## _wp05143 - conclusions on the potential welfare impact of the customs union. Finally, factors other than

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp05143 - conclusions on the potential welfare impact of the customs union. Finally, factors other than](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2005/_wp05143.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2005/_wp05143.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2005/_wp05143.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction: objectives and context
- Paper objective: gauge effects of the EAC customs union on trade flows and trade regimes of EAC member states and analyze whether introduction of the EAC common external tariff (CET) lowering tariffs in Kenya has a positive impact on trade.
- EAC members discussed: Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda.
- Stated integration path of the “new” EAC: customs union → common market → monetary union → political federation.

### Key economy and development statistics (EAC, 2003; 1990-2001)
- Combined GDP of the three EAC member states: $31.4 billion in 2003.
- Kenya:
  - GDP: $14.1 billion in 2003
  - Population: 31.9 million
  - Per capita GDP: $445
  - Real GDP growth, 1990-2001: 2.2 percent (annual average)
- Tanzania:
  - GDP: $10.3 billion in 2003
  - Population: 35.9 million
  - Per capita GDP: $286.6
  - Real GDP growth, 1990-2001: 3.1 percent (annual average)
- Uganda:
  - GDP: $7.0 billion in 2003
  - Population: 25 million
  - Per capita GDP: $280.8
  - Real GDP growth, 1990-2001: 6.8 percent (annual average)
- Sub-Saharan Africa regional average growth, 1990-2001: 2.6 percent (annual average)

### Trade flows and commodity composition (2001)
- Export destination shares:
  - Tanzania exports to EU: 37.1 percent
  - Uganda exports to EU: 64.5 percent
  - Kenya exports: EU 31.9 percent; Other African countries 35.9 percent; EAC 22.6 percent
- Kenya import sources:
  - Africa and Middle East (mainly Egypt): 35.7 percent of Kenya’s total imports
  - EU imports: 27.3 percent
- Intraregional trade evolution, 1991 → 2001:
  - Share of intraregional exports: about 6 percent → 16 percent
  - Share of intraregional imports: 2.7 percent → 10.5 percent
- Asymmetries in intraregional flows:
  - Kenya receives only 1.4 percent of total imports from the subregion
  - Tanzania: sends 9.9 percent of total exports to subregion; receives 7.2 percent of total imports from subregion
  - Uganda: low exports to EAC but receives 48.8 percent of total imports from EAC (mainly from Kenya)
- Commodity composition of intraregional trade (manufactures important):
  - Kenya: 11.5 percent and 43.4 percent of its imports from Uganda and Tanzania, respectively, are manufactures
  - Uganda: 33.8 percent and 71.3 percent of its imports from Kenya and Tanzania, respectively, are manufactures
  - Tanzania: 56.8 percent and 16.6 percent of its imports from Kenya and Uganda, respectively, are manufactures
- Principal exported commodities to the EU:
  - Tanzania and Uganda: principally agricultural commodities and minerals
  - Kenya exports: coffee, tea, cut flowers, vegetables
  - Tanzania exports: gold, fish fillets, nuts (coconuts, brazil nuts and cashews), coffee
  - Uganda exports: fish fillets, gold, tobacco, tea

### Trade regimes and tariff structures
- Characterization: “cascading tariff” structure — lowest rates on raw materials and capital goods, moderate on intermediate goods, highest on consumer goods.
- Tariff evolution, 1997 → 2002 (applied rates):
  - Kenya:
    - Tariff bands: 5.0, 5.0, 5.0
    - Maximum rate: 35.0 percent
    - Simple average: 18.4 percent (1997), 16.3 percent (1999), 16.6 percent (2002)
  - Tanzania (data for 2001 noted):
    - Tariff bands: 9.0 (1997), 5.0 (1999), 4.0 (2002)
    - Maximum rate: 50.0 percent (1997), 25.0 percent (1999), 25.0 percent (2002)
    - Simple average: 21.8 percent (1997), 16.1 percent (1999), 14.3 percent (2002)
  - Uganda:
    - Tariff bands: 4.0 (1997), 3.0 (1999), 3.0 (2002)
    - Maximum rate: 20.0 percent (1997), 15.0 percent (1999), 15.0 percent (2002)
    - Simple average: 13.2 percent (1997), 9.0 percent (1999), 9.0 percent (2002)
- Observed trends: all three countries progressively reduced tariffs since the mid-1990s; most significant reductions in Uganda and Tanzania; Kenya’s simple average marginally declined due to tariff classification modifications.

