## _cr15157 — Staff Report and MEFP Summary (Haiti, May 2015)

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr15157 — Staff Report and MEFP Summary (Haiti, May 2015)](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/_cr15157.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/_cr15157.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/_cr15157.pdf.json)

---

### Program request and objectives
- Authorities request a three-year arrangement under the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) in an amount equivalent to SDR 49.14 million (60 percent of quota).
- Proposed duration and access:
  - 3-year arrangement (May 2015–May 2018).
  - Access: 60 percent of quota divided in seven equal tranches.
  - Immediate disbursement upon approval: SDR 7.02 million.
- Overarching objective: boost Haiti’s long-term growth potential and reduce poverty while maintaining macroeconomic stability.

### Growth projections and macroeconomic framework
- Official growth projections cited:
  - 3.25 percent for growth in FY2016.
  - Range of 3.5-4.0 percent and a point projection of 3.75 percent for FY2017-FY2019.
- Staff/medium-term framework assumptions (2015–2035):
  - Average per-capita GDP growth: 2.2 percent.
  - Projected average real GDP growth rate: 3.4 percent.
  - Population growth: 1.2 percent.
- GDP growth projections elsewhere in the report:
  - Projected at 2–3 percent in FY2015.
  - Expected to pick up to 3–4 percent in the medium term as structural reforms proceed.
  - FY2016–FY2018 GDP growth expected to average about 3.5 percent (alternate statement).

### Recent performance and vulnerabilities (selected)
- Growth and poverty:
  - Haiti achieved its fourth consecutive year of real per capita growth in FY2014; GDP growth in FY2014 was 2.7 percent.
  - Excluding agriculture, growth has been steady at about 4 percent since FY2011.
  - Per-capita income growth since 2010 has not meaningfully reduced poverty.
- Fiscal and external positions:
  - Central government deficit increased to 6–7 percent of GDP during FY2013–FY2014.
  - Petrocaribe inflows averaged 4 percent of GDP during FY2009–FY2014 and financed fiscal and current account deficits; these flows decreased sharply in FY2015.
  - External public debt rose to 21 percent of GDP in FY2014 (from 9 percent in FY2011).
  - Domestic public debt around 4 percent of GDP in FY2014.
- Energy sector and fiscal cost:
  - EDH (state-owned electricity company) deficit (before CG transfers) increased to 2.5 percent of GDP in FY2014.
  - Domestic fuel prices frozen March 2011–October 2014; foregone tax revenues peaked at about 2 percent of GDP in FY2014.
  - Combined fiscal cost of fuel subsidies and EDH’s deficit exceeded social spending (social spending hovered around 3–4 percent of GDP since FY2010).
- Monetary and reserves:
  - BRH aimed for gourde depreciation typically 3–4 percent per year; allowed gourde to depreciate about 6 percent y/y through March 2015.
  - International reserves declined to below 5 months of imports by February 2015; staff suggest reserves equivalent to 4–5 months of prospective imports appropriate.

### Fiscal strategy and consolidation path
- Fiscal objective: cut central government deficit from 6¼ percent of GDP in FY2014 to about 2 percent of GDP in FY2018.
- NFPS deficit trajectory (program anchor):
  - About 7½ percent of GDP in FY2014.
  - Decrease to 3¼ percent in FY2015.
  - Decline to less than 2½ percent in FY2016−FY2018.
- FY2015 program (selected figures and measures):
  - Central government revised FY2015 budget consistent with a deficit of 2.7 percent of GDP (prior action).
  - Central Government revenue to increase to 14.7 percent of GDP in FY2015 given elimination of fuel subsidies and locked-in windfall revenue.
  - Wage bill increases of 1 percent of GDP (reclassification of transfers and increases for teachers and national police).
  - EDH revised FY2015 budget adopted with savings of about 0.7 percent of GDP from reductions in production costs and improvements in billing and collection at unchanged tariffs (prior action).
- Selected 2015 fiscal table excerpt (as presented; percent of GDP or amounts where indicated):
  - 2015 Nonfinancial public sector (I + II) 4.2
  - Central government (I) 3.7
  - Revenue and budget support 1.6
  - Budget support -0.4
  - Fuel taxes 1.5
  - Fuel price increase 0.2
  - Locked-in windfall revenue 1.3
  - Administrative measures (incl. vehicle tags) 0.3
  - Expenditure -2.1
  - Transfers to electricy sector 1/ -0.5
  - Non-electricity transfers 2/ -0.4
  - Transfers to municipalities for street lighting 0.2
  - Mitigating measures for fuel price increases 0.1
  - Wage bill 2/ 1.0
  - Petrocaribe-funded investment -1.5
  - Exceptional post-Sandy investment -1.0
  - EDH deficit (after transfers) (II) 0.5

### Automatic Fuel Price Mechanism (APM) and fuel policy
- APM commitments and features:
  - Implement an APM before the end of FY2015 to pass-through international prices into domestic retail prices and protect fiscal revenues.
  - APM will include a smoothing mechanism allowing for additional (forgone) revenues up to G 1 billion (0.2 percent of GDP).
  - International prices fully passed-through whenever additional (forgone) revenues reach G 1 billion in absolute terms.
  - Authorities committed to revise the price structure to reflect actual imported prices (instead of “Caribbean posting” quotes).
- Mitigating measures:
  - Planned well-targeted measures (e.g., social tariff for public transportation) with World Bank assistance.
  - Planned fiscal cost of direct subsidy estimated at 0.2–0.3 percent of GDP versus blanket subsidies cost in FY2014 of about 2 percent.
- Stabilization margin and storage:
  - Theoretical value of the stabilization margin at mid-March 2015 was minus G 27 million as of March 2015.
  - Installed storage capacity estimated at 365,000 barrels (equivalent of three weeks of national consumption).

### Electricity sector (EDH): reforms and fiscal implications
- Program measures and benchmarks:
  - Signature of an EDH protocol by end-June 2015 (structural benchmark / prior action) to lay out stakeholder obligations to improve sector performance.
  - Audit of the 200 largest clients and analysis on EDH tariff determination — completion by end-March 2016 (structural benchmark).
  - For FY2015, lower international oil prices plus measures to raise the cash recovery index by about 4 percentage points allow adoption of a revised EDH budget with savings of at least G 3.4 billion (prior action), reducing EDH deficit before transfers from 2.5 percent of GDP to 1.7 percent of GDP.
- Policy aim: achieve a financially viable electricity sector to attract investment, increase supply, and lower generation costs—leading to productivity gains and reduced fiscal vulnerabilities.

### Revenue mobilization and tax reform
- Key actions and timeline:
  - Eliminate remaining fuel subsidies to yield 1.5–1.6 percent of GDP in FY2015.
  - Multi-year investment in revenue administration to increase domestic revenue to 15.5 percent of GDP by FY2019.
  - Continue work towards VAT implementation and a new mining code.
  - Working group to produce a draft of the tax code by end-July 2015 (structural benchmark); preliminary draft by end-July 2016.
  - Transfer files of medium taxpayers from LTO/local offices to MTO — to be completed end-August 2015 (structural benchmark).
  - Implement program to ensure tax compliance of importers with annual turnover above G 10 million not covered by LTO/MTO — End-April 2016.

### Public financial management (TSA) and transparency
- TSA actions and prior actions:
  - Implemented memorandum (December 2014) placing all public accounts at the BRH under control of public accountants; to be applied by BNC (prior action).
  - Continue TSA rollout: conversion of spending accounts into Treasury sub-accounts; establishment of all remaining accounting centers by end-September 2015 (structural benchmark).
  - Budget documents should report special accounts and programs, civil service pensions and future pension liabilities, earmarked resources for municipalities, financial transactions with SOEs (including contingent liabilities) and all Petrocaribe-funded transactions.
- Accounting centers and reporting:
  - Five new accounting centers installed (prior action related items); all remaining centers to be operational by end-September 2015.
  - Training plan for public accountants and budget administrators planned for April 2015.
  - Reporting timetable and frequency specified in TMU for fiscal and monetary data (weekly, monthly, quarterly, annual deadlines preserved verbatim).

### Monetary policy, reserves, and BRH operations
- Reserve and inflation objectives:
  - Target international reserves at 4–5 months of prospective imports.
  - Keep inflation low and stable via moderate exchange rate depreciation and well-anchored expectations.
- Monetary recommendations:
  - Keep monetary policy tight until fiscal deficit is reduced.
  - Prefer open market operations (OMOs) over further increases in legal reserve requirements.
  - Avoid use of exceptions in reserve requirement computation.
  - Consider using 5-year government bonds acquired at end-FY2014 in OMOs; consider issuing dollar-indexed bonds to absorb liquidity (with caution).
  - Strengthen reserve management in line with 2011 safeguards recommendations and IMF TA.
- Programed NIR movements (FY2015 program):
  - After NIR decline of about US$100 million in first half of FY2015, NIR programmed to decline by at most US$50 million in second half of FY2015.
  - Monetary financing limited to drawdown of Post-Catastrophe Debt Relief (PCDR) resources to keep reserves and government deposits as cushions.

### Financial sector and supervision
- Banking sector status and vulnerabilities:
  - Banking sector remains well-capitalized and profitable; regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets around 17.1–18.0 (selected dates).
  - NPLs to gross loans varied (selected readings: 2.4 to 4.6 and 4.3 at Dec-14).
  - Credit remains concentrated in commerce and non-tradable sectors; credit to private sector (percent of GDP) recorded 16.4 (2012/13), 11.2 (2013/14), 4.7 (2014/15).
- Supervisory measures and TA:
  - Staff recommended periodic stress testing; authorities report periodic inspections and will consider stress tests.
  - Authorities allowed banks to renegotiate loans to non-tradable sectors; staff cautioned monitoring to assess capital ratio effects.
  - Authorities to consider withholding dividends or injecting new capital if needed.
- AML/CFT and legal reforms:
  - AML/CFT law adopted late 2013 addressed many CFATF recommendations; remaining reforms (penal code changes) require parliamentary approval.
  - Strengthen FATF standards implementation; adopt UCREF Bill and new Penal and Criminal Investigation Codes (2015–17).

### Debt sustainability (DSA) and medium-term debt outlook
- Public sector debt at end-2014:
  - Total public sector debt: US$2,279 million (24.8 percent of GDP).
  - External debt: US$1,825 million; PetroCaribe debt US$1,573.7 million (86.2 percent of external debt).
  - Domestic public debt about US$230 million.
- DSA baseline projections and key figures:
  - Average real GDP growth (2015-20): 3.4 percent.
  - Public debt projected to grow from about 25 percent of GDP in 2014 to 39 percent of GDP in 2035 (projection tables).
  - Total external public debt (percent of GDP): 17.4, 21.0, 21.8, 22.6, 23.3, 23.8, 24.3 (2012/13–2018/19 projections in Table 6 earlier).
- Risk assessment and scenarios:
  - Haiti’s risk of external debt distress improved from high to moderate under the baseline (mainly due to lower oil prices and some fiscal consolidation).
  - Sudden stop of Petrocaribe flows or a permanent 50 percent rebound in oil prices would materially worsen debt indicators and could return debt distress risk to high.
  - A stop in Petrocaribe financing could reduce GDP growth by about 1 percentage point and create financing gaps of about 1 percent of GDP in FY2015 and 2 percent in FY2016 relative to program projections.
- Policy implication: maintain prudent macroeconomic policies, strengthen PFM and debt management, and lock in fiscal gains from lower oil prices.

### Performance criteria, structural benchmarks, and monitoring (TMU highlights)
- Quantitative performance criteria (QPCs) include ceilings on:
  - Net BRH credit to the NFPS; net domestic assets (NDA) of BRH; deficit of the NFPS; domestic financing of the central government.
- Continuous performance criteria:
  - Zero ceiling on accumulation of public sector external arrears; zero ceiling on contracting/guaranteeing non-concessional external debt.
- Indicative target:
  - Floor for domestically-financed poverty-reducing expenditure (health, education, agriculture).
- Selected quantitative targets and memorandum items (cumulative flows since Sep-2014; amounts preserved exactly where shown in TMU tables):
  - Net central bank credit to the NFPS — ceiling: December 2014 actual 12,330; target to June 2016 up to 10,094 (table entries).
  - Net domestic assets (NDA) — ceiling: December 2014 actual -23,625; targets to June 2016 up to 10,559.
  - Net international reserves (NIR) of BRH (US$ millions) — floor: December 2014 actual 1,010; projected floors include -50, -100, -117, -150, -150, -150, -130 for March 2015–June 2016 (table entries).
  - Deficit of the NFPS — cumulative ceilings: 4,000 (Mar 2015), 8,856 (Jun 2015), 11,242 (Sep 2015), 13,471 (Dec 2015), 16,141 (Mar 2016), 18,810 (Jun 2016).
  - Domestic Financing of Central Government — cumulative ceilings: 1,178 (Mar 2015), 4,854 (Jun 2015), 5,817 (Sep 2015), 6,621 (Dec 2015), 7,232 (Mar 2016), 7,843 (Jun 2016).
  - Indicative poverty-reducing expenditures (floor): March 2015 3,630; June 2015 7,421; Sept 2015 11,345; Dec 2015 15,269; Mar 2016 19,490; Jun 2016 23,889.
- Prior actions (selected):
  - Adoption of a revised central government FY2015 budget consistent with a deficit of at most G 13.5 bn.
  - Adoption of an automatic price mechanism for refined oil products.
  - Implement TSA-related actions in line with TMU ¶35.
  - EDH Board adoption of a revised FY2015 budget consistent with savings of at least G 3.4 bn.
- Structural benchmarks (selected timing preserved):
  - Signature of EDH protocol — End-June 2015.
  - Establish working group to produce a draft tax code — End-July 2015 (preliminary draft by end-July 2016).
  - Transfer medium taxpayers’ files to MTO — End-August 2015.
  - Adoption of FY2016 budgets for Central Government and EDH consistent with NFPS deficit 2.3 percent of GDP — End-September 2015.
  - Establish and make operational all remaining accounting centers — End-September 2015.
  - Interministerial working group to share cadastre action plan — End-February 2016.
  - Audit of 200 largest EDH clients and tariff analysis — End-March 2016.
  - Implement tax compliance program for importers above G 10 million — End-April 2016.
- Adjustment mechanisms:
  - Ceilings and floors may be adjusted if budget support grants are lower than programmed (adjustor rules and caps specified in the TMU, including caps of US$10 million and US$20 million for certain adjustments).

### Risks, contingencies, and sequencing
- Key risks:
  - Complex political situation (parliamentary quorum issues in 2015; elections scheduled in second half of 2015; new President inaugurated February 2016).
  - Rebound in international petroleum prices.
  - Sudden stop in external financing from Venezuela (PetroCaribe).
  - Weather events and other shocks (agriculture >20 percent of GDP vulnerable).
  - Donor fatigue as earthquake rebuilding winds down.
- Contingency measures:
  - Additional donor financing and temporary drawdown of deposits/reserves could offset about half of a PetroCaribe-financing gap in 2015–2016.
  - Authorities identified projects to slow implementation if needed; spending pace to be adjusted in case of a stop.
  - Until ECF approval, current account projections exclude catalyzed multilateral budget support flows.

### Structural reform priorities to support growth and inclusion
- Remove structural bottlenecks: improve business environment, property rights, and governance.
- Improve infrastructure: increase access to cheaper and reliable electricity; address port and road inefficiencies.
- Strengthen financial intermediation: complete credit bureau, promote competition, develop non-bank financial sector (insurance, cooperatives, microfinance), enact pending laws on financial cooperatives and microfinance.
- Social and human capital:
  - Target consistent increases in domestically-financed spending on education, health, and agriculture (indicative target).
  - Prioritize introduction of an overall quarterly economic index and revamp national accounts (with IMF and France TA).
- Tax system modernization:
  - Introduce a full-fledged VAT system targeted for 2017–18 (program objective).
  - Finalize new tax code and eliminate small taxes in 2016–17.

### Monitoring, data, and safeguards
- Detailed reporting timetable for real sector, public finance, monetary, financial, balance of payments, and external debt data specified in TMU (frequencies and lags preserved).
- IMF safeguards and TA:
  - Update safeguards assessment no later than the first review under the new ECF arrangement.
  - Strengthen reserve management, adopt IFRS, appoint compliance officer, and enhance BRH reporting.
- Program implementation monitoring:
  - Committee chaired by Secretary of State for Finance with BRH, EDH, and MEF directorates; work with Fund Resident Representative.

