## 1. Current Account and External Vulnerabilities

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [1. Current Account and External Vulnerabilities](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp06261.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp06261.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp06261.pdf.json)

---

### I. Introduction
- Growth and unemployment in a small open economy like the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia depend on improving export performance.
- Improving export performance helps preserve macroeconomic stability by closing the current account gap to avoid losing reserves and to contain the growth of external debt.
- Competitiveness concepts:
  - Price competitiveness: associated with the level of the real exchange rate that ensures both internal and external balance (fundamental equilibrium exchange rate, FEER).
  - Structural competitiveness: related to the productivity of the economy in the long run.
- Paper organization:
  - Section II: trends in the current account balance and external vulnerabilities.
  - Section III: export performance.
  - Section IV: approaches to estimate the equilibrium real exchange rate and assess competitiveness.
  - Section V: conclusions.

### II. Current Account Balance and External Vulnerabilities
- Findings:
  - During 1995-2004, the current account deficit averaged 6.3 percent of GDP.
  - In the first half of 1995-2004 the average trade deficit was close to 13 percent of GDP; in the second half the trade balance deteriorated to 19 percent of GDP.
  - During 2000-04:
    - Exports increased by 4 percent of GDP.
    - Imports increased by almost 10 percent of GDP.
  - In 2005, the current account deficit fell sharply to 1.3 percent of GDP despite:
    - a 40 percent increase in private transfers, and
    - higher oil prices.
  - The strong, broad-based export growth and moderation in import growth in 2005 suggest an improvement in competitiveness.
- External vulnerabilities and reserves:
  - Large current account deficits over the past ten years increased external vulnerabilities, though external debt levels remain manageable.
  - The political crisis of 2001 dried up external financing, causing a steady decline in the reserve coverage ratio.
  - Capital inflows recovered from 2004 onward; the decline in the coverage ratio was reversed only in 2005 due to the sizable improvement in the current account deficit.
- Key statistics and indicators:
  - Current account deficit average 1995-2004: 6.3 percent of GDP.
  - Trade balance deterioration to 19 percent of GDP (second half).
  - Exports +4 percent of GDP (2000-04); Imports + almost 10 percent of GDP (2000-04).
  - Current account deficit 2005: 1.3 percent of GDP.
  - Private transfers increased 40 percent in 2005.

### III. Export Performance
- Historical trends and sectoral composition:
  - Political crisis of 2001 worsened export performance and growth.
  - During 1995-2000 average growth of exports: 9.5 percent, raising exports/GDP from 32 percent to 46 percent.
  - The 2001 crisis caused a severe contraction in output and exports lasting until 2004; only in 2005 did export share of GDP return to pre-crisis level.
- Sector drivers and concentration:
  - Macedonian exports are highly concentrated: iron and steel, textiles, and food, beverages and tobacco account for about 60 percent of total exports.
  - During the 2001 crisis exports fell in all sectors except textiles.
  - Recovery drivers:
    - Reopening of a large steel factory in 2004.
    - Removal of protectionist barriers in Serbia to imports of certain refined oil products in 2005.
  - Exports of iron and steel and "other" exports are main drivers of recent improvement.
- Market share dynamics:
  - Unlike most other countries in the region, FYR Macedonia has lost market share in world imports since 1995, especially in the US market.
  - Improvement since 2004, but export shares have yet to reach 1995 levels.
- Manufacturing specialization and competitiveness:
  - Analysis of 15 largest manufacturing sectors (accounting for 80 percent of Macedonian manufacturing exports in 2005) shows:
    - FYR Macedonia’s export share has increased in most of the main manufacturing sectors in which the economy is specialized.
    - However, many of these sectors have declining shares in world manufacturing trade.
    - Consequently, FYR Macedonia’s exports declined as a share of world exports due to specialization in sectors with falling global demand.
- Key statistics:
  - Average export growth 1995-2000: 9.5 percent.
  - Exports/GDP rose from 32 percent to 46 percent (1995-2000).
  - Top manufacturing sectors accounted for 80 percent of Macedonian manufacturing exports in 2005.
  - Sector concentration: ~60 percent of exports in iron and steel, textiles, food/beverages/tobacco.

