days after the change takes place";
  - notify the SFC of significant changes in its business plan covering internal controls, organization structure, contingency plan and related matters "within 7 business days after the change takes place."
- UTC 11.1 sets out proposed changes to a scheme which must be submitted to the SFC for prior approval (see Principle 25).
- By UTC 11.1(b), proposed changes of the key operators of the scheme, including the management company and its delegates, must be submitted to the SFC for prior approval and "one month’s prior notice is normally required to be given to holders before the changes are to take effect."

### Conduct of business, product provider obligations and the Products Code
- Licensed or registered scheme operators must comply with the Code of Conduct, FMCC and ICG and have conduct obligations as licensed/registered persons.
- Operators as product providers are subject to the OPs of the Products Code, including:
  - OP 3.3: product providers must act honestly, fairly and professionally;
  - OP 4.1 of the Products Handbook: operators must (i) inform the SFC promptly of any material breach of the Products Handbook and (ii) use best endeavours to take appropriate remedial action to rectify any breach promptly;
  - OP 3.6, OP 5.3 and OP 5.4: product providers must exercise reasonable care and diligence in selecting counterparties and service providers and must avoid conflicts of interest.
- FMCC contains conduct rules on staff dealing, receipt of benefits, order execution, allocation of trades, churning, etc.

### Best execution, allocation of trades, churning and due diligence
- Best execution: Paragraph 3.2 of the FMCC says a licensed or registered fund manager should execute client orders "on the best available terms, taking into account the relevant market at the time for transactions of the kind and size concerned."
- Allocation of trades: Paragraph 3.4 of the FMCC requires fair allocation of client orders and prompt allocation of executed transactions in accordance with stated intention, except where revised allocation does not disadvantage a client and reasons are clearly documented.
- Churning: Paragraph 3.5 of the FMCC says a licensed or registered fund manager should not trade excessively on behalf of the client portfolio, taking into account the portfolio’s stated objectives.
- Due diligence: General Principle 2 of the Code of Conduct requires licensed or registered persons to act with due skill and diligence, in the best interests of clients and market integrity. OP 3.8 of the Products Handbook requires product providers to discharge their functions with due skill, care and diligence.

### Conflicts of interest and related disclosure requirements
- Licensed or registered scheme operators are subject to General Principle 6 and paragraph 10.1 of the Code of Conduct on conflicts of interest.
- OP 4.2 of the Products Handbook requires product providers to avoid conflicts; where unavoidable and investors’ interests can be sufficiently protected, conflicts must be managed, minimized and properly disclosed.
- Specific CIS provisions:
  - FMCC paragraph 2.2 prohibits inducements likely to significantly conflict with duties owed to clients; requires written guidelines (including monetary limits) on acceptance of gifts, rebates or other benefits and a register of benefits above specified limits;
  - UTC provisions for class meetings where conflicts between classes of holders may arise (UTC 6.15(e));
  - UTC prohibits certain persons from voting their beneficially owned shares where they have a material interest (UTC 6.15(h));
  - UTC provisions on conflicts for HFs (UTC 8.7(k)(ii) to (v)) and structured funds (UTC 8.8).
- UTC 10.9 to 10.13 set out requirements for transactions with connected persons, including:
  - underwriting and sub-underwriting (prior consent of trustee/custodian unless all commissions and fees payable to the management company under such contracts for part of scheme assets);
  - other scheme transactions: trustee approval required, arms’ length and disclosure in the annual report;
  - cash or rebates including soft dollar commissions: disclosure in offer documents and annual reports;
  - transactions with connected broker-dealers: best execution, market rates and disclosure in annual report.
- Paragraph 13.3 of the Code of Conduct: transactions or services acquired involving payment from client assets to a person connected with the licensed/registered person must be at arm’s length terms and in the best interests of the client and "not be less favourable than those generally available in the market."
- D12 of Appendix D and Appendix E of the UTC set out required information about transactions with connected parties in constitutive documents and financial reports respectively.

### Delegation, supervision of delegates and responsibility
- Delegation of investment management functions is permitted but the management company must carry out ongoing supervision and regular monitoring of delegated parties to ensure accountability to investors is not diminished (UTC 5.5(e)); responsibilities and obligations of the management company may not be delegated.
- A scheme operator that completely delegates all core functions to another entity will not be regarded as carrying on a business in the regulated activity in Hong Kong and will not be granted or permitted to continue to hold a licence for that activity.
- Investment advisers delegated the investment management function are subject to the same acceptability criteria as management companies (Chapter 5 of the UTC).
- Delegation disclosure: delegation arrangements must be disclosed in the offering document including the KFS (UTC Appendix C3).
- Changes in delegation arrangements are significant changes in the operator’s business plan and must be notified to the SFC "within 7 business days after the change takes place" by section 4 of the Information Rule.
- UTC 4.5(a)(iii) provides that the trustee/custodian must be liable for the acts and omissions of its nominees and agents in relation to assets forming part of scheme property.
- UTC 5.5(e) and FMCC paragraph 1.8 reiterate that management company responsibilities and obligations may not be delegated.

### Regulator access to information and supervisory practice
- SFC access:
  - If delegated functions are conducted by licensed/registered managers/advisors, access to data is provided under section 180 of the SFO;
  - SFC can access information about delegated functions carried out by non-licensees through the scheme operator.
- Supervision practices and assessment:
  - For fund managers based or having a presence in HKSAR, SFC licensing process and RI registration process administered by the HKMA and SFC are described as rigorous and effective.
  - Ongoing supervision of licensed fund managers is carried out via off-site monitoring, on-site inspections and thematic reviews.
  - HKMA’s monitoring and on-site inspection program for banks (main distribution channel for CIS) is intensive and focuses heavily on selling and distribution; the HKMA refers cases to SFC where enforcement action is required.
  - SFC’s supervision program uses a well-developed risk-based system for planning off-site and on-site supervision work; off-site monitoring of fund managers is thorough and continuous.
- Assessment: "Fully Implemented" for the responsibilities described.

### Legal form, constitutive documents, disclosure and investor rights
- The definition of CIS in Schedule 1 of the SFO is functionally based and does not reference legal form; UTC envisages CIS as mutual funds or unit trusts (UTC 3.2).
- In practice, Hong Kong domiciled funds are established as unit trusts; non-Hong Kong based funds are mostly either unit trusts or mutual funds.
- All authorized schemes must comply with OP Section of the Products Handbook and UTC requirements on:
  - key operating parties;
  - operational features;
  - investment restrictions;
  - disclosure in offering documents;
  - post-authorization obligations.
- SFO empowers SFC to authorize schemes offered to the public in Hong Kong (section 104 of the SFO).
- UTC 6.6 requires constitutive documents to contain information listed in UTC Appendix D, including:
  - participating parties, representative, trustee/custodian, and investment adviser (if any);
  - obligations of the management company;
  - investment and borrowing restrictions;
  - valuation of property and pricing;
  - suspension and deferral of dealing;
  - fees and charges;
  - meetings;
  - transactions with connected persons;
  - distribution policy and date;
  - annual accounting period;
  - base currency;
  - modification of constitutive documents; and
  - termination of scheme.
- UTC 6.6: nothing in constitutive documents may exempt trustee/custodian, management company or directors from liability to holders imposed under Hong Kong law or the law of domicile for breaches of trust through fraud or negligence, nor may they be indemnified against such liability by holders or at holders’ expense.
- Responsibility for monitoring compliance with form and structure: prior authorization from the SFC required before offering to the public (section 103) and offering documents are subject to prior approval (section 105). Trustee/custodian duty includes taking reasonable care to ensure the scheme is managed in accordance with constitutive documents (UTC 4.5).
- UTC Chapters 7 and 8 set out investment and borrowing restrictions for schemes generally and for different types of schemes.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 3(1)(a) and section 1 of the Schedule to the Securities and Futures (Keeping of*

### Appendix D requires the scheme’s constitutive documents to include a statement to list the

### _cr14205 - Appendix D requires the scheme’s constitutive documents to include a statement to list the

### Investment limits and remediation
- Appendix D requires the scheme’s constitutive documents to include a statement to list the restrictions on the investment of the deposited property and the maximum borrowing limit of the scheme.
- UTC 7.23 provides that, if the investment limits are breached, the management company must take all steps as are necessary within a reasonable period of time to remedy the situation, taking due account of the interests of the holders.

### Changes to investor rights — Approval of holders
- UTC 6.15(f) provides that an extraordinary general meeting must be called:
  - a. to modify, alter or add to the constitutive documents, except as provided in UTC 6.7;
  - b. to terminate the scheme (unless the means of termination of the scheme are set out in the constitutive documents, in which case termination must be effected as required);
  - c. to increase the maximum fees paid to the management company, trustee/custodian or directors of the scheme; or
  - d. to impose other types of fees.
- UTC 6.7 allows constitutive documents to be altered by the management company and the trustee/custodian, without consulting holders, provided that the trustee/custodian certifies in writing that in its opinion the proposed alteration:
  - a. i. is necessary to make possible compliance with fiscal or other statutory or official requirements;
    ii. does not materially prejudice holders’ interests, does not to any material extent release the trustee/custodian, management company or any other person from any liability to holders and does not increase the costs and charges payable from the scheme property; or
  - b. is necessary to correct a manifest error.

### SFC approval and notice requirements
- UTC 11.1 provides that prior approval of the SFC is required for proposed changes to a scheme, including changes to:
  - a. constitutive documents;
  - b. key operators (including the trustee/custodian, management company and its delegates and Hong Kong representative) and their regulatory status and controlling shareholder;
  - c. investment objectives, policies and restrictions;
  - d. fee structure;
  - e. dealing and pricing arrangements; and
  - f. any other changes that may materially prejudice holders’ rights or interests.
- UTC 11.1A provides that for changes requiring the SFC’s prior approval, the SFC determines whether holders should be notified and the period of notice (if any). In practice:
  - the SFC requires prior notification to be given to the investors before the changes take effect;
  - normally, the SFC expects one month’s prior written notice, or a longer period if required under applicable laws or the provisions of the offering or constitutive documents;
  - the SFC may permit a shorter period of notice if the change is not significant or may require a longer period of notice (up to three months) in exceptional circumstances.
- UTC 11.1B requires the management company to inform holders as soon as reasonably practicable of any material adverse change in the financial condition or business of the key counterparties to a scheme that it is aware of.
- UTC 11.2A provides that notices to holders must be filed with the SFC within one week from the date of its issuance.
- SFC approval is also required if a scheme intends not to maintain its authorization (UTC 11.4) and for mergers or termination of schemes (UTC 11.5). Three months' notice must be given to holders in the first case and in the second case, notice period is as determined by the SFC.

### Separation of assets and safekeeping
- Every CIS for which authorization is requested must appoint a trustee/custodian acceptable to the SFC (UTC 4.1). CIS in the form of unit trusts must appoint a trustee to hold scheme assets; mutual funds must appoint a custodian.
- UTC 4.5(a)(i) and 4.5(a)(ii) require the trustee/custodian to take into its custody or under its control all the property of the scheme and hold it in trust for the holders (in case of a unit trust) or the scheme (in case of a mutual fund corporation) in accordance with the provisions of the constitutive documents, and to register cash and registrable assets in the name of or to the order of the trustee/custodian.
- The assets of the scheme therefore should be segregated and not commingled with the assets of the management company and will not form part of the liquidation assets of the management company.

### Related-party trustee/custodian rules and market data
- UTC 4.8 permits the appointment of a trustee/custodian that is connected to the management company in defined circumstances. If the trustee/custodian and the management company are both bodies corporate having the same ultimate holding company, they are deemed independent if:
  - a. i. they are both subsidiaries of a substantial financial institution; The SFC has interpreted this requirement to mean a bank.
    ii. neither the trustee/custodian nor the management company is a subsidiary of the other;
    iii. no person is a director of both the trustee/custodian and the management company; and
    iv. both the trustee/custodian and the management company sign an undertaking that they will act independently of each other in their dealings with the scheme; or
  - b. the scheme is established in a jurisdiction where the trustee/custodian and the management company are required by law to act independently of one another.
- Market data as of 31 July, 2013:
  - 78 percent of the SFC-authorized funds had an unrelated and independent trustee/custodian and management company arrangement.
  - A total of 50 entities act as the trustees/custodians for the 1,854 SFC-authorized funds.
  - 11 of these trustees/custodians are domiciled in Hong Kong.
  - There were 4 banking groups with trustees/custodians acting as the trustees/custodians of approximately 60 percent of the SFC-authorized funds.

### Winding up and termination procedures
- Appendix C24 and Appendix D17 of the UTC require that a summary of the circumstances in which the scheme can be terminated be disclosed in the offering document and constitutive documents respectively.
- To terminate the scheme in circumstances not specified in the constitutive documents, UTC 6.15(f) requires an extraordinary general meeting to be called.
- If a scheme is to be terminated, UTC 11.5 requires that, in addition to following any procedures set out in the scheme’s constitutive documents or governing law, notice must be given to investors as determined by the SFC. This notice must be submitted to the SFC for prior approval and contain:
  - the reasons for the termination;
  - the relevant provisions under the constitutive documents that enable such termination;
  - the consequences of the termination and their effects on existing investors;
  - the alternatives available to investors (including, if possible, a right to switch without charge into another authorized schemes);
  - the estimated costs of the termination and who is expected to bear them.
- The SFC can use its power under section 213(2)(d) of the SFO to apply to the court for an order to appoint an administrator over the property of a person if any person commits any of the wrongdoings specified in section 213(1)(a) or it appears to the SFC that any such matter has occurred, is occurring or may occur (section 213(1)(b)). Section 213(2)(d) applies to mutual fund corporations and trustees of unit trusts.
- The SFC can also present a petition to wind up a CIS that is in corporate form where it is just and equitable provided that the corporation is of a class of corporations which the Court of First Instance has jurisdiction to wind up under the CO (section 212(1)).
- The SFC has no power to appoint an administrator or a manager directly without going through the court process.

### Assessment and commentary
- Assessment: Fully implemented.
- Comments:
  - Best practice for CIS requires that all CIS have fully independent trustees/custodians. However, the IOSCO Principles do not prohibit custody by a related party; but they do require that additional safeguards be in place.
  - The assessors believe that such safeguards are in place in HK as:
    - (i) custodian can only be regulated entities (and substantial financial institutions – in practice banks), and therefore subject itself to supervision by a financial regulator;
    - (ii) additional rules are in place to foster independence including the prohibition that the custodian be a subsidiary of the management company and that they are not permitted to have common directors.

