## _wp0650 - References..............................................................................................................

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp0650 - References..............................................................................................................](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0650.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0650.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0650.pdf.json)

---

### I. INTRODUCTION
- Developing countries typically rely on exports of primary commodities and goods low in the production chain and are highly vulnerable to frequent and persistent shocks affecting these industries.
- Paper objective: examine the relationship between economic integration, sectoral diversification, and macroeconomic stability in developing economies using a two-country, three-sector model with nominal wage rigidity and trade barriers.
- Model features:
  - One primary sector, X, and two nonprimary sectors, A and B, symmetric except for trade barriers.
  - Home and foreign primary goods are perfect substitutes; nonprimary goods are differentiated by origin.
  - Monetary policy is designed to replicate the outcome under perfectly flexible prices and wages.
- Core qualitative results:
  - Lower trade barriers on primary goods increase the impact of primary shocks on aggregate real variables and the exchange rate.
  - Lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods reduce the impact of primary shocks.
  - Lower trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods enhance exchange rate stability but increase volatility of aggregate real variables.
  - Diversification effects are ambiguous:
    - Reducing the relative size of the primary sector reduces volatility from primary shocks.
    - Allocating resources equally between the two nonprimary sectors may be counterproductive.
    - Investment in, or shifting resources to, the nonprimary sector that is more integrated with the rest of the world unambiguously enhances macroeconomic stability.
- Relation to prior work:
  - Extends Srour (2004) by characterizing integration directly as a decline in trade barriers and allowing prices to differ across countries due to trade barriers.
  - Focuses on goods market integration within the new Open-Economy literature (Obstfeld and Rogoff (1995, 1996); Betts and Devereux (1996)).

### II. THE BASELINE MODEL
- Economy: home country 0 trades with rest of world 1.
- Sectors: primary X (oil or primary commodities, agriculture, textiles) and two nonprimary sectors A and B.
- Preferences and consumption aggregates:
  - Household utility function includes hours L, real money balances M/P, consumption of primary goods X_C, and consumption of nonprimary goods li_C (l = 0,1; i = A,B).
  - Elasticity of substitution η between domestic and foreign nonprimary goods ≥ elasticity across sectors (= 1).
  - Money enters utility with weight χ (results hold if χ → 0).
- Household budget constraint (local currency):
  - 1X X l i li li PC PC M RT M − ++ = + Π ++ (notation preserved as in source)
  - Π denotes dividends, 1M − initial stock of money balances, T lump-sum transfers, X P and li P prices, R labor income.
- First-order conditions (identities preserved from source):
  - iii PCPCγ =, (, , iXAB =)
  - 1 li lililii i P PCPC P η γ − ⎛⎞ = ⎜⎟ ⎝⎠, (0,1l =,,iAB=)
  - M C P σ χ =
- Price indices (preserved):
  - 1 11 1 0011iii PP P ηη ηη γγ −− − ⎡⎤ = + ⎣⎦, (, iAB =)
  - XAB XAB PPPP γγγ =
- Production:
  - Continuum of differentiated labor types; firm output-labor relation: 1 1 1 ii Y L α α − = − , 0 1 α ≤ <1
  - Labor aggregation: 1 1 1 0 () ii L lj dj λ λ λ λ − − ⎛⎞ = ⎜⎟ ⎝⎠ ∫ , 1 λ ≥
  - Labor demand (profit maximization) examples:
    - 1 X X X P L W α ⎡⎤ = ⎢⎥ ⎣⎦
    - 1 0 A A A P L W α ⎡⎤ = ⎢⎥ ⎣⎦
    - analogous for sector B and wage-index definitions preserved.
- Wage setting (flexible wages in baseline):
  - Wj Cj lj P σ φ λ λ = − ()

