## _wp07221

## Source details

**Canonical URL:** [_wp07221](https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07221.pdf)

## Other formats

- [Markdown version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07221.pdf.md)
- [Structured JSON version](/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07221.pdf.json)

---

### Introduction and policymaker concerns
- Paper addresses: importance and evolution of asset markets in India; impact of asset prices on the economy; policies to minimize risks as asset markets grow.
- Policymakers’ concerns:
  - RBI (March 2006) noted “financial imbalances are growing in the presence of abundant liquidity, rising asset prices, and a marked increase in risk appetite (RBI, 2006a).”
  - RBI characterized the financial system as “significantly overdrawn in terms of credit portfolios (and) banks need to recognize the reality of business and credit cycles” (RBI, 2006b).
- Policy response:
  - Over 2005–2006, the RBI gradually tightened monetary policy and significantly raised risk weights on loans to housing, commercial real estate, consumer credit, venture fund, and capital market lending, and increased general provisions.

### How significant are asset markets in India?
- Structural drivers:
  - Rapid growth reflects rising incomes and financial deregulation; real estate dominates, stock market gaining prominence, gold important particularly in rural areas.
- Household savings and asset allocation:
  - Households’ savings comprise about 28 percent of disposable income.
  - In 2004–05, about 53 percent of the annual flow of savings was invested in physical assets.
  - Value of the stock of property holdings more than tripled over the past decade to over 200 percent of GDP.
- Housing demand and real estate stock:
  - Another 31 million housing units needed to meet pent-up demand; further 2.7 million additional units per annum needed to meet needs of the growing population (Deutsche Bank, 2006).
  - Commercial real estate stock estimated at $300 billion (35 percent of GDP); market could grow by $66 billion in the next five years (Deutsche Bank, 2006).
- Equity and institutional holdings:
  - Between 2000–2005, stock market capitalization rose to over 77 percent of GDP.
  - Net portfolio inflows totaled about $10 million in 2005; foreign investors held about 10 percent of GDP in equity assets and accounted for up to one third of stock market turnover.
  - Insurance, pension, and mutual funds’ assets amount to almost 15 percent of GDP, with significant portions invested in equity.
- Gold:
  - India accounts for about 20 percent of annual global gold purchases.
  - Households’ gold holdings estimated at 28−42 percent of GDP in 2002, or $204−307 billion (Bhattacharya, 2002).

### How are asset prices evolving in India?
- Equity markets and valuations:
  - SENSEX increased at a compound annual rate of 17 percent since 2003.
  - Large inflows: some $26½ billion in 2003–2005.
  - Market integration (beta versus world markets): -0.2 in 1995–99, +0.67 in 2000–03, almost 1.5 in 2004–2005.
  - Price-earnings ratio on the SENSEX exceeds 20; mid-cap and technology markets closer to 30.
  - Valuation assessment (mid-2006): with a standard risk premium assumption of 6 percent, expected real dividend growth implied by current valuations appear in line with estimated medium-term growth potential of about 7 percent.
  - Ex-post risk adjusted returns: Sharpe ratio of 1.3 between 2001–2005.
  - Corporate after tax profits rose at a compound rate of 37 percent per annum since 2003.
  - Sensitivity: a higher equity risk premium assumption of 8½ percent would result in current valuations exceeding growth potential by about 1–2 percentage points.
- Real estate:
  - Since 2000, residential housing prices in Bangalore, Delhi, and Mumbai have more than doubled; prices in smaller tier II cities (e.g., Chennai and Pune) have risen by 25–50 percent.
  - Commercial real estate rental price increases ranged from about 85 percent in Bangalore to about 4 percent in Mumbai.
  - Office and retail vacancy rates in central business districts in India’s three main urban centers have fallen to 0–3 percent; suburban shopping mall vacancy rates are 10–14 percent.
  - Aggregate view: analysts consider real estate prices likely to continue to rise as demand outstrips supply due to demographics and rising incomes.
- Gold prices and wealth effects:
  - Domestic gold prices rose about 215 percent since end-2000, with much of the increase since mid-2005.
  - Households’ nonmonetary holdings of gold estimated at 10,000–15,000 tons in 2002.
  - By September 2006, households’ gold-related wealth would have increased by between $102–153 billion (approximately 20−30 percent of 2002 GDP) on account of rising gold prices (excluding exchange rate impacts against the U.S. dollar).