### Principle 26 — Disclosure requirements
- Description: Disclosure to investors
  - Detailed requirements for initial and ongoing disclosure are set out in the UTC.
- Offering documents:
  - UTC 6.1 provides that a scheme must issue an up-to-date offering document, which should contain the information necessary for investors to be able to make an informed judgement of the investment proposed to them, and, in particular, should contain information listed in UTC Appendix C.
  - UTC Appendix C requires that an offering document must set out, among other things, the investment objectives and risks, restrictions or investment and borrowing, fees and charges, procedures for application and redemption, frequency of valuation and dealing (including dealing days) and proper warning statements. Offering documents must disclose the rights of investors and the method of valuation of property and assets, and pricing of scheme units.
  - Appendix C2 provides that if the nature of the investment policy so dictates, the offering document should include a warning that investment in the scheme is subject to abnormal risks, a description of the risks involved, and where appropriate, the risk management policy in place.
  - Offering documents must be authorized by the SFC before they may be issued to the public (section 105 of the SFO). At least two staff members are involved in the review process for the disclosure documents.
  - UTC 6.6 provides that constitutive documents of a scheme should contain the information listed in UTC Appendix D. UTC Appendix D (D8) requires the constitutive documents to contain the rules on valuation of property and pricing.
  - By UTC 10.1, a scheme must be valued and priced in accordance with the provisions of its offering and constitutive documents and the provisions of Chapter 6 of the UTC.
  - UTC Appendix C requires offering document to disclose a list of constitutive documents and an address in Hong Kong where the constitutive documents can be inspected free of charge or purchased at a reasonable price.
  - OPs 3.4 and 6.1 of the Products Handbook provide that disclosure must be complete, accurate and fair, and be written and presented in a clear, concise and effective manner as to be readily understood by the investing public.
  - UTC 6.2A provides that a scheme must issue a KFS which is deemed to form part of the offering document and must contain information that enables investors to comprehend the key features and risks of the scheme. OP 6.7 also provides that KFS must highlight key information to investors in a clear, concise and effective manner and be prepared in a format that facilitates comparison with other products. Illustrative templates for KFS require a scheme to disclose the frequency of calculating and publishing a scheme’s NAV.
  - UTC 6.3 requires the offering document to be accompanied by the schemes’ most recent audited annual report and accounts together with its semi-annual report if published after the annual report.

### Periodic reports and timing
- UTC 5.17 and 11.6 require a scheme to publish at least two reports each financial year – an annual report and a half yearly report. The annual report must be audited by the auditor for the scheme.
- UTC Appendix E sets minimum requirements of financial reports, including disclosure requirements in areas such as the financial statements, connected persons transactions and the investment portfolios held by the scheme. UTC Appendix E contains provisions requiring standard formats in periodic reports in order to facilitate comparison.
- UTC 8.7(w) requires authorized HFs to publish quarterly reports for holders. By UTC Appendix H, these quarterly reports should be filed to the SFC and distributed to holders within one month of the end of the relevant period, except for authorized fund of HFs (FoHFs) where the timeframe for filing and distribution to holders is within six weeks of the end of the relevant period.
- UTC 11.6 provides that a scheme must publish its interim reports within two months of the end of the period, and its annual reports within four months after year-end.

### Material event reporting
- Holders of interests in CIS must be notified of material changes affecting the scheme.
- The management company must inform holders as soon as reasonably practicable of any material adverse change in the financial conditions or business of the key counterparties to a scheme that it is aware of. ‘Key counterparties’ include the management company, guarantor (where relevant), trustee/custodian and swap counterparty of the fund (UTC 11.1(b)).

### Regulator’s powers over disclosure documents
- Section 103 of the SFO requires a scheme offered to the public in Hong Kong to obtain SFC’s prior authorization, unless an exemption applies.
- If the SFC finds that the documentation contains misleading information, the SFC can require the scheme and the scheme operator to stop distributing the documentation and to amend the documentation as appropriate.

*Source: _cr14205 - Appendix D requires the scheme’s constitutive documents to include a statement to list the*

### Section 106(1)(a) of the SFO gives the SFC power to withdraw an authorization of the scheme

### Section 106(1)(a) of the SFO gives the SFC power to withdraw an authorization of the scheme

### SFC power to withdraw authorization and legal consequences
- Section 106(1)(a) of the SFO permits the SFC to withdraw an authorization of a scheme if it decides that any information provided to the SFC in respect of application for authorization of fund was at the time it was provided false or misleading in a material particular.
- Documentation that is inaccurate, misleading or false may have civil and criminal consequences under the SFO (for example, under sections 107, 277, 298, 383 or 384), and may call into question the issuer’s fitness to hold a license (sections 194 and 196).
- Under section 108 of the SFO investors have a private right of action to recover losses resulting from reliance on fraudulent, reckless or negligent misrepresentation.
- Many SFC powers of discipline and intervention (described under Principle 11) can be used in response to misleading or inaccurate disclosure.

### Advertising requirements and controls
- UTC 11.11: advertisements and other invitations to invest in a scheme must comply with the Advertising Guidelines Applicable to CIS Authorized under the Product Codes (Advertising Guidelines).
- All advertisements must be submitted to the SFC for authorization prior to their issue or publication in Hong Kong pursuant to section 105 of the SFO, unless exempted under section 103 of the SFO.
- Offers exclusively to professional investors are one of the exemptions.
- When granting authorization the SFC can impose a condition that the fund and/or its management company should cease and/or use their best endeavourers to procure their agents to cease issuing any advertisements of the scheme upon the request of the SFC.
- OPs 6.9 and 6.10 and General Principle 1 of the Advertising Guidelines require that all advertisements:
  - a. not be false, biased, misleading or deceptive;
  - b. be clear, fair and present a balanced picture of the product with adequate and prominent risk disclosures; and
  - c. contain information that is timely and consistent with its offering document.
- Advertisements may also breach section 107 (prohibition on fraudulently or recklessly inducing others to invest money).
- The SFC conducts regular checks on advertisements by choosing a date in a month and reviewing all fund-related advertisements on that date.
- When the SFC grants authorization it routinely imposes conditions relating to advertising cessation on request.

### Accounting standards and financial reporting
- Financial reports for SFC-authorized funds domiciled in Hong Kong are required to be prepared in accordance with the applicable requirements under Hong Kong Accounting Standards and HKFRS.
- Reports for funds domiciled in recognized jurisdictions must be prepared in accordance with the applicable laws, regulations and accounting standards acceptable in their home jurisdictions (e.g. UK GAAP). In practice this means that financial reports are prepared in accordance with IFRS standards.
- UTC Appendix E sets out detailed requirements for the content of financial reports.
- UTC 5.17 and Appendix E: information in the scheme’s annual report on the valuation of the scheme assets and calculation of NAV must be audited by an independent auditor.

### Power to ensure compliance with investment policies and trustee/custodian duties
- UTC 5.10: the management company must manage the scheme in accordance with the scheme’s constitutive documents in the best interest of the holders.
- UTC 4.5(d): the trustee/custodian must carry out instructions of the management company in respect of investments unless they conflict with the offering or constitutive documents or the UTC.
- UTC 4.5(f): trustee/custodian must issue a report to holders to be included in the annual report on whether in the trustee/custodian's opinion:
  - a. the management company has in all material respects managed the scheme in accordance with the provisions of the constitutive documents; and
  - b. if the management company has not done so, the respects in which it has not done so and the steps which the trustee/custodian has taken.
- Non-compliance with UTC or the Products Handbook can lead the SFC to conclude a person is no longer fit and proper, enabling:
  - investigation under section 182 of the SFO;
  - sanctions under sections 194 and 196 of the SFO, such as revocation or suspension of the intermediary’s licence or registration, fine (maximum of $10 million) and public reprimand the intermediary.

### Asset valuation: principles, timing, independent valuation and accounting guidance
- FMCC 5.3: all assets held by a scheme operator on behalf of clients should be valued on a regular basis and the basis of valuation disclosed to the clients. General principles include:
  - a. listed securities should be consistently valued at a price representative of either the daily opening, mid, closing or average price for that security at the stock exchange or market on which that security is listed or traded as indicated by an automatic price feed or other independent pricing source;
    - (In practice, listed securities are usually valued by last traded price or bid/ask price instead of average price.)
  - b. unlisted or unquoted securities should be valued at cost price subject to adjustment by reference to:
    - i. comparable third party transactions in the same investments, taking into consideration the cost of the investments;
    - ii. any appraisals of the relevant investments or issuer of the investments undertaken by qualified accountants, appraisers or a CRA. Where necessary the fund manager should seek independent confirmation of the valuation from a suitably qualified person; and
    - iii. any information generally about the relevant investments or issuer of the investments that is or becomes known to the fund manager from independent sources;
  - c. units or shares in schemes should be consistently valued by reference to the latest quoted price;
  - d. any listed securities which are not actively traded or have been suspended from trading should be identified and the price at which that security is valued should be monitored. A fund manager should maintain procedures to:
    - i. demonstrate that it will actively seek independent confirmation of the appropriate price for the security from suitable brokers or market makers;
    - ii. identify when such a security will be written down or written off in the valuation of a client account; or
    - iii. ascertain whether it will, in appropriate situations, transfer the security to its own account and if so, at what price the client account will be compensated for the transfer.
- UTC 6.12: value of investments not listed or quoted on a recognized market must be determined on a regular basis by a professional person approved by the trustee/custodian as qualified to value such investments; this person may, with approval, be the management company.
- Hong Kong Accounting Standards replicate IFRS and require fair value techniques where active market prices are not available: Hong Kong Accounting Standards 39 and HKFRS 13 set out valuation techniques.

### Timing, pricing, redemption, and handling of pricing errors
- UTC 6.13: all schemes must have at least one regular (issue and redemption) dealing day per month. In practice, most funds are priced daily.
- Offer price quoted or published must be the maximum price payable on purchase; redemption price must be the net price receivable on redemption.
- UTC 8.7(o): investments of HFs authorized by the SFC for offering to the public must be independently and fairly valued on a regular basis.
- UTC 6.11: offer and redemption prices should be calculated on the basis of the scheme's NAV divided by the number of units/shares outstanding; may be adjusted by fees and charges if clearly disclosed.
- UTC 4.5(c): trustee/custodian must take reasonable care to ensure valuation methods adopted by the management company are adequate to ensure correct pricing.
- Disclosure requirements:
  - UTC Appendix D8(b): constitutive documents must contain the method of calculating issue and redemption prices.
  - UTC Appendix C9: offering documents must disclose procedure for subscribing for and redeeming units or shares.
  - UTC Appendix C10: offering documents must disclose the maximum interval between the request for redemption and the sending of redemption proceeds.
  - UTC 11.7: scheme must publish its latest available offer and redemption prices or NAV at least once a month in at least one leading Hong Kong English language and one Chinese language daily newspaper.
  - UTC 10.7: if dealing in units ceases or is suspended, management company or Hong Kong representative must publish that fact immediately and at least once a month during suspension in newspapers where prices are normally published.
- Pricing errors (UTC 10.2):
  - If an error results in an incorrect price of 0.5 percent or more of scheme's NAV per unit/share, the trustee/custodian and the SFC must be informed immediately.
  - In such cases, individual investors should be compensated for all losses over HK$100, unless determined otherwise by the trustee/custodian with justification to the SFC.
  - SFC’s experience: pricing errors are detected early and dealt with effectively; no major problems have occurred.

### Suspension/deferral of valuations and redemptions
- UTC 10.6: suspension of dealings may be provided for only in exceptional circumstances, having regard to the interests of holders. SFC generally expects suspension only where there are difficulties in valuation of scheme assets; concern about massive redemption is generally not a valid reason.
- UTC 10.8: where redemption requests on any one dealing day exceed 10 percent of the total number of units or shares in issue, requests in excess of the 10 percent may be deferred to the next dealing day.
- UTC 10.7: management company or Hong Kong representative must immediately notify the SFC if dealing ceases or is suspended; investors must be notified on a timely basis.

### Regulatory monitoring, enforcement and sanctions related to valuation and pricing
- SFC has authority to monitor compliance with rules relating to asset valuation and unit pricing, and may use all its powers to obtain information and conduct investigations.
- Breaches of asset valuation and unit pricing rules may result in licensing action, withdrawal of a scheme’s authorization or the authorization of a particular product, and sanctions under sections 194 and 196 of the SFO.
- SFC relies on trustees/custodians’ obligations, the obligation to report pricing errors, and review of the annual auditor’s report (which includes valuation methodology) as primary supervisory mechanisms.
- SFC carries out thematic reviews when external events create potential valuation pressure (examples given: the European debt crisis, QE tapering).

### Hedge funds (HFs) oversight, licensing, authorization and supervision
- HF managers and advisers are required to hold a license for Type 4 (advising on securities) and/or Type 9 (asset management), whether or not funds managed or advised are offered to the public in Hong Kong. HFs themselves are not subject to authorization unless offered to the public.
- Licensing of HF managers requires applicants to provide:
  - (i) information on the applicant;
  - (ii) a business plan detailing nature of business and services;
  - (iii) information on human and technical resources, operational procedures and organizational structures;
  - (iv) business history (if any);
  - (v) internal controls, risk management, contingency plans; and
  - (vi) capital and shareholding structure and basic information on persons in accordance with whose directions it is, or its directors are, accustomed or obliged to act.
- SFC Guidelines on Competence set out matters for assessing competence.
- FMCC is applicable to HF managers, covering organization and management structure, fund management, and dealing with clients.
- Authorization of retail HFs:
  - HFs offered to the public are subject to SFC authorization under the UTC.
  - SFC will consider choice of asset classes and use of alternative investment strategies (long/short exposures, leverage and/or hedging, arbitrage techniques).
  - UTC allows SFC discretion to impose additional conditions on a case by case basis.
- UTC imposes specific requirements for management company of a retail HF and the fund, including:
  - The management must have requisite competence, expertise and appropriate risk management and internal controls;
  - Key investment personnel must have experience in managing HFs;
  - Management company must have internal controls suitable to the risk profile;
  - A minimum amount of assets under management (at least US$100 million) that follow HF strategies;
  - A minimum subscription by each investor of not less than US$ 50,000 except on FoHFs, where the minimum is US$10,000;
  - Liability of holders must be limited to their investment in the scheme;
  - Scheme must have clearly defined investment and borrowing parameters in constitutive and offering documents;
  - Dealing: at least one regular dealing day per month;
  - Valuation: investments must be independently and fairly valued on a regular basis; GAAP and industry best practices should be applied consistently;
  - Disclosure: offering document must lucidly explain investment strategy and inherent risks; management company must issue periodic financial reports to holders at least quarterly;
  - Investment management operations must be based in a jurisdiction with an inspection regime acceptable to the SFC;
  - Specific requirements for prime brokers.
- At time of assessment there were only four HFs authorized by the SFC for public offering.
- SFC powers applicable to HF managers include refusal of licence application, requesting information (including non-public exposures), conducting investigations and inspections, and imposing disciplinary actions such as revoking or suspending a license.
- Supervision:
  - HF management companies are part of general supervisory regime for licensees: ongoing off-site monitoring with periodic reports and on-site inspections on a risk-based approach.
  - Inspections of Hedge Fund Management Companies by year:
    - 2012/2013: 18
    - 2011/2012: 23
    - 2010/2011: 16
    - 2009/2010: 28
    - 2008/2009: 4
  - SFC conducts HF monitoring via surveys (2006, 2009) and under IOSCO HF Survey process (2010, 2012) to obtain information on larger HFs exceeding specified Net Asset Value thresholds irrespective of location, including Net Asset Value, predominant strategy/regional focus and performance, leverage and risk, assets and liabilities, counterparty risk, product exposure, and identification of significant market or product exposures.
  - SFC staff expect these surveys to become a regular part of monitoring arrangements.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 106(1)(a) of the SFO gives the SFC power to withdraw an authorization of the scheme*

### Section 378 of the SFO allows the SFC to share information collected with other regulators,

### _cr14205 - Section 378 of the SFO allows the SFC to share information collected with other regulators,

### Information sharing under Section 378
- Section 378 of the SFO allows the SFC to share information collected with other regulators, subject to some confidentiality conditions.
- Section 378 also allows the SFC to disclose information in the form of a summary compiled from any information in the possession of the SFC which summary is so compiled as to prevent particulars relating to the business or identity, or the trading particulars, of any person from being ascertained from it.
- SFC staff informed that it has shared the results of the 2010 and 2012 HF Surveys on an aggregate basis with IOSCO.