### IV. Assessing Competitiveness
A. Indicators of Wage and Cost Competitiveness
- Wage comparisons:
  - Wage costs in Macedonia are twice as high as in Bulgaria.
  - Wage costs in Macedonia are about 40 percent higher than in Serbia.
  - Only Croatia has higher wage costs than FYR Macedonia.
- REER and ULC:
  - Price competitiveness has improved in the last decade.
  - The 1997 devaluation caused a sharp real depreciation but did not noticeably affect the average current account deficit nor stop the decline in export shares.
  - Real exchange rate appreciated after devaluation primarily due to substantial depreciation of the Serbian dinar.
  - The unit labor cost (ULC) measure of the real exchange rate shows considerable improvement because productivity gains in manufacturing outpaced wage increases.

B. FEER (Macroeconomic Balance) Estimates of Equilibrium REER
- Methodology:
  - FEER defined as the exchange rate that equates the current account to the structural savings/investment balance in the medium term.
  - Three steps: estimate underlying current account; estimate structural current account; calculate exchange rate bringing underlying to structural current account.
  - Underlying current account estimated using Isard and others (2001) export/import volume equations.
- Underlying current account estimates (Table 1 figures):
  - Current Account Balance (2005): -1.3 -1.3
  - Adjustments: 1.3 -1.7
  - Private Transfers: 0.0 -3.0
  - Trade Response to Output Gaps: -1.8 -1.8
  - Trade Response to past REER depreciation: 3.1 3.1
  - Underlying Current Account: 0.0 -3.1
- Structural current account:
  - Estimated using Chinn and Hito (2005) panel equation for developing countries (excluding Africa).
  - Selected coefficients from Table 2:
    - Government budget balance (share of GDP): 0.22 [0.08]***
    - NFA as share of GDP: 0.06 [0.08]***
    - Relative income: -0.01 [0.07]
    - Relative dependency ratio (young): -0.03 [0.014]**
    - Constant: -0.03 [0.02]*
  - Substituting FYR Macedonia values yields structural current account ≈ -2 percent of GDP.
- FEER implication:
  - To bring the underlying current account in line with the structural current account the real exchange rate would have to depreciate at most by 4 percent.
  - Since 4 percent is modest and within margin of error, the REER is broadly in line with fundamentals.

C. BEER / VECM Estimates of the Equilibrium REER
- Theoretical determinants included:
  - Net foreign assets (NFA) to GDP.
  - Relative productivity (Balassa-Samuelson effect).
  - Trade openness.
  - Fiscal stance (government consumption).
  - Terms of trade.
  - Real interest rate differentials.
- Empirical implementation:
  - Vector error correction model (VECM) with Johansen maximum likelihood to estimate cointegration between REER and fundamentals.
  - Data limitations: many variables available only since 1998; cointegration tests found at least one cointegration relationship.
- Preferred specification results (selected from Table 3):
  - Cointegrating vector coefficients (1995q3-2005q4 / 1998q3-2005q4):
    - FISC(-1): 0.02 / 0.01 (t-stats [-5.3] [-4.6])
    - RGDPPC(-1): 2.74 / 1.98 (t-stats [-9.3] [-7.6])
    - OPEN(-1): -0.01 / 0.00 (t-stats [8.4] [5.7])
    - Constant C: 3.68 / 4.02
  - Error correction α: -0.29 / -0.41 (t-stats [-2.4] [-2.4])
- Findings from VECM estimates:
  - Terms of trade and NFA were not significant determinants in preferred specifications; eliminated to preserve degrees of freedom.
  - Increased openness, decline in government consumption, and movements in relative productivity explain the trend decline in the REER.
  - If relative productivity had remained at 1994 levels, the equilibrium REER would be now 15 percent higher than the current estimated value.
  - Fiscal consolidation and increase in openness have depreciated the equilibrium REER by 3 percent and 2.5 percent respectively.
  - The 1997 devaluation created a real undervaluation; subsequent appreciation raised REER above equilibrium during 2000-01.
  - During 2002-04 REER is broadly in equilibrium; by end-2005 REER is slightly undervalued.