### The EAC customs union and the Common External Tariff (CET)
- Treaty timeline and commitments:
  - Treaty establishing the EAC signed in November 1999.
  - Treaty provides for establishment of a customs union by January 1, 2005.
  - CET agreement reached by presidents on June 23, 2003.
  - CET introduced on January 1, 2005 but not fully implemented due to additional time needed to finalize administrative arrangements.
- CET band structure agreed:
  - 0 percent for meritorious goods, raw materials, and capital goods
  - 10 percent for intermediate goods
  - 25 percent for consumer goods
- Implementation phases and asymmetry provisions:
  - Tanzania and Uganda will maintain internal tariffs on an agreed list of commodities—906 tariff lines for Tanzania and 426 for Uganda—for which tariffs will be reduced gradually to zero within a period of up to five years.
  - In Uganda, items on that list initially attract a 10 percent tariff that over five years will be reduced uniformly.
  - Tanzania: each product group has a different schedule; no tariff initially higher than 25 percent; reduction to zero within five years.
  - After five years all internal tariffs will be removed and Kenyan imports will enter Tanzania and Uganda free of tariffs.
- Sensitive items and protection:
  - About 20 percent of the tariff lines were classified as “sensitive items.”
  - Sensitive items equivalent to 361 tariff lines and estimated at about 20 percent of total imports.
  - Sensitive items included: cigarettes, dry cells, fabrics, garments, matches, milk, cement, packing materials of plastic, palm oil, sugar, tires, used clothes, vehicles (reconditioned cars), vehicle chassis, rice, wheat and wheat flour.
  - As of September 2004, agreement reached on classification and applicable rates of sensitive products with exceptions for jute bags, rice, and wheat.
  - Agreement that sensitive products could not be “protected” by the maximum rate and therefore required special policy measures.
  - EAC member states agreed sensitive items would attract rates of more than 25 percent and, in some instances, a mixture of specific duty and ad valorem rates.
- Administrative and legal requirements to form the customs union:
  - Remove all internal tariffs
  - Establish a CET
  - Introduce rules of origin
  - Harmonized customs administration, customs valuation system, customs procedures and documentation

### Membership overlaps and RTA issues
- Kenya and Uganda are members of COMESA.
- Tanzania is a member of SADC and withdrew from COMESA in 2000.
- Overlap creates potential conflicting commitments with the EAC customs union.

### Effects of the three-band CET on tariff lines and averages
- Effects on tariff lines likely to increase:
  - Uganda: 3,066 tariff lines are likely to increase.
  - Tanzania: 1,224 tariff lines are likely to increase.
  - Kenya: 1,144 tariff lines are likely to increase.
- EAC CET tariff reductions by country (number of tariff lines lowered):
  - Kenya: 3,216
  - Tanzania: 2,364
  - Uganda: 1,353
- Average tariff changes (simple averages) with full CET implementation (World Bank, 2003):
  - Three-country simple average tariff: 10.9 percent
  - Kenya: decline from 16.6 percent to 10.9 percent
  - Tanzania: decline from 14.3 percent to 10.9 percent
  - Uganda: the simple average tariff 10 will increase by about 20 percent

### Tariff reform, excises, and distributional effects
- Reported tariff incidence highlights: "25.9 percent for Uganda, and 30.0 percent for Tanzania."
- Excise and suspended duties:
  - "rates of 10 percent on 467 items increasing substantially to 75 percent for beverages and 130 percent for tobacco."
  - Kenya: "imposes excise taxes on 459 items in the top tariff bracket with peaks of 50 and 70 percent. Suspended duties are applied to sugar, maize flour, and milk in the top tariff bracket."
- Effect on effective protection:
  - With a maximum tariff rate of 25 percent and low (or zero) rates on inputs, "the distortions in the effective rate of protection can be large."
  - This feature "represents a major step backwards for Uganda."
  - Although "tariffs are currently lower in Tanzania and Uganda, the nominal rates of protection may not vary considerably among EAC members."

