## _wp03207

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp03207](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2003/_wp03207.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2003/_wp03207.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2003/_wp03207.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction — key findings and context
- Transition overview:
  - "More than ten years of transition have redefined the economies of the countries of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS)2 and their interrelationships."
  - Real GDP growth: "12 percent on (unweighted) average between 2000 and 2002."
  - By the end of the decade, "most CIS economies had implemented the basic market mechanisms."
- Shocks and causes of trade decline:
  - Dismantling of Soviet and CMEA planning mechanisms.
  - Discontinuation of payment and clearing procedures producing "severe payments difficulties."
  - Introduction of independent, inconvertible currencies during "1992–94 led to foreign exchange shortages."
  - Real sector integration disruption, declining incomes (demand shock), opening to high-quality imports (supply shock), and political instability including trade blockades.
- Paper scope:
  - Analyzes CIS trade patterns over the transition decade, including "the overall quantitative trends in CIS trade," "the geographic reorientation of trade flows," and "the commodity structure of CIS trade."

### Developments in CIS trade during transition
- Aggregate trade and openness:
  - Exports increased by 154 percent and imports by 128 percent in U.S. dollar terms between 1993 and 2002.
  - 1998 Russian crisis interrupted growth; through 2002 total CIS imports did not rebound fully.
  - Trade openness (trade/GDP adjusted for PPP):
    - Rose from 5 percent in 1992 to about 15 percent in 1997.
    - Declined after the 1998 Russian crisis and plateaued at about 12 percent in 2002.
    - If GDP were not adjusted for PPP, the openness ratio would reach 50 percent in 2002.
- Geographic reorientation and concentration:
  - Intra-Soviet trade exceeded 80 percent of total Soviet trade for non-Russian republics in 1990.
  - Intra-CIS trade: 33 percent of total CIS trade in 1994; 25 percent in 2002.
  - Export commodity concentration: the three largest export products of each country accounted for an unweighted average of 67 percent of total exports.
  - Market concentration: the three main export markets averaged an unweighted 46 percent of total exports.
- Vulnerabilities:
  - High commodity and market concentration increases vulnerability to world price changes and developments in specific markets.

### Openness comparisons and regression evidence
- Reference group: 13 CEE+ countries (Albania, Bulgaria, Croatia, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Poland, Romania, the Slovak Republic, and Slovenia).
- Cross-country openness regression (double-log) explanatory variables: Population (N), PPP GDP per capita (G), EBRD transition index (E).
- Determinants of openness — CEE+ (Table 5) — Least Squares, 26 observations:
  - Constant: Coefficient -2.232035; Std. Error 0.851973; t-Statistic -2.619843; Probability 0.0156
  - POPULATIONCEE: Coefficient -0.313885; Std. Error 0.023971; t-Statistic -13.094400; Probability 0.0000
  - PPPCAPGDPCEE: Coefficient 0.391923; Std. Error 0.114396; t-Statistic 3.426031; Probability 0.0024
  - TEBRDCEE: Coefficient 2.364553; Std. Error 0.435575; t-Statistic 5.428582; Probability 0.0000
  - R-squared 0.903909; Adjusted R-squared 0.890806; F-statistic 68.983130; Prob(F-statistic) 0.000000
- Determinants of openness — CIS (Table 6) — Least Squares, 24 observations:
  - Constant: Coefficient 3.905730; Std. Error 1.496478; t-Statistic 2.609949; Probability 0.0168
  - POPULATIONCIS: Coefficient 0.047152; Std. Error 0.075683; t-Statistic 0.623019; Probability 0.5403
  - PPPCAPGDPCIS: Coefficient -0.158551; Std. Error 0.183403; t-Statistic -0.864492; Probability 0.3976
  - TEBRDCIS: Coefficient -0.359325; Std. Error 0.399372; t-Statistic -0.899725; Probability 0.3790
  - R-squared 0.072951; Adjusted R-squared -0.066106; F-statistic 0.524613; Prob(F-statistic) 0.670357
- Interpretation:
  - CEE+ regression fits well; population, PPP GDP per capita, and EBRD index are statistically significant with expected signs.
  - CIS specification performs poorly: coefficients statistically insignificant and low explanatory power.