D. Structural Competitiveness (Survey-Based Indicators)
- World Bank Doing Business (2005) rankings indicate difficulties relative to regional peers in:
  - Starting a business, dealing with licenses, enforcing contracts, hiring and firing workers, registering property, protecting investors, paying taxes, trading across borders, and closing a business.
- World Economic Forum Global Competitiveness Index (Table 5) places FYR Macedonia among the less competitive countries in the region (comparisons 2003 vs 2005).
- Structural problem summary:
  - Macedonian manufacturers have maintained or increased market share within the sectors they specialize in.
  - Specialization in low value-added sectors with declining global shares has led to overall export share decline.
  - Structural reforms undertaken have yet to yield meaningful improvements in competitiveness rankings.

### V. Conclusions and Policy Implications
- Main conclusions:
  - Price competitiveness is broadly appropriate at present; REER has depreciated steadily and the Macedonian price level is low compared with countries with similar incomes.
  - Estimating the equilibrium real exchange rate is challenging, but staff estimates indicate the exchange rate is broadly in line with macroeconomic fundamentals.
  - Direct wage comparisons suggest a cost competitiveness problem, although data heterogeneity complicates comparisons.
  - Macedonian manufacturers have largely maintained or increased export shares within specialized sectors; however, specialization in sectors with low value added and declining global demand has reduced total export share—indicating structural competitiveness problems.
  - Contrary to most transition economies, productivity in FYR Macedonia declined vis-à-vis trading partners in the past decade, though this trend has started to reverse recently.
- Policy implications and recommendations:
  - Short-term export improvement could be aided by a more competitive exchange rate, but sustained improvement requires:
    - Enhanced productivity.
    - Resource reallocation to more dynamic, higher value-added sectors.
  - Achieving structural transformation depends on reforms to improve the business environment:
    - Attracting foreign direct investment and boosting domestic private investment are key to necessary economic transformation.
    - Successful implementation of structural reforms to improve the business environment is crucial to boost investment and competitiveness.

*Source: IMF staff working paper (content unit: _wp06261 - References).*

### 1. Current Account and External Vulnerabilities............................................................. 4

### 1. Current Account and External Vulnerabilities............................................................. 4

### Major sections (by heading)
- 1. Current Account and External Vulnerabilities............................................................. 4
- 2. Export Growth and Exports, 1995-2002 ...................................................................... 5
- 3. Export Market Shares .................................................................................................. 6
- 4. Share of Manufacturing Exports .................................................................................. 7
- 5. Wage Costs in Manufacturing, 2005 ........................................................................... 7
- 6. Exchange Rate Indicators, 1995-2006 ......................................................................... 8
- 7. Selected Countries: Exchange Rates and Relative GDP 2003 & 2005 ....................... 9
- 8.         REER and its Long-Run Determinants...................................................................... 14
- 9. Econometric Estimates of the Equilibrium REER..................................................... 17

### Tables listed
- Table 1. Estimation of the Underlying Current Account ......................................................... 10
- Table 2. Estimation of the Structural Current Account ........................................................... 11
- Table 3.         REER         VECM         Estimates ............................................................................................ 16
- Table 4. Selected Countries Rankings in the Business Environment Database (2005) ........... 18
- Table 5.         Global         Competitiveness         Index ................................................................................... 18

*Source: _wp06261 - 1. Current Account and External Vulnerabilities............................................................. 4*

### References      ........................................................................................................

### _wp06261 - References

### I. INTRODUCTION
- Sustaining faster growth and reducing unemployment in a small open economy like the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia depends on improving export performance.
- Improving export performance can help preserve macroeconomic stability by closing the current account gap to avoid losing reserves and to contain the growth of external debt.
- Competitiveness concepts:
  - Price competitiveness: associated with the level of the real exchange rate that ensures both internal and external balance (fundamental equilibrium exchange rate, FEER).
  - Structural competitiveness: related to the productivity of the economy in the long run.
- Paper organization:
  - Section II: trends in the current account balance and external vulnerabilities.
  - Section III: export performance.
  - Section IV: approaches to estimate the equilibrium real exchange rate and assess competitiveness.
  - Section V: conclusions.

### II. CURRENT ACCOUNT BALANCE AND EXTERNAL VULNERABILITIES
Findings:
- During 1995-2004, the current account deficit averaged 6.3 percent of GDP.
- In the first half of 1995-2004 the average trade deficit was close to 13 percent of GDP; in the second half the trade balance deteriorated to 19 percent of GDP.
- During 2000-04:
  - Exports increased by 4 percent of GDP.
  - Imports increased by almost 10 percent of GDP.
- In 2005, the current account deficit fell sharply to 1.3 percent of GDP despite:
  - a 40 percent increase in private transfers, and
  - higher oil prices.
- The strong, broad-based export growth and moderation in import growth in 2005 suggest an improvement in competitiveness.