### Assessment
- Assessment: Fully implemented
- Comments: 

### Principles for Market Intermediaries — Description, industry and regulatory background
- Principle 29. Regulation should provide for minimum entry standards for market intermediaries.
- Industry: Securities intermediaries in Hong Kong include both banks3 and non-bank intermediaries.
- At March 2013, 117 banks were registered with the SFC to carry on securities business.
- For the non-bank sector — Number of corporations licensed under the SFO – by ownership:
  - At end-March 2013: Total no. of licensed corporations (other than banks) 1,905
  - At end-March 2012: Total no. of licensed corporations (other than banks) 1,840
  - At end-March 2011: Total no. of licensed corporations (other than banks) 1,752
  - Affiliates of banks 10% 11% 12%
  - Affiliates of insurance companies 2% 3% 3%
  - Affiliates of other financial institutions 36% 35% 35%
  - Others 52% 51% 50%
  - Percentage figures rounded to the nearest whole number.
  - Source: SFC
- There are a large number of small intermediaries in the SFC licensed sector. A small number of banks and major securities houses (including subsidiaries of international investment banks) have a major share of securities intermediation business.
- Banks are not permitted to be participants directly in HKEx so the related trade execution activities are conducted through their securities subsidiaries licensed by the SFC or other licensed execution brokers.
- At March 2013, around 37,000 individuals were licensed by SFC as representatives of licensed intermediaries (other than banks).

### Regulatory framework and licensing of intermediaries
- The regulatory framework for intermediaries largely is set out in the SFO, its subsidiary legislation, and a number of codes and guidelines issued by the SFC. There are also provisions in the BO related to EOs and ReIs.
- AIs which want to carry on one or more regulated activities are required to register with the SFC.
- Part V of the SFO provides that a person who carries on business in a regulated activity (as defined in section 1 of Part 1 of Schedule 1 and Part 2 of Schedule 5 of the SFO) in Hong Kong is required to be licensed by or registered with the SFC.
- Schedule 5 stipulates ten types of regulated activity:
  - Type 1: Dealing in securities
  - Type 2: Dealing in futures contracts
  - Type 3: Leveraged foreign exchange trading
  - Type 4: Advising on securities
  - Type 5: Advising on futures contracts
  - Type 6: Advising on corporate finance
  - Type 7: Providing ATS
  - Type 8: Securities margin financing
  - Type 9: Asset management
  - Type 10: Providing credit rating services
- Section 114(1) and (2) of the SFO requires that no person shall carry on a business in a regulated activity or hold himself out as carrying on a business in a regulated activity unless that person is:
  - a. a corporation licensed under section 116 or 117 of the SFO for the regulated activity (an LC);
  - b. a licensed bank, restricted licensed bank or a deposit taking company authorized under the BO (an AI) that is registered with the SFC under section 119 of the SFO for the regulated activity. For SFO purposes this is an RI); or
  - c. a person authorized under section 95(2) of the SFO as an ATS operator.
- A breach of section 114(1) constitutes a criminal offence.
- Individuals performing regulated activities for LCs (called representatives) must also be licensed under section 120 of the SFO as licensed representatives.
- Section 125 of the SFO provides that every LC must have at least two individuals (at least one of whom is an executive director of the LC) who are approved by the SFC as the LC’s ROs in relation to each of the regulated activity for which the LC is licensed.
- The appointment of an EO to an RI requires the consent of HKMA. That consent can only be given if the person is a fit and proper person and has sufficient authority within the institution (Section 71C(2) of the BO). Section 71D of the BO requires an RI to appoint at least two EOs for each regulated activity the RI carries on.
- ReIs are required to be registered with HKMA. It is a statutory condition of registration for a RI to ensure that its ReIs are fit and proper to be so engaged. The HKMA conducts background checks on the ReIs with the SFC and, if necessary, other relevant agencies.

### Integrity
- All market intermediaries (including LCs and RIs) are required to demonstrate that they are “fit and proper” for the purposes of being licensed by or registered with the SFC. Criteria set out in the SFO and the SFC’s Fit and Proper Guidelines and the Guidelines on Competence apply both to LCs and RIs.
- Section 129(1) of the SFO provides that in considering whether a person is fit and proper for the purposes of licensing or registration, the SFC or the HKMA must have regard to:
  - a. financial status or solvency;
  - b. educational or other qualifications or experience having regard to the nature of the functions which, if the application is allowed, the person will perform;
  - c. the ability to carry on the regulated activity competently, honestly and fairly; and
  - d. the reputation, character, reliability and financial integrity, of the ReI or corporation.
- Section 129(2) permits the SFC or the HKMA to take into account decisions made in relation to a person by other regulators, including the insurance and pension fund regulators.
- Section 119 of the SFO gives SFC power to register or refuse to register an AI to carry on business in regulated activities in Hong Kong and section 119(4) requires the SFC shall have regard to any advice given to it by the HKMA.
- Under section 132 of the SFO, a person is required to obtain the SFC’s approval before they can become or continue to be a “substantial shareholder” (defined in Schedule 1 to the SFO to mean holders of 10 percent or more of voting shares) of a LC. The SFC is obliged to refuse to approve an application under section 132 unless the applicant satisfies the SFC that the LC concerned will remain fit and proper to be licensed. Analogous provisions apply to “controllers” of AIs under section 70 of the BO.

### Capital requirement
- LCs are subject to the capital requirements stipulated in the FRR on an on-going basis.
- RIs are subject to the capital requirements applicable to AIs/RIs under the BO on an on-going basis.

### Competence
- The Guidelines on Competence published by the SFC set out the matters that both the SFC and the HKMA consider in assessing whether a person is competent to carry on any regulated activity. These requirements are applicable to all LCs, licensed representatives (including ROs) accredited to LCs, as well as RIs, their EOs and ReIs.
- Competence requirements for individuals under Part 5 of the Guidelines on Competence include a combination of education and experience qualifications, management experience and regulatory knowledge.
- Part 4 of the Guidelines on Competence establishes criteria for the assessment of the competence of corporations, including organizational structure, combined competence of personnel, proper business structure, good internal systems and qualified personnel, and a business plan addressing risks.

### Internal controls
- In considering whether a corporation is fit and proper to be licensed/registered, the SFC and the HKMA take into account whether the applicant has established effective internal control procedures and risk management systems (see Section 129(2)(c) of the SFO).
- As AIs, RIs are required to comply with the authorization criteria specified in the Seventh Schedule of the BO on an on-going basis, including requirements to maintain adequate accounting systems and systems of control to: ensure the prudent and efficient running of the institution’s business; safeguard its assets; minimize the risk of fraud; monitor the risks to which the institution is exposed; and comply with legislative and regulatory requirements.
- RIs are generally required to comply with the provisions of the SFO in the same way as LCs in respect of their regulated activities.

### Authority of regulator and assessment of applications for license and registration
- SFC handles a relatively large number of corporate license applications each year (about 150 in 2012). The HKMA deals with fewer than 10 RI applications each year, and in 2012 the number was below 5.
- Both the SFC and the HKMA have internal processes for handling applications for license/registration. The SFC’s licensing processes are subject to regular review by the independent PRP.
- The SFC’s Licensing Department has approximately 80 staff and IT systems allow applications to be made electronically.
- The HKMA has 20 licensing staff who deal with all registration applications, including for authorization as AIs.
- The SFC process focuses on 4 main aspects:
  - a. ensuring it has a good understanding of the applicant’s proposed business activities (including the impact of these activities on the applicant’s clients and on the markets it operates in);
  - b. the firm’s infrastructure – its organizational structure, internal controls and risk management and systems;
  - c. financial requirements and the firm’s internal controls and ability to comply with requirements;
  - d. the senior management team – the ROs’ integrity and competence.
- The SFC conducts regulatory checks on the fitness and properness of an applicant’s ROs, the applicant company, all directors, and substantial shareholders. Applicants and their ROs are required to demonstrate their fitness and properness including integrity but the SFC carries out selective police checks on applicants and their officers.
- The HKMA process focuses on assessing the fitness and properness of an EO of an AI which applies for the registration as a RI.
- The HKMA will exercise the power under section 119(3) of the SFO to assess the merits of an application by an AI to become a RI.
- Staff follow a procedures manual for the registration of RIs. They use the HKMA’s internal database in their assessment of proposed EOs and routinely ask SFC for information about them. The HKMA will advise the SFC whether it is satisfied that the applicant is fit and proper to be registered and may make recommendations in respect of any proposed condition(s) deemed necessary.
- To assess an applicant’s fitness and properness for the purposes of licensing/registration, the SFC and the HKMA routinely conduct external checks with other regulators, both domestic and foreign, on the past conduct of the applicant and the individuals concerned.
- The assessors’ review of files showed that these processes are applied on a consistent basis.

### Refusal of application
- The SFC is obliged to refuse a license/registration application if the applicant fails to satisfy the SFC that it is a fit and proper person to be licensed or registered under the SFO pursuant to sections 116 (LC), 117 (temporary LC), 119 (RIs), 120 (licensed representatives), 121 (temporary licensed representatives) or 126 (ROs).
- Under section 16 of the BO, the HKMA must refuse an application for authorization as an AI to carry on banking business or the business of taking deposits as a deposit taking company or as a restricted licence bank if the applicant does not meet the minimum criteria for authorization set out in the Seventh Schedule to the BO, and it has power to refuse applications in other cases.
- Under section 71C(2)(a) of the BO, the HKMA is obliged to refuse to give consent if an EO applicant fails to satisfy the HKMA that he is a fit and proper person to be an EO of the RI and he has sufficient authority within the RI concerned.

### Licensing conditions
- Under sections 116, 117, 119, 120, 121 and 126 of the SFO, any licence/registration granted by the SFC can be made subject to such reasonable conditions as the SFC may impose. The SFC may at any time amend or revoke any such condition or impose new conditions as may be reasonable in the circumstances.
- Some standard conditions are used, for example a condition prohibiting investment advisers from holding client assets.
- The HKMA has power under section 71C(9) of the BO to impose conditions on its consent for a person to become an EO.

### Revocation/suspension of license/registration
- Under sections 194 and 196 of the SFO, the SFC can take disciplinary action against a regulated person if that person is found to be guilty of misconduct or not fit and proper to be or to remain a regulated person. Subject to procedural fairness processes specified in section 198 of the SFO, the SFC may among other things:
  - a. revoke or suspend a license or a registration;
  - b. revoke or suspend part of a license or registration in relation to any of the regulated activities for which a regulated person is licensed or registered;
  - c. revoke or suspend the approval granted to a RO; or
  - d. prohibit a regulated person from applying to be licensed or registered or to be approved as an RO, etc.
- Sections 195 and 197 of the SFO also permit the SFC to revoke or suspend a person’s licence or registration upon events including entering into of a voluntary arrangement with creditors, bankruptcy, failing to satisfy a levy of execution, liquidation or winding up, conviction for a criminal offence which impugns fitness and properness, etc.
- In relation to RIs, it is a statutory condition of registration under section 119(8) of the SFO for a RI to ensure that the ReIs engaged for any regulated activity are fit and proper. In addition, a RI is required under section 125(2) of the SFO to comply with section 71D and 71C of the BO by having at least two EOs who have received prior written consent from the HKMA.
- Where an EO is, or was at any time, guilty of misconduct, or the HKMA has ceased to be satisfied that an EO is a fit and proper person or has sufficient authority within the RI concerned to be such officer, the HKMA may, after consultation with the SFC, withdraw or suspend his consent (section 71C of the BO). The HKMA also has power to remove a ReI from the register maintained under section 20(1)(ea) of the BO if the ReI ceases to be a fit and proper person (section 58A).
- The HKMA may, under sections 71C and 58A of the BO, make recommendations to the SFC about the exercise of the SFC’s disciplinary powers against EOs and ReIs under section 196 or 197 of the SFO.

### Ongoing requirements
- Section 135 of the SFO sets out the events for which notification by LCs, licensed representatives and RIs is required. For RIs, the notification must be made to both the SFC and the HKMA. Changes requiring notification are specified in the Information Rules (see also sections 20(4) and 72A of the BO for notification requirements about changes in EOs and ReIs).
- Paragraph 12.5 of the Code of Conduct requires that a licensed or registered firm should report to the SFC immediately certain specified incidents, such as any material breach or suspected material breach by itself or one of its representatives of any law, rules, regulations or code, or any material failure, error or defect of its operational systems.
- Under section 138(4) of the SFO, all LCs and licensed representatives are required to submit annual returns to the SFC within one month after each anniversary date of the granting of their licences. All LCs are also required to submit annual audited accounts. The content of these audit reports is set out in the Securities and Futures (Accounts and Audit) Rules.
- LCs are obliged to submit to the SFC a business and risk management questionnaire annually, which contains information about the LC’s business operations and risk management, including controls and procedures to ensure compliance with the regulatory requirements applicable to the LC (section 156(1)(a) of the SFO and section 3(1) of the Securities and Futures (Accounts and Audit) Rules).

### Public disclosure of licensed intermediaries
- Section 136 of the SFO requires the SFC to maintain a register of licensed persons (including LCs and licensed representatives) and RIs containing details about all persons licensed by or registered with the SFC. This enables any member of public to ascertain whether he is dealing with a licensed person or a RI and the particulars of the license or registration.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 378 of the SFO allows the SFC to share information collected with other regulators,*

### Section 20 of the BO requires the HKMA to maintain a register which contains the name and

### _cr14205 - Section 20 of the BO requires the HKMA to maintain a register which contains the name and

### Register requirement
- Section 20 of the BO requires the HKMA to maintain a register which contains:
  - the name and business address of every ReI;
  - the capacity in which every ReI is engaged in relation to a regulated function in a regulated activity;
  - the date on which every ReI was first so engaged;
  - and such other particulars as the HKMA thinks fit.
- Registers are available on the relevant regulator’s website.

