## 1. Russia Linkages (_cr15110)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Russia Linkages (_cr15110)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/_cr15110.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/_cr15110.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/_cr15110.pdf.json)

---

### Context
- Latvia’s post-crisis recovery highlights:
  - Output gap has almost closed.
  - Unemployment is now mainly structural.
  - Real effective exchange rate is broadly in line with fundamentals.
  - Current account close to balance after previously being more than 20 percent of GDP in deficit before the output collapse.
  - Fiscal policy is prudent; public debt among the lowest in Europe.
  - Smooth entry into the Euro Area.
- Political and policy environment:
  - Policy continuity likely after parliamentary elections last October; incumbent center-right coalition remains in power.
  - 2014 Article IV recommendations emphasized:
    - Gradual fiscal consolidation in line with the Fiscal Discipline Law (FDL).
    - Measures to reduce inequality and strengthen the social safety net.
    - Structural reforms to boost productivity.
    - Close supervision of non-resident deposits (NRDs) in the banking system.
  - Policy-making has broadly reflected these recommendations (PIT allowance increases, electricity sector liberalization, close supervision of NRD-specialized banks).

### Recent economic developments
- Growth and output:
  - GDP growth: 4.2 percent (2013) → estimated 2.4 percent (2014).
  - Euro Area growth: 0.9 percent (2014).
  - Current account deficit widened slightly to about 3 percent of GDP (2014).
  - Direct impact from Russia-Ukraine conflict estimated relatively small to date.
- Demand composition:
  - Private consumption growth: 6.3 percent (2013) → 2.3 percent (2014).
  - Gross fixed investment: -5.2 percent (2013) → +1.6 percent (2014).
  - Exports subdued; ruble depreciation against the euro negatively affected export receipts, especially in Q4.
- Labor market and wages:
  - Real wages increased 6.3 percent (2014).
  - Minimum wage: 320 euros per month (2014), up from 280 euros.
  - Unemployment rate: 11.3 percent (Dec 2013) → about 10.5 percent (Dec 2014); participation rate stayed constant.
- Inflation:
  - Headline inflation averaged 0.7 percent (2014) after zero price growth (2013).
  - Core inflation: 0.2 percent (2013) → 1.5 percent (2014).
  - Euro Area core inflation: 0.7 percent (2014).
- Banking and financial sector:
  - NPL ratio: 8.3 percent (Dec 2013) → 6.8 percent (Dec 2014).
  - Stock of bank credit to the private sector declined by about 7.6 percent (y-on-y) in December 2014.
  - Issuance of new loans decreased in 2014; deleveraging continued with repatriation of funds to parent banks.
- Non-resident deposits (NRDs):
  - Excluding exchange rate effects, stock of NRDs increased by 14 percent year-on-year in December 2014, broadly in line with the three-year average.
- Fiscal developments:
  - General government deficit widened by about ½ percentage point to around 1.4 percent of GDP (2014); exceeded nominal budget target of 0.9 percent of GDP largely due to a one-off payment related to the sale of Citadele bank.
  - Structural deficit (excluding the one-off cost) estimated to remain just under 1 percent of GDP.

### Outlook and risks
- Near-term outlook (2015):
  - Lackluster growth expected due to anemic external environment, particularly Russia’s sharp slowdown.
  - Lower oil prices and robust real wages expected to partly support private consumption.
  - Liepajas Metalurgs (LM) has reopened and is gradually ramping up; not expected to reach full capacity until the fourth quarter.
  - ECB accommodative stance unlikely to have much direct impact except via a weaker euro and expectations of stronger Euro Area recovery.
  - Inflation expected to fall in 2015; electricity tariff liberalization to exert some upward pressure.
- Medium-term:
  - Annual medium-term growth of around 4 percent is considered achievable conditional on enhanced competitiveness, continued prudent macroeconomic management, sufficient investment, and TFP growth.
  - Adverse demographics and continuing emigration will tend to reduce the labor force.
- Key risks (Risk Assessment Matrix highlights):
  - Prolonged slowdown in Russia and the Euro Area.
  - Further escalation of sanctions and counter-sanctions.
  - A sharp supply-driven rise in oil prices.
  - Resurgent sovereign stress (e.g., Greece).
  - Failure to implement structural reforms; rising unit labor costs eroding competitiveness.
  - Vulnerability to a severe growth or current account shock that could reverse projected medium-term decline in debt-to-GDP ratio.
- Authorities’ view:
  - Authorities broadly concurred with risks but noted low public debt and sound fundamentals make sovereign market rationing unlikely; rating upgrades over the last three years.
  - Authorities noted upside risk from a stronger-than-expected Euro Area recovery.

### Policy discussions — Fiscal policy (summary)
- 2015 budget stance: broadly neutral.
  - PIT rate cut of 1 percentage point to 23 percent (2015) expected to result in an estimated revenue loss of ¼ percent of GDP, to be offset by tax base growth from improved compliance and higher wages (including a further 40 euros increase in the minimum wage) and by a cut in capital spending.
  - Structural deficit target of 1 percent of GDP aligns with the FDL.
  - Authorities agreed the budget should be implemented flexibly per the FDL given external uncertainties; automatic stabilizers should operate fully if growth falls below forecast.
- Social protection and inequality:
  - Social protection benefits per inhabitant are less than one fifth the EU average and among the lowest in Europe.
  - Income inequality among the highest (e.g., ratio of highest to lowest income quintile).
  - Staff recommended reversing the 2013 cuts to the Guaranteed Minimum Income (GMI) benefit and its decentralization.
- Fiscal space and revenue outlook:
  - Current policies (planned PIT cuts, reduced SOE payout ratio, increases in tax allowances, cuts in social contributions) estimated to reduce revenue by over three percentage points of GDP between 2013 and 2017.
  - Staff estimate additional revenue measures equivalent to 0.6 percent of GDP in 2016 and 2017 are needed to safeguard priority investment and social spending.
  - Alternatively, substantial expenditure reductions would be required, but scope is limited given already low public expenditures.
- Staff proposals to increase revenue and reduce inequality (quantified impacts, percent of GDP):
  - Maintain PIT rate at the 2015 rate of 23 percent: 0.21 (2016), 0.20 (2017)
  - Increase property tax rate by 0.5 ppt on buildings and land: 0.22 (2016), 0.22 (2017)
  - Improve cadastral revenue: 0.08 (2016), 0.08 (2017)
  - Reverse ceiling introduced on social contributions for incomes above 48,600: 0.14 (2016), 0.14 (2017)
  - Better-targeted tax allowances (including lower tax allowances for pensioners, lower tax allowances for dependents and elimination of non-taxable threshold for high-income individuals): 0.20 (2016), 0.20 (2017)
  - Increase CIT from current 15 to 16%: 0.10 (2016), 0.10 (2017)
  - Remove excise exemptions on gazoil for agriculture: 0.14 (2016), 0.14 (2017)
  - Total potential impact: 1.1 (2016), 1.1 (2017)
- Memorandum items:
  - Structural deficit: authorities' target: -0.8 (2016), -0.7 (2017)
  - Structural deficit: staff estimate without measures: -1.5 (2016), -1.3 (2017)
  - Gap: -0.6 (2016), -0.6 (2017)
- Authorities’ response:
  - Recognized need to enhance revenue over the medium term and reduce inequality.
  - Not amenable to reversing decentralization and cuts to GMI this year but considering medium-term plans for increasing GMI benefits within an integrated social benefit system.
  - Will consider introducing progressive minimum non-taxable thresholds in the future.