### Channels linking asset prices to macro activity
- Five main channels:
  - Wealth effects (life cycle/permanent income): higher asset prices raise lifetime wealth and spending.
  - Financing / cost of capital: rising asset prices, particularly real estate, lower the cost of new capital relative to existing capital, spurring investment.
  - Financial accelerator / credit channel: asset price fluctuations affect borrowing capacity by altering borrowers’ wealth and collateral value (Kiyotaki and Moore, 1997; Bernanke, Gertler and Gilchrist, 1999), amplifying effects for leveraged borrowers.
  - Balance sheet effects and financial fragility: asset-price swings affect financial institutions’ net worth and borrowers’ health, potentially boosting nonperforming loans and forcing credit cuts.
  - Confidence effects: asset prices signal expected future real income growth, influencing consumption and investment.

### Empirical evidence on the strength of wealth and financial accelerator effects
- Evidence from other emerging markets:
  - Kuralbayeva and N’Diaye (2006): in Malaysia, Hong Kong SAR, Indonesia, and Korea a 10 percent rise in real stock prices increases private consumption by about 0.2–0.3 percent.
- Indicators suggesting small effects in India:
  - Household financial asset composition:
    - Almost three quarters of household financial wealth is held in cash, bank deposits and government securities (compared to about 60 percent in Japan, and 33 percent in Korea).
    - Households’ direct holdings of shares account for less than ½ percent of GDP, or 2 percent of household wealth.
    - Including indirect holdings via institutions raises holdings to 3½ percent of GDP; indirect holdings are primarily public or defined benefits plans where changes in market value have little direct impact on households.
  - Limited leverage and market intermediation:
    - Home equity loan market is not developed.
    - Retail gold markets that would allow households to transform gold holdings into capital have failed to flourish.
    - Gold Exchange Traded Funds (GETFs) are still in their infancy.
  - Corporate and financial sector exposures:
    - About 71 percent of corporate financial assets (25 percent of GDP) are held in government and approved securities, debentures, and Public Sector Undertakings’ bonds.
    - Less than 5 percent of corporate funds are invested in mutual funds; even less in direct equity holdings.
    - Land and property are less than 3 percent of total fixed and financial assets (5.8 percent of GDP).
    - Private sector credit rose to about 42 percent of GDP, up from under 30 percent of GDP in 2000.
    - Banks’ direct holdings of shares and mutual funds are 0.8 percent of GDP.
    - IRDA reports total fixed assets of insurers in India, including property, amounted to Rs. 146.6 million in 2005/06; equity investments are restricted to AA-rated paper and subject to exposure limits.
- Correlations:
  - No clear or strong relationship between asset prices, inflation, and aggregate demand.
  - Asset prices (Sensex changes) and WPI inflation are negatively correlated; correlations between equity prices and real activity and credit are positive and significant but weak.
- Econometric investigation (VECM, annual data 1979−2005):
  - Variables: real private consumption per capita, real stock exchange index (Sensex), real short-term interest rates, real per capita income, and a post-1991 structural dummy; series are I(1); Johansen trace finds a single cointegration vector.
  - Long-run VECM result:
    - A 10 percent increase in the stock market index is associated with an increase in consumption of one tenth of 1 percent.
    - Long-run relationship (as reported):
      - Consumption = 3.64 + 0.05Income − 0.01InterestRate + 0.00657Sensex  (coefficients shown as in source: )02093.0()00657.0()00373.0( 60.005.001.064.3IncometeInterestRaSensexnConsumptio+−+−=
  - Short-run dynamics and impulse responses:
    - Changes in wealth (stock market prices) have no contemporaneous impact on other variables.
    - Increases in stock market value have a very small long-run impact on consumption.
    - Increases in real per capita income permanently boost consumption; increases in interest rates reduce consumption over the longer term.
    - Regression diagnostics: R2 = 0.67 and the Log likelihood ratio = 80.12.

### Monetary policy stance toward asset prices: assessment for India
- Preconditions for monetary policy to respond effectively to asset prices:
  - Accurate identification of misalignments and bubbles.
  - Fluctuations sizeable and macroeconomically significant with fallout monetary policy cannot readily offset ex post.
  - Identifiable causal relationship from asset prices to inflation and aggregate demand.
  - Dependable relation between changes in monetary policy and asset prices.
- Assessment for India:
  - These conditions do not appear to be fulfilled.
  - Structural change makes identification of misalignments difficult.
  - Rapid growth in real estate ownership and credit may reflect financial deepening from a small base.
  - Even if misaligned, corrections are unlikely to have a sizeable macroeconomic impact; monetary policy can likely counter deflationary effects ex post rather than ex ante.
  - No strong relationship appears between monetary policy and asset prices (asset prices climbed despite rising interest rates over the prior two years).