### Estimated tariff-line adjustments (HS six-digit basis)
- Bands changed to 0, 10, 25:
  - Number of tariffs lowered: Kenya 3,216; Tanzania 2,364; Uganda 1,353
  - Number of tariffs increased: Kenya 1,144; Tanzania 1,224; Uganda 3,066
  - Number unchanged: Kenya 753; Tanzania 1,525; Uganda 694
- Bands changed to 0, 10, 15:
  - Number of tariffs lowered: Kenya 3,944; Tanzania 3,928; Uganda 1,353
  - Number of tariffs increased: Kenya 636; Tanzania 952; Uganda 1,859
  - Number unchanged: Kenya 533; Tanzania 233; Uganda 1,901
- Note: "Estimated at six-digit level of HS-classification."

### Customs union implementation status and trade administration
- Adoption and preparatory steps:
  - "The WTO Customs Valuation Agreement has been adopted."
  - "The EAC Customs Management Bill is expected to be approved by the EAC Council."
  - "Preparations are ongoing to complete the customs regulations and forms."
  - "Rules of origin have been agreed that adopt the COMESA rules with some product-specific rules, mainly for garments."
- Outstanding item:
  - "The Customs Union Protocol is yet to be ratified by the member states."

### Trade impact assessment for Kenya — SMART/WITS simulation results
- Methodology:
  - Static partial equilibrium SMART model employed via WITS at HS six-digit level.
  - SMART assumes products imported from different regions are imperfect substitutes and export supplies are perfectly elastic.
- Aggregate simulation outcomes (move from current MFN to three-band EAC CET):
  - Total trade increase (All product lines): $193.5 million
  - Trade creation: $193.86 million
  - Trade diversion: -0.32 million (reported as -0.321)
- Breakdown by tariff band (Table 6 results):
  - Product lines at 0%: Trade 157.37; Trade Effect -0.12; Diversion -0.12; Creation 157.49
  - Product lines at 10%: Trade 45.28; Trade Effect -0.16; Diversion -0.16; Creation 45.44
  - Product lines at 25%: Trade -9.11; Trade Effect -0.04; Diversion -0.04; Creation -9.07
  - Note: "81.2 percent ($157.5 million) of trade-creating flows resulting from the move to the new EAC CET are accounted for by products that attract a 0 percent tariff rate."
- Interpretation:
  - Trade creation has a positive effect on welfare because consumers can purchase cheaper imports instead of more expensive local goods.
  - Negative trade creation at the maximum tariff rate (25%) reflects lower trade flows resulting from higher tariff rates; many goods moved from 15 percent MFN to the maximum tariff rate and are locally produced (examples: fish, pigs, other black tea, yeasts, pictures and designs, and steel products), indicating protectionist objectives.
- Caveat on under-recording of intraregional trade (informal cross-border trade may bias baseline):
  - Kenya–Uganda unofficial cross-border trade circa 1994-95: "about 49 percent of official trade."
  - Tanzania–Kenya cross-border trade 1995-96: "about 12 percent."
  - Tanzania–Uganda cross-border trade: "about 45 percent."

### Fiscal impacts and revenue implications
- Estimated customs revenue losses for Kenya:
  - SMART simulations: "full implementation of the EAC CET in Kenya would result in customs revenue losses of US$113.3 million."
  - World Bank (2003) earlier estimate for the three-band structure (0,10,25): "approximately US$150 million for Kenya."
- Potential fiscal policy responses:
  - "World Bank (2003) estimated that in Kenya customs exemptions amount to 22 percent of potential customs revenue, so to compensate for revenue losses, policymakers could streamline exemptions, widening the tax base and increasing revenues."