---

### 18. Latvia’s three largest banks and financial sector oversight

### Banking system soundness and recent developments
- System-wide metrics:
  - Average CET1 ratio: about 18 percent.
  - Liquidity ratio: around 64 percent.
  - Regulatory minimum requirements: 8 percent (CET1) and 30 percent (liquidity).
- Citadele sale:
  - Citadele was sold to a consortium of international investors within the timetable set by DG Competition.
  - Sale triggered the exercise of a put-option equivalent to about 0.4 percent of GDP compensating the EBRD for its injection of equity capital in Parex.
- NRD exposure:
  - NRDs account for about half of the banking sector’s total deposits.
  - Over 80 percent of NRDs are estimated to originate from Russia and other CIS countries.

### Supervision framework and cooperation
- Supervision shared between FCMC and the SSM.
- SSM directly supervises Latvia’s three largest banks (about 42 percent of banking system assets).
- Joint Supervisory Teams (JSTs) for these banks:
  - Led by an ECB official and include Latvian representation.
- Colleges of Supervisors for large banking groups:
  - Chaired by Swedish supervisory authorities; include ECB representatives; FCMC has observer status.
- Authorities report good information sharing and cooperation; priority to maintain open communication among ECB, Swedish regulators, and FCMC.

### Risks from NRDs and mitigation
- Risks:
  - NRDs could be vulnerable to a sudden stop or flow reversal; covered by deposit guarantee scheme representing a significant contingent fiscal liability.
  - Example: bankruptcy of Latvijas Krajbanka (September 2011) required Deposit Guarantee Fund payout of about 336 million lats (about 2.2 percent of GDP), of which 200 million lats came from a treasury loan.
- Mitigating factors:
  - NRD banks hold major share of assets abroad in liquid instruments (European and US government securities, bank deposits).
  - NRD banks are subject to higher capital and liquidity requirements.
  - FCMC plans a “business model risk” add-on to NRD banks’ contributions to the deposit guarantee scheme.
- AML/CFT and monitoring:
  - Authorities encouraged to continue strengthening and implementing AML / CFT framework.
  - Financial Intelligence Unit strengthened with greater budgetary support, expanded staff, more training, and more sophisticated risk-assessment software.

### Resuscitating bank credit: causes, policy actions, and needed reforms
- Causes of deleveraging:
  - Debt overhang, uncertain outlook, tightened lending standards, lack of collateral, and perception of high risk for SMEs and low-income households.
  - Dominance of Nordic subsidiaries limits domestic levers; parent banks repatriated excess cash.
  - Subsidiaries report lack of demand as main reason for anemic lending.
- Policy measures taken and recommended:
  - Single Development Institute (SDI) programs: loan guarantees and subordinated loans to catalyze private bank lending.
  - Development of credit bureaus to standardize borrower information.
  - Staff encourages SDI initiatives but cautions to avoid supporting unviable businesses.
  - Insolvency and judicial reforms: increase courts, specialization of judges, new law making insolvency administrators state officials with greater disclosure and supervision, encouragement of mediation/arbitration.
  - Mortgage-law compromise: banks must offer customers a choice between “regular” mortgage and limited-recourse mortgage.

### Structural reforms to support competitiveness and productivity
- Main medium-term challenge: maintain competitiveness within the Euro Area currency union.
- Policy recommendations:
  - Future minimum wage increases should not exceed productivity growth.
  - Implement in-work tax credits and benefits; strengthen Active Labor Market Policies (ALMPs) — coverage ratio improved from 42 percent (2012) to 62 percent (2014).
  - Upgrade public infrastructure to attract FDI; ports (Riga and Ventspils) need capacity, connectivity, governance improvements per World Bank recommendations.
  - Centralize SOE management and divest non-core activities; framework law passed October 2014 to strengthen SOE governance (centralized manager, independent boards, annual reporting).
  - Higher and vocational education reforms: quality-based accreditation of study fields, consolidation of higher education institutions, shift public funds toward STEM, new financing model to reward quality, scale-up vocational training from pilot of 6 institutions.

### Staff appraisal: summary recommendations
- Near-term:
  - Allow automatic stabilizers to operate fully in weak external environment.
  - 2015 budget broadly appropriate; build fiscal space over medium term.
- Financial sector:
  - Support public initiatives to catalyze SME lending (loan guarantees, subordinated positions, credit bureaus).
  - Reforms to insolvency procedures and the court system to encourage writedowns and reduce private sector debt.
  - Maintain vigilant supervision of NRD banks and continue strengthening AML/CFT.
- Competitiveness and structural policy:
  - Future minimum wage increases should not exceed productivity growth.
  - Reforms in labor markets, education, infrastructure, and SOE management to support productivity growth.
- Administrative note:
  - Next Article IV consultation recommended on the standard 12-month cycle.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt — “Latvia’s three largest banks comfortably passed the ECB’s Comprehensive Assessment.”*

---

### Republic of Latvia: External Sector Assessment and Annex II — External Debt (highlights)

### Exchange rate assessment and competitiveness
- CGER/ERER assessments:
  - REER broadly in line with fundamentals; substantial competitiveness gains from correcting an overvalued real exchange rate have been exhausted.
  - ES and MB approaches: REER close to equilibrium; ERER points to a moderate overvaluation.
  - Quoted table entries (as presented): External Sustainability -3.5 -2.2 ...... -2.6; Macroeconomic Balance -2.8 -2.2 ...... -1.2; Equilibrium Real Exchange Rate ......4.9 5.0 10.3. (A positive number indicates overvaluation.)
- EBA-lite findings (key values as presented):
  - CA-Actual 3.1%
  - CA-Fitted 4.5%
  - CA-Norm 5.5%
  - Residual 1.4%
  - CA-Gap 2.4%
  - Policy gap 1.0%
  - Elasticity -0.36
  - Real Exchange Rate Gap -6.5%
  - Cyclical Contributions -0.6%
  - Cyclically adjusted CA -2.5%
  - Cyclically adjusted CA Norm -4.9%
  - Caution: EBA-lite CA norm of -5.5 percent of GDP is inconsistent with Latvia’s still high negative net international investment position.

