## _wp0689 - conclusions are robust under alternative behavioral assumptions and parameterizations. A

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp0689 - conclusions are robust under alternative behavioral assumptions and parameterizations. A](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0689.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0689.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0689.pdf.json)

---

### Executive findings
- Conclusions are robust under alternative behavioral assumptions and parameterizations.
- A reduction in global saving would make early consolidation more urgent from both cyclical and long-term perspectives.
- Tax reform aimed at increasing incentives to save could provide support to fiscal consolidation measures.

### Context and scope
- Paper objective: explore macroeconomic consequences of timing and composition of fiscal consolidation using a two-country version of the IMF’s Global Fiscal Model (GFM) calibrated to the U.K. economy.
- Key questions:
  - Trade-off between early versus delayed fiscal adjustment (contrast delayed consolidation with higher government debt versus an early adjustment to contain debt at about 37 percent of GDP).
  - How composition matters: increases in taxes (labor income, corporate income, personal income) versus reductions in government transfers or current government spending.
  - Robustness to behavioral uncertainty: labor supply sensitivity to real wage, substitutability between capital and labor, reduction in global savings.
- Table of contents coverage:
  - I. Introduction (Page 3)
  - II. The Model and Calibration (Page 4)
  - III. Macroeconomic Effects of Alternative Forms of Fiscal Consolidation (Page 7)
  - IV. Sensitivity Analysis and Fiscal Policies in the Rest of the World (Page 13)
  - V. Combining Fiscal Adjustment and Tax Reform (Page 19)
  - VI. Conclusions (Page 19)

### The Model and calibration
- Model features and departures from Ricardian equivalence:
  - Overlapping-generations structure with consumers facing a constant probability of death and discounting future tax liabilities.
  - Firms and workers have monopolistic power; prices and wages above perfectly competitive levels; rents reduce distortionary impact of corporate and personal income taxes.
  - Some consumers are liquidity-constrained and consume their entire disposable income.
- Fiscal instruments modeled:
  - Labor income tax (payroll tax) levied on wage compensation paid by workers or employers.
  - Corporate income tax on accounting profits of firms.
  - Personal income tax on labor income, accounting profits, government transfers, and interest income.
  - No sales tax or VAT in GFM.
- Other features:
  - Constant elasticity of substitution utility and production functions.
  - Two factors of production: capital and labor; mobile across sectors but not internationally.
  - Investment: Tobin’s Q with sluggish adjustment.
  - Wages and prices: fully flexible. Central bank: money targeting.
  - Assets: government debt (internationally traded) and equity (held domestically). Equalization of real interest rates across countries over time via debt trade.
- Calibration specifics and baseline parameter values:
  - U.K. economy size assumed around 5 percent of the world economy.
  - Behavioral parameters (baseline / alternatives):
    - Sensitivity of labor supply to the real wage: baseline 0.04; alternative representing inelastic labor supply (close to lower limits).
    - Elasticity of substitution between labor and capital: baseline 0.8; alternative 1 (Cobb-Douglas).
    - Elasticity of intertemporal substitution: baseline 0.33; alternative 0.2.
    - Wedge between rate of time preference and yield on government bonds: baseline 10 percent (implies effective planning horizon of 10 years); alternative 1 percent.
    - Fraction of liquidity-constrained consumers: baseline 20 percent; alternative all consumers can use financial markets.