### III. EQUILIBRIUM
- Symmetric equilibrium: all firms in a sector identical; households earn same wage W, supply same labor L, consume same basket C.
- Market clearing conditions (symbols preserved):
  - X XAABB LnL nL nL = ++,
  - 00 XXX A AAB BB PCn P Yn P Yn P Y = ++,
  - Substitutions lead to expressions:
    - 1 P L W α ⎡⎤ = Ω ⎢⎥ ⎣⎦
    - 1 1 1 P C W α α α − ⎡⎤ = Ω ⎢⎥ − ⎣⎦
    - (1) expressions relating W, P, C, L, M, and Ω as in source.
- Key observation: macro variables behavior governed by Ω alone.
  - First-order approximation preserved:
    - ()() 00110011 ˆ ˆˆˆ ˆˆ XXA AAAB BBB ppp ppαα α α Ω = + − + − , where hats denote log-deviations, X α is share of exports of primary goods in total income, 0i α and 1i α (i = A,B) are shares of exports and imports of nonprimary goods.

### IV. ECONOMIC INTEGRATION AND DIVERSIFICATION
- Price determination assumption:
  - Market prices abroad equal in long run; law of one price may not hold domestically due to trade barriers T independent of shocks.
  - Formal price relations preserved:
    - (1) f XXX sPPT = +
    - (1) f lili li sPPT = + , (0,1 l =, , iAB =)
  - s is nominal exchange rate (price of a unit of domestic currency in foreign currency); f superscripts denote world market prices in foreign currency; T’s represent trade barriers (positive if associated with foreign goods).
- Steady-state Ω expression preserved (indexes T defined in source).
- General steady-state insight:
  - Lower trade barriers → better terms of trade → higher Ω → higher steady-state consumption and real wages.
  - But lower trade barriers may heighten volatility.

A. All Prices Exogenously Given
- Scenario: world prices of all goods (including domestic nonprimary goods) exogenously given and subject to sector-wide uncorrelated shocks.
- Effect of a drop in world primary price:
  - Drop in income from primary exports → drop in real wages and aggregate consumption.
  - Lower labor cost → output and employment in nonprimary sectors increase, partially offsetting the shock.
- Comparative statics:
  - Larger X α (less diversified) and lower trade barriers in primary sector increase share X α and amplify the impact of primary shocks on Ω, income, and real wages, raising volatility.
  - Lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods lower X α and curb volatility from primary shocks by changing relative income shares.
  - Trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods do not affect volatility from primary shocks in this scenario.
  - Allocation between nonprimary sectors has no effect if same barriers apply to both.

B. Prices of Domestic Nonprimary Goods Endogenous
- Foreign demand for domestic nonprimary goods (preserved):
  - 0 00 f flevel f i ii ff ii P P Cv PP η − ⎛⎞ ⎛⎞ = ⎜⎟ ⎜⎟ ⎝⎠ ⎝⎠ , ( , iAB = )
  - 0i v denotes steady-state volume of exports in sector i; flevel P is exogenously given foreign price level.
  - Foreign demand is more price-elastic than domestic demand.
- Equilibrium condition preserved: 00 f iiii CC nY += , (i = A,B)
- Result: ˆ Ω = Κ ˆ f X p , where Κ depends on model parameters; larger Κ → larger volatility from primary shocks.
- Key formal results (preserved wording):
  1. As in the exogenous case, diversification via a relatively smaller primary sector lowers volatility from primary shocks, whereas lower trade barriers in that sector increases volatility.
     - A smaller primary sector or higher trade barriers implies a relatively smaller volume of trade in that sector; from ˆ Ω expressions (e.g., 0000 ˆ ˆˆ ˆ ff f XXAABB ppp αα α α Ω = ++), shifting size from X α to 0A α or 0B α lowers volatility because 0 ˆ f A p and 0 ˆ f B p vary less than ˆ f X p following a primary shock.
  2. All else equal between the two nonprimary sectors, aggregate variables are less volatile when resources (firms) are concentrated in one nonprimary sector.
     - Numerically, Κ is largest when the two nonprimary sectors have equal size and decreases as one grows relatively larger. Rationale: the larger nonprimary sector exports a larger share of output; because exports are more price-elastic, firms in that sector lower prices by relatively less to sell more output, leading to trade income being less affected by primary shocks.
  3. Lower trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods increase volatility, whereas lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods lower volatility.
     - Mechanisms:
       - Lower trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods → lower domestic consumption of domestic nonprimary goods → higher volume of exports → prices of domestic nonprimary goods less sensitive to primary shocks. Two opposing effects on volatility: smaller price sensitivity reduces impact on income, but larger export volume raises impact on income; the latter dominates.
       - Lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods produce similar effects on price elasticity and export volume but also raise total income and reduce the share of primary exports, an offset that leads to lower volatility.

