## _wp0442

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp0442](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2004/_wp0442.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2004/_wp0442.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2004/_wp0442.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction and scope
- Study objective: cross-country comparison of francophone African public expenditure management (PEM) systems to analyze similarities with and divergences from the French PEM system and among francophone African countries themselves.
- Questionnaire design:
  - Total items: 55 items.
  - Specific PEM questions: 49 specific questions.
  - General information questions: six questions.
  - PEM subcategory composition:
    - legal and institutional environment: 10 questions.
    - fiscal rules: 5 questions.
    - expenditure process and internal control: 14 questions.
    - accounting and reporting systems: 7 questions.
    - cash plan: 2 questions.
    - audit and external control: 11 questions.
- Data and coverage:
  - Responses collected from senior officials at the end of 2001.
  - Sample of 12 African countries: Benin, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Chad, the Republic of Congo, Côte d’Ivoire, Guinea, Madagascar, Mali, Niger, Senegal, and Togo.
  - Questionnaires sent to ministries of finance and IMF resident fiscal advisors where applicable; responses reviewed by IMF experts at headquarters.
- Purpose limits:
  - The paper does not provide a performance rating or define performance benchmarks; it compares PEM systems, highlights similarities/differences, and draws lessons for technical assistance (TA) implementation.

### Key features of the French reference model
- Legal framework and budget laws:
  - Core texts shaping budgeting until 2001: the 1959 Ordinance (Organic Budget Law) and the Decree of 1962 on Public Accounting.
  - Three types of budget laws passed by Parliament:
    1. initial budget law (includes all annual government revenues and expenditures);
    2. supplementary budget law (modifies the initial budget during execution);
    3. budget review law (reconciles executed budget with the initial budget after fiscal year closing).
  - Parliamentary role: Parliament has the first (voting on the initial budget law) and last word (voting on the review law) over public money.
- Appropriation types:
  - (1) Capped appropriations (crédits limitatifs): spending commitments and orders to pay are capped by the budget law (general rule).
  - (2) Provisional appropriations (crédits provisionnels): tentative amounts; government can supplement from other sources; typical use: natural disasters.
  - (3) Estimated appropriations (crédits évaluatifs): tentative estimates that can be increased; examples: debt repayments and litigation costs.
- Budgeting principles:
  - Four key principles: unity, annuality, universality, and specialty.
  - Unity: budget contains all government revenues and expenditures in a single document (general budget, ancillary budgets, and Treasury special accounts together constitute the budget law).
  - Annuality: budget approved and executed on an annual basis.
  - Universality: all revenues and expenditures incorporated; no earmarking; prevents netting.
  - Specialty: Parliament authorizes specified categories of credits (by ministry), allowing ministries to apportion credits within sub-administrations.
- Institutional roles:
  - Executive (minister of finance under the prime minister) prepares draft budget after consultations with spending ministries.
  - Executive executes the budget; spending process phases: engagement, liquidation, ordonnancement, paiement.
  - Ex post control by Parliament and the Public Audit Office (Cour des Comptes).

### Budget calendar, treasury cycle, and complementary period
- Fiscal year: January 1 to December 31.
- Deadlines and timing rules:
  - For spending requiring an order to pay (e.g., salaries and capital spending): origination act (engagement) can take place between January 1 and December 31.
  - For current expenditures other than salaries: deadline is November 30 (postponed to December 31 in emergencies).
  - December 31 is last day for giving the order to pay; actual payment should take place before January 15 of the next year.
  - Adjustment operations deadlines:
    - principal accountants: until January 15.
    - accountants designated by the finance ministry: until February 12.
    - Agent Comptable Central du Trésor (ACCT): until February 23.
  - For spending not requiring an order to pay: spending is accounted for during the year of actual payment.
- Complementary period:
  - Definition: the short period (officially 30 to 60 days, depending on countries) that stretches beyond fiscal year n, but whose transactions are linked to fiscal year n.
  - Types:
    - administrative complementary period: regularizes residual payment orders pending at fiscal year end.
    - accounting complementary period: allows proper itemization of spending.
  - Risks: a long complementary period may indicate lax budget spending procedures (unobserved closing dates, fluctuating budget calendar).
  - Reporting issue: fiscal reporting may follow a legal approach (link transactions to budget year) or a cash approach (report in year of cash flow); overstretched transaction dates complicate linking to original fiscal year.
  - Country practices:
    - France: complementary period shortened over time and is now limited to one month.
    - WAEMU guidance: complementary period should be limited to two months (transactions pertaining to fiscal year n but occurring by end-February (n+1) should be linked to fiscal year n).

### Treasury Single Account (TSA) and cash management
- TSA principle: government (via the Treasury) concentrates its cash resources in one account, usually held in the central bank.
- Institutional arrangements:
  - 1959 Ordinance stipulates local governments and public agencies (Treasury correspondents) deposit all funds at the Treasury, creating a pooled cash resource.
  - Unity of cash desk (unicité de caisse): a public accountant acts as one cashier serving many public entities.
  - "Treasury circuit": financial links between the Treasury and correspondents to show consolidated government cash status and allow transfers between entities with cash excesses and shortages.

### Expenditure process and segregation of duties (ELOP)
- Four phases of spending process (ELOP):
  - engagement: origination of spending.
  - liquidation: validation — goods or services delivered and amount of government debt calculated.
  - ordonnancement: order to pay issued by a credit manager (ordonnateur) to a public accountant.
  - paiement: public accountant disburses money.
- Segregation of duties:
  - Ordonnateurs perform the first three functions (origination, validation, order to pay).
  - Comptable/public accountant performs the payment phase.
  - Advantage: mutual control between those who commit the government and those who make payments; accountants under the finance ministry enhance monitoring through payment-phase controls.
- Exceptions to segregation:
  - government secret funds (fonds spéciaux): do not have to be justified (national security matters).
  - cash advance funds (régies d’avances): remedy lengthy procedures for petty cash in well-defined circumstances.

