## _cr16334

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_cr16334](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2016/_cr16334.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2016/_cr16334.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2016/_cr16334.pdf.json)

---

### Recent developments
- Exports declined further in the first half of 2016, combined with settling liabilities related to the two nationalized companies, reducing international reserves to 4.4 months of imports in late August 2016.
- Hurricane Earl hit Belize in early August 2016; preliminary losses estimated about BLZ$140 million (about 4 percent of GDP), nearly half in agriculture.
- Tourism performance in the first half of 2016 has been strong; stop-over tourist arrivals increased by 16.6 percent (Jan–Jul 2016 y/y).
- Unemployment rate declined from 10.1 percent in April 2015 to 8 percent in April 2016.
- Overall fiscal deficit expanded to 8 percent of GDP in 2015:
  - One-off payment related to settlement of liabilities for one nationalized company accounted for 2.8 percent of GDP of the deterioration.
  - Structural deficit worsened due to an increase in public sector wages and transfers and a large overrun in capital expenditure.
- Public sector debt rose to 82 percent of GDP in 2015.
- Authorities increased their fuel tax, expected to raise revenues by close to 1½ percent of GDP.

### Financial sector and banking system
- Improvements:
  - Non-performing loans to total loans fell to 15.8 percent (5.7 percent net of provisions) at end-March 2016.
  - Reported capital adequacy ratio increased to 25 percent at Mar-16.
  - Provisions/NPLs rose to 60.4 percent at Mar-16 (from 57.6 percent in 2015).
- Remaining vulnerabilities:
  - Loss of a significant number of correspondent banking relationships (CBRs); only two of ten banks have CBRs with full banking services.
  - Increased transaction costs and winding down of deposits in international banks; systemic bank increased wire transfer fees from about US$ 100 to US$ 300.
  - Four banks, including the systemic bank, lost credit card settlement accounts with a small New York bank.
- Board and staff recommendations:
  - Asset quality review of all banks and enhanced stress testing adjusting capital buffers for provisioning shortfalls.
  - Maintain restrictions on lending and dividend distributions for banks with weak buffers; systemic bank restrictions and recapitalization options (including dilution of shareholders) supported.
  - Provisioning policy recommendation: raise provisioning requirements to 100 percent on loan losses (secured or not) with gradual transition; prohibit profit distribution during transition.
  - Develop capital markets and asset management companies to help clean banks’ balance sheets.
  - Strengthen AML/CFT implementation and offshore sector transparency; consider technical assistance.

### Macroeconomic outlook and risks
- GDP projections and recent performance:
  - Real GDP (percent change): 2014: 4.1; 2015: 1.0; 2016 (Proj./Revised): -1.5; 2017 (Proj./Revised): 1.9
  - Growth projected to average less than 2 percent in the medium term.
- Drivers of the outlook:
  - Declining productivity, competitiveness and public investment.
  - Damage from hurricane Earl contributed to the 2016 contraction.
- Key risks and implications:
  - Rigid current fiscal spending, particularly the public sector wage bill, would fuel high fiscal deficits and add to the high debt burden absent a radical change in policies.
  - Financing constraints would reduce public investment.
  - Current account deficit would slowly improve but remain high; external position weak.
  - Remaining payments for nationalized companies and increased debt service would reduce international reserves to uncomfortable levels.
  - Further withdrawal of CBRs and low capital buffers in some banks are key threats to financial stability.
  - Insufficient fiscal adjustment and banking system weaknesses are significant risks.

### External sector, BTL compensation, and reserves
- PCA ruling (June 28, 2016): total compensation US$ 221 million (12.2 percent of GDP).
  - Government paid US$98 million (about 5.5 percent of GDP) on July 13, 2016; remaining balance (about 4.8 percent of GDP) due by July 2017.
  - Staff revised baseline assumes about 30 percent of compensation paid in US dollars, rest in local currency.
  - Full impact on international reserves in 2016-17 close to US$60 million, reducing reserve cover by 0.5 months of imports.
- Gross international reserves (millions of U.S. dollars): 2014: 487; 2015: 437; 2016 (Proj./Revised): 364 / 395 / late-Aug 2016: US$ 432;
  - In months of imports: 2014: 4.6; 2015: 4.4; 2016 (Proj./Revised): 3.7 / 3.7 / 3.7 (late-Aug 2016 reported 4.4 months).
- Exports and imports (selected):
  - Exports of goods and services (US$ millions): 2014: 1,154; 2015: 1,112; 2016 (Proj.): 956; 2017 (Proj.): 1,011
  - Exports declined nearly 29 percent in Jan–Jul 2016 (y/y); exports of goods declined nearly 30 percent during Jan–Apr 2016 (y/y).
  - Imports of goods and services (US$ millions): 2014: 1,218; 2015: 1,258; 2016 (Proj.): 1,184; 2017 (Proj.): 1,175

### Fiscal assessment, recommendations, and measures
- Fiscal outcomes:
  - Overall balance (percent of GDP): 2014: -2.4; 2015: -8.0; 2016 (Proj./Revised): -5.0 / -4.1; 2017 (Proj./Revised): -5.6 / -5.2
  - Primary balance (percent of GDP): 2014: 0.3; 2015: -5.6; 2016 (Proj./Revised): -2.0 / -1.1; 2017 (Proj./Revised): -2.2 / -1.8
  - Stock of public and publicly guaranteed debt (end-period, percent of GDP): 2014: 77.6; 2015: 82.1; 2016 (Proj./Revised): 99.9 / 93.3; 2017 (Proj./Revised): 95.7 / 94.0
- Staff priority: urgently implement fiscal measures to improve the primary fiscal balance to about 4½ percent of GDP in the medium term (staff recommend raising primary balance to 4–5 percent of GDP by 2021 and sustaining thereafter to reduce public debt to about 60 percent of GDP by 2030).
- Recommended fiscal package (total effect on the primary balance, percent of GDP — FY2016/17 to FY2021/22):
  - Total effect on the primary balance: 1.2; 4.0; 4.5; 5.0; 5.2; 5.3
  - Total first-order effect of fiscal measures and negative factors: 1.1; 4.0; 4.6; 5.1; 5.3; 5.4
  - Expenditure measures: 0.4; 1.3; 1.9; 2.5; 2.6; 2.8
    - Reducing the wage bill: 0.0; 0.5; 0.9; 1.3; 1.3; 1.3
    - Reform of Public Sector pension plan: 0.0; 0.1; 0.1; 0.2; 0.2; 0.2
    - Freezing goods and services in real terms: 0.4; 0.5; 0.7; 0.8; 0.9; 1.0
    - Cut in transfers (excluding teachers' salaries): 0.0; 0.3; 0.3; 0.3; 0.3; 0.3
  - Revenue-enhancing measures: 0.7; 2.6; 2.6; 2.6; 2.6; 2.6
    - Streamlining GST exemptions and removing MoF's discretion: 0.3; 1.0; 1.0; 1.0; 1.0; 1.0
    - Increasing the general GST rate to 15 percent: 0.3; 1.1; 1.1; 1.1; 1.1; 1.1
    - Improving collection of import duties: 0.1; 0.3; 0.3; 0.3; 0.3; 0.3
    - Increasing excise on wine, beer and cigarrettes: 0.0; 0.4; 0.2; 0.2; 0.2; 0.2
  - Second-order macro effects: 0.0; 0.0; -0.1; -0.1; -0.1; -0.1
- Memorandum items:
  - Raising the fuel tax: 1.4; 1.4; 1.4; 1.4; 1.4; 1.4
  - Reducing import tariffs in line with WTO commitments: 0; -0.4; -0.7; -1.0; -1.0; -1.0
  - Abolishing the environmental tax: 0; -0.7; 0; 0; 0; 0
- Table 6 summary (recommended measures totals):
  - Total recommended measures: BZ$207.5 million or 4.7 percent of GDP.
  - Revenue measures total: BZ$97.2 million or 2.6 percent of GDP.
  - Expenditure measures total: BZ$109.9 million or 2.85 percent of GDP.

### Policy discussions and structural reforms
- Staff emphasized prompt measures to reduce the likelihood of a disorderly fiscal and external adjustment:
  - (i) Raise the primary fiscal balance to levels that credibly place public debt on a downward path and help rebuild investor confidence.
  - (ii) Reduce banking sector vulnerabilities and strengthen the AML/CFT framework, especially in the offshore sector.
  - (iii) Given limited fiscal space, design a credible financing strategy for the GSDS and consider growth-enhancing measures that can be implemented at no financial cost.
- Growth and Sustainable Development Strategy (GSDS):
  - GSDS pillars: penetrating export markets, attracting foreign investment, effective industrial policy, enhancing market efficiency, improving infrastructure and human capital.
  - Staff recommendations: prioritize GSDS projects, estimate costs, design realistic financing strategies, and use non-debt-creating financing options such as well-designed public-private partnerships.
- Low-cost growth-enhancing measures suggested:
  - Pass the draft credit bureau law.
  - Allow greater flexibility on employment hours in labor markets.
  - Improve outcomes in starting a business, getting credit, trading across borders, timeliness of contract dispute resolution, and strengthening small businesses.

### Correspondent banking relationships (CBRs) — diagnosis and options
- Problem:
  - Withdrawal of CBRs by global banks is a major threat; only two banks have full-service CBRs; CBB lost three of its five CBRs in last two years.
- Potential regional solutions analyzed:
  - (i) Collective action to increase business volume for a smaller number of correspondent banks.
  - (ii) Scheme to purchase CBR insurance policies.
  - (iii) Creation of a US-licensed special purpose vehicle (SPV) to process international transactions.
  - (iv) Payment of higher CBR service fees.
- Assessment and staff advice:
  - Except for the SPV, solutions require strong private sector collaboration in the US and may be costly.
  - Staff advised exploring, with regional partners, fast-track establishment or acquisition of a US-licensed financial institution to provide CBRs while ensuring effective AML/CFT implementation.
  - Temporary use of the CBB’s own CBRs is possible; regional coordination recommended.

### External Stability Assessment (Annex I) — REER, gaps, and reserves adequacy
- Key findings:
  - REER is overvalued; contributes to widening current account deficits and increasing external indebtedness.
  - CA gaps and implied REER gaps:
    - ES approach: current account gap of 7.1 percent (baseline) and 8 percent (alternative); implied average REER gaps of 16 percent (baseline) and 18.5 percent (alternative) using elasticity -0.39.
    - EBA-lite: current account gap of 6.5 percent; REER gap of 16.7 percent; fiscal policy gap of -2.5 percent of GDP; structural residual 4.4 percent of GDP.
  - Export market shares declined by nearly 15 percent between 2011 and 2015; NEER appreciated by 11 percent in 2015.
- Reserves adequacy metrics (Selected ratios of reserves to optimal reserves, in percent):
  - 2015: Risk-Weighted Measure 112; SIDS Measure 76; 3 months of Imports 139; 20% of Broad Money 152; Short Term Debt 970
  - 2016: Risk-Weighted Measure 100; SIDS Measure 73; 3 months of Imports 135; 20% of Broad Money 132; Short Term Debt 841
  - 2017: Risk-Weighted Measure 80; SIDS Measure 58; 3 months of Imports 111; 20% of Broad Money 104; Short Term Debt 680
  - 2018: Risk-Weighted Measure 65; SIDS Measure 46; 3 months of Imports 91; 20% of Broad Money 83; Short Term Debt 431
  - 2019: Risk-Weighted Measure 49; SIDS Measure 34; 3 months of Imports 69; 20% of Broad Money 61; Short Term Debt 271
  - 2020: Risk-Weighted Measure 31; SIDS Measure 21; 3 months of Imports 43; 20% of Broad Money 37; Short Term Debt 174
  - 2021: Risk-Weighted Measure 12; SIDS Measure 8; 3 months of Imports 17; 20% of Broad Money 14; Short Term Debt 71
- Policy implication: tighten fiscal policy and implement structural reforms to close fiscal and structural gaps and preserve reserves.

### Debt dynamics and stress tests
- Debt recommendation: adopt objective of reducing debt to around 60 percent of GDP in the medium to long term.
- Key debt dynamics indicators (selected series as presented):
  - Nominal gross public debt (series): 88.4; 77.6; 82.1; 93.3; 94.0; 94.9; 96.7; 98.7; 100.8
  - Public gross financing needs (series): 10.3; 3.7; 8.4; 11.8; 11.8; 12.5; 15.8; 19.2; 22.5
  - EMBIG (bp) (average last 3 months, 02-Mar-16 through 31-May-16): 1193
- Stress test scenarios:
  - Fiscal consolidation scenario projects primary balance rising to 3.5; 4.6; 4.4; 4.6; 4.7; 4.7 (selected years) with real GDP growth improving to 1.5; 1.8; 2.6; 2.8; 3.0; 3.2.
  - Financial sector contingent liability shock illustrated as a one-time increase in non-interest expenditures equivalent to 10% of banking sector assets; primary balance impact in 2016 under this shock shown as -8.8.

### Implementation status and authorities’ actions
- Authorities are considering widening the tax base by streamlining exemptions.
- Restrictions remain on banks with weak capital buffers.
- Implementation of the Growth and Sustainable Development Strategy (GSDS) awaits a realistic plan for its financing.
- Actions taken and options under consideration:
  - Increased the fuel tax in late 2015.
  - Considering moving zero-rated GST items to standard rate or exempt status; moving to standard could improve revenues by about 1 percent of GDP.
  - Considering raising standard GST rate from 12.5 percent to 15 percent, yielding about 1.1 percentage points of GDP (last resort).
  - Draft Public Debt Management Bill under Cabinet review.
  - Wage freeze under consideration; authorities deferred public wage increase scheduled for FY2016/17 (savings some $15 million BZD, about 0.5 percent of GDP).
  - New Minister of State and Economic Policy Coordinating Team established to work on budget and fiscal measures; plan to submit FY2017/18 budget to Parliament in mid-March 2017.