### Effects of resource shifts on volatility
- A shift of resources to the nonprimary sector with lower (higher) trade barriers on either type of nonprimary goods unambiguously lowers (raises) volatility in the economy.
- Mechanism:
  - A shift of resources to one sector increases the share of exports in that sector and makes prices in that sector less sensitive to primary shocks, while having the opposite effect on the other sector.
  - Since the sector with lower trade barriers has a bigger share of exports to begin with, the impact of primary shocks on income decreases if resources are shifted to that sector, and increases in the opposite case.
- Transitional dynamics:
  - If resources were initially concentrated in the sector with higher trade barriers, volatility may deteriorate before it improves as capital is reallocated to the sector with lower barriers. (Numerically, K traces a bell shape.)

### Rigid wages — setup and implications
- Setup:
  - Wages are assumed fixed at the beginning of the period, before shocks are realized. Money is not neutral; the amount of money supplied ex post affects the markup of prices over wages, PW, and hence labor and consumption.
  - Maximization of expected utility implies the wage of a household is given by the expression shown in the source (W predetermined, E is the expectation operator).
- Equilibrium and monetary policy role:
  - Equilibrium conditions lead to the same expressions for L, C, and M/P in terms of Ω and PW as in Section III, but with W predetermined.
  - The equilibrium outcome depends on the choice of monetary policy. Policymakers are assumed to choose a monetary policy rule that approximates the outcome under flexible wages.
- Condition for monetary policy to reproduce flexible-wage outcomes (preserved):
  - It suffices that monetary policy reproduces the level of real wages, i.e., the equality appearing in the source:
    - ()
      1 11
      W
      P
      ασα
      αφσ
      λ
      αλ
      Θ
      +
      ⎛⎞ ⎛  ⎞⎛  ⎞
      =Ω
      ⎜⎟ ⎜  ⎟⎜  ⎟
      −−
      ⎝⎠ ⎝  ⎠⎝  ⎠
  - A money-supply rule that achieves this (as given in the Appendix) can be written in log-deviations as:
    - (1) ˆ ˆ m αφσ− =Ω Θ
  - Equivalently, since ˆˆˆ XX ppw = − and ˆˆ ˆ f XX sp p = −, an exchange rate policy rule reproducing flexible-wage outcomes can be written as:
    - () ˆˆ ˆˆ f XX sp wp = + −
  - Substituting equilibrium expressions when wages are flexible, the exchange rate policy rule takes the form:
    - ˆˆ f X sp = Η
      - Η is a positive coefficient that depends on the model’s parameters and can be examined numerically.
- Interpretation of the exchange-rate response:
  - Because the home country is assumed a net exporter of primary goods, the policy rule calls for a depreciation of the local currency following a negative primary shock to raise the price level and achieve the downward adjustment in real wages that would occur under flexible wages.
  - The smaller the drop in the markup of prices over wages in the primary sector (i.e., the more wages would adjust downward if flexible), the larger the needed exchange rate depreciation under nominal wage rigidity.
  - The larger the impact on prices and the larger the impact on real wages, the larger the needed exchange rate depreciation.