### Measurement of domestic government arrears
- Definition and timing:
  - An amount in arrears: amount owed but not paid by the government; key question is from what date the government owes the money.
  - Government debt becomes legally binding once goods or services ordered have been delivered (liquidation phase).
  - Placing an order alone does not constitute a legally binding debt or an arrear.
- Types of arrears:
  - administrative or technical arrears: liquidation occurred but order to pay has not been given by the credit manager to the public accountant.
  - real arrears: accountant unable to execute an order to pay owing to lack of cash.
- Caveats:
  - Even when cash is available, normal spending procedures require time; not everything due but not paid is automatically classified as an arrear.
- Specific rules:
  - In France, any claim on government unpaid within four years becomes void unless the creditor launches a lawsuit before that period ends.
  - WAEMU stipulation: current arrears are orders to pay not honored within 90 days; during those 90 days expenditures are considered a “float.”

### Control of budget execution
- Three types of budget control:
  - Administrative control:
    - Examples: controls by the financial controller at engagement phase and by the accountant at payment phase; spending ministries’ internal control bodies.
    - Objective: check compliance with laws and regulations governing public money use.
    - The Inspection Générale des Finances (IGF): control arm of the finance ministry covering the entire public sector (including central bank and social security), with practical focus on deconcentrated government units and entities receiving public funding.
  - Parliamentary control: exercised by Parliament (first and last word on budget laws).
  - Jurisdictional control: carried out by the Public Audit Office (Cour des Comptes).

### Parliamentary control and jurisdictional control (detailed)
- Parliamentary authorization and budget laws:
  - Parliament authorizes use of public money by the executive through the vote of the initial budget law (loi de finances initiale).
  - Only another law, namely a supplementary budget law (loi de finances rectificative), can modify the initial authorization.
  - A budget review law (loi de règlement) certifies that the budget has been executed in conformity with prior legislative authorizations.
  - Parliament can set ad hoc committees to investigate misuse of public money.
- Public Audit Office (Cour des Comptes):
  - Independent jurisdiction; attributes defined by the Constitution.
  - Scope: financial audits, performance audits (economy, effectiveness, efficiency), audits of agencies benefiting from government funding.
  - Historical note: Established by the Law of September 16, 1807.
  - The Public Audit Office has no control over credit managers and judges the accounts, not the accountants.
- Observations on control roles and timing:
  - A priori control by the financial controller at origination stage is essential because liquidation makes commitments legally binding.
  - Accountants’ control provides an additional safeguard; accountants incur unlimited personal liability in case of error or misdeed; ordonnateurs do not carry such liability.
  - The accountant’s second review is beneficial where the number of origination acts overwhelms a single financial controller.
- Ambiguities in the financial controller function:
  - Financial controllers belong to the Budget Directorate, are posted in spending ministries, monitor observance of spending procedures, do not judge opportunité of spending, report to the finance minister, act as interlocutors of the Public Audit Office and Parliament, and also act as advisers to host ministers—creating functional ambiguity.
- Ex ante versus ex post control:
  - Strong a priori controls at origination and payment phases are key features of French PEM integrity.
  - Parliamentary control of executed budget is largely symbolic:
    - ACCT checks consistency between individual accountants’ accounts and consolidated government accounts (General Declaration of Conformity).
    - Public Audit Office reconciles administrative accounts held by credit managers and accounts held by accountants.
    - Thorough audit of consolidated government accounts by the Public Audit Office occurs with a three-to-five-year lag.
    - For efficiency, the Public Audit Office audits only selected agencies every year.
- Accountability asymmetry:
  - Public accountants are personally and financially responsible for irregularities.
  - Ordonnateurs’ responsibility is not well defined; ministers are not subject to the Budgetary and Financial Discipline Court.
  - Sanctions by the court are primarily moral and reputational; an adverse judgment can reach at most two months of the wrongdoer’s salary as a civil servant.
  - The court was established in 1948 and comprises magistrates of the Public Audit Office and members of the State Council appointed by the executive for a five-year term.