External vulnerabilities and reserves:
- Large current account deficits over the past ten years increased external vulnerabilities, though external debt levels remain manageable.
- The political crisis of 2001 dried up external financing, causing a steady decline in the reserve coverage ratio.
- Capital inflows recovered from 2004 onward; the decline in the coverage ratio was reversed only in 2005 due to the sizable improvement in the current account deficit.

Key statistics and indicators mentioned:
- Current account deficit average 1995-2004: 6.3 percent of GDP.
- Trade balance deterioration to 19 percent of GDP (second half).
- Exports +4 percent of GDP (2000-04); Imports + almost 10 percent of GDP (2000-04).
- Current account deficit 2005: 1.3 percent of GDP.
- Private transfers increased 40 percent in 2005.

### III. EXPORT PERFORMANCE
Historical trends and sectoral composition:
- Political crisis of 2001 worsened export performance and growth.
- During 1995-2000 average growth of exports: 9.5 percent, raising exports/GDP from 32 to 46 percent.
- The 2001 crisis caused a severe contraction in output and exports lasting until 2004; only in 2005 did export share of GDP return to pre-crisis level.

Sector drivers and concentration:
- Macedonian exports are highly concentrated: iron and steel, textiles, and food, beverages and tobacco account for about 60 percent of total exports.
- During the 2001 crisis exports fell in all sectors except textiles.
- Recovery drivers:
  - Reopening of a large steel factory in 2004.
  - Removal of protectionist barriers in Serbia to imports of certain refined oil products in 2005.
- Exports of iron and steel and "other" exports are main drivers of recent improvement.

Market share dynamics:
- Unlike most other countries in the region, FYR Macedonia has lost market share in world imports since 1995, especially in the US market.
- Improvement since 2004, but export shares have yet to reach 1995 levels.

Manufacturing specialization and competitiveness:
- Analysis of 15 largest manufacturing sectors (accounting for 80 percent of Macedonian manufacturing exports in 2005) shows:
  - FYR Macedonia’s export share has increased in most of the main manufacturing sectors in which the economy is specialized.
  - However, many of these sectors have declining shares in world manufacturing trade.
  - Consequently, FYR Macedonia’s exports declined as a share of world exports due to specialization in sectors with falling global demand.

Key statistics:
- Average export growth 1995-2000: 9.5 percent.
- Exports/GDP rose from 32 percent to 46 percent (1995-2000).
- Top manufacturing sectors accounted for 80 percent of Macedonian manufacturing exports in 2005.
- Sector concentration: ~60 percent of exports in iron and steel, textiles, food/beverages/tobacco.

### IV. ASSESSING COMPETITIVENESS

A. Indicators of Wage and Cost Competitiveness
- Wage costs in manufacturing are higher in FYR Macedonia than in other Balkan countries:
  - Wage costs in Macedonia are twice as high as in Bulgaria.
  - About 40 percent higher than in Serbia.
  - Only Croatia has higher wage costs than FYR Macedonia.
- Real effective exchange rate (REER) indicators:
  - Price competitiveness has improved in the last decade.
  - The 1997 devaluation caused a sharp real depreciation but did not noticeably affect the average current account deficit nor stop the decline in export shares.
  - Real exchange rate appreciated after devaluation primarily due to substantial depreciation of the Serbian dinar.
  - The unit labor cost (ULC) measure of the real exchange rate shows considerable improvement because productivity gains in manufacturing outpaced wage increases.