### Comparative statics and quantitative claims (rigid-wage case)
- 1. The larger the relative size and the lower the trade barriers in the primary sector, the greater the required adjustments in the exchange rate following primary shocks, and the greater the need for a flexible exchange rate.
- 2. Whether a greater concentration of resources in one nonprimary sector calls for a more or less flexible exchange rate depends on the model’s parameters.
  - Ambiguity: greater concentration reduces the impact of primary shocks on real wages but accentuates the impact on prices.
  - Footnote example: For example, a higher concentration of resources in one sector typically increases the volatility of the exchange rate if 1σ<.
- 3. Lower trade barriers on domestic or foreign nonprimary goods lower exchange rate volatility.
  - Domestic nonprimary goods: lower trade barriers reduce the impact of primary shocks on real wages (if wages were flexible) as well as prices.
  - Foreign nonprimary goods: lower trade barriers have opposite effects on real wages and prices. The claim is shown numerically (and can be shown algebraically for 1σ<).
- 4. A shift of resources to the nonprimary sector with lower (higher) trade barriers on either domestic or foreign nonprimary goods unambiguously lowers (raises) exchange rate volatility.
  - Such a shift makes both real wages and prices less sensitive to primary shocks.

### CONCLUSION — policy-relevant findings and open extensions
- Main findings:
  - Lower trade barriers and diversification have ambiguous effects on macroeconomic stability:
    - Lower trade barriers on primary goods increase volatility stemming from primary shocks.
    - Lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods have the opposite (volatility-reducing) effects.
    - Lower trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods enhance exchange rate stability but increase the volatility of aggregate variables.
    - Diversification via a relatively smaller primary sector reduces volatility stemming from primary shocks.
    - Diversification as an equal distribution of resources between nonprimary sectors may be counterproductive.
  - Investment in the nonprimary sector with lower trade barriers unambiguously promotes macroeconomic stability (and income).
    - This extends results in Srour (2004) under alternative definitions of economic integration.
- Suggested extensions (policy and research):
  - Derive the welfare-optimizing monetary policy rather than assuming it is designed to reproduce the flexible-wage outcome.
  - Examine the issues in a general equilibrium two-country model.
  - Provide quantitative assessments of the effects illustrated.

*Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0650.pdf*

### References..............................................................................................................

### _wp0650 - References..............................................................................................................

### I. INTRODUCTION
- Developing countries typically rely on exports of primary commodities and goods low in the production chain and are highly vulnerable to frequent and persistent shocks affecting these industries.
- Paper objective: examine the relationship between economic integration, sectoral diversification, and macroeconomic stability in developing economies using a two-country, three-sector model with nominal wage rigidity and trade barriers.
- Model features:
  - One primary sector, X, and two nonprimary sectors, A and B, symmetric except for trade barriers.
  - Home and foreign primary goods are perfect substitutes; nonprimary goods are differentiated by origin.
  - Monetary policy is designed to replicate the outcome under perfectly flexible prices and wages.
- Core qualitative results summarized:
  - Lower trade barriers on primary goods increase the impact of primary shocks on aggregate real variables and the exchange rate.
  - Lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods reduce the impact of primary shocks.
  - Lower trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods enhance exchange rate stability but increase volatility of aggregate real variables.
  - Diversification effects are ambiguous:
    - Reducing the relative size of the primary sector reduces volatility from primary shocks.
    - Allocating resources equally between the two nonprimary sectors may be counterproductive.
    - Investment in, or shifting resources to, the nonprimary sector that is more integrated with the rest of the world unambiguously enhances macroeconomic stability.
- Relation to prior work:
  - Extends Srour (2004) by characterizing integration directly as a decline in trade barriers and allowing prices to differ across countries due to trade barriers.
  - Focuses on goods market integration within the new Open-Economy literature (Obstfeld and Rogoff (1995, 1996); Betts and Devereux (1996)).