### Macroeconomic effects of alternative forms of fiscal consolidation
- Baseline (delayed consolidation) outcomes:
  - Government debt increases to about 43 percent of GDP by FY2009/10.
  - Financing gap assumed to close after FY2009/10 by gradually increasing labor income taxes on workers, generating primary surpluses to stabilize debt at 45 percent of GDP.
  - Initial financing gap driven by higher government transfers which stimulate aggregate demand, especially via liquidity-constrained consumers.
  - Labor income taxes on workers need to be increased by about 2 percentage points to stabilize debt (including financing higher interest expenses).
  - Long-run increase in real interest rate muted by small-open-economy status.
  - Labor effort, investment, and consumption decline in the medium term, implying a permanent output loss of about 0.3–0.4 percent.
- Early consolidation (gradual from FY2006/07 stabilizing debt at 37 percent):
  - Damps short-term aggregate demand but yields considerable long-term output gains because lower government interest payments imply lower tax rates later.
- Instruments for consolidation analyzed:
  - (i) Lower government transfers
  - (ii) Lower government consumption of traded and nontraded goods
  - (iii) Higher labor income taxes on workers
  - (iv) Higher labor income taxes on employers
  - (v) Higher personal income taxes
  - (vi) Higher corporate income taxes
- Comparative findings:
  - Increasing labor taxes yields larger long-term benefits than increasing corporate income taxes because capital is more responsive to tax changes while labor supply is less responsive.
  - Corporate taxation becomes less distortionary if profit margins (markups) increase, as a larger share of tax falls on rents.
  - Short-term loss in output is reduced if early consolidation is via higher corporate or personal income taxes due to sluggish investment response and lower impact on liquidity-constrained consumers compared with transfer cuts.
  - Largest and most rapid gains occur when consolidation is through lowering government expenditure (transfers or spending), as this prevents further tax distortions irrespective of timing.
  - Trade-off between short-term costs and long-term benefits of early consolidation exists across instruments, except corporate income taxes where raising them earlier is preferable regardless of policymakers’ planning horizon.
  - Raising payroll taxes on workers has the same total after-tax wage income effect as payroll taxes on employers, though hours and real wage adjust differently depending on incidence.
- Net present value evaluation:
  - Gains of early consolidation compared to delayed adjustment via higher labor income taxes are between 1½ and 7½ percent of GDP depending on the instrument.
  - When adjustment is delayed, lowering transfers or government spending is even more beneficial relative to raising personal or corporate income taxes because higher debt increases required future tax distortion.

### Sensitivity analysis and fiscal policies in the Rest of the World
- Robustness and key sensitivities:
  - Longer planning horizon of consumers (e.g., 100 years instead of 10) reduces cost of delayed consolidation:
    - Consumers anticipate future tax increases and save more of short-term disposable income increases, reducing crowding-out by government debt.
    - Early consolidation still beneficial, particularly via lower transfers or spending, but consolidating early via lower corporate taxes can become more costly relative to delaying via higher labor taxes because forward-looking agents substitute away from capital accumulation.
  - Lower intertemporal elasticity of substitution (consumption less sensitive to real interest rate) increases benefits of early consolidation:
    - Delaying increases net foreign liabilities and requires trade surpluses to service liabilities; if consumption is less responsive, real interest rates must rise more to incentivize saving, magnifying capital accumulation decline and the cost of delay.
  - Increasing labor supply sensitivity to after-tax real wage increases benefits of consolidating via lower transfers and spending:
    - More elastic labor supply makes labor income taxation more distortionary; corporate income taxes may become relatively less distortionary.
    - Completely inelastic labor supply would make labor income taxation effectively lump-sum, reducing benefits of alternative consolidation measures.
  - Increasing consumers’ financial market access or higher substitutability between capital and labor has marginal effects:
    - Full access to financial markets slightly reduces crowding-out effects.
    - Higher factor substitutability increases costs of delay but makes corporate tax increases less harmful.
- Simulated reduction in global savings (Rest of the world scenario):
  - Scenario: Rest of the world increases government debt by 10 percentage points because of a temporary reduction in labor income taxes.
  - Effects on U.K.:
    - Real interest rates increase by about 70 basis points in the long run.
    - Crowding out of U.K. investment, higher labor income taxes needed due to higher financing costs, negative wealth effects via real exchange rate depreciation, and permanent decline in output.
  - Implications:
    - Delaying consolidation in the U.K. becomes more costly.
    - Preferable to undertake fiscal adjustment before a reduction in global savings reduces U.K. output.
    - Early consolidation becomes more beneficial in net present value terms.
    - Consolidation via lowering transfers or government spending becomes more attractive; raising corporate income taxes becomes more harmful given increased world demand for U.K. savings.