### Investment Advisers
- A person who carries on an investment advisory business in Hong Kong is required to be licensed or registered for Type 4 regulated activity (advising on securities) and/or Type 5 regulated activity (advising on futures contracts) and is regulated under the SFO in the same manner as other licensed or registered persons.
- If an investment adviser (who is licensed/registered for Type 4 and/or Type 5 regulated activity) deals in securities and/or futures contracts on behalf of clients, they must also be licensed/registered for Type 1 (dealing in securities) and/or Type 2 (dealing in futures contracts) regulated activity and comply with all relevant regulatory requirements applicable to dealers, such as higher capital requirements under the FRR (applicable to LCs) and operational controls requirements.
- As a matter of general practice, the SFC imposes a condition on an investment adviser’s licence prohibiting it from holding client assets. Accordingly, investment advisers holding Type 4 and/or Type 5 licences only are not permitted to have custody of any client assets.
- Assessment: Fully implemented
- Comments: The assessment by the SFC of applications for licenses is rigorous, and includes, for applicants regulated in offshore jurisdictions, detailed due diligence with the home jurisdiction regulators.

### Principle 30 — Capital and prudential requirements (overview)
- Both RIs and LCs are subject to capital and prudential requirements.
- BCP Assessment conclusions for HKMA:
  - HKMA has adopted components of Basel 2, 2.5 and 3 on or ahead of schedule.
  - More conservative approach for certain items recognized as regulatory capital than required by Basel standards.
  - HKMA applies the three Basel ratios (common equity tier 1, tier 1 and total capital) as well as a trigger for each ratio on an individual AI basis.
  - Supervisory staff regularly assesses AIs’ capital management and planning and uses stress testing.
- HKMA has wide powers of information gathering and receives standard prudential data and supplementary data; commissions annual reports into accuracy of returns and can commission external auditor reports on underlying control systems.

### Capital requirement — LCs (summary)
- LCs must meet minimum capital requirements stipulated by the FRR at all times while licensed by the SFC.
- Minimum capital requirements include a liquid capital requirement and a paid-up share capital requirement.
- FRR rules are a form of a net capital rule.
- LCs that are subsidiaries of banks are subject to the FRR on a solo basis.

### Minimum paid-up share capital (rules and exemptions)
- Section 5 of the FRR requires most LCs to maintain a minimum paid up share capital but exempts:
  a. an approved introducing agent (as defined in 58(4) of the FRR) who is not a LC licensed for Type 3 regulated activity (leveraged foreign exchange trading);
  b. a trader (a licensee that is a securities or futures dealer who deals only for its own account and does not hold client assets or handle client order - section 2 of the FRR);
  c. a futures non-clearing dealer (an exchange participant of a recognized futures market but not a clearing participant of a recognized clearing house – section 2 of the FRR);
  d. a LC licensed for Type 4 (advising on securities), Type 5 (advising on futures contracts), Type 9 (asset management) or Type 10 (providing credit rating services) regulated activity that is subject to a condition that they do not hold client assets;
  e. a LC licensed for Type 6 (advising on corporate finance) that is subject to conditions that they do not hold client assets and they do not act as a sponsor for a listed corporation.
- If an LC is licensed for more than one activity, the minimum paid up share capital is the higher or highest amount applying to an activity for which it is licensed.

- Minimum amounts (Table 1 in Schedule 1 of the FRR):
  - Type 1 (Dealing in securities) - (a) where the licensed corporation in question provides securities margin financing: $10,000,000
  - Type 1 (Dealing in securities) - (b) in any other case: $5,000,000
  - Type 2 (Dealing in futures contracts): $5,000,000
  - Type 3 (Leveraged foreign exchange trading) - (a) where the licensed corporation in question is an approved introducing agent: $5,000,000
  - Type 3 (Leveraged foreign exchange trading) - (b) in any other case: $30,000,000
  - Type 4 (Advising on securities): $5,000,000
  - Type 5 (Advising on futures contracts): $5,000,000
  - Type 6 (Advising on corporate finance) - (a) where the LC in question is not subject to the no sponsor work licensing condition: $10,000,000
  - Type 6 (Advising on corporate finance) - (b) in any other case: $5,000,000
  - Type 7 (Providing ATS): $5,000,000
  - Type 8 (Securities margin financing): $10,000,000
  - Type 9 (Asset management): $5,000,000
  - Type 10 (Providing credit rating services): $5,000,000
- AIs (banks) minimum paid up share capital and share premium account: HK$300 million; lesser amounts are prescribed for restricted license banks and deposit taking companies.

### Liquid capital requirements (framework and floors)
- Section 6(1) of the FRR requires all LCs to maintain liquid capital not less than its required liquid capital.
- Required liquid capital is the higher of:
  a. the required liquid capital requirements specified for each category of regulated activity in Table 2 in Schedule 1 of the FRR (if licensed for more than one activity, the higher amount applies); and
  b. its variable required liquid capital (VRLC).
- Definitions by section 2 of the FRR:
  a. “liquid capital” means the amount by which liquid assets exceed ranking liabilities;
  b. “liquid assets” for a LC means the aggregate of the amounts required to be included in liquid assets under Division 3 of Part 4 of the FRR;
  c. “ranking liabilities” means the aggregate of the amounts required to be included in its ranking liabilities under Division 4 of Part 4 of the FRR (balance sheet liabilities, sometimes subject to add-ons, e.g., 200 percent of the market value of written put options, section 40(12)).
- LCs must calculate liquid assets and ranking liabilities according to detailed FRR provisions.

- Minimum required liquid capital – floor amounts (Table 2 in Schedule 1 to the FRR):
  - Type 1(Dealing in securities) - (a) where the LC in question is an approved introducing agent or trader: $500,000
  - Type 1(Dealing in securities) - (b) in any other case: $3,000,000
  - Type 2 (Dealing in futures contracts) - (a) where the LC in question is an approved introducing agent, futures non-clearing dealer or trader: $500,000
  - Type 2 (Dealing in futures contracts) - (b) in any other case: $3,000,000
  - Type 3 (Leveraged foreign exchange trading) - (a) where the LC in question is an approved introducing agent: $3,000,000
  - Type 3 (Leveraged foreign exchange trading) - (b) in any other case: $15,000,000
  - Type 4 (Advising on securities) - (a) where the LC in question is subject to the specified licensing condition (no holding of client assets): $100,000
  - Type 4 (Advising on securities) - (b) in any other case: $3,000,000
  - Type 5 (Advising on futures contracts) - (a) where the LC in question is subject to the specified licensing condition: $100,000
  - Type 5 (Advising on futures contracts) - (b) in any other case: $3,000,000
  - Type 6 (Advising on corporate finance) - (a) where the LC in question is subject to the specified licensing condition: $100,000
  - Type 6 (Advising on corporate finance) - (b) in any other case: $3,000,000
  - Type 7 (Providing ATS): $3,000,000
  - Type 8 (Securities margin financing): $3,000,000
  - Type 9 (Asset management) - (a) where the LC in question is subject to the specified licensing condition: $100,000
  - Type 9 (Asset management) - (b) in any other case: $3,000,000
  - Type 10 (Providing credit rating services) - (a) where the LC in question is subject to the specified licensing condition: $100,000
  - Type 10 (Providing credit rating services) - (b) in any other case: $3,000,000

### Variable required liquid capital (VRLC) and additional requirements
- VRLC of an LC = 5 percent of the aggregate of:
  a. adjusted liabilities (liabilities less client monies held in segregated accounts and approved subordinated loans);
  b. the aggregate of the initial margin requirements in respect of outstanding futures contracts and outstanding options contracts held on behalf of clients;
  c. the aggregate of the amounts of margin required to be deposited in respect of outstanding futures contracts and outstanding options contracts held on behalf of clients, to the extent such contracts are not subject to payment of initial margin requirements.
- For an LC licensed for Type 3 regulated activity (leveraged foreign exchange trading) an additional amount of 1.5 percent of its aggregate gross foreign currency position must be held.

### Risk-sensitivity of capital requirements
- The liquid capital requirement addresses liquidity and solvency risks by requiring adequate liquid assets with a safety buffer.
- The FRR imposes capital charges for market risk, credit risk, liquidity risk and concentration risk; required liquid capital (via VRLC) increases with business size.
- Market risk: capital charges via haircuts on trading positions (e.g., investments in shares listed on SEHK subject to haircuts ranging from 15 percent to 30 percent of the investment’s market value).
- Credit risk: deductions for long outstanding, unsecured or under-secured credit exposures (e.g., amounts receivable from client outstanding one month or more after settlement date must not be included in liquid assets; see section 21(1) of the FRR).
- Liquidity risk: illiquid assets (fixed assets, illiquid bonds, time deposits with maturity of more than 6 months, assets denominated in a foreign currency subject to exchange control, etc.) are excluded from liquid assets (Division 3 Part 4 of the FRR).
- Concentration risk:
  - When amount receivable from a margin client or total amount receivable from a group of related margin clients exceeds 10 percent of the aggregate of amounts receivable from all margin clients, LC is subject to a concentration risk capital charge equal to the amount by which the margin loan due exceeds 10 percent of aggregate margin loans (section 42(1) of the FRR).
  - A concentration risk charge is imposed on proprietary positions if net market value of proprietary positions in any line of securities or investments equals 25 percent or more of an LC’s required liquid capital. The concentration risk charge is 5 percent of the net market value of the concentrated proprietary positions concerned if net market value is 25 percent or more of required liquid capital; this increases to 10 percent if the concentration is 51 percent or more of required liquid capital (see section 44 of the FRR).

### Record keeping and reporting
- Record keeping:
  - An intermediary must keep accounting, trading and other records sufficient to explain and reflect the financial position and operation of the firm’s businesses and enable profit and loss accounts and balance sheets that give a true and fair view to be prepared (section 3(1)(a) of the KRR).
  - Section 146(4) of the SFO and section 3(1)(a)(vii) of the KRR requires LCs to keep such records as are sufficient to enable them to readily establish whether they have complied with the FRR.
- Reporting:
  - LCs are subject to regular and ad hoc reporting requirements to report to or notify the SFC in respect of their capital positions.
  - Pursuant to section 56 of the FRR, LCs must submit financial returns containing a balance sheet, a computation of liquid capital and other financial data to the SFC on a monthly basis within 3 weeks from the end of the reporting period. LCs that do not hold client assets need only report on a six monthly basis.
  - The format of financial returns is specified by the SFC under section 402 of the SFO.
  - LCs are required to report any required liquid capital deficit in the return.
  - An LC must notify the SFC in writing if its liquid capital falls below 120 percent of its required liquid capital (section 55(1)(a) of the FRR).
  - If an LC becomes aware of its inability to maintain, or to ascertain whether it maintains, financial resources as required by the FRR, it is required to give written notice, as soon as reasonably practicable, to the SFC (section 146(1) of the SFO). It must also notify the SFC of its inability to comply with, or to ascertain whether it complies with, any other requirements of the FRR (section 146(3)).

### Independent audit and monitoring
- Independent audit:
  - LCs must submit annual audited accounts together with a computation of liquid capital and an auditor’s report to the SFC (section 156 of the SFO and section 4 of the Securities and Futures (Accounts and Audit) Rules).
  - Section 4(1)(g) of the Account and Audit Rules requires the auditor to express an opinion on compliance with the FRR rules.
  - The SFC follows up any issue raised or qualified opinion expressed by the external auditor of an LC.
- Monitoring by regulator:
  - The SFC analyses all financial returns with computerized tools performing analyses to identify significant deterioration in liquid capital, monthly analyses to identify significant changes and to monitor profitability.
  - The SFC performs stress testing periodically based on reported information. Risky LCs identified will be subject to close monitoring and may face more stringent reporting requirements, such as regular updates of financial positions.

### Regulator’s powers of intervention
- By section 57 of the FRR, an LC must comply with any request by the SFC to provide information, including any record or document the SFC specifies relating to the financial resources or trading activities of the LC.
- If the SFC becomes aware that an LC cannot comply with FRR requirements, the SFC can:
  - permit the LC to continue operating subject to conditions specified by the SFC (section 146(2) of the SFO and section 146(5)(b)); or
  - under sections 204 to 206 of the SFO, restrict an LC’s business or require property to be dealt with in a specified fashion if preconditions under section 207 are met (including the risk that property connected with the business might be dissipated, transferred or otherwise dealt with prejudicially to clients or creditors).
- The SFC has used these powers to address failures to comply with FRR requirements.

### Risks from outside the regulated entity
- All non-trade related receivables from affiliated companies are excluded from liquid assets of the LC (equivalent to a 100 percent deduction from the LC’s liquid capital).
- All liabilities due to affiliated companies are included in the LC’s ranking liabilities.
- Assets and liabilities from business transactions with affiliates that fall within the regulated activities are treated the same as transactions with third party customers and counterparties.
- The FRR applies to LCs on a solo basis only; however an LC must include in its ranking liabilities any amount by which total liabilities of a subsidiary exceed the assets of that subsidiary (section 52(1)(b) of the FRR).

### Assessment (Principle 30 conclusion)
- Assessment: Fully implemented
- Comments: Intermediaries are subject to minimum and ongoing capital requirements. Ongoing capital requirements of licensed intermediaries are based on a net capital rule that has imbedded charges for market risk, credit risk and concentration risk, while a minimum buffer is used to address other risks (mainly operational risk). Licensed intermediaries must submit regular financial returns.

### Principle 31 — Internal function and management responsibilities (overview)
- SFC’s Code of Conduct, ICG and other guidance provide a detailed framework for systems of internal controls and risk management for LCs supervised by the SFC and RIs supervised by the HKMA.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 20 of the BO requires the HKMA to maintain a register which contains the name and*

### Part I of the ICG deals with management and supervision. It requires that an effective

### _cr14205 - Part I of the ICG deals with management and supervision. It requires that an effective

### Management and supervision (Part I)
- Requires an effective management and organisational structure which ensures that the operations of the business are conducted in a sound, efficient and effective manner be established, documented and maintained.
- Specific requirements:
  - a. management to take full responsibility for the firm’s operations including the development, implementation and on-going effectiveness of the firm’s internal controls and compliance with them by its directors and employees;
  - b. regular and effective communication so that management is fully aware of the firm’s operations, financial position, risks and compliance with regulatory requirements;
  - c. reporting lines to be clearly identified with supervisory and reporting responsibilities assigned to appropriate staff member(s);
  - d. detailed policies and procedures established relating to authorizations and approvals, including that the authority of key positions are clearly defined and communicated to and followed by staff.
  - e. management to ensure that management and supervisory functions are performed by qualified and experienced individuals.
- “Management” is used as a generic collective term and may include a firm and its board of directors, chief executive officer, managing director and/or other senior operating management personnel.
- Reporting lines for internal audit and compliance should ensure independence, objectiveness and effectiveness, and will vary by firm structure and needs.

### Internal controls
- The Code of Conduct requires an intermediary to have internal control procedures and financial and operational capabilities that can be reasonably expected to protect its operations, its clients and other licensed or registered persons from financial loss arising from theft, fraud, and other dishonest acts, professional misconduct or omissions (Paragraph 4.3).
- Senior management must properly manage business risks, including by performing periodic evaluation of risk management processes (Paragraph 14.1).