### External debt, capital flows, and outlook (Annex II baseline projections, percent of GDP unless noted)
- Baseline external debt (percent of GDP): 154.7 (2009); 165.8 (2010); 145.8 (2011); 137.2 (2012); 131.3 (2013); 138.7 (2014); 132.6 (2015); 135.0 (2016); 131.1 (2017); 129.1 (2018); 126.9 (2019).
- Debt-stabilizing non-interest current account: -7.5.
- Change in external debt (percentage points of GDP): 32.7 (2009); 11.1 (2010); -20.0 (2011); -8.6 (2012); -5.9 (2013); 7.3 (2014); -6.1 (2015); 2.4 (2016); -3.9 (2017); -2.0 (2018); -2.2 (2019).
- Current account deficit, excluding interest payments (percent of GDP): -16.5 (2009); -8.4 (2010); -2.4 (2011); -1.0 (2012); -0.8 (2013); 0.1 (2014); -1.1 (2015); -0.3 (2016); -0.5 (2017); -0.8 (2018); -0.8 (2019).
- External debt-to-exports ratio (percent): 357.9 (2009); 310.3 (2010); 251.5 (2011); 225.6 (2012); 222.5 (2013); 239.0 (2014); 236.2 (2015); 242.6 (2016); 234.0 (2017); 229.8 (2018); 225.6 (2019).
- Gross external financing need (in billions of US dollars): 18.8 (2009); 19.7 (2010); 20.4 (2011); 20.0 (2012); 22.2 (2013); 22.8 (2014); 22.0 (2015); 21.4 (2016); 23.7 (2017); 24.3 (2018); 25.9 (2019).
- Key macro assumptions (selected):
  - Real GDP growth (percent): -14.2 (2009); -2.9 (2010); 5.0 (2011); 4.8 (2012); 4.2 (2013); 3.4 (2014); 8.0 (2015); 2.4 (2016); 2.3 (2017); 3.3 (2018); 3.7 (2019).
  - Nominal external interest rate (percent): 5.1 (2009); 3.6 (2010); 3.7 (2011); 2.9 (2012); 2.5 (2013); 4.7 (2014); 2.6 (2015); 2.4 (2016); 2.1 (2017); 2.5 (2018); 2.5 (2019).
  - Growth of exports (US dollar terms, percent): -21.3 (2009); 13.2 (2010); 27.2 (2011); 5.3 (2012); 5.6 (2013); 18.2 (2014); 18.8 (2015); 1.9 (2016); -9.1 (2017); 4.6 (2018); 7.8 (2019).
  - Growth of imports (US dollar terms, percent): -38.1 (2009); 14.1 (2010); 34.9 (2011); 4.9 (2012); 4.1 (2013); 4.2 (2014); 71.0 (2015); 172.9 (2016); 1.3 (2017); -10.1 (2018); 7.3 (2019).
- Medium-term outlook:
  - External debt expected to resume post-crisis downward trend, decreasing by more than 10 percentage points by the end of the projection period.
  - Capital flows expected stable and sufficient to cover modest current account deficit; main components: government bond issuances, Nordic parent bank funding, and NRDs.

### Export composition and partner growth
- Export shares (percent of total exports, based on exports of goods in 2013):
  - Euro Area, 47%
  - Russia, 16%
  - Poland, 7%
  - Sweden, 5%
  - Denmark, 4%
  - United Kingdom, 3%
  - Norway, 2%
  - Belarus, 2%
  - Other, 14%

### Risk Assessment Matrix (summary)
- Selected risks with relative likelihood and impact if realized:
  - Surge in financial volatility: Relative Likelihood High; Impact Low/Medium.
  - Protracted slower growth in advanced and emerging economies: Relative Likelihood High; Impact Medium / High.
  - Geopolitical fragmentation (Russia/Ukraine, Middle East, Africa): Relative Likelihood Medium; Impact Medium / High.
  - Bond market stress from sovereign risk reassessment: Relative Likelihood Medium; Impact Medium.
  - Failure to advance structural reforms: Relative Likelihood Medium; Impact High.

### Selected national macro-financial indicators (highlights, 2008–2015)
- Real GDP (percent change): -3.2 (2008); -14.2 (2009); -2.9 (2010); 5.0 (2011); 4.8 (2012); 4.2 (2013); 2.4 (2014); 2.3 (2015 Est./Proj.).
- Private consumption (percent change): -8.0 (2008); -16.2 (2009); 3.1 (2010); 2.9 (2011); 3.0 (2012); 6.2 (2013); 2.3 (2014); 2.9 (2015).
- Gross external debt (percent of GDP): 122.0 (2008); 154.7 (2009); 165.8 (2010); 145.8 (2011); 137.2 (2012); 131.3 (2013); 138.7 (2014); 132.6 (2015).
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): -12.3 (2008); 8.0 (2009); 2.3 (2010); -2.8 (2011); -3.3 (2012); -2.3 (2013); -3.1 (2014); -2.1 (2015).
- General government gross debt (percent of GDP): 16.1 (2008); 32.3 (2009); 39.8 (2010); 37.5 (2011); 36.5 (2012); 35.2 (2013); 37.8 (2014); 37.7 (2015).
- Unemployment rate (LFS, period average, percent): 7.5 (2008); 16.9 (2009); 18.7 (2010); 16.2 (2011); 15.0 (2012); 11.9 (2013); 10.8 (2014); 10.4 (2015).
- HICP inflation (period average): 15.4 (2008); 3.5 (2009); -1.1 (2010); 4.4 (2011); 2.3 (2012); 0.0 (2013); 0.7 (2014); 0.5 (2015).

*Source — Republic of Latvia, IMF staff report text as provided in the content unit.*

### 1. Russia Linkages ________________________________________________________________________________ 15

### 1. Russia Linkages

### Context
- Latvia has made remarkable economic progress since the financial crisis: the output gap has almost closed; unemployment is now mainly structural; the real effective exchange rate is broadly in line with fundamentals; the current account is close to balance after being more than 20 percent of GDP in deficit before the output collapse; fiscal policy is prudent; public debt is among the lowest in Europe; and the country experienced a smooth entry into the Euro Area.
- Policy continuity likely following parliamentary elections last October as the incumbent center-right coalition remains in power.
- The 2014 Article IV consultation recommended:
  - Gradual fiscal consolidation in line with the Fiscal Discipline Law (FDL).
  - Measures to reduce inequality and strengthen the social safety net.
  - Structural reforms to boost productivity.
  - Close supervision of non-resident deposits (NRDs) in the banking system.
- Policy-making has broadly reflected these recommendations: fiscal policy aligned with the FDL; measures such as raising the minimum non-taxable allowance under the income tax; liberalization of the electricity sector; and continued close supervision of NRD-specialized banks.

### Recent economic developments
- Growth and output:
  - GDP growth fell from 4.2 percent in 2013 to an estimated 2.4 percent in 2014, reflecting the prolonged closure of Liepajas Metalurgs (LM) and weak performance in the Euro Area (EA) and Russia amid rising geopolitical tensions.
  - Despite the decline, Latvia’s GDP growth remained above the Euro Area average of 0.9 percent.
  - The direct impact of the Russia-Ukraine conflict, including sanctions, is estimated to be relatively small to date.
  - The current account deficit widened slightly to about 3 percent of GDP.
- Demand composition:
  - Private consumption growth was 2.3 percent in 2014, down from 6.3 percent in 2013.
  - Gross fixed investment increased by 1.6 percent in 2014, following a 5.2 percent contraction in 2013.
  - Controversy over proposed insolvency law amendments likely contributed to domestic uncertainty.
  - Exports remained subdued due to weak trading partners and the full-year impact of LM’s closure; ruble depreciation against the euro negatively affected export receipts, especially in Q4.
- Labor market and wages:
  - Real wages increased 6.3 percent in 2014, driven by a higher minimum wage (320 euros per month, up from 280 euros) and competition for higher skilled workers.
  - Unemployment rate declined to about 10.5 percent in December 2014, down from 11.3 percent a year earlier; participation rate stayed constant.
  - Rapid wage growth likely reflects improved tax compliance and reduced under-the-table wages.
- Inflation:
  - Headline inflation averaged 0.7 percent in 2014, after zero price growth in 2013.
  - Core inflation rose to 1.5 percent in 2014 (from 0.2 percent in 2013); core inflation in the Euro Area was 0.7 percent in 2014.
  - Declining food and energy prices constrained headline inflation.
- Banking and financial sector:
  - Bank profitability improved; overall NPL ratio declined to 6.8 percent in December 2014 from 8.3 percent a year earlier.
  - Stock of bank credit to the private sector declined by about 7.6 percent (y-on-y) in December 2014.
  - Issuance of new loans decreased in 2014; deleveraging continued with repatriation of funds to parent banks.
  - Asset prices gradually recovered but stock and property prices remain well below pre-crisis levels.
- Non-resident deposits (NRDs):
  - Little evidence that geopolitical tensions disrupted NRD flows; NRD growth stable in 2014 and accelerated slightly toward year-end.
  - Excluding exchange rate effects, stock of NRDs increased by 14 percent year-on-year in December 2014, broadly in line with the three-year average.
- Fiscal developments:
  - General government deficit widened by about ½ percentage point to around 1.4 percent of GDP in 2014, exceeding the nominal budget target of 0.9 percent of GDP largely due to a one-off payment related to the sale of Citadele bank.
  - Structural deficit, excluding the one-off cost, estimated to remain just under 1 percent of GDP given the negative output gap and revenue gains from improved tax compliance and higher wages.