### Selected economic indicators (exact figures drawn from tables)
- Real GDP (percent change): 2014: 4.1; 2015: 1.0; 2016 (Proj.): -1.5; 2017 (Proj.): 1.9
- GDP deflator (percent change): 2014: 1.5; 2015: 1.0; 2016 (Proj.): 2.1; 2017 (Proj.): 2.4
- Consumer prices (end of period): 2014: -0.2; 2015: -0.6; 2016 (Proj.): 2.3; 2017 (Proj.): 2.4
- Nominal GDP (BZ$ millions): 2014: 3,436; 2015: 3,506; 2016 (Proj.): 3,558; 2017 (Proj.): 3,727
- Credit to the private sector (percent change): 2014: 4.7; 2015: 4.8; 2016 (Proj.): 4.0; 2017 (Proj.): 3.5
- Money and quasi-money (M2) (percent change): 2014: 7.9; 2015: 7.6; 2016 (Proj.): 2.8; 2017 (Proj.): 4.8
- Central government revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 2014: 29.0; 2015: 28.1; 2016 (Proj.): 29.2; 2017 (Proj.): 27.9
- Central government current expenditure (percent of GDP): 2014: 24.1; 2015: 25.8; 2016 (Proj.): 28.6; 2017 (Proj.): 28.3
- Capital expenditure and net lending (percent of GDP): 2014: 7.3; 2015: 10.3; 2016 (Proj.): 5.7; 2017 (Proj.): 5.2
- Primary balance (percent of GDP): 2014: 0.3; 2015: -5.6; 2016 (Proj.): -2.0; 2017 (Proj.): -2.2
- Overall balance (percent of GDP): 2014: -2.4; 2015: -8.0; 2016 (Proj.): -5.0; 2017 (Proj.): -5.6
- Stock of public and publicly guaranteed debt (end-period, percent of GDP): 2014: 77.6; 2015: 82.1; 2016 (Proj.): 99.9; 2017 (Proj.): 95.7
  - Domestic debt (percent of GDP): 2014: 10.9; 2015: 14.1; 2016 (Proj.): 31.1; 2017 (Proj.): 29.3
  - External debt (percent of GDP): 2014: 66.6; 2015: 68.0; 2016 (Proj.): 68.8; 2017 (Proj.): 66.4
- External current account (percent of GDP): 2014: -7.4; 2015: -9.8; 2016 (Proj.): -14.0; 2017 (Proj.): -10.2
- Exports of goods and services (percent change): 2014: 8.9; 2015: -3.7; 2016 (Proj.): -14.0; 2017 (Proj.): 5.7
- Imports of goods and services (percent change): 2014: 11.8; 2015: 3.3; 2016 (Proj.): -5.9; 2017 (Proj.): -0.7
- Gross international reserves, millions of U.S. dollars: 2014: 487; 2015: 437; 2016 (Proj.): 364; 2017 (Proj.): 306
  - In months of imports: 2014: 4.6; 2015: 4.4; 2016 (Proj.): 3.7; 2017 (Proj.): 3.1
- Overall balance of payments, millions of U.S. dollars: 2014: 84; 2015: -50; 2016 (Proj.): -73; 2017 (Proj.): -58

### Risk Assessment Matrix — selected high-probability, high-impact risks and policy measures
- External risks:
  - Sharper-than-expected global growth slowdown — Relative Likelihood: High/Medium; Impact: High.
    - Policy: diversify export mix, build fiscal and external buffers, broaden sources of growth.
  - Tighter or more volatile global financial conditions — Relative Likelihood: High; Impact: High.
    - Policy: fiscal consolidation and structural reforms to increase fiscal space and curb real exchange appreciation.
  - Reduced financial services by global/regional banks (CBR withdrawals) — Relative Likelihood: High; Impact: High.
    - Policy: regional coordination, temporary use of central bank platforms with effective AML/CFT due diligence.
- Domestic risks:
  - Hesitation to implement credible fiscal adjustment — Relative Likelihood: High; Impact: High.
    - Policy: carry out fiscal consolidation to raise primary balance to 4–5 percent of GDP by 2021.
  - Distress in the banking system — Relative Likelihood: High; Impact: High.
    - Policy: order undercapitalized banks to raise capital and maintain tight supervision.
  - Surge in contingent liabilities (e.g., BTL compensation) — Relative Likelihood: High; Impact: High.
    - Policy: fiscal buffers through consolidation; strengthen export competitiveness and infrastructure to attract investment.

### Implementation status and international assistance
- Lending operations and pipeline (selected):
  - Solid Waste Management Program II approved in May; Citizen Security operation in pipeline for 2016.
  - World Bank and Caribbean Development Bank loan portfolios and project updates provided; total loan portfolios and undisbursed amounts detailed (e.g., World Bank portfolio: US$72.0 million approved — US$59.3 million undisbursed).
- Statistical issues:
  - Data provision has shortcomings but broadly adequate for surveillance; priorities include consolidated public sector accounts, improved domestic debt recording, and expansion of merchandise trade statistics to cover services.
  - Participant in GDDS since September 27, 2006.

### Authorities’ views and statements (September 21, 2016)
- Authorities acknowledge mixed outlook; GDP rose 1 percent in 2015 but contracted by 1.5 percent in first half of referenced year.
- Authorities emphasize need for investment in physical and human capital and express concern about the pace and scale of fiscal consolidation proposed by staff.
- Authorities view CBR withdrawal as a market failure linked to regulatory developments in major jurisdictions; welcome Fund engagement and practical solutions.
- Authorities intend to publish the staff report and related documents and to continue engagement with Fund during Budget preparation.

*Source: BELIZE — STAFF REPORT FOR THE 2016 ARTICLE IV CONSULTATION and Supplementary Information (document excerpts)._*

### 9.8 percent of GDP in 2015. Further decline in exports in the first half of 2016, combined

### _cr16334 - 9.8 percent of GDP in 2015. Further decline in exports in the first half of 2016, combined

### Recent developments
- Exports declined further in the first half of 2016, combined with settling liabilities related to the two nationalized companies, reducing international reserves to 4.4 months of imports in late August 2016.
- Hurricane Earl hit Belize in early August 2016 and compounded the challenging economic environment.
- Tourism performance in the first half of 2016 has been strong.
- The unemployment rate declined from 10.1 percent in April 2015 to 8 percent in April 2016.
- The overall fiscal deficit expanded to 8 percent of GDP in 2015.
  - A one-off payment related to the settlement of liabilities for one of the nationalized companies accounted for 2.8 percent of GDP of the deterioration.
  - The structural deficit worsened due to an increase in public sector wages and transfers and a large overrun in capital expenditure.
- Public sector debt rose to 82 percent of GDP in 2015.
- Authorities increased their fuel tax, expected to raise revenues by close to 1½ percent of GDP.

### Financial sector and banking system
- Banking system weaknesses appear to have somewhat diminished:
  - Non-performing loans to total loans fell to 15.8 percent (5.7 percent net of provisions) at end-March 2016.
  - Reported capital adequacy ratio increased to 25 percent.
- Vulnerabilities remain:
  - Loss of a significant number of correspondent banking relationships (CBRs) by the largest banks.
  - Increased transaction costs and winding down of deposits in international banks.
- Directors called for sustained efforts to tighten supervision and reduce vulnerabilities, including:
  - An asset quality review of all banks to dispel uncertainties about capital buffers.
  - Timely completion of financial stability reports, including stress tests that adjust banks’ capital buffers for shortfalls in provisioning.
- Directors noted that loss of remaining CBRs could negatively impact the financial sector and wider economy and will require action on multiple fronts, domestically and internationally.
  - Stronger implementation of the AML/CFT framework and improved transparency in the offshore sector, with technical assistance where needed, was recommended to help address withdrawal of CBRs.

### Macroeconomic outlook and risks
- GDP projections and recent performance:
  - GDP is projected to decline by 1.5 percent in 2016.
  - Growth is projected to average less than 2 percent in the medium term.
- Drivers of the outlook:
  - Declining productivity, competitiveness and public investment.
  - Damage from hurricane Earl contributed to the 2016 contraction.
- Risks and implications:
  - Rigid current fiscal spending, particularly the public sector wage bill, would fuel high fiscal deficits and add to the high debt burden absent a radical change in policies.
  - Financing constraints would reduce public investment.
  - The current account deficit would slowly improve due to a gradual recovery in major commodity exports but would remain high, indicating a weak external position.
  - Remaining payments for nationalized companies and increased debt service would reduce international reserves to uncomfortable levels.
  - Further withdrawal of correspondent banking relationships and low capital buffers in some banks are key threats to financial stability.
  - Insufficient fiscal adjustment and weaknesses in the banking system are significant risks.

### Executive Board assessment and Directors’ recommendations
- Executive Directors noted significant vulnerabilities driven by high public debt, large fiscal and external deficits, and declining international reserves; adverse weather conditions also posed difficulties.
- Directors emphasized that decisive policies are urgently needed to ensure macroeconomic stability and improve growth performance.
- Key priorities and recommended measures:
  - Place public debt on a downward path through rigorous and sustained fiscal adjustment, including both revenue and expenditure measures.
  - Additional measures highlighted: raising the GST rate, reducing the public wage bill, reforming the pension plan for civil servants, and strengthening public financial management.
  - Contain public expenditures and increase revenue; welcome steps taken but stress need for further action.
  - Strengthen financial sector supervision and reduce vulnerabilities.
  - Asset quality review of all banks and enhanced stress testing to clarify capital buffer adequacy.
  - Strengthen and vigorously implement the AML/CFT framework and improve transparency in the offshore sector to help address CBR withdrawals.
  - Implement broad-based structural reforms to improve business climate, boost productivity, and increase competitiveness.
  - Vigorous implementation of the Growth and Sustainable Development Strategy (GSDS) using non-debt-creating financing options, such as well-designed public-private partnerships.
  - Labor market reforms were noted as important going forward.

### Key policy advice from staff
- Urgently implement fiscal measures to improve the primary fiscal balance to about 4½ percent of GDP in the medium term:
  - Widen the tax base, strengthen revenue administration, and contain spending on wages, transfers, pensions, and goods and services.
- Address public financial management (PFM) weaknesses, including internal and external controls and procurement practices, to contain low-quality spending.
- Continue to address banking sector vulnerabilities, especially weak capital buffers, by maintaining restrictions on lending and distribution of dividends for banks with weak buffers.
- Monitor and contain the impact of loss of correspondent banking relationships by strengthening AML/CFT implementation, enhancing supervision, and bolstering entity transparency.
- Develop a financing strategy for the recently adopted Growth and Sustainable Development Strategy (GSDS).
- Consider growth-enhancing measures that can be implemented at no financial cost, including:
  - Submitting the draft credit bureau law to parliament.
  - Allowing for greater flexibility on employment hours in labor markets.

### Selected economic indicators (from table)
- Real GDP (percent change): 2014: 4.1; 2015: 1.0; 2016 (Proj.): -1.5; 2017 (Proj.): 1.9
- GDP deflator (percent change): 2014: 1.5; 2015: 1.0; 2016 (Proj.): 2.1; 2017 (Proj.): 2.4
- Consumer prices (end of period): 2014: -0.2; 2015: -0.6; 2016 (Proj.): 2.3; 2017 (Proj.): 2.4
- Nominal GDP (BZ$ millions): 2014: 3,436; 2015: 3,506; 2016 (Proj.): 3,558; 2017 (Proj.): 3,727
- Credit to the private sector (percent change): 2014: 4.7; 2015: 4.8; 2016 (Proj.): 4.0; 2017 (Proj.): 3.5
- Money and quasi-money (M2) (percent change): 2014: 7.9; 2015: 7.6; 2016 (Proj.): 2.8; 2017 (Proj.): 4.8
- Central government revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 2014: 29.0; 2015: 28.1; 2016 (Proj.): 29.2; 2017 (Proj.): 27.9
- Central government current expenditure (percent of GDP): 2014: 24.1; 2015: 25.8; 2016 (Proj.): 28.6; 2017 (Proj.): 28.3
- Capital expenditure and net lending (percent of GDP): 2014: 7.3; 2015: 10.3; 2016 (Proj.): 5.7; 2017 (Proj.): 5.2
- Primary balance (percent of GDP): 2014: 0.3; 2015: -5.6; 2016 (Proj.): -2.0; 2017 (Proj.): -2.2
- Overall balance (percent of GDP): 2014: -2.4; 2015: -8.0; 2016 (Proj.): -5.0; 2017 (Proj.): -5.6
- Stock of public and publicly guaranteed debt (end-period, percent of GDP): 2014: 77.6; 2015: 82.1; 2016 (Proj.): 99.9; 2017 (Proj.): 95.7
  - Domestic debt (percent of GDP): 2014: 10.9; 2015: 14.1; 2016 (Proj.): 31.1; 2017 (Proj.): 29.3
  - External debt (percent of GDP): 2014: 66.6; 2015: 68.0; 2016 (Proj.): 68.8; 2017 (Proj.): 66.4
- External current account (percent of GDP): 2014: -7.4; 2015: -9.8; 2016 (Proj.): -14.0; 2017 (Proj.): -10.2
- Exports of goods and services (percent change): 2014: 8.9; 2015: -3.7; 2016 (Proj.): -14.0; 2017 (Proj.): 5.7
- Imports of goods and services (percent change): 2014: 11.8; 2015: 3.3; 2016 (Proj.): -5.9; 2017 (Proj.): -0.7
- Gross international reserves, millions of U.S. dollars: 2014: 487; 2015: 437; 2016 (Proj.): 364; 2017 (Proj.): 306
  - In months of imports: 2014: 4.6; 2015: 4.4; 2016 (Proj.): 3.7; 2017 (Proj.): 3.1
- Exports of goods and services, millions of U.S. dollars: 2014: 1,154; 2015: 1,112; 2016 (Proj.): 956; 2017 (Proj.): 1,011
- Imports of goods and services, millions of U.S. dollars: 2014: 1,218; 2015: 1,258; 2016 (Proj.): 1,184; 2017 (Proj.): 1,175
- Overall balance of payments, millions of U.S. dollars: 2014: 84; 2015: -50; 2016 (Proj.): -73; 2017 (Proj.): -58

### Implementation status and authorities’ actions
- Authorities are considering widening the tax base by streamlining exemptions.
- Restrictions remain on banks with weak capital buffers.
- Implementation of the Growth and Sustainable Development Strategy (GSDS) awaits a realistic plan for its financing.

*Source: BELIZE — STAFF REPORT FOR THE 2016 ARTICLE IV CONSULTATION, June 15, 2016.*

### 10.2 percent in September 2015, from 12.1 percent a year earlier, due to a moderate expansion in

### _cr16334 - 10.2 percent in September 2015, from 12.1 percent a year earlier, due to a moderate expansion in

### Macroeconomic performance and inflation
- Tourism and public investment in infrastructure supported activity.
- Decline in oil and other commodity prices led to deflation in 2015, with end-of-period inflation at -0.6 percent.
- Increases in food prices and fuel taxes restored positive inflation, at 0.2 percent in April 2016 (y/y).
- Growth is projected to decline to about 0.5 percent in 2016 and average less than 2 percent in the medium-term.