### Transitional costs, adjustment needs, and recommended policies
- Transitional costs:
  - Import-competing sectors will face increased competition, implying "transitional output and employment losses."
  - Sectoral adjustments are "the transitional or adjustment costs of lowering trade barriers."
- Recommended policy measures:
  - "strong governance policies to improve transparency and accountability and eliminate corruption;"
  - "strengthening the efficiency of the financial system;"
  - "labor market reforms to increase labor market flexibility;"
  - "an accelerated program of parastatal reform and privatization to increase efficiency and private sector involvement in the economy;"
  - "prudent fiscal policies to ensure that adequate resources are devoted to infrastructural development and improving the levels of education and health."
- Additional planned analysis:
  - "A poverty and social impact analysis (PSIA) of trade reforms is planned by the authorities and could provide the basis for programs to address these concerns."

### Broader motivations for East African integration beyond tariff liberalization
- Enlargement and linkages:
  - EAC customs union may "provide an impetus to the COMESA customs union" and position Kenya to influence COMESA CET objectives.
  - EPAs with the EU: EPAs are under negotiation regionally and a COMESA-wide customs union could be a key negotiating bloc.
- Trade facilitation and "behind the border" reforms:
  - Cooperative regional approaches to SPS standards, technical standards, investment code, competition law, intellectual property rights, and customs clearance to reduce transaction costs and enhance trade.
- Regional public goods:
  - Regional cooperation on "water basins (lakes, rivers), infrastructure (roads, railways, dams), the environment, hydroelectric and other sources of energy, and fisheries" can generate benefits and attract multilateral and bilateral support.

### SMART model: analytical outline and limitations
- Core assumptions:
  - Partial equilibrium: "no income effects."
  - Armington assumption: "HS 6 digit goods imported from different countries are imperfect substitutes."
  - "Export supplies are perfectly elastic: world prices of each variety ... are given."
- Definitions and measures:
  - Trade creation (cg TC): derived from price elasticity of import demand and tariff changes.
  - Trade diversion (cg TD): measured via elasticity of substitution across imports from different sources and constrained so TD cannot exceed original imports from other countries.
- Model limitations:
  - SMART is "a static partial equilibrium model operable under strict ceteris paribus conditions" and "disregards any adjustment process."
  - Static results may understate dynamic sectoral responses when tariffs increase (e.g., regional producers entering protected lines over time).

*Source: _wp05143 - conclusions on the potential welfare impact of the customs union. Finally, factors other than (IMF PDF content).*

### conclusions on the potential welfare impact of the customs union. Finally, factors other than

### _wp05143 - conclusions on the potential welfare impact of the customs union. Finally, factors other than

### Introduction: objectives and context
- The paper gauges the effects of the EAC customs union on the trade flows and trade regimes of EAC member states and analyzes whether the introduction of the EAC common external tariff (CET) lowering tariffs in Kenya has a positive impact on trade.
- EAC members discussed: Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda.
- Stated integration path of the “new” EAC: customs union → common market → monetary union → political federation.

### Key economy and development statistics (EAC, 2003; 1990-2001)
- Combined GDP of the three EAC member states: $31.4 billion in 2003.
- Kenya:
  - GDP: $14.1 billion in 2003
  - Population: 31.9 million
  - Per capita GDP: $445
  - Real GDP growth, 1990-2001: 2.2 percent (annual average)
- Tanzania:
  - GDP: $10.3 billion in 2003
  - Population: 35.9 million
  - Per capita GDP: $286.6
  - Real GDP growth, 1990-2001: 3.1 percent (annual average)
- Uganda:
  - GDP: $7.0 billion in 2003
  - Population: 25 million
  - Per capita GDP: $280.8
  - Real GDP growth, 1990-2001: 6.8 percent (annual average)
- Sub-Saharan Africa regional average growth, 1990-2001: 2.6 percent (annual average)