B. Estimates of the Equilibrium Real Effective Exchange Rate (EREER)
Methodologies used:
- Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) approach:
  - Indicates the exchange rate is undervalued relative to its PPP level; the PPP-based exchange rate index (domestic price level / international prices) is currently below predicted given FYR Macedonia’s relative income.
- Macroeconomic balance approach (FEER):
  - FEER defined as the exchange rate that equates the current account to the structural savings/investment balance in the medium term.
  - Three steps: estimate underlying current account; estimate structural current account; calculate exchange rate bringing underlying to structural current account.
  - Underlying current account estimated using Isard and others (2001) export/import volume equations.
  - Estimated Macedonian underlying current account ranges between 0 and -3.1 percent, depending on treatment of private transfers.
    - Table 1 figures:
      - Current Account Balance (2005): -1.3 -1.3
      - Adjustments: 1.3 -1.7
      - Private Transfers: 0.0 -3.0
      - Trade Response to Output Gaps: -1.8 -1.8
      - Trade Response to past REER depreciation: 3.1 3.1
      - Underlying Current Account: 0.0 -3.1
  - Structural current account estimated using Chinn and Hito (2005) panel equation for developing countries (excluding Africa).
    - Table 2 coefficients (selected):
      - Government budget balance (share of GDP): 0.22 [0.08]***
      - NFA as share of GDP: 0.06 [0.08]***
      - Relative income: -0.01 [0.07]
      - Relative dependency ratio (young): -0.03 [0.014]**
      - Constant: -0.03 [0.02]*
      - Time dummies and other variables included; significance indicated by *, **, ***.
    - Substituting FYR Macedonia values yields structural current account ≈ -2 percent of GDP.
  - FEER implication:
    - To bring the underlying current account in line with the structural current account the real exchange rate would have to depreciate at most by 4 percent.
    - Since 4 percent is modest and within margin of error, the REER is broadly in line with fundamentals.

- Behavioral Equilibrium Exchange Rate (BEER) approach:
  - Framework based on real interest rate parity with change in real exchange rate equal to real interest rate differential plus risk premium.
  - Long-run determinants considered:
    - Net foreign assets (NFA) to GDP: higher NFA → more appreciated currency.
    - Relative productivity (Balassa-Samuelson effect): productivity gains in tradables → higher nontradable prices → appreciation.
    - Trade openness: more openness → lower price of tradables → depreciation.
    - Fiscal stance (government consumption): higher government expenditure → appreciation.
    - Terms of trade: ambiguous; wealth effect tends to appreciate, substitution effect can offset.
    - Real interest rate differentials: capture aggregate demand, productivity, and monetary policy effects; tend to appreciate currency when higher.
  - Empirical implementation:
    - Vector error correction model (VECM) with Johansen maximum likelihood to estimate cointegration between REER and fundamentals.
    - Data limitations: many variables available only since 1998; cointegration tests found at least one cointegration relationship.
    - Preferred specification results (Table 3):
      - Cointegrating vector coefficients (1995q3-2005q4 / 1998q3-2005q4):
        - FISC(-1): 0.02 / 0.01 (t-stats [-5.3] [-4.6])
        - RGDPPC(-1): 2.74 / 1.98 (t-stats [-9.3] [-7.6])
        - OPEN(-1): -0.01 / 0.00 (t-stats [8.4] [5.7])
        - Constant C: 3.68 / 4.02
      - Error correction α: -0.29 / -0.41 (t-stats [-2.4] [-2.4])
      - Short-run dynamics: selected coefficients reported with t-statistics.
    - Findings from VECM estimates:
      - Terms of trade and NFA were not significant determinants in preferred specifications; eliminated to preserve degrees of freedom.
      - Increased openness, decline in government consumption, and movements in relative productivity explain the trend decline in the REER.
      - If relative productivity had remained at 1994 levels, the equilibrium REER would be now 15 percent higher than the current estimated value.
      - Fiscal consolidation and increase in openness have depreciated the equilibrium REER by 3 percent and 2.5 percent respectively.
      - The 1997 devaluation created a real undervaluation; subsequent appreciation raised REER above equilibrium during 2000-01.
      - During 2002-04 REER is broadly in equilibrium; by end-2005 REER is slightly undervalued.

C. Structural Competitiveness
- Despite broadly appropriate price competitiveness, survey-based indicators reveal structural impediments:
  - World Bank Doing Business rankings (2005) show difficulties relative to regional peers in:
    - Starting a business, dealing with licenses, enforcing contracts, hiring and firing workers, registering property, protecting investors, paying taxes, trading across borders, and closing a business.
  - Selected rankings (Table 4) show FYR Macedonia doing poorly in several categories compared with Bulgaria, Romania, Croatia, Serbia, and others.
  - World Economic Forum Global Competitiveness Index (Table 5) places FYR Macedonia among the less competitive countries in the region (ranking comparisons 2003 vs 2005).
- Structural problem summary:
  - Macedonian manufacturers have maintained or increased market share within the sectors they specialize in.
  - However, specialization in low value-added sectors with declining global shares has led to overall export share decline.
  - Structural reforms undertaken have yet to yield meaningful improvements in competitiveness rankings.