### External sector and reserves
- The current account deficit widened to 9.8 percent of GDP in 2015 from 7.4 percent in 2014, driven by:
  - A contraction in exports of goods of about 9 percent (mainly oil and marine products).
  - Increases in imports of machinery, manufactured goods and fertilizers, partly related to investment projects.
- Gross international reserves were reduced significantly (4.6 months of imports at end-March 2016) following the current account deficit combined with partial compensation and loan settlement payments for the two nationalized companies (BEL and BTL) in late 2015.
- The effective exchange rate appreciated sharply both in nominal and real terms in 2015, driven mostly by the strengthening of the U.S. dollar to which the currency is pegged.
- Exports of goods declined by nearly 30 percent during January ─ April 2016 compared with the same period last year, while imports of goods declined by 2.4 percent.
- Staff projections assume the government will sell a part of shares of the two nationalized companies in excess of 51 percent ownership and use the proceeds (US$ 100 million or 5.5 percent of GDP) to reduce public debt and support international reserves.
- The current account deficit is expected to slowly improve due to a gradual recovery in major commodity exports but would remain high, indicating overvaluation of the real effective exchange rate.

### Fiscal developments
- According to preliminary estimates, the overall fiscal deficit for FY2015/16 (April-March) increased to 8 percent of GDP from 2.4 percent of GDP in FY2014/15.
  - Deterioration explained by: a one-off payment related to the settlement of BTL liabilities (2.8 percent of GDP), an increase in public sector wages and transfers, and a large overrun in capital expenditure.
  - The deficit in FY2015/16 was financed through borrowing from the Central Bank of Belize (CBB) and a drawdown of PetroCaribe deposits.
- Baseline scenario projects that the fiscal adjustment, which assumes no measures beyond those announced, will remain insufficient to stabilize the very high level of public debt or reduce the likelihood of a disorderly fiscal and external adjustment.
- Staff recommend a package to gradually raise the primary balance to 4-5 percent of GDP by 2021; primary surpluses of 4-5 percent of GDP would need to be maintained beyond 2021 to reduce public debt to about 60 percent of GDP by 2030 (or stronger upfront adjustment could shorten the period).
- Recommended fiscal measures (total effect on the primary balance, in percent of GDP) — FY2016/17 to FY2021/22:
  - Total effect on the primary balance: 1.2, 4.0, 4.5, 5.0, 5.2, 5.3
  - Total first-order effect of fiscal measures and negative factors: 1.1, 4.0, 4.6, 5.1, 5.3, 5.4
  - Expenditure measures: 0.4, 1.3, 1.9, 2.5, 2.6, 2.8
    - Reducing the wage bill: 0.0, 0.5, 0.9, 1.3, 1.3, 1.3
    - Reform of Public Sector pension plan 1/: 0.0, 0.1, 0.1, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2
    - Freezing goods and services in real terms: 0.4, 0.5, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0
    - Cut in transfers (excluding teachers' salaries): 0.0, 0.3, 0.3, 0.3, 0.3, 0.3
  - Revenue-enhancing measures: 0.7, 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.6, 2.6
    - Streamlining GST exemptions and removing MoF's discretion in granting exemptions 2/: 0.3, 1.0, 1.0, 1.0, 1.0, 1.0
    - Increasing the general GST rate to 15 percent: 0.3, 1.1, 1.1, 1.1, 1.1, 1.1
    - Improving collection of import duties: 0.1, 0.3, 0.3, 0.3, 0.3, 0.3
    - Increasing excise on wine, beer and cigarrettes: 0.0, 0.4, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2, 0.2
  - Second-order macro effects 3/: 0.0, 0.0, -0.1, -0.1, -0.1, -0.1
- Memorandum items noted:
  - Reducing import tariffs in line with WTO commitments: 0, -0.4, -0.7, -1.0, -1.0, -1.0
  - Abolishing the environmental tax: 0, -0.7, 0, 0, 0, 0
  - Raising the fuel tax: 1.4, 1.4, 1.4, 1.4, 1.4, 1.4

### Banking system and financial soundness
- Broad money grew by 7.6 percent in 2015 and by 8.3 percent at end-March 2016 (y/y), supported by credit expansion to the government.
- Private sector credit grew by 4.8 percent in 2015 and was flat at end-March 2016.
- Abundant liquidity drove T-bills interest rates to near zero and lending rates continue to fall.
- Banking system resilience improved since the last Article IV, but vulnerabilities remain:
  - Gross NPLs to total loans fell to 15.8 percent (5.7 percent net of provisions) at end-March 2016, from 16.1 percent gross (6.1 percent net of provisions) at end-March 2015.
  - Provisioning increased: Provisions/NPLs rose to 60.4 percent at Mar-16 (from 57.6 percent at 2015 and 57.0 percent at Mar-15).
  - Reported capital adequacy ratio (CAR) increased by about 1.3 percentage points to 25.0 percent at Mar-16, due primarily to capital injections, a sale of a valuable asset, and improving profitability.
  - Return on assets for the banking system was 0.4 percent at end-March 2016, unchanged from end-March 2015.
  - A major bank’s NPL ratio rose to 28.6 percent (13.5 percent net of provisions) at end-March 2016 from 23 percent at end-March 2015 (9.3 percent net of provisions), due to a reclassification of a legacy loan (US$14 million or one-third of capital).
    - That bank’s CAR was 15.1 percent at end-March 2016 (13.2 at end-March 2015), but could fall below the regulatory minimum of 9 percent if the legacy loan is fully provisioned or written off.
    - If the bank’s request to restructure the legacy loan is granted, the bank’s CAR, excluding the disputed government asset on its balance sheet (US$21.5 million), would fall to 9.6 percent.
- Financial Soundness Indicators (domestic and international banks; in percent) — selected series:
  - Capital/risk-weighted assets: 20.4 (2008), 22.2 (2009), 23.9 (2010), 24.2 (2011), 19.8 (2012), 21.6 (2013), 21.7 (2014), 23.7 (Mar-15), 20.5 (2015), 25.0 (Mar-16)
  - Capital/total assets: 15.6, 16.5, 16.5, 14.7, 11.6, 12.0, 12.1, 12.3, 13.5, 13.2 (2008–Mar-16)
  - Excess statutory liquidity (in percent of statutory liquidity requirement): 30.1, 33.5, 43.8, 64.3, 83.5, 79.1, 84.4, 94.7, 80.2, 88.9 (2008–Mar-16)
  - NPLs/total loans: 11.7, 14.0, 18.7, 21.4, 20.3, 17.6, 15.7, 16.1, 15.8, 15.8 (2008–Mar-16)
  - Provisions/NPLs: 24.1, 18.1, 15.5, 24.4, 34.9, 42.8, 55.1, 57.0, 57.6, 60.4 (2008–Mar-16)
  - Provisions/total loans: 2.8, 2.5, 2.9, 5.2, 7.1, 7.5, 8.7, 9.2, 9.1, 9.5 (2008–Mar-16)
  - NPLs net of provisions/capital: 40.0, 48.2, 61.9, 66.1, 63.6, 46.5, 30.8, 29.6, 27.4, 26.8 (2008–Mar-16)
  - Return on Assets After Tax: 0.1, 0.2, 0.2, 0.1, -0.1, 0.4, 1.2, 0.5, 0.2, 0.4 (2008–Mar-16)
- Impact of loss of correspondent banking relationships (CBRs):
  - Only two of the ten domestic and international banks currently have CBRs with full banking services.
  - The systemic bank and its international subsidiary can process only non-US-dollar wire transfers.
  - Some banks have retained wire transfer arrangements with non-bank providers of payment services.
  - Four banks, including the systemic bank, have lost their credit card settlement accounts with a small bank in New York; proceeds from their credit card transactions can only be used through accounts with a major credit card company or restricted accounts such as brokerage accounts.
  - The CBB has lost three of its five CBRs in the last two years.
  - Transaction costs are increasing: for example, the systemic bank increased wire transfer fees from about US$ 100 to US$ 300.
  - Processing times for many wire transfers increased from “within twenty-four hours” to “several days.”
  - Growth rate of deposits in the banking system has fallen, driven by a significant decrease in deposits in international banks, partially offset by an increase of deposits in domestic banks.

### Outlook and risks
- Near-to-medium-term macroeconomic outlook is worse than at the time of the 2015 Article IV Consultation.
- Inflation is expected to remain moderate due to projected low international oil prices and subdued inflation in major trading partners.
- International reserves could be reduced to uncomfortable levels by: the current account deficit; repatriation of part of remaining payments for the nationalized BTL; and repayment of the super bond (US$ 526.5 million at end-2015, payable over 2020-38).
- Baseline scenario risks and potential shocks:
  - Public debt path subject to shocks to fiscal balance, GDP growth and other macro variables.
  - Twin deficits and large contingent liabilities could create very large public and external gross financing needs, accelerate reserve depletion, and usher in a disorderly adjustment jeopardizing the peg.
  - Planned sale of nationalized company shares may not yield expected proceeds.
  - Additional loss of CBRs or wire transfer arrangements could further weaken banks and the economy.
  - Disease outbreaks in shrimp and citrus sectors could further weaken export performance.
  - External risks include strengthening of the US dollar, prolonged weak growth in advanced and emerging economies, end of PetroCaribe financing, expected decline in sugar prices after EU sugar reform in 2017, and loss of tourism market share to Cuba.
- Upside factors: low international oil prices and successful implementation of the Growth and Sustainable Development Strategy (GSDS), which is not yet fully reflected in the baseline.

### Policy discussions and recommendations
- Staff emphasized prompt measures to reduce the likelihood of a disorderly fiscal and external adjustment, including:
  - (i) Raise the primary fiscal balance to levels that would credibly place public debt on a downward path and help rebuild investor confidence.
  - (ii) Reduce banking sector vulnerabilities and strengthen the AML/CFT framework, especially in the offshore sector.
  - (iii) Given limited fiscal space, design a credible financing strategy for the GSDS and consider growth-enhancing measures that can be implemented at no financial cost.
- Fiscal component priorities:
  - Strengthening revenue collection:
    - Widen the tax base by streamlining exemptions and zero-ratings on the General Sales Tax (GST).
    - Increase the standard GST rate (12.5 percent) at least to the regional average of 15 percent.
    - Enhance electronic tax filing and payment—less than 10 percent of registered taxpayers file or pay electronically in GST and Income Tax Departments.
    - Improve collection of import duties, raise the social duty on imports by Commercial Free Zones (CFZs), and introduce a cap on discretionary import duty exemptions to mitigate revenue loss from WTO commitments.
    - Use revenue administration monitoring reports to improve accountability.
  - Containing expenditure:
    - Freeze wages, replace only two out of five workers who retire, and train and redeploy civil servants.
    - Strengthen monitoring of government-supported entities and their payroll to generate savings.
    - Make the public sector pension plan contributory and gradually increase the retirement age to 62 years from 55.
    - Require parliamentary approval for any increase in overall spending beyond ceilings approved by parliament in the context of a revised budget.
    - Strengthen internal and external controls, transparent and efficient procurement, and timely production and parliamentary approval of audited government financial statements.
    - Improve classification of spending items in budget documents to facilitate parliamentary debate (example: provisions for wage payments classified as capital spending in the FY2016/17 budget).
- Staff stressed that vigorous growth-enhancing structural reforms cannot substitute for strong fiscal consolidation; “Plan B” (stronger structural reforms in exchange for weaker fiscal adjustment) is no longer viable because:
  - (i) Fiscal position has deteriorated further.
  - (ii) The sizable increase in the super bond debt service is closer (increasing by 1.7 percent of revenue in 2017 and reaching 11.2 percent of revenue by 2020).
  - (iii) Investor confidence further weakened (Belize’s super bond currently trades at only 50-60 cents per dollar).
- Without strong policy action, maintaining the currency peg will require strong private demand compression, undermining growth and risking a disorderly external and fiscal adjustment.

*International Monetary Fund — Belize: selected extracts from IMF staff report*

### 10. Staff also encouraged the authorities to phase out the practice of financing

### _cr16334 - 10. Staff also encouraged the authorities to phase out the practice of financing government spending with CBB borrowing and to develop securities markets with appropriate safeguards, which will greatly support other economic sectors (sections B and C).

### Debt financing, securities markets, and fiscal implications
- Finding: The share of domestic public debt held by the CBB expanded to about a half.
- Risk from CBB financing:
  - Financing government spending from the CBB brings excessive liquidity into the market, which, if not sterilized, can put additional pressure on the exchange rate.
- Recommendation:
  - Phase out financing government spending with CBB borrowing.
  - Develop securities markets with appropriate safeguards (transparency, disclosures, beneficial ownership checks).
  - More active debt management and more frequent auctions of government paper could generate sizeable savings on interest payments.
  - Submit the draft Public Debt Management Bill to parliament.

### Macroeconomic projections — Baseline and Active Scenarios (2014–21)
- Projections are presented as percent of GDP unless otherwise indicated. Fiscal projections are on a fiscal year basis (April to March). Public debt includes repayment of additional liabilities resulting from past nationalization of utility companies.
- I. Baseline Scenario (selected series)
  - Real GDP growth (percent change): 2014: 4.1; 2015: 1.0; 2016: 0.5; 2017: 2.5; 2018: 2.2; 2019: 1.7; 2020: 1.7; 2021: 1.7
  - Inflation, end of period (percent change): 2014: -0.2; 2015: -0.6; 2016: 2.0; 2017: 2.3; 2018: 2.2; 2019: 2.0; 2020: 2.0; 2021: 2.0
  - Primary fiscal balance 1/: 2014: 0.3; 2015: -5.5; 2016: -1.1; 2017: -1.8; 2018: -1.1; 2019: -1.3; 2020: -1.0; 2021: -0.8
  - Overall fiscal balance 1/: 2014: -2.4; 2015: -8.0; 2016: -4.1; 2017: -5.2; 2018: -4.9; 2019: -5.4; 2020: -5.5; 2021: -5.6
  - Public debt 2/: 2014: 77.6; 2015: 82.1; 2016: 93.3; 2017: 94.0; 2018: 94.9; 2019: 96.7; 2020: 98.7; 2021: 100.8
  - External current account balance: 2014: -7.4; 2015: -9.8; 2016: -10.5; 2017: -9.6; 2018: -8.8; 2019: -8.5; 2020: -8.3; 2021: -7.4
  - Gross official reserves (months of imports): 2014: 4.7; 2015: 4.5; 2016: 4.0; 2017: 3.3; 2018: 2.7; 2019: 2.0; 2020: 1.2; 2021: 0.5
- II. Active Scenario (selected series)
  - Real GDP growth (percent change): 2014: 4.1; 2015: 1.0; 2016: 0.5; 2017: 1.5; 2018: 2.2; 2019: 1.8; 2020: 2.0; 2021: 2.2
  - Inflation, end of period (percent change): 2014: -0.2; 2015: -0.6; 2016: 2.0; 2017: 3.4; 2018: 2.2; 2019: 1.6; 2020: 1.6; 2021: 1.6
  - Primary fiscal balance 1/: 2014: 0.3; 2015: -5.5; 2016: 0.2; 2017: 2.2; 2018: 3.4; 2019: 3.7; 2020: 4.2; 2021: 4.5
  - Overall fiscal balance 1/: 2014: -2.4; 2015: -8.0; 2016: -2.8; 2017: -1.1; 2018: -0.1; 2019: 0.2; 2020: 0.8; 2021: 1.2
  - Public debt 2/: 2014: 77.6; 2015: 82.1; 2016: 92.4; 2017: 89.7; 2018: 86.3; 2019: 83.0; 2020: 79.5; 2021: 75.6
  - External current account balance: 2014: -7.4; 2015: -9.8; 2016: -10.5; 2017: -7.4; 2018: -5.7; 2019: -5.1; 2020: -5.0; 2021: -4.2
  - Gross official reserves (months of imports): 2014: 4.7; 2015: 4.5; 2016: 4.1; 2017: 3.9; 2018: 3.8; 2019: 3.8; 2020: 3.6; 2021: 3.5
- Memorandum items — Scenario illustrating revenue measures envisaged by the authorities 3/ (selected series)
  - Real GDP growth (percent change) 3/: 2014: 4.1; 2015: 1.0; 2016: 0.5; 2017: 2.0; 2018: 2.1; 2019: 1.7; 2020: 1.7; 2021: 1.8
  - Inflation, end of period (percent change): 2014: -0.2; 2015: -0.6; 2016: 2.0; 2017: 3.4; 2018: 2.2; 2019: 2.0; 2020: 2.0; 2021: 2.0
  - Primary fiscal balance: 2014: 0.3; 2015: -5.5; 2016: -0.4; 2017: 0.2; 2018: 0.5; 2019: 0.3; 2020: 0.6; 2021: 0.9
  - Public debt: 2014: 77.6; 2015: 82.1; 2016: 92.8; 2017: 91.3; 2018: 90.7; 2019: 90.8; 2020: 91.0; 2021: 91.0
- Nominal GDP baseline (US$ million): 2014: 1,718; 2015: 1,753; 2016: 1,779; 2017: 1,863; 2018: 1,948; 2019: 2,023; 2020: 2,099; 2021: 2,178
- Notes on memorandum scenario measures 3/:
  - The measures include (i) moving zero-rated goods under the GST to a standard rate and (ii) raising the standard rate from 12.5 to 15 percent.