### Trade flows and commodity composition (2001)
- EAC export destinations and shares:
  - Tanzania exports to EU: 37.1 percent
  - Uganda exports to EU: 64.5 percent
  - Kenya exports:
    - EU: 31.9 percent of total exports
    - Other African countries: 35.9 percent
    - EAC: 22.6 percent
- Kenya import sources:
  - Africa and Middle East (mainly Egypt): 35.7 percent of Kenya’s total imports
  - EU imports: 27.3 percent
- Intraregional trade evolution, 1991 → 2001:
  - Share of intraregional exports: about 6 percent → 16 percent
  - Share of intraregional imports: 2.7 percent → 10.5 percent
- Asymmetries in intraregional flows:
  - Kenya receives only 1.4 percent of total imports from the subregion
  - Tanzania: sends 9.9 percent of total exports to subregion; receives 7.2 percent of total imports from subregion
  - Uganda: low exports to EAC but receives 48.8 percent of total imports from EAC (mainly from Kenya)
- Commodity composition of intraregional trade highlights:
  - Manufactures play an important role in intraregional trade (examples):
    - Kenya: 11.5 percent and 43.4 percent of its imports from Uganda and Tanzania, respectively, are manufactures
    - Uganda: 33.8 percent and 71.3 percent of its imports from Kenya and Tanzania, respectively, are manufactures
    - Tanzania: 56.8 percent and 16.6 percent of its imports from Kenya and Uganda, respectively, are manufactures
- Principal exported commodities to the EU:
  - Tanzania and Uganda: principally agricultural commodities and minerals
  - Kenya exports: coffee, tea, cut flowers, vegetables
  - Tanzania exports: gold, fish fillets, nuts (coconuts, brazil nuts and cashews), coffee
  - Uganda exports: fish fillets, gold, tobacco, tea

### Trade regimes and tariff structures
- Characterization: “cascading tariff” structure — lowest rates on raw materials and capital goods, moderate on intermediate goods, highest on consumer goods.
- Tariff evolution, 1997 → 2002 (applied rates):
  - Kenya:
    - Tariff bands: 5.0, 5.0, 5.0 (1997, 1999, 2002 column headings indicate values repeated in table)
    - Maximum rate: 35.0 percent (1997, 1999, 2002)
    - Simple average: 18.4 percent (1997), 16.3 percent (1999), 16.6 percent (2002)
  - Tanzania (data for 2001 noted):
    - Tariff bands: 9.0 (1997), 5.0 (1999), 4.0 (2002)
    - Maximum rate: 50.0 percent (1997), 25.0 percent (1999), 25.0 percent (2002)
    - Simple average: 21.8 percent (1997), 16.1 percent (1999), 14.3 percent (2002)
  - Uganda:
    - Tariff bands: 4.0 (1997), 3.0 (1999), 3.0 (2002)
    - Maximum rate: 20.0 percent (1997), 15.0 percent (1999), 15.0 percent (2002)
    - Simple average: 13.2 percent (1997), 9.0 percent (1999), 9.0 percent (2002)
- Observed trends: all three countries progressively reduced tariffs since the mid-1990s; most significant reductions in Uganda and Tanzania; Kenya’s simple average marginally declined due to tariff classification modifications.

### The EAC customs union and the Common External Tariff (CET)
- Treaty timeline and commitments:
  - Treaty establishing the EAC signed in November 1999.
  - Treaty provides for establishment of a customs union by January 1, 2005.
  - CET agreement reached by presidents on June 23, 2003.
  - CET introduced on January 1, 2005 but not fully implemented due to additional time needed to finalize administrative arrangements.
- CET band structure agreed:
  - 0 percent for meritorious goods, raw materials, and capital goods
  - 10 percent for intermediate goods
  - 25 percent for consumer goods
- Implementation phases and asymmetry provisions:
  - Tanzania and Uganda will maintain internal tariffs on an agreed list of commodities—906 tariff lines for Tanzania and 426 for Uganda—for which tariffs will be reduced gradually to zero within a period of up to five years.
  - In Uganda, items on that list initially attract a 10 percent tariff that over five years will be reduced uniformly.
  - Tanzania: each product group has a different schedule; no tariff initially higher than 25 percent; reduction to zero within five years.
  - After five years all internal tariffs will be removed and Kenyan imports will enter Tanzania and Uganda free of tariffs.
- Sensitive items and protection:
  - About 20 percent of the tariff lines were classified as “sensitive items.”
  - Sensitive items equivalent to 361 tariff lines and estimated at about 20 percent of total imports.
  - Sensitive items included (per World Bank, 2003): cigarettes, dry cells, fabrics, garments, matches, milk, cement, packing materials of plastic, palm oil, sugar, tires, used clothes, vehicles (reconditioned cars), vehicle chassis, rice, wheat and wheat flour.
  - As of September 2004, agreement reached on classification and applicable rates of sensitive products with exceptions for jute bags, rice, and wheat.
  - Agreement that sensitive products could not be “protected” by the maximum rate and therefore required special policy measures.
  - EAC member states agreed sensitive items would attract rates of more than 25 percent and, in some instances, a mixture of specific duty and ad valorem rates.
- Administrative and legal requirements to form the customs union:
  - Remove all internal tariffs
  - Establish a CET
  - Introduce rules of origin
  - Harmonized customs administration, customs valuation system, customs procedures and documentation