### Box 4 — Testing Reliability of Budget: empirical findings and thresholds
- Testing criteria for reliability (institutional, practice/record, transparency/public scrutiny):
  - Is parliament actively and critically involved in initial, supplementary, and review budget laws?
  - Is the public audit office independent and are government accounts verified regularly?
  - Are budget calendar and revenue/expenditure projection methodologies observed and credible?
  - Are budget data published and accessible to the public?
- Empirical observations on francophone African countries:
  - The vast majority of African countries fail some or all of the above tests.
  - Institutions often exist on paper but work very poorly in practice.
  - Specific shortcomings:
    - Parliamentary budgetary role remains very weak.
    - Public audit offices are understaffed and lack material means; rarely independent from the executive.
    - Technical skills limited, particularly in forecasting.
    - Computerization of government financial operations is at an early stage.
    - Absence of regular budget review laws reduces feedback on implementation.
    - Revenue forecasts often described as “voluntarist”.
- Divergences versus the French reference (selected findings):
  - In all surveyed African countries except Madagascar, the finance ministry has the monopoly in giving the order to pay (via the ordonnateur principal unique); in France line ministries give the order to pay.
  - Only in Côte d’Ivoire does budget consolidation incorporate autonomous government establishments as in France; elsewhere the budget principally refers to the central government budget.
  - A treasury single account does not exist in any of the surveyed African countries.
  - No African country produces a fiscal summary on a weekly basis.
  - Lag in production of the consolidated treasury balance is at least one month in African countries, while in the French model it is a matter of days.
  - The budget is constructed semi-manually in all the African countries, while it is fully computerized in France.
  - Among African countries, only Senegal has a full-fledged public audit office (cour des comptes); Senegal’s Public Audit Office displays some degree of independence, but depends on the sensitivity of investigations.
  - Where an audit body exists, recommendations are rarely or never implemented; audited activities limited to financial audit, not performance audit.
  - African countries verify their accounts in detail four to five years after their closing, at the earliest.
  - Budget outturns are published seven to 12 months after the fiscal year in the best cases; in many cases they are never published.
- Quantitative measures and results:
  - Data recoded into dummies against the French reference; objects measured on 46 variables.
  - Pearson correlation coefficients used to measure similarity between pairs of countries using France as yardstick.
  - Twelve specific PEM questions identified as most divergent.
  - Verification of accounts: “four to five years” after closing (earliest).
  - Publication of budget outturns: “seven to 12 months” after fiscal year in best cases.
  - Correlation cut-off: Assuming r = 0.6 is a cut-off point, the correlation among African countries is generally significant (r > 0.6).
  - Pairwise findings: Benin and Mali; Burkina Faso and Cameroon show r>0.9 in compliance with France on each single question.
  - Dispersion across PEM subcategories:
    - Audit and external control: highest dispersion coefficient = 0.76.
    - Existence of fiscal rules: second most important subcategory of dispersion.
    - Expenditure process and internal control: smallest dispersion coefficient = 0.07.
  - Cash plan practice: Except for Madagascar, all countries have a monthly cash plan updated on a monthly basis.
- Policy implications and TA recommendations:
  - Main lessons:
    - Francophone African countries borrowed the French system without matching capacities.
    - Normative similarities contrast with striking differences in measurable practice.
    - Ministry of finance monopoly on payment orders and weaker budget consolidation are distinctive African features.
  - TA priority areas:
    - Strengthen accounting and reporting, and auditing and external control—areas with largest divergence.
    - Computerization of government financial management as prerequisite.
    - Generalize monthly fiscal tables (TOFEs) and consolidated treasury balances with short lags between closing and publication.
    - Reinforce external control via more critical parliamentary involvement and creation of independent, competent audit offices.
    - TA role: train parliament members in financial matters; help design terms of reference for a public audit office.
  - TA delivery focus and sequencing:
    - TA should generally have a national focus.
    - Consolidate progress in Benin, Mali, Côte d’Ivoire, Burkina Faso, and Niger; increase TA efforts in Republic of Congo, Togo, Guinea, and Chad.
    - Prioritize robustness in practice over sophistication in design.
    - Establish a good line-item budget before adopting program budgeting or decentralizing PEM responsibilities.
    - Ensure central government functioning and managerial capacities at lower layers before decentralizing.
- Broader constraints to reform:
  - Lack of institutional continuity and fragile institutional memory.
  - Lack of public scrutiny: delays in voting budget review laws; weak parliamentary oversight; absence of external audit.
  - “Privatization” of public finance: budget choices reflecting ruling class preferences.
  - Lack of political commitment and ownership: reforms driven by donor conditionality rather than national necessity; sabotage by reform promoters.
- Overarching conclusion:
  - Budgeting and PEM weaknesses in Africa reflect broader problems of an ill-functioning state; solutions often extend beyond public finance and point to the need for government building or reform.

### Questionnaire structure (select items and indicators)
- The questionnaire records whether references are made to government role, parliament role, and control institutions.
- Select questions and response choices (examples preserved verbatim):
  - Q8. Is there a Budget Review Law? "1. Yes" / "2. No"
  - Q9. On budget matters, how does the parliament control the government (one choice only): "1. By voting the only initial finance law" / "2. By voting the only budget review law" / "3. By voting finance both the initial and the review budget laws"
  - Q12. Who can decide for the amendment (amount, appropriation...) of the budgetary authorization voted by the parliament? "1. Parliament only." / "2. Ministry of Finance (MoF)." / "3. Parliament and MoF." / "4. Spending ministries" / "5. Other (indicate)"
  - Q13. Who is, according to the texts, the person who issues payment orders in the central government? "1. The Ministry of Finance (or delegation)" / "2. All ministries managing credits (or delegation)_" / "3. The President of the Republic (or delegation)" / "4. Others (indicate)."
  - Q22. Does the expenditure circuit follow the cycle of Engagement/Liquidation/Ordonnancement/Paiement? "1. Yes" / "2. No"
  - Q27. Are the functions of the person who issues payment orders (Ordonnateur) and the one who pays (Comptable) incompatible? "1. Yes" / "2. No"
  - Q36. What is the prevailing accounting system? "1. Single entry." / "2. Double entry."
  - Q37. How are budget transactions accounted for? "1. Cash accounting only." / "2. Accrual." / "3. Mix of cash accounting and accrual accounting."
  - Q40. What is the frequency of the production of the treasury’s consolidated balance? "1. Daily" / "2. Weekly" / "3. Monthly" / "4. Annually"
  - Q41. Lapse of time between Treasury’s balances publication and their period of reference. "1. 10–15 days" / "2. Between 15 or 30 days" / "3. Between 30 to 60 days" / "4. Beyond 60 days"
  - Q42. Budget is constructed "1. Manually" / "2. Semi-annually" / "3. Entirely computerized"
  - Q54. On average, when are the state’s accounts verified in detail? "1. One to three years after the closing date." / "2. Four to five years after the closing date." / "3. More than five years after the closing date."
  - Q55. On average, when are budget outturns published? "1. In less than 3 months after the closing of the fiscal year." / "2. Between 3 or six months after the closing of the fiscal year." / "3. Between 7 or 12 months after the closing of the fiscal year." / "4. More than twelve months after the closing of the fiscal year."
- List of abbreviations included:
  - ACCT, BWI, ELOP, FAD, IGF, IMF, PEM, PRSP, TA, TOFE, TSA, WAEMU

*Source: _wp0442 - References..............................................................................................................*

### References..............................................................................................................