### Role for targeted prudential and supervisory policies
- Rationale:
  - Targeted microprudential measures can address risks from asset price buildups without the broad macro side effects of higher interest rates.
  - Such measures can limit participation in bubbles and reduce financial-system vulnerability to busts.
- Prudential measures and Indian experience:
  - Higher/differentiated capital requirements or risk weights:
    - India progressively raised risk weights on loans for housing, consumer credit, capital market investment and commercial real estate in 2005 and 2006 to levels above those recommended by the Basel Capital Accord.
  - Loan classification and provisioning:
    - By October 2006, Indian classification norms for doubtful loans were at 12 months (below international standard of 180 days).
    - General provisioning rate on standard loans in high-risk areas was increased to 1 percent in April 2006; provisioning rate on priority sector loans is 0.4 percent.
  - Loan eligibility and LTV:
    - LTV ratios of between 60–70 percent in India are relatively conservative; lending decisions primarily based on borrowers’ capacity to repay.
    - Example: Hong Kong reduced LTV ratios from 90 percent to 70 percent in 1991, and to 40 percent in 1994.
  - Credit concentration limits:
    - Indian exposure limits on group and connected party lending were relatively high at 40 percent and 50 percent, respectively, at the time of writing.
  - Dynamic provisioning (DP):
    - DP builds reserves to cover expected loan losses over the cycle; requires recognition of general provisions as tax-deductible and technical capacity to estimate expected losses.
    - DP effects can be mimicked by supervisory buffers, enriched impairment definitions, or finer risk/provisioning categories.
  - Fair value accounting:
    - Shows market values for marketable instruments and provisions for nonmarketable assets; practical problems include lack of traded benchmarks for loans, potential taxation of unrealized gains, and greater volatility in measured capital and earnings.
- Supervisory enhancements:
  - More refined stress tests, intensified on- and off-site supervision, closer monitoring of loan underwriting procedures.
  - Examples from other countries: Thailand stress tests on property price falls and quarterly reports on high-value real estate loans; Korea special diagnostics on mortgage lending; Japan identifies largest corporate borrowers for close supervision.
  - Under Basel II, Indian banks will develop their own stress tests; recommended stress-testing “over the economic cycle,” target specific asset exposures, and indicate downside risks including default probability and loss given default.
  - Recommendation: RBI to coordinate with other regulators to assess risks in insurance, pension, and mutual fund industries given increasing household asset holdings via these vehicles.

### Development of market risk management instruments and tax reform
- Market infrastructure and constraints:
  - Short selling: by end-2006, short selling of equities by foreign and domestic institutional investors was prohibited; in government securities limited to intra-day transactions.
  - Asset-backed securities (ABS): market growing at annual rates in excess of 100 percent but lags regional leaders; mortgage-backed securities modest.
  - Obstacles to securitization: stamp duties ranging from 0.1 percent to 8 percent across states; lack of a common benchmark yield curve at longer maturities; ineffective foreclosure laws; lack of a secondary market and definitional issues for exchange listing.
  - Prepayment risk: lack of hedging tools and borrower propensity to prepay loans without penalty as interest rates fell.
- Short selling: benefits and limits
  - Benefits: allows pessimistic views, disciplines valuations, increases speed of price adjustment to new information.
  - Limits: impact limited when markets dominated by optimism; prohibitions can remove pessimistic investors and contribute to inflated prices.
- Securitization mechanics and benefits:
  - Repackage relatively homogenous loans via special purpose vehicle to issue asset backed securities; allows banks to obtain long-term financing, transfer credit risk, and reduce capital requirements.
  - Indian market growth rapid but constrained by legal, tax, pricing, and market-structure impediments.
- Tax incentives and mortgage interest deductibility:
  - Full deductibility of mortgage interest can raise household leverage and exacerbate instability if asset prices decline.
  - Empirical examples (Box 1):
    - United Kingdom: phased removal beginning 1974; deductible rate reduced until eliminated in 1999; by 1998 cap applied to over two-thirds of mortgages.
    - Sweden: interest deductions reduced and capped at 30 percent in 1991; estimated housing prices may have declined by between 10–15 percent due to reform.
    - Netherlands (Yelten, 2006): immediate removal of deductibility could cause housing price falls ranging from 3½ percent (fast growth) to 36 percent (recession) over six years for high-income brackets; gradual phasing with a cap reduces declines (e.g., –13 percent in recession); in fast growth scenario prices would rise about 30 percent over six years, about 17 percentage points lower than if deductibility continued unchanged.