### II. THE BASELINE MODEL
- Economy: home country 0 trades with rest of world 1.
- Sectors: primary X (oil or primary commodities, agriculture, textiles) and two nonprimary sectors A and B.
- Preferences and consumption aggregates:
  - Household utility function includes hours L, real money balances M/P, consumption of primary goods X_C, and consumption of nonprimary goods li_C (l = 0,1; i = A,B).
  - Elasticity of substitution η between domestic and foreign nonprimary goods ≥ elasticity across sectors (= 1).
  - Money enters utility with weight χ (results hold if χ → 0).
- Household budget constraint (local currency):
  - 1X X l i li li PC PC M RT M − ++ = + Π ++ (notation preserved as in source)
  - Π denotes dividends, 1M − initial stock of money balances, T lump-sum transfers, X P and li P prices, R labor income.
- First-order conditions (exact identities preserved from source):
  - iii PCPCγ =, (, , iXAB =)
  - 1 li lililii i P PCPC P η γ − ⎛⎞ = ⎜⎟ ⎝⎠, (0,1l =,,iAB=)
  - M C P σ χ =
  - Price indices:
    - 1 11 1 0011iii PP P ηη ηη γγ −− − ⎡⎤ = + ⎣⎦, (, iAB =)
    - XAB XAB PPPP γγγ =

- Production:
  - Continuum of differentiated labor types; firm output-labor relation: 1 1 1 ii Y L α α − = − , 0 1 α ≤ <1
  - Labor aggregation: 1 1 1 0 () ii L lj dj λ λ λ λ − − ⎛⎞ = ⎜⎟ ⎝⎠ ∫ , 1 λ ≥
  - Labor demand (profit maximization) examples:
    - 1 X X X P L W α ⎡⎤ = ⎢⎥ ⎣⎦
    - 1 0 A A A P L W α ⎡⎤ = ⎢⎥ ⎣⎦
    - analogous for sector B and wage-index definitions preserved.

- Wage setting (flexible wages in baseline):
  - Wj Cj lj P σ φ λ λ = − ()

### III. EQUILIBRIUM
- Symmetric equilibrium: all firms in a sector identical; households earn same wage W, supply same labor L, consume same basket C.
- Market clearing conditions:
  - X XAABB LnL nL nL = ++,
  - 00 XXX A AAB BB PCn P Yn P Yn P Y = ++,
  - Substitutions lead to expressions (symbols preserved):
    - 1 P L W α ⎡⎤ = Ω ⎢⎥ ⎣⎦
    - 1 1 1 P C W α α α − ⎡⎤ = Ω ⎢⎥ − ⎣⎦
    - (1) expressions relating W, P, C, L, M, and Ω as in source.
- Key observation: macro variables behavior governed by Ω alone.
  - First-order approximation:
    - ()() 00110011 ˆ ˆˆˆ ˆˆ XXA AAAB BBB ppp ppαα α α Ω = + − + − , where hats denote log-deviations, X α is share of exports of primary goods in total income, 0i α and 1i α (i = A,B) are shares of exports and imports of nonprimary goods.

### IV. ECONOMIC INTEGRATION AND DIVERSIFICATION
- Price determination assumption:
  - Market prices abroad equal in long run; law of one price may not hold domestically due to trade barriers T independent of shocks.
  - Formal price relations preserved:
    - (1) f XXX sPPT = +
    - (1) f lili li sPPT = + , (0,1 l =, , iAB =)
  - s is nominal exchange rate (price of a unit of domestic currency in foreign currency); f superscripts denote world market prices in foreign currency; T’s represent trade barriers (positive if associated with foreign goods).
- Steady-state Ω expression preserved (indexes T defined in source).
- General steady-state insight:
  - Lower trade barriers → better terms of trade → higher Ω → higher steady-state consumption and real wages.
  - But lower trade barriers may heighten volatility.

A. All Prices Exogenously Given
- Scenario: world prices of all goods (including domestic nonprimary goods) exogenously given and subject to sector-wide uncorrelated shocks.
- Effect of a drop in world primary price:
  - Drop in income from primary exports → drop in real wages and aggregate consumption.
  - Lower labor cost → output and employment in nonprimary sectors increase, partially offsetting the shock.
- Comparative statics:
  - Larger X α (less diversified) and lower trade barriers in primary sector increase share X α and amplify the impact of primary shocks on Ω, income, and real wages, raising volatility.
  - Lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods lower X α and curb volatility from primary shocks by changing relative income shares (not by altering adjustment capacity).
  - Trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods do not affect volatility from primary shocks in this scenario.
  - Allocation between nonprimary sectors has no effect if same barriers apply to both.