### ICG Parts and prescribed control guidelines
- The ICG prescribes detailed control guidelines for:
  - a. management and supervision (Part I);
  - b. segregation of duties and functions (Part II);
  - c. personnel and training (Part III);
  - d. information management (Part IV);
  - e. compliance (Part V);
  - f. audit (Part VI);
  - g. operational controls (Part VII); and
  - h. risk management (Part VIII).

### Management information (Part IV)
- Requires policies and procedures to ensure the integrity, security, availability, reliability and thoroughness of all information, including documentation and electronically stored data, relevant to the firm’s business operations.
- Specifies in some detail the content of these policies and procedures.

### Evaluation of internal controls and risk management (Part VI and Appendix)
- Part VI requires an audit policy and related review function to be established and maintained which objectively examines, evaluates and reports on the adequacy, effectiveness and efficiency of the firm’s management, operations and internal controls.
- Where practicable, management should establish an independent and objective internal audit function free of operating responsibilities, with a direct line of communication to management or audit committee as applicable.
- Paragraph 22 of the Appendix to the ICG: a firm’s risk policies and measurements and reporting methodologies be subject to regular review, particularly prior to the commencement of the firm’s provision of new services or products, or when there are significant changes to the products, services, or relevant legislation, rules or regulations that might impact the firm’s risk exposure.

### Organizational requirements — Compliance function (Part V)
- Requires policies and procedures to ensure compliance with all applicable legal and regulatory requirements and internal policies.
- Management must establish and maintain an appropriate and effective compliance function which, subject to constraint of size, is independent of all operational and business functions and reports directly to management.
- Compliance staff must promptly report to management all occurrences of material non-compliance by the firm or its staff with legal and regulatory requirements, as well as the firm’s own policies and procedures.

### Systems of client protection, risk management and operational controls (Part VII and Code of Conduct)
- Paragraph VII requires establishment, maintenance and compliance with effective policies, operational procedures and controls for day-to-day operations, evaluated for effectiveness in ensuring integrity of dealing practices and fair, honest and professional treatment of clients.
- Paragraph 4.3 of the Code of Conduct repeats requirement for internal control procedures and financial and operational capabilities to protect against theft, fraud, dishonest acts, professional misconduct or omissions.

### Segregation of duties (Part II)
- Requires key duties and functions to be appropriately segregated, particularly where combining them could result in undetected errors or susceptibility to abuses exposing firm or clients to inappropriate risks.

### Senior management responsibility (Code of Conduct General Principle 9 and paragraph 14.1)
- Senior management must:
  - a. take primary responsibility for ensuring maintenance of appropriate standards of conduct and adherence to proper procedures by the firm;
  - b. understand the nature of the business, internal control procedures and policies on the assumption of risk, and clearly understand the extent of their own authority and responsibilities.

### Direct Electronic Access (Appendix provisions)
- Special provisions including:
  - a. requirement that firms establish and maintain an effective credit rating system to evaluate client and counterparty creditworthiness (paragraph 23);
  - b. requirement, prior to executing a client order, that a detailed check is made by designated staff on information relating to the client, including on account limits;, the sufficiency of available funds or available credit in the relevant account; the availability of securities to meet settlement obligations; and the authority and applicable limitations of the person placing the order (paragraph 7(b)).
- Licensed persons providing direct market access must ensure all client orders transmitted to intermediary infrastructure are subject to appropriate automated pre-trade risk management controls reasonably designed to prevent entry of orders that would exceed trading and credit thresholds prescribed for each client or proprietary account. This requirement will come into effect on 1 January 2014.

### Protection of clients — Code of Conduct obligations
- Client treatment provisions include:
  - a. accurate representations to clients (paragraph 2.1);
  - b. prompt execution of client orders (paragraph 3.1);
  - c. execution of client orders on the best available terms (paragraph 3.2);
  - d. prompt and fair allocation of trades to client accounts (paragraph 3.3);
  - e. advice provided to clients should be diligent, careful and suitable (paragraphs 3.4 and 5.2);
  - f. provision of information to clients including risk disclosure statements, timely and accurate reporting such as prompt confirmation of executed trades (paragraphs 6.2 and 8.1 to 8.5);
  - g. priority for client orders in order handling, recording and allocation (paragraphs 9.1 and 9.2);
  - h. conflicts of interest disclosure and fair treatment (paragraph 10.1);
  - i. acting honestly, fairly and with due skill, care and diligence in the best interests of clients and market integrity (paragraphs 2.1 to 2.4 and 3.1 to 3.10).

### Client funds and assets
- Intermediaries must ensure client assets and positions are promptly and properly accounted for and adequately safeguarded (General Principle 8 and paragraph 11.1).
- Procedures must protect intermediary’s and clients’ assets from theft, fraud and misappropriation (paragraph 9 in Part VII and paragraph 13 of Appendix).
- Client Securities Rules require segregation of client securities received or held in Hong Kong from intermediaries' own assets.
- Client Money Rules require segregation of client money received or held in Hong Kong from the LCs' money.
- Client securities must be registered in the name of the client or deposited in safe custody in a segregated account with an AI, another institution approved by the SFC (presently the HKSCC), or another intermediary licensed for dealing in securities (section 5 of the Client Securities Rules).
- For client monies, an LC must establish and maintain with an AI one or more segregated accounts designated as a trust account or client account into which it shall pay:
  - a. all amounts that are received from or on behalf of its clients (less brokerage and other proper charges and other amounts as specified in section 4(3) of the Client Money Rules) in Hong Kong within one business day after receipt of the amounts; and
  - b. all interest derived from the retention of client money in a segregated account. (See sections 4 and 6 of the Client Money Rules).
- Segregated client funds can be held in an omnibus client account; intermediary ledgers must contain individual client-level information.
- Section 148(3) of the SFO: client securities and collateral held by an intermediary are not liable to be taken in execution against the intermediary or its associated entity under the order or process of a court.
- Section 149(3) of the SFO: client money of a LC is not liable to be taken in execution against the LC or its associated entity under the order or process of a court.
- Under section 12 of Client Securities Rules and section 11 of Client Money Rules, an LC must notify the SFC in writing within one business day upon becoming aware that it does not comply with specified provisions in those Rules.

### Investor complaints (Paragraph 12.3 of the Code of Conduct and FDRC)
- Intermediary obligations for complaints:
  - a. handle complaints in a timely and appropriate manner;
  - b. investigate and respond promptly to complaints;
  - c. where a complaint is not remedied promptly, advise clients of further steps under the regulatory system including the right to refer a dispute to the FDRC;
  - d. review subject matter of complaints and, where issues affect other clients or raise broader concerns, investigate and remedy such issues even if other clients have not filed complaints.
- The FDRC administers the Financial Dispute Resolution Scheme (FDRS) with:
  - maximum claimable amount of HK$500,000 by way of “mediation first, arbitration next”;
  - FDRC funded by the Hong Kong Government, SFC and HKMA for set-up and operating costs in the first three years (from 2012 to 2014), and funded by the financial industry and to a lesser extent by the claimants from the fourth year (i.e. 2015) onwards;
  - board includes representatives from SFC, HKMA, FSTB and the banking and securities industries;
  - All financial institutions authorized by the HKMA and /or licensed by the SFC, except those which provide credit rating services only, are members of FDRS.

### Client information, know your client and suitability rules
- Client identity:
  - Intermediary must take all reasonable steps to establish the true and full identity of each client and each client’s financial situation, investment experience and investment objectives (paragraph 5.1 of the Code of Conduct).
  - ICG requires processes to obtain and confirm information regarding every client prior to establishment of an account (paragraph 1 under Part VII).
  - SFC’s Guideline on Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorist Financing sets out detailed customer due diligence measures expected from licensed persons.
- Know your customer / suitability:
  - General Principle 4, paragraphs 5.1 and 5.2 require establishing client’s financial situation, investment experience and investment objectives to provide suitable recommendations.
  - Part VII requires establishing client’s financial position, investment experience and investment objectives prior to account establishment and adopting procedures to ensure recommendations are based on thorough analysis and appropriate for the client, with reasons documented and retained.
  - SFC Q&A on suitability obligations clarifies that investment advisers should collect information including investment knowledge, investment horizon, risk tolerance (including risk of loss of capital) and capacity to make regular contributions and meet extra collateral requirements, where appropriate; information should be documented and updated where appropriate.

### Records (Section 3 of the KRR)
- Intermediaries must keep accounting, trading and other records sufficient to:
  - a. account for all clients assets that it receives or holds;
  - b. enable all movements of such client assets to be traced through its accounting and stock holding systems;
  - c. records that show particulars of all orders or instructions concerning securities, futures contracts or leveraged foreign exchange contracts that it receives or initiates, including particulars of each transaction to implement any such order or instruction, identifying with whom or for whose account it has entered into such transaction.

*Source: PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF CHINA––HONG KONG SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE REGION, INTERNATIONAL MONETARY FUND*

### Section 10 of the KRR requires such records to be kept for a period of not less than 7 years

### _cr14205 - Section 10 of the KRR requires such records to be kept for a period of not less than 7 years

### Record-keeping requirements
- Section 10 of the KRR requires such records to be kept for a period of not less than 7 years except for order and instruction records which are to be kept for not less than 2 years.

### Disclosure to clients
- Intermediaries are obliged to make adequate disclosure of relevant material information in their dealings with their clients (General Principle 5 of the Code of Conduct).
- Where complex products are involved, intermediaries must provide risk disclosure information in addition to the minimum content requirements set out in the Code of Conduct.
- Where an intermediary distributes an investment product to a client, it must deliver the following information to the client prior to or at the point of sale:
  - a. the capacity (principal or agent) in which an intermediary is acting;
  - b. affiliation of the intermediary with the product issuer;
  - c. disclosure of monetary and non-monetary benefits; and
  - d. the generic terms and conditions under which client may receive a discount of fees and charges from an intermediary. (See 8.3A of the Code of Conduct.)
- The Q&A on suitability obligations requires advisers to give clients:
  - relevant product disclosure documents;
  - proper explanations of why recommended investment products are suitable for them; and
  - the nature and extent of risks the investment products bear.
- Investment advisers must always present balanced views and use simple and plain language.

### Suitability and risk disclosure statements
- Paragraph 6.2 of the Code of Conduct: when opening an account for conducting certain transactions or dealing for the first time in those transactions, intermediaries must provide the relevant risk disclosure statements to the client.
- Risk disclosure statements that comply with Schedule 1 of the Code of Conduct should be given to clients in respect of:
  - a. Securities trading;
  - b. Trading futures and options;
  - c. Trading GEM stocks;
  - d. Providing an authority to lend or deposit clients’ securities with third parties;
  - e. Providing an authority to hold mail or to direct mail to third parties;
  - f. Margin trading; and
  - g. Trading NASDAQ-AMEX securities on SEHK

### Reports to clients
- An intermediary must provide a monthly statement of account to clients who have money, securities, collateral or open positions with the intermediary, or who have been provided with a contract note during the relevant month (section 11 of the Contract Note Rules).
- The intermediary must also provide a statement if a client requests it (section 12).

### Customer access to terms and conditions; remuneration disclosure
- All intermediaries must enter into a written agreement with each client before services are provided (paragraph 6.1 of Code of Conduct).
- The minimum required content of the client agreement is detailed in paragraph 6.2 of the Code of Conduct.
- The client agreement should not operate to remove, exclude or restrict any rights of a client or obligations of the intermediary under the law, and should properly reflect the services to be provided (paragraphs 6.3 and 6.4).
- The client agreement must contain a description of any remuneration (and the basis for payment) that is to be paid by the client to the intermediary, such as commission, brokerage, and any other fees and charges (paragraph 6.2).
- Paragraph 8.3 of the Code of Conduct details requirement for pre-sale disclosure of both monetary and non-monetary benefits receivable by the intermediary under specified circumstances.

### Conflicts of interest
- General Principle 6 and paragraph 10.1 of the Code of Conduct:
  - intermediaries should try to avoid conflicts of interest;
  - where conflicts cannot be avoided, ensure clients are fairly treated;
  - intermediaries must not advise or deal in relation to a transaction giving rise to actual or potential conflict unless disclosed to the client and all reasonable steps taken to ensure fair treatment.
- Paragraph 4 of Part VII of the ICG: intermediaries must have specific policies and procedures to minimize conflicts of interest and ensure clients are informed and treated fairly when conflicts cannot be avoided; includes requirement for adequate information barriers (“Chinese walls” – see paragraph 8 of Appendix).
- Code of Conduct paragraphs 9.1 and 9.2: detailed requirements on handling and execution of client orders, including requirement to give client orders priority over proprietary orders.
- Code contains specific conflicts requirements relating to analyst’s activities (paragraph 16(3)(a)). Other conflicts requirements are set out in the FMCC and the Corporate Finance Adviser Code of Conduct.

### Supervision — SFC: structure and resourcing
- SFC’s approach comprises prudential supervision (compliance with FRR requirements) and conduct supervision.
- Intermediaries Supervision Department had a total of 128 staff as of 31 August 2013.
- Staff numbers have increased by 70 percent over the last 5 years.

### Risk assessment (SFC)
- SFC uses a risk and impact assessment process to evaluate and track the risk and impact profile of LCs to:
  - a. systematically evaluate and track the risk and impact profile of LCs; and
  - b. identify regulatory focus and prioritize resources in supervising individual LCs (including off-site-monitoring and on-site inspection) by linking evaluation results to monitoring and inspection selection.
- Each LC is assessed on:
  - a. Risks – combination of financial risks and business conduct risks of a LC; and
  - b. Impact – significance of an LC on the Hong Kong securities and futures markets and investors.
- A nine-field matrix links risk/impact assessment to supervisory processes with three levels of regulatory intensity: Close Monitoring, Regular Monitoring, and Baseline Monitoring.
- The risk and impact assessment is updated in an internal database on an ongoing basis, for example on receipt of monthly returns on compliance with FRR requirements.

### Off-site monitoring (SFC)
- About half of the Intermediaries Supervision department of 128 staff do off-site monitoring work.
- Off-site staff review regulatory filings, annual audited accounts, annual business and risk management questionnaire, breach notifications, monthly returns, and other information.
- Each LC has an SFC staff member “owner” and reviews by case owners are subject to supervisory review.
- Financial soundness is assessed mainly through monthly financial returns and annual accounts; monthly returns are analyzed by computer system against 51 key indicators producing red flags.
- Sensitivity and stress testing are done regularly.
- Off-site monitoring is stepped up for higher risk or significant impact LCs (more intensive review, closer dialogue, more frequent on-site inspections).
- SFC monitors industry risk profile and business model changes via interaction with market participants, surveys, and market intelligence. Example: mystery shopping exercise in 2010 with 150 samples on 10 LCs.

