## _wp06132

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp06132](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp06132.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp06132.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp06132.pdf.json)

---

### I. Introduction
- Over the last decade, emigrant deposits (ED) have provided a substantial source of foreign exchange to the Cape Verdean economy and have been vital in maintaining the fixed exchange rate.
- Cape Verde faces a policy dilemma: fostering private initiative to spur growth implies significantly lower interest rates, while reserve accumulation essential to maintaining investors’ confidence in the peg requires keeping interest rates high and credit growth strictly in check.
- The need to increase fiscal expenditure to meet Millennium Development Goals exacerbates the “impossible trinity,” leading to higher dependency on foreign aid.
- Anticipated graduation of Cape Verde from the least developed countries group may lead to increasing difficulty over time in obtaining international aid at concessional terms.
- Further accumulation of reserves will continue to rely on emigrants’ savings; understanding forces that have driven ED in the past is essential for reserve sustainability and efficient reserve management.
- The paper studies long-run determinants of ED with respect to risk, wealth and return variables using review of related studies, statistical and econometric analyses, and qualitative assessment.
  - Includes risk indicators for domestic institutional events (change in the government, introduction of the foreign exchange law) and major economic episodes at home (devaluation fears, slippages in the fiscal policy) as well as events in host countries (introduction of the euro, September 11).
  - Return variables include interest rates in the host and the home country.
  - Wealth effect on ED assessed via developments in wages and GDP per capita.
- Paper organization:
  - Section II: evolution of ED, from the reform introduced in 1995 until recently;
  - Section III: data set and methodological approach;
  - Section IV: econometric estimation results;
  - Section V: conclusion.

### II. Evolution and Structure of Emigrant Deposits (ED)
- Role and macroeconomic significance:
  - ED are a large source of foreign currency and potential investment capital and, being partly co-owned by residents, represent a domestic liability affecting banking system stability and exchange rate policy.
  - Gross remittance flows accounted for 20 percent of GDP in 2004; the net accumulation of ED was almost 4 percent of GDP.
  - ED represented almost 40 percent of broad money in 2005.
  - As a share of imports of goods and services, ED grew from 20 percent to over 40 percent over the last decade and have been consistently above 200 percent of gross international reserves (Figure 3).
- Time profile and volatility:
  - Contribution of ED to M2 growth increased from slightly over 2 percent in 1996 to over 7 percent in 2002; lower since then.
  - Annual growth rate since the peg introduction averaged over 20 percent, peaking in June 2003 at US$73 million or 5 percent of GDP.
  - Accumulation slowed to 13 percent in 2005 with the stock at end-2005 at 30 percent of GDP.
  - Time deposits are the most volatile in standard deviation terms but have the largest mean and the smallest coefficient of variation; coefficient of variation for total deposits has been consistently around (see Table 1).
- Composition (selected end-of-year values as presented):
  - 1995: Demand 6.17, Time 77.31, Forex 16.62, Total 21.0?
  - 1996: Demand 5.68, Time 81.71, Forex 12.72, Total 23.3, Share of ED in M2 20.3, Interest rate spread on deposits 12.3, Volatility of ED flows 5.0, Contribution to M2 growth 5.4, ED net flows mean 3.6, stdev 105.0, additional 401.2
  - 1997: Demand 9.99, Time 90.10, Forex 0.02, Total 23.5, Share of ED in M2 23.5, Interest rate spread on deposits 10.3, Volatility 2.6, Contribution to M2 growth 5.5, mean 3.1, stdev 61.7, 130.3
  - 1998: Demand 9.37, Time 79.31, Forex 11.42, Total 25.1, Share of ED in M2 22.2, Interest rate spread 2.5, Volatility 2.2, Contribution to M2 growth 6.0, mean 3.8, stdev 57.0, 95.0
  - 1999: Demand 10.57, Time 89.51, Forex 0.02, Total 27.2, Share of ED in M2 24.5, Interest rate spread 15.4, Volatility 6.4, Contribution to M2 growth 6.1, mean 2.7, stdev 170.3, 104.0
  - 2000: Demand 11.18, Time 80.38, Forex 8.62, Total 29.9, Share of ED in M2 27.3, Interest rate spread 12.9, Volatility 6.5, Contribution to M2 growth 3.7, mean 1.1, stdev 201.4, 85.5
  - 2001: Demand 11.38, Time 81.37, Forex 7.43, Total 34.0, Share of ED in M2 31.5, Interest rate spread 9.8, Volatility 7.5, Contribution to M2 growth 6.4, mean 7.3, stdev 259.0, 110.8
  - 2002: Demand 11.28, Time 83.15, Forex 5.73, Total 36.4, Share of ED in M2 34.3, Interest rate spread 14.3, Volatility 7.5, Contribution to M2 growth 5.7, mean 6.9, stdev 288.1, 113.7
  - 2003: Demand 9.98, Time 85.44, Forex 4.73, Total 38.9, Share of ED in M2 37.1, Interest rate spread 8.6, Volatility 5.9, Contribution to M2 growth 4.8, mean 5.6, stdev 259.3, 128.2
  - 2004: Demand 10.38, Time 85.83, Forex 3.93, Total 39.9, Share of ED in M2 38.4, Interest rate spread 10.5, Volatility 5.2, Contribution to M2 growth 4.7, mean 4.2, stdev 244.9, 109.5
  - 2005: Demand 11.58, Time 84.54, Forex 4.03, Total 39.4, Share of ED in M2 37.9, Interest rate spread 16.0, Volatility 5.3, Contribution to M2 growth 3.0, mean 0.6, stdev 265.3, 74.2
- Legal and currency details:
  - Decree-law of September 1995 reformed special emigrants’ deposits and established three types: “emigrant deposits in foreign currency”, “emigrant savings deposits”, and “emigrant deposits in escudos”.
  - Foreign currency deposits initially specified U.S. dollar, French franc, German mark, and Dutch guilder; now held in euros and U.S. dollars.
  - Government 1 percent interest rate subsidy on escudo deposits was eliminated in November 2003 after fiscal cost reached 0.2 percent of GDP.
  - Convertibility of time and demand deposits back into foreign currency is not guaranteed and must be approved by the BCV; past attempted conversions were approved.