### Authorities’ views on fiscal measures and debt
- Actions taken and options:
  - Increased the fuel tax in late 2015 as the first step toward fiscal consolidation.
  - Considering moving zero-rated items under the GST to exempt status (prevent refund of GST paid on inputs) or to the standard GST rate of 12.5 percent; moving to standard could improve revenues by about 1 percent of GDP.
  - Considering raising the standard GST rate to the regional average of 15 percent, yielding about 1.1 percentage points of GDP (to be used as a last resort).
  - If GST measures successfully implemented, could improve the primary fiscal balance to about 1 percent of GDP in the medium term.
  - Expectation that interest on compensation for nationalization of BTL could be closer to US dollar Libor at time of nationalization (1─2 percent) versus staff assumption of 8 percent; lower interest would reduce the public-debt-to-GDP ratio by several percentage points.
  - Options to reduce public debt include a Petrocaribe debt buyback at a discount.
  - Draft Public Debt Management Bill under Cabinet review.
  - A wage freeze will be considered; authorities acknowledge the 2013 wage agreement sharply increased the public wage bill which should be contained.

### Improving resilience of the financial system — supervision, capital, provisioning, and markets
- Supervision and reporting:
  - Staff supported maintaining tight supervision; completion of the Financial Stability Report (FSR) for 2015 delayed due to limited human resources.
  - Advised allocation of resources to complete FSRs with macro-prudential indicators developed with CARTAC technical assistance.
  - Plan to use consolidated supervision framework to monitor group risk, group capital adequacy, governance, and regulatory arbitrage.
- Systemic bank and provisioning:
  - Supported restrictions on the systemic bank; no profit distribution should be allowed until banks are in a sound position.
  - Systemic bank has until April 2018 to meet provisioning requirements; recent NPL increases could raise provisioning expenses.
  - Encouraged ensuring systemic institution’s Tier I capital remains well above minimum prudential requirements, including through recapitalization.
  - Recommend recapitalization options include diluting existing shareholders; CBB could impose recapitalization.
- Capital markets and asset management:
  - Development of capital markets with safeguards could help strengthen banks' balance sheets more rapidly.
  - More developed capital markets could allow banks to tap current liquidity to raise capital or dispose of non-performing assets, including through asset management companies.
  - Authorities plan to finalize the National Payment System bill and launch the Automated Clearing House later in the year.
- Provisioning policy recommendation:
  - Provisioning requirements should be raised to 100 percent on loan losses (secured or not) given uncertainties on collateral values.
  - Loan losses neither written off nor fully provisioned should be gradually provisioned to 100 percent during a transition period; profit distribution prohibited and management fees contained during this period.
  - Asset quality review of all banks recommended during the transition.
  - Transition period could be shortened by capital market development.
  - Facilitate creation of asset management companies, including through legislative reform, to purchase NPLs and help clean banks’ balance sheets.
  - Authorities advised to request IMF TA if needed.

### Anti–money laundering / Combating the financing of terrorism (AML/CFT) and offshore sector transparency
- Risks identified:
  - ML/TF risks related to misuse of legal persons and arrangements (companies, trusts, foundations), IFSC service providers, and offshore banks could be significant.
  - IFSC uses around 150 registered agents and intermediaries abroad to establish complex entities without proper mechanisms for beneficial ownership information access and dissemination.
  - Service providers licensed without a physical presence in Belize; services generate relatively low fiscal revenues but create reputational risks.
- Recommendations:
  - Further strengthen AML/CFT framework and enhance entity transparency, especially in the offshore sector.
  - Continue dialogue with the US Treasury (UST) on TA needs.
  - Implement risk-based supervision of banks and impose corrective actions and sanctions when relevant.
  - IFSC’s registered agents and service providers should face proper licensing requirements and risk-based monitoring for AML/CFT compliance.
  - Develop mechanisms (e.g., public registry for beneficial ownership) to allow timely access to adequate, accurate, and current beneficial ownership information for all entities created in Belize.
  - Entities’ registers should immediately publish basic information related to entities created in Belize.
  - Apply effective and dissuasive sanctions for non-compliance with information requirements.
  - Step up efforts to access and share beneficial ownership information with relevant foreign authorities in a timely manner.
  - Identify, assess, and understand vulnerabilities and the extent to which legal persons and arrangements could be misused for ML/TF.

### Correspondent banking relationships (CBRs) — regional coordination and options
- Problem and rationale:
  - Withdrawal of CBRs by global banks poses challenges to Belize and other small Caribbean economies; simultaneous withdrawals can have negative externalities for financial stability, inclusion, and growth.
  - Individual banks may rationally cut CBRs based on cost-benefit analysis amid low profitability, rising costs, strengthened regulatory standards, and enhanced enforcement.
- Potential regional solutions analyzed:
  - (i) Collective action to increase business volume brought to a smaller number of correspondent banks.
  - (ii) Introduction of a scheme to purchase CBR insurance policies.
  - (iii) Creation of a US-licensed special purpose vehicle (SPV) to process international transactions.
  - (iv) Payment of higher CBR service fees.
- Assessment:
  - Except for the SPV, these solutions require strong private sector collaboration in the US; high estimates for risk-adjusted cost of CBR activity or CBR insurance could imply prohibitive prices for Caribbean banks.
  - Temporary use of the CBB’s own CBRs is possible.
  - Staff advised exploring, with regional partners, the possibility of fast-track establishment or acquisition of a US-licensed financial institution to provide CBRs while ensuring effective AML/CFT implementation.
  - Some local banks confirmed they were considering acquiring small US-licensed banks, though none had initiated such a process.

### Authorities’ views on financial system recommendations
- Provisioning and capital markets:
  - Authorities view current provisioning policy as adequate.
  - Restrictions on the systemic bank will remain until the bank is in a sound financial position; they will ensure its Tier I capital remains well above prudential requirements.
  - Agree on the need for capital market development but note private businesses are reluctant due to disclosure requirements and reluctance to dilute control; corporate bond markets could be successful though no commitment to development.
- AML/CFT and CBRs:
  - Authorities concur with staff on the need to strengthen AML/CFT but do not expect this alone to reverse CBR withdrawal.
  - Argue global banks have not provided reasons for progressive CBR withdrawal.
  - Committed to improving AML/CFT framework and engaging bilaterally (e.g., with the US) to address CBR challenges.
  - In collaboration with Belize Bankers Association, will sensitize stakeholders and foreign banks on AML/CFT progress and Belize’s implementation of international agreements to combat tax evasion.
  - Passed a Statutory Instrument to increase licensing fees and capital requirements for higher risk offshore licenses, scheduled to take effect on July 1, 2016; plan to improve IFSC supervisory capacity.
  - Consider acquiring a US bank impractical due to lengthy due diligence for foreign acquisitions.
  - View progressive withdrawal of CBRs as a market failure possibly linked to US regulatory stance; expect IMF to address the issue aggressively.

### Growth and the Growth and Sustainable Development Strategy (GSDS)
- Diagnosis:
  - Weak growth mainly driven by a decline in total factor productivity (TFP), stemming from deficiencies in infrastructure, human capital, and the business environment.
  - Reforms should aim at raising productivity.
- GSDS features:
  - GSDS guides policies for sustainable and inclusive growth during 2016─20.
  - Pillars: penetrating export markets, attracting foreign investment, conducting effective industrial policy, enhancing market efficiency, and improving infrastructure and human capital.
  - Initiatives: alleviate infrastructure bottlenecks to strengthen export competitiveness by reducing transport costs; major projects include new port facilities and upgrades of key transportation links.
  - Align with WTO requirements via new legislation, export processing zone status, and commercial free zone completion later in 2016.
  - Emphasis on priority sectors: agriculture, agro-processing, tourism, energy; diversify into new products and services.
  - Broaden access to education and healthcare via investment in new schools and hospitals in rural areas and quality improvements.
  - The strategy’s cost has not been estimated and financing remains largely unidentified.
- Staff recommendations:
  - Prioritize GSDS projects, estimate costs, and design realistic project financing strategies considering limited fiscal space and need to maintain macroeconomic stability.
  - Modest fiscal space from fiscal adjustment likely insufficient to finance GSDS.
  - More developed capital markets could expand financing sources.
  - Development partners could assist with project prioritization, costing, and mobilizing concessional external financing and private investment, including well-designed public-private partnerships that safeguard public finances.
  - Upgrade regulatory framework for project appraisal, selection, and procurement.
  - Given deteriorating export performance and widening current account deficits, addressing weak competitiveness should be an important project selection criterion.

*Source: Belizean authorities; and Fund staff estimates and projections (IMF staff report excerpts).*

### 24. The authorities should also consider

### _cr16334 - 24. The authorities should also consider

### Growth-enhancing measures and structural reforms
- Belize ranks 120 out of 189 countries in the 2016 World Bank Doing Business Report.
- Suggested low-cost growth-enhancing measures:
  - Pass the draft credit bureau law (with cabinet since 2014) to help develop financial markets.
  - Improve financial market efficiency, including the FX market, to facilitate better resource allocation.
  - Labor market reforms to allow greater flexibility on hours of employment to boost job creation and productivity, particularly in outsourcing and tourism.
  - Improve outcomes in: starting a business; getting credit; trading across borders; timeliness of resolution of contract disputes; and strengthening small businesses.
- Adoption and vigorous implementation of the GSDS recommended, using available fiscal space and non-debt-creating financing options (e.g., well-designed public-private partnerships).
- Complementary reforms suggested: greater labor market flexibility, further development of financial markets, and progress on starting a business, access to credit, cross-border trade, and timeliness of contract dispute resolution.

### Foreign exchange (FX) regime assessment and issues
- Staff assessment: Belize maintains an FX system generally liberal for current international transactions; CBB authorization is required for many transactions but is routinely granted for bona fide transactions upon presentation of requisite documentation.
- Most market participants have sufficient access to FX; occasional delays reported, especially for large transactions.
- Staff found an exchange restriction arising from the requirement of a tax clearance certificate to obtain FX for transfer of interest payments and management fees to non-residents.
  - This restriction is subject to the Fund’s approval.
  - Staff does not recommend approval of the exchange restriction.
- Reported FX access delays appear related to the loss of CBRs of two major banks and a shallow interbank market.
- Authorities are considering stepping in and intermediating FX funds between domestic banks to alleviate pressure.
- Staff will continue monitoring developments in FX accessibility.

### Authorities’ views and actions
- Authorities expect medium-term growth pick-up in agriculture owing to efforts to cope with diseases in shrimp and citrus industries and reforms of the sugar industry in line with its strategic development plan.
- Authorities noted potential in the livestock industry (benefiting from favorable market prices) and new crops (beans and corn).
- Plans to expand trade agreements with neighboring countries to bolster agriculture growth and reduce informality.
- GSDS projects to be selected and implemented mainly in cooperation with international financial institutions; transportation infrastructure guided by a transportation master plan with the Inter-American Development Bank.
- Financing for projects expected mainly from concessional funding from international donors and public-private partnerships, including the UK government’s recently announced program to support regional infrastructure projects.
- Authorities insisted FX system has functioned well and attributed occasional delays to FX market microstructure and loss of CBRs; noted uneven FX inflows across domestic banks due to client structure and a shallow interbank market.

### Financial sector vulnerabilities and spillovers
- Loss of CBRs is posing significant challenges; multiple-front approach required to address causes.
- Belizean banks’ financial exposure to a bank in Antigua and Barbuda (under receivership) amounted to about US$6.8million at end-March 2016.
  - Authorities indicate that if these assets are written off, Belizean banks’ CAR will remain well above the prudential requirement.
- Staff concerns and recommended actions:
  - Tight supervision should continue.
  - Raise provisioning requirements to 100 percent on loan losses regardless of secured status, given collateral valuation uncertainties in illiquid markets.
  - Continue restrictions on banks granted extensions on provisioning requirements.
  - Conduct an asset quality review of all banks to clarify capital buffers.
  - Develop well-functioning capital markets to allow banks to tap abundant liquidity to strengthen balance sheets.
- Recommendations to address CBR issues:
  - Closer regional and global coordination so home authorities of global banks clarify regulatory expectations.
  - Strengthen regulatory and supervisory frameworks to meet international standards, with technical assistance where needed.
  - In extreme circumstances, consider feasibility of temporary public-sector mechanisms to prevent complete loss of access to the global financial system.
  - Strengthen AML/CFT regulation and supervision and mechanisms to ensure entity transparency, especially regarding IFSC-registered agents and intermediaries that can establish complex entities without timely beneficial ownership information.
  - Support regional efforts for long-term solutions, including the possibility of a fast-track establishment or acquisition of a US-licensed financial institution to provide CBRs while ensuring effective AML/CFT implementation.