### Gravity-type model and trade with the EU
- Gravity specification: Y_EU = trade openness ratio vis-à-vis the EU (exports to and imports from the EU divided by GDP adjusted for PPP); independent variables include Population (N), PPP GDP per capita (G), EBRD transition index (E), Distance to Frankfurt (D).
- Determinants of trade with the EU — CEE+ (Table 7) — Least Squares, 26 observations:
  - Constant: Coefficient -0.905314; Std. Error 1.061577; t-Statistic -0.852802; Probability 0.4034
  - POPULATIONCEE: Coefficient -0.271320; Std. Error 0.023921; t-Statistic -11.342440; Probability 0.0000
  - PPPCAPGDPCEE: Coefficient 0.325809; Std. Error 0.116132; t-Statistic 2.805511; Probability 0.0106
  - TEBRDCEE: Coefficient 2.295569; Std. Error 0.428156; t-Statistic 5.361526; Probability 0.0000
  - DISTANCECEE: Coefficient -0.195375; Std. Error 0.067078; t-Statistic -2.912650; Probability 0.0083
  - R-squared 0.951508; Adjusted R-squared 0.942272; F-statistic 103.016100; Prob(F-statistic) 0.000000
- Determinants of trade with the EU — CIS (Table 8) — Least Squares, 24 observations:
  - Constant: Coefficient 5.277135; Std. Error 2.275016; t-Statistic 2.319604; Probability 0.0317
  - POPULATIONCIS: Coefficient 0.081054; Std. Error 0.077785; t-Statistic 1.042035; Probability 0.3105
  - PPPCAPGDPCIS: Coefficient -0.284854; Std. Error 0.192677; t-Statistic -1.478406; Probability 0.1557
  - TEBRDCIS: Coefficient 0.466898; Std. Error 0.363413; t-Statistic 1.284759; Probability 0.2143
  - DISTANCECIS: Coefficient -0.337185; Std. Error 0.162607; t-Statistic -2.073623; Probability 0.0520
  - R-squared 0.298082; Adjusted R-squared 0.150310; F-statistic 2.017172; Prob(F-statistic) 0.132777
- Interpretation:
  - Gravity-augmented model fits CEE+ well; DISTANCE significant and negative.
  - For CIS, model fit is weak; DISTANCE shows marginal significance (Probability 0.0520).

### Simulation of CIS potential trade with the EU (out-of-sample)
- Method:
  - Apply parameters estimated for the CEE+ countries to CIS actual population, PPP GDP per capita, distance to Frankfurt.
  - Scale up CIS EBRD transition indices by 37 percent to match the CEE+ average transition index.
- Aggregate simulation result for 2001 (Table 9 summary):
  - Total additional CIS trade with the EU (simulated minus actual) in 2001: US$ 119,409.2 million, equal to 183.4 percent of their actual trade with the EU.
  - This unrealized trade potential equals 2.5 percent of overall EU trade.
- Country-level additional trade with the EU (Additional CIS Trade with the EU, In US$m; In percent of actual trade):
  - Armenia: 1,828.0 ; 537.6
  - Azerbaijan: 802.0 ; 42.6
  - Belarus: 1,895.8 ; 91.9
  - Georgia: 5,281.0 ; 1,057.1
  - Kazakhstan: 14,275.2 ; 405.3
  - Kyrgyz Republic: 1,917.2 ; 1,114.0
  - Moldova: 1,626.1 ; 438.0
  - Russia: 76,185.1 ; 162.6
  - Tajikistan: 180.8 ; 0.9
  - Turkmenistan: 350.4 ; 92.4
  - Ukraine: 13,326.7 ; 170.0
  - Uzbekistan: 1,740.9 ; 183.2
  - Total: 119,409.2 ; 183.4
- Country notes:
  - Georgia: unrealized trade potential largely explained by artificially low actual trade due to unrecorded shuttle trade.
  - Kyrgyz Republic: substantial potential remains idle due to trade restrictions by neighboring countries.