### Combining fiscal adjustment and tax reform
- Revenue-neutral tax reform that increases incentives to save can support fiscal consolidation.
- Simulation:
  - Permanent reduction in corporate income taxes by 3 percentage points in the context of early consolidation, offset by either increasing labor income taxes or reducing transfers or government expenditure.
- Effects:
  - Lower corporate taxation increases after-tax marginal product of capital, stimulating saving and investment and raising long-term output.
  - Tax reform alongside consolidation produces somewhat earlier output gains and particularly enhances effectiveness of consolidation through lower transfers.
  - Short-term output losses are somewhat larger compared to early consolidation without reform, since benefits of lower corporate taxes accrue over time via capital accumulation.
  - In net present value terms, tax reform could provide a substantial boost to consolidation efforts.

### Conclusions (key policy messages)
- Significant potential benefits from early fiscal adjustment: long-term gains of preventing a rise in government debt more than outweigh short-term costs.
- Reducing transfers or government spending yields larger gains than raising taxes; raising corporate or personal income taxes creates larger distortions by reducing capital accumulation.
- Benefits of early consolidation decline if consumers have a longer planning horizon, but increase if consumption is less sensitive to interest rate changes—these behavioral assumptions alter crowding-out effects of government debt.
- Consolidating through reducing transfers or lowering government spending becomes more attractive if workers are more sensitive to after-tax real wages.
- A reduction in global savings makes early consolidation more urgent from both cyclical and long-term perspectives: higher world real interest rates substantially reduce investment and increase debt-service costs, making delayed adjustment costlier.
- Tax reform that increases incentives to save can support fiscal consolidation, particularly amplifying long-term benefits.
- Contextual note: The 2005 Pre-Budget Report measures (increase in the tax rate on oil company profits and current spending restraint) would, on staff projections, bring the overall deficit down to about 2 percent of GDP by FY2009/10 and stabilize net public debt at about 40 percent of GDP; spending restraint is an example of early and gradual consolidation consistent with the paper’s findings.

*Source: IMF staff estimates and analysis in the chapter “The Effects of Combining Early Fiscal Consolidation and Tax Reform.”*

### conclusions are robust under alternative behavioral assumptions and parameterizations. A

### _wp0689 - conclusions are robust under alternative behavioral assumptions and parameterizations. A

### Executive findings
- Conclusions are robust under alternative behavioral assumptions and parameterizations.
- A reduction in global saving would make early consolidation more urgent from both cyclical and long-term perspectives.
- Tax reform aimed at increasing incentives to save could provide support to fiscal consolidation measures.

### Context and scope (from table of contents)
- I. Introduction (Page 3)
- II. The Model and Calibration (Page 4)
- III. Macroeconomic Effects of Alternative Forms of Fiscal Consolidation (Page 7)
- IV. Sensitivity Analysis and Fiscal Policies in the Rest of the World (Page 13)
- V. Combining Fiscal Adjustment and Tax Reform (Page 19)
- VI. Conclusions (Page 19)

### Keywords and classification
- JEL Classification Numbers: E62, F41, F42, H20, H30, H63
- Keywords: Fiscal consolidation, finite lives, distortionary taxes, government debt

### Authorship and acknowledgements
- Author(s) E-Mail Address: dbotman@imf.org; khonjo@imf.org
- Acknowledgements: Thanks to James Morsink and Ben Hunt for helpful comments and suggestions; seminar participants at the U.K. Treasury seminar in December 2005 in London for constructive comments and suggestions. Views expressed are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the position of any affiliated institution.

### Analytical emphasis and empirical tools (inferred from figures and section headings)
- Macroeconomic effects of delayed versus early consolidation are analysed (Figures 2, 6).
- Comparison of impacts on real GDP of tax increases, corporate tax and markups, and spending restraint versus tax increase (Figures 3, 4, 5).
- Net present value assessment of alternative forms of fiscal consolidation (Figure 7).
- Sensitivity analysis includes a longer-planning horizon and alternative forms of early consolidation (Figures 8, 9).
- International spillovers: effects on the United Kingdom of a reduction in global savings and fiscal consolidation responses (Figures 10, 11).
- Combining fiscal adjustment with tax reform is explicitly considered (Section V).