### Outlook and risks
- Near-term outlook:
  - Lackluster economic growth expected to continue in 2015 due to anemic external environment, particularly Russia’s sharp slowdown, weighing on exports and investment.
  - Higher disposable income from lower oil prices and robust real wages expected to partly support private consumption.
  - LM has reopened and is gradually ramping up production but is not expected to reach full capacity until the fourth quarter.
  - ECB accommodative stance unlikely to have much direct impact except via a weaker euro and expectations of a stronger Euro Area recovery; abundant domestic liquidity.
  - Inflation expected to fall in 2015 reflecting lower oil prices, while electricity tariff liberalization will exert some upward pressure.
- Medium-term:
  - Annual medium-term growth of around 4 percent is considered achievable conditional on enhanced competitiveness, continued prudent macroeconomic management, sufficient investment (especially in high-multiplier industries), and productivity (TFP) growth.
  - Adverse demographics, including continuing emigration, will tend to reduce the labor force; reforms to reduce high structural unemployment necessary to maintain employment.
- Key risks (Risk Assessment Matrix):
  - Prolonged slowdown in Russia and the Euro Area could further dampen confidence and thwart recovery.
  - Further escalation of sanctions and counter-sanctions could disrupt trade settlements.
  - A sharp supply-driven rise in oil prices would remove a near-term support to disposable income and growth.
  - Resurgent sovereign stress (e.g., from Greece) could raise Latvia’s bond yields.
  - Failure to implement structural reforms could impede productivity growth and competitiveness; external assessment shows some signs of eroding competitiveness due to rising unit labor costs.
  - External assessment indicates vulnerability to a severe growth or current account shock that could reverse projected medium-term decline in debt-to-GDP ratio.
- Authorities’ view:
  - Authorities broadly concurred with risks but noted Latvia’s low public debt and sound fundamentals make sovereign market rationing unlikely; ratings agencies have repeatedly upgraded the sovereign rating over the last three years.
  - Authorities noted upside risk from a stronger-than-expected Euro Area recovery, partly due to ECB unconventional policies.

### Policy discussions — A. Fiscal Policy
- 2015 budget stance:
  - Broadly neutral.
  - Personal income tax (PIT) rate cut of 1 percentage point to 23 percent expected to result in an estimated revenue loss of ¼ percent of GDP, to be offset by tax base growth from improved compliance and higher wages (including a further 40 euros increase in the minimum wage) and by a cut in capital spending.
  - Structural deficit target of 1 percent of GDP aligns with the Fiscal Discipline Law (FDL) and balances rebuilding fiscal space with avoiding fiscal drag.
  - Authorities agreed budget should be implemented flexibly per the FDL given external uncertainties; automatic stabilizers should operate fully if growth falls below forecast.
- Social protection and inequality:
  - Staff urged further measures to reduce inequality and strengthen the social safety net: social protection benefits per inhabitant are less than one fifth the EU average and among the lowest in Europe; income inequality is among the highest (e.g., ratio of highest to lowest income quintile).
  - Authorities have taken measures such as the 2014 increase in the non-taxable minimum allowance but more is needed.
  - Staff recommended reversing the 2013 cuts to the Guaranteed Minimum Income (GMI) benefit and its decentralization, in line with a World Bank study.
- Fiscal space and revenue outlook:
  - Current policies (planned PIT cuts, reduced SOE payout ratio, increases in tax allowances, cuts in social contributions) estimated to reduce revenue by over three percentage points of GDP between 2013 and 2017.
  - Staff estimate additional revenue measures equivalent to 0.6 percent of GDP in 2016 and 2017 are needed to safeguard priority investment (public capital expenditure) and social spending.
  - Alternatively, substantial expenditure reductions would be required, but scope is limited given already low public expenditures.
- Potential measures to increase revenue and reduce inequality (staff proposals):
  - Reconsider the PIT rate cut; alternatively expand the non-taxable minimum allowance and introduce gradual phasing-out of the GMI benefit.
  - Expand property tax revenue (currently less than 0.8 percent of GDP) by enabling municipalities to raise the real estate tax rate on high-valued land and buildings above the current 1.5 percent ceiling, alongside cadastral reform to correct valuation discrepancies.
  - Remove the cap on social security contributions (while maintaining the cap on benefits).
  - Combined measures estimated to close the revenue gap under current policies.
- Additional or alternative options:
  - Reduce minimum non-taxable threshold for pensioners and tax allowance for dependents; raise excises on gazoil for agriculture with better-targeted direct support.
  - Increase the corporate income tax (CIT) rate (currently among lowest in the EU).
- Quantified potential measures (Impact on revenue, percent of GDP):
  - Maintain PIT rate at the 2015 rate of 23 percent: 0.21 (2016), 0.20 (2017)
  - Increase property tax rate by 0.5 ppt on buildings and land: 0.22 (2016), 0.22 (2017)
  - Improve cadastral revenue: 0.08 (2016), 0.08 (2017)
  - Reverse ceiling introduced on social contributions for incomes above 48,600: 0.14 (2016), 0.14 (2017)
  - Better-targeted tax allowances (including lower tax allowances for pensioners, lower tax allowances for dependents and elimination of non-taxable threshold for high-income individuals): 0.20 (2016), 0.20 (2017)
  - Increase CIT from current 15 to 16%: 0.10 (2016), 0.10 (2017)
  - Remove excise exemptions on gazoil for agriculture: 0.14 (2016), 0.14 (2017)
  - Total potential impact: 1.1 (2016), 1.1 (2017)
- Memorandum items:
  - Structural deficit: authorities' target: -0.8 (2016), -0.7 (2017)
  - Structural deficit: staff estimate without measures: -1.5 (2016), -1.3 (2017)
  - Gap: -0.6 (2016), -0.6 (2017)
- Authorities’ response on fiscal measures:
  - Recognized need to enhance revenue over the medium term and reduce inequality.
  - Emphasized ongoing measures against the grey economy and agreed property tax revenues could be improved.
  - Not amenable to reversing decentralization and cuts to GMI this year but considering medium-term plans for increasing GMI benefits within an integrated social benefit system defining a minimum combined benefit relative to median wage.
  - Will consider introducing progressive minimum non-taxable thresholds in the future.

_Italic: Source — Republic of Latvia, IMF staff report text as provided in the content unit._

### 18.      Latvia’s three largest banks comfortably passed the ECB’s Comprehensive Assessment.

### 18.      Latvia’s three largest banks comfortably passed the ECB’s Comprehensive Assessment.

### Banking system soundness and recent developments
- The wider banking system is well capitalized and liquid:
  - average CET1 ratio of about 18 percent.
  - liquidity ratio of around 64 percent.
  - regulatory minimum requirements: 8 percent (CET1) and 30 percent (liquidity).
- Citadele, the “good bank” created upon the dissolution of Parex, was sold to a consortium of international investors within the timetable set by DG Competition.
- The sale triggered the exercise of a put-option equivalent to about 0.4 percent of GDP compensating the EBRD for its injection of equity capital in Parex.