### Reasons for lower-than-expected CIS trade
- Regional and country-specific constraints:
  - Slow progress in transition: EBRD transition index average CIS 2.3 vs CEE+ 3.2 in 2002.
  - Severe trade restrictions, including trade blockades in the Caucasus and Central Asia.
  - Geographic/topographic isolation and distance.
  - Weak physical infrastructure.
  - Corruption and governance problems in customs and transport services.
  - Political tensions and restrictions to market access by key trading partners.
- Formal and informal barriers:
  - Trade taxes and nontariff barriers captured by IMF trade restrictiveness index; formal and informal barriers persist despite regional trade agreements.

### Trade restrictiveness, tariffs, and non-tariff barriers
- Regional index and tariffs:
  - Trade restrictiveness index level for the CIS region: "3.8 in 2002, significantly higher than the average of 2.0 for the CEE+ countries and the Baltics."
  - Average import tariff 1995 = 11.0 percent
  - Average import tariff 2002 = 8.7 percent
  - Non-tariff barriers and seasonal tariffs remain important; state export monopolies persist in Central Asia; delayed VAT refund repayments hinder exporters.
- Trade restrictiveness index scale:
  - EBRD transition index scale: 1 to 4 (1 = “no reforms”, 4 = developed market economy).
  - Trade restrictiveness index: level 1 means no restrictions; level 10 implies pervasive restrictions affecting more than 40 percent of total trade and trade taxes above 20 percent.
- Selected country snapshots (average import tariff; Trade Restrictiveness Index):
  - Armenia: 1997 = 3.7; 2002 = 4.0; Index 1997 = 1; 2002 = 1
  - Azerbaijan: 1997 = 10.8 (data for 2000); 2002 = 10.8; Index 1997 = 5; 2002 = 2
  - Belarus: 1997 = 12.6; 2002 = 12.2; Index 1997 = 8; 2002 = 8
  - Georgia: 1997 = 10.6 (data for 1999); 2002 = 10.9; Index 1997 = 5; 2002 = 2
  - Kazakhstan: 1997 = 13.3; 2002 = 7.8; Index 1997 = 5; 2002 = 4
  - Kyrgyz Republic: 1997 = 10.0 (data for 1999); 2002 = 5.1; Index 1997 = 2; 2002 = 1
  - Moldova: 1997 = 9.4; 2002 = 6.9; Index 1997 = 1; 2002 = 1
  - Russia: 1997 = 14.0; 2002 = 10.7; Index 1997 = 2; 2002 = 5
  - Tajikistan: 1997 = 8.0 (data for 1998); 2002 = 8.0; Index 1997 = 1; 2002 = 1
  - Turkmenistan: 1997 N.A.; 2002 N.A.; Index 1997 = 7; 2002 = 7
  - Ukraine: 1997 = 10.0; 2002 = 12.7; Index 1997 = 5; 2002 = 5
  - Uzbekistan: 1997 = 29.0; 2002 = 15.3; Index 1997 = 10; 2002 = 9
  - Table source: IMF.

### Regional trade agreements and WTO participation
- Numerous multilateral and bilateral regional trade agreements exist among CIS countries.
- WTO status:
  - Joined WTO: Armenia (2/5/2003), Georgia (6/14/2000), Kyrgyz Republic (12/20/1998), Moldova (7/26/2001)
  - Applied for WTO membership: Azerbaijan (7/97), Belarus (10/93), Kazakhstan (2/1996), Russia (6/1993), Tajikistan (7/2001), Ukraine (12/93), Uzbekistan (12/94)
  - "To date only the Kyrgyz Republic, Georgia, Moldova, and Armenia have joined the WTO while all other CIS countries, except Turkmenistan, have applied for membership."

### Geographic, infrastructure, and transit constraints
- Geographic/topographic constraints:
  - Many CIS countries are landlocked; lack of common EU borders (except Russia).
  - Caucasus and Central Asia face topographic impediments that increase transportation costs.
- Transportation and energy infrastructure issues:
  - Low and deteriorating road quality.
  - Rail transport to regions outside the CIS is more expensive due to gage differences.
  - Energy infrastructure remains largely Soviet legacy; non-transparent and discriminatory access to transit pipelines.
  - Regulations forcing oil companies to ensure domestic supplies before export access.
- Representative transport cost example (ADB estimate):
  - Truck cost Bishkek to Novosibirsk = US$ 1,598 (in addition to costs for the driver and fuel).
  - 82 percent of those costs go to Kazakhstan.
  - ADB: costs could be brought down by 75 percent if only official costs mattered.