B. Prices of Domestic Nonprimary Goods Endogenous
- Now domestic nonprimary goods prices adjust; foreign demand for domestic nonprimary goods specified:
  - 0 00 f flevel f i ii ff ii P P Cv PP η − ⎛⎞ ⎛⎞ = ⎜⎟ ⎜⎟ ⎝⎠ ⎝⎠ , ( , iAB = )
  - 0i v denotes steady-state volume of exports in sector i; flevel P is exogenously given foreign price level.
  - Foreign demand is more price-elastic than domestic demand.
- Equilibrium condition: 00 f iiii CC nY += , (i = A,B)
- Result: ˆ Ω = Κ ˆ f X p , where Κ depends on model parameters; larger Κ → larger volatility from primary shocks.
- Key formal results (exact statements preserved):
  1. As in the exogenous case, diversification via a relatively smaller primary sector lowers volatility from primary shocks, whereas lower trade barriers in that sector increases volatility.
     - A smaller primary sector or higher trade barriers implies a relatively smaller volume of trade in that sector; from ˆ Ω expressions (e.g., 0000 ˆ ˆˆ ˆ ff f XXAABB ppp αα α α Ω = ++), shifting size from X α to 0A α or 0B α lowers volatility because 0 ˆ f A p and 0 ˆ f B p vary less than ˆ f X p following a primary shock.
  2. All else equal between the two nonprimary sectors, aggregate variables are less volatile when resources (firms) are concentrated in one nonprimary sector.
     - Numerically, Κ is largest when the two nonprimary sectors have equal size and decreases as one grows relatively larger. Rationale: the larger nonprimary sector exports a larger share of output; because exports are more price-elastic, firms in that sector lower prices by relatively less to sell more output, leading to trade income being less affected by primary shocks.
  3. Lower trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods increase volatility, whereas lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods lower volatility.
     - Mechanisms:
       - Lower trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods → lower domestic consumption of domestic nonprimary goods → higher volume of exports → prices of domestic nonprimary goods less sensitive to primary shocks. Two opposing effects on volatility: smaller price sensitivity reduces impact on income, but larger export volume raises impact on income; the latter dominates.
       - Lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods produce similar effects on price elasticity and export volume but also raise total income and reduce the share of primary exports, an offset that leads to lower volatility.

*Source: _wp0650 - References..............................................................................................................*

### 4. Nonetheless, all else being equal between the nonprimary sectors, a shift of resources to the

### 4. Nonetheless, all else being equal between the nonprimary sectors, a shift of resources to the

### Effects of resource shifts on volatility
- A shift of resources to the nonprimary sector with lower (higher) trade barriers on either type of nonprimary goods unambiguously lowers (raises) volatility in the economy.
- Mechanism:
  - A shift of resources to one sector increases the share of exports in that sector and makes prices in that sector less sensitive to primary shocks, while having the opposite effect on the other sector.
  - Since the sector with lower trade barriers has a bigger share of exports to begin with, the impact of primary shocks on income decreases if resources are shifted to that sector, and increases in the opposite case.
- Transitional dynamics:
  - If resources were initially concentrated in the sector with higher trade barriers, volatility may deteriorate before it improves as capital is reallocated to the sector with lower barriers. (Numerically, K traces a bell shape.)