*Source: HAITI — STAFF REPORT FOR THE 2015 ARTICLE IV CONSULTATION AND REQUEST FOR A THREE-YEAR ARRANGEMENT UNDER THE EXTENDED CREDIT FACILITY (May 6, 2015).*

### 3.25 percent for growth in FY2016, and a range of 3.5-4.0 percent and a point projection of 3.75 percent for FY2017-FY20

### _cr15157 - 3.25 percent for growth in FY2016, and a range of 3.5-4.0 percent and a point projection of 3.75 percent for FY2017-FY2019

### Key issues and program request
- Background findings:
  - Haiti completed an ECF arrangement that helped maintain macroeconomic stability after the 2010 earthquake.
  - Haiti has seen four consecutive years of growth, but reducing poverty requires higher and sustained growth rates.
- Article IV discussion priorities:
  - Improve Haiti’s growth potential and external competitiveness.
  - Leverage low international oil prices to reduce vulnerabilities, particularly in the energy sector.
- The authorities’ proposed program focuses on:
  - A front-loaded fiscal adjustment to entrench stability.
  - Institutional reforms, mitigating vulnerabilities, and supporting growth and employment.
  - Structural benchmarks to reduce subsidies, improve public financial management (PFM) and expenditure effectiveness, and create an enabling environment for growth.
- Request for IMF support:
  - The Haitian authorities request a three-year arrangement under the Extended Credit Facility (ECF) in an amount equivalent to SDR 49.14 million (60 percent of quota).

### Growth projections and macro framework
- Official growth projections cited:
  - 3.25 percent for growth in FY2016.
  - A range of 3.5-4.0 percent and a point projection of 3.75 percent for FY2017-FY2019.
- Related notes:
  - A new ECF would catalyze identified multilateral budget support; until approval, current account projections exclude these flows.
  - Debt ratios in tableed analyses differ slightly from the DSA because average exchange rates are used instead of end-of-period exchange rates.
  - Reserves definitions: includes SDR allocation as both an asset and liability; includes gold and transactions related to BRH repurchase operations; corresponds to BPM6 definition of reserves.

### Recent performance, vulnerabilities, and diagnostics
- Growth and poverty:
  - Haiti achieved its fourth consecutive year of real per capita growth in FY2014; GDP growth in FY2014 was 2.7 percent (down from FY2013, largely due to a drought).
  - Excluding agriculture, growth has been steady at about 4 percent since FY2011.
  - Per-capita income growth since 2010 has not meaningfully reduced poverty.
- Fiscal and external positions:
  - Central government deficit increased to 6–7 percent of GDP during FY2013–FY2014.
  - Petrocaribe inflows averaged 4 percent of GDP during FY2009–FY2014 and have financed fiscal and current account deficits; these flows decreased sharply in FY2015.
  - External public debt rose to 21 percent of GDP in FY2014 (from 9 percent in FY2011 after HIPC completion), largely due to Petrocaribe financing.
  - Domestic public debt is around 4 percent of GDP in FY2014.
- Energy sector and fiscal cost:
  - The deficit (before central government transfers) of state-owned electricity company EDH increased to 2.5 percent of GDP in FY2014.
  - Domestic fuel prices were frozen from March 2011 until October 2014, producing foregone tax revenues that peaked at about 2 percent of GDP in FY2014.
  - The combined fiscal cost of fuel subsidies and EDH’s deficit exceeded social spending, which hovered around 3–4 percent of GDP since FY2010.
- Monetary and reserve developments:
  - The Central Bank (BRH) aimed to keep gourde depreciation moderate, typically 3–4 percent per year, given high pass-through to inflation.
  - Easing in monetary stance at end-FY2014 produced FX market pressures; international reserves declined to below 5 months of imports by February 2015.
  - BRH allowed the gourde to depreciate by about 6 percent y/y through March 2015 and tightened policy in March 2015 through increased reserve requirements and policy rates.
  - Staff analysis suggests BRH reserves equivalent to 4–5 months of prospective imports would be appropriate.

### Medium-term challenges and reform priorities
- Structural priorities to boost growth and inclusion:
  - Improve the business environment and property rights.
  - Increase access to cheaper and reliable electricity.
  - Improve financial intermediation and address infrastructure bottlenecks.
- Policy and institutional priorities to preserve stability:
  - Lower fiscal deficits while preserving poverty-reducing spending to crowd in private credit, preserve buffers, and support the exchange rate as a nominal anchor.
  - Improve governance, strengthen budgetary transparency, public investment management, and the monetary policy framework.
  - Address weaknesses in the state electricity utility (EDH), expedite adoption of the Treasury Single Account (TSA), and modernize legal framework for the financial sector.
- Program design features:
  - Quantitative performance criteria (QPCs) include a limit on the deficit of the non-financial public sector.
  - Structural benchmarks concentrate on reducing subsidies, improving PFM and expenditure effectiveness, and creating an enabling environment for growth.

### Risks and contingencies
- Key risks to program implementation:
  - Complex political situation that could delay reforms (parliamentary quorum problems in 2015; elections scheduled for the second half of 2015; new President to be inaugurated in February 2016).
  - A rebound in international petroleum prices.
  - A sudden stop in external financing from Venezuela.
  - Weather events and other shocks.
- Program sequencing and safeguards:
  - Until a new IMF-supported program is approved, current account projections exclude catalyzed multilateral budget support flows.

*Source: HAITI — STAFF REPORT FOR THE 2015 ARTICLE IV CONSULTATION AND REQUEST FOR A THREE-YEAR ARRANGEMENT UNDER THE EXTENDED CREDIT FACILITY (May 6, 2015).*

### 2. Achieve universal primary educationLiteracy rate in the age group of 15-24 years of age32.385.1100

### _cr15157 - 2. Achieve universal primary educationLiteracy rate in the age group of 15-24 years of age32.385.1100

### Millennium Development Goals indicators (selected)
- Literacy rate in the age group of 15-24 years of age: 32.385.1100
- Proportions of pupils starting grade 1 who reach last grade of primary: 68.066.2100
- Net enrollment rate in primary education: 47.088.0100

### MDG 3 — Promote gender equality and empower women (selected)
- Ratio of girls to boys in:
  - Primary education: 0.91.0
  - Secondary education: 1.01.1 (No target)
- Proportion of seats held by women in national parliament: 2.74.330.0
- Share of women in wage employment: 44.2 (No target)

### MDG 4–6 — Health indicators (selected)
- Under-five mortality rate: 156.188.050.4
- Infant-mortality rate: 109.159.036.4
- Proportion of one-year-old children immunized against measles: 25.885.0100
- Proportion of births attended by skilled health personnel: 24.237.3100
- Maternal mortality rate (per 100,000 live births): 157.0 (No target)
- People living with HIV, 15-49 years old (percentage): 2.91.8 (No target)
- Prevalence of HIV/AIDS aged 15-24 years old: 1.00.9 (No target)
- Malaria death rate (per 100,000 population): 5.0 (No target)

### MDG 7–8 — Environment and global partnership (selected)
- Proportion of land areas covered by forests (percentage): 5.53.7 (No target)
- Proportion of population using an improved drinking water source: 36.564.872.7
- Slum population as percentage of urban: 93.470.1 (Min. 62)
- Internet users per 100 inhabitants: 0.210.6 (No target)

*Source: United Nations - MDG Indicators, 2013 Report. Last updated: 07/07/2014*

---

### Medium-term challenges: overview and constraints to growth
- Objective: strengthen competitiveness to spur sustained and inclusive growth in the context of lower external support; safeguard macroeconomic stability by preserving fiscal and external buffers; strengthen policy framework to address vulnerabilities.
- Key constraints to competitiveness identified by staff and authorities:
  - Weak institutions: weak property rights; predatory practices; lack of transparency in government contracting; high electricity costs and hidden fuel price costs.
  - Domestic politics: political crises caused severe decreases in per-capita income during the last 30 years.
  - Inadequate infrastructure: inefficient and expensive port services and electricity supply; deficient road infrastructure.
  - Policy framework weaknesses: lack of integrated fiscal framework; many small taxes increasing costs; burdensome administrative formalities.
  - Low labor productivity: limited access to healthcare and technical education; social infrastructure the worst in LAC.
  - Data quality shortcomings: national accounts and labor indicators most affected; collection disrupted by the 2010 earthquake.

### Exchange rate and competitiveness
- Staff view: Haiti’s real effective exchange rate (REER) level broadly appropriate; further appreciation may constrain competitiveness. Gourde should remain flexible.
- Factors behind moderate REER appreciation since 2010: strong aid and remittance inflows; significant improvement in net foreign asset position following substantial post-earthquake debt relief.
- Exchange system: crawl-like arrangement, with no significant restrictions for capital movements; unchanged since the 2012 Article IV consultation.

### Policy recommendations — structural reforms
- Remove structural bottlenecks: improve basic public services, simplify legal/regulatory environment, reduce political uncertainty, strengthen governance.
- Diversify productive and export base.
- Improve property rights and governance to attract investment and improve credit access.

### Preserving macroeconomic stability and fiscal strategy
- Fiscal objective: cut central government deficit from 6¼ percent of GDP in FY2014 to about 2 percent GDP in FY2018.
- Rationale: preserve buffers amid projected reductions in concessional financing; external grants and Petrocaribe inflows each projected to decline by 2 percent of GDP between FY2014 and FY2018.
- Risks: rebound in oil prices could raise risk of debt distress.
- EDH (electric utility) deficit: decrease in international oil prices reduces EDH’s deficit by 0.5 percent of GDP in FY2015 (given lower generation costs and unchanged tariffs). Authorities plan tariff analysis and an action plan to increase cash recovery.
- Revenue mobilization:
  - Eliminate remaining fuel subsidies to yield 1.5–1.6 percent of GDP in FY2015.
  - Multi-year investment in revenue administration to increase domestic revenue to 15.5 percent of GDP by FY2019.
  - Continue work towards VAT implementation and a new mining code.
- Reorient spending: strengthen public investment framework; implement Treasury Single Account (TSA); develop targeted and sustainable social safety nets; eliminate blanket subsidies and reorient to poverty-reducing outlays (education, health).
- Fiscal transparency: budget documents should report special accounts and programs, civil service pensions and future pension liabilities, earmarked resources for municipalities, financial transactions with SOEs (including contingent liabilities) and all Petrocaribe-funded transactions.

### Monetary policy and financial sector soundness
- Objective: keep a low and stable inflation rate via moderate exchange rate depreciation and well-anchored depreciation expectations.
- Reserve target: keep international reserves at 4–5 months of prospective imports.
- Recommendations for BRH:
  - Keep monetary policy tight until fiscal deficit is reduced.
  - Prefer open market operations (OMOs) over further increases in legal reserve requirements for tightening.
  - Avoid use of exceptions in reserve requirement computation.
  - Consider using 5-year government bonds acquired at end-FY2014 in OMOs.
  - Consider issuing dollar-indexed bonds to absorb liquidity and reduce foreign exchange market pressures (with caution if fiscal deficit not reduced).
  - Strengthen reserve management in line with 2011 safeguards recommendations and IMF technical assistance; revise investment guidelines and benchmark for reserve portfolio.

### Financial market and data improvements
- Develop a deeper foreign exchange market to improve monetary policy effectiveness.
- Enhance framework for foreign exchange intervention and improve timely access to information for real-time policy decisions.
- Continue IMF technical assistance on reserve management and BRH operations.

### Growth projections under the ECF arrangement (Box 2)
- Historical average per-capita GDP growth, thirty years through 2014: -1 percent.
- Macroeconomic framework assumption for 2015–2035:
  - Average per-capita GDP growth: 2.2 percent.
  - Projected average real GDP growth rate: 3.4 percent.
  - Population growth: 1.2 percent.
- Projections conditional on political and macroeconomic stability, adequate buffers, and structural reforms to raise TFP.
- Note: Baseline growth reflects expected labor force increases, increases in capital stock (mainly due to still-high public investment), and a low (but positive) TFP contribution.

### 21.      The banking sector remains well-capitalized and profitable, but some sectors may

### 21.      The banking sector remains well-capitalized and profitable, but some sectors may 

### Banking sector: current position and risks
- Commercial bank credit remains concentrated mainly in commerce and non-tradable sectors.
- The service sector (including hotels and restaurants, mainly in Port-au-Prince) expanded after the earthquake to meet demand from the international relief effort; as that effort winds down, demand may decrease and the service sector may come under pressure.
- Supervisory and prudential measures and recommendations:
  - Staff recommended the implementation of periodic stress testing to spot risks.
  - Authorities report periodic on-site and off-site inspections safeguard financial soundness and indicated they would consider stress tests.
  - Authorities have allowed banks to renegotiate loans to non-tradable sectors to provide time for adjustment; staff cautioned that such renegotiations should be monitored to assess effects on capital ratios.
  - Staff recommended banks be ready to withhold dividends or inject new capital if needed; BRH authorities concurred.

### AML/CFT and legal reforms
- The adoption (in late 2013) of the anti-money laundering and combating the financing of terrorism (AML/CFT) law addressed a number of CFATF recommendations.
- Remaining reforms (including reforms to the penal code) require parliamentary approval according to the authorities.

### Access to credit and financial deepening
- Staff view low access to credit as a constraint to growth; deeper financial intermediation is expected to support inclusive growth.
- Measures to increase intermediation include strengthening property rights and promoting competition among financial institutions.
- Authorities highlighted:
  - A new financial inclusion strategy developed in consultation with the World Bank.
  - Establishment of a credit bureau to produce reliable information about credit-worthiness of individuals and businesses.
  - Intent to resume efforts to enact pending laws on financial cooperatives and on microfinance institutions.
  - Improved data collection in the microfinance/cooperative sector.

### New ECF arrangement: objectives
- In line with the Ex-Post Assessment (EPA) and Article IV recommendations, the ECF-supported program aims to:
  - Entrench macroeconomic stability.
  - Promote inclusive growth and sustained poverty reduction.
  - Lift bottlenecks to growth through streamlined, authority-owned policies and actions.

### Macroeconomic framework and baseline projections
- GDP growth projections:
  - Projected at 2–3 percent in FY2015.
  - Expected to pick up to 3–4 percent in the medium term as structural reforms proceed.
- Growth drivers: remittance-driven consumption, construction, a growing textile industry, and support from lower oil prices.
- Inflation: projected to remain in the mid-single digits.
- Current account deficit: projected to remain under 4 percent of GDP through FY2017.
- Risks to the baseline are tilted to the downside:
  - Domestic politics: complex situation poses challenges for policy implementation and anchoring expectations.
  - Oil prices: decline is a positive shock but remain highly volatile; risk of a stop in Petrocaribe financing could result in lower GDP growth of about 1 percentage point.
  - Donor fatigue: aid inflows decreasing as earthquake rebuilding winds down.
  - Weather events: agriculture (over 20 percent of GDP) vulnerable to shocks.
  - U.S. growth: higher U.S. growth is an upside risk; the U.S. is Haiti’s largest export market and main source of remittances (20 percent of GDP).

### Fiscal program and consolidation
- The program is built on a front-loaded fiscal adjustment.
- NFPS (program fiscal anchor) deficit trajectory:
  - About 7½ percent of GDP in FY2014.
  - Decrease to 3¼ percent in FY2015.
  - Decline to less than 2½ percent in FY2016−FY2018.
- About half of FY2015 consolidation derives from lower international oil prices and thus should not create a negative fiscal impulse.
- Program for FY2015 (selected figures and measures):
  - Central government adopted a revised FY2015 budget (prior action) consistent with a deficit of 2.7 percent of GDP.
  - Central Government revenue will increase to 14.7 percent of GDP, given elimination of fuel subsidies and lock-in of windfall revenue from declining oil prices.
  - Grants will decline by 0.4 percent of GDP.
  - Wage bill increases of 1 percent of GDP (reclassification of transfers and increases for teachers and national police).
  - Investment will decline as one-off post-Sandy emergency spending concludes.
  - EDH’s board adopted (as a prior action) a revised FY2015 budget with savings of about 0.7 percent of GDP from reductions in production costs, more rational utilization of available supply, and improvements in billing and collection at unchanged tariffs.
- Program for FY2016–FY2018:
  - FY2016 budgets for central government and EDH to be adopted before end-September 2015 in line with an NFPS deficit structural benchmark of 2.3 percent of GDP.
  - NFPS deficit will decline to 2.2 percent of GDP by FY2018 (Central Government deficit of 2 percent and EDH deficit -after transfers- of 0.2 percent).
  - To control current spending, net recruitments only in social and security sectors; wages not indexed and increases will not surpass inflation.
- Risk management related to Petrocaribe:
  - A disruption of Petrocaribe flows would create a financing gap of about 1 percent of GDP in FY2015 and of 2 percent of GDP in FY2016 relative to program projections.
  - Additional donor financing and temporary drawdown of deposits and reserves could offset half of the gap in these years.
  - Authorities identified projects that can be implemented more slowly if needed; spending pace will be adjusted in case of a stop.
  - Adoption (prior action) and implementation before end-FY2015 (continuous structural benchmark) of an automatic mechanism for oil product pricing intended to contain fiscal risks from oil price rebounds.