### Governance, corruption, and political barriers
- Corruption Perceptions Index averages (Transparency International, for eight CIS countries in 2001 and 2002):
  - CIS average: 2.7
  - CEE+ countries average: 4.1
  - EU average: 7.6
  - Scale: 1 implies severe corruption; 10 implies absence of corruption.
- Corruption in customs and transport services is widespread; transportation enterprises face multiple layers of official and unofficial costs.
- Political tensions and conflicts:
  - Ethno-national conflict impeded national consolidation in Tajikistan and Moldova.
  - Political instability in the Caucasus disadvantages the region for trade.
  - Examples of regional rivalry: "destruction of a bridge to the Kyrgyz Republic by the government of Uzbekistan to prevent shuttle trade."

### External protectionism and market access
- Protection faced by CIS exports:
  - Agricultural exports hindered by the EU Common Agricultural Policy and absence of country-specific sub-quotas for grain exports (except Russia).
  - CIS access to the EU market constrained by absence of trade concessions comparable to those granted to several CEE+ countries.
  - Many CIS countries classified as nonmarket economies by the EU and the US.
  - CIS metal exports affected by U.S. steel tariffs and anti-dumping investigations.

### Summary conclusions, empirical finding, and policy recommendations
- Summary findings:
  - Trade openness increased through 1997 but fell to a lower-level plateau after the 1998 Russian crisis.
  - The CIS continues to lag other transition economies in opening up to trade.
  - Export commodity and market concentration remains high and, for some countries, has increased.
- Empirical finding:
  - "An EBRD transition index in line with the average achieved by the CEE+ countries would correspond to an increase in CIS trade with the EU by 183 percent."
- Policy recommendations (areas of reform expected to have positive impact on CIS trade):
  - Reduction of official and unofficial trade barriers.
  - Improvements to infrastructure to reduce the costs of trade.
  - Elimination of corruption in customs and transport services.
  - Closer cooperation at the level of economic policy to overcome regional obstacles to trade.
  - Broader participation in the WTO to enhance trade liberalization in the entire region.
  - Enterprise restructuring and market-oriented reforms to diversify competitive export commodities and develop marketing channels, reducing vulnerability to shocks and partner protectionism.

*Source: _wp03207 - Section III, I investigate CIS trade openness in general and trade with the European Union (PDF chapter/section).*

### References..............................................................................................................

### References

### Tables and Figures listed in the content unit
- Tables
  - 1. CIS: Total Exports, 1993–2002
  - 2. CIS: Total Imports, 1993–2002
  - 3. CIS: Commodity Concentration of Exports
  - 4. CIS: Geographic Concentration of Exports, 1995 and 2001
  - 5. Determinants of Openness for the Central and East European Transition Economies and Baltic Countries (CEE+ Countries)
  - 6. Determinants of Openness for the CIS Countries
  - 7. Determinants of Trade with the European Union (EU) for the CEE+ Countries
  - 8. Determinants of Trade with the EU for the CIS Countries
  - 9. CIS: Potential Trade with the EU, 2001
  - 10. CIS: Trade Restrictiveness, 1997 and 2002
  - 11. CIS: Regional Trade Agreements
- Figures
  - 1. CIS: Real Growth of Exports and Imports, 1994–2002
  - 2. CIS: Directions of Trade, 1994 and 2002
  - 3. CIS: Directions of Trade by Country, 1994 and 2002
  - 4. CIS: Openness, 1992–2002
  - 5. International Comparison of Openness, 2002