### Macroeconomic outlook and fiscal policy
- Recent macroeconomic outcomes and risks:
  - Growth slowed to 1 percent in 2015 due to shocks to the primary sector.
  - Fiscal deficit reached 8 percent of GDP.
  - Public debt stock reached 82 percent of GDP.
  - Baseline outlook has worsened since last Article IV Consultation and is subject to significant downside risks.
  - Growth projected to be below 2 percent in the medium term.
  - Without fiscal adjustment, rigid current fiscal spending—particularly the public sector wage bill—would fuel high fiscal deficits and add to the debt burden.
  - Current account deficit would slowly decrease due to export recovery but remain high, exerting downward pressure on international reserves.
- Risks that could weaken the baseline: lower-than-expected proceeds from planned sale of some shares of BEL and BTL; additional loss of CBRs or wire transfer arrangements; failure to cope with shrimp and citrus shocks; protracted weak growth in trading partners.
- Staff appraisal and policy prescriptions:
  - Strong action needed to reduce likelihood of disorderly macroeconomic adjustment.
  - In absence of nominal exchange rate flexibility, adjustment must occur through tighter domestic policies—particularly fiscal policy—and strong structural reforms to improve external competitiveness.
  - Place public debt on a downward path by raising the primary fiscal balance to 4–5 percent of GDP by 2021.
    - Achieve this via a mix of strong revenue and expenditure measures, including broadening the tax base, raising the GST rate, improving tax compliance, reducing the public wage bill, initiating parametric pension reform for civil servants, and strengthening public financial management.
  - Address remaining statistical weaknesses: improve compilation of the international investment position and consolidated public sector statistics; improve timeliness of final fiscal outcomes.

*Source: _cr16334 - 24. The authorities should also consider*

### 39. It is recommended that the next Article IV be held on the standard twelve-month cycle.

### _cr16334 - 39. It is recommended that the next Article IV be held on the standard twelve-month cycle.

### Recommendation
- It is recommended that the next Article IV be held on the standard twelve-month cycle.

### Real Sector: developments and indicators
- GDP growth slowed to 1 percent in 2015.
- GDP at constant prices: 2011: 2.1; 2012: 3.7; 2013: 1.3; 2014: 4.1; 2015 Prel.: 1.0; 2016 Proj.: 0.5; 2017 Proj.: 2.5.
- Oil output (annual % change): 2011: -0.5; 2012: -1.6; 2013: -1.0; 2014: -0.6; 2015 Prel.: -0.5; 2016 Proj.: -0.4; 2017 Proj.: -0.4.
- GDP deflator: 2011: 4.3; 2012: 1.9; 2013: 2.0; 2014: 1.5; 2015 Prel.: 1.0; 2016 Proj.: 1.0; 2017 Proj.: 2.2.
- Consumer prices (end of period): 2011: 2.3; 2012: 0.8; 2013: 1.6; 2014: -0.2; 2015 Prel.: -0.6; 2016 Proj.: 2.0; 2017 Proj.: 2.3.
- Consumer prices (average): 2011: 1.7; 2012: 1.2; 2013: 0.5; 2014: 1.2; 2015 Prel.: -0.9; 2016 Proj.: 1.0; 2017 Proj.: 2.2.
- Unemployment rate, Sep. 2015: 10.2 percent; adult literacy rate, 2010: 75.1 percent; life expectancy at birth, 2014: 74 years.

### External Sector: balance, reserves, and financing
- Current account balance (percent of GDP): 2011: -1.1; 2012: -1.2; 2013: -4.6; 2014: -7.4; 2015 Prel.: -9.8; 2016 Proj.: -10.5; 2017 Proj.: -9.6.
- Exports of goods and services (US$ million): 2011: 944; 2012: 1,028; 2013: 1,060; 2014: 1,151; 2015 Prel.: 1,109; 2016 Proj.: 999; 2017 Proj.: 1,027.
- Imports of goods and services (US$ million): 2011: 945; 2012: 1,004; 2013: 1,089; 2014: 1,215; 2015 Prel.: 1,255; 2016 Proj.: 1,167; 2017 Proj.: 1,183.
- Gross international reserves (US$ millions): 2011: 237; 2012: 289; 2013: 403; 2014: 487; 2015 Prel.: 437; 2016 Proj.: 395; 2017 Proj.: 327.
- Gross international reserves in months of imports: 2011: 2.8; 2012: 3.2; 2013: 4.0; 2014: 4.7; 2015 Prel.: 4.5; 2016 Proj.: 4.0; 2017 Proj.: 3.3.
- Gross external financing needs (percent of GDP): series shown in figures; reserves in months of imports are near the regional average but could be eroded due to expected higher gross external financing needs and payments for the nationalized BTL.

### Fiscal Sector: developments, balances, and debt
- Central government revenue and grants (percent of GDP): 2011: 27.7; 2012: 26.4; 2013: 28.7; 2014: 29.0; 2015 Prel.: 28.0; 2016 Proj.: 29.3; 2017 Proj.: 27.9.
- Current expenditure (percent of GDP): 2011: 24.0; 2012: 22.1; 2013: 23.3; 2014: 24.1; 2015 Prel.: 25.7; 2016 Proj.: 27.7; 2017 Proj.: 28.0.
- Primary balance (percent of GDP): 2011: 2.3; 2012: 1.4; 2013: 1.0; 2014: 0.3; 2015 Prel.: -5.5; 2016 Proj.: -1.1; 2017 Proj.: -1.8.
- Overall balance (percent of GDP): 2011: -1.1; 2012: -0.4; 2013: -1.6; 2014: -2.4; 2015 Prel.: -8.0; 2016 Proj.: -4.1; 2017 Proj.: -5.2.
- Stock of public and publicly guaranteed debt (percent of GDP): 2011: 83.5; 2012: 79.0; 2013: 79.4; 2014: 77.6; 2015 Prel.: 82.1; 2016 Proj.: 93.3; 2017 Proj.: 94.0.
- Domestic debt (percent of GDP): 2011: 12.8; 2012: 12.4; 2013: 11.9; 2014: 11.9; 2015 Prel.: 10.9; 2016 Proj.: 14.1; 2017 Proj.: 25.1.
- External debt (percent of GDP): 2011: 70.7; 2012: 66.6; 2013: 67.5; 2014: 67.5; 2015 Prel.: 66.6; 2016 Proj.: 68.0; 2017 Proj.: 68.2.
- Despite two debt restructurings, the pace of debt reduction remains modest and the burden of public debt remains high.
- The re-emergence of primary deficits reflects continued growth in primary spending driven primarily by increases in wages, pensions, transfers and capital expenditure; revenue mobilization is higher than the regional average.

### Monetary and Financial Sector
- Money and quasi-money (M2) growth (percent): 2011: 5.6; 2012: 11.0; 2013: 1.4; 2014: 7.9; 2015 Prel.: 7.6; 2016 Proj.: 3.8; 2017 Proj.: 5.2.
- Base money expanded rapidly due to increased central bank credit to the public sector.
- Credit to the private sector (12-month growth, percent): recent slowdown; detailed series: 2011: -1.2; 2012: 1.1; 2013: 3.5; 2014: 4.7; 2015 Prel.: 4.8; 2016 Proj.: 4.0; 2017 Proj.: 3.5.
- Nonperforming loans to total loans remain high and erode profitability; high NPLs and high interest rate spreads constrain financial intermediation.
- Weighted average lending rate: 2011: 13.0; 2012: 12.0; 2013: 11.1; 2014: 10.3; 2015 Prel.: 10.0 (series truncated thereafter).
- Interest rate spreads are high relative to regional peers (February 2016 comparison shown).

### Debt Markets and Restructuring Outcomes
- Debt restructuring (bond exchange) provided near-term cashflow relief but extended financing requirements by about 10 years.
- Debt service schedule shows old instrument ("super bond") and exchanged bond; exchanged bond lowered near-term debt service but lengthened maturities to 2038 and beyond.
- Market perception: credit ratings improved after the bond restructuring (S&P upgrade to B- after completion of bond exchange) but bond prices have not completely recovered; markets' perception remains mixed, effectively limiting access to international commercial borrowing.

### Key Tables and Projections (selected exact figures)
- Nominal GDP (US$ millions): 2011: 1,489; 2012: 1,574; 2013: 1,626; 2014: 1,718; 2015 Prel.: 1,753; 2016 Proj.: 1,779; 2017 Proj.: 1,863.
- Central government revenue (BZ$ millions), selected years from Table 2: 2014/15: 962; 2015/16 Prel.: 940; 2016/17 Budget: 967; 2017/18 Proj.: 1,047.
- Central government total expenditure (BZ$ millions): 2014/15: 1,083; 2015/16 Prel.: 1,068; 2016/17 Budget: 1,266; 2017/18 Proj.: 1,151.
- Central government overall balance (BZ$ millions): 2014/15: -82; 2015/16 Prel.: -88; 2016/17 Budget: -280; 2017/18 Proj.: -63.
- Balance of payments: Current account balance (US$ millions) by year: 2012: -19; 2013: -74; 2014: -128; 2015 Prel.: -172; 2016 Proj.: -187; 2017 Proj.: -179.

### Recommended Fiscal Measures (Table 6: totals and highlights)
- Total recommended measures: BZ$207.5 million or 4.7 percent of GDP.
- Revenue measures total: BZ$97.2 million or 2.6 percent of GDP, including:
  - Widening the base of GST: BZ$38.1 million or 1.03 percent of GDP (streamlining GST exemptions BZ$33.0 million; removing MoF discretion in exemptions BZ$5.0 million).
  - Raising the GST general rate to 15 percent: BZ$41.1 million or 1.10 percent of GDP.
  - Improving collection of import duties: BZ$12.0 million or 0.33 percent of GDP (includes enhancing customs administration BZ$2.0 million; raising "social duty" levied on imports to CFZs BZ$5.0 million; introducing cap on discretionary import duty exemptions BZ$5.0 million).
  - Increasing excise taxes for wine, cigarettes, beer and rum: BZ$6.0 million or 0.16 percent of GDP.
- Expenditure measures total: BZ$109.9 million or 2.85 percent of GDP, including:
  - Nominal wage freeze during 2017/18-2019/20: BZ$31.5 million or 0.81 percent of GDP.
  - Attrition in the civil service (2-5 replacement ratio) for 3 years: BZ$19.0 million or 0.49 percent of GDP.
  - Parametric reform of the Pension Plan for Civil Service: total BZ$8.0 million or 0.21 percent of GDP (making PPPO contributory with 4 percent contributions BZ$3.1 million; increasing retirement age from 55 to 62 years BZ$5.0 million).
  - Reforming public procurement system: BZ$4.0 million or 0.10 percent of GDP.
  - Cuts in transfers: BZ$11.2 million or 0.30 percent of GDP.
- Measures/factors already incorporated in the baseline scenario:
  - Switching from fuel import tariff to fuel excise and increasing the rate: BZ$50 million or 1.4 percent of GDP (Implemented/permanent).
  - Loss of revenue due to lowering of import duties by 20-30 percent: -BZ$40 million or -1.0 percent of GDP (FY2017/18-FY2019/20/permanent).
  - Abolishing the environmental duty: -BZ$25 million or -0.7 percent of GDP (Next FY/permanent).

### Non-Fiscal Growth-Enhancing Measures (Table 7: priorities and costs where noted)
- Sections and goals:
  - 1.1 Penetrating export markets: examples include cattle sweep program continuation (BZ$5 per year) and expanding training curriculum for small exporters (BZ$0.3 per year).
  - 1.2 Attracting foreign investments: measures include reforms in the sugar industry (transport improvements BZ$10 per mile per year for 5 years) and aligning tax incentives with WTO (2016).
  - 1.3 Effective industrial policy: pass legislation to develop financial markets (2016-2017); promote renewables (Continuous).
  - 1.4 Enhancing market efficiency: pass a Credit Bureau Law and establish a Credit Bureau (2016-2017); establish a Secured Transactions and Collateral Registry (2016-2017); pass deposit insurance legislation (2017).
  - 1.5 Adequate infrastructure: complete Transportation Master Plan (2016-17); feasibility studies and build deep-water commercial port, new cruise port, bus terminal, coastal road and LPG terminal (total cost BZ$200-400 million over 3-5 years).
  - 1.6 Adequate human capital: studies and investments in schools and hospitals (BZ$80 per year where noted); enhance teachers' qualifications (BZ$10 per year); expand vocational training (Continuous).
- Implementation notes:
  - Some projects list financing partners (Inter-American Development Bank, Caribbean Development Bank, U.K. government aid program) where applicable; periods range from Continuous to multi-year (2016-2021).

### Medium-Term Outlook: baseline aggregate projections (selected)
- Real GDP growth (annual %): 2018: 2.2; 2019: 1.7; 2020: 1.7; 2021: 1.7.
- Consumer prices (end of period): 2018: 2.2; 2019: 2.0; 2020: 2.0; 2021: 2.0.
- Gross official reserves (in months of imports): 2018: 2.7; 2019: 2.0; 2020: 1.2; 2021: 0.5.
- Public and publicly guaranteed debt (percent of GDP): 2018: 94.9; 2019: 96.7; 2020: 98.7; 2021: 100.8.

*Source: IMF staff and Belize authorities (excerpted content from the provided document).*

### Annex I. External Stability Assessment

### _cr16334 - Annex I. External Stability Assessment

### Key findings on external position
- The real effective exchange rate (REER) is overvalued and contributes to widening current account deficits and increasing external indebtedness.
- Overvaluation appears largely related to fiscal and structural policy gaps.
- The strengthening of the U.S. dollar, to which the domestic currency is pegged, has contributed to nominal and real appreciation vis-à-vis other trading partners and declining export market shares.
- Compensation payments to the former BTL owners, the expected increase in the debt service burden from 2017 onward, and a potential end of PetroCaribe financing are projected to reduce net external inflows.
- International reserves are presently above standard thresholds but could decline to very uncomfortable levels over the medium term without significant policy adjustment.

### Assessment approaches and quantitative results
- Three approaches were used: external stability (ES), external balance (EBA-lite), and export market shares (MS).

External Stability (ES) approach
- Assumes strengthening of the NFA position from -123 percent of GDP at end-2015 to -100 percent of GDP by 2025 in the baseline and to -90 percent by 2025 in the alternative scenario.
- These NFA levels imply maintaining current account deficits of 2.7 percent of GDP per annum in the baseline and 1.8 percent of GDP in the alternative scenario.
- The results indicate a current account gap of 7.1 percent in the baseline and 8 percent in the alternative scenario.
- These estimates imply average REER gaps of 16 percent in the baseline and 18.5 percent in the alternative scenario under the projected path for the current account deficit and the estimated elasticity of – 0.39 percent.
- Note: "The ES approach is based on the GDP growth rates assumed in the baseline." "The average is calculated based on the minimum and maximum REER adjustment needed to bring the current account in line with the norm over the medium term."