### Supervision framework and cooperation
- Banking supervision is now shared between the Latvian regulator (the FCMC) and the SSM.
- The SSM directly supervises Latvia’s three largest banks, which account for about 42 percent of the banking system by assets.
- Joint Supervisory Teams (JSTs) for these banks:
  - led by an ECB official.
  - include Latvian representation.
- Colleges of Supervisors for large banking groups (two subsidiaries of Swedish parent banks among Latvia’s three largest banks):
  - chaired by the Swedish supervisory authorities.
  - include representatives from the ECB.
  - Latvia’s FCMC has observer status.
- Authorities report information sharing and cooperation among these supervisory bodies has so far been good.
- Agreed priority: maintain open communication channels among the ECB, the Swedish regulators and the FCMC, especially when capital and liquidity conditions are less benign.

### Risks from non-resident deposits (NRDs) and mitigation
- NRD exposure:
  - NRDs currently account for about half of the banking sector’s total deposits.
  - over 80 percent of NRDs are estimated to originate from Russia and other CIS countries.
- Risks:
  - NRDs could be vulnerable to a sudden stop or flow reversal.
  - NRDs are covered by the country’s deposit guarantee scheme, representing a significant contingent fiscal liability.
  - Example of contingent liability: bankruptcy of Latvijas Krajbanka in September 2011 required the Deposit Guarantee Fund to pay out about 336 million lats (about 2.2 percent of GDP) to cover insured deposits, of which 200 million lats came from a treasury loan.
- Mitigating factors:
  - NRD banks hold the major share of their assets abroad in liquid instruments such as European and US government securities, and bank deposits.
  - NRD banks are already subject to higher capital and liquidity requirements.
  - FCMC plans to impose a “business model risk” add-on to NRD banks’ contributions to Latvia’s deposit guarantee scheme (ensuring NRD banks pay more into the scheme per dollar of deposits).
- Current evidence and monitoring:
  - To date there are few signs of NRD inflows being impeded due to geopolitical events (see Box 1).
  - Authorities are encouraged to continue strengthening and effectively implementing the AML / CFT framework.
  - The Financial Intelligence Unit has been strengthened with greater budgetary support, expanded staff, more training programs and more sophisticated risk-assessment software, and works with the State Revenue Service and foreign regulators.

### Resuscitating bank credit: causes, policy actions, and needed reforms
- Causes of deleveraging:
  - Debt overhang and uncertain outlook are holding back credit growth and investment.
  - Tightened lending standards; SMEs and low income households face hurdles due to higher perceived risk and lack of collateral.
  - Credit contraction has persisted well past the point when most countries see a resumption of credit growth.
  - Tightening labor market and high real wage growth increase concern that lack of credit is a binding constraint on investment.
- Supply-side constraints:
  - Dominance of Nordic subsidiaries limits domestic levers to encourage credit supply.
  - ECB quantitative easing unlikely to impact lending because Nordic subsidiaries depend on parent banks for funding; parent banks are not liquidity constrained.
  - Subsidiaries report main reason for anemic lending is lack of demand.
  - Reduction in loan books created excess cash holdings that were repatriated to parent banks.
- Policy measures taken:
  - Single Development Institute (SDI) introduced programs to catalyze private bank lending, including loan guarantee schemes and subordinated loans to reduce lenders’ credit risk.
  - Efforts to develop credit bureaus to standardize borrowers’ credit-related information.
- Staff encouragement and cautions:
  - Staff encouraged SDI initiatives, while noting care is needed to ensure SDI addresses market failures rather than supporting unviable businesses.
- Insolvency and judicial reforms to boost credit:
  - Earlier legal amendments strengthened the insolvency regime, but administration and implementation could be further improved.
  - Banks report insolvency procedures can be lengthy and insolvency administrators obstructive.
  - Planned or implemented measures to reduce backlog: increase in number of courts, better specialization and allocation of judges.
  - A new law makes insolvency administrators state officials subject to greater income disclosure and stricter supervision.
  - Reforms underway to encourage mediation or arbitration as alternatives to regular court procedures.
- Mortgage-law amendments and compromise:
  - Recent amendments limited liability of mortgage borrowers to collateral and reduced the discharge period for debtors from 3.5 years to 1 year after declaring insolvency.
  - Amendments did not apply retroactively but created uncertainty and prompted some banks to charge higher mortgage down payments and ration credit to low-income households and households outside major cities.
  - Compromise requires banks to offer customers a choice between a “regular” mortgage and a limited-recourse mortgage (which can be priced differently); staff welcomed this compromise.

### Structural reforms to support competitiveness and productivity
- Main medium-term challenge: maintain competitiveness within the Euro Area currency union.
- Growth targets and constraints:
  - Medium-term growth of around 4 percent should be feasible, but adverse demographic trends exert a downward pull on growth.
  - Robust growth depends on reforms to reduce still-high structural unemployment, and on boosting capital accumulation and labor productivity.
- Minimum wage guidance:
  - Large increases to the minimum wage in 2014 and 2015; staff recommended future increases should not exceed productivity growth.
- Labor market reforms:
  - Implement in-work tax credits and benefits to improve work incentives for lower skilled workers.
  - Strengthen Active Labor Market Policies (ALMPs); coverage ratio improved from 42 percent in 2012 to 62 percent in 2014.
  - Continue projects targeted at segments of the unemployed, including active ageing and measures to improve internal mobility.
- Infrastructure and SOE governance:
  - Upgrading public infrastructure could help attract FDI and technological knowhow.
  - Ports (Riga and Ventspils) remain overly dependent on low-value added bulk traffic and face strong competition.
  - Staff urged speedy implementation of World Bank study recommendations on ports: increase capacity, enhance connectivity to land transport, improve governance and accountability.
  - Centralizing SOE management and divesting non-core activities would improve efficiency and accountability.
  - Authorities passed a framework law in October 2014 to strengthen SOE governance: require a centralized SOE manager, re-introduce independent boards and annual reporting for largest SOEs.
- Education reforms:
  - Higher and vocational education reforms to reduce skills mismatches and structural unemployment:
    - quality-based accreditation of study fields.
    - consolidation of higher education institutions.
    - better targeting of public funds to universities (shifting resources from social sciences to STEM fields).
    - new financing model for higher education prepared with World Bank experts to reward quality.
    - expand vocational training from a pilot program of 6 institutions to a wider base, include a council of social partners and sector experts.
  - Authorities agreed unwavering implementation of the education reform agenda is crucial.