### III. Determinants, Motives and Migration Patterns
- Two broad motives considered:
  - Speculative motive: ED increase with widening real interest rate differentials between home and host countries and decrease with domestic economic or political instability.
  - Altruistic motive: ED increase when the economic situation at home worsens and/or when host-country economic conditions improve.
- Implications:
  - Altruistic flows are more likely spent on consumption (residential construction, education) and less likely to contribute to financial capital accumulation.
  - Speculative flows are more likely to be converted by the banking system into investment credit.
- Migration-pattern influences:
  - Size of diaspora, migration timing, emigrant status abroad, and identification with home country affect ED.
  - Feminization of migration has been found to increase remittance flows.
  - First-generation migrants with strong home ties are more likely to remit and save at home; permanent settlers remit less.
  - Europe accounts for only a third of the diaspora but more than half of all remittances.

### IV. Data and Methodology
- Sample and dependent variable:
  - Monthly indicators for the period December 1996 – October 2005.
  - Dependent variable LDEP: logarithm of the end-of-month stock of time deposits in domestic currency (BCV data).
- Key explanatory variables:
  - Interest rates: INT_CV (ED in Cape Verde), INT_US (U.S. certificates of deposit), INT_EU (euro area deposits).
  - Inflation: CPI_CV, CPI_EU.
  - Wages: WA_US, WA_EU as proxies for wealth effects and altruism.
  - Event dummies: DUM0911 (September 11), DUMEURO (introduction of the euro), DUMF_LAW (introduction of foreign exchange law), DUMDEV (devaluation fears), fiscal slippage preceding 2001 election.
  - Note: "the CPI for Germany is used to splice the series" at introduction of the euro.
- Modeling approach:
  - Framework based on Gordon and Gupta (2004); LDEP modeled as function of contemporaneous INT and vector X (inflation, wages, seasonal and functional dummies).
  - Two separate estimations: one for euro area variables and one for United States variables.
  - Logarithms used to interpret coefficients as elasticities.
- Data limitations:
  - High-frequency GDP per capita or industrial production not available; simple plot shows negative lagged correlation of -0.4 between annual real GDP growth and ED flows for 1995-2005.
  - Change in migration composition and original currency composition of deposits not included due to lack of detailed data.

### V. Empirical Findings
- Time series and cointegration:
  - All variables are I(1) according to the ADF statistic.
  - Cointegration tests indicate one cointegrating vector at a 5 percent significance level for both euro area and U.S. specifications (possibly two for the euro area).
- Long-run relationships (selected results):
  - Euro area specification:
    - Positive long-run relationship between ED and wages in the euro area supports the altruistic hypothesis.
    - Table 7 cointegrating equation (Euro Area): LWA_EU coefficient 6.773 [ -2.560 ].
  - United States specification:
    - Wage increases in the U.S. have a positive impact on ED but evidence of speculative behavior cannot be ruled out.
    - Negative sign on Cape Verde inflation implies U.S.-resident emigrants may be sensitive to narrowing real interest differentials.
    - Negative coefficient on U.S. certificates of deposit implies better host-country investment opportunities deter flows to Cape Verde deposits.
    - Table 8 cointegrating equation (United States): LWA_US coefficient 5.934 [ -22.012 ]; INT_US -0.040 [ 5.723 ].
  - Interest rates on Cape Verde ED are not significant determinants of flows in any estimation.
- Short-run dynamics:
  - Mostly insignificant; only the devaluation dummy (DUMDEV) is significant with expected negative sign:
    - Euro Area VECM: DUMDEV -0.006 [ -2.406 ] and CointEq speed -0.041 [ -3.401 ].
    - United States VECM: DUMDEV -0.016 [ -3.795 ] and CointEq speed -0.153 [ -3.591 ].
- Robustness and stability:
  - Alternative dependent variables (disentangling interest capitalized on ED from net flows with various withdrawal assumptions) yield qualitatively similar results.
  - Results are not robust to changes in the period under consideration; Chow tests and recursive estimations suggest possible instability over time.
- Diagnostics and tests (selected):
  - ADF statistics (log levels and first differences) reported in Table 4.
  - Cointegration test statistics (Table 6) — Euro Area trace and λmax series: Null r=0 vs Alt r≥1 Trace 121.739 | λmax 50.271; United States: Trace 95.910 | λmax 53.386.
  - Misspecification tests (Table 5): Normality rejected due to kurtosis (Kurtosis probabilities 0.000); skewness probabilities reported.