- Selected 2015 fiscal table excerpt (as presented):
  - 2015 Nonfinancial public sector (I + II) 4.2
  - Central government (I) 3.7
  - Revenue and budget support 1.6
  - Budget support -0.4
  - Fuel taxes 1.5
  - Fuel price increase 0.2
  - Locked-in windfall revenue 1.3
  - Administrative measures (incl. vehicle tags) 0.3
  - Expenditure -2.1
  - Transfers to electricy sector 1/ -0.5
  - Non-electricity transfers 2/ -0.4
  - Transfers to municipalities for street lighting 0.2
  - Mitigating measures for fuel price increases 0.1
  - Wage bill 2/ 1.0
  - Petrocaribe-funded investment -1.5
  - Exceptional post-Sandy investment -1.0
  - EDH deficit (after transfers) (II) 0.5

### Monetary program and reserves
- Objectives: achieve moderate and stable inflation while preserving a credible reserve buffer; target international reserves at 4–5 months of prospective imports; ensure no monetary financing of the fiscal deficit.
- Program for FY2015:
  - After a decline in NIR of about US$100 million during the first half of FY2015, NIR are programmed to decline by at most US$50 million in the second half of FY2015.
  - Additional decrease will come from use of government deposits and expected increase in deposit dollarization until the election cycle concludes.
  - Increased exchange rate flexibility will be needed to meet NIR targets if exchange rate pressures are higher than expected.
- Program for FY2016–FY2017:
  - As fiscal adjustment proceeds and the electoral cycle ends, NIR are programmed to rebound as dollarization is gradually reduced and dollar hoarding declines.
  - Over the medium term, fiscal consolidation will permit gradual loosening of monetary policy and crowding in of private sector credit without unwarranted pressures on international reserves.
  - Monetary financing limited to drawdown of Post-Catastrophe Debt Relief (PCDR) resources to keep reserves and government deposits at cushions against shocks.

### Structural reforms to support growth and policy framework
- Focus: remove constraints to growth, complete fiscal and financial sector reforms, and prioritize actions guided by capacity constraints and TA agenda.
- Energy sector:
  - Strengthening EDH’s financial position to reduce fiscal risks and allow gradual supply increases.
  - Main stakeholders preparing a work program to be reflected in a protocol for the sector (structural benchmark), including governance improvements, performance strengthening, timely information, and consolidation of cross-arrears.
  - Authorities will audit the largest clients to boost billing and collection (structural benchmark).
  - Adoption and implementation of an automatic pricing mechanism for domestic fuel products (prior action and continuous structural benchmark).
- Property rights:
  - Strengthening property rights to support investment, access to credit (land as collateral), and broaden the tax base.
  - Inter-ministerial commission on land management to prepare an action plan for FY2016–FY2017 to strengthen legal framework and functioning of the cadastre (structural benchmark).
- Access to credit:
  - Full functioning of a credit bureau is crucial; regular reporting by financial institutions to the bureau is the first step.
  - Authorities should allow potential first-time borrowers to build credit history by incorporating alternative indicators, such as proof of utilities payment.
  - Develop non-bank financial sector (insurance, cooperatives, microfinance) and new instruments such as leasing.
- Poverty reduction:
  - Authorities will target consistent increases in domestically-financed spending on education, health, and agriculture (indicative target).
- Data quality:
  - Prioritize introduction of an overall quarterly economic index as a leading indicator of GDP growth (currently only yearly).
  - With IMF and France TA, revamp national accounts including change of base year.
  - Household survey completed; results to improve poverty and labor force estimates.
  - Authorities will address external accounts data gaps and request IMF technical assistance.

### Box excerpt: Automatic Pricing Mechanism (APM) and fuel pricing details
- Retail prices at end-2014 were somewhat higher than the LAC average but lower than advanced economies; the small gap with LAC closed after pump price decreases in February.
- Price-structure shortcomings: base imported prices used are “Caribbean posting” quotes rather than invoice-based Platt’s prices, resulting in double counting of some costs.
- Transfers to private importers (including storage costs) have increased in the last 12 months.
- APM commitments and features:
  - Implement an APM before the end of FY2015 to pass-through international prices into domestic retail prices and protect fiscal revenues.
  - APM will include a smoothing mechanism to prevent sharp domestic price increases; this mechanism allows for additional (forgone) revenues of up to G 1 billion (0.2 percent of GDP).
  - International prices will be fully passed-through (upwards or downwards) whenever additional (forgone) revenues reach G 1 billion in absolute terms.
  - Authorities committed to revise the price structure so it reflects actual imported prices and all costs in the value chain.
- Mitigating measures:
  - Planned well-targeted measures (e.g., social tariff for public transportation) with World Bank assistance.
  - Planned fiscal cost of direct subsidy estimated at 0.2–0.3 percent of GDP versus blanket subsidies cost in FY2014 of about 2 percent.
- Storage capacity:
  - Installed storage capacity estimated at 365,000 barrels, the equivalent of three weeks of national consumption.

*Source: IMF staff report text as provided.*

### 31.      Fiscal Reforms (MEFP ¶23–27). Actions were drawn from the Public Finance Reform Strategy

### Fiscal Reforms (MEFP ¶23–27)

### Major objectives
- Strengthen tax policy and administration.
- Improve public financial management (PFM).
- Enhance expenditure effectiveness.
- Create an enabling environment for the private sector.

### Tax policy actions
- Appoint a working group in charge of producing a draft of the tax code by end-July 2015 (structural benchmark).
- The working group will assess:
  - elimination of a number of small taxes with low yield and high costs,
  - adoption of a mining code,
  - adoption of a full-fledged VAT system.
- The IMF will provide technical assistance in analyzing tax expenditures.

### Tax administration actions
- Restructure and deepen taxpayer segmentation.
- Registration and audit of new potential taxpayers (identified with IMF support).
- Transfer files of medium taxpayers from the LTO and local tax offices to the MTO (structural benchmark).
- Strengthen the unit in charge of NGOs and exempted entities to increase compliance.
- Strengthen IT tax management to improve country-wide monitoring of taxpayer filings.
- Reforms at customs administration to:
  - contain tax exemptions,
  - fight smuggling,
  - communicate information from the Automated System for Customs Data (ASYCUDA) to the tax department for auditing purposes (structural benchmark).

### Public financial management actions
- Continue work on the TSA, including:
  - conversion of spending accounts into Treasury sub-accounts,
  - conversion of specific revenue accounts into secondary accounts,
  - establishment of all remaining accounting centers by end-September 2015 (structural benchmark).
- Implemented memorandum (December 2014) placing all public accounts at the BRH under the control of public accountants; to be applied by the state-owned bank BNC (prior action).
- Strengthen cash and debt management.
- Make best effort so that draft laws on reorganization of the ministry of finance and on public debt are adopted following the election of a new parliament.
- Tighten modalities for clearance of off-budget commitments (continuous structural benchmark).
- Improve effectiveness of public investment to upgrade infrastructure and reduce costs for the private sector.
- Expand the TSA to the rest of the NFPS in the medium-term to improve coverage of public sector finances.

---

### Monetary and Financial Sector Reforms (MEFP ¶28–31)

### Program objectives
- Regulatory and supervisory enhancements.
- Improve monetary policy framework.
- Promote financing deepening.
- Support inclusive growth.

### Reserve management
- Improve BRH’s reserve management framework by:
  - better documentation of reserve management decisions,
  - better alignment of portfolio management decisions to internal guidelines (in line with IMF technical assistance recommendations),
  - prepare periodic reports on the liquidity of gross reserves,
  - quantify the BRH’s three goals in managing its reserve portfolio: capital preservation, liquidity, and return,
  - refine investment guidelines and benchmarks agreed with external managers to ensure conformity with BRH objectives.

### Foreign exchange market actions
- Improve reporting of transactions.
- Begin single-price foreign exchange auctions.
- Set up an electronic platform for FX transactions.
- Establish an interbank market for foreign exchange with an increased number of participants.

### Safeguards and accounting
- Strengthen the investment committee’s autonomy from investment operations.
- Appoint a compliance officer to provide independent oversight of foreign reserves policy and investment guidelines.
- Achieve full adoption of IFRS.
- Note: IMF safeguards policy requires an update safeguards assessment to be completed no later than the first review under the new ECF arrangement.

### Banking supervision and AML/CFT
- Request IMF technical assistance on stress testing, with a view to implement them on a regular basis to identify risks.
- Implement remaining CFTAF recommendations on AML/CFT.
- Implement the 2012 Financial Action Task Force (FATF) standard to improve governance and address tax evasion.

---

### Program Modalities, Access, and Performance Monitoring

### Proposed ECF arrangement
- Proposed duration: 3-year arrangement under the Fund’s Extended Credit Facility (ECF).
- Proposed access: 60 percent of quota divided in seven equal tranches.
- Disbursements subject to semi-annual reviews with test dates in March and September.
- Rationale: ensure international reserves remain close to their appropriate value for a country exposed to large and frequent shocks; debt service to the Fund would remain manageable; Fund support considered essential and catalytic for budget support from multilateral donors.

### Performance criteria and indicators (MEFP ¶32)
- Performance criteria include:
  - ceiling on net central bank credit to the non-financial public sector;
  - ceiling on net domestic assets of the central bank;
  - floor on net international reserves of the central bank;
  - ceiling on the deficit of the non-financial public sector;
  - ceiling on domestic financing of the central government.
- Continuous performance criteria:
  - zero ceilings on (i) the accumulation of public sector external arrears; and (ii) the contracting or guaranteeing of non-concessional debt.
- Indicative target:
  - floor for domestically-financed poverty-reducing expenditure.

### Implementation monitoring
- Establish a committee to monitor implementation of reforms under the ECF-supported program.
- Committee chaired by the Secretary of State for Finance; include representatives from the BRH, EDH, and Budget, Treasury and Economic Studies Directorates at the Ministry of Finance; work closely with the Fund Resident Representative.

---

### Staff Appraisal — Key Findings, Projections, and Policy Recommendations

### Recent macroeconomic track record
- Since the 2012 Article IV Consultation, Haiti has maintained macroeconomic stability while navigating surges and declines in financial flows post-earthquake.
- International reserves remain appropriate.
- Country experienced the longest stretch of growth in per capita income since the mid-1980s.

### Growth and structural reforms
- Raising Haiti’s growth rate to "3 – 4 percent in the medium term" requires addressing structural bottlenecks to growth and job creation, including:
  - improvements in the business environment and property rights,
  - access to cheaper and reliable electricity,
  - development of secure and transferable land property rights through a functioning cadastre system,
  - financial inclusion measures such as a credit bureau and promotion of credit cooperatives and microfinance institutions.

### Fiscal policy stance and targets
- Recommended fiscal adjustment for FY2015 alongside an unchanged monetary policy stance.
- Fiscal deficit rose to "6–7 percent of GDP over the past two years"; needs to be reined in to "about 3¼ percent of GDP".
- The revised budget for FY2015 is appropriate and preserves fiscal buffers.
- Deficit target "of around 2½ percent of GDP" through the medium-term is consistent with fiscal sustainability.
- Targeting the deficit of the non-financial public sector to cover vulnerabilities, particularly EDH.
- Adoption of an automatic fuel pricing mechanism recommended to protect revenue against oil price shocks.
- Design of a targeted social tariff for public transport to mitigate impact of fuel price volatility.

### Monetary policy recommendations
- BRH should keep monetary policy tight until fiscal deficit is reduced and avoid use of exceptions in computation of reserve requirements.
- Increasing exchange rate flexibility is warranted to maintain adequate international reserves and keep real exchange rate close to equilibrium.
- Central bank should be prepared to increase exchange rate flexibility if fiscal consolidation falters to ensure international reserve buffers remain appropriate.

### Public financial management and data
- Priority to clear backlog of draft laws after election of new parliament.
- Continue PFM improvements, including final establishment of the TSA and enhancing budgetary transparency.
- Improve quality of economic data given serious shortcomings that hamper surveillance.

### Electricity sector and public investment
- Address poor performance of the electricity sector (EDH) which is a key driver of fiscal imbalances.
- Work with development partners (World Bank, IDB) to improve billing and collection.
- Achieve a financially viable electricity sector to attract investment, increase supply, and lower generation costs—leading to productivity gains, reduced vulnerabilities, and poverty reduction.
- Improve effectiveness of public investment to upgrade infrastructure and reduce private sector costs.

### Program rationale and support
- The ECF-supported program seeks to entrench macroeconomic stability, address vulnerabilities, and promote growth through owned policies and actions.
- Staff supports the authorities’ request for Fund assistance under the ECF in an amount equivalent to "60 percent of quota".
- The ECF will contribute to maintaining appropriate international reserves and anchoring expectations.
- Front-loaded fiscal adjustment and implementation of prior actions are indicative of authorities’ determination to maintain macroeconomic stability and mitigate risks.

*Source: Fiscal Reforms and program sections from the IMF document (MEFP ¶23–31 and related Staff Appraisal excerpt).*

### 45.      It is proposed that the next Article IV Consultation with Haiti take place on the

### _cr15157 - 45.      It is proposed that the next Article IV Consultation with Haiti take place on the

### Recent economic developments and outlook (2011–15; projections to 2018/19)
- Haiti's current account deficit (including grants) is projected at:
  - -6.3 percent of GDP (2012/13)
  - -6.3 percent of GDP (2013/14)
  - -3.5 percent of GDP (2014/15)
  - Projected to be -3.8, -3.7, -3.7, -3.6 percent of GDP for 2015/16–2018/19 (Table 4b).
- External current account balance (excluding official grants):
  - -15.2 percent of GDP (2012/13)
  - -12.8 percent of GDP (2013/14)
  - -8.8 percent of GDP (2014/15)
  - Projected -8.8, -8.6, -8.5, -8.4 percent of GDP for 2015/16–2018/19 (Table 1; Table 4b).
- Drivers and near-term dynamics (from figure annotations):
  - Current account deficit set to narrow sharply on lower international petroleum prices.
  - Transfers projected largely flat; slow growth in goods and services exports.
  - Lower oil prices reduced concessional flows from Venezuela (PetroCaribe).
  - Pre-election dollar hoarding pressured the exchange rate; central bank intervention has been limited.
  - High pass-through is raising inflation from recent lows.
  - Pace of reserve loss has slowed; reserve coverage remains comfortable.