### Staff appraisal: outlook, risks, and recommendations
- Near-term growth outlook:
  - GDP growth is estimated to have decelerated to about 2.4 percent in 2014.
  - In 2015 the anemic external environment—particularly the sharp recession in Russia—will continue to weigh on exports and investment, somewhat mitigated by lower oil prices, robust real wages, the reopening of LM, and the accommodative stance of the ECB.
- Medium-term prospects:
  - Medium-term growth of around 4 percent should be feasible but not guaranteed; demographic trends and structural issues pose risks.
- Fiscal policy guidance:
  - The 2015 budget is broadly appropriate, but fiscal space needs to be built up over the medium-term.
  - Automatic stabilizers should be allowed to operate fully in the weak external environment.
  - To increase the revenue envelope, staff suggested reconsidering future PIT rate cuts, greater land taxation with cadastre reform, removal of the cap on social security contributions, and better targeting of a number of tax allowances.
  - Complementary focus: shrink the grey economy through better tax compliance.
- Credit and insolvency recommendations:
  - Staff supports public sector initiatives to catalyze SME lending: loan guarantees, subordinated positions, development of credit bureaus.
  - Reforms to insolvency procedures and the court system are needed to encourage writedowns and accelerate reduction in private sector debt.
- NRD supervision and AML/CFT:
  - So far no significant disruptions to NRD flows from geopolitical tensions, but vigilant supervision of NRD banks is essential (NRD banks account for almost half of all deposits).
  - Continue strengthening and effectively implementing AML/CFT framework.
  - Minimum capital and liquidity requirements are higher for NRD banks; authorities plan proportionately higher contributions to the deposit guarantee fund from NRDs.
- Competitiveness and structural policies:
  - Future minimum wage increases should not exceed productivity growth.
  - Reforms needed in labor markets, higher and vocational education, infrastructure, and SOE management to support productivity growth.
- Administrative note:
  - Staff recommends that the next Article IV consultation be held on the standard 12-month cycle.

*Source: IMF staff report excerpt — “Latvia’s three largest banks comfortably passed the ECB’s Comprehensive Assessment.”*

### 4.5 percent in 2012–13. This is consistent with strong NRD inflows, suggesting that the incentives of Russian

### Republic of Latvia: External Sector Assessment (Box 2)

### Exchange rate assessment (CGER and ERER)
- Macroeconomic imbalances of the pre-crisis period have been largely addressed; the current account is close to balance.
- Model-based assessments suggest the exchange rate is broadly in line with fundamentals, but the substantial competitiveness gains from correcting an overvalued real exchange rate have been exhausted.
- Exchange rate assessments based on CGER methodologies conclude that the REER is broadly in line with fundamentals.
- The ES and MB approaches indicate that Latvia’s REER is close to equilibrium; the ERER points to a higher misalignment, showing a moderate overvaluation.
- Quoted table entries (as presented):
  - ApproachNormUnderlyingEquilibriumActualMisalignment
  - External Sustainability-3.5-2.2......-2.6
  - Macroeconomic Balance-2.8-2.2......-1.2
  - Equilibrium Real Exchange Rate......4.95.010.3
- A positive number indicates overvaluation.

### EBA-lite methodology findings
- The EBA-lite methodology concludes that Latvia’s policies are broadly appropriate, but finds an unrealistically large real exchange rate undervaluation.
- Key EBA-lite summary table values (as presented):
  - CA-Actual-3.1%
  - CA-Fitted-4.5%
  - CA-Norm-5.5%
  - Residual1.4%
  - CA-Gap2.4%
  - Policy gap1.0%
  - Elasticity -0.36
  - Real Exchange Rate Gap-6.5%
  - Cyclical Contributions-0.6%
  - Cyclically adjusted CA-2.5%
  - Cyclically adjusted CA Norm-4.9%
- Caution: the EBA-lite result (CA norm of -5.5 percent of GDP) is inconsistent with Latvia’s still high negative net international investment position and may not capture the specifics of Latvia’s experience (pre-crisis overheating, subsequent collapse in output and demand, and large internal devaluation).

### Competitiveness, exports, and productivity
- REER time-series indicate very substantial gains in competitiveness since the crisis, but recent developments are mixed:
  - The HICP-based REER has appreciated modestly by 2.5 percent since 2013, reflecting NEER appreciation partly mitigated by a decline in Latvia’s HICP relative to main trading partners.
- Real wage growth continued to be strong in 2014; a simple index of export profitability (export deflator / nominal ULCs) shows a continuing decline, suggesting profit margins in Latvia are being squeezed relative to Euro Area countries and more sharply than in other Baltic countries.
- Since the crisis, export growth has been supported by the large internal devaluation; Latvia has diversified its export base in product mix and trade partners.
- External environment risks: weak external environment, notably in Russia and main trading partners in the Euro Area, will pose challenges to export expansion despite mitigating effects from the euro depreciation and the recent drop in oil prices.
- Policy focus recommended: shift to generating productivity improvements that consistently exceed wage growth, including reforms to upgrade infrastructure, reduce skills mismatches in the labor market, improve work incentives, speed up the judicial process, and reform SOE governance.

### External debt, capital flows, and outlook
- External debt increased slightly in 2014 owing to government Eurobond issuances and exchange rate developments but remains contained.
- The government issued 2 billion of Eurobonds in 2014 partly to amortize European Commission loans.
- The euro value of dollar-denominated debt is estimated at 39.4 percent of GDP or 28.1 percent of total debt, and has increased following depreciation of the euro against the dollar.
- The largest share of dollar-denominated debt is owed by banks, mostly by NRD-banks; the majority of their assets are held abroad in liquid instruments, and they face restrictions on currency mismatches.
- Over the medium-term external debt is expected to resume its post-crisis downward trend, decreasing by more than 10 percentage points by the end of the projection period.
- Capital flows are expected to be stable and sufficient to cover the modest current account deficit, as they have been for the past few years. Main components of capital flows: government bond issuances, Nordic parent bank funding, and NRDs.

### Export composition and partner growth
- Export shares (percent of total exports, based on exports of goods in 2013):
  - Euro Area, 47%
  - Russia, 16%
  - Poland, 7%
  - Sweden, 5%
  - Denmark, 4%
  - United Kingdom, 3%
  - Norway, 2%
  - Belarus, 2%
  - Other, 14%
- Real GDP Growth in Main Trading Partners, 2014-15 (charted): Euro Area, Russia, Poland, Sweden, Denmark, United Kingdom, Norway, Belarus (percent).

*Source: IMF staff estimates as presented in Box 2, "Republic of Latvia: External Sector Assessment."*

### Box 3. Republic of Latvia: Risk Assessment Matrix

### Box 3. Republic of Latvia: Risk Assessment Matrix

### Side-effects from global financial conditions
- Risk description: A surge in financial volatility: As investors reassess underlying risk and move to safe-haven assets given slow and uneven growth as well as asymmetric monetary exit, with poor market liquidity amplifying the effect on volatility.
- Relative Likelihood: High
- Impact if Realized: Low/Medium
- Impact details:
  - Could lower funding for Nordic parent banks reliant on wholesale funding, further hindering credit growth.

### Protracted period of slower growth in advanced and emerging economies
- Risk description:
  - Euro Area and Japan: Weak demand and persistently low inflation from a failure to fully address crisis legacies and appropriately calibrate macro policies, leading to “new mediocre” rate of growth.
  - Emerging markets: Maturing of the cycle, misallocation of investment, and incomplete structural reforms leading to prolonged slower growth.
- Relative Likelihood: High
- Impact if Realized: Medium / High
- Impact details:
  - The Euro Area remains Latvia’s single largest trade partner, while Russia and other CIS countries are also significant export destinations.
  - A protracted slowdown would have a direct impact on exports while also eroding business and consumer confidence.

### Geopolitical fragmentation that erodes the globalization process and fosters inefficiency
- Risk description:
  - Russia/Ukraine: The mounting conflict depresses business confidence and heightens risk aversion, amid disturbances in global financial, trade and commodity markets.
  - Heightened risk of fragmentation/state failure/security dislocation in the Middle East and some countries in Africa, leading to a sharp rise in oil prices, with negative global spillovers.
- Relative Likelihood: Medium
- Impact if Realized: Medium / High
- Impact details:
  - Escalating sanctions/countersanctions could threaten other sectors of the Latvian economy (apart from food exports, which are already sanctioned).
  - Non-resident deposits (NRDs) could be susceptible to sudden stops or reversals in case of a sufficiently large shock.
  - A sharp supply-driven rise in oil prices would remove an important factor supporting projected growth, especially in the near-term.