### _wp0442 - References..............................................................................................................

### Introduction and scope
- Study objective: cross-country comparison of francophone African public expenditure management (PEM) systems to analyze similarities with and divergences from the French PEM system and among francophone African countries themselves.
- Questionnaire design:
  - Total items: 55 items.
  - Specific PEM questions: 49 specific questions.
  - General information questions: six questions.
  - PEM subcategory composition:
    - legal and institutional environment: 10 questions.
    - fiscal rules: 5 questions.
    - expenditure process and internal control: 14 questions.
    - accounting and reporting systems: 7 questions.
    - cash plan: 2 questions.
    - audit and external control: 11 questions.
- Data and coverage:
  - Responses collected from senior officials at the end of 2001.
  - Sample of 12 African countries: Benin, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Chad, the Republic of Congo, Côte d’Ivoire, Guinea, Madagascar, Mali, Niger, Senegal, and Togo.
  - Questionnaires sent to ministries of finance and IMF resident fiscal advisors where applicable; responses reviewed by IMF experts at headquarters.
- Purpose limits:
  - The paper does not provide a performance rating or define performance benchmarks; it compares PEM systems, highlights similarities/differences, and draws lessons for technical assistance (TA) implementation.

### Key public expenditure management features of the French reference model
- Legal framework:
  - Core texts shaping budgeting until 2001: the 1959 Ordinance (Organic Budget Law) and the Decree of 1962 on Public Accounting.
  - Three types of budget laws passed by Parliament:
    1. initial budget law (includes all annual government revenues and expenditures);
    2. supplementary budget law (modifies the initial budget during execution);
    3. budget review law (reconciles executed budget with the initial budget after fiscal year closing).
  - Parliamentary role: Parliament has the first (voting on the initial budget law) and last word (voting on the review law) over public money.
- Appropriation types:
  - (1) Capped appropriations (crédits limitatifs): spending commitments and orders to pay are capped by the budget law (general rule).
  - (2) Provisional appropriations (crédits provisionnels): tentative amounts; government can supplement from other sources (e.g., charges communes, general fund accounts, decrets d’avance, supplementary credit); typical use: natural disasters.
  - (3) Estimated appropriations (crédits évaluatifs): tentative estimates that can be increased; typical examples: debt repayments and litigation costs.
- Budgeting principles:
  - Four key principles: unity, annuality, universality, and specialty.
  - Unity: budget contains all government revenues and expenditures in a single document (general budget, ancillary budgets, and Treasury special accounts together constitute the budget law).
  - Annuality: budget approved and executed on an annual basis.
  - Universality: all revenues and expenditures incorporated; no earmarking; prevents netting.
  - Specialty: Parliament authorizes specified categories of credits (by ministry), allowing ministries to apportion credits within sub-administrations.
- Institutional roles:
  - Executive (minister of finance under the prime minister) prepares draft budget after consultations with spending ministries.
  - Executive executes the budget; spending process phases: engagement, liquidation, ordonnancement, paiement.
  - Ex post control by Parliament and the Public Audit Office (Cour des Comptes).

### Budget calendar, treasury cycle, and complementary period
- Fiscal year: January 1 to December 31.
- Deadlines and timing rules:
  - For spending requiring an order to pay (e.g., salaries and capital spending): origination act (engagement) can take place between January 1 and December 31.
  - For current expenditures other than salaries: deadline is November 30 (postponed to December 31 in emergencies).
  - December 31 is last day for giving the order to pay; actual payment should take place before January 15 of the next year.
  - Adjustment operations deadlines:
    - principal accountants: until January 15.
    - accountants designated by the finance ministry: until February 12.
    - Agent Comptable Central du Trésor (ACCT): until February 23.
  - For spending not requiring an order to pay: spending is accounted for during the year of actual payment.
- Complementary period:
  - Definition: the short period (officially 30 to 60 days, depending on countries) that stretches beyond fiscal year n, but whose transactions are linked to fiscal year n.
  - Two types:
    - administrative complementary period: regularizes residual payment orders pending at fiscal year end.
    - accounting complementary period: allows proper itemization of spending.
  - Risks: a long complementary period may indicate lax budget spending procedures (unobserved closing dates, fluctuating budget calendar).
  - Reporting issue: fiscal reporting may follow a legal approach (link transactions to budget year) or a cash approach (report in year of cash flow); overstretched transaction dates complicate linking to original fiscal year.
  - Country practices:
    - France: complementary period has been shortened over time and is now limited to one month.
    - WAEMU guidance: complementary period should be limited to two months (transactions pertaining to fiscal year n but occurring by end-February (n+1) should be linked to fiscal year n).