### Policy recommendations and conclusions (selected)
- Assessment:
  - Higher income, low interest rates, and financial liberalization have driven asset market booms; most asset price increases reflect structural pressures rather than pure speculation, though some segments (e.g., mall real estate) appear high.
  - Estimating overheating is difficult; a negative growth shock would likely cause asset price adjustments.
- Wealth effects:
  - Econometric analysis indicates small potential wealth effects: a 10 percent increase in equity prices is associated with a rise in real private consumption of less than one tenth of one percent.
- Monetary policy:
  - Monetary policy may not be the most effective tool to guard the financial system against asset price volatility in the current structural-change context; macro policy actions could derail financial deepening or worsen effects of an asset price reversal.
- Recommended targeted regulatory and market-development actions:
  - Tighter loan classification, provisioning, and loan eligibility requirements.
  - Improved accounting and disclosure standards to capture market, interest, and credit risk.
  - Enhanced stress testing and surveillance of financial institutions’ loan portfolios.
  - Further development of short selling and securitization markets to facilitate better risk management.
  - Re-evaluation of tax incentives for particular asset classes to ensure a more orderly evolution of asset prices.

*Source: _wp07221 - References (IMF working paper content).*

### References..............................................................................................................

### _wp07221 - References

### Introduction
- Paper examines policy implications of rising asset prices in India and addresses three questions:
  - How important are asset markets, and how have asset prices evolved in India?
  - How do asset prices impact the economy?
  - What policies would minimize potential risks as the role of asset markets grows?
- Policymakers’ concerns cited:
  - RBI (March 2006) raised concerns that “financial imbalances are growing in the presence of abundant liquidity, rising asset prices, and a marked increase in risk appetite (RBI, 2006a).”
  - RBI characterized the financial system as “significantly overdrawn in terms of credit portfolios (and) banks need to recognize the reality of business and credit cycles” (RBI, 2006b).
- Policy response noted:
  - Over 2005–2006, the RBI gradually tightened monetary policy and significantly raised risk weights on loans to housing, commercial real estate, consumer credit, venture fund, and capital market lending, and increased general provisions.

### How significant are asset markets in India?
- Structural drivers:
  - Rapid growth of asset markets reflects rising incomes and financial deregulation.
  - Real estate dominates; stock market gaining prominence; gold important particularly in rural areas.
- Household savings and asset allocation:
  - Households’ savings comprise about 28 percent of disposable income in India.
  - In 2004–05, about 53 percent of the annual flow of savings was invested in physical assets.
  - National Sample Survey: value of the stock of property holdings more than tripled over the past decade to over 200 percent of GDP (Table 1).
- Housing market demand:
  - Official and market estimates: another 31 million housing units are needed to meet pent-up demand, and a further 2.7 million additional units per annum are needed to meet needs of the growing population (Deutsche Bank, 2006).
- Commercial real estate:
  - Deutsche Bank (2006) estimates India’s commercial real estate stock at $300 billion (35 percent of GDP), the fourth largest commercial real estate market in Asia after Japan, China, and Korea.
  - Market analysts conclude potential to grow by $66 billion in the next five years (Deutsche Bank, 2006).
- Equity markets:
  - Between 2000–2005, stock market capitalization rose to over 77 percent of GDP.
  - Net portfolio inflows totaled about $10 million in 2005, with foreign investors holding about 10 percent of GDP in equity assets (Lane and Milesi-Ferretti, 2006) and accounting for up to one third of stock market turnover.
  - Insurance, pension, and mutual funds’ assets amount to almost 15 percent of GDP, with significant portions invested in equity.
- Gold market:
  - India accounts for about 20 percent of annual global gold purchases.
  - Households’ gold holdings estimated at 28−42 percent of GDP in 2002, or $204−307 billion (Bhattacharya, 2002).