### Fiscal developments (2011–15; FY projections to 2018/19)
- Central government overall balance (including grants), percent of GDP:
  - -7.2 (2012/13), -6.4 (2013/14), -2.7 (2014/15), projected -1.9, -2.2, -2.0, -2.0 for 2015/16–2018/19 (Table 1).
- Domestic revenue and grants (percent of GDP):
  - Domestic revenue: 12.8, 12.5, 14.7, 14.7, 15.0, 15.3, 15.5 (2012/13–2018/19) (Table 1).
  - Grants: 8.1, 6.5, 6.1, 5.6, 5.3, 5.0, 4.8 (2012/13–2018/19) (Table 1).
- Expenditure composition (percent of GDP):
  - Total expenditures: 28.1, 25.4, 23.4, 22.2, 22.5, 22.3, 22.3 (2012/13–2018/19) (Table 1).
  - Capital expenditures: 16.1, 12.8, 10.9, 9.7, 10.0, 9.8, 9.8 (2012/13–2018/19) (Table 1).
- FY2014/15 fiscal details (millions of gourdes; Table 2a):
  - Total revenue and grants: 88,006
  - Domestic revenue: 62,254
  - Of which: fuel taxes: 7,400
  - Grants: 25,752
  - Total expenditure: 99,402
  - Current expenditure: 53,050
  - Capital expenditure: 46,352
  - Overall balance including grants: -11,396
  - Excluding grants: -37,148
- Financing (FY2014/15; Table 2a):
  - External net financing (loans net): 6,850
  - Disbursements: 8,803
  - Of which: PetroCaribe: 8,099
  - Internal net financing: 6,621
  - Banking system contribution: 14,120 (note offsets in BRH and commercial banks)

### Monetary and financial sector
- Reserve and liquidity indicators (Table 3; Table 4a):
  - Net international reserves (program definition): 860 (2014/15); projections 890, 950, 1,017, 1,085 for 2015/16–2018/19 (Table 1; Table 3).
  - Gross International Reserves (US$ millions): 1,782 (2014/15); projected 1,808, 1,872, 1,940, 2,010 for 2015/16–2018/19 (Table 4a; Table 4b).
  - Gross international reserves in months of next year's imports: 4.8 (2014/15); 4.6, 4.5, 4.5, 4.5 for 2015/16–2018/19 (Table 4a; Table 4b).
- Money and credit (Table 1; Table 3):
  - Credit to private sector (percent of GDP): 16.4 (2012/13), 11.2 (2013/14), 4.7 (2014/15), projected 11.4, 9.0, 10.4, 11.4 for 2015/16–2018/19 (Table 1; Table 3).
  - Base money growth and broad money (12-month % change): Base money 15.1, 0.5, 3.0, 7.0, 8.1, 8.2, 7.1 (Table 3).
  - Dollarization remains elevated: foreign currency deposits percent of total private deposits 56.1, 57.0, 58.7, 58.4, 58.0, 57.6, 57.2 (2012/13–2018/19) (Table 3).
- Inflation (figure annotations):
  - Headline and core inflation rising from recent lows; pass-through from exchange rate and fuel price shocks contributing to increases.

### Banking sector performance and risks
- Structure and concentration (Figure 4; Table 5):
  - Share of top 3 banks in total banking sector assets and deposits: in the 78–85 percent range over 2011–15 (Figure 4).
  - Bank credit concentrated in commerce, services/utilities & transportation, and real estate (Figure 4).
- Soundness indicators (Table 5; summary):
  - Regulatory capital to risk-weighted assets: 17.3 (Sep-13), 17.1 (Dec-13), 17.7 (Mar-14), 17.5 (Jun-14), 17.8 (Sep-14), 18.0 (Dec-14).
  - NPLs to gross loans: 2.4, 4.3, 4.6, 3.3, 3.0, 4.3 (Sep-13 to Dec-14).
  - Return on Assets (ROA): 1.7, 1.3, 1.4, 1.9, 1.6, 1.5 (Sep-13 to Dec-14).
  - Foreign currency loans to total loans (net): 48.2, 48.8, 49.7, 51.9, 52.4, 53.1 percent (Sep-13 to Dec-14).
- Key messages from figures:
  - System's capital adequacy ratio remains above the regulatory minimum.
  - Banks remain profitable despite recent increases in NPLs.
  - Credit growth has slowed, particularly in gourdes; credit closely tied to deposit growth.

### External sector, reserves and debt vulnerabilities
- Trade and current account (Table 4a; Table 4b):
  - Trade balance (US$ millions): -2,277 (2014/15); projected -2,347, -2,470, -2,593, -2,707 for 2015/16–2018/19.
  - Exports of goods (US$ millions): 1,004 (2014/15); projected 1,058, 1,122, 1,197, 1,281 for 2015/16–2018/19.
  - Imports of goods (US$ millions): -3,281 (2014/15); projected -3,406, -3,592, -3,791, -3,988 for 2015/16–2018/19.
  - Of which: Fossil Fuels (US$ millions): -663 (2014/15); projected -735, -814, -877, -937 for 2015/16–2018/19.
- Public debt indicators (Table 6):
  - Total external public debt (percent of GDP): 17.4, 21.0, 21.8, 22.6, 23.3, 23.8, 24.3 (2012/13–2018/19).
  - Total public debt (percent of GDP): 19.5, 24.1, 25.5, 26.4, 27.2, 28.2, 28.9 (2012/13–2018/19).
  - Total public debt (millions of US$): 1,626, 2,056, 2,240, 2,453, 2,681, 2,941, 3,186 (2012/13–2018/19).
  - PetroCaribe component of debt (millions of US$): 1,235, 1,576, 1,717, 1,849, 2,003, 2,158, 2,309 (2012/13–2018/19).
- Liquidity and reserve metrics (Table 6):
  - Liquid gross reserves (US$ millions): 2,242 (2012/13), 1,782 (2013/14), 1,650 (2014/15); projected 1,677, 1,740, 1,809, 1,878 (2015/16–2018/19).
  - Reserves in months of imports of following year: 6.0, 5.0, 4.4, 4.3, 4.2, 4.2, 4.2 (2012/13–2018/19).

### IMF program design and financing (proposed ECF)
- Proposed schedule of disbursements under the proposed ECF arrangement, 2015–18 (Table 7):
  - SDR 7,020,000 on 5/18/2015; subsequent SDR 7,020,000 disbursements planned on 10/30/2015, 4/30/2016, 10/30/2016, 4/30/2017, 10/30/2017, 4/30/2018.
  - Memorandum: Prospective Total Access under the ECF arrangement: SDR 49,140,000.
- Indicative access and financing items in the Balance of Payments (Table 4a):
  - Proposed access lines and identified budget support (IDB and EU) shown as prospective items (Table 4a; Table 4b).
  - Notes: A new ECF would catalyze identified multilateral budget support. Until a new IMF-supported program is approved, current account projections exclude these flows.

### Fiscal and structural policy actions, benchmarks, and reforms
- Proposed prior actions and structural benchmarks, FY2015–16 (Table 10):
  - Prior actions (PA):
    - Adoption of a revised budget for the central government for FY2015 consistent with a deficit of at most G 13.5 bn.
    - Adoption of an automatic price mechanism for refined oil products (gasoline 95, diesel, and kerosene products).
    - Implement TSA-related actions in line with TMU ¶35.
    - EDH Board adoption of a revised budget for EDH consistent with savings of at least G 3.4 bn in FY2015.
  - Structural benchmarks (SB) with timing and rationale:
    - Signature of an EDH protocol laying out stakeholder obligations to improve electricity sector performance — End-June 2015.
    - Implement an automatic price formula for fuel products — Continuous as of End-June 2015.
    - Payment of unpaid off-budget CG commitments — To be observed continuously.
    - Establish a working group to produce by end-July 2016 a preliminary draft of a tax code — End-July 2015.
    - Transfer of all medium taxpayers' files to the MTO completed — End-August 2015.
    - Adoption of FY2016 budgets for the Central Government and EDH consistent with a NFPS deficit of 2.3 percent of GDP — End-September 2015.
    - Establish and make operational all remaining accounting centers — End-September 2015.
    - Interministerial working group to share an action plan to strengthen cadastre legal framework — End-February 2016.
    - In line with EDH protocol, complete audit of the 200 largest clients and analysis on EDH tariff determination — End-March 2016.
    - Implement program to ensure tax compliance of importers with annual turnover above G 10 million not covered by LTO/MTO — End-April 2016.
- Structural reforms to be implemented during ECF, 2015–17 (Table 11):
  - Design and implement a program to ensure compliance of importers with annual turnover above G 10 billion not currently covered by the LTO/MTO — 2015.
  - The MTO administers medium taxpayers' files effectively including those transferred from the LTO and local tax offices — 2015.
  - Finalize a new tax code and eliminate small taxes with low yield — 2016–17.
  - Complete studies on tax expenditures — 2015–17.

### Indicative program monitoring and quantitative targets (June 2015–June 2016)
- Quantitative performance criteria and indicative targets (Table 9; cumulative flows since September 2014, in millions of gourdes):
  - Net central bank credit to the non-financial public sector — ceiling:
    - 12,330 (Dec 2014 actual), targets/projections up to 10,094 (June 2016).
  - Net domestic assets of the central bank — ceiling:
    - -23,625 (Dec 2014 actual), targets/projections up to 10,559 (June 2016).
  - Net international reserves of central bank (in millions of U.S. dollars) — floor:
    - 1,010 (Dec 2014 actual), projected floors: -50, -100, -117, -150, -150, -150, -130 for March 2015–June 2016 (Table 9).
  - Deficit of the Non-Financial Public Sector — ceiling:
    - Cumulative targets shown: 4,000 (Mar 2015), 8,856 (Jun 2015), 11,242 (Sep 2015), 13,471 (Dec 2015), 16,141 (Mar 2016), 18,810 (Jun 2016).
  - Domestic Financing of Central Government — ceiling:
    - Cumulative targets shown: 1,178 (Mar 2015), 4,854 (Jun 2015), 5,817 (Sep 2015), 6,621 (Dec 2015), 7,232 (Mar 2016), 7,843 (Jun 2016).
- Continuous performance criteria:
  - New contracting or guaranteeing of public sector nonconcessional external debt — zero for the monitoring period in Table 9.
  - Public sector external arrears accumulation — 0 (to be maintained).

*Source: National Authorities; and IMF staff estimates.*

### Introduction of full-fledged VAT  system2017-18

### Introduction of full-fledged VAT  system2017-18

### Program objectives and support request
- Request for IMF Extended Credit Facility (ECF) support for a new three-year program covering May 2015–May 2018.
- Requested amount: SDR 49.14 million, or 60 percent of quota, to be disbursed in seven equal tranches over three years.
- Immediate disbursement upon approval: SDR 7.02 million.
- First review no later than December 31, 2015; second review by June 30, 2016.
- Overarching objective: boost Haiti’s long-term growth potential and reduce poverty while maintaining macroeconomic stability.

### Recent performance and key findings (2010–2014)
- Achievements:
  - Maintained macroeconomic stability and returned to growth despite the 2010 earthquake and other shocks.
  - Inflation contained in the mid-single digits.
  - Increased reserve buffers and limited exchange rate volatility.
  - Progress on structural reforms: revenue administration improvements, establishment of LTO and MTO, initial steps toward a Treasury Single Account (TSA).
- Shortcomings and risks:
  - Growth lower than projected and insufficient for rapid poverty reduction.
  - Public investment below projections and reliant on foreign grants and Petrocaribe financing.
  - Fiscal deficits in FY2013 and FY2014 rose to unsustainable levels largely due to energy subsidies costing US$ 350–450 million per year.
  - External public debt exceeded 20 percent of GDP by end FY2014.
  - Private sector credit access remains low and concentrated.
  - Slow progress on tax policy, financial sector regulation, and public debt management reforms.

### Recent economic developments and statistics
- FY2014:
  - Real GDP growth: about 2.7 percent (versus 4.2 percent in FY2013).
  - Inflation: ended FY2014 at 5.3 percent.
  - Current account deficit: over 6 percent of GDP.
  - Private sector credit growth: decelerated to 11.2 percent; credit in gourdes increased by 5.2 percent.
  - Energy sector contribution to fiscal deficit: around US$ 450 million; overall fiscal deficit exceeded 7 percent of GDP.
- FY2015 projections and medium-term outlook:
  - FY2015 GDP growth: projected to remain in the 2–3 percent range.
  - FY2016–FY2018 GDP growth: expected to average about 3.5 percent.
  - Inflation: projected to remain in the mid-single digits for FY2015 and FY2016–FY2018.
  - External current account deficit: expected to decline to the 3 percent of GDP range in FY2015; expected to widen toward 4 percent of GDP in FY2016–FY2018.
  - Petroleum-taxes: projected to add 1.5 percent of GDP to revenues in FY2015 as fuel subsidies are eliminated.
  - Domestic revenues: should reach 14.7 percent of GDP in FY2015 (2.2 percent of GDP more than in FY2014).
  - Capital spending: projected to decrease to 10.9 percent of GDP.
  - Reserve cushion target: around 5 months of imports.

### Fiscal policy adjustments and public finance framework
- FY2015 revised budget aims to significantly reduce the fiscal deficit:
  - NFPS (program definition) deficit projected to fall to about 3.2 percent of GDP (from 7.4 percent of GDP in FY2014).
- Key fiscal measures:
  - Eliminate fuel subsidies and adopt petroleum-tax measures.
  - Strengthen tax and customs administration to increase domestic revenues.
  - Contain transfers to the electricity sector and reduce reliance on Petrocaribe financing (expected to fall by more than US$200 million).
  - Rely more on domestic financing, including drawing down government deposits; expected budget support from IDB and the European Union of US$70 million; request for World Bank budget support.
- Medium-term NFPS deficit target:
  - FY2016–FY2018: reduce average NFPS deficit to 2.3 percent of GDP to ensure public debt sustainability.
- Contingency:
  - ECF-supported program includes adjusters to ensure fiscal and external debt sustainability in case of changes in expected external financing.

### Monetary policy stance and金融 operations
- FY2015 monetary policy focus: contain inflation in the mid-single digits and maintain adequate international reserve buffers.
- Central bank intentions and tools:
  - Maintain a comfortable reserve cushion of around 5 months of imports.
  - Intervene to smooth exchange rate movements caused by temporary factors.
  - Analyze issuing dollar-indexed bills directly to the public to absorb liquidity and reduce foreign-exchange market pressures (noted as contingent on fiscal sustainability).
  - Improve transmission of monetary policy and reduce obstacles to financial inclusion, including through a new credit bureau to better document borrower creditworthiness.
- Recent developments:
  - Moderate gourde depreciation during FY2014, helping anchor inflation expectations despite reduced intervention.
  - Exchange rate pressures increased early in FY2015 after allowing certain Treasury bonds to count towards reserve requirements, coinciding with a strong reduction in the fiscal deficit and moderate bank credit expansion.

### Structural reforms and planned actions (selected)
- Public financial management (PFM) and transparency:
  - Complete implementation of the Treasury Single Account (TSA) and transform all ministerial accounts into Treasury sub-accounts and secondary accounts.
  - Establish remaining accounting centers in 2015; include accounts of autonomous agencies, public enterprises and donor accounts in the TSA (2015–16).
  - Transform operations on special accounts to be included in budget documents (FNE, FER, pension system for civil servants, transactions with SOEs, Petrocaribe resources) 2015–17.
- Tax policy and revenue mobilization:
  - Increase tax compliance and modernize the tax system, including introduction of a full-fledged VAT system (noted as 2017–18) and rationalize the tax system.
  - Improve Large Taxpayer Office (LTO) and Medium Taxpayer Office (MTO) effectiveness and budgetary transparency.
- Electricity sector reforms:
  - Reduce subsidies to EDH and submit EDH under a management contract (2015–17).
  - Eliminate cross arrears (2015–17); conduct audits of largest clients to increase billing and recovery (2015–17).
  - Review contracts with IPPs (2015–16) and review tariff determination and penalties for non-payment (2016–17).
- Public investment and sectoral reforms:
  - Improve effectiveness of public investment by implementing World Bank study recommendations completed in September 2014 (2015–17).
  - Set up legal framework for the National Education Fund (FNE) (2015–17).
- Financial sector and supervision:
  - Conduct periodic stress tests for the banking sector (2015–17).
  - Strengthen AML/CFT framework by adopting the Financial Intelligence Unit (UCREF) Bill and new Penal and Criminal Investigation Codes, and implementing the AML/CFT framework (2015–17).
  - Adopt pending draft law on insurance companies (2016); adopt IFRS and strengthen independence of investment committee (2015–17).
  - Strengthen the forex market by implementing MCM recommendations (2015–17).
  - Ensure full operation of the credit bureau (2015–16).
- Structural legal and property reforms:
  - Strengthen property rights by setting up a cadastre (2015–16).
  - Adopt pending draft laws on financial cooperatives and microfinance institutions (2016).
- Other governance and fiscal management items:
  - Adopt the draft laws on reorganization of the ministry of finance and on public debt (2016).
  - Adopt the new mining law (2016–17).
  - Avoid blanket fuel subsidies and adopt/implement an automatic price formula (possible prior actions and structural benchmarks flagged for 2015–16).
  - Improve data quality: strengthen national, labor and external accounts (2015–17).
  - Implement safeguards recommendations.

### Planned reform outcomes and priorities
- Principal reform objectives listed:
  - Implement the TSA.
  - Rationalize the tax system.
  - Increase tax compliance and modernize the tax system.
  - Improve PFM.
  - Improve expenditure quality.
  - Strengthen the framework for fiscal policy.
  - Improve the effectiveness of the LTO and MTO.
  - Improve budgetary transparency.
  - Improve the framework for the electricity sector and strengthen performance.
  - Remove bottlenecks to growth.
  - Strengthen banking supervision.
  - Strengthen monetary policy framework.
  - Improve performance of the electricity sector.
  - Improve business climate.
  - Improve access to credit.