### Introduction — key findings and context
- Transition period overview
  - "More than ten years of transition have redefined the economies of the countries of the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS)2 and their interrelationships."
  - "The breakup of the Soviet Union resulted in a sharp decline in economy activity, but, following a turning point around 1996, the CIS economies have rebounded strongly, with real GDP growing by 12 percent on (unweighted) average between 2000 and 2002."
  - "While the stabilization and liberalization process in the CIS economies turned out to be lengthier than in other transition countries, by the end of the decade, most CIS economies had implemented the basic market mechanisms."
- Decline in intra-CIS trade and shocks identified
  - Dismantling of the Soviet and Council of Mutual Economic Assistance (CMEA) planning mechanisms (Brada (1976); IMF (1991)).
  - Discontinuation of payment and clearing procedures, "resulting in severe payments difficulties."
  - Introduction of independent, inconvertible currencies during "1992–94 led to foreign exchange shortages."
  - Severe disruption of real sector integration.
  - Declining incomes caused a demand shock.
  - Opening up to high-quality imports from developed market economies implied a supply shock.
  - Political instability, including trade blockades, further inhibited trade.
- Purpose and scope of the paper
  - "This paper analyzes the developments in CIS trade patterns over the transition decade, following the initial decline."
  - Section II will describe:
    - "the overall quantitative trends in CIS trade,"
    - "the geographic reorientation of trade flows,"
    - "and the commodity structure of CIS trade."

*Source: _wp03207 - References (excerpt).*

### Section III, I investigate CIS trade openness in general and trade with the European Union

### _wp03207 - Section III, I investigate CIS trade openness in general and trade with the European Union

### Developments in CIS trade during transition
- Exports of the CIS increased by 154 percent and imports by 128 percent in U.S. dollar terms between 1993 and 2002.
- The trend of increasing trade was interrupted by the 1998 Russian crisis; through 2002 total CIS imports did not rebound fully.
- Trade openness (trade/GDP adjusted for PPP) for the CIS:
  - Rose from 5 percent in 1992 to about 15 percent in 1997.
  - Declined after the 1998 Russian crisis and plateaued at about 12 percent in 2002.
  - If GDP were not adjusted for PPP, the openness ratio of the CIS countries would reach 50 percent in 2002.
- Geographic reorientation:
  - Intra-Soviet trade exceeded 80 percent of total Soviet trade for non-Russian republics in 1990.
  - Intra-CIS trade accounted for 33 percent of total CIS trade in 1994 and fell to 25 percent in 2002.
  - Geographic distribution of trade varies widely by country; some economies remain heavily dependent on intra-CIS trade.
- Export concentration:
  - Exports of oil are important for Kazakhstan, Azerbaijan, Russia and Turkmenistan; Azerbaijan and Turkmenistan are also major gas exporters.
  - The three largest export products of each country accounted for an unweighted average of 67 percent of total exports of the CIS economies (Table 3).
  - The share of the three main export markets in total exports remained an unweighted average of 46 percent (Table 4).
- Vulnerabilities: high commodity and market concentration increases vulnerability to world price changes and developments in specific markets.

### Openness comparisons and regression evidence
- Comparative approach:
  - CIS economies compared to a reference group of 13 Central and Eastern European + Baltic transition economies (CEE+): Albania, Bulgaria, Croatia, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Poland, Romania, the Slovak Republic, and Slovenia.
- Cross-country openness regression (double-log) explanatory variables:
  - Population (N), expected negative sign.
  - GDP per capita adjusted for PPP (G), expected positive sign.
  - EBRD transition index (E), expected positive sign.
- Determinants of openness — CEE+ (Table 5) — Least Squares, 26 observations:
  - Constant: Coefficient -2.232035, Std. Error 0.851973, t-Statistic -2.619843, Probability 0.0156
  - POPULATIONCEE: Coefficient -0.313885, Std. Error 0.023971, t-Statistic -13.094400, Probability 0.0000
  - PPPCAPGDPCEE: Coefficient 0.391923, Std. Error 0.114396, t-Statistic 3.426031, Probability 0.0024
  - TEBRDCEE: Coefficient 2.364553, Std. Error 0.435575, t-Statistic 5.428582, Probability 0.0000
  - R-squared 0.903909; Adjusted R-squared 0.890806; F-statistic 68.983130; Prob(F-statistic) 0.000000
- Determinants of openness — CIS (Table 6) — Least Squares, 24 observations:
  - Constant: Coefficient 3.905730, Std. Error 1.496478, t-Statistic 2.609949, Probability 0.0168
  - POPULATIONCIS: Coefficient 0.047152, Std. Error 0.075683, t-Statistic 0.623019, Probability 0.5403
  - PPPCAPGDPCIS: Coefficient -0.158551, Std. Error 0.183403, t-Statistic -0.864492, Probability 0.3976
  - TEBRDCIS: Coefficient -0.359325, Std. Error 0.399372, t-Statistic -0.899725, Probability 0.3790
  - R-squared 0.072951; Adjusted R-squared -0.066106; F-statistic 0.524613; Prob(F-statistic) 0.670357
- Interpretation:
  - For CEE+ countries the model fits well; population, PPP GDP per capita, and EBRD index have expected signs and are statistically significant.
  - For CIS economies the same specification performs poorly: coefficients are statistically insignificant and low R-squared indicates weak explanatory power.