External Balance Assessment (EBA-lite)
- EBA-lite indicates a current account gap of 6.5 percent and a REER gap of 16.7 percent.
- The EBA-lite attributes 2.5 percent of GDP of the current account gap to fiscal policy gaps and a residual of 4.4 percent of GDP to structural policy gaps.
- Staff-recommended fiscal policy adjustment would close the fiscal component of the gap; structural reforms would reduce the structural component, bringing the current account closer to levels consistent with external stability (about 3 percent of GDP or less).

Export market shares (MS) analysis
- Belize’s world export share declined by nearly 15 percent between 2011 and 2015, while its REER appreciated by about 10 percent during the same period.
- The 2015 strengthening of the U.S. dollar led to nominal appreciation vis-à-vis other trading partners; some small states with smaller REER appreciation maintained or increased market share.
- Sector-specific shocks (e.g., diseases affecting the shrimp and citrus industries) also contributed to the decline in export market shares.
- The 2015 nominal effective exchange rate (NEER) appreciated by 11 percent.

### Scenarios and numerical table highlights (selected)
- ES approach equilibrium external current account (CA):
  - Baseline: -2.7
  - Alternative scenario: -1.8
  - EBA-lite: -3.3
- Underlying CA balance (values in brackets show the minimum and maximum projected current account deficits in the 2016-21 period):
  - Baseline: [-7.4   -10.6]
  - Alternative: [-7.4   -10.6]
  - EBA-lite: -9.8
- CA elasticity to REER: -0.39 (all approaches)
- Implied REER adjustment (in percent, "+" appreciation):
  - Baseline: [-12.1  -20]
  - Alternative: [-14.4    -22.6]
  - EBA-lite: 16.7
- Current account gap (EBA-lite): -6.5
  - of which fiscal policy gap: -2.5

### Reserves adequacy, adequacy metrics, and projected trajectories
- Expected shocks to the financial account (further decline or end of PetroCaribe financing, increase in external debt service, repatriation of BTL payments) could markedly deteriorate the financial account from 2017 onward.
- Standard non-risk weighted adequacy metrics indicate reserves will fall below 3 months of imports and below 20 percent cover of broad money by 2018.
- Two risk-weighted indicators imply reserves may fall below the adequacy range in 2016-17:
  - Risk-Weighted Measure indicates reserves would represent only 80 percent of the level considered adequate at end-2017.
  - SIDS Measure suggests reserves may fall below the 75 percent lower bound of the adequacy region already at end-2016.
- Selected ratios of reserves to optimal reserves based on various measures (In percent):
  - 2015: Risk-Weighted Measure 112; SIDS Measure 76; 3 months of Imports 139; 20% of Broad Money 152; Short Term Debt 970
  - 2016: Risk-Weighted Measure 100; SIDS Measure 73; 3 months of Imports 135; 20% of Broad Money 132; Short Term Debt 841
  - 2017: Risk-Weighted Measure 80; SIDS Measure 58; 3 months of Imports 111; 20% of Broad Money 104; Short Term Debt 680
  - 2018: Risk-Weighted Measure 65; SIDS Measure 46; 3 months of Imports 91; 20% of Broad Money 83; Short Term Debt 431
  - 2019: Risk-Weighted Measure 49; SIDS Measure 34; 3 months of Imports 69; 20% of Broad Money 61; Short Term Debt 271
  - 2020: Risk-Weighted Measure 31; SIDS Measure 21; 3 months of Imports 43; 20% of Broad Money 37; Short Term Debt 174
  - 2021: Risk-Weighted Measure 12; SIDS Measure 8; 3 months of Imports 17; 20% of Broad Money 14; Short Term Debt 71
- Adequate Region ranges:
  - Risk-Weighted Measure: 100-150
  - SIDS Measure: 75-100
  - 3 months of Imports: 100
  - 20% of Broad Money: 100
  - Short Term Debt: 100

### Risks and implications
- Widening current account deficits and increased outflows pose risks to external stability given limited access to external borrowing.
- Without nominal exchange rate flexibility, adjustment must come through tighter domestic policies (particularly fiscal policy) and strong structural reforms to improve competitiveness.
- If fiscal and structural policies are not decisively adjusted, the policy gap may require nominal exchange rate adjustment; given high external debt, nominal depreciation could significantly increase the debt burden and necessitate larger fiscal tightening.

### Policy recommendations
- Tighten fiscal policy to address fiscal policy gap (EBA-lite quantifies fiscal policy gap at -2.5 percent of GDP).
- Implement structural reforms to reduce structural policy gaps (residual of 4.4 percent of GDP in EBA-lite) and improve external competitiveness by lowering production costs and improving efficiency and productivity.
- Prioritize measures that preserve reserves and address upcoming external financing pressures (BTL compensation payments, increased external debt service from 2017, potential end of PetroCaribe financing).
- Strengthen debt management and consider options to mitigate reserve depletion and external financing risks.

*Source: Annex I. External Stability Assessment (from the provided IMF content unit).*

### 11. Strong fiscal consolidation efforts are essential to bringing public debt back to a

### 11. Strong fiscal consolidation efforts are essential to bringing public debt back to a sustainable path.

### Key policy recommendation
- Recurrent debt restructuring episodes suggests that the country’s current debt level is excessive and it would be prudent to adopt an objective of reducing debt to around 60 percent of GDP for the medium to long term.
- In addition to fiscal adjustment, supporting policies to improve growth, deepen domestic financial market, and improve public debt management will also be essential to improve the debt outlook.

### Debt dynamics and vulnerabilities (selected indicators and projections)
- Nominal gross public debt (series as presented): 88.4 77.6 82.1 93.3 94.0 94.9 96.7 98.7 100.8
- Public gross financing needs (series as presented): 10.3 3.7 8.4 11.8 11.8 12.5 15.8 19.2 22.5
- EMBIG (bp) (average over the last 3 months, 02-Mar-16 through 31-May-16): 1193
- Real GDP growth (in percent) (series as presented): 2.7 4.1 1.0 0.5 2.5 2.2 1.7 1.7 1.7
- Inflation (GDP deflator, in percent) (series as presented): 2.3 1.5 1.0 1.0 2.2 2.2 2.1 2.0 2.0
- Effective interest rate (in percent) (series as presented): 5.0 3.4 3.3 3.6 3.7 4.2 4.3 4.7 5.1
- Change in gross public sector debt (cumulative, series as presented): -2.7 -1.8 4.5 11.2 0.6 1.0 1.7 2.0 2.2 18.7
- Identified debt-creating flows (series as presented): -2.9 -2.1 4.1 11.3 0.7 1.0 1.7 2.0 2.2 18.8
- Primary deficit ( - surplus) (series as presented): -2.5 -0.4 4.1 2.2 1.6 1.3 1.3 1.0 0.8 8.3
- Primary (noninterest) revenue and grants (series as presented): 26.8 28.7 28.2 29.1 28.3 27.5 27.0 27.0 26.9 165.8
- Primary (noninterest) expenditure (series as presented): 24.4 28.3 32.3 31.3 29.9 28.7 28.4 28.1 27.9 174.3
- Automatic debt dynamics (series as presented): -0.1 -1.7 1.0 1.7 -1.0 -0.3 0.4 0.9 1.2 3.0
- Of which: real interest rate (series as presented): 2.3 1.4 1.8 2.1 1.3 1.7 2.0 2.5 2.9 12.5
- Of which: real GDP growth (series as presented): -2.3 -3.1 -0.8 -0.4 -2.3 -2.0 -1.6 -1.6 -1.7 -9.5
- Other identified debt-creating flows (series as presented): -0.4 0.0 -1.0 7.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 7.4
- Contingent liabilities data note: Data for 2016 refers to liabilities resulting from past nationalization of utilities.
- Residual, including asset changes (series as presented): 0.3 0.3 0.4 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 -0.1

### Baseline and scenario assumptions (selected underlying assumptions and scenario outputs)
- Baseline scenario (assumes constant primary balance) — selected projections (2016–2021):
  - Real GDP growth (in percent): 0.5 2.5 2.2 1.7 1.7 1.7
  - Inflation (in percent): 1.0 2.2 2.2 2.1 2.0 2.0
  - Primary Balance (in percent of GDP): -2.2 -1.6 -1.3 -1.3 -1.1 -0.9
  - Effective interest rate (in percent): 3.6 3.7 4.2 4.3 4.7 5.1
- Historical scenario (selected projections):
  - Real GDP growth (in percent): 0.5 2.6 2.6 2.6 2.6 2.6
  - Primary Balance (in percent of GDP): -2.2 1.7 1.7 1.7 1.7 1.7
  - Effective interest rate (in percent): 3.6 3.7 4.2 4.3 4.6 4.9

### Stress tests and alternative scenarios (highlights)
- Fiscal consolidation scenario (selected projections):
  - Real GDP growth (in percent): 1.5 1.8 2.6 2.8 3.0 3.2
  - Inflation (in percent): 1.0 2.2 2.2 2.1 2.0 2.0
  - Primary balance (in percent of GDP): 3.5 4.6 4.4 4.6 4.7 4.7
  - Effective interest rate (in percent): 3.6 3.6 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.6
- Financial sector contingent liability shock (one-time increase in non-interest expenditures equivalent to 10% of banking sector assets) — example impact on primary balance in 2016: -8.8 (series shows Primary balance under this shock as -2.2 -8.8 -1.3 -1.3 -1.1 -0.9)
- Combined macro-fiscal shock and individual shocks modeled include: Primary Balance Shock; Real GDP Growth Shock; Real Interest Rate Shock; Real Exchange Rate Shock; Combined Shock; Financial Sector Contingent Liability Shock.

### External debt and external vulnerability indicators (selected metrics)
- Baseline: External debt (external debt-to-GDP, series presented): 70.7 66.6 67.5 66.6 68.0 68.2 66.9 63.9 60.7 56.9 52.5
- Change in external debt (series as presented): -4.4 -4.2 0.9 -0.9 1.4 0.2 -1.3 -3.0 -3.2 -3.8 -4.4
- Identified external debt-creating flows (series as presented): -7.9 -10.4 1.2 -3.7 5.6 7.6 5.1 2.5 2.3 2.2 1.2
- Current account deficit, excluding interest payments (series as presented): -1.8 -1.2 3.3 5.3 7.7 8.3 7.3 6.2 6.1 6.0 5.3
- Automatic debt dynamics (series as presented): -1.7 -1.4 -0.8 -1.5 0.8 1.9 0.7 1.1 1.4 1.3 1.2
- Contribution from nominal interest rate (series as presented): 2.9 2.4 1.3 2.1 2.1 2.2 2.4 2.5 2.4 2.3 2.1
- Contribution from real GDP growth (series as presented): -1.5 -2.5 -0.8 -2.6 -0.7 -0.3 -1.7 -1.4 -1.1 -1.0 -1.0
- Residual, incl. change in gross foreign assets (series as presented): 3.5 6.2 -0.3 2.8 -4.2 -7.4 -6.4 -5.5 -5.5 -6.0 -5.7
- External debt-to-exports ratio (in percent) (series as presented): 111.6 102.0 103.6 99.4 107.5 121.3 121.3 117.6 112.8 106.7 98.0
- Gross external financing need (in billions of US dollars) (series as presented): 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.3 0.2
- Gross external financing needs (in percent of GDP) (series as presented): 3.8 3.8 10.6 9.8 12.1 13.1 12.2 11.3 11.7 12.0 11.1

### Liabilities related to Belize Telemedia Limited (BTL) settlement (selected figures)
- 2015 Article IV Consultation projections (Supplement 3) — Valuation of BTL shares (mid-point estimate): 168.0
  - Price per share: 3.7
  - Number of shares (millions): 45.2
  - Liabilities from the nationalization of BTL (stock at the end of period): 211.1 105.6 0.0
  - Capitalized interest and other costs: 75.6 37.8 0.0
  - Total payments for the nationalization of BTL: 32.5 105.6 114.4
  - Principal: 32.5 105.6 105.6
  - in foreign currency (series as presented): 32.5 105.6 105.6
- Current baseline projections — Valuation of BTL shares: 126.5
  - Price per share: 2.8
  - Number of shares (millions): 45.2
  - Liabilities from the nationalization of BTL (stock at the end of period): 147.9 73.9 0.0
  - Capitalized interest and other costs: 53.9 26.9 0.0
  - Total payments for the nationalization of BTL: 32.5 73.9 80.1
  - Principal: 32.5 73.9 73.9
  - in domestic currency (series as presented): 0.0 38.5 38.5
  - in foreign currency (series as presented): 32.5 35.4 35.4
  - Interest and other costs (series as presented): ... 0.0 6.2
- Memorandum items (in percent of GDP):
  - Expected total recognition of BTL and other contingent liabilities (stock): ... 11.0 ...
  - Liabilities from the nationalization of BTL: ... 8.3 ...
  - Compensation for expropriation of land and other liabilities: ... 2.6 ...
  - Total payments on BTL and other contingent liabilities made in 2015: 6.6 4.2 4.0
  - Compensation for BTL shares: 1.9 4.2 4.0
  - Settlement of an old loan from BCB to BTL: 2.8 0.0 0.0
  - Payment of compensation for BEL: 2.0 0.0 0.0

*Source: IMF Fund staff estimates and country data as presented in the DSA tables and figures.*

### Annex III. Risk Assessment Matrix

### Annex III. Risk Assessment Matrix

### External risks
- Sharper-than-expected global growth slowdown, particularly structurally weak growth in key advanced and emerging economies  
  - Relative Likelihood: High/Medium  
  - Impact if Realized: High  
    - Euro area could face an extended period of low growth, reflecting weak domestic demand due to high real interest rates and inadequate structural reforms.  
    - Stagnation in tourism and exports. A weak recovery in advanced economies, especially in Europe, could significantly undermine growth in Belize, restrain public finances, and put pressures on the BOP and reserves. Belize’s share of exports to Europe is very high.  
  - Policy measures:  
    - Strengthen resilience to external demand shocks by diversifying the export mix to include a larger share of CARICOM countries.  
    - Build fiscal and external buffers to offset a potential shock.  
    - Broaden the sources of growth by diversifying into economic sectors that are less vulnerable to cyclical external shocks.