### Treasury Single Account (TSA) and cash management
- TSA principle: government (via the Treasury) concentrates its cash resources in one account, usually held in the central bank.
- Institutional arrangements:
  - 1959 Ordinance stipulates local governments and public agencies (Treasury correspondents) deposit all funds at the Treasury, creating a pooled cash resource.
  - Unity of cash desk (unicité de caisse): concept that a public accountant acts as one cashier serving many public entities.
  - "Treasury circuit": financial links between the Treasury and correspondents to show consolidated government cash status and allow transfers between entities with cash excesses and shortages.

### Expenditure process and segregation of duties (ELOP)
- Four phases of spending process summarized as Engagement/Liquidation/Ordonnancement/Paiement (ELOP):
  - engagement: origination of spending.
  - liquidation: validation — goods or services delivered and amount of government debt calculated.
  - ordonnancement: order to pay issued by a credit manager (ordonnateur) to a public accountant.
  - paiement: public accountant disburses money.
- Segregation of duties:
  - Ordonnateurs perform the first three functions (origination, validation, order to pay).
  - Comptable/public accountant performs the payment phase.
  - Advantage: mutual control between those who commit the government and those who make payments; accountants under the finance ministry enhance monitoring through payment-phase controls.
- Exceptions to segregation rule:
  - government secret funds (fonds spéciaux): do not have to be justified (national security matters).
  - cash advance funds (régies d’avances): designed to remedy lengthy procedures for petty cash in well-defined circumstances.

### Measurement of domestic government arrears
- Definition and timing:
  - An amount in arrears: amount owed but not paid by the government; key question is from what date the government owes the money.
  - Government debt becomes legally binding once goods or services ordered have been delivered (liquidation phase).
  - Placing an order alone does not constitute a legally binding debt or an arrear.
- Types of arrears:
  - administrative or technical arrears: liquidation occurred but order to pay has not been given by the credit manager to the public accountant.
  - real arrears: accountant unable to execute an order to pay owing to lack of cash.
- Important caveats:
  - Even when cash is available, normal spending procedures require time; not everything due but not paid is automatically classified as an arrear.
- Specific rules cited:
  - In France, any claim on government unpaid within four years becomes void unless the creditor launches a lawsuit before that period ends.
  - WAEMU stipulation: current arrears are orders to pay not honored within 90 days; during those 90 days expenditures are considered a “float.”

### Control of budget execution
- Three types of budget control:
  - Administrative control:
    - Examples: controls by the financial controller at engagement phase and by the accountant at payment phase; spending ministries’ internal control bodies.
    - Objective: check compliance with laws and regulations governing public money use.
    - The Inspection Générale des Finances (IGF): control arm of the finance ministry covering the entire public sector (including central bank and social security), with practical focus on deconcentrated government units and entities receiving public funding.
  - Parliamentary control: exercised by Parliament (first and last word on budget laws).
  - Jurisdictional control: carried out by the Public Audit Office (Cour des Comptes).

*Source: _wp0442 - References..............................................................................................................*

### 2.  Parliamentary control

### 2. Parliamentary control

### Parliamentary authorization and budget laws
- Parliament authorizes use of public money by the executive through the vote of the initial budget law (loi de finances initiale).
- Only another law, namely a supplementary budget law (loi de finances rectificative), can modify the initial authorization.
- A budget review law (loi de règlement) certifies that the budget has been executed in conformity with prior legislative authorizations.
- Besides formal votes, Parliament can set ad hoc committees to investigate any misuse of public money by the executive branch.
- Parliamentary control is characterized as an external control.

### Jurisdictional control: Public Audit Office (Cour des Comptes)
- The Public Audit Office is an independent jurisdiction from both the executive and legislative branches; its attributes are defined by the Constitution.
- Scope of investigations:
  - Financial audits (accounts held by the public accountants).
  - Performance audits (observance of the principles of economy, effectiveness, and efficiency in the use of public money).
  - Audits of agencies benefiting from government funding, in addition to government accounts.
- Historical and functional notes:
  - Established by the Law of September 16, 1807.
  - The Public Audit Office has no control over credit managers.
  - The office judges the accounts, not the accountants.
- The control exercised by the Public Audit Office is also an external control.

### Observations on control roles and timing
- The a priori control exercised by the financial controller at the origination stage is essential: once goods or services are delivered (liquidation or validation phase), the government becomes legally liable and it is then too late to repudiate the commitment.
- The accountant’s control, though apparently redundant, provides a further safeguard: accountants check before disbursing and incur unlimited personal liability in case of error or misdeed; ordonnateurs do not carry such liability.
- The number of origination acts can overwhelm a single financial controller; hence the accountant’s second review is beneficial.

### Ambiguities in the financial controller function
- Financial controllers:
  - Belong to the Budget Directorate (within the finance ministry).
  - Are posted in different spending ministries and government agencies.
  - Monitor observance of spending procedures, intervening at origination and payment-order levels.
  - Do not judge the relevance (opportunité) of spending, only compliance with rules and regulations.
  - Act as finance ministry correspondents in spending agencies and report to the finance minister.
  - Serve as prime interlocutors of the Public Audit Office and Parliament in investigations.
  - Also act as advisers to host ministers and can influence important financial decisions and make proposals in annual reports.
- Result: financial controller both controls and advises the host minister, creating a functional ambiguity.