### VI. Risks, Outlook and Policy Implications
- Risks to future accumulation of ED if speculative motive matters:
  - An increase in interest rates in the euro area or the United States, reducing spreads with ED rates in Cape Verde.
  - A decrease in interest rates on ED (which could lower ED but may be needed to support stronger credit growth to the private sector).
  - Sluggish growth in host countries lowering emigrant wealth and savings capacity.
  - Loss of exchange rate credibility affecting Cape Verde’s capacity to generate foreign exchange reserves.
- Risks associated with altruistic motive:
  - Increased restrictiveness of immigration laws in Europe and the United States.
  - Increase in per capita income in Cape Verde and a move to middle-income status.
  - Decline in relative wealth of emigrants (e.g., due to wage or exchange rate changes).
- Outlook and policy recommendations:
  - Future ED evolution will reflect migration patterns, home-country conditions, host-country legislation, and changes in emigrant status (temporary to permanent).
  - Trends argue against further accumulation of ED (improving Cape Verde growth prospects and tightening immigration legislation abroad), but feminization of migration and returning emigrants nearing retirement could sustain flows for some years.
  - To attract speculative-type flows while reducing domestic interest rate spreads, effectiveness in channeling ED into productive uses to generate adequate returns is critical.
  - Progress with structural reforms and macroeconomic policies that ensure economic confidence is primary; such measures are needed to underpin employment growth, offset effects of slower migration, and support diversification into export-oriented activities.
  - Over the longer term, diversification and growth will determine Cape Verde’s need for external financing, including from ED.

### VII. Selected event and diagnostic numeric highlights
- Seasonality and event averages:
  - ED net flows display seasonality significant only for January, July, and August once devaluation-fear period excluded.
  - Table 3 — Monthly average net ED flows during specific events (months presented as two numbers in source):
    - Devaluation fear: 24 | 11 months
    - Introduction of the euro: 18 | 52 months
    - Increase in fiscal expenditure that preceded 2001 election: 17 | 13 months
    - September 11, 2001: 18 | 52 months
    - Introduction of the new foreign exchange law: -19 | 91 months
    - Total 1/: 191 | 120
    - 1/ Average monthly flows over the whole period
- Model diagnostics (selected statistics reported):
  - Euro Area VECM goodness-of-fit:
    - R-squared 0.889, Sum sq. resids 0.843, S.E. equation 0.009, F-statistic 19.421.
  - United States VECM goodness-of-fit:
    - R-squared 0.750, Sum sq. resids 0.638, S.E. equation 0.013, F-statistic 6.670.
  - VAR residual serial correlation LM Tests show significant serial correlation at several lags (e.g., Lag1: 91.941 [ 0.000 ] / 57.859 [ 0.000 ]).

*Source: _wp06132 (IMF) — INTRODUCTION and related sections as provided in the content unit.*

### INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................

### _wp06132 - INTRODUCTION

### I. Introduction
- Over the last decade, emigrant deposits (ED) have provided a substantial source of foreign exchange to the Cape Verdean economy and have been vital in maintaining the fixed exchange rate.
- Cape Verde faces a policy dilemma: fostering private initiative to spur growth implies significantly lower interest rates, while reserve accumulation essential to maintaining investors’ confidence in the peg requires keeping interest rates high and credit growth strictly in check.
- The need to increase fiscal expenditure to meet Millennium Development Goals exacerbates the “impossible trinity,” leading to higher dependency on foreign aid.
- Anticipated graduation of Cape Verde from the least developed countries group may lead to increasing difficulty over time in obtaining international aid at concessional terms.
- Further accumulation of reserves will continue to rely on emigrants’ savings; understanding the forces that have driven ED in the past is essential for reserve sustainability and efficient reserve management.
- The paper studies the long-run determinants of ED with respect to risk, wealth and return variables using different approaches, including review of related studies, statistical and econometric analyses, and qualitative assessment.
  - Draws partly on previous research on remittances published in the 1996 IMF Recent Economic Developments (RED) paper and on research on nonresident deposits (Gordon and Gupta, 2004).
  - Includes risk indicators for domestic institutional events (change in the government, introduction of the foreign exchange law) and major economic episodes at home (devaluation fears, slippages in the fiscal policy) as well as events in host countries (introduction of the euro, September 11).
  - Return variables include interest rates in the host and the home country.
  - Wealth effect on ED assessed via developments in wages and GDP per capita.
- Empirical evidence suggests that the long-run determinants of ED in Cape Verde are country-specific, reflecting different rationale of flows generated by temporary versus permanent migrants.
- Paper organization:
  - Section II: describes the evolution of ED, from the reform introduced in 1995 until recently;
  - Section III: presents the data set and the methodological approach to the estimation of determinants of ED;
  - Section IV: reports results from the econometric estimation;
  - Section V: concludes.

### II. Evidence on Emigrant Deposits — Evolution and Structure of Emigrant Deposits
- ED are a large source of foreign currency and potential investment capital and, being partly co-owned by residents, represent a domestic liability; they can influence banking system stability and exchange rate policy.
- A large part of remittances arrives through the banking system due to preferential treatment and tax incentives previously granted to these deposits and a healthy banking system free of political interference.
- The stock of ED represents that part of remittance inflows arriving through the banking system that are kept in special deposits regulated by the law.
- Gross remittance flows accounted for 20 percent of GDP in 2004; the net accumulation of ED was almost 4 percent of GDP.
- ED represent a considerable share of banking system liabilities, accounting for almost 40 percent of broad money in 2005.
- Contribution of ED to M2 growth:
  - Increased from slightly over 2 percent in 1996 to over 7 percent in 2002, but has been somewhat lower since then (see Table 1).
- The level of ED decreased substantially only in the period that preceded the introduction of the peg to the Portuguese escudo in June 1998, which fueled fears of devaluation for several months.
- Annual growth rate since the peg introduction averaged over 20 percent, reaching a peak in June 2003 and accounting for US$73 million or 5 percent of GDP.
- Accumulation of ED slowed to 13 percent in 2005 with the stock at end-2005 at 30 percent of GDP.
- Composition of ED:
  - Share of time deposits in the total has averaged over 80 percent throughout the 1990s.
  - Demand and foreign exchange deposits constituted less than 20 percent of the total, with foreign exchange deposits amounting to less than 4 percent of the total at end-2005.
- Structure and stability traced to decree-law of September 1995 (Law) which reformed special emigrants’ deposits and established three types of deposits:
  - “emigrant deposits in foreign currency” — denominated in any of the four currencies specified by the Banco de Cabo Verde; interest rate applied is only slightly above the market rate; share of foreign currency deposits in total has been small and declined to less than 4 percent in 2005.
  - “emigrant savings deposits” — intended to finance investment in industry, tourism, transportation, agriculture and fisheries, and construction/acquisition/improvement of residential or rural property; maturities of six months and one year; denominated in escudos; allow owners to borrow up to twice the amount of the deposit; Law grants tax incentives to holders.
  - “emigrant deposits in escudos” — focus on attracting foreign currency which accrues to the central bank after conversion into escudos; can be co-owned by residents; particularly attractive due to high interest rate spread with deposits in the euro area and in the United States.
- Government previously offered a 1 percent interest rate subsidy on escudo deposits; subsidy was eliminated in November 2003 due to excessive fiscal cost, which reached 0.2 percent of GDP.
- Foreign exchange deposits do not bear implicit exchange rate risk; deposits in escudos have been more attractive due to relatively high return with implied exchange rate risk compared with U.S. dollar or euro deposits.
- Nominal and real interest rate spreads with euro area deposit rates were stable throughout 1995-2005, apart from some fluctuation in 2000 (Table 1 and Figure 4).
- Interest rate differentials with U.S. certificates of deposit (CDs) have been more volatile, reflecting in particular a decrease in U.S. interest rates in recent years.
- Growth of ED net flows in escudo terms has been stable over the period under consideration.
- Time deposits are the most volatile in terms of standard deviation; however, their mean is also the largest and thus the coefficient of variation is the smallest. The coefficient of variation for total deposits has been consistently around (see Table 1).