### Rigid wages — setup and implications
- Setup:
  - Wages are assumed fixed at the beginning of the period, before shocks are realized. Money is not neutral; the amount of money supplied ex post affects the markup of prices over wages, PW, and hence labor and consumption.
  - Maximization of expected utility implies the wage of a household is given by the expression shown in the source (W predetermined, E is the expectation operator).
- Equilibrium and monetary policy role:
  - Equilibrium conditions lead to the same expressions for L, C, and M/P in terms of Ω and PW as in Section III, but with W predetermined.
  - The equilibrium outcome depends on the choice of monetary policy. Policymakers are assumed to choose a monetary policy rule that approximates the outcome under flexible wages (optimal-rule derivation is outside the paper's scope).
- Condition for monetary policy to reproduce flexible-wage outcomes:
  - It suffices that monetary policy reproduces the level of real wages, i.e., the equality appearing in the source:
    - ()
      1 11
      W
      P
      ασα
      αφσ
      λ
      αλ
      Θ
      +
      ⎛⎞ ⎛  ⎞⎛  ⎞
      =Ω
      ⎜⎟ ⎜  ⎟⎜  ⎟
      −−
      ⎝⎠ ⎝  ⎠⎝  ⎠
  - A money-supply rule that achieves this (as given in the Appendix) can be written in log-deviations as:
    - (1) ˆ ˆ m αφσ− =Ω Θ
  - Equivalently, since ˆˆˆ XX ppw = − and ˆˆ ˆ f XX sp p = −, an exchange rate policy rule reproducing flexible-wage outcomes can be written as:
    - () ˆˆ ˆˆ f XX sp wp = + −
  - Substituting equilibrium expressions when wages are flexible, the exchange rate policy rule takes the form:
    - ˆˆ f X sp = Η
      - Η is a positive coefficient that depends on the model’s parameters and can be examined numerically.
- Interpretation of the exchange-rate response:
  - Because the home country is assumed a net exporter of primary goods, the policy rule calls for a depreciation of the local currency following a negative primary shock to raise the price level and achieve the downward adjustment in real wages that would occur under flexible wages.
  - The smaller the drop in the markup of prices over wages in the primary sector (i.e., the more wages would adjust downward if flexible), the larger the needed exchange rate depreciation under nominal wage rigidity.
  - The larger the impact on prices and the larger the impact on real wages, the larger the needed exchange rate depreciation.

### Comparative statics and quantitative claims (rigid-wage case)
- 1. The larger the relative size and the lower the trade barriers in the primary sector, the greater the required adjustments in the exchange rate following primary shocks, and the greater the need for a flexible exchange rate.
  - Rationale: these conditions entail a larger share of primary exports in total income and hence a larger impact of primary shocks on real wages and prices.
- 2. Whether a greater concentration of resources in one nonprimary sector calls for a more or less flexible exchange rate depends on the model’s parameters.
  - Ambiguity: greater concentration reduces the impact of primary shocks on real wages but accentuates the impact on prices.
  - Footnote example: For example, a higher concentration of resources in one sector typically increases the volatility of the exchange rate if 1σ<.
- 3. Lower trade barriers on domestic or foreign nonprimary goods lower exchange rate volatility.
  - Domestic nonprimary goods: lower trade barriers reduce the impact of primary shocks on real wages (if wages were flexible) as well as prices.
  - Foreign nonprimary goods: lower trade barriers have opposite effects on real wages and prices. The claim is shown numerically (and can be shown algebraically for 1σ<).
- 4. A shift of resources to the nonprimary sector with lower (higher) trade barriers on either domestic or foreign nonprimary goods unambiguously lowers (raises) exchange rate volatility.
  - Such a shift makes both real wages and prices less sensitive to primary shocks.

### Conclusion — policy-relevant findings and open extensions
- Main findings:
  - Lower trade barriers and diversification have ambiguous effects on macroeconomic stability:
    - Lower trade barriers on primary goods increase volatility stemming from primary shocks.
    - Lower trade barriers on domestic nonprimary goods have the opposite (volatility-reducing) effects.
    - Lower trade barriers on foreign nonprimary goods enhance exchange rate stability but increase the volatility of aggregate variables.
    - Diversification via a relatively smaller primary sector reduces volatility stemming from primary shocks.
    - Diversification as an equal distribution of resources between nonprimary sectors may be counterproductive.
  - Investment in the nonprimary sector with lower trade barriers unambiguously promotes macroeconomic stability (and income).
    - This extends results in Srour (2004) under alternative definitions of economic integration.
- Suggested extensions (policy and research):
  - Derive the welfare-optimizing monetary policy rather than assuming it is designed to reproduce the flexible-wage outcome.
  - Examine the issues in a general equilibrium two-country model.
  - Provide quantitative assessments of the effects illustrated.

*Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0650.pdf*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0650.pdf_