### Ex ante versus ex post control
- Strong a priori controls at origination and payment phases are key features of French PEM integrity.
- Control of the executed budget by Parliament remains largely symbolic:
  - Parliament validates reconciliation already carried out:
    - ACCT (account-centralizing body within the finance ministry) checks consistency between individual accountants’ accounts and consolidated government accounts (General Declaration of Conformity).
    - The Public Audit Office reconciles administrative accounts held by credit managers (not involving cash manipulation) and accounts held by accountants who pay on government behalf.
  - A thorough audit of consolidated government accounts by the Public Audit Office, in the form of a detailed verification of accounts, occurs with a three-to-five-year lag.
  - For efficiency, the Public Audit Office audits only selected agencies every year.

### Accountability asymmetry: unlimited accountant responsibility vs ordonnateur quasi-immunity
- Public accountants are personally and financially responsible for irregularities in fund management.
- Ordonnateurs’ responsibility is not well defined; ministers and elected local officials are not subject to the Budgetary and Financial Discipline Court.
  - Ministers cannot be tried by the court; members of their cabinets and other civil servants can be prosecuted.
  - Interpretation issues arise when a civil servant acts on behalf of a minister.
- Sanctions by the court are primarily moral and reputational:
  - An adverse judgment can reach at most two months of the wrongdoer’s salary as a civil servant.
  - In reality, the court is largely dormant.
- Footnote context:
  - The court was established in 1948.
  - The court comprises magistrates of the Public Audit Office and members of the State Council (Conseil d’Etat), appointed by the executive branch for a five-year term.

*Source: _wp0442 - 2.  Parliamentary control (PDF chapter)*

### Box 4. Testing Reliability of Budget

### _wp0442 - Box 4. Testing Reliability of Budget

### Testing criteria for reliability of revenue and expenditure projections
- Presumption: institutional arrangements permitting good budget preparation, execution, and control.
  - Key questions: Is parliament actively and critically involved in the vote of the initial, supplementary, and review budget laws, or is the vote a pure formality? Is the public audit office independent and are government accounts verified on a regular basis? Does the country have human, administrative, and technical capacity to properly prepare and implement budgets?
  - If answers are positive, chances are high that the budget has meaning and relevance.
- Practice and record: historical performance of budget processes.
  - Key questions: Is the budget calendar observed? How are revenue projections made (e.g., macro assumptions)? What is the methodology for expenditure costing (e.g., the utilities bill)? Are budget review laws voted on a regular basis? With hindsight, have the projections been close to outturns?
- Transparency and public scrutiny:
  - Key questions: Are budget data published and accessible to the general public? Can and does the general public critically examine the budget?

### Empirical observations on francophone African countries (summary of Box)
- General diagnostic:
  - The vast majority of African countries fail some or all of the above tests.
  - Institutions often exist on paper but work very poorly in practice.
- Specific shortcomings:
  - Parliamentary budgetary role remains very weak.
  - Public audit offices are notoriously understaffed and lack adequate material means; they are rarely independent from the executive branch.
  - Technical skills are limited, particularly in forecasting (macro assumptions underlying budget figures).
  - Computerization of government financial operations is at an early stage in most countries.
  - In the absence of regular budget review laws shedding light on budget execution figures, little feedback is given on implementation of past budgets.
  - Revenue forecasts are often described as “voluntarist” (i.e., politically motivated).

### Divergences versus the French reference model (selected findings)
- Twelve specific PEM questions show striking differences between the French model and surveyed African countries.
  - In all surveyed African countries except Madagascar, the finance ministry has the monopoly in giving the order to pay (via the ordonnateur principal unique); in France line ministries give the order to pay.
  - Only in Côte d’Ivoire does budget consolidation incorporate autonomous government establishments as in France; elsewhere the budget principally refers to the central government budget.
  - A treasury single account does not exist in any of the surveyed African countries.
  - No African country produces a fiscal summary on a weekly basis.
  - Lag in production of the consolidated treasury balance is at least one month in African countries, while in the French model it is a matter of days.
  - The budget is constructed semi-manually in all the African countries, while it is fully computerized in France.
  - Among African countries, only Senegal has a full-fledged public audit office (cour des comptes); Senegal’s Public Audit Office displays some degree of independence, but depends on the sensitivity of investigations.
  - Where an audit body exists, recommendations are rarely or never implemented; audit bodies in surveyed African countries perform only financial audit, not performance audit.
  - African countries verify their accounts in detail four to five years after their closing, at the earliest.
  - Budget outturns are published seven to 12 months after the fiscal year in the best cases; in many cases they are never published.

### Quantitative measures and empirical results (method and key numeric thresholds)
- Methodology:
  - Data on countries were recoded so that each answer was transformed into a score against the French reference (dummies 1 and 0).
  - Objects (countries) were measured on 46 variables (questions).
  - Pearson correlation coefficients were used to measure similarity between pairs of countries, using the French system as yardstick.
- Key numeric thresholds and results:
  - Twelve specific PEM questions identified as most divergent.
  - Verification of accounts: “four to five years” after closing (earliest).
  - Publication of budget outturns: “seven to 12 months” after fiscal year in best cases.
  - Correlation cut-off: Assuming r = 0.6 is a cut-off point, the correlation among African countries is generally significant (r > 0.6).
  - Findings from pairwise correlations:
    - Benin and Mali; Burkina Faso and Cameroon look very much alike (r>0.9) in compliance with France on each single question.
    - Marked opposites include Madagascar/Guinea, Senegal/Guinea, Togo/Guinea, Togo/the Congo, and Togo/Senegal (smaller r in those cases).
  - Dispersion across PEM subcategories (Table 2 summary):
    - African countries are particularly dispersed on audit and external control questions, which have the highest dispersion coefficient (0.76).
    - The existence of fiscal rules is the second most important subcategory of dispersion.
    - Description of expenditure process and internal control shows the smallest dispersion (coefficient = 0.07), indicating minimal differences among countries in that area.
    - Except for Madagascar, all countries have a monthly cash plan updated on a monthly basis.
  - Sample and scope:
    - The countries include Benin, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Chad, Republic of Congo, Côte d’Ivoire, Guinea, Madagascar, Mali, Niger, Senegal, and Togo.
    - The country objects were measured on 46 PEM questions (variables).