### Selected numerical indicators from Table 1 (end-of-year unless noted)
- Composition of ED (percent by category, selected years):
  - 1995: Demand 6.17, Time 77.31, Forex 16.62, Total 21.0? (table formatting indicates columns but preserve values as presented)
  - 1996: Demand 5.68, Time 81.71, Forex 12.72, Total 23.3, Share of ED in M2 20.3, Interest rate spread on deposits 12.3, Volatility of ED flows 5.0, Contribution to M2 growth 5.4, ED net flows mean 3.6, stdev 105.0, additional 401.2
  - 1997: Demand 9.99, Time 90.10, Forex 0.02, Total 23.5, Share of ED in M2 23.5, Interest rate spread on deposits 10.3, Volatility 2.6, Contribution to M2 growth 5.5, mean 3.1, stdev 61.7, 130.3
  - 1998: Demand 9.37, Time 79.31, Forex 11.42, Total 25.1, Share of ED in M2 22.2, Interest rate spread 2.5, Volatility 2.2, Contribution to M2 growth 6.0, mean 3.8, stdev 57.0, 95.0
  - 1999: Demand 10.57, Time 89.51, Forex 0.02, Total 27.2, Share of ED in M2 24.5, Interest rate spread 15.4, Volatility 6.4, Contribution to M2 growth 6.1, mean 2.7, stdev 170.3, 104.0
  - 2000: Demand 11.18, Time 80.38, Forex 8.62, Total 29.9, Share of ED in M2 27.3, Interest rate spread 12.9, Volatility 6.5, Contribution to M2 growth 3.7, mean 1.1, stdev 201.4, 85.5
  - 2001: Demand 11.38, Time 81.37, Forex 7.43, Total 34.0, Share of ED in M2 31.5, Interest rate spread 9.8, Volatility 7.5, Contribution to M2 growth 6.4, mean 7.3, stdev 259.0, 110.8
  - 2002: Demand 11.28, Time 83.15, Forex 5.73, Total 36.4, Share of ED in M2 34.3, Interest rate spread 14.3, Volatility 7.5, Contribution to M2 growth 5.7, mean 6.9, stdev 288.1, 113.7
  - 2003: Demand 9.98, Time 85.44, Forex 4.73, Total 38.9, Share of ED in M2 37.1, Interest rate spread 8.6, Volatility 5.9, Contribution to M2 growth 4.8, mean 5.6, stdev 259.3, 128.2
  - 2004: Demand 10.38, Time 85.83, Forex 3.93, Total 39.9, Share of ED in M2 38.4, Interest rate spread 10.5, Volatility 5.2, Contribution to M2 growth 4.7, mean 4.2, stdev 244.9, 109.5
  - 2005: Demand 11.58, Time 84.54, Forex 4.03, Total 39.4, Share of ED in M2 37.9, Interest rate spread 16.0, Volatility 5.3, Contribution to M2 growth 3.0, mean 0.6, stdev 265.3, 74.2
- Notes from Table 1:
  - 1/ End of year data, except for 2005 end of November.
  - 2/ Demand and time deposits.
  - 3/ Nominal interest rates, EU deposit rate and US CD (3 and 6 months average).
  - 4/ Annual net flows in millions of escudos.
  - Source: Banco de Cabo Verde, and IMF, International Financial Statistics.
- Additional contextual numerical points:
  - As a share of imports of goods and services, ED have grown from 20 percent to over 40 percent over the last decade and have been consistently above 200 percent of gross international reserves (Figure 3).
  - The sharp decrease in the ratio of ED to gross reserves in December 1999 stems from a significant inflow of foreign direct investment related to privatization and large disbursement of bilateral and multilateral credits that led to strong accumulation of reserves of more than 2 months of imports of goods and services.
  - Devaluation fears spread from the last quarter of 1997 throughout the first half of 1998.
  - The Cape Verde escudo was pegged to the Portuguese escudo from mid-1998 to end-1998.
  - From January 4, 1999 it has been pegged to the euro at a rate of CVEsc 110.27 per EUR 1.
- Currency and legal details:
  - Foreign currency deposits initially specified U.S. dollar, French franc, German mark, and Dutch guilder; these deposits are now held in euros and U.S. dollars.
  - Foreign exchange accrues to the commercial bank that holds the account; due to domestic liquidity requirements, the local commercial bank often sells the foreign exchange to the BCV.
  - Decree Law 45/2003 repealed Ministerial Order 63/95, which granted 1 percent annual bonus to ED; commercial banks withdrew the bonus as from the renewal date of domestic currency ED, but continued to pay higher interest on ED than on residents’ deposits.
  - Convertibility of time and demand deposits back into foreign currency is not guaranteed and has to be approved by the BCV; the few attempted conversions in the past were all approved.