### Policy implications (as stated)
- Early fiscal consolidation becomes more urgent if global saving declines.
- Tax reforms that increase incentives to save can support fiscal consolidation efforts.

*Source: _wp0689 - conclusions are robust under alternative behavioral assumptions and parameterizations. A*

### 12.   The Effects of Combining Early Fiscal Consolidation and Tax Reform .........................21

### 12.   The Effects of Combining Early Fiscal Consolidation and Tax Reform

### I. Introduction
- Fiscal rules introduced in 1997: a Golden rule (public sector’s current balance non-negative on average over the economic cycle) and a Sustainable Investment rule (net public sector debt kept at a stable and prudent level—the Treasury regards as below 40 percent of GDP).
- Despite these rules, the fiscal deficit remained large in 2003–04 and posed a challenge:
  - Overall deficit above 3 percent of GDP in recent years.
  - Net public debt edged up to about 35 percent of GDP in FY2004/05 from a low of 30 percent of GDP in FY2001/02.
- Paper objective: explore macroeconomic consequences of timing and composition of fiscal consolidation using a two-country version of the IMF’s Global Fiscal Model (GFM) calibrated to the U.K. economy.
- Key questions:
  - Trade-off between early versus delayed fiscal adjustment (contrast delayed consolidation with higher government debt versus an early adjustment to contain debt at about 37 percent of GDP).
  - How composition matters: increases in taxes (labor income, corporate income, personal income) versus reductions in government transfers or current government spending.
  - Robustness to behavioral uncertainty: labor supply sensitivity to real wage, substitutability between capital and labor, reduction in global savings.

### II. The Model and Calibration
- Model: two-country dynamic general equilibrium GFM where Ricardian equivalence does not hold for three reasons:
  - Overlapping-generations structure: consumers face a constant probability of death and use a discount factor higher than the real interest rate (future tax liabilities are discounted).
  - Markets not fully competitive: firms and workers have monopolistic power; prices and wages above perfectly competitive levels; rents reduce distortionary impact of corporate and personal income taxes.
  - Some consumers are liquidity-constrained and consume their entire disposable income.
- Fiscal instruments modeled:
  - Labor income tax (payroll tax) levied on wage compensation paid by workers or employers.
  - Corporate income tax on accounting profits of firms.
  - Personal income tax on labor income, accounting profits, government transfers, and interest income.
  - No sales tax or VAT in GFM.
- Other model features:
  - Consumption and production: constant elasticity of substitution utility and production functions.
  - Two factors of production: capital and labor; used for traded and nontraded goods; mobile across sectors but not internationally.
  - Investment: Tobin’s Q with sluggish adjustment.
  - Wages and prices: fully flexible. Central bank: money targeting.
  - Assets: government debt (internationally traded) and equity (held domestically). Equalization of real interest rates across countries over time via debt trade.
- Calibration specifics:
  - U.K. economy size assumed around 5 percent of the world economy.
  - Behavioral parameters set equal across U.K. and Rest of World (RoW); sensitivity analysis varies key parameters:
    - Sensitivity of labor supply to the real wage: baseline 0.04; alternative representing inelastic labor supply (close to lower limits).
    - Elasticity of substitution between labor and capital: baseline 0.8; alternative 1 (Cobb-Douglas).
    - Elasticity of intertemporal substitution: baseline 0.33; alternative 0.2.
    - Wedge between rate of time preference and yield on government bonds: baseline 10 percent (implies effective planning horizon of 10 years); alternative 1 percent.
    - Fraction of liquidity-constrained consumers: baseline 20 percent; alternative all consumers can use financial markets.