### On-site inspections and prudential visits (SFC)
- SFC prepares an annual plan for on-site inspection work using mixed top-down and bottom-up approaches.
- Under the on-site inspection program, all firms are inspected at least every 7 years; higher risk/impact firms may be inspected every 3-4 years.
- On-site inspections types:
  - a. Routine inspections: general checks on internal controls and risk management; tailored inspection plans and checklists.
  - b. Thematic inspections: assess sector-crossing risks; a sample of LCs selected across sizes; tailor-made review steps. Examples: selling practices reviews; thematic review of sponsors in IPO process; review of risk controls for brokers trading derivative warrants and callable bull-bear contracts.
  - c. Special inspections: cause-driven for suspected financially vulnerable LCs or imminent risks; scope tailored to specific circumstances.
- Prudential visits: last between half a day and a day; designed to make general assessment of firm controls based on management representations.

### On-site inspection activity — SFC (selected numeric data)
- Risk-based on-site inspections by major business types (table values preserved):
  - Firm Type 2012/2013 2011/2012 2010/2011 2009/2010 2008/2009
  - Brokers 148 145 82 76 116
  - Hedge Fund Management Companies (HFMCs) 18 23 16 28 4
  - Asset Management Companies (excluding HFMCs) 54 38 60 46 16
  - Investment Advisors 20 34 36 28 13
  - Others 31 12 41 22 11
  - Total No. of Inspections 271 252 235 200 160
- Breakdown of risk-based on-site inspections by inspection types (table values preserved):
  - 2012/2013 2011/2012 2010/2011 2009/2010 2008/2009
  - Routine inspections 248 152 189 171 80
  - Thematic inspections 16 85 35 26 70
  - Special inspections 7 15 11 3 10
- Number of LCs subject to prudential visits (table values preserved):
  - 2012/2013 2011/2012 2010/2011 2009/2010 2008/2009
  - On-site prudential visits 66 74 82 74 69
- Referrals to Enforcement Division as a result of on-site inspections and off-site monitoring (for investigation and/or disciplinary inquiry):
  - 2012/2013 2011/2012 2010/2011 2009/2010 2008/2009
  - Referrals 29 22 27 34 19

### Supervision — HKMA (RIs)
- Supervision of RIs by HKMA’s Banking Conduct Department includes off-site monitoring and on-site inspections of 118 RIs as of 30 June 2013.
- Three teams of HKMA staff involved in off-site supervision; specialist teams analyze reports and quarterly surveys.
- HKMA does not have a formal risk scoring system; inputs into risk assessment include supervisory experience, development of securities business, retail sales activity, complaints, Return of Securities Related Activities (semi-annual), self-reporting of breaches, input from SFC, adverse media, and industry disciplinary issues.
- Off-site monitoring reviews:
  - a. Self-assessment reports, thematic on-site examination reports, independent review reports;
  - b. quarterly surveys of RIs with retail customer base;
  - c. half-yearly Return of Securities Related Activities;
  - d. mystery shopping exercise results;
  - e. incident and exception reports from RIs.
- HKMA’s off-site monitoring supported by computerized system recording “incident summaries” for consistency and cross-RI breach identification.

### On-site inspections (HKMA)
- HKMA carries out routine and thematic inspections.
- Inspection cycle targets:
  - a. for the 21 RIs with a retail client base, the examination cycle is 1-2 years;
  - b. the top 10 non-retail RIs are subject to a 3-4 year cycle; and
  - c. other non-retail RIs are subject to a cycle that takes into account time since last inspection and known areas of concern.
- In 2012, HKMA staff conducted 27 on-site examinations covering Qualified Foreign Institutional Investors funds; accumulators and decumulators; the selling process; product due diligence; and training regarding investment products regulated under the SFO.
- HKMA emphasis in recent years on selling of products to retail clients, particularly ETFs, ILAS and high yield bonds.

### Regulatory response to problems identified (HKMA)
- HKMA’s Banking Conduct Department refers cases to HKMA’s Enforcement Department based on internal criteria including length of non-compliance, potential impact on clients, number of complaints, and fitness and properness concerns.
- 17 cases were referred in 2011, 18 in 2012 and 21 cases in the first half of 2013.
- HKMA also refers cases to the SFC where disciplinary action under the SFO, or possible administrative, civil or criminal action may result.
- HKMA referrals to SFC:
  - 2013 (Jan-Aug) 2012 2011 2010
  - Referrals 12 22 7 691*
  - * 2010 cases were almost all cases concerning the sale of Lehman minibonds.

### Assessment and supervision conclusions
- Assessment: Fully Implemented.
- Improvements after Lehman minibonds experience: SFC strengthened code of conduct for intermediaries in 2010; HKMA imposed additional requirements via circulars since 2009; HKMA created a separate department for conduct supervision; SFC pursued enforcement actions aimed at achieving compensation of investors.
- Supervisory role: identify risk and potential poor practices early, prevent risk build-up, and deal with misconduct swiftly.
- SFC and HKMA use combination of off-site and on-site supervision; both make extensive use of on-site tools compared with many jurisdictions.
- SFC’s risk-based approach includes thematic work to address clusters of risk among smaller firms and refined calibration to adjust supervisory intensity.
- Limitations in the regulatory framework for enforcement create trade-offs for SFC between client compensation and disciplinary sanctions; this is an enforcement challenge reflected in grades for Principles 11 and 12.

### Failure management, contingency planning and intervention powers (SFC and other bodies)
- SFC has a Market Contingency Plan (MCP) with specific section dealing with failure of an intermediary and procedures to contact other financial market regulators; updated contact information set out in MCP appendix.
- SFC contingency plan (Appendix 3 of MCP) sets out:
  - a. roles of designated staff in Intermediaries Supervision Department; and
  - b. core actions for major risk scenarios:
    - i. Substantial market decline;
    - ii. LCs with material systematic operational failure;
    - iii. LCs with material systematic financial failure;
    - iv. Sizable listed company failure or share price plummet; and
    - v. Bank crisis.
- The FSTB conducts a market-wide contingency rehearsal for the financial services sector every two years; last market-wide contingency rehearsal was conducted on 15 December 2012.
- Early warning systems:
  - LCs required to notify SFC under section 55(1) of the FRR in writing within one business day when:
    - a. its liquid capital falls below 120 percent of its required liquid capital;
    - b. its liquid capital falls below 50 percent of the liquid capital stated in its latest return submitted to the SFC under section 56(1) or (3) of the FRR; and
    - c. any information in previous returns submitted under the FRR has become false or misleading in a material particular.
  - Notice must contain full details and steps taken or planned to prevent liquid capital falling below required minimum or to improve liquidity.
  - Sections 146(1) and 146(3) of the SFO also provide for LCs to notify the SFC of their inability to meet capital requirements or to ascertain whether they are meeting them.
- Regulator’s powers to intervene (SFC):
  - If it receives a notice under section 146(1) of the SFO, SFC may permit LC to carry on any regulated activity subject to conditions (section 146(2)).
  - If SFC reasonably believes a LC is unable to maintain or ascertain maintenance of financial resources per FRR, SFC may (section 146(5)):
    - a. suspend the LC's license, wholly or in part, for a specified period or until specified event; or
    - b. permit the LC to carry on regulated activity subject to conditions.
  - Other SFO powers include:
    - a. impose licensing conditions under section 116(6);
    - b. impose a prohibition or requirement under sections 204, 205 or 206 (exercise requires threshold in section 207 to be met).
- HKEx powers for defaulting clearing participants:
  - a. to close out any unsettled contracts (Rule 3702(i) of General Rules of CCASS); and
  - b. to transfer any open futures/options contracts and margin collateral to other non-default clearing participants (Rule 510(f) of HKCC Rules and Rule 703(5) of SEOCH Clearing Rules).
- Court-appointed administrators/liquidators for a LC are usually authorized to allocate and distribute securities and cash back to clients (example: MF Global Hong Kong Limited where SFC restriction notice was varied to enable the liquidator to close out or transfer client positions).
- Court can appoint a person to administer property of an LC on application of the SFC if LC has contravened a relevant provision (section 213(2)(d) of the SFO).
- Use of powers: SFC has used restriction notices under sections 204-206 and the appointment of administrators in a number of cases.

### Investor Compensation Fund
- The SFC works with the Investor Compensation Company Limited (wholly owned subsidiary of the SFC) to handle compensation claims against the Investor Compensation Fund (the Fund).
- Fund established in 2003 under the SFO; funded by an Investor Compensation Levy on exchange-traded product transactions with automatic levy suspension/reinstatement trigger; levy currently suspended because fund size has exceeded maximum level required to be maintained.
- The Fund pays compensation to investors who are “qualifying clients” who suffer pecuniary losses as a result of default of an intermediary/licensed or registered dealer in securities or futures contracts, an intermediary licensed for securities margin financing or an authorized financial institution providing securities margin financing, in relation to exchange-traded products in Hong Kong.
- A qualifying client excludes certain categories of institutions and persons (including licensed corporations and authorized financial service providers).
- Claims Rules cap compensation payable to each person in relation to securities and futures respectively at HK $150,000.
- According to SFC’s compensation history, for about 70 percent of the clients who applied for compensation, this amount was sufficient to cover all their losses.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 10 of the KRR requires such records to be kept for a period of not less than 7 years*

### Section 5 of the SFO; and the matters the SFC shall have regard to under Section 6(2) of the

### _cr14205 - Section 5 of the SFO; and the matters the SFC shall have regard to under Section 6(2) of the

### Duties and standards under the SFO; REC obligations
- The SFC will apply the matters under Section 6(2) of the SFO in pursuing its regulatory objectives and performing its functions and impose prudential and capital requirements.
- The SFC will review:
  - if the company would have the capability to carry out the statutory duties specified in the SFO;
  - the various trading or clearing systems to ensure the readiness and integrity of the systems.
- Specific duties on a recognized exchange company (REC) under the SFO (Section 21):
  - ensure an orderly, informed and fair market in securities;
  - ensure that risks associated with its business and operations are managed prudently;
  - act in the interest of the public, having particular regard to the interest of the investing public;
  - ensure that the interest of the public prevails where it conflicts with the interest of the REC.
- Operational duties of a REC:
  - operate facilities in accordance with rules made under Section 23 and approved by the SFC under Section 24;
  - formulate and implement procedures to ensure exchange participants comply with the rules;
  - provide and maintain (a) adequate and properly equipped premises; (b) competent personnel; and (c) automated systems with adequate capacity, facilities to meet contingencies or emergencies, security arrangements and technical support.
- SFC actions in review of applications:
  - assess capability of applicant company to fulfil REC duties;
  - pursuant to the SFO, the SFC can attach conditions to a recognition order;
  - SFC can give orders and withdraw the licence of an exchange (prior consultation with the FS is required).

### HKEx supervision and framework under Section 5 of the SFO
- The SFC supervises all exchanges, including recognized exchanges controlled by the HKEx.
- The SFO does not list a detailed set of issues for ongoing supervision; duties imposed on exchanges provide the supervisory framework.
- Existing HKEx rules addressing aspects expected under Principle 33:
  - Products: listing rules specify product types and listing requirements; regime has features of a merit system (see Principle 16) with overall assessment of suitability in addition to disclosure requirements.
  - Intermediaries: only type 1 licensees for the cash market and type 2 licensees for the derivatives markets are eligible to be participants of the SEHK and the HKFE respectively; admission rules are based on objective criteria; exchange decisions on participants are final and conclusive.
  - Order execution procedures: rules specify order execution procedures, trade matching and execution algorithms; securities and futures/options contracts executed based on price/priority as stated in the rules.
  - Connection and access:
    - Rules (Rules 364B and 365 of the SEHK Rules and Rule 1201 of the HKFE Rules) allow participants to use software provided by exchanges, vendors or developed in-house.
    - Participants free to choose trading devices to access trading systems.
    - Current network (SDNET) allows small differences in access depending on participant location according to senior HKEx officials.
    - SEHK introduced co-location services for the cash market in November of 2012 and for derivatives in June 2013.
    - As of the time of the assessment 25 percent of the volume of the cash markets and 45 percent of the derivatives markets was coming through co-location.
    - HKEx is developing a new central gateway service to be implemented in mid-2014; new services intended to provide quicker access; all participants have equal opportunity to subscribe; among participants at the co-location centre, system access time and latency are equal.
    - Central gateway is optional initially and will become mandatory later; all participants using central gateway would ultimately enjoy the same system access time or execution response time.
  - Operational information: rules are available via the HKEx website; all participants connected to SEHK and HKFE trading systems have equal access to pre-trade information and information on completed trades; trading information is disseminated directly to participants; trade data can be used to reconstruct trading activity.
  - Risk management:
    - SEHK trading system allows trades only at prices within the range of the lowest of twenty-four spreads below the previous closing price, the lowest bid and the lowest ask price up to the time of the transaction on the day and the highest of twenty-four spreads above the previous closing price, the highest bid and the highest ask price up to the time of the transaction on the day (Rule 501F(3) of SEHK Rules).
    - HKFE trading system only allows input of prices within a price range set by HKFE; price ranges differ by product and are subject to change per market circumstances; HKFE informs participants of price range (or change) via circulars.
    - HKEx is strengthening protections to include features such as “cancel on disconnection” and “drop copy” (real-time data feed of details of trades and orders entered by a participant).
  - Direct market access: current rules do not allow direct access to non-exchange participants; direct access is intermediated through participant systems; trading systems allow users to modify certain settings to prevent erroneous trades.
    - Effective in January 2014, more stringent obligations required from participants for establishment of pre-trade controls.
    - HKEx is enhancing pre-trade controls measures to assist participants in complying with new risk management obligations.
  - High frequency trading (HFT): senior HKEx officials indicated HFT is rare in cash markets due to stamp duty; more HFT in derivatives markets where some products (e.g., options) are exempted from stamp duty; HFT often conducted by market makers for structured products and warrants that add liquidity and lower spreads; they do not have make or take models.