*Source: Attachment 1. Memorandum of Economic and Financial Policies for 2015–2018, Letter of Intent (May 4, 2015).*

### 17. While Haiti has achieved four consecutive years of economic growth during the previous

### _cr15157 - 17. While Haiti has achieved four consecutive years of economic growth during the previous

### Growth, inclusion, and sustainability
- Haiti achieved four consecutive years of economic growth during the Fund-supported arrangement, but this growth has not been sufficient to rapidly reduce poverty.
- The PSDH establishes that growth-supporting policies must be economically, environmentally, and socially sustainable.
- To ensure inclusive growth and combat extreme poverty, the government will:
  - Continue to prioritize social expenditures in the budget process and streamline categories covered under poverty-reducing expenditures.
  - Use appropriate levels of social expenditures to develop human capital, improve efficiencies at many small farms, and expand access to healthcare.

### Infrastructure, credit access, and property rights
- Key reforms to enhance growth potential:
  - Improve infrastructure, in particular the operation of the electricity sector.
  - Expand access to credit by strengthening property rights and establishing a modern cadastre.
  - Strengthen the regulatory framework of the energy sector to improve governance, transparency, and attract investment.
  - Improve efficiency and reduce the cost of port services.
- Property rights and cadastre:
  - Securing transferable property rights would increase incentives for private domestic and foreign investment, facilitate construction, promote efficient farming, and enable use of land as collateral to expand credit and mortgage markets.
  - A modern cadastre would improve resilience to natural disasters by encouraging structural improvements.
  - Structural benchmark: the inter-ministerial commission on land management will share with IMF staff by end-February 2016 an agreed action plan for FY2016–FY2017 to strengthen the legal framework and functioning of the cadastre.

### Employment, sectors with comparative advantage, and trade preferences
- Promoting formal sector employment is a program goal to increase pay and opportunities relative to informal employment (commerce and agriculture).
- The PSDH identifies manufacturing and tourism as sectors aligned with Haiti’s comparative advantages.
- The HELP/HOPE Acts trade preferences offer unparalleled access to the U.S. textile market; the government will encourage development of textiles and work to ensure extension of preferences.
- Tourism potential depends on steady improvements in infrastructure and security, broadened revenue base, and improved quality of public expenditures.

### Data, national accounts, and indicators
- The 2010 earthquake reduced the capacity to collect and distribute economic data, affecting policymaking and private sector decisions.
- Commitments to improve quality of national, labor, and external accounts over the program:
  - Introduce a headline economic activity indicator as a reliable leading indicator for economic growth.
  - Modernize the national accounts, including updating the base year.

### Fiscal framework and fiscal sustainability
- Commit to sustainable fiscal policies and buffers against shocks (international reserves and government deposits) to guard against shocks such as reduced external financing or a rebound in oil prices.
- Prior actions and targets:
  - Adopted a revised budget for the central government for FY2015 consistent with a deficit of at most G13.5 billion (prior action).
  - Strengthen public financial management drawing on the Public Finance Reform Strategy (2013).
  - Clearance of obligations from off-budget CG commitments only after analysis and proper budgeting (continuous structural benchmark).
- Targeting quality expenditures with high impact on growth and poverty reduction and seeking international support for high-return investments.

### Fuel pricing mechanism, transport subsidies, and fiscal risks
- Prevent reemergence of fuel price subsidies:
  - An automatic fuel price adjustment mechanism adopted by end-April; implementation to begin as of end-June 2015 (prior action and structural benchmark as described in TMU paragraphs 34 and 36).
  - Implementation to be complemented by direct subsidies to public transportation at a cost of about 0.3 percent of GDP to smooth fuel price volatility effects on urban public transport tariffs.
  - Authorities drafting a new regulatory framework for the fuel sector to align pump prices with actual imported CIF prices.

### EDH (Electricité d’Haïti) reforms and fiscal impact
- EDH finances require substantial improvement to achieve fiscal sustainability.
- Program features and actions:
  - The ECF-supported program establishes a target for the deficit of the NFPS, which includes EDH.
  - A protocol to be signed before end-June 2015 by the Prime Minister, Minister of Public Works, Minister of Finance, EDH, and other stakeholders to lay out obligations to achieve targeted improvements in the electricity sector (structural benchmark).
  - Protocol includes revision of electricity tariffs, penalties for non-payment, elimination of cross-arrears, review of IPP contracts, finalization of an EDH audit, and better data production/diffusion.
  - For FY2015, combination of lower international oil prices and measures targeting an increase in the cash recovery index (CRI) of about 4 percentage points will allow adoption of a revised EDH budget with savings of at least G3.4 billion that will reduce the deficit (before transfers) from 2.5 percent of GDP to 1.7 percent of GDP (prior action).
  - Structural benchmark for end-March 2016: complete audit of the 200 largest clients, produce first analysis of EDH tariff determination and penalties for non-payment, and update an action plan for 2016-2018.

### Revenue mobilization and tax reform
- Increase domestic revenue by enhancing revenue collection and tax compliance; remove “taxes de nuisance.”
- Key actions and timelines:
  - Establish a formal working group by July 2015 (structural benchmark) to draft a new tax code consolidating tax laws and eliminating numerous small taxes.
  - Working group to produce a preliminary draft of the tax code by end-July 2016.
  - Working group also to prepare adoption of a mining code, a full-fledged VAT system, and modernization of the income tax.
  - LTO and local tax offices to complete transfer of all medium taxpayer files to the MTO by end-August 2015 (structural benchmark).
  - Implement a program to ensure tax compliance by importers with annual turnover over G10 million who are not covered by the LTO/MTO by end-April 2016 (structural benchmark).
  - Medium-term milestones: finalize tax code, complete study on tax expenditures, adopt mining code, reform income tax, and introduce full-fledged VAT system.

### Public financial management and TSA
- Further strengthen public financial management and quality of public expenditures; advance Treasury Single Account (TSA).
- Actions and timelines:
  - Progress toward TSA: establish TSA by end-FY2015.
  - Implement terms of MEF-BRH protocol and MEF decision of December 18, 2014 placing public accounts at the BRH; BRH ensured application by state-owned bank BNC (prior action).
  - Four new accounting centers installed in March; all remaining accounting centers to be established and operational by end-September 2015 (structural benchmark).
  - Medium-term: expand TSA to include autonomous agencies, public enterprises, and donor accounts.
  - Improve public investment effectiveness by implementing World Bank study recommendations (September 2014).

### Monetary and financial sector reforms
- Boost financial intermediation and access to credit by:
  - Strengthening property rights (land cadastre) and encouraging competition among financial institutions.
  - Enacting pending laws on financial cooperatives and microfinance institutions.
  - Promoting use of the recently-established credit bureau to improve information flows.
- Strengthen financial sector supervision, AML/CFT framework, and data transparency:
  - Conduct periodic stress tests of the banking sector with MCM technical assistance.
  - Develop surveillance and regulatory framework for cooperatives and microfinance institutions aligned with the financial inclusion strategy.
  - Improve data collection and distribution of key indicators on the central bank website.
  - Adopt the Financial Intelligence Unit (UCREF) Bill and new Penal and Criminal Investigation Codes in line with the CFATF action plan.
  - Pursue adoption of the draft law on insurance companies.
- Strengthen monetary policy framework and BRH operations:
  - Implement 2011 MCM recommendations to improve foreign exchange market functioning, unify FX intervention process, and reduce intervention frequency to foster a deeper interbank FX market.
  - BRH received IMF technical assistance in May (foreign exchange market reporting) and August (foreign reserve management); FY2013 BRH financial statements published in November 2014.
  - Commit to strengthen autonomy of the investment committee, appoint a compliance officer for foreign reserves management, and fully adopt IFRS accounting standards.

### Program monitoring, performance criteria, and indicative targets
- A program monitoring committee chaired by the State Secretary of Finance includes BRH, EDH, and Ministry of Finance directorates.
- The program will be monitored using performance criteria as of end-March and end-September, continuous performance criteria, indicative targets as of end-June and December, and structural benchmarks as defined in the TMU.
- Selected quantitative performance criteria and indicative targets (measured as cumulative flows since September 2014):
  - Net central bank credit to the non-financial public sector - ceiling:
    - December 2014: 12,330
    - March 2015: 5,970
    - June 2015: 6,425
    - September 2015: 7,652
    - December 2015: 8,879
    - March 2016: 9,284
    - June 2016: 9,689
    - (additional figure in table) 10,094
  - Net domestic assets of the central bank - ceiling:
    - December 2014: -23,625
    - March 2015: 6,834
    - June 2015: 8,538
    - September 2015: 8,645
    - December 2015: 9,550
    - March 2016: 10,199
    - June 2016: 10,849
    - (additional figure in table) 10,559
  - Net international reserves of central bank (in millions of U.S. dollars) - floor:
    - December 2014: 1,010
    - March 2015: -50
    - June 2015: -100
    - September 2015: -117
    - December 2015: -150
    - March 2016: -150
    - June 2016: -150
    - (additional figure in table) -130
  - Deficit of the Non-Financial Public Sector - ceiling: (cumulative flows listed)
    - March 2015: 4,000
    - June 2015: 8,856
    - September 2015: 11,242
    - December 2015: 13,471
    - March 2016: 16,141
    - June 2016: 18,810
    - (additional figure in table) 21,480
  - Domestic Financing of Central Government - ceiling:
    - March 2015: 1,178
    - June 2015: 4,854
    - September 2015: 5,817
    - December 2015: 6,621
    - March 2016: 7,232
    - June 2016: 7,843
    - (additional figure in table) 8,454
- Indicative targets — Poverty reducing expenditures - floor (domestically-financed spending in health, education, and agriculture):
  - March 2015: 3,630
  - June 2015: 7,421
  - September 2015: 11,345
  - December 2015: 15,269
  - March 2016: 19,490
  - June 2016: 23,889
  - (additional figure in table) 28,446
- Memorandum items (selected):
  - Net Central Bank Credit to the Central Government:
    - Actual Stock at end-September 2014: 16,142
    - Cumulative flows since end-September 2014: March 2015: 5,797; June 2015: 5,971; September 2015: 6,918; December 2015: 7,865; March 2016: 8,195; June 2016: 8,524; (additional) 8,854
  - Stock of Base money:
    - Actual Stock at end-September 2014: 48,150
    - Cumulative flows since end-September 2014: March 2015: 52,851; June 2015: 51,761; September 2015: 50,671; December 2015: 49,580; March 2016: 50,452; June 2016: 51,325; (additional) 52,197
  - Gross International Reserves (in millions of U.S. dollars):
    - Actual Stock at end-September 2014: 1,914
    - Cumulative flows since end-September 2014: March 2015: 1,817; June 2015: 1,808; September 2015: 1,794; December 2015: 1,782; March 2016: 1,782; June 2016: 1,782; (additional) 1,802

### Structural benchmarks and timing (selected from Table 2)
- Prior actions (PA):
  - Adoption of a revised budget for the central government for FY2015 consistent with a deficit of at most G 13.5 bn.
  - Adoption of an automatic price mechanism for refined oil products (gasoline 95, diesel, and kerosene products).
  - Implement TSA-related actions in line with paragraph 35 of the TMU.
  - EDH Board adoption of a revised budget for EDH consistent with savings of at least G3.4bn in FY2015.
- Structural benchmarks (SB) and timing:
  - Signature of electricity sector protocol by PM, Minister of Public Works, Minister of Finance, EDH, and stakeholders — End-June 2015.
  - Implement an automatic price formula for fuel products — Continuous as of End-June 2015.
  - Payment of unpaid off-budget CG commitments — To be observed continuously.
  - Establish a working group to produce by end-July 2016 a preliminary draft of a tax code — End-July 2015.
  - Transfer of all medium taxpayer files to the MTO — End-August 2015.
  - Adoption of FY2016 budgets for the Central Government and EDH consistent with a NFPS deficit of 2.3 percent of GDP — End-September 2015.
  - Establish and make operational all remaining accounting centers — End-September 2015.
  - Interministerial working group shares with IMF staff an agreed action plan for 2016-17 to strengthen the cadastre legal framework and functioning — End-February 2016.
  - In line with EDH protocol, complete audit of the 200 largest clients, complete analysis on EDH tariff determination and penalties for non-payment — End-March 2016.
  - Implement a program to ensure tax compliance of importers with annual turnover above G10 million not covered by LTO/MTO — End-April 2016.

*Source: IMF staff and Haitian authorities text in the Memorandum describing the ECF-supported program and the Technical Memorandum of Understanding.*

### 1.      This technical memorandum of understanding (TMU) defines quantitative performance

### _cr15157 - 1.      This technical memorandum of understanding (TMU) defines quantitative performance

### Definitions (scope and institutional coverage)
- Central Government (CG): central administration of Haiti; excludes municipalities, the central bank (BRH), other public financial institutions, autonomous state organizations and state-owned enterprises (SOEs). CG expenditures are financed by domestic taxes and other levies and by foreign donors through, inter alia, foreign grants, ministerial accounts (comptes-courants) and foreign public debt (including Petrocaribe). All transactions financed with Petrocaribe-flows (as reported by Bureau de Monétisation des Programmes d'Aide au Développement, BMPAD) constitute, for the purpose of the ECF, CG operations.
- Special Funds and Programs: include the Road Fund (Fonds d’Entretien Routier, FER) and resources mobilized to finance the PSUGO program in addition to Treasury transfers. For the ECF, resources levied to finance FER and PSUGO will be recorded as revenues, with total expenses differing from revenues through variation of deposits recorded within CG deposits at the BRH.
- Electricité d’Haïti (EDH): SOE for electricity production, transmission, distribution. Flows between EDH and the CG include: (i) CG transfers (including through sales taxes on electricity consumption not devolved to the CG, and budgetary transfers); (ii) transfers financed with Petrocaribe resources for operation of PBM; (iii) payment of letters of credit in favor of IPPs by debiting CG deposits at the BRH to cancel unpaid generation bills by EDH; (iv) accumulation of financial claims by the CG for fuel purchases by IPPs, counterpart of EDH arrears. For the ECF, (i) and (ii) are “above the line”; (iii) and (iv) are financing items “below the line”.
- Non-financial public sector (NFPS): central government, special funds and programs, non-budgetary autonomous organizations, local governments and SOEs (government >50 percent stake, including EDH), but excluding the BRH and state-owned commercial banks.
- Public sector (PS): NFPS plus the BRH.
- Net BRH credit to the NFPS: difference between BRH assets and liabilities vis-à-vis the NFPS (Créances nettes sur le secteur public) according to Table 10R; includes net BRH credit vis-à-vis the CG and vis-à-vis the rest of the NFPS.
- Domestic arrears of the CG: expenditures accepted by the Treasury that are unpaid. Exclude unpaid off-budget government commitments.
- Unpaid off-budget CG commitments: obligations arising outside the budget process (ministries or public agencies) that may result in contingent claims on CG resources.
- Net domestic financing (NDF) of the CG: sum of (i) net central bank credit to the CG; (ii) net credit from domestic commercial banks (Table 20R), including changes in CG deposits and net issuance of treasury bills and other CG securities to commercial banks; and (iii) net non-bank credit to the CG, including net issuance of Treasury bills and other CG securities to non-banks, change in net creditor position of the CG vis-à-vis the electricity sector (including IPPs and EDH), other CG claims and debts vis-à-vis nonbank institutions (including change in net checks issued and not cashed, suppliers’ credit, payment of judicial sentences), and net change in domestic arrears of CG.
- Net external financing (NEF) of the CG: sum of (i) new external loan disbursements (including financing under Petrocaribe and loans from other external partners, but excluding the IMF); (ii) external loan amortizations; and (iii) net change in external arrears.
- EDH’s deficit after CG transfers: EDH revenues include all cash income related to distribution of electricity (recettes d’energie and recettes diverses), and CG transfers (subventions, including those financed with budgetary and Petrocaribe resources, including retained taxes). EDH expenditures include: (i) current spending corresponding to the fiscal year (excluding cancelation of arrears with IPPs)—current electricity bills by IPPs and PBM, fuel, administration, wages, maintenance; and (ii) capital spending. Revenues and expenditures correspond to the fiscal year; changes in claims or debts from previous fiscal years are recorded below the line (financing). EDH’s deficit after CG transfers = EDH expenditures minus EDH revenues (including CG transfers).
- NFPS Deficit target: defined as the sum of NDF of the CG; plus NEF of the CG; plus EDH’s deficit after CG transfers.
- Budgetary Grants: grants from Haiti’s bilateral or multilateral partners for general or sector budget support (including the European Union, the Inter-American Development Bank, the World Bank, the Haiti Reconstruction Fund, and bilateral donors).
- Poverty-Reducing Expenditure of the CG: measured as the sum of the domestically-financed expenditure by the Ministries of Health, Education and Agriculture.
- Debt (for performance criteria): as per Executive Board Decision No.6230-(79/140), Point 9, revised August 31, 2009 (Decision No. 14416-09/91): a current, i.e., not contingent, liability created under a contractual arrangement through provision of value in assets (including currency) or services, requiring the obligor to make one or more payments in assets or services according to a specific schedule. Primary forms: loans, suppliers’ credits, and leases. Arrears, penalties, and judicially-awarded damages arising from failure to make payment under a contractual obligation that constitutes debt are debt.
- Debt guarantees by the PS: an explicit legal obligation to service a debt in the event of non-payment by the borrower (payment in cash or in kind).
- Debt concessionality: an external debt is considered concessional if it includes a grant element of at least 35 percent.
- External debt: debt contracted or serviced with and to non-residents. Excludes debt issued domestically by the PS and held by non-residents.
- Arrears on external debt: all debt-service obligations (principal and interest) on loans contracted or guaranteed by the PS that are due but not paid on the due date as set out in the loan contract; exclude those arising from obligations being renegotiated with external creditors and/or those that are litigious.
- Program exchange rate for FY2015 and FY2016: 47 gourdes per dollar.
- Gross international reserves (GIR) of the BRH: external assets readily available and controlled by monetary authorities for balance of payments financing needs, exchange market intervention, and related purposes; must be foreign currency assets that actually exist. Swaps in foreign currency with domestic financial institutions and pledged or encumbered reserve assets are excluded from GIR.
- Net international reserves (NIR) of the BRH: BRH’s gross foreign exchange assets (monetary gold, all claims on nonresidents, SDR holdings, and BRH claims in foreign currency on domestic financial institutions) minus gross short-term reserve-related liabilities, minus foreign currency deposits of commercial banks at the BRH (Dépôts à vue en dollars U.S. et en Euros des BCM à la BRH, and the CAM transfer), all from Table 10R (Table 3).
- Monetary Base (for the ECF): stock of currency in circulation outside commercial banks; plus Gourde sight deposits of commercial banks (Dépôts a vue en gourdes des BCM a la BRH); plus cash-in-vault of commercial banks (Encaisses des BCM), all from Table 10R.
- Net Domestic Assets (NDA) of the BRH: stock of currency in circulation (paragraph 24) minus NIR (in U.S. dollars, paragraph 23) converted into Gourdes at the program exchange rate (paragraph 21).