### Gravity-type model and trade with the EU
- Gravity specification for trade openness vis-à-vis the EU (Y_EU):
  - Y_EU = trade openness ratio vis-à-vis the EU (sum of exports to and imports from the EU divided by GDP adjusted for PPP)
  - Independent variables: Population (N), GDP per capita adjusted for PPP (G), EBRD transition index (E), Distance to Frankfurt (D)
- Determinants of trade with the EU — CEE+ (Table 7) — Least Squares, 26 observations:
  - Constant: Coefficient -0.905314, Std. Error 1.061577, t-Statistic -0.852802, Probability 0.4034
  - POPULATIONCEE: Coefficient -0.271320, Std. Error 0.023921, t-Statistic -11.342440, Probability 0.0000
  - PPPCAPGDPCEE: Coefficient 0.325809, Std. Error 0.116132, t-Statistic 2.805511, Probability 0.0106
  - TEBRDCEE: Coefficient 2.295569, Std. Error 0.428156, t-Statistic 5.361526, Probability 0.0000
  - DISTANCECEE: Coefficient -0.195375, Std. Error 0.067078, t-Statistic -2.912650, Probability 0.0083
  - R-squared 0.951508; Adjusted R-squared 0.942272; F-statistic 103.016100; Prob(F-statistic) 0.000000
- Determinants of trade with the EU — CIS (Table 8) — Least Squares, 24 observations:
  - Constant: Coefficient 5.277135, Std. Error 2.275016, t-Statistic 2.319604, Probability 0.0317
  - POPULATIONCIS: Coefficient 0.081054, Std. Error 0.077785, t-Statistic 1.042035, Probability 0.3105
  - PPPCAPGDPCIS: Coefficient -0.284854, Std. Error 0.192677, t-Statistic -1.478406, Probability 0.1557
  - TEBRDCIS: Coefficient 0.466898, Std. Error 0.363413, t-Statistic 1.284759, Probability 0.2143
  - DISTANCECIS: Coefficient -0.337185, Std. Error 0.162607, t-Statistic -2.073623, Probability 0.0520
  - R-squared 0.298082; Adjusted R-squared 0.150310; F-statistic 2.017172; Prob(F-statistic) 0.132777
- Interpretation:
  - For CEE+ countries the gravity-augmented model fits well; distance to Frankfurt is a significant negative determinant of trade with the EU.
  - For CIS countries the model fit is weak; only distance shows marginal significance (Probability 0.0520).

### Simulation of CIS potential trade with the EU (out-of-sample)
- Method: apply parameters estimated for the CEE+ countries to CIS actual population, PPP GDP per capita, distance to Frankfurt; scale up CIS EBRD transition indices by 37 percent to match the CEE+ average transition index.
- Simulation result for 2001 (Table 9 summary):
  - Total additional CIS trade with the EU (simulated minus actual) in 2001: US$ 119,409.2 million, equal to 183.4 percent of their actual trade with the EU.
  - This unrealized trade potential equals 2.5 percent of overall EU trade (as stated in the text).
- Country-level additional trade with the EU (Additional CIS Trade with the EU, In US$m; In percent of actual trade):
  - Armenia: 1,828.0 ; 537.6
  - Azerbaijan: 802.0 ; 42.6
  - Belarus: 1,895.8 ; 91.9
  - Georgia: 5,281.0 ; 1,057.1
  - Kazakhstan: 14,275.2 ; 405.3
  - Kyrgyz Republic: 1,917.2 ; 1,114.0
  - Moldova: 1,626.1 ; 438.0
  - Russia: 76,185.1 ; 162.6
  - Tajikistan: 180.8 ; 0.9
  - Turkmenistan: 350.4 ; 92.4
  - Ukraine: 13,326.7 ; 170.0
  - Uzbekistan: 1,740.9 ; 183.2
  - Total: 119,409.2 ; 183.4
- Country notes from the simulation:
  - Georgia: unrealized trade potential largely explained by artificially low actual trade due to unrecorded shuttle trade.
  - Kyrgyz Republic: substantial potential remains idle due to trade restrictions by neighboring countries.