- Tighter or more volatile global financial conditions (with a surge in the US dollar and increasing international interest rates in particular)  
  - Relative Likelihood: High  
  - Impact if Realized: High  
    - As the currency is pegged to the U.S. dollar, the real exchange rate would appreciate, eroding Belize’s external competitiveness.  
    - With imperfect capital controls, domestic interest rates could increase, thus further raising the debt service burden.  
    - Export of goods and services would decline, and the external current account deficit would widen.  
    - There would be less fiscal space for public investment and the low investor confidence would further reduce private investment and growth.  
  - Policy measures:  
    - Carry out fiscal consolidation and structural reforms to increase fiscal space, boost external competitiveness and curb real exchange appreciation through external price competitiveness measures.

- Reduced financial services by global/regional banks (withdrawal of CBRs)  
  - Relative Likelihood: High  
  - Impact if Realized: High  
    - Major Belizean banks have already lost correspondent banking relationships with global/regional banks and finding replacement correspondents is very difficult.  
    - Financial intermediation could be damaged and seriously disrupt economic activity.  
  - Policy measures:  
    - Support regional efforts to address challenges posed by withdrawal of CBRs.  
    - Temporarily allow banks to use the central bank platforms to process international transactions, while ensuring that appropriate AML/CFT due diligence measures are effectively implemented for these transactions by the banking sector as a whole.

- Persistently low energy prices  
  - Relative Likelihood: Medium  
  - Impact if Realized: Medium  
    - The external current account deficit would narrow, but PetroCaribe soft financing could come to an end.  
    - A sustained decline in oil prices would lower the oil import bill, but the positive impact on BOP would be partially offset by lower PetroCaribe financing.  
  - Policy measures:  
    - Use savings from lower oil prices to build reserves and enhance external stability.  
    - Ensure some pass through of lower international oil prices to domestic prices to stimulate demand and enhance competitiveness while collecting some additional revenue to rebuild fiscal buffers.

### Domestic risks
- Fiscal policy implementation: hesitation in implementing a credible fiscal adjustment will leave the country in a highly vulnerable position.  
  - Relative Likelihood: High  
  - Impact if Realized: High  
    - Declining petroleum revenue, the increases in compensations for civil servants, and the rolling out of the national health insurance scheme and other spending pressures stemming from the political environment have reduced the likelihood of a significant improvement in the primary balance. Moreover, the authorities are of the view that deteriorating social, infrastructure, and security conditions constrain Belize from tightening the fiscal stance beyond the primary surplus target of 1 percent of GDP.  
    - Debt will continue to increase in an unsustainable manner. Gross financing needs would rise sharply over the medium term. Securing such financing would be a challenge due to undeveloped domestic market and limited external market access.  
  - Policy measures:  
    - Carry out fiscal consolidation gradually raising the fiscal primary balance to 4-5 percent of GDP by cutting non-essential spending, improving PFM, and raising more revenue by reducing exemptions and strengthening revenue administration.

- Distress in the banking system  
  - Relative Likelihood: High  
  - Impact if Realized: High  
    - While declining, non-performing loans remain high, and while improving, provisioning remains relatively low. Some domestic banks, including the largest bank, which is of systemic proportions, still have low capital buffers, and raising new capital to avoid a deterioration of their capital adequacy ratios could be a challenge, increasing the risk of public sector intervention.  
    - Financial intermediation could be damaged and seriously disrupt economic activity. Absorption of the financial cost of recapitalizing distressed banks by the government could entail significant fiscal costs, putting additional pressure on public finances.  
  - Policy measures:  
    - Order undercapitalized banks to raise more capital, and maintain tight supervision.

- Surge in contingent liabilities  
  - Relative Likelihood: High  
  - Impact if Realized: High  
    - Courts still have to rule on the size of the compensation the government has to pay to the former owners of the nationalized telecommunication company. In the worst case scenario, payments could turn out to be closer to the claimants’ (upper) valuation of about 12 percent of GDP. Moreover, nonresidents, who account for a significant portion of the compensation claims, would likely not roll over their debt holdings.  
    - In addition to a possible intervention for the financial sector, the government may have to incur more external liabilities, just to build up reserves and support the current exchange rate peg should BOP pressures become more severe than envisaged.  
    - Debt could increase significantly because of the compensation for the nationalized companies, further threatening debt sustainability and aggravating refinancing risks as nonresident debt holders pull out. Even though additional external borrowing was envisaged at the time of the 2013 debt restructuring, new external lending to Belize will likely be very costly. It will also further weaken debt sustainability and undermine investors’ confidence in the Belizean economy and the currency peg. Higher-than-projected compensation would exert significant drain on reserves.  
  - Policy measures:  
    - Create fiscal buffers through fiscal consolidation (see point 1).  
    - Support external stability by strengthening the competitiveness of key export sectors (sugar, banana, citrus, marine products) and further diversify exports.  
    - Strengthen the business environment and improve physical infrastructure to attract greater domestic and foreign investment and support the development of small-and-medium-sized enterprises.

*Annex III. Risk Assessment Matrix, IMF staff report content provided in source.*

### 5.2016 program. One lending operation, Solid Waste Management Program II was approved

### 5.2016 program. One lending operation, Solid Waste Management Program II was approved

### Lending operations and pipeline
- One lending operation, Solid Waste Management Program II, was approved in May.
- Another lending operation on Citizen Security is in the pipeline for 2016.
- The Bank will support Belize through new technical assistance in the following areas:
  - Disaster and Climate Resilience in Sustainable Tourism
  - Citizen Security
  - Efficiency on Public Health Supply Chain Management

### Current portfolio (in US$ million)
- The loan portfolio consists of five investment loans for US$72 million, of which US$59.3 million (82 percent) remains undisbursed.
- One of the four loans is expected to exit the portfolio in 2016.
- Loan details (Loan — Approved — Undisbursed):
  - Belize City Flood Mitigation Infrastructure Program — 10.0 — 0.9
  - George Price Highway Rehabilitation Program — 27.0 — 26.8
  - Education Quality Improvement Program — 10.0 — 6.9
  - Sustainable Tourism Program II — 15.0 — 14.7
  - Solid Waste Management Program II — 10.0 — 10.0
- Total — 72.0 — 59.3

### Loan transactions (In US$ million)
- Annual series (2009 through 2016):
  - Net flows: 4.9, -2.0, 2.9, 4.7, 1.4, -1.8, -2.1, 6.0
  - Gross disbursements: 12.9, 5.7, 10.2, 12.8, 9.7, 7.4, 8.5, 5.2
  - Amortization: 4.2, 4.3, 4.3, 6.0, 6.6, 7.4, 8.8, 8.9
  - Interest and charges: 3.8, 3.1, 1.8, 1.9, 1.7, 1.8, 1.8, 2.3
- *Projected.

### Relations with the Caribbean Development Bank — Loan Portfolio Under Implementation (as of May 18, 2016) (In millions of U.S. dollars)
- Loan — Approved — Undisbursed:
  - BRIDGE REHABILITATION - TROPICAL STORM ARTHUR — 8.8 — 0.6
  - SIXTH CONSOLIDATED LINE OF CREDIT — 10.0 — 0.0
  - BELIZE RIVER VALLEY RURAL WATER PROJECT — 3.5 — 0.1
  - THE BELIZE SOCIAL INVESTMENT FUND II — 15.0 — 4.0
  - FOURTH ROAD PROJECT - SANTA ELENA - SAN IGNACIO BYPASS — 24.7 — 10.3
  - DETAILED DESIGNS - EXPANSION OF WATER AND SEWERAGE FACILITIES, AMBERGRIS CAYE — 0.7 — 0.3
  - TA - EDUCATION SECTOR REFORM — 2.0 — 1.4
  - ROAD SAFETY PROJECT — 7.2 — 0.2
  - YOUTH AND COMMUNITY TRANSFORMATION PROJECT — 5.2 — 4.8
  - FIFTH ROAD PROJECT - PHILIP S. W. GOLDSON HIGHWAY UPGRADING — 29.7 — 29.4
  - SEVENTH CONSOLIDATED LINE OF CREDIT — 10.5 — 4.5
  - ROAD SAFETY PROJECT - ADD. LOAN — 4.6 — 4.2
  - BELIZE EDUCATION SECTOR REFORM PROGRAMME II — 35.0 — 34.9
- TOTAL — 157.0 — 94.7

### Loan transactions with CDB (In millions of U.S. dollars)
- Annual series (2009 through 2015):
  - Net flows: 10.0, 1.5, (3.8), (15.7), (3.2), (3.5), 5.5
  - Gross disbursements: 21.0, 15.0, 8.7, 6.4, 10.7, 10.6, 19.0
  - Amortization: 6.4, 7.6, 7.8, 16.0, 9.8, 9.8, 9.3
  - Interest and charges: 4.8, 5.4, 4.7, 6.1, 4.1, 4.3, 4.3

### Economic and sector work — CDB support and project progress
- CDB country strategy for Belize covered 2011 to 2015 and new loan and grant approvals during this period closely mirrored the indicative project pipeline.
- Net loan flows to Belize, negative since the start of the CSP period, turned positive in 2015 as project implementation progressed.
- Transportation sector:
  - Reconstruction progressed on Kendall (Sittee River) and Mullins River bridges destroyed by tropical storm Arthur.
  - Kendall Bridge work completed; Mullins River Bridge set for completion in July 2016.
  - Fourth Road project (commenced 2012) delayed until early 2017.
  - Fifth Road loan for Philip S. W. Goldson Highway approved in May 2014; work commenced in the first quarter of 2016.
  - Road interventions target congestion reduction, climate change vulnerability, road safety, and capacity building on gender equality and social inclusion.
  - Road safety demonstration corridor on the Western Highway from Belize City to Belmopan showed positive initial results; additional loan approved in October 2014 to expand scope.
- Water sector:
  - Construction complete on potable water supply system serving nine villages in the Belize River Valley; final disbursement expected in 2016.
  - Loan approved in 2012 to finance detailed designs for expansion of water and sewerage on Ambergris Caye; designs should be completed in the third quarter of 2016 and appraisal of the capital project scheduled to begin then.
  - Project viewed as important to sustain and boost tourism and protect the sensitive environment.
- Private sector development:
  - Support mainly through lines of credit managed by the Development Finance Corporation (DFC) for agriculture, industry, housing, and education.
  - Sixth line of credit fully committed as at end-2013; seventh approved in July 2014, including a small grant for a pilot renewable energy/energy efficiency initiative.
  - Small TA grant provided in 2014 for institutional strengthening of DFC; implementation of consultant’s report ongoing.
  - Caribbean Technological Consultancy Services (CTCS) network provides grant-funded technical assistance to MSMEs.
- Social programs and grants:
  - Significant concessional lending and grant funding for poverty reduction.
  - Belize Social Investment Fund (BSIF): US$15 million made available through a second loan approved in 2010 (following a US$7 million loan in 2003).
  - Grant funding through the Basic Needs Trust Fund (BNTF): Belize’s allocation under the 7th cycle of US$6.1 million is still under implementation and the 8th cycle allocation of US$1.6 million is currently being programmed.
  - Interventions concentrated in water and sanitation, education, health, and infrastructure; support for results-based monitoring and evaluation.
- Education sector:
  - Grant assistance in 2010 supported formulation of a comprehensive Education Sector Strategy.
  - 2012 Technical Assistance loan for Education Sector Reform supported institutional strengthening and development of a comprehensive school location plan.
  - Belize Education Sector Reform Programme II approved in May 2015 aims to significantly expand the school plant and provide supporting services to increase access to quality education.
- Youth and community:
  - Youth and Community Transformation Project approved in 2012 to build human capital among youth and children from poor communities in Belize City to reduce socially deviant behavior.
  - Project implementation scheduled for completion by the end of 2017.

### Statistical issues (As of May 31, 2016)
- Assessment of Data Adequacy for Surveillance:
  - General: Data provision has some shortcomings, but is broadly adequate for surveillance.
  - Real sector:
    - SIB publishes GDP, CPI, population and labor force/employment statistics, social indicators.
    - Timeliness and frequency generally adequate except social indicators (poverty and literacy) which have large lags due to human and financial limitations at SIB.
    - GDP on expenditure basis available only annually and with a significant lag; room to strengthen compilation.
  - Fiscal accounts:
    - Data on consolidated operations of the public sector are unavailable.
    - Priorities include preparing a comprehensive list of institutions comprising central government, general government, and public sector including extra budgetary units.
    - Social Security Board (SSB) is not treated as part of general government; Central Bank classifies SSB as other non-financial public corporation and includes its claims (deposits) on the banking system as part of broad money.
    - Difficulties persist in compilation of capital expenditure due to Capital II items becoming permanent funding allocations.
    - Current accounting practices follow neither a cash basis nor an accrual basis, contributing to inconsistent accounting and reporting of assets, liabilities, revenues, and expenses.
    - Domestic debt data recording needs improvement.
  - Monetary and financial statistics:
    - Financial soundness indicators of individual banks available quarterly.
    - Very limited data on non-bank financial institutions, especially the offshore sector; information on domestic insurance companies not publicly available.
    - Authorities are developing a financial statistics database.
  - Balance of payments:
    - SIB publishes merchandise trade data monthly with a one month lag and monthly press releases.
    - Merchandise trade data do not cover services, constraining assessment of current account given tourism services’ large share of exports.
    - Usefulness would improve if merchandise trade statistics are expanded to cover trade in services and the international investment position.
- Data Standards and Quality:
  - Participant in the General Data Dissemination System (GDDS) since September 27, 2006.
  - No data ROSC is available.
- Reporting to STA:
  - No fiscal data are being reported for publication in the Government Finance Statistics Yearbook or in the IFS.