### Regulation, standards and application process for ATS
- ATS Guidelines set out Principles and Standards of Practice pursuant to which the SFC reviews ATS applications; principles are modelled on the objectives, functions and duties of the SFC (Sections 4, 5, 6 of the SFO).
- Core standards of practice for ATS (summarized):
  - Financial resources and risk management: An ATS should comply with appropriate prudential and operational standards.
  - Operational integrity: An ATS provider should maintain electronic facilities with adequate security, capacity and contingency arrangements.
  - Fitness: An ATS should be fit and proper as established in HK or in its home country.
  - Record keeping: An ATS should keep full records of its ATS operations, including audit trails of ATS activity.
  - Transparency: An ATS should provide appropriate transparency in relation to ATS operations, traded products, including when relevant order processing arrangements, transaction execution, settlement arrangements and operational requirements or rules.
  - Surveillance: Surveillance of ATS activity should be performed by the ATS provider, a regulatory authority or another competent person, and such surveillance should be consistent with relevant market regulation in HK.
  - Reporting: An ATS provider should keep the SFC informed of its operations and traded products, and any material changes to those operations.
- Regulatory approach:
  - SFC takes a pragmatic, flexible, case by case approach; regulation level commensurate with function performed and risks posed.
  - A fair and level playing field sought so similar regulation applies to similar functions.
  - SFC considerations include: nature and extent of ATS activity; market participants affected; whether retail investors may be involved; whether systemic risk might arise. The greater the activity and potential effects (especially systemic risk), the more the SFC will expect from an ATS.
  - For ATS authorized under Part III, SFC generally relies on regulation and supervision of the home regulator for foreign operators recognized and regulated in another jurisdiction.
- Application process details:
  - SFO empowers SFC to require all information deemed necessary to process an application.
  - Applicant must submit information necessary to demonstrate compliance with the ATS Guidelines.
  - For Part III authorization applicants that are foreign exchanges/ATS already recognized by a foreign regulator, SFC requires an MoU between the SFC and the corresponding jurisdiction. If met, staff reviews home country rules and then reviews whether applicant is fit and proper; SFC conducts its own due diligence including inquiries to the home regulator rather than relying fully on the home regulator.
  - For Part V licence applicants, Intermediaries Supervision and Licensing Departments and the SOM customarily visit applicant to demonstrate systems; SFC may request additional information or external certification if system problems are severe; SFC staff indicated external certification has been requested in the past.
  - Important policy decisions (e.g., transparency, types of users with access) have been handled case by case via licensing conditions. Example: licensing conditions have limited Part V ATS that are dark pools to trading with/for institutional investors.
  - Periodic reporting obligations have been imposed via Part III authorization conditions or Part V licensing conditions and vary from quarterly to monthly reporting of volumes.
- Notification and reporting obligations for ATS (via authorization/licensing conditions):
  - Any material change to ATS operations must be notified along with explanation prior to implementation; notifications cover areas such as (i) corporate structure and governance; (ii) business plans or operations; (iii) trading rules, trading sessions and operating hours, the system operator, hardware, software, and all system interfaces; (iv) ATS provider’s contractual responsibilities in relation to users; (v) criteria for approval or disapproval of users; and (vi) business continuity and disaster recovery plans.
  - A breach of conditions or the ATS Guidelines must be notified forthwith upon its occurrence.
  - Any incidents of material service breakdown or disruption to operations must be notified upon their occurrence.

### Policy gaps, market concerns, and SFC responses
- Identified gaps and market concerns:
  - No explicit stated public policy guiding applicants choosing between exchange recognition and Part III ATS authorization.
  - Conditions applied to Part V ATS operators are not uniform; critical operational aspects (user types, transparency) have been left to licensing conditions leading to inconsistent treatment and an unlevel playing field because earlier dark pool operators were grandfathered and subject to varying, generally less onerous conditions.
  - The lack of a publicly articulated policy renders the current framework opaque for applicants deciding which framework to apply for.
- SFC actions and intentions:
  - SFC developed an internal policy to guide decisions between exchange recognition and Part III ATS after an application to operate a futures market; policy not yet publicly articulated in formal document.
  - SFC plans to issue a consultation on these issues to articulate regulatory considerations for choosing between a recognized exchange and Part III ATS in the ATS Guidelines.
  - In February 2014, the SFC issued a consultation paper proposing standardized regulatory obligations and requirements, to be incorporated into the Code of Conduct, to be imposed on all dark pool operators in Hong Kong.

### Assessment, implementation status, and comments
- Assessment: Partly implemented
- Comments summarizing reasons for assessment:
  - Lack of a clear and specific public policy to guide applicants in determining the appropriate regulatory framework for trading platforms (recognized exchanges, Part III ATS and Part V ATS) and the conditions that apply to them.
  - Two aspects:
    - Conditions for Part V ATS operators are non-uniform; reliance on licence conditions over time produced inconsistent treatment and an unlevel playing field as initial Part V ATS were grandfathered.
    - No publicly articulated policy to guide applicants in deciding whether to apply for recognition as an exchange or authorization as an “exchange like” Part III ATS; applicants lack sufficient information to make an informed decision under the current framework.
  - SFC is aware of the challenges and intends to issue consultation papers to formalize policy positions on these topics.

### Market surveillance, division of responsibilities, and HKEx operational surveillance
- Division of responsibilities:
  - MoU of 2001 on Matters related to SFC Oversight, Supervision of Exchange Participants and Market Surveillance provides framework for oversight and division between SFC and HKEx.
  - Under current arrangements:
    - HKEx is the front line supervisor for ensuring fair, transparent and orderly markets.
    - Surveillance for detecting unfair trading practices (market manipulation, insider dealing, etc) is a responsibility of the SFC; HKEx has complementary role and must refer evidence of unfair practices to the SFC.
    - HKEx has responsibilities in authorization of prospectuses (in certain cases) and product listing (see Principle 16).
    - HKEx can establish trading, clearing rules and qualifications for participants and is responsible for monitoring compliance and taking actions against participants (suspend, restrict, vary trading/clearing/settlement rights).
    - One HKEx eligibility criterion is that persons should be corporations licensed by the SFC, thus subject to SFC oversight.
    - Under the SFO, the exchange must immediately notify the SFC if a participant is unable to comply with exchange rules or financial resources rule, or if a financial irregularity or other matter may indicate the participant’s financial standing or integrity is in question or inability to meet legal obligations.
    - Under the 2001 MoU the HKEx will refer to the SFC any suspected violation of ordinances or codes, rules and regulations made by the SFC.
- HKEx market surveillance teams and resources:
  - HKEx has two dedicated teams to enforce rules related to fair and orderly trading:
    - Counterparty surveillance: monitors participants’ compliance with financial requirements and position limits. Currently this team has 7 staff.
    - Market surveillance: monitors trading activities in real time to detect unusual trades; automated systems with embedded alert parameters; team follows up alerts and refers evidence of misconduct to the SFC; the team holds regular contacts with the SFC on investigations. This team has 6 staff.
- SFC market oversight powers and procedures:
  - Section 23 of the SFO: SFC may direct an exchange company to make or amend any rules which an exchange company is permitted to make; SFC must consult the FS and the recognized exchange company before directing.
  - Sections 28 and 29 of the SFO set out procedures for ordering an exchange/exchange controller to take particular actions.
  - Pursuant to Section 28, the SFC may, after consultation with the FS, withdraw the recognition.
  - SFC may exercise emergency powers under Section 29 of the SFO.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 5 of the SFO; and the matters the SFC shall have regard to under Section 6(2) of the*

### Section 29 empowers the SFC to direct the exchange to cease to provide or operate such

### _cr14205 - Section 29 empowers the SFC to direct the exchange to cease to provide or operate such

### Emergency power (Section 29)
- Section 29 empowers the SFC to direct the exchange to cease to provide or operate such facilities or services as may be specified.
- No obligation to give the exchange 14 days’ prior notice when exercising this power.
- Limitations:
  - Can only be exercised in limited cases (e.g. natural disaster, economic or financial crisis, circumstances likely to prejudice orderly transaction of business on the exchange).
  - Any such direction can only stay in place for a maximum of 10 business days.

### Ongoing engagement and supervisory meetings
- The SFC engages regularly with the HKEx to review and discuss major strategic and policy initiatives affecting trading, clearing and settlement operations, market surveillance, regulation, and risk management.
- Topics include developments that could impact orderly market functioning and international market and regulatory developments with implications for HKEx or Hong Kong’s role as an international financial center.
- Senior management meeting cadence:
  - RMC (monthly)
  - FSTB/SFC/HKEx Meeting (bi-monthly)
  - SFC/HKEx Liaison Meeting (bi-monthly)
  - Supervision of Markets (SOM) Division and HKEx IT Team meeting (quarterly)

### Market function: data access, reporting, and notifications
- Real time access:
  - The SFC has real time access to the pre-trade information on trades conducted on SEHK and HKFE.
- Post-trade and periodic reporting received from SEHK and HKFE:
  - daily reports on the cash market from HKSCC regarding settlement compliance, margin requirement, and reports on Sensitivity Analysis (used for the purpose of determining the sufficiency of the Guarantee Fund), Liquidity Requirement of individual clearing participants and the Guarantee Fund (contributions made by individual clearing participants);
  - daily reports on Margin, Reserve Fund and Delta Positions (held by clearing participants), and on Large Open Positions;
  - daily reports on cross-market risks in respect of “high-risk” brokers reported under Consolidated Accounts Reporting;
  - weekly reports on operational statistics on the trading and clearing of the cash and derivatives markets; and
  - monthly reports on CCASS trade, settlement and depository statistics.
- Notifications of significant events:
  - HKEx must give notice to the SFC as soon as practicable of matters designated as serious as set out in Appendix I of the MoU (e.g. defaults by participants, forced liquidation of open positions of participants, suspension/revocation of, or imposition/revision of restrictions on, a participant’s trading or clearing rights).
  - HKEx must also give notice of potential breaches by participants.

### Ongoing monitoring activities conducted by the SFC
- Through analysis of reports, notices and other information, the SFC:
  - supervises and monitors activities to detect unusual market activities;
  - ensures orderly, informed and fair market operation;
  - ensures risks associated with business and operations are managed prudently; and
  - safeguards the stability of the financial market.
- Daily monitoring entails:
  - Macro monitoring (local and overseas markets) and analysis of the latest market developments, including performance, volatility, trading activities in both the cash and derivatives markets; and
  - Risk monitoring reports of various market segments to detect irregularities such as concentration and building up of positions, and identify trends and significant or sudden changes, which may have systemic impact on the stock and derivatives markets.
- Activities of major financial institutions in various segments of the Hong Kong markets are also monitored.

### On-site inspections and assessment of supervisory coverage
- As of the time of the assessment, on-site inspections had not been used for ongoing supervision of the market function of the HKEx; an inspection was planned for 2014.
- Rationale for on-site inspections: complement off-site monitoring given evolution of the exchange’s business model (including acquisition of the London Metal Exchange) and HKEx’s desire to become a more global exchange.
- Assessment: Broadly implemented.
- Comments from assessors:
  - Grade reflects lack of on-site inspections in connection with question 2b of the methodology.
  - SFC keeps close monitoring via system access, reporting obligations (including notification of breakdowns) and regular contact.
  - On-site inspections are important to review internal controls, risk management, IT reliability, and quality of reporting.
  - Recent decision to conduct an on-site inspection on the market functions of the HKEx addresses completeness concerns.
  - Assessors encourage consideration of other oversight mechanisms (e.g., whether decisions by HKEx on participantship should have recourse to the SFC).
  - Recommend an overhaul of the RMC as it does not foster a sufficiently arms’ length relationship between the SFC and HKEx as a regulated entity.

### Market reliability
- HKEx is required to give notice of incident events.
- SFC staff indicated that overall there have not been major problems (glitches) with IT.
- The SFC is a member of the RMC which provides recommendations to the board of HKEx on risk management issues.

### Listing/Product function supervision
- Supervision channels:
  - Approval of listing rules including SFC’s power to object to HKEx decisions in connection with specific products to be listed.
  - On-site examinations of the listing function performed on an annual basis; results are made public.

### Alternative Trading Systems (ATS): authorization, monitoring, and obligations
- Powers:
  - Under Part III or Part V of the SFO, the SFC can request an ATS to provide any information necessary to be satisfied that an ATS is meeting authorization or licensing obligations.
  - SFC uses the authorization/licensing process to establish minimum periodic reporting obligations on ATS.
  - SFO does not require a home-regulator-regulated ATS to send rules for formal approval, but notification requirements apply; operator cannot implement changes unless SFC satisfied with inquiries.
  - SFC can withdraw authorization (Part III) or revoke licence (Part V) given to an ATS.
- Ongoing monitoring:
  - For ATS with a Type 7 licence under Part V, monitoring is part of the general supervision of intermediaries (supervised by the Intermediaries Supervision Department).
  - Close contact with SOM when there are incidents of material service breakdown or disruption.
  - First line of monitoring is reporting obligations, including report on trading volumes (quarterly or monthly depending on services).
  - When planning LC inspections, SFC considers licensed activities and risks involved to determine inspection scope; ATS often selected as a key part of LC inspection.
- Part III ATS conditions:
  - Required to notify SFC of any material change to matters set out in the application after authorization and prior to changes taking effect (corporate structure, business plan, systems, business continuity plan, disaster recovery program, contractual documentation and admission criteria for participants).
  - SFC may allow or disallow implementation of changes in HK.
  - Authorized ATS required to provide periodic reporting on activities in HK, including identity of HK participants and trading statistics.
  - If warranted, SFC will contact home regulator under IOSCO MMoU or bilateral MoU.
- Assessment: Broadly implemented (comments relate to on-site inspection absence).

### ATS market structure, transparency, and scale
- No statutory obligation for pre and post-trade transparency for ATS.
- ATS Guidelines: SFC assesses transparency case-by-case with reference to ATS type and international best practices.
- Current situation:
  - Almost all Part III ATS are foreign exchanges or foreign-based ATS recognized/authorized by another regulator.
  - About half the ATS licensed under Part V are internal crossing facilities (dark pools) operated by brokers and investment banks for client order flows in trading of stocks listed on SEHK; these generally do not provide pre-trade transparency.
  - Recent licensing conditions limit access to these platforms to institutional investors and require investor notification about order handling; best execution obligation vis-à-vis client exists.
  - Under SEHK rules, direct business transactions must be reported within 15 minutes after conclusion of the transactions and in any event before the close of trading for transactions transacted on that closing day.
  - SFC staff informed that the percentage of off-market transactions is around 4 percent.
- Post-trade reporting and flags:
  - Trading rule of HKEx requires all trades from ATS be reported to HKEx within 1 minute after execution, enabling consolidated post-trade information.
  - From 1 February 2011 trades concluded in dark pools were voluntarily flagged as “ALP” in brokers’ reporting to SEHK; flagging became mandatory under SEHK Rules since October 2012.
- Scale at March 2013:
  - 13 licensed dark pools
  - These account for about 2.5 percent of the turnover of SEHK.
- Access of SFC to information:
  - Pursuant to the MoU with HKEx, the SFC has real time access to the trading data of the exchanges, which includes data on executed trades in the ATS authorized under Part V.
  - All ATS (including those authorized under Part III) are required to provide the SFC with periodic reports on trading volumes.
- Assessment: Fully implemented.
- Comments:
  - Given the current limited size of ATS, lack of pre-trade transparency for dark pools does not pose overall concerns for SEHK securities market transparency.
  - Policy view: decision not to require pre-trade transparency from ATS operating dark pools should be kept under review.
  - If ATS licensed under Part V grow, SFC should change supervisory approach and integrate ATS supervision into market supervision program (current approach treats ATS within Intermediaries Division).