*Source: _wp06132 - INTRODUCTION (IMF), as provided in the content unit.*

### 0.5 percent from 1999 until recently.

### _wp06132 - 0.5 percent from 1999 until recently.

### Summary findings on Emigrant Deposits (ED)
- ED net flows display seasonality significant only for the months of January, July, and August once values for the period with devaluation fears are excluded; this may reflect a “vacation effect” tied to high tourist season.
- At first glance, political and economic events (the introduction of the euro, September 11, and fiscal policy slippage) had very little impact on average monthly ED net flows, apart from the period characterized by devaluation fears preceding the change in the exchange rate peg.
- The substantial increase in ED growth in the second half of the 1990s, particularly from 1998 on, is at least partly explained by:
  - shift from a broad-currency target to a peg with the Portuguese escudo and later to the euro (more stability and credibility);
  - relaxation of exchange controls reducing informal channels;
  - high interest rate differentials in favor of Cape Verde and the interest rate subsidy granted by the Treasury.
- Recent slowdown in ED accumulation could be partly explained by weaker labor market indicators in host countries and depreciation of the U.S. dollar; recent decreases in domestic interest rates on ED should not have contributed substantially to the slowdown due to still high spreads with euro area and U.S. deposit rates.

### Determinants of Emigrant Deposits — motives and channels
- Two broad motivations considered:
  - Speculative motive: ED increase with widening real interest rate differentials between home and host countries and decrease with domestic economic or political instability.
  - Altruistic motive: ED increase when the economic situation at home worsens and/or when host-country economic conditions improve.
- Implications:
  - Altruistically motivated flows are more likely spent on consumption (e.g., residential construction, education) and less likely to contribute to financial capital accumulation.
  - Speculatively motivated flows are more likely to be converted by the banking system into investment credit.
- Empirical and contextual observations:
  - Historical period 1975–1985 (high inflation, negative real bank interest rates) suggests altruism dominated remittances prior to institution of ED.
  - Mid-1980s to mid-1990s (positive real interest rates, real GDP per capita growth, exchange rate stability) suggests reduced need for altruistic transfers.
  - Use of ED is not tracked, but studies indicate remittances are mostly used for residential construction and education; Bourdet and Falck (2003) report half of credits granted to individuals for residential construction.

### Impact of migration patterns on ED
- ED evolution is influenced by:
  - Size of the diaspora, migration timing, emigrant status abroad, and identification with home country.
  - Freedom of movement as defined by host-country legislation is the chief force in determining migration.
- Migration composition effects:
  - Gender composition: feminization of migration has been found to increase remittance flows; women are believed more likely to remit despite often earning less.
  - Return decisions: first-generation migrants with strong home ties are more likely to remit and save at home, but return/remit decisions evolve over time with migrant accomplishments and migration law restrictiveness.
- Cape Verde-specific notes:
  - Cape Verdean population abroad likely exceeds nationals at home; most emigrants historically reside in the United States but many there are fourth-generation and behave as permanent residents, remitting less.
  - Europe accounts for only a third of the diaspora but more than half of all remittances.

### Data and methodology
- Sample and dependent variable:
  - Monthly indicators for the period December 1996 – October 2005.
  - Dependent variable LDEP is the logarithm of the end-of-month stock of time deposits in domestic currency provided by the BCV.
- Key explanatory variables:
  - Interest rates on ED in Cape Verde (INT_CV), interest rates on U.S. certificates of deposit (INT_US) and euro area deposits (INT_EU).
  - Inflation at home and abroad (CPI_CV, CPI_EU), wages in the United States and the euro area (WA_US, WA_EU) as proxies for wealth effects and altruism.
  - Dummies for September 11, introduction of the euro, introduction of the foreign exchange law and change in exchange rate peg, and fiscal policy slippage preceding the 2001 election.
- Modeling approach:
  - Framework based on Gordon and Gupta (2004); LDEP modeled as function of contemporaneous INT and vector X (inflation, wages, seasonal and functional dummies).
  - Two separate estimations: one for euro area variables and one for United States variables.
  - Logarithms used to interpret coefficients as elasticities.
- Data limitations and omissions:
  - High-frequency GDP per capita or industrial production not available for Cape Verde; a simple plot shows a negative lagged correlation of -0.4 between annual real GDP growth and ED flows for 1995-2005, suggesting decreases in GDP induce altruistic flows.
  - Change in migration composition and original currency composition of deposits could not be included due to lack of detailed data.

### Empirical findings
- Time series properties and cointegration:
  - All variables are I(1) according to the ADF statistic; cointegration tests indicate one cointegrating vector at a 5 percent significance level for both euro area and U.S. specifications (possibly two for the euro area).
- Long-run relationships:
  - Euro area specification: positive long-run relationship between ED and wages in the euro area supports the altruistic hypothesis.
  - U.S. specification: wage increases have a positive impact on ED, but evidence of speculative behavior cannot be ruled out:
    - Negative sign on Cape Verde inflation implies U.S.-resident emigrants may be sensitive to narrowing real interest differentials rather than maintaining real value to families.
    - Negative coefficient on U.S. certificates of deposit implies better investment opportunities in the host country deter flows to Cape Verde deposits.
  - Interest rates on Cape Verde ED are not significant determinants of flows in any estimation.
- Short-run dynamics:
  - Mostly insignificant across estimates; only the devaluation dummy (announced change in exchange rate policy) is significant with the expected negative sign.
- Robustness and stability:
  - Robustness tests constructing alternative dependent variables (disentangling interest capitalized on ED from net flows with various withdrawal assumptions) yield qualitatively similar results.
  - Results are not robust to changes in the period under consideration; Chow test, Chow breakpoint test, and recursive estimations suggest possible instability over time.
- Diagnostic notes:
  - Normality of residuals is rejected due to excess kurtosis, but Johansen cointegration results are not affected per Paruolo (1997).