### Belize: Table of Common Indicators Required for Surveillance (As of May 31, 2016)
- Selected items with Date of Latest Observation — Date Received — Frequency of Data/Reporting/Publication (where provided):
  - Exchange Rates — 5/31/2016 — 6/1/2016 — M/M/M
  - International Reserve Assets and Liabilities of the Monetary Authorities 1/ — 3/31/2016 — 3/31/2016 — W/W/W
  - Reserve/Base Money — 3/31/2016 — 5/12/2016 — W/W/W
  - Broad Money — 3/31/2016 — 5/12/2016 — W/W/W
  - Central Bank Balance Sheet — 3/31/2016 — 5/12/2016 — M/M/M
  - Banking System Balance Sheet — 3/31/2016 — 5/12/2016 — M/M/M
  - Interest Rates 2/ — 3/31/2016 — 5/12/2016 — M/M/M
  - Consumer Price Index — 4/30/2016 — 5/25/2016 — M/M/M
  - Revenue, Expenditure, Balance and Composition of Financing 3/ — Central Government — 3/31/2016 — 5/13/2016 — M/M/NA
  - Stocks of Central Government and Central Government-Guaranteed Debt 5/ — 3/31/2016 — 5/13/2015 — M/M/NA
  - External Current Account Balance — 2015Q4 — 5/10/2016 — Q/Q/Q
  - Exports/Imports of Goods and Services — 2015Q4 — 5/10/2016 — Q/Q/Q
  - GDP/GNP — 2015Q4 — 3/30/2016 — Q/Q/Q
  - Gross External Debt (Central Government only) — 3/31/2016 — 5/13/2016 — A, MA, MNA
  - International Investment Position 6/ — NA — NA — NA/NA/NA

*Source: STAFF REPORT FOR THE 2016 ARTICLE IV CONSULTATION—SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION (As of May 2016).*

### 1.      On June 28, 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) issued a final

### On June 28, 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) issued a final

### PCA ruling on BTL compensation and financing implications
- Total amount of compensation amounted to an equivalent of US$ 221 million (12.2 percent of GDP).
- This amount is about 2 percentage points of GDP higher than staff’s projections in the staff report.
- On July 13, the government paid the equivalent of US$98 million (about 5.5 percent of GDP) to the former owners of BTL, in addition to “good faith” payments made toward compensation in late 2015.
- The remaining balance (about 4.8 percent of GDP) must be paid by July 2017.
- Authorities’ view: only about 30 percent of the compensation must be in US dollars; rest in local currency.
- Former owners’ position: 50 percent of compensation payments be made in US dollars; dispute taken to the Caribbean Court of Justice.
- Staff’s revised baseline assumption: about 30 percent of the compensation is paid in US dollars and the rest in local currency.
- Full impact of the PCA ruling on international reserves in 2016-17 would be close to US$60 million, which would reduce the reserve cover by 0.5 months of imports.
- Repatriation of the compensation payable in the local currency may increase the impact on reserves further.
- Compensation payments were made by issuing domestic debt.
- Staff’s revised projections assume sale of minority stakes in BTL and Belize Electricity Limited (BEL) would take place in 2017 rather than 2016, thereby increasing financing needs in 2016.
- As a result, the debt stock is expected to climb to nearly 100 percent of GDP in 2016, 6.5 percentage points higher than in the staff report.

### Macroeconomic outcomes and external sector, first half of 2016
- Real GDP contracted by 1.5 percent in the first half of 2016 relative to the same period in 2015.
- Drivers of the contraction: continued decline in agriculture, fisheries, and petroleum extraction.
- Services (especially tourism) and construction performed well.
- The 12-month inflation rate edged up to 1 percent in July (y/y).
- Average inflation for the first seven months of 2016: 0.6 percent.
- Exports of goods decreased by nearly 29 percent during the first seven months of 2016 relative to the same period last year.
- Imports decreased by 3.4 percent over the same period.
- Stop-over tourist arrivals increased by 16.6 percent during this period.
- Gross international reserves in late August: US$ 432 million (4.4 months of imports), close to end-2015 level despite the payment to former BTL owners.
- Unemployment eased to 8 percent in April 2016, down 2 percentage points from April 2015.

### Impact of hurricane Earl and growth outlook
- Hurricane Earl struck Belize on August 3; first-category hurricane.
- No loss of life reported.
- Preliminary Assessment Report by the National Emergency Management Organization estimates total losses at about BLZ$140 million (about 4 percent of GDP).
- Nearly half of the loss is in agriculture.
- Combined effects (first-half performance and hurricane damage) expected to:
  - Reduce real GDP growth to -1.5 percent in 2016.
  - Increase the current account deficit to 14 percent of GDP in 2016 (Table 2).
- Staff judges the hurricane impact to be likely transitory; medium-term projections are broadly similar to those in the staff report.

### Fiscal stance, debt sustainability, and staff recommendations
- Authorities should rebuild investor confidence by announcing without delay and quickly implementing a package of measures that would credibly put public debt on a sustainable path.
- Recent decision: defer the public wage increase scheduled for FY2016/17 to the next fiscal year—considered a step in the right direction.
- Staff recommendation: implement a credible package of measures to gradually raise the primary balance to 4–5 percent of GDP by 2021 (Table 3).
- Primary surpluses of 4–5 percent of GDP would have to be maintained beyond 2021 to reduce public debt to about 60 percent of GDP by 2030.
- Vigorous growth-enhancing structural reforms recommended to offset negative impact of fiscal consolidation and enhance competitiveness.
- Medium-term effects expected: lower government borrowing needs, reduced interest rates, greater investor confidence, and boosted private investment and growth.

### Key projections and fiscal measures (selected figures drawn from Tables)
- Revised public debt (percent of GDP): 99.9 in 2016; 95.7 in 2017; 96.4 in 2018; 97.7 in 2019; 99.6 in 2020; 101.7 in 2021 (Table 2, Revised).
- Revised real GDP growth (percent change): -1.5 in 2016; 1.9 in 2017; 2.8 in 2018; 2.3 in 2019; 1.7 in 2020; 1.7 in 2021 (Table 2, Revised, Baseline).
- Revised gross official reserves (months of imports): 3.7 in 2016; 3.1 in 2017; 2.3 in 2018; 1.7 in 2019; 1.0 in 2020; 0.4 in 2021 (Table 2, Revised, Baseline).
- Active scenario, Revised: public debt 99.0 in 2016; 92.0 in 2017; 88.1 in 2018; 84.6 in 2019; 81.2 in 2020; 77.3 in 2021.
- Table 3 — Total effect on the primary balance from recommended measures (in percent of GDP): 1.1 in FY2016/17; 3.9 in FY2017/18; 4.4 in FY2018/19; 5.0 in FY2019/20; 5.1 in FY2020/21; 5.2 in FY2021/22.
- Table 3 — Components (selected):
  - Expenditure measures (percent of GDP): 0.4 FY2016/17; 1.5 FY2017/18; 2.1 FY2018/19; 2.7 FY2019/20; 2.9 FY2020/21; 3.0 FY2021/22.
  - New revenue-enhancing measures (percent of GDP): 0.7 FY2016/17; 2.7 FY2017/18 through FY2021/22.
  - Specific revenue measures include: streamlining GST exemptions and removing MoF discretion (0.3 FY2016/17; 1.0 FY2017/18 and ongoing), increasing the general GST rate to 15 percent (0.3 FY2016/17; 1.1 FY2017/18 and ongoing), improving collection of import duties (0.1 FY2016/17; 0.3 FY2017/18 and ongoing), increasing excise on wine, beer and cigarettes (0.04 FY2016/17; 0.2 FY2017/18 and ongoing).
  - Second-order macro effects: 0.0 FY2016/17; -0.3 FY2017/18; -0.4 FY2018/19 onward.
- Memorandum items (Table 1 and Table 2):
  - Compensation for BTL shares as percent of GDP: 1.9 in 2015; 5.5 in 2016; 4.8 in 2017.
  - Total payments on BTL and other contingent liabilities (percent of GDP): 6.6 in 2015; 5.5 in 2016; 5.3 in 2017.
  - Nominal GDP baseline (US$ million): 1,718 (2014); 1,753 (2015); 1,763 (2016); 1,839 (2017); 1,936 (2018); 2,025 (2019); 2,104 (2020); 2,184 (2021).

### Exchange restrictions assessment (Article IV follow-up)
- Staff concluded Belize maintained an exchange restriction subject to Fund jurisdiction under Article VIII, Section 2(a) of the Articles of Agreement.
- Specific restriction: requirement of a tax clearance certificate to obtain FX for transfer of interest payments, rental income, management fees and royalties to non-residents was considered to give rise to an exchange restriction.
- Rationale: tax clearance requirement used to confirm outstanding taxes unrelated to the underlying transaction were paid before residents could obtain foreign exchange to make payments to non-residents for current transactions.

*Source: _cr16334 - 1.      On June 28, 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) issued a final*

### 2.      The Central Bank of Belize has subsequently provided additional

### _cr16334 - 2.      The Central Bank of Belize has subsequently provided additional

### Tax clearance certificate: IMF Article VIII assessment
- Central Bank of Belize provided operational details leading to the assessment that the tax clearance certificate requirement "does not give rise to an exchange restriction."
- Income Tax office does not withhold issuance of tax clearance certificates when the applicant owes taxes unrelated to the underlying transactions referenced.
- Purpose of the tax clearance certificate: "to ensure the determination of the respective net income and the withholding of the income tax due on the amounts to be paid or transferred abroad."
- The tax office pursues remedies separately against tax debtors for outstanding taxes unrelated to the above transactions.
- Staff conclusion: the tax clearance requirement "does not give rise to an exchange restriction subject to Fund approval under Article VIII, Section 2(a)."
- Date of assessment statement: September 19, 2016.

### Economic outlook and recent developments
- Recent data are described as "mixed, but tilted to the downside" (reference: staff supplement SM/16/164).
- Sector performance:
  - Tourism: "robust and growing."
  - Construction: "positive activity."
  - Agriculture, fisheries and petroleum extraction: "performed poorly."
- Labor and output indicators:
  - Unemployment rate "has declined by about 2 percent since 2015."
  - GDP rose by "1 percent in 2015."
  - GDP per capita "decline of 2.4 percent" in 2015.
  - GDP contracted by "1.5 percent" in the first half of the year referenced.
- Hurricane Earl impacts:
  - No loss of life reported.
  - Housing, infrastructure and agriculture sectors "suffered significant damage."
  - Government allocated "some $10m BzD (about 0.3 percent of GDP)" for immediate relief.
  - Authorities’ preliminary estimate of cost: "in the range of 3-4 percent of GDP."
  - ECLAC report expected later in September (authorities sought independent analysis).

### Final Ruling of the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA)
- PCA award: "US$ 221 million (12.2 percent of GDP)" for nationalized Belize Telemedia Company (BTL).
- Payment schedule and financing:
  - First half of the payment made in July 2016, financed through issuance of domestic debt.
  - Remaining balance "equivalent to about 4.8 percent of GDP" to be paid in July 2017.
- Currency composition dispute referred to the Caribbean Court of Justice; a ruling expected later in 2016.
- Macroeconomic implications:
  - PCA ruling is at "the upper end of the anticipated range" and is a "significant one-off negative impact on Belize’s public debt stock and international reserves."
  - Public debt "is now expected to reach nearly 100 percent of GDP by the end of 2016, before declining in 2017-19 and rising again thereafter if no further action is taken."
  - Despite the ruling and payment, "the payment of the first half of the award in July have not resulted in any market disruption."

### Fiscal policy and debt sustainability
- Measures already taken:
  - Fuel tax increased in late 2015.
  - Government proposed a one-year deferment of a public sector wage increase due in April 2016; estimated savings: "some $15 million BzD for the current year (about 0.5 percent of GDP)."
- Institutional actions:
  - New Minister of State appointed to focus on Budget preparations, fiscal performance review, and strengthening fiscal reporting in line with Fiscal Transparency and Responsibility Regulations.
  - Economic Policy Coordinating Team (the Team) established to identify measures to reduce current and capital expenditures, enhance revenue, and address debt management; Team includes Financial Secretary and Governor of the Central Bank.
  - Consultative process for budget FY 2017/18 commenced; plan to submit to Parliament "in mid-March 2017."
  - The Team will consider Fund and development partner recommendations, including "a possible increase to the goods and services tax (GST) and a further increase in the fuel tax."
  - Authorities emphasize consultation with business and labor communities to ensure buy-in.
- Policy stance on primary balance:
  - Authorities intend to target "a primary balance that places debt firmly on a declining path."
  - Staff’s DSA estimated debt-stabilizing primary balance: "1.2 percent of GDP."
  - Staff recommendation questioned by authorities: increase primary balance to "4-5 percent of GDP by 2021 and sustain it at this level."
  - Authorities cite the Crisis Program Review findings and express concern about staff’s "revised active scenario in table 2 of the staff supplement (SM/16/164)," which requires "a primary balance adjustment of nearly 9 percent of GDP from 2015 to 2018" but "only allows for a relatively small impact on growth."
  - Authorities stress opportunity costs of large fiscal consolidation and the need to invest in physical and human capital to support competitiveness and diversification.

### Financial sustainability and correspondent banking relationships (CBRs)
- Banking sector health improvements noted: "improved capital adequacy ratios, declining non-performing loans (NPLs), ample liquidity, and stronger regulatory frameworks."
- Financial infrastructure modernization:
  - National Payment System modernization underway.
  - Automated Payments and Securities Settlement System to be launched later this year, comprising:
    - Real Time Gross Settlement System,
    - Automated Clearing House,
    - Central Securities Depository.
- Provisioning debate: authorities disagree with staff suggestion to raise provisioning "to 100 percent," arguing it would be "inconsistent with international best practice" and could "delay the resolution of the affected NPLs."
- AML/CFT and tax transparency:
  - Belize has signed the Convention on Mutual Administrative Assistance in Tax Maters.
  - Establishing an Automatic Exchange of Information Unit in the Income Tax Department to provide financial account information based on Common Reporting Standards; Unit expected to be "fully functioning by January 2017."
- Correspondent Banking Relationships (CBRs):
  - CBR withdrawals present "an immediate threat to the financial system" and wider economy due to macro-financial linkages.
  - Authorities view CBR withdrawal as "a market failure" driven by unintended consequences of regulations in systemically important jurisdictions.
  - Staff’s "fear of the fine" analysis in the Selected Issues paper aligns with authorities’ view of the cause of CBR withdrawals.
  - Positive development: "three domestic banks in Belize have recently established a new correspondent banking relationship with a bank based in the United Kingdom."
  - Concern remains: "Belize’s largest domestic bank no longer has a CBR."
  - Authorities welcome Fund Management efforts to raise the profile of CBR issues and support Fund-hosted conference on CBRs at the Annual Meetings, seeking "practical, near-term solutions."
  - Authorities welcome recent efforts by systemically important enforcing jurisdictions to reduce uncertainty regarding regulatory scope in this area.

### Growth, GSDS, and development financing
- Growth and Sustainability Development Strategy (GSDS) remains medium-term guiding framework; endorsed in April 2016.
- Policy priorities under GSDS:
  - Boost trade by developing new crops and livestock industry.
  - Expand trade agreements with neighboring countries to support agriculture.
- Financing considerations:
  - Efforts underway to identify financing through budget cycle and development partner discussions.
  - Authorities note concerns about fungibility of funds for GSDS and sequential financing approaches by development partners.
  - Clarity on GSDS financing expected to "evolve naturally from decisions on the fiscal stance, pace of fiscal consolidation, and total amount of fiscal space."

### Conclusion and publication intent
- Authorities welcome ongoing engagement with the Fund and regular policy advice.
- Acknowledge disagreements on scale and speed of fiscal correction but are in "broad agreement with the overall findings of staff."
- Authorities intend to continue engagement with staff during Budget preparation and necessary adjustments to "ensure that debt is put on a downward trajectory."
- Authorities intend to publish the staff report and all related documents.

*Statement by Michael McGrath, Alternate Executive Director for Belize, and David Hart, Advisor — September 21, 2016*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/scr/2016/_cr16334.pdf_