### How are asset prices evolving in India?
- Equity prices:
  - SENSEX increased at a compound annual rate of 17 percent since 2003.
  - Large inflows: some $26½ billion in 2003–2005.
  - Market integration: India’s beta versus world markets has increased from -0.2 in 1995–99, to +0.67 in 2000–03, and almost 1.5 in 2004–2005.
  - Valuations: price-earnings ratio on the SENSEX now exceeds 20; mid-cap and technology markets closer to 30 (Table 2).
- Valuation assessment (mid-2006):
  - Using a standard risk premium assumption of 6 percent, expected real dividend growth implied by current valuations appear to be in line with estimated medium-term growth potential of about 7 percent.
  - Ex-post risk adjusted returns: Sharpe ratio of 1.3 between 2001–2005.
  - Corporate after tax profits rose at a compound rate of 37 percent per annum since 2003.
  - Note: A higher equity risk premium assumption of 8½ percent would result in current valuations exceeding growth potential by about 1–2 percentage points (sensitivity to equity risk premium assumption).
- Real estate prices:
  - Since 2000, residential housing prices in Bangalore, Delhi, and Mumbai have more than doubled; prices in smaller tier II cities (e.g., Chennai and Pune) have risen by 25–50 percent.
  - Commercial real estate rental price increases ranged from about 85 percent in Bangalore to about 4 percent in Mumbai.
  - Office and retail vacancy rates in central business districts in India’s three main urban centers have fallen to 0–3 percent (Jones Lang La Salle, 2006a).
  - Vacancy rates in suburban shopping mall developments are in the 10–14 percent range; mall market could be reaching saturation given pipeline developments (Jones Lang La Salle, 2006b).
  - Aggregate view: market analysts consider real estate prices likely to continue to rise as demand outstrips supply due to demographics and rising incomes.
- Gold prices and wealth effects:
  - Domestic gold prices rose about 215 percent since end-2000, with much of the increase since mid-2005.
  - Households’ nonmonetary holdings of gold estimated at 10,000–15,000 tons in 2002 (Bhattacharya, 2002).
  - By September 2006, households’ gold-related wealth would have increased by between $102–153 billion (approximately 20−30 percent of 2002 GDP) on account of rising gold prices (excluding exchange rate impacts against the U.S. dollar).

### How do asset prices impact macroeconomic activity?
- Five main channels linking asset prices to real activity:
  - Wealth effects:
    - Under life cycle/permanent income hypothesis, higher asset prices raise lifetime wealth and thus raise spending.
  - Financing or cost of capital hypothesis:
    - Rising asset prices, particularly of real estate, lower the cost of new capital relative to existing capital, spurring investment.
  - Financial accelerator / credit channel:
    - With imperfect credit markets, asset price fluctuations affect borrowing capacity by altering borrowers’ wealth and value of pledged collateral (Kiyotaki and Moore, 1997; Bernanke, Gertler and Gilchrist, 1999).
    - These dynamics affect finance premia on loans and influence investment and consumption; leveraged borrowers see amplified effects on real variables.
  - Balance sheet effects and financial fragility:
    - Asset-price swings affect financial institutions’ net worth via valuation of asset portfolios and borrowers’ health, potentially boosting nonperforming loans.
    - Severe crashes can force intermediaries to cut credit, dampening aggregate demand and triggering negative feedback loops when intermediaries are highly leveraged.
  - Confidence effects:
    - Equity and other asset prices signal expected future real income growth, influencing consumption and entrepreneurial investment decisions.

*Source: _wp07221 - References (IMF working paper content).*

### 15.      Empirical research suggests that the financial wealth channel can be significant

### _wp07221 - 15.      Empirical research suggests that the financial wealth channel can be significant

### Empirical evidence from other emerging markets
- Kuralbayeva and N’Diaye (2006) find that in Malaysia, Hong Kong SAR, Indonesia, and Korea, a 10 percent rise in real stock prices increases private consumption by about 0.2–0.3 percent, similar in magnitude to estimates for industrialized countries (see IMF 2000, and Slacalek, 2006).