### Conclusions and policy implications
- Caution in interpretation due to instability and data limitations.
- Four risks to future accumulation of ED if speculative motive matters:
  - An increase in interest rates in the euro area or the United States, reducing spreads with ED rates in Cape Verde.
  - A decrease in interest rates on ED (which could lower ED but may be needed to support stronger growth of credit to the private sector).
  - Sluggish growth in host countries lowering emigrant wealth and savings capacity.
  - Loss of exchange rate credibility affecting Cape Verde’s capacity to generate foreign exchange reserves.
- Risks associated with altruistic motive:
  - Increased restrictiveness of immigration laws in Europe and the United States.
  - Increase in per capita income in Cape Verde and a move to middle-income status.
  - Decline in relative wealth of emigrants (e.g., due to wage or exchange rate changes).
- Outlook and policy recommendations:
  - Future ED evolution will reflect migration patterns, home-country conditions, host-country legislation, and changes in emigrant status (temporary to permanent).
  - Trends argue against further accumulation of ED (improving Cape Verde growth prospects and tightening immigration legislation abroad), but feminization of migration and returning emigrants nearing retirement could sustain flows for some years.
  - To attract speculative-type flows while reducing domestic interest rate spreads, effectiveness in channeling ED into productive uses to generate adequate returns is critical.
  - Progress with structural reforms and macroeconomic policies that ensure economic confidence is primary; such measures are needed to underpin employment growth, offset effects of slower migration, and support diversification into export-oriented activities.
  - Over the longer term, diversification and growth will determine Cape Verde’s need for external financing, including from ED.

*Source: IMF staff analysis and empirical results contained in the provided content unit.*

### introduction of the euro the CPI for Germany is used to splice the series.

### _wp06132 - introduction of the euro the CPI for Germany is used to splice the series.

### Constructed dummies and variable descriptions
- DUM0911: Constructed Dummy for September 11, 2001.
- DUMDEV: Constructed Dummy for the period characterized by devaluation fears that preceded the change of the peg from the basket of European currencies to the Portuguese escudo.
- DUMF_LAW: Constructed Dummy for the introduction of the foreign exchange law in August 1998 that liberalized foreign exchange transactions.
- DUMEURO: Constructed Dummy for the introduction of the euro that coincides with the first change in government democratically elected (January 2001).
- Note: "the CPI for Germany is used to splice the series."

### Table 3 — Monthly average net emigrant deposit (ED) flows during specific events
- Devaluation fear: 24 | 11 months
- Introduction of the euro: 18 | 52 months
- Increase in fiscal expenditure that preceded 2001 election: 17 | 13 months
- September 11, 2001: 18 | 52 months
- Introduction of the new foreign exchange law: -19 | 91 months
- Total 1/: 191 | 120
- 1/ Average monthly flows over the whole period

### Table 4 — ADF Statistics Unit Root Test (summarized)
- Log Levels (Euro Area / United States columns presented):
  - dep: -0.9530
  - int_cv: 0.3660
  - int_eu: -1.6882
  - cpi_cv: -3.2090
  - cpi_eu: 1.41512
  - wa_us: -0.04512
  - wa_eu: -1.38512
- First differences:
  - dep: -10.0070
  - int_cv: -10.8130
  - int_eu: -4.2351
  - int_us: 2/-1.8059
  - cpi_cv: -11.5130
  - cpi_eu: 2/-2.57711
  - wa_us: -3.61811
  - wa_eu: 2/-2.07912
- Notes:
  - 1/ Interest rates are expressed in levels.
  - 2/ Not stationary in first differences according to ADF. However, the Schwartz Information Criterion test suggests variable is stationary.

### Table 5 — Misspecification Tests (Chi-squared test statistics)
- Skewness:
  - Degr. of freedom 65.8140 Probability 0.4445
  - Degr. of freedom 59.4410 Probability 0.093
- Kurtosis:
  - Degr. of freedom 6137.4490 Probability 0.000
  - Degr. of freedom 559.2000 Probability 0.000
- Normality:
  - Degr. of freedom 12143.2640 Probability 0.000
  - Degr. of freedom 1066.6410 Probability 0.000
- Notes:
  - 1/ The null hypothesis is that of residuals with no skeweness, no kurtosis and normal.
  - 2/ Ortogonalization is based on Cholesky (Lutkepohl) test; skewness and kurtosis is based on joint chi-square test; normality is based on joint Jarque-Bera test.