### III. Macroeconomic Effects of Alternative Forms of Fiscal Consolidation
- Baseline (delayed consolidation):
  - Government debt increases to about 43 percent of GDP by FY2009/10.
  - Financing gap assumed to close after FY2009/10 by gradually increasing labor income taxes on workers, generating primary surpluses to stabilize debt at 45 percent of GDP.
  - Initial financing gap driven by higher government transfers which stimulate aggregate demand, especially via liquidity-constrained consumers.
  - As debt rises, labor income taxes on workers need to be increased by about 2 percentage points to stabilize debt (including financing higher interest expenses).
  - Long-run increase in real interest rate muted by small-open-economy status.
  - Labor effort, investment, and consumption decline in the medium term, implying a permanent output loss of about 0.3–0.4 percent.
- Early consolidation (gradual from FY2006/07 stabilizing debt at 37 percent):
  - Damps short-term aggregate demand but yields considerable long-term output gains because lower government interest payments imply lower tax rates later.
- Instruments for consolidation considered:
  - (i) Lower government transfers; (ii) Lower government consumption of traded and nontraded goods; (iii) Higher labor income taxes on workers; (iv) Higher labor income taxes on employers; (v) Higher personal income taxes; (vi) Higher corporate income taxes.
- Comparative findings:
  - Increasing labor taxes yields larger long-term benefits than increasing corporate income taxes because capital is more responsive to tax changes while labor supply is less responsive.
  - Corporate taxation becomes less distortionary if profit margins (markups) increase, as a larger share of tax falls on rents.
  - Short-term loss in output is reduced if early consolidation is via higher corporate or personal income taxes due to sluggish investment response and lower impact on liquidity-constrained consumers compared with transfer cuts.
  - Largest and most rapid gains occur when consolidation is through lowering government expenditure (transfers or spending), as this prevents further tax distortions irrespective of timing.
  - Trade-off between short-term costs and long-term benefits of early consolidation exists across instruments, except corporate income taxes where raising them earlier is preferable regardless of policymakers’ planning horizon.
  - Raising payroll taxes on workers has the same total after-tax wage income effect as payroll taxes on employers, though hours and real wage adjust differently depending on incidence.
- Net present value evaluation:
  - Gains of early consolidation compared to delayed adjustment via higher labor income taxes are between 1½ and 7½ percent of GDP depending on the instrument.
  - When adjustment is delayed, lowering transfers or government spending is even more beneficial relative to raising personal or corporate income taxes because higher debt increases required future tax distortion.

### IV. Sensitivity Analysis and Fiscal Policies in the Rest of the World
- Results broadly robust; key sensitivities:
  - Longer planning horizon of consumers (e.g., 100 years instead of 10) reduces cost of delayed consolidation:
    - Consumers anticipate future tax increases and save more of short-term disposable income increases, reducing crowding-out by government debt.
    - Early consolidation still beneficial, particularly via lower transfers or spending, but consolidating early via lower corporate taxes can become more costly relative to delaying via higher labor taxes because forward-looking agents substitute away from capital accumulation.
  - Lower intertemporal elasticity of substitution (consumption less sensitive to real interest rate) increases benefits of early consolidation:
    - Delaying increases net foreign liabilities and requires trade surpluses to service liabilities; if consumption is less responsive, real interest rates must rise more to incentivize saving, magnifying capital accumulation decline and the cost of delay.
  - Increasing labor supply sensitivity to after-tax real wage increases benefits of consolidating via lower transfers and spending:
    - More elastic labor supply makes labor income taxation more distortionary; corporate income taxes may become relatively less distortionary.
    - Completely inelastic labor supply would make labor income taxation effectively lump-sum, reducing benefits of alternative consolidation measures.
  - Increasing consumers’ financial market access or higher substitutability between capital and labor has marginal effects:
    - Full access to financial markets slightly reduces crowding-out effects.
    - Higher factor substitutability increases costs of delay but makes corporate tax increases less harmful.
- Global context—simulated reduction in global savings:
  - Scenario: Rest of the world increases government debt by 10 percentage points because of a temporary reduction in labor income taxes.
  - Effects on U.K.:
    - Real interest rates increase by about 70 basis points in the long run.
    - Crowding out of U.K. investment, higher labor income taxes needed due to higher financing costs, negative wealth effects via real exchange rate depreciation, and permanent decline in output.
  - Implications:
    - Delaying consolidation in the U.K. becomes more costly.
    - Preferable to undertake fiscal adjustment before a reduction in global savings reduces U.K. output.
    - Early consolidation becomes more beneficial in net present value terms.
    - Consolidation via lowering transfers or government spending becomes more attractive; raising corporate income taxes becomes more harmful given increased world demand for U.K. savings.