### Bond market stress from a reassessment in sovereign risk
- Risk description: Euro Area: Sovereign stress re-emerges due to policy uncertainty, faltering reforms, and political and social upheaval, particularly in Greece.
- Relative Likelihood: Medium
- Impact if Realized: Medium
- Impact details:
  - A rise in sovereign spreads would raise the price of external financing, but is unlikely to cause credit to be rationed, given the lack of macroeconomic imbalances and low public debt.

### Failure to advance on structural reforms
- Risk description: Failure to advance on structural reforms.
- Relative Likelihood: Medium
- Impact if Realized: High
- Impact details:
  - In the absence of structural reforms productivity growth and the business environment would suffer, harming competitiveness and employment.

### Notes on the Risk Assessment Matrix (RAM)
- The Risk Assessment Matrix (RAM) shows events that could materially alter the baseline path (the scenario most likely to materialize in the view of IMF staff).
- The relative likelihood is the staff’s subjective assessment of the risks surrounding the baseline (“low” is meant to indicate a probability below 10 percent, “medium” a probability between 10 and 30 percent, and “high” a probability between 30 and 50 percent).
- The RAM reflects staff views on the source of risks and overall level of concern as of the time of discussions with the authorities.
- Non-mutually exclusive risks may interact and materialize jointly.

*Source: Box 3. Republic of Latvia: Risk Assessment Matrix (IMF staff).*

### Annex II. External Debt

### _cr15110 - Annex II. External Debt

### Debt sustainability baseline and projections (2009–2019)
- Baseline: External debt (percent of GDP): 154.7 (2009); 165.8 (2010); 145.8 (2011); 137.2 (2012); 131.3 (2013); 138.7 (2014); 132.6 (2015); 135.0 (2016); 131.1 (2017); 129.1 (2018); 126.9 (2019).
- Debt-stabilizing non-interest current account 6/: -7.5.
- Change in external debt (percentage points of GDP): 32.7 (2009); 11.1 (2010); -20.0 (2011); -8.6 (2012); -5.9 (2013); 7.3 (2014); -6.1 (2015); 2.4 (2016); -3.9 (2017); -2.0 (2018); -2.2 (2019).
- Identified external debt-creating flows (4+8+9) (percentage points of GDP): 38.7 (2009); 10.7 (2010); -25.4 (2011); 0.6 (2012); -11.0 (2013); -1.7 (2014); -3.4 (2015); -3.3 (2016); -4.2 (2017); -4.9 (2018); -5.4 (2019).
- Current account deficit, excluding interest payments (percent of GDP): -16.5 (2009); -8.4 (2010); -2.4 (2011); -1.0 (2012); -0.8 (2013); 0.1 (2014); -1.1 (2015); -0.3 (2016); -0.5 (2017); -0.8 (2018); -0.8 (2019).
- Deficit in balance of goods and services (percent of GDP): 0.5 (2009); 1.0 (2010); 4.7 (2011); 4.3 (2012); 3.3 (2013); 2.9 (2014); 2.1 (2015); 3.6 (2016); 3.5 (2017); 3.2 (2018); 3.1 (2019).
- Exports (percent of GDP): 43.2 (2009); 53.4 (2010); 58.0 (2011); 60.8 (2012); 59.0 (2013); 58.0 (2014); 56.1 (2015); 55.7 (2016); 56.0 (2017); 56.2 (2018); 56.2 (2019).
- Imports (percent of GDP): 43.7 (2009); 54.5 (2010); 62.7 (2011); 65.1 (2012); 62.3 (2013); 60.9 (2014); 58.2 (2015); 59.2 (2016); 59.5 (2017); 59.4 (2018); 59.3 (2019).
- Net non-debt creating capital inflows (negative, percent of GDP): 2.2 (2009); -1.1 (2010); -3.9 (2011); -2.2 (2012); -2.2 (2013); -1.8 (2014); -2.0 (2015); -1.9 (2016); -2.2 (2017); -2.5 (2018); -2.9 (2019).
- Automatic debt dynamics 1/ (percent of GDP): 53.0 (2009); 20.3 (2010); -19.0 (2011); 3.8 (2012); -8.0 (2013); 0.0 (2014); -0.2 (2015); -1.1 (2016); -1.5 (2017); -1.6 (2018); -1.7 (2019).
  - Contribution from nominal interest rate (percentage points): 8.5 (2009); 6.1 (2010); 5.3 (2011); 4.3 (2012); 3.1 (2013); 3.0 (2014); 3.1 (2015); 3.1 (2016); 3.2 (2017); 3.1 (2018); 3.1 (2019).
  - Contribution from real GDP growth (percentage points): 23.6 (2009); 4.9 (2010); -7.1 (2011); -7.0 (2012); -5.3 (2013); -3.0 (2014); -3.4 (2015); -4.2 (2016); -4.7 (2017); -4.7 (2018); -4.7 (2019).
  - Contribution from price and exchange rate changes 2/: 2.0 (2009); 9.3 (2010); -17.2 (2011); 6.5 (2012); -5.8 (2013); .................. (2014 onward note: see table for projection inclusion).
- Residual, incl. change in gross foreign assets (2-3) 3/ (percent of GDP): -5.9 (2009); 0.4 (2010); 5.4 (2011); -9.2 (2012); 5.1 (2013); 9.0 (2014); -2.8 (2015); 5.8 (2016); 0.3 (2017); 2.9 (2018); 3.2 (2019).
- External debt-to-exports ratio (percent): 357.9 (2009); 310.3 (2010); 251.5 (2011); 225.6 (2012); 222.5 (2013); 239.0 (2014); 236.2 (2015); 242.6 (2016); 234.0 (2017); 229.8 (2018); 225.6 (2019).
- Gross external financing need (in billions of US dollars) 4/: 18.8 (2009); 19.7 (2010); 20.4 (2011); 20.0 (2012); 22.2 (2013); 22.8 (2014); 22.0 (2015); 21.4 (2016); 23.7 (2017); 24.3 (2018); 25.9 (2019).
- Gross external financing need (in percent of GDP): 71.6; 81.7; 72.3; 70.6; 71.9; 10-Year; 10-Year; 71.2; 73.1; 67.5; 69.7; 66.7; 66.2 (table shows multiple decade-related labels; see original for context).
- Scenario with key variables at their historical averages 5/: 138.7 (2009); 116.8 (2010); 115.9 (2011); 111.8 (2012); 109.9 (2013); 107.6 (2014); -8.9 (projection footnote indicates long-run behavior).