### Other institutional and RTA issues noted
- Membership overlaps and potential conflicting commitments:
  - Kenya and Uganda are members of COMESA.
  - Tanzania is a member of SADC and withdrew from COMESA in 2000.
  - Overlap creates potential conflicting commitments with the EAC customs union.

### Additional themes highlighted (from sections listed in contents)
- The paper includes sections addressing:
  - Economic integration theory
  - Trade simulation model (SMART/WITS) and transitional costs
  - Reasons for East African integration beyond tariff liberalization:
    - “Widening and deepening” of regional integration
    - Trade facilitation and “behind the border” reforms
    - Provision of public goods
  - Conclusions summarizing findings and implications

*Source: _wp05143 - conclusions on the potential welfare impact of the customs union. Finally, factors other than (IMF PDF content).*

### introduction of the three-band tariff structure will increase tariffs in Uganda and, to a lesser

### _wp05143 - introduction of the three-band tariff structure will increase tariffs in Uganda and, to a lesser degree, Tanzania, and reduce tariffs in Kenya

### Effects on tariff lines
- Uganda: 3,066 tariff lines are likely to increase.
- Tanzania: 1,224 tariff lines are likely to increase.
- Kenya: 1,144 tariff lines are likely to increase.
- Under the EAC CET, tariff reductions are likely to be larger in Kenya: 3,216 tariff lines likely to be lowered.
- EAC CET reductions by country: Kenya 3,216; Tanzania 2,364; Uganda 1,353.

### Average tariff changes (simple averages)
- With full implementation of the CET, the World Bank (2003) estimates the simple average tariff in the three countries will be 10.9 percent.
- Kenya: decline from a simple average tariff of 16.6 percent to 10.9 percent (significant decline).
- Tanzania: decline from a simple average tariff of 14.3 percent to 10.9 percent (smaller decline).
- Uganda: the simple average tariff 10 will increase by about 20 percent.

### Excise duties and discriminatory charges
- Tanzania and Uganda apply excise duties and other discriminatory charges to protect their products from Kenyan imports.
- Tanzania applies excise taxes on 55 items at specific or ad valorem rates of 10-30 percent with peaks of over 50 percent, mostly on Ugandan and [text truncated].

*Source: _wp05143 - introduction of the three-band tariff structure will increase tariffs in Uganda and, to a lesser degree, Tanzania, and reduce tariffs in Kenya*

### 25.9 percent for Uganda, and 30.0 percent for Tanzania.

### _wp05143 - 25.9 percent for Uganda, and 30.0 percent for Tanzania.

### EAC tariff reform and excises: key features and distributional effects
- Reported tariff incidence highlights: "25.9 percent for Uganda, and 30.0 percent for Tanzania."
- Excise and suspended duties:
  - "rates of 10 percent on 467 items increasing substantially to 75 percent for beverages and 130 percent for tobacco."
  - Kenya: "imposes excise taxes on 459 items in the top tariff bracket with peaks of 50 and 70 percent. Suspended duties are applied to sugar, maize flour, and milk in the top tariff bracket."
- Effect on effective protection:
  - With a maximum tariff rate of 25 percent and low (or zero) rates on inputs, "the distortions in the effective rate of protection can be large."
  - This feature "represents a major step backwards for Uganda."
  - Although "tariffs are currently lower in Tanzania and Uganda, the nominal rates of protection may not vary considerably among EAC members."