### Quantitative Performance Criteria (QPCs) and targets
- QPCs for 2015-16 include ceilings on:
  - the change in net BRH credit to the NFPS (paragraph 7);
  - the change in the NDA of the BRH (paragraph 25);
  - the change in NDF of the CG (paragraph 10);
  - the deficit of the NFPS (paragraph 13).
- QPCs also include:
  - a zero ceiling for accumulation of arrears on external public debt, to be evaluated continuously;
  - a zero ceiling on the new contracting or guaranteeing by the public sector of non-concessional external debt;
  - a floor on the change in the NIR of the BRH.
- Government commitment:
  - not to contract or guarantee any non-concessional external debt beyond ceilings identified in MEFP Table 1. Applies to external debt as defined in paragraphs 16 and 19, with concessionality defined in paragraph 18.
  - applies to any private debt guaranteed by the government that constitutes a contingent government liability as defined in paragraph 17.
  - Exclusions from the ceiling: short-term import-related credits; rescheduling arrangements; borrowing from the Fund; non-resident purchases of treasury bills; and gourde-denominated BRH bills indexed to the exchange rate.
  - This commitment is a performance criterion, to be observed continuously.

### Adjustment mechanisms for targets
- The ceilings on the change in net BRH credit to the NFPS, the change in the NDA of the BRH, the change in NDF of the CG, and the deficit of the NFPS will be adjusted upwards, and the floor on the change in the NIR of the BRH will be adjusted downwards, if budget support grants are lower than programmed, as shown in Table 2.
  - The adjustor applies provided deviations are temporary and reflect delays in disbursements of programmed, already identified amounts.
  - The adjustor will not be applied if deviations are not temporary.
  - Staff and authorities will consult with donors to determine whether deviations in timing or amounts can be considered temporary.
  - Staff consider deviations temporary if amounts are to be disbursed within the fiscal year, or during the first quarter of the following fiscal year, at the latest.
- Specific caps:
  - The ceiling on NDF of the CG will be adjusted upwards if NEF of the CG is lower than programmed, as shown in Table 1. This adjustment will be capped at US$10 million.
  - The deficit of the NFPS will be adjusted upwards, if NEF of the CG is higher than programmed, as shown in Table 1. This adjustment will be capped at US$20 million.
  - If NEF of the CG is higher than programmed by more than US$20 million, NDF to the CG will be adjusted downwards by the difference between the additional external financing and US$20 million.

### Indicative Targets (ITs) and memorandum items
- The only IT in the program: a floor on poverty-reducing expenditures of the CG measured on a cumulative yearly basis.
- Memorandum item to be included in the quantitative performance criteria table: the cumulative change in the stock of GIR.

### Prior Actions (PAs)
- PA 1: Adoption of a revised budget for the central government for FY2015. The government will adopt a revised budget consistent with a deficit for the NFPS of at most G13.5 billion.
- PA 2: Adoption of a revised budget for EDH for FY2015. The Board of EDH will adopt a revised budget for FY2015 consistent with savings of at least G3.4 billion during FY2015.
- PA 3: Adoption of an automatic price mechanism for refined oil products (gasoline 95, diesel, and kerosene). Prior action: publication (in the official gazette or a newspaper of large circulation) of Circulaire interministeriel portant application d’une décision adoptée par le Premier Ministre (the “Circular”) stating:
  - (i) the law of 1995 establishing the automatic price mechanism will be applied from end-June 2015 at the latest;
  - (ii) beginning from end-June 2015, after each shipment, the Ministry of Finance (MEF) will publish (in a newspaper of large circulation) the theoretical price structure for each product, the price structure in application, and the theoretical value for stock of the stabilization margin;
  - (iii) the application of points (i) and (ii) will begin before end-June 2015 if the value of the stabilization margin decreases below G -1 billion (minus G 1 billion); in such a case, pump prices will be increased so the value of the stabilization margin never decreases below G -1 billion. From end-June 2015 onwards: pump prices will be adjusted upwards so as to avoid at all times that the value of the stabilization margin decreases below G -1 billion. If the stabilization margin surpasses G 1 billion (plus G 1 billion), pump prices could be adjusted downwards.
  - The theoretical value of the stabilization margin at mid-March 2015 was minus G 27 million as of March 2015 (Table 4).
  - Authorities will share with Fund staff the effective import prices, and commit to revise the price structure to include effective import prices instead of “Caribbean posting” quotations as soon as possible.
- PA 4: Treasury Single Account (TSA) and accounting centers. Protocol signed (December 2014) between MEF and BRH to transform current BRH accounts into sub-accounts. Prior actions include:
  - (i) The Treasury will send technical specifications to the BRH and the BRH will produce a pilot IT solution for accounting centers under “Economic Sector I" (generalization to all accounting centers in stages);
  - (ii) The MEF and BRH will regroup government accounts at the BRH to identify dormant accounts to be closed and accounts to be transformed into TSA sub-accounts;
  - The MEF will analyze government accounts still open in commercial banks (state-owned and private) with a view to closing them or passing them under MEF control.
  - Prior actions associated with MEF decision adopted on December 18, 2014:
    - (i) MEF will ensure that all accounts open at the BRH and the BNC (Banque Nationale de Crédit) are under the control of a public accountant;
    - (ii) BRH will allow public accountants access to the accounts under their responsibility.
  - Prior action associated with memorandum of understanding signed in March 2015 between the BRH and BNC:
    - (i) tax revenues collected by the BNC on behalf of the Tax department (DGI) and the customs department (AGD) will begin to be transferred to the central treasury account within 48 hours.
  - Prior action related with implementation of accounting centers:
    - (i) five new accounting centers will be installed: Accounting Center Economic Sector III; Accounting Center Economic Sector IV; Accounting Center Political Sector I; Accounting Center Political Sector II; and Central Accounting Center.

### Key projected figures (as presented in tables)
- Table 1: Projected External Net Financing of the Central Government (Cumulative fiscal flows since end-September 2014, in millions of gourdes)
  - Net Financing: Jun-15 5,426; Sep-15 6,850; Dec-15 8,909; Mar-16 10,967; Jun-16 13,026
  - Loans (net): Jun-15 5,426; Sep-15 6,850; Dec-15 8,909; Mar-16 10,967; Jun-16 13,026
    - Disbursements: Jun-15 6,788; Sep-15 8,803; Dec-15 11,574; Mar-16 14,344; Jun-16 17,115
      - Of which: Petrocaribe: Jun-15 6,312; Sep-15 8,099; Dec-15 10,303; Mar-16 12,507; Jun-16 14,711
      - Project loans: Jun-15 476; Sep-15 704; Dec-15 1,271; Mar-16 1,837; Jun-16 2,404
    - Amortization: Jun-15 -1,362; Sep-15 -1,953; Dec-15 -2,665; Mar-16 -3,377; Jun-16 -4,089
  - Arrears (net): Jun-15 0; Sep-15 0; Dec-15 0; Mar-16 0; Jun-16 0
- Table 2: Projected Quarterly Budget Support Disbursements (Cumulative flows since end-September 2014, in millions of U.S. dollars)
  - Donor: European Union: Jun-15 0.0; Sep-15 36.7; Dec-15 36.7; Mar-16 36.7; Jun-16 36.7
  - Donor: IDB: Jun-15 27.0; Sep-15 27.0; Dec-15 27.0; Mar-16 54.0; Jun-16 54.0
  - Total: Jun-15 27.0; Sep-15 63.7; Dec-15 63.7; Mar-16 90.7; Jun-16 90.7
- Table 3: Net International Reserves BRH, End-September 2014 (In millions of U.S. dollars)
  - A. Gross Foreign Exchange Reserves: 1,913.7
  - B. Gross Liabilities: 290.7
  - C. Net Foreign Assets (=A-B): 1,623.0
  - D. FX deposits of commercial banks and CAM transfer at the BRH: 731.3
  - E. SDR allocation (liability): 118.7
  - J. NIR (=C-D+E): 1,010.4
  - Note: Source: Haitian authorities; and Fund staff estimates. 1/ Figures are preliminary.
- Table 4: Accumulation of Stabilization Fund as of March, 2015 (January-March, in millions of gourdes)
  - Gasoline 95: 30
  - Diesel: -66
  - Kerosene: -9
  - Total: -27

*Italic: Source: IMF staff and Haitian authorities as presented in the TMU (ECF arrangement 2015–18).*

### 36.      Automatic Fuel Price Adjustment Mechanism. The implementation of the automatic price

### 36. Automatic Fuel Price Adjustment Mechanism

### Automatic Fuel Price Adjustment Mechanism
- The implementation of the automatic price mechanism as discussed in paragraph 34 will be a structural benchmark to be observed continuously.
- The automatic fuel price adjustment mechanism will begin implementation by end-June 2015, at the latest, unless the stabilization margin decreases below G -1 billion, as explained in paragraph 34.
- If the stabilization margin decreases below G -1 billion, pump prices will be adjusted upwards so the stabilization margin is at all times above G -1 billion.
- Implementation of the mechanism will be monitored through the calculation of the value for the stock of the stabilization margin (on a monthly basis) as described in paragraph 34.

### Payment of unpaid off-budget Central Government (CG) commitments
- If at any point during the life of the program unpaid off-budget expenditures give rise to claims on the central government, the Ministry of Finance, before recognizing them as debts, will:
  - (i) analyze the supporting documentation to establish the appropriateness of their nature (as effective public spending);
  - (ii) before such commitments are cleared, incorporate them in the budget through a revision.
- This structural benchmark will be observed continuously.
- Monitoring requires the Ministry of Finance to report to IMF staff (on a monthly basis) the stock and composition of off-budget CG commitments that arrive at the Treasury.

### Electricity sector reforms and EDH protocol
- The Prime Minister, the Minister of Public Works, the Minister of Finance, EDH, and other stakeholders will sign a protocol by end-June 2015, at the latest.
- The protocol will lay out obligations of stakeholders to achieve targeted improvement in sector performance and will include provisions regarding:
  - revision of electricity tariffs;
  - penalties for non-payment;
  - elimination of cross-arrears;
  - review of contracts with IPPs;
  - increase in transparency, including finalization of an audit of EDH;
  - better data production and diffusion to allow for better monitoring.

### Tax policy and tax administration reforms
- Establish a working group for drafting the tax code (under the reform unit) by end-July 2015 to:
  - put all tax laws into a general tax code;
  - eliminate a large number of small taxes (“taxes de nuisance”) with low yield and high administrative costs.
- The working group will produce the preliminary draft by end-July 2016.
- Strengthening the medium taxpayers’ office (MTO):
  - The large taxpayers’ office (LTO) and local tax offices will complete transfer of all medium-size taxpayer files to the MTO by end-August 2015.
- Implement a program to ensure compliance of importers with an annual turnover above G10 million but who are not currently covered by LTO/MTO (End-April 2016).
  - The Customs Department (AGD) will regularly communicate to the Tax Department (DGI) import activity information generated by ASYCUDA to identify new large taxpayers.

### Fiscal targets and NFPS deficit
- The Central Government and EDH will adopt budgets for FY2016 consistent with a deficit for the NFPS of 2.3 percent of GDP in line with the program.
- These actions will be completed by end-September 2015.

### Accounting centers, systems interfacing, and capacity building
- Accounting centers 1 and 2 of the economic sector were split into four accounting centers (ACES I, II, III, and IV). All established accounting centers are operational since the first half of FY2014.
- A training plan for public accountants and budget administrators is planned for April 2015.
- Authorities will implement interfacing of the information systems of revenues collection (TAX-solution and SYDONIA) with the accounting system (GL) in line with the already established timetable.
- The plan to set up other accounting centers continues in line with the already established timetable; completion by end-September 2015.

### Cadastre and property rights
- An inter-ministerial commission on land management has been established.
- With donor assistance, the commission is conducting an inventory of the cadastre on a pilot basis in a number of municipalities.
- The commission will transmit an action plan for FY2016-FY2017 to strengthen the legal framework and functioning of the cadastre in Haiti by no later than end-February 2016.

### EDH client audit and tariff analysis
- EDH will, before end-March 2016, complete the audit of the 200 largest clients.
- EDH will have a first analysis of EDH tariff determination and penalties for non-payment, and an updated action plan for FY2016–FY2018.

### Monitoring and reporting of structural benchmarks
- Information concerning the implementation of measures constituting structural benchmarks will be reported to IMF staff no later than two weeks after their scheduled implementation date.