### Policy implications and recommendations (TA and national priorities)
- Main lessons:
  - Francophone African countries borrowed the French budgeting system without matching institutional, human, and technical capacities.
  - Normative similarities (legal and institutional framework, raw description of expenditure process) contrast with striking differences in measurable practice (positive side).
  - The ministry of finance monopoly on payment orders and weaker budget consolidation are distinctive African features; accounting and reporting systems and audit and external control differ widely from the French model.
- TA priority areas:
  - Strengthen accounting and reporting, and auditing and external control—areas with largest divergence from the reference model.
  - Computerization of government financial management is a prerequisite for improved accounting and reporting.
  - Generalize monthly fiscal tables (TOFEs) and consolidated treasury balances with short lags between closing and publication.
  - Reinforce external control via more critical parliamentary involvement in budget votes and creation of truly independent and competent audit offices.
  - TA role in external control: training parliament members in financial and control matters; help design terms of reference for a public audit office.
- TA delivery focus:
  - Given convergence and divergence among countries, TA should generally have a national focus.
  - Consolidate progress in countries such as Benin, Mali, Côte d’Ivoire, Burkina Faso, and Niger; increase TA efforts in Republic of Congo, Togo, Guinea, and Chad, where PEM weaknesses are more pronounced.
- Sequencing and practical advice:
  - Prioritize robustness in practice over sophistication in design.
  - Put first things first: establish a good and solid line-item budget before adopting budgeting fads (e.g., program budgeting) or decentralizing PEM responsibilities.
  - Ensure central government functioning and managerial capacities at lower layers before decentralizing responsibilities.

### Broader conclusions on constraints and reform prospects
- Identified non-technical constraints to improved budgeting and PEM:
  - Lack of institutional continuity and fragile institutional memory; reforms can die out when key individuals leave or after violent political change.
  - Lack of public scrutiny: information not made fully available to the public; delays in voting budget review laws; weak parliamentary oversight; absence of external audit.
  - “Privatization” of public finance: budget choices reflecting personal preferences of ruling class rather than national priorities.
  - Lack of political commitment and ownership: reforms driven by donor conditionality rather than national necessity; sabotage by those supposed to promote change.
- Overarching conclusion:
  - Budgeting and PEM weaknesses in Africa reflect broader problems of an ill-functioning state; solutions often extend beyond public finance and point to the need for government building or reform as a prerequisite for sound budgeting and PEM systems.

*Source: _wp0442 - Box 4. Testing Reliability of Budget*

### 1. Reference to the government role only.

### _wp0442 - 1. Reference to the government role only.

### Questionnaire structure and scope
- The instrument records whether references are made to:
  - "1. Reference to the government role only."
  - "2. Reference to the government and the parliament roles only."
  - "3. Reference to the government, the parliament and control institutions role."
  - "4. No reference to public finance."

### Budget legislation and parliamentary control
- Q8. Is there a Budget Review Law?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q9. On budget matters, how does the parliament control the government (one choice only):
  - "1. By voting the only initial finance law"
  - "2. By voting the only budget review law"
  - "3. By voting finance both the initial and the review budget laws"
- Q10. Is there any deadline date for the elaboration and execution of the budget?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q11. Is there any supplementary budget law to modify the initial finance law in progress?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q12. Who can decide for the amendment (amount, appropriation...) of the budgetary authorization voted by the parliament?
  - "1. Parliament only."
  - "2. Ministry of Finance (MoF)."
  - "3. Parliament and MoF."
  - "4. Spending ministries"
  - "5. Other (indicate)"
- Q13. Who is, according to the texts, the person who issues payment orders in the central government?
  - "1. The Ministry of Finance (or delegation)"
  - "2. All ministries managing credits (or delegation)_"
  - "3. The President of the Republic (or delegation)"
  - "4. Others (indicate)."

### Budget presentation and consolidation
- Q14. Budget presentation
  - "1. The budget is a unified document (current and capital budget unified)."
  - "2. There are separate current and capital budgets"
- Q15. Degree of consolidation
  - "1. State budget only."
  - "2. State budget and annex budgets."
  - "3. State budget, annex budget, and the Treasury’s special accounts."
  - "4. State budget, annex budget, Treasury’s special accounts and accounts for administrative public agencies (EPA)."
  - "5. State budget, annex budgets, Treasury’s special accounts, EPAs and local governments"

### Government accounts and Treasury arrangements
- Q16. Government accounts in the banks (one choice only)
  - "1. There is only one Treasury account and it is with the central bank"
  - "2. The Treasury has several accounts and sub-accounts in the central bank"
  - "3. The Treasury has accounts in the central bank and the commercial banks?"
  - "4. Other (indicate)."