### Estimated tariff-line adjustments (six-digit HS basis)
- Bands changed to 0, 10, 25:
  - Number of tariffs lowered: Kenya 3,216; Tanzania 2,364; Uganda 1,353
  - Number of tariffs increased: Kenya 1,144; Tanzania 1,224; Uganda 3,066
  - Number unchanged: Kenya 753; Tanzania 1,525; Uganda 694
- Bands changed to 0, 10, 15:
  - Number of tariffs lowered: Kenya 3,944; Tanzania 3,928; Uganda 1,353
  - Number of tariffs increased: Kenya 636; Tanzania 952; Uganda 1,859
  - Number unchanged: Kenya 533; Tanzania 233; Uganda 1,901
- Note: "Estimated at six-digit level of HS-classification."

### Customs union implementation status and trade administration
- Adoption and preparatory steps:
  - "The WTO Customs Valuation Agreement has been adopted."
  - "The EAC Customs Management Bill is expected to be approved by the EAC Council."
  - "Preparations are ongoing to complete the customs regulations and forms."
  - "Rules of origin have been agreed that adopt the COMESA rules with some product-specific rules, mainly for garments."
- Outstanding item:
  - "The Customs Union Protocol is yet to be ratified by the member states."

### Trade impact assessment for Kenya — empirical simulation results (SMART via WITS)
- Methodology and data:
  - Static partial equilibrium SMART model employed via WITS (UN COMTRADE and UNCTAD TRAINS) at HS six-digit level.
  - SMART assumes "products imported from different regions are imperfect substitutes."
- Aggregate simulation outcomes (move from current MFN to three-band EAC CET):
  - Total trade increase (All product lines): $193.5 million
  - Trade creation: $193.86 million
  - Trade diversion: -0.32 million (reported as -0.321 in table)
- Breakdown by tariff band (Table 6 results):
  - Product lines at 0%: Trade 157.37; Trade Effect -0.12; Diversion -0.12; Creation 157.49
  - Product lines at 10%: Trade 45.28; Trade Effect -0.16; Diversion -0.16; Creation 45.44
  - Product lines at 25%: Trade -9.11; Trade Effect -0.04; Diversion -0.04; Creation -9.07
  - Note: "81.2 percent ($157.5 million) of trade-creating flows resulting from the move to the new EAC CET are accounted for by products that attract a 0 percent tariff rate."
- Interpretation:
  - "Trade creation has a positive effect on welfare because consumers can purchase cheaper imports instead of more expensive local goods."
  - The negative trade creation at the maximum tariff rate (25%) "reflects lower trade flows resulting from higher tariff rates."
  - Many goods moved from 15 percent MFN to the maximum tariff rate and are locally produced (examples: fish, pigs, other black tea, yeasts, pictures and designs, and steel products), indicating protectionist objectives.
- Caveat on under-recording of intraregional trade:
  - Unrecorded informal cross-border trade may bias baseline imports downwards:
    - Kenya–Uganda unofficial cross-border trade circa 1994-95: "about 49 percent of official trade."
    - Tanzania–Kenya cross-border trade 1995-96: "about 12 percent."
    - Tanzania–Uganda cross-border trade: "about 45 percent."

### Fiscal impacts and revenue implications
- Estimated customs revenue losses for Kenya:
  - SMART simulations: "full implementation of the EAC CET in Kenya would result in customs revenue losses of US$113.3 million."
  - World Bank (2003) earlier estimate for the three-band structure (0,10,25): "approximately US$150 million for Kenya."
- Potential fiscal policy responses:
  - "World Bank (2003) estimated that in Kenya customs exemptions amount to 22 percent of potential customs revenue, so to compensate for revenue losses, policymakers could streamline exemptions, widening the tax base and increasing revenues."