### Data provision for program monitoring — reporting requirements (selected items and frequencies preserved verbatim)
- Real Sector
  - National Accounts: Annual — Year-end + 3 months
  - Quarterly Economic Indicators (Conjoncture Economique): Quarterly — Quarter-End + 2 months
  - Consumer Price Index Breakdowns: Monthly — Month-End + 3 weeks
- Public Finance
  - Fiscal Revenues (internal, external, other): Weekly — Week-end + 1 week (4 weeks final data)
  - Expenditures on Cash Basis (wages and salaries, goods and services, external debt, current accounts): Weekly — Week-end + 1 week (4 weeks final data)
  - Central Government TOFE (Tableau des Operations Financières de l’Etat): Montly — Month-end + 2 weeks
  - Table on Current Accounts (Balance des Comptes Courants et de Fonctionment des Projets): Montly — Month-end + one month
  - Table Underlying TOFE, which enables the determination of checks in circulation and balance on invesmtent project accounts: Montly — Month-end + one month
  - Report of Revenue Collection of DGI (Rapport d'activités): Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Tables of revenue collection of AGD (Indicateurs d’activités aux ports, Rapport analytique des perceptions douanières à l'importation): Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Balance of BMPAD accounts, including (i) financing under the Petrocaribe agreement by shipment and terms therof; (ii) transfers to project accounts; (ii) transfers to IPPs; and (iv) transfers to EDH.: Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Balance of PetroCaribe/ALBA-related deposits at commercial banks and the BRH, in gourdes and in foreign currency.: Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Report on Poverty-Reducing Expenditures: Quarterly — 30-day lag (final data)
  - Table on the implementation of the PSUGO program: Quarterly — 30-day lag (final data)
  - Tableau de Bord of the the state electricity utility EDH showing monthly information on the production of electricity, making explicit the composition of production by IPP, EDH, and by region: Monthly — 30-day lag (final data)
  - Information of any off-budget claims presented for payment: Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Stock of unpaid off-budget CG commitments.: Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Data on all fuel shipments per product giving the CIF import price, the full price structure (including “marge de stabilization”) and import and consumption quantities. Data on actual collections for each month with a decomposition per product and tax type.: Monthly — Month-end + one week
  - Balance of the stock of the Stabilization Fund for fuel products: Monthly — Month-end + one week
- Monetary and Financial Data
  - Exchange Rate: Daily — Day-end + one day
  - Monetary base and sources thereof under the program definition, broad definition (sens large), and currency in circulation.: Weekly — Week-end + one week
  - Aide Memoire Table containing, inter alia: (i) Stock of BRH bonds; (ii) Deposits at commercial banks; (iii) credit to private sector (in gourdes and U.S. dollars; (iv) details of inflows and outflows of foreign exchange reserves including budget support received; (v) volume of FX transactions including BRH sales and purchases; (vi) gross and net international reserves; and (vii) net BRH credit to the central government and non-financial public sector.: Weekly — Week-end + one week
  - Statistiques monétaires tables showing, inter alia, the balance sheet of the BRH (Table 10R) and the consolidated banking sector (Table 20R): Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - FMI Weekly Tables showing, inter alia, the average and weighted interest rates on gourde and U.S. dollar-denominated deposits and credit; and excess reserves in the banking system.: Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Information on the composition of gross reserves; based on the template provided by STA expert in March 2015.: Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Banking supervision statistics and financial indicators on commerical banks: Quarterly — Quarter-end + one month
  - The calendar and planned placements of BRH bills including to banks and non banks, including in gourdes and in dollar indexed bonds: Quarterly — Quarter-end + one month
  - Audited Financial Statements of the BRH: Yearly — Year-end + three months
- Balance of Payments
  - Balance of Payments: Quarterly — Quarter-end + one month
  - Revised Balance of Payments: Quarterly — 3 months after original submission
  - BRH FX cash flow table (Tableau de tresorerie de devises); quarterly projections through end of fiscal year.: Quarterly — Quarter-end + one month
- External Debt
  - External debt report (Rapport Dette Externe) prepared by the BRH showing monthly disbursements; debt service, debt forgiveness and rescheduling, arrears, and debt stocks.: Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Details on any nonconcessional external public debt and debt guaranteed by the government, including those excluded from the ceiling as described in paragraph xx.: Monthly — Month-end + one month
  - Data on outstanding balances, accumulation, and repayment of external arrears will be forwarded within six weeks after the end of each month.: Monthly — Month-end + six weeks

*Source: _cr15157 - 36.      Automatic Fuel Price Adjustment Mechanism. The implementation of the automatic price*

### 3. Venezuela's macroeconomic

### 3. Venezuela's macroeconomic situation worsens

### Policy Response
- Strengthen business climate to make full use of advantages in HOPE/HELP acts, including by enhancing the efficiency of electricity sector and of the PIP.
- Increase exchange rate flexibility.
- Keep Petrocaribe-related deposits at adequate levels by adjusting spending plans to available resources.
- Promote domestic revenue mobilization.
- Accelerate reforms aimed at EDH's financial sustainability.
- Seek additional budget support.

### Fund relations and financial position (as reported for Haiti, as of March 31, 2015)
- Quota: 81.90; Percent of Quota: 100.00
- Fund holdings of currency: 81.83; Percent of Quota: 99.92
- Reserve position in Fund: 0.07; Percent of Quota: 0.08
- SDR Department net cumulative allocation: 78.51; Percent of Allocation: 100.00
- SDR Department holdings: 68.81; Percent of Allocation: 87.64
- Outstanding Purchases and Loans: ECF Arrangement 40.95; Percent of Quota: 50.00
- Financial Arrangements (selected approvals and amounts):
  - ECF approved 07/21/2010–12/24/2014: 40.95 approved; 40.95 drawn
  - ECF 11/20/2006–01/29/2010: 180.18 approved; 180.18 drawn
  - ECF 10/18/1996–10/17/1999: 91.05 approved; 15.18 drawn
- Projected Payments to the Fund (SDR million; as presented):
  - Principal                                                        2.464.266.72                                                        7.70
  - Charges/Interest                                           0.010.010.01                                           0.06
  - Total                                                             2.464.266.72                                                             7.76

### Joint World Bank–IMF assessment and program priorities
- Electricity sector identified as a top reform priority because:
  - Large fiscal costs crowd out other public spending.
  - Poor and unreliable electricity service is a key obstacle to economic development.
- Incorporation of electricity sector issues into the ECF arrangement and coordination with the electricity utility and government ministries is ongoing.
- Debt Sustainability Analysis (DSA) findings:
  - Haiti’s risk of debt distress improved from high to moderate on the back of significantly lower oil prices and some fiscal consolidation.
  - The balance of risks remains to the downside; a rebound in oil prices would increase likelihood of debt distress and could raise the risk of external debt distress to high again.
  - The cost of a sudden stop of Petrocaribe inflows would be lower than previously assessed (EBS/14/33) provided oil prices remain at lower levels.
  - Given extreme sensitivity of Haiti’s debt to shocks, improvements in the risk of debt distress should be interpreted with caution.
- Recommended policy priorities:
  - Maintain prudent macroeconomic policies.
  - Strengthen debt management and public financial management.
  - Deepen structural reforms to boost exports and growth.
  - Implement an automatic fuel price mechanism together with targeted mitigating measures to guard against a rebound in prices while protecting the most vulnerable.

### Statistical and data shortcomings affecting surveillance
- General: Data provision has serious shortcomings that significantly hamper surveillance; most affected are national accounts and labor indicators. Fiscal and external sector data are broadly adequate but need improvements in coverage and timeliness.
- National Accounts and Real Sector Data:
  - Only preliminary estimates of national accounts have been published since the January 2010 earthquake; final results are no longer published.
  - Base year of constant price GDP data is 1986/1987; staff aim to move the base year from 1986/87 to 2012 and improve compilation methods.
  - Incomplete and untimely reporting on agricultural sector performance; lack of an overall quarterly economic indicator to estimate quarterly GDP.
- Price and Labor Statistics:
  - CPI compiled using a 2000 household survey structure and 2004 as reference year; index follows Laspeyres methodology and comprises 287 products.
  - Separate estimates for inflation of local and imported goods are not consistent with the headline survey.
  - No labor statistics are published.
- Government Finance Statistics:
  - Monthly “Table of Government Financial Operations” (TOFE) provided for program monitoring; presentation broadly adequate but with weaknesses: limited coverage, high aggregation, misclassifications, non-reporting of major categories such as net lending, financing and Petrocaribe-related operations, and incomplete information on debt service.
  - Need to improve timeliness of accounts of autonomous agencies and public enterprises, particularly the electricity utility EDH, and establish accounts of the nonfinancial public sector.
  - Authorities encouraged to establish a plan for migrating to the GFSM 2001/2014 framework.
- Monetary and Financial Statistics:
  - Monthly balance sheets of the central bank and consolidated banking sector broadly adequate but with some central bank–commercial bank inconsistencies.
  - Need to expand coverage to include credit unions and cooperatives and to improve timeliness of reporting.
- External Sector Statistics:
  - Balance of payments data broadly adequate but suffers from deficiencies in scope, source data, and timeliness; large errors and omissions indicate incomplete coverage of current and financial account transactions.
  - Special attention needed to customs data coverage, classification of post-earthquake official and private flows, and recording of external assets and liabilities of the private sector.

### Technical assistance and coordination
- Significant IMF technical assistance missions since November 2012 across FAD, MCM, STA, and LEG covering Tax Administration, Energy Subsidy Reform, Mining Taxation, Cash and Treasury Management, Value-Added Tax, Public Accounting, Macro-fiscal work, Reserve Management Guidelines, Foreign Exchange Market, Credit Union Supervision, National Accounts Statistics, Consumer Price Index, and drafting of tax laws.
- Joint Bank–Fund work program and coordination ongoing, including a joint Bank-Fund Debt Sustainability Analysis (Update) ongoing with expected delivery May 2015.

*Prepared by the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank; May 6, 2015.*

### 1.      At end-2014, Haiti’s stock of public sector debt amounted to US$2,279 million,

### 1.      At end-2014, Haiti’s stock of public sector debt amounted to US$2,279 million,

### Overview of public sector debt at end-2014
- Total public sector debt: US$2,279 million (24.8 percent of GDP), composed almost exclusively by external debt on concessional terms.
- External debt: US$1,825 million.
  - Multilateral debt: US$136 million.
  - Bilateral debt: US$1,690 million, mainly to Venezuela (US$1,574 million of Petrocaribe debt).
- Domestic public debt: about US$230 million, mostly in the form of treasury bills largely held by commercial banks.
- Publicly guaranteed debt: about US$45 million contracted by state-owned electricity company EDH (Electricité d’Haïti).
- Other creditor/debtor positions:
  - Public sector net creditor to consolidated banking system due to Petrocaribe and other deposits at commercial banks: about US$228 million at end-2014.
  - Public sector debtor position vis-à-vis independent power producers (IPPs) for EDH arrears: about US$350 million.
  - IPPs’ arrears to the central government for provision of fuel: US$200 million at end-2014.

### Macroeconomic outlook, 2015–35 (baseline assumptions and fiscal framework)
- Growth and prices:
  - Annual average real GDP growth of about 3.4 percent, starting from 2.5 percent growth rate in 2015, increasing to 3.8 by 2019, and then declining progressively to 3 percent by 2035.
  - A stable real exchange rate vis-à-vis the US dollar.
  - Oil prices projected to decline in 2015 and increase gradually in 2016–20 in line with WEO, and to remain constant in real terms thereafter.
- Fiscal projections and public expenditure:
  - Upfront fiscal consolidation, with positive fiscal impact of lower oil prices locked in.
  - Domestic revenues of the central government increase to about 18.4 percent of GDP by 2035 (from 12.5 percent in 2014).
  - Foreign grants gradually decrease to about 2 percent of GDP (from 6.5 percent of GDP in 2014).
  - Primary expenditure (including EDH’s deficit) projected to decline from 27.8 percent of GDP in 2014 to 21.1 percent in 2035.
  - Capital expenditure (domestically and externally financed) stabilizes at 10 percent of GDP by 2035.
  - Adjustment in NFPS primary balance of about 6 percentage points of GDP during the projection period.
  - Primary deficit in 2035 about 0.6 percent of GDP, consistent with a decreasing debt ratio.
- External sector assumptions:
  - Trade deficit improves from 32.8 percent of GDP in 2014 to 13.5 percent in 2035.
  - FDI increases from 1.1 percent of GDP in 2014 to 3.7 percent in 2035.
  - Petrocaribe debt inflows decrease significantly given reduced oil bill (from 11.1 percent of GDP in 2014 to 8.2 percent of GDP in 2010 (the end of the WEO projection period)).
  - Transfers (official and remittances) decline from 26.3 percent of GDP in 2014 to 11.2 percent in 2035.
- Financing and debt issuance assumptions:
  - Gross financing needs average about 3.3 percent of GDP per year.
  - Financing composition: external debt flows about 3.0 percent of GDP and the rest by domestic debt (and deposit withdrawals in 2015–17).
  - External borrowing assumed almost evenly split between Petrocaribe flows and additional external bilateral borrowing at concessional terms.
  - Domestic borrowing limited to treasury bills with 1–5 year maturities and 8.8 percent interest rate (in US$ terms).
  - Withdrawals of PCDR account balances projected for 2015–17 totalling 1.6 percent of GDP.

### Key baseline projection tables and comparative figures
- Text Table 1 (Structure of External Public Debt at end-2014) highlights:
  - Total external debt US$1,825.4 million (100.0 total debt; 21.0 percent of GDP).
  - Multilateral creditors total US$135.7 million (7.4 total debt; 1.6 percent of GDP), including IMF US$57.2 million (3.1 total debt; 0.7 percent of GDP) and IFAD US$61.0 million (3.3 total debt; 0.7 percent of GDP).
  - Official bilateral creditors US$1,689.7 million (92.6 total debt; 19.4 percent of GDP), with Venezuela US$1,600.4 million (87.8 total debt; 18.4 percent of GDP), PetroCaribe US$1,573.7 million (86.2 total debt; 18.1 percent of GDP), BANDES US$26.7 million (1.5 total debt; 0.3 percent of GDP), Taiwan, Province of China US$89.3 million (4.9 total debt; 1.0 percent of GDP).
- Text Table 2 (DSA 2015 vs. DSA 2014) selected comparisons (average 2013-17 vs. 2018-31 where noted):
  - Real GDP: Previous DSA 4.1; Current DSA 3.3 (2013-17) and 3.5 (2018-31) vs. Current DSA figures 3.5.
  - Consumer prices (period average): Previous DSA 5.3; Current DSA 6.0 (2013-17) and 5.0 (2018-31).
  - Total revenue and grants: Previous DSA 20.6; Current DSA 20.2 (2013-17) and 20.7 (2018-31) vs. Current DSA 20.5.
  - Revenue: Previous DSA 13.4; Current DSA 13.9 (2013-17) and 16.0 (2018-31) vs. Current DSA 16.4.
  - Primary expenditure: Previous DSA 26.6; Current DSA 23.8 (2013-17) and 24.4 (2018-31) vs. Current DSA 22.0.
  - Capital expenditure: Previous DSA 14.6; Current DSA 11.9 (2013-17) and 11.5 (2018-31) vs. Current DSA 10.6.
  - Overall balance: Previous DSA -6.5; Current DSA -4.1 (2013-17) and -4.5 (2018-31) vs. Current DSA -2.1.
  - Current account balance: Previous DSA -5.9; Current DSA -4.7 (2013-17) and -5.0 (2018-31) vs. Current DSA -3.5.
  - Exports of goods and services: Previous DSA 18.5; Current DSA 19.1 (2013-17) and 21.3 (2018-31) vs. Current DSA 21.3.
  - Imports of goods and services: Previous DSA -49.8; Current DSA -49.1 (2013-17) and -44.6 (2018-31) vs. Current DSA -43.5.

### Debt sustainability outlook, 2015–35
- Projected public debt trajectory:
  - Public debt grows from about 25 percent of GDP in 2014 to 39 percent of GDP in 2035.
  - External debt grows from around 21.4 percent of GDP in 2014 to 30.5 percent of GDP in 2035.
- Composition and terms:
  - External debt accumulation lower than previous DSA due to lower Petrocaribe inflows.
  - Grant element of new borrowing increases slightly from 36 percent to 38 percent due to greater resort to multilateral financing.
- Risk assessment:
  - Haiti’s risk of external debt distress improved from high to moderate under the baseline.
  - No debt threshold breached under the baseline scenario.
  - Debt service-to-exports and debt service-to-revenue ratios do not breach thresholds under baseline but are on an upward trend.
  - A permanent 50 percent increase in oil prices would breach most thresholds and return to high debt distress.
  - An increase by 200 bps in the interest rate over the entire projection period would cause PV of debt-to-exports and PV of debt-to-GDP ratios to be breached starting from FY2028.
  - Shocks to growth and the primary balance would lead to unsustainably high public debt indicators; PV of debt-to-GDP threshold exceeded by FY2028 under such shocks.

### Increased stress scenarios
- Sudden Stop of Petrocaribe inflows:
  - Likelihood increased since last DSA due to Venezuela’s tighter financing constraints from lower oil prices.
  - A sudden stop starting in FY2016 would reduce investment spending and financing of the electricity sector, negatively affecting growth.
  - Expected short-term cushioning via decrease in domestic revenues, drawdown of government deposits (including Petrocaribe deposits), reduction in international reserves, and additional bilateral assistance.
  - Net effect: decline in oil prices causes automatic decrease in Petrocaribe financing; lower Petrocaribe flows (1.3 percent of GDP on average in 2015-17) more than offset by improvement in oil bill (3.3 percent of GDP on average during 2015-17).
  - Stop of residual Petrocaribe flows (2.0 percent on average during 2015-17) expected to subtract about 1 percent point from growth in FY2016–FY2017.
  - Stock of public debt remains broadly unchanged and risk of external debt distress remains moderate; debt ratios deteriorate slightly but are broadly unchanged at end of projection period due to faster fiscal consolidation.
- Rebound of oil prices:
  - Permanent 50 percent increase in oil prices in 2016 would decrease GDP growth and increase fiscal pressures, particularly via higher costs for electricity generation and EDH’s deficit.
  - Under this scenario, debt stock would increase to above 50 percent of GDP by 2035.
  - Risk of external debt distress would become high; ratios of PV of debt to GDP, to exports and to revenue breached by 2020–2021.
  - Debt remains vulnerable to terms and depreciation shocks; debt service ratios to revenue and exports on upward trend.