### Existence of fiscal rules
- Q17. Is there any budget deficit target (in % GDP)?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q18. Is there a limit for the debt ratio (in % of GDP)?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q19. Is government borrowing from the central bank governed by a law?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q20. Is government borrowing from commercial banks governed by a law?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q21. Is there any legal obligation governing the use of government borrowing?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"

### Expenditure process and internal control
- Q22. Does the expenditure circuit follow the cycle of Engagement/Liquidation/Ordonnancement/Paiement?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q23. Who has the right to place orders?
  - "1. The Ordonnateur"
  - "2. All credit managers"
  - "3. Other (indicate)."
- Q24. Who controls the origination acts (Engagements)?
  - "1. The financial controller."
  - "2. Other (indicate)"
- Q25. Who gives the order to pay?
  - "1. The Ordonnateur"
  - "2. Other (indicate)."
- Q26. What control procedures do the public accountants perform before paying?
  - "1. Regularity of the expenditures only."
  - "2. Regularity of payment only."
  - "3. Control on the regularity of both the expenditure and the payment"
- Q27. Are the functions of the person who issues payment orders (Ordonnateur) and the one who pays (Comptable) incompatible?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q28. At which stage of the expenditure process does the control intervene?
  - "1. At the origination stage only (Engagement)."
  - "2. At payment orders stage only (Ordonnancement)."
  - "3. At the payment stage only."
  - "4. At all stages (origination, payment order and payment)."
- Q29. Is there any due date to close origination acts (Engagements) during the fiscal year?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q30. Is there any due date to close the payment orders during the fiscal year?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q31. At which stage of the expenditure cycle does the government debt incur?
  - "1. Origination (Engagement)"
  - "2. Validation (Liquidation)"
  - "3. Payment orders (Ordonnancement)"
- Q32. Does the country have Regies d’avance (cash advance system)?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q33. Which authority decides for the creation of the Regies d’avance?
  - "1. Ministry of Finance (MOF)"
  - "2. MOF and spending ministries"
  - "3. Other"
- Q34. Are the expenditures under the Regies d’avance well-specified?
  - "1. Ministry of Finance."
  - "2. Other."
- Q35. Is there an expenditure ceiling, under the system of Regies d’avance?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"

### Accounting and reporting system
- Q36. What is the prevailing accounting system?
  - "1. Single entry."
  - "2. Double entry."
- Q37. How are budget transactions accounted for?
  - "1. Cash accounting only."
  - "2. Accrual."
  - "3. Mix of cash accounting and accrual accounting."
- Q38. What type of budgetary classification prevails?
  - "1. Administrative only."
  - "2. Economic and Economic only."
  - "3. Administrative, economic and functional classification."
  - "4. Other (indicate)."
- Q39. What is the frequency of the publication of the fiscal table (TOFE)?
  - "1. Monthly"
  - "2. Other (indicate)"
- Q40. What is the frequency of the production of the treasury’s consolidated balance?
  - "1. Daily"
  - "2. Weekly"
  - "3. Monthly"
  - "4. Annually"
- Q41. Lapse of time between Treasury’s balances publication and their period of reference.
  - "1. 10–15 days"
  - "2. Between 15 or 30 days"
  - "3. Between 30 to 60 days"
  - "4. Beyond 60 days"
- Q42. Budget is constructed
  - "1. Manually"
  - "2. Semi-annually"
  - "3. Entirely computerized"

### Cash plan
- Q43. Does the government have a cash plan?
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No"
- Q44. What is the time period for updating government cash plan?
  - "1. Monthly"
  - "2. Quarterly"
  - "3. Other (indicate)"

### Audit and external control
- Q45. Who verifies the account?
  - "1. The Public Audit Office."
  - "2. A specialized unit of the Supreme Court."
  - "3. The General Inspection."
  - "4. Other (indicate)."
- Q46. The supreme audit institution or the external control is independent.
  - "1. Yes"
  - "2. No."
- Q47. Who is legally assigned to launch an audit of a public entity?
  - "1. The ministry of finance only."
  - "2. The parliament only."
  - "3. The institution of the supreme audit itself (self-seized)"
  - "4. Various institutions previously cited in 1-2-3."
  - "5. Other (indicate)"
- Q48. External auditors’ recommendations are:
  - "1. Systematically implemented."
  - "2. Often implemented."
  - "3. Rarely implemented."
- Q49. The year of the creation of the supreme audit institution or external control.
- Q50. Number of total employees of the supreme audit institution or the external control at the end of 2001.
- Q51. How many reports did the supreme audit institution or external control publish in 2002?
- Q52. Who is responsible before the supreme audit institution?
  - "1. Public accountants only."
  - "2. Ordonnateurs only."
  - "3. Both public accountants and ordonnateurs"
- Q53. What types of audits does the external auditor perform?
  - "1. Accounting and financial audit only."
  - "2. Accounting and financial audit, as well as management audit."
- Q54. On average, when are the state’s accounts verified in detail?
  - "1. One to three years after the closing date."
  - "2. Four to five years after the closing date."
  - "3. More than five years after the closing date."
- Q55. On average, when are budget outturns published?
  - "1. In less than 3 months after the closing of the fiscal year."
  - "2. Between 3 or six months after the closing of the fiscal year."
  - "3. Between 7 or 12 months after the closing of the fiscal year."
  - "4. More than twelve months after the closing of the fiscal year."

### List of abbreviations (as provided)
- ACCT   Agent Comptable Central du Trésor
- BWI    Bretton Woods Institution
- ELOP   Engagement / liquidation / ordonnancement / paiement
- FAD    Fiscal Affairs Department, International Monetary Fund
- IGF    Inspection Générale des Finances
- IMF    International Monetary Fund
- PEM    Public Expenditure Management
- PRSP   Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper
- TA     Technical Assistance
- TOFE   Tableau des Opérations Financières de l’Etat
- TSA    Treasury Single Account
- WAEMU  West African Economic and Monetary Union

*Source: _wp0442 - 1. Reference to the government role only.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2004/_wp0442.pdf_