### V. Combining Fiscal Adjustment and Tax Reform
- Revenue-neutral tax reform aimed at increasing incentives to save can support fiscal consolidation.
- Simulation: permanent reduction in corporate income taxes by 3 percentage points in the context of early consolidation, offset by either increasing labor income taxes or reducing transfers or government expenditure.
- Effects:
  - Lower corporate taxation increases after-tax marginal product of capital, stimulating saving and investment and raising long-term output.
  - Tax reform alongside consolidation produces somewhat earlier output gains and particularly enhances effectiveness of consolidation through lower transfers.
  - Short-term output losses are somewhat larger compared to early consolidation without reform, since benefits of lower corporate taxes accrue over time via capital accumulation.
  - In net present value terms, tax reform could provide a substantial boost to consolidation efforts.

### VI. Conclusions (Summary of key findings)
- Significant potential benefits from early fiscal adjustment: long-term gains of preventing a rise in government debt more than outweigh short-term costs.
- Reducing transfers or government spending yields larger gains than raising taxes; raising corporate or personal income taxes creates larger distortions by reducing capital accumulation.
- Benefits of early consolidation decline if consumers have a longer planning horizon, but increase if consumption is less sensitive to interest rate changes—these behavioral assumptions alter crowding-out effects of government debt.
- Consolidating through reducing transfers or lowering government spending becomes more attractive if workers are more sensitive to after-tax real wages.
- A reduction in global savings makes early consolidation more urgent from both cyclical and long-term perspectives: higher world real interest rates substantially reduce investment and increase debt-service costs, making delayed adjustment costlier.
- Tax reform that increases incentives to save can support fiscal consolidation, particularly amplifying long-term benefits.
- Contextual note: The 2005 Pre-Budget Report measures (increase in the tax rate on oil company profits and current spending restraint) would, on staff projections, bring the overall deficit down to about 2 percent of GDP by FY2009/10 and stabilize net public debt at about 40 percent of GDP; spending restraint is an example of early and gradual consolidation consistent with the paper’s findings.

*Source: IMF staff estimates and analysis in the chapter “The Effects of Combining Early Fiscal Consolidation and Tax Reform.”*

### REFERENCES

### _wp0689 - REFERENCES

### Cited Works
- Al-Eyd, A., and R. Barrell, 2005, “Estimating Tax and Benefit Multipliers in Europe,” Economic Modeling, Vol. 22, pp. 759-76.
- Bayoumi, T., and D. Botman, 2005, “Jam Today or More Jam Tomorrow? On Cutting Taxes Now Versus Later,” Canada—Selected Issues, IMF Country Report No. 05/116 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).
- Bayoumi, T., D. Botman, and M. Kumar, 2005, “Effects of Social Security and Tax Reform in the United States,” United States—Selected Issues, IMF Country Report No. 05/258 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).
- Botman, D., D. Laxton, D. Muir, and A. Romanov, 2006, “A New-Open-Economy-Macro Model for Fiscal Policy Evaluation,” IMF Working Paper 06/45 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).
- Botman, D., and D. Laxton, 2004, “The Effects of Tax Cuts in a Global Fiscal Model,” Box 2.2 in World Economic Outlook, April (Washington: International Monetary Fund).
- Kumhof, M., D. Laxton, and D. Muir, 2005, “Consequences of Fiscal Consolidation for the U.S. Current Account,” United States—Selected Issues, IMF Country Report No. 05/258 (Washington: International Monetary Fund).
- Laxton, D., and P. Pesenti, 2003, “Monetary Rules for Small, Open, Emerging Economies,” Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 50, pp. 1109-46.

*Source: _wp0689 - REFERENCES*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2006/_wp0689.pdf_