### V. CONCLUSIONS AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS
Main conclusions:
- Price competitiveness is broadly appropriate at present; REER has depreciated steadily and the Macedonian price level is low compared with countries with similar incomes.
- Estimating the equilibrium real exchange rate is challenging, but staff estimates indicate the exchange rate is broadly in line with macroeconomic fundamentals.
- Direct wage comparisons suggest a cost competitiveness problem, although data heterogeneity complicates comparisons.
- Macedonian manufacturers have largely maintained or increased export shares within specialized sectors; however, specialization in sectors with low value added and declining global demand has reduced total export share—indicating structural competitiveness problems.
- Contrary to most transition economies, productivity in FYR Macedonia declined vis-à-vis trading partners in the past decade, though this trend has started to reverse recently.

Policy implications and recommendations:
- Short-term export improvement could be aided by a more competitive exchange rate, but sustained improvement requires:
  - Enhanced productivity.
  - Resource reallocation to more dynamic, higher value-added sectors.
- Achieving structural transformation depends on reforms to improve the business environment:
  - Attracting foreign direct investment and boosting domestic private investment are key to necessary economic transformation.
  - Successful implementation of structural reforms to improve the business environment is crucial to boost investment and competitiveness.

*Source: IMF staff working paper (content unit: _wp06261 - References).*

### References

### _wp06261 - References

### References

- Burgess, Robert, Stefania Fabrizio, and Yuan Xaio, 2004, “The Baltics. Competitiveness on the Eve of EU Accession,” (Washington: International Monetary Fund).  
- Cashin, Paul, Luis Cespedes, and Ratna Sahay, 2002, “Keynes, Cocoa, and Copper: In Search of Commodity Currencies,” Working Paper 02/223 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).  
- Clark, Peter, and Ronald MacDonald, 1999, “Exchange Rates and Economic Fundamentals: A Methodological Comparison of Beers and Feers,” in J. Stein and R. MacDonald (eds.) Equilibrium Exchange Rates (Kluwer: Boston), pp. 285-322.  
- Chinn, Menzie and Iro Hito, 2005, “Current Account Balances, Financial Development, and Institutions: Assaying the World’s “Savings Glut,” NBER WP 11761.  
- Cheung, Yin-Wong, Menzie Chinn, and Antonio García Pascual, 2002, “Empirical Exchange Rate Models of the Nineties: Are Any Fit to Survive?,” NBER Working Paper 9393.  
- Garcia Pascual, Antonio, 2003, “Assessing the Equilibrium Real Effective Exchange Rate: The Case of Bolivia,” mimeo, IMF.  
- Isard, Peter, Hamid Faruqee, Russell Kincaid, and Martin Fetherston, 2001, “Methodology for Current Account and Exchange Rate Assessments,” Occasional Paper 209 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).  
- Lane, Philip, and Gian-Maria Milesi-Ferretti, 2000, “The Transfer Problem Revisited: Net Foreign Assets and Real Exchange Rates,” Working Paper 00/12 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).  
- Lane, Philip, and Gian-Maria Milesi-Ferretti, 2006, “The External Wealth of Nations Mark II: Revised and Extended estimations of Net Foreign Assets and Liabilities 1970-2004,” Working Paper 06/69 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).  
- Loko, Boileau, and Tuladhar, Anita, 2005, “Labor Productivity and Real Exchange Rate: The Balassa-Samuelson Disconnect in the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”, Working Paper 05/113 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).  
- MacDonald, Ronald, and Luca Ricci, 2003, “Estimation of the Equilibrium Exchange Rate for South Africa,” Working Paper 03/44 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).  
- 21  
  MacDonald, Ronald, and Jerome Stein, 1999, Equilibrium Exchange Rates, Boston, MA; Kluwer Academics.  
- Pavia, Claudio, 2001, “Competitiveness and the Equilibrium Exchange Rate in Costa Rica,” Working Paper 01/23 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).  

*Source: _wp06261 - References*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp06261.pdf_