### Indicators suggesting wealth and financial accelerator effects in India are likely small
- Indian households’ holdings of marketable financial asset holdings are small (Table 3).
  - Almost three quarters of household financial wealth is held in a combination of cash, bank deposits and government securities, compared to about 60 percent in Japan, and 33 percent in Korea.
  - Households’ direct holdings of shares account for less than ½ percent of GDP, or 2 percent of household wealth.
  - If indirect holdings via institutions are included, these holdings rise to 3½ percent of GDP.
  - Indirect holdings are primarily in the form of public or defined benefits plans, where changes in value of financial assets have little direct impact on households’ wealth.
- Holdings of property and gold are unlikely to be leveraged.
  - The home equity loan market is not developed.
  - Retail gold markets that would allow households to transform gold holdings into capital have failed to flourish (for example, the 1999 gold deposit scheme).
  - Gold Exchange Traded Funds (GETFs), that allow households to buy and sell gold in units of as little as Rs. 100, are still in their infancy.
- Corporates’ exposure to nondebt asset markets is also small.
  - Indian corporates primarily invest in government securities rather than equity.
  - About 71 percent of corporate financial assets (25 percent of GDP) are held in government and approved securities, debentures, and Public Sector Undertakings’ bonds.
  - Less than 5 percent of funds are invested in mutual funds, and even less in direct equity holdings.
  - Land and property are less than 3 percent of total fixed and financial assets (5.8 percent of GDP).
  - Financial data could understate the true value of property holdings if valued at historical purchase prices.
- The financial sector’s exposures to asset price movements are mixed.
  - Private sector credit as a share of GDP is now at about 42 percent of GDP up from under 30 percent of GDP in 2000.
  - Banks’ direct holdings of shares and mutual funds are relatively small (0.8 percent of GDP), partly reflecting high Statutory Liquidity Requirements (SLR) and rules that call for non-SLR holdings to be in investment grade securities.
  - Some banks have relatively high exposures due to the importance of equity-linked earnings.
  - Insurance sector’s exposures to real estate and equity is low and bulk of their assets held in government securities. The same is true of the pension sector.
  - Example: IRDA reports that total fixed assets of insurers in Indian, including property amounted to Rs. 146.6  million in 2005/06. Moreover, investments in equity are restricted to AA-rated paper and must be liquid, and investments in equity cannot exceed 50 percent of investor and sector exposure limits (10 percent of free capital and 10 percent of total industrial sector exposure).

### Correlations between asset prices, inflation, and macro variables
- There is no clear or strong relationship between asset prices, inflation, and aggregate demand (Figure 12).
  - Using changes in the Sensex to proxy changes in assets prices, asset prices and WPI inflation are negatively correlated.
  - Correlations between equity prices and real activity and credit are positive and significant, but the relationships are very weak.
  - Given endogeneity of asset prices to economic activity, positive correlations do not necessarily imply causality.

### Econometric investigation of asset prices and consumption in India
- Model specification and data:
  - A VECM model examines linkages between asset prices and consumption.
  - Variables: real private consumption per capita, real stock exchange index (proxy for asset prices), real short-term interest rates, real per capita income, and an exogenous dummy for structural changes after the 1991 balance of payments crisis.
  - Data are annual from 1979−2005; all variables (except dummy) are specified in logs.
  - Augmented Dickey Fuller tests confirm the series are I(1) (Table 5).
  - Johansen trace statistics reveal the existence of a single cointegration vector with a trend and intercept (Table 6).
  - Lag selection tests suggest a lag of two is sufficient for all variables.
- Long-run VECM result:
  - A 10 percent increase in the stock market index is associated with an increase in consumption of one tenth of 1 percent.
  - Long-run relationship (standard errors in parentheses):
    - Consumption = 3.64 + 0.05Income − 0.01InterestRate + 0.00657Sensex (coefficients shown as in source: )02093.0()00657.0()00373.0( 60.005.001.064.3IncometeInterestRaSensexnConsumptio+−+−=
  - Coefficients are of the expected sign: consumption increases with rising asset prices and incomes, and declines with rising interest rates.
- Short-run dynamics and impulse responses:
  - Short-run adjustment modeled as an ECM with the error correction vector from the Johansen procedure plus lagged first differences.
  - Variables are jointly significant.
  - Impulse response functions using a Cholesky recursive scheme indicate:
    - Changes in wealth (proxied by stock market prices) have no contemporaneous impact on other variables.
    - Increases in stock market value in India have a very small long-run impact on consumption (Figures 13 and 14).
    - Increases in real per capita income permanently boost consumption.
    - Increases in interest rates result in lower consumption over the longer term.
  - Regression diagnostics: R2 = 0.67 and the Log likelihood ratio = 80.12.

### Policy implications: monetary policy stance toward asset prices
- There is no broad consensus on monetary policy response to sharp asset price movements.
  - Bernanke (2002): monetary policy should respond to asset prices only to the extent they signal current or future changes in inflation or output.
  - Cecchetti, Genbery, Lipsky and Wadhwani (2000): monetary policy should counter expansionary effects of rising asset prices to preserve financial stability even at the cost of higher short-term interest rates and lower growth.
- Preconditions for monetary policy to respond effectively to asset prices:
  - Policymakers can accurately identify asset price misalignments and bubbles.
  - Fluctuations in asset prices are sizeable, macroeconomically significant, and lead to fallout that monetary policy cannot readily offset after a correction.
  - There is an identifiable causal relationship from asset prices to inflation and aggregate demand.
  - There is a dependable relation between changes in monetary policy and changes in asset prices.
- Assessment for India:
  - These conditions do not appear to be fulfilled in India.
  - Structural change makes identification of misalignments difficult.
  - Rapid growth in real estate ownership and credit is from a relatively small base and may reflect financial deepening.
  - Even if misaligned, corrections are unlikely to have a sizeable macroeconomic impact; monetary policy should be capable of countering deflationary effects ex post rather than ex ante.
  - No strong relationship appears between monetary policy and asset prices (asset prices have continued to climb despite increasing interest rates over the past two years).