### Principle 35 — Transparency of trading (exchanges and ATS)
- Exchanges:
  - No explicit statutory requirement for provision of pre-trade and post-trade information for exchanges in general.
  - HKEx trading rules provide adequate pre-trade transparency: includes best bid and ask quotations and market depth; orders include the broker ID.
  - Post-trade information includes last traded price, day high, day low, closing price and trading volume.
  - Off-exchange trades by exchange members must be reported to SEHK and HKFE within time stipulated in rules (direct business transactions: within 15 minutes).
  - Market participants can access pre and post trade information directly via exchange market data systems or indirectly through information vendors on a timely basis; some vendors provide basic real time market information free of charge (real time nominal prices, day high, day low, closing prices of exchange products, and market turnover information).
- ATS:
  - No statutory obligation for pre and post trade transparency; SFC assesses transparency per ATS type and international best practice.
  - Many Part V ATS (dark pools) do not provide pre-trade transparency; post-trade reporting to HKEx within 1 minute supports consolidated post-trade transparency.
  - Assessment: Fully implemented.
  - Comment: Keep review of pre-trade transparency policy for ATS operating dark pools.

### Principle 36 — Detecting and deterring manipulation and unfair trading practices
- Prohibited misconduct under the SFO:
  - Market or price manipulation: prohibited under sections 274, 275, 278, 295, 296, 299 and 300 of the SFO.
  - Misleading information: prohibited under sections 277 and 298 of the SFO.
  - Insider trading: prohibited under sections 270 and sections 291 of the SFO (covers both tipper and tippee, includes listed securities and related derivatives).
  - Front running: breach of the Code of Conduct for intermediaries.
  - Unfair practices: under section 300(1) of the SFO, prohibition on employing any device, scheme or artifice with intent to defraud or deceive; or engaging in any act, practice or course of business which is fraudulent or deceptive, or would operate as a fraud or deception.
- Available remedies and sanctions:
  - SFC may bring criminal prosecution or initiate proceedings in the MMT under sections 283 and 307 of the SFO (except for front running, which is a disciplinary Code breach).
  - Criminal penalties for insider trading: maximum fine of $10 million and imprisonment for up to 10 years (section 303 of SFO).
  - MMT powers include prohibition and cease and desist orders (section 257 of SFO).
  - Disciplinary powers for intermediaries (sections 194 and 196 of the SFO): suspend or revoke licence or registration, fine or reprimand.
  - For serious misconduct, SFC likely to revoke or impose lengthy suspension and/or impose a fine (up to the maximum of HK$10 million) or 3 times of the profit gained/loss avoided, whichever is higher.
  - Disciplinary action is not mutually exclusive with MMT or criminal proceedings.
- Additional power:
  - If SFC identifies materially false, incomplete or misleading information in announcements by or on behalf of a listed company, the SFC may, by notice to HKEx, direct HKEx to suspend trading in that security under Rule 8 of SMLR.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 29 empowers the SFC to direct the exchange to cease to provide or operate such*

### Section 213 of the SFO also empowers the SFC to apply for injunctive and remedial orders for

### Section 213 of the SFO also empowers the SFC to apply for injunctive and remedial orders for

### Enforcement powers and remedies
- Section 213 of the SFO empowers the SFC to apply for injunctive and remedial orders for any contravention of provisions in the SFO.
- In the case of front running, remedies available are those for misconduct by an intermediary:
  - suspend or revoke the license;
  - fine the intermediary;
  - reprimand the intermediary.

### Arrangements to detect market manipulation
- The SFC is the authority responsible for market surveillance for detecting unfair trading practices (as indicated under Principle 34).
- The MoU between the SFC and the HKEx requires HKEx to provide:
  - real time access to the SMARTS system, and daily MSS data containing agreed trading and other information; and
  - in relation to index futures and options contracts, real time electronic access to the CIBOIS terminal and a daily data feed in an agreed manner.
- The SFC deploys dedicated systems where specified parameters can be entered to detect unusual orders and transactions.
- A specialized team within the SFC closely monitors and follows up exception reports generated from the systems.
- The SFC receives referrals from the HKEx pursuant to their MoU.

- Referrals/suspicious transaction reports received from the HKEx over the five financial years (April 1 to March 31):
  - Categories and yearly counts:
    - Suspected insider dealing: 2008-09: 0; 2009-10: 1; 2010-11: 2; 2011-12: 1; 2012-13: 1; Total: 5
    - Suspected market manipulation: 2008-09: 5; 2009-10: 2; 2010-11: 1; 2011-12: 3; 2012-13: 0; Total: 11
    - Irregularities in derivatives trading: 2008-09: 6; 2009-10: 4; 2010-11: 0; 2011-12: 1; 2012-13: 0; Total: 11
    - Complaints: 2008-09: 1; 2009-10: 4; 2010-11: 6; 2011-12: 3; 2012-13: 8; Total: 22
    - Suspected breach of DI requirements: 2008-09: 37; 2009-10: 30; 2010-11: 19; 2011-12: 23; 2012-13: 14; Total: 123
    - Others: 2008-09: 7; 2009-10: 5; 2010-11: 9; 2011-12: 4; 2012-13: 7; Total: 32
    - Total referrals by year: 2008-09: 56; 2009-10: 46; 2010-11: 37; 2011-12: 35; 2012-13: 30; Grand Total: 204
  - Note: Data is for the financial year from April 1 to March 31.

### Investigation and statutory enquiry powers
- When staff consider further enquiries necessary, a recommendation is prepared and considered by the head of the team who may approve commencement of an enquiry under section 181 of the SFO.
- Under section 181 of the SFO the SFC is empowered to obtain:
  - identity details of the person who placed the order;
  - the ultimate beneficial owner of the trade;
  - other particulars of the order.
- The SFC may ask market intermediaries to provide background information on the clients involved.
- If, after a section 181 enquiry, suspicion of market or price manipulation exists:
  - the RO of the surveillance team prepares a case assessment report setting out suspicions and recommending referral to the investigation team;
  - the ESC (senior executives from investigation, surveillance and disciplinary teams in SFC’s Enforcement Division) considers the report;
  - once approved by the ESC, the investigation may commence under section 182 of the SFO.
- Market manipulation may also arise from complaints or referrals from other law enforcement or regulatory bodies or other SFC divisions (e.g., routine inspections).

### Coordination with the DoJ and criminal vs MMT avenues
- Under the current legal framework authorities can only pursue one avenue for the six types of market misconduct in the SFO: either criminal prosecution or take the person to the MMT under sections 283 and 307 of the SFO.
- The stated policy of the SFC and the DoJ is to seek criminal actions instead of MMT actions if there is sufficient evidence and it is in the public interest under the DoJ Prosecution policy.
- In 2007 the SFC reached an agreement with the DoJ on handling criminal cases; the first prosecutions under the SFO following this agreement took place in the period of 2008-2010. After those initial indictments no more new cases have been taken by way of indictment.

### Cross-border cooperation
- Currently roughly 56 percent of companies listed in the HKEx and 60 percent of trading volume are companies whose main operations are in the Mainland (although many are incorporated in other jurisdictions such as the Cayman Islands and Bermuda).
- Market participants expressed concern about enforcement challenges faced by the SFC given this market structure, which complicates gathering evidence and imposing enforcement actions on companies or their directors.
- The SFC is heavily dependent on assistance from the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC).
- An MoU among the SFC, HKEx, CSRC, Shanghai Stock Exchange and Shenzhen Stock Exchange facilitates cooperation.
- SFC staff noted cooperation challenges stem from practical aspects (for example, the sheer size of China) rather than legal impediments or lack of will.
- Evidence of cooperation in practice includes recent cases where injunctive actions sought in HK courts required Chinese authority assistance; assistance was received, enabling asset freezing and eventual compensation for investors.

### Commodities markets and large exposures
- Market participants must report to HKFE their large open positions of commodity futures contracts traded on recognized futures exchanges and certain authorized ATS. The SFC has access to this information.
- The SFC can identify concentrations of positions and the overall composition of commodity futures markets based on this data.
- Authorities responsible for front-line monitoring of large exposures of exchange trades include HKEx and its subsidiary exchanges and clearing houses: SEHK, HKFE, HKSCC, SEOCH and HKCC.
- Reporting and position limits are specified under legislation (Securities and Futures Rules) and Exchange rules; monitoring is continuous by HKEx and the SFC.
- Statutory position limits apply to cash and derivatives products; limits are quantitative and vary by contract type.
- HKEx produces a ‘consolidated accounts report’ showing consolidated open positions when trigger conditions occur; report is generated automatically and in practice produced daily.
- Reporting and access to beneficial owner information:
  - The Securities and Futures Rules require any person holding a specified position in relation to stock options and futures contracts to submit a report to the respective exchange.
  - Exchange participants must submit reports on their positions and their clients’ positions separately.
  - Reports include the position held, time when acquired, and for client positions: client identity, nature of business (e.g., whether a HF), and account type (e.g., an omnibus account).
  - Reports are submitted to exchanges on T+1 and passed to the SFC the same day.
- The SFC may require further information under Section 181 of the SFO from persons licensed by or registered with the SFC.
- Client Identity Rules in the Code of Conduct require licensed or registered persons to ascertain the identity of the ultimate beneficiary of broker-executed transactions.
- Failure to comply with reporting requirements is a criminal offence:
  - on conviction on indictment: a fine at level 6 and imprisonment for 2 years;
  - on summary conviction: a fine at level 3 and imprisonment for 6 months.
- Exchange disciplinary penalties for failing to file large open position reports include censure, fines, limitations on trading, liquidation of positions, higher margin requirements, revocation of trading privileges, suspension from trading, etc.
- Failure to provide information when requested under Section 181 of the SFO is a criminal offence.

### Powers to take action on exposures and margining
- Exchanges and clearing houses may require participants to reduce exposures if permitted limits are exceeded and have rule powers to:
  - increase, reduce or remove prescribed limits (Rules 624, 625 of Options Clearing Rules, Rule 502 of HKCC Rules, Rule 629 of HKFE Rules);
  - if limits are exceeded, require close out or transfer in accordance with clearing house rules; if participant does not comply, the exchange may close out or effect transfer on its behalf (Rule 508 HKCC Rules, Rule 631 HKFE Rules, Rules 625 and 628 of Options Clearing Rules);
  - prescribe number of contracts or value (long or short positions) in respect of any market if accumulated positions may be detrimental (Rule 630 HKFE Rules).
- Participants must calculate and monitor margin for all open positions and delivery obligations and demand payment of such margin from clients as seen fit (Rules 424 and 425 of the Options Trading Rules).
- Clearing house margin is calculated and collected from participants for open positions (Rule 402 of HKCC Rules, Rule 603 of Options Clearing Rules, Rule 3601 and 3602 of HKSCC Rules).

### Information exchange and MoUs
- Information on large exposures is shared between HKEx and the SFC under the MoU on Matters relating to SFC Oversight, Supervision of Exchange Participants and Market Surveillance.
- Such information may be provided to other local regulators or authorities (such as the HKMA) on request under the information sharing arrangement in the SFO.
- For overseas regulator requests involving non-public information, the SFC will provide such information under the relevant MoU (including the IOSCO MMoU).

### Default procedures and market safeguards
- Current CCP risk management arrangements include:
  - Additional financial requirements above those prescribed by the SFO for clearing members;
  - Requirement to post margins on a daily basis, reassessed intraday;
  - Contribution to a default fund: basic contribution and a dynamic contribution.
- Pursuant to Section 40 of the SFO, recognized clearing houses must have rules providing for default proceedings.
- Events of default and actions are set out in exchange/clearing house rules (Rule 701 of Options Clearing Rules, Rule 509 of HKCC Rules, Rule 3701 of HKSCC Rules, Rule 568 of SEHK Rules).
- Default handling powers generally allow the Chairman to:
  - suspend trading of a defaulting participant;
  - close out positions registered in the defaulting participant’s name;
  - transfer positions to other non-defaulting participants;
  - compulsory settlement of a defaulting participant’s position.
- Minimising market impact:
  - clearing house can step in and close out trades/positions of a defaulting broker-clearing participant;
  - insolvency override provisions give clearing house default proceedings precedence over general insolvency law.
- Control of client assets:
  - SFC typically issues a restriction notice on the clearing participant under Part X of the SFO to prohibit handling of own or clients’ property;
  - SFC will apply to the Court to appoint an Administrator who returns assets/monies to clients per the Court’s order.
- Segregation of client assets:
  - Client monies and assets are required to be segregated under the Client Money Rules and Client Securities Rules;
  - Participants manage two CCP accounts: one for own positions and one for clients’ positions;
  - In practice, use of omnibus accounts usually means CCP would close out rather than transfer client positions to manage volatility.
- HKEx improvements post-Lehman:
  - standard margins for cash markets established;
  - default fund size enlarged to cover default of the first and fifth largest intermediaries;
  - stress testing methodology strengthened.
- Further improvements needed to comply with the PFMI; HKEx provided preliminary analysis of aspects to strengthen alignment with the PFMIs, including:
  - phasing out bank guarantees;
  - assessing liquidity arrangements;
  - possible changes for segregation to address portability requirements in the cash markets.
- Current note on accounts: cash market settles everything from one account; derivatives provide investor choice of individual accounts although not commonly used.

### Short selling and reporting
- Section 170 of the SFO: naked short selling is generally prohibited — a short seller must borrow shares or have a written assurance of a presently exercisable and unconditional right to vest the securities before submitting a short selling order to the SEHK.
- Short selling orders must be “marked” for traceability by the SFC (section 172 of the SFO).
- SEHK has an uptick requirement to prevent short sales at successively lower prices and eligibility criteria restricting short selling to more liquid securities.
- Effective 18 June 2012, market participants are required to make weekly reports of outstanding short positions of specified stocks to the SFC under the Securities and Futures (Short Position Reporting) Rules.
  - The reportable short position is specified in Rule 3 of the Short Position Reporting Rules.
  - Under normal market conditions, any person with a reportable short position on the last trading day of the week must report to the SFC within the following two business days.
  - The SFC can require daily reporting of reportable short positions under stressed market situations.
  - The SFC publishes aggregated short positions of specified stocks within three business days upon receipt of short position reports.
- Market makers and liquidity providers in exchange traded markets are exempted from certain short-selling restrictions when using the stock market to hedge their positions (e.g., exemption from observing the up-tick rule).

### Settlement failures and market efficiency
- Equity transactions in Hong Kong settle on T+2.
- For failed trades, SEHK conducts a compulsory buy-in on T+3 to purchase the equity from the market for settlement and collects a compulsory buy-in fee of 0.5 percent from the exchange participant who failed to settle.
- The SFC receives information on settlement failures from HKEx daily.
- SFC staff indicated settlement failures are rare; current efficiency rate is 99.7-99.8 percent.
- Staff attributed the efficiency rate to stringent short-selling rules and the compulsory buy-in.

### Assessment and comments
- Assessment: Fully implemented
- Comments:
  - Assessors note enforcement challenges faced by the SFC due to the cross-border nature of the bulk of companies listed in the SEHK.
  - Assessors note the SFC has proactively sought good cooperation arrangements with relevant authorities.
  - Assessors note challenges for criminal enforcement; both issues were considered in the grade of Principle 12.

*Source: _cr14205 - Section 213 of the SFO also empowers the SFC to apply for injunctive and remedial orders for*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2014/_cr14205.pdf_