### Transitional costs, adjustment needs, and recommended policies
- Transitional costs:
  - Import-competing sectors will face increased competition, implying "transitional output and employment losses."
  - Sectoral adjustments are "the transitional or adjustment costs of lowering trade barriers."
- Recommended policy measures to minimize dislocations and promote competitiveness:
  - "strong governance policies to improve transparency and accountability and eliminate corruption;"
  - "strengthening the efficiency of the financial system;"
  - "labor market reforms to increase labor market flexibility;"
  - "an accelerated program of parastatal reform and privatization to increase efficiency and private sector involvement in the economy;"
  - "prudent fiscal policies to ensure that adequate resources are devoted to infrastructural development and improving the levels of education and health."
- Additional planned analysis:
  - "A poverty and social impact analysis (PSIA) of trade reforms is planned by the authorities and could provide the basis for programs to address these concerns."

### Broader motivations for East African integration beyond immediate trade effects
- Enlargement and linkages:
  - EAC customs union may "provide an impetus to the COMESA customs union" and position Kenya to influence COMESA CET objectives.
  - EPAs with the EU: EPAs are under negotiation regionally and a COMESA-wide customs union could be a key negotiating bloc.
- Trade facilitation and "behind the border" reforms:
  - Emphasis on cooperative regional approaches to SPS standards, technical standards, investment code, competition law, intellectual property rights, and customs clearance to reduce transaction costs and enhance trade.
- Regional public goods:
  - Regional cooperation on "water basins (lakes, rivers), infrastructure (roads, railways, dams), the environment, hydroelectric and other sources of energy, and fisheries" can generate benefits and attract multilateral and bilateral support.

### SMART model: brief analytical outline (as used in simulations)
- Core assumptions:
  - Partial equilibrium: "no income effects."
  - Armington assumption: "HS 6 digit goods imported from different countries are imperfect substitutes."
  - "Export supplies are perfectly elastic: world prices of each variety ... are given."
- Definitions and measures:
  - Trade creation (cg TC): derived from price elasticity of import demand and tariff changes; formulae expressed in Appendix I.
  - Trade diversion (cg TD): measured via elasticity of substitution across imports from different sources; constrained so TD cannot exceed original imports from other countries.
- Model limitations noted:
  - SMART is "a static partial equilibrium model operable under strict ceteris paribus conditions" and "disregards any adjustment process."
  - Static results may understate dynamic sectoral responses when tariffs increase (e.g., regional producers entering protected lines over time).

*Source: Fund staff estimates and related analysis in the provided IMF working paper excerpt.*

### REFERENCES

### _wp05143 - REFERENCES

### References
- DeRosa, D; Obwona, M and Roningen, V., 2003, “The New EAC Customs Union:    
             Implications for Trade, Industry Competitiveness, and economic Welfare in East Africa” 
             (USAID, Washington D.C.).
- Khandelwal, P., 2004, “COMESA and SADC: Prospects and Challenges for Regional 
             Integration” (Draft Working Paper, IMF, Washington D.C.).
- Ng’eno, N.,2002, “The Status of Regional Trade Liberalization in East Africa” (African 
            Centre for Economic Growth; Nairobi).
- Mkenda, B., 2001, “Is East Africa an Optimum Currency Area” (Working papers in 
            Economics no. 41, Department of  Economics, Goteborg University).
- Panagariya, A., 2000, “Preferential Trade Liberalization: The Traditional Theory and New 
Developments,” Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. XXXVIII (June), pp.287–331.
- Schiff, L., 1999, “Will the Real ‘Natural Trading Partner’ Please Stand Up?” World Bank 
Policy Research Working Paper No. 2161 (Washington, D.C.: World Bank).
- Schiff, L., 2000, “Regional Integration and Development in Small States” (Development 
Research Group; World Bank, Washington D.C.)
- Viner, J., 1950, The Customs Union Issue (New York: Carnegie Endowment for International 
Peace).
- Venables, A., 2000, “Winners and Losers From Regional Integration Agreements” (Center 
            for Economic Policy Research; London, UK).
- Wonnacott, P., and M. Lutz, 1989, “ Is There a Case for Free Trade Areas?” in Free Trade 
            Areas and U.S. Trade Policy, ed. by Jeffrey Schott (Washington, DC: Institute for 
            International Economics).
- World Bank (2003). “Regional Trade Integration in East Africa—Trade and Revenue.

*Source: _wp05143 - REFERENCES*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2005/_wp05143.pdf_