### Role for targeted prudential and supervisory policies
- Rationale:
  - Targeted microeconomic policies can address risks associated with asset price buildups without broader macroeconomic side effects of interest rate changes.
  - Such policies can limit participation in bubbles and reduce the financial system’s vulnerability to busts.
- Prudential measures adopted elsewhere and their relevance:
  - Higher and/or differentiated capital requirements or risk weights:
    - Examples: Bulgaria, Bosnia, Croatia, Norway, and Poland increased risk weights by loan type, maturity, or currency composition.
    - In 2005 and 2006, India progressively raised risk weights on loans for housing, consumer credit, capital market investment and commercial real estate to levels above those recommended by the Basel Capital Accord.
  - Tighter/differential loan classification and provisioning requirements:
    - Examples: Bulgaria, Croatia, and Romania raised general and/or category specific risk provisions.
    - By October 2006, Indian classification norms for doubtful loans were at 12 months, below the international standard of 180 days.
    - General provisioning rate on standard loans in high-risk areas was increased to 1 percent in April 2006; provisioning rate on priority sector loans is 0.4 percent.
  - Tightening loan eligibility criteria:
    - Hong Kong reduced LTV ratios from 90 percent to 70 percent in 1991, and to 40 percent in 1994, helping withstand the 1997 property price correction.
    - LTV ratios of between 60–70 percent in India are relatively conservative; lending decisions are primarily based on borrowers’ capacity to repay.
  - Tightening rules on credit concentration:
    - Indian exposure limits on group and connected party lending were relatively high at 40 percent and 50 percent, respectively, at the time of writing.
  - Dynamic provisioning (DP):
    - DP builds a reserve to cover expected losses from loan origination; reserve builds up when actual losses fall short of expected losses and is drawn down when losses exceed expected level.
    - DP requires recognition of general provisions as a tax-deductible expense and technical capacity to estimate expected losses.
    - DP effects can be mimicked by introducing a supervisory buffer, enriching impairment definitions, or introducing finer risk and provisioning categories.
  - Fair value accounting:
    - Proxies for fair value accounting show market values for marketable instruments and provisions for nonmarketable assets (examples: United States and Denmark).
    - Practical problems: loans are not generally traded making market benchmarks difficult; possibility banks might be taxed on unrealized gains; greater volatility in measured capital and earnings.
- Supervisory policy enhancements:
  - More refined stress tests, intensified on- and off-site supervision, and closer monitoring of loan underwriting procedures.
  - Examples:
    - Thailand conducts stress tests on bank vulnerability to large falls in property prices and requires quarterly reports on approvals of high value real estate loans.
    - Korea requires special diagnostic reports on mortgage lending.
    - Japan identifies largest corporate borrowers and banks with greatest exposure for closer supervision.
  - Under Basel II, banks in India will have to develop their own stress tests of asset portfolio risks.
    - Recommendations: encourage stress tests “over the economic cycle” rather than at a point in time; target specific asset market exposures; require tests to indicate downside risks including default probability and loss given default.
  - The RBI could work with other financial regulators to assess risks in the insurance, pension, and mutual fund industries given increasing prevalence of asset holdings via these vehicles amongst households.

*Source: IMF staff calculations and text from the provided content unit.*

### 27.      The development of market risk management instruments and tax reform can

### _wp07221 - 27.      The development of market risk management instruments and tax reform can

### Market risk management instruments: overview and context
- Spain began DP in 2000 in the context of a property price boom and rapid credit expansion. Loans are divided into six categories (ranging from ‘without risk’ to ‘high risk’) with the risk weight for each categories determined in by historical experience of default over the economic cycle.
- By end-2006, short selling in India of equities by foreign and domestic institutional investors was prohibited, and in government securities limited to intra-day transactions.
- The asset-backed securities market in India has been growing at annual rates in excess of 100 percent in recent years, but issues still lag behind Korea, the region’s largest market. Mortgage-backed securities have seen only modest growth.
- Obstacles to development of securitization markets in India include:
  - stamp duties ranging from 0.1 percent to 8 percent across Indian states;
  - lack of a common benchmark interest rate yield curve for pricing, particularly at longer maturities;
  - ineffective foreclosure laws;
  - lack of a secondary market (asset backed securities are inadequately defined as a “security” for stock exchange listing purposes).
- Prepayment risk is an issue given lack of a hedging tool and propensity of borrowers to prepay loans (without penalty) as interest rates fell.