### VAR/VEC diagnostics and lag tests
- VAR Residual Serial Correlation LM Tests (Euro Area / United States):
  - Lag1: 91.941 [ 0.000 ] / 57.859 [ 0.000 ]
  - Lag2: 61.330 [ 0.005 ] / ...
  - Lag3: ...34.694 [ 0.017 ]
  - Lag5: ...85.570 [ 0.000 ]
  - Lag6: ...
  - degr. of freedom 3625
  - 2/ Numbers in [ ] are probabilities
- VEC Lag Exclusion Wald Test (selected Lags):
  - Lags 1: LM-Stat 46.497 Prob 0.113 / 23.294 Prob 0.560
  - Lags 2: LM-Stat 62.783 Prob 0.004 / 41.696 Prob 0.194
  - Lags 3: LM-Stat 38.243 Prob 0.368 / 23.360 Prob 0.557
  - Lags 4: LM-Stat 38.361 Prob 0.363 / 15.168 Prob 0.937
  - Lags 5: LM-Stat 29.743 Prob 0.760 / 19.055 Prob 0.745
- Notes:
  - 1/ The null hypothesis is that the coefficients of the lags are jointly non-significantly different from 0.
  - 1/ The null hypothesis is that of no serial correlation at lag order h.

### Table 6 — Test statistics for the cointegrating rank
- Euro Area (trace / λmax statistics):
  - Null r=0 vs Alt r≥1: Trace 121.739 | λmax 50.271
  - Null r≤1 vs Alt r≥2: Trace 71.469 | λmax 29.232
  - Null r≤2 vs Alt r≥3: Trace 42.237 | λmax 19.537
  - Null r≤3 vs Alt r≥4: Trace 22.700 | λmax 13.308
  - Null r≤4 vs Alt r≥5: Trace 9.392 | λmax 7.568
  - Null r≤5 vs Alt r≥6: Trace 1.824 | λmax 1.824
- United States (trace / λmax statistics):
  - Null r=0 vs Alt r≥1: Trace 95.910 | λmax 53.386
  - Null r≤1 vs Alt r≥2: Trace 42.524 | λmax 22.825
  - Null r≤2 vs Alt r≥3: Trace 19.699 | λmax 12.284
  - Null r≤3 vs Alt r≥4: Trace 7.414 | λmax 6.116
  - Null r≤4 vs Alt r≥5: Trace 1.299 | λmax 1.299
- Notes:
  - 1/ The unrestricted Var was estimated with 4 lags following the results from the lag exclusion test in Table 5. The adjusted sample is 1997M03-2005M10. * denotes rejection of the null hypothesis at 5 percent significance level.
  - 1/ The unrestricted Var was estimated with 2 lags following the results from the lag exclusion test in Table 5. The adjusted sample is 1996M12-2005M10. * denotes rejection of the null hypothesis and 5 percent significance level.

### Table 7 — Selected VECM results (Euro Area)
- Cointegrating Equation: CointEq t-statistics
  - LDEP 1.000
  - INT_CV -0.035 [ 1.328 ]
  - INT_EU 0.060 [ -1.351 ]
  - LCPI_CV 0.164 [ -0.192 ]
  - LCPI_EU 2.455 [ -0.944 ]
  - LWA_EU 6.773 [ -2.560 ]
  - C 35.999
- Estimates of the speed of adjustment of emigrant deposits:
  - CointEq1 -0.041 [ -3.401 ]
- Estimate of the effect of the change in the exchange rate peg on ED:
  - DUMDEV -0.006 [ -2.406 ]
- Goodness-of-fit / diagnostics:
  - R-squared 0.889
  - Sum sq. resids 0.843
  - S.E. equation 0.009
  - F-statistic 19.421

### Table 8 — Selected VECM results (United States)
- Cointegrating Equation: CointEq t-statistics
  - LDEP 1.000
  - INT_CV -0.019 [ 1.817 ]
  - INT_US -0.040 [ 5.723 ]
  - LCPI_CV -2.544 [ 5.680 ]
  - LWA_US 5.934 [ -22.012 ]
  - C (constant not reported in excerpt)
- Estimates of the speed of adjustment of emigrant deposits:
  - CointEq1 -0.153 [ -3.591 ]
- Estimate of the effect of the change in the exchange rate peg on ED:
  - DUMDEV -0.016 [ -3.795 ]
- Goodness-of-fit / diagnostics:
  - R-squared 0.750
  - Sum sq. resids 0.638
  - S.E. equation 0.013
  - F-statistic 6.670

*Source: _wp06132 - introduction of the euro the CPI for Germany is used to splice the series.*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp06132.pdf_