### Reasons for lower-than-expected CIS trade
- Regional and country-specific explanations (as identified in the text):
  - Slow progress in transition relative to reference countries (EBRD transition index average: CIS 2.3 vs CEE+ 3.2 in 2002).
  - Severe restrictions to trade, including trade blockades in the Caucasus and Central Asia.
  - Geographic and topographic features (isolation, landlocked status, distance).
  - Weaknesses in physical infrastructure.
  - Corruption and governance problems in customs and transport services.
  - Political tensions among CIS countries and restrictions to market access in some key trading partners.
- Formal and informal trade barriers:
  - IMF trade restrictiveness index captures trade taxes and nontariff barriers (Table 10 referenced in text).
  - Formal barriers and informal barriers exist despite numerous regional trade agreements.

*Italic source: _wp03207 - Section III, I investigate CIS trade openness in general and trade with the European Union (PDF chapter/section).*

### 3.8 in 2002, significantly higher than the average of 2.0 for the CEE+ countries and the

### _wp03207 - 3.8 in 2002, significantly higher than the average of 2.0 for the CEE+ countries and the

### Trade restrictiveness, tariffs, and non-tariff barriers
- Trade restrictiveness index level for the CIS region: "3.8 in 2002, significantly higher than the average of 2.0 for the CEE+ countries and the Baltics."
- Import tariffs:
  - Average import tariff in 1995: 11.0 percent
  - Average import tariff in 2002: 8.7 percent
- Non-tariff barriers remain important; some countries impose seasonal tariffs in addition to those captured by the index.
- Several state monopolies for certain exports are maintained in Central Asia.
- Delayed repayments of VAT refunds to exporters in several CIS countries constitute an additional obstacle to exports.
- Trade Restrictiveness Index scale and interpretation:
  - EBRD transition index uses a scale of 1 to 4 (1 = “no reforms”, 4 = developed market economy).
  - Trade restrictiveness index combines trade taxes and nontariff barriers: level 1 means no restrictions; level 10 implies pervasive restrictions affecting more than 40 percent of total trade and trade taxes above 20 percent.

### CIS: Country-level trade restrictiveness and tariff snapshots (selected table values)
- Armenia: Average import tariff 1997 = 3.7; 2002 = 4.0; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 1; 2002 = 1
- Azerbaijan: Average import tariff 1997 = 10.8 (data for 2000); 2002 = 10.8; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 5; 2002 = 2
- Belarus: Average import tariff 1997 = 12.6; 2002 = 12.2; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 8; 2002 = 8
- Georgia: Average import tariff 1997 = 10.6 (data for 1999); 2002 = 10.9; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 5; 2002 = 2
- Kazakhstan: Average import tariff 1997 = 13.3; 2002 = 7.8; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 5; 2002 = 4
- Kyrgyz Republic: Average import tariff 1997 = 10.0 (data for 1999); 2002 = 5.1; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 2; 2002 = 1
- Moldova: Average import tariff 1997 = 9.4; 2002 = 6.9; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 1; 2002 = 1
- Russia: Average import tariff 1997 = 14.0; 2002 = 10.7; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 2; 2002 = 5
- Tajikistan: Average import tariff 1997 = 8.0 (data for 1998); 2002 = 8.0; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 1; 2002 = 1
- Turkmenistan: Average import tariff N.A.; 2002 N.A.; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 7; 2002 = 7
- Ukraine: Average import tariff 1997 = 10.0; 2002 = 12.7; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 5; 2002 = 5
- Uzbekistan: Average import tariff 1997 = 29.0; 2002 = 15.3; Trade Restrictiveness Index 1997 = 10; 2002 = 9
- Table source: IMF.