### Short selling: role and empirical evidence
- Functions and potential benefits:
  - Can create conditions for more balanced asset price valuations by allowing pessimistic views to be expressed.
  - Adds discipline to valuations by allowing prices to be determined by both long and short positions.
  - Empirical evidence suggests short selling is crucial to limiting the emergence of asset price bubbles (Acker and others, 2000), and increases the speed with which asset prices adjust to new information.
- Limits and caveats:
  - Impact may be limited when markets are dominated by optimistic expectations.
  - Restrictions can force pessimistic investors from the market and contribute to inflated asset prices.

### Securitization: mechanics, benefits, and Indian market specifics
- Mechanics:
  - Relatively homogenous loans can be repackaged and sold as asset backed securities through transfer to a special purpose vehicle that issues securities to investors.
- Benefits:
  - Allows banks to obtain long-term financing, transfer associated credit risks to capital investors, and reduce capital requirements (IMF, 2006).
- Indian market specifics and constraints:
  - Rapid nominal growth (annual rates in excess of 100 percent) but still behind regional leaders such as Korea.
  - Mortgage-backed securities only modestly developed.
  - Legal, tax, pricing, and market-structure impediments outlined above hinder deeper market development.

### Tax incentives and mortgage interest deductibility
- Concern:
  - Full deductibility of mortgage interest can lead to higher household leverage and may exacerbate financial sector instability if asset prices decline.
- Policy tool evidence:
  - Gradual removal of mortgage interest deductibility has moderated property price increases in other countries (see Box 1).

### Box 1 — Mortgage Interest Deductibility and Real Estate Prices: empirical examples
- United Kingdom:
  - Began to gradually phase out mortgage interest deductibility starting in 1974 by placing a cap on the maximum deductible amount, and by gradually reducing the deductible tax rate starting in 1994 until all incentives were eliminated in 1999.
  - By 1998 the nominal cap applied to over two-thirds of all U.K. mortgages; reduction in deductible rate coincided with falling interest rates and housing prices continued to rise.
- Sweden:
  - Prior to 1983 mortgage interest payments were fully deductible (implying a house owner could deduct up to 80 percent of the interest).
  - Since 1983 interest deductions were successively reduced and capped at 30 percent in 1991.
  - It is estimated that this tax reform may have caused housing prices to decline over time by between 10–15 percent.
- Netherlands (Yelten, 2006):
  - Immediate removal of interest deductibility would lead to a dramatic fall in housing prices (for those in high income brackets the fall over a six-year period would range from 3½ percent if the economy were growing fast, to 36 percent if it were in recession).
  - A gradual phasing is less disruptive: introduction of a cap on interest deduction reduces the decline in house prices in upper income brackets to –13 percent in a recession.
  - In the event the economy were growing, prices would instead rise by about 30 percent fast over a six-year period. This increase is about 17 percentage points lower than if mortgage interest deductibility continued unchanged.

### Policy recommendations and conclusion (selected)
- Assessment:
  - Higher income, low interest rates, and financial market liberalization have caused asset markets in India to boom.
  - For the most part, asset prices in India reflect structural rather than speculative pressures, though some segments (e.g., real estate for malls) appear high.
  - Estimating overheating is tricky; a shock to growth would likely cause asset prices to adjust.
- Wealth effects:
  - Econometric analysis finds potential wealth effects are small: a 10 percent increase in equity prices is associated with a rise in real private consumption of less than one tenth of one percent.
- Monetary policy:
  - Monetary policy may not be the most effective tool to guard the financial system against asset price volatility in the current structural change context; macro policy actions could risk derailing financial deepening and could worsen the effects of an asset price reversal.
- Recommended targeted regulatory changes:
  - Tighter loan classification, provisioning, and loan eligibility requirements.
  - Improved accounting and disclosure standards to capture market, interest, and credit risk.
  - Enhanced stress testing and surveillance of financial institutions’ loan portfolios.
  - Further development of short selling and securitization markets to facilitate better risk management practices.
  - Re-evaluation of tax incentives for particular asset classes to help ensure a more orderly evolution of asset prices.

*Source: _wp07221 - 27.      The development of market risk management instruments and tax reform can*

---


_Source: https://www.imf.org/-/media/websites/imf/imported-full-text-pdf/external/pubs/ft/wp/2007/_wp07221.pdf_