### Policy implications and recommendations
- Maintain prudent macroeconomic policies to preserve debt sustainability gains.
- Strengthen effectiveness of public investment and public financial management (PFM), and improve debt management.
- Improve sustainability of the electricity sector to limit fiscal pressures from EDH’s deficit and related arrears.
- Implement structural reforms to improve the investment climate, boost exports and growth, and raise growth toward LIC averages as assumed in the DSA.
- Use the window created by lower oil prices to adopt good energy policies that lock in fiscal and efficiency gains.

*International Monetary Fund staff assessment as presented in the DSA update for Haiti.*

### 16.      The authorities broadly concurred with the main findings of the DSA. Staff and the authorities

### 16. The authorities broadly concurred with the main findings of the DSA. Staff and the authorities

### Authorities’ views and reform implementation
- The authorities broadly concurred with the main findings of the DSA.
- Staff and the authorities discussed the main assumptions and conclusions of the updated DSA, as well as main risks affecting the baseline.
- The authorities agreed with the need to increase the yield on growth of public investment, and more generally to contain the primary deficit of the non-financial public sector, in view of the financing risks.
- The authorities agreed on the need to speed up the implementation of reforms, but highlighted constraints slowing the process, including:
  - the complexity of some reforms; and
  - lengthy discussions originated in the presence of vested interests.
- Note: Discussions were held on a Seminar on Debt Sustainability in Port-au-Prince, during February 2015.

### Baseline public sector debt trajectory (selected figures from Table 1)
- Public sector debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 15.8
  - 2013: 19.5
  - 2014: 24.1
  - 2015: 25.5
  - 2016: 26.4
  - 2017: 27.2
  - 2018: 28.2
  - 2019: 28.9
  - 2020: 29.3
  - 2025: 33.2
  - 2035: 34.4
- Of which: foreign-currency denominated (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 13.8
  - 2013: 17.7
  - 2014: 21.4
  - 2015: 22.4
  - 2016: 23.0
  - 2017: 23.6
  - 2018: 24.2
  - 2019: 24.7
  - 2020: 25.3
  - 2025: 30.2
  - 2035: 32.2
- Change in public sector debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 4.3
  - 2013: 3.7
  - 2014: 4.6
  - 2015: 1.4
  - 2016: 0.9
  - 2017: 0.8
  - 2018: 1.0
  - 2019: 0.7
  - 2020: 0.4
  - 2025: 0.7
  - 2035: -0.5
- Identified debt-creating flows (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 4.2
  - 2013: 7.0
  - 2014: 7.5
  - 2015: 0.8
  - 2016: 0.8
  - 2017: 0.9
  - 2018: 0.7
  - 2019: 0.6
  - 2020: 0.6
  - 2025: 0.4
  - 2035: -0.6
- Primary deficit (percent of GDP and selected averages):
  - 2012: 4.7
  - 2013: 8.0
  - 2014: 7.2
  - 2015-20 Average (noted in table): 2.1
  - 2021-35 Average (noted): 1.7
- Revenue and grants (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 23.4
  - 2013: 22.6
  - 2014: 20.6
  - 2015-20 Average: 22.1
  - 2025: 20.5
  - 2035: 20.4
- Grants (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 10.6
  - 2013: 8.1
  - 2014: 6.5
  - 2015: 6.1
  - 2016: 5.6
  - 2017: 5.3
  - 2018: 5.0
  - 2019: 4.8
  - 2020: 4.8
  - 2025: 4.1
  - 2035: 2.0
- Primary (noninterest) expenditure (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 28.1
  - 2013: 30.6
  - 2014: 27.8
  - 2015-20 Average: 25.2
  - 2025: 22.2
  - 2035: 21.1
- Automatic debt dynamics (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: -0.5
  - 2013: -0.9
  - 2014: -0.3
  - 2015-20 Average: -0.6
  - 2025: -1.3
  - 2035: -1.3
- Gross financing need 2/ (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 6.7
  - 2013: 10.2
  - 2014: 12.3
  - 2015-20 Average: 7.8
  - 2025: 7.1
  - 2035: 5.5
- PV of public sector debt-to-revenue and grants ratio (percent):
  - 2015-20 Average entries include: 84.5, 84.7, 89.4, 91.3, 94.6, 96.4, 94.8, 117.7, 123.7
- Debt service-to-revenue and grants ratio (percent) 4/ (selected values):
  - 2012: 0.6
  - 2013: 3.9
  - 2014: 18.8
  - 2015-20 Average: 12.5
  - 2025: 12.1
  - 2035: 13.4
- Primary deficit that stabilizes the debt-to-GDP ratio (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 0.4
  - 2013: 4.3
  - 2014: 2.6
  - 2015-20 Average: 1.7
  - 2025: 1.0
  - 2035: 1.1

### Key macroeconomic and fiscal assumptions (selected)
- Real GDP growth (in percent):
  - 2012: 2.9
  - 2013: 4.2
  - 2014: 2.7
  - 2015: 2.1
  - 2016: 3.0
  - 2017: 2.5
  - 2018: 3.2
  - 2019: 3.8
  - 2020: 3.7
  - 2025: 3.8
  - 2035: 3.5
  - 2015-20 Average: 3.4
  - 2021-35 Average: 3.5
- Average nominal interest rate on forex debt (in percent):
  - 2012: 0.6
  - 2013: 1.2
  - 2014: 1.0
  - 2015: 1.1
  - 2016: 0.6
  - 2017: 1.2
  - 2018: 1.2
  - 2019: 1.2
  - 2020: 1.3
  - 2025: 1.3
  - 2035: 1.3
- Average real interest rate on domestic debt (in percent):
  - 2012: -4.7
  - 2013: -3.4
  - 2014: -2.3
  - 2015: -4.3
  - 2016: 1.9
  - 2017: -3.8
  - 2018: 0.7
  - 2019: 0.4
  - 2020: 2.0
  - 2025: 2.4
  - 2035: 1.3
- Inflation rate (GDP deflator, in percent):
  - 2012: 5.3
  - 2013: 6.6
  - 2014: 3.8
  - 2015: 8.6
  - 2016: 4.8
  - 2017: 6.6
  - 2018: 6.4
  - 2019: 5.4
  - 2020: 5.0
  - 2025: 5.0
  - 2035: 5.0
- Growth of real primary spending (deflated by GDP deflator, in percent):
  - 2012: 13.5
  - 2013: 13.3
  - 2014: -6.4
  - 2015: 2.1
  - 2016: 6.3
  - 2017: -7.4
  - 2018: -1.5
  - 2019: 5.4
  - 2020: 2.8
  - 2025: 3.4
  - 2035: 6.1
- Grant element of new external borrowing (in percent):
  - 2018: 36.5
  - 2019: 37.3
  - 2020: 36.9
  - 2021: 37.0
  - 2022: 37.2
  - 2023: 37.6
  - 2024: 37.1
  - 2025: 39.2
  - 2035: 39.4

### External debt and external sustainability (selected from Table 3a)
- External debt (nominal, percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 13.8
  - 2013: 17.7
  - 2014: 21.4
  - 2015: 22.4
  - 2016: 23.0
  - 2017: 23.6
  - 2018: 24.2
  - 2019: 24.7
  - 2020: 25.3
  - 2025: 30.2
  - 2035: 32.2
- Change in external debt (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 4.9
  - 2013: 3.9
  - 2014: 3.7
  - 2015: 1.0
  - 2016: 0.6
  - 2017: 0.6
  - 2018: 0.5
  - 2019: 0.5
  - 2020: 0.6
  - 2025: 1.0
  - 2035: -0.3
- Non-interest current account deficit (percent of GDP):
  - 2012: 5.6
  - 2013: 6.2
  - 2014: 6.2
  - 2015: 2.9
  - 2016: 2.6
  - 2017: 3.3
  - 2018: 3.6
  - 2019: 3.5
  - 2020: 3.4
  - 2025: 3.3
  - 2035: 3.1
- Exports (percent of GDP) entries in table include:
  - 2012: 16.8
  - 2013: 18.6
  - 2014: 19.0
  - 2015: 19.1
  - 2016: 19.3
  - 2017: 19.5
  - 2018: 19.7
  - 2019: 19.9
  - 2020: 20.1
  - 2025: 21.2
  - 2035: 25.4
- Imports (percent of GDP) entries in table include:
  - 2012: 53.2
  - 2013: 52.3
  - 2014: 51.8
  - 2015: 47.5
  - 2016: 47.1
  - 2017: 47.0
  - 2018: 46.9
  - 2019: 46.6
  - 2020: 45.7
  - 2025: 43.2
  - 2035: 38.9
- Net current transfers (negative = inflow, percent of GDP):
  - 2012: -30.0
  - 2013: -27.0
  - 2014: -26.3
  - 2015: -30.4
  - 2016: 6.9
  - 2017: -25.6
  - 2018: -24.7
  - 2019: -24.3
  - 2020: -23.8
  - 2025: -23.3
  - 2035: -22.5
  - Longer-run entries include -19.0, -11.2, -16.6 in table columns.
- PV of external debt (percent of GDP, selected):
  - 2015-20 Average entries: 14.7, 15.7, 16.2, 16.7, 17.1, 17.5, 17.9
  - 2025: 21.2
  - 2035: 23.0
- Debt service-to-exports ratio (in percent, selected):
  - 2012: 0.7
  - 2013: 1.8
  - 2014: 2.4
  - 2015-20 Average: 3.7
  - 2025: 6.5
  - 2035: 7.6
- Total gross financing need (Billions of U.S. dollars):
  - 2012: 0.3
  - 2013: 0.4
  - 2014: 0.5
  - 2015-20 Average: 0.3
  - 2025: 0.3
  - 2035: 0.3

### Sensitivity analysis and stress scenarios (selected points from Tables 2, 3b and Figures)
- Sensitivity analyses consider alternative scenarios and bound tests, including:
  - A1. Real GDP growth and primary balance at historical averages.
  - A2. Primary balance unchanged from 2015.
  - A3. Permanently lower GDP growth.
  - A4. Petrocaribe Sudden Stop.
  - B1–B5. Bound tests including shocks to real GDP growth, primary balance, real depreciation, and increases in other debt-creating flows.
- Examples of scenario outcomes (selected ratios from Table 2 and 3b):
  - PV of Debt-to-GDP Ratio (projections under baseline and scenarios include a sequence of numbers such as 85, 89, 91, 95, 96, 95, 118, 124 in the table presentation).
  - PV of Debt-to-Revenue Ratio and Debt Service-to-Revenue Ratio show large increases under adverse scenarios and bound tests (table entries include values like 40, 42, 43, 44, 45, 47, 59, 66 in one series and values like 98, 100, 99, 99, 99, 98, 129, 125 in another).
- Figure notes:
  - The most extreme stress test is the test that yields the highest ratio on or before 2025. Specific mappings in figures identify which shock corresponds to the most extreme test for each indicator (e.g., One-time depreciation shock, Terms shock).

### Policy implications and priorities (implied by DSA and authorities’ concurrence)
- Contain the primary deficit of the non-financial public sector to mitigate financing risks.
- Increase the yield on growth of public investment to improve debt dynamics.
- Speed up implementation of structural reforms, recognizing constraints such as complexity and vested-interest delays.
- Monitor external vulnerability indicators (PV of external debt, debt service-to-exports, gross financing needs) given reliance on concessional and grant-equivalent financing.

*Sources: Country authorities; and staff estimates and projections. Statement by Paulo Nogueira Batista, Executive Director for Haiti, Oliveira Lima, Alternate Executive Director, and Ketleen Florestal, Advisor to the Executive Director, May 18, 2015.*

### 1. On behalf of our authorities, we would like to thank management and staff for the

### On behalf of our authorities, we would like to thank management and staff for the continued engagement with Haiti.

### Recent Developments
- Negotiations with Fund staff were initiated in March 2015, less than two months after a new Government took office.
- The Government had indicated, at the time of the Executive Board’s discussion of the eighth review of the last Extended Credit Facility (ECF) this past December, that it would want a successor arrangement with the Fund and specified priority areas for the new program.
- Concurrent challenges:
  - Shrinking budget funding from PetroCaribe linked to petroleum prices that had fallen rapidly.
  - Repeated strikes from different sectors; some union-led transportation strikes became violent and complicated the social and economic situation.
- Key prior actions completed, exemplifying commitment to fiscal sustainability:
  - (i) Adoption of an automatic price mechanism for refined oil products with regular price adjustments starting in June 2015.
  - (ii) Adoption by the board of Electricité d’Haiti (EDH) of a revised budget with substantial programmed savings.
- Government program objectives:
  - Remove bottlenecks to growth and strengthen the fiscal policy framework.
  - Pursue tax and fiscal administration reforms to build sustainable fiscal conditions.
  - Ambitious and comprehensive reforms including: phasing out untargeted fuel price subsidies; upgrading EDH performance; improving tax compliance and collection; strengthening the legal framework and functioning of the cadastre; enhancing access to credit.

### Electricity Sector Reforms
- Authorities view a small window of opportunity to jumpstart electricity reforms with IMF and donor support.
- Staff report and selected issues paper highlight:
  - Weak electricity sector performance as a key bottleneck to growth and a significant fiscal drain.
  - Sources of losses and inefficiencies at EDH, including onerous contracts with independent power producers and, until recently, weak coordination among donors and within public entities.
- Authorities’ stance:
  - Determined to achieve a complete overhaul in the electricity sector.
  - Acknowledge reforms will jeopardize vested interests and face strong resistance domestically and externally.
  - Confident that political will and domestic ownership can yield positive results.
  - Seek better donor coordination and enhanced accountability by domestic and external stakeholders.

### Petroleum Pricing and Subsidy Targeting
- Authorities committed to depoliticize petroleum pricing at the pump and ensure subsidies are better targeted.
- Government has sought World Bank technical support to design a program to shelter vulnerable population segments from significant price increases in public transportation.

### Monetary and Exchange Rate Policy
- Haitian authorities emphasize adherence to ECF commitments and express concerns regarding the performance criterion (PC) on net international reserves (NIRs).
- Reinforcing factors for concerns:
  - Rapid increase in petroleum prices since the close of negotiations about six weeks ago, from US$50 to US$65 per barrel.
  - Expectations of an increase in food imports due to a recent drought.
  - Prospects of a decrease in travel inflows linked to uncertainties related to the upcoming elections.
- Concern about program adjusters:
  - Program accounts for assistance confirmed at negotiation and sets caps on additional external financing that can be freely used.
  - Beyond those caps, external financing will entail a reduction in the amount of net domestic financing to the central government allowed in the program.

### On the Debt Sustainability Analysis
- Staff assesses Haiti this year to be at moderate risk of debt distress.
- Staff cautions that the change from high to moderate risk is mostly due to the fall in oil prices and ensuing improvement in the terms of trade, and recommends prudence as the oil price decrease could be temporary.
- Authorities agree continued prudence is warranted in contracting debt.
- Authorities find staff’s DSA considerations unbalanced because potential upside risk from increased economic activity in the United States — which would impact Haiti particularly through remittances — does not seem to have been considered.

### Conclusions and Policy Messages
- The Fund should support authorities’ efforts to undertake difficult reforms in an electoral year.
- Directors previously advised future Fund engagements with Haiti be guided by the Ex Post Assessment of Longer-Term Program Engagement recommendations, including the need for a more realistic policy framework and greater ownership.
- Authorities’ view on ownership:
  - Full domestic ownership requires authorities remain in the driver’s seat while the Fund helps marshal support for the program.
- Fragility context and lending innovation:
  - Haiti is a country in a fragile situation and a member of the g7+ grouping.
  - With PetroCaribe flows expected to be reduced by about 50 percent, there is a pressing need to develop innovative lending mechanisms to ease financing constraints and allow Haiti to invest in a better future.

*Source: _cr15157 - 1. On behalf of our authorities, we would like to thank management and staff for the*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/_cr15157.pdf_