### Key macroeconomic assumptions underlying the baseline
- Real GDP growth (percent): -14.2 (2009); -2.9 (2010); 5.0 (2011); 4.8 (2012); 4.2 (2013); 3.4 (2014); 8.0 (2015); 2.4 (2016); 2.3 (2017); 3.3 (2018); 3.7 (2019); 3.9 (2020? table continues).
- GDP deflator in US dollars (change in percent): -14.6 (2009); -5.7 (2010); 11.6 (2011); -4.3 (2012); 4.4 (2013); 8.5 (2014); 13.7 (2015); 1.3 (2016); -8.1 (2017); 2.1 (2018); 3.3 (2019); 4.3 (2020?).
- Nominal external interest rate (in percent): 5.1 (2009); 3.6 (2010); 3.7 (2011); 2.9 (2012); 2.5 (2013); 4.7 (2014); 2.6 (2015); 2.4 (2016); 2.1 (2017); 2.5 (2018); 2.5 (2019); 2.6 (2020?).
- Growth of exports (US dollar terms, percent): -21.3 (2009); 13.2 (2010); 27.2 (2011); 5.3 (2012); 5.6 (2013); 18.2 (2014); 18.8 (2015); 1.9 (2016); -9.1 (2017); 4.6 (2018); 7.8 (2019); 7.8 (2020?); 7.2 (subsequent).
- Growth of imports (US dollar terms, percent): -38.1 (2009); 14.1 (2010); 34.9 (2011); 4.9 (2012); 4.1 (2013); 4.2 (2014); 71.0 (2015); 172.9 (2016); 1.3 (2017); -10.1 (2018); 7.3 (2019); 7.6 (2020?); 7.4; 6.9.
- Current account balance, excluding interest payments (percent of GDP): 16.5 (2009); 8.4 (2010); 2.4 (2011); 1.0 (2012); 0.8 (2013); -2.5 (2014); 11.1 (2015); -0.1 (2016); 1.1 (2017); 0.3 (2018); 0.5 (2019); 0.8 (subsequent).
- Net non-debt creating capital inflows (percent of GDP): -2.2 (2009); 1.1 (2010); 3.9 (2011); 2.2 (2012); 2.2 (2013); 2.4 (2014); 2.2 (2015); 1.8 (2016); 2.0 (2017); 1.9 (2018); 2.2 (2019); 2.5; 2.9.

Notes from technical footnotes:
- 1/ Automatic debt dynamics derived as [r - g - r(1+g) + ea(1+r)]/(1+g+r+gr) times previous period debt stock, with r = nominal effective interest rate on external debt; r = change in domestic GDP deflator in US dollar terms, g = real GDP growth rate, e = nominal appreciation (increase in dollar value of domestic currency), and a = share of domestic-currency denominated debt in total external debt.
- 2/ Contribution from price and exchange rate changes defined as [-r(1+g) + ea(1+r)]/(1+g+r+gr) times previous period debt stock. r increases with an appreciating domestic currency (e > 0) and rising inflation (based on GDP deflator).
- 3/ For projection, line includes the impact of price and exchange rate changes.
- 4/ Gross external financing need defined as current account deficit, plus amortization on medium- and long-term debt, plus short-term debt at end of previous period.
- 5/ Key variables in historical-average scenario: real GDP growth; nominal interest rate; dollar deflator growth; and both non-interest current account and non-debt inflows in percent of GDP.
- 6/ Long-run constant balance that stabilizes the debt ratio assuming key variables remain at levels of the last projection year.

### Bound tests and shock scenarios (summary)
- The Annex presents External Debt Sustainability: Bound Tests with scenarios including:
  - Interest rate shock (permanent one-half standard deviation shocks; i-rate shock figures shown in chart boxes).
  - Current account shock (CA shock).
  - Combined shock (growth, interest, current account combined; combined shock figures shown).
  - Nominal depreciation shock (one-time nominal depreciation of 30 percent occurs in 2010).
  - Growth shock (per-year percent shocks).
- Representative baseline and scenario average projections shown (baseline external debt percent of GDP: 127 in chart context; historical and scenario box averages reported in figure captions).
- Gross financing need under baseline reported on right scale in charts; scenarios compare baseline vs shocks over 2009–2019.

### Key findings, developments, and risks (from staff appraisal and press release)
- Short-term developments:
  - GDP growth decelerated to 2.4 percent in 2014.
  - Low food and energy prices held consumer price inflation around 0.7 percent despite rising real wages.
  - The 2014 general government deficit was about 1.4 percent of GDP, higher than expected mainly due to a one-off payment related to the sale of Citadele bank.
  - Bank balance sheets continued to strengthen: profitability increased and the ratio of non-performing loans declined, but credit continued to contract.
  - Growth of non-resident deposits (NRDs) in the banking system was stable.
- Near-term outlook and risks:
  - In 2015, the weak external environment, particularly the sharp slowdown in Russia, will weigh on exports and investment.
  - Mitigating factors include higher disposable income due to lower oil prices, robust real wages, the reopening of the steel manufacturer (Liepajas Metalurgs), and the accommodative stance of the ECB.
  - Over time, growth would rise to around 4 percent (medium-term target).
  - Downside risks: prolonged slowdown in Russia and the euro area; adverse demographic trends dragging on medium-term growth.

### Policy recommendations and priorities (from staff and Executive Board assessment)
- Fiscal policy:
  - Allow automatic stabilizers to operate fully in the near term given the weak and uncertain external environment.
  - Build fiscal space over the medium term.
  - Explore ways to increase the revenue envelope, for example:
    - Reconsider future personal income tax (PIT) rate cuts.
    - Greater land taxation in conjunction with cadastre reform.
    - Removal of the cap on social security contributions.
    - Better targeting of a number of tax allowances.
  - Continue efforts to shrink the grey economy through better tax compliance.
- Financial sector and credit:
  - Support recent public sector initiatives to catalyze SME lending, including by providing loan guarantees, taking subordinated positions and encouraging the development of credit bureaus.
  - Reforms to insolvency procedures and the court system to encourage writedowns and accelerate reduction in private sector debt.
  - Maintain vigilant supervision of NRD banks, which account for almost half of all deposits in the banking system.
  - Continue strengthening and effectively implementing the AML/CFT framework; Financial Intelligence Unit has been strengthened.
  - Maintain higher minimum capital and liquidity requirements for NRD banks; plan to impose proportionately higher contributions by NRDs to the deposit guarantee fund.
- Competitiveness and structural reforms:
  - Maintain competitiveness within the euro area currency union.
  - Future increases to the minimum wage should not exceed productivity growth.
  - To close the income gap with the rest of the euro area, support productivity growth via reforms in labor markets, higher and vocational education, infrastructure, and SOE management.

### Selected national macro-financial indicators (highlights, 2008–2015)
- Real GDP (percent change): -3.2 (2008); -14.2 (2009); -2.9 (2010); 5.0 (2011); 4.8 (2012); 4.2 (2013); 2.4 (2014); 2.3 (2015 Est./Proj.).
- Private consumption (percent change): -8.0 (2008); -16.2 (2009); 3.1 (2010); 2.9 (2011); 3.0 (2012); 6.2 (2013); 2.3 (2014); 2.9 (2015).
- Gross external debt (percent of GDP): 122.0 (2008); 154.7 (2009); 165.8 (2010); 145.8 (2011); 137.2 (2012); 131.3 (2013); 138.7 (2014); 132.6 (2015).
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): -12.3 (2008); 8.0 (2009); 2.3 (2010); -2.8 (2011); -3.3 (2012); -2.3 (2013); -3.1 (2014); -2.1 (2015).
- General government gross debt (percent of GDP): 16.1 (2008); 32.3 (2009); 39.8 (2010); 37.5 (2011); 36.5 (2012); 35.2 (2013); 37.8 (2014); 37.7 (2015).
- Unemployment rate (LFS, period average, percent): 7.5 (2008); 16.9 (2009); 18.7 (2010); 16.2 (2011); 15.0 (2012); 11.9 (2013); 10.8 (2014); 10.4 (2015).
- HICP inflation (period average): 15.4 (2008); 3.5 (2009); -1.1 (2010); 4.4 (2011); 2.3 (2012); 0.0 (2013); 0.7 (2014); 0.5 (2015).

*Source: IMF staff report annex tables and press release contained in _cr15110 - Annex II. External Debt.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/_cr15110.pdf_