### Regional trade agreements and WTO participation
- Numerous multilateral and bilateral regional trade agreements exist among CIS countries (examples listed in the source).
- WTO status (as reported):
  - Joined WTO: Armenia (2/5/2003), Georgia (6/14/2000), Kyrgyz Republic (12/20/1998), Moldova (7/26/2001)
  - Applied for WTO membership: Azerbaijan (7/97), Belarus (10/93), Kazakhstan (2/1996), Russia (6/1993), Tajikistan (7/2001), Ukraine (12/93), Uzbekistan (12/94)
  - To date only the Kyrgyz Republic, Georgia, Moldova, and Armenia have joined the WTO while all other CIS countries, except Turkmenistan, have applied for membership.

### Geographic, infrastructure, and transit constraints
- Geographic/topographic barriers:
  - Many CIS countries are landlocked; lack of common EU borders (except Russia) contrasts with CEE+ countries.
  - Topographic impediments in the Caucasus and Central Asia increase transportation costs.
- Transportation and energy infrastructure:
  - Quality of roads is low and deteriorating.
  - Rail transport to regions outside the CIS is more expensive due to gage differences.
  - Energy infrastructure largely remains a Soviet legacy, raising costs for energy transit and constraining energy trade.
  - Non-transparent and discriminatory restrictions of access to transit pipelines by government-dominated companies hinder trade.
  - Regulations forcing oil companies to ensure domestic supplies before export access are imposed.
- Representative transport cost example (ADB estimate):
  - Costs for taking a truck from Bishkek to Novosibirsk amount to US$ 1,598 (in addition to costs for the driver and fuel).
  - 82 percent of those costs go to Kazakhstan.
  - According to ADB the costs for a representative truck on this route could be brought down by 75 percent if only official costs mattered.

### Governance, corruption, and political barriers
- Corruption Perceptions Index averages (Transparency International, for the eight CIS countries included in the 2001 and 2002 reports):
  - CIS average: 2.7
  - CEE+ countries average: 4.1
  - EU average: 7.6
  - (Scale: 1 implies severe corruption; 10 implies absence of corruption.)
- Corruption in customs and transport services is widespread across the region; transportation enterprises face multiple layers of official and unofficial costs.
- Political tensions and conflicts:
  - Ethno-national conflict impeded national consolidation in Tajikistan and Moldova.
  - Political instability in the Caucasus further disadvantages the region for trade.
  - Absence of intra-CIS cooperation and regional rivalries inhibit exploitation of natural resources and regional trade (example: destruction of a bridge to the Kyrgyz Republic by the government of Uzbekistan to prevent shuttle trade).

### External protectionism and market access
- CIS comparative advantage areas face protectionism from potential importers:
  - Agricultural exports hindered by the EU Common Agricultural Policy and the general absence of country-specific sub-quotas for grain exports (except Russia).
  - CIS access to the EU market constrained by absence of trade concessions comparable to those granted to several CEE+ countries.
  - Many CIS countries continue to be classified as nonmarket economies by the EU and the US.
  - CIS metal exports are affected by U.S. steel tariffs and anti-dumping investigations.

### Summary conclusions, empirical finding, and policy recommendations
- Trade patterns and openness:
  - Trade openness of the CIS increased through 1997 but fell to a lower-level plateau after the 1998 Russian crisis.
  - The CIS continues to lag behind other transition economies in opening up to trade.
  - Concentration of export commodities and export markets remains high and, for some CIS countries, has increased.
- Empirical regression result:
  - An EBRD transition index in line with the average achieved by the CEE+ countries would correspond to an increase in CIS trade with the EU by 183 percent.
- Areas of reform expected to have positive impact on CIS trade (listed in the source):
  - Reduction of official and unofficial trade barriers.
  - Improvements to infrastructure to reduce the costs of trade.
  - Elimination of corruption in customs and transport services.
  - Closer cooperation at the level of economic policy to overcome regional obstacles to trade.
  - Broader participation in the WTO to enhance trade liberalization in the entire region.
  - Enterprise restructuring and market-oriented reforms to diversify competitive export commodities and develop marketing channels, reducing vulnerability to shocks and partner protectionism.

*Source: IMF.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2003/_wp03207.pdf_
